OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, March 14, 2016

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 March 14th, for those of you wishing to join us in the Pledge of Allegiance, please rise.

0:00:05 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:22 I would confirm that we do have a quorum of the City Council.

0:00:29 All seven members are here this evening.

0:00:31 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?

0:00:35 And Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we do have one amendment to the agenda this evening.

0:00:41 We would ask that item number three, conversation about the fiscal year 2015 audit be postponed until next week.

0:00:51 We found an error, but it is not material in terms of the overall numbers.

0:00:56 But we want to make sure that the information when it is presented is 100% accurate, it was caught earlier today.

0:01:03 So we want them to be able to correct the documents and then make their presentation.

0:01:07 Lori race is here.

0:01:08 She can more appropriately describe the error that was caught.

0:01:12 And I'm sure that Mr. Hunsaker will also do that during his presentation next week.

0:01:18 Thank you, Travis.

0:01:19 Just real quick, oftentimes when you say that there's been an error in the audit, it raises

0:01:24 concern and alarm.

0:01:26 There is none of that.

0:01:28 Lori can talk about what it is.

0:01:31 Lori race.

0:01:32 Good evening.

0:01:36 I'd so much rather be sharing with you, oh, here's the audit and here's the presentation.

0:01:41 The only thing is we missed, there was an entry miss that was just writing the investments

0:01:48 cost versus market value.

0:01:50 It's just we don't realize a gain or loss until we actually sell them and it's just an

0:01:55 entry we need to make it and got missed.

0:01:57 It's not a big deal.

0:01:59 So we'll have that corrected report next week.

0:02:01 You will have those in your hands before next week.

0:02:04 Thank you, Larry.

0:02:05 Thank you.

0:02:06 Fritz, do we need action to remove that from the agenda?

0:02:09 All right, thank you.

0:02:11 We have no proclamations this evening,

0:02:14 so we will open it now to the general public.

0:02:17 If there's anyone from the public

0:02:18 who would like to address the council on an issue

0:02:20 that is not on tonight's agenda,

0:02:22 you're welcome to come forward now to do so.

0:02:27 Seeing no one clamoring for the podium,

0:02:29 we will move on to the consent calendar.

0:02:32 Don Hall.

0:02:33 Move approval.

0:02:34 Second.

0:02:35 motion by Don Hall seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar is there

0:02:41 any discussion from Council seeing none Sharon roll call vote please Suzanne

0:02:49 Hawkins yes Nikki Boyd yes Sean Berger yes Chris talking to Greg

0:02:56 Lansing yes Don Hall yes yes motion passes 7 to 0 the first item for

0:03:04 Consideration this evening is a presentation of service plaques to

0:03:08 Teneal Adams, Tony Brand, and Carl Legg in recognition of their service on the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:03:14 We have our Parks and Recreation Director, Wendy Davis.

0:03:23 And former Parks and Recreation Director Dennis Boyer.

0:03:27 Yes, I have a distinguished guest here to help me with his presentation in this evening.

0:03:33 Actually, he didn't even want me to carry the plaques to the front, so turn it over to Dennis.

0:03:38 Good evening Council and Mayor. It's a pleasure to be here. It's been a while. I guess it has been a while since I've been here, but when I spread in a paper where we're honoring these three individuals that served on the Parks and Recreation Commission, I thought I'd better get

0:03:56 here because these three members you know served on the commission mostly under you

0:04:00 might say my term as director of partial recreation you know Tony Brand has

0:04:05 just been a personal friend of mine of them Tony for 20 somewhere 2027 years

0:04:10 and he first started on our tree commission and I can't remember how many

0:04:14 years did you serve on the tree commission five years on the tree

0:04:16 commission and then with the tree commission and the aquatics advisory

0:04:21 board was disbanded you know we want to move one person from the board and head on

0:04:25 there so I might say Tony the last 11 years he's been serving the city the city of

0:04:30 Twin Falls so I just want to make sure because these three people being on the

0:04:34 commission really helped me out those you know five or six years when they

0:04:39 served on the Parks and Recreation Commission so can I even say on behalf of

0:04:43 the city now I'm not the city I think you have that I still can do that anyway

0:04:49 but I really would like to you know thank Tony Graham for his years of service on

0:04:53 on the Parks and Recreation Commission,

0:04:56 because it was an honor for me to serve under his leadership

0:04:59 there when he started on the commission.

0:05:00 So I guess on behalf of the city of Twin Falls,

0:05:03 myself and Wendy Davis, someone told me

0:05:06 the Dennis 2.0 that just like to present this plaque,

0:05:14 it's a certificate of appreciation to Tony Brand

0:05:18 for his six years of service on the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:05:22 Can I have our mayor and our liaison for commission that he can come down?

0:06:13 We were just mentioning today happens to be Tony's 25th wedding anniversary married to

0:06:27 his lovely wife Mary Brand as well so they're kicking off the evening with this great event

0:06:31 and I suspect we're going to do something a lot more fun.

0:06:34 Yeah.

0:06:35 If you hear her shake, if you don't know, you're in trouble.

0:06:44 Oh Tony, you're in trouble.

0:06:48 Even though I was kind of wishing that Tennille Adams and Carl Lake could be here.

0:06:52 Tennille, I remember, she first applied for a pool of quad extractor board at that time.

0:06:58 And I think if I remember, she was kind of teaching aerobics for the Y, so we couldn't have her on the pool of advisory boards.

0:07:04 We asked her while winners in opening on Parks and Rec, we'll give you a call.

0:07:08 And I'm sure glad that we did give her a call because she was an outstanding member.

0:07:13 And also the last year she was a chairman of the commission.

0:07:16 Carl Legg might say this would be his second goal round

0:07:20 on the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:07:22 He was back on the Parks and Recreation Commission

0:07:24 even before I came director in the early 90s,

0:07:27 served at least six years there.

0:07:29 And then when he was on the Pool Advisory Commission

0:07:32 and that got disbanded, he was appointed

0:07:34 to the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:07:35 So he has served our community for quite a few years,

0:07:39 at least on the Parks and Recreation Commission

0:07:40 for about 12 years.

0:07:41 So I wish they were here, but they're not.

0:07:45 So I'd like to just again thank them for their service too.

0:07:49 Thank you, Dennis, for your kind words

0:07:51 about all of our commission members,

0:07:52 and we will be sure to get those plaques to Tintanil and Carl.

0:07:55 And had I known you were coming tonight,

0:07:57 I would not have strained myself to take the clock down

0:07:59 and change it.

0:08:00 You know what I'm saying?

0:08:02 Done all.

0:08:03 I'm actually just talking.

0:08:06 Mayor, I was wondering if I could just have a word with Wendy

0:08:09 really quick, since she is here.

0:08:11 You may.

0:08:12 And a couple of issues came up over the weekend for me.

0:08:15 that I wanted to address with her

0:08:17 and maybe inform the council of this.

0:08:20 I was down at Agra Falls again this weekend,

0:08:24 taking my dog for a run down in that area.

0:08:27 And I, first of all, we are so blessed to have that.

0:08:30 How many acres, 680 acres down there?

0:08:36 It's incredible, it's beautiful.

0:08:38 There are probably 15 different vehicles down there

0:08:41 from all over the nation.

0:08:43 And I only ran into people a couple different times.

0:08:46 But a couple that I did run into were some gentlemen.

0:08:50 I could see them clear over.

0:08:52 I was kind of up on the top trail walking along.

0:08:56 I could see some gentlemen down.

0:08:58 And it looked like they were digging.

0:09:00 And so I made my way down.

0:09:01 Took me about 10 minutes to go down and visit with them.

0:09:04 And I've talked to Wendy about this a little bit, as well as

0:09:06 Travis and Fritz the day of.

0:09:09 And they were digging.

0:09:10 And what they were doing was, actually, I asked them,

0:09:14 what are you doing?

0:09:15 They said, well, we're prospecting.

0:09:17 And I said, well, I don't believe that you can prospect

0:09:21 in a city park.

0:09:22 This is actually a city park.

0:09:24 But then in the back of my mind, I kept thinking, well, maybe

0:09:26 there's some kind of clause or some ancient rule out there

0:09:29 that says that if it used to be BLM, they could.

0:09:32 And I said, I don't think you can do that here.

0:09:34 And I cautioned them about it, but I will find out.

0:09:36 And then, of course, I had to walk clear up on a

0:09:39 I was able to get a hold of Fritz and Fritz, sure enough, told me that it is a city park

0:09:46 and that they should not be doing that.

0:09:48 And so by the time I got with these gentlemen again, they were actually digging another hole

0:09:53 down their prospecting or doing whatever they were doing and I asked them to not do that

0:09:58 and I was hoping that they were nice people because I was there by myself and they had shovels.

0:10:03 So, but they were both nice, very, very nice gentlemen

0:10:07 and cease doing that, filled in their whole.

0:10:10 But we had talked about that a little bit,

0:10:12 that maybe some signage, or maybe you could update the council

0:10:15 what your thoughts are with that.

0:10:17 Yes, I, we do have a monument sign that's going up down there

0:10:22 that talks a little bit about the park,

0:10:24 kind of gives an overview of some of the historic

0:10:26 and geological features down there.

0:10:30 Maybe I can give you kind of an idea of what it looks like.

0:10:35 I couldn't find the most recent version, unfortunately.

0:10:46 OK.

0:10:47 But on this sign, and this verbiage isn't quite

0:10:51 what the final draft is going to be,

0:10:53 because we changed it to make it just a little simpler.

0:10:57 But maybe we just, you want to look at that.

0:11:02 But on this sign, it talks about specifically the resources,

0:11:08 the cultural resources that are down there,

0:11:11 reminds people that they're irreplaceable

0:11:15 and to please enjoy them but leave them in place.

0:11:18 And so I'm thinking that piece of it

0:11:21 will address part of our concerns

0:11:23 and we also have money to put several specific signs

0:11:28 about the different resources down there.

0:11:30 So we have one for the Erie homestead, one for agar falls,

0:11:34 one for the mining, the plaster mining area.

0:11:36 And I think there's one about trail etiquette.

0:11:38 And I'm not sure if we're using all of the ones

0:11:42 that we have in the budget,

0:11:42 but we could certainly put something

0:11:44 just about kind of park rules again

0:11:46 that would be a little more specific about,

0:11:48 please don't litter, pack it out, pick up after your dogs,

0:11:55 and maybe again about please leave the resources in place,

0:11:59 whatever they may be.

0:12:01 The other thing that they mentioned to me,

0:12:03 because they've been down there quite a bit doing this,

0:12:05 I guess, and they said that they've seen hunters down there

0:12:08 in those ponds shooting ducks.

0:12:12 And so that's another thing that we maybe should address

0:12:17 and do some education.

0:12:21 Because currently, I don't think that's an area.

0:12:23 I know that we go to Durkeys Lake

0:12:25 and some other areas with our law enforcement,

0:12:27 but I'm not sure how much time we spend in Augur Falls to.

0:12:31 Well, I met after the city council meeting last week.

0:12:34 I went to the Southern Ednaom Mountain Viking Association

0:12:37 annual meeting and addressed them and talked to them

0:12:39 about Augur Falls.

0:12:41 And that came up there as well.

0:12:42 And I told them that they can legally carry guns

0:12:45 through Augur Falls, and that there

0:12:47 is a little section in that park that is BLM land,

0:12:52 that they can, not BLM, fishing game land that they can hunt on.

0:12:55 But they said, oh no, they're shooting the ducks in the pond.

0:12:59 And so my response was if you see that, call the police.

0:13:09 Because they're, you know, obviously they're not patrolling,

0:13:12 but it is a city ordinance.

0:13:13 And the city ordinance prohibits shooting animals in the park.

0:13:19 Well, but I think people have a misconception.

0:13:22 When it's so rugged down there, it does not look like a city park.

0:13:26 Yeah, I think some signage are especially around those ponds, Mike.

0:13:30 I think some folks are going down there and saying, wow, look at all the ducks.

0:13:35 This is a great place to hunt because when I was there,

0:13:38 there were probably 40 or 50 ducks in that pond.

0:13:41 It's a good sanctuary, but it's good to say.

0:13:44 It is. So yeah, maybe we do need to put some signs down there as well,

0:13:48 but those people that use the park a lot,

0:13:52 I just let them know that you know,

0:13:53 definitely make a phone call because either Fish and Game or Twin Falls Police Department

0:13:59 can respond down there if there's somebody down there violating those hunting rules.

0:14:04 I just think maybe some education for us as well. And lastly, the last thing I really wanted

0:14:11 to bring up is dogs down there in the park. You know, there's 600 acres and literally

0:14:17 there are 15 or so vehicles and I had to go out of my way to even come in contact with

0:14:23 with another human being, that seems to me to be such a great location, take your dogs

0:14:28 so that they can run off leech. And I know right now, we only are able to do that in certain

0:14:33 parks, so I just wanted to present that to the council and to you, Wendy, is there some

0:14:38 flexibility in that area?

0:14:41 Because I can guarantee you people are not using their leash down there, and I may be halfway

0:14:45 guilty there, I guess.

0:14:49 I think that that's a great thing to look into. I think that that would be a good spot to

0:14:54 to do that after we talked, I got to thinking about a little bit.

0:14:57 And I would probably want to talk to the mountain bikers

0:15:01 a little bit to see what the concerns might be.

0:15:07 Because you know, a loose dog on someone on a bike

0:15:09 sometimes is not a good mix.

0:15:11 And so I think we need to kind of look at the uses down there

0:15:13 in places and maybe we can identify some areas.

0:15:15 But I would certainly be happy to look into what it would take

0:15:22 to maybe either make all of that park or parts of that park

0:15:25 off-leash area, I think that it's a good place for dogs to run around.

0:15:30 And I'd recommend that would be a good topic to send to the Parks and Rec Commission to explore and get some input

0:15:40 and have some public conversation about it.

0:15:43 I might even be some people here tonight that might approve them.

0:15:46 Maybe Travis, did you have a comment to add to that?

0:15:49 I would just think that when you're looking at modifying a current use that you involve

0:15:55 maybe all of the potential other groups that could be adversely impacted.

0:16:01 As someone who cycles, I will tell you that the worst you scared you're more afraid of

0:16:07 dogs than you are cars because it's more unpredictable and I think that one of the things

0:16:14 that celebrated about Auger Falls that is absolutely world-class mountain biking facility

0:16:20 that we have in our area.

0:16:23 And I would want to make sure that both uses would be compatible and not favoring one over

0:16:28 the other, but making sure that there is a balance that can be struck and all parties would be

0:16:33 involved in that conversation.

0:16:35 So if you move this to Parks and Rec, you may want to also make sure that it's done at a

0:16:39 the time where the public can engage in the conversation.

0:16:43 Noon meetings can be difficult, so you might have to go outside of that, do an advertised

0:16:47 public hearing and make sure that the public has great opportunities to participate in

0:16:53 the conversation.

0:16:54 I would agree with that, but one of my philosophies of that area is it's a mixed-use area and

0:17:01 there are competing entities that would like to use it, and with 600 plus acres I'm sure

0:17:07 we can make figure this out.

0:17:09 But I agree, we should have some public input.

0:17:12 Thank you, Suzanne Hawkins.

0:17:13 Thank you, Wendy, before you go.

0:17:14 While we're talking about dogs and parks, I've been to the first fed park a few times

0:17:19 when animals have been off leash on that turf doing their business, and I don't know how

0:17:24 we're keeping that clean or what we can do about that, but that park does not need dogs

0:17:30 in it at all, and every time I'm there, I have seen dogs out on that turf.

0:17:37 I don't know, I just thought I'd throw that one out there.

0:17:43 Thank you.

0:17:44 Yeah, that's always a tough one because the ordinance, you know,

0:17:50 and we have signs that say the dogs must be on leash, but again,

0:17:54 I think it certainly is a city ordinance and we could call,

0:17:58 but as you know, that's not generally the response and then you get the messes

0:18:03 and then on artificial turf is a little more.

0:18:07 That's why I don't know if maybe the park commission could take on maybe actually no

0:18:11 dogs at that park for that reason, just because that artificial turf is not pet and child friendly

0:18:17 together.

0:18:18 I don't know, just a thought.

0:18:23 Anything else?

0:18:25 All right.

0:18:27 Thank you, Wendy.

0:18:30 The next item on the agenda is consideration of request to appoint Aaron Camacho, Cindy Collins,

0:18:36 and Gabe Austin to the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:18:39 So we had three openings due to the three members who we just recognized completing their

0:18:45 service on the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:18:48 We had several applications for the positions due the end of January.

0:18:53 An interview committee consisting of myself, Parks and Recreation Commission liaison Nikki

0:18:58 Boyd, Vice Chairman of the Commission, Mark Lambert, because our commission chair was leaving

0:19:04 to Neil and Parks and Recreation Director Wendy Davis conducted interviews on February 22nd.

0:19:11 We interviewed five applicants and at the conclusion of our discussion we would recommend

0:19:19 selection of Aaron Camacho, Cindy Collins and Gabe Austin to serve on the Parks and Recreation

0:19:24 Commission.

0:19:25 All three of those candidates did successfully pass their local background check and I believe

0:19:31 candidates are here this evening if anyone had any questions for them otherwise that

0:19:36 would be my recommendation and that requires council concurrence. Ruth Pierce.

0:19:41 I move we approve the appointment of the three candidates to the parks and

0:19:47 recreation committee. The motion by Ruth Pierce seconded by Greg

0:19:55 Lanting to approve those appointments. Sorry further discussion from the council.

0:20:00 Seeing none, Sharon Roll call vote please.

0:20:05 Nicky Boyd, yes.

0:20:07 Sean Berger, yes.

0:20:08 Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, yes.

0:20:11 Don Hall, yes.

0:20:13 Ruth Pierce, yes.

0:20:14 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.

0:20:16 Motion passes, 7-0.

0:20:19 Speech.

0:20:21 If our candidates would like to come forward and

0:20:24 just give a brief introduction and say a few words,

0:20:26 that would be great, Cindy Collins.

0:20:28 Well, I can see this is going to be a very exciting committee.

0:20:33 I have lots to think about when I go home tonight, but I am thrilled to be part of this commission.

0:20:40 I'm very interested in our parks and the health and fitness of our community.

0:20:46 And I work with a lot of new families like Nicky does, and that's one of the things we

0:20:50 always do.

0:20:51 We drive them through the parks to show them what our community has to offer.

0:20:55 So I'm really looking forward to this, and I'd like to thank you all for the appointment.

0:21:00 Thank you, Cindy.

0:21:02 Gabe.

0:21:03 My name is Gabe Austin, and thank you very much for the appointment.

0:21:14 Growing up here, I have two little boys that use the parks

0:21:17 and are in the recreation system.

0:21:19 Conversation about agar falls is very pertinent as well.

0:21:22 So I concur with everybody, what everybody's saying there,

0:21:25 but what a great, great park it is.

0:21:28 I'm just really glad to be a part of this.

0:21:31 Thank you very much.

0:21:32 Thank you.

0:21:33 And Eric.

0:21:42 I'm also very excited to be here, and thank you for the appointment.

0:21:46 I mean, those plaques look pretty neat.

0:21:48 So, I mean, I'm looking forward to those.

0:21:52 Really excited to be able to serve

0:21:53 my community in the Parks and Recreation Commission

0:21:56 and to be able to help further grow the opportunities

0:21:59 that are here in Twin Falls, so thank you.

0:22:01 All right, thanks to each of you for agreeing

0:22:04 to serve your community.

0:22:06 Welcome to the commission.

0:22:10 The next item on the agenda is consideration of a request

0:22:14 to approve the timing on street and utility construction

0:22:18 for the Sunway conveyance plant.

0:22:21 We have Renee, there she is,

0:22:26 Renee Caraway Johnson.

0:22:28 Welcome Renee.

0:22:29 We're hiding out back there, I could see you.

0:22:31 Yes, I was just watching.

0:22:33 It's very interesting when you sit in the back.

0:22:40 I'm here this evening actually representing

0:22:42 the Twin Falls School District.

0:22:46 We have the school district a couple of years ago

0:22:51 or a year ago or so, processed a conveyance plant that consists of two lots.

0:23:02 I outlined it and highlighted the street names the best I could so you can see them, but this

0:23:06 is lot one and lot two.

0:23:09 This is a separate parcel.

0:23:12 With a conveyance plant, that basically allows you to subdivide a piece of ground into two

0:23:19 parcels, it is not used for development that's used to allow you to change ownership.

0:23:26 We recently received a subdivision plat of lot one of the conveyance plat. Within our code,

0:23:41 it states that when a conveyance plat is brought in for development, either of those two lots

0:23:47 triggers full development of the perimeter of a committed splat. So the streets and the

0:23:53 other utility development and that is pretty substantial on this property. In December, the

0:24:02 council approved a deferral on this lot, this lot one, all the way around lot one, but unfortunately

0:24:11 there wasn't a process to go through a deferral of lot two because the school district, it

0:24:18 wasn't owned, they didn't want to bring it through. So anyway, I'm here today to ask

0:24:23 for basically a deferral of those site improvements on lot two because this lot is coming through

0:24:32 for a plating process. The lot is big enough and is intended for residential development

0:24:40 At the time that law is developed,

0:24:42 there will be street and utility improvements

0:24:46 made are built through that process.

0:24:48 So again, I'm representing the school district in this.

0:24:52 If this is approved tonight,

0:24:54 it will allow this plat to go forward

0:24:57 through the development process.

0:24:58 It will come through for preliminary plat

0:25:00 through the commission and then a final plat to you.

0:25:03 So we're asking that you grant them a waiver

0:25:08 basically on their site improvements on the perimeter of

0:25:12 what you.

0:25:12 Chris talking to also move second motion by Chris

0:25:23 talking to seconded by Suzanne was that you yeah second

0:25:27 advice Suzanne Hawkins to grant a waiver for the

0:25:32 development of the perimeter improvements of lot two yes

0:25:39 Thank you.

0:25:40 Is there any discussion from the council?

0:25:46 Seeing none, Sharon roll call vote please.

0:25:48 Sean Bericher?

0:25:49 Yes.

0:25:50 Chris Tockington?

0:25:51 Yes.

0:25:52 Greg Lanthine?

0:25:53 Yes.

0:25:54 Don Hall?

0:25:55 Yes.

0:25:56 Ruth Pierce?

0:25:57 Yes.

0:25:58 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:25:59 Yes.

0:26:00 Nicki Boyd?

0:26:01 Yes.

0:26:02 Motion passes 7-2-0.

0:26:04 Thank you very much.

0:26:06 Thank your name.

0:26:07 Next we have a presentation on sidewalks that will include a high level update on the existing

0:26:10 sidewalk condition, potential cost impacts, and potential opportunities.

0:26:14 We have our Public Works Director, John Caten. John, before you get started with that item,

0:26:20 could you give us a brief update on the water situation from Friday, if you would please?

0:26:26 You've got good evening, Mayor and Council. Thanks for having me.

0:26:30 Last, let's see, it was Friday.

0:26:34 Friday. We had an issue on North College with the waterline, as you're very aware, and we

0:26:43 worked with the contractor as fast as we could to repair it. And as you know, we had an advisory

0:26:51 boil order, which is a precautionary action. We didn't have any testing to demonstrate we

0:26:58 had any contamination, but we had to expose ourselves to risk. And the rules are there

0:27:03 for good reason and we followed them and we provided the notification

0:27:07 best we could. We're going to have a, I like to call it an after-action review on

0:27:12 Wednesday's internal. We're going to go through all the parties involved and try

0:27:16 to develop lessons learned and see if we can improve our response or avoid this in

0:27:21 the future. So I'm feeling good about where we're at, considering it felt like

0:27:27 we dodged a bullet. So any questions?

0:27:30 I want to say thank you to you and your crews for getting out there and addressing that.

0:27:34 I know it was probably not a whole lot of fun being, that the pictures made it look like it was pretty nasty out there.

0:27:40 So, appreciate all that you did to address that.

0:27:43 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:27:44 Thank you.

0:27:45 I'm not sure if this is for you, John, or I'm not sure where it goes.

0:27:48 It seems like about a year ago we upgraded our software so

0:27:52 when we send out text messages or alerts that not only would it hit local residents,

0:27:58 anybody within our city limits and just because I happen to have 32 people at my

0:28:04 house that morning waiting for showers and everything going on none of my out-of-town

0:28:11 visitors got the alert and so I was just curious. Right and actually I had a very

0:28:15 the same conversation with with Councilman Lanting so Josh is here and he can

0:28:22 give me the thumbs up give you the thumbs up if I get it right so there's a

0:28:25 A couple of different modules, if you will, the way I understand it.

0:28:29 One is a geographic base, and we'll actually pinpoint in a geographic area all of the addresses

0:28:36 who have registered with us that are in that impacted area.

0:28:41 So we draw a map on the GIS system, and all of the people who have registered who have

0:28:46 accounts in that area will be notified.

0:28:50 The second placement is kind of like an amber alert system, where we can do an entire system-wide

0:28:57 type notification.

0:28:58 And so there's like the two different types of notification, the one that we used here

0:29:02 was more geographically based, and you have to register to be able to use that kind of

0:29:09 right.

0:29:10 Kind of right.

0:29:11 He did this.

0:29:12 I shouldn't just let Josh do something.

0:29:15 He did really good travels.

0:29:18 I think we had about 300 or something, which was a small one out, who subscribed to that

0:29:38 service will get the text and voice amounts of their cell phones.

0:29:42 We do have the ability under certain circumstances to you to pause, which is the cell tower override,

0:29:51 which goes far and wide, you don't really be on the city to unfall to a lot of our outlying

0:29:55 communities.

0:29:56 But that's really for only life safety emergencies that qualify under, I think it's homeland

0:30:02 security and some other organizations that say that's what you can use it.

0:30:07 So we did reach, it was about 16,500 people, those were landlines and subscribers, and

0:30:19 he got out very quickly.

0:30:21 I will say on the back end though, we'll be evaluating how we respond to people who do

0:30:25 call in with questions, because when that went out, we were quickly pre-overloaded.

0:30:31 16,000 people or phone connections.

0:30:35 So connections, well, that's a lot of people.

0:30:39 Yeah, it was, yeah, it was.

0:30:43 Chris Stockington?

0:30:45 Well, I just have a question concerning the water break.

0:30:48 I think it's been, kind of what we described

0:30:50 as an operator error, and will the bonding

0:30:53 or the company pay directly for reimbursing of the,

0:30:57 not only the material, but any labor,

0:30:59 how do we figure the damage is something in this nature?

0:31:04 So thank you.

0:31:05 You know, right in the middle of that,

0:31:08 the potential risk and my ability, in my opinion,

0:31:12 at this point from what we can measure is very small.

0:31:15 And, you know, there's some things,

0:31:19 you know, there's a sweat plan in place

0:31:21 to prevent discharge into the canal

0:31:23 and things like that, well, that breached.

0:31:25 And that has been reported to the EPA.

0:31:27 And I don't expect EPA to take a drastic measure,

0:31:31 but you never know.

0:31:33 So barring that situation, the risk is very low to the city.

0:31:39 I would say less than $5,000.

0:31:42 What we did on Friday was important to me

0:31:46 to quickly resolve the problem and collaborate

0:31:49 with the contractor and just power through to a solution.

0:31:52 We met this morning and talked about, OK,

0:31:54 where are we at today?

0:31:55 What's it take to get the project back on track?

0:31:57 what your damage is and I was very comfortable.

0:32:00 They're very preliminary conversations,

0:32:02 but I'm very comfortable with where we're at

0:32:05 in our potential exposure.

0:32:07 I haven't even had a chance really to update Travis yet on that.

0:32:10 But like I said, it's very preliminary

0:32:12 and we're right in the middle of that.

0:32:14 We kind of let us know the completion of this discussion.

0:32:17 Ideally, I'll tell Travis first.

0:32:19 Yeah, just let us know through email,

0:32:22 through Travis.

0:32:24 Thank you.

0:32:25 Don't ask.

0:32:26 So just to be perfectly clear, we have no liability associated with this, according to

0:32:35 Fritz.

0:32:36 And then the cost, I've asked John and his team to account for the man hour costs for

0:32:43 the time that we spent in any additional time and labor materials that we've expanded in

0:32:50 assistance because this is not a city-caused issue.

0:32:55 So I think John and his team are doing that.

0:32:59 Thank you, Don Hall.

0:33:00 So I have another question for Josh,

0:33:01 but while he's walking up, is there a possibility,

0:33:05 I'm assuming you took pictures as you did some of this repair

0:33:08 and the like, could you bring that back to council?

0:33:10 I'd be real curious exactly what happened,

0:33:13 what size line, I guess it was a 30-inch?

0:33:15 20.

0:33:16 20-inch, and apparently there's a lot of water

0:33:18 that can go through a 20-inch line from what I understand.

0:33:21 I'd just be kind of curious exactly what happened

0:33:23 and pitchers and those kind of things.

0:33:27 Josh, I guess I just need to drill down a little bit further

0:33:30 about what you said so that I understand.

0:33:32 I know that we had this conversation before

0:33:34 when we had some issues with potential boil notices

0:33:39 and the like.

0:33:40 Is this like a reverse 911 kind of a situation

0:33:45 and it was more geographic and walk me through it again?

0:33:48 Okay, it's similar to a reverse 911.

0:33:52 What we have is a dashboard that we have in our computers

0:33:56 that allows us to literally draw a boundary around where we

0:34:00 want to send this notice out.

0:34:02 So in the process we have, we work with Rob Bulling,

0:34:05 and then JUV Engineering as they

0:34:07 ran through scenarios about how large of an area we might

0:34:10 need to send this out to.

0:34:12 We draw that area, and we send it out,

0:34:13 and it goes out to those folks with landlines.

0:34:16 Within landlines.

0:34:18 It also goes out to, when you register,

0:34:22 you can sign up your cell phone, your personal cell phone,

0:34:26 and you give your address.

0:34:28 And then if your address is within those boundaries,

0:34:30 your cell phone will also receive it.

0:34:32 So if we don't register, but we live within those boundaries,

0:34:36 and my home is just cell phone based now,

0:34:41 we have no landlines, how do we address that?

0:34:43 If I happen to be registered, I got it twice,

0:34:46 as I work at CSI and I've got rave alerts as well as the city.

0:34:50 But what about those folks that aren't registered?

0:34:53 And that's the challenge we face.

0:34:55 We have to get people to register for it.

0:34:58 We did a push, we'll have to be a series of repeated pushes

0:35:02 every year to make sure that people subscribe for it,

0:35:06 as well as going through those lists because people do leave.

0:35:09 And they can easily unsubscribe.

0:35:11 But that's one of those communications or something

0:35:15 we need to communicate to the community is that is where we need them to register and

0:35:20 subscribe for these emergency notifications.

0:35:23 We had, we put out some literature, we ran some PSAs, we did some commercial spots with

0:35:28 KMT and the Fox 14 and Cable 1, but since then we haven't really done much sense, so.

0:35:36 So with landlines we can automatically do a geographic area, but we can't do that with

0:35:42 cell phones, even though they live within that geographic area. There's no mechanism

0:35:46 for that, would you?

0:35:48 There's no well, yeah, there's no mechanism for that, with the exception of that cell

0:35:52 tower over right. But in that case, you're not just looking at Twin Falls, you're looking

0:35:57 at South Central Idaho, I think, all the way to Mountain Home, and I don't know how far

0:36:04 east.

0:36:05 I think as we discussed the last time we had a situation where we were trying to figure

0:36:08 to communicate that the challenge in 2016 is there are about 8,000 channels of

0:36:14 places where people get information and it's challenging. It's difficult. We have a

0:36:20 limited staff and limited resources and it's we can live with our community

0:36:26 partners. We worked with the call them as you know the college the school

0:36:30 district and the hospital their communication staff sent out through

0:36:33 their means to students at Canyon Ridge schools that were affected by

0:36:38 it. We can work together as a community to really get that message out there beyond our

0:36:44 own. The means that we have as an organization.

0:36:48 So it would be safe to say we learn from each one of these and we get better each time.

0:36:52 We do. Thank you.

0:36:54 Ritpers.

0:36:55 Well, so I just went on to the website because I'm not registered and the only reason I found

0:37:00 out was KMBT and I did brush my teeth when there was still a boil order. I forgot. Is that

0:37:07 I'm fine. Is that the can alert notification?

0:37:11 Yeah, if you go to the website and it says emergency services or emergency notifications, okay.

0:37:18 The emergency alert. We had that. It takes you to the circum registration site. Okay.

0:37:23 Okay. I think it's good for everybody out there at home to know. Thank you.

0:37:28 Greg Lantig. Oh, I'm sorry. Travis. Sorry.

0:37:32 So, I think it's important to recognize that we weren't under an official boil order.

0:37:40 And however it may have been portrayed, this was advisory.

0:37:46 And the language that's provided to us is really provided, it's a very simple fill in

0:37:51 the blank and there's not a lot of discretion that we have in moving forward.

0:37:57 We're aware of some conversations with some local businesses that made the decision to

0:38:03 shut down on Friday nights, not to offer services, and again, what we were saying is that this

0:38:10 is a precautionary order until we get through the process.

0:38:15 But I think it's really important to recognize that it might sound insignificant, but there

0:38:21 is a difference between a full-fledged boil order and the impacts of what that would

0:38:25 of meant for our community in John's team.

0:38:28 To give you an idea, we wouldn't be doing

0:38:30 sidewalk conversations tonight.

0:38:32 If we had a full boil order, and in addition to that,

0:38:35 I think it's important that we continue to work

0:38:38 with the members of our media to ensure

0:38:41 that the actual happenings of the event

0:38:44 are being communicated as close and accurately as possible,

0:38:49 as well as our other partners.

0:38:52 Because like Sean is saying, all of the different 8,000 of

0:38:56 conduits of information, you're probably going to get some

0:38:58 significant or variation of the answer, which could really

0:39:03 impact people's decisions in moving forward.

0:39:06 Great landing.

0:39:07 Well, mine's along the same line.

0:39:09 I'll be quick.

0:39:10 At least you got me signed up.

0:39:11 I wasn't signed up previously.

0:39:12 And now I am because I was, because I had the same impression

0:39:16 that Suzanne had on the AMBO or thing that we could just

0:39:20 push them out.

0:39:20 I didn't realize that there had to be a more severe situation beforehand and I

0:39:25 thought it was interesting some of the restaurants outside of the advisory area

0:39:29 were actually advertising on Facebook. They were outside of the advisory company here, so.

0:39:35 Mark, can you not please me?

0:39:38 So John, thank you for letting us hijack your agenda item there for a moment.

0:39:46 I appreciate the information, so we'll we'll jump back to the actual agenda item

0:39:50 dealing with sidewalks.

0:39:53 Thank you, Mayor.

0:39:55 Last year, Council requested during the budget process,

0:39:58 Council asked for more information and an update on sidewalks.

0:40:05 And so that's why I'm here tonight.

0:40:06 And so I'd like to provide some history from background

0:40:10 and on sidewalks and also talk about some hurdles and costs

0:40:15 associated with with sidewalks.

0:40:18 And then also because sidewalks are important,

0:40:21 talk about what we're doing about it now

0:40:22 on and in the future.

0:40:25 So let's begin with the city code, which we've had.

0:40:39 So this is the city code, and I'll read it here in a second,

0:40:41 but we've been operating under this paradigm

0:40:43 for over 50 years, and really the city code says,

0:40:47 sidewalks, curbs, and driveway approaches.

0:40:50 Property owner responsibility, sidewalks, curbs,

0:40:53 and driveway approaches shall be constructed

0:40:54 and repaired by the owners of the property

0:40:56 adjoining the location of the work at their expense.

0:41:01 skipped out the city engineers here by authorized and directed to inspect all

0:41:05 such work and to obtain compliance with this code.

0:41:09 So this is not an uncommon approach for cities to take

0:41:14 to have property owners maintain their sidewalks. In fact, there's an example later

0:41:19 that I'll reference that we can look at. One of the

0:41:23 problems is property owners don't always know this.

0:41:26 And even if they did know it, sometimes they can't

0:41:29 afford to do this. So, over time, you know, sidewalks have degraded and also the city has

0:41:37 developed in some areas prior to newer codes have developed neighborhoods with sidewalks,

0:41:44 with outside walks, some with curb and gutter, some without, you got everything. And so it's

0:41:50 progressive to what we have today. And engineering took a look at what we do have and they came

0:41:57 up with a rudimentary estimate that's designed to help us understand the problem and the

0:42:03 budget implication. It's a big problem. There's a lot out there without Sidewalk and there's

0:42:10 a lot of Sidewalk out there that's not in good conditions. So what they did is they used

0:42:19 our aerial to evaluate Sidewalk throughout the city. They went block by block and they

0:42:26 They were looking really for two things.

0:42:27 They were looking for is there sidewalk or no sidewalk?

0:42:30 And then from what they could tell from the area,

0:42:32 they were looking at can they tell if it's

0:42:34 in good condition or not?

0:42:36 So as you can guess, you can only tell so much

0:42:39 about condition from an area.

0:42:41 So that part of the estimate is going to be conservative.

0:42:44 It's going to be difficult.

0:42:45 But it pales in comparison to the volume of sidewalk

0:42:50 that isn't there, which exceeds 1.2 million

0:42:53 lineal feet of sidewalk. And the repair required that could be easily seen from the aerial was

0:43:05 80,000 lineal feet. So in other words, it's like 250 miles of sidewalk. It's a lot. So

0:43:12 again, we've been under this paradigm for 50 years. It's not uncommon. It's but it is

0:43:19 something that we're going to try to work through and we're not going to get there overnight.

0:43:24 Engineering also had several assumptions and caveats and I don't want to get into the weeds

0:43:30 of their estimate tonight unless Council would like me to.

0:43:33 But because later I'm going to show that when you compare their estimate to what we actually

0:43:40 experienced last year, you'll see that they're actually, their costs and their approach is

0:43:45 very conservative.

0:43:46 Meaning it's low, it's potentially a greater cost.

0:43:50 And the overall cost, if we were to fix and fix all the sidewalk and put sidewalk down

0:43:55 both sides of the street in the whole city, we're talking $49 plus million.

0:44:01 And that number is low.

0:44:03 It doesn't include inflation, contingency.

0:44:07 It doesn't include the removal of obstructions like trees, which is like the primary reason

0:44:12 sidewalks have issues.

0:44:15 And so, and also the several other things.

0:44:18 So again, moving past their estimate, we have an example of a project that we did this

0:44:25 year.

0:44:26 I'm going to go through it in detail.

0:44:29 And later this year when we do the roadshow, I'll touch on it a little bit more.

0:44:33 But there's a picture of the area of, we called it Third Avenue West, and it's a project.

0:44:49 This is Addison in Washington here.

0:44:52 And Third Avenue West, west of Washington right here.

0:44:55 There's also a DMX part right here if you recall.

0:44:59 And this area, we reconstructed the whole,

0:45:03 it was a good project because not only did we improve

0:45:07 the water main and add by our hydrants,

0:45:09 we reconstructed the whole road,

0:45:12 and we added 1,200 feet of stormwater,

0:45:15 1,200 feet of sidewalk, several EDA ramps.

0:45:25 And it's a little bit harder to see where third is there.

0:45:35 But I had to zoom out so far because I wanted to point out, when you go into a street that

0:45:43 looks like this, it has no curb and gutter, no sidewalk, and the city's water is going

0:45:50 on to property and causing problems, we have to deal with it.

0:45:54 It doesn't mean you just put curb and gutter on the street and put that water somewhere.

0:45:59 You have to look at the whole basin and if you zoom out again, please.

0:46:08 A lot of the storm water is coming from areas that are all the way down here and come all

0:46:14 the way up and down third.

0:46:17 I don't have all of the area that contributes to that storm water.

0:46:24 When we think about doing curb and gutter in sidewalk, it's more than just, I don't

0:46:29 have a curb and gutter, let's put some in, because you're going to impound water, you're

0:46:34 going to affect how storm water flows, and you can't just do that, you have to think

0:46:38 think about and you have to design it.

0:46:42 So let's talk about a couple of costs in this project.

0:46:47 1,200 feet of sidewalk was $27,000, peer-driven gutter on both sides was $69,000 and the storm

0:46:58 was $100,000 to deal with.

0:47:01 So you can tell where the cost of this project is.

0:47:03 It's approximately $230,000 improvement.

0:47:09 When I took line item break down and compared it to engineering's estimate, this verified

0:47:16 that they're on track and I wouldn't want them to ever underestimate a problem.

0:47:22 They're on track and not overestimating it either, but actually, yeah, they're conservative

0:47:31 and their estimates are slightly lower than what we experienced.

0:47:35 John, we have a couple of questions if that's right, Don Hall?

0:47:41 One thing, John, we've got a couple questions, but I just happened and I didn't do it on purpose.

0:47:45 I drove this road today because we were looking in that neighborhood.

0:47:49 And this is an exact location that I think that we need to be working on.

0:47:54 It's a neighborhood that's been there for a lot of years.

0:47:57 Some of the homes are, they're older properties and maybe not the most affluent area.

0:48:04 And I think it really has added to quality of life for these folks.

0:48:10 So again, I think they didn't have any way to get up and down the road other than the road.

0:48:16 And somebody that maybe has a limited mobility, this is a tough neighborhood.

0:48:21 So I really applaud what we've done here, but here's my question.

0:48:24 Why did we pick this?

0:48:27 Remind us why we picked this neighborhood, this street to make these improvements.

0:48:31 It's really a priority of our zone maintenance program.

0:48:34 So when we looked at this zone, this is our zone three, we try to go for

0:48:40 the biggest, you know, the biggest and most effective project we can in the zone.

0:48:45 So this was a great opportunity because not only did it have undersized water lines there

0:48:50 with substandard flow and pressure, it also had a stormwater issue.

0:48:54 And you can see this house right here.

0:48:56 Many of these houses get flooded out and crack there's street department personnel that have

0:49:00 spent Christmas Eve dealing with, you know, people who have a major problem.

0:49:06 And so it was not only, you know, so for all those reasons and the roadway needed an improved,

0:49:11 there's no sidewalk, there's no access, there's a park.

0:49:14 It was just a really good opportunity in that zone.

0:49:17 And really we're trying to do is in each zone, kind of grab that spot that's kind of win-win

0:49:23 throughout.

0:49:24 Give the biggest bang for the buck that you're going to put in that neighborhood.

0:49:27 We were able to do streets, water, sewer, storm water, connectivity to a park, it was a good project.

0:49:33 And I'm looking forward to actually in the road show showing you some before and after because like you said it's kind of it's kind of neat to see that it is thank you for after okay Nicky Boyd did you say on the when you listed the the numbers it came out to a total of 230,000 was that for 1,200 lineal feet of sidewalk curb and gutter what was that for that was for 1200 okay so let me explain we did curb and gutter on both sides and sidewalk on one side.

0:50:03 Okay, so we had 2,400 lineal feet of carbon gutter and 1,200 feet of side water.

0:50:10 Got it, thanks.

0:50:11 Actually, that's a great segue, because, is there other questions?

0:50:15 No.

0:50:16 Okay.

0:50:17 When it comes to ADA requirements, you know, if you do a roadway improvement, you really

0:50:22 need to make sure that there's an accessible route.

0:50:26 It doesn't necessarily mean you have to have it on both sides of the roadway.

0:50:30 In fact, I didn't mention that when the engineering provided investment for both sides,

0:50:37 you could immediately, if we decided to go this route, cut that in half and say, in

0:50:41 order to meet ADA standards, you could go $24,000,000,000,000, then again, you've got

0:50:48 to look at connectivity.

0:50:49 Going on one side of the street might not get you, you know, all the parks that you

0:50:53 want.

0:50:54 So, when we do projects, we look at cost, and we look at, connect, ADA, and so on,

0:50:59 This one we decided to do one side of the road for cost reasons.

0:51:03 And right away, actually, it was so now that we couldn't get any more sidewalk.

0:51:06 Chris talking to me.

0:51:07 A little bit of history, Don.

0:51:09 At one time, we had a senior center down on Rock Creek at the end of either third or second

0:51:14 or fourth.

0:51:15 And before the turn of the century, we were actually talking about a kind of an LID urban

0:51:21 renewal because of the need to be pointed out.

0:51:24 And I think our eyes were bigger than our stomach or something.

0:51:27 It didn't have the means, financial means to do it.

0:51:30 So it's been on the focus for 30 or 40 years,

0:51:36 and nothing's been accomplished.

0:51:38 And the people have borne the cost of that

0:51:40 through a degraded condition.

0:51:44 Thank you.

0:51:46 OK.

0:51:48 So we talked about what it costs to get

0:51:51 sidewalked in some locations.

0:51:53 And so here's some other hurdles and areas to think

0:51:57 about and some concerns.

0:51:59 Again, design of stormwater, curb and gutter.

0:52:03 Also, like engineering looked at, there's sidewalks out there

0:52:10 that are existing that are just in poor condition.

0:52:14 And so those are ideal candidates.

0:52:16 If there's curb and gutter there, those are ideal candidates.

0:52:19 Those are easier to replace without engineering

0:52:22 because you have an elevation you can match.

0:52:24 You can match.

0:52:25 And through a permitting process of a homeowner

0:52:27 wanted to do it, they wanted to make sure they're in compliance, you always have to go through

0:52:30 the permit process. Other things to think about, you know, if we're actually doing

0:52:42 me, let me jump down to what we're currently doing. Again, this is zone maintenance projects

0:52:49 like Third Avenue each year, we try to do that, and we don't do as much sidewalk every

0:52:53 year, but in some years we're going to do that. Again, we have overlays each year and any time

0:52:59 you have an overlay, you have to address ADA ramps. The street has $25,000 a year in their

0:53:09 budget for ADA ramps. Engineering also has $25,000 for special requests. A lot of times

0:53:16 we'll get folks who are habitually trying to get to a certain location on a certain route

0:53:22 and it's really difficult for them so we try to accommodate them in accordance with our

0:53:26 ADA transition plan. So each year they have $25,000. Also we're making good progress. Engineering

0:53:33 has submitted and been awarded two years in a row a state grant to improve ADA ramps

0:53:41 along state highway and you've seen some here recently along Addison last year we had some

0:53:46 long blue lakes and that's $60,000 each year spent two years in a row and our only obligation

0:53:54 is to manage the contracts, so it takes some time.

0:54:02 What else are we currently doing?

0:54:03 All new residential subdivisions, as you know,

0:54:06 require sidewalks.

0:54:07 New building permits require sidewalks.

0:54:10 For the most part, they're manufacturing zone.

0:54:13 Doesn't in certain situations require sidewalks.

0:54:18 When there's a material, they do.

0:54:21 And then I wanted to talk about our TransMap analysis.

0:54:27 I've talked a little bit about how we've had the streets driven by that Google vehicle

0:54:32 that measured just about everything on the street, it's measured the condition, it's measured

0:54:38 the quantity of sidewalk and they've used laser and radar to do all this and the information

0:54:46 is in development.

0:54:47 We're going to get that this year and what I'm looking forward to is it's really going

0:54:50 to help refine, go from a rudimentary estimate of what the issue is to a much more accurate

0:54:57 accurate estimate that we can take and use as a tool to develop the Master Transportation

0:55:05 Plan.

0:55:06 That's the other thing we're doing is, in this upcoming year, we're going to begin the Master

0:55:12 Transportation Plan, where we're going to talk about multi-mobile transportation, including

0:55:19 sidewalks.

0:55:20 It'll be important in the Master Transportation Plan to look at the problem.

0:55:28 to help develop priorities and, you know, it's important to remember that the general fund will

0:55:36 be paying for sidewalks.

0:55:41 And so, you know, we have the long-term planning committee.

0:55:43 That's a great place for this kind of stuff to go through and compete in accordance with

0:55:49 the Strategic Planning Council initiatives.

0:55:51 But like I said, this is the general fund, so there's lots of competing things.

0:55:56 The other thing to consider is balancing the overall street maintenance without compromising

0:56:04 other necessary.

0:56:05 So, there's only so much money and we can do some on sidewalks, but anything we take from

0:56:11 one spot and do it another, there's going to be a balance there.

0:56:15 John, Greg Lanting has it.

0:56:19 Yes.

0:56:20 Well, it's kind of, it's right along with where you're at right now.

0:56:22 talking funding sources up as you drive along the mid area of

0:56:28 blue lakes which I think has a designation of highway 93

0:56:31 alternate or something along other there from south from North

0:56:38 five points and North five points. Hey, and we did there was

0:56:43 some curb work there's some ADA work that was that was recently

0:56:47 getting finished there maybe even this winter it seems like

0:56:50 But if you get a little farther south, all of a sudden, there's no curbs, there's no sidewalks, there's no anything.

0:56:56 Since that's a state highway, is there any, besides the 60,000 of the ADA, is there any funding source there,

0:57:03 that since we're on a state highway that they might help us to put at least curb and gutter in, if not sidewalk as well?

0:57:10 You know, they're cut, they're south of, yeah.

0:57:16 You're talking about south of the railroad tracks?

0:57:19 Actually, no, there's quite an x-section there between the two

0:57:22 five points between east and north five points.

0:57:25 There's sections that have no curb and got our or sidewalk

0:57:29 into what?

0:57:29 Round third and fourth.

0:57:31 Yeah, well, down there, I didn't cancel an Idaho side

0:57:34 walks, you know, that's connection bullets.

0:57:36 But you get on farther down there.

0:57:38 They didn't do any ADA work because there's no sidewalks.

0:57:40 Yeah.

0:57:40 And no curb either.

0:57:42 If it's a state route that's all eligible,

0:57:44 and they're kind of in the same boat, I mean, we could actually

0:57:49 The really neat thing about their $60,000 program is we can help pick good locations

0:57:57 for ramps.

0:57:58 So some of them are great candidates and some of them, you know, it's going to take

0:58:04 some time to get there because that's only $60,000.

0:58:07 But beyond their $60,000, there's not another pool of money that's along.

0:58:10 If there is, I'm not aware of it.

0:58:12 Okay.

0:58:13 Around state routes.

0:58:14 I just think about that because it has a designation of a state highway, but it kind

0:58:18 It's like city street slash county road, you know, areas along there.

0:58:24 So that county road, highway district road, where our county road, highway district roads.

0:58:30 Okay.

0:58:33 Okay.

0:58:34 I want to just share an example.

0:58:37 So I kind of went over, kind of quickly went over a lot of the things we're doing right

0:58:40 now.

0:58:41 Are there any questions on what we're doing today with sidewalks and 88 ramps?

0:58:45 So we've got a $25 million problem, and we're spending like $230,000 a year, so we're like

0:58:52 on a 1,000 year plan.

0:58:54 I don't mean to make light of it, but it's a drop in the bucket, and I recognize that.

0:59:02 But we need to progress in a good, logical way, and part of that, a really important

0:59:08 part will be to do it in the master transportation plan, develop priorities, and go that way.

0:59:14 One of the things I'd like to propose to the long-term plan and let it go forward to the

0:59:19 group that's meeting now is a sidewalk repair grant program that we might fund, that the

0:59:26 city could fund, and potentially it would be for the repair of existing sidewalk.

0:59:35 The reason I think that, well, so the city of Oregon, Beaverton, Oregon, has a sidewalk

0:59:53 replacement program. I mean, they're facing the same thing we are. They can't fix

0:59:57 everything, really difficult to fix or install a sidewalk that isn't existing

1:00:04 because it involves stormwater design. And so one of the low-hanging fruit that

1:00:08 they've decided to do was address the piece that people can't quite afford to

1:00:13 take care of their sidewalk. So they're offering an incentive to property owners.

1:00:20 They have lots of requirements, but the minute what they've done is a good place to start.

1:00:26 We might duplicate some of the good ideas.

1:00:27 The Municipal Code places responsibility for sidewalk maintenance upon adjacent homeowners.

1:00:32 They have the same premise.

1:00:33 This program was developed in recognition of the inherent conflict between tree roots and

1:00:37 sidewalks in the company and the accompanying financial burden.

1:00:44 Down below, grant funds may be used for the repair or replacement of existing sidewalks

1:00:48 that have been damaged by the roots of protected trees.

1:00:50 That's a primary one.

1:00:53 And then it gets into specifying how we would award.

1:00:57 And what I'd like to say that I've looked at it,

1:01:00 I think it's a great place to start again.

1:01:03 But they have grant funds.

1:01:06 Homeowners must obtain competitive bids for jobs

1:01:08 that require permit.

1:01:09 The maximum grant reimbursement will be 50% of the lowest bid.

1:01:12 They've decided that that works for them.

1:01:14 I propose that we go to engineering,

1:01:16 let them help us develop a plan.

1:01:18 And what I will suggest to the Washington Plan

1:01:22 is that we put another $50,000 in the budget

1:01:26 for this upcoming year where homeowners could come in

1:01:29 and get a dollar for dollar match with whatever specification

1:01:34 we've established to help homeowners replace.

1:01:39 It does not accept.

1:01:41 It doesn't change the premise that the maintenance of the sidewalk

1:01:46 is on the property owner.

1:01:48 but it gives them a tool.

1:01:51 They have a few lights that came on there.

1:01:54 Dunhall.

1:01:54 So this is just for a player or replacement.

1:01:57 It has nothing to do with missing sidewalks.

1:02:01 And I'll talk about that in one minute, but go ahead.

1:02:04 Well, I was just going to say that's at least,

1:02:08 if it needs to be repaired, you have something.

1:02:12 There are neighborhoods that have nothing.

1:02:14 And I think what I heard you say, John,

1:02:17 is that there's so many more dynamics with that,

1:02:20 with curbside or maybe stormwater, things like that,

1:02:24 that make it pretty cost prohibitive.

1:02:27 But still, my view is we need to help some of these folks

1:02:31 with even having a sidewalk of some sort.

1:02:37 Chris, John, I think it has some error

1:02:40 what you're talking about.

1:02:41 But I've always been told that repairing a lot of particular

1:02:48 property defined section, the sidewalk is not cost-effective,

1:02:52 that we should be LIDing for a whole block.

1:02:55 But it is this a better idea than an LID where the city might

1:03:00 contribute to an entire section to have it done.

1:03:04 Because if you have six properties on the block,

1:03:06 and two of them do it this year and one in the next year,

1:03:10 that doesn't look like an effective program.

1:03:13 It looks like in your master planning, identify areas

1:03:16 to go to something like this.

1:03:18 that put it under an LID.

1:03:20 We've actually probably didn't get through all of it,

1:03:24 but I probably didn't explain it very clearly,

1:03:26 so can I get a do over it?

1:03:29 Mulligan.

1:03:30 Well, what we're talking here is existing sidewalk problem,

1:03:34 and what we can do with it.

1:03:36 This is a tool for that.

1:03:38 The other part is the missing sidewalk,

1:03:40 which is the humongous issue.

1:03:42 It's not only the most, but people really want sidewalk.

1:03:45 and I get it, problem is the cost with design

1:03:50 and dealing with the storm water.

1:03:52 So one of the things that we can look at doing,

1:03:55 and actually I probably asked Jackie to maybe comment

1:03:57 on this a little bit, is if council decides

1:04:00 that we want to go an L.I.D. route,

1:04:02 or there's even another city code that you may look,

1:04:12 I mean, I'm not recommending we do this,

1:04:14 but council can by resolution for sidewalk

1:04:16 to be repaired and the owner will pay.

1:04:18 So, I mean, some of our codes are old and I'm not suggesting this,

1:04:24 but there's lots of things that we could do.

1:04:26 Again, engineering, I've talked to Jackie and, you know,

1:04:32 if we wanted to start looking into furls,

1:04:34 if we want to start calling the furls, it only makes sense

1:04:37 to do just like Councilman Talkington said,

1:04:39 you're not going to do one lot at a time, it doesn't make sense.

1:04:42 You're going to design a whole block,

1:04:43 and you're going to do a whole block at a time.

1:04:45 So we can do that.

1:04:46 I just know that there's some upfront engineering that would be required and it'll take engineering

1:04:55 some time to do that to get there.

1:04:59 It's not different.

1:05:00 Jackie, I'm talking about it several years ago.

1:05:03 We didn't have pressurized irrigation and that was a big shift in how we do things.

1:05:10 And so engineering has done it before.

1:05:12 We can do it again.

1:05:15 But that is the way to do it.

1:05:17 is blocked by block. We're done for now. Okay. So long-term, just to recap, I guess just to

1:05:35 summarize, long-term implementation. So I talked about what we're doing now in some of

1:05:41 the short, very near future things like this program. And again, it's small, but it might

1:05:47 make a difference for some people in the community. But for the long-term, we need to develop

1:05:50 the Master Transportation Plan, and we need to consider how we're going to plan and design

1:05:55 for the construction of new sidewalks that will involve engineering.

1:06:00 Engineering again could potentially provide the design for storm water, curb and gutter

1:06:06 for potential new sidewalks and we could begin to call for us.

1:06:11 That's really all I have.

1:06:13 So this is what we're doing now.

1:06:15 This is what I plan to propose next year again if you have questions.

1:06:22 I just want to get the facts right there. You say we have

1:06:27 250 miles total sidewalk in the city or that needs to be replaced or repaired John

1:06:33 So we have total missing sidewalk of

1:06:37 1 million 225,000 lineal feet. That's missing missing missing

1:06:44 That's about 250 miles. I think you said

1:06:48 Yeah, I combined I combined some of those so

1:06:51 So 1.2 million, then you'll be.

1:06:56 And to do all of that would be approximately $49 million.

1:07:02 On both sides.

1:07:03 On both sides.

1:07:04 Yeah.

1:07:05 Yeah.

1:07:10 Thank you.

1:07:11 You know, John, I just want to say thank you for bringing this to us.

1:07:13 And I know that we're trying to chip away and that's my philosophy as well.

1:07:18 This is not something we're going to dig out of tomorrow.

1:07:21 It's something that we're going to have to stay on top of and continue the momentum.

1:07:26 I would just again encourage us to really look at those neighborhoods that don't have

1:07:31 anything, that at least there's some kind of connectivity I like what you did on third,

1:07:35 that make perfect sense the whole package, but give some connectivity to some parks, maybe

1:07:40 some areas of shopping as we start looking at what we need to do when we become at MPO.

1:07:46 Yes, MPO we need to be thinking about how do these folks get to a bus stop if we're going

1:07:56 to be putting bus stops even. So I you're right on track and I appreciate your

1:08:01 presentation tonight. We just need to keep chipping away.

1:08:06 Jackie, do you have something you wanted to add?

1:08:09 I just want to provide a little comment on my very crude estimate. It doesn't include a tremendous amount of work.

1:08:21 Some of these drainages are a little bit complicated because the low spot

1:08:25 goes right into some person's basement,

1:08:29 and I have to figure out where to send it

1:08:31 that's not Rock Creek.

1:08:32 So we all have to figure out where to send that water.

1:08:35 So I didn't include those things in the estimates.

1:08:40 So there's, it is low at the Costa area, I promise that.

1:08:48 And there's no right away in there, you know,

1:08:50 and there's, it's a complicated issue,

1:08:54 and it'll take a little time to get ahead of it

1:08:57 because we're going to be in for drainage analysis

1:09:00 before we actually take it on.

1:09:03 Well, it's gonna take me a little time.

1:09:09 I've done it before, but it just takes a little time.

1:09:14 Thank you, Jackie.

1:09:15 Chris, talking to you.

1:09:15 Just one other question for either of you.

1:09:18 And we also have a few roads that we

1:09:20 and X from county that are really substandard to our grade.

1:09:24 You can't attach a curb gutter side to Oc

1:09:26 to one of those flat old roads where

1:09:29 that's not good money spent, doesn't it?

1:09:31 Well, you know, and that's kind of the challenge.

1:09:33 Just tying on a curb doesn't necessarily help you.

1:09:38 Because rural sections work beautifully as rural sections.

1:09:42 When the ditch goes away and you put the curb line in,

1:09:45 that water may not go anywhere.

1:09:47 So you need to be really careful.

1:09:49 We got somewhat lucky on Falls Avenue West

1:09:53 with that particular roadway.

1:09:54 But over by on Monroe, a few of those streets

1:10:01 between Addison and Falls.

1:10:05 There's a low spot that's not going to be so easy to deal with.

1:10:15 What's the good news?

1:10:17 We're working on it.

1:10:18 Well, give us some time and we'll try to coordinate it

1:10:21 with the zone maintenance so that we can get the most bang

1:10:24 for the bunk, not only for a water system improvement,

1:10:27 but sewer and accessibility.

1:10:31 That's the way we prefer to do it now.

1:10:32 We did a test run with Zone 3's third Avenue job,

1:10:38 and it worked really well.

1:10:40 There were existing drainage issues in there

1:10:42 that were substantial.

1:10:43 They've been minimized to the extent possible

1:10:46 without doing major right-of-way acquisition.

1:10:49 We did a pretty good job.

1:10:53 Thank you.

1:10:54 Any other comments from the council?

1:10:57 Thanks, guys.

1:10:58 John, any final parting words?

1:11:01 You're all done.

1:11:02 All done.

1:11:03 All done.

1:11:03 Thank you.

1:11:09 The next item on the agenda is a general discussion about the city manager's fiscal year 2017

1:11:14 budget priorities and philosophies followed by citizen input.

1:11:19 We'll just grab a straw.

1:11:25 Okay.

1:11:26 How about let's take a quick seven minute break.

1:11:32 We will, we will recess and reconvene at 20 minutes after.

1:11:38 And this is going to be the first of four presentations that you're going to have before the actual presentation of the City Manager's Budget.

1:11:45 And tonight's conversation is to kind of share with you some of the things that I'm seeing, what I believe is important, as in a sense to prime the pump, if you will, because they're the long-term planning committee is going to come next week and start having a conversation about some of the issues that you see that merit.

1:12:08 consideration in this upcoming budget process.

1:12:11 From that, we will then take that information and long-term planning committee will make a

1:12:16 presentation to you.

1:12:18 We will then take that information and use your thoughts, our thoughts, and really begin that

1:12:24 process of creating the 2017 budget.

1:12:28 This is designed to start the conversation, or at least be a piece of that conversation.

1:12:35 And if you recall over the course of the last few weeks, we've had different conversations

1:12:39 about levels of infrastructure, areas of concern, areas of importance, each piece being an important

1:12:46 nugget as we continue to advance this city and its strategic plan.

1:12:53 Before we begin, I want to start off with showing you a quick recap of where we were at last

1:13:01 year.

1:13:02 You'll notice that the city's total taxable value grew to $2.3, $1.3 billion.

1:13:09 That taxable value number is very similar to the total taxable value that we had prior

1:13:15 to the beginning of the recession.

1:13:17 So our total taxable value has almost been all but restored, and that does not include

1:13:21 the growth that we've seen as a result of Cliff Bar and in Chibani, because those projects

1:13:27 are outside of the city's taxable value and included into revenue allocation areas.

1:13:34 You'll notice that our total net revenues were $60.765 million, which is a combination of

1:13:40 $33.65 million of general fund.

1:13:44 General fund dollars, again, those areas in which we receive property taxes or some level

1:13:48 of property taxes used to support that operation.

1:13:51 And then the enterprise funds and the non-tax supported funds are going to be those user

1:13:55 of these systems, our water sewer sanitation.

1:13:59 You'll notice that total property tax collections last year

1:14:02 were $17.907 million.

1:14:06 And then in addition to that, you're looking at what we took

1:14:08 about 1 and 1 half percent increase in property taxes,

1:14:11 as well as the new construction.

1:14:13 At the end, our property tax rate decreased.

1:14:16 It went from $7.66 per $1,000 to $7.60 per $1,000.

1:14:22 And since we did not take all that we were entitled to,

1:14:26 the city's foregone balance grew to $2.149 million.

1:14:37 One of the majors of our economy and our community

1:14:41 is our employment.

1:14:43 And our employment continues to strengthen.

1:14:45 Is there a question?

1:14:47 That's right.

1:14:48 Thank you.

1:14:49 I'm sorry.

1:14:51 Is that number gonna change because of the mistake

1:14:53 that the county found?

1:14:54 No.

1:14:55 Thank you.

1:15:01 that county air was only on the county's total valuation.

1:15:07 It was not associated with the city's valuation,

1:15:09 as I understand it.

1:15:13 Greg Lanting.

1:15:14 And again, we, we, education is still gonna be a key there

1:15:18 because I had somebody hit me up.

1:15:21 I thought it was friendly and informed

1:15:22 on what was going on and they said they were seeing,

1:15:25 well, how come we're having to pay 20 bucks to the city?

1:15:28 And when I live in the county.

1:15:30 And it's, we will continue to work through that process.

1:15:35 I think that taxation in Idaho is fairly complicated

1:15:40 with the different divisions and the different areas.

1:15:44 Urban renewal, city, schools, I understand

1:15:48 that the county commissioners had their hearings.

1:15:50 Most of the complaints were not associated

1:15:53 with paying more taxes or having to pay

1:15:55 the right amount of taxes.

1:15:56 I don't think it should be looked as paying more taxes.

1:15:59 It's more or less paying the amount of taxes

1:16:01 that should have been paid on the beginning

1:16:04 is probably the better way to look at it.

1:16:05 But there were lots of conversation.

1:16:07 Taxation's a tough issue.

1:16:09 And I think that whenever taxation comes up,

1:16:12 I think that you're always going to see that.

1:16:17 So you can see that in December,

1:16:19 which is the most current information that we have,

1:16:21 we have a 3.5% unemployment rate in the city,

1:16:25 which held true.

1:16:26 And we've been bumping around 3.3% to 3.5%

1:16:30 for the better part of the last six to eight months.

1:16:34 You'll notice that what's important is our total labor pool

1:16:38 grew by 5.2% and unemployment remained flat.

1:16:44 That tells us that there are still more jobs out there.

1:16:47 It is a robust economy.

1:16:50 And as you continue to drive up and down blue lakes,

1:16:53 you'll notice health-wanted signs almost everywhere you go.

1:16:59 That is a real concern, because there are 831 people

1:17:04 according to this inside of the city of Flint Falls

1:17:06 who are not currently employed.

1:17:11 831 total people.

1:17:16 There's a total of 1,810 people in the micropolitan area

1:17:21 that are in that same status.

1:17:25 We often talk about the importance of building

1:17:28 a strong labor component in our community.

1:17:32 And tonight's presentation is going to talk about

1:17:34 how important that is for our city.

1:17:40 So we're very familiar with this.

1:17:42 This is the strategic plan that we have talked about

1:17:46 that we have celebrated.

1:17:48 You'll notice that there are each of the eight focus areas,

1:17:51 and in each of those eight focus areas,

1:17:53 the long-term planning committee has been vetting

1:17:56 and discussing capital requests across the board,

1:17:59 across the departments.

1:18:00 They've been vetting new positions as they commonly do.

1:18:05 They've been vetting philosophies, and they are using all of that to create a recommendation

1:18:12 for you.

1:18:13 And it's all connected to this.

1:18:15 It's all connected to our strategic plan, a plan that was created by our citizens in 2012,

1:18:21 mobilized in 2013, and will be updated again later this fall.

1:18:27 And when you look at it, it almost looks like all parts are equal, but we have to remember

1:18:36 public services are provided by public employees. So maybe a better way to look at this model

1:18:47 is this. Maybe a better way to look at this is that the quality of our services and our

1:18:58 ability to achieve our vision is directly dependent upon the quality of our employee

1:19:04 core and our ability to be innovative, to be creative, and to offer the highest level

1:19:09 quality services to our citizens. Police cars don't go to the scenes by themselves.

1:19:16 Fires don't get put out by the engine alone. So on and so forth, the level of public services

1:19:23 that we provide are delivered by people. My focus in this budget is Area 8. I firmly

1:19:36 believe that as we look at doing all of the other things in the budget, and we will, we

1:19:41 will focus on and accomplishing tasks in those other areas. For me, I believe the

1:19:49 route to us being successful in our strategic plan starts with our people.

1:19:54 This area talks about this is the focus area. This is the vision and we hope

1:20:00 that we have a city that strives and accomplishes its vision and

1:20:05 mission with unquestioned integrity and the highest of ethical standards. That

1:20:10 And we recognize that we have a shared obligation to create a livable community.

1:20:16 That we support transparency in all of our decision making processes that we work in close

1:20:22 partnership with one another, with the shareholders, with our stakeholders, with our citizens, that

1:20:28 we have a high level of competency and a lean, properly compensated, respected core city staff.

1:20:40 It's a vision that I believe that means something and something that we're all striving for today.

1:20:48 The individual focus areas, goal number one, initiative 1.1, it talks about the ability

1:20:54 to attract, recruit, retain, and train the most qualified employees, that we need to continue

1:21:03 to recognize that we live in an evolving environment and so we want to continue to educate, invest

1:21:08 in our employees through training and career development, and we want to provide good, safe

1:21:14 working conditions for all of our people.

1:21:23 That we want to be a leader.

1:21:25 When it comes to wellness programs and its connection to being a healthy community, we

1:21:29 want to be a leader in employee wellness.

1:21:33 That we want to identify costs and opportunities and incentive programs and benefits all around

1:21:39 the idea of creating a safer, better place for our employees.

1:21:48 We want to treat our employees fairly.

1:21:51 We want to make sure that we have a strong, informed, and committed workforce through

1:21:56 fair compensation, good treatment, professional development programs, and that means benefits,

1:22:01 that means salaries.

1:22:03 That means training opportunities that allow them to grow, to create new opportunities

1:22:10 for themselves professionally and to encourage and support the continuing education of our

1:22:16 employees.

1:22:20 And I think that we've illustrated a commitment to those strategic planning objectives that

1:22:25 it was created.

1:22:26 So let's take a minute and think about what we've done.

1:22:30 We've moved that table 11 and a half percent since 2012.

1:22:36 There's something to be incredibly proud about.

1:22:41 9% in 2013, 2% in 2014, and a half a percent last year.

1:22:49 We've provided an average of 3% performance-based adjustments,

1:22:52 and we have the compression ratio adjustments that

1:22:55 assist in moving people through our system faster

1:23:00 than what we had previously.

1:23:10 But unfortunately, it's not enough.

1:23:14 Today, we still find ourselves fighting

1:23:17 to keep quality talent in our doors.

1:23:20 We find people that are being attracted to go to other locations.

1:23:26 We find that we are constantly competing for recruits against eastern Idaho, Treasure Valley,

1:23:33 and even all spots in the nation.

1:23:36 We recently had a planner position, a grade 10 position, middle of our organizational chart,

1:23:45 in which most of the candidates that we believed were appropriate for moving forward in the

1:23:51 process were from out of state.

1:23:55 So we need to recognize that our market is not what it has always been.

1:24:00 Our market is continuing to shift, especially as we look for key talented individuals.

1:24:06 And part of the reason is this.

1:24:09 When you look at the U.S. population by generation, you'll notice that there are five generations

1:24:15 illustrated above. We have the silent generation, the boomers that represent 75.8 or 75.6 million.

1:24:26 We have Generation X that represents 54 million and the millennials. The millennials is the

1:24:32 largest generation that we have right now. You'll notice that the boomers and the millennials

1:24:40 book and one of the smallest generations in our country's history. Generation X is small.

1:24:49 It is half. It is 50% less, excuse me, than the boomers and the millennials that are coming

1:24:57 after them. So you have to ask, is this all about supplying demand? Because what people

1:25:03 are talking about is that there is going to continue to be a shortage of qualified professionals

1:25:08 simply because there are not enough people to fill the roles.

1:25:15 That there's a growing need for multi-skilled employees.

1:25:18 As our roles become more complex and more dynamic,

1:25:21 we need people to be able to do more,

1:25:24 to be more creative, to learn on learn

1:25:27 and re-learn new skill sets,

1:25:30 to be able to compete with an ever-growing,

1:25:34 diverse collection of responsibilities.

1:25:37 that communities are now forcing to face,

1:25:40 that we have a decrease in the level of long-term commitment

1:25:43 to our organization by employees.

1:25:45 That's, unfortunately, a reality of the millennial group,

1:25:51 that the millennial group as a group will change careers,

1:25:55 not just jobs and locations,

1:25:57 they will change careers five to seven times

1:26:00 in their working path.

1:26:02 And in addition to that, we're finding that no one really,

1:26:06 truly wants to be married to their job.

1:26:10 That we all are looking for work-life balance

1:26:13 and the opportunity to work hard,

1:26:16 but then also the opportunity to enjoy the pursuits

1:26:20 and those things that we like.

1:26:22 We're finding that millennials are choosing places

1:26:24 to live first, and then they are finding jobs

1:26:29 that fit those opportunities.

1:26:31 And another thing we're finding is generation Xers

1:26:35 are beginning to follow suit of the millennials.

1:26:39 So the phenomenon is actually reverse trending.

1:26:45 So what do we look like?

1:26:48 The city of Twin Falls, and it's in total employee,

1:26:51 look like this.

1:26:52 We have 104 individuals that are considered to be millennials.

1:26:57 We have 87 individuals who are considered to be Generation X,

1:27:01 and we have 88 employees that are considered

1:27:06 to be in the Boomer category.

1:27:09 And we celebrate 40-year pins in our organization

1:27:14 with some of those members of those groups.

1:27:16 And so you will begin to see, as those boomers begin to retire,

1:27:21 we are going to focus and have to focus our abilities

1:27:25 on attracting generation Xers, which are already small in nature.

1:27:29 Remember, they're about 50% less than the millennials,

1:27:33 and we also need to focus a way to attract and keep

1:27:37 millennials into our organization. So since 2012, these are the individuals that we have

1:27:47 retained. Since 2000 January 1st of 2012, all the hiring that we have retained, 48 millennials,

1:27:58 28 generation Xers and 16 boomers. But since January 2012, what's not illustrated there

1:28:08 is we've recruited 119 people into our organization

1:28:13 and only 92 remain.

1:28:17 So not only in here is their a turnover,

1:28:21 but it's also something that we're seeing

1:28:23 throughout our entire organization.

1:28:28 So we need to focus and determine if we want to be

1:28:32 an entity that focuses on recruitment,

1:28:35 or if we want to be an entity that focuses

1:28:37 on organizational development,

1:28:40 because there's a fundamental difference.

1:28:43 And it might be slight, but organizational development

1:28:46 means that you are taking a committed core group

1:28:49 of individuals, and you are further polishing and strengthening

1:28:53 them in the area of public service.

1:28:56 And recruiting means that you're a training ground.

1:29:01 And we are going to continue to bring people in to help us turn

1:29:04 the crank, and when they leave, we

1:29:07 will bring someone else to turn in the crank.

1:29:10 But I want you to think about who gets attracted,

1:29:13 and who gets pulled away from our organizations.

1:29:17 And oftentimes, it's those that we hope to carry into the future.

1:29:23 It's those individuals that we hope will assume

1:29:26 leadership positions moving forward.

1:29:32 So one way to attract and retain the best employees

1:29:35 and to keep them motivated is to pay them

1:29:38 what our competitors are paying, or maybe even more.

1:29:47 One way to gauge that is taking a look

1:29:49 at the cost of living.

1:29:50 How far does our dollar go in Twin Falls in comparison

1:29:55 to other places?

1:29:58 Because I think that that's an important piece

1:29:59 of the entire equation.

1:30:03 And in this survey that I'm going to show you, 100

1:30:12 is the national average.

1:30:15 Anything above 100 is that it is higher than the average,

1:30:20 the national average, as a place to live.

1:30:23 The further, I guess, the smaller the cheaper it is

1:30:28 than the national average.

1:30:29 So the smaller the number that I show you,

1:30:31 the cheaper it is to live.

1:30:35 We often say that we can't compete against Boise.

1:30:40 I'm going to tell you we better learn.

1:30:42 Because the cost of living in the city of Boise

1:30:45 and the city of Twin Falls is insignificant.

1:30:50 So this study is produced by taking a look at grocery items.

1:30:54 The Twin Falls Chamber of Commerce actually participates

1:30:57 in this exact survey and as I understand it, they are given a grocery list of items to go

1:31:03 out and they buy those lists and they submit that information and that's how we come up

1:31:08 with the grocery index and the housing index is based upon housing sales and the utility

1:31:14 is based upon utilities and transportation health care and miscellaneous goods and services.

1:31:19 Each one of those indexes is based upon a score of 100 being average.

1:31:25 The difference between the city of Twin Falls and the city of Boise is 2.9%.

1:31:34 When you're referring to transportation, is that gasoline, car repair, new cut car purchase?

1:31:40 So the survey, I'm not going to remember all of them,

1:31:45 so transportation is car insurance, it's cost of an oil change,

1:31:51 it's gas price for gallon, it's tires, so it's transportation related items.

1:31:57 Same as, you know, healthcare is a list of a doctor's visit, a dentist visit, the price

1:32:04 of a prescription, a bottle of Advil, so it's health-related things, but it's designed to

1:32:11 be more robust than just it costs this much to operate your car on an annual basis.

1:32:17 And what this is designed to do is to try to create what your monthly expenses would be

1:32:26 if you live in Twin Falls, Idaho,

1:32:29 and you take those same monthly expenses

1:32:32 and you apply them to any place in the country.

1:32:36 This survey is done for all metropolitan

1:32:38 and micropolitan areas,

1:32:40 and this is the index between the two.

1:32:45 This is a possible transportation also,

1:32:47 possibly include the ability to use mass transit,

1:32:52 because that would be cheaper than driving your car,

1:32:54 typically, but maybe not.

1:32:55 I don't believe so.

1:32:56 I can give you all of the items.

1:32:59 In fact, what they do on the survey that I looked at

1:33:02 is they actually even describe the grocery items

1:33:04 that were bought.

1:33:05 So they will send you to the grocery store

1:33:06 and maybe you're buying a detergent and bleach

1:33:08 and a pound of cheese and a gallon of milk

1:33:11 and basic household items.

1:33:14 But you can see that's how they come up

1:33:16 with what that survey is.

1:33:18 So what does that mean?

1:33:20 That means that if your base salary in Twin Falls

1:33:23 is $35,000, the exact same buying power in Boise, Idaho,

1:33:29 is equivalent salary of $37,100.

1:33:34 And you'll notice that on all of these,

1:33:36 I cited all of my sources.

1:33:37 In the event that there was question,

1:33:39 I cited every single one of my sources,

1:33:41 so you could go and look at this.

1:33:43 $50,000 salary is $53,000 all the way through $100,

1:33:48 so I kind of carried what that gamut is.

1:33:52 And then I compared and contrast what we pay our employees in comparison to what are being

1:33:57 paid inside of the Treasure Valley.

1:34:00 Now it's Treasure Valley and it's not Boise because when we look at the Northwest data exchange,

1:34:06 it gives us a geographic area.

1:34:08 And the Treasure Valley includes Ada County and Boise and Napa and Meridian and Caldwell and

1:34:15 all of those cities as, and we only know that they are in area three.

1:34:22 So when we look at area three, we kind of build what that area looks like and then we can compare

1:34:28 and contrast the exact same survey data that we supplied to reflect what we pay in those

1:34:34 areas.

1:34:35 And these are the actual market wage associated with the survey paid at that point in time.

1:34:41 Travis Dunhall has a kind of question.

1:34:44 Just real quick Travis, so I can understand, I always try to look at things very simply,

1:34:48 How much does it cost us to do this?

1:34:51 How much are we bringing in?

1:34:52 Do we do anything with the differences in revenue as well, for municipalities, counties,

1:34:58 those kind of things in comparison to what we get here, you know, does that make sense?

1:35:04 Yeah, so we look at the revenue piece.

1:35:06 Yeah.

1:35:07 And I believe I did not look at the revenue piece and I did look at the revenue piece

1:35:11 because I think it's important first to expose the problem.

1:35:16 The second is, we often ask, is it affordable?

1:35:20 What can we do?

1:35:21 And I think the other response is, can we afford not to?

1:35:25 And I'm going to talk about the consequences of not having a market-based compensation

1:35:30 program in a few minutes.

1:35:32 But when you look at revenues, I believe that the City of Twin Falls has the resources to

1:35:38 be able to make significant improvements in this gap this year, but it's going to require

1:35:44 the political and the test and the fortitude to make those changes. I think that you need

1:35:52 to look at all of it. So when you look, you can see what these different wage areas are.

1:36:04 And some of them are close. Admittedly, some of these aren't bad. And they would be in

1:36:10 those realms that we would find to be generally acceptable. Some of them are areas that we

1:36:18 kind of need to work on when we compare ourselves to Boise.

1:36:22 But I think what's important when we compare ourselves to Boise

1:36:25 is Boise is not the center of the universe,

1:36:28 although sometimes we believe that it is.

1:36:31 There are other places that we are actively competing

1:36:34 against for talent on a regular basis.

1:36:40 One of those places is Idaho Falls.

1:36:44 The composite index in Idaho Falls is actually less than twin falls.

1:36:53 It's substantially less in twin falls.

1:36:57 And exact same study, exact same process, taking a look at that information.

1:37:04 And so what does that mean when the cost of living is less?

1:37:07 Well, it's just the opposite of us in Boise, where a salary of $35,000 in twin falls

1:37:14 actually has an equivalent salary of $33,190 in its equivalent of what you need to make

1:37:24 in Idaho Falls to have the same buying power and so on and so forth. So that we compare

1:37:32 ourselves to Eastern Idaho. Again, the same thing. This is going to be Idaho Falls and

1:37:37 those that are generally going to be in that area and you can see what those differences

1:37:42 are. And so when you look at the cost of living difference and then you compare and contrast

1:37:49 what we're paying, you can notice that there is sizable difference in all of these.

1:38:02 So how important is compensation?

1:38:05 We know it's about job satisfaction, we know motivation, we know absenteeism, we know turnover.

1:38:13 Those are the big four that are often talked about what occurs when you do not have a compensation

1:38:19 system that aligns itself with the market.

1:38:22 But one of the things that's different about Twin Falls is how lean we operate.

1:38:28 The City of Twin Falls is a lean organization and we are able to be lean only if we have the best talent on our ship.

1:38:37 You can't be lean if you are always a revolving door.

1:38:42 You can't be lean and offer the highest level of customer services if we firmly expect them to just continue to be here for two, three years

1:38:53 years and then take that next opportunity wherever that may be.

1:39:00 A quality compensation program needs to be built upon the philosophies of retention for

1:39:05 both public and private.

1:39:07 See, we're not competing just against treasure valley cities anymore and Idaho Falls cities

1:39:15 areas anymore.

1:39:16 We're competing against all of the economic successes that we've had, just like all of

1:39:23 the other institutions in Twin Falls are.

1:39:29 Because when you have a 3.5% unemployment rate,

1:39:33 you have six people going through the law program.

1:39:38 And we have more openings in our law enforcement,

1:39:41 in our city alone.

1:39:44 You need to find ways to fill those void,

1:39:46 to attract individuals, to move them into our organization.

1:39:52 Work productivity is something that often occurs

1:39:56 when you have market-based compensation system.

1:40:00 It's that salt of the earth southern Idaho trade

1:40:04 where we want to earn our dollar.

1:40:07 And so there is that very simple philosophy

1:40:09 that the more that we compensate,

1:40:10 the better that we compensate,

1:40:14 the more productivity and opportunity that we may have.

1:40:18 And I recognize that compensation is not all.

1:40:21 We'll talk a little bit more

1:40:22 about other things other than compensation.

1:40:25 But I want to talk for a minute about the consequences

1:40:27 to our citizens, the people that we serve.

1:40:32 I really believe that large employee turnover

1:40:36 is going to cause lower citizen satisfaction.

1:40:41 I believe that we will have fewer innovative solutions

1:40:44 being born simply because we will be teaching people

1:40:47 how to do their job, let alone looking

1:40:50 for additional opportunities that may create

1:40:52 those opportunities, that I believe that we will have a much more difficult time competing

1:41:01 for those world-class companies because to be competing for world-class, I think you have

1:41:09 to be world-class.

1:41:12 I think that if we continue to have a revolving door, we have less of an opportunity to grow

1:41:17 our leaders from the inside.

1:41:22 To my knowledge, we have never gone to an outside recruitment for a police sergeant or

1:41:28 a fire captain in our organization.

1:41:35 But if we continue the rate of turnover moving forward through that process, does that become

1:41:40 a possibility?

1:41:41 And if it does, that frightens me.

1:41:45 That frightens me.

1:41:47 I like the fact that we grow our leaders.

1:41:49 I like the fact that we promote from within every opportunity that we can.

1:41:53 We don't do it always.

1:41:54 We bring people in.

1:41:55 We want fresh ideas, we want opportunities,

1:41:58 but I like the fact that we are training world-class individuals

1:42:01 to assume future leadership positions.

1:42:05 And I really do not believe that we can afford to be lean

1:42:09 if we do not have the best of the best working for us.

1:42:19 So what are we going to do?

1:42:21 In the areas of compensation, I believe that we should be targeting

1:42:26 some sort of mid-year adjustment this year.

1:42:29 So I'm approaching this kind of like a triage approach, right?

1:42:33 I have this patient, I'm an ER doctor,

1:42:35 the patient is now in and I'm looking,

1:42:37 what is the first thing that I need to do?

1:42:38 I have to stop the bleeding.

1:42:42 I have to stop the bleeding.

1:42:46 And so I believe it's appropriate to investigate

1:42:49 the financial feasibility of doing

1:42:51 a partial year adjustment this year

1:42:55 that will allow us to move the table,

1:42:57 allow the compression ratio adjustments to take place,

1:43:01 and to move that starting salary

1:43:03 to be able to continue to compete and to attract at that level.

1:43:08 I believe that we need to trigger the study that we have

1:43:12 funded to make sure that our kinds of levels chart is adequate,

1:43:15 that the spacing in between the grades is appropriate,

1:43:18 and that the table truly represents market.

1:43:24 See, market for us can't be the way it's always been.

1:43:27 Market needs to be something different.

1:43:30 Market needs to be something that we look at where

1:43:33 we compete for those jobs.

1:43:34 And sometimes that's locally, sometimes that's statewide,

1:43:37 sometimes that's nationally.

1:43:40 And sometimes I think that we get hung up as to,

1:43:44 well, what is such and such pain?

1:43:47 And I think that we need to focus on

1:43:49 what are we going to do to attract talent in our area

1:43:53 and recognize that talent comes from many different areas.

1:43:58 And then on top of that, we need to develop

1:43:59 the next three-year plan.

1:44:02 See, every step that we took, we found ourselves

1:44:06 in a really, really good position.

1:44:09 We move the table 11 and 1 half percent,

1:44:14 but so did our competition.

1:44:18 And when you look at key positions inside of our own area,

1:44:21 our own Magic Valley,

1:44:25 we don't even break the top two or three

1:44:27 in some of them in compensation levels for employees.

1:44:34 We should be commanding the Magic Valley market always.

1:44:38 It's what we should expect.

1:44:42 And we should always look for opportunities

1:44:43 to move our organization forward.

1:44:47 So it's more than money.

1:44:49 We know that people won't stay here for money alone.

1:44:52 And we know that even if we had the most robust compensation

1:44:56 model, people would still leave.

1:45:00 People will always continue to follow life pursuits,

1:45:03 but I don't want money to be the reason they leave us

1:45:06 at all times.

1:45:11 I think it might be the first person ever

1:45:13 to throw up Maslow's hierarchy of needs

1:45:16 in a conversation about the budget.

1:45:19 But I think it's three of us here in the audience

1:45:21 who know about Maslow.

1:45:22 I know.

1:45:23 But I think it's relevant.

1:45:27 Because before we can really talk about where we want to go

1:45:30 as an organization and do one city,

1:45:32 we have to have a committed core to be able to do this.

1:45:36 We have to be able to meet the first two needs,

1:45:40 the psychological needs and the safety and security needs.

1:45:43 We also call those hygiene needs.

1:45:45 We have to be able to meet those needs so that our employees know that they are well cared

1:45:52 for, they are well provided for, because you can't get to one city, you can't become one

1:45:58 city until you can achieve those other areas of connection, emotional, right?

1:46:04 One city is about connection.

1:46:07 You can't connect if your door is always revolving with people leaving in and out.

1:46:12 It's about achievement, attention, recognition, reputation, building upon the capacities of

1:46:17 the City of Twin Falls, taking great pride in the work that we do, and creating next practices.

1:46:26 We have a team here, and I can speak from experience, that is absolutely unparalleled, and we have

1:46:35 to do something to keep them, keep them intact and move them forward because I will tell you,

1:46:43 We have other chiefs calling in to our organization and they are having conversations like this.

1:46:50 Our chief calls and says, hey, quit poaching my guys.

1:46:54 And his conversation is, start paying them.

1:46:58 So I can't poach your guys.

1:47:04 We are recognized as one of the model institutions and all of the works that they do.

1:47:09 And that conversation doesn't occur just in the police department.

1:47:12 That conversation occurs in public works.

1:47:14 It occurs in engineering.

1:47:16 occurs on a daily basis and at a 3.5% unemployment rate, people are going and grabbing quality

1:47:22 talent and we have a wonderful collection of folks working with us.

1:47:31 So it's about building one city is more than compensation. It's our opportunity to truly

1:47:37 be a part of something far bigger than ourselves and that is a huge selling point from millennials

1:47:42 and individuals who are committed to public service. Because this is an opportunity in

1:47:47 one of those places and one of those things that you can't actually do something far greater

1:47:52 for the whole than what you can ever do by yourself as an individual.

1:47:58 That we have started taking good strides in improving and improving our physical working

1:48:02 conditions.

1:48:05 That we have demolition bids, we'll bring them forward next week, they look phenomenal,

1:48:11 And we are going to begin breaking stuff, probably all knew what I was going to say.

1:48:21 We're going to start breaking stuff to be able to make improvements to move that forward.

1:48:28 We've made those improvements in public works.

1:48:31 We've made those improvements at the airport.

1:48:34 We also need to begin to focus on making those improvements in our firehouses.

1:48:41 We need to continue to invest in training.

1:48:44 As part of going with Select Health, we had a wonderful meeting last week, the end of last

1:48:50 middle of last week about building a robust wellness program in our city that is long overdue.

1:48:56 Building a program that helps create a healthier employee.

1:49:02 And not just physical, but spiritual, mental, the whole gamut in addition to physical.

1:49:09 And continuing to invest in training.

1:49:11 those tools to help our employees to be successful because I really believe that our most important

1:49:16 asset is our people. So final thoughts. If we truly want to be the employer of choice

1:49:26 that is described in our strategic plan, then we need to leave the Magic Valley in all facets

1:49:33 of compensation and we need to have the ability to compete on a statewide and national plan.

1:49:40 We need to be able to compete in a vibrant twin falls on the non-compensatory benefits

1:49:46 that are afforded as well.

1:49:50 We also need to, I believe, continue to support and foster the concepts of one city because

1:49:55 those are a little bit higher on Maslow's hire.

1:50:00 So next week you are going to hear things about the, you might hear some things from

1:50:06 the long term planning committee.

1:50:08 I shared with them my priority not quite this same way, but I really do believe that this

1:50:19 is the most critical step that we can take this year in our overall budgetary strategy,

1:50:25 and that is to make sure that we have a strong, lean, well-compensated employee court.

1:50:34 Thank you, Travis.

1:50:36 Chris talking to you.

1:50:37 Aside from going back to grad school and reliving Maslow,

1:50:40 I'd like to compliment your final review.

1:50:42 That's, at least I particularly appreciate seeing the overview

1:50:48 from the top of the hill periodically,

1:50:50 as to have always been down the bottom.

1:50:53 I'd like to talk about the foregone balance

1:50:55 of which your assumptions are of the future.

1:50:58 As you reiterate, we have a 2.149 million foregone balance

1:51:04 which I think is one of our strongest

1:51:07 calling cards reflects a positive growing economy and increasing property values and employment.

1:51:14 There's always a temptation, however, to tap into that.

1:51:18 I know some counsel periodically say, well, we should have to spend the money if we have

1:51:22 it.

1:51:23 I don't subscribe to that at all.

1:51:26 However, just using the example of John the Knight in the sidewalks, $49 million, we could

1:51:32 eat that up, not only before percent of the problem.

1:51:36 Have you looked at the foregone violence and our impending non-employment directly related

1:51:44 issues and have a feeling is that going to be a balance we're going to have to tap into

1:51:50 and meet future needs since growth doesn't pay for itself?

1:51:55 That was a rambling question.

1:51:57 Did you get the substance?

1:51:59 Yeah, I did.

1:52:02 There is no question that we have a whole host of competing needs.

1:52:09 Two weeks ago you heard a conversation about water facilities.

1:52:15 Tonight you heard a conversation about sidewalks, as well as compensation.

1:52:21 The foregone balance exists because we didn't take all of the monies that we could have in

1:52:27 those fiscal years.

1:52:30 We had a very conservative approach, and that approach has allowed us to pass along tax savings

1:52:36 over the course of the last several years to all of our citizens.

1:52:41 But sometimes I wonder if it hasn't been at the hindrance of all of the things that we've

1:52:45 been talking about.

1:52:50 Streets, road funding, water funding, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, employee compensation.

1:52:57 What's important to recognize is prior to 2012, we didn't move our salary table for

1:53:03 nine years.

1:53:07 And when you look at roadways, potholes don't begin to occur because you didn't chip seal

1:53:15 them just last year. Our systems might be deteriorating because of our

1:53:26 conservativeness. Now, that's a balance. It's absolutely a balance that you need to

1:53:32 strike between affordability, livability, and the ability to provide the quality

1:53:38 services are expected by our citizens. That in lies the balance. And I believe

1:53:46 the legislature wants to do everything in their power to remove that from being available.

1:53:54 We saw, we've heard of attacks on the foregone balance over the course of the last couple of years,

1:54:02 and this year they passed a bill that simply says that if you intend to use it,

1:54:08 then you have to have a special public hearing and just disclosing why you want to use it.

1:54:17 But I think that that balance is always going to lie in the jeopardy, and what we need to

1:54:24 do is to determine whether or not the needs that we have in the organization rise to the

1:54:32 level and importance to take the foregone balance, to support ongoing operational costs,

1:54:41 any portion of it.

1:54:42 And I'm not saying all, maybe none, but whatever that looks like, Lori is just going through

1:54:47 the process of creating revenue estimates and what that's going to look like for the upcoming

1:54:52 year. And so we can't tell you what revenues are going to look like for sure. And even with

1:54:58 Lori's number, it is subject to change just as you have realized over the course of the

1:55:03 last few fiscal years. So we'll continue to look at that. But I think the Council needs

1:55:09 to really balance all of the competing needs that were showcasing before you and help us

1:55:16 defined but best ways to spend the citizens money.

1:55:20 Thank you.

1:55:21 Any other comments from Council?

1:55:25 No.

1:55:26 Travis, I just wanted to say thank you for bringing this to our attention again.

1:55:32 Could you bring us some good news one of these days?

1:55:33 That might be really...

1:55:35 Okay.

1:55:36 So, no, I'm teasing, I'm teasing.

1:55:42 Chief Devore used to say that within our department the only true asset that we have

1:55:49 are people, because everything else is used.

1:55:52 The cars are used, as soon as you get them,

1:55:54 start driving them, they're used,

1:55:55 tires are worn out, buildings start decaying,

1:55:59 all those things, and so the most important thing

1:56:01 that we need to stay on top of is our human resources,

1:56:05 and I think you've illustrated that well tonight.

1:56:08 I certainly have, what you call it,

1:56:11 the intestinal fortitude to review issues, processes,

1:56:16 processes, ideas, compensation plans, and make sure that we are competitive because we need

1:56:23 to be, because it comes right down to the service that we provide for our citizens.

1:56:29 And that's what we're up here for.

1:56:30 We're supposed to be conduits of their needs.

1:56:33 They contact us, and then we give you our input, and then we go out and do our jobs, right?

1:56:39 right. So I say, bring us ideas, bring us solutions. You're bringing us issues tonight. And I

1:56:49 think overall we're ready to act if it makes sense. As far as the foreground balance, you

1:56:55 know, I've always been proud that we've had one because we've been conservative enough

1:56:59 to do that. We don't just take the full 3% just because we can't. And I've heard of

1:57:07 of other government entities saying that, actually.

1:57:10 We have not ever, as long as I've been on this council

1:57:13 the last 10 and a half years, ever had that philosophy.

1:57:16 But if we need to use it to ensure that we are providing

1:57:20 the correct services, the need of services for our citizens,

1:57:24 I'm not shy about going after it.

1:57:26 So just my two cents worth.

1:57:28 Thank you.

1:57:29 Greg Lansing.

1:57:30 Well again, thank you, Travis.

1:57:33 I think we all knew that some of this was there

1:57:37 We just didn't know the scope of it at this point,

1:57:40 especially concerning the employees.

1:57:42 I think we can drive around, we can see the roads,

1:57:45 and we can see the places that maybe,

1:57:47 that I grew up on a farm, as some of these others did,

1:57:52 and we always had livestock,

1:57:55 and you couldn't, you can save money by feeding

1:57:59 the livestock less, but it didn't make you save any money.

1:58:02 And I think that's kind of where we've gotten into it.

1:58:05 I think both with staff has turned over and also with roads that and like Don I

1:58:11 think we've we've taken some foregone at one point in our our careers that on

1:58:19 our ten and a half years on council and though we specifically put it on a road

1:58:23 we said we're gonna rebuild this road with this amount of foregone and the

1:58:27 beauty of that is that we got that road rebuilt but we probably got a road

1:58:31 be dealt the next year as well with that same money and continued along and so

1:58:36 again I'll say the same is done if I'm if the need is there and we need to take

1:58:42 the 3% or even some of the foreground I'm ready to do so.

1:58:47 Susan Hawkins. Thank you Travis it was a very well put together presentation and

1:58:53 has my head going in a few directions and a lot to digest tonight. In my time here

1:59:01 where I've been very supportive of making sure our employees are fairly compensated.

1:59:05 And that has always been something that I think we've needed to address.

1:59:09 I think sometimes we all get busy in the rest of our lives and forget how much everyone here in this room does.

1:59:16 And personally, if this is a problem we need to correct, I'm all in favor of correcting it and

1:59:22 I'm anxious to see what solutions you're going to bring our way.

1:59:25 Thanks.

1:59:26 And this is really something to celebrate.

1:59:32 We haven't completely climbed the entire hill, right?

1:59:37 But imagine if we would have started.

1:59:40 I mean, the strides that have been taken here

1:59:43 have paid dividends.

1:59:45 It may not have gone as far down the road as we had hoped.

1:59:50 But imagine how much further we are

1:59:52 had we not even started.

1:59:57 Ruth Pierce.

1:59:58 Well, I just want to say this is not a problem

2:00:01 that no business hasn't faced and aren't facing.

2:00:04 And when we address this was to do,

2:00:07 but I've got to tell you, the one thing I have come to discover

2:00:11 as a new council person is our employees are passionate

2:00:16 about their jobs and how you can be passionate about sewer

2:00:20 is beyond me, but I mean, just at every orientation

2:00:25 I went to, I mean, everybody.

2:00:28 I did a ride along with one of the officers a couple of weeks

2:00:31 ago and they're all over it. We had a meth bust, it was kind of fun. But I am, for an

2:00:39 accountant, okay, all right. But I think that it's really, really important that we

2:00:46 take care of our employees because they are passionate about what they do.

2:00:50 So I've been on a few ride-alongs and I'm going to look back at Lieutenant Lewis and because

2:00:54 He was the guy who I went on my ride along with.

2:00:59 And I think we had the quietest night in the history of Twin

2:01:02 Falls.

2:01:04 So I'm a bit jealous that you actually saw a little bit,

2:01:06 actually.

2:01:10 Chris, Dr. Scott.

2:01:11 I did have one specific question on page 24 of your report

2:01:15 comparing salaries in Twin Falls to Eastern Idaho.

2:01:19 One really steps out public works.

2:01:24 we're only paying two thirds of the prevailing wage

2:01:28 as Eastern Idaho and most of the other

2:01:31 cost comparisons are much, much closer.

2:01:34 If you double check that and is there a reason

2:01:36 that we'd be paying public work so much less?

2:01:39 So Gretchen helped to produce the numbers

2:01:43 so I can all but guarantee their accuracy

2:01:48 because of how thorough she is in the spreadsheets

2:01:52 in the data and the review of that.

2:01:55 I think that when you start taking a look,

2:01:57 you'll notice that there's a lot better nexus

2:02:00 between their public safety and their public works positions

2:02:04 in those areas.

2:02:05 I think that another driving factor, when we look at markets,

2:02:09 really could be the length of 10 years

2:02:12 that people are spending in those positions

2:02:14 and the capturing and the moving from position to position.

2:02:19 And so it might be a reflection of that.

2:02:21 When we look at the salary survey data, it's lots of employees.

2:02:26 It's going to take that average and what that is.

2:02:28 And we can't tell you if they are an older employee core.

2:02:32 We don't get a median age attached to that.

2:02:34 So there could be many, many different factors

2:02:36 that are attached there.

2:02:38 Thanks.

2:02:40 Don, how?

2:02:41 I'll make this quick because I better talk.

2:02:42 But you know, I keep coming back to the connection.

2:02:45 We keep talking about the amenities

2:02:48 that we need to look at to attract this workforce,

2:02:52 because that's what they're looking for.

2:02:53 They're looking for a cool community,

2:02:55 somewhere that they can feel connected,

2:02:57 somewhere that they can have fun things to do.

2:03:01 And I think we've made huge strides in that.

2:03:03 You know, we talked about August Falls tonight.

2:03:05 We've got a world-class trail system

2:03:07 that we're chipping away at every year.

2:03:10 We've invested in our roadways, and that's an amenity.

2:03:14 It's nice to be a big gift from point A to point B.

2:03:18 downtown, yeah. And all these different things, but one of those key components,

2:03:24 honestly, for the amenity, is to have the right person come to your door when you

2:03:28 need help, service. Either that's please, street, water, any of these situations. So,

2:03:34 again, I think that that's really important for us to look at as well. I

2:03:40 think you've touched on Travis, but we need to have the right people in the

2:03:45 right positions lean, but educated and excited and trained and ready to serve our community.

2:03:52 And lastly, so I'm assuming in the near future you're going to come back with some solutions

2:03:57 to us.

2:04:02 So potential solutions, ideas for solutions.

2:04:04 I hope to bring solutions and to be able to be in a position to help navigate through this

2:04:11 process.

2:04:12 Tonight was really about the exposure of the issues and the problems.

2:04:16 As the more I dug into this, the more I actually learned

2:04:20 through this process, there are results that were in here

2:04:23 that especially what I learned about cost of living

2:04:28 in Eastern Idaho was really, really interesting

2:04:33 from that perspective.

2:04:34 We will take this information.

2:04:37 We will then build a series of possible solutions and outcomes.

2:04:41 But the purpose tonight is when long-term planning comes,

2:04:44 And you have the opportunity to begin to share some of those ideas.

2:04:48 We wanted to make sure that there was enough prep work done with water, waste water, sidewalks,

2:04:57 streets, all of those conversations, the values of parks and trail systems,

2:05:03 so that when long-term planning stands before you next week,

2:05:07 that you have a really good position to say, these are the things that we think

2:05:11 that we would like to see this budget focus on.

2:05:14 They can take that information and put that into their decision-making processes.

2:05:23 Anything else from the Council?

2:05:25 Travis, thank you for bringing this information to us.

2:05:29 I think even though we've been hearing about talent challenges with our employers for many,

2:05:36 many months now, I think sometimes we just forget to remember to look here and those

2:05:43 problems are not unique to the city and they're not unique to business.

2:05:47 So to see some data behind it and understand that the challenges is important.

2:05:52 I will say too, I really like kind of the reworking of the graphic of how our strategic

2:05:58 initiatives all line up with each other.

2:06:00 I know when we went through the strategic planning process, there was a level of importance coming

2:06:06 from the council that we wanted to make sure our employees were a key part of the strategic

2:06:11 plan, but I think the way that got plugged in as an initiative like the other ones wasn't

2:06:18 quite accurate and I think that this demonstrates that perhaps a little better of these are our

2:06:24 strategic goals and they all take our human resources to make those happen.

2:06:29 So thank you.

2:06:30 And we'll look forward to the solutions next time.

2:06:35 Here's one meeting with just a solution and a happy story.

2:06:42 The next item on the agenda is public input.

2:06:44 Is there anyone in the public who would like to address the council on an item that was not

2:06:48 on the agenda this evening?

2:06:53 I'm Max Newlin, 327th Avenue East, and I've benefited from some of you new curbs around my

2:07:01 neighborhood, so it's nice to see new curbs.

2:07:03 There's a happy story.

2:07:05 Also today is Pi Day, 3.14, and so I want to have good news about that.

2:07:11 It's late in the day, so you're still going to meet Pi.

2:07:14 I was particularly pleased with Travis's presentation about one city.

2:07:20 I think that's a nice little catchphrase to talk about in our stressful times and we're

2:07:26 all in the same boat so let's celebrate that.

2:07:29 Thank you.

2:07:30 Thank you.

2:07:31 Max are up by 110,000, 3.1415 and this is 1.6 today.

2:07:38 You can round it.

2:07:39 We'll share a round it up.

2:07:42 No, I didn't know they were rude.

2:07:48 I mean, I read it on Facebook, okay.

2:07:50 Are there any other items from the city manager?

2:07:55 Do you have anything else?

2:07:57 The other items from city council.

2:07:59 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:08:00 Thank you.

2:08:01 So last week was the monthly meeting of our public library board.

2:08:06 And I am here to invite everyone on council on.

2:08:12 Excuse me, Monday, April 11th at 4 o'clock,

2:08:15 I know it'll be a quick stop before Council Monday night.

2:08:19 But that week is National Library Week, and they are giving thanks

2:08:24 to their volunteers and different people,

2:08:26 and they asked if Council members would please just stop

2:08:28 in briefly, five minutes, 15 minutes, whatever you can do,

2:08:31 and thank the volunteers who helped keep our library going.

2:08:34 They're also having a competition right now to name the bookmobile

2:08:38 that they will announce the winner that week.

2:08:41 So it will be a chance to do that.

2:08:43 And real quick, I want to take a chance while I see the opportunities, while I see Matt Barnes in the back.

2:08:47 Last week I had the great privilege of taking a group of my family out to the airport,

2:08:53 and that gave us a wonderful tour, showed us all around, and anybody who can entertain my grandchildren for two hours is superb.

2:09:00 So thank you very much.

2:09:04 Thank you, Suzanne.

2:09:06 Anyone else from the council?

2:09:08 I would remind everyone that the annual St. Patrick's Day Parade is this Thursday at 5 o'clock

2:09:14 instead of noon this year and it's a great opportunity to help support all of those great

2:09:19 downtown businesses.

2:09:22 Seeing no other items from anyone, meeting's adjourned.

2:09:26 Erin Go Pearl.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 14, 2016. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:09:35.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    91e16a7459d6b7f4ba013a7e75e24d5de7b74034c6b4e7ebac0b9070c515c5c1
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 2a6d598a7400ef4d3272918fb9dc6f4c67cf16ef77eae02149fb83060a9946f4
    part02.m4a 556614308d5c3162f722cec61b41757bbdf23d8b26db7c23dcc01ae7c9d7efde
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    5fc10d729f687cfee3974f5d847716cc0bc59225155fa1438cce5bb88fca97b9

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file