City Council meeting
Monday, December 14, 2015
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 December 14th 2015 and I don't see any Boy Scouts. I invite you up, Bill, because I know you were an Eagle Scout
0:00:08 But that was a couple years ago, so I won't make you do it. Those of you wishing to, would you please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance?
0:00:15 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:30 We'd like to welcome everyone.
0:00:35 Thank you for being here this evening.
0:00:36 We do have a form of the city council.
0:00:38 All seven members are here.
0:00:40 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments
0:00:42 to our agenda this evening?
0:00:44 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:00:45 there are no amendments this evening.
0:00:47 Excellent, thank you, Travis.
0:00:48 This is a portion where we open it up to the public.
0:00:50 If there's anyone here that would like to address
0:00:52 the council that's not on an agenda item,
0:00:55 we'll have time for those later.
0:00:56 This is your opportunity to come forward
0:00:58 and address the council.
0:00:59 Is there anyone that would like to do that?
0:01:03 Moving on to the consent calendar.
0:01:05 I'll turn that over to council for their direction.
0:01:09 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:10 Move approval of the consent calendar as printed.
0:01:15 Second.
0:01:16 We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,
0:01:19 seconded by Sean Berger to approve the consent calendar
0:01:22 as posted.
0:01:23 Anything on that motion council?
0:01:28 Sharon, roll call vote, please.
0:01:30 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:31 Yes.
0:01:32 Jim Mann.
0:01:32 Yes.
0:01:33 Sean Berger.
0:01:34 Yes.
0:01:35 Chris Hawking.
0:01:35 Yes.
0:01:36 Greg Lanthine.
0:01:38 Yes.
0:01:39 Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Mills-Soyka. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Moving now to items for consideration.
0:01:46 The first item is consideration of a request to approve John Van England to serve as a
0:01:53 library trustee. And we have our library director, Tara Bartley. Welcome Tara. Mayor Hall, our
0:02:04 city council representatives, Van Hawkins and city council members. Thank you. Thank you
0:02:09 for your time today.
0:02:11 I would like to introduce you to John, current board members
0:02:15 of the Trustees of the Twin Falls Public Library,
0:02:18 request that John Van Anglin, who resides at 2544 Carriage Way
0:02:22 Twin Falls, be appointed by the City Council to serve
0:02:26 as library trustee for a full term of office from January 2016
0:02:31 through December 2020.
0:02:33 Mr. Van Anglin expresses a strong interest in the library
0:02:36 and he did this in two different ways.
0:02:39 Initially, he sent a letter of application to show his desire
0:02:44 to be a library trustee, as well as he sat in an interview
0:02:48 with Ford of our five trustees and city manager, Travis
0:02:52 Rothweiler.
0:02:53 I'd like to take just a moment and read a little bit from the
0:02:56 letter that he submitted.
0:03:00 While growing up in Twin Falls, I remember with great fondness
0:03:03 my trips to the public library.
0:03:05 It was a special place then and today, although being absent
0:03:08 from Twin Falls most of my working career.
0:03:10 When I go now, I experience the same joyful feelings
0:03:14 I cherished when I was young.
0:03:16 Although I have no special training
0:03:18 in library science or operations,
0:03:20 I believe my many personal experiences
0:03:22 in business and life as well as serving
0:03:24 on other non-profit boards may be helpful.
0:03:27 I think you would find me to be a gregarious
0:03:29 and committed member of the board.
0:03:31 On a personal note, my grandfather, father,
0:03:34 and sister have all served as trustees,
0:03:37 And I would consider it a privilege to serve as they did.
0:03:41 And like I said, as you can see, he has shown desire
0:03:46 to be part of the trustee.
0:03:47 And I just think he's a wonderful candidate.
0:03:50 And I'd like to introduce you to John.
0:03:57 John, would you like to come up and say anything?
0:04:03 Well, thank you for allowing me to come here tonight.
0:04:09 What I wrote is what I meant.
0:04:10 I truly love the public library.
0:04:14 And I would love to be, I'm looking forward to being selected to be part of the effort
0:04:23 to make it continue to go as it has gone.
0:04:26 I think it's been, I've been to a number of different libraries.
0:04:29 I've been Spokane, Tri-Cities, Kansas, and so forth.
0:04:33 And whenever I would travel, I would go to libraries because that's where I like to hang
0:04:41 out, I'd like to read books and so forth.
0:04:44 But here in Twin Falls, I think we have a very, very special place, not only is it right
0:04:49 on next to City Park, it's pretty special inside as well.
0:04:54 So when I moved back here with my wife just about four years ago and got hooked up with
0:05:00 the library at that time, I feel pretty good about it.
0:05:05 So we go down there frequently.
0:05:07 And actually it was my sister Judy who saw the advertisement in the Times News for a
0:05:14 trustee position, I guess I missed it.
0:05:17 So she clipped it out and said, you know, you like to read, you love the library, you
0:05:21 go there a lot.
0:05:23 Why don't you think about becoming a trustee?
0:05:27 And I thought, well, yes, I think I would like to do that.
0:05:30 So if Willy, I'm willing to serve and I'd be very excited to do so.
0:05:35 Thank you, John.
0:05:37 Council any questions or direction Chris talking John. I just I missed your address you do live in the city limits
0:05:45 I do actually a little bit
0:05:47 24 kerry
0:05:49 Thank you. Thank you
0:05:51 Suzanne Hawkins
0:05:53 Thank you. I just wanted that's okay. I'm just gonna address the council John. Thank you
0:05:57 So I am the liaison to the library board and they did have three qualified applicants
0:06:03 They did go through a thorough interview process.
0:06:06 I don't think they could have gone wrong with any of the three,
0:06:08 but John did stand out from his letter.
0:06:10 He attended the last board meeting with us to get a fill
0:06:13 for what was going on, and I would like to add my recommendation
0:06:16 that he be appointed to that position.
0:06:19 Is that a motion?
0:06:20 That is a motion.
0:06:22 We have a motion on the floor.
0:06:23 Seconded by Greg Lanti.
0:06:25 My only concern with John is that there's not enough tenure in your family.
0:06:29 family.
0:06:30 Okay.
0:06:31 That's it.
0:06:32 Do we have anything further on the motion?
0:06:36 Sharon, Melco, please.
0:06:39 Jim Mundt.
0:06:40 Yes.
0:06:41 Sean Bericher.
0:06:42 Yes.
0:06:43 Chris Hockington.
0:06:44 Yes.
0:06:45 Greg Lanting.
0:06:46 Yes.
0:06:47 Don Hall.
0:06:48 Yes.
0:06:49 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:06:50 Yes.
0:06:51 Suzanne Hocking.
0:06:52 Yes.
0:06:53 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:06:54 I just wanted to add my voice.
0:06:56 Welcome board.
0:06:57 John, that is an incredibly special place.
0:06:59 my family are avid, eracious readers.
0:07:03 I'm not one of them, but my rest of my family are,
0:07:05 and they absolutely love that library,
0:07:08 and I couldn't be more excited that you're part of it.
0:07:13 Thank you.
0:07:15 Moving to the next item on,
0:07:17 items for consideration is consideration
0:07:19 of a request to renew the PSI sanitation contract.
0:07:23 We have Mr. William Baxter.
0:07:26 Welcome, Mr. Baxter.
0:07:28 Mr. Mayor, members of the City Council,
0:07:30 thank you very much and this I didn't know that was going to be that far more than I can.
0:07:35 That usually means I'm in trouble.
0:07:42 The first thing I would like to point out as we come back to this conversation about the
0:07:48 PSI contract that the city has with BSI, in my conclusion in the first paragraph, first
0:07:56 I was in, I had intent to change that September 30th date to July 1st.
0:08:03 Lori and I talked about this and as we looked this over, she suggested I not run the contract
0:08:12 negotiations right up to the end of the budget period.
0:08:16 So we're going to pull that back to July 1st so that we can come before you buy that
0:08:20 date with the options that we negotiate over.
0:08:28 The reason for tonight's presentation is that we were instructed in May 11th to come back
0:08:35 with some negotiated options for the BSI contract to address council questions and concerns
0:08:42 about the service and what types of services were available.
0:08:47 We started having those conversations in June, and then with the city's budgeting and PSI's
0:08:52 budgeting for their calendar year, and we have some thoughts we'd like to put before you
0:09:00 and get any questions and feedback on what those options might look like before we go
0:09:06 very far in negotiating and come back with a contract.
0:09:09 The request tonight would be to have an addendum signed extending the contract for a year, allowing
0:09:16 us this time to negotiate and try to address the concerns Council has in the best way possible.
0:09:22 For that piece of the conversation, Les Reitz and Jeff Webster are here from PSI to do that
0:09:29 presentation, talk a little bit about the final comment and take any questions.
0:09:34 And I won't be far away.
0:09:36 Thank you, Bill.
0:09:41 You're welcome.
0:09:42 Welcome, gentlemen.
0:09:43 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council.
0:09:46 Actually, my name is Jeff Brewster, but Webster works fine as well.
0:09:50 It doesn't mean I'm in trouble when you call me that, so.
0:09:53 Yeah, yeah, we're just here, obviously,
0:09:56 we've been discussing this with staff for a little bit,
0:09:59 kind of working on some thoughts to address
0:10:01 some of the concerns that the council had
0:10:02 in our meeting in May.
0:10:04 Just to obviously increase diversion
0:10:06 of recyclable materials and then address the issues
0:10:09 of people that quite frankly don't have a lot of volume
0:10:11 to help drop their rates on a monthly basis.
0:10:14 So some of those things are, I'm going to go ahead
0:10:17 and kind of turn that over to last for a few of the things
0:10:20 we're looking to propose.
0:10:21 Some of the items we're looking to propose is a cam size.
0:10:25 Presently the arbitrage is we have the 95 gallon
0:10:28 and the 35 gallon, which there's roughly, I think,
0:10:31 77 people in town that have this small cart.
0:10:34 We propose having more of the smaller cart
0:10:37 along with the single stream recycling container.
0:10:40 And maybe one or two other options, maybe a 65.
0:10:44 Maybe we do away for 35, we'll go to a 65 and a 95,
0:10:47 put different pricing ranges through that and with that we can cover the
0:10:51 gauntlet of not only senior citizens but low volume users. People that want to
0:10:56 recycle are there. Some of the items we see on recycling, some people don't care.
0:11:03 It's got an orange lid, I'm gonna build a whole trash. Somehow we have to be able to
0:11:08 make that person aware that there's gonna be a financial hardship for using
0:11:14 that for a trash can. It's not a trash can. So, you know, we constantly, probably one of
0:11:20 these calls we get unrecycling, because you missed my garbage that was full of trash for
0:11:24 recycled revenue, and we're not dumping. People not dumping. So, like going to different
0:11:29 sized carts, either they're charged for extras or they get content of carton only, they can
0:11:35 have multiple carts. But it states, it works only through the line that every family size
0:11:43 can get a service that's them, and all with a recycling option.
0:11:49 Yeah, and the hope is to structure obviously pricing for that.
0:11:52 So obviously, customers that have large volume in it is MSW,
0:11:56 obviously being able to charge a little bit more for those,
0:11:58 most of you want to shrink to a smart container,
0:12:00 and add more recycled cards, maybe make
0:12:02 three-second containers much, much less.
0:12:05 So maybe it's only a dollar a month for that,
0:12:07 but maybe $5 for extra trash containers,
0:12:09 just to encourage more diversion,
0:12:11 and really drive that another day.
0:12:13 We're really trying to help everybody and get some of the services out there that quite frankly everybody does want if they do want it very
0:12:20 More quality and land. So that's what we're hoping to accomplish with this
0:12:24 One of the things with recycling were the contamination
0:12:28 Kind of we proposed the staff was maybe them to strikes you out freeze rights
0:12:33 You're out that we get a ticket that if they're can is contaminated with garbage
0:12:37 We're going to call the office, the driver fills it out.
0:12:41 We hang one on the door, bring one copy to the city, and we keep one and log it.
0:12:46 So everybody involved knows that this home is on stage one of alerting that they're contaminating
0:12:51 the recycling.
0:12:52 Second time we go through, then it's a different card.
0:12:59 Third time, they have to pay for a special use of a special pickup because they're continuing
0:13:06 to contaminate the recycling and it's actually garbage at that point time,
0:13:09 which they're not paying for a second or extra garbage.
0:13:12 The good thing about that is that is very low volume number of people
0:13:17 who are abusing that system, but when they do, they end up with those contaminated
0:13:20 loads and make the recycling work that much less, because now they have to go
0:13:24 through it and fly any trash that's in there and then still go through the
0:13:27 sorting process, so it just really degrades from products that they're sending to meals.
0:13:31 So that's why that's so important to eliminate that as best we can.
0:13:35 And you're never going to eliminate it completely, but the less volume we can send its contaminator for that.
0:13:41 Obviously, another option that we would need to look at or at least consider with these changes would be
0:13:47 being able to charge extra amounts for high volume MSW users or people that are contaminating the recycling stream.
0:13:55 So one of the options on the table we discussed with staff was taking over the billing for PSI.
0:14:00 PSI have started doing a bill that you could charge for extras to build specific residents
0:14:06 that need the extra volume or have the issues with the recycling.
0:14:10 They seem very open to that as well.
0:14:13 But obviously, you would have to send a report to you guys each month or your staff each month.
0:14:18 At least the draft suit is getting charged and then he's not for once.
0:14:22 I know the way the current contract is written.
0:14:24 We have a certain number of small container users that we allow,
0:14:27 But this is the option there would be no way to do what to have less MSW while you will do what you say before.
0:14:36 MSW?
0:14:38 Trash.
0:14:39 Okay.
0:14:40 You know, in government we love acronyms.
0:14:44 Most people don't know what they do.
0:14:46 Material solublies.
0:14:47 Okay.
0:14:48 So trash.
0:14:49 Yes, trash.
0:14:50 Great landing has a question.
0:14:51 Question less on the recycling that they get a warning that their first strike with that with that warning have a list of things that are
0:14:59 Acceptable to be recycled and things just in case they're just don't know
0:15:06 Right
0:15:21 Tracking that address would have it, but at least the customer's portion may be the top
0:15:28 industry copy set, the copy that stays with the homeowner or the renter has all the acceptable
0:15:34 items and how they can be processed or maintained in there.
0:15:39 My second question would be, I know currently we pretty much accept anything that's at the
0:15:45 curb and well within reason of course but in other words if they act extra bags of
0:15:50 grass or a little time thing would that go away with the new determining the
0:15:56 volume to have a truly effective recycling program we'd almost have to be
0:16:00 allowed to charge for those that extra volume yes okay so in other words it'd be
0:16:05 be a little the analogy I would make in my mind would be it's a little like her
0:16:09 water if you use this amount of water you you pay this much you use this much
0:16:13 water. So the trash would be moving to more of a situation like that. The more
0:16:18 trash you have, the more you're going to pay and the less ready to have, and that
0:16:23 of course in my mind that really would encourage recycling because if I'm
0:16:28 having to pay extra because I always have extra trash out there and I'm not
0:16:34 recycling very effectively, I could save myself money by recycling.
0:16:38 Okay.
0:16:39 Thank you.
0:16:41 Chris talking.
0:16:42 Well, first of all, let me start off by commending your company.
0:16:46 I'm a big supporter of everything you guys have done.
0:16:50 Anything to do with recycling.
0:16:51 And I think the confluence of the residents and PSI and the city have really made recycling
0:17:00 policy for life that we can all endorse and try to improve all the time.
0:17:06 The missing ingredient is all of the reduced landfill that we have or the lack of landfill
0:17:13 that we're now sending, we get absolutely no credit through South Central Waste District.
0:17:21 I'd like to tap your mind and you think is there anything we can do, anything that we're
0:17:26 missing that beat on because they even have it in their mission statement about encouraging
0:17:33 recycling and that they do a lot of talk and no walk.
0:17:36 Yes, and that really kind of reducing the volume of the pain of her tongue rate, obviously
0:17:42 that's going to, the more diversion you get with recycling materials will drop that touch
0:17:47 field and obviously that will go down some.
0:17:49 But yeah, we'd certainly have to work with them.
0:17:52 We were working with them a little bit over the past couple years about considering a green
0:17:55 waste program which would seriously reduce the volume going into the plan.
0:18:00 They're not quite ready or prepared to start a program like that, but certainly some of them are still still there.
0:18:06 We reduced our tonnage, as I recall the figures, I may be out of date by over 1,100 tons sent to recycling as opposed to landfill.
0:18:15 Nothing's changing.
0:18:16 That's right.
0:18:21 Last correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that we're probably closer to 7,500 tons over the course since the exception of the program.
0:18:29 Yeah, we're okay.
0:18:31 I'll stand corrected by any numbers and calendar month we're doing about twenty one to twenty two pounds per home per month
0:18:38 What works out to be at the 14,000 plus homes?
0:18:42 So another recycling month? Yes
0:18:48 Well put a tap your mind
0:18:59 You think so
0:19:01 They claim they have fixed costs, but if you're making less operating hours under
0:19:07 dozers and everything else, it does reduce their cost.
0:19:12 Greg Lang, I think what Chris is from, we are paying less per ton, but then every
0:19:19 time we send less tundies, then they have to raise their rate a little bit.
0:19:23 So you really, we, yeah, we end up being more like a fixed rate.
0:19:29 So hopefully we can affect some change there.
0:19:33 Obviously, we don't want our own landfill.
0:19:36 No, they don't have the whole history to do this fine,
0:19:38 you know, and it will last longer,
0:19:40 and therefore reduce the cost of it.
0:19:45 The question I have about the violations,
0:19:47 and maybe the sanctions related to that first morning,
0:19:51 second morning, and their spines or more costs,
0:19:55 is, and I know that you're gonna be leaving some literature
0:19:57 there for educational purposes,
0:19:59 but is there any thought of reaching out to those folks,
0:20:03 because I would submit to you that some of them maybe
0:20:06 are just confused, maybe at a stage of their life
0:20:12 where they're not processing things as well as we did
0:20:15 at one time and is there any thought of maybe trying
0:20:17 to knock on the door, talk to the folks.
0:20:20 I don't know if that's even possible for you folks.
0:20:22 I know you're busy and you've got routes
0:20:23 but maybe in conjunction with the city
0:20:26 we could do something like that.
0:20:27 Absolutely, I mean it would be more difficult
0:20:29 obviously to walk up their door but in a lot of cases
0:20:31 especially if we had the customer contact info,
0:20:34 if we were doing the billing we could easily give them
0:20:36 call and at least let them know why that notes on their
0:20:40 container in the first place and we'll discuss what options are out there.
0:20:43 Another thing that we're proposing to do with the new agreement is do a lot more
0:20:48 outreach during the year. We have been doing stuff local schools and the
0:20:52 all-netries and that seems to be the best minds to tap into because they'll
0:20:56 take a home and have force recycling on them but we do want to do more with the
0:21:01 general public as well just have more things out there whether it be
0:21:05 I would just think trying to really reach them and I don't know if that's television ads to remind them how you recycle what you can recycle something just send that message because I think I think sometimes what you're seeing is folks getting confused what goes in which
0:21:28 I'd say the worst of you is really what frustrates not only us but the recycling center is those
0:21:35 folks.
0:21:36 We have had some that just would have full of dirt and everybody should know that that's not
0:21:41 acceptable recycled material.
0:21:42 So that's been some of the problem.
0:21:44 It's been pretty amazing what we've seen in some of those containers.
0:21:47 But like I said, it isn't a rare problem, but it needs to be something that we can address
0:21:51 and really attack that to fix the issues.
0:21:54 Sure.
0:21:55 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:21:56 Thank you Mayor.
0:21:57 Thank you for your thoughts and your report.
0:22:00 I think it's great to encourage recycling and I want to do that.
0:22:04 I do have a concern about moving away from the one rate for unlimited pickup, so to speak.
0:22:13 Because I've heard complaints in other communities like the state of Washington has a very strict trash pickup policy
0:22:20 and you know, trash tends to vary in a lot of our users' households.
0:22:25 holds, you know, one week you might have some additional trash, but another week you might
0:22:29 not put your can out and so I think people can get frustrated if they don't get credit
0:22:35 for that week that they didn't put their can out and then if they just happen to have
0:22:38 a peak in their volume then they're getting fined and essentially paying more for the same
0:22:44 service that they were receiving previously and that's my only concern.
0:22:48 I would hate for the public to feel like they're all of a sudden paying more for a service
0:22:54 that they've been getting at a certain rate
0:22:57 for the past five years.
0:23:00 But you guys, I also just want to mention you guys
0:23:02 do a wonderful job and you're very attentive to our customers
0:23:06 and you respond rapidly to any issues that come up.
0:23:11 So I have no concerns about approving the contract
0:23:15 in the future, but just I do have a concern
0:23:19 about moving that to a pay per volume kind of system.
0:23:24 I have to address that situation.
0:23:27 I mean, it's certainly something that we could consider offering.
0:23:30 Maybe if it's just a one-time thing, maybe we do take two or three extra bags,
0:23:34 but if it becomes something that's going underneath,
0:23:37 then we either ask them to get a second container,
0:23:40 or we do allow to charge for that extra volume.
0:23:42 So I certainly agree with that.
0:23:44 I mean, sometimes we have that time for a week and a week,
0:23:46 and they do enough of the weeks with the staff.
0:23:48 I'd like to bring Bill Baster in on this feedback there still bill.
0:24:07 In previous time I brought up a proposition the council that didn't get a second or anything
0:24:13 It's talking about the number of seniors that we have in town that not only do they
0:24:19 not use one can in a week, they don't use one can's worth a trash in a month.
0:24:25 They sometimes get quite frustrated and they're looking at why they have to pay so much because
0:24:33 it does represent a subsidy they're paying to others.
0:24:37 I wonder if there is a way that the Council could identify seniors or if it would identify
0:24:44 seniors, single seniors or some criteria that represents an extremely low usage rate.
0:24:54 And within our city computer system just coding a credit back to them to an effective, they
0:25:02 may reduce rate without adjusting all the rates.
0:25:05 There's no reason why that could not be done, could it?
0:25:09 The only thing that would require some thought on that particular piece is that we don't
0:25:17 do any kind of a check on the residents at a particular address at the present time.
0:25:24 We spot check if there is a problem, but on with water or sewer or the sanitation collection
0:25:32 issues.
0:25:33 But we don't have a good way once we have registered a tenant or an owner of a property
0:25:40 residing at that property to keep track of any hospitalizations, death, family moving in.
0:25:46 Those kind of things, we usually wait until somebody calls and says we need to change the account.
0:25:52 But we do have a rate for a specified number of seniors that qualified as of some date
0:25:58 in the past that we provided different rate to.
0:26:02 That is true, that those are the grandfather and account owners that have the one can rate
0:26:07 and that one can does not leave that address.
0:26:10 So there is some risk that somebody else moves in and starts using this.
0:26:14 That's what I'm wondering.
0:26:15 If we can't keep track of what I suggested, we're certain we're not keeping track of the other.
0:26:19 It is not easy.
0:26:20 And part of that conversation, if I recall correctly, of the identifying the seniors who are the low users
0:26:27 could we restrict it to just seniors or are there people in town who would want to utilize
0:26:35 that same service and then at what point do you bring it back in line and say well you
0:26:40 know it's too hard to manage but certainly we'd be willing to look at all these things
0:26:45 it's one of the reasons PSI have such a wonderful partner. Sure thank you.
0:26:49 If you want just my thoughts on that, we're simply, if I don't want to limit it to just
0:26:57 senior citizens with this program that we're discussing, if they have very low volume, we
0:27:01 want to be able to offer that to anybody that wants to recycle more at this time, a really
0:27:05 low volume for their domestic trash.
0:27:09 So if they only have like a 35 gun can that's even going every other week, we want to be
0:27:14 able to offer that lower price.
0:27:15 Yeah, and I'm talking about the extreme cases of a person and of a certain age living alone and and they just
0:27:23 They virtually have a little plastic bag every week or two
0:27:26 So, yeah, maybe that's something that they do only go once every other week to offer garage
0:27:33 door service for a specified number of senior citizens that could benefit from that, where
0:27:38 we'll actually go up their garage and bring their trash container down to the house and
0:27:41 come back.
0:27:42 So, there are some options that we can put to help out pretty much every company.
0:27:46 But I don't want to limit it to just senior citizens because there are some folks out
0:27:51 there that are really agreeing that they want to be the right thing and they do want
0:27:55 to have very little trash volume and recycling water.
0:27:58 We went off of that same discount for those folks as well.
0:28:02 Joe, did you want to weigh in?
0:28:03 Yeah, I think one of the things that we can do
0:28:04 is we can look at a whole series of creative approaches
0:28:07 to what this looks like at the end of the day.
0:28:10 There is a final amount of money that we have to pay
0:28:14 to PSI to take the trash and to move that from the individual
0:28:21 locations to the various transportation stations into the landfill.
0:28:27 That has a cost and there is no markup on that cost per se.
0:28:32 It's the way we operate the sanitation fund is a dollars in and a dollars out.
0:28:38 And so if you give a credit to some portion of your customers,
0:28:43 it is important that in order to balance, you're going to have to increase that cost to another collection of your customers.
0:28:51 And we will work with PSI in a series of options, but when we do that we want to make sure that
0:28:57 we are completely laying out the cost and the benefit to all of the different categories
0:29:02 so that the Council can understand the ramifications of the individual decisions.
0:29:07 Having the conversation today generically I think is okay, but the problem is without
0:29:12 looking at tangible numbers you may not feel comfortable with any of what those parts may
0:29:16 look like.
0:29:17 my seniors that I'm defending right now can say you've already adjusted the right against
0:29:23 me and I'm subsidizing unnecessary pickups for the low amount of garbage. So it's, it's
0:29:31 depending what side of the creek you're on, I guess where you see the truth or something.
0:29:36 Greg, I agree with Travis. We still have, it's, it's this, we don't subsidize this with
0:29:40 tax money. This still has to balance in some way. So if we're going to do something here,
0:29:45 We're going to have to raise something here.
0:29:47 And so I'm not saying I'm against it, Chris.
0:29:49 I'm just going to agree with Travis.
0:29:50 It has to come out equal in the end.
0:29:53 I'm not planning on putting tax money towards it.
0:29:55 That's that.
0:29:56 I would go ahead.
0:29:57 I was just going to say this sounds like the same debate
0:29:59 that the Salt Waste District says about their fixed cost.
0:30:03 These are fixed costs.
0:30:05 And they've got to be paid.
0:30:07 It's the same kind of concept.
0:30:10 Greg Glading.
0:30:10 Well, so what is our process today?
0:30:14 Are we planning on a motion for?
0:30:16 Well, I was going to ask you, Bill.
0:30:20 So basically, what you're saying on this is that you want to just have an addendum to
0:30:26 keep us going under the proposed existing.
0:30:31 Until July 1st, not September 30th.
0:30:34 That's true.
0:30:35 Okay.
0:30:35 That's true.
0:30:35 I mean, the contract would be extended through September 30th, but we will come back to council
0:30:41 with definite proposals on the options
0:30:44 before we get beefing with the budgeting.
0:30:46 So the actual, welcome to September 30th.
0:30:48 The December 30th to September 30th.
0:30:51 I make a motion that we extend the contract
0:30:52 to September 30th with the expectation
0:30:55 that the negotiations will be completed by July 1st
0:30:58 or premises raised these fingers.
0:31:00 So apparently that motion is not right.
0:31:02 By April 1st.
0:31:03 By April.
0:31:04 I think it's okay to put a little pressure on this.
0:31:05 We've been kind of dragging our feet on this one.
0:31:07 Okay, all right.
0:31:08 So the contract does extend to September 30th,
0:31:11 with the expectation of contract negotiations,
0:31:16 hopefully finished by summer on April 1st.
0:31:19 Second.
0:31:19 And most on board by Greg Lanning,
0:31:21 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated.
0:31:23 Anything further on that motion council?
0:31:26 Before we go to the vote, thank you
0:31:27 for your presentation, South Jersey.
0:31:30 Chair.
0:31:31 Sean Berriger.
0:31:32 Yes.
0:31:34 Chris Tockington.
0:31:34 Yes.
0:31:35 Greg Lanthi.
0:31:36 Yes.
0:31:37 Don Hall. Yes.
0:31:38 Rebecca Mills-Soyka, Suzanne Hawkins, Jim Mundt.
0:31:43 Yes, motion passes seven-zero.
0:31:46 Moving to the next item, update on the main avenue
0:31:49 redesign project by Mandy Roberts from Otak.
0:31:53 Welcome, I'll end, Melinda Anderson, welcome Melinda.
0:31:56 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, good evening council.
0:31:59 As you can see, Mandy Roberts from Otak is here tonight.
0:32:02 This is her first visit with you since August,
0:32:05 when she was here to present the overall
0:32:08 main avenue redesign design, and you all,
0:32:12 what she has for feedback, what she provided,
0:32:14 you basically liked what you saw,
0:32:16 and so since then, Mandy and her engineering and design team
0:32:21 have been busy working to develop the 60% plans
0:32:27 for at least part of the main avenue project,
0:32:30 which we dubbed 1A, which is main avenue
0:32:32 from Shoshone Street to Fairfield Street,
0:32:35 as well as getting started in some of the 1B
0:32:37 which you're looking at a picture of right now,
0:32:39 which is the part of the plaza next to the new city hall.
0:32:42 But anyway, Mandy's here to provide that update to you.
0:32:46 So I'll give it over to Mandy, thanks.
0:32:48 Welcome Mandy.
0:32:50 Thank you, Mayor and Council members.
0:32:52 It's a pleasure to be here on the snowy evening.
0:32:55 We don't get much snow in Seattle,
0:32:56 so it's nice to see it today.
0:33:00 So I did wanna just mention before I show you
0:33:03 some of the design updates that everything's moving ahead
0:33:07 according to schedule.
0:33:09 And just as you'll recall, there are
0:33:12 two phases of main avenue improvements in design,
0:33:17 in final design at this time.
0:33:19 Phase 1A includes Fairfield to Shoshone.
0:33:24 And that is due to be bid in mid-February.
0:33:27 It's coming right up.
0:33:29 And we anticipate that then construction would start.
0:33:32 We're saying spring of 2016, but in a couple months
0:33:35 after that, so in April, the anticipated start date
0:33:38 for that segment.
0:33:40 And then phase one B basically includes the rest
0:33:43 of main avenue from Shoshone to Jerome,
0:33:47 as well as Hanson and the extension between the two
0:33:51 second avenues and the downtown commons improvements.
0:33:55 And that is scheduled to go to bed in mid-May
0:33:59 with work anticipated to start later in the summer in 2016.
0:34:04 So we're excited about that.
0:34:05 At the same time, there is also work on a demolition package
0:34:09 being developed.
0:34:10 We're working with Hummel.
0:34:12 And that demolition package will be coordinated
0:34:17 with Star Corporation, the CMGC involved in City Hall,
0:34:22 and will include the demolition of the Rogerson Building,
0:34:26 as well as the Fountain area across the street
0:34:29 from the Rogerson Building.
0:34:31 And of course, with the partial demolition of the banner building for City Hall.
0:34:37 So that is actually anticipated to be started, the demolition work to be started in around
0:34:42 February of next year as well.
0:34:45 So lots of exciting things coming up next year in this process, lots of changes.
0:34:51 So what you see on the display screen there is an update of the main, or excuse me, the
0:34:57 Downtown Commons Plaza.
0:35:00 We've been working really closely with Hummel Architects
0:35:03 to integrate the design elements of the Plaza with City Hall
0:35:08 and to really make that area read and feel like an extension
0:35:13 of civic space with City Hall.
0:35:17 We've got Festival Street segments
0:35:19 on the Hanson Street area between City Hall and Downtown
0:35:23 Commons.
0:35:23 Festival Streets are, again, raised, curbless street areas
0:35:27 that can function as pedestrian plazas
0:35:30 during special events.
0:35:32 And we also have a festival street on Main Avenue
0:35:35 in front of the plaza there.
0:35:38 I'm showing this view first and then I'll show a plan view.
0:35:41 One of the key features that you see there
0:35:44 is a stream or river design element.
0:35:48 It's not real water, but we will use coloring
0:35:53 and texturing of concrete to create this element
0:35:56 that runs all the way through the plaza.
0:35:59 And working with Hummel, the idea is that
0:36:02 that element can extend across the street and into City Hall
0:36:06 and may even find its way in the flooring treatment
0:36:09 of City Hall.
0:36:11 It becomes a really nice way to soften up
0:36:13 all of the paving that is the plaza,
0:36:17 as well as a way to maybe provide a journey
0:36:20 through the downtown commons.
0:36:22 And we've talked about having a stamping
0:36:25 or messaging in the concrete along the way that might tell the whole history from the
0:36:33 prehistory of southern Idaho tribal history to settlement, to irrigation development, to
0:36:41 modern era and the different cultures that live here today.
0:36:45 So, it could be a really great element and it really ties in well with some of the discussions
0:36:49 and the presentation that Hummel gave a few weeks ago
0:36:53 looking at historic displays and displays of the Bizbee photos
0:36:58 as part of the city hall ground floor.
0:37:01 So we're looking at that too.
0:37:05 This is a plan view of the Plaza one
0:37:08 that's a little bit more zoomed in on the left
0:37:10 and then one that shows overall the area,
0:37:14 the downtown commons area.
0:37:16 You see that we have the city hall floor plan in there
0:37:19 And we also have been working on a floor plan for our restroom, storage, mechanical building.
0:37:24 And I'll show you more detail on that in a moment.
0:37:27 We are starting to look at the idea of, because this area is very flat and we want to have
0:37:32 a really good drainage, of gradually sloping the plaza northward and having a very simple
0:37:40 grand staircase that would raise up by two or three stairs, that's this element that you
0:37:46 see.
0:37:55 So this could be gradual stare, and then you'd have ADA ramp access, very gradual around
0:38:02 the sides of that.
0:38:04 And then we're also looking at maybe having some slab, concrete, or rock seating areas along
0:38:13 the stream.
0:38:15 We are going to look at some pockets of landscape and green, trying to keep it somewhat minimal
0:38:21 and easy to maintain, but also to just soften up that sense of the plaza and create places
0:38:26 for people to sit and watch the spray play activity.
0:38:30 One of the coolest features is that we've got some simple scoring of the concrete happening
0:38:37 here and it's a true north-south east-west scoring and it actually starts right here
0:38:45 in the center of the intersection and goes all the way through the spray pad, which we
0:38:52 are now envisioning as a compass, which would really help people be oriented to the way that
0:38:57 downtown is skewed on the diagonal. So we are anticipating that with colored concrete we'll
0:39:05 be able to articulate the compass and then we'll have spray jets that are aligned with
0:39:12 some of the major points of the Compass Rose.
0:39:17 Go on to a little bit of organization of space.
0:39:22 One of the things that we've talked about in the past
0:39:25 is that there's going to be a blank wall here
0:39:29 when the Rushson is demolished.
0:39:32 That wall has some structural relationship
0:39:34 to the adjacent wall.
0:39:36 And because of that, there's going
0:39:39 to be a lot of engineering that happens
0:39:41 to reinforce that, stabilize that.
0:39:44 And we will want to avoid not having too much structural
0:39:47 bearing or too many elements along this area here.
0:39:52 So we've been starting to look at really having this be a
0:39:55 corridor, a corridor of access that people can get through
0:40:00 with the parking area back here.
0:40:02 It also can be a flexible space where you might set up the
0:40:05 hot chocolate kiosk or other market booths or stands along
0:40:10 that wall, and those would be a simple way not to have too much structure and too much
0:40:15 design detail happening along that wall. Also, we still have space for the portable ice skating
0:40:22 rink. The splash pad will be at grade, and as we've talked about in the past, even the
0:40:28 stream design element will be at grade. So in the winter, you can set a portable ice skating
0:40:36 rink up in here, and we're going to work hard to make sure that we don't have any design
0:40:41 elements that would get in the way of how that would work.
0:40:45 Let's see.
0:40:46 I think we are also talking about some low seating walls along City Hall, and at some locations
0:40:55 in the plaza as well for just some additional seating for people, but at the same time we've
0:41:02 talked about keeping this area fairly open so that you can have people bringing their
0:41:07 and in the performance space, the stairway that I talked about earlier will then raise that area up slightly and differentiate it from the audience, which really helps in terms of just kind of defining where performance can happen.
0:41:23 It's pretty flexible and you can have a lot of different sizes of bands or a school concert or whatever in that performance space.
0:41:32 So we've got, we will have some walls in the downtown commons area.
0:41:41 We've thrown out some different ideas for people to react to.
0:41:46 And one of the ones that people really like the most is having some kind of mural face,
0:41:51 which would be an artist opportunity in the commons.
0:41:55 And sorry about that.
0:42:00 That just really lends itself well to reiterating the business.
0:42:04 reiterating the Bisbee photographs in a mural, which is also something that we've been talking
0:42:10 about for City Hall having Bisbee photographs there. So you could articulate, this is just
0:42:17 an illustration, but you could articulate Twin Falls, for example, on the wall in a nice
0:42:24 artistic way. And that could maybe even find its way into the pavement, that flow of the
0:42:29 stream part of that. And then we're talking about compatible materials or materials that
0:42:36 will look similar between City Hall and the downtown commons board formed concrete is one
0:42:44 that we've been looking at together with Hummel for some of the low walls and even for the
0:42:48 face of the restroom building. There's a lot of different options for how that can look
0:42:53 but it tends to really soften a concrete surface and give it some texture and detailing which
0:42:58 which makes it a lot nicer to look at, just some different examples.
0:43:07 And then we will be, we are planning to have unit pavers in the streetscape, in the case
0:43:15 of the downtown commons, we'll be in this area here, and that'll be a place for sidewalk
0:43:23 cafes, tables and chairs, but also some trees and some benches and furnishings.
0:43:29 Then that Paver area, there is a donor brick program going on through the Rotary and the
0:43:38 Twin Falls Community Foundation.
0:43:41 Both of their websites have information if anybody's interested in purchasing a brick
0:43:46 that can be part of the Paver design.
0:43:50 And it can be family names, it could be a message of inspiration, or anything commemorative can
0:43:56 can be placed on those bricks similar to what's out at the visitor center today is the idea.
0:44:02 And then unit pavers will also be used in some of the corners and in the furnishing zones
0:44:10 between the curb and the sidewalk area.
0:44:12 I do have some of the unit paver samples that we're looking at, which this is a really high
0:44:20 quality clay paver, it's very durable.
0:44:31 Can they support the weight of a vehicle?
0:44:36 On the weight of the vehicle, these papers in particular are designed for sidewalk use and
0:44:41 not for driving on.
0:44:43 So we aren't planning to put them anywhere where you would have vehicle traffic just on
0:44:48 the sidewalk.
0:44:49 This is Twin Falls with a lot of pickups.
0:44:51 Sometimes they get on the sidewalks.
0:44:54 Yeah.
0:44:55 If you're a grade, they will be on this.
0:44:58 Yeah.
0:44:59 I've decided to experience from elsewhere with the in-use and at grade and they don't
0:45:04 think they go.
0:45:05 Yes, these are the exact same papers that the city of Boise, oh no.
0:45:08 What did you guys do out there?
0:45:11 I just touched it.
0:45:13 I'll retract my question about the structural integrity of the so on.
0:45:20 These papers are from a company in Nebraska called Endocut Clay Company.
0:45:27 been around for decades. And the City of Boise has adopted these as a standard for many of
0:45:35 their downtown sidewalks. If you go down in Boise, you'll see a lot, especially down in
0:45:41 the core of the downtown. A lot of the sidewalks are being constructed in pavers. Some with
0:45:46 just the furnishing zones in pavers, some where more the entire sidewalk area, like in
0:45:51 in front of the Flying M Coffee Shop.
0:45:55 Whole sidewalk is, you know, pavers.
0:45:57 And these also happen to be the same type of pavers
0:46:00 that are used in front of Glambia down on 4th.
0:46:05 So you can go get a local sense of what they look like
0:46:08 and how they hold up.
0:46:09 When they're installed, they are tightly knit together
0:46:14 and that gives some structural strength to the edges.
0:46:17 So you know what that should be is new depth.
0:46:21 That's right.
0:46:23 So that is my update.
0:46:24 I'm happy to answer any other questions you might have.
0:46:27 We have a couple of lights on.
0:46:28 Rebecca, no, sorry.
0:46:30 Thank you, Mayor.
0:46:31 Thank you, Mandy.
0:46:31 I did have a question about the paving bricks.
0:46:35 Over time, they tend to move up and come loose.
0:46:38 So how would we prevent that from happening?
0:46:42 And it becoming a maintenance issue
0:46:44 or another tripping hazard, which
0:46:46 is kind of the whole theme of redoing downtown.
0:46:49 How do we prevent that from happening soon after re-doing the surface?
0:46:55 Yes, and usually when that happens, it means that there was a problem in the installation.
0:47:02 For example, the sub-base wasn't compacted to, I think it's 90% or 95% compaction that has to be achieved.
0:47:10 And then you put a layer of crushed rock, compacted crushed rock over the top of that.
0:47:16 that has to be compacted to a high degree of percentage
0:47:21 of compaction, and then sand layer,
0:47:23 and then placement of the pavers.
0:47:25 If any of that sub-base or the crushed rock layer
0:47:28 is not installed or compacted properly,
0:47:31 you can see settling over time.
0:47:34 And so it's really important to get that right.
0:47:37 And we'll be detailing that in the drawings and specs.
0:47:40 But it will also need to be supervised during construction
0:47:44 and tested as well.
0:47:46 And I think what, you know, the design of these
0:47:50 with the joints that are butted up directly
0:47:53 rather than having any kind of pervious area
0:47:56 between the pavers also helps, because it's pretty tight design
0:48:00 and holds in place well.
0:48:02 If you go to look at some of the pavers,
0:48:05 even the ones down at Glamier or in Boise,
0:48:08 go on a field trip, you'll see that some of those
0:48:11 have been there for years, and they're still really smooth
0:48:14 on the surface.
0:48:16 Yeah, we want to make sure that this is going to be a long-term smooth surface for folks.
0:48:21 Absolutely.
0:48:22 Kristoff?
0:48:23 Yeah, this isn't a question so much as a comment.
0:48:27 I'm doing quite a bit of research on early years of Twin Falls history and came across
0:48:33 in the then Twin Falls news, artists depiction of the Roggerson Hotel, which was to be three
0:48:40 stories.
0:48:41 In fact, it was three stories until the mid-60s.
0:48:45 In its construction, Mandy, it showed the west side of the building as not having been
0:48:52 built on it.
0:48:53 I think I remember seeing a tree or two.
0:48:55 The only reason I bring this up, it would indicate the Rogerson was built before the
0:49:00 building now there, you're shaking your head, Melinda.
0:49:04 That may have some bearing on the type of construction wall that came in after the Rogerson.
0:49:12 I would think it would be more indicative of the strength of the Rogerson than the other
0:49:17 wall.
0:49:18 I don't know what the structural integrity requirements are at that time, but I thought
0:49:23 I'd just bring it up to you.
0:49:24 That's a good background to know.
0:49:27 When you mentioned the tree, I also forgot to mention earlier that we are planning to
0:49:30 have some places for large trees in the plaza.
0:49:35 When they go in, they will not be large, but 50 years from now, they can become trees
0:49:41 that are shown like the one in the corner there and really be a legacy to the community.
0:49:46 It's an opportunity maybe to honor families or citizens with a specimen tree that's really
0:49:53 high quality and we can probably fit two or three or four into the plaza we're looking
0:49:58 at how that would work.
0:49:59 Do we have any other questions?
0:50:03 Mandy, wonderful presentation.
0:50:05 I think a picture says a thousand words and that's absolutely gorgeous right there.
0:50:12 that's exciting but really leads us down the road although you turned it off
0:50:16 but again thank you for your presentation. All right next item on the agenda which
0:50:24 is really not on the agenda if I could have Travis and Mitch and Greg if you
0:50:30 join me down below and Melinda Melinda's last meeting we're only going to
0:50:59 torture a little bit more at City Council is tonight and tomorrow is her last day
0:51:04 she gets to move on to really back home in her home area to another position and so we
0:51:13 wanted to just take a moment. We did this earlier at the Urban Renewal Agency meeting as well.
0:51:17 I got to stand up with the Urban Renewal Agency Board as well as Greg was there and Travis
0:51:24 and of course Mitch to just really express our gratitude and appreciation to Melinda for the fine
0:51:32 work she's done. It's been a it's been a journey, a nine year journey and so
0:51:38 without further ado and I'll allow other folks to say a few words here. This
0:51:43 plaque is from the Urban Renewal Agency as well as the city and appreciation to
0:51:48 Melinda Anderson for the nine years of dedicated service to the City of Twin
0:51:52 Falls and to the Urban Renewal Agency from January 2007 to December 2015. As mayor
0:52:00 of the City of Twin Falls and, again, let's hear earlier, chairman of the Urban Renewal
0:52:06 Agency and on behalf of the citizens of Twin Falls, we extend to you the thanks and deep
0:52:12 appreciation of a grateful community for your service.
0:52:24 Right here and then one factor, yeah.
0:52:33 And if council could stand behind, let's get you in the picture and please.
0:52:37 Question for the fact.
0:52:40 You want us to sit like this?
0:52:43 I just want to go on.
0:52:45 Can you call Nikki?
0:52:51 Josh?
0:52:52 Anyone else that would like to say to you?
0:53:12 So I've had the opportunity to work with Melinda since I arrived here in 2008.
0:53:39 And what I will share is that we are losing a public servant who really dedicated herself
0:53:47 to the betterment of Twin Falls.
0:53:49 And when you think about the economic opportunities
0:53:53 and the successes that we've had as a team
0:53:57 over the course of the last several years,
0:54:00 all of us played a critical role in peace in that.
0:54:04 And like all teams, without people playing their roles
0:54:07 and doing their spot, we wouldn't have enjoyed
0:54:10 the successes that we had.
0:54:13 We are losing a very dedicated member of our team.
0:54:17 and Walletton is gaining a very skilled
0:54:20 and dedicated professional to theirs.
0:54:23 And so she will absolutely be missed,
0:54:25 and our opportunity is to try to find someone
0:54:30 to fill some very large shoes that she is leaving behind.
0:54:35 Well, it may be figuratively and literally, right?
0:54:38 But in all seriousness, our success
0:54:41 is really part of a team-driven approach,
0:54:43 and Melinda was an integral part of that.
0:54:45 So for that I say thank you.
0:54:48 Tomorrow we have the opportunity to celebrate with the potluck
0:54:51 with Melinda, members of the team are going to get together
0:54:55 and clearly the members of the council
0:54:56 will be invited to that tomorrow at noon.
0:54:58 So with that Melinda, congratulations.
0:55:00 Thank you for your dedication to our community
0:55:02 and also being a valuable member of our team.
0:55:12 Melinda, would you like to say anything?
0:55:14 Then I need council.
0:55:15 Stage.
0:55:17 Well, since we did this at noon today,
0:55:20 I was told I gave a lovely little speech.
0:55:22 I don't know if I'll be able to replicate it again tonight.
0:55:25 I just want to thank you all for the opportunity
0:55:29 to, for me to work with you.
0:55:31 This is an amazing place.
0:55:33 When falls, it's an amazing place.
0:55:36 It'll always have a special place in my heart.
0:55:39 I have made some wonderful friends here,
0:55:41 including council members or renewable members,
0:55:44 certainly city staff.
0:55:48 And we have a great team.
0:55:49 And I know that under Travis and your leadership,
0:55:52 it will continue to be great.
0:55:53 You'll continue to do all these wonderful projects
0:55:56 that I've been really blessed to be a part of
0:55:58 over the last nine years.
0:56:00 I just wanna say thank you for the opportunity
0:56:03 that you gave me nine years ago to come work with you.
0:56:06 I appreciate it, I've been honored
0:56:08 and pleased to work with you and I shall miss you.
0:56:11 To all of the tenants right on the way to the beach,
0:56:13 so please stop by and say, hey,
0:56:15 when you go to the beach next time.
0:56:17 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:56:18 Yep.
0:56:19 So Melinda, on my first appointment to council, you put me in your little car and drove me
0:56:28 around Twin Falls and shared with me your heart and your dreams and what you vision for our
0:56:33 community and I will hold that dear forever and thank you so much.
0:56:38 Well Melinda, again, it's been a journey and it's been a wonderful journey.
0:56:46 appreciated your passion for your job, and what you've done for our community, and we only want the best for yourself.
0:56:54 Good luck.
0:56:55 Thank you all very much. Thank you.
0:56:57 Well, Melinda, I think you exemplify the type of positive leadership that's moving Twin Falls from 1950 sleepy little village to many
0:57:07 metropolis of approaching 50,000, but it's one that's attractive.
0:57:12 of the industries we're all proud of and raising the wage scale and making our
0:57:16 futures look bright and I know your reputation is already preceded where you're
0:57:22 going. We expect to hear good things out of you too. Thank you. Thank you again.
0:57:28 We have a couple more things on the regular calendar for consideration then
0:57:40 we have a couple public hearings this evening they're slated not to start
0:57:45 four, six and we're going to be successful at that again.
0:57:48 So it'll be after.
0:57:49 I know that at least one of the items here, there are going to be several folks express
0:57:54 their desire to come and speak and I think potentially some of you have determined that
0:58:00 you'd have someone speak for you.
0:58:03 So if you could kind of get that coordinated, those of you that want to speak, if you wouldn't
0:58:06 mind, please making sure that you're on the back there, there's a place for you to sign
0:58:11 in because we like to bring you up here in an orderly fashion so that we can keep that
0:58:16 portion rolling.
0:58:18 So now's your opportunity to do this while we're taking care of a few more items of business.
0:58:23 Next item on the agenda is a discussion on the mayor election process and just to update
0:58:30 folks.
0:58:31 We are a unique form of government in Idaho.
0:58:34 There's only three cities like we are.
0:58:37 We have a city manager, mayor form of government, which means that the council is really more
0:58:44 like a board, like a business board, like a GE would have a board that would run there
0:58:53 or give them guidance and direction.
0:58:56 And then within that board, they elect a chairperson to run the meetings and do the signing
0:59:04 and some of the public speaking for that board of directors because we have a
0:59:09 professional staff that run the day-to-day operations led by our city manager. So
0:59:14 every two years we have the opportunity that we would vote our own mayor at that
0:59:20 point from the seven members of the council and so tonight the council would
0:59:27 just like to have a little discussion determining the direction and how we
0:59:32 should go forward with the selection of the mayor for the beginning of next year. So with
0:59:39 that, I'll turn it over to council. All right. Chris Daukington.
0:59:47 Well, I think I've been involved, neither 12 or 13 near election processes and I tell you
0:59:55 none of them have felt entirely transparent in the public's interest, nor entirely satisfactory
1:00:07 on the process, but I have been uncomfortable, as I think most of us have been, but knowing
1:00:13 where to go to make it a little something that the public is more vested in than situations
1:00:20 I've been personally aware of where Council would meet without a public identification
1:00:27 of where and what they were meeting about and decide who was going to get at least four votes.
1:00:35 Completely without any mention of agendas or goals or objectives.
1:00:42 And I guess the selection of the mayor in Twin Falls I see has come about as part of the
1:00:48 maturity of our city right now and I would throw it open the council. I think we're all
1:00:53 looking for a way for it to be a little bit more transparent process where candidate or
1:00:59 candidates for the mayor can announce and or mention their goals in hopes to what the way
1:01:09 they're accomplished in the next couple of years. It ultimately is going to take a public
1:01:14 vote, as it always has, but I think leading up to that process, I think we're all reaching
1:01:20 for a little bit more transparency than we've had in the past, and I think there's a way we
1:01:24 can do it.
1:01:25 Thank you, Chris.
1:01:26 Greg Lanning.
1:01:27 Well, I just, just a comment on Chris's.
1:01:30 I want everybody to know, I've never been in a situation where we met and decided to get
1:01:35 four votes.
1:01:36 That must have been farther back than ten in the last ten years.
1:01:38 You were just a kid when I was on that count.
1:01:40 I was just saying that.
1:01:41 That has never happened under my tenure.
1:01:42 I was hoping to do that.
1:01:43 I don't think I ever heard that it was.
1:01:45 That's the next section of an illegal meeting,
1:01:46 and I don't want everybody to know that has not been,
1:01:49 I have never been part of that process.
1:01:51 So, Sean Barrett.
1:01:55 So this would be probably a question for Fritz.
1:01:57 So just refresh all of our memories on the,
1:02:01 is it the city code lays out that a mayor is selected
1:02:06 at the first meeting?
1:02:08 It's the state code.
1:02:09 It sets that out and then it has an alternative
1:02:12 that we talked about last time that you could adopt
1:02:16 ordinance so that it's a direct election by the by the people but the default way
1:02:22 is that at the first meeting after the election your first duty is to select a
1:02:30 mayor amongst you. So maybe to follow a bit on on Chris's comment you know I don't
1:02:38 disagree that this should be a public process I think the challenge a little
1:02:43 bit is the timing. So if we were to go along with kind of a path you were headed down there, Chris, of
1:02:49 people announced that they want to be mayor and they sort of lay out a campaign stump of what they
1:02:55 planned to do over the next two years. To do that between now and the first meeting in January includes
1:03:00 members of the current council that aren't members of the new council who are actually the ones who are
1:03:04 going to be voting on that. And so I struggle a bit with the timing of everything of do you stand
1:03:13 up now and say, I want to be mayor and have conversation with council members who won't
1:03:19 be here when you're actually having that conversation.
1:03:22 So I don't know what the solution is, I just throw that out as maybe another slight wrinkle
1:03:27 in this process.
1:03:28 Jim.
1:03:29 Oh, thank you, Mayor.
1:03:32 I agree with Sean.
1:03:33 This is a discussion to be taking place on January 3rd.
1:03:37 You know, I can sit here and make an argument that we should do this and that we should
1:03:40 We have an elected mayor and so forth, but it would be a real disservice to the people
1:03:47 who were just elected by the people to sit up here to meet for now and have those discussions
1:03:52 and make those decisions.
1:03:53 So I believe a discussion right now is quite honestly inappropriate.
1:03:57 We're back in the next second.
1:04:00 Thank you, Mayor.
1:04:01 I just want to agree with Councilman Munn.
1:04:03 I had the same thought.
1:04:05 I was kind of confused about, well, what are we talking about tonight?
1:04:08 It is kind of a difficult or interesting conversation,
1:04:13 I guess, at the very least, to have it with the council
1:04:16 who will not be selecting the mayor, those members
1:04:19 that will not be here like myself.
1:04:22 But I do agree with Chris.
1:04:24 I think that there's a time for at least a presentation.
1:04:29 Maybe put it on the last meeting in December,
1:04:32 put it on the agenda to say those candidates
1:04:36 our council members wishing to be candidates for mayor
1:04:40 can outline their objectives,
1:04:42 it can outline their qualifications,
1:04:43 and that was a little more open in public,
1:04:45 and certainly I once again agree with Councilman Mundt
1:04:48 that conversation then about who the council wants
1:04:53 to select out of those candidates,
1:04:55 and their reasons for selecting that candidate
1:04:58 can be discussed at that first meeting in January
1:05:01 as it says in state code.
1:05:04 I would, however, like to move forward this discussion about moving to a direct elected
1:05:11 mayor.
1:05:12 I believe that the people of Twin Falls are smart enough to know who they want to select
1:05:18 as their mayor, and I think it's a great opportunity to provide that to them, and it's
1:05:23 a simple switch, and so maybe I should ask Fritz this question, you know, what would it
1:05:30 take to have the staff, would they just draft an ordinance for further discussion that maybe
1:05:39 can come before this new council in January and maybe they can have a more general conversation
1:05:45 after the new mayor would be selected, then they'd have two years to discuss this and maybe
1:05:52 work out any of the details and possibly have further discussion and make a decision on whether
1:05:59 to pass an ordinance to direct elect the mayor.
1:06:02 The changes by ordinance adopted by the city council.
1:06:05 Okay.
1:06:06 Would you need a motion of the council for the staff to create that?
1:06:11 We just need instruction from the council.
1:06:14 Okay.
1:06:15 I would make a motion to direct staff to create an ordinance for further discussion.
1:06:22 That would switch our Twin Falls city system to direct a election of our mayor.
1:06:28 of our mayor. We have a motion on the floor. I'll second it just to get it for a
1:06:35 vote. We have a motion on the floor made by Rebecca Mills so I guess seconded by
1:06:41 Chris Tawke. The two lights that are on is this discussion regarding the motion.
1:06:46 Well it wasn't but I could certainly discuss it. Okay so that's the direction
1:06:50 that we're going to go Suzanne Hawkins and then no no money is not on the
1:06:54 motion. Mine was before yeah okay very good I'll keep you online and great
1:07:00 I'll vote Jim on this one again. This is premature.
1:07:04 The new council should be voting on this, not the existing council, so I will be voting no.
1:07:10 We're back in that so I guess.
1:07:13 Thank you. Well, I just want to clarify that the new council would be voting on this.
1:07:16 This is not a motion to vote on it.
1:07:19 It's a motion to have further discussion with the staff directing staff to bring in ordinance for the council's discussion,
1:07:26 which they can take up or not take up. But just to move it forward.
1:07:30 I would just add just for a point of clarification that what we're discussing this evening is the direction how we
1:07:40 want to
1:07:41 Look at selecting the next mayor. That's why we had both of our council elect in the audience
1:07:46 And this is something that we're going to further discuss on the first meeting in January
1:07:50 I feel like this motion is premature because the two in the audience need to be part of the decision making whether we bring this forward or not
1:07:59 So I will not be in support of the motion
1:08:03 So I will say I have had not one citizen of the community come to me and ask why we don't elect a mayor directly.
1:08:15 So I'm not seeing an overwhelming community response that there needs to be a change to the way that we select the mayor.
1:08:24 If that happens in the future and there is, you know, a significant group of the citizenry that says we feel this should be happening.
1:08:35 feel this should be happening. I might support it at that point to bring a
1:08:39 forward discussion, but at this point I don't see that there's been a challenge
1:08:46 identified with the way it's been happening besides kind of the process of
1:08:51 getting that done. So I won't support this at this time.
1:08:56 Chris, talking to?
1:08:58 Toen Falls is the envy of not only Idaho, a lot of states in the northwest, the
1:09:04 see our ability to conduct business in the best interest of the taxpayer and for the future.
1:09:13 And this is operating under the current city manager form of government with a hired professional
1:09:18 manager and board of directors on the city council.
1:09:23 I don't see evidence looking around Justin State of Idaho and one evidence of an elected
1:09:28 mayor that I would trade on a short day for our former government.
1:09:33 I will be voting against it.
1:09:35 Jim.
1:09:36 Thank you, Mayor.
1:09:37 I also vote no, not because I think it's a bad idea.
1:09:41 I just think that I don't want to force the new council
1:09:45 into a discussion or into a discussion on an ordinance
1:09:52 that they may not want to bring forward.
1:09:55 If they so choose to have an ordinance prepared
1:09:59 and be discussed in 2016.
1:10:03 God bless him, I think that's a great idea,
1:10:05 but I just, right now I think it's a bad policy for us
1:10:09 to fling a new council into that type of a discussion
1:10:13 as a lame duck.
1:10:16 General Callhouse please.
1:10:24 Chris Hockington.
1:10:25 No.
1:10:27 Greg Lanthim.
1:10:28 No.
1:10:29 Don Hall.
1:10:30 No.
1:10:31 Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
1:10:32 Yes.
1:10:34 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:10:35 No.
1:10:36 Jim Munn.
1:10:37 No.
1:10:38 John Bericher.
1:10:39 No.
1:10:40 Motion fails.
1:10:41 Six against one.
1:10:43 We're back on the original subject.
1:10:48 What direction do we want to tell Suzanne?
1:10:49 I think you were going to tell Suzanne.
1:10:50 Yes, thank you.
1:10:51 So this question is probably for Fritz again.
1:10:54 I've only been through the mayor process once and how it was handled then after we elected
1:11:00 Don to be mayor.
1:11:01 He brought my name forward for vice mayor.
1:11:04 So if we're declaring we want to be mayor on the night we're actually voting how do we
1:11:12 know how do we proceed with the vice mayor position.
1:11:15 I think that one is an appointment by the mayor with concurrence of the council but let
1:11:22 me check.
1:11:23 It is correct.
1:11:26 Okay so this okay so then that's the mayor's decision with the concurrence of the council.
1:11:33 Okay thank you.
1:11:36 Greg Lanning.
1:11:37 Well, just some general discussion about it. I'm not sure
1:11:41 when
1:11:44 Candidates choose to let the rest of us know that they're they're interested. I am not interested
1:11:50 I'll go forth and say that I'm
1:11:52 I was married two years. I enjoyed the two years, but I'm
1:11:56 right now
1:11:59 Don't want to do it again. Maybe in the future, but not right now
1:12:03 And it is a unique form, okay, there is any doubt about it that
1:12:07 But the concern I have going back to the other issue about the voting part is that we've seen
1:12:14 that if you're mayor more than once twice in a row and this goes back to the past, not
1:12:20 everybody but some start acting like a mayor.
1:12:22 I mean a strong mayor.
1:12:24 And they aren't a strong mayor.
1:12:26 They're a city manager, former government, and they're much more here just to lead the
1:12:30 the meetings and to, you know, you end up meeting with the companies, yes, the one to come to
1:12:37 town and you give a lot of speeches. I mean, a lot of speeches, it's astonishing how many
1:12:42 there are. I usually are the face of the community. So, for that reason, I like the fact that we
1:12:48 choose one every two years. I'm going to go back on the AIC a little bit, and I, and
1:12:53 Friends and I had quite a bit of conversation about this.
1:12:57 During the time of the AIC,
1:12:59 lawyers disagreed slightly on the,
1:13:02 they really felt like our old process,
1:13:05 that not to clear back to Chris's process
1:13:07 where you got together and you met,
1:13:09 but that those who were interested had conversations
1:13:12 with others on the council
1:13:13 to see what support they might have and went forward,
1:13:17 because this happens in every city council,
1:13:19 even the ones with the strong mayor
1:13:21 because they elect a president of the council.
1:13:24 And so every city will be going through
1:13:26 this exact same process come January 1st,
1:13:30 and 97.5% this run out number.
1:13:34 It's a very high percentage.
1:13:36 We're doing exactly what we were used to do,
1:13:38 and if everybody wonder what we used to do, exactly that.
1:13:41 If I was interested in being mayor, I talked to Don
1:13:45 and said, hey, Don, I'd like to be mayor
1:13:47 if you think about it, and see what you think.
1:13:49 I talked to Suzanne or Jim or whoever it was on the council at that time and let them
1:13:54 know that I was interested and from that I would know whether I had enough support typically
1:14:00 to have four votes because you need three people in your zone and so that's the process
1:14:05 and that I get the IC believes that that is transparent enough that we apparently right
1:14:13 now don't believe that it is on direction from our attorney and so you know like I said
1:14:20 that I was fine with the old process,
1:14:22 the AIC is fine with the old process,
1:14:24 but apparently it's not gonna work for us.
1:14:26 And so I guess I'm gonna suggest that maybe by next week,
1:14:33 those who are interested in being mayor,
1:14:37 put forth their name at the meeting next week,
1:14:39 and then we can have a discussion
1:14:43 about who it is on the first.
1:14:44 I don't wanna get in the situation
1:14:46 where we put three names on the board
1:14:48 and we put tallies behind them.
1:14:49 I'm not sure that's quite what we're looking for either.
1:14:53 I mean, I would like to feel that through that discussion
1:14:56 we could figure out who has four votes
1:14:57 and go from there and then make a motion in there.
1:15:01 But what if you have three candidates,
1:15:02 you get two people with two votes and one person
1:15:06 with three votes and then your deadline?
1:15:10 I mean, I'm not sure where we go.
1:15:14 Chris, talk to him.
1:15:15 Well, I was kind of thinking along the same line
1:15:17 as you, Greg.
1:15:18 I would offer this as part of this
1:15:20 thought of a little more transparency.
1:15:22 I didn't realize it raised quite the consternation
1:15:26 for changing things, but I think we
1:15:28 can keep the individual contacts to a minimum until, at least,
1:15:36 we announce interest to be a mayor.
1:15:39 And whether it's next week or the first one in January,
1:15:43 people that are interested might, I guess, self-nominate
1:15:48 is what you suggested, I don't know about that,
1:15:51 but maybe given two or three minutes just to say
1:15:54 what their values are or what their priorities.
1:15:57 And this would at least include a little bit
1:15:59 of public knowledge and what the people stand for.
1:16:02 And then of course, it's no different than we do
1:16:05 every time we take a vote.
1:16:06 And only thing it does is take counting before.
1:16:10 And if you had three people,
1:16:12 then I guess there would be the top two candidates
1:16:15 or some sort of a runoff that would have to be handled.
1:16:17 I don't think I've ever recalled more than two people
1:16:21 running at one time.
1:16:22 So I don't think transparency has to be a bad word,
1:16:25 but I think we can make the public at least aware
1:16:28 of somebody who's going to take the ceremonial reins
1:16:32 for the city for a couple of years,
1:16:33 at least has a public vested agenda.
1:16:43 Jim on.
1:16:44 Well, maybe I'm just trying to,
1:16:46 maybe I'm thinking this thing a little bit too simple here.
1:16:49 On January 3rd, if you want to be the mayor, hit your light,
1:16:54 talk a little bit about why you want to be the mayor.
1:16:56 And then I think, don't they, what do you call it,
1:16:58 make it sausage or whatever?
1:17:00 You deal with it.
1:17:01 I mean, I'm mildly interested anyway, but, you know,
1:17:05 I keep the sleazy politics out of it.
1:17:07 Have them get up here and talk.
1:17:08 We make people who want to go on committees,
1:17:10 get up and tell us why they want to be on committees.
1:17:12 Get up here and talk about why you want to be on that city
1:17:14 council or be the mayor.
1:17:17 And do it on January 3rd, not next week,
1:17:19 because I won't show up and do it next week.
1:17:22 Do it after I'm gone because I really don't have
1:17:24 an interest in this thing and just figure it out.
1:17:28 I mean, this is not rocket science here.
1:17:30 I'm all done.
1:17:31 You know, I might add my voice to that
1:17:34 because we actually have two council members
1:17:39 coming onto the council that might want to be
1:17:41 the mayor as well.
1:17:43 So that would give them the opportunity.
1:17:46 Something told me no from the books on their faces,
1:17:49 But you never know, so they have to have that opportunity
1:17:53 to share that as well.
1:17:55 Rebecca Milsoyka.
1:17:56 Thank you, Mayor.
1:17:57 Question for Fritz.
1:17:58 Greg mentioned the process that has been the process
1:18:01 for the last two mayor elections.
1:18:04 Does that violate open meeting laws
1:18:07 as being a serial meeting since you talk
1:18:09 about the same issue that's coming before the Council
1:18:12 for a vote with each individual member?
1:18:15 And that's the discussion I had with Greg.
1:18:17 And I know AIC disagrees with me, and I know Greg is right, every council in Idaho elects
1:18:24 a president of their council when they have a strong mayor for government, and probably
1:18:28 you don't ever see any debate about that.
1:18:31 From a staff standpoint, I'll tell you, it's always been kind of a mystery how our mayor
1:18:38 showed up on the first meeting after the election.
1:18:42 I don't think it's transparent if you're having conversations with each other about who you're
1:18:48 going to vote for because you are going to take a vote on something and if it's not in
1:18:52 front of the public then it doesn't seem right to me.
1:18:56 And that's what I've told the council.
1:18:59 Yeah.
1:19:00 And I would agree I just want to clarify because it sounds like on the every other issue that
1:19:05 we've discussed that spend the policy is that it would be a serial meeting to discuss with
1:19:12 each of us individually.
1:19:14 So I actually would agree with the way Jim laid this out.
1:19:20 I mean to a certain extent it is what it is.
1:19:22 We're going to show up at the meeting on January 4th and the new council is going to get seated
1:19:26 and the first thing we have to take care of is doing this.
1:19:30 So I think that at that meeting after the new council is seated I think those who are interested
1:19:35 and running for mayor, hit their light and give their spiel about what they would like
1:19:41 to accomplish in the next couple of years as mayor. And after that, you wait for somebody
1:19:47 to nominate someone. And it gets second and it gets voted on. I think that takes care
1:19:52 of the issue of three people or four people deciding they want to be up for the discussion
1:19:59 because you're just voting on one thing at a time. So the first person would be nominated
1:20:03 there be a second, I guess if that went down in a no vote, then we'd accept another nomination.
1:20:10 So I think that process is about as clean as we're going to get it to have it deal with
1:20:15 the new council members and get taken care of at the front of business on the fourth.
1:20:24 Ladies and gentlemen, I'd like to say that we're doing this on purpose to see how important
1:20:28 the event that you want to speak on later, but it's not the case.
1:20:32 We're up here making sausage.
1:20:33 So I think we're getting close to making a decision here.
1:20:36 Great landing.
1:20:37 Well, just a quick comment on the, not in defense of the AC, but their reasoning behind
1:20:46 the thought processes because under the rules that we're describing here where we couldn't
1:20:54 discuss any of that, in their mind that would mean if we have any issue ever coming before
1:21:00 the Council, Don and I could never discuss it ahead of time. And I don't think the citizens
1:21:05 of the city feel that's the best way to do government. The Don and I never discuss it unless
1:21:10 it's at an open meeting. The same thing with legislators at the State House that they never
1:21:17 ever discuss an issue outside of it, the debate on the open floor. I don't think the citizens
1:21:25 believe that that's the way it should operate. And so that is the TAC, AIC. They're treating
1:21:30 it just like any other issue that may come before us other than maybe the
1:21:36 boss I do just show ones that you you would have the opportunity as long as
1:21:41 you're not talking I talked to Don and then I go shot tell Sean what Don told me
1:21:45 and I go to Jim and tell what they those two told me yeah that would be a
1:21:48 serial meaning but if I just talked to an individual council member about an
1:21:51 individual issue they did not believe that that is a serial meaning so I'm just
1:21:56 doing defense there I think it doesn't really matter for this because we've
1:21:59 decided to go a different way, but that was their reasoning behind it.
1:22:04 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:22:05 Thank you.
1:22:06 I just want to agree with Jim and Sean.
1:22:08 I think that the plan laid out for starting in January and announcing and following through
1:22:13 from theirs, great.
1:22:14 And I just want to remind everybody, we are all seven elected officials, so we have been
1:22:18 elected to this board to run this board as we see fit.
1:22:22 And the chairman of the board needs to be the person that we feel we can work with the
1:22:25 best to further the city for the next two years.
1:22:28 And I feel that all seven of us are equally qualified, and as elected officials, it's just
1:22:35 the next step, and I'm comfortable with that process.
1:22:39 Thank you.
1:22:40 I think we have reached a decision, so we will be moving to the next item on the agenda,
1:22:45 which is public input.
1:22:46 This is your time to come and engage your city council.
1:22:50 If it's not something on the agenda, that's later, this is your time to come forward.
1:22:57 City manager, anything further?
1:23:02 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just a couple of quick items.
1:23:06 Number one, we have the opportunity to celebrate the retirement of Ed Lang tomorrow at three o'clock out of the airport.
1:23:14 Maintenance building, Ed has been with us for, I believe, 32 years.
1:23:19 He started out the street department and now he's finishing his career at the airport.
1:23:23 So please join us and also the community is welcome to join us in that celebration.
1:23:29 On Wednesday, we have the employee appreciation luncheon.
1:23:33 That's going to be at noon at Canyon Crest.
1:23:35 We hope that you'll join us for that.
1:23:40 Next week, we anticipate that being our final City Council meeting of the calendar year.
1:23:47 And at that meeting, there are a couple of items, but one of them is the swearing in of
1:23:52 Craig Kingsbury as the chief of police for the City of Twin Falls.
1:23:56 We are anticipating a large crowd to participate in that and to observe that swearing in.
1:24:05 So just wanted to let members of the community be aware of that.
1:24:09 Thank you, Travis.
1:24:10 Anything from the City Council?
1:24:12 That was three to five tomorrow, out of the airport, okay.
1:24:18 Council, question for you, do we want to proceed forward or do you want to take a quick break
1:24:21 and then come back for public hearing?
1:24:23 Let's proceed.
1:24:27 Let's proceed.
1:24:28 We will proceed.
1:24:29 Jim's just going to step down for a moment.
1:24:31 Next item on the agenda is public hearing.
1:24:34 It is consideration of your request
1:24:35 to approve a zoning district change
1:24:37 and zoning map amendment from R2 and R2 Pro to RV,
1:24:42 residential business for property located at 2176 and 2188,
1:24:47 Addison Avenue East in care of Tim Vosser, EHM Engineers, Inc.,
1:24:52 on behalf of Doug and Arlene Christensen.
1:24:55 So we have Tim Vosser from EHM.
1:25:00 Welcome, sir.
1:25:01 Thank you, sir.
1:25:02 Good evening, mayor, members of the council.
1:25:04 I am Tim Bosser with the HM Engineers representing Doug
1:25:08 and Arlene Christensen.
1:25:10 The request tonight is for a rezone of properties
1:25:22 at 2176 and 2188 Addison Avenue.
1:25:27 You'll notice better as the southwest corner
1:25:31 of Eastland and Addison.
1:25:33 currently to the north is neighborhood commercial direct north on the northwest corner of the intersection that's the
1:25:44 out of central credit union in that facility to the northeast is web nursery and a spot that is located on that corner on
1:25:56 the southeast corner is the oasis I believe that's the oasis and could you point those out as you go do you have the
1:26:03 I'm sorry, this is I don't central credit union.
1:26:10 This is the spot and web nursery.
1:26:14 This is the gas station in the Kmart parking lot.
1:26:17 And then there's some professional overlay lots
1:26:20 to the south doctor's office, Rob Sturgill's office,
1:26:25 and most of the rest of the property to the immediate west
1:26:30 is R2 or R2 pro depending on how far you go down the street.
1:26:37 This is in compliance with the comp plan.
1:26:42 Excuse me.
1:26:44 When that early on was staff, the initial request was going to be an NCO,
1:26:49 but staff recommended that our R.B. residential business was in compliance
1:26:55 with the comprehensive plan, and the owners of the two lots,
1:26:59 Stug and Arlene, were certainly willing to do that.
1:27:02 residential business zone and I can't remember if Rebecca was the liaison at the
1:27:08 PNC hearing but we heard quite a bit of concern from some residents that we were
1:27:15 turning it into commercial. The residential business zone was created
1:27:19 specifically for areas like this where commercial is encroaching in around you
1:27:27 and to protect the areas as a transition,
1:27:32 you yourselves came up with a residential business,
1:27:35 so it has some major restrictions on the amount of parking,
1:27:40 the amount of size that the building can be,
1:27:42 and the amount of uses, and anything that,
1:27:46 in my mind, anything that seemed to be contradictory
1:27:49 to what might blend well,
1:27:51 would then have to go before a special use permit
1:27:54 with a whole new set of rules and regulations
1:27:56 about where we get to a point.
1:27:59 At this point, the Christians have somewhat gotten
1:28:04 to the point where they just can't maintain the property.
1:28:07 They feel like they really can't sell it as residential
1:28:09 because of surrounding neighborhoods.
1:28:12 And so they feel their best option at this point
1:28:14 is to get the zone, let somebody come back
1:28:17 with a plan that works for that zone
1:28:19 and go forward from that point.
1:28:23 I'll stand for any questions.
1:28:24 Do we have any questions for Tim?
1:28:27 We do have a staff report after Tim.
1:28:29 Chris talking.
1:28:30 Tim, you may already mentioned that directly
1:28:31 to the West Boundary of the Property.
1:28:34 Is that a residence?
1:28:36 It is.
1:28:38 The West Boundary being there, which is the immediate West
1:28:43 Boundary of Doug and Arlene's home.
1:28:45 I believe Ms. Sinclair is that part.
1:28:49 Oh, yes.
1:28:49 OK.
1:28:53 Any other questions for Tim?
1:28:55 We might bring you back, Tim.
1:28:58 We do have a staff report from Jonathan Spenlow.
1:29:01 Welcome, Jonathan.
1:29:04 Thank you, Mayor.
1:29:05 So the council, really quick.
1:29:08 We do have some letters that we received from citizens on this.
1:29:11 We have three that were included in your packets.
1:29:14 We received one late today, about 3 PM.
1:29:17 And Mitch is going to put that up on the projector
1:29:24 after in public hearing, just letting me know
1:29:26 that next one.
1:29:27 Sorry.
1:29:28 Thank you.
1:29:29 There's an extra one.
1:29:30 So the history of this parcel, it's
1:29:32 part of the hill track is actually reported around 19-0 seconds.
1:29:35 So it's an old property and it falls over the years and Tim went through all of them.
1:29:40 They've been re-zoned and developed with professional and commercial offices.
1:29:46 The largest commercial building is actually the Kmart over here.
1:29:49 Those are zones, T1.
1:29:51 Everything on the west side of Eastland is R2 or with the professional office overlaid.
1:29:56 Professional office overlaid basically requires a special use permit to have an office.
1:30:01 So, there's been numerous offices along Addison.
1:30:05 As Addison's increase in traffic, fewer people want to live right on it, so we've had some
1:30:11 architect offices or health offices or things like that that have come up along that route.
1:30:16 This property, the Eastern, there's two lots here.
1:30:20 This is the blue area that we're talking about.
1:30:23 The Eastern lot is actually an office today when it got a special use permit back in like
1:30:28 95.
1:30:30 This one is actually a current residential home as a stands.
1:30:34 They're asking to change it to the residential business.
1:30:38 It's kind of a new zone, if nobody's heard about it, there's only one other property in
1:30:42 the city that's a residential business.
1:30:44 It's been recently rezoned to that.
1:30:48 That is the Future Land Use Map from the comprehensive plan.
1:30:51 The bluish, what looks like purple up there, is where the residential business was put on
1:30:57 the Future Land Use Map, meaning if you want to ask for a rezone, it needs to comply with
1:31:01 comprehensive plan, they're asking for the exact zone that is set in the future on this map.
1:31:08 These are the ones that commercial retail, there's a neighborhood center, that's where
1:31:12 the bank went in, and the medium density residential, it's for residential ranging from R2 up to R4.
1:31:19 So that's kind of the history of the area.
1:31:24 Tim did a really good thing about the other businesses, so I'm going to get right to what we need to get to done today.
1:31:29 In reviewing a request for zoning district map and zoning map amendment, the council has
1:31:35 two main objectives or tasks.
1:31:38 One, to determine whether request is in conformance with the comprehensive plan and two, to evaluate
1:31:43 the request to determine the extent and nature of the amendment requested.
1:31:48 Comprehensive plan indicates this corridor has appropriate for residential business uses.
1:31:52 There's no development plan.
1:31:53 I have no building plans tonight, it's strictly a rezone, so we can evaluate what a building
1:31:58 may look like or anything like that. Any changes will require full review by staff to determine
1:32:03 the extent nature of the changes in any building plan. Any change shall comply with the purposes,
1:32:08 uses and development standards of the residential business zoning district prior to development.
1:32:14 To make a positive vote, the city council must determine that the request is in conformance
1:32:17 with the comprehensive plan and the extent nature of changing the zoning of this request
1:32:21 residential business would allow land development that would be compatible with and not detract
1:32:26 from surrounding area. On November 10, 2015, the Commission held a public hearing on this
1:32:30 request. There were several neighbors that spoke on this issue. Upon conclusion of the
1:32:34 public hearing and discussion, the Commission unanimously recommended approval based on their
1:32:39 findings. This request was in conformance with the comprehensive plan and they also determined
1:32:45 a redevelopment of these two properties in compliance with the residential business zoning
1:32:50 district would be compatible with the existing development along this major arterial corridor.
1:32:55 Before I get to the conclusion, I want to kind of review a little bit of what the residential
1:32:59 business district is.
1:33:00 It's actually the last chapter in the second to last.
1:33:06 It is Title 10, Chapter 4, Section 23.
1:33:10 In brief, it's a pared-down version of the CB and C1 zoning districts.
1:33:15 There's fewer uses that are outright permitted, fewer that are permitted by special uses.
1:33:20 And the development standards is really one to hit.
1:33:23 It's very specific and has more stringent development requirements.
1:33:28 A few of those would be we require landscaping 20%.
1:33:34 20% isn't found in a commercial zoning district, most of the time is 3%.
1:33:40 So we require full 20%.
1:33:42 There's a thing about requiring to maintain if you can the building, but also to have the
1:33:47 residential character, put a limit on the size, the maximum size of the building, put a limit
1:33:53 on the number of parking spaces, so if your business requires a certain number, the number
1:33:58 is actually 24, so any business, no matter what it is, if you're required to have more
1:34:02 than 24 spaces based on our code, that use wouldn't be prohibited in this zone.
1:34:07 So we kind of pared down those to make that transition from commercial to residential a
1:34:13 little bit better.
1:34:14 You soften that transition.
1:34:15 So that's what the zoning district is all about, and that's where you can find it.
1:34:21 If there's any more specific questions,
1:34:23 I'll stand for any of those.
1:34:25 So, in conclusion, Council's task to make a decision
1:34:28 on the request, they may deny the request,
1:34:31 approve the request as presented,
1:34:33 or ask for additional information to be provided
1:34:35 and the request to be sent back to the commission
1:34:37 for another public hearing.
1:34:38 Staff, concurs with the planning
1:34:39 and zoning commission's conclusion and recommendation.
1:34:42 Thank you, Jonathan.
1:34:43 Chris, talk?
1:34:44 Yeah, Jonathan, are these two separate,
1:34:46 two legally separate lots?
1:34:48 They are.
1:34:49 Thank you.
1:34:51 back and they'll say thank you Mayor Johnathan I was wondering what the rear yard setback
1:34:58 is for the residential business I am the liaison to the planning and zoning and a couple of people
1:35:06 mentioned that that was their concern because they have residences that are behind the subject
1:35:13 property and so I was wondering how does residential business protect them as opposed
1:35:21 to say the NCO that's across the street.
1:35:24 The rear yard, specifically the rear yard, the rear yard for non-residential uses may
1:35:33 be reduced to the side and yard setback.
1:35:36 The side yard and the side feet.
1:35:40 Yeah, so the rear yard setback may be five feet from their homes.
1:35:43 And it is that different for NCO neighborhood commercial?
1:35:48 I have to find that one.
1:35:50 Okay.
1:35:50 If you got a minute, I'll come back to you.
1:35:51 Sure, we can come back to you.
1:35:54 Do you know Mitch just on hand?
1:35:57 Do we have any other questions while he's looking at it?
1:36:00 We'll give him just some more.
1:36:05 The NCO is actually an overlay, so it's a non-residential,
1:36:09 same as the underlying district except buildings exceeding 3,000 square feet,
1:36:13 of a yard of 50 from the property line on street frontages to the same thing
1:36:19 about rear yard. The residential uses is the same as the underlying district. Okay.
1:36:24 So it does give you a metric five feet per the code. Okay. Thank you. Do we have any
1:36:30 other questions Council? There'll be an opportunity to ask further questions.
1:36:33 Bench, would you mind going back to get the list? Ladies and gentlemen, at this time
1:36:41 we're going to go ahead and open up the public comment portion of this evening's
1:36:45 public hearing Mitch is going to look to see who has signed up for this and we
1:36:49 will call you up in an orderly fashion. I think we have a couple here. The first
1:37:16 person on the list and if I miss you, we'll give you an opportunity to bring you up, is Doug
1:37:20 You're good? Okay. That shows not to come forward. The next person is Pat.
1:37:30 What is it? Curtis.
1:37:35 Is Pat here? Okay. When you come up, if you wouldn't mind saying your name and your address, just for the record, and we will give you a couple minutes to speak.
1:37:46 Yeah, please.
1:37:57 Welcome.
1:37:58 Thank you.
1:37:59 My son-in-law is coming as my eyes because I want to show you something on the map that
1:38:04 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:08 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:18 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:42 And because it is a nice street, the city has decided we should pay a lot more taxes
1:38:51 for our homes on that street and the reason was given because they hadn't noticed how
1:38:58 nice the homes were so internally needed to increase their taxes.
1:39:05 And I understand that the city has plans for the area and that the city is growing and
1:39:21 plans do have to be made. When you buy property 45 years ago, you don't think
1:39:30 about what's going to happen to you. But I do need to call upon you all to
1:39:38 protect us, our privacy, our property values, our safety, our security, because
1:39:50 you know that whatever kind of business goes in, safety and security can come into play.
1:40:03 I would like, can you see them?
1:40:07 Patricia, did you want your son-in-law to point some things out to us?
1:40:12 Could you show him how to work that real quick, Jonathan?
1:40:16 I want to show you where I am.
1:40:19 Yeah, we can see the 1054.
1:40:21 Can you?
1:40:22 And then can you see behind, I have a very large back lot, or back yard, I own two lots.
1:40:33 Can you kind of point that out with the, it's right straight below where you were just
1:40:38 right there, right there.
1:40:39 Okay.
1:40:40 And these ones that goes to Addison Avenue.
1:40:47 Shield.
1:40:48 I own the easement rights through that to the back of my property.
1:40:57 Very good.
1:40:59 And I just thought you should know that because it is adjacent to the Christensen's property
1:41:06 if that has any bearing on the subject.
1:41:13 Okay, thank you.
1:41:15 And while we're at it, our part of Addison Avenue is still a pretty part of Addison Avenue.
1:41:31 It's up to you folks to maintain Twin Falls Idaho.
1:41:39 Some of your predecessors have not.
1:41:42 You've allowed or they've allowed Addison Avenue, West, Blue Lakes, Kimberly Road, to
1:41:55 not be a proud area, but you know how to do it.
1:42:03 It's not too late.
1:42:05 Other cities have made sure their cities don't go down in looks and you can control what's
1:42:19 left of Addison Avenue East, trees, aesthetics, even the parts that have
1:42:28 businesses have maintained their home-like look and a proud place. Don't let the rest
1:42:41 of it. Thank you Mrs. Pink. Thank you Mrs. Curtis for coming up. Thank you sir.
1:42:50 just a little bit. She took up all right for three people I'll give you one minute
1:42:56 go well if you'd say your name in your address you're sitting and I'm right
1:43:03 across sitting clear is it what's your address sir okay okay we'll get it from
1:43:12 you later
1:43:15 is my answer. It's all right sir go ahead.
1:43:23 1109, 1109 high view link, but naturally everybody that had written letters and I and
1:43:33 I and Pat prefer that this property not get rezoned and this one to not get an upgrade
1:43:45 and rezoning, but I suppose that's out of our hands and the decisions probably already
1:43:52 been made anyway. So I just wanted to concur with what she said just to keep us in mind with
1:43:59 our safety and property value is that it's thanks. Thank you sir. And that you're putting
1:44:07 up the other correspondence as we go through. Is there anyone else that would like to come
1:44:15 forward and testify in this? Absolutely sir. We're going to be low. I need to keep it right
1:44:22 about two minutes if you would please sir. If you'd introduce yourself and your address
1:44:26 we'd appreciate it. Welcome. My name is Curtis Webb. My wife and I own the property at 2150
1:44:33 Addison Avenue East. The lane that runs from Addison down to Mrs. Curtis's property is
1:44:42 our property and Mrs. Curtis has it. That's one thing that wasn't clear before. The property
1:44:50 directly to the west of this property is our land. I imagine if you put a business
1:44:58 where the question was lived, create a business quandary for traffic planning
1:45:06 purposes because right now our two driveways that enter up within probably less
1:45:13 than five feet of each other. If you would put a business there you would have a
1:45:18 business at our very law. So the property directly to the west is our property and this curse
1:45:28 has a easement on it. I came up mostly to every time I come to these meetings I learn
1:45:36 more and I'm concerned about the setback for the backyard is only five feet. That's
1:45:47 You know, that's very small, aren't you?
1:45:53 That business that would be there, and if we have on the case,
1:45:58 we have thought about whether we should be a
1:46:00 residential business, we'd be right up against Mrs. Curtis's
1:46:07 backyard, and if we stay at residence,
1:46:10 that business would be right up against Aria.
1:46:13 And then I also wonder about whether that really is
1:46:16 consistent with yet how would you do a residential business so it is consistent
1:46:24 with the residential area and those are things that are hard to answer in the
1:46:28 vacuum we don't know what will be done that just wanted to raise those concerns
1:46:33 thank you sir is there anyone else that would like to come forward at this point
1:46:40 I'll be closing the public testimony so there won't be any more public
1:46:44 testimony and allowing council to ask questions of anyone from the public or
1:46:50 staff at this time. Chris talking. I think it may have been alluded to, but I like to have
1:46:58 a little very specific demonstration that under the proposed residential business rezoning,
1:47:06 what would be the allowed ingress egress off and on to both Eastland and would that be Addison?
1:47:20 close to the corners. I can tell you the safest thing I can, they want to keep those ingress
1:47:36 and egress as far from the intersection as possible. That's what they would say mostly.
1:47:42 As far as a specific distance, I can tell you the entrance for the webs would not be touched
1:47:47 unless they wanted to do that. That's their property. They wouldn't be going away. They
1:47:52 be able to keep it unless they developed or something. Ingrass and egress, if those
1:47:56 were to be combined, they would try to keep them as far from the intersections
1:47:59 possible. That's the best answer I can do. Suzanne Hawkins. So with the the zoning now
1:48:09 is residential with business overlay, correct? Yes, the East lot has a
1:48:13 professional office overlay. The West one is just so with that, is there any
1:48:18 protection for a setback in the back property? Now I mean if somebody wanted
1:48:23 to go in there and change that, could they build right up to the property line as is, or
1:48:29 it kind of walk me through what exactly we're changing here.
1:48:41 So the professional office overlay setbacks, and these are building setbacks for the building.
1:48:52 Front sides and rears are the same as that of the district upon which the overlay is placed.
1:48:59 So in this case, seven feet, for professional offices, the rear yard may be reduced to the
1:49:05 side yard set back at the basic district.
1:49:08 Still seven feet.
1:49:09 So we're taking two feet away by making this change, possibly.
1:49:14 There's one thing that is different.
1:49:16 The one thing is the RV district restricts the size of the building a bit better than
1:49:23 the professional office does.
1:49:25 So it could be offering a little more protection down the road.
1:49:28 It offers a smaller building footprint.
1:49:32 The professional officer really does not have that same protection.
1:49:35 If we do not change the zoning and they wanted to rebuild there with a home office type looking
1:49:40 building, they still could do that correct?
1:49:43 On the east side.
1:49:44 On the east side.
1:49:45 The west side would have to be to have the professional on the silver line.
1:49:50 Okay, thank you.
1:49:52 You know Tim, I failed to give you an opportunity to come up and speak after the public testimony.
1:49:57 Did you have any response and then we'll continue with questions and then we will close all
1:50:04 for deliberations here?
1:50:05 I'm in.
1:50:06 Thank you.
1:50:07 I would like to make a couple of clarifications.
1:50:14 So Mr. Webb was perfectly accurate when I said that Miss Sinclair owned immediately to
1:50:22 the west.
1:50:23 He does own a strip of parcel 20 to 25 feet, what I believe it is, which is his driveway
1:50:30 way that leads back to his residence as well as Mr. Curtis as part of that easement I believe.
1:50:39 As for the rear yard setback granted it seems small. Screening is required for any commercial
1:50:51 use adjacent to residential so there would definitely have to be a screening fence landscaping
1:50:57 something of that nature, if anything other than residential was put back on these lots.
1:51:03 Which residential business district allows?
1:51:07 So anything not residential in nature would need to be compliant with that screening.
1:51:15 Due to the size of buildings in a relationship to the parcel, you are not going to see something
1:51:21 in the nature of 6,000 square feet if it's a restaurant because the parking requirements
1:51:28 for a restaurant are 1 in 100 maximum, 175, I believe, if it's no drive through 1 in 100
1:51:37 if it's a drive through.
1:51:38 So you couldn't even get a 2,400 square foot restaurant and in some cases.
1:51:44 So having said that because of the bulk of smaller building footprint size, the smaller
1:51:50 parking field size.
1:51:52 Anything that goes on there is going to want to get more visibility from the arterial streets
1:51:59 and they're going to want to go closer to the streets.
1:52:02 That's part of the reason I think they put that 20% landscaping requirement in that zone
1:52:08 is so that you couldn't just crowd the front and yet at the same time you're not going to
1:52:13 crowd the back on a big parcel like this.
1:52:16 I think you're going to see it well centered.
1:52:18 I can't say that for sure, but that's my belief
1:52:22 and that's how I would design the site.
1:52:25 The only other issue I wanted to bring up was access
1:52:28 to the site, which was a question from one of you up there.
1:52:31 There is currently, Mr. Webb's access there.
1:52:37 2176 access is right there.
1:52:41 2188 access is right there.
1:52:44 And there, Jonathan is absolutely correct.
1:52:48 The intent would probably be to keep the existing accesses
1:52:54 or through some way of the design of both parcels
1:52:58 to make it a better singular access that works for everybody.
1:53:02 We're through that with staff.
1:53:04 But there is no way that any portion of this
1:53:11 with the center meeting here and the center turnowing here
1:53:15 that any of this could be anything other than right in
1:53:19 and right out and those traffic patterns will take place.
1:53:23 It would be right in off of Addison Avenue.
1:53:26 It would be right out on to Eastland
1:53:28 and you city staff nor common sense
1:53:33 would allow you to do anything other than that.
1:53:36 So thank you.
1:53:37 Thank you.
1:53:39 Rebecca, you had your light on before, did you?
1:53:45 Okay.
1:53:46 That thought must have left.
1:53:47 Chris talking to.
1:53:49 Professor, I did have a question on the 20% landscaping.
1:53:52 Yes.
1:53:54 That would seem to intrude and not allow a seven foot setback, side yard or other setback.
1:54:00 That looks like the 20% would ride right over that.
1:54:04 Yeah, if you're going 20%, I did a quick calculation, Chris, I'm sorry it was Friday.
1:54:13 I forgot to bring it with me, but realistically each one of these are just a little bit over
1:54:19 three quarters of an acre with the parking field, with the building size itself, it would be
1:54:27 difficult not to have at least 30 percent. If I remember, and I want to say 40, but I must
1:54:34 say 30, at least 30 percent of this has been at least end up being landscaped on both
1:54:39 So, your interpretation, the landscaping buffering would override the seven-foot setback.
1:54:50 The buffer required via screen fence or something to that nature.
1:54:55 But the buffer along the arterial streets will definitely need to match the arterial landscape
1:55:00 requirement, which is 35 feet minimum.
1:55:03 I guess I'm directing more of the comments to the residential.
1:55:09 The occupied areas, the 20% landscaping is not, it is come to be concentrated just in one
1:55:18 area.
1:55:19 Not necessarily.
1:55:20 Well, I'm trying to say what the protection might be for the existing residences directly
1:55:26 to the west and the south, because if I just draw 20% landscaping on those two lots, there
1:55:33 just no way that you could get within the seven foot of the determinants of those lots.
1:55:39 No, the seven percent on the rear property line and what Jonathan was quoting was specifically
1:55:47 code. My take on that and it's clearly an opinion. My take on that is seven foot on the back yard
1:55:59 would be unrealistic simply because if you go anything other than residential,
1:56:05 you've already got to put a screening in there and screening definitely
1:56:10 went to landscaping as well. The other portion of that is because of building
1:56:18 requirements and fire code setbacks, if you went any closer than 10 foot to the
1:56:24 rear property line with a building, then you'd have a special construction on your
1:56:28 building for fire code, which would make it more expensive.
1:56:33 So thank you.
1:56:35 Mr. Chairman.
1:56:38 Do we have any other questions, Council, before we turn it over
1:56:41 to deliberation?
1:56:47 This time, I'll turn it over to Council for deliberation on
1:56:51 SETI.
1:56:53 What's the ordinance?
1:56:55 The executive to bring it to the center.
1:57:01 Greg Lanning.
1:57:01 Well, I've just had a question for Fred,
1:57:03 so if we voted yes for this, you
1:57:06 you would be directing that for you to prepare an ordinance back.
1:57:10 Bring it back.
1:57:15 Bring it back.
1:57:16 I move that we set forth with a plan to create an ordinance to approve a zoning district change
1:57:27 and zoning map amendment from R2 to R2 pro to RB residential business for probably
1:57:33 for Probriculate 8-2176 at 2188,
1:57:37 and it's down to East and East.
1:57:40 I'll need to see him standing in there.
1:57:42 Second, that mumbling at the end.
1:57:43 Yeah.
1:57:45 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,
1:57:46 seconded by Chris Talkington as stated.
1:57:50 Rebecca Milsoyka.
1:57:51 Thank you, Mayor.
1:57:52 Just a little discussion on the motion.
1:57:54 I was kind of surprised that they started out with NCO
1:58:00 and then kind of moved to residential business.
1:58:03 The thing about NCO neighborhood commercial is that you have to go through the ZDA process.
1:58:08 And so no matter what you're developing it will go through planning and zoning and go
1:58:13 through city councils so that you can review the particular development plan.
1:58:19 And I think that would be helpful in this situation because we have all of the residents
1:58:24 that testified saying, you know, this is my home, this is my backyard, this is my front
1:58:29 And I think that that would be helpful to go with neighborhood commercial so that they can be assured that they won't have the five foot setback.
1:58:43 And I appreciate Mr. Voster's speculations, but rezoning from residential to commercial is kind of just giving a blank check and whatever is allowed is allowed.
1:58:55 There's no assurances for these neighbors that it's not going to encroach upon their residential homes and the residential feel of where they live and have lived for some 45 years.
1:59:08 So I actually want to be sensitive to that.
1:59:11 I think it would be much better to see a neighborhood commercial overlay.
1:59:15 It would comply just as well if not better with the comp plan.
1:59:21 I think NCO would be a better choice here.
1:59:26 I don't feel comfortable just opening up to whatever development comes in.
1:59:31 I think that leaves the residents with a little to no protections or input on what is developed right next door.
1:59:38 We are rezoning the two lots.
1:59:40 I think it would be different if it were just taking that office overlay lot because it's no change in going from commercial
1:59:50 commercial to commercial but with this additional lot we are changing residential
1:59:57 into commercial nature and the state code gives protections for residents under
2:00:03 the Land Use Planning Act that we need to be very protective of property rights.
2:00:09 Greg Manning? Yeah, Fred is probably going to answer the question.
2:00:14 application in CO requires a minimum five acres and this is an
2:00:18 anchor. Thank you.
2:00:23 Okay. Well, mine was I believe we're looking at the future land use
2:00:29 planning map here. I believe our only choice is residents if we're going to change the zoning
2:00:33 and our only choice is to residential business because that's what the
2:00:36 complaint said. They would have to come in with a complaint and change
2:00:39 if we wanted to do something other than residential business and just to make sure
2:00:43 And just to make sure everyone understands residential business is a far cry from C1.
2:00:49 Across the street where Mr. Willys Oasis is, those are C1, this is not going to be C1.
2:00:56 We want more restrictions than a C1 is.
2:00:59 Rebecca, may I just ask a question of Fritz to clarify.
2:01:04 Okay, so the neighborhood commercial overlay cannot be applied to the R2?
2:01:09 It can, but it requires a minimum of five acres.
2:01:12 Okay, so the property across the street, is that five acres?
2:01:16 Yes.
2:01:19 Okay, so that's the difference.
2:01:21 Yeah, it is.
2:01:22 Okay, thank you for that clarification.
2:01:24 Anything further on this motion council?
2:01:28 Sharon, roll call, vote please.
2:01:35 Greg Landpane?
2:01:36 Yes.
2:01:37 Don Hall?
2:01:38 Yes.
2:01:38 Rebecca Milsorca?
2:01:40 No.
2:01:42 Suzanne Hawkins?
2:01:43 Yes.
2:01:44 Jim Mun?
2:01:45 Yes.
2:01:45 Sean Bericher?
2:01:46 Yes.
2:01:47 Chris Hawking?
2:01:48 Yes.
2:01:49 Motion passes six to one.
2:01:50 Moving to the next item on the agenda, another public hearing.
2:01:54 Consideration of a request to amend City Code 3-7-8 and 3-9-9 regarding beer and liquor sales,
2:02:07 service and consumption restrictions at licensed businesses.
2:02:10 I know we have Mitch's name next to this, but I know Sean brought it to our attention.
2:02:15 How do we want to handle this, Mitch?
2:02:17 I was just going to tell you that this is slightly different.
2:02:26 Ordinance, then we showed you three weeks ago or two weeks
2:02:29 or whatever, once last when we talked.
2:02:32 We went ahead and added the change from one o'clock to two o'clock
2:02:37 just for conversations.
2:02:39 And if we want to go ahead and add that,
2:02:41 then the ordinance is prepared to that effect.
2:02:43 If we drop that, we'll need to make that as part of the motion
2:02:46 to change it or to strike the two o'clock change
2:02:49 and just go with the days.
2:02:52 So in hopes of making the conversation broader
2:02:55 and more inclusive, we put it all out there
2:02:58 on the table for you.
2:02:59 So, but with that, I wasn't gonna say much
2:03:02 as can be with you, Dave.
2:03:05 So we are making adjustments to these ordinances.
2:03:07 If they're of specific ordinance, then we would-
2:03:09 There is an ordinance prepared,
2:03:11 and what it does is it changes the dates
2:03:13 like we thought of the days to include Memorial Day,
2:03:16 Thanksgiving Day, and then election days.
2:03:19 And then it also changes the one o'clock shut down time to two o'clock and number.
2:03:31 Just one ordinance number one ordinance number.
2:03:34 Okay, ordinance 31 can 31 10 if we choose to go that direction tonight.
2:03:41 Thank you, Mitch.
2:03:42 And I guess I will turn over to council for any questions or
2:03:48 thoughts before we open it up to the public for their testimony.
2:03:52 I will just chime in, so as I did bring this issue up initially, so the initial conversation
2:03:59 that I had from folks who had approached me was regarding the days, so Memorial Day Thanksgiving
2:04:05 Day and election days collectively. Through some further discussion, there was also some
2:04:13 interest expressed by local licensed establishments that they would like to have some conversation
2:04:21 about the potential of extending the hours as well from 1 a.m. to 2 a.m.
2:04:26 So, as Mitch pointed out, that's all been rolled into this ordinance for the sake of discussion,
2:04:33 but I look forward to hearing the public input to see if we want to look at all of that at
2:04:38 once or in separate pieces, so I'll just throw it out.
2:04:41 Very good.
2:04:42 I think at this time, unless Council has any objections, we'll go ahead and go with the
2:04:46 public input portion of the hearing.
2:04:50 So at this time, we're going to open up the public testimony
2:04:53 portion.
2:04:55 The rules of engagement really are,
2:04:57 if you have five or more folks that you're representing tonight,
2:05:00 I'd give you some additional time.
2:05:02 You're supposed to have sent me something prior to tonight's
2:05:05 meeting officially.
2:05:07 But we can work through this.
2:05:09 Is there anyone here that was going
2:05:11 to come speak for more than five or more people this evening?
2:05:17 Five or more?
2:05:20 So I also have a list of other folks.
2:05:23 So Dan, when it comes to your turn,
2:05:25 I'll have you come up and give you some additional time.
2:05:29 Carl Wormsbacher is the first person.
2:05:31 I think he gave up just a few of it.
2:05:33 He had to go to work.
2:05:34 He gave up on a stick too long.
2:05:36 Well, Ed Savia, well, sir, if you'd
2:05:43 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:05:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:05:48 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:05:50 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:05:53 and we're kind of exciting, man.
2:05:55 Twin Falls is being progressive, we're changing,
2:05:57 things are getting better.
2:05:59 We see growth on our main street,
2:06:00 and we're seeing it go down to the west side,
2:06:02 which me and wife is always supported
2:06:04 in the warehouse district.
2:06:07 The holidays and stuff like that,
2:06:08 that's always great.
2:06:09 It's another opportunity to make money,
2:06:11 I'm standing up here today,
2:06:13 to be one of the first in Twin Falls County
2:06:15 to do after hours.
2:06:17 That was granted from the city for planning a zoning
2:06:20 for three in the morning for after hours
2:06:22 with no alcohol sales.
2:06:25 Lots of times when it comes down to about one o'clock,
2:06:28 you're already having people exit
2:06:29 and heading out to Eden to get on our streets,
2:06:31 to go to other places that do go till two in the morning.
2:06:35 Being Twin Falls and having the opportunity
2:06:37 to serve till two, this Idaho State law says
2:06:41 we have to stop at one or five to one is what we do,
2:06:44 and then they have till about one 30 clear off beverages,
2:06:46 and then they exit the door.
2:06:48 So we're really right there in the neighborhood
2:06:50 of where we need to be.
2:06:52 The reason I'm up here trying to push the two o'clock
2:06:55 in the morning is, is we have a lot of clients that
2:06:58 are in the industry that are out there doing certain things,
2:07:01 and they don't get off until 11 or midnight.
2:07:03 And by the time they get to go do something,
2:07:05 they can't go do something in this entertainment value here
2:07:08 that we have in Twin.
2:07:09 So having the opportunity to go to that time
2:07:14 in a controlled atmosphere, still being under the state laws,
2:07:19 our county laws, and our city laws, nothing would change there.
2:07:22 It would probably increase ourselves, probably 30% to 40%.
2:07:26 So thank you.
2:07:28 Oh, you have 30 seconds.
2:07:29 OK.
2:07:30 Other than that, we're just really excited about all the stuff
2:07:33 that the city council is doing, and we appreciate
2:07:35 the opportunity to address you on that.
2:07:37 So thank you very much.
2:07:39 Thanks, Seth.
2:07:40 I failed to tell you you had about two minutes,
2:07:42 And our vice mayor to my right will give you your 32nd mark.
2:07:48 Please try to stay within that.
2:07:50 I'm not always all that strict that you've seen before.
2:07:53 So Paul Thompson, welcome, Paul.
2:08:04 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:08:05 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:08:09 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:08:12 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:08:13 I do thank you for the opportunity to have a public hearing on this.
2:08:20 My questions to this, as I process through this, does Twin Falls need to extend this time
2:08:27 to make Twin Falls a better place?
2:08:31 Do the bars need to be open?
2:08:33 Do liquor sales establishments need, does the City of Twin Falls need them to be open
2:08:40 for an additional hour for Twin Falls to be a better place.
2:08:44 Will the lives of families, will workplaces be better places
2:08:50 because we've spent the hours, one more hour?
2:08:54 Will people traveling from out of town
2:08:58 who travel to our good city, will they consider themselves
2:09:02 in their time here to have been hindered or limited
2:09:05 because our hours have been or are not what other cities are in the region.
2:09:12 If we want to make claims that Twin Falls is a unique place, then why not hang on to
2:09:18 our unique laws and be such a place as this?
2:09:27 So as far as the special holidays go, Memorial Day, Election Day and Thanksgiving, they're
2:09:35 Our unique holidays, one most particular Thanksgiving, is a holiday like no other holiday in our
2:09:42 nation.
2:09:43 Do we need to change a law that will affect the uniqueness of that day in our city?
2:09:50 So my appeal is please don't change the laws that have implications and considerations
2:09:59 public safety or the uniqueness of special holidays in our nation and in our city. Thank you.
2:10:06 Thank you, Paul. Dan Willy. Dan, if you wouldn't mind stating who you're representing this evening?
2:10:13 Well, I don't know what I'm going to get to.
2:10:15 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:10:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:10:22 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:10:28 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:10:31 in the hallway, made me say that I'd come up here. I didn't want to do this. But anyway,
2:10:37 the big thing is the state law says you can be open until two o'clock in the morning. The
2:10:44 state law says you can sell liquor every day of the year except Christmas Day. That's what
2:10:50 the state law says. But they leave it up to the city to either adopt their code or not.
2:10:55 All we're trying to do is get an alignment with the state code, and particularly on the
2:10:59 part about election day, it's so silly when people come in to our bar at three o'clock
2:11:04 in the afternoon and we won't sell them any liquor, but they can have all the beer or wine
2:11:07 they want.
2:11:08 But we say you stick around to the polls closed and we can sell you liquor, and they'll come
2:11:12 in and say, well, I was just down the street somewhere and I bought liquor today, and it's
2:11:15 so confusing even because it really refers back to the state law and we think we probably
2:11:19 are legal and we're not, so that's just a clarification.
2:11:23 And then the other part of that clarification is I'm not sure why we are closed down on Thanksgiving
2:11:28 a Memorial Day for Lictor, but I can sell beer and wine.
2:11:31 I had 300 people out of my place for a big buffet the other day on Thanksgiving.
2:11:35 I couldn't sell a Bloody Mary, but I could sell them wine and beer all day.
2:11:40 And I think I know there's important dates, but Easter is important too, so it's Mother's Day,
2:11:45 so it's Father's Day and everything's important.
2:11:47 And if you want to drink in those days and we say you can't in our bars,
2:11:51 go to the liquor store and get booze the night before or whatever.
2:11:54 Now the two o'clock thing, that was going to be a separate bill, I think, and I should
2:11:58 read to be separated because there's two issues here, but the two o'clock, that, again, would
2:12:03 put you in compliance with the state, or in alignment with the state, your choice.
2:12:08 I don't think the people I represent care too much about the two o'clock will take it if we can get it,
2:12:12 and strictly only because, like, in my event center, there is sometimes when we have like a Halloween party
2:12:18 And you've got to run them out of there because of one o'clock that's come around.
2:12:21 They want to stay for another half an hour or 45 minutes.
2:12:24 That would make it easier on us.
2:12:25 Or if there's a big party, Christmas party, some company, or a convention assault.
2:12:29 Those are the things that are important.
2:12:30 But really the first one just needs to be put in alignment to get rid of the confusion.
2:12:35 Thank you.
2:12:36 Thank you, Dan.
2:12:38 Debbie, you're here.
2:12:41 You gave your time to Dan?
2:12:44 He did do their job.
2:12:46 I believe this is Noreen Pride, possibly.
2:12:52 Noreen here?
2:12:57 Ladies and gentlemen, that's all I have on my list.
2:12:59 Was there anyone else that wanted to come forward
2:13:03 and speak on this subject?
2:13:05 Charlie, did you give your time up to Dan too?
2:13:18 Charlie, you're art in 1934, halfway.
2:13:22 I agree with Dan in terms of state regulated liquor laws.
2:13:28 It should be equal across the board, but the way I see it is all lost revenue.
2:13:34 The hour that we're not open is revenue.
2:13:38 Thanksgiving Day at Elevation, we had a great sales day, but
2:13:42 we've been selling on about 5% of sales, not being able to sell liquor.
2:13:47 So again, it's all revenue based.
2:13:50 The safety is all based on the restaurant itself and being responsible in the service
2:13:57 Well, I'm not necessarily the time for it, that's all I am.
2:14:02 Thank you, Charney.
2:14:04 Is there anyone further that would like to come up?
2:14:09 If you'd introduce yourself, but your address?
2:14:14 Ben, I live with 2733 Frankie Lane,
2:14:17 and one of the points brought up by another gentleman.
2:14:22 The tourist being hindered, I believe
2:14:25 that's what brought this to our attention.
2:14:27 In the first place, a lot of the bars,
2:14:29 we get tourists in town, and you can't serve them liquor.
2:14:33 And so, you know, they show up at your bar at 12.30,
2:14:37 and everything else is open until two.
2:14:41 A lot of this is towards tourists
2:14:43 and keeping other people happy
2:14:44 and just being able to be equal with everyone else.
2:14:48 Thank you very much.
2:14:49 Thank you, sir.
2:14:51 Anyone else?
2:14:52 I'd like Joe to board 12.33.
2:14:57 Joe, would you mind saying it into the microphone
2:14:59 because we're being broadcasted?
2:15:01 Joe to board 12.33, Worshing Avenue West.
2:15:04 I operate Jakers Bar and Grill or Twin Falls, I hope we don't stay open until later in the
2:15:11 evening. Most of my people are, most of our guests are out of the restaurant by midnight.
2:15:17 Sometimes we might be there until 1 a.m. but it's pretty rare. More of a restaurant. The
2:15:25 days like Thanksgiving and the other holidays are more of a big deal to me because there's
2:15:32 But there's other holidays that were so confused that we don't even know if we can serve on
2:15:39 Veterans Day.
2:15:40 I remember a couple years back where we were really new and we were calling other bars and
2:15:45 common liquor store and stuff.
2:15:47 So that part would be important for me, but I believe Eddy brought up earlier that people
2:15:54 are leaving as an establishment at 1am trying to get to other places by 2 in the morning.
2:16:02 put people out on the road so two o'clock would be helpful I think as far as
2:16:09 keeping drunk drivers off the road and then taxi caps so anyways that's all I
2:16:13 have thanks Joe anyone else all right at this point you had your time is there
2:16:24 anyone else at this time we're going to close the public testimony turn it over
2:16:28 to council they have any questions for anyone that testify and or staff this is
2:16:33 the time to make your request known.
2:16:37 Greg Lanting.
2:16:38 Well, I'm a little like the, some of the speakers.
2:16:44 I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I wouldn't.
2:16:45 This is the worst.
2:16:47 Okay, wait for, for the operation.
2:16:49 Oh, okay.
2:16:50 Oh, I, we're still in question.
2:16:51 I apologize.
2:16:53 I apologize for the questions.
2:16:55 I have a question for, for, for it.
2:16:57 So regarding the sale of, does this just deal for,
2:17:02 deal for deal with properties where you're going to consume on-premises, so it wouldn't address any other sales.
2:17:11 Thank you.
2:17:13 So is that Hawkins?
2:17:16 Thank you.
2:17:17 I'm not sure.
2:17:18 Maybe Brian can help me with this.
2:17:20 I was just curious, do you have any information or stats on alcohol related crimes from 1 to 2 a.m.
2:17:28 if we push it back, you're gut filling on what that's going to do to our police officers.
2:17:33 And to me, whether they leave at one in the morning or two in the morning, they're still
2:17:36 leaving with after consuming alcohol.
2:17:39 So I don't see that as a deterrent to keep them off the roads personally.
2:17:44 And I'm struggling with the one to two AM thing.
2:17:47 And I kind of like a police perspective on that.
2:17:51 Well, it's a great question.
2:17:53 And I had a really nice conversation with Chief Career this afternoon and because I think
2:18:00 this is the big question.
2:18:03 I think we're very supportive of changing the holidays.
2:18:06 That makes sense.
2:18:07 I'm not saying that we're opposed to changing the hours, but some things that we want to
2:18:13 share.
2:18:15 So alcohol related incidents are probably our number one issue, right, when it comes to
2:18:22 the things that we deal with, but that's really a question of personal responsibility.
2:18:26 And so what we've done in the last four or five years is try to develop good, solid relationships
2:18:30 with our partners in this industry.
2:18:33 So this is something that we tackle together and really making an emphasis on personal responsibility.
2:18:39 With that said, Brian and I really spent some time trying to really look at this objectively
2:18:45 and how this may or may not impact us based on the data.
2:18:49 And I don't have that information available, but what my gut instinct tells me, that changing
2:18:55 the time from two to three, I don't know what that will do to the volume, from one to two,
2:19:02 I'm sorry, I was just thinking in my mind how this works, right?
2:19:06 So from one to probably two thirty, if we are dealing with the residual of alcohol-related
2:19:11 incidents, that's probably our most critical time.
2:19:16 If we move the closing time to 2, then I'm saying that probably 2 to 3.30 will pick up
2:19:22 the same workload, but we can't say with any certainty that there will be increase in volume.
2:19:27 So to be honest with you, all that we see impacted by this is the moving of the time.
2:19:33 So instead of dealing with incidents from 1 to 2.30, we believe that we'll be dealing
2:19:37 with incidents, possible incidents, right, from 2 to 3.30.
2:19:42 we can't say with any real clarity that there will be an increase in volume related to this.
2:19:50 So really that's where we're at.
2:19:51 I don't know if that's helpful or not.
2:19:53 I mean, we have no idea how this may or may not impact us moving forward.
2:19:57 My guess is that we won't see any more impact than we're already dealing with today.
2:20:03 In either direction.
2:20:04 In either direction.
2:20:05 Thank you.
2:20:06 Chris, Greg actually has a question for Brian, I'm the same subject.
2:20:11 Go ahead.
2:20:12 Brian, correct my thought processes if I'm wrong.
2:20:19 Okay, it relates directly to what you said.
2:20:22 I'm trying to frame this question.
2:20:24 In my mind, I thought processes, I was thinking about them.
2:20:27 It might actually allow us to force a little more
2:20:31 strigently, the fall drug, because the people would be
2:20:35 spread out because some people are still getting home at one,
2:20:38 even though the law changes to two, and then somebody
2:20:41 too, so you actually have your police force could handle the influx of people leaving the
2:20:46 bar a little better because they would be spread out over a longer time span? Does that make
2:20:50 any sense or not?
2:20:51 No, I can understand what you're saying. I'm not sure how that would actually play out.
2:20:55 You generally last call and once these establishments start to close is when we have the potential
2:21:03 of dealing with incidents, right? That may be drunk drivers, it may be fights and parking
2:21:09 I mean, there's just a number of issues that go along with this regardless of when closing
2:21:15 is.
2:21:16 So whether it's closing at one or closing at two, you know, those incidents always pose the
2:21:21 potential.
2:21:22 And I want to go back to one of the things that we're doing is trying to partner with those
2:21:27 industry to alleviate, right, once again, going back to this personal responsibility.
2:21:33 So it's hard to predict what may or may not happen, but like I said earlier, something
2:21:40 tells me that it'll probably remain fairly consistent with what we're dealing with today.
2:21:46 Chris Dongham, this is a little difficult approach, but I think it ties in with what we're talking
2:21:51 about.
2:21:52 I was approached by a bar owner in town after this subject came up.
2:21:59 He has a private club and close proximity to him.
2:22:03 And I'll need your input to on Fritz on what a private club is allowed to do.
2:22:09 Allegedly, this is a meeting place for pretty much the same number and type of people that
2:22:21 results in liquor being consumed on premises up till five o'clock in the morning.
2:22:28 Vandalism to his establishment and adjacent establishments.
2:22:32 this is within the city of Twin Falls.
2:22:34 I was going to speak to you separately, but I want to let you know that there's a perception
2:22:39 that we are not enforcing either a legal consumption alcohol or property destruction related to
2:22:49 that.
2:22:50 Are you aware of private club problems in Twin Falls?
2:22:53 You know, occasionally we'll have a complaint called in.
2:22:57 You know, I always hear these rumors of these type of events where license premise has a
2:23:01 continuation of service after hours. We do try to work, you know, those
2:23:08 establishments, when those complaints are made, we also work with the state in
2:23:14 regards to this. We do not do, we have an individual that works with licensing, but
2:23:22 we don't have a specific team that focuses on this area. We really try to
2:23:28 work with the state and with the county when we do that, but we do hear reports of
2:23:35 occasionally we're an establishment, a license establishment will have a
2:23:38 continuation of service right after the doors close and for a private party and
2:23:43 private parties and license establishment after hours are not legal.
2:23:47 Further on that question if you do have a report come in and it's illegal do you
2:23:54 you investigate?
2:23:55 We do.
2:23:56 Okay.
2:23:57 That's probably the biggest issue here.
2:23:59 I'll just leave you at that.
2:24:04 Any other questions, Council, before we move towards deliberation regarding this issue?
2:24:09 Rebecca Mills, I call it.
2:24:11 Question for Fritz.
2:24:13 It was mentioned the state code on liquor sales.
2:24:15 Could you go over that for us, how the state code differs from Twin Falls' code, and if
2:24:22 this truly would bring it into alignment?
2:24:25 It's a little bit different than it was described earlier.
2:24:28 It's actually those holidays are holidays, and the hours are until one o'clock, but it
2:24:36 allows local governments to change those, except for Christmas.
2:24:41 It allows local governments to accept out, well, to allow for the sale of alcohol on
2:24:47 those holidays.
2:24:48 Thanksgiving Memorial Day, Election Day was, I think, our own thing before.
2:24:54 But so it actually allows you to, how do I say this?
2:24:59 The default is until one o'clock and no sales on those holidays, but it allows local governments
2:25:07 to allow alcohol sales on those days and until two o'clock.
2:25:12 Okay.
2:25:13 So, yeah, so those holidays are prohibited across the state unless specific cities have
2:25:20 changed.
2:25:21 unless the cities or the counties have changed it.
2:25:24 Okay, so we are in more in alignment with state.
2:25:27 We're in a local.
2:25:28 Code to speak.
2:25:29 We're sort of in alignment.
2:25:31 We're sort of modified.
2:25:32 Okay, slightly modified.
2:25:34 We've slightly modified from what the state code provides now.
2:25:37 Okay.
2:25:38 But it does allow you to change the future.
2:25:39 Sure, thank you.
2:25:40 That state code also addresses Sunday sales,
2:25:44 not just these holidays.
2:25:45 Yeah.
2:25:46 Then we've changed Sunday sales.
2:25:48 I don't know how many.
2:25:50 a number of eight years ago.
2:25:52 Yes.
2:25:53 Great planning.
2:25:54 I have first another question on the exact same topic.
2:25:58 What is this, does the state liquor stores, can they sell on these holidays and election
2:26:05 days?
2:26:06 Okay.
2:26:07 So you are dealing only with sale.
2:26:10 I know we are, I'm just asking for, what can they, I don't know, you know, the state liquor
2:26:18 store so I'm sure the Department of Administration tells them when they can or
2:26:22 when they can't unless there's a rope in our side. So since these guys buy from
2:26:26 those liquor stores and we have one of them. Sure. Would you like to come up and
2:26:30 tell us what the when the state liquor stores can sell? Debbie. Debbie
2:26:36 you're a Tia 18 North Ranch way in Jerome. I own the cove. Yeah it's been our
2:26:41 experience that you can walk into the liquor store and buy a bottle of liquor
2:26:45 on Election Day, but we can't sell it by the drink.
2:26:49 So that's how things are operating.
2:26:52 All right, thank you, thank you, Debbie.
2:26:56 Any further questions, Council, before we turn it over
2:26:58 to deliberations?
2:27:01 The only questions that you can ask after we go
2:27:03 to do the liberation is to our legal council.
2:27:10 Chris talking to me.
2:27:11 Well, I like to put this motion up for consideration,
2:27:14 but I don't want to move it to third and final.
2:27:16 We might get some more input from the public
2:27:18 in the next couple of meetings.
2:27:22 And I would move to place 31-10 on first reading,
2:27:29 by title only.
2:27:31 I'll second.
2:27:32 We have motion on floor by Chris Togg,
2:27:34 and seconded by Rebecca Mills,
2:27:35 so I could put our ordinance 31-10 on first three.
2:27:43 So Zann Hawke, title.
2:27:44 Thank you.
2:27:45 And by title one.
2:27:46 Okay.
2:27:48 I'm gonna be voting no on that motion
2:27:50 just because I'm having a hard time with moving the cells from 1 to 2 a.m.
2:27:54 Election day I don't have a problem with.
2:27:58 Memorial day I don't, Thanksgiving I would prefer to keep it the way it is but I could compromise on that.
2:28:03 But I'd really like to still see us closing down by 1 a.m. so I will be voting for no for that reason.
2:28:09 Sean Berger.
2:28:10 So along that line, I would question whether we should move on this ordinance or if we should discuss these
2:28:20 as two separate issues, one on the days and one on the hours.
2:28:23 Because I think if we try to just do this ordinance
2:28:27 and everyone opposes the hours, the whole thing will fail.
2:28:31 I can separate these before your next meeting.
2:28:35 So I have two different ordinances.
2:28:36 So I wonder if maybe we shouldn't have the discussion
2:28:39 about the issues and not specifically the ordinance
2:28:42 and then direct staff to draft an ordinance
2:28:44 that addresses what we prefer.
2:28:48 But we could certainly move forward with the conversation
2:28:52 because we're in deliberations about this ordinance.
2:28:54 If we choose to not pass this ordinance tonight
2:28:59 or the motion, we could have that conversation direct staff
2:29:04 to prepare the new master's.
2:29:06 Likewise, if it goes through the first reading,
2:29:08 we could direct them to do the very same thing.
2:29:10 We correct.
2:29:11 And we received public input that's on the record.
2:29:14 Yes.
2:29:17 Back in the middle second.
2:29:18 Thank you, Mayor.
2:29:19 I just want to state that I second the motion because I agree with the idea of the first reading.
2:29:24 I thought it was strange that we would have a hearing on a major issue with a lame-duck council.
2:29:30 I would prefer that the future council actually address this.
2:29:34 And I didn't second it as a support for the change I actually have had very few,
2:29:40 actually zero citizens ever complain about our liquor laws.
2:29:45 I don't see a reason to change them.
2:29:47 And I really don't think it will behoove anyone to be out drinking liquor later at night or make our community better.
2:29:56 We've had stabbings, you know, downtown and old town, as well as out on the North Canyon rim, a murder at Canyon Crest.
2:30:05 And those are the hours of the night when those things happen.
2:30:09 So to increase that just doesn't make sense to me, but I'm fine with the breeding and
2:30:16 I think we should get more public input.
2:30:22 Greg Lining.
2:30:23 I'm with Sean, and I don't know what
2:30:25 how the vehicle is.
2:30:26 I would be very interested in seeing this in two different
2:30:31 ordinances for what we do when we hold it down now and bring
2:30:39 it up later.
2:30:39 Vote it yes now.
2:30:41 I'm not sure how we get there if we vote it yes now
2:30:45 and still get it in two separate.
2:30:47 I don't know if we lost on that one.
2:30:48 but that's what I guess it's possible.
2:30:50 I think I'm probably gonna be in support of both,
2:30:52 but I would certainly like to see them separated
2:30:55 just so we can.
2:30:57 We don't show the bathwater out with the baby type thing,
2:31:00 and we're gonna lose one because the other,
2:31:03 because there's people that are upset with the second one.
2:31:06 So I would ask that we vote on separately
2:31:09 in some manner.
2:31:11 Sean Barreger.
2:31:15 So it's specific to the issues that are addressed in here.
2:31:18 First of all, I think we had several citizens tonight
2:31:21 came and spoke about this issue and wanting to see a change in our liquor laws. So I don't
2:31:29 think it's fair to say no one has spoken about this. I believe that Thanksgiving Memorial
2:31:37 Day and election days is an antiquated notion to restrict liquor sales on those days compared
2:31:45 to any other holidays during the year or Sundays for that matter which we have addressed several
2:31:50 years ago. The change specific to the days of service does align with what is allowed through
2:32:04 state code as a community. I think that restricting liquor while not restricting gear and wine
2:32:16 is an antiquated notion as well. Alcohol is alcohol is alcohol. And to the point that
2:32:22 Charlie made the, these licensed establishments have a responsibility to responsible service.
2:32:30 Personally, I see no difference between 1 a.m. and 2 a.m. in those establishments providing
2:32:38 that responsible service.
2:32:40 However, I don't want to jeopardize the notion of the days of the week by cramming this all
2:32:46 into one thing.
2:32:47 So I am supportive of both issues.
2:32:52 I think that it has come from responsible, established businesses in our community in service to
2:33:00 their customers who are citizens and also their customers who are visitors to our community.
2:33:05 So whatever process we need to move forward with to keep this going toward approval, I'll
2:33:12 support that.
2:33:14 if it's just reading the ordinance tonight
2:33:16 and then accepting some more public input next week,
2:33:20 I don't think that jeopardizes anything
2:33:22 leaving this in the shape it's in.
2:33:24 But I appreciate the business folks
2:33:28 who've brought this issue forward
2:33:29 and I think that they have some pretty rational arguments
2:33:35 to support it.
2:33:37 Jim Munn.
2:33:38 Okay, let's look at this logically for a minute here.
2:33:41 Right now I can walk into a bar on Thanksgiving, Memorial Day, and Election Day and drink all the beer and wine I want to.
2:33:51 Okay, so all we're saying here is, also, is that we're going to allow you to have a mixed drink during those days.
2:34:00 So, and let's just forget about this one-two o'clock thing right now.
2:34:05 Let's, I believe we should move towards an ordinance,
2:34:09 get on third and final, get it done to allow person
2:34:13 to drink beer and wine and a mixed drink on these days.
2:34:18 I mean, it's just, this is just lacking
2:34:20 in any sort of common sense here.
2:34:23 So I guess I'll vote, I forgot what Chris's motion is,
2:34:28 I think we're gonna, but let's, for both, okay,
2:34:31 I'll vote no on that.
2:34:32 That's the first reading title.
2:34:34 I'll vote no on that, but let's just get this other one done.
2:34:36 Worry about the hours next week.
2:34:39 I'm gonna weigh in now.
2:34:40 I was on council when the liquor on Sundays came forward
2:34:46 and I looked at it, very similar to what Jim just said.
2:34:50 You can just, you can get as hammered with beer
2:34:53 as you can with liquor.
2:34:55 So not that I'm a big proponent of releasing a lot more
2:34:59 and toxicants out there because sometimes
2:35:02 that doesn't turn out well.
2:35:03 But if someone has been on drinking to the excess,
2:35:07 they can do it with liquor, beer, or wine.
2:35:11 And it's up to the establishments
2:35:13 to really monitor that.
2:35:15 So the liquor piece isn't something
2:35:22 that I'm too terribly worried about.
2:35:24 I think that that's something that we need to address
2:35:27 and move forward with because, again,
2:35:29 that portion is an antiquated law.
2:35:32 The thing that I struggle with personally is the time, extending it from one to two.
2:35:38 I used to be a cop.
2:35:39 I used to also be a kid.
2:35:41 It was legal to drink at 19 when I was 19 in this state.
2:35:46 And when I was 21, too.
2:35:49 And it just gives me another hour when I was in my party mode, when I was younger, to consume
2:35:55 more alcohol.
2:35:56 And as our parents always told us, nothing good takes place after midnight, and so if we're just extending it, I'm really struggling with that.
2:36:07 The first issue is a no brainer to me, alcohol is alcohol.
2:36:13 My experience as a police officer is the longer you get people to drink at night, probably the more intoxicated they're going to get, it's just physics.
2:36:22 So that's where I'm at, I'm going to vote no for this motion because I would be more
2:36:28 than willing to vote yes, even this evening, on changing the days so that you could serve
2:36:34 liquor, just like I did for the Sundays, but I will not vote for the hours.
2:36:41 That's where I'm at.
2:36:43 Sean Berner.
2:36:44 So a question for Fritz.
2:36:46 So if the intent is to continue to have this conversation but separating these two issues,
2:36:52 that vote down to this motion that is on the table and bring another motion?
2:36:58 Yeah, because you're going to want to continue to talk about it.
2:37:05 I think one motion would be to delete the change from one o'clock to two o'clock and
2:37:11 then we can modify it accordingly.
2:37:14 But as it stands out, you're reading by title only and you're done with it.
2:37:19 Okay.
2:37:21 But you can make a mammas on subsequent readings.
2:37:23 Yeah.
2:37:24 So where are we disagreeing?
2:37:30 Well, I think Sean's asking about working on it tonight instead of it
2:37:34 Fine great planning. Yeah, that's where I'm at and I'm going to be voting no on the motion as it stands as well because I'd like to bring back a
2:37:42 Final one other motion that's third and final on the days portion and then we can continue the conversation on the hours
2:37:49 to a later date
2:37:51 So I'm going to be voting no for that reason because I would like to substitute a motion
2:37:55 that would move it to the third and final for the election days of the Thanksgiving and the
2:38:01 Memorial Day.
2:38:02 And they got the one.
2:38:03 Yeah.
2:38:04 Yeah.
2:38:05 And when I'm playing, like I said, I'm still in favor of the other one.
2:38:08 I just don't want to, I want to separate them now so we're clear on what we're doing.
2:38:13 There's someone on the phone.
2:38:15 Hello, what's hell in there?
2:38:17 Is there higher power?
2:38:18 I'm not here, man
2:38:24 Do we have that off now? All right, I think at this point we're going to go ahead and make a vote on the
2:38:33 Ordinance or the on the emotion that was brought forward Sharon
2:38:37 Don Hall no
2:38:41 Rebecca Mills like a no
2:38:45 Suzanne Hawkins no Jim on no
2:38:48 No.
2:38:49 John Bericher?
2:38:50 No.
2:38:51 Chris Tockington?
2:38:52 Yes.
2:38:53 Greg Lanting.
2:38:54 No.
2:38:55 Male.
2:38:57 Motion.
2:38:58 Fails.
2:38:59 At two words at the same time.
2:39:01 Six of them.
2:39:02 Greg Lanther.
2:39:03 Mayor Hall, I've moved that we play sortness.
2:39:06 Well, how do I, how do I delete something as part of that motion?
2:39:10 If you're going to just make a motion to delete the change from one o'clock.
2:39:13 Okay, to start with that and then you'll put that on.
2:39:16 Okay.
2:39:17 Okay, I move I make a motion that we delete the portion of one to two o'clock from Ordinance
2:39:24 Proposed ordinance 31
2:39:26 Second
2:39:27 We have a motion on the floor by Greg landing seconded by Jim Mon as stated think further on that motion
2:39:34 Sharon right back and mail so I can yes
2:39:39 Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim man. Yes, Sean Barriker. Yes, Chris talking to know
2:39:47 Greg landing. Yes, Don Hall. Yes
2:39:51 Motion passes 6-1.
2:39:53 Sean Berger.
2:39:55 I would move to suspend the rules and place the revised
2:40:01 ordinance 31-10 on third and final reading by title only.
2:40:05 Second.
2:40:07 We have motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Jim
2:40:10 Mon as stated.
2:40:11 You think further on that motion, Council, Chris, talking to?
2:40:14 I'll vote against this, but because I think we're not
2:40:16 valuing additional public input.
2:40:19 I think there are more people out here that may be willing to give their opinion and this
2:40:24 is not a case where I think third and final on this particular issue serves the full public
2:40:30 interest.
2:40:31 John Berger?
2:40:32 I would just say that this issue probably of any over the last two or three months that
2:40:37 we've addressed has had more media coverage than anything else we've done.
2:40:43 There was K&V-T news coverage, there was times news news coverage.
2:40:48 We sent our own information out from our public information office.
2:40:51 It's been on the agenda.
2:40:52 I think that folks who have a strong feeling about this issue have the opportunity to speak
2:40:58 tonight, we did have non-bar owner representatives who were here who spoke this evening, and I
2:41:04 think that there's been public input.
2:41:07 But again, I think the root of this issue is we're isolating a handful of days a year simply
2:41:15 because a hundred years ago somebody wrote them into the code.
2:41:19 Back in middle, so I can thank you, Mayor.
2:41:24 I am going to agree with Councilman Talkington on this one.
2:41:28 I think if we don't want to have this linked up council change the election of the mayor,
2:41:34 I don't know why we'd want them to change something permanent like the liquor sales laws.
2:41:40 So I think we do need more public input.
2:41:43 Also, we're more in alignment with the state code as the laws are written right now.
2:41:51 And I think that creates more consistency statewide and less confusion for patrons as well.
2:42:00 Chris, talk.
2:42:01 Well, I can tell you that maybe you've heard from the business communities, Sean, but you
2:42:04 haven't heard from other people not in the business community.
2:42:08 And I don't see where we could err wrongly on giving another week or two for the general
2:42:13 public those not associated directly with the selling of spirits to a voice
2:42:18 or opinion and forces still come into the very same conclusion by years end.
2:42:23 Jim, so what we would do is we would have to public you can drink beer and you
2:42:31 can drink wine but we want to know if it's okay if we're gonna let you drink
2:42:35 scotch and soda that's all you're doing is you're giving me another option
2:42:41 They didn't drink beer or wine.
2:42:43 I just think that doesn't make sense, Chris.
2:42:48 I will tell you, like Sean, I've had quite a bit of public comments on this subject.
2:42:54 It's probably one of the ones that has brought more folks coming.
2:43:00 And they were not some were bar owners or restaurant owners, but some were just citizens.
2:43:05 And some were younger citizens, too, that told me they were concerned about the hour issue.
2:43:11 they weren't in support of that,
2:43:13 but they were definitely in support of the motion
2:43:15 as it stands.
2:43:16 So I've had public input to me personally.
2:43:20 And as far as being a lame duck council,
2:43:23 this is not a lame duck council.
2:43:24 There's a couple folks that will be leaving the council
2:43:27 here soon, but we still have,
2:43:28 this council has the responsibility to address the issues
2:43:32 that are in front of us right now.
2:43:34 The other issue that we're talking about
2:43:36 with the election is for the next council.
2:43:39 So I guess we are lame when it comes to that,
2:43:41 but this is not, this has come, came in front of us now.
2:43:44 We have public input, we've had a personal public input,
2:43:48 so I personally think it's okay to go ahead and move forward.
2:43:52 Anything further council?
2:43:54 Chair and roll call vote, please.
2:44:00 Suzanne Hawkins?
2:44:01 Yes.
2:44:02 Jim Mun?
2:44:03 Yes.
2:44:04 Sean Beriker?
2:44:05 Yes.
2:44:05 Chris Hockington?
2:44:06 No.
2:44:07 Greg Lanting?
2:44:08 Yes.
2:44:09 Don Hall?
2:44:10 Yes.
2:44:11 Rebecca Mills-Soyka?
2:44:12 motion passes five to two thank you ladies and gentlemen for coming
2:44:17 evening and and oh thank you that was third and final thank you that's a title
2:44:22 could you read the the title and then we'll vote on that I guess I was so
2:44:27 excited about leaving I'm going to try
2:44:37 okay ordinance number 31 tan and ordinance of the city council of the
2:44:43 City of Twin Falls, Idaho amending
2:44:47 City Twin Falls City Code 3-9-9
2:44:52 by permitting the sale of beer, wine,
2:44:57 consumption, oh, no, Brits, we can't have that.
2:45:05 So 3-9-9 permitting the sale of liquor by the drink
2:45:15 Memorial Day Thanksgiving and on Election Day.
2:45:21 Is that all right?
2:45:22 That's the vice's.
2:45:24 Council?
2:45:27 Sean Barrett.
2:45:28 Move approval of ordinance 3110.
2:45:30 We have motion on the floor by Sean Barrett or seconded by Jim.
2:45:35 Fritz, point of clarification on third and final five to two.
2:45:40 We can move that.
2:45:41 Yes.
2:45:42 What's the rules of the engagement on that?
2:45:45 What's the full council?
2:45:47 Very good.
2:45:48 Anything on that motion council?
2:45:50 General Caldwell, please
2:45:53 Jim Mann. Yes
2:45:56 Sean Bericher. Yes, Chris talking. Yes
2:46:00 Greg Lamting. Yes, Don Hall. Yes
2:46:04 Rebecca Milsoyka. No
2:46:07 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
2:46:09 Motion passes 6-1
2:46:12 Ladies and gentlemen, thank you again for your patience and your input
2:46:16 It's important to it to us to hear from you. So thank you very much. Greg Lammy. My question would be we've left the
2:46:22 change from one to two on the table is that we need to stretch things that to
2:46:27 become fourth of the later date or what is our I'm good with that I didn't see a
2:46:36 lot of movement that direction again thank you folks
Download
- Transcript (text) 159 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 215 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 294 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 17.9 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 14, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:47:01.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
8faa6f617bdbfafad5d2cf247d57848e3d3e670ee79d3624a3e3ff09ef54e552 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 4 passages muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 6e5585f5411b70cc09caa88c07f780b064125a34783c70e26a1ead614534a46f
part02.m4a d41c0a5cb501d39f1f5ebd493fd202ddbe7768e76fcf4f0df1c4855b267e9b49 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 16 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
ea2c1571951c70e018d4351c2946a5d585a629e9a089da46d834f87ad115d203
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file