OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 23, 2014

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Minutes on fileExecutive session: c,c*

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:03:19 We're going to call the June 23rd meeting to order for the Twin Falls City Council.

0:03:27 And as always, we would like to begin by inviting everybody to join us in the Pledge of Allegiance, if you'd like to stand.

0:03:35 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:03:53 I'd like to confirm at this time we do have a quorum.

0:03:56 Five of the seven members are here.

0:03:58 Our mayor is home under the weather tonight

0:04:00 and should be rejoining us next week.

0:04:02 And I believe that Councilman Munn had

0:04:05 previous commitment as well.

0:04:08 Travis, are there any considerations of amendments

0:04:11 to the agenda?

0:04:12 Madam Vice Mayor, members of the city council,

0:04:15 we have amended minutes that have been placed

0:04:20 before you for your review and consideration.

0:04:24 It is not necessary to do anything in terms of the consent calendar, but just a notification that upon the review of the council, there were some quick corrections that were made once you publish or

0:04:37 once you approve of those corrections as part of the consent calendar, we will publish those as part of the corrected meeting minutes as we move forward.

0:04:45 Thank you.

0:04:46 MOCO approved the consent calendar, including the revised or amended minutes of 1.

0:04:54 May 27th and June 2nd, 2014.

0:04:58 Second.

0:05:00 We have a motion on the floor by Chris Tockington, seconded by Greg Lantine.

0:05:05 Is there any discussion?

0:05:08 Leila, roll call vote please.

0:05:09 Susan Hawkins.

0:05:10 Yes.

0:05:11 Sean Berriger.

0:05:12 Yes.

0:05:13 Jim Ma.

0:05:15 Sorry.

0:05:17 Greg Lantine.

0:05:18 Yes.

0:05:20 Chris Tockington.

0:05:21 Yes.

0:05:22 Yes, that passes on a five to zero vote.

0:05:29 We kind of got ahead of ourselves a little bit there.

0:05:32 We'd like to start the meeting with a general public input.

0:05:35 At this time, if there's anybody from the public that would like to address the council on any issues that are not on tonight's agenda, this is your chance to come chat with us.

0:05:46 Seeing no one coming forward, we are going to move on to items for consideration.

0:05:51 The first thing.

0:05:52 Vice Mayor.

0:05:53 Oh.

0:05:54 Just so that I'm clear for the record, did you approve the consent calendar or, okay.

0:06:00 Yes.

0:06:04 Okay.

0:06:05 So tonight the first item is a presentation of a certificate of appreciation from Habitat

0:06:10 for Humanity to the Building Department.

0:06:13 The presentation is going to be from Linda Fleming, and I believe we have Dwayne Thompson

0:06:18 here tonight on behalf of the Building Department.

0:06:22 Welcome Linda.

0:06:28 We recently had the National Home Builders Blitz, and I just wanted to tell you a little

0:06:32 bit and show you a little bit about what that Home Builders Blitz has done for our affiliate

0:06:37 in five quick slides.

0:06:41 During this event we were part of over 250 new homes or remodels that were engaged across

0:06:49 the United States.

0:06:50 We engaged over 200 volunteers, those are local contractors, local businesses to come out to

0:06:56 for our site and over 1700 hours to build that house.

0:06:59 And we did it in four and a half days.

0:07:02 We had our certificate of occupancy by noon,

0:07:05 which was an all-time record.

0:07:08 So advancing in this thing, okay?

0:07:12 Just a little history on home builder splits.

0:07:14 It was started back in 2002 by Tom Gibson,

0:07:17 and he partnered up with Habitat,

0:07:19 and they actually recruited 12 builders,

0:07:22 and each builder in one week's time built one home

0:07:26 for the total cost of habitat for $84,000, 12 homes, $84,000.

0:07:31 That's the beauty behind these blitz builds

0:07:33 and how magical they can be for affiliates

0:07:35 across the United States.

0:07:38 In 2006 was the first time our affiliate started

0:07:42 with the program.

0:07:43 So they brought it out across the United States.

0:07:45 We built 459 homes and housed over 2,000 people in one week.

0:07:51 Habitat did a five bedroom home, two bath,

0:07:54 for a family of nine out in deal.

0:07:56 It was amazing.

0:07:59 2008 we did it again with our first handicap accessible home

0:08:03 for the Roachborn family.

0:08:05 And we're getting a lot of similar contractors

0:08:08 who are really having a good time bringing their entire group

0:08:12 there just for one week's time versus several months,

0:08:15 engaging a lot of our big companies, Wells Fargo,

0:08:18 Lions Club, Modern Woodsmith,

0:08:21 100% donated home to Habitat.

0:08:25 2010 with a Dow turn in the economy,

0:08:28 they didn't have one nationally,

0:08:29 but your people here in the Magic Valley

0:08:31 wanted to do it again.

0:08:33 So we built for the Leah Dow house,

0:08:35 and she's a local school teacher here,

0:08:38 and this house was 65% donated through

0:08:43 Thriveant Financial, produce firms.

0:08:45 And then Glamby had joined in the hunt,

0:08:48 and donated through their charity challenge,

0:08:51 $105,000 for the first town home that we built, and that was in 2012, and that went up in just

0:08:59 one week's time as well. Pretty amazing. And if you don't know how it works, day one, that's

0:09:06 where it starts flat, from the ground to dried in on the very first day. And that's where your

0:09:11 inspectors are absolutely imperative to these builds and have been working with us hour by

0:09:18 hour to make sure that we're doing it correctly number one, safely number two,

0:09:23 and also that we don't bypass any of the rules. They too, it's roofed and dry

0:09:29 well-insited and textured. Day three, they paint and day four, they get those

0:09:33 inspectors wait until we're ready to go for those final inspections and they're

0:09:38 back on day four with us and we dedicate on day five. Very amazing thing to be

0:09:45 associated with. We're not quite sure if it's food that brings them back over and over again,

0:09:51 but we know that they are imperative and have been diligent and very patient with this crazy

0:09:58 schedule and we couldn't be more happy and delighted that they somehow decided to partner

0:10:07 with us, you the city as well, in helping us, especially in this year's impact fees, not

0:10:14 waving everything but our impact fees we really appreciate that to keep the cost down for our

0:10:19 family so I would like to dedicate a plaque. Linda could I ask you a question how do you

0:10:26 build the house in four days including pouring the concrete doesn't that have to cure? We start

0:10:32 actually from the foundation has been in for almost a month and just the floor system so we start

0:10:38 flat from the floor system and we build energy star homes we work with sip panels so we're

0:10:44 We're throwing trusses in about an hour when we're.

0:10:46 Okay, one most misprint live.

0:10:48 Yeah, pretty amazing.

0:10:52 So, it's weighing around.

0:10:57 And it's inspectors, if you've got other ones here,

0:10:59 you can't come up.

0:11:02 This one is a plaque that says,

0:11:04 for outstanding service to the community

0:11:06 with your participation in Home Builders Plus 2014,

0:11:09 because of your healthy Anderson family,

0:11:10 we'll own a simple, decent, and affordable home.

0:11:13 Thank you for your support and the part you played

0:11:15 in helping to house over 200 families in one week's time.

0:11:24 I just wanted to take it one step further.

0:11:26 This man here stayed, I think, I like to say,

0:11:30 just past June 13th so that he could do my last bill

0:11:34 before he retired.

0:11:35 And not have to break in anybody else for that crazy job.

0:11:40 I want to present to you one of our clients

0:11:48 to hang at your house and to Duane Thomas

0:11:51 for outstanding service to Habitat

0:11:53 and the community through your leadership

0:11:55 of the Twin Falls inspector team

0:11:57 during home builders blitzy events.

0:12:00 Because of your help, six families in the Magic family

0:12:03 own a simple, decent, and affordable home.

0:12:05 Thank you for your support and the part you played

0:12:07 in helping to house 1,067 families across the United States

0:12:11 since 2006.

0:12:20 Yeah, a very, very good crew.

0:12:23 And we appreciate everything that they do for us.

0:12:32 She gets it done.

0:12:34 And everybody out there just running around with a bunch

0:12:36 smiles, and I just have a blast with it.

0:12:39 It's really an enjoy and it's on and on, or to be part of that.

0:12:44 So thank you, Linda.

0:12:47 Linda, thank you for all you do for our community.

0:12:50 And Dwayne, thank you for leading such a great group of employees

0:12:53 for the City of Twin Falls all these years for us.

0:12:56 Thank you.

0:13:01 OK, moving on, we're going to go to a request

0:13:04 to name a small dog enclosure at Baxter's Park in memory

0:13:09 of Dell Drown as the Becker Small Dog enclosure donated by Dr. Marty and Teresa Becker in memory

0:13:17 of Bob and Virginia Becker.

0:13:20 And I believe we have Dennis Boyer.

0:13:21 Thank you, Vice Mayor and Council.

0:13:24 All of you probably want to know when will it be open, right?

0:13:29 So I'll start with that.

0:13:30 I'm hoping within a four to six week period, you know, we're still in the grass grow.

0:13:35 I wanted to let the grass really establish as long as we can before, as I call it, we'll

0:13:39 before we'll have the ribbon-cutting tail wagging,

0:13:42 you know, a vin out there.

0:13:44 So looking late July, first part of August, okay?

0:13:46 So that's, I know that was important everybody

0:13:48 had that thought on their mind anyway.

0:13:51 But tonight I'm here is, you know, we have been,

0:13:54 our community has been blessed with a dog park

0:13:56 where we've had a lot of volunteers that helped us out.

0:14:00 Also a lot of donations, you know,

0:14:02 literally was kicked off by Marcia Lanting

0:14:04 with her $10,000 donation,

0:14:06 hence we got Baxter's Park.

0:14:08 And also, now we had $15,000 donation from Dr. Marty

0:14:12 and his wife, Theresa Becker.

0:14:14 And also, I still love this one.

0:14:15 We had anonymous donation of $24,000.

0:14:18 That's what we have a price on the fencing was.

0:14:21 And this person worked with their financial,

0:14:24 his or her, I don't know who it is at all,

0:14:26 his or her financial advisor.

0:14:28 And that's what they donated.

0:14:29 So without the community, I still know

0:14:31 that people are still donating money

0:14:33 through their water bills for the Doc Park.

0:14:34 So thank you, community, for that, anyway.

0:14:37 But anyway, Dr. Marty Becker, you know,

0:14:41 veterinarian known around the United States,

0:14:43 but it's up in San Point, but he grew up here in Twin Falls.

0:14:46 He was really surprised that we didn't have a dog park

0:14:48 when he came back down here to visit his mother.

0:14:51 So he went out and said,

0:14:52 I'm gonna do something about it.

0:14:53 Contact me, work with the community foundation,

0:14:56 and he donated $15,000.

0:14:58 And we talked about what kind of he was looking at,

0:15:01 trying to get a name recognition.

0:15:03 So working it out with him,

0:15:05 He is requesting to name the small dog enclosure as the get the official name again is the Becker

0:15:13 Small Dog enclosure donated by Dr. Marty and Teresa Becker in memory of Bob in Virginia Becker.

0:15:19 As you remember that his mother was a real big animal lover, dog lover, you know, did

0:15:24 a lot of volunteer services at St. Luke's and also at the animal shelter too.

0:15:28 So he wanted to do something in memory of that.

0:15:31 Our naming policy that was adopted a couple of years ago talks about how you can name parks

0:15:36 or also how you can name sections of park or smaller areas.

0:15:41 For example, we have Frontier Field out by the college, also we have a small Carter-Gib Memorial

0:15:47 Field there too, so we can name smaller features in parks and our policy talks about that.

0:15:53 They follow the process, you know, submitted a request to staff myself like that.

0:15:58 I reviewed it if I looked at the criteria of our naming policy,

0:16:01 I followed the criteria of that.

0:16:03 I've got a recreation commission

0:16:04 reviewed it at their last meeting in June,

0:16:06 and they listened to it, and they forwarded a recommendation,

0:16:10 which their recommendation was to allow the naming

0:16:12 to go through of the small dog enclosure,

0:16:14 and hence we're back here at the City Council

0:16:16 for your final consideration.

0:16:19 Some of the key points of the policy,

0:16:21 there's kind of like six criteria to name or rename

0:16:24 the facilities, kind of go through.

0:16:27 They really talked about .45 where they gave a significant amount of money for this and

0:16:32 and five is about how you can name a interior feature of a park.

0:16:36 So they were just asking to name this small dog enclosure there.

0:16:40 So I'm kind of in conclusion that they submitted the request to name the commission, the review

0:16:46 that you made unanimously.

0:16:48 Recommendation to the council to prove the naming of the small dog enclosure and the handsome

0:16:53 back here at the City Council asking for your consideration

0:16:56 to name this small dog enclosure as a Becker small dog

0:17:01 enclosure donated by Dr. Marty and Teresa Becker,

0:17:03 the memory of Bob and Virginia Becker.

0:17:05 Imagine that we will make a sign somewhere

0:17:08 in this small dog area saying that somewhere.

0:17:11 I know that former Mayor Greg Lanting,

0:17:14 he had another donation of the rock sign

0:17:17 that we're placing that sometime probably next month

0:17:19 out there at the dog park.

0:17:20 so that you'll see the main name of the park anyway.

0:17:23 So I'm just here, that's into my presentation,

0:17:27 so I'm here just to answer any questions

0:17:28 if you have any.

0:17:31 Turn it over to Council.

0:17:40 Sean, very good.

0:17:41 Back up here.

0:17:42 I would like to make a motion to approve the request

0:17:47 to name the small dog enclosure at Baxter's Park

0:17:50 in memory of Dale Drown as the Becker small dog enclosure.

0:17:54 Don't need it by Dr. Marty and Theresa Becker

0:17:56 in memory of Bob and Virginia Becker.

0:17:59 Second.

0:18:00 We have a motion by Sean Berriger that's seconded by Greg Lanting.

0:18:04 Is there any discussion on the motion?

0:18:08 Leila, roll call vote please.

0:18:10 Sean Berriger?

0:18:11 Yes.

0:18:12 Greg Lanting?

0:18:13 Yes.

0:18:14 Chris Talkington?

0:18:14 Yes.

0:18:15 Rebecca Milsoica?

0:18:16 Yes.

0:18:17 Suzanne Hopkins?

0:18:18 Yes.

0:18:20 Motion passes five to zero.

0:18:23 And Greg Lanting.

0:18:24 I was glad to hear you said something about the rock.

0:18:26 I still get an email about once a month.

0:18:28 vital signs saying, when am I going to come pick up my rock?

0:18:33 And if you happen to be out there, you know, the paving of the parking lot, curb, got inside

0:18:37 walk on, Chup Avenue has been completed.

0:18:41 We're working on the restroom, we'll be installed sometime in July, and then we'll do some little

0:18:46 bit of landscaping around there, we'll place the rock.

0:18:48 So I want to make sure those projects are done before we have the grand opening.

0:18:52 But I look at sometime late July, first part of August, I'll definitely work with Josh

0:18:56 about some PSAs that get the word out because I think it will be a great celebration for Twin Falls.

0:19:01 Thank you very much.

0:19:03 Thank you.

0:19:07 Okay, item number three is a consideration of a request to award a contract to record still in construction incorporated

0:19:15 DBA RSCI in the amount of 17,963,307 for construction package two of the wastewater treatment plant upgrades.

0:19:28 and to present an update on the schedule and cost to date on the upgrades that are going on and we have Troy Vitek.

0:19:37 We have a fancy board.

0:19:43 Where is the money for?

0:19:54 The flood raiser.

0:19:58 Afternoon council members. Troy Vitek, Assistant City Engineer.

0:20:02 I've come up before you tonight to award a very large contract to record steel in court, record steel in construction.

0:20:10 in the amount of $17,960,000, $63,307 for the construction package to waste water treatment

0:20:18 plan upgrades.

0:20:20 This is the large portion of the construction package.

0:20:35 This is kind of the final icing on the cake here.

0:20:39 We've recently come before the council for many projects awarding and a lot of them were

0:20:47 included in this.

0:20:48 So we have a couple of ways we can do business.

0:20:50 We can actually pre-buy equipment, which we've done in the past, and have it out there for

0:20:56 the contractor to install.

0:20:57 In this case, we actually pre-designed and engineered and bid on the packages, and then

0:21:05 we actually assign these contracts to this final contract.

0:21:10 So he knows what price he's going to bid with, and those are incorporated in this final bid

0:21:15 package here.

0:21:16 So when you see the $17 million, they include the IFES system, which I previously came before,

0:21:23 in the amount of $1,245,000, as well as the Gates for $345,000 of change.

0:21:32 They are included in this $1.612 million.

0:21:35 The reason this number is slightly different than those two numbers, some of this, there's

0:21:39 taxes included in this, they have to include those.

0:21:43 So going down the unit price for the work, RCI is this portion of the column here.

0:21:49 They have a general cost of some work and then these are allowances that we put in there

0:21:55 for any minor change orders or stuff that we encounter on the site.

0:22:02 Minor changes, not major changes.

0:22:04 And then some other options as well as those previous packages are included in there.

0:22:11 In designing the project, there was an estimate of 23 million dollars to it and

0:22:19 this was

0:22:20 It was large and we really received a very good bit of respect you can see the

0:22:27 17 million nine hundred sixty nine thousand there and

0:22:30 There's some that are very competitive with this so they're already tightly grouped in this this area

0:22:36 But we wanted to not go over our budget one of the directions that the council gave is give us capacity

0:22:42 But also follow the budget so we ended up putting a lot of build alternatives as part of that

0:22:47 Thinking that if we were close we can add or delete these as we've felt necessary in order to really kind of hone in on that

0:22:54 Well, all of them fit and so tonight in this recommendation for 17 million

0:23:00 We would actually recommend all these items except for the 7B. This would only be even necessary if we didn't do seven

0:23:07 You can do some alternative piping. It's not very efficient, but it's workable.

0:23:13 And so we would like to actually do all of those 7 feet. So this number is slightly different than the 963,000 we show as the recommendation.

0:23:24 Let me kind of go over the project total cost.

0:23:28 So here's the actual alternatives where we're recommending.

0:23:40 The filtrate pump station is a little pump station that really needs replacing it.

0:23:43 It's completely deteriorated.

0:23:47 Some pump improvements to the irrigation lines out there, they're leaking, they're really in

0:23:53 disrepair.

0:23:54 Their irrigation base and modifications right here, this actually pays us back here within

0:23:58 three years to some out.

0:24:01 Very good investment on our dollar.

0:24:02 It allows us to turn off blowers that are very inefficient and put that effort into these

0:24:06 new high efficiency blurs that were installing this part of this.

0:24:09 and that brings us to blower 4 down here, which is another alternative.

0:24:13 By putting in a super high efficient blower, it allows us more capacity in the future

0:24:17 plus able to turn off those inefficient turn on this one.

0:24:21 The stainless steel mechanism, you have to coat a mechanism

0:24:25 with coating and it disintegrates over so many years.

0:24:29 So by going to stainless steel you don't have to, there's

0:24:34 a lot less maintenance as part of that. And then stand by power

0:24:38 here at the end, and some pump station improvements for $664,000.

0:24:44 So you had all those up in there included in the $17 billion bid number I have here for

0:24:51 you.

0:24:53 So this is kind of broken into two sections, the $16,254 as well as the $1,706,000.

0:25:01 Adds up to that $17,963.

0:25:04 You can see some other costs on that keep running through here, I'm trying to keep an

0:25:08 update. You guys updated on the other expenditures here. We have the bill

0:25:12 filter press that's going to be added to this bid. Right now a portion of that

0:25:16 money is being was judicially confirmed and we estimate there's 1.3

0:25:22 million dollars there's going to be coming as part of this expansion,

0:25:25 capacity expansion. There's also the Canyon Springs roadway that we I came

0:25:30 before you previously talked about. Replacing that roadway when they've

0:25:33 really caused a lot of damage to it. We can improve the roadway. We

0:25:39 we can just fix what we've damaged.

0:25:42 I have a quick question.

0:25:43 I have a quick question for you from Greg Lanthy.

0:25:46 I always kind of just like to know where the bidders

0:25:50 are coming from.

0:25:50 So did you tell me that there's four?

0:25:52 Looks like there were four responsive bids

0:25:54 in what part of the country they're coming in,

0:25:56 and possibly any of them from Idaho, which we always like,

0:25:59 but can't always guarantee?

0:26:00 I think, and we have CH2M here, Hill here tonight.

0:26:05 They'll be able to answer any questions.

0:26:07 but I believe RSCI is actually at a Boise.

0:26:10 Okay.

0:26:11 And so the winner will be at a Boise, Idaho.

0:26:14 They've worked with them on another project,

0:26:15 and I'll let you then talk about how they worked.

0:26:20 So yeah, they are local here.

0:26:24 I don't think there's any other questions on that.

0:26:28 With that, CH2 mail is actually recommending a word to them.

0:26:33 It's done a low bid, and I'll give you a,

0:26:36 this is, we've been out there today doing construction,

0:26:43 or you knew that.

0:26:44 And this is what it looks like today.

0:26:46 This is a portion of a large part of the study center.

0:26:51 And these are the pilings that they just

0:26:53 have been installed to protect the aeration basins here.

0:26:56 And so they can dig this whole lot.

0:26:58 So they're progressing quite well.

0:27:02 This is right where the grass was.

0:27:05 Chris, talking to him has a question?

0:27:06 Yeah, Troy or Greg, I don't think I've ever

0:27:11 been part of an award of a bit any larger than this.

0:27:14 this is certainly giant by any measure and we have to do our right obviously.

0:27:22 I appreciate it with your comments Greg.

0:27:27 I guess you have experience with them.

0:27:29 The company CH has a working knowledge of their viability and responsibility and meeting time

0:27:36 tables.

0:27:37 Yes, we're working with them on other projects and the biggest one to work on right now is

0:27:41 a $15 million project for the city of Boise.

0:27:44 And had a schedule, change order rate, extremely low,

0:27:49 probably the best contract I've ever worked on for success.

0:27:53 I'm feeling pretty positive.

0:27:56 Other bidders were from Montana, Oregon, and to Utah.

0:28:00 But only four of the five that you guys qualified were submitted.

0:28:04 I think our SCI is as good as one can get, I think they're the best.

0:28:11 Good. And surety bonding on the project is that bonding has been completed. We're kind of going

0:28:18 through this award cycle. So they bonded their bid. They just haven't we haven't done the bonding.

0:28:23 We do all the insurance bonding. We actually give them a nose to proceed. And we're also moving

0:28:28 into the heavy construction phase of the site. I'm concerned about our Canyon Spring Road. Can it

0:28:34 take all the movement of not only the steel and the concrete, but the wheels and axles and the

0:28:40 everything on their road, it obviously can't do our reconstruction of the grade right now,

0:28:47 but I mean, is it going to evaporate or speed up the destruction of that grade?

0:28:51 I think we feel that it will probably deteriorate a lot faster.

0:28:55 That's why we allotted that $1 million, and it really is a scheduling issue.

0:28:58 We don't want to inhibit this construction contract or the construction package to contract

0:29:03 it from doing their job.

0:29:04 We're slowing them down so we can't really go in there and fix it.

0:29:08 I think we'll maintain it the best we can and kind of bandaid it through, especially the

0:29:12 corner there.

0:29:13 I was noticing last night that it's really starting to rep, starting to push on that first

0:29:16 hairpin corner.

0:29:17 But we'll try to minimize that as much as we can and we really believe that once this

0:29:22 project is done, we will have to be doing something significant at that.

0:29:26 And then if you could reacquaint the council for the public's information, restrictions

0:29:31 on exercising, biking, walking on that grade, is that limited during the daytime construction

0:29:37 period?

0:29:38 So the contractor, we offer that to him and he actually has chosen not to, well,

0:29:44 construction package one contractor has chosen not to do that.

0:29:47 He has a fill-up worth his time and money to have flaggers up there more to limit the one way construction.

0:29:54 And so far there hasn't been an impact.

0:29:56 So that's not very reassuring what's comfortable for him may not be safe for the public.

0:30:01 It really isn't. And we are concerned about that. That's why we limited a lot of funds.

0:30:05 Travis, have we brought I-cramp into this project at all and made them aware of an additional exposure of the public during this construction time?

0:30:17 We haven't brought I-cramp in because the use of the grade is at your own risk.

0:30:23 Idaho has recreational immunities and it has the other types of things because we're

0:30:29 not assessing a fee, individuals are walking down that and should an individual get struck

0:30:36 very unfortunate by a member of the construction crew, we would be a civil claim and the liability

0:30:43 would be placed upon probably the driver and the company moving forward.

0:30:47 I think it's certainly something that we could talk about in terms of what does that look

0:30:52 like, and from a position of being us, for us being in a position to analyze the risk, we

0:30:58 can look at that as well, and we can get into a place where they may not want it, but we could

0:31:02 mandate it.

0:31:03 I recognize that we're at the wrong risk on that grade, but I witnessed rocks falling off

0:31:09 the canyon that may be directly or indirectly attributed to the traffic and the water and

0:31:15 everything else.

0:31:16 I would think we would be a claimant in a case like that if we're

0:31:20 exaggerating the shaking of the walls.

0:31:23 So, just a real uneasy that we're doing just what the contractor wants for their

0:31:28 convenience without additional mitigating efforts of some sort.

0:31:33 I'm not comfortable with them being comfortable, and that's not been a little safer.

0:31:38 That's something we can work into.

0:31:41 Before we move on, Travis, did you want to go back to the bond?

0:31:43 to the bond, did you have a comment on that?

0:31:47 I think you were trying to weigh in

0:31:48 and we kept talking, okay?

0:31:50 Okay, great, Grantine.

0:31:52 Well, you know, just to weigh in on that

0:31:54 exact issue as well.

0:31:57 You know, maybe it's because I've chosen,

0:31:59 if I walk out of the canyon,

0:32:00 I've chosen to go to a safer spot,

0:32:03 walk out of the chision grade,

0:32:04 but there, I mean, not the grade, but the trail.

0:32:08 You know, if we think it's dangerous,

0:32:09 I think it might be, but who best of we close it

0:32:11 to the pest pedestrian biking?

0:32:13 be honest with you. I think it probably will be upset about it, but it is a short term,

0:32:19 and if we're talking safety, that is the safest. I mean, you can flag it and make it one way,

0:32:23 but that doesn't mean that a truck isn't going to still not see somebody in the sun or something

0:32:27 on that line. So, I mean, I think that's one of our choices. We have to consider as well

0:32:32 for this construction period. We close it to pedestrian and bike traffic, because they

0:32:38 certainly have other places they can walk out of the canyon. They just have to go to

0:32:42 They have to drive a couple of miles.

0:32:45 Right.

0:32:46 And we can certainly look into that, obviously, safety is critical and important and we want

0:32:51 to make sure that users of that are safe.

0:32:55 And I think that Councilman Talkington is right, that there may not be a legal responsibility,

0:33:01 but there's probably a moral obligation to take a look at that and ensure that that is

0:33:07 progressing and safe in a manner that doesn't impact individuals.

0:33:11 Okay. On a sign note, the savings that we've got from this, well, let me go back here, so the actual bids, if you look up, it's all a running number of what we have now, it's roughly 28,726,000.

0:33:29 If you had in the Canvas reach roadway, and this 1.3 million for the Belkopress, we're right about 31,000, 91,000 has changed.

0:33:39 Originally, we had a lot of $32 million for this project.

0:33:41 I think we're really, really on schedule.

0:33:44 Those savings, there's some change order money

0:33:47 associated with building right here that if this isn't used

0:33:50 for seeing circumstances and the savings here,

0:33:55 we would really like to look at some options

0:33:57 as far as capacity and meet in the obligation

0:33:59 of the wastewater treatment plan.

0:34:01 We're still keeping the $6 million originally anticipated

0:34:04 for the collection line system in whole,

0:34:06 We don't want to lose any opportunities on making either the treatment plan have more capacity or bettering the operation

0:34:16 Stell there, so I just wanted to bring that up

0:34:19 Other than that I stand for any questions. Oh

0:34:22 We need a chart here kind of shows where we are of course

0:34:29 We we had the bond approved back in 2013 and from 9.6 million gallons

0:34:34 We've done our groundbreaking and we're we're starting through a portion of this and we'll make sure we get this email

0:34:40 and we'll put it on our city website so all the public will be aware of it but

0:34:44 to wrap this around for people to look at and as it continues to grow we'll

0:34:48 update this and pay for it from you but we're still a ways away June to June 2015

0:34:53 before we get the 13 million gallons and this assumes that we're not using the

0:34:57 CEPT system which is a chemical feed system down there and putting it towards

0:35:13 the camera up there in the corner too. I don't know if they can see it or not.

0:35:18 So, this assumes 9.6 million gallons since we're not using the CEPT treatment system.

0:35:24 And that is for actually, for slug loads and other mitigation that we have along the way.

0:35:30 So, every once in a while, we, the city will clean our sewer systems and we'll get a wash

0:35:35 of additional TSS and BOD down our system.

0:35:39 And we use that chemical system to enhance that and use it to still lead our permit requirements.

0:35:45 So this 16 million gallons doesn't reflect that usage, but it is 16 million gallons a day.

0:35:53 So I wanted to bring that up as well.

0:35:55 Oh, there it is.

0:35:58 So any other questions?

0:35:59 I'd be happy to answer them.

0:36:00 And Drake is here.

0:36:01 We're CH, so he can answer a lot of the technical aspects of it.

0:36:04 Sean Beriker.

0:36:05 So just a minor comment on the notice of award that was included in our packet.

0:36:11 Under item six, there's an extra word, 60 in there.

0:36:15 So the number doesn't read clearly on the amount,

0:36:18 the number is right, but it's spelled out

0:36:21 and there's an extra 60.

0:36:22 So for you saying that, you might want to clean up that,

0:36:25 one word.

0:36:28 Thank you.

0:36:30 Chris Tockington.

0:36:32 We're ready for a motion.

0:36:35 I would move authorization to award the contractor

0:36:39 records to construction and doing businesses RSCI

0:36:44 the amount of 17 million auto exceed 17,963,307.

0:36:50 For construction package two of the wastewater treatment

0:36:53 plan upgrade.

0:36:54 Second.

0:36:57 We have a motion from Chris Tockington,

0:36:59 seconded by Sean Berger.

0:37:00 Is there any further discussion from the council?

0:37:04 There's two different numbers in here.

0:37:05 So is that the correct effort?

0:37:06 Yes, correct.

0:37:07 Okay, good.

0:37:09 Leila roll call vote please.

0:37:15 No, was that okay?

0:37:17 So the 17,968,000, that's what we will work

0:37:20 to them along with the other so the 17 million is included in some of these two number 16

0:37:27 two fifty four one one million seven hundred eight thousand was that up to that total the

0:37:33 two million two hundred fifty thousand is kind of a contract reserve just so we keep we keep

0:37:38 that in the back of our minds because there are unforeseen circumstances where we'll run

0:37:42 it to a large something we didn't plan for either rock or large boulders or something

0:37:48 like that, then we need to actually issue a change order.

0:37:51 It's common to do that on projects, very common, so.

0:37:54 The rock clause.

0:37:55 A rock clause, yeah.

0:37:56 So there's nothing but rock down there.

0:37:59 Actually, we've been pretty lucky so far.

0:38:01 Really?

0:38:02 I'll say it.

0:38:03 Cool.

0:38:04 The $2,250,000 is included in this.

0:38:07 But this is actually what we award to the contractor.

0:38:11 So we're good on the motion?

0:38:15 Yes, that includes all the bid alternates.

0:38:18 So I want to make sure you're aware of that,

0:38:22 that we're recommending all those.

0:38:26 Okay, Leah, I think we're ready for a vote.

0:38:29 Greg Lanting.

0:38:30 Yes.

0:38:31 Chris Talking.

0:38:31 Yes.

0:38:32 Rebecca Mosleyka.

0:38:34 Yes.

0:38:35 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:38:36 Yes.

0:38:37 Sean Beroger.

0:38:38 Yes.

0:38:39 Motion passes five to zero.

0:38:41 Greg Lanting.

0:38:42 Well, I just like to take Troy and Greg

0:38:45 and all those folks that see it, too,

0:38:46 know about helping us through this.

0:38:49 When I was setting through those meetings,

0:38:51 well, how long ago was it now?

0:38:53 year ago in April as kind of the Council Representative to the Citizens Committee that

0:38:59 was working through this and making the decision on how big of a bond to go for and when to

0:39:05 go and all those things.

0:39:07 I guess maybe at that point in my mind I really didn't know what was ever going to happen.

0:39:11 So it's such exciting to actually make the big, the big, the big, the big portion of this

0:39:18 and what's going to happen is it's going to be such a fun day to go down there.

0:39:22 Got a ribbon someday that will be a better be great. Thank you. Yeah, I really think you know

0:39:26 This is really the communities

0:39:29 Four sites really put this together and I get a lot of calls daily from developers and people want to come to twin

0:39:35 You can see all the developments currently going on and it's nice to say we are we are working hard to serve you so I

0:39:41 Like that we're 22% under the engineers estimate on this

0:39:45 And I didn't mean to short all of the engineering department as well besides

0:39:51 Royal. I'm talking about all the city staff that have worked very hard on this.

0:39:55 I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. We're going to move on to item

0:40:02 number four, which is the consideration of a request to change the City of Twin Falls Cited in E-32

0:40:07 current credit card process. And we have Lori race. Good evening, Vice Mayor and

0:40:30 and City Council. Tonight I'd like to share with you a proposed change to our current

0:40:35 credit card process. And I just want to start out by sharing what we're currently doing.

0:40:44 Right now we have 16 cards in specific employees names and they're kept locked in the vault

0:40:49 and finance. An employee must fill out an approval form which requires their department

0:40:56 head's authorization, along with the City Manager, the CFO, or the Assistant Finance Director.

0:41:04 And after those two approvals are received, the employee takes the completed form to finance

0:41:09 to check out the credit card.

0:41:12 We record information in a book, the data was checked out, who checked it out, and when

0:41:17 they return the card.

0:41:19 The employee then takes that card and makes the authorized expenditure, but that's provided

0:41:25 of the vendor accepts that credit card, and what I mean by that is if I go to make an expenditure

0:41:31 and I don't have a credit card, but I have Travis's credit card, if the vendor says, Mr.

0:41:37 Rothweiler, can we see some ID?

0:41:39 I'm in trouble.

0:41:42 After the charges have been made, the employee is to attach the receipts to that original

0:41:46 form and return to accounts payable so they can compare against our monthly statement when

0:41:52 we receive that.

0:41:53 And that statement arrives, Sharon starts matching up paperwork and receipts to the charges on

0:41:59 that statement.

0:42:00 And if everything checks out, the statement is processed for payment.

0:42:05 But I can assure you that rarely happens.

0:42:07 Receipts are missing and sometimes there's no paperwork that's turned in at all.

0:42:12 Time is spent calling departments and trying to track down receipts.

0:42:16 We've actually incurred some late fees and some finance charges because the approval form

0:42:21 and receipts haven't been turned in timely.

0:42:24 And I really don't want a member of my team approving

0:42:27 something when they don't know if it's a legitimate charge.

0:42:33 When I try to be objective and look at the pros of the current

0:42:37 process, I would say that the limit that we have on those

0:42:40 cards is a positive because it limits our exposure.

0:42:44 Most of the cards have a $1,500 limit.

0:42:47 When I look at the negatives or the cons of our system, I

0:42:51 I would say that sending any card with an employee that's not the name on the card is negative.

0:42:57 Lost paperwork and receipts make it difficult for our accounts payable to reconcile that monthly fee to the 16 cards that are used.

0:43:07 And it also takes time away from other tasks she should be doing.

0:43:11 Unnecessary expense for late fees and finance charges is really not being a good steward of taxpayer dollars.

0:43:18 And several weeks pass between the purchase and when we receive the statement, folks tend

0:43:23 to get busy with their normal workloads and they forget about charges, receipts and paperwork.

0:43:33 The new process that I would like you to consider would do away without approval form.

0:43:39 I will work with the senior staff team to identify our employees who use those credit cards regularly

0:43:45 for travel and training and memberships and dues and purchasing supplies.

0:43:51 Each authorized employee would need to read and sign a credit card policy and procedure

0:43:56 statement.

0:43:57 I included an example in the packet and it would indicate the appropriate and inappropriate

0:44:03 use of the card along with the language that failure to comply with the detailed guidelines

0:44:09 for authorized purchases under the program could result in disciplinary action, cancellation

0:44:16 of card privileges and possible termination of employment.

0:44:21 When an employee makes purchases with this card, they will be notified via email that

0:44:27 it's time to review their statement.

0:44:30 They will access the card expense reporting tool through the internet and they get to review

0:44:34 their statement.

0:44:36 They are responsible for retaining all receipts for items purchased and for ensuring all transactions

0:44:42 posted are legitimate purchases made by them on behalf of the city.

0:44:48 If everything is in order, the statement is marked as reviewed and an email is then sent

0:44:54 to their manager or designated supervisor for their review and approval.

0:44:59 That manager can go immediately online to review the charges, mark them as approved,

0:45:05 and the information is sent back to Wells Fargo.

0:45:08 Once all outstanding charges have been approved, Wells can deduct the amount from our checking

0:45:13 account and that information is automatically downloaded into our general ledger.

0:45:22 So I would just share with you that the benefits that I see from this proposed change are immediate

0:45:28 access and review of all of our electronic charges, upfront settings, and what this means

0:45:35 is that we can issue or cancel cards and authorize where, when, and how much hardholders can spend.

0:45:44 We can assign monthly dollar limits, daily dollar limits, or per transaction dollar limits.

0:45:52 for each card. We can block merchant categories for each card, and we can control the number

0:45:58 of transactions per month or per day that each card can do. Cards issued in an employee's

0:46:05 name ensures accountability from that employee. And if they sell them use their card, we can

0:46:12 set that limit to $1 until such time as they would need to access it. The city is protected

0:46:19 with $1,000 liability insurance per card,

0:46:23 and right now we just have death and dismemberment.

0:46:28 Employees may check their balances and expenditures

0:46:30 online at any time, but they have no control

0:46:34 to change their limits or do anything else with their card.

0:46:37 That would be a function of the finance team.

0:46:41 Accounts payable will not be hunting down purchases,

0:46:44 tracking down receipts, or trying

0:46:46 to reconcile the monthly billings.

0:46:48 No more late fees or finance charges

0:46:50 because of lost paperwork or receipts.

0:46:54 Electronic workflows facilitate review

0:46:56 and approval of expenditures and audit capabilities

0:47:00 ensure adherence to our policy.

0:47:05 So I would just share that I view our credit cards

0:47:08 as a tool that we provide for our employees.

0:47:13 And with the new process I am proposing,

0:47:15 we would have better controls in place

0:47:18 that would protect the city, and at the same time allow our employees to use this tool as

0:47:23 it was intended. So that's all I have, and I would be happy to answer any questions. Rob

0:47:30 Adkins, our personal banker from Wells Fargo is also here to help answer any questions you

0:47:34 might have. Thank you, Lori. Chris Talkington.

0:47:38 So before you had 16 credit cards, I guess it were checked out as needed, but they had

0:47:44 not a name on them. No, they do have me. This would have a department head or a responsible

0:47:49 person per card on a card. They would not be turning in paperwork, but at a vendor they

0:47:58 would do an electronic receding that would come in. So first of all, Chris, let me make

0:48:06 sure you understand. Right now those 16 cards are issued in specific names. Okay.

0:48:12 And so we've identified people who typically use them and if somebody in the

0:48:18 police department wants to send somebody on training to Georgia with the dog, that's

0:48:24 not really a good tool for that employee because if they can't prove their brain

0:48:29 pike or brain career then it really doesn't do them any good. And so what I am

0:48:34 proposing is that we not necessarily issue a credit card for every city employee but rather

0:48:40 look at the folks who typically use those and the card would be issued in their name because when

0:48:47 you have a specific name attached to it you have better accountability and those can be tied down

0:48:54 number of transactions dollar amount of transactions where they're spent so we have really good

0:48:59 controls in place, or would have.

0:49:03 But all vendors are set up to do the electronic reconciliation of receipts.

0:49:10 So when you order something online, you should get a receipt.

0:49:13 I know that whenever I buy something online, I get a receipt.

0:49:17 So that employee is responsible to maintain that receipt.

0:49:22 And then they'll get something from Wells Fargo saying your statement's ready to review.

0:49:26 And they've got their receipts, they've got their receipts saying this is what I purchased.

0:49:34 Yep, click, click, click.

0:49:35 I reviewed it.

0:49:37 Then it goes to the appropriate supervisor or manager to review.

0:49:41 And if they have any questions, they touch base with that employee and otherwise they say

0:49:45 yep.

0:49:46 I guess where I was confused, I must be the only one.

0:49:49 I thought that there had been a problem currently of the purchaser not getting the paperwork

0:49:55 or not turning it in.

0:49:59 No, I don't.

0:49:59 We're losing it or something.

0:50:02 Just for a sample, Chris.

0:50:08 This is what we currently do.

0:50:13 And so you have to keep receipts and attachments.

0:50:17 And, OK.

0:50:20 OK, thank you.

0:50:22 Rebecca Milsoica.

0:50:24 Thank you, guys, Mayor.

0:50:25 Two quick questions.

0:50:27 One is a follow-up on Chris's question.

0:50:30 When that employee gets that email, is that also sent to the department head just in case

0:50:35 that employee, you know, sometimes you get a lot of emails, you might overlook it, you

0:50:39 might forget to double check and pay it.

0:50:42 So are there maybe two people that are getting this email just to make sure it gets attention

0:50:48 and gets reviewed and approved?

0:50:54 In regards to that question, if the employee does not meet certain deadlines in terms of

0:50:59 completing and reconciling that statement on a timely basis, then it will trigger eventually

0:51:04 an email to their supervisor letting them know that they have not reconciled that statement.

0:51:10 And eventually, these are parameters that you can set up yourself.

0:51:15 If they don't complete their reconciliation, you can set it up that in 30 or 60 days their

0:51:19 card has turned off if they don't reconcile that in the time of basis.

0:51:23 Thank you.

0:51:24 And I was thinking more along the lines of those late fees and service charges that you

0:51:29 were talking about.

0:51:30 So with that, that email come before that payment would be due, so you would avoid those

0:51:37 late fees.

0:51:38 So, Rebecca, I wish Jamie were here.

0:51:42 I'm pretty sure that that would occur.

0:51:45 There are.

0:51:46 You know, some of those things we haven't quite worked all the way out, but absolutely

0:51:51 we would set something up.

0:51:53 You know, you've still got a full statement that has to be paid timely.

0:51:57 Sorry, Rob.

0:52:00 Regarding the payment of the credit card bill that's due each month, as long as you have

0:52:05 money in the checking account, it's going to get paid every month on time.

0:52:09 We will not.

0:52:10 You'll be debited automatically each month for whatever charges were on that card.

0:52:15 So you just, you will not have late fees relative to this.

0:52:19 As far as the employee of reconciling the account and explaining those charges, that is somewhat

0:52:26 of a separate issue.

0:52:28 we will collect whatever's due each month.

0:52:33 Okay, so second question, is there a fee for this service

0:52:39 or is this just part of a thing for this service?

0:52:42 Thank you.

0:52:44 Great, Lansing.

0:52:45 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

0:52:47 I really like the feature of that you can set each card

0:52:50 with its individual limits.

0:52:52 I can't even fathom setting a daily

0:52:54 or any of those kind of things,

0:52:55 but just a set of the limits,

0:52:57 because I think all of us have fresh in our mind

0:53:00 situation the county had probably a decade ago now that where they had an

0:53:05 employee that was a gambling issue and they ran up a pretty big some pretty big

0:53:10 credit card issue bills and with those kind of individual limits and daily limits

0:53:16 that kind of thing that that takes care of that right there. Well and and you

0:53:20 could set a limit on where that card can be used as well. Right so the case

0:53:25 machine that they've seen or doesn't work. Thank you. I have a question. So the

0:53:32 employee is responsible to keep their receipts and do their own balance. After

0:53:37 they've done that, what happens to the paper receipts? They just... So Suzanne, I

0:53:43 would probably recommend that they hold those until their supervisors reviewed

0:53:47 that electronically. If the supervisor or manager has any questions, they can ask

0:53:53 Here's the receipt, here's what I bought, and once it's been approved, it's good to go.

0:54:00 So there is a feature where you can, for a fee, attach electronic receipts for a while,

0:54:09 and I thought at one point that might be a good idea.

0:54:12 But in talking with another gentleman from Wells Fargo, Jamie Majin, again, he said that

0:54:21 They don't use that feature, that they just make the employees responsible for keeping copies

0:54:27 of their receipts right from the get-go.

0:54:30 So my idea of using it temporarily probably isn't the best idea.

0:54:34 So I really liked the idea of they keep their receipts, they're responsible.

0:54:39 If you want to use a credit card, there's some responsibility that goes with it.

0:54:42 So just because we're not in the office day-to-day police fire, do they have desks or

0:54:49 place to keep those records because, you know, their car is their office, so how would that

0:54:56 work for them?

0:54:57 So right now, Chief Pike has a credit card, the three captains do the lieutenant and Patty

0:55:05 Roweater, who does a lot of the travel and training purchasing.

0:55:09 I don't know that every police officer would have to have a credit card because I think

0:55:14 they probably have folks in the office who would take care of purchasing for them.

0:55:19 The new philosophy that we're trying to move forward with is it doesn't take away that every once in a while, someone will make a purchase with their personal debit card, and then we would reimburse them for that.

0:55:36 So the idea is to take a look at individuals who utilize cards in the transaction of city business on a regular basis, and then we would give them cards.

0:55:49 And if they have a one-time purchase that might exceed their normal allocated credit limit and that is pre-authorized and approved,

0:56:01 Lori has the ability to temporarily raise that and then to be able to lower that after the payment has been made.

0:56:10 So it gives us also a lot of flexibility internally because there's also been occurrences where individuals have utilized those cards

0:56:18 cards over a period of time, and that we've actually been declined because the balance

0:56:24 and the credit limits that we've set had been used in that one month duration. So it gives

0:56:32 us the opportunity to track it, to monitor it, to make those purchases. And I think that

0:56:36 the biggest selling point, like Lori shared, was really the heightened level of accountability.

0:56:41 I mean, Lori's job as the CFO is to ensure that the practices and policies that we have

0:56:48 at the city, honor the fiduciary responsibility that we have to our citizen, and when she

0:56:54 starts looking at our credit card policy, there's clearly a better way.

0:56:59 She took this policy and introduced it to the members of the city's senior management

0:57:05 team.

0:57:06 We reviewed it, we vetted it, we talked about it, and we said we think this makes good

0:57:10 organizational sense, and because the council is involved in the establishment of the current

0:57:15 credit card policy, we felt it appropriate to come back and say we would like to change

0:57:19 that policy to the one that Lori is presented this evening.

0:57:23 Thank you. Any other discussion from Council? Sean Berger.

0:57:31 So I'm supportive of a change in the policy, but I think one thing I'd like to ask is that

0:57:38 in a few months, could you come back and let us know how it's working?

0:57:41 Yes.

0:57:42 Because I think there are a few things that I have concern about, so

0:57:47 sort of the bill gets automatically paid.

0:57:51 Finance is going to review that, so say there's things that haven't been reconciled.

0:57:56 Are you still going to go chase all the paperwork or

0:57:58 process that you would have been chasing now, even with this new policy?

0:58:04 And I just want to see how those things are working.

0:58:07 reviewing that bill and making sure it's been approved by the appropriate manager and supervisor.

0:58:13 And if there's an issue there, Sean, to me it becomes an issue between the person who has the privilege of having the credit card and their department manager.

0:58:23 So we will definitely track those things and I will be happy to come back and give a report.

0:58:27 Okay, I think my questions are more about the internal application of the process.

0:58:32 not so much how the credit cards are issued or when the banks getting paid and those kinds

0:58:37 of things because truthfully if part of the issue has been people not keeping track of

0:58:42 their receipts, you know, so for example, we don't have company credit cards where I work,

0:58:48 I put that on my personal credit card, if I don't have receipts and I turn that in for

0:58:51 reimbursement with no receipts, I don't get reimbursed.

0:58:54 So there doesn't seem to be that teeth piece of this when it's just going through this process.

0:59:01 I think, you know, after a few months of it, maybe six months, it would be nice to have a

0:59:05 report back of how's that working.

0:59:08 Thank you.

0:59:09 Thank you.

0:59:10 Chris, talking to you.

0:59:11 Yeah, I like Sean's idea.

0:59:12 I think we need a closed loop on this.

0:59:14 Get some feedback.

0:59:15 Could you answer this under your new system?

0:59:19 You have a rogue employee doing the most damage you can with your new system.

0:59:24 What is the downside ultimate downside for us?

0:59:29 So I'm going to answer the best that I can and call on my friend Rob to back me up.

0:59:35 So first of all, we're going to have limits.

0:59:37 We're not just going to give somebody a large limit on their card.

0:59:42 Second of all, if we have a rogue employee, there's the $100,000 liability per card to

0:59:49 help with misuse of that card.

0:59:52 A $100,000 liability per card.

0:59:58 And it's for the misuse of that card.

1:00:00 Is that an eye cramp or is that through wells?

1:00:02 That's through wells.

1:00:04 Is that actually for a measure?

1:00:06 Mm-hmm.

1:00:08 Okay.

1:00:09 But the worst damage financially would be the limit of the card.

1:00:12 Bad.

1:00:14 And the cost of us going to Grand Bahamas and trying to rescue a card from the guy.

1:00:20 Or be that high of a limit.

1:00:24 Okay.

1:00:26 Any other comments from council?

1:00:29 I would stand for a motion.

1:00:30 Great.

1:00:31 of the new credit card policy as outlined by our CFO at Lori Race.

1:00:39 Second.

1:00:40 We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded by Chris Talkington.

1:00:45 Any other discussion?

1:00:46 Well I think we need that Sean put that on the floor.

1:00:50 Yeah, we have within five or six months we have a report back from Lori concerning how

1:00:56 well it's working.

1:00:57 If my second will accept it.

1:00:59 Yeah.

1:01:00 So the motion then is to approve the changes to the current credit card process with a report

1:01:07 back in six months on how it is working for us.

1:01:13 Leila, roll call vote please.

1:01:16 Yes.

1:01:17 Yes.

1:01:18 Yes.

1:01:19 Yes.

1:01:20 Yes.

1:01:21 Yes.

1:01:22 Yes.

1:01:23 Yes.

1:01:24 Motion passes five to zero.

1:01:27 Lori, thank you for all the work and time you put into that for us.

1:01:33 Moving on to item five, we are going to have Mitch Humble now with the presentation on

1:01:39 the Zoning Ordinance Amendment process.

1:01:47 Welcome, Mitch.

1:01:48 Okay.

1:01:56 So I just wanted to share kind of our progress on some of these.

1:02:01 I'm authorized to start working out with the primarily most of the works been done with the zoning ordinance amendment committee.

1:02:09 So if you guys, this is an attachment in the staff report,

1:02:14 so the attachment that they had was the list of amendments

1:02:18 that we had previously approved.

1:02:19 There was 16 of them from about, not quite two years ago,

1:02:24 I think it was around September 12,

1:02:25 and we started the whole thing.

1:02:27 Of the 16, I gave just like a brief kind of status of where

1:02:32 we're at with some of them, some of them have been approved,

1:02:34 some have been reviewed, and the decision may not

1:02:38 to pursue further, um, summer under way, um, the, a lot of this you already know from the

1:02:44 last update I gave several months ago, but since then I, I guess I'll say that we've

1:02:49 had progress on three specific, um, projects. Uh, one of those, what, is the request from

1:02:57 a building height standpoint, um, particularly with our exceptions to a maximum building

1:03:03 high in some of our non-residential zones.

1:03:06 The zoning ordinance amendment committee has basically finished the work that they did

1:03:10 on that.

1:03:13 We kind of took a couple of drafts in front of our full planning zoning commission for

1:03:17 the last probably two or three, well not the last two or three.

1:03:23 We've taken it to the planning zoning commission two or three times in the last four or five

1:03:26 months for them to review and give us some feedback.

1:03:30 And now that is basically pretty prepared, we've got an ordinance form and we scheduled

1:03:34 for a public hearing at the Planning and Zoning Commission for, I don't want to say it's July

1:03:40 8th, and then following that recommendation we'll come to the Council for Public Hearing

1:03:45 as well.

1:03:47 Along those same lines, we've redone our entire parking section of the zoning ordinance.

1:03:53 Again, on most of the work being done by the Zoning ordinance committee, we took that also

1:04:01 to the planning zone commission that there are lunchtime work sessions probably four

1:04:04 or five or three or four times and that also is scheduled for public hearing that this is

1:04:08 at the PNC for July 8th upon their recommendation again it will come back here for public hearing

1:04:17 and potential adoption.

1:04:18 And then the final one that we've actually had some real progress on is the change for

1:04:23 our planning and development process and we've got a pretty good draft to that.

1:04:28 One of the things we're doing there is we're switching the name up, and I don't know that

1:04:32 I've spent a lot of time on this with the council, obviously Chris is going to be aware

1:04:37 of this being on the committee at the time when we went through it, but basically we're

1:04:41 kind of re-organizing or calling it something different, I guess.

1:04:47 When you look at planned unit development in the statute, the state says what planned unit

1:04:54 the developments can and can't be, and NARS doesn't really match what the state says it

1:04:59 can be as a planning and development, and so we're calling it more like a development agreement.

1:05:03 It's essentially what we do with them is we use them like a development agreement, so we're

1:05:07 going to go ahead and change the name of those things, not column planning and developments

1:05:10 anymore, but rather column zoning development agreements like they kind of are, to better

1:05:16 coincide with what the statute says regarding PUDs.

1:05:21 That's a significant change because we refer to PUDs like everywhere in our Title 10.

1:05:27 There's very references all over the place that refer you back to this.

1:05:32 This title on PUDs, we got to go find every single reference to a PUD and change it to

1:05:36 a zoning development agreement.

1:05:37 So it's kind of tedious and it makes, basically reading through every single page of the code

1:05:42 to try and find these references and then change the name, but not just change the name,

1:05:47 to see if there's any other things in that section

1:05:50 that we need to also change,

1:05:51 because of the changes we're making in the PUD section.

1:05:55 And so that's coming around.

1:05:57 It will probably be in front of the planning

1:06:00 and zoning commission we're hearing

1:06:02 in the next month or so with that one.

1:06:07 The Zoning Ordinance Committee also started working

1:06:10 on an amendment to title, or chapter four,

1:06:13 chapter four in the comp plan,

1:06:15 or in the zoning or is this big?

1:06:18 It talks about all the different zoning districts

1:06:20 and what you can and can't do

1:06:21 in the different zoning districts.

1:06:23 And it's basically a very comprehensive look at uses

1:06:27 and where you can do uses and is it appropriate

1:06:30 or is it not appropriate?

1:06:31 And we just started kind of scratching the surface of that

1:06:35 when we sort of put the brakes on the Zowak Committee

1:06:39 a little while ago.

1:06:40 So that's not where we're at.

1:06:42 So there's still maybe half the list that hasn't yet begun,

1:06:48 and about half the list that's either done or at some stage

1:06:51 of being done.

1:06:54 So that's kind of the brief update on those.

1:06:58 I did want to talk a little bit about this, and then the mayor

1:07:01 and I had several conversations about how to proceed with this.

1:07:05 And so I'm not sure where to go without his input here

1:07:09 and how we've talked about it.

1:07:10 But when we've gone to the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:07:16 in their lunchtime meetings, in the last,

1:07:19 we probably started doing it in the fall last month,

1:07:22 kind of giving them these data updates

1:07:24 and asking if they're feedback.

1:07:26 There are members of that commission

1:07:27 who are not on the ZOAC committee

1:07:30 who have expressed a lot of gratitude and appreciation

1:07:34 for having those discussions in front of the Planning

1:07:36 and Zoning Commission because they were being excluded

1:07:39 from that participation before.

1:07:40 And they have really kind of latched onto it, I guess.

1:07:45 They like it the whole, we don't often get nine members

1:07:48 at the lunch work sessions since we're not actually doing

1:07:52 business, but a lot of times there's six or seven of them

1:07:57 there, and then they all are participative

1:07:59 in asking questions and giving some feedback.

1:08:01 And in the lack of our ZOAC meetings for the last several

1:08:06 months, they've really kind of filled in that role.

1:08:09 and they like filling in that role.

1:08:11 And so that's the feedback I provided to Don

1:08:14 on Mayor Hall a little while ago.

1:08:16 And so we were bouncing this idea back and forth.

1:08:21 Back in December, January timeframe,

1:08:23 with the changes to the Transparency Resolution,

1:08:26 the Zawak Committee, as we had been doing,

1:08:28 could not continue to operate.

1:08:29 And in fact, it was wiped out.

1:08:31 And then right immediately after that,

1:08:34 we created it again by resolution.

1:08:36 And then we appointed two members of the Council deserve on that.

1:08:39 So right now we have a ZOH Act Committee,

1:08:40 we have two members of the Council and no other appointments.

1:08:44 So we're going to run back that direction with the ZOH Act

1:08:48 Committee.

1:08:48 We need to go through an appointment process

1:08:50 and get some more people appointed to that Committee.

1:08:54 I don't know how the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:08:55 fits in that conversation.

1:08:58 We did have two members of the P&Z on that Committee before,

1:09:02 and they were good and participated,

1:09:04 and we're glad to have them.

1:09:05 And there's others that would like to be part of it as well.

1:09:08 So part of this conversation that I wanted to open up for that,

1:09:13 sort of feedback from the council direction

1:09:15 and where you wanted to go with it.

1:09:17 But I also understand that the mayor isn't here

1:09:20 and I don't know how you want to handle that, I guess.

1:09:23 So I just thought that out to you guys.

1:09:25 But with that, that's really all I wanted to share

1:09:28 as part of my presentation.

1:09:29 So if you want to ask questions, I'll have to answer them.

1:09:36 Chris Daukington.

1:09:37 I'm not sure the Council is cognizant on one of the reasons that we formed that ZOIC Committee.

1:09:44 It was really to, rather than wait something to come, the piece of business to come before P&Z or Council,

1:09:53 we wanted to do a complete review.

1:09:55 Did we not have the title 10?

1:09:58 And just look to update, exclude, edit, modify, change sections that were no longer current or pertinent.

1:10:06 I mean that was the philosophy and if that if you agree that can P&Z still

1:10:12 handle that on a catching up the code in addition to their regular order of

1:10:20 business? I would go back a little bit to a couple years ago in the first started

1:10:26 meeting of the Zawak Committee and amendments to the zoning ordinance can

1:10:32 happen in three different ways. The council can tell staff to go work on an

1:10:38 amendment, the Planning and Zoning Commission can initiate the amendment or an applicant

1:10:42 can come in and request an amendment. So essentially we brought a list of 16

1:10:47 things that we identified as potential needs and the council reviewed that

1:10:52 list and said okay go work on that list. So there are specific identified needs

1:10:58 that wasn't a full let's review all of Title 10 kind of a thing. Now I don't think

1:11:03 that hurts, and I think it probably needs to be done, but at that meeting is when we decided

1:11:11 let's go have a committee work on these items. So I would say it was a bit more limited in

1:11:16 its scope to those list of items that were approved.

1:11:22 That's fair.

1:11:24 Having said that, if the zoning committee or the planning zoning commission or the council

1:11:29 For that matter, we're to suggest, you know,

1:11:32 why don't we review such and such,

1:11:34 we could certainly bring that up.

1:11:36 In fact, some of the items on the list were exactly

1:11:39 brought up that exact way, you know.

1:11:43 Some of them were on the list because of questions,

1:11:45 the building height was part of example,

1:11:47 the questions from some of the council members saying,

1:11:49 why do we continue to do this?

1:11:51 Let's review and see if there's an amendment

1:11:53 that needs to be done, and so we included that on the list.

1:11:57 So, having said that, I think the new transparency resolution that we're working under is going

1:12:08 to have these meetings be open in public meetings, whether they're a ZOAC committee or a planning

1:12:13 and zoning commission.

1:12:15 In that case, I don't know that it's a significant difference.

1:12:20 I'm meeting monthly with the planning and zoning commission anyway.

1:12:23 We have a lunch work session with them every month, and a lot of these have been taking up

1:12:30 the balance of that agenda for the last several months, but occasionally something else comes

1:12:37 up a training situation where we'll have Fritz come and tell them all the things they can't

1:12:42 do, which was a recent one because we have several new planings and only Christian members,

1:12:47 So, you know, some things like that take up time, too, but I think we're going to have

1:12:54 to change the way we were doing it, but I would say more so as a result of the transparency

1:12:59 resolution than as a result of ZOAC versus the planning zone commission.

1:13:03 I think we're making those changes, we're going to have to anyway.

1:13:09 Rebecca Milsoica, thanks much for the update.

1:13:13 I requested it just because, you know, I had been thinking about, you know, ZOAC and one

1:13:17 was wondering kind of where it stood, but I do have to say that as the liaison to the

1:13:22 Planning and Zoning Commission, as I've been witnessing the commission work through these

1:13:29 amendments and really have these discussions at their work sessions, I think it's been really

1:13:34 productive and I'm not, I never witnessed a ZOAC meeting, but really they've been flowing

1:13:39 and functioning in the way that I imagined ZOAC was designed to work.

1:13:44 And so I appreciate you bringing this update, and I appreciate the work that's been happening,

1:13:51 you know, to bring these amendments forward.

1:13:56 And I'm glad to hear that we finally got that on hearing coming up in July.

1:14:04 That's really what I was interested in to make sure that this is going forward.

1:14:10 As we all know, our strategic plan has said that updating the codes is very important, so I want to make sure that we are continuing to go forward.

1:14:17 And I was reminded at AIC at the Association of Idaho City's conference this past week,

1:14:22 I went to a planning and zoning best practices session, and was reminded by a couple of the community sharing what they had done,

1:14:31 that our codes need to be driven and reflective of that strategic plan, of that comp plan.

1:14:38 And so I feel like we do still have some work to accomplish a ways to go to get those to coincide.

1:14:48 And so the only comment or, you know, input that I would give on this is that numbers 10 and 13 and I think 15 and 16.

1:15:05 And that's the planned unit developments, the canyon rim overlay, and the sign code and the

1:15:11 public hearing notice.

1:15:13 All of those discussions took place in the ZOAC that under our current transparency resolution,

1:15:20 those discussions wouldn't comply.

1:15:22 And so, you know, my question would be, you know, to the council, should we have those discussions

1:15:28 again this time and involve the public.

1:15:31 I mean, last time we meant to notice the PUDs and the parking

1:15:37 and the other amendments to the public somehow,

1:15:41 it kind of slipped through the cracks and they weren't notified.

1:15:43 But I really like when it goes through the work sessions

1:15:48 and that way citizens can have time to really bring solutions

1:15:55 and bring ideas and be involved in a meaningful way

1:16:00 on the work session level and then it can go to public hearing and that gives people

1:16:05 the required notice that two week period so that they can come and put that on their

1:16:11 schedules and be involved in a meaningful way. So that would be my suggestion maybe

1:16:17 a thought that we do review those because, especially with the Canyon Room Overlay,

1:16:23 I was a little bit surprised that the Zawak Committee would come back and say,

1:16:26 No, it's perfect, let's not change anything because through our hearings on some recent

1:16:33 developments on the Canyon Rim, we had hundreds and hundreds of people in the community that

1:16:38 said this doesn't fit our vision for the community.

1:16:41 And going back to our codes need to fit what the community wants to see in the developments.

1:16:51 Somehow there's a breakdown there.

1:16:53 You know, and I think it's small things.

1:16:55 I don't think it's a huge sweeping revision of the canyon room overlay.

1:16:59 One of the points that people brought up were just building orientation.

1:17:04 Or should there be a mandatory break in buildings so that we can retain some open space.

1:17:13 The compliment says that we should have some additional setbacks where we can

1:17:20 and put that contiguous with open space to increase the look of the openness of the canyon

1:17:27 room setting.

1:17:28 So I think those are all things that we might want to include the public in the discussion

1:17:33 since the ZOAC discussion was done without anyone being able to come in and just sit in

1:17:40 and have some, you know, have their thoughts added.

1:17:48 Any other comments?

1:17:49 Chris?

1:17:50 I worked on moving the Zolac process back through the planning and zoning hearing, workshop hearing process.

1:17:56 I disagree strongly with some of your comments Rebecca having been there.

1:18:00 But I think the transparency issue serves us best by putting it to the P&Z work session moving up that way.

1:18:10 So that's one of your recommendations.

1:18:11 I mean one of the options I mean.

1:18:13 I wasn't necessarily making a recommendation, I guess I was looking for feedback.

1:18:21 I wanted to share with the council some of the feelings that the commissioners had expressed

1:18:27 to me and I thought that it was good, valid feedback from the commissioners.

1:18:34 There were three or four of them that weren't serving on the ZOAC that really appreciated

1:18:40 being involved in that process.

1:18:44 And if we go to a ZOAC, if we continue

1:18:47 to use the ZOAC and make appointments to the ZOAC,

1:18:49 then we're going to be limiting to two of them.

1:18:51 By our own transparency resolution,

1:18:53 we can't have more than two shows.

1:18:54 So we'll be specifically excluding others from participating

1:19:01 until we get to the public hearing process.

1:19:02 And by that point, the creation of the thing is done.

1:19:06 It's sort of tweaking, I guess, at that point,

1:19:09 unless we send it back, like we did with the building height,

1:19:12 one way or no good, send it back and start over, right?

1:19:15 And so that can always happen,

1:19:17 but I don't know that I have a recommendation, I guess.

1:19:22 Well, you want some action out of this eventually though, Dan.

1:19:25 I do, well, I think we need to,

1:19:27 I think we need to start either populate the ZOAC

1:19:32 with appointments or go with the planning

1:19:35 of zoning question or both or something, right?

1:19:39 but we need to have something that is now

1:19:42 like our process moving forward.

1:19:46 We've been kind of in limbo for a little while

1:19:48 and limping along through the last few

1:19:52 and I think we need to get off high center there

1:19:55 and start going again.

1:19:57 Some of the ones that are left are significant workloads

1:20:01 and I know Chris, you saw.

1:20:03 We took the low-hanging first one that we started,

1:20:07 those last several meetings before we stop.

1:20:10 That's a very big project.

1:20:12 It's going to take some time to get through.

1:20:16 But yes, feedback either way.

1:20:20 If you want to wait for the other two to be here

1:20:22 so that we can get all seven, I guess that's OK too.

1:20:28 I think you'd be helpful if you gave us just options,

1:20:32 one, two, or three to decide.

1:20:34 Formulate them into a course of action that we can digest.

1:20:41 Sean Baragru?

1:20:43 You know, I think if the planning and zoning commissioners feel like they have time to do

1:20:50 this, because I know the workload they have on a regular basis is pretty time consuming.

1:20:57 And I can only imagine the amount of time that lies ahead for some of these issues.

1:21:04 So if they feel like they have the time and willingness to commit that, I don't have

1:21:07 a problem with it residing there.

1:21:09 I don't think we need to create another thing.

1:21:12 But if they don't have time, I don't think it will get done.

1:21:18 So that's one of my biggest concerns

1:21:20 is I think that the Planning and Zoning Commissioners are probably

1:21:24 the more knowledgeable in sorting through this

1:21:29 than just random hand-picked people

1:21:31 and throw them in at committee and say, go forth and conquer.

1:21:36 But I also think they need to have a realistic expectation

1:21:39 this isn't that we're going to look at it for the next five years and maybe get

1:21:43 around to bringing something back. So that's my only input on on who maybe should

1:21:49 do this. I also think that while I appreciate the work that the committee has

1:21:55 done on the quote, low hanging fruit, I think that some of these others are more

1:22:01 significant and probably more critical. You know, for example, I'm looking at here

1:22:05 urban village and urban infill. I mean, we've been talking about sort of

1:22:09 of neighborhood commercial development for eight years

1:22:14 that I've been around off and on up here

1:22:17 and we still don't have a code that even addresses it.

1:22:21 That's an issue, that's a concern that I have.

1:22:24 So I do think that the mayor needs to have input

1:22:28 into this and Jim as well if possible

1:22:32 without dragging it out another two or three months.

1:22:35 But I think that the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:22:38 feels like they can give it the attention that it needs.

1:22:43 I don't have a problem with it residing there.

1:22:46 I think that does address the public engagement process

1:22:50 as well.

1:22:52 I disagree that any of these were done

1:22:54 in some kind of a vacuum without participation,

1:22:57 but certainly more public input can be helpful

1:23:01 as we get through these.

1:23:03 Travis?

1:23:04 So what we'll do is we'll put this on the agenda

1:23:06 for next week and we'll notify Tom Frank,

1:23:09 who is the chairman of the Planning and Zoning Commission.

1:23:12 We'll ask him to come and maybe represent the interest

1:23:14 of the Planning and Zoning Commission

1:23:16 as the council kind of moves forward.

1:23:18 We'll take Councilman Talkington's suggestion

1:23:21 and we'll provide a series of possible opportunities

1:23:24 in the staff report of options

1:23:27 and what those look like in terms of moving forward.

1:23:30 Thank you.

1:23:31 Rebecca Milsoica.

1:23:32 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

1:23:34 Yeah, I would agree with Councilman Berger

1:23:36 and Councilman Talkington in moving forward

1:23:39 the direction of using the Planning and Zoning Commission and, you know, as Mitch said, and

1:23:44 I've heard they really have the desire, you know, I think not only do they have the time

1:23:49 and the willingness, but they really do have a desire to be involved from this side of the

1:23:58 process, you know, they really want to be involved.

1:24:00 So I think it's a good direction.

1:24:02 And I think staff can really help, you know, that it's a good advice from Councilman Berger

1:24:11 that, you know, we don't really want this to drag out, and that's really why I had asked

1:24:16 for this update.

1:24:17 You know, it's been two years.

1:24:18 We really need to move forward on this.

1:24:20 But I think that staff can really help that.

1:24:22 Staff sets the agendas for all of the work sessions, and they've done a great job so far,

1:24:28 really narrowing down the topic and saying, you know, here's some materials.

1:24:32 some different examples from other cities, here's some best practices, and I think that

1:24:37 as we move forward in those discussions, it's really great to have that information available

1:24:43 to them and they look through and kind of sort through what will work for Twin Falls

1:24:48 and what won't.

1:24:50 So with the help of staff, I think that this direction can be pretty productive and we'll

1:24:57 look forward to hearing from the mayor and Councilman Munn.

1:25:00 Is that what you need to admit?

1:25:04 Yeah.

1:25:05 Yeah.

1:25:06 Okay.

1:25:07 Thank you very much for the presentation and the update.

1:25:10 Okay.

1:25:11 At this time, we are ready for any input from the public city manager or city council.

1:25:17 Chris Tockington.

1:25:22 At last week's AIC and Boise.

1:25:26 One of the work sessions dealt with building code and I believe that the answer you'll give

1:25:31 that we were reminded Travis that by January 1st of this next year, the former international, formerly known international building code must be amended to the Idaho Building Code and Energy Conservation Code.

1:25:48 And I wondered, are we there or is that in progress or what?

1:25:53 So if you remember a few weeks ago, we just did a big update on the adoption of the building codes and

1:26:01 I think

1:26:03 I think we're up to speed we'll probably take a little

1:26:07 We'll probably take a little leeway time to we will be enforcing it by January 1st

1:26:12 There's there's some notice time to get the building community kind of up to speed with it

1:26:17 That we're gonna so they all know we did we did the meeting a few weeks ago everybody were adopting these and

1:26:23 anything else? Go ahead.

1:26:40 So just a couple of quick things. I believe it's tomorrow. We have Dwayne's retirement

1:26:48 celebration at two o'clock. So it's going to be on the 24th. It's going to be in here.

1:26:55 And then Mitchell Smith, who's in our wastewater collections, is also going to be retiring.

1:27:00 and his celebration is going to be on the 25th.

1:27:04 These are two veteran employees of our organization

1:27:07 and so we're gonna celebrate their careers again

1:27:10 tomorrow and the following day, both at two o'clock in here.

1:27:17 The next week I'll be out of town.

1:27:20 That's why I wanted Zowak next week.

1:27:22 Just teasing.

1:27:25 So next week I'll be out of town.

1:27:27 Lori Race will be the acting city manager.

1:27:32 I will say that I will be generally not available, so you can send emails, but it may be a very

1:27:42 delayed response in between my abilities to respond to them.

1:27:48 The lawyer will do a fine job, and then starting after my return will begin in earnest our conversation

1:27:54 on the FY 2015 budget.

1:27:57 Thank you very much.

1:28:01 Any advisory board reports or announcements?

1:28:06 Just a very cursory overview of the air show was rather disappointing in his attendance.

1:28:14 Sure, Jim will have a reconciliation within a couple of weeks, but it looked to be substantially

1:28:21 less participatory than two years ago.

1:28:24 And of course we had the Blue Angels, but not to lessen Jim O'Donnell's incredible effort

1:28:35 to make it as self-supporting as it was, not just we're not sure of the reasons, but I think

1:28:43 one of the questions will be reviewing when Jim comes here as the continuance of the years

1:28:49 show in two years. We do not have a firm commitment from the Blue Angels, but we have a potential

1:28:57 interest. Another question might be the structure of an air show who actually would be responsible

1:29:05 whether it's better suited for the airport board or some other group and City's fiscal

1:29:16 participation in future shows.

1:29:19 It's still a good show though.

1:29:20 Thank you Chris.

1:29:22 Greg Lantham.

1:29:23 Did Travis have something to say on the outbank?

1:29:26 Sorry.

1:29:29 My only question is as to whether or not Jim will be coming because they have now formed

1:29:34 their own 501c3 but we will certainly ask Jim and invite him to present if he's interested

1:29:42 with them serving and creating their own 501c3, that connection and that oversight that we've

1:29:49 provided in the past.

1:29:51 He may have some recommendations for this.

1:29:53 Perfect.

1:29:54 Perfect.

1:29:57 Well, I noticed we have a new Times News reporter and I was wondering if Nathan Brown, right?

1:30:01 I wonder if Nathan can come up and introduce yourself and where you're from.

1:30:04 I kind of said we always like to know who's reporting on us, if you could.

1:30:09 If you come up to the mic, please, we are recorded.

1:30:11 So, oh yeah, I'm a mate, I was just going into my fourth week now, I'll move you from

1:30:22 Middletown, New York, working at the Times Herald record there for a couple of years before

1:30:26 this.

1:30:27 All right.

1:30:28 Well, thank you.

1:30:29 Welcome to the falls.

1:30:30 Okay.

1:30:34 If there's nothing else, we are going to adjourn this meeting into executive session

1:30:39 2, 3, 4, 5, 1, c to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations or

1:30:46 to acquire an interest in real property which is not owned by a public agency.

1:30:52 We will not be making any decisions in that meeting and we will not be returning out here.

1:30:58 If I can have a motion.

1:30:59 So moved.

1:31:00 Second.

1:31:01 Moved by Sean Berriger, seconded by Greg Lantine.

1:31:04 Leila, can we have a roll call vote please?

1:31:08 Yes.

1:31:10 Yes, yes, yes, yes, motion is approved five to zero and we will adjourn into executive session.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 23, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:31:38.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7142a23b03ebd088db988f7bff960ae70180b900e81f3feff415e869b1d99d21
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a bbe8625275cc2b00d11663279276737da4dcbda1b3d3c60fe5d9de5214f82548
    part02.m4a 2b82b92a7d1d72a960f82ecb3442851399bb5cf2c4ba4119cc1041d91bea832e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    1f47d9218341082dfbac0430b49ec3b906a91e53bbffd42090852984e8521f59

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file