OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, May 13, 2013

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:00 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:16 Confirm that we do have a quorum. All seven members are here, in addition of part of the staff that's here.

0:00:23 I see a manager with Travis Rothweiler, City Attorney Fritz Wunderlich, Staff Sergeant Dennis Pullen, City Engineer Jackie Fields,

0:00:33 the development director Mitch Humble, Deputy City Clerk,

0:00:37 recording secretary of the island, Sanchez.

0:00:41 Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda?

0:00:44 No, we do not.

0:00:46 There are no proclamations, although we have a kind

0:00:48 of a proclamation of that's under the item consideration.

0:00:53 First item of business then is the consent calendar,

0:00:56 Jim, I'd like to, I'm a reserve deputy sheriff

0:01:00 with the sheriff's office and I believe that on item number two,

0:01:04 There is going to be some request to have sheriff's deputies or reserve sheriff's deputies do security there.

0:01:11 So I need to recuse myself from number two so I don't know how you want to proceed there, but let's remove it for now we'll vote.

0:01:17 So Jim is recruiting himself. Do we have a motion concerning consent calendar?

0:01:32 Do we need to remove it or can we just never show you I could vote on number one.

0:01:37 Oh, I can't say any of you.

0:01:39 We're going to share it.

0:01:40 Okay. So we were moving number two. Do we have a motion on item number one?

0:01:45 Who's the first one?

0:01:48 It's the top crowd in nine, man.

0:01:51 Drag motion, then, people.

0:01:53 He's been moved by Jim Mon and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.

0:01:56 Did we approve item number one on the consent calendar?

0:02:00 Seeing no additional lights.

0:02:01 Lea, the roll call vote?

0:02:03 Don Hall?

0:02:04 Yes.

0:02:05 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:02:06 Yes.

0:02:08 Greg Lansing?

0:02:09 Yes.

0:02:10 Jim Mon?

0:02:11 Yes.

0:02:12 Rebecca Milsica?

0:02:13 Yes.

0:02:14 Yes. Motion passes 7-1. Now we will go ahead and have 7-0.

0:02:21 7-0, excuse me.

0:02:23 We might want to. I'm having trouble tonight, that's for sure.

0:02:29 Okay, then we'll now have an entertainer motion for item number two of the consent calendar, which is the Twin Falls tonight concert.

0:02:37 Move approval.

0:02:39 Second.

0:02:40 Good by Sean Berger and seconded by Susanne Hawkins

0:02:44 that we provide them number two,

0:02:46 Jim Mann will be with Staining.

0:02:49 Seeing no lights, Leila Rojova.

0:02:53 Susan Hawkins?

0:02:54 Yes.

0:02:55 Greg Lanting?

0:02:56 Yes.

0:02:57 Jim Mann.

0:02:58 Recutable.

0:02:59 Sorry.

0:03:00 Rebecca Mills-Weica?

0:03:02 Yes.

0:03:03 Chris Tockensh?

0:03:04 Yes.

0:03:04 Sean Berger?

0:03:05 Yes.

0:03:06 John Hall.

0:03:07 Yes.

0:03:08 Motion passes six to zero.

0:03:09 We have the two people that are most instrumental

0:03:12 in the, to and falls tonight, I'd like to get up and tell us a little bit about this year's schedule.

0:03:16 I think we have time in our agenda for that.

0:03:20 Robin Dopper from Hands On It.

0:03:22 Oh yeah, we have nine weeks scheduled this year, running from June 19th until August 21st.

0:03:31 We are taking off July 24th so that we don't conflict with the bike.

0:03:35 And we have some new bands, we have local bands just like the boys have.

0:03:38 We've added some new, we're kind of stepping outside our box a little bit to see how that goes.

0:03:43 And let's see if I can remember the schedule.

0:03:46 We've got mixed emotions, which is a local band that's been

0:03:49 around apparently since my husband's been in high school.

0:03:54 We've got Sweet Country Air.

0:03:55 We've got Swagger, which is Celtic Rock Band at a Park City,

0:03:58 Utah on July 3rd.

0:03:59 They're going to be really good.

0:04:01 We're excited to have them.

0:04:03 Crossfire, rough draft, double back, Sons of the Beach,

0:04:11 the Blues Brothers tribute and Jason Lugo and there's so much.

0:04:18 Jason Lugo, yeah.

0:04:19 Jason Lugo, yeah.

0:04:20 There you go.

0:04:21 So there you go.

0:04:22 Alright, thank you Robin.

0:04:23 Thank you guys for your efforts for downtown and the Twin Falls tonight, Wednesday night concerts

0:04:26 truly are a unique experience enough people where since we're streaming live, if you haven't

0:04:32 had a chance to come down there, it's one of the bigger events each week in Twin Falls.

0:04:36 It's amazing how many people you've down into down on Main Street there.

0:04:41 We're handsome, so thank you very much for your efforts on that.

0:04:45 Still waiting for you to bring Van Halen in.

0:04:47 I'm glad to be here.

0:04:53 Mayor, if I might get to have one more question.

0:04:55 The farmers are market.

0:04:56 Could you real briefly explain how that's been expanded or combined?

0:05:00 Yes, thank you, Chris.

0:05:03 So the Market on Main, which is run by the downtown alive group,

0:05:08 is combining with Twin Falls tonight this year.

0:05:10 So we are all going to be on the same side of the street

0:05:14 between Shoshone and Hanson.

0:05:17 And we have a new market director,

0:05:19 so we're hoping to get more vendors this year.

0:05:22 It's a food, craft, local produce market.

0:05:27 We'll be running the same hours and the same nights

0:05:29 as Twin Falls tonight.

0:05:31 Thank you, Robin.

0:05:32 Thanks for putting that out, Chris.

0:05:35 All right, moving on to items consideration.

0:05:38 I remember one is the presentation of a certificate

0:05:41 of appreciation to Christian Bruce,

0:05:43 president of the Twin Falls City Youth Advisory Council.

0:05:47 And I have the certificate here,

0:05:50 but I really think that I will ask one of the two ladies

0:05:54 on our council that are instrumental

0:05:56 in with the youth council to read this.

0:05:59 And I think I have Suzanne Reed one later on.

0:06:02 I'll have Rebecca read this one, if you would.

0:06:04 And then I'll let you, Suzanne talked to us about the letter

0:06:08 that we have for her as well.

0:06:10 Christine, if you'd step up the mic, we'd appreciate it.

0:06:14 Sure, well, thank you, Mayor.

0:06:16 Christine is our only senior this year that's graduating

0:06:20 out of the Twin Falls City Youth Council.

0:06:22 And she has just been a core member, an instrumental member

0:06:26 in the productivity and the endeavors of the Youth

0:06:30 Council. We appreciate her leadership. Just to give you a little bit on her background,

0:06:37 you know, she's been with the Youth Council all four years of high school. She served

0:06:41 as Clerk, Secretary, and now has been the President for the past year. And she was a recipient

0:06:48 of the Governor's Star Award, which is quite a prestigious award given by the Governor

0:06:52 of Idaho, and you compete with students from all over the state. And when they read her

0:06:58 list of activities that she had been involved in, it just seemed to go on and on and I was

0:07:04 so impressed that she really utilizes her time wisely because it's amazing how many activities

0:07:11 she's able to be involved in.

0:07:13 So we're certainly very proud of her and all of her accomplishments.

0:07:19 Today we're going to present the certificates of appreciation and I'll read what it says,

0:07:25 It's the Athenian oath, it says we will never bring disgrace to this our city by any act of dishonesty or cowardice,

0:07:33 nor ever desert our suffering comrades in the ranks.

0:07:36 We will fight for the ideals and sacred things of the city, both alone and with many.

0:07:41 We will revere and obey the city's laws and do our best to incite to a like respect and

0:07:47 reverence those who are prone to annul or set them at naught.

0:07:51 We will strive unceasingly to quicken the public sense of public duty.

0:07:56 That this in all these ways, we will transmit this city not only, not less, but greater, better

0:08:02 and more beautiful than it was transmitted to us.

0:08:05 And so, Cristina, I present this to you and you really do embody all of those ideals and

0:08:11 you've done a great service to your community.

0:08:14 And I also want to say that she leads by example and definitely just is willing to do whatever

0:08:22 tasks that she asks anyone else to do.

0:08:25 And so it's rare and it's wonderful when you have a leader that is truly committed to their

0:08:30 community and leads by example and leads through service.

0:08:34 So congratulations.

0:08:35 In addition to that, we have for you letters of recommendation for you to use as you see

0:08:43 fit to future your educational goals and I just want to say personally thank you for

0:08:48 being my friend this year and as I've been learning along with you I appreciate

0:08:53 your support of me and just all the fun we've had working together I consider you a

0:08:59 friend and I'm looking forward to seeing what your future panel ends out as and I

0:09:04 know that you are just gonna do great things not only here but wherever you go

0:09:08 Thank you.

0:09:09 Thank you.

0:09:10 Come up here all west.

0:09:11 Why don't we step down there and grab a photograph here.

0:09:15 You know what that actually works?

0:10:02 So, thanks all for supporting me and the youth council and all you guys deal with everything.

0:10:08 It's been a great run.

0:10:11 I plan on going to CSI to go get my associate of arts in theater because I started a theater

0:10:17 group four years ago and we just recently changed the name and we just got done with the

0:10:21 play Wizard of Oz. So I plan to make a community-wide theater that kids can come to, and it's cheap

0:10:30 so that they can come and act and express their feelings and just have fun. So I hope to bring

0:10:36 all kids into that. So that's my future goals. And I just want to tell you that we just had

0:10:42 elections for Youth Council. Our new president is Hannah Bello. So that's exciting. And then

0:10:49 Our Vice President is Nolan Stroop,

0:10:52 and then Clark is Jesse Stroop, she was last year,

0:10:56 and so she just did a great job.

0:10:58 And then our two directors, which we don't know

0:11:00 whether or not their treasure or PR, however that goes,

0:11:04 is Julie Ruth Malone and then Billie Dello.

0:11:07 So exciting things are going on, so just thank you.

0:11:11 Yay!

0:11:12 Thank you, Christina.

0:11:19 Hey, moving on to item number two,

0:11:21 which is the presentation of the multi-jurisdiction

0:11:24 all hazard mitigation plan

0:11:26 by Rick Fosse, president of the Whisper

0:11:28 and Mountain Professional Services,

0:11:30 and Jackie Fry, our county,

0:11:34 I can't exactly wish,

0:11:35 emergency services director,

0:11:38 I'll get it out there, it was here as well.

0:11:41 We appreciate your time, thank you so much.

0:11:43 Rick Fosse is a contractor for Twin Falls County.

0:11:46 He is doing the revision to the all hazard mitigation plan,

0:11:50 which was done in 2008.

0:11:53 This is a FEMA requirement and I'm gonna have Rick explain

0:11:56 why we're doing this.

0:11:58 The plan will be multi-jurisdictional

0:12:00 before the cities did sign on.

0:12:02 We are doing it now because of some compliance issues

0:12:05 with FEMA and some rewarding.

0:12:07 The plan is an incredible resource

0:12:10 for the smaller communities or for the cities

0:12:12 because it is no cost to you but it also opens up avenues

0:12:15 of funding for you to be able to look

0:12:17 at critical infrastructure issues, water retention

0:12:20 And Rick is going to address that.

0:12:22 So Rick is here tonight with his wife, Shanna.

0:12:25 Thank you.

0:12:29 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:12:30 My name is Rick Fawcett.

0:12:32 I'm the president of Whisper Mount Professional Services.

0:12:34 It's a small consulting firm in Oak Tull, Idaho.

0:12:39 We specialize in emergency management,

0:12:41 consulting, and land use planning.

0:12:44 We've been involved with Twin Falls County now for,

0:12:47 since about 2005 or 2006, and worked with Jackie

0:12:51 for many years, we appreciate this opportunity.

0:12:54 We are talking tonight about the multi-jurisdiction

0:12:56 all hazard mitigation plan.

0:12:58 We did offer this in 2008.

0:13:00 It's required to be updated each five years,

0:13:03 and this is the five-year update on that plan.

0:13:08 The funding for this project is provided

0:13:11 through the Idaho Department of Homeland Security

0:13:13 and the Federal Emergency Management Agency.

0:13:17 The issue that our goal of hazard mitigation,

0:13:21 which I want to point out to you is to save license and reduce property damage.

0:13:26 This is not an emergency management plan, but rather the hazard component of an emergency

0:13:31 management program.

0:13:32 And it also identifies projects which could be implemented in a community to reduce the

0:13:39 risk to the infrastructure in the community.

0:13:42 These are the participating jurisdictions, of course all the cities in the county are

0:13:48 participating as well as the highway districts. We've added this year besides and of course

0:13:55 the county but we've added the Twin Falls County Pesticatement District and also the Twin

0:14:00 Falls Canal Company. We feel like the Twin Falls Canal Company especially is an important

0:14:05 addition to this plan because they are the lifeblood of the Magic Valley and of course

0:14:09 of this county. These are the hazards that we address. Similar hazards were addressed in

0:14:17 2008. We've done some changing that I just bring to your attention. We've combined all

0:14:23 the severe summer weather events into a term called severe weather and then of course severe

0:14:29 weather storms where a standalone hazard in 2008 weeks combined extreme cold into that

0:14:38 hazard category. Drought is a big impact in the state of Idaho. Drought is for your

0:14:45 information is the most expensive natural hazard in the state of Idaho.

0:14:50 And of course the whole canal system in this community is a mitigation effort for drought.

0:14:57 That's what this community was founded on, was really bringing water to the community

0:15:01 because of the drought conditions.

0:15:03 We also look at flash flooding, river flooding, dam failure, canal failure which we've added

0:15:09 this year, geological, we've looked at earthquakes and then landslides and mudslides.

0:15:15 I'm going to talk a little bit the next slide about earthquakes because we've done some additional

0:15:20 analysis on this. In 2008, this was the highest ranked hazard in Twin Falls County based on

0:15:26 perception of the planning committee. We've since reduced that dramatically by some understanding

0:15:34 of the soils in the county. We also do wildfire, biological. We've added this year of burrowing

0:15:41 rodents. There is an outbreak of little pocket gophers in the treasure valley, in the magic

0:15:46 valley, and now moving into the Snake River Plain. These little pesky buggers do a lot

0:15:51 of damage to the canal banks. Of course, it's difficult to get rid of them. You can't shoot

0:15:58 them anymore. You can't trap them anymore in the cities. Or you can trap them. You can't

0:16:03 poison them, and so trapping and other use of owls, for example, as a predatory animal,

0:16:11 or bird to reduce the rodent population that's been added this year just because of the damage

0:16:17 to the canal infrastructure.

0:16:18 And we always include the technological hazards, even though they're knotting, required by FEMA

0:16:24 because whenever you have a natural hazard, you almost always have a fire or a hazment incident

0:16:29 as well.

0:16:34 It's probably difficult to see with the lights on the slide, but let me just, this year we,

0:16:39 at the request of the State of Idaho Hazard Mitigation Officer, we did an extensive study

0:16:46 on the soil types and the soil structures for Twin Falls County.

0:16:51 Looking specifically at, are they susceptible to earthquakes?

0:16:55 First of all, I'd mention to you that there are no active earthquake faults in Twin Falls

0:17:00 County. There are active faults surrounding Twin Falls County like down in Wells and over

0:17:06 in the Sawtos, but in the county boundaries there are no active faults. The first map here

0:17:13 is the, we look at the structure of the soils. In other words, we're looking at are there systems,

0:17:20 rocks, soil, subsurface types of structures that are susceptible to shaking. These red

0:17:32 areas are the bottom here. The green is the highest level and you probably can see on

0:17:41 your handouts that there's very little green except for down in this part of the county,

0:17:46 which is understandable because of the earthquake potential down in Nevada.

0:17:56 The thing that really does the damage when you get an earthquake though is the liquefication

0:17:59 of soils.

0:18:01 And we looked at that pretty extensively.

0:18:03 As you can see, most of the county has very low potential for liquefication.

0:18:10 So based on that, we have dropped the hazard ranking into Infals County for earthquakes

0:18:16 high to low. When we look at the hazard ranking criteria, I'm just gonna go over

0:18:23 this pretty quickly because you'll see the number totals for the city at Twin

0:18:27 Falls. We look at five different categories. Historic low occurrence has

0:18:31 it happened and then we have some rankings for it. Probability is it based on

0:18:37 modeling and decision science type tools. Are we able to determine a

0:18:43 probability, a statistical probability.

0:18:46 And so we have rankings for that.

0:18:49 Additionally, we look at vulnerability, which looks at

0:18:51 people in property, in relationship to the hazard, and

0:18:56 then spatially extend how much of, for example, the city would

0:19:00 be at risk for this potential hazard.

0:19:04 And then we look at magnitude, which is assessment of severity

0:19:08 in terms of fatalities, injuries, and property loss.

0:19:11 Based on that, those categories, this is the hazard ranking

0:19:16 for the city of Twin Falls, slightly different

0:19:19 than the county, except in the high,

0:19:26 I think we're exactly the same as the county.

0:19:28 Severe weather being number one, severe weather storms too.

0:19:31 Communicable diseases, which are human transmitted viruses,

0:19:37 human to human transmission of viruses,

0:19:39 then drought structure fire, the bird flu, which is,

0:19:44 while it's never occurred, as you can see,

0:19:47 and it has a very low probability,

0:19:48 if it ever does occur, the vulnerability,

0:19:51 a spatial extent, and the magnitude

0:19:53 would be significant to the city.

0:19:56 So you can see then, twin hazardous materials

0:19:59 are pretty high, burrowing rodents,

0:20:01 which is damaged to the canals that surround the city,

0:20:04 I think in the city, most of your irrigation waters pied,

0:20:07 correct?

0:20:08 That's my understanding when talking portions of it, okay.

0:20:12 And one thing I would add is talking to the Twin Falls Canal Company.

0:20:15 This is a, was very interesting to me, the relationship between the county,

0:20:19 or the Twin Falls Canal Company in the city in dealing with storm water is,

0:20:24 is an example of the other communities, frankly.

0:20:28 A lot of canal companies refuse to allow city storm water to go into their canals.

0:20:33 And in Twin Falls Canal Company, they actually

0:20:36 high in Fort Anticipated and desirate because it helps them with their flows and so

0:20:41 they've done some remarkable things to deal with the storm water that's put into

0:20:45 the canals as far as treatment for water for disposal and back into the river so

0:20:49 I just would would applaud you in your efforts with Twin Falls Canal Company in

0:20:55 that area that's it's not like it's not being done in any other cities that we

0:21:00 work in in the state. Based on those hazard analysis then we'd ask you if you have

0:21:09 some concerns with projects. These are the projects that were listed in the 2008

0:21:15 plan which we may want to look at a little differently. They were based

0:21:22 primarily on earthquake and landslide but to harden the Twin Falls City water

0:21:26 system supply line that comes down into the canyon as well as the sewer and then

0:21:31 developing an ordinance that manages the growth on the Canyon Rim. Are those projects that you

0:21:38 would like to continue? They were chosen by the mitigation committee actually five years

0:21:45 ago to be rather high and we actually have done pre-engineering estimates of benefit cost

0:21:49 analysis on those particular projects. If you'd like to continue those in the plan and maintain

0:21:54 them as a high priority, we'd be glad to do that. Let me just talk to you a little bit

0:22:00 about the project portion of this plan, these projects are eligible for FEMA funding to conduct

0:22:10 mitigation to address these hazards and these projects. It's a 75-25 percent, 75 percent federal

0:22:18 funding, 25 percent soft match, which can be used in-kind services, can all be used so

0:22:25 There is no cash out of pocket.

0:22:28 Engineering costs do, can be used as well for match,

0:22:31 but those are the projects that we have.

0:22:34 If there are any other projects that you might want us

0:22:38 to consider and add to the plant based on those hazards

0:22:41 that we've described.

0:22:44 Chris talking with light was first.

0:22:45 Don was first.

0:22:47 Yeah.

0:22:48 Go ahead.

0:22:49 Thank you, Chris.

0:22:50 Mr. Fosse, I'm just curious about the project

0:22:53 of developing an ordinance that restricts building on a Snake River Canyon

0:22:58 room. Where did that come from?

0:23:00 That came from the hazard mitigation committee as a suggestion five years ago.

0:23:07 There was no participation in that by the city council or the or the Twin Falls

0:23:13 planning zoning. It was more of a county planning zoning suggestion.

0:23:17 They looked at a county wide for development along the the canyon ramp as a

0:23:21 the potential and we just added that in there for the city, we can take it out, it's just

0:23:28 where it came from.

0:23:29 I guess I'm not so interested in taking it out, I was trying to understand where it came

0:23:32 from, what's the relevance to it, is there a study that says we need to do that, because

0:23:42 we're actually in a committee right now looking at the Canyon Rim and what's that?

0:23:51 to build? Yeah, development of the canyon rim. Well, the hazards of the canyon rim, I

0:23:57 think, are pretty obvious as far as protection, especially from the potential for slides along

0:24:05 the rim that would damage your infrastructure. That would be the primary concern. There's

0:24:10 a lot of wind on that canyon rim. As you know, the largest natural hazard in Twin Falls

0:24:17 County when you when you look just at severe weather is straight line wind and

0:24:21 we have looked at projects along there just based on wind and that's the

0:24:27 primary concerns that and storm water drainage okay off the rim those kinds

0:24:32 of things okay so again just so that I understand it came out of a different

0:24:36 committee saying that we need to look at possibly doing an ordinance regarding

0:24:40 that but it was on a county level done account didn't come to the city no did

0:24:44 not come from the city, but it was, we added in as a city concerned because we did the whole rim and part of city limits covered the

0:24:51 bridge.

0:24:52 Well, I just think it's appropriate to hear this now because we're actually looking at that.

0:24:56 And I, Travis wanted to say something, Mayor, is that all?

0:24:59 I'm sorry, Travis.

0:25:00 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, what I would suggest to the council is we're looking at these projects is actually to have your city staff take a crack at the first projects that then we can then work with Jackie and her team to have those

0:25:14 included. I think that the city staff has a really good understanding of what some of

0:25:20 those needs are and we'll be happy to work with Jackie through our processes and supply

0:25:25 her with a list of projects that could be included that may be eligible for FEMA grants

0:25:32 and opportunities as we move forward. I think what we want to do is we want to make sure

0:25:36 that the projects that are included are projects that are one achievable and two, one, that

0:25:44 we do believe are something that needs to be mitigated or a process in moving forward.

0:25:51 We've made advancements, I think, on all three of those as an organization, and I think that

0:25:56 we want to make sure that this is reflective of what our true needs at the City are.

0:26:05 And I just comment and thank you, I just comment that I 100% agree with that.

0:26:10 These were, there was only three city projects in the last, four city projects, let me correct

0:26:16 myself.

0:26:17 There were four city projects that were in the last plan, one of which was to raise the

0:26:22 Rock Creek sewer lift station and that was, that come out of the 2008 committee.

0:26:28 We actually took the engineers down and looked at that and the Rock Creek's lift station

0:26:32 is actually above the 100 year floodplain.

0:26:35 We dropped that out as a project just because it doesn't qualify.

0:26:39 And so I appreciate that and that would be the best place to get these projects would be

0:26:44 from staff and we could add those.

0:26:48 We'd like to get them if possible within the next 30 days those were trying to wrap this

0:26:52 up.

0:26:56 Sure, Jackie.

0:26:57 Then we're going to go to the questions here.

0:26:59 You need to come to the mic.

0:27:00 You need to come to the mic though, Jackie.

0:27:01 So because they're recorded meeting.

0:27:02 I wanted to make reference on a couple of things.

0:27:07 There was a different city manager when this was addressed also different councilman.

0:27:13 The opportunity for open house input was limited across the board.

0:27:20 Was it just to in fall city?

0:27:22 The projects that were given to us were listed in the plan.

0:27:26 Our focus this time because we've learned a lot with the process with FEMA and what they're

0:27:32 requiring is really to have some buy-in from the city's 100%.

0:27:37 It isn't myself or Rick or any of us wanting to put those projects into the plan.

0:27:42 On your behalf, it's that we really want your input.

0:27:46 There's a number of projects that have even been addressed, such as being able to have

0:27:51 a warning on the prime bridge for Highwind.

0:27:53 And that is something actually ISP has really looked at, was to have a reader boarder assigned

0:27:58 put up because of the Highwind, both on prime and even the Hanson Bridge, which of course

0:28:04 around the city but the point is we get a lot of input but the focus this time is

0:28:09 to really address these issues with you so that what's put into the plan are

0:28:14 projects that you can really look at look at block grants or look at funding

0:28:18 through mitigation funds that will really support your need and that's the

0:28:22 biggest thing so we appreciate it thank you.

0:28:26 I have a couple of suggestions, one, deals with paren bridge, not so much of the high weather,

0:28:36 but I would agree.

0:28:37 When I was a newsman, I was nearly swept off the old bridge, at least by the negative vacuum,

0:28:43 investigating an accident.

0:28:44 That's a good idea.

0:28:47 I'm more concerned for terrorism, and I think working with I.T.D. is entirely a doable and

0:28:55 and a justifiable project for the installation of security cameras, also to take a view some

0:29:01 wacko event to completely paralyze other Idaho by the severing of that absolutely vital transportation

0:29:13 link. And there may be multiple cameras not only on the travel level but even some underneath.

0:29:20 I appreciate that councilman.

0:29:23 Let me just share with you that we need to capture those kinds of projects and we need

0:29:31 to put them in a more separate classified document.

0:29:36 It's not something we want to have open to the general public so that we cannot give the

0:29:42 bad guys so to speak, you know, the idea of our protection.

0:29:45 That's part of what they call the Thera Program, Threat Hazard Identification Risk Assessment,

0:29:50 And we're working with Jackie on that and we'll sure take that on and make sure that this part of that.

0:29:56 Thank you. The second part deals with, it's actually three things tied together.

0:30:02 Two of them are nature related and one is human-caused.

0:30:06 We are extremely vulnerable in Twin Falls because by far the majority of our water comes

0:30:12 in the north side aquifer, transported across the Snake River up the canyon.

0:30:18 We have some wells, but they're low productive wells.

0:30:23 I am and continue to be concerned about the effects of a long-term drought for a number

0:30:29 of years.

0:30:30 We were seeing five or half a percent per year decrease in the flow of the aquifer.

0:30:36 I also would dispute the fact that even though we have no active faults in this area, the

0:30:43 a combination of a drought reducing the natural flow and a seismic shifting of the water tables

0:30:50 could leave us high and dry in the worst case situation. And I think it's worthy of at least

0:30:55 getting on the list of concerns. And that ties into the third thing with the aquifer. It's

0:31:01 not popular to say this now, but we still have an out of control situation in the Idaho Falls

0:31:06 area with the Idaho National Engineering, IAN, EEL, whatever it is now, with the incredible

0:31:18 number of surface dumps and burying of high-grade plutonium and low-grade transurranics on hundreds

0:31:28 of square miles, and some of those were not even mapped out.

0:31:32 I still am greatly concerned that at the time some of that plutonium could reach the water

0:31:39 table.

0:31:40 It could be transported in a bay, maybe a long period of time, but I'm more concerned

0:31:45 how would we ever get it out.

0:31:48 I only raise those because they're all related to our life supply of water, but there are

0:31:53 other cities between here and I know that have impact with that water.

0:32:00 Thank you.

0:32:01 You do have address INL in your plan because you are right on the edge of the ingestion pathway

0:32:08 for a release from a reactor accident from the advanced test reactor.

0:32:13 There's not attention being paid continually to removing the high and the low grade level

0:32:19 waste from the surface and subsurface level because it's not sexy.

0:32:24 It doesn't sell like making a big expensive containment area for a reactor.

0:32:29 And we'll certainly add those concerns.

0:32:31 I think if it just gets somewhere on a Nutilex list

0:32:36 at the bottom I'd be happy.

0:32:38 Would be that.

0:32:39 I think Chris, John Berger.

0:32:40 I was just going to concur with Travis's comment.

0:32:43 I think city staff is probably well equipped

0:32:46 to identify some of the projects that we need to do.

0:32:49 And looking at these projects from the past,

0:32:52 as they stack up to our hazard ratings of those,

0:32:56 I mean, landslide and earthquake,

0:32:59 which I'm guessing are two of the hazards associated

0:33:02 with being on the canyon ram are pretty low on the list.

0:33:06 And so I would hope we could focus our energies

0:33:09 toward the top of those hazards where we might actually

0:33:13 mitigate something as opposed to come up with projects

0:33:16 that might fit the mold.

0:33:17 Yeah, and I wanted to point that out.

0:33:18 The landslide and earthquake have moved down dramatically

0:33:21 since we've done the investigation and the soils

0:33:24 last year and so those were in fact earthquake projects, concerns about earthquake and shaking

0:33:30 the rocks and damaging the water lines going and sewer line across there.

0:33:34 That's why I want to point them out to you and make sure that you're on the same sheet

0:33:39 with us that we want to probably change those.

0:33:42 That's all a question I have to go if you want to continue.

0:33:46 Really the last step here is of course we talked about the projects, the plan will be ready

0:33:51 for review following these public meetings or having with the cities this week and with

0:33:58 the commissioners on the hazard ranking and the plan will be available for review and it

0:34:03 would help the staff would review that for you. It's not light reading, it's 481 pages

0:34:10 long now I think and the last step I guess is probably within the next 30 days or so

0:34:16 So we're going to provide to you a resolution to adopt or not to adopt the plan, but to endorse

0:34:24 the plan and ask you to buy a resolution and say that you'd participate in the plan, which

0:34:30 is a FEMA requirement.

0:34:31 And then your city is covered.

0:34:34 It's like an insurance policy.

0:34:37 You may never do a mitigation project, but if you have a disaster declared, a federally

0:34:44 declared disaster in your community, and there's damage to your infrastructure, then you're eligible

0:34:50 to receive post-disaster money from the federal government to fix the problems, and that's

0:34:54 really the purpose of this program throughout the United States, the disaster act of 2000

0:34:59 asks all counties and cities to participate in this planning process so they could be eligible

0:35:05 for the funding in a post-disaster.

0:35:07 So thank you for your time, appreciate the opportunity to be here.

0:35:11 I have one more question.

0:35:12 Sure, Mel.

0:35:13 So there's no pre-disaster because we'd really like to build some more water storage tanks

0:35:17 on this site for the drought issues.

0:35:21 There's no money attached.

0:35:23 There is money attached for pre-disaster mitigation.

0:35:25 I'm just stating that if you never do, the best thing is that you're covered in a post.

0:35:31 That's the main thing for endorsing and signing on.

0:35:35 Some counties, or some cities in the county really don't have any projects that you'd

0:35:38 like to do, but we're asking them to sign on just to protect them for the future.

0:35:42 Sure.

0:35:43 Thank you.

0:35:44 Thank you.

0:35:45 Thank you.

0:35:46 Jackie, did you have anything else to add?

0:35:49 Okay.

0:35:53 Thank you for the presentation.

0:35:55 Thank you.

0:35:56 Well, we'll get a copy of the final plan.

0:35:58 I guess.

0:36:00 I'm going to try to play in.

0:36:03 All right.

0:36:04 Thank you.

0:36:05 Will it be signed by Jackie?

0:36:06 Her autograph.

0:36:07 Okay.

0:36:08 Excellent.

0:36:09 That's important.

0:36:10 On the third page of the project.

0:36:15 Okay.

0:36:16 Okay.

0:36:17 Okay.

0:36:18 Thank you.

0:36:19 Item number three is consideration of request from Thomas

0:36:22 and Heather Wagonman to waive the non-conforming

0:36:26 building expansion permit process to allow expansion

0:36:29 of an existing non-conforming residence

0:36:32 located at 4,006 Canyon Ridge Drive.

0:36:36 Mitch Hummel will be handling this for us

0:36:39 and I see the applicant here.

0:36:41 We'll probably have you them in opportunity to speak as well.

0:36:55 I've seen some of these requests come through,

0:36:57 but probably not for a little while.

0:36:59 So I'll give you a little explanation.

0:37:01 Here's the site.

0:37:05 Falls Avenue is across the south of the property

0:37:07 just a little bit, and then that road is Canyon Ridge Drive.

0:37:13 I'm gonna zoom in a little bit here,

0:37:19 and that's kind of where we're at.

0:37:22 You can see on this exhibit,

0:37:23 the 30-foot front property line is the purple box

0:37:28 around there, and we can see that the home

0:37:30 encroaches into that 30-foot setback on Canyon Ridge Drive.

0:37:34 That is what makes this home currently non-conforming, and therefore the need for the request tonight.

0:37:42 The applicants would like to do an addition on this home, and it's this cross-hatched

0:37:50 area, that part of the plan.

0:37:53 Is that on the opposite side of the home?

0:37:56 Yep, it's on the opposite side of the home from the street.

0:37:59 So this is the facing north as well here too, and that got a little bit.

0:38:04 So the yellow in this exhibit would be the setback box.

0:38:09 So you can see that the addition is well within the required

0:38:13 setbacks.

0:38:14 It doesn't further encroach into the setback

0:38:17 on the street side where the encroach is already in place.

0:38:21 But because the home encroaches on the front side,

0:38:24 we have to go through this process of the nonconforming

0:38:27 building expansion permit.

0:38:31 The code does allow the council to waive that requirement.

0:38:33 So for residential applications, so we oftentimes

0:38:37 will see these coming for the council.

0:38:40 To do an addition, like we're looking at here on the backside

0:38:43 that complies with the code, is that all right?

0:38:45 Or do we still want to make these guys go through the nonconforming

0:38:48 building expansion process, which is a series of public hearings

0:38:51 and planning his own equation gets involved and all that.

0:38:55 So typically in the past, we've seen these things come through

0:38:59 and they would be approved so long as no further encroachment

0:39:05 is being proposed or, you know,

0:39:07 and that is the case here.

0:39:08 We have no further encroachment being proposed.

0:39:13 So the council has an option to implement section 1034

0:39:18 and waive the requirement for the nonconforming building

0:39:20 expansion.

0:39:23 It's basically where we're at.

0:39:25 So you don't need to hear from the applicant

0:39:28 unless you have questions.

0:39:31 or I can try to answer questions if you have them.

0:39:33 Chris, talk you to them.

0:39:34 I think I read it in here, Mitch, but just reacquaint us

0:39:37 that if this non-conformance use or expansion use

0:39:43 were allotted then on the, what is this, the setback building

0:39:50 setback from a lot line of seven feet?

0:39:53 For the side that's not adjacent to the street,

0:39:56 this, let me make sure there's other picture here.

0:39:58 You can see that this lot has streets on three sides.

0:40:02 And because of that, it's got a front yard on three sides.

0:40:05 Those are 30 feet.

0:40:06 The side that's, in this case, the west side of the property

0:40:09 is a seven foot setback.

0:40:10 This is in the SUI zone.

0:40:12 So that's a seven foot.

0:40:13 Seven foot?

0:40:14 OK.

0:40:16 Oh yeah, sorry to say it here.

0:40:17 We're back a little second.

0:40:19 Thank you, Mayor.

0:40:20 I do have a question for the applicant, or perhaps if you.

0:40:24 Mr. Reggman, if you'd come forth and identify yourself

0:40:26 So give us your addresses as a broadcast and meet, even we need to get that information.

0:40:31 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, my name is Thomas Wong.

0:40:34 I live at 4.05. Can you describe it to him also?

0:40:38 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Very quiet voice, so maybe a little louder if you could.

0:40:42 Probably more directly into the mic. There you go, thank you.

0:40:45 Thank you. I appreciate you coming.

0:40:48 Because your house will, where the proposed addition is, it will come closer to your neighbor's house.

0:40:55 curious since this process will waive the public hearing.

0:41:00 Have you just informed your neighbors of your intent?

0:41:02 Yes, because we spoke with our neighbors.

0:41:04 I don't know if you can see from the picture there, but there's actually kind of a hedge

0:41:08 of trees of high fence there.

0:41:11 So they really would not even really see it at all.

0:41:14 Okay, so none of the trees will be removed.

0:41:17 Nothing will be removed.

0:41:18 Nothing will actually be moved in any way there.

0:41:21 that we have spoken with all the neighbors north,

0:41:24 southeast, west, southeast, southwest, everyone around.

0:41:29 Great, yeah, it didn't seem to be a project that would affect them,

0:41:34 but I just wanted to make sure that they were informed

0:41:36 before we waved the process.

0:41:37 Thank you.

0:41:39 Mr. Eigman, did you ensure already there?

0:41:41 Did you have anything else to add?

0:41:42 No, no, no, no, no, this time, Mr. Mayor.

0:41:44 All right, OK, thank you.

0:41:48 Seeing no lights and no additional information

0:41:50 before it, do I have a motion?

0:41:53 I would move to approve the request of the applicants wengements to waive the nonconforming

0:42:01 building expansion permit process and allow expansion of the existing nonconforming residents

0:42:07 at 4005 Canyon Ridge Drive.

0:42:14 Second.

0:42:15 I'll move by Chris talking in a second by Rebecca Miltzsleke.

0:42:20 Mine says 4,000 and six, but is it actually 4,000 and five, Mitch, on the address?

0:42:26 Mine says five.

0:42:27 I'm going to make sure we get the right address in there.

0:42:30 The motion.

0:42:31 The staff report says five.

0:42:34 Okay.

0:42:35 So it is five.

0:42:36 All right.

0:42:37 That's what Chris's motion was.

0:42:39 All right.

0:42:40 So you know additional lights.

0:42:42 Lea, roll call vote.

0:42:43 Greg Latin.

0:42:44 Yes.

0:42:45 Yes.

0:42:46 Rebecca Milseika.

0:42:47 Yes.

0:42:48 Chris Coughington.

0:42:49 Yes.

0:42:50 Sean Berger.

0:42:51 Yes.

0:42:52 Don Hall.

0:42:53 Yes.

0:42:54 Suzanne Houghton.

0:42:55 Yes.

0:42:56 Motion passes 7-0.

0:42:57 Thank you for going through the process.

0:43:00 Moving on to item number 4.

0:43:03 Consideration request to use street impact fee funds to install a traffic signal at the

0:43:08 intersection of North College Road and Fillmore Street.

0:43:12 Jackie Fields.

0:43:13 Good evening.

0:43:15 Tonight, the request is to use Street Impact Feast to install a signal at the intersection

0:43:24 of North College in Fillmark. Currently, the capital improvements plan for the impact fees

0:43:33 includes a signal at the intersection of Cheney and North College. So, when the project, the

0:43:49 the Chaney Drive project constructs, it will extend from Washington Street as the bar proposes

0:43:57 down onto North College, and North College will kind of tee into Chaney. In this way,

0:44:07 the roadway will focus the traffic towards Wal-Mart and the hospital, where we believe

0:44:17 people will have an express interest in going. At the time that we developed the CIP, it wasn't

0:44:23 clear to me or known that this alignment would be just as it is suggested to me. And so I wasn't

0:44:31 sure whether or not we would need a signal there in the near term or not. In the near term

0:44:36 we're not going to need a signal there. But we do now have warrants for a signal at the

0:44:44 the intersection of North College and Fillmore, sorry.

0:44:49 And that is, not on that map.

0:44:54 Yeah, mile, it doesn't really look like the Fillmore

0:44:59 that we know and love, but so generally,

0:45:02 a third of a mile down the street.

0:45:04 So that's the congestion there is getting to a place

0:45:07 where we can't mitigate it with striping

0:45:10 and with additional signage.

0:45:13 We talked about making it a three-force way stop configuration, and that just exacerbates

0:45:20 our situation.

0:45:22 The loads there are intense in two of the legs, and one has none, and the third one's still

0:45:29 less in pretty fair traffic.

0:45:35 The rules for impact fees is that they need to be used on growth-related projects.

0:45:42 development that has occurred over time and is growth related. So we're seeking a permission

0:45:59 to use the funds there because impact fees are what I budgeted for this year and out of

0:46:05 all of the various signals that are impact fee related, this is this one would be the

0:46:14 most appropriate from a load perspective, from a alarm perspective. So that's why I'm

0:46:21 here asking for approval tonight.

0:46:23 Here we have a couple of lights, actually three lights.

0:46:25 Rebecca Milsika.

0:46:27 Thank you, Mayor.

0:46:28 My question is for Jackie on the proposed teeny drive.

0:46:34 It seems like she would be used to get east to west

0:46:38 or in and out of town.

0:46:40 And so I'm wondering why it curves down towards North College,

0:46:44 which is a two-lane street, as opposed

0:46:47 to curving up towards Pole Line, which

0:46:49 seems more suited to fit higher fields of traffic.

0:46:53 Because if you're already on North College

0:46:55 or you're somewhere along Washington Street,

0:46:58 don't you think you would take Washington Street and then

0:47:01 pull, I mean, I'm not an engineer.

0:47:02 I'm just asking because this is how I would drive.

0:47:05 You'd think that Washington Street and Pull

0:47:07 I'm being more capable of holding higher traffic.

0:47:11 It just seems weird we would direct traffic down to North

0:47:14 College, which is just two or three lanes now of a street

0:47:19 Does that make sense, is that on the street master plan that it goes that direction or why

0:47:25 is it being proposed in this configuration?

0:47:30 So the short answer is that that type of alignment is shown in the street master plan.

0:47:40 Now to your question of why wouldn't it dive up towards pole line or come straight across?

0:47:48 So if I'm here, the part of who we're trying to serve are people all the way down the pole

0:48:07 It's not as direct, people tend to take the most direct to the fastest street in the hospital.

0:48:17 So the hope that the goal is to provide for a suitable alternative to polls and polling towards this fairly intense commercial area.

0:48:33 So the goal is also to potentially direct through traffic around the developing CSI campus.

0:48:44 Okay, and that's part of the reason that CSI sought the federal aid funding as a safety project because ultimately in the long range

0:48:52 goal the hope is that North College will not become a dangerous road for the people that come across the street and

0:49:00 There's a large number of people that do not believe that pedestrian overpasses are

0:49:08 Will be used

0:49:09 Okay, and so are we will this?

0:49:12 this construction of the street

0:49:15 caused more traffic to be put on North College

0:49:17 and would that cause additional lanes needed

0:49:20 and to widen that out to full width?

0:49:24 Or are we tracking that process so that we'll know

0:49:28 are we gonna need to upgrade North College

0:49:30 specifically between Fillmore and Blue Lakes?

0:49:37 It is likely that at some point in our future

0:49:39 with or without that Chaney Drive extension,

0:49:42 the piece of North College between about the film or at least back towards Blue Lakes will

0:49:48 need to be widened. There's just a tremendous amount of traffic there. The goal here is to

0:49:54 have the people coming from Wal-Mart and the hospital not necessarily choosing to drive

0:49:58 on North College from Washington all the way out but to go around on Cheney. So potentially

0:50:04 a diversion of the near term traffic load. Years and years from now there may be a tremendous

0:50:10 number of people on all streets, Pole Line, Chaney, North College, someone will be wishing

0:50:16 for a road right through the middle of CSI's campus and then falls as well, you know, because

0:50:22 that's the way of it. As you grow, there becomes more pressure on your collectors.

0:50:27 Okay.

0:50:28 So we're trying to address collector capacity with this project directly.

0:50:35 Okay.

0:50:36 And so if we track, are we tracking traffic loads on that so that it would qualify for

0:50:43 growth related funding?

0:50:47 On Chaney Drive?

0:50:49 Well on North College particularly.

0:50:51 Not yet.

0:50:53 Okay.

0:50:54 But you bring up a good point.

0:50:56 So currently there is, the CIP is, the Capital Improvements Plan is up for revision and it

0:51:05 may be something that we choose to track,

0:51:07 although we're not going to have data until the road

0:51:10 where it actually opens.

0:51:11 And as an aside for those of you that may be interested,

0:51:17 we're going to schedule a public hearing

0:51:20 for a discussion on this actual alignment.

0:51:22 And several weeks from now,

0:51:24 it always seems like a couple to me,

0:51:25 but I believe the date is June 10th.

0:51:27 So a past council had asked staff

0:51:33 and the project proponents

0:51:34 to come and discuss the alignment when it got to a place

0:51:37 where there was preliminary design

0:51:39 and the environmental is completing.

0:51:41 So it's about the right time.

0:51:45 Great, I appreciate that.

0:51:46 Thank you.

0:51:47 It might be something that we at least talk about

0:51:49 or consider.

0:51:51 Don Hall, you know, Jackie, I wish we could go back

0:51:54 and build Cheney all the way through,

0:51:57 but there's a building in the way.

0:51:59 I think it's Gold's Gym that you can't even get

0:52:02 through there, right?

0:52:03 Yeah.

0:52:03 And speaking as one that drives this road two or three times a day, the North College on

0:52:10 the way to the CSI campus, the intersection that we're talking about, Fillmore and North

0:52:16 College scares me a lot because there's so much traffic on there.

0:52:22 I think that a signal is warranted, just my own perspective.

0:52:27 And so I'm in full support of this.

0:52:32 The other issue about Cheney kind of curving around the campus, I think one of the reasons

0:52:37 that CSI is interested in this is because it will lighten the load on North College that

0:52:44 is on the campus basically because that's being used drastically now as a arterial for folks

0:52:55 to get over to Washington.

0:52:56 So I think the first step obviously is the signal and then the next step hopefully we

0:53:00 can pull that road around. I think it's going to make all of us a lot happier and safer.

0:53:06 Dr. Stockton?

0:53:08 Well, Jackie, I'm a whole surprise that we would put a signal on a T-intersection as opposed

0:53:16 to an axe. Is it really warranted by the traffic flow, not accidents?

0:53:22 So remarkably, we're relatively accident-free, however, the loads are impressive.

0:53:34 So when the traffic tech showed up with data, it kind of made me question it because it's

0:53:43 big.

0:53:44 It's in several hundred, you know, hundred or so.

0:53:48 Well, certainly take the word on the data, but my real question is why it's on it, why

0:53:54 that's not someday, that's supposed to be a cross, or not a T. That's my exact question.

0:54:02 I will not vote for this if it leads to the assumption that we're going to punch in North

0:54:06 Fillmore from Falls. Well, I think that that is, while that is a personal goal of mine,

0:54:17 is probably not going to be realized in my career here.

0:54:21 If CSI were to dedicate some of their own land

0:54:23 and not impact the property's residential properties

0:54:27 to the east, that is one thing.

0:54:30 But it is a terribly expensive proposition

0:54:33 that I hope that this signaling will not, in your mind,

0:54:38 necessarily mean the next year or even when I'm alive

0:54:43 on this council, that I would vote for it.

0:54:48 Other than that, I hope it's a real good project.

0:54:51 I'll just acknowledge your opinion as to what it is.

0:54:56 I also probably want to reassure you that putting in a signal there does not imply that I'm going to be able to get court and conservation park moved any time in my lifetime.

0:55:06 At the fire station, the issues are numerous, including the property owners.

0:55:12 It's going to stay generally in our long-term plan.

0:55:16 But I think we can agree on the increasing trap

0:55:18 bloating in that area.

0:55:21 Well, Jackie, I'm going to concur with Dawn on the,

0:55:25 I mean, you've been to the Pioneer Post Office

0:55:29 and came out that way and wanting

0:55:30 to turn left on the North College.

0:55:33 I can't believe the accident data doesn't show it,

0:55:36 because each and every time you're struggling to do so,

0:55:42 that's a pretty intense corner at this point.

0:55:44 because of all the, like you said,

0:55:46 all the growth that has occurred in there,

0:55:48 including the post office and those office buildings

0:55:50 and people coming, pole lying to come that way.

0:55:53 It's a very busy intersection.

0:55:55 I hope we voting yes to use impact fees to build this thing.

0:55:59 Don Hall's light and next, then Suzanne Hockett.

0:56:02 Jack, I just want to clarify.

0:56:03 We're saying it's a T intersection,

0:56:05 but it really isn't.

0:56:06 Fillmore is punched through.

0:56:07 It doesn't go very far, but it is punched through, right?

0:56:11 Next to the, I'm running sounds off.

0:56:14 I'm looking at Google Earth right now. It's a quarter mile, at least, punch through.

0:56:19 There it is. Oh, wait.

0:56:24 I will be in the future. I would be in full support of punching that all the way through,

0:56:29 but I agree with Chris that it needs to minimize the impact of those residents.

0:56:36 I know that they're very concerned about that, but that's just another route for folks to take.

0:56:43 A lot of people find their way through the campus or somewhere and then bypass what they

0:56:50 would take if Fillmore was punched through.

0:56:52 This is that I guess.

0:56:56 I was going there too, living on the west side of Washington and working on Blue Lake

0:57:03 Street across from there, that is my main road through Twin Falls and the post office

0:57:07 with my business.

0:57:09 I can't count how many close calls I've had personally there with people turning off of

0:57:16 Fillmore on to North College and coming straight into you as you're going straight, they don't

0:57:20 stop there.

0:57:21 It's a very scary place to go and I was going to mention that it does go through there at

0:57:26 the Renaissance office complex.

0:57:28 You can go straight across there and I say kudos to you.

0:57:33 This will make my life a much safer place and I appreciate it.

0:57:37 Thank you.

0:57:38 Seeing no additional lights, I assume we're probably ready for a motion.

0:57:47 I would move approval of the request to use street impact funds,

0:57:53 fee funds to install a traffic signal at the intersection of North College and

0:57:58 Fillmore. Second.

0:58:01 I've been moved by Don Hall and seconded by Susanne Hawkins that we approve this request for a traffic signal.

0:58:08 North College and Fillmore. Chris.

0:58:10 Second, could you kind of acquaint the council on rape

0:58:12 firms, what kind of dollar figure we're talking about on this?

0:58:19 We should clear this project at $300,000 or less.

0:58:24 OK.

0:58:24 Thank you.

0:58:26 Wow, that seems like a lot for a single,

0:58:28 but I know that's what they cost.

0:58:29 I haven't formally estimated it.

0:58:32 All right.

0:58:32 Sure.

0:58:33 OK, it's been I've been using a traditional number

0:58:37 for signal installation that could be an I2D type signal.

0:58:44 So I just don't, we might have a little bit of right away

0:58:48 acquisition we have to do.

0:58:51 I hope not.

0:58:52 I'm going to try to skinny right up through there.

0:58:54 Thank you, Jackie.

0:58:55 Don Hall.

0:58:56 I've always told people, because I think I've been told this

0:58:58 before, you need to bank on about 500,000 for a traffic signal.

0:59:02 But it just depends on the intersection of life.

0:59:04 I've been using four.

0:59:05 And it depends on where you are.

0:59:07 If it's really big, then after a while your master arms

0:59:11 can't get long enough, so you have to put in extra poles

0:59:13 and stuff like that.

0:59:14 On this specific intersection, is there any underground

0:59:18 already placed?

0:59:20 Nothing there.

0:59:21 We have to do everything.

0:59:23 OK, thank you.

0:59:24 Somebody might surprise me with conduit,

0:59:26 but I would guess it is an R.

0:59:28 OK.

0:59:29 All right, so you know additional lights?

0:59:35 Leyla, roll call vote?

0:59:36 Jim Mun.

0:59:37 Yes.

0:59:38 Rebecca Milsica.

0:59:39 Yes.

0:59:40 Chris Talkington.

0:59:41 And Thursday last like yes.

0:59:43 Sean Berger.

0:59:44 Yes.

0:59:45 Don Hall.

0:59:46 Same as Chris.

0:59:47 Yes.

0:59:48 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:59:49 Yes.

0:59:50 In Greg Lansing.

0:59:51 Yes.

0:59:52 Motion passes 7-0.

0:59:53 Thank you, Jackie.

0:59:54 The next item is public input.

0:59:56 The amendment to public that has something they would like to bring forth tonight that has

1:00:04 not been already discussed.

1:00:06 No one's sprinting forward, so we'll move on to City Manager.

1:00:13 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, just a couple of quick items.

1:00:16 Number one, we're going to have our second public open house for the wastewater bond election.

1:00:24 It's going to be on this Thursday at six o'clock from five o'clock to seven o'clock in this room.

1:00:32 You can vote absentee through Thursday and then individuals who are

1:00:39 Interested in voting in the election would actually vote at their usual polling place on the 21st polls

1:00:46 Will be open from eight in the morning till eight at night. What was the time on Thursday?

1:00:51 5 p.m. to 7 p.m.

1:01:05 two hours. All right, okay. Donald, I just want to mention all Travis and then I apologize.

1:01:14 I can wait my turn. Sure, sir. At this time, you know, one of the things that we're trying

1:01:21 to do is really plan those council meetings in advance for workload, although some nights

1:01:26 it doesn't appear that way, we really are trying to manage the agenda. We have no business right

1:01:31 right now for the Tuesday after Memorial Day, which would be the May 28th meeting.

1:01:38 So I throw that out to the council.

1:01:41 If in the reason we're approaching you two weeks in advance at this point in time,

1:01:46 we do not believe there will be any items.

1:01:48 But should you elect to hold the evening meeting, we would have accounts payable.

1:01:55 And so we just kind of have to adjust our internal schedules if there is no meeting on how we process bills and accounts.

1:02:00 just so that the council knows, we have no business or items for your consideration at

1:02:05 this point for the 28th of May.

1:02:09 And then this week is a pretty significant week for our police department as they're going

1:02:14 forward with a tip of the cop on the 15th.

1:02:19 They have their awards banquet on Thursday.

1:02:25 They have their beat the heat in which Captain Anthony Barnhart will be the rabbit.

1:02:33 And so if you can beat him, you'll get a very nice medallion.

1:02:38 Mind you that he is an incredible shape.

1:02:41 So I'm not certain how many medallions will be handed out that day, but those folks that

1:02:48 beat him will be obviously very fast.

1:02:50 And then also there in combination with Maxie's Pizza, they'll be also delivering pizzas.

1:02:57 And all of these causes and all of the monies that they raise goes to the Special Olympics.

1:03:02 And so it's really a really great cause that they're moving forward with.

1:03:06 And so I would encourage you to support that as you can this week.

1:03:10 Also, the Memorial, the Law Officer Memorial, which will be Saturday at 11 o'clock.

1:03:17 If you've never had the opportunity to attend that event,

1:03:20 I would strongly encourage you to do so.

1:03:24 I'd like to go ahead and take up the one issue concerning

1:03:27 the meeting on the 28th.

1:03:30 I will not be here.

1:03:32 There's a side note, but that doesn't mean if you'd

1:03:34 rest in you want to come here and approve accounts payable

1:03:37 and go home, you're certainly welcome to,

1:03:40 but I would suggest that we may be canceled

1:03:42 on meeting if there's no items for business that evening.

1:03:46 I will be out of town that night as well.

1:03:47 I actually, too, I'm out of town that night.

1:03:49 All right, so I think we should have everyone calling.

1:03:53 Just to do that.

1:03:54 Nice job.

1:03:55 All right, if you're hearing no dissension,

1:04:00 do we need a vote on that for it?

1:04:01 It's the council meeting.

1:04:03 I'm just going to make an administrative decision

1:04:05 as the mayor that we are canceling the meeting on that week

1:04:09 due to the lack of business and, in fact,

1:04:10 it looks like quite a few are going to be out of town.

1:04:13 So, when I'm adjusting your schedule for the accounts payable, Don Hall.

1:04:19 I wanted to remind folks that there will be an original town cell site residential walking

1:04:25 tour on May 18th as well.

1:04:28 It starts at 10 a.m.

1:04:31 It will start at the library and that's just before the police memorial that I was also

1:04:35 going to mention.

1:04:36 It's at City Park at 11 at the Van Shell and if you haven't been to either of those, I

1:04:43 got a preview of the walking tour the other night with Dr. Tremaine and it's

1:04:47 fascinating to walk around this town and look at the architecture and the rich

1:04:52 history that we have here and and and homes that I drive by every day that I

1:04:59 didn't realize the different styles and and little nuances of them and it's well

1:05:04 worth taking that trip and and if you know anything about Dr. Tremaine it's an

1:05:09 an entertaining trip as well, so just wanted to tell folks about that.

1:05:13 All right.

1:05:14 Thank you, Don.

1:05:15 Chris, thanks.

1:05:16 All due respect to our public hearing, it's waiting to take just a moment if you pass those

1:05:20 out to the Council.

1:05:21 The Library's, of course, as all departments are in the city getting into the budget this

1:05:26 year, but the fascinating facts from last year I think is worth looking after just a second.

1:05:32 If you go to the back page, the Library, of course, in the past year has started extending

1:05:38 it's hours into the Monday evening. The last year, there has been a fairly major remodeling

1:05:45 of the interior of the library, which is with the tax credit from Idaho Power and the monthly

1:05:53 savings on power is really bringing the building into the energy compliance mode finally. They've

1:05:59 had a bunch of compact shelving that came out of capital improvements. So the book, Mobile,

1:06:06 again I'd like to say what a dramatic improvement this represents for the city because we've

1:06:12 done it with existing staff and we're going to be able to take books and library materials

1:06:17 to people that have not had or chose not to have access. Also laptops are now available,

1:06:25 the library. If you go inside a couple salient facts in the middle of there, this is one of

1:06:31 measure of communication meeting centers for the entire city. Nearly 800 people a day go through

1:06:38 the library and in that amount of time they check out 1,538 items per day, those 800 people.

1:06:48 And the library now has over 200,000 items including everything from hardback covers to

1:06:54 CDs and music. So the library is kind of in the shadows a lot of time, but it's one of

1:07:02 the major quality of live entities that we can pride ourselves in. Thank you.

1:07:08 Thank you Chris. Sean Burger. So I just wanted to point out that the hanging

1:07:13 baskets that we'll be returning to Shoshone Street the week of the 27th are sold out in

1:07:20 All of them, only less than 10 days with two emails

1:07:25 and about four phone calls, they're gone, so.

1:07:28 How many altogether, Sean?

1:07:30 So that puts us, actually at 71.

1:07:33 Wow.

1:07:35 I'm having a little back and forth with Dennis

1:07:37 to see just how many brackets we have,

1:07:38 so there may be a couple still available,

1:07:40 or may need to refund a couple of people

1:07:43 their sponsorships, but we should be in good shape

1:07:47 for that, and the baskets are all ready to go from mosses,

1:07:50 and the city crews are all ready to go with watering,

1:07:52 and we will get the signs changed out

1:07:54 with vital signs over the next couple of weeks,

1:07:57 and should be all bright and cheery for western days.

1:08:00 Excellent.

1:08:01 Thank you, Chuck.

1:08:02 Appreciate your efforts and chambers efforts on this.

1:08:05 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:08:07 I'm not quite sure how to address this.

1:08:10 So this year we've kind of let the impog thing

1:08:14 go without making any decisions.

1:08:16 And one of the unintended consequences of that

1:08:19 is our city band. We have always been their source of funding and they are scheduled to

1:08:25 start performing in June but we haven't approved any money and they have no money to go forward

1:08:30 with. And so we've kind of left them in a really precarious situation and I know we're

1:08:37 not ready to make impog decisions but they are the one thing that is solely dependent

1:08:44 on us really and to drop funding to them without any advance warning. I feel it's kind of an

1:08:50 an unfair position to put them in because they haven't had a chance to look for other

1:08:54 funding.

1:08:55 I think they've kind of assumed that we were going to take care of them because we didn't

1:08:59 make it clear to them that we wouldn't.

1:09:01 And so I don't know what your guys' feelings are, but I thought I should make everybody

1:09:07 aware.

1:09:08 Travis.

1:09:09 So the funding has been allocated through the budget process as a larger pot, but the

1:09:15 council has not gone through the process of dividing up the pot to specific causes.

1:09:20 And so we've been as a staff working with Rebecca, Jim Munn, and the Mayor in developing

1:09:31 a new matrix.

1:09:32 And Josh, I believe, sent that out today.

1:09:33 And it's a matrix designed to look more.

1:09:39 I look at it and look good.

1:09:41 Josh will be sending it out later today or tonight, tomorrow.

1:09:47 What it does is it really resembles that of the health care or the health initiative,

1:09:51 between false health initiative and Rebecca brought that up.

1:09:55 And that's the new model that we've been focusing on.

1:09:58 Typically what we've done is we've allocated last year

1:10:01 it was $21,200 to the city band.

1:10:04 And that money is available as part of the $100,000

1:10:12 that the council has put into larger part

1:10:15 that is still waiting for allocation.

1:10:20 Rebecca Mills, like it's late, was first, I believe.

1:10:23 Thank you, Mayor.

1:10:23 I just wanted to report from the committee

1:10:25 that we are finished with our process.

1:10:27 And so as soon as we could place MPOG on the agenda,

1:10:32 I believe we're ready to go to make those decisions.

1:10:35 And so it would just be up to scheduling.

1:10:38 And it's unfortunate that so many people

1:10:41 are going to be gone because I was thinking

1:10:43 that it might be a really good item for May 28th.

1:10:46 But with so many council members gone,

1:10:49 we might need to schedule a different day.

1:10:51 but I believe that we're ready to discuss in POC

1:10:55 as soon as we see fit.

1:10:58 Oh, I for one council, after it took me a while

1:11:03 to get my head around why we funded the city band,

1:11:07 but once I did and attended those meetings

1:11:10 and saw folks that come far and wide to come see them

1:11:14 and that's their entertainment.

1:11:15 It really does in my opinion,

1:11:17 bringing us back to our history

1:11:19 and to see families and folks come into that city park

1:11:24 and enjoy that, it's almost like you're stepping back in time.

1:11:28 I would, I don't think our intention of trying

1:11:31 to do something with Impog this year was anyway,

1:11:35 trying to undermine or take away from our city band

1:11:41 and if we need to make a special motion tonight

1:11:45 to make sure that we retain the funding for them

1:11:48 so that they can go on.

1:11:50 I understand they have a budget to meet.

1:11:53 And again, I don't think our intention was to delay this

1:11:57 to the point where they were unsure

1:11:59 or they couldn't fund their own performances.

1:12:03 So I'm in.

1:12:04 It was a motion.

1:12:06 OK, I make the motion that we fund the city ban

1:12:09 to their amount that we always do every year this year.

1:12:14 Second.

1:12:15 Then move by Don Hall and second the by Rebecca

1:12:17 I can build a sliker that we've been on the band of $21,200.

1:12:22 We do have some lights on.

1:12:25 I have not been doing a good job of keeping up here.

1:12:27 So Sean Berger, I believe, was next.

1:12:28 And then Jim Mine.

1:12:32 So with all due respect to the council folks who

1:12:35 made this motion in the second and to the city band,

1:12:39 does it not defeat the purpose of actually revising

1:12:42 our MPOG process to be something more accepting

1:12:45 of the full council and then circumventing it

1:12:48 by just passing a motion to fund them to the level we did last year.

1:12:52 It just seems completely counterproductive to the whole process.

1:12:56 We've been going through all these months to assess the municipal powers

1:13:00 outsource grant program.

1:13:03 And again, with all due respect to the band, I think what they do is wonderful.

1:13:08 They've been in existence for 100 plus years, and I think that they could rely

1:13:15 on some other community support to support their programs,

1:13:19 much as I think all of the other programs

1:13:24 that we fund through the Municipal Powers

1:13:25 Outsource Grant Program,

1:13:27 there isn't one that we fund 100%.

1:13:32 Thanks, John, Jima.

1:13:34 Thank you, Mayor.

1:13:34 I also really think I will support funding this evening

1:13:40 without a complete vetting of the entire

1:13:42 impact process that was put together

1:13:44 to examine all these different groups who have come forward.

1:13:48 I am concerned about the timing, I agree with Rebecca, it would be nice to have a meeting

1:13:53 soon where we could get this thing funded, but it does somewhat circumvent the M-POG process

1:13:59 by funding the city ban and not allowing all of those groups to make a presentation or have

1:14:07 a vetting process with the council, so I won't support the motion.

1:14:11 Thank you, Mayor.

1:14:13 First of all, I just want to clarify that I don't have a conflict with the city ban in

1:14:17 years past I did as my husband played in the band and he received funds, he was paid for

1:14:24 that.

1:14:25 And so there was a financial conflict and he's no longer in the band so I no longer have

1:14:28 financial conflict.

1:14:29 But I do want to say in response to the comments made that I think the city band is different.

1:14:37 I don't think it circumvents the process.

1:14:39 reason why we were finding MPOC was because it was such a tricky process to grade, in

1:14:48 a sense, these presentations and we were presented with more requests than we have funding, and

1:14:54 so it's a difficult process to sit up here and to have some sort of objective and systematic

1:15:00 way to grade the process, I think the city band is different because it bears the city's

1:15:06 name. It is the Twin Falls City Band. It's the longest running band. I think it's one of

1:15:11 two longest running bands in the United States of America. I can't imagine why you would break

1:15:17 with that history and that significance to our community. As Councilman Hall was saying,

1:15:24 the historic significance and the community significance is just huge. You can see by

1:15:31 by how many people attend those concerts every year.

1:15:35 But I think it's different because it bears our name.

1:15:38 It may not be ran by us because obviously we're not musicians.

1:15:44 It's really based on volunteers who volunteer to play.

1:15:48 But I think the refining of the process

1:15:51 has more to do with deciding what other projects we will join.

1:15:58 For me, anyway, I can't imagine not funding the Twin Falls City Band.

1:16:02 So I will support the motion.

1:16:05 Chris, David?

1:16:06 No, I just want to make sure we attached a dollar amount on the motion you get by $30,200.

1:16:12 Well, yeah, but we said like we get every year.

1:16:14 I think that was your original motion.

1:16:18 What I mean by last year, I think, good point.

1:16:20 And I sure don't have any problem with what the passing I had and having some contributions come

1:16:26 and do offset the cost, but get your tradition and I can't make the distinction in my mind

1:16:35 with any more clarity of how unique this is. I'm not ready to give up on tradition.

1:16:42 My name is Alan. I will be voting in favor of the motion. We're backing me to a very

1:16:48 good point about that our name is on the ban. It's on the thing. The list, there's the Twin

1:16:54 the fall city ban, the tradition, and I think this is just one of those things that people

1:16:59 expect the city to fund, just like they expect us to fund the police department or they expect

1:17:06 us to fund the airport, and so I will be voting in favor of it.

1:17:11 Jim.

1:17:12 Thank you, Mayor.

1:17:13 Here's my concern.

1:17:15 We have $100,000 allocated for MPOG.

1:17:18 Traditionally, over the last several fiscal years, the city ban has been part of that MPOG

1:17:23 process. So now we're going to, because of this funding issue, we're going to separate the

1:17:29 city band out of the vetting process with these other important groups, like the Crisis Center

1:17:34 and others, and just fund it. I guess my concern is, if we are this solid on the city band,

1:17:43 it's been a tradition since 1905 and so forth, maybe we should adjust the motion to say we're

1:17:49 We're going to pluck the city band out of MPOG forever and ever and ever.

1:17:55 We're going to develop a line item over here in our M&O budget for the city band and we're

1:18:01 going to fund it separately and we're going to reduce our M&O or MPOG to $80 or $79,000.

1:18:10 I would support this motion if some sort of adjustment was made in the motion, but

1:18:15 I'm not going to support it unless we pluck them out of the game, put them over here,

1:18:20 have a vote on whether we create an M&O, line item for that city band, because it's just not fair to the other group to do it any other way.

1:18:31 I have to say that I agree with everything that's been set up here other than plucking them out.

1:18:37 I think that the reason that I made the motion and the reason that I feel very passionate about this is that it's very unfair to an organization.

1:18:46 that has relied on the funds solely,

1:18:51 were sole source funding stream for them.

1:18:54 And then out of the blue, in the middle of their budget year,

1:19:00 we tell them that there's going to be a different process.

1:19:04 Now, if we would have done this six months ago,

1:19:06 I think that would have given them time to go out

1:19:08 and raise funds if it was a different amount

1:19:13 that we would give them.

1:19:14 And I think they would be okay with that.

1:19:16 But to do it at zero hour like this is not fair to them.

1:19:21 And I'm not in support of plucking them out.

1:19:24 I think that they need to go through the process.

1:19:26 I'm just more supportive of, well, if you let me finish,

1:19:31 I'll tell you why, of allowing them to stay in it this year

1:19:36 because we're making this decision at zero hour.

1:19:40 I just think for their sake that that's better

1:19:44 for them to understand that the funding is going to be solid for them.

1:19:49 Because to do otherwise they're going to have to pass hats now to try to fund their operation.

1:19:56 So I agree with Jim if the intent of the council is to perpetually fund the city

1:20:02 band why is it in the municipal powers outsource program because we've

1:20:07 determined it's an in source program.

1:20:09 So put it in the Parks and Rec budget and line item and funded.

1:20:14 You know, one slight correction to Rebecca, they're not volunteers.

1:20:21 The money pays the people to be in the bank.

1:20:24 That's what the money pays for.

1:20:28 We have fireworks every year that I would argue the community expects the city to fund,

1:20:34 which we don't fund completely.

1:20:37 We had an air show last year that we required the committee to come with detailed accounting

1:20:46 of how they weren't going to leave the taxpayers on the hook for a project that brought tens

1:20:53 of thousands of people to town and gave them something to do on a weekend.

1:20:58 And again, I thought the whole intent of having the subcommittee review this process was to

1:21:04 make the process accountable and equitable and to just truthfully, willy-nilly, say they're

1:21:15 are going to get funded, I won't support it.

1:21:18 I don't think that the intent is to let the city band know that they are forever funded

1:21:26 by the city or the city council, but I think that this is the chance where we have to use

1:21:31 our brains and to think outside the box a little.

1:21:34 We by revamping our processes have put them in a situation where they've had no choices

1:21:40 left.

1:21:41 And I think we do need to continue forth with how we are going to change impog and make

1:21:45 it a better in the future.

1:21:47 But the truth is, because we decided to change and not fund things when we normally do, now

1:21:54 we have created a problem for our city band.

1:21:58 And whether we like it or not, it is part of our history, it is a huge part of Twin Falls,

1:22:04 and they do not have time.

1:22:06 Their first concert is scheduled for the first week in June.

1:22:08 They are out of time.

1:22:10 They're at a point where either they need a yes or a no, so they can make decisions.

1:22:16 And I guess we have to let the pieces fall where they do, but we are the ones who have put

1:22:20 them in this situation by changing our scheduling without giving them any foreknowledge of it.

1:22:25 And so it's not like it's a yes forever, year funded type decision tonight.

1:22:30 It's we're changing things.

1:22:32 We need to make them whole and then go on from there.

1:22:35 And then next year, yes, they do need to go through the process like everyone else.

1:22:40 Yeah, let's try to wrap this up. We've got an important city or a public hearing here, but I think we're in agreement that

1:22:48 It's a value in invaluable service, but we're not necessarily happy with

1:22:54 The mPOG funds being used for it again as is an eloquently put

1:23:00 This is the failure of the city council to keep this on the front burner to resolve it to find it however you want to say

1:23:07 Let's not inconvenience one of the landmarks of the recreation for City of

1:23:13 Twin Falls. Let's just approve this $21,200 funding and mentally make a note

1:23:21 this next year to move toward Moby and Park and Rack or wherever but out of the

1:23:27 MPOG. So let's we've all had our chance to stand the soapbox and let's move

1:23:32 forward on this thing. Jim, well you're gonna have to listen to the soapbox. There's

1:23:37 a few more seconds. Is there any possible way that we can get this M-POG thing on the

1:23:43 Monday City Council meeting? You know, we have to maintain the integrity of this process.

1:23:50 I understand what we're doing here. But is there, can we bring this to a conclusion on

1:23:59 Monday?

1:24:00 I think the challenge that you would have and bring it to a conclusion soon, whether it

1:24:05 be Monday or a subsequent immediate council meeting is the fact typically you ask for applications,

1:24:14 you ask for submittals, you ask.

1:24:16 The proper way to do it, yes.

1:24:17 You ask for, you put out an announcement, you have a window of application.

1:24:24 There's a vetting of those applications by the city attorney to make sure that they fall

1:24:29 under the municipal powers outlined by Title 50.

1:24:33 Then we determine which projects are eligible for funding and which projects are not and then those are the ones that

1:24:40 Historically at that point in time I've come and made a presentation

1:24:44 To the City Council and then the City Council goes through their prioritization and award process

1:24:58 I agree with councilman talking and I don't mean to belabor the issue, but I do want to clarify

1:25:03 because in part what Councilmember Berger said is true, the band members are paid, but they

1:25:09 are paid a set amount and it is a very small amount and they work many more hours on their

1:25:14 performances and in performing than they are paid for. So I didn't want to give people

1:25:19 the impression that they are just employees in a sense of the city where they mark their

1:25:24 time card and get as much funding as, but they get as much pay for the hours that they work.

1:25:30 And so, in that sense, that's really why I describe it as a volunteer organization.

1:25:37 Yes, they do get paid and compensated in some way, but certainly not for the hours of service that they provide.

1:25:44 Thank you.

1:25:44 Seeing no more additional lights, we have a roll call vote.

1:25:47 Perfect, Ms. Wieke.

1:25:49 Yes.

1:25:50 Chris Talkington.

1:25:50 Yes.

1:25:51 Sean Beriker.

1:25:52 No.

1:25:54 Don Hall.

1:25:55 Yes.

1:25:56 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:25:57 Yes.

1:25:58 Greg Lanting.

1:25:58 Yes.

1:26:00 Jim Young.

1:26:00 No.

1:26:01 Okay, motion passes five, two.

1:26:04 Don brought up one quick question.

1:26:06 Well, we'll actually we'll cover it afterwards.

1:26:08 We should get on to our public hearing here

1:26:11 and move forward here.

1:26:13 The schedule for six and we're only 26 minutes late.

1:26:19 Request for zoning district change

1:26:22 and zoning map amendment from R2 to NCOPUD

1:26:25 for 4.7, one acres to allow planned mixed use development

1:26:30 consisting of combination of neighborhood

1:26:31 commercial uses including a financial institution facility on property located

1:26:37 northwest corner of Eastland Drive and Addison Avenue East. Tom Rell is

1:26:42 apparently the applicant and LLC Tom and Cheryl Aldrich. This is Scott Allen from

1:26:50 the land group will be represented. Mitch Humble. We're gonna let that go first to make the

1:26:58 the presentation in the state.

1:27:00 All right, David.

1:27:01 Scott Allen, from the land group.

1:27:03 I'm welcome.

1:27:04 Mitch would do the work for me.

1:27:07 You have to be remembered.

1:27:21 Mr. Mayor and Council members, I am Scott Allen.

1:27:24 Tom and Cheryl are alleged to have a prior commitment

1:27:26 in Arizona tonight, so they won't be here,

1:27:28 so I'll be speaking on their behalf.

1:27:31 We've, the property in question for this rezone tonight

1:27:35 is located along out of Southern Eastland.

1:27:37 takes into account these five parcels.

1:27:41 It's currently zoned R2, and it's

1:27:43 surrounded by quite a few uses.

1:27:46 We have a developed subdivision, residential subdivision,

1:27:48 to the north, Jim Ford, Mary Ford, which

1:27:51 is in the audience tonight on the parcel directly west,

1:27:55 which is a pasture.

1:27:56 They also have a professional studio

1:27:58 with residents on that property as well.

1:28:00 To the south, our residential homes, along with homes,

1:28:04 have been converted to businesses that

1:28:08 On the southeast corner, we have a convenience store

1:28:11 and cave marked the large box user.

1:28:13 Then as we move to the east, we have web nursery,

1:28:16 the old Kelly Garden Center, and also the day spawn.

1:28:21 So we have several uses in that area.

1:28:24 The traffic counts for Amazon and Eastland,

1:28:26 where they are gate where materials into the city.

1:28:30 If you look at ITD's numbers,

1:28:31 the city numbers from 2011, that's most current.

1:28:34 There are about 26,000 to 30,000 cars a day go through that intersection.

1:28:40 So the request tonight is to convert this property from an R2 zone to an R2 NCO-PUD zone, which

1:28:48 basically is a neighborhood commercial over there.

1:28:51 The reason for the PUD, that's one of the caveats going through the NCO zone, rezone.

1:28:56 You have to go through a PUD process along with it.

1:28:59 You have to color it.

1:29:12 The property right now has two homes on site.

1:29:16 There's a house in this lot and a house in this lot.

1:29:19 We all remember the old white house that burned,

1:29:22 was removed years ago.

1:29:27 The reason I bring up the existing homes on site,

1:29:30 I just pick our picture here, north is straight up.

1:29:32 So the two homes are about here is one, about here is one.

1:29:37 We have sewer capacity for two structures on the site.

1:29:40 That is what has been put into the sewer model.

1:29:43 And so going forward, that's really all the circumstance we have is two residential unit

1:29:48 capacities at this time.

1:29:51 The rezone is for the entire parcel.

1:29:53 At the present time, there is a sales and purchase agreement on the south property.

1:29:58 That is by item of the central credit union.

1:30:01 And there's a representative here tonight to speak a little bit on their behalf for that.

1:30:06 On the north portion, we get back into the light retail, like commercial area.

1:30:11 And that's kind of a standalone parcel, if you would.

1:30:14 The architectural styles will be similar.

1:30:19 We will have one sign out on the road for these four areas or four units,

1:30:24 and then the actual financial institute on the south would have a sign on Addison

1:30:30 and a sign of their own on Eastland.

1:30:32 We will work with the city in rewriting the PewDie agreement in the section four sign each,

1:30:38 The state right now is we want an off-premise sign,

1:30:41 but the city does allow multi-kenesines.

1:30:44 So what we're trying to negate, not the signs,

1:31:10 this is a development across, this is on Eastland Drive,

1:31:13 North of Addison, directly across from Amazing Grace Church.

1:31:18 This is a beautiful professional office development,

1:31:21 but each lock that backs up to Eastland has been assigned.

1:31:26 And what's occurred over the years,

1:31:27 It's starting to look like blue lakes in that area,

1:31:29 as far as the amount of signage is per lot.

1:31:31 So we want to get away from that look.

1:31:33 We actually just want to do actually in the sign

1:31:44 plan as part of the PUD.

1:31:45 We show one sign in this area, which

1:31:47 is a multi-tena sign, which would

1:31:48 be one mighty sign with placards for the tenets

1:31:52 of these four buildings in that.

1:31:54 The signage for the South Park property, of course,

1:31:57 would be for the Idaho Central Credit Union in this location

1:32:00 and what on the house.

1:32:02 And that's per pose, which you're allowed.

1:32:04 So we're trying to reduce the amount of signage on that as well.

1:32:07 When we develop this plan, one of the big big problems

1:32:11 with this property was there is a floodplain that

1:32:13 runs through this portion of the property.

1:32:16 Therefore, we can't place buildings in that area

1:32:19 and develop in that area.

1:32:20 So that is why we have the two buildings along the North

1:32:23 Property Line and two buildings along the South area.

1:32:28 By doing that, we can work with the flood zone,

1:32:33 parking in there, and actually developed a property in a very efficient manner.

1:32:39 Even though the building loading on the site only takes up 10% of the site or the square

1:32:43 footage of the buildings is only about 10% of the site, we normally shoot for 20% to 25%.

1:32:50 That is totally due to the floodplain running through there.

1:32:53 So the residents around it will enjoy the fact that there's not a great amount of building

1:32:58 on the site.

1:32:59 Prior to having these meetings, we did we did enough a neighborhood meeting at that particular time the credit union was not

1:33:08 entered into a sales and purchase agreement and

1:33:10 We had shown the residents that the drive-through for the bank would be on the east side

1:33:15 The credit union does have specific criteria for drive-throughs

1:33:19 They like locating the drive-throughs on the north side because of the sunshine and the cameras and into screens

1:33:26 If you locate on the east side they have problems with that

1:33:29 So we went ahead prior to entering into a contract with ICCU, and we relocated this drive-thru facility on the north, and then we met with the fourths over here, because now the cars would enter basically east to the west, and there would be some possible impacts from car lines.

1:33:50 We want to meet with the Jason property owners and get their thoughts and feelings on this change, because it was different from the neighborhood of the media.

1:33:58 Jim Ford is in the audience, he can speak on behalf of himself and his wife, but we worked

1:34:04 closely with him in establishing a landscape plan that not only helps mitigate light trespass

1:34:11 by the use of coniferous trees in those areas, but we've also added a 30 foot landscape strip

1:34:17 on the west portion and we've required those trees to be planted at one tree per 400 square

1:34:23 feet and eight foot height that initial planning. Jim and Mary Ford also had a

1:34:28 concern that the south 60 feet be landscaped with low vegetation because

1:34:36 they do have a business next door and their business sign would not be visible

1:34:40 if we created this forest along their property boundary. And so we basically

1:34:45 have met that requirement of the neighbors as well. Presently they have

1:34:50 There is a ditch that runs through here and the forts do not have a bridge across that

1:34:57 ditch so their property is bisected.

1:34:59 So we have made arrangements along the West property boundary to put a temporary gate

1:35:04 in until the time they actually do get a bridge on.

1:35:09 So we work closely with the neighbors on the West.

1:35:11 As we move to the north, we reduced the landscape strip along the north to 20 feet which is

1:35:18 the standard building setback and the reason for that on the west side because of the flood

1:35:24 plane we don't have any buildings in here to provide mitigation for noise and light but

1:35:29 on the north we do we have two buildings and so on the north we have 20 foot of landscaping

1:35:34 roughly 50 feet of building 60 to sidewalks we're over 75 feet from the parking area which

1:35:40 the only noise from these type of developments like commercial and special office is going

1:35:44 from parking areas, car door slamming, car motors, and tire noise.

1:35:50 So we've reduced that amount of landscape along the north, and we've also reduced the

1:35:55 number of trees from 1 to 400 to 1 to 500 square foot down here.

1:35:59 Still 8 foot high planning, 50 percent B, and 50 percent B of the citrus.

1:36:06 In the NCO zone, there are some strict caveats and requirements as far as landscaping.

1:36:12 There is a requirement park in areas that five foot landscape strips between park installs.

1:36:17 So that's what you see in this area.

1:36:18 We've also placed some landscape islands in the center of those.

1:36:23 Also even though Eastland and Addis are gateway arterials, City code requires 30 foot of landscaping.

1:36:30 In the NCO zone, if you have buildings that are over 3,000 square foot size, you have to

1:36:35 have 50 foot wide landscaping on the front.

1:36:38 And that is what is shown here.

1:36:39 these yard areas on this particular property take up over 30% of the site.

1:36:45 20% is the requirement, 30%, it's actually about 37% so the site will be greatly landscaped

1:36:53 as you come in which is really a neat deal because these are two gateway materials into

1:36:58 Twin Falls and I really think that through this through a diligence and this design that

1:37:03 this is really going to be benchmarked for future NCO projects as it comes from.

1:37:08 There was early on when the city of Twin Falls was working on Addison and Eastland.

1:37:14 There was an agreement which I think Don, you probably signed that agreement as mayor.

1:37:19 The Arleigh just did give up additional right away along Addison and Eastland.

1:37:23 In return for that donation the city agreed to install the asphalt widening, the three approaches, and the curb gutters sidewalk.

1:37:34 The approach on the west or on Addison is as far west from the intersection as possible

1:37:39 to make it as safe as possible. We have adjusted this approach

1:37:44 and the approach along Easton a little bit north to get them further away from the intersection

1:37:48 and also get them to line up with the approaches across the road to avoid any traffic conflicts that may exist on that site.

1:37:56 Through the P&Z process, there were a few questions asked by the adjoining property owners

1:38:04 I know this Watkins and Rebecca was there as well.

1:38:10 I was looking for Watkins.

1:38:16 I was looking for Watkins.

1:38:20 I was thinking of Linda.

1:38:25 The concerns that were brought up there, I just want to make everyone on the council aware of those, where there are a lot of matures on the trees on the side.

1:38:32 And we agreed to pass on the word to the developers,

1:38:37 because this site is going to be rezoned and then sold off.

1:38:40 But there will be developers in the future

1:38:41 who have served as become available for the Northern Lots.

1:38:44 That they need to take an inventory of the trees that

1:38:47 are there specifically to see if they are healthy

1:38:50 and see if they're of a type and size that can be readily

1:38:53 and easily moved without a knife.

1:38:55 And so we've agreed to do that as part of the process

1:38:59 as we've moved forward.

1:39:01 Jim and Mary Fort, which have the property to the west,

1:39:04 they receive irrigation water along the north,

1:39:07 and also down through the Arliges property,

1:39:10 where state statute requires us to continue

1:39:13 to live with water to them, and it's gravity

1:39:15 or irrigation water.

1:39:17 And we will work with the ports on development plans

1:39:19 on rerouting those water systems.

1:39:22 Policy and Clara had the same concern

1:39:24 about possibly preserving trees.

1:39:26 And then she also had some concerns about these approaches.

1:39:30 that since they were part of the agreement with the city as far as this one being right

1:39:35 in, right out, and the one on East London, the one on Asenby, the full service approaches

1:39:40 with left hand turn base, we are following the statute from the executed agreement with the

1:39:47 city.

1:39:48 Ken Stewart, which lives about 300 feet west over here, was concerned about lighting.

1:39:55 The E says that he can see the lights from the stinker station which is 600 feet to the east.

1:40:02 What we've done in the PUD agreement was actually required everybody that comes in for a building permit to submit a photometric plan of each lot.

1:40:11 What that does is it's a plan that shows the height of the light, the type of light,

1:40:16 and there's actually a footprint of the foot handles given out of the property.

1:40:20 And by doing that, we can mitigate any light trust pass from security lighting on the side.

1:40:27 The credit unions also stepped up during the P&Z presentation and said that they would work with the neighbors on a schedule

1:40:33 and turn off as many lights as possible while still maintaining the security lighting.

1:40:38 So those are the mitigations that were used there.

1:40:41 The last question was, is the entire parcel going to be developed?

1:40:46 You know the goal in this is to get through the rezone and all the credit union

1:40:53 I'm sure dusty tonight will tell you they're ready and chomping at the bid to get going on this

1:40:57 And so I know that credit union wants to develop immediately and there are sort of pasty

1:41:01 credits for them

1:41:03 The northern portion was what's the reason if the limit is approved will be offered for sale

1:41:08 Until sewer becomes available who knows how long that would be until it is done. So that's kind of the time frame on that

1:41:13 uses on-site. The NCL zone is very, very restrictive on uses. If you're looking for

1:41:20 the PUD agreement, you'll see that we're tailoring it back to about 36 uses total,

1:41:25 something like that. That's special uses and outright community uses. So it's a

1:41:31 very restricted zone. Uses such as dog kittles, tattoo parlors, convenience stores,

1:41:36 etc. have been removed for the well-being of the neighbors to the same part of the future.

1:41:41 So I think we've done a great job and not only the layout, but the diligence with the neighbors and we don't keep them supported tonight.

1:41:51 Since ICCU is wanting to move forward very readily and very fast, we would ask if at all possible that this item we put on the third and final tonight and voted on if possible.

1:42:05 I'm just curious about the drive-thru and the lighting issue.

1:42:12 Is that because it's a 24-hour ATM type of situation?

1:42:17 Because generally, credit unions aren't open in the evenings, right?

1:42:22 The whole concern, even in the neighborhood meetings, was just car lights in general.

1:42:28 It wasn't ours of operations, car lights.

1:42:31 One thing I felt a mention along the perimeter of both the north and the west base

1:42:35 There will be a six foot fence in addition to this on the west is 30 foot landscape strip

1:42:41 These symbols right here denote coniferous trees or pine trees

1:42:45 So there's a full foliage there year-round

1:42:47 And so that's what we've worked with with the neighbors is trying to come up the plan

1:42:52 So where car lights come through

1:42:54 There's pine trees there and a fence there as well as the lighting will be shielded the screen

1:43:00 So that took care of the concerns of the neighbors of the B&C.

1:43:03 It did.

1:43:04 It did.

1:43:05 Okay.

1:43:06 I was just going to ask why the traffic for the drive-through wouldn't go the different

1:43:11 direction to the east.

1:43:13 Because that would mitigate the whole.

1:43:15 Yeah, I just want to drive through 90% of the cars is going to be on the drive-through

1:43:19 against the buildings.

1:43:20 They like that interaction with the human.

1:43:23 Makes sense.

1:43:24 Thank you.

1:43:26 Driver side face the building.

1:43:27 Yeah, makes sense.

1:43:28 Sean Burger.

1:43:29 On the on the access on the on the north and on the

1:43:35 South West corner there

1:43:38 So the the left turns out does that clear the raised median that's in

1:43:44 both Eastland and on

1:43:47 Addison this has been reviewed by Troy B tech city engineering staff

1:43:51 Okay, this is I was looking at the drawings

1:43:55 I was assuming that that was the raised median drawn out of this is not there right now Sean

1:43:59 on, this is where the actual road is only built about this point right here, and this

1:44:06 would be just a painted center, because you don't think the medians basically start right

1:44:11 here and go down, so this is why this is just a right in right out, because up here is not

1:44:16 raised because we have about six different approaches along where the need to turn left.

1:44:21 Thank you.

1:44:22 First argument?

1:44:23 Yeah, just to follow up on that, Sean's question, what is the actual distance of that

1:44:30 Addison and the southern most ingress point there I couldn't find it on these drawings

1:44:41 I might have over walked it survey here

1:44:59 That's the one on Addison Bay almost three building lots wide

1:45:09 It's very hard to read this but it's dusty do you know the way you're being very small

1:45:44 script that it's about the issue here is and what the agreement with the city the

1:45:56 the executed agreement with the city is is there's already three existing approaches.

1:46:01 There's about one here, one here, one here, all three of those go away, and what about

1:46:10 on the east one side?

1:46:13 The only allowed approaches on east loan are those two approaches as soon.

1:46:17 Okay, thank you.

1:46:21 Right, the, the, the central credit view to one to speak, you said it briefly and then

1:46:27 and we'll move on to the staff report.

1:46:33 Dusty Wilson, home Idaho Central Credit Union.

1:46:37 Not a resident, but we have a branch here on 649 pole line.

1:46:41 Apologize for the voice.

1:46:43 Got a little bit of a cold going on.

1:46:46 If you'll indulge me for a minute,

1:46:47 I'll tell you a little bit about Idaho Central.

1:46:50 Idaho Central Credit Union was organized

1:46:52 as a state chartered financial institution in 1940,

1:46:55 and we opened our first branch here in 2000, 1986.

1:47:00 As of this morning, we have 21 branches.

1:47:02 We just opened our 21st branch this morning in Meridian, Idaho.

1:47:06 We have 1.3 billion in assets roughly over 400 team members

1:47:11 around the state and over 134,000 members across Idaho.

1:47:17 Roughly one in 16 Idaho is just a member

1:47:20 of Idaho Central Credit Union.

1:47:22 Idaho Central Credit Union's mission

1:47:24 is helping members achieve financial success.

1:47:26 This is in the hanging slogan on a wall somewhere.

1:47:28 This is something that we live every day.

1:47:30 In fact, every team member reports their supervisor at least twice a month on how they've helped

1:47:36 members achieve financial success to justify the continuance of their employment.

1:47:40 It's a great program.

1:47:43 Through superior products and world-class service, ICCU's goal has been, and we succeed in being

1:47:49 the fastest growing financial institution in Idaho for many years now.

1:47:54 In 2013, Idaho Central Credit Union was voted the number one best place to work in Idaho

1:48:01 among the large employer category.

1:48:03 Idaho's central credit union was recognized as reported

1:48:06 in credit union times, a national publication,

1:48:09 as being the top performing credit union

1:48:11 in the United States in 2012.

1:48:14 There were 410 credit unions in the category,

1:48:18 over 500 million in assets, and a net worth ratio of at least 7%.

1:48:23 So that's number one in the country.

1:48:28 That was determined by SNL financial and nationwide financial analytics firm.

1:48:35 So that's a little bit about ICCU.

1:48:38 Why does ICCU want to invest and increase our investment really in Twin Falls, Idaho?

1:48:45 As of the end of March, I apologize, I don't have updated numbers on this.

1:48:48 We had 11,244 members who frequently use our Twin Falls Pull Line branch.

1:48:53 That's a branch about 2,400 square feet.

1:48:56 That's about half the size of our average branch.

1:49:00 Our local membership here in Twin Falls has been very loyal to us, even driving long distances

1:49:05 to come here to pull line to do business with us.

1:49:07 So we want to give back over the next year, I hope to make a couple more announcements here

1:49:12 and increase our investment in Twin Falls substantially.

1:49:16 So a little bit about what we want to build here.

1:49:18 I apologize.

1:49:19 I didn't bring the same drawing I brought to the planning and zoning meeting, but in your

1:49:24 packet you've seen probably a couple of images of similar branches that we intend to build.

1:49:30 We want to build 5,200 square feet, roughly five tellers, four new account, a combination

1:49:37 new account and loan desks, as well as a manager office and two support offices, a full service

1:49:43 ATM, 24-hour ATM, to address the question earlier, it is a 24-hour ATM, but it's very minor traffic

1:49:50 usually at our ATMs after hours is, you know, half a dozen or a dozen per night even on busy nights.

1:49:57 I think where the biggest issue will probably come is in the winter hours, right at the end of our day,

1:50:02 closing, you know, historic five, six o'clock at night and we'll have a few headlights there. But

1:50:07 really shouldn't be an issue. This isn't a maverick by any means. So building features, our

1:50:13 architect will be working with the city of Twin Falls to make sure that we build in harmony with

1:50:17 the residential area. We'll build a hip-drue for good residential blend, a blend of brick

1:50:23 and stucco, and then we'll we intend to make, extend the hip-drue for our drive-through and

1:50:29 we're happy to implement any lighting controls that we can to be compatible with the neighborhood

1:50:35 development. We do ask that we keep some lighting around the ATM for security, but we can keep

1:50:40 that pretty minimal. We can even stage our lighting. ICCU generally designs in all of my

1:50:47 time with the credit and you know eight years we've never had a building that we

1:50:50 designed that wasn't awarded a financial incentive for energy efficiency we've

1:50:54 done to do LED lighting to a great extent in our buildings so that allows us to

1:50:59 support just a great amount of control so we can do a great deal to help and

1:51:04 protect the the feel of the neighborhood. Anybody have any questions for me?

1:51:10 We're good right now. Thank you. Mitch Humble from the city will use the staff report.

1:51:15 This is why I asked Scott to go first because I knew he'd do such a thorough job on the presentation.

1:51:25 So really I don't want to repeat everything he said.

1:51:28 I don't really have anything to counter with.

1:51:30 I will talk a little bit about process and a couple of points that I wanted to make there.

1:51:36 But really he did a really good job of explaining the project and what it is and what it's going to be.

1:51:41 I'd add that I guess a lot of these things are required by our neighborhoods, our neighborhood

1:51:48 commercial overlay, you know, the pitched and the gabled roofs, the landscaping requirements

1:51:54 that you talked about, the restrictiveness on the uses, there's a maximum building height

1:51:59 of 25 feet.

1:52:00 So a lot of these things we're doing in the code, they're proposing to exceed some of

1:52:06 those, the 50 foot buffer on the street is, that's in the code, all that stuff in there,

1:52:11 they're really laying this out, lots of landscaping, and exceeding in the landscape's requirements.

1:52:20 And then more restrictive in terms of the uses in the signage, the sign plan that they proposed

1:52:26 with the change that we're recommending on the no-off premise signage and rather incorporate

1:52:32 what the sign code calls a multi-tenant sign.

1:52:36 We had a picture of one of those in the packet and that's generally what they're after, rather

1:52:42 than seeing four different signs along the street frontage have one with multiple names

1:52:48 on it.

1:52:49 Again, more stringent than the code allows but makes a little bit nicer development.

1:52:56 So this is a PUD request, any NCO request we have has to be a PUD, that's never going

1:53:01 to this process.

1:53:04 There was a hearing of the Planning and Zoning Commission on April 23rd, and at that meeting,

1:53:11 the recommendation from the Commission is to unanimously approve the request with a couple

1:53:16 of conditions.

1:53:17 We'll get to those.

1:53:18 Let's see here.

1:53:30 There was a comment, Scott made a comment about the third and final reading.

1:53:36 With the rezone, you guys know that we follow up the rezone usually with an ordinance.

1:53:40 changes the base zoning on the property and that isn't, we don't usually bring that tonight.

1:53:47 So we have a hearing, we get the input, we get the approval and usually we come back at

1:53:50 another meeting usually in a week or two and we adopt the ordinance and so you don't have

1:53:54 an ordinance in your packet to approve tonight.

1:53:58 But when we do bring that back as often as the case will, we'll talk about putting it on

1:54:03 third and final reading form at that point.

1:54:05 During the ordinance adoption, we come back at some point in the future with a PUD agreement

1:54:11 that you'll also look at.

1:54:12 We're preparing the final version of that as well with a lot of these conditions that

1:54:16 we're talking about here that will come back again in the future, meaning in its final draft

1:54:22 form and it will include the list of uses and the sign plan will be appropriate and all

1:54:29 the attachments will be part of that as well.

1:54:31 So, tonight we're looking at the presentation they made,

1:54:37 the discussion of all these additional things

1:54:39 with further limiting the list of uses.

1:54:44 I'll say that the NCO is appropriate for the property

1:54:47 at conformers with the master development plan

1:54:48 or the future land use plan.

1:54:52 And I really just don't have a lot to say.

1:54:56 They were very thorough in their presentation.

1:54:58 We'll try to answer the questions that we have.

1:55:01 We do need to open a public hearing.

1:55:04 I did get one letter submitted to me by email

1:55:07 from someone who wanted to be here, but couldn't come tonight.

1:55:10 And I'll just kind of throw that up here on the overhead

1:55:15 as we go through the process.

1:55:18 But really, I just turned it over to Council for questions

1:55:20 if you have any.

1:55:21 And then we do need to, like, sit open the public hearing

1:55:23 at some point.

1:55:23 I have a couple of lights, Chris Dichman.

1:55:26 Mitch, under the allowed uses in the NCO zone,

1:55:29 I'm referring to the, in our agenda pack at the page,

1:55:34 followed with the tenant name,

1:55:36 monument song you have here,

1:55:38 allowed uses under retail trade include heating places,

1:55:43 so it'd be 1D, follow that.

1:55:46 All right, now, following to the next page

1:55:52 of miscellaneous, any facility with drive-through services,

1:55:57 that's number three.

1:55:58 So combining an eating establishment with drive-thru services we would say that a fast food operation would be allowed in an NCO.

1:56:08 With, I think, with the special use permit, the drive-thru lane for a restaurant or actually the request tonight shows the master development plan with the bank and the drive-thru lane.

1:56:26 the request would be to approve that specific use as it's being shown so that the bank doesn't

1:56:31 have to come back and get an SUP later.

1:56:33 I understand that.

1:56:34 Right.

1:56:35 So if on the lot to the north with those four buildings, if one of those would like to develop

1:56:39 with the drive-through, they would have to come back through to get a special use permit

1:56:42 to get a drive-through.

1:56:44 So that's on the second page.

1:56:45 Those are all uses that require an SUP to move forward with.

1:56:50 So you could have, if approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission, you could have a drive-through

1:56:55 restaurant. If you have a drive-through restaurant, you have obviously extended hours, and that

1:56:59 means night lighting, good. All right. Thank you.

1:57:05 Rebecca, I'll see you.

1:57:07 Thank you, Mayor. My question is about the Arledge agreement that was referenced by the

1:57:15 applicant. That wasn't included in our packet. Do we have a copy of that? Can you explain

1:57:21 what that agreement is, what it states, and how it affects this development.

1:57:27 There was a right of way, I don't have a copy of it with me tonight either, there was a right

1:57:31 of way dedication agreement from a couple of years ago.

1:57:38 Let's see if we have one.

1:57:41 Basically the city had a desire to construct Eastland and reconstruct the intersection and

1:57:49 And we approached the property owners at that point with a request to do this that would

1:57:56 require right of identification from the property owner, property owner work with us on the dedication

1:58:01 and in exchange for dedicating the right of way and allowing us to go ahead and build

1:58:06 that property, build the road on their property.

1:58:09 There was some concessions given to them with regards to approaches and where they might

1:58:13 be located at.

1:58:14 And that's basically the nuts and bolts of that agreement.

1:58:19 They also reduced the number of driveways that were already on the property, which was

1:58:25 a big plus for us as well.

1:58:26 They had, for example, three in the short distance on Addison, three driveways that were

1:58:30 existing and I think were neck and neck and neck and neck and down to just the one.

1:58:34 And then there was two or three up up Eastland that's being kept at two.

1:58:40 So anyway, that's, like I said, the gist of the agreement, it looks like it was done

1:58:45 in November of 2011, so about 18 months ago.

1:58:49 Okay, and so has the city completed their financial commitment to this project as far as curb gutter and so I don't

1:58:56 Go to work on a lot of it, but not

1:59:00 As Scott mentioned, there was a point on the property

1:59:04 So the map here

1:59:07 We've completed our Eastland construction probably

1:59:11 You know right about in here, and so we have more work to do on Eastland to the north of that

1:59:17 that. That will come with the next phase of Eastland construction that we are going

1:59:24 to do out there. We separated out the intersection job from north of there. So that is the future

1:59:32 to be built but we are working on it.

1:59:36 Great.

1:59:37 And just to follow up on that answer we have been instructed by city staff to let them

1:59:42 know what the construction schedule is ASAP on the portion of Madison Avenue because right

1:59:49 now there are two homes here and there are existing approaches there serving those homes.

1:59:54 So we will work closely with city staff on those homes or tour down for the construction

1:59:59 of ICCU so they can budget for this approach construction in the south of us.

2:00:05 Thank you.

2:00:06 Okay, great. Yeah, I just wanted to clarify because I noticed that in the staff report,

2:00:14 there's a photo, I don't know what page it's on, but this approach will be moved further

2:00:19 north as shown on master development map, but it's a photo of Eastland and I believe it's

2:00:28 the area that was just constructed last year and so I just want to make sure that the city

2:00:33 wouldn't be redoing any of the work that they had just performed. Okay, great. Thank you.

2:00:42 I just want to clarify for the citizens that they had already paid for that construction.

2:00:47 They wouldn't be doing that once again. Yes, that's the correct photo.

2:00:51 All right. Seeing no additional lights, questions I will now open the public hearing for public

2:00:59 testimony if you are you checking the list force Travis the yeah we will give a

2:01:14 lot of two minutes and I don't see a big crowd if you Mr. Ford if you want to speak

2:01:18 on three you'll go to three minutes I'm ready for thirty-seven and Mr.

2:01:25 Councilman Hall will vice-mart Hall will give him a

2:01:29 There's 30 seconds left, so Jim Ford Jim Ford 2133 Addison Avenue East as

2:01:38 mirror landing would attest normally I'd come up here and tell each of you not to

2:01:42 trust anything that Scott Allen said however he's done an outstanding job on

2:01:49 putting this together and I would tell you that Mary and I fully support this we

2:01:54 welcome my CCU to the community our community and I was just wondering how

2:02:00 they felt about municipal bands.

2:02:03 And in the interest of brevity that's all I have.

2:02:09 Thank you.

2:02:10 All right.

2:02:11 Thank you, Mr. Fort.

2:02:12 Scott's already spoken and I believe Mr.

2:02:17 Wooster can't read it here.

2:02:19 He's already spoken as well.

2:02:20 So as someone else, as someone else in the audience that is, did not sign up but would like to speak on this issue.

2:02:27 Seeing no one will close the public comment portion of the hearing.

2:02:31 Bring it back to the council for their consideration.

2:02:36 Don Halslite was on first.

2:02:37 Thank you, Chris.

2:02:38 I just want to say, Jim, when I held up to 30 seconds,

2:02:41 that was your not the amount of time that you had.

2:02:45 Because you did it right at 30 seconds.

2:02:47 Good job.

2:02:48 I just want to say that I know that this intersection is

2:02:51 an appealing intersection for businesses.

2:02:55 It just makes sense.

2:02:56 And I know that we kind of gone round around with other businesses in the past.

2:03:00 And one of our major concerns, what I heard from the council and for myself, is that we

2:03:04 wanted to have something that would blend well with the neighborhood and take that in consideration

2:03:12 because a lot of folks live along there and that's their livelihoods and or their homes.

2:03:17 So sure seems like this is a good fit for the neighborhood and really, Mr. Fort, your endorsement

2:03:26 of it means a lot to my decision.

2:03:28 Okay, if we're going to get into this sketch, we're kind of still in the question part, I'm

2:03:32 sorry.

2:03:33 Do I need to close the public hearing before we move on?

2:03:37 I'm getting here, sir, sorry.

2:03:41 We have closed the public.

2:03:43 We have a public hearing, but we were kind of still in the question mode at this point.

2:03:48 I'm ready to make a motion.

2:03:49 I'll back off.

2:03:51 Let's move it back to the council then for consideration of motion and then we'll go into

2:03:57 discussion.

2:03:58 I would move to approve the request of the applicants' Tom or OLC for zoning district

2:04:03 change and zoning map amendment from R2 to NCOPUD for 4.71 acres to allow the plan use

2:04:11 This mixed development on property located north west corner of east and drive north

2:04:18 and at the avenue east.

2:04:20 Second.

2:04:22 Then moved by Chris taking in seconded by Don Hall.

2:04:27 Now the lights will be on for a second.

2:04:31 Thank you Mayor.

2:04:32 Just a comment on the process.

2:04:35 I thought that it was a very successful hearing at the planning and zoning level.

2:04:40 I always tell Mr. Fort that his neighbors are among the most informed and active neighbors

2:04:45 in the city.

2:04:46 They're actually a great example for all of us.

2:04:48 We've had about a dozen or more show up for the planning and zoning.

2:04:53 The applicant has done a great job of working with their neighbors and being a considerate

2:04:58 and thoughtful neighbor.

2:05:00 So I don't have any concerns about this particular development.

2:05:04 just a comment on the process.

2:05:07 Just this is the first PUD rezone that I've seen

2:05:10 that we haven't gotten a proposed development agreement,

2:05:18 a PUD agreement with it.

2:05:19 And so I know that comes later,

2:05:23 but usually we get something in writing

2:05:25 to kind of give us something tangible to say,

2:05:30 you know, you are proving this planned unit development.

2:05:33 And so it is a bit difficult for me to approve a rezoning

2:05:38 to a PUD that technically we haven't seen.

2:05:40 And I talked to the staff and it doesn't exist yet

2:05:44 since I guess in the process.

2:05:46 It comes later, but just wanted to comment

2:05:48 that as a council person, for me it is difficult

2:05:51 to rezone land into perpetuity to a PUD that doesn't yet exist.

2:05:58 Just there's nothing tangible there.

2:06:00 And so nothing that would be in writing

2:06:02 that we could hold future owners of the land too.

2:06:06 So when you.

2:06:06 We should take a speech right now, but I think.

2:06:09 And I understand.

2:06:10 And so this is just a comment on our process, actually,

2:06:14 on the city's staff side, our process.

2:06:16 It would be, I think, more helpful for the community

2:06:20 and those who come to the public hearing

2:06:23 just so that what's presented is what is built

2:06:26 and that a situation doesn't arise

2:06:29 where, you know, what's presented is not what is developed.

2:06:34 And so it would be helpful for me anyway

2:06:36 to see that PUD or at least a proposed PUD

2:06:41 so that we know what we're approving the new zone as.

2:06:45 But based on the presentation,

2:06:46 based on the diagrams, it appears to be

2:06:51 a wonderful improvement to the land.

2:06:55 Jim, you turned light back up,

2:06:56 but I still have a gym list, right?

2:06:59 The only comment I would make on that particular one, Rebecca, would be the fact that even though we do see it sometimes, see the PUD with it, PUDs can be changed by future counsels.

2:07:10 So even though you voted in on that particular PUD, it could actually be changed in the future by Council vote.

2:07:17 So, remember that one.

2:07:21 So you know other lights?

2:07:23 The other roll call vote.

2:07:25 Chris Talkington.

2:07:26 Yes.

2:07:27 Sean Berger.

2:07:28 Yes.

2:07:29 Don Hall.

2:07:30 Yes.

2:07:31 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:07:32 Yes.

2:07:33 Greg Lanting.

2:07:34 Yes.

2:07:35 Jim Mann.

2:07:36 Yes.

2:07:37 Rebecca Milsica.

2:07:38 Yes.

2:07:39 Motion passes 7-0.

2:07:40 Hopefully they can get it back to us next week for the ordinance.

2:07:43 Look forward to a quality development there.

2:07:45 I've asked her to do it well for the previous language.

2:07:48 Absolutely.

2:07:49 The only thing left we have on the agenda is for the German into an executive session

2:07:55 67-235.

2:07:57 Before we ask for a motion on that, uh, western days are we still planning as a council to

2:08:06 participate in the parade like we did we have in the past.

2:08:09 We have the fire trick third, do we have a hand counter, how many we have and see whether

2:08:13 we need to get alternate transportation as well.

2:08:17 I'm in.

2:08:18 I don't know.

2:08:19 All right.

2:08:20 I will plan on being here.

2:08:24 I don't know just yet.

2:08:25 It's the third, right?

2:08:26 It's the second.

2:08:27 What is it?

2:08:28 First.

2:08:29 First.

2:08:30 First.

2:08:31 Can I?

2:08:32 Chris, are you planning on participating in the parade for western days?

2:08:36 What day is that again?

2:08:37 First.

2:08:38 First.

2:08:39 Well, you were having the experts.

2:08:40 Hey, we covered that already.

2:08:41 I'm sorry.

2:08:42 We were talking important land use issues.

2:08:45 Probably not.

2:08:46 of my German exchange student daughter coming

2:08:48 and are gonna be in and out of the hole.

2:08:51 Thank you.

2:08:52 Rebecca?

2:08:53 No, I'm actually gonna participate

2:08:54 in the National Guard Boss Appreciation Day

2:08:56 and that's being held the same day from 7 a.m. to 2 a.m.

2:09:00 All right, well it sounds like the fire truck,

2:09:01 if you would have a fire truck available in the island.

2:09:05 Fire truck, I think it should have enough room

2:09:07 for us to all be in the bucket of that, it appears.

2:09:10 Okay, now moving on to exactly section 67,

2:09:13 2, 3, 4, 5, 1, c to to conduct liberation

2:09:16 during labor negotiations, or to acquire an interest

2:09:19 in real property, which is not owned by a public agency.

2:09:24 I would entertain a motion to that effect.

2:09:26 So moved.

2:09:27 Can move by Jim Mon and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins

2:09:31 for the exact session.

2:09:32 The other roll call vote.

2:09:34 See Sean Berger.

2:09:36 Yes.

2:09:37 Don Hall.

2:09:37 Yes.

2:09:38 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:09:38 Yes.

2:09:39 Greg Lanting.

2:09:40 Yes.

2:09:40 Jim Mon.

2:09:41 Yes.

2:09:41 Yes, yes.

2:09:42 Yes.

2:09:43 Yes.

2:09:44 Motion passes over to zero, but we will not be coming back out into session and making

2:09:48 decisions normally we make any that would require public vote in the executive session.

2:09:56 Nobody's listening.

2:09:58 They're already gone.

2:10:01 We're adjourned.

2:10:04 So, executive session.

2:10:07 Sometimes we just lose control, and then we don't.

2:10:12 Especially me.

2:10:14 Especially me.

2:10:16 Sorry for spacing out.

2:10:21 Look out, here's all your stuff up on the counter here.

2:10:24 Did you have anything for me to sign?

2:10:26 Okay.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, May 13, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:10:31.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    536db965bd666bb4d2d0e2675f229d0f934473a31c93ed862a53db22ea4e46dc
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 6d57bb3caf8a2adb586a5eda0b9527e02f0bb795ed81789c40fb3fef108e2805
    part02.m4a b5ff2bab6a55e1711d8cde8a8c66a3100976ba7b419cf1231e9f195066d17183
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    aa0639b85d859061baebf32106afa152eeceaa054a542935c6b2e95805ae08af

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file