Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-07-07, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-07-07/ [0:00:00] quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers. First item on the agenda is the Pledge [0:00:06] of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise. Thank you. Next on the agenda is our invocation [0:00:30] and we have Rabbi Tony Prater, Rabbi Tony, would you please come up? [0:00:35] Thank you for being here. [0:00:38] Turn it on. [0:00:41] There's the... [0:00:44] Okay. [0:00:46] Thank you for having me here, Mayor and City Council. [0:00:49] And since this is the inaugural one, we're kind of figuring it out as we go. [0:00:53] But thank you very much for letting me be here. [0:00:56] Baruchatah Adonai, Elohinu Melahalam, Asher Kedishanu, Bhumitzvotab, Bizivanu, [0:01:03] O'odlekneir, Shail Kihila, which means blessed are you, eternal our God, who [0:01:09] sanctified us with your commandments and commanded us to engage in community [0:01:12] matters. We gathered a day as residents of Twin Falls with the intention of [0:01:17] building a community we can all be proud to call home. May the discussions and [0:01:21] decisions tonight be guided by wisdom and understanding. Grant everyone the [0:01:26] ability to listen to one another with open hearts and minds and to work together for [0:01:30] the common good of all of the people of Twin Falls. May the decisions be a source of blessing [0:01:35] for all of those on this council and all of this council serves. [0:01:39] I mean. [0:01:40] Thank you. [0:01:41] Thank you Tony. [0:01:44] Okay. [0:01:45] Next on the agenda is the consent calendar. [0:01:49] Council wishes. [0:01:51] Move to approve. [0:01:52] Thank you. [0:01:53] Do I have a second? [0:01:54] Second. [0:01:55] Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written. [0:02:01] Rachel Rolkovo, please. [0:02:04] Ruth Pierce. [0:02:05] Yes. [0:02:06] Chris Reed. [0:02:07] Yes. [0:02:08] Craig Hawkins. [0:02:09] Yes. [0:02:10] Jason Brown. [0:02:11] Yes. [0:02:12] Spencer Cutler. [0:02:13] Yes. [0:02:14] Gary Lohmer. [0:02:15] Yes. [0:02:16] And Grayson Stone. [0:02:17] Yes. [0:02:18] Thank you. [0:02:19] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:02:20] So if you are here for the Magic Valley Kid Market, the pop-up pictures, moving night and [0:02:22] the inner court, all three events have been approved. [0:02:26] Okay, next under items of consideration is an action item. [0:02:32] Prove resolution 2025-01-1, a resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, [0:02:39] Idaho, rejecting all bids for the 2025 Grand View Odor Control Project and directing staff [0:02:47] to pursue obtaining bids through the open market. [0:02:50] We have our environmental manager, Nathan Erickson. [0:02:53] Welcome, Nathan. [0:02:54] Thank you, Mayor, Council. Appreciate your time tonight. [0:02:57] Yes, I'm here tonight to talk about our Otter Scrubber project. [0:03:02] I'll remind you that last year we did a trial, [0:03:05] and on the corner of Grandview and Federation, [0:03:08] we have been pursuing installing a permanent Otter Scrubber there. [0:03:13] We've been through the design with our engineer, [0:03:16] and then went through bidding, and the bidding, [0:03:19] we only received one bid back, [0:03:22] And it was for just over a million dollars. [0:03:26] It was substantially higher than we expected for the project. [0:03:31] We do still have just over half a million dollars left in the budget for this year. [0:03:36] And we may need more. [0:03:37] So just kind of trying to figure out how the project will ultimately cost. [0:03:43] But we do know that the million dollars is excessive to what we were expecting. [0:03:49] We do feel like there might have been an error in that bid, and so we're coming to tonight [0:03:54] to counsel to reject that bid and then allow us opportunity to go out on the output market [0:04:00] to find a more reasonable bid, and if there's any questions. [0:04:05] Thank you. [0:04:06] Excuse me. [0:04:07] Any questions for Nathan? [0:04:08] Sherry. [0:04:13] I'll make a motion if there's any questions. [0:04:17] Okay. [0:04:18] Go ahead. [0:04:19] Okay, I will move to approve resolution 2025-011, a resolution of the City Council of the City [0:04:30] of Twin Falls, Idaho rejecting all bids for the 2025 Grandview OA control project and [0:04:37] directing staff to pursue obtaining bids through the open market. [0:04:42] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:04:44] Thank you. [0:04:45] Motion by Sherri Vomer, seconded by Jason Brown to approve resolution 2025. [0:04:50] 5-0-1-1, a resolution of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, IDO, rejecting all [0:04:56] bids for the 2025 Grandview Odor Control Project and directing staff to pursue obtaining bids [0:05:03] through the open market. Any discussion? Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:05:09] And Sarah Cutler. Yes. [0:05:12] Sherry Ballmer. Yes. [0:05:13] Grayson Stone. Yes. [0:05:14] Jason Brown. Yes. [0:05:15] Ray Cockams. Yes. [0:05:16] First read. Yes. [0:05:17] And Ruth Pierce. Yes. [0:05:19] Thank you, Nathan, motion passes seven to zero. [0:05:24] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item. [0:05:28] Request to authorize the use of $1,234,820 [0:05:34] of cash reserves from the respect, [0:05:39] sorry, should have put my glasses on, [0:05:42] from the respective funds is needed [0:05:44] to fund the City of Twin Falls Health Plan Trust [0:05:47] and we have our city manager, Travis Rothfiler, welcome. [0:05:50] Thank you. Madam Mayor, members of the council, [0:05:52] so this is one of the first steps that will ask the council [0:05:55] to continue to go forward with as we look at becoming [0:05:59] a self-insured organization as it relates [0:06:02] to major medical health insurance. [0:06:05] As you will recall last year during the budget process, [0:06:09] we had conversations about moving that direction [0:06:11] and because of the time that it was taking [0:06:13] and the information that was needed, [0:06:16] We made the decision to slow down and submit our application for this year effective for [0:06:24] the next fiscal year and insight of the budget message we described. [0:06:28] The benefits of going that direction will spend, we'll talk about that tonight. [0:06:32] One of those primary steps is required by Idaho code is that we have to set up an independent [0:06:38] trust and that trust is going to be a separate legal entity. [0:06:43] It has its own tax identification number, it has its own Board of Directors, which is composed [0:06:48] of five members of the City's Executive Leadership Team, and it is required to follow all the [0:06:55] requirements set out and set forth by the Idaho Department of Insurance. [0:07:00] One of those requirements is described in code is to make sure that the trust has an [0:07:04] adequate balance to be able to cover and fund those insurance claims as they come forward. [0:07:11] So this is one of the first seedings that we would do. [0:07:15] We're asking to use cash reserves. [0:07:17] It will come from the major cash reserve funds, [0:07:21] and it is divided proportionally based upon where [0:07:24] the employees are housed. [0:07:25] And so the police officers, the firefighters, [0:07:28] the general government workers will all [0:07:31] come out of the general fund. [0:07:32] Those that are employed in the water department [0:07:35] will come out of the water fund, the sewer fund, the airport [0:07:38] for the airport funded, and so on. [0:07:39] So, this is just to move that step as required [0:07:44] as part of our insurance or application. [0:07:46] Our application has had one review. [0:07:49] There were some deficiencies in our application. [0:07:51] We didn't think that we would get it perfect. [0:07:53] And so we've already corrected and submitted information back [0:07:57] to the Department of Insurance for their review. [0:07:59] This is another one of those steps and processes. [0:08:02] I will share that we're asking for this [0:08:05] to be more of a enabling resolution. [0:08:08] And so that when it is approved, [0:08:11] we can immediately go forward and transfer those funds [0:08:14] into the trust bank account that has already been established. [0:08:17] We don't want to go through the process [0:08:19] of sending funds into a trust. [0:08:21] And then for some reason, have it not be approved, [0:08:24] have to go through the entire process of unfunding the trust. [0:08:26] And so it's a lot easier to have authorization [0:08:30] from the council, have it sit into a holding pattern, [0:08:33] have it launched into the trust once it is approved. [0:08:35] And we anticipate that will occur sometime [0:08:38] in the month of August. [0:08:40] With that, I'm happy to stand for any questions. [0:08:43] Thank you. [0:08:44] Any questions for Travis on this? [0:08:47] Yes, Mayor. [0:08:49] Spencer? [0:08:51] Double check, sorry to call you out in the meeting. [0:08:54] But noted, the letter to the Department of Insurance [0:08:59] was attached, and I did not see that in the packet. [0:09:03] We can forward it on to you. [0:09:07] The letter to the Department of Insurance [0:09:10] kind of talked about the different areas that we had to work for to make sure that [0:09:13] we're corrected. This was one of the items on that list. [0:09:17] That was good. Any other questions for Travis? Hey, Jason Brown. I'll make a [0:09:26] motion if we're ready. I think we're good. Yep. I'd move to authorize the use of [0:09:31] $1,234,820 of cash reserve from the respective funds as needed to fund the [0:09:40] City of Twin Falls Health Plan Trust. [0:09:43] Grayson Stone. [0:09:44] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:09:45] I'll second the motion. [0:09:46] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grayson Stone, [0:09:49] to authorize the use of $1,234,820 [0:09:54] of cash reserves from the respective funds [0:09:57] as needed to fund the City of Twin Falls Health Plan Trust. [0:10:01] Any further discussion? [0:10:05] Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:10:06] Chris Reed. [0:10:08] Yes. [0:10:08] Ray Hawkins. [0:10:09] Yes. [0:10:09] Jason Brown. [0:10:10] Yes. [0:10:11] Councillor Cutler. Yes. Yes. Sherry Fulmer. Yes. [0:10:14] Grayson Stone. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. [0:10:17] Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Travis. [0:10:21] Hey, next item on the agenda is a presentation. [0:10:25] A presentation of the city manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2526 [0:10:32] followed by citizen input. And we have Travis. Here I am. Here you are. [0:10:37] So my son and my wife are in Washington, D.C. [0:10:43] and they had this amazing opportunity to go and tour [0:10:49] all these different amazing Smithsonian museums today. [0:10:53] And when I talked to Jack this morning, he said, [0:10:55] I was so excited that I could barely sleep. [0:10:58] And I hope it was the exact same experience for you [0:11:00] as we're going through the budgeting process [0:11:02] that you are so excited that you could barely sleep last night [0:11:05] And I can tell curp your enthusiasm, please. [0:11:10] Here we are to go through the budget. [0:11:11] The audience is the same way. [0:11:13] Drop us. [0:11:13] I can tell. [0:11:17] And I appreciate the fact that everybody has to be here, [0:11:19] even the ones behind me. [0:11:22] Because as we kind of present this, [0:11:24] it is done in the spirit of being part of a team [0:11:28] and being part of the One City. [0:11:30] The budget book will be placed online tomorrow morning. [0:11:34] You should all have a copy of that. [0:11:36] The PowerPoint presentations will also be able, [0:11:39] will be placed online so citizens have information. [0:11:42] They can digest that. [0:11:45] For those that are watching at home, [0:11:49] they can reach out to us by phone or by email [0:11:52] as they have questions throughout the week [0:11:55] and the upcoming weeks. [0:11:57] And then I will also share not only now [0:11:59] but also towards the end as the council [0:12:01] always welcomed community conversation about the budget as we go through the [0:12:06] individual focus areas. We'll talk about those focus areas as we move forward. I'm [0:12:12] excited to say you've already received one request. I think that was all forwarded [0:12:16] to you by a member of our community talking about the need to improve the [0:12:22] surfacing as the services of some of the tennis courts. And so that that was [0:12:27] forwarded on to you and that will be part of one of the potential options that you [0:12:30] have to fund. But tonight what we're going to do is we're going to talk about the general overview of [0:12:35] the budget. And so what I'll share with you is the legal process of that, the legal process. [0:12:45] The legal process is going to run concurrent with our fiscal year, which is on October 1st [0:12:50] and runs through September 30th. The state calendar is slightly different than ours. We follow a federal [0:12:55] calendar. And these are all the different sections of the Idaho code that as it governs the budgeting [0:13:02] process, the allocation of resources. Idaho State Code sets out a series of [0:13:07] guidelines and opportunities as it relates to how we publish, how we [0:13:13] establish revenues, the maximum revenues that you can take, and also talks about [0:13:17] my job description. And one of those is to keep the council fully informed of the [0:13:22] financial conditions of the city and prepare and submit a budget to you. And so [0:13:26] this budget is done in accordance with Idaho Code, and it's not done just by me. [0:13:30] For those that are familiar with our process, it really starts at the beginning of each year. [0:13:37] Sean Berger and Matt Hicks led our organization through the long-term planning process this year. [0:13:44] So we have members of our team. Austin is with us. He is part of the long-term planning team. [0:13:50] He wanted to see this process through to completion. And so I know one person is here voluntarily and excited to be here tonight. [0:13:59] But really, this is a team effort, and it is really built through the eyes of, in the hands of many. [0:14:07] If this budget were built through just the lenses in which I see the city, it would be incomplete. [0:14:12] Because my knowledge of all of the needs across the organization is just based upon my knowledge. [0:14:18] And individuals have far greater expertise in certain areas. [0:14:22] So our budget is built by engaging our citizens. [0:14:29] We took a look at the citizen survey and we look at that citizen survey to say, how are we doing? [0:14:35] You know one of the great questions is in local government our citizens are in a sense captive, right? [0:14:41] We are the provider of local government services, but if we were to receive a Google review [0:14:46] How would we score? [0:14:48] And I think that's a different mindset than what most governments take a look at is because how we perform the ways in which we perform [0:14:56] form need to be well understood. [0:14:59] That doesn't mean we say yes. [0:15:01] In fact, there's a lot of things that we have to say no to, [0:15:03] and there's a lot of guiding principles and laws [0:15:06] and reasons for that. [0:15:07] But every single day, what we want to do [0:15:09] is we want to make sure that our citizens, if they [0:15:12] had a choice, would choose us. [0:15:15] And so we strive to reach their expectations. [0:15:18] The overall confidence and the quality of life [0:15:21] were not numbers and scores that I [0:15:22] had hoped to see probably far greater than what most government [0:15:26] entities are getting right now. In fact, we know this is far greater than what the federal [0:15:29] government received. But yet, when you are striving to be the best, we want to take a look at even [0:15:36] positive marks with a critical eye. And so, while, you know, more than 73% of the citizens [0:15:44] say that Twin Falls is either good or an excellent place with quality of life, we want to continue [0:15:49] to do what we can to move that needle. We take a look at economic indicators and we'll share [0:15:55] some of those that went into the formation of this budget. We take a look at labor, we [0:16:00] take a look at housing, the cost of doing business, and the things that are influencing [0:16:05] our processes. We engage our employees. That's part of that long-term planning process and [0:16:11] we've been doing this for years. They connect the strategic plan and the budget, and as we [0:16:17] had shared that strategic plan we had hoped would have been updated by now. But as we've [0:16:24] We've gone through Title 10, as we've gone through all some of the other heavy lift. [0:16:29] We decided not to lengthen you to having four hour meetings, and so we pulled that back little [0:16:34] and we're still continuing to do the background work with our consultants, and we'll engage [0:16:39] with the council and the community in the month of August. [0:16:47] We build a budget around consensus. [0:16:50] So not only part of the long-term planning team, but the executive management team, we [0:16:55] meet in here. [0:16:57] And this year was a bit unique. [0:16:59] The meeting was short, and we'll kind of go through some of that. [0:17:03] But we talk about those things that we want to eliminate or those things that we can do [0:17:09] without to ensure that the budget that we present is sustainable, that it is tolerable [0:17:15] in the eyes of our rate payers, [0:17:17] and it meets the most important needs of the organization. [0:17:22] And in that process, we're hoping to transform our government, [0:17:24] where we believe in our leadership philosophy [0:17:28] and how we conduct ourselves as based upon the values [0:17:31] of the city of Twin Falls. [0:17:35] And this is really a credit to our team, [0:17:38] where for the 13th year in a row, [0:17:41] we're one of very few organizations [0:17:43] that wins the Distinguished Budget Award [0:17:45] and the certificate of achievement [0:17:47] for excellence in financial reporting. [0:17:51] These aren't awards that we compete for just to win awards. [0:17:54] These are symbols of the work that goes [0:17:59] into the document and our processes. [0:18:04] They're reviewed by our peers and our peers say [0:18:07] that these are, our efforts are distinguishable. [0:18:13] That's how we form it. [0:18:15] And then when we take a look at it, [0:18:16] what I think is really important is that we start looking at the community through the [0:18:22] same set of lenses, because as I shared, when I look at the City of Twin Falls and how someone [0:18:27] else may look at the City of Twin Falls could be incredibly different. But if we can level [0:18:32] set by agreeing on the same statistics, that allows us to understand what some of those [0:18:38] needs may be. And so the City of Twin Falls has grown by about 9.72% over the course of [0:18:46] the last five years. And if you continue that rate of growth moving forward, the City of [0:18:52] Twin Falls will be nearly 65,000 people by the year 2030. I remember when I started, we [0:19:03] questioned when the City of Twin Falls would reach 50. And now we're thinking 65, but as [0:19:13] you know, the 65,000 of Twin Falls is not necessarily the biggest concern that I have. [0:19:21] Part of that larger concern is the 40,000 vehicles that come across the prime bridge every single [0:19:27] day and the vehicles that come in from Quyler, from Kimberley, from other places to the south, [0:19:34] where our daytime population will grow in excess of 116,000. [0:19:41] And we measure that by the number of cars that are coming into the city every single day. [0:19:46] And whether we're looking at that through our flock camera system, or we're looking at that [0:19:51] through I-TD counters, every single counter that we look at shows that the city of Twin [0:19:56] Falls more than doubles. [0:19:58] And then if you say, well, they're just passing through, well, that's an impact on our roadways [0:20:04] and our roadway system. [0:20:05] But if you take a look at the total number of retail sales inside of Twin Falls City, there [0:20:11] were $2.1 billion retail transactions according to the US Census Bureau in 2022. And the per [0:20:20] capita spend was $38,320. That's pretty impressive. In fact, that's so impressive. It's twice [0:20:30] the state average. It's twice the national average and it's nearly $7,000 more than the [0:20:40] per capita income. So I want that to register just for a minute where our per capita income [0:20:47] is $7,000 less than our per capita retail sales. And so there's two things, right? I've shared [0:20:53] with you, we either have amazing financial problems to a person in our community, or there's [0:21:00] some external influences impacting that. And if you subscribe to the City of Twin Falls [0:21:05] doubles every day, and you cut that number in half, we now fall in line with both the state [0:21:12] in the national average in retail sales per capita, [0:21:17] at right around $16,000 to $18,000. [0:21:23] The median home price in the city of Twin Falls [0:21:26] has grown by 63% since the year 2020, 63%. [0:21:34] I want you to think about some of your investments [0:21:36] and some of your portfolios and ask yourself, [0:21:38] has that asset growing at that same rate? [0:21:42] And we're still much more affordable [0:21:44] than the state of Idaho median average. [0:21:47] which is almost $110,000, $105,000 more than ours. [0:21:53] And both are still low in comparison to their all-time highs. [0:21:57] In addition to that, the city of Twin Falls' unemployment rate [0:22:01] is at 3.4%, which equates to 973 people unemployed. [0:22:05] It's lower than the state of Idaho and the national average. [0:22:10] The housing prices are going up. [0:22:13] Median income is not rising as fast. [0:22:17] There's an outside influence impacting our ability to deliver services uniformly and equally to [0:22:24] every person who comes into our community and we're going to continue to grow. So when we think [0:22:32] about the budget and we think about moving forward, those are the factors that we put in place. [0:22:41] Everybody wants to know the end of the book. So we'll share with you what is the impact of this [0:22:46] And honestly, what we do is we use a median person, that person that doesn't exist, the [0:22:55] person that consumes 18,000 gallons of water, capped at 12,000 gallons of sewer, as sanitation [0:23:02] and recycling, and has a median valued house inside the city. [0:23:08] And overall, we're projecting that the total impact to that person is going to be about [0:23:12] $9.05 per month if that person truly exists. [0:23:17] Now what I will also share is that if you were to run [0:23:20] the Rothweiler family through this same calculation, [0:23:24] it's a dollar, where the value of my home in this last year [0:23:30] according to the accessor has actually decreased, [0:23:34] where I'm nowhere near 18,000 gallons of water. [0:23:41] And so when you take a look at that median, [0:23:45] what we encourage every citizen to do is to take this information and translate it to [0:23:52] their own personal experience, not towards this is what's going to happen to everybody. [0:23:59] Because what happens to our individual taxes is really directly dependent upon the value [0:24:05] of the property in which you own, and the property if it qualifies for a homeowner's exemption, [0:24:10] which means that it's owner-occupied. [0:24:12] So those are some of the various statistics that we're taking a look at. [0:24:17] Any questions? [0:24:18] Okay. [0:24:22] All right. [0:24:23] We'll keep going. [0:24:26] So in January of every year, the county assessor goes through and they say, what is the market [0:24:32] value of your home to create a assessment for taxes? [0:24:37] And state code provides our assessor guidelines in a window in which that property value must [0:24:44] fall. [0:24:45] Since the property taxes are based upon your value [0:24:49] on or near January 1st of each year, [0:24:52] I've shown the value and the increase of the home [0:24:57] in that period of time. [0:24:59] So you can see that the value, the median value of a home [0:25:02] from January of 24 to January of 25 grew by $10,500. [0:25:12] And what we can expect is that slow trend, [0:25:15] where it shows Twin Falls, it shows Idaho, [0:25:19] and it shows the Boise market. [0:25:21] And below that also reflects [0:25:24] what the 12 month projected price increase is [0:25:27] for all of those homes. [0:25:29] So you can see that Boise right now [0:25:31] has crusted over a half a million dollars [0:25:34] as a median value home, [0:25:36] and their projected increase over the course [0:25:38] of the next 12 months is about 1.2%. [0:25:41] Where the city of Twin Falls is 367,000, [0:25:45] and have a projected increase of about 2.3%. [0:25:49] And we are in line with the national average [0:25:53] for median home value. [0:26:00] But I think that only tells part of the cost [0:26:03] because one of the things that we shared last year with you [0:26:06] was the home buyer index. [0:26:08] It's a matrix that was developed to illustrate [0:26:13] not only the median price of a home, [0:26:16] but also the external impact such as [0:26:19] what is the median wage, and what is that wage that's needed [0:26:24] to be able to qualify, and what is that gap in that disparity? [0:26:30] And in Twin Falls, and in Twin Falls County specifically, [0:26:34] were the third worst out of 25 surveyed counties [0:26:39] in the state of Idaho when you begin to compare [0:26:41] and contrast median income with median home value. [0:26:46] And we were 117th out of 1310 counties surveyed [0:26:53] across the entire country. [0:26:56] Where they create this difficulty index, [0:27:00] and the difficulty to secure financing for a home [0:27:05] is at 84.3, is the number that they gave us. [0:27:11] Where competition at 90.8 remains strong, [0:27:15] where scarcity is probably in line, but economic instability was one of the major concerns that [0:27:25] our citizens had, and that is largely driven, not necessarily by the local economy, but what [0:27:31] is occurring at the federal level as it relates to interest rates. [0:27:34] I thought that this was really, really interesting as interest rates are still around that 6.86% [0:27:42] is happening in someone like me who has explored maybe a new home a couple of [0:27:49] different times, starts working the pencil. And when you're sitting at just [0:27:57] below a two percent interest rate, you recognize the cost of money and how I'm [0:28:05] willing to enjoy the home that I have in comparison to buying a new home at that [0:28:14] cost and so individuals that I speak to there still are significant cash [0:28:19] deals that are occurring, there are still loans that are occurring and we believe [0:28:25] that should the Fed drop or lower the interest rate that you'll start seeing [0:28:31] potentially more movement which could increase competition. The median [0:28:41] cost index is the measurement that we use. It is a 20-point [0:28:47] over the four-year period. We measure everything from March to March and then [0:28:56] also the consumer price index is now hovering around 2.4%. So it is [0:29:01] trending in the right direction but what's important to recognize is it's still [0:29:07] higher than the Fed's 2% rate that they strive to achieve and we are still [0:29:14] working on price volatility and you take a look at the cost and we'll have [0:29:19] some conversations about cost and equipment and what are tariffs or the [0:29:23] threat of tariffs or the discussion of tariffs doing to some of the vehicles [0:29:27] that we're going to be wanting to acquire. Unemployment is part of the picture but [0:29:35] our true worker shortage is another piece of that where there for every [0:29:41] 300 positions, we lack 25 bodies of qualified workers to fill them. [0:29:48] And so while our unemployment rate is generally at full employment, you can see that we've [0:29:58] added 53 laborers in a window of time. [0:30:04] And if this information correlates back to what the Secretary of State has shared of individuals [0:30:13] that are choosing to move into Idaho. They tend to be rich, they tend to be [0:30:22] retired, and they tend to be Republican. And we're starting to fit that trend as [0:30:31] more people are moving into our community. They may be porting their job [0:30:36] with them, or they're able to work remotely, or they have retired, and they [0:30:42] have chosen this is their place that they want to live. Labor is going to be [0:30:48] something that is going to be important and you can see that when it comes to [0:30:54] labor participation the market is still strong but we don't have enough workers to [0:31:00] be able to fill all the positions that we have and that it still is below [0:31:06] pre-pandemic levels. So attracting individuals, attracting not only companies [0:31:14] as it relates to economic development, but making sure that we have the [0:31:17] labors to fill those roles is increasingly important. So those are the [0:31:24] economic figures that we use when we're establishing the budget. Are there any [0:31:29] questions that you have? Is there anything different than what you've seen in [0:31:38] in your own search, right? [0:31:48] So we're looking through the community [0:31:50] with the exact same set of lenses. [0:31:52] We have the data that is before us to help guide [0:31:56] the conversations as we move forward. [0:31:59] Because one of the things that we wanna do [0:32:00] is we wanna make sure that we are following [0:32:02] these overarching strategies. [0:32:05] We continue to want to create a document that is nimble, [0:32:08] that is able to respond to opportunities [0:32:12] and unforeseen challenges. [0:32:14] But we also want a budget that is going to be strategically [0:32:18] sound and is going to be sustainable. [0:32:22] We want to create a budget that is affordable. [0:32:25] No one likes to pay property taxes. [0:32:27] I don't like to pay property taxes. [0:32:29] But we recognize that property taxes [0:32:32] is what helps cover the services that we offer. [0:32:37] And one of the things, if our population doubles daily, [0:32:42] the example that I like to share, [0:32:43] that if I were a private business and my only half of my customers were paying for my service, [0:32:51] there are really two options. Option number one is that I go out of business. I've created [0:32:57] a non-sustainable business model where I'm giving my products and services for free to [0:33:01] every second customer. Or the second is I have to assess a higher rate to those paying customers. [0:33:08] And unfortunately because of the tools that we have in the state of Idaho, the ladder is [0:33:12] is true for us. [0:33:14] And I will make my plug, again, that if we had the opportunity [0:33:18] for a local option sales tax, it would benefit the city [0:33:21] of Twin Falls immensely. [0:33:23] Just based upon our numbers, I believe that we could provide [0:33:26] $11 million of property tax relief annually. [0:33:31] And as I will share with you, $11 million of property tax [0:33:37] relief translates into true sustainable properties [0:33:41] actually with an additional $11 million to be able to go support those services that are [0:33:45] impacted directly by growth. We want to tie everything to the strategic plan and I believe [0:33:52] that the long-term planning team did a great job at that. We want to continue to be the employer of [0:33:58] choice because in a tight labor market retention is the best tool that we have and so we're going [0:34:06] to spend a lot of time in this year's budget talking about our employees. The movement to self-insurance [0:34:12] is part of that. Gretchen has been a strong advocate for moving this direction for years [0:34:19] and over the course of the last 12 to 18 months, it has finally penciled and so we are seizing [0:34:26] that opportunity. We're asking the council to consider taking the statutory allowed increases [0:34:33] and that internally we've gone forward to minimize utility rate increases to the degree [0:34:39] that we can, making sure that we can still offer [0:34:41] the level of services, but yet also we're meeting [0:34:44] bond covenances in those places in which we have debt. [0:34:50] So this is a side-by-side comparison of a lot. [0:34:55] The first is the total value of the community [0:34:57] you can see has gone up by $229 million. [0:35:02] The total budget this year is $7.2 million [0:35:06] less than last years. [0:35:09] Our tax spending is down $11 million, [0:35:13] but our non-tax spending is up by 3 million. [0:35:19] Non-tax spending is water sewer sanitation. [0:35:26] But the primary driver here is impact fees, [0:35:28] where we collect impact fees and we bank those over time [0:35:33] and then we apply cash reserves to fund projects [0:35:38] that are part of the impact fee plant. [0:35:41] So the most significant portion here [0:35:43] is the use of cash reserves, [0:35:45] not the increase of utility rates as reflected. [0:35:49] We're looking at a zero percent increase for water, [0:35:51] which is tending to be the trend. [0:35:53] I think five of the last six years, [0:35:56] we have not had to increase the water rates. [0:35:58] We did last year at two and a half percent. [0:36:00] And when you think about the consumer price index [0:36:02] growing by 20%, that's pretty significant work [0:36:06] members of our public works team to find and continue to find efficiencies. [0:36:12] The sewer rate increase is a result of trying to continue to meet bond covenants, looking [0:36:18] at revenues that continue to fall a bit as our industrial partners become more efficient [0:36:23] in their operations, but also recognizing that we have some very large projects coming up. [0:36:28] We want to make sure that we have the resources to be able to fund those, and then a two and [0:36:33] have percent increase for sanitation and recycling this year. After the budget [0:36:40] process we're going to be coming to the Council presenting to you a RFP that we [0:36:48] intend to release for new sanitation services. The contract that we have with [0:36:56] PSI is set to expire on December 31st of 2026 and we would like to make an [0:37:04] announcement of the winning vendor with the help of the council through a [0:37:09] competitive process by January 1st of 2026 so that if there is a change and that [0:37:15] PSI is not selected to be the provider that we have enough [0:37:19] give we've given enough time to the winning person to be able to fully [0:37:24] capitalize because garbage trucks and 17,000 containers is probably not [0:37:31] something that they can just go buy off the shelf. So when we compare total taxable [0:37:37] value of the city over time, this is how that chart has grown and you can see [0:37:43] that it continues to grow. $83 million this year of our total growth is a result [0:37:51] of new construction. And you can see that $125 million of that comes from the [0:37:59] reassessment of properties as dictated by the assessor. The total taxable value of [0:38:04] $6.4 billion does not include the $628 million of urban renewal. So if you look [0:38:11] at the entire value of the properties within the corporate boundaries of the [0:38:14] city of Twin Falls, we have now crested over $7 billion. That does not include [0:38:24] the Chabani expansion. It will not fall onto the tax rules until it's occupied. So [0:38:31] we can expect our community, the urban renewal agency, that continue to grow in [0:38:38] value based upon the economic development efforts that we've had. This is a [0:38:43] reflection of the tax rate and you can see that since about 2023 it has been [0:38:47] incredibly consistent falling right within about 30 cents and we've made [0:38:56] considerable headway since 2020 was we've been continuing to be very mindful of [0:39:02] what that looks like. One of the questions we often get asked is what is [0:39:09] our tax rate and how does it compare to others and just reflecting on a tax [0:39:12] rate isn't the complete picture because the tax rate is just a simple [0:39:18] multiplier. It was property tax process is very, very easy. This reflects what is the multiplier [0:39:24] versus the median home value. And so we used a consistent source for all the median home [0:39:30] values. We used the associated tax payers levy book to establish the tax rate. We took the tax [0:39:36] rate. We assumed that all of these homes were owner occupied and then we applied what is the [0:39:45] individual city taxes paid. And you can see of all the major cities there, the City of Twin Falls [0:39:51] is the lowest tax rate, or excuse me, tax burden inside of the City of Twin Falls, [0:39:58] and $1,141 per median home value. Now you're all thinking, you pay more in property taxes than $1,100. [0:40:08] Say I know. I only, and we only, have the opportunity to control what occurs inside the City of Twin Falls. [0:40:15] And all of your tax bills reflect all of the other taxing entities, whether it be the College of Southern Idaho, or the County, or the Highway District, or the Weed and Mosquito District, or the abatement, whatever that is, that entire collection of property taxes. [0:40:36] We only have the impact to control what the site of the city is. [0:40:39] The city's portion of the median home is less than all of the other cities inside of the [0:40:45] state of Idaho. [0:40:46] And a good comparison is the city of Corda Lane's taxes, right? [0:40:55] You can see are slightly less than the city of Twin Falls's or excuse me, a dollar or more, [0:41:04] the right in the same ballpark, but it's tax rate is half and it's because it's being [0:41:08] multiplied against a much higher value median. [0:41:13] So when individuals look solely at a tax rate, they're not looking at the complete picture. [0:41:18] And so we'll be working to put up our tax calculator. [0:41:22] I'll work with Josh to put that up so that as individuals got their individual assessments, [0:41:26] they will be able to walk through to determine what their property taxes are this year compared [0:41:30] to last week. [0:41:33] We believe that the more information that we can provide, maybe the fewer assumptions [0:41:39] will be made about the budget and the process. [0:41:48] So here is the breakdown of the entirety of the budget. [0:41:52] This is a graphical illustration of what we had shown a little bit earlier. [0:41:56] But we have the government funds which are largely supported by some form of property taxes. [0:42:01] We have the enterprise funds which we treat as each individual business account and we [0:42:05] have other funds which is also going to be non-tax supported and transfers. So you [0:42:10] can see the total budget is broke down into those three categories and then we [0:42:16] take that budget and we say of the $95 million dollars how are we spending the [0:42:22] money in which 42.8% goes to personnel costs 23.1 of the entire budget goes to [0:42:29] operation and maintenance 25% goes to capital small portion goes to debt [0:42:35] service and 5.5 goes to transfers. Transfers are the rents that each individual company inside [0:42:42] of our larger collaboration will pay for professional services. So the Water Fund doesn't have an [0:42:48] attorney, but they assist in providing city attorney fees through a transfer. They don't [0:42:54] have a human resource department, so they pay rents on the different services that are paid [0:43:02] for out of property taxes. [0:43:05] So in the general fund, which is largely funded [0:43:08] by property taxes, you can see that revenue collected, [0:43:12] it's about 68.2% of the nearly $60 million [0:43:18] goes to fund general fund. [0:43:21] General fund is going to be those police and fire [0:43:25] in general government services departments. [0:43:27] We have the street fund, we have the airport fund, [0:43:30] and we also isolate capital. [0:43:37] On the other side, you can see that 55% of the tax-supported funds or government funds [0:43:45] is paid for by property taxes, but that doesn't mean that 55% of the budget comes from property [0:43:51] taxes, just one element of it. [0:43:54] So if you take a look at the $30 million against a $95 million budget, about a third of the [0:44:03] entire budget comes in the form of property taxes. [0:44:06] So just think, if we could cut property taxes by $11 million, how much better that would [0:44:12] all sit with us? [0:44:16] Here is the picture of the City of Twin Falls as we've continued to grow. [0:44:20] This year's new construction and annexation will equate to $418,000 of new property tax [0:44:30] revenue. [0:44:32] And what the growth, what those values are over time, are reflected there. [0:44:38] The big gold spike here is the new construction that we received when we closed out the urban [0:44:44] renewal agency. [0:44:46] We are able to classify that as new construction and we're able to take 80% of that taxable [0:44:53] value, 20% goes automatically into property tax relief. [0:44:57] new annexation and new construction and annexation, we're able to take 90% of that value. [0:45:08] Building permit revenue continues to exceed expectations. [0:45:12] So far through half through May, we've collected $1.2 million and you can see in just building [0:45:19] permit funds, we had asked to collect about $900,000. [0:45:23] We've had some significant one-time capital projects, but we've had significant one-time [0:45:29] capital projects for the last several years. [0:45:32] The team was able to convince me to increase it by $100,000 this year. [0:45:37] One of the things that we don't want to do is we don't want to chase revenue projections. [0:45:43] We never know if the economy is going to soften considerably, where if we over-inflate [0:45:50] building permit revenues into the long-term future, [0:45:53] then we will have to make systematic reductions, [0:45:57] and we have the opportunity to create an unstable budget. [0:46:02] So those are largely the tax-supported funds. [0:46:05] Are there any questions? [0:46:15] This is going back a few slides. [0:46:17] Hey, you tell me when to stop. [0:46:19] Slide 17, but you don't need, [0:46:21] you might just note this off the top of your head, [0:46:23] it'd perfectly fine. [0:46:25] You were talking about foregone balance, [0:46:28] And I remember years ago when we were talking about [0:46:30] lovely forgorn balance and some rules have changed. [0:46:33] How much do we have left in a forgorn balance? [0:46:41] There's about 470 million numbers in this budget. [0:46:45] There, yeah. [0:46:48] So on page 27 of the city manager's budget message, [0:46:52] this budget asks that you take the equivalence of 1%, [0:46:57] which translates into 324,968 dollars. [0:47:02] And if you follow that recommendation, the foregone balance will be $598,326. [0:47:10] I just remember we talked about that years ago quite often and how much is still left. [0:47:22] One of the things to remember is that the opportunity to collect that foregone balance [0:47:27] taxes that you could have otherwise imposed in the past [0:47:31] that you elected not to, which translates into a savings [0:47:35] to the individual taxpayers over that window of time, [0:47:40] could go away at any time with legislative action. [0:47:44] And because of how our budgets are set, [0:47:48] it is highly likely that the legislature [0:47:50] would invoke an emergency clause. [0:47:53] And so there would be no opportunity to forecast [0:47:56] when they were going to take it away, [0:47:58] and have an opportunity to collect that. [0:48:03] A large piece of the foregone balance that we've collected [0:48:06] has gone to create the council capital, [0:48:08] and we'll talk about that under responsible community, [0:48:11] and we'll share about some of the opportunities [0:48:12] that you might have as I get a little bit later [0:48:14] in the presentation. [0:48:16] Thank you. [0:48:21] Enterprise funds. [0:48:23] So these are the funds that we treat like a small business. [0:48:28] So each one of these is self-contained, [0:48:30] each one of these are supported by the fees that they generate. [0:48:34] And so the water fund, the waste water fund, and sanitation fund [0:48:38] are the largest funds that we tend to focus on. [0:48:41] The impact fee is one of the drivers this year, [0:48:44] where 100% of the impact fee funds is derived [0:48:49] through an impact fee that is assessed at the time [0:48:52] in which building permits are issued. [0:48:55] Water users, A, into the water company. [0:49:00] If you are not on the city's water system, [0:49:03] you don't pay a water bill. [0:49:06] Sewer fund the same way, sanitation the same way. [0:49:11] So you can see what those increases are [0:49:15] in terms of total expenditures, [0:49:18] total expenditures in the water fund this year [0:49:20] are going to increase by 1.17%. [0:49:24] We're looking at having a significant increase [0:49:27] in the sewer fund. [0:49:30] But the largest piece of that is $4.8 million of cash reserves [0:49:35] that we're applying to one-time projects. [0:49:37] We're going to collect about $11.5 million in user fees, [0:49:42] and we're going to apply $4.8 million of cash reserves [0:49:46] to be able to complete significant projects. [0:49:49] If the city didn't have the financial position that it had, [0:49:52] those projects don't go away. [0:49:54] Those projects would still have to be completed, [0:49:56] but we would be asking for an additional $4.8 million [0:50:00] from our residents to cover those costs. [0:50:03] And then inside of the sanitation fund, [0:50:06] you'll see that in combination with reserves, [0:50:10] we're looking at about a 3.38% increase for that. [0:50:27] Talked about one of the largest pieces is our employees. [0:50:31] And you can see that in focus area eight [0:50:35] is the center of our organization. [0:50:37] And they said we're going to spend a lot of time talking about our employees. [0:50:42] Public services do not happen without gifted and talented employees that are members of [0:50:46] our team. [0:50:47] And so in an effort to try to be the employer of choice, we're asking for a 4% performance [0:50:53] adjustment, a 3% table move. [0:50:57] Remember as part of our compensation system, it's not 4 plus 3 equals 7 in terms of compensation. [0:51:04] The table move happens independently of the performance adjustment, not every employee [0:51:09] benefits from the table adjustment. [0:51:13] We have a $900 employee Viva contribution. [0:51:17] We're asking for a $1,000 continued HSA contribution for health insurance, funding to maintain health [0:51:23] insurance by the movement to self-insurance, all of our insurance premiums, not only for [0:51:31] the employer but also for the employer are flat. And continuing of our retention pay agreement. [0:51:37] So as those employees hit those five year anniversary marks, we asked for three additional [0:51:43] years and we will compensate them in advance. Should they leave us before that through your [0:51:50] period, they have an agreement to pay that back at 100%. It is not prorated. So our full [0:51:58] time equivalents inside of our budget will grow to 354 employees as opposed to the 351 [0:52:07] that was contemplated in last year's budget. And if you did the math, you can have this [0:52:12] up and say, well, Travis, that's six and how come it doesn't grow by six? The 351 included [0:52:19] the hope that we are going to be successful and get the safer grant. So it included the [0:52:23] three firefighters in the last year's budget. The true FTE number was not quite [0:52:28] 351 because we didn't give the three firefighters but that we budgeted our [0:52:33] share. This year we're not banking on a safer grant. Grants through the federal [0:52:39] government right now are at certain at best and the need for firefighters is [0:52:45] real and so we are looking at paying resources, finding the resources to come [0:52:52] up with three additional firefighters. [0:52:55] In total, all of the departments at the beginning [0:52:56] of the process asked for about 17 and a half total FTE. [0:53:00] The cost of those positions was $1.5 million. [0:53:04] We did some extensive vetting, and we were able [0:53:07] to have a first year cost of $729,000, [0:53:11] of which 508 is in the tax-supported funds. [0:53:15] But that doesn't mean that all $508,000 is coming [0:53:18] from tax-supported funds. [0:53:19] So for example, the victim witness coordinator, [0:53:22] which will be housed in the police department, which is in the general fund and the tax-supported [0:53:26] fund, we're going to use our opioid funds as part of the opioid settlement and we believe [0:53:33] that we have collected or anticipate we will collect nearly 10 years of salary for the victim [0:53:40] witness coordinator. [0:53:43] So that will not, well, it will be an amazing benefit to those who fall victim of crime in [0:53:49] in our community. [0:53:50] Amazing resource for those not only in our legal team, [0:53:54] but also for the police and for the individuals. [0:53:57] But it comes at a very full cost to us. [0:54:04] I shared with you in one of my weekly reports [0:54:07] the work that is being done by both our public works [0:54:11] and our engineering team. [0:54:13] I believe that at that point in time [0:54:14] they calculated $49 million with the public works projects [0:54:18] that we're either started or contemplated in the future. [0:54:21] We're looking for another staff engineer [0:54:23] to be able to cover that workload. [0:54:27] We're looking at creating a chief prosecuting attorney [0:54:32] as our courts continue to grow and expand. [0:54:35] We're also looking to assign $100,000 in the water department [0:54:40] which comes from the water department [0:54:41] to assist with their reorg efforts. [0:54:44] They had asked for a position inside of the budget. [0:54:49] We definitely believe that the structure needed to be looked at. [0:54:54] We weren't necessarily convinced that adding the position was the right move, but we wanted [0:54:58] to reserve funding so that when they complete that reorganizational effort, we can pull the [0:55:02] trigger and move that. [0:55:04] And then moving a deputy city clerk to a city clerk position, Idaho Code describes the need [0:55:08] for a city clerk. [0:55:09] We want to make sure that we're in compliance with state code. [0:55:16] The operation of maintenance budget is going to go up by 1,338,000 or 6.1%. [0:55:25] That's just the cost of what we're seeing in terms of doing business and the projected [0:55:29] cost that we have moving forward. [0:55:37] Capital is at $25 million. [0:55:39] You'll say, why is it less than last year? [0:55:44] part of that production is the completion of the Eastland Project. Well why it's not completed [0:55:52] now and we all wish that it were. As part of the budget process it is completed and so no [0:56:01] more funding will be allocated to Eastland Ever and the SLFRF projects that have really [0:56:16] driven the 24 and 25 budget will be completed as well. Since fiscal year 26, the city has spent [0:56:26] $188.2 million in capital improvement. If that's a broad overview of the budget, any questions? [0:56:43] All right. So as I shared, everything goes through our strategic plan. The internal [0:56:49] organization is the heart of what we do. I am going to breeze through these. We have [0:56:57] dedicated an evening to a collection of these, so my purpose is to kind of share [0:57:05] some of that highlight and to get you thinking about what are we doing and what [0:57:09] are we not doing. One of the things you'll see is tennis court resurfacing. That was [0:57:12] part of our budget process at $75,000. We'd like to think CSI as being a [0:57:18] continued partner on that project with us. We have some trail maintenance money, we [0:57:26] We have some Hanson Street Plaza and playground money through the CDBG funds, as well as parking [0:57:33] lot repairs throughout the entire city. [0:57:37] It's under focus area one for a healthy. [0:57:39] Travis, what's ABI? [0:57:42] ABI force? [0:57:43] Got it? [0:57:44] Thank you. [0:57:51] Yes. [0:57:52] Yes. [0:57:56] Did I say that Sean went through the long-term planning process? [0:57:59] It's ingrained. [0:58:00] I just love it, a tractor thing. [0:58:05] from an economic developer. And he's also, he also has a legacy farm and [0:58:10] fuel. He does have a farm. He knows tractors. Moving on. I don't know. I don't know [0:58:19] feed those tractors. But I think Gretchen does know tractors. It's a [0:58:23] ball-filled groomer. Okay. A field ball, a field groomer. Awesome, thank you. You can [0:58:33] see that under a learning community it really is the focus on, internally it's [0:58:37] our partnerships that we have with all of the different learning institutions, but [0:58:41] But for here we focus our expenses on the library. [0:58:45] Mitch had shared the importance of having ADA compliant restrooms inside of the library. [0:58:52] You authorized architectural work. [0:58:55] This is to fund that project in the next budget when that is complete. [0:58:59] Also $50,000 for continued carpeting and other improvements for the library. [0:59:09] Here is a secure community and that really is going to cover police, fire, building safety. [0:59:18] The cost and design of the evidence storage at $400,000 as well as new patrol vehicles [0:59:25] and continued lease payment, water tender, apparatus, lease payment, a heavy vehicle extrication [0:59:34] and stabilization kit and additional fire hose [0:59:37] are the larger capital expenditures [0:59:40] that are part of becoming a secure community. [0:59:47] Being accessible is really about transportation, [0:59:51] multimodal, also we include parts of the airport [0:59:56] as it relates to their construction project. [0:59:58] So you'll find the airport in not only an accessible community [1:00:02] but also under a prosperous community [1:00:03] in its connection to economic development. [1:00:06] The continued maintenance at $1.9 million for seal code. [1:00:10] Overlays and maintenance projects [1:00:11] at 721,000 road construction projects. [1:00:15] And we also have not only construction projects [1:00:17] that are sponsored by the city, [1:00:18] but the continuation of the sidewalk grant program at $75,000. [1:00:28] You can see that a large piece of our budget [1:00:33] is going to be found inside of the environmental community, [1:00:36] which is going to be driven by water and wastewater. [1:00:40] We have $3 million for mainline replacements [1:00:44] in and out throughout the city, meter replacements, [1:00:48] some pressure zone adjustments, equipment. [1:00:52] And then we have a canyon line drop line [1:00:56] for the wastewater treatment fund, [1:00:59] which is probably one of the larger driving projects [1:01:02] in addition to the Jacobs contract. [1:01:04] So when you take a look at the $16 million that we had [1:01:08] in the sewer fund, 11 and a half million dollars, [1:01:13] just without the $4 million of cash reserves, [1:01:16] $4 million is going to the Canyon Room drop line [1:01:19] and just shy of $4 million goes to the Jacobs contract. [1:01:33] There are no direct funding associated [1:01:36] with a prosperous community, [1:01:38] but really is our talk and commitment [1:01:40] with the urban renewal agency from a capital perspective [1:01:44] in addition to that, we've asked Sean to shepherd the community event center RFQ process as well [1:01:56] as the citizens committee that is helping through that. So in subsequent years you may see puzzles [1:02:03] inside of that. Being a responsible community really talks about what are we doing to ensure [1:02:09] that the city remains that quality place to live. [1:02:14] And so one of the things that we've done is we've directed [1:02:17] Council capital money to ensure that the funds that you're creating [1:02:22] are going directly to the improvement into the community. [1:02:26] Last year the Council awarded these projects at $757,000. [1:02:35] This year you have an opportunity to maybe allocate a little bit more. [1:02:39] So, right now, when I said to you at the beginning that this budget is process was unique, we [1:02:52] walked into budget balancing with a surplus. [1:03:00] I've been doing this for 25 years and I've never seen that happen. [1:03:05] And as we took a look at what was sustainable, we crafted and created the budget. [1:03:13] And then since that time, we've got an additional revenue estimates that have come in that have [1:03:18] continued to build up that total revenue coming in that we didn't allocate. [1:03:24] And the challenge that we had was we did not want to allocate it to ongoing expenses because [1:03:30] we were concerned about what that future may look like. [1:03:34] And the long-term planning team went back and they added projects that they had previously [1:03:40] left off the table when we found additional resources. [1:03:44] So we placed it all into capital contingency. [1:03:48] So you can see that we have a capital contingency [1:03:50] of $615,000, which is far greater [1:03:54] than any capital contingency that we typically carry. [1:03:57] So I'm asking to hold about $250,000 of that, [1:04:01] which would free up an additional $365,000 [1:04:05] that you could add to one-time council capital projects [1:04:08] this year. [1:04:09] And, there has been some questions, is MPOG Bible? [1:04:15] It was a wonderful project that was contemplated, [1:04:18] and the reason that it was created in the past, [1:04:22] have maybe changed. [1:04:25] And it is a great opportunity during a budget process [1:04:29] to ask, is it still a value project, [1:04:32] or is there other and higher better resources for that $50,000? [1:04:38] And so if you were to include, [1:04:39] $365,000 of budgeted contingency, as well as the $50,000 PEMPOC program, should you elect [1:04:47] to cancel it, your one-time capital budget this year would grow to $1.185 million. [1:04:56] And what we've asked is all of the departments, when they make their presentations, to share [1:05:00] how they would, if sitting in your space, how they would allocate it to one-time significant [1:05:08] projects that benefit the community. [1:05:10] Now my ask is, again, even though we're asking for an additional staff engineer, please don't [1:05:16] add to the workload of our engineering team. [1:05:19] So if we had projects that were already designed or additional capital that we could help further [1:05:26] or a tool that would allow us to be more innovative, that would be great. [1:05:33] I've also asked the department leaders not to present any costs or any projects that have [1:05:38] reoccurring costs or significant reoccurring costs. Because if we were to do that, there's [1:05:45] no guarantee that the $365,000 is going to be there next year and we would chip away at [1:05:52] the 770 and it would turn into an operational fund. And I think council has done great work [1:05:59] with the 770, with the SLR, RF and the other funds that you've had to be able to apply to [1:06:06] to create a livable community. [1:06:09] And we talked about some of the different compensation [1:06:12] adjustments as it relates to an employee organization. [1:06:15] We also have $115,000 to complete the financial software. [1:06:19] We have $65,000 to perform a compensation study. [1:06:23] We do that every five years to ensure [1:06:25] that we are market competitive. [1:06:28] And then we have repeater replacements [1:06:30] and a higher ground update, which is a software package. [1:06:39] And that's your budget. [1:06:41] in total, it's about $7 million less than last year. [1:06:45] And when you only look at the tax-supported funds, [1:06:49] it's about $11 million less than last year, [1:06:53] I believe that the team really stepped up. [1:06:56] When you walk into a budgeting conversation [1:06:59] for the purposes of balancing, [1:07:01] and when I was sitting in the budget hearings [1:07:03] and I kept kind of a running total [1:07:06] and I would always reflect back, [1:07:09] I had to pause more than once [1:07:13] to make sure that I could still do math [1:07:16] because everything was coming in less than [1:07:19] where we were the prior year, [1:07:20] except for one-time capital budget. [1:07:22] So next week you'll hear focus areas one, seven, and eight, [1:07:27] which is going to be learning responsible [1:07:32] as well as our internal. [1:07:34] Excuse me, healthy, not learning as two. [1:07:39] Any questions? [1:07:41] Questions for Travis? [1:07:43] Chris Freed. [1:07:45] Question for Travis, but also I think question for the council. [1:07:47] So August 4th is that when as a council we're going to discuss [1:07:54] that normally it's a 770, but that's when we need to have that. [1:07:58] Cause I know that sometimes in the past we've new ideas [1:08:02] have come in and we've maybe delayed that a little bit, [1:08:06] but that's the council meeting where we need to have that. [1:08:09] August 18th. [1:08:11] August 18th is when you would like to have that. [1:08:12] So on the preliminary budget on the 4th is you're going [1:08:16] to set the maximum spending. [1:08:18] And so unless you elect to cut the 770, [1:08:24] you can continue to work through those allocations [1:08:26] and have those conversations. [1:08:27] But really, by the 18th is the last time in which we'll [1:08:32] have that conversation. [1:08:33] And so when the citizens come to the public hearing, [1:08:35] and hopefully they do, they engage in our process. [1:08:38] Open invitation, anyone come one, come all. [1:08:42] That on the 25th when we go through the budget, [1:08:45] that they have a complete understanding of not only [1:08:48] what was in the budget, but what has changed over the course of our conversation and how [1:08:53] the council is going to allocate, potentially, up to $1.185 million. [1:08:57] Perfect, thank you. [1:08:59] And that second August 4th should really be maybe August 11? [1:09:04] No. [1:09:05] No. [1:09:06] So you'll notice that we're, there's a week in there, we're not even going to talk about [1:09:10] the budget. [1:09:11] Oh, wow. [1:09:12] Interesting. [1:09:13] And that's you need to. [1:09:14] Yeah, it's, it's weird. [1:09:15] Yeah, I know. [1:09:16] I'm out of here. [1:09:19] I will change it. [1:09:20] You know, I didn't realize how it had a few works of the budget conversation, but we'll [1:09:23] definitely add it. [1:09:26] I want to say that we're trying something new, but we're really kind of more subject [1:09:31] to publication deadlines and the state code requirement to publish a budget. [1:09:38] And those deadlines have shifted up significantly, which actually caused us to adopt the budget [1:09:46] a week later than what we normally do. [1:09:49] And so that's why you have a one week gap. [1:09:52] And I didn't think that you wanted to hear two summaries [1:09:58] of the budget, the same presentation, [1:10:01] in consecutive Mondays. [1:10:02] But if you'd like that, we can certainly arrange [1:10:07] for that to occur. [1:10:09] All those opposed. [1:10:12] Thank you, Travis. [1:10:13] Any questions on anything related to budget [1:10:17] with Travis. Thank you very much. Very thorough. Okay, so we do allow public input on the budget. [1:10:27] And so we're going to do that first. This is the time for general public input. So the first [1:10:32] part of public input would be if anybody has anything they'd like to share with council [1:10:38] related to the budget today, the budget presentation. Okay, seeing no one, any general public input, [1:10:50] anybody that wishes to address City Council on anything not on today's budget. [1:10:59] Okay advisory board reports anybody have anything from the only thing that I would [1:11:08] bring up is that the uh building department would have a million meeting [1:11:13] into the 17th of the 24th um to go over our building code and hopefully we'll have a [1:11:19] good meeting and I'd encourage people to participate in that. Perfect. Okay. [1:11:27] Anybody else? [1:11:29] Hey, we're gonna move on to our public hearing. [1:11:32] It's an action item. [1:11:34] Public hearing and consideration of ordinance number 2025-010 [1:11:40] adopting the First Amendment to the Urban Renewal Plan [1:11:43] for Revenue Allocation Area 4-3, [1:11:46] and we have our URA Director, Sean Barrick, or welcome, Sean. [1:11:51] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [1:11:53] please. Well, I was haptraps' presentation here. Alright, thank you so much. So in May [1:12:13] of this year, the urban renewal agency of Twin Falls and Chobani commence certain discussions [1:12:21] concerning de-annexation of one parcel of approximately 28.23 acres from an existing revenue allocation [1:12:30] area. I'm going to use a ton of jargon over and over in this, so I'm going to try to pause [1:12:35] and walk through this just to clarify a couple of things. So revenue allocation area 4-3 is [1:12:42] on the screen there. It's outlined by that yellow line that's generally referred to as [1:12:48] the Chobani area. The hashtag piece in the corner there in the southeast corner is the [1:12:56] 28 and change acreage that we're talking about. [1:13:01] And in also in this case, DMXation is a slightly different term [1:13:05] than you're used to dealing with. [1:13:07] This is not about taking it in or out of the city limits. [1:13:11] It's about taking it out of the revenue allocation area. [1:13:16] So back in May, the agency at this discussion, [1:13:20] we retained a consultant to do a fiscal analysis [1:13:24] of what it would mean to remove that property [1:13:26] from the current revenue allocation area, [1:13:29] which was created back in 2011. [1:13:31] His findings were that a relatively small percentage [1:13:34] of revenue allocation proceeds [1:13:37] that would be lost through this DNxation process. [1:13:42] For the purposes of this First Amendment also, [1:13:46] the agency has bonds related to this revenue allocation area. [1:13:51] Zion's Bank had to provide basically a waiver [1:13:55] of doing a full consultants report [1:13:57] on what the financial impact of removing [1:13:59] that property would have been. [1:14:01] They provided a letter to the agency, [1:14:05] basically waving that responsibility [1:14:07] to have that separate consultants assessment. [1:14:11] So in discussions with Chobani, [1:14:12] they've expressed interest to continue to work [1:14:14] with the agency and the city [1:14:16] to support their $500 million expansion project [1:14:20] and to explore additional financing opportunities [1:14:24] infrastructure improvements. One of those options may be the use of tax increment financing to [1:14:32] finance additional wastewater and power improvements on that property pursuant to a new piece of legislation [1:14:39] that passed this last legislative session. Avia with that is that all of the properties within an area [1:14:47] used by a manufacturer must be a single ownership. This 28 acres is the only parcel within revenue [1:14:55] allocation area 4-3 that is not owned by Chobani. But to move forward with the potential for that [1:15:02] secondary discussion, this piece of property needs to be removed from revenue allocation area 4-3. [1:15:10] So again, today's action only deals with removing that property. Should there be action in the future [1:15:17] to move forward with some other modification to this area related to its length of time [1:15:22] and other financing provisions that will come at a future date, your action today does not [1:15:27] impact that except that it would then allow Giovanni and the agency to move forward with [1:15:32] some revision to this area based upon single ownership. [1:15:41] So on May 19th, the Urban Renewal Agency adopted a resolution approving this First Amendment [1:15:47] which the annexes this parcel. [1:15:49] I noticed was made to the overlapping taxing districts. [1:15:52] Regarding the proposed change, [1:15:54] the notification was made to the city. [1:15:56] The Planning and Zoning Commission did review this [1:15:59] to ensure conformity with the city's comprehensive plan, [1:16:03] which they adopted a resolution that was passed [1:16:05] on June 4th to do so. [1:16:08] So before you this evening is the ordinance [1:16:10] to formally adopt this amendment [1:16:13] to the Urban Renewal Plan for Revenue Allocation Area 4-3, [1:16:16] which would remove this parcel. [1:16:19] Just for reference, when I talk about DNxation, [1:16:21] again, that's removal from this revenue allocation area. [1:16:24] That particular parcel is actually not within the city limits. [1:16:27] Currently, it was never annexed into the city. [1:16:31] It was an agreement between the county and the city [1:16:33] that it could be included there as a county parcel. [1:16:36] So it remains in the unincorporated area of the city. [1:16:40] So tonight, you need to have a public hearing [1:16:43] to allow the opportunity for public input on this. [1:16:46] It is an ordinance, so should you wish to advance it [1:16:49] this evening, which staff would recommend [1:16:52] and encourage you to do so. [1:16:53] You will need to place it on third and final reading [1:16:57] by Tynil O'Lanley under suspension of the rules [1:16:59] and adopt the ordinance. [1:17:01] And in the conclusion there, it gives the suggested motions. [1:17:05] I will say in the second one, I do have a typo there. [1:17:08] That should be ordinance 2025-010. [1:17:13] a little aggressive with my cut and paste there and didn't change that one so [1:17:17] I'd be happy to stand for any questions that you may have at this point or after the [1:17:23] opportunity for public input. [1:17:25] Any questions for Sean before I open up the public hearing? [1:17:29] Okay, thank you. Thank you. So I will open up the public hearing on [1:17:38] consideration of this ordinance. If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on [1:17:44] On this particular item, please come up to the podium seeing no one. I will close the public hearing [1:17:58] Council wishes [1:18:05] Oh [1:18:07] Jason actually click down. Yeah, go ahead Jason. I'll I'll make the motion if we're to that point [1:18:13] Yeah, I would move that we dispense with the reading [1:18:18] reading with the reading rules and place ordinance 2025-010 on third and [1:18:26] final reading by title only. Thank you Chris Reed. I'll second that. Thank you [1:18:32] motion by Jason Brown seconded by Chris Reed. We motion to dispense with the [1:18:38] reading rules input ordinance 20 excuse me 2025-010 on third and final [1:18:45] reading by title only. Any discussion? Rachel Rokalvo please. Craig Hawkins. Yes. [1:18:55] Jason Brown. Yes. And Sir Cutler. Yes. Jerry Volmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Yes. [1:19:02] Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Next. Grayson Stone. Oh just as he does that. [1:19:15] Thank you Madam Mayor. I move that we approve Ordinance 2025-010 as presented. [1:19:23] Thank you Jason Brown. Thank you motion by Grace and Stone second by Jason Brown [1:19:29] to adopt Ordinance 2025-010. We need to read the ordinance. Ordinance 20-25-010 [1:19:39] and Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho approving the [1:19:44] First Amendment to the Urban Renewal Plan for Revenue Allocation Area 4-3, which First Amendment [1:19:51] seeks to de-anic certain area from the existing Revenue Allocation Area 4-3, which First Amendment [1:19:59] amends a plan that includes revenue allocation, financing provisions, authorizing the city clerk [1:20:07] to transmit a copy of this ordinance and other required information to the county and state [1:20:12] officials and the affected taxing energies, providing several [1:20:18] ability, approving the summary of the ordinance, providing for waiver of the [1:20:23] reading rules, and providing an effective date. Any discussion, Amy Rok, Rachel, I [1:20:35] made it almost through the whole meeting. Rok, I'll vote please. Ruth Pierce. Yes. [1:20:39] Chris Reed. Yes. Chris Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. [1:20:43] Yes, thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Sean. Thank you, everyone. Our meeting is adjourned.