City Council meeting
Thursday, August 22, 2013
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:57 I'm sending good karma. Don't sigh about that. It's on 13th. Moving around long. My karma is better. Yes, because it does like it's two monitors.
0:01:50 They're good. They have two monitors. Right. I hope that doesn't come up that way because Rich did it the last time when I don't go. He can read.
0:02:00 He can. It's recent. It's recent. That's why he just.
0:04:20 We have 30 seconds to postpone, let's do it, and we're on streaming tonight, five of them
0:06:33 I think.
0:06:47 We have a chapter, sir, the priority, that's a tough one, it has that word you're rehearsing
0:07:02 in town?
0:07:27 Yes, sir.
0:07:34 20 seconds.
0:07:35 The August 22nd special meeting of the Football City Council to order, all of this is special
0:07:41 I think we still should blunce the flag, so John, join me, please stand.
0:07:49 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:08:02 We do confirm that we do have a quorum, staff members,
0:08:11 The major was your Travis Roth,
0:08:13 Father City, major city attorney,
0:08:15 Fritz Wonder, like Deputy City Clerk,
0:08:17 the 30th Secretary of the House of Sanchez,
0:08:19 and we have a lot of other staff here who I'm sure
0:08:22 are here on invitation to help us to work through this.
0:08:28 So I will turn the first item on the agenda
0:08:30 is discussion of the 2014 physical year,
0:08:33 but it's Travis Roth, why?
0:08:37 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:08:38 they're never in a time in my career
0:08:41 that I thought I would refer to this as like an episode of the movie Groundhog Day, where
0:08:47 here we are again.
0:08:49 We really appreciate you coming in on a special meeting and having a good opportunity to understand
0:08:59 some of the issues that have arose since we adopted the budget on Monday night.
0:09:05 We've developed a presentation to kind of walk you through what kind of changed and what
0:09:11 kind of transpired so that you have a good understanding of what happened.
0:09:18 We're also going to be able to walk through and share with you what hasn't happened, and
0:09:22 then at the end we have a series of options to present to you should you be interested in
0:09:27 exploring those.
0:09:30 Again, we put in the mission statement because that really stands for what we are as an organization.
0:09:40 These are the key budget drivers that we created on the 29th or started to create on the 29th
0:09:47 of April.
0:09:48 Each one of those key budget drivers have generally remained unchanged.
0:09:54 Those budget drivers in terms of limiting the statutory maximum to 3%, that is remained unchanged.
0:10:05 The issues don't have much to effect a compensation, at least not at this point.
0:10:11 Infrastructure, we kept that as a priority and something to move forward.
0:10:16 And then also we continued to find innovative strategies to create more efficient incomes.
0:10:22 None of that has changed as a result of our conversations.
0:10:26 And as we go through this, a lot of this is going to look familiar and to kind of point
0:10:31 out and illustrate what did change?
0:10:34 it's illustrated in red. And what's important that as we go through this and I
0:10:41 would encourage this be a bit of a different presentation than the other
0:10:45 ones, that as you have questions about where we're at and how we got here it
0:10:51 might be really good to ask them at that time. So this budget is still balanced,
0:10:58 it's still sustainable, it is still fiscally sound. None of those things
0:11:04 change because we have not increased or decreased from the $17.2 million that we anticipate that
0:11:11 we would collect the property tax collections.
0:11:13 And we'll go through a mathematical formula to illustrate how that $17 million by taking
0:11:19 the 3% should that be the direction you still choose to go down is still there is still available.
0:11:27 Our total budget number has not changed.
0:11:30 On the 19th, you adopted a budget for $52,937,917.
0:11:37 That remains unchanged, at least at this point.
0:11:42 But this is what has changed.
0:11:44 And this is why we've called you in,
0:11:46 because this could be something that causes us, maybe,
0:11:52 pause or concern to examine where we've put forward.
0:11:57 And that is when we took a look on the 19th.
0:12:01 We were assuming based upon information
0:12:04 that we had received from the county assessor's office
0:12:06 that the total taxable value of the city
0:12:09 was $2,335,649,471.
0:12:16 Now let me share something else real quick.
0:12:30 I think the tab still on it, Rose.
0:12:41 They want to illustrate.
0:13:05 So here's the good news about being
0:13:08 buried in a budget process and not getting to all of our emails on Monday the 19th.
0:13:15 So on Monday the 19th from the assessor's office we received a series of spreadsheets.
0:13:25 We received a series of spreadsheets that basically said use these numbers to calculate
0:13:30 your tax rate.
0:13:31 And you'll notice that on the 19th the number that they provided to us was 2,408,000,000.
0:13:41 And had that honestly had I read my email, I would have came in and said, we have a lot
0:13:49 more opportunity before you.
0:13:52 Because that would have been the new number that we went forward and we would have encouraged
0:13:57 you to use.
0:13:58 Because it would have been the most up-to-date number.
0:14:01 By Idaho code standards, and I've recited the code in an email, the exact site of the
0:14:08 but in Title 63 of the Idaho Code, it says that the county shall provide the cities the
0:14:15 final number by August 5th, or the first Monday, the first full week in August.
0:14:20 So we thought that there was a correction and this came in.
0:14:25 Unfortunately, this was followed up the following day with this one, and you can see that our
0:14:41 Our market value went from $2.4 billion to $2.139 billion in a span of a matter of hours.
0:14:50 And then you have to ask what happened.
0:14:53 And what happened was innocent human error.
0:14:57 There is a new process that all of us are trying to understand, and it's a result of
0:15:02 the Idaho legislature's change of how personal property taxes to be calculated.
0:15:10 $214 million of Chobani's personal property tax was credited to the city in all of the
0:15:17 other taxing entities outside of the urban renewal agency.
0:15:22 That is what caused our value to rise to $202.4 billion.
0:15:32 When the air was caught, they appropriately provided that credit to the revenue allocation
0:15:42 area number three, and it was removed from Twin Falls County, Twin Falls School District,
0:15:51 the College of Southern Idaho, the City of Twin Falls' total taxable values.
0:15:56 I thought the school district was able to keep that financing.
0:16:02 They're only able to keep a portion of it, I believe.
0:16:05 But these you can notice, if you look there, you can see
0:16:08 Twin Falls County and the College of Southern Idaho.
0:16:11 Their number also changed by that 214 million,
0:16:15 that 214 million dollar number, again,
0:16:20 should rightfully be credited to the agency.
0:16:25 We've looked back to them.
0:16:31 Any questions?
0:16:33 So when we had the opportunity to speak to Mr. Bowden,
0:16:40 was incredibly apologetic. It was human error, and it does happen. It does happen, especially
0:16:49 when you're trying to understand new tax law. It's the very, very first year of that tax
0:16:55 law. So that gives us an idea of what happened. And again, as it illustrated with the last bullet,
0:17:02 it was inadvertently provided to us that it should have been remained that of the agency.
0:17:10 So this is the net effect.
0:17:13 What is illustrated in black remains those things that remain unchanged because they follow a
0:17:19 different process or a different series of ways to account for them.
0:17:25 So the total taxable value for the city truly is $2,193 million.
0:17:32 And we had an opportunity to have a conversation of why didn't it grow as fast as what it was
0:17:37 originally anticipated in the 235.
0:17:40 Gary shared with us that when they had to do the reappraisal for the area, when the economy
0:17:48 collapsed, almost all properties went through that to get in that reappraisal.
0:17:54 In this year, most of those properties were out in the rural areas that saw that reappraisal.
0:18:00 And so most of the properties within the city and with both residential and commercial did
0:18:08 did not go through that reappraisal process because their mark on that five-year calendar
0:18:13 has not occurred yet. So not all the properties were reassessed to see the growth and the increase
0:18:19 in the economy. That was one of the reasons for that decrease, is that we just didn't
0:18:25 see the growth that what was there. But the biggest reason is, you know, again, that urban
0:18:32 And that is the cause and the difference from the numbers that we worked with.
0:18:38 Our total net revenues coming into the system remain functionally unchanged.
0:18:43 At this time, our total tax collections remain unchanged because our tax collections are based
0:18:48 upon 3% more revenue than what was collected in the prior year.
0:18:55 Not necessarily directly attached to the total taxable value.
0:19:01 where the total taxable value does come into play, is where we see the taxes per 1,000 or
0:19:08 our tax rate. So when we do the math, you can see that we had always been talking about
0:19:13 a tax rate of $7.40 because the denominator changed. That now goes to $7.88 if the $17,286,791
0:19:33 dollars is to be collected in property taxes.
0:19:36 Okay, that's the first part where I'm a little bit.
0:19:41 I need to go to the dunces stool or something.
0:19:44 I'm having a difficult understanding that the total taxable value of our property is decreased,
0:19:51 but we have to increase the property tax rate per thousand to get the guaranteed 3% of the
0:20:01 3% that we're guaranteed to have.
0:20:04 So what we've done up there,
0:20:05 so I've jumped ahead a couple of slides.
0:20:07 Let me, Chris, if I could go through this slide real quick.
0:20:11 Okay, we told me to ask questions at the time.
0:20:13 All right.
0:20:14 I'll take the done help for a minute.
0:20:16 No, it is a good question.
0:20:17 You just want to slide it.
0:20:20 So what we wanted to illustrate is this, right here,
0:20:27 illustrates the different total taxable value numbers
0:20:33 received from the county for this fiscal year.
0:20:38 And we graphed them.
0:20:41 So the first one is what the total taxable value of the city
0:20:45 was last year, which was $2.152 billion.
0:20:50 That went up to $2,337.
0:20:54 It came back down to $2,153.
0:21:00 And that is what we, that number right there
0:21:02 is what we use to present the initial budget to you.
0:21:06 And that is where we said the tax rate may go to
0:21:10 if you take 3% $8.03.
0:21:15 The next one we received on the 15th of July
0:21:20 after having a series of conversations with the assessor.
0:21:23 And we worked off of the $2,335 million number
0:21:28 all the way through our process.
0:21:32 And then on Tuesday, we received notification of that error.
0:21:41 So the question is, is why did the tax rate change?
0:21:46 Why does the tax rate have to go up?
0:21:49 And here is the mathematical calculation.
0:21:53 So pre-August 20, what we've done is to determine the tax
0:21:58 rate.
0:21:58 It is a mathematical formula.
0:22:02 That's all it is. Tax rate is math. We don't assess mills in the state of Idaho and since
0:22:11 we don't assess mills, it is a simple math formula where we take total government spending
0:22:20 on property tax collections, which is the 17,286,000. We divide that by the total taxable
0:22:32 value of the city, and we get a tax rate of $7.40.
0:22:37 What that tax rate illustrates is the proportionate share of what you owe in taxes for every $1,000
0:22:46 of value of property you have.
0:22:51 Well, you can notice then post 20th that nothing changed on the tax side, on the revenue side
0:23:02 that we anticipate to collect, which is the 3%.
0:23:06 What did change, though, is the denominator.
0:23:10 That means that more per thousand,
0:23:14 because the denominator's shrunk,
0:23:17 more per thousand per capita was placed onto the tax rate.
0:23:23 And so the new tax rate is $7.88.
0:23:28 should government tax collection revenues remain unchanged.
0:23:35 That was a reminder that it was 771 last year.
0:23:39 $7.71 last year.
0:23:45 And this is again, we've illustrated this,
0:23:48 the graphical illustration of that tax rate
0:23:52 and that kind of illustrates what that looks like
0:23:56 over that same period of time.
0:23:58 Again, the only difference is the green graph,
0:24:01 and it's illustrated in red in terms of what that change is.
0:24:05 So what's basically put is at the same tax rate as 2007
0:24:11 within about $0.05 per $1,000 of value.
0:24:17 The tax rate in 2007 was $7.83.
0:24:25 You'll notice that, again, that's what we move forward with.
0:24:33 So then we said what occurs and what is the impact
0:24:37 on a median family home?
0:24:42 And this is what is projected.
0:24:44 You'll notice that the 2013 is illustrated in green.
0:24:49 You'll notice that the increase in tax rate, which
0:24:55 is illustrated in blue, if you take the 3% and new construction,
0:24:59 the annual difference in property taxes
0:25:01 paid on the median home in Twin Falls would be an increase of $11.86 or $0.99 a month.
0:25:11 And because most properties were not reassessed and most properties fall below that total maximum
0:25:18 homeowners exemption to keep taxes flat, you have to keep the tax rate flat.
0:25:27 And so the tax rate would be $7 and if we if we chose to move back to the
0:25:36 771 which we did this year and whatever percent that would be then the tax rate their tax rate would be exactly the same
0:25:43 So we had been talking
0:25:49 So if we wanted to keep the flat rate at
0:25:52 at 771, then we would not be taking the 3% that we agreed
0:25:58 at the beginning that we want to take.
0:26:00 That's right.
0:26:00 So then we would be adding to our foregone balance again?
0:26:03 Yeah, I'm going to illustrate that.
0:26:04 OK, just very good.
0:26:09 So that's.
0:26:11 And then remember, so when we were talking in total,
0:26:16 over the course of the entire year, we didn't break this out.
0:26:19 We didn't break out the random samples of properties,
0:26:23 And we didn't do that because the tax rate was going down,
0:26:26 so significantly it was going down far greater.
0:26:29 And so we were saying that based upon the growth,
0:26:31 we really believe that property taxes are going to go down
0:26:33 because this is the reflection.
0:26:36 But we weren't so certain.
0:26:38 And so we broke out that exact same sample of homes
0:26:42 that we had in the prior year.
0:26:44 And each one of these homes, parcels A through J on this page,
0:26:49 The property taxes paid on those parcels is represented
0:26:56 by the property in blue.
0:26:59 And then the 2014 represents the difference in changes.
0:27:06 And you can see that some of those houses are looking
0:27:10 at a $7 and these are annual increases.
0:27:13 They range from $7.14 to a high of $7, $6.75.
0:27:33 And remember, what that's going to be applied against
0:27:36 is the total taxable value of that home.
0:27:39 And so where you're looking at most of those changes
0:27:42 is where it remained flat is a result of a product
0:27:49 of the increase in the tax rate.
0:27:51 In other cases, you're looking at either a decrease
0:27:55 in the total homeowners exemption,
0:27:58 and an increase in the tax rate is causing some of those
0:28:02 larger increases that we see up here,
0:28:04 because they are above the 50% or $81,000 maximum threshold.
0:28:13 And there's absolutely less impact, actually,
0:28:17 on commercial properties,
0:28:19 because there is no homeowners exemption
0:28:22 on commercial properties.
0:28:24 And because there is no homeowner's exemption,
0:28:27 you're looking at a tax rate difference here,
0:28:33 rather than a total taxable value difference.
0:28:36 Again, it's math.
0:28:38 I think it's actually the next slide
0:28:39 that is the commercial problem.
0:28:41 Oh, sorry, that's still residential.
0:28:42 Yep, yep, yep, yep.
0:28:45 And then that's an illustration of what occurs
0:28:46 with the flat rate, I'm sorry, I got one right here.
0:28:48 So right here is, you'll notice that there is still
0:28:52 some increase because they're of the homeowner's exemption.
0:28:56 Does that make sense?
0:28:57 So the homeowner's exemption goes down on this sheet.
0:29:00 And it's a combination of homeowners exemption and increase on tax rate on the first sheet.
0:29:12 The next slide is the commercial properties.
0:29:14 And you'll notice that those are largely attributed to the increase in the tax rate.
0:29:22 Most of the values of those remain functionally unchanged.
0:29:27 notice that one property sees a decrease and that just goes through that whole
0:29:31 reassessment. The other thing that is not factored in here that needs to be
0:29:36 included and we didn't know how to do it is the first $100,000 personal property
0:29:40 tax is exempt. So this gives you an idea if we're doing an apples-to-apples
0:29:45 comparison of last year but it is highly likely that since most of these
0:29:49 properties have the $100,000 or less threshold that is going to be exempted
0:29:56 from their personal property tax collection.
0:29:58 So that is going, and that piece again is picked up
0:30:02 by the state of Idaho through the distribution
0:30:04 of sales tax dollars.
0:30:12 And this is what happens to all those properties
0:30:15 if you don't take the 3% and you keep the tax rate the same.
0:30:19 And it makes sense because in our sample,
0:30:22 none of them were reassessed in value.
0:30:26 So this would be if the, we kept it in.
0:30:28 If we kept it at 771, which is what we had last year,
0:30:33 Almost all the commercial either go down or pay zero more.
0:30:38 Well, no, they all go down because remember this does not include the hundred thousand dollar.
0:30:44 So if we leave it at $771, all of them, all commercial will get a tax cut of some variety.
0:30:53 Yes, that is true.
0:30:55 And the magnitude of the tax, well, yes, that is true.
0:30:58 Based upon the law that would be true.
0:31:00 looking at Sean because I think they also exempted anything new, right?
0:31:06 Anything new below $3,000 or some kind of professional.
0:31:11 So any commercial property that actually has personal property, right?
0:31:15 Well, actually, it's the tax reduction after $771.
0:31:19 And just making a hypothetical case, if a council decided to stick with the $740 per
0:31:26 thousand that would represent a rather dramatic decrease increase decrease for
0:31:33 those property tax owners. To get to 740 you need to cut about 1.5
0:31:39 million dollars out of the budget. Okay. Thank you for having that figure at
0:31:46 hand. It's about that's about what it is. Did we get Suzanne's question answered?
0:31:52 Okay. This chart again remains unchanged because the budget hasn't remained
0:31:59 change because the amount of money that you allocated hasn't
0:32:02 remained hasn't changed.
0:32:04 It's just the proportion of share of the tax loads is what
0:32:09 has changed.
0:32:11 We're still anticipating under the current budget to collect
0:32:14 $17.2, $8, $6 million, which is the 3% increase in revenue,
0:32:20 which is unaffected.
0:32:22 The revenues collected are unaffected by the total tax
0:32:26 value unless you decrease the tax rate.
0:32:31 And back there, make sure we got Suzanne's question answered.
0:32:34 If we choose to reduce the tax rate,
0:32:37 then that money would move over into the foregone.
0:32:40 And we're going to get that.
0:32:41 OK.
0:32:42 Yeah, thanks.
0:32:44 So what we've done is a site-by-site comparison
0:32:49 of what this looks like in terms of median home value total
0:32:55 cost to live inside the city of Twin Falls with the new numbers.
0:32:59 So you'll notice we still take our same property of $142,300, which is the median value.
0:33:05 And again, this is a hypothetical example trying to create as close to an apples to apples
0:33:11 to occurs in this weekend.
0:33:13 You'll notice that the water bill, the sewer bill, and the sanitation bill remain unchanged
0:33:18 because they are not affected by property taxes.
0:33:22 The change occurs in the property taxes and what we were looking at based upon a tax rate
0:33:27 of $7.40 would be a residential tax bill of $526.60 when we received the new taxable value
0:33:38 and based upon the spending that tax rate would increase to $7.88 and the total tax is paid
0:33:48 on the median home in Twin Falls would be $5.60 at 71 cents.
0:33:53 By $560.71 cents.
0:33:57 By comparing the first column, which is 2013, a budget
0:34:01 with the last column, which is what the budget would be
0:34:06 if things remained unchanged, you can see
0:34:10 that the monthly difference is $7.69 cents.
0:34:16 But if you remove the voter approved sewer bond
0:34:19 That difference is $2.48 per month.
0:34:25 And again, that is largely impacted by the change
0:34:29 in that tax rate.
0:34:35 So what if you want to do nothing?
0:34:40 Well, the do nothing is we've done our part as staff
0:34:45 and shared with you the information
0:34:48 with the changes in the tax rate as we've learned it,
0:34:53 as caused by the new taxable value.
0:34:58 But let's say that you want to keep the tax rate flat at $7.71.
0:35:04 The first thing that we need to do is we need to reduce total property tax revenues by $500,
0:35:09 excuse me, $359,216.
0:35:15 And that would come out of the $685,848.
0:35:20 So that means that new tax bill revenues coming into the system,
0:35:24 we would bring in approximately $326,000.
0:35:30 We would go through the process,
0:35:31 and we would be prepared tonight to have you adopt a new ordinance
0:35:35 that reflects changes in those allocations
0:35:38 to the government fund and the capital fund moving forward.
0:35:44 To keep the tax rate flat, our total property tax collections
0:35:47 would be $16,927,573.
0:35:53 This would represent that we were taking 0.84%
0:35:56 of the statutorily allowed 3%,
0:36:00 which would increase the city's foregone balance
0:36:03 from 1,478,577 to 1,837,793.
0:36:17 So 2.16% of that 3% is rolled forward into the foregone?
0:36:22 Yes.
0:36:24 Yeah, about this, yep.
0:36:29 As we illustrated, we were prepared
0:36:37 to take the steps that you need.
0:36:40 We're prepared to answer any questions that you may have.
0:36:43 We have the team assembled.
0:36:46 Upon learning of the information,
0:36:49 we've gone through and developed a possible roadmap
0:36:57 for you to consider, should you want to take
0:36:59 and have a flat tax rate.
0:37:01 Whatever you want to do, staff is here to assist you,
0:37:06 get to a budget that you believe is appropriate for the community.
0:37:10 I do want to emphasize that the only thing that changed in this process
0:37:16 is the taxable value.
0:37:18 Everything else that we've had the conversations has not.
0:37:23 But we also recognize the significance of the increase in the tax rate
0:37:29 and what that may represent.
0:37:30 So we stand ready to assist working through the issue.
0:37:35 Well, I'm sure everyone else might have their own thoughts.
0:37:39 Before I'm ready to change anything from what we have done,
0:37:42 I would like to see what may need to be cut from what I felt
0:37:48 was and even stated was a progressing budget moving forward
0:37:54 to meet our strategic planning.
0:37:57 I'd like to see what those items are before I decide to.
0:38:00 change the rate, so to speak, or go back to the old rate.
0:38:04 I want to see what we're losing in this or what your suggestions are, and we may have
0:38:10 suggestions as well, I think everyone has been looking at the budget saying what would they
0:38:15 cut if we need to cut, and we may have different opinions as well on that.
0:38:20 That's a guaranteed.
0:38:21 We'll raise the being of the electronic copy and that will give you a copy.
0:38:45 I've got one.
0:38:46 Okay.
0:38:47 It'll be a live version.
0:38:48 May I have one?
0:38:58 Yes.
0:38:59 Travis.
0:39:00 Sure.
0:39:02 Thanks.
0:39:12 So maybe a bit about the process that we went through to come up with this.
0:39:17 Members of the city's senior management team went through and we had conversations and we
0:39:22 started at the operations side of the budget and we looked at the operations side and we
0:39:27 we went through those parts and pieces.
0:39:31 And we added those to the list.
0:39:36 And then we also kind of took in a last in first out philosophy
0:39:42 of what that looked like moving forward.
0:39:56 So this is.
0:39:57 Sure.
0:39:58 I'm sorry, Susanna Paul, just knock me on the floor.
0:40:01 It's all something happening.
0:40:02 Susanna.
0:40:04 Oops.
0:40:05 Since what we're really discussing is changing a multiplier
0:40:08 and not changing the percentage of what we're going to take,
0:40:12 to only to maintain the multiplying tax rate
0:40:17 and not necessarily dollars.
0:40:21 Do you have numbers like this is 0.84% of our 3% now?
0:40:25 What if we just wanted to fudge a little bit
0:40:29 and go to 2% instead of 3 or something like that?
0:40:31 And then what that would look like in cuts?
0:40:33 Yeah, we need that.
0:40:34 So that's why we brought in the live spreadsheets.
0:40:39 And know that what we put here may not be the best list
0:40:43 and the only list and there might be other things
0:40:46 in the budget that you think that are less important
0:40:51 than the items that we've included here.
0:40:53 Sorry, everybody's having to help me out today
0:40:56 because I'm reading the fours of going,
0:40:57 we're back in the middle second.
0:40:59 Well, that's fine.
0:41:00 Were you finished Travis?
0:41:01 Because I was just gonna kind of start
0:41:04 with the general thought.
0:41:06 Because as you mentioned in your presentation,
0:41:09 You know, back when we said take the 3%, we actually didn't know the tax rate.
0:41:14 And I kind of expected it to, didn't expect the growth, expected to be slightly larger
0:41:19 the tax rate than the year passed when you take that 3%.
0:41:24 So it's always kind of a surprise because we tell you, I want to take the 3% and then
0:41:29 we can look at it.
0:41:30 And I do recognize the significance of it, but again, I committed to taking the 3% and
0:41:36 the money being spent has not changed, so, and the concerns and the disagreements that
0:41:43 I had in the budget and the reason that I voted against it were about priorities and about little
0:41:49 changes that I would prefer or that I just couldn't defend, and it wasn't the will of
0:41:55 the council which I appreciate and still feel that way, but I did commit to take the 3% so
0:42:03 So I don't feel that it's necessary to necessarily make any cuts because the tax rate is a multiplier
0:42:10 and it's kind of always a surprise anyway and we made that commitment before we actually
0:42:16 knew this result.
0:42:19 Sean, yeah I actually, I would agree with Rebecca's assessment, you know, the budget really was
0:42:25 established through a lengthy process of community input that went into the strategic plan, you
0:42:33 and put through the budget process, really establishing our current and short-term needs,
0:42:40 our long-term needs, and I think that the entire process really allowed for a lot of thought
0:42:48 that went into what ended up in the budget, regardless of the tax rate.
0:42:55 The tax rate is the end product, it's not where you start with the process.
0:42:59 So I too would support making no changes to the current adopted budget and having it as
0:43:06 as it stands without having to go through this exercise.
0:43:09 And what do we want to cut?
0:43:11 Because I don't think we need to.
0:43:13 I prefer to keep the budget that we adopt.
0:43:18 What do you want to else like to weigh in?
0:43:22 I don't feel I could agree with either of those positions.
0:43:30 Suzanne?
0:43:34 I tend to agree that we wanted to take a 3%
0:43:37 with whatever that meant.
0:43:39 And I'm comfortable staying with what we've done.
0:43:44 I want to hear your presentation.
0:43:49 I'd like to go through your presentation.
0:43:52 So what we did is we went through the process and we analyzed different parts of the budget.
0:44:04 And we went through the process.
0:44:06 I think it's important to recognize that we felt that everything that we put in there merited funding.
0:44:13 And we went through a process that was probably more robust than what we've ever had internally.
0:44:20 where rather than going through and having a single session of department leaders, we
0:44:27 met as a large collective group and we vetted the budget and the budget processes.
0:44:36 And like I shared with you at the very beginning, it was probably the most robust series of conversations,
0:44:44 especially on the second day of that process that we've probably had in our budgeting process
0:44:50 in, especially since I had been here.
0:44:53 We implemented a similar version of that,
0:44:56 starting on Tuesday with the city's senior management team.
0:45:03 And we went through this process to define those things that
0:45:10 is there going to be a significant decrease
0:45:14 in the level of service if we don't advance
0:45:17 these types of things?
0:45:19 And so we were able to come up with a list of things that we looked at and said, you know,
0:45:27 if all things are equal, these are things that should be equally placed out there.
0:45:34 So we put on the trail improvements, because as you remember, the trail improvements came
0:45:41 from that place of extra health insurance money or a windfall that was generally unanticipated.
0:45:50 So what we said that we may want to do, because the Council was very excited to have a group
0:45:56 come in and very excited about building a partnership with a group to build trails, we said that
0:46:07 it may be appropriate to spend $150,000 of our cash reserves to build those trails and
0:46:14 to move that forward, to help honor that commitment.
0:46:17 So cumulative, we would remove $208,000.
0:46:25 The next step is that I believe that getting the senior management on that same philosophical
0:46:33 place and having us all rolling the book together is important, but it doesn't all have to be
0:46:39 done in a single year.
0:46:41 So what this represents is a reduction of that by half.
0:46:44 I will tell you that I would like to have and I would probably be asking for the other
0:46:49 half next year, just because I think it's important to have all of them moving forward.
0:46:57 The library, because of how we operate with the library, would have to come up with their
0:47:01 proportion share.
0:47:03 The tax rate affects all things equally and so the library receives monies from the city
0:47:10 And what we did was we removed their proportion share,
0:47:14 which constitutes 4.77%.
0:47:17 The math is illustrated below.
0:47:19 And it would be a reduction to the library of $17,000.
0:47:23 And the library could determine what is best in moving forward.
0:47:27 We tried to involve the library and the process
0:47:30 that both Seaash and Barbara are on vacation
0:47:32 through September 3rd as we understand it.
0:47:35 So this is not a really good welcome home gift.
0:47:40 We appreciate that, but that's kind of where that is.
0:47:44 We would remove $11,000 from contingency,
0:47:47 and we would keep our contingency at even $200,000.
0:47:52 We had in the capital fund.
0:47:53 We have a contingency line item in the capital fund.
0:47:57 And when we were moving those different things
0:47:59 through as a result of those changes,
0:48:02 that contingency went to $211,000,
0:48:04 we would return that back to $200,000 and let them-
0:48:08 I think you missed the wellness too.
0:48:10 Oh, excuse me.
0:48:12 I'm following Lori's highlight.
0:48:14 So the contingency goes away.
0:48:16 The $30,000 was also a product of the health insurance.
0:48:24 And so we took that and we had removed that from consideration
0:48:29 as well.
0:48:31 We removed the airport vehicle.
0:48:33 We had a conversation and we felt that although it is a really 90s, mid 90s vehicle with considerable
0:48:40 mileage, we felt that maybe one more year we could go forward.
0:48:46 You'll notice in the budget that it's a $30,000 expense, but those expenses are shared with
0:48:51 the county and so it would be a $15,000 reduction of our revenues.
0:48:58 It would also represent a $15,000 reduction in the amount that we would assess the county
0:49:05 because we provide those uniformly.
0:49:10 We would postpone the Parks Master Plan for one year, and we would bring that back as
0:49:18 a significant priority in the following year.
0:49:24 We have a couple of positions that we felt from an intern perspective that we would eliminate
0:49:30 from the process.
0:49:32 These have been in the organization for a while.
0:49:35 They are used and they are filled, but we felt that we get a lot more bang with the full-time
0:49:42 employees.
0:49:43 Interns are wonderful help.
0:49:45 They really do good work for us, but when faced with those decisions, this is what we
0:49:51 looked at.
0:49:53 We throw on MPOG and we felt that it was fair to take a look at that because with the exception
0:50:01 of the band because we understood that the band might have a placement in moving a direct
0:50:07 allocation somewhere else.
0:50:09 We understand the need and the gift that we provide and the value of service that is provided
0:50:15 by all of those entities, but we listed it up there as an opportunity.
0:50:22 The grant writer position is another one that we layered out there.
0:50:28 We feel that as we've gone forward in the research, we have the job description, we're
0:50:32 ready to go.
0:50:33 If the grant writer is not funded this year, we would probably bring that request back the
0:50:38 following year.
0:50:41 We removed the landscaping from the pool, and then, I won't say Dennis, the community
0:50:55 Be Garden has been added to the list because the group that had been working with us has
0:51:01 seemed to have dissipated.
0:51:03 And so the sense of urgency is not necessarily there.
0:51:10 And we would bring that back in subsequent budget years.
0:51:15 So what we provided was a total list of $567,666.
0:51:23 need to keep a flat tax rate of $359,000. And so if you remove community garden, the grant
0:51:49 rider, and Envog, you're about there. We're about there, but we've spent $150,000 to get
0:52:05 there, right? If only if you elect to keep the funding or any funding associated with
0:52:16 the trails. You don't have to put any money in for trails. What we were doing is just trying
0:52:22 to provide a response to what may be perceived as a project. So what we did is we took our
0:52:32 cash reserves and we said we will augment the funding that was there because we took away
0:52:36 the revenue that would have been there to supply it.
0:52:39 Chris, I've got to ask a repeat question because I want to make sure I understand. Back on the
0:52:46 on the 740 earlier rate to go from 771 down to that 740,
0:52:54 which would represent 31 cents,
0:52:58 we would lose an additional $1,141,000.
0:53:07 I want to make sure that I understand.
0:53:08 $1,053,000.
0:53:10 Okay, well, in excess of a million, though.
0:53:12 Yes, I did understand that correctly.
0:53:14 And what's important about the 740 tax rate
0:53:17 is it was always fictitious from the entire beginning
0:53:20 of the conversation.
0:53:22 Thank you.
0:53:22 Maybe I won't ask that again.
0:53:26 OK.
0:53:27 We've seen their suggestions for the one of a better word
0:53:32 if we choose to drop back to a flat rate.
0:53:39 Again, I'm going to, somebody may have changed their mind,
0:53:43 but five of the seven of us have stated
0:53:47 their thoughts concerning remaining at the 3% that we,
0:53:54 the 3% comes from what we chose to do
0:53:58 at the beginning of the budget process,
0:54:00 we voted as a group to elect to take the 3%
0:54:05 and a reminder to everyone,
0:54:06 including staff and everyone's here.
0:54:10 We're the only ones anywhere
0:54:11 that don't take the 3% every year, okay?
0:54:14 That's one of the things I want to keep harping on.
0:54:17 Nobody else doesn't take the 3%.
0:54:19 They just figured it's a cost of doing government
0:54:23 and moving forward and they,
0:54:26 I mean, you can talk to any community in the Magic Valley
0:54:29 and they automatically take the 3%.
0:54:32 They don't even know what we're discussing.
0:54:34 What are you, when you talk about not taking a 3%
0:54:38 they're confused by it.
0:54:38 We've obviously had years and we didn't
0:54:40 or we wouldn't have a foregone balance.
0:54:43 So I'm gonna be in favor of staying with what we said
0:54:46 we would do at the beginning of the budget process.
0:54:48 We said we would take the 3%.
0:54:51 I'm ready to continue with that process.
0:54:55 Don, do you want to chime in before we have Chris or?
0:54:58 No.
0:54:59 Yeah, Chris.
0:55:00 Well, I didn't understand we took a vote.
0:55:01 I didn't know that five of you had felt that way.
0:55:03 I heard Don say you wanted to hear you, and I didn't know you.
0:55:06 But I mean, I can live with the facts,
0:55:08 but five of you feel that firm of the rate.
0:55:13 Well, I don't feel the firm.
0:55:13 We're just saying, what I'm saying
0:55:17 is that we as a council stated at the beginning of the budget process and asked them to put
0:55:24 a budget together with 3%.
0:55:26 That was with some different assumptions on taxable basis.
0:55:30 Right.
0:55:31 Actually not taxable rate at that time was actually lower than it is now.
0:55:35 It was less than it is now.
0:55:38 If you look at that little chart with the assessment values.
0:55:42 It was 2.153 billion.
0:55:43 Right.
0:55:44 It was actually going to be eight dollars and four cents if we took the three percent at that particular time when we made that decision correct
0:55:51 Lori
0:55:55 Fritz just reminded me that there is no motion that needs to be made
0:56:00 If you want to stay with the action that you took on Monday
0:56:05 If you do not want to stay with that
0:56:08 Action you have to make a motion to change the budget the
0:56:15 The right here, Suzanne, your question.
0:56:19 Thank you, so I'm just going to ask.
0:56:21 If you wanted to take 2%, we have to reduce $166,000.
0:56:35 And the levy rate would be $7.80.
0:56:49 I need some clarification here.
0:56:51 If a motion was made this evening
0:56:53 that would keep the tax rate at 0.071,
0:57:00 And that would take a motion and a majority to change that, okay.
0:57:07 And then that would subsequently require us to make some cuts in the budget.
0:57:10 Yes, sir.
0:57:15 I'll make a motion.
0:57:17 Just to get this underway.
0:57:19 I would move that we reduce, stay with me, troops.
0:57:29 The taxable, the tax rate to, where's my page here?
0:57:37 to $7.71 per thousand dollars of taxable value and make subsequent cuts to drop that to that rate.
0:57:58 Just starting to second to put it on the floor.
0:58:02 Most of them made that we change from our Monday night decision to
0:58:10 Take
0:58:13 And reduce that back to last year's levy rate of zero zero seven seven one
0:58:19 Chris talking well, I just have to say philosophically though. I'll probably vote in favor of it
0:58:28 I think the County
0:58:29 Assessors department through their human error has lost us a great
0:58:33 a week loss of face with people who have diligently followed the budget.
0:58:38 I realize now going down to the $7.40 rate, requiring a million plus a million, 50,000 or
0:58:48 something like that is totally unrealistic for the continuity of our city strategic plan.
0:58:54 I'm erk and I don't know how to take out my dissatisfaction with the
0:59:07 professionality that I saw coming from the assessor's office no matter what the human error content.
0:59:14 I just want to kind of reiterate, when we started this process back in
0:59:22 God knows when that was, April, even in July, early July, we were operating on a
0:59:37 estimated market valuation that was less than what we're actually at now.
0:59:44 And still at that time, our philosophy of what we wanted to do with the budget, talked
0:59:52 about taking the statutory allowed 3%.
0:59:58 But again, the process of building the actual spending plan of what we needed to spend in
1:00:02 order to meet the needs of our citizens started much before that.
1:00:07 So to me, to now make a decision based upon the tax rate, which really is, in my mind, the
1:00:16 The last thing you come to, not the first thing we started with, just seems backwards to me.
1:00:22 It seems to me that the process is, what are our citizens need, what are the services we
1:00:27 need to provide to meet those needs, what's that going to cost, what's the value of the
1:00:33 community, do the math, there's your rate, not we want to hit $7.40 and back into that.
1:00:40 So I think we have gone to so much work as a staff, as a council, and really as the citizens,
1:00:52 those who have followed the budget process closely, the groups that have come and spoken
1:00:58 to us, to just pull the plug on that now in really what's going to be somewhat arbitrary
1:01:07 cuts that are going to have real impacts on things that we have laid out in the future.
1:01:14 Jim, thank you, Mayor.
1:01:17 I kind of compare this to finding out from my employer that I'm going to have a certain
1:01:25 amount of money brought into my bank account on Monday and then having a budget built around
1:01:32 that.
1:01:33 And then finding out Tuesday that that amount of money has changed, I'm, as a human being,
1:01:38 I'm going to have to adjust my personal expenditures based on that mistake by my employer.
1:01:45 And I'm probably not going to be able to go out amongst the community and ask for money to meet those needs that I might have.
1:01:53 And that is a conservative thought.
1:01:56 I believe that we will be able to continue with Phase 2 of our city's compensation strategy with this budget flat rate at 771.
1:02:04 I think that we're going to be able to work on infrastructure systems and enhance water
1:02:08 to every done and see that's going to be preceded with.
1:02:14 We're going to be working on those other effective outcomes in the community.
1:02:17 We do have a solid, solid capital budget that we're going to be able to proceed with.
1:02:22 So I think this is a situation where, whereas we build a budget, then we tax, we've already
1:02:30 made that decision, now we're going to go out because of a mistake.
1:02:33 going to ask the community to pay higher tax. That is a fact. We're going to go ask them to pay a
1:02:40 higher tax. I believe that at the flat rate, we can get done what we need to have done here,
1:02:48 and next year we can look at things again. We have a real solid budget here. We're going to be
1:02:57 making some reductions. I understand that, but we're going to have a very solid budget and you're
1:03:01 and you're gonna be able to meet the majority
1:03:04 of those objectives that are outlined
1:03:06 in your strategic plan.
1:03:07 So I would vote for the flat tax rate of 771.
1:03:13 Jim, I'm gonna go out in a slightly different direction.
1:03:18 If we had been working under the number from July 8th
1:03:22 during this entire time, saying we wanted to 3%,
1:03:26 we would have been anticipating a tax rate
1:03:28 of $8.04 right, Lori?
1:03:30 Okay. And then when this new number came in from the county that says that it's
1:03:36 Higher than that we would be dropping down to 788 and we would be happy
1:03:40 Because we've been under the assumption all during the process that we were gonna be at 804
1:03:46 And suddenly we're down to 788 and well, that was great. The county raised that a little bit that helped us out
1:03:53 We're down to 788 so I will be voting against the motion
1:03:57 And we made the agreement at the beginning of the budget year that we were going to take
1:04:05 the 3 percent.
1:04:06 We felt we had the needs to take the 3 percent.
1:04:09 We were basically willing at that time to pay the eight dollars and four cents.
1:04:13 And now we're paying 788.
1:04:16 And that's going to be my vote on it.
1:04:25 Question on the motion.
1:04:27 All right.
1:04:28 So, you know, the likes, the motion is to change from Monday night and go back to a,
1:04:33 and Fritz, please correct me if I get something wrong here, okay?
1:04:37 Move to a, back to the 771 rate that we text for 1,000 last year based on our newest evaluation
1:04:47 from the, uh, the other hotel vote.
1:04:53 Sean Berger?
1:04:53 No.
1:04:55 Don Hall?
1:04:57 No.
1:04:58 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:05:00 No, great glanting. No, Jim, I'm yes, I think a mils like that. No, Chris talking to yes, motion fails to the five. Do we have any other business before us tonight?
1:05:16 I was besides the executive session. So the next item on agenda is to move to the executive section. 67 to 45 to consider the back on third. Did you have a light?
1:05:30 Okay, well I won't reopen. It's a negotiation involving trade commerce with someone outside of the state of Idaho is in competition.
1:05:40 So, Rebecca, we'll select it.
1:05:42 Move to adjourn to executive session pursuant to Idaho code 67-2345-1E.
1:05:48 Second.
1:05:49 And move by Rebecca, we'll select it and second by Sean Berger to move to executive section under those that number.
1:05:56 We have a roll call vote.
1:05:57 Don Hall.
1:05:58 Yes.
1:05:59 Suzanne Hawkins yes good glanting yes Jim on yes Rebecca middle so it got yes
1:06:06 was talking to Sean Berger yes motion that's seven to zero we're adjourned to
1:06:12 exactly session we will not be coming back and having any additional business
1:06:16 thank you
Download
- Transcript (text) 48 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 64 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 87 KB
- Audio (M4A) 15.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Thursday, August 22, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:06:24.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
39fae2f089c2a0867a53254f22e07dad62b15d9cf8f7303d5ffe878168e16399 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 3e097a6d51a8123807f69ccab625025c638580e86c2b1e9761cad2346967fe09 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
42cf397ef5d9b0eb3802acba6a275f6f781fa2efc675b5e965f4fa76b3d6a3bd
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file