OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 29, 2013

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:31 Finish the term on the either side.

0:00:35 Yeah, I know that at one point.

0:00:37 At one point, that's true.

0:00:39 Got them on the corners.

0:00:41 Keep them close enough in a partner.

0:00:43 Watch it.

0:00:44 Who are you going to have to have it?

0:00:47 Apparently.

0:00:52 You didn't ask many amendments, constitutional questions.

0:00:57 No, no.

0:00:58 That's talking to the country.

0:01:01 the

0:04:36 Call the order of the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday April 29th 2013 as always our first order of

0:04:51 Business as a pledge we have a couple scouts that have agreed to come up and leave us in the pledge if you guys come up

0:04:56 to the front, get us started.

0:04:58 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:05:21 All right, because go to the mic one at a time and tell us your name and who your troop is, where you meet, and why you're here.

0:05:30 I'm Kendall Rast, we're both from Troop 68, we need at Emmanuel Lutheran Church.

0:05:38 I'm here because I have to talk to one of the city council members about a issue that concerns the citizens.

0:05:48 So that's why I'm here.

0:05:51 Great lining.

0:05:52 My name is Hayden Bowman-Bowai.

0:05:55 I'm here working on my communications merit badge,

0:05:58 and I need to listen to a topic present today,

0:06:02 right down the point of view.

0:06:04 All right, thank you.

0:06:05 Thank you, gentlemen.

0:06:08 And we know the next item, which is a conference

0:06:11 we have with quorum, all seven members are present.

0:06:14 Introduction of staff, City Manager Travis Wasp-Wattler

0:06:18 is here, City and Trinity-Fritsch-Wanderlich,

0:06:20 Debbie Sirte, Deputy City Clerk,

0:06:22 the recording secretary via the Sanchez, and we have several others in the audience.

0:06:28 I think you should introduce everyone else.

0:06:30 I think I'll wait on that one two at a time.

0:06:34 Tell me I have the rights, all the names now, so don't mess it up.

0:06:40 Mr. Rothbard, we have the amendments to the agenda, okay.

0:06:44 Proclations are in none.

0:06:45 The first item for a business is consent calendar.

0:06:49 Councilor Wiggers?

0:06:51 Move, move.

0:06:52 Second.

0:06:53 and moved by Jim Mann and seconded by Don Hall

0:06:57 to move by Jim Mann and seconded by Don Hall

0:07:02 to approve the consent calendar as printed.

0:07:05 Seeing no lights, the other roll call vote.

0:07:07 Don Hall?

0:07:08 Yes.

0:07:09 Suzanne Hotkins?

0:07:10 Yes.

0:07:11 Greg Lansing?

0:07:12 Yes.

0:07:13 Jim Mann?

0:07:14 Yes.

0:07:15 Rebecca Milsoyka?

0:07:16 Yes.

0:07:16 Chris Tockington?

0:07:17 Yes.

0:07:18 Sean Berriger?

0:07:19 Yes.

0:07:21 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:07:22 Moving on to items for consideration.

0:07:25 discussion on solid waste or was it solid waste you were going to speak about?

0:07:30 That's correct.

0:07:31 All right.

0:07:32 That's the floor.

0:07:33 Thank you, Mayor.

0:07:35 I've been trying to figure the best way to present this to the council for some weeks now.

0:07:41 A solid waste district is quite a complex subject since it's composed of not only the overstructure

0:07:50 administration, if you will, but the participant counties, seven counties, each with their own

0:07:57 area of jurisdiction, costs, and it's probably most akin to the old Sercon, which Chief Munn

0:08:07 is intimately aware of, the difficulties going back to how the Idaho Constitution lays out

0:08:17 division between counties and the cities, the counties are the taxing authorities.

0:08:23 Cities are actually just vehicles of convenience almost and have very few rights vis-a-vis the

0:08:32 counties.

0:08:34 As such, when you have a multi-county jurisdiction, as Sercom was of multi-county, I think it was

0:08:40 five counties, less than four counties, and seven counties in the solid waste

0:08:46 district, it's not unusual because each of the counties has an even voting measure for

0:08:53 the smaller counties to have a disproportionate influence on policies, ultimately dollars,

0:09:03 and the day-to-day operations.

0:09:05 This is not good or bad, it's just a fact of how the multi-county jurisdictions work

0:09:11 in the state of Idaho.

0:09:14 The information I'm going to provide to you deals primarily, almost entirely with the personnel

0:09:20 side of the solid waste district and the participating counties.

0:09:25 I'm doing that because not because as suggested the council has a very short attention span,

0:09:31 but I don't want to bore you and keep you here till midnight and get lost of several

0:09:36 questions I'm hoping to raise as part of a general information but education and discussion

0:09:43 that we might have to see is the district running the way we think it should, if there

0:09:49 are changes, how we might affect those or how we might gain a little bit more voice in a

0:09:56 multi-million dollar operation of primary importance, not only because it takes the trash away from

0:10:03 our front yards, but it's a matter of the sentimentally controlled and directed by the EPA and DEQ.

0:10:12 So it is a vital service just like wastewater and water delivery is.

0:10:18 I'm going to hand out, and by the way, I've spoken with the city manager.

0:10:24 He has the very same information that I'm distributing to the council.

0:10:28 I think I have one extra one.

0:10:30 Well, if anybody needs one, it doesn't have one.

0:10:36 First I started off with one more.

0:10:40 off with a, there are two sets of documents

0:10:45 stapled together separately and the one in the back

0:10:47 is more or less supportive to the ones in the front.

0:10:50 Excuse me, could we put that?

0:10:51 Oh.

0:10:52 So the audience can see as well.

0:10:56 And I'm open to any questions any time.

0:10:59 And I've also asked Lori and the city manager

0:11:02 to interject or answer her questions

0:11:05 if in fact there are any.

0:11:07 I may be the only one that has curiosity about the issue.

0:11:10 As a little bit of background concerning Twin Falls City, here at Bernona's TFC, Solid Waste District, SWD, and our primary contractor for removing the waste PSI.

0:11:23 A little bit of background. As we're well aware from the data we get from Laurier City Manager, in the city over three and a quarter years through our recycling program, we reduced our contribution to the landfill by 4888 tons.

0:11:39 88 tons. That's just a little bit under 10 million pounds of solid waste that is being

0:11:47 picked up and dumped in a hole and covered up. And this covers the period from 2010,

0:11:53 11, 12, and the first three months of 2013. The solid waste district is tax-supported and

0:12:01 is mentioned by the seven Magic Valley counties that make up the Magic Valley, 185,000 residents.

0:12:07 last year, we sent about 171,000 tons to the landfills, we're a very insignificant part,

0:12:19 only about one point, a little bit under one point two of the total amount.

0:12:25 Twin Falls City provides, however, almost one out of four tons, 24% of the sun age.

0:12:32 And if you look at it from Twin Falls County, we represent 60% of the total landfill.

0:12:38 There's no way you can downplay the city's participation as anything except the major contributor.

0:12:46 Within the presentation we had a couple months ago from the Solid Waste District Director,

0:12:52 he mentioned four principles guiding the Solid Waste District.

0:12:56 the fourth principle was one relating to opportunities to reuse, reduce, and recycle.

0:13:05 I think I raised the point at that question the county commission was here that what evidence

0:13:10 is this reflected in the Twin Falls tax that we are charged should not be raised, there should

0:13:16 be taxes over the three and a quarter years of our decreasing tonnage coming from our homes.

0:13:24 Or if it's not going to be reflected through reduction in taxes attributed to the solid waste

0:13:33 district, how or when should it ever to put some teeth into their fourth principle. Otherwise,

0:13:41 as an old recycling list, I look at it as just an empty verbiage that has no meaning. I did

0:13:48 speak with the new manager of PSI, Kevin Malone, about the same day as the city manager spoke

0:13:55 to him coincidentally. He was mentioning a couple of interesting facts that he's come from,

0:14:01 I think, Vancouver is his last base of operations. He's pretty familiar with solid waste around

0:14:08 the country, and up to 60% of solid waste has been what we call paper in a co-mingled stream.

0:14:16 But this has, and it's been largely because of newspapers, but with the decrease in people

0:14:22 taking an active newspaper subscription or at least a hard copy, there's been a real

0:14:27 change in that co-mingled waste, and that 60% for paper is decreasing to some amount less,

0:14:35 I'm not sure.

0:14:37 He did, however, mention something that we're all very aware of.

0:14:41 the so-called green waste that for six or seven months every year, many homes do not

0:14:48 lead the grass clippings on the yard, but put them in either the big blues or in bags

0:14:55 to be picked up.

0:14:57 And we have, I think, the term is unlimited pickup or non-chargeable.

0:15:03 You can put as many out as you want, and there are some homes that routinely put out two,

0:15:08 I've seen as many as 12 and 15 in a couple of homes.

0:15:13 And so those are people really that I think are doing a disservice to their lawns, first

0:15:20 of all, and second are writing on the rate that PSI charges us, which is set yearly,

0:15:29 and it's a rate that they give us times the number of households.

0:15:34 My first question coming from this background of the council, we see from the figures, you

0:15:40 see, if you go to that second part of the package I've given you, I've circled in the

0:15:45 upper right hand corner showing the amount of tonnage that we have reduced.

0:15:52 There's no reason to expect those tonnages, even that they are decreasing over what we

0:15:59 want, instead of increasing, they are still contributing fewer tons and pounds to the landfill

0:16:06 every month.

0:16:08 What can and should we do to see about impacting the taxation, the rate, or other solutions that

0:16:17 we might have in an effective recycling program?

0:16:23 Travis and I talked a little bit about why our tonnages are decreasing, and I think you'll

0:16:29 be happy to answer any questions about that, but I think we're really saying that it may

0:16:33 be a combination of several factors for that fair assumption. I'd like to move now to the

0:16:40 second part of my little factoid sheet is comparing the solid waste district and the seven

0:16:45 counties personnel costs for this year. You see two columns before you, that's the lower

0:16:52 half of that part of that page on the screen. The full-time equivalents for the solid waste

0:16:57 district in the seven counties, that's up to the point where they transfer, or no longer

0:17:05 have jurisdiction over the solid waste where it goes through the transfer stations. Actually,

0:17:10 you're pretty close. There's around 27 and 28 full-time equivalents in those two jurisdictions.

0:17:16 One composes seven separate counties and one solid waste district. The personnel budgets

0:17:22 though start blipping out significantly with the solid waste district last year or this year

0:17:29 that we're in of a million six hundred nineteen thousand versus a million four hundred seventy

0:17:34 one thousand. I've gone through the breakdown and you're welcome to see this but I didn't

0:17:41 want to kill more trees needlessly and I have the information here in each of the counties

0:17:47 and the solid waste district there are people identifiable as the management. In other words

0:17:52 in Lincoln County is reasonable that they would have a manager or somebody responsible

0:17:56 for the number of employees they have.

0:17:59 And in the solid waste district, those personnel budgets for management are over $583,000 compared

0:18:08 to the seven counties of $421,000.

0:18:12 If you take the management as a percentage of the personnel budgets in the seven counties,

0:18:18 It's a little bit over 28, well, 28.6%, but in the solid waste district, it blends to 36%.

0:18:28 That's curious because in this current year that we are in, the seven counties separately

0:18:34 have decreased their personnel budgets by almost 6%, while the personnel budgets have

0:18:40 increased by almost 4%, 3.95%.

0:18:46 I've chosen to identify two positions within the Solid Waste District that I think will

0:18:53 make sense when I get to the summary part here in a couple minutes.

0:18:58 The Solid Waste District Director who spoke to us, his total compensation in this year is over $100,000.

0:19:07 And the Chief Financial Officer designated as such,

0:19:12 even though I have reports that she's been a secretary for around 15 years.

0:19:17 She's now labeled as a CFO, earns well over $103,000.

0:19:25 I think this is an area of concern for the council, and hopefully it should be for the seven counties.

0:19:32 Because I've asked the city manager how does that compare to our compensation packages for our two most important public safety people,

0:19:41 people, the police chief and the fire chief, we don't have to go over those dollar amounts

0:19:45 now.

0:19:46 I see our fire chief sweating bullets back here and we're not going to discuss your salary.

0:19:51 The point is I think in public safety positions you're not unused to seeing salaries this high

0:19:57 but for a solid waste district, I consider those to be pretty excessive for public service

0:20:05 type of employment.

0:20:07 The back page is a summary page, and it relates to the second page, the second part, where

0:20:14 you will see an audit from the CPA firm does the audit, did the audit for 2012 for the

0:20:26 Southern Idaho Solid Waste District.

0:20:29 You'll also identify with me next to the last paragraph that I've highlighted, where the

0:20:36 The audit indicates, quoting now, we did identify a certain deficiency in internal control

0:20:43 that we consider to be a significant deficiency and also to be a material weakness.

0:20:50 The district does not have the skills and competencies necessary to prepare their financial

0:20:54 statement in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles or to prevent, detect,

0:21:01 correct material misstatements in the financial statement prepared for them.

0:21:10 Thank God I'm not a CPA because I probably be used to this type of verbiage, but when

0:21:14 I see a statement of that nature in a public audit, it raises flags in my mind.

0:21:22 I also have had contact with sources associated with the solid waste district, and they indicate

0:21:29 that there may be lack of internal controls that relate to the time private entities, not

0:21:40 like a PSI, but private entities may be delivering trash to transfer stations and may or may not

0:21:48 involved proper checks and balances, that is with receipts, registers, numbers, sequential

0:21:59 numbers. I'm not making a chart so much as raising this as a question that if we have

0:22:06 an organization with this highest structure of the top personnel, including the chief financial

0:22:13 officer. I wonder why we would get an audit deficiency statement of this nature and I'm

0:22:20 personally curious what kind of internal controls are missing in the organization.

0:22:28 With that, if you have questions, I'd answer them the best of my ability. This is meant

0:22:32 to be informational. And I personally, as a city council person, representing 25% of

0:22:40 of all the trash goes to the district,

0:22:41 I think we have a legitimate need to know more

0:22:43 and have some questions answered.

0:22:45 Jim.

0:22:46 Thank you, Mayor.

0:22:47 Thank you, Chris, for the very informative report.

0:22:50 And quite honestly, that correspondence that

0:22:54 was written by Gerald Price and Associates is shocking.

0:23:01 I just wanted to say that several months ago,

0:23:03 when the solid waste director spoke to us,

0:23:06 and I was maybe I came on a little strong with a guy.

0:23:09 but I was very, very concerned about some of the answers

0:23:11 that I heard in regards to our recycling

0:23:14 and what we're decreasing that

0:23:16 and why are we still seeing increases?

0:23:19 With this letter, that's also very, very concerning.

0:23:23 And also, there was an answer I believe given

0:23:25 about operational costs increasing up to, was it $60,000?

0:23:34 That was a number I thought I heard.

0:23:37 But operational costs were increasing.

0:23:39 This may have been the commissioner speaking due to just an operational cost increasing.

0:23:48 I wasn't really happy about or I didn't have a very good understanding of what that increase

0:23:54 in operational costs pertain to.

0:23:56 So I'm very disturbed by this and I commend you for putting this together for us because

0:24:02 I think it really lays it out in layman's terms about concerns that we have as citizens.

0:24:11 Thank you.

0:24:13 The question I would have on anybody who can answer it.

0:24:20 The one on the director in the CFO, do they have fiduciary or oversea responsibilities

0:24:28 over the seven counties collection?

0:24:33 You know, the sites, do we know that?

0:24:35 Or it shows that they're, you know, that's what I'm saying.

0:24:40 Their costs are more, but I'm trying to explore reasons that it may be, are they over the management?

0:24:45 In other words, the counties have a mid-management and they're the management over the whole thing

0:24:49 or do the counties handle their own up to the point they turn it over to the transfer stations?

0:24:55 I guess that's the question I would have. Do we know that Travis?

0:25:00 I am not familiar with how the Solid Waste District is structured or organized.

0:25:07 I'm not short of knowing that Josh is the director of the facility

0:25:15 And that the board is composed of a representative from each of the county who serves on there.

0:25:22 The city has not had a relationship to be involved in the board making or the decision making processes.

0:25:30 So I'm not familiar with their structure or what that looks like.

0:25:34 we have Suzanne serves on the on the board as an ad hoc or whatever the term

0:25:41 might be just representing this you don't have a vote or we have no say so no say

0:25:46 so we're just there to help keep us informed yeah and the second part let me

0:25:51 face one and then I'll turn it back over to you I guess Jim and then Chris

0:25:55 both said that paragraph I would certainly like that explained a little

0:25:59 closer and I might call on Lori to do so if she is has any thoughts being our

0:26:04 our CFO about what that might mean there and that's number one and number two I

0:26:10 remember the this discussion with Commissioner Yuri slightly different than

0:26:14 maybe you did Jim in that they had not the reason the way it had the increases

0:26:20 they were proposing to us anyway that they had their creases they had not been

0:26:23 charging enough in the past in other words that fund had been being supported

0:26:28 with tax funds and they were just catching it up so that the who used the system paid for

0:26:36 the system and the general tax payers didn't pay which is kind of interesting since all the

0:26:40 other counties do it on their general taxes they don't do it on the way we do it here.

0:26:44 That makes it and I agree with you that that makes it even more concerning when they say

0:26:48 that and I quote the district does not have the skills or competencies necessary to prepare

0:26:52 their financial statements and accordance with general accepted county principal.

0:26:55 This would have been the individual counties was not keeping up with their collection earlier transfer stations.

0:27:02 Laura, could you comment briefly on that?

0:27:05 And I just want to make one more statement before staff recedes.

0:27:08 So everybody understands in the community, 24% of the solid waste tonnage is manifested through the city of Twin Falls.

0:27:18 But we have no vote in regards to the planning, organizing, leading, or correcting of the solid waste district.

0:27:24 That's a fact, correct?

0:27:25 Are setting the formula, sir?

0:27:27 No, but it's Sercom.

0:27:29 We did negotiate, finally, a voting position

0:27:34 on the Sercom board because of the extraordinary amount

0:27:38 of work the city of Twin Falls generated

0:27:41 and participated as part of that.

0:27:44 We did get a voice on the board.

0:27:46 And I was to have a vote.

0:27:47 Yes, indeed you were.

0:27:50 Travis.

0:27:53 This is where the city manager gets the opportunity

0:27:55 respond if that's okay and don't fill in the blanks appropriately. Mrs.

0:28:01 Rice is obviously available. So I really think that you have to look at the size

0:28:07 and the complexity of the organization and when earlier Chris shared this with

0:28:12 me this afternoon I read it obviously if I'm looking at it from the perspective

0:28:17 of the city of Twin Falls a relatively complex organization it would be very

0:28:24 troubling to me, as it should be probably very troubling to you.

0:28:31 But I think that you also look at the depth and the size of the organizations that are

0:28:37 also out there.

0:28:38 And in some cases, the size of the organization really does lend to the strength that the organization

0:28:48 has in terms of manpower behind it.

0:28:51 So we would have the expectation or I would have the expectation that our financial staff

0:28:56 is absolutely top-notch and we would have that expectation because of the robust nature of

0:29:02 our organization.

0:29:04 Other organizations may not be the same way.

0:29:07 How the city of the bill and the blank who is much smaller in a smaller rural setting

0:29:14 then it operates is maybe different than the luxury

0:29:19 that we have the opportunity to operate in.

0:29:23 Our environments are very, very different.

0:29:27 So I think that when you read that statement,

0:29:30 I think it's important to recognize the organization

0:29:34 that it is referring to.

0:29:35 Again, if it were us, and I shared this with Chris,

0:29:38 and Lori shared the same thing with Chris,

0:29:40 if it were us, we would be concerned,

0:29:43 And hopefully you would be very concerned in terms of what that statement is saying.

0:29:49 Good, Jim?

0:29:55 Sorry, you're back, I'm sorry, you're back.

0:29:58 That's fine, thank you, Mayor.

0:30:00 Thank you, Chris, for Councilman talking to him for just making us aware of these facts.

0:30:06 I think that, well, a couple of points I want to make, you know, our representative,

0:30:11 our vote is our county commissioners.

0:30:14 And I don't think it would be a problem.

0:30:16 I think it would benefit us to use them as our spokesperson, use them as a representative,

0:30:24 and go through the steps that the bureaucracy that's laid out in how the solid waste system works.

0:30:33 But I do think that you point out some good concerns, especially about personnel, especially about the audit report.

0:30:42 I would say we should make a statement or lay out our concerns,

0:30:46 ask Southern Idaho Solid Waste to address these concerns.

0:30:50 And also there's a process that commissioners have to approve the budget request much like we do with Southern Idaho Solid Waste.

0:31:00 And the Twin Falls County Commissioners go through that process.

0:31:04 And so they have direct talks and negotiating different aspects of their budget.

0:31:10 if they're asking for an increase for personnel here

0:31:12 or an increase for raises in certain areas,

0:31:17 they're gonna go through that process

0:31:18 and perhaps we can learn more about what steps they take

0:31:24 and perhaps we could have a representative,

0:31:26 perhaps Councilman Talkington would want to be present

0:31:32 when they do have those talks with Southern and those solid waste.

0:31:34 But I think that we should definitely voice our concerns

0:31:39 but use the proper channels and ask our commissioners to represent us.

0:31:44 And they can also, if they take that to the Southern Idaho Solid Waste Commission,

0:31:52 they can start the conversation on a level that matters,

0:31:55 on a level that has direction and has ability to make changes and make votes.

0:32:01 But I think these are great concerns and I think we should use our vote.

0:32:06 we should use our commissioners and involve them in the process.

0:32:15 And I certainly recognize respect, Rebecca's opinion in regards to utilizing the commissioners

0:32:21 to proceed in different negotiations with the solid waste board.

0:32:25 What I discovered with working with CIRCOM and as Chris indicated,

0:32:29 this, the configuration of this entity is somewhat like CIRCOM,

0:32:33 where it becomes a little bit more complex is when the interest of the city of Twin Falls

0:32:39 Twin Falls are not the same as the county of Twin Falls.

0:32:42 And we discovered that several times during CIRCOM in which the Police Department, the

0:32:47 Twin Falls Sheriff's Office, the Police Department, the Twin Falls Fire Department, we had policy

0:32:52 concerns that were somewhat different, not better, but different than Twin Falls County

0:32:58 Sheriff and other rural fire agencies.

0:33:00 And there was no way for us, and we handled the vast majority of radio calls.

0:33:05 in the vast majority of work through Circum,

0:33:07 we had no voice there, and we were,

0:33:09 I guess for no other better term, held hostage

0:33:11 because we had to utilize the resource of the county

0:33:15 whose vision and mission during those times

0:33:20 was different than ours.

0:33:22 And at the end of the day, in the final analysis,

0:33:24 we were able to negotiate a voice on the board

0:33:29 and have a vote and proceed that way.

0:33:31 And I don't think that, honestly if our best interest in the county's best interest bifurcate and go different directions, then we, we're not going to be able to proceed.

0:33:49 over do we do we pay the county or do we pay the district we are built by the

0:34:02 county part so our relationship is with the county okay so I and that's what I

0:34:07 thought I agree with the auto Pio so I though correct but the landfill fees we

0:34:16 paid yeah through the county to the solid waste district so I agree with Jim's

0:34:23 observations both respecting Rebecca's opinion and understanding there's a process that I think

0:34:30 we should try to go down, but I think we need to understand that I think because we pay the

0:34:35 county it sets up a different kind of relationship than we're all on the same team together. It's

0:34:41 really a we're paying a bill to them. So I do think that that conversation is going to be

0:34:48 be challenging to make sure we're all on the same page about defending our interests.

0:34:54 But I do think that that's probably the appropriate place to start the conversation and Chris,

0:34:59 I think you've raised some very good concerns here.

0:35:04 The other piece that sort of comes to my mind is are there parts and pieces of this that we

0:35:09 do have some control over that we can manage our own destiny?

0:35:12 For example, Green Waste, we had talked earlier, I think when we had the presentation previously

0:35:17 about potentially setting up recycling programs within the city to get that out of the waste

0:35:23 stream.

0:35:24 What efforts might we be doing to try to increase our curbside single stream recycling?

0:35:30 The things that we do have some control over at the same time as looking at these other

0:35:34 issues.

0:35:36 Susan Hark.

0:35:38 I think the thing to remember with that is the solid waste district claims, their costs

0:35:43 are fixed.

0:35:44 So even though we send less and we do our part recycling, it actually causes our costs to

0:35:49 go up because of their cost per ton.

0:35:55 And so yes, I think recycling is great and I think it's something we should look at, but

0:35:59 at the same time you have to remember that's not going to affect what we pay according to

0:36:04 their pay chart.

0:36:05 Chris Tyke.

0:36:07 Well, I would suggest then that as our liaison, you have them strike that fourth principle about

0:36:13 opportunities to reduce, reuse, and recycle if it's a meaningless statute for a statement.

0:36:22 I think the Council needs to get a handle on reducing the Green West as Sean just indicated.

0:36:29 That was my first question.

0:36:30 We're already at the point now where people are bagging their yardage and I hope can be

0:36:35 market-driven rather than pinnitive and think it through because merely to have

0:36:42 respect PSI to stop and tag and bill people for extra bags is going to drive

0:36:48 up their cost and we have to think of the squeezing on one side and bulging on

0:36:52 the other so to speak but we've got to get the green waste down. I think probably

0:36:58 the best summary statement I can make is I hope that not everybody has lulled into

0:37:04 that audit statement is not meaning anything or why is it in there.

0:37:09 I must ask if it is meaningless or the fact that the solid waste district increased their

0:37:19 personnel budget by 3.95% in the year that they receive an audit with some red flags.

0:37:27 That's oil and water that doesn't mess to me and it doesn't make sense.

0:37:31 At the same time, I have played the game with Sir Comme with the counties and with all due

0:37:37 respect, Rebecca.

0:37:42 You don't have a dance partner when you're a non-voting member and they don't always have

0:37:47 your best interests at the heart.

0:37:49 I would hope we could use some format of having a combination of the county commissioners and

0:37:55 solid waste districts come to us with the idea in mind how to make it more equitable for

0:38:00 what I hope is a sustained, ongoing, and increasing effort of recycling, not some after effort.

0:38:09 Recycling has to be here to stay. It's not an afterthought. We are being penalized as

0:38:16 you just brought up, Suzanne, by recycling. That doesn't make sense, even in government

0:38:22 circles and talk.

0:38:23 And I think it's not just us. I suspect there are other communities that are part of the

0:38:28 a solid waste district that faced that same issue, particularly Blaine County, with their extensive recycling programs.

0:38:36 I can wait a second.

0:38:37 Thank you, Mayor.

0:38:38 I just want to respond real quickly.

0:38:39 It's less of an opinion about how we should use the county or work with our county.

0:38:47 But it's more about that is just the fact that that is how it works right now.

0:38:51 If we want to change it, we can certainly work on that.

0:38:53 But I don't want us to assume first that we have

0:38:57 different goals and different opinions.

0:39:00 I wouldn't doubt if our county representatives also

0:39:04 believed there was concerned with these documents

0:39:08 and concern with the personnel costs.

0:39:11 So anyway, before we assume that they don't have

0:39:13 our interests in mind, I think we should just ask

0:39:15 and see first.

0:39:21 All right, well as we have an accident,

0:39:24 mind your other than the reach.

0:39:25 Thank you. Thank you for the time.

0:39:27 Sure. I still go back to the one that's most concerning to me.

0:39:33 I think that's one of the points you were trying to point at Chris,

0:39:36 that they're paying 103,000 for their chief financial officer,

0:39:39 and their county company doesn't feel they have the capabilities

0:39:44 to do what they need to do.

0:39:46 And I would think we have several people on staff that have that capability.

0:39:49 So that's the most concerning to me.

0:39:52 And I think I will try to work with the City Manager

0:39:56 and maybe we'll see whether we,

0:39:58 what course of action we do have Chris.

0:40:00 Yeah, thank you.

0:40:01 If you'd like to be involved with that,

0:40:02 I'd appreciate it as well as it is in, okay.

0:40:05 Moving on to item number two,

0:40:07 which is a consideration of a funding

0:40:09 of the maintenance portion of the hanging basket,

0:40:13 hanging flower basket project along Shoshone Street,

0:40:16 being partnership with Twin Falls Area Chamber of Commerce.

0:40:19 And I see my chamber of commerce,

0:40:20 the CEO stepping down for this item.

0:40:30 We have some, Mr. Rothwether, I'm sorry,

0:40:35 just assumed he'd start talking.

0:40:38 Probably have a habit of doing that.

0:40:41 Mr. Mayor, members of the council,

0:40:43 as you will recall, last week we began the conversation

0:40:46 very briefly and quickly about,

0:40:49 is this the Hanging Basket Project something

0:40:52 that we should move forward and partner with the chamber

0:40:57 directions to maybe bring back or resurrect the hanging basket program.

0:41:04 And in that conversation last week, we shared with you that there were about 72 hanging

0:41:08 baskets that typically lined down to Shown Street.

0:41:11 And in those 72 baskets, it was largely a chamber of commerce project where they would

0:41:19 go out and they would actively solicit donations from members of the community.

0:41:25 And that would cover the cost of the basket as well as the watering and the maintenance

0:41:31 of that program.

0:41:33 And then it reached to the place of the increased cost associated with the maintenance.

0:41:37 And I think that Sean is here to talk about or be available to talk about the history and

0:41:42 what has occurred.

0:41:45 But from my perspective, it was one of those things that we started to talk about after

0:41:51 Mr. Prater and the downtown alive group came in and met with Medchin said we would like

0:41:58 to do something with the banners and from that I had the conversation with staff and

0:42:04 then also with Sean wearing his chamber hat saying is there something that we could do

0:42:10 as a city partner with the basket process.

0:42:14 And so then we began that conversation in moving forward and in your agenda packet this

0:42:20 this evening. Probably the most thing is we'll focus on the budget impacts we should talk about on page two.

0:42:28 And what I want to direct you to are the city's expenses because if you look at that sheet,

0:42:43 you'll probably notice that some of those costs have a range.

0:42:47 And that is really because we've never done this before, but it is one of those things that we thought that

0:42:54 If we were to partner, we would be responsible for the labor and the water

0:42:58 and component of that, and that the chamber would be responsible for the

0:43:02 solicitation of the baskets and raising the money to actually procure those

0:43:07 baskets and signage in moving forward. So if it's appropriate, Mr. Mayor,

0:43:14 members of the council, I will run through the city's expenses, and then I

0:43:17 will turn it over to Sean, and he can talk about the chamber expenses that they

0:43:21 would look at. The city's expense is if we look at the labor range from about $5,040

0:43:27 to $7,500 and if you, and that would be for the duration, the heat, the duration, and if

0:43:33 you ask why is there a variability, it's because the number of days and the time it will take

0:43:39 to water is largely going to be dependent upon the heat and the amount of time that they're

0:43:44 moving in through that process. I think it is safe to say, at least from this standpoint,

0:43:51 is that these are additional costs above and beyond

0:43:54 what we currently have anticipated.

0:43:57 And we may be able to achieve some economies

0:44:00 with staff internally, but we believe that it's probably

0:44:04 going to require an extra body or a portion of an extra body

0:44:09 to assist in this manpower effort.

0:44:12 There's an initial effort to hang the baskets of about $150

0:44:16 from a labor perspective.

0:44:18 The fuel is really a variable.

0:44:20 We had conversations internally about the fuel.

0:44:24 How long does it take to drive about a quarter to a half mile

0:44:30 over the course of the entire time,

0:44:32 recognizing that most of it's going to be an idle time.

0:44:35 The vehicle would be donated to us by Wills.

0:44:37 They had made that commitment as described

0:44:39 in the staff report.

0:44:41 And then you're looking at pumps and mislays,

0:44:42 expenses of about $400.

0:44:44 And so the city's total outlay to kind of move this forward

0:44:48 the first year would be somewhere between $6,500 and $9,000.

0:44:54 These are funds that we do not necessarily have budgeted for this expense.

0:45:00 It's not something that we thought about during the development of the fiscal year 2013 budget,

0:45:07 but if it is something that the Council wanted to move forward with, we would certainly include

0:45:12 those costs in a 2014 budget and beyond.

0:45:19 We understand that the baskets, there are baskets that are available and they are ready

0:45:24 for purchase and so if we could work in this process, I believe it is the chambers intent

0:45:33 that if there's a commitment from the city to be able to move forward on the labor component

0:45:39 and the watering side of it, that they would begin their fundraising efforts to procure

0:45:45 the baskets.

0:45:46 Again, we have 72 possible hanging opportunities in some of the conversations we've had.

0:45:52 We felt that that actually may not totally materialize, but we don't know.

0:45:57 Obviously, if we were not able to find 72 different donors for the baskets, the total

0:46:03 costs of the labor would obviously decrease, but proportionately, it's unknown.

0:46:08 How much more time does it take to water five plus baskets really becomes the question

0:46:14 over that number.

0:46:15 So with that, Mr. Mayor, members of the council,

0:46:17 we have to stand for questions now.

0:46:18 I do not know the light, the light does not hold.

0:46:21 Travis, this is in addition right now.

0:46:23 This is not being, again, just to reiterate what you said.

0:46:26 This is not being absorbed by a current person

0:46:29 that we have on staff.

0:46:31 It's, you're looking at this being in addition,

0:46:34 so we would hire another seasonal employee.

0:46:37 Yes, so we've had the conversation.

0:46:39 We do have one person that works downtown.

0:46:42 we believe that we might be able to have them as part of their duties assist us in this effort,

0:46:49 but we really believe that the volume of the work that they're doing would cause us to probably

0:46:54 have to hire an additional employee to move forward.

0:46:57 And so we wanted to be conservative in our approach and state that we believe right now

0:47:02 never having done this but having talked to people who had, it would take a body to assist

0:47:09 in this effort.

0:47:10 Because it takes two individuals to water these plants, because you have to have a driver and someone in the back, watering.

0:47:17 Correct.

0:47:18 Okay.

0:47:19 And again, as you stated before, this is a non-budgeted item.

0:47:23 We did not anticipate this.

0:47:25 That is correct, again.

0:47:27 Correct, Ms. Leopold.

0:47:29 Thank you, Mayor.

0:47:31 If we decide to go forward this year, where would the funds come from?

0:47:34 So next week, Lori Race is going to share with you where we stand in terms of general fund.

0:47:39 Our general fund right now is solid and healthy.

0:47:43 In the labor side we have expended less than what was anticipated because of vacancies that

0:47:48 have occurred throughout the year.

0:47:50 We also are at a position in terms of capital and operating costs lower than where we would

0:47:56 anticipate to be at a six month window.

0:47:59 There's a preview of next week's budget message from Lori.

0:48:01 We look really good.

0:48:03 So it would come out of money that we had proposed for personnel and operating costs, but we're

0:48:08 not going to be utilizing?

0:48:10 Yeah, so we would place these into the park fund, right?

0:48:14 Because what we'd like to do is we'd want to make sure

0:48:16 that we're accurately tracking the expenditures appropriately.

0:48:20 And so we would place these into the park fund,

0:48:23 and we would go forward.

0:48:25 When I say how we're looking in totality,

0:48:28 it's not the park fund that I'm speaking,

0:48:29 but it's the entire general fund.

0:48:31 And when we go through that audit process,

0:48:33 we focus on the major fund types and general fund

0:48:36 being that not type.

0:48:37 Thank you, Travis.

0:48:38 John, did you want to speak to us

0:48:41 from the chamber perspective?

0:48:44 I would be happy to.

0:48:45 So when Travis brought this up to me,

0:48:50 it's probably worth explaining why we don't do the hanging

0:48:52 basket project all by ourselves anymore.

0:48:54 So in 2009, we began to experience challenges

0:49:00 getting sponsorships.

0:49:01 So the sponsorship cost for the baskets

0:49:03 previously was $275 a year to sponsor a basket.

0:49:08 because we had not only the expense of the baskets,

0:49:10 but we had the maintenance cost, which at that time was

0:49:12 around $8,000.

0:49:16 We were notified by the vendor that provided that maintenance

0:49:20 to us that the cost, the following year,

0:49:23 was going to be $12,465.

0:49:26 So you spread that, and whether it's $12,000

0:49:30 because you watered 64 baskets or $12,605

0:49:37 because your water in 72, it's 12,000 plus, it's a lot of money.

0:49:41 And you have to spread that across the cost in the basket.

0:49:44 So what happened is we were down to about 50 sponsors

0:49:48 and our cost went up $4,000 a year.

0:49:53 When we were able to do the baskets the final year in 2010,

0:49:56 thanks to the BID, actually, the BID under-road,

0:50:01 I think about $6,500 to basically break that program even.

0:50:06 And at that point, we decided as the chamber that we couldn't take that on as a responsibility

0:50:11 as a liability.

0:50:14 With this set up, with the maintenance piece being handled by the city, if you so choose

0:50:19 to move forward with that, we control our own destiny on the other end.

0:50:24 So if I only get 40 sponsors, we'll only buy 40 baskets, as opposed to, got an order 72,

0:50:31 hope I can sponsor all of them, which was really the process we went through before.

0:50:35 So, you know, it's a great program.

0:50:39 It was around for about 15 years before we had to stop doing it.

0:50:44 We do get some inquiries about it, of why it's not happening truthfully.

0:50:48 I think this is one of the things that the city gets blamed for or rewarded for that wasn't

0:50:52 their project in the first place.

0:50:55 And I think more calls have actually come to Travis and his folks than have come to the

0:50:59 chamber.

0:51:00 But we're very willing to work on this moving forward.

0:51:05 I mean, we're ready to start soliciting sponsorships.

0:51:07 My anticipation is because we're not covering that maintenance cost,

0:51:10 that the sponsorship level will be down to a point

0:51:13 that it won't be quite as cost prohibitive.

0:51:16 Although I haven't calculated that exact number yet.

0:51:19 Now, 72's in the 125 range.

0:51:23 Yeah, I think we'll be in that range.

0:51:26 Some of this is a bit unknown.

0:51:27 You know, not every sign is going to need to be redone.

0:51:30 No, if we have a sponsor that's sponsored previously

0:51:32 and they're signs in good shape,

0:51:33 we're not going to have that expense.

0:51:35 but we are missing several signs,

0:51:37 we're obviously missing some brackets.

0:51:39 And there is, you try to build in a replacement cost as well

0:51:42 because you inevitably lose a couple

0:51:44 that whether...

0:51:46 To the Magic Valley Zephyr Bandles, or whatever so.

0:51:50 But probably more in the, you know, 120 to 140 range

0:51:56 than the 275 range.

0:51:59 I'd be happy to answer that one.

0:52:02 Sean, I appreciate the history of how we arrived.

0:52:06 where we're at. I remember it well, but I'm glad that we were able to do that, and I appreciate

0:52:11 what you've said, but maybe just to reiterate, do you feel fairly confident that there's

0:52:16 enough interest with chamber members and your fundraising that you can do a pretty good

0:52:21 percentage of these 72 baskets? Just reiterate that.

0:52:25 So I went through the list that we had the last year we did this, and my best guess of

0:52:31 those folks is there are probably 35 of those that I think are kind of a no brainer.

0:52:36 So I don't think it's going to be an aggressive solicitation campaign for the next six months

0:52:42 to try to get the money raised.

0:52:43 And again, if we only get 35 sponsors, then we'll only do 35 baskets.

0:52:48 Chris, what would you think of this?

0:52:52 As I understand, the city's commitment would be more or less fixed, whether you have 35 or 70,

0:52:59 because the vehicle is going to be used and what are they going to do when they're not watering.

0:53:04 I guess you could put them to some other purpose or use.

0:53:08 You could.

0:53:09 Sounds like the solid waste district issue.

0:53:14 But you believe that those employees could be doing other things

0:53:17 if we don't need them for the full two hours?

0:53:19 Sean was going to answer.

0:53:23 If he wants to.

0:53:24 Well, I haven't finished my question.

0:53:26 It may make more sense.

0:53:27 So I was suggesting we aim for a threshold to save 50.

0:53:31 There's nothing magic about that.

0:53:33 Figuring that anything less than that

0:53:34 would make an efficient use of your person.

0:53:37 But if you can't attract use, I'm elsewhere.

0:53:40 Watch notes.

0:53:41 In dentist lawyers here in the audience to assist,

0:53:43 but yes, we have one person we have downtown down

0:53:45 to assist with the sprinkler system that

0:53:48 is ours and doing routine maintenance down in that area.

0:53:52 We would use a portion of that person's time to assist

0:53:55 with this.

0:53:56 But again, we believe that there are some additional staff

0:54:00 that we need to be able to support

0:54:02 the overall operations and mission of the park

0:54:06 in recreation program.

0:54:08 So we would use a portion of that on budgeted time

0:54:12 for this project, and we would use them to supplement

0:54:17 other activities in our parks and our park system right now.

0:54:23 For example, and I believe that we are going to have

0:54:26 recycling program in our parks.

0:54:29 So there is now a movement, and I think

0:54:33 it's being perpetuated by the Youth Council,

0:54:37 that we're going to have a recycling program within our parks,

0:54:40 which is a wonderful program.

0:54:42 But more than likely, there might be some additional times

0:54:45 and things associated with that, again, unknown.

0:54:49 But if you look at Dennis's team,

0:54:51 you look at the number of parks that they go forward and work,

0:54:55 I don't think that he would turn down more help if it were provided to him.

0:55:01 Susan Hawkins.

0:55:03 OK, I have a couple thoughts, and I'm

0:55:04 going to try not to jumble this up.

0:55:06 When I first heard about this, I was all gung-ho and thought,

0:55:09 what a great idea.

0:55:10 And then the more you kind of stew on things,

0:55:14 you think of a few things.

0:55:15 And I was just curious, first of all,

0:55:18 the city is paying for all of their part out of their budget,

0:55:21 but the chamber is fundraising for their part.

0:55:24 Would the chamber be willing to split the labor costs with us

0:55:27 and make that a 50-50 so it's not all out of city's pocket but more of a joint venture?

0:55:33 Well one of the bonuses the city has is you get to tax people and then the membership

0:55:37 organization that requires people to give me money for a budget so while I appreciate

0:55:43 those are different things that's my revenue stream at the chamber is asking people for

0:55:47 money.

0:55:48 Got it.

0:55:49 And in all honesty if this is turning into a chamber taking this program back on I can't

0:55:55 of $17,000. My other question would be then, have we designated the money from the parking

0:56:04 meter sales for something or is that something that can go towards this since we wanted that

0:56:08 money to stay downtown? So what's important to recognize about the parking meter money

0:56:15 is it's one time money. Right. We're not going to have any additional parking

0:56:19 meter sales. I guess I'm just thinking about it this year because this is an unbudgeted

0:56:24 expense this year. Right. So what's going to happen on the revenue

0:56:27 side is we're going to receive revenues generally into the general fund and then we're going

0:56:31 to extend them out of the general fund and so I'm looking at the bottom line of what that

0:56:35 looks like. That it be certainly what we could use. I mean we could attach it or we could

0:56:41 assign it. I think it may make more sense if you're looking at making an investment in

0:56:50 the downtown area that it is a permanent investment that you can say. This is what we

0:56:56 we did with the parking meter of money.

0:57:00 Point will take them, thank you.

0:57:02 Don Hall?

0:57:03 I have one more quick thing to add to that.

0:57:05 Also, I think if the chamber were to take this on its own standalone project,

0:57:10 then we're getting back into the $250 to $300 range for sponsorship.

0:57:14 I think that really was a big piece of our challenge.

0:57:17 It was the double whammy of economic hard times,

0:57:21 businesses being asked to pony up that money, and the increased expense.

0:57:26 And I just, I am not confident we can go out and solicit $275 sponsorships in any reasonable amount of time.

0:57:35 I understand that.

0:57:36 I look at it as a business owner on Blue Lakes.

0:57:38 Nobody's going to pay to water my flower baskets.

0:57:41 I have to do it myself.

0:57:43 So I just try to remember that in the back of my mind.

0:57:45 Yes, we have special interest in our downtown and we want to see it thrive.

0:57:50 But you look at all the other small business owners all over the community that has to

0:57:55 paid the $250 to buy the flowers, plant them, water them,

0:57:58 take care of them through the summer for their businesses.

0:58:01 Look at the baskets more as a piece of the public landscaping

0:58:04 that it's just downtown, because it's not a flower basket

0:58:08 hanging in front of someone's business

0:58:10 that's getting taken care of.

0:58:11 It's, they get their name lashed onto it.

0:58:13 Right.

0:58:16 And we welcome a sponsorship from your business

0:58:19 of all the baskets in the basket.

0:58:21 I should have thought at all.

0:58:25 It's blinking, so I figured you.

0:58:26 I've got two questions.

0:58:27 Sean, just so folks understand,

0:58:30 this is not, for lack of a better term,

0:58:34 a chamber scheme to make a lot of money,

0:58:36 so you can go to the south of France, right?

0:58:38 This is just directly towards the baskets

0:58:41 and their costs associated.

0:58:42 The sponsorship costs will be calculated

0:58:44 to cover our hard expenses.

0:58:47 And also, I mean, we have labor costs

0:58:49 and those types of things too,

0:58:50 of soliciting the sponsorship.

0:58:51 Sure.

0:58:52 No, this is by no means any giant fundraisers

0:58:55 for the chamber.

0:58:56 And then I have a question for Dennis.

0:58:58 Remember, this was that five to 10 minutes, Dennis.

0:59:04 Well, I've only taken five or 10 minutes.

0:59:08 For the rest of you, I can't calculate.

0:59:10 When we said that last week, we was like, we never talked about it.

0:59:14 And now we're talking about talking about it.

0:59:17 So we're not going to get done.

0:59:18 Dennis, I think it's fair to say the city runs on a pretty thin line.

0:59:23 We are employees per 1,000 compared to other communities is fairly low.

0:59:31 We've always run a pretty thin line.

0:59:33 What about the Parks Department and to have another person, part-time person, seasonal person?

0:59:39 Well, actually, give me the history, the last five years.

0:59:42 How many part-time employees have you added to your?

0:59:48 at it. Okay. Currently right now we have nine full time park employees and also we probably 13 to 15

0:59:55 seasonal employees that we have. Probably out of those current 13 seasonal employees I would say

1:00:01 probably about 10 of them work 40 hours a week and we have some people that just do weekends you

1:00:06 know maybe Friday, Saturday, Sunday so some of them on again 27 to 30 hours you know we do have one

1:00:11 person that works really downtown he chooses to work only 30 hours a week that's all he wants

1:00:16 work. Retired gentlemen, so we give them 30 hours. But probably in the last five years,

1:00:21 that increase in seasonal employees, my best guess is maybe a couple, I would say there.

1:00:29 And also kind of discussing how to man this. We're thinking that we have a lot of recreation

1:00:36 kids. Some of our college students that are always looking for more hours, because those

1:00:40 college students when they work, they may work 10 hours one week. The next hour they

1:00:44 to make work next week, maybe 20 hours,

1:00:46 just kind of depends on the schedule, what we need them for.

1:00:48 So there's probably, we're thinking some of these kids

1:00:51 that are from college that might want

1:00:52 a couple of extra hours every day.

1:00:54 So we're thinking that we could probably

1:00:56 give those kids some extra time.

1:00:58 So I guess really why I'm going here is this isn't,

1:01:01 I mean, this is a body per hour

1:01:06 that you could utilize for other activities downtown

1:01:10 throughout the park system, somehow.

1:01:12 And it's not just really, I mean,

1:01:13 I'm not going to drive to the parks and rec departments.

1:01:16 You bunch of people drinking coffee all day with nothing to do.

1:01:18 I mean, you keep these folks busy during the,

1:01:21 especially the summer season.

1:01:23 And this could be in addition to that,

1:01:25 and very useful to the city.

1:01:27 Yes, it would be.

1:01:28 Okay, thank you.

1:01:32 You're back, no, sorry.

1:01:33 Thank you, Mayor.

1:01:34 Well, I don't know for the discussion part,

1:01:36 but I just want to make two observations

1:01:38 that I think of when I look at this report

1:01:41 and the contributions that people are making.

1:01:43 You know, we're about to talk about the strategic plan and in which parts of the strategic plan

1:01:48 that we should put forth.

1:01:50 So I don't have a problem supporting this program because it fulfills the prosperous community

1:01:55 goal one revitalized downtown, create programs that revitalize downtown.

1:02:01 So I think it would be a good contribution, however small, you know, and I think that's

1:02:05 what's great.

1:02:06 And the second observation is the partners that are involved, I mean, there are people

1:02:10 in the community, from the private sector, from the chamber,

1:02:14 that are coming together to make this program possible.

1:02:17 So I think it's reasonable for the city to participate

1:02:20 and help brighten downtown with some flowers, you know?

1:02:24 As, you know, aesthetically focused that is.

1:02:29 And usually we try to, you know, focus on more hardcore things

1:02:32 like infrastructure, but I think this is a great thing.

1:02:35 I think that it's addressed in the strategic plan,

1:02:38 And I don't have a problem funding at this year with excess funds from the general fund

1:02:44 or personnel fund where we can find those, you know, and also just want to thank Moss Greenhouse,

1:02:51 Will's Toyota, the Chamber, all the different partners that were mentioned in this report,

1:03:00 LidlSigns, because, you know, after all the strategic plan that we're talking about, we're

1:03:06 having partners and if we don't participate and be a partner in that, you know, then

1:03:13 camp partners if you're not a partner, right? So, I'm for it.

1:03:20 We have no additional likes to have a motion. Jim, I'd recommend it so I can.

1:03:31 No, I was going to let Jim. Do you want to make it, Jim?

1:03:34 I would move that we would appropriate out of probably reserves, just call it a contingency,

1:03:45 an amount of money not to exceed $8950 for the purposes of providing labor, fuel pumps,

1:03:54 waiting expenses for the downtown baskets.

1:03:58 I'll second.

1:03:59 I move by Jim and seconder by Rebecca Middle-Suckett.

1:04:03 We go ahead with an expense of $8,950 up to $8,900.

1:04:10 Not to exceed.

1:04:11 I'm going to vote against flowers.

1:04:14 For the maintenance portion of the hanging flower basket

1:04:17 practice, it's in partnership with the footballs area chamber

1:04:20 commerce.

1:04:21 We have additional lights.

1:04:23 Seeing them, we have the roll call vote.

1:04:25 Susan Hawkins.

1:04:26 Yes.

1:04:27 Greg Lansing. Yes. Jim. Yes. Rebecca Melsweka. Yes.

1:04:32 Has talking to you. Yes. John Berger.

1:04:34 Oh, sorry. And Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes six to zero.

1:04:41 Thank you very much for the John for the effort to the chief run this apartment with us.

1:04:47 It's a quick fight.

1:04:51 Moving on to item number three, a brief presentation of the City Manager

1:04:55 here followed by a general discussion about the City Council's

1:04:58 Physiogonal Year 2014 Budget Priorities and Philoscopies.

1:05:03 City Mayor Travis Ross Leiler.

1:05:05 And I see we have a lot of department heads out there too,

1:05:07 so might be cool.

1:05:08 We do, and they're very happy to be with us this evening.

1:05:11 Thank you.

1:05:12 We'll see the joy.

1:05:14 And they will also be joining us next week as well.

1:05:17 So Mr. Mayor, members of the Council,

1:05:22 brief presentation was further defined in my agenda statement by 30 minutes.

1:05:29 So you may consider a recess, then we will get into the brief presentation, but it's

1:05:40 really your call.

1:05:41 I just wanted to make sure that you know that the presentation was about the brief presentation.

1:05:47 Well, 30 minutes.

1:05:48 It's all definition of brief.

1:05:53 I was trying to define the word.

1:05:54 Let's take a five minute break and try to limit it in five minutes.

1:05:57 Good time.

1:06:03 Folks can't even sit for an hour without it.

1:06:05 Actually, okay, good night, but I don't think so.

1:06:07 But there's once in a while, I don't know if I can hear this.

1:06:10 I've heard a lot of love.

1:06:11 You've seen it like nine beverages.

1:06:13 I don't know if you should.

1:06:15 I'm a liquid guy, man.

1:06:17 Yeah, I'm still recovered.

1:06:19 Just like that.

1:06:20 Just like that.

1:06:21 Just like that.

1:07:24 issue that's important to the citizens.

1:07:27 I might have done my podium to talk to Judge Gar

1:09:21 I'm going to talk about the commercial ones as they take it away, are they taking it back

1:10:20 I'm surprised that we're using this.

1:10:24 I'm serious.

1:10:28 I thought it was law.

1:10:32 I put it in that position.

1:10:36 I know I'm in the law.

1:10:40 I'm in the law.

1:10:44 I'm in the law.

1:10:48 I mean, it's one of all the boxes.

1:10:52 And so I just kind of have a vote.

1:10:54 A vote is down.

1:10:55 That's better.

1:10:57 Yeah.

1:10:58 I know.

1:10:59 I know.

1:11:00 I know.

1:11:01 I know.

1:11:02 I know.

1:11:03 I know.

1:11:04 I know.

1:11:05 I know.

1:11:06 I know.

1:11:07 I know.

1:11:08 I know.

1:11:09 I know.

1:11:10 I know.

1:11:11 I know.

1:11:12 I know.

1:11:13 I know.

1:11:14 I know.

1:11:15 I know.

1:11:16 I know.

1:11:17 I know.

1:11:18 I'm talking about me.

1:11:23 I'm talking about me.

1:11:28 Doctor Strange, who has grown from past 22?

1:11:34 We're just conversations about your life.

1:11:41 I don't want you to grow in any of them.

1:11:44 I want to be all American.

1:11:47 to have it away from going on vacation and that's all I like to think about right now.

1:11:51 It's like, I'm ready to have my dad to go.

1:11:53 I'm ready to hear through.

1:11:55 That's going to be a problem for you.

1:12:01 I was coming.

1:12:12 Many things that we focused on in our conversation at PSI.

1:12:15 We would actively encourage our citizens to dispose of that green waste, you know, alternative

1:12:21 methods.

1:12:22 And we are going to be working as a city with PSI and moving forward to develop some strategies

1:12:27 to really encourage our citizens to be able to divert green waste from another place.

1:12:33 So we'll continue to be working on that as we move forward.

1:12:37 It seems to be the, if you're in a neighborhood that has some empty lots, they'll seem to

1:12:41 to be very popular, probably not to the seagrion of the owners of those lots, I'm sure, but

1:12:47 don't know.

1:12:48 Since it is, we do have this on the internet.

1:12:52 I personally mulch my lawn, probably 95% of the time that I mow my lawn, at the beginning

1:13:00 of the season and the end of the season, sometimes I'll bag it.

1:13:03 But these new modern mulchers, if you mow it on time, just for folks to know, you don't

1:13:09 even notice the graphs. It doesn't even leave. I mean, it goes right back into the soil, which

1:13:16 you know, I'm not, I don't understand all this stuff, but they say that's actually better

1:13:20 for your lawns if you mulch it. So I just, on a personal note, I do it all the time.

1:13:26 I believe, I don't believe we beg any of our parts or the golf course, dude. I don't believe

1:13:33 so at all. There's our all.

1:13:34 And the graphs that did compose those hats and nitrogen back in your soil. So it's a free

1:13:40 for those items. Right. We do back inside the pool and inside the fence area so the

1:13:45 grass doesn't get into the pool itself so we back that and maybe I think occasionally

1:13:50 we do back at City Hall but all the other ones we just mow and let it lie in the grass.

1:13:55 You've thought about getting goats to understand.

1:14:05 So, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, this really begins our process in discussing and

1:14:15 forming and formulating the fiscal year 2014 budget.

1:14:21 We are starting this process six months before the beginning of the 2014 fiscal year.

1:14:28 And I am not aware of another organization that begins their budgeting process this publicly,

1:14:35 early and so I think it's a real compliment not only to the council but also

1:14:41 to the staff as we move forward. You'll notice that there are every member of the

1:14:47 City's Senior Management Team as well as key department leaders have joined us

1:14:50 this evening. They will join us again next week to have this conversation. To

1:14:55 really move forward as we begin the process of constructing the major

1:14:59 priorities that will make up the fiscal year 2014 budget. We also have

1:15:07 142 members watching us live on the Internet right now. So imagine another

1:15:14 142 people sitting in this room participating and watching the beginning

1:15:20 of the budget process. That probably doesn't even include the people on Channel

1:15:25 doesn't include the people on channel 17 and it does not include those who will

1:15:30 download this and view this at a later time. So let's begin the process. Everything

1:15:40 that we do should be linked to our mission statement and our mission statement

1:15:45 really does set the example and it really does state the reason why the city of

1:15:50 Twin Falls exists. We are the stewards of the public trust and it is our due

1:15:57 Again, it is our duty to promote the general safety, welfare, and health of the 45,000 citizens

1:16:08 that call Twin Falls home and the nearly 30,000 additional folks that come into our community

1:16:15 on a daily basis.

1:16:17 When we go forward and we set levels of service, it's important to remember that we have such

1:16:23 an extended family, if you will, of people in the Magic Valley that come into our city on

1:16:28 a daily basis for work, for the opportunity to participate in commerce, to go to school,

1:16:35 to go to the hospital, or for a myriad of other reasons. When we craft and provide levels

1:16:43 of service, it is for all of those visitors as well. The difference is that it is on the

1:16:52 tax payers of those who own properties within our community.

1:16:57 So why do we budget?

1:16:59 Really, it's important to always remember that budgeting is the lifeblood of government.

1:17:05 It describes those key strategic priorities that we will help move our community forward.

1:17:10 It allocates precious and scarce resources, revenues that otherwise would have been given

1:17:18 to other purposes if we all had our choices, right?

1:17:20 No one likes to pay taxes.

1:17:22 no one really likes to pay fees, but all of those fees and dollars and services are what

1:17:30 we use to provide the very levels of service that we all have come back.

1:17:36 Roadways, parks, recreation, police, fire, economic development, the list of the things

1:17:43 that we do moves forward.

1:17:46 Every year it is our goal to have a budget that is balanced.

1:17:50 In fact, we are mandated by law to do that.

1:17:54 One that is visically prudent and one that we have the ability to move forward and that

1:17:59 is completely sustainable.

1:18:02 We also want to make sure that we have a budget that lives up to our mission statement.

1:18:06 One that protects our citizens and keeps us safe.

1:18:09 One that enhances our community's quality of life.

1:18:12 One that allows us to create the infrastructure that we need so that we can continue to grow

1:18:17 and realize the vision of that strategic plan that you just passed last week.

1:18:26 So when we go forward, we're transforming resources into programs, resources, into services.

1:18:34 And the idea of tonight's conversation is not to balance the budget, again, the idea of

1:18:42 tonight is not to balance the budget, but it's really to begin those higher level of conversations

1:18:49 Because from this conversation and the conversation that we have next week, we as a city team will go into the lab, if you will, and we will continue to construct that budget that meets the needs of the council, that meets the needs, the operational demands of the city that implement our strategic plan.

1:19:10 We want to make sure on an annual basis that our budget is providing high-quality efficient

1:19:15 for governmental services.

1:19:17 That's why we're in the business, that we are allocating resources in the manner that

1:19:22 is fitting of the citizens' needs, that we are always being concerned about the long-term

1:19:29 viability and the sustainability of the programs and services that we offer, and we want to

1:19:36 make sure that we are taking those opportunities to secure those collaborative partnerships.

1:19:42 Partnerships are important to us as we continue to move forward.

1:19:50 Again, one of the things that I think is really important that we all come to the same place

1:19:56 and conclusion is there is a direct correlation between the levels of service that we're able

1:20:01 provide the level of funding that is captured and provided by our citizens.

1:20:14 So I'll take you back.

1:20:15 I'll take you back to last year when we had a very similar conversation, more of a refresher.

1:20:21 And from that fiscal year 2013 budget, that budget that we're operating in right now,

1:20:28 we had these four major priorities.

1:20:32 priority was to make sure that our tax collections and revenues that we brought in did not exceed

1:20:41 or did not use more than $1 million of the entire foregone balance as a starting point.

1:20:47 It's not a commitment to use the million dollars, but it really is, it sets that maximum ceiling,

1:20:54 and as we go through conversations in May, in June, July, and August, we will continue

1:21:02 to scrutinize how those funds are awarded and appropriated for the different purposes in

1:21:07 which staff believes it's important and which you believe is important in the purgement of

1:21:12 the strategic plan.

1:21:14 We talked about the importance of having our wage structure represent more of a market wage

1:21:20 in our area and our HR team led by both Susan and Gretchen did a phenomenal job last year

1:21:27 in developing what I would describe as a very good first phase

1:21:31 in a compensation plan.

1:21:32 And when we made that presentation to you last year,

1:21:35 we said that there were subsequent phases

1:21:37 that we would want to ultimately have a conversation about.

1:21:42 That we wanted to make sure that we were developing funding

1:21:45 solutions for our infrastructure, not only where

1:21:47 we were deficient today, but ones that gave us the opportunity

1:21:52 to maybe get ahead of that curve.

1:21:54 that allowed us the opportunities to grow, to expand,

1:21:58 and to meet regulatory compliance issues

1:22:00 as they went forward, and always.

1:22:03 We want to make sure that we are honoring

1:22:05 our fiduciary responsibility by having the highest,

1:22:10 most effective, and efficient services

1:22:12 that we can possibly provide.

1:22:13 Performance measurement is one of those things

1:22:16 that we have started, and it will help us

1:22:18 in scrutinizing internally how well we're doing,

1:22:22 And it may allow us the opportunity to find best practices that help us align our levels

1:22:29 of service with the citizens' expectations as presented in a community survey, as well

1:22:35 as what's illustrated in the strategic plan.

1:22:41 So what did budgets look like over the course of the last two fiscal years?

1:22:46 We have a very quick snapshot of the budget that was adopted in 2012, and then the budget

1:22:53 that was adopted in 2013.

1:22:56 And you'll notice that the spending went up.

1:22:58 We shared why those reasons occurred.

1:23:01 We went forward and we had conversations

1:23:03 about the decrease in the market value extensively.

1:23:06 We had total tax collections increase last year

1:23:09 by about $576,000 where we took the 3% growth formula

1:23:17 and the new construction role.

1:23:20 It showed what the translation in that tax rate was

1:23:22 And we had a long conversation about the tax rate

1:23:26 and how that tax rate is just a multiplier

1:23:29 to the values of the property that it's being compared to.

1:23:33 And then we also illustrated what that meant

1:23:36 in $1,000 of taxable value.

1:23:41 This is what that net budget looked like over the course

1:23:43 of those years.

1:23:44 And you can see that the net budget that we're operating

1:23:47 under this year for fiscal year 2013

1:23:50 is lower than the budget that was what we used to operate in fiscal year 2009.

1:23:58 In the blue graph, you can also see that the property tax portion or the general fund government

1:24:05 fund portion is lower and the enterprise or proprietary fund is similar as well.

1:24:16 So this is just a quick glance at what we did.

1:24:19 We had $480,000 that came from the statutory 3% allowance, as well as $95,444 that came

1:24:31 from the new construction or the growth formula calculation.

1:24:35 And that caused the impact to our tax rate.

1:24:38 When we looked at the taxes that were paid by the individuals, generally, residential property

1:24:45 owners paid about the same or less were commercial entities and industrial

1:24:50 partners paid slightly more than what they had the prior year. That is largely a

1:24:55 reflection upon what we saw with valuations last year. Homes decreased more

1:25:02 than what the decrease in the homeowners exemption was where commercial properties

1:25:07 remained relatively constant or even in some cases saw a slight increase

1:25:13 depending upon the investments that they may have made

1:25:17 or the revaluation of their buildings.

1:25:20 So let's talk about tax options for the fiscal year 2014 budget here

1:25:31 for what they look like.

1:25:33 So if the council were to take the statutory 3%,

1:25:38 that would increase total tax collections by almost $500,000,

1:25:45 $498,000. We've rounded because we're early, right? Obviously, we get very, very specific

1:25:53 as we move forward. And every 1% would cause $166,000 of new tax revenues to come into that

1:26:03 system. The growth formula, which is a combination of the new construction role and the annexation

1:26:10 role would produce about $151,000 of new construction, which is based upon what we believe to be

1:26:18 at about $18 million of total taxable value growing into our community, as well as an annexation

1:26:26 role of about $22,000. The annexation occurred as a result of the annexing of the Champlain

1:26:34 property associated with the Chabon. We get the base of that the agency will capture the

1:26:39 increment above that. A couple of things to point out. Number one, that new construction

1:26:48 role, remember everything that when we go forward talks about what it was like last year.

1:26:56 It's not what it was like today. And last year we really began to see those improvements.

1:27:03 And the mere issuance of a building permit does not mean that it appears on our tax roll

1:27:08 the following year. In some cases, there might lag a fiscal year or two because it really

1:27:13 is dependent upon when occupancy or possession of that property is taken. The city also has

1:27:21 a total foregone balance of about $1,479,000. That foregone balance is what I would describe

1:27:30 as an opportunity cost. We as a city have made that decision not to leverage a tax to

1:27:38 the fullest extent that we can and under the Idaho statutes when it comes to municipal

1:27:45 taxation it says that any of those funds that you do not collect can be reserved for

1:27:51 a future year and you can incorporate that into your budgets moving forward. It is not

1:27:56 retroactive. We cannot go back in tax and it is just something that is forward looking

1:28:01 that allows you that opportunity. It is also statute. So that means that it can change

1:28:07 at any year that the Idaho legislature meets,

1:28:12 just like all of the other laws that we have.

1:28:15 So what you're telling us is,

1:28:17 as the legislature said, you can no longer have a foregone

1:28:20 than that million and a half goes away.

1:28:24 That opportunity goes away, that is correct,

1:28:26 because what is going to happen is you will set

1:28:29 a total tax rate.

1:28:30 You'll fill out an L2 form, you will set that tax rate,

1:28:34 and we have to do that by the first week in September

1:28:37 by statute, that it will be a completed process.

1:28:40 When the Idaho legislature goes in and meets

1:28:42 on the first Monday of the first full week of January,

1:28:47 they will meet that duration and all of the laws

1:28:49 that they have when it comes to taxation are often,

1:28:55 they go backwards with an effective date of January 1st

1:28:58 because taxation in Idaho occurs in the back years

1:29:02 is a rear looking tax.

1:29:04 You pay for those services after you have received them.

1:29:07 So any tax changes or any tax law changes would have an effective date more than likely

1:29:13 of January 1st, 2014, which has always been the case, you know, and it is the case with

1:29:20 personal property tax reductions this year of the $100,000, that $100,000 will come off

1:29:27 the tax year calendar for those businesses beginning in January 1st, 2013.

1:29:38 So what does that mean?

1:29:40 What that means is if you were to take only that growth formula, new construction and annexation,

1:29:45 it would allow for an increase of $311,000 of new tax revenue coming into the system.

1:29:53 If you took the growth formula in the statutory 3%, total tax collections would be $17,410,000

1:30:01 approximately, and would create an addition of $810,000 of tax funds available to offset

1:30:08 it costs associated with the general fund. If you took the statutory three, the statutory

1:30:14 growth formula and the foregone balance, you would increase total tax collections by approximately

1:30:21 $2.3 million and that $2.3 million again would be just in the general fund, bringing total

1:30:29 tax collections to $18,900,000. So as you're thinking about those options, we thought that

1:30:39 would be important to provide you some statistical data

1:30:43 about the health of our community

1:30:44 and what it looks like moving forward.

1:30:46 We've spent a lot of time in past

1:30:49 by just talking about the municipal cost index

1:30:51 and the best way to look at the municipal cost index

1:30:54 is to consider that our version

1:30:56 of the consumer price index.

1:30:59 It takes a look at the basket of the goods

1:31:02 that we use at a city and it applies a modifier to that.

1:31:08 For this year, if you look at from April of 2012 to April of 2013, the Municipal Cost

1:31:16 Index has increased or the cost of doing business for municipalities has increased about 1.9%

1:31:24 over the prior year, which is similar to what we've seen also with the Consumer Price Index.

1:31:31 And so we often here to keep up with inflation, that's why I have that in quotes.

1:31:36 And if you were to say that the city was not able to find additional internal efficiencies

1:31:40 through the adaptation of technology or through some secrets of performance measurement, we

1:31:46 would have to find $935,900, which of the total budget, right, of the $49 million budget,

1:31:56 just to keep up with that inflationary mark, $561,000 would have to come from those tax

1:32:02 Ex supported funds, which is general funds to read airport and the like.

1:32:07 And then the other would have to come from the enterprise funds, which is going to be sewer and water until you're looking at about $375,000 in those areas.

1:32:20 The-

1:32:21 Travis, on that slide, would that include, when you talk about these percentages and municipal costs and dash all this?

1:32:32 That would include the cost to do business, basically, asphalt and parts and pieces that

1:32:39 we need.

1:32:40 Does that also include some kind of formula for employee compensation?

1:32:46 No.

1:32:47 Okay.

1:32:48 Very good question.

1:32:49 Thank you.

1:32:50 And earlier today I had both Lori and Mike present this and one of the things, or review

1:32:54 this and one of the things that Lori quickly shared with me because there's something else

1:32:59 So that is just the same level of services that we are providing today.

1:33:04 It does not allow for significant increases that we may experience in health care, asphalt,

1:33:11 fuel.

1:33:12 This is where it lies by looking at costs in April of last year to cost April of this year

1:33:19 for the exact same collection of services.

1:33:22 No expansion thereof.

1:33:23 Thank you.

1:33:26 Thank you.

1:33:28 other thing that we want to focus on is obviously we're all concerned about

1:33:32 taxation. We, and taxation isn't critical for all of us, right? We want to make sure

1:33:37 that the level of taxation is appropriate for the level of service, that we are

1:33:43 able to compete economically, right? Tax rate is important. The amount of taxes

1:33:49 that a business is going to pay could be a deterrent from coming to our

1:33:52 community in comparison to a selecting another community. It can also be one of

1:33:57 those things is an incredible concern of the residents who live here. We want to make

1:34:02 sure, as we always have, that the budgets that we pass are efficient and they're effective,

1:34:08 but also they're affordable, right? Because there are, again, 45,000 citizens and then a

1:34:15 collection of businesses above that that we are going to ask to pay for these levels of

1:34:21 services. And so we need to make sure that what we're doing is not only well justified,

1:34:25 But it is something that does not significantly enhance burdens that may be experienced by

1:34:33 people within our community.

1:34:36 For some, the recession isn't over.

1:34:40 And I think that that's important as we continue to keep that in the back of our mind moving

1:34:45 forward.

1:34:46 So we all know that the Homeowners' exemption as a result of legislative action was indexed

1:34:52 to market trends.

1:34:54 And the homeowners exemption for the upcoming tax year decreased an additional 3.54%.

1:35:03 It will go from $83,974 to $81,000 in total, okay.

1:35:11 So that means that those houses, depending upon how they're responding to the market,

1:35:19 will probably see decreases in the amount that they're able to offset.

1:35:24 in terms of a residential occupied homeowners exemption.

1:35:27 What's important, last year we saw a significant decrease

1:35:32 in the homeowners exemption as well.

1:35:34 But people's individual properties in our community

1:35:36 decreased at a rate faster than the homeowners exemption.

1:35:41 So I think it's like 9 and 11% right.

1:35:46 Right.

1:35:47 So you've had that in your first paragraph there, Travis.

1:35:50 We are interested even though we're

1:35:52 seen a bounce in

1:35:53 remember its prices and

1:35:55 remember your delay

1:35:56 it's a year delay

1:35:57 and so we believe that this

1:35:59 we will see it continue

1:36:00 downward decline not as

1:36:02 significant as last year but

1:36:03 in the neighborhood of

1:36:04 three to five percent

1:36:05 and that in the subsequent

1:36:07 years we should probably see

1:36:09 that moving up when it comes

1:36:10 to residential properties.

1:36:11 We'll probably a really good

1:36:13 indicator is what occurs to

1:36:15 the homeowners exemption and

1:36:17 that's probably usually

1:36:18 released in about October.

1:36:20 So when that begins out

1:36:21 begins out swinging its indication that the market is beginning to become stronger.

1:36:26 And what is the county assessor base their reductions on? I mean, you talked to the

1:36:37 different cities around, I'm on the board directors, I associate about cities, and

1:36:41 everybody saw a different percentage drop and it didn't seem to have anything to

1:36:47 do with they have a sense so I will tell you that there is a series of parameters

1:36:51 that all assessors have to follow there is a census and that when they do that

1:36:57 census all the properties must fall within that so they do checks it's

1:37:01 assisted through the Idaho Tax Commission and it really is a reflection

1:37:07 on the health of our individual communities so just like in the cities of

1:37:12 of those that reside in the Treasure Valley.

1:37:15 We saw significant ramp ups and property values

1:37:18 far more than what we saw here in 2004, 2005, 2006.

1:37:23 I mean, we saw homes doubling on a year after year basis.

1:37:26 We never saw that here.

1:37:28 And so obviously, when it responds back to the market,

1:37:30 you're going to have higher peaks.

1:37:32 You're probably going to have higher valleys.

1:37:34 We didn't experience those same peaks in Twin Falls.

1:37:38 We saw inflationary increases,

1:37:40 But as a result, our decreases have not been by comparison

1:37:44 to what they've seen in those other communities.

1:37:46 It's more of a, I mean, it's been significant,

1:37:50 but certainly far less than what they had seen.

1:37:53 Commercial properties based upon the conversations we have

1:37:56 believe that will be flat or they'll see

1:37:58 some additional increase as well.

1:38:00 So graphically, this is what the homeowners exemption

1:38:02 has done.

1:38:03 In 2005, it became indexed and it moved to $75,000.

1:38:08 then it was reflective and you can see that from the legislation that was passed that indexed

1:38:15 it, the difference is $6,000 and so when you look at this, it's really easy to see that

1:38:21 the value of the homes have essentially returned to somewhere between 2006 and 2007 levels

1:38:26 and more than likely this is probably the trough of that and in subsequent years we'll

1:38:31 start seeing that increase and move forward.

1:38:35 The other thing that we want to talk about are the total number of building permits that

1:38:38 it issued.

1:38:40 You can see that we selected March.

1:38:44 The total number of permits from a single family perspective that were issued had more to see

1:38:49 if you work.

1:38:50 That has, as Mitch and I have talked about, more to do with internal issues than it has

1:38:55 to do with market conditions.

1:38:57 I think that's a very right, Mitch.

1:39:00 And that if you take a look at the total number of single family permits issued at 67 are higher

1:39:07 than the total number of single family permits that were issued in the year prior.

1:39:12 Why is that significant?

1:39:14 Fiscal year 2012, we really did see a turnaround in our building community to about 65% increase

1:39:20 over what we saw in 2011.

1:39:22 And so we're outpacing that as well.

1:39:27 This gives you an idea of the total number of permits that are issued all the way from

1:39:31 the total mechanical and plumbing permits moving forward.

1:39:37 Year to date revenues are significantly higher, about 45% higher than what we had experienced

1:39:44 the prior year.

1:39:46 That's really a good indicator for what we can see future new construction roles be as

1:39:53 we move forward and it is also a good indicator of where permits are as we move forward as

1:40:00 we talk about that budgeting process.

1:40:02 So building permits impact us two ways.

1:40:05 Number one, the direct revenues that we receive on an annual basis and then the second is how

1:40:10 it translates into increase in taxable value for our community in subsequent years.

1:40:14 But if you back out the new commercial related to Glamby and Chibani, it would be a very

1:40:19 different story would it not be?

1:40:20 So Chibani is not included in any of our numbers.

1:40:23 Okay.

1:40:24 Not Chibani were included.

1:40:26 And the reason we've made the conscious decision not to include that is because it is such an

1:40:31 outlier.

1:40:32 I mean, it's a $450 million commercial project that slightly skews some of the things that

1:40:40 are up there.

1:40:41 We do that often based in stone land.

1:40:43 We don't.

1:40:44 We're looking for some consistency.

1:40:45 I wish to add decimal points for attention.

1:40:52 The Glamby is though included, yes, and there will be additional commercial improvements

1:40:56 that we will see.

1:40:58 The Glamby project is significant for our community.

1:41:01 It makes a large statement downtown, but from a value perspective, it is probably similar

1:41:05 to what we would see other types of commercial properties moving forward as.

1:41:11 The total number of dollars collected you can see are about 18.4% up by comparison to where

1:41:18 we were in the prior year.

1:41:20 And remember, that is coming off the winter season, right?

1:41:24 And so that's typically when construction is a little bit slower, but yet at the same time,

1:41:29 it is, you know, good indication that things are beginning, that upward trend moving forward.

1:41:37 Unemployment is another key indicator.

1:41:40 One of the things that has changed after this recession is what is defined as statistically

1:41:45 full employment, and they've up that number from 4% pre-recession to 5% post-recession.

1:41:52 And you'll notice where we rank in the city of Twin Falls.

1:41:55 This is not our micro-pulten area.

1:41:57 This is not the county.

1:41:59 This is specifically the unemployment rate, according to the Idaho Department of Labor

1:42:02 for the city of Twin Falls.

1:42:04 It's the one that we track monthly on our dashboard.

1:42:07 It's the one that helps us understand whether or not our citizens are working to help us

1:42:13 their capacities to pay water bills and sewer bills and taxes, and so we track those who are directly our customers.

1:42:21 You'll notice that it is down from 7.3% last year in March down to 5.8, and it continues a downward trend each of the last few months.

1:42:32 You'll notice the state unemployment rate is about 6.2 with the national unemployment rate having recovered slightly,

1:42:39 significant but not to the same level of significance that we've enjoyed here in

1:42:43 Twin Falls. And full employment was considered five percent? That way you have

1:42:49 that in your recollection? We've been down as low as 1.7. It was

1:42:58 described to me that that was warm bodies. People employed that maybe shouldn't have been.

1:43:05 And you ought to think if that's all right.

1:43:07 Two to three percent of people that are working shouldn't be.

1:43:10 That's the way that it's been explained to me.

1:43:12 Which three percent?

1:43:14 That's up to you to judge.

1:43:19 So to kind of prime the pump, if you will,

1:43:24 there are a couple of things that I believe

1:43:26 that are important as we kind of move forward

1:43:28 and what this looks like.

1:43:29 And number one is to continue phase two

1:43:31 of the compensation strategy to make sure

1:43:34 that it is one of those things that we are staying vigilant

1:43:37 to moving forward.

1:43:39 You guys did such great work last year.

1:43:41 We overcame significant gaps.

1:43:46 And what I don't want to do is lose the ground and the momentum

1:43:50 that we move by saying and believing that we have arrived.

1:43:54 We can illustrate that there should probably

1:43:55 some salary and table movements that could still occur.

1:43:58 But I think it's also important to take a look

1:44:00 at the other side of that ledger,

1:44:03 to take a look at where our folks have longevity

1:44:06 in our organization, we provided a 2.5% adjustment

1:44:10 to those who were above the marketplace, right?

1:44:13 Those who have been long, 10-year,

1:44:14 generally with our organization.

1:44:17 And after the social security vacation was allowed

1:44:22 to expire, those same employees saw a 2% increase

1:44:26 in that tax.

1:44:27 So now that they were left with a half a percent increase,

1:44:30 difference comparison to where they were the prior year, right?

1:44:33 Percy has made their announcement

1:44:34 that other half percent is going to go to offset their costs.

1:44:39 And so coming in July, those employees

1:44:43 would essentially be having the same effective take-home

1:44:47 on the other side of the market because it had been used

1:44:50 for other purposes.

1:44:51 The good news is it's not going backwards.

1:44:55 The bad news is it doesn't really help us continue

1:44:59 to make sure that that long-term talent is

1:45:01 with us in the organization.

1:45:02 But again, great work last year.

1:45:05 I hope it is something that we can continue moving forward.

1:45:08 Have we thanked you, right?

1:45:12 Obviously, we've done really, really good work on a strategic plan.

1:45:18 We spent a year building that thing, and it is really something that we should be proud of.

1:45:23 Regardless of some of the comments and beliefs that have been stated,

1:45:28 this is the time to implement that strategic plan.

1:45:31 that the implementation occurs through the budgeting process, and now what we are going

1:45:38 to do is we are going to fund strategic planning objectives, and we have a window and a process

1:45:43 to do that, and we will track benchmarks through performance measurement. It's always been our

1:45:47 intent to do that, also through the budgetary process, and we look forward to doing that and

1:45:51 holding ourselves accountable for the results that we committed to making forward with our

1:45:55 partners.

1:45:56 The next is to continue investment into our capital improvement systems. We want to make

1:46:00 sure that we're not sliding backwards on capital. We want to make sure that we have those conversations

1:46:05 like we had a few years ago when it came to road construction. Are we funding our roads

1:46:09 appropriate to have a eight-year cycle? And from those conversations we recognized we weren't.

1:46:17 Well we have those same issues and problems with other types of infrastructure as well.

1:46:23 Water lines, sewer lines, and maybe a wastewater treatment plant if our citizens don't look favorably

1:46:30 upon our request for them to consider the $38 million bond.

1:46:36 You know, one of the things in addition to that is really our facilities, the facilities

1:46:43 that we operate in, making sure that we're going to continue to invest in those places

1:46:48 that we work out of, like continuing phase two of the Police Department expansion, continuing

1:46:55 what, or not expansion, but renovation project inside, looking at other assets that we have

1:47:00 to remodel to make sure that the working conditions

1:47:03 that we provide our employees are good, that they're safe,

1:47:07 and that they're ones that we can be proud of.

1:47:11 And then obviously, we need to continue to find ways

1:47:14 to strengthen those public-private partnerships,

1:47:16 to help spread those costs, to bring in those synergies,

1:47:19 to really get an army of people to help come in,

1:47:22 to move that forward.

1:47:23 Some of those things may include volunteer coordinators.

1:47:26 Some of those things, I think really that sky

1:47:29 is that limit when we have those conversations

1:47:32 and looking and moving forward,

1:47:33 but finding ways to strengthen that as we move forward.

1:47:37 Those are my thoughts.

1:47:38 That's where we stand.

1:47:40 I have 1% left on my iPad, so I'm happy about that.

1:47:43 I was watching that takedowns again.

1:47:47 I'm not gonna make it, but here we are.

1:47:49 It's impressive, actually.

1:47:50 Yeah.

1:47:51 Maybe I should do that more often

1:47:53 is what some of you are saying.

1:47:54 You can start with 10% and head it quick.

1:47:57 I actually kinda went over there and drained it

1:47:58 a little bit.

1:47:59 I did have one question.

1:48:02 Chris, sorry, I didn't see you.

1:48:04 We really did bite the bullet last year, the speaking of the Council on that, readjustment

1:48:09 of the comp schedule.

1:48:10 I think there's some inefficiencies that we really started to iron out.

1:48:14 Phase two, I would guess it's going to be our major surprise as far as discretionary income

1:48:21 that the Council uses to employ, to continue the thing, the correction.

1:48:28 I would think it'd be real helpful to the council

1:48:30 if we had as early of an indication as possible

1:48:34 of what some of those phase two figures

1:48:36 are going to amount to.

1:48:39 The way he's grabbing his papers,

1:48:41 I can see that he's probably a step ahead of him.

1:48:43 He tells when he's gonna tell us, I think.

1:48:46 We will be prepared to have that conversation, certainly.

1:48:53 One of the things that we look at is compensation

1:48:57 as we shared last year needs to be as important

1:49:01 and as high of a conversation that we have

1:49:04 when it comes to funding major capital initiatives

1:49:07 undertaken by the city.

1:49:09 We've stated that in our strategic plan.

1:49:11 And when we say that, I believe that they should be

1:49:13 on par with one another, that when we have those conversations

1:49:17 about personnel, we should do so in a vacuum,

1:49:20 but we also got to have that conversation

1:49:21 about what our operational costs, what do those look like,

1:49:26 what are the capital initiatives

1:49:27 that we really need to move forward with.

1:49:30 we will present that absolutely and it will be very early on in the in that process we

1:49:34 can make that commitment unless really you say differently if you tell us staff our number

1:49:42 one priority is blank really that's what that process is this is this is where we hope and

1:49:50 the issue so this is the very beginning we started this about two years ago and it was

1:49:55 an intentional effort to fully engage the council on the front end of that budgeting

1:50:00 process. And we wanted to make sure that you were actively involved, that you had the opportunity

1:50:07 not to feel like you were rubber stamping a document that was created by staff, but you

1:50:11 had the opportunity to be fully engaged in that process. And so really from your engagement,

1:50:17 the last slide that I showed was your thoughts. I wasn't certain what would happen to my iPad

1:50:22 if it went all the way to zero so I turned it off. But really this is your thoughts and

1:50:27 It may not occur tonight.

1:50:29 Maybe tonight is the bring in the information,

1:50:32 and then at the next meeting, really move forward.

1:50:34 And if we want to do it, additional times, that's great.

1:50:39 What I put up here was really what

1:50:43 those budget hurdles and those calendar events

1:50:47 looks like for us.

1:50:49 We will begin to have those conversations

1:50:52 with the city staff on May 21st, 22nd, 23rd.

1:50:58 We're also changing our internal budgeting process as well.

1:51:02 Again, you'll see lots of senior staff members smiling right now

1:51:05 because they're going to sit through the entire budgeting

1:51:07 process with me.

1:51:07 So they're really, they're really, no.

1:51:09 I see one and spill back, and he always smiles.

1:51:13 I think they're all really looking forward to that.

1:51:16 Because this is a management team,

1:51:18 and the idea of the management team

1:51:20 is to make sure that we are all hearing what the will of the council is moving forward the

1:51:25 implementation of the strategic plan and holding one another accountable for the performance

1:51:30 and meeting the expectations of the council.

1:51:33 So here's our calendar.

1:51:34 You'll notice that we on June, so on May 6th we will come back again and have another

1:51:47 conversation with the councilor next week.

1:51:50 On June 10th the council had requested to have a public input session about what the

1:51:54 budget looks like and on that same evening I will present what we've in the

1:51:59 past called the in progress budget which is to take the comments from this place

1:52:03 and then to take the comments that we have and the development of the budget

1:52:07 from the the staff internal budget hearings and then present where we're

1:52:15 at to say did we hear you right do we understand are we on the right path this

1:52:19 the direction moving forward appropriate and then we run into a whole series of presentations

1:52:27 on the budget piece by piece with ultimately the council having a public hearing on the

1:52:35 19th and adopting the 2000 budget on August 19th.

1:52:41 Donald, you know Travis I really like the calendar of advance I mean that really gives

1:52:50 me some comfort of exactly how this is going to roll out so I appreciate that one thing

1:52:57 that I because this is now a historic document that we might use to look at in the future

1:53:03 I'd probably add tonight to your calendar up there because this is your preliminary conversation

1:53:08 with council and it's up there I don't see April 29th on there it says April 30th

1:53:15 I want to fight Twin Falls County of public hearing that's not all a different thing.

1:53:19 No, we're not on there.

1:53:20 We're a week ahead.

1:53:22 So we have that starting on Monday, May 6th and if we run into a three week process, we'll absolutely do that.

1:53:28 Absolutely.

1:53:30 I just think it's again, I like this whole flow.

1:53:35 Schomburger.

1:53:36 I'm just a couple of things to some of Chris's comments.

1:53:39 I think the commitment to the employee needs last year, to me,

1:53:45 is a no-brainer that that needs to continue to move forward this year, because otherwise

1:53:49 it just sort of makes moot our commitment last year, because it's not a one-year program.

1:53:55 A couple of other items, the strategic plan.

1:53:59 So I think toward one of the last meetings, I had asked if we could get that as where we

1:54:05 could sort it by priority number.

1:54:11 Are you remembering that, Mike?

1:54:13 I'm not really sure.

1:54:14 So, Ellis, since it's in somewhat of a spreadsheet format, to be able to sort it by ongoing one,

1:54:21 two, three, so that you kind of get in our mind about what are the immediate focus areas.

1:54:29 And the last item is, while I appreciate that the state legislature agreed to cover the personal

1:54:37 property tax revenues that won't be coming in this year, I was just reading the draft

1:54:42 rules today, and it seems to be a rather convoluted process that they're establishing, and not that

1:54:50 we wouldn't get that money at some point, but I would like to know when we would anticipate

1:54:56 getting that money from the state for that offset, and I don't need an answer tonight.

1:55:00 Is that something I'd like to know?

1:55:02 Okay.

1:55:03 You know, if we're carrying that however many dollars it is for some period of time, we'll

1:55:11 do that.

1:55:12 Thanks.

1:55:13 Since several have, and then Rebecca will be next the phase two of the compensation is important to me.

1:55:20 Also, as much as we can increase the budget for maintaining our roadways, I think that's one of the things,

1:55:28 the theme that we all hear often.

1:55:31 We weren't hearing it rip the newspaper from people who don't even live here.

1:55:35 And I'm thinking, well, if you lived here, you'd help pay for it.

1:55:39 That was my response to him in my mind.

1:55:42 But mine was local option sales tax, but you know, I said that too, but I can't vote on that.

1:55:47 So I figured that I'd hold off.

1:55:50 But yeah, those two items are my list and I think I'm willing to provide as much revenue

1:55:57 as we can provide.

1:55:58 Yeah, I don't know about four guns, but I'm certainly about three percent time.

1:56:01 We're the only city in the world that even talks about it.

1:56:07 So, Rebecca.

1:56:08 Thank you, Mayor.

1:56:11 Just I couldn't agree more with your budget strategies, in fact I would add one from the

1:56:17 two previous years, which was to continue to pursue innovative strategies and find more

1:56:21 efficient outcomes, and we've had some great success in the past few years of rebitting contracts,

1:56:29 reassessing contracts, and I hope that we would do that in the coming years.

1:56:33 You know, any contract that has not been re-evaluated in the past three or four years, I hope that

1:56:39 staff first would take a look at it, maybe see some opportunities, and if necessary, and

1:56:45 if it's possible to do in-house that we would definitely read that for a couple of reasons,

1:56:50 one, to keep competition among the different providers in the city, and two, to reinforce

1:57:00 and to ensure the citizens that they're paying a competitive rate.

1:57:05 And so it's kind of difficult when you have contracts that are 30-year contracts or they

1:57:12 haven't been reassessed in our terms of office.

1:57:18 I think we should definitely look at that if it's possible in-house.

1:57:21 I know we've talked about certain specific contracts that would have to be overseen by

1:57:28 another entity at a great cost.

1:57:31 So I certainly want to add that.

1:57:35 I would support taking the statutory 3% and the growth and the annexation, but not the

1:57:43 foregone, just because I think that that 3% is for a reason so that it's doable.

1:57:50 You mentioned it being affordable to citizens, I think that's important, and it's great to

1:57:56 see that our unemployment numbers are down, but as you've said, there's still people struggling.

1:58:02 I think we need to remember that.

1:58:03 Also remember that one where adjusting rates

1:58:07 for water and wastewater,

1:58:09 especially in light of the upcoming bond election.

1:58:11 I think we need to be extremely sensitive

1:58:14 to that situation as far as what's affordable

1:58:18 for people to pay it and not always compare ourselves.

1:58:21 It's good to compare yourself to other cities

1:58:23 but if you compare yourself to a rate that is ridiculous

1:58:27 in another city, maybe it makes you feel better

1:58:30 but it doesn't necessarily mean that we are low

1:58:34 or staying where we need to be.

1:58:36 So maybe just keep that in consideration.

1:58:40 I did have a few strategic plan objectives to put forth,

1:58:44 but if up to the mayor's discretion,

1:58:47 if we're waiting for that conversation,

1:58:48 certainly look forward to that in the future.

1:58:51 Well, that's some travices about setting our agenda,

1:58:54 I think a little bit as far as when the strategic plan

1:58:57 objectives are coming forward.

1:58:58 We're just gonna throw our thoughts out,

1:58:59 So if we get a couple of lots of lights,

1:59:02 if you want to throw some of those out, Rebecca,

1:59:04 that's why.

1:59:05 Don Hall.

1:59:07 Tonight's just kind of preliminary information to us.

1:59:11 And so I want to get preliminary thoughts back to you, Travis.

1:59:14 And I really liked our full four goals last year.

1:59:19 So I'm going to go through those just really rapidly.

1:59:22 Limit tax increases to statutory minimums.

1:59:25 I agree with that.

1:59:26 The 3%.

1:59:27 I think that if we're going to be a progressive community,

1:59:30 that are going to be funding the needs of our community.

1:59:33 We need to be brave, courageous, and do that.

1:59:37 I am a little hesitant to talk about the foreground right now,

1:59:41 unless I see some reason that we need to take that.

1:59:45 I've always been a little bit prideful of our city

1:59:48 that we have a foregone.

1:59:50 When you go to other cities, they look at you like you have

1:59:52 three heads when you talk about foregone amounts.

1:59:54 So I'm proud of that.

1:59:57 And also, to me, it's almost like a piggy bank.

2:00:02 Keeping in mind, I understand that the legislature

2:00:05 could take it away from us tomorrow,

2:00:07 but I'm proud of that.

2:00:09 Fund a compensation strategy that brings all of our employees

2:00:13 closer, obviously that is a goal.

2:00:15 And I think the councils already stated that.

2:00:17 I really want us to continue our momentum there.

2:00:21 We owe it to our community, not just to our employees,

2:00:24 to our community because the way that we do our service to our community and provide that service

2:00:30 is by having well-trained, well-motivated employees and this helps us reach that goal.

2:00:37 Develop funding solutions to make improvements to our infrastructure. I mean infrastructure

2:00:42 we're talking about all the time. We're about to ask the community to help us with that as well

2:00:47 but I want to continue that momentum on the roads and the like you've covered that real well.

2:00:52 continue to pursue innovative strategies and find more efficient outcomes.

2:00:57 That should be our goal every year.

2:00:59 That's our calling.

2:01:00 We are spending the money from our citizens that give us this money.

2:01:06 We ask for it.

2:01:07 We tell them they have to give it to us, I guess, but they give it to us and so we need

2:01:11 to be very, very conscious of how we spend that.

2:01:13 And somewhere in there, obviously, we have this new strategic plan that we need to kind

2:01:18 of encapsulate within all four of those.

2:01:21 So I like the direction.

2:01:23 Just asking.

2:01:25 Well, I guess it's time for us to put our cards on the table.

2:01:27 My goodness, I just come early this year.

2:01:32 My bias, if it's going to be any help to you,

2:01:34 is I will be greatly influenced by the wastewater bond results.

2:01:40 Rebecca alluded to it.

2:01:42 It will temper my willingness to extend very far.

2:01:47 Just coming here, I have to tell you.

2:01:49 $6 a month for the average residential.

2:01:51 Doesn't sound like much $80 a year,

2:01:53 but it nonetheless will limit my range of stretch

2:01:59 on this coming year and there's one to be up straight.

2:02:02 Up forward with you.

2:02:03 That's why I've heard right from the 72 bucks a year.

2:02:06 Well, yeah, $6.57, yeah.

2:02:09 Okay, we'll go down to $70.

2:02:11 And for the record, it's $5.21 just for the 60 cents.

2:02:15 But that's governmental creep.

2:02:18 I just put a little factor in it.

2:02:21 And I'm pushing both my actor.

2:02:23 Hey, Joe.

2:02:24 We're back on my led one, Suzanne, talking to them,

2:02:27 you and their first chance, and then you go back, right, Suzanne?

2:02:31 Just weigh in real quick.

2:02:32 I agree with everybody else.

2:02:34 I think that it's a great starting place.

2:02:36 I appreciate all the work you put into the information.

2:02:39 I like to mull things over a little bit

2:02:41 and kind of think about it.

2:02:43 But I think this is some great information

2:02:45 to get us started in the right direction.

2:02:47 and I think staff's doing a good job getting us there.

2:02:50 Thank you.

2:02:51 Rebecca.

2:02:52 Thank you, Mayor.

2:02:54 I did have a few objectives that I wanted to point out.

2:02:58 And Council can reserve your thoughts, or think about it,

2:03:02 and we can talk about it in the future.

2:03:05 But one is the dog park.

2:03:07 And I think it should be a priority in the park's budget

2:03:12 for a couple of reasons, even over projects

2:03:15 that have been in line, so to speak, for many years.

2:03:19 One is because of the community interest

2:03:21 and objective, healthy community, 1.1f,

2:03:25 says that we'll develop a response to interest in dog parks

2:03:28 and community gardens.

2:03:30 Second reason is there's great interest in it.

2:03:34 They do have some startup funding.

2:03:36 So I would prioritize it as far as moving it forward

2:03:40 and making it functional.

2:03:42 It doesn't mean it needs to be fully built out.

2:03:45 kind of a few weeks ago you showed us the full cost.

2:03:49 And it doesn't have to be fully built out,

2:03:51 but it should be fully functional.

2:03:53 And I think that that's a priority.

2:03:54 It should be a priority because we do offer other parks.

2:03:59 We have toys at different parks.

2:04:01 We have walking trails at different parks.

2:04:03 We don't offer a dog park.

2:04:04 And if that's something our citizens want,

2:04:06 you talked about providing services

2:04:08 that are being requested.

2:04:10 I would ask that that would be a priority

2:04:13 as far as whatever funding you need to get it to a functional stage, I think that that

2:04:18 should be a priority.

2:04:21 The other thing I think is a small step that we can do in this year's budget to address strategic

2:04:28 plan objective AC which is accessible community 1.2c to sign bike pass and identify bike lanes

2:04:35 with striping on roads where appropriate.

2:04:38 And what's really great is right now, we have a group in the community of cyclists and a couple of members that have already drawn up some bike-friendly routes that are already in existence.

2:04:51 And so I would like to see us as a city provide kind of an educational map of bike-friendly routes that already exist.

2:05:00 And there are a few, I guess, kind of secrets of ways to connect the bike trail.

2:05:08 And I didn't know about them until psychotherapy and our group of cyclists took us on an educational

2:05:15 tour.

2:05:16 And I actually always thought I would always go to one end of the Canyon Rim trail and

2:05:24 kind of end, you know, from like the end of Washington and kind of end at Canyon Crescent.

2:05:29 And I really didn't think I could go further, so I would go back, or I would come from the

2:05:33 other side on Eastland, the curve of Eastland and Poline.

2:05:37 But anyway, there are group of cyclists that have these short cuts, and there are ways that

2:05:42 you can sign that trail or indicate whichever method is appropriate, either indicate with

2:05:48 striping on the roads or indicate with a uniform symbol that is either a bicycle or something

2:05:56 this as bike route, something identifiable, something that maybe has an arrow, an example

2:06:03 is when you come up Canyon Springs Road where it crosses Fillmore, you have a couple of options,

2:06:10 you think that the trail ends. And so what you might do is you might think to start taking

2:06:16 the sidewalk that goes along Breckenridge, and that ends abruptly. I think people are frustrated

2:06:20 and they don't use the trail system, they don't use their bikes because they don't know where

2:06:25 to go and how to connect the trails.

2:06:26 So anyway, I would like to see the city offer that,

2:06:30 and it would go a great length to address HC1.1A, which says,

2:06:36 develop a strategy for connecting a trail system.

2:06:39 And it's a small step in signing bicycle safety

2:06:44 and pedestrian safety, which is SC4.1E.

2:06:49 And there are just many objectives

2:06:51 that this would help address without having to go through

2:06:56 and build the trail ourselves.

2:06:59 You know, I think our Parks and Rec Director, Dennis Boyer,

2:07:04 estimated about a little over $1 million

2:07:07 if we were gonna connect the trails

2:07:09 by building the actual infrastructure.

2:07:12 But I think that in using our community members,

2:07:14 using these partners that we're talking about,

2:07:17 we can provide this brochure, we can provide it

2:07:20 at the chamber, at the visitor center,

2:07:22 and also in the welcome packet that I hope

2:07:25 that we can move forward RC1.2B,

2:07:29 develop a welcome packet for new residents

2:07:31 and utility customers.

2:07:32 I think that would be a great asset.

2:07:34 If you're really talking about encouraging people

2:07:36 to ride their bikes and be competent,

2:07:38 use alternate transportation.

2:07:41 We need to do our part in making it visible,

2:07:44 signing it, and making people aware of the trails.

2:07:46 And this is something I've learned in the past

2:07:49 a few months and so as I've gained this information,

2:07:52 I just think it would be beneficial for us

2:07:55 to provide it in uniform format to the citizens

2:07:59 so that they can do the same thing.

2:08:00 I think it would go a long way in addressing trail connectivity

2:08:04 and encouraging healthy lifestyles.

2:08:07 Thank you.

2:08:08 So you know the lights, Travis, I think that covers for tonight

2:08:13 and we'll look forward to additional chances

2:08:16 to speak to you about the budget

2:08:19 and hear more details about the budget.

2:08:21 And so I'll move on to their,

2:08:23 do you have any closing remarks?

2:08:25 Just so that people are aware,

2:08:28 we will have this conversation for sure on May 6th again.

2:08:33 And we may at the Council's discretion have it again

2:08:36 on the 13th, should that be the Council's goal

2:08:39 and wish after that we will work as a staff

2:08:42 and then present what we have developed

2:08:45 at the June 10th meeting.

2:08:48 I would also, since we have box 240-ish people watching online,

2:08:53 that should they have any thoughts,

2:08:55 I would encourage them to communicate those with you

2:08:58 or with us as staff, emails if they're on the website now,

2:09:03 right?

2:09:04 Emails just click away and they can start

2:09:08 lighting up our email inboxes with their thoughts

2:09:10 and how they'd like to see this move forward.

2:09:13 Okay.

2:09:16 Next item, do you have anything additional

2:09:18 Travis, others in the budget, let's you go first on that,

2:09:21 the last item on our, they do, all right.

2:09:25 Travis, continue.

2:09:28 Box of chocolates.

2:09:30 That's what I thought.

2:09:32 So this is actually, if I could have had Mike and Lori

2:09:38 higher enough, they don't know I'm doing this.

2:09:44 There's a reason why they all had to come, it wasn't that.

2:09:46 So we set out a very ambitious goal, and that was to make sure that what we were developing

2:10:01 in terms of a budget document was the highest of best practices, and that there is a group

2:10:08 called the Government Finance Officers Association that scores and rates budgets, and very few

2:10:15 in the state of Idaho have ever been able to achieve this, let alone do it in one year after

2:10:20 we've made that commitment to move forward.

2:10:23 And it really is the work of these three individuals

2:10:27 behind me that made this possible.

2:10:29 And so what I have here is the Distinguished Budget Award

2:10:33 Presentation to the City of Twin Falls

2:10:36 from the Government Officers Association.

2:10:39 And this is more than just a plaque that

2:10:43 will hang on the wall.

2:10:45 This really does enhance things like bond ratings.

2:10:49 It gives a level of assurance to those that what we are doing has been scrutinized by those

2:10:57 who are in the profession and that we do it right.

2:11:01 It is also one of those things, it's our badge of courage, if you will, that we will put for

2:11:06 the very first time in our history, at the very front cover of our budget stating that

2:11:12 what we have done follows the best practices of the organization.

2:11:17 So these three behind me really deserve the credit and the movement forward, also the department

2:11:22 leaders behind them who assisted in that effort.

2:11:27 This isn't possible without a team, and the team did a good job.

2:11:33 We may hear by asking you to speak with the phone.

2:11:43 Yes, speech.

2:11:48 no annotated audit statements, as I'm going to say.

2:11:53 Inclusion of the meeting, I have this to present to each one of you as well.

2:12:06 Tonight's Lake Council Award night, right?

2:12:09 Typically, you're the one that are handing out the awards, right?

2:12:12 Now it's our opportunity to really hand this out.

2:12:16 This comes to you on behalf of Zion's Bank and really the effort and the courage that the city council put forward

2:12:26 forward, as well as the members of the Urban Renewal Agency on the Chibani financing.

2:12:31 And what they did was they took what's called the Bonfire.

2:12:34 And the Bonfire to us may not be of significance, right?

2:12:40 But this is like the cover of Sports Illustrated for those professional athletes to put it in

2:12:47 perspective.

2:12:48 And the City of Twin Falls and their Chibani financing project is on the cover of the Bonfire.

2:12:57 And this is the first Idaho project ever to appear on the cover.

2:13:05 And so on behalf of Cameron Ariel and Zion's bank, who they wanted me to present this to

2:13:12 each one of you, really for your dedication and your courage in working through what I

2:13:19 think we would all believe a very interesting financial process.

2:13:25 And so with that, yeah, I congratulate you on this award.

2:13:30 So is this a national publication?

2:13:33 It is.

2:13:34 It is a first day out of New York City.

2:13:36 All right.

2:13:37 New York City.

2:13:41 We can all reach over and pat each other on this role.

2:13:45 Kind of a...

2:13:46 Good job.

2:13:48 There you go.

2:13:49 That's kind of neat.

2:13:51 One more thing.

2:14:01 The last thing I have is just a really quick reminder that we're going to have an executive

2:14:04 session at 3.30 on the 6th, so we will start and we will meet in here and then we'll immediately

2:14:11 go and adjourn into executive session. We will come out of executive session to begin

2:14:16 a regular scheduled meeting at five o'clock.

2:14:22 And you want to be one and they probably have something else they want to do, break

2:14:26 forward to the council tonight and they've waited patiently during this time to be able

2:14:30 to present it. So you know anyone on council have something that they would like to break

2:14:35 Thank you, Mayor, I just want to remind the public and everyone that this is the final week

2:14:43 of art and soul and one of the cool things that psychotherapy offered this past weekend

2:14:47 was an art tour by bicycle and that's really the way to see it is they're just far enough

2:14:53 apart that you don't want to get in and out of your car but I just experienced just half

2:14:59 probably or more of a third of the arts and so throughout this week I definitely want to

2:15:04 catch the rest of it, but I would encourage everyone to definitely get out and see it because

2:15:07 it is really phenomenal and it's so surprising to see how many of those artists are from

2:15:13 to and falls.

2:15:14 So it's a real privilege and I would encourage everyone to get out and see the art and also

2:15:19 vote before 2PM on Saturday because there's like $30,000 in prize money up for grabs.

2:15:26 So your vote counts.

2:15:28 So we always encourage people to vote.

2:15:30 So might as well encourage them to vote at Art and Soul.

2:15:33 Suzanne Huygens.

2:15:37 Two quick things.

2:15:38 First of all, on Thursday, it was a privilege to attend the dispatcher or communication specialist

2:15:43 lunch and, unfortunately, say goodbye to two of our city employees, but congratulate those

2:15:48 that are staying and doing a good job for us.

2:15:51 So I went to make sure they got a shout out on record.

2:15:54 And also, if you get a chance, drive by Harrison Park and see the four new trees that were planted

2:15:59 on Arbor Day and thanks to the Boys and Girls Club and a Meristar casino for their donations

2:16:06 and help in labor and time.

2:16:09 It was a fun day.

2:16:14 See you no one else.

2:16:17 We're adjourned.

2:16:29 And Chris, give me coffee, give me a few.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 29, 2013. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:16:37.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    714f3dbaa61227dcf38554e655102af314b792a6d3ae3ce6ab82c2169c9ee784
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a ffd2c10b6dd3d89af7f89ef2cf4ba2045e817c606aeaefdda04a860247853cb7
    part02.m4a 7ae323cfb6bd0bad51ef4910802a724b9450d0f27037baaa52181b77c2f9f94d
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    68e42118f4031931e4023e8f471d74647e3d3d2e315add241eb7f70afa62f46c

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file