City Council meeting
Monday, March 16, 2015
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on fileExecutive session: a
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:01:01 Jim
0:01:06 Jim yeah, I'm right here Jim Jim Jim
0:01:17 Hello Jim. Can you hear me? I can we can barely hear you. How's this any better? He must be on mute. I'm thinking you might be on mute
0:01:34 Are really?
0:01:38 Okay, I hear you very very well. I just
0:01:46 You apparently had problems hearing me
0:01:48 Jim I can barely hear you. We haven't started the meeting yet
0:01:52 Okay, well I had my mouth right up against the phone. I guess we'll be okay, right?
0:02:07 I know you're there, Jim.
0:02:08 Okay.
0:02:12 Wait, if you give me some direction Travis gives me direction.
0:02:28 It's not verbatim. I said close to verbatim, which isn't verbatim. I just like to incorporate what you have to say in there.
0:02:40 But I do recall when you said, you know, when I vote no to put your comments in there and I do that for everybody.
0:02:46 And so I, you know, any direction, and it's not the bottom.
0:02:51 Yeah.
0:02:52 Are you sure?
0:02:53 Yeah.
0:03:43 Thanks for the other.
0:04:03 How do you know they didn't just want to come to the meetings?
0:04:07 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.
0:05:30 It's March 30th, 2015.
0:05:32 And we traditionally start our meetings with the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:05:35 And I see that we have our youth council here, so we were wondering if the youth council wouldn't mind coming forward and leading us in the pledge for the rest of us if we could rise.
0:05:43 if we could rise, please.
0:05:57 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:06:09 If it's a boy scout or a girl scout,
0:06:10 we usually make you introduce yourselves
0:06:12 and do the whole what badge you're working on,
0:06:14 but I think you have a presentation
0:06:16 in a few minutes anyway, right?
0:06:18 So we'll call you up then.
0:06:19 Thank you.
0:06:23 We do have a quorum of the City Council,
0:06:25 six members are present in body and one on blind.
0:06:28 Jim, are you there?
0:06:34 Jim, are you there?
0:06:35 Yes, I am.
0:06:36 Okay, very good.
0:06:37 So all seven members are here.
0:06:40 First thing I want to ask is from our city manager,
0:06:43 do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
0:06:46 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:06:47 we have no amendments this evening.
0:06:49 Very good.
0:06:50 We do have two proclamations.
0:06:51 I have the privilege of reading.
0:06:52 The first one being organ, eye and tissue donation month
0:06:57 is Stephanie Buckley here.
0:06:59 Okay, I'll call you up and just minute, I'll read it.
0:07:02 I'll bring it down to you and then if you would say a few words, Stephanie, that'd be great.
0:07:06 Proclamation from the City of Twin Falls.
0:07:09 Oregon Eye and Tissue Donation Month, whereas spring is a season of promise and renewal,
0:07:15 and nothing could be more fitting during this time than to reflect on the abundant miracles
0:07:20 of life and growth.
0:07:22 Oregon and Tissue Donation presents an opportunity to share in these miracles.
0:07:27 technology has made it possible for thousands of Americans to benefit from
0:07:32 organ and tissue transplantation. Sometimes this means restored vision or
0:07:39 help for severe burns, sometimes a heart, liver, or bone marrow transplant, and
0:07:45 whereas more and more Americans are aware of organ and tissue donation, thanks to
0:07:52 the widespread education about this worthy cause. And whereas, it is each family, American
0:07:59 family, and each citizen that makes organ and tissue donation work, the generosity of organ
0:08:05 and tissue donation can save nine lives and improve over 50 lives. And whereas, there
0:08:11 is still a critical need. Over 123,000 people are on the national waiting list, locally,
0:08:19 700 people wait. About 18, nationally, about 18 people die every day while waiting.
0:08:26 Another name is added to the National Waiting List every 12 minutes. Please mark
0:08:32 yes on your driver's license and tell your family to do as well. And whereas
0:08:38 April is National Donate Life Month, a month dedicated to educating people about
0:08:44 about the need for a donation.
0:08:47 Now therefore, I don't haul, Mayor of Twin Falls, Idaho do hereby declare the month of
0:08:53 April as Organ Eye and Tissue Donation Month in Twin Falls, Idaho and recognize the efforts
0:09:00 and involvement of the Yes, Idaho Coalition and our many families and encourage all the
0:09:07 citizens of Twin Falls to participate in this program by registering on the Idaho donor registry.
0:09:14 I've witnessed this along with Leila Sanchez, our deputy city clerk, and Stephanie, if you come forward.
0:09:39 That's how the cameras are.
0:09:41 Thank you.
0:09:41 This is not in my job description when I first got this job.
0:09:44 So I haven't speaking to middle school children all day about the importance of organ,
0:09:51 eye and tissue donations.
0:09:52 So my voice is a little sore as well.
0:09:54 Yeah, in Idaho, we have about 65% of our licensed drivers are registered to be donors,
0:10:02 which really is an impressive number.
0:10:05 But there is still a need to raise awareness.
0:10:07 There's a lot of myths and things out there
0:10:09 about the organ donation that we're trying to just raise
0:10:13 awareness about.
0:10:14 So I just encourage the citizens at Twin Falls to go to yesidaho.org
0:10:19 this month to maybe answer the questions
0:10:22 that you might have about organ donation
0:10:24 and to talk to your families and with your friends
0:10:26 about the importance of donation.
0:10:28 I had invited, I don't see him here,
0:10:31 invited a local citizen Mike Park who owns a funeral home here in town about
0:10:35 seven years ago. He received the gift of a liver transplant. He was a recipient of
0:10:41 a liver and since that time he's been able to continue to run his business and
0:10:46 spend time with his family. So he's one person in our community that's been
0:10:50 affected by organ donations. So again I encourage you to just think about that
0:10:54 more and to go to yesidaho.org. Thank you. Thank you Stephanie. We also have another
0:11:00 proclamation and fair housing month proclamation I will be handing this to
0:11:04 Mandy Thompson maybe not I'll be handling it to our city manager fair housing
0:11:12 month proclamation whereas April 2015 marks the 47th anniversary of the passage
0:11:18 of title eight of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 commonly known as the Federal
0:11:24 Fair Housing Act, and whereas the Idaho Human Rights Commission Act has prohibited discrimination
0:11:32 in housing since 1969, and whereas equal opportunity for all, regardless of race, color,
0:11:39 religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin is a fundamental goal of
0:11:47 our nation, state and city, and whereas equal access to housing is an important component
0:11:53 of this goal as fundamental as the right to equal education and employment, and whereas
0:12:00 housing is a critical component of family and community health and stability, and whereas
0:12:06 housing choice impacts our children's access to education, our ability to seek and retain
0:12:11 employment options, the cultural benefits we enjoy, the extent of our exposure to crime
0:12:17 and drugs, and the quality of health care we receive in emergencies, and whereas the laws
0:12:24 of this nation and our state seek to ensure such equality of choice for all transactions
0:12:30 involving housing, and whereas ongoing education outreach and monitoring are key to raising
0:12:37 awareness of fair housing principles, practices, rights, and responsibilities, and whereas
0:12:43 only through continued cooperation, commitment, and support of all item funds can barriers to
0:12:50 fair housing be removed. Now, therefore, I don hall mayor of the city of Twin Falls do hereby
0:12:55 proclaim April 2015 to be fair housing month in the city of Twin Falls, state of Idaho. I have
0:13:03 signed this as well as Lee Isla. So I'll hand this to you afterwards, Travis. Is there anything that you
0:13:08 you need to add, Mitch Humble, our Deputy City Manager.
0:13:12 This is going to be a little bit impromptu,
0:13:15 but this is a declaration we do each year.
0:13:19 For fair housing, it's an important topic for us as a city,
0:13:24 particularly as we expand our job base,
0:13:29 and then we're having to find housing
0:13:31 for a lot of more worker-type folks.
0:13:34 And fair housing is an important aspect of that.
0:13:36 And from the city standpoint, it's also
0:13:39 extremely important for us to do this all the time because it keeps the compliance with various laws and
0:13:43 and the requirements out there for the federal government so that we can continue to receive
0:13:47 grant money and so we're just happy to
0:13:51 happy to keep doing it. Thank you, Manch. I appreciate your
0:13:55 presentation. We will now move to the general public
0:13:59 input. If there's anyone here from the public that would like to address the city council,
0:14:03 this is your time to come to the podium. I see no one running
0:14:10 towards the podium, but I do see a light on from Councilman Lanting.
0:14:14 If you have a point of personal, I can't find my package package.
0:14:18 Could you send me another packet via the agenda? Thank you.
0:14:23 All right. I see no one coming forward, so we will move on
0:14:27 to the next item, which is the consent calendar.
0:14:31 So I will turn that over to Council for their direction.
0:14:35 Suzanne Hopkins. I move approval of the consent calendar as printed.
0:14:40 Second.
0:14:43 I have motion on the board by Suzanne Hopkins, seconded by Sean Verger to approve the consent
0:14:49 calendar as printed.
0:14:51 Anything further on that motion, Council?
0:14:54 Chris talking to.
0:14:55 I would like to make a couple references to our minutes and our financial payables since
0:15:01 that's a large part of our job as Council people.
0:15:04 I'm making reference now to the March 9 meeting minutes of the Council item 1.6.
0:15:11 was dealing with a particular subdivision and its lack of enforcement of conditions and restrictive
0:15:20 cabinet CC&Rs. And I just wanted to reiterate if I had contact with a person or two since
0:15:26 that meeting that it is the developer, not the builder within a homeowners association
0:15:32 that's responsible for enforcement. The second point I'd like to make mention to make people
0:15:40 aware of how money is being spent locally for the benefit of taxpayers.
0:15:47 Durkys like stairs I see looks like it's underway or nearly done for 155,000.
0:15:52 I've forgotten how expensive it was.
0:15:55 That pales however, in comparison to the $2.2 million on our wastewater treatment plant.
0:16:02 And I'm assuming that's still pretty much under budget and on schedule or under and under on both of them.
0:16:10 We have Troy B. Tech in the audience shaking his head in the affirmative and
0:16:14 is that good?
0:16:16 And then just before we take a vote, I would like Melinda to give us an update on Cliff
0:16:20 for some time tonight, particularly the storm water and the canal lateral, if you know the
0:16:27 status of that completion time, appreciate that.
0:16:31 So maybe you can do that during your report this evening.
0:16:34 Thank you Melinda.
0:16:35 Thank you.
0:16:36 That's it, Chris.
0:16:37 Is there anything further on the motion council?
0:16:40 the aye that will call vote please.
0:16:42 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:16:43 Yes.
0:16:44 Jim Munn.
0:16:45 Yes.
0:16:47 Sean Berriger.
0:16:48 Yes.
0:16:48 Chris Talkington.
0:16:49 Yes.
0:16:50 Greg Lanting.
0:16:51 Yes.
0:16:51 Don Hall.
0:16:52 Yes.
0:16:53 Rebecca Milseica.
0:16:54 Yes.
0:16:55 Motion passes.
0:16:56 Seven to zero.
0:16:58 We are now moving on to items for consideration.
0:17:00 I just want to let the audience know as well as council
0:17:02 that we are going to do a little bit of shifting here.
0:17:05 I'm going to be moving item number six up to number two.
0:17:09 There's some scheduling conflicts that the presenter has that I want to make sure she's
0:17:15 able to get out to.
0:17:16 But we will start under number one is request a reappoint Calvin Palmer as a continuing board
0:17:23 member for the Twin Falls Housing Authority and we have Penny Earl in the audience.
0:17:33 Was that Penny Earl that ran out?
0:17:41 Well, maybe we will move on to item number two,
0:17:45 which is now the old item number six.
0:17:48 We will move to the update on the main
0:17:51 Avenue redesign progress by Mandy Roberts from OTAC.
0:17:56 Welcome, Mandy and Melinda.
0:17:58 Thank you, Mayor and Council.
0:18:00 As you all know, this is Mandy Roberts from OTAC.
0:18:02 She is a principal with the company,
0:18:04 as well as the project manager for our project.
0:18:08 I just want to give a quick introduction to you regarding her presentation tonight.
0:18:15 As you know, sometime in the future you as the City Council will be accepting all the
0:18:21 various improvements that the Urban Renewal Agency will be constructing for this main avenue
0:18:27 project.
0:18:28 So having your review of and buy in as we move through the process is going to be really
0:18:34 important.
0:18:35 So this is one of the first times where we've really been able to talk to you about actual
0:18:42 design work that's going on.
0:18:43 We've made some decisions about infrastructure, but now we're moving on to the above ground
0:18:50 piece, but Mandy's going to focus a lot of her time on during her presentation.
0:18:54 So Mandy, thank you.
0:18:55 Thank you, Melinda, and welcome, Mandy.
0:18:58 Thank you.
0:18:59 It's a pleasure to be here this evening, and I appreciate the schedule shift.
0:19:02 meeting with representatives from each block while I'm here this week and we
0:19:07 have a meeting this evening at 6.30 to meet with folks from Fairfield to
0:19:12 Gooding. So thank you for bumping me up on the schedule. I wanted to first of all
0:19:19 just give you an update on some of the design concepts that have been developed
0:19:24 to date and that we presented in February and some public and stakeholder
0:19:30 workshops, and then also give you a summary of some of the things that we heard as a result
0:19:34 of those presentations, and following that, there are some key topics that we have been
0:19:42 working with, the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency Board on, in that they have as a board
0:19:49 reached consensus about those topics.
0:19:51 So we want to make sure that Council is up to date with those topics as well, and then
0:19:57 all close with just a review on schedule and next steps in our process.
0:20:03 So when we were here last month, we had sickle their meetings during the course of a week
0:20:09 and then we had a big public workshop at the ballroom on a Thursday evening and had real
0:20:16 good attendance and engagement.
0:20:19 And we presented a number of different concepts for really organizing the street improvements
0:20:24 on Main Avenue, everything from looking at parallel parking on both sides to angled parking
0:20:34 on one side, parallel on the other, and with each of these, a different framework of dimensions
0:20:42 results in what's left for sidewalk space and sidewalk cafes and all of that.
0:20:49 we presented these ideas to the attendees and participants
0:20:53 in our meeting.
0:20:55 Also, each one results in a different quantity of parking
0:20:59 per block.
0:21:00 So it was good for people to understand
0:21:02 how much parking we have today versus what parking would
0:21:06 be yielded by the different design concepts.
0:21:09 One of the ones that we heard a lot of interest in
0:21:13 was this one called the meandering street alignment, which
0:21:18 basically has a mid block crossing at the mid point of each block and alternating with
0:21:25 angled parking on one side, parallel parking on the other side. And folks commented positively
0:21:31 a lot on this design. A lot of folks liked having the meander to the street as a traffic
0:21:36 calming element in Main Avenue. Also, as opposed to having angled parking on both sides
0:21:45 for the entire link. This allows us to have a little bit more space for sidewalks and sidewalk
0:21:50 cafes. That said, we've been talking block by block with different groups and there's
0:21:58 still the potential to have angled parking on both sides and some blocks, especially when
0:22:02 there's a need for that amount of parking. So we can really apply these concepts flexibly
0:22:09 throughout the entire distance from Fairfield to Jerome
0:22:13 and reach a favorable solution working block by block
0:22:18 with different representatives.
0:22:21 So this is just kind of a sketch of what the straight alignment
0:22:26 looks like as well as a straight-on view just
0:22:31 to give people more of a sense of the human scale
0:22:34 of the improvements.
0:22:35 And of course we would be talking
0:22:37 about new street furnishings and street trees and landscaping, as you see here, and we've
0:22:44 started to float some ideas out there about what those might look like as well.
0:22:49 And we heard a lot of positive remarks and support for going with a prime bridge theme.
0:22:58 So continuing with the bench that we have in a lot of areas of town, including out at
0:23:03 the new visitor center and
0:23:06 Mandy, I think we might have a question.
0:23:08 Oh, sure.
0:23:09 Oh, thank you.
0:23:10 Yeah.
0:23:11 Just a quick question on how you might apply the concept of when you would put an angle
0:23:15 parking versus when you would put in the parallel parking.
0:23:18 Is that something you would consult with the merchants about or look at kind of the demand
0:23:23 in front of certain storefronts or how would you determine that?
0:23:28 Yes, that's really going to be an outcome of the meetings that we're having this week.
0:23:33 We have got those same options at the table when we're meeting block by block with different
0:23:40 property owners and merchants and getting their input on what they would like to see.
0:23:45 So we have two meetings per day to accommodate different schedules.
0:23:50 And in addition to that, since I'm here all week, I've also scheduled meetings with folks
0:23:54 that couldn't attend those meetings.
0:23:56 And if for some reason we have no shows, I'm knocking on doors.
0:24:01 So we really want to go around to each property and kind of get input on their block and what
0:24:06 they would like to see, not only on the parking, but also where would you like to see information
0:24:12 kiosks on your block?
0:24:13 What are some opportunities for landscaping that you see?
0:24:16 So kind of that real detailed input is where we are now at the stage of our process.
0:24:22 Thank you.
0:24:23 Okay.
0:24:24 So getting back to furnishings then, there's been a lot of interest in using the prime
0:24:30 bridge as a theme. A lot of folks have said they really like how this represents an iconic
0:24:38 element of Twin Falls, but also it's somewhat understated and doesn't draw your attention away
0:24:44 from just the beauty of the architecture and other elements of main avenue. And so here
0:24:49 we've started to look at how you might adapt that design for different sizes of benches and
0:24:55 chairs and trash receptacles and even with the light, you know, an arch element that you
0:25:01 could use for signing or to hang flowering baskets from. Here's another example just showing
0:25:10 how we might be able to work with light fixtures to have banners and flower baskets and use that
0:25:18 arch concept there. Another item or element that a lot of folks
0:25:25 really like the idea is an arch gateway. A little bit more complicated in terms of a design
0:25:32 process, but when we ask people where they would like to see something like this, a lot
0:25:38 of folks said, on Shoshone, coming into downtown in the vicinity of 2nd Avenue, north. Is that
0:25:46 North or West, I get confused, sorry.
0:25:48 But it's North and West.
0:25:51 It's North and West.
0:25:52 It's North and West.
0:25:53 It's North and West.
0:25:54 Which way are you coming?
0:25:55 I'm coming from Blue Lakes.
0:25:56 It's actually North and East.
0:25:57 Okay, thank you.
0:25:58 And South and West.
0:25:59 Right, that's right.
0:26:00 Okay, so this is an example of course from Kansas City, but you can envision that you might
0:26:05 be able to take again that prime bridge architecture and replicate elements of that in an arch like
0:26:12 this.
0:26:13 And of course we would need to design it so high enough
0:26:16 for truck clearance and all of that,
0:26:17 but could be really an exciting way
0:26:19 to announce main avenue in downtown.
0:26:23 And there might be other elements
0:26:25 at some of the five corners or gateways to downtown
0:26:29 that could also be incorporated
0:26:31 to really build more of a sense of arrival
0:26:34 and identity to downtown.
0:26:37 And of course, people also would like to have
0:26:40 a little bit more attention to information,
0:26:43 maps, kiosks. We do have some kiosks down on May now, but they're dated and it's time
0:26:48 to really look at a new updated solution. So again, those could have an architectural
0:26:54 look that is similar to the prime bridge as well. Part of our work has looked at the downtown
0:27:02 Commons project, which previously had been proposed in the location where the fountain
0:27:09 is now on Hanson. And with the purchase by the agency of the
0:27:16 Rogerson site, there's an opportunity to move the downtown
0:27:19 commons to that site. And we've looked at some different
0:27:23 configurations of how you might have a splash play area, a
0:27:27 concert space, restrooms, and other features in that plaza. And
0:27:34 of the different concepts that we've floated during the
0:27:37 workshops, people tended to really like this one for its symmetry and just in
0:27:44 terms of usability of the concert space which is down at the kind of eastern end.
0:27:49 You could have concert space in combination with a building that could
0:27:55 have restrooms and storage and you could have chairs and tables and things stored
0:28:00 in that building as well. So a lot of folks really warmed to this idea which
0:28:06 which we're now further exploring in our design process.
0:28:09 Of course, right across the way is the Future City Hall Building, so a great companion for
0:28:16 downtown commons.
0:28:17 We've also, and I believe I've presented this in the past at council, but we've talked
0:28:23 a lot about some areas of the streetscape being raised and curbless.
0:28:29 We've been calling that festival streets, and those are areas that you could, would be
0:28:35 open to traffic on a normal day, but during an event or festival could be closed to traffic.
0:28:41 And the reason for making them curbless is that then it's just a wide open accessible
0:28:47 area that people can walk across really easily and it feels very pedestrian friendly and accessible.
0:28:54 So just showing some different examples, this one's from Mercer Island, Washington of how
0:28:59 that looks and works for parallel parking.
0:29:04 You can see sometimes ballers and paving colors are used to delineate the street space.
0:29:11 This is an example in Portland, Director Park, and over on the left-hand side is a raised
0:29:18 street that is also functions as part of a plaza.
0:29:22 So the plaza just gets that much bigger when that street is closed and used as a festival
0:29:27 street.
0:29:29 This is one that's in design in Seattle that we're designing, and it's sort of a combination
0:29:34 of a raised intersection and a more typical
0:29:39 curb and gutter section of street that can be closed,
0:29:42 the whole area can be closed off for events.
0:29:46 And this is one you probably have seen in Boise,
0:29:48 8th Street, been there for a long time,
0:29:51 so it's not necessarily a new concept,
0:29:53 but something that people have adapted
0:29:56 in a lot of different ways in their city,
0:29:58 including even the basketball in Boise as well,
0:30:02 where they've got colored paving, and it's pretty much all
0:30:06 at one level, slightly recessed.
0:30:09 This is what the side looks like with unit pavers.
0:30:12 And then, of course, when they have festivals,
0:30:14 they close the street.
0:30:16 And other places, this isn't Moscow,
0:30:19 but it kind of looks like Moscow, Idaho,
0:30:21 and what they do during their farmer's market,
0:30:23 where they just close the street and have tents
0:30:25 aligning either side.
0:30:27 So we're starting to really think about how
0:30:29 to integrate these ideas into the design and working with staff on different design
0:30:35 treatments and dimensions.
0:30:38 So we, you know, we heard in addition to the things I already mentioned, people really liked
0:30:44 the idea of the meandering street.
0:30:47 They liked having the mid-block crossings, which we have on a lot of blocks today, and
0:30:50 they want to see those on all five blocks.
0:30:54 Those were generally fine with angled parking, a parallel parking, alternating, but some would
0:31:00 like to have angled parking on both sides where we have it today.
0:31:04 We have been talking about back-end angled parking or reverse angled parking.
0:31:10 And overall, I would say from all the folks that we've talked to, people understand the
0:31:16 safety and visibility benefits with providing that orientation of parking.
0:31:21 There are some folks that have concerns, whether people would be able to get used to that and
0:31:27 how folks would feel about that downtown.
0:31:30 A lot of downtowns are implementing this.
0:31:34 And one of the things that we're suggesting is some kind of a demonstration event where
0:31:38 we stripe an area and people come and try it and see what it's like.
0:31:42 And that might help people understand the benefits a little bit better if they use it.
0:31:47 So something to think about for upcoming events.
0:31:51 really like the idea of festival streets integrating those into some areas. I'll show you a graphic
0:31:57 in a minute about where we've been thinking about doing that next to the plaza.
0:32:03 Prine bridge furnishings. I mentioned that already. Lighting is an interesting topic.
0:32:09 A lot of folks really like the existing lamp posts that we have downtown, even the color
0:32:15 and the historic look of those. One of the technical issues that we've been evaluating
0:32:20 is that they are not super efficient with how they cast light down on the sidewalk.
0:32:26 And so they also have some structural challenges in terms of if we wanted to add hanging baskets
0:32:35 and banners that they may not have the structural strength to be able to do that.
0:32:39 So we are going to be looking at the potential to replace those with something that's very
0:32:43 similar, but more efficient with lighting.
0:32:46 So stay tuned on that.
0:32:48 I think I covered all those points as well.
0:32:52 The four key items that the Urban Renewal Agency Board has reached consensus on to date include
0:33:02 replacing the utilities in the alleyways.
0:33:06 You'll recall that there have been some earlier conversations about whether or not we should
0:33:09 move some of the utilities such as water to Maine Avenue.
0:33:14 And we went through a very thorough evaluation process and looked at that.
0:33:19 The board did with city staff and decided that the best approach would be to keep all
0:33:26 of the utilities in the alleyways, which then avoids that necessity for individual properties
0:33:32 to have to reconnect to water, which would have been a real challenge and extensive process.
0:33:39 So that's one of the key decisions that's been made today.
0:33:42 Another one is moving downtown commons to the Rogersons site.
0:33:47 And then with that, the ability to open up Handsons Street then for multi-modal access.
0:33:54 Today it's closed.
0:33:55 If we open it to bikes, pedestrians, vehicles, it just gives us that much more access to
0:34:03 Main Avenue, which is great in terms of activity and economic vitality.
0:34:08 We have heard, though, that people don't want it to become a fast street, so making sure
0:34:13 it's a green street with traffic calming and really pedestrian and bicycle friendly is
0:34:18 part of the design.
0:34:20 And then in terms of parking quantity, we've talked about that here in Council in the past,
0:34:26 and the analysis that showed that, overall, downtown, we have a lot of parking capacity
0:34:33 on a typical day.
0:34:35 And with that information out there, folks feel pretty comfortable about keeping the
0:34:41 same amount of parking that we have on Main Avenue.
0:34:44 And if there's an opportunity to add some more spaces here and there, they would like
0:34:48 to see that and the board agrees with that.
0:34:50 So those are the key items.
0:34:53 So we've been focused in this area for study, looking at the alleyways for improvement,
0:35:01 And then Main Avenue, we're starting to look at different construction staging options.
0:35:07 And when we've talked about doing the alleyway construction first and then doing Main Avenue,
0:35:14 a lot of folks like that approach, because you can imagine that people could then park
0:35:18 in the back and access back doors and have, you know, all of that really complicated
0:35:25 utilities work out of the way first, which is nice to do.
0:35:31 at different corridors as part of the project and improvements to those corridors and looking
0:35:39 at where we might have festival streets on main avenue, we've in that blue area in conjunction
0:35:47 with the downtown common site, we're starting to look at how festival streets could be integrated
0:35:53 with the plaza in that area.
0:35:57 to give you a sense, here's a graphic of what the section from Shoshone to Hanson looks
0:36:04 like today and over on the right-hand side is where that existing plaza is.
0:36:10 So in our design concepts, what we're looking at then is, of course, removing the buildings
0:36:16 that are at the Rogerson site today and that becomes a plaza space which is actually much
0:36:20 bigger than what the Downtown Commons Project was before, which is great, gives us more
0:36:25 space for concerts and things like that, and then opening up hands and all the way.
0:36:31 And it just so happens that the street extension aligns perfectly with an access way that's
0:36:38 already in that parking area, so we won't have to lose parking spaces with that extension,
0:36:43 which is great.
0:36:46 So I think that covers my presentation for the most part, happy to answer any questions,
0:36:52 to sum up in terms of our schedule, we are on schedule to complete the preliminary design
0:36:58 work by the end of May, and then the project then would move forward into final design
0:37:04 and development of construction documents with the hope that construction would start early
0:37:09 next year.
0:37:10 Thank you, Mandy.
0:37:11 We have several lights on.
0:37:13 Great lighting.
0:37:14 First off, Mandy, I believe in some of the times they've talked about whatever the schedule
0:37:19 of doing the alleys first and that would be an opportunity for all the businesses to take
0:37:25 that time to maybe refresh their rear entrances because whenever Main Street gets closed down,
0:37:30 that's going to be their best access for their customers and so if they have a chance
0:37:34 to make those rear entrances a little more attractive and things on that line, maybe
0:37:39 that's something that we've talked about, I want to make sure that was brought up.
0:37:42 And then on the reverse angle parking, you know, that's one of the things I've been pushing
0:37:46 for all along here and I think it would be just for the safety reasons and I also think
0:37:51 it gives us an opportunity to work possibly with the state that maybe we don't need the
0:37:57 two one-way seconds don't need three lanes and if we could get them to agree to two lanes
0:38:02 and then we could have reverse angle parking on the side towards main street of both of
0:38:08 those streets at some point in the future we would actually be adding considerable amount
0:38:12 parking to downtown in that one move that's a leak that those short half walks to
0:38:17 to Main Street. So this is a thought process. I know the state and believe it's
0:38:23 one of the eastern Idaho resort cities there is a state highway and they do it
0:38:27 they have a loud reverse angle parking on that state highway in order that because
0:38:33 it's so much safer and that's the only thing that they will allow as far as
0:38:36 angle parking on the state highway is reverse angle to the safety. Thank you
0:38:41 Well, visuals are really important in this process, and I have a couple of pictures that
0:38:47 I'd like to present, Mandy, that hopefully will make their way into your presentations
0:38:51 and eventually back to Travis and City Hall.
0:38:55 This is a picture, compliments the Blit printers, Bel-Necals, about 1948.
0:39:02 I think it's all of our aspirations that sometime we'll see this again, minus the fedoras, but
0:39:07 a lot of people walking on Main Street. This is looking toward the east, and some of the
0:39:13 businesses are still in business. But that shows old-time Twin Falls. The next photo
0:39:20 was taken about 1966 or 7 right after the original urban renewal. This was looking the
0:39:28 office away toward the west. The figure must have been taken on a Sunday or morning or
0:39:34 something like this. The first photo, I think, was a
0:39:37 vis-vis photo. This one, he died in 54, so this was in the
0:39:42 late 60s. Shows our new city hall and everything. But a
0:39:46 little bit of archival visuals for you. So let me give them to
0:39:50 you here.
0:39:52 Thanks, Chris.
0:39:53 And thanks to Bill Nichols at Blip.
0:39:56 Thank you, Chris. Rebecca Mills, so I can
0:40:00 Thank you, Mayor. I'm just a couple of questions on the
0:40:03 the downtown common site.
0:40:04 I know at the public meeting they presented a concept of possibly an ice skating rink, so
0:40:10 I was wondering if that remained part of the plan and who was maybe slated to take care of
0:40:17 that?
0:40:18 Was that going to be a private or a public enterprise and who would maintain and install and run that
0:40:26 ice skating rink?
0:40:28 So our concept for that to date has been as a portable ice skating rink that gets installed
0:40:39 or erected each holiday season for two or three months, similar to what they have at
0:40:45 the village at Meridian, that new shopping center there, they have a small portable ice
0:40:51 skating rink.
0:40:53 And what we've done in the design process is to ensure that there could be enough space
0:40:59 to install something like that in terms of who would actually purchase or rent that and
0:41:10 run it, that's yet to be determined.
0:41:12 So we think it's a great idea and it's a great way to bring winter customers downtown
0:41:18 and to offer something year-round seasonal downtown.
0:41:22 I think in terms of making it a permanent ice skating rink with plumbing that has to be
0:41:29 flushed out and could have a lot of maintenance issues, we thought a better approach would
0:41:35 be to look at that portable type of system and that might be more sustainable over time.
0:41:41 So that's the direction things have been going, we're happy to entertain other thoughts or
0:41:46 ideas on that.
0:41:47 Yeah.
0:41:48 I just wanted to be careful.
0:41:49 A lot of the comments from the public were positive on it, but my only concern is that we
0:41:53 not present an idea to the public that can't be funded or we don't have a private partner
0:42:00 who wants to do that.
0:42:02 You know, we've got to make sure we make plans that are doable.
0:42:06 But my other concern, I mean, it would help with bringing people in seasonally, I mean,
0:42:11 three months, three, four months out of the year.
0:42:14 the commons is heavily utilized.
0:42:16 There's a lot of people on a weekly basis downtown,
0:42:19 and so I understand that.
0:42:21 But how would you prevent it from just becoming
0:42:25 an empty space throughout the rest of the year?
0:42:27 I mean, the two thirds, the majority of the year,
0:42:30 it's gonna be not very great weather for outdoor events.
0:42:36 One concept that I heard from someone was to have
0:42:39 like a row of small shops or something
0:42:41 that the URA could rent out at an affordable cost
0:42:46 to kind of bring some sort of commerce,
0:42:48 some sort of business that would actually bring the people
0:42:51 because my concern is just having a big empty open space.
0:42:56 Doesn't mean that people are gonna come use it.
0:42:58 And it's right there on second.
0:43:00 So how are you going to design maybe a protective buffer
0:43:05 between this crowd gathering space
0:43:07 where you want children playing and you want families,
0:43:10 But then you have a parking lot and a highway right there next to it.
0:43:15 So I'm kind of afraid of opening that up and not having the proper feel for a gathering space
0:43:23 as it's right there on second.
0:43:25 Yeah, and I appreciate the comments.
0:43:28 I wanted to bring this graphic back up because I think that can help answer some of the questions.
0:43:35 So we have looked at the intimacy of a public space is really important and one of the concerns
0:43:43 that we had early on was just that when you look to, I guess that would be kind of a northerly
0:43:49 direction, that area is just parking.
0:43:53 And so when you look out that space like you're saying, it feels like it's not really contained
0:43:58 and it's kind of open to parking.
0:44:00 So that's why in this concept we've drawn a building there.
0:44:04 And that building is conceptual at this point, but it could be like you're talking about,
0:44:10 it could be a place where the ice gates are rented.
0:44:13 It could be places for vendors to sell hot chocolate.
0:44:18 It could, you know, obviously could have restrooms and kind of permanent storage space as well.
0:44:22 But we think having some kind of a structure there on that side is really important and
0:44:27 would help to not only contain this space, but could activate it if it had some uses
0:44:31 like that with vendors that could be in those spaces.
0:44:36 In terms of kind of the flexibility of the space and your question related to if you
0:44:42 had that ice skating place, how would it be used throughout the year.
0:44:47 So what we're showing is the idea of flexible use throughout the seasons and that star circle
0:44:54 is where the splash pad would be.
0:44:58 And then what you would do is turn that off during the winter.
0:45:02 And then you could, as long as it's designed,
0:45:05 everything's at grade, you could put a portable ice
0:45:07 getting rink right over the top of that.
0:45:10 So of course, in the winter, that's
0:45:12 where the ice getting rink would be,
0:45:13 but in the summer that would go away.
0:45:15 And then in terms of just concerts and seating space,
0:45:20 We've heard that typically about 300 people will sit and watch the concert series, but
0:45:28 another thousand or so might be milling around and kind of shopping or strolling.
0:45:34 So what we try to do is design a space where you could fit about 300 chairs, but also it
0:45:40 could expand and if you turned off the splash pad, you could expand it and have more chairs
0:45:46 floating out towards main avenue.
0:45:48 And if main avenue is at grade as a festival street
0:45:51 and closed off, you can have even more space out there.
0:45:55 So we're trying to think about how the design could work
0:45:58 flexibly for different types of events.
0:46:01 It's not a really big open space.
0:46:04 It might seem like that when you look at the graphic.
0:46:07 But it's really compared to some of the other public plazas
0:46:11 in downtown, which sometimes are even half a block
0:46:14 a full block. This is a pretty small public space comparatively. So I think
0:46:21 we'll have to worry about it feeling too empty, but at the same time it does need
0:46:25 to be activated and contained and well-designed for flexibility. Thank you. And
0:46:31 then just lastly I have a question on there's a clock I'm not sure what what
0:46:35 street it's on but it's over by the school district offices. What's happening with
0:46:40 that clock? I think it's important that we maintain some of the historic
0:46:44 elements of Main Street and so I just wondered if you will be keeping that.
0:46:48 Yes, Pastor Bear Morton with the Magic Valley Bible Church I think is his church is right
0:46:54 next to that clock and he talked with us about that and he actually really appreciates that
0:47:02 space there as a place where people congregate before church and having the clock there is
0:47:07 nice.
0:47:08 Unfortunately it's not operating right now so we do want to retain it but ideally it would
0:47:12 be great to see if we could get it fixed so it works. So that's the plan. Okay so it would
0:47:19 it would remain in that location and be put back if it's moved. Exactly. Okay. Thank you.
0:47:24 Great. Good question Rebecca and some thoughts I've had as well. One of the things I see as
0:47:32 possibilities here and I think I brought up one of the ureibil that existing building
0:47:36 that you show there just to the northwest of the proposed plaza. I think you may see if
0:47:43 somebody with the entrepreneurial school we've seen in other places might decide to open up
0:47:48 doors out into the plaza and maybe that could become a set of one business could become like
0:47:54 three businesses with a sidewalk cafe on the corner and things on that one that will also
0:47:59 help to prolong the life and the use of the plaza. And then this next one will be a little
0:48:05 tongue-in-cheek that the operation of the ice rink would be a little bit of
0:48:14 great project for the Twin Falls BID that says that doesn't exist, that's not
0:48:18 going to happen. No longer exists I should say. Before I make any comments, Jim, do you
0:48:25 have any comments you'd like to make? No, fine. Thank you. One thing I wanted to
0:48:31 say, I want to reiterate what Greg said about the back-end parking. I've been
0:48:35 of that sense I've experienced it and I believe that Idahoans can figure it out.
0:48:41 I think that it's a safer way of parking specially and congested where kids around and sidewalk
0:48:50 areas and public are.
0:48:51 So I'm a proponent of that.
0:48:53 My question for you, Mandy, is the lighting that we're contemplating here, we want to architecturally
0:49:00 and visually pleasing, but what about the technology of it
0:49:04 being downward facing instead of light pollution
0:49:07 that a lot of folks are concerned with today?
0:49:09 Yes, and that's exactly the issue with the fixtures
0:49:13 that are there today, although they have been retrofitted
0:49:16 with LED, which is a very energy efficient type of fixture,
0:49:21 just because of the design, the light tends to flow outward
0:49:26 instead of downward.
0:49:27 So we're going to be looking at, even with those lantern style
0:49:32 fixtures, there are some that are designed
0:49:34 so that they direct light downward.
0:49:37 So we're going to be looking at how to find,
0:49:40 how to have a picture that's very similar architecturally,
0:49:43 but has light pointing downward.
0:49:45 And usually there's kind of an internal shield
0:49:48 or something that helps to focus light downward
0:49:50 and also the bulbs point downward more than the ones
0:49:54 in these lamps.
0:49:57 Also with the LED, I know that there is at least some folks out there that have real concerns with LED and the brightness and the actual type of lighting that it is with melatonin and all that stuff.
0:50:11 I'm not sure you've looked into that at all.
0:50:14 You know, I think that's a really good point and the best lamps that I've seen really do a good job of kind of filtering that brightness.
0:50:24 And it might be that once we find some options that we can bring some examples in for demonstration
0:50:30 It might be good for folks to look at those. Yeah, perfect
0:50:33 That's all I have a
0:50:35 Council anyone else have a question or comment?
0:50:39 Thank you. Yeah, Mandy. Thank you for making the presentation. I'm Linda. Thank you for your part as well
0:50:46 Safe travels to the rest of your events this week
0:50:50 We're going to be moving on to the next item and that is the request to
0:50:54 to confirm the appointments of the Mayor of Colby Ricks,
0:50:58 Scott McClure, and Sean Noots to the Building
0:51:02 Department Advisory Committee.
0:51:04 I just wanted to let council know that there
0:51:07 are nine voting members of the Building Advisory Committee
0:51:11 and three of which their terms came up in February.
0:51:16 All three still have the ability to be reappointed.
0:51:20 One chose not to be reappointed.
0:51:23 The other two chose to be reappointed and those two members are Scott McClure and Sean News.
0:51:32 The other gentleman or the other position was an architectural professional position
0:51:38 and we had a gentleman that actually applied and several of us got together, interviewed
0:51:44 him and I've conferred with our council liaison throughout this process, Sean
0:51:52 Barreger and as well as Jared Boardy who's here to answer any questions this
0:51:57 evening. Mr. Ricks is Colby Ricks is the gentleman, the
0:52:03 architectural professional that would like to be appointed with the other two
0:52:07 being reappointed. So I turn it over to council for their direction on these
0:52:12 appointments. Rebecca Mills-Soy. Thank you Mayor. So how did we engage the public?
0:52:18 Did we put a call out for applicants or tell them about the positions and how?
0:52:23 Yeah I think that's a really good question. We discussed that Rebecca
0:52:26 because these are such specialty positions in our in our community. I'm
0:52:32 gonna ask Jared to come up forward and maybe explain that to us a little bit
0:52:36 further how these are positions on this committee and they have to be within
0:52:41 in these disciplines and how we did reach out to the public.
0:52:44 So we had the each members in our city code,
0:52:47 you have to meet the specifications for each member.
0:52:50 The one that stepped down was Blauger-Loflin,
0:52:52 the architectural seat.
0:52:55 And I called a bunch of architects within town.
0:52:58 There's not a lot local that we have,
0:52:59 and the ones that contacted they weren't interested in applying
0:53:03 for the position.
0:53:04 So when we got Colby, he was more than interested.
0:53:07 So that's how we reached out to the people in our community.
0:53:10 and he was the one that showed the most interest, sure.
0:53:14 Okay, so you just reached out to architectural firms
0:53:16 and he was one of those that you reached out to.
0:53:19 Right.
0:53:20 He's actually worked with Roger,
0:53:21 the one that's set down from the current seat,
0:53:23 so he was somewhat familiar with the process and how it worked.
0:53:28 Great.
0:53:28 And did we post this on our city website
0:53:30 and just inform, hey, we're in need
0:53:33 of an architectural volunteer?
0:53:36 We did post on the website.
0:53:37 What happened was the expire in February,
0:53:40 So we're kind of in need to get the seats filled for our next advisory board meeting.
0:53:44 So I just started to found the phone and trying to get people.
0:53:47 Sure.
0:53:48 Well, I understand that it's specialized and we're looking for architectural positions.
0:53:53 So but just to make sure that we hit everybody, we make sure everybody knows that it's open
0:53:59 maybe next time we can also post it on our website and just say, we're looking for this.
0:54:03 This is a specialized position, but how do we make sure we try to reach everyone?
0:54:07 I think you guys did a good job, that'd be great.
0:54:13 Any further questions regarding these appointments?
0:54:15 Confirming my appointments here.
0:54:17 Sean Berger.
0:54:20 I would make a motion to confirm the appointments
0:54:23 of Colby Ricks, Scott McClure, and Sean Newtz
0:54:26 to the Board and Department Advisory Committee.
0:54:29 Second.
0:54:30 Motion on board by Sean Berger,
0:54:32 seconded by Chris Talkington as stated.
0:54:35 Anything further on that motion council?
0:54:39 the aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye aye
0:55:10 About a year now, I grew up in Southeastern Idaho on a farm, and when I went to University
0:55:19 of Idaho and graduated there in the architecture school, and I ended up in Central Washington.
0:55:26 The economy was a little slow when I graduated, and I ended up in Central Washington in Yakima,
0:55:33 and I was in Yakima for 11 years.
0:55:37 I ended up coming down here during spring break and I just wanted to come back to Idaho and
0:55:43 I happened to run into Roger Loughlin who was planning on retiring in August and I got
0:55:49 him to hold out for a little while longer to help introduce me to a lot of the people
0:55:55 that he's worked with and so probably the end of this year Roger will be fully retiring.
0:56:01 So I'm just very excited to be here and get more involved in the community.
0:56:10 Well, Colby, we just wanted to say thank you for stepping forward and serving on this committee.
0:56:13 We truly treasure folks that do this for us because we need your input.
0:56:19 So thank you and I, when you said something about U of I, I heard a go-vam.
0:56:24 Go-vam.
0:56:25 Go-vam.
0:56:26 Go-vam, go-vam.
0:56:27 Go-vam, go-vam.
0:56:28 Good job, obviously.
0:56:29 Thank you.
0:56:30 Yeah.
0:56:31 on the agenda is request away by non-conforming building expansion permit
0:56:36 process to Chris Benford for a home located at 728 Locust Street and we
0:56:43 have Jonathan Spenlove and I believe Chris might be here this evening as
0:56:46 well welcome Jonathan thank you mayor members of the council this is located
0:56:54 you said 728 Locust Street what happened was we got a building permit for from the
0:57:01 applicant to expand an existing residential home. So what they have here is an old entrance
0:57:09 here on the home. So this is Locust Street towards the left of the screen. Do we have
0:57:15 a pointer down there? He could utilize. So we got a building permit for this gentleman
0:57:30 to expand. So this is the old entrance way. It was basically just your drop step cement.
0:57:36 He wanted to expand into it and have a better porch.
0:57:40 The house, the pink line is the center line setback.
0:57:48 Center line setback is an engineering thing
0:57:50 for expanded roadways.
0:57:52 Locust Street being a major collector,
0:57:54 has a 62 foot center line setback.
0:57:57 So the house, it's approximately three feet
0:57:59 into that center line setback.
0:58:01 So if we go back to this, the existing home
0:58:08 is within that center line setback by just that three feet.
0:58:11 This will be an expansion of that nonconforming house
0:58:16 because he's going to put a roof over it.
0:58:19 So it makes it part of the actual building.
0:58:22 If we're simply a patio, it wouldn't be part of the building.
0:58:25 So the expansion really is this section,
0:58:28 it's 84 square feet.
0:58:30 What we're asking for is that waiver in city code 1034
0:58:35 talks about the requirements of this section,
0:58:37 which is a nonconforming building expansion permit.
0:58:40 may be waived for residences and residential uses
0:58:43 by motion in a minute entry of the city council.
0:58:45 If the council wishes, it may waive the requirements
0:58:47 as section 1034, the applicant would continue
0:58:50 through the building permit process.
0:58:52 This will allow Mr. Binford to proceed
0:58:54 with the addition without a public hearing.
0:58:56 If the council feels that Mr. Binford should go
0:58:58 through the nonconforming building expansion permit process,
0:59:01 which is a public hearing process
0:59:03 with the Planning and Zoning Commission,
0:59:05 the application will be required
0:59:07 and a public hearing shall be held before that commission.
0:59:10 It extends the process by 30 to 45 days and then an appeal period thereafter.
0:59:14 So, in conclusion, staff recommends accounts review and act on the attached request to waive
0:59:21 the nonconforming building expansion permit process for a home located at 728 Locust Street.
0:59:27 I'll stand for questions.
0:59:28 Very good.
0:59:29 Any questions?
0:59:30 Chris talking to.
0:59:31 I would so move.
0:59:32 So, I get a motion on the floor by Chris talking to the executive by Greg Lanting to improve
0:59:38 the non-conforming building smash and permit located at 728 Locust Street anything
0:59:45 further on that motion council.
0:59:47 We have a roll call vote please.
0:59:50 Sean Burger.
0:59:51 Yes.
0:59:52 Chris Talkington.
0:59:53 Yes.
0:59:54 Greg Lanting.
0:59:55 Yes.
0:59:56 Don Hall.
0:59:57 Yes.
0:59:58 Rebecca Masleka.
0:59:59 Yes.
1:00:00 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:00:01 Yes.
1:00:02 Jim Munn.
1:00:03 Yes.
1:00:05 Motion passes 7-0.
1:00:06 Thank you.
1:00:07 Where did you go?
1:00:08 I'm trying to get some John already.
1:00:09 On the agenda is request to approve a resolution to destroy semi-permanent and temporary records.
1:00:15 We have Sharon Bryant with us and if we choose to do this tonight, Council, the resolution
1:00:19 number will be 1943.
1:00:22 Welcome Sharon.
1:00:23 Good evening.
1:00:26 State code 50-907 requires that any government entity that would like to destroy semi-permanent
1:00:38 temporary records, has a process they go through.
1:00:42 We have to get the Idaho Historical Archivists
1:00:47 to review our resolution.
1:00:51 And if there's anything that they feel is of historic value,
1:00:56 then we would have to keep those.
1:01:01 I have gone through that process with them,
1:01:04 and they have not found any of the records listed
1:01:07 on a resolution to be of historic value.
1:01:10 So we are okay that way.
1:01:14 Our city attorney is the person that needs to review this
1:01:19 and he has given his review an okay to destroy these records.
1:01:24 So the last step is to have council approve the resolution
1:01:31 and once that's approved, I will call up a certified
1:01:39 records, destruction company, and have them shredded the document shredded.
1:01:49 We have a couple of lights on and great landing.
1:01:53 Sharon, we had a AIC board meeting here recently where there was a lot of conversation about
1:01:59 apparently a lot of cities have been sending records to Boise and now Boise say it to the
1:02:03 state and the state say, hey, if we no longer want them, you have to take them and it was
1:02:07 a big deal to some of the Treasury Valley cities.
1:02:10 We have not been in that category as you explained to me via e-mail at that time that
1:02:14 board meeting.
1:02:15 We've been keeping all of our permanent records ourselves and not relying on the state for
1:02:21 storage.
1:02:22 Is that true?
1:02:23 That's correct.
1:02:24 I want to check to make sure we're there.
1:02:26 These are not the same records, these are so much better.
1:02:28 These are semi-permanent and temporary records.
1:02:31 Thank you.
1:02:33 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:02:34 Thank you.
1:02:35 Just a clarification, in the state code it says that semi-permanent records will be kept
1:02:42 for not less than five years, but some of the things you have listed under semi-permanent
1:02:47 records are only two and three years old.
1:02:51 Bob, those are temporary records.
1:02:55 So it's just the way the report was written?
1:02:57 Yeah.
1:02:58 Okay.
1:02:59 Because I just found that a little confusing.
1:03:01 Thank you.
1:03:02 Rebecca, Melsoika.
1:03:03 Thank you, Mayor.
1:03:04 So this is just the destruction of the paper copy.
1:03:09 Do you keep a digital copy on hand?
1:03:11 Some of the records that will be destroyed, these are records that we won't keep.
1:03:21 They are either like the financials are logged into our general ledger and those are kept.
1:03:30 So there are temporary records that we don't have any use for anymore.
1:03:35 So I mean we won't keep them, we won't keep copies of any of these records, they will be
1:03:42 destroyed.
1:03:43 Okay, and even like people's personal, like for example the personnel files up to 2001,
1:03:49 is that something you keep a digital copy if someone's still an employee or these would
1:03:55 be people that are not employed with the city any longer.
1:03:58 Okay.
1:03:59 Great.
1:04:00 Thank you.
1:04:05 Chris Houghington.
1:04:06 Has to be a small tree of paper and all those records sharing this really off the wall.
1:04:11 But would you see if they're recycled, all that shredded paper, email me or do you know?
1:04:17 We have to have them destroyed.
1:04:23 There's certain criteria to destroy records and we choose to have them shredded.
1:04:30 And the company that I believe that we use, I believe they do recycle all of that because it is a recycling company.
1:04:40 It'll be a big volume.
1:04:43 Good luck, me know.
1:04:43 If you could check on that.
1:04:45 Appreciate it.
1:04:45 Thank you.
1:04:47 You know, Sharon, the personnel files, those things, we don't, we don't keep those for.
1:04:53 There are personnel files that are permanent records.
1:05:00 These are not.
1:05:01 What's the difference?
1:05:02 Give me an example so I understand a little bit better.
1:05:07 Well, a permanent record would be.
1:05:17 architect drawings, maybe, building the permanent drawings.
1:05:20 Those are the, yeah, those aren't river destroyed.
1:05:31 What's difference, Fritz?
1:05:33 The legislature has told us exactly which records are permanent, semi-permanent, and temporary,
1:05:40 and they're all listed in the statute.
1:05:43 You can see them there.
1:05:44 But they list out specifically what kind of records fall in which categories.
1:05:49 And we've adopted the same categories as the state has done.
1:05:54 Okay.
1:05:58 Okay.
1:05:59 I'll look for a motion from council.
1:06:02 Greg Lanning.
1:06:03 Move approval of resolution 1943.
1:06:07 Second.
1:06:08 Motion on 4 by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the resolution as stated.
1:06:14 Anything further council?
1:06:17 The aye will vote please.
1:06:19 Chris Chalkington.
1:06:20 Yes.
1:06:21 Greg Lanning.
1:06:22 Yes.
1:06:23 Rebecca Milsoyka.
1:06:24 Yes.
1:06:25 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:06:26 Yes.
1:06:27 Jim Munn.
1:06:28 Yes.
1:06:29 Sean Berger.
1:06:30 Yes.
1:06:31 Motion passes seven to zero.
1:06:32 Thank you Sharon.
1:06:33 Disappear on me real quick.
1:06:37 Next item on the agenda is a request to approve the Twin Falls City Youth Councils.
1:06:41 Take a stand with your local police officer concept.
1:06:45 We have Jonathan Ruff coming forward.
1:06:48 Jonah.
1:06:49 I'm sorry.
1:06:52 Jonah.
1:06:53 Your new name is Jonathan.
1:06:54 Welcome.
1:06:56 Thank you. I am the president of the Twin Falls City Youth Council. I first like to thank
1:07:03 Mr. Hicks for his enthusiasm and immense support for this campaign. The Youth Council
1:07:09 has decided to start the Take-A-Stand with the local officer campaign in order
1:07:13 to help the community to take a correct stand with our officers. So not as much
1:07:17 locally, I believe many people in our nation have wrong ideas and emotions about
1:07:22 officers. I think it is necessary for a community to have a good relationship with
1:07:27 its law enforcement to help with this team. We can't pay attention to just that. We want the citizens in our community to take selfies with the officers when they have the opportunity but only at appropriate times.
1:07:37 We would encourage that the selfies taken be published to media sources and tagged
1:07:42 with several hashtags that we have made available. Times News will allow the selfies to be sent in to magicvalley.com
1:07:49 And they would be judged and nominated to photo would be published either weekly or monthly.
1:07:55 And then the winning photo would have the name of that officer next to the selfie.
1:08:01 If this plan seems feasible or is accepted, the Council wants to take a group photo with Council and then Mr. Higgs and all of us together this evening.
1:08:08 And the youth times will look into a bill board to kick out this campaign with that photo.
1:08:16 If we do that, we have to, what do you call it when you put some photoshopped Jim Munspace?
1:08:22 I'm sorry.
1:08:23 Okay.
1:08:24 Okay.
1:08:25 Council have any questions or comments?
1:08:28 Suzanne?
1:08:29 Thank you.
1:08:30 Hi, Jonah.
1:08:31 How are you?
1:08:32 Good.
1:08:33 So with the Council's approval, are you still planning on forwarding this idea to other youth
1:08:39 councils through the state of Idaho and seeing if we can take it out of the local area and
1:08:44 expand it across the state?
1:08:46 Yes.
1:08:47 We all need this to be, I don't know how long it would take, but we hope it be a statewide.
1:08:52 I don't know how long it would take, but we hope it be a statewide.
1:08:55 Thank you.
1:08:56 Jonah, if you don't mind, I'd like to ask Captain Hicks a question if he would come forward.
1:09:02 So, Captain, I know that you've worked through this through the department, but I know sometimes some officers are a little camera shy.
1:09:12 How is this going to be portrayed or seen by them?
1:09:17 by now. It's completely voluntary. The officers have initially been told and
1:09:21 they've been told in the future that we're strongly supporting the program. We're really
1:09:24 encouraged and we're participating. It's completely voluntary. I was actually very surprised by this
1:09:29 group and I made the initial proposal to us that they were sent so to know about the times
1:09:33 that they are encouraging people to take these photographs. All you need to do is scan the
1:09:37 local news sites today and see that people are taking photographs selfies during critical
1:09:41 incidents, natural disasters, or emergencies in major cities, completely contrary to what
1:09:47 the purpose of this program is. And these group of kids identified this well over a month
1:09:51 ago. So we're completely in support of that. We've emphasized as part of their program,
1:09:56 and it was their idea, not ours, that as they advertise this to make sure that people know
1:10:01 if there's a good time to approach officers to do this and a bad time to do that. But this
1:10:05 is, again, the idea started with this group. We just obviously reinforced that with them.
1:10:10 That's one of the reasons why we're completely behind this program. You should be very proud of these kids
1:10:14 I mean this we're very fortunate here in Twin Falls
1:10:17 We have a group of kids that recognize this issue the want to support the police department
1:10:21 There's other locations that are quite so fortunate. We're very fortunate to have this group in our city
1:10:27 Develop this program. Thank you, Captain
1:10:30 Clarifies that any other comments or thoughts from council or shall we give these
1:10:35 these fine young men and young women at some direction this evening.
1:10:39 Suzanne Hopkins.
1:10:40 Well, I would like the honor of making the motion to accept the proposal from the Twin
1:10:45 Falls City Youth Council to support your local officer program with selfies, as explained,
1:10:52 and give a mark blessing to invite other youth councils across the state to join in in this
1:10:56 campaign.
1:10:57 So you get a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting.
1:11:02 I concur anything further on this motion council before you get away.
1:11:07 I'm going to have you introduce everyone, but we're going to take the vote first.
1:11:11 I see no lights.
1:11:12 So we are the roll call both, please.
1:11:14 Greg Lanting.
1:11:15 Yes, Don Hall.
1:11:16 Yes, Rebecca Mills, like a yes, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:11:20 Yes, Jim.
1:11:21 Yes, Sean Barakur.
1:11:23 Yes, he's talking to us.
1:11:25 Motion passes seven to zero.
1:11:27 And before you want to take a picture of the evening, you said, okay, before you do that,
1:11:32 Would you mind having each of the members stand
1:11:34 and you introduce them?
1:11:35 Jonah?
1:11:36 Try not to mess their name up like I did yours.
1:11:38 OK.
1:11:40 Well, starting on the left, this is Harley.
1:11:43 He is the vice president, Jesse.
1:11:47 She is the secretary, Hannah, one of our members,
1:11:51 and Isavia.
1:11:52 She is the public relations, and Caitlin.
1:11:56 Very good.
1:11:56 How would you like to do this?
1:11:57 Do you want us up here?
1:11:58 Do you want us down there?
1:12:01 Probably up here somewhere.
1:12:03 Okay and if Captain Hicks would come up forward,
1:12:05 Council, would you mind stepping down?
1:12:07 And we have to leave enough space for Jim Mons' photoshopped.
1:12:10 Okay.
1:12:11 Okay.
1:12:17 Thank you, Miro.
1:12:18 I'm just going to worry that we need to switch more and our...
1:12:46 Yeah, I'm just going to...
1:12:49 I can just look back and look over here and just do my job.
1:12:51 I can just move up.
1:12:53 Just make point of this.
1:12:55 Okay, it's a fair way to look up towards the phone.
1:13:38 Oh, yes.
1:14:04 Let's have the phone.
1:14:10 And maybe actually, can we have the two-
1:14:13 to know who is going to vote.
1:14:42 Make sure you give them that.
1:14:44 Let's get some smart phones out there.
1:14:46 I'm going to take a lot for you.
1:14:48 You're going to vote.
1:15:00 Yes.
1:15:07 You're going to vote.
1:15:08 Yes.
1:15:18 All right.
1:15:19 That's one more.
1:15:26 Oh, it's the same.
1:15:28 Okay.
1:15:29 Very good.
1:15:30 Thank you.
1:15:31 John, I think you wanted to say at least one more thing.
1:15:38 Well, the council has our fourth annual community tight days the last week and in April.
1:15:44 That's something to keep in mind.
1:15:47 We always get free then and be back in the whole community for Saturday and Sunday.
1:15:53 Could you control the weather a little bit better this year?
1:15:56 I wish.
1:15:57 We have moved locations this year too.
1:15:59 Yes, so we need a question.
1:16:05 Very good.
1:16:06 Okay, nice location.
1:16:07 Well, I just want to say thank you to all of our youth council for your commitment and your involvement and to come out with an idea like this to bring law enforcement into a more positive light.
1:16:19 There's been so much negativity in the last and I appreciate that you doing that because by and large, our officers do a great job in protecting us.
1:16:31 So thank you and thank you Captain Hicks as well.
1:16:33 Thank you.
1:16:34 Moving on to the next item on the agenda is a request to approve First Amendment to the
1:16:43 Cliff Bar Development Agreement.
1:16:47 Melinda Anderson.
1:16:48 Thank you, Mayor.
1:16:49 Thank you, Council.
1:16:50 Good evening again.
1:16:53 So you recall on October 17th of 2013, you, the Council along with Urban Renewal Agency
1:17:00 and Cliff Bar all signed an agreement to development agreement.
1:17:04 Well, now, it's a year and a half later.
1:17:06 Lots of stuff has happened, and we're
1:17:08 to the first amendment of that development agreement.
1:17:13 And you'll also recall that the original development agreement
1:17:17 showed how the deal sheet had a timeline for various items
1:17:23 would be completed.
1:17:25 So there are aspects of the development agreement
1:17:27 itself as well as the timeline and the deal sheet that
1:17:31 changed in that 18-month period of time, including the amount of tip dollars needed to help with
1:17:42 the new, all the new infrastructure that's going in to support Cliffs infrastructure along
1:17:47 with the amount of private investment that the city, or excuse me, the company itself
1:17:54 will invest in over the next few years during the lifetime of the TIFF period, which is, as
1:18:01 you know, 20 years from the time the district is created.
1:18:06 So I have attached to this report, I've attached the amendment, I've attached a red-lined of the
1:18:14 original agreement.
1:18:18 The red line shows the changes that are being made as compared to the original document.
1:18:23 amendment is actually in front of that and then you'll see the new timeline and
1:18:26 the new deal sheet. Both the deal sheet as I mentioned really reflects the
1:18:37 refinement of the infrastructure estimates that we made over a year and
1:18:43 a half ago, almost two years ago in this. So we've been able to refine those
1:18:48 numbers. You'll see that the TIFF financing and the deal sheet has increased
1:18:52 from $18.9 million to $21.3 million, and the same day that the agency board approved this
1:19:02 amendment, they also approved a new line of credit agreement and a promissory note with
1:19:10 Cliff Bar increasing that short-term financing that Urban Renewal has with Cliff Bar from
1:19:17 $19 million to $22 million.
1:19:20 They also extended the amount of time in which to pay off that short-term note.
1:19:25 It was supposed to be paid off June 15th of this year.
1:19:28 We've extended that one year until June 15th of 2016.
1:19:33 So the Urban Renewal Agency has already approved both this agreement and their financing documents
1:19:38 to go along with it.
1:19:41 You'll see in probably some of the most important changes, especially to the Urban Renewal Agency
1:19:47 is that section 2.5 which showed that Cliffbar was going to guarantee payment of their property
1:19:55 taxes each year so that the agency could make their annual debt payment. That language has
1:20:01 been changed. The reason for the change is that Cliffbar is interested in having a tax
1:20:06 exempt financing and if they make a guarantee it cannot be tax exempt, it has to be taxable.
1:20:13 So that was the reason for the change to begin with.
1:20:17 Now the change basically just says, and I really gobbled this up when I mentioned it to the Urban
1:20:25 Renewal Board and Fritz had to save me, so he may have to do again the same thing tonight.
1:20:29 But basically what it does is, while it's not a guarantee that Cliff Bar will pay their
1:20:35 full property taxes each year, they will, but if for some reason the amount that they paid
1:20:40 didn't cover the annual debt for that year.
1:20:44 The urban renewal agency, nor the city,
1:20:46 are responsible for making up the rest of that payment.
1:20:50 We're just being really clear with Cliff Bar on that.
1:20:53 So that was the change that was negotiated
1:20:56 between the agency and Cliff Bar.
1:20:59 Fritz had a big hand in this, along with Rick Skinner,
1:21:02 who was the bond council for the urban renewal agency,
1:21:05 also helped develop this language.
1:21:08 to make sure that the agency was protected,
1:21:10 that it wouldn't have to come up with money
1:21:12 that it didn't have to pay off of debt each year.
1:21:15 So, and the reason for that is,
1:21:17 CLIP-R is looking to actually purchase this debt themselves
1:21:23 rather than having us go through a bank financing.
1:21:25 So a tax exempt financing means that the interest rate
1:21:29 would be quite a bit less than what it would be
1:21:31 as a taxable bond issue.
1:21:34 So that, in essence, is the change for Section 2.5?
1:21:39 And I may just stop there and see if there's any questions.
1:21:43 Good point, are there any questions from Council?
1:21:47 Makes sense.
1:21:49 Just real quick, if they can't make the payment,
1:21:54 city's not responsible for making the payment,
1:21:56 the URA's not responsible for making the payment,
1:21:59 who's responsible?
1:22:00 So if Clif Bar actually purchases the bond,
1:22:03 they just wouldn't get the full payment that year.
1:22:05 if they don't make a tax payment large enough
1:22:09 to cover that bond payment.
1:22:10 Okay.
1:22:11 Since it would be Cliffbar purchasing the bond.
1:22:13 Makes sense.
1:22:14 And the language also is in this amendment
1:22:18 protects the agency should Cliffbar ever decide
1:22:20 to sell the bond issue to somebody else.
1:22:25 We'll still have that same protection in here.
1:22:28 That wouldn't change.
1:22:30 Any questions Council?
1:22:33 No questions thus far?
1:22:35 So the rest of it really is, so because all three parties
1:22:40 signed the original agreement, that's why we're asking
1:22:42 all three parties to sign it, the Urban Renewal Board,
1:22:45 U.S. City Council, and then Cliff Bar as well.
1:22:48 And the rest of it really is just about making changes
1:22:51 to what Urban Renewal Agency has promised to do,
1:22:56 basically finish out the infrastructure,
1:23:00 convey the property, create the tip district
1:23:04 that it needs to create and then do some improvements
1:23:07 on the site of Cliff Bar.
1:23:11 So that's in essence with the remainder of the amendment is.
1:23:16 And I'd certainly be open for questions if there are any.
1:23:19 Travis, did you want to make a comment?
1:23:21 You know, just a quick highlight.
1:23:23 The reason this is coming before the City Council
1:23:25 this evening is because we were a party,
1:23:27 like Melinda said, to the original agreement.
1:23:30 There are no changes to this agreement
1:23:32 that impact the city financially from a timeline perspective,
1:23:37 all of the changes here only impact the relationship
1:23:40 between the agency and Clickbar.
1:23:42 Thank you, Travis.
1:23:43 Rebecca, Mel Suica.
1:23:44 Thank you, Mayor.
1:23:45 Just a couple of questions on the changes of page six.
1:23:52 I was just wondering what the value is or the necessity
1:23:57 to change that section in 6.2.1, including
1:24:02 without limitation water lines for process water,
1:24:06 domestic water, and fire suppression.
1:24:07 I mean, how is that different than, you know,
1:24:10 what the agreement was before?
1:24:12 Well, the agreement wasn't totally clear about it
1:24:14 at that point, so this is clarifying it.
1:24:17 Okay, so you're just adding clarification in there.
1:24:20 The only other question is,
1:24:23 I noticed there's an added section on page seven,
1:24:26 six point two point four about the mechanical equipment yard.
1:24:30 Yes.
1:24:31 And the URA is going to install a masonry screen wall.
1:24:34 Yes.
1:24:35 And is that considered public infrastructure?
1:24:39 How does that qualify?
1:24:40 Yes, it's considered infrastructure eligible for financing.
1:24:44 And we ran that group for it as well as our bond council.
1:24:48 OK, so that's considered public infrastructure then.
1:24:51 OK, thank you.
1:24:53 Do we have any further questions?
1:24:58 I think Sean got it.
1:25:01 Mayor, I would move to approve the first amendment
1:25:04 to the Clifffire Development Agreement as presented.
1:25:08 Seconded.
1:25:09 We have a motion on floor by Sean Berriger,
1:25:11 seconded by Chris talking to him.
1:25:13 Before we go to a vote on that motion,
1:25:15 I would allow Travis to thank you.
1:25:16 Just, yeah, thank you for the record.
1:25:18 So the screening wall would fall under
1:25:20 what would be generally classified as site improvements.
1:25:23 And that's why it makes it eligible.
1:25:25 Okay, thank you.
1:25:26 Thank you, Travis.
1:25:28 Anything further on the motion council?
1:25:32 Lee, I will roll call vote, please.
1:25:35 Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milsoka. Yes.
1:25:38 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Munn. Yeah.
1:25:42 Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris Tocky. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes.
1:25:47 Don Hall. Yes, twice. Almost eight to zeros. Seven to seven to zero motion passes.
1:25:56 Thank you. Next item. Oh, Chris Dot? Yeah. Could I get a little update on those two items?
1:26:00 The storm. Yes. Thank you. Thank you.
1:26:03 So the, as you know, earlier, actually late last year,
1:26:08 we did, there was a contractor that finished rerouting
1:26:13 the Twin Falls Canal Company lateral user run directly
1:26:17 through the property from south to north.
1:26:19 And we have relocated that to run along the southern boundary
1:26:22 of the property to 3,300, north on 3,300 to Eldridge,
1:26:28 west on Eldridge to where it would have hooked up before
1:26:31 and then run under the rail line to hook up and go continue north.
1:26:35 So that's what the, that's, that has been completed.
1:26:39 The, there is a city irrigation project on Hankins Road
1:26:44 that's in process now to finish and they're,
1:26:48 they should be pretty much finished now
1:26:50 since irrigation season is now pretty much upon us.
1:26:52 Well that was the question, it looks like they're pushing
1:26:54 the deadline there.
1:26:55 They're gonna have water in their face any minute there.
1:26:58 So I haven't talked to anybody in engineering today about this.
1:27:01 So I don't know how soon they're finished, but I would suspect that they're very close
1:27:05 if they haven't finished already.
1:27:07 And then the stormwater retention?
1:27:09 So stormwater retention will be part of the site improvements that the agency will be making
1:27:13 on the site itself.
1:27:15 And I think that's already been pretty well scraped out to the south of the proposed building,
1:27:20 isn't it?
1:27:21 You know, I don't have that information.
1:27:23 I was talking with Troy earlier, and he's not clear on that there's anything been going
1:27:26 on with that yet.
1:27:27 There's a large pond basin out there for something.
1:27:30 If we have been there already for the JCO site, so when JCO subdivision was put in a lot of storm water retention ponds were put in as part of that development.
1:27:41 Troy, would you mind introducing yourself, say, what department you're with?
1:27:45 Troy Vitek, the Assistant City Engineer.
1:27:47 I know a portion was being removed because they needed material for the building pad.
1:27:53 So they may have gathered some material from there.
1:27:56 And there is actually planned to be upon generally in this area
1:28:00 and then a larger pond in this area to account for all that storm water.
1:28:04 But they will develop that. We will check as part of the building permit process.
1:28:08 I think the one of the south has been worked on recently.
1:28:11 I just touched out there yesterday and it looked like an activity.
1:28:14 They need a lot of material for the size of this building.
1:28:17 A lot of precious topsoil gone.
1:28:20 Thank you, Troy.
1:28:23 Thank you for the question. No, okay. We're moving on to the next item
1:28:28 Melinda and Fritz as well request to approve conveying
1:28:33 90 acres of the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency property located at 556
1:28:39 Champlain Way south to Cliffbar Melinda. Thank you mayor evening council, so I'm going to put a map up
1:28:47 So that you can see what's going on
1:28:49 So this is 90 acres of the balance of the former JECO subdivision, all the area outlined
1:29:02 in the blue dashed line.
1:29:06 That is the specific acreage that we're talking about this evening is requesting the council
1:29:11 to approve that transfer by the Urban Renewal Board to Cliff Bar and the reason that we're
1:29:18 asking the Council for this approval is that the revenue allocation area or TIFF district
1:29:25 has not yet been created. It expects we expect to have that happen in the next few months,
1:29:30 but it hasn't happened yet. So by Idaho Code 50-2007, that transfer property needs to be approved
1:29:41 by the local governing body, which in this case is yourselves. So the agency was getting
1:29:47 ready to make that transfer quickly. We've got a lot of the things done that the
1:29:51 or Cliff Bar was hoping that we'd have finished by now and so they're requesting
1:29:57 we and their renewal board is requesting that approval of conveying 90 acres as to
1:30:06 from the group and renewal board to Cliff Bar Bakery Company LLC of Twin Falls.
1:30:12 Thank you Melinda. Any questions for Melinda? Rebecca Melsoik.
1:30:17 Thank you, Mayor.
1:30:18 Thank you, Melinda.
1:30:20 What are the steps that need to happen in the next six to eight weeks?
1:30:24 Are there delays or further creation of the allocation area?
1:30:29 So we're just now finishing the draft of the legal plan that will go with it, which
1:30:37 would then first go to the Urban Renewal Agency for their approval.
1:30:41 that it would go to the Planning and Zoning Commission for their review and recommendation.
1:30:49 And then we would schedule a public hearing in front of U.L. City Council for your approval.
1:30:56 Before you actually hear it, we would get the plan out to all the local taxing districts
1:31:00 for their review.
1:31:03 And then once the public hearing happens and then you would prove the plan, we would
1:31:08 and then send the plan out again to all those taxing districts,
1:31:12 notifying that this has been approved by the city council.
1:31:16 And then we work with the county and we work with the state tax
1:31:19 commission to make sure that the district goes into effect.
1:31:23 For what did I miss?
1:31:28 So what would be the benefit of conveying the land early?
1:31:31 I mean, I think the code's pretty clear about the risk.
1:31:34 You know, I even talked about the risk of giving the land
1:31:37 having it not the allocation area not be created, which doesn't seem likely, but are
1:31:43 there any other risks that you can think of, or what's the importance of conveying the land?
1:31:49 Well, part of it is that I'm trying to adhere to the development agreement and the amendment
1:31:53 of which you just approved tonight, that's part of it.
1:31:55 But in Clif is, as you know, getting started, they have started being dirt, and they expect
1:32:02 to begin construction here in just a couple of weeks, and they would like to construct
1:32:06 on their own property.
1:32:08 As far as a risk, I'm not seeing any.
1:32:13 So the procedure for conveyance of land
1:32:16 by urban renewal agency, if it's within an area with a plan,
1:32:20 they put out a request for proposals.
1:32:24 So we've done that in a few places downtown,
1:32:26 but this is the exact same process we used for Giovanni.
1:32:29 So before the plan is in place, there's a procedure
1:32:32 that allows you to bypass that.
1:32:35 And as you know, you all really approved this already
1:32:39 in the original development agreement,
1:32:40 because it was always contemplated
1:32:42 that this would be transferred to Cliff Bar
1:32:45 for their development.
1:32:46 Sure, I'm just wondering if you go through all
1:32:49 of the public hearings and the reviews
1:32:51 by all of the other entities, if they have any objections,
1:32:55 I mean, is there any value to that?
1:32:57 If you've already conveyed the link.
1:32:58 Right now, Cliff Bar is at risk,
1:33:01 because Cliff Bar has provided all the financing
1:33:05 for everything that's been there.
1:33:10 Great planning.
1:33:11 Mayor Hall, I would move approval of the being
1:33:15 90 acres of the Twin Falls River renewal,
1:33:17 it's the property located at 556 Champlain Way,
1:33:21 South to Cliff Park.
1:33:23 Second.
1:33:24 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,
1:33:25 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
1:33:28 Anything further on that motion council?
1:33:31 The item, roll call please.
1:33:34 Rebecca Milsoy-Khan?
1:33:35 Yes.
1:33:36 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:33:37 Yes, Jim Munn.
1:33:39 Yes.
1:33:41 Sean Berriger.
1:33:42 Yes.
1:33:42 Chris Talking to you.
1:33:43 Yes.
1:33:44 Greg Lansing.
1:33:45 Yes.
1:33:46 Don Hall.
1:33:47 Yes, Ocean Pass is 7-0, Greg Lanning.
1:33:50 Well, I'll take this opportunity when Cliff Bar found
1:33:53 that I was going to be in the Napa Valley area last week
1:33:57 during the my girlfriend's spring break,
1:34:01 that they invited me to come down to their corporate offices,
1:34:04 which was unbelievable.
1:34:07 I mean, the culture there is something we just don't have here.
1:34:11 And it's when it falls at this point, as far as relaxed.
1:34:14 And I think the CEO had the same t-shirt he hung on at the ground
1:34:20 breaking on at work that day.
1:34:22 And it's really fun to see that and see their action
1:34:27 and their operation.
1:34:28 They've repurposed an old valve building,
1:34:31 to a valve production building for their offices.
1:34:35 I happen to be there, they timed my visit with the same time as their weekly, I don't
1:34:41 know, I would say a pep rally as much as anything, it's just kind of a meeting for them to get
1:34:46 a few information out, it's certainly fun and active and everything and they asked me
1:34:51 to speak for 30 seconds or less, and so I did, I made sure I kept it under 30 seconds, but
1:34:57 about our excitement about them coming just when it falls, but it was just, it was fun
1:35:01 to see them all in their work environment and not here is a part of signing documents and
1:35:06 that type of things.
1:35:08 Everything they talk about that we've heard they have at their place, the gyms and everything
1:35:12 else is all there, the daycare, the works, everything is there.
1:35:16 And they're just excited that they're coming into and falls for their first facility.
1:35:25 And you can tell they are.
1:35:26 As soon as some of the people that were here saw me, they're immediately coming up and
1:35:31 talking to you and then talking about the ground breaking and different things so
1:35:34 it was fun. How many neckties current? Zero. Perfect. Zero neckties. Thank you
1:35:41 for sharing that Greg. Four of us were able to do the same thing not long ago
1:35:45 and five of us and felt the same thing. Very very warmed and relaxed and and what
1:35:53 we spent the whole day with them actually and what a great culture that
1:35:56 they have there. And I think it's going to benefit our community immensely. So, thank you very
1:36:03 for sharing that. Okay, anything further on this Council? All right, we will move to the
1:36:08 next item which is public input and or items from City Manager City Council. We do have
1:36:12 two public meeting or two public hearings this evening. I am planning on taking a short
1:36:17 break in between this section and those. So, anything from the public, anyone from the
1:36:24 public would like to address the council this evening. See, see, no. Yeah, come on
1:36:34 forward. I know I know your school teacher, you know how to do this. If you'd
1:36:40 introduce yourself. Julie Davis. Thank you, Julie. If we do want to respond to one of
1:36:47 the items on the public hearing, do we do that now? We will give you an
1:36:52 opportunity to speak during the public hearing testimony portion of
1:36:57 Whichever item. Thank you. Anyone else from the public?
1:37:03 City Manager, City Council. Great landing.
1:37:07 I would like to I know it's just Wednesday is last day. We have John
1:37:12 Alexander in the crowd who is the opinions editor for the Times News
1:37:15 and have a late night email buddy of mine is if I disagree with
1:37:19 him or if he's cured me or or if you if I do agree with him, we
1:37:23 Yeah, we'll sometimes trade emails back and forth,
1:37:29 but we appreciate your time here in Twin Falls.
1:37:33 And like I said, we did not disagree with you,
1:37:35 but you always started a conversation,
1:37:36 and that's good, that's one of the things we'd like to add.
1:37:39 So John, would you mind coming to the podium?
1:37:41 Tell us where you're going.
1:37:43 Yeah, please, you're not shy about the public.
1:37:47 Yes, your job.
1:37:49 Where are you headed off to, John?
1:37:51 I'm following John Pfeiffer and on him to Carbondale, Illinois.
1:37:54 Carp, very good.
1:37:56 Yeah.
1:37:57 Well, congratulations, I guess.
1:37:59 So you might have wanted my old Air Force friends down there.
1:38:01 Okay.
1:38:02 Come back and see Cliff Barr when it's done.
1:38:04 I plan on it.
1:38:05 Okay.
1:38:06 Thank you, John.
1:38:07 Anything further from Council?
1:38:10 Okay.
1:38:11 At this point, what I'd like to do is just take a short seven minute break.
1:38:16 We'll return it 20 till and we'll start the public testimony.
1:38:20 Public hearings.
1:38:21 I just want to make sure I check that before we reconvene, so at this point, we're reconvening
1:46:09 the City of Twin Falls Council meeting. We're going into two different public hearings,
1:46:15 so we will give an opportunity. We always give an opportunity for public testimony during
1:46:20 the public hearing. So Julie, we'll make sure we get you up there. Okay, I know you're
1:46:24 excited. So we are moving to the first item which is a request for a zoning district change
1:46:31 and zoning map amendment from C1 PUD to C1 for 7.5 acres of undeveloped land located on
1:46:41 the north side of the 2400 block of Addison Avenue East. Cara of Dave Tebow, did I say
1:46:48 that right Dave? On behalf of Joe Russell. So Dave you will be making the presentation
1:46:54 then we'll follow it up with a staff report.
1:46:56 Okay, thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council.
1:46:59 My name is Dave Tebow with EHM Engineers at 621,
1:47:02 North College Road here in Twin Falls.
1:47:04 Tonight I'm representing my client, Mr. Joe Russell,
1:47:07 who is the current property owner
1:47:09 of the property outlined in red up on the screen.
1:47:13 This property is located on Addison Avenue East on the North side,
1:47:17 kind of across from the funeral home
1:47:20 and the Department of Homeland Security.
1:47:23 It's currently undeveloped.
1:47:25 Prior to my client owning the property,
1:47:26 the property, previous property owner,
1:47:29 applied for a rezone to C1 PUD.
1:47:33 However, the PUD was never finalized and executed
1:47:36 on the property, therefore, the current zoning status
1:47:39 of this property was left in limbo,
1:47:41 which is impeding development of this property by my client.
1:47:47 This evening, we would ask that the city council
1:47:50 approve a rezone request to rezone this back
1:47:53 to the underlying C1 zoning designation of the property.
1:47:57 As you can see by the map, property to the west,
1:48:01 to the east, and to the south,
1:48:03 is all zone C1 along Addison Avenue East.
1:48:06 To the north, we have a multifamily residential complex
1:48:10 that zones R4, and then some single family residential
1:48:14 development to the northwest that's zoned R2.
1:48:17 This zoning request is in compliance
1:48:19 with the compliance and the master plans for the area.
1:48:22 It's consistent with current land use and the anticipated uses
1:48:28 within the C1 zone are compatible with neighboring uses.
1:48:32 Therefore, that's my request this evening
1:48:33 to clear this zoning designation issue up
1:48:37 and finalize it to allow for the development of the property.
1:48:40 I'll stand for questions if you have any.
1:48:42 Very good.
1:48:43 We have Dave here to answer any questions
1:48:46 or we can go to the staff report next.
1:48:48 Chris talking.
1:48:49 Oh, let me have the staff report.
1:48:51 Very good.
1:48:52 So at this time, where does the Jonathan Spennel up,
1:48:54 come up and give us the staff report, welcome Jonathan.
1:48:57 Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council.
1:49:00 I think Dave summarized really well that 95
1:49:02 is when the PUD went through, it was never signed.
1:49:06 There's no agreement that we can enforce.
1:49:09 At the time it was for a specific use on the property,
1:49:14 as it was presented, however, since there's no document,
1:49:16 there's nothing the planning and sewing department can enforce.
1:49:19 It's one of those things and loopholes we've changed
1:49:21 with their code amendment to ZDA's.
1:49:23 So that this type of issue won't happen again in the future.
1:49:28 Dave summarized where it's at,
1:49:30 the issue that we have, the surrounding uses,
1:49:33 C1, the ones to the east are also under a PUD,
1:49:37 and that's a separate PUD, separate agreement.
1:49:41 Stuff to the west is a nursery,
1:49:44 and further to the west,
1:49:45 and some other commercial uses.
1:49:47 Across the street, we have funeral home,
1:49:51 St. Luke's clinic is down here on carriage and Addison East.
1:49:55 So that's the clinic.
1:49:57 Lots of commercial properties along this corridor,
1:50:00 especially in this area.
1:50:04 If this were to be approved, the zoning change,
1:50:07 it would go straight to the C1.
1:50:08 So any development that occurred,
1:50:10 if it fell within the permitted uses,
1:50:12 would just simply apply for a building permit.
1:50:14 We can go to the permitted uses in the C1 zoning section
1:50:17 for those types of things.
1:50:18 If it's something needs a special use permit,
1:50:20 would get a special use permit.
1:50:22 That's kind of the change we're contemplating here.
1:50:24 Just be the regular uses containing the C1 zone.
1:50:28 On February 24th, the Planning and Zoning Commission
1:50:30 held the public hearing.
1:50:32 There was no public comment.
1:50:33 And after deliberation, they made a recommendation.
1:50:37 They determined that, one, the request
1:50:39 is in conformance with the comprehensive plan designation
1:50:42 of commercial slash retail for this site,
1:50:44 and two, the extent and nature of changing the zoning
1:50:47 of this property.
1:50:48 C1 would be compatible with and not detract from the surrounding area and there was a motion
1:50:53 and a second in all members who were present voted in favor of the motion.
1:50:58 So in conclusion if the City Council determines this request is in conformance with the comprehensive
1:51:02 plan designation of commercial slash retail for this site and agrees the extent and nature
1:51:08 of the changing of the zone of this property from C1 PUD to C1 would be compatible with
1:51:13 and not detract from the surrounding area then staff recommends approval of this request
1:51:17 as presented and as recommended by the PUNNING and SONIC Commission.
1:51:20 Thank you, Jonathan, Chris, talking to me.
1:51:27 I guess I'm a little confused because the proposed land use is a, and I may have to have
1:51:34 the applicant respond to this as well, but the proposed land use is a residential apartment
1:51:41 complex by the information we have.
1:51:45 And yet, if we drop the C1P&E, Jonathan, under the C1, we potentially, if the developers'
1:51:53 plans were to change, could have a unregulated but business-allowed convenience store, 24-hour
1:52:03 operation convenience store on the northern terminus, directly adjacent to residential property,
1:52:10 which is at our tube.
1:52:12 under a straight C1 without a PUD, it would be whatever is the log use within the C1.
1:52:20 Correct. If it's allowed within the C1 zone.
1:52:23 That's the thing that I think the Council needs to be a little aware of.
1:52:27 C1 and R2, that was one of the first lessons I learned in municipal governance that it's not a good mix.
1:52:36 And although I certainly have no reason to expect that the residential apartment complex
1:52:42 would not be put in. I'm just saying under the law of C1, anything that's allowed in
1:52:48 that use could be placed at considerable risk to property owners with the largest investment
1:52:57 of their life, their homes in direct proximity to it. So I would like to have some comment
1:53:03 from the applicant.
1:53:04 I have a councilman talking to my clients disclosed his plans to me and currently this
1:53:14 property is for sale.
1:53:16 He intends to market it as a multifamily apartment residential complex.
1:53:23 I've seen and met with Renee Caraway and disclosed some of our preliminary designs for that complex.
1:53:30 I can't tell you what could happen arbitrarily in the future.
1:53:35 exactly right that it could could change but I don't have any evidence that's been presented
1:53:40 to me or plans that have been presented to me.
1:53:43 Therefore all I can tell you is what I know currently and that is that our intent is to
1:53:47 develop it and market it as a apartment complex.
1:53:51 Thank you.
1:53:52 And we want to clarify the zoning so that we can move forward because it's in a state
1:53:55 of limbo.
1:53:58 Thank you.
1:53:59 Rebecca Melsoica.
1:54:00 Oh, thank you, Mayor.
1:54:02 It may be tied to the 24-hour convenience store would have to come through a special use permit process, so that would require public hearing.
1:54:11 But you're right about the uses being C1.
1:54:15 My question is, for the C1 zone, what kind of buffer is required between the commercial use and the residential use?
1:54:25 I know that there are some requirements there.
1:54:27 There are, and there's screening requirements found in the code.
1:54:29 It requires a screening fence or screening material outlined
1:54:33 with certain criteria for what it needs to be,
1:54:36 when it abuts against the residential zones.
1:54:38 Can you go over the buffer there?
1:54:41 I mean, how wide is the distance?
1:54:44 Is there a Burma requirement?
1:54:45 Landscape requirement?
1:54:48 If you give me a few minutes, I'd find it in the code.
1:54:50 Sure, yeah, take your time.
1:54:51 Just for our information, because that was my concern as well,
1:54:56 is how these are two homes.
1:55:01 Otherwise the zoning is very compatible.
1:55:03 Every other direction is a C1 zoning.
1:55:07 And I've read in the report that it originally was C1.
1:55:11 It was rezoned to a PUD, which makes sense.
1:55:13 A PUD is very specific development plan.
1:55:16 And if that car lot's not going forward,
1:55:19 it doesn't make sense to have that zoning there.
1:55:23 I can reply to the history that my client has within this community specifically.
1:55:30 My clients developed the Rocket Express car wash that abuts directly to some R2 single
1:55:35 family residential homes and this particular issue of buffer and screening against residential
1:55:41 was brought up at the time of that development.
1:55:44 Mr. Russell did install landscaping and fencing to meet the requirements there and has nothing
1:55:49 but positive comments and remarks and I believe this council is aware of those
1:55:53 comments and remarks related to that particular development. I have every
1:55:57 confidence that he'll comply with the the code and I believe that's a staff
1:56:02 recommendation that we meet the engineering requirements on building
1:56:05 submittal anyway so I think that this code is enforced by your city staff.
1:56:11 Okay Jonathan. So specifically the screening is found in a 10-11-3 reference
1:56:17 That's Title 10, Chapter 11, Section 3,
1:56:20 talks about screening in the requirement.
1:56:22 It's basically a six-foot fence can be made of all
1:56:25 to materials, it can be landscaping or combination thereof.
1:56:31 Require between commercial and residential uses.
1:56:33 So in between those two things, you
1:56:34 have to have a screening fence or material
1:56:37 or something that meets the minimum standard.
1:56:39 Those standards are six-foot, fence or wall, wood, solid,
1:56:44 vinyl, metal, concrete, or concrete block.
1:56:46 you can also do landscaping that can meet it.
1:56:49 It also says it shall complete the obscure objects inside the screened area when viewed
1:56:53 from any angle outside the screened area and shall be constructed so as to reduce noise
1:56:59 lights and a blowing trash.
1:57:01 So that's straight from the coat.
1:57:04 And how about a setback above the building?
1:57:06 And it's told me that before I started and I remember that one.
1:57:10 We did create the 25 foot setback for any buildings adjacent to residential properties.
1:57:15 So there would be a 25-foot setback from property line.
1:57:18 I'll put any building on there.
1:57:20 OK.
1:57:22 Greg Leining.
1:57:23 This might be a question.
1:57:24 Jonathan, you might be honest.
1:57:25 There might be Fritz.
1:57:28 What were their options for doing this?
1:57:32 Could they have came through and asked for a different PUD?
1:57:36 Or could they have come through and asked for a change
1:57:40 to a CUNPUD that more closely matched their use of the property?
1:57:44 What were their options?
1:57:46 their options, which we outlined were exactly that.
1:57:49 They could change the PUD, repropose a new one,
1:57:52 or I think the timing of this was they would do the new ZDA,
1:57:56 and this is another option.
1:58:00 I'm not sure there are many other zones,
1:58:03 I'm sure there's other zones that could meet it,
1:58:05 but for their needs, I don't know if they would go
1:58:06 to a different zone, but they could.
1:58:09 A PUD or ZDA basically is a rezone,
1:58:11 and that would be definitely an option.
1:58:13 I think this is the option they chose to come forward with.
1:58:16 And those would be the only two options because it's planned for a commercial, so we'd have to come with a comp plan.
1:58:22 Right.
1:58:23 But I just have the same concerns as Chris has.
1:58:28 If I've got something that has already been approved into a PUD, which gives me a little more control,
1:58:33 or not me personally, but the city more control, I hate to lose that because even in their narrative,
1:58:41 Then the, uh, Mr. Tybolt's, uh, conversation that they're planning to market this and market
1:58:50 it means I don't have the same protections I have with Mr. Russell's history in the community.
1:58:56 If he's no longer in control of property, how do I depend on Mr. Russell's past, you know,
1:59:03 consideration of the neighbors? She's like, obviously I've been to, to the car wash and yes,
1:59:08 I would look at him through there today and I noticed how much landscaping was there and the
1:59:12 The lighting was done in a matter to point straight down and all the things that you're
1:59:17 referring to, but if he's selling the property, you know, do I have the same thing with Joe
1:59:23 Blow from Portland?
1:59:24 So it chooses to develop this property and is not as good a neighbor as Mr. Russell is.
1:59:31 So those are my concerns I have.
1:59:33 If I go to go from PUD to C1 and opens up even with special use permits, things that
1:59:39 I maybe don't want next to that are to.
1:59:42 So, this is Ann Hawkins.
1:59:45 Thank you.
1:59:46 I guess on the alternative side, what gives me a little comfort is to the West, everything
1:59:51 is C1 butting up against R2 there, and evidently the neighbors haven't had any complaints.
1:59:59 It looks like when they built those houses, they knew there was C1 next to them.
2:00:05 So I don't see it as being that big of an issue to make it match everything else that's
2:00:11 already a long stretch of road.
2:00:13 Prince.
2:00:14 We should get through to the public hearing before we start.
2:00:16 Yeah, my fault.
2:00:17 It was just a nice start.
2:00:18 Nice to meet you.
2:00:19 We started debating it instead of clarifying and asking questions.
2:00:24 Are there any other questions?
2:00:26 Council.
2:00:28 OK, at this point, we will open this up to the public for any public testimony.
2:00:34 Anyone in the public that would like to come forward and discuss this item?
2:00:41 Julie, this wasn't the one that you wanted to.
2:00:44 Just want to make sure I gave you that opportunity.
2:00:48 All right.
2:00:49 At this point, I'm going to close the public testimony portion
2:00:53 of the hearing, but keep it open for council
2:00:55 to ask questions of either the applicant or city staff.
2:01:02 And eventually, I will close that down just for city council
2:01:06 debate over the issue.
2:01:08 At that time, we can only ask clarifying questions
2:01:11 of our council.
2:01:12 Doesn't he have five minutes for rebuttal?
2:01:14 He does, I was going to go home.
2:01:15 Oh, I'm sorry.
2:01:17 I thought you were moving on to the question still.
2:01:19 My fault.
2:01:20 I'm going to have time tonight.
2:01:23 I was just going to summarize some of the questions
2:01:25 that I heard expressed by council during the discussion.
2:01:29 As you're aware, notice was given to all the adjacent property
2:01:31 owners within 300 feet.
2:01:33 None chose to attend to the Planning and Zoning Commission
2:01:36 north this meeting.
2:01:38 And so while I understand your concerns,
2:01:40 I think that's significant evidence
2:01:43 that there's not a concern with this particular rezone request.
2:01:47 Next is we did examine and met with Renee with the city
2:01:52 and examined the possibility of a PUD.
2:01:54 We met with her in November of 2014.
2:01:56 She recommended we proceed with the PUD application.
2:01:59 My clients spent significant money
2:02:01 in preparing that application.
2:02:03 I then met with Renee to submit all of the parts and pieces
2:02:06 that were required for that application in January
2:02:10 and was told that the city had adopted the ZDA ordinance.
2:02:13 And therefore, rather than spend another several thousand dollars
2:02:17 on the ZDA conformance and application, Renee recommended
2:02:20 that we rezone it to straight C1 zone.
2:02:25 And that's how we got here today.
2:02:27 So I understand your concerns.
2:02:29 We tried and tried and were six months late now
2:02:32 on our development options and we'd like to move forward
2:02:35 with C1 zone.
2:02:35 Thank you.
2:02:37 Do we have any of the questions of either city staff or the applicant?
2:02:43 Okay. At this time, I'm going to close the public hearing.
2:02:48 I can get that and turn it over to council for their deliberations.
2:02:58 Rebecca, I'll go first.
2:03:03 You know, I had similar concerns to Chris talking to and I point well taken
2:03:07 that no one has shown up to the public hearing.
2:03:10 And so, I guess I would just request that the message be passed on to the developer that he be mindful of the R2 residents.
2:03:23 And even though, you know, the multi-tenant buildings, you know, the apartments that people live in are allowed in C1.
2:03:33 And oftentimes they are zones C1. It's still where people live. It's still their residences.
2:03:40 And I'm not as concerned as switching this property back to C1
2:03:44 because it does comply with the comp plan.
2:03:47 It is compatible with most of the surrounding uses.
2:03:52 In fact, it's identical to three of the four zones around it.
2:04:00 A lot of the 24-hour uses and the higher traffic uses are
2:04:07 under a special use permit.
2:04:10 I actually prefer the traditional zonings because there are clear setbacks, there are
2:04:14 clear buffers, there are clear standards that the developer has to comply with.
2:04:19 What I've seen in PUDs is they're usually used to circumvent those setbacks and they
2:04:26 end up being higher density and more impactful to the neighbors.
2:04:31 In fact, we just had a PUD that came through,
2:04:34 was on the backside of an R2 neighborhood,
2:04:37 a very high value R2 neighborhood,
2:04:39 and it was allowed that businesses be on the backside
2:04:45 within a few ten or so feet,
2:04:48 operating from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.,
2:04:51 in their backyards, essentially.
2:04:53 So I actually am comfortable, more comfortable,
2:04:56 with our city code standards in regular zones
2:05:00 I am with PUD sometimes. I think sometimes things slip through PUDs easier than they
2:05:06 do with regular zoning. So anyway, this property was zone C1 before. I don't have any objections
2:05:12 to taking it back to C1, especially because the current PUD isn't usable regardless. I
2:05:17 mean, you can't, if the car dealership is no longer in the market and it's been 20 years
2:05:25 I suppose that I don't have any objections.
2:05:31 Thank you, Rebecca.
2:05:33 Anything from any other council member?
2:05:38 Stand for direction from council.
2:05:40 Rebecca Milsoica.
2:05:43 I'll move approval to approve the zoning district change and zoning map amendment from C1PUD to C1 for seven and a half plus or minus acres of undeveloped land located on the north side of the 2,400,000.
2:05:57 of the 2400 block of Addison Avenue East.
2:06:01 Second.
2:06:02 Motion on the floor by Rebecca Milsorica,
2:06:03 seconded by Suzanne Hopkins.
2:06:07 Anything further on the motion council?
2:06:09 Chris Talking.
2:06:10 Well, probably vote for it.
2:06:12 I don't get a lot of comfort,
2:06:16 and it has nothing to do with the applicant
2:06:18 and his purchase on the marking of the ground.
2:06:21 I'm looking at the logistics of an encroachment
2:06:25 of a C1 development on an existing residential property.
2:06:30 But it's the other way in residents come to a commercial,
2:06:32 they know what they're getting into.
2:06:35 I think you mentioned Jonathan, it was a 25-foot setback
2:06:40 on the northern terminus of this.
2:06:42 Any development adjacent to residential property
2:06:45 or future residential development
2:06:47 has to have a 25-foot building line setback
2:06:51 from property lines, so there would be any buildings.
2:06:53 If I could stop you, Fritz, we're not supposed to take any more staff comments.
2:06:59 We can't ask our attorney.
2:07:01 That was a clarification you already mentioned.
2:07:03 That was okay.
2:07:04 You should tell me what the ordinance is.
2:07:09 So where are we?
2:07:11 We're still on the motion.
2:07:14 Well, I know, but the 25 foot, we can have clarification, Fritz.
2:07:18 He mentioned that before, thank you.
2:07:22 Go ahead, John.
2:07:26 Yes, no building would be within 25 feet of the property line.
2:07:31 to Jason Taney, residential property.
2:07:34 Okay, thank you.
2:07:36 Anything further on the motion council?
2:07:39 Lee, I have a real call vote, please.
2:07:43 Suzanne Hawkins?
2:07:44 Yes.
2:07:45 Jim Mun?
2:07:47 Yes.
2:07:48 Sean Berriger?
2:07:49 Yes.
2:07:50 Chris Talkington?
2:07:51 Yes.
2:07:52 Greg Lantine?
2:07:52 Yes.
2:07:53 Don Hall?
2:07:54 Yes.
2:07:55 Rebecca Milsoyka?
2:07:56 Yes.
2:07:57 Motion passes seven to zero.
2:07:58 Thank you, Dave.
2:08:00 The next item on the agenda for public hearing is request of a 15 foot by 128 foot plated, but undeveloped drainage and non-vehicular head path access easement located between lots 41 and 42, block one of Settlers Ridge Subdivision number three.
2:08:21 So is Caro Bismans fish on behalf of settlers ridge LLC and I believe we have Tim Vosser
2:08:28 here to make the presentation or Mr. Fish.
2:08:41 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:08:46 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:08:51 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:09:00 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:09:07 and I agree with it, and I don't really have any problems, so unless there's some questions
2:09:12 you have, I'll stand for questions, but I think this report covers it pretty plainly.
2:09:21 Thank you, Ms. Fish.
2:09:22 Tim, did you want to add anything as far as the?
2:09:25 Just as a clarification, this is a request to dedicate the path portion of an easement located
2:09:37 together.
2:09:44 The path portion would be right there.
2:09:47 The bulk of the easement for drainage and utilities would stay in place.
2:09:52 It's just for the vacation of the path and alternate path locations are there and there
2:09:58 to connect to the canyon and path.
2:10:01 So that's the main request.
2:10:03 Very good.
2:10:05 Thank you, Mr. Bosser.
2:10:07 I think we're ready for a staff report.
2:10:09 Welcome back, Jonathan.
2:10:11 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
2:10:14 So in 2004, we had a request for the Pilarity Platt
2:10:18 for Settlers Ridge, it contained a lot more land
2:10:20 than what we're looking at here.
2:10:21 This is just one of the bases.
2:10:23 During that public hearing, I see staffs stated
2:10:27 that the Platt needed to reflect this new requirement
2:10:29 of connecting cul-de-vacs with surrounding pathways.
2:10:32 during the planning process, this pedestrian pathway
2:10:34 was placed in its current location,
2:10:36 and eventually the final plan for settler dredge number three
2:10:38 was recorded.
2:10:40 The path we're talking about is to note it was this one here,
2:10:43 there's another one here, and this is a tract, actually,
2:10:47 that will be dedicated to the city,
2:10:49 and there will be a pedestrian connection there as well.
2:10:51 The path we're talking in question
2:10:53 is actually currently Canyon Rim Road.
2:10:57 They're with through a vacation process some time ago,
2:11:01 And currently, this area is under construction.
2:11:04 So the space is, right now they're building Park View up here,
2:11:08 and it will connect to the Northern or whatever
2:11:11 Western portion of Canyon Rim Road.
2:11:13 Once that is completed, the current Canyon Rim Road
2:11:17 that runs this way will no longer be used for vehicles.
2:11:20 It will be closed right down here on Federation Road,
2:11:24 and it will be turned into a walking path.
2:11:26 So half the road is going to be eliminated.
2:11:30 I'm not sure the specifics on how that's going to happen.
2:11:32 I know it was taken care of before,
2:11:34 but this will then be a walking path.
2:11:38 So what we're vacating is the connection
2:11:40 from this cul-de-sac and ensuing other area
2:11:44 of walking area to that pathway here.
2:11:47 Now the alignment of the path starts here,
2:11:49 it comes up this way,
2:11:52 and then it cuts across right here.
2:11:56 It does not go through this property here.
2:11:58 And that was private property.
2:11:59 The time of vacation, it was not part of the application,
2:12:02 So that's still private property and a private roadway
2:12:04 for that resident that lives there.
2:12:06 So that's kind of the background of where we're talking
2:12:08 about in a little bit of the history.
2:12:11 The code section we're talking about that was in place in 2004.
2:12:14 I'm not going to read the whole thing,
2:12:16 but it is quoted in the staff report.
2:12:18 It talks about right away from pedestrian walkways
2:12:21 in the middle of long blocks.
2:12:23 They may be required where necessary
2:12:25 to obtain convenient pedestrian circulation
2:12:27 to schools, parks, et cetera, et cetera.
2:12:30 That was the code used at the time of plant to place this pedestrian walkway.
2:12:35 As Tim said, we're only vacating the pedestrian.
2:12:38 We're not vacating the easement or the drainage so that will stay in place.
2:12:43 This vacation process requires a public hearing with the Planning and Zoning Commission.
2:12:47 After receiving recommendation from the Commission, the City Council holds another public hearing,
2:12:51 which we're doing tonight.
2:12:52 If the request is approved, an ordinance is adopted, published, and recorded.
2:12:56 On February 24, 2015, the Commission held a public hearing and was asked to make a recommendation
2:13:00 There was no public comment at that meeting after deliberation. There was a motion and all members present voted in favor of the motion
2:13:08 So in conclusion to the City Council request to vacate a
2:13:12 15-foot by 128 foot platted undeveloped drainage and nonvehicular pedestrian access easement located between lots
2:13:19 4142
2:13:20 Block 1 of South Madrid's settler's Ridge subdivision number 3 as presented staff recommends approve the subject of the following condition number one subject to site
2:13:28 that fundamental has required by building engineering
2:13:31 fire and zoning officials to ensure compliance
2:13:32 with all the local city code requirements and standards.
2:13:38 That is all.
2:13:39 Do we have any questions in council?
2:13:46 All right.
2:13:46 Oh, Rebecca, I'll select it.
2:13:48 Thank you, Mayor.
2:13:49 Just a quick question from the, I guess,
2:13:52 the Northeast pedestrian connection on the development
2:13:55 to the Southwest park connection.
2:14:00 connection. What's the length of that stretch of trail? For clarification type
2:14:06 from here to here. No, sorry, all the way to that. If we were to vacate the
2:14:14 connection through the center, what would be the distance between the two possible
2:14:21 pedestrian access points? So these lots, I had this, I did not put it in,
2:14:31 And these lots are approximately 100 feet.
2:14:34 So if I count, there's 11 or 12.
2:14:36 So it'd be 1,200 with the lots.
2:14:40 Another 113, I'm guessing around 1,400, that's a guess.
2:14:44 But I'm like calculated at once before in the last meeting.
2:14:46 And I totally forgot to put in this one.
2:14:49 It's about 1,400 feet.
2:14:51 So almost a mile about a mile.
2:14:54 No?
2:14:54 Before a mile?
2:14:55 4th of a mile.
2:14:56 Yeah, about a fourth.
2:15:01 Thanks.
2:15:02 Anything for another day?
2:15:04 Any other questions before I open up the public testimony portion of this evening's
2:15:09 hearing?
2:15:11 Okay, at this point we are opening the public testimony portion of this hearing.
2:15:15 If you'd like to come forward, we generally time this about two minutes, but we're going
2:15:19 to give you a little more time tonight because there's not a whole lot of folks here.
2:15:22 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:15:33 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:15:40 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:15:47 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:15:53 in the middle of long blocks? What would be considered the distance of a long block?
2:15:58 Does anybody know that?
2:15:59 that. Generally what we do is we take all your questions then we'll have staff
2:16:04 answer those when you're all done Julie. That's okay.
2:16:08 So then my question would be if this is considered a long block then why would
2:16:12 we be vacating that pedestrian access to public
2:16:17 my question is why the developers want to
2:16:22 do away with it. It seems to me like just one more
2:16:27 Good thing about our subdivision and I meant my question is why they would choose to do that
2:16:32 Is it a cost issue and if so, are they at liberty to give the cost of either doing away with it or putting it in?
2:16:41 If those are my other questions
2:16:48 Okay
2:16:50 Stand by we might bring you back up and ask you some questions. Thank you, Julie
2:16:55 Is there anyone else here from the public that would like to come forward and testify this evening?
2:16:59 Okay, at this point we are closing the public testimony portion, however, keeping the public
2:17:08 hearing open in case there's any questions of Julie or staff or the applicant.
2:17:15 So I guess what we'll do is start, Jonathan, would you mind trying to answer or Mitch?
2:17:23 Answering the questions that Mrs. Davis had to see.
2:17:28 And some of it might be directed towards the developer, of course.
2:17:42 They were pointing at you.
2:17:44 Troy's sitting back.
2:17:45 Yeah, I'm just thinking about coming up.
2:17:49 I don't believe we define law and block anywhere at all.
2:17:54 So it would be, I'm just going to make sure of that here.
2:18:05 It would just be whatever we all decide is too long.
2:18:09 We as in city staff or as in council?
2:18:14 Sure, I would say with the approval of a plat,
2:18:18 that issue would come up and we would look at the situation
2:18:21 and say, oh, this is a little long.
2:18:24 It gets difficult to really put a lot of force behind
2:18:33 a definition that isn't later.
2:18:35 It's not crazy to mark.
2:18:37 So it's just a statement in the code that says long blocks.
2:18:39 You might want to do this.
2:18:40 Now, it also says, for convenient access to parks and schools
2:18:45 and shopping and those kinds of things.
2:18:46 And you can certainly make a good argument
2:18:48 that trail is something you would want
2:18:51 to provide convenient access to in that park category.
2:18:54 The linear park is what the trail is.
2:18:56 So it certainly fits that piece of that sentence
2:19:01 that you might want to consider a connection somewhere
2:19:03 in the block of a long block if we decide
2:19:06 that a quarter mile is a long walk or not.
2:19:10 We don't have a definition for it.
2:19:14 I don't believe in my nine year, 10 year that we've ever been really pushed on the issue either.
2:19:23 So I couldn't even tell you what we've done historically in this situation of long blocks.
2:19:30 I can talk about cul-de-sacs going up to streets like this currently is, but that street is also going away.
2:19:38 So the second part of that requirement isn't what's drawing the connection there
2:19:44 that street isn't going to be a street anymore.
2:19:46 If a street was going to stay, then every one of those
2:19:48 cul-de-sacs should have a walk way through.
2:19:51 The street's going way.
2:19:53 So that's usually what we do for those connections
2:19:58 is at the end of the cul-de-sacs.
2:19:59 It just kind of works out so that the long block question just
2:20:04 and they're never seeing it come up.
2:20:06 So I don't know how to answer it rather than to say that it's
2:20:09 not defined in the code anywhere.
2:20:11 and we haven't really seen it apply.
2:20:20 I have a couple other lights on,
2:20:22 but I want to make sure that we address her questions.
2:20:26 I think you've kind of answered the why
2:20:29 they would want to vacate it.
2:20:30 And the cost question, Tim?
2:20:36 The cost really is minimal compared to the cost
2:20:40 for this phase of this subdivision.
2:20:42 The bid came in over a million dollars on the current phase.
2:20:46 And a large part of that is turning a full roadway
2:20:52 into a walkable path along that part of the canyon room.
2:20:59 I think it was probably 2005, and we initially,
2:21:03 2004, 2005, and we initially met with the city on this.
2:21:07 And the current planning and zoning director
2:21:09 at that time, Mr. Wharton, was very wishful
2:21:15 that the developer would work with the city
2:21:16 and create Canyon Rim Road as a pedestrian easement path,
2:21:23 along with still being wide enough to accept utility
2:21:28 and emergency vehicles, which the developer worked
2:21:30 with the city on at that time and did.
2:21:33 That the main driving thing during that time
2:21:36 was the city's wish to be along the Canyon Rim.
2:21:38 The other one was the fact that so many people used it
2:21:41 at the time, and they still do,
2:21:45 even at this point in time, we were basically one way traffic right there now while we're
2:21:51 doing the remainder of the development of part view. And you still see quite a bit of foot
2:21:56 traffic along that roadway. It doesn't prove to be too long to them. The cost, again, is
2:22:02 really not an issue. The cost is going to be incurred and fencing in the ability to sell
2:22:09 lots with a pathway going down the middle of two lots. That's usually the biggest complaint
2:22:16 you get on something when you've got multiple paths on cobas, that's people don't get the
2:22:20 sense of privacy or security. So that's the intent.
2:22:25 Thank you, Tim. Thank you. Great planning. Just a quick question, and I'll relay it by
2:22:32 our answer later. But the current city, Jonathan or Mitch, or our current city block in Twin
2:22:38 Falls is typically one-eighth of a mile, correct? The link to one city block.
2:22:46 It's a trick question. I see nobody else getting up again. It really does vary
2:22:53 dramatically from location to location. So what is the example though, aren't
2:22:59 the ones? Let's take the president's streets. Okay, those are very grid-like
2:23:03 system aren't those blocks, they're like chute and haber and out those on 8th mile connections.
2:23:11 Troy wants to speak.
2:23:12 I'm sorry, I'm going to speak up here.
2:23:14 Troy VTech.
2:23:16 I'll just give you an example here. This is more than passages.
2:23:19 There's 10 lots there. These are 80 feet by lots. So 800 to 1,000 feet is usually
2:23:24 approximately what an average block is. But this is really up to the developers. They can space
2:23:30 a little bit more. We do have requirements for quarter mile roads. So every 1320 feet you have to have one, but that's about it.
2:23:38 Okay, thank you. Rebecca, now second.
2:23:42 Thank you, Mayor. My question was, sorry, I lost it. Now I'm distracted by the eighth mile block and how long is the block?
2:23:59 You can come back to me. Are there any other questions why Rebecca
2:24:03 I was going to follow up with Mitch's comment about determining what is a long block and so my question was just on the process that happened back in December of 2004, which is how, and so this is my question I just want to make sure I understand what has happened to this property to this point.
2:24:32 It came through a final plat and this requirement was put into the plat and so the planning and zoning commission and the council at that time felt that this was a long block and that's why they required it.
2:24:47 Is that accurate to say or?
2:24:56 So, again, not having been here at the time, it appears that that would be the case, so.
2:25:03 But it was probably like a special addition to the, the plan, an additional requirement place.
2:25:10 In the preliminary process, not the final process, but, but yeah, it would be, that would appear to be the case.
2:25:17 It looks like a long stretch, maybe poke another trail out connection.
2:25:20 I think, uh, Councilman Lansing was on P&Z at that time, so maybe he could answer the question.
2:25:25 I was on PNC in 2004 actually. Troy B. Tech represented so I was actually on the other
2:25:34 side of the fence. I was part of this plot. So I kind of have a little bit of history here.
2:25:39 I believe the reason they had the discussion and the requirement at the time was the Lamar
2:25:46 felt that there's a public park in this area and he felt that this connection would be more
2:25:53 Linear I guess the connection
2:25:57 So while you're still able to access it. I believe that's where where the requirement for that particular one came in
2:26:04 It wasn't why wasn't located elsewhere
2:26:06 And so is that still a plan to be a park there? That is actually currently a park in southern Ridge
2:26:13 Okay, and that park also has access from this cul-de-sac which is that we were
2:26:20 You know the lady that got up and spoke lives on North Fork
2:26:23 So there's a logical connection from park to the park.
2:26:30 There is no pathway through the park. It just has access to the park.
2:26:34 Right. Thank you.
2:26:36 Greg Lanning, I think you want to make.
2:26:37 I was actually going to concur. I was on planning a zoning at that time.
2:26:41 And that was the reasoning for it.
2:26:45 For both of those, actually, it was to access that park.
2:26:48 The connection that is there off of North Fork Road,
2:26:52 which is still there, there's a nice little concrete
2:26:55 with fences on both sides from the neighbors,
2:26:57 but fences up, connected into that park,
2:26:59 and that was the reasoning was to check,
2:27:01 connect the new Canyon Trail,
2:27:06 if it wanted a better term, to that park
2:27:09 by coming through there.
2:27:11 Part of it was considered because of possibilities
2:27:13 of parking access, and things people would park around
2:27:16 that park and get to the trail.
2:27:18 We always talk about trailheads and that's trailheads are a
2:27:21 person of it and I believe the preliminary plan had it on there
2:27:27 or we put it on.
2:27:28 I can't remember which the case was in 2004.
2:27:31 I just remember, I remember it being there when I saw this
2:27:35 vacation I immediately contacted Jonathan and asked that we
2:27:38 might be able to possibly have the minute from that because I
2:27:42 remember it being a trade off for something else.
2:27:44 We gave them something for putting that in but I can't
2:27:47 remember what it was so I'm not going to state that that's the case but do we have
2:27:53 any further questions for city staff the applicant or even the young lady that
2:27:58 testified earlier well we're beyond the public testimony portion of the hearing
2:28:09 this evening yes if we had a question for you are there any other questions
2:28:15 council before I turn it over to deliberation, closing the public hearing.
2:28:20 We are now deliberating.
2:28:24 Chris talking to him.
2:28:25 I would move to approve the vacation of the nonvehicular use of the 15 by 120 foot plotted
2:28:35 but undeveloped earnings and nonvehicular easement located between lots 41 and 42 block
2:28:41 one, the settlers read subdivision number three.
2:28:47 Second.
2:28:48 by Chris Talkingen, seconded by Sean Berger.
2:28:50 We have a couple of lights on, great glad.
2:28:53 Well, I'll be voting against this vacation,
2:28:56 so it's partially because of the history
2:28:58 that I talked about.
2:28:59 I believe this easily meets the code requirement
2:29:03 as a long block.
2:29:05 I made the previous reference to the fact
2:29:07 that posted blocks, many of the blocks in the city
2:29:10 are at 1.8 to slightly more than that.
2:29:12 This being actually a little more in a quarter mile,
2:29:15 when you figure that you have to come around the corner
2:29:17 and you have the distance of those lots there.
2:29:21 I believe that the planning is owning back then
2:29:24 felt as important and it was placed
2:29:27 into the preliminary plait on purpose.
2:29:30 And I hate to say it works like this,
2:29:33 but it feels like a little bit of an in-run,
2:29:35 the brown, what was required back then,
2:29:38 because both of those were put in at the same time,
2:29:40 the extension of North Fork Road into the park,
2:29:45 as well as this one to match up with the park
2:29:47 And to me, somebody in the past thought it was important enough to require it to be placed
2:29:52 in plenty of zoning and council at that time, and so I'm going to ask that we maintain this.
2:29:58 Those lots are huge.
2:29:59 Look at the size on those.
2:30:01 Those are 27,000 square foot lots.
2:30:04 They can certainly give up that little bit of trail there and put a fence down to for their
2:30:10 own feeling of protection, because they aren't going to have any protection anyway, because
2:30:15 they have to be open to the park.
2:30:17 through the trail. So that part to me that the security part really does a whole water.
2:30:23 I just think it's time that we we make sure that we make the canning rim trail as
2:30:28 accessible as possible and this will make it more accessible to not only the
2:30:33 neighborhood but places for people to park to get to get on to the trail by
2:30:37 using the areas around Northern Ridge Park. Thank you. We're back a mile so I can.
2:30:44 Thank you Mayor. I think Councilman Landing makes a good point about the past but my concern
2:30:53 is the current values of the community and what they want and we heard testimony tonight
2:31:00 on the value of trail connection and I think taking away dedicated trail connection would
2:31:07 actually be the opposite of what the community has told us they value about the future direction
2:31:15 of the City of Twin Falls through our strategic plan.
2:31:19 And I think it would actually be in violation of several objectives of our strategic plan.
2:31:24 And so it wouldn't be honoring the past or the current state of our community,
2:31:29 the values that we have today, those values which we're all sworn to represent,
2:31:35 and that I agree with.
2:31:38 I'm never a fan of giving away public right away, and no one's surprised by that.
2:31:44 But if there's a good reason, you know, if you no longer need it, or if you know, it's being relocated,
2:31:51 I certainly could support it, but tonight I just have not heard enough reason to remove dedicated public access to the canyon rim.
2:32:02 The canyon rim is a community's asset, and the community deserves access to it.
2:32:10 I believe that this is a long block and
2:32:13 The fact that there's a park there and a trail connection from a park to the canyon room
2:32:18 Road and then and then the trail goes on further connecting to another part of the neighborhood just
2:32:25 Provides further reason
2:32:27 To keep this connection. I think it's a value to the entire community
2:32:32 Especially to the neighbors who testified tonight
2:32:34 So in reading some of the comments from the planning and zoning discussion, there are a
2:32:44 few items that did stand out that I appreciated the concern.
2:32:49 One is that often in subdivisions we've seen that end up with these short trail connections
2:32:58 they become run down and maintained full of weeds. I am not concerned that that's going
2:33:06 to happen in this neighborhood. Looking at those two lots in particular, that this trail
2:33:12 runs between, I can't imagine, this is going to become a maintenance concern to not be
2:33:17 taken care of. I think there is space and ways to create buffer, berming, landscape, whatever
2:33:27 types of development around it to create the privacy and screening issues from the neighbors.
2:33:36 I would agree that having connectivity of our trail system across the community from hidden
2:33:43 lakes to, you know, this will be the far west end of our trail system and then continuing
2:33:52 through that development, it's important.
2:33:55 It's one of the last pieces of Canyon Rim Trail that we'll actually have in our community
2:34:01 and having the ability to access that easily, particularly where this is a residential subdivision.
2:34:07 I was looking at the rest of the trail.
2:34:09 We have many sections of quarter mile or longer trail sections that you can't access except
2:34:15 for at the ends of them.
2:34:17 They're currently next to undeveloped commercial properties.
2:34:19 When that happens, there will be accesses.
2:34:22 will not happen in a residential neighborhood because you can't just start
2:34:25 traipsing through people's yards. So I think it's an appropriate connection to
2:34:29 keep the trail system fluid and connect to those other amenities.
2:34:35 Great mining. I remembered, finally, I knew there was something in my mind that
2:34:41 the reasoning that it was one of the reasons it's placed there, the reasoning
2:34:46 was, that is also the reason why the bathroom was placed where it was on
2:34:50 Northern Ridge. This was an opportunity to have a direct connection to a restroom
2:34:55 which we have very little of on our trail and that's why one of the other
2:34:59 reason why I knew there was another thing but that was why the restroom was
2:35:02 placed where it was in the corner of Northern Ridge Park and then because it
2:35:08 had direct assets trails so somebody could actually have a restroom access
2:35:12 off of the trail. Suzanne Hopkins. I'm going to agree with the comments I've
2:35:18 I've heard to me this seems like an appropriate place for a trail head to connect in.
2:35:24 I know my family loves that little park there.
2:35:26 We spend a lot of time in that area and I think this subdivision has been wonderful.
2:35:32 I think it's a great asset to our city and to have that connection from that park to the Canyon Room Trail out there.
2:35:39 It only makes sense to me to leave it where it is.
2:35:42 Thank you, sir.
2:35:43 Anything further from council?
2:35:46 Leila Roquevo, please.
2:35:47 Jim Munn. No. Sean Berger. No. Chris
2:35:58 Talkington. Yes. Greg Lantane. No. Don
2:36:03 Hall. No. Rebecca Masleika. No. Suzanne
2:36:09 Hawkins. No. Motion. Fails. Six to
2:36:14 one. Council, do we have anything further?
2:36:21 We I did have a question. I heard a
2:36:24 couple council members talking about the
2:36:26 trail and the putting up fences along the trail as it develops. Mitch, can you remind
2:36:33 us how that works when someone develops near the trail they have to put up a certain standard
2:36:41 of fencing but it doesn't seem like it's very cohesive, uniform, there are sections without
2:36:50 Yes. So we'd necessarily have a requirement for fencing along the Canyon Rim Trail.
2:36:59 This neighborhood has some HOA fencing restrictions that the city isn't really a part of.
2:37:07 But trails just gently around, we don't usually require development of them.
2:37:13 Unless there's like a safety hazard and then we'll put like a safety fence.
2:37:19 Well, really the question is not so much this development here is what I'm talking about but when you get down by Canyon Crest and
2:37:26 Some of those other areas. I know that they were required to put a certain standard fencing along certain sections
2:37:33 Is it because of hazard?
2:37:35 On the rim side? Yeah on the rim side
2:37:36 Yeah, where there is a safety concern where the trail is too close to maybe a cliff, okay?
2:37:42 Then we'll have some fencing when we do put fencing up we have a particular standard of fence that we like but we don't
2:37:48 necessarily just offhand require fencing all the way up and down the track.
2:37:51 So it's a safety concern if there is a location.
2:37:54 And then there's a stand of clothes, very good.
2:37:56 I think Chris has a question.
2:37:57 Well, I walked there quite a bit and first of all, it's a beautiful new improvement.
2:38:01 The section connecting, pulling in Eastland, that's about a third of a mile loop there.
2:38:08 And the fencing just went up here this last week on it.
2:38:12 But the fact that the fencing was going up and there was not many areas where it's
2:38:17 very close, actually, the Canyon Rim, maybe a couple, but then you proceed to the West,
2:38:23 and on either side of the bridge, there are sections that are very close to the drop-off
2:38:29 that have no fencing whatsoever.
2:38:31 So I don't see the consistency in how and when we require fencing at all.
2:38:39 How do we determine if it's too close, not close enough?
2:38:44 What's the measure?
2:38:46 I'm sorry to hit you cold the question came up tonight. So I thought I'd ask so
2:38:50 I don't think there's a real firm answer to it. It's just kind of like a little
2:38:57 closest but what not really it's about that scientific it's nothing more firm.
2:39:04 Well Don I would really suggest we have the city look at that section between
2:39:09 really the bridge going west up to behind Canyon Park West there are a couple
2:39:16 is there that I think actually present a safety hazard.
2:39:21 I agree, Mitch, is that possible for us to go and take a review of that and then maybe let us know what you find out?
2:39:27 Of course, the issue.
2:39:29 Yeah, yeah. Perfect. All right. If there's nothing further council, we are adjourned.
2:39:34 This is going over there, get all our signs and premises eyes.
Download
- Transcript (text) 143 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 192 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 262 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 16.4 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 16, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:39:54.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
fb265473c3890c4fc953c09ff006dcdd01f3b14441d681d424514f95a8606186 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 2 passages muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a b11ce5c2c5f90d1eb1596e11bace1d7025fa8f9a6da6a351fabf6960d4a496d7
part02.m4a 52026fbd3624d089f78e0f08d21116b3c1da64be8b50ca3c315e295a6ae665c6 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 8 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
e9559f4b2005884b63060d8f556ef51ef86fee339c0769532cf50db0674dddff
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file