Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-11-12, recording 1 (started 16:55) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-11-12/ [0:07:06] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the November 12th, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum [0:07:14] We have six members present in chambers and councilman read is excused [0:07:20] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise [0:07:26] Okay, we have no proclamations tonight. So next on the agenda is the consent calendar [0:07:52] council wishes [0:07:53] Mayor I'd like to make a motion we approve the consent calendar is written. Thank you. Do I have a second? [0:08:00] I'll second. Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins second by [0:08:04] Sherry Vomer to approve the consent calendar as written Amy roll call vote, please [0:08:11] Ruth Pierce. Yes, Craig Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Sherry Vomer. Yes [0:08:19] Yes [0:08:20] Thank you motion passes six to zero [0:08:22] Okay, next on the agenda is a work session, and we'll be going headed upstairs to do that. [0:08:30] Travis, do you want me to go ahead and do general public input right now? [0:08:35] So we will be moving the work session upstairs to the overflow room, so we'll get to that [0:08:43] here in a minute. [0:08:44] But next is the time for general public input. [0:08:48] If there's anybody in the public that wishes to address City Council at this time, you [0:08:53] can come down to the podium and state your name and what you want to say. [0:09:02] Hey, see no one advisory board reports. [0:09:06] Craig? [0:09:07] Council will be doing the judging for the other sweater contest, the State Retreat, [0:09:12] so just be aware. [0:09:15] The last two people did it, you know, it was unacceptable. [0:09:18] I'm going to say, absolutely awesome. [0:09:20] The other thing, as a council, we're supposed to do a service thing. [0:09:29] Who do we turn that into? [0:09:33] Briana, isn't it? [0:09:35] No. [0:09:38] Chief goes to. [0:09:40] You mean the connection experience for the raffle? [0:09:44] You can email them to me, and I will get that to the appropriate people in the committee. [0:09:50] Okay, great, thank you Sean. [0:09:52] That's all I have. [0:09:53] Anybody else? [0:09:55] Yes, Mayor. [0:09:56] Oh, go ahead. [0:09:57] I haven't updated about the library for a while. [0:10:00] Not a lot of news, which is good news, [0:10:02] but we do have a library board meeting tomorrow afternoon. [0:10:06] And we're doing interviews for a new member of the board, [0:10:09] so that position would, I believe, [0:10:11] start working in January. [0:10:13] So that's just what's going on in the world of the library. [0:10:16] Perfect. [0:10:17] Thank you, Sherry. [0:10:18] In Parks and Rec, Vista Bonito Park is moving along, [0:10:25] and so be watching for an open house [0:10:28] on being able to bring your ideas and suggestions [0:10:32] for that park, and it'll be a really great park, [0:10:35] looking to be a bigger park, the community park. [0:10:39] I'm learning this, neighborhood parks [0:10:41] and community parks, right? [0:10:42] Okay, Wendy's saying yes, very good. [0:10:45] So anyway, that's an exciting thing [0:10:47] because that will be a neighborhood park or community park, which is, which would be [0:10:52] quite big in service, a lot of people in that area. [0:10:56] Okay, anything from the city manager? Okay, so what we'll do is we'll take a [0:11:03] adjournment for a minute and we'll go upstairs and reconvene the meeting and [0:11:08] go through the two agenda items at the work session. [0:11:12] So we'll see you in a few minutes. Hey, I'm gonna call the meeting back to [0:15:21] order under work session. Our first item is a presentation, a presentation of draft charter [0:15:29] for proposed multi-use events and our ad hoc committee and we have our economic development [0:15:35] director Sean Berger. Welcome, Sean. [0:15:37] Thank you, Mayor and Council. Thanks for the opportunity to catch up with you on the work [0:15:48] for us on the multi-use events center feasibility study. I've changed the name of [0:15:53] this about 14 times since we started back in the SLF or F days but this is [0:16:00] what I've settled on. So as you may recall part of the funding that the [0:16:07] council allocated from the SLF or F funds included $125,000 for a [0:16:14] feasibility study for a convention, conference, multi-use event space. In the [0:16:24] discussions following that allocation, we determined to put that off until this [0:16:31] new fiscal year in order for it to potentially align with the new urban [0:16:36] renewal area. Should that be a piece of the feasibility moving forward? So we are [0:16:41] And now in that fiscal year that money is in the budget currently and what I've presented [0:16:46] to you in your packet is a draft of a charter that outlines the work of this committee and [0:16:55] really a request that the mayor populate that citizen committee with the consent of the council [0:17:04] to move forward with drafting and requests for qualifications for an appropriate consulting [0:17:10] firm that could do that feasibility work and bringing that back to the council. [0:17:15] So would you like me to go through the detail of what is in the draft there? [0:17:21] So again the background on this goes back to the presentation that was made clear back [0:17:25] to the SLF or F committee. [0:17:28] The most recent comprehensive study of a potential facility like this was conducted in 1992. [0:17:36] I was more than 30 years ago and at that time the chamber had commissioned that and it noted [0:17:43] that the city certainly had demanded a need for this type of facility. [0:17:48] So fast forward 30 years we have a couple of newer facilities that have lost about five [0:17:54] others in that time for meeting space and so I think that there definitely is potential [0:18:02] demand for it. The feasibility study funding would allow us to align with several components [0:18:10] of the strategic plan, including the creating conditions to attract businesses to locate, [0:18:17] stay and expand within the city, looking to hang our hat on tourism as one of the key [0:18:26] industrial or economic drivers for the community and increasing job opportunities and supporting [0:18:32] workforce development. So the objectives for this Adhoc Committee would be to prepare a [0:18:40] request for qualifications for the consulting services to conduct the feasibility study. The [0:18:45] scope of that really would be not only identifying needs, potential programming, space-wise for [0:18:53] the facility, potential locations, but taking those next steps and figuring out how it would [0:19:00] to operate what are potential funding mechanisms, [0:19:02] whether that's something like an auditorium, [0:19:04] district creation, if there are other entities [0:19:08] that might like to operate that, [0:19:10] its public private partnership, et cetera. [0:19:13] And bringing those recommendations back [0:19:17] to the Council for review once the study is completed. [0:19:21] I would recommend that this group be not huge. [0:19:25] So I've suggested seven voting members to be a part of this [0:19:32] and then also to include a representative from the council [0:19:37] and certainly city staff as appropriate [0:19:39] when we may need them for different input. [0:19:43] But potentially to include the Urban Renewal Agency, [0:19:47] the local business associations, [0:19:51] potentially CSI in the school district [0:19:53] or at least bringing them in for consultations [0:19:56] since the facilities may also help to serve [0:19:58] some of their needs frontier community resources, [0:20:02] formerly Region 4 Development as a potential funding source [0:20:07] to help identify a funding for it, [0:20:10] and to bring that group together relatively near future, [0:20:14] do a request for qualifications, [0:20:18] get that information together, [0:20:19] and have a group be able to pull together [0:20:22] the full study in the coming months, I would anticipate this is not more than a 12-month-ish [0:20:29] process to get those recommendations back. [0:20:36] This is following a similar pathway as the recreation center committee, creating a pathway [0:20:45] identifying who would be on that, having that appointment by the council, and then driving [0:20:50] that forward. [0:20:53] I have at least to answer any questions you may have. [0:20:57] Any questions for Sean? [0:20:58] So you're basically asking us to approve your charter tonight? [0:21:04] Tonight? [0:21:05] Is that correct? [0:21:06] I believe that can be a head-not-ish type of direction. [0:21:10] And then finalize that. [0:21:13] Then I would work with you, Mayor, on suggestions for who to appoint. [0:21:17] And then that would be an action of the council at a future date to select and appoint that committee. [0:21:25] Any objection to moving forward with this? [0:21:28] You have the go ahead. [0:21:34] Thank you, Sean. [0:21:38] Next is a discussion about the city's special event permit process and possible changes to that process and we have our [0:21:46] WDS City Manager Mitch Humboldt. Welcome Mitch. Thank you. Craig's enjoying too and Wendy and Elwee's over there if we have questions and all that kind of stuff. [0:21:59] If you remember, some months ago we went through a process to kind of figure out a waiver policy. [0:22:08] I wanted to do this very much the same way, where we'll talk about there's some issues that we need to address. [0:22:15] You know, pick them off one at a time, talk about various options and then show you maybe a recommendation from staff [0:22:21] and then get some feedback from the council. [0:22:24] And then what we will do is we'll go take that feedback [0:22:27] and create something to come back for future action. [0:22:30] So this is not an action item tonight. [0:22:32] This is more of a discussion item. [0:22:34] Give us your input. [0:22:35] Give us your feedback to help shape the creation of whatever [0:22:37] policy or code, right? [0:22:40] Because it could go either way here. [0:22:42] Kind of shape how that's going to turn out. [0:22:45] And so if we have the special event that came through, [0:22:55] some of you will recall the paranormal circus that [0:22:59] happened at the mall at the parking lot. [0:23:01] A couple of weeks after that, some folks [0:23:03] came to a council meeting during the open or the public [0:23:06] impossession and proceeded to just really [0:23:09] file a bunch of complaints about the event. [0:23:12] Most of those complaints were like the nature of the event, [0:23:15] like the content of the event, stuff [0:23:17] that we don't really do a lot with in terms of regulatory. [0:23:23] But there was one comment that came out of that that I thought [0:23:25] was valid, that we needed to kind of examine. [0:23:27] And the comment was, in your code, [0:23:29] you say, if 45-day application process in these guys applied, [0:23:34] I want to say it was like 39 days. [0:23:36] And yet, you approved it in the code, or special events. [0:23:41] That would be a reason to deny the event, [0:23:44] because you didn't give us the 45 days. [0:23:46] Now, in practice, we don't really do that, right? [0:23:50] We try to meet people where we can. [0:23:52] We try to run people through the processes where we can. [0:23:56] were not so hard cores to clear on the code stuff. [0:24:00] And we could find six or seven maybe in the last year [0:24:04] where we had done better than 45 days. [0:24:08] But it was a good, it was a good maybe a wake up call, right? [0:24:13] And what we found was that there are several instances [0:24:17] or practices, I should say, where the code [0:24:21] and our process don't really align. [0:24:25] And so what we wanted to do is repair some sort of a recommendation, right? [0:24:31] Whether that's a change to the process or a change to the code or maybe a little both. [0:24:35] The feeling is that they probably really should align, right? [0:24:39] And so that's the kind of action maybe where we could be challenged [0:24:45] and where we could lose when we are not following our code [0:24:49] when we have adopted code and some things. [0:24:52] found several instances in the special event process where we're not doing that. [0:24:56] And so we wanted to take a little time, go through this, do we want to change the code [0:25:00] to what we're doing in practice or do we want to change our practice to what we're doing, [0:25:04] what we're seeing in the code. And while we're at it, [0:25:08] we think there's a couple of other things we have to point out with the special event code that are [0:25:12] somewhat problematic. And then we will, we're going to put [0:25:17] prepare whatever that amendment needs to be and then come back. So was that [0:25:21] that clear and since it we're involving special event permits you know police [0:25:28] departments very involved in that parks departments very involved that a lot of [0:25:31] the departments get involved in that but those are the kind of the two lead [0:25:34] projects and so we've got we said Wendy and Eloise and Craig both here couldn't [0:25:40] pipe up and have a conversation along with us so so I'm gonna go through a [0:25:51] slide like pick them off kind of one issue at a time we'll make a [0:25:54] recommendation I'll describe maybe what the issue might be and then ask for some [0:25:59] input. Some of these are not big deals. Some of these are bigger deals. I decided I [0:26:04] would start with an easy one. There are some people at the city that feel like [0:26:11] the term special event permit often gets confused with a special use permit and [0:26:18] And special use permitted you all know is a zoning term. [0:26:23] It's very much a permanent action on the use of the property, [0:26:28] especially if end permits are not at all related to zoning, [0:26:31] and they shouldn't be related to zoning. [0:26:33] And there was this kind of thought that perhaps if we change the name [0:26:37] something else like a community event or, you know, some of those kinds of things, [0:26:42] we might eliminate some confusion for the public for some of the internal staff, [0:26:47] as we started looking at what some of the places are calling them, and there's a couple [0:26:54] other options, but by and large, most communities in Idaho are using the term special events. [0:27:00] And so while that is something that we thought we should bring up, and for confusion, I think [0:27:07] our recommendation is that we should just stick with it, right? [0:27:09] And so there are some other options, but anyway, with that, throw that out there, that's issue [0:27:17] number one. Is the confusion internal or external? I think it's both primarily. There [0:27:32] are departments internally that absolutely get the distinction. There are also some [0:27:40] internal departments that don't really understand zoning that well and don't [0:27:43] really understand the difference but I don't think the problem is internal. I [0:27:47] think the problem comes from some of the external folks that like for example if [0:27:53] If you wanted to have an event at a venue that was zoned for events, zoning will often [0:28:05] show up as a special use permit and you don't need a special event permit if you have a [0:28:11] special use permit. [0:28:12] And so again, the terms do are similar, they do sometimes got some confusion, I don't think [0:28:18] it's a big enough confusion personally that we can't overcome it and we have for some [0:28:23] time but it was just one thing that our little committee that worked on this kind of identified [0:28:27] as a potential. I don't think it's a big enough problem but there is a little bit of confusion [0:28:33] both the interline expert. I think it sounds like an education thing. Just spend a little [0:28:40] extra time educating everybody. And then also one more comment procedurally here. If we [0:28:47] are still broadcasting a recording so if you want to say something and the public wants [0:28:51] to be able to hear it. You don't need to use your mics. [0:28:53] I know we're all sitting close and I can hear you just. [0:28:59] Anyway, other thoughts? [0:29:03] Moving on. [0:29:05] This is another one that's not really a problem [0:29:08] in terms of a current difference between process and code. [0:29:12] But it's one that we've identified that a lot of other communities in Idaho [0:29:16] actually do it this way. [0:29:18] And that is, they have tiered kind of events. [0:29:21] So you have a small event, a medium event, a large event, a tier one, a tier two, [0:29:25] three, whatever you want to call it. [0:29:27] And the reason being that some of these events are really, [0:29:30] really easy to get through, and they're not really problematic. [0:29:33] And why would you want to do a 45-day, for example, requirement? [0:29:38] Why would you want to do a large fee requirement if it really [0:29:41] is a fairly simple process? [0:29:45] And so in our code, an event is an event. [0:29:49] They're all the same. [0:29:50] They're all treated the same. [0:29:52] And so the regulations that we come up with are going to apply [0:29:59] to everything the same way, even though for some it isn't going [0:30:04] to. [0:30:06] Some of them, we can probably knock these things out in, you know, [0:30:09] two, three weeks, not 45 days, but some we really do need [0:30:17] the extra time, right? [0:30:18] And so if you have one tier or one type of event and you write it [0:30:23] so that you can meet the code every single time, [0:30:25] some of the smaller ones are gonna have a hard time [0:30:28] with that or the other way around, right? [0:30:31] So, this is again, I put this early on in the case [0:30:36] in the presentation because if we decide [0:30:39] that we think a tiered approach is the way to go, [0:30:42] it'll impact all the rest of the conversations [0:30:46] that we're gonna have tonight. [0:30:47] If we decide we're not going to, [0:30:49] it again, it'll impact all the rest of the conversation [0:30:51] we're gonna have. [0:30:53] We do believe in the staff level that it makes sense to have a tiered approach, and what we've thrown together up here is a three tiered approach. [0:31:01] Tier one, the smaller up to tier three at the higher end. [0:31:05] Well, you can kind of see maybe what the differences would be between them with the large ones that are going to people that are going to close big roads. [0:31:20] I'm thinking maybe like the western days parade where we're actually thinking blue lakes. [0:31:25] We have thousands of people that present. [0:31:27] That's going to be a very different kind of an animal [0:31:31] than closing a cul-de-sac down for a block party [0:31:34] in the neighborhood, for example. [0:31:38] And we ought to. [0:31:41] And so we think that recommendations [0:31:44] should be to create the tears. [0:31:46] And we think that this would be a good idea for the tear [0:31:49] creation. [0:31:50] And so, yes, throw it out there for today. [0:31:59] I read it again, maybe we're OK. [0:32:00] I just wanted to clarify that a special event, not everything [0:32:04] happens in the park is a special event. It has, in order for it to be a special event, [0:32:09] right now it has to have over 500 people or, so they've got some ends up there now, or [0:32:16] amplified sound, or sale of alcohol, or a street closure. And so if an event has one [0:32:24] of those four things, it becomes a special event immediately. But if it's 250 people, [0:32:29] amplified sound, no alcohol and no road closures, it's a park reservation. I just [0:32:35] want to make sure it was clear the difference there. So when we get to [0:32:41] special events status, what Mitch said is absolutely true. Once it hits, special [0:32:47] events status, everything's treated the same. So for example, if this is one of [0:32:53] our favorite ones. So if St. Ed's wants to come over and do a little thing, [0:32:59] with their kids and they want to use the band shell and they want to amplify the [0:33:05] sound it elevates it to a special event and they might have fifty people but [0:33:11] because they were doing amplified sound now it becomes a special event so I just [0:33:15] want to make sure it was clear what where that distinction is between when [0:33:21] it's just using the park and a park reservation and when it becomes special [0:33:25] event so that in your head you understand the difference between when code requires it now. [0:33:35] Also, we'll come back to this issue with the ban shell in a couple slides later on that I want to bring up as well because that's the specific issue we'll talk about the ban shell and actually across the street here in a second. [0:33:51] And I think the key up there that I was getting tangled up with is the less than 500 and amplified sound because I was seeing less than 500. [0:33:58] I was like, oh my gosh, now everything's a special event again, but it has to be an AND or. [0:34:03] Yeah, and the alcohol sales, for example. Anything with alcohol, I'll say we're going to recommend B especially. [0:34:08] That makes sense. I like the tiered approach myself. [0:34:12] Yeah, that makes sense. [0:34:16] Thinking that I can think of one event that was kind of last minute that actually probably turned out to be a park event, but quite a while ago that liked the tiered thing. [0:34:35] Yeah, I like the tiered idea. I had a question about events that might be already permitted [0:34:41] by code. So, for example, there could be a church that can easily accommodate 600 people [0:34:47] as far as parking capacity in the building. If they have a Thursday evening chili cook-off [0:34:54] and 550 people show up, we're not wanting them to get a special event permit. Is that permitted [0:35:01] already by code because it's a church or is that like a I don't mean to open [0:35:09] Pandora's box by the way I like to keep things simple so I'll I've been and just [0:35:15] say briefly it depends we have a church in town that sometimes will throw a [0:35:24] party outside with like a concert kind of a thing and through the special event [0:35:32] process we also have a lot of churches that on a Wednesday night have [0:35:37] Athering where they do the chili cook off whatever we get the inside versus outside is a part of it [0:35:44] I think amplified, you know bothering the neighbors as a part of it [0:35:48] If you really get a like said the concert that'll be for the whole neighborhood [0:36:04] That one will usually have come and I haven't seen you do that [0:36:08] I just have a quick question. So they'll be a step up in the extraordinary city resources from tier two to tier three [0:36:21] would be [0:36:23] so [0:36:29] This is sort of describing what might make one and in both cases tier two or two three if you're going to require [0:36:36] extraordinary city [0:36:37] Resource versus we probably should define that term a little bit [0:36:40] But if the city's going to have to spend money that we wouldn't otherwise spend I would define that [0:36:48] And so if that's the case, you know over time for police to work the event [0:36:53] We if it weren't for the event we wouldn't have the police there doing the overtime. It's extraordinary resource [0:36:58] If it requires that, then you're going to go out of the tier one and into the tier two or three. [0:37:04] The biggest difference is between two and three is the size of the gathering, the size of the street, [0:37:10] that may be as impacted and arterial versus the local street. [0:37:13] Other than that one question. [0:37:17] I guess Mitch, you're just looking at whether we like the tiered system versus not necessarily the details at this point, right? [0:37:34] We'll be able to deal with the details, but if you have input on details, it's a good [0:37:40] time for that as well. [0:37:41] I'm in support of the tier system. [0:37:44] The only question I had is, and I think Wendy alluded to it was, let's say, 250 people. [0:37:50] Have we looked at the size of events of what we had? [0:37:54] Would it be better to break it off if it's more than 250 or is 500 something that you've [0:38:00] looked at most generally as an event of what those numbers should be. [0:38:07] I would say that the code currently says 500 or more is an event, less than 500 is not. [0:38:14] We weren't necessarily suggesting a bunch of drastic changes, but I also don't know [0:38:20] that we really spent a ton of time researching. [0:38:23] Okay, so this thing that happened at the park with 300 people, should that have been an [0:38:28] event? [0:38:29] did a lot of that, but Wendy has had probably more of a feel for just reserving the park [0:38:34] for a thing, right? [0:38:35] And maybe you have a 50 for the trash plan on parks. [0:38:49] We have a review process and when our department reviews it, there are certain thresholds that [0:38:55] trigger certain requirements. [0:38:57] For instance, 250 triggers a trash plan, a parking plan and portables. [0:39:03] So we're looking into those types of impacts to the facility, not necessarily the special event piece, so it does capture that. [0:39:11] Yeah, no, that's fine. I was just looking, is there a gray area in there in the sense of, to me, if we're bringing in porta-potties and things like that, then there's at least a level of a trigger point or something to think about, [0:39:27] Should the city be taking on that financial responsibility and not the event itself? [0:39:35] Or is that part of reserving the park that says, hey, if I need border parties, you're already paying for it? [0:39:41] And to be honest, that's kind of what we get at with it that way. [0:39:46] So to avoid extraordinary resources, if your event is going to put enough pressure on a space [0:39:55] that exceeds what normal day-to-day operations and where in terror and use of the facility would be, [0:40:03] it becomes the responsibility of the organizer to take care of it. [0:40:08] So in other words, I think it gets at what you're thinking, Jason, in that it requires them to bring in [0:40:20] the extra things that they might need to have their event so that it isn't a negative impact [0:40:25] on the park and I guess I mean again I think we're getting down into the [0:40:30] details and that's not necessarily what we're looking for I just I think it's a [0:40:34] great idea to do tears but let's make sure that we're we're covering the basis [0:40:39] of so tears are yeah and I think we're getting that now with the park [0:40:44] reservation if it's in a park right 150 people and the parking lot of the church [0:40:49] like Spencer was talking they're doing amplified sound this is a big one this is [0:41:14] a significant difference in our code versus our process. If you read the city [0:41:19] code regarding special events, the authority to approve a special event lies [0:41:23] with the chief of police and yet we bring to the council for approval. And so I'm [0:41:34] trying to think back because I was working here when we did the code as it [0:41:40] exists today and I kind of remember being part of that process and I remember [0:41:45] I would say the Chief Police has an authority, but I also remember at some point the council [0:41:52] saying, you know, we'd love to see those, we'd like to see those, and part of that, I [0:41:59] recall part of that reason for that being that it's good for the event if we have them [0:42:04] at a council meeting with publicity for the event, right? [0:42:08] And so if they come to a council meeting for approval, it gets in somebody's, you know, [0:42:13] agenda, the newspaper might pick it up, and it might be good for the event, and it's [0:42:18] a little bit of a publicity thing. [0:42:20] I saw it more as that than as a control thing, right? [0:42:24] I don't believe the council was asking [0:42:25] for the control of the process, [0:42:27] but more helping the events along. [0:42:30] That's my recollection of it, I don't sit on the council. [0:42:34] Right? [0:42:35] But we don't do the process now, does not match the code. [0:42:38] I recollect a little bit different, [0:42:40] because I think we had a couple of events [0:42:43] that we were totally unaware of. [0:42:46] And so we asked to put those on the consent calendar, so we would know about the event. [0:42:52] So if we got contacted by a citizen about an event that we weren't in the dark. [0:42:59] So I don't know that it needs to go as far as we approve them as much as we just would [0:43:07] like to know about them. [0:43:09] whether it's a calendar that's shared versus put on the consent calendar, just a minor tweak. [0:43:17] We're not in a position to decide. [0:43:20] We don't know all the details chief knows. [0:43:25] We gave us the ability to pull something off and ask a question, thinking of the laser light [0:43:30] show. [0:43:32] So if there's a way to do it to where we still have knowledge and potentially input [0:43:39] or whatever it is, if there was a happy medium there, I mean, Chief can approve those Ollie [0:43:47] likes. [0:43:48] Madam Mayor, what if we, when we asked the city manager's office if there's an announcement, [0:44:00] maybe there's a block. [0:44:03] What events were approved? [0:44:05] approved. We also have an opportunity to like I said create a calendar maybe you know from [0:44:14] you know the chief's office that says here's all the events we proved we could do it at the [0:44:18] meeting if we still like the public component of it. One of the reasons I wanted to bring [0:44:22] it up is specifically because when we another question a little later on we're gonna talk [0:44:26] about timing of how long it takes us to review these. Getting it to the council really does [0:44:33] add time to the process as much as maybe two weeks, right? I think that if we had it [0:44:40] approved at the staff level whether that be the parks director, the chief of [0:44:44] police, the city manager, or designees or whatever ends up being, we probably would [0:44:48] want to build it an appeal process. So if somebody doesn't like the decision they [0:44:53] get, they can have an opportunity to appeal to the council. That will also [0:44:56] build in some time to the process. Isn't code currently give the appeal to [0:45:01] Council? Yeah, right now the authorities with the chief and there's an appeal to [0:45:05] the council so we'd like to keep the appeal process and so there's just [0:45:13] implications in other pieces of it where the authority lies. Does that allow us [0:45:18] into appeal event that was approved? It's an applicant appeal process as I [0:45:27] understand it now. Yeah, I think keeping it with city managers, I'm just reading [0:45:37] up there the police chief or whatnot to have whoever in the city to manage those [0:45:45] and approve them and then like you said with the appeal process. I don't think [0:45:49] every single one needs to come to city council. When we were reviewing other [0:45:53] other cities around the state the chief is a very common place for this to [0:45:58] light. We have some other options. We are unique almost among cities, night with city [0:46:04] manager. That could be a place for it. A parks director gets involved in almost [0:46:09] almost all of the, not almost all, but a high percentage of the events. So maybe [0:46:14] that's part of it too. But we have options. We think our recommendation was [0:46:20] let's stick with the chief and we'll find a different mechanism to make the [0:46:24] council aware of what's happening. One of the things that I would like to ask [0:46:33] is that you run the approval process in terms of liability [0:46:38] by the council action, shielding the organization [0:46:41] as opposed to by the chief for this particular request. [0:46:46] I think that there's greater liability [0:46:48] if you do it by the individual by the chief [0:46:50] as opposed to if the council makes the approval. [0:46:52] So if we can run that through Bruce, [0:46:54] I recommend that we do that. [0:46:58] And actually the liability question [0:46:59] is something we're gonna come back to. [0:47:02] I think the mayor had touched on something [0:47:06] or more of my thought, and then Gretchen's comment is, [0:47:09] are we putting the Chief of Police in a situation [0:47:13] or scenario from a liability? [0:47:15] But I go back to the premise of opening up the discussion [0:47:19] with a particular special use event that occurred. [0:47:28] I would be in a position, I'd prefer not to be caught [0:47:30] off guard of something, and now that's not a, [0:47:33] you're not gonna catch it 100%. [0:47:35] So I was looking back to the tiered conversation. [0:47:38] Do you maybe put some type of trigger or threshold [0:47:42] in that tier where a tier one is going by the chief of police [0:47:46] and or something like that to where. [0:47:49] And I'm assuming the larger events [0:47:50] may bring bigger publicity. [0:47:54] I look at the one that we discussed, the paranormal search. [0:47:57] I'm assuming it would have fallen into the tier three [0:48:01] according to the numbers. [0:48:03] Have we seen maybe a trend that the ones that are a little bit more, [0:48:08] people are questioning a little bit more fall into that higher tier? [0:48:11] And maybe we look at how that happens too. [0:48:15] With the tiered approach, we certainly could treat the different tiers differently. [0:48:18] That's one of the advantages of the tiered approach, right? [0:48:22] And then design some type of reporter, but that can say, hey, 500 tier one events were, [0:48:27] and these are the events, and we move on, the council doesn't see it on the agenda each week [0:48:32] something but assuming as we move up we'd probably want to be aware of what's [0:48:37] happening. The code I said currently is written where the chief is approving and [0:48:53] we're not doing that. I think that opens us up to a bit of liability. I think it [0:48:57] goes back to what Gretchen said that I think for just discussion purposes not [0:49:04] saying I want it this way but I would say that the council would approve tier [0:49:07] three and then the chief and even if you put the city manager tier two something [0:49:13] like that, I don't think it has to be that way, but you know what the [0:49:17] attorneys say may give us some direction of what's going on. [0:49:22] Other thoughts? Okay, so this concept of extraordinary city resources is one we [0:49:40] should talk about a little bit. There's like three places in the code where it [0:49:44] says if you have an event that requires extraordinary city resources, the city [0:49:48] will build you for that. We don't do that. We don't do that in some big ways, right? [0:49:55] We don't do that in traffic control. We don't do that in any other departments over time besides police security over time. [0:50:03] So we actually give away a lot of extraordinary resources for city for special events. [0:50:12] We do charge for some, right, whenever we have beer sales and the police department sends people for security specifically for beer sales, [0:50:20] we'll charge those, right, for that over time. [0:50:23] Every single parade we have we essentially give away to the public. We have, I'm trying to think the last [0:50:31] parade I went down for, we had 20 to 25 city employees setting up the barricades, coming back later, [0:50:38] taking down the barricades all on overtime, didn't charge it. We had traffic control set up in various [0:50:46] locations didn't charge for it. There's a traffic control plan that needs a [0:50:52] you know a MUTCD compliant plan that needs to be done again that we don't charge [0:50:58] for those kinds of things but we do charge for for some stuff right and so [0:51:03] that we're more not consistent here and we don't charge for some very large ones. [0:51:10] Now we've had this conversation with the council before we've we came summer of [0:51:14] of 23, I think it was. [0:51:16] And there's a very similar presentation [0:51:18] and we showed you all the money that we're not recovering [0:51:22] from some of these events and the council at the time said, [0:51:24] we understand and there's a value to special events [0:51:26] and that's the value, right? [0:51:28] And so we still don't charge for those things. [0:51:31] So our recommendation is in a very similar path. [0:51:44] We didn't necessarily want to beat this horse again [0:51:46] but we're not complying with our code. [0:51:49] So we probably should rewrite the code [0:51:52] in this case, to say what we will or won't be willing, I guess. [0:52:02] And so this is a complicated one, and it's a kind of an important one, right? [0:52:08] Because right now, we're not following the code. [0:52:12] Is there an issue if you charge a percentage versus, so the city covers half, the event covers half, [0:52:22] so that we all have skin in the game. [0:52:24] Is there a problem with that? [0:52:28] It feels like we should write into the code, right? [0:52:31] That there's a value to the community at large [0:52:34] for special events and recognition of that value [0:52:36] of the city's willing to cover blah, blah, blah, right? [0:52:40] And fill in the blank, 50% or 25% or whatever it ends up in. [0:52:46] I think we can decide what we're gonna do there, right? [0:52:49] So the council has authority to direct the resources [0:52:54] of our tax resources, right? [0:52:57] Certainly within the purview to spend tax money on those kinds of things. [0:53:02] I just think we need to say so, right? [0:53:06] Because right now we're just flat out. [0:53:09] Well, I think if I recall in our 2023 discussion, [0:53:12] the total amount as the percentage of our $100 million budget was pretty minor. [0:53:21] And I think we chose not to beat that horse at that time. [0:53:26] I don't remember specifically, I know that we talked about western days versus the St. [0:53:37] Patty's Day versus other specific issues and maybe your group looks at those and says what [0:53:45] are we paying, what are they paying, where's a common thread that we could build into the [0:53:52] code? [0:53:53] year calendar year example we used a year example and it was in that forty to seventy [0:54:03] thousand dollar range for the year a bunch of it more than like half of it was western [0:54:09] dicks right one event right so so does it make sense to use the tiered system and then [0:54:16] apply a percentage dollar amount or something to the tiered system and lower tiers are going [0:54:21] to obviously have lower impacts as well the big ones are going to be really the big loss [0:54:27] says if you want to call it that is parades, right? The parades are where we're losing a bunch of money and it's spread across [0:54:34] multiple departments in those barricades that we have. And the last time we did this we didn't really have the barricades. [0:54:41] The barricades are a fairly new acquisition for us. We don't charge for the rental of the barricades, right? [0:54:46] We just go put them up and take them down and usually it's like I said there's some overtime involved in that. [0:54:52] But there's also a public safety aspect of it as well. [0:54:58] We propose, we should not have these barricades in a budget a few years ago, right? [0:55:03] And to Mitch's point and Mary, your point, we have come a long way in the last three, [0:55:09] two to three years on public safety for parades and different events. [0:55:14] As an organization, I think our biggest expenditure on special events is going to be the parades. [0:55:19] And it's not just the traffic safety that we do, but it's also safety for the attendees, [0:55:26] whether that's from a law enforcement security and safety aspect or these barricades that we [0:55:32] now use. [0:55:33] The first few times, I usually drive a police car to lead the Christmas night light parade. [0:55:43] When you, I know a lot of you, members of the council, then in the fire tracker, and it [0:55:49] was really kind of scary because it is dark. There's a lot of lights which are [0:55:53] blinding as well from the police car, different things and the little boys and [0:56:00] girls want to come out and get candy. And as your chief of police the last thing I [0:56:05] wanted is a child or anybody injured during what's supposed to be a [0:56:08] celebratory event whether it's the night light parade, St. Patty's parade, [0:56:14] etc. As an organization we are doing some great things. Mark Thompson and our [0:56:20] in our street department. They are wonderful partners and truly the ones, when I started [0:56:26] here, special events were as far as the staffing. If it was in the park, the parks department [0:56:32] helped and then it was the police department's problem, quote unquote. Now we have come so [0:56:37] long, it's so far long. It's truly a city wide organizational event. Whatever that event [0:56:44] is and the night light praise a great example. Of course, Western days is a great example. [0:56:49] a lot of people into the community, but it takes a lot of resources. [0:56:53] Recently, the last two western days of the parades, we have had our team put the barricades [0:56:59] along, which is shown near City Park. [0:57:02] We don't have enough barricades, we go all the way up to blue lakes and stuff, but that's [0:57:06] really where we, in point, it is the most dangerous to have children running out in front of the [0:57:13] flows, et cetera. [0:57:14] So, there's a lot more to it than there was a couple of years ago, mayor, to your point, [0:57:20] And I would, as your chief of police recommend that we do, I think exactly this one of what [0:57:25] you were saying is have maybe a different approach on the tiers, whether it's extraordinary [0:57:31] resources, whatever we define that as, we're going to have to recoup some of that. [0:57:36] The problem that we have, we do get some requests for I'll say like a homecoming type pray. [0:57:43] And I think we need to be a little bit, I would advise council to be a little bit, um, [0:57:50] pathetic to those kind of smaller events that maybe happen every couple of years if a certain school wants to do a [0:57:57] Homecoming type parade down main or whatever [0:58:00] Recognizing that budgets are different. They're not businesses. So I would I would caution that we also keep that in mind [0:58:07] That we may have different types of [0:58:13] The last parade that I went down and dealt out with we had [0:58:17] had employees from the airport, from parks, from streets, from IT, so you cancel down there. [0:58:27] All helping to set up these barricades, it's turned into Craig's Point. It's turned into [0:58:32] a very much of one city kind of approach to those things, which is kind of cool to see, [0:58:37] but it also impacts a lot more people than it used to. One of the thoughts that I had [0:58:42] had for parades, resources, we can, we can, we have a pretty well figured out the main [0:58:50] street parades, right? Our barricades work for the main street parade. We kind of know [0:58:55] the control plan pretty well. And so perhaps we will cover the expenses for a main street [0:59:04] parade that follows our predefined route. If you want to parade, that's a different route. [0:59:09] So maybe that's a trade-off and again, that's a big deal for western days because they don't [0:59:21] follow that route and there's an expensive parade for us to deal with. [0:59:26] So I don't know if that's, are we pushing too much back on western days or not, it parades [0:59:35] pretty... [0:59:47] Thing to these later? [0:59:49] Oh again, there's a place in the code where it says to apply for an event, there's a fee, [1:00:01] And then there's other place in the code where it says if you cost any money, you'll save it. [1:00:10] I think if we define what an extraordinary cost is to the city, then we can continue to have that conversation as we kind of fill out through some of these. [1:00:21] Because if it's a 50% or we look at the tier, my personal feeling is there is a cost that we need to recover. [1:00:30] What that cost is, not quite sure. [1:00:32] but my thought was back to the police is, [1:00:35] we're paying for police to be there, [1:00:37] but also then police the rest of the city. [1:00:39] And so, to me, the cost comes to the police [1:00:42] that are covering the event is a cost that I would, [1:00:48] I think, yeah, over time, setting up barricades. [1:00:51] I'm assuming, lack of not knowing, [1:00:54] couple of hours were gone, [1:00:56] but if an event's lasting three or four hours, [1:00:59] you're starting to calculate some time. [1:01:10] Calus went to your point, in the police department [1:01:13] historical we have generally budgeted [1:01:15] and our overtime budget for these events. [1:01:18] But what hasn't happened is budgeting [1:01:20] from other departments for the overtime. [1:01:22] The street department as an example does, [1:01:24] I don't know, actually don't know if they did this year, [1:01:26] historically they don't add overtime [1:01:29] for this type of event or in the police department we do. [1:01:31] So to be fair, we put money in our overtime budget [1:01:35] I guess just moving forward and it gets probably a conversation we need to figure out what that [1:01:44] hearing or willingness to recover some but let's not overburden our event holders [1:01:58] well and you need to be consistent between the code and process to yeah that's why I brought it up [1:02:05] mainly because we're gonna keep doing what we're doing we need to change the code so other thoughts [1:02:13] that's before I move on to the next one. [1:02:18] So on this particular issue, I'm going to go back [1:02:20] to what I was talking about in the very beginning [1:02:22] with these venues that are approved to have events, right? [1:02:29] I don't know why, but a Canyon Crest, for example, right? [1:02:31] Canyon Crest event center is an event center, right? [1:02:34] That's their purpose for being. [1:02:36] They are zoned appropriately for that stuff [1:02:40] that happens at Canyon Crest event center. [1:02:41] They don't come to the police department all the time [1:02:43] to get special event permits, they just don't, right? [1:02:46] Our code allows that to happen. [1:02:48] It says that if you're an event that's been zoned for this, [1:02:51] you don't have to get a special event process. [1:02:54] Now, we have two city-owned venues [1:03:00] that I would say are designated event venues. [1:03:05] The plaza across the street is built and developed [1:03:08] as an event venue, right? [1:03:10] The ban shell is an event venue. [1:03:14] That's what they are. [1:03:15] are zoned appropriately and yet we still will make somebody come and get a [1:03:21] special event permit for use of those venues when maybe they could just be as [1:03:27] simple as a park reservation because they still are facilities and so this is a [1:03:32] question that I wanted to bring up. Do we want to just by virtue of being the city [1:03:40] and the band shell, like that's why the band shell was built for the city band to be concerts [1:03:48] there. And yet we may come through every year and get their event permit for the year's worth [1:03:52] of concerts. It seems excessive. [1:03:55] But if we have an event with a thousand people in the Commons, we want to have a process more [1:04:05] than just to park reservation. [1:04:06] Yeah, so what I would say is their event venues intended for sound, they're not necessarily alcohol sales, they're not necessarily, you know, some other things. [1:04:18] So the Wednesday night concert series, for example, one of the tiers that we showed you was commercial venting. [1:04:24] They're going to close the streets in a set of commercial venting. They're going to have alcohol sales. [1:04:30] There's a lot about that event that is more than just using the band shell for the city band concert [1:04:37] They probably should so go ahead and get the special event permit for [1:04:42] the Wednesday at concert series the Thursday night summer band [1:04:48] City band concerts [1:04:50] Who doesn't know that those things aren't gonna happen every Thursday night forever, right? It's like in happening [1:04:56] re-World War II. Question I have there then would be could we not provide an [1:05:03] exception for the city band? I know it opens up well or for some some other [1:05:09] people asking for that same exemption or exception. And I use them as the example [1:05:14] but there are a lot of little events that happen at City Park in the band [1:05:19] show like a Easter morning church service right? Does it then it does it [1:05:24] become more of a time of the event and not location of the event. So, Easter morning. It's [1:05:31] happening in the morning during, let's say, regular business hours at eight o'clock in [1:05:35] the morning. Probably not. Yeah, church. No one's going to get upset. But if that event's [1:05:40] happening at midnight in the park, I mean, so. [1:05:44] City Park currently has regulations that [1:05:48] Talk about when events can happen in the by-unshell [1:05:54] in certain timing [1:05:57] Already and one of the times that they're supposed to avoid is Sunday mornings until like [1:06:06] There's a time on Sunday morning so that anything you're doing so that you can't have a rock concert [1:06:12] that goes for three days, it starts up at 10 o'clock on Sunday morning and interferes with [1:06:17] church services up nearby churches. So there's hours already in place that limit the use of [1:06:27] the ban shell. So if I went for a special event permit to say I want to have a concert [1:06:34] inside of those hours, are we going to exclude them? Just in just saying that's, I guess maybe [1:06:41] not explaining maybe well so I get that we have certain hours that you can't [1:06:47] already you don't have to have a special use or whatever but if I wanted to say [1:06:50] hey I want to have a three-day drop okay so like I can't even super see though [1:06:55] the park already has the regulation the fact that it's amplified sound it's [1:07:01] they're not consistent with each other so for example yesterday the Veterans Day [1:07:09] event didn't come in until Friday and they need to have a fight sound. It's not a huge event and [1:07:16] if we were to say that gosh the band shell, this is an appropriate use of the band shell, [1:07:22] it's at the right time of day, it's all of the things, it's under 500 people, maybe it doesn't [1:07:32] need to be a special event, maybe or the little church, yeah, the talent show from St. Edwards, [1:07:41] It's maybe it's 75 people, it's in the van shell, [1:07:46] it's three o'clock in the afternoon on a Tuesday, [1:07:50] it meets everything else in a venue that's designed [1:07:53] to be that so maybe we don't worry about it. [1:07:56] But, so again, is that part of a tear structure? [1:07:58] And do you change those numbers to a hundred and above? [1:08:02] Or I'm asking a rhetorical question, so it's just, [1:08:07] and then also consider the impact [1:08:09] while we were talking a little bit ago, [1:08:10] when you talk about these structures and the tier structures, [1:08:14] consider the insurance that may need to be involved, [1:08:19] because we don't want somebody with 500 people in the park, [1:08:23] and somebody gets hurt who's following this. [1:08:26] But they're required to provide proof of interest. [1:08:28] No matter what size. [1:08:30] Well, when you have a question for you too, [1:08:31] you reference the talent show from St. Edward's. [1:08:34] What keeps two parties, if there's not a event permit, [1:08:38] to make sure we're clarifying event permit versus use permit [1:08:43] because they're very different things, an event permit [1:08:47] what keeps another group from coming in saying [1:08:49] that they're going to use it as well. [1:08:53] You have a part preservation process. [1:08:55] So there's the right, yeah. [1:08:57] But if neither party has a reservation. [1:08:59] So then, you know, and this is kind of where, [1:09:03] so the conversation can sound like if you've gone [1:09:07] to the event process and you've gotten the permits, [1:09:12] where, so, okay, so you and Spencer go over [1:09:18] and you pull your cars under the grass [1:09:20] and you turn your cereals up really loud [1:09:23] and you just start having a party, right? [1:09:26] And maybe even bring a kick. [1:09:28] And you're doing the whole thing [1:09:29] and you've got people there [1:09:31] and you haven't gone through any, [1:09:32] you're just using the park to do this thing. [1:09:37] And they get a call from a neighbor, [1:09:40] maybe that lives in one of the townhouses, and now the police department shows up, and [1:09:48] they ask you to leave, because you're violating certain rules of using the park. [1:09:54] And so now we could ask you to leave because you're being disruptive. [1:09:57] Works for me. [1:10:01] But if you reserve the plaza across the street, I'm thinking about our Special Olympics torture [1:10:09] that we had over the summertime. [1:10:11] We had a group run around the torch. [1:10:15] They stopped at the Plaza across street. [1:10:17] They set up a microphone and they spoke. [1:10:21] Microphone means, regardless that there was only 50 people [1:10:24] there, the microphone means, especially that. [1:10:27] And it seems silly to make that process go through, [1:10:31] to me, it seems silly to make that process go through, [1:10:33] especially that, you know, 45 day or 35 day process. [1:10:38] And, you know, all these other things, [1:10:40] just to be able to do that small thing that was over in 20 minutes. [1:10:43] So where do you draw the line? Because you had the first federal rock paper scissors with [1:10:50] lots of sound and lots of people. And so you can put with a park reservation and keep the [1:10:57] tears that you're talking about. But again, the first fed thing, shut down the streets, [1:11:02] set up commercial vending. They had a bunch of other things that would have kicked in at [1:11:07] alcohol cells, they're not just a presentation venue using it as a presentation. There's other [1:11:15] things that would have kicked in. And so I kind of feel like what I'm suggesting is that [1:11:20] maybe if we have our two presentation venues and people want to use them for presentations, [1:11:24] that should be okay. But if you want to sell alcohol or sell other commercial vending or [1:11:31] you know, these other big impacts close the street down, you're going to trigger the [1:11:36] especially in any way. It's more than just using the ban shell to broadcast and sell to them. [1:11:43] And if you take it down to a lower level, in the park code, there's all kinds of behaviors [1:11:49] that are prohibited without permission. Certain behaviors are just flat out prohibited, and [1:11:53] then some are prohibited without the permission of the director, which is what our reservation [1:11:58] process does and the permit that we give. So if you're going to drive on the grass, you [1:12:03] cannot drive on the grounds without permission of the director. So if you want to drive on [1:12:08] the grass and you submit your permit, and I can say yes, Spencer, you can drive your [1:12:11] truck right in there and turn on your music, that'll be fine. Or we could write, or he could [1:12:18] just try to do it, and then there's a problem, right? So the code allows us to enforce the, [1:12:25] sorry Spencer, you can do it if you want to try it. So it just, it allows us to regulate [1:12:32] behavior that hasn't been gone through a process and hasn't been permitted. [1:12:36] So that's what it becomes a problem. [1:12:38] So do you like this proposal, Wendy, or do you agree with that? [1:12:45] I think it would simplify some things. [1:12:48] Yeah, so as I'm thinking this is a work session, so we're not going to get into the weeds and [1:12:55] grass of it. [1:12:57] But I always have to look at the devil's advocate of, you know, you're talking about [1:13:03] churches and small groups and things like this. [1:13:07] And just remember that as we grow, small groups are not always maybe within our values. [1:13:16] I don't know. [1:13:18] But also, okay, so let me go back to when you were talking about Special Olympics and [1:13:22] whatnot. [1:13:23] Is there anything, and maybe this isn't open for discussion right now because I don't want [1:13:27] to be here until nine o'clock at night. [1:13:30] But is there a way to do exceptions properly within the city? [1:13:36] I think that's what this does. [1:13:40] It just seems really, really broad. [1:13:42] And maybe that's okay. [1:13:43] If you designate it as an appropriate space for these things as a venue, right? [1:13:50] And it's a small group, and it's a small thing. [1:13:54] I can permit it without it winding up in a special event process. [1:14:00] I think to, I'm sorry, what do you say? [1:14:03] say into your point now I think that we're we're trying to take some of the red tape [1:14:09] out of the process for the smaller groups the the St. Ed's their great choir [1:14:15] that does a show at noon they still have to get a part reservation which they'll [1:14:20] have their insurance and all that but the police chief and the city council [1:14:24] doesn't have to sign off on that I think that's what we're trying to do [1:14:29] that's in my mind to try, you know, the Special Olympics torch run with 10 athletes from our [1:14:36] Twin Falls Special Olympics teams, some law enforcement that we ran. [1:14:42] I think that's where I'm thinking if there's any way, and maybe there isn't, you know, you [1:14:46] have to get a permit with the exception of, but maybe that's where we get into more trouble [1:14:50] is the exception of. [1:14:51] Well, I think if you want to use our stage here, or the band shell, you're going to have [1:14:56] to get reservations from the park director. [1:14:59] Right. [1:15:00] And they can do that up to two days in advance, or even less, [1:15:03] depending on what you're telling me, which I wasn't aware of, [1:15:06] which was good, was that there are certain parameters [1:15:09] that if you're going to be doing stupid things, then you're out. [1:15:14] And this, by designating these as pre-approved venues [1:15:19] for certain things, like amplified sound, if we say, [1:15:22] gee, we have a band shell. [1:15:24] I guess we intended that to have amplified sound. [1:15:26] or we built a stage right out here with the intent of having amplified sound, [1:15:32] maybe we don't have to go get permission to have amplified sound. [1:15:35] However, if you want to do the same thing at Harry Berry Park, [1:15:40] now it's not a pre-approved venue, it's really close to neighbors, [1:15:43] and now we have to have a different conversation, but this would prohibit, [1:15:47] or it would make it easier for us to permit some of these little things. [1:15:52] I understand where you're going with this now. [1:15:54] I think my head I'm thinking two different things so for this yes, I agree [1:15:58] Couldn't we essentially have tears per location meaning like [1:16:03] Ansel here's your tears the comments here's the tears all else [1:16:07] Like you're talking about amplified sound because that's one of the conditions that triggers a special event permit [1:16:13] So if it's at one of those two locations, and it's just amplified sound it doesn't trigger a special event permit [1:16:19] That's basically what we're saying. [1:16:22] Well, the numbers might. [1:16:24] The numbers might. [1:16:25] And what I'm suggesting here is, this is, if we just, this is just us interpreting our [1:16:31] process or our code, right, if we decide that this is what we're going to do, the code [1:16:35] is already written to allow venues that have been designated to not get these permits. [1:16:41] We just haven't been doing it. [1:16:43] We've been making them get the permits at these two venues. [1:16:45] We don't have to do that. [1:16:47] So this is more of a procedural kind of a thing, more so than a code thing. [1:16:52] But I think what this does is exactly what you just described. [1:16:55] This would be the smaller tier thing for those two venues specifically. [1:16:59] And it's just the way that we're interpreting what's written. [1:17:06] Application timelines. [1:17:11] And this is another one where really is a benefit of the tier system. [1:17:16] I think because some of these things take a little while, particularly when we're going to need to schedule security over time, right? [1:17:23] right, the police department needs time just to make sure they can get people on the schedule [1:17:29] to do it. [1:17:31] And if we have these come to the city council meetings for approval, then they'll need time [1:17:37] to get a couple of weeks just to get staff work written, get on an agenda. [1:17:42] If they're approved by the chief, we'll need a little bit of time to allow for an appeal [1:17:46] process to happen. [1:17:47] And so there's some time, but these smaller events really, we can get those done very quickly. [1:17:53] And so I think our recommendation here is just going to be, again, go with the tiers and [1:17:56] then reflect the timelines to be what I would say what we can realistically accomplish. [1:18:06] And then live with those timelines. [1:18:09] And that's, I think, the bigger one here. [1:18:11] So when we turn down an event permit because they submitted a few days past the deadline, [1:18:22] We need to be willing to do that, and we need to have the support to do that. [1:18:29] So when Craig's just out of the event, he needs to know that Travis doesn't go in there and [1:18:33] say, or the council won't do that too. [1:18:37] We haven't been doing that, right? [1:18:40] So we've been making things work. [1:18:44] And that is specifically the one that was challenged in July that was a violation of our [1:18:51] code. [1:18:54] I think we can tear the events and we can write the timelines in such a way that really is doable, right? [1:19:01] Not overly long, but a reason, right? We can get a ton of that, man. [1:19:07] Yeah, I was just going to add that I support whatever time frame city staff needs to protect themselves. [1:19:13] I want someone to come show up on a Monday for an event they want to have Friday, [1:19:18] And you know, you've got to pick one day, personnel issue another day, and then three [1:19:25] things the council said you need to have done by this day, and you have to drop it. [1:19:28] So whatever time frame staff needs to be able to do your job side support. [1:19:36] And to be honest, the ones that tend to show up on Monday for Friday are small. [1:19:41] And we can process those in two to three days in a park thing. [1:19:45] If it doesn't wind up being, you know, if it doesn't trigger a special event piece, we [1:19:53] can usually move those through pretty quickly and usually those are the ones that are, oh, [1:19:59] hey. [1:20:05] When I responded to the group, I got several emails from the group that was complaining [1:20:10] about our timeline. [1:20:13] We'd done some research to look at other events that had been approved in less than 45 days. [1:20:21] I can go through all of them, but live nativity, southern idol outdoor show, [1:20:25] NAMI Walk, summer carnival, haunted swamp, retail therapy, grand opening, [1:20:30] garibaldi's, all those were done in less than 45 days. And so if we have that [1:20:36] many events that are not doing the 45 days, we have a lot of education to do, [1:20:45] it seems to me, with our event planners to say we're sticking with this, and [1:20:52] And some of them weren't even 30 that probably could have been if so so I think we have to if we're gonna be hard and solid [1:21:00] I think we have to be [1:21:03] Very right. Yeah, very much so [1:21:07] Affective date and send it out to all the non-profits and all sorts of PSA's [1:21:13] And I think we really have to get the word out. We really know who all of our [1:21:18] our event handlers are, because they come back most of them year after year, and we do reach [1:21:24] out to them. I think Eloise, you reach out to them here at any time now to say, get on [1:21:28] the calendar for next year. So we have communication with them. This would be an easy one to add [1:21:32] to that. One of the things I forgot to say earlier is that some of those events, when [1:21:37] it's a repeat event and we are familiar with the event, we can move those through much [1:21:41] quicker. Like you mentioned, Taunin Swamp, right? We've done the Haunin Swamp for years [1:21:45] now. We've done Western days for 30 years now, right? [1:21:49] But again, they didn't apply 45 days prior to the event. [1:21:53] Didn't. [1:21:54] And yes, we could run them through faster, but if we're going to be solid with this application, [1:21:59] then that's fine. [1:22:00] But one of the things we can write into the application is a first time event, a paranormal [1:22:06] cirk, we need the 45 days for you guys because we just don't know what we're getting into. [1:22:12] the seventh year of Haunted Swamp, we could probably cut that down to 30 days, but we could write it appropriately. [1:22:19] Which then is your second box instead of your third box. [1:22:22] And actually the third box includes the repeat event too. [1:22:25] So a tier one event is shorter, even a tier two or a tier three event that's a repeat event, we could probably get it in shorter. [1:22:32] And if we go back and start writing this, we'll really tweak these days and maybe 30 days is 28 days or whatever. [1:22:41] I'm with Spencer, you know, whatever, if staff has a timeline in mind, but I, you know, going [1:22:47] back to the scenario that was just said that we had an event come in on a Monday and we wanted [1:22:53] to get approved by Friday. [1:22:54] I don't want to put ourselves into a box where we don't have the discretion to make some of [1:22:59] those decisions and make an event happen. [1:23:01] And again, if there's something that we can write in that says if you've, if this is multiple [1:23:08] year event, you've come in, we understand you, we understand you, you understand us, let's [1:23:13] move on. [1:23:14] Again, we bring up paranormal syrup, I don't think it was necessarily even though it was [1:23:20] a nuance of the time that was being approved, I think it was the event in which was being [1:23:25] approved. [1:23:26] And I don't want to get into a box where we are not flexible enough to work with the citizens [1:23:31] in situations. [1:23:32] Obviously, we know one time event is probably going to take longer. [1:23:36] So however we can write that into code, the process, [1:23:41] I would like to give staff and our community [1:23:44] the best amount of flexibility as we can. [1:23:48] I think the tiered program allows us to be the most flexible. [1:23:52] And when I listen to that list, pretty much all of them [1:23:56] are events held in non-city facilities. [1:24:01] And if we can get this all figured out in time, [1:24:05] we can add all of those to the list that email, [1:24:09] the Eloise emails, out. [1:24:12] And those come in for us by January 1st. [1:24:17] And so we're processing all of the big ones in January. [1:24:21] And it could help by reminding them, hey, [1:24:25] you want to do this again? [1:24:27] Turn in your paperwork now. [1:24:29] And we can easily include that, which will probably [1:24:32] cut that list way down also, because it's just a matter of them, [1:24:35] Oh, I got to do that too. [1:24:40] I think I got a couple more topics. [1:24:43] Gretchen mentioned earlier this idea of the liability insurance. [1:24:46] The code currently requires a $500,000 liability policy [1:24:50] for an event holder. [1:24:51] That's uncommon in Idaho. [1:24:53] Most of them are a million. [1:24:55] Some are even two. [1:24:57] And I want to say that we landed on 500 [1:24:59] because there was some kind of a tort claim limit that was 500. [1:25:03] But that doesn't necessarily mean that somebody who has an accident [1:25:06] or whatever they not still have the coverage that they need. [1:25:09] And so our thought was maybe increase it to a million dollar policy [1:25:13] to be more consistent with what other communities are doing. [1:25:17] So again, our recommendation is when we read it, update the code, [1:25:20] let's bump that up a little bit as well. [1:25:22] Yeah, I don't think 500 is enough anymore. [1:25:25] And then fees. [1:25:31] So currently any, especially if an application is a $25 fee. [1:25:38] Lou Cordano is the first guy that gets to see those same. [1:25:41] We blow through that $25 worth of fee in our lose time or whatever. [1:25:49] We need to change our fees. [1:25:52] They need to be appropriate. [1:25:53] We need to charge a fee that's appropriate for the amount of work that we're doing. [1:25:58] We don't do that. [1:25:59] And particularly if we go with a tiered program, we can tear the fees as well. [1:26:04] Other communities out there are charging as much as $200 for their fees. [1:26:09] I don't think we should make money. [1:26:13] We need to charge, you know, what we're spending, right, and I don't know what the numbers really should be, I just know that probably 25 is too low. [1:26:23] And so this conversation today is like, would you be willing to entertain a fee increase and maybe tiered fees along with tiered? [1:26:32] Yes, on the tiers and figure out what that fee may be. [1:26:37] And the second part of this question that I wanted to think about is a lot of communities [1:26:41] require a cleaning deposit or a, you know, and we have a parade on Maine that goes down [1:26:48] and they blast off the confetti things and then we come in Monday morning and have in [1:26:59] the past gone and clean that up and send people a bill. [1:27:02] And occasionally we actually get people to pay the bill. [1:27:07] Sometimes we don't. [1:27:09] If we had like a deposit and I'm not suggesting a huge deposit, a $500 deposit that would go [1:27:15] So right back at the end of the event, when nothing happened to cause us to use that money, [1:27:21] a lot of communities in Idaho are also doing that. [1:27:23] And here's the $500 deposit at the end of your event, here's your $500 back, or we spent [1:27:29] all day cleaning up ketchup off of the patio or the plaza and that cost you $75, but here's [1:27:38] $425. [1:27:40] You also put language in there just essentially saying that you have to be in good standing [1:27:46] to hold the event again. [1:27:48] Yeah, if you owe us money from last year's event, get square before we give it to me. [1:27:52] Yeah, I think that's a good idea. [1:27:54] How I would plan that. [1:27:55] Other thoughts on that? [1:27:58] Thank you. [1:28:03] Then my last start is just this. [1:28:05] What else did we miss that you guys want to talk about, especially events? [1:28:08] I've asked all the questions I wanted to ask. [1:28:13] I guess the only question I would add to it as we talk about application fees. [1:28:22] Are you, do you have an appetite to talk about reservation fees as well? [1:28:28] four spaces to maybe find another way to recover some costs [1:28:34] for events in our spaces, because right now the band shell [1:28:37] is $50. [1:28:39] The Western days pay is $100, because they get between the [1:28:50] outlets and the band shell. [1:28:54] And the downtown common state is also $50. [1:28:59] So we could, if you're comfortable with it, we could [1:29:03] take a look at bumping park reservation fees up for the spaces as well as the application [1:29:14] fee for special events. [1:29:16] I'm comfortable in looking at that. [1:29:19] That seems pretty inexpensive. [1:29:22] I'm comfortable looking at that. [1:29:23] Can you tell me what where say a family reunion of 125 people would lie? [1:29:30] If I came and wanted something like that, a park reservation? [1:29:33] Unless you had amplified sound at a park that wasn't one of these two that we just talked about in any way you're listening to that. [1:29:42] Because I'm all for looking at the fees, but I want to make sure that we're not tunnel visioned on commercial events that we're not killing or small. [1:29:52] We have a lot of special events that are not to big commercial events. [1:29:56] And then we have a lot of park reservations that a lot of park reservations that don't ever [1:30:02] hit you, especially that hundreds. [1:30:06] Oh, I have to share with you guys back, I want to say, 12 or 15 years ago, we came through [1:30:19] a process to change our reservation fees for the park facilities, fairly lengthy process. [1:30:26] The parks made some recommendations. [1:30:30] We went through the hearing process, approved the increases at the council level, and then [1:30:43] the very first event that had to pay the new fees complained to all several of the council [1:30:50] people and then like a week later the council asked for us to come back and we went right [1:30:55] back to reservation rates. [1:31:00] Not saying we shouldn't do it, I think we should probably look at our reservation rates. [1:31:03] I think they're probably too low. [1:31:05] Maybe we took too big of a step back then, [1:31:07] I don't really remember what the rates were. [1:31:09] And the first one out of the gate was like the Mother's Day. [1:31:16] That's the other one, yeah. [1:31:19] And so they had a much larger fee than what they had been used [1:31:26] to paying. [1:31:28] I think that's where we become thoughtful [1:31:31] and don't just say, oh, we're going to put a fee. [1:31:32] So I think when I think of you guys going back [1:31:36] and deciding about these structures, [1:31:38] that's something that is kind of a given that you take a look at all events that would come [1:31:45] in and how that impacts them. [1:31:47] Again, I think it's communication. [1:31:50] So knowing the event coordinator on that particular event, it probably caught her off guard and [1:31:57] she's very vocal and he had a couple of people up and they reacted but- [1:32:05] And so the structure also changed and right now we he reserved a banjo and I think at that point [1:32:10] He said, you know, the park is this much half the park the banjo [1:32:15] Here of how much are you actually reserving they just kind of hit all again? [1:32:20] I think it goes back to communication and letting [1:32:23] Event organizers know what's going on so there's not blindsided [1:32:28] Couldn't we could we almost do a delayed? [1:33:01] in August when we do our fee update. These are going to be in there, right? And that way you have [1:33:06] till October 1 next year before they actually take effect. Yeah, that's the way to do it. Anything else you guys want to add? Anything else for [1:33:16] match. That's it, so our meeting's adjourned. Thank you guys.