WEBVTT

00:00:33.230 --> 00:04:08.230
Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the March 31st 2025 City Council meeting.

00:04:08.230 --> 00:04:10.270
I want to confirm we have a quorum.

00:04:10.270 --> 00:04:14.630
We have all seven members present in chambers.

00:04:14.630 --> 00:04:17.030
First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

00:04:17.030 --> 00:04:18.990
If you wish to join me please rise.

00:04:18.990 --> 00:04:39.430
You need a crowd like that every day.

00:04:39.430 --> 00:04:41.470
Thank you guys.

00:04:41.470 --> 00:04:44.790
No proclamations tonight.

00:04:44.790 --> 00:04:50.910
So next on the agenda is the consent calendar council move to approve thank you to have

00:04:50.910 --> 00:04:56.870
a second second thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Craig Hawkins to approve the

00:04:56.870 --> 00:05:06.750
consent calendar as written Amy roll call vote please yes yes yes yes yes yes yes

00:05:06.750 --> 00:05:12.950
Jason Brown yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes

00:05:12.950 --> 00:05:16.560
Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.

00:05:16.560 --> 00:05:20.920
Hey, our next item under items of consideration

00:05:20.920 --> 00:05:23.480
is an action item, a request to confirm

00:05:23.480 --> 00:05:26.920
the city manager's appointment of Mitchell Brooks,

00:05:26.920 --> 00:05:29.760
the second to the position of fire chief

00:05:29.760 --> 00:05:32.240
for the city of Twin Falls.

00:05:32.240 --> 00:05:36.760
Upon confirmation, Mayor Pierce will issue the oath of office,

00:05:36.760 --> 00:05:40.480
which I didn't get a copy of, but I assume you have it.

00:05:40.480 --> 00:05:45.930
Somebody has it.

00:05:45.930 --> 00:05:49.360
Go ahead, Travis.

00:05:49.360 --> 00:05:54.360
Madam Mayor, members of the council, two weeks ago today,

00:05:54.440 --> 00:05:59.440
we celebrated the retirement of Chief Les Kenworthy

00:05:59.600 --> 00:06:05.310
and his slightly more than seven years in our organization.

00:06:05.310 --> 00:06:08.990
And with his retirement comes an opening

00:06:08.990 --> 00:06:12.510
in the position of fire chief for the city of Twin Falls.

00:06:14.910 --> 00:06:19.710
The fire chief is one of a handful of positions

00:06:19.710 --> 00:06:25.430
inside of the city that is a member of the city's executive leadership team.

00:06:25.430 --> 00:06:35.310
And Twin Falls Municipal Code 1-2-4 defines it as a department head.

00:06:35.310 --> 00:06:42.240
Department heads in our organization include the deputy city managers, the chief financial

00:06:42.240 --> 00:06:50.810
officer, the police chief, the fire chief, the city engineer, the public works director,

00:06:50.810 --> 00:06:54.450
and the Human Resource Director.

00:06:54.450 --> 00:07:00.530
Whenever there is a vacancy of these positions, it is the requirement of the City Manager,

00:07:00.530 --> 00:07:09.690
as described in 1-2-3 of the Twin Falls Municipal Code, to recommend the appointment of an individual

00:07:09.690 --> 00:07:12.690
to serve in that capacity.

00:07:12.690 --> 00:07:20.970
And the Council's role is to evaluate the individual and then to act upon the City Manager's

00:07:20.970 --> 00:07:28.190
recommendation and it is my pleasure tonight to recommend to you Mitchell Brooks to the position

00:07:28.190 --> 00:07:37.280
of Fire Chief for the City of Twin Falls. You all know Mitchell Mitchell's been with our

00:07:37.280 --> 00:07:48.190
organization since 1999. He has served in every position inside of the Twin Falls Fire Department.

00:07:48.190 --> 00:07:56.190
He said seven years as a battalion chief in the last two slightly less than two and a half

00:07:56.190 --> 00:08:01.190
years as the city's first deputy chief.

00:08:01.190 --> 00:08:06.190
In that position he has worked strategically on department operations.

00:08:06.190 --> 00:08:12.190
He has assisted in fire suppression, building and constructing meaningful relationships

00:08:12.190 --> 00:08:18.150
with our mutual aid providers, our emergency service partners,

00:08:18.150 --> 00:08:23.220
and he has helped in disaster response.

00:08:23.220 --> 00:08:27.460
I believe he is now shifting or going over to a parallel team

00:08:27.460 --> 00:08:34.370
to assist in our development of a local emergency plan.

00:08:34.370 --> 00:08:36.490
Inside of our organization, he has served

00:08:36.490 --> 00:08:40.170
as a member of the city's executive management team.

00:08:40.170 --> 00:08:44.130
He has embraced the concept of one city.

00:08:44.130 --> 00:08:49.090
He has attended the University of Virginia's lead training

00:08:49.090 --> 00:08:52.160
program.

00:08:52.160 --> 00:08:55.960
He has done the things necessary to prepare him for those roles,

00:08:55.960 --> 00:09:00.360
and then he has gone above and beyond by investing in himself.

00:09:00.360 --> 00:09:04.120
He has a bachelor's degree from Grand Canyon University,

00:09:04.120 --> 00:09:09.240
in which he achieved just in May of 2024.

00:09:09.240 --> 00:09:12.120
Mitchell went back to school in anticipation

00:09:12.120 --> 00:09:15.480
of being able to be prepared and ready for this position

00:09:15.480 --> 00:09:20.240
as he studied and got a bachelor's of science degree

00:09:20.240 --> 00:09:23.920
in applied management.

00:09:23.920 --> 00:09:26.640
He has spent time internally looking

00:09:26.640 --> 00:09:30.200
at CAD and EMS systems, building relationships,

00:09:30.200 --> 00:09:32.600
and focusing on the things that he needs to do

00:09:32.600 --> 00:09:36.470
to be a leader worth following.

00:09:36.470 --> 00:09:39.750
He has my complete support.

00:09:39.750 --> 00:09:44.750
I believe he is the right man at the right time for this role

00:09:45.070 --> 00:09:47.350
and to carry on the progression

00:09:47.350 --> 00:09:49.870
of the Twin Falls Fire Department.

00:09:49.870 --> 00:09:53.390
And with that, it is my pleasure to recommend to you,

00:09:53.390 --> 00:09:59.010
Mitchell Brooks, to the position of Fire Chief

00:09:59.010 --> 00:10:00.690
at Stanford, any questions?

00:10:00.690 --> 00:10:03.730
I also asked Mitchell to come to the front

00:10:03.730 --> 00:10:08.730
and he is excited to answer your hard grilling questions.

00:10:09.130 --> 00:10:10.850
You see that on his face.

00:10:10.850 --> 00:10:18.370
Yes, it's full of questions, of course.

00:10:18.370 --> 00:10:19.370
Thank you, Travis.

00:10:19.370 --> 00:10:27.290
Any questions for Travis or Mitchell, Grace and Stone?

00:10:27.290 --> 00:10:28.490
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

00:10:28.490 --> 00:10:32.570
So in a previous life, I was a firefighter down in New Mexico.

00:10:32.570 --> 00:10:36.050
And we ran EMS and fire.

00:10:36.050 --> 00:10:38.450
And it was probably one of the best times of my life.

00:10:38.450 --> 00:10:41.530
And I learned a lot from those guys.

00:10:41.530 --> 00:10:44.450
I get a lot of anxiety being a city official and everybody

00:10:44.450 --> 00:10:49.450
looking for leadership and meeting with Chief Brooks.

00:10:51.530 --> 00:10:54.570
He's exactly who I wanna follow into a fire.

00:10:54.570 --> 00:10:57.650
I think you epitomize everything what a leader is.

00:10:58.770 --> 00:11:01.520
So if there's no more discussion,

00:11:01.520 --> 00:11:04.240
I wanna teach him how to fish and maybe hunt a little.

00:11:05.420 --> 00:11:08.350
But other than that,

00:11:08.350 --> 00:11:09.870
I'd like to make a motion to confirm

00:11:09.870 --> 00:11:11.110
the city manager's appointment

00:11:11.110 --> 00:11:12.550
of Mitchell Brooks the second

00:11:12.550 --> 00:11:14.150
to the position of the fire chief

00:11:14.150 --> 00:11:19.030
the City of Twin Falls upon confirmation Mayor Pilar's will issue the oath of

00:11:19.030 --> 00:11:25.030
office. Thank you Jason Brown. Thank you motion by Grayson Stone seconded by

00:11:25.030 --> 00:11:29.750
Jason Brown to confirm the City Manager's appointment of Mitchell Brooks the

00:11:29.750 --> 00:11:35.840
second to the position of fire chief for the City of Twin Falls. Any further

00:11:35.840 --> 00:11:39.240
discussion? Amy Rokalvo please.

00:11:39.240 --> 00:12:25.950
First read yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes

00:12:25.950 --> 00:12:30.360
and we expect everyone.

00:12:30.360 --> 00:13:36.560
Brookes, you should have started there.

00:13:36.560 --> 00:14:11.680
So we have the oath as part of the packet,

00:14:11.680 --> 00:14:15.640
and then after we'll do the official pinning of the badge,

00:14:15.640 --> 00:14:17.840
and I believe your wife will be doing that.

00:14:17.840 --> 00:14:20.040
So if she wants to come and join you now.

00:14:20.040 --> 00:14:26.040
And then it's conclusion of the oath and the pinning,

00:14:26.040 --> 00:14:28.840
we would invite the council, the management team,

00:14:28.840 --> 00:14:32.960
and then obviously all the members of the fire team

00:14:32.960 --> 00:14:37.120
team who would like to congratulate Mitchell on this appointment.

00:14:37.120 --> 00:14:43.370
That's what broke the second.

00:14:43.370 --> 00:16:25.710
That's all I'm going to swear.

00:16:25.710 --> 00:18:29.770
I said it got him.

00:18:29.770 --> 00:18:33.470
Well, I got a few things.

00:18:33.470 --> 00:18:36.070
One of the things I pride myself on is being

00:18:36.070 --> 00:18:37.550
brevity and being short.

00:18:37.550 --> 00:18:40.560
So I just want to take a long.

00:18:40.560 --> 00:18:44.440
But first, I just want to thank the Council City

00:18:44.440 --> 00:18:49.720
Administration, all the colleagues that are in the crowd.

00:18:49.720 --> 00:18:51.440
I haven't been this nervous in a long time.

00:18:51.440 --> 00:18:54.620
And so you can probably sense it and what I'm saying.

00:18:54.620 --> 00:18:57.280
But also I want to thank my family

00:18:57.280 --> 00:18:59.800
for being behind me through this journey.

00:19:01.380 --> 00:19:04.700
I'm immensely grateful for the amazing support

00:19:04.700 --> 00:19:06.940
and mentorship that I've received.

00:19:06.940 --> 00:19:09.660
Having served under three other fire chiefs.

00:19:09.660 --> 00:19:11.260
I have a really good idea of where we've been,

00:19:11.260 --> 00:19:16.440
where we're at today, and also where we're going.

00:19:16.440 --> 00:19:18.720
So as chief, I'm committed to diligently working

00:19:18.720 --> 00:19:22.080
towards achieving the goals outlined in our strategic plans

00:19:22.080 --> 00:19:27.180
in supporting the men and women of our organization.

00:19:27.180 --> 00:19:30.020
I will uphold and promote our one city values

00:19:30.020 --> 00:19:31.860
and strive to create a clear vision

00:19:31.860 --> 00:19:33.640
for the fire department.

00:19:33.640 --> 00:19:37.140
Our focus will be on continuously improving service delivery

00:19:37.140 --> 00:19:42.500
to the residents and the visitors of the city of Twin Falls.

00:19:42.500 --> 00:19:43.980
I want to express my heartfelt thanks

00:19:43.980 --> 00:19:45.740
to everyone here supporting me.

00:19:45.740 --> 00:19:48.740
And I eagerly look forward to shifting the spotlight

00:19:48.740 --> 00:19:51.440
for myself to the incredible team.

00:19:51.440 --> 00:19:53.970
I have the privilege to lead.

00:19:53.970 --> 00:20:11.630
So thank you, everyone.

00:20:11.630 --> 00:20:15.150
This is normally when we have a moment of sight, not really.

00:20:15.150 --> 00:20:20.480
It's if you want to all want to take a minute and leave,

00:20:20.480 --> 00:20:23.680
I'll let you unless you want to stay for this really riveting

00:20:23.680 --> 00:20:25.280
meeting that we have.

00:20:25.280 --> 00:20:27.120
But we'll take a couple of minute break

00:20:27.120 --> 00:20:28.520
and let you all leave.

00:20:28.520 --> 00:23:56.640
So OK, thank you, everyone.

00:23:56.640 --> 00:23:58.560
That was great.

00:23:58.560 --> 00:24:01.920
So next on the agenda is an action item.

00:24:01.920 --> 00:24:04.160
Confirm the appointment of Rui Gomes

00:24:04.160 --> 00:24:06.840
and reappointment of Todd Ramber and Kelly Hurgis

00:24:06.840 --> 00:24:09.080
out to the planning zoning commission,

00:24:09.080 --> 00:24:11.800
and we have Jonathan Spinwell, our director.

00:24:11.800 --> 00:24:13.480
Thank you, Jonathan.

00:24:13.480 --> 00:24:14.880
Thank you, Mayor, members of the council.

00:24:14.880 --> 00:24:19.320
This item has three people that are listed on it.

00:24:19.320 --> 00:24:22.360
Rui is replacing somebody who is moving,

00:24:22.360 --> 00:24:26.200
and that person actually had a term that ended in March,

00:24:26.200 --> 00:24:28.840
so it was kind of gratuitous at that point.

00:24:28.840 --> 00:24:32.120
And then two other people on here are reappointments.

00:24:32.120 --> 00:24:38.280
will be fulfilling the first three-year term Kelly and Todd are currently on the commission

00:24:38.280 --> 00:24:43.600
and will finish up I think Todd finishes his first full three-year term and Kelly had a

00:24:43.600 --> 00:24:44.600
partial.

00:24:44.600 --> 00:24:50.300
It will be reappointed to their respective seats and that is a conclusion of the report and

00:24:50.300 --> 00:24:51.560
let's see how many questions for me.

00:24:51.560 --> 00:24:52.560
Rui is here.

00:24:52.560 --> 00:24:56.560
The reappointments are not here just in case there's any questions on that.

00:24:56.560 --> 00:24:57.560
Thank you.

00:24:57.560 --> 00:24:58.560
Any questions for Jonathan?

00:24:58.560 --> 00:24:59.560
I would entertain a motion.

00:24:59.560 --> 00:25:02.960
Thank you.

00:25:02.960 --> 00:25:10.380
motion. I will move to confirm the appointment of

00:25:10.380 --> 00:25:15.780
Ruigong's and reappointment of Todd Ramber and Kelly Hurgisall to the planning and

00:25:15.780 --> 00:25:19.660
zoning commission. Thank you Jason Brown. Second. Thank you motion by

00:25:19.660 --> 00:25:25.380
Sherry Volmer seconded by Jason Brown to confirm the appointments. The appointment

00:25:25.380 --> 00:25:30.100
of Ruigong's and the reappointment of Todd Ramber and Kelly Hurgisall to the

00:25:30.100 --> 00:25:36.100
Planning and Zoning Commission. Any discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.

00:25:36.100 --> 00:25:41.720
Great Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes.

00:25:41.720 --> 00:25:48.980
Grayson Stone. Yes. Sherry Vomer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Rhee. Yes.

00:25:48.980 --> 00:25:56.050
Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you Jonathan. Congratulations Rhee. Where

00:25:56.050 --> 00:26:02.700
are you? Oh there you're hiding. You're clear in the back. Thank you. Okay

00:26:02.700 --> 00:26:05.560
Okay, next on the agenda is an action item.

00:26:05.560 --> 00:26:08.360
Are we quest to confirm the mayor's appointment

00:26:08.360 --> 00:26:13.360
as Steve Hayes to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission

00:26:13.460 --> 00:26:17.380
and we have our Parks and Rec Director, Wendy Davis.

00:26:17.380 --> 00:26:19.250
Welcome, Wendy.

00:26:19.250 --> 00:26:20.770
Good evening, Mayor and Council.

00:26:20.770 --> 00:26:24.090
I told Steve that everybody was here from him.

00:26:24.090 --> 00:26:27.250
So he's a little disappointed when everybody ran out.

00:26:27.250 --> 00:26:32.250
So we have two openings on the commission

00:26:32.250 --> 00:26:41.500
And one reappointment, we tried to select from the previous candidates that we chose from in

00:26:41.500 --> 00:26:49.970
December and have now reopened the position and have some applications that we need to

00:26:49.970 --> 00:26:52.470
go through here pretty quick.

00:26:52.470 --> 00:26:57.010
So there will be another appointment here shortly, but Steve was certainly outstanding in the

00:26:57.010 --> 00:27:03.250
last round of interviews that we had and so we were thrilled to have an

00:27:03.250 --> 00:27:08.830
opportunity to invite him to join the Commission this time. Also, Deb Van

00:27:08.830 --> 00:27:16.490
England has served her first three-year term and has, and is willing to serve a

00:27:16.490 --> 00:27:22.020
second three-year term and I don't think she's still down in the warm

00:27:22.020 --> 00:27:33.520
country. So with that, Steve is here and I'd like to request that you appoint Steve to

00:27:33.520 --> 00:27:35.020
the commission for a three-year term.

00:27:35.020 --> 00:27:39.020
You want to appoint Steve and reappoint up?

00:27:39.020 --> 00:27:41.020
Point Steve and reappoint up, yep.

00:27:41.020 --> 00:27:43.020
Okay, I did it, Sarri Velmer.

00:27:43.020 --> 00:27:52.900
Just real quick, before I make a motion for this, I had the pleasure of interviewing Steve

00:27:52.900 --> 00:28:01.900
well and I think he's going to bring some great knowledge of youth sports here and he

00:28:01.900 --> 00:28:09.920
really really cares a lot about recreation as a whole so glad to see you here.

00:28:09.920 --> 00:28:20.130
And I will make a motion to I will move to confirm Mayor's appointment of Steve Hayes in reappointment

00:28:20.130 --> 00:28:23.530
of Deb Van England to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission.

00:28:23.530 --> 00:28:29.610
Thank you Jason Brown second. Thank you motion by Sherry Vollmer seconder by Jason Brown to confirm the mayor

00:28:30.090 --> 00:28:32.490
appointment of Steve Hayes and reappointment of

00:28:32.770 --> 00:28:36.330
Deb Vann England to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission

00:28:37.330 --> 00:28:40.900
Any discussion Amy roll call vote please

00:28:42.630 --> 00:28:48.830
Jason Brown yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Jason Stone. Yes, Harry Vollmer. Yes, Ruth Pierce

00:28:49.270 --> 00:28:51.270
Yes, yes

00:28:51.270 --> 00:28:52.270
and Craig Hawkins.

00:28:52.270 --> 00:28:53.270
Yes.

00:28:53.270 --> 00:28:54.270
Thank you.

00:28:54.270 --> 00:28:55.270
Motion passes 7-0.

00:28:55.270 --> 00:28:56.270
Thank you, Wendy.

00:28:56.270 --> 00:28:57.270
Next.

00:28:57.270 --> 00:28:58.270
He has a presentation.

00:28:58.270 --> 00:28:59.270
Stay there.

00:28:59.270 --> 00:29:00.270
Congratulations.

00:29:00.270 --> 00:29:01.270
Oh, okay.

00:29:01.270 --> 00:29:02.270
Well, he'll stay.

00:29:02.270 --> 00:29:10.270
Recognize Kurt Melton for his service on the Parks and Rec Commission, and we have Wendy

00:29:10.270 --> 00:29:11.270
Davis.

00:29:11.270 --> 00:29:12.270
Yes.

00:29:12.270 --> 00:29:18.670
So, Kurt joined the Parks and Recreation Commission in April of 2019 and has dedicated six years

00:29:18.670 --> 00:29:21.030
of service to the commission.

00:29:21.030 --> 00:29:28.350
He brought with him a connection to the pool, which is where we started, and his professional

00:29:28.350 --> 00:29:34.430
experience as a civil attorney and civil law attorney and his leadership on the commission.

00:29:34.430 --> 00:29:43.190
He served as the chairman two or three years under his leadership.

00:29:43.190 --> 00:29:44.870
We've accomplished a lot of things.

00:29:44.870 --> 00:29:48.030
He's also been a very dedicated commissioner.

00:29:48.030 --> 00:29:53.030
I think almost as dedicated as you at showing up at Arbor Days.

00:29:53.710 --> 00:29:54.870
He was better.

00:29:54.870 --> 00:29:58.710
Well, and you both brought staff, which is excellent.

00:29:58.710 --> 00:30:03.310
So always willing to be there in the volunteer times,

00:30:03.310 --> 00:30:05.630
showing up at different opportunities

00:30:05.630 --> 00:30:07.550
and to meet the public.

00:30:07.550 --> 00:30:11.230
And has certainly been a huge asset to the commission

00:30:11.230 --> 00:30:14.390
and we're certainly sorry to see him go.

00:30:14.390 --> 00:30:17.550
So I'd like to have him come down.

00:30:21.900 --> 00:30:25.940
And maybe, at least the mayor, but maybe Sherry and Craig,

00:30:25.940 --> 00:30:27.880
you don't all serve with him, was you

00:30:27.880 --> 00:30:30.640
willing to come down and present the?

00:30:30.640 --> 00:30:33.440
I do have a question though for Kirk.

00:30:33.440 --> 00:30:35.520
With him leaving the commission, does this

00:30:35.520 --> 00:30:40.810
mean that there is no possibility of a sled hill?

00:30:40.810 --> 00:30:43.210
That's an inside joke.

00:30:43.210 --> 00:30:45.370
Has been promised to me.

00:30:45.370 --> 00:30:47.210
And so that's going to help.

00:30:47.210 --> 00:30:48.050
Oh, yes.

00:30:48.050 --> 00:30:52.850
I forgot to mention his advocacy for a sledding hill.

00:30:52.850 --> 00:30:58.760
In any park, we can find one to put it in.

00:30:58.760 --> 00:31:00.540
And we're gonna name it the Kirk Melton,

00:31:00.540 --> 00:31:53.480
slutty hill.

00:31:53.480 --> 00:31:57.320
Okay, next on the agenda is an action item.

00:31:57.320 --> 00:32:02.320
A request city council approved a special event permit

00:32:02.640 --> 00:32:07.640
for the organizers of Circa, Italia, Circus event.

00:32:09.160 --> 00:32:12.480
And I believe, Lou, are you gonna,

00:32:12.480 --> 00:32:23.040
we have Lou Coronado, obviously from the PD.

00:32:23.040 --> 00:32:30.800
Thank you Madam Mayor and members of the Council. This is a request to prove a special event

00:32:30.800 --> 00:32:38.640
permit for organizing the Circa, Italia Circa's event. I believe we have a representative from

00:32:38.640 --> 00:32:47.760
Circa on teams listening in. They can answer more questions as well. The special event application

00:32:47.760 --> 00:32:56.600
was submitted to have this Circa et al event at the Magi Valley Mall for the dates of April

00:32:56.600 --> 00:33:05.400
25th through April 28th at the Magi Valley Mall Park in front of the O Shopco building.

00:33:05.400 --> 00:33:15.880
This is described as a acrobatic theatrical circus style event under a tent.

00:33:15.880 --> 00:33:18.760
There will be two large tents.

00:33:18.760 --> 00:33:26.520
The main tent is 131 feet round where all the circus-style event are going to take place.

00:33:26.520 --> 00:33:34.400
Additionally, the event organizers mentioned that there will be no animals, alcohol, open

00:33:34.400 --> 00:33:38.600
fires, power techniques, rides, or games at this circus.

00:33:38.600 --> 00:33:44.680
It's just going to be acrobatics-style circus.

00:33:44.680 --> 00:33:50.400
The event organizers have also secured all permits required for the event.

00:33:50.400 --> 00:33:54.160
There's a high win action plan in place because of the tents.

00:33:54.160 --> 00:33:57.440
There's emergency fire evacuation plan submitted.

00:33:57.440 --> 00:34:01.360
They have a security plan in place.

00:34:01.360 --> 00:34:07.760
They have public announcements ready for case emergencies.

00:34:07.760 --> 00:34:15.170
they will submit the liability insurance before this event takes place.

00:34:15.170 --> 00:34:23.610
I also contacted Trevor Wright, who is the general manager for Magic Valley Mall, and

00:34:23.610 --> 00:34:28.570
he fully supports this event to be hosted at the Magic Valley Mall.

00:34:28.570 --> 00:34:33.770
He also mentioned that this event took place seven years ago at the Magic Valley Mall, and

00:34:33.770 --> 00:34:38.310
it was well received by the public.

00:34:38.310 --> 00:34:44.630
So we were asking for approval from City Council for this circus event.

00:34:44.630 --> 00:34:52.710
Like I said, the member of the organizers, one of the organizers is on teams if we have

00:34:52.710 --> 00:34:54.960
questions.

00:34:54.960 --> 00:34:57.520
Thank you, Lou.

00:34:57.520 --> 00:34:58.520
Grayson.

00:34:58.520 --> 00:34:59.520
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

00:34:59.520 --> 00:35:02.120
Is this the same group that put on the Halloween event?

00:35:02.120 --> 00:35:03.120
It's not, correct?

00:35:03.120 --> 00:35:04.510
It's not.

00:35:04.510 --> 00:35:05.510
It's a paranormal circus.

00:35:05.510 --> 00:35:06.510
It is.

00:35:06.510 --> 00:35:07.510
It is the same group.

00:35:07.510 --> 00:35:15.960
So I have a question for the applicant then, if she would stand for a question.

00:35:15.960 --> 00:35:17.960
Ms. Rosa, can you hear me?

00:35:17.960 --> 00:35:29.910
Can you hear me?

00:35:29.910 --> 00:35:32.360
Yes ma'am, can you hear me?

00:35:32.360 --> 00:35:33.360
Yes.

00:35:33.360 --> 00:35:34.360
Perfect.

00:35:34.360 --> 00:35:40.360
So, one of the things that I received back on the event on Halloween was the type of content

00:35:40.360 --> 00:35:42.360
that was held.

00:35:42.360 --> 00:35:46.570
Can you walk through what the content will be for this event?

00:35:46.570 --> 00:35:47.570
Yes.

00:35:47.570 --> 00:35:56.570
Circuit Talia, the unit that is going to this location is family oriented circus.

00:35:56.570 --> 00:36:00.690
It is not like the paranormal.

00:36:00.690 --> 00:36:03.890
Paranormal is geared towards more of an adult audience.

00:36:03.890 --> 00:36:08.890
Even though it's no sexuality content,

00:36:08.890 --> 00:36:15.090
this is a family area to show that it's for you.

00:36:15.090 --> 00:36:20.530
The children of all ages is welcome at the show.

00:36:20.530 --> 00:36:22.880
Okay, thank you ma'am.

00:36:22.880 --> 00:36:24.640
Appreciate it.

00:36:24.640 --> 00:36:27.880
Thank you. Any other questions or comments?

00:36:27.880 --> 00:36:37.390
I also, uh, YouTube, this circus atalia and is not anything near what I normal was.

00:36:37.390 --> 00:36:42.390
Um, it is what I saw on the YouTube is family oriented.

00:36:42.390 --> 00:36:45.480
Perfect. Thank you.

00:36:45.480 --> 00:36:46.480
Thank you.

00:36:46.480 --> 00:36:47.480
Yeah, absolutely.

00:36:47.480 --> 00:36:51.480
And this is a, you know, it's a family oriented show area.

00:36:51.480 --> 00:36:53.480
Let's talk about.

00:36:53.480 --> 00:36:54.480
Yeah.

00:36:54.480 --> 00:37:00.270
Yeah, thank you, rosen anybody else have any questions Chris read

00:37:00.270 --> 00:37:06.070
I just have a comment that I I didn't YouTube and but I did go on their website and all the pictures and everything that they had

00:37:06.350 --> 00:37:08.870
looked more family friendly than

00:37:09.510 --> 00:37:13.850
The reports back that we got from the other circus, so I'll make a motion if we're ready

00:37:13.850 --> 00:37:19.830
Thank you, Chris, please I move that we approve the special event permit for the organizers of the CERC

00:37:20.510 --> 00:37:23.430
Italiana circus event. Thank you Jason Brown

00:37:23.430 --> 00:37:24.430
Thank you.

00:37:24.430 --> 00:37:30.870
Motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown to approve the special event permit for the

00:37:30.870 --> 00:37:35.360
Circa etalia circus event.

00:37:35.360 --> 00:37:37.840
Any further discussion?

00:37:37.840 --> 00:37:40.580
Amy Roll call vote please.

00:37:40.580 --> 00:37:41.580
Bencer Cutler?

00:37:41.580 --> 00:37:42.580
Yes.

00:37:42.580 --> 00:37:43.580
Grayson Stone?

00:37:43.580 --> 00:37:44.580
Yes.

00:37:44.580 --> 00:37:45.580
Very Volmer?

00:37:45.580 --> 00:37:46.580
Yes.

00:37:46.580 --> 00:37:47.580
Ruth Pierce?

00:37:47.580 --> 00:37:48.580
Yes.

00:37:48.580 --> 00:37:49.580
Chris Reed?

00:37:49.580 --> 00:37:50.580
Yes.

00:37:50.580 --> 00:37:51.580
And Jason Brown?

00:37:51.580 --> 00:37:52.580
Yes.

00:37:52.580 --> 00:37:53.580
Thank you.

00:37:53.580 --> 00:37:54.580
Motion passes 7-0.

00:37:54.580 --> 00:37:57.540
Thank you, Rosa.

00:37:57.540 --> 00:38:00.600
Thank you very much.

00:38:00.600 --> 00:38:16.600
Okay, next on the agenda is an action item and consideration of resolution 2025-002, creating a policy to allow for an invocation to be delivered at the beginning of a city council meeting.

00:38:16.600 --> 00:38:19.600
And we have our city manager, Travis Rosweller.

00:38:19.600 --> 00:38:22.600
Welcome, Travis. Thank you.

00:38:22.600 --> 00:38:29.160
Excuse me, members of the council, it is trying to get used to reading.

00:38:29.160 --> 00:38:39.170
Oh, some of you already there. I'm trying to join the crowd. This is, so I'm going to be like this,

00:38:39.170 --> 00:38:44.560
because this is a lot easier for me. So over the course of the last several years,

00:38:45.760 --> 00:38:53.520
whether it be me or members of the council have been approached about starting off a meeting

00:38:53.520 --> 00:39:01.760
with an invocation. And in the past, when we've looked at that request, the response was,

00:39:01.760 --> 00:39:10.720
we do not have a detailed policy to ensure that the invocation that would be provided would be one

00:39:10.720 --> 00:39:19.600
that would be one of encouragement, one that would not be necessarily in support of a single type of

00:39:19.600 --> 00:39:30.120
faith in support of a denomination, in support of a denomination at all, but really in a space

00:39:30.120 --> 00:39:37.680
to be able to start a meeting off at a tone of a positive nature, to ensure that the work

00:39:37.680 --> 00:39:44.200
and the actions that we do as a, whether it be a council or as the presenters come up,

00:39:44.200 --> 00:39:49.080
is done so in the spirit of cooperation and mindfulness

00:39:49.080 --> 00:39:51.860
inside of a community.

00:39:51.860 --> 00:39:54.500
There is several Supreme Court cases

00:39:54.500 --> 00:40:00.460
that have gone through asking is an invocation legal under the

00:40:00.460 --> 00:40:02.340
establishment clause.

00:40:02.340 --> 00:40:06.020
And the United States Supreme Court in 2014

00:40:06.020 --> 00:40:09.220
and the town of Grace v. Galloway affirmed

00:40:09.220 --> 00:40:12.500
that an invocation is allowed so long

00:40:12.500 --> 00:40:15.780
as it follows certain guidelines.

00:40:15.780 --> 00:40:17.580
And organizations have the ability

00:40:17.580 --> 00:40:19.940
to choose to continue to do that.

00:40:19.940 --> 00:40:24.620
It is something that many organizations have long done,

00:40:25.620 --> 00:40:28.940
whether they're communities inside the Magic Valley,

00:40:28.940 --> 00:40:32.080
inside of the State House at our legislature.

00:40:33.300 --> 00:40:37.660
There are actions that are taken,

00:40:37.660 --> 00:40:39.740
but there are also rules and guidelines

00:40:39.740 --> 00:40:41.900
that work through that process.

00:40:41.900 --> 00:40:48.540
So inside of the resolution, there's also an attachment that kind of describes the process

00:40:48.540 --> 00:40:52.900
should the council adopt the resolution that should be followed.

00:40:52.900 --> 00:41:00.860
I will say that prior to coming here, I did have conversations with different faith leaders,

00:41:00.860 --> 00:41:07.060
not just those that are Christ-based, but other faith leaders within the community.

00:41:07.060 --> 00:41:13.240
We also had conversations with our legal counsel to ensure that the resolution that was taken

00:41:13.240 --> 00:41:22.830
before you gives you an opportunity to make a decision without legal or other repercussions.

00:41:22.830 --> 00:41:25.430
I will say that I did receive an email this morning.

00:41:25.430 --> 00:41:30.070
I believe each of the members of the council received it as well, encouraging you not to

00:41:30.070 --> 00:41:32.290
support this.

00:41:32.290 --> 00:41:36.690
But inside of the rules, it talks about the time and the duration.

00:41:36.690 --> 00:41:40.530
The rules here are ones that we would suggest,

00:41:40.530 --> 00:41:44.410
but we say that it shouldn't take any longer than two minutes.

00:41:44.410 --> 00:41:48.090
We say that it will be on an invitation basis

00:41:48.090 --> 00:41:51.410
and that we will set that invitation.

00:41:51.410 --> 00:41:54.010
And initially, staff would recommend

00:41:54.010 --> 00:41:58.810
that we start this process as once a month

00:41:58.810 --> 00:42:03.650
and say it's maybe the first Monday of each month.

00:42:03.650 --> 00:42:09.810
We want to make sure that many different viewpoints are able to be shared, and so the

00:42:09.810 --> 00:42:14.170
city of Twin Falls will work to maintain a list.

00:42:14.170 --> 00:42:18.490
We will work to have individuals come and that they will present.

00:42:18.490 --> 00:42:23.610
And I've had individual conversations with members of the different faiths to be able

00:42:23.610 --> 00:42:31.480
to assist in helping us put that list together.

00:42:31.480 --> 00:42:36.480
faith shall not preclude them from being able to give an invocation. In fact, we may have

00:42:36.480 --> 00:42:44.180
individuals who want to come and share thoughts and considerations, and they may not have

00:42:44.180 --> 00:42:55.250
a faith or share a faith. That there is a prohibition that should somebody use this as

00:42:55.250 --> 00:43:01.810
their own personal bully pulpit to provide disparaging comments against other religions,

00:43:01.810 --> 00:43:08.210
Should it not be used as a time of positive and uplifting message, a time of lobbying or

00:43:08.210 --> 00:43:14.370
request specific funding or support that they shall be banned, which is appropriate, from

00:43:14.370 --> 00:43:19.330
participating in this process for a minimum of two years before they're able to get back

00:43:19.330 --> 00:43:21.880
on to the list?

00:43:21.880 --> 00:43:26.560
An invocation may also be a moment of silence, a personal reflection.

00:43:26.560 --> 00:43:33.880
It does not necessarily need to be words that are shared, and that there is no requirement

00:43:33.880 --> 00:43:37.120
for individuals to bow.

00:43:37.120 --> 00:43:45.280
There is no requirement for individuals to stand, that this is truly a voluntary act for

00:43:45.280 --> 00:43:47.600
those who want to participate.

00:43:47.600 --> 00:43:54.920
I'm happy to answer any questions that you have with the religion, about the religious

00:43:54.920 --> 00:44:01.880
peace. Again, it is not just for Christ-based religions, it is for all individuals of all

00:44:01.880 --> 00:44:06.840
types of beliefs to be able to come and offer positive and affirming messages to the Council

00:44:06.840 --> 00:44:12.920
to set the tone on a positive note before you begin your deliberations. I would also have

00:44:12.920 --> 00:44:20.790
been asked about a time frame. When do we anticipate this would start? It's summer. We want to

00:44:20.790 --> 00:44:25.670
make sure that we have an opportunity, you should this pass, to develop the calendar to

00:44:25.670 --> 00:44:33.150
get individuals slotted and slated to make sure that we are creating a calendar that represents

00:44:33.150 --> 00:44:40.350
diversity and inclusiveness, words that we should not be afraid to share and to use, but

00:44:40.350 --> 00:44:44.110
really creates an encouraging moment for all to come together.

00:44:44.110 --> 00:44:49.880
So with that, I'm happy to stand for any questions that you might have.

00:44:49.880 --> 00:44:53.970
Thank you, Travis. Any questions or comments?

00:44:53.970 --> 00:44:54.970
Anyone?

00:44:54.970 --> 00:45:02.960
Just to kind of talk about it a little bit, you know, I'll start off with, you know, I don't

00:45:02.960 --> 00:45:08.960
have an issue with doing something like this, but I want to make sure in Travis you had stated

00:45:08.960 --> 00:45:17.730
it, is we're not opening the door for this to become a point of, I'll just say, solicitation

00:45:17.730 --> 00:45:21.970
for churches or things like that, or any particular religion.

00:45:21.970 --> 00:45:28.050
I think we've got to be pretty careful in that door that we open.

00:45:28.050 --> 00:45:34.740
This is something new for the City of Twin Falls.

00:45:34.740 --> 00:45:42.000
So I guess my concern would be, or issue maybe, is developing that list.

00:45:42.000 --> 00:45:43.000
Who's going to control it?

00:45:43.000 --> 00:45:46.720
Who's going to house that inside of the city itself?

00:45:46.720 --> 00:45:51.520
Would that be your office or would that be somebody else?

00:45:51.520 --> 00:45:53.680
No, it would be under the direction

00:45:53.680 --> 00:45:55.640
of the city manager's office with the assistance

00:45:55.640 --> 00:46:00.680
of the deputy city clerk to assist in making sure

00:46:00.680 --> 00:46:05.400
that there's the list that is created,

00:46:05.400 --> 00:46:09.920
that it is, I would describe, balanced and well-rounded,

00:46:09.920 --> 00:46:14.840
that we are notifying and reminding individuals.

00:46:14.840 --> 00:46:16.960
I'll give you an example.

00:46:16.960 --> 00:46:20.680
I'm hoping not only am I getting glasses,

00:46:20.680 --> 00:46:23.880
but I'm recognizing that if I don't put things in my phone,

00:46:23.880 --> 00:46:28.160
I forget, I had to remind it twice to take my kid's car

00:46:28.160 --> 00:46:32.160
into get serviced, and that was on Friday and Monday.

00:46:32.160 --> 00:46:36.120
So if someone is scheduling out nine months from now

00:46:36.120 --> 00:46:38.560
and they pull a Travis, we want to make sure

00:46:38.560 --> 00:46:42.560
that we don't leave an empty slot with their name presented

00:46:42.560 --> 00:46:45.580
on a calendar, and so there will be some assistance

00:46:45.580 --> 00:46:48.620
of just reminders, making sure that those dates work.

00:46:50.200 --> 00:46:53.440
If there's a need for a substitution,

00:46:53.440 --> 00:46:55.000
the city will fill that.

00:46:55.000 --> 00:46:58.840
It will not be filled by an individual.

00:46:58.840 --> 00:47:02.280
Part of that process is that we are going to have them

00:47:02.280 --> 00:47:06.160
affirm to the rules, that they acknowledge the rules

00:47:06.160 --> 00:47:09.400
and they affirm to the rules prior to them

00:47:09.400 --> 00:47:12.440
taking the microphone.

00:47:12.440 --> 00:47:15.640
We want to make sure that this is positive.

00:47:15.640 --> 00:47:16.840
It is uplifting.

00:47:16.840 --> 00:47:19.040
It is not disparaging.

00:47:19.040 --> 00:47:25.480
And it is not becoming secular.

00:47:25.760 --> 00:47:27.600
Just to follow up to that a little bit,

00:47:27.600 --> 00:47:30.560
you look at a resolution or something like that,

00:47:30.560 --> 00:47:33.920
should the situation arise,

00:47:35.560 --> 00:47:39.480
the city council would have the ability to stop

00:47:40.560 --> 00:47:43.600
this from occurring if it seems to get out

00:47:43.600 --> 00:47:44.600
Okay.

00:47:44.600 --> 00:47:46.370
Control is that?

00:47:46.370 --> 00:47:47.370
Yeah.

00:47:47.370 --> 00:47:55.530
Just like all meetings, the mayor has the ability to offer the invocation or excuse me to stop

00:47:55.530 --> 00:47:57.330
the meeting.

00:47:57.330 --> 00:48:04.520
One of the suggestions is that maybe it is not televised, you know, that it is not part

00:48:04.520 --> 00:48:10.020
of the normally broadcasted meeting.

00:48:10.020 --> 00:48:17.020
There are lots of things I understand that unfortunately we now live in a world that we

00:48:17.020 --> 00:48:23.260
have to take an abundance level of precaution even when you believe that you're trying to

00:48:23.260 --> 00:48:31.220
do something good and positive because you have political and process terrorists that want

00:48:31.220 --> 00:48:37.140
to come in and take advantage of different situations, which is a sad commentary on the

00:48:37.140 --> 00:48:42.100
places that we are and find ourselves. But I do believe in the individuals that I spoke

00:48:42.100 --> 00:48:54.820
to that they would be able to offer a blessing. Religions pray differently and so an invocation

00:48:54.820 --> 00:49:00.580
should not be viewed as a prayer. It should be viewed as an opportunity for a lifting and

00:49:00.580 --> 00:49:07.620
positive comment that may not be centered around any singular religion, not saying

00:49:07.620 --> 00:49:09.500
that it can't be.

00:49:09.500 --> 00:49:12.500
Thanks Travis.

00:49:12.500 --> 00:49:15.340
Thank you Spencer.

00:49:15.340 --> 00:49:16.500
Thank you Mayor.

00:49:16.500 --> 00:49:21.180
You know, prayer or an invocation can be very positive.

00:49:21.180 --> 00:49:24.380
It can be an opportunity to find some humility, reflect upon our blessings.

00:49:24.380 --> 00:49:28.380
It can be a time to think outside of ourselves into a higher purpose.

00:49:28.380 --> 00:49:33.420
It's also an opportunity for things that are a lot more harmful in sinister.

00:49:33.420 --> 00:49:42.540
It can be divisive, it can be a manipulative way to find moral high ground, it can be grandstanding,

00:49:42.540 --> 00:49:47.980
and as we talk about all the precautions to make sure that doesn't happen, I ask myself

00:49:47.980 --> 00:49:50.900
then why do we even worry about that?

00:49:50.900 --> 00:49:57.700
Let's not create the busy work for the staff, let's not open the door for issues and fights

00:49:57.700 --> 00:50:01.580
and battles down the road.

00:50:01.580 --> 00:50:04.920
This resolution, it does refer to our founding documents

00:50:04.920 --> 00:50:07.220
and, as I think, about the Constitution,

00:50:07.220 --> 00:50:08.940
especially in the time it was written.

00:50:08.940 --> 00:50:11.980
It's miraculously, if that's maybe not an oxymoron,

00:50:11.980 --> 00:50:15.660
it's miraculously secular.

00:50:15.660 --> 00:50:19.420
I feel like things have worked very well without having this.

00:50:19.420 --> 00:50:20.740
There's a lot of opportunities.

00:50:20.740 --> 00:50:24.340
You can hardly go anywhere in town without turning and seeing

00:50:24.340 --> 00:50:26.060
a church somewhere.

00:50:26.060 --> 00:50:32.220
people have homes, people can hold public gatherings and private gatherings and pray, and our meetings

00:50:32.220 --> 00:50:38.420
just don't need to have that to be effective. I have some deeply personal spiritual beliefs

00:50:38.420 --> 00:50:42.860
and I have regular practices that I hold sacred and I just don't share those with other people

00:50:42.860 --> 00:50:48.020
because it hasn't been necessary. And so I would ask that we don't approve this and we

00:50:48.020 --> 00:50:55.580
don't open the door for more divisiveness. I would love if it just simply worked and it

00:50:55.580 --> 00:51:00.300
bring us together and think of our shared values but I think there's way too much

00:51:00.300 --> 00:51:05.790
opportunity for the opposite to happen. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Sherry Volmer.

00:51:05.790 --> 00:51:15.860
This one's a little bit difficult for me because I have a strong spiritual side

00:51:15.860 --> 00:51:24.290
and I take that very serious and it's also somewhat private for me in a

00:51:24.290 --> 00:51:32.060
around about way. Anyhow, when I look at the City Council, you know, we're here to serve

00:51:32.060 --> 00:51:40.340
all. And we are nonpartisan for a reason, which I completely appreciate and think it should

00:51:40.340 --> 00:51:47.020
stay that way. But I also wonder about people who do not have a faith, and are we singling

00:51:47.020 --> 00:51:56.070
them out, marginalizing them? You know, I attend quite a few meetings that we start before

00:51:56.070 --> 00:52:01.590
with a like-minded prayer and I appreciate that. I just am not sure that the City Council

00:52:01.590 --> 00:52:08.870
is one of those places that we need to do that and I did write a little bit of notes

00:52:09.830 --> 00:52:16.390
because you know I didn't want to make it seem like I am anti-religion because I am not by any

00:52:16.390 --> 00:52:23.910
means. I appreciate the diversity of our community and I live and breathe every day by my spirituality

00:52:23.910 --> 00:52:31.020
But there are two options that I think about.

00:52:31.020 --> 00:52:36.280
If we do want to change things or add anything to this, aside

00:52:36.280 --> 00:52:39.200
from just not doing it and keeping it the way that we've

00:52:39.200 --> 00:52:44.560
been doing, I would recommend either a moment of silence

00:52:44.560 --> 00:52:51.910
or just real quickly, I'll read there's one that

00:52:51.910 --> 00:52:59.200
where such as a manager or mayor or somebody could come up and say something like let us

00:52:59.200 --> 00:53:03.720
take a moment to reflect on the importance of community respect and service as we begin

00:53:03.720 --> 00:53:09.240
this meeting, may we approach our work today with the wisdom and a commitment to the common

00:53:09.240 --> 00:53:10.840
good.

00:53:10.840 --> 00:53:14.800
That's just an example of something that we could do.

00:53:14.800 --> 00:53:22.120
I think it's very touchy for people, again, too, like myself, to say I don't know that

00:53:22.120 --> 00:53:27.860
This is the right venue for it.

00:53:27.860 --> 00:53:32.250
It's a very long conversation on my end.

00:53:32.250 --> 00:53:34.490
Thank you, Sherry, Craig Hawkins.

00:53:34.490 --> 00:53:39.300
Travis, I think, looking at this, I really

00:53:39.300 --> 00:53:43.330
would like to have the prayer in the meetings.

00:53:43.330 --> 00:53:46.660
I think that we certainly could use the help.

00:53:46.660 --> 00:53:49.700
But on the other side, that coin has brought out, too,

00:53:49.700 --> 00:53:54.460
is the possibility of abuse to it.

00:53:54.460 --> 00:53:56.820
I think I would probably tend to be in favor of it more

00:53:56.820 --> 00:54:08.180
I would be against it. It's hard to figure out all the angles that somebody could come up with to try and take advantage of that opportunity, but I'd certainly like to give it a try.

00:54:08.180 --> 00:54:12.130
Thank you, Grayson Stone.

00:54:12.130 --> 00:54:24.130
Thank you, Madam Mayor. So, members of council, I've gone through demons in my life all the way through personal and with my daughter, and I can't tell you how many times I've fallen to my knees and prayed to God and tried to figure out what's going on.

00:54:24.130 --> 00:54:31.570
there's no doubt in my life or reason to believe that I'm not a man of faith. I'm

00:54:31.570 --> 00:54:36.690
a very spiritual person. However, I also feel like we were elected to be stewards

00:54:36.690 --> 00:54:42.210
of those four doors and make those four doors be welcoming to anybody and

00:54:42.210 --> 00:54:48.970
everybody that walks through. I view the city council, someone as a board of

00:54:48.970 --> 00:54:53.770
directors, and then we're here to conduct business. This has been a really tough

00:54:53.770 --> 00:55:00.090
one for me, but I don't want anybody to ever feel uncomfortable walking into

00:55:00.090 --> 00:55:08.140
these chambers, period. I think if we open, I'm probably committing political

00:55:08.140 --> 00:55:13.140
suicide here, but if we open Pandora's box, it will be abused, and we're opening

00:55:13.140 --> 00:55:31.800
ourselves for liability, just can't get behind it. So, this is a hundred percent in

00:55:31.800 --> 00:55:37.410
favor of this. I understand that there are potential for abuse, there's

00:55:37.410 --> 00:55:47.330
potential for abuse and everything, had a conversation several years ago when we had

00:55:47.330 --> 00:55:55.120
something put forward and the individual shared with me, you don't legislate on the

00:55:55.120 --> 00:56:07.160
what ifs or the it could happen because yes they will happen but I believe whether you

00:56:07.160 --> 00:56:12.180
invoke the name of God or you come up and have a moment of silence, it is a way in which

00:56:12.180 --> 00:56:18.640
as a community we can come together. We can share one another's beliefs, had the opportunity

00:56:18.640 --> 00:56:23.520
several years ago to work with many on the interfaith council in our community. It was

00:56:23.520 --> 00:56:30.830
a great experience for me. People who prayed differently than I did, prayed to a different

00:56:30.830 --> 00:56:37.070
God than I did. And I was able to support them. And those who don't have a faith and they want

00:56:37.070 --> 00:56:42.950
to come and take a moment of silence, I am completely fine with that. And I think that

00:56:42.950 --> 00:56:48.510
But it's important that these chambers show that type of community, as we talk about different

00:56:48.510 --> 00:56:52.630
churches, or the lack of a church if you do not attend one.

00:56:52.630 --> 00:56:54.190
That's still a community.

00:56:54.190 --> 00:56:59.830
And this group can embrace that and stand together with that, no matter who's up there

00:56:59.830 --> 00:57:03.030
praying, we can participate or not.

00:57:03.030 --> 00:57:07.990
Just as we do with the Pledge of Allegiance, we don't force everybody to stand, we invite

00:57:07.990 --> 00:57:08.990
them to.

00:57:08.990 --> 00:57:15.970
this is an invitation choose to or not to but don't be offended I think it's a

00:57:15.970 --> 00:57:19.290
great thing that for our council and community

00:57:19.290 --> 00:57:27.380
Councilman Reed will you stand for yield for a question sir don't you think we

00:57:27.380 --> 00:57:32.300
do that with the Pledge of Allegiance on the get-go knowing that you were in

00:57:32.300 --> 00:57:39.460
Boy Scouts remember the oath correct God and then country prayer first oh

00:57:39.460 --> 00:57:46.800
Oh, it's second.

00:57:46.800 --> 00:57:48.060
We're going back to Boy Scout.

00:57:48.060 --> 00:57:50.890
You got me.

00:57:50.890 --> 00:57:55.890
So a comment I would make is I have probably more faith

00:57:55.890 --> 00:58:01.330
in fellow man than seems to be some of the rest of you.

00:58:01.330 --> 00:58:02.850
And I don't mean that negatively.

00:58:02.850 --> 00:58:06.410
I'm just saying I'd like to give it a shot personally.

00:58:06.410 --> 00:58:12.450
I know some of the people that are very interested in saying

00:58:12.450 --> 00:58:15.130
a few words at the beginning of council.

00:58:15.130 --> 00:58:22.380
I trust that our staff will vet out the crazies, right?

00:58:22.380 --> 00:58:25.380
And so, I personally...

00:58:25.380 --> 00:58:31.340
See, that exact is the whole point, right?

00:58:31.340 --> 00:58:34.340
Because if we open it up for everybody, then you're dictating what's crazy and what's not.

00:58:34.340 --> 00:58:38.340
If you're going to open the podium up, you're opening the podium up to everybody,

00:58:38.340 --> 00:58:43.340
and then you're allowing city staff then to dictate what is invoked.

00:58:43.340 --> 00:58:47.820
And so you so could I finish going? Yeah, okay

00:58:47.820 --> 00:58:54.460
So I personally would support this resolution as it stands right now

00:58:54.980 --> 00:59:04.200
So I'm gonna call on Chris since he yeah, yeah the motion anybody else have any other comments before they

00:59:05.500 --> 00:59:06.940
Jerry I

00:59:06.940 --> 00:59:11.140
My comment is not about anybody coming up being crazy. I'm just trying to

00:59:12.380 --> 00:59:14.140
Respect the people

00:59:14.140 --> 00:59:18.720
that maybe don't have a religion and that maybe we turn this into instead of an

00:59:19.060 --> 00:59:25.020
Invocation like that that we turn it into a moment of silence or that we turn it into something similar that I had mentioned

00:59:25.020 --> 00:59:28.860
I think when we get into different religions, I

00:59:29.740 --> 00:59:31.740
Appreciate celebrating different religions

00:59:32.260 --> 00:59:34.260
And again, I have

00:59:34.340 --> 00:59:37.480
There's many times I've sat in my car and prayed, but that is me

00:59:38.140 --> 00:59:42.380
I haven't asked anybody to come in there with me from a different religion

00:59:42.380 --> 00:59:50.590
And I think there's some other options that we can see.

00:59:50.590 --> 00:59:52.090
Okay. Thank you, Shari.

00:59:52.090 --> 00:59:55.090
Anybody else before Chris makes his motion?

00:59:55.090 --> 00:59:57.890
Just a minute if I can't jump in without hitting the button.

00:59:57.890 --> 01:00:02.590
I think, you know, just listening and trying to work through some of this.

01:00:02.590 --> 01:00:07.890
I mean, it's, I think my comment was is at some point,

01:00:07.890 --> 01:00:11.090
if we need to maybe take a step back, we can.

01:00:11.090 --> 01:00:14.090
It's not a requirement that somebody come in.

01:00:14.090 --> 01:00:27.650
I mean, and do this, so I mean, I am struggling a little bit again with this, but I think it's

01:00:27.650 --> 01:00:34.730
having an opportunity to promote some form of belief, we use religion, you know, however

01:00:34.730 --> 01:00:42.730
we want to do that, but we all have some core level of belief in who we are or some levels.

01:00:42.730 --> 01:00:48.450
So again, I think we need to, when my personal opinion, I shouldn't say we, my personal opinion

01:00:48.450 --> 01:00:56.370
is, is, you know, venture down this road lightly and again, I, I wouldn't, I wouldn't echo what

01:00:56.370 --> 01:01:00.710
the mayor has said is we do have confidence in the staff and helping us navigate through

01:01:00.710 --> 01:01:03.540
this.

01:01:03.540 --> 01:01:04.540
Okay.

01:01:04.540 --> 01:01:05.540
Yes.

01:01:05.540 --> 01:01:06.540
Go ahead, Travis.

01:01:06.540 --> 01:01:14.940
So on that, what I would share is, um, as we witnessed, uh, the legislature, every session,

01:01:14.940 --> 01:01:23.940
What law is or rule is on the books can be amended and changed slightly or significantly.

01:01:23.940 --> 01:01:27.940
And those modifications should this approve.

01:01:27.940 --> 01:01:39.670
Often are a reflection of actors or behaviors that occur that were maybe unanticipated.

01:01:39.670 --> 01:01:50.670
And I'm hoping that those that will help in that process will be respectful of the community,

01:01:50.670 --> 01:01:55.670
that we're not having to worry about these things.

01:01:55.670 --> 01:02:03.670
I share those concerns because that's the reality that I work in day in and day out.

01:02:03.670 --> 01:02:12.020
25 years ago I was significantly more naive but I would I like to share with

01:02:12.020 --> 01:02:21.000
the council all sides of the conversation as you are venturing into making a unique

01:02:21.000 --> 01:02:24.900
decision such as this.

01:02:24.900 --> 01:02:30.720
I'm sure you've got a question, yes just a quick question. So should this pass and I am

01:02:30.720 --> 01:02:36.960
I'm not concerned, the least of my concerns is somebody crazy coming in here and doing

01:02:36.960 --> 01:02:37.960
things.

01:02:37.960 --> 01:02:41.240
It's people being marginalized.

01:02:41.240 --> 01:02:51.600
So should this pass, and we want to change, make changes to this later on down the road,

01:02:51.600 --> 01:02:56.820
what is the process or how hard is that to change?

01:02:56.820 --> 01:03:01.580
It's a very, very, it's easy, it's an easy construct.

01:03:01.580 --> 01:03:08.380
During any council meeting, just as you have done in the past,

01:03:08.380 --> 01:03:14.220
during the advisory report piece, any member of the council

01:03:14.220 --> 01:03:19.820
from the Dias can say we would like to have this ordinance placed back

01:03:19.820 --> 01:03:27.750
on to the next agenda for conversation and reconsideration.

01:03:27.750 --> 01:03:28.950
It's that easy.

01:03:28.950 --> 01:03:30.870
So we're not talking months.

01:03:30.870 --> 01:03:31.750
No.

01:03:31.750 --> 01:03:34.630
No, we could.

01:03:34.630 --> 01:03:37.620
And if you're doing this once a month,

01:03:37.620 --> 01:03:44.040
and let's say that meeting does not turn out particularly well.

01:03:44.040 --> 01:03:46.000
At that very meeting, you could say

01:03:46.000 --> 01:03:50.920
we would like to bring this up for conversation to review

01:03:50.920 --> 01:03:56.020
and to reflect upon what had just occurred.

01:03:56.020 --> 01:03:58.260
This needs to be an agenda item.

01:03:58.260 --> 01:04:00.300
And so if it's brought up at this meeting,

01:04:00.300 --> 01:04:03.220
it can be on next week's meeting.

01:04:03.220 --> 01:04:09.570
Okay. Any other questions before Chris, Chris Reed?

01:04:09.570 --> 01:04:12.570
I might have a question. Sorry.

01:04:12.570 --> 01:04:15.570
Something was rolling around upstairs.

01:04:15.570 --> 01:04:16.570
I can see that.

01:04:16.570 --> 01:04:21.370
So ultimately, we have public input, correct?

01:04:21.370 --> 01:04:23.370
The end of each of our meetings.

01:04:23.370 --> 01:04:33.470
If somebody chose to take the two minutes for the general public input and come down and say a prayer, we would allow them, correct?

01:04:33.470 --> 01:04:34.470
There's...

01:04:34.470 --> 01:04:36.470
We've had it happen before.

01:04:36.470 --> 01:04:47.560
Yeah, so when you have less defined rules under the public input session than what is

01:04:47.560 --> 01:04:56.490
in the resolution, what I would say is the resolution would present, would prevent that

01:04:56.490 --> 01:05:02.930
from moving forward because we say that the invocation shall occur at the beginning of

01:05:02.930 --> 01:05:06.530
in the meeting in accordance to this process.

01:05:06.530 --> 01:05:09.570
But ultimately, something very similar to this

01:05:09.570 --> 01:05:11.210
could currently happen.

01:05:11.210 --> 01:05:13.690
We are just now structuring in a way

01:05:13.690 --> 01:05:15.490
at the beginning of the meeting, which we've

01:05:15.490 --> 01:05:17.610
had general public input in the beginning of the meeting.

01:05:17.610 --> 01:05:21.090
But we're structuring in a way in which we're

01:05:21.090 --> 01:05:24.610
asking those individuals to be positive, uplifting,

01:05:24.610 --> 01:05:28.710
whatever their faith is, or lack thereof,

01:05:28.710 --> 01:05:31.530
something that could currently happen.

01:05:31.530 --> 01:05:35.840
but we're just asking for it to be a little more structured

01:05:35.840 --> 01:05:38.640
and representative of our entire community.

01:05:38.640 --> 01:05:40.080
Madam Mayor, Councilman Reed,

01:05:40.080 --> 01:05:42.800
I believe the only prohibitions that you have

01:05:42.800 --> 01:05:45.800
on the citizen input session is that they cannot speak

01:05:45.800 --> 01:05:48.520
to an item that is currently on the agenda

01:05:48.520 --> 01:05:51.480
or bring up any personnel issues,

01:05:51.480 --> 01:05:55.720
and all personnel issues must be shared with the city manager,

01:05:55.720 --> 01:05:58.310
and if it's about the city manager, it goes to the mayor.

01:05:58.310 --> 01:06:01.870
Which we would hope those aren't addressed in prayer as well.

01:06:04.820 --> 01:06:06.820
I'll make a motion if we're ready.

01:06:06.820 --> 01:06:07.820
Okay, Chris.

01:06:07.820 --> 01:06:15.200
I move that we approve resolution 2025-002, creating a policy to allow for an invocation

01:06:15.200 --> 01:06:19.400
to be delivered at the beginning of the Twin Falls City Council meeting.

01:06:19.400 --> 01:06:20.400
Thank you, Craig Hawkins.

01:06:20.400 --> 01:06:21.400
I'll second that.

01:06:21.400 --> 01:06:29.320
Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Craig Hawkins to approve resolution 2025-002,

01:06:29.320 --> 01:06:34.400
creating a policy to allow for invocation to be delivered at the beginning of City Council

01:06:34.400 --> 01:06:42.180
meetings any further discussion Amy roll call vote please grace and stone

01:06:42.180 --> 01:07:02.580
no Jerry Volmer no Ruth Pierce yes Chris Reed yes Greg Hawkins yes Jason Brown

01:07:02.580 --> 01:07:11.360
yes and Spencer Cutler no thank you motion passes 4 to 3 thank you

01:07:11.360 --> 01:07:27.170
everyone for your discussion. Anything else you want to add? Just for the record, we're

01:07:27.170 --> 01:07:45.130
missing Jason Brown on the hope results. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Next on the agenda is

01:07:45.130 --> 01:07:51.110
an action item. A request to use water enterprise funds in the amount of three and a half million

01:07:51.110 --> 01:07:57.210
for the construction of City, the City of Twin Falls, Southwell number five. We have our

01:07:57.210 --> 01:08:02.690
City Manager Travis Weiler. Madam Mayor members of the Council, this item should

01:08:02.690 --> 01:08:09.250
appear to be like Groundhog's Day. This is a project that you have seen come

01:08:09.250 --> 01:08:15.050
before as part of our budgets. In each of the last, I believe, two or three

01:08:15.050 --> 01:08:21.370
fiscal years, we have come forward and we have communicated and talked about that

01:08:21.370 --> 01:08:26.690
need extensively. And really what this is, is it is adding a fifth wheel well in

01:08:26.690 --> 01:08:31.270
in our south well field to allow us to take advantage

01:08:31.270 --> 01:08:34.770
of additional water rights in that area

01:08:34.770 --> 01:08:37.070
and to be able to more efficiently

01:08:37.070 --> 01:08:40.850
and effectively deliver water into the community.

01:08:40.850 --> 01:08:43.950
Hydraulically, the water can flow downhill a lot easier

01:08:43.950 --> 01:08:46.350
than the cost of pumping it uphill

01:08:46.350 --> 01:08:51.090
and moving it throughout our community efficiently

01:08:51.090 --> 01:08:53.430
and effectively is obviously the goal

01:08:53.430 --> 01:08:55.790
of all of our enterprise systems.

01:08:55.790 --> 01:09:01.750
Unfortunately, we've had several projects that have come up that have had to require

01:09:01.750 --> 01:09:08.810
us to supplant this project from moving forward.

01:09:08.810 --> 01:09:19.950
As you recall, last Wednesday was last Wednesday.

01:09:19.950 --> 01:09:21.450
I'm Flice.

01:09:21.450 --> 01:09:22.450
Just last Wednesday.

01:09:22.450 --> 01:09:28.350
We had an amazing announcement inside the community with Chivani two Wednesdays ago.

01:09:28.350 --> 01:09:30.610
Yes, thank you.

01:09:30.610 --> 01:09:32.510
It's Daxes, I understand how they all go.

01:09:32.510 --> 01:09:34.510
Sorry, yeah, they all go together.

01:09:34.510 --> 01:09:36.870
But two Wednesdays ago, on the 19th,

01:09:36.870 --> 01:09:40.270
we had an amazing opportunity to participate

01:09:40.270 --> 01:09:43.830
in a groundbreaking ceremony where

01:09:43.830 --> 01:09:45.790
Tumani is going to grow and to expand

01:09:45.790 --> 01:09:50.430
with an additional $500 million investment into our community.

01:09:50.430 --> 01:09:54.390
And that investment causes us to no longer

01:09:54.390 --> 01:09:58.030
kick the can of this project down the road.

01:09:58.030 --> 01:10:04.810
So what we're asking is for the Council to authorize $3.5 million of cash reserves to

01:10:04.810 --> 01:10:07.330
be able to advance this project.

01:10:07.330 --> 01:10:12.970
And on this project, I want you to think of it as almost like a short-term loan from cash

01:10:12.970 --> 01:10:13.970
reserves.

01:10:13.970 --> 01:10:20.650
We're going to take the funding and have the funding allocated so that we can move forward

01:10:20.650 --> 01:10:23.770
with the bidding of this project.

01:10:23.770 --> 01:10:30.890
And then, we will budget for the balance of this project, and so, while we're taking

01:10:30.890 --> 01:10:36.770
and asking for the authorization, you will not be spending the entirety of the $3.5 million

01:10:36.770 --> 01:10:40.850
of cash reserves because they will not be able to complete the entire project within

01:10:40.850 --> 01:10:43.090
that calendar year.

01:10:43.090 --> 01:10:49.130
The balance of that project that we did allocate, or had planned to allocate in 2026, will feed

01:10:49.130 --> 01:10:51.850
back into cash reserves.

01:10:51.850 --> 01:10:55.530
So, at the end of fiscal year 26,

01:10:55.530 --> 01:11:00.090
we'll be, should be close, if not at the same cash reserve

01:11:00.090 --> 01:11:02.450
position that we are currently.

01:11:02.450 --> 01:11:04.770
And that is having an unrestricted cash balance

01:11:04.770 --> 01:11:10.250
in the water fund of $9,437,000.

01:11:10.250 --> 01:11:13.220
With that, I'm happy to stand for any questions.

01:11:13.220 --> 01:11:15.260
We got a lot of water experts in the room

01:11:15.260 --> 01:11:18.060
that can answer the technical ones.

01:11:18.060 --> 01:11:20.740
Chris, your name is still up there, are you?

01:11:20.740 --> 01:11:21.980
I'm a question.

01:11:21.980 --> 01:11:23.820
We've talked about this enough, I'm ready to go.

01:11:23.820 --> 01:11:27.380
But if folks have technical water questions,

01:11:27.380 --> 01:11:29.340
as a banker, I don't have any of them.

01:11:29.340 --> 01:11:31.260
I passed two.

01:11:31.260 --> 01:11:33.100
OK, Grayson.

01:11:33.100 --> 01:11:36.500
Madam Mayor, I'm just ready to support Chris.

01:11:36.500 --> 01:11:39.420
Anybody want to talk about water before we have it most?

01:11:39.420 --> 01:11:41.900
We should talk about prayer more.

01:11:41.900 --> 01:11:43.940
OK, thank you, Chris, please go ahead.

01:11:43.940 --> 01:11:45.380
I move that we approve the request

01:11:45.380 --> 01:11:50.780
to use the Water Enterprise Funds in the amount of $3.5 million

01:11:50.780 --> 01:11:55.780
for the construction of the City of Twin Falls Southwell 5.

01:11:56.800 --> 01:11:58.000
Thank you, Grace and Stone.

01:11:58.000 --> 01:11:59.500
Thank you, Madam Mayor, I'll second.

01:11:59.500 --> 01:12:02.400
Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Grace and Stone

01:12:02.400 --> 01:12:05.520
to approve the use of water enterprise funds

01:12:05.520 --> 01:12:08.080
in the amount of 3.5 million

01:12:08.080 --> 01:12:13.080
for the construction of City of Twin Falls Southwell Number 5.

01:12:13.960 --> 01:12:16.600
Any further discussion?

01:12:16.600 --> 01:12:19.160
Amy Rokavo, please.

01:12:19.160 --> 01:12:20.640
Sherry Volmer, yes.

01:12:20.640 --> 01:12:25.640
Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown,

01:12:25.640 --> 01:12:27.840
Spencer Kettler, and Grayson Stone.

01:12:27.840 --> 01:12:29.040
Yes.

01:12:29.040 --> 01:12:29.540
Thank you.

01:12:29.480 --> 01:12:32.120
Motion passes 7-0.

01:12:32.120 --> 01:12:33.920
Thank you, Travis.

01:12:33.920 --> 01:12:37.060
Yes, you have one more.

01:12:37.060 --> 01:12:42.700
Request to use up to $6 million in sewer reserves

01:12:42.700 --> 01:12:45.740
to fund the city's share of the expansion

01:12:45.740 --> 01:12:49.860
of the Northeast sewer line in Poe Line Road

01:12:49.860 --> 01:12:54.940
from the corner at Eastland to Blue Lakes Boulevard.

01:12:54.940 --> 01:12:56.300
Travis is back.

01:12:56.300 --> 01:12:59.300
I'm back, and I promised to leave after this one.

01:12:59.300 --> 01:13:00.300
Okay.

01:13:00.300 --> 01:13:02.980
Um, and they're members of the council.

01:13:02.980 --> 01:13:08.740
Uh, this project is also tied to Chibani's half a billion dollar expansion, but I need

01:13:08.740 --> 01:13:18.980
to go back, um, more than a decade and a half ago when this sewer line project first started.

01:13:18.980 --> 01:13:25.780
So as the city was continuing to grow and to expand, the city had started to make improvements

01:13:25.780 --> 01:13:29.940
in and to create a northeast sewer line prior to that.

01:13:29.940 --> 01:13:34.500
The sewer line kind of bisected through the community.

01:13:34.500 --> 01:13:41.980
The city started, generally down by the great, and it started to work its way east then eventually

01:13:41.980 --> 01:13:46.180
was going to make its way south.

01:13:46.180 --> 01:13:53.910
And over a period of time the city was able to complete segments of the project.

01:13:53.910 --> 01:13:58.630
At the leadership at the time believed that the city wanted to move the project, but it

01:13:58.630 --> 01:14:05.230
was not able to fund the project in any greater increment than about $250,000 a year.

01:14:05.230 --> 01:14:09.870
And so we were making small builds and small segments.

01:14:09.870 --> 01:14:16.830
And we had completed the section up to the corner of Pole Line and Eastland, and then

01:14:16.830 --> 01:14:23.080
in 2011, Chibani announced that they were coming.

01:14:23.080 --> 01:14:28.200
And as a result of that, they partnered with the city and they completed the balance of

01:14:28.200 --> 01:14:34.440
the sewer line in, I believe it was at or slightly under a year.

01:14:34.440 --> 01:14:39.400
There were three different projects, and I believe Spencer Cutler was working in the

01:14:39.400 --> 01:14:46.280
private side as I was reviewing old engineering notes that he was part and overseeing a segment

01:14:46.280 --> 01:14:53.520
of that line. And inside of your council packets there is a map that reflects the different segments

01:14:53.520 --> 01:14:58.560
that were completed and you can see the one piece that was not done. And that piece was

01:14:58.560 --> 01:15:03.680
not completed because number one we believed at the time when Chibani initially announced

01:15:03.680 --> 01:15:09.880
that they were going to be having a million gallons of sewer flow that we had ample capacity

01:15:09.880 --> 01:15:17.560
and the decision by in partnership with Chibani, that segment of the line was moved and we had

01:15:17.560 --> 01:15:23.720
always communicated with them that should you grow and to expand that segment is going

01:15:23.720 --> 01:15:26.000
to need to be completed.

01:15:26.000 --> 01:15:33.880
Chibani moved to a 2 million gallon per day and we evaluated and made the determination that

01:15:33.880 --> 01:15:39.720
sewer line had capacity for the area and the growth to be able to support it.

01:15:39.720 --> 01:15:45.280
With this most recent expansion, Chibani is contemplating at least a 3 million gallon per

01:15:45.280 --> 01:15:49.520
day and the line needs to be expanded.

01:15:49.520 --> 01:15:55.480
But in addition to that, it also accommodates additional growth inside of our water service

01:15:55.480 --> 01:16:01.720
boundary and potential other growth should that boundary be expanded.

01:16:01.720 --> 01:16:06.400
The one thing that you don't want to do when you're making this type of investment is to

01:16:06.400 --> 01:16:12.330
undersize it when the most expensive part of the project is probably rock.

01:16:12.330 --> 01:16:18.130
And so what we want to do is we want to make sure that the line is ample and it is going

01:16:18.130 --> 01:16:24.450
to be able to service the needs of our community for the next several decades.

01:16:24.450 --> 01:16:32.330
So in partnership with Chibani and the city and Chibani have both agreed to allocate or

01:16:32.330 --> 01:16:39.050
split the first nine million dollars of the cost at 50-50. And then in the event

01:16:39.050 --> 01:16:44.310
that there's any cost overruns the city will cover up to an additional $1.5

01:16:44.310 --> 01:16:49.610
million making your total liability of about six million dollars. And we came up

01:16:49.610 --> 01:16:54.170
with that because really the size of the growth for the balance of the growth

01:16:54.170 --> 01:17:00.590
area of impact is in that potential in that threshold. Should it be more than

01:17:00.590 --> 01:17:06.670
$6 million, our agreement requires us to come back and have a conversation about cost sharing

01:17:06.670 --> 01:17:13.390
and additional sizing of that pipe as we move forward.

01:17:13.390 --> 01:17:21.790
The current reserves in the sewer fund are at $16.619 million.

01:17:21.790 --> 01:17:28.630
This would leave $10.619 million should the entirety of the $6 million be expanded as a

01:17:28.630 --> 01:17:31.660
result of this project.

01:17:31.660 --> 01:17:37.660
those are all unrestricted. With that I'm happy to stand for any questions that you

01:17:37.660 --> 01:17:44.890
might have. Thank you. Any questions for Travis on this particular item? I can't

01:17:44.890 --> 01:17:53.530
see who that is. It's me. Okay. At least it's the only one I can see on there. I don't

01:17:53.530 --> 01:17:57.870
have a question. I'll make a motion. Go ahead. Quad move to approve the request to use six

01:17:57.870 --> 01:18:03.090
million dollars in sewer reserve funds for the city share of the expansion of the Northeast

01:18:03.090 --> 01:18:09.090
sewer line in Pole Line Road from the corner of Eastland to

01:18:09.090 --> 01:18:15.690
the Lake's Boulevard. Thank you, Grace and Stone. Thank you Madam Mayor. I'll second.

01:18:15.690 --> 01:18:21.690
Thank you motion by Jason Brown second by Grace and Stone to approve the use up

01:18:21.690 --> 01:18:27.690
to six million dollars in sewer reserve funds to fund the city share of the expansion of

01:18:27.690 --> 01:18:33.690
the Northeast sewer line and Pole Line Road from the corner at Eastland to Blue Lakes Boulevard.

01:18:33.690 --> 01:18:36.550
Any discussion?

01:18:36.550 --> 01:18:38.550
Amy Roll call vote, please.

01:18:38.550 --> 01:18:41.310
Ruth Pierce.

01:18:41.310 --> 01:18:42.310
Yes.

01:18:42.310 --> 01:18:44.530
Chris Reed.

01:18:44.530 --> 01:18:45.530
Yes.

01:18:45.530 --> 01:18:46.530
Greg Hawkins.

01:18:46.530 --> 01:18:47.530
Yes.

01:18:47.530 --> 01:18:48.530
Jason Brown.

01:18:48.530 --> 01:18:49.530
Yes.

01:18:49.530 --> 01:18:50.530
Spencer Cutler.

01:18:50.530 --> 01:18:51.530
Yes.

01:18:51.530 --> 01:18:52.530
Gary Volmer.

01:18:52.530 --> 01:18:53.530
Yes.

01:18:53.530 --> 01:18:54.530
And Grayson Stone.

01:18:54.530 --> 01:18:55.530
Yes.

01:18:55.530 --> 01:18:57.070
Thank you.

01:18:57.070 --> 01:18:59.320
Motion passes seven to zero.

01:18:59.320 --> 01:19:00.320
Thank you.

01:19:00.320 --> 01:19:01.320
Okay.

01:19:01.320 --> 01:19:04.320
That is it for items of consideration.

01:19:04.320 --> 01:19:06.320
We have a couple of public hearings.

01:19:06.320 --> 01:19:15.080
But before we move to those, this is a time for general public input, which is addressing

01:19:15.080 --> 01:19:23.960
anything that is not on today's agenda or is specifically on personnel issues.

01:19:23.960 --> 01:19:30.760
So anybody who wishes to address City Council can come down to the podium and you have two

01:19:30.760 --> 01:19:35.980
minutes.

01:19:35.980 --> 01:19:36.980
Okay.

01:19:36.980 --> 01:19:37.980
See no one.

01:19:37.980 --> 01:19:38.980
Bye.

01:19:38.980 --> 01:19:42.190
Yes, sir.

01:19:42.190 --> 01:19:45.570
Are you here for the public hearing?

01:19:45.570 --> 01:19:48.450
You're here to just for public input.

01:19:48.450 --> 01:19:54.860
Yes, you can come down then.

01:19:54.860 --> 01:19:58.820
Please state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and then you have two

01:19:58.820 --> 01:20:03.380
minutes.

01:20:03.380 --> 01:20:04.380
Where's that button?

01:20:04.380 --> 01:20:11.340
Where's that button?

01:20:11.340 --> 01:20:18.180
I'd like to invite the Council and the citizens of Twin Falls to attend the hands-off rally and

01:20:18.180 --> 01:20:24.660
protests that take place on Saturday April 5th, starts at 1130 at the Twin Falls City

01:20:24.660 --> 01:20:29.940
Park. Speakers there, Jim Jones is going to be there from the Republican

01:20:29.940 --> 01:20:36.100
Attorney General, Kaylee Peterson, a congressional candidate who will be there

01:20:36.100 --> 01:20:43.550
speaking and I've seen Iran, I hope I got her name right with Senator who DSA is going to be there.

01:20:43.550 --> 01:20:47.560
Indivisible, we have a local chapter now it's

01:20:47.560 --> 01:20:51.240
to involves county indivisible, part of the national chapter.

01:20:51.240 --> 01:20:53.840
This is part of a national day of protest

01:20:53.840 --> 01:20:55.520
and it's against the current administrations

01:20:55.520 --> 01:20:58.070
on democratic actions.

01:20:58.070 --> 01:21:05.890
We wish to speak out and we wish to be heard.

01:21:05.890 --> 01:21:11.690
As city councilman, you are given a unique platform.

01:21:11.690 --> 01:21:15.090
That's greater than I as a citizen is.

01:21:15.090 --> 01:21:18.290
Though we're all aware of what's happening in our country now.

01:21:18.290 --> 01:21:20.610
We have different opinions on it probably.

01:21:20.610 --> 01:21:23.050
but it certainly can't hide from it.

01:21:23.050 --> 01:21:25.330
Even though it's national issues,

01:21:25.330 --> 01:21:27.650
they will affect the city of Twin Falls,

01:21:27.650 --> 01:21:29.850
they will affect your citizens.

01:21:29.850 --> 01:21:31.890
And so I wish you to speak out on it

01:21:31.890 --> 01:21:35.170
in whatever form you choose to and not be silent.

01:21:36.010 --> 01:21:39.290
Please use Liz Cheney's example of courage

01:21:39.290 --> 01:21:41.610
who gave up her political future

01:21:41.610 --> 01:21:44.870
and spoke for country over party

01:21:44.870 --> 01:21:47.190
and showed the courage to speak out.

01:21:47.190 --> 01:21:49.470
Show an example to other people.

01:21:49.470 --> 01:21:50.470
Thank you very much.

01:21:50.470 --> 01:21:54.910
Final 10 seconds, public input on your invocation.

01:21:54.910 --> 01:21:57.710
We can't talk about anything that was on today's agenda.

01:21:57.710 --> 01:21:58.710
I'll come back.

01:21:58.710 --> 01:21:59.710
Thank you very much.

01:21:59.710 --> 01:22:00.710
Thank you.

01:22:00.710 --> 01:22:03.120
Thank you, sir.

01:22:03.120 --> 01:22:09.700
Anybody else have anything from the audience?

01:22:09.700 --> 01:22:12.300
How about advisory board reports?

01:22:12.300 --> 01:22:13.300
Anybody have anything?

01:22:13.300 --> 01:22:17.140
Then to the month, so it's probably pretty quiet.

01:22:17.140 --> 01:22:23.150
Any manager's office?

01:22:23.150 --> 01:22:24.470
Okay.

01:22:24.470 --> 01:22:26.470
So then next on the agenda

01:22:27.750 --> 01:22:35.350
In having a conversation with our planning and zoning staff the next two public hearings could take the balance of greater than an hour

01:22:35.350 --> 01:22:39.110
I share that in the event that the members of the council would like to take it

01:22:39.110 --> 01:22:44.390
That was my next thing out of my mouth is does anybody want to take a break five minutes?

01:22:44.670 --> 01:22:48.130
Okay, we'll be back here at six twenty five. Thank you

01:22:48.670 --> 01:24:47.410
Okay, we're way past our time to start

01:24:47.410 --> 01:24:53.930
So we're having technical difficulties and a couple other conversations over here.

01:24:53.930 --> 01:24:58.300
So who's up?

01:24:58.300 --> 01:24:59.300
Who's up?

01:24:59.300 --> 01:25:00.300
Okay.

01:25:00.300 --> 01:25:06.340
So the first item, public hearing is an action item, a request for a zoning title amendment

01:25:06.340 --> 01:25:16.260
to repeal and replace Title 10 items to include regulations pertaining to Chapter 2 zoning districts.

01:25:16.260 --> 01:25:19.930
And we have Jonathan Spendlove.

01:25:19.930 --> 01:25:24.570
And it's a public hearing so you could read the rules of the public hearing as well.

01:25:24.570 --> 01:25:27.890
Good idea.

01:25:27.890 --> 01:25:28.890
It's been so long.

01:25:28.890 --> 01:25:31.310
I don't know what to do.

01:25:31.310 --> 01:25:32.310
Okay.

01:25:32.310 --> 01:25:35.190
These are the nine steps for a public hearing.

01:25:35.190 --> 01:25:38.310
City staff will present the request and analysis.

01:25:38.310 --> 01:25:42.790
The applicant, which we are the applicant, will then present their request.

01:25:42.790 --> 01:25:48.630
The commission will, excuse me, the council will then ask questions of the staff.

01:25:48.630 --> 01:25:51.990
Other questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened.

01:25:51.990 --> 01:25:57.190
During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions

01:25:57.190 --> 01:25:59.710
about the request being considered.

01:25:59.710 --> 01:26:05.490
When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, then present

01:26:05.490 --> 01:26:07.750
your comments or concerns.

01:26:07.750 --> 01:26:11.710
You will have three minutes for this public hearing.

01:26:11.710 --> 01:26:19.310
the public comments are concluded, the staff will be invited to answer any questions. After

01:26:20.510 --> 01:26:26.670
the staff answers or clarifies any comments is needed, then after the closing statements,

01:26:26.670 --> 01:26:31.870
the public hearing will be closed and Council will have open discussion and take action.

01:26:33.170 --> 01:26:36.770
So, Jonathan, are you up or will or tag teaming?

01:26:36.770 --> 01:26:41.290
We're tag teaming. There's a lot here and awesome. Yeah, okay

01:26:41.690 --> 01:26:48.410
So the first item we're talking about zoning districts and okay switch the screens over here and I'll show you as we start

01:26:48.610 --> 01:26:50.890
I'm not going to step follow the staff report

01:26:51.570 --> 01:26:54.770
exactly really what we're doing is we're putting replace the whole thing and

01:26:55.370 --> 01:27:01.030
We'll walk you through what we have taken to the Commission and some of the direction the Council's previously given us

01:27:01.650 --> 01:27:05.930
Or this public hearing this is not the final public hearing on any changes

01:27:05.930 --> 01:27:08.290
This is like the middle public hearing.

01:27:08.290 --> 01:27:09.490
We're just input.

01:27:09.490 --> 01:27:09.990
Yep.

01:27:09.990 --> 01:27:12.370
And so we had our work session to give us direction to go write

01:27:12.370 --> 01:27:12.870
something.

01:27:12.870 --> 01:27:13.370
We've written it.

01:27:13.370 --> 01:27:15.610
We're now here taking input.

01:27:15.610 --> 01:27:20.330
There is at least one more hearing for all of the chapters

01:27:20.330 --> 01:27:22.530
to be brought back to you for any of the changes

01:27:22.530 --> 01:27:26.710
and all the direction we've had and probably more input.

01:27:26.710 --> 01:27:28.430
These things take a while.

01:27:28.430 --> 01:27:31.070
So I'm going to start with showing what we currently

01:27:31.070 --> 01:27:33.470
have for our zoning districts and the regulations that

01:27:33.470 --> 01:27:34.310
are within it.

01:27:34.310 --> 01:27:35.390
I'm not going to go through the whole thing

01:27:35.390 --> 01:27:39.730
because there's 76 pages of regulations on zoning districts.

01:27:39.730 --> 01:27:43.910
We'll give a few examples as we go through these.

01:27:43.910 --> 01:27:45.270
This is the table of contents.

01:27:45.270 --> 01:27:47.550
You get to a zoning district.

01:27:47.550 --> 01:27:49.990
This one being the agricultural district.

01:27:49.990 --> 01:27:51.830
This is what the coach shows today.

01:27:51.830 --> 01:27:55.720
You'd go through use regulations, permitted and special.

01:27:55.720 --> 01:28:00.280
You would then go through development standards

01:28:00.280 --> 01:28:02.880
that are here, their property development standards,

01:28:02.880 --> 01:28:04.440
and you go through what the use of the lots,

01:28:04.440 --> 01:28:10.840
a lot area, the occupancy, the building height, yards, which is your setbacks from the front,

01:28:10.840 --> 01:28:17.000
side and rear property, property setbacks, you'd have an access, landscaping, parking,

01:28:17.000 --> 01:28:25.080
signs, false fences, etc. That same flow or that same series is every district has that

01:28:25.080 --> 01:28:32.000
same thing. So the urban, suburban urban interface has the same uses, development, and so on

01:28:32.000 --> 01:28:35.830
and so on and so on. I'm going to skip all the way down to getting to

01:28:35.830 --> 01:28:44.130
air with me while I scroll quickly. The Commercial District, yep.

01:28:44.130 --> 01:28:49.450
So this Commercial Central Business District, the same. The difference being the

01:28:49.450 --> 01:28:54.570
uses that are put into this list of permitted and special and then the

01:28:54.570 --> 01:28:58.130
development standards are different. Obviously for a commercial district versus

01:28:58.130 --> 01:29:05.090
the AG district. The uses we are tackling in different chapter where we

01:29:05.090 --> 01:29:19.090
We've done a separate zoning districts and the uses to a separate list, it's going to be a matrix and you've seen a version of that in previous work sessions where you list all the uses and then the zones are going to be vertical and you kind of go through and find your zone.

01:29:19.090 --> 01:29:22.090
You find the use and be able to be permitted uses, especially uses.

01:29:22.090 --> 01:29:32.730
Today what we're really tackling is the development standards, which is this section, your lot area, occupancy, your lot occupancy, your building height, your setbacks, the landscaping.

01:29:32.730 --> 01:29:37.710
We're going to actually pull the landscaping from this and put it in some chapter.

01:29:37.710 --> 01:29:40.550
We talk about the percentages and all that.

01:29:40.550 --> 01:29:42.270
Parking we also pulled off.

01:29:42.270 --> 01:29:46.000
But that's really where these districts come into play.

01:29:46.000 --> 01:29:52.000
When we were going through this, there were districts that we've never used, like the residential

01:29:52.000 --> 01:29:53.000
mixed use.

01:29:53.000 --> 01:29:57.280
There's two commercial mixed use districts or properties that we have in town.

01:29:57.280 --> 01:30:01.080
There's a couple of other districts that we found that maybe shouldn't be zoning districts.

01:30:01.080 --> 01:30:03.280
Maybe there should be something else.

01:30:03.280 --> 01:30:11.710
has led us to this chart here. And we've showed you this chart before as well. This is the

01:30:11.710 --> 01:30:18.110
current zones in black, the blue of what we propose it to go to and this would be the proposed

01:30:18.110 --> 01:30:23.470
zoning districts on the far right. This would basically enumerate what the names are going

01:30:23.470 --> 01:30:29.510
to be and they coincide with what our comprehensive plan calls some of these areas. Ag stays the

01:30:29.510 --> 01:30:36.280
The same SUI suburban urban interface just felt real residential because that's what it

01:30:36.280 --> 01:30:37.280
is.

01:30:37.280 --> 01:30:40.630
It's rural and it's 1 acre lots.

01:30:40.630 --> 01:30:48.290
Our one and our two identical except for one thing, which is the rear yard setback.

01:30:48.290 --> 01:30:53.650
And so we are proposing those to be the same and for the properties that have the larger

01:30:53.650 --> 01:31:00.470
rear yard setback to now potentially have building closer to that rear yard.

01:31:00.470 --> 01:31:01.470
It's 5 feet.

01:31:01.470 --> 01:31:05.790
setback of 25 to 20 and that's the two differences so one of them would just

01:31:05.790 --> 01:31:09.330
have a little bit bigger buildable area on their property as we're proposing as

01:31:09.330 --> 01:31:14.670
they're nearly identical the R4 and R6 are separated central business become

01:31:14.670 --> 01:31:20.960
central city district and it encompasses the old town or OT zoning district downtown

01:31:20.960 --> 01:31:26.280
you'll see that later. Commercial just goes to commercial instead of C1 there used

01:31:26.280 --> 01:31:30.560
to be a C2 we back in the day and that's why they were one and two and got rid of

01:31:30.560 --> 01:31:34.000
C2 a long time ago, we figured we'll just call it commercial.

01:31:34.000 --> 01:31:37.080
Industrial districts, they separated open space airport,

01:31:37.080 --> 01:31:39.400
Old Town is only in a few blocks.

01:31:39.400 --> 01:31:43.240
When I say a few, it's a dozen or two so blocks downtown

01:31:43.240 --> 01:31:45.160
or less, and so that would just be encompassed

01:31:45.160 --> 01:31:46.880
in central city.

01:31:46.880 --> 01:31:49.440
And then you have these mixed uses that nobody's ever used

01:31:49.440 --> 01:31:52.280
separately other than like a commercial mixed use.

01:31:52.280 --> 01:31:55.040
And really, we're just gonna make them just one district.

01:31:55.040 --> 01:31:56.600
The SI stays the same.

01:31:56.600 --> 01:31:59.400
This mobile home overlay district,

01:31:59.400 --> 01:32:01.140
The overlays is where we end up having some

01:32:01.140 --> 01:32:03.720
that we eliminate or change.

01:32:03.720 --> 01:32:06.200
That was a result of a bygone area.

01:32:06.200 --> 01:32:08.160
We don't utilize that anymore.

01:32:08.160 --> 01:32:11.400
You can't actually say discriminate against mobile homes

01:32:11.400 --> 01:32:13.560
or modular homes in residential districts.

01:32:13.560 --> 01:32:15.320
The states come up with a statute.

01:32:15.320 --> 01:32:17.400
You just need to eliminate that one.

01:32:17.400 --> 01:32:18.600
Special office stays the same,

01:32:18.600 --> 01:32:23.600
Canyon rim stays the same, NCO overlay is now combined

01:32:24.940 --> 01:32:27.920
with residential business community market district.

01:32:27.920 --> 01:32:29.440
And this warehouse overlay district really

01:32:29.440 --> 01:32:34.320
historic district and we have a separate chapter for historic districts so it needs

01:32:34.320 --> 01:32:39.160
to just be moved from zoning. In the end we have this list and we've added to it

01:32:39.160 --> 01:32:45.230
the parking overlays and we have for our conversations earlier gone from three

01:32:45.230 --> 01:32:53.080
parking overlays to the parking overlay that was just like a in-person reduction

01:32:53.080 --> 01:32:57.470
and essentially we rolled that into the no-

01:32:57.470 --> 01:32:59.550
or I think we did the case-by-case

01:32:59.550 --> 01:33:01.670
or the turn-to-do-roll them into.

01:33:01.670 --> 01:33:02.750
I'm looking at Will, turn-to-remember,

01:33:02.750 --> 01:33:04.590
which one we rolled it into.

01:33:04.590 --> 01:33:06.590
I think we made the no-required parking larger

01:33:06.590 --> 01:33:08.790
and the case-by-case is the same.

01:33:08.790 --> 01:33:13.530
Yes, that's fine on there.

01:33:13.530 --> 01:33:17.010
This is the chart that we would go towards the districts.

01:33:17.010 --> 01:33:18.690
Pausing, because we have a lot to go through,

01:33:18.690 --> 01:33:20.700
I just wanna make sure we're,

01:33:20.700 --> 01:33:23.100
these are districts and these are the names,

01:33:23.100 --> 01:33:24.940
they are the names aren't set in stone

01:33:24.940 --> 01:33:28.020
if there's any, are we're over any of the names,

01:33:28.020 --> 01:33:29.900
to reaffirm what we've talked about previously

01:33:29.900 --> 01:33:34.260
and going forward.

01:33:34.260 --> 01:33:36.340
Any questions, Grayson?

01:33:36.340 --> 01:33:37.340
Thank you, Madam Mayor.

01:33:37.340 --> 01:33:38.180
Director Spinlove.

01:33:38.180 --> 01:33:42.270
So on the old town, if I remember correctly,

01:33:42.270 --> 01:33:44.410
and I'm sure you're going to get to this,

01:33:44.410 --> 01:33:47.750
the uses were pretty liberal as far as like what you could do

01:33:47.750 --> 01:33:52.550
there in comparison to central, what you're now calling,

01:33:52.550 --> 01:33:53.430
Central City.

01:33:53.430 --> 01:33:53.930
Correct.

01:33:53.790 --> 01:33:55.470
Is it still there?

01:33:55.470 --> 01:33:56.790
Should I brush my memory?

01:33:56.790 --> 01:33:58.950
We've gone through, we're going to look through that.

01:33:58.950 --> 01:34:03.110
We've gone through to see if any of the uses are being lost.

01:34:03.110 --> 01:34:07.830
We don't believe any of them are being lost, meaning there's no taking of a property right

01:34:07.830 --> 01:34:13.390
that we have identified on any of the properties to make sure that it is more difficult to build

01:34:13.390 --> 01:34:14.390
in that area.

01:34:14.390 --> 01:34:16.390
That's typically on fourth enhancement.

01:34:16.390 --> 01:34:21.190
It's like actually where the old warehouse is, the old warehouse area.

01:34:21.190 --> 01:34:22.190
Correct.

01:34:22.190 --> 01:34:23.910
I think we're focused on the URA District too.

01:34:23.910 --> 01:34:26.390
some of the URAs in there, it's almost like

01:34:26.390 --> 01:34:28.070
Treasure Valley coffees in the old town,

01:34:28.070 --> 01:34:31.440
which is part of the issue is warehousing

01:34:31.440 --> 01:34:33.400
in that district was not permitted.

01:34:33.400 --> 01:34:35.040
Correct. It was a special use,

01:34:35.040 --> 01:34:37.720
but it was only where their warehouses were.

01:34:37.720 --> 01:34:39.240
Just wanna make sure we're on the same page.

01:34:39.240 --> 01:34:46.390
Yeah. Thank you.

01:34:46.390 --> 01:34:50.790
This is the new format, and what we've gone to

01:34:50.790 --> 01:34:53.270
is pulling out each of those individual districts

01:34:53.270 --> 01:34:56.110
that had basically the same regulation,

01:34:56.110 --> 01:34:59.110
and we made the standards applicable to all districts.

01:34:59.110 --> 01:35:04.190
So when we talk about access, malls, fences, hedges, those are the same language in every

01:35:04.190 --> 01:35:05.190
district.

01:35:05.190 --> 01:35:06.190
We're now just putting them all at the front.

01:35:06.190 --> 01:35:10.950
We talk about architectural projections, the interpretation setbacks, all the regulations

01:35:10.950 --> 01:35:14.950
that were the same in all the districts are now just up front so we can lose a lot of

01:35:14.950 --> 01:35:24.020
words throughout the whole 76 pages of document, including accessibility structures, and then

01:35:24.020 --> 01:35:25.620
you just get to open spaces.

01:35:25.620 --> 01:35:33.960
The great big old boxes are going to be drawings, and I have some examples of some of the districts

01:35:33.960 --> 01:35:34.960
that have been created.

01:35:34.960 --> 01:35:43.020
There will be drawings that give us a lot of dimensions in the list of lot area dimensional

01:35:43.020 --> 01:35:46.940
standards, setbacks, height, and all of that.

01:35:46.940 --> 01:35:55.060
Each of the districts will look similar in its form, but the differences will be building

01:35:55.060 --> 01:36:06.170
height, setbacks, that will be the same for every district, form and function with some

01:36:06.170 --> 01:36:20.950
of these main building, accessory building heights, commercial, this is a drawing I made, it's

01:36:20.950 --> 01:36:27.400
crayon, so that one's going to get better, and that is the intent of the handroom overlay

01:36:27.400 --> 01:36:39.590
and the maximum height, this is what one of them looks like, we're just giving them to

01:36:39.590 --> 01:36:47.650
to do a better one, a better one for TN1, with some of the setbacks.

01:36:47.650 --> 01:36:53.480
What we've asked them to do, or a consultant, is to have a drawing that's more like this,

01:36:53.480 --> 01:37:03.490
to show your setback, your height would be G, your setbacks off of the front would be C.

01:37:03.490 --> 01:37:12.580
That is an example of more of what central city would be.

01:37:12.580 --> 01:37:23.080
As we go through each of these chapters, those gray boxes would end up having things like this.

01:37:23.080 --> 01:37:33.740
In terms of the districts, we have modified a few of the heights at requests of some of

01:37:33.740 --> 01:37:41.320
the builders and developers, particularly of the leave in the rural residential zone.

01:37:41.320 --> 01:37:44.560
That's important to things.

01:37:44.560 --> 01:37:49.200
We don't have a lot of SUIRO residential and city millivolts, but we do have an agreement

01:37:49.200 --> 01:37:53.480
with the county to use our code, and that's why we've had that request.

01:37:53.480 --> 01:38:03.630
The request is to go up to 40 feet tall, so we reflected what they've requested, mainly because we measure the full height of the building to the peak of the roof.

01:38:04.430 --> 01:38:11.430
Some of those buildings out in the rural residential area are getting large and tall, with some of their

01:38:12.070 --> 01:38:19.820
second story or three story with the roof line being pitch being what it is, they'd like that extra five feet.

01:38:20.280 --> 01:38:24.120
We've accommodated that as 40 feet, 35 feet when you're on an acre.

01:38:25.400 --> 01:38:29.550
from the road is imperceptible, I guess,

01:38:29.550 --> 01:38:35.340
from the public way and potentially a neighboring property.

01:38:35.340 --> 01:38:37.780
Other than that, the only other change that we talked about

01:38:37.780 --> 01:38:41.620
was this town neighborhood one, which is the R1 zone

01:38:41.620 --> 01:38:45.060
and the R2 zone becoming a singular zone.

01:38:45.060 --> 01:39:26.040
And I can bring up a map to show it's not

01:39:26.040 --> 01:39:28.600
at something with our JS system that's not working at this point,

01:39:28.600 --> 01:39:39.120
which is what it seems to be.

01:39:39.120 --> 01:39:43.280
R1 zone, by memory, is predominantly in the northeast

01:39:43.280 --> 01:39:50.220
part it down over here. There are very few areas outside of that that have our

01:39:50.220 --> 01:39:57.080
one and extends to a lot of area that is not constructed currently. Most and not in

01:39:57.080 --> 01:40:04.160
the city limits. I know most of these neighborhoods are one. They extend down

01:40:04.160 --> 01:40:11.250
into Incins and on Eastland. Many of the newer subdivisions that have been annexing

01:40:11.250 --> 01:40:19.190
have been annexing to R2 predominantly for that rear yard setback and I think

01:40:19.190 --> 01:40:24.860
Their area is about 500 feet smaller, the minimum last size.

01:40:27.320 --> 01:40:35.680
Since this isn't working, I'm not gonna use this map anymore.

01:40:35.680 --> 01:40:52.270
The visual didn't work out, I'm sorry.

01:40:52.270 --> 01:40:55.190
So what we're proposing is the minimum area of 7,000

01:40:55.190 --> 01:40:58.630
and 10,000, that's the R2 zone currently.

01:40:58.630 --> 01:41:03.630
About 60% of the residential zone property in the city is R2.

01:41:05.310 --> 01:41:08.600
Bill's gonna find something, he might have a different map.

01:41:08.600 --> 01:41:11.920
So we're, we've had this discussion before,

01:41:11.920 --> 01:41:17.920
just reiterating this discussion what it really will do is allow for those

01:41:17.920 --> 01:41:22.480
properties to have more buildable area could be there for house could be for

01:41:22.480 --> 01:41:29.030
covered patio which is predominantly what we get a lot of those for I don't see

01:41:29.030 --> 01:41:33.630
negatives from my point of view to combining those two zones and just

01:41:33.630 --> 01:41:37.990
assigning the R1 into being the town neighborhood along with the R2 to town

01:41:37.990 --> 01:42:03.850
neighborhood one mayor if I can just jump in why Jonathan everybody's looking at

01:42:03.850 --> 01:42:04.850
If you don't mind.

01:42:04.850 --> 01:42:05.850
Chair, go ahead.

01:42:05.850 --> 01:42:06.850
I can just ask a quick question.

01:42:06.850 --> 01:42:11.570
So, Jonathan, it looks like we're trying to consolidate and make the code a little bit

01:42:11.570 --> 01:42:23.290
more free-flowing for the community that uses this area of our code a little bit more.

01:42:23.290 --> 01:42:27.370
Have we, have you talked to or worked through some of that with the development community?

01:42:27.370 --> 01:42:31.170
I know you guys have regular meetings with the developers.

01:42:31.170 --> 01:42:35.700
Have you received really a whole lot of feedback on this specific?

01:42:35.700 --> 01:42:42.740
not on the zoning districts okay the council would recall this we've been at

01:42:42.740 --> 01:42:50.880
this for here's the PDF for a long time 2018 was when we started a lot of

01:42:50.880 --> 01:42:55.600
conversations happen in 2018 2019 and 2020 and then they've fallen off as

01:42:55.600 --> 01:43:02.630
lives get busy I mean this has always been something to do for us in terms of

01:43:02.630 --> 01:43:07.190
specifics it's been available we've had these conversations brought up that we're

01:43:07.190 --> 01:43:10.430
rewriting the code, anybody interested, please contact me.

01:43:10.430 --> 01:43:12.790
There are hundreds of lines of code in different chapters.

01:43:12.790 --> 01:43:15.720
They may or may not be interested in all of them,

01:43:15.720 --> 01:43:18.080
but they've all been available and we've brought it up.

01:43:18.080 --> 01:43:19.440
Yeah, but I guess the biggest thing

01:43:19.440 --> 01:43:22.320
is that it does look like we're trying to streamline

01:43:22.320 --> 01:43:25.080
how to work through that, find some of those.

01:43:27.650 --> 01:43:31.130
Yeah, and predominantly, you're gonna see most of that

01:43:31.130 --> 01:43:34.010
when we get to the uses matrix,

01:43:34.010 --> 01:43:36.600
which is in chapter four,

01:43:36.600 --> 01:43:38.440
and conditional uses in the use matrix,

01:43:38.440 --> 01:43:42.980
where dozens of currently special uses

01:43:42.980 --> 01:43:46.660
are going to become what we're proposing conditional

01:43:46.660 --> 01:43:48.870
with the conditions written.

01:43:48.870 --> 01:43:52.470
We'll get to that in the next iterations

01:43:52.470 --> 01:43:54.030
as we finish those.

01:43:54.030 --> 01:43:55.710
This truly is what you're seeing up there

01:43:55.710 --> 01:43:59.990
is more of the purple that's darker in that eastern part

01:43:59.990 --> 01:44:02.920
and they're very little on the northwest,

01:44:02.920 --> 01:44:04.760
and that one's been rezoned anyway.

01:44:04.760 --> 01:44:07.240
So everything's on that dark purple on the eastern side

01:44:07.240 --> 01:44:10.600
is where the R1, the AR zone is.

01:44:10.600 --> 01:44:12.960
That would become town neighborhood with the R2,

01:44:12.960 --> 01:44:19.470
which is what's all around it.

01:44:19.470 --> 01:44:26.420
Any questions or anything on that part?

01:44:26.420 --> 01:44:28.960
That all in the city limits?

01:44:28.960 --> 01:44:30.160
No, okay.

01:44:30.160 --> 01:44:32.520
If you see a subdivision, it probably is,

01:44:32.520 --> 01:44:37.880
except for Woodridge and Longbow,

01:44:37.880 --> 01:44:40.680
which is where Will's cursor kind of are in Highlawn,

01:44:40.680 --> 01:44:44.080
that right there is not in city limits.

01:44:44.080 --> 01:44:51.080
But the R2 that's north of it is, that was annexed, and they wanted R2 because of the benefits of R2.

01:44:51.080 --> 01:44:58.710
The rest of those subdivisions are in city limits that are R1.

01:44:58.710 --> 01:45:04.480
That's all morning sun that is cursors on now, which is falls in Hankins.

01:45:04.480 --> 01:45:15.960
And then further up to the northwest is where you get into that eastland near the temple. Up or there, that's all in city limits.

01:45:15.960 --> 01:45:16.960
Okay, thank you.

01:45:16.960 --> 01:45:28.740
We will have visuals like this for every zone that have better depiction of the step-x, the

01:45:28.740 --> 01:45:36.550
use it or the bulk standards as we'll put to placement bulk standards to show the maximum

01:45:36.550 --> 01:45:42.440
heights and the setbacks other than those ones were not proposing many differences and

01:45:42.440 --> 01:45:46.590
were trying not to take any property way, but were trying to give us more back.

01:45:46.590 --> 01:45:54.210
One thing that we have discussed previously and are restating and reaffirming again is

01:45:54.210 --> 01:45:58.880
the change to the front setback.

01:45:58.880 --> 01:46:02.880
The front setback we'd like to propose 15 feet

01:46:02.880 --> 01:46:07.140
or habitable space, which is living space.

01:46:07.140 --> 01:46:11.140
So buildings could be built with like a front porch or a front living space

01:46:11.140 --> 01:46:16.610
15 feet from the property line. Currently that is at 20 feet.

01:46:16.610 --> 01:46:20.610
A garage would then have a 20 foot setback to accommodate the parking

01:46:20.610 --> 01:46:28.700
space off the road. We've talked about this before, everyone to reaffirm that that is

01:46:28.700 --> 01:46:33.020
direction we're trying to go in hopes that we can give more land area again to

01:46:33.020 --> 01:46:39.620
people to build front porches front covered areas and to have a different

01:46:39.620 --> 01:46:43.820
look of homes instead of the garage be the front it could allow for the homes

01:46:43.820 --> 01:46:48.460
to be in the front. It's a different look we're not forcing people to do that

01:46:48.460 --> 01:46:53.720
that's just an option for people to do and we would still allow for the

01:46:53.720 --> 01:47:07.180
driveway to be utilized for vehicles at 20 feet deep. That is the same layout

01:47:07.180 --> 01:47:12.460
out for every district, we're going to go through every single one, but we can.

01:47:12.460 --> 01:47:19.060
Other slight modifications are lowering minimum lot areas to be accommodating to what the

01:47:19.060 --> 01:47:21.720
developer groups and builder groups have asked for.

01:47:21.720 --> 01:47:27.700
It's not eliminating them, and you didn't always come eye to eye with every single number,

01:47:27.700 --> 01:47:31.060
but we didn't lower the amounts down to what made sense.

01:47:31.060 --> 01:47:35.420
And also I'm taking off about 1,000 square feet per lawn area.

01:47:35.420 --> 01:47:40.980
In some cases, we'll just say there.

01:47:40.980 --> 01:47:45.700
Real quick, just a general note on the forebaddying of this.

01:47:45.700 --> 01:47:49.660
Table 13 right here, where it talks about the lot dimension

01:47:49.660 --> 01:47:53.300
just summarizing it, you can tell that there's

01:47:53.300 --> 01:47:56.100
three items that we have NAN.

01:47:56.100 --> 01:47:59.620
That is NA for the entire code.

01:47:59.620 --> 01:48:02.780
our consultants and other land use codes

01:48:02.780 --> 01:48:06.780
utilize those type of dimensions, a future,

01:48:06.780 --> 01:48:11.440
and, or pretty regularly, that's pretty common,

01:48:11.440 --> 01:48:14.200
land use regulations and bulk and placement regulations.

01:48:14.200 --> 01:48:19.760
However, since we didn't do it, we chose not to put them in.

01:48:19.760 --> 01:48:23.200
Those are placeholders that, if we want to, in the future,

01:48:23.200 --> 01:48:25.060
we can get into it.

01:48:25.060 --> 01:48:28.120
Or if you don't think we need that,

01:48:28.120 --> 01:48:30.960
we can look at eliminating those as placeholders,

01:48:30.960 --> 01:48:34.320
because right now it just says NA for all of those

01:48:34.320 --> 01:48:35.440
throughout the whole code.

01:48:35.440 --> 01:48:37.200
It's a placeholder.

01:48:37.200 --> 01:48:40.640
We have not had minimum widths and minimum depths for lots.

01:48:40.640 --> 01:48:42.880
We've left that up to the market and developers

01:48:42.880 --> 01:48:46.340
to have minimum widths to be usable.

01:48:46.340 --> 01:48:51.340
We do have a lot coverage now, a maximum of 60%.

01:48:53.480 --> 01:48:55.760
In all of the time I've been here, no one has ever hit

01:48:55.760 --> 01:48:58.920
the 60% because of the setbacks that we have.

01:48:58.920 --> 01:49:02.080
and we did some brief calculations with the 15,

01:49:02.080 --> 01:49:03.760
five and 10, 15 on the back,

01:49:03.760 --> 01:49:07.840
you don't meet 60% coverage of the property for a building.

01:49:07.840 --> 01:49:11.120
So there's no point in having a coverage of a building

01:49:11.120 --> 01:49:15.740
regulation, because it never really mattered.

01:49:15.740 --> 01:49:17.700
Trying to give that power back to property owners

01:49:17.700 --> 01:49:24.000
to build on their property with some minimum regulation.

01:49:24.000 --> 01:49:27.120
Just going off the math coverage.

01:49:27.120 --> 01:49:32.120
So we currently do the 60% coverage period.

01:49:32.120 --> 01:49:40.120
I think this was more tailored to the Max impervious services, so not building placement, so you can't be building, can't be 60 percent.

01:49:40.120 --> 01:49:47.120
Typically, it's more along the lines of impervious surfaces on the back goes to stormwater retention.

01:49:47.120 --> 01:49:49.120
So that would be the purpose of that type of way.

01:49:49.120 --> 01:49:57.680
We're into the mundane stuff now. I know that we are.

01:49:57.680 --> 01:50:05.680
I'm just scrolling through all the other changes. We don't have any other changes to highlight

01:50:05.680 --> 01:50:09.780
light unless you want to go through them line by line to show which ones and

01:50:09.780 --> 01:50:15.540
now we've decreased some we've increased stop touch on the screen

01:50:15.540 --> 01:50:22.840
so we're done at a request from some of the developers this would be the R6

01:50:22.840 --> 01:50:28.660
district the maximum height currently is 35 feet and we had a request to go to 40

01:50:28.660 --> 01:50:33.660
this gets at them being able to get three stories without having a flat roof

01:50:33.660 --> 01:50:38.000
trying to get three stories in 35 feet you end up just with the flat roof design if

01:50:38.000 --> 01:50:41.360
if you can get up to 40, I think they would prefer 45.

01:50:41.360 --> 01:50:43.320
Gonna split the difference a little bit for us.

01:50:43.320 --> 01:50:55.930
40 could have some pitrups.

01:50:55.930 --> 01:51:03.130
They all look the same in terms of mixed use heights,

01:51:03.130 --> 01:51:06.090
get its 40 because here our six for their T and three

01:51:06.090 --> 01:51:09.600
is the same and then I'm gonna get to central city

01:51:09.600 --> 01:51:12.000
and commercial and pause.

01:51:12.000 --> 01:51:16.160
We did some fairly bigger changes down here.

01:51:16.160 --> 01:51:21.080
Central city becomes, ZB is Old Town in ZB currently.

01:51:21.080 --> 01:51:27.970
And we have proposed that maximum height to be 65 feet.

01:51:27.970 --> 01:51:31.430
By right, without additional public hearings currently,

01:51:31.430 --> 01:51:37.090
it is at 50, 5-0, without additional hearings.

01:51:37.090 --> 01:51:40.890
65 is that 15 additional.

01:51:40.890 --> 01:51:43.690
The process to go above that is still within this code

01:51:43.690 --> 01:51:49.480
to have two public hearings that goes to P&Z and the council.

01:51:49.480 --> 01:51:51.880
I will pause for discussion and direction

01:51:51.880 --> 01:51:54.840
on if this is an OK regulation for the council

01:51:54.840 --> 01:52:03.960
to keep going with 65. Grayson. Oh, thank you, Madam Mayor. How tall is 160? I knew you're gonna ask

01:52:03.960 --> 01:52:09.130
him. I had it in my head earlier. No, I've should ask you. I was gonna ask him. My bad. I think it's

01:52:09.130 --> 01:52:18.060
around that 60. Right at 60. 65. It's gonna be close. I don't believe it's 70. It's six stories,

01:52:18.060 --> 01:52:24.140
it's four and two. Right. And I'd know that the four stories were closer to that, like,

01:52:24.140 --> 01:52:32.740
It's better than me, Jonathan. I would have said less than a hundred, but I remember the number not being 70, I don't believe.

01:52:32.740 --> 01:52:36.740
I'm comfortable with it. I'd prefer to go downtown.

01:52:36.740 --> 01:52:56.670
And this CB District, like we can talk, map is, is the blue down here.

01:52:56.670 --> 01:52:59.670
We talk about Manish has shown, which is basically here.

01:52:59.670 --> 01:53:06.440
It does extend on long the seconds up to the five points, both south, these five points, west, five points.

01:53:06.440 --> 01:53:09.400
That is all of that area.

01:53:09.400 --> 01:53:13.070
The old town is down here, like down in this area.

01:53:13.070 --> 01:53:22.300
All of that would then be central city and those heights could go up to 65.

01:53:22.300 --> 01:53:48.140
Commercial zone, I believe we kept most of this and we kept it at 50.

01:53:48.140 --> 01:53:52.420
We are open for having that go to whatever height you wish as well.

01:53:52.420 --> 01:53:54.540
It's just a number.

01:53:54.540 --> 01:53:55.540
You can have that discussion.

01:53:55.540 --> 01:54:04.430
Other than that, I believe we kept most of the setbacks and all of that the same as it currently is in the commercial zone.

01:54:04.430 --> 01:54:11.550
When we're talking about parking and landscaping, those are in different chapters and so we've took all those regulations and put them somewhere else.

01:54:11.550 --> 01:54:16.600
Any discussion on commercial zone higher than 50 feet?

01:54:16.600 --> 01:54:24.850
Commercial being everything that's along Blue Lakes and Pole Line, some of Washington and Addison.

01:54:24.850 --> 01:54:25.850
Madam Mayor.

01:54:25.850 --> 01:54:26.850
Yes.

01:54:26.850 --> 01:54:31.850
The 160 building has an allowance of 85 feet.

01:54:34.930 --> 01:54:36.930
I knew it was over 70.

01:54:36.930 --> 01:54:38.930
You should have called me out on it.

01:54:38.930 --> 01:54:39.930
I didn't.

01:54:39.930 --> 01:54:42.930
Hey, Director Spillam, we're talking about heights.

01:54:42.930 --> 01:54:45.930
So we keep this 50 feet in here.

01:54:45.930 --> 01:54:48.930
They can still go from a variance, correct?

01:54:48.930 --> 01:54:51.930
They can still go through the process for extra height.

01:54:51.930 --> 01:55:00.400
I think I'm comfortable leaving it at 50.

01:55:00.400 --> 01:55:04.820
I think I would go a little higher for me.

01:55:04.820 --> 01:55:12.200
I just, as soon as I could eat and up all our farm land, and eventually we're going to be needing to look upward.

01:55:12.200 --> 01:55:19.030
That's on blue lakes, boulevard, and then poline as well.

01:55:19.030 --> 01:55:26.830
Harder to tell than this, pretty much anything a long Addison, Washington, west of Washington.

01:55:26.830 --> 01:55:31.310
Addison going east of blue lakes.

01:55:31.310 --> 01:55:37.950
There's a fair portion of C1. Then you get out towards where like B&B and some of those

01:55:37.950 --> 01:55:45.810
the older D&B, the newer D&B, all of that over there. Everything along Blue Lakes, including Fred Meyer,

01:55:46.940 --> 01:55:53.100
it goes back about what looks like a quarter mile in some spots. Everything at the mall,

01:55:53.820 --> 01:56:00.880
everything on Pull Line, other than the Las Lagos area right there. That is all C1.

01:56:00.880 --> 01:56:07.880
That's why I asked the question about the variances, about the height, they can always go back and ask for more.

01:56:07.880 --> 01:56:13.480
Jonathan, I was going to ask you how many people have wanted to push that.

01:56:13.480 --> 01:56:22.660
We've had a couple come in, they less than a handful try to push that 50 foot height right now.

01:56:22.660 --> 01:56:28.980
I would echo, I would prefer to go vertical before we go out if we have the opportunity.

01:56:28.980 --> 01:56:34.300
The variance is still, but at some point in the future is we start getting more pressure

01:56:34.300 --> 01:56:35.300
to go higher.

01:56:35.300 --> 01:56:40.300
I think it's a conversation that we can have to maybe revise that specific number for what

01:56:40.300 --> 01:56:45.620
that corridor looks like if we are getting a lot of applicants for variations and things.

01:56:45.620 --> 01:56:50.180
Again, we've created an easier mechanism than a variance.

01:56:50.180 --> 01:56:53.020
The state code has a variance being very specific.

01:56:53.020 --> 01:56:56.540
We actually just create a safety valve and say go to two public hearings.

01:56:56.540 --> 01:57:02.260
It's the criteria is less, it's just a presentation, this is why, and then you, to counsel, makes

01:57:02.260 --> 01:57:06.370
a decision with some mitigating factors.

01:57:06.370 --> 01:57:11.810
It is easier to do, and in terms of the number, a lot of the ones we've seen have been the

01:57:11.810 --> 01:57:16.570
number and they've included it in like a ZDA or something like that to get the extra height.

01:57:16.570 --> 01:57:23.250
It's not like hundreds, but of course I've been wrong already in this meeting.

01:57:23.250 --> 01:57:28.250
But as long as we create it, we're trying to streamline and make the process again.

01:57:28.250 --> 01:57:34.250
If we get a lot of pressure to say, hey, 60 in a commercial, I can readdress that.

01:57:34.250 --> 01:57:51.500
But if we have an under the current height, I don't add at this point versus making sure that our water system can do all of that stuff.

01:57:51.500 --> 01:57:56.300
That's from Brown to your point, too, on that commercial zone.

01:57:56.300 --> 01:58:01.300
Typically, where I have my professional capacity, I've seen requests for grants has been in multifamily.

01:58:01.300 --> 01:58:06.560
And in the code, it's C1, you can have as much multifamily as you want as long as you can park it.

01:58:06.560 --> 01:58:10.560
And so, I think, John, there are directors, some of you can correct me if I'm wrong,

01:58:10.560 --> 01:58:15.560
but, typically, that's when you're seeing your height variances in multifamily,

01:58:15.560 --> 01:58:18.560
where they want to take as much advantage of the footprint as they can.

01:58:18.560 --> 01:58:27.110
They have had some of those and some they usually go through a ZDA, I guess some of that.

01:58:27.110 --> 01:58:32.810
And they have gone a little bit over 50 spots.

01:58:32.810 --> 01:58:42.810
And lately, this is over here, lately we've had lots of redevelopment meetings where they've been wanting to go a little bit higher.

01:58:42.810 --> 01:58:53.610
And what we've directed them is if you choose to go that route, choose the ace amount you think you need to get what you want.

01:58:53.610 --> 01:58:55.050
to get what you want.

01:58:55.050 --> 01:58:58.530
The last one we had was the hotel on Bridgeview,

01:58:58.530 --> 01:59:00.530
or sorry, yeah, I guess Bridgeview,

01:59:00.530 --> 01:59:01.810
the best bike parking lot.

01:59:03.410 --> 01:59:04.610
That was the last one we did,

01:59:04.610 --> 01:59:07.050
and it was only about a five-foot variance,

01:59:07.050 --> 01:59:11.570
but we were trying to say, as least as possible.

01:59:11.570 --> 01:59:13.650
So we're trying to get people to stay closer

01:59:13.650 --> 01:59:16.170
to that number that we've already decided.

01:59:16.170 --> 01:59:17.650
And if it's much more, we say,

01:59:17.650 --> 01:59:19.370
that's really not too much,

01:59:19.370 --> 01:59:22.250
or that's not too likely to get approved,

01:59:22.250 --> 01:59:24.450
So we've been dissuading that.

01:59:24.450 --> 01:59:26.330
That is just for your information

01:59:26.330 --> 01:59:27.850
when you're making that decision.

01:59:27.850 --> 01:59:33.050
You have a decent amount of people wanting to go higher.

01:59:33.050 --> 01:59:34.850
So what is higher?

01:59:34.850 --> 01:59:39.770
55 feet as summer 55, so I want to go 75.

01:59:39.770 --> 01:59:43.290
So what would be that hotel being constructed, right?

01:59:43.290 --> 01:59:45.370
So it's three stories is what it looks like.

01:59:45.370 --> 01:59:48.370
I think back to the Councilman Stone's request

01:59:48.370 --> 01:59:51.570
is some of the apartment complexes

01:59:51.570 --> 01:59:56.150
your family have gone three floors, typically at this point.

01:59:56.150 --> 02:00:02.890
I don't know if we have any that have four floors, but what would that, if this 55 feet

02:00:02.890 --> 02:00:05.250
get us there, what does that look like?

02:00:05.250 --> 02:00:14.980
It depends on the hotel, if you're already putting an elevator on other floors.

02:00:14.980 --> 02:00:20.620
Then as your point was saying, go to a ZDA or something like that to work through that process.

02:00:20.620 --> 02:00:24.900
That's not hampering the situation through what we're doing.

02:00:24.900 --> 02:00:38.230
Not too greatly. We'll keep it at 50 for now. I would advocate we can look at it every year and say, do we need to raise it up next this year or next year?

02:00:38.230 --> 02:00:40.230
It's pretty easy to change this number.

02:00:40.230 --> 02:00:47.840
I think we can track that too based upon the applications for variances, which should be a pretty easy metric to gauge.

02:00:47.840 --> 02:00:57.240
Moving on to the industrial districts, the development standards are going to be the same for those two districts.

02:00:57.240 --> 02:01:04.100
we are proposing 75 feet in height for industrial districts. It's currently not that. It's still at

02:01:04.100 --> 02:01:10.460
the 50, but most of them have all gone for an additional height. This predominantly in these

02:01:10.460 --> 02:01:17.020
areas ends up being more for like a tall tank, a silo or silo or water, which is which gets a building

02:01:17.020 --> 02:01:22.700
permit, but it is not classified as equipment. Sometimes we have people that classify equipment

02:01:22.700 --> 02:01:26.540
that are taller like amalgamated and some of them have just equipment pieces that are taller.

02:01:26.540 --> 02:01:32.920
These are actual things that end up being between a building of somebody working in it and any piece of equipment.

02:01:32.920 --> 02:01:37.500
And I think 75 feet in the industrial area is okay.

02:01:37.500 --> 02:01:41.500
There are going to be properties where they're near housing that have been there a long time.

02:01:41.500 --> 02:01:43.500
Someone could take advantage of this.

02:01:43.500 --> 02:01:45.500
I think that is impossible.

02:01:45.500 --> 02:01:48.500
Those are really difficult to accommodate everybody for.

02:01:48.500 --> 02:01:52.940
But this would help a lot of our industrial users not have that extra.

02:01:52.940 --> 02:01:57.900
as we've seen Columbia do that a few times. That's kind of the height they're looking for.

02:01:57.900 --> 02:02:17.820
So that's 65 to 75 feet. Airport, currently we have a we have a set amount I can't

02:02:17.820 --> 02:02:24.020
remember what that height is. And what we've done here is just say as long as the

02:02:24.020 --> 02:02:32.690
airport's okay with it we don't care I'll tell you. Yeah we have if you're not 35

02:02:32.690 --> 02:02:35.890
and then you can authorize additional heights basically on the for these

02:02:35.890 --> 02:02:40.130
regulations. We're not an airport related. If it's airport related, then the airport

02:02:40.130 --> 02:02:54.210
board has a regulation on the airport property. For their heights to TSI, it

02:02:54.210 --> 02:02:58.510
has been some years, but we did talk with CSI a while ago, and we got through most

02:02:58.510 --> 02:03:03.830
of these that don't be changed anything from that. We went to 40 feet, they have

02:03:03.830 --> 02:03:16.550
a lot of their educational buildings that get up taller than 30, 35.

02:03:16.550 --> 02:03:18.310
And sir, did you have something?

02:03:18.310 --> 02:03:20.830
Yeah, of course I'd speak up when it comes to college.

02:03:20.830 --> 02:03:23.780
I looked at you and saw.

02:03:23.780 --> 02:03:31.880
When we redid our, we have some language in there

02:03:31.880 --> 02:03:36.640
about our building height following commercial district

02:03:36.640 --> 02:03:38.680
height changes or something like that.

02:03:38.680 --> 02:03:41.640
You very well could have, I am, that is, I will look into it

02:03:41.640 --> 02:03:42.360
and let you know.

02:03:42.360 --> 02:03:44.990
I'll double check that too.

02:03:44.990 --> 02:03:52.080
And if that were the case, CSI being where it's located,

02:03:52.080 --> 02:03:54.780
I see no issue with it being that way.

02:03:54.780 --> 02:03:56.970
From my perspective at all.

02:03:56.970 --> 02:03:59.530
Because I think we have additional provisions

02:03:59.530 --> 02:04:02.330
that give us additional setbacks or landscape barriers.

02:04:02.330 --> 02:04:05.450
So the taller buildings are forced

02:04:05.450 --> 02:04:08.370
to be on the inner part of campus.

02:04:08.370 --> 02:04:13.330
I'll review that too.

02:04:13.330 --> 02:04:14.800
Thank you.

02:04:14.800 --> 02:04:16.080
That's all for the zoning districts.

02:04:16.080 --> 02:04:17.720
A lot of the regulation that was written

02:04:17.720 --> 02:04:21.590
is now in different chapters because going to end up

02:04:21.590 --> 02:04:24.030
being confusing this district.

02:04:24.030 --> 02:04:26.230
Any further questions on zoning districts?

02:04:26.230 --> 02:04:30.230
Any questions for staff before I open up the public hearing?

02:04:30.230 --> 02:04:34.690
Okay.

02:04:34.690 --> 02:04:39.410
The no one.

02:04:39.410 --> 02:04:42.410
So next I'm opening up the public hearing.

02:04:42.410 --> 02:04:50.410
There's anybody in the audience that wishes to address any items pertaining to Chapter 2 zoning districts.

02:04:50.410 --> 02:04:59.780
Please come down to the podium, state your name, and address and present your comments or concerns.

02:04:59.780 --> 02:05:12.370
Anybody for zoning, chapter two zoning districts?

02:05:12.370 --> 02:05:15.850
No, we're not close to public hearing any comments.

02:05:15.850 --> 02:05:16.930
Closing comments?

02:05:16.930 --> 02:05:19.930
I don't have it other than this is the general direction

02:05:19.930 --> 02:05:22.210
we will take and we'll finish out the items

02:05:22.210 --> 02:05:23.730
with the changes in any modifications

02:05:23.730 --> 02:05:25.570
we see that are problems.

02:05:25.570 --> 02:05:27.210
We will see this at an additional hearing,

02:05:27.210 --> 02:05:29.850
or two or three, however many we get

02:05:29.850 --> 02:05:32.090
in order to, you know, direct it to have

02:05:32.090 --> 02:05:33.770
and we'll go from there.

02:05:34.610 --> 02:05:37.130
Anybody have any comments on this?

02:05:37.130 --> 02:05:40.120
Thank you for your work on it.

02:05:40.120 --> 02:05:42.120
Yes, thank you very much.

02:05:42.120 --> 02:05:45.080
Almost the finish line.

02:05:45.080 --> 02:05:47.080
Okay.

02:05:47.080 --> 02:05:50.820
And you can do a vote to say that's the direction taken.

02:05:50.820 --> 02:05:51.820
I'm sorry.

02:05:51.820 --> 02:05:57.390
So would somebody like to make a motion that we're comfortable with this direction?

02:05:57.390 --> 02:06:04.220
I'd move to approve or move to, we're not really approving, are we?

02:06:04.220 --> 02:06:06.220
Support the direction.

02:06:06.220 --> 02:06:11.920
I'd moved to support the direction that the planning and zoning staff have taken on the title 10

02:06:13.580 --> 02:06:16.700
Chapter two zoning districts. Thank you. Do I have a second?

02:06:18.040 --> 02:06:21.960
Thank you motion by Jason Brown seconded by Craig Hawkins to

02:06:23.720 --> 02:06:31.180
You didn't say approve what where did you support? Thank you. That was the one I was told. Yes

02:06:34.920 --> 02:06:36.920
Forgot already, okay

02:06:36.920 --> 02:06:43.200
Support the title 10 chapter 2 zoning district change it zoning district

02:06:44.280 --> 02:06:46.280
regulations as presented

02:06:46.560 --> 02:06:50.610
any further discussion

02:06:51.090 --> 02:06:53.090
Amy roll call vote, please

02:06:53.860 --> 02:07:01.940
Ruth Pierce yes, yes, yes, Craig Hawkins. Yes Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Grayson Stone

02:07:01.940 --> 02:07:07.140
Yes, and Sherry Vomer. Yes. Thank you motion passes 7 to 0

02:07:07.140 --> 02:07:15.390
Okay, next is an action item that will basically go the same format, request for a zoning

02:07:15.390 --> 02:07:24.520
title amendment to repeal and replace Title 10, focusing on Chapter 6 Landscaping Regulations.

02:07:24.520 --> 02:07:26.880
Is this you, Will, or both?

02:07:26.880 --> 02:07:27.880
No, same thing.

02:07:27.880 --> 02:07:28.880
This is both, again.

02:07:28.880 --> 02:07:31.670
Okay.

02:07:31.670 --> 02:07:33.670
I'm trying to do this again.

02:07:33.670 --> 02:07:40.000
These are the current regulations found in the property development standards for each

02:07:40.000 --> 02:07:43.520
of the zones and for the landscaping sections.

02:07:43.520 --> 02:07:45.910
And this is we've highlighted.

02:07:45.910 --> 02:07:49.470
This is where they all talk about what the zone

02:07:49.470 --> 02:07:52.110
or how much landscaping is it be placed on the property.

02:07:52.110 --> 02:07:53.430
And then we'll go through the items

02:07:53.430 --> 02:07:56.750
and how much as many trees and shrubs are gonna be put

02:07:56.750 --> 02:07:58.810
on the property.

02:07:58.810 --> 02:08:00.130
As we talked about in the districts,

02:08:00.130 --> 02:08:02.410
the landscaping is within each chapter

02:08:02.410 --> 02:08:03.570
or each zoning district.

02:08:03.570 --> 02:08:07.980
And that's what we've put on here is each one of these,

02:08:07.980 --> 02:08:09.380
this one's the SUI district,

02:08:09.380 --> 02:08:13.160
and it has these regulations.

02:08:13.160 --> 02:08:20.980
This one is the R1 variable and it has these regulations.

02:08:20.980 --> 02:08:22.760
So forth, I'm gonna keep scrolling down

02:08:22.760 --> 02:08:24.680
as we go through each one.

02:08:24.680 --> 02:08:27.040
Each district will have its own.

02:08:27.040 --> 02:08:33.320
There'll be a chart that we're gonna get to in a minute.

02:08:33.320 --> 02:08:38.380
It gets more complicated when you get to the M2 district

02:08:38.380 --> 02:08:40.920
and it talks about non-residential uses,

02:08:40.920 --> 02:08:43.320
two square feet per linear foot of frontage,

02:08:43.320 --> 02:08:45.480
placed between the building and the street,

02:08:45.480 --> 02:08:52.150
We have that commission, if there's a zero setback line,

02:08:52.150 --> 02:08:54.430
the open space just says the commission sets them

02:08:54.430 --> 02:09:02.090
amount of the other ones, like commercial.

02:09:02.090 --> 02:09:03.970
There's so many pages up the airport district,

02:09:03.970 --> 02:09:06.320
but it's all the same.

02:09:06.320 --> 02:09:09.720
It's commercial use, 10% of the total required parking area

02:09:09.720 --> 02:09:12.910
or 3% of the total land area.

02:09:12.910 --> 02:09:14.630
That regulation is very common through

02:09:14.630 --> 02:09:19.950
the commercial zone and some others.

02:09:19.950 --> 02:09:22.630
And then this gets to the old town district,

02:09:22.630 --> 02:09:25.510
which is very specific in the old town district

02:09:25.510 --> 02:09:28.270
for a lot of different things.

02:09:28.270 --> 02:09:30.430
Frankly, a lot of people can't meet some of these things

02:09:30.430 --> 02:09:33.830
because there's zero setbacks.

02:09:33.830 --> 02:09:35.510
We have like the 30 inch high masonry wall

02:09:35.510 --> 02:09:36.830
hander shrub plant,

02:09:36.830 --> 02:09:40.620
provided between the parking lot and public sidewalk.

02:09:40.620 --> 02:09:43.920
We're room for that in the old town district.

02:09:43.920 --> 02:09:45.560
Usually the current regulations again,

02:09:45.560 --> 02:09:48.040
this is what we currently have in the code.

02:09:48.040 --> 02:09:50.000
Watermark has on there.

02:09:50.000 --> 02:09:51.120
I'm trying to get through all of them

02:09:51.120 --> 02:09:56.310
because they all say very similar 10%.

02:09:56.310 --> 02:10:03.040
The site, 25% of each property, we maintained,

02:10:03.040 --> 02:10:09.580
that is the Special Office Overlay District,

02:10:09.580 --> 02:10:12.400
warehouse, historic overlay district,

02:10:12.400 --> 02:10:14.000
has something that's just

02:10:14.000 --> 02:10:20.930
a store preservation commission, the last one,

02:10:20.930 --> 02:10:22.690
special landscaping requirements,

02:10:22.690 --> 02:10:24.590
fronting the college,

02:10:24.590 --> 02:10:25.810
special landscaping requirements

02:10:25.810 --> 02:10:30.040
for gateway arterials, is a different section.

02:10:30.040 --> 02:10:33.240
And then this is the general landscaping.

02:10:33.240 --> 02:10:38.420
I get through all the regulation down to 10, 11, 2,

02:10:38.420 --> 02:10:43.420
This tells us how much land area we devote to landscaping in a project.

02:10:43.420 --> 02:10:47.740
That's what all of those regulations in those previous 19 pages are.

02:10:47.740 --> 02:10:49.740
We are in a certain district.

02:10:49.740 --> 02:10:52.740
You have a certain percentage of the project or the land area.

02:10:52.740 --> 02:10:53.740
It's like 10%.

02:10:53.740 --> 02:10:56.740
That gives you a square footage amount of your property.

02:10:56.740 --> 02:11:08.380
10, 11, 2, then talked about how much trees and shrubs you had to place on the property based on one tree per 500 square feet and one bush or shrub per 100 square feet.

02:11:08.380 --> 02:11:14.840
square feet, which we all understand and that's where we're at. Gateway

02:11:14.840 --> 02:11:23.240
materials were specific to these roads, highlighted there, Addison Avenue, Addison

02:11:23.240 --> 02:11:26.920
Avenue East, Addison Avenue West, Blue Lakes Boulevard, Blue Lakes Boulevard North,

02:11:26.920 --> 02:11:31.840
Blue Lakes Boulevard South, Kimberly Road, Washington Street from Addison to

02:11:31.840 --> 02:11:35.080
2nd Avenue West, and Washington Street North, Washington Street South,

02:11:35.080 --> 02:11:40.240
Bull Line Road from Rock Creek Canyon to Eastland Drive North, Eastland Drive from

02:11:40.240 --> 02:11:47.450
Pauline Road East at Kimberly Road. All of that of most of our arterials, one that's not

02:11:47.450 --> 02:11:54.780
on there is Hank and Droad. It's a gay arterial. Trying to think of another one, but I can't.

02:11:54.780 --> 02:12:02.140
Sunway might not be one that is not on that list. That list was done in 1999. Those were

02:12:02.140 --> 02:12:06.380
all of the arterials at the time that were going to be with the city limits. The intent

02:12:06.380 --> 02:12:12.520
of this was for people coming into town and are on the arterials having lands keeping along

02:12:12.520 --> 02:12:24.010
the roadway and at this regulation it has a 30-foot strip when vacant land or

02:12:24.010 --> 02:12:27.970
cleared land is being developed. Washington Street North from Madison to

02:12:27.970 --> 02:12:33.720
Casville had a 10-foot width because it was a because of the corridor that

02:12:33.720 --> 02:12:42.650
was changed in 2009 because they widened Washington and there was a 10-foot width

02:12:42.650 --> 02:12:49.150
if you had existing buildings being being remodeled. We clear on the

02:12:49.150 --> 02:12:52.400
This is going to be important as we get to the newer regulation.

02:12:52.400 --> 02:12:59.400
Another aspect of this that we've current is this is in addition to all other landscape requirements.

02:12:59.400 --> 02:13:02.400
You can't use them together to match.

02:13:02.400 --> 02:13:07.400
So if you are on this landscape aisle, you have to have that.

02:13:07.400 --> 02:13:14.400
It can't be utilized to the 10% of the site or the 3% of the site or 10% of the parking area.

02:13:14.400 --> 02:13:17.400
That's been a problem for a lot of developers.

02:13:17.400 --> 02:13:24.400
That comes from this first line that I'm going to highlight in addition to you and as part of the landscape requirements specified elsewhere, you provide this.

02:13:24.400 --> 02:13:39.240
This landscaping section is where you get to 500, 100, and it talks about how much and what it needs to be done, whether you can display vehicles, etc.

02:13:39.240 --> 02:13:53.880
That's current code, our proposed chapter brings them all under one chapter to chapter six.

02:13:53.880 --> 02:14:04.060
And we have the general things that apply to everything, just in this section here.

02:14:04.060 --> 02:14:11.960
We have, we're trying to apply them to all non-residential, the words up here say commercial

02:14:11.960 --> 02:14:18.520
uses, but really that means non-residential, and they apply to five or more residential units

02:14:18.520 --> 02:14:19.520
on a single lot.

02:14:19.520 --> 02:14:23.840
I've got to go back to my notes because when Will and I were going through this earlier,

02:14:23.840 --> 02:14:27.360
think we found some things were like wait that we didn't mean to do that as we

02:14:27.360 --> 02:14:41.720
checked it again and again and again. On D this is this is current code and we

02:14:41.720 --> 02:14:46.000
may need to have this conversation. All trees in public right away shall be

02:14:46.000 --> 02:14:48.440
maintained according to the practices established by the Twin Falls Street

02:14:48.440 --> 02:14:53.800
Commission basically per city code A4. Any tree that's not on private property

02:14:53.800 --> 02:14:57.920
comes under if it's in the right of ways under the protection of the city of Twin

02:14:57.920 --> 02:15:02.560
Falls. They bring property owners are required to maintain them but they have to

02:15:02.560 --> 02:15:06.800
get an arborist to take care of them or to trim them.

02:15:06.800 --> 02:15:12.250
Chance Munns is the responsible party for that program.

02:15:15.120 --> 02:15:16.520
We basically were just mirroring

02:15:16.520 --> 02:15:18.640
what the code said somewhere else.

02:15:18.640 --> 02:15:21.280
That's a topic that may come up under discussion tonight.

02:15:21.280 --> 02:15:23.760
I'd say that code section is not being changed

02:15:23.760 --> 02:15:25.760
with what we're proposing.

02:15:25.760 --> 02:15:30.500
That's a code section that's found in Title A, Chapter Four.

02:15:30.500 --> 02:15:32.780
And if that is a topic of conversation,

02:15:32.780 --> 02:15:35.040
I'd certainly bring it up.

02:15:35.040 --> 02:15:37.300
It would just need to be changed over in that other title,

02:15:37.300 --> 02:15:38.920
not necessarily this one.

02:15:38.920 --> 02:15:41.000
It would just mirror whatever that says.

02:15:41.000 --> 02:15:43.680
So do we even have a tree commission anymore?

02:15:43.680 --> 02:15:45.560
Yep, you've assigned it to the Parks and Rec Commission.

02:15:45.560 --> 02:15:46.400
Okay.

02:15:46.400 --> 02:15:48.650
One of their duties.

02:15:48.650 --> 02:15:50.290
Just not a formal commission,

02:15:50.290 --> 02:15:52.650
like we used to have with Dave Mead in charge.

02:15:52.650 --> 02:15:53.730
Not a tree commission.

02:15:53.730 --> 02:15:54.570
Yeah.

02:15:54.570 --> 02:15:55.730
Basically a tree commission is a Parks and Rec Commission

02:15:55.730 --> 02:15:57.090
and that handle those duties.

02:15:57.090 --> 02:16:00.120
Okay.

02:16:00.120 --> 02:16:04.440
Any other questions on that part?

02:16:04.440 --> 02:16:07.220
Okay.

02:16:07.220 --> 02:16:13.800
We have some exceptions to the landscaping rule.

02:16:13.800 --> 02:16:18.040
These standards do not apply to single household dwellings on a single lot or accessory dwelling

02:16:18.040 --> 02:16:19.040
units.

02:16:19.040 --> 02:16:27.440
It duplex on a single lot or a single triplex or fourplex on a single lot.

02:16:27.440 --> 02:16:33.720
We wrote it so basically fourplex or less on an individual parcel does not have to comply

02:16:33.720 --> 02:16:38.520
with the landscaping requirements.

02:16:38.520 --> 02:16:47.500
That was a proposal that we heard from the development community, community and feedback.

02:16:47.500 --> 02:16:54.860
We can write that regulation to be what we would like, and we'll soon try to remind

02:16:54.860 --> 02:17:02.440
me currently, I believe it only says single family and duplexes don't follow the landscaping

02:17:02.440 --> 02:17:03.440
code.

02:17:03.440 --> 02:17:04.440
Am I correct?

02:17:04.440 --> 02:17:06.440
Did I remember that right?

02:17:06.440 --> 02:17:07.440
Generally.

02:17:07.440 --> 02:17:08.440
A little bit more context.

02:17:08.440 --> 02:17:12.800
I will get into this a little bit more or get into this now.

02:17:12.800 --> 02:17:18.570
So in the table on the right is 1064, calculating and required improvements.

02:17:18.570 --> 02:17:24.460
that we realized we were, we neglected what the current code was saying.

02:17:25.260 --> 02:17:31.820
When we were reviewing what the current code says, the residential one and residential two

02:17:31.820 --> 02:17:42.120
neighborhoods. So the TN one essentially said that it would be, let me find it, 10% of the site

02:17:42.120 --> 02:17:53.960
for non-residential uses for the TN two, which is our R4 district, would be our 10% of the site

02:17:53.960 --> 02:17:55.960
for non-residential so going along.

02:17:55.960 --> 02:17:59.240
It still exempts it for pretty much all those uses.

02:17:59.240 --> 02:18:03.480
Any residential use within those two districts,

02:18:03.480 --> 02:18:06.360
there's no landscape requirement.

02:18:06.360 --> 02:18:10.360
However, when you get to the R6 or the TN3 district,

02:18:10.360 --> 02:18:15.360
it says 10% of the site for all uses except one and two.

02:18:15.560 --> 02:18:20.560
That's where three and four boxes become permitted by right.

02:18:20.560 --> 02:18:31.740
So what the code says is those three and four plexes, because they're permitted by right, you have to follow the landscaping of 10% of your site.

02:18:31.740 --> 02:18:36.740
So that's the only place where we give out that exception.

02:18:36.740 --> 02:18:46.050
What I really want to ask the question is, do we want three plexes and four plexes to have landscaping regulations or not?

02:18:46.050 --> 02:18:52.050
I was going to ask, please tell me again which districts allow the triplexes and four plexes.

02:18:52.050 --> 02:19:06.850
Currently, R6 with R4 as a special use, which is converting to the TN3 district up here.

02:19:06.850 --> 02:19:10.520
Can't you also do it under C1 with special use?

02:19:10.520 --> 02:19:18.690
D1 allows four apartments and that'd be commercial up here.

02:19:18.690 --> 02:19:27.390
Jonathan, maybe I'm not catching her, so I'm just trying to process what would the alternative be?

02:19:27.390 --> 02:19:32.190
no landscaping period or no trees or no.

02:19:32.190 --> 02:19:34.430
So we're talking about what is,

02:19:34.430 --> 02:19:38.350
we want to require people to install not what they will install.

02:19:38.350 --> 02:19:41.110
Many people install landscaping.

02:19:41.110 --> 02:19:42.950
Many of them install more landscaping

02:19:42.950 --> 02:19:45.920
that is minimally required.

02:19:45.920 --> 02:19:47.120
We're going to create an exemption.

02:19:47.120 --> 02:19:49.040
This exemption we wrote to include

02:19:49.040 --> 02:19:50.440
four plexes and triplexes.

02:19:50.440 --> 02:19:53.000
What you have occasionally is

02:19:53.000 --> 02:19:58.880
four plex, triplex, apartment complex.

02:19:58.880 --> 02:20:01.460
All on one lot, whether or not those

02:20:01.460 --> 02:20:08.610
should be exempted from landscaping.

02:20:08.610 --> 02:20:11.050
Maybe it's something to think about

02:20:11.050 --> 02:20:13.050
while we go through the rest of this,

02:20:13.050 --> 02:20:14.490
because then you can actually say,

02:20:14.490 --> 02:20:17.050
does that type of regulation do I want to be exempted

02:20:17.050 --> 02:20:21.530
for triplexes and four plexes?

02:20:21.530 --> 02:20:25.010
If those are the case, you have six or eight

02:20:25.010 --> 02:20:27.450
parking stalls for it, so you'd be exempting like

02:20:27.450 --> 02:20:32.410
parking lot requirements, like how for landscaping,

02:20:32.410 --> 02:20:33.410
you'd be doing that kind of stuff.

02:20:33.410 --> 02:20:36.770
So why don't we contemplate that question,

02:20:36.770 --> 02:20:38.530
then go through the rest of the site,

02:20:38.530 --> 02:20:40.930
does this make sense to have,

02:20:40.930 --> 02:20:42.690
in a triplex or a four-plus unit,

02:20:42.690 --> 02:20:45.490
doesn't make sense to have as a single family or two-plus?

02:20:45.490 --> 02:20:47.330
Yeah, this exemption is everything that you're gonna see

02:20:47.330 --> 02:20:51.570
after, including the site, gateway, everything.

02:20:51.570 --> 02:20:56.750
We'll contemplate some of that as we're going through it.

02:20:56.750 --> 02:21:01.150
We do not have a current requirement for a landscape plan

02:21:01.150 --> 02:21:04.430
on submittals for building permits.

02:21:04.430 --> 02:21:07.850
we've been getting in as a request for on our

02:21:07.850 --> 02:21:10.490
as quickly as our application.

02:21:10.490 --> 02:21:15.170
We would like to have a submission of a landscape plan,

02:21:15.170 --> 02:21:17.050
reviewed part of the building permit,

02:21:17.050 --> 02:21:22.050
and through that we have put a square footage,

02:21:22.050 --> 02:21:25.890
a 4,000 square feet or more of total landscape area

02:21:25.890 --> 02:21:27.690
to provide a landscape plan prepared

02:21:27.690 --> 02:21:30.210
by current Idaho design professional.

02:21:30.210 --> 02:21:32.650
That is, Idaho licensed design professional

02:21:32.650 --> 02:21:37.100
that includes, that is covered from engineers,

02:21:37.100 --> 02:21:38.660
all types of engineers,

02:21:38.660 --> 02:21:42.300
landscape architects, architects.

02:21:42.300 --> 02:21:43.460
I might be missing another one in there

02:21:43.460 --> 02:21:47.780
that's an Idaho licensed design professional.

02:21:47.780 --> 02:21:50.780
4,000 square feet was in discussion.

02:21:50.780 --> 02:21:52.500
We came up with that in discussion

02:21:52.500 --> 02:21:56.540
with the nursery installers.

02:21:56.540 --> 02:21:58.840
When I asked them what do you think in terms of a big area

02:21:58.840 --> 02:22:02.340
that you would need a plan or want a plan or have a plan,

02:22:02.340 --> 02:22:05.100
that was where we came up with 4,000 square feet.

02:22:05.100 --> 02:22:06.420
Some of them wanted it to be smaller,

02:22:06.420 --> 02:22:08.220
and we just said 4,000 square feet

02:22:08.220 --> 02:22:11.340
ends up being a pretty big project

02:22:11.340 --> 02:22:14.670
when it's required landscaping.

02:22:14.670 --> 02:22:16.530
So when you require 4,000 square feet,

02:22:16.530 --> 02:22:19.150
give us the plan designed by a professional.

02:22:19.150 --> 02:22:25.540
If you happen to provide more, you won't require it.

02:22:25.540 --> 02:22:26.700
That is a different change.

02:22:26.700 --> 02:22:28.860
That is a big difference from what we currently have,

02:22:28.860 --> 02:22:33.450
which is we don't have that requirement.

02:22:33.450 --> 02:22:34.890
We just simply last for a plan to know

02:22:34.890 --> 02:22:36.850
that you're complying, and sometimes the plans

02:22:36.850 --> 02:22:40.260
just say we're gonna comply with CityCUBE.

02:22:40.260 --> 02:22:47.000
is the purpose of that because we don't have the follow-up and it never gets done at some

02:22:47.000 --> 02:22:48.000
point in time.

02:22:48.000 --> 02:22:50.000
I would say sometimes.

02:22:50.000 --> 02:22:51.000
Okay.

02:22:51.000 --> 02:22:53.800
Other times we would really like to have this so we know if you're going to try and plant

02:22:53.800 --> 02:22:58.580
or they're going to plant something where we have utilities or someone else has utilities,

02:22:58.580 --> 02:23:00.700
we'd like that to be contemplated beforehand.

02:23:00.700 --> 02:23:01.700
Got it.

02:23:01.700 --> 02:23:04.420
And it usually is on most commercial projects.

02:23:04.420 --> 02:23:08.000
They do that because it's cost money to change those plans.

02:23:08.000 --> 02:23:12.440
we've made accommodation to have field modifications in here. Yes, some of that is

02:23:12.440 --> 02:23:15.040
we don't know where it's supposed to be because it just said they'll comply with

02:23:15.040 --> 02:23:22.470
code and then we go out there and where are all these shrubs trees. Are there

02:23:22.470 --> 02:23:27.130
many newer residential subdivisions that have common areas that would exceed that?

02:23:27.130 --> 02:23:34.740
I'd hate to have a developer hire a landscape architect or some other

02:23:34.740 --> 02:23:37.800
design professional feels competent in that area just to say we're gonna have a

02:23:37.800 --> 02:23:41.400
a grass strip here with sprinklers or some things that make sense.

02:23:41.400 --> 02:23:47.200
Yeah, we currently have, when you're doing common areas between the sidewalk and the road,

02:23:47.200 --> 02:23:50.800
we currently have a subdivision requirement to have it as a design.

02:23:50.800 --> 02:23:55.780
We require a tree and ground cover requirement with sprinklers already,

02:23:55.780 --> 02:23:58.180
and they're just working straight with chance.

02:23:58.180 --> 02:23:59.380
Is that, I don't know if that was the question.

02:23:59.380 --> 02:24:03.580
I guess in theory, the civil engineer could call that out on a plan.

02:24:03.580 --> 02:24:05.780
I think most people feel confident doing that.

02:24:05.780 --> 02:24:16.070
Civil engineers are under the Idaho license design professional herb state code this table

02:24:16.790 --> 02:24:22.790
we noticed at night is completely oversight I just these numbers are not what we currently have in

02:24:22.790 --> 02:24:30.930
code some of them we know we need to change back to at least have what we have primarily

02:24:31.730 --> 02:24:40.120
as well and I brought to my attention we have most of them end up being for non-residential uses

02:24:40.120 --> 02:24:45.680
because the residential are exempted in all of the AG, the rural residential, the town neighborhoods,

02:24:45.680 --> 02:24:53.190
those are all essentially, your single family home you don't have one, but if you're non-residential

02:24:53.190 --> 02:25:01.040
use you have five or ten percent of the area. The one that I would bring most attention to would be

02:25:03.060 --> 02:25:09.860
central city, currently as 20 percent of the site, if you're non-residential and the same as

02:25:09.860 --> 02:25:14.870
underlining zone or residential it's basically their sixth zone and we we

02:25:14.870 --> 02:25:19.930
proposed it to be 5% up here. I don't know if we want to drastically change

02:25:19.930 --> 02:25:27.180
that although we also have a lot of it to be built right up to the property line

02:25:27.180 --> 02:25:31.260
because you're allowed to downtown. We don't we don't have landscaping in that

02:25:31.260 --> 02:25:40.020
area. Commercial is another one we have up there 5% we're proposing 5% of

02:25:40.020 --> 02:25:56.900
area currently, it is 3% of the lot area that is increasing. It's not just 3% of

02:25:56.900 --> 02:26:01.500
the total area, it's also 10% of the lot area for 5 plus units. If you're doing

02:26:01.500 --> 02:26:07.390
multifamily in that area, it'd be the 10%. And we are in the weeds on this one

02:26:07.390 --> 02:26:12.980
because we know landscaping in the percentages, we have to put this somewhere.

02:26:12.980 --> 02:26:17.400
And this is, we can either take the direction of keep what we have currently

02:26:17.400 --> 02:26:21.080
or we can say make it so we get more.

02:26:21.080 --> 02:26:23.120
I guess that's really the direction I'm looking for.

02:26:23.120 --> 02:26:25.520
If you look around town, we have what we have

02:26:25.520 --> 02:26:27.920
from a lot area as we get to the bottom.

02:26:27.920 --> 02:26:30.640
We can talk about these as you get through the gateway landscape.

02:26:30.640 --> 02:26:35.660
These are section changes drastically as well.

02:26:35.660 --> 02:26:36.580
There's not a lot of pages here.

02:26:36.580 --> 02:26:38.870
There's only six pages.

02:26:38.870 --> 02:26:40.790
So what's the feedback you're getting

02:26:40.790 --> 02:26:45.980
from the developers on this issue?

02:26:45.980 --> 02:26:48.660
It's been about five years since I've had a conversation

02:26:48.660 --> 02:26:56.500
one on with anybody. I had multiple conversations in 2018, 19, and 20, and we went with the direction

02:26:56.500 --> 02:27:05.710
we had at that time. I don't believe this table was meant to change from what we currently

02:27:05.710 --> 02:27:11.460
had. It just ended up being changed. I never came back to double check it. It was just a

02:27:11.460 --> 02:27:14.660
completely blind spot for me until this morning when we were looking at it going, wait, what

02:27:14.660 --> 02:27:20.500
did we really change here? Again, I thought it was the same and it's not. Okay. That's

02:27:20.500 --> 02:27:28.310
just the honest answer for you. Thank you. So I'm going to come back to the percentages as

02:27:28.310 --> 02:27:38.350
well as the exemption. All of these depart or departure of current code for trees and shrubs,

02:27:38.350 --> 02:27:45.260
we currently have 50% of them to be evergreen. We're funding that to be problematic in some areas,

02:27:45.260 --> 02:27:54.580
and we'd rather have in talking with the nursery owners and the nurserymen as well as chance more

02:27:54.580 --> 02:27:57.940
of this table which ends up being if you have a certain number of trees and you

02:27:57.940 --> 02:28:02.500
have a number of species, evergreen or not, deciduous doesn't really matter as

02:28:02.500 --> 02:28:07.490
long as we bury. So if anything comes into wipe out a certain species, not

02:28:07.490 --> 02:28:14.040
everything's going at the same time. This seemed to be fairly well received by the

02:28:14.040 --> 02:28:17.820
nurseries that we talked to. They fairly well helped us develop it. They kind of

02:28:17.820 --> 02:28:20.580
gave us the numbers on what we should do. They were in the industry so we just

02:28:20.580 --> 02:28:29.600
took what they gave us or these numbers and the numbers of species. We're

02:28:29.600 --> 02:28:34.440
changing how we measure the plants. Currently a tree just has to be four feet

02:28:34.440 --> 02:28:40.790
tall when you plant it. The only requirement we have, they gave us a few

02:28:40.790 --> 02:28:45.730
back that's probably not the right way. One and a half inch caliper for a

02:28:45.730 --> 02:28:50.610
deciduous or five feet tall evergreen is really what we should have or a well

02:28:50.610 --> 02:28:56.680
established stock. That's a big change it to change as well as the shrubs

02:28:56.680 --> 02:29:02.860
being two gallons and others being one gallon if it's like a grass or something

02:29:02.860 --> 02:29:09.460
like that. This will get to the last which is ground cover. We do not currently require

02:29:09.460 --> 02:29:14.220
any ground cover to be placed in any required landscaping. We do not require grass, we do

02:29:14.220 --> 02:29:21.100
not require gravel or anything else. It can be dirt, just with trees and shrubs as long

02:29:21.100 --> 02:29:27.880
as you keep the weeds down. We heard from multiple people in the community, just public comment

02:29:27.880 --> 02:29:31.360
during different things that we should have ground cover requirements. This is what we

02:29:31.360 --> 02:29:37.380
came up with. We came up with this from against the input. It's been a few years since

02:29:37.380 --> 02:29:43.810
We have the input and this is not the final list that it has to be.

02:29:43.810 --> 02:29:49.290
We can talk about whether we want certain ground covers to be allowed or these ground

02:29:49.290 --> 02:29:55.270
covers to not be allowed to pause for those conversations to take place if you'd like.

02:29:55.270 --> 02:29:58.070
We had directors come up and I'll jump in on that one.

02:29:58.070 --> 02:30:01.630
So we received public comment regarding the ground coverage.

02:30:01.630 --> 02:30:05.550
Is there a reason that we specifically chose those to be prohibited?

02:30:05.550 --> 02:30:09.720
Was it aesthetics or was it drainage?

02:30:09.720 --> 02:30:15.460
I think asphalt and concrete definitely is that just creates impermeable surface in terms

02:30:15.460 --> 02:30:20.580
of pea gravel, road base, rubber mulch, and some of those if those are in areas closer

02:30:20.580 --> 02:30:26.260
to our roads, some of those things can be problematic on our roads or in our drainage

02:30:26.260 --> 02:30:27.260
systems.

02:30:27.260 --> 02:30:33.660
Other than that, we talked about it with other people and we came up with the list.

02:30:33.660 --> 02:30:40.700
I'm not an expert on landscaping, at least in this type of version of it.

02:30:40.700 --> 02:30:47.940
I'll try to call on you if you go ahead, Sherry.

02:30:47.940 --> 02:30:55.060
A couple of questions, do we, we are, and I don't remember the exact wording for it, but

02:30:55.060 --> 02:30:57.700
we are a tree city, an official.

02:30:57.700 --> 02:30:59.700
Tree city USA.

02:30:59.700 --> 02:31:00.700
Thank you.

02:31:00.700 --> 02:31:01.700
Tree city USA.

02:31:01.700 --> 02:31:07.620
So is there a requirement for us to remain a tree city USA for a number of trees?

02:31:07.620 --> 02:31:15.990
I mean, what is there a requirement looking at chance and it's not a yes.

02:31:15.990 --> 02:31:22.190
So this meets the requirement or does this exceed the requirement or I I'd love to see

02:31:22.190 --> 02:31:30.550
our entire community landscaped and it's beautiful but I also don't want to incur excess costs

02:31:30.550 --> 02:31:32.190
in trying to build.

02:31:32.190 --> 02:31:36.070
So the tree city requirements are more about public trees, private trees.

02:31:36.070 --> 02:31:40.950
And so the trees and parks, trees and rice away, and we certainly do meet those requirements

02:31:40.950 --> 02:31:42.670
if we continue to get our certifications.

02:31:42.670 --> 02:31:43.670
That makes sense.

02:31:43.670 --> 02:31:44.670
Okay.

02:31:44.670 --> 02:31:50.070
And then real quick, as we're looking through ground cover, has artificial turf been discussed

02:31:50.070 --> 02:31:51.420
as an option?

02:31:51.420 --> 02:32:01.780
I think it was a little rot up, and I think we have right here this section would have

02:32:01.780 --> 02:32:06.980
that non-vegetated materials, decorative rockstone or greater artificial turf papers

02:32:06.980 --> 02:32:15.910
If it doesn't compromise is it more than 50% of the required area some of those end up being non-permeable or

02:32:17.120 --> 02:32:19.660
Impermeable so the water will just run off into somewhere

02:32:21.420 --> 02:32:26.540
landscaping sometimes or as usually accounted for as where storm water will percolate

02:32:31.060 --> 02:32:33.350
Yeah, Jonathan obviously

02:32:33.990 --> 02:32:37.950
Grayson or Councilman stone it, you know, we received this some input

02:32:39.030 --> 02:32:43.970
There's some in the room that were associated with that email

02:32:43.970 --> 02:32:49.970
wanting to make sure that we look at that and having an opportunity to look at it.

02:32:49.970 --> 02:32:57.120
I look at it from a standpoint of some zeroscape, some of that type of stuff,

02:32:57.120 --> 02:33:04.330
looking at do we do we want to venture? I think it was, Sherry had talked about his

02:33:04.330 --> 02:33:07.570
artificial turf. I know that those types of things are becoming more and more

02:33:07.570 --> 02:33:18.570
popular. I just want to make sure that we're looking at materials. I look at

02:33:18.570 --> 02:33:25.290
like pit run, road ballast, that type of stuff from a resource management. I mean, he probably

02:33:25.290 --> 02:33:31.210
shouldn't be using that necessarily as a landscape, but maybe P gravel might be an option

02:33:31.210 --> 02:33:37.050
or something like that, or some type of rock. Understanding the issue that you brought up

02:33:37.050 --> 02:33:44.920
with getting into the roadway or whatnot. But I, we also want to look at some things that

02:33:44.920 --> 02:33:50.340
from a landscaper also help minimize water

02:33:50.340 --> 02:33:55.110
man's as well to some extent. We're allowing that

02:33:55.110 --> 02:34:00.120
as an option. We have a couple options. We do not currently have this regulation.

02:34:00.120 --> 02:34:07.640
Okay. And if this is getting into design criteria that typically our council has

02:34:07.640 --> 02:34:13.180
not been away from done, we have also had some

02:34:13.180 --> 02:34:17.160
properties that have installed items that have heard from

02:34:17.160 --> 02:34:22.440
Maybe not this council or but some previous saying why did we allow that and we go

02:34:22.440 --> 02:34:29.760
Well, if we don't regulate it, then we have to you know, there's a there's a balance. So I what I'm seeking is this is what we were

02:34:29.760 --> 02:34:32.660
I am not the holding to any of

02:34:34.020 --> 02:34:39.340
Necessarily just proposing if we want to regulate them, but I appreciate I have starting point for discussion

02:34:39.340 --> 02:34:43.740
And if we say you know what we're just gonna stay away from ground cover still and we can still do that

02:34:43.740 --> 02:34:46.980
I think we should venture down the path of ground cover.

02:34:46.980 --> 02:34:51.940
I think we should have some more conversation around that as we go through.

02:34:51.940 --> 02:34:58.720
I like the direction that it's going personally, but I know there's others in the participate

02:34:58.720 --> 02:35:07.110
again or from a development side than I do, making sure that we're getting that input

02:35:07.110 --> 02:35:08.110
and that feedback.

02:35:08.110 --> 02:35:14.910
Obviously, it's been a while since we've maybe talked to them specifically about this.

02:35:14.910 --> 02:35:18.510
I do like the fact that maybe it's something that we

02:35:18.510 --> 02:35:21.710
address what extend at this point.

02:35:21.710 --> 02:35:24.030
That would be the direction I'm looking for.

02:35:24.030 --> 02:35:25.710
This is the starting point we can say,

02:35:25.710 --> 02:35:29.560
we can just cross them off as we go, or?

02:35:29.560 --> 02:35:33.560
Well, I can get on board with asphalt and concrete flat work

02:35:33.560 --> 02:35:37.000
unless someone tells me other.

02:35:37.000 --> 02:35:39.600
But I like the artificial grass.

02:35:39.600 --> 02:35:42.680
Looking at some of that type of stuff.

02:35:42.680 --> 02:35:45.240
that he has used p gravel as

02:35:45.240 --> 02:35:46.480
that as well as

02:35:46.480 --> 02:35:50.700
was brought up in the email

02:35:50.700 --> 02:35:51.220
so

02:35:51.220 --> 02:35:54.260
i guess the only thing i would say is maybe we need to have more conversation

02:35:54.260 --> 02:35:57.660
with

02:35:57.660 --> 02:35:59.620
that deals with this

02:35:59.620 --> 02:36:05.010
well that puts a little bit more pressure on you

02:36:05.010 --> 02:36:08.260
which

02:36:08.260 --> 02:36:12.380
yes i'm going to specifically that the ones mentioned i see that so

02:36:12.380 --> 02:36:13.780
if i and i can

02:36:13.780 --> 02:36:17.820
if i take just the account you have you have what they are proposing is what

02:36:17.820 --> 02:36:19.380
they propose

02:36:19.380 --> 02:36:23.000
This is the best I could come up with.

02:36:23.000 --> 02:36:25.480
How would you like me to proceed with,

02:36:25.480 --> 02:36:28.640
do we just strike these and bring that back to you?

02:36:28.640 --> 02:36:32.320
I would say yes, but that's my personal opinion.

02:36:32.320 --> 02:36:34.520
But that would be the direction, because I'm just going,

02:36:34.520 --> 02:36:38.560
I'm cool if I've heard from, you have a letter that

02:36:38.560 --> 02:36:39.880
is from some of the representatives that say,

02:36:39.880 --> 02:36:40.880
these are the items we think should

02:36:40.880 --> 02:36:44.200
be stricken from the prohibited materials.

02:36:44.200 --> 02:36:48.640
And it included p-gravel, road base, rubber mulch,

02:36:48.640 --> 02:36:50.150
What about roadbase?

02:36:50.150 --> 02:36:51.150
What is that one there?

02:36:51.150 --> 02:36:55.300
P gravel, rubber, mulch, and pit run in balustroc.

02:36:55.300 --> 02:36:59.660
So the ones that were deep prohibited based on the input you got from the one email would

02:36:59.660 --> 02:37:07.790
be asphalt, concrete, road-based gravel, and impermeable plastic weed barrier.

02:37:07.790 --> 02:37:10.350
So I would say let's have some more conversations.

02:37:10.350 --> 02:37:14.550
So strike, p gravel, and rubber, mulch.

02:37:14.550 --> 02:37:18.350
But I'm sure that the pit run and some of that other stuff is going to come into the conversation

02:37:18.350 --> 02:37:19.350
as it is done.

02:37:19.350 --> 02:37:21.350
But again, that's that's my

02:37:21.350 --> 02:37:30.560
My direction in my opinion and if you'd like we can do because this has been quite a while since we've typed into the reasons

02:37:30.560 --> 02:37:35.920
Why we came up with this list if you'd like we can do a little bit more research diving into say

02:37:36.520 --> 02:37:42.280
Yes, there's a good reason for this or and then we can have that conversation when we go through the ordinance

02:37:43.600 --> 02:37:47.010
Okay

02:37:52.710 --> 02:38:02.680
This is the alternative plan.

02:38:02.680 --> 02:38:06.680
Basically say if you don't want to do any of those things, you can have an alternative plan.

02:38:06.680 --> 02:38:08.680
We've had this before, but we had no guidance on it.

02:38:08.680 --> 02:38:14.680
Anybody that's been on the commission, maybe it's Chris, maybe it's the last one that might have had one of these alternative plans brought to the commission.

02:38:14.680 --> 02:38:17.680
We go out and know what process and what we're looking at.

02:38:17.680 --> 02:38:20.680
Now we have at least a process someone can go through.

02:38:20.680 --> 02:38:22.680
We gave ideas.

02:38:22.680 --> 02:38:27.930
And then it's just reviewed upon basically by the planning zone of commission.

02:38:27.930 --> 02:38:33.560
If it ends up being an artistic mural or other display, it goes to the art commission because you created them.

02:38:33.560 --> 02:38:36.360
So if it's in a public area, that's where we take it.

02:38:36.360 --> 02:38:39.360
You don't want to do this landscaping or something's happening.

02:38:39.360 --> 02:38:41.860
Let's do a public mural or something.

02:38:41.860 --> 02:38:45.860
Take it through that group to have that be reviewed there.

02:38:45.860 --> 02:38:51.190
And then there's always the other innovative ideas that we can't think of anything else someone might want to do.

02:38:51.190 --> 02:38:56.880
Just take it to the commission and we think and look at it.

02:38:56.880 --> 02:39:00.880
Don't plant invasive species for the state of Idaho.

02:39:00.880 --> 02:39:03.120
We just threw that in there because some people ask us.

02:39:03.120 --> 02:39:05.760
We just, I don't know the state standard,

02:39:05.760 --> 02:39:07.960
so we just put it in there.

02:39:07.960 --> 02:39:12.280
Arturo landscaping, instead of having gateway arterial,

02:39:12.280 --> 02:39:13.520
the intent of the gateway arterial

02:39:13.520 --> 02:39:14.840
in the beginning was all the arterials

02:39:14.840 --> 02:39:16.950
as you're coming into town.

02:39:16.950 --> 02:39:19.110
We have newer ones, and instead of keeping up the list,

02:39:19.110 --> 02:39:21.780
we just said arterial landscaping.

02:39:21.780 --> 02:39:24.540
We recognize that there are particularly the section

02:39:24.540 --> 02:39:27.540
of Washington where buildings are already constructed,

02:39:27.540 --> 02:39:31.220
or where right of way was taken by the state of Idaho

02:39:31.220 --> 02:39:35.430
to get a wider road, this could cause some issue.

02:39:35.430 --> 02:39:37.790
Because what we actually went to was a landscape strip

02:39:37.790 --> 02:39:40.190
with an average depth of 30 feet.

02:39:40.190 --> 02:39:43.470
No area having a depth less than 15 feet measured

02:39:43.470 --> 02:39:48.690
from the back of sidewalk or future sidewalk.

02:39:48.690 --> 02:39:51.250
And we don't include concrete fabric sidewalks or paths

02:39:51.250 --> 02:39:52.250
not towards that area.

02:39:52.250 --> 02:39:55.770
So what you'd end up having is parking

02:39:55.770 --> 02:39:58.050
that can be closer than 30, but you still

02:39:58.050 --> 02:40:02.100
of 15 feet of landscaping along the arterial.

02:40:02.100 --> 02:40:04.000
The areas that are currently established

02:40:04.000 --> 02:40:05.860
were the had right of way taken.

02:40:05.860 --> 02:40:08.260
Those are primary candidates for variance.

02:40:08.260 --> 02:40:10.740
In the true sense of the word of a variance for the state of Idaho,

02:40:10.740 --> 02:40:12.500
they didn't create the problem.

02:40:12.500 --> 02:40:16.060
They have a regulation that was changed since it was created.

02:40:16.060 --> 02:40:18.500
And you have a process to go through to say, yes,

02:40:18.500 --> 02:40:22.460
that item can be alleviated by granting a variance

02:40:22.460 --> 02:40:26.300
to the arterial landscaping section.

02:40:26.300 --> 02:40:28.580
And the commission hears that as a public hearing,

02:40:28.580 --> 02:40:33.580
and they can grant whatever amount the person declares it has.

02:40:35.020 --> 02:40:36.860
That is what Barreons are for,

02:40:36.860 --> 02:40:41.060
because when as regulation changes and things are already done,

02:40:41.060 --> 02:40:45.710
that's the process that's set up to alleviate the situation.

02:40:45.710 --> 02:40:48.990
I acknowledge that there might be more of those being requested

02:40:48.990 --> 02:40:53.480
by making this arterial versus gateway arterial,

02:40:53.480 --> 02:40:56.720
particularly Washington Street from Addison up to Caswell,

02:40:56.720 --> 02:40:58.960
as that was that section of roadway.

02:40:58.960 --> 02:41:03.580
could take Washington all the way to Falls technically and get there. We want to address

02:41:03.580 --> 02:41:08.340
that specific area, give me the direction to address that specific area and we will make

02:41:08.340 --> 02:41:12.620
an exception for it just like it's currently in there that says 10 feet. We just felt like

02:41:12.620 --> 02:41:19.540
it would be. We had a valve of the variance to deal with that. That is the whole arterial

02:41:19.540 --> 02:41:24.020
landscaping section. It used to be a lot bigger than that. I'll pause there for anything else

02:41:24.020 --> 02:41:28.020
Maybe some other thing to note.

02:41:28.020 --> 02:41:32.260
So, previously, I should say, currently,

02:41:32.260 --> 02:41:38.180
arterial landscaping was exempted

02:41:38.180 --> 02:41:40.540
out any residential land use.

02:41:40.540 --> 02:41:45.510
If it's residentially zoned, then you don't aren't required.

02:41:45.510 --> 02:41:55.660
That zoning map that went somewhere.

02:41:55.660 --> 02:42:00.080
If you can see on Addison Avenue East,

02:42:00.080 --> 02:42:05.080
There's a portion that is zoned right where Jonathan's

02:42:05.080 --> 02:42:08.000
mouse is zoned residential.

02:42:08.000 --> 02:42:11.920
You know requirement would be required for that to be 30

02:42:11.920 --> 02:42:17.000
feet set back at this point, or that landscaping requirement.

02:42:17.000 --> 02:42:23.160
We felt that was, there was a hard break there,

02:42:23.160 --> 02:42:26.680
and if you're wanting to create this cohesive feel,

02:42:26.680 --> 02:42:28.960
having it residentially zoned property

02:42:28.960 --> 02:42:32.000
might prohibit that residential feel.

02:42:32.000 --> 02:42:37.080
So what we were proposing today is take out the zone

02:42:37.080 --> 02:42:42.080
exemption, but keep the, if it's a single family or duplex

02:42:42.080 --> 02:42:44.720
or triplex with those exceptions at first,

02:42:44.720 --> 02:42:47.160
that it wouldn't require.

02:42:47.160 --> 02:42:50.120
Most of the houses that are in that area

02:42:50.120 --> 02:42:52.440
are single family houses.

02:42:54.700 --> 02:43:00.550
And if we, if they were to redevelop

02:43:00.550 --> 02:43:02.150
or they did an addition,

02:43:02.150 --> 02:43:05.710
then it wouldn't come into play.

02:43:05.710 --> 02:43:08.470
If they were to tear down and redevelop into,

02:43:08.470 --> 02:43:12.230
let's say, a five plex, or if we lowered the unit

02:43:12.230 --> 02:43:16.430
to three plex or four plex, then they'd have to develop.

02:43:16.430 --> 02:43:21.110
Or if they redeveloped it to a more intense use.

02:43:21.110 --> 02:43:23.670
So that way we get the cohesive feel,

02:43:23.670 --> 02:43:25.990
but we're still playing with the code to say,

02:43:25.990 --> 02:43:27.750
no, we have these exemptions to protect

02:43:27.750 --> 02:43:31.510
those single families, those duplexes.

02:43:31.510 --> 02:43:36.510
And if you wanted to go as the direction is what this current proposal, the three and four plexes as well.

02:43:36.510 --> 02:43:42.030
Any comments on that?

02:43:42.030 --> 02:43:47.800
Makes sense to me.

02:43:47.800 --> 02:43:52.840
What to think about?

02:43:52.840 --> 02:43:54.840
This is not, this is one of the harder chapters.

02:43:54.840 --> 02:44:04.470
Any other comments before I open up the public hearing?

02:44:04.470 --> 02:44:06.470
There's a hole in these two guys.

02:44:06.470 --> 02:44:07.470
Oh.

02:44:07.470 --> 02:44:08.470
Oh.

02:44:08.470 --> 02:44:09.470
Okay.

02:44:09.470 --> 02:44:11.240
Wishful thinking.

02:44:11.240 --> 02:44:12.240
I thought you said that was it.

02:44:12.240 --> 02:44:13.240
Well, on that section.

02:44:13.240 --> 02:44:14.240
Oh.

02:44:14.240 --> 02:44:15.240
Oh.

02:44:15.240 --> 02:44:16.240
And sleeping is difficult.

02:44:16.240 --> 02:44:17.240
Okay.

02:44:17.240 --> 02:44:18.980
I should have looked at the pages.

02:44:18.980 --> 02:44:20.780
Canyon and overlay landscaping.

02:44:20.780 --> 02:44:23.980
This applies to the only areas in the canyon and overlay.

02:44:23.980 --> 02:44:25.340
As we were going through this again,

02:44:25.340 --> 02:44:26.900
this is what actually we didn't change anything

02:44:26.900 --> 02:44:28.220
from current code.

02:44:28.220 --> 02:44:31.570
I actually believe A and B need to be removed.

02:44:31.570 --> 02:44:33.490
They make it very difficult to develop

02:44:33.490 --> 02:44:41.560
and it's not clear what these depths are from or to.

02:44:43.430 --> 02:44:48.040
Particularly if we have arterial landscaping elsewhere.

02:44:48.040 --> 02:44:49.440
It has a 30 foot depth.

02:44:49.440 --> 02:44:54.480
I would propose striking these two and not moving them forward, particularly the use buffer

02:44:54.480 --> 02:44:57.400
because this is actually meant between like a commercial and residential use.

02:44:57.400 --> 02:45:01.560
There should be 50-foot landscaping area and we have not, that's difficult.

02:45:01.560 --> 02:45:07.040
That takes a lot of precious land from the Canyon Rim area, so those would be stricken.

02:45:07.040 --> 02:45:18.150
The rest of these are exactly as their current code states, which are then becoming, moving

02:45:18.150 --> 02:45:20.990
to these, the parking on landscaping.

02:45:20.990 --> 02:45:26.540
This landscaping is required whenever there's 20 or more parking spaces that is currently

02:45:26.540 --> 02:45:37.770
in place. There is the discussion we've had is on landscaping islands. Developers group

02:45:37.770 --> 02:45:44.260
would like that to be 20 or 25 spaces in a continuous row. This is your landscape islands

02:45:44.260 --> 02:45:50.180
in a parking lot. When you start at one end and you go to the other, you have 15 currently

02:45:50.180 --> 02:45:54.780
and then you need a landscape island. They would like that to be 20 or 25 before you have

02:45:54.780 --> 02:46:02.140
the landscape island interrupting the landscape section or the parking row and I would like

02:46:02.140 --> 02:46:12.320
some direction on 15 what we have now they'd like it to be 20 or 25. I'd be in favor of increasing

02:46:12.320 --> 02:46:38.980
that 20 or 25 and Madam Mayor can I ask a question when he's pulling that up? Dr. Stemmem all this will be

02:46:40.020 --> 02:46:44.020
is it your intention before this becomes codified to have a member or have a meeting with the

02:46:44.020 --> 02:46:53.250
Development community to get their feedback. I'm an all-in kind of deal. There will be there'll be another hearing here

02:46:53.250 --> 02:46:58.830
Correct, but are you gonna have meetings with them outside of the public hearing? We have yes

02:46:58.830 --> 02:47:02.670
I know you've had and we will continue to have any meaning they wish

02:47:03.210 --> 02:47:07.710
These are the parking lots

02:47:07.710 --> 02:47:12.780
Trying to find the target

02:47:13.480 --> 02:47:26.640
So these are landscape islands here landscape island here. You just count there would be one here

02:47:26.640 --> 02:47:33.280
And two more in that hole.

02:47:33.280 --> 02:47:36.760
Yeah, if you go to 25, you'd have one in the middle, probably.

02:47:36.760 --> 02:47:40.170
If you have 15, you'd end up having two.

02:47:40.170 --> 02:47:46.440
Yeah, I wouldn't. I don't have an issue with 25.

02:47:46.440 --> 02:47:48.110
Yeah.

02:47:48.110 --> 02:47:50.110
We will do that as we go forward.

02:47:50.110 --> 02:47:54.110
Because, you know, just doing that count right there, it seems reasonable to...

02:47:54.110 --> 02:48:09.950
Before we move on, go up to the introductory paragraph.

02:48:09.950 --> 02:48:12.620
Currently, it...

02:48:12.620 --> 02:48:17.620
Currently, Code says that this is for non-residential parking areas of 20 or more.

02:48:17.620 --> 02:48:23.460
year more. We're proposing any parking area of 20 or more. The impact is the same

02:48:23.460 --> 02:48:31.860
and single family and duplexes will never have a 20 required parking

02:48:31.860 --> 02:48:39.860
it's really going to be for your bigger multifamily projects. Again the impact

02:48:39.860 --> 02:48:44.780
of 20 stall parking a lot is going to be the same whether it's used for a

02:48:44.780 --> 02:48:50.200
residential or commercial development. We wanted to make that really on the same

02:48:50.200 --> 02:48:59.590
point. That makes sense. This just tells you how big those are and that you can group them.

02:48:59.590 --> 02:49:03.270
If you don't like them, you can group into one area. That's been actually helpful for a lot of

02:49:03.270 --> 02:49:08.710
things. I don't propose changing that. We've added this proximity to overhead power lines,

02:49:08.710 --> 02:49:18.470
per Idaho powers, request as they've had some planted in areas. We would just be getting this

02:49:18.470 --> 02:49:23.980
with the building permits when we review them. Just basically following some Idaho statutes and

02:49:23.980 --> 02:49:26.740
and some nuisance items.

02:49:26.740 --> 02:49:29.740
We added some guidelines for pollinators, plants,

02:49:29.740 --> 02:49:32.340
and to request the pollinator council.

02:49:32.340 --> 02:49:35.900
It's not a requirement, it is just recommended.

02:49:35.900 --> 02:49:37.740
Strongly recommended as we wrote in there,

02:49:37.740 --> 02:49:41.090
because that's the language they liked.

02:49:41.090 --> 02:49:43.930
This as for field modifications,

02:49:43.930 --> 02:49:45.450
basically when you're building something,

02:49:45.450 --> 02:49:47.330
you have a conflict of where landscaping is

02:49:47.330 --> 02:49:49.850
with any utility or any other item in the field,

02:49:49.850 --> 02:49:50.970
they can just change that,

02:49:50.970 --> 02:49:53.370
make the change and notify us that it's done

02:49:53.370 --> 02:49:54.610
and that it's been moved.

02:49:54.610 --> 02:49:57.850
This actually streamlines not having to ask for a revision of a plan.

02:49:57.850 --> 02:50:00.770
They can just move it, tell us it's in the general area,

02:50:00.770 --> 02:50:02.650
we can just move on, we get all the items.

02:50:02.650 --> 02:50:05.650
And that's a little type of thing.

02:50:05.650 --> 02:50:08.370
Very helpful not having to get a change order from a plan

02:50:08.370 --> 02:50:11.710
for moving at the future.

02:50:11.710 --> 02:50:15.790
This says that the certificate of occupancy

02:50:15.790 --> 02:50:22.820
must is done, or the TCO process that we've already talked about

02:50:22.820 --> 02:50:27.970
that we've already changed would cover this.

02:50:27.970 --> 02:50:30.290
And then if they have this 4,000 square feet

02:50:30.290 --> 02:50:32.170
and we're basically just getting written certification

02:50:32.170 --> 02:50:33.490
that it's done and we don't,

02:50:33.490 --> 02:50:36.130
we're in and out there trying to count 200 shrubs

02:50:36.130 --> 02:50:38.730
and a number of trees just to ever plant it installed.

02:50:38.730 --> 02:50:42.560
It says we've installed the plan.

02:50:42.560 --> 02:50:45.040
That way we can have fewer issues in the field

02:50:45.040 --> 02:50:47.860
with inspections.

02:50:47.860 --> 02:50:52.620
This simply enumerates what's currently in code elsewhere

02:50:52.620 --> 02:50:58.010
for nuisances of an obstructions.

02:50:58.010 --> 02:51:01.050
This lasts as a guide for wildfire areas,

02:51:01.050 --> 02:51:03.250
which is our wild end urban interface areas.

02:51:03.250 --> 02:51:06.090
We have some of it in the eastern part of town.

02:51:06.090 --> 02:51:07.450
None of it really in city limits

02:51:07.450 --> 02:51:10.530
other than what's along the canyon rim.

02:51:10.530 --> 02:51:12.570
We wrote this a few years ago at the pre-quest

02:51:12.570 --> 02:51:16.040
of some neighboring communities that asked for some help.

02:51:16.040 --> 02:51:18.160
So we just decided to throw it in here as a guideline.

02:51:18.160 --> 02:51:20.740
It's not a requirement.

02:51:20.740 --> 02:51:22.700
We've successfully gone through landscaping section

02:51:22.700 --> 02:51:25.020
as much of a slog as it was.

02:51:25.020 --> 02:51:28.980
Sorry, it was a lot of items to be changed and talked about.

02:51:28.980 --> 02:51:29.980
There's no other questions

02:51:29.980 --> 02:51:32.900
if you have any more or we'll answer them.

02:51:32.900 --> 02:51:33.900
Other questions?

02:51:33.900 --> 02:51:34.900
Okay.

02:51:34.900 --> 02:51:47.230
We, the planning zoning did for it, added a condition requesting to include in the original

02:51:47.230 --> 02:51:55.110
town site, sorry, downtown area of the diagonal streets where the historical pattern has

02:51:55.110 --> 02:52:02.670
been tree lined at the time of redevelopment or a triggering event that street trees would

02:52:02.670 --> 02:52:12.710
be required. That is something that the commission forwarded to you. I'm sure you'll

02:52:12.710 --> 02:52:19.950
hear about it during public comment. But it is something that you should take into consideration

02:52:19.950 --> 02:52:26.870
today if that is something we would like to do. When doing a little bit of analysis on

02:52:26.870 --> 02:52:35.100
it, we were even the most trees that you'd get is one to two trees in a landscape requirement.

02:52:35.100 --> 02:52:41.940
Which isn't too onerous on a property or the onerous portion is if we don't require them to maintain it

02:52:42.300 --> 02:52:46.820
Or we don't require them to trim it without getting permission from the tree

02:52:47.500 --> 02:52:49.500
Commission or hiring in harbors

02:52:50.020 --> 02:52:52.020
that may be

02:52:52.020 --> 02:52:58.170
problematic as well as trying to remind me this is the motion that the

02:52:58.810 --> 02:53:00.070
Commission made

02:53:00.070 --> 02:53:03.270
Attic and just the landscaping should be installed following

02:53:03.270 --> 02:53:07.790
City Code which is the minimum and the park strip when required improvements

02:53:07.790 --> 02:53:11.710
were triggered in order to get lands to be more in line with historic nature

02:53:11.710 --> 02:53:18.080
downtown that was the requirement or the condition they added only we didn't

02:53:18.080 --> 02:53:22.200
make that applicable to only in the area that would be specific and where it's

02:53:22.200 --> 02:53:27.790
located where it's located could be a few different things that could just be

02:53:27.790 --> 02:53:32.620
the original town site would be it would need to be location specific

02:53:32.620 --> 02:53:38.760
Otherwise, you would have that requirement on everybody in town, so you can, you could do that,

02:53:39.800 --> 02:53:44.680
but if the idea is historic nature of downtown, then we should have an area that it's specific to.

02:53:45.480 --> 02:53:49.560
This does correspond with the second email you got. We got a letter from

02:53:49.560 --> 02:53:56.950
in January from Fran Florence about this, and he was there this meeting. That's what this is

02:53:57.510 --> 02:54:02.790
asking for. Their condition is whether or not we want to create basically an overlay district

02:54:02.790 --> 02:54:08.430
downtown for landscaping should require trees to be planted in the park strip and

02:54:08.430 --> 02:54:14.610
the additional information is the owners are responsible to maintain that

02:54:14.610 --> 02:54:18.970
what's in the park strip but they have to get an arborist to maintain it per the

02:54:18.970 --> 02:54:24.660
city code because it's in city property. This is in the right-of-way. Those are

02:54:24.660 --> 02:54:31.810
the two pieces of information you need to know and whether or not we want to do

02:54:31.810 --> 02:54:40.040
that or not. They're currently some coin and maybe I'm thinking of something else

02:54:40.040 --> 02:54:48.360
But isn't there something that they, people can apply for some sort of financial assistance

02:54:48.360 --> 02:54:53.960
for the trees or is that when they're cutting a tree down or is it a sidewalk?

02:54:53.960 --> 02:54:54.960
And maybe I have that wrong.

02:54:54.960 --> 02:54:56.960
That's why I have a grant program.

02:54:56.960 --> 02:55:00.160
Okay, the sidewalks do, but the trees don't have any cutting ground program.

02:55:00.160 --> 02:55:01.160
I'm aware of.

02:55:01.160 --> 02:55:10.860
I have a lot of information.

02:55:10.860 --> 02:55:11.860
I'm going to step away.

02:55:11.860 --> 02:55:12.860
Okay.

02:55:12.860 --> 02:55:19.380
So, any further questions or discussion before I open up the public hearing?

02:55:19.380 --> 02:55:28.530
Hey, I will open up the public hearing specifically on titled and focused on chapter six landscaping

02:55:28.530 --> 02:55:36.460
regulations. You guys arm wrestle for that. Go ahead Gerald come on down. I think that

02:55:36.460 --> 02:55:43.040
was the fastest I see me the one of you moving a long time. Yeah, please state your name. My name is Gerald Martin

02:55:43.040 --> 02:55:51.620
I'm here this evening. I'm here two reasons. Number one, Dave Tebow, I believe you all

02:55:51.620 --> 02:55:56.700
have got a letter from him. He was unable to attend. He received notice of this sometime

02:55:56.700 --> 02:56:03.020
over the weekend. He had another commitment this evening, unable to attend. But he specifically

02:56:03.020 --> 02:56:08.860
works with and leads to the extent that can be led, the development community. And he's

02:56:08.860 --> 02:56:15.750
for the opportunity to have some time with staff to work through some of these issues.

02:56:15.750 --> 02:56:20.470
Much of what's in here is very good. It's clarification and things that we went

02:56:20.470 --> 02:56:24.870
through this morning and they're good. But there are a couple things that as

02:56:24.870 --> 02:56:29.590
worded are unworkable in the development community when you got to deal with

02:56:29.590 --> 02:56:34.590
limited irrigation season and that type of issues. I think it's language we can

02:56:34.590 --> 02:56:39.230
work through. We'd like to be able to come in as a development community and

02:56:39.230 --> 02:56:43.310
and support this in his final format.

02:56:43.310 --> 02:56:45.590
So that is the first thing.

02:56:45.590 --> 02:56:47.230
It's Dave's request.

02:56:47.230 --> 02:56:49.550
He was unable to attend.

02:56:49.550 --> 02:56:51.710
And he's speaking, I believe, in his memo

02:56:51.710 --> 02:56:54.110
that you should all have in your file

02:56:54.110 --> 02:56:56.670
was an opportunity to get input

02:56:56.670 --> 02:56:58.270
from the development community.

02:56:58.270 --> 02:57:01.470
Some of these issues have been discussed in the past

02:57:01.470 --> 02:57:02.510
that I need.

02:57:02.510 --> 02:57:04.110
It's been a while as staff,

02:57:04.110 --> 02:57:05.990
this report's been two or three years

02:57:05.990 --> 02:57:08.110
since we've talked about some of those.

02:57:08.110 --> 02:57:12.590
We'd like to have the opportunity to go back and get that input from the development

02:57:12.590 --> 02:57:14.750
community more than just the nurseries.

02:57:14.750 --> 02:57:16.150
You know, they're similar to product.

02:57:16.150 --> 02:57:19.670
The rest of us got to implement it and make it work.

02:57:19.670 --> 02:57:24.630
The second is there are some language issues in here that I think we can make it more clear

02:57:24.630 --> 02:57:26.110
and give some flexibility.

02:57:26.110 --> 02:57:34.030
I think landscaping has, is one of those subjects that every site is different.

02:57:34.030 --> 02:57:37.870
Every building that you're landscaping is different.

02:57:37.870 --> 02:57:43.710
I think we need some flexibility in the language on not so much as a quantity of landscaping

02:57:43.710 --> 02:57:49.290
but the type and the placement and the grouping.

02:57:49.290 --> 02:57:53.060
There's certain parts of your building you want to accented.

02:57:53.060 --> 02:57:57.420
There's parts of your building you want to keep clear signage issues.

02:57:57.420 --> 02:57:58.940
There's a lot of things.

02:57:58.940 --> 02:58:03.140
I think the change you suggested in parking flexibility.

02:58:03.140 --> 02:58:19.880
I never was an object of the 15 spaces, but I wanted some flexibility because maybe that landscaping could serve the project better if it were moved, so it accented the appropriate spot.

02:58:19.880 --> 02:58:31.740
So flexibility, we would just like you to provide the development community an opportunity to meet with staff before this becomes official.

02:58:31.740 --> 02:58:32.740
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:58:32.740 --> 02:58:46.590
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:58:46.590 --> 02:58:54.590
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:58:54.590 --> 02:59:05.260
[Muted for privacy: home address]

02:59:05.260 --> 02:59:09.760
mission. I'd like the council to consider and I think we're going to have time to go back

02:59:09.760 --> 02:59:17.880
through and work this council to consider to expand that area that requires infill if you

02:59:17.880 --> 02:59:27.180
will of trees to include the president's streets from Lincoln to Taylor. Those are the streets

02:59:27.180 --> 02:59:31.780
the presidential streets that actually have curb gutter and sidewalk. Beyond that they don't

02:59:31.780 --> 02:59:36.700
have curb gutter and sidewalk and there's cars parked in those areas that would

02:59:36.700 --> 02:59:41.460
typically have trees in them and I don't think it's practical to try to to go back

02:59:41.460 --> 02:59:49.020
and capture those and also to include the tree streets if you will and then some of

02:59:49.020 --> 02:59:53.780
the avenues that go beyond I have a map that was included in that mailer to you

02:59:53.780 --> 02:59:59.820
it looks like the state of Texas it expands the area probably about 25% over

02:59:59.820 --> 03:00:04.580
what was there before. The second thing is I'd like to have a trigger point that has something

03:00:04.580 --> 03:00:12.780
to do with the investment made in the property. Triggering it to a 25% additional property, additional

03:00:12.780 --> 03:00:18.540
expansion is impractical because of the size of the lots. It's very unlikely anybody will

03:00:18.540 --> 03:00:24.060
be able to expand that big. So I'd like to have it tied to a dollar amount, something

03:00:24.060 --> 03:00:29.880
like a $10,000 permit cost or expansion on cost for a permit.

03:00:29.880 --> 03:00:34.620
And then finally, just when we talk about spacing on these trees,

03:00:34.620 --> 03:00:39.580
I'd like to try to look at a 25-foot spacing on trees

03:00:39.580 --> 03:00:41.620
or attempt to get the 25-foot spacing.

03:00:41.620 --> 03:00:45.060
And I've had a long discussion with a chance on that.

03:00:45.060 --> 03:00:50.820
And he thinks maybe 25 is too small of a setback,

03:00:50.820 --> 03:00:57.100
Although I can cite examples of very good landscaping issues, the temple landscaping,

03:00:57.100 --> 03:01:06.660
those are in 27-foot centers, the U.S. bank building downtown, those are on 25-foot centers,

03:01:06.660 --> 03:01:10.940
and then the city's own landscaping in the parking lots is on 20-foot centers along the

03:01:10.940 --> 03:01:11.940
avenues.

03:01:11.940 --> 03:01:19.820
I think we can maybe compromise to go from a 50-foot center to hopefully a 25-foot center.

03:01:19.820 --> 03:01:27.500
That's in downtown Twin Falls are 50 feet wide and typically for homes and that would

03:01:27.500 --> 03:01:30.700
mean hopefully two trees in front of each lot.

03:01:30.700 --> 03:01:35.740
If we look at what's been developed in the past, that's what's been, that's more the

03:01:35.740 --> 03:01:38.860
spacing that we've seen.

03:01:38.860 --> 03:01:47.380
And to remind you all, this is to try to preserve and even bring back the nature of downtown.

03:01:47.380 --> 03:01:55.580
is on the top of our list in our comprehensive plan, the nature of downtown, and carving out

03:01:55.580 --> 03:02:03.260
this special area for downtown is absolutely complying with the wishes of our citizens as

03:02:03.260 --> 03:02:05.540
defined in the comprehensive plan.

03:02:05.540 --> 03:02:11.420
And if we don't address it in a way that helps repopulate it, we're going to see trees

03:02:11.420 --> 03:02:18.940
die that we've already seen trees die, but when we have long stretches along the avenues

03:02:19.820 --> 03:02:26.940
where there aren't any trees or any landscaping and it's graveled, it will be much more difficult

03:02:26.940 --> 03:02:34.220
for us in the future to encourage investment in the downtown residential areas. And we really need

03:02:34.220 --> 03:02:39.900
to do that to help continue our progress in what we've done downtown. Thank you.

03:02:39.900 --> 03:02:42.050
Thank you, Fran.

03:02:42.050 --> 03:02:47.090
Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this issue?

03:02:47.090 --> 03:02:54.450
Can you want to say before I close the public hearing?

03:02:54.450 --> 03:03:06.900
I have nothing left on fear to reiterate other than it's I know there's only six pages.

03:03:06.900 --> 03:03:09.220
There's a lot of changes we're trying to make it better.

03:03:09.220 --> 03:03:11.840
There's some things we can keep modifying.

03:03:12.900 --> 03:03:16.660
The only thing out, some clear direction if there's modifications from what we have,

03:03:16.660 --> 03:03:18.740
some clear direction on where to go.

03:03:18.740 --> 03:03:26.940
So particularly if it could be on any designs such as this downtown, increased tree planting

03:03:26.940 --> 03:03:32.100
overlay that will take some time to create and bring back and have some regulation and

03:03:32.100 --> 03:03:36.740
some clear expectations on what you would look for us or we should write.

03:03:36.740 --> 03:03:43.460
And then the other thing that we need clarification on is if you want to exempt out one single

03:03:43.460 --> 03:03:54.000
family, two family, three and four family units as well. So, angle duplex, triplex or four plexes.

03:03:54.640 --> 03:04:03.650
Yeah, I guess just to address a couple things for the timelines for certificate

03:04:03.650 --> 03:04:09.650
occupancies, we address that in our required improvements which is our current 10-11.

03:04:10.770 --> 03:04:17.010
We allow for temporary certificate occupancies for six months to have that be

03:04:19.060 --> 03:04:23.220
This for six months and it's just double vegetation.

03:04:23.220 --> 03:04:25.500
So you have to have your curving and whatnot in,

03:04:25.500 --> 03:04:27.220
but the vegetation that would be required,

03:04:27.220 --> 03:04:29.440
the trees and the shrubs can be temporary

03:04:29.440 --> 03:04:31.000
for up to six months.

03:04:31.000 --> 03:04:35.820
That would go for that.

03:04:35.820 --> 03:04:38.320
Otherwise, there's really no other items to address

03:04:38.320 --> 03:04:42.770
unless you have questions and want us to address them.

03:04:42.770 --> 03:04:45.230
Okay, so I can close the public hearing.

03:04:45.230 --> 03:04:47.270
We can have discussion.

03:04:47.270 --> 03:04:50.650
Okay, all right, I'm going to close the public hearing

03:04:50.650 --> 03:05:02.440
and move on to direction from the council, specifically the single family, duplex, triplex,

03:05:02.440 --> 03:05:06.080
foreplex, question as exempt.

03:05:06.080 --> 03:05:09.070
I'm guessing something.

03:05:09.070 --> 03:05:18.430
Can you stop the screen over for us so we can show this right here?

03:05:18.430 --> 03:05:20.230
This exception right here, yes.

03:05:20.230 --> 03:05:23.760
So that's the first item maybe Sherry?

03:05:23.760 --> 03:05:25.590
Yes.

03:05:25.590 --> 03:05:33.860
So, I appreciate that the development community does want to partner with, and I think that

03:05:33.860 --> 03:05:42.300
that's a really good idea to do that within the specified timeframe.

03:05:42.300 --> 03:05:45.980
The first one is the certificate of occupancy.

03:05:45.980 --> 03:05:50.140
I think a temporary certificate of occupancy for landscaping.

03:05:50.140 --> 03:06:00.000
I can see where no certificate of occupancy could be a heartache, especially for commercial.

03:06:00.000 --> 03:06:04.320
exception for the single found you know that the residential's I guess I'll call

03:06:04.320 --> 03:06:10.160
it that only goes up to four plex is that right has written up there we are

03:06:10.160 --> 03:06:20.340
exempting out up to four plex is on a single lot okay that I mean that sound

03:06:20.340 --> 03:06:27.050
that sounds reasonable was there a third was it was worth and then the

03:06:27.050 --> 03:06:35.330
suggestion by Ian Z was not an item the suggestion by P&Z is to create that

03:06:35.330 --> 03:06:41.450
downtown overlaid to require trees to be planted along the street when there is a qualifying,

03:06:41.450 --> 03:06:46.810
I call it a qualifying event. From a code standpoint, we have when required improvements

03:06:46.810 --> 03:06:51.890
kick in. That's what we refer to as using that mechanism being already created. Um,

03:06:51.890 --> 03:06:56.890
the testimony heard was to create some other mechanism on amount of investment. I don't

03:06:56.890 --> 03:06:59.610
know what that looks like and have to investigate that more.

03:06:59.610 --> 03:07:06.870
So I like the idea of the downtown, I'm trying to think of what the streets are now, I've

03:07:06.870 --> 03:07:11.590
only put here on my life, Blue Lakes, the diagonal.

03:07:11.590 --> 03:07:12.590
Like the original town site.

03:07:12.590 --> 03:07:15.030
The original town site, yeah.

03:07:15.030 --> 03:07:22.970
I mean it would be great to extend out but I don't know how that financially impacts some

03:07:22.970 --> 03:07:30.710
people in those areas but I can see the, keeping the integrity of the original town site with

03:07:30.710 --> 03:07:39.240
education. Anybody else have any comments other than Sherry?

03:07:39.240 --> 03:07:48.500
Excuse me Madam Chair. The only thing I would suggest is that I also believe that some of

03:07:48.500 --> 03:07:54.020
the items are going to do some input in conversations with the development council. And so I would

03:07:54.020 --> 03:08:00.980
suggest that you have staff the flexibility to meet and have those conversations and we

03:08:00.980 --> 03:08:07.460
might bring back to you something that could be different after those conversations than

03:08:07.460 --> 03:08:16.660
what you see tonight. But we will not be voting on this or do you want us to? I don't. You can you

03:08:16.660 --> 03:08:25.140
can vote because this is I like and this is preseason. You're going to see the entirety of title 10

03:08:25.140 --> 03:08:30.020
again. So we're doing these every single piece of title 10 that you're having a conversation like

03:08:30.020 --> 03:08:37.140
Jonathan said will have a individual piece and then a larger conversation about the totality of

03:08:37.140 --> 03:08:42.260
the changes later. I think we could have a motion to that effect as well. Jason, did you have a

03:08:42.260 --> 03:08:47.860
comment? I, you know, Jonathan, you wanted us to give you some direction and I think what Travis

03:08:47.860 --> 03:08:52.340
had just said. I think the biggest thing I'm struggling with is I know there's there's interested

03:08:52.340 --> 03:08:59.060
parties specifically with some of that. So continue to work with the group of developers,

03:09:00.320 --> 03:09:06.320
the overlay district of making sure that we keep and preserve. I like the idea, I like the concept,

03:09:06.320 --> 03:09:14.320
but how big, how small, whatever that looks like, I think it needs to be looked at.

03:09:14.320 --> 03:09:21.540
Obviously, there's a map that presented it, planning and zoning seems somewhat reasonable,

03:09:21.540 --> 03:09:26.340
but is that, is that, to its full extent, does it need to come down a little bit?

03:09:26.340 --> 03:09:33.480
So, I like that direction, up the foreplex, I don't think that thing gives me harbor from

03:09:33.480 --> 03:09:38.900
what's stated there, but I do believe there's probably a little bit more

03:09:38.900 --> 03:09:48.710
saging with this. Obviously that's what you're looking at is what that direction

03:09:48.710 --> 03:10:00.540
of massage looks like. But overall I'm comfortable with what is what has been

03:10:00.540 --> 03:10:07.880
presented. I think you guys have done it.

03:10:07.880 --> 03:10:19.310
Chris, right? I think that I don't have more plexes and those types of things. I think that we're going to have to fill the space with something so

03:10:19.310 --> 03:10:27.180
They're going to put some type of landscaping in and not a lot, you know, not fun and they need certain amount that that's fine

03:10:27.180 --> 03:10:29.180
I don't have a problem. I

03:10:30.360 --> 03:10:36.220
Appreciate the overlay. I have some concerns three years ago three and a half years ago

03:10:36.220 --> 03:10:42.560
we had I won't say a similar conversation, but a conversation about the same area and

03:10:44.580 --> 03:10:46.580
Preserving the mandating

03:10:46.580 --> 03:10:52.080
reserving the historical nature of the homes and so when it comes to the trees in

03:10:52.080 --> 03:10:57.910
this area I love trees I think it's great I just have a hard time telling

03:10:57.910 --> 03:11:04.880
somebody we're requiring you to do it and it will cost you something that personal

03:11:04.880 --> 03:11:10.320
property rights I'm struggling there but again you know this is kind of the new

03:11:10.320 --> 03:11:14.770
thing I know it's going to be coming back I personally would like the kind of

03:11:14.770 --> 03:11:22.180
like the pollinators recommendation, understanding that, hey, we would like that, not a hard,

03:11:22.180 --> 03:11:25.910
you have to do that. That would be my.

03:11:25.910 --> 03:11:33.540
Well, and I think we have a hard time tying it to a dollar amount, just because there's

03:11:33.540 --> 03:11:43.350
some people that may not be in that position. Back to the personal property, right, issue.

03:11:43.350 --> 03:11:49.380
Okay, anybody over there looks right, I'm okay.

03:11:49.540 --> 03:11:54.540
Anybody want to give a general support motion?

03:11:56.740 --> 03:11:59.700
Please go back and be with the developers.

03:11:59.700 --> 03:12:03.420
I would like that developer conversation

03:12:03.420 --> 03:12:05.740
to take place sooner than later.

03:12:05.740 --> 03:12:08.980
We've been working on this since 2018,

03:12:08.980 --> 03:12:13.110
and so I'd love to get it done in my term if possible.

03:12:13.110 --> 03:12:19.880
We could do that by the end of 25, seven years.

03:12:19.880 --> 03:12:20.720
Grayson.

03:12:20.720 --> 03:12:22.600
Madam Mayor, I'm going to make a motion.

03:12:22.600 --> 03:12:24.000
Thank you.

03:12:24.000 --> 03:12:30.040
Madam Mayor, I'll make a motion to support the direction

03:12:30.040 --> 03:12:33.080
director spin love on his zoning title

03:12:33.080 --> 03:12:36.160
amendments to repeal and replace title 10, focus on chapter 6,

03:12:36.160 --> 03:12:39.960
landscape and regulations contingent upon developers'

03:12:39.960 --> 03:12:41.480
feedback.

03:12:41.480 --> 03:12:41.980
Thank you.

03:12:41.880 --> 03:12:43.400
Do I have a second?

03:12:43.400 --> 03:12:44.160
I second.

03:12:44.160 --> 03:12:47.800
Thank you, motion by Grayson Zones, seconded by Chris Reed,

03:12:47.800 --> 03:12:51.400
to support the direction the zoning title amendment

03:12:51.400 --> 03:12:54.480
for replacing title 10 focusing on chapter six

03:12:54.480 --> 03:12:59.480
landscaping regulations with builder and other input.

03:13:02.110 --> 03:13:04.810
Any further discussion?

03:13:04.810 --> 03:13:08.560
Amy Roll call, please.

03:13:08.560 --> 03:13:09.440
Chris Reed.

03:13:09.440 --> 03:13:10.600
Yes.

03:13:10.600 --> 03:13:11.400
Craig Hawkins.

03:13:11.400 --> 03:13:12.240
Yes.

03:13:12.240 --> 03:13:13.080
Jason Brown.

03:13:13.080 --> 03:13:13.920
Yes.

03:13:13.920 --> 03:13:14.760
Hunter Cutler.

03:13:14.760 --> 03:13:15.600
Yes.

03:13:15.600 --> 03:13:16.440
Grayson Stone.

03:13:16.440 --> 03:13:17.280
Yes.

03:13:17.280 --> 03:13:27.540
Yes, thank you. Motion passes seven is zero. Madam Mayor, sir, there will not be an executive session or a need for an executive session.

03:13:27.540 --> 03:13:33.540
That was my next question. Staff is not prepared to move forward with that tonight. We hope to have it next week.

03:13:33.540 --> 03:13:38.540
Okay. Thank you, sir. That being said, our meeting is adjourned. Thank you, everyone.
