City Council meeting
Monday, December 15, 2014
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:11:55 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council Order.
0:11:58 It's 404.
0:12:02 We're a couple minutes late to our early meeting this evening.
0:12:06 First thing that we have on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:12:09 For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:12:15 And Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:12:26 what letter to you just as per all around.
0:12:30 Thank you all.
0:12:31 We do have a quorum of the city council.
0:12:33 This evening, six members are here.
0:12:36 Councilman Munn will be here a little bit later.
0:12:38 He had some conflicts.
0:12:39 Should be here around five, I believe,
0:12:41 to continue with the meeting this evening.
0:12:44 So the first item on the agenda,
0:12:46 that's why we're meeting here a little bit early,
0:12:48 is we get to meet with our legislative delegation,
0:12:52 and we're privileged to do so.
0:12:54 So at this time, I'm going to ask council members
0:12:56 go ahead and have a seat in the front and we'll move down to the down below.
0:13:24 So the first thing I want to do is apologize for the way in which we have, I know I don't,
0:13:29 I want to turn it over to the mayor.
0:13:33 We even rehearsed this, I don't know what's going on.
0:13:36 I just wanted to just take a moment and thank you all for being here this evening, our local
0:13:41 legislators.
0:13:43 Government really works when we can have contact with each other, look at each other in the
0:13:48 the eye and talk about issues.
0:13:49 And this is a perfect example of that.
0:13:51 We really appreciate you spending the time
0:13:54 with us this evening.
0:13:55 We have a series of presentations that we would like
0:13:58 to make and then we'd like to have kind of a,
0:14:00 really more of a conversation with you than anything.
0:14:02 So again, we really appreciate you being here this evening.
0:14:05 I do want to call out Nancy Duncan
0:14:08 from the Kimberly City Council.
0:14:09 She's over representing them this evening
0:14:11 and is going to be taking part of our conversation as well.
0:14:14 So welcome.
0:14:22 So let me try that again.
0:14:24 I apologize for the way the room is set up.
0:14:26 So originally last year, I thought
0:14:28 it worked out really, really well.
0:14:29 We had tables and everything wrapped around.
0:14:32 But tonight's calendar for the council
0:14:35 is incredibly packed.
0:14:36 And we have some emerging issues that came up just
0:14:39 as late as late Thursday afternoon.
0:14:42 And we're expecting quite a few people
0:14:44 to come to the meeting tonight.
0:14:45 So we didn't have the ability to tear it down
0:14:47 and set it back up for the meeting.
0:14:48 So I apologize.
0:14:50 And also, I want to thank you.
0:14:53 We recognize that this is a very, very busy time for you,
0:14:58 that you are probably meeting with a series of different groups
0:15:01 of people every single day.
0:15:02 And everybody wants to kind of go in and bend your ear
0:15:05 for a little while.
0:15:07 And we really appreciate the time that you're taking with us.
0:15:11 I've prepared a very quick presentation
0:15:13 just to kind of give you that snapshot state of the city,
0:15:17 where are we at, where are we going,
0:15:19 what have we done, what do some of these things look like,
0:15:23 so that you could take that back and share
0:15:26 some of those things.
0:15:27 And then from there, we also have some issues
0:15:31 that we'd like to kind of discuss and share with you.
0:15:34 And each of the members of the team
0:15:35 have very specific points that they're going to talk about.
0:15:38 If there's something that we don't talk about
0:15:40 and we don't discuss and yet you have questions,
0:15:43 please let us know.
0:15:44 And then this is completely interactive.
0:15:46 If I say something that doesn't make any sense,
0:15:48 please stop me and I'll be happy to try to clarify
0:15:52 or provide answer, or point to those who really are
0:15:56 the experts within their individual area of expertise
0:16:00 and help them.
0:16:04 So one of the things that we really want to share
0:16:07 and impress upon everybody that we talk to
0:16:10 is everything that we do is really driven
0:16:12 around our strategic plan and our strategic planning process.
0:16:16 You'll notice in this entire process
0:16:18 that there are four colored boxes,
0:16:20 organizational structure, partnerships, strategic action,
0:16:24 fiscal priorities, all wrapped around
0:16:27 to try to achieve a long-term vision of the city.
0:16:31 Two years ago, we went through a very engaged process
0:16:34 with our strategic plan, and we will continue
0:16:36 that process later this year as we go forward
0:16:39 with the strategic planning update.
0:16:41 I think it's important to recognize that that document
0:16:44 is something that is a living document
0:16:46 that we want to continue to modify and update
0:16:49 So it reflects the current operating conditions that we're at.
0:16:54 Underneath that, we have eight overarching priorities
0:16:58 that help create that vision.
0:17:00 It's a healthy community, a learning community,
0:17:03 a secure and accessible environmental communities,
0:17:06 prosperous, responsible.
0:17:08 And then one that we've added compared to years past
0:17:11 is more talking about our internal organization.
0:17:14 Each one of those are used to create the overall vision
0:17:18 that we've worked with our partners and our citizens
0:17:21 that helped realize for the City of Twin Falls
0:17:24 by the year 2030.
0:17:26 And you'll notice at the bottom,
0:17:27 we have each of the individual city partners
0:17:30 and departments that are part of that,
0:17:32 where they create a series of goals,
0:17:34 and a series of objectives that create those budgetary
0:17:36 allocations, and from those allocations,
0:17:39 we want to do an assessment.
0:17:40 And that's where we use everything
0:17:42 from our performance measurement system
0:17:46 that we're really starting to construct inside the city
0:17:49 to citizen surveys to really taking a look
0:17:52 at workplace efficiency and effectiveness.
0:17:57 When we go forward, we really start asking questions
0:17:59 about what are we doing, why are we doing it,
0:18:02 and how are we going to get there.
0:18:03 And this is kind of the model that we use
0:18:05 to drive our budgeting decision-making process.
0:18:08 And we're pretty proud of this.
0:18:10 This is something, one of those practices
0:18:12 that we created in-house, where we understand
0:18:15 the fiscal year outcomes.
0:18:17 And we really try to make sure that the right people
0:18:19 in the right places are able to make the right decisions,
0:18:23 that we're making sure that we're honoring
0:18:25 one of the most important things that we do
0:18:27 in local government, and that is protect the public health
0:18:29 and public safety.
0:18:30 Then also we want to make sure that we're maintaining
0:18:32 our infrastructure and being able to advance our community.
0:18:35 So all of those processes really help move forward
0:18:39 and help us realize our strategic plan.
0:18:43 And it really does start at the ground level.
0:18:45 One of the things that we're very proud of is our long-term planning committee.
0:18:49 It's a collection of employees at all levels of our organization that meet and they go forward
0:18:54 to describe all of the things that we need to do to help realize our strategic plan.
0:18:59 And so from there we create the priorities, we fund the priority ones, and we move the organization
0:19:07 hopefully one step forward to where we hope that it lands by the year 2030.
0:19:11 And what's important with all strategic plans is making sure that it's
0:19:20 fundable. You have to be able to pay for those things that you want to do as you
0:19:26 move forward. And so this is a snapshot. The City of Twin Falls is 2014 fiscal
0:19:32 year budget by comparison to the 2015 year fiscal budget that we just moved
0:19:38 into. You'll notice that the total taxable value of the city increased by
0:19:43 about $28 million. Total revenues into the system increased from $52.1 million to $56.4 million.
0:19:53 And you'll notice those tax-supported funds versus those non-tax-supported funds.
0:19:58 And very similar to the legislature, part of our government is funded strictly or in part by the use of property tax dollars.
0:20:05 Another piece of that is funded strictly by user fees, whether that's water, sewer, or sanitation.
0:20:12 You'll notice our total tax collections are up about $357,000 this year.
0:20:18 And one of the things that we're pretty proud of is that the tax rate decreased $0.19 per $1,000 of taxable value this year inside our community.
0:20:28 And the city of Twin Falls was able to grow its foregone balance.
0:20:32 Our foregone balance now sits at $1,874,900, which is one of the largest in the Magic
0:20:39 Valleys, if not one of the largest in the state.
0:20:43 And what does that mean in real terms?
0:20:46 That means that our citizens right now realize about a 10.62% savings in taxes in which they
0:20:55 otherwise would have paid had we taken 3% every single year and not elected to have a foregone
0:21:01 balance. And I think it really speaks to the conservative approach that we've had
0:21:05 when it comes to budgeting because we recognize that there are goals and there
0:21:09 are priorities, but at the same time it must be done in a context of reality. And
0:21:13 so what we do is we really describe the process, we describe the outcomes, and
0:21:19 then we work within our means to achieve that. So then you have to put it into
0:21:27 context. Well, what does that mean to the average person who lives inside the
0:21:33 City of Twin Falls. And what we've done is we take that median house, that median value
0:21:39 of that house, and that has helped that just to drive from us by the, by the census. So
0:21:43 we take the census number, so the average residential structure inside the City of Twin Falls is,
0:21:49 has a value of $144,300. And after we apply the homeowner's exemption and the property
0:21:56 tax rate for the appropriate year, you'll notice that that's what they pay in property
0:22:01 taxes inside the City of Twin Falls. And then we tried to say what does that
0:22:05 average person consume in terms of water? What is their demand in terms of waste
0:22:10 water? And what is their annual sanitation bill? And what we've reflected is the
0:22:15 cost to live in Twin Falls decreased by $2.56 in 2015 than what it was under the
0:22:23 city services that were provided.
0:22:26 One of the things that we were able to capture,
0:22:30 so that you had it, was this is the most recent
0:22:35 enough to be able to look for all
0:22:37 and the most effective attacks.
0:22:40 So that's just a sheet that is prepared
0:22:43 by the assessor's office, and maybe that's
0:22:45 some good information, and what it does
0:22:46 is it reflects what the values of the property taxes are.
0:22:50 It's two-sided, so you can take a look at the 2013,
0:22:54 as well as the 2014 tax years.
0:22:58 make those comparisons. One of the things that we look at is what is the cost of
0:23:03 doing business and that's something that you guys look at as well. We use what's
0:23:07 called the municipal cost index and that municipal cost index is based in
0:23:11 clearly an inflationary factor that we use inside the city of Twin Falls so
0:23:15 it is developed by the American cities and counties and that inflationary factor
0:23:20 the cost of doing business if we were to provide the exact same level of service
0:23:23 in the city of Twin Falls was 2.26%.
0:23:30 So that's part of the equation.
0:23:33 Yes, sir.
0:23:35 Question.
0:23:36 I guess maybe it's about 90% of the $6.6.6.
0:23:43 So what we do, the 500, it only includes the city.
0:23:46 That's a very good question.
0:23:47 So what we do is we illustrate only those parts and pieces
0:23:52 that we have direct control over.
0:23:54 We provided the other information so that you could see what
0:23:57 the total impact to the tax rate was based upon the bonds and based upon the individual
0:24:03 decisions that were made by each of the individual tax agencies over the course of the last
0:24:07 year.
0:24:16 So one of the things that we continue to also monitor inside the City of Twin Falls is the
0:24:20 unemployment.
0:24:22 And in October of 2014, the unemployment rate was 3.1 percent inside the City of Twin Falls
0:24:29 and our micro-paulting statistical area had it at 3.0.
0:24:35 The micro-paulting area includes both
0:24:37 Rome and Twin Falls counties.
0:24:40 And you can see how that is improved year over year
0:24:43 and from the prior month.
0:24:46 So in October of 2013, 5.4% was our unemployment rate.
0:24:53 Today it's 3.1 inside the city of Twin Falls.
0:24:55 And we track the city of Twin Falls
0:24:57 because we want to understand, are our citizens going to be able to pay their water bills and
0:25:01 property taxes and those types of things as well as the micro-pulgent area because we want
0:25:07 to make sure we recognize that we're a regional economy and we want to take a look at that overall
0:25:12 health. It's important to recognize that most economists consider full employment to be about
0:25:19 5 percent. And so what that represents here is that we are beyond what would be classified
0:25:26 as a full employment statistic and one of the things that we've talked a lot about as a region
0:25:31 is how do we continue to market our community not only to prospective businesses but to prospective
0:25:39 residents to help fill some of those technical voids that may occur for the creation of jobs.
0:25:45 And then when we reflected back in the height of the Great Recession, our unemployment rate,
0:25:49 the highest unemployment rate reached in our area was 8.9 percent. That was in February
0:25:54 So in that period of time, you can see how we've grown, how we've continued to improve.
0:26:01 And really, that is through the work of quality partnerships and the areas of job creation,
0:26:06 job expansion throughout the region.
0:26:12 Building activity is another thing that we track.
0:26:15 And when you look at the total increase in tax-supported spending, one of the key drivers that we have here
0:26:22 is the more robust building permit process that we had in comparison to where it was in
0:26:29 years past. Other key drivers are state shared revenues. Those are continuing to go up because
0:26:36 our total taxable value continues to increase, which is part of that formula as well as being
0:26:41 a growing economy. So we're seeing a little bit more in terms of state shared revenues
0:26:46 and franchise fees and investment income is beginning to return a little bit, not significantly.
0:26:52 But investment income is certainly better than the eight basis points that we were achieving
0:27:01 just a few years ago.
0:27:05 This next slide which shows building activity, illustrates one fiscal year compared to the
0:27:11 next.
0:27:12 And what's important about this is a series of different things.
0:27:15 The first is the total value of the permits for the fiscal year grew significantly.
0:27:24 They grew by 32 percent or almost a little over $20 million.
0:27:30 That translates into the expansion of our tax base in subsequent years.
0:27:35 That is how we continue to grow that tax base and as we continue to grow those tax bases,
0:27:40 as those building permits are transformed from a permit to an occupancy role and they fall
0:27:45 on to that, we're able to grow and expand that tax base. And as you continue to grow
0:27:51 and expand that tax base, it causes the opportunity for additional revenue and also causes the
0:27:56 opportunity the way the item structure is built to cause a lowering of the tax rate.
0:28:02 The other side of the coin is the revenues collected. And you can see that revenues
0:28:06 collected in that point of time were 29.9%. There was not a fee adjustment from year over
0:28:13 year associated with that. So those are just reflecting up the qualities of
0:28:19 instructors moving forward. So on the sheet if you take a look at, so this is
0:28:36 just going to show the values we can get back. We have a report that kind of
0:28:41 illustrates that, this is just going to show the value of the permits, it's not
0:28:44 going to reflect the revenues that were collected. We can, we have a report, we
0:28:50 We can probably get that before the end of the meeting, can we look for that real quick.
0:28:57 So that's going to be the estimated value of the finished product.
0:29:07 That's not going to be the value of the permits coming into the system.
0:29:12 So this is, yes, we're seeing more, I think more commercial than, or a continuing increase
0:29:41 in commercial in our region and we expect that to continue, especially as you look out
0:29:47 at the RIM project and the other commercial activities that we're seeing.
0:29:54 I think that when you take a look at a purely competitive place inside the city of Twin Falls,
0:29:59 we really like where we stand and I think that we like that because our tax base, the
0:30:06 level of services that we're able to provide, the fact that we're a regional center, I think,
0:30:10 all adds value to that decision and I think that it's just going to continue to pay dividends
0:30:16 not only for us but also for our focus.
0:30:30 The great deal on the drilling from there before a lot of other things.
0:30:49 We did, yes, so what is important is in fact it's in all of our areas when we saw a decline
0:30:56 in the level of work or in the amount of revenue that was being collected in 2011 I believe
0:31:03 We had to make some pretty tough decisions
0:31:05 into that fiscal year in which we had 11 very,
0:31:10 well, we had 11 positions and some were filled,
0:31:12 some were not, and we had to have some tough conversations.
0:31:15 Over the course of a period of time,
0:31:18 we've been able to restore some of those positions
0:31:21 or change how we operate as an organization
0:31:24 and looking at process, I think, as important
0:31:26 as we continue to move forward.
0:31:27 We are not as, I mean, a million dollars
0:31:30 is considerable revenue coming into the system on an annual basis,
0:31:35 but it is proportionately not as significant
0:31:38 as what you may see in other communities
0:31:41 that will get building for the revenues
0:31:43 as they use that to drive decisions forward,
0:31:46 especially in those communities to the north of us.
0:31:59 We believe that this growth chart is still
0:32:02 within the realm of reality.
0:32:05 Obviously, it's projecting out for quite a few years, but in order to realize these targets
0:32:11 and these numbers, it requires a 2% annualized growth rate.
0:32:15 That's what this represents, is a 2% annualized growth rate moving forward each and every single
0:32:21 year.
0:32:22 2% annualized growth is considered to be about moderate-based growth.
0:32:29 It's not sizable, it's not significant.
0:32:34 And I think it's what's important is we will continue to grow as the economists and the
0:32:41 individuals that shared at the Taxpayers Conference.
0:32:45 Part of that concern was we need to make sure that we're also bringing in all demographic
0:32:51 as opposed to single demographic so that we are having an active and robust workforce.
0:33:26 And we might take them.
0:33:27 If they're employable and educated, we might take their children.
0:33:31 And with that, I think it's important to recognize that with that comes some sizable things.
0:33:46 Perfect segue is the continued investment in our infrastructure to make sure that we have
0:33:51 the ability to meet those growing demands.
0:33:55 So one of the things that I think is really important and one of the statistics is we look
0:34:02 back, the city has been incredibly proactive when it comes to advancing capital infrastructure
0:34:09 moving forward. We've allocated $150 million in capital projects since 2007. Just think
0:34:20 that $150 million, our total budget inside the city of Twin Falls this year is $56 million.
0:34:26 Okay, that's everything. That's all operations. That is everything. Now part of that is our bonds,
0:34:32 long-term debt instruments that we need to be able to advance and move forward. But what this
0:34:36 And this illustrates our part of those larger chunks, those larger pieces.
0:34:40 Nearly $36 million in our water infrastructure, $55.5 million in our waste water infrastructure,
0:34:49 $18.12 million in street infrastructure, and $9.97 in our airport.
0:34:58 This doesn't include the monies that the urban renewal agency has done on top of that.
0:35:06 doesn't include our partnerships with ITD when it comes to the full project of
0:35:11 Washington Street. And the balance of that is replacing those fire trucks and
0:35:16 those other apparatus as we need to make sure that we're delivering those public
0:35:19 cities. So when we look about how we're moving the organization forward, that's
0:35:25 pretty impressive. And then when you think that we drop the tax rate on top
0:35:29 of it, it gets to be one of those things that you kind of begin to smile. And as
0:35:34 representative harken spoke about we become to start being that envy of the
0:35:40 state of saying what is going on in the Magic Valley because it's not just
0:35:43 windfalls it's kimberly it's Jerome it's goodings recent announcement with the
0:35:48 Glandy facility you know it's all of these larger regional partnerships that
0:35:52 really do help cause growth the city of Twin Falls now I I've made no bones I
0:35:59 tried to be fairly competitive when it comes to economic development but we
0:36:03 We also recognize that the stronger all of those communities are around us, the stronger
0:36:08 the City of Twin Falls becomes because we are the regional center for a geographic area
0:36:14 that contains 250,000 people.
0:36:18 And if we can continue to support their efforts for growth and expansion and they get stronger
0:36:23 like fruit black going over in Rupert, that is only a benefit to us as a community as we
0:36:30 move forward.
0:36:31 Specifically some of our successes, we have these big three.
0:36:36 But it's impossible for us to take the emblems of the nearly 30 businesses that have chosen to expand and
0:36:45 locate in our downtown area and those other businesses that are locating out in the area.
0:36:50 But to put it in perspective, these three entities will represent at the completion of their projects
0:36:59 their projects $125 million in capital investment.
0:37:04 600.
0:37:06 Excuse me, $625 million in capital investment, over 1,350 direct jobs and thousands of indirect
0:37:14 jobs behind them.
0:37:17 And on top of it, they're quality corporate citizens that are going to cause us to stretch.
0:37:24 They're going to cause us to continue to create those best practices and to continue to sustain
0:37:30 type of community that Twin Falls is because that's why they came here. They didn't come
0:37:35 here because they're expecting change. They came here because they expect us to keep those
0:37:40 values intact and to continue to keep what makes Twin Falls truly great. So I go back
0:37:48 to this because again this is part of that driving factor and driving force and one of
0:37:53 the things that we had to take a look at is that green box, our organizational structure.
0:37:59 So you may have saw that, but this is one of the things that we have done.
0:38:04 And I have a couple of folks that I'd like to officially introduce to you in the event
0:38:08 that you may or may not know that.
0:38:10 If Brian and Mitch can come up.
0:38:12 They have no idea they were doing this, but it's good for them, right?
0:38:17 If they knew they were to be introduced, they might not have shown it up this evening.
0:38:23 No.
0:38:24 They're familiar faces.
0:38:26 They've been with our organization for a long time.
0:38:30 and they've done good works.
0:38:32 And we've taken them and we've asked them to do something
0:38:35 different and to do something more.
0:38:37 What we've done is we've organized our organization
0:38:42 based around the strategic plan that we have.
0:38:47 Brian is going to, and is migrating, both of them
0:38:52 are migrating very slowly into these new roles
0:38:55 with an effective, official effective date of January 1.
0:38:59 But Brian's going to be the deputy city manager over public safety.
0:39:04 And that's going to oversee police, fire, dispatch, and code enforcement.
0:39:12 That is one single focus area, having providing the security.
0:39:18 The green box, all those green boxes that are going to be under
0:39:22 bitches jurisdiction as community services and development.
0:39:26 That includes everything from parks and recreation, planning and zoning,
0:39:29 building, public works, the airport, and engineering.
0:39:34 And those meet three of our strategic planning objectives.
0:39:38 We also have other parts and key members here.
0:39:43 Glory Race is going to continue to serve as the city's
0:39:47 chief financial officer.
0:39:48 Susan Harris continues to do the great jobs that she has
0:39:52 done and the areas of human resources, and as well as
0:39:55 Jackie and Engineering Chief Ron Clark
0:39:58 and Fire Belinda in Economic Development,
0:40:01 a couple of new faces, Andy,
0:40:03 and we'll talk to him in a few minutes
0:40:04 about public transportation.
0:40:07 This is really to try to build an organization structure
0:40:10 that allows us to continue to grow,
0:40:13 create efficiencies, review our process, and to be nimble.
0:40:19 We as an organization need to be as nimble as we can
0:40:22 so that we can continue to capitalize on opportunities
0:40:26 I think that everyone would agree that the place that we work is not slowing down and it's
0:40:32 not getting any easier, but for us to be able to capitalize, we have to make this move, and
0:40:37 this is what this move represents.
0:40:40 There is no additional staff associated with this, we will move two positions to accommodate
0:40:45 those two, and it's also from a budgetary perspective, it's with the addition of one of
0:40:53 that we put into the budget.
0:40:58 There'll be subsequent positions that
0:41:01 will be moving and if you point
0:41:04 up on this chief of police positions,
0:41:06 or we're actively looking for a chief of police position,
0:41:09 because one of the things that Brian had to do with,
0:41:12 he had to join the civilian acts.
0:41:16 Give me a couple of minutes for you to share with us.
0:41:19 No, I'm not.
0:41:20 I'm here.
0:41:24 You know, one of the things in regards to public safety,
0:41:29 that I find interesting, and even though I'm really new
0:41:33 to this role, is the idea of partnerships and collaboration
0:41:37 that opportunities for partnership and collaboration
0:41:40 that exist within the city, that we really haven't had,
0:41:45 well, it's not that we haven't had the time,
0:41:47 it's that we haven't taken the time to look at,
0:41:49 the efficiencies that we can find.
0:41:50 I met with Sean Stanley, our code enforcement person today.
0:41:55 I was amazed at the work that he's doing,
0:41:58 how it relates directly back into law enforcement
0:42:01 into the fire service.
0:42:02 So I'm excited about those possibilities.
0:42:04 And I think there's really some synergy
0:42:07 that could be created between all those groups.
0:42:13 Any questions?
0:42:17 Any questions?
0:42:21 I think it's an exciting time to be in a polling city.
0:42:31 I had no idea.
0:42:32 So I was concerned with all of that.
0:42:35 Totally unprepared.
0:42:40 But we have some good things coming.
0:42:41 But in addition to the structure, we have some philosophy changes in management structure style kind of things.
0:42:47 And it's just a great time to be here in a glad new part of it.
0:42:51 And to, you know, the opportunity of the collaboration I'm trying to talk about,
0:42:57 and my crew there are the green stuff at the bottom of the chart.
0:43:02 We have a lot of opportunities for the collaboration as well.
0:43:05 I think one of the things I'm going to try to do to be to post folks, get them all over, play well, like homework, and please, that's a great example.
0:43:21 We're not thinking about maintaining our infrastructure as we're designing our infrastructure, and that's going to be a problem for us, but we haven't done that yet.
0:43:33 We've always kind of tried to stay on top of that thing,
0:43:35 but I think we're going to do more of that as we go.
0:43:41 So the opportunity to work with more.
0:43:45 It's bringing more good people to the center.
0:43:58 Hiring from the Dan, or obviously, a lot of good people
0:44:03 in the police department, so you can become the chief
0:44:05 with the same little niches department.
0:44:09 They're moving off the people that have filled it out
0:44:12 within the city.
0:44:14 So Mitch's position was the role that Mitch previously
0:44:18 served in was eliminated.
0:44:19 It's an interesting conversation, all right?
0:44:30 And then what we've done is we are looking on a search
0:44:35 for the Chief role.
0:44:38 We've appointed Brian Creer to serve as an interim
0:44:41 because he does not want to be at this time in his career
0:44:46 to be the chief long term.
0:44:49 And we are out doing a national search.
0:44:53 And we will more than likely have some internal applicants to be able to look at and to fulfill
0:44:58 that role.
0:44:59 And what I will say is that they certainly have home-filled advantage.
0:45:03 I think it's important that we really look and make sure that the absolute best person is
0:45:10 selected for that role and will continue to do that look and at any point in time when
0:45:16 we feel that that right person has emerged at any point in that process.
0:45:21 I won't be afraid to approach the council and say,
0:45:25 I think this person is ready for that one.
0:45:36 About that many months ago, we replaced our building official.
0:45:40 And we did a nationwide search for that position.
0:45:43 We had very strong outcomes.
0:45:48 We found the best one was right here.
0:45:54 So, going through that process of strength,
0:46:01 this is a point of fact, that you have to go through the motion.
0:46:08 and we competed in came out on top.
0:46:14 And I think that we'll find some folks
0:46:16 that really do that well on the turtle.
0:46:18 And I think sometimes we do
0:46:20 help fight at that special council.
0:46:35 I think one thing I would try to do
0:46:37 is take a moment of how we measure success through time.
0:46:43 Yeah, so I think that, you know, it's a really good question.
0:46:46 How do you measure that success?
0:46:47 That this model is the right model.
0:46:50 And I think that you do that by looking
0:46:52 at the collaborations that are able to be created.
0:46:55 So one of the things that we recognize is that the strategic plan is not going to be
0:47:00 able to advance unless we're able to create better strategic partnerships and those partnerships
0:47:07 are not only internal but they're also external.
0:47:10 We also have other measurements that we can use.
0:47:13 As we continue to build our performance measurement system, we can take a look at our efficiencies
0:47:17 to see what those look like.
0:47:18 As we continue to do citizen surveys, we continue to see if we are making strides in progress
0:47:24 in terms of our level of service and our quality of service, in those areas that can
0:47:29 be back and attributed back to the model.
0:47:34 And it may require some additional tweaks as we continue to move the organization forward.
0:47:40 What I will say is that the model that we were using really was driven by the hierarchy.
0:47:46 It has lots of linear lines, lots of approaches with a single person sitting, and this is who,
0:47:53 If you read it, it didn't look like you were inspiring and causing and creating collaboration.
0:48:00 One of the measures will be obviously how is our organization working.
0:48:05 We are committed to drive decision-making downward, and when we say that, we mean that we want
0:48:11 employees to be able to make the right decisions in the areas where the information is.
0:48:16 And so by having those processes in place, we believe that our employees are going to be
0:48:21 a higher level of service to our citizens, and that is going to be reflected in
0:48:26 citizen surveys, performance, and everything else associated with us trying to
0:48:31 advance the city.
0:48:32 Yeah.
0:48:38 Yeah, there was a time when surveys were set out,
0:48:53 and I'll try to pensive them,
0:48:55 and I'll try to pensive them,
0:48:56 but at least we're, you know,
0:48:57 the water department went out,
0:48:58 and it was just a thousand to do something.
0:49:00 Right, building a business.
0:49:05 Are we doing anything?
0:49:06 Hey, some, yes.
0:49:18 Whenever we do an occupancy,
0:49:20 we're going to send a survey
0:49:22 in the mail to the, to us,
0:49:24 and feed that kind of permitting inspection process.
0:49:29 That's why we can't do it.
0:49:30 It's not really means that.
0:49:33 It's not every residential one, but it's not every residential one, but it's a sample
0:49:40 of residential permits.
0:49:41 And we get a lot of those back.
0:49:50 One of the things that we've struggled with is obviously in law enforcement, right?
0:50:03 Those contacts can be negative.
0:50:06 can be negative, but if you step back and look at the broader context of what we do in public
0:50:12 safety, I think there's real value. We've talked about using a form of survey. From our standpoint,
0:50:20 we want all of our fill of context to be problem solvers. We don't hire just report takers.
0:50:26 We want individuals that solve problems. A lot of times those are neighborhood problems.
0:50:31 So we think there's real value in measuring that contact.
0:50:34 Now, for granted, a lot of those contacts are negative.
0:50:37 But there's also big thumbs and neighborhood members
0:50:42 that are associated with those contacts.
0:50:43 And we think there would be value in looking at that.
0:50:56 So these are just some of the things that we look at doing
0:50:58 is it's really continuing on the same philosophies
0:51:01 by implementing the strategic plans,
0:51:03 making sure that we're physically conservative.
0:51:05 We want to make sure that we're continuing to invest
0:51:07 in our employees.
0:51:09 Really, that is where the lifeblood of public services
0:51:13 delivered.
0:51:14 Fire trucks still can't respond on their own.
0:51:16 Police cars don't go on their own.
0:51:19 And so it's really important for us to make sure that we're
0:51:21 continuing to able to attract.
0:51:23 We're able to retain.
0:51:24 We're able to provide the right types of training to all
0:51:26 of our folks to make sure that they are providing the highest
0:51:29 level of service in our organization.
0:51:32 We want to continue to invest in our infrastructure,
0:51:34 and that includes our facilities.
0:51:36 of that $150 million that we illustrated,
0:51:40 very, very little of that one into our structures,
0:51:42 and we have a citizen finance committee
0:51:45 that has been wrestling,
0:51:46 and we will probably wrestle even a little bit more tonight
0:51:49 about where the right options for us
0:51:51 to continue to move forward as an organization in that area.
0:51:55 And most importantly, we owe it to all the citizens
0:51:58 that we serve to continue to find
0:51:59 those more efficient, more effective outcomes.
0:52:03 Jack and I are gonna now do the next little piece,
0:52:06 But I'm going to start, because one of the areas that as we
0:52:09 continue, this is something that we want to share.
0:52:12 We recognize that there is.
0:53:29 So one of the things that we want to also talk about is that
0:53:33 area and transportation funding.
0:53:36 And as we know, it's something that you're going to continue
0:53:39 to be talking about at the legislative level.
0:53:42 We want you to recognize the important role that you play
0:53:47 in local government and our infrastructure.
0:53:50 So we've been waiting a quick step since 2010.
0:54:00 So you'll notice, if you go to the far right,
0:54:03 you'll notice what this year, in 2010,
0:54:06 on the right, it's 4 to 10 years from the beginning,
0:54:11 2004 to 2014.
0:54:15 The total amount that we had spent,
0:54:19 in actual expenditures in the budget and moving forward,
0:54:23 was right around $2,285,000.
0:54:30 And if you go up to the next amount,
0:54:33 you'll recognize that we received $1,340,000
0:54:40 in highway user fee, which came from the state.
0:54:45 And that represented 67.7% of our street funding
0:54:50 in our budget.
0:54:51 And then if you advance that to 2014,
0:54:56 you see that we received an additional $120,000
0:55:00 in that 10-year window of time.
0:55:03 And rather than being nearly 2-thirds of the city's total
0:55:07 street fund budget, it dropped to a little bit more
0:55:13 than a quarter.
0:55:16 And as we continue to look for solutions
0:55:19 for statewide infrastructure, I think
0:55:23 It's important to say that we're in that same place
0:55:27 that you are as well.
0:55:29 We are supplying more property tax dollars this year
0:55:35 and have for the last several years just to continue
0:55:38 to make sure that we're able to move forward
0:55:41 with road and road construction.
0:55:44 So I'm gonna turn it over to Jackie
0:55:46 to talk about what this means in,
0:55:50 what does this mean in real life?
0:55:51 Because there's another piece of the equation that Jackie is able to talk about.
0:55:59 For those of you that do not know, Jackie Fields is the city's engineer, and she is...
0:56:06 So, for those of you that don't know me, I started, I worked at ITB before, I worked here.
0:56:24 And so in 2004, we were bidding projects with Plant Max at 25 bucks a ton.
0:56:31 No one's seen 25 bucks a ton in years.
0:56:34 So part of our reality and what happened was transportation had to do with oil and inflation and paying people to do the work and those type of things.
0:56:48 But our reality is that the cost changed dramatically.
0:56:53 The other piece of our reality is that the city is attempted to spend money to proactively take care of the roads and we I think we are
0:57:03 confirmed in our
0:57:07 Achievement of making an eight-year seal cycle of sorts on the roadway, which is awesome
0:57:12 That's the cheapest way to take care of the roads
0:57:17 We are challenged and struggling to balance the roads that are absolutely failing
0:57:23 with the roads that need overlays.
0:57:26 To put an overlay on a road that's failing is
0:57:29 kind of like putting lipstick on a pig.
0:57:32 It's well-aware.
0:57:33 It's still what it is, and it doesn't last very long.
0:57:36 So there's a certain amount of waste
0:57:39 associated with overlaying roads that have already been
0:57:42 and reconstruction is tremendously.
0:57:45 And Travis shows you the stretch
0:57:49 like that plays out for us as the challenge
0:57:52 challenge between all of the businesses.
0:57:58 So the Council and the Council before it now
0:58:02 has been very committed to augmenting
0:58:06 our transformation dollars to try to stay ahead of the day
0:58:11 as our people.
0:58:15 Whether they live here or not.
0:58:17 What?
0:58:23 When the conversations occur, I know they're tough.
0:58:26 And I know that portions are all of you
0:58:28 to take a beating on taxes and how to do that now.
0:58:33 Our problem exists with or without additional funding.
0:58:39 And the longer we wait, the more you
0:58:42 see the degradation curves.
0:58:44 I'm sure most of you have seen how your pigment takes
0:58:48 a dive over time.
0:58:49 And if you get too far off the curve,
0:58:51 we're back to the whole lipstick thing again.
0:58:53 And that ultimately exacerbates what's already
0:58:57 a pretty tough issue for all.
0:59:00 So it's, I obviously, you know, I obviously would advocate for a larger improvement,
0:59:17 but I think that we are happy to have anything that was just in a spot where we can,
0:59:23 it'll be a happy day if I can retire reporting to the council that we've achieved an overlay program
0:59:30 that pulls the life of the pavement into what I could actually have for a while
0:59:34 They weren't able to say we have all of our payments in better condition.
0:59:40 That's our goal.
0:59:41 We're trying to get rid of our poor payments and get into our worst payments.
1:00:04 I was not able to go to the legislative session because I was attending and absolutely awesome.
1:00:11 But I did read the notes and there was apparently a presentation on why it's written.
1:00:19 a worry and a concern that we will be able to retain enough water to continue a
1:00:27 lot of stress up there. So there is a summary on that, okay, so the discussion
1:00:45 had to do with having a consumptive use of junior and priority water rights,
1:00:56 that's the vulnerable to a container are some cities
1:01:03 that fall into that category.
1:01:05 And so there are some questions out there
1:01:07 for how to retain your water rate.
1:01:10 And I want to urge you to keep it all, keep it all.
1:01:16 And keep it all for not only the people who
1:01:18 have to drink the water, but people who
1:01:19 need water to conduct their business.
1:01:22 So that'll include this.
1:01:26 It sounds like this could be administrative guidance
1:01:33 by statute the rules.
1:01:34 So if it comes up in the statute component,
1:01:37 instead of the rule component, we are hugely concerned
1:01:41 about how we've done a try to do a really good job
1:01:43 about securing water rights for the future.
1:01:47 Hopefully, for the grandkids and the great grandkids,
1:01:50 then it would be nice to be able to keep those
1:01:52 not in the curtailment decisions that we only now
1:01:58 have a way of having effective people later
1:02:01 working in the fact that the foresight of our predecessors.
1:02:06 And they did a good job.
1:02:07 There's no doubt that it would become more of a discussion
1:02:11 on how the municipality could keep hold of their water aid,
1:02:16 and frankly, if the long-hauls die,
1:02:20 people employ an associated facade in our parks
1:02:30 and even our cities, but drinking water for now.
1:02:44 From what I could gather in this presentation,
1:02:46 there wasn't, there was just a presentation
1:02:49 instead of actual recommendation.
1:02:52 I haven't heard any chatter about action,
1:02:55 where that would go,
1:02:56 whether it comes through a room that didn't work,
1:02:59 starts at that stage.
1:03:04 Probably be able to build exactly where that would look.
1:03:11 You know, it was at the water use of smoke groups.
1:03:15 This was the AIC legislative meeting
1:03:18 and there were some topics in there.
1:03:20 These were part of the handouts.
1:03:21 Now, I don't know what happened in real life
1:03:23 and people made the presentation.
1:03:30 And that was this visible.
1:03:33 It was...
1:03:34 Okay.
1:03:35 I know.
1:03:38 Well, you know what, I apologize to you if you weren't there for assuming you are an issue.
1:03:43 Well, it doesn't matter where they are or not.
1:03:46 It is what happens.
1:03:49 And we will.
1:03:50 And I appreciate the question.
1:03:51 You can hand this one.
1:03:52 Okay.
1:03:54 We'll share.
1:03:55 I'll grab that piece out and make sure everyone has a...
1:03:58 And then the last topic for me was...
1:04:03 I think it's a public works for Tamar.
1:04:16 Well, and I know there's so much activity going on
1:04:19 that maybe gave those water calls.
1:04:22 And I had a farmer on the North Side,
1:04:24 all the other great, who's taxed at least 2000,
1:04:28 and the issue is all of those people
1:04:32 that have been here are getting on top of the North Side
1:04:35 who are maybe getting to those water rights
1:04:39 and people.
1:04:41 That's right.
1:04:42 So everything they can and then we know that this room
1:04:46 and pretty close were all in there.
1:04:49 Absolutely, so there's, you'll see in that,
1:04:52 when I get in the handout,
1:04:53 we'll see if there is some discussion on rank and potential
1:04:56 impacts and that call as they are used to our business.
1:05:00 We've been, you know, city of twin has been trying
1:05:03 to not be in a position where we have trouble
1:05:10 with curtailment, but you know, this really does apply
1:05:13 Well, the rules that form about how we hold water are important to all of us and how that applies.
1:05:34 Yeah, where we came involved in this process is that they expanded it literally.
1:05:43 The bubble was on both sides of the river.
1:05:49 It was expanded and they got much harder to think.
1:06:04 And our we're still in the same spot, our fundamental care is perhaps philosophical for us, which is an awesome place to be in, but we don't care about how it's invented.
1:06:15 We spent a day on this last Thursday, called the Kellogg.
1:06:21 We are and we are more recognized from the city.
1:06:30 But I recognize that.
1:06:45 So it's generally what I was trying to present is that we actually care about how rules are formed because rules end up affecting all of us.
1:06:56 And even if we're in good shape now, someday there will be another city engineer.
1:07:04 And several generations down the line, if you have a good set of rules, they apply for a long time.
1:07:09 And I want to look, you know, with our forecasting lenses on to imagine our impacts and be prepared for them responsibly.
1:07:19 I think the other piece is when we've been talking about wanting to be a good regional partner.
1:07:26 And if our regional economy is strong, that means that the other ones need to be strong as well.
1:07:33 So if those on the north side have a significant water call, where there might be a sizable
1:07:41 professionally operated dairy out there, that milk finds its way to the Chobani facility
1:07:47 and the Glenby facilities in Twin Falls.
1:07:51 And that's 800 jobs at Chobani alone that if for some reason milk can't be supplied
1:07:57 and the yogurt can't be produced, the impact is sizable.
1:08:01 So just because there may be a city that's, you know, struggling to determine what does
1:08:07 that look like, the impacts are very real here and every economy is interwoven in the
1:08:14 Magic Valley.
1:08:15 So we're obviously not only concerned for us, like Jackie said, but then also from a larger
1:08:21 and more macro level, we want to make sure that all of our partners also have the benefit
1:08:25 of things moving forward.
1:08:28 The next thing, the next person we want to introduce to you is Mandy Thompson.
1:08:35 Mandy is technically our grant administrator and unofficially does everything else.
1:08:45 And one of the things that has kind of found its way into Mandy's lap and processes is
1:08:51 really public transportation.
1:08:53 started with a grant and that is right now in Mandy's lap and then that will
1:08:59 transition into bitches as they work collaboratively on that project so right
1:09:05 now I'll introduce to you Mandy Thompson. Good evening I'll be brief just a few
1:09:13 words with you about public transportation this is a topic that I think is
1:09:18 relatively new to discuss in the community of Twin Falls. I started with the
1:09:24 city a year ago, and it was just, again, a topic of discussion that people were mentioning,
1:09:31 but it wasn't necessarily something that we thought was on the minds of our citizens.
1:09:37 However, through the process of going through our strategic plan and engaging our community,
1:09:44 we truly found out that public transportation is in need within Twin Falls.
1:09:50 And along with that is this looming deadline, or maybe deadline is not the right word, but
1:09:59 level of population that Twin Falls is getting very near.
1:10:04 As soon as the City of Twin Falls reaches 50,000, we will be designated as a small urban area.
1:10:10 And once we reach that designation through the next census in 2020, we will then be asked
1:10:16 to form what's called a Metropolitan Planning Organization.
1:10:19 And once we've done that, we will then begin or will be tasked with providing public transportation
1:10:25 as a city service.
1:10:27 So while that potentially is anywhere between 8 and 10 years from now, we've decided that
1:10:33 it's something that we need to look at and we need to research and understand what that
1:10:38 will look like in the City of Twin Falls, how we as a city will provide that transportation
1:10:43 and what the needs are of our community, not only now but going forward.
1:10:46 So, as Travis mentioned, I applied for and we received a grant last spring for a transit
1:10:53 development plan, a study essentially looking at what the needs of Twin Falls are right
1:10:57 now and what we can do moving forward to begin preparing for the designation of an urban
1:11:03 area and that eventual organization of a metropolitan planning organization.
1:11:08 So that's something that we will be just starting coming up in April and hopefully we'll have
1:11:13 that done in about six months, and then what we envision is that will then give us some
1:11:21 additional tasks to look at as we move forward.
1:11:24 And then one thing that we've learned in addition to, and if we've gone through this process,
1:11:30 is that there's a lot more to pillow transportation than just a fixed wrap bus system.
1:11:35 We were present at a workshop along with Kimberly in November looking at mobility in general.
1:11:43 How your citizens
1:11:46 Get from point A to point B within your city and clearly right now
1:11:50 Predominantly everyone drives the car, but there's so many other options and so many other ways that
1:11:54 S as a city can make our you know, make this community a lot more accessible through bike routes and trails and walking
1:12:03 Eventually maybe a fixed route bus system and then also
1:12:06 So different things that we can do to encourage that
1:12:10 through traffic calming and just different techniques.
1:12:14 And so there's a lot of opportunity right now
1:12:16 for the city to be on the forefront
1:12:20 of public transportation and mobility.
1:12:22 And again, working kind of in this new structure
1:12:24 that we're looking at and working across
1:12:26 the entire organization and involving not just
1:12:29 potentially the community development folks
1:12:32 in public transportation, but police and fire.
1:12:35 and public works and roads and all of the infrastructure that's required.
1:12:41 When Melinda's doing her downtown redevelopment program and going through and updating all
1:12:48 that infrastructure in downtown, we need to be able to plan for public transportation
1:12:53 so that we're not having to go back several years down the road and remove some of that
1:12:58 work because we didn't plan for bus stops and some of those other things.
1:13:02 So it truly will be a collaborative effort.
1:13:03 So, it's something that is definitely here to stay.
1:13:06 And as we move forward, we look forward to working with all of you,
1:13:10 because as we move into that metropolitan planning organization status,
1:13:14 we will look to the state through ITD for a lot of our funding.
1:13:18 And so, we'll certainly be hopeful that you all can help us in that endeavor.
1:13:24 So, thank you.
1:13:25 So, one of the challenges, and especially for our friends over in Kimberly,
1:13:35 is that when you start looking at MPO status,
1:13:39 it is highly likely that they're going to get drug along with us.
1:13:43 And when you think about the considerable resources
1:13:48 that the City of Twin Falls has, just by our sheer size,
1:13:52 and then you take and you impose all of those same requirements
1:13:55 onto a community just because of their proximity,
1:14:00 really talks about why we need to be working collaboratively now today because
1:14:06 that day is coming. In fact, when you look, we were a bit surprised that we
1:14:13 didn't fall into that initial MPO status. We're not complaining because with that
1:14:20 there are other sizable things that come forward and one of those is when you
1:14:26 To reach that 50,000 threshold, new NPDS storm water phase two standards kick into effect
1:14:34 and that's something that you guys have heard about in the past.
1:14:37 In fact, there are cases that were litigated before the Idaho Supreme Court that state
1:14:44 that a fee based upon the current Idaho structure cannot be created.
1:14:50 In fact, a fee is considered unconstitutional because you can't describe the particular
1:14:56 that is attached to that fee, and cities are required now to use property tax dollars to
1:15:01 cover storm water requirements.
1:15:04 And the EPA does not care how you pay for it so long as you have a system in place to pay
1:15:12 for that.
1:15:13 In the past, there has been talk about an assessment and whether or not an assessment would be
1:15:18 an appropriate vehicle underneath the Idaho Code as opposed to using property tax relief.
1:15:24 And should that issue come up, we would ask that you, again, consider to take a look
1:15:29 at that.
1:15:30 Property taxes, when it comes to local government, is capped at 3%.
1:15:35 And that 3% is often used to, if it is taken, it is often used to cover the cost of a growing
1:15:42 community.
1:15:43 Twin Falls has been very, very fortunate, but we estimate that storm water will be a
1:15:49 billion plus.
1:15:53 So when Jackie gives you the oh yeah, when you say a million, you'd probably save to
1:15:57 go up to $2 million.
1:15:59 Dollar annual price tag to be able to move that forward.
1:16:03 And so we would look for some help and assistance.
1:16:07 50,000 for us might be a few years away.
1:16:11 But again, one of the things that you will see is we are not waiting until we hit those
1:16:15 targets and those thresholds.
1:16:17 We want to have all the proper planning and the processes in place so that it is a smooth
1:16:23 transition into the next reality. So for Representative Harkin, he had to ask the
1:16:28 question. We had committed to get an answer to him and what we're going to do is
1:16:32 we're going to compare fiscal year 2013 to fiscal year 2014 in comparison to
1:16:39 commercial versus residential. In 2013 we collected $820,048 in total
1:16:49 building permit revenues, 35 of that was derived from commercial.
1:16:55 Last year, as in as we illustrated in fiscal year 2014, we collected $1,616,609 and the
1:17:04 split between commercial and residential was about $50.50.
1:17:11 That shows we got really pretty good team back there.
1:17:16 Yeah.
1:17:19 It pulls the area.
1:17:24 It pulls the area of influence.
1:17:26 In fact, we were working with Sarah Michaels,
1:17:31 who's some of you may know Sarah and have met Sarah.
1:17:36 We're actually going to be starting work on the front end
1:17:38 of that process to hopefully try to create our reality.
1:17:42 And we're collaboratively through that process
1:17:45 as opposed to it having just been sent for us.
1:17:47 But it will not just be the city of Flint Falls.
1:17:49 So for example, Moscow and Pullman
1:17:53 our MPO status and designation.
1:17:58 Lewiston and Clarkston, our MPO status.
1:18:02 And so I believe Chubbock has been brought into Pocatello's MPO.
1:18:08 And so really by area and sphere of influence.
1:18:17 Our understanding is it's not us, but we want to work.
1:18:23 We want to work with ITD to help through that process.
1:18:27 We'll be working with ITD to understand that process.
1:18:43 I've met with the gentleman who, he just, IT is going, as I'm sure you all know,
1:18:50 undergoing some very large restructuring.
1:18:53 So that transportation performance has changed significantly.
1:19:00 The gentleman that he is essentially managing the MPOs for the state,
1:19:06 we are going to be working with him to better understand how the MPO is formed
1:19:12 and how we can bring all of the potential players to the table
1:19:16 and understand what all the requirements will be so that when we do have that designation,
1:19:22 everyone will be, you know, have an understanding how to go forward.
1:19:25 Once the Census is certified, which this last Census was certified in January of 2013,
1:19:31 so it was good two years after the actual Census, once the Census is certified, we will
1:19:39 have a year to create the MPO.
1:19:41 And there are a lot of federal and state resources that we can utilize to do that going forward.
1:19:50 So that's partly, again, why we are really wanting to be on the front end of this so that
1:19:54 We have a better understanding and it's not something that we're reacting to because I have spoken at length with several people throughout Idaho and Montana about how they prepared for public transportation in a small community, such as Twin Falls, and most of the time it was very reactionary, and they were doing it because they were told they had to.
1:20:12 So we're hoping by planning for it, we can be a little more prepared.
1:20:32 I think so.
1:20:33 I think it definitely could be, but again, unfortunately.
1:20:41 One of the things that we need to make sure that we're doing is actively collaborating
1:20:44 with all of our regional partners so that in the event that they are, they're part of
1:20:49 that on that front end process.
1:20:51 The other side is if they're not, there is still connectivity into our community and
1:20:57 there's opportunity for us to all grow through those partnerships and synergies.
1:21:15 I'm going to turn it over to Melinda real quickly and Melinda's going to talk about urban renewal
1:22:37 briefly and other economic development.
1:22:40 Thanks Travis.
1:22:42 Good evening and thanks for coming again this year.
1:22:45 This is really helpful for us to be able to talk to you go like this sort of informally.
1:22:51 So a lot of what I'm working on and with, well as you know I'm the city's economic development
1:22:57 director but I'm also, because I'm that role, I'm also have the role of executive director
1:23:02 for the Urban Renewal Agency so I have both of those.
1:23:06 Which is not an uncommon model for many urban renewal agencies around the state of Idaho.
1:23:13 But a lot of what I'm working on right now, especially with Urban Renewal, is our downtown
1:23:18 redevelopment, especially our main avenue redesign project.
1:23:23 So the agency hired an organization, OTAC, back in August, and they have a number of sub-contractors,
1:23:30 including JUB engineers, kiddleson, which is from Boise.
1:23:34 What's really nice about OTAC is they have a couple of folks, both named Mandy, on their
1:23:39 team, who actually have Twin Falls roots.
1:23:43 Mandy Roberts, who's the principal.
1:23:45 parents grew up here in Twin Falls. I don't know her maiden name, so I don't know what
1:23:51 her parents name is unfortunately. No, no, this is not the other Mandy. So Mandy Roberts
1:23:59 actually was, she grew up in Boise, went to the University of Idaho, but her parents
1:24:02 are from here, so she comes here a lot because she's really familiar with Twin, and so they
1:24:06 were pretty excited to get started. The other Mandy is Mandy Warbeck, who's now Mandy Flat,
1:24:11 is also part of the team.
1:24:14 So it's really nice to have those local connections
1:24:18 helping us with our redevelopment process,
1:24:20 but still understand what's important here in Twin Falls.
1:24:23 So design is underway.
1:24:26 There's been a lot of surveying done regarding infrastructure
1:24:30 and parking, traffic, that kinds of things,
1:24:33 because that all plays a big part in the design.
1:24:36 We're looking at basically a five block area of Main Avenue
1:24:40 from Jerome on this end to Fairfield on the opposite end
1:24:44 of main avenue.
1:24:46 As you know, with urban renewal agencies around the state
1:24:48 primarily, we're looking at streetscape
1:24:50 and infrastructure improvements.
1:24:52 Infrastructure is always the big thing as far as cost,
1:24:56 because infrastructure, new water lines, sewer lines,
1:24:59 storm sewer, all of that, streets, sidewalks, all of that
1:25:02 is expensive, and so that's going to be a big part of the cost.
1:25:06 One of the things that JUB and our engineering department
1:25:10 has been looking at is how we improve water sewer
1:25:14 and storm sewer with everything that's in the alley.
1:25:16 Do we relocate some of those?
1:25:19 But we're also looking at what the impact may be of both
1:25:23 to the city as well as to property owners
1:25:25 and what that may look like.
1:25:27 So we've got all these various decisions we're making.
1:25:30 We expect to finish the design piece,
1:25:34 the 30% design piece by the end of this coming May, May 2015.
1:25:40 What Otak will present that at that point is like I said infrastructure improvements
1:25:46 Design which is streetscape landscape by you lighting
1:25:52 signage
1:25:53 parking
1:25:54 All kinds of things that help want to make sure make main Avenue an attractive place to have a business and to continue helping
1:26:03 Private property owners actually redevelop their properties as well part of that
1:26:08 you probably have heard is the agency has purchased the
1:26:10 Rochester building a few months ago and just recently directed
1:26:15 staff to look into as for bids for demolition because that is a
1:26:20 consideration. It's not a done decision. It is a consideration.
1:26:25 One of the pieces that OTAC has come up with preliminarily is they
1:26:29 believe that moving the fountain that is currently at the corner
1:26:32 of Main and Hanson Street would be better relocated and
1:26:36 designed over on the Rogerson site.
1:26:39 So that's a possibility of what could happen.
1:26:41 It creates a bigger plaza area, and it also
1:26:44 would help reopen Hanson Street to traffic again, which would
1:26:47 help traffic flow immensely around downtown.
1:26:54 So other things going on downtown, Travis mentioned earlier
1:26:57 that there's been 30 new businesses in downtown.
1:27:01 A lot of that came from the work we did with Columbia,
1:27:04 which they opened up about a year and a half ago in Old Town.
1:27:07 We're also St. Luke's, and for SPED have also done major renovations as well,
1:27:13 which has really helped create that new retail environment for new retail businesses to come in.
1:27:20 The agency leased the former REDS trading post site to a mobile bakery,
1:27:25 which is there are several days a week serving breakfast and food or lunch items,
1:27:30 as I think they're going to use that as a tryout to see if they're going to have a permanent facility at some point.
1:27:35 but so they're using this as a triad, which doesn't cost the agency any money,
1:27:39 and we get a big $50 a month, so it's really affordable to the entrepreneur
1:27:44 who's just getting started.
1:27:47 We're also, there's also a group of investors looking at opening up a recreational facility
1:27:52 in downtown, which would be pretty exciting as well.
1:27:54 I think there's a lot of people that have some interest in that.
1:27:57 So on the economic development piece of, or my hatch, we've got it,
1:28:02 we're currently working a couple of small projects.
1:28:05 Now, I would say small because we've had some really big projects in the last few years.
1:28:11 These two projects separately are probably five million dollars or less an investment.
1:28:16 They're anywhere from 20 to 80 employees.
1:28:20 They're really in the early stages.
1:28:22 They're industrial, they're not food related, they're very dry, so they wouldn't be using
1:28:26 a lot of water or sewer for these particular.
1:28:29 But they're pretty small ones and we're going to, so we're working with those.
1:28:33 to make sure that they can make the right decision to come to twin.
1:28:39 So, you know, and as you know, economic development and urban renewal is a big piece of that because
1:28:44 oftentimes new business requires new infrastructure and that's how urban renewal can really help
1:28:49 with that.
1:28:51 So I heard Speaker Bed-Kee say last week at the ATI conference that he is looking for comprehensive
1:28:58 urban renewal legislation to come forth sometime this legislative season.
1:29:03 I was part of a group that went to Salt Lake earlier this year to look at how Utah uses
1:29:08 their urban renewal.
1:29:11 It's, while there's some similarities, there's a lot of differences between the two states
1:29:16 about how urban renewal is used, and I'd be happy to have that technical conversation with
1:29:23 you later time.
1:29:24 I think we're running out of time tonight for that piece, but there is going to be a group
1:29:27 getting together to look at what that comprehensive legislation looks like, and I just want to
1:29:32 thank all of you for over the years your support of urban renewal it is a it's
1:29:38 one of the best tools we have for economic development and downtown
1:29:43 revitalization that the state has so thank you so that really concludes what
1:29:52 we wanted to share with you and and hopefully the impression that we're
1:29:56 we're leaving you is we believe that the city of Twin Falls as well positioned
1:30:01 as we continue to look towards the future.
1:30:04 But at the same point, we are going
1:30:07 to need to look to you to make sure
1:30:09 that those tools that we have are not diminished or taken away,
1:30:13 especially when you look at things like urban renewal.
1:30:16 That really is the single most economic development
1:30:19 tool that we have.
1:30:20 And if you look at all of our successful economic development
1:30:23 projects that we've had, they've been
1:30:25 used to create the critical infrastructure components needed
1:30:28 to land and create those companies that we talked about.
1:30:31 So with that, I would turn it over to any questions
1:30:33 or remarks that you have as we move forward
1:30:38 before we do any closing.
1:30:40 We use a very good mirror and impressed
1:31:23 with this, we're not always quite able to get jerked around
1:31:35 by the fans.
1:31:38 I'm not there in the alternate room.
1:31:56 I do not cause you harm.
1:31:58 It may not.
1:31:59 It may never help.
1:32:01 I know we are into the area around, but I've mentioned this, you know, the area between
1:32:22 my falls typically, when my falls are finer, I'm both going to expand, literally go commercially
1:32:29 residential and better culture, up so we're going into school, the other side of the
1:32:35 which we over the whole other mile.
1:32:38 And I assume we're looking at all those areas
1:32:42 that are not within the city right now,
1:32:45 but certainly going to be part of our expansion.
1:32:48 Yeah, and I think that, yeah, so the city is,
1:32:51 as an RFQ out right now, Mitch,
1:32:54 an RFQ out for, I don't think we've accepted,
1:32:57 it's not closed, it's still, or just closed.
1:33:00 It closed us Thursday.
1:33:02 So on Thursday will be the last day that we accept proposals and applications to assist
1:33:09 us in the look moving forward as we revise our comprehensive plan.
1:33:14 And it's going to be important that our partners from Kimberly, from Filer and all the other
1:33:19 surrounding communities are helping be a part of that conversation.
1:33:23 As we continue to grow and continue to expand, our growth has impacts and both positively,
1:33:30 there are some maybe some adverse impacts to those communities.
1:33:32 And so what we're trying to do is, you know,
1:33:34 if you look at past planning, it might not have been as robust
1:33:38 and as inclusive as we're making this move forward.
1:33:41 But I think that we're really trying to secure those relationships
1:33:45 with moving forward.
1:33:47 And I'm hoping that next year's legislative conversation,
1:33:50 we also invite and have the forward thinking to invite the folks
1:33:54 from Jerome to be here as well,
1:33:56 so that we're kind of presenting that microcosm of Magic Valley City's really working collectively
1:34:04 in unison to advance everything in the Magic Valley.
1:34:08 Well I know the guy over there.
1:34:12 I'm still a little sore.
1:34:15 Mike is a wonderful man and he's doing a great job over there and really we're taking
1:34:20 that first step in really securing that relationship with our closest partner and closest neighbor
1:34:26 and that is the city of Kimberly.
1:34:31 If there's nothing else, I don't know if Don wants to offer a close, but I just want to
1:34:36 say thank you.
1:34:38 Thank you for everything that you guys do for us.
1:34:45 What I really appreciate most is that you are a phone call away and you are an email away
1:34:53 and whatever that vehicle is, you are very, very quick to respond and you're also very
1:34:59 quick to reach out when you see something coming that impacts us or could impact us just to get
1:35:05 our thoughts or our ideas.
1:35:06 And I really appreciate that relationship.
1:35:09 I appreciate each one of you and the work that you do.
1:35:13 I wish you safe travels to and from Boise as you make your initial pilgrimage and then
1:35:19 back and forth as you come home to visit family and friends, but be safe and know that we're
1:35:24 here and a blessed Merry Christmas and holiday season to you and we look forward to working
1:35:30 with you after the first of the year.
1:35:34 You know I don't know if I could say it any better.
1:35:35 I was just going to say again thank you for being so accessible to us.
1:35:40 I've had conversations with a couple of you while you were on the floor even and that's
1:35:45 how close you are to us and again government works when that happens when we can have these
1:35:51 conversations and we can problem solve. So thank you so much for doing that and
1:35:55 being here with us this evening we look forward to a robust legislative season.
1:36:00 So this time I'm going to go ahead and put City Council into recess. We'll take
1:36:05 about a 10-minute recess. The process and things right.
2:04:31 Leila are you ready? I would like to reconvene the meaning of the Twin Falls
2:04:40 City Council December 15, 2014. We traditionally start with the Pledge of Allegiance. We've
2:04:47 already done that, but I will never miss an opportunity to do the pledge, especially since
2:04:53 we have some Boy Scouts in the audience that would love to lead us in that process again.
2:04:58 So, boys, if you wouldn't mind coming forward, and for those of you wishing to, please rise.
2:05:04 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for
2:05:23 which its chance, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
2:05:31 Gentlemen, if you wouldn't mind going to the microphone, and as we talked before, if
2:05:35 you could tell us your name, troop you're with, and what you're working on, and where
2:05:41 you meet.
2:05:42 I'm Stephen Conder. We're working on the communications at badge
2:05:47 We are troop 59 and we eat and we meet at the Eastland Church
2:06:00 We say that up here once in a while ditto good job. Thank you gentlemen for being here this evening
2:06:11 Next item on the agenda is
2:06:14 Confirming that we do have a quorum of the city council again all seven city council all seven members are here this evening
2:06:20 Travis, do we have any amendments to our agenda?
2:06:27 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
2:06:28 there are no amendments this evening.
2:06:30 Thank you, Mr. Rothweiler.
2:06:32 We have no proclamations, and this is the time
2:06:35 where we open it up to the general public
2:06:37 for any general comments that you would like
2:06:39 to engage your city council on.
2:06:43 It's not something on the agenda.
2:06:44 We'll have time for those in a few minutes.
2:06:47 But anything else, is there anyone in the audience
2:06:50 that would like to come forward and address the council?
2:06:54 Okay, I see no one running for the podium again,
2:06:57 so we will move now to the consent calendar
2:06:59 and turn that over to the council for their direction.
2:07:07 Greg Lanning, move approval.
2:07:09 Second.
2:07:10 We have motion on floor by Greg Lanning,
2:07:12 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar
2:07:16 as posted.
2:07:18 Anything further on that agenda item council?
2:07:22 Leila, can we have a roll call vote please?
2:07:24 Suzanne Hawkins?
2:07:25 Yes.
2:07:26 Jim Mon?
2:07:27 Yes.
2:07:28 Sean Berriger?
2:07:29 Yes.
2:07:30 Yes. Great glad. Yes.
2:07:32 Don Hall. Yes.
2:07:33 Right back to Mils
2:07:49 Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Next item on the agenda is we're going to move to the public hearing portion. We are not going to start that until six. It's one minute to six. So I thought what I would do first is explain to folks that we are going to have a short presentation from our city employees.
2:07:56 employees are actually Mitch Humboldt, who will describe some issues that have arisen regarding
2:08:03 this public hearing agenda item.
2:08:07 So it's close enough to six for me, Mitch.
2:08:11 So if you'll go ahead and get started.
2:08:15 So with public hearings, you all know that we have a notice process that involves signs
2:08:21 on the property, a little display or packets that go into the signs and letters, and newspaper
2:08:28 notes, and all that kind of stuff. So with this particular hearing, we notified it for
2:08:33 tonight's meeting, the newspaper, and then there was a typo in the letter that gets mailed
2:08:40 out. And there was a letter mailed out to a list of folks that owned property within
2:08:46 300 feet, plus several more that we felt were impacted by it. With an incorrect date of
2:08:51 December 10th, everything else was accurate, but that particular one had an incorrect date
2:08:56 of December 10th. We caught that in time and we re-notified it, sent out another list of
2:09:02 letters that corrected the date with the big old notice across the top set direction, you
2:09:07 know, hearing the end of December 15th. That was the incorrect one was mailed on November
2:09:13 I want to say 28, I think it's 20.
2:09:16 And they're also put in the signs out on the property,
2:09:19 on the same day, on December 1st,
2:09:21 the new letters were sent out
2:09:22 and corrected letters were put in the signs.
2:09:25 In that three-day span, we had somebody pick one of those up
2:09:29 and show up here on December 10th
2:09:31 to participate in the hearing
2:09:34 and they found a block through my imagine.
2:09:36 I don't know if there's anything going on here Wednesday night.
2:09:39 So since then, that person then contacted one of you all
2:09:43 and came to our attention that that had happened.
2:09:46 We've called that person.
2:09:48 Let him know what was going on the correct date
2:09:50 and all that kind of stuff.
2:09:51 The proper notices have gone out.
2:09:53 We're okay legally to proceed with the hearing tonight,
2:09:56 but I just wanted to let you all know
2:09:57 that that had happened.
2:09:58 And then any questions about that?
2:10:00 You can try to answer them before we get into the hearing.
2:10:03 Very good, Mitch.
2:10:05 Any questions?
2:10:06 Rebecca Nelson, I guess.
2:10:07 Thank you, Mayor.
2:10:08 And thank you, Mitch, for the explanation.
2:10:09 I was the council person that was notified by a citizen.
2:10:13 I was just out ringing the Salvation Army Bell, and it's a great time for people to see you and talk about concerns, but I was really glad.
2:10:21 I think it was more just a coincidence that we ran into each other, and she was able to say, you know, I showed up to public hearing on the date that the notice said, and nothing was there.
2:10:32 And I didn't get a chance to speak, and it is fortunate that the final hearing, the recommendation is now coming tonight, and so we were able to correct that with her.
2:10:41 I do have a little bit of a concern moving forward.
2:10:45 We don't know how many people grabbed that incorrect notice and maybe wanted to participate
2:10:50 and then kind of thought it was over and didn't have the opportunity for a correct notice.
2:10:56 So I hesitate to proceed, but I know that we've met all of the legal obligations.
2:11:04 So if the council would like to, you know,
2:11:09 re-notice, I certainly would be in support of that,
2:11:12 but if the council would like to proceed,
2:11:15 I know that we legally can.
2:11:17 I just have that concern for all the people
2:11:19 that we don't know that got the incorrect notice.
2:11:23 Thank you Rebecca.
2:11:25 Anyone else have a comment?
2:11:27 Jim Munn.
2:11:30 I would love to proceed this evening,
2:11:31 but if there's a chance out there
2:11:33 people who have who picked up a wrong notice because of our screw up did not
2:11:39 are not notified I don't want to proceed either. Suzanne Hawkins. Can we find out
2:11:46 how many people are here tonight for this because it's not fair to them either if
2:11:50 they came out for this after getting the right notification and I don't want to
2:11:53 inconvenience the people that took the effort to get here. Sure if we could have
2:11:58 by show of hands if you're here again for the public hearing on the land use the
2:12:03 the land zoning change, could you raise your hand?
2:12:09 Yeah, it seems like we have quite a few great landings.
2:12:14 That's the point.
2:12:15 Yeah, if the date on the incorrect one
2:12:17 had been after this date, I might agree,
2:12:20 but since it was before this date,
2:12:22 and if even the people showed up on the 10th,
2:12:25 they would have an opportunity to find out
2:12:27 what the next date was, I'm ready to proceed.
2:12:31 Chris talking it.
2:12:32 When all oil sales ask Brits,
2:12:35 is that a proper interpretation?
2:12:36 because we pre-nauticed it earlier than the actual.
2:12:40 Have we covered our bases legately?
2:12:42 Yeah, the posting is required a minimum of seven days out,
2:12:45 and in this case, it was like 14 or 15 days out.
2:12:49 The correct notice.
2:12:50 The correct notice was 14 or 15 days out.
2:12:53 Yes.
2:12:54 Okay.
2:12:57 All way in, I think, 14 or 15 days.
2:12:59 I kind of agree with Greg that if it was after
2:13:02 it had an issue, but since it was before the actual hearing
2:13:07 and it was 14 days out, to me that's more than half of the time.
2:13:13 Just to clarify as well, the mailed notices were also, so the affected property owners
2:13:19 were mailed the first dish.
2:13:22 The mailings went both times, so the incorrect ones were mailed and then the corrected ones
2:13:29 were mailed.
2:13:30 Right, so the mailed notices and the posting are printed off in the 14 day window.
2:13:37 Yeah, I would support moving.
2:13:41 So what I'm hearing so far from council,
2:13:43 there's two that aren't comfortable with moving forward,
2:13:46 and the rest of us are, is that what I'm hearing?
2:13:51 Okay, so I think we'll go ahead and move forward
2:13:53 with that agenda item.
2:13:55 We will now move to the public hearing portion
2:13:57 of tonight's agenda,
2:13:59 and it is a request for annexation of a 40 plus
2:14:03 or minus acre parcel and a zoning district change
2:14:07 zoning map from R1 variable to C1PUD to allow a planned mixed-use development compatible
2:14:16 with urban village, urban infill design, as described in the Twin Falls Vision 2030,
2:14:23 a comprehensive plan, and consisting of a combination of a mixed residential professional
2:14:30 office and light commercial uses on property located at the southwest corner of Poline
2:14:37 Road East and Eastland Drive North and I believe we have Gerald Martin's as the applicant this evening making
2:14:43 presentation and as Gerald is making his way to the podium those of you wishing to testify about tonight's
2:14:50 public hearing please put your name on the back. There's a sheet in the rear of the
2:14:55 council chambers here so that we can call you up here one at a time when that time comes.
2:15:01 So, Mr. Martins, we have 15 minutes.
2:15:05 Thank you, and I'm not going to take the 15 minutes.
2:15:07 I think that I can summarize it quicker than that.
2:15:10 For the record, my name is Gerald Martins.
2:15:12 I'm here this evening at represent
2:15:14 in the actual applicant, Northeast Investments, LLC,
2:15:19 the representatives of which are here this evening.
2:15:24 I'd like to give you just a little bit of brief history
2:15:27 of how we got here this evening,
2:15:29 the process that we went through to develop this urban village plan that we're presenting
2:15:36 and that we have worked on.
2:15:38 Urban village is a relatively, well, it is a new concept.
2:15:41 It's the first one that's ever been attempted.
2:15:43 In fact, we really don't even have a zoning for it.
2:15:47 It's a concept in the comprehensive plan, but we've worked toward the concepts of that
2:15:52 urban village concept as we developed this plan and I'll give you a little brief history
2:15:58 of that.
2:15:59 And recently, three months ago, we prepared a plan which we felt met the, or at least met the spirit of the urban village.
2:16:08 We submitted the necessary applications to planning and zoning staff.
2:16:13 They scheduled a hearing and we had a hearing hearing in these chambers before planning and zoning.
2:16:18 It was well attended, would be a way to describe it.
2:16:22 It was a relatively long meeting.
2:16:24 It was a very courteous meeting, but we had a lot of input.
2:16:28 recommendations, and an awful lot of questions from the neighborhood.
2:16:32 We have a neighborhood out there that's very concerned about what happens in their neighborhood.
2:16:38 We listened to those inputs, we noted them, and at the request of the applicant, it was
2:16:43 tabled that evening, and we went back to the drawing board.
2:16:49 We had several informal meetings with several of the neighbors out there to try to define
2:16:55 What they individually were looking for would hope to see.
2:16:58 And then we had a large neighborhood meeting.
2:17:01 That was, I believe, the largest neighborhood meeting
2:17:04 that I've ever assembled in some 30 years.
2:17:08 We left that meeting after a couple of hours of taking input
2:17:12 and suggesting ideas with, as near the unanimous consent
2:17:18 of what we'd like to see as we could do.
2:17:21 We then went back to the drawing board
2:17:25 and equally to the PUD agreement, which you have in your packet this evening, and made
2:17:32 those changes and came back on the 25th of November and presented that to planning and
2:17:38 zoning. We had numerous neighbors get up, expressed that they were comfortable with
2:17:46 the changes that had made. They were happy and recommended the project go forward. We went
2:17:55 through that process, and I'd like to take a few minutes
2:17:58 of you this evening, and just give you a little summary
2:18:01 of the project, what you're likely to see it,
2:18:04 what hopefully you will see out there
2:18:07 as this project develops.
2:18:17 Beginning in the upper northwest corner,
2:18:21 there's a piece of property that was,
2:18:24 that brought this project forward to begin with.
2:18:27 It is a project for the Bishop's Lourhouse.
2:18:30 There is a representative of that group here,
2:18:32 this evening he will get up after me and explain to you what that is, what it amounts to, so
2:18:39 I won't address that any further. As you move to the south is a piece of property, that
2:18:48 the PUD agreement and the plan allows for either townhomes, professional offices or single
2:18:57 family residences, meeting R1 variable standards. The goal of the neighborhood I might express
2:19:10 here is to have if it's residential units to have it owner occupied or to the extent
2:19:16 possible owner occupied units. And that is a logic for the townhouses versus apartment designation.
2:19:24 The southern boundary for a quarter of a mile was a piece of property that had the most
2:19:30 concern of the neighborhood and in the end what we've ended up with there is our one
2:19:35 variable single-family residences, lots, same as the zoning to the south.
2:19:43 In addition to that, we added some criteria to that project that has to rough slope architectural
2:19:51 materials landscaping, no access directly from Cheney Drive, no garages visible from
2:19:58 the neighborhood, and just some basic hike limitations to 28 feet.
2:20:06 Those are all summarized in the PUD agreement that you have in your packet.
2:20:12 Moving north is a transition area which is designated for writ professional.
2:20:19 and beyond just normal professional office space,
2:20:23 it does require a master landscaping plan
2:20:27 to assure that landscaping around those offices
2:20:30 would all be uniformly designed and maintained
2:20:34 to not only the quality of the transition,
2:20:37 but the appearance of the project.
2:20:40 Finally, inside the curve, the largest parcel
2:20:45 is designated as commercial.
2:20:47 C1 uses further restricted by size, no building can be larger than 40,000 square feet.
2:20:55 There's height limitation of the 35 feet, even though C1 will now allow to go higher up
2:21:01 to the greater height.
2:21:04 There are significantly increased landscaping requirements within the parking areas.
2:21:11 It requires a place of landscaping in the parking area that C1 zones would normally allow.
2:21:22 That summarizes the uses.
2:21:23 There's a few other key criteria in the PUD agreement that will go through quickly.
2:21:30 First of all landscaping, there's extensive language in the document concerning landscaping,
2:21:37 35 feet along Pole Line and Eastland, which is the gateway landscaping requirement for
2:21:45 the community. There are some further requirements concerning site distances near the curves to
2:21:51 make it safer. We've added 20 foot of landscaping along Chaney and along both sides of Mountain
2:21:59 view. We've added significant additional landscaping along an area, a portion of which
2:22:07 is wetlands and a portion of which would be a little neighborhood part. We've got landscaping
2:22:12 requirements there. I've noted that the building height limitations of the master landscaping
2:22:22 plan in any area that's developed as a professional office or townhomes will require a master landscaping
2:22:31 plan for its entirety to be installed uniformly and to be maintained by the property owners'
2:22:41 association. One of the important features along the easterly side of Mountain View Drive
2:22:49 will be the trail, an extension of the trail that was constructed in the subdivision to the
2:22:55 south. It will go to the north boundary and hopefully consolidate pedestrians at a single
2:23:01 crossing a pole line to get over to the canyon rim trail system along the canyon rim.
2:23:09 Signage is limited throughout to wall mount signs or monuments signs and monument signs
2:23:17 for individual businesses are limited in size.
2:23:20 There will be no pylons, rough mount signs.
2:23:24 We've restricted the signing to basically monuments only and we further restricted them
2:23:29 that they have to be met to a standard architectural theme,
2:23:36 which will be developed by the developer.
2:23:38 So all of the bases will have a similar appearance in signage.
2:23:42 Again, planning and zoning approved this request
2:23:47 for this requested zoning and on the 25th,
2:23:53 and we've requested your approval this evening.
2:23:56 These conditions that were placed upon the approval
2:23:59 by planning the zoning are acceptable,
2:24:01 and we expect those to carry through your approval.
2:24:05 Thank you, and we're glad to answer the questions.
2:24:07 Looks like we have a couple of questions.
2:24:09 Gerald, Chris, document.
2:24:10 Gerald, you may have covered this, I might have missed it,
2:24:12 but what lighting restrictions or controls
2:24:16 that you're placing, especially with the industrial use
2:24:19 up there in the North.
2:24:21 Lighting of this.
2:24:22 North West corner.
2:24:23 Lighting, of course, especially with the commercial area
2:24:28 where it's adjacent to two arterials.
2:24:30 The light sources will not escape the boundary
2:24:34 of the property.
2:24:36 And we will have a uniform lighting criteria,
2:24:42 architecturally approved lighting criteria
2:24:44 for the entire project.
2:24:46 Thank you.
2:24:47 Rebecca Mills, so I go.
2:24:48 Thank you, Mayor.
2:24:49 Thank you for your presentation.
2:24:53 This is designated in the comprehensive plan
2:24:55 as urban village and in fill.
2:24:57 and I realize that we haven't yet done our job
2:25:01 in providing those standards.
2:25:02 The comp plan says that we'll provide specific standards
2:25:06 for urban village and infill.
2:25:07 So I understand why you're going with C1PUD as the preferred
2:25:12 zone.
2:25:13 So my question is, if you look at urban village urban infill,
2:25:18 it has a heavy emphasis on the open space and the parks.
2:25:22 And you mentioned, and you have some open space, green space
2:25:26 and some parks on there.
2:25:27 Can you talk about the functionality?
2:25:29 What kind of places are those?
2:25:30 Are those for, you know, picnic type, you know, benches?
2:25:34 Or what's the function of your open space?
2:25:37 Well, actually, first of all, in green space,
2:25:40 if you add up the required green space and provide it
2:25:43 on this project without the discretionary green space,
2:25:47 it exceeds 20% of the site will be green space.
2:25:51 Say in that functionality, first of all,
2:25:55 And this portion of the green space encompasses
2:26:02 a jurisdictional wetlands.
2:26:04 And that, of course, will be, there
2:26:08 are certain rules and regulations on wetlands
2:26:11 in terms of maintaining water quality and landscaping.
2:26:15 And there'll be some limitation, obviously,
2:26:17 to activities within those areas.
2:26:21 The other green space south of the gated entry,
2:26:24 potential gated entry to the townhomes is a small
2:26:28 park that would be incorporated into the townhome
2:26:32 or office development that would provide passive
2:26:38 picnic tables, passive place for pedestrians or
2:26:43 residents to spend time with their grandchildren or go
2:26:46 outside and enjoy the green space or the sunshine.
2:26:49 In addition to that, the pathway that goes all the way
2:26:52 through the property will be landscaped on both sides and provide a pleasant environment
2:27:02 for those users of that trail.
2:27:04 There are no within the property, there are no public designated type parks.
2:27:11 I don't think anybody tends to fence it off, but there is not a public park designated within
2:27:17 the boundary.
2:27:19 Thank you, and then so so that's a walkway in in the middle of that landscape
2:27:25 Begins at this point and follows the east side
2:27:29 Met of you. It's it's more than a sidewalk. It's ten foot wide to accommodate my sickles pedestrians
2:27:37 strollers
2:27:39 Handicap vehicles or handicap
2:27:43 Wheelchairs, I guess what I'm trying to say
2:27:45 that type of
2:27:47 corridor through the project okay and that's on the opposite side yes so when you get to
2:27:52 polling you mentioned crossing polling what types of crossings are you going to have at
2:27:58 polling is that we will work with across walkers discussion but there we've attempted with
2:28:04 a pathway system to consolidate pedestrian traffic to this point we show a crosswalk at
2:28:09 that location when you get at the current time the actual new trail that this council is just
2:28:16 It's recently funded, comes to a point about down here.
2:28:20 There needs to be a connection made, it's on somebody else's property.
2:28:24 I would expect that the city is going to be looking, the right away for it has been dedicated on the other side.
2:28:30 So I would expect that the city and the Parks Department or somebody is going to be looking to make that connection somehow.
2:28:36 But we have consolidated the pedestrian traffic to one point to make it as safely as possible.
2:28:45 But the traffic, we don't see a traffic warrant for a normal signal at that location until this commercial project is significantly developed if then, but at least a safely striped crosswalk is going to be much better than what's out there now.
2:29:02 Okay, yeah, of course the concern is safety there and crossing the line is quite a busy street there, so thank you.
2:29:09 Great timing.
2:29:10 Carol or maybe you mentioned this one.
2:29:12 Where's the, there's a park designated just,
2:29:17 in my mind, it's just west of,
2:29:20 just west of this piece property and maybe just north of Cheney.
2:29:26 Is that true or is it?
2:29:28 There's a park, there's a designated park right here.
2:29:32 Right, isn't there one over to the west of it as well?
2:29:35 My home day, Paul.
2:29:36 Yeah, there's a planning and development here that designates one in this area, too, from
2:29:46 a long time ago.
2:29:47 Right.
2:29:48 There's like a three acres, we have the land, but the...
2:29:49 Well, we don't have it yet, but there's a requirement in the PUD to dedicate upon development, much
2:29:54 like the one that Gerald mentioned up here.
2:29:57 Okay.
2:29:58 All right.
2:30:00 Thank you.
2:30:01 This is probably more for Mitch when you...
2:30:02 I'm assuming you're making the staff report, Jonathan's making the staff report.
2:30:06 I do have questions along with what Rebecca was just asking about crossing
2:30:12 pole line. This is in my neighborhood so this is perfect. I ride my bike through
2:30:16 the field right now with all the thorns and probably trespassing. Doesn't say
2:30:21 trespassing. But and crossing pole line is you're taking your life in your own
2:30:28 hands, crossing pole line there. Do we have plans for traffic calming something
2:30:34 in that area, if this is going to be really a driven pedestrian route, and people will
2:30:41 use it to get to the trail, I guarantee you. What are our thoughts in the future?
2:30:47 So I would ask actually for Troy to come on up and talk about that one a little bit.
2:30:52 We do have some plans, and my guess is the signal is probably the best one, but I'll let
2:30:58 Troy kind of speak to that a little bit.
2:31:00 I know this is a little outside of what we're talking about here, but I think it's very
2:31:03 important on the safety aspect. Yes, Gerald did bring that forward when we talk in discussions
2:31:08 with them. There's been some conversation. Todd Glass is a portion of the trailways
2:31:18 here and Dennis currently is putting a trailway in this position. So connection from here to
2:31:23 here or here to here still needs to be developed. So there's some thought to have in one axis
2:31:30 and this is the most likely intersection since it's far enough from the turn of the curvature.
2:31:37 Now, Jackie is currently in a project to illuminate this portion of the roadway.
2:31:42 That'll be happening pretty soon, but right now, there's no warrant.
2:31:45 Gerald's agreed to do a traffic study because we've talked about a right turn,
2:31:49 with a bit of possibly creating a right turn bay.
2:31:53 We went along here to allow traffic to move south,
2:31:56 south but I'm guessing that even the highest and best use of this it's
2:32:01 probably not gonna warn a signal at either this location or this location at
2:32:06 this time so it'll be pretty much just a stop bars probably some signing for that
2:32:13 effect. It's not a kind of a roadway that you'd put in a protective island in the
2:32:18 middle of it or anything like that to try to calm that trip. There's people
2:32:21 scream around that corner. And there is actually the reason Jackie's eliminating
2:32:24 This corner right now is because people drift across this line as they are speeding around that corner
2:32:30 Drifting means something different to me than you
2:32:33 They cross the other okay, and so you have to illuminate it before you can put in an island
2:32:39 So there is but the island she's thinking about is kind of like in front of Costco just a division
2:32:44 So it keeps them in their traffic
2:32:47 Not a major wide headfoot landscape diamond, so
2:32:51 So we try to avoid those where possible islands in there, but if the counts are, we can work
2:32:59 with the developer on that and try to minimize those impacts as far as traffic in pedestrians.
2:33:04 Again, I just want to go on record if we're going to have this and it makes sense to me.
2:33:09 You're going to drive a lot of traffic to that cross pole line and I would just hope
2:33:13 that we would really consider the safety aspects of that and slowing the traffic down.
2:33:19 Okay?
2:33:20 Let's be with you.
2:33:21 What am I up here?
2:33:22 I'd like to bring up one thing.
2:33:24 Go run it.
2:33:25 We've been in discussions about Mountain View coming up.
2:33:28 Of course, a free runner right here.
2:33:30 There's a couple of other approaches in here.
2:33:33 There's one here, of course, down here.
2:33:35 These are proposed to be private.
2:33:37 Private easements type needs.
2:33:40 We're still in discussions with Gerald about probably making those tracks or something like that.
2:33:45 difficulty with addressing because how do you address say you know this corner
2:33:51 of this building if it's off of a tract it has there if it's off of an easement it's
2:33:56 hard to give a word easement a road game so we're going to continue those
2:34:02 discussions with him but I want to make that part of the record. Thank you sir.
2:34:06 Okay appreciate it. If you have somebody about the other building
2:34:10 the other building of the Quine, so let's speak.
2:34:16 Gerald, did you want the folks from,
2:34:19 I think it's the Bishop's storehouse?
2:34:20 Are they part of the presentation?
2:34:22 Yeah, they're part of the presentation.
2:34:22 I'd like to add just one thing that I didn't forget,
2:34:24 and then I'll turn it over to them,
2:34:26 and Troy brought it up.
2:34:28 Specifically, what you see this evening
2:34:31 is attempting to get zoning.
2:34:34 Well, we, to move forward for the Bishop's storehouse
2:34:37 quickly as possible. We intend to submit tomorrow. If we get positive approval this evening, we'll
2:34:44 be the preliminary plat and the preliminary plat has provided those tracks and addressing
2:34:51 issues that Troy brought. You will not see the preliminary plat, but you will see the
2:34:57 final plat behind that that will have those same tracks shown on it. So we will be bringing
2:35:03 forth a planning and track plan that addresses the addressing issues that Troy brought out.
2:35:12 And this first plan that you will see only provides for this property to be sold at the
2:35:20 present time. It requires a balance of the property to be built into large blocks that
2:35:25 require further resub division when the uses are known.
2:35:28 So before we go beyond the Vishops Storehouse Project,
2:35:37 we will be back before you with a preliminary and final
2:35:42 plan for each of the other parcels.
2:35:44 Very good.
2:35:45 I'd like to invite them up.
2:35:46 I think we have about another five minutes.
2:35:48 But prior to that, Rebecca has a question.
2:35:51 Thank you.
2:35:52 That brings up one question.
2:35:53 So the wetlands area, the landscaping and that portion,
2:35:57 would that be developed at a later time
2:35:59 or is that developed when the Bishop's storehouse is developed?
2:36:03 It will be developed as part of the Bishop's warehouse plant.
2:36:08 In fact, it is our intent to develop as part of the Bishop's
2:36:13 warehouse.
2:36:14 I keep saying warehouse.
2:36:15 It's a storehouse.
2:36:17 Bishop's storehouse project.
2:36:21 It's important to them.
2:36:23 But Bishop's Storehouse Project, as a development of that,
2:36:28 we will complete the development of Mountain View
2:36:30 in its entirety, including the utilities underneath it.
2:36:36 And then I don't have to trespass anymore.
2:36:38 No.
2:36:39 It'll be dedicated right away, and certainly the mayor.
2:36:44 I appreciate that.
2:36:45 I think that'll be an important road to build.
2:36:48 I agree with that.
2:36:49 If you would state your name, sir, and welcome.
2:36:51 Sure.
2:36:51 [Muted for privacy: street address]
2:36:52 [Muted for privacy: street address]
2:36:56 [Muted for privacy: street address]
2:36:59 to co-insist in, I don't care what he calls the thing.
2:37:03 But the official title is the Bishop's storehouse.
2:37:07 The LDS Church is anxious to provide a facility like this
2:37:12 in the city of Twin Falls.
2:37:13 The closest facility like this right now is currently
2:37:16 burly.
2:37:18 And so they either ship items over here
2:37:20 to a meeting house area for people that need to go there,
2:37:26 go over to Burleigh.
2:37:28 Where the idea of the urban village
2:37:33 is ideal for this type of facility.
2:37:36 It's a small scale.
2:37:38 It's about 14,000 square feet, very low traffic volume.
2:37:44 When we reach your comprehensive plan
2:37:46 on what an urban village is, we look at someplace
2:37:50 that you're trying to create the environment to live, work,
2:37:54 and play in all in the same kind of area,
2:37:57 very pedestrian, friendly, smaller scale buildings,
2:38:01 those kind of things.
2:38:02 And so our facility fits very nicely in that.
2:38:05 What a Bishop's storehouse is, if you're not familiar with it,
2:38:09 is it's kind of a small grocery store
2:38:12 without a cash register.
2:38:15 So for an example, if, let's say I'm
2:38:18 having a tough time making ends meet for a month or two.
2:38:22 I can go to the LDS ecclesiastical leader in my area
2:38:27 and say, hey, I'm really struggling putting breakfast
2:38:31 on the food for my kids.
2:38:33 And he can say, all right, let me help you out here.
2:38:36 And he'll write me out almost like a prescription
2:38:38 or a shopping list.
2:38:40 And then he'll send me over to the Bishop's storehouse.
2:38:43 And I can go get milk, eggs, those kind of things
2:38:48 to help feed my family.
2:38:50 The Bishop's storehouse doesn't really,
2:38:54 people just off the street don't walk into it,
2:38:56 so it's not like a typical retail grocery store.
2:39:00 I think I got some pictures here,
2:39:02 some are just really quickly of kind of,
2:39:05 there's a home storage center also in there
2:39:07 to kind of help people, but.
2:39:11 So really what it is, it's an avenue,
2:39:16 it's an avenue for the local,
2:39:18 ecclesiastical leaders to help people that are in need to get the basics for their family.
2:39:27 The reason why the Urban Village fits really well for us is we do have truck traffic once
2:39:35 or twice a week to bring in fresh fruit, milk, those kind of things.
2:39:41 Maybe once a month or every other month they'll bring dried goods in.
2:39:47 So it's a really very low volume area.
2:39:50 The majority of the facility is actually warehouse part.
2:39:59 The entire place is staffed by either volunteers or missionary people.
2:40:05 So the amount of number of employees, number of what's called customers is very low volume
2:40:13 so it fits well into the urban village.
2:40:16 All this, the design of the building, the site requirements fit excellent with the PUD requirements
2:40:23 that the developer has asked for, and we're more than happy to meet or exceed any of the
2:40:29 landscapes, the lighting issues, anything like that that they ask.
2:40:34 So I'll just hold any questions for that.
2:40:36 Do we have any questions for Mr. Watson?
2:40:40 None so far, sir.
2:40:41 Great.
2:40:42 Thank you for your presentation.
2:40:43 All right.
2:40:44 Thank you.
2:40:45 I'm going to turn it over to Jonathan's fan love who's going to give a staff report.
2:40:52 Welcome Jonathan.
2:40:53 Thank you Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.
2:40:58 I'm going to spend talk about a lot I'm going to be brief, trying not to reiterate anything
2:41:02 Gerald or the Bishop's storehouse people have gone over.
2:41:06 As I'm talking about and going through my staff report, it's essential to have the PUD
2:41:11 with you as well as the Master Development Plan, particularly on the Master Development
2:41:22 plan, as Mitch looms into a spot. I want to focus on a different area that Gerald didn't
2:41:30 bring up. The area over here, and it's in your packet, describes the areas on the Master
2:41:35 Development Plan. My staff report goes through these areas as far as the criteria and what
2:41:40 can be built there. Gerald went over them very well, not going to go through all of them.
2:41:45 But what we get to is Covenant Number 2, in the PUD, starts with Covenant Number 1, Nature
2:41:51 agreement that it goes to number two and it goes through different things. That number
2:41:54 two talks about the uses. This is what can be built in these areas. Gerald described the
2:42:01 Bishop's storehouse in the northwest, the townhomes or the R1 variable single family homes or professional
2:42:09 offices. That is described as period B. One of the conditions we placed on this and the commission
2:42:15 agreed with was to make that all or nothing. So it has to be all professional, all townhomes
2:42:21 or all single family.
2:42:22 So we have a nice full development, not half and half.
2:42:27 That way it also keeps the landscaping,
2:42:29 modulus, and well taken care of all under the same ownership.
2:42:32 So as the uses go down in my staff report,
2:42:35 area A, Bishop's Storehouse, area B,
2:42:37 just described area C down on this plan,
2:42:41 marks this area, as well as area F.
2:42:46 Gerald went down.
2:42:47 These two areas are gonna be developed the same
2:42:50 in my staff report and talk about the criteria, I'll get to those.
2:42:53 So as we go through that section of the staff report,
2:42:57 it describes each section.
2:42:58 This area D is the one that's most open.
2:43:01 It allows for developments most like the C1 zone.
2:43:06 What Gerald did was take the C1 zone,
2:43:08 and he cut a lot of those uses out.
2:43:10 So therefore, he had a limited use,
2:43:13 took out some things that wouldn't necessarily fit in this area.
2:43:17 He didn't add anything extra.
2:43:20 He did move some from a loud outright to special uses,
2:43:24 namely the gas station, some of those things you have
2:43:27 to get a special use permit for those
2:43:28 to actually take place in this specific area.
2:43:31 They're not allowed anywhere else.
2:43:33 They won't only be allowed up here, long,
2:43:36 pole line, and east line.
2:43:38 So that's kind of the use section.
2:43:41 I'm not going to go over the possible impacts other
2:43:43 than they're restricted.
2:43:45 And some of those areas are further restricted by Covenant
2:43:48 5th and I'll get to that in a little bit.
2:43:50 Gerald Darts spoke about landscaping.
2:43:52 It's above and beyond, but we require most places under our current code.
2:43:56 The gateway landscaping is going to be taken care of on Pull Island in Eastland.
2:44:00 He's also adding Mountain View and Chaney. He's also increasing the
2:44:04 requirement on the internal parking lot landscaping. We just changed
2:44:08 that code. Right now it requires every 15 spaces to be broken
2:44:12 up. They're requiring every gate to have a landscape island to break up the
2:44:16 landscape in areas. The landscaping plan details, the types of plants that can be planted
2:44:23 into more than we require. It also talks about water-wise plants and more evergreens that
2:44:30 are more native here instead of your deciduous trees. The development standards for the architectural
2:44:36 style and building size. Gerald has restricted the building size of 40,000 square feet. If
2:44:41 you want bigger, it'll have to go to a special use permit. So that's another government oversight
2:44:46 and public hearing for any neighbor that's going to be impacted by this.
2:44:51 So any building in this whole area, most likely, in this C, this area D, which is the C1 restricted
2:44:59 zone, nothing can be built over 40,000 square foot, and that's building footprint.
2:45:07 Professional office restrictions, details, the landscaping, and that has to be maintained
2:45:11 uniformly.
2:45:13 The development standards along Chaney, this is where we get to anything within 280 feet
2:45:19 of Chaney Drive. These are a sharp departure from what we normally do. I'm on page 6 of
2:45:26 my report if anyone wants to follow. All the buildings within this 280 feet, so namely
2:45:31 area C and F, as depicted on this development key. They have a minimum living unit size of
2:45:40 residents as being 1,600 square feet. The residents left have a two-car garage or a larger
2:45:45 The lot area has to be 10,000 square feet, details the exterior building materials of brick,
2:45:51 stucco, stone, or combination, no garage, doors can face chaining, roof pitches shall
2:45:56 be not less than 6 and 12, and the building height shall not exceed 28 feet, as well as
2:46:02 any fencing parallel to and adjacent to chaining drive shall be uniform and approved by the
2:46:07 architectural committee.
2:46:09 What this is going to do and the impacts are, most of this stuff is normally the CC&Rs
2:46:15 developments. The city has not normally gotten into enforcing these things. The
2:46:20 picture will be when somebody comes to get a building permit and they're unaware
2:46:23 of these items the city will then be informing them of these increased
2:46:26 building time reviews or building permit reviews as well as any impacts to future
2:46:33 on landowner. It's something we haven't done before but we can't do it in a PUD
2:46:38 and that's part of what Gerald has talked with neighbors about. So those are the
2:46:42 minimums. We can build more. It also accounts to a minimum for the town homes up here in this
2:46:48 area B as well. That's another section that's applied to.
2:46:54 Jonathan, will there still be a homeowners association as well? That is, well, I realize
2:47:04 they don't have regulatory authority, but truthfully, I'd rather deal with the city than
2:47:09 I believe someone Gerald can, I believe Gerald's answering the affirmative or.
2:47:15 Right.
2:47:16 Either way.
2:47:17 I mean, I'm sure it's an easy answer.
2:47:18 That's all right.
2:47:19 Yeah, that's perfect.
2:47:20 There's a significant common area in landscaping that has to be maintained that will have to be
2:47:26 done by property owners association, not only for the association.
2:47:29 Okay.
2:47:30 And it will be a combination of office owners, homeowners, and commercial property owners,
2:47:39 all of which will be assessed by the Association to maintain all of the landscaping that we've
2:47:45 talked about, along with the wetlands, and any other amenities that are developed as part
2:47:50 of the project.
2:47:51 So there will be a property owners association, and there will be an architectural review committee
2:47:56 Also, that controls the architecture on all of the buildings.
2:48:00 Great.
2:48:01 So hopefully that group will have communicated these issues
2:48:05 to folks who are developing homes in there.
2:48:08 But worst case, it comes to you all.
2:48:10 And you see that?
2:48:10 Yes, it would be part of our building review.
2:48:12 It'll take more time to do those as well as inform people
2:48:15 that aren't aware that they have a minimum square footage
2:48:18 of 1,600 square feet for living space.
2:48:21 That crosses over anywhere.
2:48:24 The Chaney Drive restriction as well as this.
2:48:26 Both of them have been living space of 1600 as written in the PUD.
2:48:30 The only difference between these two areas of the area B, C and F would be the area B
2:48:35 has a height of 35 feet, which is what the rest of the city and normal city code has.
2:48:42 So these other areas are going to be limited to 28.
2:48:45 That's a difference.
2:48:46 Chris talking in has a question.
2:48:50 The townhouses are almost directing north of some of the most expensive homes in Twin Falls.
2:48:57 And I bring this up because several months ago we had a PUD applicant come in and plead for a higher density zoning.
2:49:04 I'm supposing that our tightened PUD standards now would not allow that.
2:49:12 For the heightened density?
2:49:14 Density in particular.
2:49:15 Yeah, so I'm going to answer.
2:49:18 To go up to a six or a four.
2:49:20 This will have an underlying zone of R1.
2:49:23 So they will have to meet the minimum law sizes of the R1,
2:49:27 which even in the townhouse, even in the townhouse.
2:49:31 OK, so it does not it will not increase the density.
2:49:34 Cannot be increased without going through it.
2:49:36 Yeah, they will meet the minimum law size.
2:49:38 And the other question is, how did PNC reconcile
2:49:41 this non commercial warehouse, the bishops storehouse
2:49:45 warehouse is, that seems a totally incompatible use.
2:49:50 They didn't speak against it or anything.
2:49:56 They didn't bring it up.
2:49:58 I know in the public committee meeting earlier, there was some discussion of that.
2:50:04 The one today? No, the one where, I think the largest attendance, I think, Gerald, you mentioned it or somebody did.
2:50:10 That was a point of discussion. And I'm yet to be convinced of the feasibility of this PUD that looks
2:50:17 otherwise well-constructed to have a non-commercial warehouse that
2:50:22 adjacent, closely adjacent to some very nice housing, but that was not a
2:50:29 discussion point. Was not brought up if I were to try and gather the thoughts of the
2:50:34 P&Z they felt that the neighbors were for it and they didn't have anybody speak
2:50:37 against that particular use. No that's not correct. That's not correct.
2:50:42 as we keep going, the sign plan Gerald went through restricting the sign plan as they have
2:50:54 restricted themselves to certain signs. They're not allowing root signs or pylon signs and development
2:50:59 standards for the buildings of pedestrian improvements. He's already talked about the pedestrian pathway.
2:51:06 We do not feel that that change or have any significant impact to the development or its
2:51:13 connectivity to surrounding areas.
2:51:15 On November 25th, a public hearing before the play
2:51:18 and zoning commission took place upon conclusion
2:51:21 of the public hearing and deliberations.
2:51:23 Commissioner Munoz made a recommendation
2:51:25 to the city of recommendation
2:51:27 the zoning district change and zoning map amendment
2:51:29 as presented and including staff recommendations
2:51:33 is an appropriate zoning district.
2:51:35 Commissioner Darracott seconded the motion.
2:51:36 All members voted in favor of the motion
2:51:39 subject to the conditions stated in the staff report.
2:51:42 In conclusion, staff concurs with the commission's recommendation.
2:51:45 Rebecca, Ms. Soica has a question.
2:51:47 Thank you, Mayor.
2:51:48 One additional question.
2:51:49 The area D that you pointed out, I believe it's area D,
2:51:52 the one that says most like a C1 zone.
2:51:55 What is the height restriction in that area again?
2:51:58 Is that the same 50 feet as C1?
2:52:00 They restricted it to 35 feet.
2:52:01 35, OK.
2:52:03 Thank you.
2:52:04 Any further questions for Jonathan?
2:52:08 Chris, talking about that.
2:52:08 Just to follow up to, I think, Rebecca's question,
2:52:10 or maybe it was yours done.
2:52:13 In any PUD, annexation PUD, have we had the experience of requiring the applicant, the
2:52:22 builder, to make the improvements in this case, which would be a polling crossing?
2:52:31 I'm not sure I've been here long enough to go to the historic PUD.
2:52:34 This subdivision, this whole development, will drive an increased use of the roads, both
2:52:42 east-west north-south and that it's probably should be paid for by the
2:52:48 applicants up front. Can I ask Claire, do you mean probably crossing like a traffic
2:52:54 signal or just putting in the car? No, no, no, the pedestrian safety that I'm most
2:52:58 concerned about, be it split with an island, crosswalks, blanking lights,
2:53:03 something short of a warranted traffic signal. Yeah, I would think we have done
2:53:10 similar restrictions. I can't think of a specific like what they call like a refuge island halfway
2:53:17 through, but we have had one that comes from would be departments near the college that was
2:53:25 a year or two ago when there was some traffic calming required along with that zoning.
2:53:30 And so it's something that we have done in the past and then I would think that we could do
2:53:34 if we have some concerns about that crossing.
2:53:36 require that. Thank you. Chris, anything further from council?
2:53:43 Thank you, Jonathan. At this time, I will go ahead and open it up for public testimony.
2:53:49 If someone could go back and get the list for me to see, I bet we have a mixed list,
2:53:54 so I'm going to have to really kind of weave through it. But at this time, we're going to
2:53:58 open it up to the public for their testimony. We generally limit you to about two minutes of
2:54:04 piece. This is Anne Hawkins to my right here. We'll hold up a 30 second sign. Don't freak
2:54:09 out when you see the 30 second sign. You have 30 seconds left. And we'll go from that. Thank
2:54:18 you Mitch. I think I see two potentials. If I'm wrong, we'll go ahead and continue to open
2:54:35 this up. There's other people that would like to testify. But it would look to me that it's
2:54:39 it's Chris Stern's would be the first person that would come up.
2:54:44 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:54:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:54:57 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:55:09 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:55:13 If I want to turn left, you better be 10 minutes early because you cannot turn left off of Julie
2:55:19 Lane on to Eastland.
2:55:22 We go from two lanes to four lanes, back down to two lanes when we get close to Bridgeview.
2:55:28 I'm not sure where, I mean I kind of have an idea where Mountain View comes in, but then
2:55:33 we go right back down to two lanes of traffic again.
2:55:37 That road is a mess, and I can't imagine anybody trying to cross pole line there.
2:55:44 I can't believe you do that on your bicycle.
2:55:47 The traffic there is, the four lanes is great, but where it goes down to two lanes on both
2:55:54 ends, at Bridgeview and again at, well, right there at Julie, clear to falls.
2:56:02 If you try to go anywhere at 505, the traffic is backed up from Falls clear to Julie Lane.
2:56:10 How are we going to add all of the traffic that's going to come from that area?
2:56:16 My other concern is the truck traffic coming in on Mountain View to the Bishop's warehouse.
2:56:26 I don't know if any of you know about trucks or how you get in and out of places like that.
2:56:31 If you come out of Mountain View and try to turn left, I just don't see that the traffic
2:56:37 through there is going to allow for the amount of traffic that I would see coming in off of
2:56:45 Mountain View to Pole Line.
2:56:47 I think we really need to do something with that street from Bridge View to where it goes
2:56:53 to the four lanes.
2:56:55 I would challenge all of you to drive over there and do that.
2:56:58 But on the side streets and try to get out on East Linder or Poe line, it's almost impossible
2:57:05 between probably 7.30 and 8.15 and 5 o'clock and 5.30.
2:57:13 Thank you.
2:57:14 Thank you, Chris.
2:57:15 I believe Lynn Rasmussen, are you here to speak on this?
2:57:23 Well, is there anyone else that would like to speak from the public regarding this?
2:57:29 Could you come forward, sir?
2:57:31 Are you on here?
2:57:32 No.
2:57:33 Okay.
2:57:34 If you...
2:57:35 No, I'll take care of it.
2:57:36 When you get to the podium, sir, if you would state your name and your address, I'll
2:57:39 try to rapidly fill that in.
2:57:43 My name is David Sparks.
2:57:45 I live in 1999, Poline Road East, but our home is back to the rim.
2:57:54 We're about a block.
2:57:55 Thank you, pass our house every time you go there, pre-help the trail on the north and
2:58:01 the trail on the east and we have a clear view between our house and all of this property.
2:58:10 I'm impressed with what they've done here.
2:58:14 We have a deeded groundwater right from the Idaho Department of Water Resources, which
2:58:21 comes out of the area here, year round, and it's been coming out.
2:58:27 Whoever started to develop the property to the north did put it on the ground so that
2:58:33 it comes into we have a large pond down there with a lot of ducks bed and breakfast type.
2:58:39 The end and out the world and I most have gone in the morning but we have noticed how
2:58:49 they have improved this property from what it was when we moved there in 1999.
2:58:54 I was before the trail was, and this was nothing but a reeds all over and broken fence all over and they've cleaned it all up.
2:59:08 And this is I known these two people who are developing this.
2:59:12 Their desire is to have something that is concrete, complements the city itself.
2:59:20 Okay, one other thing, we observe all of the traffic that comes, a lot of bicycles, some
2:59:28 of them in the night with lights on all of that jewelry.
2:59:30 That's not me.
2:59:31 And if I have a clock in the morning with their lights on, anyway, there is a lot of traffic,
2:59:38 foot traffic that goes there and with your new trail which goes around the blah, blah,
2:59:43 blah house and up to the other, there are people who are making that round and I've
2:59:49 I've observed people, there is excitement occasionally when you cross that road.
2:59:56 The lady talked about Julie Lane, I come up on pole line, and the light at falls and Eastland,
3:00:05 and the one over on Madrona and Pole Line do give you a chance, you might have to wait two or three minutes,
3:00:15 So without island there, you're able to get in and out without too much problem.
3:00:19 The problem is, I see with this, is people coming in and out of the gravel road there,
3:00:26 is if they could have a blinking light or something, at least up there for people who
3:00:31 are not familiar with the area, they know that they need to watch out there.
3:00:36 Thank you very much.
3:00:37 Thank you, Mr. Sparks.
3:00:38 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:00:41 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:00:50 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:00:55 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:01:01 concerns during the various meetings that we met with Gerald and the previous two planning and
3:01:06 zoning meetings. And so I just thought I'd come up and give my two cents that we actually have felt
3:01:11 as a neighborhood that this is a good thing, a good compromise, a good way to move forward.
3:01:18 To address your concern, Councilman Talkington, once we actually met as a neighborhood and really
3:01:23 voiced the concerns, people were a lot less concerned about the Bishop's storehouse than
3:01:27 they were about having a lot of apartments between where we all live now and the storehouse
3:01:32 and it kind of all got voiced kind of as we don't want any of that.
3:01:35 But as we've kind of come to this compromise here, I think the feeling was once the apartments
3:01:41 we're gone. Everyone is pretty happy with this compromise. I think everyone's still concerned
3:01:47 about getting from there across the same way. We've got kids that love to ride bikes.
3:01:52 We love to access that trail. We'd love to stop light there. But in terms of the development,
3:01:57 at least the 30 to 40 people that met with me various times, as we tried to work through
3:02:05 this we're pretty happy with this this plan is it sits on the screen so yes thank
3:02:11 [Muted for privacy: street address]
3:02:22 [Muted for privacy: street address]
3:02:26 [Muted for privacy: street address]
3:02:30 but I'm here traffic does is a concern on Julie even prior to me knowing about this
3:02:38 getting out on turn left off of Julie Lane is is getting harder and harder all
3:02:44 the time so there is more traffic I think a light is gonna be eminent in the
3:02:49 near future and I do run also down the pole line and Eastland at times and but
3:02:56 cut off the narrowing of the street to Bridgeview is another concern of mine.
3:03:02 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:03:15 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:03:18 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:03:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:03:24 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:03:28 And we were in favor of the changes that were made to this.
3:03:32 And the only problem that I have had through the whole thing
3:03:36 was the amount of traffic that goes through here
3:03:38 and person being able to get onto the street
3:03:42 where it comes from two lanes to one lane.
3:03:45 I think that that's something that the city really needs to look for.
3:03:48 I can't believe that they would make a four lane road with both hands in just two lanes.
3:03:53 And it does a lot of problems with trucks and the traffic trying to get on the road.
3:03:58 Thank you.
3:03:59 Thank you, Mr. Conner.
3:04:01 Is there anyone else?
3:04:03 Mr. Rasmussen, I think you're up.
3:04:10 Welcome, sir.
3:04:14 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:04:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:04:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:04:43 [Muted for privacy: home address]
3:04:49 This certainly would not be a detriment to the neighborhood.
3:04:54 As far as the trucks that come there, Johnny remind me,
3:04:58 I think that's only two a week.
3:05:01 Is that right?
3:05:03 Two a week at the most where a truck would come to deliver goods there.
3:05:09 And then there might be a smaller truck that disperses it somewhere else, but very little
3:05:17 traffic, very little, very few employees, very, very little even car traffic.
3:05:26 I'd like to mention that the developers are too humble to jump up and say this, but they're
3:05:35 the ones that put those four lanes around the Eastland and Pole Line.
3:05:41 Otherwise, it would still only be two lanes, I guess, but but they in conjunction with
3:05:49 Working with the city put those four lanes and they put I believe the power in
3:05:54 in the
3:05:55 roadway
3:05:57 and among other things I can't remember what all it was but
3:06:01 Maybe they could address that or Gerald could
3:06:06 So I guess what I'd like to say is I mean, I think it's a great
3:06:16 development, the way they met with the neighbors and they're all in favor of it now.
3:06:23 Oh, I would like to talk about the traffic a little bit.
3:06:28 Sir, sir, your two minutes is up.
3:06:30 I'll give you a let you stretch in at 30 seconds.
3:06:33 Okay, I'll say this real fast.
3:06:35 I've, my real estate office for the last seven years has been on the corner of Julie and Eastland Drive.
3:06:41 Once in a while you have to wait a few minutes, but I've never seen anybody wait 10 minutes like was said and
3:06:49 If you're a patient there's always a break in the traffic that you can get out
3:06:53 I
3:06:55 Agree someday there will need to be traffic light, but that's that's growth that happens throughout the city
3:07:03 So, thank you very much. Thank you. Mr. Raskins. Is there anyone else that would like to test them?
3:07:07 So at this point I'm going to close the public testimony portion of tonight's hearing and allow Mr.
3:07:16 Martin's to come back up.
3:07:18 This is still a time that Council can ask questions of anyone and later I will close all questions
3:07:26 and go into the deliberations.
3:07:27 So Mr. Martin's.
3:07:29 Thank you.
3:07:30 I took a few notes.
3:07:31 So I'll try to comment on that order.
3:07:34 First of all, this Bishop's warehouse looks as little like a warehouse as any warehouse
3:07:40 in town.
3:07:41 I think they had the renderings up there earlier.
3:07:46 They've done the best to disguise it as a warehouse, it's not a rule, a truck, dock
3:07:51 doors, and all of the hurricanes, all of the access will be designed to accommodate those
3:07:56 few trucks that come and go.
3:08:00 that Victoria alluded to.
3:08:03 Part of the agreement we have is that we will provide
3:08:07 a traffic study before we move forward
3:08:09 with any of the commercial aspects of this project.
3:08:13 That will be another plot, another time,
3:08:15 and another traffic study.
3:08:16 And at that time, we'll probably have a better handle
3:08:19 on uses so that we can do a more accurate,
3:08:22 better traffic study.
3:08:25 Traffic concerns have been brought up
3:08:27 at every meeting every time.
3:08:29 And as Lynn pointed out, the best section of the road
3:08:33 is the two frontages on this property
3:08:35 that were built by the developer to four lanes
3:08:38 as part of the Northeast sewer project some seven years ago
3:08:42 at a cost of a million dollars or more.
3:08:45 And the insult in there is adequate sewer and water
3:08:47 that benefits the entire neighborhood.
3:08:50 Also, as part of this project,
3:08:52 we will be extending Mountain View drive-through
3:08:55 in the first phase that is going to provide
3:08:58 alternative traffic route for all of the people that live in the subdivisions. To the south,
3:09:03 both to get to their homes and away from their homes and potentially eliminate some
3:09:08 of the conflicts up near Julie Lane. I guess everybody's driving habits will have to determine
3:09:14 how that works, but I notice that people usually find the easier out. Groundwater, water right
3:09:24 exists will be not blocked. In fact, we'll be enhancing it. We will be taking the spill
3:09:30 from the city's irrigation pump station, which is located in the southwest corner, and adding
3:09:37 that to the water in the wetlands, which will end up providing the ducks with a little
3:09:43 bit more water. I think unless I miss something or the issues that I heard come up. So if there's
3:09:56 any questions I'll be glad to answer them or I'll sit down and answer them later.
3:10:00 Thank you. Very good. Just to reiterate to Council this is still an opportunity that
3:10:04 we can ask the applicant, city staff or even members of the audience questions.
3:10:10 Jim. Thank you Mayor. I'd like to direct my questions to Deputy City Manager Mitch
3:10:15 Humbler. I want to get back just for a few moments on this notice issue. This is
3:10:20 So I can clearly understand this in my mind.
3:10:24 On what date did you notice people to make the mistake of attending December 10th?
3:10:31 Those letters went out and the papers put inside on December 28th.
3:10:35 Okay.
3:10:36 You just were placed on December 1st.
3:10:39 Okay.
3:10:40 So three days later and letters were sent to, they were sent on November 28th.
3:10:45 The same exact letters were again subsequently put out on December 1st.
3:10:49 Yeah, to the same list of folks.
3:10:51 Chris, talking to us.
3:10:57 Well, I think it's appropriate that the applicant work with the city for the traffic study.
3:11:02 I'm a little bit interested with the traffic studies going to show that there's traffic
3:11:07 increase, decrease or through time, I mean, with the development not beyond the concept
3:11:14 stage you're not going to know the ultimate impact, except by density and the average
3:11:19 number of vehicles per home.
3:11:22 What might that study show, Carol?
3:11:23 At this point in time for the storehouse, the townhouses, and the residential and the office
3:11:31 portions of it, we can do an accurate traffic study because we know the exact number of homes,
3:11:36 the exact number of residents, exactly what can happen.
3:11:39 Because in the PUD agreement, that density is specified.
3:11:44 The only part of this property that at this time would require some speculation is that
3:11:52 commercial portion.
3:11:54 However, there are, I think, pretty well established and well recognized studies that have tied
3:12:07 square footage of retail to number of cars.
3:12:13 is what we've used in traffic studies
3:12:15 for all of the other commercial projects that we've worked on.
3:12:19 We now know the square footage.
3:12:22 I mean, we know the land area.
3:12:24 We know the parking requirements.
3:12:25 We can back in exactly to the square footage
3:12:28 of retail space that will be there.
3:12:30 Now, whether it's a Whole Foods or something else
3:12:35 has some influence on the number of cars and the hours
3:12:39 that they use, but it really doesn't, in fact,
3:12:42 magnitude that greatly. So sounds like you have a formula you could come up with
3:12:49 it in a half an hour and figure it. We can. Now we have a proof. I'm more interested in the
3:12:54 follow-on so we know the impact by your realistic planning. What do we do with that
3:13:00 Mitch? When we and as I noticed earlier and Mitch can address it as we noticed
3:13:04 earlier up out of this process we have to get it in our zoning. The next step will
3:13:11 be to get the Bishops storehouse plat, then we have to come back with a plat for another
3:13:19 plat for the rest of the property. And at that point in time we'll have more information
3:13:25 and can probably, we'll be able to provide you that traffic study. It's kind of a chicken
3:13:34 in the egg. I have to know what I can do before I can calculate what how I'm going to impact
3:13:39 But then what leverage do we have after passage of this annexation to require the applicant
3:13:45 to participate in a pedestrian crossing?
3:13:49 So that would, having to play with the results of the traffic study and the plating is when
3:13:55 we would hit them with the required improvements that would all come along because of the proposed
3:14:02 entirely separate action.
3:14:04 Again, I'm going to say I don't think it's inappropriate now to if in the zoning of the
3:14:11 PUD, if we're showing a trail crossing to go ahead and say let's go ahead and put that
3:14:18 trail crossing in, if that's what we want to do now.
3:14:22 The traffic study and where that requires a right turn lane or not and if that requires
3:14:26 right away dedication or not, all that stuff will be dealt with when we do the plats and
3:14:31 the traffic service show that this needs a right turn lane and so we'll get their dedication
3:14:35 on the plan at the time.
3:14:36 All that kind of stuff.
3:14:37 Thank you.
3:14:38 We're back in Malasaka.
3:14:39 Thank you, Mayor.
3:14:40 This question is also for staff, maybe Jack here, Troy, engineering staff.
3:14:48 What comes to mind on the crossing at Pole Line is that light on Addison, near Smiths,
3:14:55 which is kind of a little button that you push and some very bright LED flashing happens
3:15:01 and you can see that you need to stop from blocks away.
3:15:06 Is number one, what is that called?
3:15:08 And is that something that would be, if you know,
3:15:11 is that something that would be helpful,
3:15:14 you think to require in this crossing a pull line?
3:15:17 Or should we leave it open to whatever the traffic study says?
3:15:22 But I agree with Mitch, and I think
3:15:25 that we need to make a provision to know
3:15:28 that this crossing will be there before anything happens
3:15:30 safety-wise with people trying to cross-pull lines.
3:15:33 So that is one type of option.
3:15:35 Was there a rapid flashing beacon or something like that?
3:15:38 There's an acronym for it.
3:15:39 But that is an option.
3:15:41 We can put two.
3:15:43 We also put one in that sure showed it made as well.
3:15:46 It's slightly different configuration,
3:15:48 but it is an option for the developer to put it in.
3:15:52 We can ask him at that point.
3:15:54 OK.
3:15:55 And then maybe this is a question for Fritz,
3:15:58 then what would the ideal way to require that?
3:16:06 How would we add that on to this PUD?
3:16:10 I would recommend that you leave it a little bit general in terms of a pedestrian bicycle crossing
3:16:20 as approved by the engineering department because I'm sure they have some ideas about how this ought to be done
3:16:26 that works best both for the traffic and for the pedestrian crossing.
3:16:29 Okay, thank you for that.
3:16:32 Second question really quick to address.
3:16:34 I appreciate all the public input.
3:16:36 I do understand there's an issue at Julie Lane and Pole Line, especially if you do want to turn left at those specific hours, morning hours, afternoon hours.
3:16:45 I have experience that even though I don't live in the neighborhood.
3:16:49 So another question for engineering staff.
3:16:51 What are the plans, future plans for that intersection,
3:16:57 and sorry Troy, I should have given you a heads up.
3:17:01 What are the future plans for that area
3:17:03 as far as our city planning,
3:17:07 and when would a signal or some sort of regulation
3:17:13 kind of be imposed on that intersection?
3:17:17 So the Julie Lane,
3:17:20 And we've had people in here actually ask about crosswalks there, I'm saying conversation
3:17:24 as this, and there are people that walk across there, and it is a wider road, but we've done
3:17:30 traffic studies on it, and unfortunately it just doesn't pull a warning right now.
3:17:34 The volume of traffic necessary for that is incredible.
3:17:39 So Julie Wayne, Camva Ridge, and Chaney here, for instance we did a traffic study on Chaney
3:17:45 here right now there's 36 vehicles I think a week and are leave that site that's really small
3:17:54 given that blue lakes have 60,000 kind of things so. Have we done studies on Julie Lane? Do we know
3:17:59 how many? I don't have the information on my head it's like two years old I think okay we have done
3:18:05 studies there. There is a back up there and I think as well with me anytime there's a back up
3:18:14 I'm frustrated. It seems like we need to progress because in that fast society, you have to move fast and I'm sure it feels like 10 minutes at times.
3:18:22 But when you get down to it, the traffic's just not there to warrant it at this time.
3:18:27 Okay, and how far away do you, I don't know what the numbers are like,
3:18:31 how far away do you think that intersection is from a warrant? Is it significant again?
3:18:37 It's significant.
3:18:39 Okay, and then one follow-up question on the lanes going from four lanes to two lanes.
3:18:46 I understand that this subject property, there are four lanes all around the perimeter.
3:18:53 What are the city's plans and intentions for that section from Julie Lane where it narrows
3:18:59 back to two lanes until falls?
3:19:02 Who's responsible for that and what are the city's plans on widening that up for four lanes?
3:19:06 And when this actually came up originally, the property on the north started developing
3:19:10 these, developers actually kind of had some foresight, and they developed those
3:19:13 and there's five lights there to each way in the center turn lane.
3:19:16 The property to the west of here, they didn't own.
3:19:19 And we, as the city, I was here at the time, I was explaining that we approached those people
3:19:25 and asked the city to put that road through, continuing with the width and those property
3:19:29 owners wouldn't have that time to give up the property.
3:19:32 So we can't trust, we can't put it on without condemnation process.
3:19:36 which we didn't want to go there. It's the same thing south at Jubilee. I mean it's
3:19:41 really purchasing property and widening the roadway. We did it
3:19:45 previously from fall south and that's quite a process. You have to go through
3:19:50 appraisal processes, meet with homeowners. It's a lengthy process and you guys as
3:19:56 you well know we're working on Eastland. We're at the south part we're starting
3:20:00 with all the part right now but I'm sure that's on radar to go through there
3:20:04 trying to create a uniform roadway throughout, but it'll be a few years before we get there, too.
3:20:08 So, at what point do we know what year that we're planning? Because, like you said, a road reaches a point where we know that we need to widen it, so we did the falls project.
3:20:20 At what point will we take on this Eastland project, and will that be in cooperation with the state because Eastland is a state highway?
3:20:30 Or what are the plans for that?
3:20:33 Jackie recently looked into that.
3:20:35 It's not in the state highway.
3:20:37 She looked at it for those federal dollars that she recently came for the mid-ad
3:20:38 to the sixth portion.
3:20:39 They liked to have destinations.
3:20:40 For the federal projects, you need to go from somewhere to somewhere.
3:20:43 We tried to say that the temple was a destination and we couldn't quite convince the feds
3:20:56 that that was a destination.
3:20:59 So they're probably not part of this.
3:21:01 So this would be pretty much funded by city dollars at that time.
3:21:04 As far as time frame, the property to the north and best of this, they're looking, we've
3:21:12 had interest in the developing around the YMCA and we're in discussions with them now.
3:21:17 So portions of that will be developed and if they develop, we'll probably encourage them
3:21:22 to talk to their neighbors and see if we can get one uniform road with you there because
3:21:26 we all see this beneficial, but we can't force them to widen that, nor these at this
3:21:31 time.
3:21:32 I think you, Troy, and then follow up for either Mitch or Travis.
3:21:37 On our transportation plan is the widening out of Eastland fully.
3:21:44 What type of priority is that in our planning documents?
3:21:52 Or is it on the horizon at all?
3:22:07 So, with our transportation planning, we don't have them listed out by priorities.
3:22:13 We did a couple of years ago approach a project on Eastland for widening in several sections
3:22:18 and backed off the widening and just did a surface replacement project in several cases
3:22:25 where widening wasn't an option due to a lack of ride-away with it, basically.
3:22:31 I will say that as we come around the corner over on the pole line section,
3:22:35 that piece of it I believe is included in our impact fee capital improvement plans now
3:22:41 And it's a piece that we can start spending some street impact fee dollars on and it's about a quarter-mile of
3:22:48 Of widening there, but that also will require right away acquisitions, and it's an expensive quarter-mile road
3:22:55 But that is one of four or five street projects that made it to the
3:23:00 to the street impact fee capital improvement plans list, so that's
3:23:06 It's not necessarily prioritized, but it's one of five projects that made it there
3:23:10 So in that sense, it's a fairly high priority right and then the those dollars expire in a certain time period
3:23:16 So we would spend them before they expire. Yeah, absolutely and but
3:23:23 that year that's like an eight-year window from the time they're collected and
3:23:28 We're pretty short on that right now. I mean we've only had that money in the bank for a
3:23:33 year or two, maybe
3:23:37 No, I'm good
3:23:42 I have a question, Jonathan, regarding the landscaping of parking lot, landscaping islands.
3:23:52 We had quite a conversation about that in Zolac when the old Zolac, is this the more
3:23:57 expanded landscaping islands or the little tiny ones that were put in some other parking
3:24:04 logs?
3:24:05 I believe these are going to meet what our current code says they're just going to do
3:24:08 more often.
3:24:09 Okay.
3:24:10 So tell me what the current code says.
3:24:12 The code takes a nine by 15, it might be eight,
3:24:17 it's something eight by 15, it's eight by 15, it's eight.
3:24:21 Different than those little triangles.
3:24:23 Yeah, I believe so.
3:24:23 Okay.
3:24:24 I think they're different.
3:24:26 Very good, that's the only question I have.
3:24:28 Does Council have any other questions
3:24:29 for the applicant or city staff
3:24:32 or any of the folks that testified this evening?
3:24:35 Okay, at this point I'm going to close public testimony
3:24:39 and questions to staff and Toronto Council
3:24:43 for deliberations.
3:24:44 Just real quick, Mitch, is this a up and down vote
3:24:49 and then bring back an ordinance?
3:24:51 Yeah, so we'll look for your direction
3:24:53 on whether to prepare an ordinance or not.
3:24:55 And with that, it's also a PUD,
3:24:58 so we'll bring back a PUD agreement as well.
3:25:01 So you have two things coming back to you.
3:25:03 Very good, Chris talking.
3:25:04 I would move to a proof annexation of the 40 acre
3:25:07 plus or minus parcel.
3:25:09 There's only district change in map
3:25:11 from R1 variable to C1PUD to allow the plan use
3:25:16 mix development compatible with the Infrid and Village
3:25:18 urban fill-in field designation as described
3:25:22 within Twin Falls City documents in 2030,
3:25:25 adding the requirement that the applicant
3:25:27 in Twin Falls City conduct a traffic study
3:25:31 and determine an appropriate pedestrian crossing
3:25:34 mountain view and pull line to be paid for by the applicant.
3:25:40 Do we need to add that there's an ordinance to bring back an ordinance?
3:25:43 Fritz, you want to add that?
3:25:45 What about the P and Z recommendations?
3:25:50 Do we need to add that, Fritz?
3:25:54 No, if I heard the staff recommendations and we will, if you vote positively,
3:25:58 we will bring back the ordinance and the PUD.
3:26:01 And don't ask me to repeat.
3:26:02 Okay, so second got it got a motion on floor by Chris talking and seconded by Greg
3:26:08 Lansing. And if you can't repeat it, I'm not going to Chris Schonberger can you
3:26:13 clarify whether the staff recommendations are included in that motion planning and
3:26:18 zoning commission recommendation.
3:26:20 That's why it's clarified.
3:26:24 That would be determined.
3:26:25 Thank you.
3:26:28 Rebecca Mills, so I can.
3:26:29 Thank you, Mayor, and then clarification on the pedestrian bicycle crossing.
3:26:34 Is that going to match the wording of what Fritz recommended for the crossing to be approved by the engineering department?
3:26:39 Okay, thank you.
3:26:43 That was affirmative as well, Suzanne Hawkins.
3:26:45 Thank you.
3:26:47 First of all, I do want to say that I do believe that the traffic in that area is definitely growing.
3:26:53 However, the condition of the roads outside this boundary is not this developer's responsibility.
3:27:00 And as much as we know, we need to start addressing some of that.
3:27:03 I really think that's a separate issue than what's being presented to us tonight.
3:27:07 And like to make sure we kind of clarify what they are responsible for and what they're not.
3:27:11 I know that this developer has worked tirelessly with the neighborhood and
3:27:17 has gone above and beyond to come up with something that will work for the neighbors as well as the city.
3:27:24 I think the property need, developing it is in our best interest.
3:27:28 It's part of our city, we're growing that direction.
3:27:30 And so for those reasons, I will be in support of this.
3:27:34 Sean Berger.
3:27:37 Thank you, Mayor.
3:27:38 I too would like to thank the developers of this property
3:27:41 for the patients you've had in, in,
3:27:44 raining in a little bit and going back through the process.
3:27:48 I'd also like to actually commend the neighbors
3:27:50 for the way that they've approached this.
3:27:52 Often we get these developments and everyone digs their heels
3:27:55 in at the beginning and even when there is a willingness
3:27:57 compromise, there's an unwillingness to compromise and it creates a lot of problems.
3:28:02 So I think that the neighbors have done a good job in working closely with the developers.
3:28:08 I do think this can be an attractive functional addition to that corridor that is going to
3:28:16 continue to develop.
3:28:19 Growth is somewhat inevitable along these corridors and yes, it brings with it challenges
3:28:24 and it brings with it opportunities for us to all work together to make those improvements.
3:28:29 When we talk about the challenges of traffic on Eastland, you know, a residential development
3:28:37 on this corner would have created all of that as well.
3:28:41 Cars are cars and they drive on roads and it's because we want to get from one place to the
3:28:44 other.
3:28:45 So we'll continue to look at those in our planning and try to figure out good solutions
3:28:50 to them but again I want to commend everyone for working through this and coming up with
3:28:56 a really positive addition for our community.
3:28:59 Thanks Sean.
3:29:00 I just want to add I agree with just everything which just said about the collaboration but
3:29:06 I think this is our first urban village, urban infill project?
3:29:11 We've had a couple of others come through but this one never-
3:29:16 That never comes to fruition at this level.
3:29:19 I'm not going to come to development yet.
3:29:21 So this may be one of the first ones to see some development.
3:29:24 I'm very excited about it.
3:29:25 I think our community needs this.
3:29:28 I'm a neighbor there, and I'm looking forward to it.
3:29:30 So you can't, yes, can't, can't, I'm sorry, sir,
3:29:38 but you can't at this point where we can't take any more
3:29:42 public testimony.
3:29:45 So Rebecca, so I go.
3:29:47 Thank you, Mayor.
3:29:48 I was at the original P&Z hearing as the liaison.
3:29:52 And so of course this is a great improvement over the original plan.
3:29:59 So I am in favor of it and I appreciate all of the work that you've done on it.
3:30:05 But I will approve it with two recommendations to city staff.
3:30:10 I think that we need to start prioritizing fully building out Eastland.
3:30:16 It's just a well traveled road.
3:30:18 We only have those three main north-south corridors, blue lakes, Washington, Eastland.
3:30:26 We need to start prioritizing the improvements that need to be made to that road and also
3:30:32 a recommendation for us to create guidelines and detailed zoning for urban, village, urban
3:30:42 I know that's something that we have planned to do and intended to do, but I would also recommend that that would be a high priority item because as these developments start to come through, we really want some guidelines and uniformity and our comprehensive plan instructs us to do so.
3:31:01 So thank you.
3:31:02 Thank you, Rebecca.
3:31:03 Anything further?
3:31:04 Leila roll call vote, please.
3:31:06 Jim?
3:31:08 Yes.
3:31:09 Sean Berrigger?
3:31:10 Yes.
3:31:11 Yes.
3:31:12 Yes.
3:31:13 Yes.
3:31:14 Yes.
3:31:15 Yes.
3:31:16 Yes.
3:31:17 Yes.
3:31:18 Yes.
3:31:19 Motion passes seven to zero.
3:31:20 Mr. Taylor, if you want to say something, I'll allow you to do so now.
3:31:23 If you'll need to go to the microphone, sir.
3:31:28 I would just suggest we put in a toll across the whole line and you put in your token.
3:31:37 I think that's a great idea.
3:31:39 don't tempt us and we will dedicate all the proceeds to the city. I like that even
3:31:45 better. Gary if you'd like to come forward real quick. Thank you very much.
3:31:51 I see major in the traffic is they only use one lane they use the inside lane
3:32:04 going and coming. They don't use maybe two or three out of 20 cars as you
3:32:12 follow them through and around. And I keep thinking that asphalt is going to die if we
3:32:19 don't get some traffic on it because it has to be built on. So maybe try to find a way
3:32:27 to get people to use both lanes and I think that will help close those gaps up a little
3:32:35 bit so people can get across.
3:32:37 Mr. Storey, from now on, I'm going to be driving the outside lane.
3:32:40 I'm having to identify himself, don't happen to identify himself.
3:32:43 Mr. Starr, could you say your name and your address real quick sir?
3:32:48 Gary Starr at 1042 Wildwood Way when involved.
3:32:53 Thank you, Mr. Starr.
3:32:54 Thank you.
3:32:55 Moving on to the next item is discussion and possible action on the citizen city facility committee recommendations to acquire the Banner Furniture Building on Main Street.
3:33:08 transform the existing city hall and police station into a public safety complex and to use unrestricted cash reserves to pay for the project.
3:33:17 Before we get started on this item, I do want to talk to the audience.
3:33:22 I know this is brought up a lot of real strong feelings on both sides of this equation.
3:33:27 I would ask for proper decorum this evening at the council meeting.
3:33:32 I know that people will be coming up and making comments.
3:33:36 If you agree with that comment, the best thing you can do is be silent.
3:33:40 Sometimes people's passion get out of their way and they might applaud or something like
3:33:47 that.
3:33:48 That's absolutely in my opinion the wrong thing to do and it shows a disrespect for folks
3:33:53 that might have an opposite view.
3:33:55 So I would just ask that we just have a good decorum tonight and a positive meeting.
3:34:02 With that, I'm going to kind of line out how we're going to run this meeting this evening.
3:34:06 We've had a citizens committee that has met and deliberated and looked at information and
3:34:13 then they are bringing us a recommendation.
3:34:15 Out of that committee, there were three co-chairs.
3:34:18 I'm going to first ask those three co-chairs to come forward and spend about 15 minutes
3:34:24 between the three of them and give us the recommendation and or any other thoughts that
3:34:29 might be on their minds, but keep that at about 15 minutes.
3:34:33 The next person that I'm going to ask to come forward
3:34:36 is Mr. Eric Wadi.
3:34:38 And allow him a few minutes to make his presentation.
3:34:41 I know he wasn't able to make his presentation the other night
3:34:45 or the other day at the Citizens Committee.
3:34:48 And so I think it's appropriate for Mr. Wadi to come forward.
3:34:52 I also reached out to Mr. Kramer, Commissioner Kramer,
3:34:56 and he declined to come this evening,
3:34:58 gave me some really good information,
3:35:00 but I will add that we do have Commissioner Mills
3:35:03 in the audience, so there could be some questions
3:35:05 directed to Commissioner Mills,
3:35:06 because I know there were some questions regarding
3:35:08 why the county did this,
3:35:10 or why the county went whatever direction.
3:35:14 Mr. Kramer, Commissioner Kramer did give me some
3:35:16 indication regarding some of those questions as well.
3:35:19 So, Mr. Wadi, and then next I'm going to allow
3:35:24 the Citizens Committee, those that were on the actual
3:35:27 Committee to come forward if they would like to speak.
3:35:30 We'll give you one or two minutes.
3:35:32 I'm going to treat this very similar to a public hearing
3:35:34 and bring you forward and allow you to speak first.
3:35:38 And then we're going to open it up to the general public.
3:35:41 The reason that I'd like to do this is I think maybe
3:35:43 that process might answer some of the questions
3:35:46 that the general public might have
3:35:48 that they didn't have access to.
3:35:50 So I think that's probably the best way
3:35:51 that we can do this the fairest way.
3:35:53 So at this time, we're going to ask the three co-chairs
3:36:00 to come forward, Greg Polson, Gary Garnan, and Jill Scheme,
3:36:04 and allow you to have the podium.
3:36:07 Rebecca?
3:36:08 I'm sure at the best.
3:36:11 [Muted for privacy: street address]
3:36:12 [Muted for privacy: street address]
3:36:15 [Muted for privacy: street address]
3:36:17 First of all, on behalf of the 22 citizens of the Burundas
3:36:22 Committee, we want to thank the City Council
3:36:24 for allowing our input.
3:36:27 While we don't all agree, we do have,
3:36:31 we were privileged to be part of the process.
3:36:34 So we hope that as I'm going to give you
3:36:36 a brief background of where we went on the process,
3:36:40 Greg will have more information,
3:36:42 and Jill will have information as well.
3:36:44 So we've had our first meeting,
3:36:47 and in that first meeting, the first motion that was made
3:36:52 was that we needed a city hall, a new one.
3:36:56 That was the first one, it passed unanimously,
3:36:58 if I remember correctly.
3:37:00 The second motion was that it be in the city core,
3:37:06 in the original Twin Falls town site.
3:37:09 That also passed.
3:37:11 From then on out, we had discussions on various sites
3:37:15 and so on.
3:37:16 The city had originally started with 11 potential sites.
3:37:20 They had narrowed it down some,
3:37:22 And Travis gave us specific instructions.
3:37:26 First, you all wanted us to make a recommendation
3:37:31 of the best site.
3:37:33 Second, the funding mechanism.
3:37:36 So we did that.
3:37:37 The next thing we did is we narrowed it down to three sites,
3:37:41 the Latham property on second,
3:37:44 the Banner building and the clinic.
3:37:47 After serious discussion, we eliminated the Latham property
3:37:52 because of potential hidden costs that we weren't aware of.
3:37:57 In the process, we also had a climp from Hummel Cum
3:38:01 who's who you hired to do some evaluations.
3:38:05 Now, he gave us numbers to work.
3:38:09 Are those numbers correct?
3:38:11 We don't know, but his firm is a professional.
3:38:16 So we do know that they use the same program
3:38:20 throughout their entire process of evaluating these properties and the cost.
3:38:26 So therefore we use their numbers as a base.
3:38:30 You won't know the real cost of this project until you get the bids in.
3:38:37 It could be lower, it could be higher.
3:38:40 We used Clint's numbers.
3:38:45 The other thing we did is we said this had to be run with Fritzes oversight on a parliamentary
3:38:53 procedure.
3:38:54 So we did that.
3:38:56 And so we had lots of discussion.
3:38:59 We had six meetings and they were all at least an hour and a half long.
3:39:03 So every member of this committee gave a fair amount of their time not to mention the time
3:39:09 that they researched their own information.
3:39:12 There was also a meeting in which we did a tour of all three sites.
3:39:17 And there was time before we even started the committee process that we toured sites.
3:39:23 So we felt like that we had a pretty good grasp of what potential sites were.
3:39:31 We had Travis tell us when we assumed that the base this off of your five year plus
3:39:40 strategic plan plus history that you needed plan on two people per year at 400
3:39:47 square foot per people for offices for the 200 per person. If that is the case, the
3:39:55 banner building ultimately would give you 30 plus years of growth. The clinic would
3:40:01 give you 100 years of growth. Those were our two my final decisions is where we
3:40:09 were going to go. In that process, we had a motion made to limit to just the two buildings.
3:40:18 That passed 17 to 5. The second motion that came up was to do the banner building. That
3:40:27 motion was, then there was another motion while that was being discussed to suspend the discussion
3:40:35 and have a table that allowed Eric and Terry to talk.
3:40:43 That motion was seconded, but it failed 15 to 7.
3:40:49 The next motion was then we passed the motion to do the banner building at 17 to 5
3:40:56 in the vote of the committee.
3:40:58 Then we had a motion to how to pay for this.
3:41:03 this. And after discussions with Lori,
3:41:07 Reyes, and Travis, we came to the conclusion that there was a motion made, I
3:41:13 should say, to have you do this out of your surplus funds, the $13 million. We
3:41:20 figured that this would probably the banner building would be about a total of
3:41:24 $7 million. That included the $2.3 million to remodel the existing city hall for
3:41:30 public safety, the purchase of the banner building, and Hummel's estimate of $4.5 million
3:41:38 to do the remodel of the banner building.
3:41:41 So we recommended that we voted for that and that's what we came up with.
3:41:47 The bottom line is your citizens committee recommends that you buy the banner building,
3:41:56 remodel it, and pay for it out of the surplus money.
3:42:00 Thank you, Mr. Barnan.
3:42:02 Rebecca, do you have a question?
3:42:04 I do have a question for Gary real quickly.
3:42:07 Just on your process, I wasn't able to make every meeting,
3:42:10 but I made the three meetings where you had a discussion,
3:42:12 and then you voted at the beginning of the December 11th
3:42:17 meeting, but I did have a question on your agenda.
3:42:21 There seemed to take an abrupt change in process
3:42:25 from the December 4th meeting to the December 11th meeting,
3:42:28 where you sat up front and you started to do roll call votes and you started to invoke
3:42:33 Robert's rules.
3:42:34 I was just wondering, in the December 4th meeting, there was some questions as to they need more
3:42:40 information from Eric Wadi and from maybe more accurate numbers on the clinic and some information
3:42:47 from the county because according to the December 4th minutes on page 3, Hummel did speculate
3:42:54 on why the county didn't go into the clinic.
3:42:58 So my question is just on the procedure, you know, you put these people on your agenda,
3:43:04 you invited them to come and then you didn't allow them to speak.
3:43:08 And so could you speak to that abrupt change in procedure and why that was done?
3:43:15 We used the format that Fridge Wonder, Lick, recommended based on the open meeting law and
3:43:21 proper procedure.
3:43:23 Prior to that, we had just had people sitting out in the audience, we had no real good way
3:43:28 of knowing who was on the committee, who was voting, who wasn't. So we moved the entire
3:43:33 committee up here, the three co-chairs set here, and in a meeting prior to the open meeting,
3:43:44 I guess it was determined that it was because of my experience on urban renewal, whatever,
3:43:48 I had more experience in parliamentary procedure than the other two co-chairs. And so that was
3:43:53 why we did that. As far as the question about why people were not included or not included,
3:44:03 all I can say is we had a, we did parliamentary procedure, we did it in order that it was the
3:44:11 motions were made, and as far as the chairs were concerned, we had no, we did not direct
3:44:17 either any of those comments or those things.
3:44:21 The only change we made was based on Fritz's recommendation
3:44:25 for the open meeting was.
3:44:27 As far as an individual member of the committee making
3:44:30 a motion being seconded, we had open discussion and so on.
3:44:35 So we just followed those kind of rules.
3:44:39 OK, so in that recommendation came at your last meeting.
3:44:44 Yeah, maybe I can explain a little more.
3:44:47 I can't remember if you were at the meeting before the one that ran until two o'clock.
3:44:53 About one thirty or so, yeah.
3:44:54 December 4th, is that where?
3:44:57 Previous meeting ran until I think it did run until two o'clock.
3:45:02 It was running so late that members were leaving because they had appointments to go to.
3:45:07 They did not get the chance to establish an agenda for the next meeting.
3:45:13 So the co-chairmen talked about what the agenda should be, and I don't think there was an agreement
3:45:18 among the co-chairmen about what the agenda should be.
3:45:22 And so it was decided at the beginning of the meeting that the committee should vote on
3:45:27 what the agenda should be on the last meeting.
3:45:33 And that's as far as they got.
3:45:34 And I think if you were there, you heard them vote that that's the way they wanted to proceed.
3:45:40 So I think the problem was is the committee itself did not create that agenda.
3:45:51 Not yet.
3:45:52 So it was, I agree with you, it was confusing, but it was like, there was no committee created
3:46:00 agenda, and like I said before, in talking to the co-chairman, there wasn't even an agreement
3:46:07 on what the agenda ought to be.
3:46:10 Did we give them at the outset, like at the beginning of the committee, did we give them the proper procedure for creating their agenda?
3:46:17 Or is it just were there complications in them not knowing?
3:46:21 We pretty much tried to let them run themselves, but we were running into complications.
3:46:27 And so we did try to step in to get it a little bit more organized because there were a couple of meetings that you saw when you were there.
3:46:34 They were kind of disorganized.
3:46:37 did at the last meeting require all the members. If you're going to be on the committee member,
3:46:41 you're sitting up here so everybody, the co-chairmen and the committee members could see each other
3:46:46 before that they had their backs to, the chairmen had their backs to the members. And it wasn't
3:46:54 always clear we had, you probably saw, we tried to have signs on one side where the committee
3:47:00 members were supposed to sit and they weren't necessarily doing that so it was a little confusing.
3:47:05 We had some speakers and it wasn't clear whether they were speaking as a committee member or
3:47:10 as part of the public, so we reorganized that.
3:47:13 So we knew exactly who the committee was.
3:47:16 The committee could see the chairman, the chairman could see the committee, they could talk to each other.
3:47:21 And then we asked them to require the committee itself to determine how they would proceed.
3:47:28 Okay, thank you for that clarification and thank you, Gary, for providing that information.
3:47:34 I just was puzzled in watching the transformation of the committee and maybe in the future we
3:47:38 can just provide that guidance and expectations on the front end because I don't think it's
3:47:43 anyone's fault that there was confusion.
3:47:46 I'll just speak to that.
3:47:49 We are going to do things differently in the future.
3:47:51 We learn some very valuable, valuable lessons through this process.
3:47:56 I want to make sure that we're trying to stay within the 15 minutes.
3:47:59 The questions that are asked of folks will not be counted against your 15 minutes.
3:48:05 So how much time do we have left?
3:48:08 Mr. Polson, I think you're next.
3:48:12 Great, Paulson from 2301, Settlers Lane in Twin Falls.
3:48:18 So first of all, I was a novice and committed to this committee and
3:48:22 apologized for not running it as well.
3:48:25 It was kind of a learning process and I appreciate everybody's patience.
3:48:28 also appreciate the council for involving the citizens
3:48:35 in going through this process.
3:48:36 It was very enjoyable and educational
3:48:39 and I feel good about the decision that was made.
3:48:42 Gary talked a little bit about the process
3:48:45 and the committee as a whole.
3:48:47 The committee votes and makes their decisions
3:48:50 and they all have their own reasons.
3:48:53 We did spend six meetings.
3:48:55 The meetings I estimated there was at least 11 hours
3:48:57 meetings-ish and then in addition we were given a lot of materials to follow through
3:49:03 and to work through. So each member has their own reasons for why we chose the
3:49:10 Vanderbilt building. I was going to just briefly go over my reasons as to why I
3:49:15 believe it was a good building. The first thing that I would comment on is
3:49:20 through the looking at the existing sites where the city is working right now
3:49:26 Now, that was very eye-opening, I feel, and I got a lot of respect for the city.
3:49:33 They have, in my opinion, really utilized the space that they've been given.
3:49:38 Those buildings, some of them were built in 1943, and through the Hanson edition, we've
3:49:45 gotten a lot of usage out of those buildings.
3:49:47 However, you know, my heart goes out for some of those people.
3:49:51 The police in particular, that building is pretty cramped.
3:49:54 And I think that it was very unanimous that we could see the importance of addressing this
3:50:00 issue when we examined those buildings.
3:50:04 I could spend a lot of time on my, you know, some of the things that I saw there, but I don't
3:50:07 know that we have the time.
3:50:09 So but I would like to say that I think everybody is, I think most of the people feel very strongly
3:50:14 that something needs to be done and we appreciate involving the citizens and doing this the way
3:50:20 it's been done.
3:50:21 I think it's a neat process.
3:50:23 Number two is we spent a lot of time in meetings and going over numbers and things like that.
3:50:30 The numbers are what they are, they need to be debated, but I feel that they're one of
3:50:36 the things that came about that I strongly agree with is you look at buying a new building
3:50:42 versus one of the existing buildings.
3:50:45 I don't want to say that I'm cheap or anything like that, but it appears that there's a substantial
3:50:51 savings by going with an existing building.
3:50:56 From what Clint said, we're looking at almost a dollar
3:50:59 a square foot, which in this case could be millions of dollars
3:51:03 if one of these buildings that exists already works for us.
3:51:07 So the next kind of the bullet point that I would make that
3:51:10 was part of my decision was, hey, let's take a hard look
3:51:13 and see if one of the existing buildings works.
3:51:17 The next thing was what is the size that is needed for the building and that was something
3:51:24 that we did quite a bit of time debating on.
3:51:27 We were given guidance from the city that we needed approximately 45,000 square feet or
3:51:34 40,000 square feet and we spent a lot of time going, well, how can we rely on that?
3:51:41 Can we not rely on that?
3:51:43 And so I would like to point back to the December 4th meeting and in the minutes of those meetings, we talked about doing an in-depth study and we asked Clant flat out, would you recommend a needs program prior to purchasing a building?
3:51:59 Clint said he didn't believe there was, there is a need for the program now.
3:52:04 The city is currently utilizing about 20,000 square foot and therefore is safe to assume the clinic building and banner building.
3:52:12 a common city hall offices and it could be laid out of floor plan. The space needs
3:52:17 program does not mean to be done to know that the buildings are big enough. So
3:52:22 that's the information we got from the architect. Also he said we said well it's
3:52:28 big enough now is it always going to be big enough? And he said well Clint said
3:52:33 by estimating the square footage for two people a year it was estimated that it
3:52:39 It would take 30 to 40 years for the city to grow into the smaller of the two buildings.
3:52:45 So when you look at the size, that was a determining factor, in my opinion, which meant that both
3:52:53 buildings of the used had enough space.
3:52:56 Then you look at what can you do with these buildings to design-wise?
3:52:59 The buildings are very different, other than just the size.
3:53:02 You look at the openness and you look at the design of the buildings.
3:53:08 Because I had, you know, we've got numerous illustrations, and I don't know if we had
3:53:16 this little project.
3:53:17 This was an illustration that passed out of the Hanabot.
3:53:22 During our tour of the clinic by Eric, and my thoughts on this are, when you look at
3:53:31 the existing way that the city's being ran, it was designed in 43, then we added the hands
3:53:38 building. As a result of that, not everything is like nobody had an opportunity to say this
3:53:43 is the way for the city to work. This this function should be next to this function next
3:53:48 to this function. And the banner building is fairly wide open. And my understanding is that
3:53:57 the red walls in the clinic which was built to be a clinic, even though the clinic is
3:54:03 It's a wonderful building and it has its own virtue for sure.
3:54:07 Those walls are not movable.
3:54:09 So I think if we wanted to give a clean slate, you know, space to the city and say, build the city how you want,
3:54:16 that there's a lot to be said for the Vanderbilt building and that's part of my, you know, and I did appreciate the clinic as well,
3:54:22 but I feel that at the end of the day, I like the open space and the ability to give the city the ability to build the building that they'd like.
3:54:32 And so that was part of my logic and the other people have great logic as well.
3:54:36 Thank you, Mr. Paulson.
3:54:37 Mrs. Keats, you're up.
3:54:43 Thank you for letting me speak tonight.
3:54:45 When I started this process, I thought it would be a fair and transparent process.
3:54:52 And I know people say I'm talking in the minority of what happened on the committee.
3:54:57 However, there really wasn't a minority dissension as much as need for more information.
3:55:05 And that's what the committee members wanted.
3:55:07 And all along in this process, when we came up with our agenda,
3:55:12 we would email, or Leila would initiate what's your agenda.
3:55:16 We would email what was going to happen.
3:55:19 And then we would work on it.
3:55:20 This last meeting, after the last meeting,
3:55:24 I was approached by several committee members
3:55:27 asking if Terry Kramer could,
3:55:30 someone from the county could be here.
3:55:31 So I asked Terry Kramer.
3:55:33 And then also the numbers for the clinic,
3:55:36 if they were up to date, Eric Wadi and his architect,
3:55:39 we're gonna present current numbers
3:55:41 because the numbers that we had were from 2008
3:55:44 and based on the county using that building.
3:55:48 So in addition to the parking study,
3:55:52 the Thursday before the meeting,
3:55:54 I actually, the December 4th meeting,
3:55:56 I contacted Mandy Roberts from OTAC
3:55:58 and said I understand you have a parking study coming out.
3:56:02 And is there any information that we should give to our committee this week?
3:56:07 And she said, well, Travis, although I know there's a dispute, but this is what she told me,
3:56:12 Travis said I'll be on your agenda next week.
3:56:17 I'll be presenting at your meeting next week, which was December 11th.
3:56:21 The co-chairs weren't told about this.
3:56:25 So I assume someone put her on the agenda, although she really wasn't on the agenda.
3:56:29 And then we added her to the agenda.
3:56:31 But I guess Andy, what is it, Del, Deladin from Kittleson?
3:56:35 I'm not sure his name.
3:56:36 Was supposed to be on the phone.
3:56:39 I guess I have a question.
3:56:40 Was Andy ever on the phone?
3:56:42 Was he?
3:56:43 No one acknowledged Andy or heard or whatever.
3:56:46 But the part that was disturbing to me
3:56:49 is when we went back and forth with the agenda items,
3:56:52 I emailed Greg and Gary and said,
3:56:55 these are the people that are going to present.
3:56:57 They then came back and said, I want to do a discussion prior
3:57:00 I didn't understand that because to me, why not do a discussion after you have all the information.
3:57:05 This is a big purchase by the city of Twin.
3:57:08 It's supposed to be for their taxpayers.
3:57:11 How can you not let people present current information?
3:57:14 I mean, if you make a loan from a bank, you would want current numbers, not from six-year-old numbers or six-year-old information.
3:57:21 And it was very disturbing that the vote happened at the top of the agenda and blocked our presenters from presenting.
3:57:29 of the members tonight from the committee refused to come
3:57:32 because he is so embarrassed how we treated presenters
3:57:35 and invited them prepared and did not let him speak
3:57:38 at a meeting and he felt that we were rude
3:57:42 and we're embarrassed and didn't want to show up
3:57:44 at this meeting tonight.
3:57:45 I felt the same way.
3:57:46 I felt like the process was hijacked.
3:57:49 I felt like we needed more information
3:57:51 to make a huge decision like this.
3:57:53 This is $7 million at the minimum
3:57:55 that taxpayers have to pay.
3:57:57 And also, it's not for city employees.
3:58:00 The city hall will be here beyond you all when you come and go.
3:58:04 It's for the taxpayers.
3:58:06 And to be honest, since this decision was in the paper,
3:58:10 I have not heard from one citizen who said, wow,
3:58:13 that's great, the banner building.
3:58:14 They have said to me, there's no parking.
3:58:17 It's inaccessible.
3:58:18 And what's wrong with the old clinic?
3:58:22 And I thought the process was not what I thought there would be.
3:58:26 I think the rules changed constantly.
3:58:29 So anyway, I was disappointed with how it felt
3:58:32 and a few of the committee members felt like they
3:58:36 wasted their time.
3:58:37 They were used by the city and said they would never volunteer
3:58:41 for anything again.
3:58:42 And so if that's how the process works,
3:58:44 I don't think it was effective for citizens
3:58:49 if you want them to volunteer to do this again.
3:58:51 I feel the same way.
3:58:53 And, you know, it's more than just location.
3:58:56 Some people say it was just location.
3:58:58 Well, if the buildings were equal, then it's location.
3:59:01 But the buildings are not equal.
3:59:03 And I felt like we should have had the information
3:59:06 being able to discuss it, not hijack the process,
3:59:09 vote before three people were supposed to present.
3:59:12 I mean, we had parking issues downtown.
3:59:13 There was a parking study.
3:59:15 Wouldn't it have been viable for the committee to hear
3:59:18 any kind of parking solutions?
3:59:20 At one point, someone in our meeting said,
3:59:22 But no, the Rogers and Building, you could park there.
3:59:24 But then we found out that URA is going to make it into a plaza.
3:59:29 Well, you know what?
3:59:30 Maybe we should have gotten more information.
3:59:32 I was told I could gather any information I could.
3:59:35 Travis told me that.
3:59:36 I did.
3:59:37 I gathered a 2005 Space Needs Assessment.
3:59:40 I still believe the city should be doing that in this process right now to know exactly how much space they need.
3:59:47 And Travis also told us we had as much time as we needed.
3:59:50 She said that a few times to this committee, we were never told the deadline was tonight.
3:59:56 And I don't think the process was one that I would ever want to see repeated or be part
4:00:01 of again along with a few other people on the committee.
4:00:04 And that's how I feel about this.
4:00:08 So thank you very much.
4:00:10 Thank you, Ms. King.
4:00:12 Next person that I'd like to call up is Mr. Wadi.
4:00:15 And Eric, we talked short on the presentation, sir, if you could.
4:00:20 You need to put anything on the overhead for folks to see?
4:00:23 Oh, ladies and gentlemen, while we hand this stuff out, it's been requested of me that
4:00:30 we take a potty break.
4:00:33 Why?
4:05:17 We are reconvening the City Council meeting, and we have Mr. Wadi.
4:05:20 The floor is yours, sir.
4:05:22 Okay, thank you.
4:05:23 Thank you, City Council.
4:05:26 Thank you for allowing me to bring some information and provide some additional information.
4:05:36 Thank you.
4:05:37 A couple of comments, these are some slides, I guess I have a copy of them.
4:05:42 But we have an opportunity here, what are we comparing this stuff to?
4:05:47 Right now as we speak, we have an excellent example if we look out at County West.
4:05:52 They took a great big building of approximately 250,000 square feet,
4:05:57 is over three times the size of this clinic building, and they converted it to a one-stop
4:06:03 shop for its citizens. I'd like you to go over there and take a walk and look around, like
4:06:09 I'm sure a lot of you have done. I've done that in the ballpark of $60 a square foot.
4:06:16 A lot of the concerns and obstacles that have been presented regarding the clinic building
4:06:22 have already been addressed out there.
4:06:25 Sinks, pipes, extra space, things of that nature.
4:06:31 Here's for example, the extra space out there
4:06:34 that the county brings in.
4:06:37 Commissioner Kramer told me about a million dollars a year
4:06:40 in revenue for they rent out extra space.
4:06:42 It's about 50 cents a foot a month.
4:06:45 If the city would get this building,
4:06:48 maybe they don't wanna be landlords.
4:06:50 I don't blame them.
4:06:52 They could put out an immediate call to all agencies, schools, parks, recreation, fire,
4:06:57 police, police, who doesn't need some extra space?
4:07:00 Training, seminars, how about an in-house fitness center?
4:07:04 Employee daycare, unused space in the building, that was a big issue.
4:07:10 What do you do with the extra space?
4:07:12 Well, an idea that I have had the building over here.
4:07:16 There's a lot of large sealed doors already in places
4:07:21 that you could cordon off certain sections of the area.
4:07:24 It has only controlled HVAC that can very safely
4:07:29 and economically be controlled.
4:07:31 And you hold that space till it's needed.
4:07:35 Also, the presenter that I brought last week was a local architect
4:07:39 here in town for many, many years.
4:07:41 And he told me he has knowledge of this building.
4:07:44 It's of an A-type building construction.
4:07:47 It's built to the highest standards available, FYI.
4:07:52 The replacement cost on this building is in the range of $16 million.
4:07:57 The existing infrastructure is something that I don't believe has been brought forward.
4:08:02 Phones, fiber optic, backup generator system, three elevators,
4:08:07 suited for all ADA needs, drive-on, and drop-off zones for public transportation.
4:08:15 to come. Security, it's a big issue for a lot of people in buildings these days. It'd be
4:08:21 easily retrofitted for safety doors. Storage is doing all the tours around town and the
4:08:27 different agencies. This facility has a halo and fire suppression system. In addition to
4:08:32 the sprinklers and the fire escapes, also an FCC tower. So to kind of wrap this thing
4:08:39 If you guys, let's just say, for example, you need 25,000 square feet, take the bottom floor that would facilitate the immediate needs.
4:08:49 All offices, council chambers, offices for council members, drive up window, go pay your water bill, a lot of meetings, storage room.
4:09:02 And this is where the information kind of got a little convoluted, you know, using $50, $60 a foot,
4:09:09 versus 106 to 112, there's some big swings.
4:09:14 And make an assessment of what really needs to be done.
4:09:18 I'm advocating a lot of this building is moving ready.
4:09:21 Some of it may need some room.
4:09:23 So instead of talking seven to 10 million,
4:09:28 purchase price of 27, I know from the private sector what 100,000 will do.
4:09:33 What 250,000 will do.
4:09:35 Those are things that need to really be looked at too.
4:09:40 Much of the bottom floor, I believe is moving ready, offices.
4:09:44 Some of it may be just need some cosmetic work.
4:09:48 But again, a great testimony is out there right now, live and relevant at County West.
4:09:53 Look what they've done for $60 a square foot.
4:09:56 I had some quotes from some local people.
4:09:58 We were contemplating a motel and a boutique store.
4:10:02 And I got quotes in the $40 to $60 a range.
4:10:05 not the 103, not the 116,000.
4:10:08 In the information that was presented to the committee,
4:10:12 the committee did what the best they could
4:10:15 with what they had to feed on,
4:10:17 but it was based upon a complete gut out and remodel.
4:10:21 That's where a lot of this deal got crazy.
4:10:23 It was built based on a whole gut out and remodel.
4:10:29 So by phasing in this building as the needs present itself,
4:10:35 into the future you're always going to be relevant to meet the needs of your
4:10:40 citizens
4:10:41 you'll never be outdated you'll never outgrow your building again
4:10:45 uh... so
4:10:48 i've taken the tours
4:10:50 i've seen the cramp people
4:10:52 lack of meeting space lack of storage for space
4:10:55 uh... buildings scattered around town
4:10:59 uh... and really consider this is a one-stop shop
4:11:02 It will meet the current and the long-term needs more efficiently and economically than
4:11:08 the other options presented.
4:11:11 So the current runs out, parking, some issues there that's already there, correct.
4:11:22 I can just kind of flip through those.
4:11:25 Ready to go offices.
4:11:26 If I was doing plans, I'd love to roll them out on that big table right there.
4:11:29 Look out at the park, go have my lunch, listen to the band, full generator power, backup
4:11:35 records, close to downtown, natural light, room for town for chambers, nice common foyer area,
4:11:44 you know, they're 70 to 100 offices just like that. I asked the guys at the county, they had 100
4:11:50 sinks, that was a big deal, I looked at the sinks, you know, it took them two days in some sawsalls
4:11:54 and they cut them out, that was it, it was over with. Zonal heating and cooling throughout,
4:12:00 you can set that very economically, you can mothball any portion of that building that
4:12:05 that you want to, were you going to go buy a building anywhere for $30 a square foot of
4:12:09 this quality?
4:12:10 It's not happening.
4:12:11 Full of commercial kitchen, all the lunches that we've eaten here through weeks and months,
4:12:17 I mean, look at the city spends, they could do that, could use that plug in and play,
4:12:22 I've had two cafes, that's $100,000 with equipment.
4:12:25 Okay, oop, clock and gas.
4:12:30 So anyway, what do you do with the extra space?
4:12:33 I touched on some of those.
4:12:35 or some ideas, but the main takeaway council is they were basing it upon $100 plus a square
4:12:42 foot. We're saying the closer average is maybe 50, maybe 60 down in that range. Consider it,
4:12:48 this is a long-term deal. Whoever says, geez, I can't use the extra space. You need the
4:12:55 extra storage. They'll grow into it. It's a century building right there. And maybe the
4:13:01 the last one now. The pros on the sides move in ready, minimal improvements, ample parking,
4:13:10 file and document stations, good grief. I was in the basement of the building department.
4:13:14 They got 100 year old records just rotten in the mold down there. It's not good. ADA compliant,
4:13:21 ready to go. It's a current and active building. It won't have an effect on Main Street commerce.
4:13:28 Parking will come off. The guy that wants to go buy a guitar or watch battery, he's not
4:13:32 I'm going to be waiting, you know, have his space taken by the guy once Bezwaterville.
4:13:37 Conveniently located, the fiber optic feeds PMT told me that the new hospital is the only
4:13:44 one in town that has more capacity than this.
4:13:48 Easily segregated.
4:13:49 What do we do with the extra space?
4:13:51 Easily segregated.
4:13:52 What are you going to buy for $30 a square foot?
4:13:56 Look at this.
4:13:57 replacement costs, $16 million, the certified ADA elevators, and something we could talk
4:14:05 about is some possible, assuming low assumption financing from the county.
4:14:14 Anyway, any questions?
4:14:17 If we don't have any questions right now, Eric, please stand by and we'll have some, right?
4:14:20 It looks like we do have one.
4:14:22 Sean Barrett.
4:14:23 Alright, so Eric, thank you for the information.
4:14:25 So, so did you, is this the information that you shared with the committee when you gave the tour of the clinic building?
4:14:32 Did you go through all this kind of information with the tour?
4:14:38 Not with this great detail, no not with this great detail because I was, I was, the attorney said I can't, you know, talk about, you know, to present the thing and that was part of the delay in getting, you know, this information.
4:14:54 But the short answer is yes, I provided a lot of this.
4:14:57 This is a different slide presentation than I had.
4:15:00 That's the same kind of information.
4:15:01 This would be a small place.
4:15:02 You can move all your facilities here.
4:15:04 Yeah, right.
4:15:05 Stop, stop.
4:15:06 Did you have the cost information
4:15:07 when you presented that information to the committee?
4:15:10 Yes, I did.
4:15:11 Yeah, I did.
4:15:13 Not to the exact, but the main thrust of it was this.
4:15:16 A lot of this is moving ready.
4:15:19 That was instead of just going out and spending, boom,
4:15:22 $100 and some dollars a foot, 60,000 square feet.
4:15:26 I was saying, hey, let's just slow down,
4:15:28 take a deep breath and phase into this building.
4:15:30 A lot of it's moving already.
4:15:32 That was your trust.
4:15:33 So from this presentation tonight,
4:15:36 what new information are you providing
4:15:39 that was providing more information for the committee?
4:15:42 Right, well, where's that one?
4:15:45 The summary that was provided.
4:15:46 Did you have that summary in the business?
4:15:49 Yeah.
4:15:50 Well, the summary showed that my building
4:15:53 was going to be $10 million or something like that.
4:15:56 I'm saying it would be in the low billion.
4:15:58 So that was the information from the architects.
4:15:59 What I'm saying is what new information
4:16:01 are you presenting that you hadn't presented
4:16:03 to the committee previously?
4:16:05 Right here.
4:16:06 And to take a look at what the county did out there
4:16:09 in a similar type building, that's
4:16:11 what I'm presenting.
4:16:13 Maybe that makes sense.
4:16:15 Well, I mean, I think part of the rationale
4:16:18 for having this lengthier discussion tonight
4:16:20 was that there was information that the committee didn't have the opportunity to hear.
4:16:26 So I'm asking if you're presenting different information and new information that the committee
4:16:30 didn't have.
4:16:31 Yeah, $100 a square foot, time 40, 50, 60,000 square foot versus $50 a square foot.
4:16:38 Here's a big swing.
4:16:40 That's the main difference.
4:16:41 So the cost difference?
4:16:42 Cost big though.
4:16:43 Yes.
4:16:44 Not draining, having to use up a bunch of city cash.
4:16:46 You know, two, seven with some consumable out-of-pocket cash to see if you can maybe get in this for a million and a half.
4:16:53 And be operating soon, seamlessly.
4:16:56 Thank you.
4:16:57 Okay.
4:16:58 Do we have any other questions for Mr. Wadi?
4:17:02 I see none.
4:17:03 Thank you, Eric, and we might be calling you back for some questions.
4:17:06 Okay.
4:17:07 The other person that was on the agenda for the committee was Commissioner Kramer.
4:17:14 Commissioner Kramer, I did talk to him today and he told me he wasn't so much going to make a presentation to your committee
4:17:21 But be there for Q&A really is what he was there and he shared some information with me
4:17:26 But again
4:17:27 We have a commissioner in the audience that would be much better at answering questions this evening to the council if you did have specific questions
4:17:34 Regarding the clinics or the county's decision that I Leon you'd be more than willing to come forward when you we had some questions
4:17:40 Thank you. So I just want to make that aware or make the council aware of that. Next, I would like to open it up for a minute to
4:17:49 minutes a piece for actual committee members that served on the committee. Not public at large. We'll give you some time
4:17:58 towards the end, but the committee members. And I have a list of those committee members and I have a list of a few folks
4:18:06 folks that signed up. So maybe I'll start there. If you're in, is there still a signup
4:18:10 sheet in the back? If, if, as we're going through this process, if you would sign up
4:18:15 in the back, if you haven't signed up yet, and then if you put a C next to your name so
4:18:20 I know that you're a committee member, that'll help guide me this evening. So with that being
4:18:24 said, I'm going to start bringing up some of the committee members first, and I believe
4:18:30 I'm looking here.
4:18:31 Daphne, were you on the Daphne Mallory?
4:18:34 I'm going to bring you up first.
4:18:36 Oh, Helen, I'll get out on it.
4:18:41 Welcome, Daphne.
4:18:43 Thank you so much.
4:18:45 Two things about the process that I think you should consider
4:18:49 as you make your decision.
4:18:51 One, the conflict of interest was presented to us,
4:18:55 and it was presented in terms of business interests, those
4:18:59 who might have an interest in the commercial problem.
4:19:02 However, I think in hindsight, it should have been expanded
4:19:07 to those already involved in downtown and other related
4:19:11 projects.
4:19:12 The reason being as just an ordinary citizen,
4:19:16 mom in the community, my information
4:19:19 was limited strictly to the committee and what was presented.
4:19:23 But what appeared to me in hindsight
4:19:25 is that people had a lot more information
4:19:28 beyond the scope of the committee.
4:19:30 And they were more confident in their decision making and recommendations as a result.
4:19:35 And so I think in terms of future committees that that conflict of interest really does need
4:19:42 to be expanded and I think you as a council should know that some information, I did not
4:19:48 feel as a committee member that I had sufficient information to make the decision.
4:19:53 I think others felt that they did have enough information because they were involved in
4:19:58 other related projects in terms of what we were dealing with as a committee.
4:20:02 So that was the main thing for me.
4:20:04 I could not make a decision as a committee member because I did not have enough information.
4:20:10 Secondly, I would also point out that in terms of the funds, that was another big issue
4:20:19 for me, that you are, I did not feel, I think the operative word in the summary was that
4:20:27 We did not need a program assessment now, now was the operative word, but as a committee,
4:20:34 we were asked to do a little bit more long-term thinking than now.
4:20:39 And so the square footage requirements were based on what we would need now, but my concern
4:20:44 is what will we need 20 to 30 to 40 years from now.
4:20:48 So I don't know if that's standard, that you don't do a program's assessment, but my concern
4:20:52 is that at the end of the day, we ended up making a decision on the hearing now and not
4:20:59 20, 30, 40 years from now and if we are dipping into cash reserves, I think I would have liked
4:21:04 to see a little bit more long-term thinking.
4:21:07 Thank you.
4:21:08 Thank you, Daphne.
4:21:10 Alan Horner.
4:21:24 Thank you, seek counsel in there for allowing me to talk.
4:21:29 I just want to put, I'm not going to get into all the salient points because we've discussed
4:21:33 those and talked about them in our meetings and I have to admit at times they got a little
4:21:40 overwhelming because I think one thing we did was within the committee we missed the site
4:21:46 of what we were charged with and it was to find the best what we felt was the best location.
4:21:56 So with that, let me just read real quickly some of the things that I wrote down.
4:22:02 Just ask for volunteers to serve on the Citizens Committee for Facilities.
4:22:09 Over 33 people volunteered, with several ruled ineligible due to a conflict event or others
4:22:15 dropping out.
4:22:18 Some of the other points that were made with regard to financing and how we handled that.
4:22:25 And did we need a facility?
4:22:27 We were really pretty much all in agreement with that.
4:22:31 The one remaining question then that I think was our big concern was to locate a new City
4:22:40 Hall.
4:22:41 Now the City Council and staff, I believe, spent many hours before we were involved analyzing
4:22:46 11 sites and narrowing it down to three that would work.
4:22:50 This analysis included the use of such independent experts as how more architects for structure
4:22:55 and space evaluation.
4:22:57 Hiddlson and associates for transportation, road, design, parking, pedestrian, walkways,
4:23:04 bicycle counts, and traffic operations.
4:23:07 Now various other experts in the field were also utilized and gave us input in one form
4:23:13 or another with some still working on such things as design and the look.
4:23:19 Hummel Architects and independent party has given their expert analysis of space utilization,
4:23:26 growth, potential, cost, etc. One key factor for me was that when it came to cost analysis,
4:23:33 Hummel has a history of actually working with the county on their experience at the clinic
4:23:38 building. That weighed very heavily. And as I said, it had credence to what they had to
4:23:45 say. This in my mind, as I said, only added further credence to the numbers that they had
4:23:51 extrapolated. In reviewing the kittleson assessment of existing and future
4:23:56 transportation conditions which included parking, the study appears to be very
4:24:01 complete, shows adequate parking, and the ability to design good traffic patterns
4:24:06 for auto pedestrians and bicycles. And I should mention I'm talking directly to
4:24:11 the Banner Building downtown. I admit when I came on the committee I had a bias
4:24:17 towards a downtown location. I also told myself I was going to be open, fair,
4:24:22 and give equitable analysis to all sites presented,
4:24:26 not knowing before that first meeting,
4:24:28 what sites were under consideration.
4:24:30 This decision was made all the harder
4:24:32 because I consider myself a friend to all three owners
4:24:35 and to some of those on the committee
4:24:37 who have differing opinions or views.
4:24:39 Alan, your time is up, sir.
4:24:42 No.
4:24:43 Sorry.
4:24:44 Okay.
4:24:45 Okay.
4:24:46 Just maybe one wrap up sentence.
4:24:48 Well, I think we had 17 people vote for this.
4:24:51 All 17 of those felt they had enough information in front of them to make a decision, and that's what occurred.
4:24:59 That's all I'll say.
4:25:00 Thank you, sir.
4:25:02 Rebecca, you received an email.
4:25:04 Should we put that up?
4:25:05 Should we read it?
4:25:06 What would you like to do?
4:25:07 I did.
4:25:07 I think the committee member requested that it be read into the record.
4:25:11 So if a staff member could read that comment, I received an email from there.
4:25:17 You're displaying it, and I'll read it.
4:25:19 Right now, it looks like the only ones I have on the list here are citizens at large.
4:25:24 So if there's other committee members, please, while I'm reading this,
4:25:27 if you could sign up in the back, and then I'll call you up next.
4:25:31 So I'll go ahead and read this into the minutes.
4:25:37 This is from Barry Noblic, and he was a member of the committee, and he says,
4:25:41 I cannot attend.
4:25:43 I was embarrassed that our committee had asked people to come and provide information
4:25:47 and would not hear them.
4:25:48 how we treated our fellow citizens that had taken the time to provide information was
4:25:53 rude and uncalled for.
4:25:55 I am sure no one on the committee would want to be treated in the same manner.
4:25:59 It was shameful, display, the decision was, will be fine, but that type of behavior is
4:26:05 disappointing.
4:26:06 Rebecca, did you have further on that?
4:26:08 Your lights on.
4:26:09 That's all I received.
4:26:10 I'm sorry.
4:26:11 I can't see my light.
4:26:12 Okay, very good.
4:26:13 Could we bring up the list so that I can continue to...
4:26:23 Again, I want to say thank you for everyone that's here.
4:26:27 You're spending a considerable amount of your free time because you believe in bringing this to our attention, your perspective, so thank you for being here again this evening.
4:26:39 Next person on the list is Lori Ward.
4:26:57 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council.
4:27:08 I have, I guess, I'm taking a Daphne, I'm sorry,
4:27:15 I don't mean Daphne's last name,
4:27:16 comments into account about folks having equal information.
4:27:20 I think actually the value in an exercise like this
4:27:23 is that you get lots of folks with lots
4:27:26 of different backgrounds and different levels of information
4:27:30 and that adds to the richness of the experience.
4:27:34 And we had lots of people talk from lots of different points of view.
4:27:39 And we tended to get a little bit, we turned it lost in the weeds.
4:27:45 We had some circular, not forward motion happening in some of those earlier meetings.
4:27:51 I think ultimately the decision we made, which was strongly supported by the committee, to
4:27:57 me there were all those emotions and musings and whatever other actions you want to use
4:28:02 aside.
4:28:03 There were a couple of inescapable critical facts.
4:28:07 One is that with those final two buildings,
4:28:11 they are where they are.
4:28:13 You can't change a location.
4:28:16 They are as big as they are.
4:28:17 You can't change that.
4:28:20 The third criteria, which was not as significant,
4:28:23 is costs involved.
4:28:26 And the banner building after,
4:28:30 as Mr. Horner said,
4:28:31 evaluation by experts in this, the banner building was the only choice out of the three
4:28:38 finalists that we could fund without having to raise taxes, the citizenry.
4:28:46 It had the added advantage because of its location that it would help promote downtown
4:28:51 development and revitalization, which is a very timely subject right now.
4:28:56 for all of those things to occur at one downtown is tremendous.
4:29:01 Size-wise, we had a lot of attention also given
4:29:05 from city staff and clearly a lot of analysis
4:29:09 in the factual information that they tried to provide to us.
4:29:12 The goal was to not sway our opinions with the information.
4:29:17 Looking several decades into the future,
4:29:19 that banner building fit the bill.
4:29:22 And I didn't want to pass along a comment
4:29:24 from Terry Patterson who said that he felt the merits
4:29:27 of the banner building stood on their own regardless
4:29:30 of other structures that we consider.
4:29:33 So thank you very much.
4:29:34 Thank you Ms. Ward.
4:29:36 Travis Squoste, did I say your last name right?
4:29:39 Excellent.
4:29:40 I guess I spent two years sitting around a few years.
4:29:45 Thank you Mr. Mayor and Council.
4:29:46 First of all, I just want to say I appreciate the opportunity
4:29:48 to participate in that Citizens Committee.
4:29:50 It was a great experience and I'm trying
4:29:52 to echo some of the comments but I'll
4:29:53 speak for myself and my own experience there.
4:29:56 One, I just want you to know that as we
4:29:58 deliberated on that decision, it was much more than cost.
4:30:00 It was really about location and what that would do for downtown,
4:30:03 at least for my opinion.
4:30:05 We did have lots of opinions shared on different components.
4:30:09 I think you need to take in mind that 17 of the 22 members
4:30:12 did vote in favor of that.
4:30:13 And I do take exception at no time where we ever railroaded
4:30:16 by the city to cut this short or have a lack of information.
4:30:19 In fact, they provided us everything we needed.
4:30:21 And it was those committee members who made a decision.
4:30:23 that day to make a decision with the motion
4:30:26 to move forward with that.
4:30:27 And I would also just add at no time
4:30:29 where it was I in the under any delusions
4:30:32 that we were only making a recommendation to you.
4:30:34 We understand that you're gonna make that final decision
4:30:37 in regard to the recommendation that we made to you.
4:30:38 You're gonna make your own decision tonight.
4:30:41 And I think as the Board stated,
4:30:43 sometimes we were getting a little too deep in the weeds
4:30:45 to try to make that decision for you.
4:30:46 And I think we've come up with a good recommendation
4:30:48 from the committee to let you guys.
4:30:49 And so you've heard from the citizens at this point
4:30:51 with 17 to the 22 supporting that.
4:30:53 So, thank you.
4:30:55 Thank you Travis.
4:30:57 Ed, I'll mess it up.
4:31:00 Dece?
4:31:02 I saw Ed's name.
4:31:03 Let me see a day more, we'll see what I'm talking about a little bit.
4:31:06 [Muted for privacy: street address]
4:31:10 [Muted for privacy: street address]
4:31:15 [Muted for privacy: street address]
4:31:19 and I appreciate the opportunity.
4:31:20 It was a rough process, though, that that cannot be disputed.
4:31:25 And maybe we do own apology to some of the people
4:31:28 that were not allowed to present at the last meeting.
4:31:31 But given the duration of some of the previous meetings,
4:31:33 I felt it was important to see the process
4:31:35 become a little bit more streamlined and get moving on.
4:31:38 I did feel that I had enough information.
4:31:40 City staff gave of us everything that we needed.
4:31:43 And I was confident in the expert opinions
4:31:45 that we were receiving from Hummel and other people
4:31:49 who came and gave us information.
4:31:53 In the end, just from my perspective,
4:31:56 I really didn't see much comparison between the two buildings.
4:31:58 Initially, I wasn't a fan of Banner.
4:32:00 I didn't want to see the retail space be lost on Maine.
4:32:03 But when we got down to the last two choices,
4:32:06 there really was no comparison.
4:32:09 I don't want my city government to be a landlord.
4:32:11 I don't want us to buy a building that half of it
4:32:13 has to be mothballed right away.
4:32:15 I want to look at a 30 to 50 year plan, not a 100 year plan.
4:32:19 I just don't see what we're going to do with the extra space.
4:32:24 Parking, I think, will be an issue,
4:32:26 despite what the study says, there's the reality of the numbers,
4:32:30 first the emotional response of the information
4:32:32 that we've been seeing from citizens for the last eight,
4:32:35 10 years.
4:32:36 Whether there's enough parking or not
4:32:38 is not necessarily how people feel about it.
4:32:40 I'm actually anxious for a project like this
4:32:43 to help continue to drive that conversation.
4:32:45 I think there are additional things
4:32:46 that we can do about the parking downtown.
4:32:49 Accessibility, same thing.
4:32:51 If people think that it's too far away,
4:32:53 part of what we're looking to do here
4:32:54 provide an anchor in downtown that increases what traffic and supports this
4:32:58 businesses down there. So I don't see this a bad thing. In the end I also didn't feel
4:33:03 that the clinic was moving ready. I felt that there was too much work to be done
4:33:06 there to make the usable space to turn it into a facility that I would be proud
4:33:10 of to call the city hall to say this was a new project and something that we put a
4:33:15 lot of effort into and wasn't just shoe-horning ourselves into a fast option.
4:33:20 Thank you.
4:33:21 I don't know if you can get better timing than that.
4:33:27 Dave Moore.
4:33:30 Welcome, Mr. Moore.
4:33:32 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
4:33:33 Council.
4:33:34 I served on the committee.
4:33:35 I was a late add and was invited to join at about meeting number three.
4:33:43 All of the information that I based my decision to support the banner building on came from
4:33:50 information handed out in those committee meetings in this room.
4:33:55 I don't have access to anything beyond that.
4:33:58 Taking the information given and again the numbers came from a professional using industry-established
4:34:06 matrixes to establish those numbers and analyzing those numbers, analyzing the proximity to downtown,
4:34:15 a desire that exists in this community to revitalize downtown and the importance of supporting that
4:34:22 effort that urban renewal is doing. The banner building made sense. The clinic building, I agree
4:34:31 with the gentleman who just spoke a hundred years from now we wouldn't fill it up. We don't need a
4:34:35 hundred year plan. And the part that's not used will be an ongoing maintenance cost even if you
4:34:42 to quote mothball it, you still have to maintain it to a certain level in order for it to remain
4:34:49 viable part of the building. If you don't, it deteriorates. I just want to reiterate, there
4:34:57 were 22 people on that committee, 17 of them have voted in favor of recommending the banner
4:35:03 building. And I think that with the available information, the task given to us, we have
4:35:10 performed what was what we were tasked to do and I will heartily support the recommendation.
4:35:17 Thank you.
4:35:18 Thank you, sir.
4:35:19 Brian Dobbs.
4:35:20 Welcome, Mr. Dobbs.
4:35:26 Mr. Mayor, Council, thanks for hearing from us tonight.
4:35:29 I feel a little silly.
4:35:31 I'll tell you because this is my first opportunity to sit on a committee of any kind government-wise.
4:35:36 I took the chance and I got to tell you, I loved every minute of it.
4:35:42 It was, I never felt it was drudgery.
4:35:44 I didn't feel that I was ground or persuaded or railroaded in any way.
4:35:50 I got ample good information.
4:35:54 In fact, I got such quality information that when I would take it home at night,
4:35:57 I could read through and go through it.
4:35:59 And by the next meeting, you know, I had, I was able to make sense of everything that we had.
4:36:04 We got tours of every single location.
4:36:07 We got hands on.
4:36:08 We were right in the middle of all of it.
4:36:11 including the clinic where I mean it was it was we got taken really through the
4:36:15 whole thing and a lot of this information was provided to us and so I
4:36:19 don't I don't feel like I was short anything vital to make a quality decision
4:36:26 and in the end the banner building really stood out my mind is being the right
4:36:30 direction to go what it does for the downtown what it does for the vision of
4:36:34 Twin Falls and what we can do with that can't just mention something in our
4:36:38 meetings and that was that we want to be we want a building that's not only
4:36:41 functional we want something we can be really proud of something that will
4:36:44 stand out when we when people do go to the city hall you know it's it gives
4:36:50 you that feeling when you go to Boise City Hall you're gonna walk up go wow this
4:36:53 is a new building with a neat area in front of it and the banner building offered
4:36:59 that in space we're gonna be able to build the building we want around an
4:37:03 existing frame and that's fantastic in addition will be able to put together the
4:37:08 facilities that we need inside to fit exactly what we want it to fit that we
4:37:14 won't have to retrofit anything. So in the interest of time, expense and
4:37:19 quality, I think our recommendation stands. Thanks very much. Thank you, Mr.
4:37:24 Dobbs. I show no one else from the committee on my list. Before I go to the
4:37:31 community at large, I want to give that opportunity one more time. All right, Kevin
4:37:36 Bradshaw welcome again Mr. Bradshaw. Kevin Bradshaw 1193 Eastridge Circle. How much time do I have? Two minutes
4:37:52 sir. When does it start? Right now. Okay, I won't be labored the point that the fact that the agenda was wrong which
4:38:01 was in retrospect left out I think a key speaker but we know that happened and now it's been rectified I suppose but I think
4:38:10 It would make more sense back then.
4:38:13 I've got two pages, so I will briefly go through my points.
4:38:19 There are six meetings.
4:38:20 I've only seen two videos that were actually online, for me,
4:38:23 as a citizen, to review.
4:38:26 And then there was some meeting notes.
4:38:28 But I don't believe that the parking issue was taken care of,
4:38:34 even at the last meeting, on December 11.
4:38:37 And the parking behind the banner bank on the study shows,
4:38:41 I believe, 50% to 80% full during the peak times.
4:38:44 And so put a city hall in there and you're going to have some issues.
4:38:49 The accurate costs that Eric Wadi didn't get to present to the committee members
4:38:55 regarding his building and at $50 to $60 a square foot versus the $120 that was shown.
4:39:05 And then, at least at the first video I saw, and the last one,
4:39:11 the committee member said, we need to do a side-by-side comparison.
4:39:16 We don't have enough information. At least a few of those people did.
4:39:19 And that wasn't really addressed very well.
4:39:23 No current appraisal in the Banner Building as far as cost.
4:39:28 Have they really looked into realistic future growth of the city,
4:39:32 long-term expansion ability.
4:39:34 The clinic actually does allow that.
4:39:36 Even though you have some dead space for a while,
4:39:39 it's easy to grow easily.
4:39:41 As an example, the Hanson Street Building Department
4:39:43 is a perfect example.
4:39:45 It grew into that space so fast when we had a rush.
4:39:49 There's going to be times that will have growth,
4:39:52 and then we'll have slowdown.
4:39:54 So that's one.
4:39:56 And the space and easement assessment
4:39:58 at 55,800 by 2015 for future growth.
4:40:04 I guess I'm out of time.
4:40:06 Well, I was going to let you go about another thing.
4:40:07 I've let others go about 30 seconds or so.
4:40:09 I think that's fair to let you.
4:40:12 Alan Horner says this will help the downtown.
4:40:14 I feel that some other commercial building
4:40:17 would be better suited in there for that purpose.
4:40:22 And the people that I've talked to say the Vanderbilt building
4:40:26 is not the place to be.
4:40:28 I think we need to have a public hearing or more input
4:40:31 from outside source that has shown up.
4:40:34 But Kent Pride, or Kent Just is right,
4:40:36 we need a city hall that's gonna give us pride
4:40:39 and something to be proud of.
4:40:41 And if you look at all the building that's been going on,
4:40:44 Shoshone Street, Farmer's Bank,
4:40:48 Columbia, Toyota,
4:40:51 and Wheels, I see the Forest Law offices,
4:40:55 Those are accessing the main avenues right there,
4:41:00 and they've created their own parking.
4:41:02 Thank you for this time.
4:41:03 Thank you, Mr. President.
4:41:05 Lisa Fairbanks, your name's on here, Lisa.
4:41:12 You have to come up now.
4:41:13 Welcome.
4:41:16 Did you sign?
4:41:17 Did someone sign you in?
4:41:18 Yes.
4:41:21 City Council, I just want to thank the committee members
4:41:24 and everybody who have taken the time.
4:41:26 And as I've been downtown for 27 years,
4:41:30 and I can't even be more excited about City Hall going down there.
4:41:34 I think it's just what?
4:41:39 Thank you, Lisa.
4:41:41 Ladies and gentlemen, that's all I have on the list to come and speak.
4:41:45 I will open it up.
4:41:47 If anyone else would like to come forward, certainly we'll allow you to.
4:41:51 Gary, could I have Leah come up first?
4:41:53 Her hand was up first, I think.
4:41:55 So Leah, if you could come up and state your name and your address, please.
4:42:08 My name is Lea Bambian, 250 camera away.
4:42:11 I'm just curious from, and I've been getting sick,
4:42:15 so sorry, I've been curious from a business perspective,
4:42:20 how many of the committee members actually spoke
4:42:23 to the merchants downtown to kind of understand
4:42:26 what kind of climate they wanted to create
4:42:31 as far as morale and culture,
4:42:35 I'm not just this building and parking,
4:42:39 but actually what kind of a downtown town they envision.
4:42:43 I don't recall.
4:42:47 Excuse me, I don't recall much of that happening,
4:42:52 but I could have also missed it because I was away.
4:42:54 So I don't know if that's a question
4:42:56 for the committee members or if someone could answer that.
4:42:59 What I'll do, Leah, is I'll address that to Gary,
4:43:02 maybe he and one of the co-chairs
4:43:04 could come up and answer that.
4:43:05 My second point that I wanted to bring up is in regards to talking about revival in downtown,
4:43:12 I think it's important to see that two different ways. Just building buildings and restructuring
4:43:22 infrastructure doesn't necessarily rebuild downtown. The most important part is culture,
4:43:30 morale, retail, the consuming aspect of it. I think just to look at the downtown as well,
4:43:39 there's a building that's empty, there's a potential to fill it and use it. That's kind
4:43:46 of a fast jump. I think that the climate and the morale needs to be really looked at as
4:43:54 far as the revival, the main revival of what has happened downtown and that revival comes
4:44:00 is from consumerism, so thank you.
4:44:04 Thank you, Leah, I hope you feel better.
4:44:05 Is there anyone other than the co-chairs?
4:44:07 I'm gonna allow the co-chairs a couple minutes each,
4:44:09 if they'd like to come forward,
4:44:10 we're gonna treat this kind of like a public hearing,
4:44:12 you're the applicant.
4:44:14 If you'd like to come up forward,
4:44:15 is there anyone else that would like to come forward?
4:44:20 So I think I will let Gary go, and then you,
4:44:23 and then Greg, if you'd like to, so Gary, come on up?
4:44:30 You ask us to give you a recommendation.
4:44:33 So 22 of your citizens did that.
4:44:37 You have been elected to make tough decisions and be used
4:44:42 art funds that we give you as taxes in a fiduciary manner.
4:44:47 So we depend upon you to do that.
4:44:50 You don't have to follow our recommendation.
4:44:54 But no matter what building you decide to do,
4:44:57 I want to say two things.
4:44:59 In our very first meeting and Kevin
4:45:01 alluded to, it can't just brought up, it is time for the city to do something that makes
4:45:09 this community proud of its city. You have the opportunity to build that into your legacy,
4:45:19 and I urge you to do that. The second thing is, remember that the city and urban renewal
4:45:28 has for years talked about trying to fix up downtown. In recent years, urban renewal has
4:45:34 done some great things in Old Town, like St. Columbia and some developers of the Salt Lake
4:45:40 or the Salt Lake. The St. Luke's administrative offices, the Toyota improvements, many others,
4:45:48 great new businesses and things have happened downtown. And you all need to take pride in
4:45:55 that because you are part of the reason it happened. Urban renewal is part of it. You
4:46:00 you have the opportunity to really make downtown special.
4:46:05 But the last thing I will say is also,
4:46:08 one of the things our community wanted is for you
4:46:11 to be sure you include a way to develop art
4:46:16 in our community in this facility.
4:46:19 Make us proud of this facility
4:46:22 and use the assets of our community.
4:46:25 Thank you.
4:46:26 Stand by it real quick, Gary.
4:46:27 Just try to answer your question, Leah.
4:46:30 It was absolutely an opportunity for anyone downtown to also get on this committee.
4:46:35 So there was that opportunity.
4:46:36 Are you aware of her question regarding-
4:46:39 I didn't hear very well.
4:46:40 She asked-
4:46:42 Yeah, me too.
4:46:43 So make sure I say this rightly.
4:46:44 How did the committee engage business owners downtown regarding this process?
4:46:53 the committee, the city put out a notice, the city put out a notice that people were interested
4:47:00 in serving on this committee to apply. They did. They then asked if they could take a tour
4:47:08 of facilities and primarily City Hall prior to their organizational meeting. At the organizational
4:47:16 meeting, that's when people volunteered to be on it. As far as the committee itself, we
4:47:22 he did not solicit anybody to be on the committee.
4:47:25 It was all done through the written questions from the city.
4:47:28 Very good, thank you Gary.
4:47:30 Jill, you're on.
4:47:38 I just wanted to make this point, because I think I forgot to do it.
4:47:41 So it's always good to come back up.
4:47:43 Thank you very much.
4:47:44 When I was doing research for this committee,
4:47:46 I obtained a 2005 Space Needs Assessment.
4:47:50 That was done by Tom Courtney for the city.
4:47:52 They went through every department.
4:47:54 They looked at all the needs.
4:47:55 And in that space needs assessment,
4:47:58 It's said by 2015, the city would need 55,800 square feet by the year 2015 with 5,000 for future growth.
4:48:08 Now, that did not include police, it did not include fire, it included parks and
4:48:15 rec, but that was only 700 square feet.
4:48:18 So it still would have been 55,100 square feet for 2015.
4:48:24 My concern with the Banner Building is right now, 30,000 square feet for $4.5 million,
4:48:31 no parking.
4:48:32 So now you'll have to extend the mezzanine, and that includes City Council Chambers, which
4:48:38 the 2005 assessment did not include.
4:48:41 So you're going to have to extend that, do the basement.
4:48:44 I have no idea where all your files are going to go.
4:48:47 Conference rooms, everything that we were told they need, and then what?
4:48:51 Are you going to have to build a parking garage?
4:48:53 you're going to have to buy buildings behind.
4:48:57 I really worry that this building is not big enough.
4:49:00 I worry about accessibility for citizens.
4:49:02 And as we become 50,000 public transportation,
4:49:06 the clinic is able to have buses go in, go out, drop people off.
4:49:10 I don't know how you would do it in the banner building.
4:49:13 I don't think it's going to be big enough.
4:49:14 I really don't.
4:49:15 And how do you then go back to taxpayers and say, wow,
4:49:18 we made a mistake because we didn't do a space needs assessment
4:49:20 now.
4:49:21 And I really don't think it's going to be big enough.
4:49:24 And I just want to stress that.
4:49:26 And I don't think it's a good location.
4:49:28 I lived in many large cities.
4:49:30 I lived in Boston.
4:49:31 I lived in Dallas, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Columbus,
4:49:35 Toledo, Manian, Pennsylvania.
4:49:38 Boston has Newberry Street, Manian, Pennsylvania.
4:49:42 People go down for restaurants, art galleries, gift shops.
4:49:46 They don't go down for City Hall.
4:49:48 I'm sorry.
4:49:49 Daoist Head City Hall, business buildings down there, it was a ghost town at five o'clock and on weekends.
4:49:55 Think about that, to have a city hall that's closed.
4:49:57 Five o'clock and on weekends, what are you going to do then across from a plaza?
4:50:02 I don't think it's going to generate business downtown, I really don't.
4:50:05 Thank you.
4:50:05 Thank you, Jill.
4:50:06 Great, did you want to come forward?
4:50:11 Thanks again.
4:50:13 Just to reiterate my points again, in my opinion, even after listening to Eric against tonight.
4:50:20 If you want to rebuild the structure so that you have flexibility, assuming you want to build and have the creative ability to build the building you want, knock on walls, etc.
4:50:32 I believe that the banner building gives you a lot of open space. Because of that, I believe it's the least expensive option.
4:50:39 I also believe it's the closest size to what the city says they need.
4:50:45 And we listened to a lot of argument.
4:50:47 That was a heated point.
4:50:48 I still believe it is what the city needs size-wise.
4:50:53 But I do believe that as part of the process,
4:50:55 you guys will do a business studying on that to confirm it.
4:50:57 You'll also do additional studying to confirm the numbers.
4:51:00 And I encourage you and I am comforted
4:51:02 by knowing that that's going to happen.
4:51:04 But I still believe those two things.
4:51:07 I believe it gives you the most design flexibility
4:51:09 because of the structure and the grid system
4:51:12 that is built on and the architects can talk more to that.
4:51:15 You have a lot of options to build, do some creative things that are going to make it a beautiful building.
4:51:20 I think it's the option that's going to look the best.
4:51:23 And then the downtown is a plus if it helps downtown business.
4:51:27 I think it will.
4:51:28 Two things that we didn't really talk about was the financing option.
4:51:32 I feel that financing it with the reserve funds makes a lot of sense because I believe it's the fastest solution.
4:51:39 I believe that there's enough money in there.
4:51:41 And I believe that if you're you know, I mean there's some serious concerns with the the way city is right now
4:51:47 I don't want to you know
4:51:49 Maybe I don't want to make it like I'm scared of it because it works
4:51:53 But you're out of space and the police station in particular has some real problems with the space and those are some
4:52:00 Important people doing really important stuff in addition. I think that the critical documents of the city in the current building are
4:52:07 are protected nicely, but not perhaps at the level that those documents deserve to be protected.
4:52:14 The other thing about funding it in this manner is that it gives you the option to ask, act quickly.
4:52:22 I don't know if the banner building will be available for them.
4:52:25 So that's what I think and I appreciate your time.
4:52:28 Thank you, sir.
4:52:29 I would like to make a recommendation to the council tonight.
4:52:33 We've been at this for five hours now at various city meetings from four o'clock till now.
4:52:40 Some of us went to work this morning at seven as well, so we've had a long day.
4:52:44 The decision regarding facility is incredibly important.
4:52:50 It's a decision that we need to be fresh and able to think clearly on, potentially ask more
4:52:58 questions, get more information.
4:53:02 So my suggestion and council can make motions if they will is that we table this issue in
4:53:13 a real soon, maybe even next council meeting, we can put it on the agenda.
4:53:17 I'll look and see what that looks like.
4:53:20 And revisit this with the information that we have and potentially make a decision.
4:53:27 But that's my suggestion and I saw lights come on so I must have hit a nerve.
4:53:31 Thank you, Mayor.
4:53:33 No, actually, I just want to agree.
4:53:35 I think that's a great idea.
4:53:37 I actually tonight want to recommend a public hearing.
4:53:40 I think this is a great discussion, a wider discussion for the public.
4:53:44 And I appreciate the notice that we have had for this one meeting.
4:53:49 But of course it is a Thursday notice for this meeting.
4:53:52 And thank you to the committee.
4:53:54 I really do appreciate all of your input and all of the time and hours that you spent in the work that you did.
4:53:59 And we've heard a lot from the committee, but I personally don't feel comfortable with the level of public engagement that we have currently.
4:54:08 And so I think the least we can do if we're going to spend half of all unrestricted reserves that the city currently now has in the bank on one project.
4:54:19 I think the least we can do is have a public hearing.
4:54:22 I would move to hold a public hearing.
4:54:25 I know we need two weeks' notice.
4:54:27 Council can debate this but I think January 5th would be Monday in two weeks at six
4:54:35 o'clock so I move that we have a public hearing on this very item January 5th at
4:54:40 6 p.m. We have a motion on the floor motion fails for a lack of second. Greg
4:54:49 Lanning. Well I guess I'm ready to go tonight I think we've had we've been
4:54:55 studying this issue for a really long time this was a public hearing that's
4:54:58 That's why I didn't second the public hearing.
4:55:00 This was a public hearing.
4:55:02 Anybody that's been following anything in town
4:55:05 knew what was going on tonight,
4:55:07 and whether or not they knew exactly they could speak
4:55:10 or not, I think that's the case.
4:55:11 We got an awful lot of people,
4:55:13 including having a look over at the K&V team.
4:55:16 I was at the time of those people
4:55:17 and all these people in the audience
4:55:19 are ready for a decision.
4:55:21 And we just cause them all to come back next week
4:55:25 or whenever we choose to do it,
4:55:27 is if they really want to be involved in the process,
4:55:29 they're going to want to come back.
4:55:30 So my feeling would be we go ahead and we hace it out
4:55:34 and we get to figure that tonight.
4:55:37 Okay, great.
4:55:38 That's, we'll move on to the next, Chris talking to.
4:55:40 Well, I agree with Gary Garnand.
4:55:43 We are up here because we have to demonstrate leadership.
4:55:47 This has been one of the most transparent
4:55:50 and widespread input selection processes
4:55:55 I've been aware of because the city, first of all, did its own due diligence.
4:56:00 We appointed a committee of some 22 members who did their own due diligence.
4:56:06 We had the advantage of looking at humble architects, apples versus apples comparison on
4:56:12 some of the properties.
4:56:14 We have limited fund reserves, which drives the law of the decision to me.
4:56:18 We were looking for 30 years, not 100 years of growth, even I won't be on the council
4:56:23 100 years to decide what to do.
4:56:26 77% of this committee voted in favor of our own previous
4:56:31 decisions to do with the Banner Building.
4:56:33 And a couple of points that haven't been brought out,
4:56:35 besides have been the most affordable,
4:56:37 the three finalist decisions are two, actually.
4:56:41 Boise City Hall is located in the downtown,
4:56:43 and that's been part of the reason for the research,
4:56:46 and so that city's growth.
4:56:49 on the other hand, move their city hall out of downtown structure.
4:56:53 And I think even they will acknowledge it almost get at it.
4:56:58 There's no reason for an additional public hearing because somebody's going to be on the winning side,
4:57:02 somebody's going to be on the losing side.
4:57:04 I'll make a motion.
4:57:06 I move as we accept the recommendations of the Citizens' Facility Committee appointed by
4:57:12 the Council to take the Banner Building as our first choice to be funded for
4:57:19 renovation with reserve funds.
4:57:21 Thank you.
4:57:22 We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking
4:57:24 and seconded by Greg Lanting as stated.
4:57:27 We have lots of lights on.
4:57:28 Suzanne Hawkins.
4:57:29 Thank you.
4:57:30 I have a couple questions for staff.
4:57:33 Do we have a rough idea of how many people actually
4:57:36 pay their water or utility bills in person versus mail them in?
4:57:40 I mean, what is the foot traffic we have now at that counter?
4:57:46 Yes, we did that as part of this.
4:57:48 And Lori raised this going to come up.
4:57:51 Okay, and while she's looking at that kit, okay,
4:57:55 while she's getting that,
4:57:57 Jill mentioned the 2005 space needs study.
4:58:01 Can you expand on that?
4:58:03 That did not include police and fire back then?
4:58:06 And they said that big?
4:58:08 So when you look at the space needs,
4:58:10 I gave that, my report is with Rebecca right now.
4:58:14 It does contemplate a,
4:58:19 what's called I guess a fifth option.
4:58:21 And that fifth option was the construction of a brand new city hall, which was not part
4:58:25 of the initial analysis, but as the architect says in his memo to Tom and to the council
4:58:33 at the time that they didn't believe that any analysis would be totally complete without
4:58:37 looking at it.
4:58:38 Jill and I have a different interpretation, and that is that I believe that if you look
4:58:44 at the sentence that says 55,000 square feet for all departments.
4:58:51 And I come to that just from a place then looking at the number of square feet that we
4:58:55 currently have in our organization.
4:59:00 So it's important to recognize that the 2005 Space Needs Analysis was completed prior to
4:59:05 the city's acquisition of the Hanson Building.
4:59:08 And so you've got to really think all structures and all facilities were located right here
4:59:13 in this main campus and I believe also at the time
4:59:16 that the council chambers may have been in the old City Hall,
4:59:23 which is now the police classroom.
4:59:24 That transitioned at some point in time.
4:59:27 Right now today, if you take the administrative functions
4:59:32 of the city and you take the Hanson building,
4:59:37 it's roughly 18 to 19,000 square feet.
4:59:41 And if you add the Hanson facility to the entire city complex,
4:59:47 I'm going to bet that you might get close to that 55,000 foot
4:59:52 number.
4:59:52 I can't tell you off the top of my head
4:59:54 of how big the fire station is with its base.
4:59:57 And I can't tell you how big the current police station is.
5:00:00 I don't know maybe Brian or somebody might be able to.
5:00:04 But when you think about the amount of space that we're
5:00:07 currently occupying, as an organization,
5:00:10 we may be getting close to that 55,000 square foot
5:00:13 with the acquisition of the Hanson building.
5:00:18 We would, it is hard for me to believe that we would,
5:00:23 that there would be a study that would contemplate
5:00:25 that we would need 55,000 square feet in 10 years
5:00:30 based upon the current, just how we've added people
5:00:34 judiciously in our organization's history,
5:00:38 especially under Tom's 10.
5:00:40 And in 2005, the city was, that was still before the economic collapse.
5:00:46 So the city was probably anticipating more growth during those years that we actually had
5:00:52 to go back the other direction.
5:00:54 No, actually was pretty impressive about that study is a lot of the information that was
5:01:00 taken was from one of the initial long-term planning committees that I know Mrs.
5:01:06 was also part of it and they really tried to pinpoint the growth based upon what they
5:01:13 were seeing out there and they did a really good job in trying to get that.
5:01:19 Thank you.
5:01:21 Mitch has the.
5:01:22 Okay.
5:01:23 So, one of the things that we, when we were looking at it, we looked at, so, well, they're,
5:01:47 Mitch was part of the one who oversaw part of this process and I'll turn that over to
5:01:54 both Mitch and Marie to answer questions about direct contact at utility cameras.
5:01:59 Thank you.
5:02:06 So a member of my team put together this lovely spreadsheet and it was just a sample.
5:02:12 As you can see it was the first part of November, Thursday, Friday and then Monday, Tuesday was
5:02:17 a holiday and then Wednesday.
5:02:21 And he actually did the breakdown by hour, so we could see when the heaviest traffic was.
5:02:28 And I think if you look at that, it's probably 16, hold on one second.
5:02:42 So you can see there from 8 to 9 that we're not even open then.
5:02:46 So those are folks that have just come in the back door.
5:02:50 9 to 10, about 15 people, 13, 16, 14, 15.
5:02:56 did you just scoot over a little bit, Mitch?
5:02:58 Yeah.
5:03:00 12, 16, and about 16.
5:03:03 Now, this is probably not our busiest time.
5:03:07 I think that probably closer to the first of the month
5:03:10 is a little bit busier.
5:03:12 But they actually counted, and this was a sample.
5:03:16 And then about how many are walking
5:03:17 at the Hanson Street building right now?
5:03:23 So when you ask a accountant, she
5:03:25 get a nice stretch here.
5:03:28 My team put a little tick marks on a piece of paper.
5:03:31 And I don't actually have it with me tonight.
5:03:36 I'm polished for that, but I know that it was fewer than what we saw in the city hall.
5:03:41 Okay. Thank you.
5:03:42 There had to have been a slide role used in that process too.
5:03:47 Right. So we did provide that information to the committee and let's see here.
5:03:53 We averaged 30 customers per day over the same week.
5:03:58 Okay.
5:03:59 So it was the week of Veterans Day, so there was a holiday email.
5:04:04 And that was pretty evenly distributed throughout the day.
5:04:07 High day was 37.
5:04:09 Low day was 22.
5:04:11 Okay.
5:04:12 And one last question.
5:04:13 This is probably going to go to Lori, I think, too.
5:04:15 So both of these buildings are currently on the tax role in which
5:04:19 ever way we go, that building then comes off our tax role, right?
5:04:23 tax role, right? So will it affect much our property tax collection, either way? Does that make sense?
5:04:31 Cleric, my if it's if the answer is yes on the banner facility. Don't know about the clinic. The
5:04:36 banner facility is in is in private ownership. And that would then obviously become tax
5:04:46 example if that's where the city went. I am on clear as to the ownership of the
5:04:52 clinic. If it's under complete and private total ownership then that
5:04:59 that building would also come off of the tax rules. So there would be a cost
5:05:04 difference there as well because you're looking at 2.7 million versus 450,000.
5:05:10 That's what they're assessed up.
5:05:12 Yes, so the sale price is maybe different than what the total assessed price of the facility
5:05:21 would be.
5:05:22 Okay.
5:05:23 Thank you.
5:05:24 Jim.
5:05:26 Thank you, Mayor.
5:05:27 I would ask, Councilman, during the course, if he would entertain in his motion or at least
5:05:35 have a discussion about a purchase price and how we would pay for that.
5:05:39 Through reserve funds
5:05:45 Yeah, oh yeah, okay
5:05:48 Part of the motion that it'd be paid in a centardy including the place remodeling through reserve funds
5:05:55 I got you on that one and then the purchase price on the banner building
5:06:03 Was intended to be yeah, I didn't catch the person Alex. Could you look back at the motion and then refresh our memory?
5:06:10 Yeah, I didn't get a purchase price. I think that needs to be included.
5:06:21 That was meant to be included, yes.
5:06:24 And there was no addition of the recommendation regarding the remodel of the PD or we don't need to deal with that now.
5:06:32 Is that your question as well?
5:06:33 Right, because I was just going to have a quick discussion about directing staff to develop an RFQ for architects to help us design both the banner building and the old city hall and police
5:06:47 a new police station.
5:06:49 That would probably be in a separate motion if we do agree to go in that direction.
5:06:53 Or you want to include that in your motion?
5:06:56 No, that's correct.
5:06:57 I think we just need to have a fundamental question of the Citizens Committee.
5:07:01 I think that is a good recommendation.
5:07:03 And that's a secondary motion.
5:07:05 You can see from there.
5:07:07 Sean Verger.
5:07:08 I too want to say thanks to the committee for the work that they did on this.
5:07:13 And as we learn from time to time up here, and many of you have learned in your public
5:07:18 service as well, sometimes not everyone agrees.
5:07:22 But it is a democracy and we do our best to let majority rule.
5:07:27 I think Mr. Grannon made a good comment too in that the seven of us are elected by the
5:07:33 citizens to make tough decisions and have robust conversations and gather that information.
5:07:42 But we don't live in a direct democracy where we go take everything to a vote and
5:07:46 have hearings at NOSM to get everybody's opinion and go door to door and ask what they think.
5:07:53 We all agree that we need a new city hall.
5:07:56 We need new facilities, not only to serve the needs of our employees,
5:08:03 but those employees to provide the service to our citizens.
5:08:07 I am confident that there will continue to be streets that run past the banner building that one can drive their car on and park nearby and have access.
5:08:18 I'm confident that they will be accessible to all.
5:08:22 I am confident that we will make the design to serve the needs of the citizens.
5:08:27 And I think that we have studied this actually councils before us have studied this staff before us have studied this and we have had ample information to make a decision for what we can see as the foreseeable future in the vision of where Twin Falls is going.
5:08:49 So I think it's time that we
5:08:53 Support this recommendation from the committee
5:08:56 And then I do think that we should perhaps entertain the suggestion of councilman Munn on
5:09:01 direction first after move forward from there
5:09:05 Rebecca, milsoka
5:09:06 Thank you mayor
5:09:07 Well, I just want to point out the difference between this meeting and a public hearing a public hearing would have a two-week notice
5:09:14 for any
5:09:15 Interested members. It's posted in the paper
5:09:18 It's also posted at the site of the subject, and so I think it's very different than having
5:09:25 a notice on Thursday and having a meeting on Monday.
5:09:29 I think that we heard from at least one downtown merchant that would indicate to us that we
5:09:35 need to have a wider discussion.
5:09:37 I also believe in this day and age, and it is not unprecedented, for us to use multiple
5:09:42 avenues for citizen engagement.
5:09:44 I think in this day and age, it should be a requirement.
5:09:47 In the past, we've done simple online surveys for people who can't come to a committee.
5:09:54 Not everyone has the luxury of being retired or having the flexibility in their work schedule
5:09:58 to attend hour and a half to hour meetings every Thursday in the middle of the work day.
5:10:04 And so I think that people should be given an opportunity to voice their opinions.
5:10:11 It doesn't have to be long or lengthy.
5:10:14 And if you put out a survey, monkey survey, in letting people choose which location they
5:10:21 prefer for one or two weeks, I think you'd get a better sense of what the public wants
5:10:27 us to do with their tax dollars.
5:10:29 Just because we don't have to take this decision to the public for a vote doesn't mean that
5:10:35 we shouldn't ask for their input on a $7 to $10 million project.
5:10:42 I personally don't have quite enough information or I don't believe that this council has had
5:10:50 the conversation about how to address parking issues at the banner site, how to address accessibility.
5:10:59 I personally, that's been my concern this entire time.
5:11:03 I don't think we can count public lots as part of our personal employee parking.
5:11:10 we've told the downtown merchants that they can't do that either.
5:11:14 And I think it's also hypocritical of us to tell them that we will not
5:11:18 consider any changes to downtown parking lots until the
5:11:22 downtown parking survey is completed. And here we are making a huge decision
5:11:26 that will impact downtown parking prior to
5:11:30 the results of that study prior to OTAC's study coming
5:11:34 out and recommendations to us. I do have questions. I do
5:11:38 if I can, ask questions at this time about the plaza.
5:11:43 Some committee members referred to a plaza,
5:11:45 some committee members didn't know about the plaza,
5:11:49 but it was a vital argument to proponents
5:11:52 of the Banner location at that December 11th meeting.
5:11:55 And I need to know how much that plaza is going to cost
5:12:00 if we're including this in the new feel and look
5:12:02 of the Banner City Hall location.
5:12:06 we need to know where the money is coming from.
5:12:09 I sat on a committee that evaluated all of the TIF dollars
5:12:13 available for downtown infrastructure improvements.
5:12:16 And we were only able to select six or seven
5:12:20 of the 13 very vital projects for downtown water lines,
5:12:25 sewer lines, power, because we had limited funds.
5:12:29 And so I'm wondering where the funding for number one,
5:12:31 the purchase of the Rogerson,
5:12:33 did that come out of those TIF dollars
5:12:35 that are supposed to go to that infrastructure,
5:12:38 so the businesses can move downtown
5:12:39 so we can see more revitalization.
5:12:42 How much is that going to cost the relocation
5:12:46 of the water line that apparently runs through
5:12:48 the Rogerson, the demolition of the Rogerson,
5:12:51 and how much does this apply as a cost?
5:12:53 I think as a council, our due diligence
5:12:56 is in finding out what the complete vision
5:13:00 is going to cost the taxpayers,
5:13:02 what the mezzanine is going to cost the taxpayers,
5:13:04 because we'll be coming back when we run out of space,
5:13:07 and we're not sure how many years it could be 10,
5:13:10 it could be 20 or 30.
5:13:12 I'm hoping it's more along the lines of 50 years.
5:13:15 But I think that the taxpayers deserve to know
5:13:20 what the total cost of this project is,
5:13:21 and when we have parking needs in the future,
5:13:26 what are those going to cost?
5:13:27 Because right now the study results
5:13:30 weren't much different than what we already knew.
5:13:33 There was the same study was done by CSI six, seven years ago and said,
5:13:37 hey, your parking lots are half full, you don't have a parking problem.
5:13:41 But if we move 100 or so city employees down there, and then downtown does pick up,
5:13:48 I hope this is the magic bullet that will revitalize downtown.
5:13:52 But suddenly you do have a parking problem because suddenly your lots won't be 50% full,
5:13:56 it'll be 100 or 80% full.
5:13:58 So I think we need to think long term, and I think we need to think from a customer perspective.
5:14:04 I think the question, does the banner building serve the purpose for city staff?
5:14:12 Absolutely, I think it's an excellent place.
5:14:15 It will serve all their needs, but when you think of it from a customer perspective,
5:14:19 does this suit the citizens needs, the elderly that disabled, those who can't walk very far?
5:14:25 I think we need to rethink that.
5:14:26 So there's a few questions that you had.
5:14:30 Greg slides on next and I think that he could probably address.
5:14:33 I will have one to correct me anytime I fall short.
5:14:39 The plaza, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the,
5:15:11 towards helping revitalize downtown open space areas.
5:15:15 Thanks.
5:15:16 The funding for that is we have a community partner
5:15:20 that is looking to help us or possibly completely
5:15:25 build that force and that being the rotary.
5:15:27 They have been raising money to redo the Hanson Street part.
5:15:31 And so the plan would be to, they would help us to rebuild
5:15:36 to rebuild the plaza, then the Hanson Street would then be opened up as a, mostly, it would
5:15:45 be allowed, there would be traffic allowed, it would be, we talked about traffic calming
5:15:49 and things earlier today, lots of traffic calming, people could get through there and
5:15:53 utilize that, it would also open up those two parking lots to probably a little more use
5:15:57 because they will have a street attached to them down through the middle.
5:16:01 The parking survey shows us that there's 50% usage at the peak time for that lot, especially
5:16:09 the lot that's in behind St. Vince's to Paul and Open Chain Building and what are we on.
5:16:15 Claude Brown's, that lot is very seldom used unless it's at the Wednesday night concerts.
5:16:21 That's about it.
5:16:22 It gets full.
5:16:25 We also have control and this isn't part of your race.
5:16:28 So if I missed something, we'll end it,
5:16:30 certainly come up and comment on it.
5:16:32 We certainly have control on where our employees park.
5:16:37 We've asked that the businesses downtown do that.
5:16:39 We have that control.
5:16:40 We also have a lot that we're using now
5:16:43 for partially using for the Hanson building
5:16:47 that's over and behind us,
5:16:48 they'll call it the beacon, it's called Scooters Now.
5:16:51 We could have our employees park there
5:16:54 that is also very underutilized parking lot.
5:16:57 And so we have some options there
5:16:59 of requiring where our employees park
5:17:01 to make sure that we do not think.
5:17:03 And then moving on to the one about the downtown businesses,
5:17:07 I of course have not talked to all the downtown businesses,
5:17:09 but I'll guarantee you, I've had a lot of them in my year
5:17:12 and they're very in favor of the Vanderbilt.
5:17:15 They want that constant traffic down there
5:17:18 of the employees, the people coming to pay their water bill,
5:17:22 the people coming to the Hanson building,
5:17:24 what was the Hanson building at four
5:17:26 for those operations.
5:17:29 I still think that this is a vision.
5:17:31 Of course, everybody has a vision
5:17:33 of what we can make that building to be.
5:17:34 And that's the part you have to realize.
5:17:35 Most people are looking at the building as it is,
5:17:38 not as it could be.
5:17:40 And one of the things I see is the possibility
5:17:43 of a drive-through down the alley.
5:17:45 We'd have to maybe change a code or do to make it happen,
5:17:48 but it's still a possibility.
5:17:49 That there could be a drive-through in the alley
5:17:52 at the side of the better building.
5:17:54 And so, anyway, those are my answers.
5:17:57 And Belinda, it has a better one.
5:18:01 I was finished on mine.
5:18:03 I'm excited about City Hall being downtown.
5:18:07 I want to see the visions, like Jim said, to the RFQ.
5:18:10 I want to see the visions of what we can make this building
5:18:12 be.
5:18:13 So like Jim just said, we can make this the community proud.
5:18:18 And I think I would like everybody to maybe withhold
5:18:21 judgment a little bit on what it might look like
5:18:23 until we see what it's going to look like.
5:18:26 because I don't think we have seen that exactly yet,
5:18:28 but I'm excited.
5:18:30 Thank you, Greg.
5:18:31 I just wanted to state,
5:18:32 I know there's been some conversation tonight
5:18:35 about not enough public input.
5:18:37 I don't know how much more public input.
5:18:38 You had six meetings that were noticed
5:18:41 that folks knew were taking place
5:18:44 and we had a meeting tonight as well
5:18:46 that was very well advertised,
5:18:49 that folks knew,
5:18:50 because I had a lot of people contact me regarding tonight.
5:18:53 I've had people bend my ear about what location as well.
5:18:58 I think this committee did a real service to the city.
5:19:03 They went over every little piece of information and
5:19:07 I trust their judgment, invigorated now.
5:19:12 So I've got some energy, I'm ready to make a decision.
5:19:15 So, Rebecca Milsoyka.
5:19:19 Thank you, Greg, for your input on that.
5:19:20 I still didn't get an answer on the question though for the costs of what you've spent so
5:19:26 far on the Rogerson.
5:19:29 I know you don't have the exact cost on the, if you are going to demolish for a plaza, but
5:19:35 then how much does the plaza cost and are we putting that on to the total of this option
5:19:41 for City Hall?
5:19:42 So we will know the cost of the five block main avenue redesign project, the 30% design
5:19:48 cost by the end of May. That will include the plaza. So I don't have a cost figure for you
5:19:55 yet. It will be the end of May before that is confirmed, what those costs are going to be.
5:20:01 But as Councilman Lansing mentioned, the Twin Falls Community Foundation as well as the Twin
5:20:07 Falls Rotary Club have raised over $400,000 for the plaza that will be available for use
5:20:13 in the construction of this plaza,
5:20:16 if that's a decision that the urban renewal board goes in.
5:20:20 Okay, and then the, so the purchase of the Rogerson
5:20:25 did that come out of that 16.9 million?
5:20:28 Yes, it did.
5:20:29 Okay, and that was how much?
5:20:30 400 and $450,000.
5:20:34 Okay, so when we, I still need more information,
5:20:41 Councilman Munn, please.
5:20:43 So, when we decided to purchase that Rogerson building, you don't know how much it will be to demolish it, to put the plaza in?
5:20:56 Correct.
5:20:57 Okay.
5:20:58 Anything else?
5:20:59 Thank you.
5:21:00 Ladies and gentlemen, I think we've had ample discussion and questions.
5:21:05 So, at this time, I'm going to bring this motion to the vote.
5:21:09 I'm Gailah Rokov.
5:21:10 Sean Berriger.
5:21:11 Yes.
5:21:12 Yes.
5:21:13 Yes.
5:21:14 John Hall.
5:21:15 Yes.
5:21:16 Rebecca Milsweicke.
5:21:17 No.
5:21:18 Suzanne Hawkins.
5:21:19 Yes.
5:21:20 Jim Munn.
5:21:21 Yes.
5:21:22 Motion passes six to one.
5:21:25 We want to address your other issue.
5:21:30 Jim Munn.
5:21:31 Mayor, I would.
5:21:32 Oh, yeah.
5:21:33 Let me just follow my way through this.
5:21:38 Mayor, I would move that we direct staff to proceed with the development of an RFQ for
5:21:46 architects to design, to select an architect to design the banner building for a new city
5:21:57 hall and to ask a selected architect to design a renovation of the current police station
5:22:08 and current city hall into a new police station.
5:22:13 Second time.
5:22:15 Public safety station, same thing.
5:22:17 Yeah, a police complex.
5:22:23 We have a motion on board by Jim Mon,
5:22:25 seconded by Chris talking about it, Chris, and then that.
5:22:28 Get on.
5:22:30 Anything further on that motion council, Rebecca Mills,
5:22:32 so I could.
5:22:33 Yes, question for staff.
5:22:35 It was my understanding, and I could be incorrect in this,
5:22:36 so please correct me if I'm wrong,
5:22:38 that we selected Hummel.
5:22:39 Was that just for preliminary or,
5:22:42 it was my understanding we were going with Humble,
5:22:44 so this is opening it back up?
5:22:46 That is correct.
5:22:47 So what we would do is the Idaho Code requires us
5:22:51 to go out to our request for qualifications process
5:22:55 once you trigger certain dollar figures.
5:22:57 Obviously this would trigger that dollar figures
5:22:59 what we would do is we would submit and publish RFQs.
5:23:02 We would go through a scoring process
5:23:04 just like we do should this motion pass.
5:23:07 And we would then present that ranked list to the council
5:23:12 for its consideration, and then upon the ranked list
5:23:15 of the conclusion of the process,
5:23:17 we would negotiate a contract.
5:23:19 Okay, thank you.
5:23:20 So I thought I heard you say yes, we have selected,
5:23:22 Hummel, but no, we're going to go through this process.
5:23:25 We have not selected.
5:23:26 Okay, just for preliminary, okay.
5:23:28 There's that.
5:23:29 And we're gonna go through the process.
5:23:30 Great landing.
5:23:31 The only question I have, I'm obviously
5:23:32 I'm in favor of the motion, but I'm a little worried
5:23:35 about the wording because as I look up there
5:23:37 chief Clark and he should he come up with a female officer, he has no room for a female
5:23:41 locker room. I think that it has to be a public safety area because I believe that they are
5:23:48 probably going to need to expand into parts of that area.
5:23:51 The only challenge I see in that, Greg, is that once we trigger one female firefighter,
5:23:56 all three stations have to be brought up to that level. Am I correct? Because you
5:24:02 You can't say you're only at that station, they have to be able to do so really when that
5:24:07 gets triggered we have some decisions to make on all three stations, is that correct?
5:24:14 Well we certainly can't deny hiring a female because we don't have that.
5:24:17 Well I'm not saying that we do that, I'm just saying that if that takes place we'll have
5:24:21 to do it on all three stations.
5:24:23 There are temporary stop gap things that we could put in place right now today if we
5:24:29 hired a female firefighter.
5:24:30 Very good.
5:24:31 I did want to exclude the architect looking at what the needs of the fire department is down here by saying police station rather than public safety.
5:24:40 Well, I think you adjusted it to public safety complex, Jim.
5:24:46 Sure.
5:24:47 Did you?
5:24:48 No.
5:24:49 I mean, let me get on my microphone.
5:24:51 This is, as I understand it, this has nothing to do with the fire station.
5:24:59 This has all to do with the current police station and the current city hall into the
5:25:03 development of a new police facility.
5:25:06 Is that where we're at here?
5:25:07 I mean I don't want to get down on the weeds on this because it's 915 but where we at?
5:25:12 The only involvement in the fire station is actually where IS is currently housed and
5:25:17 IS would move out of the fire station.
5:25:20 So there is some renovation of the fire station?
5:25:22 At some point in time.
5:25:23 I would amend my motion to include a public safety which may include the main fire station.
5:25:28 I'll agree with that.
5:25:29 We have an amendment to the, well, just an adjustment to your motion.
5:25:34 Anything further on this motion council?
5:25:36 We have a roll call vote, please.
5:25:40 Chris Talkington?
5:25:40 Yes.
5:25:42 19.
5:25:43 Yes.
5:25:44 Don Hall?
5:25:45 Yes.
5:25:46 Rebecca Milsoica?
5:25:47 Yes.
5:25:49 Susan Hawkins?
5:25:50 Yes.
5:25:51 Jim Young?
5:25:52 Yes.
5:25:53 Sean Beherger?
5:25:54 Yes.
5:25:55 Motion passes seven to zero.
5:25:56 Ladies and gentlemen, I think that's all that we have on the agenda tonight.
5:25:57 Again, a big shout out to our committee.
5:25:59 Thank you for all the time that you spent on this item.
5:26:01 And thanks for everyone coming out this evening.
5:26:04 We are now adjourned.
5:26:13 Wednesday, Kenny Crass.
Download
- Transcript (text) 265 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 355 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 488 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 15, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 05:26:42.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
160c95ab68612ba4f332007cf1dd357c805c62859414acd23eaa359605ac9406 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 29 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
f47d5cf43c0655af2ba8747738cc676f5561f4bd2337a9a9b4095a63ba3bb7c0
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file