City Council meeting
Monday, March 3, 2014
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:01:20 I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council order. It's Monday March 3rd, 2014
0:01:25 It is five o'clock and as we traditionally do we start our meeting off with the Pledge of Allegiance
0:01:31 So those of you wishing to join us, please rise. Let me ask a question first Troy. Are there girls counts? Oh?
0:01:40 Yeah, right now they are
0:01:43 I think they lost all color in their face if you'll please join me. Hi
0:01:50 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:02:03 Thank you everyone and welcome.
0:02:05 We do have a quorum of our city council.
0:02:07 All seven members are here and my first question is, do we have any amendments to the agenda to our city manager, Traverse Rethwaite?
0:02:15 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, staff is going to pull item number five off of items
0:02:20 for consideration from tonight's agenda.
0:02:25 We're pulling the item at the request, actually, of the applicant and the individual who had
0:02:30 submitted the proposal.
0:02:33 She was able to sell the property to a separate buyer and it closed and they notified us on
0:02:41 late Friday from her
0:02:43 realtor after the agenda had
0:02:46 been published and so we wanted
0:02:47 to pull that item this evening.
0:02:49 The issue, as you'll recall,
0:02:51 regave her or gave the
0:02:53 property an easement.
0:02:55 The easement stays with the
0:02:56 property and so the issue has
0:02:59 been resolved and so that is
0:03:01 the reason which we're pulling
0:03:03 item number five this evening.
0:03:05 Thank you, Travis.
0:03:06 Anne, I checked to make sure
0:03:08 we generally when we add
0:03:09 something to the agenda,
0:03:11 we make an amendment, but since it's being pulled,
0:03:13 we don't necessarily need to do that.
0:03:17 So moving down, we do have a proclamation tonight,
0:03:20 and we have John and Judy Fisher here to receive this,
0:03:24 but it's my honor to read our proclamation tonight.
0:03:29 Office of the Mayor, City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:03:31 proclamation, multiple sclerosis awareness week,
0:03:35 March 3rd through the 7th, 2014.
0:03:38 I just wanna let everyone know that I've been given
0:03:41 permission to say MS from this point on, because I don't want to mess the sclerosis up.
0:03:47 Whereas MS interrupts the flow of information between the brain and the body and stops people
0:03:54 from moving, is an unpredictable, often disabling disease of the central nervous system.
0:04:02 And every hour in the United States, someone is newly diagnosed.
0:04:07 And whereas the National Multiple Sclerosis Society reports that in our state more than
0:04:15 5,300 people are living with this disease, and MS generally strikes young adults between
0:04:22 the ages of 20 and 50, attacking them in the prime of their lives and affects more than
0:04:28 400,000 people nationwide.
0:04:32 And whereas symptoms range from numbness and tingling to blindness and paralysis, and the
0:04:39 progress, severity and specific symptoms of MS is any one person cannot yet be predicted,
0:04:48 and any one person cannot yet be predicted.
0:04:51 But advances in research and treatment are moving us closer to the world free of MS.
0:04:57 And whereas the National MS Society has been committed throughout the years to mobilize the voices of people statewide who want to do something about MS now and is currently planning several major statewide fundraisers and educational programs to raise awareness of MS.
0:05:18 And whereas walk MS and bike MS events are scheduled this year throughout the state of Idaho.
0:05:25 and whereas the National Multiple Scoroches Society devotes program and services to enhance
0:05:32 the lives of those with MS and invest in research towards a cause and cure.
0:05:39 Now therefore, I, Don Hall, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls in the State of Idaho, do hereby
0:05:46 proclaim March 3rd through the 7th 2014 as multiple sclerosis awareness
0:05:53 week and urge all citizens of Twin Falls to join in this observation. So if I could
0:06:01 have John and Judy come forward. My name is John Fisher, this is my wife Judy,
0:06:26 and that's why we're involved with MS. Judy suffered with MS since the 80s.
0:06:33 Anyway, thank you, Mr. Hall, the rest of the council, and I just want to say a little
0:06:41 bit more. There's actually 2.3 million cases nationwide of MS, 200 new cases every week
0:06:50 are diagnosed, and it's troubling that there's 8 to 10,000 cases in juveniles nationwide.
0:06:58 So it's get, you know, the age group is getting lower.
0:07:02 And another 10 to 15,000 juveniles with at least one symptom of MS.
0:07:08 And the money raised with WALK MS and our bed race event and bike MS, 82% of the funds actually
0:07:17 go for research, education and other programs.
0:07:20 So there's very little overhead with the MS Society.
0:07:24 And we'd just like to invite you all down for the bed races, June 14th downtown.
0:07:30 It's a groove.
0:07:32 Yeah, I'm not sure.
0:07:36 I don't think we're not going to get a groove.
0:07:38 Well Greg, get it one year.
0:07:41 Anyway, thank you very much.
0:07:45 Thank you so much.
0:07:46 Thank you both for coming and raising the awareness.
0:07:48 I appreciate it very much.
0:07:49 It needs to be awareness.
0:07:51 There's a lot of people who don't have never heard of it.
0:07:54 Sean Berger has a if I get a say a quick word mayor
0:07:59 I really want to commend Judy and John for their commitment to raising the awareness and the funds that they do here
0:08:05 In this community my mother-in-law passed away with MS here a few years ago
0:08:10 And the efforts that you guys put in really had do help to raise those funds and help support the research
0:08:16 And I do commend you for for all that you do
0:08:19 Thank you Sean for your help
0:08:21 Thank you
0:08:23 Moving on to general input from anyone in our audience that's not regarding
0:08:29 anything that we have on the agenda tonight. Anyone would like to come forward
0:08:33 and address the council? I see none. We'll move on to the consent calendar and turn
0:08:41 that over to council. Sean Berger. Who would move approval of the consent calendar?
0:08:49 We have a motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Jim Mundt to
0:08:55 to approve the consent calendar,
0:08:57 anything further on that motion council?
0:09:00 I see no lights, the other please,
0:09:03 roll call vote please.
0:09:05 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:09:07 Yes.
0:09:09 Jim Mun?
0:09:09 Yes.
0:09:10 Sean Berrigar?
0:09:11 Yes.
0:09:12 Chris Talkington?
0:09:13 Yes.
0:09:14 Greg Lanthain?
0:09:15 Yes.
0:09:16 Don Hall?
0:09:17 Yes.
0:09:17 Rebecca Milzaca?
0:09:18 Yes.
0:09:20 Motion passes, seven to zero.
0:09:22 Moving on to items for consideration.
0:09:25 Under number one,
0:09:26 Those of you wishing to grab an agenda should be one at the back of the room.
0:09:30 Is a presentation by Rich New on problem solving court in the fifth judicial district.
0:09:36 Welcome Rich.
0:09:37 Thanks.
0:09:38 First up, my name is Rich New.
0:09:41 I am the district white problem solving court manager for the fifth judicial district.
0:09:45 I'd like to crows your off-wiler for first meeting with me and then inviting you to come speak tonight.
0:09:54 So what I wanted to do is really just kind of present a little bit of information in the
0:09:58 form of the council about what we do.
0:10:01 The problem solving courts really aren't very well known.
0:10:05 And I think an opportunity exists to kind of bridge what we do with what the city commission
0:10:12 is and what the city is doing.
0:10:14 And I'd like to kind of be able to open up a dialogue in that regard and press a lot of
0:10:19 different areas that we cover within the problem solving courts.
0:10:23 the PowerPoint presentation, and then I'll go through and I promise down that I keep it
0:10:29 short. Anyway, let's see if I can make this work. We have several different types of problem-solving
0:10:39 courts. Drug courts being the oldest and the most well-known. General Ross Kelly is our
0:10:45 district coordinator for the Drug Courts. We also have mental health court that I coordinate.
0:10:52 We have a Child Protection Drug Court, which is now being renamed into a Family Reunification
0:10:58 Drug Court, the Shelley Finney is the coordinator of, and we have a DUI court that is coordinated
0:11:05 by Steve Conger, and then I am the district wide manager in law and all of them.
0:11:15 By the way, this presentation will be made available to the council for print afterwards
0:11:19 if anybody is interested in it.
0:11:21 The goals of the problem-solving courts first and foremost is community safety and community
0:11:25 protection.
0:11:27 As a court, our number one goal is making sure that the community we live in is safe and protected.
0:11:33 We also look to reduce costs.
0:11:35 We try and decrease incarceration rates.
0:11:39 In terms of mental illness, we really try to decrease hospitalization rates.
0:11:43 But we also try and reduce the amount of law enforcement contact that the folks we work
0:11:48 would have, as well as reducing prosecution costs.
0:11:53 And what we found is that our abilities to do that are
0:11:56 significant in terms of the hundreds of thousands of dollars
0:11:59 a year.
0:12:01 And then, obviously, our tertiary is to improve the quality of
0:12:05 life that people would end up in these programs.
0:12:12 Now, how we do that, first and foremost, is through a system
0:12:15 of coerced treatment.
0:12:17 And this is the do-it-or-else concept.
0:12:20 We try and help people change.
0:12:23 Most of the folks out there, they're dealing with drug and alcohol issues,
0:12:27 mental illness issues, that end up involved with the courts.
0:12:30 They don't like the life that they're having.
0:12:32 Most of them will tell you that.
0:12:34 And they'd like to do something different.
0:12:36 Most of them don't know how to make that happen.
0:12:39 They also are very afraid of dealing with the process of change,
0:12:44 which is always uncomfortable and very often painful.
0:12:47 What we do is we offer a lot of motivation to help kind of speed that process up.
0:12:52 And our thought is, if we can take the problems that they have,
0:12:59 both through unmanaged mental illness, unregulated drug and alcohol issues,
0:13:04 and reduce those problems, we remove the threat that those folks pose to our society.
0:13:10 If we put them in jail, put them in prison, we have a temporary solution to the problem.
0:13:15 housing for a while and we can protect the community until they are released. That
0:13:20 which time they come back and they're our neighbors again and sometimes they
0:13:24 learn a few more skills that they didn't have before they went to prison. If we
0:13:29 can improve how they live, give them a better quality of life and improve their
0:13:33 pro-social behaviors, they can be our neighbors and we don't have to be worried
0:13:37 about them. That's our goal. We also offer enhanced supervision. We intervene
0:13:43 faster to rule in law violations than what would happen through just
0:13:47 or standard law enforcement or standard probation efforts alone.
0:13:51 We have so much more frequent contact, but when they're out doing the wrong thing,
0:13:55 we're going to know it sooner and we're going to be able to intervene faster.
0:13:59 Before I became a coordinator for the Problem in Solving Courts,
0:14:03 I spent a lot of years as a felony probation and parole officer
0:14:07 and we would have people of scond and I would get the information
0:14:11 about a week later a report might get submitted to a prosecutor and then submit it to a judge
0:14:15 to a judge and that a warrant would be issued.
0:14:17 And normally we could expect they warrant to be issued
0:14:20 in a week to 10 days.
0:14:21 I got noticed this morning at 8 a.m.,
0:14:24 but one of the participants of my mental health court
0:14:26 of Scotland, I had an arrest warrant issued 30 minutes later.
0:14:30 And people out looking for that person active.
0:14:33 That's the change in response times that we have
0:14:35 within the problem-solving courts.
0:14:37 When we can react that much faster, we also have the opportunity
0:14:43 if we can catch that person, bring them back
0:14:45 in the full, so to speak.
0:14:46 They don't have as much time to inflict more damage on our community.
0:14:50 They don't cost us as much.
0:14:53 And then we also utilize the intensive motivational strategies
0:14:56 in a team approach.
0:14:58 The folks that come into these programs have access to the resources
0:15:01 that are available for these programs, for the most part,
0:15:04 just like everybody else does.
0:15:06 But we take all of those community resources.
0:15:08 We put them in the same room at the same table talking
0:15:10 about the same person, so that those resources are maximized
0:15:14 in their efforts.
0:15:15 We're not hitting different agencies against each other.
0:15:19 We're working in unison.
0:15:20 And our effectiveness goes through the roof when we do that.
0:15:23 It's a key element to our success as the team strategy.
0:15:32 The DUI court.
0:15:34 DUI court started in October of 2006.
0:15:38 It's been going now for about seven years.
0:15:42 It started off very slow initially.
0:15:44 First year, they had two participants,
0:15:45 and no dollars for treatment.
0:15:47 Matter of fact, Guy was their treatment provider.
0:15:49 So we beg hard to get somebody who knew what they were doing
0:15:52 to come in and start helping us out a little bit better.
0:15:55 It grew quickly.
0:15:57 Currently, there are 52 active participants in DUI court,
0:16:01 10 of which are felons.
0:16:02 The rest of them are misdemeanor offenders.
0:16:07 They've had 240 graduates.
0:16:09 And in the last seven years, only 35 of those folks
0:16:12 who have re-offended with the DUI.
0:16:14 DUI rates for recidivism are sky high.
0:16:19 And this is an extremely high success rate in terms of low
0:16:22 reservation and at very low cost of the community.
0:16:26 This is an extremely successful program
0:16:30 that we've been operating.
0:16:37 Child Protection Drug Court is our newest drug court.
0:16:41 And it's kind of a hybrid.
0:16:43 Some of the participants in this program
0:16:45 have criminal charges pending, but generally
0:16:47 for drug-related issues.
0:16:48 Several don't, probably half don't.
0:16:51 But they do have active child protection cases.
0:16:56 These folks get the access to drug and alcohol treatment.
0:16:59 The goal of this program is to bring the children and parents
0:17:03 back into a healthy family unit.
0:17:05 They also can get some of the legal benefits
0:17:07 that we offer through the problem solving courts.
0:17:10 But ultimately, we've got a more intensive strategy
0:17:13 towards completion of their child protection case.
0:17:18 And their slogan at the bottom is,
0:17:21 this court is not about parents getting their children back.
0:17:23 It's about children getting their parents back.
0:17:26 And if you want to see chaos in court,
0:17:28 come attend one of these because they bring their kids.
0:17:31 But they do great things.
0:17:33 We've done operating this program primarily based
0:17:36 from grant funding, and it was just,
0:17:39 we just received another three-year grant
0:17:40 to continue that program, not in business month.
0:17:45 I should say the team consists of the judge,
0:17:49 the coordinator, department of health and welfare,
0:17:51 case workers and supervisors, CASA, substance abuse treatment provider, and then the public
0:17:58 defender and department of probation.
0:18:08 Mental health court, this is the program that I coordinate.
0:18:10 We actually have two.
0:18:11 We have an adult felony program here in Twin.
0:18:14 We have a misdemeanor program in the Minkaj area.
0:18:18 We can serve up to 25 participants in the felony program.
0:18:21 I currently have 22 with eight applicants.
0:18:24 It's a two-year minimum program that's very intensive.
0:18:28 We work with folks that have a severe and persistent mental illness.
0:18:32 These are the folks that most generally are going to be canyon view.
0:18:37 These are the folks that tend to have the highest suicide risk.
0:18:41 But they also cause a lot of significant other problems for our community.
0:18:46 All of them, for the most part, all of them are felons.
0:18:49 We have an agreed to take in five misdemons.
0:18:52 so we've worked out an agreement with Magistrate Probation
0:18:56 to bring in five Mr. and Mr. and Mr. and Mr. and Mr. and Mr.
0:18:58 to the felony offenders that we work with.
0:19:02 The team approach here, we utilize
0:19:04 the sort of community treatment services,
0:19:07 peer support specialist services,
0:19:10 vocational rehabilitation.
0:19:11 We have a substance abuse treatment provider
0:19:13 that we contract with.
0:19:15 In addition to probation, parole, public defender's office,
0:19:20 myself, and a judge of that.
0:19:23 In essence, we're gonna provide a really a 15 to 18
0:19:26 member team working with each of these individuals.
0:19:31 I'd also point out the cost of incarceration
0:19:34 with this population is about 25% higher
0:19:38 than it is with the standard population.
0:19:40 And average stay at State Hospital South
0:19:44 is currently $1,800 a day if we're able to reduce.
0:19:52 Benefits to the participants,
0:19:54 we get faster stabilization through course of therapy.
0:19:58 We do individualized treatment planning.
0:20:00 We provide an increased level of contact with treatment,
0:20:04 and for a long contact with treatment,
0:20:06 we provide better outcomes.
0:20:08 We can make additional referrals to other resources,
0:20:12 and the big benefit to them, and this applies
0:20:14 across all problem solving courts,
0:20:18 when they successfully complete the program.
0:20:20 And generally, we do another period of regular probation,
0:20:22 demonstrating the skills that they've learned in the program.
0:20:25 They get to come back in front of the judge
0:20:27 and would draw their guilt, including to their case discernment.
0:20:29 That's the carrot to the state we are.
0:20:38 Drug court began in September of 2001.
0:20:40 Like I said, it's our longest running program.
0:20:42 It serves medium to high risk for re-offense felony offenders
0:20:46 with drug dependency issues.
0:20:50 The high risk issue, I'd point out,
0:20:51 that's not high risk in terms of the most dangerous
0:20:54 and most threatening.
0:20:55 These are the folks who have been assessed
0:20:56 to be the most likely to re-offend with another drug
0:20:59 from their drug offense.
0:21:01 We have courts all throughout the district.
0:21:03 Current capacity district-wide is 77,
0:21:07 and it is a post-conviction program,
0:21:08 as are most problem-solving courts now.
0:21:10 In other words, they have all entered a guilty plea,
0:21:13 been convicted, and have a sentence hanging over their head.
0:21:17 This program takes approximately 14 to 18 months
0:21:20 to complete and is followed by another period
0:21:24 of supervised felony probation.
0:21:27 They attend regular treatment, regular support groups,
0:21:30 frequent drug and alcohol attendance,
0:21:33 and then court appearances on a weekly basis.
0:21:36 That's kind of the standard model
0:21:37 that we follow is designed after the drug court,
0:21:40 where initially they come once a week and meet a judge
0:21:44 and talk about how they're doing one-on-one with a judge.
0:21:47 As they progress through the program,
0:21:48 generally through phases,
0:21:50 and most programs are either four or five phases long,
0:21:53 their appearance before the judge decreases
0:21:55 with each phase.
0:21:56 In drug court, we're averaging 30-40% success rates, which doesn't seem real high.
0:22:07 But a hallmark stellar treatment program, at best, is running 10-15% success rates.
0:22:14 Those are the folks that we study to see, here's how you do it, and we're finding 30-40%.
0:22:19 I put 30-40% because right now there's some disagreement between Judge Butler and Darrell
0:22:24 or Oskely is to which number it is,
0:22:26 but that's our average right now,
0:22:28 so 40% success rate.
0:22:30 And that's not to recidivate to either a new drug crime
0:22:33 or a drug relapse, so those are huge numbers.
0:22:43 In looking at the City of Twin Falls three years
0:22:45 strategic plan, I noticed some similarities.
0:22:50 And that's what the goals that you guys have
0:22:52 are the same that we do.
0:22:54 You've identified a desire to make efforts
0:22:58 to deal with mental health issues
0:23:01 to partner with other agencies in doing that.
0:23:03 And currently that's an exploding trend.
0:23:07 Cities doing in counties do it state and nationally.
0:23:09 Everybody's doing it.
0:23:11 We're all looking at this problem for what it is,
0:23:13 and it's real serious and it's costing us a lot,
0:23:17 in terms of money as well as human issues.
0:23:19 An improved response to drug and alcohol related incidents.
0:23:22 That's what we do in our drug courts and our mental health
0:23:24 groups, and our D-Wattens.
0:23:26 This is the mission of problem solving course.
0:23:34 Proactively responding to changing trends in illegal drug abuse and prescription drug abuse.
0:23:38 It's the same thing that we're doing.
0:23:40 We happen to be down there on the streets seeing what those new trends are.
0:23:44 We have a lot of information that we can share, as well as we'd love to share all the information
0:23:49 that you do as we may have.
0:23:51 Supporting strong educational programs on drug and alcohol abuse, our efforts towards prevention need
0:23:56 to be enhanced, and I think a cooperative effort can happen there.
0:24:00 I would love for every coordinator in this district
0:24:02 for it themselves out of the job.
0:24:05 And then obviously focusing on street level drug problems
0:24:08 and users and how those will do.
0:24:14 Resources and needs, these are just some examples.
0:24:18 The city has law enforcement support.
0:24:21 It's incredibly beneficial to what we do.
0:24:23 That immediate response that we need in intervening
0:24:26 with the participants that we've got having problems.
0:24:29 As well as the responses that they have
0:24:33 kind of better educated response that they have in terms of working with the
0:24:36 mentally ill through the CIC key training. The cooperative efforts between city
0:24:41 law enforcement and the problem-solving courts I think is critical. And we've seen
0:24:45 excellent support from the city law enforcement currently. I think that's a
0:24:49 huge resource in benefit to us. Obviously having prosecutor support from
0:24:53 the city with the misdemeanor level of work that we have, the majority of those
0:24:57 passed through the city's prosecutor and having that support is a huge benefit to
0:25:03 as well as understanding how our efforts can benefit them
0:25:08 for reduced prostitution costs, getting voluntary police taken,
0:25:14 and getting harsher sentences.
0:25:16 We typically sentence people in problem-solving courts
0:25:18 to a harsher sentence than what the average population
0:25:22 for the same crime is given, because they're offered
0:25:25 such a large benefit of potentially having it removed later on.
0:25:30 community service resources. A lot of the plans that the city is rolling out
0:25:35 involves volunteers. Every single participant in drug court owes a hundred
0:25:40 hours of community service and they look for places to do it. We look for
0:25:44 projects for them to do. We would like to be able to offer that service to the city
0:25:49 when there's a project needed and there's labor needed. We get folks who need to do
0:25:53 some work and we can offer that support as well. Education information
0:25:58 We have a lot of information about current events, current things that are happening, I believe we can be a resource to the city, and to the cities, agencies, and what we do.
0:26:08 And then obviously the biggest benefit is if we can develop some increased communication, we improve effectiveness across the board and for both parties.
0:26:18 I think that's the goal that I have tonight is to hopefully start that communication.
0:26:25 That's what God I would offer.
0:26:27 I would have to talk to you for any questions.
0:26:30 Very good. Thank you, Mr. New. Suzanne Hawkins.
0:26:34 First of all, thank you very much, and Steve Conger, for the time you spent with me back in January.
0:26:39 It was very eye-opening to me to sit through that whole process and watch what takes place.
0:26:44 And I just wanted to share first of all a couple of my notes from that day.
0:26:48 And everything that I took notes on was the positiveness of being there.
0:26:53 not being someone who's in court or in that environment often I was very nervous
0:26:58 going in and seeing how you guys addressed each person personally and how
0:27:06 the judge knew their personal struggles and where they've come from and how far
0:27:10 they've gone and the way he addressed that in such a personal manner and was so
0:27:14 positive in his reinforcement of the participants I found it to be very
0:27:19 different than what I expected. You expect to go to court and you know have
0:27:24 people just be in punished left and right. And I thought it was interesting the way
0:27:29 they handle the question of the day and ask each participant how they feel
0:27:33 about something and on this particular day the question was how do you what is
0:27:38 a good and they didn't use the word punishment sanction if you fell to meet
0:27:44 one of your requirements and listening to the participants' perspectives on that and what
0:27:51 mattered to them as they're working through this process, I just found it very educational
0:27:55 and exciting to see how many people were really trying to better their lives and using the court
0:28:02 as a system to do that. I came out of there feeling much more positive than I expected.
0:28:08 Second, correct me if I'm wrong, but it's Sergeant Howe that works closely with the DUI
0:28:13 I just want to commend Chief Pike that day he knew the participants by name.
0:28:21 He knows when he's out on the streets, you know if they need an extra pick me up and somebody
0:28:25 just to pat him on the back and tell him they're doing a good job.
0:28:28 His personal touch with the people I know makes a huge difference in helping these people get
0:28:33 their lives back on track.
0:28:35 The whole thing was just really phenomenal to watch how something can be so positive in
0:28:40 community and for one I would be very supportive of whatever we can do to open up
0:28:45 the communications and make sure that we are a good partner with you in helping our
0:28:49 citizens get healthy again. Thank you Suzanne, Chris talking to Mr. New, first of
0:28:55 all I think your success rates are to be commended. I work in juvenile
0:29:02 adjudication for 13 years and know how difficult it is to affect change in youth
0:29:07 and that adults that has to be compounded, as I read, by my figure, it's about a 14% recidivism
0:29:16 rate on your DUI court, which is an 86% or so success rate. I assume that's out after a couple
0:29:24 years. That's over the last seven years. Seven years, okay.
0:29:27 It is for some that are fairly frequent, but it also includes others that have come that
0:29:31 full set. And 35 to 40% success rate in the drug court is highly commendable. Everything
0:29:36 you can do on the DUI and the drug offenders, not only reduces the family chaos, but it reduces
0:29:44 societal costs.
0:29:46 So take heart and it sounds like you're exceeding a lot of the national or the state figures.
0:29:54 It's too bad there is not more of a counseling court system at the state incarceration level.
0:30:02 That's just a crime factory there,
0:30:05 how they're turning out people and the recidivism rate
0:30:07 is incredibly high.
0:30:09 I only find fault having worked with jibinals
0:30:13 for you to consider in this matrix system you have.
0:30:19 Do you have a victim restitution or restoration component
0:30:23 of this where offenders who have committed crimes
0:30:28 either, I don't know, in DUI, crashing a car, hurting somebody, or stealing for drugs.
0:30:36 We found that extremely difficult to implement at the juvenile level, and one of the most successful
0:30:41 long-range alteration programs for a face-to-face meeting, several meetings with the victim and
0:30:50 the victim.
0:30:51 I do know, sir, that a lot of improvements and strides have been made within the juvenile
0:30:57 system, especially within the juvenile drug courts now, which I neglected to mention, we
0:31:01 do have to do the drug courts as well. And the victim's mediation efforts that are happening
0:31:06 are very strong now. There is a lot of resistance to trying that in the adult side. A lot of
0:31:13 people are very scared about meeting the felon who offended against them. So there's a lot
0:31:18 of resistance. In terms of the victim restitution, primarily the focus is on repayment. We have
0:31:26 not had a large call at any kind of rest restorative work within the adult system, with the exception
0:31:35 of within mental health books.
0:31:37 And there have been several events where we have worked on that within the mental health
0:31:41 course because of the nature that fear involved with some of the crimes that have happened
0:31:46 there.
0:31:47 And we deal with some very very violent crimes within mental health books, strangulation issues,
0:31:53 And we have work towards restoration and some of that mediation type work there, but it's
0:32:01 very limited.
0:32:02 And I appreciate your comment for that.
0:32:04 And lastly, can I follow up on that?
0:32:08 When I was at DUI court, one of their steps to complete the program is they do have to
0:32:13 attend a series at the college where victims speak, and they have to sit through listening
0:32:19 to what the victims have been put through from being victims of DUI.
0:32:23 So yes, that is part of, I know the DUI program anyway.
0:32:26 That's not a direct victim restoration where it's a one-on-one though.
0:32:30 No, but at least they are being educated on what their crimes have been doing.
0:32:36 Lastly, I'd like you to tell you what a problem you're up against while in Juby.
0:32:42 We conducted a number of voluntary surveys with our repeat victim
0:32:48 to repeat customers rather, and found a wide demographic
0:32:53 backing.
0:32:55 Kids are more likely to smoke marijuana than tobacco.
0:32:59 Why?
0:32:59 Because there is nothing reported about the downside effects
0:33:03 of marijuana.
0:33:04 There's a lot out there on tobacco that kids go where they
0:33:07 see the illusion of it not being harmful to them.
0:33:12 And marijuana is a gateway drug, despite what some people
0:33:17 say to the escalation of the people you deal with.
0:33:20 So my hat's off to you and I really think that the one-on-one victim
0:33:25 restoration is a missing but a vital component.
0:33:29 Thank you.
0:33:31 I wanted to compliment you on your presentation.
0:33:34 It was eye opening, some good information,
0:33:36 but mostly I wanted to compliment you on your tie-tack,
0:33:39 it's Marine Corps tie-tack.
0:33:41 So good job on that.
0:33:43 I noticed that it says presentation possible action.
0:33:46 What was curious about?
0:33:49 Did you have anything that you were thinking we could do?
0:33:54 No, I don't think there's an action.
0:33:55 I think that it illustrates in the strategic plan
0:33:58 that there's a partnership and part of our ongoing opportunity
0:34:03 to highlight the strategic plan is to share those partnerships.
0:34:06 And we continue to work with Rich.
0:34:08 I was really excited when he came in
0:34:09 and we had our first conversation that
0:34:12 was started after a conversation and invitation that
0:34:15 was extended to Councilwoman Hawkins.
0:34:17 And so we'll continue to work that process and to secure that partnership.
0:34:22 Thank you, Travis.
0:34:23 Any final words, Rich?
0:34:24 Very nice presentation tonight.
0:34:26 We appreciate you coming.
0:34:28 Take care, sir.
0:34:36 Next item on the agenda is consideration of your request to confirm the reappointment of
0:34:40 Gary Bond, Dan Brizzee, and Darren Hall to the Building Inspection Department Advisory Committee.
0:34:47 And this is the first time I've been on the agenda to speak.
0:34:50 So this is a little different.
0:34:52 Just wanted to let the council know that Gary Bond, Dan Brzee and Darren Hall have all completed
0:34:58 their term on this committee and all three are eligible and have requested to be reappointed
0:35:04 to the committee. Darren Hall and Dan Brzee both reside outside of the city in the area
0:35:09 of impact so if you confirm my reappointment tonight, we'll have to waive their city residency
0:35:20 for that requirement.
0:35:22 This committee is a little different committee
0:35:25 in the with specific building trade employment needs
0:35:31 within the committee themselves.
0:35:33 The folks that are on the committee
0:35:35 have specific background issues that we need
0:35:38 to have on that committee.
0:35:40 And that's one of the deciding term reasons why I thought
0:35:44 it would be appropriate to reaffirm or put them back
0:35:48 on the committee.
0:35:49 They've all been valued members and contributed
0:35:53 to the department and I'll just turn it over
0:35:57 to council wishes but I have elected to reappoint
0:36:01 both Gary Bond, Dan Brzee and Darren Hall
0:36:05 to the building inspection department advisory committee.
0:36:08 Great learning.
0:36:09 I move that we confirm you're appointed
0:36:12 with Gary Bond, Dan Brzee and Darren Hall
0:36:15 the inspection department advisory committee
0:36:17 We're out of city.
0:36:24 Second.
0:36:25 Have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting.
0:36:27 Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
0:36:29 And we have a light.
0:36:30 Rebecca Milsoy.
0:36:31 Thank you, Mayor.
0:36:33 What are the specific requirements of this committee?
0:36:36 Is it a certain portion of the members
0:36:39 need to be from these trades?
0:36:41 Or what are the specific requirements?
0:36:43 From the different trades.
0:36:44 But maybe I'll have Mitch kind of weigh in on that.
0:36:46 He has the specifics in front of it.
0:36:51 Excuse me. It's not a oh, wait. It's quicker. That's not helpful
0:37:08 Okay, so yeah, it's that one on the top there
0:37:22 A little bit it'd be really really helpful
0:37:28 Well, can can the
0:37:31 Yeah, yeah, zoom in on the screen itself or you can just read it to us
0:37:38 Yeah, I'll just tell you.
0:37:40 So it's not a percentage of membership.
0:37:42 It's very specific.
0:37:43 We have to have one electrical contractor, one mechanical
0:37:48 contractor, one plumbing contractor.
0:37:52 I think it's two residential homebuilders,
0:37:59 a non-residential contractor.
0:38:03 Let's see, an architect or an architect, an engineer,
0:38:11 and then one member at large.
0:38:13 So basically it's one from each of the categories
0:38:17 except for two on the residential home builder
0:38:19 and then one at large and so it's very specific
0:38:23 as far as membership goes.
0:38:25 Thank you and how long do we know how long
0:38:27 that these members have been serving so far on this committee?
0:38:31 I don't recall offhand, I know that they've filled
0:38:34 one term obviously.
0:38:35 Both of these guys have been actually multiple terms.
0:38:38 I don't, both of them actually predate my time here, so more than eight years.
0:38:46 And did we call for applicants with these specific?
0:38:49 Publicly?
0:38:50 No.
0:38:51 I did not.
0:38:52 Okay.
0:38:54 Well, I only hesitate a little bit.
0:38:57 I think that when we waive the residency requirement, it's important to remember that we do want
0:39:03 to have representation within city limits and maybe we should be a little sparing in
0:39:10 in waiving those requirements.
0:39:11 I would have liked to see probably a call for applicants.
0:39:14 I'm sure there may be others in the community
0:39:16 that would wanna serve or have the opportunity to serve.
0:39:20 Thank you.
0:39:21 Anything further on the motion and council?
0:39:25 Leila, roll call vote, please.
0:39:28 Jim?
0:39:28 Yes.
0:39:30 Sean Berriger.
0:39:31 Yes.
0:39:32 Chris Talkington.
0:39:33 Well, even though I agree with Rebecca on the thoughtfulness
0:39:38 to at least ask for other applicants, I'll vote yes.
0:39:43 Greg Lanting.
0:39:44 Yes.
0:39:45 Don Hall.
0:39:46 Yes.
0:39:47 Rebecca Melzweka.
0:39:48 No.
0:39:49 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:39:50 Yes.
0:39:51 Motion passes.
0:39:52 Six to one.
0:39:53 Next item on the agenda is consideration and request to confirm the reappointment of Jack
0:40:00 Jardine to the Golf Advisory Committee.
0:40:03 I saw Jack come in just a minute ago.
0:40:07 Jack was appointed to the Golf Advisory Committee last March to fulfill a partial term
0:40:12 He does not live within the city, so the council will waive his residency last time, and I'm
0:40:20 assuming we'll have to do that again, this time if they confirm.
0:40:25 He is eligible and has requested to be reappointed to a full three-year term.
0:40:32 Mr. Jardine has had a perfect attendance record and has been a valuable member of this commission
0:40:40 and has contributed.
0:40:42 And I wish to
0:40:46 reappoint Jack Jardine to the Golf Advisory Committee.
0:40:50 Strigg lining.
0:40:52 Well knowing how Jack hit the ground running
0:40:55 and was a major presence at the Friends of Munich
0:40:58 during the last year,
0:41:00 his first few months as a member,
0:41:02 I would like to, I would move that we can affirm
0:41:06 your appointment of Jack Jardine for a whole three year term.
0:41:10 The Gulf Advisory Board in the wave is out of city,
0:41:14 wave the out of city record.
0:41:16 Second.
0:41:17 Have a motion on it for by Greg 19 and seconded
0:41:20 by Suzanne Hawkins.
0:41:22 Rebecca Milsoic.
0:41:23 Thank you, Mayor.
0:41:25 Just wanted to ask the same question.
0:41:26 Did we call for applications on this one?
0:41:28 We did not.
0:41:30 I think we should provide an opportunity
0:41:32 for the community to be able to sit in on these.
0:41:35 And I appreciate Jack's service.
0:41:36 I'm sure he's done a wonderful job.
0:41:39 But I do think it's important for representation of people who live within the city limits or paying city taxes on these.
0:41:46 And so I would at least like to call for applicants and give people the opportunity should they choose to volunteer.
0:41:53 And I would feel better about the reappointment if we had made the call and no one applied or this was the only applicant.
0:42:01 But not knowing that, I'll vote no on the confirmation, but it's not a no vote against an individual just against a process.
0:42:08 Thank you, Suzanne Hawkins.
0:42:13 I had the pleasure of working with Jack the last year,
0:42:16 since he's been appointed with the Golf Commission
0:42:18 until this year recently.
0:42:20 And I would just like to say the Golf Commission's
0:42:22 a very unique board.
0:42:24 I think it's very important that we hear from our citizens
0:42:27 and open things up to the public.
0:42:30 But at the same time, some of these commissions
0:42:31 are there for very specific reasons
0:42:33 to do a specific job to help us.
0:42:36 The golf course with the way it's set up now
0:42:39 is a different group than what it was years ago,
0:42:43 when it was actually ran and maintained by the city.
0:42:46 And they have done such a good job of restructuring
0:42:49 how our golf course works.
0:42:50 So it's not costing the citizens any money,
0:42:53 any longer to have a golf course.
0:42:55 And one of the main functions is the fundraiser
0:42:57 to keep the golf course moving.
0:42:59 And Jack has just, he has had so much input in that.
0:43:03 And his visibility in the community,
0:43:07 people know who he is and people trust him and he has a good reputation, he
0:43:12 golfs at our golf course, he knows what it needs, he understands the workings of it.
0:43:16 So again, I'm very comfortable with his reappointment. He is the right person to
0:43:21 take that seat for the next four years. Thank you, Suzanne. I just wanted to add
0:43:26 that I'm sensitive to what Councilwoman Milsoyka said about opening it up and
0:43:33 and allowing others from our community to serve
0:43:37 and specifically city residents.
0:43:42 But I look at these committees, and well frankly,
0:43:45 many times we have a tough time filling some of our committees.
0:43:48 And when you have good active members that are involved,
0:43:54 I want to pat them on the back.
0:43:57 I want to say stay involved as long as we can keep you involved
0:44:01 and continue that momentum for our community.
0:44:04 Greg Lanning.
0:44:05 Well, I think another important I'll make it quick
0:44:07 is that one thing, Jack, you have to fill a one year term
0:44:12 instead of a full term.
0:44:14 And so just fairness to him, I think he's proven his work.
0:44:20 And he certainly deserves a full term
0:44:23 if we were, he was at the end of a full first term
0:44:27 and a few things like that.
0:44:28 I mean, I may have looked at it differently
0:44:30 with this before we just fulfill one year's time for him
0:44:34 to get a full term and we'll go from there.
0:44:36 Thank you, great.
0:44:37 Chris, talk to you.
0:44:38 Well, I voted for Mr. Jordan because of the out of residency
0:44:43 non-conformance to our rules.
0:44:45 But I agree with you, but that I certainly
0:44:48 will go with the majority and vote for Jack now.
0:44:50 But I think it's a real oversight for us
0:44:52 not to open up to the public on both of these.
0:44:56 I'm very disappointed.
0:44:57 I think it's a step backward to the openness that we have been making big attempts on all
0:45:04 our advisory groups as well as ourselves.
0:45:07 Anything further on the motion council?
0:45:09 Leila, roll call vote please.
0:45:13 Sean Berger?
0:45:14 Yes.
0:45:15 Chris Talkington?
0:45:16 Yes.
0:45:17 Greg Lansing?
0:45:18 Yes.
0:45:19 Don Hall?
0:45:20 Yes.
0:45:21 Rebecca Milsoica?
0:45:22 No.
0:45:23 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:45:24 Yes.
0:45:25 Jim Man?
0:45:26 Motion passes six to one.
0:45:29 Moving to the next item on items of consideration
0:45:32 is consideration of a request to terminate a temporary easement
0:45:36 that was placed by a platted right-of-way
0:45:39 and terminating an easement for a temporary drainage,
0:45:42 retention, basin area.
0:45:44 We have Troy Vitek.
0:45:49 Evening mayor and council people.
0:45:51 For the record, my name is Troy Vitek.
0:45:53 This is the city engineer.
0:45:54 I'm just coming before you tonight
0:45:55 because Canyon Park North was recently developed
0:46:00 and they constructed Fillmore.
0:46:02 Fillmore happens to be a private roadway in there.
0:46:04 And when we went through a vacation process,
0:46:07 the existing Fillmore Street kind of goes
0:46:09 through their planned area.
0:46:12 So we decided we'll vacate the roadway,
0:46:16 but we can't give up our right to that roadway
0:46:20 until the new roadway was constructed.
0:46:22 So they placed a temporary easement on top of that roadway.
0:46:26 So we vacated the platen right away,
0:46:28 put a temporary easement over the existing roadway
0:46:31 until the new roadway was constructed.
0:46:35 Now that the roadway is constructed,
0:46:36 we've accepted it, or we haven't accepted it
0:46:39 because it's just private, but we've reviewed
0:46:41 all the testing materials and conforms
0:46:43 to our requirements and stuff like that.
0:46:46 We feel that we can now give up our temporary easement
0:46:49 of the existing Fillmore roadway.
0:46:52 And there's the drainage facilities that that road was
0:46:56 used to drain into.
0:46:57 You can see the example.
0:46:58 There would be all the area that's shaded.
0:47:01 That portion of the roadway used to be plated right away.
0:47:06 And now it exists in the temporary easement.
0:47:10 They would just like to dissolve that temporary easement.
0:47:12 When they went through the vacation process,
0:47:14 we entered into an agreement with them.
0:47:16 All the paperwork was essentially pre-prepared.
0:47:19 And this is just confirms we move in that easement at this time.
0:47:25 Any questions?
0:47:26 Any questions from council?
0:47:28 That old, dark, and areas, the vacation?
0:47:31 That was the original vacation.
0:47:33 That actually went away.
0:47:34 It was vacated.
0:47:35 When they vacated, they gave us a temporary easement
0:47:37 for that roadway, just to make sure they didn't leave town,
0:47:41 didn't construct the roadway.
0:47:42 We could still have access through there.
0:47:47 Now that it's no longer a road, we feel
0:47:50 but sworn in to remove the easement.
0:47:53 There are utilities in that easement.
0:47:55 We do have easements on those at utilities,
0:47:58 so there's water in there,
0:47:59 or that idle power is maintaining and keeping their easement.
0:48:05 We're back in that second.
0:48:07 Thank you, Troy.
0:48:08 So you mentioned some utilities
0:48:09 that will, will they stay in that location?
0:48:12 Yes.
0:48:13 And will buildings be built on top of them,
0:48:15 parking lots paid?
0:48:16 Okay.
0:48:17 So they're gonna remain open.
0:48:18 There is over the top of those utilities,
0:48:21 No buildings will be constructed alone.
0:48:23 Okay, thank you.
0:48:25 Jim Ma.
0:48:26 Mayor, I would move to terminate a temporary easement that was replaced by a platted right
0:48:31 away as well as terminating an easement for the temporary drainage retention basin area
0:48:35 in Canyon Park West.
0:48:38 Second.
0:48:39 We have a motion on the floor by Jim Maune, seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
0:48:44 Anything further on that motion?
0:48:46 Council.
0:48:47 Liahla, roll call vote, please.
0:48:51 Chris Talkington.
0:48:52 Yes.
0:48:53 Greg Lanting.
0:48:54 Yes.
0:48:55 Yes.
0:48:56 Yes.
0:48:57 Yes.
0:48:58 Yes.
0:48:59 Yes.
0:49:00 Yes.
0:49:01 Yes.
0:49:02 Yes.
0:49:03 Motion passes.
0:49:04 Seven to zero.
0:49:05 And as we know item number five has been pulled from the agenda.
0:49:10 So we'll move down to item number six is a consideration of a request to adopt and ordinance amending city code nine dash six dash eight regarding the city's regulation of on street large truck parking.
0:49:24 second reading Mitch Humble. Don't really have anything new to add from our last
0:49:32 couple of conversations about this. It's simply on the agenda so we can look at
0:49:37 it another time and give some folks a chance to talk about it if there's anyone
0:49:40 here to talk about it. I think that was the desire of the council last time so I'll
0:49:43 just sit down and answer questions if you have them or if there's any of the
0:49:47 public that wants to talk about it. Very good thank you Mitch. We do have an
0:49:52 One item on here, number six, is there anyone here that wanted to speak regarding the number
0:50:01 six which is adopting an ordinance amending city code regarding city regulations of on
0:50:07 street parking by large trucks?
0:50:12 Anyone here?
0:50:14 Scott, you can come up and talk about it if you want.
0:50:18 Sean Barrigar.
0:50:19 Mitch, did you receive any calls from anyone during the last week after this was publicized
0:50:25 last week. Have you had any of your staff? We haven't got any calls. The only thing I got was a note handed me
0:50:32 tonight from one of the property owners out there saying, please let's adopt this. Okay, that's it. Thank you.
0:50:39 Chris talking. I was the one responsible for dragging the city's feet on the thing and I have to say I
0:50:44 not heard from a single person. So they've either all vetted their frustration or are watching TV
0:50:52 eagerly tonight to make sure that we jump through the hoops.
0:50:55 Rebecca Milsoyka.
0:50:57 Thank you, Mayor.
0:50:59 I did hear some feedback just on the radio listening to the local station.
0:51:04 Some people had thoughts about it, but obviously they're not here tonight.
0:51:08 I think my concern with changing the code based on a single localized problem is that
0:51:14 might have some unintended consequences.
0:51:17 These people are on the truck route that we've asked them to take and when we ask them to park
0:51:22 in M1 or M2 zoning, we're kind of sending them through our town, kind of in search of
0:51:27 this zone property that isn't visible to the eye and I know we're going to educate people
0:51:33 but then again they're long-haul truck drivers so it's a constant flow of new people.
0:51:38 Unlike downtown parking where you can kind of educate the users that come back over and
0:51:44 over again, I'm kind of worried about, you know, the enforcement of this, because sure
0:51:50 we can write a lot of tickets, but I'm not sure that's a really good use of our officer's
0:51:57 time or even our code enforcement time.
0:52:01 So I'm just afraid that this is maybe a too large sweeping step to change your entire
0:52:06 code just for the single problem.
0:52:08 I think it could be addressed with maybe some signs put up in this specific area.
0:52:14 I know that Walmart welcomes truck parking in the C1 zone, which is nearby.
0:52:21 And I believe that the people who are parking there would be respectful of the signs.
0:52:26 So I just don't support changing our entire code just for this one localized incident.
0:52:31 I think we should take some more measured and appropriate steps first.
0:52:34 Thank you, Rebecca, I just wanted to remind counsel that if we choose to enact this this evening that we'll have to go to third and final, because it's the second reading.
0:52:45 Great landing.
0:52:47 Mayor Hall, I move that we suspend the rules and place order of 3063, third and final by title only.
0:52:58 Second.
0:52:59 We have a motion on the floor by Greg and Lanting, seconded by Sean Berra.
0:53:05 Greg, do you still have further?
0:53:07 Chris talking to me.
0:53:08 Is it appropriate for a question here for the vote?
0:53:11 Sure.
0:53:12 Mitch, one question.
0:53:13 Your research with Boise Caldwell, Pokey, Namp and Rexford show that all those municipalities
0:53:20 do regulate on-street parking, at least in residential areas, what have you found so far as commercial,
0:53:28 allowing them commercial?
0:53:29 All of the cities we looked at pretty much treat them exactly like we currently treat them.
0:53:35 So we would be kind of stepping out here in new grounds as far as I know.
0:53:39 So none of them currently prohibited except in manufacturing and wanting to.
0:53:43 No residential is but they all think.
0:53:45 Thank you.
0:53:46 Jim.
0:53:47 Thank you mayor.
0:53:48 I was just going to indicate before the Greg made the motion that whereas I respect the
0:53:54 the right honorable woman's opinion in regards to this being a very small localized issue.
0:54:00 I think the matter, the evidence was very, very clear that this was a significant problem
0:54:05 with public nuisance littering and other behaviors that do have to be dealt with in this area.
0:54:15 So I certainly, and I think that applying city codes to specific, narrowly focused areas of
0:54:21 the community is not overreaching in this regard.
0:54:23 So I will in fact support this, this ordinance.
0:54:28 Thank you, Councilman Munn.
0:54:29 Anything further on the motion council?
0:54:32 The roll call vote, please.
0:54:34 Greg Lansing.
0:54:35 Yes.
0:54:36 Don Hall.
0:54:37 Yes.
0:54:38 Dr. Camille Suica.
0:54:39 No.
0:54:40 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:54:41 Yes.
0:54:42 Jim Munn.
0:54:43 Yes.
0:54:44 Sean Berger.
0:54:45 Yes.
0:54:46 Chris Tockens.
0:54:47 Yes.
0:54:47 Motion passes six to one.
0:54:51 Need to read the title, if you would, please.
0:54:54 Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, that Twin Falls City Code Subsection 968
0:55:00 be amended to prohibit on-street truck parking, except in manufacturing districts, are well engaged in loading or unloading.
0:55:08 Council wishes. Greg Lanning.
0:55:11 Move more approval. Awardments 3063.
0:55:13 Second.
0:55:14 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Jim Mon. We have a light. Chris talking.
0:55:19 If this passes, which it looks like it will, I would request that internally the city staff
0:55:27 make your department look at it and come back and report and say six months time on the impact,
0:55:32 either feedback from truckers or if there's been just a shifting to the problem, if littering
0:55:39 is still a problem, something to evaluate whether being on the cutting edge and this time has
0:55:45 been smart or whether we've been too smart. Okay.
0:55:50 Makes sense to me. Thank you, Chris. Anything further on the
0:55:53 motion? The ailer, we'll call vote please. Don Hall. Yes.
0:56:01 Rebecca Mills Dweka. No. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim Mann. Yes.
0:56:08 Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris talking to us. Greg Glantin. Yes.
0:56:14 Motion passes six to one. Moving on to the next item. Number
0:56:18 is consideration of a request to adopt an ordinance
0:56:22 to transfer lots nine and 10,
0:56:24 lock 119 to the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency, Mitch Humble.
0:56:31 Obviously, I'm not Melinda.
0:56:33 So, I know you're under down on the agenda for to do this one,
0:56:36 but I sent her home, I said I gotta be here anyway,
0:56:37 I might not take care of it.
0:56:38 But anyway, the last couple of weeks we've talked about this item
0:56:42 for a few meetings, this would be the property
0:56:45 that the city is gonna dispose of to the agency on second.
0:56:48 We had the other hearing last week, and there was a little objection that Council directed
0:56:54 us to prepare an ordinance, and that ordinance is ready for your adoption tonight, if you
0:56:59 so choose to adopt it.
0:57:01 If so, we do need to do the third and final motion again, if not, we can bring it back
0:57:05 for a second reading with the next one.
0:57:07 Do we have an ordinance number?
0:57:09 3064.
0:57:10 3064.
0:57:11 Thank you.
0:57:12 Thank you, Mitch.
0:57:14 Any questions, thoughts?
0:57:15 Council?
0:57:16 Great.
0:57:17 Chris talking.
0:57:18 Chris talking to passage of 3064
0:57:24 Oh, I thought of just a simple majority. Oh, okay, all right
0:57:28 Third and final by title only and their suspension rules
0:57:32 Second we have a motion on for by Chris talking 10 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to suspend the rules and place ordinance 30
0:57:40 64 on third and final by title only
0:57:46 Anything further on that motion council
0:57:48 The aye on the roll call vote please.
0:57:50 Rebecca Milsoyka, yes.
0:57:53 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.
0:57:55 Jim Munn, yes.
0:57:57 Sean Berriger, yes.
0:57:58 Chris Talking too, yes.
0:58:00 Greg Lante, yes.
0:58:02 Don Hall, yes.
0:58:03 Motion passes, seven to zero.
0:58:06 Mayor, let me read the title.
0:58:07 Oh, thank you, Green's title.
0:58:10 In ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls,
0:58:12 Idaho, authorized in the transfer
0:58:15 are conveyance of rail property by the city
0:58:17 to attack supported governmental unit.
0:58:21 Great mining, move approval of ordinance 3064.
0:58:25 Second.
0:58:26 Motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,
0:58:28 seconded by Sean Burger to approve ordinance 3064.
0:58:34 Greg Lanning.
0:58:35 Oh, I'd like to speak in favor of this ordinance
0:58:38 or this change that we're moving on ordinance, excuse me,
0:58:41 moving the land over the urban and rural agency
0:58:45 where they can market it with the building next door.
0:58:47 We take an empty lot that is a dirt lot, it's not a paved lot that allows them to market
0:58:56 that building in a much more effective manner and provide a boost to downtown Twin Falls
0:59:06 because that building is probably not going to sell without having a lot attached to it.
0:59:11 It's an unused lot that we're not utilizing it.
0:59:14 If we were using it for parking, we'd actually be breaking our own parking codes because it's not paved.
0:59:22 Thank you, Greg.
0:59:22 Anything further on the motion?
0:59:24 Rebecca Mills-Soy?
0:59:25 Thank you, Mayor.
0:59:26 We've talked about this before, so I'll just keep my comments brief.
0:59:30 I think that privatizing public parking downtown has really been one of the struggles for downtown and really caused a lot of our parking issues down there.
0:59:38 I think I know that it's in our strategic plan to address parking issues downtown.
0:59:43 But to take a parking area that's now a place where anyone can park and move it in a private property,
0:59:50 I think further compounds the parking issues downtown, but I do support the Urban Renewal Agency for
0:59:57 working downtown to improve the properties down there.
1:00:04 Thank you, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:00:07 The lot that we're discussing is across the street from one of our parking lots, is that correct?
1:00:12 the parking lot that we have across, oops,
1:00:15 across the street on Second Avenue is very seldom full
1:00:19 if my recollection is correct from driving
1:00:22 around that side of town.
1:00:25 So for people to park on the far side of Second Avenue
1:00:28 and really have to cross that street
1:00:30 to get to most of the businesses on Main Street
1:00:32 probably isn't gonna be a primary parking location
1:00:36 for most people.
1:00:37 And so utilizing it in a private business
1:00:39 where it can benefit the community,
1:00:41 increase our tax base and beautify that area a little bit makes a lot of sense to me and so I will be supporting this.
1:00:48 You pretty well said everything I wanted to say so thank you. I think it's right on track. Anything further on the motion council?
1:00:58 Leila, roll call vote please.
1:01:01 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:01:02 Yes.
1:01:03 Jim Mann?
1:01:04 Yes.
1:01:05 Sean Berger?
1:01:06 Yes.
1:01:07 Chris Chalkington?
1:01:08 Yes.
1:01:09 Greg Lanti?
1:01:10 Yes.
1:01:11 John Hall?
1:01:12 Yes.
1:01:13 six to one moving on to just let everyone know we do have a public hearing
1:01:18 this evening it states that it won't start any earlier than six and we're
1:01:22 really close so I think we might be close to that sixth this evening but the
1:01:25 next item on the agenda is public input and or items from city manager and city
1:01:31 council so this is the time for the public if they wish to come and address
1:01:35 the council regarding something that's not on the agenda because you'll have time
1:01:41 for that in a few minutes. I think we're going to have some of that later. This is the time
1:01:45 for you to come forward and address the council. Is there anybody wishing to do that? You're
1:01:51 walking this way Brad. I see no one so I'm going to ask the city manager do you have anything
1:01:57 for just real quick Mr. Mayor members of the council one of the things that we obviously
1:02:01 have been tracking is the amount of precipitation that we find in our mountains. Snowpack is important
1:02:10 especially when we started looking at reservoir and reservoir depths.
1:02:14 One of the things that I learned over the weekend, speaking with who a person I'd considered
1:02:19 to be a water expert, is that they're anticipating that all of the reservoirs will fill as a result
1:02:25 of the moisture and snow that we received in the month of February, which is good news
1:02:32 for us.
1:02:33 I think it is also also a cautionary tale where it should require us as a local community to continue to find ways to find more conservation, and to take advantage of that resource.
1:02:47 And so the city staff and team has been working aggressively with some of our media partners on the development of some messaging, and Josh Palmer's really taking the lead on that, so you'll start seeing that very, very near future.
1:03:02 Something about hashtags. That's yeah, that's all I know
1:03:09 Anything from City Council Greg landing
1:03:12 right before the tonight's Council meeting I was on a conference call I'm on the executive committee of the
1:03:20 Association of Idaho cities and
1:03:22 it was called specifically for the
1:03:26 legislation that would limit cities ability to utilize them a domain for
1:03:32 concerning irrigation districts
1:03:34 The good news of the phone call was that the Pioneer Irrigation District has fired their attorney
1:03:41 and who has been the stumbling block for their agreement in the City of Caldwell and the Pioneer Irrigation District
1:03:47 appear quite close to an agreement and that they have actually met with both the leadership of the legislature
1:03:55 and the legislature is still feeling pressure to bring the legislation that was contemplated by Mr. Betkey
1:04:02 Speaker Betkey will probably come forth and the Nod Nod Wink Wink was that they probably passed the House and they'll refer to the State Affairs Committee and the Senate and kill it.
1:04:13 That's the Nod Nod Wink Wink. There's no guarantees in those. It's always scary when things do get to the legislature and get voted on.
1:04:21 So that's a particular one.
1:04:23 Several other bills that the AIC has been working on the city's behalf,
1:04:28 the URA bills, the public defender issue with the movement moving it to a,
1:04:36 from a misdemeanor to infraction, whether it would cut into our ability to enforce codes.
1:04:43 And some of those are still working, but they were quite confident on those,
1:04:47 including the design review bill that passed quite easily in the house,
1:04:52 and appears that Senator Sitaway is going to find a drawer to place it in the Senate and not allow it to even come to a committee hearing.
1:05:01 So those are ones that the AIC has been working on our half considering and we have been looking at them as well.
1:05:09 Thank you, Greg. Suzanne Hawkins.
1:05:11 I just want to give a public acknowledgement to the Magic Valley Commonwealth School.
1:05:18 meet at the Presbyterian Church and last week I had the opportunity to go speak to their junior
1:05:22 high classes about local government, city government and civics and I have to tell you
1:05:27 it's always refreshing to see how the youth in this valley understand and engage in questions
1:05:34 and what's happening and participate in that and I just want to thank the school for inviting
1:05:39 me and let them know how much I enjoyed spending a couple hours with their students and it was
1:05:45 really a great experience.
1:05:46 Thank you, Suzanne. I wanted to bring to the attention of the council that we had a vote last week
1:05:52 I think where we had a
1:05:54 abstention and I
1:05:56 Contacted our city attorney because I wanted to have a little more knowledge about how to look at
1:06:02 abstentions of votes on council part and
1:06:05 The advice I got from our city attorney if you look under Roberts rule of order now keeping in mind we do a very modified
1:06:14 Robert's a rule of order, but if you ever abstain from a vote you have to have a legal
1:06:20 qualification conflict of interest to be able to do that. If you abstain and you
1:06:26 don't have that, then it's my obligation and I'll do this better in the future to
1:06:30 state that one vote not in favor, not against the motion but not in favor
1:06:37 instead of abstain abstention. So I wanted to bring that to your attention.
1:06:41 learning experience for me and I'll try to monitor that closer in the future.
1:06:46 All right, Council, we can go right into the public hearing or we could take a
1:06:53 three or four minute break because I think we might be here for a while. So let's
1:06:59 go ahead and take a five minute break. State signs to allow temporary real estate
1:07:31 open house signs in the public right away under specific conditions. We are
1:07:36 We're going to have the applicant come up first, and she'll have about 15 minutes if you wish
1:07:43 to do that.
1:07:44 Anyone wishing to testify, make sure you put your name on the back there so we can bring
1:07:48 that up.
1:07:49 And then we'll call you up and we give you about two minutes apiece to come up and speak.
1:07:53 So with that being said, Jim Munn, do you have?
1:07:55 Yeah, thank you, Mayor.
1:07:57 First thing I want to do is have a discussion in regards to whether I should participate in
1:08:04 this discussion or not.
1:08:05 And I am a member of the Greater Twin Falls Board of Realtors.
1:08:10 I'm currently my license to practice real estate is currently inactive.
1:08:16 I wanted to make sure before I would proceed in this hearing whether there would be a conflict
1:08:24 of interest.
1:08:25 And if there is not a conflict of interest is defined by the Idaho Attorney General's
1:08:30 Office, I do want to participate because I'm paid by the community and I was elected by the
1:08:35 community to make decisions in this regard. So, I consulted with the City Attorney, I know
1:08:39 he's corresponded with Council in this matter, and I'd like to have some discourse with him
1:08:46 in regards to this before the hearing is underway.
1:08:48 So, Jim did give me that question. I sent an email out to the Council earlier today. This
1:08:56 is out of the ethics and government manual from the Attorney General's office. It just
1:09:02 answers a question and it refers to Title 59, Chapter 7, and it's actually in 703 on
1:09:12 the definitions. But I guess the long and short of it is if you look at subsections B
1:09:18 and C, either one of those would apply to any of you that would be a realtor who might
1:09:24 see this as an advantage to you as a realtor personally. If it affects you the same as it
1:09:32 effect. All these other people, a large group, and I think when I talk to you, Jim, you estimated
1:09:38 like 300.
1:09:39 I believe there are, and I would defer to Nancy, but I think there are around 300 members
1:09:43 in our association. Is that correct? How? 260.
1:09:47 So it can affect you the same way it affects a group like that, and there is not a legal
1:09:53 conflict of interest.
1:09:54 So there's not a conflict of interest, but thank you. Then I will proceed in this hearing.
1:09:59 Thank you, Jim, and thank you, Fritz, for that information.
1:10:03 So we will go ahead and turn it over to Nan Ghandi of the Greater Twin Falls Association
1:10:08 of Real Affairs.
1:10:10 Welcome, Nan.
1:10:11 Thank you.
1:10:12 Mayor Hall.
1:10:13 Members of the city council, recognizable.
1:10:19 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:10:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:10:28 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:10:35 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:10:42 the Greater Twin Falls Association of Realtors can increase the visibility of temporary, directional,
1:10:49 real estate, wayfinding signs.
1:10:52 This expansion of the ordinance would also impact the 404 families that currently have
1:10:59 their homes on the market here in the city of Twin Falls and the area of impact.
1:11:08 This would also affect any future sellers, families that would be putting their homes on the market.
1:11:16 It also impacts builders, developers, lenders, title companies, home inspectors, insurance agents,
1:11:25 anyone and anybody in those businesses that depends on real estate to make a successful
1:11:33 business.
1:11:35 The key to selling a residential property is to get the maximum exposure for the property.
1:11:40 Open houses are an important tool in accomplishing this goal.
1:11:44 They are important to sellers.
1:11:46 A lot of realtors, quite frankly, would prefer not to use their weekends doing open houses,
1:11:52 but their sellers demand it.
1:11:55 Open houses are a time-honored method that's been used for years not only in the Twin Falls
1:12:00 area but nationally.
1:12:05 The present provision of the current ordinance limits the use of wayfinding signs as an important
1:12:11 part of marketing the open house.
1:12:15 To have an effective open house, it is necessary to advertise ads are costly.
1:12:21 Realtors are reluctant to place expensive ads in newspapers when they may not be able
1:12:25 to place signs to direct potential buyers to the property.
1:12:33 This could also result in a lack of revenue for the newspapers.
1:12:39 Realtors are not asking for the ordinance to be removed from the books, only that minor
1:12:43 changes are implemented to allow the wayfinding signs to be placed for a very limited period
1:12:49 of time in visible places to direct traffic to the open houses.
1:12:55 look for directional signs to direct them to the open house. The economic impact of
1:13:02 the real estate market in Twin Falls according to the IMLS, which is the
1:13:06 Intermountain Multiple Listing Service, for 2012 over 82 million dollars of
1:13:12 real estate. In 2013, a total of over 114 million dollars of real estate sold. This
1:13:22 This is one of the larger economic impacts of any business or profession in the City of
1:13:28 Twin Falls.
1:13:30 Helping real estate sales thrive helps the entire citizenry economically.
1:13:38 The real estate market has historically driven the economic recovery process.
1:13:43 The real estate market has been hit hard in the last several years.
1:13:47 Unemployment remains a drag on the housing community.
1:13:50 The industry does not need any other impediments to restrict the improvements to the real estate
1:13:57 market.
1:13:59 Regarding possible impacts, city staff mentions concerns regarding the site triangle.
1:14:06 However, open house A-frame signs are 26 inches in height.
1:14:14 City ordinance 9-9-16 defines the obstruction to traffic as follows.
1:14:21 An obstruction constituting a traffic hazard shall exist if any object, structure, or thing
1:14:30 except buildings, residences, which are otherwise in conformance with the law, is allowed to
1:14:36 exist which exceeds three feet above the existing roadway center line elevation.
1:14:42 The proposed amendment specifically limits the height of the directional sign to comply
1:14:48 with the site triangle provision of 9-9-16.
1:14:53 Realtors are not asking for any change in signage
1:14:56 at their place of business or in the placement
1:15:00 of regular real estate marketing signs,
1:15:04 for instance yard signs.
1:15:07 Their request is to allow increased flexibility
1:15:10 in the placement of temporary, directional devices
1:15:15 to drive traffic to the open houses.
1:15:18 The business model of real estate sales is unique.
1:15:21 No other business does offer off-site open houses
1:15:26 as services to their clients.
1:15:29 Buyers are conditioned to look for directional signs
1:15:31 to direct them to an open house.
1:15:34 Although staff considers the existing ordinance
1:15:37 to be adequate, there are other communities
1:15:40 who have recognized the challenge of holding open houses
1:15:44 and the buyers need for directional signs.
1:15:47 Similar ordinances are currently on the books in the city of Ketchum and the city of Caldwell,
1:15:54 allowing open house signs in the public right of way under conditions similar to those proposed
1:15:59 in this amendment.
1:16:01 The association is aware of past problems with the placement of signs on sidewalks as
1:16:07 depicted in some of the pictures that were in the staff report.
1:16:11 Most of those signs shown would continue to be in violation of the ordinance.
1:16:17 In an effort to eliminate any violations, the association proposes an aggressive educational
1:16:24 process for all realtor members and new members.
1:16:29 The code enforcement officer, Sean Stanley, has indicated his willingness to provide an
1:16:34 educational presentation to one of our monthly membership lunches.
1:16:40 and staff will provide training to new member orientations.
1:16:44 We would also encourage individual brokers
1:16:47 to provide training at their sales meetings.
1:16:52 And I'd like to, maybe I should have done this
1:16:55 in the beginning, give the rest of my time
1:16:57 to Nancy Glaisman, is that permissible?
1:16:59 Certainly.
1:17:08 You have about another seven minutes.
1:17:11 Okay, thank you.
1:17:14 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:17:17 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:17:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:17:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:17:36 I believe in the process, the system, and I watch, I'm a real nerd, I watch the Council meetings on television,
1:17:45 and I know what's happening in the city.
1:17:50 And we're not going to hold that against you, OK?
1:17:53 There was a comment once by Mr. Lanting
1:17:56 that something about turning the cameras off
1:17:59 were the two people who were still watching.
1:18:01 I looked at my husband like, here we are.
1:18:07 So I do know what's going on in the city.
1:18:10 And in early 2013, I recognized the need for the city's wastewater
1:18:15 a bond to pass. I tapped into the resources available through the National Association
1:18:21 Realtors to get a $10,000 grant to help make that happen and it did happen the bond pass.
1:18:28 So I'm excited for that for our city. This process to get the zoning amendment passed
1:18:34 hasn't gone so well. And I felt like the process has somewhat been tainted from the start
1:18:40 and I'm disappointed in that.
1:18:43 In July 2013, Association of Representatives,
1:18:46 men and formerly, with city staff and two council members
1:18:50 to brainstorm about the possibility
1:18:52 of assigned ordinance change.
1:18:55 In July, on July 31st, before the amendment
1:18:58 had actually been drafted by the Realtor Association,
1:19:03 the Zoya Committee meant and voted
1:19:04 to send a negative recommendation
1:19:06 to the Planning and Zoning Commission,
1:19:08 even though they didn't know what the proposed amendment
1:19:11 would say. In November 2013, Nan Gandy and I met with Renee Caraway, John's family, John's family, and I'm a real fan of Shawn's. I tell agents if Shawn picked up their sign they deserved it. So, and Shawn knows that. At that time we discussed the types of problems Shawn was experiencing with the placement of signs. And he said there had been at one point a lot of problems with the signs.
1:19:40 But several brokerages had arranged in office training
1:19:43 and the problems had been dramatically reduced.
1:19:48 Even though Sean is a key player in any discussion
1:19:51 about signage, he wasn't at the December 10th P&C meeting,
1:19:55 despite the fact that many of the commission members had
1:19:58 questioned for him.
1:20:03 Moving ahead to the staff analysis included in the packet
1:20:07 tonight, none of the signs included in the analysis
1:20:10 would be allowed under the proposed amendment.
1:20:13 The proposed, most of them are on the sidewalk.
1:20:18 And the proposal that we have before you is,
1:20:22 specifies a minimum 36-inch clear passageway
1:20:26 on the sidewalk.
1:20:28 So I don't know why these signs are included.
1:20:32 Also in the staff analysis, there is a comment
1:20:34 that open house signs are not allowed
1:20:36 in the public right away and catch them are Caldwell.
1:20:42 This is incorrect.
1:20:43 I have a copy of those.
1:20:47 Can I put them up?
1:20:48 Absolutely.
1:20:49 Please.
1:20:59 This is called well.
1:21:01 Thank you.
1:21:02 And they kind of skirted the issue by saying that the detached landscaping strip for the
1:21:09 purposes of this section is not considered public right away, but they do allow the open
1:21:15 house signs in the detached landscaping strip.
1:21:33 Ketchum did quite an extensive ordinance change in February of 2012 and this is basically
1:21:41 what their, this is what their ordinance says.
1:21:45 I've had a lot of conversation with Rebecca Bundy who is a senior planner with the city
1:21:51 at Ketchum and I tried to get her to go on record about the things that she told me because
1:21:56 She said, even though the council was worried about it,
1:22:02 but they thought this idea was good for business,
1:22:05 good to keep the market moving, they just
1:22:09 were worried about the outcome.
1:22:10 And she said, in the end, it's been a non-event.
1:22:13 So I said, please go on record and say that.
1:22:15 She said, you know, Twin Falls experience could vary.
1:22:18 I don't want to do that, but that was her comment to me.
1:22:23 So tonight, I would ask you to please put any aside,
1:22:27 any bias that has been interjected into this discussion so far. And look at what is proposed
1:22:33 with fresh eyes and open minds and judge what is presented on its own merits. And now on to
1:22:39 the positive stuff. In my role as the Association Executive, I coordinate the education for agents
1:22:50 And particularly new agents.
1:22:52 And in the pictures that are in the staff report,
1:22:55 there's, I think it goes on, yeah, on February 15th,
1:22:59 there was a new agent who had an open house.
1:23:02 And her pictures, her signs are the ones
1:23:05 that are depicted in the picture.
1:23:06 She's here.
1:23:07 I warned her before the pictures popped up.
1:23:10 And it occurred to me that I should not be relying
1:23:14 on her office to train her about where to put the signs.
1:23:17 I should be doing it at new member orientation.
1:23:21 So it is my plan no matter what happens here tonight,
1:23:26 that I would add that into our quarterly new member orientation
1:23:30 and go over what the ordinance says for those new members.
1:23:34 And I'd like to have Sean involved in that if he's available.
1:23:39 So they start out knowing him and they would be more comfortable
1:23:42 talking to him with their questions before they have their science picked up.
1:23:47 So my vision would be that for particularly for Sean that violations and complaints about
1:23:55 science would become non-existent through an education program.
1:23:59 Thank you.
1:24:00 Perfect.
1:24:01 Turn it over to the staff and we have Jonathan Spindler.
1:24:06 Welcome Jonathan.
1:24:07 Thank you Mr. Mayor and members of council.
1:24:25 So the regulatory impact approval of this ordinance will allow off-premise open-out signs to advertise
1:24:31 within public right-of-way, a little bit of history.
1:24:34 Council approved, ordinance 2012 and 81,
1:24:36 which replaced Twin Falls Title Code, Title 10, entirely,
1:24:40 and in December 2008, it was approved by Council
1:24:43 or replaced the sign code in its entirety.
1:24:46 Also, ordinance 3005 in June of 2011,
1:24:50 also made miscellaneous sign related changes
1:24:52 in the Twin Falls City Code.
1:24:55 This request is made by the Twin Falls Association
1:24:58 of Realtors asking for a zoning title amendment, which would amend Twin Falls City Code 10-9-9k,
1:25:06 real estate signs.
1:25:08 The proposed amendment is requesting to allow real estate open house signs to be located
1:25:12 on any public right away subject to A, limited hours not to exceed five total hours in any
1:25:16 one day, B, access of right away, a public right away to remain open, including wheelchair
1:25:22 access and C, signs to be removed from the right away within one hour after completion
1:25:27 of open house.
1:25:28 I think they've done a very good job in summarizing their request.
1:25:34 I don't need to go over that whole section that's already in your staff report about what
1:25:39 they're wishing for, the impacts that might have on their enterprise.
1:25:43 I'm going to move right to the next section, which is the Twin Falls Comprehensive Plan.
1:25:49 It was updated in 2009.
1:25:51 Within that plan, a section was devoted to the design of streetscapes and possible enhancements
1:25:55 to road right-of-ways and surrounding corridors.
1:25:58 Commercial signage within the streetscape design guidelines or it's associated streetscape enhancements.
1:26:04 Commercial signage within right of way is not addressed as a goal or objective of the current comprehensive plan.
1:26:11 Community design concept section and residential signage is not discussed at all in Title 10 and
1:26:17 it does not allow for residential signage in the city to come false.
1:26:21 Possible impacts.
1:26:23 If it's approved, the conement will not change the current regulation of any sign being prohibited.
1:26:27 In site triangles located intersections of streets,
1:26:30 alleys, and driveways, as stated in Title IX,
1:26:33 Chapter 10, Section 16.
1:26:35 The site triangle is an industry standard that is focused
1:26:37 on providing for and maintaining safety.
1:26:39 It is designed to allow clear visibility for all types
1:26:42 of traffic, pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicle at intersections.
1:26:46 Signs over three feet tall would still not be allowed
1:26:48 in this triangle if the amendment is granted.
1:26:51 It would allow this specific private commercial enterprise
1:26:55 to utilize the public right-of-way for advertisement.
1:26:58 Current city code prohibits all signs
1:26:59 from being placed in the public right-of-way.
1:27:02 It also prohibits all off-premise commercial signage,
1:27:05 with one exception being the real estate,
1:27:07 open house and or real estate signage.
1:27:10 It's the only enterprise that allows off-site signage
1:27:13 in the city currently.
1:27:15 Staff feels this amendment to the city code
1:27:17 would cause confusion and possibly an increase
1:27:19 in violations by other private individuals
1:27:20 and businesses that will see this as a precedent
1:27:23 to allow all types of commercial advertising signs
1:27:26 within the public right-of-way.
1:27:28 Other businesses may feel that there,
1:27:30 they should be allowed to permit,
1:27:32 be permitted to advertise off-premise
1:27:34 and within public right-of-way to allow their visibility.
1:27:37 Staff-consultated iCrimp, ICRMP regarding this request,
1:27:41 they express concerns with signage being placed
1:27:43 in public right-of-way, which could cause an accident.
1:27:47 There has comment about catching Caldwell.
1:27:49 I've got, they've got them here.
1:27:58 This is a specific section of Caldwell's sign.
1:28:01 I've got the entire section.
1:28:04 With that regard to them disallowing the space
1:28:07 between sidewalk and roadway, there is another section, page 14.
1:28:21 Off-premises real estate signs, and it specifically
1:28:24 prohibits off-premises real estate open house signs that
1:28:28 are not allowed in the right-of-way area.
1:28:32 Caldwell is not part of Ada County.
1:28:34 A to count a highway district disallows all signage and right-of-way also.
1:28:38 So there's no cities within that county that allow signage and commercial in any way.
1:28:44 The next section of catch them, catch them, there is a, it's their last sentence in B4.
1:29:08 Which provided they are not located on pavement or within any improved pedestrian or bicycle way.
1:29:13 Catch them is different from our community.
1:29:16 They do not have detached sidewalks.
1:29:18 There's one section in the entire city.
1:29:21 Downtown, Main Street and Sun Valley Road,
1:29:28 they have all attached sidewalks,
1:29:31 much like our downtown area,
1:29:32 which means if they're going to advertise
1:29:34 real estate signs in this area,
1:29:35 they would have to be behind the sidewalk
1:29:37 because they can't be on pavement or on the sidewalk.
1:29:40 They are residential areas,
1:29:44 and these are just samples of the,
1:29:45 I can't show the entire city.
1:29:47 They do not have sidewalks in the residential areas
1:29:49 except for very few portions.
1:29:51 So if they were to advertise in catch them, it would seem
1:29:56 like it's on private property because they don't have sidewalks
1:29:58 in the residential areas.
1:30:00 They also don't allow them in this tight triangles either.
1:30:03 So I also spoke with representative from catch them,
1:30:06 not the same one.
1:30:08 But they agree they do not have issues with it,
1:30:11 but catch them's different from Twin Falls.
1:30:14 It's not the same, it's a different environment,
1:30:16 it's a different setup as we can see.
1:30:17 They don't have sidewalks in the residential areas,
1:30:20 but signs are also not allowed on any paved portions in their city.
1:30:25 It effectively eliminates it except for what would seem like private property.
1:30:30 The next thing I spoke with Mike Scott, a representative from the Hadoa Transportation Department.
1:30:40 He has told me that there will not be any signage allowed on any of the state roads.
1:30:46 I've listed the roads that will not have any signage allowed on them.
1:30:50 The majority of Shoshone Street, Washington South, Blue Lakes Boulevard, from the bridge
1:30:55 down to Kimberly Road, both seconds, Kimberly Road, Pull Line Road, from basically Rock Creek
1:31:02 all the way to Blue Lakes Boulevard North and Addison Avenue, the area of impact on the West,
1:31:08 limited to Blue Lakes Boulevard North.
1:31:10 All of those are state highways and those will not be allowed to have signage in them either.
1:31:15 So this code section would not allow them to be placed in that right of way as well.
1:31:22 So in conclusion, on December 10th, 2013, the commission held a public hearing on this request.
1:31:31 There was considerable discussion and comments by both the real estate industry and the commission, please see attachment number five, which is a portion of the minutes.
1:31:39 The public hearing and discussion, the commission recommended denial of this request as presented by a vote of three, four, and four against.
1:31:47 vote is as follows. Commissioner Gray, no. Commissioner Munoz, no. Commissioner Tatum, yes. Commissioner
1:31:53 Dvor, yes. Commissioner Woods, no. Commissioner Boyd, yes. And Commissioner Frank, no.
1:32:01 Thank you, Jonathan. Do we have any questions from council, from either presenters or our
1:32:07 staff? Greg Lenny.
1:32:09 Just my question would be, obviously, we have signs here and it shows the signs on the sidewalk
1:32:15 And that would not be allowed under the proposed ordinance,
1:32:18 as I understand it, but is in many of these areas,
1:32:22 is there any area that is public right away
1:32:26 that isn't the sidewalk, other than the tap sidewalk areas?
1:32:31 Because I think of all of the residential areas
1:32:34 and they don't have a tap sidewalk.
1:32:36 So in other words, the sign would either have to be on
1:32:39 the sidewalk or on the private property.
1:32:42 There is no public property other than the sidewalk
1:32:46 and the street, obviously, somewhere on the street.
1:32:49 We've got an answer.
1:32:52 Okay, thank you.
1:32:54 These are taken on Saturday.
1:32:59 The one on the upper left, no sidewalk is on the corner.
1:33:04 Potentially the site trying long, not sure,
1:33:06 but that could be right of way.
1:33:10 There just is no sidewalk there.
1:33:11 Okay.
1:33:13 one on the upper right would be right of way there is that's an area that has a
1:33:17 detached sidewalk. I'm assuming that's a Federation Road. I'm not sure where that
1:33:23 one's taking Sean Federation Road. Lower left and the lower right although the
1:33:30 streets sometimes aren't built out we may have right of way behind the sidewalk
1:33:34 Sean informed me this morning those two signs although they may be in the right
1:33:38 of way would not have been picked up or moved since they're not impeding the
1:33:41 sidewalk, how does side triangle type stuff. Okay. So is
1:33:47 there places? Yes, there are places in town. They're limited. I
1:33:51 can't identify all of them. And to could you repeat the streets
1:33:56 again that would not be under our purview or control or whatever
1:34:02 you want to call it? It's going to be extensive. They were all
1:34:07 of the major highways, all the ones of the state controls. The
1:34:12 majority of Shoshone Street, it's not the entirety. It's just
1:34:15 where the state controls it.
1:34:16 Washington South, Blue Lakes Boulevard,
1:34:18 pretty much the entirety from the bridge
1:34:20 all the way down to Kimberly Road,
1:34:22 both of the second streets, the one ways, Kimberly Road,
1:34:26 and its entirety that's within the city limits.
1:34:29 Pull Line Road from Rock Creek to Blue Lakes Boulevard,
1:34:32 all the state road, and Addison Avenue,
1:34:35 from the area of impact limits on the West
1:34:37 to Blue Lakes Boulevard, more at that five points.
1:34:40 Thank you.
1:34:42 Any other questions from council?
1:34:44 I'm wondering if Sean could give us a little perspective on numbers of complaints or how
1:34:53 often he's dealing with these issues since he wasn't part of the planning and zoning commission.
1:34:59 We haven't really had a chance to hear some of your perspective.
1:35:01 You know, in the last couple years it hasn't been that big of a deal.
1:35:07 The things that we look out when we go out are safety issues, side obstructions, obstructing
1:35:13 things of that nature as shown in the earlier picture if they are behind a sidewalk that still might be city right away but we're not going to take the time to go out and measure that it's not a safety issue it's not a site obstruction it's fine as far as we're concerned.
1:35:33 and dealing with cold enforcement in any city code is priority for us to be consistent,
1:35:40 no matter what code it is. So I think the difficulty in allowing any sign in the right away
1:35:47 would be being consistent. It would be very tough to go tell Joe's hamburger shack that they can't
1:35:55 have a sign where one of these are allowed. So maybe looking at these two pictures, the two on
1:36:05 on the top, would you pick those up and remove those?
1:36:08 Yes, we would.
1:36:10 The one in the top left, you can see it's a safety issue.
1:36:13 It's right there by a crosswalk.
1:36:16 There's a fire item right there.
1:36:18 That is city right away.
1:36:20 The one on the top right, we would pick that up
1:36:23 as it is on this side of the sidewalk.
1:36:27 The other two, the bottom left, we probably would not pick
1:36:32 that up.
1:36:33 This other one on the bottom right, we would not.
1:36:36 Because it's behind the sidewalk, correct?
1:36:42 Any other questions, Council?
1:36:44 Nann, did you want to any rebuttal or if you want to wait until the end?
1:36:49 Yes, sir.
1:36:53 Thanks, John.
1:36:54 What I'm going to do now is I'm going to open up the public testimony portion of tonight's hearing.
1:37:00 So, if someone could go back and get the list for me,
1:37:03 and we're going to allow you two minutes, Pete.
1:37:06 Suzanne, over to my right here, you're left, she will hold up a 30 second sign.
1:37:12 That just means you have 30 seconds left and we don't throw darts at you or anything if you get real close
1:37:18 So don't don't don't freak out or anything, but that's kind of our rule and that's how we engage and we want to give you that time
1:37:24 So at this point I'll go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of the hearing and I will be calling folks up
1:37:32 Jack were you here for this?
1:37:35 Mr. Jardine and when you come up say state your name and your address just for the record if you wouldn't mind
1:37:41 Welcome, Mr. Jurdine.
1:37:48 Hey, thank you.
1:37:49 Thank you.
1:37:50 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:37:51 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:37:57 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:00 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:38:07 And we have one of the finest associations you'll find anyplace.
1:38:10 I recently had to help my daughter by a house in Meridian.
1:38:14 We found her house through an open house directional arrow in the city of Meridian.
1:38:21 And we had been spent four different days.
1:38:23 Now, being raised here, I still don't know all the streets.
1:38:27 And I dare say I could point some addresses to you that you don't know where it's at.
1:38:32 If we have a client from out of town, or an out of town client is here looking to see what makes this the Magic Valley,
1:38:39 we need to be able to let them find these homes.
1:38:44 If I was selling a home for any one of you, you would want me to do everything I could
1:38:50 to market it.
1:38:51 And the one thing it is when I have an open house is to get people there to see your home.
1:38:56 You might have just been appointed to the lieutenant governor's job, and they're leaving
1:39:00 the twin.
1:39:01 You want me to get it gone so you can buy a house up in the big city.
1:39:06 This is part of our business.
1:39:08 It's a big business, and I spent over 50 years in this city selling, and this I can tell you
1:39:15 It's an important part, Mr. Mayor and Council,
1:39:18 we appreciate what you're doing, and thank you so much,
1:39:20 but this is an important thing.
1:39:22 Thank you very much.
1:39:23 Thank you, Mr. Jardin.
1:39:25 Mr. Scott Martin, welcome, Mr. Martin.
1:39:34 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council.
1:39:37 I just want to come not as a realtor,
1:39:39 but in the mortgage industry, it's a real estate industry.
1:39:42 And give our support.
1:39:43 I was actually surprised to hear the negative recommendation
1:39:48 from the staff.
1:39:49 And mostly because I really didn't think it would be that big of an issue.
1:39:53 It's a way for the community to keep a vibrant real estate market.
1:39:58 And as we've seen, you guys have seen staff and the reduction of staff because of the real estate market going down, it impacts everyone.
1:40:06 So my recommendation would just be that look at your neighbors that have tried to sell their homes and
1:40:13 I haven't been able to, and any law there, right now, hinders or reduces a family's ability to sell their home.
1:40:20 That law needs to be amended.
1:40:22 So I strongly support this amendment.
1:40:24 Thanks.
1:40:25 Thank you, Ms. Martin.
1:40:27 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:40:37 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:40:42 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:40:45 So not as long as some in this room, I've never, ever had anybody complain about
1:40:51 signs and I don't know. You know, most of us all use these. I guess I'm just surprised
1:40:59 too as to why it is that big of an issue. They've been being used for a very long time
1:41:05 and we don't see Joe's burger stop putting one up. I mean, I guess, so I'm not seeing
1:41:11 where this is an issue either. And like you said, maybe we can pass this and see what happens
1:41:17 in six, seven months down the line, come revisit it and see if it has been a negative impact,
1:41:23 you know. So anyway, I support it and I just want to say that for agents, especially new
1:41:28 agents, this is how they get their start. Like I said, I've been doing it for 14 years,
1:41:35 but even, even I, you utilize these. But new agents, this is where they start their career
1:41:41 is by doing open houses. They'll do them for other agents because they don't have listings.
1:41:46 So this is how they start, now it's very expensive to advertise in our newspaper.
1:41:50 I don't know if you realize that, but I think the cheapest ad for an open house would be
1:41:54 around $200.
1:41:55 These new agents cannot afford that.
1:41:58 So this is a great way to get traffic there and believe me buyers look for them.
1:42:06 And like Scott or Jack said, especially the out of town buyers, they'll pick up a newspaper
1:42:12 maybe to see if there's an advertisement in there for the open houses.
1:42:15 But they still need the signs to kind of direct them to where those places are.
1:42:20 So, and here again, I appreciate Nancy.
1:42:23 She said she would educate people too and make sure they get them picked up in a timely fashion.
1:42:28 But anyway, I do support it and I appreciate your time.
1:42:31 Thank you.
1:42:32 Thank you, Mrs. Brown.
1:42:33 Linda Virgin.
1:42:34 I'd like to bring her sign up too with my quick question.
1:42:41 Hi, I'm an active realtor here in the state of Idaho, then active for over a decade here.
1:42:47 I do, I'm working under Canyon Side Urban Realty and have been the whole time.
1:42:54 And as I was listening to Susan Brown, I was remembering my first open house over a decade
1:43:00 ago, and I sold that house that was sold from that open house.
1:43:04 A lot of times when I'm doing my open houses, I have people and traffic come in, they said
1:43:10 I just stopped because I saw the sign.
1:43:13 And so I am in favor of this amendment.
1:43:15 Please consider that.
1:43:17 Thank you.
1:43:18 Thank you.
1:43:20 Okay.
1:43:21 Once in a while, I just can't say your name, so be kind.
1:43:27 Corey, I think it starts with an R. He's going to tell us what it is.
1:43:38 My name is Corey Robinson.
1:43:40 Robinson.
1:43:41 I live in 1151.
1:43:43 I'm sorry.
1:43:44 We're going to give you an extra 30 seconds to go.
1:43:47 Go ahead, Corey.
1:43:48 I live in 1151 seerway in Kimberly. I've been a realtor here for about a year and six months
1:43:55 I'm like like everyone's dating here. I'm a newer realtor. I'm not from the area originally
1:44:00 I I survived my business survives from open houses
1:44:04 And I'm just thankful that I can't put out a sign currently
1:44:08 I have sold about a million dollars of homes directly from these open houses
1:44:14 And I use that money to support me and my family.
1:44:18 So this subject is very touching to me because, you know,
1:44:22 with more advertising, with being able to represent my client's properties better,
1:44:29 I know I can be more successful and ask you to give me that tool tonight.
1:44:33 Thank you so much.
1:44:35 Thank you, Mr. Repson.
1:44:38 Thank you.
1:44:41 Sandy Schmidt.
1:44:48 I just want to apologize right off to everyone that I butcher your name so my
1:44:52 name is Sandy Schmidt I was at 3634 North 3300 Eastern Kimberly I'm also a
1:44:57 realtor here for a core group realty and I put an ad in the paper every week and
1:45:01 I do two to three open houses and even with the ad in the paper I still have a
1:45:06 lot of people that don't know I use these kind of signs and I also use this sign
1:45:11 here to help a little bit more with directional and you'll see it's not very
1:45:14 very tall. But like I said, with the signs, people are having a tough time. I'm having
1:45:20 people call me, still trying to find out how to get their stuff. So this is my business,
1:45:26 and I have other people helping me, and it's been successful so far. And we try to be very
1:45:32 kind and ask that people were putting their signs in their yard that if we can put them
1:45:37 there, we always put them behind the sidewalk. And I would never put one on one of those
1:45:43 main arterial streets because somebody would steal it. And I support this and I hope you
1:45:49 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:45:54 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:46:05 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:46:10 lifeblood. They help people get to the houses. We have a lot of new subdivisions, streets
1:46:16 that you know even us as realtors it's like what's where's that at we'll look at
1:46:19 each other you know have to go look it up on a map without the directional signs
1:46:23 people don't find them even people who've lived here for a long time so I'm in
1:46:27 favor of this amendment and like everybody else said they're not that big
1:46:31 we don't put them where they shouldn't be or if we're new we're gonna teach them
1:46:35 how not we're not to put them but if you pass us we can appreciate it thank you
1:46:39 You're on here again, did you want to come?
1:46:42 Oh, no, that was...
1:46:43 Very good.
1:46:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:46:46 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:47:03 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:47:09 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:47:12 I am also a commissioner, and you know that I voted in favor of this.
1:47:19 I am a little bit surprised. Actually, I'm a lot surprised.
1:47:23 This is a very old way of doing business.
1:47:27 It's not anything new having these signs.
1:47:31 And I very much admire my peers for coming forward
1:47:35 and wanting to clarify what exactly is in this code
1:47:39 so that they can adhere to it.
1:47:42 And they have commented on the things that they would like to do.
1:47:46 I'm also confused by how these signs are confusing.
1:47:53 People expect to see these signs.
1:47:55 Right now, and Sean, you can attest to this too.
1:47:58 The traffic in the neighborhood, the subdivision where we live, has tripled as the weather's
1:48:04 nicer.
1:48:06 People are driving around.
1:48:07 They're driving around neighborhoods that they like.
1:48:11 They're either from out of town or in town.
1:48:14 They're driving around the neighborhoods they think they might like to live in and they're
1:48:18 looking for open house signs.
1:48:22 They don't necessarily have the paper with them, they don't have a map with them.
1:48:26 They're driving areas specifically for open house signs.
1:48:30 And I think that this is something that we are not asking as a realtor association for
1:48:37 anything super special or really anything really different than how business has been
1:48:42 being conducted for decades, and I've strongly urge you to consider positive vote on this.
1:48:51 Thank you.
1:48:52 Thank you, Ms. Boyd.
1:48:54 Bonnie Boer.
1:48:58 Thank you.
1:49:00 Mayor, City Council, my name is Bonnie Baker.
1:49:04 It's B-O-E-K-E-R, but if you look at it, you can't say it, and if you say it, you can't
1:49:10 spell it.
1:49:11 Okay.
1:49:12 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:49:15 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:49:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:49:22 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:49:25 I'd like to help you visualize the big picture here and the impact that this ordinance has
1:49:32 on homeowners and the economy of the City of Twin Falls.
1:49:36 The Greater Twin Falls Association of Realtors wants to be your partner in promoting the
1:49:42 the good things for the City of Twin Falls.
1:49:45 Realtors recognize the need for updated city infrastructure,
1:49:51 for a successful school system and for great jobs.
1:49:56 They all go hand in hand.
1:49:58 We feel so strongly about it,
1:50:01 that we were able to give $10,000
1:50:03 to help promote and pass the sewer bond.
1:50:08 The trickle down effect of every home sale is huge
1:50:12 and it starts with the fix-up before the sale.
1:50:16 Paint, carpet, a plumber to fix the leak,
1:50:21 an electrician to install a new electric panel,
1:50:25 and maybe they gotta call the roofer for a new roof.
1:50:30 And when the buyers move in, it all starts over again.
1:50:34 A new fence, maybe some more new paint.
1:50:38 Mom gets new furniture and Dad gets a new lawn mower.
1:50:42 At the P&Z meeting, there was a concern
1:50:44 about allowing realtors, sign privileges that would create even more problems with the yard
1:50:50 sailors. The yard sale problem already exists. The real estate sale stimulates thousands of
1:50:58 dollars into the local economy and we use professional signs and take them down as they
1:51:03 are only up there for temporarily for an open house. If your home is around the corner in
1:51:10 to call the SAC down the lane, how do you direct traffic to your open house?
1:51:15 The homeowners need this option to place temporary signs and the real estate sign is one of the
1:51:21 most important tools we have.
1:51:24 So please consider this trickle-down effect on the economy from the sale of a home versus
1:51:30 with professional signage versus the effect that the yard sale has on the end economy with
1:51:38 a cardboard box sign.
1:51:40 Thank you.
1:51:41 Thank you, Bonnie.
1:51:42 Nathan Lidle.
1:51:43 Light up.
1:51:45 Here's the deal.
1:51:48 I think maybe you guys were doctors in your last life.
1:51:52 I just want to say go ahead.
1:51:55 I thought I printed clearly, but you're not the first one to mess that up.
1:52:03 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:52:04 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:52:08 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:52:15 Real Estate here in Twin Falls.
1:52:18 I just want to talk a little bit about the economic impact and contribution to Idaho,
1:52:23 a little bit broader.
1:52:24 The real estate industry accounted for $9 billion of the gross state product in 2011.
1:52:31 There's a multiplier effect that has been talked about before as far as income generated
1:52:37 from a house sale, without, because of the time limitations, I'm going to shorten it,
1:52:43 but the median price to home in Idaho is about $115,400. So the total income derived
1:52:48 from that sale has been estimated about $41,760 from the sale of that home. And the reason
1:52:54 that's important is when we look at our 2012, our National Association of Realtors has put
1:52:59 together a home buyer profile, a home buyer and sale profile.
1:53:04 And in this, they listed where buyers found the home that they purchased.
1:53:10 And number one is the internet, number two is the real estate agent, number three is the
1:53:13 yard sign slash open house sign.
1:53:16 It's obvious in this list of about ten different items that it's been an integral part of people
1:53:21 finding the home that they bought.
1:53:24 Furthermore, information sources that they used to find their home, number two and three
1:53:28 as yard signs and open house signs.
1:53:33 We feel that there were a large pillar in this economic foundation of this community and
1:53:40 that these signs are an integral part of our business that we've been using.
1:53:44 We hope that you'll consider allowing the proposal that we have put forth.
1:53:48 Thank you.
1:53:49 Thank you, Mr. Leita.
1:53:51 Brad Wills.
1:54:02 My name is Brad Wills at Tutu to Shown Street West in Twin Falls.
1:54:07 He's not listening.
1:54:09 He's talking.
1:54:09 She's got to record it.
1:54:10 It's recording.
1:54:11 It's recording.
1:54:12 OK.
1:54:14 So I'm the past president of the Home Builders Association.
1:54:17 And so we also deal in this.
1:54:20 And I'm going to digress for a minute.
1:54:23 Pinmanship with adults is terrible.
1:54:27 We are gathering names, unless, for the bond issue.
1:54:33 And we have to translate those into a master list.
1:54:37 And I am just appalled.
1:54:39 And when you stand up there, I think this guy did sign
1:54:43 the sheet, the Robinson, because there was no way I could
1:54:46 tell that that was Robinson.
1:54:49 But I blew it up several times, and I finally got it.
1:54:53 Well, thank you for backing me up.
1:54:54 And whatever I owe you, you got it.
1:54:58 Does that count in my two minutes?
1:55:00 No, it doesn't.
1:55:01 So the sign ordinance that we have is really good.
1:55:06 We did that as a community effort.
1:55:08 A lot of work went into that.
1:55:09 So what we have works pretty well.
1:55:12 This is mainly directed towards residential, it seems like.
1:55:15 Those are the areas that are a little bit away from traffic.
1:55:19 And I would think that for both the realtors, the builders,
1:55:24 and the developers, we all signage our properties.
1:55:27 But we always do it on our own property.
1:55:30 But this is a little unique situation.
1:55:32 So I think if this was done well, it was within the parkways
1:55:37 or it was within areas that don't affect public safety.
1:55:43 I would ask that you guys at least consider it,
1:55:46 and I think it would be, we're a small enough community,
1:55:49 this is what's nice about a small community,
1:55:51 is we can make decisions like this.
1:55:53 So with that, I will ask you to support it.
1:55:57 Thank you.
1:55:58 Thank you, Mr. Wilson.
1:55:59 Josh Hazen.
1:56:04 I even said it right. Gary Shook.
1:56:08 Mayor and City Council. My name is Gary Shook. I'm with Canyon Center One Realty.
1:56:17 And I would hope that you guys would support this amendment from the standpoint
1:56:21 that I don't do open houses very often, but when I do, even
1:56:25 with the most extensive proof and reproof of print ads
1:56:29 they can be inaccurate most of the time. And
1:56:33 these right here are what get people to our houses who,
1:56:37 from California, Oregon, Washington, I can't tell you how many times I had people
1:56:40 rolling with a fifth wheel, pulling a load of four wheelers, saying, hey, we just were
1:56:45 passing through, didn't realize how nice this town was, saw the open house sign, and
1:56:49 the next thing you know, they're calling you four months later, and they're gonna move here.
1:56:53 So to say that these aren't helping our industry would be, I mean, they're incredible.
1:56:59 So as much as I'm not, I don't enjoy the open houses, because it's better use of time.
1:57:06 My sellers depend on me to do the open houses because they believe them.
1:57:10 So therefore, I'm kind of at their mercy.
1:57:13 So I hope you guys would consider that information in your vote as well.
1:57:17 Thanks.
1:57:18 Thank you, Mr. Shook.
1:57:19 Beverly Shook.
1:57:20 Beverly Shook and I live in 1990, Campbell Ridge Drive.
1:57:30 And I work as a team at Canyon Sider and Realty Gary Shook and he told you he doesn't like
1:57:35 to do open houses.
1:57:37 So therefore, I'm the new agent.
1:57:39 I used to do the new stuff.
1:57:42 And I do use these.
1:57:43 And I'm excited about the education
1:57:46 that has been said that they would
1:57:49 do to share with the new agents how and where to put the signs.
1:57:54 My time is valuable as well as our client's time.
1:57:57 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:58:01 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:58:03 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:58:06 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:58:09 it's pretty much impossible for, even though I say the address,
1:58:12 and I tell people to get it on their navigation,
1:58:16 it's hard for them to find where we live.
1:58:18 So I use these for parties as well,
1:58:22 just place the little, you know,
1:58:24 should party on it,
1:58:26 but if I were to do an open house on any of those hammerhead locks,
1:58:31 it would be very important for me to be able to have a directional sign
1:58:34 to show whoever's driving and looking for that listing to look at it, they would be able to see where to go.
1:58:41 So, thank you for your time.
1:58:43 Thank you, Mr. Chair.
1:58:45 Francis Alves.
1:58:48 Alves. Alves. Alves.
1:58:52 You're on.
1:58:53 We can't have to sign in. Thank you for seeking.
1:58:55 I am a new agent. I've only been an agent since around 2010.
1:58:59 I do depend on the open houses for my business.
1:59:02 When I first started out, and even today in our office,
1:59:05 if an agent cannot afford to put the ad in,
1:59:08 a seasoned agent will pay for that ad,
1:59:11 and we host the open house.
1:59:13 It's a way of us giddy-glades,
1:59:15 hoping to potentially sell that home,
1:59:17 and I hope that you will consider passing this.
1:59:21 On a second thing, it will not hinder people
1:59:25 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:59:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:59:29 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:59:31 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:59:39 So I feel that our industry has been penalized when the yard sale people will still continue to do what they're doing.
1:59:45 So thank you.
1:59:46 Thank you.
1:59:47 Herk.
1:59:48 Oh, he did not want to come up.
1:59:51 Okay.
1:59:54 Herky alves.
1:59:56 How'd I do?
1:59:57 Good.
1:59:59 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:00 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:05 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:06 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:12 show people where the houses are at.
2:00:15 And I hope that you guys all consider that.
2:00:17 And yeah, Sean needs to do that sign in front of my house.
2:00:22 Thank you, sir.
2:00:23 Cesar Duran.
2:00:24 Mayor Council.
2:00:30 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:32 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:33 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:42 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:00:48 We didn't buy the house that we walked into for the open house, but we did end up buying the house because after talking to an agent and a lender, we ended up buying instead of renting.
2:00:59 So, now hosting open house signs, I still run into neighbors that come over, they're renting
2:01:05 the house down the street, and then they now they go from rent or into a buyer.
2:01:10 So, it doesn't only help, I mean it does help my pocket, but it also helps the clients and
2:01:15 the community out there to know that they can get into a home instead of renting.
2:01:19 So, I just hope you guys support this.
2:01:24 Thank you.
2:01:25 Lynn Ellis.
2:01:26 Ellis. Hi, my name is Lynn Ellis, 1154 East 900 South. I've been a realtor for three months,
2:01:39 so I'm in your report with the signs that weren't supposed to be there. I want to promise you that
2:01:47 that that won't happen again and I hope that you support me.
2:01:52 Thank you.
2:01:55 Yes, sir.
2:01:56 Lead of war.
2:02:04 Do for all.
2:02:07 You ask for it.
2:02:11 Mayor, City Council, I'm lead of war and I live in 4128 Metal Ridge in the area of impact.
2:02:19 Most of you know me from my other life but I am now realtor also.
2:02:22 also, in fact, I'm the president of the elected of the Association, so I'll be president next
2:02:27 year or so.
2:02:28 You're the past president, president.
2:02:29 And now you get me.
2:02:31 And my job was to come up kind of at the end and summarize some of this things and go
2:02:36 over some of the points again with you.
2:02:38 But since there's more people still to talk and since they covered the points pretty well,
2:02:42 I'm going to spare you that.
2:02:44 What I am going to do is talk about one thing that you haven't occurred tonight and haven't
2:02:50 seen.
2:02:51 And that is any citizens out here complaining about the science
2:02:54 or saying, don't do this, not one, not one.
2:03:00 So I don't think it's a specific issue.
2:03:02 I think it's a staff issue.
2:03:05 And the other thing that didn't get brought up,
2:03:09 I know it's in your packet, but there are areas in this town.
2:03:13 There are some areas where you cannot put signs
2:03:16 on private property and get them to an open house
2:03:19 as virtually impossible.
2:03:21 The other issue is that, I don't know if you noticed,
2:03:24 but people go away on the weekends and during the summer
2:03:27 and they're not there, so you knock on their door
2:03:29 to see if they'll let you put a sign up.
2:03:31 You can't do it, because there's no one there to talk to.
2:03:35 So as some of the people pointed out,
2:03:37 you may have paid for a really expensive ad
2:03:40 that just goes to waste, but you can't put up the signs
2:03:43 and get people into it.
2:03:46 The last thing I want to mention is that everybody here,
2:03:50 I'll be done.
2:03:51 Everybody here, although they work for Prudential, or Gateway, or what's there or somebody else,
2:03:58 their independent small business people, they represent themselves, what they sell is what
2:04:04 they make.
2:04:05 And so it's easy to look at these big companies and say, oh, well, they can do without it.
2:04:10 It's not big companies, it's individual realtors that are independent business people.
2:04:15 So thank you.
2:04:17 Thank you, Mr. Dvor.
2:04:18 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:04:19 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:04:36 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:04:41 [Muted for privacy: home address]
2:04:46 love looking at open houses. And I often get people saying, thank you for putting those
2:04:50 signs out so I could find your home. There's a lot of people that don't use GPS on their
2:04:54 phone, they still need help navigating around the town, and they're very, very beneficial.
2:05:00 As far as some of the things that the city laid out that were concerns, the site triangle.
2:05:06 As you see, this is not going to obstruct the site triangle.
2:05:10 These are the type of signs I use.
2:05:11 They're great.
2:05:12 I always have a moment of dread when I'm done with my open house to see if my signs are
2:05:17 still there.
2:05:18 Luckily, I haven't lost any of mine yet, but you know, this is what we're using.
2:05:24 not going to obstruct the site triangle. Also, as far as people coming out of the woodwork
2:05:29 and throwing signs everywhere and making a special request for a certain niche industry,
2:05:35 there already are laws on the books that are catering towards realtors. So, I don't
2:05:41 think that's an issue. People look forward to seeing those signs. We're just trying to
2:05:48 sell the homes, generate more revenue, and get the houses moved as quickly as possible.
2:05:54 Because we're taking time out of our Saturday to help sell these homes when we could be at
2:05:59 home with our family, relaxing.
2:06:02 But it's a necessary component of being a real estate agent and I strongly urge you to
2:06:07 support this change for everyone.
2:06:11 Anyway, that's it.
2:06:13 Thank you, Mr. Twiesen.
2:06:14 Ladies and gentlemen, that's all I have on our list up here.
2:06:18 Is there anyone else that now has a burning desire to come forward?
2:06:24 We hear from Brad all the time. I think Lucy should have.
2:06:30 Well, I'm going to close the public testimony portion of this.
2:06:37 We're going to keep it open so if we have questions of staff or even those that have made testimony,
2:06:43 we're going to allow that. But at this point, we're closing the public testimony and turning it over to.
2:06:48 Actually, we generally allow the applicant to do any rebuttal.
2:06:54 I'm not sure what she's going to rebut with the public death's money, but Nann, would you
2:06:58 like to come forward?
2:06:59 I don't have much else to say.
2:07:05 I want to thank everyone that has commented here tonight and would ask for your positive
2:07:10 vote on this.
2:07:11 I think it's a very important issue.
2:07:13 As Lee said, we are independent contractors just because there is Canyonside, Irwin, Prudential,
2:07:20 way over your door doesn't mean you get all the money.
2:07:25 Also, when we supported the water waste issue and I know probably, I won't say a percentage,
2:07:40 but many, many of us also in favor of the school bond issue, this community is growing
2:07:45 So much that in real estate, we need to have these vehicles to help us sell this real estate.
2:07:52 I think everybody else has said it very nicely and that's all I have to say.
2:07:56 Thank you, Mrs. Andy. We do have a light. Chris Stockington.
2:08:00 Jonathan, under the proposed zoning title amendment change,
2:08:04 was there any mention about ensuring that any such signage would be non-illuminated?
2:08:10 Bill of State signs right now are not allowed to be illuminated that's in the general sign code, but no in what day proposed it's not in there but it is somewhere else.
2:08:22 Well, just discussion among the Council since if this were eventually approved, I only have a concern that there may be so much success with the usage of the new placement of the signs that would be a tendency to push that few hours in the day toward the evening.
2:08:41 what has not been a side obstruction or triangulation problem has that potential,
2:08:47 especially under maybe rain or less in perfect conditions. So if there could be
2:08:53 some assurance that the placement of these signs does not allow any sort of
2:08:59 illumination either through AC or DC battery, I'd like to make sure that
2:09:06 but that's the case.
2:09:11 We're giving it just a moment, I think Mr. Humble is looking that up to give some feedback.
2:09:21 And is there an amendment, I mean, a ordinance number?
2:09:28 There's not an ordinance prepared yet.
2:09:30 It would require us to come back with an ordinance.
2:09:33 So if I can, so there's a provision under the prohibited signs in the code that talks about signs which move
2:09:43 and or animated by means of flashing traveling or blinking lights
2:09:46 or other means not providing constant illumination.
2:09:50 Is that the section that the illuminated signs is maybe into?
2:09:59 What section is that?
2:10:00 10, 9, 10.
2:10:03 Did you hear that match 10, 9, 10?
2:10:06 That's the whole issue we're dealing with, 10, 9.
2:10:08 So that restriction that Sean just referred to is about,
2:10:11 like blinking or flashing lights, and a constant illuminated
2:10:15 signed would be permitted under the current code with that section. I just
2:10:22 want to make sure there's would be a lot. Okay, so the section that Sean referred to
2:10:28 says these kinds of signs are not allowed, and it lists off a bunch of things in
2:10:34 there, and one of those is blinking or flashing lights, and it specifically
2:10:37 excludes constant illuminated signs from being prohibited, therefore a
2:10:43 a constant illumination would be allowed,
2:10:46 and we see a constant illumination would be allowed
2:10:50 under the current cycle, and we use that pretty regular,
2:10:52 actually, a lot of signs have constant illumination.
2:10:58 So that's not, in that section,
2:11:01 it doesn't necessarily prevent real estate sign
2:11:04 from being illuminated if it was a constant illumination,
2:11:07 just if it was flashing or blinking.
2:11:09 But I'm gonna jump through here
2:11:10 and see if I can find anything else.
2:11:12 Well, meanwhile, I'd like to get the motion on the floor
2:11:14 for further discussions.
2:11:15 So I'll move it for a moment.
2:11:17 Chris, I'm not at that stage yet.
2:11:18 We're still allowing, we're not at the deliberation stage
2:11:22 of the public hearing yet.
2:11:24 I'll allow you to do that when we get there.
2:11:26 Trust?
2:11:27 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
2:11:28 and you could make that specific prohibition
2:11:34 in this process if you wanted to move forward,
2:11:36 stating that there couldn't be any signless
2:11:40 a question to the public right away couldn't be eliminated as it's related to open house
2:11:45 science.
2:11:46 I mean, you could take that step to specifically prohibit it, therefore you'd be ensured that
2:11:51 it is covered as opposed to some other section of the code.
2:11:57 So that would be a simple fix to this regardless what it says anywhere else in the code.
2:12:02 Right, and what we would do is we would take your comments tonight and if instructed by
2:12:07 a majority of the council, we would prepare an ordinance for your review and consideration
2:12:11 at a subsequent meeting and we would expedite that through the process.
2:12:15 I don't see why we couldn't have something depending upon the complexity for the council's
2:12:19 consideration next week, if that was the direction of the council.
2:12:22 Very good.
2:12:23 I'm going to go ahead and turn over to Rebecca for a question.
2:12:28 Thank you, Mayor.
2:12:29 It was just more deliberation and comment.
2:12:30 Would you like me to wait on that?
2:12:31 Well, do we have any other questions for, because once we go into deliberation, we cannot
2:12:36 to ask any other questions other than to our city attorney.
2:12:41 Are there any other questions?
2:12:42 Okay, we are turning over to deliberation, Rebecca Melsoica.
2:12:47 Thank you, Mayor.
2:12:50 Appreciate all of the participation tonight.
2:12:54 It is apparent that the signs are important, and I agree with the majority of you said that it's not a big deal.
2:13:01 Probably won't create a problem.
2:13:02 I think there's a couple of issues that need to be addressed as far as ADA compliance.
2:13:07 I think that Ketchum actually has a good code in not allowing it on a sidewalk or pedestrian walkway.
2:13:15 I think that's a good idea.
2:13:16 I do want to point the council to the minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting where this was deliberated though.
2:13:23 They did have a thorough and lengthy discussion and I think that the commissioners really addressed some issues.
2:13:31 They pointed out that the current set of rules aren't being followed, which kind of points
2:13:35 to a disregard on the applicant's part for the current set of rules.
2:13:40 And they appreciated the thought of educating, but currently the rules aren't being followed.
2:13:47 And we even heard that in some of the testimony tonight, though some said that they will certainly
2:13:53 try to do better.
2:13:56 And I agree with some of the commission members that said, you know, we need to, and staff members
2:13:59 that said we need to keep the code consistent for the users and I personally don't have
2:14:06 a problem with the signs in the right away. I think that the sign code is not popular
2:14:12 with citizens. I don't think it's a citizen initiative. Obviously no one spoke against
2:14:19 having the signs but I do believe that we should be consistent and allow all types of
2:14:25 of different signs, you know, there are people who do estate sales that make their living
2:14:30 off of estate sales, and that was brought up by Commissioner Munoz, there are different
2:14:35 types of businesses, craft fairs, concerts, events, things like that.
2:14:42 They also brought up the issues that they really felt like the code, if amended, should be
2:14:52 more inclusive, which I would concur with.
2:14:56 I think that I could be supportive of an amendment that is not specific to real estate signs but
2:15:04 allows political signs, which we all know and have to put out, and it is difficult.
2:15:10 I think that Mr. Divor's comment is very true that in some people's private property, if
2:15:17 they're in the site tingle, they cannot put a sign on their own private property.
2:15:22 to the sign code.
2:15:23 So I believe there's some difficulties with the sign code.
2:15:26 I believe it needs amended.
2:15:28 I would be in support of directing staff to bring some ordinance that would maybe be more
2:15:33 inclusive and this is in concurrence with the planning and zoning commission board.
2:15:41 And I do want to point out, I know that Fritz addressed that there is no legal conflict
2:15:45 of interest but for me two of the commissioners that voted yes, voted in favor, it was a three,
2:15:51 four vote, but two of those three voting in favor were real estate agents.
2:15:55 And I just don't see how you can belong to the association that is the applicant of the amendment,
2:16:03 and it not be a conflict.
2:16:05 So I would feel better about supporting an ordinance that was more inclusive of all different types of advertising,
2:16:14 commercial advertising that is.
2:16:16 Thank you Rebecca.
2:16:17 Chris, do you want to make your motion?
2:16:19 At least to get up with the discussion which we're having now, but I would authorize the
2:16:24 zoning title amendment change to code 1099K, dealing with real estate signs, allowing temporary
2:16:33 roll of state open house signs in the public right away, under I think there were three
2:16:37 specified conditions, plus an additional one not allowing illumination of those signs.
2:16:43 We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking to him seconded by Jim Mundt to
2:16:51 well you heard it it's there great landing well here in the other the other
2:16:59 comment I'm more I'm more along the line of I think it would be better if we we
2:17:06 do approve this that we keep it specific and we have each individual group
2:17:11 coming and present their case for what it would be I am certainly not in
2:17:16 in favor of allowing political science in the right away.
2:17:19 If you've ever been to Seattle, Washington,
2:17:21 when a city election is going on,
2:17:23 and every public right away may have 10 signs
2:17:27 from the same person in it,
2:17:29 it gets ridiculous up there,
2:17:31 and I will never vote for allowance of political science
2:17:36 in the public right away.
2:17:37 I think that we have plenty of time
2:17:40 in which to line up private property for science to be,
2:17:44 but I would be in favor of the amendment or the motion as presented.
2:17:50 Hey, great.
2:17:51 Suzanne Hawkins.
2:17:53 I would like to make an amendment to the motion
2:17:57 that we set our guidelines something like 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.
2:18:02 to make sure that the signs aren't up in the evening
2:18:05 or whatever.
2:18:07 I'll just say 9 to 9 now.
2:18:09 I understand the realtors here don't want to work extra hours
2:18:12 but you don't know what's going to come in the future of somebody who might want to try something new and have a
2:18:16 Late night open house. I'd just like to make sure it's daylight hours
2:18:19 Well, maybe just as a recommendation if that's your motion say daylight hours
2:18:24 Okay, it's 9 p.m. Okay certain times here is that's true daylight hours
2:18:29 So we have a motion on the floor to amend the motion to only allow
2:18:34 the signs during daylight hours
2:18:36 hours. I'll I'll second it just because I want to ask a couple questions about
2:18:42 the motion. Very good. We have motion on floor by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by
2:18:47 Greg Lanting. I have a couple of lights before you.
2:18:51 I was under the impression and maybe I'm looking at it incorrectly that they
2:19:02 were only asking for with the specific times that the open house was being going on. And
2:19:12 so does if that were the case, I'm not sure at the time limit is necessary. I don't have
2:19:18 any problem of adding that because it makes it even more restrictive than that because if
2:19:22 somebody did want to have one until nine o'clock in February, they wouldn't be able to. So that
2:19:27 makes it even more restrictive. So I don't have any problem voting yes on the men. But
2:19:30 But I thought it did limit it to their times, and they had to pick them up just as soon as
2:19:38 those times were up.
2:19:39 They did propose five hours per day, but it doesn't say during when.
2:19:43 And actually, that thought came listening to Councilman talking to and talking about the
2:19:48 lighted signs and evening hours and blocking.
2:19:50 And that was my only thought.
2:19:51 Like I said, I'm sure that most realtors don't want to work that hour, but just you
2:19:56 never know what's going to come down the future, and I'd rather put the sideboards up
2:19:59 now.
2:20:01 Thank you, Susanne, Schomburg.
2:20:04 Thank you, Mayor.
2:20:05 So in listening to the comments tonight, this is nothing new.
2:20:12 And truthfully, I don't fault the real estate community
2:20:16 for continuing to do this, even though it
2:20:18 was a violation of the code for some time.
2:20:20 I actually commend you for coming forward with a solution
2:20:23 instead of just continuing to break the rules
2:20:25 and hope you don't get caught.
2:20:27 So I think this is a positive step.
2:20:33 The real estate industry is a unique critter
2:20:37 and it really does drive so much of our economy
2:20:40 that I think we do need to look at it
2:20:43 a little differently in how you're showcasing that product.
2:20:47 You can't put the house up in the front window
2:20:49 of your storefront and expect people to come by it.
2:20:53 It just doesn't work that way.
2:20:55 I'm really not confident that this does create confusion.
2:20:59 One, it's been happening against the rules
2:21:03 for some period of time.
2:21:04 And I don't see all kinds of other signs going up
2:21:07 on sidewalks and in right of way all over town.
2:21:10 And secondly, it actually is you can put signs up
2:21:15 in the right of way downtown.
2:21:17 That's a provision of the code.
2:21:18 You can put sandwich signs up in the right of way
2:21:20 on Main Street.
2:21:22 And that's been happening and again I don't see folks all over the rest of town trying
2:21:27 to do that and emulate that so I really don't see that's an issue.
2:21:32 I do firmly believe that we need to protect public safety and I think making sure that
2:21:39 these signs can be placed in such a way that doesn't block access to the sidewalk, block
2:21:45 access to that ADA compliance and doesn't cause a site obstruction, but again I think it would
2:21:55 be a reach to say that signs this size are a site obstruction in the community. I almost
2:22:02 feel this is a bit of a solution looking for a problem from the enforcement perspective and
2:22:11 Again, I want to commend the real estate community for coming together with a reasonable solution
2:22:18 and for your willingness to help educate and keep your agents in compliance with it.
2:22:27 I think if there are opportunities to not put those signs on the sidewalk and you can knock on the door of the neighbor
2:22:34 and say, can I put that there, you should try to do that.
2:22:37 I don't think there should be a blank check to go stick them, you know, as close as you possibly can get them, but I do think that this is something that really does need to be supported to support that industry that drives the economy so much.
2:22:56 And with some, you know, with some of these other items that were brought up like estate sales, you know, I see auction signs up that are directing you how to get there.
2:23:06 you how to get there.
2:23:07 Maybe those are other areas we need to think about
2:23:10 if there is a huge demand for it.
2:23:13 But this is a pretty solid group of folks here
2:23:16 with a broad reach in the industry.
2:23:19 And some of these other things like craft fairs
2:23:21 and concerts in advance, there are provisions
2:23:22 in the code that allow for those signs of readiness.
2:23:25 So I do think that this is something we need
2:23:28 to move forward with and certainly
2:23:31 with support of this evening.
2:23:34 You know, I've really struggled with supporting this on several fronts.
2:23:42 I really look at it as a public safety and accessibility issue.
2:23:46 I look at it as a safety issue, or excuse me, a fairness issue with other businesses.
2:23:55 And then I look at it as a aesthetic issue.
2:23:58 But as I was rolling my garbage can and recycling,
2:24:04 then back to my house the other day,
2:24:07 it dawned upon me, I was blocking the sidewalk,
2:24:11 and it was blocking the visual,
2:24:13 it was blocking accessibility,
2:24:17 and it's for a period of time
2:24:19 so that our garbage can be picked up.
2:24:22 Not saying this is garbage,
2:24:23 okay, but it's, and it blocks way more
2:24:27 than any of these signs ever dreamed of blocking.
2:24:31 So it kind of made me realize that,
2:24:35 you know, for a temporary basis,
2:24:37 I like the amendment that was made for daylight hours.
2:24:40 I think this is, I think this is a fair and just amendment
2:24:47 and I will be voting in support of it.
2:24:52 Is there anything further on the amendment?
2:24:56 Question on the amendment.
2:24:57 What's that?
2:24:58 You just saying question.
2:24:59 Okay, very good. Thank you, Chris.
2:25:01 Leila, roll call vote on the amendment.
2:25:04 Daylight hours.
2:25:05 Jim Munn. Yes.
2:25:07 Sean Berriger. No.
2:25:10 Chris Tockman. Yes. Greg Lantane. Yes.
2:25:14 Don Hall. Yes.
2:25:16 Rebecca Milsuelka. Yes.
2:25:19 Suzanne Hockman. Yes.
2:25:20 Motion passes, six to one.
2:25:23 Now to the main motion.
2:25:27 Leila, roll call vote, please.
2:25:30 Sean Berriger. Yes.
2:25:32 Yes.
2:25:33 Greg Lanting.
2:25:34 Yes.
2:25:35 Don Hall.
2:25:36 Yes.
2:25:37 Rebecca Masoika.
2:25:38 No.
2:25:39 Suzanne Hawkins.
2:25:40 Yes.
2:25:41 Jim Mundt.
2:25:42 Yes.
2:25:43 Motion passes 6-1.
2:25:45 Congratulations.
2:25:46 You have your amendment.
2:25:48 And that would be Bienkraut back this year.
2:25:51 Is there anything further from Council this evening?
2:25:58 I'm Chris Fauchington.
2:26:00 Again, I think the suggestion was made by the Realtors and I'd like to follow up on that.
2:26:04 I'd like to have a report back from Sean within a reasonable period of time of weather
2:26:11 and factor realtors that are continuing to police their pick out of the signs.
2:26:16 I know you will, but all those nodding heads there.
2:26:19 Is that a fair question?
2:26:21 Okay.
2:26:22 That or even my request?
2:26:23 Very good Chris.
2:26:24 That sounds fair to me.
2:26:26 All right council just want to remind you that our council pitcher will be next Monday
2:26:32 at 3 30 at Addison Photography meetings adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 141 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 190 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 261 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 3, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:27:30.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
c00ed5eb21b0c7fae544689f88cd9a95182524f328cacc3b3a9e4326fa0c9878 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 49 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
1d8b095c5a33227946a7823e630669348129b58c20f2d11573d923166207bc71
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file