OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 10, 2015

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 As always, we do the Pledge of Allegiance at the beginning, so those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:00:05 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:22 Again, welcome to everyone to our meeting.

0:00:26 Do want to confirm that we have a quorum of the City Council.

0:00:29 We have six out of the seven members here this evening.

0:00:31 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda?

0:00:35 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we don't have necessarily an amendment for the agenda,

0:00:39 but just notice that there is a corrected collection of meeting minutes that are included for your review this evening.

0:00:46 The change appears on page number four, item number four of consideration on that evening.

0:00:54 We had the wrong motion and that is illustrated in red for you.

0:01:00 And we would ask that you use the amended copy

0:01:04 as part of your consent calendar this evening.

0:01:06 Very good, so we'll use the amended copy

0:01:08 as part of the consent calendar.

0:01:09 Thank you, Travis.

0:01:10 We have no proclamations.

0:01:13 Next is we always give an opportunity

0:01:15 for our public to come forward and state what's on their mind.

0:01:20 If we could keep it brief, that would be excellent

0:01:22 because we do have a full agenda this evening.

0:01:24 So this is the time for anyone from the public

0:01:26 that would like to come forward and engage

0:01:30 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:01:37 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:01:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:01:48 [Muted for privacy: home address]

0:01:53 all the happy horse hockey and diversity, nation of immigrants, sharing and

0:01:57 caring, etc. I've also spent time reading and watching videos about the

0:02:00 Islamic global jihad against Western civilization.

0:02:04 It's real, it's a danger to all of us, but I don't see any leadership in this country standing up to protect us.

0:02:09 Rather, I see our public officials giving them aid and comfort, a shield of protection.

0:02:15 What am I to think?

0:02:16 CSI plans to settle at least 300 Syrians here.

0:02:19 Christians from the Middle East are not being settled here only Muslims.

0:02:22 In February of this year, Michael Steinbach, Assistant Director of the FBI Counterterrorism Division said that the FBI can't vet these people.

0:02:30 can't vet these people. Syria is a belt state, so there are no systems, no databases, no

0:02:35 files to search for information on these people. So we have to rely on the United Nations to

0:02:40 tell us that they are okay. Are you aware that the United Nations High Commissioner of

0:02:46 Refugees is a member of the Socialist International? His name is Antonio Cateras. He was Vice President

0:02:53 of the Socialist International from 1992 to 1999. He was President of the Socialist

0:02:58 International from 1999 to 2005 when he became the High Commissioner.

0:03:03 The United Nations High Commission agency determines who is a refugee.

0:03:06 Do you really think a member of the socialist international is choosing the right people

0:03:10 for the United States?

0:03:12 I have young children.

0:03:13 I know that most of you have children or grandchildren, maybe even great grandchildren.

0:03:17 I'm worried about their future, but I don't see any of you concerned about their future.

0:03:21 I only see people who can't seem to turn down a single federal dollar no matter what the strings

0:03:25 attached to it are.

0:03:27 I'm asking you to change that.

0:03:28 I'm asking you to help stop this refugee resettlement program to save American jobs for Americans,

0:03:34 American tax dollars for Americans, and most importantly to save the future for American

0:03:38 children because if this reverse colonization of our country continues, there won't be a

0:03:43 future for American children.

0:03:45 John F. Kennedy said that those who make peaceful change impossible make violent change inevitable.

0:03:52 Please help us make the elimination of the CSI refugees resettlement program peaceful by

0:03:57 by supporting bill HR3314.

0:04:01 Thank you.

0:04:01 Thank you.

0:04:03 Is there anyone else that would like to come forward

0:04:05 and engage your city council?

0:04:10 All right, now moving on to the consent calendar.

0:04:12 I'll turn that over to council direction,

0:04:14 keeping in mind that we have amended minutes.

0:04:18 Greg Lanning.

0:04:19 We'll approve all the consent calendar

0:04:21 with the amended minutes.

0:04:23 Second.

0:04:24 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,

0:04:25 seconded by Sean Berger as stated.

0:04:29 Anything further on that motion council?

0:04:32 Sharon, roll call, please.

0:04:34 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:04:35 Yes.

0:04:36 Jim Munn.

0:04:37 Yes.

0:04:38 Sean Berriger.

0:04:39 Yes.

0:04:39 Chris Talkingfield.

0:04:40 Yes.

0:04:41 Greg Lanting.

0:04:42 Yes.

0:04:43 Don Hall.

0:04:43 Yes.

0:04:44 Motion passes 6 to 0.

0:04:47 Moving on to items for consideration.

0:04:49 The first item is consideration of a request

0:04:52 to approve the use of street impact fees paid

0:04:56 by the Twin Falls School District

0:04:58 for the construction of a traffic signal

0:05:00 at Hankins Road and Stadium Boulevard.

0:05:03 And we have our Deputy City Manager, Mitch Hemble.

0:05:07 Welcome Mitch.

0:05:07 Thank you.

0:05:08 The request tonight is to talk about some impact fees

0:05:11 that we've received from the school district.

0:05:14 As you guys are all aware, we have four different projects

0:05:18 that school districts running through right now

0:05:19 where impact fees were assessed.

0:05:22 And one of those projects, the Pillar Falls,

0:05:26 let me make sure I got the name right.

0:05:27 Pillar Falls Elementary School,

0:05:29 actually had a development requirement of that school

0:05:31 to build this traffic signal at Hankins and Stadium

0:05:35 for safety purposes.

0:05:37 That traffic signal is actually found on our

0:05:41 impact fee, street impact fee capital improvement plan.

0:05:45 And so according to our own city code

0:05:48 and also state laws about impact fees,

0:05:50 we can't charge an impact fee for an improvement

0:05:54 that we can't require the developer of a project

0:05:58 to build an improvement and make them pay impact fees

0:06:01 for the same type of improvements.

0:06:02 And so it's called a double dipping kind of thing.

0:06:05 And so on the pillar falls,

0:06:06 we've actually refunded the street portion

0:06:08 of those impact fees,

0:06:10 which means the other three projects,

0:06:12 South Hills Middle School Rock Creek Elementary School

0:06:14 and the Canyon Ridge High School expansion

0:06:16 have all paid a street impact fee,

0:06:19 that those aren't directly tied to the need for the signal.

0:06:23 The school district requested and to basically use those three payments of impact fee toward

0:06:29 the same signal construction project, which is a perfectly eligible expense for those fees.

0:06:36 We took this request to the impact fee advisory board on, I'm going to get my date wrong here,

0:06:42 on their July meeting, July 23rd, and discussed it with the board, the board unanimously recommended

0:06:49 approval of the request and so we're here before the council to see if that would be

0:06:53 okay with the council to spend those monies $34,100 $34,170 to go back to the

0:07:01 street back to the school district to spend on the $400,000 plus traffic signal

0:07:06 and so that's just a real brief explanation if you want me to go into more details

0:07:11 I'm happy to but also we have represented from the school district here who can chat

0:07:16 about it as well. Thank you Mitch. Chris talking to us.

0:07:19 was latest in that group, but just like to update the Council of how impressed that meeting

0:07:23 was and understanding we had three new members came in, four new members came in with virtually

0:07:32 no background except they were what they were able to assimilate from previous minutes or

0:07:37 talking with staff members. One of them is an architect, there are people in the building

0:07:42 industry, there's I think one general member. A couple of years I've been on this, I have

0:07:48 not seen a more engaged group for the size of it, dealing with the role of impact fees,

0:07:56 and for once not dealing and squabbling over the legality of the thing, but how the money

0:08:02 can and should be used, in this case, to offset some of our new growth issues, specifically

0:08:08 the traffic light that we're talked about.

0:08:12 It really was most impressive and I think that it

0:08:15 it bodes well for getting these funds moving quite fast

0:08:20 in the police fire parks and streets that we have set aside

0:08:24 for the future. Very impressive.

0:08:26 Thank you for this.

0:08:27 This is a really great job and we had nine people on that commission

0:08:30 for the first time in like a few years to show up for the meeting.

0:08:33 I think they're interested now that they smell the money and see

0:08:36 money that they get to help invest in it is good. Thank you. Suzanne Hawkins. I'm ready to make

0:08:43 a motion if that's okay. I think we're good to go. Okay. I move that we approve the request to use

0:08:48 the street impact fees paid by the Twin Falls School District for the construction of the traffic

0:08:53 signal at Hankins Road in Stadium Boulevard. Second. We have a motion on floor by Suzanne Hawkins

0:09:00 seconded by Greg Lanting as stated. Council have anything further on that motion. I see no lights

0:09:08 Sharon, roll call, vote, please.

0:09:10 Jim Mann.

0:09:11 Yes.

0:09:12 Sean Baraker.

0:09:13 Yes.

0:09:13 Chris Tockington.

0:09:14 Yes.

0:09:15 Greg Lanthing.

0:09:16 Yes.

0:09:16 Don Hall.

0:09:17 Yes.

0:09:18 Suzanne Hopkins.

0:09:19 Yes.

0:09:20 Motion passes 6-0.

0:09:23 Thank you, Mitch.

0:09:24 Next item on the agenda is consideration

0:09:26 of a request to adopt a resolution

0:09:28 to allow the city to procure goods and services

0:09:31 on the open market and awarding this year's zone maintenance

0:09:35 project to 9th River Incorporated.

0:09:38 We have John, Kate, and welcome John.

0:09:40 Thank you, Mayor and Council.

0:09:41 Good evening.

0:09:42 You'll recall, at the end of June,

0:09:46 I came before you and explained that we had bid

0:09:49 our annual project this year.

0:09:50 We got one responsive bid, and it was substantially higher

0:09:53 than our engineers' estimate, and it was our recommendation

0:09:57 to reject this bid, and Council approved that rejection.

0:10:02 Since then, I've been in contact with Idaho Sand and Gravel

0:10:08 due to their backlog and schedule this summer that they're not in a position that they can renegotiate.

0:10:14 So, tonight the request that I'd like to make it, there's two steps here.

0:10:19 One is to request the council to approve a resolution that would allow me to negotiate for cure services on the open market.

0:10:29 I've had a conversation with Night River, Inc., as you can see in the documents,

0:10:35 And they have come in substantially less than Idaho

0:10:40 Sand and gravel, approximately $153,000 less.

0:10:45 And Tim Vosser with the HM is here.

0:10:48 He provided the design.

0:10:49 He put the estimate together.

0:10:51 He's available for questions if you

0:10:53 want to ask him about current bidding environment

0:10:55 and his estimate specifically.

0:10:58 But tonight, I'd like to first request for the resolution.

0:11:02 And then I'm going to ask if that resolution passes

0:11:06 to enter into a contract with the bank firm.

0:11:11 What would the resolution number

0:11:13 be, Sharon, if we choose to?

0:11:16 Resolution 1948.

0:11:19 1948, thank you, Sharon.

0:11:21 Chris, talk to me.

0:11:22 John, I have a question.

0:11:25 Admittedly, the bed that we rejected was out of sight.

0:11:29 And even at the attempt to get them to resubmit,

0:11:33 they apparently felt that they couldn't or wouldn't.

0:11:35 So the new contender and I forever,

0:11:38 now we've had experience with them,

0:11:41 with the wastewater plant work as I understand, haven't we?

0:11:44 Yes, they've done water line work for us.

0:11:47 And yes, they did, on or false.

0:11:50 Well, I am still concerned because that 153,000

0:11:54 is about 20% less than the high bed.

0:11:57 And that is much wider than the usual 5% or less

0:12:03 we get between a high and a low bed.

0:12:06 Are we missing something?

0:12:09 Is there a performance bond, protections for us,

0:12:14 or some protection in case they are just

0:12:18 at no personal reflection on the company,

0:12:20 but missing something and can't live with this bed?

0:12:26 Your question is if knife river can't?

0:12:30 The new low bidder.

0:12:31 I know there is payment and performance bonds if you have full contract we dinner into a full contract with my forever

0:12:37 They'd be obligated to

0:12:40 comply with the contract

0:12:42 All we can ask for them. I guess and

0:12:45 Suzanne Hawkins. Thank you John. I don't know if this is for you or Tim

0:12:51 But I don't remember what the engineer estimates were originally. Do you have that information?

0:13:03 So

0:13:05 So I'm sorry, Tim Vosser with the H-engineer.

0:13:08 Thank you, just for folks at home.

0:13:10 Basically, what we did was prepare that easement sometime in the early spring of this year.

0:13:16 And it was really based off highest prices from the previous year that we had experienced.

0:13:23 We over-estined rock and we also over-estined prices that we thought were there.

0:13:30 The current climate is just people are so busy that we're getting high bids in order for people to

0:13:37 cover the extra time they spend in the field with blended staff and support. We're also seeing some

0:13:45 some things down in that area that I think because of the crowded area and

0:13:50 traffic control and getting people in and out of their residence is that that's gonna raise the price and you're never gonna see a drop in that.

0:13:56 It's just a congested spot that's

0:13:59 going to win to hire the usual prices.

0:14:03 But the original estimate was for 520,000.

0:14:07 And the newest estimate from the night for river, of course, is

0:14:11 696, 713, 50.

0:14:17 So even though that's roughly 30% more than the estimate,

0:14:21 I think it's probably the best we're going to see

0:14:25 considering the current climate going into the end of this year and even into the

0:14:30 start of next year for that area. So should we expect more bids out of line with our

0:14:37 estimates are we getting back into what is really current and what's true so we're

0:14:42 not so far off in the near future? You know, I think you're good. It's a

0:14:48 crystal ball effect but I think you're going to see more people from out of town

0:14:53 coming in that don't have the work in their areas.

0:14:56 And maybe that'll help balance the scale a little bit.

0:14:59 But as far as what our local environment is like,

0:15:03 everybody's really busy with right now.

0:15:05 And a lot of that has to do with school district projects,

0:15:08 not only here, but in Jerome and other areas as well.

0:15:13 Thank you.

0:15:16 John, did you have things to add?

0:15:18 Yes, thank you, Mayor.

0:15:20 Councilman talking to just, you know,

0:15:21 I had the same concerns, you know,

0:15:23 with the first go round.

0:15:25 It was just way too high.

0:15:26 And so I couldn't stand up here and recommend

0:15:29 that we go forward.

0:15:30 And the reason I feel more comfortable doing that now

0:15:32 is all the other construction meetings

0:15:34 I'm sitting in for various projects.

0:15:37 I keep hearing over and over again.

0:15:38 Let's wait till next spring to bid,

0:15:41 because the bidding environment will be better.

0:15:43 Well, I can't tell for sure what's going to happen,

0:15:46 but I keep hearing that over and over again.

0:15:48 And I think we're facing a bubble here

0:15:51 that's going to last longer than next spring.

0:15:53 So we can continue to, I think it's,

0:15:57 it could become a bad habit to defer maintenance

0:16:00 when we could stay the course within reason.

0:16:06 I do think that the second bit is more reasonable

0:16:09 and more reflective of what's going on than the first one.

0:16:14 Thank you, John.

0:16:15 Okay, we have two different actions this evening.

0:16:17 Great lining.

0:16:18 I would like to move approval of a resolution in 1948.

0:16:22 Second.

0:16:23 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,

0:16:25 seconded by Sean Berriger to approve resolution number 1948.

0:16:29 Anything further on that motion council?

0:16:33 Sharon, roll call vote please.

0:16:37 Sean Berriger.

0:16:38 Yes.

0:16:39 Chris Tockington.

0:16:40 Yes.

0:16:41 Greg Lanning.

0:16:42 Yes.

0:16:43 Don Hall.

0:16:44 Yes.

0:16:44 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:16:45 Yes.

0:16:46 Jim Lunn.

0:16:47 Yes.

0:16:48 Motion passes six to zero.

0:16:49 And the second is to be able to negotiate with them.

0:16:52 Correct.

0:16:53 And we have negotiated mayor.

0:16:54 The contract amount is $696,713.50 and with the council's permission, I'd like to request

0:17:05 that we enter into a contract with Landford River for that.

0:17:08 I'd like to move that we accept the negotiated contract of $696,700, $13.50 for the zone maintenance

0:17:18 program with Ninth River, Southern Idaho Division.

0:17:22 Second.

0:17:24 No, I thought it was perfect.

0:17:27 Motion on four by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hopkins.

0:17:31 It's true.

0:17:32 So before we go on to the vote, John, did you have something?

0:17:36 I'd like to add that.

0:17:37 The budget, we do have enough money budgeted for this project.

0:17:40 I didn't have to do anything special.

0:17:42 We had enough contingency planned for this project.

0:17:45 So we can't afford it too.

0:17:47 Okay.

0:17:48 Thank you.

0:17:49 That's always important.

0:17:50 We just assumed that.

0:17:53 It might have been a good question.

0:17:56 Anything further on the motion council?

0:17:59 Sharon Rotomo please.

0:18:01 Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Suzanne Hocking,

0:18:06 Yes, Jim Munn, Sean Bericher.

0:18:09 Yes, motion passes six to zero.

0:18:11 Thank you, John.

0:18:13 Greg Lannings.

0:18:14 I'm wondering if we could have a moment

0:18:15 to ask possibly the school district representatives

0:18:17 and the Brad Wills, whether or not

0:18:19 how the bidding is going for the school

0:18:21 since every taxpayer who's a tax-parent city falls falls

0:18:25 is also a tax-payer in the Twin Falls Clue District.

0:18:29 So Brad, could you talk to us about how their bidding

0:18:31 processes went?

0:18:32 Are they done yet, or do they have more to put out,

0:18:34 or Brad before you begin there?

0:18:36 I just want to let the folks know

0:18:37 they came and made their presentation.

0:18:38 You're more than welcome to stay,

0:18:40 but if you guys need to get up and leave,

0:18:42 it doesn't hurt our feelings.

0:18:43 People leave in the middle of our meetings all the time.

0:18:45 Just want to make sure that you're comfortable.

0:18:47 Okay.

0:18:47 Go ahead.

0:18:48 So we have the same philosophy right now where we've bid the first two schools, elementary

0:18:57 schools toward Falls and Rock Creek, ESI's, the contractor on those.

0:19:02 The next middle school south of town just bid here last week, or actually I'm sorry,

0:19:09 I was bidding this week, which is later than we had thought with the same intent that what

0:19:15 John was talking about was just seeing prices being really high.

0:19:19 We want to maximize the dollars, so Canyon Ridge expansion is being delayed a couple more

0:19:27 months for that same purpose.

0:19:29 Just with Jerome doing a high school, our high school, just all those things, we're

0:19:34 seeing a very limited subcontractor pool on our account.

0:19:40 So that's just to reiterate that we are seeing the same thing that you guys saw as a school

0:19:46 district.

0:19:47 Brad, do you think that in retrospect, maybe the school district, they're building all three,

0:19:55 basically about the same time, or trying to, in retrospect, we started the Rock Creek on Grandview,

0:20:03 Northwest, and it's the same contractor doing the second one. So we stair stepped up with about

0:20:09 a, probably seven, eight week separation. So a lot of the same subs can work on both of them.

0:20:15 And then we're seeing that same thing with the, but it's a different contractor.

0:20:20 It's Anderson construction out of Boise that is doing the middle school.

0:20:25 But, you know, we're getting advice from our general contractors that they're limited in some areas that we should watch that and maximize that.

0:20:37 So I guess it's a pretty good problem to have that we're so busy in our local environment

0:20:44 with construction.

0:20:45 With your upcoming projects, you'll see that in probably with the urban renewal projects,

0:20:50 we have to be aware of that too.

0:20:52 And now, Chris talking.

0:20:53 I'd like to remind the council that we had an airport bed on the remodeling that had to be broken into two years

0:21:00 because of the out of bounds bidding by available sources.

0:21:05 And they basically mentioned it was going to have to be done on overtime.

0:21:10 That was the rationale.

0:21:12 It was a labor component more than anything.

0:21:15 Thank you, Chris.

0:21:16 Thank you, Brad.

0:21:17 Appreciate your input.

0:21:18 Moving on to the next item, which is consideration of a request to approve a preliminary 30% main avenue redesign concept.

0:21:26 We have Melinda Anderson as well as Mandy Roberts from OOTAC.

0:21:31 Welcome Melinda.

0:21:32 Thank you, Mayor.

0:21:33 Thank you, Council.

0:21:34 So, tonight, the show is Mandy Roberts from OTAC is going to be presenting the 30% preliminary

0:21:45 design.

0:21:46 And when I say preliminary, it really is, 30% is not very far into the design piece.

0:21:51 So we're going to see a lot of great pretty pictures for this, but there's going to still

0:21:56 be a lot of work to do.

0:21:58 So, earlier today, we met with both the project advisory committee, the PAC, and the project

0:22:04 and as well as the Urban Renewal Board.

0:22:08 Both bodies unanimously approved overall

0:22:12 the 30% design that you're gonna see tonight.

0:22:18 Certainly there are lots,

0:22:19 there were lots of questions and suggestions

0:22:21 for potential tweaks, which is part of the next phase

0:22:25 as we get into 100% design and engineering

0:22:28 is to look at some of those issues and consider that.

0:22:32 But I want to caution us tonight that we're really just asking the council, if you are

0:22:38 in favor of this overall design, understanding that there will be tweaks along the way based

0:22:43 on all the feedback that we continue to get from you as well as the community at large.

0:22:51 One other thing I want to say about this design is it really reflects everything that

0:22:55 we all heard over the past year from the community as well as the values that we had put together.

0:23:00 So I'm really excited about this.

0:23:03 I think you're really going to like it.

0:23:05 You will see as part of the council packet,

0:23:09 we included preliminary costs.

0:23:11 Again, I'm just really reiterating it.

0:23:14 These are very preliminary.

0:23:15 And as we get into it through the 100% design,

0:23:18 those numbers will be better refined.

0:23:21 We're also not ready yet tonight to talk about phasing

0:23:24 of how this project may go in the future.

0:23:26 As we have started with the design and engineering

0:23:31 for the alley infrastructure, we're learning more and more

0:23:33 things that we weren't aware of prior to this recent work

0:23:40 that we're doing.

0:23:41 So we're going back and looking at really what's the best way

0:23:44 to skin this cat, to move forward on construction on everything.

0:23:50 And I think we'll have more answers, more clear answers

0:23:53 on that part of it later on this year.

0:23:56 Yes, sir.

0:23:58 So before Mandy comes up, preliminary costs, those are estimates.

0:24:02 They're definitely not bids.

0:24:04 Correct.

0:24:05 They're just estimates and they will, like I said, they will be refined as OTAC gets through

0:24:11 100% design and engineering as we learn more.

0:24:15 Thank you.

0:24:16 And so I'm going to ask Mandy to come up and make a presentation.

0:24:18 It looks like Christmas.

0:24:19 And it also is important to note that this isn't a final project cost because there are

0:24:23 a lot of add-ons that are anticipated that we have to seek community block grants for.

0:24:29 Correct.

0:24:30 Part of one on the memo I think Mandy put in at the last page, some of the cross streets,

0:24:35 we have the potential to actually get a community block grant for those to use that instead of

0:24:41 TIFF money.

0:24:42 Excellent.

0:24:43 Thank you.

0:24:44 Thank you.

0:24:45 Good point.

0:24:48 Mandy, welcome.

0:24:49 Thank you so much, Marin Council.

0:24:50 Good to see you again.

0:24:51 Hopefully, a lot of what I'll be showing you tonight will look familiar because we're

0:24:55 We have been here in the past giving updates as we've moved through preliminary design.

0:24:59 Now we have the full picture and we're really calling it a master plan for the downtown

0:25:06 area that you see in the image here which extends from Fairfield to Jerome and includes

0:25:13 all five blocks of main avenue as well as the downtown commons site on the Rogerson site.

0:25:22 And festival street segments which we've talked in the past can be raised areas of street that

0:25:29 are raised at sidewalk level, closed during events for markets, concerts, things like that.

0:25:37 Those are the light colored, light gray colored areas that you see just eastern of, excuse

0:25:45 me western of Shoshone to the mid block and western of Hanson to the mid block.

0:25:53 Those areas through a lot of public input, there was interest with the good into Shoshone

0:25:58 block of having a festival street segment there on that half of the block.

0:26:04 They do a lot of festivals there, Oktoberfest today, and they wanted to formalize that function.

0:26:13 And then it made sense to do the same type of treatment near the downtown common site so

0:26:18 that when the downtown commons is used for concerts, you can really expand that event use

0:26:25 all the way out into the streets in both directions actually.

0:26:30 So we're showing a festival street between downtown commons and city hall as well.

0:26:35 So you can almost think of downtown commons as kind of the living room to city hall and

0:26:40 that would extend across Hanson at one level to City Hall,

0:26:46 New City Hall building.

0:26:47 Very exciting.

0:26:49 So also the master plan includes some concepts related

0:26:54 to enhancing the alleyways.

0:26:56 I'll go into those in a little bit more detail.

0:26:58 And enhanced crossings of the two second avenue couplet system.

0:27:04 So what we mean by that are basically

0:27:07 curb bulbs or curb extensions at intersections along the second avenues to really enhance

0:27:13 pedestrian and bicycle connectivity.

0:27:16 For example, on Hanson, that would really enhance crossing from City Park all the way

0:27:22 to downtown Commons and Maine and then further south to the work areas down there and the

0:27:29 old town areas of Gambia and St. Luke's and folks that are working down in that area.

0:27:37 So I will go through some of the details now.

0:27:42 This cross-section should look familiar.

0:27:44 We came and talked to you about cross-sections in May and this is the final result of that

0:27:51 with front end or head-in angled parking on both sides of the street retained.

0:27:57 We also have travel lane widths that could accommodate potential conversion in the future

0:28:02 if the city decided to do that.

0:28:05 Conversion to back and forth.

0:28:07 Yes, and then possibly adding sherrows in the future with that configuration.

0:28:12 We have sidewalks on both sides of 13 and a half feet to the face of curb, which is one

0:28:20 foot less than what's out there today.

0:28:25 One of the things we've done to balance that is we've in the festival street areas we have

0:28:31 introduced a cross section that there's a lot of interest and support in with the project

0:28:36 advisory committee and the block by block merchants that we've talked to where we would

0:28:41 not have parking on the northern side of the street where the festival streets are and

0:28:49 that would be an expanded sidewalk space as you see in this cross section which would

0:28:53 accommodate additional sidewalk cafes and festival space,

0:28:57 festival areas, and additional sidewalk capacity.

0:29:03 You could still have sidewalk cafes

0:29:06 on the other side of the street in the furnishing zone.

0:29:10 There's space there for that type of use.

0:29:13 And remember, I talked about the park lit idea

0:29:16 in past meetings, whereas if someone really wanted

0:29:20 to have a lot of dining capacity in front of their restaurant

0:29:23 in the future, they could come to the city and work out,

0:29:27 possibly the idea of renting parking spaces

0:29:30 and converting those into sidewalk cafes.

0:29:32 A lot of cities are doing that these days.

0:29:34 It's kind of cool.

0:29:35 Portland, some of the Intermountain cities.

0:29:38 So it's an idea that is a way to use parking spaces

0:29:42 effectively for other uses in the future if you want to.

0:29:48 The Hanson Street extension is also shown in our master plan,

0:29:52 which, as you'll recall, will build Hanson from Maine Avenue

0:29:58 south to Second Avenue South.

0:30:02 And potentially, we've shown that it could either extend

0:30:07 into the parking lot or extend all the way

0:30:09 to Second Avenue South and connect.

0:30:12 This is a cross section that's very common on many

0:30:15 of the other cross streets downtown with travel lane

0:30:19 widths of about 11 feet and parallel parking lanes on each side of 8 feet wide and then

0:30:27 about 10 and a half feet of sidewalk space on each side of the street.

0:30:31 So we just tried to really match what is typical on other cross streets in downtown

0:30:36 with that cross section.

0:30:37 The idea that I want to mention is we've talked about Hanson being a really friendly

0:30:42 pedestrian and bicycle corridor.

0:30:44 So we are showing the idea of having a shared, a share-out treatment on Hanson and having

0:30:53 some trees there, keeping speeds low, certainly as you approach the festival street area and

0:31:00 you see a change in pavement potentially, that will slow vehicles down as well.

0:31:05 So we should be able to achieve that objective of having it be a really nice pedestrian bicycle

0:31:11 corridor through some of these design treatments.

0:31:15 This is an illustration looking roughly southwest at the downtown commons location and you can

0:31:26 see the building across the street, how we tried to replicate that.

0:31:31 Interestingly, the look and feel of the street can really be affected by the choice of paving

0:31:37 material.

0:31:38 And so here we're showing unit pavers and we do have a cost, a potential cost item of

0:31:43 adding unit papers in the furnishing zones, at intersection corners, and in the festival

0:31:49 street areas which add a color and texture compared to if it was just plain concrete as

0:31:58 it is today.

0:32:00 And the choice of that color is really yet to be determined if we went with more of

0:32:05 a red brick all the way through changes the look and feel of the street.

0:32:08 So we're going to work with the project advisory committee a little bit more and look

0:32:12 get some specific patterns and colors and get some more input on that.

0:32:17 And I would love it if Council has some thoughts about that too tonight.

0:32:21 Yes.

0:32:22 Yes.

0:32:23 Yes.

0:32:24 Yes.

0:32:25 Yes.

0:32:26 Yes.

0:32:27 Yes.

0:32:28 Yes.

0:32:29 Yes.

0:32:30 Yes.

0:32:31 Yes.

0:32:32 Yes.

0:32:33 Yes.

0:32:34 Yes.

0:32:35 Yes.

0:32:36 Yes.

0:32:37 Yes.

0:32:38 on main avenue for the five block areas

0:32:40 and the downtown comments is 220,000 additional.

0:32:44 Chris talking to me.

0:32:45 And the lighting mandate to re-acquaint us

0:32:47 with what the idea is, do we keep the same standards

0:32:50 and require and go for more efficient money?

0:32:53 Yeah, we've been looking into that very deeply

0:32:56 and consulting with experts in the field.

0:32:59 And we definitely will need to replace the entire electrical

0:33:03 system to accomplish our goals of having capacity for events

0:33:08 and holiday lighting to also meet a better standard of lighting

0:33:16 for pedestrians downtown.

0:33:17 Right now we don't have as efficient of lighting

0:33:20 wash on the pedestrians as we would like.

0:33:23 So with that, with the new electrical system,

0:33:27 we really need new light poles.

0:33:29 So we've been looking at some cost models, cost examples

0:33:32 for those.

0:33:33 Well, we've heard fairly pretty clearly

0:33:35 from the community and project advisory committees.

0:33:37 They really like the look of their existing light poles.

0:33:40 So we're looking at options that would retain that look,

0:33:44 the fluted, historic pole, even the green color,

0:33:49 but would be a completely new pole and fixture.

0:33:52 With the downcast on the light, no shooting up in the air.

0:33:55 Exactly, so a hood or mirrored element at the top

0:33:59 would keep light pointing downward.

0:34:02 So that is in the budget that you see,

0:34:05 which I'll talk about in a minute,

0:34:06 for main avenue to replace the electrical system,

0:34:09 lighting and electrical for events.

0:34:13 And for just to get back to paving,

0:34:16 there's a real advantage to using for unit pavers

0:34:20 where we might have those using kind of a mix of colors

0:34:23 and just holds up better to traffic and dirt and wear.

0:34:29 And so it's just a matter of kind of choosing the right mix

0:34:32 and thinking what would work best in downtown.

0:34:34 You can see there's some examples here

0:34:36 how that looks.

0:34:39 This is a bird's eye view from similar location,

0:34:43 downtown commons, vicinity.

0:34:46 And what I really like about this view

0:34:48 is it gives you a sense of how the mid block crossings would

0:34:50 work.

0:34:51 So the desire for those is that they would be raised.

0:34:54 And so if you're pushing a stroller

0:34:56 or you're in a wheelchair on one side of the sidewalk,

0:34:59 you just continue at the same level all the way across.

0:35:03 Traffic would ramp up a very gradual speed hump,

0:35:08 not a speed bump, but a gradual speed hump.

0:35:10 And when they approach the festival street area,

0:35:13 if it's raised, then they'll stay at that level

0:35:16 and go back down on the other end of the festival street.

0:35:20 So I think those could be a really nice feature

0:35:23 in the design as well.

0:35:24 In your experience, is that,

0:35:26 we always talk about traffic calming devices

0:35:29 to keep people, keep their speeds down.

0:35:31 Did those help with that?

0:35:33 Yes, they very much do, yes.

0:35:37 The Downtown Commons Master Plan, a few key features

0:35:42 in the Downtown Commons that are in our preliminary design

0:35:46 and Master Plan include an upgraded restroom building

0:35:50 with a stage.

0:35:52 And it's a very simple stage.

0:35:53 It's not a high technology stage with a lot of sound

0:35:58 and lights, but more an upgrade to what's happening today,

0:36:02 a raised platform deck with some good electrical access for plug and play for the concerts to

0:36:08 bring their own sound systems.

0:36:11 Shading is something that we're looking into.

0:36:14 One of the things that we've found is that tensile shade structures can be very expensive,

0:36:20 so we're looking at some different options or there are some more portable options that

0:36:23 might be less expensive.

0:36:25 Shade is going to be really important here.

0:36:27 It's a lot of exposure, solar exposure on this plaza.

0:36:31 A lot of people like to be shady when they're watching the concert, so we want to keep that

0:36:35 in mind in the design.

0:36:38 We're showing the festival streets in the master plan, the splash play area as well.

0:36:45 And one feature I want to note is the area to the south of the restroom stage area and

0:36:53 the splash play area are all at one grade.

0:36:56 So you could effectively turn off the fountain and during a concert, that whole area could

0:37:02 fill up with chairs for seating for the concert or people standing.

0:37:06 And even to the extent that you could expand all the way out into the festival streets and

0:37:11 gain a lot of capacity for the concerts or performances at the stage.

0:37:18 So we are showing that the potential with festival streets on Hanson and Maine, that you would

0:37:23 raise that intersection and it would all be,

0:37:26 excuse me, everything in that L would be at sidewalk level.

0:37:30 We would use paving and ballerds to control traffic

0:37:33 in that zone.

0:37:35 Sean Berger has a question.

0:37:36 Andy, on this particular block along the plaza there,

0:37:39 is there no parking in that section of Hanson

0:37:42 in the concept plane?

0:37:44 Right now we're showing parking on the city hall side,

0:37:47 that there would be parking there.

0:37:49 We had decided not to show parking on the plaza sides

0:37:53 just because of concerns with kids or folks walking back and forth to City Hall or across

0:37:58 the street, you know, visibility between cars might be a problem, but we are showing parking

0:38:03 on the opposite sides of the street, and then we're capturing new parking spaces on the Hanson

0:38:10 Street extension, which you can't really see in this view, but where we're building the road

0:38:15 through on both sides of the street.

0:38:17 The reason I ask is I have heard some concerns expressed with like the building department

0:38:24 type functions moving to the new city hall.

0:38:27 People are on their way out to a job site, they're all in their trailer, they need to

0:38:31 pull in and pick up a permit.

0:38:34 The accessibility for convenient parking for them, again it's not going to be a park there

0:38:38 all day type thing, but I thought that particular section of Hanson on the west side may be the

0:38:47 the more convenient parking as they would come in off the other second.

0:38:53 But I think it's something to consider not just individual vehicles, but where,

0:38:59 where will that traffic be able to be accommodated?

0:39:04 Very well could be in that next block.

0:39:07 Yeah, but I think just something to plan ahead for both with this project and

0:39:11 with the city hall planning of figuring out where's the handiest place to say,

0:39:15 look if you're popping in to get a permit, here's the best way to come in.

0:39:18 Right.

0:39:19 I think staff has been hearing some of those same concerns the past few months and I know

0:39:24 that the agency and will be working pretty closely with the city on what the Hanson Street

0:39:30 will look like between the Plaza and City Hall because everybody's got a big impact to

0:39:36 everybody.

0:39:37 Travis, do you want to add?

0:39:42 Okay.

0:39:43 Moving on.

0:39:44 This is a floor plan, again, it's preliminary for what the restroom building and stage area

0:39:52 could look like.

0:39:53 We provided some area for maintenance, access and storage, the ability for ramping, if you

0:39:59 need to roll equipment up to the stage, you need to have a ramp.

0:40:04 And you know, there's some refinements that probably need to be made to the restroom access.

0:40:09 We were talking about those this morning, how that would work.

0:40:13 But in general, this would really be an upgrade to what's happening today in terms of how performance

0:40:20 space is organized in the plaza.

0:40:22 Chris, talking in that space.

0:40:24 Mandy, there's an old TV radio guy.

0:40:26 I see a potential problem and I'm assuming you've already headed this off at the past.

0:40:30 But the alignment of the stage shooting directly south, are you concerned about the soundbound

0:40:37 off of the Idaho youth ranch and clogged brown building and even City Hall by the over maxed

0:40:46 amplifiers of our music system on a weekly basis. Have you thought about that or a sound

0:40:52 of sorbing material?

0:40:55 You know, only in the form of landscape, we do show in the master plan to go back one slide,

0:41:03 idea of some grassy areas that could be

0:41:06 burned and maybe curved around to the

0:41:08 south there. So the thought there is to

0:41:12 try to provide a little bit of sound

0:41:15 containment as well as seating space for

0:41:20 people and to help attenuate the heat.

0:41:23 You know, anytime we have landscaper

0:41:25 grass that helps the concern and again

0:41:29 we need to work these things out with

0:41:31 city and maintenance is that any time you have grass it has to be mowed and watered. So it's

0:41:38 something, you know, there's some trade-offs there to think about. And I would be really

0:41:42 interested in other thoughts. We don't have a lot of, we don't have a, just with the cost

0:41:50 that we're looking at here, we don't have a lot of capacity to do additional architectural

0:41:54 elements for sound attenuation.

0:41:59 So it's a challenge.

0:42:02 What we're really trying to do is upgrade conditions from what's happening today.

0:42:08 And so, you know, I guess that's kind of a quasi-answer, but we're hoping that through

0:42:15 some of the softscape, landscape that we can help to provide a better environment for the

0:42:20 concerts.

0:42:21 And if you have ideas, Chris, that would be great to hear those from you, take them back to the team.

0:42:30 I personally would not lean towards grass. What about that artificial stuff that we're seeing

0:42:38 popping up? It certainly wouldn't help with temperature, but it sure probably would sound

0:42:45 absorption and give it a better. I mean I've seen a bunch of it around our even

0:42:51 our town. That's a little weird in the winter but the first federal park is

0:42:56 yeah. Yeah. Plastic. Yeah. Something that this is these are the details when you go

0:43:06 from 30% to 90% basically and even from 30% to 60% we really want to have these

0:43:13 materials decisions made, so we'll be looking at those details and weighing the pros and

0:43:19 cons, and that's when it comes down to decision making costs and really, you know, making

0:43:25 some decisions.

0:43:26 But I think we really wanted to try to cool things off a bit with some kind of landscape,

0:43:30 whether it's mode grass or just landscape in the plaza, I think it would be helpful.

0:43:37 Low maintenance.

0:43:39 The lower the maintenance, the better.

0:43:40 We understand that.

0:43:42 So moving on to the next slide, I just wanted to mention that there are things that we're

0:43:50 providing space for that are not necessarily going to be budgeted in the project, but could

0:43:57 happen in the future with downtown group coming together to fund things or through other funding

0:44:04 sources.

0:44:05 We talked a lot in past meetings about a portable ice getting rink that could be self-contained.

0:44:11 could come in, set it up for a couple of months, charge a small fee, and manage it, and then

0:44:16 take it down.

0:44:18 And we have provided space in the plaza for that to happen.

0:44:22 So it could be a great use there, also holiday lighting.

0:44:26 We've talked about within the spray play area, you could actually put a sleeve in the center

0:44:31 point for a tree that could be, you know, locked and removed for the tree during holiday time.

0:44:39 So you're not going to be running through the sprinklers during the winter, seems like a

0:44:42 good winter time use.

0:44:44 And then of course all the other festival lighting and ideas, those are, there's a lot

0:44:48 of great, catenary light systems and accent light systems that I think could really add

0:44:54 vibrancy and interest at night time, not only in the plaza but along the streets gate.

0:44:59 So we really want to encourage, I think, the merchants to be flexible and creative in how

0:45:04 they do lighting in front of their shops.

0:45:10 And we've been asked several times to really take a look at the alleyways and how to better

0:45:15 organize the trash to make them safer, more accessible to improve lighting and pedestrian

0:45:23 access.

0:45:24 So we had a couple of different concepts.

0:45:26 I threw these in quickly.

0:45:28 They were not in your packet and I apologize for surprising you with them, but I wanted

0:45:31 to share them with you.

0:45:32 This one shows dumpsters.

0:45:35 Instead of as we have dumpsters in the alleys kind of placed here and there of different sizes,

0:45:39 would be dumpsters of a consistent size all placed along the landscape strip for access

0:45:46 and the potential for not just asphalt but other potential unit pavers in areas where

0:45:53 or concrete where pedestrians are walking between parking and doorways.

0:46:00 And then enhanced lighting is also shown in these views as well as landscape and trees.

0:46:06 We have a lot of interest with our budget advisory committee

0:46:09 in the alleyways, especially the alleyway areas

0:46:13 that are near where festival streets would be.

0:46:16 Those seem to be the high priority areas for enhancement.

0:46:21 And this one is even a more aggressive idea

0:46:24 of actually taking all the trash containers

0:46:27 and putting them into CMU walled containers,

0:46:31 which a lot of commercial areas do.

0:46:34 It requires a little bit more diligence from folks taking their trash out and whatnot, so

0:46:43 it's also more costly, but it's potentially a long term idea to think about in some of

0:46:49 the alleyways to really get trashed away from the places where people are walking.

0:46:54 The main idea there.

0:46:56 This is one of the cross sections of the alleyway showing how dumpsters could be lined up in

0:47:01 the landscape strip and cleaning up the alleyway environment for walking and pedestrian access.

0:47:09 So we did take a look at costs and I'm just going to quickly click through without going

0:47:17 through all the details, but I wanted to point out some of the kind of main costs that are

0:47:24 in the memo that we prepared for the board that they looked at today.

0:47:29 So the alleyways, as we've talked about in the past, the estimated cost for replacing

0:47:35 the utilities and resurfacing the alleyways as the 5 million, that's item A, for B, for

0:47:41 the 5 blocks of main avenue, basic improvements and replacing lighting, electrical, sorry about

0:47:49 that landscape, trees, enhanced sidewalk areas is 4,750,000 at about 950,000 per block.

0:48:03 And again, I want to really make the point that these costs are very preliminary.

0:48:07 We're at a 30% level of design.

0:48:09 When we're at that level of design, we tend to put in contingencies that are higher.

0:48:15 We tend to be conservative about costs because there are things that we're going to learn

0:48:19 as we go further into engineering that will help us fine-tune our costs.

0:48:24 So these are very preliminary, but these are the costs that we've estimated today.

0:48:30 They do include design and soft costs that we need to include in the contingencies as part

0:48:37 of the project.

0:48:38 Item C, then, as you asked earlier, is if we added unit pavers, that represents a net of

0:48:45 taking out concrete and adding in unit papers in furnishing zones and what not.

0:48:51 And then we've also done the same thing with the festival street options, DE and F that

0:48:59 represents a cost of if we were to instead of have a recessed asphalt street segments

0:49:07 in those areas, we would have raised concrete areas, so the cost of raising the street up

0:49:14 and using concrete material is what those are, the net add of that.

0:49:17 I won't go into any other details, but you can kind of see how all the different elements

0:49:24 are broken down into components and we have cost for those.

0:49:27 We really wanted to give the Urban Renewal Agency a tool for decision-making so they could

0:49:33 understand what the cost of adding or subtracting different elements might be so that we could

0:49:40 arrive at a decision at what the project will be that gets built and how it's

0:49:44 based. So with that I'm happy to answer any other questions or taking any other

0:49:48 comments you might have. Great landing. Well a couple of comments. One I'm really

0:49:52 glad to see we're doing something about the Grand Electra Coles. I followed one

0:49:57 couple of wins. I followed Tony Prater around after the concert to see the

0:50:02 variations he goes because he has to fake the lights into thinking that they're

0:50:07 it's dark so the the vendors all have power and then he has to go around back

0:50:12 afterwards and shut it off and turn it on and it's kind of a process they're

0:50:16 using to kind of make it happen at this point for the for the vendors to be able

0:50:21 to have electricity and then also I was in wall of wall recently and which has a

0:50:27 very private downtown of course they have a couple of vanities middle and we

0:50:31 don't have a hundred wineries but there 40 of them have a tasting ribs downtown

0:50:35 which helps their downtown dramatically. Plus, in fact, they don't have them all and they still

0:50:41 they're downtown. It's still the main shopping area because the malls are all over in Richland

0:50:46 and the other cities quite a ways away. They have a huge Macy's right downtown and things that just

0:50:52 some advantages they have. And the other advantage they have, they have 105 foot street, didn't you

0:50:57 tell us we have a 90 foot street? That's right. Okay. But one of the things I would point out that

0:51:02 They have done one, they've taken out all their landscaping, except for the trees, and replaced them with pavers.

0:51:08 And the reason being was just less maintenance.

0:51:11 And with colored pavers, so you really don't have very mature trees spaced the wrong way.

0:51:19 And then their light poles looked a little like our show show street does, where they have light poles.

0:51:25 light poles, every light pole has a very huge hanging basket that that's how they get their

0:51:31 flowers and that kind of thing downtown. But just some impossible ideas of things that maybe

0:51:37 we don't need as much landscape as we think we do because that was always been an issue

0:51:41 for since the 70s is the maintaining that landscaping. So thank you.

0:51:48 Sean Merger.

0:51:49 I would add that for the hanging baskets in downtown Walla Walla, they also have a plumb

0:51:53 irrigation system to take care of those as opposed to trying to get people to go out and water them twice a day.

0:51:58 Yeah, which is a good point.

0:52:01 Is that what you're asking for?

0:52:05 I will.

0:52:06 I'm just going to say if you're going to implement a hanging basket program, it would be a good idea to put irrigation in.

0:52:12 We have discussed that drip irrigation systems and we have an expert looking into that.

0:52:18 Sometimes I guess water and electricity can mix well, so we're going to look into the option.

0:52:23 Chris, talking. Very impressive. Again, being the numbers guy right now, I'm very concerned that

0:52:30 it could be as much as almost two years before we start writing checks on some of these

0:52:35 end items. Really, the contingency you've built in, is that two years worth of coverage for us?

0:52:45 I'd hate for us to have to start deleting wholesale some of these great ideas you have

0:52:50 and I'd rather have a real high ball right now and come back than have to stretch or these

0:52:57 community block grants I'm concerned about whether they're going to even come to fruition.

0:53:02 You're comfortable with the contingency.

0:53:05 We do have construction contingency amounts in the estimates.

0:53:10 And would you mention also about on average, what percent they might be?

0:53:15 It's a combined design and construction contingency of 25%.

0:53:19 Okay.

0:53:19 So it is high, but it's at 30% design.

0:53:24 That's pretty typical.

0:53:27 Now what we would say is that we would have a level of comfort that this could be a two

0:53:33 two season project and that cost estimate would be good for two seasons.

0:53:39 If things got phased beyond that, then we'd need to add in escalation.

0:53:45 It's the appropriate annual percentage to cover that.

0:53:48 So.

0:53:49 Thank you.

0:53:50 That's what we're reassuring.

0:53:51 Thank you.

0:53:52 Do we have any other questions for either Linda or Mandy before we move on to the decision to,

0:53:58 we need to give them some direction?

0:54:02 Greg Lanning.

0:54:03 I was going to move approval of the 30% design

0:54:06 as presented by Nancy from,

0:54:09 no mandates you'd be from, okay.

0:54:12 Second.

0:54:13 I have a motion for Greg Lanning,

0:54:15 seconded by Sean Berninger.

0:54:18 Did you have questions?

0:54:19 No, I'm good.

0:54:21 Kristoff?

0:54:22 What are we exactly approving on this?

0:54:25 I mean, it's not a dollar figure, Travis.

0:54:28 It's more concept and schematic data

0:54:32 the boundaries of the cost and the concept.

0:54:35 So the only thing that we're asking you to review

0:54:38 and approve is the concepts that you visually

0:54:42 saw this evening.

0:54:44 And what that's going to allow them to do

0:54:46 is say that at 30%, they've heard you.

0:54:50 And this is a plan that they can then

0:54:53 take forward to perfect the 60 and the 90% drawings

0:54:57 at those times and at those benchmarks.

0:54:59 They will bring those back.

0:55:01 At that same time, they should also be able to provide some additional cost refinements,

0:55:06 so that as you move to this place, ultimately at 90% before you bid, you have a good understanding

0:55:12 of what the project is going to look like, as well as what the project costs are going

0:55:16 to be.

0:55:17 And at that point, we'll start developing some strategies that if the estimated engineering

0:55:22 cost is significantly above or below, we'll find a way to deploy those resources in the

0:55:30 of beneficial use.

0:55:31 And if there's a European renewal, we'll be right in the checks.

0:55:34 Correct.

0:55:35 That is correct.

0:55:38 Linda, did you want to add anything?

0:55:39 No.

0:55:40 Good.

0:55:41 Thank you.

0:55:42 Very good.

0:55:43 Anything further on the motion council?

0:55:45 Sharon Rojo, please.

0:55:47 Greg Lanting?

0:55:48 Yes.

0:55:49 Don Hall?

0:55:50 Yes.

0:55:51 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:55:52 Yes.

0:55:53 Jim Munn?

0:55:54 Yes.

0:55:55 Sean Barricker?

0:55:56 Yes.

0:55:57 Chris Hockington.

0:55:58 Yes.

0:55:59 Post passes six to zero.

0:56:00 Thank you, Mandy.

0:56:01 Thank you, Melinda, for the presentation.

0:56:02 Well, just one thing, Mandy will be back, and her team on August 24th for a special meeting with the Urban Renewal Agency for the Agency Board to review and hopefully approve that next hundred phase,

0:56:16 hundred percent design engineering phase contract since she now has completed their first one.

0:56:23 Thank you.

0:56:24 Thank you very much.

0:56:25 Moving on to the next item on the agenda.

0:56:28 Number four is a presentation of the City Manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2016 followed by as always

0:56:35 Citizen input about the budget and we have our deputy city manager Brian Pike

0:56:42 Doing this portion. So welcome Brian. I'm sure our home below there. Well, thank you, Mary members of the council tonight

0:57:11 I do have the privilege of

0:57:13 actually bringing the focus area

0:57:15 to close. I think if I'm right this is the sixth time that we've talked to you about budget

0:57:22 six consecutive time and then actually there's another two weeks so we've had a

0:57:28 total of about eight weeks of talking about the budget and so I get to continue

0:57:32 the presentation of the fiscal year 2016 city managers recommended budget and

0:57:37 tonight we're going to focus on focus area two and three and to kind of make

0:57:42 things a little bit different. I want to reverse that order to talk about focus

0:57:45 area three and then finish with two. But before I get started I also want to

0:57:50 to just spend a few minutes taking the team. There's, this is really a team

0:57:54 approach and the information that I have this really comes from a number of people.

0:57:58 So I have Chief Clark, Chief Brian Career, Lieutenant Stott's and Sean Stanley in the

0:58:02 audience tonight to answer any questions that you may have for them. And

0:58:08 they've been really instrumental in helping me get this prepared. As we move

0:58:11 through, we're going to break down these focus areas into our own little specific areas. And

0:58:16 when we get through with each area, I'll probably pause to see if you have any questions about

0:58:21 that specific area. And then we can go back and address any concerns that you would have.

0:58:26 The real goal here tonight is to continue to build connection with our strategic plan and

0:58:32 what that really looks like in the budget process. Now, this is the slide that I'm hoping

0:58:37 to move past really quickly.

0:58:39 This is the one you've seen in different settings, right?

0:58:42 It looked a little bit different.

0:58:44 But the bottom line is that this is kind of where we're at.

0:58:49 We've had some new numbers that came in, which

0:58:52 adjusted the total taxable value.

0:58:55 And you'll see that reflected here.

0:58:57 I think if I'm correct, that preliminary number

0:59:01 and total taxable values, $2,278,878,114.

0:59:08 So that's the latest preliminary number,

0:59:11 and you'll see that reflected here in the tax rate,

0:59:13 the proposed tax rate of $76,600 per thousand, $77,2.

0:59:19 So that's kind of where we're at.

0:59:21 I'm hoping that Travis will explain in detail

0:59:24 the ramifications of that revision for you

0:59:26 as we move forward towards the adoption

0:59:29 of the tentative budget.

0:59:31 but it's important that you see that.

0:59:34 Tonight I really want to spend some time focusing

0:59:36 on the secure community.

0:59:39 And as we have in every focused area,

0:59:42 we presented the 2030 vision.

0:59:45 This is the vision that our community has

0:59:49 for what its secure community would look like in 2030.

0:59:53 And really what this is,

0:59:54 is this is our aspiration of what we want to become.

0:59:58 Our strategic plan states that the power of aspiration

1:00:02 drives positive vision.

1:00:05 On the other hand, fear underlies a negative vision

1:00:08 and has the potential to cloud that vision,

1:00:11 which I think is really interesting tonight

1:00:15 is that we're talking about public safety.

1:00:18 Specifically, we know that the fear of crime

1:00:22 or the fear of fire safety, even maybe the fear of lack

1:00:25 of quality life, is just as powerful as the actual events

1:00:29 themselves.

1:00:30 This is something I've spent my entire career looking at, right?

1:00:33 The fear of crime is just as powerful, just as effective as crime itself.

1:00:38 So I wanted to start a little bit with the vision.

1:00:40 There's the vision.

1:00:41 That's what we look like.

1:00:42 That's what we aspire to be in 23.

1:00:45 With that in mind, I want to take you to where we're at.

1:00:59 So here's where we're at.

1:01:00 And so this is the 2014 National Citizen Survey.

1:01:04 And I think this is important because when we're talking about budget,

1:01:07 And we're trying to build a connection between where we're at with our budget and how it relates to the strategic plan.

1:01:13 I wanted to go back to this. There's some numbers here that I think that we're not really happy with.

1:01:18 We know that we're doing a good job. We know we can do a better job.

1:01:21 And really the goal as we move forward is to address some of these concerns here.

1:01:26 There are some good points. I think 88% of the people feel safe in the neighborhood.

1:01:30 That's something that we're proud of and we want to continue to drive that number forward.

1:01:34 Our overall police rating is 69%, it's not really what we want to be.

1:01:40 And you can see here there's another area under prevention.

1:01:43 So our citizens, 53% of them were satisfied with our prevention efforts.

1:01:48 In police, 68% in fire.

1:01:50 And those are numbers that we want as we move forward to increase.

1:01:55 Code enforcement and animal control, what's interesting about here,

1:01:58 here are these numbers.

1:02:00 I was talking to Sean, and Sean takes code enforcement so seriously.

1:02:03 does such a good job, him and his team,

1:02:05 that this is not a number that he's happy with,

1:02:08 and we're not happy with, but I want you to know

1:02:10 that we're probably doing more in the area

1:02:12 of COVID enforcement and animal control than we ever have.

1:02:16 So we're looking at what these numbers mean

1:02:19 and how it relates to kind of where we're at,

1:02:21 and then obviously driving our budget forward.

1:02:25 So this is the survey we think

1:02:27 that it provides some great feedback for us

1:02:29 and it helps us when we sit down

1:02:30 to put together our budget.

1:02:34 So I want to start with Twin Falls Fire.

1:02:40 I want to start with Twin Falls Fire.

1:02:42 And one of the things that we're doing

1:02:43 is just giving you a quick snapshot of what

1:02:48 your fire department was doing last year

1:02:51 to give you an idea as we move forward

1:02:52 and the type of equipment and operations

1:02:55 that we're asking for.

1:02:56 So here's really, this is your fire department.

1:03:00 This is some of the metrics that they have.

1:03:02 This is the work that they did.

1:03:04 And I won't go into detail of all of this, but I think there are a couple of areas that

1:03:08 I would like to focus in tonight.

1:03:10 Really one of these areas, and obviously we know response time is a driver from fire service.

1:03:15 I would be more than happy to let Chief Clark talk about why that's important.

1:03:20 But probably so.

1:03:21 The thing that Chief Clark and I are talking about is a four minute 21 response time.

1:03:25 So what happens if that's a four minute 40 second response time and how does that impact

1:03:29 our future service?

1:03:30 Those are the things that we're looking at talking about.

1:03:32 The other area that I want to focus on is right here, you know, sometimes public safety is I call it

1:03:38 It's like a zero balance game. You'll always spend more money on public safety than you ever feel like you get back from it, right?

1:03:44 It's I think over the years. I think I've heard

1:03:49 Public safety referred to as a necessary you know you have to have it cost a lot of money. What do you what do you get for it?

1:03:55 Well, if you if you use the service or any service whether it's code enforcement, please or fire

1:04:00 You know, the value in that or you've picked up the phone in dial 9-1-1, you realize the value.

1:04:05 But specifically here, our fire department has saved $12 million worth of property this last year.

1:04:11 And that's total value. So if we take that $12 million and we zero down on homes and we're using the median home value,

1:04:20 our fire department has saved $4,350,600 worth of homes.

1:04:25 And this is what it looks like, right?

1:04:28 Of course, those homes, Chief Clark asked me a great question.

1:04:32 He said, each one of those homes, 144,000, probably not.

1:04:35 But the idea is to say that sometimes when you think about fire service and the service

1:04:40 that they provide, and in reality, they save 30 homes.

1:04:44 So just imagine if you didn't have 30 homes in your community.

1:04:48 Brian, could you explain that to us?

1:04:50 So they're going out on calls.

1:04:52 They're putting out fires before they go on and destroy whole businesses or homes.

1:04:57 That's what we're saying here, right?

1:04:58 That's exactly right.

1:04:59 And that doesn't, they're not factoring in maybe saving the house to the left or the right

1:05:05 of the residence.

1:05:06 It's on fire.

1:05:07 They're just factoring in fires that they've been involved in where they've stopped and

1:05:10 each.

1:05:11 So that number could be much higher than that.

1:05:13 But the reality is it's a pretty conservative figure and I think that's a real, it's a real

1:05:18 an example of what the fire department is doing.

1:05:24 So here in the main capital request, I don't think these are anything new.

1:05:28 are things that you have seen throughout the presentations. There's a fire rescue vehicle.

1:05:34 There's self-contained breathing apparatus. Great story here, right? If you've ever had

1:05:38 to use this equipment, you know how important it is. That's the difference between life

1:05:43 and death. There's EMS, EMT, transition at 17,000, and then the wrapper intervention team

1:05:49 packs. It's really the heart of Twin Falls Fire Capital Request. So let's just a brief overview

1:05:55 a little bit of fire service and where they're at in their request. Any questions for the

1:06:00 fire department? Well, we've got to get Chief Clark.

1:06:03 This is Anhock. I'll ask. Sorry. So, I'm just kind of curious, the EMS EMT transition. I

1:06:12 don't know if I've missed something, but I haven't really heard that explained. What

1:06:15 exactly are we doing and what does that mean? Chief Clark, would you mind coming up? I

1:06:19 I told you I'd get you up here.

1:06:21 I appreciate it, sir.

1:06:24 Be nice.

1:06:25 We know how close you are to retirement.

1:06:28 It may be tonight.

1:06:31 Mary Council, just a brief overview of this.

1:06:35 Here's the scoops, Suzanne.

1:06:37 Everyone in our Fair Department is an EMR,

1:06:40 which is an emergency medical responder level.

1:06:43 State certifications.

1:06:49 All of the governmental stuff that goes along with it.

1:06:52 We're in a position where we may as well bump it up to an EMT level because now we have

1:07:00 to bring in the structures.

1:07:01 We have to do modules to keep everyone certified and up this stuff.

1:07:06 So for 17,000 if you can bump it up to an EMT level, once you bump it to the EMT level

1:07:12 then you have all of that other stuff disappears.

1:07:15 All the modules, that kind of the little nuances that go along with it that we struggle with,

1:07:22 all the time throughout the year, this takes care of it.

1:07:25 So will they be offering a different level of service then?

1:07:29 Will they be more qualified to do things that we're not qualified to do now?

1:07:33 Actually, from a state level, they would prefer that we were EMTs.

1:07:37 Almost every department is an EMT level.

1:07:39 We're like a basic first responder level.

1:07:43 An EMT lets you do a little bit more stuff.

1:07:47 From the medical side overview of the EMS side, they're pretty particular about what you can

1:07:52 and cannot do for obvious reasons, liability issues, things like that, but so it would give

1:07:58 us not necessarily, we're not going to respond any faster, we're not going to really do some

1:08:04 things any better or more frequently, but it puts you at a level where you can, if you

1:08:09 need to, and believe it or not, sometimes we're the first ones on scenes, not all the time.

1:08:16 Sometimes we are, sometimes EMS, police, fire EMS work really well together, but they all

1:08:20 have different functions. So sometimes depending on the nature of the

1:08:24 incident, you can really utilize people with that level of training. Thank you.

1:08:29 Chief, do you think you'll ever get to the paramedic level, having one on each

1:08:34 engine? Is that something on the horizon? If you heard? Well, I can tell you

1:08:38 this, that would be a decision much above my pay level. But I can tell you,

1:08:47 You're in the full blown EMS business at that point.

1:08:51 And they're depending on which side of those fences you're on.

1:08:58 Do you do you do things like that or not?

1:09:00 Do you get that far into it?

1:09:02 Because if you do, it can be a real money loser.

1:09:06 I'm just wondering if that's going to be the next level

1:09:09 that the state puts out some day saying that every engine crew

1:09:12 has to have.

1:09:14 You see that?

1:09:15 I really wouldn't think so because of, you know, even departments that are, that are,

1:09:20 fire departments that run EMS out of their stations, that kind of thing, that have fire

1:09:24 paramedics, I don't see that happening here for years because of the separation between

1:09:30 Magic Valley EMS, those paramedics and us, you know, we work really well in conjunction

1:09:36 with them, but going to a paramedic level is a very expensive proposition, yes.

1:09:42 Mr. Stoneman has a question.

1:09:43 Chief, with three new schools going in,

1:09:45 I'm concerned that this is going to speed up

1:09:47 the necessity for us to reconfigure our station,

1:09:51 so for us response time.

1:09:54 What's the latest on that?

1:09:55 Are we pushing the boundaries and those are out of areas?

1:09:58 Yes.

1:10:01 And what we're waiting for anxiously, of course,

1:10:05 is the comp plan conclusion, where they're going to be

1:10:10 looking into this stuff and researching it.

1:10:13 And I really appreciate the effort to let that comp plan

1:10:20 drive this station location business

1:10:22 where they need to be, how many need,

1:10:24 all that kind of stuff as opposed to, for example,

1:10:27 me trying to out guess it.

1:10:29 So, but if you take things like Cliff Barch,

1:10:31 Chubani Hospital, future growth,

1:10:35 I mean we have three stations right down the center of town

1:10:38 and one at the airport.

1:10:39 So obviously at some point you're going to be affected.

1:10:43 It's just a matter of when and when it happens,

1:10:45 where are you going to locate those stations?

1:10:47 I was more concerned with the little people in the schools

1:10:50 than building, but there is a direct relationship though

1:10:54 to response time to people's insurance rates,

1:10:57 is there not?

1:10:59 Eventually?

1:11:00 Sure.

1:11:01 I'm not sure everybody's aware of that.

1:11:02 Yeah, if you're in the city limits,

1:11:04 all right, ISO rating is a three,

1:11:07 and we are a really solid three.

1:11:12 Every major fire department in the state of Idaho,

1:11:15 including Boise is a three, has an ISO rating of three.

1:11:19 So we are a solid three.

1:11:21 So that's not a problem.

1:11:22 You know, one of the other things that sometimes people forget

1:11:25 because you become so commonplace,

1:11:26 but you see fire trucks and things like that,

1:11:29 ambulance is going through.

1:11:30 We have what we call an Opticom,

1:11:32 and it changes the traffic lights

1:11:35 so that you can flow on through like that.

1:11:37 It makes a lot of difference with these response times.

1:11:39 And every light in the city is outfitted

1:11:45 with an Opticom unit when they put new ones in,

1:11:47 they automatically put the Opticom on them.

1:11:49 It makes a lot of difference.

1:11:51 Not just from in-town response times,

1:11:53 but for out in the district.

1:11:55 You can get out of town a lot quicker if you need to.

1:11:58 So the schools and the little people and all that,

1:12:01 the other thing to keep in mind is this,

1:12:03 from a safety standpoint, I mean,

1:12:05 the schools of today, they're built really

1:12:08 safety-conscious sprinkler systems,

1:12:11 all sorts of good stuff like that,

1:12:14 for that very reason.

1:12:15 And they run new safety drills.

1:12:17 They exit the building, and they practice all that kind of stuff.

1:12:20 So it makes a difference.

1:12:21 Travis, did you have something you wanted to add?

1:12:23 I'm sorry.

1:12:25 Well, just that plan is going to be available,

1:12:27 like the chief said, with the comp plan.

1:12:29 And we anticipate that being about a year process.

1:12:33 The council approved the additional scope

1:12:35 as part of the comp plan.

1:12:36 And so we're looking at what is the best way

1:12:38 to preserve that ISO rating of a three

1:12:41 as described by the chief.

1:12:42 Very good.

1:12:43 Thank you, Travis.

1:12:44 Thank you, Chief.

1:12:45 Mr. Pike?

1:12:52 I might just be a little too far.

1:12:54 OK, next I'd like to kind of go through a little bit

1:12:57 of the police department's budget,

1:12:58 share a little sum of the metrics that they're dealing with.

1:13:01 And I've included in the handout that you have,

1:13:04 it actually might say the top 10 types of calls,

1:13:07 but the reality is there's only seven, not 10.

1:13:09 So I just wanted to give you an idea.

1:13:11 This is what the police department is handling.

1:13:14 This is the top 10.

1:13:16 Well, what's visible is the top seven calls for service,

1:13:20 and it gives you an idea of the workload

1:13:23 at the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department

1:13:24 are conducting.

1:13:26 But this is another graph that I wanted you to see,

1:13:29 because one of the things that you're gonna hear a lot

1:13:31 about is crime rate, and we know that in the last 20 years,

1:13:35 our crime rate is down substantially, probably 37%.

1:13:40 And you'll see this is the five-year trend.

1:13:42 It's actually going down.

1:13:43 We had a little bummed last year in Group A crime.

1:13:45 The question is, well, what is group A crime?

1:13:47 A group A crime is actually the serious crimes.

1:13:51 And there's a whole list of them.

1:13:53 I brought it.

1:13:53 It's actually two sheets of robbery, homicide, murder.

1:13:58 There's some serious property crimes.

1:14:01 I'm going to give you an idea a little bit about things

1:14:03 that are happening in Twin Falls.

1:14:04 And all this is drawn from the state information.

1:14:08 Now, here's the interesting part.

1:14:11 And I know we've talked a little bit about this.

1:14:13 When we talk about group B crimes, one of the things that has come up is this idea of the

1:14:19 influx population, the non-residents activity, and how it impacts services.

1:14:24 I think I wanted to include this to give you an idea.

1:14:27 47% of the people listed at Twin Falls police report are non-residents.

1:14:32 46% of the people issued an infraction or a misdemeanor citation were non-resident.

1:14:37 30% of that group A crime arrest, not all total offenses, but group A arrest, we're non-residents

1:14:44 and 24% of group B arrest are non-residents.

1:14:48 So we're reaching a point now where we can start drilling down, getting data out of our

1:14:52 system that actually helps us support this idea of the influx population and how it impacts

1:14:58 our ability to deliver service.

1:15:01 One of the things about this is Twin Falls continues to grow.

1:15:04 I suppose you could look at it in several ways.

1:15:06 And I think in the past, we have looked at it maybe

1:15:10 through a lens that says that it's great that Twin Falls is

1:15:15 growing, but it's not fair that the residents of Twin Falls

1:15:17 actually pay for this, right?

1:15:19 Pay for the activity of non-residents.

1:15:21 But the reality is, as Twin Falls continues to grow,

1:15:24 one way or the other, the citizens of Twin Falls pay for it.

1:15:28 Because if we're not available to respond to them

1:15:30 when they fall because we're dealing with one of these

1:15:32 issues, they're not getting the service.

1:15:34 So, although I understand the mentality,

1:15:38 I also realized the reality of where we're at

1:15:40 is that Twin Falls continues to grow

1:15:42 and that service delivery is certainly part of it.

1:15:45 So here are the main, and like I said,

1:15:47 you probably have seen these a number of times.

1:15:50 Here are the main police capital request

1:15:53 and personnel request, five patrol vehicles,

1:15:57 body cameras.

1:16:00 This is phase two TASER replacement.

1:16:01 So last year we did phase one of our Taser replacement.

1:16:05 Taser is just one of those items that has a shelf life

1:16:08 and has to be updated.

1:16:10 The bomb squad sued $25,000.

1:16:12 That's a large capital item, but this is the first time

1:16:15 that the City of Twin Falls has actually had to make

1:16:18 a purchase for the bomb squad.

1:16:20 The majority of their equipment has been purchased

1:16:24 through grant funding that Staff Sergeant Dan Lewin

1:16:27 has secured for us.

1:16:28 And then two additional patrol officers

1:16:31 to help us meet those service delivery needs.

1:16:34 With that, any questions for police or chief rear?

1:16:39 We gotta get to bring chief rear up here too.

1:16:41 Any questions for the VHSE board?

1:16:44 You know, I don't see any lights, Chief.

1:16:50 I'm really apologize for that.

1:16:52 Maybe that's something to do with going through.

1:16:55 So many times, huh?

1:16:57 I think you can keep going.

1:17:01 I've got to head myself here a little bit.

1:17:03 I'm going to go back.

1:17:07 Presentation over.

1:17:09 OK, here we go.

1:17:10 I want to talk a little bit about code enforcement.

1:17:13 I'm amazed at the quality and quantity of work

1:17:16 our code enforcement team does.

1:17:18 Sean and his team performing just really an exceptional service.

1:17:21 And the one thing that I just want to brag a little bit,

1:17:24 the one thing I love about it is when they make contact

1:17:26 with the resident, it's never pleasant.

1:17:29 But when they knock on the door, they usually provide four

1:17:31 or five options for that resident.

1:17:33 It's not just about, here's your notice, picture problem.

1:17:36 It's, here's your, here's our concern, right?

1:17:39 And here are four or five options to help you mitigate that.

1:17:43 And even to a point sometimes where, you know,

1:17:45 we'll do some real creative stuff to make it happen.

1:17:49 Quality of life, it's one of those issues that I guess

1:17:51 my quality of life is different than your quality of life,

1:17:54 but when it comes to code enforcement,

1:17:57 you can really see the impact of what it's like

1:17:59 to have somebody that may live next to you,

1:18:01 that's not maintaining their property to I guess the level that we would want, right?

1:18:09 And whether it's like of this or it's the RV that sits out in front of the house or I can think of a million issues,

1:18:15 these are important issues and as you can see, it keeps our code enforcement team very busy.

1:18:23 Now these numbers, I want to say starting, this is the fiscal year right now.

1:18:26 So starting in October, up to July, the end of July,

1:18:31 and you can see predominantly where

1:18:33 their focus is water, weeds, and junk.

1:18:44 Our code enforcement team has really,

1:18:46 and Mitch talked about this last week,

1:18:48 they're asking for a full-size pickup truck.

1:18:50 Pickup truck they're using now is kind of a hand-me-down.

1:18:53 They've had it for almost over a decade.

1:18:57 It's really essential piece of equipment.

1:18:59 With that, any questions for code enforcement?

1:19:02 I do have a comment, you know, as a council member we hear quite often issues in the community

1:19:12 they contact us and say there's this R.B. parked out here, they're running this kind of business

1:19:17 and shouldn't be weeds, whatever.

1:19:20 And I just wanted to compliment you, Sean, that you're always, you and your team are always

1:19:26 Johnny on the spot to respond to those which gives us as council member an ability to respond

1:19:33 back to the citizens and let them know that it's their complaint is being taken seriously.

1:19:38 So thank you for doing that.

1:19:40 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:19:41 Thank you.

1:19:42 I just would like to take the opportunity to let the community know that along with Sean

1:19:47 and his team they have contacted our youth council who in situations where people really need

1:19:53 physical help cleaning up.

1:19:55 Our youth council will go out at no charge and help residents when they get into that situation.

1:20:01 And I know they get excited every time Sean sends them an email and says, hey, I have a

1:20:04 property for you.

1:20:06 And so it's been a really good team effort there as well.

1:20:09 Thank you, Suzanne.

1:20:11 Greg Whalley.

1:20:12 Well, much along the same line of the grad, thanks to Sean and the teammate.

1:20:18 I feel bad contact at him sometime because I know, especially after we've had a major

1:20:23 rain event, you know, about two weeks later, everybody's weeds are back up, but so you feel

1:20:27 bad about contacting him. I have certain ones, people who call me every time, and I know when

1:20:34 I get to the number of my phone, I'm like, well, I'm going to be shot in the email and

1:20:37 shot. So, but I do thank you for your, you almost always, well, all these, I want to put them

1:20:45 almost in a prompt attention to it. Sometimes the people take a little bit of a prodding,

1:20:53 but they usually get it cleaned up a certain way. The ones that always astound me, the ones

1:20:59 that are in the PI districts, where they're already paying for the water, and why not just

1:21:03 put in lawn and water? Because they're already paying for it at the PI district.

1:21:12 And lastly, in Focus Area 3 is a Twin Falls Communication Center.

1:21:17 And I thought this would be somewhat interesting.

1:21:20 There are a couple interesting numbers here,

1:21:22 obviously total inbound calls being over 100,000.

1:21:25 20,000 of those are 911 calls.

1:21:28 And 61% of those inbound calls are actually from landlines

1:21:32 would surprise me because I thought that would be much lower

1:21:35 and that our wireless users at 11% would be much higher.

1:21:39 So, you know, Lieutenant Statz and I have talked a little bit about this.

1:21:42 We'd like to go back and look at that five-year trend to see what that number looks like,

1:21:46 but something that we're fairly confident is that wireless calls will continue to grow

1:21:51 as we move forward.

1:21:52 In addition to handling all this, right, our dispatchers also have to respond

1:21:56 to almost a quarter million radio transmissions.

1:21:58 So these are transmissions that have to be answered.

1:22:02 In this year budget, the Capital Request for Communications really

1:22:05 this interrupted power supply for e9-1-1, Craig has, he's applying for a grant, so that's

1:22:14 a possibility, but we do have this money set aside just in case the grant does not come

1:22:18 through, we'll have money to purchase this. So any questions for communications? Any

1:22:23 questions?

1:22:24 Chris, talking.

1:22:26 I want to verify what I think we know is correct that the newest generations of cell

1:22:32 All phones all have an ability to be tracked to precise locations by assault hours now.

1:22:39 Is that correct?

1:22:42 We didn't get your appropriate.

1:22:44 And when you say precise, what limitations?

1:22:47 To direct an emergency crew too.

1:22:52 Yes, we are.

1:22:53 Our own county.

1:22:54 Our dispatch center is, it's called phase two compliance.

1:22:58 So any wireless phone call that comes into our center,

1:23:03 we would be able to find them or pinpoint them.

1:23:06 And that wasn't always the case in the earlier generation.

1:23:09 That's correct.

1:23:10 Exactly.

1:23:11 So precise, I don't mean down to the foot, but to locate them.

1:23:15 That's right.

1:23:16 And they keep trying to really minimize that area 50 meters,

1:23:24 something in that range, but they realize that they need to get that

1:23:28 down more precise and technologies are enabling that.

1:23:32 I keep losing my cell phone so I hope you could get it down a little closer so we can

1:23:36 find it.

1:23:39 So one of the things that we wanted to highlight is that we're talking about today where we're

1:23:49 talking about an isolated focus area and it's just dominated in some ways.

1:23:54 Now Mitch did talk about the planning position but this area is really dominated by police

1:23:59 fire and code enforcement. But I think what's really important, like all of our focus areas,

1:24:04 as we move forward, is that all of our focus areas are really tied together. Travis has

1:24:09 that beautiful chart of all the focus areas and how they tie back to the community. In

1:24:13 the same way, you know, really, our focus area ties right into healthy community. We

1:24:18 have the mental health issues. We have the drugs, the DUIs, the enforcement. We tie right

1:24:23 directly into the learning community, which I will go into in just a minute. We have great

1:24:28 relationship with the College of the 9-0 with a fantastic relationship with the

1:24:32 Twin Falls School District and we continue to build on those partnerships.

1:24:35 But there's also a tie to an accessible community as we move forward with bike trails

1:24:40 and what that looks like and how that impacts us and the environmental community

1:24:43 where we're code enforcement is directly impacted. So just real briefly I want to

1:24:49 focus jump over to a learning community and once again here's the 2030 vision this

1:24:54 This is our aspiration of what we'll look like in the future and what education and the learning

1:25:00 community really means.

1:25:02 And for this year, I've just highlighted some things.

1:25:04 We don't have, this is the one of the focus areas that does not really have a lot of activities.

1:25:08 But the truth of it is there's a tremendous amount of human capital that goes into this

1:25:13 area.

1:25:14 Like I said, with our relationship with the college, our continuing and ongoing relationship

1:25:17 with Twin Falls School District.

1:25:19 There are some things though, the library will have an upgrade, I believe that's a $12,000 upgrade

1:25:24 in the front entrance, we're going to continue to support a safe learning environment.

1:25:30 You know, you can't learn in an environment that you don't feel safe in, and we'll do that

1:25:35 through our relationship with the school district and school resource officers.

1:25:39 And then really continue to develop educational programs in the school that focus on drug

1:25:44 use, violence, bullying, fire, you know, safety.

1:25:48 Our fire department is in the schools talking about fire safety and fire prevention.

1:25:52 So we've got a lot going on, that's just kind of a little bit of a snapshot of focus

1:25:56 areas two and three, some of the things that we're doing, and how those tie directly back

1:26:01 to our strategic plan.

1:26:02 With that, I'd stand for any questions.

1:26:07 Do we have any questions for our Deputy City Manager, Mike?

1:26:09 Brian, I think you've done a fantastic job.

1:26:14 Thank you for your presentation, sir.

1:26:19 Council, it is 6.25, and my question to you is, would you like to take a three, four minute

1:26:24 break or do you want to forge along and and ahead keep going from what's going on

1:26:32 Oh I'm always good for going okay Chris talking to I'd just like to make a kind of a wrap up

1:26:38 statement on this budget I think you said six times we've met publicly in public format

1:26:45 so we met six consecutive weeks tonight is the seventh and prior to that we had five

1:26:51 other conversations and so in total when we get through this conversation we will have

1:26:55 met 13 times in an open session having a dialogue about the city's budget.

1:27:00 Well that speaks for itself. This is my 24th budget year and I'd say is probably among the

1:27:06 easiest the budgets that I recall. A lot of that has to do with the new growth that has

1:27:13 helped not making very hard decisions for all the other years on the prioritization of

1:27:20 new funds. The staff has just done an excellent job of laying out our priorities, how to accomplish

1:27:27 them both through the strategic plan and the 13 or 11 or is it 100 meetings? It doesn't

1:27:33 make any difference. Fact is that there is virtually no excuse for lack of public knowledge

1:27:38 or interest at this point. And third and kind of in summary, I'd just like to say that every

1:27:45 year. It seems like there's less public involvement at this level. It's something in the water.

1:27:54 It's actually something to help people receive their information. But the fact that we are at

1:27:59 this point with such a clear vision of where we want to go this next year, it just proves to me

1:28:05 once again that the city government has the confidence of the public and the city government works.

1:28:11 Thank you, Chris, with that, we're going to move to the next item on the agenda, which

1:28:17 is consideration of a request for the adoption of the tentative budget for the City of Twin

1:28:23 Falls and set August 24th, 2015 at 6 p.m. as the date and time for the public budget hearing.

1:28:32 And we have our city manager, Trevor Swethweiler.

1:28:34 Mr. Mayor, thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.

1:28:37 So tonight, again, is the first official action that you're going to be taking on the budget.

1:28:41 We've had lots of conversation and lots of build up to this point.

1:28:46 And tonight, we're not adopting the budget, but what we're asking you to do is buy in accordance

1:28:51 with the item of the vote, set the maximum spending level for this budget.

1:28:57 We take that maximum spending level and then we will publish that and we will also set

1:29:04 the public hearing as stated for 6 o'clock PM on August 24th.

1:29:11 really as a matter of recap and I did not

1:29:14 prepare a presentation tonight but just more of a matter of recap because of the

1:29:18 conversation. This budget, the total budget for the City of Twin Falls this year

1:29:23 will be $60 million, $765,948. That is an increase of $3,683,759

1:29:39 are roughly 6.45 percent. But what's important to recognize of that $3.6 million increase

1:29:48 is nearly $3.1 million is going to come from our cash reserves to help build the Will's

1:29:55 booster station, a project that we talked about during the conversation, and that Will's

1:30:00 booster station does more to assist in opening up additional grounds for additional home

1:30:06 sites within our community. This budget, as is illustrated up here, shows that the tax

1:30:15 rate is going to be similar next year as compared to the tax rate that is imposed for this fiscal

1:30:22 year. It also illustrates that the total cost to that average resident, that average resident

1:30:29 that we've described over the course of the last several weeks of having a home that is

1:30:34 in the neighborhood of about $144,000.

1:30:38 That consumes 18,000 gallons of water on a monthly basis.

1:30:41 That consumes the maximum cap of 8,000 gallons of sewer

1:30:45 and has curbside recycling.

1:30:47 We'll actually see a decrease in the cost of city government

1:30:51 by anywhere between 62 cents a month and 32 cents a month.

1:30:56 There's a couple of factors there.

1:30:59 Number one, the cost of doing business increased by 1.27%.

1:31:05 This is the second consecutive year that the City of Twin Falls has been able to put together a budget that has been under the municipal cost index inflationary index.

1:31:16 The second thing and something that we have not spoke a lot about is that individuals that are above the $144,000 home value will more than likely see a tax decrease in this upcoming year as a result of the larger increase in the home owners exemption.

1:31:34 is afforded to them. So for those houses that are able to take full advantage of the homeowner's

1:31:41 exemption because that grew more significant than the maximum increase we're seeing here,

1:31:48 all of those residents should enjoy a tax reduction from the city in comparison to the city services

1:31:55 and that assumes that values and everything else remained unchanged. Tonight is just the

1:32:02 the first step that you will take.

1:32:04 And after that conversation on August 24th,

1:32:08 we are going to ask you to adopt the budget that evening.

1:32:11 So for those members of our community

1:32:14 who have yet to come and participate,

1:32:17 but still feel that they want to, there's still time.

1:32:21 We will continue on having a conversation next week

1:32:24 about focus area number six,

1:32:26 and we'll do a recap of the budget.

1:32:29 And then we'll do a general recap on the evening

1:32:32 that we'll ask you to adopt the ordinance moving forward.

1:32:36 But that'll be happy to stand for any questions.

1:32:39 Council, maybe this time we'll go ahead

1:32:41 and open it up for public comments

1:32:44 and then get some direction, questions

1:32:48 for our city manager or any of the city staff.

1:32:50 So at this time, this is an opportunity.

1:32:53 Every time that we talk about the budget,

1:32:55 how many times?

1:32:56 10?

1:32:58 13 times that we've talked about budget every time that we've talked about it.

1:33:02 We always open it up to the public for their comments.

1:33:05 So this is your opportunity to engage your counsel regarding the tentative budget that

1:33:11 has been laid out.

1:33:12 So community, come forward.

1:33:19 If you would state your name and your address, Madam, that would be perfect.

1:33:24 Nikki Boyd, 878, Morning Sun Drive here in Twin Falls.

1:33:29 This has been an amazing opportunity to come.

1:33:31 I think I've been to all of them.

1:33:35 What an amazing opportunity.

1:33:37 And this is open to every single person in our community.

1:33:41 And for those, there's so many things to learn.

1:33:46 And this understanding how this works actually makes us

1:33:50 better citizens by partaking of this.

1:33:52 And I'm going to highly encourage,

1:33:54 tell people about this in the future,

1:33:56 because it's just something that's absolutely worth every time.

1:34:00 And it's also shows how hard you guys work and how hard everybody's working for our one

1:34:05 common goal, which is good for everybody.

1:34:08 So thank you for the opportunity to sit in on all of this.

1:34:13 Thank you, Mrs. Boyd.

1:34:14 Appreciate you coming forward.

1:34:16 Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?

1:34:19 All right.

1:34:20 If this time I'll turn it over to Council for questions and or direction.

1:34:24 Sean Berger.

1:34:27 I would move adoption of the tentative budget for the city of Twin Falls in the amount of

1:34:33 $60,765,948 and set August 24th at 6 p.m. as the date in time for the public budget hearing.

1:34:45 We have a motion on the floor as stated by Sean Berger and seconded by Chris Talkington.

1:34:53 Council have anything further on the motion.

1:34:58 I will just, and we'll probably say this several more times, we take this portion of

1:35:04 what we do on City Council extremely seriously.

1:35:07 This is our money, because it's our money too, we're taxpayers as well.

1:35:12 It's this community's money and we want to make sure that we spend it wisely.

1:35:17 And I just wanted to compliment you and your team so far.

1:35:20 It's been great.

1:35:21 We've got a couple more weeks.

1:35:24 It's been great.

1:35:25 It's been a great learning experience as well.

1:35:26 Thank you, Nikki, for sharing that.

1:35:28 that Sharon roll call vote please. Don Hall yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim Mun

1:35:37 yes Sean Berger yes Chris talking yes Greg Lanthine yes motion passes 6 to 0

1:35:46 next oh what one might or point of clarification this is the high water

1:35:52 mark for the budget but on the ad valorem amounts that can still be moved

1:35:58 within the budget, as I recall, can or not.

1:36:01 Yes.

1:36:02 Okay.

1:36:03 Thank you.

1:36:05 All right.

1:36:06 With that, the next item on the budget is on the agenda, okay, budget on my mind, is public

1:36:13 input.

1:36:14 This is another opportunity for the public to come forward and speak to your council regarding

1:36:19 any issues that you would like to.

1:36:24 Yes, ma'am.

1:36:25 If you would state your name and your address, please.

1:36:31 My name is Lebern.

1:36:32 I'm not a president of Twin Falls, but there are some things that are going on in Twin Falls

1:36:42 that affect all of us in the Magic Valley, which concerns me greatly, and therefore that's

1:36:48 the reason for my visit today.

1:36:52 We talked earlier about a secure community and public safety and lack of quality of life,

1:37:00 you're all very important. However, we have, as you are all aware, something that's going

1:37:07 to be happening to us in our area, it's not going to stop unless we all start to get involved.

1:37:14 And that is the refugee resettlement. I have been doing a lot of study. There's a lot

1:37:20 out there to learn, but this is an nefarious organization to try to ruin our communities

1:37:28 all across America. It also has to do with the United Nations with their ultimate goal

1:37:34 of making sure that every community in the United States has no more than 50% white people.

1:37:43 The nefarious actions of not only our administration and the United Nations trying to take control.

1:37:50 I'm not trying to scare people, but we do need to be aware of this and be sensitive to

1:37:57 to it and start planning for it, because these wonderful plans

1:38:01 that have been presented tonight for a beautiful downtown

1:38:04 community for all the services that are going to be

1:38:07 upgraded will not be a high priority if it gets out of hand.

1:38:12 These services, the refugees, are only

1:38:17 supported for 90 days by the federal government.

1:38:21 And after 90 days, it is our responsibility as taxpayers

1:38:26 in this valley to support them.

1:38:30 They have no desire based on the evidence

1:38:33 that I will present to you tonight.

1:38:35 No desire to integrate into our community.

1:38:38 They will be a community within a community

1:38:42 and have no concern or regard for our way of life

1:38:46 or our culture.

1:38:48 This is a very serious issue and I hope

1:38:50 that someone on this committee or someone

1:38:53 within City of Twin Falls takes it upon themselves

1:38:57 to become an expert and help educate everyone else.

1:39:01 I will continue to do my work the best I can,

1:39:04 but I'm just one lone person with the keyboard.

1:39:09 So if you allow, I would like to approach the bench

1:39:13 and present you with some evidence

1:39:15 as to what's really going on.

1:39:17 This is a story about what happened to another community

1:39:21 in the United States.

1:39:22 All you have to do is substitute the name that's on this document for Twin Falls and you can see our future.

1:39:30 I can take that please.

1:39:35 Thank you.

1:39:39 Thank you for your input.

1:39:40 Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address the city council?

1:39:46 We will move now to any other item from our city manager.

1:39:52 Mr. Mayor and members of the council just a couple of quick items.

1:39:56 First, this Wednesday, from five o'clock to eight o'clock,

1:39:59 we're going to have our second city fair.

1:40:01 The first event really provided us an opportunity to engage

1:40:05 and connect with the members of the community

1:40:06 about the different projects moving on.

1:40:09 We intend to do that again, again, this Wednesday.

1:40:12 And it's going to be located in the future side

1:40:14 of the new city hall building on the corner

1:40:16 of Main Street and Hanson Street.

1:40:18 And it's also going to be the opportunity

1:40:20 to participate in the summer concert series as well.

1:40:24 Who's the band?

1:40:28 I'm usually inside.

1:40:30 Josh, do you know who it is so that we can give them

1:40:33 some advertisement?

1:40:35 The signs on the new city hall look fine, by the way.

1:40:39 I'm glad it's the only thing I'm asking you to do.

1:40:42 It's called Dirty Rotties, but they're tank trans men.

1:40:45 One of the guys is actually on our streets crew.

1:40:47 Or water crews, excuse me.

1:40:48 OK, thank you very much, Josh.

1:40:50 And again, that's going to go from 5 o'clock to 8 o'clock.

1:40:53 It's a second opportunity for members of our community

1:40:55 to participate in what they would like the future city hall exterior of the building and

1:41:00 the flow of the building to look like so we'd encourage participation.

1:41:03 We'll also have representatives to talk about the downtown project, the Canyon Springs Road

1:41:08 Project, the Comp Plan Project.

1:41:11 Again, police are also going to have a presence there as well as many other departments.

1:41:17 So just a really good opportunity for members of the city team to connect with its residents.

1:41:22 The second is on Thursday evening at Candy King Park, or Cascade Park.

1:41:27 We're going to have the annual city employee and family picnic.

1:41:31 We would encourage you to come.

1:41:32 It's a great opportunity to fellowship with the hard-working men and women of our organization,

1:41:38 the ones who really do deliver that public service to our citizens.

1:41:43 And then as a matter of looking at your future calendars and so that you can have an opportunity

1:41:50 need to prepare what some of the future meetings look like as you're aware, we try to budget

1:41:55 time in each of the council meetings and right now we're going to the end of the calendar

1:42:01 year right now.

1:42:03 And it appears that on the 31st of this month, August 30, which is the 5th meeting, assuming

1:42:12 that you adopt the budget, there will not be a need for the council meeting that evening.

1:42:17 The second meeting that we will throw out there as a potential cancellation date is 928.

1:42:23 That is some time out there.

1:42:25 But as we engage the members of the council about who's going to be in town, it appears

1:42:30 that there are going to be several members out of town on that date on 928.

1:42:37 And in addition to that, both Mitch, Brian, and I, all three of us will also be out of

1:42:43 town at the annual International City Manager's Conference.

1:42:47 Is that a holiday or something?

1:42:49 It is not.

1:42:50 It sticks and death leper.

1:42:53 I didn't get invited.

1:42:54 I was.

1:42:58 Yeah, it was enough.

1:43:02 I want to apologize.

1:43:03 I'm not going to be able to make it on Wednesday night.

1:43:05 I didn't want to miss one, but I already have a prior engagement.

1:43:08 So the last one, the last city fair, was phenomenal.

1:43:11 Good job.

1:43:11 Good job.

1:43:13 Anything else? Okay, turn it over to City Council, Suzanne Hawkins.

1:43:18 I'm going to call Josh back up to help with this one.

1:43:20 I believe we have a big event Friday out of the airport.

1:43:24 Thank you.

1:43:28 So we were contacted by the 124th Fighter Wing

1:43:34 to do an aircraft dedication of the A-10,

1:43:37 something of my favorite aircraft.

1:43:39 So of the A-10 C, so they're going to fly in two of them.

1:43:43 They have nose art that's dedicated both to the,

1:43:45 that will dedicate both the city of Twin Falls

1:43:47 and the city of Jerome, because of resources

1:43:49 we kind of have to compile all together.

1:43:51 And it's really to recognize those communities

1:43:56 who support their veterans, past and current,

1:44:00 who have served their countries and their communities,

1:44:02 whether it be in the National Guard

1:44:04 or in the full-time armed services.

1:44:06 So we really encourage all of our citizens

1:44:09 to come out if they can make it.

1:44:10 It's a great photo op, and you can get up close

1:44:12 and personal with one of those eight tens.

1:44:15 And we have a couple very brief speeches.

1:44:18 But they're Dunhall and Colver, Bob Colver,

1:44:23 who is the president of the Jerome City Council.

1:44:26 I think that's the title.

1:44:27 Excuse me if I missed the.

1:44:28 That's correct.

1:44:29 So that'll start.

1:44:32 1130.

1:44:33 Yeah, 1130 AM on Friday.

1:44:36 And we're asking people to just kind of congregate

1:44:38 at the readers' flying service at their lobby.

1:44:41 And then we'll kind of escort people out

1:44:43 when their aircraft's arrived.

1:44:44 And we all care rides in the A10 too, I think.

1:44:47 So I asked that, but how do you start a little bit of a hula?

1:44:51 Be a little uncomfortable to ride on the pilot's lap.

1:44:55 I don't know if this is a dental look at that.

1:44:57 Some of us would still do that.

1:44:59 Greg Lanning, Josh, and also my favorite aircraft.

1:45:02 And of course, everybody who loves them calls them

1:45:05 by the warthogs.

1:45:05 That's right.

1:45:07 Most survival bar aircraft in the world.

1:45:11 Thank you, Josh.

1:45:12 Thanks, Josh.

1:45:13 Anything else from City Council?

1:45:15 Greg Lanning.

1:45:15 I just want to mention that Urban Renewal had a little ceremony down at the park across from

1:45:22 Columbia Foods headquarters to reveal the sign that they'd already been named that they

1:45:30 named it before they gave it to us, but it's a Dennis Boyer park with the new sign that's

1:45:34 there, and one of the unique things was he asked for it to be six foot six tall, and that's

1:45:38 how tall the sign is, because that's how tall Dennis is.

1:45:43 can't miss the name on it either. It's definitely Dennis Boyer Park. Very nice

1:45:48 ceremony. Thank you for sharing that. Anything else from City Council? Excellent.

1:45:52 We are now in jail. Good job. Those eight tens will be around.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 10, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:46:08.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7e4b0c9ee789d07a3b6e213b7e56266b0e67def8bd9621d694cb5449e81eb9b6
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 076aa79846caf0390a6065d1c39db83ef8a3746333112eeeec9847c034bb240e
    part02.m4a 678c10463d58fdbff53c21406b9c1b8f85c936a37e17b2fe2bd8a8bcd9d71b3c
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    70df9a3b1e7eaa3c0020aa782d99060d3f7b25448a5abe524ed4e45e3d726321

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file