OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 6, 2014

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.

Transcript

0:05:56 We are calling the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order, it's October 6th, Monday, it's right at 5 p.m.

0:06:11 And we always start off our meeting with the Pledge of Allegiance, and this evening we have the privilege of a young boy scout that will come up, Dalton, and lead us in the pledge.

0:06:20 So those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:06:22 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:06:42 Dalton, if you could go to the podium, pull that microphone down, face this way, I have

0:06:48 a few questions to ask you.

0:06:50 First, what is your name, sir?

0:06:52 My name is Dalton Mentor.

0:06:54 And you are in the Boy Scouts.

0:06:56 What are you working on this evening?

0:06:57 I am working on citizenship in the community.

0:07:01 What troop are you with?

0:07:02 I'm in troop three.

0:07:05 And where do you meet, sir?

0:07:08 in the Twin Falls 11, or, oh yes, church building.

0:07:16 Okay, very good.

0:07:18 Put you on the spot.

0:07:20 I don't think we have any constitutional questions

0:07:22 this evening, so we really appreciate you coming up here

0:07:25 and leading us in the pledge.

0:07:27 Thank you, young man.

0:07:30 I do want to confirm that we do have a quorum

0:07:32 of the City Council, all seven members

0:07:33 are here this evening.

0:07:35 Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:07:38 Mr. Mayor and members of the Council,

0:07:40 there are no proposed amendments this evening.

0:07:42 Thank you, Mr. Rothweiler.

0:07:44 We have no proclamation, so we start off next

0:07:47 with any general public input.

0:07:49 Is there anyone here this evening

0:07:51 that would like to address the City Council

0:07:53 on something that's not on the agenda?

0:07:57 Anyone like to come forward?

0:08:00 I see no one coming forward,

0:08:01 so I will turn it over to the Council

0:08:03 regarding the consent calendar.

0:08:07 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:08:08 I move approval of the consent calendar as presented.

0:08:12 Second.

0:08:13 We have a motion on the floor by Susanne Hawkins,

0:08:15 seconded by Sean Berger to approve the consent calendar

0:08:18 as posted.

0:08:19 Anything further on that motion council?

0:08:23 Gailah, roll call vote please.

0:08:25 Susan Hawkins.

0:08:26 Yes.

0:08:27 Jim Mann.

0:08:28 Yes.

0:08:29 Sean Berger.

0:08:30 Yes.

0:08:30 Chris Tockenston.

0:08:31 Yes.

0:08:32 Greg Lanci.

0:08:33 Yes.

0:08:34 Don Hall.

0:08:35 Yes.

0:08:36 Rebecca Milsway.

0:08:36 Yes.

0:08:37 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:08:39 And I'm assuming the next item under items for consideration

0:08:42 is why we have such a large crowd here this evening.

0:08:46 But it is the formal pinning ceremony

0:08:48 for Lieutenant's Terry Thuassen and John K. Wilson.

0:08:52 We'll turn it over to our Chief of Police, Brian Pike.

0:08:57 Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council.

0:08:59 It's a real privilege to be here tonight.

0:09:01 This is something that we've been working on for almost two

0:09:04 years.

0:09:05 So I have the honor of presenting to you

0:09:07 our two new attendants, John Wilson and Terry Thuassen.

0:09:11 The position of Lieutenant, although not new to our department,

0:09:14 There's another step in our efforts to create an atmosphere that promotes decision-making and problem-solving at the lion level.

0:09:20 It also consolidates the patrol division into two platoons, each led by a lieutenant and supervised by three sergeants.

0:09:27 The step allows our department to readjust our shift schedule to accommodate a dedicated swing shift.

0:09:33 This adjustment begins the process of placing officers in service when they're needed and ensures better patrol coverage for our community.

0:09:40 It also taps into the senior leadership team of our staff

0:09:43 sergeants to help us plan and direct the department's future,

0:09:46 while ensuring that we're in alignment with our strategic plan

0:09:49 and meeting the needs of our community.

0:09:52 This time I'd like to invite staff sergeant Terry Thuylson

0:09:56 and staff sergeant John Wilson to come forward.

0:10:05 What I'd like to do council as we always do is give you a little

0:10:07 biographical information about each one of our new lieutenants.

0:10:12 I think it's important for you to understand

0:10:14 for the community to understand their background.

0:10:17 After all, it's one of the things that we take great pride in.

0:10:20 I'd like to start with Terry Thuisen.

0:10:22 Terry was born in Jerome Idaho and he grew up here

0:10:25 in Twin Falls just two houses away from Councilman Chris

0:10:28 talking to.

0:10:29 So maybe afterwards we can get together and you've got a

0:10:32 little insight.

0:10:32 Always a ball very safe.

0:10:34 Councilman, maybe we should stop now.

0:10:39 Terry graduated from Twin Falls High School in 1991.

0:10:42 Terry met his best friend in Sweetheart Ana in 1994,

0:10:45 while he was living in Stockton, California, and they were married in June of 1995.

0:10:51 Terry and Ana have four children, Michaela, Andrea, Tiana, and Stephen.

0:10:56 Terry began his career with the Rexburg Police Department in August of 1996,

0:11:00 as their code enforcement and animal control officer.

0:11:03 He was advanced to patrol in October of 1996.

0:11:07 Terry was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department in May of 1998.

0:11:12 Since that time, Terry has served in a number of assignments

0:11:14 within our organization.

0:11:16 He served as a bike officer, a school resource officer,

0:11:21 a bike patrol team member, a SWAT operator and team leader,

0:11:25 a field training officer, a drug recognition expert,

0:11:28 and standard field sobriety testing instructor.

0:11:31 Terry was promoted as sergeant in 2003

0:11:34 and staff sergeant in 2005.

0:11:37 Terry has supervised the patrol squad,

0:11:39 narcotics team, case detectives, our field training program, and our hostage negotiations

0:11:44 unit.

0:11:45 Terry currently holds a post-basic, intermediate, advanced, and supervisory certifications.

0:11:50 And I think this is really interesting.

0:11:53 During his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, Terry took advantage of the

0:11:57 city's tuition reimbursement program, earning his bachelor's degree in criminal justice

0:12:03 from Boise State University in 2006, 2009 Terry graduated from George Fox University

0:12:09 with a master's business degree. John Wilson, John, there's lots of stories, where do I start?

0:12:22 I always bet on John, one way or the other I always bet on John. John was hired by the

0:12:27 Twin Falls Police Department in November 16, 1998 bringing 14 years of law enforcement

0:12:32 experience to our city and his wife, Gloria, and their two sons moved here from California.

0:12:37 Prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, John worked with the Ventura

0:12:40 County Sheriff's Office where he held the California Post Advanced Certification.

0:12:46 John received his Idaho Post Intermediate Certification in March of 1994 while employed

0:12:50 with the Kootenay County Sheriff's Office and received his Advanced Certification in July

0:12:55 of 1999 while employed with us.

0:12:58 During his employment with our department, John has been a DARE officer, a school resource

0:13:02 officer, a gang expert, a drug abuse recognition expert, a field training officer, and he's

0:13:08 been involved in SWAT. John recently completed his associate's degree in criminal justice

0:13:13 through California Coast University. In October of 2002, John was promoted to Staff Sergeant,

0:13:19 one of the only individuals still left in our department that went from officer to Staff

0:13:22 Sergeant. He was transferred to the STAR team in May of 2004. John returned to the Patrol

0:13:29 division in 2006 until he was transferred to his current assignment in the Criminal Investigations

0:13:34 Division in 2011. The position of police lieutenant is the third highest ranked position in our

0:13:41 department. This position is instrumental in building solid working relationships within

0:13:46 and without the department. It's also responsible for directing and overseeing our law enforcement

0:13:51 and prevention strategies. Terry and John are proven leaders within our organization. They're

0:13:56 They're also committed partners interfacing throughout our community.

0:14:00 As Lieutenant State will lead our patrol division.

0:14:03 The patrol division is the largest division of the department and represents the front line of our service delivery.

0:14:09 John and Terry, tonight you're invested with authority to carry out the responsibilities of your position.

0:14:16 Authority will control, but it will not motivate.

0:14:19 Our officers will motivate themselves based on the environment that you create for them.

0:14:25 In addition, this authority does not belong to you.

0:14:27 It belongs to the organization and reports back to the community.

0:14:32 Tonight, your role changes.

0:14:35 Yesterday, our officers worked for you and their respective assignments.

0:14:38 Tonight and beyond, you work for them.

0:14:43 I don't want you to underestimate, because each of you has within you more resources of

0:14:47 energy than you've ever tapped, more talent than you've ever exploited, more strength

0:14:52 than has ever been tested, more to give than you've ever given.

0:14:57 And I think as individuals, you must understand that about yourself and as leaders, you must

0:15:02 understand that of others.

0:15:04 I'm proud of both of you and I know that you will serve our community in a professional

0:15:10 and a dedicated manner.

0:15:13 Tonight is just a little bit different from my normal promotion.

0:15:15 I've asked John's wife, Gloria, and Terry's wife, Anatysus, me and the pinning of Villeton's

0:15:20 bars.

0:15:21 No one makes it on their own and we recognize this as a department.

0:15:24 We all know the support we receive from our spouses, our significant others, and our family

0:15:29 ways to help build the foundation for our success.

0:15:32 And I think we'd be remiss in recognizing that tonight.

0:15:36 Following the pinning of the bars,

0:15:37 I'd ask Mayor Hall to join me in presenting John and Terry

0:15:40 with their new lieutenant badges.

0:18:59 Lieutenant's, both the chief and I have spoken.

0:19:03 We think because of this position that you're now obtaining,

0:19:08 it would be more than appropriate

0:19:09 if you could spend a few minutes and just address the council.

0:19:13 And the rest of the folks in the audience.

0:19:15 I was kind of hoping Terry would start maybe even the tone a little bit, but I've always

0:19:25 had this inner dialogue with myself and now everybody gets to hear it.

0:19:32 Well, we actually were tipped off that this could happen, so we had a little bit of a discussion

0:19:38 about what we would talk about.

0:19:40 We talked about some of the big issues that the police department is facing and has faced.

0:19:46 One of the things that I think is very important is that we continue to work to staff our police department and

0:19:55 This will be something especially during this first year that is really going to be a challenge

0:20:00 for the lieutenants and the sergeants and the officers who are assigned to patrol it's important that we

0:20:07 Continue on with this plan that the chief is set forth to

0:20:11 to have our dedicated swing shift, to provide the level of service to our community that

0:20:19 we say we're going to. And this is going to be something that Terry and I and the

0:20:25 sergeants and the captain have committed to and will continue to commit to in order to

0:20:31 provide that level of service. And I think a year or two years from now we'll look back

0:20:37 and see how this started and feel good about where the police department is and where our

0:20:43 police department is going.

0:20:46 Thank you, Lieutenant.

0:20:47 Well, it's to take more time, so we'll have a few more things for us.

0:20:59 But we were talking with Captain Hicks this afternoon, a number of conversations with the

0:21:05 chief, I think, as a group, as well as one-on-one.

0:21:09 It's really kind of emphasized the amount of change that we're going through organizationally,

0:21:14 organizationally, but not just as the department, but as the city, and we're going through this

0:21:20 change in preparation for the challenges that lie ahead in the near future as well as the

0:21:28 distant future.

0:21:29 I'm just really excited to have the opportunity and really optimistic about the direction we're

0:21:35 going as a department and organization to prepare for those challenges that are coming to us.

0:21:42 talked a little bit about staffing and not just staffing in the police department but as a city

0:21:48 trying to find those innovative ways of delivering the service that we need to that we're promising

0:21:54 the community that we're going to do is going to be a challenge. But I think with the strategic

0:21:59 plan that we have developed with ideas such as DEDACs and starting to take root and move forward

0:22:06 It's an exciting time for the Police Department and just in very honored and pleased and excited to be a part of that.

0:22:15 Thank you Lieutenant.

0:22:19 Sure.

0:22:22 Well it's just it's really weird being up here but these two, these two, to the people in the community, these two now command staff officers are going to do a wonderful job.

0:22:36 And they're true leaders in the department and the community.

0:22:40 And I was reflecting a little bit back on sitting with Terry and

0:22:45 Don when you first came, I interviewed you for the first time in Ellec.

0:22:52 So I'm very, very proud of both of you.

0:22:53 So good luck and let's take the department forward.

0:22:58 I just wanted to say I had the privilege of working with both of you.

0:23:02 I remember the days and what an awesome privilege to sit here when you're

0:23:07 promoted into a command staff position.

0:23:09 And I have full confidence in both of you.

0:23:12 Thank you for taking these positions and moving us forward.

0:23:24 So at this time, we're going to take about a 30 second break

0:23:27 because we know what happens after these events.

0:23:30 So thank you all for being here and supporting

0:23:32 your brothers and sisters in arms.

0:24:09 I think we're at the point where we can go ahead,

0:24:11 especially I have full confidence in our next presenter.

0:24:15 He'll use his Marine Corps voice and addresses.

0:24:19 To request to approve changes to resolution 1711,

0:24:22 to amend the policy established for the sale

0:24:25 and destruction of firearms in the possession

0:24:28 of the Twin Falls Police Department,

0:24:29 and we have Captain Brian Career.

0:24:32 Welcome, Captain.

0:24:35 Thank you, Mayor Councilor.

0:24:40 December, December 2013, we had our last firearms auction

0:24:46 and from that auction, going back and looking

0:24:51 at the state code, comparing it to our current city resolution, there were some minor changes

0:24:59 that needed to take place so that our city resolution would, in fact, reflect accurately

0:25:05 as it's written in state code.

0:25:07 And I think everybody has the packet that identifies those changes and recommendations.

0:25:16 And secondly, the resolution as it currently stands,

0:25:24 I wanted to talk just briefly about the process

0:25:29 when we have in our possession illegal firearms.

0:25:32 The current city resolution talks about

0:25:34 what we do with firearms during that auction process.

0:25:37 And the way I read that sentence,

0:25:42 I wasn't comfortable with the city being

0:25:44 in the position that is currently in.

0:25:46 When we talk about we will sell illegal firearms

0:25:49 once they're sold then before somebody takes possession

0:25:51 of said firearm, we will then make it legal

0:25:56 before they take possession.

0:25:58 And so what I wanted to do is reflect in the change

0:26:03 of that would be that so that nobody would misinterpret

0:26:09 that we are selling illegal firearms.

0:26:12 So the one important part that I want to point out

0:26:15 is that when we talk about, in the new section,

0:26:18 it's section eight, the language that I want to have

0:26:23 brought forward is that any illegal firearm

0:26:25 that can be made legal prior to any sale,

0:26:29 that we would take the steps necessary,

0:26:32 make it legal before advertisement.

0:26:36 In our last firearms process, we had three firearms

0:26:40 that were identified as illegal, that could be made legal,

0:26:44 but they made it on the auction posting

0:26:46 before we could make them legal.

0:26:49 They were since pulled the day of the posting.

0:26:52 They were pulled.

0:26:53 They were made legal.

0:26:54 We spent the dollars to make them legal.

0:26:57 And then they went back up on the auction site.

0:26:59 And so I think that would correct any future issues.

0:27:04 And then lastly, the cost to take an illegal firearm

0:27:10 and convert it to a legal status.

0:27:12 When I'm talking about illegal firearms,

0:27:14 I'm not talking about automatic weapons.

0:27:16 We're talking about weapons that say a shotgun that the barrel is cut too short, if we replace

0:27:20 the shotgun, then the shotgun is now legal.

0:27:23 If the stock is cut too short, if we replace the stock, it is now a legal shotgun for sale.

0:27:29 And we did that with several firearms last year.

0:27:33 The minimum bid is $20 for any licensed firearms dealer to bid.

0:27:39 So part of that $20 is that if we, if the cost of two examples to replace a shotgun stock

0:27:45 to make it legal of $16, then the minimum bid would still be $20 on that shotgun and the

0:27:53 purpose of that is that if we're going to spend line item dollars to make a firearm legal,

0:28:01 then I think it's only appropriate that we recoup at least that $16 or $20 or $25 at

0:28:05 the cost as a minimum bid.

0:28:09 I can tell you that last year or December and the fire, the closing of the auction, we sold

0:28:13 approximately 90 firearms, $8,300 was generated to the General Fund, and $4,700 was generated

0:28:20 back to the Asset Forebature Fund.

0:28:22 The Asset Forebature Firearms, those are firearms that are seized in drug cases, and so the revenue

0:28:28 from that can only go back to the Asset Forebature account to be used for the sole purpose of the

0:28:34 furthest drug investigations.

0:28:38 So those are the changes that I propose.

0:28:40 This has been reviewed by Fris with his blessing, and so I bring up a for you for your consideration.

0:28:49 What is the resolution number if we're just amending 1711, is that correct, to be a whole

0:28:57 new number?

0:28:58 What would that be?

0:29:03 Can you research that while we're asking some questions?

0:29:08 Chris Dockinga.

0:29:09 Captain, I've been through this before and still have my tail feathers singed.

0:29:16 This is an improvement over our original wording in the city bill that caused quite

0:29:22 concerned by people that didn't think there was an appropriate, the people in the firearm

0:29:27 cell business that there's not an appropriate opportunity for some of them to bid on it,

0:29:34 to purchase a legal, a safe weapon.

0:29:38 I'm wondering if you see any merit on the last section, number nine, that refers currently

0:29:48 as proposed to any firearm not sold after being offered for sale at two auctions shall be destroyed.

0:29:58 I would hope that we could find another way to sit.

0:30:01 There's a market for these safe-approved weapons by an electronic auction or other means maybe

0:30:09 of it were not really thinking about now, is there anything wrong with that?

0:30:13 I personally don't have issue with any firearm not sold up to two offerings for auction would

0:30:19 be destroyed.

0:30:21 I think it's a good safety net for the city, but I can tell you that the firearms auctions

0:30:28 that we've had in the past and the ones since I've taken over property evidence again, we

0:30:33 have never had a firearm that hasn't been auctioned.

0:30:38 There's an interest in police sees firearms auctions.

0:30:43 And I was really amazed that there was even some firearms

0:30:48 that a firearms person that's interested in them

0:30:53 wouldn't spend $20 on how much money that these guys

0:30:56 were bid on the firearms.

0:30:57 So I think it's a good safety net to have as an in case.

0:31:05 But as history's shown at least me,

0:31:08 we don't have firearms that come back to us from the auction.

0:31:12 had any that have not been sold at auction to an approved licensed auctioneer.

0:31:18 None that I'm aware of since I've been involved in property and evidence. This is my second time

0:31:22 of having property and evidence. I had a couple of years separation from it with some other

0:31:26 assignments and then I've taken it back about three and a half years ago.

0:31:30 You think of any other way under the absurd eventuality that we have a firearm not sold

0:31:35 that we might realize some income off of it. Let's say an exotic model. Let's say a collector

0:31:43 to the doctor's item.

0:31:47 Are you asking if it doesn't sell?

0:31:52 I'm just wondering if the local market is large enough under the potential for an exotic safe authorized firearm to be sold other than Justin Twin Falls.

0:32:06 Here's the experience that we had.

0:32:08 On the last auction, the one we did in December, we actually planned us out to benefit any of the members that would be qualified to purchase.

0:32:16 qualified to purchase was during Christmas time, prior to Christmas.

0:32:22 Many of the firearms dealers that express to us that there are some of their biggest sales

0:32:26 come around the Christmas time frame, which was really beneficial to us at the police department.

0:32:33 Almost guaranteeing that we would have no firearms, we'd turn back from auction, but the auction

0:32:39 company that we use is a local auction company and they reach out worldwide.

0:32:43 We had several auctions.

0:32:44 A lot of firearms were sold to firearms dealers from back east.

0:32:49 Firearms that have no interest in our area were bid on from firearms dealers from all

0:32:54 over the world.

0:32:56 And are there usually more than one bid or is it just matter on the vehicle or on the

0:33:06 instrument?

0:33:07 It depends on the firearm and the interests of the firearm.

0:33:09 There are some that are collectors modeled.

0:33:12 We sold a firearm that was fairly functional, but because of its age, it needed grips, it needed some gun smithing work, and there was a huge bidding war on it.

0:33:24 So I think the opportunity is there for any firearms dealer.

0:33:28 We do advertise locally to all the firearms dealers, but through the auction company, they also advertise to all of their firearms dealers.

0:33:38 So they can reach far many more dealers than we can even imagine.

0:33:42 So, Captain, just so that I have clarification, I think I heard you right, we actually use an auction company to auction these, and they do, they're worldwide.

0:33:51 Yes.

0:33:52 So, folks locally have the opportunity to bid on these, as well as throughout the world.

0:33:58 Correct.

0:33:59 Very good.

0:34:00 As long as they're licensed.

0:34:01 As long as they're licensed.

0:34:02 Yes.

0:34:03 They have to be a licensed, and they have to be able to prove through the auction company, they actually have to register with the auction company to show their credentials.

0:34:10 Very good.

0:34:11 And upon sale, we actually get a copy of the FFL, and then they signed a release of identification

0:34:17 to the city.

0:34:18 So we have those records as well, which firearms dealer purchased, which specific or multiple

0:34:23 firearms?

0:34:24 So I think I'm a little sensitive about this issue as well.

0:34:28 I wasn't on council at the time, but I had to appear on the radio after this issue when

0:34:32 I was working for the police department.

0:34:34 Do you see any holes in this policy that might be detrimental to the policy with firearms owners?

0:34:41 Do you see anything that, I mean, you've been in this game for a while, Brian, and you've

0:34:46 been in a property disposal for a while, do you see anything that we're not seeing here?

0:34:51 I don't.

0:34:52 And I rely heavily upon our city's legal team to review.

0:34:59 I will tell you that we have had several instances where we have found firearms.

0:35:05 So we do an ATF trace on it, go back and find the original owner.

0:35:09 Some of those owners don't know, don't remember who they sold that firearm to.

0:35:12 So we can't track down current ownership of that lost firearm.

0:35:16 And our goal in property devidences to return the property to its rightful owner.

0:35:20 And we take all the measures that we have available to us to find the owner.

0:35:27 So it's not so much a whole, maybe it's just a little bit of discomfort.

0:35:31 When you look at a highly valued firearm and you don't know where it belongs.

0:35:39 can't find out where it belongs. But I'm also comforted knowing that it's going to

0:35:43 make itself its way to a licensed dealer.

0:35:46 Very good. Leila, did we come up with the resolution number?

0:35:51 1932. Say that one more time. 1932. 1932. Thank you. Council have any further questions

0:35:58 for Captain? Jim? Move approval resolution 1932 is written. Second. We have motion on

0:36:10 for by Jim Munn, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve resolution 1932 anything

0:36:17 further on that motion council. I just want to state that I appreciate the time

0:36:23 and effort that you put into this and and this is an issue near and dear to a

0:36:29 lot of folks' hearts so I appreciate the time that you put into it.

0:36:34 Lee Island, roll call vote, please. Jim Munn. Yes. Sean Baraker. Yes. Chris

0:36:39 No. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milsoyka. Yes. Suzanne Hocken. Yes.

0:36:48 Motion passes. Six to one. Thank you, Captain. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is a request

0:36:55 to authorize the mayor to sign the award document for the Idaho Bureau of Homeland Security Emergency

0:37:02 Communication Commission grant in the amount of $28,765. And we have Lieutenant Craig Stott's

0:37:09 make a presentation. Welcome, Lieutenant.

0:37:11 Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council. I'm here in Mandy Thompson's place as our

0:37:19 grant coordinator. She couldn't be here tonight, so I've sent in her place to do that. Really,

0:37:27 what we have in our request is to obtain some grant funds that we have been awarded. Again,

0:37:35 And it just needs to be a signature of the mayor to go ahead with that.

0:37:39 And this grant would be used to replace some mapping software that we need to upgrade our

0:37:47 mobile components in our police car.

0:37:51 It's the mapping systems in the mobile units in the police cars.

0:37:56 They have not been upgraded for some time.

0:38:01 The current version of our CAD system is they don't make that mapping software anymore.

0:38:09 So unfortunately we would have to move forward with an upgrade and in the background of proposal

0:38:15 we have two options.

0:38:18 Number one is we're looking at purchasing a new CAD system for dispatch.

0:38:23 Our original CAD system was installed in 2003.

0:38:28 So it's served us well, however, there are some things that we are looking for in a new

0:38:33 CAD system.

0:38:36 And as technology changes, we all know, it changes rapidly.

0:38:42 So we're at a point now where we're looking at replacing the CAD system.

0:38:46 We can do that with E9L1 fees that we collect, however this grant would not allow us to actually

0:38:53 purchase the CAD software, just the mapping piece of it.

0:38:59 So the option one is to use those funds for the new mapping

0:39:05 software, which will work with different vendors.

0:39:08 And that's the other thing.

0:39:09 When you go out and you're looking for CAD software, some

0:39:12 of the vendors supply the mapping, and others use third

0:39:17 party vendors.

0:39:18 So we're at a point where we haven't decided, obviously,

0:39:22 what direction we're going to go, yeah, there's several options out there.

0:39:25 So we're in the process now of doing our due diligence and doing the research on that CAD

0:39:30 piece.

0:39:31 However, this mapping software, we can use it to, number one, upgrade our existing.

0:39:39 If we do get and go with the CAD vendor that supplies their own mapping, this is option two.

0:39:48 We would then return that grant with no penalty to the city for doing so.

0:39:57 Our recommendation is that we approve the grant so that it is available if, in fact, we do need it.

0:40:06 And if we don't, then we return that to the state.

0:40:11 Do we have any questions for Lieutenant Stott's?

0:40:15 Rebecca Mels like it.

0:40:16 Thank you, Mayor.

0:40:18 Is there a large cost difference between option one and two?

0:40:23 Or is the consideration just a preference of system?

0:40:28 It depends on what vendor you go with.

0:40:31 I mean, there's a huge difference in cost, depending on which vendor you do go with.

0:40:36 And like I said, there's several vendors out there.

0:40:39 You can get into CAD systems that could cost you easily three-quarters of a million dollars.

0:40:44 So, that's obviously not a direction that we're looking at going.

0:40:50 We can accomplish that with a system that's far less than that.

0:40:57 So, the upgrade, like is discussed in Option 2, we have funds available from a grant that

0:41:05 we applied for back in 2013, which is around just under $50,000, which we can use to upgrade

0:41:14 our existing CAD to that new platform.

0:41:21 And then this piece would then be returned.

0:41:24 Okay, so there's no financial advantage to option one or two?

0:41:29 Option one, that would be obviously go and purchase

0:41:32 a new CAD system which we would be using

0:41:35 the emergency communications 911 fees

0:41:38 that we collect to pay for that.

0:41:40 So there would be no cost to the taxpayer.

0:41:44 Okay, and then you said there's no penalty

0:41:45 for returning grant funds.

0:41:48 does that affect you when you apply in future years,

0:41:50 or do they not consider that?

0:41:53 I don't know.

0:41:54 I couldn't ask that.

0:41:55 We have had this discussion with the people

0:41:57 that have we've been working with on the grant,

0:41:59 and they are aware that because that portion got stripped out,

0:42:04 actually the purchase of the CAD,

0:42:06 they understand the position we're in.

0:42:08 And it may or may not be used,

0:42:12 depending on what direction we go.

0:42:13 Sure, okay.

0:42:14 I was just wondering if it might affect us

0:42:16 in future applications, but hopefully not then.

0:42:20 Travis, you look like you wanted to weigh in,

0:42:22 but I'd say, you know, based upon our current conversations,

0:42:26 we don't believe it'll have a future impact,

0:42:28 but it's probably gonna largely depend upon the timing

0:42:31 and those who are reviewing the applications

0:42:33 at some point in the future.

0:42:35 Thank you.

0:42:36 Thank you, sir.

0:42:37 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:42:39 How soon do you anticipate making a decision

0:42:41 on which way to go?

0:42:43 Well, I'm gonna be attending a seminar

0:42:47 in about two weeks up in Boise where they have a large vendor base that we can research

0:42:54 and you know review their products, it really is just going to depend on our IS team from

0:43:06 a technical perspective and then the administration from what it is we need to get out of the

0:43:12 system. This part of the problem is not being able to get information out of the system. Like

0:43:19 I said, because it's just outdated, we've changed, we've grown. So we're going to be looking at

0:43:24 those options. So, so IT will be working with you and helping make sure we get what we need.

0:43:30 Absolutely. Okay. Thank you. Chris talking. I would move to authorize a mayor to sign the award

0:43:36 document for the Idaho Bureau of Homeland Security Emergency Communication Commission grant in the

0:43:40 the amount of twenty eight thousand seven sixty-five

0:43:44 most of the floor by christalia seconded by great landing

0:43:49 anything further

0:43:50 other local please

0:43:53 some bear yes

0:43:55 has talking yes

0:43:56 great landing yes

0:43:58 don hall yes

0:43:59 but they can also get yes

0:44:01 susan hawkins yes

0:44:02 jim mind yes

0:44:03 what's passed seven to zero thank you lieutenant

0:44:07 let us know the

0:44:08 the outcome

0:44:11 Next time on the agenda is discussion on the upcoming audit for the City of Twin Falls for

0:44:17 fiscal year 2013 through 2014.

0:44:22 Looks like Travis Rothweiler is up first but I show Lori race as well.

0:44:26 Mr. Mayor we're on item number four.

0:44:29 I crossed the wrong one out.

0:44:31 Thank you for, I was wondering why Lori was not up here.

0:44:35 Thank you.

0:44:36 Let me, let me, yeah, I was just testing.

0:44:37 You just wanted me to hear talking about the audit before me.

0:44:40 I'm Jim's very excited about the audit, so I didn't want to put that off.

0:44:45 I am happy to sit down and do my part.

0:44:50 Alright, let's try this again.

0:44:51 Let's try this again.

0:44:52 Request to hire Region 4 Development Corporation to serve as a grant administrator for the City of Twin Falls

0:44:58 on Idaho Community Development Block Grants received for the Cliff Bar Project.

0:45:03 Travis Rothweiler.

0:45:04 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, I certainly will not take much time

0:45:08 not take much time so that we can immediately get to the pre-audit conversation and presentation

0:45:12 shortly.

0:45:14 What you have before you is an agreement with the Region 4 Development Corporation to assist

0:45:20 us in oversight of the various grants that we have with the Idaho Department of Commerce

0:45:25 in particular, the CDBG's that we have for the Cliff Bar Project.

0:45:29 As you're aware, Region 4 Development Corporation has been the group that has helped us not only

0:45:33 prepare the applications but also be with us as a partner and presentation in presenting

0:45:38 those applications to the state and to the advisory commission.

0:45:44 What is important is that we go forward and we can account for the various funds and as

0:45:53 they come in we've made certain job commitments or Cliff Bar has made certain job commitments

0:45:58 then we want to make sure that they have and be certain low to moderate income requirements.

0:46:05 So even though that we have a grant administrator on board, we believe that it's important to

0:46:09 have that assistance from Carleen and her team who had to go through the Cliff Bar Project

0:46:16 in a very, very similar manner.

0:46:18 And Carleen in the past as well as others from Region 4 have shared that intricate process

0:46:24 that they used and Carleen is also here.

0:46:26 And you mean Chobani?

0:46:28 Chobani, yes, sorry.

0:46:29 Okay.

0:46:30 So we've had to do for Chobani and that what we will have to do for Cliff Bar moving forward.

0:46:36 You'll notice that the term of the agreement is for the length and it's to ensure that based

0:46:41 upon the hiring schedules, we have the opportunity to fully account for all of those jobs as

0:46:47 we move forward.

0:46:48 And again, this is just a recognition and agreement for the cost of helping with those

0:46:53 grants and other projects as they may come forward.

0:46:56 Carleen Herring with Region 4 is here,

0:46:58 and she can assist with any questions

0:47:01 and have any things to add that you have moving forward.

0:47:05 Thank you, Travis.

0:47:06 Do we have any questions, Council?

0:47:11 Stand for a motion.

0:47:12 Greg Meimov that we approve the hiring

0:47:15 of Region 4 Development Corporation Service Grant

0:47:17 and Ministry for the City of Twin Falls

0:47:18 on the Edo Community Development Block Grants

0:47:21 received from the Cliff Bar Project.

0:47:25 Second.

0:47:26 It's not for by Greg Lanning, executive by Chris Talkington, as stated.

0:47:30 Greg Lanning.

0:47:31 I would like to commend Carlene and her staff for the times that when

0:47:36 a rhyme was mare and took me up and led me through the process.

0:47:39 Whenever I had to present for these community block drafts,

0:47:44 we were pretty good-shaped to get them, but there was always that little bit of moment

0:47:47 as you were standing in front of that assembled group.

0:47:50 He too makes the decision that, hey, I'm not going to get this.

0:47:54 a little more like a fool, and Carlin talking out of that thought process, so thank you, Carlin.

0:48:00 Thank you, Greg.

0:48:01 John Berger?

0:48:02 I do have a question on the two different parts of the project.

0:48:07 We have different items in the agreement that will be handled and some that won't.

0:48:12 Can you just maybe quickly clarify for me why they're different, please?

0:48:18 Sure, Mayor and Council, thanks for the opportunity.

0:48:21 The reason we've got two different scopes of work is that we have broken up the tasks

0:48:25 that are required by the Community Development Block Grant Program into two separate pieces

0:48:30 that fit best with the schedule of construction.

0:48:35 Some items take a longer construction period, therefore we've provided the city with that

0:48:39 oversight of those task items to coincide with that lengthier construction period.

0:48:46 One thing that isn't currently in this agreement that I spoke with, both the engineer and Jackie

0:48:51 about it earlier is that there will be acquisition.

0:48:53 If you notice in the scope of work on the lift station, the wastewater improvements, we have

0:48:58 that acquisition is not applicable.

0:49:00 It's now applicable.

0:49:01 So we've adjusted our cost within that same total budget number to accommodate that additional

0:49:07 task item.

0:49:09 So again, some of those things just fell better with the wastewater versus the electrical project.

0:49:14 The Davis-Bacon specifically is a big construction project.

0:49:18 I'd hope Howard doesn't need to pay Davis-Bacon therefore there's no labor standards compliance associated with that task.

0:49:24 Great. Thank you.

0:49:26 Thank you, Carling.

0:49:28 I just wanted to state that I am in full agreement with this motion.

0:49:32 Your services for these activities are invaluable.

0:49:37 And I guess we could probably try to take this on ourselves, but we wouldn't have a grant writer anymore.

0:49:43 She would be doing this full-time and we'd be weeding our way through the process when you already have a method and

0:49:50 A track record that's been outstanding for the city. So thank you. Thank you. I appreciate that on the side note

0:49:56 Mandy and I have talked about having her shadow some of the items so that she's more familiar with it

0:50:01 She was at the block grant training

0:50:04 She now understands a little bit more about what the weeds look like

0:50:07 So we will be working with her directly, as well as on other community projects that she has undertaken.

0:50:14 Thank you, Caroline. Appreciate that.

0:50:17 I see no further lights. We have a roll call vote, please.

0:50:20 Chris, talking to Greg Lansing.

0:50:22 Yes.

0:50:23 Don Hall.

0:50:24 Yes.

0:50:25 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:50:27 Yes.

0:50:28 Jim Munn.

0:50:29 Yes.

0:50:30 Sean Berger.

0:50:31 Yes.

0:50:32 Motion passes 7-0. Now moving on to Jim's item.

0:50:34 on the upcoming audit for the City of Twin Falls for fiscal year 2013-2014, Lori Race.

0:50:39 Welcome, Lori.

0:50:40 What a long password for, wow.

0:50:50 She's an accountant.

0:50:53 That is.

0:50:54 That is.

0:50:55 What's the question here?

0:51:07 So good evening mayor and city council.

0:51:10 Every year after the annual audit has been completed, we invite our independent auditors

0:51:15 to come and present the audit to you, along with their opinion and findings about our

0:51:19 financial records. And this year, we'll still be doing that, but tonight we wanted to share

0:51:26 some audit information before the fact. So independent audits are vital part of accounting.

0:51:36 They're performed to ensure the validity and reliability of information as well as to

0:51:41 provide an assessment of a system's internal control. The goal of an audit is to express

0:51:48 an opinion on the organization in question under evaluation based on work done on a test

0:51:54 basis. An audit must adhere to auditing standards generally accepted in the United States of

0:52:01 America, and the standards applicable to financial audits contained in government auditing standards

0:52:08 issued by the Comptroller General of the United States. These standards assure third parties

0:52:14 or external users that they can rely upon the auditor's opinion on the fairness of financial

0:52:20 statements or other subjects on which the auditor expresses an opinion.

0:52:34 So let's talk about internal controls.

0:52:37 First of all, internal controls are the responsibility of management.

0:52:42 It's our responsibility to review, prepare and implement them, and continually evaluate

0:52:49 their effectiveness, continually evaluate their effectiveness.

0:52:55 Internal controls should be defined as the reviews, the checks and balances, and the methods

0:53:02 and procedures we have in place to enable the city to safeguard its assets.

0:53:07 They allow us to conduct our business in an orderly and efficient manner, safeguard our

0:53:13 assets and resources, deter and detect errors, fraud and death, ensure accuracy and completeness

0:53:21 of our accounting information, produce reliable and timely financial and management information,

0:53:28 and ensure adherence to our policies and plans.

0:53:32 The most effective procedures are those that have the greatest segregation of duties.

0:53:37 The more people involved in the process, the less likely it is that an error will occur.

0:53:46 So that's pretty textbook stuff.

0:53:49 And what I really want to do is just share with you some examples of the segregation

0:53:53 of duties, reviews, and checks and balances in place at the city.

0:53:59 So for instance, our utility billing cash shares accept payments, but they cannot make

0:54:05 adjustments to a utility account.

0:54:09 All billing adjustments are prepared by the billing clerk, then reviewed and approved

0:54:14 by their immediate supervisor.

0:54:17 The person in charge of reconciling our cash account

0:54:20 does not accept cash payments or pay the bills.

0:54:23 He opens the statements, he brings them to me,

0:54:26 for my review and signature,

0:54:28 proceeds to reconcile the accounts,

0:54:30 then has the Assistant Finance Director

0:54:33 review those reconciliations.

0:54:35 Also, our statements are reconciled by the 15th

0:54:38 of the following month.

0:54:40 Timely reconciliations help you to catch problems.

0:54:44 The Assistant Finance Director reviews the sequence of payroll checks, tracks the number

0:54:49 of checks written, and reviews, oh, I am falling behind, we're going backwards, let me just catch

0:54:55 up.

0:54:56 It's so important to have your finger on the right key.

0:55:02 So the Assistant Finance Director reviews the sequence of payroll checks, tracks the number

0:55:07 of checks written, and reviews payroll documents, departments pick up their checks for distribution

0:55:12 to their employees, and each new full-time employee has an appointment with the payroll

0:55:18 clerk to come in and set up their payroll.

0:55:22 Chex to vendors are reviewed, approved, and coded by each department.

0:55:28 After invoices are entered into the system, a member of the finance team, other than our

0:55:33 accounts payable clerk, and the city manager review the payable listing in detail, and then

0:55:39 it's reviewed by each of you each week before distribution.

0:55:44 Every time I initiate a transaction through the state investment pool, email notifications

0:55:50 are immediately sent to Travis, Brent Hyatt, and Shane Carpenter.

0:55:55 Whether I'm making a withdrawal or a contribution, they're immediately notified of that that's

0:56:00 occurred.

0:56:03 Every month, I thoroughly review and compare online with the tax-supported funds budget

0:56:09 to actual information.

0:56:11 I also do this for our enterprise funds and I report that information to Travis.

0:56:17 Every quarter I stand up in a public meeting and provide a financial report on the revenues

0:56:23 and expenditures of the City of Twin Falls.

0:56:26 You review budget to actual information before each and every update.

0:56:31 One point that Brent made to me was the culture at the City of Twin Falls.

0:56:38 We do not have an attitude of being complacent.

0:56:41 I would challenge you to drop a piece of personal mail in the mailbox that doesn't have a stamp

0:56:46 on it.

0:56:47 I challenge you to go to the front desk and try to cash a personal check.

0:56:52 This is not an all-inclusive listing of our internal controls.

0:56:58 I've asked Scott Hunsaker and Susan Klein to attend this evening to share their objective

0:57:03 review and observations, and afterwards, Brent, Scott, Susan, and I would stand for any questions

0:57:09 you might have.

0:57:11 Thanks, Laurie.

0:57:12 Welcome.

0:57:16 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

0:57:17 Council, it's good to be with you this evening.

0:57:21 This is a little bit different.

0:57:23 We're here a little bit early.

0:57:24 Normally we're here in a couple months and presenting the audit, but I think this is a

0:57:27 good healthy discussion to talk a little bit about internal controls and what our role

0:57:32 is in those internal controls.

0:57:35 Just as Laurie stated, the internal controls are is a management function.

0:57:40 And then we as auditors, as external auditors, come in and evaluate and test those controls.

0:57:49 So that's a two-part process.

0:57:50 The evaluation happens and occurs with us discussing with staff what controls exist and

0:57:58 get an idea as to how the controls are working and functioning.

0:58:03 Throughout this process, we determine if they're strong enough or there's room for improvement

0:58:08 in different areas.

0:58:09 And at that time, we can make suggestions and comment on those and try to assist in improving

0:58:15 those controls.

0:58:17 The second step in that process, once we understand the internal controls, is we test the transactions.

0:58:23 We've talked a little bit about that at the end of the audit that we'll select samples

0:58:27 of transactions that we'll go through and make sure that they comply with the controls

0:58:32 that have been established.

0:58:35 But as I said, it's a sampling.

0:58:38 We select different types of transactions, whether they're checks or payroll or those types

0:58:43 of things to make sure you're in compliance with your own internal controls.

0:58:48 So that's kind of what we do.

0:58:52 The question arose, what if we were to find an issue?

0:58:55 There's two different items that we're doing here.

0:58:58 During the evaluation process, often we can find things that need improvement.

0:59:04 It depends on the level of that finding as to how we'd handle that.

0:59:10 If it's a small tweak to the internal control, it would probably just be handled with the finance

0:59:14 department and that would be handled prospectively and going forward and things would be changed.

0:59:19 If it's a significant deficiency or there's a problem that could compromise the city's

0:59:25 assets, that could be noted in the audit report.

0:59:30 And if you look at your audit report, the very end of it, there's an internal control

0:59:34 document and that's where you'd notice those types of things that we we know

0:59:38 that there's a deficiency and then there would be a management response to

0:59:43 that deficiency and how management intends to overcome that deficiency.

0:59:48 Then the following year we would go back and test that deficiency and see if it

0:59:53 was come and then that would be resolved. So just so you kind of understand how it

0:59:57 would come to your attention. The second item that can happen is during our

1:00:03 testing we may find instances of non-compliance, where transactions may have been handled, didn't

1:00:11 follow these controls, it had been established. Again, it kind of depends on the type of transaction

1:00:18 and what's going on. Generally, we would expand our test. We would select more of a sample and

1:00:24 get a larger population to test and see if that was a one-time occurrence or more. After

1:00:30 We've done that. We would discuss it with almost always the level above where that transaction

1:00:36 took place. That could be with the City Finance Department. If it was in their own department,

1:00:40 we would discuss it with Travis or with the City Council, just depending where we're

1:00:45 at in that process. The same thing could occur that those instances would be noted in not

1:00:50 a report when we would find instances of non-compliance. So that's kind of how the processes work as

1:00:57 an external auditor and what we would do to test your internal controls.

1:01:06 Now just a little bit of our opinion as to how the city handles transactions.

1:01:13 We've been very impressed with the city's internal controls.

1:01:17 Very proactive in how they handle the staff handles transactions and several things give

1:01:24 me comfort as to how things are being handled.

1:01:27 you've hired very qualified staff that have been educated and know accounting and know

1:01:34 what internal controls are. That's a significant thing and many of the entities around don't

1:01:39 have that luxury. And so that's a great thing from your perspective.

1:01:44 Second, Laurie did mention it, is your internal controls are a dynamic thing. They're always

1:01:51 changing which is great often in entities and total control gets set and established and

1:01:58 they never change.

1:02:00 And with technology and different personnel, things can happen that there needs to be adjustments

1:02:05 regularly.

1:02:07 And staff here at the city has evaluated and adjusted things very regularly and it's very

1:02:14 good to see and it gives us some comfort that it's an active thing.

1:02:20 And then I was also mentioned as the control environment of the city.

1:02:24 There's a very low tolerance for non-compliance, which is great to see.

1:02:31 The tone at the top, they call it, is very good and it's established and very good.

1:02:38 So kind of in conclusion, internal controls are really just to lower the risk of potential

1:02:44 misstatements and problems.

1:02:47 internal control system can be full-proof. There's always potential problems with

1:02:55 collusion or other things that can get people to get around these types of things.

1:02:58 But really we're just here to try to lower the risk and minimize the risk. But

1:03:03 from our perspective the city has done a very good job in establishing and

1:03:07 monitoring the controls that have been established. So if you have any questions

1:03:12 Do we have any questions for either Scott or Lori?

1:03:17 We're stopping it.

1:03:18 I'm pleased and happy that our internal controls within City Hall make sense so far as reconciling

1:03:27 payments and cash.

1:03:30 Twin Falls has some peripheral operations and I'm speaking parks, recreation, swimming in particular

1:03:37 around even PSI. Are there cases, or is it standard practice to allow payments in the field

1:03:45 in any of those situations of parks and rec and PSI and elaborate on the reconciliation at the

1:03:54 swimming pool when kids come in with cash?

1:03:58 So I'm going to cover the two outside partners first, and I'm going to let me talk about the

1:04:02 website partner in terms of parks and recreation to talk about that.

1:04:08 So number one, with PSI, any billing that PSI does they do as an independent party.

1:04:15 The city of Twin Falls provides solid waste services to its residential customers.

1:04:22 Those residential customers pay that bill to the city of Twin Falls as part of their larger utility bill.

1:04:29 So they're not collecting any of those funds.

1:04:32 We do bill for additional cans and those types of things, but that is done separate and

1:04:37 independent of the city and is done in relationship to a specific contractual

1:04:43 relationship between PSI for that extra can and that particular customer.

1:04:48 How about at the transfer station of a city resident where to take a load to the transfer station?

1:04:53 The transfer station again is outside of our responsibility and scope of control.

1:04:57 So we can only have, I think what's important to recognize is we can

1:05:02 We only have the controls and for the functions in which we are responsible for.

1:05:09 The transfer station is not one of those functions that falls under the guidance or

1:05:13 the direction of the city of Twin Falls.

1:05:15 It falls under the guidance and direction of the county.

1:05:18 So I think that that's important.

1:05:20 The swimming pool is a equal thing as well.

1:05:23 The swimming pool is managed on our behalf by the YMCA.

1:05:30 funds that they collect are required to go through their books, they never enter into

1:05:35 our processes.

1:05:38 They come and they make an annual report to you as part of that compliance, but in terms

1:05:44 of how their internal controls are set up at the YMCA, PSI is really more respective

1:05:52 of their independent entities and how they control their resources.

1:05:58 I will have Lori talk about what we do with other entities, such as Parks and Rec or the

1:06:10 Building Department that are specifically under the city's umbrella.

1:06:16 So Chris, I think about Parks and Recreation piece similar to if somebody brings cash to

1:06:23 the front counter.

1:06:26 So if somebody brings cash to the front counter and they don't ring that in on that person's

1:06:32 account, then in 30 days time that person's going to come and say, hey, I paid my bill

1:06:38 and I don't have credit for it.

1:06:43 At the Parks and Recreation Department, I know that Shane Carpenter has made some changes

1:06:50 to how that all interacts.

1:06:52 And I've asked Brantiff maybe he wanted to come up and visit about that a little bit.

1:06:57 So they have their own software system, Parks and Recreation.

1:07:03 But they provide reports and all kinds of information to the Finance Department that Shane reconciles.

1:07:10 So.

1:07:11 But they do make payments on occasion in the field, the customers, the kids.

1:07:16 Well, when you say the field, it's at the Parks and Recreation Department or online, they can register online.

1:07:22 Nothing on a baseball field, though.

1:07:24 No.

1:07:25 Nothing in a soccer field.

1:07:26 No.

1:07:27 Nothing in the middle of the night in the alley.

1:07:29 No.

1:07:30 Okay.

1:07:31 The cash at the falls.

1:07:33 So the cash at the falls, we give out tickets that are sequentially numbered.

1:07:40 So, they put their tickets in their bag and they put their cash in their bag and they deposit

1:07:47 that at the bank.

1:07:49 Then we get that information back and we check the sequential lumbering of the tickets and

1:07:54 count the number of tickets times three bucks for admission or twenty bucks for the bus and

1:07:59 reconcile that too.

1:08:00 Did you want Brandt to come up?

1:08:03 Did you have anything to add to it?

1:08:09 You don't have to.

1:08:10 You know, I'm so sorry, it is.

1:08:14 Can you see my regard?

1:08:16 Nothing substantive to offer.

1:08:19 I think we've a couple of thoughts

1:08:22 that I've had just in a broad brush stroke,

1:08:25 because we inherited a structure that

1:08:29 was kind of enhanced by Gary Evans.

1:08:33 Gary Evans had been a successful auditor for decades.

1:08:37 and his footprint still exists in the city.

1:08:40 And we do evaluate and modify this things change,

1:08:44 but we really do have a terrific internal control system.

1:08:49 Those instances where there's some weaknesses

1:08:52 or the potential of the falls is a great place.

1:08:54 Gate receives with one person, you know,

1:08:56 it's really a high-risk area.

1:09:02 And I think I thought it was fascinating,

1:09:05 last, not this summer, but the summer before, we reconciled those on a daily basis, as Lori

1:09:11 mentioned. And we had an instance where we were $100 short. And we couldn't figure out

1:09:17 how or why it just didn't fit. And as we were in the process of trying to determine exactly

1:09:25 why we were approached by the bank and they said, were you $100 short? Yeah. And they indicated

1:09:31 that they had had internal problem and it wasn't our fault,

1:09:37 but the $100 that was missing happened outside of the city,

1:09:40 but it was just fascinating to me that that's how in tune,

1:09:45 that check and balance was.

1:09:49 So, and we've done what we can.

1:09:51 I don't know, I can't really think of anything.

1:09:54 And we respect the internal controls as Scott indicated.

1:09:59 It's one thing to have them.

1:10:02 And sometimes for us who live under them,

1:10:04 that's a little bit of a burden.

1:10:06 So you're tempted to bypass those.

1:10:09 And that's when the system, you know,

1:10:11 becomes breaks down a little bit.

1:10:15 And we have a high respect, you know,

1:10:18 for those in control controls.

1:10:19 I don't see any instances within the city

1:10:22 of my fellow employees, you know,

1:10:26 bypassing those or trying to take shortcuts

1:10:28 so that they can get their work done more efficiently

1:10:32 without the control zone.

1:10:33 That's just the observation.

1:10:35 Thank you, Grant.

1:10:37 Lori, I have a question for you.

1:10:40 As you were talking about, or as we were discussing

1:10:43 some of those other areas where Chris mentioned

1:10:46 going out to the transfer station,

1:10:49 I've been out there before and they always ask you

1:10:51 the question, do you want to recede?

1:10:53 Now it strikes me as, why shouldn't you just give me

1:10:57 receipt, you know, because I'm giving cash. Cash is always the, that's the risk, isn't it?

1:11:04 You bet it is.

1:11:05 So if someone was to come and pay cash in one of our venues that we're responsible for, do

1:11:11 we give them the option of having a receipt or do we give them a receipt?

1:11:14 We are printing out that when we're doing the transaction, a receipt is printing. They don't

1:11:19 have to take it with them, but that receipt is printing.

1:11:22 Okay. And maybe it's the same thing at the transfer station. I'm certainly not trying to

1:11:26 saying anything but it just always struck me weird that they even asked the question

1:11:30 I would just think that they want to give us automatically you don't have to take it

1:11:34 but here it is yes yes okay do we have any other questions from council I think

1:11:42 we're good thank you Laurie thank you thank you yeah thanks for the

1:11:46 background research for shot thank you as long as you guys are up a night

1:11:54 worrying and we can sleep okay good point next item on the agenda is

1:12:00 this discussion of the city manager's recommendation

1:12:02 to create a citizens committee

1:12:04 to review current city facilities.

1:12:06 Travis Roth, welcome.

1:12:08 Mr. Mayor and members of council, good evening.

1:12:10 So it's back.

1:12:12 And we said that it would come back.

1:12:13 So as you recall, going back on March 31st,

1:12:17 we had our long-term planning committee come in

1:12:22 and share their observations and current

1:12:24 in terms of the structural facilities

1:12:27 that were currently operating in.

1:12:29 And throughout a series of conversations

1:12:31 during the budget, we had six overarching priorities

1:12:35 at the very beginning.

1:12:37 And one of those priorities was to look at our structures

1:12:41 as something as maybe an area that we had

1:12:45 a bit of deferred maintenance.

1:12:47 We looked at in terms of how we were able to staff

1:12:53 out of those areas, the separation, how full they were

1:12:57 getting and whether or not we had enough room

1:13:00 in the end for additional employees.

1:13:03 But really the conversation started even a little bit

1:13:06 further back than that.

1:13:08 And as you'll recall, it was almost about 15 to 16 months ago.

1:13:14 We had a plan as a part of the 2013 budget

1:13:18 to move forward with some renovations and some improvements

1:13:22 in the police facility.

1:13:23 And when we wanted to move forward

1:13:25 with those police improvements, we

1:13:27 had hired the services of an architect.

1:13:29 We asked the architect to help us with those plans and to help us to be able to move forward

1:13:34 to make improvements that we felt would last us for a period of time.

1:13:39 And then we opened the bids.

1:13:42 And when we opened the bids, we were shocked about how much that had increased in a single

1:13:47 month's time over the engineering estimates.

1:13:50 And then when we started to do the math and move forward, we began to notice that the cost

1:13:55 of the potential improvements may be approaching a million dollars.

1:13:59 we began to question internally whether or not a million dollars for a short term solution

1:14:05 was in the best interest of our community. And as you recall, that was about the same time

1:14:10 that we were having a conversation about the strategic plan. And so oftentimes we have the

1:14:14 conversation, why are the facilities and the improvements not included inside the strategic

1:14:20 plan? Because we were running two simultaneous passes as we went forward and we really believed

1:14:27 that we are going to be able to build a project

1:14:30 in accordance with architectural estimates,

1:14:32 right until the time when we open the first bits.

1:14:35 And you'll recall at that point in time

1:14:37 we asked you to reject those bids because of costs,

1:14:40 and we begin that process of exploring and looking forward.

1:14:43 Then go on to March.

1:14:46 The status of our facilities has not changed.

1:14:49 In fact, the status of our facilities today

1:14:51 as we continue to grow and expand

1:14:53 and add employees to our organization

1:14:56 in a prudent manner, takes up available office space,

1:14:59 and we are beginning the process of not only transitioning

1:15:02 office space, large commuting room space, and office space.

1:15:07 But again, if you take a look at the police station,

1:15:09 the place where we started the conversation,

1:15:12 it is getting difficult to add additional officers

1:15:15 into that facility.

1:15:16 And we have other deficiencies in our facilities throughout.

1:15:20 So as a part of the budget, there was a recommendation

1:15:23 as a result of the long-term planning committee's recommendation, to begin the possibility of

1:15:28 including funding into the budget.

1:15:31 And as you recall, that conversation really began to drive the entire budgetary conversation.

1:15:36 And in fact, it became a bit of a distraction because it began and was the only focus.

1:15:43 And we made the decision prior to publishing and presenting the budget to remove that, with

1:15:51 the commitment of coming back to it shortly after the budget adoption and we are asking

1:15:58 now to resume those conversations but to resume those conversations in a very public process.

1:16:06 Very similar to how we treated the wastewater treatment plant discussion because really

1:16:11 at that point in time that facility was really in no different of a place than all of the

1:16:16 other facilities that we had, and we reach a point of making some critical decisions based

1:16:21 upon the types of facilities that we have in our organization.

1:16:26 So I would like the Council to allow the City staff to begin the process of working with

1:16:33 the Citizen Advisory Committee, and that Citizen Advisory Committee would have a series of

1:16:38 purposes, but the fundamental purpose would be to answer questions and then report back

1:16:43 to the City Council with its findings.

1:16:46 And so Mr. Mayor, I'd like to outline my proposed steps and clearly those could be negotiated in

1:16:54 a manner that you feel is appropriate to make sure that you get the appropriate information

1:16:59 to be able to make a decision should you be asked to make one by this group.

1:17:06 So we would like to begin our process with a series of tours of our facilities.

1:17:15 And we'd like to begin that on the 22nd and the 23rd of this month.

1:17:22 And we believe that timing is actually pretty important because it is almost coinciding with

1:17:29 another conversation that is occurring within our community that is being driven by the

1:17:34 urban or new agency as they're looking for long-term funding options for the

1:17:38 infrastructure projects that they're looking at moving forward. And we would do

1:17:44 tours that would encourage not only looking at all three of our facilities but

1:17:51 also another location. We would take a look at our facilities at the Hanson

1:17:55 building, we'd take a look at our facilities at the City Hall building, currently at the

1:18:01 police building, and then we would also ask the citizens to take a look at another structure.

1:18:07 And that structure would be the banner furniture building in downtown Twin Falls.

1:18:13 Only because, and to see if that really did meet the options and the long term needs of

1:18:19 the community moving forward.

1:18:21 And in that process, it is important that the community vet that building, but a whole

1:18:28 host of other choices that they may have before them.

1:18:33 And I believe it's important for them to take time not only

1:18:36 inventing the location, wherever that may be, whether that's

1:18:40 the banner furniture building or another place.

1:18:44 And also define and determine a way that we're going to pay

1:18:48 for it.

1:18:50 As you know, we have a few options to pay for these types

1:18:53 of projects.

1:18:54 One is through a property tax general obligation bond.

1:18:59 General Obligation Bonds require a two-thirds vote moving forward.

1:19:05 A second option that we would have available to us

1:19:07 would be a levy override.

1:19:10 A levy override would require a vote of the citizens,

1:19:12 and it would require the project to be paid for in two years.

1:19:17 Or taking a look at using cash reserves

1:19:23 that we have in our existing accounts.

1:19:28 All three of those options have paths.

1:19:33 So for example, if either the first two options

1:19:37 were recommended by the committee,

1:19:39 it would be incumbent upon the committee

1:19:40 to talk about when, what elections cycle,

1:19:44 for what term, if it's a bond, and what does that look like?

1:19:48 And asking them like they did the wastewater treatment

1:19:51 facility to assist in having a community-wide conversation

1:19:56 about that.

1:19:58 If the decision to use cash reserves was recommended,

1:20:03 then we would also ask that they evaluate this project

1:20:06 in comparison to other projects that we may have

1:20:09 that would also be competing for those users of reserves

1:20:12 to prioritize them and make that as part

1:20:15 of the community decision and discussion.

1:20:19 As they came forward, we would ask them

1:20:23 to also answer any questions that the council would need

1:20:26 to be able to move forward with a decision at any point in time.

1:20:32 We would anticipate that they would make a presentation to the City Council in early December

1:20:39 at the soonest, with anticipation that the City Council would take that information under

1:20:44 advisement and respond in a manner shortly thereafter, assuming that the Citizen Committee

1:20:51 was able to satisfy and answer all of the questions that were proposed by the City Council.

1:20:58 The selection of the committee I believe needs to be done in a manner very similar to the

1:21:01 wastewater treatment plant and it is done in a manner of any interest party who wants to

1:21:06 assist in the decision come forward.

1:21:10 During the community tours we may have individuals who want to share their opinion but not necessarily

1:21:19 participate in the discussion so we will also give them opportunities to do so.

1:21:23 We will have cards available where individuals can provide a couple of checks to some certain

1:21:30 questions based upon the information, the knowledge that we provide, as well as any additional

1:21:36 comments that they would like to submit to the Council.

1:21:40 All of those would be eligible and reviewed for the public record and we would place them

1:21:44 on our website so that individuals could also see on those comments.

1:21:51 The conversation of a city facility needs to be a public conversation.

1:21:59 And it needs to be a public conversation because city halls, police stations, and public safety

1:22:06 facilities and the like really are public buildings.

1:22:11 And in any regard of how we fund it, it is the public's money and the public needs to

1:22:18 participate in that conversation.

1:22:21 So with that, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, I'd be happy to stand for any questions.

1:22:28 And be certainly in a position to respond to or add any elements and steps at this point

1:22:35 in time that you believe would be the medical decision-making process.

1:22:41 Thank you, Travis.

1:22:42 I also see that there are members of the public here, and I'm not sure if they were wanting

1:22:47 to address us, but we will start with questions from Council.

1:22:50 And then I will open it up in case there is any public comments that anyone would like

1:22:54 to make.

1:22:55 So, Chris, talking and you're on first.

1:22:58 Well thought out while I'll explain Travis, I'm wondering if the Council approves the committee

1:23:05 for your request.

1:23:07 You probably will be providing background information to them of similar Northwest or

1:23:13 Idaho municipalities that have faced the same situation we have.

1:23:18 some other successes and failures, so that there would be some learning curve you could

1:23:23 get this committee.

1:23:25 Absolutely.

1:23:26 And maybe what can and can't be done within what time period.

1:23:31 I mean, they won't be working in a vacuum.

1:23:33 No.

1:23:34 We believe that's a great question.

1:23:36 Thank you, Mr. Talkington.

1:23:38 We would provide the same level of information and care at the beginning of the process like

1:23:42 we did in the wastewater treatment plant process, where we would take the time to build up that

1:23:48 core knowledge base so that they can feel comfortable in making that decision and moving forward.

1:23:52 And as I glanced back, I noticed one of our co-chairs that became a pseudo waste water treatment

1:23:59 plant expert in her exploration of this process.

1:24:05 What I would say is after we provide the information, I think it's really important for the staff

1:24:12 to step back and let the committee work and serve really at their pleasure in capturing

1:24:20 whatever information the entire group would need to move forward.

1:24:24 That would mean the advantages of location, exactly as you said, the success stories and

1:24:31 maybe the less than success stories of other communities that have gone through a process.

1:24:39 We would provide information on financing.

1:24:41 We would typically use our financial advisors to come in and assist with that so that they

1:24:48 had the full palette of information to be able to make this decision moving forward.

1:24:53 In addition to that, we think it's important that should they choose some options over

1:24:57 the other, we need to have a conversation about some other projects that are out there.

1:25:03 And I think that this group needs to have the ability to stack a city facilities project

1:25:09 up against several other potential competing projects

1:25:12 that may be out there so that when they make a recommendation

1:25:15 to the City Council, they're doing so not myopically,

1:25:19 but with a full field of vision of everything

1:25:21 that's out there.

1:25:23 Great landing.

1:25:24 Well, thank you, Travis.

1:25:27 I really enjoyed our process with the wastewater treatment

1:25:30 plant.

1:25:31 We stepped back as a council.

1:25:33 I was mayor at the time, and I tried to sit at the back

1:25:36 and tried not to participate better once

1:25:38 well, I broke my own rule on that.

1:25:40 But one of the other things, and we, like we said,

1:25:43 we have one of the co-chairs here tonight,

1:25:46 that group kind of weeded out their own leadership

1:25:49 at the same time.

1:25:50 They came forth with some co-chairs

1:25:54 to help facilitate the meeting.

1:25:55 So staff didn't have to stay involved in the leadership

1:26:00 of the meetings.

1:26:01 The co-chairs could take that responsibility on,

1:26:06 And it made it feel even more open and public.

1:26:10 And they could lead the group to the group decision

1:26:15 that they came up with, ultimately,

1:26:17 when it was passing the bond election.

1:26:21 And I will fully support your proposal.

1:26:24 Thank you, Greg.

1:26:25 Back to me on the second.

1:26:26 Thank you, Mayor.

1:26:27 Thank you, Travis.

1:26:28 I just have a few questions.

1:26:30 I really like the concept of having a committee prioritize

1:26:35 the need for a city hall compared to other projects.

1:26:38 Do you have any idea what would be on that list,

1:26:41 or will the council be seeing that list?

1:26:43 I'm just curious what the other projects might be.

1:26:46 Yes, so we think that the council

1:26:47 should probably help create that list.

1:26:49 But also, we'd be working with staff

1:26:51 at some of the probably the more obvious ones.

1:26:53 One of the ones that we've had a conversation about

1:26:56 in the community would be the Canyon Springs grade.

1:26:58 And what does that project look like?

1:27:01 It's going to be, we'd be using some best estimates, but really with the Canyon Springs

1:27:07 Great Project, what's important, the reason that we're going forward with the engineering

1:27:11 process this year is to help us define the project, to help us define the cost.

1:27:16 Right now the costs are a bit ambiguous because we're not really certain of what the full scale

1:27:21 of that project would be.

1:27:23 But certainly that would be one that quickly rises to the top of my mind.

1:27:28 Another conversation that we had during this process was the wheels booster station.

1:27:33 The wheels booster station is a needed booster station that is needed if we're going to be

1:27:40 able to create additional housing opportunities and eliminate one of the significant hurdles

1:27:45 that we have for, as it's been called, workforce housing or entry level housing and additional

1:27:52 development opportunities in plated subdivisions in the south section of our community.

1:27:58 One of the advantages of covering that could be as a whole series of other options as well.

1:28:03 So we expect that this group would not only take a look at this project, but they may also

1:28:09 have to take a look at the other projects and say, this is important, and if you proceed

1:28:15 forward, you may look at these funding options as well.

1:28:18 So for example, on the wheels booster station, you have other options and not to say that

1:28:23 this committee would discount it, but they may be able to come forward and say, this project

1:28:27 is a blank priority and in order to fund the priority,

1:28:31 we would recommend this type of funding option moving forward.

1:28:35 I would suggest that any things that you would also have

1:28:39 on those, please let me know, but we would use the strategic plan

1:28:45 as part of that backbone in moving forward.

1:28:48 I think it's important that the projects shouldn't be something,

1:28:53 in my opinion, it shouldn't be something that have never

1:28:55 been contemplated or discussed in the community, but certainly ones that have been rising to

1:29:00 that community level of conversation.

1:29:03 Sure.

1:29:04 And then you mentioned that this committee will discuss possible locations, like multiple

1:29:10 locations for the City Hall, but I was wondering since the council has identified the one location

1:29:16 of Bannerbank and we've put some financial commitments and some financial investments into

1:29:20 this one location, how and in what way can this committee look into other locations as

1:29:28 a true possibility?

1:29:30 Can I stop you?

1:29:31 It was banner furniture, not banner bank.

1:29:33 Sorry, did I see banner bank?

1:29:35 I'm so sorry.

1:29:36 I didn't want you to have that.

1:29:37 I didn't realize I said that.

1:29:39 I'm sorry.

1:29:40 So I think honestly and objectively.

1:29:42 I mean, what I think is important is even though the city has put down a small amount to preserve

1:29:49 of our options so that we could publicly talk about the building because one of the things

1:29:53 that obviously is a concern that the minute that you express an interest in a property

1:29:57 and you find out that someone is a real buyer, that price may have a significant escalation

1:30:02 overnight.

1:30:03 So by being able to preserve an opportunity to acquire what the decision of the community

1:30:10 moves forward I think is important.

1:30:11 What I will say is the committee I believe will make a best long-term decision whether

1:30:18 is this place and will emphasize that.

1:30:20 I think it's important that if it's this place or another place, we're talking about spending

1:30:26 a lot more money than the earnest money that may be credited to a facility in the long-term

1:30:31 future of a particular area in the community.

1:30:34 So I would encourage that the community would vet all properties and then that group is going

1:30:40 to come back before the council.

1:30:42 And if they select a different alternative and a different property, I believe that they

1:30:47 will be able to share why. If they move forward and they say that the banner facility is in

1:30:51 the best interest, I believe the council should ask them why. And I believe that in any case,

1:30:57 whatever property they select, the members of this community will be able to describe

1:31:02 why.

1:31:03 Thank you. And so you mentioned the small amount of money. How much have we spent to

1:31:10 date on invested in the banner?

1:31:12 Yes, so as you know, we've spent $10,000 to retain the building, at least for a period

1:31:19 of time, and that $10,000 will be credited to the transaction costs, should it be able

1:31:26 to move forward.

1:31:27 Prior to even looking at facilities, we wanted to take a look at the structural integrity of

1:31:33 the building, and as well as the systems that are inside of the building, the combined cost

1:31:40 is of those is under $5,000.

1:31:43 And then in addition to take a look at the building to say,

1:31:46 what could this be other than a furniture building?

1:31:49 We've enlisted the help of an architectural firm.

1:31:52 And that cost is right around $12,000.

1:31:55 So if you look at the total price tag right now,

1:31:58 we're looking at about $30,000 ish in that $30,000.

1:32:04 I will tell you is insignificant to what

1:32:08 the full-blown cost of a facility like

1:32:11 restructuring these would be. It's no

1:32:14 different than the process that we use

1:32:16 when we're looking at renovating the

1:32:19 police building as we went forward using

1:32:21 either cash reserves. We spent money to

1:32:23 enlist the services of an architect to

1:32:25 help us evaluate decisions and I think

1:32:28 it's all part of a good due diligence.

1:32:30 We've also spent a lot of staff time. So

1:32:33 when you take a look at a lot of staff

1:32:35 time when we evaluated ten other

1:32:37 other facilities, we've taken many tours of some facilities and we've refilled and

1:32:41 examined others.

1:32:42 So I do not have the ability to examine or

1:32:46 to provide you a cost of the soft value of the soft cost that we've spent on the project.

1:32:55 Thank you.

1:32:56 Thank you Rebecca.

1:32:57 Sean Bearer.

1:32:59 I agree that this is a good process that you laid out here, Travis, to take a look at this.

1:33:05 Honestly, I think the success that we had and the evaluation of the wastewater treatment facility with basically a come one come all who'd like to be on this committee really was an outstanding way to engage the community.

1:33:20 We spent a lot of time during the year grumbling about folks not showing up to budget hearings and planning and zoning hearings and so forth.

1:33:30 And I think that this process has proven to be successful not only with the wastewater treatment

1:33:36 issue, but certainly the school district has had some success with the last couple of those at bonds.

1:33:41 I just think it's a great way to engage the community.

1:33:44 I think as far as a process, this is great.

1:33:47 I think there are a lot of details about the substance of those meetings that truthfully I don't know that the seven of us need to be

1:33:56 trying to figure that out tonight up here.

1:34:00 So, I would certainly be supportive of that in moving forward, and it's a pretty aggressive

1:34:06 timeline too, which is good in the fact that it's a smaller buy-in for folks to participate.

1:34:13 It's not a huge month's drag-out process, so I think timing is good and would certainly

1:34:20 be supportive of that this evening.

1:34:22 Thanks, John.

1:34:24 Jima.

1:34:25 Thank you, Mayor.

1:34:26 And I don't want to elaborate too much, but I certainly support your plan, I think, as

1:34:29 well thought out. I think it's imperative that we do include the community in this. I also

1:34:34 support your due diligence on the banner, our due diligence on the banner building. I think

1:34:39 that's just a reasonable business decision that the community would expect from us. So I say

1:34:44 carry on. It is a very tight timeline, but I think what you're doing is reasonable and

1:34:52 falls well within our strategic plan where we want to take the community. So go get them.

1:34:59 I don't want to waste everybody's time and reiterate what's been said, but I think it's important we all go on record

1:35:06 and I just want to say that I'm very supportive. I'm very appreciative for all the work you and staff have put into this already

1:35:12 and I'm ready to move forward and I think the citizens committee is going to be a great way to get her done.

1:35:19 Chris talking to.

1:35:20 So with that, I'd like to motion that we authorize creation of a citizens committee

1:35:29 by the city manager, I guess, to review current city facilities.

1:35:35 We have a motion on the floor by Chris Tottenham.

1:35:38 Second.

1:35:39 Jim Beecher, I actually use my light, this little thing right here.

1:35:43 I will say that I'm still going to give an opportunity for folks that are in the audience

1:35:55 to have a say a few words, but I think the motion is appropriate.

1:36:01 I personally am going to be supportive of it.

1:36:03 I think that we have done our due diligence.

1:36:07 Anytime you spend public's money, we're very, very careful about that.

1:36:11 And I think we've been careful about that.

1:36:13 And I like the idea of engaging the community as much as we can,

1:36:19 especially on these long term facility needs.

1:36:24 We are sitting in a facility across the street.

1:36:28 Many folks don't realize this, that predates my birth.

1:36:33 And I feel like I'm kind of an old man.

1:36:35 1961, we see pictures of that building as a city hall.

1:36:39 I was born in 1961.

1:36:40 I can't believe it's still standing, but that just shows you how important and how we look at facilities within the city and we're careful with our purchases, even back 53 years ago, and I know that we were actually in the building even prior to 1961.

1:36:59 So I will be supportive of this.

1:37:01 Great landing.

1:37:01 I wonder what our population was in the 1960s.

1:37:04 20,000, I looked it up today.

1:37:06 20,721, is that right?

1:37:09 In 1960, it was, you recall that?

1:37:12 No, actually, I'm gonna rest.

1:37:14 Okay, let's just stop here, Chris.

1:37:18 That's pretty accurate.

1:37:19 That's what I looked at earlier.

1:37:21 Because it didn't change for about two decades, seriously.

1:37:26 That's amazing, Chris.

1:37:27 All right, do we have anything further on the motion?

1:37:30 Leila, roll call vote, please.

1:37:33 Glinty? Yes.

1:37:35 Don Hall? Yes.

1:37:36 Rebecca Masleika? Yes.

1:37:38 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mundt. Yes. Sean Berreber. Yes. Chris Tock. Yes. Motion passes. Seven to zero. And would you like to say a few more words for our comments?

1:37:50 Maybe so that there is absolutely no misunderstanding. These are going to be very public meetings. We're going to broadcast those meetings. I envision the meetings would be in here that we would try to utilize our

1:38:05 we will post it, it will be available, people have the opportunity to comment if they can't make the meeting schedules.

1:38:12 So again, we want to do everything that we can to ensure that this process is very much open to the public

1:38:22 and that the public has the opportunity to weigh in for as long of duration as they choose,

1:38:29 whether that be the single postcard at the beginning of the process.

1:38:34 beginning of the process or all the way through to maybe being selected as a co-chair and

1:38:39 being tasked with the responsibility of making a decision or presenting you with a series of

1:38:46 recommendations.

1:38:47 Thank you, Travis, and that's an excellent segue into much like when we deal with our

1:38:54 budget.

1:38:55 Every time that we discuss the budget, we open it up to the public for them to make comments.

1:38:59 I think that's more than appropriate with this type of a situation in front of us.

1:39:04 So at this time, I'm open to the public, there's anyone that would like to address the council.

1:39:10 We've seen several potential co-chairs back there.

1:39:13 There could be some potential co-chairs out there.

1:39:16 Mr. Horner, welcome, sir.

1:39:18 My name's Alan Horner.

1:39:19 I don't know.

1:39:20 Am I supposed to get my address?

1:39:22 Yeah.

1:39:23 Okay.

1:39:24 and I wish I could say that I was born in 1961.

1:39:29 I've got a few more years on it.

1:39:32 I just want to applaud the city council for creating an atmosphere under which these type of proposals can come forward for the betterment of Twin Falls.

1:39:45 I also want to applaud city staff for having the courage to step up and make these type of

1:39:56 proposals to the city council that move Twin Falls forward.

1:40:01 I think Twin Falls is in a position that we will probably never experience again at least

1:40:09 in my lifetime, maybe the 61ers will have these opportunities again, but I'm sure that

1:40:15 that Iowa mode, where we have an opportunity to advance Twin Falls and make it such a highly

1:40:24 visible area that our children want to come back here, that we've created jobs, we're

1:40:33 going to have people that are not going to necessarily feel that this is the way to move.

1:40:39 appreciate that they have their feelings. It can be expressed, though, in a committee like

1:40:47 this. I think the job that the committee on the treatment plant did was phenomenal. But

1:40:57 it's this open dialogue that can take place that you don't see even in a lot of cities

1:41:06 today. So I just want to applaud you and encourage you to go forward. I'm glad that

1:41:12 it's a quicker timeline that we don't get bogged down in misopportunities. I can

1:41:17 tell you what we're seeing. We've got a lot of people now or we have clients

1:41:25 that are coming forward looking to do things in the downtown area. And it's

1:41:32 It's not just because of what the City Council may do on these facilities, it's what's happened

1:41:38 already with the things with the buildings that have been purchased now that are advancing

1:41:46 that cause.

1:41:47 They recognize the importance of a downtown area, but wherever this is located is just

1:41:56 going to enhance the reputation at Twin Falls.

1:41:58 So thank you to the City Council.

1:42:01 Thank you for city staff for the work they've put into this.

1:42:06 Thank you, sir, for sharing your opinion.

1:42:07 It guides us.

1:42:08 Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?

1:42:17 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:42:18 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:42:22 [Muted for privacy: street address]

1:42:23 Thank you, Mayor and City Council.

1:42:26 I did not anticipate speaking this evening, but I do have a couple of thoughts as we've

1:42:30 gone through this conversation.

1:42:33 I too very much appreciate, just as a citizen, the opportunities that the City Council and

1:42:39 the City staff provided, I regard the wastewater treatment committee and the outcome as very

1:42:48 successful.

1:42:50 And one of the critical elements was the amount of information that the City staff did provide

1:42:56 to us.

1:42:58 of us myself, especially were beginners with that particular subject and they really were

1:43:05 great hand holders in getting us through that and that information is important.

1:43:09 I would say that in terms of the number of options presented to the committee, I think

1:43:15 it would be important, please, to the folks who do end up on this, that we not have a whole

1:43:25 universe of competing projects to consider.

1:43:31 I think that keeping a clear vision that we're looking at facilities is important.

1:43:38 We do need to understand the background that there are other competing and their projects

1:43:43 and there is not an infinite way to fund all of those.

1:43:49 So that part of it I do think is important but I would implore you that please don't give

1:43:52 of a committee a list of 20 different ideas to put forward

1:43:57 because the fact that they'll be looking

1:43:58 at different facilities, different funding options,

1:44:02 all of those things I think is a lot for a group

1:44:04 to consider especially in a short period of time.

1:44:07 I would agree as Mr. Berger pointed out

1:44:11 that actually, or maybe with you, Mayor Hall,

1:44:14 that having a fairly aggressive timeline

1:44:17 is I think a good thing.

1:44:18 that folks are not facing, you know, two years of a commitment in this.

1:44:25 And the way that this process was set up previously, and it sounds like we'll be again,

1:44:31 that it's open, people were able to come to whatever they could come to,

1:44:36 whether it be one meeting or ten meetings and have the input and have that heard.

1:44:41 I think was a great thing.

1:44:44 And we did have a really wide variety of folks and a wide variety of concerns,

1:44:47 that I think as you all know that as a committee we ended up with a little bit different recommendation

1:44:53 than I think was expected. And the community agreed overwhelmingly. So I would encourage

1:45:01 folks to hop on board. This is a big deal. I will say that also being an early 60s person,

1:45:09 I do have to say that the 1960s were not particularly good architectural years. And that I'm fairly

1:45:17 confident we can improve upon what we have to work with currently.

1:45:25 And those are really the big things that I just think it was a very positive experience

1:45:30 coming from someone who participated throughout that process and I think that this will be

1:45:36 a great approach, that it is wonderful.

1:45:40 And I would anticipate a few more folks to have a little bit of interest in this topic

1:45:45 and can't wait to see it move forward.

1:45:48 I would also finally say that I think it will be also important

1:45:52 to liaise with the OTAC advisory committee

1:45:56 that the URA is putting together.

1:45:59 There are a little bit happening in tandem in parallel,

1:46:03 so I think that that will be probably an important element as well.

1:46:07 So thank you very much, and I think it'll be a great thing.

1:46:12 Thank you, Lori.

1:46:13 Thank you for your suggestions.

1:46:14 Is there anyone else that would like to address?

1:46:24 Thank you.

1:46:25 Mr. Mayor, City Council.

1:46:26 My name is Tom Ashenbrenner, 338-5-Hylon, and I'm also the owner of Rudy Zakruk's Paradise

1:46:33 downtown on Maine.

1:46:35 But first, I'd like to say as a citizen, I agree with everyone that this is an appropriate

1:46:39 process.

1:46:40 It's got to be a public process, obviously, for City Hall, but also for downtown.

1:46:44 Downtown infrastructure is publicly owned.

1:46:48 That's a distinctive difference between that and other shopping areas and commercial areas

1:46:53 in the community and the revitalization of downtown that is under discussion and beginning

1:46:59 is a public process as well.

1:47:01 It's very appropriate for public institutions like City Halls to be located in downtown cores.

1:47:11 They build on that whole public perception of a downtown.

1:47:15 It's owned by the community and it becomes, as the power and the energy goes, it becomes

1:47:21 the sense of place that we keep hearing and talking about.

1:47:25 And the key right now is the timing.

1:47:28 Five years ago, ten years ago downtown was not ready to be revitalized.

1:47:33 Five years ago it was not ready.

1:47:34 It's ready now.

1:47:35 And it's starting to become evident by things like

1:47:39 October 1st participation Friday and Saturday for those of you

1:47:42 that were able to be downtown.

1:47:44 And it wasn't really anything the merchants did.

1:47:46 It was the outpouring of interest by the community that wanted

1:47:51 to take over their downtown streets and have an event

1:47:53 and have a function and have a party.

1:47:55 And everyone was well behaved and happy that we saw.

1:47:59 And it was bigger than we've ever had before.

1:48:04 and it was put together by a couple very energetic, younger business owners.

1:48:08 Kinsey is one of them, and there was a few more.

1:48:11 On very short notice, and the community embraced it.

1:48:14 This has the potential, should the process work, and it goes through all the phases,

1:48:20 and the community embraces it to be another huge step forward to continue to build that energy.

1:48:26 Along with St. Luke's, Presidentstown Town,

1:48:28 The new first federal

1:48:31 Presidentstown town continues to build.

1:48:34 I think you're all

1:48:36 should take credit for doing the appropriate thing

1:48:39 and studying all the angles.

1:48:41 But when I take the community hat off and put the

1:48:43 downtown business hat on, I can't help but stand

1:48:46 damn excited to see where this might go.

1:48:49 Thank you.

1:48:50 Thank you, Tom.

1:48:51 Jeff, come up where we ask.

1:48:53 Is there anyone else that would like to come up?

1:48:56 All right, it doesn't appear so we if this is going to be any kind of indication of a public input, it's going to be very, very good and I appreciate the three of you coming up and sharing your opinions and I look forward to the rest of the community engaging us as well.

1:49:17 This is such an important issue.

1:49:20 So with that, we will move on to any other public input.

1:49:25 Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address the council?

1:49:30 I see no one.

1:49:32 And are there any other items from our city manager?

1:49:36 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, it's been talked about a couple of times, but

1:49:39 just to make sure that everyone has it on their calendar.

1:49:43 Otak, which is the group that has been hired by the Urban Renewal Agency to

1:49:48 assist in the look and the exploration of the downtown community is going to be in town starting

1:49:55 on the 13th when and they are going to be sharing and having a public wide conversation on the

1:50:02 evening of the 16th from 6 o'clock to 8 o'clock in the historic ballroom. And so I would encourage

1:50:10 all members of the community to attend that if they're interested in the project and in

1:50:15 downtown. Also, in addition to that, there's going to be a project website that's going to

1:50:21 be launched, and as it is launched, there's going to be information that's placed on that

1:50:25 website. As well as, as you recall, we had a phenomenal first public meeting and a series

1:50:33 of stakeholder interviews. Those were placed and will be turned into a report, and I believe

1:50:40 we're anticipating the release of that port in the next week or so.

1:50:45 I think it's going to be presented, as I understand it,

1:50:47 talking with Melinda to the Urban Renewal Board.

1:50:50 And then after that, it'll be placed onto a website dedicated to this project.

1:50:55 That link to that website can be found or will be found on the city's web page.

1:50:59 Or it is www.twinfallsmainavenue.com.

1:51:05 And that would be, it's going to be a clearing house for all of the information

1:51:09 for public events and information moving forward.

1:51:13 The last thing I want to say on that as you recall,

1:51:15 if you took a look at that agreement,

1:51:18 Kettleson is a group that does traffic patterns,

1:51:20 traffic flows and parking.

1:51:23 That was a group that was a part of the OTEC study

1:51:28 and as a result of the downtown business merchants coming forward

1:51:32 and asking us to take a look at parking and parking considerations

1:51:36 in the proposals that they place together.

1:51:38 The kettleson group has started their work.

1:51:41 They were actually in town last week to explore opportunities with parking and

1:51:48 traffic flows and the like.

1:51:49 And we anticipate that that will be, when that is available,

1:51:52 we will make sure that that is presented to the city council.

1:51:55 So that you have a good understanding of what the possibilities may be in

1:51:59 relationship to the downtown group that made those, or that had petitioned those changes to you.

1:52:07 Thank you, Mr. Rothweiler, anything from City Council?

1:52:11 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:52:13 Travis, maybe you can help me with this.

1:52:15 I think Thursday night at seven is the bike forum meeting here, do you know?

1:52:21 My iPad's not pulling up the city website right now, so I can't get it.

1:52:25 But it seems like we're sipping.

1:52:28 That's correct, it's the biker out connectivity meeting where they're going to present kind of the plan that city staff came up with and

1:52:36 asked for approval from the citizens.

1:52:38 Yeah Thursday night, 7 o'clock here, right?

1:52:40 Correct, yeah.

1:52:44 Yeah, if the ninth is a Thursday, I believe it's the ninth.

1:52:50 Is there anyone else from council?

1:52:51 Thank you, Suzanne, for sharing that.

1:52:53 I see no one else from council, so at this point,

1:52:56 we will adjourn.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 6, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:55:39.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    f623941639a30f2e7ff69724029699719bba1da7ded68d2d6429a1434a126748
  5. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 3 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    df9561182f92837603870c7df17aea34b560e0356a1638d620dcd54b02c7ee4c

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file