OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 17, 2016

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: a,b

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:08:04 I'd like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, October

0:08:08 17th.

0:08:10 The first item of business is a request to adjourn into executive session under Idaho Code 742061A

0:08:18 to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual agent wherein the

0:08:23 respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy

0:08:28 or need.

0:08:29 This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or

0:08:33 deliberations about staffing needs in general.

0:08:38 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:08:39 So moved.

0:08:41 Second.

0:08:42 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Don Hall to adjourn into executive session as stated.

0:08:49 Chris Daukinton.

0:08:58 It is an opportunity for the council to evaluate the qualifications of a candidate

0:09:03 for you are asked to confirm an appointment later on this evening.

0:09:07 may be the case that which we hope it's not that you may not like the candidate that I'm

0:09:13 moving forward and which point we will strike that from the agenda later this evening.

0:09:20 But the discussion is already being up to questions that the council might come up with.

0:09:33 Is your mic on?

0:09:35 Nope.

0:09:36 Is yours?

0:09:37 It is.

0:09:38 I'm just a little bit puzzled it seems either redundant or unnecessary and please excuse

0:09:43 my for-bearing sense.

0:09:45 So I think it's a fair question.

0:09:47 I think that the council reserves the right to ask the tough candidate, the question tough

0:09:53 candidates should they so choose in a setting to determine whether or not he's going to be

0:09:59 an appropriate fit and based whether or not my recommendation for his appointment to serve

0:10:03 as a fire chief meets your scrutiny.

0:10:08 Any other questions or comments on the motion?

0:10:14 I'm thrilled to be here tonight for a meet and greet for a new

0:10:19 card chief to meet and decide.

0:10:26 All right.

0:10:27 Chair Nolke, I'll vote, please.

0:10:29 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:10:30 Yes, Nikki Boyd.

0:10:31 Yes, Sean Bericher.

0:10:33 Yes, Chris Tockeington.

0:10:35 And who's the director?

0:10:36 Yes.

0:10:37 Greg Lanting.

0:10:38 Yes, Don Hall.

0:10:39 Yes.

0:10:40 Ruth Pierce.

0:10:41 Yes.

0:10:42 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:10:44 So we will adjourn into executive session.

0:10:46 So I'm going to actually reconvene the City Council meeting for Monday, October 17th.

0:10:58 We did call the meeting to order at 4 o'clock and then met in an executive session.

0:11:04 So now we will resume the balance of the agenda.

0:11:07 So to begin with, those of you wishing to join me, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:11:14 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:11:30 We do have a quorum of the city council this evening, all seven members are in attendance.

0:11:34 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda?

0:11:38 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no amendments to this evening.

0:11:41 Thank you.

0:11:42 We have no proclamation, so the next item would be general public input.

0:11:47 And I believe we only have one person signed up who actually has an item on the consent calendar.

0:11:51 If there's anyone else who wishes to address the City Council on an item not on tonight's agenda, you are welcome to come forward now.

0:12:00 Seeing no one, we will move on with the rest of the agenda to the consent calendar.

0:12:05 Council wishes.

0:12:09 Don Hall.

0:12:09 I will move approval.

0:12:12 Second.

0:12:13 Motion by Don Hall.

0:12:14 Seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.

0:12:19 Is there any discussion?

0:12:22 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:12:24 Nicky Boyd.

0:12:25 Yes.

0:12:26 John Beriker, Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hopkins.

0:12:34 Yes.

0:12:35 Motion passes 7-0.

0:12:38 So for those of you who are here for special event applications, those were just approved

0:12:42 on the consent calendar.

0:12:43 So you're welcome to stick around for the rest of the meeting if you'd like, or you can sneak

0:12:47 out.

0:12:52 Other items for consideration, the first is a request to appoint Tonica Sellot to serve

0:12:56 as a library trustee and we have Tara Bartley from the library.

0:13:01 Welcome Tara, a very direct director I should say from the library.

0:13:09 Good evening.

0:13:11 Mayor Barriager, our city representatives Suzanne Hawkins and city council members, thank

0:13:16 you for your time.

0:13:18 The Twin Falls Public Library Board of Trustees had a resignation in August.

0:13:22 a four-year devoted member Margaret Peck resigned from the board due to removing

0:13:27 outside of the city limits. So the Board of Trustees sent out a call to our

0:13:33 community and asked for anybody that was interested that resided in the city of

0:13:37 Twin Falls to putting an application and we were very fortunate because we

0:13:41 received four highly qualified applicants. The Board of Trustees, the city manager

0:13:47 Travis Rothfoyer, interviewed all four of the applicants and all four of them

0:13:52 and brought a desirable element that would work on our board.

0:13:56 But I would like to introduce you to Tana Cassella,

0:13:59 because Tana was one of our four app.

0:14:03 And what we, the Board of Trustees,

0:14:05 came to realize while we were interviewing,

0:14:08 and Tana was that she brought a variety of experience

0:14:11 with her.

0:14:12 She's a strong supporter of the library,

0:14:14 and I highly emphasize this part,

0:14:16 she is a big time user of the library.

0:14:20 And so, I would like to take a moment and read the letter she submitted in her application.

0:14:27 Dear Twin Falls City Council and Twin Falls Public Library, I'm writing and

0:14:32 response to your call to the community for interested candidates to fulfill a

0:14:35 library trustee position for the remainder of the 2016 year. I would like to put

0:14:40 forward my candidates here for the post. I am confident that my passion for our

0:14:45 library is an excellent match. As for my skills, I humbly submit this letter along

0:14:49 with my resume and trust you to decide if I may be of service to your community in this

0:14:54 way at this time.

0:14:57 My resume shows you that I have an arcing career path.

0:14:59 I am very grateful to be in a position where service to my family and community is more

0:15:05 important than my corporate career.

0:15:07 I have held honorable corporate academic and municipal post in my journey over the last

0:15:11 25 years.

0:15:13 By my previous work and volunteer experiences, I have gained graceful leadership and participation

0:15:19 skills.

0:15:20 I have worked in conjunction with cities, colleges, parks and recreation, education, homeless

0:15:26 and community for over five years.

0:15:29 In those roles, I refer to our library system constantly from my support and remind my peers

0:15:33 citizens of their valuable access to so many resources.

0:15:38 I hope you will give me an opportunity to serve our city.

0:15:42 I assure you that I would be an asset as a trustee of our library.

0:15:47 So I come to you today in representing the Twin Falls Public Library Board with their request

0:15:52 that Tana Casela, who resides at 2544 Carriageway, be appointed to the City Council to serve as

0:15:58 a library trustee, be appointed by the City Council to serve as a library trustee for a partial

0:16:03 term of the Office extending from November 9th, 2016 through December 31st, 2017.

0:16:12 Thank you, Tara.

0:16:13 Are there any questions for Tara or her, Tana, Suzanne?

0:16:16 I don't have a question, but I'm ready to make a motion if everybody else is good all right

0:16:22 Okay, I would like to move that we approve the appointment of Tana Cocella to serve as the library trustee for the dates just stated

0:16:30 second

0:16:30 The motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Nicky Boyd to appoint Tana Cocella to serve as a library trustee

0:16:38 Is there any further discussion?

0:16:41 Seeing none Sharon will call vote please

0:16:43 John Berrigger, Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hocking,

0:16:52 Nikki Boyd.

0:16:54 Motion passes 7-0. Congratulations, Donna.

0:16:57 So, since you're there, and even though we heard your letter, just give us a little bit about yourself and why you're excited about this.

0:17:04 I am excited about this. Thank you. I'm thrilled. Thank you for the opportunity.

0:17:08 opportunity and I look forward to doing this. This is my first board for a municipality.

0:17:15 So I'm looking forward to learning about that and I am a dedicated advocate of the library

0:17:20 and I'm proud of what we've done in Idaho with the consortium and so I look forward

0:17:24 to being a part of that. Thank you very much.

0:17:27 Thank you, Tana. Suzanne, thanks.

0:17:29 I just wanted to say welcome, Tana, and let everyone know that at our last board meeting

0:17:32 last week, Tana did attend as a visitor to get herself up to speed and I think it's

0:17:38 It's going to be a great addition to the board and I look for more good things to come.

0:17:43 Thank you.

0:17:44 Thank you.

0:17:46 Next on the agenda we have the swearing in of Tim Sol to the position of Twin Falls City

0:17:51 Fire Chief, our City Manager, Travis Rothwiler, welcome Travis and welcome Tim.

0:18:00 He has a lengthy speech prepared.

0:18:02 So Tim will soon learn that I can be a little windy.

0:18:08 Here we go.

0:18:09 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:18:11 It is my pleasure to not only formally introduce Tim Soul

0:18:16 to the community of Twin Falls, but to ask for your confirmation

0:18:20 of my request to appoint Tim to the position of Fire Chief.

0:18:24 As you know, our position of Fire Chief was served

0:18:28 by Chief Ron Clark.

0:18:29 He served in that's dead for over 18 years,

0:18:32 and he was with our department for 40 years.

0:18:35 And upon his announcement of his retirement,

0:18:39 we began that process to look for a quality successor, somebody who could take the department

0:18:46 that Chief Clark built and take that and continue to advance that just as we ask all of our

0:18:52 department leaders to do.

0:18:56 We started our application process in May of this year.

0:18:59 In total, we received 21 applications from qualified individuals from all across the country.

0:19:06 We asked members of the council, we asked members of local 1556, we asked members of the city's

0:19:13 executive and leadership teams to serve on a series of interview panel boards to review

0:19:19 the applicants so that we found the most well-rounded candidate that we could present before you this

0:19:26 evening.

0:19:27 And I believe that we have found a quality candidate in Tim's soul.

0:19:32 After the Skype interviews in which we interviewed eight, we went through a process and we had

0:19:37 narrowed it to three finalists.

0:19:40 And through a series of circumstances and events, we found ourselves with a single candidate

0:19:45 that came through our process.

0:19:49 But make no mistake, Tim is not a consolation prize for the City of Twin Falls.

0:19:54 In fact, truth be told, he was the only unanimous number one candidate coming out of the Skype

0:20:00 interviews. He was the only candidate that everybody had said, he is one that I want to

0:20:05 spend more time and to learn about. After we went through that process, we invited Tim

0:20:11 to Twin Falls where he participated in a series of interviews boards. And those boards were

0:20:17 composed of diverse collection even more so than the Skype interview boards. We asked our

0:20:22 partners from EMS, we asked our partners from the Fire District, the City Council from the

0:20:28 city staff, we asked members of our community to help us find that next fire chief.

0:20:36 Not only did Tim interview before our boards, but he took it upon himself to go to each one

0:20:40 of the stations and spend time with each shift.

0:20:44 And it really spoke volumes to me about his dedication and his enthusiasm.

0:20:49 But most importantly, we knew that Tim was looking to determine whether or not he was going

0:20:54 to be a right fit and we were a right fit for him.

0:20:58 appreciated his due diligence. And I think that you can look behind me and see the many

0:21:04 professional firefighters that we have, and they have shared many positive responses, very

0:21:11 positive about Tim and what he has been able to have and share with them so far. And I

0:21:18 think that's just a testament of the person that is before you today. After the interviews,

0:21:25 We did a comprehensive background check, deputy city manager Brian Pike went to Nevada in

0:21:32 which he spent time reviewing Tim, his background, and talking to Tim's colleagues and peers

0:21:38 in Nevada.

0:21:40 We found absolutely nothing that would change our opinion that he was the right candidate

0:21:46 for the role.

0:21:48 So about Tim Sol.

0:21:50 Tim has been in fire service for over 25 years.

0:21:53 In fact, he would tell you that this was a second career.

0:21:56 His first career was in the area of counseling in which he served in the mental health professional

0:22:04 field.

0:22:06 He started his fire services as a volunteer.

0:22:09 And over that 10 year, became an AMT, became a firefighter in a community outside of Cleveland.

0:22:16 Family events brought him to Montana in which he served all the way in the ranks in Kalis

0:22:23 He worked as an EMS director for Flathead County.

0:22:27 He also worked as an assistant fire chief for the city of Calistem, Montana.

0:22:31 He spent the last five years in Nevada.

0:22:36 And again, his path is a bit different. It might be described as

0:22:41 a typical for someone who is in the area of fire service.

0:22:45 He has a bachelor's degree in social administration and a master's degree in

0:22:49 science, master's of science and in psychology from case western

0:22:53 and Reserve University at Cleveland, Ohio.

0:22:57 And just earlier this year, he received the designation of being an executive fire officer

0:23:04 from the National Fire Academy.

0:23:07 This is one of the highest credentials that an individual can receive in the area of fire

0:23:12 service.

0:23:16 Tim also has an impressive understanding of the One City Initiative and concepts.

0:23:21 While he hasn't worked under those philosophies in all of the pieces that he produced and

0:23:27 all of the information and then through all of his interviews, he talked about the importance

0:23:31 of being a servant leader.

0:23:33 He talked about the importance of value.

0:23:35 He talked about the importance of valuing those who he works with, teamwork, communication,

0:23:42 empowerment, mentorship, coaching.

0:23:46 We really believe, as a leadership team, that Tim meets all of the qualifications that are

0:23:52 expressed in the job description.

0:23:54 We believe he has the intangibles to be a quality fire chief and continue to guide our

0:23:59 department and to continue to lift it where Chief Clark had left it.

0:24:05 And with that, I would ask for your confirmation of my request to appoint Tim Sol to the position

0:24:11 of Fire Chief for the City of Twin Falls.

0:24:13 Thank you, Travis.

0:24:16 Don Hall.

0:24:17 Are you ready for a motion?

0:24:18 I am ready for a motion.

0:24:20 Mayor, I would make the motion that we confirm the appointment

0:24:23 of Tim Soul as the fire chief for the Twin Falls Fire Department.

0:24:27 Second that.

0:24:29 Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Chris Tockington

0:24:31 to approve the appointment of Tim Soul as the Twin Falls Fire Chief.

0:24:36 Is there any discussion from the council?

0:24:40 Don Hall.

0:24:41 No discussion, just excitement.

0:24:43 With your background and getting to know you a little bit,

0:24:46 and the extensive background that we did as an organization,

0:24:51 I see real positive things.

0:24:53 We're moving a, the city is changing, just period.

0:24:58 We're all in the midst of that change

0:25:00 and we appreciate your leadership coming on board

0:25:03 and I'm just very excited for us.

0:25:07 Chris Cotton.

0:25:08 Yeah, just to follow on Don's comments,

0:25:09 I think we're really fortunate to have a person

0:25:12 that has the demonstrated skills in counseling.

0:25:15 not sure how you're going to use it whether you're going to need to counsel

0:25:20 or crew or the victims of fires but I'm sure it's going to open up some

0:25:24 interesting scenarios and you come to us highly educated with the masters and

0:25:29 that's the way our city is going with increased educational competence as well

0:25:34 as on the job training that you receive so we're really fortunate to have you

0:25:39 chief maybe that psychology will help with presentations to the council

0:25:45 Any other discussion from the council?

0:25:48 Seeing none Sharon roll call vote, please

0:25:50 Chris hockington yes Greg Lanting yes Don Hall yes Ruth Pierce yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Nicki Boyd yes

0:26:04 John Barrieger yes motion passes seven to zero congratulations

0:27:01 I swear to some.

0:27:02 I swear to some.

0:27:03 I swear to some.

0:27:04 I swear to some.

0:27:05 I swear to some.

0:27:06 I swear to some.

0:27:07 I swear to some.

0:27:08 I swear to some.

0:27:09 I swear to some.

0:27:10 I swear to some.

0:27:11 I swear to some.

0:27:12 I swear to some.

0:27:13 I swear to some.

0:27:14 I swear to some.

0:27:15 I swear to some.

0:27:16 I swear to some.

0:27:17 I swear to some.

0:27:18 I swear to some.

0:27:19 I swear to some.

0:27:20 I swear to some.

0:27:21 I swear to some.

0:27:22 I swear to some.

0:27:23 I swear to some.

0:27:24 I swear to some.

0:27:25 I swear to some.

0:27:26 I swear to some.

0:27:27 I swear to some.

0:27:28 I swear to some.

0:27:29 I swear to some.

0:27:30 I swear to some.

0:27:31 To which I have been appointed according to the law and to the best of my

0:28:02 To be a good one in there somewhere yeah

0:28:06 You're on the payroll now chief

0:28:34 I just want to thank the council and Travis and the department for, you know, really the

0:28:49 honor of being able to be appointed to serve, you know, the city, the community as well as

0:28:55 the organization.

0:28:56 It's a real honor and I'm very humbled to be here.

0:29:01 I'm humbled and honored to carry on what Chief Clark has really, you know, put together

0:29:10 there were the past long career of dedication that he gave to the city and the department,

0:29:16 as well as the, you know, patain cheese behind me and the men, you know, who've been able

0:29:23 to come. I just, I'm overwhelmed. I was told that that fifth bugle would weigh heavily

0:29:30 very quickly. And I think until you carry that fifth bugle, it is something that you

0:29:36 probably can't imagine. And I'm starting to get the weight of that at the moment.

0:29:41 I'm very grateful for the opportunity to serve the city, to serve the community, and to serve

0:29:49 the men who are the watchers of the flame, the keepers of the flame, the watchers of the

0:29:57 night. It's very poetic. I love the fire service and everything that it represents. And I'm

0:30:03 Again, very grateful for your faith that you've given in me to be a part of this community and department.

0:30:11 Thank you.

0:30:12 Thank you, Tim.

0:30:14 Well, certainly welcome to the city and the family that we have here and certainly welcome to our community.

0:30:31 We appreciate your investment in us and making a decision to join us.

0:30:38 And we wish you all the best and look forward to your leadership.

0:30:41 So welcome.

0:30:42 Next on the agenda is any items from the city manager or from the city council?

0:30:53 Ruth Pierce.

0:30:54 I just have a couple of things.

0:30:57 I'm the liaison to the historic preservation commission and they're looking at historic

0:31:06 guidelines for parks and downtown Twin Falls and are sponsoring an open house on the 26th

0:31:14 from 5.30 to 7.30 at the ballroom, hoping for some public input and especially some downtown

0:31:21 business owner input. So if anybody's interested in attending that, that'll be a good event.

0:31:27 And then, secondly, I want to remind everybody that next Monday is tough enough to be pink

0:31:33 for the city. So you'll see everybody in pink.

0:31:37 We can just wear a pink, right? We don't have to be pink.

0:31:39 Yeah. Yeah. Got it.

0:31:45 anything else from members of the council?

0:31:48 All right, we'll see none.

0:31:51 We will move to the next item on the agenda,

0:31:54 which is a request to adjourn under Idaho Code 74-206-1B,

0:31:59 executive session to consider the evaluation,

0:32:02 dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges

0:32:06 brought against a public officer, employee, staff member,

0:32:09 or individual agent or public school student.

0:32:12 school student. So moved. Motion by Nicky Boyd. Second. Second by Ruth Pierce to adjourn

0:32:21 into executive session as stated. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, Sharon will call

0:32:28 vote please. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Sean R. Suzanne Hawkins.

0:32:36 Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris talking. Yes. Motion passes at 7 to 0.

0:32:43 So just for everyone's benefit, we will be adjourning.

0:32:47 We will not be reconvening following this executive session,

0:32:50 nor will we be making any decisions while we are in

0:32:53 an executive session.

0:32:54 We'll have to adjourn.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 17, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:33:02.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    2d432b1b08c202c4df7bb99c2f6abf57daebba15a913c8c03002cc5377aa7994
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a cd4d2b24d2def953870779d50d6b77fbb243ce1acb005fc4aa106f271c706710
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    6b4caff0889b8f33bc5cfdd5773fcf23dd9ad35dae6c54c0b89129ba1aca9817

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file