OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 13, 2016

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.

Transcript

0:00:00 for Monday June 13th. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:00:06 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:22 We do have a quorum of the City Council in attendance this evening. Six of the seven members are here,

0:00:31 here and Nicky Boyd is not able to join us this evening. Mr. Deputy City

0:00:36 Managers, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? We're going to

0:00:42 actually rock paper see there's over there. There are no amendments to the agenda.

0:00:47 Thank you. We have no proclamations this evening either. So the first item is

0:00:51 general public input if there is anyone here from the public who wishes to address

0:00:55 the Council on an issue that is not on tonight's agenda. Now is your chance to

0:00:59 please come forward.

0:01:08 And if you could please introduce yourself for the record.

0:01:11 Terence Edwards, 172 Long Island, Jerome.

0:01:18 Thank you.

0:01:21 I guess my concern is as I've conveyed to Mr. Hall here

0:01:27 in the past with the refugee situation

0:01:31 we have in this community and the Muslim impact.

0:01:36 And I guess everybody's aware of what happened in Orlando

0:01:40 and what's happened in San Bernardino

0:01:43 and what's happened in parts other than here,

0:01:47 small communities even.

0:01:50 We've been made aware of a situation

0:01:52 that alleged assault of a minor child

0:01:56 and we can't get any information on it.

0:01:59 Apparently it's been indicated that was

0:02:02 the perpetrators were for Muslim youth

0:02:06 that conducted this, I guess it was rape,

0:02:10 and we've heard that it's consensual,

0:02:12 but my concern is there's no such thing

0:02:14 as consensual rape of a minor.

0:02:17 The police department, as I talked to Mr. Hall about it,

0:02:21 that he's adamant that everybody on the police department

0:02:24 is good people, and he's looked him in the eye,

0:02:27 and those folks are good people, and they're peaceful,

0:02:31 and the Muslims are peaceful.

0:02:33 That's what they said, San Bernardino,

0:02:35 that's what they've said in other places

0:02:38 that we've seen this carried out.

0:02:42 And I know that you can't stop everybody

0:02:44 and be concerned about it,

0:02:45 but when there is a violation of somebody's rights

0:02:48 and their attack on their personal being,

0:02:52 we should be able to be made aware of that.

0:02:55 And I think that there's a method of cover-up here

0:03:01 in the community.

0:03:02 I think it starts with the police department.

0:03:05 I think that they have their mouth zip-closed.

0:03:08 The media is not getting in on it.

0:03:10 We hear more information about KMBT than we do from the

0:03:14 community at large and the police department.

0:03:17 So I'm just alerting you to the facts that if you don't

0:03:22 get your head wired to your posterior, you folks are

0:03:27 going to be with a mic in front of your face trying to

0:03:31 answer questions about Islam, the Quran, the Hadith, the Sunnah, and you're going to act

0:03:37 like a bunch of morons because you don't have a clue of what's going on in this community

0:03:42 and other communities that are receiving refugees.

0:03:45 ISIS is here, the Muslim Brotherhood is here, there's been violations already occurred by

0:03:53 Muslims here, and it needs to be addressed, and if you don't address it, there's going

0:03:59 be hectic pay and it's not by me but it's by the community the community is not

0:04:04 going to sit around and wait for you guys to get your head and tail whether

0:04:08 wired together so you need to be leaders not followers and not just go to the

0:04:13 presses like oh we didn't know anything oh we don't have a clue and if you do have

0:04:19 a clue you ought to have us open house here and tell everybody about it because

0:04:23 we're not getting that information thank you thank you for sharing your concerns

0:04:29 Mr. Edwards.

0:04:30 Don Hall.

0:04:31 Well, since I was listed specifically, we did meet about a year and a half ago.

0:04:37 We discussed the refugee program and you shared some information with me regarding Islam and

0:04:43 the like.

0:04:46 It's a mischaracterization to say that I just cover my eyes up and look at people and they're

0:04:51 all great people.

0:04:52 I know all people have challenges depending on your religion, depending on who you are, depending

0:04:59 on your makeup, we all have our own challenges.

0:05:03 What I stated was the folks that I've come in contact, my colleagues, the people that I

0:05:08 work with that happen to be refugees, I vouch for those that work hard, their members of

0:05:16 our community, their own businesses, our police officers, their probation and parole officers,

0:05:24 their nurses, their members of our community.

0:05:28 I can't vouch for every refugee.

0:05:29 I'm just telling you who I run into.

0:05:32 And I just wanted to make sure, and I have no idea what you're

0:05:38 talking about on a rape of a young lady by four other folks.

0:05:45 I don't know what you're talking about there.

0:05:47 I remember ever talking about that if that's what you're

0:05:50 bringing up.

0:05:51 Well, I don't know anything about that, sir.

0:05:53 So Mr. Edwards, again, thank you for your comments this

0:05:56 Okay, well, actually no, because this isn't a debate of the issue tonight.

0:06:01 This was an opportunity for you to share some information with the council and we appreciate that.

0:06:05 Certainly our law enforcement community, if there is a crime or an alleged crime that's been perpetrated.

0:06:14 The highest confidence in our police department that that is being investigated.

0:06:17 If you have information specific to that, I would encourage you to go speak to our police department about that.

0:06:22 that this is just here say through the community

0:06:25 and your sentiments, I don't know that that becomes

0:06:28 an actionable item for our police department

0:06:30 to investigate.

0:06:31 So again, I would encourage you to do that.

0:06:39 Okay, again, sir, this is not a debate of this issue.

0:06:44 So I would be happy to meet with you individually

0:06:47 if you'd like some direction on how to talk

0:06:49 to the police department following this meeting.

0:06:52 If that will work for you, you're welcome to give me a call.

0:06:54 if you can't stay through the meeting this evening.

0:06:57 But again, this is not the forum for a debate of the issue.

0:07:02 You presented information to us and we appreciate that.

0:07:05 And if there is follow up that needs to happen,

0:07:07 we will certainly share that

0:07:08 with our law enforcement office.

0:07:11 Thank you.

0:07:15 Is there anyone else from the public

0:07:16 who would like to address the council

0:07:18 on any issues this evening?

0:07:25 My name is Heather Stroup, 3161 East 3200 North Twin Falls.

0:07:31 And I own a small business here in Twin Falls

0:07:33 And I've also been a little shaken up by what's happened in Orlando.

0:07:38 And mainly because I know what the Islamic influence that has been creeping into Twin Falls has also done.

0:07:47 I am close friends with someone who was spit on in Winco by Islamic women and told that her God was nothing, that all was everything.

0:07:58 And to me, that's a serious offense.

0:08:04 Additionally, there have been hit runs that obviously

0:08:09 we heard about in the news, also by Islamic people.

0:08:15 And many other incidences from small to larger,

0:08:20 I also have heard about a minor who

0:08:23 was attacked in this community.

0:08:26 And I have young people of my own that I would like to keep safe.

0:08:32 College age, daughter, that I would like to keep safe, and I don't feel like I can at this point.

0:08:40 I'd like to know if the city council knows where the youths were who perpetrated the crime that was in this community.

0:08:52 Well, again, I'm not aware of a crime that has been reported, and

0:08:56 those wouldn't be reported to the city council.

0:08:59 As the city council should know where the crime is, if there's crimes in the community.

0:09:02 Those wouldn't be reported to us as a matter of course.

0:09:06 This is the first I've heard of this with this being brought to our attention this evening.

0:09:09 I'm happy to do some follow-up with our law enforcement office to find out if this has

0:09:14 been indeed reported, but again, if it is speculation and hearsay throughout the community

0:09:20 and there's no filing of a police report, how can there be police action if it's never

0:09:24 been reported to them?

0:09:26 So I can do the follow-up with that after this meeting.

0:09:28 I'm happy to do so, I'm happy to get back with you about it.

0:09:33 As a business owner, if I continue to see, when I came to Twin Falls I thought it was a

0:09:40 wonderful city, a safe city, and my business took off, in fact like a race horse, and I have

0:09:47 actually been kind of raining it in because I've seen what's been going on in this city.

0:09:53 If I do a little advertising, I know my business will grow to the point where I'm overwhelmed

0:09:57 and I have to hire people because I know it's a cross-brained business, but I'm not going

0:10:03 to do that if I feel like my family isn't safe here. I'll take my business and go somewhere

0:10:10 else. That's all I have to say.

0:10:16 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:10:29 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:10:36 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:10:42 know what's going on we don't know what's going on so I have not heard a news

0:10:48 report about allegations that a vehicle ma'am it is I just want to know if it's

0:10:53 typical and then I'll move on is it typical I mean you know if you're a

0:10:57 lawyer or you're a judge you don't want to kind of follow a case you have to make

0:11:00 a court decision is that the is that the rules for the counsel so I am telling

0:11:04 I am not aware of a news story about allegations of an assault against a minor in our community by Islamist.

0:11:11 Okay. So I'm going to ask you all because this is not a debate forum. I understand that. I totally get that.

0:11:19 Where is the forum that we can have? Very honest and open discussion.

0:11:24 So if you feel you... Not a private one, you and I open.

0:11:28 May I answer your question, please? Yeah. Please do.

0:11:32 If you all would like to request time on the agenda to have a discussion about specific factual items, I'm happy to schedule that.

0:11:40 If you want to come to this meeting and talk about your beliefs about Islam and have it be a rehash of the conversation we had in here several months ago,

0:11:51 I don't know that there's any productive part of that discussion.

0:11:55 I don't know what conversation you're referring to.

0:11:57 When members of your various groups and people with your positions on the refugees came to this meeting to talk about anti-refugee sentiments.

0:12:08 My primary thing on this piece of paper is what forum can the community go to and say, hey, we have questions?

0:12:16 Do we have something established already that I'm unaware of, whether it's by email or by some kind of website that I'm missing

0:12:24 so that I can go and ask, okay, I'm hearing this.

0:12:28 Do I write to the department heads or is there a monthly forum that I'm missing?

0:12:33 Is there something that maybe we can set up to open up dialogue in the community?

0:12:37 I would be more than happy to set up a meeting to discuss questions you may have

0:12:42 if you're going to come with questions.

0:12:45 So to be honest with you, I have yet to hear a question from any of you this evening.

0:12:49 Okay, here's my question.

0:12:51 Excuse me, ma'am. You've come to tell us that we're not...

0:12:55 I'm not telling you anything. I'm asking you a question. I'm actually asking a question.

0:12:59 Okay. So, are you aware...

0:13:03 Are you aware that there's a lot of pornography

0:13:07 on foreigner web pages

0:13:11 in Twin Falls that's child pornography?

0:13:16 I am not personally aware of that, but again, if there are specific allegations

0:13:20 you feel crimes are being committed, call the police.

0:13:24 Okay.

0:13:25 How about the death of the 17-year-old refugee boy who died suddenly?

0:13:30 Do we know why he died?

0:13:31 Was he sick?

0:13:33 I'm concerned about him just as a person, and I don't know where to find that information,

0:13:39 just to find out why did some 17-year-old boy suddenly die?

0:13:44 Again, I'm not familiar with that case.

0:13:47 And the baby girl found in the diaper bag?

0:13:49 Who do I go to to ask specifically more details about her?

0:13:54 That was found out in the county.

0:13:55 I would suggest that you contact the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office or the prosecutor's office.

0:14:00 Do we know how many additional refugees Twin Falls has received beyond the abstract's 300?

0:14:06 I do not believe we've received more than that, but I would recommend you contact the

0:14:10 refugee center and speak to the director there.

0:14:13 That's information that they share very freely.

0:14:15 Do we know why the mosque received a permit in a day?

0:14:20 I don't know what the time frame was of those building permit issues, but certainly contacting

0:14:25 our building department.

0:14:26 I actually haven't.

0:14:27 I'm not getting anywhere in that, that's mine here.

0:14:31 Okay.

0:14:32 Let's see.

0:14:33 What else do I have on here?

0:14:35 So, Julie, here's what I would recommend.

0:14:37 If you have written questions that you would like answers to, I'm happy to go follow up on

0:14:41 those.

0:14:42 I am not going to have those answers off the top of my head sitting here this evening.

0:14:46 Shall I email you all my questions?

0:14:47 That would be great.

0:14:48 just give me a written copy of them now if you already have them printed out.

0:14:51 No, you won't be able to read my hand, right?

0:14:53 Okay, emailing them to me would be fantastic.

0:14:55 Perfect.

0:14:56 And you will reply or you'll just direct me to all the offices I need to talk to?

0:15:00 I will certainly do my best to find the answers for you or direct you to those that can give you that information.

0:15:05 Okay.

0:15:06 And again, if you all would like to schedule some follow-up to have those answers discussed in a public forum,

0:15:12 I'm happy to get that on agenda in the coming months because you have to understand.

0:15:17 I guess we just figured you know, I mean, honestly, we just figured you know this is a giant operation city government

0:15:24 We are not aware of every single bit of minutia that occurs

0:15:27 Can I encourage you though just as a citizen to possibly come up with something that's more of an open forum or maybe a public forum of some

0:15:35 Kind to just open dialogue up because we're not you might you might look at us and think that we're some kind of a coalition of weirdos and

0:15:42 And actually, there's professionals, there's business owners, there's college graduates.

0:15:46 We're not just a bunch of weird people.

0:15:48 We're people that are living here in this community paying our taxes.

0:15:52 We're nationals of, somewhere in the United States or Idaho.

0:15:56 And we have what we feel anyway, are legitimate concerns.

0:16:00 And people are coming saying, what's up with this, what's up with that?

0:16:02 Who wants to go, I don't know.

0:16:04 I mean, obviously you guys know it's not comfortable when somebody's questioning

0:16:07 about something that's serious and you don't know.

0:16:10 So we would like to be able to say, OK, Bob, here's the answer to this.

0:16:15 Go here and find out the answer to this.

0:16:18 So if you'll share your questions with me, I'm happy to do that.

0:16:21 I would also say, so last fall, we actually had a very large community forum

0:16:25 to discuss many of these issues.

0:16:28 That wasn't so much an open discussion.

0:16:30 And I actually talked to them in a private meeting before that.

0:16:33 So another question that I have is, I think you were referring

0:16:39 to the February 22nd meeting where people just from the community ran out of it.

0:16:42 I was talking about the Times News Forum that was so last month.

0:16:46 Yes, I was talking about the discussion we had here.

0:16:49 There were 10 individuals that stood up and told you this is not a good idea.

0:16:53 We're just, we didn't even know each other.

0:16:55 Many of us did not know each other, so it wasn't a coalition of, hey, you say this and

0:16:59 I'll say that.

0:17:00 It's not how it works.

0:17:02 Coming in here saying, I believe everybody had an opinion of saying this is not the time.

0:17:06 these issues aren't being addressed.

0:17:08 In other words, this is not the time to support more of the refugee or put more taxes towards

0:17:16 the program.

0:17:17 And again, not to rehash that whole issue in February, but one, none of your tax dollars

0:17:21 were being spent on that.

0:17:22 Two, that actually was not your tax dollars being spent on that.

0:17:26 It was a private foundation that was being applied to funds for.

0:17:29 Secondly, it was not about bringing more refugees to the community.

0:17:32 community, it was about being involved in a community discussion, much like you are requesting

0:17:37 that we have.

0:17:38 Right.

0:17:39 Except for, I guess my question there is that it was in a unanimous vote when in fact the

0:17:47 majority stood up and said no, we can't support this as community.

0:17:51 Well, again, I'm not going to rehash something that we already made a decision on in February.

0:17:56 I'm just thought I'd bring that up.

0:17:58 I appreciate it.

0:17:59 You know, my personal issues, and I actually have many more than that, but obviously, I've talked beyond that.

0:18:05 So I look forward to seeing your specific questions, and we'll look forward to it, but you'll do it.

0:18:11 Thank you.

0:18:12 Chris Stockington.

0:18:14 Ma'am, I'd like to get a little clarification.

0:18:16 I'm confused.

0:18:17 You say you don't know each other, and you're disorganized, and yet you spoke as a group.

0:18:22 Are you a group, or are you happy to come in here all the same?

0:18:25 I know some of these people more than others, obviously, one semester.

0:18:29 I'm speaking right now.

0:18:30 Or did you come in here by happenstance at the same time?

0:18:34 Do you have a name of your group or something that we can see what kind of membership it contains?

0:18:43 How many people?

0:18:44 I'm here as an individual, as a citizen, with serious questions which I would take somewhere

0:18:50 else if I knew exactly where to take.

0:18:52 We haven't asked her my question.

0:18:53 Are you representing or part of a group as large as we could kind of get an idea how many

0:18:59 there are?

0:19:00 as an individual.

0:19:01 But when I was referencing the fact

0:19:03 that we spoke on February 22nd, many of those people

0:19:06 I did not know had no relationship with.

0:19:09 So we did not call each other prior and say,

0:19:11 hey, get down there.

0:19:13 You just happened to show up the same night.

0:19:15 Yes, we did.

0:19:16 I know that that seems crazy, but some people actually

0:19:20 follow what's going on.

0:19:21 And sometimes your friend calls you and said,

0:19:23 did you see that?

0:19:24 But no, we didn't come here together as a group on that night.

0:19:27 That was the night one of the last speakers, might have been the very last speaker.

0:19:32 A woman who called for preservation of the white race.

0:19:35 Is that what you're standing for?

0:19:36 I have no idea what you're talking about.

0:19:38 She said that in the microphone it was recorded.

0:19:41 Well certainly would not be my perspective.

0:19:44 Thank you.

0:19:46 Anyone else?

0:19:47 Don Hall.

0:19:48 No, that's just a comment.

0:19:51 I think it's best for folks when they come in front of the city council.

0:19:54 certainly this is an open discussion at the beginning, but if you have some

0:19:58 question, specific questions, to be fair to us, just like we would be fair to you,

0:20:02 is to bring those questions to us so we can research them. A couple things that

0:20:06 you brought up this evening, I don't have a clue. I had not read it in the

0:20:10 newspaper. I tend to watch the news quite a bit. I try to keep track of the

0:20:17 issues because I feel that that's a responsibility as a citizen. But I'm not

0:20:22 aware of some of the things that you brought up. And I would just suggest bringing those

0:20:28 questions to us so we can research them to find out because that's no knowledge of it.

0:20:35 And in our meetings prior, we've had a couple meetings, Julie, where you brought me some

0:20:39 questions. I researched them and I brought you back answers.

0:20:43 Yes, you did.

0:20:44 And what we really look for in questions or thoughts or concerns in the community is I

0:20:50 I look for something actionable, something if you can have conjecture and say, this is

0:20:56 going on, but let's look at the specifics of where it's going on, when did it take place,

0:21:01 those kind of things, so that we can have folks research it and do a good job and figure it

0:21:06 out.

0:21:07 Blanket statements don't work very well unless we have specifics.

0:21:10 Couple issues that you brought up, we researched and we found out.

0:21:14 We've done research on the whole permitting process of the mosque, the Islamic Faith Center

0:21:20 out there and we have that blow-by-blow of exactly how all that worked, we can provide

0:21:26 that for you.

0:21:27 I thought that I had done that but if I hadn't that's my fault because we researched it to

0:21:32 find out.

0:21:33 Well you know that my husband is a builder, several of you know that takes about two weeks

0:21:35 to get a house permit so to see the Times News actually announce permit in a day, of

0:21:42 course it's going to raise questions right?

0:21:44 Yeah I'm not.

0:21:45 And I've researched it and I know other people have too and nobody's really finding an answer.

0:21:50 We can find that answer or you know we deserve that as a community.

0:21:54 Well frankly I remember reading through the whole document because they gave me the timeline

0:21:58 of exactly how that whole thing took place.

0:22:02 One of the questions you had is that they were going to have a calling tower.

0:22:05 We found out they were not going to have a calling tower and if they did have a calling

0:22:08 tower it would have to be by special use permit and no special use permit was drawn or asked

0:22:15 for.

0:22:16 So these are what's that?

0:22:18 they did have one on the plan?

0:22:19 Not that we see.

0:22:20 Nothing that came in front of the building department

0:22:23 that we have any knowledge for.

0:22:25 If they have something other than that,

0:22:26 they still need what would need to go through the process

0:22:29 with the city to get a special use permit for that.

0:22:32 And I would assume that that would be fairly controversial

0:22:35 since that's right in the middle of the neighborhood.

0:22:37 I would think so.

0:22:38 So I think that public hearing would be more heated than this.

0:22:43 I'm not gonna say heated, it would be interesting.

0:22:45 Let's just say that.

0:22:46 Right. Well, thanks for your time.

0:22:47 even though it's not always easy, but thank you.

0:22:51 Thank you.

0:22:53 Anyone else?

0:22:54 Howdy.

0:22:57 Nolan's troop, twin falls out of Ho, 31, 6, 2, and east, 3, 200 north.

0:23:02 I actually have the news article about that, um, well, sexual assault, if you want me to

0:23:07 leave it here for you since none of you had heard about it.

0:23:09 I can leave it here at the podium or bring it to one of you.

0:23:12 That'd be great.

0:23:13 It was in the news and, uh, can be confirmed that it was a reported sexual assault.

0:23:20 it has been before the police already. But I did have a legitimate question. I mean obviously

0:23:26 there's a lot of concern among citizens about refugee resettlement. I mean that's undeniable.

0:23:33 We're concerned. What's Twin Falls City doing about these people's concerns? Because there's

0:23:39 people who are legitimately scared. What's Twin Falls City doing? The essence that I'm

0:23:44 getting out of you guys is you know, kind of like it is you know you're kind of sitting

0:23:48 don't really care a whole lot. That's kind of the essence that I'm getting. Like you don't

0:23:54 really care about our issues. So actually Mr. Stroop, we've given you 25 minutes of our

0:23:58 agenda this evening to discuss this issue that wasn't on the agenda in the first place.

0:24:03 And with all due respect, I think that is giving you time and an opportunity to air this out.

0:24:10 Right. I don't appreciate the lack of respect that I feel we're being given, calling us

0:24:17 lacks a day as a call and laid back about this. So again, this is an open forum and I look forward

0:24:24 to having some discussion about it, but I also want you to understand that there needs to be a

0:24:29 level of decorum in this forum here. So I appreciate your bringing the concerns. Related to the

0:24:36 actual refugee resettlement program, I'll remind all of you that that program is not a function of

0:24:42 the City of Twin Falls. It is a function of the federal government as managed by the College of

0:24:48 Southern Idaho here under the guidance of a state office. We are certainly in communication with those

0:24:55 folks about the program that takes place in our community and we will continue to have ongoing

0:25:00 discussions with them. But the City of Twin Falls is in no position to say yes or no this program

0:25:07 will or won't happen unilaterally. And we are in discussion with those other organizations

0:25:13 that certainly have heard the same concerns that you're expressing here this evening. And

0:25:19 I would encourage you to understand the program by speaking to those who operate it as well.

0:25:23 I'm not asking you to try and stop the program. I know that you don't have authority over that.

0:25:27 My question was posed as what is the Twin Falls City doing to make its residents feel

0:25:30 safe? Because whether or not this refugee program is part of the federal government, they're

0:25:35 bringing them into Twin Falls City. This is very much my issue as it is all your issues.

0:25:40 So what's Twin Falls City doing to make sure its residents feel safe and are safe?

0:25:49 The City of Twin Falls provides service to all of its citizens whether they are-

0:25:52 Would you understand that?

0:25:53 Whether they are a Muslim faith or Christian faith or no faith at all.

0:25:59 And those are the things that we are doing to keep this community safe.

0:26:02 Is providing service?

0:26:05 Yes, but what suggestions might you have that we need to be doing to make you feel safer?

0:26:10 Well, personally, it's not my safety issue.

0:26:13 I mean, well, it is my safety issue, but I don't feel scared.

0:26:17 There are a lot of people in the community who do because of instances like San Bernardino,

0:26:21 one of the shooters there was a refugee.

0:26:26 I feel like to involve should be, I'm not a racist or white supremacist, but this should

0:26:33 be profiling.

0:26:34 It works.

0:26:35 I mean, if the last two mass shootings have been committed by Muslims, why aren't we

0:26:41 profiling Muslims. It makes sense doesn't it? Here's a niche like white

0:26:47 supremacists. We're profiling white supremacists. If somebody's a skinhead

0:26:50 and got a swastika tattoo, we're profiling them, correct?

0:26:55 I don't know. Again, I don't work in law enforcement in the city. To be honest,

0:27:01 as an American, I hope that's not happening because I think that infringes

0:27:05 upon everybody's freedoms. So, I understand there are further questions here that I

0:27:11 I don't think we're gonna get aired out

0:27:12 in the open forum this evening.

0:27:14 So what I would like to do is schedule

0:27:17 for a future meeting and opportunity

0:27:18 for you all to bring these questions

0:27:20 and for us to have some experts

0:27:22 who actually deal with this on a regular basis

0:27:24 to be able to answer your questions.

0:27:25 Because right now, I don't think we have the answers

0:27:30 to the questions that you are gonna continue to ask.

0:27:32 And we love that.

0:27:33 Does anybody want this news article?

0:27:35 Yes, please.

0:27:36 You can just leave it with the deputy city managers there.

0:27:38 Thank you.

0:27:39 Thank you for your time.

0:27:42 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:27:48 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:27:51 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:27:55 We'll get there eventually.

0:27:56 OK.

0:27:57 I want to reply to some of the other public input that's

0:28:01 going on.

0:28:02 Several years ago, there was this fear about refugees coming.

0:28:07 So I look at the Times News, and I see who was arrested.

0:28:11 And I don't see any Muhammad, Trawleys, or any what I regard

0:28:15 is Muslim names. I see a lot of Americans, but I'm not afraid of Americans. I see a lot

0:28:21 of Hispanics, but I'm not a famous badniks. And I'm not afraid of Muslims. And I think

0:28:26 if it's people who are afraid, make it the city's job to keep them from being afraid and

0:28:32 want to protect their college kids, I think that's something needs to happen when they're

0:28:37 babies. That you have self-confidence in yourself, so you aren't afraid of what happens

0:28:42 in San Bernardino because it happens in California doesn't mean it's going to happen to your neighborhood

0:28:47 tomorrow or maybe four days from now or maybe six years from now.

0:28:52 People that live in fear just have something that's uncontrollable by any government agency.

0:28:58 And if we start saying only have to be afraid of people who are so at Stikas or at pointy

0:29:02 hats or that does influence on my benefits.

0:29:06 I am all for public defenders because when somebody comes up and says, Mr. Newell and

0:29:11 When you are a crook, I want somebody to stand up and say, I'll defend him, stand up for

0:29:15 his rights and liberties.

0:29:17 Thank you.

0:29:19 Thank you, Mr. Newland.

0:29:20 Chris Stockington.

0:29:21 I'd like to just answer the gentleman's question about what we're doing to make the community

0:29:25 safer.

0:29:26 In a general term, sir, we were using community policing.

0:29:30 You probably have seen the term.

0:29:33 Various communities have slight variations on it, and some are more successful than others.

0:29:37 But for a number of years, we've employed highly educated trained police officers from

0:29:44 a multitude of ethnic backgrounds that are reflective of our community, Hispanic officers

0:29:51 for Hispanic parts of the community, bilingual often, and they're native tongue.

0:29:57 We encourage officers not only to ride behind closed car environment, get out to mixed with

0:30:03 people get involved with community events at the park because that communication that the

0:30:09 police established with the police is a single best ingredient for building that communication

0:30:14 and trust that leads to safety. Are we doing a perfect job? No, but I think especially with

0:30:20 our new chief that comes from Nampa with a gang and drug background that we're trying

0:30:25 to get on top of, we're going to be making more gains and improvements. Second thing that

0:30:32 I'd like to point out is that the despicable scum in Orlando that killed 50 people wasn't

0:30:39 American citizen.

0:30:41 He was a sick American, okay?

0:30:43 Yes, his parents were refugees, but you know what?

0:30:46 My parents were refugees from Ireland after the potato famine.

0:30:50 I'm sure glad you guys weren't around testifying against my relatives for that time, okay?

0:30:56 We're all children of refugees, immigrants, in some form or fashion.

0:31:00 If they were a Lando person, was an American citizen, not sure if you were aware of that.

0:31:08 Any other members of the public would like to address the Council on any issues before

0:31:12 we move to our regular agenda this evening?

0:31:18 Seeing none, the first item on the agenda is the consent calendar and before I get a

0:31:23 motion on that, I would note one correction on the second page of the minutes under the

0:31:31 motion on the engineering lab equipment, it says it was approved six to zero and

0:31:35 that must have been five to zero because two of us were absent.

0:31:38 Chris Stockington.

0:31:43 But the change has so noted out move approval the consent calendar.

0:31:47 Second.

0:31:48 The motion by Chris Stockington seconded by Greg Lanting to approve the consent

0:31:53 calendar with the correction to the minutes.

0:31:55 Is there any discussion?

0:31:58 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:32:05 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.

0:32:07 Sean Veriker, yes.

0:32:09 Chris Stockington, yes.

0:32:11 Greg Lanting.

0:32:12 Don Hall. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.

0:32:15 Motion passes 6-0. Under items for consideration, consideration of a

0:32:26 request to enact a new chapter 13 of Title 6 of the Twin Falls City Code

0:32:30 prohibiting graffiti requiring removal and abatement and providing for a penalty

0:32:35 for violation of this code and we have our Twin Falls Police Chief Craig Kingsbury

0:32:39 Welcome Chief. Thank you Mayor and Council. When I was here about a month ago

0:32:44 Council, Council, you, we spoke about graffiti and you asked me to research some other cities

0:32:50 and graffiti ordinances that are happening in the state of Idaho.

0:32:56 The draft before you this evening is a result of that research and then working in a course

0:33:01 with our legal council on Friswendreich.

0:33:04 So what I have before you is a proposed ordinance that prohibits graffiti and you might say, well,

0:33:11 Of course, we don't allow graffiti because vandalism is already against state code.

0:33:15 But this also gives us the ability to work with the property owners and

0:33:21 to better track their graffiti.

0:33:24 When we look at crime, specifically what I would call gang crime,

0:33:30 the Twin Falls Police Department is trying to improve and further our efforts in

0:33:34 the documentation of the criminals who associate with street gangs or

0:33:41 other types of criminal gangs.

0:33:45 One of the ways to do that is proper documentation.

0:33:48 One of the things we can do to document that is to document

0:33:51 their graffiti, to note what it says, because as you're aware,

0:33:55 oftentimes it becomes a billboard for what may happen,

0:33:58 and may be advertising or recruiting for them.

0:34:01 So this ordinance is one step in doing that.

0:34:05 And I have it before you.

0:34:07 I hope you've all had a chance to read it.

0:34:08 There are two different types of penalties in this, I would point out.

0:34:13 Number one, if an owner fails to remove the graffiti within the amount of time specified,

0:34:20 they could be subject to an infraction and a fine.

0:34:24 I would tell you though that the way this ordinance works in other cities,

0:34:29 we work with the city's work with the owner to try to remove the graffiti.

0:34:34 We are no means trying to impose fines against the owners.

0:34:38 I can speak for the city that I left, as you mentioned, that came from NAPPA.

0:34:43 I'm not aware of my time at the NAPPA Police Department, my entire time of 24 years, where

0:34:49 we actually issued a citation to a property owner for Felda Removager.

0:34:57 We worked with them, and that would be the intention here to use the juvenile offenders

0:35:02 group.

0:35:03 work with juvenile probation and get those kids who have been in trouble and maybe have caused

0:35:09 some of the graffiti to get them out and work to paint over that.

0:35:13 We would of course work with code enforcement.

0:35:15 We would work with our patrol officers to help to remove the graffiti.

0:35:19 We have some great organizations in the city of Twin Falls that have already taken among

0:35:24 themselves to work with different property owners to remove the graffiti.

0:35:28 So I want to say that all of this does have a penalty, a portion that may become necessary, and I would hope not.

0:35:36 But the primary goal of this ordinance is to be able to document and record the graffiti so

0:35:43 that we know what's going on as a police department in the city and

0:35:46 then to work with the owners to remove the graffiti as soon as possible.

0:35:50 I would stand for any questions.

0:35:52 Don't call.

0:35:53 when I read through your, I'm going to try it with a mic on this time.

0:35:59 Chief, when I read through your report, your ordinance, the thing that struck me, and

0:36:04 then I also received a phone call from a citizen today regarding the same issue.

0:36:08 And I know you explained it.

0:36:10 But I just had a concern with the punitive aspect of a victim being victimized.

0:36:20 And then we come in and find them, because they're not adhering to removing the graffiti.

0:36:27 Now I get what you're saying, but my concern, and I understand that we need to have some kind

0:36:33 of encouragement for them if they're not following through to get rid of the graffiti, because

0:36:40 we know the broken windows theory, where if you leave it here, then it'll grow over here

0:36:45 here and grow over here and it's like a virus, it will just keep going.

0:36:51 But I'm just wondering if we can soften that somehow in the ordinance because the intention

0:36:57 today is to not use a punitive piece, but you're not going to be here in 20 years, I'm not going

0:37:03 to be here in 20 years, it might be someone else, well it will be someone else in our positions.

0:37:10 the intention of what we had the the the ordinance for might get lost and and be

0:37:16 more of an enforcement leg and and I just have I I'm just concerned about it

0:37:23 evolving into something that we don't want it to and and I think with an

0:37:28 ordinance it's you know it's better to have the intention in the ordinance at

0:37:32 the beginning then hope that it'll continue with the mentality that we have

0:37:37 today because I know your heart I know that you don't want to go right

0:37:40 citations for someone that can't remove the graffiti because maybe they can't

0:37:45 afford to remove the graffiti they don't have the ability and and I know that

0:37:50 will work with them and and and I agree with you we have some some folks out

0:37:56 there like the juvenile offenders that can help through the county I know that

0:38:00 we used to have a real strong graffiti bus organization here back in the 90s when

0:38:06 I was a police officer that took care of these issues I'm just concerned about the

0:38:10 enforcement. Does that make sense to you? Mayor Councilman Hall, absolutely that makes sense.

0:38:15 And I get your concern. I had the opportunity this afternoon prior to Council to talk to

0:38:20 a citizen about that very, that very concern. And I would have no objection to working with

0:38:28 Fritz to put something into our, you know, into the ordinance that kind of speaks to the

0:38:35 intent. I will tell you that again in my mind the only time would probably be

0:38:41 looking at issuing that summons would be and oftentimes property owners who live

0:38:47 out of the area and just don't care about the blight and refuse to cooperate and

0:38:53 that may get into you have similar issues with code enforcement issues and a

0:38:56 maintenance issue which this ordinance also calls for an abatement method as

0:39:00 well. So, that's the only time I would see us ever doing the

0:39:07 infraction type of punishment on a homeowner or a popular one.

0:39:11 Can I just follow up just real quick?

0:39:13 It's also the cost of the abatement itself. That's within the

0:39:18 ordinance. So, it's not just the infraction citation, but it's the

0:39:21 cost. And again, I go to the, maybe the elderly person that's

0:39:27 on a fixed income they can't afford to remove it so that we go out and remove it and we send

0:39:33 them a bill and or we put it on their property tax.

0:39:36 I just would like to see us somehow in there and you've already addressed it but the intent

0:39:42 that we would work through all these other avenues prior to the punitive side.

0:39:49 Thank you.

0:39:50 Chris Stockton.

0:39:51 You know when I brought this up a few weeks ago I forgot to include the graffiti busters

0:39:56 in a maybe part of the solution, Dave Batakie, he's a CPA locally, he was involved with that

0:40:04 about 20 years ago at Mickey's

0:40:23 on probation and juvenile adjudication makes a lot of sense. After all, they clean up the

0:40:27 highways and they've been out tagging the night before, so why not get them to clean

0:40:32 that up? But what I might suggest is that we not put this on third and final, just carry

0:40:37 it over, let it percolate in the community for another week or two and see what the community's

0:40:42 comments about the alleged community nature of it. But I guess my bottom line is that I

0:40:48 I think that we can make it, and this 20 years ago,

0:40:52 we didn't do anything with an ordinance.

0:40:54 I think it was just this graffiti-buster group.

0:40:56 What the ordinance is a last resort,

0:40:58 I think we can work with a community involved people

0:41:01 to make it a pretty win-win situation.

0:41:03 Great Lansing.

0:41:08 Bob, obviously I agree with what you're trying to do here

0:41:10 and also certainly have the same concerns

0:41:12 about the impunity of the public.

0:41:14 Quickly questions I have with entities,

0:41:19 other governmental entities, do we have any control over them

0:41:23 with this ordinance or not?

0:41:24 I think of about, if you walk from the visitor center

0:41:28 down underneath there, often there's on the bridge,

0:41:31 there's the concrete of the bridge,

0:41:32 there's through feeding there sometimes,

0:41:35 and I'm thinking, well, that's the state.

0:41:36 Can we force the state to clean up?

0:41:39 That's just a valid question.

0:41:41 It was a walking in a neighborhood today

0:41:44 that has the new post office boxes,

0:41:47 and there's graffiti on the back of that post office box.

0:41:50 Do we have the ability to force the postal service

0:41:54 to clean up their box?

0:41:57 You know, those are questions I have,

0:41:58 and maybe you can't answer, maybe Fred's can,

0:42:01 maybe we need to research them, but I do like the idea,

0:42:03 and I wouldn't think that maybe if we'd let a percolate

0:42:06 for a week and then actually had a quick public hearing

0:42:09 concerning it might be anybody who is interested to speak

0:42:13 and OMAX would like to speak on it and let's see whether that thing's.

0:42:18 I wholeheartedly agree with the ordinance.

0:42:21 I think we need something along this line.

0:42:22 If we can soften the unity portion of it, I would be in favor of that as well.

0:42:26 Thank you.

0:42:27 Thank you.

0:42:29 Susan Hawkins.

0:42:30 Thank you.

0:42:31 I don't have a lot to change.

0:42:32 I just kind of wanted to echo what's being said.

0:42:35 I have a hard time even the thought of penalizing somebody who's been a victim

0:42:41 because they haven't been able to get the issue resolved,

0:42:44 that just doesn't seem fair to me at all.

0:42:49 I understand the out-of-state property owner,

0:42:52 and I don't know how to legally get to the point

0:42:54 where you're trying to get,

0:42:56 but the way this is now,

0:42:57 that part of it really is hard to deal with.

0:43:01 Sorry.

0:43:02 You don't have to abolish a heist.

0:43:04 I would remind Council,

0:43:08 you asked me to break something before.

0:43:10 That's what I'm doing.

0:43:11 Yes, and I think we do need to address it.

0:43:13 I think there needs to be some way to keep the community clean, but to possibly penalize

0:43:20 a victim that just doesn't make sense to me.

0:43:25 Don't know.

0:43:27 I would just add, I know Chris said don't go third and final this evening, read it or

0:43:33 my suggestion really is maybe we could work with our council, just try to soften that

0:43:39 and then bring it back next week, that I think that's probably.

0:43:44 I'm sure that Fritz and I could do that.

0:43:46 Could we not, Fritz?

0:43:47 Fritz, do you have some ideas?

0:43:48 We could soften, but you have to give us some more ideas

0:43:51 about what you'd like.

0:43:52 We could remove the infraction part of it.

0:43:55 But if we remove the abatement part of it,

0:43:59 there's nothing left.

0:44:02 Well, let me ask you this question.

0:44:03 Can we, in the language, talk about all the other steps

0:44:06 we're going to take before we go to the punitive?

0:44:09 to really get what I'm after is the intent that in 10 years that the next reader of this

0:44:14 ordinance will know what we were trying to accomplish.

0:44:17 Maybe as an initial step at this as we work our way through it, maybe we don't impose infractions

0:44:24 or require abatement until it's come before you so you know exactly what has happened rather

0:44:29 than leave it with our code enforcement.

0:44:32 We can see how many times you're getting these and maybe you'll get a better feel for how

0:44:38 you might want to handle it.

0:44:40 Okay.

0:44:40 That makes sense.

0:44:41 What would it be possible to include language that talks about sort of first steps being,

0:44:47 and I don't know who it is, if it's code enforcement or law enforcement or whoever, you know,

0:44:50 would work with resources available to assist in the removal of the graffiti.

0:44:56 So that would be like the juvenile offenders.

0:44:58 And then maybe the next step is maybe it references community organizations that assist with that.

0:45:03 But throwing a couple of those options out first, that again,

0:45:07 It's still the responsibility of the property owner that that be removed, but

0:45:11 that we're a willing partner to provide some resources and tools.

0:45:16 But if there's not a willingness to do that, or those tools aren't available,

0:45:20 we still need to be removed.

0:45:23 And Fritz is not a good head yes for the record and so I will work with him

0:45:29 all this next week and we will bring a new and improved draft before you next week to start over how to act.

0:45:36 don't pull all the teeth out though, all right, tagging is tough. We need to control tagging.

0:45:43 It promotes more gang association. It has some consequences that we're going to make

0:45:49 it toothless. If I could, Mayor and Council, again, going back to my experience in another

0:45:58 jurisdiction, sometimes we also had property owners of fences and things that wanted to

0:46:07 have that kind of stuff. And it gets to be a fine line. I mean, if they own property, of

0:46:11 course, they can paint it any way they want. Sometimes they would scare landlords, you

0:46:15 know, if they lived in a, in a place or not the property owner, but they would scare landlords

0:46:19 into the, the landlords then become convinced to, to leave that gang graffiti up and that

0:46:24 gets to be a real conversation with those property owners. So, sometimes fear is associated

0:46:30 with that. I don't believe that we have, we're not to that, that level here in Twin Falls

0:46:37 And I hope we don't get there.

0:46:38 So that's part of the purpose of this.

0:46:41 Thank you.

0:46:43 Great Lansing.

0:46:43 Good.

0:46:44 Can I assume that since nobody answered my question about whether we

0:46:47 can help the state and the post office, can we?

0:46:52 Now, under this ordinance, you could not.

0:46:56 There's nobody to impose an infraction against.

0:46:59 I mean, you can't do it against federal government

0:47:01 or the state government.

0:47:03 And the abatement, you know, our remedy there

0:47:06 is we put it on their taxes.

0:47:07 there are no taxes on those. But beyond that, as you know, you know, the beds tell the states

0:47:15 what they can do. The states tell us what we can do. So we're not in a very good position

0:47:19 to tell them what they have to do. We need to find some way we can tell it to you.

0:47:25 So, Mr. Newland, did you want to give any input this evening on this, or

0:47:30 you're welcome to share some brief comments? Max Newland, 328-7 of that would be these twin

0:47:37 I caught him out in the parking lot on the way in, so I went to the proper people at the proper time, almost.

0:47:44 And my beef is, and he says they use this for tracking.

0:47:48 And so tomorrow I'm going to go in and ask him where all graffiti happens, so I can see that map and how that's tracked.

0:47:53 Because it's my prejudice, which means I don't know for sure, but I believe in my own beliefs that poor people get more tags than rich people do.

0:48:03 And so then again this becomes punitive against the poor people then the rich and my suggestion for a solution

0:48:09 I won't be part of the problem in part of the solution is put a

0:48:13 One-tenth of one-half of a percent tax and make it everybody's problem. We just pay for graffiti when it comes up

0:48:19 Everybody shares the birds like insurance. Thank you very much

0:48:24 Thank you, Mr. Nuhlin

0:48:29 That's a that item coming back to us

0:48:31 So here's here's another opportunity for the public to provide us some input if

0:48:38 anyone would like to address the public who didn't have a chance to earlier.

0:48:41 All right items from the city manager from the deputy city managers.

0:48:48 Gentlemen, I have two items for you. The first one is on Thursday I was

0:48:55 reminded that I we I'll say I'm going to say Travis failed to introduce Jake

0:49:02 J. Clazinsky, who's sitting right behind me.

0:49:06 J. Clazinsky is our new city manager's intern,

0:49:09 so he's working with us for the summer,

0:49:10 and he sat down with the tableists

0:49:12 with a couple of council members at lunch tonight.

0:49:14 You all know Jake, we introduced him to council meeting

0:49:15 and we didn't.

0:49:16 So here we go.

0:49:18 This is Jake, he's gonna be with us for the summer,

0:49:20 he's a student at Boise State, right?

0:49:23 That other school.

0:49:25 The one that I didn't got to.

0:49:26 But we're happy to have him, he's doing a great job,

0:49:29 and hopefully he'll, you guys will get to work with him

0:49:31 and get to know him as well, so.

0:49:34 You'll find him a cubicle.

0:49:37 He's got a full-on cubicle just like I do.

0:49:40 Just like I do.

0:49:41 Just like I do.

0:49:42 Right.

0:49:43 The second thing I was going to provide you

0:49:46 is a really brief update on the tear down

0:49:49 of the Roderson building.

0:49:50 It's the last thing I did before I walked in this room

0:49:52 tonight was check on that.

0:49:53 It is mostly down, probably 80% down.

0:49:57 They tell me it'll be completely down by 10 o'clock

0:50:00 tomorrow morning. There is no need to close Main Street for tonight. There was a thought

0:50:05 that that might need to happen and they're well past that point. So tomorrow after 10 o'clock

0:50:12 there should just be a big pile of rubbish to start hauling away. And it went really smoothly

0:50:17 over the weekend. They were very grateful for the opportunity to work overnight. And so we're

0:50:22 making real good progress there. And I see you all an email with a YouTube link that shows

0:50:26 some good video of that coming down. I want to say that was

0:50:28 probably taken Saturday evening, I think, because it looks like

0:50:33 it's pretty close to the beginning of it. But anyway, so it's

0:50:36 making good progress.

0:50:38 Thank you, Mr. Chris talking to me. I have a question on

0:50:41 star corporation raising the building. Have they told you

0:50:44 anything about asbestos levels? I see them keeping the hose on

0:50:50 to keep dust of all kinds of baited, but right, and they went

0:50:53 through before or the major demolition and remove obvious things.

0:50:57 But has there been much evidence of asbestos in this Paris form?

0:51:02 There was.

0:51:03 There was, I wouldn't say significant amounts of asbestos.

0:51:06 There was asbestos present in the Rogerson building.

0:51:09 There was a several week long abatement period where the asbestos

0:51:12 was being removed by certified asbestos removal folks

0:51:17 before ideal demolition started doing anything.

0:51:20 And so that's all happened.

0:51:21 That'll happen before anything they're doing now.

0:51:25 And the same story is actually true for the banner building

0:51:29 across the street that the city's doing.

0:51:31 There was asbestos in that building as well.

0:51:33 A lot of it we knew about.

0:51:34 In fact, in both buildings, we did a test

0:51:37 to identify it all ahead of time, identified most of it.

0:51:41 They were able to uncover more as they started getting in.

0:51:45 And all of that has been abated now as well

0:51:47 in the banner building.

0:51:48 And now they're starting just regular demolition

0:51:52 on both buildings.

0:51:54 But all these festivals removed by certified folks

0:51:57 and done in accordance with all those rules

0:51:59 and regulations for it.

0:52:01 So, thank you.

0:52:04 Thank you.

0:52:05 Items from the city council.

0:52:07 So I wanted to just try to man with a couple first.

0:52:09 We have the Canyon Springs Road Committee

0:52:12 is meeting this week on Thursday.

0:52:16 I'm continuing their work as they continue

0:52:18 to explore the challenges and opportunities

0:52:21 with the Cane and Springs grade

0:52:23 and trying to balance recreation and transportation needs

0:52:26 out there, so that group's been doing a lot of hard work,

0:52:29 a lot of heavy duty engineering reading with that group.

0:52:33 And then just two other quick things I wanna point out.

0:52:36 First, I'd like to acknowledge the loss

0:52:38 of a couple of our key community members this last week.

0:52:41 David Mead, who was probably one of the most engaged citizens

0:52:44 I've ever had the opportunity to meet,

0:52:47 certainly involved in a number of important activities over the history of our community,

0:52:51 including a significant support of the arts and certainly our natural settings in the canyon

0:52:56 passed away last week. And second, Willie Dane, who was another lifelong supporter of

0:53:01 our community, never afraid to share his opinion, but whose entrepreneurial spirit really served

0:53:06 a lot of folks here, including the visitors down at Social and Falls, as he operated the

0:53:10 concessions there. So our thoughts and prayers are certainly with the, with the mead and

0:53:15 Dane families. And finally, a fantastic weekend with the Special Olympics state

0:53:21 games held here, had the opportunity to be a part of the opening ceremonies on

0:53:25 Friday evening and several hundred athletes and their supporters from around

0:53:30 Idaho. Outstanding community support, I couldn't be prouder of Twin Falls for

0:53:36 the way they stepped up to be part of those games not only in volunteering to

0:53:40 help with them but certainly just spectators showing up the crowds or the

0:53:44 The stands were full of folks on Friday night and I know at the events all day Saturday as

0:53:48 well.

0:53:49 I do want to give a special acknowledgement to Suzanne Hawkins for her work in coordinating

0:53:54 those volunteers.

0:53:55 I know she has some background and experience with that with some other significant community

0:53:59 events but that is not an easy task.

0:54:02 I'm hurting the cats out there.

0:54:03 So Suzanne, thank you for all that you did to your friend.

0:54:10 Don Hall.

0:54:11 Well, first of all, I want to say thank you for bringing up the two losses that we had this last week.

0:54:18 They were both very, very good men.

0:54:20 So thank you for doing that.

0:54:21 Couple of other things I want to bring to your attention is, first of all, we had the Vietnam Memorial event at City Park on Saturday morning.

0:54:31 And our own Chris talked to them, who is a Vietnam veteran,

0:54:35 Air veteran gave a welcome for the city and shared some wise words and did a really good

0:54:41 job.

0:54:42 I appreciate Chris standing up and doing that.

0:54:45 Also just a side note, I don't know if many of you were able to read Michelle Michael's

0:54:50 article about the memorial that we have at the corner there in City Park.

0:54:54 But that is probably, if it's not the oldest in the United States, it's one of the oldest

0:55:00 in the United States.

0:55:01 is the first in Idaho, anyway, memorial for our Vietnam vets.

0:55:06 67, no, no.

0:55:07 Yeah, it's 67, and that's phenomenal.

0:55:11 We have that in our city park to honor the men that sacrificed for us.

0:55:17 Number two, the next issue is I was able to attend the URA meeting at lunch.

0:55:24 And please correct me why I'm wrong here.

0:55:25 I meant you were there with me.

0:55:27 But a couple things that really stood out to me in the presentations and the information

0:55:33 that was shared and what they decided to, some of the decisions they made, is first of

0:55:37 all they are going to be putting three new fire hydrants on the main street side of Main

0:55:44 Street during the project.

0:55:47 Some significant costs to be able to do that, but it's the right thing to do to have the fire

0:55:52 hydrants on the front of Main to better protect those buildings.

0:55:56 Number two, the thing that still amazes me, I wasn't aware of this until the presentation,

0:56:01 but several of the buildings along Main Street have basements that jut out almost to the street.

0:56:10 So underneath those sidewalks, there's actual basements, into the public right of way.

0:56:16 So there was some debate today about how that even took place, but it was done back in the day.

0:56:21 But that's a significant thing that the folks that are doing the project are looking at because

0:56:28 the sidewalks and everything are going to be removed and replaced and we need to ensure

0:56:34 that they are built correctly in case a fire truck ever had to pull up on the sidewalk

0:56:39 or a fire or something to make sure that it's stable to be able to do that.

0:56:44 And a couple of locations, it didn't look all that stable to me in looking at it.

0:56:49 So just a couple notes that I thought I'd bring to your attention that was very interesting and the group is all over.

0:56:57 Thank you, Don. Suzanne Ockens.

0:57:00 Thank you. I have a couple things as well.

0:57:03 First of all, I'd like to give a big thanks to City staff.

0:57:07 We had some citizens who were concerned with the crossing area behind the new mall by Canyon Springs Grade Road.

0:57:17 We were hoping people would stay on the sidewalk up to fill more across the street and then pick up the trail and go back around.

0:57:24 But that is not the natural flow of traffic.

0:57:26 And we had a lot of people crossing in a very dangerous area where there was parking on the streets and people were darting between cars.

0:57:33 And so it was brought to our attention and city staff jumped on it.

0:57:36 There's a new crosswalk there. There's no parking signs now.

0:57:39 And I had the residents from that neighborhood tell me that it's had a natural calming effect on the traffic as well.

0:57:46 and they are just absolutely thrilled to death.

0:57:49 It was a good solution for a neighborhood that was concerned

0:57:53 and I think City staff did a great job addressing that.

0:57:57 I also wanted to report that last Thursday night

0:58:00 was our first city band concert of the year.

0:58:03 And it was really great.

0:58:04 They picked up on our Special Olympics theme

0:58:08 and poured in some Olympic music

0:58:10 and they were really good at reminding the crowd

0:58:14 to come out and support the athletes as well.

0:58:16 And I thought they just did a fantastic job bringing that all together for us.

0:58:20 My third one is to the council members.

0:58:22 I am scheduled for radio next week, but I will be in Boise for AIC as will most of you.

0:58:28 It's Wednesday morning.

0:58:29 I have to go up Tuesday night with the youth council.

0:58:32 And I didn't know if anybody wanted it, and if not, not to throw you under the bus.

0:58:37 My thought is it might be a great chance for Wendy to give an update on parts of our things

0:58:41 happening.

0:58:42 So we will definitely turn it to the staff and we'll let them or wrestle who can answer any of the rest of us for available.

0:58:50 Well, I'm here but not available.

0:58:52 That's fine. Thank you.

0:58:54 Anything else from the council? You all ready to keep rolling with public hearings?

0:59:02 This is wrong. Okay.

0:59:04 Chair, Chair, this is here.

0:59:08 We will move to the next section of the agenda, which is a few public hearings that we have scheduled this evening.

0:59:14 Now the first is consideration of a request for a PUD amendment to the North Haven PUD agreement number 235 to allow additional building heights within the North Haven Business Park subdivision number two as per city code and ordinance 3077 for property located

0:59:31 Northwest of the Chini Drive West and Villier Street intersection. We have Gerald Martins on behalf of North Haven Business Park.

0:59:40 Welcome, Mr. Martins.

0:59:44 Thank you, Council.

0:59:46 My name is Gerald Martins. I'm here with this evening to represent North Haven Business Park, the owner of

0:59:53 the undeveloped property in North Haven Subdivision, which is outlined by the dashed line.

0:59:58 In 2006, this project was platted, platted, and platted, and platted, and the PUD document

1:00:05 was recorded.

1:00:09 And it's specified to building heights that match the code at that time.

1:00:13 Since then, the city has changed their code.

1:00:16 This is a very simple request to just bring the height limitations within that property

1:00:21 in performance of the current code.

1:00:24 In the future, I'll be wiser.

1:00:25 I'm just going to put in the PUD documents that it will conform to code at the time of

1:00:30 the applicant, but we did put in a specific 35-foot height limitation, and that is restricting

1:00:37 some potential development in that property.

1:00:39 So we're just asking that the PUD be amended to allow performance, and that is the language

1:00:46 with the code as it is at the time the application is submitted.

1:00:50 That, I'll be glad to answer any questions.

1:00:52 Any questions for Gerald?

1:00:54 I do not see any, so we will turn it over to City staff for the staff report, Jonathan Spendlove.

1:01:04 Thank you Mr. Mayor.

1:01:06 I think Gerald summed it up really well, really, and the only thing I have left is the possible impacts.

1:01:12 We do have some of the buildings that are built.

1:01:14 Norco and Dialysis Center here.

1:01:17 This is Castle's Corner.

1:01:19 First Federal with some other office buildings in this area.

1:01:22 The surgery center for St. Luke's is across the street being constructed currently.

1:01:27 The other buildings in the area that are taller than 25 feet, some of them are taller than 35.

1:01:32 The hospital obviously is taller than 35 feet.

1:01:34 CSI has a few, we don't see any really big impacts, the only thing is the visual impact to anything.

1:01:41 During a public hearing on May 24th, the commission unanimously, uponing his zoning commission,

1:01:47 unanimously recommended approval as presented and subject to the following

1:01:51 conditions subject to amendment being applicable only for the undeveloped lots

1:01:54 within the North Haven Business Parks Division number two which is the area is

1:01:58 outlined.

1:02:01 So I actually have a question related to that subject to provision so in the

1:02:11 future if there were to be a redevelopment of one of the existing lots

1:02:14 would it have to stay at 35 feet or would it be allowed to move?

1:02:21 That's what conditions states, yes.

1:02:23 So if castles corner were demolished and something else wanted to go in that was taller, that's

1:02:29 what that amendment or that recommendations would be precluded from going to 50.

1:02:36 Was there a rationale presented by the planning and zoning commission for those particular lots?

1:02:42 that I think Gerald May Crick, only that the owners of those lots had already been sold.

1:02:48 And so they were not part of the application that does not preclude and

1:02:54 look for mitch for guidance on that if they did sign the application for it, I'm not sure.

1:03:00 Is that the idea of Gerald?

1:03:02 Yes, well, the reason obviously is that they would have all had to

1:03:08 and applicants for the change.

1:03:11 It's our feeling that each of those,

1:03:14 if they so choose, could come in with the same argument

1:03:17 we're presented here today that the code has changed,

1:03:20 and if they were, and I really couldn't see the reason

1:03:23 why in all likelihood it wouldn't be grounded,

1:03:27 but they would have to come in with a specific request

1:03:30 for those specific lots whenever that would occur.

1:03:34 Those are relatively all new buildings.

1:03:36 All of the users out there were well aware of this, they were notified of this hearing,

1:03:43 and we had discussed it again, so I don't think they're anxious to see the increased density of this brain.

1:03:50 So thank you.

1:03:51 Thank you, Joe.

1:03:52 Chris Stockton.

1:03:53 Hi, Jonathan.

1:03:54 I question, I certainly think it's appropriate to consider amending this PUD for the 50 feet.

1:04:02 As I recall, we've had questions in the past of the 50 foot is an absolute height or would

1:04:09 that be able to include fascia, flag poles, antenna, out-service buildings in addition

1:04:18 to the net 50 feet from ground level or the measurement point?

1:04:22 So we measure from nearest top of curb from the nearest public roadway.

1:04:27 50 feet, it does not include the architectural projections,

1:04:31 uninhabitable space, type of deal flag poles would be something different.

1:04:34 So 50 feet is really like your habitable space on a building.

1:04:39 So it could be some number of feet and is some number of feet. I think the Shiloh end is one of the cases.

1:04:45 And Fairfield is a newer one too as well, that had some architectural...

1:04:49 So there is no ultimate height to this, it's only the habitable height.

1:04:52 Within reason yet.

1:04:54 What's reason?

1:04:56 That's a good question for us.

1:04:58 Boom, I want to buy a bag of a new one.

1:05:01 Thank you.

1:05:02 Thank you.

1:05:04 So we will open the public hearing for this item.

1:05:10 I'm guessing nobody's signed up to speak on this.

1:05:13 If there's anyone here who would like to speak on this issue,

1:05:17 please come forward.

1:05:20 Seeing no one, we will close the public testimony

1:05:23 portion of the public hearing and turn it over to Council.

1:05:27 Or some discussion.

1:05:28 that you have any closing comments you want to give me?

1:05:30 Okay.

1:05:32 Chris talking.

1:05:33 So is this an ordinance or just a passage?

1:05:35 There's no ordinance tonight.

1:05:38 It would just be approval.

1:05:40 I would move to Amanda PUD 235 with the attached PNC conditions.

1:05:47 Second.

1:05:48 Motion by Chris talking 10 seconded by Ruth Pierce.

1:05:53 I'm going to write page to write those down here.

1:05:56 Seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request as presented with

1:06:01 as presented with the condition of the planning and zoning commission as well.

1:06:05 Any discussion from the council?

1:06:11 Seeing none, Chair, and we'll call vote please.

1:06:13 Sean Baraker?

1:06:14 Yes.

1:06:15 Chris Tockington?

1:06:16 Yes.

1:06:17 Greg Lanting?

1:06:18 Yes.

1:06:19 Don Hall?

1:06:20 Yes.

1:06:21 Ruth Pierce?

1:06:22 Yes.

1:06:23 Suzanne Hawkins?

1:06:24 Yes.

1:06:25 Motion passes 6-0.

1:06:26 The next item on the public hearing agenda is consideration of a request to approve a special

1:06:30 use permit to construct and operate a professional office on property located on the south side

1:06:36 of the 1500 block of Bridgeview Boulevard. We have Gerald Martins on behalf of Temple View

1:06:41 Properties. Welcome again Gerald. It's convenient to come back to back for you.

1:06:48 Again my name is Gerald Martins for the record representing Temple View Properties to the

1:06:52 owner of the property called East Park, professional subdivision number two. Recently went through

1:07:00 the planning process. This is a property immediately to the south of Home Depot that they can property.

1:07:07 If any of you have been by their construction grading activities going on. This is a relatively unique request because there is a requirement on this property that any development we brought before City Council for approval. It was to appease the concerns of the residential neighbors to the south.

1:07:27 What's proposed for this property is in total conformance with the criteria in the PUD, but basically not to exceed 6,000 square feet single story building

1:07:38 with some limitations on height.

1:07:42 This is proposed as a new title company building, approximately 5,400 square feet, ground level.

1:07:54 There is a basement, mechanical and a brick room in the basement of the facility.

1:08:03 It is one story.

1:08:05 It is very compatible in colors, materials, stone, as the surgery center that we brought

1:08:11 before you on this diagonal lot a few weeks ago.

1:08:17 There will be another one coming to you in probably in about three weeks, which is a property

1:08:22 immediately to the west of this property. Once again, architecturally, they are all

1:08:28 compatible. They all have cross-use parking, common landscaping, all of the

1:08:36 landscaping on the entire perimeter of this property will be association owned

1:08:40 maintained. So we're going to have a very consistent uniform professional

1:08:46 office project. That would be glad to answer any questions. We're just here to show you

1:08:53 what we're doing and feel free to criticize the architect. He's not here. I criticize architects

1:09:01 all the time. Any questions for Gerald? Seeing none, we'll turn it over to Jonathan for a staff

1:09:08 report. Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. This history is actually very

1:09:13 similar to the history or a couple weeks ago about the surgery center which I've talked

1:09:17 about.

1:09:18 It's all came in about the same time for plating with regard to this newest plat was actually

1:09:23 really recently but it was kind of pre-plated before.

1:09:26 The conditions are the same in the PUD and it's a professional office overlay within that

1:09:31 PUD, you need a special use permit in that but then there's also a vision to come to

1:09:35 you within that PUD so we're satisfying that.

1:09:38 All the required improvements like the parking, landscaping, screening, storm drainage all

1:09:42 appear to be in conformance with what's required in city code with the plan that Gerald showed.

1:09:49 Additionally, the PUD also has a few others, talks about buildings construct from this property

1:09:55 will be constructed using residential style architecture and will have an architectural finish

1:09:59 to sit at the pleasing. All professional buildings in Syria will be limited to single

1:10:03 story, which it shows. Buildings within 350 feet of locus may have larger buildings. Building

1:10:11 The living space in Chaney will be positioned,

1:10:13 since it's not facing Chaney.

1:10:15 And then the landscaping,

1:10:16 there's a perimeter landscaping requirement

1:10:18 along Bridge Boulevard.

1:10:19 All those things we will look for

1:10:20 during the building permit process.

1:10:22 Again, we're just here for kind of the use of the property,

1:10:24 which is professional office,

1:10:25 totally allowed through special use permit.

1:10:28 The impacts to the area,

1:10:30 due to nothing being there previously,

1:10:32 there will be increase in vehicular traffic.

1:10:34 It's really close to Madrona, Locust, Holine,

1:10:39 Chaney Drive connects to Blue Lakes Boulevard,

1:10:41 we do not believe it, it's hardly any of the traffic

1:10:43 will go through nearby residential neighborhoods,

1:10:46 unless somebody from that neighborhood

1:10:47 is coming to this business specifically.

1:10:49 There are ample collectors and arterials around it

1:10:52 to get you in from this whole area.

1:10:56 Now light intrusion is another one

1:10:57 that we've heard from the neighbors to the south.

1:11:00 So we did add a condition similar to the other business

1:11:02 we had as far as subject to all lighting being downward facing

1:11:06 and the light source being shielded

1:11:07 from nearby residential properties.

1:11:09 So should the council grant this special use permit

1:11:12 as presented staff recommends two conditions,

1:11:15 number one subject to the site plan amendments

1:11:17 as required by building engineering fire and zoning officials

1:11:20 to ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements

1:11:22 and standards and compliance with the East Park PUD

1:11:25 agreement number 213 and number two is dealing

1:11:28 with the lighting that I just previously stated.

1:11:30 That is all.

1:11:32 Thank you, Jonathan.

1:11:33 Any questions for Jonathan?

1:11:38 Same and we will open the public hearing

1:11:41 If there's anyone who would like to provide testimony on this item,

1:11:47 see no one, we will close the public input portion of the public hearing and

1:11:52 turn it over to council, Suzanne Hawkins.

1:11:55 Thank you.

1:11:56 I move that we approve the request for a special use permit to operate a professional

1:12:01 office on property located on the south side of the 1500 block of Bridgeview Boulevard.

1:12:08 Application 2788 with the attached conditions mentioned

1:12:15 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins

1:12:18 Seconded by Don Hall to approve the request as presented with the conditions also

1:12:22 Included there any further discussion from the Council

1:12:28 Seeing none share it roll call vote please

1:12:30 John Barreger yes Chris talking to yes Greg Lanting yes Don Hall. Yes. Yes. Yes

1:12:37 Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, motion passes six to zero. Finally, on the public hearing agenda,

1:12:47 we have consideration of a request for a zoning title amendment to amend city code 10, 7, 20,

1:12:56 B, 2, C public hearing notice requirements by adding or as determined by the administrator

1:13:02 to the number of posted public notice signs required and this is coming to us from the

1:13:09 City of Twin Falls. We have Jonathan Spindler. Welcome, Jonathan. Yes. You're going to give

1:13:14 your own staff report too? City Council approved ordinance 2012, July 6,

1:13:23 1981. Pretty much the code we have today. We made an amendment to that on March 2015, amending

1:13:31 public hearing notice requirements. Due to some lack of notice, some people felt

1:13:36 like they were not getting noticed. We increased the distance, we increased this

1:13:39 number of signs, and we increased the size of signs. After a year or so of having

1:13:46 this, we have some experience with those notice requirements and have seen that

1:13:53 sometimes that notice requirement is excessive. Particularly this last

1:13:58 amendment that Gerald had today with the North Haven PUD. This originally his signs, if he

1:14:06 included the entire PUD, would have encompassed three 4x4 signs along Washington, eight 2x3

1:14:15 signs along Chaney Drive, three along Parkview, and eight 4x4 public signs along Pole Line Road.

1:14:23 It would have been littered almost literally with public hearing signs.

1:14:27 I can't pay.

1:14:28 Yeah.

1:14:29 Any questions?

1:14:32 Not only that, but we're also looking at the cost to people.

1:14:36 So the city does not have these signs.

1:14:38 We do not provide them.

1:14:39 They either make them or rent them.

1:14:42 So in some of these public hearings, we've noticed some of them tend to be excessive.

1:14:48 So the idea behind requiring more signs was well-intentioned, and when the code says you

1:14:55 shall, we have no way of saying you shall or may do fewer.

1:15:00 So the amendment that we have is to have some human discretion as the administrator adding

1:15:13 this underlined or as determined by the administrator under if the property contains 300 or more

1:15:18 more feet of street frontage on a single street, one sign shall be placed on the property for

1:15:22 each 300 feet or portion thereof of the street frontage or as determined by the administrator.

1:15:28 In this particular case, and there's a few others that we've had, having eight signs along

1:15:32 pole line would seem, somebody may seem to think there's multiple public hearings going

1:15:37 on because it's covered such a large area.

1:15:40 The idea behind this was some of the manufacturing zones where you have larger lots, you might

1:15:46 need more signs. Whether or not we need eight along the section is something we think we can

1:15:53 reasonably handle with the staff review, hence the ORS, torn by the administrator. We can

1:15:59 always use the OR. We were unable to do less. So on May 24th, the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:16:05 held a public hearing on this request, no one spoke for or against the request. There was

1:16:10 a motion to approve. And the second, all members present voted in favor of the motion. In conclusion,

1:16:16 The staff concurs with the Planning and Zoning Commission.

1:16:19 The Council may grant the zoning

1:16:20 a title amendment as requested,

1:16:21 recommend a modification of the amendment as presented,

1:16:24 which would require another public hearing,

1:16:26 or request the amendment be denied, that is all.

1:16:32 John Hall.

1:16:33 So, Jonathan, I remember going through this debate,

1:16:36 and it was really about the northwest end of town.

1:16:39 We had a development out there that.

1:16:42 Southeast?

1:16:43 Southeast?

1:16:43 Southeast?

1:16:44 Not that was North.

1:16:45 Near Chobani, that's where it kind of started.

1:16:48 But I also thought we had one out where they were doing some of the apartments or whatever anyway and then that one came up to you

1:16:54 Yeah, because because the the signs were so far back people couldn't figure out where well

1:17:00 How do we mitigate that? How do we ensure that that the intent of what we were trying to accomplish before?

1:17:07 will

1:17:09 Follow through with this new amendment

1:17:13 Does that make sense I think so before we were going with the notification

1:17:19 Only of the state notification, which is 300 feet from property boundary that we've notified letters to

1:17:25 Also, we just said a sign posted on the property

1:17:28 single sign in most cases

1:17:31 Now we require those signs to be near to the roadway and perpendicular to the roads

1:17:36 You can see them as you're driving towards them within reason

1:17:40 By doing both of those increasing the 300 to 2 now the base

1:17:44 The base requirement to send letters out is 500 feet for any actionable item besides one thing which is a plan.

1:17:51 Everything else is 500, 750, and 1,500 for residential items, 750 for most commercial,

1:17:59 and 1,000 feet for any industrial type or R6 I think is only.

1:18:06 We've increased both the letters being sent, the size of the sign, and we dictate the location

1:18:13 of the signs now to be closer to roadways.

1:18:15 We basically, when we send out the notice what they need to send in letters and put in the

1:18:23 signs, they get a map just like this, and with everything.

1:18:26 We say you shall put a sign, three signs along this roadway, and we put a dot saying you shall

1:18:32 put the sign here, here, and here.

1:18:34 We dictate those locations a lot more clearly than we ever had before.

1:18:38 That is now common policy within our department to do.

1:18:41 Okay, thank you.

1:18:44 Any other questions for Jonathan?

1:18:48 Is there any further staff report on this?

1:18:53 Seeing none, I will open the public testimony portion of this hearing.

1:18:58 If anyone would like to speak on this issue.

1:19:02 Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion of the public hearing and

1:19:06 turn it over to the city council.

1:19:09 Greg Lanter.

1:19:10 I have made that mistake for a lot of time though.

1:19:17 Somebody made it to the other day that he's got my mind.

1:19:21 I would move to approve the zoning title amendment to amend City Code 10-7-20B2C for the public hearing those requirements by adding as or as determined by the administrator to the number of posted public notice signs required.

1:19:37 second motion by Greg Lansing seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the change to

1:19:46 the zoning title amendment as presented is there any discussion from the council

1:19:51 seeing none Sharon roll call vote please Chris Tockington yes Greg

1:19:57 Lanting yes Don Hall yes Ruth Pierce yes Suzanne Hocken yes Don Burger yes

1:20:04 Motion passes 6-2-0, thank you, Jonathan.

1:20:09 Next on the agenda we have two executive session items for the Council's consideration.

1:20:17 The first is executive session under, I don't know, Code 74-2061-C to acquire an interest in real property, which is not owned by a public agency.

1:20:27 and also 7402 a 6-1f to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated, but imminently likely to be litigated.

1:20:42 The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

1:20:47 Don Hall.

1:20:48 So moved.

1:20:49 Second.

1:20:51 Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adjourn into executive session under those

1:20:59 two sections of Idaho Code, is there any discussion? Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call

1:21:04 vote, please.

1:21:05 Greg Lanzine?

1:21:06 Yes.

1:21:07 Don Hall?

1:21:08 Yes.

1:21:09 Ruth Pierce?

1:21:10 Yes.

1:21:11 Suzanne Hawkins?

1:21:12 Yes.

1:21:13 Sean Berricker?

1:21:14 Yes.

1:21:15 Chris Talking.

1:21:16 Yes.

1:21:17 Motion passes 6-0.

1:21:18 We'll let the audience know.

1:21:19 Convening following the executive session nor will we be making any decisions in the executive session and with that we are adjourned

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 13, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:21:31.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    be410173a5e810abd3302ce1d0336a88f92415af700092b114887d1332aa8531
  5. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 6 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    e8d7a7e222f13415a67ff5e4de3640a00e55f7d9d228a145cb9b1a6c234957a5

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file