Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-07-31, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-07-31/ [0:00:08] Okay, good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the July 31st, 2023 City Council [0:01:44] meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers. [0:01:51] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please [0:01:54] rise. Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight, so on to the consent calendar. Council [0:02:20] wishes Craig Hawkins. Mayor would like to make a motion to approve the consent [0:02:24] calendar is written. Thank you. Do I have a second? Second. Thank you. Motion was [0:02:30] that you? Okay motion by Craig Hawkins second by Ali Scavalle to approve the [0:02:35] consent calendar as written. Amy Roll call vote please. Ruth Pierce yes [0:02:41] Yes. [0:02:42] Face read. [0:02:43] Yes. [0:02:44] Thank Hawkins. [0:02:45] Yes. [0:02:46] Jason Brown. [0:02:47] Yes. [0:02:48] Yes. [0:02:49] And Alex Kaval. [0:02:50] Yes. [0:02:51] How about me? [0:02:52] And Mickey Boy? [0:02:53] Yes. [0:02:54] Thank you. [0:02:55] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:02:56] Okay. [0:02:57] So if you're here for the fill the boot fund racer, that has been approved. [0:03:00] So next moving on to items of consideration, we have one item tonight, but it's a big E. [0:03:07] We have a presentation of the city manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2324 followed [0:03:13] by citizen input and we have Gretchen's God, our deputy city manager. [0:03:18] Welcome Gretchen. [0:03:19] Welcome and good evening. [0:03:21] I know the packet is impressive in size but we promise to be concise. [0:03:26] All right, very good. [0:03:36] So through July here we have been presenting through various staff and departments. [0:03:44] proposed fiscal year 24 budget and as it relates to our strategic plan and the [0:03:52] progress and the steps that we've made in the last fiscal year as that's moving [0:03:56] forward. I will recap as we have been some of the pieces as we have gone into [0:04:03] the budget planning and how it affects our residents and taxpayers before we [0:04:07] We finish on the last focus area of the strategic plan, focus area eight. [0:04:14] So we set the vision and the goals of each budget that we create in order to be responsive [0:04:22] and responsible in how we are creating the budget packet in general. [0:04:27] We have the obligation to make sure that it is stable and that it is sustainable given [0:04:32] the economic changes and conditions that are happening both globally and within our nation. [0:04:38] We have to be sensitive to the operating environment and recognize that local pressures such as [0:04:43] housing and labor create a very difficult environment to operate in and make sure that [0:04:48] we have the right resources for the people that are working here. [0:04:54] Because we are progress oriented, we tie all of our expenditures directly to the strategic [0:04:59] plan and making sure that we're accomplishing the vision pieces that are in that plan. [0:05:07] Given the competition for labor, we have to be the employer of choice and that means putting [0:05:13] our team first. [0:05:15] That means that we have an effort every time to look at compensation, benefits and our policies [0:05:20] to make sure that what we are providing is supportive and responsible in how we treat [0:05:25] our employees. [0:05:29] By code and by responsibility, we have to balance available revenues against those expenses, [0:05:34] making sure that we don't have an undue burden on our taxpayers and our community. [0:05:40] And that also includes minimizing our utility rate increases to what's necessary in order [0:05:45] to meet bond covenants, expenses, and ongoing maintenance costs in order to ensure the infrastructure [0:05:52] that we have in our systems. [0:05:57] As we have been presenting, we are trying to get to the punch line first. [0:06:02] I want to just put a note out here and say that today, our finance team received some [0:06:07] updated numbers. [0:06:09] This slide will change next week as well as the next couple of slides. [0:06:13] They were firming up those numbers and so we did not want to prematurely present them, [0:06:18] but I wanted to let you know that next week this will look a little different. [0:06:24] If you look at this slide from a standpoint of what the average home or median home cost, [0:06:31] which was 352,000 in January of 23, and that number hasn't changed or indexed very much [0:06:38] as we're sitting in now basically the 1st of August, we're still at about 350,000. [0:06:45] The impact of the budget that we have prepared keeps the tax rate generally the same. [0:06:52] And against the property valuations that the Assessors put out, the average homeowner, [0:06:57] If this was what the value of your home would be, would be looking at an increase of $3.65 [0:07:03] per month, or an annual cost of $43.77 in property tax, and again, this number will modify slightly [0:07:11] next week. [0:07:13] The utility bills and the utility rates that are proposed for this coming fiscal year for [0:07:18] water a two percent increase two and a half. I just think that I was missing a half and [0:07:28] also for sewer and those rate adjustments and no adjustment to sanitation is projected for [0:07:34] this next year are looking at a five dollar and seventy cent monthly increase for property [0:07:40] for utility bills. So the total of those so the total of the utility rate increases [0:07:47] are about $68 per year, and then the annual increase for the property tax of $43.77. [0:07:55] That would be the new burden to our homeowners. [0:08:03] Over the last few years, the City of Twin Falls taxable value has seen significant increase, [0:08:08] and this number will also be adjusted next week based on the addition of the URA properties [0:08:14] that are closing. [0:08:18] You can see about a 50 percent increase from just two years ago from what we have gained [0:08:24] overall in our values. [0:08:30] I wanted to spend just a little bit of time on this slide to talk in general about what [0:08:35] is included in roughly the $10 million increase in total net expenses. [0:08:42] As we have talked about this in the last few presentations, we have focused primarily on [0:08:46] SLF RF funds, but there are some additional pieces that I just want to touch on again, [0:08:52] And they've been presented in the individual focus areas. [0:08:56] In the general fund, part of that $5 million increase includes the two lease payments for [0:09:01] the fire trucks, the total $744,000. [0:09:07] In addition, it also includes the $1.3 million that we have been allocated for the transit [0:09:13] program and funding the new Twin Falls Ride TFT and the position, the transit coordinator [0:09:20] that is assisting in that program. [0:09:24] the enterprise funds, there is $755,000, which is mainly attributed to the electric and Idaho [0:09:33] power rate increases that's associated with our water department. [0:09:38] And in wastewater collections, we have about $1.6 million increase in M&L and ongoing maintenance [0:09:45] and capital improvements that they're going to be doing for line infrastructure replacement. [0:09:51] And then finally, in airport construction, still under enterprise funds, about $2.2 million [0:09:56] in construction projects that are scheduled to go forward this next year. [0:10:00] So significant infrastructure, significant assets and capital purchases that are being [0:10:05] made. [0:10:07] Finally, there are some general fund increases that HR is going to be touching on, which [0:10:12] talk about the personnel-related costs that are part of being the employer of choice and [0:10:16] maintaining our compensation and benefit package. [0:10:28] So as we have moved forward, you can see that again, [0:10:31] our tax rate continues to be one of the lowest [0:10:34] that the city has issued. [0:10:37] We believe that our conservative approach, [0:10:40] our responsible planning and our effort to balance out [0:10:45] our expenses helps maintain that low rate for our citizens. [0:10:51] Any questions on the budget pieces that I've provided to you [0:10:54] before we get into the focus area? [0:10:57] Any questions for Gretchen? [0:11:00] thorough. Thank you. Thank you. So as we've talked about we start with the overview of [0:11:07] the budget piece and then we go into this specific focus areas of the strategic [0:11:11] plan. We believe that we have the overall view of our mission and our [0:11:18] guiding principles and policies and those direct the efforts of each one of our [0:11:23] focus areas that all are related to and dependent on the work of our internal [0:11:30] organization. We are a service organization and it takes people to perform the work that [0:11:35] we do in order to accomplish the overall vision. So with that, I will give you to our capital [0:11:44] chief primary people person and that would be Ida Clark, our HR director. [0:11:50] No, that is some title. Good evening, Madam Mayor and council members. In the 2030 vision [0:12:04] and for the internal organization. [0:12:06] It talks about the City of Twin Falls [0:12:09] will strive to carry out the mission [0:12:11] within question, integrity, and the highest ethical standards. [0:12:14] In its role as stewards of community assets, [0:12:17] it will focus on proper use of available resources [0:12:20] and continually assess programs and processes [0:12:22] to ensure maximum effectiveness. [0:12:27] So one of our core values is integrity. [0:12:30] And as we work through this presentation tonight, [0:12:32] we have carefully balanced assets [0:12:33] while assessing programs and processes. [0:12:36] We have also kept the sentence, a high level of competencies provided from a lean and properly [0:12:41] compensated and respected core staff at the forefront of our decisions. [0:12:48] Keeping in line with our organizational goals as well, we have budgeted a 4% performance [0:12:54] increase and a 5% table adjustment. [0:12:58] The average salary increase for both private and public is projected at 4.1% nationwide. [0:13:04] We did participate into salary surveys in the early spring and based on the comparison [0:13:09] and review of the surveys in order to continue to properly compensate staff a 5% table adjustment [0:13:16] is needed. [0:13:17] While career fields like engineering and legal continue to outpace us in the private industry, [0:13:23] we remain very competitive in the other career fields. [0:13:27] We filled out a 4% increase in a 5% table adjustment or justifiable to employees and [0:13:32] sustainable to the city. We have budgeted to continue the employee retention pay [0:13:38] program. For employees who have completed five full years, the city will offer a [0:13:42] tiered retention program that provides a financial incentive for a three-year [0:13:47] commitment of service. We have also elected to remain the select health for [0:13:53] medical insurance. We did receive a 7.2% increase in the premiums. This was [0:13:58] better news as it was lower than we had projected. The city covers 100% [0:14:03] percent of the employee premiums in a significant portion of [0:14:07] dependent coverage. [0:14:08] Depending on the employee's participation in our healthy [0:14:11] living program, the increase to the monthly premium for the [0:14:13] employee would be anywhere from $5 to $30. [0:14:19] I also wanted to note for the budget that the total annual [0:14:25] purchase of health insurance is $5.7 million. [0:14:28] Employees share in this cost, and moving forward, we will [0:14:32] begin investigating again self-insurance to see if that is [0:14:35] is something that would be viable for the city. [0:14:42] We have also transitioned funding, current funding, [0:14:46] that we had for the one-time $2,000 payment [0:14:48] to, for the parallel teams, propose changes [0:14:52] to a new leave-a-cruel program and implementation [0:14:55] of a health reimbursement arrangement. [0:14:57] That's otherwise known as an HRA Viva. [0:15:00] And this proposal includes a tenure-based vacation system [0:15:03] and medical leave-a-cruel per pay period. [0:15:06] and the HRIVB as a post-separation account [0:15:09] that would replace our current retirement bank hours. [0:15:17] So to move on to, as we previously stated, [0:15:20] we strive to maintain a highly qualified and lean staff, [0:15:23] and after careful review and consideration, [0:15:25] we are requesting four new positions [0:15:29] and three upgrades to current full-time positions. [0:15:32] Three of those new positions are full-time, [0:15:34] and one is part-time. [0:15:37] The requested part-time custodian [0:15:38] will be combined with an already budgeted part-time custodian. [0:15:42] And our hopes is that having one full-time position [0:15:44] for custodian, we will receive more applicants that [0:15:48] are interested in full-time work and benefits. [0:15:51] That position would be shared between the airport and city hall. [0:15:54] The transit coordinator position is currently funded [0:15:57] through a grant. [0:15:58] It is a two-year grant, and when that is complete, [0:16:00] we will fully fund that position. [0:16:03] The building department is reducing their full-time positions [0:16:06] by one. [0:16:07] And then you will note that we did have, we have five other positions that were requested [0:16:12] and discussed during our budget process. [0:16:15] There are five firefighter positions that you will see on there that will be worked through [0:16:21] with a safer grant. [0:16:23] And these are true and give, true give and take conversations that we have. [0:16:27] They are difficult, but we have to consider the overall organization and our strategic [0:16:32] objectives when we're pushing forward these positions. [0:16:34] Okay, now that we have our compensation in place, we want to talk a little bit about recruitment. [0:16:42] So speaking of our benefits, we do preload vacation and sick for our new hires. [0:16:48] Employees receive at least 40 hours of sick and vacation. [0:16:50] New hires have expressed their appreciation for this benefit. [0:16:54] As life goes on, when you change jobs, you still have doctor's appointments and children [0:16:58] still get sick. [0:17:01] True to our vision as well, we are finding ways to streamline applicant process. [0:17:06] The applicant process has been streamlined for making it easier for applicants to apply. [0:17:11] Kaitlyn has also been working with LaserFishing IT to make it easier for references to respond [0:17:16] to her. [0:17:17] We are also using Microsoft Bookings. [0:17:19] What this does is applicants can go in and schedule their interviews on their own time, [0:17:23] so that reduces the follow-up that our staff has and coordination in those interviews. [0:17:30] Currently, applicants do pay a $25 testing fee, so we have budgeted $2,000 to cover those [0:17:37] testing fees we're hoping that that helps incentivize some who may not want to pay [0:17:42] to test and then also we have removed that test from some of our processes where we [0:17:47] did not feel that that was valid anymore. You'll see that we have done 34 external [0:17:52] recruitments 15 internal and internal promotions and assignment opportunities [0:17:58] we have hired 40 new hires from October to July. Today is July 31st [0:18:05] I was August. [0:18:07] So we have also requested 22,000 for continued psychological exams. [0:18:12] This is for police, fire, and dispatch. [0:18:16] This is an imperative step in our background process. [0:18:18] We do use a renowned and respected psychologist in the public safety realm. [0:18:23] We have also budgeted additional 15,000 for fire comprehensive wellness screenings. [0:18:28] This will allow a more in-depth medical screening that's relevant to the firefighters for the [0:18:32] exposures that they have on some of their calls. [0:18:36] And I did put up here our statement that we have changed [0:18:39] and added to our job recruitment page. [0:18:42] And we like to think of it as an open invitation [0:18:45] to apply for what we believe as the employer of choice. [0:18:51] And talking about health and wellness, [0:18:53] again, that is part of our goals [0:18:55] and our internal strategic plan. [0:18:59] And so we have budgeted $7500 for new gym equipment. [0:19:03] We've heard from our employees that they love the gym [0:19:05] and they would like to keep utilizing it [0:19:07] and that some new equipment is needed. [0:19:09] We've also budgeted 1700 for onsite luncheon learns. [0:19:13] Christian recently sent out an employee survey [0:19:15] asking for topics that employees would like to see [0:19:18] covered at these luncheon learns, [0:19:19] and then also she has started having them out [0:19:22] at departments and different times [0:19:24] that are better to accommodate the employees [0:19:27] when they can sit down and learn [0:19:28] and then possibly even bring in their spouses. [0:19:31] On August 24th, we will have, [0:19:34] we're going to be bringing back the employee health fair. [0:19:36] So that is open to all employees and their families. [0:19:39] And Kristin is currently working on streamlining [0:19:41] the first report of injury, which helps us process [0:19:44] and move along workers' compensation a little bit faster. [0:19:48] Onto the risk management side, [0:19:50] we have streamlined that process. [0:19:52] Citizens can file their torque claims online, [0:19:55] and then employees can also report property damage online [0:19:59] as well, and that comes directly [0:20:00] into Kristin and I to work through. [0:20:02] Last year, we did go direct insured, so that means we removed the broker, and by doing that, [0:20:08] it did reduce our liability premium by about $46,000. [0:20:12] Okay, I want to talk a little bit about engagement, so every year we do an employee engagement survey, [0:20:19] and the good news is that it does keep going up, so we came back at $74.59, the share. [0:20:25] So again, that's another little increase. I did want to note that the most recent Gallup poll [0:20:30] has that 31%. So only 31% nationwide is engaged at work. So for us to be at 74 and then continuing [0:20:38] to increase speech volumes to the culture that we have here at the city. Some of the other items [0:20:46] that we talk about, the good, we heard a lot about benefits, flexible work schedules and co-workers, [0:20:52] and then we also asked some areas they'd like to see us improve, and they did ask for us to [0:20:57] continue working on communications supervisor training in our One City [0:21:00] Palisius. I did want to go over a couple of specific questions in this survey and [0:21:06] in number four is in the last two weeks I have received feedback from my [0:21:10] supervisor about my job. That is a direct correlation we believe to our parallel [0:21:14] teams work the performance development team and that is they put in a yearly [0:21:19] performance evaluation and then also the mid-year check-ins. So you can see that [0:21:23] had a pretty big increase more excited to see employees are feeling that they're [0:21:28] hearing from their supervisors. Question number nine was I have authority to make [0:21:32] decisions which enable me to do my job. Again we believe this is a direct [0:21:38] correlation to the city's values in the high performance training that we have [0:21:41] been conducting and then number 11 my organization provides opportunities to [0:21:46] learn and develop and we have hired we hired a full-time position the [0:21:51] organizational development coordinator and again we believe that could be [0:21:55] correlated back to the trainings and the ongoing one city that we have. I want to [0:22:02] touch real quickly on our parallel teams because I don't think we've mentioned [0:22:06] that a lot and it is these are part of our one city high performance concepts so [0:22:11] we already have some that are active we have four teams that have accomplished [0:22:14] their mission and have disbanded the performance development team is wrapping [0:22:18] up right now but the leave a cruel team is a perfect example of our outcomes it [0:22:23] was a three-year process however this budget does include the proposed leave [0:22:26] of accrual changes that do provide a greater benefit [0:22:29] to our employees. [0:22:33] Moving on to organizational development, [0:22:36] we have budgeted 12,500 for supervisor training [0:22:41] on DE&I and emotional intelligence. [0:22:44] And I want us to remember that everyone of us [0:22:46] in this room here tonight, we are part of different groups, [0:22:49] and so we are all part of a different generation. [0:22:53] We all came up in a different household makeup, [0:22:56] and right now we're all part [0:22:57] of a different household makeup as well. [0:22:59] We have all experienced different historical events [0:23:01] that have shaped us. [0:23:03] We come from different background, education-wise, [0:23:06] and we or even our family members may have a disability. [0:23:10] So part of the benefits of having an emotional intelligence [0:23:13] in a DE&I training is communication [0:23:16] is improved between team members, [0:23:18] thanks to a better understanding of differences. [0:23:21] Job satisfaction and morale are increased [0:23:22] because employees feel respected and valued. [0:23:25] Discrimination workplaces reduce things to better education. [0:23:29] and customer services improved through enriched recognition and understanding of the needs of our [0:23:34] customers. So this is not only relevant to our team members but also to the community that we serve. [0:23:40] So inclusivity means that our staff has plenty of viewpoints to utilize our innovation, [0:23:45] problem solving and effective decision making. I said right through that. So I know what is [0:23:54] It is diversity equity and inclusion. [0:23:59] Thank you. [0:24:00] So I am going to transition to Ancina, but I'm happy to answer any questions before I have [0:24:07] Ancina come up. [0:24:08] Any questions for Ancina? [0:24:10] All right. [0:24:13] Thank you very much. [0:24:14] Welcome, Ancina. [0:24:19] Good evening, Madam Mayor and City Council members. [0:24:23] So included in your handouts is a copy of our one city pillars. [0:24:29] This is the foundation to our One City High Performance Organization training. [0:24:36] The One City training is our collaborative effort to provide each employee with an overview of [0:24:41] our high performance philosophies and structures. [0:24:45] Employees leave the training inspired to innovate and also are empowered to make process changes [0:24:52] for the benefit of all stakeholders. [0:24:55] Why do we love One City? [0:24:58] It's a true investment in our employee and the organization, and our leaders recognize [0:25:03] that our employees are worth the investment. [0:25:11] This fiscal year we provided numerous learning and development opportunities for our employees. [0:25:17] We held our first One City book hub with Jonathan Stenlove facilitating the conversation, Sergeant [0:25:24] Dusty Solomon and Megan Humboldt provided mental health for state training, and in a [0:25:29] continued effort to provide new employees with an overview of the city as an organization, [0:25:35] we now provide Myers-Briggs training and employee orientation on a quarterly basis. [0:25:42] Since October 2022, EMT members have delivered three four-day one-city trainings. [0:25:51] With another one coming up in September and our first two-day in December, we will finish [0:25:57] this fiscal year with having 87 employees complete the One City training at an approximate [0:26:03] cost of 1,600 per training. We continue to count for inflation while budgeting for this [0:26:10] ongoing cost to provide meals and training materials for this all day training. [0:26:16] 31,000 is budgeted for our annual city retreat, employee recognition luncheons, military plaque, [0:26:27] summer, picnic, and one employee breakfast. We have an employee recognition every quarter. [0:26:35] Through the Employee Recognition Program, we come together to celebrate and recognize the [0:26:40] actions of our colleagues who go above and beyond to care for others in our organization [0:26:46] and in the community. These employees exhibit the one city values of integrity, connection, [0:26:53] Honesty, commitment, and teamwork. [0:26:57] ELT and EMT appreciate being able to connect [0:27:01] with these employees on a personal level, and this year marked us [0:27:05] coming back together in person to celebrate the good work being done at the city. [0:27:09] And thank you to the council members that were also able [0:27:13] to join us in recognizing our employees. [0:27:21] In recognition and support of our employees' continued service [0:27:25] In commitment to keeping our nation safe, we installed a military plaque tribute along with [0:27:31] military branch flags in the city hall lobby. We filled a large military plaque with our employees [0:27:38] name and I'm pleased to say that we have since started a smaller plaque in support of our military [0:27:45] employees. The city currently has one employee deployed. The employee breakfast continues to [0:27:56] be a way for employees to connect outside of their departments. It reflects our teamwork culture [0:28:02] by helping to create meaningful relationships and breakdown silos throughout our organization. [0:28:07] We had 175 employees attend last fall and 185 employees attend the spring at an average cost of [0:28:15] $2,600 for each breakfast. This year's budget includes a continuation of the breakfast. [0:28:23] The City continues to invest in employees by creating an inviting learning environment. [0:28:35] Various updates have been made to the innovation room over the course of the year. [0:28:40] HR purchased extra tables, a podium, and a stool for our instructors. [0:28:45] Additionally, IT upgraded the laptop, installed two touchscreen TVs and a sound bar at an [0:28:52] approximate cost of $3,500. [0:28:56] We hope to continue to improve the room by installing two air units during the next fiscal [0:29:01] year, which Gretchen will touch upon in the 770 slide. [0:29:06] We recognize that delivering a great learner experience has an impact on organizational [0:29:12] health metrics, like employee engagement, improved productivity, and workforce retention rates. [0:29:20] This concludes my portion of the presentation. [0:29:23] Are there any questions? [0:29:25] Any questions for Encina? [0:29:28] Okay, thank you. I will now turn the presentation back over to deputy city manager Gretchen Scott [0:29:36] So as we have the last couple of years we could your last couple of weeks we continue to add to this slide for the council directed capital [0:29:53] The 770,000 that was taken as part of foregone for gone amounts several years ago that you've been directing us to spend on very specific projects [0:30:02] The only thing that is added today is $20,000 for HVAC improvements in the training room. [0:30:12] We got a quote for the unit that we would install, and these are the, other, aren't any [0:30:17] in this room, but they're the wall-mounted unit that supplies both heat and air conditioning [0:30:23] to the room. [0:30:24] We had a local vendor come and give us assessment of the room. [0:30:30] isn't enough airflow currently. And so it wasn't necessarily designed for the use [0:30:37] that we are using it for. It was just a shell space. Human resources has been [0:30:44] using it pretty consistently as a training facility in order to improve [0:30:48] the conditions, the comfort level of the people that participate. That's what we're [0:30:54] looking at in terms of that process. It's about $20,000, $10,000 for the unit itself. [0:31:00] and then we're estimating the installation costs. [0:31:03] The roofer that performed the work on the membrane [0:31:06] that was part of construction of this building [0:31:09] wasn't able to provide us a quote [0:31:11] for the actual installation yet, [0:31:13] but they said that they'll continue to work on that. [0:31:15] So we'll refine that number as we get better numbers. [0:31:18] I know that there are some additional items [0:31:22] to be considered as part of this [0:31:24] that we're hoping to have information for you [0:31:26] before we get to the conclusion [0:31:28] of all of the budget presentations. [0:31:31] So that concludes tonight's budget presentation [0:31:34] and focus area eight. [0:31:37] Next budget presentation will be conducted by Travis [0:31:42] and reviewing those more specific numbers [0:31:45] that we've gotten from the county [0:31:47] and refined through the finance team. [0:31:50] So with that, any questions? [0:31:52] Any questions for Gretchen? [0:31:56] Doesn't look like it. [0:31:57] Excellent, thank you. [0:31:58] Thank you. [0:32:01] Moving right along. [0:32:02] So next on the agenda is a time for general public input. [0:32:06] The first part will be any public input anyone has [0:32:11] on the budget itself. [0:32:13] So if there's anybody in the audience [0:32:15] that wishes to comment on the budget, [0:32:18] please come down to the podium. [0:32:22] Okay, seeing no one general public input, [0:32:26] anybody here from the public that wishes to address council [0:32:30] and anything other than the budget on items [0:32:33] not on today's agenda. Yes, sir. Please come down and state your name and whether [0:32:39] you're a resident of Twin Falls and you have two minutes. My name is Kyle Parrish. [0:32:45] I'm a resident of Twin Falls and I just want to quickly point out that this area [0:32:51] Idaho is one of the few places that we grow this call, call the new potatoes, we've [0:32:57] We've been losing 350,000 acres of farmland every year, [0:33:02] and I just want to suggest starting building up [0:33:05] because I think it's more efficient. [0:33:07] And I have an idea of how to build a rec center [0:33:10] in with an apartment building where either where [0:33:14] the old hospital was on Showstone Street or the lot [0:33:19] next to the school building on Main Street. [0:33:22] Thank you. [0:33:23] Thank you. Anybody else that wishes to speak to Council? [0:33:32] Okay, see no one advisory board reports. [0:33:34] Anything from the Council on meetings? [0:33:38] Anybody, anything from the City Manager's Office? [0:33:41] We do, we have a couple of quick items. [0:33:43] Madam Mayor, members of the Council, as you know, [0:33:46] this Wednesday at seven o'clock, [0:33:48] we are going to have our annual State of the City address, [0:33:51] in which members of the City Council [0:33:53] will be engaging on certain topic areas [0:33:56] and then selecting or taking the opportunity [0:33:59] to address questions on a myriad of things. [0:34:03] So again, 7 a.m. at second street market. [0:34:07] Please RSVP with the Chamber of Commerce [0:34:11] if you want to have breakfast, if you just want to come. [0:34:13] There is no cost. [0:34:16] There's a ribbon cutting for our new microtransit program. [0:34:20] It's going to be this Thursday at 2 o'clock. [0:34:24] It's going to be right around the downtown comments areas [0:34:28] where we'll be doing that downtown, that ribbon cutting. [0:34:32] And then it's alluded to by Gretchen next week, [0:34:34] we are going to have the first official action [0:34:37] that you'll take on the budget. [0:34:40] Over the course of the last seven weeks, [0:34:43] we've been sharing the budget by focus area. [0:34:47] At the next meeting, you will be adopting the tentative budget [0:34:52] and that tentative budget will set your maximum spending caps. [0:34:57] And so at that point in time, you cannot raise any expenditure above that cap. [0:35:03] In addition to that, we'll be asking you to set the official public hearing for the 21st of August. [0:35:13] And then also tomorrow night is National Night Out, it begins at 5 o'clock PM in City Park. [0:35:22] So there's a full whole host of events [0:35:27] in the last of the heat of the summer days. [0:35:31] Thank you, Travis. [0:35:33] OK, so we have two public hearings tonight. [0:35:35] They're not till 6 o'clock. [0:35:37] Are you guys want to move into executive session [0:35:40] for 25 minutes till that's all right? [0:35:43] OK, so again, the public hearings [0:35:48] will be 6 at 6 o'clock. [0:35:49] but we have on the agenda and action item under 74-2061A [0:35:55] to consider hiring a public officer employees staff member [0:35:59] or individual agent. [0:36:00] We're in the respective qualities of the individual or to be [0:36:03] evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need. [0:36:07] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy [0:36:10] in elective office or deliberations about staffing needs [0:36:13] in general. [0:36:15] So I just need a motion. [0:36:16] So moved. [0:36:17] Thank you. [0:36:18] Do I have a second? [0:36:19] Second. [0:36:20] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to move into executive session under 74-206-1A. [0:36:28] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:36:30] Chris Reed. [0:36:31] Yes. [0:36:32] Thank you Boyd. [0:36:33] Yes. [0:36:34] Greg Hawkins. [0:36:35] Yes. [0:36:36] Jason Brown. [0:36:37] Yes. [0:36:38] Alex Koval. [0:36:39] Yes. [0:36:40] Spencer Cutler. [0:36:41] Yes. [0:36:42] And Ruth Pierce. [0:36:43] Yes. [0:36:44] Motion passes 7-0. [0:36:45] We will be coming back in about 20 plus minutes for public hearing. [0:36:48] Thank you. [0:59:52] Okay, good evening again, ladies and gentlemen. [0:59:56] We're reconvening from our executive session. [1:00:00] It's time for the public hearing portion of our meeting. [1:00:04] First, we have two public hearings tonight. [1:00:08] I'll read the rules first and then we'll move into the first one. [1:00:14] We shall follow these nine steps for each request listed under the public hearing portion [1:00:18] of the agenda. [1:00:20] City staff will present the request and analysis. [1:00:23] The applicant will then present their request. [1:00:26] The council will ask questions of the applicant or staff. [1:00:31] After questions have been answered, the public hearing will be open. [1:00:35] During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions [1:00:39] about the request being considered. [1:00:42] When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address and present [1:00:46] your comments. [1:00:47] After giving testimony, please sign the public sign and she located in the lobby with your [1:00:52] name and address for the record. After public comments are concluded, the applicant will [1:00:57] be invited to answer any questions and make a closing statement. Staff will then answer [1:01:02] clarify any comments as needed. After the closing statements, the public hearing will [1:01:07] be closed, no further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed, [1:01:14] and then the council will have open discussion and take action. [1:01:19] So our first public hearing is a request for an annexation of property with a zoning designation [1:01:27] of C1 and R6 located on the northwest corner of 3300 East and Kimberly Road, Carav Sidlithomis, [1:01:35] PZ23, Dazz 0, 0, 3, 3, and we have Lisa Strickland, our city planner. [1:01:41] Welcome, Lisa. [1:01:42] Good evening, Council. [1:01:45] This is a request for zoning district change for approximately 40 acres proposed to be annexed [1:01:52] into the city with a zoning designation of R6 and C1. [1:01:57] Property is located at the northwest corner of Kimberly Road in 3300 east and it is currently [1:02:02] zoned R1 variable and is undeveloped. [1:02:07] The applicant would like to plan for the C1 zone to extend approximately 1,000 feet north [1:02:16] from Kimberly Road frontage with the remaining property being rezoned R6 which allows for [1:02:23] single family up to multifamily which is 5 units or more. [1:02:28] The property is currently in the C1's area of impact and therefore would need to be annexed [1:02:32] to receive centralized water and sewer services. [1:02:36] These services are not currently available, therefore making the development dependent [1:02:40] upon these improvements being made. [1:02:43] To the north is rural residential, to the east is undeveloped, and with some rural residential [1:02:51] to the northeast that is located within the Kimberley area of impact. [1:02:57] And Chobani is on the south side of Kimberley Road, and the future land use map for this [1:03:04] property is mixed use and typically mixed use serves local and regional areas. It sits [1:03:12] at an intersection of a major arterial, anchored by a grocery store, civic or entertainment [1:03:18] uses and is pedestrian oriented. Examples of land uses would be retail, office, restaurant, [1:03:25] civic and cultural entertainment, mixed housing, hotels, plazas and parks. The density for [1:03:31] So this type of area would be 10 to 20 dwelling units per acre and the proposed R6 C1 zoning [1:03:38] designation would be compatible with the comprehensive plan designed, described as mixed [1:03:46] use. [1:03:50] This slide shows approximately how deep the 1,000 feet would encroach into the lot and [1:03:57] the amount that would be left for the R6 zoning. [1:04:00] The property to the east is in the Kimberley Road area of impact and their plan shows commercial [1:04:06] would be approximately 500 feet from Kimberley Road and residential would be further north. [1:04:13] The applicant does not currently have plans for the development of this property should [1:04:17] the property re-zoned and annexed into city. [1:04:21] Any further plans for property development would require plating the property. [1:04:26] The R6 designation would require centralized city services for development and would allow [1:04:32] for, as I said previously, single family, duplex, triplex, fourplex, and multifamily five units [1:04:39] or more. [1:04:40] The commercial zoning designation would allow for the retail and many other commercial-oriented [1:04:45] businesses that could be beneficial to the surrounding area. [1:04:49] The property is located along a major arterial that has been constructed to withstand the [1:04:53] traffic that would be generated by a mixed-use development. [1:04:57] For City Code, prior to the annexation or the incorporation of this area, the Council [1:05:03] shall request and receive a recommendation from the Commission on the proposed plan and [1:05:09] prior to adopting a zoning ordinance for changing it to the city limits. [1:05:15] The City Council has to hold a public hearing. [1:05:18] The planning is owning held a hearing on June 13th and they met a recommendation to [1:05:23] to approve the request as presented. [1:05:26] The commission is tasked to make a recommendation [1:05:28] to the council on the zoning, [1:05:32] and the council is tasked with making a decision [1:05:35] on the zoning as well as the annexation of the property [1:05:38] into the city limits. [1:05:43] That concludes my presentation. [1:05:46] If you have any questions, I'll stand for those, [1:05:48] and the applicant is also here for any questions as well. [1:05:52] Any questions for Lisa? [1:05:56] Okay, you said she have, come on up. [1:06:08] Good evening, council members. [1:06:10] Thank you for your time tonight. [1:06:12] I thought Lisa did an excellent job, [1:06:14] so I don't really have anything to add to what she said. [1:06:17] I would stand for questions if there are any. [1:06:21] Any questions for Lisa at this time? [1:06:24] Excellent. [1:06:25] Thank you, sir. [1:06:26] Thank you. [1:06:29] Okay, so that being done, [1:06:31] I'm going to open up the public hearing. [1:06:34] Anybody in the public who wishes to address the council [1:06:38] on this particular issue, please come down to the podium. [1:06:45] Seeing no one, I would assume there's no further input [1:06:49] from either one applicant or Lisa, [1:06:55] you don't have anything else to add. [1:06:57] Hey, I'm going to close the public hearing [1:07:00] and council discussion. [1:07:06] I think it's pretty straightforward. [1:07:08] I'd certainly encourage that. [1:07:10] Okay, Chris Reed. [1:07:13] I don't have any comments. [1:07:14] I agree. [1:07:15] I'll make a motion for ready. [1:07:17] Perfect. [1:07:18] How does everybody, anybody else have a comment? [1:07:21] Hey, Chris, we're, yes. [1:07:23] Okay, I moved that. [1:07:25] Wait a minute. [1:07:25] I'm gonna give small legal advice. [1:07:27] Can somebody please reference the comprehensive plan [1:07:29] and discussion on being conforming to that? [1:07:32] We have it in our report. [1:07:33] I just need confirmation in the minutes from that. [1:07:35] As part of the? [1:07:37] As part of your discussion. [1:07:39] Why don't you stay there just in case I miss that. [1:07:42] Well, that's fine. [1:07:43] So you want it in the motion, is my question. [1:07:45] No, you just, in your discussion, [1:07:47] you say you've consulted the comprehensive plan. [1:07:49] You believe it is in conformance to that. [1:07:51] The state statute requires you to consult the plan [1:07:54] while you're making your decision. [1:07:55] Okay. [1:07:56] Simply to be stated there in the minutes. [1:07:58] To that effect, Mr. Spendlove, [1:08:00] have you reviewed the comprehensive plan [1:08:02] in connection with this application? [1:08:04] Yes, in our report, yes. [1:08:06] And does this proposed land use comply [1:08:10] with our comprehensive plan? [1:08:12] Staff believes it does. [1:08:13] All right, thank you. [1:08:14] Thank you. [1:08:16] Any other discussion before we move to a motion? [1:08:19] Jonathan, is that adequate? [1:08:21] Okay. [1:08:22] Chris Reed. [1:08:24] I move that we approve the annexation of property [1:08:26] with a zoning designation of C1 and R6 located [1:08:30] at the northwest corner of 3300 East [1:08:33] and Kimberly Road, Carap Cidlith-Sommies. [1:08:36] second Jason Brown second thank you motion by Christopher Reed seconded by [1:08:41] Jason Brown to approve the annexation of property with the zoning designation of [1:08:46] C1 and R6 located at the northwest corner of 3300 East and Kimberly Road [1:08:52] Amy Roquevo please. Hey keep Boyd yes Frank Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes Alex [1:09:01] Thank you, motion passes seven to zero. [1:09:08] Thank you, Sid. [1:09:11] Okay, next public hearing is an action item. [1:09:15] I am going to have to recuse myself from voting or discussing this. [1:09:20] I'm personal friends, business relationship with the applicant. [1:09:25] So I will be stepping down and vice mayor Chris read will take over. [1:09:30] On to our next item a public hearing and action item request for a rezoning of [1:10:02] property from R4 Pro to C1 located at the northwest corner of Washington [1:10:08] Street and Robbins Avenue care of Elmer Blakey on behalf of Penelope L. [1:10:15] Parker and we have Jonathan spend up here. Thank you. Let's be a read this [1:10:21] This property, I'm going to show the zoning of the Sydney map here, this large is basically [1:10:26] square here at the northwest corner has described, has been re has been zoned R4 Pro for quite [1:10:34] some time has been undeveloped as far as we can actually tell in any records that we have [1:10:39] available to us. [1:10:41] The applicant is asking to rezone it to see one to have more opportunities to market the [1:10:45] property. [1:10:46] They've had limited, I guess, movement on an R4 Pro so they're seeking to see one [1:10:52] to have a broader scope of uses that they could look for. [1:10:56] When rezoning the property, you'll be looking at the future land use map. [1:11:00] This shows a town, sorry, neighborhood commercial, [1:11:03] along Washington Street, neighborhood commercial, [1:11:06] as various uses, basically neighborhood serving, commercial retail offices. [1:11:12] The C1 zone accomplishes that, I'd say, mostly. [1:11:16] It also allows for larger buildings that are normally found, like, in a neighborhood. [1:11:21] But setbacks, landscaping and parking requirements kind of limit the size of that. [1:11:28] A C1 zone does allow buildings to go up to 50 feet tall, but they do have to maintain a [1:11:33] 25 foot setback from anything that's residentially zoned nearby. [1:11:37] So there is some protection, not when it's across the street, but when it's adjacent property [1:11:42] lines. [1:11:43] So anything to the west, have a 25 foot setback for that. [1:11:46] The nearest C1 zone is found down Washington towards this intersection of Caswell. [1:11:53] There's some commercially zoned properties and then along that corridor, those are C1 [1:11:56] zoned as well. [1:11:57] So C1 is not unheard of in this area. [1:12:02] In terms of the types of uses, C1 has a lot of different types of retail. [1:12:08] Commercial, there's even some multi-family allowance for it. [1:12:12] When making your decision, you should take into account the comprehensive plan, the feature [1:12:17] use map and the recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission which was [1:12:21] recommended approval by a vote of six to zero and your task is to make a decision [1:12:27] on rezoning the property to see one or you could recommend a different zone or make a [1:12:33] different zone with your request with your approval. You can table the item for [1:12:38] additional specific information if you had any. That is all I have. The applicant is [1:12:44] here for their presentation. Thank you. Any questions for Jonathan right now? [1:12:52] Alex Cabal. [1:12:54] Yes, Jonathan on this one. Same question as the last one. How does the C1 designation for [1:13:01] this proposed redevelop or rezoning comply with our comprehensive plan? [1:13:07] So this witness shows the neighborhood commercial. The comprehensive plan has this as the neighborhood [1:13:13] commercial, I guess, the vision for that area. Supporting services small scale surrounding [1:13:20] the neighborhood design of complimented neighborhood character, some mix of uses, townhomes, condominiums, [1:13:25] apartments, senior housing. All of those items are in the C1 zone, including a few more. [1:13:31] The one detriment, if there is to a C1 zone, is the list is broader than that, and there's [1:13:38] limited I would say protection for neighboring properties that are adjacent [1:13:45] because of the height that is allowed at 50 feet all residential properties have [1:13:50] a 35-foot height max so it's something to be taken into account that doesn't mean [1:13:55] that it doesn't comply the final decision rests with the council on whether it [1:13:59] does or not. Thank you Jason Jonathan how taught with those those complex is [1:14:07] there for CSI and the R6. That was kind of the first, what, how would that, would it be [1:14:13] within that 35 foot? I'm just trying to get a, get a reference on. So yeah, the campus park [1:14:20] up here on the northwest corner are, I believe, at 35 feet at all. They're, they're at that [1:14:24] maximum. These other dorms don't go that high. They're in that upper 20s. Okay. And then you [1:14:31] did say, let's say a half a mile, no more than a mile down the street. There is commercial [1:14:37] that would that would be similar to what we could anticipate or expect here. [1:14:42] Yep, and this map showing that there's a car dealership right here. It's not, I [1:14:47] don't even know if it's a quarter mile. Okay, and then that C1 zone continues south [1:14:51] all the way down to you get to the Oasis. Okay, yeah, so the new physical therapy [1:14:58] building would have been that C1 type of as well. Okay, it kind of runs along that [1:15:05] corridor. Yep. Appreciate it. Any other questions for Jonathan? Yeah, Jonathan, so on that, [1:15:13] you know, if that C1 comes with a 50 foot height restriction, is there anything else that would [1:15:18] cap that? I mean, I can't imagine somebody living out there would suddenly want a 50 foot structure. [1:15:24] Is there any other regulations out there that would potentially cap that height restriction [1:15:29] for that with that C1 designation? Negative, they can't go taller than that without permission. [1:15:34] What does prevent them from encroaching too close to residential? [1:15:39] There's two things on this property specifically. [1:15:42] One, the nearest residential is actually across Robbins, which has approximately 50 plus feet of right-of-way width. [1:15:49] And then there's also a 15-foot setback on that road. [1:15:52] So the distance from the home to a building is going to be in that 60 to 70 foot before they even look at the building. [1:15:59] And that's if someone puts a building that close to that road. [1:16:02] Washington has a similar step back to it. [1:16:05] It's actually wider, it's 35 from the property line. [1:16:07] So, the residential's around it are not going to be literally right adjacent. [1:16:11] So, that's what makes this one a little bit, I mean, it's unique, it's why the decision [1:16:16] kind of is at a, or a property basis. [1:16:19] Other than that, there's nothing that caps it at 50 other than that's just what the C1 zone has. [1:16:24] Okay, thanks. [1:16:26] Okay, any other questions? [1:16:28] We'll move on to the applicant if welcome. [1:16:39] Good evening. I'm an L.P. Parker. My husband, Elmer Blakey, maybe was the one that was indicated [1:16:46] on the application, but he's unable to be here this evening. So I want to thank you all for [1:16:51] hearing me out. I thought Mr. Stenlove did a great job, and I can answer any questions you have. [1:16:57] Hopefully I can answer any questions you have. Any questions? Okay. I think you're safe right now. [1:17:06] Now, we'll open it up, we might have some questions. [1:17:09] Well, don't know if anybody's, I don't think there's anybody here, [1:17:12] but we're gonna open up the public hearing now [1:17:15] for any questions. [1:17:19] Anybody wishing to ask questions, please come forward. [1:17:23] The fact that there's nobody in the audience, all right? [1:17:27] Okay, Jonathan, anything? [1:17:30] And Ellipy, any questions or anything else [1:17:32] that you would like to add? [1:17:37] Please, yes. [1:17:38] Hey, Mal, should I touch you now? [1:17:39] The only thing I would add is that immediately, [1:17:42] This piece of property immediately to the north is the surgery center. [1:17:47] So there is a big C1 development right next door. [1:17:51] So it's the empty piece that's never been developed. [1:17:53] It's been for sale for about 20 years, I believe, Dr. Fissu had it for sale. [1:18:00] So it had never sold. [1:18:02] It was his estate that sold it. [1:18:04] So there is a lot of commercial right along that area with the surgery center being right [1:18:10] next door. [1:18:11] Thank you. [1:18:12] Thank you. [1:18:13] Okay. [1:18:15] We'll close the public hearing. [1:18:17] Thoughts? [1:18:21] Any comments? [1:18:22] Spencer? [1:18:28] I had a hard time hitting the button. [1:18:32] Just looking at the planning and zoning notes, there was no complaints or protests from any [1:18:36] of the neighbors. [1:18:37] I know there are some residential homes nearby, but it's seen as how there was no comments [1:18:42] or whatever. [1:18:43] It seems like this complies with the future land use map and should be approved. [1:18:49] I move to approve the rezone of property from R4 Pro to C1 located at the northwest corner [1:19:03] of Washington Street and Robins Avenue. [1:19:05] I'll second. [1:19:06] We have a first by Jason Brown, second by Nikki Boyd, Amy Roll Call vote please. [1:19:18] Craig Hawkins. [1:19:19] Yes. [1:19:20] Jason Brown. [1:19:21] Yes. [1:19:22] Alex Kaval. [1:19:23] Yes. [1:19:24] Yes. [1:19:25] Motion passes. [1:19:28] 6-0 with one abstention. [1:19:30] We will move on. [1:19:34] We did not conclude. [1:19:35] All that we needed to talk about in our executive session. [1:19:38] So if I can have a motion on that action item to move back into executive session, please. [1:19:51] I'll make it. [1:19:53] I move that we move back to executive session pursuant to Idaho Code 74-206-A. [1:19:58] I'll second. [1:20:00] I have a motion to move into executive session by Alex Kaval seconded by Jason Brown. [1:20:06] Amy Roll called vote please. [1:20:08] Jason Brown. [1:20:09] Yes. [1:20:10] Alex Kaval. [1:20:11] Yes. [1:20:12] Spencer Cutler. [1:20:13] Yes. [1:20:14] Ruth Pierce. [1:20:15] Yes. [1:20:16] Chris Reed. [1:20:17] Yes. [1:20:18] Nikki Boyd. [1:20:19] Yes. [1:20:24] And Craig Hawkins. [1:20:25] Yes. [1:20:26] We will not be making any decisions in executive session and we will not be coming back into [1:20:31] session. [1:20:32] The meeting is adjourned.