City Council meeting
Monday, December 22, 2014
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:10:50 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order.
0:10:53 It's December 22nd, 2014.
0:10:55 For those of you wishing to, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:11:01 Aye.
0:11:02 Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the City Council meeting.
0:11:21 Want to confirm that we do have a quorum of the City Council.
0:11:24 All seven members are here this evening.
0:11:26 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments
0:11:28 to our agenda this evening?
0:11:30 Mr. Mayor and members of the council,
0:11:32 we do have one proposed amendment this evening.
0:11:34 It is to issue an alcohol license
0:11:38 to GUP's LLC doing business as GUP's Hot Rod Grill,
0:11:44 located at 110 Main Avenue North.
0:11:48 And you wanna add that just to the consent calendar?
0:11:50 If we could.
0:11:51 Very good.
0:11:52 Greg, Lansing.
0:11:53 move that we add the alcohol license approval of the alcohol license for
0:11:57 get the top right bill.
0:11:59 Second motion on the floor by Greg Lanning seconded by Rebecca
0:12:03 Melsoica to add as stated anything further on that motion.
0:12:08 Chris talking.
0:12:09 I wonder I may have one additional item is Mr. Robin Wells in the audience.
0:12:14 Civil Air Patrol Robin Wells.
0:12:19 I'd like to add the appointment or the advancement of two lieutenants within the Civil War Patrol
0:12:27 as their report business if we could just give a couple minutes up front, Mayor.
0:12:31 Absolutely. I don't know if we do. We need to add that as an agenda item.
0:12:35 We can do it under the general public input session and it'll be in court recorded for our meeting minutes.
0:12:40 Very good. If that will work for you, Chris.
0:12:42 Oh, certainly. Very good.
0:12:43 All right. We have a motion on court counsel. Do we have any further on that motion?
0:12:48 The island roll call vote, please Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Jim. I'm yes, Sean Berger. Yes, he's talking. Yes
0:12:56 Greg Lanting yes, Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca no, so I can yes motion passes seven to zero
0:13:02 We have no proclamations this evening, but what we do have is general public input and if that gentleman's
0:13:09 first of all, I guess I'll just open up to the community anyone in the audience that would like to come forward and
0:13:14 address the council this evening. I see no one coming forward so I will turn it
0:13:21 over to Councilman talking. Mr. Wells your time has come please come to the
0:13:28 podium will you please Robin nobody here representing the Civil Air Patrol then
0:13:42 are you on your way sir are you Mr. Wells? Very good. Okay thank you. I was
0:13:51 approached by Robin several weeks ago about the right up the podium if you will
0:13:55 right here please. And then just face this way about the potential couple minutes at the front end of
0:14:02 the audience at the front end of the meeting excuse me for some important civil error patrol business.
0:14:10 Those of you probably associated with civil error patrol one way or another know it's an
0:14:15 important edge on to the Air Force as well as our airport operation with our other alternative
0:14:21 already in.
0:14:24 Thank you, Mr. Talkington, for letting us come on the short notice.
0:14:36 I have a rather long piece that it would be good to read, but in the interest of time,
0:14:47 cut it short.
0:14:50 Civil Air Patrol is a auxiliary of the United States Air Force, and we do search and rescue
0:14:58 And we do cadet programs.
0:15:03 We have had quite a seven-year period with the two young people that you're going to
0:15:12 meet here in a little bit.
0:15:16 We have NCO ranks as the Air Force.
0:15:19 And at this point, the two cadets that are here tonight have reached and passed the requirements
0:15:26 to become second lieutenants.
0:15:29 And this is a big deal for them and the Air Force, it's a big deal.
0:15:38 So big that the Air Force would like to have a little bit of recognition for the individuals
0:15:51 and in the community when they reach what's called the Mitchell Award, which is the second
0:15:58 and then at the lieutenant stage,
0:16:03 they are to be awarded by the mayor of the city,
0:16:08 the United States Senator, the United States Representative,
0:16:12 and I suppose the governor would work.
0:16:16 But this is to be kind of the end of a long period of earning
0:16:26 rank and requirements.
0:16:29 these two cadets, like I said, have been with me for seven years, and during that time life
0:16:39 has happened to everyone, and they are either in college or in one cadets case, he is a United
0:16:52 States Marine.
0:16:54 So when he's doing Marine Corps stuff, he'll be working on tanks, and when he comes home
0:17:01 on vacation, he'll be doing search and rescue.
0:17:05 So Mayor Hall, if you would award their rank in insignia, or what they have earned and have
0:17:22 actually been granted the privilege of wearing the officer, rank.
0:17:29 So essentially, sir, they're going from a non-commissioned officer to a commission officer through this process.
0:17:39 That's correct.
0:17:40 Okay, and you're going to have to enlighten me on the proceedings you want me to come down.
0:17:45 I do.
0:17:46 Okay.
0:17:47 Ms. Duncan, would you come with me with your background, sir?
0:17:49 I wanted that I have one of you.
0:19:03 That was actually kind of fun.
0:19:52 Yes.
0:19:53 Congratulations to both of you. It's a it's a big deal like Captain said so thank you for coming in front of us
0:19:59 And it was a great honor for us to be part of your
0:20:02 Promotion great job. Thank you. Thank you, Councilman talking to him for bringing that to our attention
0:20:10 Is there anyone else from the general public that would like to come forward?
0:20:13 Well at this time, I think what we would like to do if you with the
0:20:18 Patience of the folks in the audience. We would like to take it just a real short recess
0:20:22 We're going to go outside and look at the new fire truck.
0:20:26 Those of you wishing to join us, please do so.
0:20:29 Everybody loves the fire trucks.
0:20:31 We are recommitting the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council.
0:25:36 We are now moving down to the consent calendar with the addition, Greg Lanning.
0:25:41 Move approval to consent calendar as amended.
0:25:44 Second.
0:25:45 Motion on floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as amended.
0:25:51 I think further on that motion council.
0:25:55 Will the aye of the roll call vote please?
0:25:56 Jim Munn.
0:25:57 Yes.
0:25:58 Sean Berriger.
0:25:59 Yes.
0:26:00 He's talking to us.
0:26:01 Yes.
0:26:02 Greg Lanting.
0:26:03 Yes.
0:26:04 Don Hall.
0:26:05 Yes.
0:26:06 Rebecca Pilsuica.
0:26:07 Yes.
0:26:08 Suzanne Honkin.
0:26:09 Yes.
0:26:10 Motion passes.
0:26:11 Seven to zero.
0:26:12 We will be moving down to items for consideration now.
0:26:13 The first item will be presentation for Twin Falls Fire Department Level 3 Firefighter
0:26:19 certifications to David Olens, Tyrone Prescott, Scott Wyatt, and Joel Miller.
0:26:26 Turn it over to Chief Ron Clark. Welcome, Chief.
0:26:29 Thank you. Happy Holidays, Mayor and Council into the whole wide world, of course.
0:26:34 It's pretty hard difficult to follow being tagged a second lieutenant.
0:26:40 But we'll do our best. I appreciate you taking the time to look at the new fire truck.
0:26:47 Right quickly, it's amazing to me what a mere $485,000 will do this in age, and just for an FYI, that truck is going into service tomorrow.
0:26:58 That was the reason we brought it over tonight, so you guys could take a peek at it.
0:27:02 Chief, if I could just make a comment.
0:27:06 Chris said this as we were walking out.
0:27:08 It's hard for us to see that that's a new truck because of the way you take care of all your trucks.
0:27:14 in such pristine shape, and I would agree with that comment.
0:27:18 Well I'd like to take credit for me washing them waxing them all the time, but it's really
0:27:22 not me.
0:27:23 Well when I say you I mean that.
0:27:26 Yeah.
0:27:27 I appreciate that because it's been probably a couple of decades since I've been wearing
0:27:31 them.
0:27:32 And I would assume I'm never going to wash them out of them.
0:27:36 But we have what we call a zero tolerance level with those trucks, and we are acutely
0:27:42 aware of the fact of where the money comes from, to buy these pieces apparatus, and therefore
0:27:47 we take really good care of them.
0:27:50 So I appreciate your comments.
0:27:54 And onto another subject, we're here this evening and I appreciate you taking the time
0:27:58 to recognize four of our Twin Falls firefighters for successfully completing our Twin Falls
0:28:04 Fire Department Level 3 certification.
0:28:08 We have four firefighters.
0:28:09 As I said, firefighter Dave Owens, Joe Miller, TJ Prescott, and Scott Wyatt have achieved
0:28:14 this certification.
0:28:16 These classes on an average, usually by the time you can get completely finished, it can
0:28:21 take you a couple of years to get through our Level 3 certification.
0:28:24 We have a Level 1, a Level 2, and a Level 3.
0:28:27 None of them are kidneys.
0:28:29 So these guys have put in well over 100 hours of classroom and bookwork to get this certification.
0:28:37 certification meets or exceeds and in almost every instance exceeds anything the state
0:28:42 requires. So I'm really proud of these four people and the others in the department that
0:28:48 have achieved this level three level. It's our highest level like that. And they have
0:28:52 a hundred hours in classes such as state fire and spectra certification. It's not an easy
0:28:57 class. Fire caused determination. So fire investigations, arson, things like that. Every
0:29:02 one of the department is spiffed up to that level.
0:29:05 Incident Command System, which we use at every incident.
0:29:10 Managing Company Tactical Operations is a preparation class.
0:29:14 Managing Company Tactical Operations, a decision-making class.
0:29:18 And managing Company Tactical Operations, a tactics class.
0:29:22 So with those, it's kind of the core and the backbone
0:29:26 of the fire service.
0:29:27 We run under the Incident Command System,
0:29:29 and these classes and all that tell you what to look out for and how to do your job as
0:29:34 best you can.
0:29:35 So we're very proud of these firefighters and I would ask the mayor to present their certificates,
0:29:39 their level three certificates to them.
0:29:44 And they are right.
0:29:49 And you can just call their name and do it wherever you want to get it all.
0:29:56 And congratulations.
0:29:57 Thank you.
0:29:59 Appreciate it.
0:30:00 Thank you.
0:30:01 Appreciate it.
0:30:03 We're very proud of this department.
0:30:52 Thank you very much.
0:30:53 Appreciate it.
0:30:54 Thank you all.
0:30:55 Thank you for your service to our community.
0:30:57 As an ex-cop, we always kind of jab at each other, firemen and cops.
0:31:02 But honestly, we appreciate your service and the dangerous part of your job and really the
0:31:11 heart-wrenching part of your job, too, that was on display recently. So thank you.
0:31:16 You're very welcome. We love police officers and all other city departments.
0:31:20 Wow, that's PC, man.
0:31:25 Moving on to the next item is consideration of your request to appoint
0:31:31 Kyle Tarbet to the Board of Trustees to serve a full term of office from January
0:31:37 2015 to December 2019 for the library and Susan Ash will be coming forward.
0:31:45 But before that, Sean Berger.
0:31:48 Yeah, Mr. Mayor, because Kyle is an employee of the Twin Falls Chamber, I am going to recuse
0:31:54 myself from this discussion and approval.
0:31:57 Thank you very much.
0:31:58 So noted.
0:31:59 Susan, come forward, please, and welcome.
0:32:09 So Mayor Hall, the Library City Council Representative Jen Mundt, and City Council Members, thank
0:32:15 you for your time today.
0:32:17 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:32:23 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:32:28 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:32:36 Mr. Tarben expresses a strong interest in the library
0:32:39 and is prepared to accept the full responsibilities
0:32:41 of a working library trustee for his term of office.
0:32:44 And I'd like to read a little bit from his letter
0:32:47 that he wrote to the Board of Trustees.
0:32:51 This is from Kyle.
0:32:52 I have always enjoyed reading, and credit that to my mother,
0:32:55 who took me to the Demere Memorial Library in Rupert
0:32:58 each week to choose two or three books.
0:33:01 My siblings and I participated in summer reading programs,
0:33:04 movie nights and many other activities at the library.
0:33:07 My connection to the Twin Pauls Public Library is very different.
0:33:11 My wife usually takes our two young children to choose two or three books of their own each
0:33:16 week.
0:33:17 I read those books each night with them before bed.
0:33:19 They know I'll let them stay up a little bit longer for one more.
0:33:23 Clifford, Curious George, or Berenstein Bear Story, which usually turns into two or three.
0:33:28 I cherish the opportunity to read to my children and quiz them on letters, numbers, colors,
0:33:33 shapes in the books. Even though my business to the library and frequent, the impact of
0:33:39 the library on my family is great. I would be honored to serve on the Board of Trustees,
0:33:44 my educational background is in political science and public administration, and I have
0:33:49 experience in marketing, social media, public relations, government relations, volunteer
0:33:55 management, events and fundraising. I am very willing to put my skills to use in benefiting
0:34:00 the Twin Falls Public Library.
0:34:02 Thank you.
0:34:05 Council?
0:34:06 Chris Dockington.
0:34:08 Susan, I'm just forgetting who is Kyle replacing on the board.
0:34:12 Ahmed Hansen?
0:34:13 Oh, okay.
0:34:14 He's terming out, right?
0:34:17 Yes.
0:34:18 You have big shoes to fill their account.
0:34:20 Right.
0:34:21 I'll stand for a motion.
0:34:24 Council, Suzanne Hawkins.
0:34:25 I would like to make a motion that we appoint Kyle Tarrbitt to serve as a library trustee for
0:34:32 full term starting in January of 2015 and running through December of 2019.
0:34:38 Second?
0:34:39 Motion on 4 by Zhenhalken, seconded by Jim Mon.
0:34:43 As stated.
0:34:44 You think further on that motion council.
0:34:46 I just wanted to say thank you Kyle for stepping forward and serving in this capacity.
0:34:51 We know how important that library is to this community.
0:34:55 Absolutely important.
0:34:56 A little shady on your employment.
0:34:58 But other than that, you know, you're a fine young man in a good example, so anything further
0:35:06 counsel? Lee Eilabro Kofo, please. Sean Berriger. He's listening. Chris
0:35:12 Talkington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milsoica. Yes. Suzanne
0:35:21 Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mine. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Kyle, if you wouldn't mind just
0:35:28 saying maybe a couple words, tell us a little bit about yourself.
0:35:32 Sure.
0:35:34 As you heard from my letter, I grew up in Rupert.
0:35:37 Always going to the library.
0:35:38 I've had a love of reading and learning throughout my life.
0:35:42 And it's just something that I'm passionate about.
0:35:46 I'm excited to see my children are now passionate about.
0:35:48 And it's a great opportunity for me to be more involved
0:35:51 in the community and also involve my family in that service.
0:35:55 So I'm very excited and thank you all.
0:35:58 Very good.
0:36:00 And thank you Board of Trustees,
0:36:02 got this evening and if we can give Kyle a hand.
0:36:10 Excellent.
0:36:10 Moving on to the next item is consideration
0:36:13 of a request to confirm the appointment
0:36:15 of Samantha Camp through the Historic Preservation Committee
0:36:18 to serve a partial term from December 22nd, 2014
0:36:22 to July 21st, 2014.
0:36:26 And Randall Watson is here to back us up.
0:36:29 So we advertised for a position because we had to fill a partial term of individual going
0:36:38 off the historic preservation because of just time conflicts.
0:36:44 And so recently we interviewed three different folks and I will just tell you Jim was part
0:36:50 of that, Randall and of course Kelly was as well.
0:36:54 and three quality individuals, but Samantha, as far as I'm concerned, your energy just
0:37:01 filled the room and we really are excited about having that energy on the historic preservation
0:37:07 commission. Not that the folks on commission aren't energetic, Randall. So if you'd like
0:37:12 to say a couple words, Randall?
0:37:14 You bet. Thanks. Honorable Mayor, Vice Mayor and City Council. I'm Randall Watson, as the
0:37:19 the mayor stated, chairman of the Twin Falls Historic Committee.
0:37:24 And as he said, we interviewed an excellent pool of applicants
0:37:28 and requests that Samantha Camp be appointed.
0:37:32 She has a great passion and enthusiasm
0:37:36 for the city of Twin Falls history.
0:37:38 She brings excellent marketing, media, and graphic art skills
0:37:43 as shown by her resume.
0:37:45 She also has attended college and political science
0:37:49 and will be a valuable asset to the Twin Falls
0:37:51 Historic Preservation Commission.
0:37:54 Very good, thank you, Randall.
0:37:55 I just want to state that this is my appointment.
0:37:59 Now I would ask council if they would confirm that.
0:38:04 So moved.
0:38:05 I'll second.
0:38:06 Motion on the floor by Jim Mon,
0:38:08 seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
0:38:11 Anything further on that motion, council?
0:38:14 Leila, roll call vote, please.
0:38:16 Chris Talkington?
0:38:17 Yes.
0:38:18 Greg Lanting?
0:38:19 Yes.
0:38:19 Yes.
0:38:20 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:38:21 Yes.
0:38:23 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:38:24 Yes.
0:38:25 Jim Munn.
0:38:26 Yes.
0:38:27 Sean Bericher.
0:38:28 Yes.
0:38:29 Motion passes 7-0 Samantha.
0:38:30 That was a squeaker.
0:38:31 If you wouldn't mind coming up to the microphone.
0:38:33 One of the things that really impressed me about you was your energy but also your marketing
0:38:38 skills that maybe you could help bring some ideas to our commission.
0:38:43 So if you just spend a minute and let us get to know you.
0:38:47 Well thank you, I really appreciate that.
0:38:50 My sister commented when we came in here that this is really exciting for me.
0:38:55 I love all of this kind of stuff.
0:38:58 I'm a big fan of city government and it's really exciting for me to be a little part of
0:39:04 it now.
0:39:06 So thank you all so much for this.
0:39:11 So you commented on my marketing, I currently work for Randy Hanson Automotive and I do all
0:39:16 of that.
0:39:17 spend the whole day doing. So I'm really excited to be able to hopefully bring that
0:39:22 to the city and help market this place that I've loved so much for so long. So
0:39:28 thank you. Very good. Any questions for Samantha? Welcome board. Let's give her a
0:39:32 hand. Moving on to item number four. Consideration of a request to award a
0:39:44 bid to replace the Woodin-Durkeys Lake Stairs with metal stairs to Morgan
0:39:49 construction in the amount of $193,853 and we have Dennis Boyer. Welcome Dennis.
0:39:57 Thank you Council Mayor. It's a pleasure to be here tonight. Yes, I'm here tonight to hopefully
0:40:03 to have the Council award this bid to Morgan's construction to replace the
0:40:08 wooden stairs. First I have a question for all the Council, how many have been on
0:40:11 those stairs? I've looked at them. I've looked at them. Okay, so for those three
0:40:19 that have been on that. You can see that those stairs were built in 1995 and they
0:40:23 are in need of replacement. We have the last several, well, 20 years since they
0:40:29 have been put up, my staff has always done some minor repairs over there and also we
0:40:33 have contracted some work. You know, the wood is just shown at age now and we
0:40:37 had unfortunately we had a small accident about a year ago in January of
0:40:42 this year where a young boy, you know, fell through one of the railings that the
0:40:46 really just kind of popped off.
0:40:48 So it was unlikely at that time I had money
0:40:51 to start the engineering project on that.
0:40:53 So it was a good timing that this all happened
0:40:55 so we could replace those stairs.
0:40:58 So like as I mentioned, those stairs were built
0:41:00 about 20 years ago and I do have a few pictures
0:41:03 that I think that was part of my staff report
0:41:05 that I can show you also.
0:41:10 That, you know, like I said, these stairs
0:41:12 were on the west east, excuse me, the east side of Durkys Lake.
0:41:14 And when we acquired some additional property
0:41:17 around Durkeys, this kind of helped complete our loop
0:41:21 around the lake.
0:41:22 Originally, we didn't own some of the property
0:41:24 right on the border of the east side,
0:41:26 and we traded with some property, the developer of,
0:41:28 hit like the states, we traded some property with them,
0:41:30 so we could kind of do a whole loop around the lake.
0:41:34 But to do that loop around that,
0:41:37 we had to build these stairs here.
0:41:38 So we contracted those, like I said, those stairs back out
0:41:41 in 1995 to get built.
0:41:46 And if I remember right, there's seven sets of stairs.
0:41:48 This is one of the larger sets that we have right now
0:41:51 to help go up there.
0:41:54 And this set of stairs is probably our one,
0:41:56 our worst condition soon after,
0:41:59 really the next day after the accident,
0:42:01 you can see some of these railings have kind of fell off
0:42:03 that we've put up this kind of this orange construction
0:42:07 fence up there so we wouldn't have that problem anymore.
0:42:11 The city hired McLaren to the design of the replacement
0:42:15 stairs and kind of manage the bidding process.
0:42:18 You know, at that time we estimated about $200,000 for this.
0:42:23 And also, besides replacing it up the existing set of stairs we have now, we kind of identified
0:42:29 some couple of other areas that we thought stairs would be a nice addition to it to make
0:42:34 a little bit easier to get around the lake.
0:42:37 So we have, like I said, we have a core engineer to kind of do the designs and do some alternate
0:42:41 bids on two sets of stairs, two extra sets of stairs, and where's the three extra sets
0:42:48 of stairs?
0:42:49 I think three extra sets of stairs and kind of a ramp area.
0:42:54 We get my glasses out now.
0:42:56 I can't remember everything now.
0:43:02 We advertise in a paper like what we normally do and also McLeur Engineering contacted two
0:43:06 local contractors to hopefully they would submit bids.
0:43:10 The bids were due the first part of December on December 4th, and at that time we only had
0:43:14 two contractors that submit the bids on time.
0:43:17 The current scenario, we reviewed the bids and determined that Morgan Construction Out
0:43:21 of Idaho Falls has submitted the low satisfactory bid in the amount of $229,533.
0:43:29 But that bid included all the alternates that we had there.
0:43:36 But this past summer, I had a kind of, I mixed a whole group together.
0:43:41 Every year we have a group of rock climbers, and the first part of October has a rock climber
0:43:45 competition.
0:43:46 And what they have done is they have done always some little projects for me to kind of help
0:43:51 work on our trails and work on the climbing areas while they're doing their competition.
0:43:55 Also I had a Boy Scout looking for an Eagle Scout project.
0:43:58 Also the rock climbers contacted this Access Fund group that they travel around the nation
0:44:04 and help entities with their trails.
0:44:07 So we brought them into, so we kind of combined all three
0:44:09 of them, and back last October, they did a project
0:44:13 where they worked on some erosion areas.
0:44:15 Because one set of the stairs that we're going to add
0:44:18 a new one, we have a lot of erosion problems.
0:44:20 If you've been around that trail lately,
0:44:22 you know, used to be 20 years ago, I call them goat trails.
0:44:25 That's all they were, just a little dirt trail.
0:44:27 But how much use we are getting around the lake now
0:44:29 that these trails are some of them, we get a lot of erosion
0:44:33 because also we're just getting the dirt passed.
0:44:35 And of course, when we have the heavy rains like we did in August,
0:44:38 the water just starts making these gullies.
0:44:40 So what I did is working with these groups,
0:44:43 they kind of did erosion controls in these areas.
0:44:46 And the idea was hopefully if these erosion controls will work,
0:44:50 I don't have to put a stairs there, two different areas.
0:44:54 And I really want to give these erosion controls a couple of years
0:44:57 to see if they really will do the job like they are intended to build.
0:45:01 And if they do, they're saving the cities over $35,000 in stairs.
0:45:08 So I'm hoping that comes through.
0:45:10 So this map here, I don't think I included this in the staff report.
0:45:18 So, okay, this is of course Turkey's Lake, you know,
0:45:26 the parking lot, you kind of walk along the pay path here.
0:45:30 Set up stairs number one, this is a new set of stairs.
0:45:33 Just if you know, you've been back here, this is kind
0:45:35 of a tough area, you got to climb down.
0:45:37 You almost have to kind of use your hands a little bit, so we want to put a small set
0:45:40 of stairs there to help with the process.
0:45:43 We are replacing set of stairs two, three, four, five.
0:45:47 Then we have a ramp in this area here where you kind of have to walk down a steep rock
0:45:55 incline and then go back up incline.
0:45:58 So we're looking at putting a ramp in there so just easier access for people on there.
0:46:04 and these two set of stairs.
0:46:06 And this is one of the new set of stairs we're putting at,
0:46:08 because this is the area.
0:46:10 This is where that one residence is right there,
0:46:12 if you're walking around the trail.
0:46:13 This set of stairs will be really easier
0:46:15 to get down to the next level.
0:46:17 And these two areas, I talked about the erosion control
0:46:21 that we had these groups work on.
0:46:22 So this is set of stairs that we're not recommending to build.
0:46:25 And this is the set of stairs that we're not recommending
0:46:29 to build.
0:46:30 There is a set of stairs right now,
0:46:32 but we're looking at doing addition to it.
0:46:33 But I think with these erosion control units that we've installed, we can maybe prevent installing those stairs later on.
0:46:41 So, kind of in conclusion, we have $200,000 in this year's budget to replace these stairs or add new ones.
0:46:49 Staff is recommending to award the base bid of $144,318.
0:46:56 That is just replacing of the existing stairs we have now.
0:47:00 And to add the bids for stairs number one,
0:47:06 and stair number nine is right here.
0:47:07 It's stair number one here, and do this ramp number six.
0:47:11 Those extra two sets of stairs and ramp is $49,535.
0:47:17 So a total bid of $193 and $893,853.
0:47:25 There you go.
0:47:25 Couldn't spit it out right.
0:47:28 So I do have Mike Trapper with McCurr Engineering.
0:47:31 If you have any questions for Mike,
0:47:33 he's available to answer those questions.
0:47:34 So I'll stand ready for questions now.
0:47:38 You know, I have a question real quick, Dennis.
0:47:40 Before we put the stairs in, what was the tr-
0:47:43 I mean, were there-
0:47:44 There wasn't really, if I kind of remember
0:47:47 the property that we traded, this right around here
0:47:51 was still private property.
0:47:53 So, you know, we didn't have this trail
0:47:55 on the south side of the lake wasn't in there
0:47:57 until 1995, 96.
0:48:00 So there wasn't really kind of a loop around here.
0:48:06 I believe on the north side, this is a rock climbing area
0:48:09 that people have been using for years and years.
0:48:11 So I believe people did hike around this way,
0:48:15 but unless they cross-profit property,
0:48:17 they weren't allowed to go further around here.
0:48:19 So it wasn't until we traded property
0:48:21 until the early 90s that this trail really
0:48:25 was taking advantage of when people started using it.
0:48:27 Did they use it before just selling or?
0:48:30 I might have, you know, I mean, as a kid growing up myself,
0:48:33 you know, I never went on the north side of the lake.
0:48:36 Never did, as a kid.
0:48:37 It was always on the south side.
0:48:39 There you go.
0:48:40 Chris talking to you.
0:48:41 Mike, I wonder if you could tell us the middle arrangement
0:48:44 that we're replacing the wood with what the anticipated life
0:48:48 of that metal will be and what require maintenance
0:48:51 such as priming or painting.
0:48:53 We are going to epoxy coat the all the stairs and all the steel will be epoxy coated paint
0:49:04 and then we're using the trucks decking as that plastic deposit.
0:49:10 You do have a set of, there's two of the sets of stairs in the back that are existing right
0:49:14 now.
0:49:15 They're steel with that same sort of decking and they're, I think we're pushing 20 years
0:49:20 and they don't even show any wear on them.
0:49:23 I mean, they're in excellent conditions,
0:49:25 so I would expect unless we get vandalism
0:49:28 or some other issue going on,
0:49:29 they're good for at least 40 plus years.
0:49:32 And the only thing that's gonna wear out on
0:49:35 is that just the decking and that truck's decking,
0:49:39 and that can be replaced at any time
0:49:41 if there's an issue with them.
0:49:42 And that's a polymer or a plastic?
0:49:44 It's a plastic kind of a composite.
0:49:46 Yeah, yeah.
0:49:47 You get it this out nowadays.
0:49:49 UV impervious?
0:49:50 Yes, okay.
0:49:53 Sean Berger.
0:49:54 Are you ready for a motion?
0:49:55 I think we are, sir.
0:49:56 I would move that we award the base bid
0:50:03 and alternate bids of stairs one, nine, and six
0:50:08 in the amount of $193,853 to Morgan construction
0:50:15 as presented.
0:50:17 Second.
0:50:18 Motion on four by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
0:50:23 Sean Berger mentioned as well Dennis made this presentation to the Parks and Recreation Commission last week and the Commission
0:50:29 was impressed with the project and support above it, so
0:50:36 Dennis I can't imagine that we'd ever get to a place where we can in this area make it any kind of ADA accessible
0:50:43 Just to rugged just to rugged. It's I can't tell you probably that the vertical rise from probably where the stairs number one going up to the top
0:50:56 Okay.
0:50:57 Well, nothing's impossible with money.
0:51:00 All right.
0:51:01 Anything further on the motion council?
0:51:03 Lee Eilabro call vote, please.
0:51:11 Reg Lanting.
0:51:12 Don Hall.
0:51:13 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:51:14 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:51:15 Jim Munn.
0:51:16 Sean Berger.
0:51:17 Yes.
0:51:18 Motion passes.
0:51:19 Seven to zero.
0:51:21 Thank you, Dennis.
0:51:22 And thank you, Mike, for coming.
0:51:24 Thank you very much.
0:51:25 Good to see you again, sir.
0:51:27 Next item is consideration of a request to adopt an ordinance
0:51:30 for the vacation of property located in the undeveloped portion
0:51:33 of the JCo subdivision, including platted public right of ways
0:51:38 and easements on property located at 556 Champlain Way,
0:51:42 also known as 3300 East Road for the Twin Falls Urban Renewal
0:51:46 Agency.
0:51:48 We have Mitch Humboldt making the presentation.
0:51:50 Welcome, Mitch.
0:51:52 Hi, thanks.
0:51:54 On October 20th, we had a hearing about this vacation
0:51:56 for the JCO subdivision.
0:51:58 This is necessary to make the Cliff Bar project come
0:52:03 to fruition and that hearing the council approved it.
0:52:06 There was a condition on there basically that we need to turn
0:52:09 around at the end of what will be the new end of Eldridge Road
0:52:13 and we needed that to be dedicated before we vacated the
0:52:16 right away and that happened this afternoon actually
0:52:19 at the Urban Renewal Board meeting.
0:52:20 So that's been taken care of and now we can proceed
0:52:23 with the vacation ordinance.
0:52:24 So anyway, that ordinance has been prepared
0:52:27 in accordance with the approval from October.
0:52:30 And we're recommending that the ordinance
0:52:32 be adopted tonight to make this all final.
0:52:35 It is an ordinance of one adopted tonight
0:52:37 when we do need to go to third and final
0:52:38 and you know, waive the rules and all that kind of stuff.
0:52:42 So if you have any questions, I'll try to answer them for you.
0:52:44 There's also representatives out here
0:52:46 from engineering folks who can help us too.
0:52:48 Right.
0:52:49 Yeah, what's the ordinance number in case we choose?
0:52:51 383.
0:52:52 3083. Very good. Chris talking. I would move to place
0:52:56 ordinance 3083 on 3rd and final by Todd lonely under suspension
0:53:00 of the rules. So you motion on floor by Chris talking and
0:53:04 seconded by Greg Lanti. Kristia. Anything further on that
0:53:12 motion council? Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca milsoica. Yes. Suzanne
0:53:19 Hawkins. Yes. Jim. Yes. Sean Burger. Yes. Chris talking
0:53:23 Yes.
0:53:24 Greg Lanting.
0:53:25 Yes.
0:53:26 Motion passes.
0:53:27 Seven to zero.
0:53:28 Leila.
0:53:29 You could read that.
0:53:30 In ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating the
0:53:34 rail property described below and providing for best unit title to the property so vacated.
0:53:41 Stand for a motion council.
0:53:44 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:53:45 I move approval of ordinance 3083 as read.
0:53:49 Okay, motion on four by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting.
0:53:56 Anything further on the motion council?
0:53:59 Leanna Rokal vote please.
0:54:01 Rebecca Milsoica?
0:54:02 Yes.
0:54:03 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:54:04 Yes.
0:54:04 Jim I?
0:54:05 Yes.
0:54:06 Sean Berger?
0:54:07 Yes.
0:54:07 Chris Tawkins?
0:54:08 Yes.
0:54:09 Greg Lanting?
0:54:09 Yes.
0:54:10 Don Hall?
0:54:11 Yes.
0:54:12 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:54:14 Next item on the agenda, Mitch again, will be consideration to request to adopt an ordinance
0:54:21 for annexation of property located at the southwest corner of Pole Line Road East and
0:54:27 Eastland Drive North for North East Investment LLC. Mitch Humble.
0:54:34 Mayor, if you don't mind, I might want to talk about this one and the next item together.
0:54:39 They're directly related.
0:54:41 Okay.
0:54:42 But then we'll address them separately.
0:54:43 We'll have a motion separately.
0:54:44 Very good.
0:54:45 So last week at the Council meeting, I had a public hearing regarding a rezone of the
0:54:51 properties in Poland. That rezone was to a planning and development. So this item, this
0:54:59 first one, is the ordinance that actually will make that rezone effective. And that ordinance
0:55:05 is prepared. It's in front of you again tonight for your adoption. And again, it is an ordinance
0:55:11 so we'll need to do the third and final and the waving thing if we want to go forward that
0:55:15 tonight. The next item is the PUD agreement that goes along with the PUD that was approved
0:55:20 last week and essentially that is the document that puts into place all the code type language
0:55:28 that will come along with the ordinance and that's the picture of the plan and the specific
0:55:35 development requirements that's going to apply to this piece of property and again that has
0:55:38 also been prepared in accordance with the approval for last week and the action on that would be
0:55:43 simply to authorize the mayor to sign that agreement and then we'll execute that with the property
0:55:49 So if you have questions again, folks here who represent those property owners and I can try to answer your questions as well.
0:55:56 We recommend approval of both.
0:55:58 Very good. So we're taking the first one first and it would be potentially 3084 ordinance.
0:56:05 Greg Lanning.
0:56:06 A move that we suspend the rules in place ordinance 3084 and third and final only by title only.
0:56:12 Third and final only.
0:56:15 Second.
0:56:16 Greg Lanning made the motion. Chris Tockdence seconded the motion. Chris
0:56:21 talking. Excuse me. I'm a little bit off. Anything further on that motion
0:56:28 council? Lee Island. Roll call vote please. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim
0:56:33 on. Yes. Sean Berger. Yes. Chris talking. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca
0:56:41 Yes. Motion passes 7-0 if you read the title.
0:56:45 An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, annexing certain real property below described.
0:56:52 Providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary area of impact in zoning districts map amendment.
0:56:59 Stand for motion council. Sean Berger. Move approval of ordinance 3084.
0:57:06 Second.
0:57:07 Motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins, proven ordinance 384.
0:57:13 Anything further on that motion council?
0:57:17 We have a roll call, please.
0:57:19 Jim Munn.
0:57:20 Yes.
0:57:21 Sean Berger.
0:57:22 Yes.
0:57:23 Chris Chalkington.
0:57:24 Yes.
0:57:25 Greg Lanthing.
0:57:26 Yes.
0:57:27 Don Hall.
0:57:28 Yes.
0:57:29 Rebecca Milsoica.
0:57:30 Yes.
0:57:31 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:57:32 Yes.
0:57:33 Motion passes.
0:57:34 Seven to zero.
0:57:35 has talked about is consideration request to approve the PUD agreement between the city
0:57:40 of Twin Falls and northeast investment LLC and authorize the mayor to sign the agreement.
0:57:45 Is that basically it?
0:57:47 Greg Ladd?
0:57:48 Move that we approve the PUD agreement between the city of Twin Falls and northeast investment
0:57:54 LLC and authorize the mayor to sign said agreement.
0:57:59 Second.
0:58:00 Motion on the floor by Greg Laddings.
0:58:01 Seconded by Sean Berriger.
0:58:03 Chris Stockington.
0:58:04 move to amend that motion to draw a reference to the use regulations. Specifically, I think
0:58:13 that's on page 7 of our ordinance that refers to special uses. It's use regulations, subtitle
0:58:21 B special uses, sub-point retail trade, sub-point B and a log uses, inclusive of gas stations.
0:58:33 I would like to move that the PUD in this location not allow gasoline slash fuel or electric
0:58:43 recharge stations.
0:58:45 I'll second.
0:58:48 Motion 4 by Chris Stockton, seconded by Rebecca Milsoyka to amend as stated, basically do not
0:58:55 allow.
0:58:56 Do not allow that special use condition and I'd be willing to defend it if anybody wanted
0:59:02 to have my rationale.
0:59:03 I have a question for Chris.
0:59:06 If we're going to do that at this point,
0:59:10 should we have advertised where we're going?
0:59:11 I mean, I just want to know the legal.
0:59:14 It doesn't require an advertisement.
0:59:17 OK.
0:59:18 The PUD agreement itself has not been advertised.
0:59:22 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:59:27 Thank you.
0:59:28 If I remember right when we talked to the neighbors,
0:59:30 everything that was in this agreement they had already
0:59:32 seen and was all K with them.
0:59:34 And I believe that the neighborhood and the developer
0:59:37 had carefully gone through this to make sure that it all met their desires and at this point
0:59:43 I'm not comfortable changing it on the developer without having him here to at least have input
0:59:48 on that personally.
0:59:50 Jim.
0:59:51 Thank you Mayor.
0:59:53 I would ask, I would like to hear Councilman talking to the argument this regard.
0:59:58 Very good.
0:59:59 Councilman talking.
1:00:00 I feel that this transcends the immediate use of the property.
1:00:06 There are great deal of traffic on Pauline in Eastland.
1:00:10 There's adjacent property across the canyon rim.
1:00:14 That's a point of a spirit, if you will, of a delicate piece of property that is to the
1:00:21 developers' comp them.
1:00:22 That's been redesigned quite well.
1:00:25 However, service stations, I think, have their place.
1:00:28 I don't think this is one of them.
1:00:30 They often are 24-hour operations, 24-hour operations,
1:00:34 24-7 as a matter of fact.
1:00:36 Employee large canopies for all weather protection,
1:00:40 which becomes some side of a site amusement.
1:00:44 They employ strong lightage in night hours.
1:00:48 They have intercom service that would interrupt
1:00:51 the somewhat residential neighborhood environment.
1:00:55 They have a lot of transient traffic
1:00:57 that can be brought in and out of that 24-7.
1:01:00 And as important as anything,
1:01:02 it would require bearing large tanks
1:01:04 and basically pure rock, which I think could destabilize
1:01:09 some of the surrounding homes that are closer to the canyon rim.
1:01:14 The fact that people may have looked at the overall conditions
1:01:19 until they could get down and see the applied use of some
1:01:22 of these, I don't think that everybody really
1:01:25 had gone into detail of those.
1:01:27 We have restricted gas stations and other PUDs,
1:01:30 and I think it would be a good complement
1:01:32 not to have an electric fuel recharge station
1:01:37 in this corner location.
1:01:39 Thank you, Chris.
1:01:40 Great landing.
1:01:41 A question for, this was Mitch as I can see Jonathan.
1:01:47 Mitch, the gas stations were allowed outright,
1:01:51 or by supposed to use for it.
1:01:55 The way they show up in the agreement as it is now,
1:01:58 it's by special use.
1:01:59 Thank you, Mayor.
1:02:05 I seconded the motion because I think that when you watch the presentation by the developer, you look at the overall plan of this development.
1:02:15 I would agree that a service station really isn't compatible.
1:02:19 We do want to reduce the traffic impacts coming in from Poline or in from Eastland.
1:02:28 So I think that makes sense to just remove gasoline
1:02:34 and service stations from Special East Permit.
1:02:37 Thank you, Rebecca.
1:02:40 I'm better.
1:02:43 I was just gonna note, I feel that with it being
1:02:46 a provision under special uses,
1:02:48 it would have to come forth with a hearing process
1:02:51 and have notification again.
1:02:54 So should that request come in the future,
1:02:58 feel there would be ample participation opportunity by the community and the possibility of placing
1:03:07 restrictions on hours of operation and design elements and those types of things. So I'm
1:03:14 comfortable leaving it as it is in the special instances.
1:03:17 I guess I'll weigh in. I'm kind of in the same boat that Sean just said. I think that
1:03:24 that it would have to come through with the SUP process
1:03:28 that there'd be ample time for a review of anything
1:03:32 that they would want to do with this.
1:03:36 And to restrict it at this point,
1:03:38 I just don't feel comfortable with it as well.
1:03:41 So anything further on this,
1:03:43 the amendment to restrict the gasoline
1:03:46 and or electric recharge stations
1:03:49 at this development council.
1:03:53 Leyla Rokalvo.
1:03:55 John Berger. No. Chris Talkington. Yes. Greg Lanting. No. Don Hall. No. Rebecca
1:04:05 Milsoyka. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. No. Jim on. No. Motion fails. Five to two. Moving on
1:04:15 to the main motion. Any further comments Council. Greg Lanning. Well I'm
1:04:23 And I probably could have talked about this during the amendment,
1:04:27 but I'm saving this Mr. Taylor's here,
1:04:29 and I'd like to thank him and his group for working so well
1:04:33 with the neighbors.
1:04:34 I mean, this is certainly a much different proposal
1:04:37 than first hit planning and zoning.
1:04:39 And to your credit, a lot more expensive proposal
1:04:43 than first hit planning and zoning.
1:04:45 I mean, there's a lot more considerations in here.
1:04:48 I went from apartments to high quality homes on the edge
1:04:51 and things along that line.
1:04:52 a lot of different changes that I think made it more acceptable to the neighbors and actually
1:05:00 welcomed by some of the neighbors without a doubt and maybe something I'm not sure exactly
1:05:04 where each one lives to know who's who was rooting for at that point but I would like
1:05:10 to thank Mr. Taylor for his past investment in our community and this particular investment
1:05:16 I will be voting yes.
1:05:19 Thank you.
1:05:20 Great.
1:05:21 Anything further council?
1:05:22 We'll call vote, please.
1:05:26 Chris Talkington.
1:05:27 No.
1:05:28 Greg Lanting.
1:05:29 Yes.
1:05:30 Don Hall.
1:05:31 Yes.
1:05:32 Rebecca Milzoyka.
1:05:33 Yes.
1:05:35 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:05:36 Yes.
1:05:37 Jim Mann.
1:05:38 Yes.
1:05:39 Schonberger.
1:05:40 Yes.
1:05:41 Motion passes 6-1.
1:05:44 Moving on to the next item on the agenda council.
1:05:47 Would be consideration of a request
1:05:49 to approve the city council schedule of regular meetings
1:05:54 and public hearings of 2015.
1:05:56 Travis, you're welcome, Travis.
1:05:58 Thank you.
1:06:09 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
1:06:10 what you have before you is a list of the published meetings
1:06:15 that would occur over the course of the next year.
1:06:21 Following a last year's recommendation of the council
1:06:25 to meet every available Monday or the following Tuesday
1:06:29 in which there's a holiday, we have followed that.
1:06:32 So you'll notice that there are occasionally
1:06:34 a Tuesday meeting, and that is why those are showing.
1:06:37 You'll also notice that we have specifically noted
1:06:41 in outline times in which we will not host public hearings.
1:06:45 And those times are to recognize that there may be
1:06:48 certain times of the year that the public business
1:06:50 still needs to be conducted, but it does not necessarily mean
1:06:54 that those items need to be public hearings
1:06:57 and brought forward, and what we did was we used
1:06:59 the major holidays to help drive that decision so that if there were individuals who were planning
1:07:06 on being away or being out of town, that the city staff was going to make sure that there
1:07:12 would not be any public hearings that were posted on those days.
1:07:15 We've also followed suit in the planning and zoning publishing schedule as well.
1:07:23 You'll notice that there are a series of meetings and what we're doing tonight is in accordance
1:07:30 with Title 67-23-4-3 subsection 1, which basically states that when we have regular meetings, we
1:07:40 can move forward and we can advertise this and adopt it, and that satisfies that portion
1:07:48 of the Idaho Open Meeting Law requirement.
1:07:50 But that would be happy to stand for any questions.
1:07:54 Travis, I just wanted to say that I appreciate that because we heard some concerns from some
1:07:59 citizens relative to having public hearings around those holidays that it might not be
1:08:06 convenient for folks or it might limit their ability to testify. And you were proactive and
1:08:14 as Mr. Munge said, you fixed it. So we appreciate government when it's flexible like that. So
1:08:21 thank you. Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
1:08:23 Thank you, Mayor. And I would reiterate that as well. I appreciate the responsiveness to the
1:08:29 public feedback, I think that that was some good feedback to make sure we don't
1:08:32 hear, you know, large or small public hearings around the time of major holidays.
1:08:38 I think that that's really a kind consideration for the public and I think
1:08:44 that will improve our participation rate as well. So if there are no further
1:08:49 questions, I'll move approval of the 2015 City Council meeting calendar. Second.
1:08:56 Motion on floor by Rebecca, so I guess seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the council meeting overview
1:09:04 Schedule as hosted
1:09:06 Greg landing. I'd like to be an amendment to the motion. I would like to go ahead and
1:09:12 eliminate the fifth Monday of
1:09:15 the months that have five Mondays and
1:09:19 Give a second. I'll speak to what?
1:09:21 We have a motion on floor council second have a motion on floor by Greg landing seconded
1:09:28 by Suzanne Hawkins Greg landing well the reason I will say this is that when we had this in
1:09:34 the past I think a many council members used it the same way I did if I knew there was not
1:09:38 going to be a meeting that's when I tried to schedule any vacations I was going to take
1:09:43 that I try traditionally if I want to be out of town I try to do a Tuesday to Sunday type
1:09:49 the situation but it doesn't always work out that way. So this manner I could go
1:09:53 ahead and schedule a vacation that would be over a Monday and I wouldn't be
1:09:56 worrying about missing a meeting. I would know it in advance and even when we had
1:10:01 the when we were not meeting on the fifth Monday in the past if there was
1:10:05 enough pressing business we wouldn't have to meet anyway. It was driven by more by
1:10:09 the need than it was just say well we're gonna have five meetings I'm we're gonna
1:10:14 meet every Monday no matter what so that's the reason for my motion. Very good.
1:10:18 Well, this is somewhat of a new tradition because I can tell you I spent most of my
1:10:23 council career in five meetings a month.
1:10:26 Somehow people were able to take their own personal convenience citizens to live up, I
1:10:31 think to what the citizens, a lot of them to do, and that's to be accountable for all
1:10:36 the scheduled Monday meetings that we can do business with.
1:10:41 And I'll take just the same, the opposite tack, Greg, as you and say, let's schedule it
1:10:46 we don't have business, let's cancel it.
1:10:50 So I will not be voting for favor of deleting the 5th Monday.
1:10:54 Don't think it serves the public interest.
1:10:57 Great, lightning.
1:10:58 Well, if we do have it scheduled and we decided to delete later,
1:11:02 it certainly doesn't give you any chance to plan ahead and try to not miss any
1:11:06 meetings because if you plan for it and be the 5th one and maybe it won't be there
1:11:11 and you don't know for sure, and I'm not sure how recent we're talking about.
1:11:16 We got on council in 2005, it was already in place, and then obviously been in place before
1:11:21 that which would have been during some of your tenure.
1:11:24 Nope.
1:11:25 It was all, guarantee it was there in 2005.
1:11:28 I think, honestly, Greg, I think, because we came on the same time, I think it was Lance
1:11:33 that brought it and it was probably our first year.
1:11:35 Good to be with you.
1:11:36 Yeah.
1:11:37 I think that's more accurate because I remember the discussion.
1:11:40 So, you young whippers now for the standard change.
1:11:46 Thank you, Chris.
1:11:47 I was going to ask you Travis, before the motion was made, I was going to ask you really the fifth Monday as far as scheduling, what was your perception?
1:11:58 Did we need those? I know we had some heavy times and lifetimes. Do you think that overall do you think that we were okay without scheduling the fifth Monday?
1:12:10 I'm putting you on the spot, I'm sorry, but I just want to get your perspective. You're the one that really looks at these things.
1:12:15 And so Mitch just gave me the perfect answer.
1:12:17 He said we'll work with it either way.
1:12:21 Way to go, DCM.
1:12:23 I think that there were times where
1:12:26 we were struggling to find things to place
1:12:29 on a meeting agenda.
1:12:31 There were times when we canceled a meeting
1:12:34 and that we brought you back.
1:12:36 And because we canceled a meeting,
1:12:38 we watched the thing grow of issues that emerged.
1:12:42 And so really, I think that Mitch's point is actually right.
1:12:47 What we tried to do is we tried to budget time
1:12:51 in every single one of the meetings.
1:12:54 And when we budget that time,
1:12:55 we try to keep a two hour time limit
1:12:57 within our ability as to have to control that.
1:13:00 We can continue that same philosophy
1:13:02 with four meetings a week or four meetings a month
1:13:06 or five meetings a month.
1:13:09 Very good, sir.
1:13:10 Rebecca Mel second.
1:13:12 Thank you, Mayor.
1:13:14 Well, I think I really don't like when we have really heavy agendas.
1:13:18 I think that they go on long and then maybe some items get short-changed in deliberation
1:13:24 and discussion.
1:13:25 So I think that having the opportunity of scheduling the fifth Monday and using that
1:13:31 to spread the work out would be a good idea.
1:13:34 And it is our job.
1:13:36 I mean, we work.
1:13:37 We come to a meeting once a week.
1:13:39 So I don't think it's too much to ask.
1:13:42 But I think it will give us an opportunity to even out our agenda is much better.
1:13:47 She's on Hawkins.
1:13:50 I really don't have a feeling one way or the other because we can add a meeting or
1:13:55 we can take a meeting off correct.
1:13:57 So I don't think I've missed a meeting this year.
1:14:01 I've been able to work my calendar to be here every Monday.
1:14:04 And I would have to say that I like having it scheduled, but
1:14:08 I can understand Greg's point of view because it is easier if you can plan a
1:14:12 vacation a little bit earlier and save the money on the travel expenses and get out of town
1:14:17 So I think I'm leaning more towards Greg's point of view just to make it easier for the council to schedule that because if we need
1:14:23 A meeting we can still have the meeting so I think I'll
1:14:26 You talked yourself into
1:14:30 Anything further on this motion council the animal call vote on the amendment
1:14:38 the amendment is to
1:14:40 I think there's three different months there, isn't it, Travis?
1:14:47 Four.
1:14:48 If the amendment as proposed goes forward, the meeting that would occur on this sheet on March 30th would not occur until April 6th.
1:15:03 So it's March 30th, June 29th, August 31st, and November 30th.
1:15:10 So for for Mondays. Yes, what you're up is that's eight percent of our work here
1:15:17 Very good anything further on the motion council the other roll call vote please on the amendment great glancing. Yes
1:15:24 Don Hall. Yes
1:15:26 I bet the mils like that. No Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
1:15:31 Jim on no
1:15:33 Shonberger. No
1:15:36 No
1:15:38 motion fails four to three
1:15:40 Now, Shonda, so I would like to make an amendment as well that the March 23rd 2015 meeting not have public hearings as that is the Monday of spring break.
1:15:55 One second.
1:15:56 So March 23rd.
1:16:02 That is potentially going way is spring break.
1:16:06 We would not have a public hearing on that date as well.
1:16:09 We have motion on floor by Sean Barrett or second by Rebecca Mills.
1:16:12 anything further on that motion makes sense to me good catch the other roll
1:16:19 call yes Rebecca mils like yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim and yes Sean
1:16:28 Burger yes Chris talking to yes yes yes motion passes seven to zero now on to
1:16:35 the main motion of the actual calendar as amended anything further on that
1:16:39 motion council. The aye the roll call vote please.
1:16:43 I'd like to know so I can yes. Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim on yes.
1:16:48 Sean Berger yes.
1:16:50 Chris talking to yes. Greg Lansing yes. Don Hall yes.
1:16:55 Motion passes seven to zero. Moving on to the next item on
1:17:00 the ends real quick yes. So as staff we try to budget these
1:17:03 items moving forward to a budget that time and one of the
1:17:07 Other things that we need to know is when we have quorums and when we do not have quorums,
1:17:12 so that as you move forward with planning those schedules out, if you could forward those to
1:17:17 us because we're going to budget time in every single meeting and if you do not have a quorum,
1:17:23 then those items will cause those longer drawn out meetings in the future.
1:17:28 So as you're planning with your family what those holiday occasions or those absences
1:17:34 maybe if you could forward those to us in advance, we'd appreciate that.
1:17:37 Travis, what's the best mechanism to Leila, to you, to be, and email us both.
1:17:44 We can put it on her calendar.
1:17:46 We take that to our executive team meetings, and then we discuss each agenda as we move
1:17:54 forward and we actually plan them out, and I think right now we're looking in the month
1:17:58 of February.
1:17:59 Very good.
1:18:00 to ask also if you wouldn't mind just see me so that I see what's coming up and
1:18:04 know what's going on aspires the quorums and things like that I'd appreciate it.
1:18:08 Thank you Travis. Now the next item on the agenda is request to adopt a resolution
1:18:14 declaring a sole source supplier for purchase of law enforcement electronic
1:18:18 control devices I believe this was an add-on late add-on but it's on the agenda.
1:18:23 Mr. Mayor. And we have Captain Matt Hicks. Welcome sir. Good evening. Happy holidays everybody.
1:18:28 excuse my voice, I'm recovering from the flu, I'm not contagious, but I'm doing the best I can here.
1:18:35 We'd ask you tonight to consider adopting a resolution to declare a sole source supplier for the purchase of electronic control devices for the police department, commonly referred to as TASERS.
1:18:46 The police department was approved in the current year budget to purchase 24 TASER devices, which were replaced 24 that we purchased in 2006.
1:18:54 And since the purchase price is in excess of the statutory limit, we would ask you to
1:19:00 consider adopting the sole source exception. We believe it qualifies for several reasons.
1:19:07 The TASER devices that we use, and again electronic control device, TASER, they're almost synonymous,
1:19:13 although TASER is exclusively the product of TASER International, which is the supplier we would request that we purchase these items from,
1:19:20 are really the only viable manufacturer for this product in the law enforcement industry.
1:19:25 The current department policy we've adopted is based solely on TASER products and their use.
1:19:31 Our instructors, which include Sergeant Luke Gowns, who's here to meet tonight if you have any questions,
1:19:36 have been solely trained in the use of TASER international products,
1:19:40 as well as all 72 of our officers in the department.
1:19:44 The software that we currently use at the police department to capture data
1:19:48 We have to use these and train with them as solely a taser international product
1:19:53 Luke has done some research try to find out if there's any other viable alternatives for this and
1:19:58 We found one company that has just in the last couple months produced a product that was mostly
1:20:05 Dedicated for the private sector. They're trying to market for the law enforcement industry
1:20:08 But we cannot find that any sales in the law enforcement industry and no real
1:20:14 Feedback as to the quality of the product
1:20:16 So we don't feel it's reasonable to try to place a bid out for products that are untested
1:20:21 in our industry.
1:20:23 And given the depth that we've gone to to explore this product, use it extensively over
1:20:28 the last several years, we feel it would qualify for the sole source exception and we'd ask
1:20:33 you to consider adopting the resolution.
1:20:36 Thank you, Captain.
1:20:37 Leah, what would their resolution number be?
1:20:39 1938.
1:20:40 1938.
1:20:41 Thank you.
1:20:42 Turn it over to council for questions, Chris Tockington.
1:20:45 Move adoption of a resolution 1938.
1:20:47 That was easy.
1:20:52 Chris Tockington made the motion to adopt resolution 1938,
1:20:56 seconded by Greg Lanting.
1:20:58 Rebecca Milsoyka.
1:21:00 Thank you, Mayor.
1:21:01 Thank you for your report, just a quick clarification.
1:21:03 So there's no other company that makes a product that
1:21:08 tasers people, I guess, I don't know if that's a brand name,
1:21:11 But when you when you tase people there's no other company that makes that type of a product
1:21:17 There is one other company and I'll let loose be just real briefly about the research that he
1:21:21 Yes, there is one other company. It's called phaser and they just started up this year
1:21:28 Like a captain hick said they have not been tested they have not been selling well for the law enforcement community
1:21:34 They are marketed more for the private sector also the new tasers that we are
1:21:39 We are planning on purchasing or going to replace the ones we carry now which are being
1:21:43 discontinued and the phaser company, the tasers are very similar to the ones we're carrying
1:21:47 now.
1:21:48 So we're actually moving to a better product that we're carrying now, it's an X2 version
1:21:52 of the taser which is a semi-automatic version and it also has a smart cartridge which is
1:21:58 better for us as far as downloading data and what it saves.
1:22:01 Okay, thank you.
1:22:03 Semi-automatic you can tell you's more than one person.
1:22:06 these we carry now we have to switch the cartridges out on the X2 has two
1:22:11 cartridges already in it so we can actually tase two people yes if we need
1:22:14 to and rather than switch the cartridge is out which we have to do
1:22:18 now
1:22:23 I think they volunteered to be your test subjects here well to hear in your
1:22:31 report tonight makes sense to me to go with this because obviously there's
1:22:35 There's competition out there, but that's untested.
1:22:38 And in this realm, we don't want to carry untested products without any history.
1:22:43 So I think it's reasonable as far as I'm concerned.
1:22:46 Anything further on the motion council?
1:22:49 The other roll call vote please.
1:22:50 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:22:51 Yes.
1:22:52 Jim Mun?
1:22:53 Yes.
1:22:54 Sean Berrigger?
1:22:55 Yes.
1:22:56 Chris Tawkin?
1:22:57 Yes.
1:22:58 Greg Lanci?
1:22:59 Yes.
1:23:00 Don Hall?
1:23:01 Yes.
1:23:02 Rebecca Milsica?
1:23:03 Yes.
1:23:04 Motion passes 7-0.
1:23:05 Thank you, gentlemen.
1:23:06 the public that would like to address the council this evening. See no one coming forward. Any
1:23:12 items from our city manager? Mr. Mayor members of the council in observance of the holidays coming
1:23:19 out the city will be closed on Christmas Eve. He'll be closed on Christmas day and also be
1:23:24 closed on New Year's Day. Our next regular scheduled meeting would have been on December 29th. That
1:23:31 meeting is being canceled for lack of items on the agenda. And our next meeting that we will meet is
1:23:36 on January 1st, 2005, January 5th, 2015, it has a five minute, right?
1:23:45 We'll be here one hour, so January 5th, 2015 is our next regular scheduled meeting.
1:23:52 Very good, great landing.
1:23:54 I'd like to report some information from today's URA board meeting and those are others that
1:24:00 were there if I get something wrong, please correct me.
1:24:05 They chose to go in with option A, which would be that they will do all of the replacement
1:24:11 in the alley, with going with the more expensive pipe that will allow them to put at least
1:24:17 in the same vicinity, both the sewer, the storm water and the water pipe.
1:24:22 This allows them to make it less of an impact for a couple different reasons on the merchants.
1:24:31 and all the most of the work will be being done in the alley,
1:24:34 which is less likely to disrupt the business.
1:24:37 And number two, it will cost the businesses less
1:24:40 because they will not have to switch their service
1:24:42 to the main street.
1:24:43 And so they went with this a little more expensive option,
1:24:47 but it certainly will help the downtown businesses
1:24:51 to weather the storm, should it still to speak.
1:24:55 Yeah, if you wanna put a little extra in there.
1:24:57 So thank you.
1:24:59 If I get anything wrong, let me know.
1:25:01 Okay, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:25:04 Just a quick note to council and staff.
1:25:07 My mom brought in a tray of Christmas goodies tonight
1:25:09 while we were meeting,
1:25:10 and I have plates over there on Lee Ila's desk,
1:25:12 and I'd really love it if everybody had come pick up
1:25:15 something before you call it a night.
1:25:16 Merry Christmas.
1:25:18 Thank you, Sam.
1:25:19 Suzanne, Rebecca Melsoiken.
1:25:21 Thank you, Mayor.
1:25:22 Just to follow up question to Greg,
1:25:23 does that fit in their budget, though,
1:25:26 the budget that they're anticipating?
1:25:28 I think it's a good choice.
1:25:29 I just I know they're working on a limited amount of funds.
1:25:33 And so do they anticipate having any budget issues?
1:25:37 The one change that we'll probably make
1:25:39 is that some of the outlying and Travis
1:25:40 might address this a little better.
1:25:42 Some of the outlying things, if you may have seen the map
1:25:45 where they had water lines and sewer lines
1:25:47 were actually out of downtown, but actually served downtown,
1:25:51 those may or may not be able to be completed under their plan.
1:25:57 if they essentially went to this other plant and Travis
1:26:00 and he spoke to them today and so he might want to.
1:26:03 Yeah, I think it's a little maybe expand on the logic
1:26:06 that they used to get to that spot was the original plant
1:26:10 did not contemplate changing out the water line.
1:26:12 And without changing out the water line,
1:26:17 they estimated that the life of the water line
1:26:20 optimally has a most between 10 to 15 years.
1:26:24 But they were concerned that when they started working
1:26:26 in that area that it actually might degrade and it might have a life span somewhere between
1:26:31 five to ten years.
1:26:33 And my recommendation to the committee was if you were going to go through and do the
1:26:36 project, do it right the first time, complete the water lines, complete the sewer lines,
1:26:42 complete all of those projects because the amount of disruption that could occur in the
1:26:45 downtown area is probably something that is probably only tolerable once.
1:26:51 Right now it's important also I think to note that we're using engineering estimates
1:26:55 and those engineering estimates tend to be a little bit more conservative at this point
1:27:00 in the game than what they are.
1:27:03 So what I've suggested to the agency is that they initially selected six projects and if
1:27:09 one of those projects is not able to be funded at this time, that we removed that one project
1:27:16 and that it would someday probably become the responsibility of the city when it is needed
1:27:20 to be constructed.
1:27:21 Because the choices you either do the downtown project or the other projects right the first
1:27:27 time, or you do a little bit of them and they ultimately become the city's responsibility
1:27:32 when the agency closes its district doors anyway.
1:27:35 So for example, on that waterline decision, the Urban Renewal Agency has about seven years
1:27:41 left.
1:27:42 And if the life expectancy of the waterline is ten years, that means in three years after
1:27:47 the agency closes, that will become the city's responsibility.
1:27:51 It would cause a secondary disruption.
1:27:54 I think it's, again, everything that moving forward
1:27:58 is engineering estimate, and I think
1:28:00 it's important to be patient with the agency
1:28:02 as they're allocating their resources towards that larger
1:28:05 downtown project and moving that forward.
1:28:08 They also refinanced their bond, which
1:28:12 gave them a savings on interest that they
1:28:15 will be able to apply to the project as well as gave them
1:28:18 Additional monies for to advance the construction project as opposed to waiting for the increment to rolling on an annual basis
1:28:27 As was currently
1:28:29 Contemplated thank you Travis. Thank you Greg. I have a couple things. I wanted to bring to attention of the council one is the radio
1:28:36 We traditionally go to the radio about once a week. We rotate that between five of us to
1:28:44 well to weren't going and I
1:28:47 I think we all know that top story is going through some changes right now.
1:28:54 With Kelly Class after a distinguished career in radio broadcasting has retired and so his
1:29:00 last show will be this month.
1:29:03 And I've also been told that Jill Scheme will not be returning to the radio as well in the
1:29:08 new year.
1:29:09 They are in the process of hiring a new host, what that's going to look like they don't
1:29:14 know yet.
1:29:15 They're in the formation of that.
1:29:16 So my recommendation, and I've been in contact with management at the radio to find out exactly
1:29:21 what the plan is.
1:29:22 My recommendation is we kind of go in a holding pattern for now, and maybe this is a time for
1:29:27 us to really review what our media strategy is, and it might be something that we go out
1:29:34 when we're invited with this new program, I don't know, or if we have something that we
1:29:38 really want to go out and talk to the folks.
1:29:41 But I think it might be a time for us to work with our PIO and develop maybe a little
1:29:47 more comprehensive media strategy for contacting and communicating with the public.
1:29:54 So anyway, I wanted to bring that to your attention and I will stay in contact with you
1:29:57 all to let you know what I find out what their new direction will be.
1:30:03 Any questions about any thoughts?
1:30:05 All right.
1:30:06 The last thing I wanted to say is Merry Christmas to everyone and Happy New Year and hopefully
1:30:12 this is a blessed time with your family.
Download
- Transcript (text) 72 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 98 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 136 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 22, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:30:23.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
86bed8da9311c7a7b4ab5cb3eb67369f2292743a02327f13a142874a576a59b0 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 3 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
2d8e50fb38a3a93c5ebad8f4e58086e8d6b7826549281d3447ba571ea2509918
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file