City Council meeting
Monday, April 25, 2016
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:00:00 April 25th, our first order of business is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:00:03 Those of you wishing to join me, please rise.
0:00:08 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:27 I will confirm we do have a quorum of the city council.
0:00:30 Six members of the council are here currently.
0:00:33 Councilman Lanting is running just a few minutes late
0:00:35 and we'll join us soon.
0:00:38 Mr. Rothwell, are there any amendments
0:00:39 to the agenda this evening?
0:00:41 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:00:42 there are no amendments this evening.
0:00:44 Thank you.
0:00:46 Next, we have a proclamation.
0:00:49 The American Cancer Society's Paint the Town Purple Week,
0:00:55 whereas an estimated 8,080 Idaho residents
0:00:59 are diagnosed with cancer each year
0:01:01 and 2,200 will not survive.
0:01:03 And whereas this city is joining over 5,200 other communities
0:01:07 worldwide to host the American Cancer Society's Relay for Life,
0:01:11 an event to celebrate cancer survivors
0:01:13 and remember those who are no longer with us.
0:01:16 And whereas Relay for Life raises funds
0:01:18 to help the American Cancer Society create a world
0:01:21 with less cancer and more birthdays
0:01:24 by helping people say, well, get well, find cures
0:01:27 and fight back.
0:01:29 Now, therefore, I, Sean Berriger, mayor of the City of Twin Falls,
0:01:32 hereby proclaim May 1 through May 7, 2016, as the American Cancer Society's Paint the
0:01:39 Town Purple Week and the official kickoff of Relay for Life in this City.
0:01:44 In doing so, I urge citizens to celebrate cancer survivorship, remember loved ones lost
0:01:49 to the disease, honor caregivers, and join Magic Valley's fight against cancer.
0:01:54 Display your purple around the town, home, business, and schools.
0:01:58 together we will find a cure. And here to accept the proclamation this evening, Candie
0:02:04 O'Draero. We just would like to get every money in Twin Falls. Really excited about really
0:02:24 for life. It's the 25th year of really for life here in Twin Falls. And so we really want
0:02:29 to get everybody excited and really plaster this town in purple. So we are encouraging all
0:02:35 businesses, homeowners, everything. We also have a contest going around town that is for
0:02:41 the businesses who have the best paint the town purple. So we do have a website and we'd like
0:02:46 people to come and look at it. We'll be stating the businesses that will be in our contest for
0:02:52 paint the town purple. But we would like to encourage everyone to come out to relay which
0:02:57 is May 20th and 21st. It is a public event and we would like to have everyone out there.
0:03:04 We also on May 7th, we have at the Immanuel Lutheran Church at 12 o'clock noon, yeah.
0:03:13 We do have a survivor's dinner, so we're asking all cancer survivors to please come out to
0:03:18 our survivor's dinner.
0:03:19 It's a free dinner hosted by tomatoes at that time.
0:03:22 So thank you and we appreciate that you do in our proclamation.
0:03:26 Great.
0:03:27 Don Hall.
0:03:32 I just want to acknowledge that our mayor were purple tonight.
0:03:36 I've got to have some stuff.
0:03:39 Ruth Pierce.
0:03:41 I just wanted to say I'm a breast cancer survivor and I so appreciate what everybody
0:03:46 is doing.
0:03:48 Tell me again when the dinner is at.
0:03:57 Would you please?
0:03:58 Yeah.
0:03:59 So I'm a ten year survivor.
0:04:01 Yay!
0:04:02 And if it wasn't for my doctors and my friends and everybody I wouldn't be here today, so
0:04:11 Thank you for everything you're doing.
0:04:12 Thank you.
0:04:16 Next on the agenda is general public input.
0:04:18 So anyone who would like to address the council on an issue
0:04:21 that is not on this evening's agenda,
0:04:23 you are welcome to come forward and share that with us now.
0:04:26 In spite of the huge crowd that we have here this evening,
0:04:31 no one is on that agenda item.
0:04:33 Next, we have our consent calendar.
0:04:35 Council wishes.
0:04:37 Don Hall.
0:04:38 I would move approval.
0:04:40 Second.
0:04:42 Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins
0:04:44 to approve the consent calendar.
0:04:47 Is there any discussion?
0:04:50 Chris Tock.
0:04:51 That, Dot and I were talking a little earlier
0:04:53 and I think he has talked to spokesperson
0:04:57 for the upcoming Vietnam Veterans Memorial.
0:05:01 And I sure do hope that the speaker
0:05:06 will be a Vietnam-era veteran.
0:05:09 Politicians are a dime a dozen,
0:05:11 but if they've had military service in that time,
0:05:14 I'm sure appreciate it.
0:05:15 If there's anything you can do on that.
0:05:19 Any other discussion from the council?
0:05:22 Seeing none, Sharon, roll a call, vote, please.
0:05:27 Suzanne Hopkins, yes.
0:05:28 Nikki Boyd, yes.
0:05:30 Sean Beriker, yes.
0:05:31 Chris Talkington, Greg Lanting, yes.
0:05:34 Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, yes.
0:05:38 Motion passes seven to zero, Don Hall.
0:05:41 I would like to have Tom Maxwell,
0:05:42 who's kind of helping to spearhead this come forward
0:05:45 and maybe say a few words about that event.
0:05:49 That's okay with you, Mayor.
0:05:51 That would be fine.
0:05:52 Well, I think you've spent some time up here before,
0:05:54 so I didn't think it would hurt your feelings.
0:05:57 I don't know, I don't spend much time up there
0:05:59 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:06:01 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:06:06 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:06:09 Commemoration Welcome Home Celebration.
0:06:11 This is our second annual, we're gonna do it
0:06:14 for a few more years if we can keep it happening.
0:06:16 Last year we had over 300 attendees at the park,
0:06:20 88 veteran group motorcycle riders this year
0:06:23 were anticipating about 150 riders,
0:06:27 and 500 people at the park.
0:06:29 We have veterans information and services available
0:06:32 for the veterans of all wars.
0:06:34 We're working now with a lot of the assisted living facilities
0:06:39 and skilled nursing facilities to bring
0:06:40 as many veterans out of those places as we can.
0:06:43 We're looking for volunteers to help those veterans
0:06:45 in the World Chair or have need for help at the park,
0:06:49 so if anybody would like to help,
0:06:50 they can contact me at Hospice Visions, seven, three, five,
0:06:54 oh, one, two, one.
0:06:56 We look forward to the event,
0:06:57 and we look forward to the next few years
0:06:59 of doing the same to welcome the Veterans' Home
0:07:02 in a manner that they deserve.
0:07:03 Thank you.
0:07:04 Thank you, Tom.
0:07:05 Thank you, Tom.
0:07:07 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:07:08 Tom, I just want to let you know that you're good.
0:07:11 I support you, and I wish I could be there.
0:07:12 you have picked the same day as Idaho Special Olympics here in Twin Falls, so I'll be there
0:07:19 with you in spirit that day.
0:07:25 The next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to enter into an agreement for
0:07:29 the completion of the Canyon Rim Trail and we have our City Manager, Travis Rothwiler.
0:07:34 Welcome, Travis.
0:07:35 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, good evening and thank you for the opportunity to present
0:07:41 the memorandum of understanding for your consideration.
0:07:46 The agreement is between Gary and Connie's store, the Twin Falls Community Foundation and MavTech,
0:07:54 the Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee, and the City of Twin Falls for a wonderful
0:07:59 opportunity to complete the largest missing segment of our trail.
0:08:04 The agreement calls for MavTech to move forward and to acquire an easement through fundraising
0:08:13 and through other opportunities and through the events that they raise to help support
0:08:18 wellness and healthy living inside of our community.
0:08:21 And then from that, and upon receipt, the city will then take that easement and they will
0:08:26 transform that into a trail.
0:08:30 And that trail will ultimately connect from the where the dot is right now, corner at
0:08:37 the corner of Pull line in Eastland and connect all the way over to the evil
0:08:44 Knievel jumpsite where that trail is now. You know this is a wonderful and special
0:08:50 day and this agreement has really been the work of many. In fact, some of those
0:08:58 are, many of those are in the room and and sometimes projects like this take a
0:09:04 a long time to build and they take lots of dreaming and they take lots of ambition and
0:09:10 it starts with great former leaders in our community like Tom Courtney and Lamar Orton
0:09:17 and Gary Young and Dennis Boyer who had a vision to create a trail system inside of our community
0:09:24 and they started with that process and there's people like Gerald Martins and Ken Stutzman
0:09:29 who worked side by side to construct that trail.
0:09:34 And then this piece, this piece that is ultimately
0:09:38 coming forward today with the assistance of MavTech
0:09:41 and their hard work.
0:09:42 And again, Mr. Martin's was instrumental,
0:09:45 but also people like Cindy Collins,
0:09:51 who really worked hard to drive this project here.
0:09:57 I just have the opportunity to be the one to say,
0:10:00 we would ask your support of the agreement
0:10:05 and we would encourage your support
0:10:06 and we'll stand for any questions that you have.
0:10:10 Thank you, Travis.
0:10:11 Chris, talk.
0:10:12 It's not a comment.
0:10:12 I'd like to pay a little extra tribute.
0:10:14 You mentioned the three foundational members city hall
0:10:19 including Tom Courtney and Gary Young.
0:10:21 Gary Belamarorton in our audience,
0:10:23 and I'm gonna embarrass him by making him stand up.
0:10:26 I'm not sure if many of you are aware
0:10:28 that our Canyon Rim Trail started in Rock Creek Canyon.
0:10:32 And Lamar was a driving force to begin the negotiation
0:10:36 with various parties to link up little parcels
0:10:39 in Rock Creek Park.
0:10:42 And all of us knew that he didn't know
0:10:44 what he was doing and look what we have now.
0:10:46 He, I was only worried when you had negotiations going on two
0:10:53 parcels with an open in the middle.
0:10:55 And I figured that one in the middle
0:10:57 was going to hold his ransom, but he saw the spirit of the trail system in Rock Creek
0:11:02 and Lamar, it's up to you. Good job.
0:11:12 Any other comments from the council?
0:11:14 I'm glad I'd like to add to Travis's comments about partnership. It has taken an awful lot
0:11:20 of people, an awful long time to have this come together and I will tell you of all the
0:11:26 paperwork I get to sign as mayor. I'm probably looking forward to signing this one the most
0:11:30 since in my short-term as mayor.
0:11:33 But I think the cooperation and partnership
0:11:36 of the store or family, MavTech and the Twin Falls Community
0:11:40 Foundation, many, many individuals
0:11:43 who have helped to support this, and then certainly
0:11:46 the public entity of the city as well.
0:11:49 But the partnership isn't quite over yet,
0:11:50 because there are some funds to be raised,
0:11:53 and MavTech will be telling us a little bit about that
0:11:56 after we vote on this agreement.
0:11:59 If there are no other comments from the council, I would entertain a motion.
0:12:03 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:12:04 I would be very pleased to make the motion that we authorize the mayor to sign the, um,
0:12:11 get the terminology right.
0:12:17 The memorandum of understanding with the four mentioned parties to connect the canyon
0:12:23 room trail and get this beautiful thing done.
0:12:28 Second.
0:12:29 The motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Don Hall.
0:12:34 Is there any further discussion from the Councils?
0:12:36 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:12:37 Oh, sorry, I just forgot to move.
0:12:38 Don Hall.
0:12:39 I think you stated it very well, but we certainly
0:12:42 need to say thank you to everyone in the audience
0:12:44 and all the hard work.
0:12:45 But we need to also just say thank you to the stores
0:12:48 one more time for their cooperation and help in this.
0:12:53 Seeing no further discussion, Sharon, roll call vote, please.
0:12:59 Nikki Boyd?
0:13:00 Yes.
0:13:00 John Barrieger, Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Parris, Suzanne Hocking.
0:13:08 Yes.
0:13:09 That is great.
0:13:10 I would like to invite Jamie Teague from the Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee to
0:13:23 come forward and say a few words if you would please.
0:13:25 Wow.
0:13:29 This is a great day.
0:13:30 Thank you so much.
0:13:31 Thank you, Travis.
0:13:32 I'm going to try not to.
0:13:34 I told them.
0:13:35 I said, oh my gosh, I can't get emotional.
0:13:39 get emotional by this, my heart is really full.
0:13:43 Thank you so much to all of you who've worked on your part
0:13:48 and allow us with this wonderful partnership
0:13:50 to come together on behalf of MapTek.
0:13:53 It has been a really long road,
0:13:56 and like Travis said, some of these take a long time,
0:13:58 but for me, I wanted it now, right?
0:14:01 Waiting for this moment has been a dream
0:14:06 and thank you for helping bring this to a reality.
0:14:09 We are so thankful for all the hard work
0:14:13 and dedication that the council and the Twin Falls City
0:14:17 has given to put this together.
0:14:21 It's going to be an amazing, amazing trail.
0:14:24 It's gonna be incredible for this community.
0:14:27 We are very thrilled and excited.
0:14:30 So on behalf of MAFTEC,
0:14:33 there's scatter clear throughout this room.
0:14:36 I'd like to speak on behalf of them and thank some wonderful people as part of this partnership.
0:14:42 First of all, thank you, Gerald Martins.
0:14:44 Gerald, you've been without you, honestly, and Cindy Collins.
0:14:51 You guys have been behind the scenes from day one pushing.
0:14:55 Thank you so much.
0:14:56 We cannot thank you enough.
0:14:59 And Travis, for your support, honestly, without you on the other side, on behalf of the city.
0:15:06 Thank you so much for being there for us from day one as well.
0:15:12 Travis has the same vision as I think all of us making this happen for the city.
0:15:19 As well as Sean.
0:15:21 Sean thank you again on behalf of all of us.
0:15:25 We really appreciate your support and acknowledging our vision as well.
0:15:30 That map check has put forth.
0:15:35 Dennis Boyer, without you, man, starting all of this and many countless hours of listening,
0:15:45 supporting, walking the trails with all of us.
0:15:48 Dennis has been the planning guru with us from day one as well.
0:15:55 The Twin Falls Community Foundation Board, we have Leonard here and I thank you so much
0:16:02 Twin Falls Community Foundation.
0:16:04 No, thank you so much for your guys' support.
0:16:07 I really appreciate you guys partnering with MAFTEC.
0:16:10 We love being under the board.
0:16:13 And I don't think John's here tonight, Nerler,
0:16:15 but he's been the one who's had to listen
0:16:20 to many, many questions on my behalf.
0:16:25 And Bill Green.
0:16:26 And Bill Green with Team Leany.
0:16:28 From, you guys just have to know that I started with Bill, I said, hey, I want to start this
0:16:36 committee, can you help me get some people?
0:16:39 The first night the room was filled.
0:16:41 Bill just helped get all the running community involved into working with us.
0:16:49 Mandy, for Grant, and thank you for allowing Mandy to work with us on behalf of MAFTEC.
0:16:58 and helping us raise the funds.
0:17:00 We really appreciate you, Matthew, your hard work.
0:17:04 Wendy Davis will be, she doesn't know yet.
0:17:08 But welcome, Wendy.
0:17:13 Here we go, working together.
0:17:18 And I cannot forget this wonderful team of hard-working
0:17:23 people who have told me to shut up more than once and to stop it because they've been there
0:17:33 from day one.
0:17:34 Thank you so much and I have tech team and we are not done.
0:17:37 Of course we're not done but we do have many plans to get this $600,000 raised by next
0:17:45 March of 2017.
0:17:48 We do have some grants in the works.
0:17:50 We also working with some other private individuals to help us in getting these funds.
0:17:59 So don't worry.
0:18:00 We will not let this opportunity slip by.
0:18:03 So thank you.
0:18:04 Thank you all.
0:18:05 Thank you so much.
0:18:06 This is such an awesome, awesome opportunity and we're very, very grateful.
0:18:21 So Jamie, you have an opportunity coming up with Western days that people can sign up
0:18:26 for the run and help you raise some money, right?
0:18:28 You did.
0:18:31 If you'd like to come up and just real quick, tell people how to get involved in that.
0:18:36 Okay, thank you.
0:18:37 So June 4th, we do have the Spirit of Magic Valley event that's coming up.
0:18:43 And it's a half marathon, a 10k and a 5k event.
0:18:47 It is one of our, one of the six fundraising events we have planned for this year.
0:18:53 So you can register by going to our website at mapcheck.org, M-A-V-T-E-C.
0:18:59 And you can also support us by going to Idaho Gives on May 5th.
0:19:07 And you can support that through the Twin Falls Community Foundation.
0:19:11 And when you give your donation, just put trails, and I'll go straight to the trails to
0:19:17 go towards this endeavor.
0:19:19 Thank you, Sean.
0:19:20 Thanks, Jamie.
0:19:24 So assuming that you all don't want to stick around for the rest of the meeting, I'll give
0:19:28 you a couple of minutes if you all want to sneak out before we move on with our agenda.
0:19:33 But thank you again for being here this evening.
0:19:35 Well, we love to have you.
0:19:37 You're welcome to stay.
0:19:39 It's great Lamar showed up and goes put it back about 78. I think he started
0:19:59 Right so next on the agenda we have a presentation of certificates of appreciation to Tony Hughes and John
0:20:14 Bonnet to recognize their eight years of service on the City of Twin Falls development impact the advisory committee
0:20:21 We have deputy city manager Mitchell Humble. Welcome. Thanks
0:20:27 and council. We have a couple of certificates to stand out tonight and the certificates are
0:20:34 for the eight years of service on the impact fee advisory committee. What this doesn't say
0:20:39 is that for a year or so before that both of these guys served on our impact fee, I don't
0:20:44 know what we call the recreation committee. And so they've really got nine years into this
0:20:51 effort and there are last two original members left on the committee and they're no longer
0:20:58 with us and we're really sorry to see them go.
0:21:02 So we wanted to bring him here and have Chris and Mayor Berger if you guys could come on
0:21:07 down and hand those certificates out left.
0:21:09 Tony and John come on up here.
0:21:11 Let me just make a real quick comment if I could, Mayor.
0:21:18 This is very unique type of a committee.
0:21:22 It's entirely tested through court proceedings, but it's based upon the premise that new growth
0:21:29 should help to pay for existing infrastructure.
0:21:33 And it's four categories, police, fire parks and streets where fees are charged for new
0:21:39 building lots, et cetera, that are able to be utilized through the committee that these
0:21:45 gentlemen represent to build everything from part of the trail system to stop
0:21:51 lights, police equipment, fire equipment. It has really been a help to the city's
0:21:56 budget. So to that point I'll say this specifically this event that we just
0:22:01 witnessed here with the agreement we're going to use a lot of those parking
0:22:04 factories to pay for the construction of that trail. That's the plan anyway so
0:22:09 So thanks to John and Tony going up and...
0:22:35 So I can bunny ear you.
0:22:49 Do I do stand on the standing line?
0:22:54 Sure.
0:22:55 It's delicious.
0:22:58 No.
0:22:59 That's how it works.
0:23:12 It's a fast fish.
0:23:13 It's the fourth of something Smith would do.
0:23:15 You do it.
0:23:16 Well, thank you gentlemen for your years of service
0:23:30 and after you take a break, you can come back
0:23:32 and do something else, right?
0:23:34 Next, we have consideration of a request to approve the recommendation of the Twin Falls
0:23:40 Housing Authority to appoint Paulette Ellis as a commissioner, Penny Earle, Twin Falls Housing.
0:23:51 Welcome.
0:23:54 Yeah, I'm here today to request that you consider the reappointment of Paulette Ellis.
0:23:58 She's already served one term for the Housing Authority.
0:24:02 For those of you that don't know what the Housing Authority is, we were established in
0:24:06 as a low-income public housing authority under the guidelines of HUD, manage 196 units for elderly, disabled, and families of children.
0:24:18 And because of Paula's prior experience with the same clients over the years, she worked with the Department of Health and Welfare,
0:24:26 she's been a really good asset to the Housing Authority, and I'm going to be retiring this year,
0:24:33 year and so I really like to see this longevity go on because she has learned a
0:24:39 lot over the last few years. All right thank you. Is there a direction from the
0:24:47 council? Nicky Boyd. I did that we approved the request for the recommendation of the
0:24:53 front-class housing authority to reappoint a Paulette Ellis as a commission. I'll
0:24:58 second that. Motion by Nicky Boyd seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the
0:25:02 recommendation to reappoint Hallette Ellis. Is there any discussion? Seeing none,
0:25:09 Sharon Rollco vote please. Sean Baraker. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Greg Lanting.
0:25:15 Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes.
0:25:21 Motion passes 7 to 0. Don Hall. Just wanted to say congratulations on your
0:25:26 retirement and happy golden years, right? Thank you. Next is a presentation of the
0:25:36 The long-term planning committee ideas as they fit with the strategic plan for fiscal
0:25:41 year 2017 through fiscal year 2022, we have police chief Craig Kingsbury.
0:26:00 Well, good evening, Mayor.
0:26:01 Well, you're not a city council, very.
0:26:03 I'm sorry, but.
0:26:03 You're not chief Kingsbury.
0:26:05 No, he's part of it.
0:26:07 We have Ron and Gary.
0:26:08 They wanted to have the fire department come up first and kind of get things.
0:26:12 It's the dog and pony show or just not sure which is the dog and which is the pony.
0:26:17 So we're back.
0:26:18 What I'd like to do this evening is I'd like to start by letting some of the folks in the
0:26:23 audience know kind of what we do, what the long term planning committee is, and how it applies
0:26:28 to the strategic plan.
0:26:30 So if you'll bear with me, I'm going to go through just some overview of the process,
0:26:37 and then we'll get started.
0:26:38 So what is the strategic plan?
0:26:41 So the plan identifies eight focus areas that were put together with input from the City
0:26:47 council recommendations from the city employees and recommendations from the
0:26:53 community. Those eight focus areas are healthy community learning community
0:26:58 secure community accessible community environmental community prosperous
0:27:04 community and responsible community and then the eighth one is focus area eight
0:27:11 which is focus on the internal organization. So what is long-term
0:27:16 planning so in 2010 when the long-term planning committee was put together it
0:27:21 was in fact a group of individuals that come from different departments that came
0:27:26 together with a list of priorities that were far and above more important than any
0:27:31 other priority in the city. Over the first few months of every year we identify
0:27:39 and prioritize personnel and capital needs of each department and then we're
0:27:45 challenge to present that in a five-year plan. So with process review, again this
0:27:53 year we challenged each other by looking at individual department processes and
0:27:57 structures to ensure that we as one city are utilizing our current resources
0:28:03 effectively and efficiently as possible. So one of the things that we talked about
0:28:12 this year in the long-term planning committee is what makes an organization
0:28:18 And that was a question that actually come up in one of our sessions.
0:28:23 And I think that the overwhelming, resounding answer to that were the women and men of that
0:28:30 organization, the people that work in that organization.
0:28:34 So last year, the way we presented this to you was we gave you a laundry list of priorities,
0:28:40 and we attached them to each strategic plan focus area list by list.
0:28:48 This year, I think what we're going to do is we're going to focus on what we see as the heart and soul of the organization,
0:28:55 and that is the internal organization itself, and how those priorities come together,
0:29:01 and how we attach those out to the strategic plan.
0:29:04 So, keep in mind that this is just a very brief look at a very robust document that I'm sure you have in front of you now,
0:29:18 And we're just going to touch on the priorities and identify those back to those focus groups.
0:29:23 So with that, I'm going to ask Craig Kingsbury to come up and
0:29:27 I'll be able to agree.
0:29:33 Thank you, Ron.
0:29:35 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
0:29:38 As Ron stated, the long term planning group is made up of employees,
0:29:43 employees of the City of Twin Falls.
0:29:45 And we have, we look at some different photographs that we have here of our employees in action.
0:29:52 over the over the last year or two.
0:29:54 And our employees truly are what makes this city great.
0:30:00 As one of the newer employees,
0:30:01 I am very, very happy to be here
0:30:04 and can tell you that this is a great place to work.
0:30:08 This city's a great entity to work for.
0:30:11 And even better than that,
0:30:13 the citizens are a great group of people to work for.
0:30:16 And that's what we're all here for.
0:30:19 Now, I think what we need to do
0:30:22 is look at our mission statement.
0:30:23 What's the mission statement of the City of Twin Falls?
0:30:26 Our mission statement up here,
0:30:28 our mission as stewards of the public trust
0:30:31 is to meet current and future needs of the community,
0:30:33 promote citizen involvement, preserve our heritage,
0:30:36 conserve and protect our social and physical resources
0:30:40 and enhance the quality of life in Twin Falls.
0:30:44 We all try to do that each and every day.
0:30:46 There have been some great things that happen even tonight
0:30:49 that really reflect on what the mission statement is
0:30:51 for the City of Twin Falls.
0:30:54 Now, as you know, I'm a relatively new member of the Twin Falls family, and when I got told
0:31:00 that I was going to as a new member of this family serve on the long-term planning committee,
0:31:05 I didn't really know what to expect.
0:31:07 I had been involved in budget processes in past years at the other entity that I worked
0:31:12 for, but I didn't really understand how we would have employees from all different departments
0:31:20 get together to try to come up with some recommendations on how to spend the taxpayer
0:31:26 money.
0:31:29 That first day that we were in there, the city manager came in and I think I had been
0:31:33 an employee for about three to four weeks at that time.
0:31:36 My head was still spinning but Travis came in and talked about what his vision was, what
0:31:42 he really wanted to focus on going forward.
0:31:46 And that really was on focus area eight of our strategic plan.
0:31:50 Now, you probably recognize this slide here because I sold it from a presentation that the
0:31:56 City Manager gave to this very council several weeks ago.
0:32:00 When you look at all of the focus areas, all the ones that Ron mentioned, healthy community,
0:32:05 learning community, secure community, accessible community, environmental, prosperous and responsible,
0:32:13 everything to be successful points inward at our internal organization.
0:32:18 We talked about our mission statement, our guiding principles, all the way through to what's
0:32:23 the vision.
0:32:24 What do you as policy makers want from the employees of the City of Twin Falls?
0:32:30 What do we hope to gain?
0:32:32 You know, I think we all would agree that to run a good organization, we need competent
0:32:38 and yet compensated staff in order to make sure all of this works.
0:32:43 And we all agree that employees are a very important part of that mission in fulfilling
0:32:46 the strategic plan. Over the past five years, and this number shocked me a little bit. I must admit, we've
0:32:53 got 132 city employees that have left, and some of them have rode off into the
0:32:58 sunset in retirement, some of them we asked to retire, but 89, 89, left for other employment.
0:33:05 This is my short time at the police department, two have left. One wanted to work for a federal
0:33:11 agency and one took a job with St. Luke's. So in my almost four months we've lost two police
0:33:20 officers. But again over the last five years as a city entity we've lost 89 employees. And
0:33:27 when you think about what is the cost to us as an organization? Well looking just at the
0:33:33 police department over the last five years we've had 54 officers that have left their
0:33:37 employment. Of those 54, 34 have left for other employment. So, 20 of those people either retired,
0:33:45 were off into the sunset or left for other reasons. And then you look at 11 of those, have went to
0:33:51 work in the Treasure Valley, Boise, Nampa, Meridian, and even the Idaho Attorney General's office.
0:33:59 Our dispatch center, we've lost 11 dispatchers in that same time frame, three of which went to
0:34:04 other dispatch centers. And as I was looking at that list that I had from
0:34:11 Gretchen and Human Resources at all the employees that have left over the last
0:34:15 five years, you know, there are other departments that were as affected as well.
0:34:19 You know, the fire departments, lost people, public works have lost some
0:34:24 employees. And you think, well, what's the cost? What's the cost at that? Well, I
0:34:31 I think we don't need to look at the salary that we lose because when an employee is here,
0:34:36 even an employee that's here for a few years in training,
0:34:39 we always are going to get some value from that employee.
0:34:42 But yet, they're also going to be learning and they're not going to be as valuable as a three, four, five plus year employee will be.
0:34:49 We lose that institutional knowledge.
0:34:53 We decide to a little bit smaller, I apologize, but to recruitment costs,
0:34:58 On average, to recruit for a position, it cost our HR department $2,000 and $3,000.
0:35:04 So when you talk about financial, that's one thing to look at.
0:35:08 And then the first year, training and salary.
0:35:11 In some of our city departments, when we hire people that don't have any experience,
0:35:16 they really take that first year to get their feet on the ground and
0:35:21 have that knowledge base where they can operate in a safe and effective and efficient manner.
0:35:28 Now, in my department, the police department, I think about the field training.
0:35:33 I think about the post-academy.
0:35:36 I think about the equipment we have to purchase.
0:35:39 You're probably aware when we hire police officers, generally speaking, we are going
0:35:46 to put them in a 15 to 17-week field training program where they have another officer right
0:35:49 with them.
0:35:50 So we have taken an experienced officer and now he or she becomes a teacher and they then
0:35:56 partner with that new officer for 15 to 17 weeks. So really those two officers have become
0:36:03 maybe one or 1.25 about halfway through the process. We're also going to purchase uniforms
0:36:10 and equipment. The uniforms that your men and women in blue wear, they are expensive.
0:36:17 The ballistic vents, best for example, we pay $790 for those. And generally that's not
0:36:24 not something that you transfer to another employee if they don't work out, because you
0:36:29 know we come in all shapes and sizes. And you couldn't take somebody like me and if I didn't
0:36:35 work out take my ballistic vest and maybe give it to somebody like Dusty Solomon, it just
0:36:40 wouldn't work. So you have to think about that cost. Sure the firearms are expensive,
0:36:45 but firearms they can be transitioned fairly easily. So think about the other departments,
0:36:52 Public works, they're buying uniforms, they're buying equipment, they're doing training, fire department.
0:36:58 It's not just in the cost of money, but intrinsic value.
0:37:03 It is the institutional knowledge that we want to instill in these employees.
0:37:09 And looking at it as you extrapolate that out, if we lose a two-year employee, that's a pretty big hit.
0:37:17 If we lose a five-year employee, that even becomes a little bit greater hit.
0:37:22 last fall, the Twin Falls Police Department lost a detective who was very trained. He was
0:37:29 our polygraph examiner, which that's a very expensive class, about $10,000 to $15,000, a
0:37:36 10-week class generally. He also was one of our arson investigators and also was involved
0:37:41 in internet crimes against children. So we had a lot of training. He had, I believe,
0:37:45 about 15 years on the Twin Falls Police Department. And he went to work for the Idaho
0:37:50 Attorney General's office.
0:37:52 We are still trying to scramble and catch up with the losses that we suffered from that.
0:38:00 Retaining employees truly is the number one goal of the long-term planning committee.
0:38:07 We're going to talk about some other things as my co-presenters are going to come up here.
0:38:11 But our number one goal as a committee was employee retention.
0:38:16 It really fits with the strategic plan and it fits with focus area number eight.
0:38:21 I think you would all agree that when we look at what makes
0:38:25 Twin Falls great, it's that we operate with a mentality of one
0:38:29 team, one mission, and one city.
0:38:32 And so now I'd like to turn it over to Wendy Davis to talk about
0:38:35 some council priorities.
0:38:43 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:38:48 So in the past, the long term planning committee has approached
0:38:51 the city council to find out what their priorities would be,
0:38:55 generally after we're done with the process.
0:38:58 my understanding and so this year we approached the group to find out what your priorities were
0:39:05 while we were still in the process.
0:39:07 We heard these to be a summary of your priorities and that includes technology, working smarter,
0:39:13 not harder, maintaining our clean water and improving the water quality in the city,
0:39:20 trail development enhancement, development and looking into a recreation center, providing
0:39:26 good quality customer service and continuing to work on our sidewalks and maintaining the
0:39:31 sidewalks.
0:39:33 So as a result of hearing these priorities, we went ahead and took a look at the long-term
0:39:41 planning recommendations as we were coming forward and tried to figure out how they matched
0:39:45 with your priorities.
0:39:46 So tonight I'm really talking about the priorities that we heard from your group and how it matches
0:39:53 with some of the projects that we're pushing forward.
0:39:55 a lot more things on the list that I'm going to talk about this evening, but this just kind
0:39:59 of gives you an idea of how the things that we heard you say fit with the projects that
0:40:07 we're bringing forward.
0:40:08 This slide is primarily an opportunity just to give you a visual of what it looks like
0:40:14 of these priorities and the projects that we identified and how they link together and
0:40:18 how they fit within the strategic plan.
0:40:21 And when you see on here things like learning community or environmental community, prosperous
0:40:25 community and you don't see any projects listed under there, it doesn't necessarily mean that
0:40:29 we don't have projects that we're pushing forward or that we're not doing things to work
0:40:33 to further those focus areas.
0:40:36 It's just that based on the priorities we heard, we didn't identify those projects as
0:40:40 things to talk to you about tonight.
0:40:42 So it doesn't mean that we just totally neglected three or four areas within the strategic plan.
0:40:49 So let's talk about those priorities, and some of those.
0:40:51 Chris, Chris, talk.
0:40:53 I didn't see one that, at least I've mentioned,
0:40:56 I think has been an ongoing priority,
0:40:58 and it's completing or working toward completion
0:41:01 of the GIS system for all underground utilities.
0:41:06 That is vital, that's labor saving,
0:41:08 it's a type of technology.
0:41:10 Did I get this rolled in somewhere, or where is that?
0:41:19 We do it routinely for new development,
0:41:21 that's sooner or later, it's going to be required
0:41:24 for all of our internal structure.
0:41:29 You can just make a little note on that.
0:41:32 It's included in there.
0:41:34 I was trying to figure out exactly which project it was
0:41:37 because we talked a lot about GIS.
0:41:40 And so it definitely is included.
0:41:42 And I'm just, I'm kind of wondering why we didn't bring it
0:41:45 forward, but so the website, we're looking,
0:41:49 we're recommending that we improve the city's website.
0:41:52 And we feel that that will give us an opportunity to communicate to the public better,
0:41:57 what's going on throughout within the city.
0:41:59 Try to make the website a little more user friendly.
0:42:02 Right now, they say if you're looking for a job and you get into the city's website,
0:42:07 it's not mobile friendly.
0:42:08 It's three or four clicks and we lose some of those young potential police
0:42:13 officers that get about four clicks in and think, you know what, never mind.
0:42:17 And so we're looking for a better platform to interface with the community
0:42:21 and to communicate with the community
0:42:23 as to what's going on within the city
0:42:25 and give them a better forum.
0:42:28 We're also looking to upgrade the Springbrook software
0:42:32 and include an employee portal,
0:42:34 which would cut down on all of the paper
0:42:38 that's necessary as far as employee information goes.
0:42:41 So that would include the employee's ability
0:42:44 to go in and check the W-2 forms
0:42:46 and look at their pay stubs
0:42:48 and look at all that information within the computer instead of having to do it through
0:42:55 the paperwork.
0:42:56 We're also looking to upgrade the time clock system which would pretty much eliminate the
0:43:01 need for paper time sheets which the piles that I deal with with all of our seasonal and
0:43:06 part time staff is incredible and I can't imagine what it looks like city wide.
0:43:10 So again, reducing the opportunity for error there.
0:43:15 So by the time we get to FY 17, the body cameras for the police department should be all purchased
0:43:21 and at this point now we're looking for the support of those cameras, which is the back
0:43:29 on the backside of that data management that's going to come through the body camera program.
0:43:34 And then another one is to go through and digitize all the hands and building documents
0:43:40 get those cleaned up so that we have access to all of those online and digitally instead
0:43:44 of the massive amounts of paper that's out there right now.
0:43:50 The Recreation Center obviously is still a hot button out there and we dedicate some money
0:43:57 to take another good hard look at that opportunity, looking for community partnerships, looking
0:44:03 for opportunities to partner and to find some funding to see if we can't figure out a way
0:44:08 to push this project forward.
0:44:11 As far as clean water goes, we are recommending water meter replacement which will upgrade
0:44:19 some of the water meters and allow better monitoring of the water as well as increased
0:44:23 revenue generation through the water use.
0:44:27 We're also looking to bring well number five online and that's the one that's south
0:44:31 of town which would reduce the pressure on the one on this side of, on this side of town
0:44:41 so that it doesn't have to go as far to reach those customers on the south side of town.
0:44:46 And then also a water operator which would help increase the service of the water department.
0:44:53 As far as trail development enhancement goes, we don't have a big project because we were
0:44:58 waiting for the big one tonight.
0:45:01 So really right, good timing, right?
0:45:05 So really all we were talking about as far as trail management enhancements this time
0:45:09 would be more maintaining and enhancing our current trail system and really didn't know
0:45:15 how to address this other project but now it's out there so that's an exciting piece
0:45:21 as well but that was already budgeted for us so that's not in this current plan.
0:45:26 The sidewalk improvement we are recommending a sidewalk match program for sidewalk replacement
0:45:32 for citizens in the community to help start improving the sidewalks and continue to improve
0:45:37 the sidewalks.
0:45:38 And then as far as customer service goes, I feel like, you know, we've hit this one pretty hard.
0:45:44 But actually, I think I want to go to this one for a minute and then we'll come back to customer service.
0:45:49 So we're recommending these positions to come forward.
0:45:52 And obviously, these are all new positions that would all further the customer service objective.
0:45:58 The victim witness coordinator for the police department enhances the services to the community and
0:46:03 helps support the healing process for victims.
0:46:07 We also need a body camera, DDACS coordinator for the police department, which would be the
0:46:11 person that manages that data as it comes in off of those body cameras.
0:46:16 Currently, the fire training officer is a part-time position, that's an officer that
0:46:22 does this work kind of on the side, and this would be a full-time training opportunity and
0:46:28 an officer for that.
0:46:29 There's also a mechanic for the city shop, and then, as I mentioned before, the water
0:46:36 I think it's really needed.
0:46:37 That's going to bring in.
0:46:38 Oops.
0:46:39 I'm lost.
0:46:40 Okay.
0:46:41 So back to customer service.
0:46:42 So we feel like, you know, we heard the city managers, priorities, we've heard yours.
0:47:00 We feel like we're doing a good job of supporting both and bringing forth recommendations that
0:47:06 reflect the support of both of those sets of priorities.
0:47:10 So as far as customer service goes, I think we've talked about the fact that we feel that
0:47:14 the employees within the city really hold a critical piece in customer service.
0:47:20 And so along with bringing on some new positions,
0:47:24 we're also recommending that we make some efforts toward employee retention and compensation.
0:47:30 So with that, that's pretty much what we're talking about for FY17.
0:47:36 Now Rob's going to talk to us a little bit about the next five years and kind of what to expect there.
0:47:41 So good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:47:50 I get to talk to you about the most fun part of the long-term planning.
0:47:56 If you want to call it that or the most controversial.
0:47:59 Anyway, we spend a whole lot of time.
0:48:03 And the long-term planning committee is put together to do exactly that.
0:48:09 try to plan out what we have looking down the road ahead of us and we've heard tonight we
0:48:22 think that employees for the city you know are a big part of this place and taking care
0:48:29 of employees and you know we know that we can't always keep employees here just because
0:48:35 of pay, lifestyle and family may pull employees away for one thing or another, but we want
0:48:43 the employees that are here and happy to be here.
0:48:48 We want them to stay here other than a paycheck pulling them from us.
0:48:55 So we talk a lot about our table and our salary with Chabani and Cliff Park coming in and
0:49:04 more companies will be coming in.
0:49:06 Our goal is to maintain a competitive market
0:49:10 and keep those employees here.
0:49:12 We're also looking at doing salary and pay scale evaluation,
0:49:18 going through that process, and making sure
0:49:20 that we've got our positions and our salaries matching up
0:49:23 with the competitive market.
0:49:25 Insurance and health care, that's the drill in the room.
0:49:28 We all know that that's something that the market drives that and there's a lot of change
0:49:38 in that and ongoing stuff that we may have to take a little less or have better coverage
0:49:45 or pay a little more to have better coverage.
0:49:48 But we all talk about that and we understand that just so if we can be competitive across
0:49:55 the board with other people for benefits and that kind of stuff.
0:50:03 Positions, that's a huge thing that we talk about also.
0:50:10 Over the past five years, we've had 25 positions added, keeping that in mind.
0:50:16 During the recession, we did cut ten and a half positions.
0:50:20 And some of those have been restated over the past five years, and the other 15 were new
0:50:26 position so that's roughly about three positions a year. We discuss, you know, the
0:50:34 city's prided itself and all the departments have on being a lean machine
0:50:42 and that's good to the point that we talk about employees and taking care of
0:50:50 employees and we start putting you know the workload and what are we how hard are
0:50:56 What are we demanding and asking of our employees, you know, day-to-day?
0:51:04 Well, maybe we do need to start hiring some people to fill some spots.
0:51:11 Granted, in the next five years we're looking at some people in the legal department,
0:51:19 economic development, planning and zoning.
0:51:22 HR would be glad to have some help. They've been put through the
0:51:27 ringer with a lot of hiring in that lately. You know, Gretchen's
0:51:32 been busy busy busy building inspector and community
0:51:37 forester. We talked about those and those are needed positions.
0:51:41 And then staffing for public safety. The fire department's doing a
0:51:47 now to see where we may need our next station and of course with a new station and growth
0:51:55 in the community. Once that station comes on board, there's an immediate 12 personnel,
0:52:02 just a man at fire station. So that's a huge chunk of personnel out of what we talk about
0:52:11 And there's also, you know, with growth, there also comes fire or police officers in that to
0:52:17 take care of that.
0:52:18 And then also in water and sewer, you know, the GIS technician that Chris brought up, we
0:52:24 talked a whole lot about that.
0:52:27 And we're just, we're right there, but we're not, you know, there's so much GIS data that
0:52:35 we bring in that we need someone and we know we need someone to be able to take all that
0:52:41 Because it's hard for one person to try to bring, you know, we can go collect all kinds
0:52:48 of data, but if we can't get it into our system, then all that collection we did doesn't really
0:52:53 do this thing good.
0:52:54 So that's definitely a position we talked about.
0:52:56 And then the shop mechanics, you know, as we grow and have more equipment and all that,
0:53:03 you know, more stuff means maintained.
0:53:06 And so we also talked about that.
0:53:09 Rob, Dunall has a question.
0:53:11 Okay.
0:53:12 Explain what a community forester is.
0:53:15 A community forester is somebody that goes out and takes care of the trees around the city.
0:53:23 Like an arborist?
0:53:24 On arborist, yes.
0:53:25 They, when, you know, you can only cut certain trees down, some you can't cut down, so we
0:53:31 have somebody that goes out and makes that decision and takes care of those, yeah.
0:53:39 Trees in the right of way.
0:53:40 Okay. Very good. Thank you. So capital improvements. A lot of us are doing, you know, facility plans and
0:53:50 that kind of stuff now. And these plans are pretty important. We put money aside to do these. But these plans are starting to drive the way that we're
0:53:58 our direction in, you know, the next 5, 10, 15 years. So it's important that we maintain doing that and that we, you know, take the best
0:54:09 about advice out of those plans and start getting that
0:54:13 towards the way we're doing what we're doing.
0:54:15 The seal coat and that kind of stuff,
0:54:18 the micro-paver program,
0:54:21 and then streets and water and sewer,
0:54:23 we do our zone maintenance,
0:54:25 and that kind of drives our direction
0:54:28 and what we're replacing and what we're doing there.
0:54:31 Pressure irrigation master plan is gonna be coming up,
0:54:35 and that's kind of just using our water resources
0:54:38 and using our water to the best of our abilities
0:54:41 and our water rights.
0:54:43 City-wide equipment replacement,
0:54:46 that's our equipment for our cities
0:54:49 a multi-million dollar investment, excuse me,
0:54:53 and taking care of that equipment
0:54:55 and maintaining it and then also trading it off
0:54:59 when we can get the most value out of it.
0:55:02 You know, we used to just keep something
0:55:03 until it fell over dead and then we went
0:55:07 and we need something in it, yeah, we just send it out there.
0:55:13 But we're trying to get to a point in arms,
0:55:15 getting us to a point where we get a piece of equipment,
0:55:19 we use it, and then we trade it off
0:55:21 and get the most bang for our buck out of it
0:55:23 when we trade it off.
0:55:25 So we talk a lot about that.
0:55:28 Of course, in the body cameras and tasers,
0:55:31 the bomb squad, the equipment for that,
0:55:33 those need replaced.
0:55:35 And IS is looking up for a backup generator for them to help in emergencies.
0:55:43 Trail improvements, parks and restaurants upgrades, those are all things that over time deteriorate
0:55:49 and they need maintenance and care also.
0:55:55 Land has been a discussion.
0:55:58 We all know that there's only so much of it and they're not making any more of it and
0:56:03 and they don't double stack it.
0:56:06 So when we start talking about five years down the road,
0:56:09 where are we gonna be putting things?
0:56:12 Water towers, parks and racks, center,
0:56:16 those kind of things in our storage facilities.
0:56:20 We need to start looking at where land is available,
0:56:24 because once it's bought and sold, it may be a lifetime,
0:56:28 or it's gonna cost us an arm and a leg to get it back.
0:56:31 So we're starting to look at that.
0:56:33 Canyon Springs Great Solution and who we can partner with
0:56:36 that and how are we going to pay for that?
0:56:38 Because that's a huge deal too.
0:56:42 And then like I said, planning for emergency services,
0:56:45 the fire stations and equipment and bodies to man those
0:56:49 are a big capital item also.
0:56:54 So what is our goal?
0:56:57 Our goal of a long-term planning community
0:57:00 is to plan for our future and plan five years out.
0:57:05 And what are we going to need?
0:57:06 And keep in mind, it's a plan.
0:57:09 It's not a set in stone goal.
0:57:13 We look at things and did we know when Chobani came three
0:57:18 years before they were here and what
0:57:21 that was going to do to us?
0:57:24 So it's our best guess and we try to plan
0:57:28 And we try to take out those peaks and valleys,
0:57:31 so that it's not a huge slam to our budget or our customers.
0:57:37 And try to even that out so that we're still providing good
0:57:41 services at a reasonable rate to all of our customers.
0:57:44 That's kind of what our main goal of the long term
0:57:49 is, is to be able to budget for the things that we need,
0:57:52 and not because when we start pushing everything out,
0:57:56 And we get into that, well, we can't, we can't,
0:57:59 but we just keep pushing, pushing.
0:58:01 We just keep building the pile.
0:58:03 And eventually, you've got to do something.
0:58:06 So that's kind of our goal and what we try to do.
0:58:10 We can't make everything perfect,
0:58:12 but we try to smooth it out as best we can,
0:58:14 and we give you guys something that you can look at,
0:58:18 and recommend.
0:58:20 So that's kind of the end of our presentation.
0:58:23 Chris Stockington has a cutting.
0:58:26 This will probably require city manager as well,
0:58:29 the rest of your input during the recession
0:58:32 where we eliminated that 10 and a half full-time equivalence.
0:58:36 I just remember most of those I think
0:58:38 were building and development related.
0:58:41 I don't think we had any public safety officers cut back.
0:58:45 Any lesson come out of that?
0:58:47 I think we also combined positions or something,
0:58:50 but we'll have other downturns.
0:58:53 even though we're trying to get rid of them, but what's our lesson coming out of that with
0:58:58 the 5% of the employees that we eliminated position was?
0:59:04 So when we went through the process of eliminating the position to think one of the things that
0:59:07 we looked at was not only a workload analysis, but also kind of looking at the revenues that
0:59:14 were being brought in.
0:59:16 The engineering department, the planning and zoning department were really built for workloads.
0:59:22 And I think that if you look at the lessons learned, I think that I will tell you that
0:59:28 I probably cut too deep in some of those areas, especially in the area of the building trades.
0:59:36 We were asking far too much of our lead building official, even when we had reduced the number
0:59:44 of single family permits almost by a sixth from what we saw in the highs of 2006 and 2007.
0:59:51 It was still far too much work that we were placing on the shoulders of that one individual.
0:59:59 So I think one of the lessons learned was while some of those positions were definitely
1:00:08 attached to a level of growth and it definitely attached to a workload measure that we could
1:00:13 do without temporarily, you saw that some of those positions were absolutely needed and
1:00:19 And sometimes the numbers don't tell the complete story of the situation.
1:00:26 I think it's evident the value of those positions because when the economy began to turn around,
1:00:34 those positions that were eliminated were restored into our budget.
1:00:41 Not all of the positions resulted in a layoff situation.
1:00:44 In fact, we took low hanging fruit because all of those positions were vacant at the time,
1:00:50 and so we just went forward and did not fill them.
1:00:53 I think another lesson learned was to ensure that we held public safety departments intact.
1:01:00 During the recession, the decision was made not to reduce or not to keep any of those positions
1:01:06 unfilled, and I think that that is a solid lesson learned.
1:01:10 we would continue to fill those positions just as we had during that process.
1:01:15 I think that's a fair analysis.
1:01:19 Ruth Pierce.
1:01:20 I just wanted to say I appreciate all you on the committee, how hard you have worked and
1:01:26 your forward thinking thought process that really helps a newbie kind of get.
1:01:31 I mean, I've seen some of the things that you're talking about, but it really helps me formulate
1:01:36 what our focus needs to be.
1:01:38 Thank you.
1:01:39 Any other questions from the council?
1:01:45 Any more presentations?
1:01:47 I'll turn it back over to Ron for closing.
1:01:49 Thank you.
1:01:50 Thank you.
1:01:51 Well, we do appreciate you letting us come out and do our presentation.
1:01:54 One of the things I wanted to kind of point out was what a privilege it is to actually sit on this committee.
1:02:00 It was a real eye-opener for me, and I know it has been for a lot of the folks that have sat on it.
1:02:05 We've got a lot of new faces this year.
1:02:07 And some of the things I heard, especially from those that are from out of the area that
1:02:11 aren't used to the way that we do things here, really do appreciate the opportunity to get together
1:02:17 and do this.
1:02:18 So with that, I'd like to actually ask the long-term planning group committee to actually
1:02:23 stand up and just kind of be recognized so that's all we got.
1:02:37 All right.
1:02:38 Well, to echo some of Ruth's comments, thank you to all of you for the time that you put
1:02:43 in.
1:02:44 I think that this has been really effective in my time on the council for getting a look
1:02:52 inside how things work at the city because the seven of us aren't there day-to-day, and
1:02:59 so I think it's been valuable input from the employees and the long-term planning committee
1:03:04 to look at not only the needs for the immediate future, but be thinking about that next five
1:03:08 years so that we all are caught off guard with them.
1:03:11 Rob, did you ask them now, Stan?
1:03:15 Thank you again.
1:03:16 I just want to, on a side note, I just want to do, let you guys know that we appreciate
1:03:20 your support and I'd also like to thank you for giving us the time to go and do the One
1:03:28 City Retreat.
1:03:29 You know, until you have a relationship with people and you can start to build that trust
1:03:38 until we have that, we can't really move forward with our One City.
1:03:44 being a member of the long-term planning committee,
1:03:48 I wish that we could have more of this kind of stuff,
1:03:53 because we've built those relationships,
1:03:57 and we have some heated discussions.
1:04:01 But once you're able to build that relationship
1:04:04 and build that trust, you're able to have those discussions,
1:04:08 and then you're not worried about, okay, well,
1:04:11 What's going on is somebody going to get me or that.
1:04:15 And we've been able to do that in this committee.
1:04:19 And as much as I hate to probably let it go,
1:04:22 I'll probably let someone else from my department do it next year.
1:04:25 But I think that they deserve that chance to be able to get that exposure to that.
1:04:33 And I can tell you personally it helps us through the tough stuff
1:04:38 and the things that aren't so fun to talk about.
1:04:41 We're able to work through that,
1:04:42 and I go home at night and I don't think,
1:04:45 well, if somebody's got it out for me,
1:04:47 they didn't agree with me today.
1:04:48 So I just wanted to let you guys know,
1:04:50 I appreciate you getting,
1:04:52 letting us take that time and have that day
1:04:55 and do those retreats and for the training
1:04:59 and sending people back.
1:05:01 I think it'll be money well spent down the road here.
1:05:05 So I just want to mention that.
1:05:07 Thank you, Rob.
1:05:08 Don Hall.
1:05:09 I'll try to be succinct here.
1:05:12 My journey with the City of Twin Falls began October 10, 1988, when I started with the Twin
1:05:18 Falls Police Department.
1:05:19 And through that journey, and then later on being part of the City Council, and we are
1:05:25 not management, we are governance only.
1:05:28 We do not manage the day-to-day operations.
1:05:31 That's why we have a team.
1:05:34 I have to say that I was always proud of my time at the city, and I learned a lot.
1:05:39 I like to look at myself as a lifetime learner, always trying to pick up new techniques, new
1:05:47 leadership skills, those kind of things.
1:05:50 What I've seen from the city in the last few years from the employees has inspired me, and
1:05:54 I just wanted to say thank you.
1:06:00 I think you guys are doing a great job.
1:06:03 And just to illustrate that, I had a gentleman get a hold of me today and tell me, Rob, it's
1:06:09 in your department.
1:06:10 And he's a gentleman that tends to bring me conspiracy theory, so I always take a deep
1:06:15 breath when he brings me stuff.
1:06:17 But he said his son recently, well, this weekend, had a leak out by his sprinkler system, but
1:06:23 by the water main coming into his home.
1:06:26 And he was, and it started sinking the alley, actually.
1:06:29 And he called the city and one of your team went out to him and again I'm like, okay, what's
1:06:37 he going to tell me now?
1:06:39 And he said that this gentleman, whoever it was, I don't know who it is yet, and maybe
1:06:42 we can research that, spent the time with them, looked at the situation.
1:06:47 It was obviously not the water, the city's part, it was his part, helped him pump out the
1:06:54 water out of the big huge hole that he had dug up.
1:06:59 if he could stay a little bit longer in helping with some buckets to get some water filled up
1:07:05 so that because they had to turn off the water going into the home so that they could flush
1:07:08 toilets and things like that later on. And he said he was just absolutely amazed by the customer's service.
1:07:15 So thank you.
1:07:17 Thank you, Don. Great talking to you.
1:07:20 Well, I'd like to make a personal reference to my work experience and how different this is.
1:07:26 There are so many business situations I've been involved with, and government organizations
1:07:34 as well.
1:07:35 This is seen as a threat.
1:07:37 It's seen as a threat to the people at the top in putting the city manager.
1:07:45 The very fact that we're having this discussion here and have done this more or less for several
1:07:50 years and then improve every year with that one City One Team One mission is incredibly
1:07:57 powerful. It's beyond democracy because it makes each one of us accountable for decision
1:08:04 making and the follow through. You can't claim you don't know what's going on. And we can't
1:08:10 either, unfortunately. We're on the hook. This is an incredibly positive reinforcement
1:08:19 the mantra I use, the city government works. We were the weather on the ground and it's in
1:08:27 motion all the time and I'm incredibly impressed with the strength of this very flat organizational
1:08:33 structure that we've created. It's broad but it's not deep with a lot of levels. You know
1:08:39 a lot of cities can learn from us.
1:08:41 Well, once again, thank you for all of your effort and the process continues with the budget
1:08:51 planning based upon this input and Travis.
1:08:57 So what's next?
1:08:59 So we will take this information and we will begin to create a pre-tentative budget.
1:09:08 If there is even such a term, we can kind of make out stuff as we go.
1:09:11 We will come back to the council before we publish the budget in the preliminary budget to say this is what we heard and
1:09:20 we will share that with the council prior to going in and having a final publishing of that budget.
1:09:27 So continue to think about those projects and priorities that we have not only in fiscal year 2017 but in those years and beyond.
1:09:37 We will also begin to continue to share additional information, the results of the Citizen Survey,
1:09:43 sharing that information about how the community views the levels of service that they're receiving,
1:09:49 how we can make improvements in some of the strategies that we have to improve those areas, and also to retain those areas that we're strong.
1:09:57 So continue to think about this process because we're going to come back to you in May to have another conversation prior to publishing the budget.
1:10:06 We will then begin our budgetary conversations the second full week in July and we will run
1:10:14 all the way through the final Monday of August in which we will have a different piece of
1:10:21 the budget presented to the members of the Council for comment and for consideration and
1:10:25 just as always we would encourage the community to come and share their thoughts and their
1:10:33 sentiments in any one of those listening sessions that we have.
1:10:38 In addition to that in the new twist, we are looking at going and
1:10:42 having community listening sessions outside of the Monday at five o'clock time.
1:10:48 Sometimes this isn't convenient, but we've talked about developing a strategy where we could go and
1:10:53 just have conversations about the upcoming budget with members of our community.
1:10:58 maybe on their turf and on their terms as we continue to roll out and we forward with this process.
1:11:04 Thank you, Travis. And could we get a copy of this presentation, either put in our drop box?
1:11:10 You know, I haven't seen it yet either. So it's on my list of getting a copy of the long-term planning presentation for everybody, absolutely.
1:11:17 Thank you. Maybe a classroom for a dinner.
1:11:21 Next on the agenda is another opportunity for public input. If there is anyone here from the public who would like to address the Council on
1:11:29 Any issue?
1:11:31 David you just come to observe this evening. He's hanging out in the back. All right
1:11:37 All right, well seeing seeing no one running to the podium any items from the city manager
1:11:44 Mr. Mayor members of the Council, so we're moving and today was the first of a series of waves
1:11:50 of our move into our temporary location for the next 17 months.
1:11:58 We will continue the second wave tomorrow.
1:12:02 And as that wave continues, we hope to be fully operational out of the old key bank,
1:12:12 which is located on the corner of Maine and to show an effective Wednesday of this week.
1:12:20 So City Hall is operating kind of out of both locations.
1:12:25 If the citizens have utility bills they want to pay, we're asking them to go to the existing City Hall tomorrow and then transfer over to the temporary location beginning on Wednesday.
1:12:38 We will then begin the process of completely vacating the existing City Hall so that Star
1:12:45 and Hummel can get in there and begin the pre-demolition work.
1:12:49 And if everything goes right, according to our planning schedule, we should be cutting
1:12:53 the ribbons on a brand new public safety building somewhere about a year from now.
1:13:02 So we're looking at about May of 2017 for that to finally occur.
1:13:11 Thank you, Travis.
1:13:12 Any items from city council members?
1:13:15 Don Hall.
1:13:16 I just wanted to add, I still think we should have the drive up window.
1:13:19 And maybe that's where your office is, so that we can just drive up and make comments and questions.
1:13:24 Sounds like you're the one getting all the calls from the citizens, maybe you can drive up window.
1:13:29 So where Mitch has posed to me.
1:13:33 is in a fishbowl.
1:13:36 I mean, I have 300, well, not quite 300 degrees,
1:13:40 but almost 300 of 360 degrees of a bank of windows.
1:13:46 So you can watch me work.
1:13:49 All you want.
1:13:50 We will.
1:13:56 Anything else from the council?
1:13:59 Nothing, this meeting is adjourned.
1:14:01 You know anything about bug banks?
1:14:03 I was building it there.
Download
- Transcript (text) 69 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 91 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 123 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 25, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:14:05.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
7d69427addcbc1ea144029b43256162ea83194ca40f3d0d11ed7910906020200 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 3 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
25717abdc208e2faa8f114e34cd5b343e66aa4cceec6b2ff1a8554ed30879732
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file