OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, November 2, 2015

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 into a regular meeting and we have three other boy scouts in the back so I'm going to ask them to come up and

0:00:05 introduce themselves

0:00:06 Two of them are 11 one of them is 14

0:00:08 So they threw the 14 year old under the bus and he has to do with most of the work

0:00:12 So come on up

0:00:13 if you'd introduce yourself

0:00:19 Right there at the mic and face this way, please and tell us where you meet your troop number and what you guys are working on tonight

0:00:26 So my name is Kendall Breyer's Baird and this is my brother Daniel and then this is Lucas Roberts and

0:00:33 We are in Troop 70 and we meet at the Church of Jesus Christ,

0:00:38 Latter Saints Church Building, it's Park Avenue.

0:00:43 Park Avenue.

0:00:44 It's building on that place.

0:00:45 And we are working on our citizenship in the community, my

0:00:48 wretch.

0:00:49 Very good.

0:00:50 Actually, you introduced them so they don't have to.

0:00:52 We give the folks a hand.

0:00:58 Thank you, gentlemen.

0:00:59 Next item on the agenda is a proclamation.

0:01:02 This comes from the office of the mayor and it is a proclamation,

0:01:06 Whereas hospice and palliative care offers the highest quality in professional services

0:01:12 and support to patients, families, and caregivers.

0:01:16 Facing serious and life-limiting illness and palliative care providers take extraordinary

0:01:22 measure to ask and list it to what is important to their patients, family, and caregivers

0:01:30 and, whereas skilled, compassionate, loving, hospice, and palliative care professionals,

0:01:38 including physicians, nurses, social workers, therapists, counselors, health aides, clergy,

0:01:43 and volunteers, provide comprehensive care, focused on the wishes of each individual patients

0:01:50 and their families, and whereas, while 59% of patients pass away in their own home through

0:01:56 pain management and symptom control care giver training and assistance, emotional and spiritual

0:02:03 support allowing patients to live life to its fullest until its final moment surrounded

0:02:09 and supported by their loved ones and friends. While hospice and palliative care reaffirms

0:02:16 the belief in the essential dignity of every person regardless of health, age or social

0:02:22 status, and that every stage of human life deserves to be treated with the utmost respect

0:02:29 and care.

0:02:30 And whereas each year, more than 1.7 million Americans, along with their families living

0:02:36 with life, limiting illness, received care from hospice programs throughout the United

0:02:41 States, and more than 430,000 volunteers contribute 22 million hours of volunteer service to hospice

0:02:50 programs annually.

0:02:52 And whereas hospice and palliative care providers encourage all people to learn more about the

0:02:58 options of care and to share their wishes and family with family loved ones and their

0:03:04 health care professionals.

0:03:06 And whereas the National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization recognizes over 5,800 active

0:03:14 programs throughout the U.S. working towards a shared vision of a world where individuals

0:03:20 and families facing serious illness, death, and grief will experience the best that humankind

0:03:27 can offer.

0:03:28 Now, therefore, I, Don Hall, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim November

0:03:33 2015 as National Hospice and Palliative Care Month and encourage citizens to increase their

0:03:41 understanding and awareness of care at the end of life and to observe this month with appropriate

0:03:47 activities and programs. I have the honor of signing this along with Leahy LaSanchez or Deputy City Clerk.

0:03:54 And I know we have Nora here as a volunteer that I would like to hand this to you, Nora, and a few

0:04:00 wouldn't mind saying a few words, please. Mayor Hall and council, people, persons, and the beautiful

0:04:24 citizens of Twin Falls and the Boy Scouts. Amazing. You guys did rock. You did really great. Samuel,

0:04:30 Boy Scouts, you give hope to the citizens of Twin Falls.

0:04:34 Perfect.

0:04:35 I just want to thank you so much for the proclamation

0:04:39 and proclaiming November National,

0:04:42 or bringing awareness to Twin Falls,

0:04:45 about National Hospice Appalliative Care Month.

0:04:50 Hospice and palliative care happens at the end of life

0:04:55 and the end of life passing from this life into the next

0:04:58 is just as natural as normal as being born.

0:05:03 Hospice, unfortunately, is an organization

0:05:08 that oftentimes does not get the recognition

0:05:12 until it's on a need to know basis.

0:05:16 If it's as natural and normal as being born,

0:05:18 we should all want to learn more about it.

0:05:21 Hospice is here not only for the person who's passing,

0:05:25 but for the family members and the friends

0:05:27 who are surrounding that loved one.

0:05:30 We're not all given the opportunity

0:05:32 to be awake one minute and in glory the next.

0:05:35 Sometimes we linger.

0:05:37 And when we do linger, it's hospice visions

0:05:40 and hospice organizations throughout the United States

0:05:43 that make sure that those individuals

0:05:46 don't suffer, have reunions with their loved ones

0:05:51 and their families through spiritual counselors,

0:05:54 are chaplains, the best in nursing care,

0:05:58 the best in social work, and the best in volunteers.

0:06:02 So thank you very much for doing this for us

0:06:05 and encouraging the people of Twin Falls

0:06:09 to take a little time and understand

0:06:11 what hospice is all about.

0:06:13 And if there's anyone out there that

0:06:15 would like to volunteer for such a great organization,

0:06:19 is my name and number on your website?

0:06:22 It can be.

0:06:22 It will be.

0:06:23 That's great.

0:06:24 Thank you all so very much.

0:06:26 One thing I just wanted to add just real quick,

0:06:28 this is kind of near and dear to me

0:06:30 because my father passing away a few years ago,

0:06:33 hospice care was so important to him.

0:06:35 And my own daughter actually works in this industry

0:06:38 and I have a lot of respect for folks that work

0:06:43 and go out and do this work with our loved ones

0:06:47 and help them through that final stage of life.

0:06:49 So thank you.

0:06:51 If we can give them a hand please.

0:06:57 Thank you, Nora, for bringing this to our attention.

0:06:59 Next item on the agenda is general public input.

0:07:01 This is a time for anyone in the community

0:07:03 that would like to address the council.

0:07:05 This is time for you to come forward.

0:07:07 Keep in mind, we do have a public hearing later on,

0:07:09 so if you're here for that,

0:07:10 we'll give you time to talk about that issue later.

0:07:13 Is there anyone that would like to come forward?

0:07:17 I see no one coming forward,

0:07:19 so we will now move to the consent calendar

0:07:21 and ask the council for their direction

0:07:23 on the consent calendar.

0:07:24 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:07:25 I move approval of the consent calendar as printed.

0:07:28 So motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,

0:07:30 seconded by Greg Lanting to move the approval

0:07:33 or approve the consent calendar,

0:07:35 anything further on that motion council?

0:07:38 Sharon Roll call vote please.

0:07:40 Sean Beriker.

0:07:42 Yes.

0:07:43 Chris Hockington.

0:07:44 Yes.

0:07:45 Greg Lanking.

0:07:46 Yes.

0:07:47 Don Hall.

0:07:48 Yes.

0:07:49 Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:07:50 Yes.

0:07:50 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.

0:07:52 Motion passes six to zero.

0:07:55 Moving on under items for consideration,

0:07:58 The first item is presentation of Peace Officer Standards and Training Council certificates

0:08:03 to the following individuals.

0:08:05 Officer William Jensen, Officer Medina, Ally, Bogovitch, Close.

0:08:13 You know, just a side note, Medina was my student at CSI and I've messed her name up this whole

0:08:19 time.

0:08:20 You've been an officer for about a year and a half and I still messed up.

0:08:27 And Officer William, I'm sorry, Officer Preston Stevenson.

0:08:31 So we have Lieutenant Terry Lewis, welcome Terry.

0:08:34 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council.

0:08:36 We appreciate you having us tonight.

0:08:38 I'd like to call Officer William Jansen and Medina Elebegovich up to begin with Mr.

0:08:45 Mayor if you would assist with the presentations.

0:08:52 Officer William Jansen was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on December 2nd, 2013 as

0:08:57 a full-time police officer.

0:08:59 William was born and raised in Jerome, Idaho and graduated from Jerome High School in 2002.

0:09:05 He went on to further his education at the College of Southern Idaho where he earned two

0:09:09 associates of applied science degrees.

0:09:12 He recently celebrated the two-year anniversary of his marriage to Miranda Brown.

0:09:18 William is a sergeant in the Idaho National Guard in the Idaho Army National Guard with

0:09:23 over 13 years of service including two combat deployments to Iraq.

0:09:28 William attended post basic academy and successfully completed session 178.

0:09:34 William graduated from the post academy on March 14, 2014.

0:09:41 Officer Medina Alebegovic was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 19, 2014

0:09:47 as a full-time police officer.

0:09:50 Medina was born in Bosnia.

0:09:52 She and her family moved to the United States in 1999 when she was seven years old and lived

0:09:58 here ever since.

0:09:59 Medina graduated from Canyon Ridge High School and went on to attend the law enforcement program

0:10:04 at the College of Southern Idaho.

0:10:07 Her goal going into the program was to successfully complete it and to work for the Twin Falls

0:10:13 Police Department.

0:10:15 Her family is very important to Medina and she has always had the support of her husband

0:10:19 and family in her endeavor to become a law enforcement officer.

0:10:23 has been assigned to work in the City Communications Center for the past few

0:10:28 months as she and her husband are expecting their first child. It's with

0:10:33 great pleasure that we present officers William Janssen and Medina Alabegovitch

0:10:38 with their basic certification from the state of Idaho Peace Officer Standards

0:10:42 and Training Council. I'd like to have Officer Preston Stevenson come forward.

0:11:22 Officer Stevenson was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on July

0:11:35 to 2006 as a full-time police officer. Preston was born in Ogden, Utah. In 1993, he and his

0:11:42 family moved to Hagerman, Idaho, where he attended high school and graduated in 1998.

0:11:48 He attended Rex College and Idaho State University, where he played football. Preston attended

0:11:55 the Idaho Post Basic Academy and graduated in September of 2006. He received his intermediate

0:12:01 certification on July of 2010. Preston and his wife Jody have four children Maggie, Avery,

0:12:09 Kason and Lucy. It's with great pleasure that we present Preston with his advanced certification

0:12:16 from the State of Idaho Peace Officers Standards and Training Council.

0:12:49 Well I just wanted to congratulate all three of you just one more time. Thank you for the service

0:12:53 that you provide and Medina you have to tell me when the baby's born. I'm right after your parents

0:12:59 and your husband.

0:13:01 Please open here something, okay.

0:13:03 So congratulations.

0:13:04 Folks, we certainly appreciate and understand

0:13:07 that once the agenda item that you're really interested in

0:13:11 is over, you can leave.

0:13:13 Don't feel like you need to stay.

0:13:15 We'd love to have you stay,

0:13:16 but I'm assuming that most of you would like to go ahead.

0:13:19 So we're gonna, actually, we're just gonna be quiet

0:13:22 just for a moment and let those that need to leave,

0:13:25 go ahead and leave.

0:13:27 Thank you, folks.

0:13:30 Mayor, I'm worried about your driving our audience away.

0:13:33 It's hard enough to get them in.

0:13:35 I can clear out a room pretty quickly.

0:13:39 All right, I think we're going to go ahead

0:14:02 and get started on the next item.

0:14:04 Under items for consideration again, number two

0:14:07 is presentation of an update of the Twin Falls Police

0:14:10 Department's implementation of body worn cameras

0:14:14 and body worn camera implementation program grant.

0:14:19 And we have Captain Anthony Barnhart making presentation.

0:14:21 and welcome, Captain.

0:14:22 Thank you.

0:14:23 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council, and thank you for giving us this opportunity

0:14:28 tonight to give you an update on the implementation of body warning cameras in the Police Department

0:14:35 and also the body warning camera pilot implementation program grant.

0:14:41 So early on, we recognized that body warning cameras as a law enforcement is a law enforcement

0:14:46 strategy aimed at improving public safety, reducing crime, and improving public trust.

0:14:53 In June of this year, we applied for the body-worn camera pilot implementation program grant through

0:14:59 the Department of Justice.

0:15:02 This was a $20 million grant.

0:15:06 There were 285 applications processed for this grant from 42 states, the District of Columbia,

0:15:12 and tribal governments.

0:15:15 One of the 285 applications processed, the justice awarded 73 grants.

0:15:22 We are the only agency in the state of Idaho to receive this grant.

0:15:26 The grant period begins October 1, 2015, and ends September 30, 2017.

0:15:33 We were awarded $90,000 in this grant.

0:15:37 Having been successfully successful in this grant process, we will be responsible for

0:15:43 cash for a mandatory cash match, which we have budgeted in this fiscal, in this current

0:15:48 fiscal budget. The intent of the program for the grant is to develop, implement, and evaluate

0:15:56 a body-worn camera program as one tool in a law enforcement comprehensive problem-solving

0:16:03 approach to enhancing public safety and community trust. As part of this process, we are mandated

0:16:10 to go through a six-month policy development phase,

0:16:14 we will be engaging our internal and external stakeholders

0:16:18 to create promising practices and best policies

0:16:21 for the use of body-worn cameras.

0:16:23 This phase of development has to be accomplished

0:16:27 before we can purchase any body cameras.

0:16:32 As part of the grant application,

0:16:34 we submitted a tentative timeline of the overall project.

0:16:39 The earliest we have planned to roll out body-worn cameras

0:16:42 on our police officers in an incremental approach

0:16:46 would be August of 2016.

0:16:52 Like other new forms of technology, body-worn cameras

0:16:55 have the potential to transform the field of policing.

0:16:58 However, because the technology is so new,

0:17:01 a large body of research does not yet exist

0:17:04 regarding the effects of body-worn cameras

0:17:07 and what they have on policing.

0:17:09 Some preliminary evidence indicates that the presence

0:17:12 the body-worn cameras helps strengthen criminal cases,

0:17:17 accountability, transparency, and can assist

0:17:21 in de-escalating conflicts, results in more constructive

0:17:24 encounters between the police and members of the community.

0:17:30 While we are enthusiastic about the implementation

0:17:32 of body-worn cameras, we must also

0:17:34 remember that this is one more tool in our approach

0:17:38 to a comprehensive problem-solving model

0:17:42 to enhance public safety.

0:17:45 As cameras quickly become part of every officer's uniform,

0:17:50 we must learn how to interpret video

0:17:53 as a complex piece of evidence rather than a conclusive proof

0:17:59 at first glance.

0:18:01 In conclusion, if implemented correctly,

0:18:03 body-worn cameras will help strengthen the policing

0:18:06 profession.

0:18:07 These cameras will promote evidence preservation,

0:18:10 encounters with the public, department accountability,

0:18:13 and transparency. We must always remember that the ultimate purpose of these cameras

0:18:20 should be to help officers protect and serve our community and with the

0:18:25 instant-brain questions. Thank you Captain. One thing I wanted to say before we

0:18:29 start the questions is I know that it took a lot of folks in collaboration to put

0:18:34 this together but really my hat goes off to Mandy Thompson our grant

0:18:39 writer. She is worth her weight and gold and more. I think part-time employer that has brought in a lot of income to the city to be able to utilize grant funds to further our mission to serve the people. So thank you, Mandy.

0:18:57 Very.

0:18:58 What?

0:18:59 Captain Barnard.

0:19:00 I know there's been a lot of discussion about the fact that the recordings are in essence

0:19:07 public records and do we have a plan or do we have enough direction from the state of

0:19:12 how long those are going to be needed, need to be kept, what format can they be kept in

0:19:19 and just things along that general thing that they are, am I correct that they are in public

0:19:23 record the recordings?

0:19:24 You are correct.

0:19:25 And it's my understanding that at the state level, that they are starting to have this discussion.

0:19:30 So we may see some legislation come out that gives direction in that area right now.

0:19:35 There is no direction.

0:19:36 There are some best practices.

0:19:38 We have been in communication with other organizations that have implemented the body-worn cameras, and we reviewed their best practices.

0:19:48 And we kind of have an idea, but ultimately that's all going to be developed in that six month policy development phase.

0:19:55 Thank you.

0:19:56 Sean Berger.

0:19:57 So, my question is about that policy development phase.

0:20:02 So is the Department of Justice providing any kind of resources on how this has rolled

0:20:08 out in other communities?

0:20:09 It seems like a rather comprehensive policy endeavor.

0:20:14 So they are, as part of the grant, the $2 million of that grant was given to an organization

0:20:21 that would help roll out the body camera policies and procedures.

0:20:27 I know that the University of Arizona is one of the groups that's helping participate in that,

0:20:32 and I forget the name of the other group, but they are providing support in that.

0:20:38 Great, thank you.

0:20:42 Chris, talking.

0:20:43 With my news background, Captain, I'm concerned we've identified the video as public records,

0:20:50 but they're also evidentiary under some circumstances.

0:20:55 And that's a crossover area that's going to take a lot of very precise

0:21:00 legaling and best practice search, that's sort of the thing.

0:21:04 So I would encourage us to get ahead of the curve as much as possible

0:21:09 dealing with our attorney and association Idaho cities

0:21:14 so that we cannot make any more mistakes than we need to from the beginning

0:21:19 and certainly give access to the public,

0:21:24 meaning the press of that legitimate video source.

0:21:28 Absolutely, I totally agree with your concerns

0:21:29 and we're concerned about the same thing,

0:21:31 and we will be engaging our prosecutors

0:21:33 to for help in that area.

0:21:36 Thank you.

0:21:38 Do we have any other questions or comments

0:21:41 for Captain Barnhart?

0:21:43 Wonderful presentation, sir.

0:21:45 Thank you for updating us.

0:21:46 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

0:21:47 Appreciate you.

0:21:49 Moving on to the next item under items for consideration.

0:21:52 Number three is consideration request

0:21:54 to approve a contract with RCP-Peterson consulting LLC

0:21:58 to develop a transit development plan

0:22:01 for the city of Twin Falls.

0:22:03 And we have Mandy Thompson making this presentation.

0:22:07 Welcome Mandy.

0:22:10 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council.

0:22:13 As you said, we are here to consider a contract

0:22:16 with RCP-Peterson consulting LLC.

0:22:18 Should develop a transit development plan

0:22:20 the City of Twin Falls, a little background. As you recall, the City of Solicitive RFQ is

0:22:26 from qualified consulting firms to provide professional services to the city in the form

0:22:31 of a transit development plan. We sought those proposals on Monday, August 24th, and we received

0:22:37 two submittals to that RFQ. Myself, Councilman Lanting, Josh Barrett, who is a staff engineer,

0:22:44 Renee Caraway Johnson, who is our zoning and development manager, and Mitch Humboldt, one

0:22:49 of our deputy city managers reviewed the two proposals.

0:22:53 The group ranked these two proposals based on a criteria

0:22:55 that was outlined in the RFQ, ranked them,

0:22:59 and then we ended up doing a Skype interview

0:23:01 with RC Peterson Consulting at which time we determined

0:23:07 that they were indeed the consulting firm of choice.

0:23:11 We brought that back to council and recommended that we go ahead

0:23:15 and accept that bid and begin negotiating a contract.

0:23:20 At that time, it was requested by Councilwoman,

0:23:23 excuse me, Milsoika, that we perhaps should go ahead

0:23:28 and call a few of the references of the, of RC Peterson,

0:23:32 just to verify that indeed what was in their proposal,

0:23:35 matched with what their former clients felt about them.

0:23:39 So we did do indeed do that,

0:23:40 and we received glowing recommendations

0:23:42 from all three of the organizations

0:23:44 that we spoke to, and I appreciate the suggestion that we do that,

0:23:48 two had completed work with them, and we're both

0:23:50 considering engaging with them on other projects,

0:23:53 and one is in the process of working with them right now.

0:23:59 So tonight, I bring to you a contract

0:24:05 to go ahead and, or a contract with RC,

0:24:09 Peterson, and Consulting, in addition to a scope of work

0:24:13 and a estimated budget at the cost of $48,730.

0:24:23 Very good, and we have,

0:24:24 I was kind of waiting to see, well, I'm gonna ask you.

0:24:27 I'm gonna bring this to you,

0:24:28 and I suppose I am asking for your guidance

0:24:31 on whether or not you'd like to accept this contract.

0:24:34 And have the mayor sign the contract.

0:24:35 Yes. Yes, very good.

0:24:36 Greg Lanning.

0:24:37 I was ready for a motion.

0:24:38 Do we have any questions before Greg's motion?

0:24:42 Greg Lanning.

0:24:44 Mayor Hall, I move that we accept the contract

0:24:47 with for the amount of 48,000.

0:24:50 What was the change 730?

0:24:51 730 dollars.

0:24:52 730 dollars with R.C. Peterson's consulting LLC

0:24:56 to develop a transit development plan for the city

0:24:59 of Twin Falls and authorize the mayor to sign that contract.

0:25:04 Second.

0:25:05 We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,

0:25:07 seconded by Chris Tockington.

0:25:09 Rebecca Milsuk.

0:25:11 Thank you, Mayor.

0:25:12 And thank you, Mandy, for looking into their references,

0:25:17 their former clients and making sure that they had a good experience.

0:25:21 And reading through the contract, it's very well written and really there isn't anything

0:25:27 that I could add to make it better.

0:25:30 And I think it's a good example of what's become our standard practice of first engaging

0:25:36 the stakeholders and engaging the public at the beginning, during, and then towards the

0:25:41 end of the process.

0:25:42 And so I'm very satisfied with this contract, and I support it.

0:25:51 You have anything further, Council, before we go to the vote.

0:25:56 Sharon Roll call vote, please.

0:26:00 Chris Tockington.

0:26:01 Yes.

0:26:02 Greg Lanting.

0:26:03 Yes.

0:26:04 Don Hall.

0:26:05 Rebecca Mills-Soyka.

0:26:07 Yes.

0:26:08 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:26:09 Yes.

0:26:10 Sean Barrieger.

0:26:11 Yes.

0:26:12 Motion passes 6 to 0.

0:26:14 Thank you, Mandy.

0:26:15 Thank you.

0:26:16 Next item on the agenda items for consideration is public import or and or items from City Manager City Council.

0:26:23 So we'll start with the public again. Is there anyone from the public that would like to address the Council on any issues this evening?

0:26:31 Other than the public hearing you'll have a chance to do that in just a few minutes.

0:26:35 Is there anyone that would like to come forward? City Manager City Council.

0:26:42 I would just like to encourage folks, obviously tomorrow is Election Day and please make your

0:26:51 voice heard.

0:26:53 It's an absolute privilege to be able to vote.

0:26:58 A lot of countries around this world don't have that privilege.

0:27:01 So please make your voice heard and get to the polls.

0:27:06 Great landing.

0:27:07 I would like to echo those sentiments.

0:27:09 I think city elections typically run around 15% of the eligible voters number and I'd like

0:27:17 to remind all those that you're listening to get up vote.

0:27:21 We are the closest to you.

0:27:22 We probably have more effect over what taxes you pay and things than any other group.

0:27:27 We were one of seven.

0:27:28 The people that are running for this office that's compared to one out of 70 legislators

0:27:33 or 1 out of 535 congressmen and for some reason we don't have the glamour of our presidential

0:27:41 or governor's race obviously but we're the ones that can actually affect more things

0:27:46 within your life than any of those other groups can so please get out and vote and be like

0:27:52 Chicago get out and vote early, vote often I guess we're going to stay away from that

0:27:58 Just vote early and your time.

0:28:01 Do we have anything further from council?

0:28:03 Well, I think at this time,

0:28:04 we obviously have an executive session,

0:28:06 but I think the time is limited for us

0:28:08 to be able to really get deep into the next subject.

0:28:12 So I think at this time,

0:28:13 we're going to take a recess and reconvene.

0:28:17 I know that says a quarter to seven.

0:28:18 I keep getting confused too.

0:28:19 That's a quarter to six.

0:28:21 Yes.

0:28:22 And we are going to take a recess

0:28:25 and then reconvene at six for the public hearing.

0:28:28 What we're going to do, we have said Dennis Boyer,

0:28:30 Dennis Boyer, this is off the way with input,

0:28:35 on the greater area Twin Falls Transportation Committee's

0:28:39 project priority list.

0:28:40 And we have our city engineer, Jackie Fields.

0:28:43 Welcome, Jackie.

0:28:47 Good evening.

0:28:52 So the Greater Twin Falls Area Transportation Committee

0:28:55 is grouping transportation entities throughout the valley.

0:29:01 That includes the City of Twin Falls.

0:29:03 And one of the primary missions of that group

0:29:07 is to provide input on ITD's transportation improvement

0:29:16 program.

0:29:16 They used to have a different acronym.

0:29:20 And the way that that's done is through the priority list.

0:29:35 So the priority list is a fairly stale document.

0:29:38 You can understand what the matter is.

0:29:40 It's split into the different categories of funding.

0:29:43 This is a state project.

0:29:46 Horizon Project is one that is beyond the seven-year mark.

0:29:53 Is it funded by local urban funds or local rural funds, or something called L-RIP, which

0:29:59 is like a maintenance payment maintenance program for very small population groups?

0:30:08 So you'll notice in the L-RIP program that City of Kimberly is still allowed to stay in,

0:30:17 But at some point in time in the near future, Kimberly and Twin are going to be considered

0:30:22 together for funding.

0:30:25 So we have been notified that we need to work together in making funding applications for

0:30:32 the local urban program.

0:30:34 So you know, we did that.

0:30:37 This is the current list and it has a wide variety of projects.

0:30:43 Now, those projects don't just come out of the blue.

0:30:46 They are generated by various things, and one of those things is a planning study that

0:30:55 was done in 2004, and it was called the Southeast Twin Falls Alternate Study, and there has been

0:31:03 progress made on those project lists over time.

0:31:07 And so part of one of the products of this current study was to generate a new list of

0:31:12 jobs for this list.

0:31:15 We also can put on capacity projects of our own, but projects that are supported by some

0:31:21 kind of study or by consensus of the transportation, the greater Twin Falls Area Transportation Committee

0:31:27 tend to receive, have a better chance of getting funding.

0:31:31 So on October 5th, I made a presentation to you about some of the projects that were possible,

0:31:39 and those were a list of safety projects.

0:31:45 Generally you remember those, most of the safety projects are outside of the city of

0:31:49 Twin but there are a few that were within the city and they're relatively small in

0:31:53 price and probably pretty manageable. They were located at, they comprised some

0:32:01 advanced signing on Highway 74 near Orchard installation of some different types of

0:32:09 The signal has at the intersectional locust in Kimberly Road and installation of left-turn

0:32:19 lines on Highway 30 to help with the potential cue that can form up there.

0:32:44 There were also a list of capacity projects.

0:32:47 The study looked for places where there could be some limitations ultimately in our planning

0:32:54 horizon and listed several projects. The projects in parentheses are, you know, you can see that

0:33:03 thing on the left is when I'm calling a parentheses. I think there's another name for it, but there

0:33:08 it is. And they are all related to improvements that help the downtown core effectively. And

0:33:15 then the three on the bottom are major capacity improvements on our south roads. So we talked

0:33:23 about these and when we were having a conversation about what do we value, what should we be focusing

0:33:30 our efforts on. We had a discussion and I recommended supporting safety projects for downtown projects

0:33:37 and then capacity projects starting at our western, most north, south route and moving eastward.

0:33:45 That conversation also included discussion on the last piece of the study.

0:33:55 Jackie, I do have a light on Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:34:01 Thank you, Mayor.

0:34:02 And Jackie, when a rip fits into your presentation,

0:34:03 you can address that.

0:34:04 I appreciate the extra time that we've

0:34:06 had to look through the study and look at the numbers

0:34:10 that they provided to us.

0:34:11 And I was just wondering if you could talk more

0:34:14 about the benefit to cost ratio that's attached to each project

0:34:18 and what that means and if that was considered

0:34:22 as far as weighing these projects.

0:34:26 And then when it talks about the projected future conditions,

0:34:30 for example, is that an I-9?

0:34:33 Am I saying that, or is it a I-9?

0:34:34 I-9?

0:34:35 I-9?

0:34:36 OK.

0:34:37 Yeah, I-9A, you know, it talks about the undesirable LOS

0:34:41 by 2018.

0:34:43 Can you talk about just for the public

0:34:44 and for all of us to understand that better?

0:34:47 What LOS is and these benefits across ratios?

0:34:54 whenever it's convenient in your presentation.

0:34:57 Yes, thank you.

0:34:59 Well, it was a timely question because it fits now.

0:35:05 Great.

0:35:06 So let's see here.

0:35:20 This is I-9A, and it consists of doing some reconfiguration

0:35:25 work at the intersection of blue legs and Kimberly

0:35:28 wrote at 5.0 section of the railway.

0:35:35 cost benefit ratio is a number that is associated with the cost of the benefits are given a

0:35:50 numerical value based on what kind of accident is reduced and what kind of congestion is

0:35:56 alleviated.

0:35:57 So if you have a death, death is very expensive not only mentally but physically expensive

0:36:08 obviously, because you're no longer around.

0:36:10 So it receives a very high value.

0:36:13 So if you had a death on a per safety project,

0:36:17 that would tend to really weigh heavily

0:36:20 on the benefit side, eliminating the opportunity for death.

0:36:23 If you have a very high or a higher cost benefit ratio,

0:36:27 then eliminating a fender bender,

0:36:30 which has a very small safety benefit.

0:36:34 on capacity projects, the benefit is also uses delay.

0:36:40 So how much delay is there?

0:36:42 How much fuel is burned?

0:36:44 How much time is wasted?

0:36:46 And I couldn't go anymore in depth on that right now

0:36:51 without having to go back and do kind of research project

0:36:53 for you, but functionally,

0:36:55 these are formulas that are plugged into and used.

0:37:01 So I'll pick up to that generally.

0:37:05 Yes, thank you, that's very helpful.

0:37:07 And just could you explain what LOS is?

0:37:09 LOS is called level of service.

0:37:12 OK.

0:37:12 And so level of service is directly related to how much

0:37:18 you're antagonized.

0:37:20 And how long do you have to wait at that intersection?

0:37:22 How much stop and go to your up with?

0:37:26 Do you have to, are you inconvenienced?

0:37:28 So a long time ago, in our Transportation Master Plan,

0:37:32 showed some pictures of level of service A and level of service F and F actually in

0:37:38 larger cities has there's several refs for different levels of stop-and-go type

0:37:43 traffic and level A is clear sailing it's like you're you and a few of your best

0:37:49 friends are on the road and that's it. And that is and that's a certain I know

0:38:02 What you're saying in a logarithm or something, how do you come about the LOS, I guess, is what I'm wondering.

0:38:12 Level of service is related to the volume on the road and measure delay, can you measure delay?

0:38:22 But it's a certain equation that you plug in the information into to determine it or how do you come up with the grade?

0:38:36 is an equation. So one and I don't usually personally do not usually

0:38:41 attribute a level of service to a roadway. So but I can get really close. So I'm

0:38:47 an unofficial estimator. Okay. I don't use the equations but transportation folks

0:38:55 have for the purposes of our reports. Okay. Thank you. Okay. So part of this

0:39:01 This conversation also included what was being recommended for next steps on a potential southeast

0:39:10 Twin Falls alternate route.

0:39:24 Within the body here it talks about potential next steps and the reason for it.

0:39:31 There was a need or we believed that we needed to, if we were going to pursue, if anyone was

0:39:37 going to pursue an alternate route that they needed to have more public involvement. The

0:39:44 public involvement in the scope of this project was extremely limited. It was basically a presentation

0:39:49 to government type officials. And there was a recognition that there needed to be more

0:39:53 outreach. There also was a recognition that we probably needed to do an origin destination

0:40:00 study. There was one done at the report in 2004. Origin destination studies, actually,

0:40:06 They stop people and you ask them where they're going.

0:40:09 And it's really inconvenient.

0:40:10 And it's kind of expensive to conduct.

0:40:12 But there could be some good information that comes out of it.

0:40:16 And then the next few steps included were steps taken

0:40:23 by transportation entities, Twin Falls Highway District,

0:40:27 Twin Falls County, in potentially the city of Twin.

0:40:31 And they were modifications to transportation master planning

0:40:35 project master planning processes, and potentially also comprehensive planning processes.

0:40:42 But the, and the bullets don't require it, but that's how you actually implement the product

0:40:51 of the plan.

0:40:52 If there was a desire to go forward and investigate the alternatives more thoroughly, then a public

0:40:59 involvement program should happen, an origin destination study should happen, and some

0:41:05 work by the transportation entities would then occur potentially after that.

0:41:12 So that conversation took a backseat to the concept and the reality that Greater Twin Falls

0:41:21 Area Transportation Committee had been meeting illegally for years.

0:41:27 And so, the body of the agenda item addresses that,

0:41:33 but you would briefly discuss that now.

0:41:35 Please, please do.

0:41:36 So, the Greater Twin Falls Area Transportation Committee,

0:41:41 I'm just gonna call on the committee.

0:41:43 That committee is a county committee,

0:41:45 and they actually have a secretary who takes minutes.

0:41:48 Sometimes those minutes are handwritten.

0:41:50 There's no requirement that they be anything other

0:41:53 than handwritten, but obviously typed minutes

0:41:57 are kind of handy. Everyone can read them. The chair went on to request and received permission

0:42:05 from both the county commissioners and the owner of the meeting place, Idaho Joe's, to

0:42:09 post a list of the meetings that are going to occur during the year. Since similarly to

0:42:16 city commissions, if you have a bunch of standing meetings, you can post the entire list. But

0:42:20 you need permission from both your governing body, which is the meeting commissioners, and

0:42:25 place, the people at your meeting place, so they did that. We also, City of Twin also

0:42:30 volunteered to post the list and they're posted down by utility services and the

0:42:34 drinking pom. In the main part of City Hall. 48 hours, at least 48 hours prior to the

0:42:41 meeting, the chair or his designee potentially the secretary will post the

0:42:46 agenda at the county as required and at Idaho Joes. That process happened for the

0:42:53 October 15th meeting and it is anticipated that it will continue to happen for the

0:42:59 remainder of the time that the committee means. So a public meeting is in order to

0:43:07 have a public meeting you have to have a quorum and we have been having a little

0:43:11 bit of trouble having getting quorum together. We being the committee. So the

0:43:18 The chair researched the decisions that were made at the meetings where there was actually

0:43:26 a quorum.

0:43:27 Sometimes it's just a coffee clutch.

0:43:30 People get around and because there's no quorum.

0:43:31 So you just kind of chat, you can't approve minutes, and you can't make any decisions

0:43:35 so people just kind of talk about transportation stuff.

0:43:38 You know, oh, what are you doing with CLK neighborhood and so on.

0:43:43 But the chair went back and looked, he found a potential 180-day statutor limitations on

0:43:51 decisions.

0:43:52 And so he went back six months and found that we had made the committee had actually made

0:43:57 an illegal decision in May.

0:44:00 When Keller made its presentation to the greater twin vote to the committee, he presented some

0:44:05 draft conclusions.

0:44:06 And that caused quite a bit of discussion.

0:44:09 And at the end of that discussion, the committee agreed that there should be a team of the affected

0:44:18 parties to review the study.

0:44:20 So those affected parties were the transportation entities that were directly affected.

0:44:26 So the City of Twin, the Twin Falls Highway District, and the City of Kimberly.

0:44:32 The motion was made to have representatives from those entities, so that was Rob Wright,

0:44:41 the purchase myself, participate on this review team.

0:44:45 That motion was unanimously approved.

0:44:48 Since it's in a legal decision, the committee waited it publicly at the meeting of October

0:44:59 13th, which was properly noticed. So it's very possible that that could be taken up at a future meeting.

0:45:08 May I stop and just real quick, because as you're talking, I'm trying to work this out my mind.

0:45:16 And this isn't thrown rocks at anyone because obviously I've actually served on the Greater

0:45:21 Twin Falls Traffic Committee as well, early 2006. And I wasn't sure whose committee it was, but recently

0:45:31 we found out through investigation that it's actually a county committee.

0:45:35 We didn't know that before.

0:45:37 We didn't know if it was a city committee.

0:45:38 I just knew I was the liaison and that we had our city engineer always in attendance.

0:45:43 Who appoints when you talk about a quorum?

0:45:47 Who appoints committee members then?

0:45:50 Should it be the county commissioners?

0:45:52 I believe the charter for the committee does not have

0:46:00 of the county commissioners making all of the appointments.

0:46:03 I believe that they are, that the composition of the committee

0:46:07 is a member selected by their respective jurisdiction

0:46:14 for each jurisdiction.

0:46:16 So if Casselford wanted a representative,

0:46:18 they would pick who they wanted to go and-

0:46:20 Who's they though?

0:46:22 Castle Ford.

0:46:22 They'd cast the castle for it.

0:46:24 So if the city of Castle Ford wanted to have a representative,

0:46:27 Okay.

0:46:28 They could because they take care of their roads

0:46:30 and they could appoint those people.

0:46:32 So what the city of Twin did,

0:46:34 as the city of Twin said that their liaison

0:46:38 would be the member of the committee

0:46:43 and that I could proxy for them in their absence.

0:46:48 Okay.

0:46:49 Okay.

0:46:50 So for example, the chamber of commerce

0:46:53 is designated in the resolution by the county

0:46:56 to have a position and so our board selects a person

0:47:01 to serve in that capacity.

0:47:03 So the resolution from the county says you will have

0:47:08 city of so-and-so, city of so-and-so,

0:47:09 Chamber of Commerce, trucking industry,

0:47:12 I mean it designates the types of people

0:47:15 who serve on the committee.

0:47:16 A county resident, a city resident,

0:47:20 a trucking company person.

0:47:25 And so when those people make themselves known,

0:47:27 when they say they're interested,

0:47:29 then there's a process for choosing them

0:47:35 that is done within the committee itself.

0:47:40 Since there's usually no one who wants to participate,

0:47:43 it's what very, very few volunteers,

0:47:47 very few interest parties,

0:47:54 huge competitive processes in the time I've planned.

0:47:56 So again, it made sense to me that the chamber,

0:48:00 the board would select someone,

0:48:01 the city would select someone,

0:48:03 how support they want it but that at large folks and the trucking company

0:48:09 trucking industry who who recommended those folks

0:48:16 are chosen by the committee and the resolution allows that to take place

0:48:22 okay now at this point I can't tell you that's exactly true and but I'll go

0:48:29 I guess I'm just structured, we have structure to our committees and we know who appoints and how all that happens.

0:48:36 And there is a structure that's written down.

0:48:39 So I am not a person who is actually in charge of the process.

0:48:44 And so I haven't dumped into it.

0:48:48 Okay. Thank you, Jay.

0:48:49 Okay. So that's all I have to say on whether or not the committee is doing its best to come into compliance with open meaning laws.

0:49:02 And to perpetuate that throughout to take care of any

0:49:06 glaring errors that existed in the process.

0:49:09 So we're having discussions like amending the agenda formally

0:49:15 at the beginning of the meeting.

0:49:19 While there's a pause here, just let you folks know, I know a few folks have come in since we've started

0:49:28 the public hearing here. If you're interested in testifying, we'd appreciate it if you'd sign up in the back.

0:49:34 Okay, so I believe that there, so you'll open the floor for testimony and then, so the end

0:49:45 of my staff report is to talk about the Greater Twin Falls Area Transportation Committee's

0:49:52 priority list.

0:50:01 And this is it.

0:50:03 So this is the current list and it was voted for and approved at the last committee meeting.

0:50:16 So, it is the tradition of that group to place all of the amendments.

0:50:24 You know, you get a whole bunch of lines on a piece of paper and somebody might be confused.

0:50:28 And so, typically, it is brought back for a final look.

0:50:31 And the chair has traditionally opened the floor for amendment.

0:50:36 If you saw something that wasn't quite right, or you changed your mind or received more input,

0:50:41 you know, he's been willing to allow that.

0:50:45 Can I stop and just forget the lights come on?

0:50:48 Sean Berger.

0:50:49 So these projects that are listed on this priority list,

0:50:53 are any of these the same ones as the lengthy list

0:50:58 of safety and capacity projects that evolved out

0:51:03 of the 2004 study, or the most recent study?

0:51:08 No.

0:51:09 OK.

0:51:09 And the part of your recommendation in your staff report

0:51:13 talks about prioritizing safety projects, then capacity projects in downtown.

0:51:20 So as part of what you're asking us is whether we feel those projects should be injected

0:51:26 into this list?

0:51:27 Yes, it's accurate.

0:51:29 But not necessarily at the expense of the number one ranked project, which is Second

0:51:37 Avenue is Washington, 6th and Minidoka.

0:51:40 So that is a large local urban application that could actually embody several of those

0:51:50 downtown capacity projects.

0:51:53 Thank you.

0:51:54 Chris.

0:51:55 Chris talking.

0:51:56 I want to be very clear.

0:51:57 I understand the highlighted projects are a list accumulating from the time JFAC met

0:52:08 under open meeting laws.

0:52:10 So these meet our scrutiny under open meeting laws in all form and fashion.

0:52:17 Let's see.

0:52:18 This list was presented at the first legal meeting, now of October 13th.

0:52:31 That wasn't a posted meeting though, wasn't it?

0:52:33 That was posted.

0:52:34 That was the first one.

0:52:35 So I would guess you're saying yes to my question.

0:52:38 This, well, this list is 15 years old or more.

0:52:42 I understand.

0:52:43 But this list in its entirety was presented to the committee for debate and discussion on October 13th.

0:52:53 Okay, thank you.

0:52:54 And just for clarification, because I know we're getting there, but we have input tonight, we have no authority.

0:53:01 That's accurate.

0:53:02 Okay.

0:53:02 Well, you have a voice.

0:53:03 Of course.

0:53:04 And your voice is your liaison, which is Rebecca, and in our absence, we present the request.

0:53:12 But we're one of, you know, it's a large committee.

0:53:16 Sure, okay.

0:53:18 No more lights.

0:53:21 I'm done with my presentation

0:53:22 unless you have more questions.

0:53:24 Do it, and you're going to follow up

0:53:26 after the public testimony going to the West again.

0:53:29 I can do that.

0:53:32 Great planning.

0:53:32 I'm a little confused, Jackie.

0:53:34 I'll have to get this players as,

0:53:37 when we were discussing this list,

0:53:40 October 10th or whatever it was.

0:53:42 Yes.

0:53:43 That's all right.

0:53:44 And we, we didn't look at any of these.

0:53:47 All we looked at was the three safety ones

0:53:50 and the five or six capacity ones.

0:53:52 And you were asking this at that time.

0:53:54 I thought you were asking this to prioritize that list.

0:53:58 And that list seems to have went away

0:54:00 and we now have this list.

0:54:02 No, this list existed.

0:54:05 Okay.

0:54:06 And it's last year's form.

0:54:08 So when I came to you on October 5th,

0:54:11 I was trying to gather what your priorities were

0:54:19 with regard to the safety and capacity projects

0:54:22 to see if you really wanted to include a specific project

0:54:25 or if it was the direction that I was recommending

0:54:30 what you were gonna be happy with.

0:54:32 Do you want me to lobby first for safety projects

0:54:34 and then downtown projects and then capacity projects

0:54:36 or do you wanna choose a different order?

0:54:39 So I was trying to determine or verify

0:54:42 what I believe are your values for incorporation

0:54:46 into this list.

0:54:48 Okay, and so are we going to do that at some point tonight?

0:54:51 It would be lovely.

0:54:52 Okay, all right.

0:54:54 So I'd be honest with you Jackie,

0:54:57 before I could do that,

0:54:58 I may need more discussion with you

0:55:00 and your presentation about those again,

0:55:04 to be able to do so, okay?

0:55:06 Like right now, I've come like,

0:55:08 we've switched over to this list that I just now saw.

0:55:11 And so, okay, if I'm maybe the only one confused.

0:55:18 You know what, it's all good.

0:55:19 This is a large project.

0:55:20 So the sixth of Minidoka project takes in,

0:55:24 just about every single one of those projects

0:55:26 that have a piece of it.

0:55:28 So they're just little pieces of it.

0:55:29 If we accomplish the whole job,

0:55:31 or any given piece along the way,

0:55:33 we've still accomplished the mission.

0:55:35 That's what I wanted to hear.

0:55:35 Thank you.

0:55:36 Yeah, you bet.

0:55:37 And I can show you that list again.

0:55:40 Okay.

0:55:40 mentally you'll be able to see that they're all on that alignment. Right. Well, I'm looking

0:55:44 at a map of it and it appears to be I can see what you're saying, but I was a little

0:55:48 confused. I didn't think, I didn't realize we were working on this at all tonight. I thought

0:55:52 we were just working on those eight items and prioritizing them. We are. Okay. All right,

0:55:58 good. Yeah. Suzanne Hawkins. I apologize. Is this list in our packet because I can't find

0:56:06 No, this list is, I even just finished drafting it, so I got it on work.

0:56:13 And I hate to be your problem child, but my eyes aren't good enough to really, from here,

0:56:18 go through that, so I'm struggling a little bit with that.

0:56:21 Is there any chance you have an extra copy that maybe I can get closer to my eyes?

0:56:28 Yes, I know that one.

0:56:29 Thank you.

0:56:30 So, yeah.

0:56:32 Thanks.

0:56:37 I don't know, perhaps you can make copies during the public testing.

0:56:42 Someone could run this up.

0:56:45 No, no, he's done a workout just fine.

0:56:47 Okay.

0:56:48 You're bringing up a good point.

0:56:49 I can see that it's not easy to see.

0:56:51 I know what's on it because it's generally the same as last year.

0:56:54 So, but that's not necessarily helpful for you.

0:56:59 Would it be helpful to sit in GMC?

0:57:01 It's a joke.

0:57:03 You're an helpful person.

0:57:06 It is a real crowd.

0:57:12 And we just had confirmation that you can't see it either.

0:57:14 So, I...

0:57:15 It was...

0:57:16 Okay.

0:57:17 We've functionally had one job, and it was working on improving the roadway that is Washington

0:57:28 Street, sixth and minidotable in an effort to...

0:57:32 Josh, could you make 20 or more copies in case folks in the audience would like them?

0:57:38 Thank you, sir.

0:57:39 encourage and build it to like a truck worthy capacity to provide some relief to the

0:57:46 seconds. Okay so at this time I'm going to open up the public hearing this is a

0:57:56 time for folks to come forward and make their voices heard we generally limit

0:58:01 that to about two minutes you could be succinct I'm not going to be super strict

0:58:09 on that but if you just out of courtesy for others in the audience that would be great.

0:58:14 And I have one more thing.

0:58:15 Okay.

0:58:16 So in my paperwork I have a letter from a Mr. Carney that also has some opinions that could

0:58:29 be incorporated in the further study section of the document which is to be there.

0:58:36 Well maybe we could actually put it up while we're having the public testimony.

0:58:40 Because I think it falls right in line with that. Although I'm going to be honest with you, it's a very long

0:58:45 document, long letter, and very detailed. If you had trouble reading the other one.

0:58:53 So, at this time I'm going to go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of this evening's

0:59:04 hearing and go by our list here. And the first, if you would come up and introduce yourself, give us

0:59:10 address and please address the council. First person we have on the list is Jill

0:59:15 Scheme. Thank you. I'm not sure exactly why you wanted. Thanks for having us here. The

0:59:29 public here for this presentation the committee does not report isn't part of

0:59:35 the City of Twin Committee or Council. It is part of the county and it's been

0:59:40 quite frustrating frankly that even though they're doing open meeting laws the

0:59:44 meetings were not posted online, we're not, the agenda wasn't there, I'm having trouble

0:59:50 getting the minutes from the last meeting, I asked right after the meeting, could I get

0:59:54 them from September meeting, October to date, I still haven't received the minutes.

0:59:58 I think it's totally inadequate to have that committee meet at Idaho Joe's, and frankly

1:00:02 it seems like everyone thinks this committee doesn't do anything, I'm not sure exactly

1:00:07 why the committee exists, although I do know that it's, they do make recommendations, they

1:00:13 They've just spent $99,000 of taxpayer money for this study.

1:00:18 I still can't get an answer on who came up with the three routes.

1:00:22 I understand the steering committee did, and I've heard that from other members of the committee,

1:00:26 but the chairperson of the committee insists they didn't.

1:00:30 And I still can't get the answer to whose homes are going to be displaced and the three routes.

1:00:34 Now, this is public information.

1:00:36 I've been asking that question since August 4th.

1:00:38 I have not received that.

1:00:40 And frankly, we live there.

1:00:43 It's our home and the fact that it's printed in the paper,

1:00:46 that there's going to be a truck route,

1:00:48 possibly in front of our house,

1:00:50 has dropped our property values.

1:00:53 We wouldn't be able to sell without disclosing that.

1:00:55 And we have no comfort and no information

1:00:58 about what's happening with our home.

1:01:01 And I find it very frustrating.

1:01:03 And 25 years they haven't followed open meeting laws

1:01:06 and they argue about putting it online

1:01:09 on the county website, it's totally unacceptable.

1:01:13 And if it was any of your homes,

1:01:15 I think you'd feel the same way.

1:01:17 I mean, you have a future, you think,

1:01:18 oh, do you improve your home?

1:01:20 Do you not?

1:01:20 Is it gonna be destroyed?

1:01:21 Who knows?

1:01:22 It won't tell you.

1:01:26 I think it should be disbanded, frankly.

1:01:28 And I don't know what's going on with the truck route.

1:01:31 I think the three routes that are proposed are invalid

1:01:34 because it was done during meetings that weren't open.

1:01:38 they might say that they're here now, but who decided those?

1:01:41 I don't know.

1:01:42 So I'm totally frustrated.

1:01:44 And I think that they should go above and beyond open meeting

1:01:49 laws, post them on the website, doing a agenda,

1:01:52 sort of driving to a restaurant to figure that out.

1:01:54 I mean, I was out of town.

1:01:55 I wanted to know what time the meeting was.

1:01:57 Wanted to know what the agenda was.

1:01:59 Can't find it.

1:02:00 So anyway, I'm, I guess, telling you my discontent

1:02:05 with this committee and trying to get the information.

1:02:08 and I'll just have to pursue other ways to get it,

1:02:12 and that should not be.

1:02:14 So for whatever it's worth,

1:02:16 I think all this should be started over

1:02:19 with public input from the beginning,

1:02:22 not from this point on.

1:02:24 I mean, 25 years, how many, how,

1:02:26 two years they've been working on this,

1:02:27 and we just found out about it, not acceptable.

1:02:30 Anyway, but thank you for listening.

1:02:31 Thanks for encouraging us to come,

1:02:33 and I appreciate your work.

1:02:34 Joe, would you mind giving us your address?

1:02:36 3648 North 3300 East Kimberly and maybe they'll tell you if my house is being

1:02:42 displaced. I don't know. Maybe you can find out for me. Thank you. Thank you Jill.

1:02:46 And what I'm going to try to do folks tonight is that if you have questions,

1:02:50 specific questions, I'll try to list that and then we'll address those as best we can.

1:02:56 Next person is Tom Skeen and Tom I'm assuming you live the same place because

1:03:04 was a little parenthesis, so I think you're good to go.

1:03:09 My only question is the authority of the committee.

1:03:16 In a conversation with the county commissioner, Terry Kramer,

1:03:20 I was told that a great Twin Falls area of transportation

1:03:25 committee was not county committee, so I'm confused about that.

1:03:33 Beyond that, the discussion tonight really hasn't been about the new highway,

1:03:37 So we're a little out of place there probably.

1:03:40 But anyway, thank you.

1:03:41 Well, you're very welcome, sir.

1:03:42 Thank you for coming forward.

1:03:49 Next person is Steve Woods.

1:03:52 Welcome, Steve.

1:03:54 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council members.

1:03:57 The reason I came here tonight was because I attended

1:04:01 a meeting back in early October, where we talked about

1:04:05 where you talked about many of the same things.

1:04:08 And the meeting at that time dissolved into a discussion

1:04:12 about the southeast traffic way, and that got into open meeting discussions and everything

1:04:16 else.

1:04:17 That was a major issue.

1:04:19 Most of the other stuff that was presented was not even part of the discussion.

1:04:24 Everybody was concerned about southeast trafficway issues, and even tonight, the same thing happened.

1:04:32 Jackie just kind of briefly mentioned the southeast truck route issue, but the rest of

1:04:41 discussion was about all the other Monday, Monday, and if you will projects around the

1:04:47 area. And like many people, I'm here because I didn't know it was going to come up for discussion.

1:04:55 I mean, that Southeast truckway in my mind is a major consideration because it talks

1:05:02 about getting rid of Agland, it talks about urban sprawl, which is against the comp plan.

1:05:08 There's a lot of things that I see are not good with the southeast traffic way.

1:05:14 We have a Kimberly Road comes into Twin Falls, a right pass truck and tire facilities that

1:05:21 can be used by motels and restaurants that can be used.

1:05:25 If we bypass all that, what happens to that area from Hankins Road to Blue Lakes?

1:05:31 Does it just die because nobody's going by there anymore?

1:05:35 I think there's a lot of other alternatives, but that's apparently not what we're discussing

1:05:40 tonight.

1:05:41 That's something on the back burner.

1:05:42 And maybe that's something in future discussions on this, recognizing that it is a key issue to

1:05:48 say it won't be discussed or it will be discussed.

1:05:51 Give a little more depth to the agenda.

1:05:54 Thank you.

1:05:55 Thank you, sir.

1:05:57 Bill Groves.

1:06:00 And by the way, if I mess your name up, please just correct me.

1:06:03 Oh, Steve, I'll say your address.

1:06:04 I don't think you said it.

1:06:06 32, 10, Longbow Drive, is that correct?

1:06:08 32, 10, Longbow Drive area of impact.

1:06:10 Thank you, sir.

1:06:12 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:13 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:13 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:18 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:06:22 And I think it's totally wrong to have somebody come from out

1:06:26 of town and tell us what we're going to do with our city

1:06:28 and county, and the people that live there are not involved.

1:06:32 You don't know it unless you see it in the paper.

1:06:35 I think that's totally wrong to do it that way.

1:06:37 You're displaced in all these homes,

1:06:39 like everybody else has said.

1:06:41 Nobody will tell us whose homes,

1:06:44 and I'm pretty sure mine is one.

1:06:46 It'll put me out of business,

1:06:47 put my neighbors out of business

1:06:49 that are got cattle and things out there.

1:06:53 It'll put a dairy out of business across the canyon.

1:06:56 And I think there's other options,

1:06:57 like the Blick Highway that we had to have years ago,

1:07:02 before the trucks to come off the 93 and come into town,

1:07:06 we had to have that.

1:07:07 And now that's not even an option.

1:07:10 And I think there's another option that nobody's really brought up

1:07:12 is to go clear south, come off at Hollister across the BLM ground,

1:07:18 get to foothills road and go to Hanson and right straight to the freeway.

1:07:22 If we don't want them into windfalls, why bring them so close?

1:07:27 And there's a lot of trucks that come in.

1:07:29 They come off Highway 74, come over to Blue Lakes,

1:07:33 right into town and right out Kimberly Road.

1:07:36 They do the same on Eastland, with a little work

1:07:39 and not so much money,

1:07:41 while it looks like that Eastland could be redone a little bit,

1:07:44 bring them right into town around the corner of the Malcomated,

1:07:47 or right into Kimberly Road, and they're out of town.

1:07:52 I just like to put my two cents worth in

1:07:55 that I'm too old to move and re-establish at this stage.

1:07:59 Well, thank you for your time.

1:08:01 Thank you.

1:08:02 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:08:14 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:08:19 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:08:23 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:08:26 We just need to know what's going on. We have no idea for you in displays or not.

1:08:31 We went to the Kimberly meeting over there and that's the first we really even knew what was going on.

1:08:35 And over there, we asked even Gary Young,

1:08:40 why aren't we being informed?

1:08:41 They said, well, it's because of this,

1:08:43 we didn't want you to be informed,

1:08:45 because we had adverse to that.

1:08:49 We just want to be informed.

1:08:50 We want to know if we're being displaced.

1:08:51 All three routes is going to affect me on my property.

1:08:55 So we just want to be concerned in what's going on,

1:08:58 and just to be known to go to a meeting to a decent place.

1:09:03 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:09:04 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:09:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:09:22 [Muted for privacy: home address]

1:09:27 we know what was studied in the decision for the route? Do we know that all those

1:09:32 trucks crossing that bridge are really headed out south of town? I travel that

1:09:37 I rode every day, I had to drone, I worked for a trucking company, and I see the trucks on

1:09:42 that road.

1:09:43 A lot of them are Gary Ameth, a lot of them are headed to the beat, a hall, a lot of them

1:09:47 are going into twin to do business in twin.

1:09:49 So is there been a study on where the final destination is of those trucks, in discussion

1:09:55 with Arlo Lot, who has served on committees like this in the past, he said that in the

1:10:00 past there has been studies done on crossing that bridge, and that most of those trucks

1:10:04 aren't headed south of town.

1:10:06 So just would like some more information on knowing that, on how this decision was based.

1:10:13 Also something that was discussed at my workplace was in the past they discussed possibly a new

1:10:19 bridge going across the canyon.

1:10:21 But that was 15 to 20 years ago when it's never happened.

1:10:25 So how does that affect us?

1:10:26 Is this just going to go away and no answer if we wanted to sell now, if we want to move,

1:10:31 it's affected our property value greatly.

1:10:34 Thank you.

1:10:35 Thank you, thank you.

1:10:36 Max Newlin, welcome Max.

1:10:42 I'm Max Newlin, I'm at 3, 28, 7th Avenue East.

1:10:46 I'm not directly involved.

1:10:48 My house isn't going to be tore up or anything.

1:10:50 But I think you need to tighten up your ship when you have one

1:10:54 little entity that points somebody and another entity that

1:10:57 points the body, and nobody wants to be on this.

1:11:00 And so you never have a quorum.

1:11:02 There ought to be some kind of parliamentary and legal

1:11:05 decision about managing your membership in the committee if people don't show up then replace them

1:11:12 Because you'll continue to have no quorum, and then what can you do if you can't get a quorum that was my

1:11:19 Two cents worth. Thank you. Thank you, Max

1:11:22 That's the last person that I have on the list as there been anyone else that would like to come forward

1:11:28 All right

1:11:31 I will be closing the public testimony portion but keeping the discussion and

1:11:36 and questions, this gives the opportunity to counsel still to ask folks that might have testified tonight.

1:11:41 Jackie, anyone else questions before we close all of that and begin our deliberations?

1:11:48 So we are closed with the public testimony portion and we're going to be calling Jackie back up here for questions, I'm sure.

1:11:56 Greg Lanning.

1:11:57 What did we want to have Jackie have a closing first or before we start?

1:12:02 I'm okay with that, but your light came on so I didn't know how I get interested you were to go.

1:12:06 Well, if Jackie has a closing, let's go ahead and do that.

1:12:09 I was just going to make some comments concerning what the public test was.

1:12:12 So maybe this is a better spot.

1:12:16 The one on the county, we have been told it's a county committee.

1:12:20 And whether it is, if it isn't, it's not our community, I can guarantee you that.

1:12:23 It's definitely, it's not ours.

1:12:25 And it's not the counties.

1:12:26 I'm not, maybe it's ITDs.

1:12:27 I'm not sure who it is on that one.

1:12:30 I would offer that.

1:12:32 And with council accordance that we can certainly publish the meeting dates and times and things

1:12:41 on our website somewhere I would think because we do have connection to the committee, Travis,

1:12:45 is that possibility?

1:12:46 Because they can't get it on the county one, they can put it on ours?

1:12:51 Yeah, we can certainly put any information out there as a public resource, but it's not

1:12:57 going to remove the responsibility of the entity who sponsors the community to honor all of

1:13:03 the public. I'm just trying to spread warrants and a wider net hopefully. I think we we we

1:13:10 can we can we can certainly post information as it comes available to us on our website in

1:13:18 in hopes of creating better information and for members of the community I think that at

1:13:29 some point in time we have to recognize that the city of Twin Falls's website is for the

1:13:33 the purposes of the city of Twin Falls.

1:13:36 And that it's, you know, being good at sharing information

1:13:43 is part of that public service and responsibility,

1:13:45 but I also think that the county should be strongly encouraged

1:13:48 to place information on their website,

1:13:51 just as we have done and were instructed to do

1:13:55 through a series of processes that we took on last year.

1:13:58 Well, I agree with that,

1:14:00 that county should be doing it,

1:14:01 But if they aren't doing it, we need to help out.

1:14:03 That's just the way I put it.

1:14:05 I wanted to stay just upfront that we don't know.

1:14:08 We've not contacted the county.

1:14:10 We've had testimony that they have,

1:14:12 but we don't know that for sure.

1:14:13 We do have a county commissioner in the audience.

1:14:16 Leon Mills is here, so he certainly is welcome to come forward

1:14:19 and state some information to us,

1:14:23 but that's his decision.

1:14:25 So Greg, do you have any-

1:14:26 I've got some more.

1:14:27 Yeah, okay.

1:14:28 Do you want to continue with that?

1:14:29 Sure.

1:14:30 It's obvious to me, and this is just discussion at this point or thought process to kind of

1:14:38 answer some of the things.

1:14:39 It's obvious to me that maybe the public portion of this discussion, Jackie outlined

1:14:44 that there is a public portion coming to discuss that route as well as everything else

1:14:49 on that list, and obviously that probably should have came before any routes were determined

1:14:58 for the water better.

1:14:59 We saw the routes, we brought them to us, so we didn't have any prior, at least I didn't,

1:15:08 I didn't have any prior knowledge of the three routes before they were brought to us for discussion.

1:15:13 Great, if you don't mind, could I ask Fritz come forward?

1:15:17 Fritz, this is a public hearing, and generally what we do is we take all testimony, questions

1:15:23 and answers, and then we go into deliberation.

1:15:26 It sounds to me like we're starting to go into deliberation, is that still the...

1:15:30 No, I think there's a lot of confusion here because obviously people are very upset with

1:15:35 the southeast corridor because of what's happened in the past and they're voicing their concerns

1:15:41 here but that has nothing to do with the public hearing today.

1:15:45 Jackie needs a priority list that has nothing to do with that so probably we shouldn't.

1:15:50 I know people are concerned about it.

1:15:52 I know you want to address it but you're not in a position to fix it because it isn't your

1:15:57 committee. I guess you can offer suggestions to the county commissioners, but this public

1:16:03 hearing is not the place to deal with that because Jackie's public hearing is what is

1:16:08 your priority and safety list from the list she has, has nothing to do with the southeast

1:16:14 corridor.

1:16:17 Thank you, Fritz. So, these are the questions that I heard. I'm just going to throw them

1:16:24 out. It's not part of what we're going to do tonight, but if someone could address these

1:16:28 So you can, as Councilman Lanting was having a conversation about next steps, if you will,

1:16:39 you can have that conversation after the public hearing piece and process.

1:16:45 So get through your business and your work that you need to move forward with, and then

1:16:50 you can re-engage on those other things that were brought up so that it just doesn't fall

1:16:58 silent. I think that is much cleaner process. Thank you. Rebecca. That's a great idea. And

1:17:06 so I'll hold my comments on that until we make our recommendation. Very good. Chris talking.

1:17:11 I think I'm more fundamentalist to my hope. I'd like to see who takes responsibility for

1:17:18 this organization. If the county does not claim it, then it almost seems like it's ITD is by

1:17:25 default and there should be enabling legislation we have to find ownership of

1:17:32 this we've seen the ordinance that created the committee it's a county

1:17:38 ordinance thank you thank you councilman talking to actually running me of the

1:17:45 question that I had last time we had this discussion Gary Young presented us

1:17:51 with a city ordinance and he claimed that this committee was also a city committee because

1:17:56 we passed an ordinance and I'd like to hear Fritz's opinion on that.

1:18:01 That was like 1992 or something like that and then there were two county ordinances I

1:18:06 think after that so those we can't both have the same committee and so the more recent one

1:18:13 is going to control.

1:18:14 So it's a county, it is a county committee.

1:18:17 have to I don't think you have the authority to take it over as it's their

1:18:22 committee right no and I wouldn't want to I just wonder what position that place

1:18:25 is the city of doing pausing because that resolution is on the books what do

1:18:29 we need to do something about that resolution or I don't think you do

1:18:33 because the county is taken it so it's created first here at the city and the

1:18:38 county has taken it over a year from the documentation we saw at the at the

1:18:42 meeting on October 5th okay thank you for that so friends again are we get

1:18:45 and wayward again from the boss ass, let's do it.

1:18:48 If we could finish up Jackie's thing,

1:18:50 because this is really getting confusing,

1:18:51 if you can finish up Jackie's thing.

1:18:53 And then we can readdress this.

1:18:55 Thank you.

1:18:55 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:18:56 I was just going to ask if you had those copies,

1:18:58 so I can have it up here to look at.

1:19:01 Thank you.

1:19:02 The ones that were run off.

1:19:03 Good idea.

1:19:03 Yeah, sorry.

1:19:06 OK.

1:19:08 So at this time, I'm going to ask Jackie

1:19:10 to go ahead and readdress the council.

1:19:19 And do we have enough?

1:19:21 Are there members of the audience?

1:19:26 Thank you, that would like a copy.

1:19:31 Max, could you take care of that for us?

1:19:33 Could you get those out?

1:19:35 So Jackie can start a presentation.

1:19:40 Jackie Fields?

1:19:41 Our task at hand is to talk about projects and values,

1:20:01 because that will give us a very handy way

1:20:06 to get a project into greater Twin Falls area

1:20:11 of transportation and community priorities.

1:20:13 Okay, so we have a list of safety projects.

1:20:22 So that's I-2, I-7, and I-3 are within or near the city.

1:20:32 And they are safety improvements that could directly benefit

1:20:39 people that live here and the people that come here to work.

1:20:45 They are fairly modest in price.

1:21:05 So this is the Capacity List Project.

1:21:09 I-8, I-9, I-11, and I-13, are all.

1:21:18 I-9, I-9, A and B, right?

1:21:21 Yes.

1:21:22 Okay.

1:21:23 Yes.

1:21:24 I-11 and I-13 are all projects that generally fall in the alignment of the Washington Sixth

1:21:32 and Minidoka Project, okay?

1:21:35 So the terminus of the Washington, the last year, I was trying to move forward and I

1:21:40 talk to you about potentially applying for a local urban project to improve Washington

1:21:48 Street from Washington and Addison southerly around on the 6th through the intersection

1:21:56 where the deep pool grill is and then tying into the five points at Blue Lakes. So these

1:22:03 projects are all along that alignment and would be improvements in lieu of the

1:22:12 entire project could be or they could be part of the entire project. There are other

1:22:20 other projects that affect us directly in town and those are major widening

1:22:26 projects on Washington Street from Highland orchard on Eastland from US

1:22:31 30 to orchard we've already been working on that rebuilding that

1:22:34 roadway, but this would be widening as well. Well, let's see, Eastland from 30

1:22:40 to Orchard works on the railroad underpass, which is a huge problem for us

1:22:44 financially. Wightening the road and realigning the railroad is huge. And then

1:22:54 the last project is on Blue Lakes, which is widening segments of that roadway to

1:22:58 five lanes from right about at the five points down to Orchard. There are other

1:23:04 Other projects on this list, well, okay, Blue Lakes and Orchard,

1:23:10 it says to install a traffic signal.

1:23:12 We've talked to the highway district,

1:23:14 and we have warrants that support replacing,

1:23:19 or the placing once again, the four-way stop configuration

1:23:24 that was in play when we were doing arsenic.

1:23:26 And we think that that's a good short-term fix

1:23:30 until the volumes come up a little more.

1:23:35 Okay, so that's our, that's the entire list of projects

1:23:40 recommended for, from the study.

1:23:46 The question before you tonight is,

1:23:48 how would you like to prioritize going after some

1:23:52 or all of these improvements?

1:23:55 If we, if we don't want to work on any of them,

1:24:00 specifically, that's okay.

1:24:05 We wanted to still put in a local urban application

1:24:08 for the seconds from Washington, 6 in Minidoga,

1:24:12 that's also okay.

1:24:14 So there's no conflict between saying,

1:24:16 I want you to go for a local urban project

1:24:18 that you won't get money for for 10 to 15 years.

1:24:21 And doing some of these intermediate fixes

1:24:24 like improvements that she's shown at six,

1:24:28 they're out there by Blue Lakes and Kimberly Road.

1:24:36 So, the values component becomes, do you want to do, do you want to tackle safety projects

1:24:43 first and then go after these smaller projects on the alignment and then do capacity projects

1:24:50 or do you want to choose some other order or or do we want to abstain in its entirety

1:24:57 and potentially stick with this as our sole project, these two as our sole projects or any

1:25:05 variety of the of the you have you have so many choices so I was hoping to just

1:25:12 talk about values and step and and say what do you want to do safety projects

1:25:17 first downtown projects first pass the projects first or nothing okay so we have

1:25:26 lights ready for questions Kristok so if we were to put priority one is

1:25:32 safety of those projects, what would be the top one, how would they rank, how would they

1:25:39 fall out I guess.

1:25:45 So if we said the city safety projects or the city's priority, then we could choose, well,

1:25:58 we could insert ourselves into the Highway District and State Project and say, you know,

1:26:02 this is really important to do a project out at 3,300 in Kimberly Road.

1:26:07 affects all of us in the area and it could be a very positive attribute for people who

1:26:12 are afraid of being rear-ended on the state highway or we could confine ourselves to our

1:26:18 city projects and we could choose those on the cost benefit analysis or we could choose

1:26:23 them on some other value like I think it would be really beneficial to have advanced warning

1:26:35 signs on highway 74 because I myself have tried to blow through the signal at orchard

1:26:40 For instance, that would be, that's not true.

1:26:43 Okay, I'm just using that as an example.

1:26:45 So that would be, that's enough of a valid point

1:26:49 to bring that forward as a priority.

1:26:53 I mean, we don't have to confine ourselves

1:26:54 to the cost benefit ratios if we don't want to.

1:26:59 So how did your rank those?

1:27:01 I only caught I too as being one of your safety ones.

1:27:06 Fair question, haven't you, right?

1:27:09 If you left it up to me, I would rank I3

1:27:12 as our number one safety project.

1:27:15 And I would then rank I7 and then I2 because I never

1:27:21 blow through the signal ever.

1:27:27 I never, ever miss it, not even in the fog.

1:27:30 Someone apparently has a problem with this,

1:27:33 and so it's still a good project.

1:27:35 It's fairly nominal in cost.

1:27:37 We could almost accomplish it without statements.

1:27:42 That would be my recommendation to go with safety.

1:27:45 Thank you, Chris.

1:27:45 Sean Berger.

1:27:48 I was going to agree that I think the safety project should be philosophically our priority

1:27:55 and I would certainly follow your recommendation on which order those go in.

1:28:01 I would however say that the Washington 6th Minidoka seconds project collectively is real

1:28:10 close to the same priority in my head, that if that project in its entirety or even in

1:28:19 pretty significant pieces could start moving forward sometime sooner than 20 years from

1:28:25 now, I think that it addresses many issues unique to downtown for capacity and getting

1:28:34 around and also addresses some industrial needs downtown with businesses, with industries

1:28:41 as well.

1:28:42 So I would put those both very close, but I think, again, philosophically, safety should

1:28:47 be the priority.

1:28:48 So if there is a convenient way of plugging that into this list and recommending that

1:28:53 to the committee, I would certainly support that.

1:28:58 And just quickly, I would mention, too, I believe that the Origin and Destination Study

1:29:04 that's discussed as possible next steps with part of the Southeast Corridor also helps to

1:29:10 address some of the Washington Street Sixth Minidoka issues because there has been some

1:29:17 question as to whether the goal of these improvements is to get traffic through Twin

1:29:24 Falls or to Twin Falls or from Twin Falls.

1:29:27 And I think that we've certainly heard that from the industrial folks, downtown Conagra,

1:29:33 capstones, some of those people, they're bringing trucks to and from Twin Falls not trying to

1:29:38 bypass us.

1:29:39 And so, I think having that study done would be really helpful

1:29:44 in determining whether the southeast corridor is really a priority,

1:29:50 or B, if we need to be focusing attention on making improvements

1:29:55 in and around downtown to address those.

1:29:59 Thanks, Sean.

1:29:59 Rebecca Milsuken.

1:30:01 Thank you, Mayor.

1:30:02 Thank you, Jackie, for your explanations tonight.

1:30:05 One of the things that we talked about at our last meeting

1:30:08 on this topic was what really caused an item to be put under the safety list or what caused

1:30:15 it to be put under the capacity list.

1:30:18 And it really wasn't clear.

1:30:21 I guess a lot of it overlapped.

1:30:23 You know, some improvements are both safety and capacity.

1:30:28 And so I, of course, philosophically would prioritize safety.

1:30:35 But as I'm looking at the breakdown of these projects, we can see that I-3, if we place that

1:30:41 as the highest priority, it's had seven crashes and two fatalities, and yet I-2 has had eight

1:30:48 crashes and three fatalities, and that's the five-year crash history on that.

1:30:53 So what I'm thinking is, you know, we need to decide how to classify something as truly

1:31:01 a safety-related item, but I agree with Councilman Berger as I was contemplating these projects.

1:31:09 I think that our strategic plan and just the collective desire from the community and the

1:31:16 momentum behind this number one-ranked project of the second avenues, I think that would really

1:31:23 demand for me that that that be of high priority, certainly along with safety, but I don't know

1:31:34 about the number two ranked local urban project, but I would certainly be comfortable supporting

1:31:41 that number one and only that number one as far as from the list that comes from the committee.

1:31:50 But other than that, of course, I think we would all say we all support safety projects.

1:31:56 But I also would place a heavy weight on the cost to benefit ratio, and I think that needs

1:32:05 to be talked about and considered before we have an official list.

1:32:12 Greg Lanning.

1:32:14 I'm going to be one I obviously shown your comments as Rebecca talked about.

1:32:19 I think those are kind of the direction I would go to the safety ones and then looking

1:32:25 at the full change over from the seconds to Minidoka as you explained it and I'm going

1:32:32 to throw another portion into this.

1:32:34 I remember last year's legislature when they went through the entire funding, refunding

1:32:40 or additional funding to ITD, they threw a little thing in at the end that I don't think

1:32:46 people realize there's half and quite as it's going to half of any surplus immediately goes to I.T.D.

1:32:53 and we don't get a cut of that part either by the way that's the second part of it we get a cut of

1:32:57 all to I.T.D. the city of Twin Falls will not get a cut of that so that kind of points it towards

1:33:03 needing to be an I.T.D. funded project but I got a feeling that there might be looking for things

1:33:09 that are ready to go and so anything anything we can do to make that move on the second avenue is

1:33:14 ready to go for the additional additional fifty two four million dollars which will be coming

1:33:19 their way at least fifty four million dollars will be coming their way that they haven't gotten

1:33:24 their budget in any way shape or form at this point in time. An extra fifty four million

1:33:29 from the state surplus of a hundred and eight million will be there looking for projects

1:33:35 and we need to have our project as far down the road as we can. So the ready to go and that

1:33:40 to me is our number one obviously we need to go safety first but that one to get on

1:33:44 the for that application for that urban whatever you call it Jackie Urban

1:33:50 Utilization Grant is that what you called it? It's a local urban project. Right okay,

1:33:55 all part with it. I had urban in the work. We need to make sure that we're

1:34:01 ready to go on that because there's some extra money floating around ITD that

1:34:07 they're just now right at this moment thinking about how we're going to spend

1:34:10 Thank you.

1:34:12 Thank you.

1:34:13 Thank you.

1:34:14 Very good then.

1:34:15 Suzanne Hoffman.

1:34:16 Thank you.

1:34:17 Jackie, in your opinion, is it better to have more of our items on the list so they

1:34:23 know we're ready on these things or is it better to just go after one thing and try to

1:34:27 get their attention on that?

1:34:30 How do you weigh that from how they make decisions?

1:34:41 Here's the list and you can see clearly that the majority of the goals on the list are not

1:34:49 funded at this time, which means they don't happen any time in the next five to seven

1:34:56 year, five to six year, please, horizon.

1:35:00 So in my opinion, we can do either.

1:35:09 We can do a select few of our top priorities.

1:35:12 We can put everything we think is important on there.

1:35:16 Your single project competes for a limited amount of funds and will be reevaluated at the moment

1:35:22 of submittal for a project to see whether or not it actually makes a warrant.

1:35:27 So for instance, we're not necessarily ready to do the widening, the capacities on Washington

1:35:33 Street aren't necessarily driving the widening project this year.

1:35:37 So we could submit if we wanted, but we wouldn't get funded for it.

1:35:41 So we'd simply look at that decision at the time.

1:35:44 Okay.

1:35:45 Well, I support what we've been talking about with getting the safety needs out there.

1:35:49 And I appreciate you mentioning the stop sign at Orchard and Blue Lakes because that one is

1:35:53 near and dear to me.

1:35:54 And I don't want to let that intersection slide away because to me that one is a safety issue

1:35:59 as well.

1:36:00 So I appreciate you mentioning that, but I'm comfortable with the recommendations of the

1:36:05 rest of the council and hitting those safety needs, but keeping the Minidoka seconds and

1:36:10 to show a project on the list if we can.

1:36:17 Can I ask a question?

1:36:18 Please.

1:36:21 So we'll prepare and make a local urban submittal

1:36:25 for the entirety of the project on the second half

1:36:27 is in January.

1:36:30 That's about the time to do that.

1:36:34 Great.

1:36:37 Are there any of these particular projects

1:36:40 that stand out as something that you would like to have

1:36:44 then independently, like that is, in the time frame that's

1:36:49 closer than 10 years from now. So it, to me, I think if we say that the downtown projects

1:37:02 are priorities and we want to apply for a project that occurs in a term that's nearer than 10

1:37:08 years, I would suggest that the improvement that's just shown in sixth is a significant

1:37:14 project in its own right that actually has an improvement that could be realized there.

1:37:20 And let's see, and the analysis of Merta and a second would be beneficial for the city

1:37:31 as well.

1:37:34 I ate 9-11.

1:37:40 Let's throw the question back to you based upon a capacity rating.

1:37:45 How would you go?

1:37:46 What jumps out of you?

1:38:00 I really would like to do Washington Street from Highland to Orchard, but it doesn't make

1:38:06 it.

1:38:07 Give us a number.

1:38:08 Yeah.

1:38:09 It's down there at the bottom, S-4.

1:38:10 It's not going to qualify.

1:38:11 It doesn't matter what I want.

1:38:17 So again, I didn't really catch a question.

1:38:20 It was more of a statement I heard from you.

1:38:21 So the question I had was, did you want to pick one of these

1:38:26 in particular to bring forward, if you don't?

1:38:31 That's OK.

1:38:32 Can we pick two?

1:38:33 Sure.

1:38:33 OK.

1:38:34 Very good.

1:38:34 That's a question back.

1:38:35 Great laugh.

1:38:36 If you want to.

1:38:37 And Jackie, like something like I-13,

1:38:40 do we need to wait on the state on that?

1:38:42 Can't we go ahead and do that on our own?

1:38:44 We probably won't apply for a project for $14,000.

1:38:47 We'll just talk to the state and start working together on it.

1:38:50 And between their maintenance money and our maintenance money,

1:38:54 we can probably accomplish that.

1:38:56 Yeah.

1:38:56 Let's say, just moving back to the bar that's on the road, 8 feet.

1:39:00 I can't imagine that even would cost $14,000.

1:39:03 But I guess I've.

1:39:04 It's a few extra signs.

1:39:05 And they're assuming that you're going to do it

1:39:09 in the absence of a seal coat.

1:39:10 So you want to remove, obliterate the existing pavement

1:39:12 our games.

1:39:13 Okay.

1:39:14 It's a high end.

1:39:18 So I didn't weigh in.

1:39:20 So I'll weigh in.

1:39:21 I guess I agree with Rebecca.

1:39:23 I don't know how you can not prioritize safety.

1:39:26 When you have safety in front of a title, we're not going to prioritize that.

1:39:30 So obviously that makes sense to me.

1:39:32 And then under second avenues in Washington, Washington Street South and sixth in Minidoka,

1:39:38 all that, I-8 and I-11 also appeal to me as well.

1:39:42 What do you need from us tonight?

1:39:44 Do you need a motion stating our priority list so that you can take it with you?

1:39:55 Would be fine.

1:39:57 So that would be fine.

1:39:59 Yeah, that's probably the best way.

1:40:01 Okay.

1:40:02 Consensus on the direction would be awesome, however I can get that or we're going to get

1:40:08 that.

1:40:09 Okay.

1:40:10 Because she needs to take that.

1:40:11 So at this point, do we have any other questions and then we'll just turn it straight over

1:40:16 to deliberation towards a motion from the council.

1:40:20 Any other questions for Jackie or anyone else in the audience?

1:40:25 At this time, we're going to turn it over

1:40:27 to the liberation and or emotion,

1:40:30 so I need direction from camera, Chris talking.

1:40:32 Okay, well, just to make sure that we've already done this,

1:40:34 I would say that first prioritization based on safety,

1:40:39 I would motion that we recommend I-3, I-2, and I-7.

1:40:49 motion on the floor for and it sounds like this is where we're going to start

1:40:54 and maybe get other motions yeah okay break it down on the pieces so we have

1:40:58 motion on the floor I know I have a life second oh your second it's Sean

1:41:01 Berger we have motion on the floor by Chris talking to the seconded by Sean

1:41:04 Berger we'll turn it over just to discussion on that motion council any

1:41:08 discussion I see none so we're gonna begin there Sharon with a roll call

1:41:15 please Greg Lanthine yes Don Hall Rebecca Mills-Soyka yes

1:41:27 Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim Mann or not Sean Beriker yes Chris talking yes

1:41:34 motion passes six to zero further discussion Council on direction Sean

1:41:40 So I would move to also include Project I-8 and I-11 as capacity projects.

1:41:54 Second.

1:41:55 Motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka as stated.

1:41:59 Anything further on that motion?

1:42:02 Council.

1:42:04 Chair and roll call vote please.

1:42:06 Don Hall?

1:42:07 Yes.

1:42:08 Rebecca Mills-Soyka?

1:42:09 Yes.

1:42:10 Suzanne Hawkins?

1:42:11 Yes.

1:42:12 Sean Berrigger, Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting.

1:42:17 Yes, motion passes six to zero. Sean Berrigger.

1:42:23 And I don't know that I need to make this a motion, but if I do, everyone can tell me.

1:42:28 I would just say keeping the other three projects that are on the current list.

1:42:36 So the second avenue is, I guess it's listed there twice. It's not really three projects, but yeah,

1:42:41 Yeah, two different funding sources keeping those on there also as priorities.

1:42:46 And if we don't need a motion on that then.

1:42:50 Second. We have a motion by Sean Berger, seconded by Greg Glanting.

1:42:55 It wasn't a very, you know, right. I can make a motion to do that.

1:42:59 I'm going to take it. Sorry.

1:43:01 That's okay. Anything further on that motion council Rebecca Mills, so I can.

1:43:06 Yeah. Question for Jackie. I know that we tried to fund the pull on to Eastland section.

1:43:10 section, the blue licks to candle ridge and we were rejected, they didn't feel like it

1:43:16 was enough of a destination and so that's my only concern with these two recommendations.

1:43:22 I fully support number one but number two, do you feel that it would even be possible that

1:43:32 it would get funding or and where does it come from?

1:43:34 I mean, we have all of the analysis from the study

1:43:38 on each of these projects.

1:43:40 And then, whole line to Eastland, we have no information on.

1:43:45 So, whole line to Eastland is a road section

1:43:50 that's known to us as being narrow and really old.

1:43:56 And that segment was originally longer than that.

1:43:59 Part of doing a local urban application

1:44:02 is that we need to show that people are going there

1:44:06 for a reason, or they have a reason to be on that road.

1:44:11 So we picked, we picked Lulex to Campbell Bridge

1:44:15 because people are coming off of the state highway,

1:44:18 which is a perfect logical nexus or whatever,

1:44:21 and going to a temple, which I thought

1:44:23 was a perfect logical nexus,

1:44:25 because there's a lot of people,

1:44:26 but so it looked like a project

1:44:30 that had a good set of termini on it.

1:44:34 And the road is obviously decrepit

1:44:37 and rapidly becoming undersized.

1:44:42 Is it, has anything changed?

1:44:45 The volumes have increased a little.

1:44:47 The road is getting a little more compromised

1:44:53 and it's ability to withhold the traffic.

1:44:57 Can I get funding on it?

1:44:58 I don't know that.

1:45:00 So that's why Second Avenue.

1:45:03 Well, Second Avenue is before it

1:45:04 because it's part of your priority.

1:45:07 And also it appears to be one that would be more

1:45:11 More competitive.

1:45:15 Thank you.

1:45:16 Anything further on that motion, Council?

1:45:19 Sharon Rofogo, please.

1:45:24 Right back in the house.

1:45:26 Yes.

1:45:28 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:45:29 Yes.

1:45:30 Sean Barriker.

1:45:30 Yes, Chris Hockington.

1:45:32 Yes, Greg Lanting.

1:45:34 Yes, Don Hall.

1:45:35 Yes.

1:45:36 Motion passes six to zero.

1:45:38 That takes care of that piece now.

1:45:42 I want to be a respecter of those that came and testified.

1:45:45 There's three or four different questions I have here that I heard them say hopefully I'm succinct enough, but before even that

1:45:55 Commissioner Mills would you mind coming forward? I have a question for you because it sounds like there is some

1:46:01 Confusion where there the county believes this is their committee or not. Could you could you address that?

1:46:06 Yes, I apologize earlier, but really you were in a public hearing for this election of that and it really had nothing to do with the county

1:46:14 I didn't really care to testify, but Lea Mills, 150 Jefferson Street, and I am a Twin Falls

1:46:19 County commissioner.

1:46:22 And what we do have, and we just found this out, I mean, unbeknownst to probably Mr.

1:46:29 Lanting, is the fact that we just found this out too, that it's really not an ordinate in

1:46:35 any way, shape or form.

1:46:37 It was a resolution done in 94, 2004 again.

1:46:42 So the real thing about it to us is, yeah, who is this?

1:46:47 I mean, Mr. Young, we thought was a representative of the city,

1:46:52 but Rebecca's the representative, Jackie.

1:46:54 And so I think as a, the next step might be to figure out,

1:46:59 who's the representative of Castle Ford?

1:47:00 Who is the representative?

1:47:01 And that makes up the body, the voting body.

1:47:04 And we'd never heard of it until a couple of months ago

1:47:08 that it was anything to do with George, who is our chairman,

1:47:12 representative from the county and that's what we thought he was. We did not know

1:47:17 that 20 some years ago this was something that was made up and how the

1:47:23 recommendations really go. And so I can't really speak a lot about it but as far

1:47:28 as making it available on our website not a problem as far as posting it not a

1:47:32 problem. We're willing to comply with that in all aspects as we shape this into

1:47:37 what it probably was supposed to be, you know, but I'm willing to try to answer any questions

1:47:43 also. So Commissioner, have you had a chance to run this by your legal to look at the resolution

1:47:52 to see what your perspective is? Keep in mind I realize you're one of three, just like I'm

1:47:57 one of seven. Have you been able to do that? We've talked to our legal and it is just a

1:48:03 resolution. It could die for a lack of involvement. It's not an ordinance that anybody really needs

1:48:10 to keep up. But we see the importance of it, but as we move forward, again, George is the

1:48:17 only one in my tenure that's even been there. I've never been there, so I don't know. It was

1:48:22 just a meeting that we go to kind of like the Red Sea War or any meeting of several that we

1:48:30 do it then. But like I said, the flaws in it are, we don't have the organization set

1:48:38 up because nobody knows where they're from and who they represent. That's what I see personally.

1:48:43 But the other thing is, is that if we were violating the open needle law, and we didn't

1:48:49 we never had a quorum there ever. There was just one county commissioner. So we're we

1:48:56 We will put it on our website.

1:48:58 We do already notice the meeting.

1:49:01 We place it at County West, and also, as you said, on the door of the Idaho Joes.

1:49:08 So that makes that legal requirement.

1:49:11 Again, I think they've only made one decision in a long time, and I don't really know what

1:49:18 authority that decision they have to make also.

1:49:22 Do you think it would be helpful, sir, if maybe the chairman of that committee actually

1:49:28 came and made a presentation to the full county commissioner?

1:49:31 Oh, he.

1:49:32 You can get your head around this.

1:49:34 He has.

1:49:35 He has.

1:49:36 Okay.

1:49:37 Yeah.

1:49:38 But not, and this was a year ago.

1:49:39 And this was just when he was telling us about the three routes around the city.

1:49:43 Well, I mean more of the structure of how this is and how the resolution is.

1:49:48 I've just-

1:49:49 Yeah.

1:49:50 No, I understand all that.

1:49:51 Okay.

1:49:52 Yeah, you know what I'm saying.

1:49:53 It's the really the authority of that body.

1:49:55 And again, where the finances come from,

1:49:58 it says each entity pays so much, the city owes so much,

1:50:03 the county, but no one was ever collecting,

1:50:05 no one was ever, there's never a treasure.

1:50:07 I mean, this is real, but again, it falls back,

1:50:10 Marvin Humbleman, Brent Ranky, so on.

1:50:13 Those were the initiators of this committee.

1:50:16 So we were not ever, we just thought it was immediate,

1:50:21 know, no one had that history at all.

1:50:24 Well, thank you, sir.

1:50:27 But it hasn't moved forward.

1:50:28 You know, if you have any questions, I'll try to answer them.

1:50:31 But we're here to correct it, you know, and help move forward in any way we can.

1:50:37 Okay.

1:50:38 Thank you, sir.

1:50:39 Thank you.

1:50:40 The questions that I heard I'm going to go one at a time here is who came up with the three

1:50:45 routes?

1:50:46 That's what I heard.

1:50:47 Jackie, could you maybe try to address that or give us some indication?

1:50:52 Okay, Keller was contracted to do a study by the commission by I.T.D. I.T.D. So they worked with the committee to set up the contract. So there was a small group of people that was very young with the chair. Dave Burgess from the Highway District and me worked with I.T.D. liaison to set up the contract.

1:51:25 And that's what we did.

1:51:27 We argued about what the scope should be.

1:51:29 We argued about the money, how that money should be attributed

1:51:34 to do tasks.

1:51:36 So, Keller conducted a technical, produced a tech number

1:51:42 report, and then ultimately the study.

1:51:45 And in the study, they made recommendations for next steps.

1:51:50 And they did show three potential routes that could be

1:51:54 worthy of further investigation.

1:51:57 That was the product.

1:51:58 Okay, so that's where the three routes came from,

1:52:02 it's from the Keller.

1:52:04 Okay, thank you.

1:52:06 What is the authority of the committee?

1:52:09 Do they, what authority do they have?

1:52:17 The group that provides recommendations,

1:52:20 so they can provide recommendations to legislators,

1:52:24 they provide recommendations to IT,

1:52:28 they do that annually with IT or more often.

1:52:33 And then we have provided recommendations

1:52:37 to the legislature that committee has done.

1:52:40 That's the authority.

1:52:42 It's a recommended body only.

1:52:44 The other question that I saw is whose committee is it?

1:52:50 And it's fairly clear to me that it sounds like

1:52:53 it's the county committee through resolution in 2004.

1:52:55 Sure, it's only I'm saying, there was some confusion.

1:52:59 And it's everybody makes a mistake once in a while.

1:53:02 And it's possible that, and said it wasn't a committee because he hadn't heard about it.

1:53:09 Sure.

1:53:10 Sure.

1:53:12 Sure.

1:53:13 It's possible.

1:53:14 And then I have another note that I can't even understand what my question is.

1:53:17 So, Greg Lanning.

1:53:19 Well, I'd like to answer one other.

1:53:21 I would like to actually comment or question the other.

1:53:25 This is going to be in the, someone in opinion answer here.

1:53:30 about the new bridge again which would be the new bridge that would take highway

1:53:34 93 straight through to the interstate and again this is my opinion but I've

1:53:39 looked at it close enough I think it's fairly strong opinion the new bridge was

1:53:43 one of the carrots that was dangled by the governor for the Garvey bonds as one

1:53:52 of the things that the Badgy Valley could receive if we went ahead with we this

1:53:58 legislature approved borrowing ahead of time of what we're called the Garvey bonds to be repaid by future

1:54:06 federal appropriations of dollars and

1:54:10 it was a carrot that was dangled and

1:54:12 I don't know the exact dollars that have went everywhere, but it appears that almost I'm gonna say

1:54:19 90% of the Garvey funds have went through the treasure valley and so it was a carrot to get our legislators to vote yes

1:54:26 that I don't think anybody ever thought was ever gonna happen. That's my opinion.

1:54:32 So if somebody asked about the new bridge, that's what it is. I don't see it

1:54:38 is on, you talked about a rising, I don't think it's on anybody's horizon. At this

1:54:43 point, maybe it is a 50-year horizon, but certainly not a 10-year horizon.

1:54:49 The purpose of that study was to investigate the need. The need wasn't there.

1:54:56 I worked at ITD at the time, and the recommendation in that report was to look again in another

1:55:02 20 or potentially 40 years, but to consider amending transportation plans in the respective

1:55:12 highway districts and so on to preserve land for right-of-way, to make setbacks on dwellings

1:55:22 and things like that.

1:55:23 Okay.

1:55:24 The devastation wasn't as significant in the future, okay.

1:55:27 So third bridge crossing was a real study and it was really unwarranted at the time for further

1:55:36 environmental work right away acquisition and anything like that.

1:55:41 She has more faith in the political process than I do apparently.

1:55:50 Those were the questions that I had.

1:55:51 I just wanted to turn that over to council.

1:55:53 Anything further you want to discuss regarding this?

1:55:56 I'll never drive again after the night.

1:55:59 I wanted to say to the folks in the audience,

1:56:02 I certainly appreciate your frustration.

1:56:05 I understand that whenever your home is a subject

1:56:09 of an issue that hits right to home.

1:56:12 So I appreciate that.

1:56:14 Joe, would you like to say something?

1:56:16 I'll allow it come forward.

1:56:23 I was going to say I found some conflicting information

1:56:27 when Jackie just reported because I was the one who contacted

1:56:30 and spoke to Jennifer Bergen initially about this.

1:56:33 And I was the one who found out from ITD

1:56:35 that the resolution was in 1991 and then another one in 2004.

1:56:40 I also found out from ITD that they did not

1:56:43 commission the study, that the study, they just paid for it,

1:56:46 that the committee asked for the money and for the study,

1:56:50 and they just paid for it.

1:56:51 And it was between Nathan Jerky who forwarded me the email.

1:56:55 I forwarded to Jennifer Bergen, the attorney.

1:56:58 And I even said, do you just pay $99,000

1:57:02 whenever a committee requests it?

1:57:05 So he made it clear to me that it was not generated by ITD,

1:57:09 but it was generated by this committee.

1:57:12 So I just wanted to make that clear

1:57:14 because it was just conflicting.

1:57:16 I don't know if you knew that, but I just wanted to make sure

1:57:19 that was on the record.

1:57:20 Thank you.

1:57:20 And just real quick, Jackie.

1:57:22 So basically what Jill saying is they made the committee made

1:57:25 the recommendation to spend that money with Keller,

1:57:27 but the authority is still with I.T.D.

1:57:30 That's accurate.

1:57:31 OK.

1:57:33 Is that fair, Jill?

1:57:34 That's a very funny thing.

1:57:40 All right.

1:57:41 So, ladies and gentlemen, I again appreciate all of you

1:57:43 coming out and sharing your opinion, Commissioner Mills.

1:57:48 Thank you for coming forward and answering some questions

1:57:51 towards this evening.

1:57:52 At this time, I would like to reconvene ourselves or move

1:57:58 into Executive Session 74206, one F again.

1:58:02 We went through that before.

1:58:04 So at this time, do I need to make another motion just go?

1:58:07 We are going to reconvene into Executive Session.

1:58:11 Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 2, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:00:07.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    97b27bf34017532b9dbc102a899fb4ae50dbd2929173dbc1d2cbc6cec7cd2469
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 3 passages muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 28153c3224b8ad0b1db5a31992963f660d1bdf65f158aa474141eabbcac54d3c
    part02.m4a 855d3bed031d6037d6aa6f886ea362e3fa2e018c4c0d155da4d2a0292dc8a855
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 13 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    4daefef46fd8dbc5d6124f25929d58a98f24b137dba01423076f3300e4a489be

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file