City Council meeting
Monday, February 23, 2015
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:01:45 I'd like to call the meaning of the Twin Falls City Council to order. It is February 23rd, 2015,
0:01:51 and I don't see any Boy Scouts in the audience. I tried to get a couple volunteers up here,
0:01:55 but so I'll just go ahead and start us if you'd rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:01:59 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:02:17 Well welcome everyone to our City Council meeting. We do have a
0:02:22 quorum of the City Council however, we have two members that are not here this evening had prior engagements that they needed to attend to
0:02:30 Mr. Rothwether do we have any amendments to the agenda?
0:02:34 There are no amendments this evening. Thank you, and that we have no proclamation. So we're going to move to the
0:02:40 input from our citizenry if there's anyone that would like to come forward and
0:02:44 and address any issues with the City Council,
0:02:48 now is the time to do so.
0:02:51 No one's coming forward,
0:02:52 so we will move now down to the consent calendar.
0:02:55 I'll lie on council,
0:02:57 give me direction on the consent calendar.
0:02:58 Chris talking.
0:02:59 I do have a question, by my desk.
0:03:02 Absolutely.
0:03:03 Mr. Manager, I notice on miscellaneous,
0:03:07 we have a number of checks, some refund checks,
0:03:11 some of them as little as four and seven cents.
0:03:14 Is that a proof accounting procedure to cut a check for that little amount of money or
0:03:19 can they not be swept into some year in right off for those auto amounts?
0:03:24 It seems like a non productive way to handle a less than a dollar bill.
0:03:32 You know that's a really good question and I'm going to have to talk with Laurie race.
0:03:35 Lots of the miscellaneous refunds that you're seeing are associated with utility billings.
0:03:40 And so let me talk with Lori to see if there is a different or better way and we'll get
0:03:44 back to you.
0:03:45 And a number of them work to the same pay as well.
0:03:50 Probably 12 to 15 of them and none of them are the same person or business.
0:03:55 Yeah, I believe if they go to the same person what you're going to see is what we're, they
0:03:59 will see that in a single check.
0:04:02 So all the amounts would be added together and you'd see that in a single check.
0:04:06 What we're doing is we are probably going forward and we're breaking it out.
0:04:10 responsible pay for the individual accounts of part of it's a sewer fund, the water fund,
0:04:16 the sanitation fund, there might be three different accounts pieces showing there, but
0:04:22 we'd probably write them one check would be my guess, but let me talk with Lori and we
0:04:26 will certainly get back and respond.
0:04:27 Thank you.
0:04:28 With that, I would move approval of consent calendar.
0:04:32 Okay.
0:04:33 We have motion on floor by Chris Houghton and seconded by Jim Monday, who approved the consent
0:04:37 calendar as posted.
0:04:39 further on that motion council.
0:04:43 Leila, roll call vote, please.
0:04:44 Suzanne Hopkins.
0:04:45 Yes.
0:04:46 Jim Munn.
0:04:47 Yes.
0:04:48 Chris Tawkington.
0:04:49 Yes.
0:04:50 Don Hall.
0:04:51 Yes.
0:04:52 Rebecca Mill-Soykin.
0:04:53 Motion passes five and zero.
0:04:54 Moving now under items for consideration, the first item is consideration of a request
0:04:58 to approve a resolution that will authorize the mayor to execute the cooperative agreement
0:05:04 for the intersection of Blue Lakes, Boulevard, and Haverton Avenue.
0:05:08 And for council's edification, the number if we choose to do this will be resolution 1941.
0:05:15 So we have our city engineer, Jackie Fields.
0:05:19 Welcome, Jackie.
0:05:20 Good evening.
0:05:22 Tonight's request is to ask the council to sign the resolution to authorize you to execute
0:05:28 the cooperative agreement for work at the intersection of blue legs and hayburn.
0:05:34 So ITD, as you know, has jurisdiction of lulex in that area, and they are going to do some
0:05:44 localized milling in lay.
0:05:47 And when they do that, they're going to tear up the loops that are there.
0:05:51 So we staff heard about this and thought that it might be a great opportunity to stop replacing
0:06:01 loops and put cameras in. It makes our operations a little bit more easier. It puts us in a spot
0:06:09 where we don't have to worry about the loops coming up to the surface over time and getting
0:06:14 destroyed, those types of things. So, in order to do that effectively, we thought that we
0:06:22 could enter into an agreement that would allow us to buy and install the camera equipment,
0:06:28 And the state in order to contribute to that,
0:06:31 naturally, needs an agreement of sorts.
0:06:33 So this becomes the conveyance so that they can reimburse the city for half the cost.
0:06:40 So it's a good idea and it's a nice, clean way to implement change.
0:06:48 And so tonight we're asking the council to authorize the mayor to sign that agreement.
0:06:59 We're good. Do we have any questions for Jackie this evening? Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
0:07:04 Thank you, Mayor. Just a quick question. We're calling these loops. Could you describe their
0:07:10 function and maybe how a camera functions differently? They provide the same function
0:07:15 for traffic flow. Is that what the loop does? Yes. So the loop is a wire that's embedded
0:07:24 below the plant mix. So you lay the loop down and then you pave over the top of it and it detects automobiles and then it sends a message to a controller that changes the signal according to the program.
0:07:38 So the camera looks instead and says okay I see something instead of actually feeling it.
0:07:45 So loops have a way of coming up through the pavement over time because you can't put them very deep.
0:07:53 And when you mill, you can't avoid them.
0:07:57 So they're going, they're absolutely torn right out of the ground.
0:08:01 Okay. So it would be fair to say it's just that's kind of the older way of doing something.
0:08:06 And this is a new technology that you're replacing. Okay.
0:08:09 Yeah, you bet. Great. Thanks.
0:08:11 Suzanne, I know you're next, but can I have to do a follow-up question about that?
0:08:14 Same question I had similar. I'm a motorcycle rider, so sometimes we just don't trip the
0:08:21 the signals are cameras more sensitive to that than the loops or were loops better than
0:08:31 cameras just I'm just more curious than any of my understanding is that cameras are better
0:08:37 than lips okay for detecting those vehicles so if you're not getting detected there could
0:08:43 be a variety of reasons for that so if you're on your motorcycle and you're not getting
0:08:47 detected and you look up there and you see something on the mast arm that doesn't look
0:08:51 like a signal head. Give Mike a jingle and he'll kind of look into why you're not being
0:08:58 detected. So be sure to be able to tell them what lane you're in and whether you're first
0:09:03 or not. Okay. Well this isn't the first. Because you'll be standing, you'll be sitting there
0:09:09 waiting for a good out. Like three lights sometimes. Yeah. So those are the time, that's
0:09:15 a good time to let him know time of day and where you were and then he can try to figure
0:09:19 out whether you're not getting detected because of sunlight or you know some other
0:09:24 obscuries or the camera is pointed a little too far back okay very good thank you Suzanne
0:09:32 Hawkins thank you well we're talking about that intersection is there any plans of putting
0:09:37 left hand turn lanes of that intersection on blue lakes lights right now it's just kind
0:09:42 of go as you can go.
0:09:44 Not at this point in time.
0:09:48 Any just not enough traffic to warrant it or?
0:09:53 I don't know the answer to that.
0:09:55 Okay.
0:09:56 So if you'd like us to ask that that is looked into,
0:09:59 we certainly can do that.
0:10:00 I would be interested because I've sat there quite some time.
0:10:04 Okay.
0:10:05 Thank you.
0:10:06 You didn't know you were going to get all these particular questions.
0:10:08 Did you?
0:10:09 Yeah.
0:10:10 It's all right.
0:10:11 So we'll look into it.
0:10:12 Issues with how timing goes on blue lakes and trying to get everybody through and
0:10:18 Whether you're not you need fully protected or protected permissive or things like that
0:10:23 So we can certainly ask to have that looked at I think that's the only intersection left that does not have left hand-turned signals
0:10:31 Sounds like a right-of-way acquisition issue
0:10:34 The lanes are actually physically there. There's not there's no life head that provides a difference in time
0:10:39 So it's a delay associated
0:10:41 thing to provide a specific opening for left-turn movements.
0:10:47 Interesting.
0:10:48 All right, I see no further lights.
0:10:50 I'm Chris Stockton.
0:10:51 Pass a mopassage for resolution 1741.
0:10:54 Second.
0:10:55 Motion on floor by Chris Stockton.
0:10:56 Seconded by Rebecca Milsoica to pass resolution 1941,
0:11:02 authorizing the mayor to execute a cooperative agreement for the intersection of blue
0:11:06 who likes boulevard and haber and avenue.
0:11:09 Anything further on that resolution or that,
0:11:12 excuse me, that motion.
0:11:15 Le either roll call vote please.
0:11:17 Chris Tockington?
0:11:18 Yes.
0:11:19 Don Hall?
0:11:20 Yes.
0:11:21 Rebecca Mills-Weica?
0:11:22 Yes.
0:11:23 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:11:23 Yes.
0:11:24 Jim Munn?
0:11:25 Yes.
0:11:26 Motion passes five to zero.
0:11:27 Thank you Jackie.
0:11:28 Thank you.
0:11:29 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request
0:11:31 to adopt an ordinance for zoning district change
0:11:34 and zoning map amendment from R1 variable to R2
0:11:38 for property located on the east side of the 500, 600,
0:11:42 and 700 blocks of Hankins Road North
0:11:47 for the Twin Falls School District 411.
0:11:50 And just for your knowledge council ordinance,
0:11:52 3089 will be the number if we choose to do this.
0:11:56 Renee Caraway Johnson, welcome.
0:11:58 Yes, good evening.
0:12:00 As you indicated, this is a request
0:12:02 for your consideration and adoption of an ordinance
0:12:05 for a piece of property that was rezoned by this body.
0:12:10 Little background, on January 13th of this year,
0:12:13 the Planning and Zoning Commission did hold a public hearing
0:12:16 regarding this request to rezone this 51 acres
0:12:19 from R1 variable to R2.
0:12:22 Upon conclusion of that public hearing,
0:12:23 the commission did unanimously recommend
0:12:26 that rezoning come to this board as presented.
0:12:30 On February 9th, you held a public hearing on the request,
0:12:34 and upon conclusion of that,
0:12:35 a public hearing council member,
0:12:37 Talkington, moved approval of the zoning district change
0:12:41 and zoning map amendment from R1 variable to R2,
0:12:44 for 51 plus or minus acres located on the east side
0:12:48 of Hankins Road as presented,
0:12:50 and that motion was approved six to zero.
0:12:54 So upon conclusion, the council directed staff
0:12:58 to prepare an ordinance for your consideration.
0:13:00 We have done so, it's in your packet
0:13:02 and we're asking for your approval
0:13:04 of that ordinance this evening.
0:13:05 And this will be typical ordinance
0:13:07 where it's third and final, all that stuff.
0:13:09 Very good.
0:13:10 Council have any questions?
0:13:14 I see no lights.
0:13:14 Do we have a direction through council on the ordinance?
0:13:19 I'll move approval of that ordinance.
0:13:24 Oh, third and final to suspend the rules.
0:13:26 What else would everyone say?
0:13:27 By title?
0:13:28 By title only.
0:13:29 Second.
0:13:30 Motion on floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Rebecca Middle,
0:13:33 soika as stated and then further on that motion council.
0:13:38 Lee Island, roll call vote, please.
0:13:43 Chris, whoops, sorry.
0:13:45 Don Hall?
0:13:46 Yes.
0:13:47 Rebecca Middle, soika?
0:13:48 Yes.
0:13:48 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:13:49 Yes.
0:13:50 Jim Munn?
0:13:51 Yes.
0:13:52 Chris talking to me.
0:13:53 Motion passes five to zero.
0:13:54 You could read the, or no?
0:13:57 In ordinance of the city council
0:13:58 or the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:14:00 rezoning rail property below describe.
0:14:03 Providing the zoning classification, therefore, and ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning district's map amendment.
0:14:11 Stand for development, direction from council to San Hawkins.
0:14:14 I move approval of Ordinance 3089 as read as read.
0:14:21 Second.
0:14:22 I have motion on floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Chris Talkington to approve Ordinance 3089.
0:14:29 Anything further on that motion, councilor?
0:14:32 Leanna?
0:14:33 Roll call, vote, please.
0:14:35 Rebecca Mills-Soyka?
0:14:36 Yes.
0:14:38 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:14:39 Yes.
0:14:40 Jim Mann?
0:14:41 Yes.
0:14:42 Chris Talkington?
0:14:43 Yes.
0:14:44 Don Hall?
0:14:45 Yes.
0:14:46 Motion passes 5-0.
0:14:47 Thank you.
0:14:48 Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to adopt an ordinance to vacate undeveloped
0:14:51 property within the portion of Northern Passage Subdivision Number 3 and 4 on property located
0:14:58 at the northeast corner of Federation Road Extended and Grand View Drive North for Northern
0:15:04 passage, Inc. This ordinance number will be 3090 if we choose to do so. Renee
0:15:10 Caraway Johnson again. Yes, hello again. Again, this is a final process in a zoning
0:15:16 public hearing process or vacation process. We're asking for the Council's
0:15:21 consideration on an ordinance that does allow vacation of this property. Little
0:15:26 background on January 13th of this year, the Planning and Zoning Commission did
0:15:30 to hold a public hearing regarding the vacation of this 13 acres, which is a part of Northern
0:15:39 Passage Subdivision 3 and 4. There were certain other elements that were included in that vacation,
0:15:45 which were streets and some public utilities. There was a positive recommendation by the
0:15:51 commission that went on to this body and on February 9th, the council did hold a second
0:15:56 public hearing, upon conclusion of that public hearing and deliberation, Council
0:16:00 member Lanting moved approval of the vacation of these 13 acres of undeveloped
0:16:05 property to allow for repladding and ultimately development of a new elementary
0:16:10 school. There were two conditions attached to that approval. One was subject to
0:16:16 site plan amendments as required by building engineering and fire and zoning
0:16:20 officials and the second was to submit all utility letter letters and conditions that
0:16:27 may be required upon adoption of the ordinance. Those letters have been submitted and reviewed.
0:16:32 So that condition has been met. Councilman Berrigger did second the motion and the motion
0:16:36 was approved six to zero. So we are here this evening again to ask for your approval of
0:16:41 the ordinance to allow this development to go forward.
0:16:44 Very good. Thank you, Renee. Any questions? Chris talking.
0:16:47 And Renee again, I want to make sure that the approval of this vacation ordinance with the two attached conditions
0:16:55 still allows the city leverage or provides leverage for the city before issuance of a building permit
0:17:02 or extending Federation Road for vehicular and pedestrian traffic.
0:17:08 As a matter of fact, the special use permit for that Rock Creek Elementary School or pillar
0:17:15 falls.
0:17:16 Rock Creek Elementary School will be on the commission's agenda tomorrow evening and that
0:17:20 will be a discussion item at the special use permit request development of the school.
0:17:26 But past due to this ordinance will not preclude that it will just be a step along the process.
0:17:33 We're not closing out any opportunities we have to assure a safety of that area.
0:17:39 Thank you.
0:17:40 Any further questions from council?
0:17:44 Doesn't look like it.
0:17:45 Stand for a motion.
0:17:47 I've moved placing a 39 on third and final by title only under suspension of the rules.
0:17:55 Second.
0:17:56 Motion on the floor by Chris talking.
0:17:58 Talking tenant.
0:17:59 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated.
0:18:03 You being further on the motion council?
0:18:05 Leila, roll call vote again, please.
0:18:07 Jimun?
0:18:08 Yes.
0:18:09 Chris Talkington?
0:18:10 Yes.
0:18:10 Don Hall?
0:18:11 Yes.
0:18:12 Rebecca Melsoica?
0:18:13 Yes.
0:18:13 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:18:14 Yes.
0:18:15 Motion passes 5-0.
0:18:17 If you could read the title.
0:18:19 In ordinance of the mayor and the city council
0:18:21 of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating the real property
0:18:25 described below and providing for the student title
0:18:28 to the property so they can stand for a motion council Suzanne Hawkins I'll move
0:18:34 approval of ordinance 30 90 second
0:18:47 we have most of the floor by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Chris
0:18:51 talking to him to approve ordinance 30 90 the island will call vote president
0:18:57 Yes.
0:18:58 John Hall?
0:18:59 Yes.
0:19:00 Rebecca Masoika?
0:19:01 Yes.
0:19:02 Susan Hocken?
0:19:03 Yes.
0:19:04 Jim On.
0:19:05 Yes.
0:19:06 Motion passes 5-0.
0:19:07 I just think we're moving so quickly this evening.
0:19:09 We don't know what to do with ourselves.
0:19:10 We can have to have some pauses in between motions.
0:19:13 Next item on the agenda is presentation of the City Pool Finance Report.
0:19:17 And it's going to be a presentation by John Pauli, the Aquatics Director of the YMCA.
0:19:22 John, come on down.
0:19:24 Welcome, sir.
0:19:25 Thank you.
0:19:27 Thank you, Mayor and Council.
0:19:29 We're gonna have to bring a second copy.
0:20:07 Good evening.
0:20:08 Thank you for your time tonight.
0:20:10 So I'm just gonna, you know, like I did last year,
0:20:12 go over our, how we did over the last year
0:20:14 and answer any questions and just kinda go from there.
0:20:17 So, I'm gonna start with our revenue side.
0:20:20 The city of Twin Falls co-op,
0:20:21 that's the $10,000 a month at the city base to the Y.
0:20:27 So no surprises there.
0:20:28 That's what it always is every year.
0:20:30 Our daily admissions from last year
0:20:32 was $68,784.27.
0:20:35 You will notice from the year before that is down,
0:20:37 we did not have a very good summer last year.
0:20:40 It got cool and rainy.
0:20:42 And we had a good July, but we did not have a good June.
0:20:44 We did not have a good August, especially August.
0:20:48 We really kind of depend on August
0:20:49 when it comes to daily admissions at the pool.
0:20:51 And then when that weather did not materialize and it rained,
0:20:54 and you guys dealt with a lot of those problems
0:20:56 from that rain in August.
0:20:57 Did it rain?
0:20:58 I don't know, right?
0:20:59 Yeah.
0:20:59 Well, here's a quick story on that, with the rain.
0:21:02 There was so much rain in the pool that actually raised the pool water about two inches.
0:21:05 Wow.
0:21:06 I've never seen it do that before.
0:21:07 So, not here at least.
0:21:09 So that was a new one.
0:21:10 Let me ask you a real quick question about that.
0:21:12 From what I understand, that's not really all that good because that's not water that's
0:21:16 been treated and all those dynamics, right?
0:21:19 No, and we were closed.
0:21:20 So which helped.
0:21:21 We did our backwashing procedures to lower it and to get it cleaned up and all that stuff.
0:21:26 But when you have those rainstorms like that, you really do have a lot of things being
0:21:31 introduced. Now, unfortunately, we do have our UV light and our chemical systems, which are going
0:21:35 to help. So the system held up fine and we kept it going. And then when we did ever get a couple good
0:21:40 days of weather, we did okay. But August wasn't that great of a month for us. So we need a hot summer this year.
0:21:46 So our sales at the city pool, those are down a couple thousand dollars from two to five.
0:21:53 We had the snack shop agree open last summer than from the year before. We didn't have that open
0:21:58 the year before. The operator didn't want to do it anymore so it was closed.
0:22:02 There's a new operator in there so he has a two-year contract with us so this
0:22:05 is coming year over year second year with that. So that could hover around there
0:22:09 could be a little higher. We're just waiting to see how we do on that. We've
0:22:13 started to kind of introduce more items that we can sell at the desk such as
0:22:17 goggles. I didn't think I could go through 30 goggles in January and February but
0:22:21 I did, so that was pretty good.
0:22:25 So I better make sure I'm stocked for June.
0:22:28 Swim lessons, we were actually up with swim lessons.
0:22:31 Couple of reasons for that.
0:22:32 We went to an elite swim lesson format,
0:22:34 where we had a one to four ratio,
0:22:36 instead of what we used to have,
0:22:38 which we had a little few of those classes,
0:22:39 but most of our classes were mainly a one to six ratio,
0:22:42 so there wasn't as much, and it was a little bit lower.
0:22:45 So we decided to increase our quality
0:22:48 by guaranteeing a one to four ratio.
0:22:49 Now with that, we did increase the base cost of that
0:22:53 by a couple of dollars for the certain categories,
0:22:55 but it has been a way better program than it was before,
0:22:59 because when you have one to four,
0:23:00 it's so much easier to come up with classes
0:23:02 than it was one to six,
0:23:03 and you're getting more attention with your kids,
0:23:06 which is, it's just all around,
0:23:08 been a great experience for the program.
0:23:11 Our hurricane swim league team went through the roof
0:23:14 and numbers, we had about 190 kids last year
0:23:18 when we had 147 in the year before, so we keep going up with that.
0:23:22 It's fun watching them swim, especially during the day.
0:23:25 It really makes that place busy.
0:23:27 That's what we're really kind of shooting for.
0:23:29 We really want to do well with our dailies and our swim lessons.
0:23:32 It's better to be diversified rather than having to depend on one or the other.
0:23:35 That's really what my goal is there.
0:23:37 City pool revenue, that's a category I want to see gone, which is good for last year.
0:23:41 It's zero. I don't like unexplained revenues.
0:23:44 That's really what that is.
0:23:46 Our memberships for the city pool went up about $2,000 from the year before I was happy to see that.
0:23:51 Alright, now our YMCA memberships did go down about $4,000.
0:23:55 The reason for that being is that in not last year but the year before we did raise our full YMCA membership rate.
0:24:02 It was a little bit of a jump more so than any other jump we'd ever done.
0:24:06 And I do believe that was the reason for that decrease.
0:24:09 Now those numbers are starting to stabilize and go back up, so I'm thinking that's going to be a little bit more.
0:24:14 more. This next report I'll give to you next year. Also, there was another point on that.
0:24:21 Okay, yeah, that was the $4 per visit figure that we agreed with when Greg Lanting was
0:24:27 mayor a couple years back on how we would report this. Now, we will increase that to
0:24:31 $4.50 for this next report that we do. The reason it's not is because we didn't implement
0:24:36 the fee increase until October, so it's in this year, so I didn't want you to wonder
0:24:40 why that hadn't been applied.
0:24:43 So those are our revenues for September 13th or August 14th.
0:24:47 Is there any questions I can answer on the revenues?
0:24:51 Keep up the swim lessons.
0:24:52 As a grandfather, I think your swim lessons are a high point in my granddaughter's life.
0:24:57 Thank you.
0:24:58 Okay.
0:24:59 Well, we're doing a new format for spring break.
0:25:00 All our spring break lessons are free.
0:25:02 In fact, you don't want to get out of the pool, so I'm doing your 24 hours a day, you
0:25:06 please.
0:25:07 I'm not very biased there or anything.
0:25:08 That's what my daughter said.
0:25:11 I do have a question.
0:25:12 And I noticed that on the YMCA, remind me, I mean, it was, you took a huge hit the year
0:25:17 before, or the grand.
0:25:19 Yeah, that was when.
0:25:20 Remind me about that.
0:25:21 That was when we increased our membership rate quite a bit.
0:25:25 And so you just lost.
0:25:26 Didn't respond very well.
0:25:28 Okay.
0:25:29 So, now it's looking like our membership rates are what the public is willing to pay because
0:25:35 a couple of different reasons we have a new corporate category.
0:25:38 That is a little bit of a lower price than the normal rate.
0:25:41 You have to have so many people and corporate.
0:25:43 I will check it in and tell you all the details on that,
0:25:45 but I'm not in charge of this corporate program.
0:25:47 But they've really worked on ways to get that back up.
0:25:50 And we're seeing the general membership go up.
0:25:52 I just checked it today.
0:25:53 All memberships combined.
0:25:54 YCD pull YMCA.
0:25:55 It's 7700 individuals are members of the Y.
0:25:58 So that's the highest it's been since 2011-2012.
0:26:02 So where we did hit 8,000 at one point, so we're hoping to push that door
0:26:06 in the next month or so to get back above 8,000.
0:26:10 And what I'm liking on this is I've looked at the city pool memberships as well,
0:26:14 just for this year, I'm noticing that I wasn't sure if those would go down with the,
0:26:19 you know, with the right memberships going up.
0:26:21 I actually stayed pretty stable, being really strong, which is really great,
0:26:24 because when I first started, I found some old files for my first years here in 2008, 2009.
0:26:29 YMCA city pool memberships were at $29,000 a year, so we have seen a nice increase in the number
0:26:35 of the public who are becoming city pool members as well.
0:26:38 So that's great.
0:26:39 I'd rather if they can't be a full-wide member, I understand, but I would love to have them as a city pool member.
0:26:44 So, options are what works best, in my opinion.
0:26:48 So, moving on to expenses, accounting legal, that's our portion of how much we spent on that within the organization.
0:26:56 Bank charges was down from 67 to about 49.
0:27:01 We have a new deal with a bank that has given us a better rate, so we're really happy to see that.
0:27:06 Let's help this across the board.
0:27:08 Repairs and maintenance that that is something that
0:27:11 There's no predicting on that one. So I've already have to pay a thousand dollars to fix the pool vacuum
0:27:16 So that's already a start to the new year that I wasn't planning on doing for this year
0:27:20 So it's just gonna be a fluctuation when it comes to that
0:27:24 Food that's what we paid a cater for the bubble put up and bubble takedown
0:27:29 Health insurance that's all of our full-time staff. It's down because we didn't have as many full-time staff within this period as we did
0:27:36 the year before. Now that will go back up because really it was just me and one
0:27:40 other person that was on health insurance and they were at the end and they don't
0:27:44 long they no longer work with me anymore so that really was just covering for the
0:27:48 most part my health insurance but now there is three people and the third so
0:27:52 that will a third of another person I'll kind of go into some explanation that
0:27:56 here in a second once we get down a little farther but we added some more
0:28:02 staff the Parks and Rec Commission got to meet the rest of my leadership team I
0:28:06 I have a front desk supervisor, a water fitness director,
0:28:10 sorry, a fitness director.
0:28:11 She's in charge of land and water,
0:28:13 but a third of her time goes to the water,
0:28:16 which is great, because I could not afford
0:28:18 doing a full-time water fitness director,
0:28:20 so it's really great that she runs those fitness programs,
0:28:22 so she splits her times by about two thirds,
0:28:25 sorry, not a quarter, two thirds on land and third in water.
0:28:29 And I also have a lifeguard coordinator
0:28:30 who's able to come in and do drills on the staff
0:28:33 when they're not suspecting it,
0:28:34 do many in-services stuff that's really,
0:28:36 I used to handle, but has been more difficult in recent years
0:28:39 with adding responsibilities and stuff like that,
0:28:41 so she's doing a good job of making sure our staff are ready.
0:28:45 If you're ever there during an open swim shift,
0:28:46 and you see them all jumping in the water,
0:28:48 it's probably a drill, so that's a good thing.
0:28:50 That's how we're trying to stay on our toes.
0:28:54 My ability and insurance, that's relatively the same
0:28:57 as it was the year before.
0:28:58 Office expenses went down a little bit.
0:29:01 We're doing a better job of keeping track
0:29:02 of what we need and don't need.
0:29:04 Payment to our affiliate organization,
0:29:06 That one's a little interesting.
0:29:07 That is the year before and this year's,
0:29:11 because the year before we didn't pay anything into that
0:29:13 to the YMCA of the USA,
0:29:14 and we did have to do a little bit of catch up on that category.
0:29:19 Can I stop you there real quick?
0:29:20 Yeah.
0:29:22 So obviously, so it's about $2,500 a year,
0:29:25 which is substantially higher than the year before.
0:29:28 Are the dues just going up with the Y,
0:29:30 or did you have some growth that caused that?
0:29:33 How'd that work out?
0:29:34 The YMCA of the USA, they take 2% of our gross.
0:29:39 And as we've grown more and more since we kind of fell down with that membership increase,
0:29:44 they will take more because our 2% gets higher.
0:29:47 So that would be the reason why for that.
0:29:49 And it's great.
0:29:50 It pays off really well.
0:29:52 We get a lot of good trainings.
0:29:53 I've been to a lot of these types of trainings.
0:29:55 Trainings are the big one.
0:29:56 Using the Y brand is great as well.
0:29:58 I mean, anything that Y National does, you can kind of feed off of that, which is really great.
0:30:03 So it is a great program to be a part of.
0:30:07 Administrative costs, that's our salaries
0:30:10 that aren't necessarily at the city pool.
0:30:12 On the second page is the Y-City Pool Financial Explanations.
0:30:16 Our administrative costs are CEO, Bookkeeper,
0:30:20 membership coordinator, marketing director, front desk
0:30:23 supervisor, and our Bookkeeper, I said that right.
0:30:27 So it just takes all those into account for that,
0:30:30 for what they do, because we do, especially with HR.
0:30:33 The pool probably has the biggest staff pool out of all three of the Y locations just
0:30:38 because it's water and we need to be safe.
0:30:40 So I'll get into that why our numbers look the way they do in a second.
0:30:44 Robic instructors pretty much the same, went up a little bit that's experimenting with
0:30:49 new classes and stuff like that so that fluctuates from year to year.
0:30:54 Clerical wages, that went down a little bit in just the regards because we went from
0:30:58 a system where we had a supervisor that was at all three wise to now we have a supervisor
0:31:02 who's just at the pool and she works the bulk of her hours, she works eight hours a day, she's
0:31:08 the front desk person eight hours a day as well. So that's how we are doing two jobs at one time.
0:31:12 And I do a little bit of front desk now to try and watch those costs as well because it's winter time
0:31:18 and you know it helps the cost a little bit. Life-guarding, that's the big one. Why that one is so much higher
0:31:25 from the year before. I don't know if you remember last year when I came in here and I kind of gave
0:31:30 the heads up that this is going to happen. It happened and it is a lot higher because
0:31:34 we've gone to two lifeguards on duty all day long. It's a lot safer facility. Communication
0:31:39 is a lot better. I would never go back to doing it any other way. It's great. Now the
0:31:45 expense is a little bit ahead of the revenues that I asked you that you guys approved of
0:31:50 late last year. We'll see those on the next year's report. We did take this on. We weren't
0:31:55 going to wait for that to go through. We decided to take the hit for this year and be
0:31:59 be safe because we'd rather do that than something happen because that can be the whole
0:32:04 heck of a lot worse than, you know, added $30,000 loss. So that's why we did that and
0:32:09 it's better to be safe. Safety comes first, always money comes second. That's the way
0:32:14 it always will be at the pool. Maintenance, that's a category you'll see down to. That's
0:32:20 actually janitorial. It's really not maintenance that got mislabeled wrong. That category will
0:32:24 be down to zero because our lifeguards do it at night now and throughout the day. So
0:32:28 We really just kind of mix that together and they do a really good job of keeping it clean
0:32:32 So I'm really happy and I'm proud of them how good of a job they do
0:32:35 Swim lessons with that one to four ratio. There is an added expenses and cost
0:32:40 So yes, we went up in our swim lesson category by about seven thousand dollars
0:32:45 And we did increase by about six thousand dollars and expenses. So we did notice an increase with that
0:32:52 City pull other that some of them other categories that were hard to associate
0:32:56 We're working on cleaning that up for next year. So that's down to zero two
0:32:59 I don't want that category even in there.
0:33:02 Payroll tax expenses, those are what we pay for our payroll taxes, unemployment, same idea that went down.
0:33:08 The reason that went down is we are with nonprofits, the state allows us to pay our unemployment on a case-by-case basis.
0:33:16 So right now we have zero people that are on employment, so we pay zero dollars to the insurance tax fund.
0:33:21 Well, but if we do get anybody on unemployment, we have to pay 100% of that.
0:33:26 So we just do a very good job of trying to avoid that.
0:33:29 So and it's worked out pretty well.
0:33:30 If at a year and we haven't had anybody on unemployment,
0:33:32 so that's how we're able to lower that cost.
0:33:34 That's a new IRS rule, isn't it?
0:33:36 No, it's through the state.
0:33:38 I think it's for government and non-profits.
0:33:41 I don't know the exact specifics on it.
0:33:42 That was just kind of the overview.
0:33:44 My book, Keeper, gave me on it.
0:33:46 That was kind of, when we hired our full-time bookkeeper,
0:33:48 she went and do that category.
0:33:51 I wish I could answer more on that, but.
0:33:53 I'm wondering if it's new to Chris,
0:33:54 because I don't remember that in the boys and girls club.
0:33:57 So yeah, that's how they worked it out with the states.
0:34:00 I believe you.
0:34:01 We're just, it's probably new.
0:34:03 Yeah.
0:34:04 Yeah, so we're happy for it.
0:34:06 So we'll, you know, we never really had unemployment issues
0:34:10 before then, so really a lot of that unemployment money
0:34:12 was just across the association, which is really
0:34:14 just going to waste, which is good.
0:34:18 We'd rather it be that way.
0:34:21 Yeah, you're probably not going to get arguments
0:34:22 from some businesses on that.
0:34:24 I can imagine.
0:34:26 Pooled chemicals, that stays pretty consistent at 25.
0:34:30 Might go down a little bit with the decrease in gas prices.
0:34:33 I'm not going to count on it though, but it'd be nice to know a little bit.
0:34:36 Because everything's petroleum based, isn't it?
0:34:39 Yeah.
0:34:40 It's a whole transport.
0:34:41 Yeah.
0:34:42 I mean, I don't know.
0:34:43 It won't go below 20,000.
0:34:44 I know that.
0:34:45 I've never seen it go below 21,000.
0:34:47 That year of September 2011 to August, it was the lowest I've ever seen it.
0:34:52 I've seen it.
0:34:53 Program supplies, those are supplies we use for our programs to succeed.
0:34:58 Advertising at about 10,000 for, that's about 28% of our total amount that was spent on advertising.
0:35:04 We do notice that in our program, guys, those program guides are quite a bit more expensive
0:35:08 than you'd think when they go out.
0:35:10 I'm working on one right now that, we're working on getting sponsorships and raising
0:35:14 monies for, so that will actually be very heavily pool related, about 75% of it will
0:35:20 pool information in it and the last quarter will be about day camp stuff so it's gonna
0:35:24 be really good once it goes out in early April. Retirement that's that had been
0:35:30 mainly myself and my X aquatics assistant aquatics director at the moment it's just
0:35:36 me so that might go down actually a little bit next year just because we don't
0:35:38 my newer people haven't really met the requirements for why retirement yet but
0:35:42 ultimately that will go up in the next couple years. Product supplies the
0:35:47 different products we use, toilet paper, stuff like that.
0:35:50 Uniforms, whistles, fanny packs, stuff along those lines.
0:35:54 Are utilities?
0:35:56 That one's always the most really one of the more expensive
0:35:59 categories.
0:35:59 I have an actual chart I'd like to show you on that one.
0:36:02 I like this chart because it goes into a better detail
0:36:09 rather than looking at costs because it changes so much
0:36:11 from year to year.
0:36:12 So as you can tell from with our, actually, right.
0:36:21 Our therms have followed pretty much the same kind of down-up, down-cut trend throughout
0:36:26 the years, same with our kilowatts.
0:36:30 So that's how I'm really looking at how we're using our utilities.
0:36:34 The dollars is really hard to kind of go by, so try to look at it every month and plug
0:36:39 it in.
0:36:40 The September from that first year, that was a weird month because we paid some and the
0:36:43 city paid some and the contract switched from you guys to us when it came to paying for
0:36:49 the utilities. That's really, I wouldn't look at that one for it. John, John, John,
0:36:55 Councilman, talked and has a question. Well, yeah, it looks like the seasonal
0:36:59 but because of cooler temperatures, heating the water explains most of it. But
0:37:03 aside from the seasonal curvature on the thing, John, do we have or Dennis, I
0:37:12 guess any of you, is our heating plant efficient? Is it the type, the kind, and
0:37:19 the age that it should be to give us the cheapest cost of heating. I've kind of lost track where
0:37:26 we are on that. I know we have been making some changes. Yeah, I can't remember exact
0:37:32 a year, but we did replace the boilers in there. They're a lot more higher efficient than we had
0:37:37 in the past than the original wood boilers from 89. I believe they're five or six years old now,
0:37:44 but they're really high efficient and we've had good success with those. And are they tested
0:37:48 to make sure that they are tuned or whatever to cap it
0:37:51 if they're maximum efficiency.
0:37:53 Yeah, my staff can handle a lot of that,
0:37:55 but if it's out of their expertise, we do hire, you know,
0:37:59 Brazil has come in or another heating firm has come
0:38:01 in to check and we've had, I know in the past,
0:38:04 the manufacturer has sent a rep to check on those heaters
0:38:07 before.
0:38:08 And then of course at night, don't you still put a blanket
0:38:11 on even in the winter under the tent?
0:38:13 So, okay, thank you.
0:38:15 Sounds like you're being efficient users of our energy.
0:38:20 Well, and actually, and this won't,
0:38:21 when you have a $13,000 a month,
0:38:23 like our gas bill right now, like we do.
0:38:26 Yeah, I know, that's a lot.
0:38:27 A little more than my house.
0:38:28 Yeah, right.
0:38:29 We did install some, the thermostats in our pool building
0:38:33 were old, old mechanical ones that you'd move a little dial.
0:38:37 We did install about a month, almost a month ago,
0:38:40 we installed two digital ones in there,
0:38:42 and the why did that?
0:38:44 And I know it's not going to bring it down to like $6,000, but hey,
0:38:48 brings it down a couple hundred bucks or maybe a thousand or two a year or something.
0:38:51 That would be great because what was happening at night is there was no way to regulate it
0:38:55 when people weren't there.
0:38:56 So it was blasting at 85 degrees in the middle of the night.
0:38:58 Now it pops down to mid 60s.
0:39:00 So I'm hoping that will help a little bit.
0:39:02 But they're probably able to be computer program from afar or two.
0:39:08 They're more like standard digital thermosets you'd find in a house or something along those lines.
0:39:13 We didn't really go really expensive. We tried to keep the you know the cost on a little bit on it
0:39:17 But they're great units. They've been working out. Well, um, I know Kevin from Parks and Rec was saying
0:39:22 He liked him because it's gonna be less wear and tear on the units on the roof
0:39:25 So that was another added benefit as well, you know, that's hard to calculate how much money that saves
0:39:30 But you know, maybe it buys another year or two over the units. I don't know, but he was happy to see that as well
0:39:36 so
0:39:38 And then just to finish up the work workman's comp
0:39:43 Those are our rates, our portion for Workman's Comp claims.
0:39:48 We're hoping that goes down here in the next year.
0:39:50 So we did have a couple years back where it's kind of the price to go in business where
0:39:54 though that when you're on a pool deck, things happen sometimes.
0:39:57 But we've had a last couple of years, last two years, two and a half years.
0:40:01 We've had some pretty good success with that.
0:40:03 So we're hoping to see that rate go down here before and along.
0:40:05 So, and then what it comes out to is our total expense is about $510,000,
0:40:11 $474 with a net loss of $41,477.78, big reason for that being the lifeguard wages, almost the only reason for that much more of a loss because we did spend so much more on the lifeguards.
0:40:27 I'm thinking, well, from looking at it, we should recoup a lot of that back with what we did with the rate increases for the memberships and the daily admission fees.
0:40:38 Thank you Mayor.
0:40:44 So that was as a follow-up question.
0:40:47 When you implement the new fee, do you think that the fee will cover the cost that you're seeing in the added lifeguard position?
0:40:56 Not all of it.
0:40:57 I do think it'll be a good chunk of it, but not all of it.
0:41:00 Okay. And so how do you plan to adjust for that or what's the plan to pay for that added cost?
0:41:08 The big plan right now is to get more people through the pool doors really to be honest with you more people through the doors more people
0:41:14 Taking out memberships more people taking some lessons. That's really kind of what the plan is the moment. We didn't want to bring a
0:41:21 big dollar increase in daily admissions or
0:41:25 You know four or five six seven dollars a month increase in pool membership rates because we're gonna end up losing membership
0:41:31 So it was a very fine-tuned what we wanted to ask for so we didn't ask for maybe what we could have or
0:41:38 or whatever to make up for the law.
0:41:39 So that's my job as a running the city pool
0:41:43 is to come up with other ways to make up for that.
0:41:46 This program guide that I'm having going out here
0:41:47 in early April, I'm thinking this is the first time
0:41:49 we've ever done something like this,
0:41:50 is gonna help with that.
0:41:51 I'm able to get, so far about half of it already paid
0:41:54 through through sponsorship.
0:41:55 So that makes it a little bit better as well.
0:41:59 So I need to be an innovator to try and make up the rest.
0:42:02 All of it, I probably couldn't make up on my own.
0:42:04 There's no way.
0:42:05 but if I can get 15,000 to 20,000,
0:42:08 now it's gonna make it way more capable.
0:42:10 Okay, and I did notice that your numbers are down
0:42:13 and you kinda touched on that.
0:42:14 You think it was mostly weather related.
0:42:17 It's not a trend that you're seeing.
0:42:19 You're not worried about this coming season.
0:42:22 If we have good weather,
0:42:23 you think those numbers will bounce back.
0:42:25 I'm very happy with the numbers
0:42:26 for January and February so far.
0:42:28 We've had over 11,000 visits
0:42:31 in the first almost two months of the year already.
0:42:34 I have not gone back to compare that with last year.
0:42:37 Isn't depth as I want to yet,
0:42:39 but it is up from the year before,
0:42:41 just from a quick rough,
0:42:42 it was about 1500 to 2000 already higher
0:42:45 than the year before, so I'm really happy to see that.
0:42:48 I will have way more detail on that next year
0:42:51 when it comes to that, I didn't wanna push that
0:42:54 and not have a good idea on that.
0:42:56 That's why I didn't wanna give you those numbers
0:42:58 because I really was not as prepared for those
0:42:59 as I wanted to be.
0:43:01 Okay, great, thank you.
0:43:02 Do we have any further questions?
0:43:06 I think it was a great report.
0:43:08 I appreciate you being as detailed.
0:43:10 Now, I do have a question for Council.
0:43:11 Do you want, John, just to give you some guidance.
0:43:13 Do you want John to go item by item or more of a highlight?
0:43:17 Were you comfortable with tonight's presentation?
0:43:20 What's Council's thoughts?
0:43:22 Jim?
0:43:23 Oh, thank you, Mayor.
0:43:25 Well, I just have all this report prior.
0:43:28 I'm just asking.
0:43:29 I think it's good that he goes through the detail.
0:43:31 One of the things, I'm concerned when we have a $41,000 deficit in your budget.
0:43:38 How do you fix that, what did you do to fix this budget?
0:43:43 What it is, well, we came, a couple things, when we came through with the increases that
0:43:47 we asked for to make up for that.
0:43:49 Also another thing that has helped with this, and I've kind of touched on a little bit,
0:43:55 but not a lot, is the Elizabeth Pool went down about when we did this.
0:44:00 of those life-guarding dollars that we're using there mostly, I mean, helped a lot.
0:44:05 They didn't quite get us back to where we needed to be.
0:44:08 But we can't depend on that forever and always because the Elizabeth Pool is going to reopen.
0:44:11 So it really didn't hurt us as bad as it could have hurt us.
0:44:15 So that is, we kind of took some funds from that operation to make the city pool safer operation.
0:44:21 So in your August, excuse me, September 13th through August 15th budget, you anticipate
0:44:29 being at least even?
0:44:32 I wouldn't quite say that now.
0:44:33 I'd say closer to what it was last year, the $12,000 loss.
0:44:37 Okay.
0:44:38 Yeah.
0:44:39 Okay.
0:44:40 Well, yeah, good luck.
0:44:41 That's tough one.
0:44:42 I think I was encouraged when I heard you say you were going to try to find innovative
0:44:46 ways to increase revenue, but I also encourage you to find innovative ways to cut expenses.
0:44:51 We've been doing that definitely we've actually I'm actually glad you touched on that because
0:44:56 What we're doing now as well as like I was talking about Boston where it was before
0:45:01 Our front desk was ran by one person that ran all three. It was really an efficient way of running a desk
0:45:07 Now our person is there on location all pretty much all four hours are at the desk
0:45:11 So instead of having her separate hours that helps there as well
0:45:14 I'm picking up, you know eight hours or so a week to help out because I'm already gonna my desk doing so it doesn't hurt to be there
0:45:20 for eight hours running the desk as well.
0:45:23 So we are doing some things like that.
0:45:25 I do have to guard a little bit just to maintain my skills.
0:45:28 So I do guard a little bit right there.
0:45:30 We are finding ways to try and save money as well.
0:45:34 But we have been doing that for almost the entire time
0:45:37 I've been here.
0:45:38 So there's not a lot to find cuts at other than shutting
0:45:42 the door certain hours of the day.
0:45:43 Don't want to do that.
0:45:46 But that's almost to the point where
0:45:48 were at for cutting expenses would be to close a certain hours, but that's not even an option
0:45:53 on the table, at least from the Y's standpoint at all. So that's kind of where we're at. Now
0:46:00 with pools, I know Dennis is going to test this when the city ran the pool. If you can
0:46:06 get even, then you're making a ton of money. We'd like to achieve that. If we can get back
0:46:12 down to 12 I would be happy with that as well. Great thank you. Chris talking. Well first of
0:46:18 all John I'd like to compliment you I think we're making progress every year of having what I'd
0:46:25 term a really professional management by you and the why and it does take specific commitments by the
0:46:32 city such as the the boilers and the thermostats to make sure that we're using the money as efficiently
0:46:40 as possible. I'm not opposed to considering in a following year some sort of a cost-living
0:46:48 increase from the city on top of that 120. I would say I would much rather do that than
0:46:55 I see in many places bumping up swimming lessons for children. My bias is to keep those low
0:47:02 as the best kind of recreation that we can have to keep the kids safe and out of trouble
0:47:10 And my bias is that's something that the city should and could underwrite much as we do other forms of recreation for parts of the city.
0:47:20 Job well done.
0:47:22 Thank you.
0:47:23 And this year, this next year is really going to tell us more because this last year was a transition with that guard.
0:47:29 I'm really curious to see what happens this next.
0:47:32 On September 2015, we're going to have a lot more data to be able to process and go from there.
0:47:38 from there because last year was a mess when it came to adding more guards but
0:47:43 there was no extra monies coming in and then the cold summer so it was kind of
0:47:47 hard to tell where you're at well we should have much better data for
0:47:50 September I see no further lights John thank you again great presentation good
0:47:56 information thank you for your time thank you we are moving on to the next
0:48:00 item which is public input and or items from city manager city council so we'll
0:48:05 start with the public is there anyone from the public that would like to
0:48:08 address the council. I see no takers. We're moving over to the city manager. Mr.
0:48:16 Rothery, do you have anything for the council? Mr. Mayor, members of the council, I do.
0:48:20 So take advantage of a few minutes that we have in between now and the public hearing
0:48:25 that can't start until six o'clock. Earlier today, I sent out an email to the members
0:48:31 of our local legislative delegation, specifically the members of our, of the House of Representatives.
0:48:38 a particular house bill. And it's House Bill 173, I believe. And in that bill, it basically
0:48:46 says that it's proposed by Representative Mike Moyle, who's the majority leader of the
0:48:53 Montana House, or excuse me, the Idaho House. Old habits will never die, right? That's where
0:48:57 I used to work. And I used to work for the majority leader. We'll just leave it at that.
0:49:04 This one. No, not this one. And this house bill would remove one half of the city's new
0:49:18 construction dollars that we would collect on an annual basis. And the new construction
0:49:23 dollars are what we often refer to as the growth formula. And in the last budget year,
0:49:30 That would have equaled about 65% of the total new tax revenues that came in for the City
0:49:37 of Twin Falls.
0:49:39 So as you recall, we collected about $244,000 in new construction dollars and we collected
0:49:45 a total of $375,000 in new property tax dollars in their totality.
0:49:52 The idea is these funds would be shifted to schools to offset the costs and the issues
0:49:58 that are occurring with school funding.
0:50:03 It really is a shift of our resources that causes significant issue and problems for us.
0:50:09 What does $122,000 represent?
0:50:11 It represents two and a half police officers or two and a half firefighters or a significant
0:50:17 portion of our current road maintenance budget.
0:50:20 And I think that we would also agree right now that road maintenance is something that
0:50:24 we want to continue to increase funding, and this could reduce that.
0:50:32 So I think, in my opinion, and maybe I think that this is probably a bill if I were to ask
0:50:36 the members of the council, this is one that we as an organization would probably stand
0:50:41 with the Association of Idaho Cities, the Association of Idaho Counties, the highway
0:50:46 districts, and everyone else who would be impacted by this and saying, we think this is bad legislation.
0:50:53 I sent out an email because I didn't want to stand up for the entire council without
0:50:57 having a conversation with the council saying the city of Twin Falls as an entity does not
0:51:04 support this legislation without understanding your thoughts which then leads to the purpose
0:51:12 of I guess my question.
0:51:14 We are starting to see a significant amount of bills coming through the process that were
0:51:19 we're generally not anticipated at the beginning of the session.
0:51:23 When it relates to cities and our abilities to either grow or to fund services or to use
0:51:32 certain powers that have long time been provided to cities, whether it be the powers of eminent
0:51:38 domain or the powers of annexation and everything in between.
0:51:43 We're also seeing bills that really could significantly impact our urban renewal partners
0:51:49 And it could cause some additional responsibilities
0:51:52 on behalf of the cities.
0:51:55 And part of those responsibilities
0:51:57 with our urban or rural agency partners may cause some additional
0:52:04 complications for the city and agency as we move forward
0:52:07 as being separate and distinct entities.
0:52:10 The purpose of what I'm standing here asking is,
0:52:14 how would you like to be involved in that process?
0:52:19 I often will get calls from members of our local house or Senate delegation as bills are coming up
0:52:26 and I will candidly share my thoughts and my opinions, but that may not always necessarily reflect the opinions of the council.
0:52:33 And so I'm trying to really find that balance and strike that balance.
0:52:38 I think that there are some issues out there that are what I would call something that we would probably all be in support of either opposing or working together.
0:52:48 And yet, there are probably some bills out there that we, as a group, may be very divided
0:52:54 on them.
0:52:55 And I think that I have an understanding of what some of those bills may be, but when
0:52:59 you make those assumptions, we all know what can happen with that.
0:53:03 So I'm here really more in to take a few minutes and just seek the guidance of counsel on how
0:53:08 you'd like to be involved in that legislative process.
0:53:11 I just wanted to remind us that we can't do this on email because it could be a serial
0:53:16 meeting, you send out an email, then I respond, and then Jim responds, we have to be so careful
0:53:21 about that.
0:53:22 And also keep in mind our transparency resolution as well.
0:53:25 So these are things that we need to be very cognizant of during this process.
0:53:30 And I have a bunch of lights on Travis, so I'm going to start going down the list.
0:53:34 Chris talking to you.
0:53:35 Well, I think the AIC is our logical vehicle for forwarding our concerns.
0:53:41 On the positive side, Travis, I'm optimistic when a member of the House or Senate, especially
0:53:47 a sponsoring member, solicitors are our opinion, it's those that we don't hear from that I
0:53:53 think we can construe as often oblivious to local government.
0:53:59 Local government is what works.
0:54:01 The fact of legislature for years now since 2008 is not funded education at the point
0:54:08 where they're looking for quick fixes.
0:54:11 And that quick fix looks like it's going to come
0:54:13 at the expense of our new property tax revenue
0:54:16 if this were to go through.
0:54:17 So I'm very open to Travis being the logical conduit
0:54:24 for the representative to say what do you think about this
0:54:27 for him to forward and say the heads up
0:54:30 but for us to join in a consortium with AIC.
0:54:34 There are logical, I mean, there are legitimate lobbying group.
0:54:38 Thank you, Chris, Suzanne Hawkes.
0:54:41 Thank you.
0:54:42 So we all have other responsibilities
0:54:50 that we take care of on a daily basis.
0:54:51 And I feel that as a council, we've hired Travis
0:54:54 to represent us.
0:54:56 And I believe that he knows the impacts
0:55:00 on the city greater than we could ever comprehend
0:55:03 because we're not in that daily business.
0:55:05 And so I feel fully confident when these issues come up
0:55:08 And they need an immediate response like some of these, you just don't have time to call a meeting, you don't have time to post it, it's not practical.
0:55:15 So I believe that we've hired you to do that for us and that as these issues arise that you're responsible enough to handle them in a professional manner on our behalf.
0:55:27 And so I'm fully confident with your ability to do that.
0:55:31 Thank you, Suzanne.
0:55:32 Rebecca Milsoy.
0:55:33 Thank you, Mayor.
0:55:34 Thank you, Travis, for sharing that with us.
0:55:36 I would like to be informed on kind of what issues are coming up and what's going on.
0:55:41 And I think that we could receive an email from you just letting us know, okay, I've had this inquiry.
0:55:46 This is the issue at hand.
0:55:48 I think if we all make an effort to only reply to Travis or the legislator that's inquiring.
0:55:57 I think that gives us an opportunity to share our perspective as individual council members,
0:56:03 We, like you said, we may be divided on an issue, we may be, you know, have a unanimous opinion on it.
0:56:11 I would like to be informed somehow, and so as long as we're not discussing over email, I think we won't have any open meeting law concerns.
0:56:20 If that actually would provide us the opportunity to get back to you, and then you of course would then know whether we stand together or divided on an issue.
0:56:32 That would give us the opportunity to also have a conversation with our legislators.
0:56:37 If I could, Fritz, could you come forward?
0:56:40 I just want to make sure that we're very careful here.
0:56:42 By the way, I've learned in my life,
0:56:45 reply all is not always your friend.
0:56:47 Never reply all of them.
0:56:49 No, I know you were.
0:56:50 I'm just saying that personally.
0:56:51 I've done that a few times.
0:56:53 Talk to us about what we can and can't do again.
0:56:56 Okay, so, Rebecca's idea, and certainly I think Travis would have no problem forwarding,
0:57:02 I think he should forward any of those emergency new legislation to you so you know what's going on.
0:57:09 There's nothing wrong with any of you replying to the legislator who sent that out,
0:57:16 but you should not send them to Travis because you're sort of giving a vote to Travis, which he then in turn says,
0:57:22 says, okay, here's the position of the City Council, and you've sort of indirectly taken
0:57:27 a vote that way, so you can't do it that way.
0:57:29 Very good.
0:57:30 That's what I was afraid of.
0:57:31 Well, I just want to piggy up back on some of the comments.
0:57:34 We've hired our City Manager to run the day-to-day operations.
0:57:38 He or she are trained, educated, and have the experience to do this job.
0:57:43 So we've got to rely on some trust there, and you've shown trust, I mean, we can trust
0:57:51 because of the past, just keep us informed of what's going on, is my opinion.
0:57:56 If it looks like something that you really believe that we should come together and
0:57:59 have a vote, then we need to call a meeting and have a vote to give you some direction or
0:58:03 give our direction towards the AIC.
0:58:07 But I am more than confident in your perspectives and your views on these issues,
0:58:13 to be able to reach out to the legislators on these respects.
0:58:17 Does that house work?
0:58:18 I just want to offer, yes, as long as we're copied, yes.
0:58:23 To maybe take Travis out of this, if you go to the AIC's website, you can sign up for
0:58:27 the hot notifications and everything that Travis is getting, you will get directly, and that
0:58:32 takes him out of the middle.
0:58:34 And then if something pops up that you see that you think we need to address as a council,
0:58:38 we can maybe go out it that way, and that way there's no legal questions about serial
0:58:42 meetings or anything because it's totally legitimate to get it from the AIC, and they
0:58:46 They send them out daily.
0:58:47 They send out hot links.
0:58:48 But that wouldn't give us the information Travis just gave us.
0:58:51 Oh no, that's exactly where it came from.
0:58:53 And that's what we're expected to be knowledgeable about by the taxpayers.
0:58:58 We've got to be in the loop somehow.
0:58:59 So we can be aware of that as long as our attorney indicates we don't get back to you
0:59:07 our feelings.
0:59:08 So Chris, what you're saying makes sure that I understand and it makes sense to me that
0:59:12 we could get these bulletins or alerts.
0:59:16 We have to have sometimes someone translating it to us.
0:59:18 How does it really affect us locally?
0:59:20 Absolutely.
0:59:21 And that's what we have travel.
0:59:22 That's what we have travel.
0:59:23 Yeah, absolutely.
0:59:24 Very good.
0:59:25 Travis.
0:59:26 So maybe I'd also offer a suggestion.
0:59:29 So one of the things that I'm going to be doing
0:59:32 is participating in a weekly briefing update
0:59:36 of emerging legislative issues with the Association
0:59:40 of Idaho Cities.
0:59:42 That meeting is going to occur on Fridays.
0:59:46 and when it occurs on Fridays,
0:59:48 it's well after the time in which we publish the agenda.
0:59:54 But obviously, there typically is not a legislative action
0:59:57 that occurs on a course over the weekend.
1:00:01 Maybe what I can do when we've also put as a public input
1:00:06 and for city manager, maybe above that way,
1:00:08 I can put a legislative update.
1:00:10 And part of that conversation, as there is time,
1:00:15 I think it is much more impactful if we say a majority or unanimous support or oppose of
1:00:23 members of the Twin Falls City Council.
1:00:26 I think that would carry a lot of weight, especially when members of our local delegation
1:00:30 are looking for suggestions and solutions in moving that forward.
1:00:34 I'd like to use that because I think that is much more powerful than just me sending an
1:00:41 email saying, I oppose.
1:00:44 Now there will be times where, so for example, a bill will get a print hearing on a Tuesday
1:00:51 morning and it will have a public hearing on a Wednesday where we have a 15-day notice
1:00:57 period to provide public hearing.
1:01:00 I believe that their time frame is significantly condensed and so as a result of that, we may
1:01:07 not have those opportunities to get together but I will do everything that I can and if
1:01:12 If I am uncertain, I will certainly share and maybe not take a position but share the impacts
1:01:21 and I will certainly always keep you CC'd and informed of all correspondents that I have
1:01:26 with the members of our local delegation.
1:01:28 Thank you, Travis.
1:01:29 We have another light.
1:01:30 Rebecca, may I say?
1:01:31 Thank you, Travis.
1:01:32 I think that's a good idea to just have a legislative update on the agenda.
1:01:35 I would ask if you do feel like you're going to ask us to vote on something or maybe support
1:01:39 or not support something, maybe send us something over the weekend so that we can at least
1:01:44 be red up on it and I guess make an educated vote.
1:01:48 I'm just so we don't come and feel unprepared to really support or stand behind a certain
1:01:55 position.
1:01:56 Thanks.
1:01:58 And my last comment about this, I guess I'm more sensitive, but it sure seems like that
1:02:04 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:06 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:07 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:08 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:09 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:10 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:11 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:12 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:13 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:14 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:15 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:16 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:17 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:18 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:19 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:20 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:21 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:22 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:23 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:24 I don't know how to do that.
1:02:25 this seems to be the year in which cities and our operations tend to as well as
1:02:32 counties local government in general really appear to be under the the spotlight
1:02:38 of some certain members of the Idaho legislature but I would add this especially
1:02:42 since this is obviously strange it is our obligation as citizens not only city
1:02:47 council members but citizens of the city that when we see something that could
1:02:51 negatively affect our city, we should get a hold of our legislators.
1:02:56 I know every one of them very well, our local legislative folks, and they're always open to our inputs.
1:03:02 So we need to reach out, and that includes all of us if it's something that we feel strongly about.
1:03:09 No, I would disagree with that.
1:03:10 Some of them are more receptive than others.
1:03:13 The LIP service does not equal action on items of importance to the local government.
1:03:20 I say urban renewal specifically.
1:03:23 I will take that as your perspective.
1:03:25 My perspective is different.
1:03:27 Thank you.
1:03:28 Anything further Travis?
1:03:30 Thank you.
1:03:31 Chris, you had your light on.
1:03:32 Yeah, I'd like to thank Travis for his my weekly updates and he's giving us some big picture issues.
1:03:39 I find them especially help on fact what we're just talking about kind of plays right into that, but
1:03:45 they're talking about the
1:03:48 parent
1:03:50 Accommodation of the challenge on the water issue with the spring. I think is it been really helpful and it'll it gives me the idea of having a little bit something
1:03:59 forward-thinking that I can neither
1:04:02 Responded semi intelligently to when the citizen talks about it or be aware of some issues that the council needs to
1:04:09 I think further about one item that he did mention earlier, dealing with our city water
1:04:15 billings.
1:04:16 I've done this just for my own personal edification to see if I could have an online water bill
1:04:22 without a hard copy sent.
1:04:25 And it did not take long to get the online bill, but I still got a hard copy.
1:04:31 But maybe you can check into the program to see if there's a way that if I make a selection,
1:04:37 We don't have to have that tree killed and that posting stamp used.
1:04:42 I was particularly taken away with your comments of the approximately 15,000 billings monthly.
1:04:50 Only about 300 was not that have requested online and about 150 actually pay online.
1:04:59 That just in very rough numbers.
1:05:01 So I would hope this is one issue.
1:05:03 We can become much more digitally sensitive and try to increase the number of people who
1:05:11 either access and or pay online.
1:05:14 I must say that there are cheaper alternatives and paying the $3.50 that the city requires
1:05:20 to pay online.
1:05:21 My bank does it for nothing, so there are cheaper ways of doing it.
1:05:26 I think we should really try to extend that roughly 3% or so of the people that see
1:05:31 either bill online to a much higher amount, 10% or something.
1:05:35 I don't have the means to tell you what to do, but thank you.
1:05:39 It's all positive.
1:05:43 Maybe I missed that whole.
1:05:44 It costs $3 and something to pay online and
1:05:47 it doesn't cost anything to mail it in or drop it off.
1:05:50 That is correct.
1:05:51 Remind me why, why?
1:05:52 That is a fee.
1:05:53 So when we initially went to the process, that is a fee that is charged by credit card companies.
1:05:59 for the right to be able to utilize that service.
1:06:02 And so that fee that is assessed is passed directly
1:06:05 on to the customer.
1:06:07 But I pray you.
1:06:09 But what if can we can they pay with debit cards?
1:06:12 Is any form of card is and.
1:06:16 Let's say I pay through my bank
1:06:18 and I'm not charged at all.
1:06:19 That's right.
1:06:20 Online.
1:06:22 Okay.
1:06:23 That's right.
1:06:25 All right.
1:06:26 Thank you.
1:06:27 All right.
1:06:28 the portion of City Council, anything from the City Council, before we move on to our public hearing this evening.
1:06:35 All right, it sounds like we would need a quick break, or let's go until 10 after.
1:06:40 I'd like to reconvene the City Council meeting for February 2030.
1:11:36 It is now 6-11 in the evening, and we have a public hearing,
1:11:42 which is consideration of request for a zoning title amendment to amend Title 10 to increase the required
1:11:49 public knows for various public hearings and we have Jonathan spend love as a
1:11:54 presenter from City perspective. Thank you Mayor Hall and Council a little bit
1:12:01 of history on this amendment it was requested the request was generated by
1:12:05 the Planning and Zoning Commission following discussion regarding the
1:12:08 effectiveness of the current public hearing notice requirements as described
1:12:12 as the code and these discussions occurred as a direct result from some
1:12:15 public hearing items that took place in August and September of last year, so 2014.
1:12:20 A staff generated the amendment under the direction of the Planning and Zoning Commission.
1:12:26 We had multiple public work sessions, using the first Wednesday of every month, so it was
1:12:32 in October, November and December, and during those work sessions we went through this code
1:12:36 section to get this result.
1:12:40 What this is going to do is change multiple sectors within Title X, the major change across
1:12:45 occurs in Title 10, Chapter 7, and a new Section 20 has been written.
1:12:50 To address all the concerns and changes voiced by the public and the commission,
1:12:54 some changes also address some discrepancy between Twin Falls City Code and State
1:12:58 statute regarding notice.
1:13:00 So in the staff report, there's three major changes that I'm going to hit.
1:13:03 First one is applicants will be required to notify public hearings,
1:13:06 send letters, and post signs on the same day.
1:13:10 The second one is notification distances have been increased in order to more adequately
1:13:13 provide notice to surrounding property owners.
1:13:16 And number three, the number and size of public notice signs
1:13:19 has been increased to provide more adequate notice
1:13:21 on adjacent street furniture.
1:13:23 So the first one regarding the letters and the signs,
1:13:28 they will be applicants will be required to post the property
1:13:32 and send the letters on the same day.
1:13:34 Previously we had them on two different days,
1:13:35 so this is gonna be 15 days prior to the public hearing.
1:13:39 The letters will be sent and the sign
1:13:40 will be posted on the property.
1:13:42 That's a change that's taking place.
1:13:45 It'll help staff more closely monitor the status
1:13:48 of the notifications, help us catch notification
1:13:51 violations sooner, and simplify the process for the applicant.
1:13:54 We'll also provide an increase of notification time
1:13:57 to adjoining property owners and residents.
1:13:59 Previously, the signs were only had to be there for a week.
1:14:02 This requires it to be 15 days, so it'll
1:14:04 be up a little bit longer.
1:14:07 In addition to the other changes, you'll
1:14:08 see that it'll be much more adequate notice.
1:14:12 Second major change listed above is the increase
1:14:16 in the minimum notification distance.
1:14:18 Currency code applies in across the board 300 feet measured
1:14:21 from the exterior property line.
1:14:23 That 300 feet also originates in state statute,
1:14:27 but we can't increase it if we wish and we've done so.
1:14:31 A distance, they're gonna change depending
1:14:35 on the circumstance.
1:14:37 There'll be no, notification will be at a minimum of 500 feet.
1:14:41 there will be nothing notified less than that.
1:14:44 Those items are generally special use permits,
1:14:48 some of those smaller items,
1:14:49 but they have an increase,
1:14:50 so nothing will be less than 500 feet.
1:14:52 That's gonna catch a lot more residences,
1:14:55 a lot more people and owners.
1:14:58 Certain public hearings within the C1, CB, R6,
1:15:02 and MH01 zoning districts will be notified at 750 feet.
1:15:07 So that's a dramatic increase from the base to 300
1:15:10 that it was before.
1:15:12 And then public hearings or certain public hearings
1:15:13 in the M1 and M2 zoning districts will be notified at 1,000.
1:15:18 So what this means is anything going to or from
1:15:21 that C1, CBR6 or MHL1 zone will be a 750.
1:15:26 So if it's zoning to it or zoning from it,
1:15:28 anything involved with those zones will be at 750.
1:15:32 Anything involving the manufacturing districts
1:15:34 to or from will be the 1,000.
1:15:38 So that's a big change for us.
1:15:41 The third change is increasing the number and the size of the signs to be placed on the site.
1:15:47 Locations that front and multiple roads will be required to place a sign on each frontage.
1:15:52 If you have a corner lot, there will be one on both streets.
1:15:56 Locations will be required to have a minimum of one sign per 300 feet of street frontage
1:16:01 or a fraction thereof, so if you have 301 or 302 feet, you're going to have two signs placed equal distance.
1:16:08 locations that front a city designated arterial street or state highway will be
1:16:12 required to furnish signs that are in minimum four feet tall and four feet wide.
1:16:16 Right now they are two by three so those are a lot bigger signs. With the bottom
1:16:24 of the sign being at least three feet above the ground so they're more visible
1:16:28 on those larger streets where people are driving faster you'll be able to see the
1:16:31 sign more readily. The other part of that is they'll be perpendicular to the driving
1:16:37 So, if the perpendicular to the roads, you can see a lot better.
1:16:42 Right now, there allowed to be parallel.
1:16:44 So you can only see it right up on it.
1:16:47 So you're able to see it further away.
1:16:55 It's just handing me a note here.
1:16:57 We still have the ability to require additional mailings per the administrator.
1:17:00 We didn't change that part.
1:17:01 So if we feel that something needs to be more adequately noticed,
1:17:05 we can increase that distance from 550,000 to whatever we feel is adequate
1:17:10 adequate for those areas, particularly a situation where, say, most of the
1:17:16 neighborhood is notified, but there's like two people at the end of the street
1:17:19 that are outside that distance of 500 or 750 feet. We would include those two
1:17:24 people so that the whole neighborhood would be notified. Those are specific
1:17:28 instances. We also, some other changes that we have, we need to provide the
1:17:39 decision by the Planning and Zoning Commission on Public Notice when items
1:17:42 are forwarded to the City Council.
1:17:44 So if there's a zoning change, they have a vote on it.
1:17:46 We will include that vote on the notice to you
1:17:50 so that people know what the planning and zoning decided
1:17:52 prior to coming to this meeting.
1:17:55 The other thing is a time frame to remove
1:17:57 the public notice signs.
1:17:58 So they have to be down a certain number of days
1:18:00 after the meeting's taking place.
1:18:03 An requirement for staff to furnish a press release
1:18:05 to the local news media and to post the public notice
1:18:07 on the city website.
1:18:09 Other sections listed on the amendment
1:18:12 are to redirect the reference for public notifications to the newly created Title 10,
1:18:17 Chapter 7, Section 20.
1:18:19 So we're creating a whole new section and redirecting all the others to this new section
1:18:23 about public notice.
1:18:26 On January 27th, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on this amendment.
1:18:30 The Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval of the Code Amendment has written.
1:18:34 However, one Commission requested upon adoption of the ordinance, the new Code Section 10720
1:18:40 reference specifically in the various code sections being modified, so they'd say 10,
1:18:45 7, 20 instead of just the public notice section. The attachment reflects this addition. In conclusion,
1:18:51 staff concurs with the commission's recommendation and asks for the City Council approval.
1:18:55 Thank you, Jonathan. Do we have any questions for Jonathan? We're back in the next slide.
1:19:02 Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Jonathan, for your report. In the different sections that
1:19:08 addresses it says that no amendments are needed for ZDA and requests for additional
1:19:13 height. Can you give us the requirements for those two and why they're kind of
1:19:18 left out of these new changes? I'm not mistaken those changes reflect it just as
1:19:23 a public hearing required. I think they'd already point to this new section and
1:19:27 Mitch can be still on the road that little piece. I believe that's what they
1:19:32 do is point to this new section anyway or something like it. That's right they
1:19:36 They just said use the hearing notice that's required for zoning change.
1:19:42 Okay, so they are the same.
1:19:44 They're the same.
1:19:45 Okay, so no amendments needed.
1:19:47 Okay, great, thank you.
1:19:50 Do we have any other questions?
1:19:53 All right, at this time, I'm going to go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of this evening's public hearing.
1:19:59 I've been out in the audience on numerous occasions trying to get our Times News reporter to come up forward because I keep forgetting, but to no avail.
1:20:07 So at this time, it's anyone else that would like to come forward.
1:20:11 This is your time.
1:20:12 So Mayor, I have one letter that we received.
1:20:15 It's a total of three sentences.
1:20:17 I can either read it or put it on the screen.
1:20:19 Could you do both?
1:20:20 Sure.
1:20:21 Well, at the same time.
1:20:23 Yes.
1:20:24 You are now a deputy city manager.
1:20:26 You can do that.
1:20:29 All right.
1:20:30 This is from today Climes.
1:20:32 Please accept this email as my positive input
1:20:34 on the expansion of both Notus area
1:20:37 and lift on the number of letters that can be sent out.
1:20:43 This is a positive change by opinion.
1:20:44 I'm unable to attend the meeting tomorrow.
1:20:46 And I do too schedule a complex.
1:20:48 Thank you, Mitch.
1:20:49 Is there anyone further would like to come forward?
1:20:53 All right, at this time, I'm closing the public testimony.
1:20:56 portion of this evening's hearing
1:20:58 and turning it back over to council.
1:21:01 Chris Stocky.
1:21:02 I would move to approve the amendments title
1:21:06 increasing the required public notice
1:21:08 various public hearings pursuant to the describe changes and the conditions attached.
1:21:15 I'll second.
1:21:16 I have a motion on the floor by Chris talking and seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
1:21:21 Rebecca, did you have a question or comment?
1:21:24 Just to comment.
1:21:25 Okay, very good.
1:21:26 Yeah.
1:21:27 I just wanted to share and thank the Planning and Zoning Commission on all their work along
1:21:32 with the staff.
1:21:33 They really did a great job on this amendment.
1:21:36 As we see, there's no input tonight, but there was a lot of input at the work sessions as we went along.
1:21:42 And so I think all of that front end worked and involvement with the public really created a responsive document,
1:21:53 a good amendment that is balanced, it's not reactive, but it is responsive.
1:21:59 And I think it will address some of the issues that we saw.
1:22:03 And as Jonathan stated, the Planning and Zoning Commission
1:22:06 did initiate this, but so did the Council.
1:22:09 We also requested this change.
1:22:11 And so I find that it is probably not perfect.
1:22:15 We may need to change it in the future,
1:22:16 but I think it's certainly an improvement
1:22:18 upon our current process.
1:22:20 I support it.
1:22:21 Thank you, Rebecca.
1:22:23 I'll just weigh in and say, I agree with what Rebecca just said.
1:22:27 I know that we discussed this during ZOAC
1:22:30 and many other committees.
1:22:32 and we just felt that it was time to go beyond
1:22:36 what the minimum of the state said
1:22:39 to better serve our community and get better notice.
1:22:42 Because the zoning changes,
1:22:46 can change people's properties tremendously
1:22:49 and they need to have some input when they come about.
1:22:52 So I really want to thank staff and planning zoning
1:22:57 and all those that were involved in coming up
1:23:00 with these changes.
1:23:04 That I see no further light.
1:23:05 So Lee Aila, roll call vote, please.
1:23:09 Don Hall.
1:23:10 Yes.
1:23:11 Rebecca Milsoka.
1:23:12 Yes.
1:23:12 Suzanne Hunken.
1:23:13 Yes.
1:23:14 Jim Mann.
1:23:15 Yes.
1:23:16 Chris Taughton.
1:23:17 Yes.
1:23:17 Motion passes, five to zero.
1:23:18 And unless there's anything further.
1:23:21 We'll have that ordinance back for your consideration
1:23:24 makes meeting probably.
1:23:26 Very good.
1:23:27 Thank you very much.
1:23:28 And with that, we're going ahead and adjourn.
Download
- Transcript (text) 85 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 114 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 157 KB
- Audio (M4A) 19.8 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, February 23, 2015. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:24:03.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
29c642196cc27562e04f953d61cc7a67afc8ceff2ffb60dbee9b8556da402cbe - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 115c01afffa0a9877fd7ac17912c8e3ad81e01c2e9b068d0284dc12fdec4c736 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
480b1c9139f08ecc82cd2fc1b4a59254b6f81bedbf8771bd68fe8d56b601486e
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file