OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 26, 2015

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 October 26th 2015 I see no boys or girl scouts in the audience so I will lead us in the pledge

0:00:08 for those of you wishing to join us please rise.

0:00:13 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:27 Thank you all and I appreciate being here and please feel welcome.

0:00:34 I do want to confirm that we have a quorum of the city council.

0:00:37 Here all seven members are with us this evening.

0:00:42 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda?

0:00:45 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, not necessarily an add to the agenda, but maybe a clarification to the agenda under the adjournment to the executive session, which staff is asking.

0:00:53 It cites 74-2061B as in boy, but you also cite item A as an apple and B as in boy.

0:01:03 Item A is to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member, or

0:01:08 individual agent wherein the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in order

0:01:14 to fill a particular vacancy or need.

0:01:17 This paragraph does not apply to the filing vacancy of an elected office or deliberations

0:01:22 about staffing needs in general.

0:01:25 Very good.

0:01:26 Thank you, Travis.

0:01:27 I will, uh, thank you.

0:01:28 Thank you.

0:01:29 Thank you.

0:01:30 Thank you.

0:01:31 We have a motion on the floor by Chris Stockton, seconded by Greg Lanting, as stated.

0:01:38 Anything further on that motion?

0:01:40 Sharon, roll call vote, please.

0:01:43 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:01:49 Yes.

0:01:50 Jim Mann.

0:01:51 Yes.

0:01:52 Sean Bericher.

0:01:53 Yes.

0:01:54 Chris Hockington.

0:01:55 Yes.

0:01:56 Greg Lanting.

0:01:57 Yes.

0:01:58 Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:01:59 Yes.

0:02:00 Motion passes.

0:02:01 Seven.

0:02:02 Four.

0:02:03 Zero.

0:02:04 Next item on the agenda is a proclamation.

0:02:06 No, shaved November from the Twin Falls Police Department.

0:02:08 From the office of the mayor.

0:02:10 No, shaved November of 2015.

0:02:12 Whereas among American men, prostate cancer is both the second most commonly diagnosed

0:02:17 cancer and the second leading cause of cancer deaths.

0:02:21 Although prostate cancer, incident and mortality rates have declined over the past two decades

0:02:28 in 2015 alone, an estimated 220,000 men in the United States will be diagnosed with the

0:02:35 illness and almost 27,500 men will die from this disease.

0:02:41 Whereas during National Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, we remember those lost to prostate cancer

0:02:48 offer our support to patients and their families and highlight our commitment to better prevention,

0:02:54 detection, and treatment methods.

0:02:57 Whereas the Twin Falls Police Department has indicated a desire to help support the treatment

0:03:03 and awareness of prostate and testicular cancer by promoting a program entitled No Shave November.

0:03:11 Now therefore, I, Don Hall, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, proclaim the month of November

0:03:16 as no shade November 2015.

0:03:19 And by this action, let it be known that we, the employees of the Twin Falls Police Department

0:03:25 and the citizens of the City of Twin Falls, support research, awareness, and treatment of

0:03:31 prostate and tistecular cancer.

0:03:34 I've witnessed this as well as Leila Sanchez, and I believe that we have Ben Hammer, Officer

0:03:39 hammer that would like to come forward. I present this to you and say a few words.

0:03:43 Council, thank you for letting me be here. No-shave November is a national event

0:04:07 that's recognized all across this nation by different organizations including

0:04:11 police departments, private companies out there as well as nonprofits. No-shave

0:04:16 November is an event that is mainly used to support cancer research or local

0:04:22 causes in our communities. The Twin Falls Police Department has decided to do

0:04:26 over the course of the last two years is to support this cause by allowing our officers

0:04:31 to grow out facial hair which we are normally not allowed to do and each officer is willing

0:04:35 to donate $25 to this cause. Where this money goes is the St. Luke's Mountain State Tumor

0:04:40 Institute. St. Luke's Mountain State Tumor Institute is a nationwide recognized organization which

0:04:46 helps in cancer research as well as treatment. We have a local branch here in Twin Falls

0:04:53 which all the money is donated to. This year, no shade of November has grown almost exponentially

0:04:59 and almost overnight. We've actually partnered this year with the Jerome County Sheriff's Office,

0:05:04 the Jerome Police Department, the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office, the Barbershop at

0:05:09 Geary and Dale and Company on Main Avenue and 103.1 to hedge Dr. Nick Redbone. All of these

0:05:16 organizations have come together this year in order to support this cause as a whole.

0:05:20 And this year we are overall calling it Magic Valley, no shape, no member.

0:05:25 We've set up a Facebook page as well as three separate donation websites.

0:05:29 One for the Jerome area, one for the Twin Falls area, and

0:05:32 one for Dr. Nick Spans, which he calls the free connection.

0:05:35 So this is a pretty big event this year.

0:05:38 We're looking to have some fun with it and looking to raise even more money.

0:05:42 Over the course of the last two years, we were able to raise just over $4,000 to

0:05:45 donate to MISTI, not only from our officer donations, but also community support.

0:05:50 And we keep looking for more and more people to get involved in this and more companies

0:05:55 to donate and we just like to have fun with this while supporting our community.

0:05:59 Well, Officer Hammer, first of all, I wanted to say we appreciate your input here.

0:06:04 You're the one that have driven this from the beginning.

0:06:09 And it is kind of heartening to see everyone kind of coming together now and

0:06:14 making a friendly rivalry between you and all the canyon sides and the life.

0:06:19 So it's going to be a really, really good event and I pledge to grow my beard out although

0:06:23 it's about two weeks in I'll be regretting that.

0:06:27 Greg Lanning.

0:06:28 Did you tell us the website because I just wanted to try to donate online to November

0:06:33 and I need it somewhere else totally.

0:06:36 Absolutely.

0:06:37 So for the Twin Falls area it is www.y-o-u-caring-c-a-r-i-n-g-e dot com slash yes.

0:06:47 So why are you so you caring.com slash TFPD underscore no shape.

0:06:53 So long ones in a Facebook. Yeah, it's also on a Facebook website,

0:06:57 but we can definitely write that down for you.

0:07:00 Well, I went to the Twin Falls Police Department website and I can't find it from

0:07:03 there. Can you get to it from the one calls?

0:07:05 Police Department website. Yes, I don't mean the Facebook page.

0:07:08 Yeah, I believe so. I believe we've posted it on there.

0:07:11 All right. Chris talking.

0:07:13 Well, again, we have kudos for taking this project on your belt.

0:07:17 I'm curious, what kind of reaction do you get from some of the

0:07:21 citizenry that you stop, let's say, for a patrol, a traffic stop,

0:07:25 or toward the end of the month, that's going to be a little shock in the middle of the night, isn't it?

0:07:30 It's definitely a little different for people.

0:07:32 You know, I've been approached by several people, though,

0:07:34 that says it almost makes us more approachable to show that we're more human being

0:07:40 and that we can, you know, that we feel good at supporting causes.

0:07:43 But people tend to like it.

0:07:44 Some of us grow better beards than others, and I think we've seen that

0:07:47 in the past few years but you know it's we like to have fun with it. But you don't

0:07:52 have many repeats when you have scraggly looking off us and scaring people.

0:07:56 Yeah. Yeah. Well I'm sorry I can't do it because my beard was scared of the heck

0:08:00 out of most people. I'll send a contribution. Good job. I just wanted to

0:08:05 mention our city manager's already started a month ago and you just can't

0:08:08 Oh, it's friendly rivalry.

0:08:15 John Berriger.

0:08:16 So I have my check for you because I'm too lazy to go on the website and I look forward

0:08:22 to this every year because I hate shaving more than anything.

0:08:26 Thank you.

0:08:27 I would also add, I hope this is okay with you Ben, but I offered it to my students at

0:08:32 CSI their officers in training obviously and you know they're college students so

0:08:37 they're poor starving college students and whether they pay this or eat ramen's

0:08:43 tonight so I gave it to them for $15 I hope that's okay absolutely and you know

0:08:47 the one thing I did forget to mention is Kenan Ridge High School jumped on board

0:08:51 too and so their student body council is gonna be pushing this out there too so

0:08:57 you know we have a lot of community support and I think this is growing even

0:09:00 more and more. Of course, we're encouraging not only just the police department but

0:09:04 city employees as general. Anybody who wants to get involved and you don't

0:09:08 you don't have to donate I mean if you can't donate that's fine but you know I

0:09:12 would ask it anybody who's grown out of beer or anything like that get the word

0:09:17 out there. We've even set up our Facebook page so there's profile pictures on

0:09:21 there so if you want to change your profile picture to our logo and spread

0:09:24 the word even more. So we're going to want to fund this. Very good. Again good job and

0:09:27 I appreciate your work, and I see the wheels turning in my city manager's head. I think he's getting ready for a comeback, so

0:09:37 The next item on the agenda is general public input

0:09:40 this is time for anyone any citizen that would like to approach and

0:09:44 Discuss an issue with the council this is your time to come forward the only thing that we ask is try to keep it brief because obviously

0:09:51 We have an agenda and please have it not be something that's on the agenda because we can give you time for that when that time comes

0:09:58 So this is your opportunity I see no one coming forward, so we will move now to the consent calendar turn that over council for their direction

0:10:11 It was a tie so great go ahead

0:10:16 Second we have motion on for by Greg Lanthine seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent the consent calendar as

0:10:23 as placed on the agenda.

0:10:26 Rebecca Milsop.

0:10:27 Thank you, Mayor.

0:10:28 I just wanted to clarify for some of these minutes,

0:10:30 I was absent and I wanted to clarify that.

0:10:32 I had a baby this year and so I was on maternity leave

0:10:35 at that time and explained the absences.

0:10:38 So thank you.

0:10:38 Very good, thank you.

0:10:40 Chris talking to you.

0:10:41 And are we pretty current with minutes

0:10:43 as of now then, Travis?

0:10:46 Almost.

0:10:50 We're getting a lot closer, I believe,

0:10:52 after the approval of these were between three to four.

0:10:55 And I would include tonight's session out from having them all completely cut up.

0:11:01 That it will be which minutes much earlier are the latest ones.

0:11:07 The latest ones.

0:11:08 Okay.

0:11:09 Because there's kept up for some of us to remember how we voted on issues at far back.

0:11:14 So let's appreciate that.

0:11:18 I see no further lights.

0:11:19 Chairman Rokov, please.

0:11:22 Jim Mann.

0:11:23 Yes.

0:11:24 John Berriger.

0:11:25 Yes.

0:11:26 Yes.

0:11:27 Greg Lanting.

0:11:28 Yes.

0:11:29 Don Hall.

0:11:30 Yes.

0:11:31 Rebecca Milsoka.

0:11:32 Yes.

0:11:33 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:11:34 Yes.

0:11:35 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:11:37 We have now moved to items for consideration.

0:11:40 The first item is presentation of information regarding the city's specifications for construction

0:11:47 and regarding policies on streets.

0:11:49 We have our city engineer, Jackie Fields.

0:11:51 Welcome, Jackie.

0:11:53 Thanks.

0:11:55 So, we use engineering department as the way that I'm talking about and all of the development

0:12:02 community use the city standard specs and standard grinds.

0:12:06 We use them for public works construction, we use them for subdivision development and

0:12:11 for large commercial construction projects.

0:12:14 And the reason that we use the city spec is that we wanted the community to develop in

0:12:22 a uniform manner.

0:12:24 Our city spec has been around a long, long time.

0:12:28 It is likely that it predated the Idaho standards for public works construction.

0:12:35 It absolutely did not predate ITD's specification, but we didn't use ITD's specification because

0:12:47 that is confined to roadway work alone.

0:12:50 It doesn't talk about water and sewer infrastructure, so our specs are really out of date.

0:12:55 You have been approached slowly but surely over time, and some things you haven't been

0:13:00 approached about.

0:13:01 We've just done it on changes that we wanted to make.

0:13:05 For instance, we were asked to consider using C900 plastic pipe instead of ductal iron, and

0:13:12 after some pretty serious consideration on what the risk was and so on, we chose to incorporate

0:13:18 the use of plastic pipe in certain applications in the public right away for our infrastructure.

0:13:26 Our ADA standards in the ones that are published in our City Effect are out of date.

0:13:32 They're really out of date.

0:13:33 In fact, for a while there are everyone's specs for out of date, including ITDs.

0:13:37 So we have come to a place where we are building ADA ramps in a manner that is appropriate according

0:13:45 to the federal standard and we need to catch our specifications up.

0:13:51 We also have been having trouble with our plant mix spec.

0:13:57 So when I came to the City of Twin, I had never heard of the Marshall method because

0:14:02 my working career, it wasn't used, but we used it here and because we were very busy and had

0:14:09 to prioritize the types of things that we're going to work on and what we're going to change,

0:14:14 I know if it actually seemed to work, I didn't worry about changing them.

0:14:19 I'm worried about the things that weren't working so well.

0:14:23 So we have been, we've had a small workload for the last nine years or so and after I

0:14:35 walked myself for that, we've arrived at a place where we actually can carve out the

0:14:40 time to address thoughtfully changing specifications.

0:14:45 So in theory, it's really easy just to say, okay, we're not going to use this spec, we're

0:14:50 We're just going to use this other one, but it's not quite as easy as one would be led

0:14:58 to believe.

0:14:59 Let me show you.

0:15:05 Okay.

0:15:06 And the Idaho standards for public works construction, that's a statewide spec book.

0:15:11 This is what your roadway typical section looks like.

0:15:13 It tells you nothing about what that is.

0:15:33 You can see that there's like something on the top, something in the middle, and something

0:15:38 on the bottom.

0:15:39 And then when you go into the notes, it tells you what those things are.

0:15:47 It's going to be plant mix and aggregate, but it doesn't tell you how much that when you

0:15:57 produce your plant set, you're going to specify it.

0:16:02 That works great for public works construction that we did when we're designing a road, but

0:16:09 our city spec has a prescriptive number in there for residential and collector roads that

0:16:15 makes it really easy. The owner of the land in Note B, when the road is being built, the

0:16:24 owner of the road is the developer. So the city spec gives the developer and staff a standard

0:16:36 and easy recipe for making a roadway that's so they don't have to actually design every

0:16:43 single residential and collector road. Now we still develop our city spec requires

0:16:49 that arterial roads, the one mile roads are designed because those loading

0:16:56 realities are all over the place. Eastland is a lot different than orchard. Orchard

0:17:01 is a lot different than Falls Avenue and so on. So each one of those

0:17:05 roadways needs a little bit of special treatment. So for over a year we have

0:17:16 worked on a weekly basis for a couple hours at a time to review the city spec

0:17:22 and take the pieces of the city spec that we found to be invaluable from our

0:17:27 working experience or helpful to the people that wanted to come in and just

0:17:31 know what they needed to do without having to screw around with a lot of extra

0:17:36 expanse to do some design and we tried to reconcile those and we in into what ISPWC said and we

0:17:46 came up with a document that we have dubbed the City of Twin Falls revisions to the ISPWC.

0:17:54 Now we were very close to beginning our implementation schedule which includes a discussion with

0:18:00 all of the people who are directly affected by this.

0:18:04 That is contractors, the plant mix people, aggregate

0:18:07 producers, high companies, developers, our local design

0:18:13 engineers.

0:18:15 So as we began, got ready to engage those folks,

0:18:19 ISPWC came up with a new addition.

0:18:22 They went from 2012 to 2015.

0:18:26 So a whole bunch of our revisions were obsolete.

0:18:29 We had to go through and take just a little bit more time and clean them up.

0:18:34 So we waged the great debate on whether or not we wanted to change our spec or adopt ISPWC.

0:18:42 And I really think that we should go ahead and adopt ISPWC and retain a small book of city-style revisions.

0:18:48 This is the ISPWC, which I did not send you.

0:18:52 This is a statement that really works pretty well.

0:18:56 Pretty good plan set.

0:18:57 It has a group of people that work on the revisions to the document regularly.

0:19:03 And it brings in a wealth experience from other communities

0:19:07 from their own personal experience.

0:19:09 This piece of the spec doesn't work.

0:19:11 This is obsolete, we're having trouble with that.

0:19:14 And it helps create a document that perhaps is more resilient.

0:19:18 What does that stand for again?

0:19:20 Idaho standards for public works construction.

0:19:31 So in the process of, so we've begun a public involvement

0:19:38 process.

0:19:38 And we met with developers, some developers, some contractors,

0:19:44 and some plant mix producers, Cluffer and Idaho materials

0:19:50 construction, which used to be ISG.

0:19:53 And it became really clear that our belief that the crushing

0:20:00 for next year's materials, we believe that the crushing

0:20:03 for next year's materials began.

0:20:05 And after Christmas, January, both Cluffer and IMC

0:20:10 said no, no we're crushing any time now, we're waiting for you to tell us whether

0:20:16 what kind of spec we need to make so that we can produce a good material. So we

0:20:22 decided that we would focus on the plant mix and the aggregate portion of the

0:20:29 specifications and try to get to a place where we had consensus. That process has

0:20:34 several weeks and it was really kind of smooth. It's a pretty nice process. And I

0:20:42 think we have our aggregate manufacturers in a place where they will

0:20:48 be able there. We'll be able to deal with our spec. Maybe some of our

0:20:54 conversations that we have during construction will be minimized and

0:20:59 perhaps become a little bit better. Switch over to PowerPoint presentation

0:21:10 Because part of what happened when we were trying to make a decision on how we wanted to revise the spec is that we need a little bit more information.

0:21:19 And so we went after it.

0:21:23 Jackie, could I ask one question?

0:21:26 Yes, please.

0:21:27 But then up to this time, in many municipalities, including the city at one fall, you had internal specs, let's see if we're road construction or rehabbing.

0:21:39 And those standardization between them, you can make arbitrary changes and the ITD unless

0:21:48 it was their project wouldn't, I mean, it was that arbitrary, is that what you're saying?

0:21:55 Specifications are developed to meet the need of the particular community.

0:22:00 So this is a combination of specifications and it's kind of helpful because it helps

0:22:08 people who haven't necessarily dealt with a particular aspect, grab a hold of uniform

0:22:13 specification. And then they can tune it up to their own reality. So for us, we're willing

0:22:19 to accept ductal iron and plastic, you know, seen on your pipe. Some people don't want to

0:22:27 accept ductal iron pipe at all. It's too heavy. They don't want to maintain it. They are perfectly

0:22:34 fine with the risk so they'll write in a special provision into their own documents

0:22:38 that's safe.

0:22:39 We don't have any use.

0:22:41 C900 pipe.

0:22:42 And the vice versa also occurs if you have contractors that constantly hook your water

0:22:46 lines and tear them right out of the ground, you may not want to use C900 pipe, you may

0:22:51 want to stay with Dr. Lyre.

0:22:53 So there's still some freedom in ISPWC to do things that are meaningful and work for

0:22:59 your community.

0:23:00 But I guess it leads to the logical question that wouldn't this have, doesn't this leave

0:23:05 the city open to quite a bit of liability if there's, I don't know, a substandard construction

0:23:14 that leads to an accident and somebody getting hurt?

0:23:17 I don't, we don't believe so.

0:23:19 So they have a pretty robust section on how contracts work.

0:23:24 It is a specification that takes into account standards of care for how materials are supposed

0:23:32 to be handled.

0:23:36 It's commonly used, and we've used it on a whole bunch of our larger projects, arsenic,

0:23:40 we've used them on our arsenic jobs.

0:23:44 We use some of ISPWC on Washington Street North, but it's over-ridden by IITD spec.

0:23:53 I'm just trying to remember, I think some of the conversation began back when Poll

0:23:57 line was rebuilt and is that some of spurred on some of this conversation because I know

0:24:03 that we had questions regarding how that roadway was built what standard it was is it for a

0:24:09 truck route because obviously you have a lot of very heavy trucks on that road with the

0:24:14 longevity of the road was is that part of the conversation here or was it again?

0:24:19 Sure and it's been ongoing.

0:24:20 We've had a whole bunch of people coming in you know they asked us well first of all you

0:24:26 So, I have here, and I can't believe that our roadways are still here, they're 50 years

0:24:36 old and some of them actually haven't been sealed, and it's like, why is that still here?

0:24:42 So, there's my first question, and it's been in place for as long as I've been here, and

0:24:48 I've said things like, that road is here by the grace of God and good luck, and things

0:24:53 like that.

0:24:54 We've also had people who have asked us we consider making the roads narrower

0:24:59 So that's gonna be a topic for a different day. That's on topic tonight, but they've also asked us to consider making the roads thinner

0:25:07 You know, do we really need that much material in the roadway for whatever reason and that applies across the board

0:25:14 Not only to the residential and collector roads, but also to the heavier roads like Washington Street North and Boy. Okay

0:25:21 When people ask us, gee, you know, can you consider making the roads thinner?

0:25:29 Part of that discussion is how much longer is what we have, you know,

0:25:33 how much longer is our road going to last?

0:25:36 You know, if it's 10 inches and we make it 6 inches, how long will it last?

0:25:43 And then we have our current redways that we also wonder how long they're going to last

0:25:50 because they've been in play for 47 years and 50 years,

0:25:53 and it's pretty impressive.

0:25:56 So we've also had questions by different folks asking us

0:26:00 to use different things as part of the base.

0:26:04 People want to know if they can use wrap recycled plant mix.

0:26:08 They want to know if they can use pit run,

0:26:11 been washed, or whatever.

0:26:14 They want to know if they can use bigger rock,

0:26:17 and really big rock down to.

0:26:20 And then materials with no rock, they want to know if they can use wrap in the plant mix.

0:26:27 You know, ITU is that how come we don't?

0:26:30 Well, we simply don't because Marshall Mix does not deal with wrap.

0:26:34 You know, if you have a Marshall design standard and Marshall testing method,

0:26:38 you do not have a way to address recycled plant mix into your material system.

0:26:45 By moving to ISPWC, there's a section under the plant mix,

0:26:49 part of the document that will send you a right to IITD for the specifications on how

0:26:54 to use RAP in the clinics and currently that's when we consider specifications, we have to

0:27:03 make a decision on whether or not we want to use someone else's reasonably good spec

0:27:07 or try to create a brand new one all by ourselves.

0:27:10 So we opted for using somebody else's reasonably good spec.

0:27:16 Okay so in order to answer all these questions we needed a little bit of help.

0:27:20 So I entered a contract with American Geotechnics and the fellow that worked on the contract

0:27:26 is a guy named Justin.

0:27:28 So if I slip and say Justin, it's American Geotechnics.

0:27:32 So in the scope of this contract, we asked Justin to take a look at some of our existing

0:27:37 payments and see how well they're performing.

0:27:42 If they're performing very well, then we can talk about what else we need to do.

0:27:46 Should it get thicker?

0:27:47 Should it get thinner?

0:27:50 We asked American geotech to evaluate aggregates for us, help us understand whether or not this

0:27:57 spec we want to move to and ISPWC is less than what we have now.

0:28:02 I really wasn't interested in having less than what we have now unless we absolutely had to

0:28:09 go there.

0:28:10 Wanted to try to be equal or maybe even a little better.

0:28:15 Then we asked for some help on a group of things that include what should we do if we

0:28:24 allow rapid a mix.

0:28:25 If we're going to allow recycled asphalt pavement into our black top, what are some things we

0:28:33 need to pay attention to?

0:28:38 So that's kind of what the last section deals with.

0:28:41 So we need to do a short study on definitions, so that I don't keep feeling guilty for using

0:28:48 terms that are not...

0:28:51 So in a roadway section you have the dirt part, and that's comprised of base and sub-base,

0:28:57 and it's known as ballast.

0:28:58 So I talk about ballast all the time, it's not actually just dirt, but it looks like dirt.

0:29:05 And then we have the surface course, which is a wearing surface, and that just keeps your

0:29:10 dirt in place and it is black top for many of you and I call that plant mix, okay, all

0:29:17 the time.

0:29:18 It could also be concrete.

0:29:19 Okay, there's another definition that you need to be aware of as we walk through this

0:29:25 process.

0:29:26 Under our ordinary standard of care, we design roadways for 20-year lives.

0:29:32 So we can extend that pavement life, so if we do nothing, that pavement should fail after

0:29:38 20 years if it receives the kind of traffic loading that it was designed for and

0:29:44 If it was placed

0:29:46 Property so if we do some it might maintenance like seal coats or overlays

0:29:52 We can add 16 years easily to the life of the pavement and end up with something that'll still be in place

0:29:59 36 years from now when we know this is a fact because we're driving on roads that you guys have never seen paved and

0:30:05 And, you know, we've all most of you have probably been around long enough to know of a 36-year-old

0:30:12 payment.

0:30:13 Maybe not Ollie, but close.

0:30:15 Okay, so, this is the sting, this is functionally the same city standard drawing for a residential

0:30:25 and collector street that was in place in 1978.

0:30:29 So how old were we in 1978?

0:30:32 It calls for a residential street to have a 10-inch section and a collector road, these

0:30:40 column arterials, but a collector road to have a 14-inch section.

0:30:46 So on the first arrow you can see that there's 8 inches of ballast and 2 inches of level of

0:30:55 surface material.

0:30:56 Okay, so how were those, how were those standard sections developed?

0:31:00 This becomes really important when people are asking me why they need to build something that meets the standard.

0:31:06 They're like, well, what I've given you is fine. I don't know that, and I don't know that it's equivalent.

0:31:11 So I started looking around and asking everyone I knew, including Gary Young, how these standard sections were developed.

0:31:18 Well, we don't know. They were here. They appeared to work, and it makes it very difficult for us to back our way back to

0:31:31 where we want to go for potentially doing something different,

0:31:35 if we're asked to do something different. So that's the now what piece.

0:31:39 We decided that we would work backwards and

0:31:44 talk about how to design a roadway. Okay, so when you design a roadway

0:31:48 you need to put your road on something. You're going to put it on earth

0:31:53 and that's going to be called the subgrade and the subgrade is going to have

0:31:57 a level of strength associated with what kind of material it is.

0:32:01 So if it's clay, it's got a really small R value,

0:32:05 it has no strength.

0:32:06 If you have rock, it has a higher R value,

0:32:10 it has a lot of strength.

0:32:11 And over the time that we have been working on payments here,

0:32:19 we've actually gathered data.

0:32:20 Unbelievable, but true, we actually have R value data

0:32:24 for our neighborhood, and better than that,

0:32:27 it's scrambled all around town.

0:32:29 So we have a fair idea of what our materials are like.

0:32:34 The soil conservation force says that our materials,

0:32:36 our soils, generally uniform, except right around the pulleys,

0:32:40 and there's a few swamps here and there.

0:32:43 But in general, we have pretty good soil,

0:32:45 and we have test data to talk about how strong it is.

0:32:49 So these little blue diamonds are our tests,

0:32:53 and they are all over town.

0:32:57 And the number on the bottom tells you what the R value is.

0:33:01 Sixties, okay, it can be a little higher, 10 is bad,

0:33:06 and it's really bad, it's punky material,

0:33:09 no you have to do something else to keep your road in place.

0:33:13 And then on the vertical axis,

0:33:15 you have a percentage scale

0:33:18 that's gonna become important later.

0:33:20 So for now, you can see that the majority of our,

0:33:25 are the majority of our test data falls out here

0:33:31 in the neighborhood of 30 to 60.

0:33:34 So that's nice.

0:33:36 If we lived in places that had permafrost,

0:33:38 we'd have to start bridging pavements,

0:33:40 and the roadways would get a lot more expensive.

0:33:43 So when you're designing a road,

0:33:47 you need to get your ballast deep enough

0:33:49 so that, okay, there's the sentence,

0:33:51 but what you need to do is you need to keep

0:33:53 the ground below it, mother earth, dry,

0:33:56 and oh, so it doesn't get wet.

0:33:58 Because it gets wet, it's gonna pump,

0:34:00 and it comes the roadway.

0:34:03 So how deep is that?

0:34:04 Well, our geotech recommends 12 to 17 inches.

0:34:08 Just keep it in mind.

0:34:11 OK, so the next piece of your pavement design

0:34:14 has to do with traffic index.

0:34:16 You have to decide how busy your street is going to be.

0:34:20 And when you make a decision on how busy your street is going

0:34:23 to be, it's going to be a residential street

0:34:24 or something like that, then you can do a little math

0:34:26 equation and you can get these things, ESLS, E-S-A-L-S.

0:34:30 That is an 18,000 pound load crossing on your pavement.

0:34:34 It's used all the time.

0:34:38 You have no 18,000 pound loads on your axles,

0:34:43 on really dinky residential streets,

0:34:44 except for the moving man on the ground today.

0:34:47 Okay, so then we put the data into a chart

0:34:51 with collectors that we already had test data on,

0:34:53 and we got some numbers.

0:34:56 What's important about that, what's important about that

0:34:59 is that we generally ended up in a spot

0:35:02 where how we've classified our roads is more or less

0:35:05 consistent for residential collectors.

0:35:07 So that's important.

0:35:09 What we're asking how we're classifying our roads

0:35:11 is generally consistent with the kind of volumes

0:35:14 that we expect to see.

0:35:17 OK, so there's a few more things you need to take into account

0:35:19 when you're working on pavement design.

0:35:21 You need to know whether you have groundwater

0:35:23 is generally an on issue for us.

0:35:26 You also need to know what your frost susceptibility is.

0:35:29 Remember I was talking about how you want to keep earth dry

0:35:31 so that it doesn't pop on you,

0:35:33 well we have really susceptible soils.

0:35:36 And when Justin was out, he was shocked and awed,

0:35:39 and he took pictures and he came running back in the office

0:35:41 to tell us about how, what the heave was like

0:35:44 in the middle of winter, and we're all saying yeah, I know.

0:35:47 We know that as we drive over the manhole lids

0:35:50 in the street and the pavement's up.

0:35:53 Our frost depth is 24 inches.

0:35:56 We felt in the standard of care says

0:36:00 that designing for the entire frost depth

0:36:02 is probably a bit excessive.

0:36:04 If you design for half of the frost depth

0:36:07 or 70% of the frost depth, you're usually in the right ballpark.

0:36:10 So not quite magically.

0:36:12 We're still on the 12 to 17 inch ballpark

0:36:16 for the kind of ballast roadway section

0:36:19 that's gonna stay put for a while.

0:36:24 Okay, Justin says we should consider geotextiles.

0:36:28 That's great.

0:36:28 So how are our streets doing?

0:36:30 Well, this is Shoop.

0:36:32 Shoop has a PCI number.

0:36:34 This is Shoop between Martin and Kearney.

0:36:36 Dean rebuilt that just a year or two or three ago.

0:36:39 This is a picture right before then.

0:36:41 The PCI number, the pavement condition index was 47.

0:36:45 That's not good.

0:36:46 That pavement is full, it's in the neighborhood of 50 years old.

0:36:50 Then we have a little Julie Lane over by Madrona.

0:36:54 I'm pretty sure that's Julie Lane.

0:36:56 I took pictures this morning and I got confused

0:36:58 when I was putting it in here, but the important part

0:37:00 is that that pavement is a good looking pavement,

0:37:02 and Julie Lane has a PCI number

0:37:05 that is indicating a good looking pavement, 72.

0:37:10 So getting back to that.

0:37:11 So Shoop is, it's at the end.

0:37:14 Shoop is totally gone.

0:37:16 So, no seals on it, it's gonna have to be rebuilt.

0:37:22 It should be rebuilt.

0:37:23 And until it's rebuilt,

0:37:26 we will probably continue to put a seal coat on it,

0:37:28 because amazingly, CO2 kind of glues everything down

0:37:33 for a short period of time.

0:37:35 And it keeps water from penetrating

0:37:37 through the cracks in the pavement.

0:37:41 When water penetrates through the cracks in the pavement,

0:37:43 then it's so steep ballast, ground starts to pump,

0:37:47 the fines come up into the ballast

0:37:49 and your pavement degrades even more.

0:37:52 Okay, so your pavement condition index numbers,

0:37:55 here's your little chart.

0:37:57 Generally, if you're above 70, you're in great shape.

0:38:00 Generally, if you're below 40, you are in big trouble.

0:38:05 There's our very difficult to see little chart

0:38:07 on the roadways that we selected.

0:38:09 So we took a sampling of data from 2009

0:38:13 and asked Justin to take a look at him again in 2013.

0:38:17 So he gives you a number for nine and 13,

0:38:20 and not surprisingly, the pavement degrades over time.

0:38:26 So I made a few circles here, so here's number five, here is 2009, and here we are in 2013.

0:38:38 So the pavement decay, not a big deal, is still above the 70 lines that are in good shape.

0:38:45 So what happened right here?

0:38:47 Well, we sealed the road.

0:38:49 So this is exactly what happens when you do mine or maintenance on your roadway.

0:38:53 It took an old crappy route that was just in the throes of death down here below the 30s

0:38:58 and put a seal on it and my goodness it's going in together and it's pretty good for the time being.

0:39:04 Now as you get into this category you go farther and farther down and eventually you cannot

0:39:11 come up above your 40 PCI line. So you really want to deal with it. When you get to 25 you should

0:39:20 start seeing these signs of catastrophic failure, like water coming out of your

0:39:25 pavement and potholes forming like almost spontaneously, it's kind of a bad deal.

0:39:31 Okay, so what we did with this data is we said, hey, how much remaining life do we

0:39:36 have on these payments? I always ask if he's doing math, he should just tell me how

0:39:41 much I have left. Well, I can see that after we finish our reconstruction on

0:39:46 that we have some collectors that we probably need to think seriously about addressing.

0:39:52 Locust between North College and Falls is a zero.

0:40:01 It's at the end of its life. What does it look like? It looks okay.

0:40:05 It's doing some weird things. We're getting running.

0:40:09 We're getting these breakups that are going to be the Shur's potholes.

0:40:13 is cracking all over the place, you can still drive on it,

0:40:17 but we need to seriously consider planning that

0:40:21 for reconstruction.

0:40:23 What about Locust, you had that zero life remaining,

0:40:26 is that for just a particular stretch?

0:40:29 Yes, that stretch is defined as the piece

0:40:33 between North College and Falls.

0:40:36 So that was what happens is when you're looking

0:40:38 at your PCI numbers, you have to pick a place

0:40:42 that you're gonna look at every single time.

0:40:44 and keep that stretch the same so that your dataset makes sense.

0:40:49 So not all of locus is in terrible shape,

0:40:52 but there are pieces of it that are in dioration.

0:40:57 Let's see.

0:40:58 OK, so this is a common comment that I've heard.

0:41:02 Oh, our aggregate is really hard to produce.

0:41:05 You know, that inch and a half rock is totally hard to come by.

0:41:09 Can you do something?

0:41:11 We said, OK, we'll look into different gradations

0:41:13 and see if we can find something that's suitable in equivalent.

0:41:16 That three fractured face that rule you guys use,

0:41:19 you know, you make me crush the rock too much,

0:41:21 it causes too much waste, it's a terrible thing,

0:41:24 it's totally unnecessary.

0:41:26 I could use a single fractured face,

0:41:28 can't you just use that?

0:41:31 Okay, we'll look at it.

0:41:33 And then I wanna, you know, I've had comets for,

0:41:36 I wanna use wrap and I wanna use paper.

0:41:41 All components in my body.

0:41:43 So, are those gonna perform the same or not?

0:41:47 I don't know.

0:41:48 I don't know the answer to that.

0:41:49 And I don't know how to get through it.

0:41:50 That's what we hired American Indian Tech for.

0:41:52 So we checked out the gradations.

0:41:55 It's a huge section of the document and it would be agonizing for you and that's the

0:42:00 answer.

0:42:01 If we use ISPWC spec for a two inch aggregate, it will be equivalent to city's inch and

0:42:08 a half.

0:42:09 Makes it perfect side step into the ISPWC for us.

0:42:13 Okay, this was the one that was popularly called for, we can use one fractured face.

0:42:20 It'll behave the same as three.

0:42:22 Intuitively, that's abhorrent to me.

0:42:26 And I really stuck my heels in and resisted, but you know what, the science is the science,

0:42:31 and there it is, and I'm wrong, so we're changing the single fractured face, which helps

0:42:37 us walk into the ISPWC and easily into ITE for SuperPave.

0:42:45 Now, being able to use wrap as part of the ballast section, it actually weakens the payment

0:42:52 and shortens the life of the whole section.

0:42:55 Very sad day, we really wanted to be able to do it, it can't be in the ballast.

0:43:01 But it can be in the plant mix.

0:43:03 So we need to be careful about how much goes in there, we need to be careful about how,

0:43:09 so plant mix is made up of rock and oil.

0:43:12 So you can use the wrap recycled asphalt plant next to this part of your rock.

0:43:17 If you have 17% of that rock as wrap, we're going to be able to, we think we'll be able

0:43:23 to manage it well and end up with a decent good quality product that we'll be happy with.

0:43:28 Jackie, how do we know, I mean if you do say 17%, how do we know that's what they're putting

0:43:33 in it?

0:43:34 I know we test later, but how do we know on the front end?

0:43:37 So we can stand there.

0:43:40 Do we?

0:43:41 Plant.

0:43:42 We have at times, but we rarely do that.

0:43:46 Usually trust is good enough, there's a ticket that's produced, it comes out electronically,

0:43:52 so you know it's usually where, if they say they're putting in 17% ramp, they are.

0:43:59 And then the testing process later confirms their denial.

0:44:02 You can do testing to figure out how much is in there.

0:44:06 Okay.

0:44:07 And we said, okay, we can use wrap-and-plant mix, this is great, you know, it's good to

0:44:10 be able to use recycled materials, it's commonly used elsewhere, should we write our own spec

0:44:15 or use ITDs.

0:44:17 We want to use ITDs.

0:44:18 It's written, it's tested.

0:44:20 They've been improving it based on their own problems and errors.

0:44:25 By using ITDs spec, we can use their testing methods, which are already written and developed

0:44:30 and we can use their payment plan, which will help with modest discrepancies.

0:44:37 So how about pit-run?

0:44:39 Okay, you can't use pit run anywhere. You want to it's a sad day, but

0:44:46 Great planning. What is what is pit run? Did I miss that earlier? I don't think I heard that

0:44:51 pit run is a

0:44:55 Waste product of crushing

0:44:58 Okay, so it's not very strong. Okay, that's all I need. I

0:45:08 Okay, so

0:45:10 Okay, so here we are, we're at the 800-pound gorilla, then this is really the issue at hand here.

0:45:18 When you look at the strength of the soils, and you say, gee, most of our data is down

0:45:23 here between 30 and 60, those little percentages at the top are the statistical odds that your

0:45:30 pavement is going to fail before it hits its design life.

0:45:32 Do you want an 87 and a half percent chance that you're going to succeed, 75 percent chance

0:45:38 that you're going to succeed, or something less?

0:45:41 So if you are risk averse and you pick eighty seven and a half percent

0:45:48 For an R value or I pick it then that R value would be thirteen

0:45:53 You can see the two little yellow bars that go down if I know you're a little less risk averse or I'm a little less risk averse

0:46:00 I could choose for you know gamble

0:46:03 Say seventy five percent of my pavements are gonna remain for their entire design life

0:46:08 maybe longer and choose an R-value of twenty-something, twenty-seven. Okay so

0:46:16 here's your refresher course. Our current typical section for residential

0:46:20 streets is ten inches of roadway for residential street and fourteen inches for

0:46:27 a collector. If we choose a R-value of twenty-seven, so seventy-five percent

0:46:33 odds of succeeding in the lifespan of the pavement and addressing things like

0:46:38 frosty, our residential street section is 17 inches thick. 17 versus 10 is

0:46:44 measurable. Okay, same thing with collectors. If we're a little less

0:46:50 risk-averse, and we want to be a little more conservative, on a residential street,

0:46:55 pavement only gets thicker by an inch and a half. The depth, you know, the

0:46:58 ballast section. But when you get over to the major collector section, you know, the

0:47:02 looks of the world, it gets a lot thicker. It's six more inches. More

0:47:06 More importantly, that's 12 inches.

0:47:09 It's a whole foot thicker than our existing collector's sign.

0:47:14 OK, so this is a political cartoon.

0:47:18 So if I offended anybody, I apologize,

0:47:20 but I think it's kind of funny.

0:47:21 So the little dude is saying about his plan,

0:47:25 oh, they're just trying to scare you

0:47:28 to the little old lady who's getting ready to be eaten.

0:47:32 And really, we have to decide whether this is going

0:47:36 to be crushing financially or not for people

0:47:39 that are doing work.

0:47:42 We also need to balance that against our values

0:47:44 and what we think our needs are.

0:47:46 So it could be, it's not the 800 pound gorilla,

0:47:51 maybe it's a mythula.

0:47:53 It's likely to be in the middle somewhere, okay?

0:47:55 That's really the way that goes.

0:47:59 Beautifully, we have these pavements that are ancient.

0:48:02 Look, six, Haberne, sections of Haberne,

0:48:05 the older section of Mountain View,

0:48:07 those puffs are 42 years, 50 years old,

0:48:09 and they're there, they're physically present.

0:48:13 And that's great, you know?

0:48:18 That probably balances perhaps that possibly balances some of our concern on risk

0:48:28 Okay, we do have even our newer payments federation is a really good shape. It's only 12 years old

0:48:35 It's it's performing according to oil. I mean it has not been loaded for its lifespan

0:48:41 but it has had a lot of construction traffic on it.

0:48:45 So this is federation between Parkview

0:48:48 and Washington Street in Seltner's Ridge.

0:48:50 There it is, it's pretty good, just like it's supposed to.

0:48:55 It's a PCI number support site.

0:48:57 Here's Locust near Julie Lane.

0:49:00 Okay, I took this this morning, and I'm sorry,

0:49:03 it's kind of busy, it's kind of busy out there,

0:49:05 so having me run out and roadway and take picture

0:49:08 and run back borders on stupidity

0:49:11 in that category, in that area, but you can see the wheel paths are shiny, the runs are forming,

0:49:22 the breakup is occurring in the wheel path, and right there is one of this winter spotless,

0:49:28 in this work.

0:49:30 So things like this, and funky shoving kind of in the middle of nowhere, you know, when you

0:49:37 see little humps in the pavement in the middle of nowhere, you know that it's time to start

0:49:41 Where are you at on Locust?

0:49:45 I'm on Locust, right at Julie Lane. I parked my car on Julie and I walked in near Julie Lane.

0:49:51 I'm trying to figure out because a portion of Locust is much newer than the rest of Locust,

0:49:59 and I'm trying to remember which street. It's not very past Julie, then it's almost, I mean, fairly new.

0:50:05 fairly new. This is still narrow. So this is this is the three lane section and it

0:50:12 winds up for the newer lane which was only built onto the edge remember mm-hmm

0:50:16 and so this is the center line. So I guess all everything I'm thinking newer

0:50:23 but it's relative because when I was on planning zoning the first time around in

0:50:27 the early 80s which seems like that that long over really was a long time ago I

0:50:32 Yes, that's 30 years. Okay

0:50:36 Okay, that's right. Okay

0:50:39 That seemed seem new to me, but I guess time has passed doesn't it?

0:50:44 That's subdivisions only 30 years old

0:50:49 Okay, so we have a little Tyler Street

0:50:52 I had a little Tyler Street was built in 1968. It was a 10-inch section, so

0:50:58 We've had our 10-inch residential Street section for a long long time

0:51:01 And little old Tyler Street has no traffic, very little load, and it's looking pretty rough.

0:51:08 And we didn't do PCIs on it, pavement condition indices tests on it because it's a little residential street.

0:51:15 But, you know, it's kind of hanging in there. It should be nearing the end of its life because it's old enough to be there, but, you know, it's still here.

0:51:24 And then we have 11th, built around 1970. That's also a 10th section.

0:51:30 That road is not heavy.

0:51:33 This slide, particularly on the right, is helping you understand that you have nothing left.

0:51:42 So it is likely that it is near a waterline plate, or an old waterline plate.

0:51:51 There's no evidence of a patch, but that's a very interesting rectangular shape that is not necessarily shared with the rest of the roadway.

0:51:59 And that's water coming up, not from a recent rate.

0:52:02 Water coming up through the bottom, sadly.

0:52:05 Now, once you have the cracks in here,

0:52:07 water comes in from the top, too.

0:52:09 So the rest of this roadway doesn't

0:52:12 have the same experience across yet,

0:52:14 but it's in poor shape, nonetheless.

0:52:17 OK, so the deal with the PCI is the more you have,

0:52:21 the worse it is.

0:52:22 Obviously, one crack isn't going to kill you.

0:52:24 A few cracks here and there aren't going to kill you.

0:52:26 When the whole road is a crack and you

0:52:28 have to mop on the craft seal, it's time.

0:52:32 Okay, so currently, as we decide whether,

0:52:36 as we decide what we want to do,

0:52:39 at some point in time, we'll have to make a decision

0:52:41 on what we really want to do.

0:52:45 We need to, in the same way that we,

0:52:48 we've had this discussion before for somebody.

0:52:51 So we have a budget, we fund our eight year seal code cycle,

0:52:56 we've been investing in the neighborhood of $300,000,

0:52:59 sometimes more on overlays.

0:53:02 We have a reconstruction budget that usually gets us

0:53:04 one and a half lane miles.

0:53:06 If in a particular section of Eastland that we're on,

0:53:10 the truck loading is very heavy,

0:53:12 so we're getting a little bit less.

0:53:14 But in general, and as an average,

0:53:16 we should get one and a half lane miles.

0:53:19 That three quarters of a mile or two lane road.

0:53:22 So when we make a decision on what kind of failure

0:53:26 we're gonna accept,

0:53:28 And then we are taking into account that this is our current budget and when we have, I believe

0:53:41 it's 254.

0:53:42 No, that's not right.

0:53:46 We have a much larger number of roadway miles here.

0:53:52 I apologize to you.

0:53:53 I know this number and I can't remember right now.

0:53:57 Those amounts of overlay and reconstruct are a small portion of the number of roadway, number

0:54:02 amount of revenue. So we will balance our cost against cost. So part of the reason

0:54:10 I'm coming here is that I understand that at some point in time you're gonna

0:54:14 hear about this and you're gonna hear about concerns about the cost of construction.

0:54:19 So I wanted to try to explain the logic behind it and give you a chance to start

0:54:25 thinking about value statements and ultimately how much cost the city will bear over time.

0:54:34 Jackie, I think we owe 420 miles to Rhodes.

0:54:37 Thanks.

0:54:38 Thank you very much.

0:54:42 I actually know most of the time.

0:54:45 So I apologize.

0:54:47 So what ends up happening is that I can go through a process to modify the city specs.

0:54:55 But at some point in time, I need to incorporate some of this work

0:54:58 into a transportation master plan that comes before you.

0:55:02 And what I ultimately don't want to do is be in a spot

0:55:07 where we've invested a tremendous amount of time and effort going

0:55:10 down the path that we don't want to be on.

0:55:13 So I wanted to try to provide you some information.

0:55:16 We're currently having conversations now with developers

0:55:18 and with contractors trying to understand and find

0:55:24 and adequate balancing point between long-term means of the community and the actual ability

0:55:31 to succeed on their part and then I'll probably be down.

0:55:37 Because really it centers around when we get these roads from the developers, we're like

0:55:42 adopting the roads.

0:55:44 And they become ours and we're responsible for their maintenance and they're rebuilding

0:55:49 and if they're substandard that comes quicker which costs the public more money.

0:55:54 Is that balance between that and the developers being able to develop the land and do it in

0:56:01 a reasonable manner and watch their costs, right?

0:56:06 That's absolutely it.

0:56:11 Chris Tye.

0:56:12 Well then, I guess bringing it all together, what's your master plan for taking the input

0:56:17 and getting the priorities revamping these standards?

0:56:23 Do you have some road map in mind?

0:56:27 Yes, so the road map was that we considered moving ISPWC and then developed city standard

0:56:33 revisions to those documents.

0:56:36 And then we began to invite people in to make sure that we weren't missing something.

0:56:41 So we've invited in contractors and developers and aggregate crushing and plant mix people.

0:56:51 So the plant mix providers think that they are pretty good with where we are with respect.

0:57:00 That's what we need to send it by one more time to say is this, you know, are we all still

0:57:05 on the same page?

0:57:07 We're having the development community is ready to begin continuing conversation on the typical

0:57:16 sessions and other portions of the ISPWC. Things that have to do with water pipe and sewer pipe and

0:57:22 can your manholes have flat lids on them and things like that. So we hope that we can get consensus on the plant mix section so we can get crushing going for next year and

0:57:34 potentially adopt that in advance the rest of the space. So when we do that we will, I feel that I will need to come back and chat with you.

0:57:48 and chat with you about how risk averse you are.

0:57:52 And potentially bring some information on cost.

0:57:57 So initially, my recommendation is

0:58:00 to be more risk averse on collector roads

0:58:02 that have higher volumes and less risk averse

0:58:06 on residential streets because they've been holding up

0:58:10 fairly well.

0:58:11 So to me, that would mean using an R value of 13

0:58:15 on collectors and using an R value of 27.

0:58:24 I think that's right.

0:58:25 On residential streets.

0:58:32 Yep, that's it.

0:58:34 And then at some point in time,

0:58:35 maybe during our next transportation master planning process,

0:58:39 we could consider the idea of using a minor

0:58:43 and major collector designation.

0:58:45 We're fairly common.

0:58:48 Now, that's not set in stone.

0:58:50 I'm trying to have a conversation with people

0:58:52 and gathers an input.

0:58:55 and then try to form a reasonable opinion,

0:59:00 is consensus based.

0:59:02 I may not get there, but I'm gonna try.

0:59:05 When you do bring these back to us,

0:59:06 I'm assuming the development community will know that

0:59:09 and they will be able to come at the same time

0:59:10 and make their-

0:59:11 That's accurate.

0:59:12 That's absolutely accurate.

0:59:13 Okay.

0:59:14 This is Ann Hawkins.

0:59:16 Jack, I just wanna say thank you.

0:59:17 I don't wanna pretend like I understand all of this

0:59:19 completely, but you make it understandable.

0:59:22 So at least I feel like I'm kind of in the ballpark.

0:59:24 And I appreciate that very much.

0:59:26 Thanks.

0:59:27 I appreciate the fact that you guys didn't like fully glaze over first thirty seconds like glaze over once or twice

0:59:38 Yeah, locusts and where was that again?

0:59:44 Uh one thing that i'm going to uh kind of push the next year or so honestly in in my endeavors of being in the community recently

0:59:51 Especially as we're looking at rebuilding some of these rows like tyler

0:59:55 For example, you showed a tailor, excuse me, Taylor, it's Tyler.

1:00:02 You can see no curb, no sidewalk, anything there.

1:00:06 And when we get ready to rebuild those type of roads, I think it's time to have a conversation

1:00:11 about pedestrian transportation as well, so just to give you that highlight.

1:00:17 So Tyler's kind of an interesting little street because it's part of the old way where we didn't

1:00:22 necessarily, you know, people walked in the street, it was no big deal, and grabbed the irrigation came through and ditches.

1:00:28 And as the dishes went away and the road leveled up, there was no place for the water to go off the roadway, and that helped decay us from the road.

1:00:36 So, sorry, off subject again.

1:00:39 So, do you know how the project's going, the CSI corridor down off of Cheney, where it's coming around?

1:00:48 I kind of expected something to be happening there, and I haven't seen anything.

1:00:52 So while we have you.

1:00:53 Yes.

1:00:54 At this point in time, sit easily zone on that project.

1:00:58 So I actually know the answer.

1:01:00 So we're having a pre-con in the next few weeks.

1:01:04 So that means that we're getting ready to kick off.

1:01:07 Good question.

1:01:10 I want to reiterate.

1:01:10 Thank you for bringing that to us and bringing us up today.

1:01:15 Thanks for staying with us.

1:01:16 All right.

1:01:18 Next item on the agenda, we have a public hearing coming up.

1:01:22 But the next item on the agenda again is public input

1:01:25 and our items from city manager, city council

1:01:27 will start with the public.

1:01:29 If there's anyone that would like to come in front

1:01:31 of the council, this is your time.

1:01:35 See no one coming forward.

1:01:37 Mr. Rothwilert, do you have any items for us?

1:01:44 Just one quick update and then I'll ask councilman

1:01:47 Tockington if he wants to ask his question

1:01:49 or if he just wants me to jump into the answer.

1:01:52 We had to, he had asked me an email,

1:01:54 by a question earlier by email about the Hankins water tank

1:02:00 project now is an opportunity to have a conversation

1:02:02 with members of our engineering team about the status of that.

1:02:05 So last week we talked about the pool deck

1:02:08 and in our investigation we believe that the pool deck,

1:02:12 which is that in particular the four foot wide section

1:02:17 that seems to be deteriorating,

1:02:19 is more than likely covered under warranty.

1:02:22 And so we're pursuing that.

1:02:23 I want to let the council know.

1:02:25 There was a cost to replace and that type of information.

1:02:29 Wendy Davis believes that that is more than likely covered

1:02:33 by warranty, we will confirm that,

1:02:35 and then we will move forward to make sure

1:02:37 that if it's covered by warranty

1:02:39 to get that replaced expeditiously.

1:02:44 The second is, Councilman Talkington earlier today

1:02:47 sent me an email about the status of the Hankins water tank.

1:02:53 First, that system is tied into our system.

1:02:55 It is functioning, and it is according to League Laysman.

1:02:59 It is supporting the fire flows and the subdivisions that are located within that pressure zone

1:03:04 as designed.

1:03:07 You'll recall that the Hankins Water Tank facility initially had a project cost of $3 million

1:03:17 when we were going through the early engineering estimates.

1:03:20 That's the price that was assigned.

1:03:23 And remember that that project was proportionately shared between three water users.

1:03:27 The first was the city was going to contribute 48% of the total cost to cover its proportionate

1:03:33 share.

1:03:34 The tax increment from the Cliff Bar project would cover 36% of the project and the remaining

1:03:40 balance would be covered by the other urban renewal area, area 4-1, to be able to cover

1:03:46 those project costs.

1:03:49 We came back with a revised estimate budget of $5.6 million after moving forward.

1:03:56 And then Lee shared with me today that the final budgetary cost of the project, when it's

1:04:02 all said and done, will be about $4.4 million.

1:04:05 And really, that's a credit to our team overseeing that project and good, good environment.

1:04:11 He said the entire project went very, very smooth when it came to the tank.

1:04:16 The only little glitches they had was around the landscaping portions and they believed that they have those rectified and should be in the final processes to close out that bid in the upcoming weeks.

1:04:26 Second question regarding that, is there room enough to put another tank there? Okay, talk to us about that just real quick.

1:04:35 So we acquired additional land for the opportunity to be able to put a secondary tank there if that area warranted a secondary tank at some point in the future.

1:04:44 the future. And so when we acquired the additional ground, we

1:04:47 acquired is to be able to place a second tank in that area.

1:04:52 Obviously that would make sense if it needed and be cost effective

1:04:56 because it's all if that was the right location. I mean, I think

1:04:59 that positioning and importance is going to be critical as we're

1:05:02 looking at additional tanks and well sites. The positioning of

1:05:06 the well site is critical to its its overall location. In some

1:05:11 locations is Jackie shared with me are better than others and so while we may

1:05:15 have ground at this site for a subsequent site it may not be the next

1:05:20 best site for the next tank we may want to look at other property acquisitions

1:05:26 at some point in the future but only holding that ground allows us to put

1:05:30 another tank in that place at some point should it be ever needed there great

1:05:36 planning. Travis did the proportion shares remain the same for the three

1:05:41 three entities that were hoping to pay for it. They did. Okay. Thank you. Chris

1:05:46 talking. So water is I'm assuming this foam ding is now because you've mentioned the

1:05:53 pressure upgrade. That's sufficient to handle the new school. It will that's a

1:06:01 question, I guess, in school.

1:06:06 I don't know if the new school, if it's located in that pressure zone, but we can

1:06:10 certainly find out. We do know that in our conversations that I don't know if it's

1:06:14 going to be serviced out of this spot or another location, but at this point in

1:06:19 time, I don't believe that we're concerned about fire flow issues in those

1:06:24 areas.

1:06:29 In a more general sense, because of this cost sharing, it was paid off chip

1:06:33 and I guess, but the residents in that area,

1:06:37 whether it be any positive impact on fire grades

1:06:41 because of that increase?

1:06:43 Not necessary.

1:06:45 No. So when they evaluate the city,

1:06:47 they evaluate the city in its totality for insurance rating

1:06:51 for the ISO. They do not evaluate

1:06:54 particular neighborhoods or areas.

1:06:57 And so if there is a benefit that is achieved,

1:07:00 It would be a benefit to all the availability of fire flow and fire pressure is one part of the equation response times

1:07:09 Manning standards training are a series of other

1:07:15 Items that go into determining ISO ratings in our conversations with chief Clark

1:07:21 The ISO rating for the city of Twin Falls is a solid three and it would take quite a bit of

1:07:27 of deterioration to become a four, and it would take a significant amount of upgrades

1:07:32 and capital to become a two.

1:07:36 That said, part of our plant, we want to continue to make sure that we are staying on top of

1:07:40 that, and as part of our comp plan, as you'll recall, we are investigating the possibilities

1:07:44 of future locations of additional fire stations as a part of that comp plan piece.

1:07:49 The positioning of fire stations and acquiring grounds for the future will be also, I think,

1:07:58 a very good and proactive approach to preserve that minimum three rating.

1:08:02 In the last part of the question, Travis, that the original price is 7.3 million down to 4.4,

1:08:09 I guess.

1:08:10 That's about a 40 percent, almost a 40 percent reduction.

1:08:14 How did we get that amount of savings with the scope, project scope, but that would be great?

1:08:20 No.

1:08:21 And that would, I think it's just a result of a very competitive bid environment.

1:08:26 The initial project came in under budget.

1:08:31 We had some retainage for some additional improvements at the 5.6 and when it was all

1:08:36 said and done, the project was 4.4.

1:08:39 So really it was just an indication of a favorable bidding environment from the city when JUB put

1:08:45 together their cost estimates.

1:08:50 It was based upon projects of a similar nature that were bid in other locations.

1:08:55 That's certainly something for us.

1:09:00 It's certainly better going that way than the other way.

1:09:03 Okay.

1:09:05 Is there anything?

1:09:06 Is that Travis from you, sir?

1:09:08 Is there anything from council?

1:09:11 Great landing.

1:09:12 I'm going up Wednesday to meet with the executive director of the IC, as well as the executive

1:09:20 director of the Association of Counties, and they're the Association of Counties president,

1:09:26 so if anyone has something, they're talking about the upcoming legislation, if you have

1:09:30 something you would like me to discuss with them.

1:09:34 Just email it to me, and I'll do so.

1:09:36 Thank you, Urban Renewable.

1:09:38 Yeah, well, I would I'm pretty sure urban renewal will be on our list of conversations that it is on every conversation when you talk about

1:09:45 The same response from the what is there is there is there anything else from council

1:09:52 Council and I apologize, but folks were going to take a short break

1:09:57 So we're going to journey come back to the public here on behalf of Canyon Park one

1:10:03 And I believe that Gerald Martin's will be making the presentation from EHM

1:10:09 Engineer and welcome Mr. Martin's. Thank you for the record. My name is Gerald Martin's.

1:10:16 I'm here this evening representing Canyonport Development. There's also another

1:10:19 representative of the developers here if there are any questions specific to

1:10:23 Panera Bread but we'll try to keep this move along quickly. We can. This is a very

1:10:31 very simple amendment to the PUD agreement.

1:10:35 It's been before planning the zoning, which was approved.

1:10:38 It basically allows a drive-through window specifically

1:10:42 for Panera bread on this one lot.

1:10:46 This is located within the Canyon River, over the lady's zone.

1:10:50 And the PUD agreement allows,

1:10:54 allow under the PUD process, we're allowed to do this,

1:10:58 but we didn't have it in the original PUD document,

1:11:00 So it's a very specific request specifically for this user.

1:11:06 Planning and zoning had in the preliminary presentation

1:11:11 and the official presentation, they had two issues

1:11:14 that I can recall.

1:11:16 One is that if granted it would be specific to Panera,

1:11:21 so that Panera didn't build this special use,

1:11:27 This drive-through would not be allowed for any other user.

1:11:31 The other concern was the orientation of this facility

1:11:37 so that the headlights of the car sitting in the drive-through

1:11:40 didn't shine into the highway.

1:11:42 And so the traffic pattern of this

1:11:44 travels around the east side and then towards the west

1:11:47 to the pickup window.

1:11:49 There's a landscape buffer between the,

1:11:52 first of all, between the drive-through

1:11:54 and the rest of the parking.

1:11:55 Secondly, this building, because of the additional large

1:12:00 right-of-way setbacks, 80 feet from the highway,

1:12:04 it's a significant distance from US 93.

1:12:08 If you look at the exhibit,

1:12:11 on your highway and the site.

1:12:17 Whoops, don't do that.

1:12:18 Oh, yes, again, do I have to ask again?

1:12:22 No, this section here is,

1:12:27 land that was reserved for future widening of the highway if another bridge were ever built.

1:12:34 It has been landscaped in front of by the developer in front of the outback restaurant

1:12:40 to the south and that landscaping will get continued on north as part of this project

1:12:48 development.

1:12:49 With that I'll just be glad to answer any questions.

1:12:51 We have any questions for Miss Martin's before the staff presentation.

1:12:55 I see no lights, Daryl, thank you very much.

1:12:59 Jonathan Svenlup from our engineering department.

1:13:01 Welcome Jonathan.

1:13:02 Oh, before he begins, if you're here to testify about this particular item, if you wouldn't

1:13:09 mind signing up in the back so that we can bring you up in an orderly fashion, the building

1:13:14 or the room is so full of people right now, so make sure we do that.

1:13:18 Welcome Jonathan.

1:13:19 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.

1:13:22 So brief history, it's all in staff report just in brief.

1:13:26 This project kind of started 2000.

1:13:27 There had been multiple PUDs and different plats that were combined.

1:13:30 There was some story to history.

1:13:31 Really the recent history was in 2012 when we had the ordinance for vacating Fillmore,

1:13:38 that we had a Canyon Park-amended PUD, the subdivision of preliminary and final plats.

1:13:43 And then the actual PUD agreement was approved in August 2012, and then the final plat was

1:13:49 done in 2013.

1:13:50 So that's kind of the recent history of what's happened since then there've been multiple building permits out here

1:13:55 with Dick's Ross, Ulta, Petco,

1:13:58 some of those other things that progressed up here along with some other buildings that have happened. During that process, we had an application,

1:14:05 some talks about

1:14:07 restaurant at the time we don't have names, but they talked about having a drive-through here. During our preliminary talks, we found out

1:14:15 going through the PUD

1:14:17 that it specifically did not talk about

1:14:19 allowing a drive-thru and what code we're talking about here is actually the

1:14:25 Canyon Rim Overlay Zone so that's in 10-4-19. In that zone it specifically says

1:14:30 that no drive-thru windows allowed Jason to along the Snake River Canyon that was

1:14:36 left off the list of allowed users so not supposed to have a drive-thru in that

1:14:41 Canyon Rim Overlay that overlay zone comes down and encompasses that property

1:14:46 somewhere in here. It's basically 750 feet from the canyon rim face or edge. Not even

1:14:53 by special use but an outright prohibition. Just outright is not listed as a permitted

1:14:57 use. Therefore it is listed somewhere else so therefore it was not permitted. Since this

1:15:04 is part of the PUD, this whole property, they are allowed to ask for concessions in the code

1:15:11 changes variations as you will. They did not ask for that. So what they're doing

1:15:16 tonight is amending the PUD for a specific lot in this PUD development to allow for

1:15:21 the special experiment or the drive-through. So going for the actual amendment

1:15:35 if I can find it. This is the actual amendment that they will be adding to the

1:15:44 PUD. It did not include the entire document. It's quite long. What they're

1:15:48 actually amending is paragraph 2B under uses. This number two is the actual

1:15:55 amendment. It was specific to lot 7 block 1. They talked about maybe developed as

1:16:00 a restaurant with the drive-through, constructed in accordance with the

1:16:03 patch site plan as exhibited. One and specifically limited to the proposed

1:16:09 Panera Bread facility. If this goes through they have to develop it according

1:16:13 to the site plan that gave us, which is this one, and it will be limited to Panera

1:16:21 bread only. Anybody else that came in afterwards would not be allowed to use the

1:16:25 drive-thru facility. They would have to change the PUD again to use the drive-thru.

1:16:31 So that's what the implication of this means. In conclusion on September 29th

1:16:39 hunting and zoning commission heard this request. Commissioner Woods made a

1:16:43 motion to recommend approval for the request. The City Council has presented

1:16:47 Commissioner Munoz, seconded the motion.

1:16:49 Commissioner Stearacott, Munoz Woods,

1:16:51 and Higley voted in favor of the motion,

1:16:53 and Commissioner Gray and Reid voted against the motion.

1:16:55 So it passed four to two,

1:16:57 recommended for approval to the City Council

1:16:59 as presented subject to the following.

1:17:01 One subject to operation of a drive-through window

1:17:03 being limited to Panera Bread restaurant only.

1:17:06 Number two, subject to site plan amendments

1:17:09 as required by building engineering foreign zoning officials

1:17:11 to ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements

1:17:14 standards and the Canyon Grid Canyon Park PUD agreement number two six four the

1:17:18 last one is a typical one you put on all so in conclusion staff occurs with

1:17:24 the commission's recommendation stand for any questions do I have any questions

1:17:28 for either staff or Mr. Martin's Rebecca Mills so I thank you mayor thank you for

1:17:37 your presentation Jonathan I was here for the discussions on this particular

1:17:41 PUD but I wasn't here for the discussions in the Canyon Rim overlay zone and so I

1:17:47 I don't know if anyone has some information on why,

1:17:52 specifically in the Canurum overlay code drive-throughs

1:17:56 were not allowed.

1:18:02 I wasn't here for any amendment when

1:18:03 that was implemented back in the day.

1:18:05 I know we looked at it again.

1:18:06 We didn't change anything over the last few years.

1:18:08 It's just specifically left off the list.

1:18:10 But it is included as a special use for the areas in the Canurum

1:18:15 overlay near Rock Creek.

1:18:17 OK, just not the purine.

1:18:20 Yeah, and it's not for the Snake River Canyon,

1:18:23 but it is allowed as a special use

1:18:24 in that rock creek canyon, really.

1:18:26 Okay, so it wasn't for traffic reasons,

1:18:30 or we just don't know.

1:18:31 Good.

1:18:34 This is Anne Hawkins.

1:18:34 Thank you.

1:18:35 So the elevation on this property,

1:18:37 if I'm not mistaken, is quite a bit higher

1:18:39 than all the other buildings in that development.

1:18:42 Does that pose any concerns back to the headlights shining in,

1:18:46 or the, you know, with the traffic quiet?

1:18:49 Am I correct, Gerald, does that one up?

1:18:52 Is that property up higher?

1:18:53 It seems like it was built up, no?

1:18:58 The location of this particular lot is higher than outback

1:19:05 and it's higher than the visitor center,

1:19:06 but it's lower than the primary buildings

1:19:09 that sit to the west.

1:19:10 Okay.

1:19:11 And it's also lower than the buildings

1:19:15 as you go on up the highway.

1:19:16 You cross the bridge, the road climbs

1:19:18 as you go to the south.

1:19:20 So this particular pad would be slightly higher than out back, a little bit higher than the visitor center, but lower than the restaurant pad that's being constructed currently behind the visitor center, and lower than the major building's mix.

1:19:39 Okay.

1:19:40 And so, I guess the photograph, you can see the visitor center in the background here looking from the site.

1:19:51 I was thinking it was on that higher pad.

1:19:54 I was thinking it was that higher one above the visitor center.

1:19:57 So you got me straight and thank you. I was just confused.

1:20:00 Chris, talking to the approval of this PUD amendment then is business specific.

1:20:09 Yeah, Panera leaves for another location, the new applicant, if they wanted to drive through, would have to come to this.

1:20:17 This in other words is a one-time unique change the rules that's correct

1:20:23 that's in violation of the original Canyon room and PUD structures they're

1:20:30 asking for change variation from that's correct there are any other questions I

1:20:42 am going to move towards the public hearing open it up for public comments

1:20:49 and testimony if you could bring the list up Jonathan I know there's only one

1:20:55 one but I'll call you out why you start making your way to the mike sir if you

1:21:02 wouldn't mind I'll give you a few minutes Kevin Gray good evening council if you

1:21:12 could say your address six oh one Spark Street thank you and welcome also

1:21:16 member you're planning the zoning commission and one of the two devoted

1:21:19 not in favor of this amendment first let me say that I'm very much in favor of an

1:21:25 Arab Red Company coming to our town I'm even in favor of their occupying this

1:21:30 particular parcel. What I do not favor is proposed amendment throwing out the rules

1:21:34 that were established prior to the construction of the shopping center. Mr.

1:21:40 Martin's would likely argue that the property is not adjacent to the canyon

1:21:43 and trail. However, well, that's a literal definition and as a legal description, this

1:21:49 may be true, but to those who proposed and those who adopted this overlay map, this

1:21:56 parcel was and is adjacent enough to be included.

1:22:02 Let's talk about traffic in this shopping center in particular the roundabout.

1:22:06 I like the roundabout and I think overall it has been well received.

1:22:10 Nevertheless, at several of our planning and zoning meetings and work sessions,

1:22:14 the topic of traffic delays and backups created the signal that Fillmore and BlueLays

1:22:19 has received much discussion.

1:22:22 Adding a drive-through on this particular lot in what is basically a cul-de-sac,

1:22:26 bringing the added vehicular traffic inherent to the drive-through restaurant

1:22:30 will only serve to exacerbate the already congested roundabout and signal at Fillmore and Blue Lakes.

1:22:39 There's also the position and site elevation of the building itself on the property.

1:22:44 Businesses along the Blue Lakes corridor should be designed and constructed such that their fronts face the corridor.

1:22:51 This proposed building is facing toward the rest of the shopping center.

1:22:55 It's back to the Boulevard.

1:22:57 We discussed, as you heard and also asked questions of, the issue of headlights heading

1:23:05 toward the lakes.

1:23:09 As I suggested to the Canyon Park representative who was here during our meeting, to propose

1:23:16 to Panera Bread Company, given the number of pedestrians in this area, perhaps a large patio

1:23:21 or seating area and a walk up order counter would be more appropriate for this site.

1:23:27 Now I'd like to share with you a bit of regret.

1:23:29 Two earlier decisions by the Planning and Zoning Commission have led to hindsight conversations

1:23:34 at our work sessions.

1:23:36 No one can deny the success of a certain drive-through coffee shop, but had we the knowledge of the

1:23:41 traffic congestion it would create and the fact that the flow of traffic in and out of

1:23:46 this lot cannot now be changed, we probably would not have voted in favor of that particular

1:23:51 location.

1:23:52 The other site, the other regret is on Blue Lakes Boulevard in this very shopping complex.

1:23:57 We allowed the construction of a multi-retail unit that displays the blue lakes boulevard

1:24:01 what could only be described as the backside of a building.

1:24:05 We didn't allow or didn't require that the front of the building be facing the boulevard.

1:24:11 I would like not to look back on this particular development and think how we could have avoided

1:24:15 these problems had we voted differently.

1:24:18 And you council members can keep that regret and check by voting against the amendment.

1:24:23 Thank you.

1:24:24 Thank you Mr. Gray.

1:24:25 Is there anyone else from the public that would like to testify?

1:24:30 Okay, at this time, I'm going to close the public testimony and

1:24:34 turn it over to the applicant for any comments that he would like to make regarding the testimony.

1:24:47 First of all, for the simple one, we've reviewed the staff recommendations and

1:24:52 we concur with staff recommendations, so get that behind us.

1:24:56 Secondly, I would, I guess, point out based upon that testimony that this

1:25:01 This location is some 300 feet from the trail.

1:25:08 It's not adjacent to the trail,

1:25:10 but it's certainly observable

1:25:11 from the visitor center parking area.

1:25:17 And it is set back from the roadway.

1:25:19 Panera Bread has worked diligently

1:25:21 and the architect is here this evening.

1:25:23 We want to address the architecture of the building,

1:25:26 but because we can't have access

1:25:30 to Lulex Boulevard.

1:25:37 It's difficult to have access to the front of the building

1:25:41 to face this is a street.

1:25:44 But the architect has tried to address all sides of the building

1:25:48 to make it as attractive as possible.

1:25:51 With that, I'll be glad to answer any other questions

1:25:54 or anything that I may have omitted in response.

1:25:57 I think that I know the issues of the headlights

1:26:07 we've addressed that with landscaping,

1:26:09 we've addressed it by the setback,

1:26:10 and the fact that the headlights will not be

1:26:14 while the vehicles are in the waiting to either order

1:26:18 or to pick up their order,

1:26:20 will not be oriented toward the street,

1:26:24 toward to cause a problem with the traffic on blue lakes.

1:26:29 That, well, we glad to answer any questions.

1:26:31 Thank you, Jared.

1:26:32 I just wanted to remind the council

1:26:33 that this is still time for asking questions.

1:26:37 It is not time for deliberations.

1:26:38 I will close the public hearing when that time comes.

1:26:42 And at that time, we can no longer ask any questions

1:26:45 of anyone but our legal counsel.

1:26:47 But at this time, you can't.

1:26:49 Christotniett.

1:26:50 Yeah, sure.

1:26:51 Just a moment.

1:26:55 Well, is it?

1:26:57 The architect, so if you can answer any question specifically.

1:27:00 What is your name, sir?

1:27:02 Jeff Stokes is here, counsel.

1:27:04 In case you would like to ask him, my question is true.

1:27:07 All right, very good.

1:27:08 My question may pertain to the architect.

1:27:11 I'm a little bit unclear since they drive through Wendell.

1:27:14 Wendell will have traffic coming through parallel with blue lights.

1:27:19 Then what is the screening or anticipated visual retention of those headlights at night time?

1:27:28 Mr. Stokes, if you'd come up and introduce yourself.

1:27:32 My name is Jeff Stokes. I work for the landlord and the developer,

1:27:38 Woodbury Corporation, where in-house architecture from too,

1:27:42 so I can speak towards anything regarding that.

1:27:46 Welcome sir.

1:27:46 Thank you and then I guess to answer everybody's question,

1:27:50 there's a couple of things that we had concerns.

1:27:52 One of the other things, trail content also,

1:27:54 to note a little bit when we're talking about the adjacent area,

1:28:00 where we're also lower than out back,

1:28:04 the slope kind of goes down towards the visitor center,

1:28:07 but also at Blue Lakes at this point too,

1:28:11 Blue Lakes is actually higher than the pad.

1:28:15 So we're actually quite a couple feet,

1:28:20 three feet or so below Blue Lakes Highway 2.

1:28:24 So in that way it's an advantage as well. We also have

1:28:28 an easement. You can use the pointer and show exactly where

1:28:32 it's at. So this is Blue Lakes above here.

1:28:37 There's been some natural landscaping that's been done to about here or so, and we're going

1:28:43 to continue that landscaping along Blue Lakes to help with the screening there.

1:28:48 So on that side there, I also said we had some big posters.

1:28:54 I forward some of these elevations to Jonathan also, and he, yep.

1:29:01 So this will be actually, you can see the cars behind, that's the visitor center parking

1:29:07 lot and these are some screening that this is looking at mature height so we're

1:29:12 down the road a little bit but we put in these plants we get them in pretty big

1:29:17 you see the plants that we put in already how big well so these are similar

1:29:24 these will be similar to what's at the roundabout already so they're they're

1:29:28 called in an Austrian pine they're full-screen they're these guys what size is

1:29:34 that mr. Stokes 60 feet tall and so you're looking let's go there's a six foot guy

1:29:41 so it's about that high and the screen is pretty good but it's feeling pretty

1:29:46 quick you can see the plants so within a three or four-year period it'll be

1:29:50 pretty good the shrubs will be within three or four years will be at mature

1:29:53 typically and so those the shrubs will screen up pretty good so we have a pretty

1:29:58 screening between the visitor center, parking lot, the canyon, and then again along here

1:30:05 we'll have pretty good screening. Typical to what we already have in that area. So I feel

1:30:14 comfortable that everything is going to be screened on the landscaping side and then

1:30:18 on the building side. There's an architecture review committee we've already been working

1:30:23 through with the tenant and their elevations and what they're preferring and we're driving

1:30:28 them towards an appealing four-sided building. I understand everybody's concern. The problem

1:30:35 when we have a building like this in the middle of the pad is it's very visible from all four

1:30:42 sides. And so it's important to us as much as anybody else that this appeared right from

1:30:49 all four sides. And so we've been working on those elevations. I can kind of show you

1:30:53 a little bit with where we're at. Again, this isn't a decision that's all, these are

1:30:58 still concept. It will be as good or similar to what we have here, if not better. But we're

1:31:07 working through our committee and trying to get everything together. This takes in some

1:31:11 of the same elements that we had at the Visitor Center with the Rusted Steel and the iron works

1:31:15 that were brought in from the prime bridge. But as you can see, this is kind of the front

1:31:26 elevation. The one that's the back side is everybody sees it right there. Yeah. And

1:31:32 there'll be some patio seating in that area away from the noise and traffic. And

1:31:38 so it faces kind of the the rest of the project. And so this is the back side. You

1:31:47 could see well actually this is facing the parking lot in the canyon. So here's

1:31:51 the pickup window and then the drive-through kind of runs through here. There's

1:31:56 There's going to be an order board somewhere along this location, but it's not really a part

1:32:02 of the building elevation, but there'll be an order board here, and then there's a raft

1:32:06 of corner that goes through here.

1:32:09 So this is a side that faces blue lakes, and this is the side that faces the visitor center.

1:32:16 Thank you.

1:32:17 Thank you.

1:32:18 And do you have any more questions?

1:32:20 Well, Chris has answered your question.

1:32:22 Greg Lanning.

1:32:23 Actually, he answered my questions as well.

1:32:26 All right, does council have any other questions

1:32:29 for the applicant, architect, staff members

1:32:33 before I close the public hearing

1:32:35 and turn it over to just deliberations between council?

1:32:41 Public hearing is now closed.

1:32:43 Turn it over to council for deliberation.

1:32:52 And or direction.

1:32:55 Chris talking to.

1:32:56 I guess this isn't an ordinance change, simple motion.

1:33:00 You know, okay.

1:33:01 Well, to get the matter on the floor,

1:33:03 I would move to approve the PUD agreement,

1:33:06 Ken and Perk West PUD 264, allowing a Panera bread.

1:33:11 Restorant on Lot 7 Block 1 with a dry-through facility,

1:33:17 subject to the conditions of the planning and zoning

1:33:26 of whenever that was.

1:33:32 The two recommendations that were listed.

1:33:35 Okay.

1:33:36 motion on the floor by Kristoff. Seconded by Greg Lanting to have discussion regarding

1:33:42 that motion council. Rebecca Melsoika. Thank you, Mayor. As I stated, I wasn't here for

1:33:50 the conversations on the canyroom overlay, so I can only imagine why they had a specific

1:34:00 rule to not have drive-throughs in the canyroom overlay, but I was here for the conversations

1:34:06 for this particular PUD, and we had hundreds of people come out and sign petitions, and a

1:34:11 lot of people were opposed to the nature of the development being with its back to the

1:34:17 Canyon Rim. The Canyon Rim overlay states that really the intent of it is to embrace the

1:34:24 natural view, to embrace that natural resource. And a lot of the testimony was that they wanted

1:34:32 to be more pedestrian oriented.

1:34:34 And in our strategic plan, we do want our shopping centers

1:34:38 and our areas to be more pedestrian or bicycle friendly.

1:34:47 You know, I agree with the testimony tonight that a drive

1:34:50 through at this particular location not only does it violate both

1:34:54 of current PUD and the current code that governs this area,

1:34:59 it would just add to the congestion of that roundabout.

1:35:01 And I have personally sat in backed up in the round about waiting for the light to change.

1:35:07 And I can only imagine how that would add to the congestion.

1:35:11 So at this time I think it's on wise to start making exceptions for drive-thrus in the canyon room over Lazon.

1:35:20 Thank you Rebecca.

1:35:21 Anything further from council?

1:35:26 Sharon, roll call vote please.

1:35:34 Sean Bericher?

1:35:36 Yes.

1:35:37 Chris Tockington?

1:35:38 Yes.

1:35:40 Greg Lanting?

1:35:41 Yes.

1:35:42 Don Hall.

1:35:43 Yes.

1:35:44 Rebecca Milsoka.

1:35:45 No.

1:35:47 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:35:48 Yes.

1:35:49 Jim Munn.

1:35:50 Yes.

1:35:51 Motion passes.

1:35:52 Six to one.

1:35:53 Next item on the agenda is potential adjournment into executive sessions 74-206-1A and B, which reads to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member or individual agent wherein the respective qualities of individuals

1:36:12 are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need.

1:36:16 This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elected office or deliberations

1:36:22 about staffing needs in general, and B, to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or

1:36:29 disciplining of, or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer,

1:36:33 employee, staff member, or individual, agent, and Greg's favorite part, or public school student.

1:36:40 That's on earth. I rolled out from that old council for their direction.

1:36:44 Great planning.

1:36:46 Actually Suzanne Hawkins.

1:36:48 Suzanne Hawkins. I move approval of executive session for the reasons

1:36:52 previously read. Second. Motion on the floor by

1:36:56 Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Sean Berger to move into

1:37:00 executive session. Anything further on that motion council?

1:37:04 Sharon Roll, call vote please. Chris Tockington. Yes.

1:37:08 Yes.

1:37:09 Don Hall.

1:37:10 Yes.

1:37:11 Rebecca Milsoyka.

1:37:12 Yes.

1:37:13 Suzanne Hopkins.

1:37:14 Yes.

1:37:15 Jim Mann.

1:37:16 Yes.

1:37:17 Sean Baraker.

1:37:18 Yes.

1:37:19 Motion passes.

1:37:20 Seven to zero.

1:37:21 I just wanted to let the public know that we will be going into executive session.

1:37:24 We will not be coming back out again and can reconvene in this evening.

1:37:29 We are now going in.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 26, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:37:40.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    44c7c59ea5e1b7d6e9a5ba448176a304ba6e9d7640b937d67927cf47d8ad95e8
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a a83bdffd628e23ab085344d0685e7378d7a80112cdde120d23cd29cb63386912
    part02.m4a fb4c52bf75eb5874a120b743081ab71bdd455bfc857a9704f75426d537240955
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    765d6c633c4a1a9271521037ede6e8a96480fa99e8515667973ba9f981288403

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file