City Council meeting
Monday, February 24, 2014
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Moments cited in findings and the timeline
Transcript
0:04:02 like to call the meaning of the Twin Falls City Council to order. It's Monday, February 24th, 2014
0:04:08 and welcome everyone in the audience and those coming to present and those just
0:04:13 coming to watch the festivities of the day. We always start our meetings off
0:04:19 with the Pledge of Allegiance and we are honored to have three of our local Boy Scouts
0:04:23 that will come up and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance so those of you
0:04:27 wishing to please join us.
0:04:29 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:04:55 Thank you very much and I've already talked to these young men and they kind of know what to do so.
0:05:01 One at a time come on up to the podium.
0:05:05 Alrighty, my name is Brian Lawrence. I am an Eagle Scout, so I'm just here for a moral support for these guys.
0:05:12 These guys are working on the communications merit badge.
0:05:20 We're from the 74th troop, and we meet at the Harrison Building.
0:05:30 Perfect, thank you.
0:05:34 My name is Sean Keaster. I'm here participating in the communication
0:05:39 where I badge. Thank you Sean. My name is Chris Crozier. I'm
0:05:44 2 74 star link also for communications. Very good. Thank you
0:05:48 Chris and I told all three boys that they can't get their
0:05:51 communication badge unless they communicate. So we appreciate
0:05:54 them very much. Oh no Mayor I think we've heard from the home
0:05:57 meeting over to the Eagles County probably run up with a
0:06:00 great deal of expertise. I think he probably run the better
0:06:02 We need better than any of us.
0:06:04 So I really appreciate that.
0:06:06 I want to confirm that we do have a quorum
0:06:08 of the city council.
0:06:09 All seven members are here this evening
0:06:11 and turn it over to Travis Rothwiler
0:06:14 on considerations of any amendments to the agenda.
0:06:17 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:06:19 there are no additions to the agenda,
0:06:21 but we'd like to maybe change some of the orders
0:06:23 we kind of move forward this evening.
0:06:26 The two items as we would like to flip flop items number two
0:06:29 And then item number three, we need to be a bit flexible on.
0:06:37 Mr. Morris is on an active call right now.
0:06:41 And so what we'll do is we'll continue to move down the progression
0:06:45 of the agenda items and when he comes here,
0:06:47 maybe fall into the next available slot thereafter
0:06:51 if he misses his rank in the queue.
0:06:55 Thank you, Travis.
0:06:55 There's no need to do any kind of a,
0:06:57 because we're just shifting around.
0:07:01 Just keep me honest regarding three and keep moving down and when Ed gets here, if someone can give me the high sign, hopefully I'll see him come in.
0:07:08 Next on and on the agenda is general input from the public. There's anyone here that would like to address the council this evening on an unrelated item that's not on the agenda tonight. This is your time to do that.
0:07:22 to do that.
0:07:25 I see no one running towards the podium,
0:07:26 so we're going to move down to the next item,
0:07:28 which is the consent calendar,
0:07:30 and turn that over to the council wishes.
0:07:34 Chris Stockton.
0:07:35 I do have one question on the accounts payable for, Cited in E-31
0:07:38 let's say, account number 12, 193, page 14.
0:07:42 That's bank in New York, 715,000.
0:07:45 That's all related to the bond issue.
0:07:47 I was wondering if that's all, I'm sorry.
0:07:51 No, go ahead.
0:07:52 I'm just wondering if there's any anomalies
0:07:54 and amount we're paying or why we're paying that this time.
0:07:59 Lori, raise.
0:08:01 Chris, that's a principal payment on existing debt.
0:08:05 Existing.
0:08:05 Yes.
0:08:06 Nothing on the new.
0:08:08 Right.
0:08:09 Thank you.
0:08:11 Anything further, any other questions on the consent calendar?
0:08:14 Or is there, oh, Travis?
0:08:16 Maybe just a quick, maybe, addition to that.
0:08:22 All of the fees associated with the new debt
0:08:26 that we just issued, we'll be taking out of the proceeds.
0:08:30 And so we will get a net number placed
0:08:32 into our construction account.
0:08:34 And so all of those cost of issuance
0:08:36 will be taken off the front.
0:08:38 The net amount will be placed into our construction account.
0:08:42 And next week, Lori Race is going
0:08:44 to be doing a presentation on the amount of funds.
0:08:48 I guess she's doing it later on tonight.
0:08:49 She's going to describe the amount of funds
0:08:51 that are available for construction.
0:08:55 Great landing.
0:09:00 Is there a way the local citizens I know they're usually are tax-free bonds.
0:09:05 Is there a way for local citizens to participate in buying those if there is a minimum that they or who they would contact.
0:09:12 Lori?
0:09:13 If there was any interest they would need to contact Cameron Ariel with science bank before the issuance.
0:09:24 Thank you.
0:09:26 Okay, I'll turn it over to council wishes on the consent calendar.
0:09:31 Greg, move the roll.
0:09:32 Second.
0:09:34 We have a motion on floor by Greg Lanning, seconded by Sean Berger, anything further on the motion to approve the same count of the council.
0:09:43 I see no lights.
0:09:44 Layallin, roll call vote please.
0:09:45 Suzanne Hopkins.
0:09:47 Yes.
0:09:48 Jim Mon.
0:09:48 Yes.
0:09:49 Sean Berger.
0:09:50 Yes.
0:09:51 Chris Talking.
0:09:52 Yes.
0:09:53 Greg Lanning.
0:09:54 Yes.
0:09:54 Don Hall.
0:09:55 Yes.
0:09:55 Rebecca Milse, yes.
0:09:57 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:09:59 Moving to items for consideration, those of you wishing to, there's agendas at the back of the room.
0:10:04 you can follow along. The first item is consideration of a request to waive the residency requirement
0:10:11 for Dan Homestead during the last 18 months of his second term on the airport advisory board
0:10:17 and we have Bill Carberry, our airport manager. Thank you very good evening council members.
0:10:22 Welcome. Dan Homestead is here tonight. I was first appointed to the board by the city council
0:10:28 in 2009, and then reappointed for a second and final term.
0:10:33 They're allowed to consecutive terms on a board out there.
0:10:36 So he was reappointed in 2009.
0:10:39 Speaking with Dan recently, he said, hey, Bill,
0:10:41 I'm moving out of the city, you know, the county.
0:10:44 And that'll be happening later this spring.
0:10:47 What does that do to my position on the board?
0:10:49 So after speaking with the city attorney, it was made,
0:10:56 he made me aware that there's a section,
0:10:58 2.11 where the council has the ability to waive a residency requirement.
0:11:04 So Dan's got about a year and a half left on his second term.
0:11:08 And so I would strongly encourage you to allow him that waiver in this incident.
0:11:14 Dan's been an excellent board member, he's been very keen, particularly with our service issues.
0:11:19 And economic development in the community has been a great contributor to the board.
0:11:23 So I would recommend the council waive that for his last year and a half for a second term.
0:11:30 And Dan is a pilot himself.
0:11:32 He is correct.
0:11:33 And cracker jack flight instructors.
0:11:35 Wow.
0:11:36 Just that's the way you want to cracker jack.
0:11:39 Right?
0:11:40 Council, any questions?
0:11:43 Chris, talk.
0:11:44 Move that we would waive the residence requirement for a Dan's own stead to continue to serve on
0:11:50 the advisory board for the airport.
0:11:53 I have a motion on board by Chris talking it seconded by Greg Lanting on this apparent
0:12:00 Controversial
0:12:04 Agenda anything further on the motion council
0:12:07 We island roll call vote, please Jim on yes
0:12:12 Sean Baraker. Yes, it's talking to yes
0:12:15 Greg Lanting yes
0:12:17 Don Hall. Yes
0:12:19 Rebecca Milseika. Yes
0:12:21 Susan Hawkins yes motion passes seven to zero congratulations Dan and I want to
0:12:27 tell you thank you for all the things you do in our community actually I don't
0:12:30 think we say that enough to you you're on about every committee that I know of
0:12:34 or have been and and generally the leadership of those committees so thank
0:12:38 you for everything you do for us we are moving number five item on the agenda
0:12:45 up now keep me honest here Travis I think that's right so we are going to
0:12:50 The consideration of the request to authorize the mayor to sign the sub-agreement material
0:12:55 purchase contract for the local Falls Avenue intersection improvement, key number 13-5-4-4,
0:13:02 and approve payments of local match and we have our city engineer Jackie Fields.
0:13:07 Welcome, Jackie.
0:13:08 Good evening.
0:13:09 Last year we applied for three local highway safety improvement projects and we were awarded
0:13:15 two of them.
0:13:17 This project was not awarded.
0:13:19 It was not awarded primarily because the local highway technical assistance council was working
0:13:25 with I-T-D and the feds to try to make a streamlined small process for these really small jobs.
0:13:32 And this qualifies into the very small job category.
0:13:36 So they didn't execute our agreement.
0:13:37 They sent back the city's $1,000 check.
0:13:40 They pooled the sign project with several other communities.
0:13:46 So they're making a mass purchase of signs and posts, and they have resubmitted to us and
0:13:54 that looks a lot like an award of a contract, but it's actually called a sub agreement in
0:13:59 the state's language because we're part of a materials purchase.
0:14:03 So they're asking us to basically do what we had originally volunteered to do, which is
0:14:08 install stop bars and larger stop signs along Falls Avenue between Washington and Blue Lakes
0:14:15 and to contribute $1,000 towards the match.
0:14:18 And if we don't actually use all of that money,
0:14:22 then eventually they return it through the accounting process.
0:14:25 So the recommendation from staff tonight
0:14:29 is to authorize the mayor to sign the sub-agreement
0:14:33 for local Falls Avenue intersection improvements
0:14:36 key 13544 and approved payment of $1,000 towards the match.
0:14:41 The beauty of this deal is that we don't
0:14:43 to pass a resolution. That's one other small difference.
0:14:47 Very good. Thank you, Jackie. Any questions for our city engineer?
0:14:53 Suzanne Hawkins. I'm ready to make a motion. Go.
0:14:56 I move that we authorize the mayor to sign the sub agreement to purchase the materials for
0:15:01 Falls Avenue intersection key number 3544 and approve pavement of the local match of $1,000.
0:15:08 We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Jim Munn.
0:15:16 Anything further on that motion council?
0:15:20 I see no lights.
0:15:21 The aye will roll call vote.
0:15:23 Sean Burger.
0:15:24 Yes.
0:15:25 Chris Tocchinsen.
0:15:26 Yes.
0:15:27 Greg Lantine.
0:15:28 Yes.
0:15:29 Don Hall.
0:15:30 Yes.
0:15:31 Rebecca Milsoica.
0:15:32 Yes.
0:15:33 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:15:34 Yes.
0:15:35 Jim Munn.
0:15:36 Yes.
0:15:37 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:15:38 Jackie, I do have a real quick question.
0:15:40 session at Fillmore and North College, the lights seem to be up, seem like everything's
0:15:47 ready to rock and roll, but they're not activated yet. They haven't activated. What's the timetable
0:15:53 for that? Are you aware?
0:15:57 Yes. I'm aware of the timetable. So we are coordinating with Northwest Signal to come
0:16:05 down and actually do the start up make sure everything actually works and provide the training.
0:16:09 And what does that mean?
0:16:14 I'm trying to remember the actual date. I can't remember. I just wrote an email about this like last week and I can't remember what I said.
0:16:27 What do they have to provide training? What is that?
0:16:31 The controllers are changing, slightly the technology is changing a little bit.
0:16:37 Our controllers are actually obsolete, so as we bring a new signal on, they're just required
0:16:44 to train, period to say, this is it, how this particular unit works.
0:16:48 And then over time the training curve drops off to nothing, but our controllers are new.
0:16:55 And they also are required to stay on there and do the startup test and make sure that it
0:16:59 follows through all of the logic and if the logic is messed up then they're
0:17:04 right there they can fix it which is really nice. Great mining. So it's a
0:17:10 little more than just flipping the switch there. Everything has to because
0:17:14 it's not it's a it's a smart light in other words as compared to the dumb one
0:17:18 we bought for that for down at what pole in that one time just to get us through
0:17:21 the start of the school year. That's accurate. Okay. Yeah. Difference between a
0:17:27 a dumb phone and a smart phone.
0:17:29 Well, it takes a little bit of doing it.
0:17:31 And you want to make sure that it's
0:17:33 going to behave the way it's supposed to behave like when
0:17:36 you use the pre-empt.
0:17:36 It works so that in a fire truck hitting somebody years ago.
0:17:44 It's a good point.
0:17:45 It's an important thing.
0:17:47 So I'm assuming that Mike Sullivan will be intimately
0:17:51 involved in this, because he seems to be at all those.
0:17:53 Yes.
0:17:54 OK.
0:17:54 He's the lucky one.
0:17:55 So and he is the one that informed me of the date
0:17:58 that Northwest it's scheduled to come down and I think soon that's good
0:18:07 no for me yeah okay I'm sorry it is next Monday next Monday I think that's
0:18:16 with Chris yeah excellent we have the best scoop but I didn't want to put you
0:18:21 on the spot I should have sent it to the council all right thank you Jackie
0:18:27 You appreciate it.
0:18:28 It's soon, no.
0:18:29 It's soon.
0:18:30 Very good.
0:18:32 Thank you.
0:18:33 So it looks like we will be moving to item number three next, which is consideration of
0:18:41 a request to approve a letter of support for SB 1273 firefighter presumptive illness, because
0:18:48 I think we saw Ed Morris come in.
0:18:51 Maybe you can tell us what the answer was.
0:18:54 Welcome again.
0:18:55 Ed.
0:18:56 as late we were on a call. Greg wants to know what the call was. I've got one damn most
0:19:03 change. Well I'm back. Ed Morris to impulse firefighter
0:19:11 local 1556 president. I sent you an email on those questions that you guys had
0:19:19 hopefully you had a chance to read them. We're just back again second meeting
0:19:24 asking for a letter of support for Senate bill 1273. Very good. Any questions? Jim
0:19:31 one here. Well, I'm but I think it was fairly well vetted last week. I certainly
0:19:38 had an opportunity to do some research and I certainly supported so I'm ready to
0:19:43 make a motion. I think that's appropriate. I will move to approve the letter to
0:19:51 support Senate bill 1273 the firefighters presumptive illness bill.
0:20:00 motion on floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Sean Merigert.
0:20:04 Do we have any discussion regarding this motion?
0:20:06 Looks like we do.
0:20:07 Suzanne Nockens.
0:20:08 I just want to say thank you for the follow up email.
0:20:11 It helped answer a lot of my questions, and it gave me a chance to do a little more research online.
0:20:15 I did go to the state's website and read through the bill again.
0:20:18 And I apologize for not being prepared the first time you sent it to us, but
0:20:23 I do understand now and it does make sense.
0:20:25 And thank you for your persistence in educating us.
0:20:28 I appreciate it.
0:20:29 Thank you for your time.
0:20:30 Chris talking.
0:20:31 Yeah, one of our primary concerns last time
0:20:34 was the budgetary impact.
0:20:35 And just for the public, they should know what we know,
0:20:39 that the average impact on overall department budgets
0:20:43 in the state is a 1 10th of a percent to 44 hundreds of 1%,
0:20:47 which translated dollars as 48 and a half thousand
0:20:52 to 165,000, I'm assuming that's annual, isn't it?
0:20:57 of all Idaho government entities.
0:21:01 It's minimal, and as I told you before,
0:21:03 I certainly support it.
0:21:05 I look at it akin to we veterans
0:21:08 who work either around hazardous nuclear components
0:21:12 or Agent Orange for Vietnam vets.
0:21:15 And government needs to protect those of you
0:21:17 who have walked in harm's way.
0:21:21 Thank you, Chris.
0:21:22 Rebecca, Mel, so I can.
0:21:23 Thank you, Mayor.
0:21:24 Thank you for your presentation.
0:21:25 I've kind of gone back and forth on this bill.
0:21:28 It's an interesting bill.
0:21:29 I think it is well written.
0:21:31 I think that it goes through the occupational diseases and I can certainly support those.
0:21:35 I think that they're unique to firefighters.
0:21:39 I think the only thing that I'm a little hesitant about is the list of cancers and that's just
0:21:44 because they are so common, breast cancer, testicular cancer and I don't think it'll
0:21:50 make a huge difference.
0:21:52 everyone's saying it's you know I think it's a good bill. The question is whether
0:21:59 to endorse it though and I'm kind of struggling with that and so I'm not
0:22:03 necessarily against it but I think like the Association of Idaho City is a just
0:22:07 want to stay neutral on it but certainly I wish you the best of luck.
0:22:10 Thank you and I have a question regarding I certainly understand the
0:22:18 hazard type part of my background was firefighting as well of these chemicals
0:22:23 and the like that are floating around when you're going into a building with the plastics and
0:22:27 everything else that you have to deal with.
0:22:30 Where are we at with technology as far as your turnouts and clothing to be able to help shield
0:22:36 our firefighters a little bit better?
0:22:38 Actually the IAF, the Idaho or the International Fire Chiefs and then some other groups are
0:22:45 together.
0:22:46 They're working on what they call positive pressure turnouts where your exhalation air
0:22:50 goes in and creates a positive pressure inside, which will help keep some of the
0:22:55 smoke out. That would be good. They're not on the market yet. So it's coming. With our
0:23:02 respiratory protection, we're well protected and our department does a
0:23:05 really good job of ensuring that we wear those at the right times. So breathing
0:23:11 it in isn't as big a deal as it used to be, but it's like absorption through the
0:23:16 scam. Yeah, like I stated last time and we were just talking today, there's days when
0:23:20 When you go in real thick black smoke, you go back to the station and your legs are black
0:23:24 just from stuff infiltrating up through your turnouts.
0:23:29 What about the turnouts themselves that we have now?
0:23:32 Do we do annual cleaning of those because I'm assuming these chemicals are residual.
0:23:36 They stay with them.
0:23:37 Well, we clean them on a regular basis.
0:23:40 We're supposed to clean them after every structure fire when they're dirty and we take
0:23:44 real good care of them.
0:23:45 We inspect them on a semi-annual basis, at least.
0:23:48 Most people more than that.
0:23:49 I look them over every morning, but, okay, very good.
0:23:54 Answer my question, Greg Lenny.
0:23:55 Well, yeah, I would like to thank you again
0:23:58 for the opportunity you presented to me,
0:24:00 and I know you have other councils to go up
0:24:02 and do the fire training demonstration
0:24:05 for one of a better word up in the Meridian,
0:24:07 at their unbelievable facility, by the way, for training.
0:24:11 And making sure that we're still on track,
0:24:14 I know we do, we place things on a certain schedule,
0:24:18 but I certainly noticed the difference
0:24:20 between their tanks and our tanks
0:24:23 as far as the weight of the tanks
0:24:24 and the capacity of the tanks and those kinds of things.
0:24:27 And make sure I'm through my support
0:24:29 that when it's time to replace that schedule's up.
0:24:33 We definitely, it's something we don't want to skip.
0:24:35 We want to move to those bigger,
0:24:37 more capacity lighter tanks
0:24:39 that would certainly provide additional safety.
0:24:41 And so I'm certainly in favor of that for future budgets.
0:24:44 You're good, thank you, Greg.
0:24:46 Hi.
0:24:47 Oh, Chris, talk to you.
0:24:47 Right to make a motion unless somebody else wanted to comment we have a motion. They were just making comments
0:24:52 Must be the chemicals I didn't know
0:24:55 All legal
0:25:01 Anything further on this motion council the air could we please have a roll call please Chris talking ten yes
0:25:08 Great landing. Yes, don Hall. Yes, I think the mils like a abstain
0:25:17 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
0:25:19 Jim on yes
0:25:21 Yes.
0:25:22 Motion passes six in favor one abstention.
0:25:28 Moving on to the next item, thank you for your support.
0:25:32 Thank you.
0:25:33 Thank you.
0:25:34 Moving on to the next item, we're going to number four now, which is an update on the
0:25:37 $38 million bond issuance for the voter approved project improvements at the city's wastewater
0:25:45 treatment plan.
0:25:46 We have our finance director, Lori race.
0:25:49 Welcome, Lori.
0:25:57 Good evening, Mayor and City Council.
0:25:59 So tonight I'd like to visit with you about our bond issuance, and I'd also like to share
0:26:05 just a little bit of background with you, in particular why we use the bond bank and the
0:26:11 different sales.
0:26:12 I promise it won't be a terrible, painful lesson.
0:26:16 So we use the Idaho bond bank because they have easy access to the capital markets.
0:26:24 By issuing debt through the bond bank, we benefit by a better interest rate.
0:26:30 Because of their access, because of their credit rating, we can get better interest rates.
0:26:36 And their credit rating is typically rated AA1, which is high grade for long term debt.
0:26:43 The only thing that's better is AAA, and that's considered prime.
0:26:47 We get the benefit of having lower underwriting costs.
0:26:51 Because of the pledge of state shared revenues being an attractive feature for bond buyers,
0:26:58 it can result in lower interest rates.
0:27:02 And there are two kinds of sales, negotiated and competitive.
0:27:07 And a negotiated sale is typically what the city has done in the past.
0:27:12 And you use a negotiated sale when you need to explain the terms of the sale.
0:27:18 It's not straightforward.
0:27:20 competitive sale is one where straight forward, easily explainable, you don't have to talk
0:27:28 to the bond buyers about it, and it typically results in the best rates.
0:27:33 And the city has used this for the last two sales.
0:27:39 So on February 12th, we sold bonds.
0:27:43 The total issuance through the Idaho bond bank was $51.6 million.
0:27:49 There's some interesting facts I want to share.
0:27:52 So there have been 182 bond cells in Idaho since 1990, and this was the largest competitive
0:27:58 cell.
0:27:59 We had 12 bidders as the closing seconds ticked down, and that was also a record for the state
0:28:05 of Idaho.
0:28:06 I'll just share with you that I'm watching it on my computer, and we start out with
0:28:12 two bids, and then one, because you're watching the clock and you're, you know, they're putting
0:28:18 out their bids.
0:28:19 And then we had six, then we had three.
0:28:22 And by the end of the sale, boom, 12.
0:28:26 So it's kind of exciting for me.
0:28:29 So the 12 was also a record for the state of Idaho.
0:28:33 When the sale was over, we had interest rates ranging from 3.47%.
0:28:48 So those rates were ranging from 3.47% to 3.73%
0:28:56 on the total issuance.
0:28:58 So these are the bidders and then the interest rates.
0:29:03 So the difference between the lowest and the highest bid
0:29:09 is going to result in a savings of over $5 million
0:29:13 in total costs of interest over the life of the debt.
0:29:18 Because the city share of that debt
0:29:20 has a shorter duration than the other bonding entity,
0:29:23 we're only going for 20 years.
0:29:25 We ended up with a true interest cost of 3.31%.
0:29:30 Now, this is a little bit higher than what we were projecting last March,
0:29:35 but it's lower than what we were seeing in the fall.
0:29:38 In fact, this is the lowest rate since July of 2013.
0:29:45 One more thing I'd like to share with you, and I have talked about this before,
0:29:49 is the surety policy that we were able to obtain.
0:29:52 So accrediting is an evaluation of a credit worthiness of a debtor, and it's made by a rating
0:30:01 agency on the debtor's ability to pay back the debt and the likelihood of default.
0:30:07 The rating represents the rating agency's evaluation of qualitative and quantitative information
0:30:13 for the entity, no mathematical formulas.
0:30:16 They use their judgment and experience in determining what information should be considered
0:30:21 in giving a rating. So AGM issued the City of Twin Falls, a bond surety policy, without
0:30:29 going through the process or expense of having to be rated. Their executive director told Cameron
0:30:35 area of the science bank, we couldn't not do it. If we had not been able to obtain this
0:30:51 policy, what you're looking at are the bonds we sold, they were sold at a premium, and then
0:30:59 the what's going to be deposited to our construction fund and the list of expenses.
0:31:06 And I've circled the Shirdi bond policy of $226,460.
0:31:13 If we hadn't been able to obtain that, we would have had to have set aside $3.5 million
0:31:19 and held that in a debt reserve fund for the duration of the debt.
0:31:24 And that would have taken our deposit to the project construction fund from the $39.5
0:31:31 million that you see there to $36.2 million.
0:31:39 So Cameron also shared that this is the first time that his organization has seen this type
0:31:46 of policy issued without going through the process of being rated.
0:31:51 I think that speaks volumes for us.
0:31:54 Now I did say these bonds were issued at a premium.
0:31:57 We know that they were attractive to the investors based on the results, but we don't know specifically
0:32:04 what they were attracted to, whether it was the size of the issuance, market conditions,
0:32:10 credit, there could be a variety of things.
0:32:18 But all in all, this was a very successful bond issuance for the city.
0:32:23 And most importantly, for our rate payers, the type of sale we used saved millions of dollars
0:32:28 and interest costs plus the strength of our wastewater fund allowed us to not have to tie
0:32:33 up three and a half million dollars in a debt reserve fund. These dollars will be able to
0:32:40 go directly to the project. So that's really all I have for you tonight and I'd be happy
0:32:45 to answer questions.
0:32:46 We have a couple of lights on the way. Great landing.
0:32:49 Well, when we talked about it was a bigger, we were issuing $30 billion, obviously over
0:32:54 half of the the bond sale but you know who we're paired with on that so it's
0:32:59 the city of Jerome and they were issuing 13.6 million and we were issuing
0:33:04 38 million okay all right and then my second question if I can absolutely
0:33:09 mayor thank you does the publicity of late that we've been having in a paper
0:33:19 does that have any you know it's the wrong crane and the issues about some
0:33:23 investments? Does that hurt the bond fund or you know?
0:33:26 You know, Greg, I don't believe that that had any bearing. So, our financial advisor with
0:33:37 the team at the bond bank, they put together this debt. They have information about the
0:33:42 city of Jerome and they have information about the city of Twin Falls, if any of the investors
0:33:48 want that information. They actually had two of the bidders call and ask about the entities
0:33:57 drone and twin. They didn't get the bid. And they had another individual or another underwriter
0:34:03 call and just asked kind of some global questions. So I don't believe what's occurring had any
0:34:11 impact on this.
0:34:12 Okay, thank you, Lori.
0:34:14 Great.
0:34:15 Who's talking?
0:34:16 You have to just follow up on that as a former bond salesman.
0:34:19 Wouldn't that AA1 have as much influence regardless of current affairs as about anything?
0:34:26 Yes, Chris.
0:34:27 And that's really based on the debt of the Idaho bond bank.
0:34:31 Yeah, right.
0:34:32 Yes.
0:34:33 I'm confused about a couple of things.
0:34:34 All right.
0:34:35 One, our true cost of 3.31, that's why outside of the range that you gave us a 3.47 to
0:34:42 7-3 I guess I don't understand. So let me visit about that. So you know how bonds are
0:34:48 structured and they mature at different rates and they all have different interest rates
0:34:53 attached to them. Everything that the city has in that total issuance is 20 years. The
0:35:01 entire issuance is 25 years and so they go through each of those bonds and the term and
0:35:11 the interest rate, they're paying and they go through, they figure that out and they calculate
0:35:17 what our true interest cost is. So the other entity, City of Jerome, is going to be higher
0:35:24 than that 3.47%. Their bonds are longer.
0:35:28 Yeah. So the shorter term, the more the discount?
0:35:34 Not discount. The shorter the term, when they, you know, Chris, I wish I'd have brought,
0:35:39 I did. Hold on one second. Because I apologize I did not bring it. There's a
0:36:12 schedule that shows the date of each bond the amount of those when they mature
0:36:16 their interest rate. I think that they were all issued at a premium in the
0:36:21 first 20 years except for the year 2030 which was issued at a discount and then
0:36:28 the years after 20 were issued at a discount. So when they go through the
0:36:33 mathematical calculation, that's how they come up with the true interest cost.
0:36:38 And I thought if I had the picture to put up there, it might make more sense to you.
0:36:42 And then two more little questions.
0:36:44 A lot easier to speak to this.
0:36:46 $226,460 savings as a result of the bond surety policy.
0:36:53 That's an actual.
0:36:56 Go ahead.
0:36:57 So that $226,000 is the cost that we have to pay
0:37:05 to not have to put $3.5 million in the debt reserve fund
0:37:09 for 20 years.
0:37:11 Good, okay.
0:37:13 Very fine, that kind of well wrapped up.
0:37:14 Appreciate it, thank you.
0:37:16 Our city manager would like to weigh in,
0:37:18 Travis, Ralph, what?
0:37:19 Maybe to kind of go forward and illustrate the difference
0:37:22 in the true interest costs that the city of Twin Falls
0:37:25 is going to pay in comparison to the city of Durham.
0:37:27 So one way to look at it is the interest cost that is assessed,
0:37:32 if that is going to be the average over the course of the entire 25 year period,
0:37:37 is going to be 3.47%.
0:37:41 The city of Twin Falls' piece is about 3.31%.
0:37:45 And I believe the city of Jerome's is 3.89.
0:37:49 And so when you take an average of those,
0:37:51 you're going to get a cost over the life of the 25 year period.
0:37:56 But we're not responsible for the entire 25 years.
0:38:00 We're only responsible for those interest charges in our portion.
0:38:04 And so what it reflected when you looked at it is the interest that was being assessed
0:38:09 in years 21 through 25 was substantially larger on the whole
0:38:15 than the interest that was being issued in the first 20 years.
0:38:19 And that drove up the true interest cost of 3.47%.
0:38:22 And that is the responsibility of the city of Jerome,
0:38:25 because they are the only one that will have debt
0:38:28 at the conclusion of that 20-year period
0:38:30 associated with this issuance.
0:38:32 And I remember the last question that I might,
0:38:34 the, no, it's not worth, I'll talk to you later,
0:38:42 but it's not taking the time.
0:38:44 Thanks.
0:38:45 Thank you, Chris Schonberger.
0:38:46 So I don't have a question, I just have a comment
0:38:48 to commend you, Laurie and your team,
0:38:51 both in finance and throughout.
0:38:53 I know you were working closely with Public Works
0:38:55 and all those different departments.
0:38:57 And I think it speaks volumes that your goal was to help save money
0:39:02 for the ratepayers, and you mentioned that in your presentation.
0:39:04 I think that's important, because it allows us to make those improvements at less cost.
0:39:10 So kudos to you and all of your team.
0:39:12 Thank you, Sean.
0:39:15 You know, I'd concur with what Sean just said, plus, you're just so excited
0:39:18 about this stuff when you come up.
0:39:20 It's kind of infectious.
0:39:21 We appreciate that very much.
0:39:23 Any other question, Council for.
0:39:26 Well, we appreciate it.
0:39:27 Oh, Chris, again, our bond rating as I recall, didn't you say that our our issuance was oversubscribed?
0:39:36 Yes, we got a premium.
0:39:38 But the thing is, I mean, there could be so many factors that I didn't want to dwell on that being.
0:39:44 Yes, it's the city because it could be a variety of the general health of Idaho's bond rating and economy and our local
0:39:51 ability to repay issues of this nature all speaks favorably the atmosphere that we created.
0:39:59 Travis?
0:40:01 The 3.31% that was realized by the city of Twin Falls and this issuance is just below AAA rated.
0:40:10 I think that's important to recognize is that the 3.31 is above the AA1 of the state's credit rating.
0:40:18 credit rating and I think that that really, there's a reason for that and I think that everyone's
0:40:23 talking about it and Lori's being incredibly humble in her approach.
0:40:27 Thank you again Lori.
0:40:30 We're moving back to the future here, number two on our items for consideration and it's
0:40:35 a consideration of a request to approve the implementation of a cross-connection program
0:40:41 and we have our water superintendent Rob Bower.
0:40:44 Welcome Rob.
0:40:45 Thank you.
0:40:46 evening honorable mayor and counsel.
0:40:49 As you know this evening we'd like to discuss the implementation of our cross-connection
0:40:55 program and I think what I might do is maybe have Mike, I'd like to introduce Mike Brown
0:41:00 and have him go first and he can kind of set the stage with the rules and regulations
0:41:05 and what the rules are that he has to administer down to us and let you fill you in on that
0:41:12 I'll come back with a discussion for plans moving forward and ideas that we have.
0:41:21 That's okay.
0:41:22 Very good.
0:41:23 Works for me.
0:41:24 Rob.
0:41:25 Thank you.
0:41:26 Mr. Brown.
0:41:27 Welcome.
0:41:28 Hi.
0:41:29 Mike Brown.
0:41:30 Sorry.
0:41:31 Mike Brown, DEQ.
0:41:32 In September of last year, I had the privilege of doing your sanitary survey, which is a survey that
0:41:40 Department of Environmental Quality is required to do
0:41:42 of every water system every five years
0:41:45 for exemplary performers every three years for everybody else.
0:41:51 And at that time, one of the significant deficiencies
0:41:56 that was found was the lack of a active cross connection
0:42:03 control program for the city.
0:42:05 You have all the ordinances in place
0:42:08 the exception of the one that we added in last year in April, but none of the active
0:42:16 components, the annual inspections being required, well, it was there but they had not been done,
0:42:23 they haven't been followed through, and therefore you were, had that significant deficiency.
0:42:32 deficiencies are those things which pose a potential threat to human health through inaction
0:42:44 or I won't say deficiencies again, but deficiencies in apparatus and plumbing and operations of
0:42:59 the water systems.
0:43:01 Or with that it's something that must be fixed within 180 days it has to have a plan and we're working on that plan to get that done and there's a timetable that's associated with that.
0:43:14 All the other items that were on there were very minor.
0:43:19 They've been taken care of. This is the only pending left item from that sanitary survey.
0:43:25 And then we follow the IDAPA code,
0:43:30 this big long giant string numbers, it's 58010806,
0:43:35 and then the four items that actually pertain to it are AB-CD-E,
0:43:42 being the newest one that requires those assemblies
0:43:48 to be done and replace after 10 years.
0:43:50 after 10 days when they're found defective.
0:43:58 This is not unique to Twin Falls,
0:44:02 it's happening with a lot of cities.
0:44:05 There was a big push back when this came about in 2007,
0:44:11 eight-ish, everybody jumped on board,
0:44:13 got their ordinances in place,
0:44:16 started doing it for a year or two,
0:44:17 and then just fell the wayside.
0:44:19 I know this because I used to be an operator,
0:44:21 And that's what happened with my system and with the systems
0:44:24 that were pertaining at that time.
0:44:28 Oh, the rules right there.
0:44:32 As you can see, it's just community water systems.
0:44:34 It says the water purveyor, the city,
0:44:37 is responsible through their cross-connection control program
0:44:41 to take reasonable and present measures
0:44:43 to protect the water system against contamination.
0:44:46 Blah-blah-blah.
0:44:47 It's very wordy.
0:44:48 There have been incidences where people have gotten very ill through lack of cross-connection
0:45:01 control.
0:45:02 We had one happen in the United Water and Boise, there was a lawsuit against that, and ultimately
0:45:08 the state lost.
0:45:11 One of the best ways that cities can relieve themselves of some liability there is through
0:45:17 this active program because you can say, well, you know, we've done everything that we possibly
0:45:22 could. And if you don't do that, then there is kind of that, well, in a court of law, hey,
0:45:30 you're following, you're not following your own rules, what makes you think that you're
0:45:34 following anybody else's, you know, and it leaves that doubt and ultimately that's what
0:45:39 was almost different court cases doubt. You have had some incidents that have occurred
0:45:47 in twin that could have the potential to have had some issues they didn't, luckily.
0:45:57 You had a individual who was shut off on their culinary water and decided to hook their pressurized
0:46:06 irrigation into their house that had potential to go back into the system.
0:46:12 You had some irrigators doing some blowouts on the east end of town that actually created
0:46:21 a hydro lock in the line because they were able to push the air through the sprinkler
0:46:27 system back into the main lines.
0:46:30 A few years ago, before my time, you had a backup at the Mr. Wash, whereas the soap
0:46:36 got back through the lines there.
0:46:39 So it's not something that it's a question of when it's going to happen, it's a question
0:46:46 of when and the ability to mitigate that, those damages and protect that system for those
0:46:54 kind of contamination events.
0:46:57 Okay.
0:46:58 Chris, talk to us.
0:46:59 So to expand this out to Joe Q resident at his home, the burden of proof upon them would
0:47:08 be after a certain amount of publishing and public
0:47:12 notification for them to contact a private inspector and
0:47:16 stuller for a backhoe backflow filter on each hose bed with
0:47:24 that data.
0:47:25 You know that really boils down to what the water system
0:47:31 Derm deems as their potential hazards
0:47:37 That faucets on a home no typically no a sprinkler system on the drinking water system. Yes
0:47:46 that that boils down to
0:47:51 A wwa recommended practices
0:47:54 USC they have there's like five different publications that have it and we kind of accept them all and
0:47:59 And so here it's kind of up to you which ones you want to accept, but typically accepted ones are
0:48:07 the AWWA
0:48:09 Pacific Northwest and the USC because USC is the one that
0:48:13 Test all the assemblies and approves them for use. So it's just kind of easier to
0:48:18 implement
0:48:21 So do you think it would be maybe we could have Rob do his
0:48:24 Presentation and that might answer some of our questions and then if you'd stand by mr. Brown
0:48:28 I'm maybe there might be some further questions. I don't understand how backflows happen
0:48:33 Okay, so I want to figure out how this all works. It's all a big mystical thing to me
0:48:40 You have a high pressure in the line and
0:48:48 How
0:48:57 You're all safe
0:49:00 Well, unless you induce that back from, and that happens in a few places down in the older
0:49:09 part of town, where some residents have still maintained their own private well, and a few
0:49:15 of them, what they're not supposed to do, have them still hooked into their homes, and if
0:49:20 the pressure in their pump in their well exceeds the pressure of the main, they can actually
0:49:28 pump right back into the main. Another way that backflow happens is through like a
0:49:34 venturi effect, like a handheld atomizer. You reduce the pressure over that hole and
0:49:43 you'll draw back in if the house is shut off or something or if you have a large
0:49:50 demand from a fire event and you drop the system pressure down you can actually
0:49:56 City water. We're not talking about PIs out in the new parts of town. No, not
0:50:02 pressurized irrigation is is separate from the drinking water and in most
0:50:09 instances it isn't reintroduced. There are instances where you know
0:50:15 something like that can't happen. But typically you're talking about the
0:50:20 reversal of that flow in that water line. It's going against its intended
0:50:25 directions supposed to be going from the main to the facility that comes from the facility back you
0:50:30 So there's a backflow device that needs to be at every home so that this doesn't happen regardless what home you have
0:50:38 Is that the rule no the rule is that?
0:50:42 Anything that you deem as a high hazard such as sprinkler systems boilers
0:50:51 Chemical introduction for car washes things to that effect
0:50:56 It sounds like we've already been doing the inspections on the commercial stuff
0:51:00 So what we're really talking about tonight is residential
0:51:03 So I think that's probably going to be a lot of our questions
0:51:05 How does this affect residential those that are on potable water systems for their sprinklers versus those that are on PIs?
0:51:12 And so Rob do you want to come up and maybe address those things?
0:51:16 Thank you, mr. Brown please stand by because I'm sure we'll have other questions for you
0:51:21 Thank you, Mike
0:51:23 Okay, so yeah
0:51:25 There are two different systems and we need to know that and not every system, every meter needs a backflow.
0:51:33 You can have water from your hose bib and never need a backflow.
0:51:38 If you have PI pressures, push eyes irrigation and your city water is separate from that.
0:51:44 You don't need a backflow. We have problems every once in a while. We'll catch where somebody thinks, oh, well I need water early.
0:51:50 early. So they'll go in and tie into their city water and hook it in to their
0:51:56 pressurized irrigation system. Well with no backflow, then they come and turn on
0:52:03 pressurized irrigation. Pressurized irrigation has higher pressure going out
0:52:09 than what the city water does. For instance south-south of town, some places
0:52:13 have 45-50 pounds and we're putting you know 60 pounds or more going down that
0:52:21 PI line there's a very real chance of that but with PI we need to make sure
0:52:27 that's none that if you are on pressurized irrigation you don't need a
0:52:32 backflow put on that it's only for the systems that are too city water they're
0:52:37 are using city water for their spankers.
0:52:40 Except for those subdivisions that are supposed to be on PI,
0:52:47 but haven't been turned on yet, they're unpaudible.
0:52:50 They'll have to have them.
0:52:51 We have, where we supply city water to the subdivision that's
0:52:57 still on city water, we have an RP device, right, where we
0:53:00 supply that.
0:53:01 We make sure we protect.
0:53:03 OK.
0:53:03 So that's going to be a steady of that.
0:53:05 Yes.
0:53:06 Yep. So anyway, move on. All righty. So, now that Mike's explained to you kind of where we're at, I've kind of sat down and went through this and thought, okay, so now how can we make this work and not be a huge burden on the people but yet the main focus is to make sure we're protecting our citizens
0:53:31 against themselves sometimes and protecting us also.
0:53:37 So obviously education is gonna be the key number one deal
0:53:41 in this to making it work and doing it right.
0:53:45 I've worked with Josh and me and Josh and Travis
0:53:48 have sat down and talked about doing different types
0:53:51 of commercials and bill stuffers and working
0:53:54 with the local media and getting the word out.
0:53:58 It's not like we're gonna go out there
0:54:00 and shut your water down.
0:54:02 Look at these split if, you know,
0:54:04 and there's gonna be a lot of them
0:54:05 that are not in compliance.
0:54:07 But I think Mike will work with this
0:54:08 as long as we're making a consensus effort
0:54:11 to get this going and do the right thing.
0:54:15 The industry involvement, the landscaping
0:54:18 and sprinkler companies, the question was brought up,
0:54:21 will this be a burden on the city and our employees?
0:54:26 Because the testers have to be certified in license,
0:54:29 they're going to go out and they're looking to go out and drum up business so
0:54:33 they're going to be looking for them when they go out and turn the sprinkling
0:54:36 systems on the screen they're going to be checking them out if they're not up to
0:54:40 snuff they'll be letting the person know hey we need to have you do this this is
0:54:45 what it's going to cost so really on our end of it it's just going to be the
0:54:50 paperwork coming back in so that we have to keep to comply with the rules that
0:54:55 Mike has for us. The enforcement, obviously we're going to need the blessing and city council on it.
0:55:04 We have our ordinance that's been in place for a while.
0:55:08 As we just need to do is follow it.
0:55:13 And like I said in manpower, the city employees, building inspection, water employees, meter
0:55:18 areas, the lawn and fire suppression companies, everybody's trained and licensed and knows
0:55:25 what they're looking for.
0:55:26 And we're out there every day, working usually in a different place every day.
0:55:33 So we'll be able to handle the workload on that end of it.
0:55:38 The testers, we make sure that they are licensed one and that their equipment is certified and
0:55:44 It has to be, I don't have to have the paperwork for that.
0:55:49 We talked about how we wanted to do the testers list or whatever and
0:55:54 Travis brought up a good idea about seeing what council thought about
0:55:59 doing like we do with the tow truck companies, setting a price.
0:56:03 And if you want to be on the city list to get called, this is what the price
0:56:08 is going to be.
0:56:10 Obviously that doesn't block everyone out.
0:56:12 if you want to be on the list the city puts on the city website you'll do it for
0:56:18 X and $100 and the average price for going right around here is about $45.
0:56:23 Will that be that price or the last? I think it'll be that I think that price
0:56:28 will probably once this goes I think the cap throughout is going to begin.
0:56:33 But what my point is is if we say like you say $45 it's the average price and
0:56:39 We say it has to be at least 45 that doesn't preclude people getting on that list that are 25
0:56:52 It's not very similar to what we do with tow truck
0:56:56 Operators being on a city list you have to be at this level and that's a discussion item. It's not
0:57:02 Well that
0:57:09 It'll get tight out there, and I think people, you know, when you can line up a whole street,
0:57:14 I think they'll do it for a lot less than that.
0:57:16 I think they'll probably kind of govern themselves once that comes into effect.
0:57:21 And then, so some of these sprinkler companies that go out and blow out, it would behoove
0:57:25 them to become certified, so they can do it all in one step and, yeah, yeah, and they do,
0:57:30 they have people that are certified, and they've kind of been waiting on us, like, when are
0:57:35 Are we going to do this or what's going on?
0:57:38 So they're all pretty much ready to go.
0:57:41 They're just waiting on us to make the move.
0:57:44 So worst case scenario for a citizen of Twin Falls.
0:57:48 I'm sorry, Rebecca.
0:57:49 I didn't see you.
0:57:50 I'll let you go next.
0:57:54 You come out to their house, or they have someone come out
0:57:56 and inspect because they're on pobble water
0:57:58 for their sprinkler system.
0:58:00 And they find out they don't even have a backflow device.
0:58:03 What are we looking at for that citizen?
0:58:06 Well, basically, most sprinkler systems run off of a one-inch service, so rough figures
0:58:15 for one-inch backload vices about $150.
0:58:17 Installation could be anywhere from, depending if it's new construction or existing construction,
0:58:25 probably $200,000 to $800,000 maybe, depending on, you know, and that's high-end.
0:58:33 But if they've got, you know, it's been there for 12, 15 years and there's a huge pop their tree there and they've got to dig the tree out or remove the tree sidewalk, Kerbin Gutter.
0:58:44 You know, there's so many variables there. It's hard to say. I wouldn't give anybody a bid to go paint their house if I didn't go look at it because I might lose.
0:58:52 Right.
0:58:53 So, that's just a rough.
0:58:55 Okay.
0:58:56 I'll probably have some more questions, but I've been in the door and we're back.
0:58:59 Okay.
0:59:00 Thank you, Mayor. That's fine.
0:59:02 Well, I just wanted to comment, I appreciate all the information that you provided to us,
0:59:06 especially the list of fees, and I noticed that, you know, you had the average test cost
0:59:12 is $45, and I think that that's correct, but there are two kind of outliers that are double
0:59:18 the cost of everyone else, and when you take those out, the average is actually $36, and
0:59:23 so, you know, I think I'd be more inclined to set it maybe at $35, and like you said, it's
0:59:27 going to self-regulate, but I think it's a good idea.
0:59:30 I think it's good to set a price and the more reasonable the price, the more likely people will be to comply.
0:59:36 Yeah, and that was just an average price, you know, it'll be your decision if you guys want to do that.
0:59:44 The price is yours to set, so we just wanted to give you a kind of an average of what it was in the area.
0:59:50 But you're right, there are a couple that are better than more.
0:59:53 Thank you. Yeah, I just noticed if you remove those, the average price is closer to 35, which I think would be a good amount to set.
1:00:00 25
1:00:03 Traverse and have other lights we go ahead. Hey, I just on that point
1:00:06 I think it's important to emphasize this that we're we're saying you have to subscribe to that price or
1:00:13 Lower to be on our list
1:00:16 Which is we're not saying that you have to subscribe to any price to offer the service inside the community because we can't
1:00:23 Regulate that but when people turn to us about who to go to what we're saying is if you want to be on our list
1:00:29 this is the maximum price that you are allowed to assess.
1:00:34 And like Rob shared, that is really worth seeking guidance
1:00:39 from the council in terms of what that looks like.
1:00:42 Very good. Suzanne Hawkins.
1:00:44 So how do we know who needs to be tested and who doesn't?
1:00:49 I mean, we don't know who has sprinkler systems
1:00:51 necessarily connected and who doesn't,
1:00:54 and how do you enforce compliance?
1:00:58 When the sprinkler systems get turned on, I'm going to have a meeting with all of the
1:01:06 sprinkler companies and fire suppression companies.
1:01:09 There's a backflow certification class.
1:01:12 I believe it's second week in March, and I will be a part of that.
1:01:19 And most of the guys in the area that test will be there to get their license re-certified.
1:01:24 So I'm going to bring it up there.
1:01:26 We're going to send letters out to people that aren't there,
1:01:29 to all the sprinkler companies that we have on record.
1:01:33 I want to put a deal in the paper.
1:01:36 I know I believe it was Paul.
1:01:39 But last Thursday, they had a big deal on the paper.
1:01:42 Notice about that they were going to have
1:01:44 to start doing the back-to-side system compliance, too.
1:01:48 And they had a big notice in the paper.
1:01:51 So I'm going to be working with Josh quite a bit on that.
1:01:54 We have just by people complying on their own, we have close to 2,000 records of Backflow
1:02:07 devices already.
1:02:08 And then the guys when they go out and work will always be looking and they'll bring in
1:02:15 the address to Walley and make sure that we've got it in our record and if we don't, we'll
1:02:19 just send them a letter and say.
1:02:20 So our software database is already set up to track that as we start getting the information
1:02:24 compiled. I know we're looking at new handheld devices and so that will I'm
1:02:33 assuming make that easier as we're out in the field with that to start keeping
1:02:37 track and then again what is the if somebody refuses to comply or is being
1:02:43 a little tricky about getting there what what do we do to help get them ready to
1:02:49 comply. The first letter that goes out usually just lets them know that they have a back
1:02:55 load of ice and they have a belief 45 days I believe to get a test turned back in if they
1:03:02 haven't turned it back in then yet send them another notice and let them know that they
1:03:08 need to get a come in the compliance and get it tested. Notice their responsibility and
1:03:14 I believe that's 15 days and then there's a final notice letter that goes out and I see
1:03:27 there are five or ten days on that one and that's the final notice and need to get this
1:03:32 done or we're going to have to potentially shut your water up.
1:03:38 Jim Munn I would move that we have staff proceed forward with the back flow cross connection
1:03:47 program with testers who choose to be on the city's web page as certified testers
1:03:58 to proceed with. I like Rebecca's idea of $35 or less for the certification take
1:04:07 out the top two because they were way off the charts there.
1:04:11 Motion on the floor. Second.
1:04:13 Motion on the floor by Jim Mine seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
1:04:18 Chris talking. Yeah, so Rob that 35 is a defensible figure in your mind. Oh, yeah, okay
1:04:29 Rebecca, so I got thank you here, and I just want to add I appreciate you
1:04:34 Including the letter that you're gonna send out in our packet and I think that will really help educate people and I actually think that
1:04:41 The the center paragraph the middle paragraph should be the first one because I think it it gets at the basic information
1:04:47 information, kind of these questions that Councilman have mentioned about, you know, do I qualify?
1:04:53 You know, how do I know if I'm someone that this applies to?
1:04:57 But I think that, you know, knowing the sentiment towards federal mandates in this community,
1:05:02 I think if we focus actually on the positive outcome and the things that we're trying to
1:05:06 accomplish as far as you want to be healthy, you don't want to get sick because your water
1:05:10 is contaminated, I think that it will actually just naturally encourage people to be in compliance.
1:05:16 And so...
1:05:17 I had no problem with that.
1:05:18 When I was a very male and I read it and I was like, oh yeah, well that makes sense.
1:05:22 Okay.
1:05:23 It's a little more palatable that way.
1:05:24 Great.
1:05:25 Yeah.
1:05:26 I think that we're going to do a great job educating people and I did send an email just
1:05:30 with some thoughts on, you know, how to maybe make it more friendly towards people so that
1:05:36 they can relate to it and understand, you know, like Councilman Munn was saying, what
1:05:41 is this?
1:05:42 How does it apply to me?
1:05:43 So I think as long as we address those areas
1:05:47 and kind of in layman's terms help people understand,
1:05:49 okay, why do I need this?
1:05:51 And why should I comply?
1:05:54 I think that we'll definitely be headed in the right direction.
1:05:57 So I appreciate all your work on it.
1:05:59 No problem.
1:05:59 I totally agree.
1:06:01 No, I've been here for a while,
1:06:03 but backflow was my deal for a while before I moved on,
1:06:08 but it was funny you'd get people calling in
1:06:11 and they'd be just irate, and then you'd have to sit there
1:06:16 and let them blow the steam, and once they got done,
1:06:19 then you'd sit down and explain, well, you know,
1:06:21 really the real reason we're doing this
1:06:24 is to keep our children and all of our families safe
1:06:29 to provide for us, for me, being the waters of pretend
1:06:33 is to provide the city with the safest water
1:06:35 that I can possibly provide, and to follow the rules
1:06:40 of government. But usually once you explain to them, you know, this is why we do it. Yeah,
1:06:46 it's kind of a pain and it's another rule or another 40 bucks or whatever. But in the end,
1:06:53 most of the people were like, no, okay, we get it. Yeah. So, yeah, education is going to be,
1:07:01 you know, we need to do that. If people aren't informed, they have no way to know it. So I think
1:07:09 We haven't done a ton of it the past years, but I put a lot of money in the budget this
1:07:14 year for $25,000 to do education and conservation efforts to engage with the public and let them
1:07:22 know what the rules and regulations and why we have them and what they're for.
1:07:30 I just want to drill down a little bit further on, you said that you have a list of folks
1:07:34 that you know at least 2,000 that have backflow devices.
1:07:38 You have a list of folks that don't have backflow devices that should.
1:07:44 Those are the ones that I'm most concerned with because if we're talking a $1,000 pop to a family that's substantial.
1:07:52 I get the reasons for this.
1:07:54 Absolutely.
1:07:55 It's the right thing to do.
1:07:56 But I would hope that we can try to help or mitigate that your family on a fixed income.
1:08:03 And you have sprinkler system.
1:08:04 You might just go out there and shut your sprinkler system off from the house.
1:08:08 and start dragging a hose.
1:08:10 I mean, that's probably what I would do.
1:08:11 So I think anything that we can do to help mitigate that
1:08:14 and help those folks, that would be advisable.
1:08:17 And I agree with this advertisement
1:08:19 getting the word out to folks that this is coming
1:08:22 so that they can be prepared.
1:08:24 Very, very important.
1:08:25 And again, I agree that we've got to do this.
1:08:29 We're probably late in doing this, okay?
1:08:31 But those are the folks that I'm most concerned with.
1:08:34 Yeah, and we'll work with them.
1:08:36 And there's different kind of systems
1:08:37 you can do to that don't you know you can use a system with no controllers or no valves
1:08:44 downstream of it and you don't need a backflow device on it. So the way you set them up obviously
1:08:50 of course the ones that have the automatic valves and everything everybody wants to know
1:08:55 but if you can't afford that then there's other options you can go to also.
1:08:59 Okay, great landing. Well in the secondary part of that one I know this is probably something
1:09:06 that's going to take more than this meeting to try to set up.
1:09:08 But I agree with Don, the mitigation of those
1:09:12 who don't have it is probably more concerning to me
1:09:15 than the ones that do just need to have a checked
1:09:17 on a scheduled basis.
1:09:19 But I don't know, we have anything within our city code
1:09:24 that allows us to say, all right, this is what's required
1:09:28 and we'll actually arrange for it to be put in
1:09:31 and then we'll charge over a four-year time span
1:09:34 a two-year time spent of what it is on their water bills.
1:09:37 As Pritz is going back there going, oh my god,
1:09:39 what is he talking about?
1:09:40 Well, I also see Travis shaking his head.
1:09:43 No, we don't have that ability.
1:09:45 Okay, all right.
1:09:46 Okay.
1:09:47 We have a constitutional problem
1:09:49 where we can't lend our faith or credit.
1:09:51 All right, that makes sense.
1:09:52 Makes sense.
1:09:53 But just drilling down on that one more time.
1:09:56 If that's the case, if it's gonna be a thousand bucks
1:09:58 and there's no mitigation of that,
1:10:00 do those residents have the option
1:10:02 I'm shutting off their sprinkler system, just dragging a hose.
1:10:06 Okay, and I would hope again, Rob, I'm sure that we will.
1:10:10 But we try to work with those folks.
1:10:12 Because that's a shock, by the way, you have to pay $45 a year
1:10:18 to get inspected and it's gonna cost you $1,000.
1:10:21 That's a big shock.
1:10:24 No, I'm talking about those that have to, that's the case.
1:10:29 thousand dollars is on the high end and I appreciate that I know you do a
1:10:32 worst-case scenario and I appreciate that but we need to look at work say scenario
1:10:36 for folks just in case yeah Rebecca Melsoika thank you mayor who would people
1:10:41 call the mayor talked about you do have a list of people who need the back flow
1:10:46 and they don't have it would they just call the water department be able to
1:10:49 find out if if they need that okay we have a list of people already on a list
1:10:55 And most all of this may clear companies in the areas now have a certified test for.
1:11:02 Thank you.
1:11:03 John, did you want to weigh in?
1:11:05 Just something to add.
1:11:06 Travis, now.
1:11:07 Robin.
1:11:08 Rob's really put the education piece together, he's focused on that, which we agree is most
1:11:15 important.
1:11:16 So one of the other things we could offer is, you know, it does get confusing.
1:11:20 What is all this made?
1:11:21 Do I need one?
1:11:22 It's all I care.
1:11:23 Do I need one or not?
1:11:24 That's right.
1:11:25 We have an open house, you know, we can have a couple of
1:11:29 houses where people can come in, we can show them examples
1:11:31 and pictures and say, now you live in this subdivision
1:11:34 that has pressurization, you're fine, but what you want
1:11:36 to look for is this, you know, we can have, we can do that.
1:11:39 Could we, by invitation, could you come look at my house
1:11:44 kind of a deal for folks?
1:11:46 You know, call up the water, hey, I don't know what I have
1:11:49 as a citizen, you know, I think that might be helpful
1:11:51 to folks.
1:11:52 I think that's what's part of our job.
1:11:54 That's what Rob's referring to when he says we've been working on people because you know someone might call us and say you know
1:11:59 I do have a popular train. It's a thousand bucks for me to do it
1:12:02 We would go out there and be willing to look at it brainstorm. Maybe we can bring our water line to a different location in their yard for them
1:12:09 Maybe it's easier for us
1:12:11 We would entertain that beautiful. I know seven people up here. They're probably becoming you real quick
1:12:19 Really good presentation tonight anytime we're talking about raising fees
1:12:24 You know, this is can be construed as a tax.
1:12:27 It's another fee that we have to put on the citizens,
1:12:30 and we're very sensitive about that.
1:12:32 I know it's a contentious issue, it always has been,
1:12:35 but there's rules that govern us,
1:12:37 and when I have to be the superintendent,
1:12:40 that these are the rules and they're the rules,
1:12:43 and I see they're, are we following them?
1:12:46 It's like, yeah.
1:12:48 I get it.
1:12:49 So, Rob, again, thank you.
1:12:50 It looks like we have a motion on four.
1:12:52 Any other concerns or comments?
1:12:55 Council on the motion?
1:12:57 I see no lights.
1:12:58 Leila, roll call vote, please.
1:13:02 Regent Lausien?
1:13:03 Yes.
1:13:04 Don Hall?
1:13:04 Yes.
1:13:05 Rebecca Melsweka?
1:13:06 Yes.
1:13:07 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:13:08 Yes.
1:13:09 Jim Mudd?
1:13:10 Yes.
1:13:11 Sean Beriker?
1:13:12 Yes.
1:13:12 Yes.
1:13:13 Motion passes seven to zero.
1:13:15 Again, thank you, Rob, for the presentation.
1:13:17 Moving to item number six, consideration
1:13:19 that we request to adopt an ordinance for the zoning,
1:13:22 district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to R4 Pro for property located at 840 Addison
1:13:29 Avenue and we have Mitch Humble making presentation and just let folks know that we do have two
1:13:33 public hearings tonight in our agenda states that we will not address those public hearings
1:13:38 until six or afterwards. So obviously it's going to be afterwards.
1:13:42 Mitch.
1:13:43 Thanks. We have a ordinance for your consideration tonight. This is to put in place the zoning change
1:13:52 that we talked about a couple of weeks ago. This is from R4 to R4 Pro. It's at the corner
1:13:57 of Addison in 11th Avenue North. This was approved, like I said, a couple of weeks ago,
1:14:03 paired the ordinance in accordance with that approval and it's ready for your adoption tonight.
1:14:08 It is an ordinance, if you do want to adopt it tonight, we do need to put on the third and
1:14:11 final wave the rules and all that good stuff so with that I'll just try to
1:14:16 answer your questions again the other before we go there do we have an
1:14:18 ordinance number thirty sixty two thirty sixty two thank you any questions
1:14:23 for my humble Chris talking to move placing ordinance thirty sixty two and
1:14:29 third and final by title only and suspend the rules second motion on
1:14:35 floor by Chris talking and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to suspend the rules and
1:14:40 place Ordinance 3062 on third and final by title only anything on that motion
1:14:45 council I see no lights yeah the roll call vote please Don Hall yes Rebecca
1:14:52 Milseuka yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim and yes Sean Baragar yes yes
1:15:00 yes big Lansing yes motion passes seven zero if you read the ordinance in
1:15:08 In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, we zoning real property
1:15:14 below described, providing the zoning classification, therefore, and ordering the necessary area
1:15:20 of impact in zoning district's map amendment.
1:15:25 Council wishes.
1:15:26 Great landing.
1:15:27 Move approval of order of 362.
1:15:28 Second.
1:15:29 You have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting seconded by Jim not to approve ordinance 362.
1:15:35 We have a roll call vote, please.
1:15:42 Yes.
1:15:43 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:15:45 Yes.
1:15:46 Jim Munn.
1:15:47 Yes.
1:15:48 Sean Berriger.
1:15:49 Yes.
1:15:50 Mr. Talkington.
1:15:51 Yes.
1:15:52 Great landing.
1:15:53 Yes.
1:15:54 Don Hall.
1:15:55 Yes.
1:15:56 Motion passes.
1:15:57 Seven to zero.
1:15:58 Next item on the agenda.
1:15:59 Number seven is consideration of your request to adopt an ordinance amending city code nine dash six dash eight regarding the city's regulations.
1:16:05 a city's regulation of on-street large truck parking.
1:16:10 We have Mitch Humboldt again.
1:16:13 Okay, this is another ordinance that we talked about last week.
1:16:15 In fact, I brought back up this time,
1:16:19 you see traffic sergeant Howe back there.
1:16:22 He's here to help answer your questions in case
1:16:24 you have any that might really be in enforcement.
1:16:29 So we did prepare the ordinance that we discussed last week.
1:16:33 It makes a change to Title IX, and that would be in Chapter 6, Section 8.
1:16:38 Essentially, this is exactly like we described at last week.
1:16:43 This is just basically a large truck parking, and where it used to be permitted in basically anywhere that wasn't a residential zone.
1:16:51 We're pushing those on-street parking to the industrial zones in one and in two.
1:16:58 Those are the zones also as it would work out that if you were to do one of these off-street large truck parking lots
1:17:05 those would be the zones where those types of uses would be permitted as well. It made sense from
1:17:11 a staff standpoint that if you're gonna allow off-street that would be the same place as where maybe on-street would be appropriate.
1:17:17 There's one other change I didn't really talk about last week and I just thought I'd mention here at the very beginning of this paragraph on 968.
1:17:24 We discussed, we provide a brief kind of definition for large truck and it's one half ton capacity.
1:17:31 And in the second part of the paragraph we talk about one half ton capacity and there's
1:17:36 a disconnect there so we thought it would be a good idea to take those opportunities for
1:17:40 in this section to make them the same.
1:17:42 So a large truck is going to be in both halves to find is one and a half ton capacity.
1:17:48 And then the rest of the change just as what we talked about off-street parking is limited to manufacturing so with that
1:17:59 a whole lot more to it. Let's leave it open for questions and discussion.
1:18:04 Any questions for Ms. Schumbel to that? Suzanne Hawkins.
1:18:08 So in our manufacturing zones, which I'm not really up to speed exactly where that is,
1:18:14 there is parking available for these trucks there or do you mean off street on on street like
1:18:21 whether parking now in the commercial zones that really isn't good for this city if we're moving
1:18:27 into M1 and M2 are there good spaces available for that many trucks i know yesterday dave and i
1:18:34 walked again and not only were both sides of the streets lined with trucks but they're even
1:18:40 parking backwards into traffic which really bothers me and we picked up trash the whole way
1:18:47 through there and I can't even tell you how many shattered bottles we counted and it was just really
1:18:55 ugly but I'm afraid now what are we doing to the M1M2 and where exactly is that and where are they
1:19:01 going and is there room for them and all that. So I'm pulling up a map here so I can show you all
1:19:07 where the M1 and 2 zones are, always pulling up a map, hold on a second, it doesn't want
1:19:20 to, oh, there it is, looks really bad.
1:19:44 The colors don't come up very good, but this color that's down in this area here, it's
1:19:49 kind of a, I don't know, greenish, yellow, orangey, weird color, that's the color for
1:19:55 the M1 and M2 designation, and so we got a big chunk of it down here on the south side
1:20:00 of the city is a little bit over in here which would be around like Coca-Cola over there
1:20:11 right off of Park and then there's a little bit downtown here too. That's mostly where
1:20:19 it is in that south part of town. There are places with loads of open on street parking
1:20:26 in M2 zones. Primarily I would say, around JCo, I guess would be a great idea where that might
1:20:35 be available. I don't know that the law go there. The other side of the Dead Road Hankins Road
1:20:43 as you head back to the west, all of that is manufacturing zones as well, but busier in terms
1:20:51 of the development down there, right? So there's maybe not as much room on the street as there
1:20:54 would be out there. So yeah, there are places where it would be an option. I don't know how
1:21:05 well people will use it. I think what we like to see is places develop that are off street
1:21:14 and use of the properties for this purpose, right, like truck stops of sorts, you know,
1:21:21 truck parking a lot where they can all kind of go and
1:21:24 Maybe leave their car when they go off in their trucks and then come back and the car's still there and safe, you know
1:21:30 So I think that's one of the things they like about this area up here by Walmart is that Walmart would allow
1:21:35 Right, I know there was one truck that they were doing mechanical work on it in the street and so I'm just concerned that again
1:21:44 We're not making another problem down the road
1:21:47 For the industrial area, like I said, they're kind of on the outline parts of town.
1:21:56 I'm not sure how that's going to really play out.
1:21:59 I think it works.
1:22:01 I think why people have congregated where they are now is because it's a handy location.
1:22:06 But I also think that that very issue is why the code amendment is needed.
1:22:13 So we don't just keep pushing it from a commercial area to commercial area.
1:22:17 You know, although I'm supportive of this ordinance, we'll vote for it.
1:22:27 We'll be pushing this truck traffic out here.
1:22:29 I sure don't think that as the city's responsibility, however, to provide parking.
1:22:35 I mean, that's a private contract relationship understanding.
1:22:42 But a person in violation of this ordinance, what would the, is that, that's a misdemeanor
1:22:50 with a set fine?
1:22:54 And so what would that amount?
1:22:56 The first violation is $35 violation if it's not paid within, I think it's three business
1:23:01 days, it goes up to $50.
1:23:05 If we do pass this, I hope we can spend a few bucks on some leaflets to plaster the windows
1:23:12 or something to let the truckers at least know before we start
1:23:15 uh... citing
1:23:16 citing them so as far as the
1:23:18 enforcement goes i've already talked with the code enforcement staff
1:23:22 uh... and they're preparing exactly that
1:23:24 presentation right now
1:23:26 uh... they're gonna basically take
1:23:28 what we did for downtown
1:23:30 eighteen months ago
1:23:31 that we had a like a when we change all the rules for downtown parking
1:23:35 use that as a kind of a template and make another little handout that they can
1:23:38 going to put in the windows of trucks and their intent from a code enforcement standpoint
1:23:44 would be to get out there and try to educate first, much like we just talked about with
1:23:47 the water thing, try and help people understand what the new rules are rather than just go
1:23:51 out with a ticket book and start sighting.
1:23:54 But that's why the cops do it.
1:23:57 We're going to educate first, really try to fix the problem, I guess, rather than just
1:24:07 have the coffers.
1:24:09 I know that Fritz weighed in saying it was an infraction,
1:24:12 but I don't think that got to the mics for folks at home.
1:24:15 So it's an infraction starting at $30, $30, Fritz, $35?
1:24:21 I think Mitch has given the fines for the off-street parking
1:24:26 fines for downtown.
1:24:27 It's a traffic infraction.
1:24:28 So it's just going to be a parking.
1:24:30 And it's probably like $75, including court costs.
1:24:36 If they fail to pay those, they're turned over to collection.
1:24:38 they can have their licenses suspended if they fail to pay them.
1:24:42 So it doesn't seem like much on the outset,
1:24:46 but it can, especially for truck drivers, would be pretty important.
1:24:50 Very good.
1:24:50 Thank you for this.
1:24:51 Great planning.
1:24:52 Well, I'm just wondering if that flyer that you're talking
1:24:56 about Mitchell that have talked about, maybe,
1:25:00 so they identify where the M1, M2 areas are?
1:25:03 I'll stick a copy of the map up there, too.
1:25:06 So is the world spread pretty quickly to them?
1:25:08 They'll talk a lot and they'll they'll find the new areas quickly. I'm sure
1:25:17 And you're looking for a motion to sign up this evening to adopt we have an ordinance
1:25:21 It's ready for adoption if that's here and to adopt it. What is the ordinance number 30 63
1:25:28 30 63
1:25:29 If you want if you want to do that we'll have to do the third and final thing again
1:25:32 If you want to do three readings we can certainly do three readings. That's all
1:25:35 I'm gonna go there. Thank you
1:25:37 I move that we suspend the rules in place ordinance 3063 on third and final by title only
1:25:44 Second motion on the floor by Greg Manning seconded by Suzanne Hawkins
1:25:49 Chris talking I move to mend that to move it back to first reading
1:25:53 And I'd be happy to weigh it a second. I'd explain that second
1:25:57 Okay, we have a motion to amend that motion to go on first reading and that's Chris talking 10 second
1:26:04 I'm Mills, so I get Chris
1:26:06 If we move it to the first or next meeting we can put on the third and final, but something
1:26:12 of this logistical log jam for the truckers, I think we should at least owe them the courtesy
1:26:19 of a week or so for the word to get out and for them if they so choose to come out and
1:26:26 try to defend themselves, there's no issue that's so one-sided that there isn't maybe
1:26:32 something we haven't heard or thought of and I just feel a little more
1:26:36 comfortable taking final action in an ensuing week. Very good. Rebecca Milsuk.
1:26:42 Thank you Mayor. I was actually going to say the same thing kind of like the food
1:26:48 truck ordinance that we did. You know we had the three readings. I think it's a
1:26:51 better opportunity to inform the public and allow for some time so that
1:26:55 people can be aware of it because we you know have the opportunity to change
1:26:58 city code without a public hearing, without any really outreach to let people know that we're doing it, so that's why I second it.
1:27:06 Very good. Greg Lanti?
1:27:08 Well, the only counter I would have is that the week, this is already the second time we've talked about this particular issue and
1:27:16 plus we're already been stated that we're going to go into an education mode for several weeks before any tickets are actually
1:27:23 issued, and I believe that'll give them ample time to find new places. If they can't find
1:27:30 a new place in three weeks, they're probably going to have to go somewhere else. That would
1:27:35 be my reasoning that we're out. This is like the second then we've talked about it.
1:27:40 Anything further on the amendment, Council?
1:27:44 Leila Roll call vote on the amendment. Suzanne Hawkins?
1:27:49 Yes. Jim Mine? Yes. Sean Berger? Yes.
1:27:54 Chris talking to yes, Greg Lanthine. No
1:27:58 Don Hall no
1:28:00 Rebecca mils like yes motion passes
1:28:04 five to two
1:28:06 The amendment passes five to two and we still need to do the main motion
1:28:11 Which I think is a spend the rules. I mean if it's wiped out the main motion. Yeah, so how do it how frets?
1:28:17 How does that work?
1:28:18 But we we had an amendment to the main motion of suspending the rules, but now we're not suspending the rules
1:28:23 So we don't need to do anything. No, it was just on first reading. Okay, very good and Travis so for first reading
1:28:29 We should have a little read it by title only. Yes, very good if you do so
1:28:33 And ordinance of the city council of the city at one falls Idaho that's one fall city code sub section 968
1:28:40 Be amended to prohibit on-street truck parking
1:28:43 Accepting manufacturing district districts are well engaged in loading or unloading
1:28:48 very good so we have fulfilled our duties and we'll bring this back next week for
1:28:54 second reading and or to spending the rules council deems necessary next item
1:29:01 on the agenda is public input and or items from city manager and city council
1:29:05 keeping in mind we still have two public hearings so is there any public input
1:29:09 anyone from the public that would like to come and dress the council on
1:29:12 something that we have not discussed or will not be discussing this evening city
1:29:18 manager, city council. Rebecca Milsuk.
1:29:25 Thank you, Mayor.
1:29:26 I just wanted to make the council where I received an email from a mediation group
1:29:31 that is going to primarily through the Idaho Fair Intermountain Fair Housing Council.
1:29:38 They're an action group that seeks to address some issues that may be related
1:29:44 to refugee fair housing here in Twin Falls.
1:29:48 some bars to choice in housing and just some other issues.
1:29:51 They're gathering the stakeholders.
1:29:54 And so I received this email and wanted the council to know
1:29:58 that the first meeting is tentatively set for March 19th,
1:30:02 9-2 noon is in Boise, and I can get you the details on it later.
1:30:06 Really, right now, we're just going to be listening,
1:30:10 seeing where we can help, making sure we're aware
1:30:12 of the fair housing issue, and they've identified the city
1:30:17 as a stakeholder and so you know I think we're more
1:30:21 observers and listeners at this point and really
1:30:25 I just want to see what we can do to help
1:30:27 and make sure that we're aware of any issues
1:30:30 that are going on in our city.
1:30:31 And Travis may have something to add, but.
1:30:35 Travis?
1:30:35 So in relation to that staff will probably
1:30:41 also accompany to go up because it's probably going
1:30:43 to be some philosophies or processes
1:30:46 that we might generally need to be aware of,
1:30:48 from our perspective.
1:30:50 And so we are going to go through a process
1:30:53 of identifying the appropriate staff or staff persons
1:30:56 to be able to go in a company,
1:30:59 members of the council who may attend this workshop.
1:31:04 And as always, if more than three go,
1:31:08 please let Travis know so that we can advertise that meeting.
1:31:12 Correct?
1:31:17 I heard that would be another.
1:31:18 please keep it to just three.
1:31:20 It gets very, very logistical with meeting minutes
1:31:23 and all that other types of stuff.
1:31:25 So if less than a quorum would go,
1:31:28 it'd be greatly appreciated by staff.
1:31:31 We will report back whoever goes,
1:31:34 what occurs at those meetings.
1:31:35 Actually, a couple comments were made during this.
1:31:38 So, so, French, could you come forward?
1:31:41 I think maybe what I heard from Council is probably right.
1:31:44 I mean, when we go to a AIC meeting,
1:31:47 And there's more than four of them are go.
1:31:49 We don't necessarily advertise that because it's not our meeting.
1:31:53 How's that work?
1:31:54 So you have to think about whether you are deliberating toward a decision.
1:32:00 That includes receipt of information, but it's on a matter that's before the City Council
1:32:05 or will be before the City Council.
1:32:08 So if you're just getting information at AIC, you're not deliberating.
1:32:12 You're gaining general information, but there isn't any matter that's in front of you
1:32:17 that you would be hearing about.
1:32:18 On this particular issue, there's potential we could
1:32:22 to be deliberating or not, just so that we are-
1:32:25 I don't know how you could be.
1:32:26 Okay.
1:32:27 You're just getting general information, I think.
1:32:29 So, so X-NAM, when I said more than four can go, okay?
1:32:33 Very good.
1:32:34 Thank you, Prince, for clarifying that.
1:32:36 Anything else from City Council?
1:32:39 Council, we can either take a break.
1:32:41 It sounds like we need a break.
1:32:43 So we are going to take a seven minute break,
1:32:45 return at six thirty five
1:39:11 the council that is now six thirty five i think that's the first time we've ever
1:39:16 been on time coming back i i did want to mention i forgot to put in that uh...
1:39:20 we are starting uh... a uh...
1:39:24 mayor
1:39:24 manager city manager breakfast once a month
1:39:28 uh... that travis and i will be attending or or
1:39:32 at just as an effort to try to reach out to the public a little bit more, and the first
1:39:37 one will be March 10th at 7 a.m. at Kelly's. So those of you wishing to come and join us
1:39:44 and ask questions and have a cup of coffee with us, you're more than invited. So the
1:39:49 first one we will be doing this. Is that the second Tuesday? What is that? Second Monday
1:39:57 of every month at a different location will be advertising out on our website as well
1:40:02 as here at the meetings. We'll let folks know. So the more the Mary come on in. We are now
1:40:08 moving towards our two public hearings this evening. The first one being a public hearing
1:40:13 to consider adoption of a resolution authorizing the mayor to sign and submit an application
1:40:19 to the Idaho Department of Commerce to partially finance improvements to the Twin Falls Senior
1:40:26 Center and we have Janet Rowe from the Twin Paul Senior Center Director I believe is your
1:40:32 title making the presentation and then I think we'll probably have a staff follow-up after
1:40:37 that and then we'll open up the public so welcome Janet.
1:40:40 Hi my name is actually Janet.
1:40:42 Janet.
1:40:43 That's okay.
1:40:44 Thank you.
1:40:45 Thank you.
1:40:46 There is a Janet Rowe in town.
1:40:47 Okay.
1:40:48 What I wanted to let everybody know is we worked on our budget and what we're trying to do is
1:40:54 to do some improvements at the senior center.
1:40:56 The main focus is energy efficiency.
1:40:58 I have three huge units on top of the roof
1:41:02 that do me basically no good for heating and cooling.
1:41:04 That is the biggest part of my problem.
1:41:07 And in fact, in doing the research for this grant,
1:41:10 we found out that there was no as-builds,
1:41:13 any inspections of the duck work or anything else
1:41:17 that's in that building.
1:41:19 And it looks like we had somebody up there
1:41:21 that just drew a snake everywhere.
1:41:23 So it's not doing us any good.
1:41:25 The energy efficiently, we have two long runs.
1:41:28 The units aren't sized correctly,
1:41:30 so part of the building burns up.
1:41:31 The part of it that is exposed on the outer walls,
1:41:34 which is the two corners.
1:41:35 On the west side, they freeze to death,
1:41:37 and the other people burn up.
1:41:39 So we're trying to fix those.
1:41:41 So what we did is we had an energy audit done,
1:41:44 and they determined that there's certain things
1:41:46 that we need to do to fix those problems.
1:41:48 So the biggest cost of our budget is $112,588
1:41:53 to install new units and do the duct work, plus the engineering that's necessary to get
1:41:58 it so we have no surprises, but the gentleman that gave me that estimate does have an engineer
1:42:04 on staff and they feel that should cover it.
1:42:07 The other things that we're wanting to do is in doing that is also put some sound reduction
1:42:13 insulation panels up on the wall.
1:42:15 I've been in the process.
1:42:17 This is an ongoing request.
1:42:18 a year ago we applied for the grant and did not get it from the Idaho Department of Commerce.
1:42:24 I've been working with them over the past year to refine certain aspects of the application
1:42:29 and to get costs more concrete to know exactly what our budget was.
1:42:35 So that's what this one is here.
1:42:36 So basically we're trying to get some sound reduction in the, because of the fact it has
1:42:41 12 foot ceilings and it's cheaper to put those up versus lowering the ceilings and replacing
1:42:46 the spring push system.
1:42:48 So one of the things that we want to talk about was the handicap accessibility.
1:42:55 It was all placed on the back side of the building, but the doors for handicap accessibility
1:42:59 are on the front side.
1:43:01 And it's cheaper for me to have the sidewalk ripped out in the front of the building and
1:43:05 lower the sidewalk to meet the accessibility codes on the front of the building.
1:43:11 And in that way, because if I try to fix the doors, it's going to cost about $15,000 to
1:43:16 like both of them swinging and out with mechanisms
1:43:19 and with the inspections from the city,
1:43:21 they basically said,
1:43:22 I'm not gonna keep them on the hinges
1:43:24 with the wind blowing over there.
1:43:26 So that's what we've looked through there.
1:43:28 We're also trying,
1:43:32 we've also done improvements to the rest of the building.
1:43:35 It's just basically the main hall area
1:43:37 that's left to be painted and to have the sound tiles
1:43:40 and we've been constantly doing that.
1:43:41 We've also put numerous amount of electrical upgrades
1:43:45 to handle the capacity of our new computer room
1:43:48 and the upgrades into the kitchen.
1:43:50 So right now the estimate cost is $181,271.
1:43:56 We're asking for approximately $144,000.
1:44:01 And when I was here with Carleen from Region 4,
1:44:03 she thinks we need to put a little bit of a contingency
1:44:07 into our plan, so we may increase that
1:44:09 just a little bit more.
1:44:10 And then, basically, I think I can come up with approximately $6,626 to be able to help
1:44:19 with the project, and then the rest of it is the $15,674 or things that we've already
1:44:26 done that were hoping that they'll approve and allow us to match with.
1:44:30 So, and then the in-kind contributions is the last column or things that we're willing
1:44:35 to do.
1:44:36 recently took the grant administrator test because I used to do the Idaho Department of
1:44:42 Commerce grants 27 years ago and I did pass so now I have the certification to administer
1:44:48 the grant myself. So that will help with some in-kind and that's basically it. Is there
1:44:55 any questions?
1:44:56 Chris, don't you?
1:44:58 I believe when we're off this goes back before my time or in between my times and I don't
1:45:03 think you were here. I don't know who I'm pointing the question now, but I think we should all
1:45:08 be really upset that a building I thought that was built with city funds or through some sort of
1:45:14 grant co-granting was apparently built so shoddily, and that's not that old, is it?
1:45:20 The building, I don't know how old exactly the building is because we figured it was built in
1:45:24 about 1991, I think, and we've been in it 13 years. Okay, that sounds about reasonable,
1:45:29 that was before coming back on but for the insulation to be virtually no
1:45:35 insulation and for the unbalanced heating cooling system that something
1:45:40 doesn't sound right on that. Well like I said we've got plenty of insulation in
1:45:43 the ceiling which is around all the massive duct work but like I said the
1:45:47 city employees that have been up there the engineers or the electricians they
1:45:52 don't like going up there either because it is absolutely a nightmare on how
1:45:55 things were cut apart, went through the firewalls, some it goes through, some goes around, things
1:46:02 that are like that. But like I said, I went and talked to three heating agencies and basically
1:46:07 I don't, in order for me to fix the units, I have to figure out how to get those run sizes
1:46:12 down. And what the recommendation is, is to, the big unit that's in the middle is basically
1:46:17 a ten ton unit that's on the roof, is to take that unit out first and then pull everything
1:46:23 out so then they can pull everything out through the top and then put the rest of the units back
1:46:29 in and put the duct work in.
1:46:31 I think the texture has got shorted I guess.
1:46:33 Well, Janette, I think that the question really is about the construction.
1:46:36 So we're planning just the building.
1:46:38 Yeah, because it was the treasure code.
1:46:40 It was privately built.
1:46:42 I mean, the city assumed it.
1:46:43 But it was new at the time.
1:46:45 It was bought and built.
1:46:47 It was built by some private individuals as treasure code if you remember it.
1:46:51 It was the amusement laser tag
1:46:54 It was in the early 90s. I guess it was because it's after I left. Okay, so it was private private operation
1:47:01 Well, it was a private operation, but I think
1:47:03 We had something to do with it because it was the ID money or something that was involved. You had a two-year
1:47:10 Levy override
1:47:12 That allowed you to acquire it and it was an existing structure at the time in which you did
1:47:18 It was privately built.
1:47:24 Yeah, it was not built from the ground up.
1:47:26 It was not built by the city and associated with the levy override.
1:47:31 It was renovated and remodeled and acquired through that process and whatever renovations
1:47:36 occur.
1:47:37 Also, I think it's important to recognize and bitch is sharing with me that we believe
1:47:41 that at the time in which the original building was constructed, it was an era before the
1:47:48 The state had mandatory inspections when it came to mechanical.
1:47:52 And so those would have been at the time in which the treasure cove or whatever that structure was, was built for the first time.
1:48:06 I have completely tested everything I know about that now.
1:48:10 Thank you Mayor. I do have another question though. Hopefully you know I was just wondering when the city took it over. We didn't inspect it or in the purchase usually you have an inspection done or that sort of thing.
1:48:25 I am going to have to plead ignorance. It was 1991 or maybe 13 years ago. So I'm going to. Yeah, I can't tell you.
1:48:39 But in looking back with there be any record of an inspection.
1:48:43 We haven't been able to locate one.
1:48:45 Mitch and I have been working on it for what, about three months?
1:48:49 OK.
1:48:49 Hey, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:48:52 I don't have a question, but I want to say thank you for my tour
1:48:55 when I was down there last month.
1:48:56 And I think you've done a wonderful job with what
1:48:59 you've had to work with and the improvements you've
1:49:01 made and the soundproofing board that you've already put up
1:49:04 and the painting and all the hard work you and your staff
1:49:07 have put into the building.
1:49:08 And I want to say thank you.
1:49:09 I appreciate you.
1:49:10 Thank you.
1:49:11 I appreciate it.
1:49:14 Doesn't look like we have any other questions.
1:49:15 Do we have a staff report regarding this?
1:49:21 I guess the two things.
1:49:22 Number one, Carlin is here here if you had any questions
1:49:24 about how this might impact other block grants
1:49:26 that we're going forward with.
1:49:28 The answer is it will not.
1:49:30 All the federal requirements that are required associated
1:49:32 with this will be running through our grant processes
1:49:36 to alleviate them of those concerns.
1:49:38 Carlin shared with me that Regent Forres
1:49:40 gonna run those associated with the two Cliffpart grants
1:49:43 that we have, staff is supportive of the effort
1:49:46 and we would echo the comments that you had
1:49:49 with Jeanette and what this thing looks like
1:49:52 in the effort that she's put forward.
1:49:55 Very good.
1:49:55 There's our staff report.
1:49:56 So if there are no further questions
1:49:59 for either staff or Jeanette,
1:50:01 we will open up the public hearing portion of this meeting.
1:50:05 So, Jen, if you want to have a seat just for a moment.
1:50:09 Okay.
1:50:09 There might be some other questions,
1:50:11 and we will give you time to rebut
1:50:13 any of the public testimony that might come forward.
1:50:16 So, this time I open up the public testimony portion
1:50:19 of tonight's hearing and allow anyone
1:50:22 from the public to come forward.
1:50:27 I see no one coming forward,
1:50:28 so we are closing the public testimony portion
1:50:31 of this hearing and any final comments
1:50:35 that you would have, Jeanette, before I turn it over to Council for deliberation, or any
1:50:41 final questions they might have.
1:50:43 The only other thing I'd like to say, and it just relates back to the grant, is I've been
1:50:47 keeping statistics.
1:50:48 I've been there, it's actually two years at the end of this month, that I've been the
1:50:52 site manager there.
1:50:53 And from the time I first started running the center, that's why I gave the second sheet,
1:50:57 it was to give you an update I did this year ago.
1:51:01 There was less than 400 people that utilized the center.
1:51:03 At the very bottom it tells you that my congregate members, which are the people that actually eat at the center,
1:51:08 that was 1241 people as of December 31st.
1:51:12 That means that they came into that center at least once within a year.
1:51:16 Because if they didn't, they used to fall off the list.
1:51:18 Now we get to keep them on the list.
1:51:20 They changed the rules as of February 1st.
1:51:22 But that's quite a difference in the number of people that are utilizing the center.
1:51:26 Also, the increase in the home-delivered meals and the people that are eating at the center.
1:51:34 Those two statistics there, we are the largest by far center in this region out of the 15 senior centers.
1:51:43 Thank you.
1:51:44 Any further questions, council?
1:51:48 I'll turn it over to the deliberation and our motions.
1:51:51 Chris Cotton.
1:51:52 Have a resolution number?
1:51:54 The ailer.
1:51:55 1919.
1:51:56 I would move that resolution 1918 be passed by the council authorizing the mayor to sign
1:52:03 the submit an application that had Department of Commerce to partially finance improvements
1:52:09 the Twin Falls Senior Center.
1:52:10 1919, Kristin.
1:52:11 We have a motion on the floor by Chris Tottenham approving ordinance or excuse me resolution
1:52:23 19 19 seconded by Greg Lanting anything further on this motion council the either
1:52:32 roll call vote please Jim on yes Sean Berger yes yes talking ten yes Greg
1:52:40 Lanting yes Don Hall yes Rebecca Milsweka yes Suzanne Hawkins yes motion passes
1:52:47 seven to zero. We don't need to attach a dollar amount to this
1:52:52 though. No big. The city has absolutely no financial liability
1:53:00 we're working directly with them. Anything further Council? I'd reiterate
1:53:08 thank you again and good luck. I want to do a little advertising on here. I'd
1:53:14 just like to remind everybody that we're having our spring-fing fundraiser on
1:53:17 March 1st, which is this Saturday, we're having a try-tip dinner that's being prepared by our ship,
1:53:22 live auction, silent auctions, and Gary and Cindy Braun. So the tickets are $25 and they're going very fast.
1:53:29 Have an opportunity, please come out and support us. Thank you.
1:53:31 March 1st, huh?
1:53:33 Thank you. And what date was that again?
1:53:35 Saturday, March 1st.
1:53:36 Saturday, March 1st. Thank you very much, Jeanette. Nice job tonight.
1:53:40 Number two, under public hearing, is public hearing the consideration to consider the city's intent to
1:53:47 to dispose of a 6,200 give or take square foot portion of City-owned lot located at
1:53:55 aunt at or on second have a new South block 119 lots nine and ten and we have
1:54:03 Melinda Anderson thank you mayor thank you council members as I'm here again
1:54:11 representing the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency in their request to ask the city to transfer.
1:54:20 A city owned piece of property on 2nd Avenue South adjacent to, as you recall, a building
1:54:28 at 122, excuse me, 242 2nd Avenue, South as owned by the Urban Renewal Agency to offer.
1:54:38 For the agency to offer both this vacant lot for parking as well as the building to help
1:54:43 get it redeveloped. Tonight, as you know, is the public hearing. That was approved when
1:54:49 you approved Resolution 1918 a few weeks ago. And so, I'm acting both as the applicant and
1:54:58 as the staff report tonight to ask that the council hold a public hearing on this matter
1:55:06 and then to approve this request to make the transfer so that next week staff can bring
1:55:11 back an ordinance making it official thank you. Thank you. Melinda any questions for
1:55:18 Melinda Council I see no questions so at this time I'm going to open up the public
1:55:27 hearing testimony portion of our hearing this evening for anyone that would like
1:55:32 to come forward and testify make comments regarding this issue I see no
1:55:40 one coming forward so at this time I'll close the public testimony portion of the
1:55:44 hearing and turn it on to council for any further questions and or motion great
1:55:50 money. We need a third and final on this for an ordinance. That's coming back.
1:55:56 If we can just get a vote from you open ordinance next week. I move that we
1:56:01 approve the request to the city's intent to dispose of the 6200 square feet
1:56:07 portion of the city on property. Second Avenue South block not 119 last 9 in 10
1:56:13 and then dispose of that property to the
1:56:17 every new agency, is that correct?
1:56:20 And bring back, should we stay, bring back an ordinance
1:56:22 or buy it in that?
1:56:24 Bring back an ordinance, just a future meeting.
1:56:27 Second.
1:56:27 We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,
1:56:30 seconded by Sean Berriger.
1:56:32 Any further on that motion council?
1:56:36 I see nothing further.
1:56:38 So, Leada, roll call vote please.
1:56:40 Sean Berriger.
1:56:41 Yes.
1:56:42 Yes.
1:56:43 Yes.
1:56:44 very glancing yes yes yes yes motion passes six to one very welcome
1:56:58 and thank you for your presentation anything further from council anything
1:57:01 further from staff we stand adjourned
Download
- Transcript (text) 104 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 139 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 190 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 6.7 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, February 24, 2014. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:58:31.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
c29b92d554f57a5445673953afefbeb6573c566e4b0dc2eb6d6d0a638ed6397e - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a dbce2ace037a2aed5069d7d4cbf0314f445f0df407fe12ab6a9643d0f4ea4760
part02.m4a 291c0a8c0485a6c984175ddb97061f9a49b23fe9b63f526285310dfadb3c63ec - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
550844c11b33e8fa006aa16f2589638e4ec2dfd2ad47f2c00cabb7247995c8e1
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file