City Council meeting
Monday, March 9, 2015
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:07:21 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. It's March 9th, 2015,
0:07:26 and it is 5 o'clock in the afternoon. We always start our meetings off with Pledge of Allegiance,
0:07:32 and today we have some Girl Scouts that have volunteered to come forward and lead us. Ladies,
0:07:37 if you'd come forward, for the rest of us, please rise. We want to get the other ladies
0:07:48 Wait, look, what's up? I want all the ladies up here first. Okay, all yours.
0:07:57 Let us sit down ladies, and then if you could state your, what is it called?
0:08:19 law if you could state the law let's give those ladies a hand thank you ladies
0:08:49 we'll be calling you up here in just a minute I do want to confirm that we have
0:08:52 a quorum of the city council this evening all seven members are here Mr.
0:08:56 Rothwiler do we have any amendments to our agenda mayor members of the council
0:09:02 we do have a few amendments to the agenda this evening the first is on the
0:09:09 We consent to calendar item number two.
0:09:13 We would ask that the council move that to item of consideration and it appear as your
0:09:18 first item this evening.
0:09:22 Additionally we have sent out some corrected minutes.
0:09:27 They were handed out and we would just note that for the record that the corrected minutes
0:09:33 would be a part of the modified packet.
0:09:39 I believe that we also on the, well,
0:09:42 let's go ahead and make that motion to move that if we would.
0:09:45 Greg Lanning, I move that we amend the agenda
0:09:47 as recommended by our city manager,
0:09:50 trail provider.
0:09:52 Second.
0:09:52 And motion on four to amend the agenda
0:09:55 by moving item number two under consent calendar
0:09:57 to item number one under items for consideration,
0:10:01 Greg Lanning making that motion,
0:10:03 Sean Berger, seconding now.
0:10:05 Anything further on that motion council?
0:10:07 And the amended minutes.
0:10:08 on the well and then both things second good with that anything further on the
0:10:16 motion council the other roll call vote please Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim
0:10:21 Munn yes Sean Burger yes Chris talking yes Greg Lan team yes Don Hall yes Rebecca
0:10:28 Mills like that yes motion passes seven to zero we will now move to after the
0:10:35 Proclamation Girl Scout Week 2015. I have the pleasure of reading them. Girl Scout Week
0:10:42 2015, whereas March 12th, 2015, marks the 103rd anniversary of the Girl Scouts of the USA
0:10:50 founded by Juliet Gordon Lowe in 1912 in Savannah, Georgia. And whereas throughout its distinguished
0:10:57 history, Girl Scouting has inspired millions of girls and women with the highest ideals
0:11:04 of courage, confidence, and character, and whereas girls discover, connect, and take action
0:11:11 to make their local communities and the world a better place.
0:11:15 And whereas more than 2.8 million current Girl Scout members nationwide will be celebrating
0:11:22 the 103 years of this American tradition with 59 million women who are former Girl Scouts
0:11:30 and living proof of the impact of this amazing movement.
0:11:34 Now therefore, I, Don Hall, by virtue of the authority vested in me as the Mayor of the
0:11:39 City of Twin Falls, do hereby applaud the commitment Girl Scout has made to America's
0:11:44 girls and proudly proclaim the week of March 8th through the 14th, 2015, as Girl Scout week,
0:11:52 and I have signed as the Mayor as well as Leah LaSenchas, as our Deputy City Clerk, and
0:11:57 This time I'll move down and hand this to Nancy.
0:12:22 Basically does this proclamation every year.
0:12:24 Right.
0:12:25 No, you think it's smelly or something.
0:12:36 Here we go.
0:12:37 Of course I've never heard anything.
0:12:40 This is the end of the item.
0:12:46 We'll take a longer than any other.
0:12:48 Anything software.
0:12:57 We don't have anything chocolate right now.
0:13:01 Anything.
0:13:03 Just be a little bit.
0:13:05 Oh, that's the one I wanted.
0:13:06 Those are yours.
0:13:07 I'm talking about free oils and savannas.
0:13:09 You mean the savannas?
0:13:10 I was able to help.
0:13:11 Thank you very much for that, it will help these girls with great leadership skills and
0:14:23 they will be giving back, so thank you very much.
0:14:26 Thank you, and ladies, thank you for coming to me, congratulations.
0:14:33 the agenda is general public input.
0:14:35 Is there anyone from the public that would like to come forward and
0:14:40 state anything to the council this evening, engage the council?
0:14:44 I see no one coming forward, so we're now moving down to the consent calendar.
0:14:48 Greg Manning.
0:14:50 Mayor, I'd like to remove item six for some discussion.
0:14:55 I think we might have a couple things that need to be moved for
0:15:00 discussion, so we'll wait on all of them.
0:15:02 That'll work six.
0:15:04 Sean Berger.
0:15:05 Okay, yes, Mr. Mayor, I'd request that item number seven be removed from the consent calendar as I am a neighboring property owner.
0:15:14 So I may recuse myself.
0:15:16 Very good.
0:15:16 And so six and seven, is there anything else?
0:15:20 Travis, were we going to remove, oh, never mind, we already did that.
0:15:26 So we are good to go.
0:15:28 So six and seven, do we have a motion in that respect?
0:15:30 So we have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills, so I guess, seconded by Jim Mun.
0:15:37 Any further on that motion council?
0:15:40 The roll call vote, please.
0:15:42 Jim Munn.
0:15:42 Yes.
0:15:43 Sean Berger.
0:15:44 Yes.
0:15:45 Chris Chalkington.
0:15:46 Yes.
0:15:47 Greg Lansing.
0:15:48 Yes.
0:15:49 Don Hall.
0:15:50 Yes.
0:15:51 Rebecca Masuika.
0:15:52 Yes.
0:15:53 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:15:54 Yes.
0:15:55 Motion passes seven zero, so I will stand for a motion to, for the rest of the consent calendar,
0:15:57 Sean Carrot.
0:15:58 I would move approval of the balance of the consent calendar items.
0:16:03 I would have had a chance to talk about six shit though.
0:16:07 These are the ones that weren't removed.
0:16:08 Yeah, they're not we're just going to the ones that were removed. So, okay. All right.
0:16:11 All right. Most of us to remove six and six. Yes. I'm sorry. I didn't realize we had
0:16:16 that motion for that. My fault. Do we have a second on? I'll second. We have a second
0:16:21 on that motion to approve the remaining items on consent calendar by Sean Berger, seconded
0:16:25 by Rebecca Milsoyka. We got it. We'll call vote. Yes. Sean Berger. Yes. Chris talking
0:16:32 to us. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milsoyka. Yes. Susan Hawkins.
0:16:38 Yes, Jim on yes, motion passes seven to zero.
0:16:42 So we will start with item number six.
0:16:44 I think that one was yours.
0:16:46 Yes, I was wondering if it was representative
0:16:48 for the your storeers here or your story himself.
0:16:53 Might be here.
0:17:03 Well, I'm and I talked to you once earlier
0:17:06 on the phone about this.
0:17:07 I've had several neighbors contact me
0:17:09 to her live in business point number one in the city.
0:17:12 First, I want to make sure in the city manager wants me
0:17:14 make sure you know that the city does no enforcement for CCNOCs.
0:17:18 That is actually the actual committees and things like that.
0:17:21 So I guess I was wondering what the, their recourse is,
0:17:26 and this was my opportunity since I saw binos
0:17:28 week number two coming on for the final plan to,
0:17:31 I was hoping Mr. Storey might be asked,
0:17:33 what is their recourse as far as feeling that some
0:17:36 of their CCNRs have not been enforced,
0:17:39 and what is their recourse to maybe get them enforced,
0:17:41 and is the architectural committee still active
0:17:45 or do they need to form their own?
0:17:46 Will it be the same one for Beno's point two
0:17:49 as it is for one and they're the separate
0:17:52 or commingled or just those are the questions they have.
0:17:55 Gerald, if you would introduce yourself
0:17:57 and you have about seven questions to answer.
0:17:59 Yeah, sorry.
0:18:00 I was trying to remember that, no, I lost track.
0:18:05 Yeah, my name is Gerald Martin's EH Image Years,
0:18:08 our firm prepared the final plan
0:18:10 that's before you this evening.
0:18:11 I was only here just to make sure that this didn't happen,
0:18:16 but when you pulled it from the agenda,
0:18:19 I knew what you were going to say.
0:18:20 So, yeah, Mr. Landon did ask me about this.
0:18:24 I have followed up with it, and I think
0:18:26 he's specifically concerned, for the most part,
0:18:29 about failure to three or four of the loss
0:18:33 to complete the front yard landscaping,
0:18:36 and or maintain their front yard landscaping
0:18:38 that was installed.
0:18:40 Is that correct?
0:18:41 Well, mostly the initial put in because the CCNR say that it should be done by the builder.
0:18:49 That's correct.
0:18:50 And so in the chain of command here, the chain of Mr. Storer is a developer.
0:19:00 He sells a lot subject to the builder, subject to the CCNRs.
0:19:06 The CCNR could be implemented, whether it's the color of the houses or the siding or rough
0:19:16 pitch or landscaping is the responsibility of the builder.
0:19:23 I have identified there are two lots.
0:19:27 I know that the landscaping was never installed.
0:19:30 I have contacted that builder, and he has assured me that they will follow up with the homeowner.
0:19:41 The home, what happened in both those cases and in many sales, a credit was given to the
0:19:47 buyer to do his own landscaping as part of the transaction.
0:19:51 But it is, I believe, the responsibility of the builder to go back and take care.
0:20:01 He's the one that received the credit, and he acknowledges that.
0:20:05 So I guess I don't have any document here tonight for sure that's going to happen, but
0:20:11 I can assure you that I won't again follow up with it.
0:20:15 And specific to that subdivision, I do not believe there is an organized active.
0:20:26 It is created, the Homeowners Association is created, but it's not active.
0:20:33 You know, nobody stepped up to enforce the regulations.
0:20:37 After the architectural review, the architectural review component is just a piece of that, and
0:20:46 those were done on each and every home.
0:20:48 It had the right amount of siting, the right amount of trim, the right pitch of the roof,
0:20:53 the right square footage, the right setbacks and all of that, but it's the builder and
0:20:59 or the homeowners that failed to implement what was approved on the plans.
0:21:08 The only the only recourse that I could even suggest is a builder and I don't know what
0:21:13 the route to get there is other than peer pressure on him before he gets any additional
0:21:21 lots to build.
0:21:23 The one question they have is that I know that in a lot of neighborhoods they went ahead
0:21:27 and they've reformed their CCNR committee or whatever you want to call it.
0:21:32 Could you get to me or through Gary what that process would be?
0:21:37 I know they have to go out and get pictures and think, but what that process is and I'll deliver to them
0:21:42 so they make you could reform the CCNR committee for the Benels Point One I'm talking.
0:21:47 The CCNR is of course a form and recorded and it's very specific with the authority of the association is I mean
0:21:59 I just had a bylaws and they recorded and I can get you a copy of that
0:22:02 Well I have a sense of the bylaws I just wasn't sure what what the process or have you never encouraged in somebody to start a new
0:22:10 The process basically is you have a whole of neighborhood meeting and at that neighborhood meeting you led the collective board and directors
0:22:17 And then the Board of Directors,
0:22:19 the likes of President, Vice President,
0:22:22 Secretary Trager, and they have the right to assess,
0:22:25 first of all, to assess all of the homeowners
0:22:28 to maintain the common area and to operate the association.
0:22:32 And secondly, they have the right in that
0:22:34 through that association to proceed and complete
0:22:39 the work that hasn't been done and through the tax
0:22:42 and get that on the tax rolls and recover
0:22:45 from the property owner.
0:22:46 Okay, I will pass that information on.
0:22:48 Thank you, Gerald.
0:22:49 I'll get you a draft of that.
0:22:50 There's a few more lights,
0:22:51 but first I would like to ask you a real quick question.
0:22:54 I know Greg's bringing this to our attention,
0:22:56 but do we have any standing when it comes to CCRs?
0:23:00 I mean, City has no standing.
0:23:02 Okay, okay, I just wanted to make sure that
0:23:04 I was just asking a question that was brought to me
0:23:08 by some citizens.
0:23:09 Okay, okay.
0:23:10 Really, usually it's just to answer that.
0:23:13 It really, it really beholds on the developer to do it because I'll guarantee you a poorly
0:23:25 developed phase one does not encourage marketing in phase two.
0:23:29 And so I think the developer along with those two builders and those builders are active
0:23:35 builders currently.
0:23:37 And I think we'll get that taken care of.
0:23:39 Appreciate it.
0:23:40 Thank you.
0:23:41 Thank you, Mayor.
0:23:43 I also had a question on item six.
0:23:45 I was hoping that Greg would ask my question, but apparently he had a different question.
0:23:49 Mine is more for staff.
0:23:51 I see that this final plat, the subdivision is in the CRO, the canyon rim overlay area.
0:23:58 And I was wondering, I know that we require a trail along our other canyon rim.
0:24:03 Is there any planned trail that we require along the rock creek canyon rim?
0:24:10 I don't see one on the plot, so that just made me curious.
0:24:20 So, um,
0:24:21 Magic could you introduce yourself for the office?
0:24:23 Yeah, Mitch Humble, W.C. Manager.
0:24:25 We require trails to be constructed where there's a trail shown on the trail master plan.
0:24:30 Not necessarily along the canyon rims.
0:24:32 Now, there happens to be a trail shown on the canyon rim,
0:24:35 the Snake River Canyon rim on the master,
0:24:36 the trail master plan, so I was just trying to open up a trail master plan in here
0:24:41 to make sure that, and I believe in that section the trail is actually in the canyon,
0:24:46 not on the rim, but I'll find the master plan here and we'll make sure of that, but yeah.
0:24:53 Oh, and yeah, so I thought you were going to bring it up.
0:24:56 I'm still trying to find it.
0:24:58 Okay, well while you're looking, you know, I just, I thought of that this weekend when
0:25:03 I had the opportunity to walk that new section of trail that we put in by Pillar Falls, the
0:25:09 view is amazing.
0:25:10 And our trails are something that we can be proud of and that really benefit our citizens,
0:25:15 know for future generations and so I would hope that even now as we're updating our parks
0:25:21 and Rec Master Plan we can take a look at that so that we can plan for the future and really
0:25:27 take advantage of this opportunity and have the foresight because I know as we're trying
0:25:32 to connect our Canyon Rim Trail on the north end, their house is in the way and there are
0:25:38 things blocking the connection that make it difficult.
0:25:43 And so maybe if the next time, maybe you can inform us of the next time the Parks and Rec Master Plan is meeting,
0:25:52 maybe we can take a look at that and see what plans we can make to implement a trail system along the rock creek canyon.
0:26:03 Yeah, I'll have to find out from Dennis when the next meeting is going to be there.
0:26:08 You're undergoing that update right now, as you all know.
0:26:11 Great.
0:26:12 So, yeah, we'll send a note out when that meeting's coming up.
0:26:14 Yeah, and it can only enrich that neighborhood.
0:26:17 I mean, it brings value and quality of life to the subdivisions as well.
0:26:22 Ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to let Sean Berger weigh in because he has the answer.
0:26:26 The next meeting of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan Steering Committee is Thursday,
0:26:31 March 19th at 6 p.m. here.
0:26:35 Thank you.
0:26:36 Thank you, Sean.
0:26:37 And I might weigh in on that just a bit.
0:26:41 There is not a trail along this canyon, but there is public space preserved so that if
0:26:45 anybody ever chose to put a trail in it good, but it's part of this project we've worked
0:26:50 with Dennis on a park that fronts the entire frontage of this project has public space that
0:26:57 It'll be landscaped by the developer in a,
0:27:00 I guess in a very passive manner.
0:27:03 So that doesn't require city maintenance crews,
0:27:07 but there is preserved the corridor along the rim,
0:27:10 along the front edge of this subdivision.
0:27:12 So that the public can get along the canyon rim,
0:27:16 they just don't have a trail at this point in time,
0:27:18 but the right of way does exist, thank you.
0:27:20 Okay, one question on that.
0:27:22 How wide is that public?
0:27:24 The partner?
0:27:25 Yeah.
0:27:26 Well, it varies probably up.
0:27:27 There's a part of it, a stormwater retention area, part of it, so it's probably 150 feet
0:27:33 up to 150 feet in width.
0:27:35 Okay.
0:27:36 So it's a white strip.
0:27:37 Thank you.
0:27:38 Thank you, Gerald.
0:27:39 Chris, talking.
0:27:40 Well, actually, I think my point had been clarified.
0:27:42 I misunderstood to Gerald earlier to indicate that if homeowners have problems with CC and
0:27:49 our CCR development or enforcement that that was a responsibility that falls back on the
0:27:58 builder. I've always understood it be to the developer that formed the CC in our structure.
0:28:05 Is that how you had indicated it? I misunderstood. I want to make sure any residents that are
0:28:10 listening viewing tonight know that their recourse is against the developer, not a builder, a
0:28:15 The obligation to implement goes to the builder, but the
0:28:20 ultimate responsibility is with the developer. So if the
0:28:24 developer doesn't perform, I think any owner has
0:28:28 the ability to go through the back to the developer
0:28:32 and the homeowners association.
0:28:36 Thank you. Information, but the
0:28:40 homeowners association is structured to deal with
0:28:44 these issues either through peer pressure.
0:28:51 If that doesn't work, then I guess you do assessments,
0:28:54 and if that doesn't work, I guess ultimately,
0:28:57 you end up in the court system to enforce
0:29:00 that the owners complying with the covenants.
0:29:08 Thank you, Gerald.
0:29:08 Thank you, Lenny.
0:29:09 Those covenants, those covenants,
0:29:11 stay with the property perpetually.
0:29:13 Great mining. Here are one more question. I know this and this might be
0:29:18 actually staff for an year there Joe, or for our bitch. This particular
0:29:25 subdivision, this portion of it never reaches park and so there's no streets
0:29:31 going through the park and so do we have a requirement on how many egresses and
0:29:37 things that we need to have into the, because all the realistically almost
0:29:43 all of us is going to come down noble for about a half a block or for course block and
0:29:48 then turn on Heidi and go into the subdivision. So is that enough with the
0:29:52 highland on the other end? Is that enough for what we normally require or?
0:29:57 Yeah, so we have a requirement with single family lots that not more than 30 can
0:30:02 come off a single point. And if you can find your way through other streets with
0:30:07 two different means of access then you're good and there's there's multiple.
0:30:11 actually is two other ones like I didn't even realize that one street went through clear down there
0:30:16 But it does I was
0:30:17 One one day and I realized it went through when I ran around looking together things. So all right. Thank you
0:30:23 Any further questions on that item? I'll stand for a motion to approve
0:30:28 Item number six because the number seven still fold off
0:30:31 I'm moved to approve item number six
0:30:35 Second that motion on four by great planning seconded by Chris talking then we recommend so I
0:30:40 Oh, before you vote, I was just wondering, it looks like Mitch maybe has something for us?
0:30:45 No, it's additional socks. Okay. Oh, maybe.
0:30:47 On the trail. I'm sorry. Yeah, we did have that.
0:30:49 I don't have my laser pointer, so I'm going to point with my pen here.
0:30:52 So the dark line that's the solid line that's here is the existing rock creek trail,
0:31:02 and then it turns into a dash line right down here,
0:31:05 which is basically a continuation of the existing trails you go down rock creek.
0:31:09 So this trail is on the trail master plan is in the in the canyon rather than up on the rim and so that's
0:31:16 That's why there wouldn't have been one required
0:31:20 necessarily
0:31:21 To comply with the trail master plan. Okay. Thank you
0:31:25 We have motion on the floor anything further on that motion
0:31:28 We have a roll call. Oh, please
0:31:30 Chris talking to yes great glancing. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca milsoka. Yes
0:31:36 Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Jim Munn. Yes, Sean Verigar. Yes, motion passes seven to zero. Item number seven was pulled up due to conflict.
0:31:47 And so I believe that Sean will be recusing himself, Greg. Move approval. Item number seven.
0:31:54 Second. Motion on four by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve item number seven on the consent calendar, anything further on that motion council?
0:32:05 The ailerole called the clerk.
0:32:07 Greg Lanting yes.
0:32:08 Don Hall yes.
0:32:10 Rebecca Mills like that yes.
0:32:12 Suzanne Hawkins yes.
0:32:14 Jim Munn yes.
0:32:15 Chris talking yes.
0:32:17 Motion passes six in favor one accused.
0:32:22 And ladies and gentlemen we're off the consent calendar.
0:32:24 Moving on to items for consideration will be item number one
0:32:28 where we moved it down to is consideration of a request
0:32:31 to approve a barren wine license for Leslie Cooper Smith,
0:32:35 doing business as Coops at 1703 Addison Avenue East.
0:32:39 And I believe Mitch Humboldt will cover this for us.
0:32:41 Mitch.
0:32:43 Thanks.
0:32:45 First by apologize for being nice to the meeting.
0:32:48 We have this alcohol permit for Coops.
0:32:52 Part of the alcohol permit process
0:32:53 is for the city planning zoning department
0:32:56 to sign off that the zoning is appropriate
0:32:58 for the issuance of a license.
0:33:02 And so when you have, in the zoning ordinance,
0:33:04 when you have a restaurant that's gonna sell alcohol
0:33:07 for onsite consumption in that restaurant
0:33:09 is within 300 feet of residence,
0:33:11 as that requires a special use permit.
0:33:13 And there is not a special use permit
0:33:16 that is enforced and active on this property right now
0:33:19 for that use.
0:33:21 Having said that, there was one that went through the process
0:33:25 for a different restaurant at the same location.
0:33:27 in 2011, that was issued, the special use permit was issued,
0:33:33 but the use was never established, meaning that the holder
0:33:37 of the SUP never went and got their alcohol license.
0:33:40 So the sales of alcohol is the need for the SUP, not
0:33:44 the restaurant, and they never got their alcohol license,
0:33:46 so they never really implemented the use
0:33:48 that they had gotten the SUP for.
0:33:50 Our code actually has a provision in it
0:33:52 when you have an SUP that's been issued,
0:33:55 but the use has not been established,
0:33:57 then the Planning and Zoning Commission can take a look
0:34:00 at that without going through a whole new SUP process
0:34:04 and decide whether or not to just allow that SUP
0:34:07 to apply later.
0:34:09 And so that can happen, and there's a Planning and Zoning
0:34:12 Commission meeting tomorrow night where that can happen.
0:34:16 The planning, her plan would be to go to that,
0:34:19 Planning and Zoning Commission meeting at this
0:34:20 isn't a agenda item for that agenda.
0:34:23 have them look at the SUP that they approved back in 2011
0:34:28 and decide if there's enough significant differences now
0:34:31 to that request, whether to go back through a hearing
0:34:35 process or not.
0:34:37 If they approve, I'm not sure what to call that request,
0:34:41 but if they decide that there is no real significant difference
0:34:46 between the two requests and the 2011 SUP can stand,
0:34:50 then they can make that choice tomorrow night.
0:34:52 If that happens, then this alcohol license can be issued.
0:34:57 If they instead say, you know, things are different, that was then,
0:35:01 this is now, you need to go through your own hearing process,
0:35:04 then we'll do that, and there'll be a notice requirement,
0:35:07 and we'll show up at probably a month from now by the time it actually gets noticed
0:35:12 and everything taken care of.
0:35:14 The thought was that tonight the council could, if you elected to,
0:35:18 you could approve this alcohol license subject to the decision
0:35:21 the decision being made by the planning and zoning commission
0:35:23 tomorrow night.
0:35:24 In fact, decision isn't made.
0:35:27 Then we'll come back after a new SGP is granted.
0:35:31 But we would need that to be stated in your motion
0:35:34 for approval tonight, subject to P&Z action tomorrow night,
0:35:39 essentially.
0:35:40 Thank you.
0:35:41 There's Shambir.
0:35:43 Shambir?
0:35:45 Could it not be just conditioned upon the issuance
0:35:47 of a special use permit and leave it to the planning and zoning
0:35:50 commission to either go through that process tomorrow or later or later now
0:35:55 after I hear but if we just made it continued upon that do either way I would
0:35:59 assume that's correct
0:36:03 Chris talking I thought you're gonna motion that I was going to but then
0:36:07 there's a whole Christmas tree no over here so why don't you make the motion so
0:36:13 I would make a motion to approve the beer and wine license request for coops
0:36:20 contingent upon issuance of a special use permit by the Planning and Zoning Commission.
0:36:25 Sorry for that.
0:36:26 Motion on 4 by Sean Bearer, seconded by Chris Talkington.
0:36:30 Now the Christmas tree as we describe Rebecca Milsick.
0:36:34 Thank you Mayor.
0:36:35 I just wanted to ask and make sure that the owner has been notified and they know to show up tomorrow at the Planning and Zoning Commission if they so choose.
0:36:45 I believe.
0:36:47 I mean, yeah, I'm running ahead of conversation with Representative of the owner this afternoon.
0:36:52 Great, thank you.
0:36:53 Jim.
0:36:54 Thank you, Mayor.
0:36:55 My only concern here is that SUP was issued four years ago.
0:37:01 And we've been very, very clear as a council that we believe that the proper notification
0:37:06 of residence is even expanded over the last, in our zoning stuff, in our zoning changes
0:37:12 and so forth.
0:37:13 becoming more proactive in the notification of residents in and around areas that are going to be changed.
0:37:20 This is four years ago.
0:37:21 We could have a significant number of new residents in that area who would not have an opportunity to vent this matter if they so wished.
0:37:28 So I'm going to vote no on this and require them to go through the initial SUP process.
0:37:35 Thank you, Jim.
0:37:35 Anything further?
0:37:37 Leanna, roll call vote, please.
0:37:41 Don Hall?
0:37:42 Yes.
0:37:44 Rebecca Milsoyka?
0:37:45 Yes.
0:37:47 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:37:48 No. Jim Munn. No. Sean Berriger. Yes.
0:37:53 Chris Talkington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes.
0:37:57 Motion passes 5-2-2.
0:38:02 Next item on the agenda is a presentation of the city of
0:38:06 Twin Falls 2014 audited financial statement made
0:38:10 statements by Mulkey Hunsaker and company
0:38:14 PLLC. We have Lori Race as well as Scott Hunsaker
0:38:18 here this evening, and Jim has just been waiting for this event.
0:38:22 You know, I am a quick study and I learned from those Girl Scouts. I think next time we
0:38:30 have any kind of financial presentation, I'll be bringing cookies.
0:38:34 There you go. So good evening mayor and city council. Idaho Code 67450B states, the governing
0:38:43 body of a local governmental entity whose annual expenditures from all sources exceeds $250,000
0:38:52 shall cause a full and complete audit of its financial statements to be made each fiscal
0:38:57 year.
0:38:58 So we've complied with that code and we also feel that it's important to have a formal
0:39:03 presentation of the audit findings made to you, the governing body of the city of Quinn.
0:39:09 We do this because we believe it adds another layer of transparency to city finances and
0:39:14 government.
0:39:16 We believe that the audit presents presentation, adds validity and credibility to what we're
0:39:21 doing.
0:39:22 And it provides an independent review and appraisal of how we are handling taxpayer dollars so
0:39:27 you'll be receiving an unbiased expert review.
0:39:31 The finance team headed by Brent Hyatt put together an audit plan and Susan Klein began
0:39:37 her field work in late December, and she completed that February 19th, which is the date of the
0:39:42 financial statements. Scott Hunsaker with Mulkey Hunsaker and Company is here this evening to
0:39:48 present those audit findings and audit opinion for the City of Twin Falls 2014 financial statements.
0:39:55 So you should have all received an electronic copy in your agenda packet. We wanted to make
0:40:00 sure you had that so that you could review it in case you had any questions for Scott
0:40:04 while he's here this evening.
0:40:06 So with that, I'll turn it over to Scott.
0:40:08 Thank you, Lori.
0:40:09 Welcome, Scott.
0:40:15 It's good to be with you, Mr. Mayor and Council.
0:40:21 We'll try to use this.
0:40:22 I know that you've received electronic copies,
0:40:24 so I have what I'm talking about right in front of you,
0:40:27 but we'll try to show what I'm talking about up there.
0:40:32 But it's good to be here.
0:40:34 It represents the ending of an audit significant amount of time.
0:40:39 on the audit for the city staff and well as our staff.
0:40:42 So it's good to be here to present the audit to you.
0:40:47 I won't take long, we'll hit some highlights
0:40:49 and move on with any questions you may have.
0:40:53 Really, if I were looking at this,
0:40:55 there'd be three things that I would suggest
0:40:57 that you look at would be,
0:40:58 the first would be the audit opinion.
0:41:00 Next would be the management's discussion analysis
0:41:02 and finally the findings in the back,
0:41:06 The last couple of pages.
0:41:09 First would be the audit opinion that I just mentioned on pages one and two.
0:41:14 It's an unqualified opinion and it's actually a standard letter.
0:41:20 There's no deviations from that letter because you do present management's discussion and analysis.
0:41:26 So that is the most important thing for you to hear the unqualified opinion.
0:41:33 Here a few months ago when we discussed internal controls, what we put our role is with the internal controls,
0:41:40 and just to follow up on that discussion, we did test the internal controls
0:41:46 with sampling methods and other things like that that we don't need to get in detail with,
0:41:51 but nothing was found to deviate from your internal controls,
0:41:54 or nothing that was noted that needed to be disclosed, so that's very good.
0:42:00 The next section is the management's discussion analysis and and the title describes what it really is
0:42:07 It's it's the management management's required to write this
0:42:11 And they have the city staff wrote this and it's really I won't present much more than what's here
0:42:18 Tonight because it's it's very well written and summarizes the significant events that have happened for this fiscal year
0:42:25 notably the transactions between the urban renewal and the
0:42:28 the city as noted in the first bullet point there.
0:42:34 A significant transaction between Jibani.
0:42:38 Next, there's some, again, some urban and rural activities.
0:42:42 Saying if these weren't there, these contributions,
0:42:45 how much would the net assets increase?
0:42:48 Change in policy, there's noted of transferring
0:42:52 from the general fund to the capital improvement fund.
0:42:55 And finally, the wastewater treatment plant,
0:42:57 bonds for that project. There's there's great information here back with
0:43:04 comparative numbers that you can go through in the management discussion analysis
0:43:08 graphs and things like that for each review and lastly the internal control
0:43:15 document at the very end the last couple pages Lawrence. What pages for those
0:43:21 That's 89, 89, 90, 90 on.
0:43:29 Scroll.
0:43:30 Way down to the bottom.
0:43:33 Jim does memorize this, but I thought that I would just.
0:43:38 Yeah, and really, this is a standard letter.
0:43:43 There was no internal control deficiencies or significant weaknesses that we noted during
0:43:49 that talk about before.
0:43:52 So those three things are kind of highlights for you to hit if you don't have a couple
0:43:56 hours to sit and read through this whole document.
0:43:59 But those are things that I would want to look at if I were sitting in your seats.
0:44:04 But overall went very well.
0:44:06 We appreciate the city's staff's help with getting everything done and getting it to a
0:44:13 timely manner.
0:44:14 It works very well.
0:44:15 So if you need any more detail, I'd be glad to give it to you.
0:44:18 I'm not sure how much detail, but we've got a lot right here.
0:44:22 But we depend on Chris talking to a lot on these matters because I believe he read the whole thing. I
0:44:26 Appreciate him
0:44:28 Talking to well Jim was been my mentor
0:44:32 But I want to have his currents
0:44:36 It is I want to have assurance and light at what has happened with several public agencies of late
0:44:43 including our community college
0:44:45 that all dealings with cash items in particular
0:44:50 receiving or following the very strict protocols of not having people receiving
0:44:57 money that make deposits and yada yada. I want to have absolute assurance that we
0:45:03 run a tight ship even in excess of the minimal requirements, Scott. It's a very
0:45:08 good point and question. Absolute assurance is kind of strong, but I
0:45:15 I understand what you're saying, in the environment we're in there, there is some concern in that area, absolutely.
0:45:24 What we do is go in and look at the control structure and see how those receiving processes happen, and make sure that the structure is in place that it could prevent something from happening.
0:45:39 And then we go in and select sample of items to make sure that that process is being followed.
0:45:45 Now we don't look at every single transaction, so to say absolute assurance may be a little
0:45:51 bit strong.
0:45:53 But we can say that we tested and the items that we have tested comply and do exceed standard
0:46:00 protocol.
0:46:01 You have very, very strong internal controls here and test receding is no different.
0:46:08 handled very, very well here. So I don't know if I answered or check this.
0:46:12 Well, let me just throw out one one other additional if I can don't. Are we adequately
0:46:20 funding the financial section of our budget to assure that we have enough floating ombud
0:46:30 troubleshooters, forensic auditors, drop in unexpectedly.
0:46:35 I don't want us to pare down our expenses at the cost of losing public respect.
0:46:42 If we need additional inspectors some way or something, you might additionally boost our confidence.
0:46:49 You know, I'm open to that, okay?
0:46:51 We cannot in Twin Falls or any public agency afford to lose the public's trust.
0:46:58 Yeah, I think it funded very well
0:47:03 Could there be more additional procedures done absolutely that that was performed a few years ago where we'd select certain agencies or certain
0:47:11 Departments of the city and go and do kind of surprise visits and count things and check their process mid-year
0:47:19 And we did that as kind of an additional procedure
0:47:22 And it worked well
0:47:24 could that be done again? Absolutely would be the answer but that's up to the
0:47:29 the council and determine what you want done there. Well we don't know the
0:47:34 questions asked we can't very well be specific enough to guide you. Yeah true
0:47:40 but I don't I don't see any real significant risk. If there was significant
0:47:45 risk that goes with our audit plan we said well this department looks it has
0:47:50 something weak in it, we would devote more resources to that and test that more because
0:47:55 it's a risk-based approach in how we audit.
0:47:59 And so if there was something that we felt raised to that level, we would look at it
0:48:03 more significantly or more closely.
0:48:06 Now if the council had some department they were concerned with, we could become involved
0:48:12 if that was necessary.
0:48:14 Thank you.
0:48:15 Great landing.
0:48:16 off topic, but I just got a text message that we have audio no visual
0:48:21 honor to our audience. That sounds good to me.
0:48:26 So, but I don't see Josh. So, Tammy, did you, okay, this was on Channel 17 is what the text
0:48:34 keep you. I would just like to add those entities that we're talking about that have had troubles.
0:48:41 They were audited every year because they're over 250,000, so it's incumbent upon our city staff, our professional city staff, and us to keep our eye on the ball.
0:48:54 And Chris made a great suggestion a few months back when this came to light in the media and you guys came and made a presentation.
0:49:04 So I would be open to any other checks and balances that we can put in,
0:49:08 not being so encumbering that we can't even get our jobs done.
0:49:11 But there's a certain amount of trust, human trust that we have to have in each other.
0:49:16 But as Reagan said, I believe, trust but verify, especially when it comes to cash on it.
0:49:22 So nowhere is going to be 100 percent, you can't get there.
0:49:26 But if we have the mechanisms in place, as best we can, and we learn from our counterparts
0:49:31 from each other because we've seen some issues in the past with other governmental
0:49:36 entities and private businesses we just need to keep our eye on the ball.
0:49:40 Do we have anything further Council Scott thank you Lori thank you for the
0:49:48 agenda I'd appreciate your time to see you next item on the agenda is consideration
0:49:53 of a request to approve revisions to the license backflow assemblies testers list
0:49:58 and we have Robert Boling.
0:50:01 Welcome, Robert.
0:50:05 Good evening, our Roman Council.
0:50:08 We appreciate your time this evening
0:50:10 to bring this request before you.
0:50:13 As you know, last year when we started
0:50:16 doing the backflow program council approved
0:50:20 having a list that just had testers
0:50:23 that resided in the county, Twin Falls County,
0:50:26 on our internal list that we send out.
0:50:29 As we got through the season, towards the end of it, we started getting customers calling
0:50:37 into Wally because on our letter that we send out, it gives them a month time frame
0:50:45 to get that test down and back into us.
0:50:49 So we started receiving calls from customers saying, hey we're having problems
0:50:53 getting somebody to come out and getting this done in a timely manner
0:50:57 and we're afraid you're going to come and shut our water off.
0:50:59 And you know, that's not our initial plan is to run right
0:51:03 out and shut off people's water.
0:51:06 You know, if we can't get them to comply,
0:51:08 that is part of the program down the road.
0:51:12 That's not what we want to start out with.
0:51:14 So what we'd like to do is get your blessing
0:51:19 on expanding our list, the list that we had initially
0:51:25 had about, well, they have included it in there.
0:51:29 You can see there's about 2 thirds more people on that list.
0:51:35 Some of the problem, too, is Kimberly and Jerome.
0:51:39 They both require their citizens to have their test done
0:51:44 by June 1st, or they go out and turn their water off.
0:51:48 So people in Jerome and Kimberly are calling these guys
0:51:54 on this, you know, there's only so many of these guys,
0:51:58 and so they're calling and giving them,
0:52:00 you know, we'll give you another $10, whatever it is,
0:52:03 get over here so we don't get our watershed off,
0:52:06 which leaves our citizens kind of stuck out to dry.
0:52:11 So if there's more people on the list
0:52:13 that they have a choice to get a hold of,
0:52:18 I don't think it's gonna hurt anybody last year,
0:52:21 everybody was pretty busy,
0:52:22 In fact, like I noted, some of the guys that do this after hours in the evenings or on the weekends,
0:52:29 they got on the boat and started saying, you know, I'm getting tired of angry citizens calling me,
0:52:35 and I can't get, you know, they just tell them I can't get to you.
0:52:38 Well, I'm going to get my water shut off. What am I doing?
0:52:42 So that's what we wanted to bring to you, and she has a blessing on it,
0:52:49 since you guys voted on it.
0:52:51 If you're not in Falls County list,
0:52:53 I want to make sure we brought it to you
0:52:54 for your attention and gave you the option
0:52:57 to change that list.
0:53:01 Great learning.
0:53:02 Rob, are we basically just expanding
0:53:05 to any main imagine valleys?
0:53:07 This is on this list, is what?
0:53:08 Yeah, the original list that we had,
0:53:12 you can see there's some,
0:53:14 and some of these are sprinkler,
0:53:15 fire sprinkler companies that come out of Boise
0:53:18 here every Eastern Idaho, but they're coming down to the six, eight, ten inch devices.
0:53:25 Little big stuff, yeah.
0:53:28 Rob, just one question I have regarding the timing of when they should get this done.
0:53:40 It would make it, it's just an opinion of mine.
0:53:44 Make it a little easier for folks to get this done when either they turn their sprinkler
0:53:48 systems on or when they turn them off. So when you do it in the middle there
0:53:53 so then they have to bring someone out a did additional time. The person that did
0:53:57 mine last year is the person that blows out my sprinklers. So I had him come and
0:54:02 do it while he can do that. Does that make sense? Yeah and really when you
0:54:08 think about it the device when you let it sit all winter and the gaskets and
0:54:14 seals get corroded and cressy when you turn that on in the spring from April or
0:54:21 whenever we turn them on until October that's when we want to make sure that
0:54:24 device is working okay if these guys can't get them tested you know and we drag
0:54:29 it out through the summer and they get it tested in October well it's tested
0:54:33 and we know it was working correctly for two weeks and it sits all winter you know
0:54:39 they come out turning on isn't working correctly now because it's set all
0:54:42 and that's the biggest deal with law sprinkler systems is why they recommend
0:54:47 they're tested yearly because and should be tested you know and that's why Jerome
0:54:52 and Kimberly have went to you have it done by June 1st so that they know
0:54:58 everything's being protected and they and I think they went that route because
0:55:03 people were dragging it out to the end and well I think that's why they went
0:55:09 that route. Okay. Thank you. And you know, that's that's a choice and
0:55:13 stance that you guys will choose. If we should ever go that route.
0:55:18 Chris talking. Well, Rob, I think if memory service, correct,
0:55:21 could we not limit to this to Twin Falls County based upon the
0:55:26 the charges that we were going to all include a list with somebody
0:55:30 in the Burleigh Rupert area that travel expense would be so
0:55:34 excessive that we would probably be accused of unfair
0:55:39 burdening of people.
0:55:42 What was that not part of our
0:55:43 discussed?
0:55:45 I think what we originally came down to was that the people
0:55:50 that wanted to put their price on the list, put their price on
0:55:54 the list, and then in the end, it was
0:55:58 Twin Falls County.
0:56:00 Okay.
0:56:00 People still have the opportunity to put their prices on there.
0:56:05 We'll make sure we do that.
0:56:08 Sean Berger.
0:56:11 Well, I think this is a terrible problem to have because it means people are actually getting their devices tested and people are keeping busy.
0:56:18 So I appreciate you bringing this to us.
0:56:22 I appreciate the communication you've had with the providers and I would make a motion to authorize the water department to expand the list back.
0:56:30 expand the list back to the way it used to be to provide more opportunity for folks to get this done.
0:56:37 Second.
0:56:38 Motion on floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
0:56:41 Rebecca Melzukka.
0:56:43 Thank you Mayor.
0:56:44 This is a clarifying question.
0:56:46 So everyone on the list though is someone that the city certifies is certified to check your back
0:56:54 flow system and they're a safe provider.
0:56:56 Is that the benefit of the list?
0:56:58 Yes, and before we let anybody get on the list,
0:57:01 we make sure that they have the requirements
0:57:04 and the license to do so,
0:57:05 and we also make sure that they have their device tested
0:57:10 or requirements and so that their devices
0:57:12 are working correctly, and they provide
0:57:14 all that paperwork for us.
0:57:16 I believe we'll start, we're gonna start meeting with,
0:57:20 having a testers meeting and meeting with the testers,
0:57:24 manually to kind of cover any questions that they have before we start going out and starting over her new in the year again and
0:57:33 that way if they've got any questions we're all on the same page. I did meet with we're looking at doing
0:57:41 commercials with Kimberly Jerome, Buell, and with Josh doing some media and that kind of stuff.
0:57:49 to put it out there, you know, we're all in the same boat,
0:57:53 just not just Twin Falls or Jerome or Kimberly.
0:57:56 It's a rule we all have to follow.
0:57:59 And hopefully that'll kind of get it out to the people
0:58:02 that, you know, it's not just us forcing them on.
0:58:05 Everybody's having to complain.
0:58:07 Sure, and then maybe a suggestion for just citizens' peace
0:58:10 of mind.
0:58:11 I don't know what your policy is,
0:58:13 but when you send out those notices and say,
0:58:14 oh, you have a month, maybe if they provide some sort of
0:58:18 for or date for when they have an appointment to have their system tested,
0:58:24 then they can just have some assurance that we'll check back with them after that date
0:58:29 or they can provide that information.
0:58:31 They're really at no risk if they have an appointment for their system to be checked.
0:58:36 We actually have three letters go out the first one and then there's this first notice
0:58:41 of non-compliance and then a termination letter that we sent out,
0:58:44 so it's actually spread out over a three-month period.
0:58:47 So, we'll just run right out of 30 days and cover water.
0:58:51 Right, sure.
0:58:53 But maybe we can also communicate that.
0:58:54 Then hey, if you have your appointment, then no need to be
0:59:00 angry with the backflow testers, and no need to fear.
0:59:04 So that would be great.
0:59:05 Yeah, that's a new process here.
0:59:07 So we'll take us to the world to get in the groove.
0:59:10 Sure, thank you.
0:59:11 OK, we have a motion on the floor.
0:59:13 Anything further on the motion?
0:59:15 I see no lights.
0:59:16 The Alvaro Cabo, please.
0:59:17 Becca Mills-Sleika. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Munn. Yes. Sean Bericher. Yes. Yes. Greg Lansing. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Rob. Appreciate your report. Thank you. Good luck.
0:59:33 I'm on the agenda consideration of a request to approve the some way conveyance plot consisting
0:59:39 of two lots on 93.
0:59:41 You ever take acres located dead?
0:59:43 2705 East 4025 North within the area of impact for the Twin Falls school district.
0:59:51 We have Renee Caraway Johnson.
0:59:53 Good evening Mayor Hall and City Council.
0:59:57 Typically conveyance plots are not pulled off of the consent item but this particular parcel
1:00:03 has had quite a bit of interest because it does involve the soccer fields and the new splash
1:00:10 park from first schedule and so we thought we would bring it to you and explain a little
1:00:14 bit about the process for conveyance plots and the future planning that would be required
1:00:20 for this property. Actually, conveyance plots were incorporated into our code in 2007. A conveyance
1:00:28 This spot was created for the allowance of taking a piece of property and splitting it
1:00:33 into two parcels for the purpose of selling.
1:00:36 A conveyance plot does not allow development of the property.
1:00:41 It does allow the property to be recorded as a final plot.
1:00:45 We have dedication of easements and rights of way that are part of that recordation, but
1:00:51 no development is occurring on that conveyance plot at the time.
1:00:56 We do have a little bit of history on the property in case some of you were here or not
1:01:00 here.
1:01:01 In 2001, the only land use on the property that's occurred was a special use permit for
1:01:07 the soccer fields.
1:01:08 That did occur in May of 2001.
1:01:12 It allowed the development of the soccer fields the way they are currently laid out, plus some
1:01:18 additional room for expansion, which hasn't occurred as of today.
1:01:22 I don't know if we want to show you any of the exhibits.
1:01:28 You have them in your packet, so if you have questions,
1:01:30 I can certainly do that if you need to do that.
1:01:33 But the plat does cover 93 acres.
1:01:37 The request is this.
1:01:38 Renee, maybe we could show them,
1:01:39 because we have audience members that might want to see them.
1:01:42 If that's OK.
1:01:43 OK.
1:01:46 This map here is our zoning map.
1:01:49 It does show that this parcel has two different zones in it.
1:01:52 The green property is zoned to SUI,
1:01:55 and the pink property is a residential zone
1:01:57 that's R1 variable.
1:01:59 It is located in the city's area of impact.
1:02:11 This is actually an area of the site of the future plan,
1:02:15 and this particular map has been in some packets
1:02:19 that have come before you recently.
1:02:22 You have the soccer fields that are in the upper left-hand
1:02:26 corner.
1:02:27 You have the future park for the slash park for First Federal.
1:02:32 The property that's directly below that, that goes from the east to the west side, is also
1:02:38 part of the lease agreement that's incorporated between the school district and the city.
1:02:44 So it's that whole section.
1:02:46 This property also shows you the future location for a school if that does occur.
1:02:53 And then the remainder of the property that is located at the north east section corner
1:02:58 of North College and some way is the motivator for this property coming through for condensed
1:03:07 black.
1:03:08 The school district does own the entire site and they are interested in driving off this
1:03:14 larger section which is about 36 acres that's highlighted in yellow on lot two and they're
1:03:25 wishing to sell that property. So again this is a conveyance spot that's coming
1:03:31 through to be allowed for the school district to sell that. A conveyance spot
1:03:36 currently does require recordation of the easements and rights of way at this
1:03:41 process time. I will tell you that I spoke with the engineering department last
1:03:47 week. There are a couple of conditions in your staff report. I was asked to add
1:03:53 another condition. This particular area is a correction section and Troy is here
1:04:01 to answer questions if you have some technical questions but there was some
1:04:06 concern at this point the dedication that's going to be on this conveyance
1:04:10 flat in particular at the corner of some way and falls may need to have some
1:04:20 additional right-of-way and or easements at the time of
1:04:24 plating and development of the property. And so she, she
1:04:29 Jackie asked that there'd be an additional condition placed on
1:04:33 this.
1:04:39 The property is located in the area of impact, as I said, which
1:04:42 means that this process this evening does require a
1:04:46 recommendation by this body and the final approval will come by
1:04:50 by the Board of County Commissioners.
1:04:52 So I will take this to the commissioners
1:04:54 upon the decision of this body.
1:04:57 Approval of the commencement will allow this plot
1:05:00 to be recorded on that property to be marketed.
1:05:03 So it's also is consistent with the comprehensive plan,
1:05:11 which shows the area designated as open space
1:05:14 and media density residential.
1:05:16 So upon conclusion, staff does recommend
1:05:19 that the commission recommend approval
1:05:21 of this conveyance plan as presented subject to three conditions.
1:05:26 The first one is subject to technical review
1:05:28 about the City Engineering Department and zoning officials
1:05:30 to ensure compliance with all applicable city code
1:05:32 requirements and standards.
1:05:34 Number two is subject to easements and rights of way,
1:05:36 as shown on the current plan,
1:05:38 being dedicated prior to recordation.
1:05:42 And three is subject to reevaluation
1:05:43 of the right away dedication located
1:05:46 at the Sunway North College intersection
1:05:48 at the time of planning for development.
1:05:51 Thank you Renee, Sean Berger.
1:05:55 With college, intersection or the Sunway and Falls intersection.
1:05:59 Please fall.
1:06:01 OK.
1:06:02 Thank you.
1:06:02 I would so moved.
1:06:09 Have motion on floor by Sean Berger,
1:06:11 seconded by Greg Lanting.
1:06:13 So moved.
1:06:15 Greg Lanning.
1:06:16 Could you wait for the previous map up there?
1:06:20 Is that one there?
1:06:21 What is that coming in here?
1:06:23 That's a future road coming from the residential development that's platted to the list.
1:06:28 Okay, so the elementary would actually have two accesses.
1:06:34 Right below the proposed elementary school is a platted subdivision.
1:06:38 Okay, but that is a falls extended though, right?
1:06:42 That's Creek-Sideway.
1:06:45 So it's Creek-Sideway in Santerra and then, yeah, there you go.
1:06:52 Okay, all right, okay
1:06:56 Okay, I forgot about that
1:06:59 Rebecca mail so you get a follow-up question to that is
1:07:10 So that that road will run right next to that future park site or are we planning for that making sure we're not building in that
1:07:17 Right away. So that road goes through in the future
1:07:20 Is that correct? Yes, and yes, it'll run adjacent to the future
1:07:25 part of the splash pad park site and it dedicates all the way up to North
1:07:33 College at that point. It actually continues from there past Xavier school
1:07:38 and eventually we'll get to Poline. Okay great and when is that development plan
1:07:43 to take place that road connection? I mean if that road goes in would it then
1:07:48 be the city's responsibility to build that road through or? So with this
1:07:56 subdivision here that that phase is being in and being reviewed right now it's
1:08:01 okay very much phases it's on Tara for and that'll be part of their half of it
1:08:08 will be part of their construction the right away on the school district's half
1:08:13 is being dedicated it's underneath this yellow line through here it's being
1:08:17 dedicated and at some point the development of that property will will
1:08:21 trigger that and that'll be us or the school district or both. Some combination.
1:08:26 Okay. And then as you continue north it'll happen with, it's already happened to immediately
1:08:31 adjacent to Xavier. You can see part of that on the ground right now. And as you go north
1:08:35 of Xavier, that'll happen when those properties develop. Would there be a benefit or an advantage
1:08:41 to constructing the road when the other partners construct their half? Yeah, there's certainly
1:08:51 would you could do some economies of scale to go with one contract for four
1:08:57 different partners we could certainly work through those at the time great
1:09:00 yeah I would encourage us to do that if at all possible kind of coordinate our
1:09:03 schedules and build the road completely
1:09:10 I see no further lights the other will call vote on the
1:09:12 motion to do so Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim yes Sean Berger yes yes talking yes
1:09:18 Great line team. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Mills-Sway gun. Yes. Most passes 7-0. Thank you, Renee. Next time I'm on the agenda is consideration of a request to negotiate with Hummel Architects a scope of work to include remodeling and renovating the Banner Furniture Building, the current city hall, police station, and possibly fire station number one. I know the agenda says Brian Pike would be making free station, but we have our city manager at Trev. Trev.
1:09:46 Good evening, Mayor and Council, Travis Rothweiler, City Manager, Brian Pike is
1:09:51 able this evening and so I've told him that you really don't need to come in to
1:09:56 cover this one. I'll do this one. So really this is the first step in the RFQ
1:10:02 process. The RFQ process that we followed is outlined in titles 67, 23, 20 of the
1:10:08 Idaho Code in which we go forward and we look at the qualifications of the
1:10:13 various firms for design professionals and an architect is a design professional that
1:10:18 falls under this category.
1:10:21 We went through a public announcement in which time we had received an inquiry from
1:10:27 21 different firms and from those inquiries they produced six separate proposals of qualifications
1:10:35 for us to review.
1:10:37 All of them were very, very good.
1:10:39 We had a committee of individuals that helped review those.
1:10:44 They included Mayor Hall, Vice Mayor, Suzanne Hawkins, and then members of my team, Mitch
1:10:50 Humble, Brian Pike, Larry Rayce, and I.
1:10:52 We independently reviewed all of the firms, and we came up with our top three.
1:10:57 We interviewed the top three firms.
1:10:59 Those three firms were Hummel Engineering, CSH, QA, and Badcock Design Group.
1:11:06 We completed the design of the interviews, and then we independently scored them.
1:11:11 And from our scoring process, Hummel was the individual that was selected to be the name
1:11:17 of the firm presented to the City Council to be able to begin that process of negotiation.
1:11:23 If we are unable to successfully reach an agreement and scope of work with Hummel, we would move
1:11:29 to the number two firm, the number two firm is CSHQA.
1:11:33 If we are unable to move there, then we get the committee back together to determine if
1:11:38 we proceeded forward with the PAPCOC design group or if we started the process all over
1:11:44 and requested individuals to again submit moving forward.
1:11:50 We also, prior to bringing this before you did a series of background checks and reference
1:11:55 checks with many of the projects that Hummel had worked on previously and when it came
1:12:03 to the architectural work and the design work that they completed, they received very, very
1:12:10 strong references and as we negotiate that scope for the design piece we'll look at
1:12:15 that bringing that forward.
1:12:16 So tonight we're asking you to authorize the city staff to begin negotiations with Hummel
1:12:22 architects for the projects that were outlined in the staff report.
1:12:27 Thank you, Travis.
1:12:28 Do we have any questions?
1:12:30 Rebecca, I'm going to second.
1:12:31 Thank you, Mayor.
1:12:32 I have a question on Humboldt's experience or qualifications for different types of environmentally
1:12:40 friendly building.
1:12:41 I know that CHSQA does a lot of lead certification and that sort of a thing is we're building
1:12:48 this 50-year solution for City Hall, do they have someone on their staff that can take a
1:12:55 look at the most up-to-date, most environmentally efficient technology so we can incorporate what
1:13:05 we can into this new building?
1:13:06 Yes, so I would ask other members to jump in as well.
1:13:11 Lead certification was one of the questions that we did spend some time looking at.
1:13:16 What's interesting about LEED certification is being LEED certified, especially when you
1:13:20 look at this type of building they believed, all the firms we spoke to believe that was
1:13:24 going to be an achievable standard.
1:13:27 When you start looking at then the different levels of LEED certification, certainly they
1:13:32 felt that some may be a significant cost to achieve, such as a gold or a platinum standard.
1:13:40 But they really did believe that achieving LEED was something that was not a LEED certified
1:13:47 project for all of these projects would not be a stretch.
1:13:51 I think it's safe to say that HOMEL does have experience in LEED and green processes.
1:13:57 And we have planned in having that conversation and incorporating that into the contract of
1:14:01 work.
1:14:02 What's important is that we'll come out more in the design standards as opposed to the contract
1:14:09 that we navigate through.
1:14:12 But they are capable and they have someone on staff
1:14:14 that specializes in that area.
1:14:17 It's our understanding that they have the resources available.
1:14:20 OK.
1:14:21 Great.
1:14:22 One other question on Hummel.
1:14:26 What other projects are they working on?
1:14:28 I believe they're working on the school,
1:14:31 one of the schools or both of the schools.
1:14:33 How do they feel about their ability
1:14:34 to handle the workload of doing these projects concurrently?
1:14:39 So that was a very specific question that we asked during the interview phase and they
1:14:44 answered that they believed that this project would work nicely and they had the staff to
1:14:48 be able to dedicate towards it.
1:14:50 I believe Hummel shared with us that they had 30 design professionals in their firm and would
1:14:56 be able to work through with our schedule.
1:15:00 Okay and our project manager or project lead would be different than someone who's working
1:15:07 on other projects in the community or with the one person
1:15:10 be sharing the project?
1:15:12 Our project lead is going, if this is approved,
1:15:14 is a Clint Severs, and I'm not aware of what Clint's other work
1:15:18 is associated with the project.
1:15:21 I was going to ask Brad to see if, but I don't notice
1:15:24 that he's no longer here.
1:15:28 Chris, talking?
1:15:28 Just a little follow up on Rebecca's questions.
1:15:31 Do we have a attendee calendar of the scope of work
1:15:36 that's just really unknown at this point?
1:15:38 All of those things will be developed through the contractual phase.
1:15:44 So what's going to happen is we've determined by qualification basis who we believe is the
1:15:50 best for us to begin that work with.
1:15:53 The next phase of this is to define the scope, the timeline, and the contract fee for service.
1:15:59 That will be brought back to the council moving forward.
1:16:02 And the conversations that we've had and when they roughly talked about timelines, we believe
1:16:10 that it would occur no sooner than late fall of 2015 before any construction would occur
1:16:18 and that it was probably somewhere between a full year build, I believe.
1:16:22 So we're looking about 18 to 24 months in moving forward.
1:16:28 And I think it's really important with that proposed beginning that it's coordinated with
1:16:33 the urban renewal downtown project so that we're not ripping up streets unnecessarily
1:16:40 repeatedly and not bumping into each other.
1:16:44 That's a very good point.
1:16:45 We've already had various conversations with the downtown tonight group and we wanted to
1:16:51 make sure that any activity that we were moving forward with would not adversely impact
1:16:57 a great community event and I know that they've also been working with the Urban Renewal
1:17:02 Agency so that any disruption would certainly not be caused by us.
1:17:09 Thanks.
1:17:10 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:17:11 Thank you.
1:17:12 I just wanted to weigh in.
1:17:14 When we heard the presentations from the three firms, we did require that their lead
1:17:19 person be the person who presented to us so that they were familiar with us and we were
1:17:24 familiar with them.
1:17:25 So we did get to meet them all and spend some time with them.
1:17:29 And I believe Clint was the one who told us that his current project in twin was just finishing
1:17:34 and he's excited to have another job and he has full time commitments to this project.
1:17:43 I see no further lies do we have a motion council.
1:17:47 Does that happen?
1:17:49 I would like to move that we proceed forward with a humble architecture firm for, I'm sorry,
1:17:57 I wrote over my notes on here, so I'm too real for humble architects for the scope of
1:18:03 work to include remodeling and renovating the banner furniture building, the current city
1:18:07 hall, police station, and possibly fire station number one.
1:18:10 Second.
1:18:11 Motion on floor by Susanette.
1:18:12 Hawk and seconded by Sean Berger.
1:18:15 To begin the negotiations, anything further on motion, Council?
1:18:19 Leila, roll call vote please.
1:18:21 Jim Mann?
1:18:22 Yes.
1:18:23 Sean Berger?
1:18:24 Yes.
1:18:25 Chris Tockington?
1:18:26 Yes.
1:18:27 Yes, Rebecca Melsoika. Yes, Suzanne Hockens. Yes, motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Travis.
1:18:35 I'll tell Brian that you did a fantastic job in his step.
1:18:42 Next item on the agenda is appointment of Suzanne Hockens as the City Council liaison
1:18:46 to the Twin Falls Library Board. This is my agenda item and I wanted to bring Council up
1:18:51 to date on.
1:18:53 Interesting information that I found through the process of really trying
1:19:00 to cement our relationship in a stronger way with the library board looking
1:19:04 at I know statutes related to our relationship and how it works as we all know
1:19:10 that library is and how legislatively or legally that we work with the libraries a little bit different.
1:19:19 For example, when we appoint board members,
1:19:22 this is the only award, I believe, that we appoint,
1:19:25 that actually the city manager and the council appoints.
1:19:28 So that's kind of a different twist.
1:19:30 And in reviewing, and as you know, traditionally,
1:19:35 the council has given the mayor the responsibility
1:19:42 authority to appoint members of the council
1:19:45 as liaisons to different committees.
1:19:48 that's been a tradition that the city has done for many years.
1:19:53 And we usually do that when the new mayor comes in,
1:19:57 or if the mayor's selected every two years,
1:20:01 whoever that is.
1:20:02 And so we've traditionally just appointed these liaisons
1:20:06 every two years.
1:20:07 Well, I did something really funny.
1:20:09 I actually read the Adho Code regarding the appointment
1:20:12 of the liaison to the library.
1:20:15 First of all, it says a member of the city council
1:20:18 shall not be, the council appointed, excuse me,
1:20:23 a member of the city council shall not be one
1:20:25 of the five appointed trustees to the library board.
1:20:28 So we couldn't appoint a city council member
1:20:31 as a library board member, but each year,
1:20:35 so it's annually, it's not every two years,
1:20:38 each year the council shall appoint one of its members
1:20:45 to be a liaison to the board
1:20:49 without having voting rights.
1:20:50 So actually it is to be done every year,
1:20:53 instead of every two years.
1:20:55 So I took the liberty of reaching out
1:20:58 to one of our council members and asking her
1:21:00 if she would be interested.
1:21:01 Suzanne Hawkins said that she would.
1:21:04 I've also taken liberty of reaching out to the library,
1:21:09 Susan and letting her know that this was potentially
1:21:14 going to be happening tonight.
1:21:16 But at this point, I put it back into the council's lap
1:21:19 because you are the one that appoints the liaison
1:21:23 that the mayor is not.
1:21:25 Sean Barrier.
1:21:28 Well, thank you for doing all of that homework.
1:21:31 I would move to approve the appointment
1:21:34 of Suzanne Hawkins as the city council liaison
1:21:37 to the Twin Falls library board.
1:21:40 So we're going to move on floor by Sean Barrier,
1:21:42 seconded by Greg Lanti.
1:21:44 Yeah, at least one light, Chris talking to.
1:21:46 Well, the last time I understood Jim Munn was layers,
1:21:49 and so is he bowing out?
1:21:51 I'm bowing out?
1:21:52 He is.
1:21:53 I had a wonderful time working with him over the last year,
1:21:56 but pursuant to Idaho Code, I think
1:21:57 it's a good opportunity to put a new face in the chair.
1:22:00 And second question to her point, actually,
1:22:03 at my time on the library board, I was always ex officio.
1:22:07 I never voted.
1:22:08 And that is correct.
1:22:09 I just read through that just to clarify.
1:22:14 And hopefully you didn't have the impression
1:22:15 I was saying that they should because that's not the point.
1:22:19 I was just reading that session for him, Chris.
1:22:21 And he was there, he was apparently there illegally over here.
1:22:24 Yeah, it's the second year anyway.
1:22:28 It's funny when you read the code.
1:22:32 Anything further on the motion council?
1:22:35 The other roll call vote, please.
1:22:37 Sean Berger.
1:22:38 Yes.
1:22:38 Chris Tockington.
1:22:39 Yes.
1:22:40 Greg Lanting.
1:22:40 Yes.
1:22:41 Don Hall.
1:22:42 Yes.
1:22:42 Rebecca Milslica.
1:22:43 Yes.
1:22:44 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:22:45 Yes.
1:22:46 Yes, motion passes seven to zero.
1:22:49 We will move down to update on pending legislative issues
1:22:53 and back to our city manager Travis Rathweiler.
1:22:57 So last week we spent some time going
1:22:58 through different legislative issues.
1:23:00 We outlined some of those things that we felt
1:23:03 could be incoming and concerning.
1:23:07 And over the course of the last week,
1:23:10 lots of possible proposed pieces of legislation
1:23:15 are being reconsidered.
1:23:17 And there are many pieces of legislation
1:23:20 that at one time we thought might be developing traction
1:23:24 or no longer developing any traction,
1:23:26 whether they would be issued or would not be issued.
1:23:30 The only piece of legislation that I have to report on
1:23:33 actually doesn't require any council action,
1:23:35 there was an annexation bill that would have changed
1:23:39 how annexation is done with category A, B, and C
1:23:44 organizations. That was introduced to a committee and by Wednesday the
1:23:51 committee, local government had taken action 11 to 1 to hold the bill in
1:23:56 committee and not to advance it forward to the floor. With that it appears that
1:24:02 there are just the three urban renewal bills that may be introduced but it does
1:24:08 not sound at this point in time that they may be continued that they may move
1:24:13 forward. Those three bills would involve the report to the council. It would revolve
1:24:21 and also, I think that was the biggest one, it was the annual report to the city council.
1:24:31 There is some conversation of whether or not urban and rural agency members would be elected
1:24:38 members, but that bill has yet to surface as we had talked about last time the
1:24:43 sponsor of that bill was going to be communicating when that bill was ready and
1:24:47 as I understand it it still has yet to leave RS form. So it sounds like a
1:24:53 legislative session that was really gearing up to be something for us to be
1:25:00 very paying very close attention to. Seems to be one of those sessions where
1:25:06 not a significant level of change will be made to the way in which cities conduct business
1:25:14 and operate. With that I'm happy to stand for any questions that you may have and I know
1:25:21 several participate again on various phone conferences and on various committees that
1:25:26 I would ask to help answer questions as they may have them.
1:25:30 Any questions for Travis?
1:25:34 No Christmas tree.
1:25:36 You must have covered it very well, Travis.
1:25:38 Thank you.
1:25:39 Last item on the agenda is public input and or items from city manager, city council.
1:25:44 So we will start off with the public.
1:25:46 Is there anyone here that would like to address the council?
1:25:50 Come forward and please introduce yourself.
1:25:52 Welcome, Penny.
1:25:53 Thank you for letting me do this.
1:25:55 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:25:59 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:26:03 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:26:07 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:26:10 and wrote a letter, my husband and I composed a letter
1:26:14 recommending our choice, Matt Hicks, and the reasons why.
1:26:19 And I'd like to submit this to the council.
1:26:23 And so if you want me to read it, I can,
1:26:26 whatever you want me to do.
1:26:27 Well, the floor is yours, if you'd like to read it,
1:26:30 and then I think I would probably
1:26:31 submit it to the city manager.
1:26:33 He is.
1:26:33 Yes, tomorrow I didn't have time.
1:26:34 I figured he would have a new.
1:26:37 Penny, Penny, Penny, Penny, the way this actually works
1:26:41 is the city manager chooses a person to bring forward
1:26:46 to the council, so it starts at his level.
1:26:48 OK.
1:26:48 So if you'd like to read your letter,
1:26:50 we certainly will.
1:26:51 OK.
1:26:52 Dear city council members, and of course, city manager,
1:26:56 This letter is regarding the upcoming choice for Chief of Police for the City of Twin Falls Police Department.
1:27:03 My husband and I were associated for several years with the Twin Falls Police Department as members of the Citizens on Patrol group.
1:27:11 Our volunteer service consisted of various activities in situations such as helping with traffic control for parades,
1:27:18 seat belt surveys and many hours of driving around reporting suspicious activity.
1:27:24 During that time, we worked closely with several officer liaisons, one of which was Matthew Higgs.
1:27:32 In our experience, we found Matthew Higgs to be an excellent coordinator and support officer
1:27:39 who was more than able to utilize our services to the maximum benefit.
1:27:44 We have a tremendous level of respect and confidence in his ability to fulfill the role
1:27:50 of the Twin Falls Police Department Chief of Police.
1:27:52 is in temperature will be greatly benefit our community.
1:27:57 We appreciate your consideration
1:27:59 considering this letter of recommendation
1:28:02 since early Robert Plus and Danielle Plus.
1:28:05 If you'll hand that to Travis
1:28:07 and then I have one other thing,
1:28:09 Penny just for your application in the future,
1:28:12 we opened it up to the public at the beginning
1:28:14 of the meeting too, so you don't have to sit
1:28:16 through the whole thing in the future
1:28:17 if you wanna come back.
1:28:19 We welcome you to everyone,
1:28:22 but just for your own knowledge.
1:28:24 Okay, thank you so much.
1:28:25 Thank you for bringing that forward.
1:28:26 Is there anyone else from the public
1:28:28 that would like to come forward?
1:28:31 City Manager, anything in addition?
1:28:36 Mr. Mayor, members of council at this time,
1:28:38 it would appear that we will be canceling the meeting
1:28:42 on March 23rd, but we will be having the meeting
1:28:45 on March 30th.
1:28:47 So I know that some members of our community
1:28:52 We still believe that we no longer conduct business on the 5th Monday.
1:28:58 We will not be conducting business on March 23rd due to a series of absences.
1:29:03 And then also items that we're able to push to the evening of the 30th.
1:29:08 The evening of the 30th, which is typically the 5th Monday, is a meeting that we have two public hearings that we will be scheduling and moving forward.
1:29:17 As well as other items of business.
1:29:18 Thank you, Travis.
1:29:19 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:29:21 Thank you.
1:29:23 I have been approached by paint magic, and they would like the City of Twin Falls to have
1:29:28 a paint team this year as they're right now working on lining up teams.
1:29:34 I think it's a great opportunity for the city to get involved.
1:29:37 I would be willing to captain our team.
1:29:40 If others are interested, we can put it out to city staff, to employees, everybody who
1:29:45 would be interested.
1:29:47 We need 15 people to have a team.
1:29:49 But I was just wanting to pull the council and see if you guys are interested, if you're okay with me,
1:29:54 keeping the communications open and moving forward with that.
1:29:58 I would just say that absolutely.
1:30:00 Is there a date, do we know?
1:30:02 They're just starting their meetings now, the first meeting's coming up for basic information.
1:30:07 And I do know that there's no financial cost.
1:30:10 They provide the paint and the expertise we just provide the manpower.
1:30:14 Thank you.
1:30:16 Does anyone further on that?
1:30:18 Yeah, just a comment, we might want to coordinate,
1:30:21 I know the fire department in the past,
1:30:23 and I think it's every other year,
1:30:24 they do a paint magic house,
1:30:25 so if perhaps you don't have enough,
1:30:29 we can coordinate with them,
1:30:30 maybe assist them in their work, or do our own, so.
1:30:33 Thank you.
1:30:34 So good, thank you.
1:30:36 Chris, talking to me.
1:30:37 This is concerning fiscal 016,
1:30:41 which I guess you're starting here within the month.
1:30:44 A background is with kind of a review of Twin Falls demographics as we're certainly aware
1:30:52 of one of our major growth components population moving in our elderly senior population moving
1:31:00 back to be either family or leaving their own nest for whatever reasons.
1:31:06 The number of seniors as a percentage of our tax paying population and service users is
1:31:13 I think growing significantly, we've discussed this somewhat in the past, but I would appreciate
1:31:20 consideration by the Council to instruct the city manager to have a review, revisit again
1:31:28 concerning our solid waste fees, how they apply to seniors and or singles, who can qualify
1:31:37 currently what fees and the means testing just to review it.
1:31:43 So I would appreciate it.
1:31:45 Council would give that a consideration in time for any
1:31:49 action that we may decide or know action for the upcoming
1:31:53 fiscal year.
1:31:54 Well, I saw the city manager shaking his head in the
1:31:56 affirmative and I'm just going to look at the council and it
1:31:59 looks like good suggestion.
1:32:01 I've talked to several people or they've talked with me.
1:32:05 You get cornered by a senior, that means somebody older than me, by the way, done.
1:32:10 They don't let you go, but several people are using their neighbor's trash camp because
1:32:14 they only have one, according to them, at least, one or two bags every two weeks.
1:32:20 And I don't have an idea how that happens.
1:32:23 But I think it's worthy of a review.
1:32:26 Thank you, Chris.
1:32:27 Did you have further, Travis?
1:32:28 No.
1:32:29 Just, oh, you were going to, okay.
1:32:31 Anything further from council?
1:32:32 Because I mean the council agrees that we should always look at it.
1:32:36 Yeah, yeah, we have the head not.
1:32:38 So, yeah.
1:32:39 Greg, what?
1:32:40 We have a little more extensive review today and several council members are there.
1:32:44 So I'm speaking to the audience now because most were there.
1:32:48 About the possible plans for downtown and the, the, your, your,
1:32:55 your a board took some kind of consensus votes concerning the different things that
1:33:00 things that they were going to do, but they are also going to bring it to the entire council
1:33:05 for a future date for us to take a look at and see if we are any, because they really
1:33:11 don't want to be going forward and then find that they've run into a wall with us.
1:33:17 We've scheduled that for March 30th.
1:33:19 Okay.
1:33:20 March 30th.
1:33:21 All right.
1:33:22 And they also, individual members have contacted me with thoughts about, you know, as they're
1:33:28 trying to find ways to stretch our money to cover as much ground and as much down there
1:33:32 as they could whether or not we would be in something I'm just throwing out for us to
1:33:36 think about because we're getting ready to be in a budget year whether or not the repaving
1:33:41 of Main Street after they're done doing everything is going to be 100% their dime or whether we
1:33:49 might be able to share in it.
1:33:50 I'm just passing that.
1:33:52 There's asking the question.
1:33:53 They're not demanding, not saying they're just wondering whether or not we would be willing
1:33:58 to share in that cost.
1:34:00 Is this the you are a board members that are calling you or are just citizens?
1:34:04 Board members.
1:34:05 Okay.
1:34:06 Whether or not.
1:34:07 Because when that of course will be an expanse, they're trying to stretch their dollars as far
1:34:10 as they can't.
1:34:11 They're so.
1:34:12 Well, the one thing that I would add, I've been contacting the folks in the community and
1:34:16 I concur with this.
1:34:18 They say, you know, sometimes we think about this as possibly being phase one for downtown revitalization
1:34:25 And and but but this particular person said don that's that's like phase two the phase one was in 1970
1:34:34 So so if history has any any lesson for us is that the phases will come every 30 to 40 years
1:34:41 So we want to get the biggest bunch bang for our buck while we're doing this and I I can throw with that
1:34:46 and maybe it's something we would consider looking into.
1:34:50 Chris, talk to us.
1:34:51 Yeah, especially with the reconstruction of our city hall
1:34:54 that's second and main street, I think we have a legitimate skin
1:34:57 in the game to help on that.
1:34:59 By the way, the original urban renewal district
1:35:03 in for that downtown project was July 19, 1965.
1:35:08 Goes back considerably further than that.
1:35:11 Thanks, Chris.
1:35:12 Travis, did you want to weigh in?
1:35:14 just to provide just a moment of caution and I certainly don't want this to take it that
1:35:21 I don't believe that the city shouldn't be a partner with the urban renewal agency we've
1:35:26 been good partners with them but I really do believe that number one I think the city
1:35:31 needs to with its resources that are scarce it needs to prioritize the projects that it
1:35:38 wants to advance and it wants to move forward and I guarantee you there will be several
1:35:43 competing interests. And so I really, and they're not competing interests, they're competing
1:35:49 interests that have been developed collectively by us. And so as we're looking at trying to
1:35:56 find funding opportunities for all of those things, I would strongly encourage us to refrain
1:36:03 from making any firm commitments, not that we're not wanting to be partners, but until
1:36:10 we've had an opportunity to really have a conversation about all of the projects and that the council
1:36:15 has the opportunity to fully vet and prioritize them first.
1:36:22 Vice Council, that's why you're in your position, Ruben, and Mel Seigen.
1:36:26 Thank you, Mayor, and thank you, Travis.
1:36:28 I did just want to voice my thoughts and they're very similar to yours on the project and I
1:36:35 I wasn't able to make the meeting today, but I would encourage the URA to keep their eyes on that budget.
1:36:44 I was a part of the committee that reviewed all of the needed infrastructure projects.
1:36:50 And they have a limited amount of funds, 16.8 or $9 million that they've currently spend half a million on the Rogerson building.
1:37:01 After spending that money, they've discovered they have some more work to do with moving a waterline and reinforcing a wall.
1:37:09 There seems to be a lot of added costs to the decisions that they're making.
1:37:14 And I know that they went into executive session to date to discuss acquiring another property.
1:37:20 I don't know if it had to do with the downtown project, but we do need to keep our eye on those infrastructure projects.
1:37:27 that that original committee assessed based on the city engineer and based on JUB because those are
1:37:33 the projects that are going to allow businesses to relocate downtown and we can have the prettiest
1:37:39 main street and we can have nice sidewalks and a nice road but if we don't get those critical
1:37:47 water and sewer lines and utilities we aren't going to revitalize downtown and so I would encourage
1:37:54 the IRA to keep their eye on their budget and stretch those dollars as much as they can.
1:38:00 But, you know, I think ice skating rings and plazas are a great idea.
1:38:06 But we really need that underground infrastructure and we need to keep our focus in the right
1:38:11 place.
1:38:12 Thank you, Rebecca.
1:38:13 Great timing.
1:38:14 Well, I would agree and I believe that the infrastructure is their number one priority
1:38:18 and they're going to be doing it before they do anything else.
1:38:21 And let's not lose sight of the ball either, that the plaza is not going to be completely
1:38:26 paid for by the URA, it's going to, there's a large community component that have raised
1:38:34 lots of money to build the things, the infrastructure, some of the niceties at least in the plaza
1:38:41 that you're referring.
1:38:42 Thank you, Greg.
1:38:43 Anything further from Council?
1:38:45 We are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 89 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 119 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 163 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 2.1 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 9, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:39:05.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
8e8ee7a2733f88b1626e7fbc1e86645d18423c171ab01054ec060dd98f461fe7 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a eec5dcbcfb46a8bb1829a1b1f973f73ed80921c569ad02bbad9df08c2623c581
part02.m4a 1a01a710e713df95fe216cf5f2b661cea623ebab25c042d72a3c488647a3cd10 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 4 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
f65c741de434d7ba37afc94fa8a6a4c376a2f2e00c91909383251fb3acef418a
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file