City Council meeting
Monday, December 19, 2016
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 I'd like to call the order, the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, January 9th, 2017.
0:00:05 For those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:00:09 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:25 So we're all struggling to move around up here with our big snow boots on.
0:00:31 I would confirm we do have a quorum in the council here.
0:00:36 Six members are here this evening.
0:00:38 Councilman Lansing is unable to join us tonight.
0:00:41 Mr. Rothwell, are there any amendments to the agenda?
0:00:43 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:00:44 there are no amendments this evening.
0:00:46 Thank you.
0:00:47 We have no proclamation.
0:00:48 So the next item is general public input.
0:00:50 This is an opportunity for the public to address the council
0:00:53 on any issues that are not on the agenda this evening.
0:00:57 If you would like to address this, please come forward.
0:01:01 Seeing none, we'll move on with the agenda.
0:01:03 First item for consideration is the consent calendar,
0:01:07 Council wishes.
0:01:09 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:10 I move approval of the consent calendar.
0:01:15 Second.
0:01:17 The motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Don Hall
0:01:19 to approve the consent calendar.
0:01:21 Is there any discussion?
0:01:22 Chris Stockton.
0:01:23 I'd like to have somebody from the house here tonight.
0:01:30 From Valley House.
0:01:32 Thank you.
0:01:33 You are.
0:01:34 I'm Dave Barr.
0:01:37 First Vice President of the Valley House Board.
0:01:40 So Valley House is actually the next item on the agenda.
0:01:44 Excuse me.
0:01:45 Excuse me.
0:01:46 So hold on, we'll finish up the consent calendar here,
0:01:49 and then we'll get there.
0:01:50 Any other discussion on the consent calendar?
0:01:54 Sharon, I'll call the vote, please.
0:01:56 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:57 Yes.
0:01:58 Nikki Boyd.
0:01:59 Yes.
0:01:59 John Berriger.
0:02:00 Yes.
0:02:01 Chris Tockman.
0:02:02 Yes.
0:02:03 Don Hall.
0:02:03 Yes.
0:02:04 Ruth Pierce.
0:02:05 Yes.
0:02:06 Motion passes.
0:02:07 Now, under items for consideration, the first is a request from the Valley House to waive
0:02:12 all building permit fees associated with renovating an existing home located on Rose Street to
0:02:17 increase their short-term transitional housing for women, and on the agenda, we actually have
0:02:23 Sharon Breshears down and also Jared Boardy from our building department.
0:02:26 Jared, maybe you want to start off with the information and then we'll have our folks
0:02:30 from Valley House expand on that.
0:02:33 So good evening.
0:02:34 Yeah, the architects here and some representatives from Valley House Sharon couldn't make it.
0:02:39 So we'll have Colby come up and explain the project to you guys and I can stand for any
0:02:43 questions you have for building for my piece.
0:02:44 It sounds perfect.
0:02:45 Thank you, Jared.
0:02:51 So I'm Colby Ricks with Laughlin Rick's architecture and I'm here on behalf of Valley
0:02:56 House.
0:02:57 So Valley House where they're located right now on Rose Street in Addison, they purchased
0:03:02 a new piece of property.
0:03:04 property right now we're calling it the blue house, the exterior of the house's
0:03:09 painted blue. There were some additional facilities on this property and I know
0:03:14 that they probably weren't frequented by the you know some that they had a lot of
0:03:22 problems there. There was a lot of drugs that were going on in that area and they
0:03:26 cleaned all of that up. They tore down all those problem houses and they
0:03:30 They approached us and asked us if it would be feasible to take what they're calling the
0:03:35 blue house and turning it into a transitional house for about six months for up to 12 single
0:03:42 women.
0:03:44 And we did an evaluation on it.
0:03:46 We think that it is a very good project and that it was feasible for them to do that.
0:03:53 So with the services that the Valley House provides in order to utilize as much money
0:04:00 as possible for the project and helping out the women that will be in this facility, the
0:04:07 Valley House is requesting that the building permit and the plan review fees be waived so
0:04:12 that we can use that money to help you with the project.
0:04:19 Thank you Colby.
0:04:20 Chris talking to you.
0:04:22 I'll come in with my question for you please or somebody from the house.
0:04:27 I'm fairly familiar with it but I'd like to have just a little expanded discussion of your referral base,
0:04:35 how you get your referrals as well as do you and how you coordinate with other 501c3s in our area.
0:04:43 Appreciate it.
0:04:45 I do the best I can. I'm fairly new with Valley House just joined the board last year.
0:04:52 Sharon is trying to get home to Gooding before the snow storm.
0:04:56 So do you have the handout or the attachment that she provided?
0:05:02 We do.
0:05:03 Is it a pretty good rundown on what's going on?
0:05:05 I think the referrals come from a number of places. Some of it is health department, child protection,
0:05:12 A lot of walk-ins, a lot of referrals from other 501c3s that don't deal with the people
0:05:25 that Valley House does or vice versa.
0:05:29 I don't know if that answers your question.
0:05:33 Sure.
0:05:34 And I had to assume that this summer...
0:05:35 And it's the broad spectrum.
0:05:36 They find us in a lot of them to receive the numbers.
0:05:42 I think the public wants to know that there's not an easy way for people that don't have
0:05:49 honest intentions just flow from one self-help home to another, that you're talking amongst
0:05:57 each other, you know.
0:05:58 We have the same discussion with Sharon, and she does coordinate tightly with others.
0:06:06 One thing about Valley House is there is a zero tolerance drug policy.
0:06:13 So that is not necessarily the case everywhere else.
0:06:16 So there tends to be referrals from Valley House to other places.
0:06:21 And as a final question, I just had a question and comment that I'm impressed with you expecting
0:06:27 the residents of the home to be out during the day looking for a gainful employment or a
0:06:34 way to take control of their own lives.
0:06:38 That's the short-term, every day goal, and we were just there today talking about this
0:06:43 year's fundraiser, and two Valley House residents came in and they were all excited, one had
0:06:50 just been hired, and the other was on his way to a job interview.
0:06:54 And he was thrilled.
0:06:57 And it's not just the short-term, not just every day they have to do that.
0:07:03 There's a timeline to graduate and be independent and self-sufficient.
0:07:09 And it's quite successful, I wouldn't say, we're 100% successful.
0:07:16 No one can be.
0:07:17 Sure, thank you very much.
0:07:19 Thank you.
0:07:20 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:07:21 Thank you.
0:07:22 I know you guys do a great work there.
0:07:25 Very impressed with what you offer, but because you're asking this of the city residents and the city taxpayers,
0:07:31 We have any idea what percentage of people are actually from the city limits because I know you're the only home in the entire Magic Valley and what portion of people were helping from outside our city limits.
0:07:43 I can't answer that question.
0:07:45 There are people that show up at the bus station not even from this region and we take care of them.
0:07:54 I don't know.
0:07:55 We can get that for you.
0:07:57 would be helpful information because we do have to answer to our citizens as to what
0:08:01 how we're spending their money.
0:08:02 I'm sure Sharon could have answered that question, but I can't.
0:08:05 I understand.
0:08:06 Thank you.
0:08:09 Any other questions from Council?
0:08:12 Don Hall?
0:08:13 I think I'd just address your question a little bit, Suzanne.
0:08:15 I think that many times the folks that go to Valley House would be in the city somewhere.
0:08:21 Most of them, even if they come here from other areas, folks that are homeless many times gravitate
0:08:27 towards the biggest community, the largest community.
0:08:31 And so we would find ourselves as Twin Falls being
0:08:34 the largest city, attracting a lot of those folks anyway.
0:08:37 So Valley House serves that need.
0:08:40 And as the previous police officer
0:08:41 and boys and girls club director,
0:08:43 I worked hand in hand with this organization
0:08:45 that serves our community, serves these folks,
0:08:48 the ones that are at the greatest need.
0:08:50 So I just wanted to add that.
0:08:52 Thank you.
0:08:54 I agree with you, but I don't have any.
0:08:57 So it's statistics to answer your question.
0:09:01 Thank you, Chris talking to me.
0:09:02 I would so move that we waive building permit fees
0:09:05 associated with the renovation of the existing home
0:09:10 on Rose Street for Valley House.
0:09:13 Second.
0:09:14 Oh.
0:09:15 Motion by Chris Dagenton, seconded by John Hall
0:09:18 to approve the request to waive the building permit fees
0:09:22 estimated at $2,280.
0:09:26 Is there any discussion?
0:09:27 Don Hall.
0:09:28 I would just add that we do this fairly,
0:09:31 I'm not gonna say routinely, but routinely.
0:09:34 For any community partner that serves in this capacity,
0:09:38 they care of our citizens.
0:09:42 These are folks that would probably many times
0:09:45 find their way into the police department
0:09:48 and other endeavors that we have to fund as a community.
0:09:53 community so I have no hesitation to vote for this because they're serving those
0:10:00 folks that need it the most. Jared is anything else that you need to add from
0:10:05 the building department? All right seeing no further discussion. Sharon
0:10:11 Rolkel vote please. Nicky Boyd? Yes. John Bericher? Yes. Chris Hockington? Yes.
0:10:17 Don Hall? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Motion passes. Thank you.
0:10:23 Thank you so much.
0:10:26 The next item on the agenda is a presentation of a progress update, excuse me, to erect a
0:10:32 statue to John E. Hayes, the original survey of the Twin Falls City site, and discuss potential
0:10:38 locations for the statue.
0:10:40 We have Paul Smith and Curtis Eaton here this evening to present.
0:10:45 Welcome, gentlemen.
0:10:46 We have Curtis Eaton.
0:10:47 Paul's going to hide out on the audience.
0:10:50 Mr. Mayor Dan members of the council. I'll follow up to you last time and we were kind of partners in this project. I understand
0:10:59 From all accounts. He got an a plus, so I feel the pressure
0:11:04 Thank you very much for making time to hear a very very short presentation on this topic
0:11:12 Paul is here. I think you all know him. He is my partner in this project
0:11:17 We worked very, very closely for, actually, a couple of years now.
0:11:22 And I think you also would also know Leonard Anderson, who has been a member of the Project
0:11:30 Advisory Committee for the downtown main avenue project, and he is president also of the Twin
0:11:37 Falls Community Foundation.
0:11:41 So the purpose this evening is just to take a minute to review why there is a sculpture
0:11:48 that looks like the one I think you have in the packet for your meeting.
0:11:55 The reason for that sculpture is the picture that is on the cover of the book called The
0:12:00 Forest of Wormwood and it was commissioned by the Twin Falls Canal Company.
0:12:05 picture was taken in 1904, the person who is shown in that picture is named John E. Hayes.
0:12:33 That's a replica of the picture that's on the book called Forest of Wormwood.
0:12:44 You can see the tripod and the leg of the tripod that is nearest you has what is actually a little
0:12:50 Surveyor's flag at the bottom of the tripod. We're told by Mr. Hayes' grandson, Dr. Maddock,
0:13:02 who is a physician in Salt Lake, that that flag is at the intersection of Maine and
0:13:08 Shoshan. And so, those of us who had a chance to talk it over and think it over over the
0:13:16 period of time, think that a representation of that moment
0:13:22 in the outgrowth and outburst, some of us
0:13:27 refer to it as the umbilical cord of the belly button,
0:13:33 actually, of Twin Falls, depicting that
0:13:37 and having a representation of the statute is a good idea.
0:13:41 So, we've had many conversations about it, most recently, and this is the update part of
0:13:50 it.
0:13:51 I think you would know that Urban Renewal set aside some money for public art projects, and
0:13:56 at their last meeting, they approved $20,000 for this project.
0:14:02 The details are to be worked out, but I believe it's on a matching basis, and that money will
0:14:06 be available as we are able to raise private funds.
0:14:13 So that has taken place, I think, since we were last year.
0:14:16 We also had a conversation with Mandy Roberts and Andrew Guho.
0:14:23 And you probably know Mandy is the design architect
0:14:26 for the main avenue project.
0:14:28 And Andrew is the principal of the contractor.
0:14:33 The most recent conversation we had with them approximately two weeks ago was for the purpose
0:14:42 generally of discussing the downtown project, and it was their suggestion that we reconsider
0:14:48 the location of the statute.
0:14:52 I think you all know that we have been considering the plaza, I think it's referred to in front
0:14:58 of Columbia Bank, and that has its charm, of course, if for no other reason than is very
0:15:06 near the intersection of Maine and Choshone.
0:15:14 Recently, this conversation with Mandy and with Andrew, it was their suggestion that we
0:15:24 reconsider that location and consider instead putting it in the sidewalk near the downtown
0:15:35 commons.
0:15:36 And so it would not be in the commons in their suggestion.
0:15:42 It would be in the sidewalk and as I understand it, it would be near the upper left hand corner
0:15:48 of that block where the word construction is located.
0:15:52 would be in that position. Talking with Mandy and Andrew about it, there are a couple of
0:15:57 reasons for that suggestion. One is there really is a line of sight issue. You can avoid having
0:16:08 the complication of the intersection by setting the statue back far enough if you have it at
0:16:16 the Columbia Plaza, but it has to satisfy the line of sight issue. And once you do that,
0:16:22 gets further and further away from the intersection. Some of you may have heard that our initial
0:16:27 proposal was to have it not near the intersection, but in the intersection. We were going to have
0:16:32 a roundabout and we were going to protect it with whatever metal was needed and have
0:16:37 concrete barriers and all this kind of stuff. And we had the conversation with the Idaho
0:16:42 Transportation Department to have it in the intersection. It was a very short conversation.
0:16:50 we asked them to reconsider, no, they said no, and so we gave up on that and so actually
0:16:57 it's been kind of an evolution in the thinking for some of us. If it can't be at that exact
0:17:01 location, then where can it be and still satisfy kind of that historical perspective? If it's
0:17:09 a few feet away, it satisfies. Maybe if it's a block away, it still satisfies. But the question
0:17:16 of having the historical representation of that moment in time at the corner of Maine
0:17:23 and Shoshone.
0:17:25 I've had to evolve in my thinking actually, and I've had a recent text exchanged with Leon
0:17:32 Smith, and he says it's still preferable to have it on the corner of Maine and Shoshone,
0:17:38 but when we take into account all of the considerations that may be argued for it being at a different
0:17:45 place, then maybe we should pay attention to what Mandy and Andrew have said. And so Travis
0:17:54 had the opportunity to sort of run this by Dan Brizzy of Urban Renewal. And speaking
0:18:01 for Travis, I know you realize that Travis speaks pretty well for himself. But speaking
0:18:06 for him, he thinks that the chair of Urban Renewal would be in favor of this modification.
0:18:15 So the reason that Leonard is here tonight, I think, is to evidence his and the Twin Falls
0:18:22 Community Foundation support for this change in location.
0:18:27 And again, he speaks exceptionally well for himself and he's welcome to do so.
0:18:32 He said maybe he didn't need to this evening.
0:18:35 So the people we have talked to thus far seem to be in support of the change in location.
0:18:43 The details would have to be worked out, of course, but it appears that maybe instead
0:18:50 of having it right at the intersection, having it near a block away from that intersection
0:18:57 makes sense for another, I think, a pretty important reason.
0:19:02 And that is this is a pedestrian area.
0:19:06 You we all would have a statue that is in an area that would be, in essence, a magnet
0:19:12 for pedestrians, hopefully older people and hopefully younger people who would walk around
0:19:18 to see the signage next to it, ask about it, maybe be better informed about the history
0:19:24 of our town by having it a place where you can spend the little time and you're not rushing
0:19:29 back and forth to get across either main or shown street at that intersection.
0:19:34 So that's the essence of our presentation to you.
0:19:39 We wanted to make sure that the city manager knew that this discussion was, let's say, evolving.
0:19:45 And he thought that it was a good idea for us to tell you that the discussion is evolving,
0:19:53 at least to the extent of modifying that location.
0:19:57 I'd be glad to entertain any questions you have and the difficult ones, of course, Paul
0:20:05 here to answer.
0:20:06 Thank you, Chris.
0:20:07 Chris Stockton.
0:20:08 Yeah, of course, I'm not sure I misunderstood the location the upper left hand corner not on Main Street
0:20:13 That are more akin to the alley is that where you're saying
0:20:17 That Jim makes more sense and as we were as we were talking about it
0:20:26 They they meeting mandy and Andrew were saying that the
0:20:32 Pavers these are all papers here. I think you realize that that paper sidewalk is wide enough that it would accommodate
0:20:39 the base of the statute and still allow pedestrians to pass by on both sides.
0:20:46 We got into the weeds enough to ask the question, could we have papers of maybe different sizes
0:20:53 near the statute so that those that are the larger investors would have some acknowledgement
0:21:00 of their investment.
0:21:02 And, Mandy, as I guess the design expert thought that would be a no problem whatsoever.
0:21:09 Thank you, Don Hall.
0:21:12 Curtis, I understand the reason for moving it, it kind of makes sense.
0:21:16 I would prefer it at the actual location, but because of how you outline site issues and the like, it makes sense.
0:21:25 My question is, and maybe you've addressed this in the past, I don't remember asking it.
0:21:30 But is this going to be designed and built in a way that if kids climb on it, it'll be robust
0:21:36 enough to deal with that?
0:21:38 Especially at this location, when we have our events down there, it's packed.
0:21:43 And I've had kids, you've had kids, and they like to climb.
0:21:49 Well, Mr. Hall, that's a great question.
0:21:53 It's kind of an ongoing discussion to make sure that that question is answered definitively.
0:22:01 The idea now is to have the base slightly elevated, although not too much, because if
0:22:07 you get it too elevated, then you kind of lose the interactive nature of the statue.
0:22:13 And as you would recall, the picture in the statue itself has sagebrush built into the
0:22:23 statue.
0:22:25 That will be a bit of a barrier.
0:22:30 there have to be an additional barrier talking about possibly landscaping such as this. And
0:22:37 there's actually been some discussion about, you know, maybe the best deterrent is a couple
0:22:44 of rose bushes. And then someone said, but parents are going to send their kids through.
0:22:51 So landscaping is one answer, and the sturdiness, the principal area of concern, I think, is the
0:23:04 plum bob, and all of the rest of that, I think, can be made strong, you know, including the
0:23:11 tripods and so on, that if somebody tried to climb on it, it's going to take an Alabama
0:23:17 Clemson type player to do damage to it, but the plumb bob could be damaged.
0:23:23 And so there are several answers that are being explored such as attaching it to the base,
0:23:28 such as having a decision on landscaping around that so that it wouldn't show that it was tested.
0:23:35 That's a very important question.
0:23:37 I think one of the premise ideas for moving it here is so that both kids and older folks
0:23:46 would be attracted to it.
0:23:49 And as I remember, there's such a thing
0:23:51 as an attractive nuisance idea that Fritz could tell you
0:23:54 about a nauseam probably.
0:23:58 But when you're attracting kids, you
0:24:00 need to be careful about what you're attracting them to
0:24:03 so that they don't get hurt, and also
0:24:05 so they don't do damage to the things.
0:24:07 So I can't tell you that the answer has been achieved,
0:24:12 but it's being very carefully explored.
0:24:14 Thank you.
0:24:15 I think it is a slight follow up to Don's question there, so in the staff report we have, it talks about if it's determined the statue would be placed on city property or accepted as a gift, but the city then appropriate maintenance agreements will need to be put in place.
0:24:28 The intent be that the maintenance obligation would be the city's then ongoing?
0:24:33 Yes.
0:24:34 Mr. Mayor, I think that's, I'm going to say typical, if we've looked into it with other cities, there is the gift to the city.
0:24:44 the gift to the city with the understanding that the city does not take on any liability
0:24:51 by virtue of the gift. But then as kind of the quid of the quo, the city takes on the responsibility
0:24:57 of ongoing maintenance. We don't have paperwork, but we're working on it. And we think there
0:25:04 needs to be a very carefully worded kind of an agreement about what is delivered to the
0:25:10 city and then when does the city's responsibility arise and what is the responsibility from that
0:25:18 point forward?
0:25:19 So I think we are beginning to address that in verbiage that I know you and your council
0:25:27 will want to consider.
0:25:29 I think certainly it's a noble project to honor our history and I think it's a very tastefully
0:25:36 done piece.
0:25:39 I would be concerned that it is,
0:25:42 fragile is probably a strong word,
0:25:43 but susceptible to more damage than not being so accessible.
0:25:50 And the only other concern I would express about the plaza area
0:25:54 is that I think wherever it exactly gets placed
0:25:58 needs to not impede this event street concept
0:26:02 that really is one of the shining stars
0:26:06 of this new renovation of giving that accessibility to plunk it in the middle of that accessibility
0:26:12 may be challenging, but I'm sure that our architect, Dan Tam, will make sure that it's
0:26:17 in the right place for that.
0:26:19 Mr. Mayor, your first point about the potential fragility of it, I think that's very similar
0:26:29 to the discussion that I had with Mr. Hall.
0:26:32 That's a legitimate concern to have it accessible and yet have it so that it cannot be easily
0:26:41 damaged.
0:26:42 That's a very, very important consideration.
0:26:47 And as far as still its location is concerned, I think the idea, when I pointed out on the
0:26:54 chart to Mr. Talkington, where I think I understood Mandy and Andrew were talking about, it is
0:27:02 at the very, is that Northwest edge of the downtown commons so that it wouldn't
0:27:12 impede the flow of traffic nor the overflow if there's an event there that
0:27:16 would overflow on the main street, it wouldn't interfere with that. I think
0:27:19 that was part of their location to the ratio.
0:27:22 Yeah I mean it's one thing to have your Civil War general up on a pedestal in
0:27:28 the middle of around about 15 feet up it's another to have something you know
0:27:33 you know, behind a 12-inch landscape wall.
0:27:38 I think if I can presume some consensus possibly
0:27:46 to the change of location, we are beginning
0:27:50 to work on documentation of it.
0:27:53 And I think that's something maybe Fritz or other people
0:27:55 would want to have clearly understood.
0:28:00 One, the maintenance part of it.
0:28:01 What is the obligation of the city?
0:28:03 and to an understanding that it's being as carefully
0:28:07 as possible designed to avoid immediate damage, great.
0:28:16 Stogginton?
0:28:17 So Travis, should we accept it tonight
0:28:19 and say we're expect to have a mutually agreed upon
0:28:23 maintenance agreement and we're working on location
0:28:26 what action would you suggest?
0:28:29 Yeah, I think that that would be appropriate
0:28:31 and that we could work through the details.
0:28:33 know that in speaking with Curtis and Judge Smith, it was really important that as they
0:28:41 kind of walk through these final steps that there is a surety in knowing that this is
0:28:46 really going to happen and that it's going to be able to be placed on to some sort of
0:28:51 dedicated place.
0:28:53 One of the concerns that they had as they shared with me was to go through this effort
0:28:57 to have it cast and then not to have it have a home.
0:29:01 And then I also believe that some of the individuals who would like to make contributions to this
0:29:08 are waiting for these final little pieces to make sure that it truly would be in a prominent
0:29:14 display piece.
0:29:16 I think that we can work through those details, you know, and I think that you can accept the
0:29:24 The gift depending or pending the outcome of a mutually agreed upon agreement between the
0:29:34 city and those who are looking at providing it.
0:29:42 Certainly, entertain such a motion should someone like to make one to that effect.
0:29:50 Nikki Boyd.
0:29:52 I move that we approve the progress update to erect a statue and are in favor of the proposed
0:30:04 location at this time, and are anticipating receiving a maintenance agreement.
0:30:13 Does that say?
0:30:15 Accept it as a gift.
0:30:17 Oh, and accept it as a gift.
0:30:20 Does that cover all the basis?
0:30:22 Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Chris Tockington to accept the gift contingent upon the development
0:30:35 and approval of a maintenance agreement, how's that?
0:30:39 Nicely re-worded.
0:30:42 Any further discussion by the council?
0:30:44 Chair and roll call vote please.
0:30:50 Sean Berriger?
0:30:51 Yes.
0:30:52 Chris Tockington?
0:30:53 Yes.
0:30:54 Don Hall?
0:30:55 Yes.
0:30:56 Ruth Pierce?
0:30:57 Yes.
0:30:58 Yes.
0:30:59 Motion passes 6-0.
0:31:01 Chris Stockington.
0:31:02 I'd also like to put in a plug for the Forest of Wormwood book referred to by Curtis.
0:31:08 I've just finished it for the first time and I thought I was fairly knowledgeable of early
0:31:14 a sudden Idaho history built around the water projects.
0:31:19 It is a excuse my expression as I hell over read.
0:31:23 It fills in so many details that everybody from children in school to old codgers on city
0:31:32 councils are going to benefit by knowing our background and the people such as Mr. Hayes
0:31:38 that made it possible.
0:31:41 So I would impose this as a reading assignment for everybody in Twin Falls and must watch the
0:31:50 the cells of the bucket of the celling.
0:31:52 Thank you, Chris.
0:31:54 Curtis, thank you to you and Paul for your leadership in this
0:31:57 and for bringing this forward.
0:31:58 And hopefully you received what you needed this evening.
0:32:01 Mr. Mayor, at the risk of provoking reconsideration
0:32:05 of your most recent vote, Dave Lemure
0:32:10 is the artist who created, I only learned recently,
0:32:16 this little statue that they call it a meckette.
0:32:18 He created that, and Paul and I were both, I would say blessed in some ways, but at least
0:32:27 very, very lucky to see the process of taking the clay model of that and having it turned
0:32:34 into the bronze model.
0:32:37 And that happened at a foundry in Joseph, Oregon, and if things go the way the discussion
0:32:44 is undergoing. That's where the larger bond section is. It's amazing. To take a, I'm gonna
0:32:58 call it a two-dimensional thing that's the picture on a book and turn it into a three-dimensional
0:33:05 thing that you've all seen.
0:33:09 It was here with Paul spoke last time.
0:33:12 It's remarkable.
0:33:14 I think Paul and I feel a sense of obligation
0:33:17 to try and satisfy all the issues and sentiments
0:33:21 that you've raised.
0:33:22 Thank you.
0:33:23 Thank you.
0:33:26 Next on the agenda is a presentation
0:33:28 of an update on the main avenue redevelopment project.
0:33:31 This is a presentation from Paul Johnson with CH2M.
0:33:35 Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just getting the presentation online.
0:33:48 Again, my name is Paul Johnson, and I'm the owner's representative for the Urban Renewal Agencies Main Avenue Redevelopment Project.
0:34:02 So I'm pleased to have the opportunity to provide the same update to City Council as was provided to the Urban Renewal Agencies Board earlier today.
0:34:11 On the first page, you'll see a picture of the block mock-up for the pavers.
0:34:30 We had the opportunity.
0:34:32 We asked Gu Ho, the construction manager, to bring several different mock-ups to the Parks
0:34:39 and Recreation Department meeting that we had on December 21st, and that was very helpful
0:34:46 and short-listing several pavers that we're going to allow vendors to bid on for this project
0:34:53 that meets the specifications.
0:34:55 So that mock-up is available at the Parks and Recreation Office if anyone wants to see
0:35:00 that.
0:35:06 First an update on the construction manager general contractor's progress over the last
0:35:13 month and then at the end of this we'll share a public information flyer with you that is
0:35:19 in final draft form and would look forward to any comments from the council before we send
0:35:26 that out.
0:35:28 Over the last month, Guho has been reviewing the final plans and specifications that are
0:35:34 very nearly complete, 99.5% by OTAC, the design firm.
0:35:41 They're preparing the bid packages.
0:35:44 So in the February, later in January and February, the project will be out for bid and will be
0:35:50 prepared to ask the Urban Renewal Agency for approval of what we call the GMP or guaranteed
0:35:57 maximum price in early March.
0:36:01 The first construction activity that you'll see is landscape demolition.
0:36:08 And we plan to have landscape demolition.
0:36:16 This might blink in and out a little bit,
0:36:18 based on the screen resolution, but I think we're OK right now.
0:36:21 Thanks.
0:36:22 Landscape demolition should occur over President's Day weekend
0:36:25 from February 17 through February 20.
0:36:28 We have a meeting with Parks and Rec tomorrow
0:36:30 just to receive final confirmation from the tree
0:36:34 commission on that.
0:36:36 They were concerned about the total of tree replacements.
0:36:40 And we have approximately the same new trees that are being put in place after taking down
0:36:47 the old trees.
0:36:48 Guho will be there to explain the demolition process.
0:36:53 We're respecting the public project advisory committees' wishes and the council's wishes
0:37:00 to make sure that the trees are taken down appropriately before they leave out.
0:37:07 We plan to leave three-foot stumps at each location.
0:37:10 The reason for that is two-fold, one to prevent a tripping hazard, and secondly to provide the
0:37:16 heavy equipment, something to grab later on in the demolition process when the root systems
0:37:21 are pulled out.
0:37:23 So let's see, okay, let's go back to page two, yeah, thank you, can we switch controlled
0:37:46 into that, okay, all right, all right, on December 21st we had on item three we had a
0:38:03 a very positive meeting with the project advisory committee.
0:38:07 Guho had presented a block by block construction demolition
0:38:11 and construction plan for main avenue which made sense to
0:38:15 all the merchants who were present. So the way the project will
0:38:19 roll out is in area one that you see
0:38:23 from Shoshone to Gooding,
0:38:27 that would be the first area. The blocks will be done on a two month by two month
0:38:31 basis, sequencing as you see here.
0:38:35 So the first area would go from April through May 2017.
0:38:41 And as we presented a couple of months ago, the sequence will include the street demolition
0:38:48 and sidewalk demolition, but the merchants will have access to the front of their businesses
0:38:54 the very same warning that the sidewalks are demolished out.
0:38:58 It will be compacted, crushed gravel, but it will be taped off so that the public will
0:39:03 still have access to those businesses.
0:39:06 Another plus is that many of the businesses have access from the alleyways, and there's
0:39:10 parking from the alleyways.
0:39:12 So we view very little inconvenience to the merchants.
0:39:16 Just we're trying to minimize that as much as possible.
0:39:19 So area two then would be staggered by one month, and that would be from good to fair
0:39:27 and that would occur in the May to June timeframe.
0:39:32 And then we would move back to Shoshone over to Hanson in area three
0:39:37 in the June and July timeframe.
0:39:39 And then the fourth area would be from Hanson to Idaho Street from July to August 2017.
0:39:47 The fifth area would be from Hanson to Jerome,
0:39:53 And that would occur from August to September.
0:39:58 And then the final area six would be what we call
0:40:01 Hanson Street South from Maine Avenue down to Second Avenue.
0:40:06 And that would occur in September and October.
0:40:09 So that increases the number of mobilizations
0:40:12 by certain subcontractors such as the pavers.
0:40:15 But the paving contractor, I mean,
0:40:17 but this really minimizes inconvenience
0:40:20 to the public and the merchants, we think.
0:40:22 So we received unanimous support from those who attended the project advisory committee meeting
0:40:29 on the 21st.
0:40:30 They seemed like this phasing plan and that's what we'll hold to unless we have any other
0:40:36 comments from any of the groups.
0:40:38 Paul, can you describe to me?
0:40:40 So when you talk about phasing, is that everything would be completed in that block in
0:40:46 that period of time and then they move to the next or will landscaping all come in at the
0:40:50 into the whole five blocks or?
0:40:53 There will be some final finishing touches,
0:40:55 including landscaping and some street amenities.
0:40:59 But for all intents and purposes,
0:41:01 the sidewalks and the pavers will be complete
0:41:03 in that two month period and the street paving
0:41:07 and parking and so forth.
0:41:08 We're still working out some of the details
0:41:10 for a turnaround at the end of the block,
0:41:13 making sure that we have fire access and so forth.
0:41:16 But yes, we would have some final amenities
0:41:20 would come in toward the end of the project, the benches, and perhaps the light poles and
0:41:27 the landscaping.
0:41:28 With the basic functionality of being able to get pedestrians and vehicles with those areas
0:41:33 that you should work.
0:41:34 Great.
0:41:35 Thank you.
0:41:37 Okay.
0:41:38 All right.
0:41:39 Then the next slide, please.
0:41:43 So the design progress has culminated with submittal of the final design.
0:41:49 We're still working through some very final details.
0:41:52 A few examples are the paper options, which I talked about.
0:41:56 Here's a picture of a tree grate at the Boise City Grove Plaza
0:42:04 project.
0:42:05 There are a lot of things that happen there,
0:42:07 including irrigation and electrical outlet connections
0:42:10 and so forth.
0:42:11 We want to make sure we're not creating a tripping hazard,
0:42:13 and that we have the right kind of irrigation system
0:42:18 for the landscaping.
0:42:20 The irrigation system that we will have,
0:42:22 I think, is an improvement over what you see in the picture
0:42:24 with the circular drip irrigation.
0:42:26 We'll have a deep root irrigation system for your project,
0:42:29 which is an improvement.
0:42:31 The gravel fill under the roadways and sidewalks,
0:42:34 it's kind of a construction detail,
0:42:36 but it's something that Guho suggested
0:42:38 and should increase competition and reduced prices
0:42:42 based on the type of aggregate
0:42:44 that would go on the sub base layer
0:42:46 And then the final layer just below the brick and the sidewalk.
0:42:50 So the contractors will have the option of doing 3.25 inch
0:42:53 minus crushed material rather than what we call the pit
0:42:57 runner larger stone and sand material at the lower section.
0:43:00 Sometimes it's more efficient on a project like this
0:43:02 just to bring in all the same material.
0:43:04 So we'll be able to reduce costs that way by providing the
0:43:09 bidders with more options.
0:43:11 The Light Pole Foundations is another one.
0:43:14 the original design called for seven foot deep foundations,
0:43:18 if you can believe it, for the 16 foot light poles
0:43:21 at the intersections.
0:43:23 I guess the calculations lead to that,
0:43:25 but we've asked the engineers to reconsider
0:43:28 something that goes only five feet deep,
0:43:30 because then we can avoid the OSHA shoring requirements
0:43:35 when we have staff down into the excavation.
0:43:39 It's not mine.
0:43:41 All right.
0:43:41 Okay, so we're working on that final detail, which will simplify construction and improve
0:43:48 safety for the workers.
0:43:50 And then the trenching detail will allow the electrical systems for the street amenities
0:43:57 and for the light poles to be in the same trench as the storm drainage, which will present
0:44:02 an economy and reduce prices for the project.
0:44:05 So we're in the final stages of preparing the bid packages.
0:44:08 We'll have more on that next month, as I mentioned.
0:44:10 Next slide, please.
0:44:19 Item 10 on the basement issues.
0:44:21 We've discussed this before.
0:44:23 We do have one basement in fill that we plan to do
0:44:26 in front of Mr. Crowley's property at Moose Hill and Twin
0:44:29 Beans, the existing basements that extend under Main Avenue,
0:44:33 at Key Bank and Wells Fargo will remain,
0:44:36 but will skin off the unattractive surface there, which they've
0:44:41 been trying to waterproof over the years,
0:44:43 And we'll provide a new waterproofing layer
0:44:45 above the basement structure, and then provide brick
0:44:50 and concrete sidewalks above that.
0:44:52 So it'll be a distinct improvement there.
0:44:55 We do need to have a licensing agreement
0:44:58 between the property owner and the urban renewal agency.
0:45:01 So the attorneys are working on that now.
0:45:04 Just some other details on testing inspection
0:45:06 and inspection and other things that I updated
0:45:08 the URA board on earlier today, but all project details
0:45:12 moving forward. Next slide, please. We mentioned the possible additional sidewalk
0:45:21 repair project. If we do receive good bids which we're hopeful that we'll bid
0:45:28 this under budget, we would like to use remaining funding and cooperation with
0:45:33 property owners to repair badly needed areas that are in dire need of sidewalk
0:45:40 replacement because it'll be a shame to have main avenue rebuilt and then have
0:45:44 some cracked and many cracked and broken sidewalks from from main avenue up to the
0:45:49 seconds. So the details of what the cost-sharing arrangement might be with property
0:45:54 owners are still being worked out but we'd like to use the remaining portions of the
0:45:58 budget for sidewalk and curb and getter repairs in some of these other areas. And
0:46:05 we're on budget so far. We'll know more next month. Paul Dunhall has a question. Just a
0:46:11 quick question, Paul, I kind of get what you're saying about trying to prepare the sidewalks
0:46:17 going to the seconds, but I know there's a group of folks that are called the Forgotten
0:46:23 Main Street. Would it be more advantageous just a suggestion for us to extend it on Main
0:46:30 Street to try to reach a little bit more Main Street than it would be to go to the
0:46:37 seconds. Just a question. Do you mean further? Either east or west of Jerome and
0:46:45 and west of Fairfield? Yes. I just throw it out as a food for thought. I'll
0:46:53 mention that to Jesse Schurman and Nathan and Dan Brzee and we'll talk about that.
0:47:00 Again that's just you know I've just had some folks approach me about Main Street
0:47:06 it ending where it did. Obviously, we don't have, they don't have an
0:47:12 inexhaustible resources to do the whole Main Street, but there's a way that we
0:47:16 could extend it, I think it might. I think the good will. What we're looking at with
0:47:21 hopefully some nominal amount of money that's remaining would be sort of
0:47:29 standard, curb and gutter and sidewalk replacement, but not the full scope of the
0:47:33 main avenue redevelopment that would be a much more expensive proposition if if
0:47:39 you're referring to continuing the whole streetscape Easter West I don't think
0:47:44 that's well well well well no not not in this that would be nice we have the money
0:47:48 but I some of those sidewalks are just in horrible shape east and west
0:47:54 we're open to any of the priorities as determined by the urban renewal agency
0:48:01 city and city input on that will know more I think around the midpoint of the project
0:48:06 as to how the projects progressing and what funds are available so we have some time to
0:48:11 work on that.
0:48:12 I'm just planning the seat and I'll be at those meetings so I'll plant that seat.
0:48:15 Sounds good.
0:48:16 Thank you.
0:48:17 Chris talking.
0:48:18 And Paul what can you tell us about the alley subsurface worker and how far along are
0:48:25 way of any snags, any anticipated costs, any delays.
0:48:32 I know what JUB is reporting on that with respect to the alley utility work and there
0:48:40 is the water and sewer and the gas work that is going on for purposes of the City Hall project.
0:48:47 It's not under the same scope as the main avenue project, but I understand that it did
0:48:52 and the bids came in within budget, and that work is ongoing.
0:48:57 And I was talking with a JUB representative today
0:49:00 about the schedule.
0:49:02 We'll have a bit of overlap on area one
0:49:04 from Shoshone to Gooding, and a little bit of coordination
0:49:07 to do there, but to anticipate that completing on time
0:49:12 and on budget, I understand that the remainder
0:49:16 of the alleyways work will be deferred for a few years,
0:49:18 and there's about a $6 million budget overall
0:49:22 for all the utility work in the alleys.
0:49:25 So I don't expect it to be ongoing,
0:49:28 other than in that first law.
0:49:31 Thank you.
0:49:31 With some overlap.
0:49:32 All right.
0:49:33 Now just a quick overview of this lawyer.
0:49:34 Oh, I've got a couple more questions up here, so.
0:49:37 Ruth Pierce.
0:49:38 Yeah, so I actually own a building
0:49:40 in that forgotten Twin Falls.
0:49:42 So it's between Fairfield and Eden.
0:49:44 And our sidewalks where the trees have buckled up,
0:49:48 the sidewalk are really bad.
0:49:50 I mean, like liability bad.
0:49:52 I've pulled out a tree and replaced a sidewalk,
0:49:58 but it's pretty bad down there.
0:50:01 And if there was something that could be done,
0:50:03 forgotten Twin Falls is a nice term.
0:50:06 It's not what I refer it as,
0:50:08 but if there's something that could be done
0:50:10 kind of down towards, so I'm across
0:50:14 from the Times News parking lot,
0:50:16 it would be really helpful.
0:50:18 or at least some sort of shared something.
0:50:20 So we weren't necessarily handling the brand of the costs.
0:50:27 It's not cheap.
0:50:28 I'll be working, like I said, with Nathan and Jesse on that.
0:50:33 And I would think that any property owners
0:50:35 who are able and willing to kick in a share of costs
0:50:40 would probably receive first priority over other areas
0:50:44 where the anticipation would be that the DRA funds 100%.
0:50:49 Thank you.
0:50:50 Susanne Hawkins.
0:50:51 Okay.
0:50:52 If I remember correctly, when we rezoned the URA rezoned that district, that section was
0:51:00 not included.
0:51:01 And so I don't think the URA can spend money there.
0:51:05 Good point.
0:51:06 I would have to study the boundary of area 41.
0:51:08 I'm sure.
0:51:09 Yeah.
0:51:10 Because there was a lot of discussion given to that and that's why I thought you were looking
0:51:13 towards the second avenues because I was under the impression that that block is not included.
0:51:19 Just a heads up.
0:51:21 Thank you.
0:51:24 No more questions.
0:51:25 OK.
0:51:26 All right.
0:51:26 We have final draft public information flyer.
0:51:29 Again, this was prepared by OTAC.
0:51:35 On the first page, it just provides some project information.
0:51:40 Advises the public that the area,
0:51:42 main avenue, will be open for business all through construction
0:51:46 and that parking will still be available, if not on the street,
0:51:50 but right nearby encourages continued support
0:51:53 for downtown businesses.
0:51:55 The depiction, of course, is of the Commons area,
0:51:58 which will be enhanced by the statute.
0:52:04 Then on pages two and three, we have the phasing plan,
0:52:07 which I discussed a little bit earlier,
0:52:10 showing the overall project phasing
0:52:13 and pedestrian access in the hatched area
0:52:15 and the upper left between Gooding and Fairfield.
0:52:19 You'll see a construction staging area.
0:52:22 That's where Guho's equipment would be placed.
0:52:24 But we will attempt to leave as much of that area
0:52:27 for parking as possible.
0:52:29 Right now, we're thinking roughly 2-thirds
0:52:30 for construction staging and 1-3 for parking.
0:52:33 But we'll restrict the construction area as much as possible.
0:52:37 As far as a walk-in location for Guho's office,
0:52:44 they are looking into renting some space on Main Avenue
0:52:47 So that as merchants have questions,
0:52:50 they'll be able to access their office quickly
0:52:52 and talk to Rob Kloninger, the onsite superintendent,
0:52:56 about their concerns.
0:52:59 We also have, on the second page,
0:53:02 we have the contacts, Josh Palmer right now,
0:53:06 the city's communications director,
0:53:07 and then Anthony Guho from the construction firm.
0:53:12 And then on the final page, it's just a suggestion
0:53:16 that the public can buy a brick to support the project
0:53:19 and reminders that restaurants and businesses and so forth will be open and
0:53:24 then a little bit better rendering of what the street will look like with the diagonal parking.
0:53:31 Continuing in a very similar manner as to what you now have.
0:53:36 So that concludes our overview, but if there are any recommendations on the flyer,
0:53:43 if we could please get those by January 12th or the end of this week, that would be appreciated.
0:53:48 One comment so far is that we should make an attempt to make the font a little bit crisper
0:53:55 and that may just be because of converting, I did a cut and paste with the cut tool in Powerpoint.
0:54:04 That may be the reason for it, but I'll work with Mandy to make sure the font size has increased
0:54:08 a little bit and is very legible in the final flyer.
0:54:12 If there's any suggestions as to content, please let Josh or Nathan Murray know and we'll
0:54:20 incorporate that.
0:54:21 Thank you for the opportunity to provide the update.
0:54:27 Thank you, Paul.
0:54:28 Great information.
0:54:29 It's going to be an exciting year, Dan Tam.
0:54:35 So just a reminder, we do have two public hearings scheduled to start not sooner than
0:54:40 six o'clock and we're just a couple minutes before six and we have a few more items on
0:54:45 our regular agenda.
0:54:46 So if you're here for the public hearings, stick around, we'll get to you pretty soon.
0:54:50 Next is a presentation on snow plowing methods, techniques, and priorities from our public works director, John Caton.
0:54:57 Welcome, John.
0:54:58 Is there snow down there?
0:54:59 Thank you, Mayor and Council.
0:55:00 Where are your snow boots?
0:55:02 I don't know.
0:55:03 Water.
0:55:04 Yes.
0:55:05 Yes, Travis Rothwiler.
0:55:07 So before John begins, I think that it would be appropriate.
0:55:11 You know, we have several members of our team that have been really working very hard on behalf of our citizens to clear snow,
0:55:23 to remove snow that's over blocking storm drains, to ensure that the roads are passable.
0:55:32 They've started very, very early.
0:55:35 And I know that I saw that Dean Littler, the street super had walked in.
0:55:40 John Caten, obviously, Doug Gonzalez, who's overseeing wastewater, Robert Bulling who oversees water.
0:55:50 And Mark Thompson, who's also with us tonight.
0:55:55 All of these folks really came together and worked collaboratively as a single public works team.
0:56:03 And in conjunction with police, in conjunction with fire, and I think that as we start this,
0:56:09 We planned this conversation several weeks ago.
0:56:14 So when we are budgeting time for council agendas,
0:56:18 we are laying those out several weeks in advance.
0:56:21 We hope we didn't cause the snowstorm that, honey.
0:56:25 But in all seriousness, John and his team,
0:56:29 led by Dean, by Robert, and by Doug,
0:56:31 have done an absolute job.
0:56:32 And I think we'd be remissed if we didn't recognize that
0:56:35 on the front end of a snow removal presentation.
0:56:38 Absolutely.
0:56:39 Thank you, Travis.
0:56:40 Thank you, Travis.
0:56:41 Okay, like Travis said,
0:56:43 we've had this presentation planned for a while,
0:56:46 and as far as time we can go as we nailed it.
0:56:48 Okay.
0:56:49 Yeah.
0:56:49 Yeah.
0:56:51 Really tonight, it's a two-part presentation.
0:56:54 I'd like to go first and really just kind of
0:56:56 give you an update on the situation,
0:56:59 talk about what we've been doing and the size of the problem,
0:57:02 maybe answer some of your burning questions that you may have,
0:57:04 and then I would like to turn it over
0:57:07 to Mark Thompson, who is the street supervisor,
0:57:10 and he's going to give a presentation
0:57:12 on how we do snow plowing, why we do snow plowing,
0:57:16 all the different techniques and methods
0:57:18 that we've tried over the years,
0:57:19 and what has been working well for us.
0:57:22 So again, it's a little bit of a two-part approach,
0:57:24 and so for now, I'll start with where we're at.
0:57:29 Last Friday, Travis asked the city senior staff
0:57:37 to put together an emergency operation center.
0:57:39 And so the police chief, the fire chief, myself,
0:57:43 and several others got together.
0:57:45 And he started planning because of the amount
0:57:48 of snowfall we've gotten over.
0:57:49 The last seven days, it's been approximately 16 inches
0:57:51 of snow, which was difficult to deal with.
0:57:56 But then we knew the weather, the rain,
0:57:59 and the warm weather that was headed our way
0:58:00 could potentially cause some serious problems.
0:58:03 So we were trying to prepare for that emergency,
0:58:05 so we got together.
0:58:07 And in that time and time, we were able to put together what I think was a pretty good
0:58:11 plan and a pretty good response.
0:58:14 The streets aren't pretty out there, so it's not perfect.
0:58:17 But I want to talk about the size of the problem and really what we're up against and what
0:58:21 we've been doing.
0:58:23 To give you an idea, in the City of Twin Falls, we have 630 lane miles of roadway to
0:58:31 maintain and to Plow Snow on.
0:58:33 And that's basically from Twin Falls to Las Vegas, and that's every city street in Twin
0:58:40 Falls.
0:58:41 And when we go out and we plow streets and Mark's going to get into it in more detail,
0:58:45 I'm going to spend a lot of time on it.
0:58:47 We have priority routes.
0:58:48 Those are familiar ones you know, the arterial is the collectors, and that's about 200 lane
0:58:54 miles.
0:58:55 And that's from here to Ontario.
0:58:58 So when you talk about a single snowstorm and the amount of time it takes to plow from
0:59:01 here to Las Vegas and then you have it's snowing the whole time you're doing
0:59:05 that by the time you get to Las Vegas you pretty much have to turn around and
0:59:08 doesn't look like you've ever been there before. So we're up against a lot.
0:59:13 Our call volumes have been high we knew that we were gonna have high call
0:59:18 volumes and actually so this map this map is should be somewhat familiar to you
0:59:43 It's our zone maintenance map, then what we did is on Friday the public works leadership
0:59:50 came in and started to identify locations of concern for storm water and flooding.
0:59:57 And that's what those red dots are on there.
0:59:59 We have approximately 30 different locations of high concern.
1:00:04 That means that you either require babysitting like they're going to foul up continually.
1:00:10 And you might think, well, why don't you fix that?
1:00:13 Well, it's not really an infrastructure problem as much as it is, just the nature of slush
1:00:17 and ice coming in and need constant maintenance.
1:00:21 So these locations are critical.
1:00:23 We've prioritized them based on also on risk.
1:00:26 So are they associated with the parenthule?
1:00:27 Are they a mass of a amount of water or are they a medium amount of water?
1:00:32 So given these priorities and this direction, the Doug Gonzales in wastewater, he's the
1:00:39 of the US Water Collection Superintendent, broke up his team
1:00:42 into different sectors.
1:00:44 Rather than go by zones, we had to group a couple of zones together,
1:00:47 and basically, I don't want to get too detailed here,
1:00:50 but from Falls North is sector one, from Falls to Addison,
1:00:55 to sector two, and south of Addison, to sector three.
1:00:58 It worked well for the Emergency Operations Center,
1:01:01 meaning fire and police, when we start talking to each other
1:01:04 about incidents in different certain locations,
1:01:07 The vernacular we were using was sector, so we're in sector one or two.
1:01:12 Doug was able to, we only have seven, eight members in wastewater collection.
1:01:19 He was able to deploy all of his people this weekend, starting Sunday at ten in the morning,
1:01:27 and the goal was to go out and just, it was prior to the melt,
1:01:32 and the goal was to assess the situation, see what we're up against,
1:01:35 see what the drains look like.
1:01:37 Is there a mountain of snow on a certain drain,
1:01:40 just to be prepared with what we have?
1:01:43 If there was an opportunity to make progress
1:01:45 and start clearing drains, we were gonna start doing that.
1:01:48 Well, it warmed up Sunday, and the team stayed out all day.
1:01:52 I think the last person probably came in six o'clock
1:01:58 that day we called in others.
1:02:00 And that's what we've been doing this weekend
1:02:04 and anticipation of this storm event,
1:02:07 and I should probably back up to.
1:02:12 Because of the size of the problem,
1:02:15 I think it's difficult for people to understand
1:02:19 what we're doing and if we're doing something.
1:02:22 And I know Council is very well,
1:02:24 I want to share the public that.
1:02:26 We've had every single piece of equipment that we own
1:02:29 that has a plow on it out in the city streets
1:02:31 for the past seven to 10 days, night and day, 24-7.
1:02:36 And now we've got people trying to clear drains 24-7.
1:02:40 And now we've got a little bit more snow to deal with.
1:02:43 So we start getting into some staffing and rest
1:02:45 and safety issues.
1:02:47 And so we definitely need to start doing some shift work
1:02:51 and get people some rest.
1:02:54 If you ask Dean and Mark, his team is getting tired.
1:02:58 So tonight, Dean elected to send the street department home,
1:03:03 for example, get them some rest, because we're probably
1:03:05 going to get called out again here pretty shortly.
1:03:09 And the members of the other members of Public Works water
1:03:12 and wastewater are still out clearing grains.
1:03:20 Like Travis said, we've had a ton of help.
1:03:22 This has been a team effort from dispatch
1:03:25 to parks, the citizens, concerned citizens that
1:03:28 have been helping, or they see a problem they make the call.
1:03:31 We, like I said, our call volume is massive today.
1:03:34 Vicki, in our office, was getting phone calls, literally,
1:03:39 if you did math, it was like every three minutes,
1:03:40 you'd get my phone call.
1:03:42 And some of those are multiple locations.
1:03:45 And those are not just, thank you for calling.
1:03:48 Those are calls for service.
1:03:50 People have to go out and actually do something.
1:03:55 So anyway, that's pretty much where we're at to date.
1:04:02 Do you have any questions so far?
1:04:05 Don't know.
1:04:06 The rumor that's been going around for 30 years,
1:04:09 as I heard it, is that we sold off our snow plows
1:04:13 and that's why they're not out there during the warm seasons.
1:04:16 Could you dispel that or confirm it?
1:04:22 So the rumor is that we sold them to Jerome.
1:04:27 I hadn't heard that one.
1:04:30 How I'd like to carry that rumor is when I came from Jerome,
1:04:34 I stole them all back there's so much I could say about that actually in our
1:04:45 present we really are going to talk about that tonight it's not true we have
1:04:49 clouds we've never I'm not aware of any time in our history that we sold them
1:04:53 we've replaced some and we actually have actually still have one piece of
1:04:57 equipment for you three old older pieces equipment so anyway
1:05:03 Mark's going to get into that. Any other questions?
1:05:06 Chris Stockton. Travis, we can ask the governor to bring in
1:05:13 declare an emergency and bring in the guard with the weather
1:05:17 for the next week being wet, whatever form her and I'm asking
1:05:23 you John as well. Are we able to keep our head above water on
1:05:26 this? Get it get to the point where it's too much for us to
1:05:31 handle both with the safety issues on her staff and the equipment and the 630 line miles, lane
1:05:38 miles.
1:05:41 That would be, well, you know, we've done a lot of planning, a lot of preparation, and
1:05:47 obviously we'd have to, whatever the situation would dictate.
1:05:50 If we got to that point, I would feel comfortable knowing how to get that done, especially through
1:05:57 Travis.
1:05:58 point in time I don't see that I think I think today and the last the way that
1:06:02 the weather in the rain has come today has actually been a reasonable snow melt
1:06:06 and actually I feel like we kind of knock on wood dodged a bullet so far but we do
1:06:12 have some more weather coming our way and so I feel I feel like we've got a
1:06:15 handle on it and I'm feeling fairly confident with that. Suzanne Hawkins. Thank
1:06:23 you. I just wanted to confirm that I gave a citizen a good answer this week
1:06:27 because it is there is nothing in City Code to prevent a home owners association from
1:06:34 hiring their own company to come in and clean their streets in our city.
1:06:38 Is that true or false?
1:06:45 I don't think we have anything in City Code, but the attorney can, but one of the things
1:06:56 that we would really caution is that if the type of equipment
1:07:04 that we use is designed to be operated on in Municipal Street,
1:07:07 and this is something that Dean and John have really imparted to me,
1:07:13 is that so on the bottom of every, and I'm going to get this language wrong,
1:07:16 so please excuse me, but we have, you know, we don't run with a steel bit on the bottom
1:07:23 of that, we run with a rubber bit.
1:07:25 And that makes a big difference, especially when you start
1:07:29 looking at manholes and water line services.
1:07:34 And Dean, when we were having a meeting, I believe it was
1:07:39 on Friday morning or Thursday morning, we were talking
1:07:43 about some of these different things.
1:07:44 And they were talking about how you could hit one of those
1:07:47 just wrong and it becomes an amazing flying projectile.
1:07:52 And so we would, if people are going to go out
1:07:55 and they're going to hire their own groups,
1:07:59 the first thing I would do is defer all of those questions
1:08:02 to Dean and his team to determine whether or not
1:08:06 it's not only safe, but whether or not individuals
1:08:10 trying to do maybe something of good will
1:08:14 don't impact and do greater damage to our road surface
1:08:17 that requires us to go back in later on in the year
1:08:20 and put better care for it.
1:08:22 So legal or not, I think that there's a question
1:08:26 of responsibility, risk, and safety
1:08:28 that I think need to be addressed
1:08:30 before a whole bunch of different independent contractors
1:08:34 go out and start plowing city roadways.
1:08:36 I'm feeling very good because I actually passed
1:08:38 all that information along and gave him your name
1:08:42 and number.
1:08:42 LAUGHTER
1:08:45 Yes, I agree.
1:08:45 I think it's a can of worms.
1:08:46 Because not only is there emphasis
1:08:49 damage risk, you may play a play-state pile of smell and location that causes extreme flooding
1:08:55 to a lot of people. So if you're not intimately familiar with how things drain and where drain
1:09:00 locations are, you can cause a significant amount of damage. I miss something important. Can I
1:09:07 go back? Please, Dean. Okay, thank you. I just wanted to talk about the priorities over the
1:09:12 last several days. The emergency operations center identified. Number one was
1:09:20 responder safety. So if we go out and we're trying to help people and we get hurt, that's
1:09:24 not a good thing. Public safety is number two and private and public property is number
1:09:32 three. Those are our priorities as we try to do what we're doing. We want to maintain
1:09:39 access. We want to avoid a flood and one of the big concerns that the building official
1:09:45 has of course is roof loading and roof collapse with the snow as you're well aware.
1:09:50 It was dry now it's not very heavy and it can put your roof at risk for collapse.
1:10:00 And Mark's probably going to get into it but generally speaking we don't go into residential
1:10:06 areas and plow unless we absolutely have to.
1:10:11 The reason we did it this year was because we felt that the police and fire may have a emergency response problem.
1:10:18 If someone's having cardiac arrest and they can't even get to the house, we felt that that was a significant risk.
1:10:25 When we go into residential and we plow, it's a balance, it's a love-hate relationship.
1:10:31 Because one neighbor calls and says, please plow our street.
1:10:35 And then the same neighbor, or a different neighbor,
1:10:37 in the same neighborhood, we'll call and say,
1:10:39 why did you power streets?
1:10:41 If I can't get out.
1:10:42 So kind of, damned if you do, damned if you don't,
1:10:47 we have to make a judgment call.
1:10:49 And there's times where we did power
1:10:51 as an initial neighborhood, and they did get stuck.
1:10:55 And based on, again, risk, there are some situations
1:11:00 that we'd actually go out and help.
1:11:02 if the person that is elderly or disabled or has to as requiring medical assistance,
1:11:08 that isn't an emergency but still requires like maybe medical supplies delivered
1:11:12 or needs to go to a doctor's appointment, we did deploy resources to go help those folks out.
1:11:18 Again, go in, you think you're going to problem it,
1:11:21 somebody's life better but sometimes it doesn't, it makes it worse.
1:11:26 Any other questions before I turn it over to Mark?
1:11:28 John, just one other comment I would make so Wednesday in the middle
1:11:33 I love the storm, I drove from my office on the north side of Bantown thinking I would be a genius and take whatever street it is over here that comes up to the Fire and Police Department.
1:11:44 I can love that and it will be plowed.
1:11:47 And it wasn't.
1:11:48 So, I came across a couple of people who were kitty corner in the intersection driving cars they shouldn't have been out there.
1:11:57 got out and helped push, ran into so many people who were out helping others.
1:12:02 I think that the citizen response, not only in their actions, in helping others,
1:12:08 but in their attitude, and maybe more importantly their attitude,
1:12:11 in understanding that this is pretty impressive in it.
1:12:15 What we got, it's certainly rare, and we're all in it together,
1:12:20 so complaining about it isn't going to make it get fixed any faster.
1:12:24 I really appreciate everyone's taking it in stride, communicating what needs to be communicated
1:12:32 that is an emergency or critical and understanding that a lot of it is just a nuisance and moving
1:12:38 past that.
1:12:39 So I've certainly experienced that with the calls that I've taken and the emails I've
1:12:45 received and the people I've run into and I think that's been good for you and your crews
1:12:51 in the rest of the city team.
1:12:53 So thanks to the citizens for doing that.
1:12:57 Good point.
1:12:58 When I was out, I saw lots of people helping each other.
1:13:00 It's been good.
1:13:02 And while it's not perfect, I am very pleased
1:13:06 with how Public Works has been able to get this far.
1:13:10 It could be worse.
1:13:12 Anything else?
1:13:14 Okay.
1:13:15 Thank you, John.
1:13:24 Mr. Mayor, Council, I'd like to thank you for letting me
1:13:27 come and share this with you. To start off with, we just wanted to kind of give you a kind of a pass
1:13:38 versus present. What we had back in 1984, which was a couple plows, a couple road graders, and a
1:13:47 couple of sand trucks. Now, we have, at 1984, we started with about 20 miles of priority one
1:13:55 roads. Now in 2017 we're over 200 miles of just priority one roads and we've updated
1:14:04 our fleet to instead of just having two plow trucks and two sand trucks that would run one
1:14:12 would run in front of them and then the sand truck would come behind them. We've updated
1:14:17 them to combination vehicles where we have a plow and sand truck together. We've still
1:14:24 got the two road graders, the front loader, the plows. We've updated our skid steer with
1:14:33 a plow. We've got two de-icer trucks that we use for pre-wetting and we've still got
1:14:41 the snowblower that we purchased back in 1982. So we wanted to show you this picture.
1:14:55 This was taken last Thursday after the storm kind of broke. The two plows on the two graders
1:15:03 are the original plows that we had back in 1984.
1:15:06 So if we ever did sell a plow, it wasn't one of those two.
1:15:10 So when we start plowing, we start with all our priority one
1:15:19 roads.
1:15:21 We have over 200 miles of priority ones.
1:15:24 Each truck of each of our five trucks
1:15:27 has to cover 40 miles.
1:15:29 And we have 12 two truck routes.
1:15:32 And when we talk about two truck routes,
1:15:34 They are routes that consist of multiple lane roads like blue lakes, Washington, and we send
1:15:43 two trucks tandem together so we can cover both lanes and turn lanes in one pass so we're not
1:15:50 making four different passes to cover everything. We've broken it up into two single truck routes
1:15:57 which are routes with just single lanes, passing lanes, and those would be like
1:16:04 Grandview, Hank, and stuff that we can do with one pass with one truck and make
1:16:12 the most of our time. Each truck, each one of our trucks can carry five yards of
1:16:18 material and we wanted to base these routes on what we could cover with the
1:16:26 the amount of material we had in the trucks.
1:16:29 So we've figured out that each one of our trucks
1:16:32 can cover between 8 and 10 miles with that five yards
1:16:34 of material.
1:16:42 So once we finish all our priority one roads,
1:16:44 and we, they're safe and passable,
1:16:46 we move on to the priority two routes, which is basically
1:16:50 all residential streets in our eight maintenance zones.
1:16:54 So when we switch, each one of our trucks
1:16:58 will take one maintenance zone and they'll
1:17:02 complete that maintenance zone until that's finished.
1:17:05 Once we finish the priority two routes,
1:17:07 we move on to the priority three,
1:17:10 which is all the city-owned parking lots and alleys.
1:17:12 With this last storm,
1:17:16 water department jumped in with their back hose
1:17:20 and cleaned all the parking lots,
1:17:22 so that kind of took a lot of time to wait,
1:17:26 so we didn't have to do.
1:17:28 So when we talk about city-wide coverage,
1:17:30 We have over 630 lane miles of road, each truck has to cover 126 miles, which last week
1:17:48 and with this storm, each route was taking us about an hour and a half to finish.
1:17:54 So with that, with those routes, it takes 21 hours per truck to cover the entire city,
1:18:03 which is 105 man hours and we end up putting down 86 tons of salt and sand.
1:18:11 So when we talk about salt and sand, we're currently using a mixture of 6 to 1, which is
1:18:20 6 to 10 wheelers to 1 load of sand.
1:18:23 With this storm, we knew the temperatures were going to drop, so we actually bumped it up to
1:18:29 2 loads of salt.
1:18:32 We cover that every year owed that we have we use salt and sand
1:18:38 2013 was our biggest year
1:18:40 We put out two twenty four hundred eighty one tons of salt and sand this year. We've doubled just in the last two months
1:18:48 We've put over five thousand tons of salt and sand down
1:18:51 The drawback to salt and sand is spring clean up
1:18:57 Which pretty much a one-to-one?
1:18:59 If we put out 5,000 tons of salt and sand, we sweep up 5,000 tons of sand.
1:19:09 And it takes four sweepers, two water trucks, about two months is going it up.
1:19:18 And you've probably noticed in spring, you'll see a dust cloud going down the road with, even with water, you know, it's just a dust cloud.
1:19:27 You can't even see the sweep right there.
1:19:30 So we've also used liquid de-isers.
1:19:37 In 2010, prior to 2010, the only thing we used was magnesium chloride.
1:19:44 And it's a great product.
1:19:49 The cost is a little bit higher.
1:19:52 But we were finding that in lower temperatures, below 20 degrees,
1:19:57 it would start to freeze and we'd actually create ice.
1:20:02 So we started researching different types of liquid de-ishers.
1:20:10 So in 2011 and 2012, we experimented with geomelt, which is a sugar-beat based product,
1:20:19 and it actually great product.
1:20:22 It lowers your freeze point to about minus 37 degrees, but in this area we don't usually
1:20:30 to get those types of low temperatures, and the cost was enormous.
1:20:35 So we kind of quit that, and then we went to salt brine in 2013,
1:20:40 which is about 15 cents a gallon to produce versus the dollar 8
1:20:44 a gallon of the geomelt.
1:20:46 So it's really saved us a lot of money.
1:20:54 So when we make salt brine, we're using 2.28 pounds of salt
1:21:02 per gallon to get the ideal concentration of 23.3 percent, which at that concentration gives
1:21:11 us our lowest freezing point. Anything above 23.3, your temperature, your freeze rate starts
1:21:17 to rise. So at 24 degrees, or 24 percent, it raises your freeze point to negative one.
1:21:25 And if you go to 25, it actually goes to 13 above zero. So just those little differences
1:21:32 and your concentrations can really, it can cause problems.
1:21:39 So our application rate in certain areas
1:21:42 were 30 to 60 gallons per lane mile.
1:21:46 In the canyon, we're up in the higher end,
1:21:49 up in the 60 gallons per lane,
1:21:52 just because it gives us that extra time to get back
1:21:57 and it'll melt ice for quite a bit longer.
1:22:01 We also use it in pre-wetting applications.
1:22:04 Each one of our trucks are set up with DICER tanks.
1:22:08 As the sand leaves the truck, it is sprayed to start
1:22:12 that chemical reaction with the salt.
1:22:16 We're currently using salt brine on canyons springs to show
1:22:20 them falls in all major intersections.
1:22:22 We try and pre-wet.
1:22:28 So the advantage is to salt brine is we can pre-wet prior
1:22:32 to a storm event. We can hit all our priority one roads and keep the ice from building. What
1:22:45 the brine does is when it hits the ground, it creates a film and it keeps the snow and
1:22:53 ice from bonding to the pavement so when we do plow it, it comes off easier. We have
1:22:59 less passes to make. There's less risk to motorists for windshield damage and we can
1:23:06 apply a lot per day to 2,000 to 6,000 gallons per day and we're wanting to go higher in that.
1:23:16 So it also reduces our overtime call outs for minor storms because we can pre-wet and we
1:23:22 can melt up to a couple inches of snow and we don't get the call outs.
1:23:29 we're also reducing the sedimentation that's going into our storm sewers.
1:23:35 So in the future, we'd like to expand the use of our salt brine.
1:23:41 We're currently retrofitting a dump truck that was an old sewer jet truck
1:23:47 to be used as a deicing truck.
1:23:52 We also purchased a new flush truck for the sweepers this year
1:23:57 that will be converted into a deicer also.
1:24:01 We've built, we bought our first one, we've built the last two.
1:24:04 So we feel we can come in and just build one versus trying to buy a setup.
1:24:11 And in the future, starting here pretty quick, long term planning will be asking for
1:24:17 our own brian maker.
1:24:19 We can produce it at a reasonable cost.
1:24:40 And our goal within the next few years is to be able to spray liquid on every city street
1:24:45 before a storm event.
1:24:48 So that would hopefully greatly reduce the time you spent out on the roads.
1:24:55 Any questions?
1:24:59 Not not.
1:25:00 Obviously not just reduce the time you spent out there, but add to the safety
1:25:05 for folks driving.
1:25:06 And I think that's paramount as well.
1:25:08 And I know that's what you probably meant to say as well.
1:25:11 But I think that's just so important for us to be able to get out there
1:25:16 and prevent when we can.
1:25:17 I think we've all been witnesses to how many cars got stuck or had to help push people out and some traffic collisions as well and property damage.
1:25:30 So thank you for your presentation.
1:25:32 One comment I'd make and I mentioned this to Travis last week.
1:25:38 So during the peak of the storm on Wednesday, I had calls from a couple of places.
1:25:42 One was the Bishop's storehouse.
1:25:44 Actually, it was on Thursday.
1:25:45 They had a truck on its way from Salt Lake, that particular side street, Mountain View hadn't
1:25:51 been hit by a plow because in reality they're the only thing there.
1:25:57 And so a suggestion they have is once we're not in the middle of these storm events, maybe
1:26:02 taking another look at our priority road system.
1:26:04 I know we try to address school areas, but maybe thinking about should we be looking at
1:26:11 areas that have churches or those kind of community services that in an emergency may
1:26:17 be needed, maybe just kind of reassessing that priority list on every once in a while, one
1:26:26 because we have all these new subdivisions that have come in and again, they're kind of the
1:26:30 only thing out there, but it was a critical service for them that day because they had families
1:26:35 coming in to get assistance and couldn't get a truck in.
1:26:40 So just a suggestion as we get through the storms to think about those areas.
1:26:47 Any other questions or comments?
1:26:50 Chris Stockington.
1:26:51 Well, it's kind of a reference to the question I asked last week and I'm not sure the answer,
1:26:55 but we have to control those intersections for the water to be able to run off in our
1:27:01 limited storm drains. Is it working? Are most of the storm drains below the sidewalk level?
1:27:09 At the water level, I mean now? Are we keeping up with it at all?
1:27:15 I think today we've made a great headway with it. I think we're almost there.
1:27:23 Are the storm drains themselves open? I mean, they're not going to freeze up even though they may get
1:27:29 get their open to the atmosphere. I'm not sure if they themselves.
1:27:34 That was one of the things we were worried about to begin with. We thought about clearing
1:27:41 the storm drains prior to the thaw, but we were afraid if we went in too soon and exposed
1:27:50 all the drains that they would freeze and it would cause a bigger problem. So we chose
1:27:54 to leave the snow on the drains until the very last minute, and then that's when we started
1:28:01 moving.
1:28:02 Great job.
1:28:03 Thank you.
1:28:04 Anything else?
1:28:06 I don't see anything else.
1:28:09 Great.
1:28:10 Thank you so much.
1:28:11 Thank you.
1:28:18 Now go get some rest because it's going to be a busy couple of days I think for you
1:28:22 all again.
1:28:23 Next on the agenda is a request to amend Twin Falls City Code 3-19-1 regarding catering
1:28:29 permits to conform with 2016 amendments to Idaho Code 23934A, Sharon Bryant.
1:28:38 This is me and your council, Sharon Bryant, Deputy City Clerk.
1:28:42 I'm here to ask that you amend the Twin Falls City Code 3-19-1 regarding catering permits
1:28:52 to conform with the 2016 amendments to Idaho Code 23-934A,
1:28:58 which changed the length of the time
1:29:04 that a party or convention can obtain a catering permit.
1:29:09 And they've also added that catering permits will not be issued
1:29:14 without written approval by the Fire Inspector.
1:29:22 Any questions for Sharon, Ruth here?
1:29:29 Sharon, what was the old length of time
1:29:30 and what's the new length of time?
1:29:34 The old length of time was three consecutive days,
1:29:40 and they have expanded that to five.
1:29:43 Thank you.
1:29:46 And the change was driven by communities that had events
1:29:50 that lasted longer than three days, such as tree
1:29:53 ford and poison.
1:29:57 You have an ordinance number?
1:29:58 I'm going to guess 2017 dash two.
1:30:04 Chris Stockington, move placing two old one seven dash two on
1:30:08 third and final by title under only under suspension rules.
1:30:12 Second motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Ruth Pierce to
1:30:16 place ordinance 2017 dash two on third and final reading by title
1:30:19 only by suspending the rules.
1:30:22 Any discussion?
1:30:24 Sharon, I'll call vote.
1:30:27 Chris Stockington.
1:30:28 Yes.
1:30:29 Don Hall.
1:30:30 Yes.
1:30:30 Yes.
1:30:31 Ms. Anne Hocken.
1:30:32 Yes.
1:30:33 Nikki Boyd.
1:30:34 Yes.
1:30:35 Shown Burger.
1:30:36 Yes.
1:30:37 Motion passes 6-0.
1:30:38 Chair, would you read the title, please?
1:30:47 Ordinance number 2017-2.
1:30:50 And ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho amending Twin Falls City
1:30:56 Code 3-19-1 regarding catering permits to conform with 2016 amendments to Idaho Code 23-9-30-1.
1:31:06 34A be it ordained by the mayor and the council of the city of Twin Falls Idaho that
1:31:12 Twin Falls City Code 3-19-1 is amended as follows.
1:31:18 Susan Hawkins move approval of ordinance 2017-2 second motion by Suzanne how can
1:31:27 say that by Nikki Boyd to approve ordinance 2017-2 is there any discussion
1:31:32 Seeing none, Sharon Roll, call vote please.
1:31:36 Don Hall?
1:31:37 Yes.
1:31:38 Ruth Parris?
1:31:39 Yes.
1:31:40 Suzanne Hocken?
1:31:41 Yes.
1:31:42 Snicky Boy?
1:31:43 Yes.
1:31:44 Sean Bericher?
1:31:46 Yes.
1:31:47 Chris Hocken?
1:31:48 Yes.
1:31:50 Motion passes 6 to 0.
1:31:51 Thanks, Sharon.
1:31:52 Thank you.
1:31:53 Next on the agenda is another opportunity for public input.
1:31:54 Anyone from the public wishing to address the Council on an item not on this evening's
1:31:58 agenda?
1:31:59 You're welcome to come forward now.
1:32:02 Seeing no one, Travis, anything from you?
1:32:08 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, two items.
1:32:11 Number one, we are going to be closed next Monday
1:32:16 in observation of Martin Luther King Jr. Day.
1:32:19 And that means that the City Council meeting
1:32:22 will occur on Tuesday at five o'clock.
1:32:26 And then also congratulations to Councilman slash
1:32:31 commissioner Don Hall for accepting the position today
1:32:36 the position today in taking the oath. I think that Don, we were talking about this earlier, is
1:32:42 is maybe the only individual to serve in a in a dual capacity in the history of our community.
1:32:51 So congratulations to Don. Anything from the council? Well, Don, I would echo Travis's comments.
1:33:06 Congratulations on your new position. However, you're not done working yet because we do have
1:33:12 public hearing still. And next Monday, Don will be joining us for a little
1:33:19 memento of our thanks for your service to the community as we prepare also to
1:33:23 swear in Christopher Reed as our new council member next week. Tuesday.
1:33:28 Tuesday, that's what I meant. Thank you. Seeing nothing else from anyone, are we
1:33:36 good to keep going or anybody to break? We'll keep cruising through. All right,
1:33:41 We will move to our public hearings now.
1:33:43 The first is a request for a zoning district change
1:33:46 and a zoning map amendment for 2.14 plus or minus acres
1:33:50 from C1 PUD to C1 ZDA to develop a hotel and accessory uses
1:33:57 with a maximum building height of 55 feet
1:34:00 on property located east of 1788 Washington Street North
1:34:04 for West Park Partners, LLC.
1:34:07 We have Gerald Martins in representing the applicant,
1:34:11 and then a staff report from Jonathan Spemlove.
1:34:13 Welcome, Mr. Martins.
1:34:15 Thank you.
1:34:16 For the record, my name is Gerald Martins.
1:34:18 I'm here this evening representing West Park Partners,
1:34:21 the owner of the property located just south
1:34:25 of the intersection of Washington and Poline
1:34:28 and immediately to the east of the existing hotel.
1:34:31 It's a 2.14-acre parcel.
1:34:34 for proposing here to develop this one eight or two point
1:34:38 so agar parcel as a hotel
1:34:41 the ZDA will be specific, that's the only use allowed
1:34:46 is an addition to the fact that it would be hotel
1:34:50 that would be have the increased height
1:34:53 to 55 feet maximum height.
1:34:57 When I read through the staff report,
1:34:59 I have reviewed the staff recommendations with Jonathan
1:35:03 and we concur with the staff recommendations.
1:35:09 Thank you, Gerald.
1:35:10 Jonathan, it's my love.
1:35:12 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
1:35:15 history on the property is storied.
1:35:17 It's about two-pater, page and a half.
1:35:19 I'm not gonna go through all of it,
1:35:19 but it started in 1893.
1:35:22 It was a PUD that encompassed a large tract
1:35:26 northeast corner of Washington and Poland,
1:35:28 and went all the way past Canyon Crest,
1:35:29 over to the other side of the time, Cooley.
1:35:32 So lots of property over the years,
1:35:34 and that's what these dates are over the years.
1:35:35 been pieces that have been cut out for different businesses and different PUDs or ZDA's. Some
1:35:41 of those included Walgreens, Covers, the current hotel here, as well as some of the other lots
1:35:48 over here on the east side of Canyon Crest and so on and so forth. That's what all the
1:35:53 histories about is all of those different PUDs that have come through this property. In
1:35:59 order to come through, they're looking primarily for an additional height. The C1 zoning district
1:36:06 because of the height of 50 feet.
1:36:09 They're asking for 55 feet.
1:36:10 In order to do that, that's two public hearings.
1:36:13 Additionally, a hotel in the C1 zone
1:36:17 requires a special use permit.
1:36:18 So they elected to do a ZDA, which kind of combines
1:36:21 all those processes into two public hearings
1:36:23 along with the Ponting and Zoning Commission.
1:36:25 The recommends to the city council
1:36:26 and then you make the decision to have this ZDA.
1:36:30 The draft of the ZDA is included in the packet.
1:36:33 It's really small because there's only two things
1:36:35 asking that Barry from the C1 Zone, one of already talked about, hotel being
1:36:40 permitted, and the maximum height being pushed up to 55 feet. So per the city code
1:36:46 we're working with this 10-6 is the zoning development agreements. They've
1:36:49 applied or provided a master development plan since it's only one lot.
1:36:59 It's basically this building here being the new hotel, the existing Fairfield
1:37:04 over here on the west, some parking area, and they're actually going to be working
1:37:09 conjunction with another, so there's going to be this outdoor seating area where the
1:37:15 two hotels can use this common outside area together. So it's kind of a one user type
1:37:21 of deal. The impacts on these typically involve around increased vehicular trips, potential
1:37:29 light intrusion and noise from the daily operations of the business. The light noise of the operations
1:37:34 are most likely to be felt on the northern portion of the property. The homes on the west
1:37:38 side of Washington Street will be shielded by the Fairfield Inn that's
1:37:41 currently constructed in operation. The residential area to the north will be in
1:37:44 close proximity to this development. There will be some ambient noise and light
1:37:48 intrusion. Increasing vehicular trips is expected as there will be multiple units.
1:37:54 I don't know the total number, I think it's north of 100 but not a percent
1:37:59 short, but the vast majority will take place on Washington Street, North and
1:38:04 with both these roadways being constructed at arterial standards.
1:38:08 It's not expected this project will create a great burden on the road system in the area.
1:38:14 On December 13th, 2016, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing.
1:38:18 There was considerable discussion regarding the pedestrian and vehicular
1:38:22 use of the private street.
1:38:25 And on the south side of this development, the commission felt the impacts of hotels created
1:38:28 unsafe pedestrian crossings along the private drive.
1:38:32 And the commission felt many of those pedestrians were coming from the hotel.
1:38:35 that number would only increase another hotel being built.
1:38:38 The developer stated he would work on a master of pedestrian planning with staff to provide
1:38:42 safe means for people to walk, upon conclusion of the applicant presentation and staff presentation
1:38:47 and discussion the commission unanimously recommended approval of their request as presented subject
1:38:52 to the following conditions.
1:38:55 Number one subject to site plan amendments as required by building engineering, fire and
1:38:58 zoning officials to comply with applicable city codes and standards.
1:39:02 number two subject to a master pedestrian pathway plan for the entire undeveloped area
1:39:06 between Washington Street North and Canyon Crest Drive being reviewed by staff.
1:39:11 There's staff reports written a little bit differently because of last week's storm we
1:39:14 kind of sent it out before I was quite finished with it and had other things to go on.
1:39:19 But what I've pointed here is two things we talked about after this after last week.
1:39:29 There's two things that we'd like to modify on this number two.
1:39:33 In areas in red, basically a small change in language,
1:39:36 instead of being reviewed by staff,
1:39:38 it'd be approved by city staff.
1:39:40 And then included in the West Park
1:39:42 Zoning Development Agreement.
1:39:44 We'd be putting this master pedestrian plan with the ZDA
1:39:47 so we could actually have a way to enforce it,
1:39:50 because what we're going for.
1:39:51 And that was the intent of the commission.
1:39:54 When we created this condition,
1:39:56 was done at the meeting.
1:40:00 So this is something we thought about afterwards.
1:40:02 It's a timing thing.
1:40:02 When do we enforce it?
1:40:03 How do we enforce it?
1:40:05 What do we get?
1:40:05 How do we look at it?
1:40:07 And additionally, the zoning administrator
1:40:09 asked for the ZDA ordinance in the West Park commercial number
1:40:12 10 final plat to be recorded prior to development.
1:40:16 That's something that's already a required encodent,
1:40:18 which is something we'd like.
1:40:19 Whoever, if this development doesn't happen or something
1:40:22 occurs in the future, we'd like them to know we need that
1:40:25 plan before they can actually build on the property.
1:40:28 So it's more of a cursory plan.
1:40:32 That concludes the staff presentations.
1:40:33 I have any questions?
1:40:35 Any questions for Jonathan?
1:40:39 Do not see any.
1:40:41 So with that, we will open the public hearing.
1:40:47 And I don't have to sign up sheet,
1:40:50 but I'll just ask, because there aren't many people here.
1:40:52 If you would like to speak on this item,
1:40:56 please come forward now to provide your testimony.
1:41:07 Welcome.
1:41:08 If you would please state your name and address for the record.
1:41:10 Max Newland, 327th Avenue.
1:41:13 I remember having one of these hearings before, and there was a big discussion about how high
1:41:18 and how we make changes, and the Fairfield says, that's not really too high.
1:41:25 This other thing we had along was architectural accoutement, and so I'm asking is the 55 foot
1:41:31 including all the architectural fruffinas, or what's the, does that allow you to have
1:41:39 a third floor, it's what I'm guessing that it does.
1:41:42 And so I'm just making sure that you guys remember Mr. Max's
1:41:47 as a concerned citizen and have that question.
1:41:49 Thank you.
1:41:50 Thank you.
1:41:51 We will have the applicant answer that following the public
1:41:55 testimony portion of the public hearing.
1:41:57 Is there any other public comment?
1:41:59 Seeing none, we will close the public input portion of the public
1:42:06 hearing and turn it over to the applicant to reply.
1:42:10 He's looking.
1:42:15 Well, I was struggling here to read the elevations, but the response is, and the heights have
1:42:24 always been the area that needed to be protected by the fire department for occupancy of people.
1:42:30 Architectural features such as canvasular entrances and architectural features that extend above
1:42:39 the space that's enclosed for occupancy could exceed the 55 feet.
1:42:47 So the 55 feet is a normal and inhabited envelope of the building, envelope is a word
1:42:55 I'm trying to come up with, but it's a space that encloses the building.
1:43:00 Some examples would be pop-ups above the roof that might screen mechanical equipment.
1:43:10 Oftentimes we do a little screen, six above the roof, to screen the mechanical equipment.
1:43:17 Sometimes it's done to create an identity.
1:43:20 One I can think of is Lowe's, which is that years ago, the Lowe's deal on the front, that
1:43:25 That's their logo, extends above that.
1:43:28 Sometimes it's just jugs in the parapet to provide interest and character to the building.
1:43:34 But the answer is yes, there could be portions of this above 55 feet, but not inhabited by occupant.
1:43:42 Thank you.
1:43:43 Thank you, Gerald.
1:43:44 Travis, or else, mother?
1:43:45 I think Mr. Martin's last statement was probably the absolutely spot on him.
1:43:51 But when you look at the building height, it's the place that is being occupied, anything that is above that is often excluded.
1:44:00 And if you often think of like church churches and their steeple, their steeple is often not included in that height zone or variance.
1:44:10 Thank you, Mr. Martin.
1:44:11 Could I add, I would just to inform that by the owner's representative that this particular case of 55 feet encompasses everything.
1:44:20 So, thank you.
1:44:20 Thank you.
1:44:21 I wanted to state that for the concerned neighbor.
1:44:24 Thank you.
1:44:25 Thank you.
1:44:27 Chris talking.
1:44:28 So it's kind of redundant for me to ask this question,
1:44:30 but an elevator shaft would not extend beyond 55 feet.
1:44:37 The shaft would, but the elevator would not.
1:44:41 There is mechanisms in an elevator,
1:44:44 you got a car that you ride in.
1:44:46 That's right.
1:44:47 And above the car is mechanisms that lift the car up.
1:44:52 And so there could be elevator shafts about 55 feet,
1:44:55 but not in the case, not in this case.
1:44:58 Thank you.
1:45:02 Thank you, Gerald.
1:45:03 All right.
1:45:06 But then I will turn it over to Council for deliberation.
1:45:10 Christock.
1:45:11 Well, we'll throw it on the table.
1:45:14 I would move to approve the request for the zoning district
1:45:18 change and zoning map amendment for 2.14 acres from C1PAD
1:45:23 to C1ZDA to develop a hotel and accessory
1:45:27 uses with a maximum building height 55 feet on the property located at 1788
1:45:32 Washington Street North subject to the addition of the attached conditions where
1:45:39 there are three or four three three attached conditions second motion by
1:45:47 Kristoknend seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the request subject to the
1:45:52 conditions right there. Is there any
1:45:59 discussion? Thank you, boy. Yes, Mr. Mayor, I
1:46:03 wanted to check the Jonathan, you're out of there.
1:46:07 The master pedestrian pathway,
1:46:11 is that now added on to those four? Yes, so what
1:46:15 we're going to do is this condition number two will require them to bring that
1:46:19 master pathway planned back to city staff, we'll talk with them about
1:46:23 that will then be included with the ZDA.
1:46:28 Okay, we'll see that prior to passing any ordinance
1:46:31 for the ZDA to be approved.
1:46:33 Okay, mine still was the draft.
1:46:35 And so, and I couldn't quite read that.
1:46:37 So I just wanted to make sure this was now, okay.
1:46:39 Thank you very much.
1:46:42 Any further discussion?
1:46:46 Share your roll call vote, please.
1:46:48 Don Hall.
1:46:49 Yes.
1:46:50 Ruth Parris.
1:46:51 Yes.
1:46:52 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:46:53 Yes.
1:46:53 Nikki Boyd.
1:46:54 Yes.
1:46:55 Don Barrieger.
1:46:56 Yes.
1:46:57 Yes.
1:46:58 Motion passes 6-0.
1:46:59 That was a valid question.
1:47:00 Mr. Martins.
1:47:01 That was a valid question.
1:47:04 A next is a request for a vacation of portions of a utility easement and a sewer easement located
1:47:12 within Lot 1 Block 1 St. Luke subdivision, a PUD on property located at 801 Poline Road
1:47:19 West for St. Luke's Magic Valley.
1:47:21 We have Jason Thezmer with the land group representing the applicant and then the staff
1:47:28 report from Jonathan and Sven left welcome.
1:47:31 Thank you.
1:47:32 My name is Jason Densmer.
1:47:33 I'm with the land group here tonight
1:47:35 representing St. Luke's for this application.
1:47:38 As a little bit of background, I'm
1:47:41 sure everyone's familiar with the hospital campus.
1:47:43 It's between Grandview and Parkview Dry's South Pole Line.
1:47:48 The main hospital building is in this portion of the site.
1:47:52 And at the time the hospital was constructed,
1:47:55 some land was left aside on the east end of the campus
1:47:57 for future expansion, particularly at the northeast corner,
1:48:01 there's an area that was identified
1:48:04 to meet future needs for medical office building space.
1:48:08 Well, the future is now, and so it's now been concluded
1:48:12 that it's time to build the medical office building
1:48:15 for that.
1:48:16 Over the seven or eight years since the hospital
1:48:17 was opened though, the needs for that building
1:48:20 have increased beyond the space that was originally allocated.
1:48:25 And so some of the improvements that we're putting in at the time of the original construction
1:48:29 are unfortunately in the wrong place and we need to do some reorganizing of them in order
1:48:34 to fit in the medical office building that's now being planned.
1:48:38 So this is a little graphic that blows up that northeast corner of the overall campus
1:48:43 and shows a gray outline here, the proposed medical office building overlaid with the two
1:48:50 easements that we're here tonight to request vacation of.
1:48:54 The green easement through here was a sewer city, a twin-fault sewer that existed before
1:49:00 the hospital was even constructed.
1:49:02 And at the time of the hospital construction, the line that used to lie within that easement
1:49:06 was relocated, but the easement for it was never vacated.
1:49:10 So the easement, there's a new easement on the new sewer line, but the old easement is still
1:49:14 there where the sewer line is no longer out.
1:49:16 So there's a little bit of an administrative cleanup that we're asking for tonight in
1:49:20 order to vacate the green easement.
1:49:22 The blue easement follows a new water line that was installed
1:49:27 seven or eight years ago again in anticipation of a
1:49:31 medical office building.
1:49:32 It would have provided the water service to that
1:49:34 medical office building and fire protection for it.
1:49:37 But as you can see, it's clearly in the wrong place
1:49:39 for the medical office building.
1:49:41 It's now being planned.
1:49:42 We've worked with the city's engineering and have
1:49:44 figured out an alternate route for the water line.
1:49:47 And we'll be providing a new easement over the new water line.
1:49:50 But in order to process the building permit for the
1:49:52 Medical Office building. We're here tonight to request your approval for
1:49:55 vacation of that blue easement as well. I think that's about a 10,000 foot overview
1:50:01 of the application but if I goofed it up please let me know how I can answer and
1:50:05 clarify for you. Any questions? Thank you. Don't see me. Thank you very much.
1:50:13 Jonathan spend love. Thank you Mr. Mayor Jason did a really good job of
1:50:20 summarizing everything. The only additional information basically is that
1:50:27 They've recently constructed a surgery center here.
1:50:31 You can see that, and that's a parking lot of budding.
1:50:34 So most of this landscaping area is going to be removed.
1:50:38 They'll be putting parking lot in there.
1:50:40 They will look, now that I see that in this area here,
1:50:47 it'll match, it'll be a mirror image of that.
1:50:50 So part of this, it's part of their landscaping
1:50:52 and trailer will be removed.
1:50:54 But overall, the sewer easement is a,
1:50:58 a paper easement, nothing in it. City Engineers doesn't have any desire to keep it. The water
1:51:04 easement, they've been working on a plan, and you'll see some conditions that we've listed
1:51:08 for that plan. We need that plan before we can approve the ordinance to vacate this as
1:51:14 well as we need the new water line re-routed. So there's a few things that we're going to
1:51:18 be working out for the plan and before they can get their building permit because we have
1:51:23 to protect our city infrastructure.
1:51:25 So on December 13th of planning and zoning commission held a public hearing on the request, there
1:51:30 was no public comment and upon conclusion on the public hearing and discussion, the motion
1:51:34 was made and approved to recommend approval of the request the city council has presented
1:51:40 with staff recommendations recommended for approval and with the following conditions.
1:51:45 Number one subject to the site plan amendments as required by building engineering fire and
1:51:49 zoning officials to ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements and standards.
1:51:53 Number 2, subject to receiving an approvable construction plan for the relocation of the existing
1:51:59 water main per city engineer prior to publishing the ordinance for vacation.
1:52:04 The zoning administrator added a number 3, subject to a correct legal description for
1:52:10 the portions of the utility easement and a sewer easement being proposed for a vacation.
1:52:14 We had some miscommunication on the easement language and so we're looking for that.
1:52:19 We need it anyway.
1:52:20 It's just one of those things we put on here so it's very clear to the applicant that concludes
1:52:25 the staff report.
1:52:26 Thank you.
1:52:27 Jonathan, any questions for Jonathan?
1:52:28 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:52:29 I'm not sure if this question is for you or not, but we'll try.
1:52:32 Is there any plan to redo the walking trail through there?
1:52:35 Because I know how much that is used.
1:52:38 I see a ton of people out there walking on that.
1:52:42 I don't have an answer to that one.
1:52:43 No idea.
1:52:44 That's somebody from St. Luke's or?
1:52:45 Yeah.
1:52:52 Yeah.
1:52:53 So, St. Luke's obviously recognizes the value of that walking path also.
1:52:57 So, as part of the MOB, we're including pedestrian and sidewalk connections that will help link
1:53:02 up with the trail both on the north and south sides of the MOB so that it won't be quite
1:53:07 as gracefully arked through the landscape as it was before, but those connections will
1:53:12 still be made.
1:53:13 Great.
1:53:14 Thank you.
1:53:15 Any other questions?
1:53:18 We will open the public hearing.
1:53:23 Is there anyone pushing to speak on this item?
1:53:27 You're welcome to come forward now.
1:53:30 Say no one will close the public testimony portion
1:53:34 of the public hearing.
1:53:36 Any questions or comments from the council?
1:53:40 That was, I would certainly entertain a motion.
1:53:43 Thank you, boy.
1:53:46 I move that we grant the request for a vacation
1:53:48 of portions of a utility easement and a sewer easement
1:53:51 located within Lock 1, Lock 1, Block 1, St. Luke's subdivision,
1:53:56 a PUD on property located at 801 Poline Road West
1:54:00 for St. Luke's Magic Valley, application 2827,
1:54:05 as presented, and with staff recommendations.
1:54:11 I'll second that.
1:54:13 Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce
1:54:16 to approve the request,
1:54:19 subject to, and including the staff recommendations.
1:54:23 Is there any discussion?
1:54:27 Chair and roll call vote, please.
1:54:29 Ruth Pierce?
1:54:29 Yes.
1:54:30 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:54:31 Yes.
1:54:32 Nikki Boyd?
1:54:33 Yes.
1:54:34 Yes.
1:54:35 Chris Tockington.
1:54:36 Yes.
1:54:37 Don Hall.
1:54:38 Yes.
1:54:39 Motion passes.
1:54:40 Six to zero.
1:54:42 Seeing nothing further.
1:54:43 The meeting is adjourned.
1:54:44 Fire.
Download
- Transcript (text) 107 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 144 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 197 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 5.9 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 19, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:54:59.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
3bdb946a089997322417140f230249b0307444da11f341c93038ed22b361d013 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 004df5d5d670fd207d55707db93c67c3c3d8a13e2a6bba87111f467a364997f3
part02.m4a 9d6cd23481b64247381084f264e01c2357e02e88ea24f4d2e7f8c0ae3f319ed7 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
feb9290f168c4f5c07ece307a38c343708ceae565b54297d1dd22b2577956bd0
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file