OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 12, 2015

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: b

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:00 Solve to order. It's October 12th, 2015.

0:00:05 What I would like to do, if you don't mind this evening, is I'd like to have just a moment of silence.

0:00:10 We were very blessed to be able to put together a proclamation about Harold Gerber last week,

0:00:18 and that was my honor to put that together with the ILA, and then we had Suzanne read it,

0:00:26 and then we gave that to their son.

0:00:28 Carol passed away this weekend,

0:00:30 so if we could just have a moment of reflection and prayer.

0:00:44 Again, I just think that it was such a blessing

0:00:47 to be able to do that.

0:00:48 While Harold was alive, I know that his son took that

0:00:51 to him that evening and put a smile on his face.

0:00:55 So next item, we always do a Pledge of Allegiance

0:01:01 to start our meeting.

0:01:02 And this evening we have three very motivated girl scouts in our audience that would like

0:01:09 to come forward and lead us in the pledge.

0:01:12 So come forward and then we'll listen to what you tell us to do.

0:01:40 Excellent and ladies, if one at a time if you could go to that microphone facing this

0:01:44 way and tell us your name what troop you're with what you're working on this

0:01:50 evening why you're here and where do you meet my name is Cara about and we are

0:01:58 trip six and we meet at manual Lutheran and we're working on inside government

0:02:04 side government excellent you don't have to tell us all that you can just say

0:02:10 your name. My name is Mackenzie Howard and I'm Troop 6. We meet at Amanda Lutheran

0:02:19 and our badges that badge we are working on inside government. Excellent,

0:02:23 excellent. Thank you. I'm Stephanie Case and I'm with Troop 6 and we meet at

0:02:31 manual Lutheran and we're working on inside government. And I saw that all

0:02:36 three of you had like a little interview time with Councilwoman Suzanne Hawkins.

0:02:42 You had an opportunity to talk to her.

0:02:45 Did she pass?

0:02:47 Excellent, all right.

0:02:49 They're very sharp and they're working hard

0:02:51 on how they can help involve others in our community

0:02:54 and local government as well.

0:02:56 I'm very impressed.

0:02:56 I am as well.

0:02:57 If we could give the ladies a hand.

0:03:02 You can sit down now.

0:03:05 Thank you ladies.

0:03:08 We do have a quorum of the city council this evening.

0:03:12 Six members are here.

0:03:14 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments

0:03:16 to our agenda, sir?

0:03:18 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments this evening.

0:03:21 Thank you, Travis.

0:03:22 We do not have any proclamations, and at this time I'll go ahead and open it up for

0:03:26 any input from the general public.

0:03:28 There's anyone here that would like to address the Council.

0:03:31 Now is your time.

0:03:32 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:03:36 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:03:39 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:03:41 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:03:43 I've got another 1,000 miles to do.

0:03:45 I'm going to do that on my 75th with my grandkids.

0:03:49 I got away from them two years older.

0:03:52 This Saturday at 630 at the K-MV TV station on Blue Lakes,

0:03:58 I'm gonna give a public talk with slides

0:04:00 and demonstrations and question and answers about

0:04:03 how fun it is to ride 3,100 miles all by yourself every day.

0:04:09 Six flats when you have to,

0:04:11 and I can tell you how many jars of peanut butter

0:04:13 it takes to do that.

0:04:15 Thank you very much.

0:04:16 Thank you, Max.

0:04:17 Again, that's October 17th at 6.30 p.m. at K.M. V.T., located at 1100 Blue Lakes Boulevard, North.

0:04:28 Is there anyone else that would like to come forward and address the council?

0:04:32 I see no one rushing for the podium there.

0:04:35 So the next item on the agenda is the consent calendar.

0:04:38 I'll turn that over to council for their direction.

0:04:40 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:04:41 And move approval of the consent calendar.

0:04:44 Second.

0:04:45 Motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Sean Berger to approve the consent calendar

0:04:50 as posted. Is there anything further on that motion council? Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:04:56 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mann. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca

0:05:09 Mills-Soyka. Yes. Motion passes. Six to zero. Moving now under items consideration, the first item is

0:05:17 consideration and approval to negotiate a contract with C.R. Peterson consulting

0:05:22 LLC to develop a transit development plan for the City of Twin Falls. We have

0:05:28 Mandy Thompson and Mitch Humble. Welcome Mandy. Thank you Mayor,

0:05:34 members of the Council. Tonight we bring to you our request to consider our

0:05:40 recommendation from City staff to negotiate a contract with C.R. Peterson

0:05:43 consulting. If you recall in April, I didn't have to do the math into my head here, April

0:05:51 of 2014, the City of Twin Falls was awarded a $40,000 grant through the IDL Transportation

0:05:57 Department to commission a transit development study on the future of public transportation

0:06:02 in Twin Falls. Having been awarded that grant, there was a bit of a lag time between one

0:06:08 rewarded and when we actually had the funds to spend.

0:06:12 So working with Mitch this summer,

0:06:15 we went through the process of putting together a RFQ

0:06:19 to request proposals from qualified individuals and firms

0:06:25 seeking to conduct a study for the City of Twin Falls.

0:06:28 We released that in August and those proposals

0:06:33 were due back to the City of Twin Falls by August 24th.

0:06:36 We received two proposals in response to the RFQ.

0:06:41 Together with myself, Greg Lanting, Josh Baird, Renee

0:06:45 Caraway Johnson, and Mitch Humble,

0:06:47 we reviewed the two proposals.

0:06:49 We independently scored those proposals.

0:06:52 Independent one another, everybody ranked

0:06:54 CR Peterson Consulting as the highest, their first choice.

0:07:00 So we went ahead and did a Skype interview

0:07:04 with the owner of the firm, as well as his associate

0:07:08 that will be the project manager on the project.

0:07:10 And upon completion of the interview,

0:07:13 which we just took the opportunity to ask

0:07:15 in a little bit more in-depth questions,

0:07:17 I think we all wanted to kind of see

0:07:18 if we felt like it was a good fit.

0:07:21 And it was unanimous that we wanted to go ahead

0:07:24 and offer the opportunity to them

0:07:26 and negotiate a contract with them.

0:07:28 So we are here for your approval tonight.

0:07:31 Do you have any questions for Mandy or Mitch?

0:07:33 Mitch, did you have anything to add?

0:07:35 Your name's on here, so I didn't want to leave you out.

0:07:37 I think my name's only there because I gave her the template

0:07:42 for the staff.

0:07:44 That works.

0:07:46 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:07:47 Thank you.

0:07:48 Mandy, where is CR Peterson consulting located at?

0:07:52 They are located in Oregon.

0:07:54 And if you will give me a moment, I'll tell you,

0:08:01 I believe they're out of Portland,

0:08:02 but I want to do another match.

0:08:06 Portland area.

0:08:07 Yes.

0:08:08 And so they're easily accessible and they will be spending time here as well as.

0:08:12 Yes, and in fact the owner of the business, the consulting firm Ross Peterson has family

0:08:17 in Idaho.

0:08:18 So they come, he comes on a fairly regular basis.

0:08:21 In addition, they have a couple other contracts with other municipalities in Idaho.

0:08:28 So their hope is that they can tack on some of the trips that they'll do for us with some

0:08:32 of their other work so that they can head down on the travel costs.

0:08:36 Great.

0:08:37 Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:08:39 Thank you, Mandy.

0:08:40 In your report, you say that they've done some work with other rural communities, and that's

0:08:45 one of the reasons that that committee chose them.

0:08:48 Do you know of any of the communities that they worked with?

0:08:51 Yes.

0:08:52 Right off the top of my head, Idaho Falls.

0:08:54 They've been working with Idaho Falls.

0:08:55 They also have worked with Logan, Euchaw.

0:08:58 And then they also have, they were selected to do the state wide mobility management analysis.

0:09:05 I don't know how familiar are with public transportation through ITD and Idaho, but for

0:09:10 some number of years we operated under what was called the mobility management or an organization

0:09:21 where there were mobility managers that set throughout the state, but last year the organization

0:09:28 of that came under question and ITD ended up reorganizing and they had this firm come in

0:09:33 and do an analysis of essentially the entire state.

0:09:36 So I think we have a fairly decent handle on Idaho in general, but also working with smaller

0:09:41 communities that are kind of making that leap from rural to small urban.

0:09:46 Great.

0:09:47 And have we talked to anyone from Idaho Falls or Logan Utah or kind of looked at their past

0:09:52 work there?

0:09:53 No, we do not.

0:09:55 Okay.

0:09:56 We might want to just get some feedback on some of the communities they've worked with,

0:10:00 but I have no other qualms about them.

0:10:02 It seems like a great choice.

0:10:04 Okay.

0:10:06 Do we have any other questions?

0:10:09 Direction from Council, please.

0:10:12 Great lining.

0:10:13 We are all in move that we select CRP,

0:10:16 Anderson Consulting, LLC, to develop,

0:10:18 transit development plan of city from falls

0:10:21 as to be our first choice, excuse me,

0:10:23 and for the staff to begin negotiating country.

0:10:27 Second.

0:10:28 Motion on the floor by Great lining,

0:10:29 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins, as stated.

0:10:32 Is there anything further on that motion to Council?

0:10:36 Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:10:43 Jim Munn, Sean Berger, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Rebecca

0:10:51 Mills-Soyka, Suzanne Hopkins, Motion Passes, 6-0.

0:10:57 Thank you, Madam.

0:10:59 Next item on the agenda is consideration and approval

0:11:05 of an agreement for wastewater services

0:11:07 between the City of Twin Falls, the Twin Falls Urban Renewal

0:11:10 agency, Anchobani, Idaho, LLC, with an effective date of September 1st, 2015, with Travis

0:11:20 Routhweiler, our city manager, welcome, sir.

0:11:22 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the council.

0:11:23 Before you have an agreement, it's a three-way agreement.

0:11:26 It's between the city, the Urban New Agency, and Chibani.

0:11:30 The Urban New Agency approved this agreement earlier today at their board meeting, and we're

0:11:37 asking the council to do the same.

0:11:39 This agreement has also been approved by Chibani moving forward.

0:11:45 So I want to take you back.

0:11:46 I want to take you back to November 3rd of 2011 and at that point in time we approved

0:11:50 an original development agreement and there were some thoughts and there were some concepts

0:11:55 in terms of the development agreement and also laid out the requirements of both the

0:11:59 city, the agency and Chibani.

0:12:02 All of those requirements were met and had been fully executed in that entire process.

0:12:10 One of the city's commitments was to allocate $2.75 million for a pretreatment facility to help offset those.

0:12:18 And then part of that would be recommitted or repaid back to the city over a period of time based upon a portion of that flat rate of $2.84 being dedicated to that facility.

0:12:32 So every 1,000 gallons that was sent, the development agreement spelled out how much

0:12:39 money would flow back into the city's reserve funds.

0:12:46 That total amount of repayment or to the city was $353,445 from the time that they started

0:12:55 flowing and moving forward.

0:12:58 At some point, I want to say in about 2013, late-13, early 2014, Jibani started that process

0:13:07 of making sure that they were operating their own pretreatment facility and the timelines

0:13:14 of BitFuzzy, but they were operating their own pretreatment facility and we had contracted

0:13:19 with CH2M Hill to assist with that process.

0:13:23 But later, and as we had shared with the council,

0:13:27 Giovanni had made the decision and based upon really where they felt that they could generate economies of scale as they hired a different firm to operate their facility.

0:13:38 And in this entire time, we've been working on an agreement that basically turns that facility and modifies the development agreement as such.

0:13:51 And then also repays the city back with $2.75 million

0:13:55 that was committed to them.

0:13:57 So in the agreement before you,

0:13:59 the Urban Renewal Agency would use tax increment financing

0:14:03 and they would reimburse the city $2.75 million in its entirety.

0:14:08 And the city would write a check to Chibani

0:14:11 in the amount of $353,445.

0:14:16 And the idea is, as though this agreement would have been

0:14:20 been in place at the very first day that they started flowing, because there is enough tax

0:14:26 inclement financing available to completely cover those costs, and that city's need for

0:14:31 assistance would not have been there.

0:14:34 The reason we're asking for a September 1 date is because it aligns with our billing process.

0:14:39 As you know, from the month of September, we would read those bills, and then we would

0:14:44 begin to calculate that in October, and they would owe their bills towards the end of the

0:14:51 month.

0:14:52 So September 1 effective date would have all of the numbers completely checked by both groups

0:14:58 and both accounting staffs.

0:15:00 The agreement has been reviewed by legal counsel, and it is there for your approval.

0:15:06 You'll notice, however, we did hand out a modified agreement that did come in later than the time

0:15:14 of the fact that it came in about four o'clock today.

0:15:16 And the biggest change occurs in section 2.4 and section 5 and it has to do with the easement

0:15:28 and I'll have Fritz talk about the technical changes that appear in the document.

0:15:35 Thank you and welcome, Fritz.

0:15:37 So the agreement provides, you'll see the second part which is exhibit A is an easement agreement

0:15:45 And if you'll look at the drawing,

0:15:46 you'll see that that covers the entire pre-treatment facility.

0:15:51 That's a perpetual public utility easement.

0:15:57 And within that agreement, it provides

0:15:59 for termination in the case that they cease to in operations

0:16:02 or it's no longer needed.

0:16:06 And I think the idea eventually is

0:16:08 that Jumani will acquire that pre-treatment facility

0:16:13 from us. In that eventuality then that easement will terminate and we previously, our idea

0:16:21 was we were going to have a second underlying one so we can get to the flume so we can do

0:16:25 the measurements and check the outflows of the pretreatment facility. That's something

0:16:30 we have to do ordinarily. So today the thing that changed was, and you'll see the language

0:16:36 in there, is that this will not terminate until they have created a new easement, a new

0:16:41 to access Eastman to get to that flume.

0:16:45 Jackie Fields has been talking to Giovanni's engineer,

0:16:50 and they still haven't quite agreed on where that goes.

0:16:54 I think they're talking about moving a gate and some things.

0:16:57 But in any event, that doesn't have to be done now

0:16:59 because they've agreed they'll do that

0:17:01 at the time of termination.

0:17:03 That is the only change.

0:17:06 Any questions for Fritz while he's here?

0:17:11 Travis?

0:17:13 We would just ask the council consider the agreement.

0:17:15 We'll stand for any questions.

0:17:16 Do we have any questions, Council?

0:17:20 Sean Berger.

0:17:22 I do not have a question.

0:17:23 I'm ready to make a motion if you're ready for that.

0:17:25 Do we have any questions before the motion, Council?

0:17:29 Sean Berger.

0:17:30 I would move to approve the agreement

0:17:32 for wastewater services between the City of Twin Falls.

0:17:35 The Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency and Chobani Idaho LLC

0:17:39 with an effective date of September 1st, 2015 as presented.

0:17:42 Second.

0:17:43 Motion on four by Sean Berger,

0:17:45 seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.

0:17:47 as stated anything further on that motion council.

0:17:53 Sharon Roll call vote please.

0:17:54 Sean Baraker.

0:17:55 Yes.

0:17:56 Chris Hock or Greg Lanting.

0:17:58 Yes.

0:17:59 Don Hall.

0:18:00 Yes.

0:18:01 Rebecca Milsoyka.

0:18:02 Yes.

0:18:03 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:18:04 Yes.

0:18:04 Jim Mundt.

0:18:05 Yes.

0:18:06 Motion passes six to zero.

0:18:10 Next item on the agenda is public input again.

0:18:13 If there's anyone that would like to address the council,

0:18:16 now is your chance to do it again at the end.

0:18:19 So is there anyone wanting to do that?

0:18:25 Any other items from our city manager?

0:18:30 Just a reminder this Wednesday morning

0:18:32 is the activate Magic Valley breakfast at the Stone House.

0:18:37 I believe it starts at 7.30.

0:18:39 And so you're, we would invite not only the community,

0:18:43 but also certainly the council to come

0:18:45 and celebrate the second year of activate Magic Valley.

0:18:49 Thank you.

0:18:51 Is there anything from our city council?

0:18:54 We are scheduled to go into executive session,

0:18:57 potentially tonight if you approve it.

0:19:00 I do have one thing, I just wanted to bring the council

0:19:03 up to date, as you're aware, this is walked over,

0:19:09 and I have been challenged, or we are challenging each other,

0:19:14 28 mayors in the state to see who walks the most this month.

0:19:18 The good news is that I have a solid second place

0:19:22 with 334,922 steps that's the good news that's about I'm averaging between 10

0:19:33 and 15 miles every day and it's killing me yeah I don't know the bad news is the

0:19:44 leader a Gordon P and it doesn't tell you where they're from but I think he's

0:19:48 the mayor from Emmet, is at 475,000 steps. I've calculated that out because an average

0:19:58 adult walks so many steps per minute, 100 steps per minute. He is walking between seven

0:20:05 and a half and eight hours a day. I'm walking about four and a half hours a day. I don't

0:20:11 I don't know how you do that, but I am giving a good college try.

0:20:18 I will work very diligently, but I will tell you that I'm a little bit tired, but we'll make it work.

0:20:25 Suzanne Hawkins. First of all, I need to apologize. Last week you entrusted me with the paper and asked me to bring it back tonight,

0:20:31 and I neglected to do so. So I will throw it out there. It's time of year for us as a council to vote on our representation

0:20:39 to the i-print board and this year we only had one name on our ballot which is

0:20:43 Mayor Brian Bladd from Pocatello. You can write in a vote and it needs to be signed

0:20:48 him dropped in the mail this week and I forgot to bring that paper tonight so I

0:20:51 need to get it to you but I wanted to remind you so you could get Council input.

0:20:54 Thank you. In our form of government of course the mayor is just another council

0:21:00 member. I did more of a chairman of the board, chairperson of the board so these

0:21:04 He's kind of voting opportunities.

0:21:06 I always feel strongly about bringing it to the full council

0:21:09 for their direction, instead of me just voting.

0:21:13 Would you, I guess I'll just address council,

0:21:15 how would you like me to proceed with that vote?

0:21:18 Greg Lanning.

0:21:20 Brian Blad is also a board member of the AIC,

0:21:23 seems to take his responsibilities at the

0:21:27 I cramp very seriously and I would have no problem

0:21:29 with our vote for Brian Blad.

0:21:32 He's mayor of Puktel.

0:21:35 I see heads nodding. Thank you. If I could get that so I could sign it, I won't get it in.

0:21:40 Thank you. Well, I gave it to you because I forgot. So thank you for reminding us anything else from council this evening.

0:21:50 All right. Last item, potentially going into adjournment into executive public.

0:21:57 I already did.

0:22:00 Wake up, Greg.

0:22:02 Twice.

0:22:04 I missed it.

0:22:06 I missed it.

0:22:08 Next item is executive session 74-2061B to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining

0:22:16 or to hear from planes or charges brought against a public officer,

0:22:20 employee, staff member, individual, agent, or public school

0:22:24 student. I'll ask for directions from council.

0:22:28 Councilor Greg Lanning.

0:22:29 I move that we live in the executive session under 74-2061-B.

0:22:34 Second.

0:22:35 Motion on the 4th by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:22:39 Is there anything further on that motion, Council?

0:22:42 Chair and roll call vote, please.

0:22:45 Greg Lanning.

0:22:46 Yes.

0:22:46 Don Hall.

0:22:47 Yes.

0:22:48 Rebecca Mills-Soyka.

0:22:49 Yes.

0:22:50 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:22:51 Yes.

0:22:52 Jim Mann.

0:22:52 Yes.

0:22:53 Sean Barrick.

0:22:54 Yes.

0:22:54 Motion passes 6-0.

0:22:56 Just want to let folks know we will be going into executive

0:22:59 session, we will not be coming back out this evening to adjourn or to come together again.

0:23:06 We will not be making any decisions.

0:23:10 We are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 12, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:23:24.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7ff50ab95b9c21cd029347831f631ad12b82b1d327e6f58d87aad3845a607d36
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 0fe711bdc3785b230a1777f4f9430d7536b22ed075712049f3d037a8ad1e3e29
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    fd81734dd7a54c68fdbe54d534260b3d2de34bb03c1cda61ae201d69eadfa105

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file