OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 21, 2013

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:02:41 I'd like to call the order of the Monday, October 21st, 2013, a meeting of the Twin Falls City Council.

0:02:47 Our first item is always as the pledge of allegiance, if you'd like to join us, please rise.

0:02:56 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:03:08 a little bigger pause and I noticed rewatching the meeting from last Thursday that I didn't

0:03:18 get the equipment early since it kind of hits the bus before we started so. I do it for

0:03:23 him but we do have a quorum but his six of the seven members are here. The introduction

0:03:27 of some of the staff in present, City Manager, Crafts, Wiler, City Attorney, Fritz Wonder,

0:03:33 like I assume we'll be here, the mean development director Mitch Humble, Deputy City Clerk,

0:03:39 Secretary of the Senate, Staff Engineer Lee Glazeman,

0:03:43 Vice President of the other one.

0:03:45 Senator Jackie Fields.

0:03:50 We have, Travis, do we have any considerations

0:03:52 to the amendments to the agenda?

0:03:55 Yes, Mr. Mayor, we have two.

0:03:58 One of them is just a revised or amended meeting minutes

0:04:02 from October 7th, 2013.

0:04:04 Those were emailed to you earlier today,

0:04:06 that correction was noted by the island.

0:04:09 So since that was a part of your normal meeting packet,

0:04:12 we would ask that you acknowledge that as an amended copy.

0:04:15 The second is we have a beer and wine license

0:04:17 for John T. Incorporated doing business as a stone house

0:04:20 and company at 334th Avenue South.

0:04:24 That item should have been placed before you

0:04:27 at your desks before the meeting.

0:04:29 We can stand for any questions.

0:04:30 Chris, I do have one question on accounts payable,

0:04:33 Mayor Saul, I'd like you to decide if you want to take

0:04:36 it off or if I can just ask the question.

0:04:37 on the accounts payable for knife river for the auger falls project is an even

0:04:44 amount of $500,000 payment I'm assuming this is payment in progress for the total

0:04:50 project as opposed to a completed project. We often get $500,000 in zero zero

0:04:56 cents payment. We've Glazeman is here he's the engineering over the project and he

0:05:01 can stand and address that. It was a data entry issue the actual amount was

0:05:08 five hundred and ten thousand but when it was written out on the type form the

0:05:12 five looked like a dollar sign and so Knight River was expecting a check for

0:05:16 five hundred and ten they got a check for ten and they got it to our attention

0:05:21 oh okay so we gave him ten thousand said five hundred ten thousand yeah that must

0:05:29 finish we we underpaid them to go around the second that's a great bid

0:05:34 All right.

0:05:35 I'm going to entertain a motion to amend the agenda as described by Travis.

0:05:42 So moved.

0:05:43 Second.

0:05:44 Then moved by Don Hall and seconded by Jim Munn to amend the agenda as described by Mr.

0:05:53 Rothweidler.

0:05:54 Seeing no discussion, the aye will roll call vote.

0:05:57 Don Hall.

0:05:58 Yes.

0:05:59 Yes.

0:06:00 Greg Lansing.

0:06:01 Yes.

0:06:02 Jim Munn.

0:06:03 Yes.

0:06:04 Rebecca Milzweka.

0:06:05 Yes. Motion has the consent calendar has been amended as described by six-dills

0:06:13 vote. Now moving on to the consent calendar as a whole. Do I have a motion?

0:06:17 Move approval. Second.

0:06:21 Then moved by Suzanne Hawkins and seconded by Don Hall to approve the amended consent

0:06:27 calendar. Seeing no white, the other roll call vote.

0:06:30 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanthine. Yes. Jim Mann. Yes. Rebecca Milsweka. Yes.

0:06:35 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Moving on to the first item of

0:06:43 consideration is consideration of request to award the 2013 wastewater treatment plant

0:06:49 dewatering improvements project to performance systems of Fruitland I know in the

0:06:53 amount of three million five hundred fifty seven thousand one hundred and thirty

0:06:57 nine dollars. Leak basement for our engineering department. Good evening

0:07:10 Mayor and Council. The project that we're talking about is actually, this is the

0:07:17 treatment plant north is at this end to the left, down by the UV system that we

0:07:23 have created a couple years ago and this location right here is where we're

0:07:28 doing the improvements. It's a dewatering building with belt filter presses. In 2011

0:07:36 the city sought and received judicial confirmation of our funds to be able to

0:07:40 rehabilitate various wastewater components, including replacement of the aging dewatering

0:07:44 system at the City's wastewater treatment plant. The old dewatering system is in this building

0:07:50 right here. The dewatering system improvements are the final project to be constructed with

0:07:54 the judicially confirmed funds. In February of 2013, the City awarded a pre-selection bid

0:08:00 for two belt filter presses to be included in the dewatering design. In May of 2013, the

0:08:06 City passed a special bond election to fund additional improvements to the wastewater treatment

0:08:12 plant which included the installation of a third belt filter press.

0:08:16 So for the judicially confirmed funds we were going to install two belt presses and then on

0:08:23 the bond fund we were going to install a third belt press.

0:08:26 Subsequent to the sewer bond approval was determined that cost savings would be realized

0:08:30 if all three of the belt presses could be installed all in one project rather than two

0:08:35 separate projects. So that's what we decided to do is by utilizing the remainder of the

0:08:42 judicially confirmed funds with the balance being funded with the sewer bond funds. On September

0:08:47 26, bids were open for the 2013 wastewater treatment plant dewatering improvement project

0:08:53 and yes I do try to keep those names shorter but I'm not going to lie. Four bids were received

0:08:58 ranging from $3,557,039 to $4,183,000, with the lowest apparent bid coming from Performance

0:09:07 Systems, Inc. Psi of Fruitland, Idaho. CH2M Hill, the city's consultant on the project, reviewed

0:09:13 the bids and considered them responsive. CH2M Hill further reviewed their bid estimate, which

0:09:18 ranged from roughly $2.8 million to $3.6 million, with a target estimate of $3.1. They determined

0:09:25 that the low bid was within the accuracy range

0:09:27 of the estimate classification they performed

0:09:29 as defined by the American Association

0:09:31 of Cost Engineering standards.

0:09:34 They have provided additional explanation,

0:09:35 and I included that.

0:09:37 It's quite a lengthy explanation.

0:09:43 Regarding potential reasons for the low bid coming in

0:09:45 near the high end of the range,

0:09:47 the primary considerations included potential higher costs

0:09:50 due to the lack of local bidders on the project

0:09:52 and possible trend in higher construction costs

0:09:54 in the Twin Falls market.

0:10:00 As I described before, funding comes from two sources,

0:10:02 judicially confirmed funding and sewer bond funding.

0:10:05 It's estimated that the construction of de-watering

0:10:06 improvements and related work will draw down the last of the

0:10:10 judicially confirmed funds, but about 910,000 coming from

0:10:13 sewer bond funds.

0:10:15 This project is important.

0:10:17 If the existing de-watering system fails, we could potentially

0:10:20 violate our NPS permit and actually have extra costs just

0:10:26 associated with temporary measures.

0:10:30 Staff recommends that the wastewater treatment dewatering

0:10:34 project be awarded to performance systems, Inc.

0:10:36 of Fruitland, and about $3,557,000, $39,000.

0:10:41 Questions?

0:10:42 Well, could you give us where the, I mean,

0:10:45 that performance is out of Fruitland?

0:10:47 You know the location of the other three entities?

0:10:52 I don't recall.

0:10:53 But they were all out of this area.

0:10:55 think most of them were in Boise and and and they'll believe us

0:10:59 it was basically they were on the Treasure Valley area.

0:11:03 Okay. Okay. Chris talking to you and then Rebecca

0:11:06 Millstig. Did you indicate that lawyer has looked over the

0:11:11 contract? You know, that was one of the considerations to make

0:11:17 sure that. See where I find it here. We can do that

0:11:27 prior approval. The city attorney is a word recommendation. And I

0:11:31 I think we had some minor glitch on our prior contract that was legal-esque, and I would feel better if we had Frix's review of this thing.

0:11:40 We can certainly do that.

0:11:42 Thank you, Mayor.

0:11:46 I'm glad that we can fight some cost savings in doing the belts altogether, but I'm a little bit surprised since the reason for the judicial confirmation back in 2011 was the fear that the belts were going to fail, and we would violate our permit.

0:12:01 So, have we been safe from violating our permit in these past two years?

0:12:08 I'm just surprised that we haven't, because I remember the discussion of the belt being

0:12:12 one of the major concerns for the emergency judicial confirmation instead of the longer

0:12:18 process of taking it to a vote.

0:12:20 So, I was just wondering how we were doing, and if we were at any risk in the past two

0:12:26 years?

0:12:27 We've certainly been living on borrowed time.

0:12:30 There was a substantial amount of time involved

0:12:32 with the design and there have been other things

0:12:36 that we've been doing and association with that bond also.

0:12:39 UV diffusers, headworks, there have been several other

0:12:44 projects that have been involved down there,

0:12:45 but yes, it is an urgent matter.

0:12:49 Great, well I'm glad to see that.

0:12:50 We're moving forward and it's a fortunate timing

0:12:54 that we've been compliant with our permit

0:12:57 in this time and that we can find some savings

0:12:59 in combining the projects.

0:13:01 That's great.

0:13:02 Travis?

0:13:03 I might just add on Deliz's comment

0:13:05 where the purpose of ordinary necessary

0:13:08 is not only in cases of emergency,

0:13:10 but it's to ensure that we're placing equipment

0:13:14 on a useful schedule when they've outlived

0:13:17 their useful life.

0:13:19 And so these are parts and pieces

0:13:21 that are critical to the operation

0:13:24 that need to be replaced.

0:13:25 And so we went to the process of ordinary necessary.

0:13:29 It was to replace equipment that had outlived its useful life.

0:13:32 It wasn't operating as efficiently and effectively as we had thought at that period of time.

0:13:38 And much to the credit of Lee and his team that he's working with, they were going down

0:13:45 the path.

0:13:46 And then when the opportunity of the bond came up, they said, what if?

0:13:50 And they illustrated the savings and it was considerable.

0:13:54 We did a risk analysis of going to bid, you know, it's one of those real gut check opportunities

0:14:01 and it came to the conclusion that the benefit of the savings of costs was far greater than

0:14:10 the potential risk that was there of the failure of the equipment.

0:14:14 Dr. Stockton?

0:14:15 I'm ready to make a motion.

0:14:17 I'm ready for a motion if you're ready to make one.

0:14:20 Council approve of the watering the watering

0:14:26 Bid submitted by performance systems in the matter of three million five five seven one hundred and thirty nine dollars even

0:14:33 subject to the city's attorneys review and approval

0:14:37 second

0:14:38 Then moved by Chris talking then second by Rebecca Mill so I get the award to

0:14:43 perform the systems of fruitland and amount of three million five hundred fifty seven thousand one hundred thirty nine dollars

0:14:49 with our attorney's approval of the contract before actually you should have it.

0:14:58 Seeing the lights, the other roll call vote.

0:15:01 Greg Lanting.

0:15:02 Yes.

0:15:03 Jim Mann.

0:15:04 Yes.

0:15:05 Rebecca Mills-Soyka.

0:15:06 Yes.

0:15:07 Chris Tonkin.

0:15:08 Yes.

0:15:09 Don Hall.

0:15:10 Yes.

0:15:11 Suzanne Honkin.

0:15:12 Yes.

0:15:13 Motion passes six to zero.

0:15:14 Thank you Lee.

0:15:15 Bill.

0:15:16 Is there a chance we can have you come up with a podium?

0:15:17 I've got a quick question for you.

0:15:19 Since we're on wastewater treatment things and stuff.

0:15:22 Maybe if you could just give us an update

0:15:24 on the design of our new system,

0:15:28 or our addition to our system?

0:15:30 Yes, we have, we're essentially at the 30% completion level.

0:15:34 So we had, well, it's the Phase Two expansion project.

0:15:37 So we just finished with our 30% design.

0:15:39 We had a workshop with the city staff.

0:15:42 And in fact, we have another meeting coming up Wednesday

0:15:45 is to discuss some of the other cost estimates

0:15:48 and items on it, scheduling.

0:15:50 And then we're pushing to have the 60% design completed

0:15:54 here in November.

0:15:55 All right.

0:15:56 Thank you, Bill.

0:15:58 Moving on to item number two, which

0:16:00 is a consideration of request by Jerry and D. Packer

0:16:03 to waive the non-conforming building expansion permit

0:16:06 process to allow an expansion of an existing legal non-conforming

0:16:10 residents located at 539 Briar Cliff Drive, Ms. Humbler, our Community Development Director,

0:16:17 will be handling this one.

0:16:28 Thanks.

0:16:31 So, probably we're talking about here, this is, it's hard to see, but that actually sets

0:16:36 the Filer Avenue.

0:16:38 This is the extreme west end of Filer as we turn north into Briarwood, and this is a private

0:16:45 a large, lotish development on the Rock Creek Canyon.

0:16:51 So this shows where the proposed expansion to the home

0:17:00 and be, this is the home in question,

0:17:02 they're wanting to add an expansion to the side of it.

0:17:08 The home is non-conforming in that it sets too close

0:17:11 to the Canyon Rim for Rock Creek Canyon.

0:17:14 You see this measuring here at 28 feet.

0:17:17 The city code actually says you gotta be back

0:17:19 least 50 feet, 100 feet if you don't have a geologic study. And so, since the home is

0:17:26 at 28 feet, nonconforming designation comes into play, you can see from the plane here

0:17:33 that the expansion isn't proposed to be any closer, so we're not going to make it any more

0:17:38 nonconforming than it already is, which is one of those key things that we'll like to

0:17:42 look at when we talk about whether or not to waive the process. But it is within that

0:17:49 hundred foot setback still that would require the geologic study and that's

0:17:54 important because you'll see later on that we're going to get to the flower

0:17:57 yeah maybe if you want to go ahead and do this we should so get the geologic study

0:18:00 like the code says we need but anyway we have a nonconforming home the code does

0:18:06 give the opportunity for residential properties to come ask the council to

0:18:10 waive the the hearing process in order to grant a permit for a nonconforming

0:18:16 building expansion. If you guys decide not to grant this waiver, then the applicant would

0:18:22 have to go through a series of planning and planning commission in here and kind of invite

0:18:27 the public and the whole business there. In order to get the building permit, and that

0:18:33 adds 30 to 45 days or so, depending on how meeting dates fall out in the process to get

0:18:40 that. So oftentimes we'll come and talk to the council about a waiver of that process. For

0:18:44 residential properties. This is just one more though. So that kind of describes what's going

0:18:51 on, what the request is. If you guys would like to approve this, then we recommend go ahead

0:18:58 and say in subject to city code, which includes the geologic survey or the geologic study being

0:19:05 done to make sure that the ground under there isn't going to, you know, fall into the canyon

0:19:10 with a bunch more weight on it, so with that,

0:19:13 we can really answer your questions if you have any,

0:19:15 and I believe their applicant representation is here as well.

0:19:19 Okay, thank you Mitch.

0:19:21 Would anybody from the applicant like to give you

0:19:24 five minutes to kind of give us your thoughts on it?

0:19:27 Somebody want to step forward and identify yourself

0:19:29 and say your address?

0:19:30 I'm Jerry Packard, owner of the property and question.

0:19:37 First of all, I'd like to thank the city council

0:19:39 for their time, I know it's precious,

0:19:41 I don't want to take a lot of it out.

0:19:43 And I don't want to go over a bunch of stuff that's already

0:19:45 been submitted because you have that knowledge.

0:19:49 But I would like to stand here and ask.

0:19:51 If you have any questions, maybe I could answer them.

0:19:55 OK.

0:19:56 We've got a few lights coming on here.

0:19:58 Donald was your first friend.

0:20:00 Who was?

0:20:01 Who was?

0:20:02 Donald.

0:20:03 Mitch, I have a question for you.

0:20:07 This home was built prior to our ruling

0:20:10 that it had to be 50 and 100, how did that happen?

0:20:14 Right, I want to say the data on this home was about 1970.

0:20:17 So our Canyon and Sep Act didn't come in until the 90s.

0:20:20 So this actually predates that by a good length of time.

0:20:24 OK.

0:20:25 I have no questions for you, Jerry.

0:20:27 Chris talking to?

0:20:28 Hi, Jerry.

0:20:29 How are you?

0:20:30 A long time ago, I was saying.

0:20:32 Do you have any problems with seeking a geologic surveyors

0:20:37 opinion on the stability of the ground for their proposed

0:20:39 addition?

0:20:40 I thought it all, maybe I'm a little misinformed on the exact process, but I didn't want to

0:20:48 spend the money for a survey until I knew if it was going to be a possibility we'd get

0:20:55 it approved.

0:20:56 And so I thought we needed to get the variance first and then do it, or I guess need some

0:21:02 direction from you on that.

0:21:04 And if the Council did approve it, I would guess that there would be some resources available

0:21:08 if you want to ask one of our city staff of names, qualified surveyors, okay?

0:21:13 Rebecca, we're back in minutes, look.

0:21:15 Thank you, Mary.

0:21:17 I don't have a question for Jerry, but I do have a comment on, I remember that a similar

0:21:23 request had come to us earlier this year and it was in February where the council did waive

0:21:29 the process and they did not require a geological study, and so I had asked the staff for the

0:21:34 And the recommendation was to approve the request

0:21:40 without the geological study.

0:21:42 And at the time I was against it, you know,

0:21:45 I really felt that we should do it.

0:21:46 But in an effort to be fair and consistent, you know,

0:21:52 in the minutes it says that it passed without a geological

0:21:56 study that the last permit that came to us.

0:21:58 And then Zoning and Development Manager Caraway stated

0:22:02 that the property on the west side of that home had gone

0:22:07 through a legal nonconforming expansion permit process

0:22:10 and a geological study was not required.

0:22:13 And she also stated that it is historically

0:22:16 a remodel of an existing structure has not been required

0:22:19 to complete the study.

0:22:21 So in an effort of consistency, I

0:22:25 would be in favor of not requiring the geological study.

0:22:30 Jim, I'm OK.

0:22:33 Thank you, Mayor.

0:22:34 I'm ready to make a motion for done.

0:22:37 I would move to waive the nonconforming building expansion

0:22:40 permit process to allow an expansion of an existing legal

0:22:43 nonconforming residence located at 539 Breyer clip drive

0:22:50 without a geological deal.

0:22:53 Second.

0:22:55 I move by Jim Mullins.

0:22:56 Second by Rebecca Belsleke that we approved the nonconforming

0:23:01 building expansion permit process to allow expansion

0:23:05 that for 539 Briarwood Cliff Drive without

0:23:08 and geological study, Suzanne Hock.

0:23:12 I don't have the minutes from that meeting,

0:23:14 but if I remember that previous house

0:23:17 was just a remodel and not an add-on, there was no addition.

0:23:21 They were just doing some remodel work

0:23:22 and had to come before us.

0:23:24 And I think that might be the difference

0:23:25 where this time we're actually adding on to the structure

0:23:28 and not just remodeling it, but I don't know

0:23:30 if I'm correct on that.

0:23:31 Does anybody know?

0:23:33 Travis.

0:23:35 The issue that came before you in 2013 could be classified more of a significant rebuild.

0:23:42 As opposed to an extension or expansion of the facility.

0:23:47 If I remember in the February 2013 case that was owned by Mr. John Davis.

0:23:55 Essentially the front portion of the building was the only thing that remained and

0:24:00 it was the entire back portion that was completely reconstructed.

0:24:05 I would just add the building footprint changed slightly.

0:24:12 If you wanted to put this photo up on the overhead, you can.

0:24:28 But in both cases, it doesn't encroach further into the setback.

0:24:33 I think that was the guideline.

0:24:36 Do we remember how far this was back?

0:24:40 I think it's like 29 feet or something.

0:24:44 I feel so much more.

0:24:46 I can, this is hard to see it here.

0:24:49 So just for everybody else's sake,

0:24:52 the photograph shows the stark gray kind of,

0:24:55 that's the home as it existed at the time the photo was taken.

0:24:59 This red kind of drawn in outline, I guess,

0:25:02 was gonna be the proposed remodel home.

0:25:05 So the footprint did change dramatically.

0:25:10 That's just so everybody can understand

0:25:12 what they're looking at there.

0:25:13 Sure, you did.

0:25:14 All right, thank you.

0:25:17 Well, there are two issues.

0:25:18 I think we need to resolve, first of all,

0:25:20 we're talking about the difference between

0:25:23 Snake River Canyon and Rock Creek,

0:25:25 and there's a vast difference,

0:25:26 so far as the vertical distances,

0:25:28 and I'd be remiss to say that I'm not sure

0:25:34 if it's the right thing to weigh them in either case,

0:25:36 but I see a consistency problem,

0:25:38 because if we do not require a geologic survey here,

0:25:42 here are two back-to-back proposals that we waive,

0:25:45 What do we do on the next applicant that is in a known

0:25:49 fault area, whether it's on raw creek or snake river canyon?

0:25:53 I think we're getting into more difficulty by waving this

0:25:57 and sending a standard that completely violates our setback,

0:26:01 safety, building safety, consideration via the geologic

0:26:07 survey.

0:26:08 I certainly don't want to impose additional,

0:26:11 unnecessary expenses on Mr. Packer.

0:26:13 But I think we're going to arc inconsistency by not requiring this going to cause us more

0:26:18 problem than solve.

0:26:20 Mitch, do we have an estimate of what the geologic survey might cost?

0:26:30 Everybody, all my engineers are shaking their head.

0:26:34 It's under 100,000, Jerry, we know that.

0:26:36 More than $1,000 less than 100,000 is the company.

0:26:43 Mr. Mayor, if you'll give us one second, I believe that that discussion came up in February

0:26:49 We're going to look in the meeting minutes real quick.

0:26:52 And while poor Mr. Packer is standing there, I'll ask him a question because I appreciate

0:27:02 you not wanting to repeat the information we have, but for the publics who are just tuning

0:27:07 into the meeting for their edification.

0:27:10 In your letter, you stated that this addition is because of mobility issues, because of your

0:27:17 daughter having a wheelchair and so you're needing all the bedrooms and the bathrooms are

0:27:22 upstairs, and you're needing a bedroom and bathroom on the ground floor, is that correct?

0:27:29 That's correct.

0:27:30 Okay.

0:27:31 When we bought the home, we were younger and we thought, uh, what matter, you know, and

0:27:35 as we get older, uh, even for the wife and I, we never know when we might not be able to

0:27:42 maneuver the stairs, but we've recently, uh, had some developments have come in play that

0:27:49 require our daughter to live with us in that she is not able to do the stairs and

0:27:55 she's either wheelchair or stroller dependent on you know whether it's a good day or bad day

0:28:04 and so we could probably get her up the stairs and down all right but there's no

0:28:11 a shower or bathroom facilities upstairs so I think that there is a bathroom that

0:28:18 about stairs without a shower or bathtub.

0:28:21 That's why we'd like to have the bedroom on for her,

0:28:25 and then that would include the shower and bathtub.

0:28:30 Thank you for that information.

0:28:31 I think it's important to consider

0:28:33 that it's not an aesthetic remodel or something like that.

0:28:36 It actually is for ADA accessibility,

0:28:39 and I think that's important

0:28:41 because your house is in that canyon set back regardless,

0:28:45 And according to the code, you get the geologic study

0:28:48 because it will set where your setback needs to be.

0:28:51 And so whether you get the study or not,

0:28:53 I don't think it's going to change where your house is.

0:28:56 And the addition is just alongside of that.

0:28:59 So while I agree with Councilman Talkington,

0:29:02 I think we have kind of created a problem

0:29:04 of violating our own code.

0:29:06 But in the past, we have waived this study.

0:29:09 And so it is difficult to all of a sudden

0:29:11 start to apply that requirement, and when do you do that?

0:29:15 But I certainly think that the ADA accessibility

0:29:19 is a valid consideration in this case.

0:29:23 Travis, did you find the information?

0:29:25 There is a number listed in the meeting minutes,

0:29:28 and it's a relatively large number.

0:29:32 And I want to say that Mitch and I are looking at it.

0:29:37 And when we talk about it, it doesn't necessarily

0:29:40 say the size of the land in which the geological study was performed on, it doesn't talk about

0:29:46 the location.

0:29:47 And so it may be Mitch and I are looking at it and believing that if the number provided

0:29:54 in the meeting minutes in our opinion does not represent an apples to apples illustration

0:30:00 of what those potential costs could be.

0:30:03 Don Hall, I have a question for Fritz, I have a question for Fritz, sir.

0:30:12 Okay, Fritz, if we approve this without asking for the geological survey or study, does, and there is some sort of a canyon fall-in issue, are we bringing liability upon the city by approving something that is non-conforming and not?

0:30:33 You're certainly not guaranteeing that it's a stable site by any means and I think by this

0:30:37 discussion you're indicating to the applicant that he might want to consider.

0:30:43 In fact I think he even talked about a geologic study so it is a canyon rim.

0:30:49 I agree with what Travis says.

0:30:50 I don't think this is apples and oranges because if you remember the site there's a

0:30:55 sheer cliff like 400 feet.

0:30:58 On the other one.

0:30:59 in that area and we know we have some recent rock fall in that area and this part of rock

0:31:03 creek is not like that.

0:31:05 Okay.

0:31:06 Okay.

0:31:07 I guess I'm in the mode of just thinking we need to be as consistent as possible but

0:31:14 I would say if it was my property, I'd probably want to study.

0:31:19 All right.

0:31:20 We have to do a motion on the floor that was to approve or to waive the nonconfrontal

0:31:25 expansion permit process for the property of 539 Briarwood, Briar cliff drive without a

0:31:33 Geologic study

0:31:37 Moved to amend to remove the exclusion not requiring the

0:31:43 Geologic serving

0:31:44 an amendment by Chris talking to him to remove the portion of the the motion that had to do with a

0:31:53 the not requiring it. Yeah not requiring it. That's the no second. Now I can vote

0:32:01 quick. See no additional lights. We have a roll call vote on the main motion. Jim

0:32:09 Munn. Yes. Rebecca Milsica. Yes. Chris Talkington. No. Don Hall. Yes. Suzanne

0:32:17 Yes. Great. Yes. Motion passes five to one. Like like Councilman Halzer vice mayor

0:32:28 Halzer I might have my property I might have one anyway so that's up good to be up to you.

0:32:33 Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. I'm not opposed to your project. And I

0:32:41 appreciate your I want to go on the record that and I might just mention that's

0:32:47 that's why you have the statutes that allow for you to take individual cases

0:32:53 and and if an excellent comes along that isn't there's some question on it that's

0:32:59 really a concern then you're by right you should be different but on the same

0:33:05 token that I just wanted to mention too we are in the county it's just in the city

0:33:10 impact zones as far as your liability question. I wouldn't think you'd be half liable. And

0:33:20 I might add we've lived there for over 30 years and in 1980 there was an earthquake, as most

0:33:26 of you remember, and it rattled the chandeliers and shook the doors and nothing changed and

0:33:32 no cracks as well. No movement of any kind that I've ever seen. So we felt pretty comfortable

0:33:40 All right.

0:33:41 Thank you, Mr. Packer.

0:33:44 Next item of business is public input, is anyone in the audience that has something they

0:33:48 wanted to bring to the council's attention?

0:33:50 I've seen no one coming forward, City Manager.

0:33:57 Mr. Mayor, members of the council and also for the benefit of those watching and maybe encouraging

0:34:04 our friends in the media to assist in helping us get the word out, but we're also going

0:34:08 to be sending a series of PSAs on top of this.

0:34:11 On Wednesday, November 6th at 7 o'clock in the evening, we're going to be holding a community

0:34:17 discussion on bicycle connectivity.

0:34:22 The idea of the conversation is to really look at that accessible community part of our strategic

0:34:27 plan and begin to have conversations about how do we create connecting opportunities, utilizing

0:34:36 existing infrastructure, and bringing people for where they want to travel.

0:34:43 So the idea of the first meeting is to more gather input to find out where people who use

0:34:49 bicycling as a form of commuting, the places that they desire to go, and then building and

0:34:55 creating a series of main bicycle connection points throughout that.

0:35:04 We are going to be doing some work, and we've been working with members of our community on

0:35:09 this process along the way, and so now it's a really good opportunity to get the community's

0:35:14 engagement and involvement to see what are those steps moving forward.

0:35:18 We have funds that we put in the budget for this year, and so it's utilizing that $20,000

0:35:23 thereabouts that we talked about under Parks and Recreation.

0:35:28 So once we've defined those routes, and I use the term route loosely because there's a legal

0:35:33 connotation with the term route that we're looking at possibly avoiding, but the idea is

0:35:39 to provide, share the road type concept with members of the bicycle community and members

0:35:45 of those traditional commuters.

0:35:47 We have some lights, none at all.

0:35:49 I have a couple of comments.

0:35:51 One is on the bike issue.

0:35:53 Could you send that email out on the date when we're having that meeting, when you have

0:35:57 it in it?

0:35:58 If I do that, it'd be helpful.

0:36:00 But I noticed the other day when we had our wonderful event here that we had at least one

0:36:04 bicycle out there that had to chain themselves to a traffic sign.

0:36:09 And I'm wondering if it's time for us to start talking about maybe putting some bicycle routes

0:36:14 or bicycle racks at strategic locations and city property by e-city council chambers, city

0:36:22 hall, police department, those kind of things.

0:36:25 So I thought I'd mention that.

0:36:29 And number two, we had a great meeting today with the historic preservation committee commission,

0:36:34 excuse me, where Darrow Buffalo came in and gave a great training for it because we have

0:36:39 a lot of new faces on our new commission.

0:36:42 And it was really worthwhile to just give you a preview.

0:36:45 They will be coming to the city council next week at our next meeting, I believe.

0:36:50 I think it's going to be on the agenda and talking to us about their five-year strategic

0:36:55 plan for the commission and to approach the council to obviously make sure that's in our

0:37:03 view the direction they should be going to but you'll be proud of this committee they're

0:37:07 very very active.

0:37:08 Thank you.

0:37:09 I don't remember anything else like it.

0:37:12 Thank you Mayor.

0:37:13 I just wanted to share about an event that I think some of us got to go to last Tuesday

0:37:19 which was sponsored by the Times News and the Attorney General's Office regarding open meeting

0:37:24 laws and public records and it was quite informative and I wanted to encourage the council to either

0:37:31 I'll email you a link to the electronic version or you can get a paper version of there's a

0:37:36 manual that the Attorney General has created on open meeting laws and I learned a lot of

0:37:43 new information at this session, especially relating to how deliberation and decisions

0:37:52 and governing bodies are defined by the statute and it's good to read up on that.

0:38:00 And it actually started me thinking about which committees, you know, most of our committees

0:38:06 actually are governed by open meeting laws and we definitely comply with most of that.

0:38:13 But we do have some committees that are not posted and I have gotten some citizen input

0:38:18 that, you know, maybe there's a citizen that wants to observe that portion of the deliberation.

0:38:23 And according to the Open Meeting Law, you really can't separate the deliberation from

0:38:29 the decision.

0:38:30 I mean, if it's a body that's making a recommendation to the agency, to the public agency, either

0:38:37 the council or the URA, the public, based on the intent of the law, has the right to view

0:38:46 the deliberations and a right to be a part of the process and know that it's going on.

0:38:52 So I'd like to have a conversation with the Council, possibly on a future agenda, to just

0:38:57 talk about which committees we would like to notify the public of and let the public view

0:39:02 that process.

0:39:03 I think it's important, I think there's an important statement in here by the Attorney

0:39:07 General that says, in general, if you're unsure whether a meeting should be open to the public,

0:39:13 should err on the side of being open and I would certainly support that. I know for its

0:39:18 support that so I would just like to have a conversation about having you know any you

0:39:24 know and this manual really goes through the legal decisions that have been made you know

0:39:29 not only in Idaho but in California and Florida that have really said that part of the deliberation

0:39:38 is part of the decision and so I think it matters that that part of the decision is open to the

0:39:44 public and complies with the laws intent to allow the public to watch their government at

0:39:52 work.

0:39:53 It's really their right.

0:39:55 So just want to make the council aware of that and be looking for that on an upcoming agenda.

0:40:01 Thank you.

0:40:02 Susan Harkins.

0:40:03 I just want to take a moment.

0:40:05 I know you all got the email today about the wonderful job our youth council did this week.

0:40:09 Last Friday they spent their afternoon out helping a citizen who was out of compliance

0:40:14 with weeds and problems in his yard and our group of kids went out there and worked their

0:40:19 little selves to death making sure all the weeds were pulled, the leaves were raked and

0:40:23 everything was cleaned up.

0:40:26 And the meeting right before the kids did that they also had two new members join.

0:40:30 And the youth council is doing great things.

0:40:32 They have a lot of things coming up and I just want to say it is wonderful having such

0:40:38 energy and youthful citizens willing to get out there and help in our community and I'm

0:40:42 proud of them.

0:40:44 Thank you Suzanne.

0:40:45 Do they need more practice?

0:40:47 No, I'm just teasing.

0:40:50 Chris talking about personal reflection.

0:40:53 I certainly compliment Rebecca for taking an acting role in reviewing our open meeting

0:40:59 laws.

0:41:00 My personal reflection is that a lot of the genesis for movement toward a state legislative

0:41:06 open meeting law came because of the serious and ongoing and continual violations of voting

0:41:13 open meetings that occurred in local government, including on Twin Falls City Council much

0:41:19 long ago, much before any of us were hardly even alive except me.

0:41:25 But I would say that the irony now is that the open meeting laws that are being so strictly

0:41:33 adhered to by this group in particular are flagrantly and violated for 90 out of 90 days

0:41:39 of every legislative meeting because the state legislature goes into what they call a caucus

0:41:45 which violates every definition of a meeting.

0:41:51 It should be open and they are not.

0:41:52 They explained to us at that night that they're not bound by the same open meeting laws we are.

0:41:58 Their rules come down from the state constitution and their statutes which are different.

0:42:02 So they're not in violation, they have a different rule book than we do.

0:42:06 I tell you what, if there were a majority of the state legislature agree they would have open meeting laws and

0:42:11 no caucuses, they are not bound by the constitution.

0:42:14 And that's how they explain and rationalize that they hold violating meeting laws that we can't get away with.

0:42:22 I will cut them no slack whatsoever, it's due as they say, not as they do.

0:42:27 And I brought that up that nice Chris doing a cheek because I knew that we weren't going to, I was going to the goose and the gander type thing.

0:42:35 They did say that due to a lawsuit that was brought concerning that similar issue to that, they have started following open meeting laws for all their committees.

0:42:45 if they didn't previously, but they have now passed policies

0:42:49 and rules within these legislature.

0:42:51 But I agree with the whole heart of the Chris,

0:42:53 but I don't see us in the change, either, so.

0:42:57 All right, batting up windmills now, and then, OK.

0:43:01 Anyone else in the city council has something

0:43:02 they would like to bring before the group?

0:43:05 Seeing none, we do have a executive session that's

0:43:11 on our docket for Idaho code 6723451C

0:43:17 to deflect which under C you can connect

0:43:21 the lorations concerning labor negotiations

0:43:23 or to acquire interest in the real property

0:43:25 which is not owned by a public agency.

0:43:27 One of the things they talked about that night Travis

0:43:29 was that one of the ways we could even be a little more open

0:43:33 is since that covers two different things.

0:43:35 If we're not covering both of them,

0:43:36 maybe we should leave one of them out.

0:43:38 especially that public school student one that is on

0:43:41 or quite often that was one of the ones they suggested that we do

0:43:44 that this.

0:43:45 Or say which one.

0:43:45 Yeah, say which one we are following under C not not not

0:43:49 actually list both.

0:43:50 So do we know which one we're following under C.

0:43:52 We do and we're looking at possibly acquiring real property

0:43:57 that is not owned by a public entity.

0:43:59 All right.

0:43:59 So I will change that to 672451C to acquire interest

0:44:04 in real property, which is not owned by a public agency.

0:44:08 Council wishes and we do have a light, Donald.

0:44:13 So moved.

0:44:14 All right.

0:44:15 And moved by Don Hall and seconded by Susanne Hawkins that we go into executive session

0:44:21 6723451C to discuss a quiet interest in a real property which is not owned by a public agency.

0:44:29 Seen the lights, Lea Rojolo.

0:44:33 Rebecca Milsoka?

0:44:34 Yes.

0:44:35 Chris Tockington?

0:44:36 Yes.

0:44:37 Don Hall?

0:44:38 Yes.

0:44:39 Yes, very glancing. Yes, Jim. Yes, and motion passes six to zero. We will not be

0:44:48 coming out and making any decisions after this meeting and we're adjourned to the

0:44:53 executive session. I got tired to say I'm glad they brought that but I got tired

0:45:06 to say about that.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 21, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:45:07.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    22f2d0fe0630b53c3fc57c7f4fcccc46f1ea0faf242d913a4972f6509a75943f
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a c169368da18235fc711b6953171121d41a737e847ba7fedcbc6739af721b1a3e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    7e1561db872044642c507b0eb0dc6537ffc46e5a85f07600664782b56901f9b2

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file