Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-10-07, recording 1 (started 16:56) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-10-07/ [0:04:36] So we're going to hang on just a minute. [0:04:38] We're having a couple technical difficulties up here, [0:04:41] but we will be starting shortly. [0:05:59] That means you can't. [0:06:14] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, [0:06:15] and welcome to the October 7th, 2024 City Council meeting. [0:06:20] I want to confirm we have a quorum. [0:06:22] We have all seven members present in chambers tonight. [0:06:27] Our first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:06:29] If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:06:51] Thank you. [0:06:52] two proclamations tonight. The first one is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, October 2024, [0:07:00] whereas every year too many Americans are impacted by the pain and hardship caused by [0:07:06] breast cancer, and whereas breast cancer remains one of the leading causes of cancer-related [0:07:12] deaths among women, the City of Twin Falls proudly honors those who have lost their lives [0:07:17] to breast cancer, and the courageous survivors who are still fighting it. [0:07:22] Whereas October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, the City of Twin Falls will stand with [0:07:27] breast cancer survivors and raise awareness in advanced research efforts. [0:07:33] Furthermore, we commit ourselves to support survivors, their loved ones, and organizations [0:07:39] that seek to forge a future free from all cancer. [0:07:43] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim October [0:07:49] 2024 to be Breast Cancer Awareness Month. [0:07:52] We encourage citizens, government agencies, private businesses, nonprofit organizations, [0:07:59] and all others to join in activities that increase awareness of breast cancer prevention. [0:08:06] So this proclamation happens to be near and dear to my heart because I'm an 18-year breast [0:08:11] cancer survivor and so every year I get thank you. So every year I get to read [0:08:20] this is a good year. Okay so the next one is fire prevention week 2024 fire [0:08:28] prevention week October 6 through 12 2024 whereas the City of Twin Falls is [0:08:34] committed to ensuring the safety and security of all those living and [0:08:38] visiting our city. Fire is the serious public safety concern both locally and [0:08:44] nationally, and homes are the locations where people are at risk from fire. Home fires killed [0:08:50] more than 2,700 people in the United States in 2022, according to the National Fire Protection [0:08:58] Association, and fire departments in the United States responded to 360,000 home fires, and [0:09:05] whereas roughly three out of five fire deaths happen in homes with either no smoke alarms [0:09:11] with no working smoke alarms. Working smoke alarms cut the risk of dying and [0:09:16] reported home fires almost in half and smoke alarms since smoke well before you [0:09:22] can alerting you to danger in the event of fire in which you may have as little [0:09:27] as two minutes to escape safely and whereas Twin Falls residents should [0:09:32] install smoke alarms in every sleeping room outside each separate sleeping area [0:09:38] and on every level of the home, and Twin Falls residents should make sure their smoke alarms [0:09:45] meet the needs of all their family members, including those with sensory or physical disabilities, [0:09:52] and residents should test smoke alarms at least once a month. [0:09:56] Residents who have planned and practice a home fire escape plan are more than prepared [0:10:01] and will therefore be more likely to survive a fire. [0:10:05] Whereas Twin Falls First Responders are dedicated to reducing the occurrence of home fires and [0:10:11] home fire injuries through prevention and protection education and residents are responsive to public [0:10:18] education members measures and can take personal steps to increase their safety from fire, especially [0:10:25] in their homes. [0:10:27] And whereas the 2024 Fire Prevention Week theme, smoke alarms make them work for you, serves [0:10:34] to remind us of the importance of having working smoke alarms in the home. [0:10:39] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim October 6 [0:10:45] through 12, 2024 as Fire Prevention Week throughout this city, and I urge all people [0:10:51] of Twin Falls to make sure their homes have smoke alarms and to support the many public [0:10:57] safety activities and efforts of the Twin Falls Fire Department. [0:11:02] I think, Gabe, are you here? [0:11:04] You want to come down and get this? [0:11:06] Our fire marshal. [0:11:48] Madam Mayor, Council, thank you for this time [0:11:50] to stand with us in this fire prevention week, [0:11:53] as we obviously, it's a year round measure, what we're doing. [0:11:57] But the smoke detector one hits near and dear to our hearts. [0:12:00] As earlier this year, we've had two of our own residents [0:12:02] here in Twin Falls, Paris, and a home fire. [0:12:05] And in that house fire, there was two detectors in the home, [0:12:07] but there was no batteries in those detectors. [0:12:10] And those lives, we have a 54% chance, [0:12:14] higher chance of being notified early in those early two minutes. [0:12:18] So the smoke detector thing is a simple solution that I think we can all team up with as a city [0:12:23] on every level to help ensure that fire safety in the home. [0:12:26] So thank you for your partnership in this. [0:12:29] Thank you, Dave. [0:12:33] Okay, next on the agenda is the consent calendar. [0:12:37] Council wishes to approve. [0:12:39] Thank you to have a second. [0:12:40] Madam Mayor, I'll second. [0:12:42] Thank you motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grace and Stone [0:12:45] to approve the consent calendar as written. [0:12:49] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:12:53] Excuse me, Ruth Pears? [0:12:54] Yes. [0:12:55] Chris Reed. [0:12:56] Yes. [0:12:57] Craig Hawkins. [0:12:58] Yes. [0:12:59] Jason Brown. [0:13:00] Yes. [0:13:01] Bensor Cutler. [0:13:02] Yes. [0:13:03] Gary Vomer. [0:13:05] Yes. [0:13:06] And Grace and Stone. [0:13:07] Yes. [0:13:08] Thank you. [0:13:09] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:13:10] Hey, next on the agenda under items of consideration. [0:13:14] First item, an action item, a request to negotiate [0:13:18] with suburban construction management [0:13:20] for CMGC services associated with the renovation [0:13:24] of the public work site and used 1.2 million from water [0:13:28] and wastewater reserve funds to fund the project. [0:13:32] And before Aaron makes his presentation, [0:13:35] I'm gonna have to recuse myself today [0:13:37] and turn the mic over to Jason. [0:13:39] I do some accounting work for this company, [0:13:42] So I won't be voting tonight. [0:13:46] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:13:47] Go ahead, Aaron. [0:13:49] All right, I'm back. [0:13:51] I came in July to walk through what staff thought [0:13:56] was a great alternative for the Public Works Site [0:13:58] renovation project. [0:14:00] As you recall, back in 2023, Public Works staff [0:14:04] went through the long-term planning process [0:14:06] and budgeted $1.2 million for the Public Works Site [0:14:09] Improvement Project. [0:14:11] We received one bid at that time. [0:14:13] we did at the typical design bid build fashion. We received one bid for over $2 million, which [0:14:19] we just couldn't afford. So we went back to the drawing board, as you will, and sat down [0:14:25] with the other public works departments and figured out a couple of alternatives that help [0:14:29] us reduce the costs. And some of those alternatives were to use public works staff to help do some [0:14:36] of the work that was required. And so as we were going through that process, we also determined [0:14:40] and then we wanted to change our project delivery method [0:14:43] from this design bit build, which is typical, [0:14:46] to a CMGC, which is construction manager, [0:14:48] general contractor type contract. [0:14:51] And so I came to council in July [0:14:53] and asked for permission to use the $1.2 million [0:14:56] and to proceed with this. [0:14:57] So today I'm back to wrap that up. [0:14:59] We've gone through the request for qualifications portion [0:15:04] of that, of the state code that allows us to do that. [0:15:07] And I'm here today to ask for permission [0:15:09] to go ahead and enter into negotiations with suburban construction and to get the $1.2 million [0:15:16] that since rolled into reserve, those previous budgets rolled into reserves, asked for that [0:15:20] as well. [0:15:21] So when we did the request for qualifications, we had two submittals, one from Peterson Brothers [0:15:26] Construction and the second for suburban construction management, both highly qualified [0:15:31] firms who had five staff members from the city review, both statement of qualifications [0:15:37] and they determined that the highest scoring one was suburban construction management. [0:15:43] So at this time staff would request permission to enter negotiations with suburban construction [0:15:47] management and to use the $1.2 million that's rolled into water and wastewater reserves, [0:15:54] pull that out to use it this fiscal year to complete that project. [0:15:58] I will stand for any questions if you have. [0:16:01] If there are any questions for Aaron, entertain a motion, make the motion if you're ready. [0:16:13] I move that we approve the negotiations with suburban construction management for the CMGC [0:16:19] service associated with the renovation of the public work site and use 1.2 million from [0:16:26] the water and wastewater reserves to fund the project. [0:16:31] Sherry Holmer. [0:16:32] I'll second. [0:16:33] We have a motion to accept or go into negotiation with suburban construction management for CMGC [0:16:42] This is associated with the renovation of the public work site and use 1.2 million from [0:16:47] water and wastewater reserves funds for this project. [0:16:50] Amy, roll the vote. [0:16:54] Yes. [0:16:56] Sorry, Chris Reed. [0:16:57] Yes. [0:16:58] Craig Hawkins. [0:16:59] Yes. [0:17:00] Jason Brown. [0:17:01] Yes. [0:17:02] Spencer Cutler. [0:17:04] Yes. [0:17:05] Gary Vollmer. [0:17:06] Yes. [0:17:07] Grayson Stone. [0:17:08] Yes. [0:17:09] And Rose Pierce. [0:17:10] Epstein. [0:17:11] Motion passes 6 to 6, yes, 1 abstention. [0:17:14] Turn the back time back over to you. [0:17:18] Thank you, Mayor. [0:17:19] Thank you. [0:17:20] Thank you, Aaron. [0:17:21] Next is an action item, a request to approve the purchase of a 2024 John Deere, 624P Will [0:17:29] Loader at a cost of $165,390.47 using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Source Well and authorize the Public Works Director to execute the contract. [0:17:45] We have Mark Thompson, our Street Department Superintendent. [0:17:48] Welcome, Mark. [0:17:49] Thank you. [0:17:50] Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. [0:17:53] Thank you for allowing me to come before you tonight [0:17:55] and make this request. [0:17:58] In July 1, 2019, Idaho Code 672867-2807 went into effect. [0:18:07] And this code essentially gave political entities [0:18:10] the ability to participate in cooperative purchasing [0:18:13] programs with the approval of his governing body and as long as the goods and services [0:18:19] procured were the result of a competitive solicitation process. [0:18:25] So in December of 2019, City Council adopted Resolution 2019-014, which authorized staff [0:18:33] to use and join cooperative purchasing programs. [0:18:36] A staff can approve purchases up to the informal bid limit. [0:18:41] If they exceed the informal bid limit, which is 150,000, the City Council must approve the [0:18:47] purchase. [0:18:48] So, as we started looking at our equipment replacements for this fiscal year 2425, we also [0:18:55] looked at some operational changes that we've had over the last few years. [0:19:00] So, at one point, we had two different storage areas where we stored material. [0:19:05] One was out on Orchard next to right across from Kleckford, and then the other one was [0:19:09] behind the old or the dog pound. [0:19:13] And each one of those locations, [0:19:14] we had a loader parked at one of those locations. [0:19:18] At this time, we only have one, [0:19:20] but we've still got two loaders parked at one location. [0:19:22] So it really doesn't make sense [0:19:24] to have two loaders parked out there. [0:19:26] So with this purchase, [0:19:29] we'll be actually trading in two and buying one. [0:19:33] We'll be replacing the loader that was purchased in 1998, [0:19:37] I believe it says 1988, but it's 1998. [0:19:41] and then a loader that was purchased in 2012 and both the purchase price, the purchase price reflects the trading values of both loaders. [0:19:48] Over the last couple years the city has created a fleet committee and this fleet committee has developed a replacement schedule for all the equipment. [0:19:59] This purchase was approved by the fleet committee. It was later presented and approved by the long-term planning committee and later adopted as part of the fiscal year 2024-25 budget. [0:20:11] So, in conclusion, I would like to request your approval to purchase a 2024 John Deere [0:20:17] 624P loader at a cost of 165, 390, 47, using a cooperative purchase agreement with Sourcewell [0:20:27] and authorize the Public Works Director to execute the contract. [0:20:31] Answer any questions? [0:20:33] Any questions for Mark Jason? [0:20:34] I don't have any questions. [0:20:35] I'll make a motion. [0:20:36] If anybody have any questions, Chris? [0:20:38] How far out would it be on receiving this? [0:20:41] If we can with your approval tonight and we can sign the papers tomorrow within probably a couple days [0:20:57] Okay [0:21:03] I'd move to approve the purchase of a [0:21:06] 2024 John Deere 624 P. Will [0:21:09] to be able to build a [0:21:16] loader at the cost of $165,390.47 using a cooperative purchase agreement with Sourcewell and authorized the public work director to execute the contract. [0:21:23] Thank you, Jason Stone. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll second. [0:21:26] Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grayson Stone. [0:21:31] To approve the purchase of a 2024 John Deere 624P, [0:21:35] will loader at the cost of 165, 390, and 47 cents using a cooperative purchasing agreement [0:21:43] with Sourcewell and authorizing the Public Works Director to execute the contract. Any [0:21:49] further discussion? Amy Rokow, please. [0:21:52] Great Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. [0:21:56] Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. [0:21:58] Jerry Bomer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. [0:22:01] Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. [0:22:05] Thank you, Mark. [0:22:06] Thank you. [0:22:09] So that is all under items of consideration. [0:22:12] The next item is general public input. [0:22:16] This is general public input on anything not on today's agenda. [0:22:21] So this is not input for the public hearing tonight. [0:22:25] This is strictly on items not on today's agenda and obviously no personnel discussions [0:22:34] as well. [0:22:35] Is there anybody here that wishes to address Council on anything not on today's agenda? [0:22:42] I'm down, end state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and you have [0:22:50] two minutes. [0:22:51] It's going to be hard for you, Paula. [0:22:54] How are you? [0:22:55] Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. [0:22:57] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:23:00] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:23:06] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:23:13] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:23:20] well, like you don't have to even think about it. I remember what that was like, [0:23:26] but now when I want to go someplace in town, I really have to count the steps [0:23:34] between where I can park and where I really want to be. [0:23:39] And I'm sure that because you don't have this issue, [0:23:43] it hasn't occurred to you that we should be paying attention [0:23:47] to our handicapped parking situation in Twin Falls. [0:23:51] Did you know, for instance, that there are 76 to 78 spaces [0:23:58] at the curb on the three sides of City Park? [0:24:03] 76 or 78, I counted yesterday. [0:24:07] There's not one handicap space, not one. [0:24:13] For a person like me that would like to go to, oh, Western days [0:24:17] or a concert or all of the wonderful things [0:24:20] that we have in the park, I can't do it unless I can park close. [0:24:27] And you don't have to make double van size spaces. [0:24:31] You can use the spaces that are at the end on the diagonals. [0:24:35] It gives a little extra space for a person getting out of a car. [0:24:38] So that's one place. [0:24:41] Number two, over by second South Market, [0:24:44] they have one handicap space for all of the people that use that. [0:24:50] When I asked the owner there about the handicap parking [0:24:53] situation, her answer was, well, you know, [0:24:56] you can park across the street in the lot. [0:24:58] Do you realize what it means for somebody like me to have to walk three lanes of a state highway to get to our parking space? [0:25:07] But the city controls those spaces that are on the street. [0:25:12] The city could designate additional spaces there. [0:25:16] Thank you, Paula. [0:25:16] Your time is up. [0:25:17] There's one more place in town. [0:25:19] I appreciate that. [0:25:20] You've got your two minutes. [0:25:21] But if you would like to send me an email. [0:25:24] I would like to make a suggestion for what you should do. [0:25:27] I just wanted to send me an email and then I'll pass it on to our group. [0:25:32] I would like the city to inventory and pay attention. [0:25:35] Thank you, Paula. Thank you. [0:25:39] Anybody else that wishes to address City Council on something not on today's agenda? [0:25:48] Seeing no one advisory board reports today. [0:25:51] Ms. Reed. [0:25:53] We had the Magic Valley Air Show take off already last Thursday. [0:25:59] Yes, Thursday. Very successful. It was in partnership with the Chamber of Commerce. [0:26:05] The group that's putting together the air show for 2025 is ready to go. They're looking for [0:26:11] volunteers. They're looking for vendors. They're excited about next year's air show. We have the [0:26:15] Blue Angels coming in. It will be a huge event in Twin Falls. So that event was successful and we're [0:26:22] looking forward to next year's air show. Thank you, Chris. Do you have anything? Yeah, I just was [0:26:29] I was going to say the police academy is still going strong. [0:26:32] We had a blast last week. [0:26:35] I'd really recommend anybody that's interested. [0:26:38] It's open to the public to go at no cost. [0:26:40] And it really gives you an appreciation [0:26:42] for the men in blue. [0:26:45] And I'm grateful for that. [0:26:46] Thank you, Craig. [0:26:47] Thank you, my graduate. [0:26:51] We'll see. [0:26:52] That's next week. [0:26:55] City manager's office. [0:26:58] Hey, next we're going to move into the public hearing. [0:27:05] This is an action item, but before we get started, Craig Hawkins. [0:27:10] Mayor, I'm going to excuse myself from this, because I have some dear friends that are part of the Alco Bell Corporation, so I'll be withdrawing that meeting. [0:27:19] Okay, thank you. Okay, so this is an action item. It's a request to appeal the planning and zoning commission's decision regarding special use permit, PZ24-0076, to allow drive-through with extended resources. [0:27:45] with extended retail hours of operation on property located at 2616 Addison Avenue East, [0:27:54] Cara Floyd Gilbert, PC240098, and we have Kelly, is it Kelly or Jonathan? [0:28:02] Okay, but before I do that, I'm going to read the rules related to public hearings. [0:28:07] We're going to be following these steps tonight under the public hearing portion of our [0:28:15] agenda. First city staff will present the request and analysis. The applicant will [0:28:22] then present their request. The appellate will then present their, make their [0:28:29] presentation and then council can ask questions either during the presentations [0:28:35] or prior to the end once they finished and after the questions have been asked [0:28:42] then the answer the public hearing will be open and that means anybody here [0:28:47] can testify tonight you are when you come up to testify please state your name and [0:28:55] whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and you will need to keep your public [0:29:00] comment your public input part down to two minutes and we will have a timer on [0:29:06] that. I ask that you be respectful and cordial, we're all here to listen and [0:29:13] we're all adults and human beings so I would request that everybody stay [0:29:20] cordial. Once the comments are completed then the applicant has an [0:29:25] opportunity for any closing comments. The appellate has any opportunity for any [0:29:31] comments and then staff will wrap up if there's any comments at the end and then [0:29:36] the public hearing will be closed and then the council will make out their [0:29:42] discussion and make their decision. Okay Kelly. Thank you Mayor. Good evening [0:29:49] council. This is a request to appeal the decision of the planning and zoning [0:29:54] commission on the special use permit request for a drive-through and extended [0:29:58] hours of operation at 2616 Addison Avenue East. On August 13th the planning [0:30:05] zoning commission approved this request with adding conditions regarding extended hours, [0:30:10] a taller screening wall, and the landscape plan. Citizen Floyd Gilbert is appealing the [0:30:17] commission's decision and the request is being brought to City Council for new public hearing. [0:30:23] Tonight's decision by the Council is a brand new decision on the original request. [0:30:29] The Council may approve the request as presented, add conditions to an approval, [0:30:34] deny the request or table for further information. [0:30:38] The original SUP request was for the drive-through [0:30:41] and extended hours of operation from 7 a.m. to 2 a.m., [0:30:45] seven days a week for a new Taco Bell location. [0:30:49] The restaurant itself is outright permitted [0:30:51] in the C1 Commercial Highway District, [0:30:53] which this property is zoned. [0:30:56] So if they did not request extended hours or the drive-through, [0:31:00] they could submit for a building permit tomorrow. [0:31:04] And again, they ask if he requests us solely for the drive-thru and extended hours of operation per city code 1013 to 2. [0:31:12] The special use permit process requires a public hearing in which interested persons have the opportunity to be heard with regards to the application. [0:31:20] City code 1048.2 states, the special use permit is required for any facility with drive-thru service and permitted retail trade out uses. [0:31:30] operating outside the hours of 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. [0:31:33] So that's why we're here tonight. [0:31:37] Her city code drives through lanes [0:31:39] must have a vehicle stacking requirement [0:31:42] of five cars per lane from the first window, [0:31:45] pickup window, order board, or other stopping point. [0:31:48] I'm gonna try to scroll through. [0:31:59] This is the site plan that the applicant, [0:32:03] the original applicant has submitted. [0:32:07] This area has seen a lot of development [0:32:09] in the past few years, and many requests [0:32:11] come before the Commission and Council. [0:32:14] The Addison Springs Storage ZDA was recently amended [0:32:17] to allow a drive-through restaurant [0:32:19] to be outright and outright permitted use [0:32:23] in the appellant's documentation. [0:32:28] I think it was misunderstood what that drive-through was approved [0:32:31] for, it was approved for a drive-through restaurant. [0:32:36] The property at 2794 Addison Avenue East [0:32:40] has been rezoned to include C1 zoning [0:32:43] for the northern portion of the property, [0:32:46] and specially used permits were approved [0:32:49] for storage unit rentals and a gym [0:32:51] on the northwest corner of Addison Avenue East and Carriage Lane. [0:32:56] The request follows the development pattern of this area. [0:32:59] This area has transitioned from farm grounds [0:33:02] to neighborhood commercial [0:33:03] with a mix of residential commercial [0:33:05] professional office and services. [0:33:08] I go back to my other map. [0:33:22] This map shows the zoning in the area [0:33:24] and the designations on the future land use map. [0:33:28] The 2016 comprehensive plan shows this area [0:33:32] as appropriate for neighborhood commercial, [0:33:34] which is this purple area down Addison Avenue, [0:33:38] providing supporting services and small scale commercial uses [0:33:42] for the surrounding neighborhood. [0:33:44] The other portions north and south [0:33:46] are designated as town neighborhood. [0:33:51] The commission weighed the request [0:33:54] with potential impacts to the residential neighborhood [0:33:56] to the south. [0:33:57] The commission added the following conditions [0:34:00] to the special use permit approval. [0:34:02] The extended hours of operation were approved [0:34:05] for Friday and Saturday nights until midnight. [0:34:08] Week nights would have to be, they'd have to close at 10. [0:34:12] The landscape plan needs to be brought back [0:34:14] to the commission for approval prior [0:34:15] to submitting the building permit. [0:34:17] And the applicant has put together a landscape plan [0:34:21] And it is part of my presentation tonight. [0:34:26] And the screening wall on the South property line [0:34:28] must be a seven foot CMU wall. [0:34:31] There is a requirement for a screening [0:34:34] to be between any commercial and residential. [0:34:37] So they condition that to be specifically [0:34:39] a seven foot CMU, concrete wall. [0:34:42] Kelly, what's the CMU? [0:34:44] It's concrete. [0:34:45] Any fashion? [0:34:46] The block wall. [0:34:47] Yeah, okay. [0:34:48] The original applicant has submitted a new site plan to the Council for consideration, [0:34:53] as well as the landscape plan for the property. [0:34:56] The Council may approve the landscape plan to submit tonight, and that would satisfy [0:35:00] the commission's original condition. [0:35:04] Staff has received numerous public comments on the request and appeal, which have been [0:35:08] included with the agenda packet. [0:35:11] I can scroll through those. [0:35:13] received the ones from the Planning and Zoning Commission, and 19 with the agenda packet today [0:35:23] at noon. [0:35:24] I emailed you the rest, it was up to 23, 20 to 33 of those comments. [0:35:32] The applicant is here to present the original request to the Council and Mr. Gilbert the [0:35:35] appellant is here to present his appeal. [0:35:38] Okay. [0:35:39] So this is the vicinity map. [0:35:42] We're right here at the corner of Addison and Carriage. Across the street, this lot [0:35:49] right here, just north, is where the old steam espresso drive-through has a [0:35:55] building permit right now. There are storage units over here, storage units on [0:36:00] this side, and a new gym is going in right here at 1. Across the street is [0:36:07] St. Luke's next to the proposed vacant lot is the CPR physical therapy and then [0:36:18] there are various other commercial uses along Addison and then the residential [0:36:22] area is just to the south with Thompson Park and I have a bigger [0:36:28] picture of that I apologize. There's your zoning map and your future land use map. [0:36:32] the applicant will go through their site plan and their elevations and their new [0:36:43] revised landscape plan. This is the special use permit with the added [0:36:56] conditions. This is what was approved on the 13th of August. Here's an aerial view [0:37:04] showing a bigger picture of the area and I've just marked a few places. Here's the [0:37:16] subject property, Twin Falls High School, and then the Clyde Thompson Park is right here. [0:37:23] So I know it's just trying to get a bigger scope for everybody. [0:37:29] And this is an incident report that was done for that intersection at Addison and Carriage. [0:37:36] It was one of the council members asked for some stats. [0:37:43] So here are the stats from since August of 2019. [0:37:46] 9 incidents at that intersection, the last one being reported April 6, 2022. Most of [0:37:58] them are rear ends or fail to obey the signal with one in here hit a wild animal in 2020. [0:38:07] That is my presentation. I can stand for any questions and like you said, the applicant [0:38:17] and the appellant are both here to give their presentations. [0:38:20] Thank you, Kelly. [0:38:21] Jason. [0:38:22] Hey, Kelly, when did that light go in? [0:38:25] You might have heard exactly. [0:38:26] I don't know exactly what I was told today about 10 years ago. [0:38:29] OK. [0:38:31] Thank you, Grayson. [0:38:32] OK. [0:38:32] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:38:33] Can you scroll back up to where the stacking's at? [0:38:36] Which one? [0:38:36] On the side plant. [0:38:37] With their stacking? [0:38:38] Yep. [0:38:41] Down one. [0:38:42] Stop moving. [0:38:46] That's the card. [0:38:50] It's up here, Grace. [0:38:51] Yeah, right there. [0:38:52] This one. [0:38:53] That's one? [0:38:56] So all those cars coming in are facing residential versus [0:38:59] Addison, correct? [0:39:00] Yeah, they would come right here. [0:39:02] Yeah, coming off Addison towards carriage. [0:39:07] Thank you. [0:39:07] I mean, towards the residential. [0:39:10] They're facing south. [0:39:11] They're facing south. [0:39:11] Right. [0:39:12] I just want to make sure I was reading that correctly. [0:39:15] Anybody else have any questions for Kelly? [0:39:22] OK. [0:39:24] Next, we'll hear from the applicant. [0:39:32] And both the applicant and the appellant [0:39:34] have 15 minutes apiece. [0:39:36] AAR and City Council members, thank you for your service. [0:39:46] Thank you for the opportunity to be heard. [0:39:48] I'm going to share my time with Julie Ben-Intendi, [0:39:51] who's the project manager here. [0:39:54] My name's Kevin West. [0:39:55] I'm outside legal counsel for the SON Corporation, [0:39:59] which is a Taco Bell franchisee. [0:40:02] I am just going to make a few introductory comments, [0:40:06] mainly about the company, [0:40:08] and then the turn, the time over to Miss Ben-Intendi. [0:40:12] I am sensitive to the concerns [0:40:15] that some have about out-of-state megacorporations coming into communities to pillage and plunder, [0:40:24] if you will, without regard for the community or as citizens. [0:40:30] I want to assure you that that is not the situation that we're dealing with here. [0:40:35] We are not talking about Taco Bell Corporation and I want to make that distinction. [0:40:41] We are talking about a local franchisee, and I thought it would be helpful for you to know [0:40:47] a little bit about that local franchisee. [0:40:51] The SON corporation is a family business with its headquarters located in Idaho, and with [0:40:59] restaurants throughout southern Idaho. [0:41:02] The strange sounding name, SON, is phonetically to portray the initials of the company's founder [0:41:10] who is Stanley O. Nicollason, SON. [0:41:14] And interestingly enough, back in 1969, Stanley Nicollason [0:41:19] opened one of the first Taco Bell restaurants [0:41:22] in the United States. [0:41:24] And he, along with his three sons and five daughters, [0:41:29] eight children together, operated that restaurant, [0:41:34] prepared foods or customers, and were very successful [0:41:39] in that early Taco Bell 55 years ago. [0:41:44] Carl Nicholson, who is here with me, [0:41:46] is one of the three sons of Stanley Nicholson. [0:41:50] And Carl and his two brothers after Mr. Nicholson passed away [0:41:55] took over management of the company. [0:41:58] Through a lot of hard work and great customer service, [0:42:02] well-liked food, and by being good community citizens, [0:42:08] The SON corporation has grown from that one Taco Bell back in 1969 to having 36 Taco Bell [0:42:16] restaurants, half of which are in Idaho and half of which are in the state of Oregon. [0:42:24] In Idaho the restaurants are located in Boise, Meridian, Jerome, Burley and also in Twin Falls. [0:42:32] Carl and his two brothers have now largely retired from the business and now the third [0:42:38] generation of Nicoleysons are operating and running the company. All of those third generation [0:42:45] members live with their families in Idaho as does Carl and the company now has over a thousand [0:42:53] employees over half of which are located in Idaho and I will say also in 1995 the company opened its [0:43:02] It's restaurant here in Twin Falls in the Magic Valley Mall. [0:43:07] It has done business there very successfully, has employed hundreds and hundreds of people [0:43:13] from the local community, and they have endeavored to treat their employees respectfully and be [0:43:19] good members of the community. [0:43:22] The SOM Corporation has always been a great corporate citizen and contributor to the communities [0:43:31] in which they do business, including Twin Falls. [0:43:35] The company has donated thousands of dollars [0:43:37] to the Boy Scouts, to the Boys and Girls Club [0:43:41] of Twin Falls, to the Idaho Shakespeare Festival, [0:43:44] to the Women's and Children's Alliance. [0:43:47] They have believed in making the communities [0:43:51] they do business in a better place to live. [0:43:54] I have reviewed the Twin Falls City Code [0:43:56] and the comprehensive plan, [0:43:58] as well as the site plans for the location at issue. [0:44:01] I believe that the legal requirements are satisfied for the special use permit and to address that [0:44:09] in greater detail I will introduce Julie Ben-Intendi who is a senior project manager. [0:44:15] Thank you very much. [0:44:16] Thank you. [0:44:22] Good evening. [0:44:23] Thank you Kelly for putting together such a thorough report. [0:44:28] I really do appreciate all the work you've done on this. [0:44:31] What I wanted to do was focus in on some of the questions that have come up and how we [0:44:36] of just them. [0:44:38] And I know some of the concerns, specifically [0:44:42] about the drive-through, we've looked at several site [0:44:46] orientations, trying to figure out the best way [0:44:49] to bring traffic in, get it about, [0:44:52] having the least impact on the neighborhood to the south. [0:44:57] Part of this was we are doing a reverse of what [0:45:01] is a standard layout for the Taco Bell in order [0:45:03] to get the menu board up towards the Addison [0:45:07] and further away from the neighborhood itself. [0:45:11] This helps provide a buffer for the noise. [0:45:16] And also we had a fence called out [0:45:19] and we were happy to meet the recommendations [0:45:22] to do the concrete masonry unit wall, [0:45:27] which will help a lot with light and sound. [0:45:30] but we are also providing right here in our landscape plan. [0:45:37] Right there. [0:45:38] So we've done an enhanced landscape buffer right here, [0:45:42] and you'll see this section through here [0:45:44] to kind of give you an idea. [0:45:45] We're providing evergreen deciduous landscaping [0:45:49] to provide not only a sound buffer, [0:45:52] but color variations throughout the year. [0:45:56] And then seven feet, I know that we did receive [0:45:59] comment about it's just another wall for graffiti but there's several [0:46:06] fences that are out there right now that currently don't have any graffiti on it [0:46:09] and I do feel like the landscaping landscaping itself will help provide a [0:46:14] nice break that that doesn't provide just a blank wall for someone to paint on. [0:46:20] What else? We do have our five car stack from the order point which is right [0:46:28] here. And we do have an additional four in front of that. This exceeds the actual Taco Bell [0:46:37] stack requirements that they have of eight, so providing the extra one for the city's requirement [0:46:44] of the five from the order point. Let's see which I think builds on here. We did provide also a [0:46:54] section cut through the berm required up at the north of the property just to kind of give [0:47:00] an idea of scale and how that will relate to the street right there. [0:47:07] Looking at how traffic moves in and out of this site, currently this access point right [0:47:14] here is showing a straight in, straight out access point. [0:47:18] As you can see up here, I've marked these so that they are a little bit darker, but this [0:47:23] is a double line right here and there should legally be no left turns out of this parking [0:47:29] lot. So anyone who is coming out of this commercial business here for the physical therapy should [0:47:36] legally only be able to turn right. You'll see people turning left. I mean, but as traffic [0:47:43] does increase, you know, this is something to think about. We are providing a safer [0:47:48] route to come out onto carriage where you can then legally get into a turn lane and go left [0:47:53] onto Addison. We hope that this will provide a good neighbor with our PT neighbor here so [0:48:06] that as he addressed in his letter he was concerned about people that have certain physical issues [0:48:13] they might have mobility issues trying to get in and out of here dealing with the traffic [0:48:18] coming in to the drive-through, hopefully this would help them actually be able to get out of [0:48:26] the site in a safe manner. We are also open to the idea of maybe potentially right here, [0:48:33] creating a cross-access opening to their parking lot if they were open to that idea. [0:48:40] That way their clients would not even have to deal with the drive-through traffic other than where [0:48:46] is coming out right here. And so these pictures here are just to show that there [0:48:53] is double yellow lines on both as an end carriage that come past the site in [0:49:00] both directions. So this would be a write-in write-out site. [0:49:07] Dealing with the building itself, I know sometimes the concern is lighting and the [0:49:15] fact that people don't want a beacon in their neighborhood. The Taco Bells in [0:49:20] general really do kind of address that and they fit well into more of a [0:49:25] neighborhood setting. They don't have you know street lights and building lights [0:49:30] that blazed up the neighborhood. As you can see here I provided a couple night [0:49:35] shots just to kind of show that the lighting is a little bit more low-key. [0:49:40] It's the designated purple color, but it's not this neon color that lights up miles away. [0:49:52] The style of the building right now is a more modern look, and it looks really quick. [0:50:06] The extended hours, I know that there's been some concerns about that. [0:50:11] corporate currently requires that all locations are open until at least midnight and they [0:50:16] do prefer the 2am time period. I did ask Stan to kind of put together some numbers so [0:50:23] we'd have an idea of like how many orders to expect during those time periods. So he [0:50:28] said on average for a location, similar to this in a smaller neighborhood, typically [0:50:34] between 10 to 12 they get about 40 cars and a lot of those are online orders or [0:50:41] Uber orders and then from 12 to 2 they get about 10 and that's that's an average [0:50:47] I'm not saying that's every night and then addressing the 500 cars that would [0:50:55] that's the max like that's on a busy night you know or a busy day like where [0:50:59] maybe there's a game or something where people are out and about, but it's more [0:51:04] standard to have it closer to probably about 300 orders on an average day. So [0:51:10] when we said 500 we had to put a number at it of what we would expect at the [0:51:16] most, right? The dining room does close at 10 p.m. and no walk-ups are allowed. So [0:51:26] this is purely a vehicle only approach to get orders. More and more, they're [0:51:32] seeing orders that are through Uber orders or online orders so people are [0:51:38] moving through the actual drive-through a lot quicker than it used to be and I [0:51:48] know another concern was people looked at the location that's up by the mall [0:51:52] and that is one of the busiest locations that they currently own and [0:51:59] And that's kind of crazy to think about when they've got locations all through like Salem, [0:52:04] you know, Minville, or not, Kaiser, you know, Ontario, you know, Boise, you know, so for [0:52:10] us to compare that to a location that's in a smaller neighborhood neighborhood, you know, [0:52:17] we did look at some that are more consistent to an apples to apples comparison. [0:52:21] I stand for questions? [0:52:24] Questions for the applicants. [0:52:28] Grayson? [0:52:33] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:52:35] So in looking at the site plan and all those stacking cars facing south, when you guys were [0:52:42] designing your site, what was the aversion to flipping that and having the cars face out [0:52:47] towards Addison for the stacking? [0:52:50] To do so would cause the order point to be down by the neighborhood because you would [0:52:56] have to come up on the right side of the building. [0:52:59] So they would basically just take that in 180 it. [0:53:04] So what I'm, I guess what my question is if you just took the direct inversion of that [0:53:07] and put the menu board and you're stacking on the right side and literally flipping that [0:53:12] model or flipping that side plan. [0:53:15] It's not feasible. [0:53:16] It's, it's again, if you're saying, so what I'm, what I'm, what I'm, my question is if [0:53:24] they came down Keraslane and they come through and you flip your parking to the left side [0:53:29] and your drive through then kicks directly out towards Addison. [0:53:33] So it would be on this side right here. [0:53:36] Correct. [0:53:36] OK. [0:53:37] And so you're saying they would come in on this side. [0:53:39] So your menu point would be up by right where that meeting is, [0:53:41] right by that island, on the northeast corner. [0:53:44] Nope, northeast corner. [0:53:45] Up here. [0:53:45] Right there. [0:53:47] If you put your menu board there, [0:53:48] and all the cars are facing towards Addison, [0:53:53] it doesn't come into play at all, like just shifting [0:53:57] that whole model and flipping it over. [0:54:01] How would they be pointing at Addison [0:54:03] if the menu board is right there? [0:54:05] So if you come through. [0:54:08] Where's the many board right now on this? [0:54:10] It's on the west side. [0:54:11] There's no way to put the menu board on the east side [0:54:14] and have the cars facing north. [0:54:15] No. [0:54:16] Because it has to be on the driver's side. [0:54:24] I guess I'm not making the connection. [0:54:26] And somebody can got it, got it. [0:54:38] So you were, Grayson, you were trying [0:54:39] to say having the lights point out towards the road [0:54:43] instead of back into the neighborhood versus, I think, [0:54:46] So we're looking at it here, I'm assuming the reader board, [0:54:50] people are talking, generates maybe more noise [0:54:53] and that's why he put it to the north, is that correct? [0:54:56] Correct, that'll be the loudest point, [0:54:58] actually would be the speaker. [0:55:00] The reader board would be the speaker. [0:55:01] Yes, because that's where you'd hear them taking the orders. [0:55:05] So this menu board order point right up there, [0:55:09] if we, I actually did do a site plan where I came in the other way [0:55:14] and we were pointing up towards Addison, [0:55:16] but it meant putting the menu board down closer [0:55:18] to the neighborhood, and it was closer [0:55:20] than we would like to do for the sound. [0:55:23] We do try to keep that in mind when we're, you know, [0:55:27] laying out a site plan, the effect of the noise [0:55:30] on residential neighbors. [0:55:32] Copy, thank you. [0:55:34] Thank you, Chris. [0:55:38] You had brought up maybe a cross-use land agreement [0:55:41] with the physical therapy company next door. [0:55:46] in those two locations so you would be comfortable with their customers driving [0:55:51] through the parking lot and coming out on carriage. Yes. So I do have a question so [0:56:00] if you end up with more than nine cars where do you intend for them to stack? [0:56:07] Honestly if there's not room and this would be the case with any drive-through [0:56:14] right if there's not room in the drive-through they need to pull into a parking [0:56:18] spot and somebody's gonna monitor that or that's logic. In all the years of owning [0:56:30] these Taco Bells, you know, I talked to Stan a little bit about you, some of the [0:56:35] past things that have come up. They really haven't had any issues with this. [0:56:42] It's one of those things where I do think most people when they see that a [0:56:49] drive through is full, they will bypass it. Sometimes it's purely for time constraints [0:56:54] alone. But also like if they are doing an online order, there's also options to park and walk [0:57:02] in and pick it up too. And a lot of people are looking more and more at ordering on the [0:57:07] app or that just because it's quicker. They don't want to sit in line. [0:57:14] other questions. I just had a question on and I was trying to find the physical [0:57:23] therapies letter that they had sent but they addressed a concern about possible [0:57:27] customers parking in their parking lot and walking over. What is the barrier [0:57:33] like between your place and your neighbor's place? There's currently an [0:57:40] existing vinyl fence, a chain-link with vinyl in it. This along with that, this, it [0:57:46] starts up right about here and it comes all the way down to the corner. And like I [0:57:55] said, it's very rare you would even see that many customers parking for that [0:58:01] amount of time. I know like just from my own driving around and looking at [0:58:07] different drive-through restaurants. It's very rare you see even five cars parked there. [0:58:14] People that are ordering this kind of food are usually in a rush. They're getting food in going [0:58:20] places. They're not getting it to sit and have a sit-down meal. It's a quick grab and go. [0:58:30] And I do know that there was concerns also about people taking it over to the nearby park. [0:58:34] Again, most people that are going to go through a drive-through restaurant are just grabbing [0:58:39] food in there on their way somewhere else. [0:58:41] Thank you, Grayson. [0:58:44] Did you have something else? [0:58:45] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:58:47] So, at this point, you don't have any agreements with adjacent property owners for back-stacking [0:58:52] if traffic becomes a problem, correct? [0:58:55] Correct. [0:58:58] Anybody else? [0:58:59] Thank you. [0:59:02] Yeah, thank you. [0:59:03] Mr. Gilbert, are you here? [0:59:07] Yes, he is. [0:59:08] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:59:23] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:59:29] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:59:31] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:59:34] to support this appeal. [0:59:36] I also thank the Times News for covering this issue [0:59:39] and I want to thank the city council [0:59:40] for the work that you do. [0:59:42] I appreciate that your job is sometimes very challenging [0:59:44] as in making decisions like this. [0:59:47] To the matter of hand, let me start with repeating our assertion [0:59:49] as stated in the appeal narrative. [0:59:51] The Appellants assert that the Planning and Zoning Commission abuse discretion without sufficiently [0:59:55] considering impact when they voted to grant special use permits during the public hearing [1:00:00] held on August 13, 2024. [1:00:02] Furthermore, the Appellants maintain that neither the Planning and Zoning Commission or the City [1:00:06] of Twin Falls have the right to violate the peace, security, property values, and overall [1:00:10] quality of life of the affected residents and businesses without just cause or compensation. [1:00:15] Taco Bell is a non-essential business. [1:00:17] It's drive-through and extended hours do not qualify as just cause. [1:00:23] As I hope to show, our appeal is not an idle complaint based on opinion. [1:00:28] This appeal was formed with care and with consideration for all parties involved. [1:00:31] We do not wish to waste the council's time. [1:00:36] During this entire process, there has been much confusion about the actual subject to hand. [1:00:40] To be perfectly clear, we do not object to businesses willing to operate under the current [1:00:44] zoning. [1:00:45] We only seek to appeal the special use permits pertaining to a drive-through and extended hours. [1:00:50] We have tried to make this clear in all of our communications. [1:00:54] If you have received communications to the contrary, all I can say is that we did our best [1:00:57] to present the issue clearly. [1:01:00] By profession, I am a data scientist and I have a master's degree in statistics. [1:01:05] The information I will present to you today is supported by standards and best practices. [1:01:10] Some of this information was not included in the appeal narrative because other obligations [1:01:14] prevented me from gathering the data and performing the analysis for the appeal application deadline. [1:01:20] I hope that you have the opportunity to read the appeal narrative. [1:01:22] covers items that I will not have time to cover tonight. [1:01:43] All right, let's get oriented north. [1:01:47] I mean, you've seen this, so hopefully, [1:01:49] you know, which direction is which Addison is up here. [1:01:52] Here's Lane is here. [1:01:55] CPR therapy is over here. [1:01:57] This is their vinyl fence. [1:02:01] They do have that shared entry for both the entry and the exit [1:02:04] for both businesses. [1:02:07] Critical things to remember about CPR therapy. [1:02:10] CPR therapy hosts group events. [1:02:13] I'm not sure that everybody's aware of that. [1:02:15] They testified of that in the last hearing. [1:02:17] They have group events. [1:02:20] They will have several vehicles entering [1:02:23] and exiting the property at the same time. [1:02:27] DPR therapy serves vulnerable populations [1:02:29] that often have difficulty driving [1:02:31] and navigating complex situations. [1:02:33] That's something that they had in their field letter [1:02:35] this time and last time. [1:02:37] DPR therapy serves a critical role in our community. [1:02:41] PPR therapy is an established business, so I think it deserves precedence in this matter. [1:02:51] Over here we have St. Luke's Clinic, down here at the bottom we have, you can start seeing [1:02:56] the residences, this is the Miller's house, they're the ones that are the closest to Taco [1:03:00] Bell. [1:03:02] Over here we have arrows indicating the direction to 9th Avenue and the high school, the Christian [1:03:08] High School, 9th Avenue is the only way to get from Eastland into the neighborhood and [1:03:15] it's we're concerned that it's going to draw a lot of traffic through the neighborhood. [1:03:20] Chardonnay assisted living is that direction and also Thompson Park is in that direction. [1:03:28] Let's see, the rectangles are vehicles representing different classes, they're all labeled. [1:03:34] I don't know if you can see that, let me just go over really quickly. [1:03:38] green one is sedan, the orange one is large SUV, the blue one is a pickup truck and the [1:03:45] red one is crossover, the gray one is minivan and the reason that we come clear why I did [1:03:53] that, I wanted to show situations based on our observations in the city of what the mix [1:04:00] of vehicles are and the fact is we have a lot of large vehicles here, that's not a [1:04:04] But we have dated back that up. [1:04:08] And all of these rectangles are very important in that they are too scale. [1:04:11] I was very careful to scale them according to the measurements on their diagram here. [1:04:19] And just as an indication of that over here on the right hand side you see a pickup truck [1:04:23] and you see our pickup truck, the blue rectangle. [1:04:28] And it's essentially the same size in fact this other pickup truck is a little bit larger. [1:04:33] that's getting acquainted with the map here. Let's see, the red arrows are turns [1:04:42] that shouldn't be made. I think we all agree on that. The left hand turns [1:04:50] essentially out of both exits. Right through traffic flows from north to south [1:04:56] and traffic flows in and out of Taco Bell, bought at both of these sites, the [1:05:01] Addison and the Carriage Lane. We have several concerns here. I will start with [1:05:06] the most important one and see how far we get. I forgot to start my timer. Do we [1:05:10] have a timer running. Thank you. Is it possible on the the information I received [1:05:20] on Friday I could have between 15 and 20? Is it possible to go over 15 minutes? [1:05:25] I don't think so. Okay. Simply put, one major concern is that Addison shared entrance and exit will get congested and lead to sub-metinum expected backups on to Addison Avenue East. [1:05:38] Unfortunately, the worst case scenario here is very likely. We will go over the numbers leading to this scenario later, but you can probably imagine that during winter [1:05:46] operating hours during imperfect. Let me get up there. You can see up here during [1:05:53] imperfect lighting and or slick road conditions and unexpected slowdown here [1:05:58] or a full stop will lead to serious harm because it is a major artery leading to [1:06:03] the freeway. The possibility of a semi-truck getting involved is very [1:06:06] possible. This type of accident could lead to major injuries or fatality. Also [1:06:11] because Addison is an artery to the freeway and because people are accustomed to it [1:06:14] being a country road speeds exceeding the speed limit are very common unlike [1:06:19] every other very busy drive-through in town there's no option for a safe [1:06:23] overflow hence there is very little margin for error. As I mentioned before we aren't [1:06:31] dealing with just Taco Bell traffic this is a shared entrance with CPR therapy [1:06:34] and they post group events. Taco Bell has been very very popular in Twin Falls [1:06:39] as noted. Mr. Nikleison noted that in the planning and zoning hearing that the [1:06:45] Twin Falls location is one of the busiest in Idaho, I will repeat it again tonight. [1:06:49] This location will be the only restaurant of its kind in the area. [1:06:54] During this appeal process I have received a lot of feedback from people that want a Taco [1:06:58] Bell location on this side of town. [1:07:02] There are significant residential developments here, including an apartment complex nearby. [1:07:06] More residential development is planned to the east. [1:07:09] There is also a significant commercial development in this area which will pull their own client [1:07:14] to this location, which will also bump up Taco Bell visits. [1:07:18] There are schools in the area we can expect [1:07:20] increased traffic flowings, especially [1:07:22] during the busy period, which is lunch hour. [1:07:24] Finally, when Taco Bell first opens, [1:07:26] there will be a honeymoon period. [1:07:29] Some people point out that Sonic failed in this area, [1:07:31] so they believe that Taco Bell might not be busy. [1:07:35] Sonic failed before all of this development, [1:07:37] before the apartment complex and so forth. [1:07:40] All of these points strongly suggest [1:07:42] that a backup here is inevitable, [1:07:44] but let's look at some numbers to help support this claim. [1:07:47] The Taco Bells, especially, use permit applications, [1:07:49] stays at the owners expect 500 cars, [1:07:50] which you explained per day at this site. [1:07:53] They do not, and she said that that would be in max, [1:07:56] but we can say 300. [1:07:59] They do not provide any support for this estimate, [1:08:01] nor they date at the time, [1:08:03] and they'll previous hearing, I should say, [1:08:05] nor do they provide likely range of values, [1:08:07] nor do they provide any estimates for volume spikes. [1:08:10] That's the critical thing. [1:08:11] It doesn't matter if they only get 100 cars per day. [1:08:13] If they come in faster than they go out, [1:08:15] you have a serious problem. [1:08:18] We know from looking at Google Maps, traffic metrics [1:08:20] at the Magic Valley Mall location, [1:08:22] experiences higher volume from noon to two, [1:08:24] from five to seven, have those here. [1:08:27] On the weekdays, it's more pronounced. [1:08:30] So I'm moving through this quickly. [1:08:34] Briefly also, Insight. [1:08:37] Intouch Insight has done the drive-through studies [1:08:39] they do every year, and they have shown, [1:08:42] in this particular study, again, [1:08:44] moving through quickly, that the average service time for Taco Bell is 194 seconds, which is [1:08:56] a little over three minutes, okay? [1:08:58] Three minutes, 14 seconds, okay? [1:09:03] This is very helpful information. [1:09:04] I should say service time, by the way, is from the speaker, the board, to where they pick [1:09:09] up the food. [1:09:10] It's not the wait time in line, it's not the total wait time, okay? [1:09:14] Unfortunately, while this is helpful information, this doesn't show us the range, the distribution [1:09:25] of possible wait times and service times. [1:09:28] And so I went out and I watched the Taco Bell here because even though they are busier, the [1:09:33] service time should be so far. [1:09:34] I mean, I think that's a good assumption. [1:09:36] Or at least that's the assumption that I'm making, that they should be able to process [1:09:39] cars essentially the same amount of time. [1:09:42] So I went out on three different days and I recorded 118 service times at the noon and [1:09:47] the average service time across all of my samples was three minutes and 29 seconds compared to [1:09:54] in-touch insights three minutes and 14 seconds is to be expected that my average service time [1:09:58] would be longer because I was at busier times but this shows that I'm basically on the nose [1:10:02] and so the rest of my data probably can be used to generalize. [1:10:07] This is where I got the mix of cars and going through quickly as you can see we have a lot of SUVs [1:10:14] and trucks, and vans, all these are large vehicles, they well outnumber the crossovers instead of vans. [1:10:21] What does that mean? That means you're going to have longer queues. [1:10:24] As I also observed is that the larger cars also had larger spacing. [1:10:27] I saw spacing as large as 10 feet being left between the cars. [1:10:34] Okay, and then this is the distribution of service times that I observed. [1:10:39] The smallest time is here on the left of 77 seconds, the largest time is 477 seconds, which is almost eight minutes. [1:10:48] That's a pretty wide distribution, and this is only, I was watching I think, two and a half hours total for 818 cars. [1:11:01] So we can expect to see even the greater extremes, which hopefully I'll be able to get to. [1:11:06] This distribution, by the way, is, as a statistician, is exactly the type of distribution we would expect to see from this. [1:11:13] I mean, in this kind of business, for service times, this is called a truncated log-normal distribution, [1:11:19] and so it makes it, again, makes me confident that my data is appropriate. [1:11:27] Okay, and then here we do have some, this shows that car times are correlated. [1:11:35] This is the how correlated the first, second, third, and fourth car that are serviced times [1:11:45] are with the car ahead of it, I mean the first car. [1:11:48] And so if you have a car that's been in there for just, I mean just going through quickly, [1:11:52] the car is behind it, go through quickly. [1:11:55] If the car is in there for a long time, chances are the next car is going to be in there for [1:12:00] a long time which I will show. [1:12:04] That's some statistics. [1:12:06] So just to show that that is valid, that that is not happening by chance, and the counts [1:12:16] of total drive through queue length anywhere from 1, which is the car itself, up to 11. [1:12:21] Again, this is a fairly small sample size. [1:12:23] They're going to be seeing a lot more of this than we are. [1:12:29] Okay. [1:12:30] I mean, then I would see. [1:12:31] Okay. [1:12:32] I'm not putting all this together, how does this apply to the situation at hand? [1:12:38] Essentially, what it means is that I'm showing here three large vehicles and showing how it [1:12:47] extends that line and how with just six cars in the queue and cars exiting CPR, we're going [1:12:56] to have blockage there. [1:12:59] And so we don't need a huge queue to have a block. [1:13:04] We only need six cars to have a block in because we have cars coming in for both Taco Bell and [1:13:10] CPR basically, you know, more than just Taco Bell traffic. [1:13:15] You're going to get backups here, unintended and sudden unexpected backups, which means [1:13:23] rear end, which again was pointed out here. [1:13:26] But the most common accident up there was a rear end already without this situation because [1:13:32] people aren't expecting it here and I very good yeah the left hand turns that's [1:13:42] that's what it is but yeah basically what I can show is that this is very likely [1:13:50] to happen it is I think in this I don't think it is very likely in this area that [1:13:57] especially with the honeymoon period and so forth that this simply will happen [1:14:02] and they don't have an alternative unfortunately. [1:14:05] In and out, why did you pass in and out [1:14:07] because in and out came and presented an alternative, [1:14:09] a credible alternative, and they had room to move [1:14:11] and the people were willing to work them. [1:14:14] They don't have that option. [1:14:16] And so it's an accident. [1:14:19] And that's a bad situation. [1:14:25] I just in the end, I guess really briefly, [1:14:29] we are very concerned about the impact of property values. [1:14:33] I want you to know that the people that are closest, [1:14:37] of the people who live closest, [1:14:38] to the Taco Bell, three of them are veterans, [1:14:41] two of them are disabled veterans, [1:14:44] and they have, and two of them are retired middle school [1:14:50] teachers, two of them have worked in the [1:14:53] telecommunications industry, all very productive people [1:14:57] who have really done a lot for the community [1:15:00] and for the country, and aren't rich people, [1:15:03] And now they're facing losing quite a bit of money [1:15:07] for property on their property values here. [1:15:09] And that's really hard to take. [1:15:13] That's actually my main point besides the traffic. [1:15:19] Yes, that's it. [1:15:21] Thank you for the time, any questions? [1:15:24] Great, son. [1:15:25] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [1:15:26] So that's an extensive presentation. [1:15:29] I appreciate all the effort that you put into that. [1:15:31] You mentioned earlier that your backgrounds [1:15:33] and data sciences to justify the data from me personally [1:15:37] in my own thought process. [1:15:38] Will you just talk on your background, on data science? [1:15:42] Is it degrees, is it? [1:15:44] Yeah, I have a master's degree in statistics, [1:15:46] and my career before that was in computer science, [1:15:49] software development, and so those two things [1:15:51] work very well in data science, [1:15:52] which is just a broader application of all of those tools. [1:15:56] It's both software development, [1:15:58] it's machine learning, it's AI, and it's statistics. [1:16:01] Yeah, thank you. [1:16:02] Anybody else have a question? [1:16:09] My question is actually for city staff, so I'll wait in case someone else has questions [1:16:12] for the appeal. [1:16:13] Okay. [1:16:14] It doesn't look like any questions. [1:16:25] All right. [1:16:27] Thank you. [1:16:28] Spencer, do you want to ask your question? [1:16:33] Yes. [1:16:37] I was curious about the drive-through that's permitted outright across the street and I [1:16:42] believe if I remember right, the approach to the street is already established. [1:16:48] What kind of distance do we have between the intersection and the approach for the drive-thru [1:16:52] that's already approved on the other side? [1:16:55] Well, the building permit hasn't been approved yet. [1:16:57] It's in review. [1:16:58] I would have to pull that up and I don't have that information with me tonight. [1:17:04] I can try to get it. [1:17:09] Jonathan's getting it. [1:17:11] I don't know what I have access to on this computer, so. [1:17:15] Understood. [1:17:16] Thank you, Kelly. [1:17:19] Any other questions before we open up the public comments? [1:17:24] Okay, so I'm going to open up the public hearing, and when you come down to address City Council, [1:17:34] please step to the podium, state your name and address, and then present your comments [1:17:40] and concerns. [1:17:42] After if you haven't already signed the public record, which I need to have that, you haven't [1:17:47] already signed that at the end please sign that before you leave and comments [1:17:56] will be two minutes you have two minutes to make your comments and once everybody [1:18:02] has made their comments we'll invite the applicant and the appellant backup and [1:18:09] staff back up to answer any additional questions we have a sign-in sheet we do [1:18:17] Kelly has it right here. I wanted to clarify your question the intersection [1:18:23] from Addison going north on carriage to that private entrance. That distance [1:18:28] compared to this one on the same road or is it a different question than I was? [1:18:32] Yeah well my concern overall is how close the entrance on Addison is to the [1:18:38] intersection and I was curious about Addison and carriage. What kind of [1:18:44] distance from the intersection to the approach. [1:18:46] I know the one on the north, the distance [1:18:50] are around 300 feet, they go to a joint entrance [1:18:53] or joint access on the north side, [1:18:56] and then they wrap into a parking lot. [1:18:58] I'll have to get to the two for this site. [1:19:00] I know the one on the carriage is around 200 [1:19:02] until you get to that entrance. [1:19:03] I didn't measure the other one. [1:19:06] All right, thank you. [1:19:08] Kelly, why don't you hand me that, [1:19:10] and then I'll start by calling your name [1:19:12] if you happen to sign up, and then we'll let everybody [1:19:15] We'll have an opportunity, but I'll start with the ones that sign up. [1:19:19] And if you have changed your mind about, [1:19:22] testify, just tell me you've changed your mind and we'll move on. [1:19:26] So first on the list is Kevin West. [1:19:29] Oh, there it's Kevin. [1:19:32] Teniel Sorensen, you're going to time that or maybe? [1:19:43] Okay. Welcome, Teniel. [1:19:47] Hi, welcome or welcome, I'm sorry. [1:19:49] You're welcome, you guys too, I guess. [1:19:52] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:19:54] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:19:59] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:20:01] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:20:08] with the cross country runners from the neighborhood lighthouse school, from the elderly walk in [1:20:16] the neighborhood, the visitors to Thompson Park. [1:20:19] We have a lot of foot traffic, and this increased traffic from the Taco Bell is going to impact [1:20:25] the people's safety, the children's safety. [1:20:29] The last thing we want is for anybody to get hurt or killed, and so that was one of the [1:20:35] issues that I just wanted to remind you guys of. [1:20:38] We have a lot of people that visit the Thompson Park for barbecues, baby showers, all sorts [1:20:45] of different events. [1:20:47] other thing that I wanted to I guess that was pretty much it actually just [1:20:56] asking you as city officials that you know it's our responsibility as parents [1:21:01] grandparents and as citizens and you all as city members you prioritize the [1:21:08] safety of our community and that's it thank you for your time. Thank you [1:21:13] Tennille. Next I have Kirsten Stewart and then on deck is Kurt. I'm Kirsten Stewart [1:21:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:29] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:37] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:41] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:45] They'll have U-turns at the St. Luke's Clinic. [1:21:48] They'll have U-turns at Chardonnay, Thompson Park, or at the corner of carriage and Trotter. [1:21:54] And this particular Taco Bell is in a small lot. [1:22:00] I don't think a McDonald's would fit there or a Dutch brothers or a Chick-fil-A on that [1:22:05] corner. [1:22:06] And of course Taco Bell is not as busy as those. [1:22:09] But when we think about Carl Juniors, Carl Juniors probably is not as busy as Taco Bell. [1:22:16] They do have a plan. [1:22:17] They have a spillage area for traffic flow. [1:22:21] I'm concerned that if Taco Bell is built and the drive-through is built, I'm concerned [1:22:27] that I'm going to have to come and address it again and I'd really rather be handled [1:22:32] now. [1:22:33] I don't want any surprises of extended hours if they've changed them and I'm a little concerned [1:22:40] that they could appeal that at a later date and it would just pass through and I wouldn't [1:22:45] know about that. [1:22:47] I will repeat again, I think this is not the lot for Taco Bell. [1:22:54] I don't think the Taco Bell is going to make enough money there either. [1:22:58] That's all. [1:23:01] Thank you. [1:23:02] Next we have Kurt Stewart. [1:23:12] I'm Kurt Stewart. [1:23:13] I live 10, 3, 6 carriage lane. [1:23:16] What everything has been said so far is it's just there's not enough room to have that type [1:23:25] of fast food restaurant on that corner. [1:23:27] It's a busy enough corner already without adding more to it. [1:23:33] There's like mentioned before, [1:23:34] there's a lot of people that walk and ride their bikes [1:23:37] and take their children to the park [1:23:39] and a lot of high school traffic as well. [1:23:42] There's a physical therapy building, [1:23:44] there's a medical clinic, assisted living home. [1:23:48] There's emergency vehicles that come in there [1:23:51] plus fire trucks all the time to take care of those people. [1:23:56] It's just too much traffic for the area. [1:24:00] It's not a good location for a Taco Bell. [1:24:05] And it's unsafe. [1:24:08] And there's a lot of backup. [1:24:10] There's no plan, which is mentioned before, of that. [1:24:14] Yeah, it may not happen, but yeah, it may happen. [1:24:17] And then what's going to take place? [1:24:20] It's just not nothing against Taco Bell. [1:24:24] It's just not a good location, in my opinion, [1:24:27] for that type of restaurant and all the traffic, all the noise, it's a quiet [1:24:34] neighborhood already and we hate to lose that and we've lived there for over 25 [1:24:42] years and we don't want to lose that sense of safety and quietness of the [1:24:51] neighborhood which could be disrupted by all this. Thank you. Thank you. Next I have [1:25:01] Randy Kern thank you mayor thank you city council for taking all of our opinions [1:25:19] right we appreciate that and Floyd's facts which are awesome because that [1:25:23] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:31] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:37] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:40] I mean, I just being honest, but the drive-up is a real concern. [1:25:44] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:46] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:53] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:25:57] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:26:02] had to stop yesterday for a ball that was racing across 9th Avenue because the kid lost control [1:26:07] of it, right, and paying attention. [1:26:10] It's just a huge concern. [1:26:13] Anyone coming from East London is going to go down ninth. [1:26:17] And there is a ton of foot traffic, a ton of kids, [1:26:20] a lot of traffic there. [1:26:21] And that's how I would get to Taco Bell if I was coming [1:26:23] from East London. [1:26:24] I wouldn't go down Addison. [1:26:26] I would go down ninth, right? [1:26:28] So just that's a huge concern. [1:26:31] And then when you get out to Addison Avenue, [1:26:35] there's no way those cars are going to be stopped on the road. [1:26:38] I can't imagine that there's not a big enough footprint put it on the other side of carriage [1:26:42] or the other side of Addison would be awesome where they're talking about putting this coffee [1:26:46] place and there's a elevation change so those folks are going to have to go down carriage [1:26:52] go around and come back in they can't come off Addison it's a huge drop it's 15 feet [1:26:57] 20 feet there's no way they're going to build that so that traffic has got to go around so [1:27:03] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:27:06] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:27:24] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:27:37] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:27:42] the people take advantage of turning around in my driveway. They've come within inches of hitting my vehicles and with Taco Bell they're just going to add to more traffic. [1:27:57] My other concern is I cannot afford to put in a sidewalk. I've been there for 19 years. I'm a disabled veteran on my next income. [1:28:09] Well, I am going to have people walking across my property to get to Taco Bell, because they're [1:28:18] walking on my grass, because I am right behind Taco Bell. [1:28:23] And I do worry about pedestrians destroying my property. [1:28:32] People deciding that they want to walk around the corner and onto my property to eat their [1:28:39] meal because it's a grassy area or vandalizing my property because they'll be [1:28:50] walking across my property. So I am definitely against it because of traffic [1:28:58] and then I'm also concerned about, you know, they say there won't be any lights [1:29:04] coming across because of the seven-foot wall. There will still be lights. They say [1:29:09] that there will be no noise because of that wall. [1:29:12] You have 10 seconds. [1:29:13] Eight seconds. [1:29:14] But people are going to be honking their horns [1:29:16] for people to move on. [1:29:18] That's all I have to say. [1:29:19] Thank you. [1:29:21] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:29:34] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:29:38] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:29:43] specifically from the drive-through. [1:29:46] There will be, when customers are exiting that lot on carriage, [1:29:52] There will be customers turning left, even though there's a double line, they're not allowed to. [1:29:56] There will be customers turning left going through carriage and then up on 9th out there. [1:30:02] That's the only way out would be up that way. [1:30:04] My biggest concern is that we have a lot of children in schools. [1:30:11] Lighthouse is down up on 9th and O'Leary and I know both of those schools have kids [1:30:17] that run track, football and other sports and they have those students run [1:30:22] around all the way through Thompson Park, down to that corner of Addison and Carriage and then back. [1:30:28] Just I know that because my kid runs sports and done my kids both go to the lighthouse. My [1:30:34] daughter rides her bike to school and back and so I'm concerned about the traffic, the additional [1:30:38] traffic coming through there. And I know that there are daycares and a couple other businesses [1:30:46] is there on 9th that are near Lighthouse that would be affected by the additional traffic [1:30:51] as well. [1:30:52] And so I'm just concerned about the traffic and sometimes those students, if they're coming [1:30:57] from high school during lunch, wouldn't be paying attention to all the other kids around [1:31:02] or the other foot traffic around and would cause some problems there. [1:31:06] So I just wanted to make sure that you guys are well aware of those situations. [1:31:11] Thank you, Sam. [1:31:13] Next I have Michelle Larson. [1:31:26] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:31:31] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:31:34] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:31:39] All the traffic with all the new neighborhood [1:31:41] over across Carriage on the other side of Addison, [1:31:44] all those new houses and apartments. [1:31:46] All the traffic is coming down Carriage, turning on 9th. [1:31:49] So after school, I have difficulty just pulling out [1:31:53] of my driveway because the bus stops, [1:31:55] and then all the cars pile up. [1:31:57] It's pretty bad already. [1:31:59] And I watched kids that daycare that's right down ninth, [1:32:02] they bring those little kids, they're like preschool age. [1:32:05] They're walking down the street to go to the park. [1:32:07] There's the track people, there's sports, [1:32:10] there's people doing baseball practice [1:32:12] and all kinds of stuff there, football practice. [1:32:15] But my mom lives in that facility, [1:32:17] which is just a crossword that proposed places, you know, [1:32:20] and that assisted living. [1:32:21] And then when she sees the doctor, [1:32:23] Sometimes it's in that St. Luke's, but I've even [1:32:26] talked to the nurses there. [1:32:27] All of them said it's really hard for them to leave. [1:32:29] They couldn't make this meeting. [1:32:31] It's hard for them to get out because of traffic already. [1:32:34] And my concern is these kids are all running around. [1:32:38] They're riding bikes. [1:32:38] They're going through the park. [1:32:40] And it's going to increase all this traffic. [1:32:43] Where are they going to put it? [1:32:45] It's not that far. [1:32:48] So Hanson, people, all the truckers [1:32:50] to come in with Hanson, down Addison. [1:32:53] That is a very busy road. [1:32:54] So if we have people coming out right before a stoplight, [1:32:57] I mean, it's right before, it's on that corner. [1:33:00] I don't know how people are gonna make that left turn [1:33:03] to get into that lane. [1:33:05] Right now there's just one lane each way [1:33:06] in a center turn lane. [1:33:08] Same with on carriage, the St. Luke's office is there. [1:33:12] People are trying to get healthcare, [1:33:13] whether it's CPR or they're going to get to appointments. [1:33:18] They don't need to be in an accident. [1:33:19] concerned about everybody's safety but I watch kids all the time and they run [1:33:24] they get away from parents you know or whatever and your time's up okay thank [1:33:29] you and I'm just concerned about thank you and Ambulance says they already come [1:33:34] to my mom's facility repeatedly thank you I'm worried about that late night stuff [1:33:38] with high schoolers and thank you and okay yeah and I know the other talk about [1:33:44] Your time's up, okay. Yeah, thank you. They're open till 3 a.m. Thank you [1:33:48] Hey now bill. I'm gonna botch this last name. I don't know where you are is it? [1:33:54] I can't read your writing. Sorry. Okay [1:34:02] My name is Bill Swanson of a 1076 Trotter lived in this town for 51 years [1:34:08] And sitting there listening to Floyd Floyd. Thank you for putting this all together all of our neighbors [1:34:14] Thank you for coming out and supporting us in this one thing. I want to ask you all be proactive rather than [1:34:22] And when I say that it [1:34:24] It stems from the traffic it stems from all of the kids everything that everybody has brought to you right now [1:34:30] Telling you what we are all concerned about there will be accidents that carriage. It's not a very wide intersection right there [1:34:38] We all know people people are people you cannot control people look at blue legs [1:34:44] You have businesses on blue lakes right now of no left-hand turn. We'll still turn learn left on blue lakes [1:34:53] Trying to get some of this [1:34:55] Jack in the box if you if you approve the extended hours to two o'clock in the morning [1:35:00] All you have to do is go out there jack in the box. Nothing good happens at night [1:35:04] Everybody leaving the bars. They're gonna go to jack in the box [1:35:08] They're gonna go to Taco Bell just like they do a jack in box [1:35:11] We're going to have to listen to the bumping music. We're going to have to listen to the cars honking their horns all of the lights [1:35:18] Smelling the the trash because their trash receptacle is backing up right [1:35:23] To the back of the properties that are right there on carriage lane. My house is directly behind the physical therapy place [1:35:29] If you look at some of the the areas, and I know I've only got 20 seconds left [1:35:42] Look at Eastlin and Addison the Sinclair right there everybody travel in East on Addison [1:35:47] They pull through the double line, which is illegal, that's still going to be the same thing. [1:35:54] You're going to have so many problems in that area, that's why I ask you. [1:35:59] We all know that Twin Falls is going to grow, I am totally fine with that, but be smart about where we're at in the school district. [1:36:06] Thank you Bill. [1:36:07] Okay, Jonathan Miller. [1:36:10] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:15] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:18] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:21] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:36:23] especially when people don't seem to be happy. [1:36:25] But I appreciate your efforts to do what you feel is right in this situation. [1:36:29] I appreciate the comments that have been shared and the concerns. [1:36:32] I think they're real and valid and I think they're important to consider. [1:36:36] I think that I wanted to just reaffirm some of those concerns as my own as well. [1:36:41] And also, I shared some comments earlier today, some questions, [1:36:45] some questions and I see that some of the things that were done in Chared Early were to address [1:36:51] some of those concerns and I appreciate that. One of them was the question about U-turns [1:36:55] and some of those kinds of things and I think that it would be prudent and wise if it hasn't [1:37:00] already been done, maybe it has to do a really effective traffic study in the area and make [1:37:05] sure that the concerns that have been expressed with traffic getting in and out of the drive-in [1:37:11] are addressed with traffic measures, [1:37:14] and that they follow the MU-ECD directives [1:37:19] that are out there. [1:37:20] If there's any thing else I could say, [1:37:23] I guess I would just say, [1:37:24] I have family members that have lived [1:37:26] in this neighborhood before. [1:37:27] They don't live there now, but they have lived there, [1:37:29] and they had small children. [1:37:29] They often went to the park. [1:37:31] It's a great thing to do. [1:37:32] I sometimes go there with some of my friends as well, [1:37:35] and really enjoy the environment that's there, [1:37:37] and I'm concerned that the new restaurant [1:37:40] will change that, making it more difficult for people to enjoy the happy environment that's [1:37:46] there right now. I really appreciate all the things that have been shared and your efforts [1:37:50] in considering this situation. Thank you. [1:37:52] Thank you. Okay, that's everybody that signed up, up top. Is there anybody else that wishes [1:38:02] you come down and address City Council? We're going to take turns. I see you're up first [1:38:09] and there's a lady behind you that will be next. [1:38:13] So. [1:38:23] Okay, Paula Brown Sinclair, 2146 Addison Avenue East. [1:38:28] And I actually feel that I'm part of the neighborhood [1:38:31] of Taco Bell. [1:38:32] I'm one of the last residences on the right [1:38:35] as you drive east toward this subject property. [1:38:38] I have a couple of thoughts, points that I haven't heard made [1:38:43] in this whole conversation. [1:38:44] And I did go back and read the P&Z minutes. [1:38:49] So I want to share two thoughts with you. [1:38:51] Number one, I think P&Z got it right. [1:38:54] I think that you need to hear from somebody [1:38:56] that despite all of the concerns that have been raised tonight, [1:39:01] and I know that they're heartfelt and valid, [1:39:04] but growth and development and change, it can be hard. [1:39:10] And that's why we have zoning laws. [1:39:13] In this case, we have planned ahead [1:39:17] for the development on our end of town. [1:39:20] We have wisely designated appropriate places [1:39:23] for the services that we need. [1:39:27] And you know, Addison has from the very first days [1:39:30] of our community been the major east-west arterial. [1:39:35] I don't remember a time ever, [1:39:37] I've been out there for 25 years, [1:39:39] that Addison, east of Eastland, [1:39:41] has ever been zoned anything other than commercial. [1:39:47] So the people that have made choices [1:39:51] to reside in that area would have known of the plan [1:39:55] for commercial development. [1:39:57] They should not be heard now to complain that the empty lot [1:40:02] that they bought next to zoned commercial [1:40:05] is going to be developed as a commercial activity. [1:40:10] And that's how planning and zoning should work, and I believe it worked in this case. [1:40:16] But one other thought, I want you to visualize the couple square mile area, bordered on the [1:40:21] North by Filer on the West by Locust and on the South by Kimberly Road, because that's [1:40:28] where I live. [1:40:29] East Twin Falls. [1:40:31] In that area, there are two, count them, two restaurants. [1:40:38] Now to say that we need more restaurants on the east end of town, it's irrelevant. [1:40:44] Need doesn't have anything to do with it, but I want you to hear a resident say, we want [1:40:52] more food resources on our end of town. [1:40:57] Thank you, Paula. [1:40:58] Your time's up. [1:40:59] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:41:20] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:41:33] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:41:49] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:41:57] frequently and it is a busy neighborhood and in that neighborhood they have signs posted [1:42:05] in their yards that says slow down this isn't a raceway and so I believe that they have a [1:42:14] valid point and most of what I've heard and I'll admit I've come late to the [1:42:19] party but most of what I've heard has been in regards to the people that live [1:42:24] on that side of carriage lane or that side of Addison but there's a lot of [1:42:30] people that live down on my side of carriage lane and there's a lot of [1:42:35] traffic down in that area too and especially it's very exciting to have [1:42:41] fit one come in there, but that's going to increase the traffic in that area as well. [1:42:47] Development is good, and I truly do appreciate all the work and effort that each of you put [1:42:54] into your service as living in public office, because I've been in your place as well. [1:43:02] I know sometimes that it gets old, listening to public comment, but I just want to say [1:43:11] But do the very best that you can and project that confidence that people might have in you [1:43:18] that you did do the very best that you could after you heard all of the facts that have been presented to you. [1:43:24] Thank you. Thank you, Sharon. [1:43:27] Is there anybody else in the audience? Please come down. [1:43:30] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:43:44] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:43:47] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:43:55] That's a busy place. [1:43:58] We've already made a mess out of our traffic control on Blu-Lace. [1:44:03] Let's not do the same thing on Addison. [1:44:06] Let's keep it why we have the property to make things happen. [1:44:11] Let's do it and it is a concern. [1:44:13] I'll stand out there at seven o'clock in the morning, [1:44:16] and there's traffic from Carriage Lane, [1:44:19] all the way to Eastland, all the way, [1:44:22] just because of some buses. [1:44:24] Cars come in both ways, let's not get anybody killed, [1:44:28] let's just take care of it. [1:44:29] I like singing there for people, I like them together, [1:44:32] and that's just gonna make it a big old mess. [1:44:36] Thanks for hearing me out though. [1:44:37] Thank you, Kurt. [1:44:40] Anybody else in the audience that wishes, [1:44:42] I see two, three, four, you just take turns. [1:45:00] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:45:03] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:45:04] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:45:07] I'm opposed to this location for the drive-through, [1:45:10] the traffic at the internet section is really bad. [1:45:15] Floyd's diagram was great. [1:45:18] The rear ends are anticipated. [1:45:21] And I've also heard a lot about the double solid yellow lines [1:45:25] that you're not supposed to turn left on. [1:45:27] Well, I pulled up the Idaho driver's handbook [1:45:30] from July this year, and it says, [1:45:33] two solid yellow lines means that neither lane of traffic [1:45:36] can cross the lines unless they are turning [1:45:39] if it is safe to do so. [1:45:41] A driver can cross a double yellow line when turning left [1:45:44] into or out of a driveway or entrance to a business. [1:45:48] No passing is allowed. [1:45:50] So, when they say that you can't turn left out of the exit onto Addison, they can, [1:45:58] because it's just a double-level line, as is on carriage up until where you drive [1:46:05] into the drive-through off of carriage, also a double-level line. [1:46:10] So, people can't turn left out of both of those entrances, and that's what I'm concerned [1:46:17] about, out onto Addison, people will turn left. I see it everywhere else. I've heard people [1:46:27] talk about the double double yellow line. That is not in the Idaho driver's handbook. So I'm [1:46:34] curious as what the double double double yellow line is supposed to mean. But anyway, like I [1:46:44] said I'm opposed to drive-through at this location. I don't think it's it's not a [1:46:50] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:46:59] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:47:19] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:47:24] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:47:30] to go walk the park and it's going to make it a lot more difficult. [1:47:34] We also have many people that walk down our street on their way to go to the park so there's [1:47:40] a lot of foot traffic. [1:47:42] One lady said that we should know that businesses were going in. [1:47:45] I haven't heard anybody say that they were against having a business going there. [1:47:50] against having a drive-through going in there and we were wondering we were also [1:47:58] hoping that you would consider the fact that it would reduce our property values [1:48:02] for somebody that wants to come in and open a business that doesn't even live [1:48:07] in Twin Falls that lives in Boise. I don't think I heard anybody talk about the [1:48:16] fact that it's windy in Twin Falls and we're gonna get a lot of trash from this [1:48:21] fast food place in our neighborhood. Everything else that they talked about I agree with. So [1:48:30] I mean we chose where we moved into because all of the businesses in that area are all [1:48:37] like nine to five. Money through Friday it's in it and it's such a safe neighborhood and [1:48:43] this will make it so it's not safe and I'm worried about the people in our neighborhood. [1:48:48] Thank you for listening. [1:48:50] Thank you, Patty. [1:48:54] Anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council, [1:49:03] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:05] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:32] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:36] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:41] There's an awful lot of rookies in here. [1:49:44] I got a real problem and you might have noticed that I'm handicapped and trying to get across [1:49:55] Kerry's Lane over to Thompson Park where I like to go walking especially this time of [1:50:06] year is next to impossible. Most of the people that drive down that road know me and so they [1:50:13] so they'll stop and let me get across, but I think I could get hit any time. [1:50:23] The other thing that nobody brought up at that corner, there's three school buses that [1:50:30] stop at that corner and pick up kids, not one person, this mention the school buses. [1:50:38] The other thing is that those parents that are hauling their kids to school and coming [1:50:45] from the north side of Addison and that traffic clear up to Chardonnay trying to get around [1:50:55] that corner and it's a disaster. [1:50:58] Anyway, I'm the old guy that says out there in the morning and drinks my coffee in my garage [1:51:04] door with my dogs and watches what happens in the neighborhood. [1:51:08] I know what's going on. [1:51:11] Thank you. [1:51:12] Thank you, Kelly. [1:51:13] Is there anybody else that wishes to address City Council before I move back to the applicant [1:51:22] and the appellant? [1:51:23] Okay. [1:51:28] So we have one more or are you leaving, leaving? [1:51:33] Okay. [1:51:34] So first, yes. [1:51:37] The procedure is five minutes for each of them. [1:51:40] Okay. [1:51:41] Thank you. [1:51:42] So we'll start with the applicant. [1:51:43] I'm not sure who's coming up, eh? [1:51:48] And you're timing them, John? [1:51:50] or Amy or somebody just okay thank you yes first of all thank you for those of [1:52:01] you that have served I do appreciate you I just wanted to address a few items [1:52:08] that came up through the conversations from the neighbors some things where we [1:52:15] only have so much control over right I know that when concern was foot traffic [1:52:21] We will be providing sidewalks which will upgrade that site and actually provide a safer route [1:52:27] around that corner and to the [1:52:29] busiest parts of getting out to Addison and things like that. We can only take it to obviously the extents of our property. [1:52:38] I know there was concerns about the size of the lot. [1:52:41] This is actually a very standard size for the lots that we developed for Taco Bell. It's not a small lot. [1:52:48] It's pretty average, so I don't have exact score footage on that, but if anyone [1:52:56] does need that information I could look it up and find it for you. I know that [1:53:01] there was concerns about noise. We can only do so much. We're gonna try to [1:53:06] mitigate the noise. We're not saying that there will not be any noise. We're doing [1:53:10] our best to try to provide buffers and mitigate. That's all we can do. [1:53:17] You know, hopefully this would actually help maybe lessen some of the noise coming from Addison. It's a very busy street [1:53:25] trash [1:53:26] The trash enclosure is actually located more than 50 feet from the closest residential fence [1:53:33] Which is a pretty decent distance [1:53:36] Taco Bell the corporate has pretty strict requirements for cleanliness. They have regular inspections [1:53:43] things like that [1:53:45] There's pretty high standards for keeping their locations up to snuff so [1:53:52] There won't be trash floating around like it's [1:53:56] They have it collected as needed some times multiple times during the week [1:54:01] and [1:54:03] The other issue is increased traffic [1:54:08] This you got to understand a lot of the people who will be using Taco Bell are actually people that are already [1:54:15] in the neighborhood and using the streets. [1:54:18] There will be some increase of people driving [1:54:21] to this location to use it. [1:54:23] But overall, the large number of people coming [1:54:27] to this location are people that are already in the area. [1:54:32] So it may increase some traffic on some of the side streets, [1:54:38] but also we're trying to direct them back out to Addison [1:54:43] and care. In the last meeting, we talked about potentially maybe working with the city and [1:54:50] seeing if there was some way to provide buffers like those candlesticks or something like that. [1:54:57] That might keep people from turning left. I don't know if that really is an option, but [1:55:03] we would be open to talking with city engineers about that. Just ideas. Obviously, we're trying [1:55:10] to think about ways we can create a safe environment, we don't want children run over, [1:55:19] hopefully providing new sidewalks and clear ingress out of this parking lot will actually [1:55:27] help people get around the site instead of a dirt lot. [1:55:32] I was just trying to think if there's anything else. [1:55:39] I think that was the most of them, you know, again, we're just trying to be a good neighbor [1:55:43] here and we want to make sure that we're working with the city to provide a, you know, a project [1:55:50] that will be successful but will also, you know, be a good neighbor to those people that [1:55:56] are around us. [1:55:58] Thank you. [1:55:59] Thank you. [1:56:06] You also have five minutes. [1:56:08] Yeah, good notes that they can't control the traffic and the noise. [1:56:15] We agree. [1:56:16] We invite uncontrollable traffic and noise into the area. [1:56:19] It's not inevitable. [1:56:20] It's not required. [1:56:21] There's still no plan to provide or handle drive-through overflows. [1:56:27] And based on the site, they can't, I agree, that they might have other sites that are the [1:56:31] same size, but they probably are in like a strip mall or something where it won't overflow [1:56:35] onto a regular high traffic street. [1:56:39] We live in harmony with existing businesses, part of planning and zoning is also used to [1:56:43] protect livable walkable spaces to create beautiful living areas. We love [1:56:49] living in Twin Falls because there's awesome stuff here. Let's make awesome [1:56:54] places to live. It invites people into the towns. Why would, again, why would we [1:56:59] invite unnecessary noise and traffic and whatever else into an area where we [1:57:05] live? And again, we live in harmony with the businesses that are there. We are not [1:57:09] arguing about the zoning, we agree, we understand the zoning, but we're arguing [1:57:14] about is extending the zoning. I wasn't able to cover all the evidence that shows [1:57:19] that traffic overflows are likely to happen. Perhaps it has occurred to you by [1:57:25] now that the situation as plain as the risk is will open both the city and [1:57:29] Taco Bell up to severe litigation when, when, not if an accident occurs, I hate [1:57:35] to speak on those terms because we should be more concerned about the person in [1:57:38] the accident, even so it is not good business to invite litigation. [1:57:43] Because the data speaks so strongly in the case, you could easily be sued for negligence [1:57:48] because you knew ahead of time that there was significant risk involved. [1:57:52] I have a lot of information here that I wasn't able to get to that really shows with solid [1:57:57] support that this is very likely to happen. [1:58:01] If you need more time to discuss this, I'm happy to meet with planning and zoning or with [1:58:06] any consultant that you have to show the scenario, [1:58:10] if you need a table of the issue. [1:58:13] That is our dual concern is also with property values. [1:58:18] I wish Doug Miller had mentioned [1:58:20] that he has visited with the realtor [1:58:21] and he is guaranteed to lose value in his home. [1:58:28] Why? [1:58:29] Why would we do that? [1:58:31] That is so strange. [1:58:32] And that is precisely why we have special use permits [1:58:36] because they aren't appropriate for everywhere. [1:58:39] This is a beautiful livable walkable area [1:58:41] that has been testified many, many times. [1:58:44] Let's keep it that way. [1:58:47] It's working. [1:58:49] It's working. [1:58:49] I mean, it has been mentioned that it's kind of busy, [1:58:51] but yeah, we understood that when we came here, [1:58:54] but the Taco Bell extended hours [1:58:59] and drive through certainly was not. [1:59:00] That is new. [1:59:01] And when we moved here, that was not a consideration. [1:59:05] I certainly wouldn't have moved here. [1:59:06] I have a child that adopted Down Syndrome Kid. [1:59:09] We came to this street because it was safe. [1:59:15] I want to keep it that way, obviously. [1:59:17] And that's what planning and zoning is about. [1:59:19] I don't have to, sorry, I'm not preaching to you. [1:59:21] You know this better than me, you know your job. [1:59:24] But this is a serious concern. [1:59:27] Again, also when you're affecting property values, [1:59:32] that is taking money away from people without recompense. [1:59:36] Nobody has visited with these people [1:59:37] find out who they are and to offer them compensation for what they're going to [1:59:41] lose and as I noted before these are not rich people this matters to them I was [1:59:46] just discussing with the millers and they were saying yeah that's our [1:59:48] nest egg that's what we've got they're relying on that that is their main asset [1:59:55] so why would we take that away from them it just doesn't make sense especially [2:00:00] when Taco Bell there are so many sites that would work so well for them and like [2:00:04] I said I couldn't believe I got almost accosted online about all the people like man we don't [2:00:11] mess this up we really want to talk about on this side of town that's fine let's have [2:00:15] it on this side of town but it doesn't harmonize with this location every other business in [2:00:21] this location does because it's the same planning I mean it's the same zoning you have any more [2:00:29] questions for me right thank you very much thank you Jonathan or Kelly do you [2:00:40] have anything to add before I close the public hearing standing up here for [2:00:45] any questions we might have I'm thinking of the ones that we need to answer or [2:00:48] if they're sticking in your mind that we need to answer for you okay start [2:00:53] with Grayson thank you Madam Director Spill-Love and City Staff so we're [2:00:58] applying the same nine criteria that we would on specialties permit that would [2:01:02] Planions only would apply as well correct. That's correct. I believe those are in your staff report on page 2 rough guess one and two [2:01:11] Jerry [2:01:13] Other stop signs currently at 9th and carriage. I just looked at that. I don't believe there's a yield sign [2:01:19] I believe on 9th as you get to carriage at least that's what the Googlers image or the Google Street View image [2:01:25] Showed me [2:01:26] So that's the best information I have for I don't believe there's a stop sign [2:01:31] I'm assuming it's current. [2:01:34] Assuming that that's been happening in the last year or so. [2:01:37] I don't believe we've added any and I'm looking. [2:01:39] I think Lee's looking to make sure that he's going to look the same thing. [2:01:43] Okay. Thank you. Jason. [2:01:45] Jonathan, just looking at it and trying to figure out this location a little bit more. [2:01:53] They still have to submit, building permit, submit all of that stuff, [2:01:57] work with other local utilities in the area to make sure that all those requirements are done [2:02:02] if it were approved. Any type of construction would go through all of their [2:02:07] own, especially to utilities. So we would do water, sewer, idle power. If there's any [2:02:15] canal or anything like that in the area, they would then go through the canal [2:02:18] company to deal with any type of issues with that. If there is one in the area, I [2:02:22] believe there's one on the south side. So they would, whatever they're doing to be, [2:02:26] whatever they're gonna change in the area, they'd have to get that permission first [2:02:30] And then we'd get enforced in on the building permit. Yes. Well, 9th Avenue does have a yields fact going [2:02:41] I just have one more yield signs to near very different than the stop signs on carriage and night [2:02:55] but also [2:02:58] I can't I can't not say I am a real estate professional, and I just [2:03:05] would appreciate that real estate professionals be very very careful on [2:03:09] on saying that they guarantee a property value will decline [2:03:13] because of a certain business unless that can be backed up [2:03:18] by multiple locations because we do have other locations [2:03:21] that do back up to commercials that do not decline [2:03:25] in property values. [2:03:26] So we just need, I know that's been brought up many times [2:03:29] and not just by one person but by many people. [2:03:32] And I just want to put that out there to be very careful [2:03:37] when you tell people that. [2:03:41] Anybody else have any questions for before I close? [2:03:45] Probably carrying any information you need from staff that you can think of. [2:03:50] On the street or anything like that. [2:03:52] I know that there are existing conditions that we'd had with the original report [2:03:56] that identified or at least on our end, we attempted to identify the issues [2:04:02] and to mitigate those if it were approved. [2:04:06] Looks like Jason has a question, Jonathan, and I appreciate you bringing that up. [2:04:10] one thing that just popped into my mind is I was just looking at a couple of [2:04:14] different things do we have traffic counts do we know looking at Lee because [2:04:20] he's here for or for like vehicles that come through doing the counting aspect [2:04:25] are you talking on carriage on probably Addison mostly but if we have him for [2:04:30] carriage it would probably be nice to know that as well don't we do not have [2:04:37] We have counts on carriage, we have counts on Addison, and going east-west combined, [2:04:44] we average about 11,600 a day, 24-hour period. [2:04:54] And that's one direction? [2:04:57] It's basically 6,000 both ways. [2:04:59] Okay. [2:05:00] So interestingly enough, like I said, we don't have anything on carriage I looked, [2:05:06] to try and find similar intersections, falls and locusts, that's also about 6,000 east and west, [2:05:16] and interestingly enough the southbound on locust is also about 6,000. So an intersection [2:05:21] about that size can be 6,000. [2:05:28] Lee, does your information break out the size of vehicle or do you have any of that information? [2:05:35] I don't have that on me when we did the traffic counts on Locust we had to let it [2:05:41] truck some things like that. Thank you. The other item I'd want to clarify from a [2:05:49] city code standpoint so when you're looking at drive-throughs and our sizing [2:05:54] we size them or the required size is 9 by 20. It's the same size for a parking [2:06:00] stall. So I know larger trucks those 3500 extended four-door long beds are 22 [2:06:07] inch feet so the average like that coupled with smaller vehicles 9 by 20 [2:06:14] seems to be what's fit and has been the standard for years. Are there any plans [2:06:22] that I may not or that we may not be aware of of whitening Addison anymore [2:06:27] or changing that intersection concrete or anything like that within the [2:06:33] intersection future plans that we may not be aware of. [2:06:36] I mean again look at lead if there's those those exist I know I didn't know if [2:06:41] there was anything set in place yet that maybe we should development has [2:06:44] occurred on the north side and we got drop lanes and extended lanes on the [2:06:47] north side I don't know if that's same as on the south side carriage is a [2:06:53] collector so we would expect the applicant to improve carriage adjacent to [2:06:59] property to the collector standards. Okay, but nothing in the street. Addison, I did not look at [2:07:05] the width of that, but yeah, they would be required to meet the current standards. Okay, [2:07:10] that answer your question. Okay, any other questions for staff before I close the public hearing? [2:07:22] Okay, public hearing is closed. So, Council, Grayson. Madam Mayor, I didn't get to jump in on [2:07:34] the last one so I'll jump in on the first one on this one. I want to just say I [2:07:40] really appreciate everybody coming out and talking about this property. This is [2:07:43] a great turnout and I really appreciate everybody taking the time to come out [2:07:45] and to advocate. I want to make it clear that property is zoned commercial. [2:07:51] Something will come in. It will increase noise and it will increase traffic. It's [2:07:56] zoned outright and by permitted use. That being said you know and evaluating the [2:08:04] special use permit requirement. There's there's those nine criteria you have to hit number [2:08:08] eights. Will it have vehicle approaches to the property which shall be so designed as [2:08:13] to not create an interference traffic on surrounding public thoroughfares? At this point based upon [2:08:19] that site plan, I think that it goes against number eight. That's why I asked that direct [2:08:24] question is what it's what about the excess stacking with there not being a other room [2:08:29] on either side of them. I mean you've got two roadways one to the west one of the north [2:08:33] and CPR to the east, and they don't have written permission from CPR to stack in their parking lot, where does it go? [2:08:41] It goes into the road to the north. You've got all that multi... I mean, I want to be proactive about this, and I... I just... [2:08:54] Okay, Grayson. I mean, Spencer, sorry. [2:08:59] Too many sons. Too many sons. [2:09:03] Thanks, Mayor. Well, in light of recent votes of mine, I hope people don't already roll their eyes. [2:09:08] think they know where I'm going with this, but it does concern me, you know, the default [2:09:15] is that a drive-through and the extended hours is not allowed. It's a special use permit, so [2:09:19] they're asking special permission to do something that's not currently allowed. And, you know, [2:09:26] the fact that drive-throughs are typically a special use permit is a task acknowledgement [2:09:30] that they do have higher traffic counts than other commercial businesses or professional offices. [2:09:35] And I think of how close that approach is, it reminds me somewhat of a gas station that [2:09:41] you would find among the name of the business, but a gas station over it falls and blue lakes. [2:09:47] And I think that's just poor planning when we're creating those situations. [2:09:51] I don't want to be accused of nimbi-ism. [2:09:54] There is a right way to do things. [2:09:56] On the north side of Addison, there is a drive-through permitted outright it sounds like, [2:10:01] but it's several hundred feet from the intersection. [2:10:03] It definitely creates a different type of a situation that just seems like smart planning, [2:10:09] and then there's a lot about the harmony of the neighborhood and things like that. [2:10:15] Despite all the commercial properties there, none of them have the, to my knowledge, have [2:10:21] the extended hours. [2:10:23] There might be one or two exceptions, but you know, by and large. [2:10:27] In fact, I think it's safe to say the majority close it at typical business hours. [2:10:33] they don't even stay open oftentimes in the evening hours. [2:10:35] So it really is a change to what's already been established [2:10:38] there. [2:10:39] And it would also be different if this was maybe 20% built out, [2:10:43] but this side of the streets mostly built out already. [2:10:45] So I just don't see the logic in granting special permission [2:10:51] to extend what's permitted there. [2:10:55] Thank you. [2:10:56] Thank you, Spencer. [2:11:01] Anybody else? [2:11:03] Jason? [2:11:10] I always have something to say. [2:11:13] I do want to thank Taco Bell for coming in. [2:11:16] We appreciate your business currently, up by the mall, [2:11:21] as Grace was talking about changing the pattern of the drive [2:11:25] through. [2:11:26] And just so you know, I frequent Taco Bell. [2:11:29] I think I've been to all of yours in Idaho. [2:11:31] I'm not proud to say that. [2:11:32] But it would be the same as the Burley Taco Bell [2:11:35] that you were talking about and that flow. [2:11:39] So thank you. [2:11:40] We do appreciate it. [2:11:42] I do have the same concerns that have been brought up. [2:11:46] Interference with traffic and the surrounding thoroughfares, [2:11:50] the extended hours where we put right up to residential property, [2:11:57] that is also a concern. [2:12:00] So for those reasons, I'll be voting no. [2:12:03] Thank you. [2:12:07] Anybody else have any comments, Jason? [2:12:13] You know, the only thing that I'm considering or looking [2:12:16] at and trying to figure out, I think everybody [2:12:18] is considered valid points, trying to look through this [2:12:24] and figure out what we have going here. [2:12:30] I think I appreciate the recommendations from the P&Z. [2:12:38] I just don't see how I could extend it beyond a midnight [2:12:42] operation hour if it were to go through. [2:12:46] And so that's probably the biggest hang up for me [2:12:50] is the hours of operation at this point. [2:12:54] But I would support a midnight closure. [2:12:59] Thank you. [2:13:01] Jerry, do you want to go ahead? [2:13:02] Yeah, like most people have said here, it'd be great to have. [2:13:10] I'm over on that side of town as well, not in that particular area. [2:13:14] But it would be great to have other food options, [2:13:17] like somebody had mentioned at one time. [2:13:20] And I think Taco Bell is small enough [2:13:22] that it could work somewhere out there. [2:13:25] I'm really concerned about on the corner with the stacking. [2:13:30] I am concerned about that. [2:13:34] I've been through that intersection quite often. [2:13:36] So that does concern me. [2:13:38] And I would hope that our, and I don't hope, [2:13:42] I know that our P and Z staff and police department [2:13:47] or whatever would look at the safety aspects of that. [2:13:52] I'm not sure that I'm really, I'm not a fan of the stacking. [2:14:00] To me, there's not enough. [2:14:05] Grayson, did you have another comment? [2:14:08] Yes, Madam Mayor. [2:14:08] I just want to point out too, I wrote a note here. [2:14:12] In the staff report, it did indicate [2:14:14] that staff even had identified as a potential negative impact [2:14:18] on the area. [2:14:22] Thank you. [2:14:23] Chris, you're still up. [2:14:24] Did you have some? [2:14:25] I'll make the motion for ready, and I'm going to make it in the positive to appeal, so everybody knows that. [2:14:32] So what you're doing to that design, yes, you need to make this in the positive to approve it, just like you would be approving it. [2:14:42] And then your vote is for sure, either you're approving it or you're not approving it. [2:14:46] And that's the original application, not the appeal. [2:14:49] Do you basically use the emotion to approve the special use permit? [2:14:54] I know that's okay. [2:14:55] We're not worried about the appeals. [2:14:57] We're not worried about the appeal. [2:14:58] It's like you're brand new. [2:14:59] I know that we have to put that up there, but your real and real is to a motion to approve [2:15:04] in whatever conditions I would if I could get a little bit more information. [2:15:09] If there were, just so we're very clear on the record, get the information. [2:15:14] If there is discussion on a number, I hear the stacking number, if there's a number that [2:15:19] you would rather see that if they had that, something along those lines of you want 10, [2:15:25] you want 15, you want 100, whatever that might be, or a different plan, you can, I'm [2:15:30] not saying not to change any decisions, just say, hey, there's not enough, we think for [2:15:35] this type of business you need 12, whatever you want that in the motion, no, you want [2:15:41] and that just got just more on the record that you've wrestled with this idea. [2:15:46] So just for commentary for me because I was one that initially brought it up, [2:15:49] especially earlier during the applicants presentation, so I'll answer that immediately. [2:15:53] So coming off carriage, if there was a way that could flow down through carriage, [2:15:57] all the lights are facing towards Addison and then all the stacking could technically [2:16:01] be off of Addison and be in that lower south corner and go up. That makes sense. [2:16:08] So it would come down carriage and then rotate up in a reverse L, more or less, and then kick [2:16:16] bad out on to Addison and go east. [2:16:22] That's my thought process. [2:16:24] Turn right. [2:16:25] Right. [2:16:26] Yep. [2:16:27] So you'd come right down carriage, go in, get your food, and go back out. [2:16:32] That was my issue with the stacking. [2:16:35] The entrance exit. [2:16:38] So it would be a left in and a right out. [2:16:41] So do you believe that you would get more stacking [2:16:47] in that configuration than what would be? [2:16:51] So I'm not an engineer, but I think [2:16:52] it would provide more room for them [2:16:54] to have a drive-through on the right side [2:16:56] than it would the left side. [2:16:57] And that's based upon a professional capacity, [2:16:59] and I would be- [2:17:00] It would all be predicated. [2:17:02] That would be predicated on the reader board [2:17:04] as the code reads. [2:17:05] So pull the site plan back up, [2:17:06] and I could probably articulate this better. [2:17:08] I don't, can I just jump in real quick? [2:17:10] I don't know if I'm prepared today to say 10, 15, 20. [2:17:15] Yeah, I'm not giving a number. [2:17:16] I just, right now, I know that what the code says. [2:17:19] We're not engineers. [2:17:21] Correct, but I'm having this discussion going. [2:17:23] We just need, bye's not enough, we know that. [2:17:26] Okay. [2:17:27] We need more. [2:17:28] Perfect. [2:17:29] I think that's something as a city we need to look at. [2:17:30] I think we're not that fine. [2:17:32] I don't think it's, I don't think the answer's five's not enough. [2:17:34] I think it's, if it's over five, [2:17:36] and then you're back on the Addison, you're backed up. [2:17:38] Yeah. [2:17:39] when we're right in the minutes we're right in this decision we have to write [2:17:42] why [2:17:42] no I get it [2:17:46] okay so in order to make them up so crazy I'm just saying I want to clarify [2:17:50] what Jonathan said if there's any conditions or anything associated with [2:17:54] those on there or if it's just a blanket right that's just a special [2:17:58] use permit as presented yeah we have I mean the other stuff from the P&Z you [2:18:02] could still reference that if you wished to say we prove as presented [2:18:08] I'll just the same position. [2:18:11] Move to approve the special use permit, PZ24-0076, to allow a drive-thruick with extended retail [2:18:18] hours of operation on property located at 2616 Addison Avenue East as presented. [2:18:26] Thank you, Grayson Stone. [2:18:28] Thank you motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the special use permit [2:18:34] PZ24-006 as presented. Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please? [2:18:46] Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer Cutler? No. Grayson Stone? No. Jerry Vollmer? No. Ruth Pierce? No. [2:18:59] No. [2:19:00] Chris Reed. [2:19:01] No. [2:19:02] And Craig Hocken. [2:19:06] Okay. [2:19:07] Motion fails. [2:19:08] One yes. [2:19:09] Five no and one abstention. [2:19:21] Anything. [2:19:22] Any other direction you have for us before we adjourn the meeting. [2:19:30] Okay. [2:19:31] Thank you, everybody. [2:19:33] Thank you to both sides for being here tonight. [2:19:35] We really appreciate your input and I appreciate everybody being cordial. [2:19:43] and respecting that it was a tough decision. [2:19:45] So thank you. [2:19:48] Meetings adjourned.