Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-02-05, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-02-05/ [0:01:52] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the February 5th, 2024 City Council meeting. [0:01:59] I want to confirm we have a quorum. All seven members are present in chambers tonight. [0:02:05] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:02:10] Okay, we have no proclamations tonight. So first the consent calendar. [0:02:35] Council wishes Craig Hawkins mayor would like to move that we accept the [0:02:40] calendar is written thank you do I have a second I'll second thank you motion by [0:02:45] Craig Hawkins second by Sherry Vomer to approve the consent calendar as written [0:02:51] Amy Rokalvo please appears yes yes yes yes yes yes Jason Brown yes [0:03:00] Spencer Cutler, Grayson Stone, it's very Vomar. [0:03:05] Thank you, motion passes seven to zero. [0:03:09] So if you were here for the special event for St. Patrick's [0:03:12] Day Festival or for the Trick or Treat on Main, [0:03:16] those have both been approved. [0:03:18] So under items of consideration, the first item [0:03:22] is an action item. [0:03:23] It's a request that City Council approve the special event [0:03:27] permit for the organizers to show [0:03:29] Shawn falls after dark event and we have Wendy Davis and Chief Kingsbury I believe that we'll be presenting. Come on up, Wendy. [0:03:43] Good evening, Mayor and Council. I wanted to preface this request with just a little bit of kind of background on the processes that are involved in this kind of an event. [0:03:53] The special event process is what we're discussing tonight and that's the request that's before [0:03:59] you. [0:04:00] That is basically housed in the police department and there's certain qualifications that make [0:04:08] an event a special event. [0:04:11] The other piece of doing an event in public spaces, especially in the parks, is the park [0:04:16] use permit. [0:04:17] And that falls under the jurisdiction of the Parks and Recreation Department. [0:04:21] And so there's been some questions and some concerns about a few things. [0:04:26] So as we talk about the special event piece, I wanted to just let you know what we're doing [0:04:32] as part of the park permitting process. [0:04:34] I've met with these ladies. [0:04:36] We've talked about past concerns and some of the things that we wanted to do a little [0:04:39] bit differently this year. [0:04:42] And so in the park use permit, which comes through the director, I have talked to Bruce [0:04:49] about this. Last year we added some different language in the permit that [0:04:53] required increased insurance to cover loss of life since they are using the [0:05:01] facility after dark. It's not really designed to be an after dark facility so [0:05:06] we've had them have a higher level of insurance in the past. We will take care [0:05:10] of that through the lease agreement that we're drafting and also I met with them [0:05:15] we discussed the fees. And so as you may have seen in the staff report, but I [0:05:22] wanted to just mention again that they have agreed to designate 5% of their [0:05:28] gross revenue from the event as part of the use of a public space for private [0:05:36] gain. And so that piece of code that prohibits this kind of an event in a space [0:05:42] like this, we'll do a lease to handle it and then we will include that fee piece as part [0:05:48] of the lease. So if that makes sense and if you don't have any questions about that, I'll [0:05:55] turn the event piece over to the chief to talk about the Shoshan Falls Afterdari. And [0:06:02] I'll be right there if you have any questions. [0:06:07] Thank you, Wendy. Mayor Council, thank you. Yes, this is a request for the City Council [0:06:15] to approve the special event application for the Shoshone Falls after dark event. [0:06:21] This year will be the fourth year, if it is allowed, that this event will take place. [0:06:25] This is Shoshone Falls Park. [0:06:28] The event is scheduled to run every weekend in May, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday [0:06:35] during those weekends. [0:06:37] Now, as a refresher, a couple of things that make this necessitate a special event permit [0:06:45] under our city code, our city ordinance, number one, [0:06:49] they're expecting more than 500 people. [0:06:51] So any event that expects more than 500 people [0:06:55] does require a special event permit. [0:06:58] Number two, amplified sound and or noise. [0:07:03] As a reminder, this particular event [0:07:05] will be playing amplified music set to a laser light show. [0:07:10] Therefore that is the amplified sound or noise [0:07:13] takes place. Those two items, another one would be user sale of alcohol, which is not taking [0:07:20] place at this particular event. But those first two items are what would necessitate the special [0:07:27] event of this particular approval from City Council. Now, if you don't have any questions [0:07:34] for me, I would like to turn it over to Sarah Rorabak. [0:07:38] Thank you all for allowing me to ask for permission for this event. [0:07:52] As he stated, we've done Shoshone Falls after dark for three years now. [0:07:56] We are a nonprofit organization and this is our way to be able to get some funding to our [0:08:01] organization and continue to help with our mission. [0:08:05] So our event essentially is that we put up a bunch of lights and we have Shoshone Falls [0:08:10] glow after dark. [0:08:12] This does go to the beat of the music. [0:08:15] The sound is amplified as they stated, so everyone can hear it over the roaring waterfall. [0:08:20] And yeah, we plan to do the weekends in May to hopefully optimize the water flows and still [0:08:27] have the show so it doesn't go until midnight because of the light in the summer. [0:08:31] We would love to offer the City of Twin Falls 5% of our total sales just as a thank you for [0:08:38] allowing us to continue to use the park. [0:08:40] Of course, having that many people down there does cause depreciation of the park and the [0:08:46] road. [0:08:47] So we just want to say thank you so much for allowing us to have this event previously. [0:08:52] And if you do accept, we would love to offer 5% of our total sales. [0:08:57] Does anyone have any questions for me? [0:09:00] Any questions for Sarah? [0:09:03] I know in the past we've had some complaints about sound. [0:09:06] is this and I'm sure you already said that but the folks who live across Shoshone Falls [0:09:12] in Jerome County have expressed some concerns in the past and I wonder if you can just address [0:09:17] that. Yeah absolutely we would love to get the contact information from anyone who does feel [0:09:23] like the sound is too much and they would like to be warned. There will be a few nights that [0:09:27] we are testing the sound out before the show. This wouldn't go past 10 30th and then the show [0:09:33] itself will not go past 11 just like last year's as well but if anyone does want us [0:09:39] to contact them before the noise starts happening we would be happy to we can [0:09:44] also turn it down if they want to call us and let us know that it's way too loud [0:09:48] especially during our run-throughs we are happy to crank that down just to make [0:09:52] sure everyone can sleep and we would love to give them a warning before the [0:09:56] show as well just to be courteous to our neighbors. [0:10:00] Yeah, I guess it's more of a question for city staff. [0:10:04] Are we allowed to accept the 5% in lieu of the permit? [0:10:07] If we approve the permit, are we allowed to accept the 5%? [0:10:12] You are. [0:10:13] I'll turn it over to Bruce if I miss Steph here. [0:10:16] But because you're leasing the facility, it's like a concessionaire's license and we have [0:10:21] several of those throughout the city. [0:10:24] An example would be any of the concession stands that we have, say, out at Sunwaysocke Field. [0:10:29] is a portion of the profit that is provided to the city for the right to utilize our facility [0:10:34] for a for-profit or for a nonprofit venture. [0:10:37] Tommy, thanks. [0:10:39] So Grace, and just to give you a little bit of background, in the past we have discussed [0:10:43] wear and tear on the park and us not receiving any remuneration for the damage or the wear [0:10:51] and tear. [0:10:52] And so we directed staff last year to come up with something that would fix that. [0:10:57] So this looks like it's an example. [0:11:00] Sarah, I just want to reiterate this noise thing. [0:11:02] I've been the recipient from the same person several times [0:11:07] in the last four years, and it's really frustrating. [0:11:14] And so whatever you can do, I chief hazard number, [0:11:17] I have her number, but I mean, I get calls at midnight [0:11:20] and 11 o'clock with complaints. [0:11:23] So we really, really need to pay attention [0:11:25] to this noise issue. [0:11:28] Yeah, absolutely. [0:11:29] Yep. [0:11:30] Yes, Chief. [0:11:34] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:11:35] And as a reminder, one of the caveats [0:11:39] that will be included in the special event permit [0:11:42] is that the City of Twin Falls Police Department's [0:11:45] SHIFT Commander during the events [0:11:47] has the authority to shut down these events [0:11:51] if we get noise complaints that they're not dealt with. [0:11:54] So that is part of it, Mayor, as a reminder [0:11:57] that the police department can shut down this event [0:12:01] if we do get these noise complaints. [0:12:03] And we don't have to include that in our motion. [0:12:05] It's automatically correct. [0:12:07] It is in the staff report and in the permit. [0:12:10] Thank you. Thank you. [0:12:12] Any other questions for Sarah? [0:12:15] I would entertain a motion. [0:12:17] I want to make sure we make this approval contingent [0:12:22] upon the lease agreement being drafted and signed [0:12:25] and agreed on by all parties. [0:12:28] though. Chris Reed. [0:12:30] Before I make the motion, I just want to thank everybody that's been involved. [0:12:33] I know this has been an ongoing conversation for the last four years. [0:12:36] So thank you to everybody that's brought this together. [0:12:40] So I move that we approve the special event permit for the organization. [0:12:46] The organizer of this is shown falls after dark event contingent on the lease agreement. [0:12:53] Thank you. [0:12:54] Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grace and Stone to approve the special event permit for the Shoshone Falls after dark event contingent on the lease agreement. [0:13:08] He finalized any further discussion? [0:13:12] Amy roll call vote please. [0:13:14] Thank you. Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. [0:13:20] Grayson Stone. Yes. Gary Bomer. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you everyone. [0:13:30] Okay. Next on the agenda are the we get to the fun stuff, right Chief? [0:13:35] The first one is a presentation, a request to swear in three new Twin Falls Police Department [0:13:42] officers, Nicholas Fernandez, Jacob Kennedy, and Andy Taylor, and introduce the police [0:13:48] department's new additions to the record. It's records department, Bella Gregory, and [0:13:53] we have Chief Kingsbury. Again, thank you, Mayor and Council, and absolutely, this is [0:13:58] the fun stuff. This is the stuff that I love to do, and I want to thank you, Mayor and [0:14:03] members of the Council for allowing us to bring our employees before you. Not only are we [0:14:10] going to swear in three officers to introduce a new officer. We're also going to publicly [0:14:15] award four of officers that have received different levels of post certifications as [0:14:20] well as introduce you to one of our newest members of the police department, Baloo. So [0:14:25] we have the next reaction items are all all TFPD and we're very excited and I appreciate [0:14:30] the opportunity to do that. So if I could have officers for NANDAS, Kennedy and Taylor and [0:14:36] Ms. Gregory, come down and stand to my left place. [0:14:58] So Mayor, Council, you have heard from me [0:15:03] every time we have this opportunity [0:15:05] about what an honor it is to present [0:15:08] these fine men and women to you and to our community [0:15:11] as a whole. [0:15:13] Tonight, we have four individuals [0:15:17] who have chosen a career of service [0:15:20] and a career of service that sometimes is not always easy. [0:15:25] And we have several of their family members behind us in the audience to also embark on that career of service. [0:15:33] That service in public safety is specifically law enforcement. [0:15:38] You see these three men standing to my left wearing the uniform of the Twin Falls Police Department similar to what I am wearing. [0:15:46] You also see Ms. Bela Gregory standing to my left directly in civilian clothes. [0:15:52] Ms. Gregory has taken a job in our records department, where she will work alongside one of the finest team of records custodians that I've ever seen in my 34 and a half years of law enforcement. [0:16:05] We have a wonderful team. If I could just give a little shout out to that records team. Last week the auto state police was in town. [0:16:12] They met with our records supervisor, Tandy Reynolds, and her team to do their audit. [0:16:18] Then they called to speak with me. They wanted me to come down and meet with them. [0:16:23] I will tell you that when you get a call that the state police wants to talk to you about the audit, [0:16:28] as a chief, you kind of wonder, uh-oh. But I knew better than that because I knew this team. [0:16:35] And they were gushing over how well our team did. The audit was perfect. [0:16:41] Not a single piece of paper out of place. [0:16:44] Our security was exactly what is expected from the Idaho State Police and subsequently [0:16:50] from the Federal Bureau of Investigation on how we store and keep all of our criminal records. [0:16:56] That's the team that Ms. Gregory is joining us to become a part of. [0:17:02] As you notice, as you look at the uniform that I wear, these three gentlemen and many members [0:17:07] out in the audience are wearing today. [0:17:10] You notice some symbolism that goes with that uniform. [0:17:14] The first one is our patch that we wear on our shoulders. [0:17:18] This patch are something very similar to this patch for the City of Twin Falls Police [0:17:22] Department has graced the uniforms of the TFPD members for decades, decades and decades. [0:17:32] Our symbol showing the Twin Falls, which you see throughout the city as our city seal, [0:17:38] if you will, is something that for us at the police department represents all the men and [0:17:44] women who have gone before us and served this community admirably, have chosen this career [0:17:51] in law enforcement. [0:17:53] Another piece on our uniform, which is a pretty important piece, is the badge. [0:18:01] The badge it is worn above our left breast pocket. [0:18:06] badge that we will be pinning on these three gentlemen with the help of their [0:18:09] family members shortly. That badge is a symbol of law enforcement. That badge is [0:18:17] a symbol of our code of ethics demanding the best men and women that choose this [0:18:22] career and live up to that symbolism throughout the next 20 or 30 years as [0:18:28] they go through their career protecting and serving this very great community. I [0:18:32] I often talk to our college's southern Idaho law enforcement class of which two of these [0:18:39] gentlemen are attending. [0:18:40] We have several of the members out here with their director, Mr. Robert Roush. [0:18:45] And I talk about how even though badges may be different sizes and shapes, some agencies [0:18:52] wear stars, some wear shields. [0:18:54] There's all kinds of different police badges out there. [0:18:57] But if you think about when you're traveling this great country of ours, if you need help, [0:19:02] you look for a badge. It doesn't matter if the badge is a star or a shield or in [0:19:09] some cases the shape of the state of Louisiana like there's state police [0:19:13] lawyers. But you look for that badge and that's a symbol that means help is [0:19:18] arrived. We have several uniforms behind us that are not to [0:19:21] and falls police apartment tonight and those you that badge and all of these [0:19:25] uniforms that's that same symbolism. However mayor council members of this [0:19:31] community. Probably the most important piece that we wear on our uniform is our [0:19:37] nameplate. Our nameplate above our right breast pocket bearing our last name, our [0:19:45] family name. And you might ask, well why is that the most important? Because when [0:19:51] you go out and you're representing this great organization and this great [0:19:54] profession, I always remind officers and other employees representing their [0:20:00] family, representing that family name, and every once in a while, throughout our country, [0:20:07] peace officers stumble, and when that happens, those three things all get thrown into the, [0:20:15] you know, into the news, not only the name of the agency, the fact that they're a law [0:20:21] enforcement professional, but also their family name. [0:20:25] So as we embark upon swearing in these regenement tonight and recognizing these employees and [0:20:30] others this evening. I remind everybody to wear this uniform with pride and to go [0:20:37] about protecting and serving with our mission and the values of this city so [0:20:42] espouses so that we can do this and uphold our code of ethics each and every [0:20:48] day. Now Mary I'm going to take a second to introduce them read their bios. [0:20:53] Immediately to my left as I mentioned is Isabelle Gregory. She was hired by the [0:20:57] Twin Falls Police Department on November 6, 2023 as our records clerk. [0:21:02] She was born and raised right in Jerome Idaho and graduated from Jerome High School in 2020. [0:21:08] Isabelle supported her team and leaders in her advanced drama team and choir during her [0:21:13] years of high school. [0:21:15] Prior to joining the Twin Falls Police Department, she worked as a circulation technician at the [0:21:20] Jerome Public Library in Jerome. [0:21:23] She attended the College of Southern Idaho and graduated with a associate's degree in [0:21:27] visual arts. [0:21:29] She lives here with her family, her husband, new husband, and cat. [0:21:35] She loves to do art, read, and craft. [0:21:38] Her life experience and upbringing have taught her to value those that work for the community [0:21:42] and to contribute where she can help others. [0:21:45] Isabel, if you would take a second to introduce your family members that are here with us [0:21:50] today. [0:21:52] here today is my husband, Allen, he's very fair. Unfortunately, the rest of my family couldn't [0:21:59] make it, but thank you. Thank you and welcome, Allen. Thanks for being here. Okay, I'm my [0:22:08] LePrense who's next. We got Nick Hernandez. All right, Nicholas Hernandez was hired by the [0:22:15] Twin Falls Police Department on November 20th, 2023 as a police officer. Officer Hernandez [0:22:21] was born and raised in Indianapolis, Indiana. He graduated from Runcali High School in 2012. [0:22:28] Officer Hernandez accelerated as a team member and leadership skills on Barstee Hockey Team. [0:22:33] Prior to his employment with us, he was a police officer for the City of San Diego, California [0:22:38] for three and a half years. [0:22:40] Officer Hernandez attended Holy Cross College and graduated with a bachelor's degree in psychology. [0:22:45] He then moved to Twin Falls in October of 23 as he took this job. [0:22:50] He is here with his wife and three daughters and his son who was born just last December. [0:22:54] I think we'd like to come here and introduce what you have with you. [0:23:01] Good evening. Up top is my wife, my three daughters, my newborn son, my mom, my stepdad, [0:23:11] my mother-in-law, and then my father-in-law and that mom. Thank you. Next, Andy Taylor. Andy's on [0:23:26] the end there, okay. Andy was hired by the TFPD on December 4, 2023 as a police officer recruit. [0:23:32] He was born in Chesapeake, Virginia and raised in Tonopah, Nevada. [0:23:38] He moved to Dayton, Nevada in 2018, where he graduated from Dayton High School. [0:23:43] Prior to his employment with TFPD, he worked at Empire Cat in Round Mountain, Nevada, as [0:23:48] a warehouse associate in Parks League. [0:23:51] He's passionate about serving his community of Twin Falls in a law enforcement role. [0:23:56] Law enforcement has always been a dream of Andes. [0:23:59] He was a police explorer cadet with a nine county sheriff's office for approximately five [0:24:03] years. [0:24:04] Those experiences have taught him that serving others is what he has always wanted to do. [0:24:08] So Andy, if you'll come here and introduce your family members. [0:24:14] Good evening. [0:24:15] I have my dad and my mom and my girlfriend who I've been with for four and a half years [0:24:21] now and then her grandparents right next door. [0:24:24] Welcome. [0:24:31] And then in the middle we have Jacob Kennedy. [0:24:37] Jacob was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on November 20, 23 as a police officer recruit. [0:24:42] He was born in Mission, VA, they hold it. [0:24:46] Mission, VA, Ohio, California. [0:24:49] But he was raised in Huntington Beach, California and graduated from Edison High School. [0:24:54] He celebrated as a team member in leadership skills on the cross country and track and field varsity teams. [0:25:00] Prior to employment with the TFPD, Jacob wanted to help and serve his country in the Coast Guard. [0:25:06] He's passionate about serving his community and law enforcement role. [0:25:09] Jacob's life experiences have taught him that serving others is where he wants to focus [0:25:13] his energy. [0:25:14] Jacob? [0:25:15] Introduce your family. [0:25:18] Good afternoon. [0:25:20] Right here in the third row, I got my dad, my mom, my brother, and then behind them. [0:25:28] I also have some family friends as well. [0:25:37] Thank you, Jacob. [0:25:38] I think it's kind of cool to see some legacy of service that is obviously out there in our [0:25:42] audience. [0:25:43] want to thank all the family members for being here tonight. [0:25:46] So now, what we will do next, Mayor, [0:25:49] if you will come down to swear these three gentlemen in. [0:25:53] Belo, have you kind of just moved over that way a little bit? [0:25:57] Gentlemen, if you'll come over here. [0:25:59] So what'll happen is the mayor's coming down. [0:26:01] Oh, that's blue. [0:26:03] You'll get your turn, Belo. [0:26:05] As the mayor is coming down here to swear you in, [0:26:09] when she reads the oath, and when she's done, [0:26:11] You'll have to sign two copies of the oath of office. [0:26:15] The reason you sign two copies is one goes permanently [0:26:17] in your file, and the other one we will keep for one year, [0:26:20] and when you receive your one-year anniversary, [0:26:22] we'll present that to you framed so that you can hang it up [0:26:25] at home to remind you that oath that you take here tonight. [0:26:28] OK, so if you gentlemen want to kind of spread out this way [0:26:30] a little bit. [0:29:28] So now what we will do is we will have the badge painting [0:29:33] ceremony, and then just sure what we're going to do, [0:29:37] After we get these three gentlemen, their badges pinned, [0:29:41] then we'll introduce the four officers [0:29:43] getting certificates in Officer Shropshire in Boulou. [0:29:47] When that's all done, we'll have y'all come down [0:29:49] and shake their hands. [0:29:50] Is that work, Mayor? [0:29:50] Yes, perfect. [0:29:51] Thank you. [0:29:52] OK, so we'll start off to pin Officer Nicholas Hernandez. [0:29:58] We have his wife, Hayden. [0:30:09] That's OK. [0:30:42] And for Officer Kennedy, we have James, his father coming. [0:31:22] Mary would now be an inappropriate time to let James know that we are still hiring and [0:31:26] have openings. [0:31:27] Lateral transfer bonuses. [0:31:28] I don't know. [0:31:29] It's inappropriate. [0:31:30] In fact, do you have an application on you? [0:31:32] Oh, yes. [0:31:33] Yeah. [0:31:34] Easy peasy. [0:31:35] Okay. [0:31:36] And now for Officer Taylor, his father, Brian, okay, gentlemen, I'll have you kind of scoot [0:32:23] that way a little bit and, Mary, with your permission, I'll just move on to the next item [0:32:29] on the agenda. [0:32:30] Absolutely. [0:32:31] Okay. [0:32:32] I would, I'm going to turn this over to Lieutenant Chuck Garner. [0:32:51] Madam Mayor, members of the council, [0:32:54] thank you for giving this opportunity [0:32:55] to formally recognize some significant career [0:32:58] achievements for four of our officers tonight. [0:33:00] I'd like to have Officer Daniel Clifford, [0:33:02] Officer Medina, Alabegovitch, [0:33:05] Corporal Candice Orr, and Detective Morgan Wade come down. [0:33:22] And those have been a while since we've done this [0:33:24] in front of council. [0:33:25] I know we have two new council members [0:33:26] that haven't witnessed us awarding post-certification, [0:33:32] so a quick primer for what you're about to see. [0:33:35] In the state of Idaho, peace officers [0:33:37] are required to be licensed and certified. [0:33:40] And there are six, seven different levels [0:33:44] of certification that officers can [0:33:46] and earn basic, intermediate, advanced, [0:33:50] supervisory, master management, and executive certificates. [0:33:54] Each certificate is earned based on the scale of [0:33:58] use of service, training hours, [0:34:01] and a combination of college education. [0:34:05] So, these four officers tonight have had to work pretty hard [0:34:09] to receive these certificates. [0:34:13] Officer Daniel Clifford was hired by the [0:34:15] Twin Falls Police Department on June 20th, 2016. [0:34:20] He was born in Idol Falls and raised in Rigby. [0:34:22] After graduating from Rigby High School, [0:34:24] He served a two-year church mission in Southern California, followed by five years of service [0:34:29] in the United States Navy. [0:34:32] Officer Clifford is married and has one child. [0:34:35] He attended the Idaho Peace Officers Standards and Training Basic Patrol Academy Session 187. [0:34:41] Currently holds the post basic certification and has received 902 post training hours, [0:34:47] and he will be receiving his intermediate certificate tonight. [0:34:57] Dr. Medina Alabegavitch was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 19, 2014. [0:35:03] She is married and has three children. [0:35:06] Medina is a graduate of Canyon Ridge High School in the College of Southern Idaho Law Enforcement [0:35:11] Training Program, which she entered with the express goal of completing the program and [0:35:16] being hired by the Twin Falls Police Department. [0:35:20] Officer Alabegavitch, who is also cross-trained as an emergency communications officer, currently [0:35:26] serves in the patrol division. [0:35:28] She holds the post-basic and intermediate certifications and has received 1,018 post-training hours, [0:35:35] and she will be receiving the advanced certificate tonight. [0:35:41] Corporal Candice Orr, who will also be receiving the advanced certificate, was hired by the [0:35:45] Twin Falls Police Department on June 13, 2016. [0:35:49] She was born and raised in Linnamucka, Nevada, and moved to Twin Falls in 2012. [0:35:54] She is married with one child and with her permission, I'm allowed to say, another on [0:35:58] the way. [0:36:01] Corporal Orr graduated from the College of Southern Idaho with an Associate Degree in Criminal Justice [0:36:05] in 2014 and later attended CSI's Law Enforcement Training Academy. During her time at the Twin [0:36:11] Falls Police Department, she has been a field training officer, a Taser instructor, also [0:36:17] cross-trained as an emergency communications officer, and a member of our Honor Guard. She [0:36:23] holds the post-basic and intermediate certifications and has received 1,077 training hours. [0:36:30] Detective Morgan Waite will be receiving the post-master certificate tonight. [0:36:36] This is a big deal. Very few of our officers obtained this certification. [0:36:45] There's probably four or five currently with the police department that have been able [0:36:51] in combination with service, training hours, civilian education reached this goal. [0:36:57] So this is pretty cool. [0:36:58] Techton Morgan Wake was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on October 7, 2013. [0:37:04] He was born in Burleigh, Idaho, 10th of 11 children. [0:37:09] He was raised in Haberne and graduated from medical high school. [0:37:13] After high school, he served a two-year church mission in Bulgaria. [0:37:17] After returning from his mission, Officer Morgan Wake attended the College of Southern Idaho [0:37:25] before moving to Pace in Utah, where he worked part-time in the Utah County Jail as a civilian control board operator. [0:37:31] operator. He proceeded further educational opportunities by attending Utah Valley University [0:37:37] in the College of Southern Nevada. Prior to being hired by our department, Detective Weight worked as [0:37:43] a patrol officer with the North Las Vegas Police Department for approximately five years. [0:37:48] He and his wife chose to come back to Idaho to be near their families to raise their six children [0:37:53] in a smaller community and to escape 130 degree July patrols. Detective Weight served [0:38:02] to the patrol division, served as a field training officer, a school resource officer, [0:38:07] and is currently an investigator in our criminal investigations division. [0:38:11] He's also a member of the hazardous device unit, our bomb squad. [0:38:16] Detective Wake holds Idaho Post basic intermediate and advanced certificates [0:38:21] and is received 1,905 post training hours. [0:39:17] And so they don't get off. [0:39:18] Scott free I'm gonna have them introduce anyone they have in the audience tonight [0:39:22] and if they don't have anyone in the audience I still want them to come up to [0:39:25] the mic to tell you right you're on the spot my wife Justine and my son [0:39:32] Bridger right here today I just have my work family all right my husband and [0:39:46] my daughter Remy husband Ryan my wife is at home with our six kids are my [0:39:56] five boys we call in the war department and it's just not polite to [0:39:59] bring him these sacred chambers. Got it. Thank you. Thank you for sparing us. Nice job [0:40:09] officers. Okay mayor with your permission. Move on to the next item on this agenda. I'm [0:40:17] really excited about this. We're going to introduce you and this community to one of [0:40:21] our newest members of the police department and also get a little update on what's happening [0:40:26] with our canine unit. So with that I'm going to turn this over to officer Brad beige. Welcome [0:40:41] Brad. [0:40:42] Good evening. [0:40:43] Madam Mayor, members of council. [0:40:44] I have a couple things tonight. [0:40:50] The big thing is we're going to introduce you to Blue and Tyler Shroffshire and present [0:40:53] him with a certificate. [0:40:56] Before we do that, we have two dogs here for you tonight. [0:41:04] Back in January of 2022, I stood here and I asked you for funding to send me to an instructor [0:41:10] school to train police dogs. [0:41:14] You approved that, and I attended a 500-hour, 12-week basic handler course in Tuscaloosa, [0:41:18] Alabama, at the Alabama Law Enforcement Training Center. [0:41:23] These are a product of that decision. [0:41:26] I came back and obtained a high liability canine instructor certificate through the Idaho [0:41:32] Post Academy, and I put on our first basic handler course in the City of Twin Falls, which [0:41:38] was attended by Josh Rivers and his dog, Ringo. [0:41:42] graduated that class and have been working the street as a detection K-9 team for about [0:41:48] a year now. In December of last year, Officer Tyler Shropshire was selected as our newest [0:41:55] K-9 handler for the department. Him and his dog are going to replace Brock, who recently [0:42:01] retired last summer. Tyler and I got to go down to Alabama to the kennel where I obtained [0:42:07] training and where we get our dogs and we had the ability to go down there and work with [0:42:12] blue while we were down there and bring him back. [0:42:16] When we got back, Tyler was put through a 180-hour basic handler course here in Twin Falls, [0:42:22] top by me. [0:42:24] While we were down in Alabama, I had the opportunity to put about eight different dogs through selection [0:42:29] testing and we picked one to replace my dog Enzo, who's going to retire this spring. [0:42:37] That dog is a 14-month-old Belgian Malinois named Hugo. [0:42:41] will be here sometime this spring to start his training. [0:42:47] So from December 10th to January 12th, [0:42:49] he can, Tyler Shropshire in Blue, completed a 180-hour basic canine [0:42:53] handler course. [0:42:54] They received training and tracking, [0:42:57] formal obedience, evidence searches, and narcotics detection. [0:43:01] And this team is kind of unique to our city. [0:43:05] In years past, we have never had a single-purpose detection [0:43:08] team, and what that means is they are only trained [0:43:10] to locate narcotics. [0:43:12] They're not trained to bite or apprehend any violent criminals. [0:43:16] This is the first team that we've trained to track people [0:43:20] that is not also trained to bite. [0:43:21] And the idea behind that is our capabilities to track [0:43:25] missing children, vulnerable adults, people that walk away [0:43:28] from somewhere and are unable to be found. [0:43:32] We also can use this dog to track less violent crimes [0:43:35] in the city of Twin Falls. [0:43:37] So this team is kind of the pioneer [0:43:39] on tracking non-violent people. [0:43:42] is a huge asset to our department. [0:43:45] On January 12th, Tyler Shropshire and Belu graduated their basic Canine Handler course here [0:43:50] in the City of Twin Falls and so I am here tonight to present a certificate to Tyler for [0:43:55] the completion of that 180 hour course which is a long time to be hanging out with me. [0:44:02] I can tell you that. [0:44:03] So I'm going to present him with his certificate and this is Belu. [0:44:08] as a two-year-old German Shepherd and he was born in Slovenia, came all the way [0:44:13] here from Eastern Europe to be with us. Tyler, would you come up to the mic [0:44:33] and introduce your family, please, and Baloo's family if there's any? I think [0:44:45] Baloo's family is still overseas, so we're out of luck on that one. Okay. As for me, [0:44:50] I do have a family here in the Magic Valley. We've been here for my whole life, [0:44:56] my family's life my dad worked for the city I'm supported in this profession [0:45:00] by my wife and my daughter unfortunately they were not able to be here tonight [0:45:04] so I'm supported by all the rest of my family in blue [0:45:12] you may not like all the other dogs or I can't quite tell yet yeah [0:45:20] Well, that's you got to walk by him. [0:45:29] Well, so do I. [0:45:32] Only once. [0:45:34] Mayor Council, thank you so much for allowing us to do this. [0:45:37] So now if I could have Officer Schwabshire, Baloo, all of our officers receive certificates and our new officers and of course, Bella, come out here and line up so you can come down and shake their hands. [0:45:50] Bella, come on out. [0:45:52] You can stand by Baloo. [0:46:06] So what I'll have you do mayor council, if you want to come out this way, follow the city management team and then we'll have, behind the city council city manager, we'll have the police department leadership team and our executive leadership team with the city. [0:47:34] Okay, so I would imagine that some people are going to leave picture time unless you want [0:48:27] to stay for the rest of the exciting meeting. [0:48:30] We can take a minute and let everybody step out unless you want to stay. [0:48:36] Don't I'll go at once [0:49:39] Okay, moving on to the next agenda item. It's an action item. Let's make sure Wendy's here [0:49:48] Oh, Wendy, you're up [0:49:51] Consider a request to allocate [0:49:54] 369,000 of SLF RF money to fund repairs at first federal [0:49:59] Park and we have Wendy Davis our Parks and Rec. Director welcome Wendy. Hello again. [0:50:07] Thank you. So this evening I am here to request the reallocation of those funds [0:50:16] the leftover funds from the shop project. I think Gretchen gave a report a couple [0:50:21] weeks ago on that as update of that project and there was some savings from [0:50:27] that. And we have encountered some problems out at First Federal Park at the playground [0:50:35] with that AstroTurf surface and the splash pad that we never were able to get a remedy [0:50:45] in place that we were able to open that at all last year. And so we've been looking [0:50:49] at ways that we could work with First Federal to try to fix that and get those faces open [0:50:56] and back up, especially the maintenance on that turf. [0:51:01] And so this seemed like a good opportunity [0:51:03] to get the funding that's required in order to do that. [0:51:08] I don't have any solid estimates. [0:51:11] I talked to a playground representative. [0:51:15] He's been out, he's seen it a couple of times [0:51:18] and he just kind of gave us an idea of what [0:51:20] the two projects would probably run us. [0:51:22] Until we have funds allocated, [0:51:25] I can't really put it out for bid until I have too money behind it to have the conversation. [0:51:30] So that's what I'm asking for tonight is to take those funds and be able to go get some [0:51:36] bids and see if we can't get those two things fixed. [0:51:40] And just to note, I'd like to mention that for federal has allocated $60,000 to toward [0:51:47] the project. [0:51:48] Thank you, Wendy. [0:51:50] Chris, I know we had a lot of conversations last year with the splash pad. [0:51:56] a lot of going on on social media about the concern about it, knowing that people utilize [0:52:01] this park, what would the turnaround be to get these two areas fixed? [0:52:07] So truly, so I had had several conversations before on how quick we could get on the schedule. [0:52:15] If we can get these funds, I'll probably turn around and start working on trying to get [0:52:19] some beds tomorrow. [0:52:21] And if we can get him in quick enough, maybe we can still get it done this spring. [0:52:27] I mean, that would, I'm watching the lightning bolt coming right out of the sky. [0:52:33] I mean, right now for even trying to say that out loud. [0:52:35] But my hope would be that we could get this coming from as I want to know. [0:52:41] I don't know. [0:52:42] Okay. [0:52:46] It's zoos, yes. [0:52:47] It's neptune. [0:52:49] But possibly this year, this summer, the park will be our hope. [0:52:54] And by getting these funds, now, otherwise I'd have to go through the process, get them allocated. [0:53:00] They wouldn't be available until October and hello, second summer of apologizing. [0:53:09] Yeah. [0:53:10] Thank you. [0:53:11] Thank you. [0:53:12] Grace and Stone. [0:53:13] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:53:14] Miss Wendy, are those numbers that you requested based upon the gentleman you had come visit the park? [0:53:20] enough. So I guess that's my question to cut it off of Councilman Reed's comments. [0:53:25] Yeah, and the city manager also, but he did tell me that he said if we budget 225 that's [0:53:33] complete. So what we would do out there is pull up the old turf and there's a there's [0:53:39] so there's a base of gravel under at the bottom and that's been compacted and then there is [0:53:45] foam over the top of that. And then on top of the foam goes the turf. And so I think it's [0:53:56] the basis fine. The foam center needs to be rebuilt a little bit. And I think we could [0:54:05] either put down a new foam padding or just fill it in and then relay the entire turf [0:54:12] So that's the 225 and we're still struggling with what the surface at the splash pad needs to be. [0:54:20] But that number, I believe, would allow us to pull the concrete out, fix whatever we break, taking the concrete out, poor new concrete, and get us a concrete surface that is flush with, that would remedy the original problem which was the bad [0:54:39] poor of concrete that got us to having a surface on top of it anyway. And those two [0:54:44] numbers were based on that kind of work. Great, thank you. [0:54:51] Spencer Cutler. Well, you've been nice to get this done. I hope the stars do align for you. [0:54:56] If this is reallocated, then will you need to come back to Council with the apparent low bidder [0:55:01] for approval to move forward? Sure, how that works. Or would you simply be able to just get things [0:55:05] done? It depends upon the amount. So we believe right now that we can go through an informal [0:55:11] process. If the 250 and under right if the number grows beyond that we'll have to start over go through a formalized bit process and per state code we [0:55:23] would bring those back for board approval. Wonderful. Thank you. Thank you. Chris Street. I'll make a motion. Perfect. I move that we approve the allocation of [0:55:35] of 369,000 of SLF RF funds to repair the first federal park. [0:55:42] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:55:43] I'll second that. [0:55:44] Thank you. [0:55:45] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown [0:55:47] to approve the allocation of 369,000 of SLF RF money [0:55:54] to fund repairs at first federal park. [0:55:58] Amy Roll call vote, please. [0:56:00] Craig Hawkins? [0:56:01] Yes. [0:56:02] Jason Brown? [0:56:03] Yes. [0:56:03] Spencer Cutler? [0:56:04] Yes. [0:56:04] Grace and Stone? Yes. [0:56:06] Mary Volmer? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. [0:56:08] Chris Reed? Yes. [0:56:10] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Wendy. Thank you. [0:56:14] Okay. Next item on the agenda is also an action item. [0:56:20] Authorized authorization of Travis to sign a memorandum of understanding with [0:56:25] IDO Department of Transportation to accept a grant award of [0:56:30] $8,281,960 for Reconstruction of Eastland Drive. [0:56:38] And we have Jesse Sherman from Staff Engineer. [0:56:42] Welcome, Jesse. [0:56:44] Yes, thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:56:47] So last fall our engineering staff applied [0:56:50] for a Strategic Initiatives Program Local [0:56:52] Transportation Grant. [0:56:55] This January, $100 million was awarded [0:56:58] in Transportation Improvements Across Idaho. [0:57:02] Our application was among 127 applicants requesting $293.93 in funding. [0:57:12] Twin would be eligible up to $10 million in assistance because we have recently been determined [0:57:18] as a large metropolitan urban area. [0:57:23] We coordinated with our public works and our street department to determine which unfunded [0:57:28] project would have the most impact on transportation and windfalls and determine the roadway reconstruction [0:57:34] of Eastland Drive from Falls to Addison would have the most positive impact. Staff worked [0:57:41] to complete the application to a proper roadway evaluation, push the design and obtain support [0:57:47] letters from both public and private organizations, depending on Eastland or safe and efficient [0:57:53] transportation. In December the city received the good news that the Idaho Transportation Board [0:58:00] award it when falls with our entire request of $8,281,960. Attached as a [0:58:10] memorandum of understanding detailing our obligations of the award. I guess that's it. [0:58:19] I can clarify anything or answer any questions. Any questions for Jesse? I [0:58:26] think this is exciting. That's certainly going to be a benefit to the people over [0:58:36] that area. I know. So thank you for your efforts and getting that going and for those [0:58:42] that did the grant. That's amazing. That is lots of money. That's nice. Jason Brown. [0:58:49] Yeah Jesse on this one is it going to be similar to what we've done in the past [0:58:54] in the area where it will be resurfaced with concrete and through that corridor? [0:58:59] Can you explain a little bit of kind of what the the grant will go to? Yeah so [0:59:05] There was limitations on the application, but yes, we've recently done some [0:59:14] improvements on some of the intersections with concrete and we've [0:59:18] recognized that concrete would be the best surface for the high truck pasty [0:59:27] that happens on Eastland and that traffic capacity. One of the things that [0:59:32] that we did to, I guess, get ready to properly, [0:59:40] I guess, rehab Eastland was we did a material study [0:59:45] to determine the most responsible way [0:59:49] to build the cross-section of the road. [0:59:52] So that actually, when we had done some of that stuff, [0:59:57] it helped us show that we had a lot of skin in the game [1:00:02] regarding having professional service [1:00:05] to determine which type of surface to put down. [1:00:09] And the recommended surface was concrete. [1:00:11] We also had a pavement, like a Hot Mix asphalt pavement [1:00:17] section that was a lot thicker and would have gone into our utilities [1:00:22] and cost more money regarding some of the utilities. [1:00:25] So we decided that concrete was the best surface. [1:00:30] Thanks, Jesse. [1:00:31] I'll make a motion if there are no other questions. [1:00:33] Any other questions? [1:00:34] Go ahead, Jason. [1:00:35] I'd move to approve the city manager, Travis Rothwater, [1:00:40] to sign a memorandum of understanding [1:00:42] with the Idaho Transportation Department [1:00:44] to accept a grant in the amount of $8,281,960 [1:00:50] for the reconstruction of Eastland Drive. [1:00:52] Thank you, Jason Stone. [1:00:55] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grayson Stone [1:00:58] to authorize Travis, design the memorandum of understanding [1:01:02] with I.T.D. to accept the grant award of $8,281,960 [1:01:08] for Reconstruction of Eastland Drive. [1:01:11] Any further discussion? [1:01:13] Amy Rokavo, please. [1:01:17] Jason Brown. [1:01:18] Yes. [1:01:18] Spencer Cutler. [1:01:20] Yes. [1:01:20] Grayson Stone. [1:01:21] Yes. [1:01:21] Jerry Bomer. [1:01:22] Yes. [1:01:23] Ruth Pierce. [1:01:23] Yes. [1:01:24] Chris Reed. [1:01:25] Yes. [1:01:25] And Craig Hawkins. [1:01:26] Yes. [1:01:27] Thank you. [1:01:27] Motion passes 7 to 0. [1:01:29] Thank you, Jesse. [1:01:31] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, [1:01:35] a request to initiate a zoning code amendment [1:01:38] to modify Title 10 Chapter 11 required improvements. [1:01:43] We have Jonathan's been logged our P&Z Director. [1:01:45] Welcome, Jonathan. [1:01:47] Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council. [1:01:49] I'm gonna pull up quick item. [1:01:53] I'm not going to begin necessarily with the staff report. [1:01:57] That's a short staff report. [1:01:58] What I am going to bring up is a small presentation, it's not very long, which is last week we were [1:02:08] directed to bring this item back to you on the agenda. [1:02:12] There's a lot of words on there, so I'm going to ask you to focus on me real quick. [1:02:17] And I'm going to enter into what I call this work session kind of with you, what I usually [1:02:20] do with our planning and zoning commission, more of an interactive discussion, give you [1:02:24] a lot of information and we can start the Q&A. [1:02:27] This is the code section in its totality that we're talking about tonight, 10-11-1. [1:02:32] The whole regulation applies to certain projects when they come for a building permit. [1:02:38] I'm going to go through separating the regulations throughout what is kind of like a run-on paragraph. [1:02:44] If you can notice the first one is really big, the second one was added on later as an exception. [1:02:50] So what I'm going to go through is three things. [1:02:54] was amended a few times and the exceptions within this paragraph actually [1:02:59] only apply to those what is for items, landscaping, screening, parking, and streets. [1:03:08] All of this regulation applies to any new permanent building or structure when it's [1:03:13] constructed, placed or in large. [1:03:15] And that's what's actually on the first line right here. [1:03:20] I'm going to get to that first line, but applies to everything when you're changing [1:03:24] the use of a property. [1:03:25] All items two through nine are required. [1:03:28] Then there's some exceptions to when those things are required, [1:03:32] but those exceptions only apply to the first four. [1:03:35] Sanitation, which is your trash enclosure, the water and sewer, [1:03:39] which is your utility connections to fresh water and sewage. [1:03:43] Your storm water management and the floodplain regulations are required [1:03:48] and every single time a project has a building that's constructed, [1:03:54] placed or erected or enlarged or when there's a change of use of the building structure or parcel of land [1:04:01] We have a definition of change of use in this zoning code. I'll get to that a little bit later [1:04:07] So the way this code sections constructed is [1:04:11] Anything that happens gives us all eight items and then it was constructed to build in [1:04:17] Exceptions and I'm gonna go through those exceptions one by one. So you guys can kind of see it [1:04:22] They were written in different years [1:04:24] When they're granted essentially for landscaping screening, which is fences around properties [1:04:31] that are commercial between commercial residential, the parking area, the streets, just curb gutter [1:04:36] sidewalk. [1:04:37] There's never an exception given for the trash enclosure, water sewer, storm water. [1:04:41] Any questions on this giant paragraph that you have in front of you? [1:04:46] We're going to get to the one sentence in a minute. [1:04:49] This whole paragraph basically says, this is when we get these items, and these are the [1:04:53] items we're looking for whenever there's a new project in town or change of use of property. [1:04:58] And we have questions so far. [1:05:00] Jason? [1:05:02] Yeah. [1:05:03] Well Jim, just so it's clear, so items six, seven, eight, nine, there are no exceptions [1:05:09] for those. [1:05:10] Those have to be done if there's a change of use where you come in for a modification. [1:05:15] The only time that is accepted is the situation we had a few weeks ago where there's a paragraph [1:05:20] in here or there's a sentence in here. [1:05:21] Okay. [1:05:22] That's correct. [1:05:23] There are exceptions, as you said, associated with certain aspects. [1:05:27] Yep, and some of those, I'll get to the exceptions one by one, because I'm going to separate out the thoughts here in a second. [1:05:32] Any other questions so far? [1:05:36] Go ahead. [1:05:38] So, now the paragraph has been separated into different sentences. We can kind of, pardon, parcel this out. [1:05:44] First line is the qualifier for when things have to be done. We've kind of talked about that one. [1:05:50] You build something, you change the land, this section applies, and this section are meaning [1:05:55] this chapter. [1:05:57] The second line is when it's required, unless otherwise provided, all required improvements, [1:06:05] and these are the required improvements up here two through nine, shall be a condition [1:06:08] of any building permit and they shall be completed prior to final inspection and occupancy of [1:06:13] the building. [1:06:14] So that second sentence is saying all of these items shall be done before they occupy the [1:06:19] building unless otherwise provided. [1:06:22] I will tell you there's only one exception in all of these and it is in the landscaping [1:06:28] section. [1:06:29] The landscaping section, which is why I included the code in your, that's the attachment, the [1:06:34] landscaping section basically gives us the ability to give a temporary occupancy. [1:06:40] We can't have that occupancy temporary go beyond the current planting season or the next [1:06:45] planting season, because the actual words. [1:06:47] Essentially, in the winter time, you can still plant stuff, [1:06:51] but usually the nurseries don't have stock. [1:06:53] They don't have the actual plant or tree to put in the ground, [1:06:57] so they can't get it. [1:06:58] So we allow them to have a temporary until, essentially, [1:07:03] you know, into spring or summer occupy the building, [1:07:05] but then plant the tree. [1:07:07] Okay? So that's what the second sentence talks about. [1:07:12] This next one, which is kind of two thoughts kind [1:07:15] of together is where you get to some exceptions. [1:07:18] It's a cost exception. [1:07:22] Cost of the improvements, two through five, [1:07:24] again landscaping, screening, parking, and streets. [1:07:27] If it exceeds 25% of the proposed private improvements, [1:07:31] so you're building a new building, [1:07:33] and the cost of the stuff we're asking for [1:07:35] is greater than 25% of what you're doing. [1:07:39] An agreement can be negotiated to allow required improvements [1:07:41] if you staged over a period of time, [1:07:43] not to exceed three years. [1:07:45] We've done that in-house often. [1:07:48] And most of the time we've used this for paving of areas that were not required for the building to function. [1:07:55] It could be some of the streets or sidewalks or things like that. [1:08:00] We just say do it in the next three years. [1:08:01] We get a document basically a contract between us the landowners say we're going to do it in the next three years. [1:08:06] Some of times they say we'll do a little bit every year and sometimes it's just we'll do it by the end of three years. [1:08:13] The next thought is whenever building is constructed placed, etc, etc. [1:08:18] Is it an isolated or undeveloped area or in cases of exceptional hardship? [1:08:23] That's the phrase that we talked about. [1:08:26] Improvements may be deferred by the Council in cases where deferral would otherwise be unavailable. [1:08:29] Those are like two separate thoughts in that, but they're kind of together because they came together. [1:08:35] So, Grayson has a question, but I do as well. [1:08:39] Give me an example of an isolated or undeveloped area. [1:08:44] Have we ever had one? [1:08:46] to the degree that we've exercised this and really it comes down to it is cost [1:08:52] prohibitive for a builder or developer to go too far beyond our current utility [1:08:58] boundaries to the point of not being able to fund the project. It's expensive [1:09:04] to go a quarter mile with sewer and water to get to an isolated spot. The cost of [1:09:10] doing those improvements really is it's not in you got to have sewer and water so [1:09:14] really our boundaries been sucked in pretty close work city limits it just [1:09:19] hasn't happened in my tenure and that has to be approved by council the [1:09:25] extreme hardship okay great isolated or undeveloped yeah thank you madam mayor so [1:09:30] when it talks about an agreement may be negotiated I guess to piggyback off [1:09:35] what mayor Pierce was just talking about is that to be negotiated with the [1:09:39] counselor who's that to be negotiated with we have done that in house the [1:09:44] The agreement is what we've done in house. [1:09:47] And I'm trying to remember if we bring those here. [1:09:49] I think we do bring the deferral agreements to you. [1:09:52] And we say here's a three year deferral agreement. [1:09:54] And I believe they're on the consent calendar generally. [1:09:58] The negotiation is how long is it gonna take? [1:10:00] Is it you just can't go past three years. [1:10:03] If it's enough work that we believe can't be done [1:10:05] in one or two, I mean, generally we give them [1:10:07] whatever time up to three years that they ask for. [1:10:11] And then we bring them to you. [1:10:12] Copy, thank you. [1:10:15] That's it, thank you. [1:10:16] The last paragraph talks about an exception for minor modifications and the size of the [1:10:23] building not to be more than 25% increase or a total size over 10,000 square feet. [1:10:29] Again, it's an exception to landscaping, screening, parking, and streets. [1:10:36] It's not the exception for the other stuff, which is your trash and clothes or water sewer [1:10:41] stormwater. [1:10:42] And essentially if you add like a vestibule [1:10:44] onto the front of a building, it's a minor modification. [1:10:48] It's not over 25%. [1:10:50] Two through five are not required for your building permit [1:10:52] to be issued and to be occupied for that building. [1:10:58] So any other questions? [1:11:00] And I have some examples of when these sections would [1:11:03] require what's a change of use, what's [1:11:06] in addition to a building, something [1:11:11] that does not require these things, [1:11:12] it's not a change of use would be if a restaurant moves [1:11:15] into one building, they go out of business and a new one comes in, there's no change of [1:11:20] use, there's no expansion of the building, they're just able to move in. Same with like [1:11:25] any type of office. But if you add on to the building, then it starts to, we look at a lot [1:11:31] closer as a 25%, what's the cost, the improvement, that kind of stuff, and we do that all at [1:11:36] house. Right. So, kind of hard to see, I believe you can see on your foot up on the screen up [1:11:43] here, it's a little bit dark. [1:11:45] I've highlighted the sentence, and then I've highlighted [1:11:48] in yellow, and the phrase is in red, [1:11:52] which we were asked to bring back. [1:11:55] In changing this, we can do a few things. [1:12:00] Removing just the phrase, or in cases of exceptional hardship, [1:12:03] it leaves the sentence intact, and you can still have [1:12:06] the isolated or undeveloped area, [1:12:08] and that phrase, that sentence still works. [1:12:10] You could remove the entire sentence, [1:12:13] And that would still leave the section intact [1:12:16] and just remove these exceptions out of it. [1:12:19] And so we could still apply the code [1:12:21] as it's written today without any real change. [1:12:26] That's an easy fix, that's something we can do. [1:12:30] What I would like to do, that's really the end of it, [1:12:33] but I'm gonna give you a little bit of direction [1:12:34] as we're kind of in this conversation. [1:12:37] If we do that, nothing else, I think that would be fine. [1:12:40] And I would simply ask for re-affirmation of when you guys would like, the counts would [1:12:46] like, the improvements to be finished. [1:12:48] The current code reads that these items are to be done prior to final inspection and occupancy [1:12:54] of the building. [1:12:55] And if you simply have the discussion say yes, we want these things finished before somebody [1:12:59] occupies the building, then we have re-affirmation that's what you're looking for and we will [1:13:04] not sign temporary until all of those things are finished except for landscaping can [1:13:09] be temporary, but nothing else can be. We could also move different directions, which is reshape [1:13:17] this section, add some exceptions for other things. If you wanted to for sanitation like the trash [1:13:21] enclosure or parking stripes or something like that, we can do that. No, in practice, I will tell [1:13:29] you that in the middle of winter, and if there's snow on the ground, we as a staff believe that it's [1:13:35] a bit excessive to require painting to be on the ground when it's covered in ice. So we work with [1:13:40] with people and we do a more common inspection [1:13:43] to get the painting down as soon as possible. [1:13:47] Not in the code, but that's a little bit of why people [1:13:50] that enforce this stuff are not a robot [1:13:52] because we can kind of make those judgment calls. [1:13:55] It's not listed here to do that, [1:13:56] but it is something we've done in those instances. [1:14:01] I will rest for any questions [1:14:02] and we can start discussing how we'd like there. [1:14:05] So a couple of things, Jonathan. [1:14:07] I'm a little bit leery of completely striking exceptional hardship, and I know that's a [1:14:16] different direction than what you were directed, but I'm concerned that if we do have a case [1:14:21] of extreme hardship, which probably needs to be defined, that like for example, some [1:14:30] natural disaster, that to me would constitute an extreme hardship, a big flood, you know, [1:14:36] had flooding issues or somebody couldn't. I mean, that may not be the best example. What [1:14:43] are your thoughts related to removing that section, that wording, that red phrase? [1:14:54] From my standpoint, if you don't remove it, then you should be more clear to say exceptional [1:15:01] hardship, meaning you can have a meaning phrase after that. I were going that route. I would [1:15:09] I know it sounds crazy, but I'd hook it to whenever the council has some sort of declaration [1:15:13] of emergency, because in that case, it is something like that. [1:15:16] We have declared emergency and we're kind of dealing with special circumstances. [1:15:20] Like COVID? [1:15:21] Well, yeah, I mean technically it was and even the governor declared it and we suspended [1:15:28] some of our like sign regulations for that because everybody's putting out, you know, [1:15:33] drive throughs in certain spots or pickups and we allowed that because we had a declared [1:15:37] emergency. [1:15:39] like that would cover your flooding, earthquake, fire, like massive explosion somewhere that [1:15:46] kind of wrecked a couple blocks or something. [1:15:49] Well, I think what was our issue was trying to determine what that definition was. [1:15:57] I think we were kind of on different pages, some of us, where it wasn't really defined [1:16:03] and there wasn't a clear direction. [1:16:06] Is that terminology used in other federal? [1:16:10] There is. [1:16:11] FEMA actually has a definition of exceptional hardship when it deals with granting remedy [1:16:16] for floodplain issues. [1:16:18] And it has to deal with something not of the applicant's doing, more of a natural cause [1:16:27] or natural geography of the property. [1:16:31] It'll like prohibits you from actually utilizing or following the code strictly. [1:16:35] It really is that it's someone that has just something occur on the property or is a natural [1:16:41] Thing on the property that causes the use of the property to not be utilized fully [1:16:46] So they have exceptional hardship within FEMA's floodplain code [1:16:51] I found that later. Okay, but [1:16:56] Okay, well, there's several other people that want to weigh in but just for thought Chris read [1:17:02] Jonathan, thank you the presentation [1:17:04] Personally, I'm in favor of getting rid of the entire sentence, understanding with the [1:17:10] conversation that just had maybe putting that language in someplace else as far as if there [1:17:17] was an emergency, that would be it because it seems like exceptional hardship to try to [1:17:23] define that or planning doesn't constitute exceptional hardship. [1:17:30] So, for me, that's too broad to open, what you talked about as far as Section 2 through 5, your team is great, all right? [1:17:46] And I don't question that, but while we're doing this, if we're going to provide some exceptions, completely understand, [1:17:55] I mean, if somebody wanted an occupancy right now and he said, hey, go plant a tree, the [1:18:01] tree's going to die. [1:18:02] I mean, there's no reason to do that. [1:18:03] And so that, but putting that in the code, I think is important, especially as we move [1:18:07] forward where they're, we're removing this exception, just to make sure everybody's all [1:18:15] black and white. [1:18:16] And there isn't a feeling of, well, you let me do this, but you don't let so and so, and [1:18:20] you're showing favoritism. [1:18:22] I think that two through five while we're in here, [1:18:25] that would be where we would put that information in, [1:18:28] but I would be in favor of removing that entire sentence. [1:18:33] The entire sentence searches the phrase. [1:18:35] The entire sentence. [1:18:36] Okay, Grayson Stone. [1:18:38] Yeah, I just want to publicly go on the record [1:18:40] and clearly state, I appreciate everything [1:18:43] that the city employees do on level two. [1:18:46] With Troy Vitek staff, your staff, Matthew Long's staff. [1:18:50] In my opinion, none of us, when we're elected officials, [1:18:54] we're not billing officials, maybe with the exception [1:18:56] of Councilman Keller, are we actively involved [1:18:59] in the construction industry and or maintenance? [1:19:03] It would be my intention that we make an amendment [1:19:09] to the code that empowers the staff on level two [1:19:14] to have full control over this. [1:19:16] Like I said, we don't do this on a day-to-day basis. [1:19:20] this is what you guys do. [1:19:22] And so I don't know if it's striking the whole sentence, [1:19:27] like Councilman Reed is sitting, [1:19:29] or if it's just getting rid of the term [1:19:31] or in case of exceptional hardship, [1:19:34] I feel like the following phrase improvements [1:19:37] may be deferred by the Council in case of the deferral [1:19:39] would otherwise be unavailable. [1:19:41] It encompasses the phrase or in case of exceptional hardship, [1:19:45] but even then that opens it up to debate. [1:19:47] So I guess I'm asking you a question, Director Stemlove. [1:19:53] What is the best course of action as far as if we're going to edit? [1:19:58] Let's do it right. [1:19:59] Let's give you guys full control. [1:20:01] You guys are the brilliant officials. [1:20:02] It needs to be in your court. [1:20:04] So what would your absolute preference be? [1:20:07] I'm going to not. [1:20:10] In a professional opinion. [1:20:12] Yes. [1:20:13] I guess that's the key word I have to use in your profession. [1:20:16] Answer it a bit with a question to you, which if we need to answer really the question. [1:20:20] of when does the Council want landscaping, screening, parking, and streets to be finished? [1:20:27] And if you want to have those be temporary at all, if you do, then we need to change this [1:20:34] section to allow for some of those things to be not finished on a project before building is occupied. [1:20:42] If that's, if you're like, nope, we want those things finished other than the trees and the shrubs. [1:20:46] The landscaping is what we're okay with because that's practical. [1:20:50] Everything else I want finished before you occupy that building. I think that is really the key question where things are a little bit [1:20:57] split either want them all except landscaping which is what the code says now or we want to allow exception which is [1:21:04] Okay to do another place is do that if we do that I [1:21:10] Guess I'd say can we let's answer that question first [1:21:13] Then we will know which direction to take when we write it [1:21:16] One is super easy, I just strike it when we keep on as we have today and we get those [1:21:21] items prior to a building being occupied. If we want to make exception, I need to do [1:21:27] a little bit more tweaking which is to upgrade the enforcement arm when they [1:21:31] don't finish those items. So this is where I think that I have a little bit [1:21:37] of a rub. So I enjoy the fact that Twin Falls is open to commercial [1:21:42] development coming in or any development in that point. I also feel like it's [1:21:46] imperative that everybody plays by the same rules, and on their timelines and schedules, [1:21:51] and their development schedule. [1:21:53] I don't think it's any, it's not a shocker to anybody that our asphalt plants close, maybe [1:21:58] mid-November, early December. [1:22:01] I think it's unfair to those other people that can abide by those timelines, and then [1:22:05] we have this out in the code for folks, and I'm not saying this has happened in the past, [1:22:13] but folks that haven't just gotten their stuff done. [1:22:17] So that's really my rub and again, I really just want to empower our professionals. [1:22:24] Our taxpayers are paying you guys to be the experts and so my preference would be to defer [1:22:28] to you on how we handle this to make sure that you guys have the final call. [1:22:36] And to do that I'd say you strike the sentence and just reaffirm what you want. [1:22:39] This code says exactly what you're saying which is everybody knows we want these things [1:22:43] done prior to you being in that building. [1:22:46] landscaping. [1:22:47] Except the landscaping we can... [1:22:49] But John okay with everything else will be finished before you can occupy that building. [1:22:54] And you can simply just say that's where we're reaffirming here today. [1:22:57] Strike this sentence. [1:22:58] I'll bring you a code amendment which is pretty... [1:23:00] It's a quick one. [1:23:01] We're just erasing that sentence and really debate or the discussion of point people do. [1:23:06] We've reaffirmed when we want these things done. [1:23:08] We want them done before you occupy the building. [1:23:10] And your professional opinion is that give absolute authority back to the building department [1:23:14] level too. [1:23:15] Yeah, it's still there and I will tell you, it is easier to get compliance from somebody [1:23:22] who can't be in their building yet and to try and go after them after the already in it. [1:23:28] It is the ultimate hook, it's the ultimate thing from the construction world or the zoning [1:23:34] enforcement world of, I will not sign your CFO because you have to have these things [1:23:38] done because that's what the council's directed us to do, that's how we want our city to be [1:23:42] constructed. [1:23:43] Okay. [1:23:47] Okay. [1:23:48] Yes, Madam Mayor. [1:23:50] Jason. [1:23:51] Yeah, Jonathan. [1:23:52] Thanks. [1:23:53] Yeah, I'm leaning towards what really what kind of what you just said. [1:24:00] I think, you know, my, my issue with some of this is, and I think Councilman Reed kind [1:24:06] of said it or alluded to it, to some extent, that is, I think a, the reason this situation [1:24:12] is coming up is because I think of poor planning, and I would not like to be in that situation [1:24:21] again. [1:24:22] You know, Councilman Stone also indicated our asphalt plans are open typically from first [1:24:32] part of April to the last part of November in the area. [1:24:35] There are a few times that they close early because of weather conditions. [1:24:39] I'm less inclined to give an exception because someone didn't take the nine months to prepare [1:24:48] for that asphalt plan to get that improvement done. [1:24:53] I could see the benefit of landscaping, maybe even just say, okay, when do our landscaping [1:24:58] companies open or close? [1:25:00] They close in on November 1st and open back up, you know, let's say May 1st for the lack [1:25:07] of not understanding what they do, I think we could bracket that exception maybe a little [1:25:14] bit more. The other question I have is when does the three years start? The way when they [1:25:21] submit the application or when does that time frame start? Because three years seems like [1:25:29] a really long time to get some of this done and waiting back to the response that you [1:25:36] just gave us in the sense of if we let them in the building outside of landscaping, I mean [1:25:43] they can take three years to get that done. [1:25:45] Yeah, that stage deferral would start from the date that we signed the agreement. [1:25:49] Okay. [1:25:50] It would basically be your approval date. [1:25:51] The approval date that we signed is what we've been going on for council. [1:25:55] That's for the deferral. [1:25:57] The other one, which is the other one down here in the next sentence, is the date of completion [1:26:01] of the other portions. [1:26:02] And that's when we would issue any type of CFO for that portion. [1:26:06] But I don't know if that was really where you're after I think you were after. [1:26:08] No, it's that time. [1:26:11] It just three years seems like a really long time to get some of that type of stuff done [1:26:16] in my mind, particularly if it sounds like we're leaning towards landscaping. [1:26:21] I mean, really that should be a 12 month type of exception. [1:26:27] The other part that I'm struggling with just internally is, you know, in the situation of [1:26:37] the pandemic that we had just gone through, I mean, PVC prices for sewer, pipe and water [1:26:44] pipe just went through the roof, supply chain really truly was hampered during that timeframe. [1:26:51] Did we navigate through that, yes, but there are times that I don't think we can foresee [1:26:57] that there may be an exception that we use a different material type, that truly would [1:27:04] be a, hey, I just simply can't get it. [1:27:08] But that's the only reservation in my mind in the scenario that I'm trying to work through [1:27:13] with doing that. [1:27:15] But I'm leaning more for, hey, look, these are our requirements, and I'm assuming that [1:27:23] we're pretty explicit when when people come in and saying hey these are the things [1:27:28] you got to do before we're going to give you a CFO. Yes we are. We also work with [1:27:33] people on projects that if there's a portion of the property that can be [1:27:38] phased that isn't like essential for the function of the building we've phased [1:27:43] out those areas an example would be like a large dealership right and so they [1:27:49] need extra area to put cars on to stage or to view them or whatever. We wouldn't [1:27:56] require that to be paved. All we simply ask is to just cordon it off until it is [1:28:00] paved. If it's not part of any other critical infrastructure piece like an [1:28:07] ADA accessibility or the stormwater area. Also if there's some sort of sidewalk [1:28:13] area that's just not required it's just kind of like around the building or [1:28:16] somewhere else on the property that doesn't go anywhere. [1:28:19] We can phase those out. [1:28:21] We can also bond. [1:28:23] So Troy is able to bond for public improvements [1:28:25] if we need to, if it's in the public way. [1:28:28] Kind of like the sidewalk on the front of a building [1:28:30] or out of the street. [1:28:32] We do what we can to be creative with this section [1:28:35] currently to allow for those things to happen. [1:28:39] But that's something we do, [1:28:41] and it's not really explicitly written in here, [1:28:43] but we do that because we know that. [1:28:45] And I think that's important that we give you the autonomy to be able to use your professional [1:28:50] judgement to say, hey, this sidewalk is the sidewalk to know where, I think that's what [1:28:56] I'm looking for is the ability to give the staff the opportunity. [1:29:02] There always needs to be some caveat in there that if there is a situation that people really [1:29:08] do need to come in front of council that we provide that for them. [1:29:11] But there are exceptions. [1:29:13] We have to use our best professional judgment in these types of scenarios. [1:29:17] I just think that we need to make sure that we're kind of holding everybody to the same [1:29:24] standard. [1:29:25] Travis, did you have something? [1:29:28] I do. [1:29:29] And so I think that whenever the council is going to create a policy, whenever you say [1:29:35] it always has to be uniform, there's going to be an exception that immediately surfaces [1:29:40] that you're going to wish that you would have accounted for. [1:29:43] And so when this issue was for starting, I think that if the tools would have been provided [1:29:48] to the members of our team to allow for discretion using their professional judgment on certain [1:29:54] things, we could have made a good process in moving forward. [1:29:59] If we say it always has to be this way, you're going to require painting to occur on asphalt [1:30:06] before you can occupy a building, and if that's in the middle of February, no one's doing painting, [1:30:11] the council's saying, that's okay. [1:30:13] And when all reality, I know that you're probably saying, but we want you to use judgment. [1:30:18] The thing about our team is, they are going to follow the code to the letter that is provided. [1:30:25] That is what they are charged to do. [1:30:27] And so while you're saying, we want you to use your creative latitudes, your judgments to make process, [1:30:33] you're creating a law that they are required to follow. [1:30:39] And so my suggestion would be you got an amazing team [1:30:44] that would have the ability to take, I think, the conversations that you've had [1:30:49] and to produce a series of amendments that allows for consistency, [1:30:55] that allows for them to use their professional judgment, [1:30:58] and also some level of flexibility when it would be reasonable. [1:31:03] I trust our team to be able to do that, as opposed to saying, [1:31:07] these items always have to be done, [1:31:10] because the minute you do that, [1:31:12] it is going to put us in a difficult situation. [1:31:15] Maybe it is that asphalt thing, right? [1:31:17] And Jonathan is saying, [1:31:18] we're able to work with members of our public [1:31:20] to remove or cordon off portions. [1:31:23] In my opinion, that takes that flexibility away here. [1:31:27] Madam Mayor, I apologize to jump in here real quick, [1:31:29] but doesn't that sentence superseding that highlighted area [1:31:35] where it says an agreement may be negotiated [1:31:37] to allow the required improvements to be staged [1:31:39] over the period, does that not cover it? [1:31:43] It's only if the caustic seeds look 25%. [1:31:49] It does not cover it. [1:31:54] Okay, we have a couple more, Chris Reed. [1:31:58] I was gonna make a motion, [1:31:59] but there's Spencer's behind me. [1:32:03] Oh, thanks, Spencer. [1:32:04] Thanks, Councilman Reed, thanks, Mayor. [1:32:06] I was just going to say, there's a lot of ideas that aren't bad ideas, but we could go down a lot of rabbit holes, and I think at some point, we just need to get something accomplished, and so I would be in favor of, as Councilman Reed said, simply striking that sentence, and I would support that if that was a motion you were going to make. [1:32:24] I'm in favor. [1:32:25] Okay. Anybody else? Nobody's lights come on. Bruce, do you have anything you want to weigh in while we're [1:32:36] discussing this? [1:32:38] Since you came all the way from Boise. You need to come up to the mic, please. [1:32:44] Thanks, Madam Mayor. I don't at this time [1:32:48] I think the discussion has been right on in terms of what the parameters are, what you're dealing with and [1:32:53] know from a legal perspective, I think that the council is in the right direction in terms of how you're considering it. Thank you. [1:33:00] Okay, thank you. Chris, do you want to go ahead? [1:33:03] Yeah, so the motion to strike this sentence, but we just had a lot of discussion as far [1:33:10] as some other things in allowing city staff to move forward, because it's not just striking [1:33:19] that sentence. There's some more to it. [1:33:21] Yeah, and we can, if you seem to say we're going to strike it, we know that that's something [1:33:24] we want to do, if that's what I'm kind of generally head nods, is we're going to strike [1:33:28] it with further direction to bring back an amendment to kind of to create other [1:33:35] exceptions or avenues for exception for certain items and I don't I'm gonna tell [1:33:41] you what my my opinion I would be fine if we extended the exceptions which could [1:33:48] include a time frame or something like that to 11 6 which is the trash enclosure [1:33:54] I do not believe we would want to have any exceptions for sewer water, storm water, or floodplain regulations. [1:34:04] That's from a staff's perspective. I say I'm going to keep those out, but I can bring back some form of, [1:34:10] it's not open-in but options for future things. And it probably is going to end more towards the construction season issue, [1:34:19] which is a seasonal issue, which is what we hear more often of, like it's winter I [1:34:23] can't pave it and like okay we get that that's probably where I'm gonna go [1:34:29] towards given some of the direction we have does that help her hinder we'll see [1:34:35] once I make the motion. So Chris before you do Mitch I think what most we in? I was [1:34:41] just gonna let you know in Jonathan's staff report he actually provided you [1:34:46] some sample motions at the bottom of it and there's like one, I think it's the [1:34:51] second one, that is exactly what he just said or there's another one which is the [1:34:57] first one that is exactly what Spencer maybe just said before that and so maybe [1:35:01] if you want some help crafting those motions Jonathan has taken some time to [1:35:05] do that and they're gonna have it up right here. So okay we've got a couple [1:35:09] other people that have weighed in so Chris if you hold on a second Spencer [1:35:14] Are you good? [1:35:15] Yes. [1:35:16] Okay. [1:35:17] Great. [1:35:18] Yeah. [1:35:19] Madam Mayor, this may be a super dumb question for Director Spunlove and Travis, but if we [1:35:24] just crossed out that first part of the sentence before it starting with if the cost of improvements [1:35:30] required sections 10-11 and we scratched that all the way down to where it says an agreement [1:35:36] may be negotiated to allow the requirement, it required improvements. [1:35:39] So it would be capital, you know, and agreement may be negotiated. [1:35:44] that solve the issue it seems like it would there could be something we would [1:35:49] need to put some parameters as to which ones we want to accept as far as what [1:35:54] you'd be wanting to negotiate on yeah I think so if we took this idea you get [1:35:58] my cursor back up here you took this idea which is this sentence I don't know if [1:36:03] you guys are seeing this on yours it is only 4 2 3 0 5 and it doesn't cover [1:36:09] the trash enclosure water sewer. You'd want to modify that to have the sections [1:36:17] we're talking about staged over a period of time not to see three years. That's a [1:36:22] possibility. I think that accomplishes what we're talking about. But right now [1:36:28] you're looking for a direction on that one paragraph as you can see his three [1:36:33] sample motion so I'm gonna let Craig talk if you want and then we'll let Chris [1:36:39] make a motion. My thought would be, does that give you the latitude you need to be effective? [1:36:45] Yeah, so in what, yes, to a degree and I would put boundaries on it because we were trying, [1:36:51] when we're trying to enforce this or apply this to people equally, we don't want anybody to have [1:36:56] any arbitrary decision from staff. I mean, we want to have some decision making ability to take what's [1:37:00] practical, but we don't want to be accused by any one user of, you gave that guy a three or deferral, [1:37:06] And I only got a one year deferral. [1:37:08] So we're going to have to, if that's the idea for certain items to kind of go that way, [1:37:13] we would help craft like in the situation or we'd come to you to have that. [1:37:18] At the same time I'm going to say, if that's throughout, we need, [1:37:22] you're going to see a better enforcement arm or the temporary. [1:37:27] Because right now I don't have one. We have a thousand dollar deposit. [1:37:32] That's it. [1:37:33] And I think it needs to be their percentage of the cost of the project or something else to make them finish [1:37:39] To be able to occupy the building. So it's just a heads up on that one. Okay, but yeah, it would give some latitude to [1:37:45] Allow these things to happen if that's when if you're okay with those improvements happening later [1:37:51] Would that fall into sample three then? Yep [1:37:57] Okay, sample three I wrote in there to have a bit stiffer penalty [1:38:01] Perfect. [1:38:03] Miss Reed, you're up. [1:38:05] Alright. [1:38:06] I move we begin the zoning title amendment process to strike the exceptional hardship deferral within city code 10-11-1 [1:38:16] and create a temporary building occupancy option for additional items, trash and closures, parking lot painting, etc. [1:38:24] and create a more immediate enforcement provision for violations of this chapter. [1:38:30] as discussed in this meeting. [1:38:33] Okay. [1:38:34] Do I have a second? [1:38:36] Craig Hawkins. [1:38:37] I second. [1:38:38] Thank you. [1:38:39] Emotion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins. [1:38:43] To begin the zoning title amendment process, strike the exceptional hardship deferral within [1:38:48] code section 10-11-1, creating temporary building occupancy option for additional items, trash [1:38:56] College and College parking lot paint etc. and create more immediate enforcement [1:39:01] for violations of this chapter as discussed in this meeting. So I have a [1:39:08] Chris Reed Mitch Humboldt somebody. Just at the conclusion of your debate [1:39:14] staff would like to talk. Okay so any further discussion Amy Roel call vote [1:39:21] please. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. [1:39:30] Jerry Bulmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. [1:39:37] Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 1, Jonathan. Thank you so much for all your hard work [1:39:43] and helping us through this process. Yeah, Madam Mayor, so now you have started an active [1:39:51] zoning process. And as a result of that process, it's going to take somewhere between eight [1:39:56] to 9 weeks to be able to complete as we go through all the entire land use processes. [1:40:02] And so now you're in this gap where you've instructed staff to make a change to a land [1:40:07] use code and you still have an existing code. [1:40:08] And so it'd be my recommendation that any request that may come forward you pause until [1:40:15] you wait till the outcome. [1:40:16] And so it doesn't mean that individuals may not want to approach the council but my recommendation [1:40:20] would be because you have a pending action that could be in conflict with the decision [1:40:25] that you just consider those as appropriate [1:40:29] at the conclusion of this process [1:40:31] because this process was started first. [1:40:33] Perfect. [1:40:34] Everybody clear with that? [1:40:36] Awesome. [1:40:37] Thank you so much. [1:40:39] Okay, so that's all for the items of consideration. [1:40:45] Next we have on the agenda, [1:40:47] a time for general public input. [1:40:49] If there's anybody from the audience [1:40:51] that wishes to address city council [1:40:54] on an issue that is not on today's agenda [1:40:57] or is not regarding city personnel, please come down. [1:41:04] Okay, seeing no one, advisory board reports. [1:41:07] Anybody, Chris Reed. [1:41:09] I don't have a report just a reminder though [1:41:11] that we do have two meetings tomorrow. [1:41:13] The airport advisory board needs tomorrow [1:41:14] at 11 o'clock at the airport [1:41:16] and then the public art council will be here at 12 o'clock. [1:41:21] Perfect. [1:41:22] Anybody else? [1:41:23] Yes, Mayor. [1:41:24] Yes. [1:41:25] The historic preservation committee has a recommendation they're forwarding to council [1:41:30] and I want to let council and all I support this and there's two pieces to it. [1:41:34] One would be to reduce the committee from seven to five members. [1:41:38] That's because it's been a challenge to always have a quorum when needed. [1:41:42] And if we don't have a quorum then that can delay the applicant which we're supposed to serve, not delay. [1:41:48] So I think that the community would still be representative with only five members. [1:41:53] The other thing would be to take out the requirement that at least one lives in the district, the [1:42:01] historic district. [1:42:04] It seems like a good idea because conceivably that person would be an advocate for those property [1:42:08] owners in the district. [1:42:10] But prior members have also expressed that it's kind of a conflict of interest too, especially [1:42:15] if a neighbor friend wants something or if the person on the committee has a business [1:42:22] that is the same as a competing business. [1:42:24] So it seemed to create more conflict than it did representation. [1:42:29] So I do recommend, or I should say, [1:42:32] I do support that recommendation. [1:42:34] Thank you. [1:42:35] Anybody else? [1:42:37] City manager's office. [1:42:39] Madam Mayor, members of the council, [1:42:40] just as a reminder, the 19th of this month, [1:42:44] this president's day, and as a result of that, [1:42:47] we typically move the meeting to Tuesday, [1:42:49] that we are considering cancelling that meeting. [1:42:52] And so you'll meet next week. [1:42:54] You'll be off the week of the 19th and 20th, [1:42:57] and then we'll resume again the following week. [1:43:00] Perfect. [1:43:01] Thank you. [1:43:02] Okay, no public hearings tonight. [1:43:04] So next on the agenda is an executive session. [1:43:08] Executive Session 74-206C to acquire an interest [1:43:14] in real property not owned by a public agency [1:43:19] and F to communicate with legal counsel for the agency to discuss the legal ramifications [1:43:25] of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated, [1:43:31] but imminently likely to be litigated, the mere presence of legal counsel [1:43:37] at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement. [1:43:41] So I just... [1:43:42] So moved. [1:43:43] Do I have a second? [1:43:44] Second. [1:43:45] Motion by Chris Reed. [1:43:46] Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to move into executive session under Code [1:43:51] Section 74-206C and F. Amy Roll call vote please. [1:43:58] Grace and Stone. Yes. [1:44:02] You're a Sherry Bulmer, sorry. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. [1:44:08] Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. [1:44:12] And Spencer Cutler. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. I just let everybody [1:44:17] know that we move into executive session. We will not be back. We will not be making any [1:44:22] votes in executive session. And so our meeting is adjourned. Thank you.