Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-03-06, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-03-06/ [0:00:45] Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the March 6, 2023 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present here in chambers and Councilman Brown is excused. [0:00:59] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise. Next is the consent calendar. Council wishes. [0:01:30] Thank you, Chris Reed. Motion by Alex Koval, seconded by Chris Reed, to prove that consent calendar is written. [0:01:44] Amy Rolkow, please. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6 to 0. So if you were here for the bans at the bridge, [0:02:05] fighting the fact for the Paris condominiums, McKee and Racing Airport and Highway 16 Airport, [0:02:13] release they've all been approved. Next is our items of consideration. So our first item is an [0:02:22] action item presentation of the City of Twin Falls 2022 audited financial statements. Our presentation [0:02:31] by Scott and Sacred are you. Bread's not here to introduce you, so you're on your own. Our [0:02:39] Travis is here to introduce you. [0:02:47] So, we've had a mayor council bring us our assistant, a CFO, who helps facilitate the audit. [0:03:01] Right now he is upstairs completing the first day of his one city bootcamp training. [0:03:07] And so they are probably running a little bit closer, getting there from his line. [0:03:20] So, story for another day. [0:03:26] I introduced Scott. [0:03:29] Scott's been a partner with the City of Twin Falls for a long time. [0:03:33] for us. For as long as I've been a member of the City of Flint Falls, I know that his work is often [0:03:40] ventured to have Scott kind of people say this, but I also want to say it as well. [0:04:09] Clusion of tonight's presentation. As you continue to read the odd questions, Scott and members of this [0:04:18] team are always available to get together to get fully satisfied with your response, because not [0:04:26] only is it my fiduciary responsibility, but it is yours as well to which Spill is spent in accordance. [0:04:36] Welcome Scott to have us while they're doing what doesn't state it in the agenda [0:05:30] But I assume that we need to accept the financial statements as our action item [0:05:37] Thank you the tensiest side [0:06:24] That may not but hope tonight to kind of explain things a little bit differently [0:06:30] First of all, we are a gigantic company. [0:06:52] We have seven or eight CPAs and several bookkeepers and some support staff and with taxes and some other peer-reviewed [0:07:13] audits that we do and make sure that there are complifies in us to do or profit audits as well as non-profits [0:07:34] as well as governments and single audits, which are gation districts as well as non-profits. [0:07:51] The city is one of those of those of us that we do. [0:07:56] The governmental accounting is different than its unique. [0:08:00] Because of that, that's for somewhat unique. [0:08:16] It's one of these types of of of us has to have 40 hours every year, just in government. [0:08:21] So that's a good thing for each of us to stay up with current, [0:08:25] because they're changing things all the time. [0:08:28] And there's several changes. [0:08:38] So that's us. [0:08:39] And what does the governmental audit entail? [0:08:42] What do we do? [0:08:51] And it's fair to me that there's no material in the statement. [0:08:54] And we also review the controls of the entity of the city, [0:09:04] test those internal controls, [0:09:10] also perform a single audit. [0:09:12] We test their federal programs, [0:09:16] cities, and compliance with those first disordered opinion. [0:09:35] This used to be a three paragraph, three pages. [0:09:48] This paragraph that I've highlighted [0:09:50] is the opinion paragraph that it says [0:09:58] in our financial statements referred to present fairly [0:10:02] in all material respects to respect [0:10:04] financial position of the City of Twin Falls, I don't know. [0:10:07] In accordance with its accounting principles, [0:10:09] generally accepted in the United States. [0:10:12] Well, that's the punchline. [0:10:15] That's the most important thing that we can say tonight. [0:10:17] All these tests that we'll talk about in a few minutes, [0:10:21] this is the conclusion that we've materially correct. [0:10:29] So how do we arrive at this important opinion? [0:10:33] We assess the risk of transactions and balances. [0:10:38] It's your financial statements and the transactions [0:10:42] answer statements and balances, assess what is risky. [0:10:54] That's when we just say, okay, this is a higher risk transaction [0:11:01] because of the balance or unusual balance. [0:11:04] The high risk area is that maybe susceptible to fraud. [0:11:09] We expand our testing and look at the test that those are focused on [0:11:18] these risk assessments are a critical part of our business plan. [0:11:23] Try to use as many external sources. [0:11:28] bank confirmations, balances, and with third parties to verify those balances. [0:11:36] That's the best source that we can have until that's kind of how we arrive at these opinions. [0:11:43] A bit about internal contractinisms are ruled and procedures implemented by a company [0:11:57] who ensure the integrity of the financial and accounting are audit. [0:12:07] We issue an opinion. [0:12:08] For example, cash transactions shouldn't also perform the bank reconciliation. [0:12:18] reconciliation should be separated. [0:12:21] An example of it being established doesn't really refer to what's happening in terms of [0:12:47] just being a single audit is when an entity, any entity, spends more than $750,000 in a [0:12:59] fiscal year of federal funds. [0:13:03] Once that entity is cross that threshold, a single audit is necessary or required by [0:13:08] the federal government, and so what a single audit does is we go in, we make sure that [0:13:18] The results of those single audits are part of your reporting package at the very end. [0:13:36] That is also submitted to the federal government through the audit clearing house. [0:13:41] And it was 140 pages this document that you received. [0:13:55] That's just the way it's going every time it gets longer. [0:14:02] But it's important to understand what she received. [0:14:05] It's much deeper in detail. [0:14:08] You wouldn't receive it just a normal statement as the authority referred to. [0:14:16] There's also a very important part for you is that the management's discussion and analysis [0:14:25] often referred to as MD&A. [0:14:28] This is where your accounting staff and personnel have written and said how the city is doing [0:14:41] in these last year or two, like this last year or last couple of years have been kind [0:14:47] of strange with revenue from government. [0:14:52] I do explain some of those things, including ground research after that. [0:15:08] Then we get into the financial statements and other kind of interesting, there's two sets [0:15:16] of French statements government-wide, which looks at all your assets, your infrastructure and everything, [0:15:22] all the debt that you have the city to fund statements, which kind of gathers things that are similar types of transactions or purposes. [0:15:35] It was the city able to meet their obligations in the come-loads that are very detailed, going through the city and what type of entity you are and all the balance sheet items, [0:15:50] supplementary information, statistical information, and finally there's a lot of information. [0:15:57] This is the GFOA, which is the government finance officer's association. [0:16:10] This is an award. [0:16:15] Your financial statements are submitted to the GFOA voluntarily. [0:16:19] The most governments don't do the countings personnel and I'm sure. [0:16:27] This and others have encouraged this. [0:16:29] They're submitted to this organization which kind of oversees all government. [0:16:33] I received this award for the last several years. [0:16:39] I was interested to know how common this is. [0:16:44] There's five cities in the State of Idaho that have received this award and the City of Twin Falls is what it's essentially auditing the audit that goes through and look and ask questions and it's a very detailed process at the City of to get this award and to the statement what it's for really to make sure that the statements are just real quick. [0:17:19] The Busted County staff and you hear quarterly, I believe, numbers are from September and you've had financial updates since, so I don't meet them. [0:17:32] But this is kind of a change, significant changes from last year to this year. There's quite a bit of differences. [0:17:42] And some of these big swings, and it just are, sometimes you receive grants in advance of performing the grant. [0:18:00] So you'll see these liabilities increase so much. [0:18:04] Some of it's all explainable. [0:18:11] Those charged with governance, which is the City Council. [0:18:31] Things that we need to communicate. [0:18:35] First of all, our role is to form an opinion [0:18:37] and also as to how the Ottawa First Travis mentioned. [0:19:16] He's had some lot of experience in his career, [0:19:18] so he knows what we're looking for [0:19:20] and what we need to appreciate their help [0:19:22] and to qualify to staff, eventually for a county [0:19:40] or for governments was unusual. [0:19:43] Across the board, there was significant reserves, [0:19:58] which is great to see tax payers' perspective, but from an auditor's perspective is what means when some of his strong [0:20:09] foundations, the risk kind of those down a little bit appreciate the opportunity to be here and to present [0:20:22] like Travis said, we're always available or something's brought up. I try to send those questionnaires, I hope you're [0:20:34] received, to let you report directly to us if something's happened that you're concerned with. [0:20:41] Each drastically increase in investor earnings in two different areas and to share with us. [0:21:27] So, your investments as we take a snapshot view, and as of September 30th, investment [0:21:44] statements, and if the market has moved significantly, investments to market, so whatever the market [0:21:56] is done on that, it just happens that there was a significant, show the significant, I [0:22:10] don't think it's very significant to you, this is common with especially when we're [0:22:22] in such a high fluctuation time. I'm switching the opposite on the exact statements that the [0:22:31] Marston, we see this huge, intense, disused, gasket of the 71. Is the statement that's it? That's [0:22:43] when we have to tell more false off account questions for you to segregate it. Sometimes you can, [0:23:34] but it's so heavy. That's, that's, you're like, that's it. Thank you very much, Scott. Thank you. [0:24:17] So, yes, Chris Reed. We accept the presentation of the, and the statements of the, the City of [0:24:31] of 2020-22 audit to financials. Scott Hunsaker. [0:24:37] Can you do I have a second? [0:24:41] Key motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Allie Scavalle, [0:24:44] to the audited financial statements as presented. [0:24:51] Amy Roll, call vote please. [0:25:01] Yes, and next on the agenda is an action item. [0:25:10] Consider recommendations from the Public Arts Commission [0:25:13] and the Parks and Rec. [0:25:16] Mission to Accept a Donation from Right Physical Therapy [0:25:19] for metal art is to be placed at the Twin Falls City Pool, [0:25:24] our Parks and Rec, Director. [0:25:40] And the National Statement begins, [0:25:41] so Shane's trying to save me from conversation. [0:25:48] So I'm excited to be here this evening, [0:25:50] because this is the first time that our two commissions [0:25:54] have intersected on a project, [0:25:57] and this is actually the first thing [0:25:58] that's come to the Public Art Commission [0:26:01] with any significance so far. [0:26:05] They've been working really hard [0:26:06] their mission statement and getting the resolutions taken care of and getting [0:26:11] processes put in place so to the fortune or misfortune of right physical [0:26:18] therapy they wound up right in the middle and I found this great test or process so [0:26:24] the reason this is on the consideration this evening is so I can kind of walk you [0:26:29] through what the process looks like for the moment and we may need to make a few [0:26:34] changes as we start to go through this but in September we received our request to donate [0:26:44] a piece of art and I should have brought I think you guys have a picture. It's like some metal [0:26:50] art with it's like a swimmer swimming they asked if they could donate it to the city pool so I had [0:26:56] them fill out the donation form which at the time was the way to do it our commission had so [0:27:11] So application to the Arts Commission and then to the Parks and Recreation Commission. [0:27:19] My problem is where their jurisdictions began in the end. [0:27:24] So essentially the commission has been tasked with making recommendations to city council [0:27:33] regarding the selection of artists, the acquisition of works of art, and the acceptance of gifts [0:27:38] and loans of works of art. [0:27:41] The Parks and Recreation Commission has the task of evaluating a donation for appropriateness in the location in conjunction with the Parks and Recreation Department as well as reviewing any signage or plaques. [0:27:59] And so, suddenly I realized I didn't know how to do this exactly, so I had the art commission [0:28:07] take a look at the art to see if they deemed it appropriate, or placement in a public space, [0:28:14] and making sure that accepting that art worked. [0:28:18] And so, as you can see through their motion, they had some concerns about ownership, [0:28:24] and can they do they really own it, can they give it to us? [0:28:27] need the artist to help with the installation again, one of the maintenance [0:28:31] costs of like, then the Parks and Rec Commission basically just took a look at [0:28:38] the piece to say, putting something like, well it makes sense. Again, this one was [0:28:45] a little more awkward because it goes on a wall versus I think the intention is we [0:28:51] don't really want, there needs to be some discussion about location and the [0:28:58] appropriateness of a location, we don't, the art commission can't really just say, [0:29:03] oh my gosh, this is awesome, we want to center right in the middle of City Park and then have us, [0:29:07] whether it's the department or the Parks and Rights Commission, say, [0:29:10] oh, maybe that's not the best place for that. So we need to work through that a [0:29:14] little bit. This evening, recommendation from each commission to accept this piece [0:29:22] of art and have a place at the pole. And we did work through the concerns about [0:29:27] turns out I think he just commissioned the art to be made with a guy that has a [0:29:33] CNC machine that can do it which is a little bit different than a piece of art [0:29:41] that I had an artist's commission to do. Chris, so this is on the application it [0:30:05] doesn't talk anything about size and we've seen the picture and I think all of [0:30:09] us in our heads think it's a certain size but he did send me some dimensions I [0:30:16] think it's about two feet tall and maybe three feet wide and so it's not as big as [0:30:21] it looks and when I was at my physical therapy on President's Day I walked in [0:30:27] I wanted to see where it was and they've already taken it down so now it's [0:30:30] just a piece of it but I think it'll work on the [0:30:37] Sounds wall by the hallways you go into the pool and that's where Kate thought it would fit to [0:30:43] and you also stated that [0:30:47] John had [0:30:48] Approved it. That's so excited to have any like excited to have it. Okay, Craig Hawkins [0:30:55] Excellent, that'd be great [0:31:08] motion by Craig Hawkins second and by Nicki Boyd to accept the [0:31:13] The donation by right physical therapy for a metal art piece to be placed in the city pool, their discussion. [0:31:31] Yes. [0:31:37] Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Thinking next on the agenda is a request to reallocate 16,450, $5.38 in pool capital dollars to fund a circulation system study and design. [0:31:57] And we have John Polly, Aquatic Supervisor. Welcome, John. [0:32:00] So I'm here this evening to request that the Council reallocate budgeted cap-on-proofment dollars from the city pool facility main incident hands-on-adhesive funds to fund a needs assessment for the city pool circulation system. [0:32:14] As I start looking into replacing the pump, we struggle with finding information on the pump and the circulation system. [0:32:20] Since we have little information to go off of, the circulation system has been modified in different ways over the years, and that knowing if a pump replacement would solve the problem with the Parks and Recreation leadership team [0:32:31] team decide that the best course of action was to have a needs assessment performed by the [0:32:35] guidance that we need. [0:32:37] Through conversations with the aquatic design group, I have learned that our system is no [0:32:42] longer a use method of circulation, with many of them being replaced with modern systems. [0:32:48] This is consistent with what we've experienced with finding replacement parts. [0:32:53] Having a circulation system that works properly is the most important mechanical aspect of [0:32:57] swimming pool. [0:32:58] With this being the case, we decided that the city pools remaining capable of funds should [0:33:02] be reallocated to perform this assessment. The goal of the study is to identify our best [0:33:06] path forward that will provide a long-term solution for the City Cool Circulation System. [0:33:10] Staff is requesting that Council reallocate $9,031.28 from this facility, made its budget [0:33:18] in $7,424.10 from the facility enhancement, um, light item for a total of $16,455.38 [0:33:26] to be used for the study. [0:33:28] The aquatic design group design estimated that it would be $16,000 for the study and design of a new system. [0:33:34] Staff intends to use the recommendation from the study to guide future capital requests. [0:33:39] For questions that you may have. Any questions for John? [0:33:45] This is a design, so do you think that this will give you enough that when they're done, you can either order what you're going to get bids from... [0:34:00] Is that the hope then? [0:34:01] Yes, that's definitely the goal. [0:34:16] Basically, so I believe the solution will be to use my best judgment as the circulation system will be used [0:34:31] The components that we already have make a new system work with it [0:34:36] So retrofitting, that's the best word I can describe it [0:34:39] With all theirs only to tell us, psych, there's nothing you can do [0:34:55] Tear it out, build a similar type of circulation system where they aren't doing something like this [0:35:06] So I'm encouraged by that [0:35:08] I can't say that 100% certain to you either [0:35:15] study and Craig Hawkins. [0:35:31] Second. [0:35:33] Key motion by Christopher Reed, second by Craig Hawkins to approve the request to reallocate [0:35:39] 16,458 in City Pool Capital dollars to fund the Circulation System Study and Design project. [0:35:50] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:35:52] Yes. [0:35:57] Thank you. [0:36:03] Motion passes 6-0. [0:36:04] Thank you, John. [0:36:05] Thank you, Council. [0:36:07] Next is an action item, a request to approve utilizing [0:36:11] Unbudgeted Airport Fund reserves in the amount of $37,450 [0:36:17] to refurbish the airport farm pump and well system. [0:36:21] We have Bill Carberry, our airport manager. [0:36:24] Welcome, Bill. [0:36:25] Thank you, Mary. [0:36:26] You need to just start off with the airport farm on the, [0:36:38] this is the East End of the airport. [0:36:39] That's the approach to runway 25. [0:36:42] And we've got about 200 acres of farm ground. [0:36:45] irrigated farm ground that's been operated at the airport for a long time [0:36:50] and his son J.D. Messner as the airport farmers for probably back the also farm [0:37:02] ground in the salmon tracks south of the airport so recently Matt Barthes is [0:37:12] the back of the room listening in there. He's got a break from one city boot camp [0:37:17] that's Matt you know we got with Ryan Baumann and so we have our own [0:37:29] airport well and water system just almost out of the frame here you can see [0:37:33] storage tank in that corner. We have a separate airport farm well, just along the parades [0:37:41] it provides supplemental water in addition to Twin Falls Canal Company watersheds. The [0:37:49] farm does stretch past 3000 east, that's the lake's extended, so they operate and irrigate [0:37:55] this area here from this source and salmon. Water when it's available feeds in from the [0:38:02] south side there are also salmon track watersheds so fairly successful so so we [0:38:14] went we were kind of distressed here about the farm not performing well [0:38:17] how was ryan on this and it was an assessment ryan sort of right [0:38:23] right shotgun with the farmer on this and really the determination was needed [0:38:28] that the farm well and its whole system the shaft the bolts on the bottom it needs [0:38:36] a complete they receive their proposal from vertoline pumps ink proposal is for [0:38:44] of $32,570. So my request today includes a 10% contingency for that. So one of the interesting [0:38:57] things about our contract with the farmer is that there is some cost sharing component [0:39:03] to have. It's about 15% of any repair, not to exceed $6,000 in a year. So with this repair [0:39:10] estimate in the request for 37,450. The range of that cost sharing would be anywhere from $4,885 to $5,617. [0:39:23] And we would invoice once the job is complete the messengers for reimbursement. [0:39:29] So, your foreign lease would bound to make these repairs that was part of the package years ago. [0:39:39] some of the infrastructure and the ability to provide water, which certainly adds value [0:39:44] to the fair market rental of that. [0:39:47] The airport receives about $46,176 annually from the farm, so it's a nice revenue stream [0:39:54] for the airport activities that we have. [0:39:59] So with that, I recommend the council approve using on a budget of the airport fund reserves [0:40:05] in the amount of $37,450 to refresh the airport farm. [0:40:10] Spence or color. [0:40:15] It makes sense to me. [0:40:18] I just had a little arithmetic question. [0:40:20] So the band was 32, 570, plus 10% contingency. [0:40:25] That doesn't add up to the requested amount. [0:40:28] Did I make a public mouse? [0:40:30] This is very embarrassing. [0:40:32] So was I that far off? [0:40:36] So what is? [0:40:42] Well, it should be 30, 27. [0:40:51] 15%? [0:40:52] Yes, 15% cost sharing. [0:41:02] I may have misspoke. [0:41:04] So I think you said 10% [0:41:11] If I may have said 10% I apologize if this vote in my in my report it does say 15% so I was [0:41:19] I'm taking more than 10% contingency [0:41:29] Cost-sharing oh I see so you're percent so I did her so it is 10% of the [0:41:41] 32 [0:41:42] 32 570 plus 10% [0:42:04] I'm coming up on the next report to you, so say goodbye. [0:42:07] You might check that. [0:42:09] The wizard in conclusion, I would recommend the council [0:42:13] approve using the un-budget airport fund reserves [0:42:19] in the amount of $35,827. Thank you for that catch. [0:42:24] Thank you, Spencer. Any other questions for Bill? [0:42:27] Utilizing fund reserves in the amount of $1,827 [0:43:01] to refurbish the airport farm pump and well system. [0:43:05] Nicky Nicky Boyd, keep motioned by Spencer Keller, seconded by Nicky Boyd to approve utilizing [0:43:13] on-budget airport fund reserves in the amount of, write it down, $1027 to refurbish the airport [0:43:24] farm pump and well system. Any further discussion? Amy Rollkavo, please? [0:43:29] Yes, yes, yes, thank you motion passes six to zero [0:43:43] Hey, you're up next bill. Well mayor, I must confess mr. Mulkey [0:43:55] But I can't take credit for the next one so [0:44:01] Try to do fast math [0:44:05] The second request is for a change order for our security system [0:44:10] So in 2022, we budgeted $65,000 to make upgrades to our security system, [0:44:17] hardware and software for access control to the doors, [0:44:21] all of those types of things in the terminal, the gates, [0:44:24] as well as surveillance and cameras. [0:44:26] We got off to a grand start on the surveillance upgrades, [0:44:30] but last spring we stalled because of the unavailability of some of this [0:44:35] for the security system, the communications, [0:44:39] the software and the controllers at the door. [0:44:45] So with the help of Rich Hall, we started to try to get back on the [0:44:49] more and see how we could get this finished. [0:44:51] So he works with Apex for a change order that I would accomplish. [0:44:56] These upgrades that we need to have, changing a specific piece of hardware to an alternate [0:45:01] and help the job get down. [0:45:05] It also really be more robust. [0:45:08] I think he was ultimately more pleased with the second approach that we're [0:45:11] So, coming up to the math here, so we've got many reserves, [0:45:19] plenty of reserves, 3.45 million. [0:45:23] The change order proposal is for $7,661.59, [0:45:28] ending a 10% contingency on that. [0:45:32] I came up with $8,427, so I'm batting $500 to thank you. [0:45:37] Yeah, we checked the math here. [0:45:39] So with that, I would recommend the Council approve $8,427 of un-budgeted airport reserves [0:45:47] to fund the change order with Apex security. [0:45:54] Any questions? [0:45:55] Nicky Boy, do I have a second? [0:46:34] Thank you, motion by Nicky Boy, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the request of $8,427 [0:46:44] of un-budgeted airport reserves to fund the change order with Apex security. [0:46:50] Amy Roll, call vote please. [0:46:55] Yes, thank you, motion passes six to zero. [0:47:13] Thank you for your patience and your good you are this evening. [0:47:18] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to approve an ordinance, [0:47:24] to allow certain markings on curb streets and avenues and alleys, [0:47:30] and we have Shane who, no bar city attorney. Welcome, Shane. [0:47:34] Thank you, Madam Mayor, Council members. I'm also glad Scott is still here because I had a similar [0:47:39] conversation with my father who's a CPA, my profession, the conversation wasn't dry [0:47:45] enough so I decided to go to law school. [0:47:47] In this instance, mayor and council members, we often have requests typically from fundraiser [0:48:03] scout individuals who want to pay addresses on curbs as a fundraising mechanism or want [0:48:10] to pay their address. [0:48:14] as it reached is not a city official generation of this we went through the [0:48:27] city initial a process that we would include a specification in our revision to [0:48:41] the ISPWC which is the Idaho state our Idaho standard for public works [0:48:46] construction that's not and they felt confident shouldn't be until that's the [0:49:10] reason for the late addendum received this after any questions for [0:49:28] as it relates to the process as you know in ordinance has to be read on three [0:49:36] separate days unless the rules are suspended and it provide in the Stafford proposed language should this council want to suspend the rules in place this one that's on third and other questions be f**king so you have a motion. [0:49:55] I'd like to. [0:49:56] That's okay. [0:50:07] Thank you Chris Reed. [0:50:09] Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins second by Chris Reed to put ordinance number 2023.003 on third and final reading by title only. [0:50:20] E.M.E. ROCO vote please. Fund Chrystreet. It's number 2023-003. [0:51:03] An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending [0:51:08] Twin Falls City Code by amending Section 6-2-9C, allowing for certain [0:51:15] markings to be made to curbs, streets, avenues, and alleys, and requiring specific [0:51:20] standards when making such markings. Markings period. Now, Chrystreet, you do have a [0:51:33] second motion by Chris Reed second by Nikki Boyd to approve ordinance number [0:51:40] 2023-003 Amy Roquevo please yes [0:51:53] motion passes six to zero okay that is it for items of consideration next is a [0:52:05] time for general public input this is a time that anybody from the public who [0:52:10] wishes to address council on an issue that's not on today's agenda is welcome [0:52:17] to come down speak advisory board report Craig through the manager's office the [0:52:46] next our public hearings we will start at 6 a 6 p.m. and so we will be [0:52:54] taking a break for about eight minutes and we will be back for the public [0:52:59] Okay, good evening ladies and gentlemen, it's 6 p.m. [0:53:49] So we'll move on to our public hearings, I guess, yes, okay, so the first public hearing [0:54:05] is an action item. [0:54:07] It's a request for approval of the inflationary adjustment to development impact fees, PZ-23.004. [0:54:17] And we have Jonathan's been loved, our planning and zoning director, welcome Jonathan. [0:54:21] Mayor, members of the council, this item is coming back to you. [0:54:26] The original time we discussed was during the annual report from the impact fee committee [0:54:29] that happened in June. [0:54:32] We've advertised this meeting and we also sent out additional notification to the Builders [0:54:38] Association and the developer. [0:54:39] We did receive one public. [0:54:42] I've advertised this for a fee increase up to 8% councils decision or is your charge [0:54:54] your task is to come up with a decision of the matter and I have some sample motions. [0:55:00] Look at, they're not specific to what you have. I also have an Excel spreadsheet [0:55:09] that would show you the increases by percentages for each of the double checked [0:55:24] all the numbers. That's the exact percentages. These numbers are rounded. [0:55:32] You can see they're rounded up along. So this is the 8% change. This is the current [0:55:40] fee structure as we have it today. 8% change the dollar amount for each of the [0:55:45] I guess it's categories, but really they're funds, they're separate to four separate funds, like this section over here [0:55:53] And we have a total fee that most people look at. It takes all of those into account. And what should be noted is that the single family and multi-family [0:56:01] bear the cost of the entire Parks Impact fee, a commercial building. The retail building does not pay that fee, so they pay per square footage amount. [0:56:12] There's no non-reswork fee, so that's the key to it. [0:56:21] To be clear, if you had a multi-family dwelling unit, whether it was a duplex, [0:56:25] Yes, it comes down here to the multi-family. Anything over a single family detached is a multi-family. [0:56:32] And that difference is solely the difference between the traffic generator or the number of vehicle trips that gets generated by that dweller. [0:56:41] I have an end offer questions or discussion or any changes you want me to do for a percentage wise. [0:57:05] Thank you. Amy, would you roll forward to the questions for John? [0:57:27] So these fees are assessed when the building permit is applied for, and then before they [0:57:34] can receive the permit to do construction, that's when they pay it. [0:57:38] Okay, so all of these fees would be able to build the permits being pulled. [0:57:42] Choose the ones that are on January, those are the current ones, so any way pulling a permit. [0:57:52] Within your discussion and or motion you can put a date to say. [0:57:55] So did I give this spreadsheet set up that you can just change to 8% and see numbers change? [0:58:09] was curious how a 6% as the commission recommended versus 8% for MCI. [0:58:16] That is the difference ends up being 262, first single family, 221. [0:58:26] But this year so it kind of shows you the one different settlement pace. [0:58:32] So under the 8% it was 315, 295, 352, 95, 262, 220. [0:58:46] Just for Jonathan, we'll open public hearing any public comments. [0:59:11] As Jonathan mentioned, we did have one letter sent in, but is there anybody in the audience [0:59:18] which wishes to come down and address Council on this particular item? [0:59:25] See, no one else closed the public hearing and opened it up for Council action discussion. [0:59:33] whatever you choose. Oh yes. Can I just clarify for the record, the one letter that we received was an opposition to the APRISET increase. [0:59:40] Okay, what's in the packet? So is it in the packet? I said everybody knew that. Okay, anything else you want to add? [0:59:47] So, anybody wish to make a motion? 8% is that correct? Is that your? [1:00:25] Motion to increase the fees 8% period, sir. Second, [1:00:37] Q motion by Greg Hawkins, second by Alex Koval to approve the inflationary impact, [1:00:49] inflationary adjustment for development impact fees to 8%. [1:00:55] Council discussion, Ms. Reed. [1:00:59] This is the increase from June from November 15 of [1:01:24] 11% per the inflationary adjustment that was under the previous capital improvement plan. [1:02:01] There were some very specific things that were not part of that improvement plan. [1:02:10] Particularly some things we need to remember why this change was huge. [1:02:20] We no longer were getting these for parkland and then the city will buy the parkland. [1:02:28] So in terms of an exchange it was developers no longer the reasons for that. [1:02:37] It won't bring over just receiving a dollar, it was needed in the city that had a choice when and where to purchase the parkland. [1:02:46] land so that $1,000 of this increase was strictly changing that mechanism 22 to 39. [1:02:57] Another big one that you can see on here was the fire. [1:03:00] In a box we now reassess the amount to the fire stations basically just because of the [1:03:17] first station is reported at six or something that was more like eight or nine but that's [1:03:22] why the inflationary address was coming to play. [1:03:24] The last one was the streets and the streets had a pretty big amount for different ones [1:03:30] because of the projects that began to be included, some of the street projects that got included on it, [1:03:36] but also we saw a really sharp increase in intersection costs for a signalized intersection. [1:03:44] Within the last five to seven years it's gone from, that's what caused the November $21 amount to jump so high, [1:03:57] were those three main things. In January we took that 4% because fire station costs and everything we're seeing are going up. [1:04:13] But Spencer, it's rated as second councilman Hawkins motion for there. [1:04:17] I think somebody did, so... [1:04:27] That's what you end up having is to dip into your reserves. [1:05:03] Okay. [1:05:04] If you need to do it, I mean, there's something else. [1:05:06] I mean, I'm sure there's other mechanisms that are possible, but... [1:05:09] If you can't pay for what the impact fees you have to find, what we identify in that plan is other funding sources. [1:05:15] It's fair to say that at that, and keep Chris Street. [1:05:32] Who, at that same point... [1:05:34] So in favor of it, concern that we don't keep up with MCI, [1:05:55] that it's going to come back and haunt us. [1:05:57] I mean, we've seen the prices increase, [1:05:59] and I'm actually kind of surprised it's only a percent. [1:06:03] So, let's go for it. [1:06:05] Craig Hawkins. [1:06:06] I was going to say, we want to keep the prices of problems. [1:06:54] Amy Rolkow, please. [1:06:59] Yes. [1:07:00] Chris and Alex, come on. [1:07:07] Thank you. [1:07:08] Motion passes 5 to 1. [1:07:11] OK, next, Jonathan, you're up again. [1:07:14] Next item on the agenda is public hearing. [1:07:18] so request to approve a new application fee [1:07:21] for the historic property designation application. [1:07:24] PZ23-0014. [1:07:28] Yes, so this was something that came before the council. [1:07:32] It was in the fall, customer discussion. [1:07:38] To bring it to you in, we needed to, [1:07:40] this was a follow up to creating the historic property [1:07:44] designation with a small fee to accomplish. [1:07:49] It does require a couple hearings, [1:07:51] particularly in ordinance with the council [1:07:52] to actually have that, but it's really similar to some of the smaller applications. [1:08:06] And just to be clear, that fee doesn't include renting the sign or the publishing, it's just stuff. [1:08:21] Yeah, it's basically us putting it into the paper for the hearing, and then when we post the property, [1:08:27] it's not required to rent a sign someone can print something or make up the sign using our template. [1:08:34] So we don't, for those, if they need to send letters or pay for the coordinates public. [1:08:47] Any questions for Jonathan? Oh, on this, before I open up, [1:08:52] this re- moving the historic declaration. [1:09:10] So a piece of property was declared because- [1:09:14] Yeah, so if someone comes to suit designates as an historic property, [1:09:18] they do that through a little- [1:09:27] Mitch, she's shaking his head. [1:09:29] They've been taking other ordinance to repeal the ordinance. [1:09:53] So if this gets approved as it's been, [1:09:56] moving at some later point- [1:10:14] Good question. [1:10:16] Any other questions for Jonathan? [1:10:32] Unless some groups generated processes in state statute [1:10:48] are distinct and different. [1:10:50] So this is the one that a person could come and say, [1:10:52] I have a store property. [1:10:54] There are things that benefits them to do that. [1:10:57] We have to notify the assessor of that as part of the process. [1:11:06] But yes, this could be a, we're establishing state statute [1:11:26] at 67, 46, 14. [1:11:32] Any other questions for Jonathan before I open up [1:11:34] for public hearing? [1:11:38] Is that right? [1:11:41] So is there anybody in the audience that wishes to address council on this application fee? [1:11:51] See no one? [1:11:53] Council discussion or action? [1:11:59] Ms. Reed, Alex Koval? [1:12:10] Thank you, motion by Christopher Reed, second by Alex Koval, to approve a new application [1:12:17] fee for the historic property designation application of $250. [1:12:25] Any further discussion? [1:12:26] Amy Roll-Covote? [1:12:27] Yes. [1:12:28] Yes, thank you, motion passes six to zero. [1:12:41] Thank you, Jonathan. [1:12:44] That is it for today, so meeting is adjourned. [1:12:48] Thank you, everyone.