Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-01-17, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-01-17/ [0:01:29] and welcome to the January 17th, 2020 City Council meeting. [0:01:37] I wanna confirm we have a quorum. [0:01:38] We have six members present in chambers [0:01:41] and Councilman Brown is excused tonight. [0:01:46] The first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:01:48] So you wish to join me, please rise. [0:02:09] Acclamations tonight. [0:02:11] So next item is the consent calendar. [0:02:14] Council wishes. [0:02:23] Thank you, motion by Craig Hawken, seconded by Alex Kaval to approve the consent calendar [0:02:28] as written. [0:02:29] Amy Rokow, please. [0:02:30] Yes, thank you. [0:02:31] Motion passes 6-0. [0:02:36] Next on the agenda are items of consideration of the first item as an action item and request [0:02:53] to declare city equipment number 3254 and a Suzoo MB-2-0-0. [0:02:58] You've been muted to unmute yourself, press star six. [0:03:03] Was that a hint? I'm just gonna start over just cuz. [0:03:11] Okay, requested to declare city equipment, number 3254 in a Zuzu MB207 P-Pates driver, [0:03:19] surplus, enabling the sale to another government. You end up government and we have Mark Thompson. [0:03:25] Welcome, Mark. [0:03:56] We're placing our current December, I started to go cabin chassis sitting on there. [0:06:03] Are you still negotiating that? Yes. [0:07:21] There's a state statute that we're also complying with this meeting. [0:07:29] So, let's start over with the... [0:07:45] Prove the cell of the truck. [0:08:00] Okay, so we need to put five. Sorry, I don't get more $95,000. [0:08:17] And leave out the January 3rd, because that was our prior... [0:08:21] Okay, how's that? [0:08:22] I'm going to motion by Craig Hock for the second invite. [0:08:33] I'll at least give all two to approve decoration of the paint striper surplus. [0:08:39] and enable the sale to the Father Highway District for $95,000 and use the funds to offset the cost of the new Striper. [0:08:48] Amy Rocha, I'll pass this to zero. [0:09:06] So next item on the agenda is an action item, review, discussion and action on the annual financial report and impact fee program for fiscal year 2022. [0:09:38] Jonathan's been one of our P&C Director. Welcome. I'll be up here for the next, I don't know, [0:09:52] two items associated with the Impact Feet Program. This one is the first one talking about the annual [0:09:57] report, a couple different items in that report that we'll second item after is talking about the [0:10:05] FCI increase, so we separate those out to have those conversations separately. This first one on [0:10:10] the annual report, I'm not going to go through things in the packet. Attachment number two is the [0:10:24] long one, that's the entire program. That's something you needed to know in case you had any questions [0:10:28] Some items that were seeking funding. [0:10:32] The minus number three was the current totals [0:10:45] for the revenues of this year. [0:10:47] And we get an unaudited number from our finance team [0:10:50] as they keep track of that all year. [0:10:52] The impact fee committee was what we spent this year, [0:10:58] which was 371,317 streets, [0:11:03] along the city on the parks is $46,047 in parks [0:11:21] to purchase fence material. [0:11:22] That was a pre-purchase of fence material at a good price. [0:11:25] For the river bend trail section is a piece of [0:11:28] We also did some miscellaneous site work at the Trailhead, at Eastland Drive and Pole Line Road. [0:11:42] Those were the two expenditures for this year. [0:11:52] Any questions for Jonathan? [0:11:53] Per state statute, we do this annual report. [0:11:59] We also talk about queries or complaints, and generally forcing the report to the impact accepting the report at Motion. [0:12:20] We accept the report, and it's pretty simple. [0:12:45] You've actually been very kind and spelled out your art motion exactly. [0:12:49] In motion, so we do appreciate that. [0:12:54] We do appreciate that. [0:12:55] Any questions for Jonathan before we have a motion? [0:12:59] Ain't a motion. [0:13:09] Craig Hawkins. [0:13:13] Motion to approve in. [0:13:14] Do I have a second? [0:13:30] Second. [0:13:32] Motion by Craig Hawkins. [0:13:33] Second by Spencer Cutler to approve the annual financial report and impact fee program for 2022. [0:13:43] to any further discussion. [0:13:47] Amy Rokow, please. [0:13:56] Yes, a motion passes six to zero. [0:14:09] Their action item requests for approval, [0:14:13] inflationary adjustment to impact fees, [0:14:17] and we have Jonathan still. [0:14:19] Yeah, so city code, [0:14:32] decks of the city needs, [0:14:38] projects we've put into that [0:15:08] to person to build a build a commercial buildings, [0:15:14] pay into each of those streets. [0:15:22] Those projects are created, [0:15:24] and we look at those, [0:15:25] We did a recent makeup with the dollars of 2019 progress through time. [0:15:33] Those projects and costs, as we all know, [0:15:43] state statute standpoint that's hooked that to what's called the municipal cost index. [0:15:48] Very similar to a consumer price index. [0:15:51] When it talks about inflation, to MCI, [0:15:55] it's basically the cost of the city to build those things. [0:15:58] And we get that from a certain source to the cities and counties [0:16:07] where they take what I cost cities to build things like the cost of a barrel, [0:16:10] of oil, gas, deep asphalt, things, build the stuff we're looking to take that MCI and apply [0:16:21] it to the original costs every year so that those MCI, this last year was 8% order to build [0:16:37] our list, we needed costs, council adopted them, we basically put in a council would allow [0:16:46] the MCI to increase every year to stop that increase on the impact fees. [0:16:54] Now it's not a direct correlation necessarily of impact fee, percentages, then increase increases [0:17:03] The council can't increase any fee over 5%, but the MCI used to be 5%, 1.2%, [0:17:20] a separate state statute that says, and moreover, for you to increase the fee, [0:17:29] so this is a separate item because you have kind of a choose-your-own-adventure. [0:17:38] Basically, take an action to set a public hearing date for an increase fee amount. [0:17:44] You can take an action to not allow an increase, [0:17:48] They say we are not going to increase fees. [0:17:50] You could also take an action to increase it. [0:17:53] Options you have, I will give you a truncated version of what's in your minutes. [0:18:04] Prehere, this is debated pretty heavily. [0:18:15] Before they came, because that group almost said they can't leave the meeting. [0:18:24] No option for them to not have a recommendation to you. [0:18:26] This is what I told them, so at the end of the hour was you guys all have to make a recommendation. [0:18:30] There's no option not to. [0:18:31] It was a vote of five to one for a six percent or no higher than six percent. [0:18:36] That's what is reflected in the minutes and the attachments. [0:18:42] If it is over a certain percentage or you decide you want it to be over 5%, you do not have [0:19:05] to declare necessarily a percentage you could say we want to put a public hearing [0:19:11] for 8% at the most and we will set that public hearing to publish it in the paper. [0:19:21] So I remember this discussion last year and the reasons we moved to MCI is because it does truly [0:19:40] elect our cost of doing business. That's just something to remember from last year. I think [0:19:49] we added that code section or that revised that last year wasn't it? [0:19:54] It's been a while but we have to iterate okay. [0:19:56] So any questions for Jonathan? [0:19:59] Jonathan so the has and minimum is such a debatist kind of talk about we need to have [0:21:00] be able to pay for these things because we don't have that stuff so new growth is what's [0:21:09] spurring the requirement of how that met new station. We should pay it. [0:21:14] Uppers also are cognizant of if it's too much it might put some shackles on new development that cost that process for an hour and a bit [0:21:36] Not taking it past when to redo this type of stuff [0:21:52] Chris Reed [0:23:44] Has Spencer [0:23:45] Index went up by 8% [0:23:52] headwalks [0:23:55] Rose and PVC pipe [0:23:59] I'm sure projects that would be impenetheds the struggle to recommend the full 8% to us [0:24:14] Council is new even 6% [0:24:20] We need to have to some 8% to keep the cost isn't given to go with 6% [0:24:46] I'm thinking is a public key. So I just want to share my thoughts with the council. Thank you for listening. [0:24:54] Any else have a comment? So I personally am leaning towards 8% [0:25:01] Taxpayers, I know it's tough. I'm a CPI right now. I looked it up at 6.5% [0:25:14] So 8% is not a huge discrepancy. Like there has been in the past, but Travis did you have some data? [0:25:25] Did you have some data? [0:25:27] Just, uh, Councilman, I published it at six, your cap is six, if you publish it at eight, it's your cap is eight. [0:26:03] So we're doing consensus to have a primary servant. [0:29:36] Yes. [0:29:41] Next item is an action item, a request to adopt ordinance 2023-001, [0:29:47] or the rezoning of rezoning. [0:29:50] Is that what that really means? [0:29:52] That's what it says, but that's why you're here. [0:29:54] This item is the ordinance for what was commonly known as the North Canyon Med Operators as [0:30:30] as they came through in December at the City Council meeting. [0:30:35] It was heard on November to decide to move forward [0:30:46] the rezone in the Oval Process section [0:30:57] is where the language is, [0:30:58] two places on third and five from least every board. [0:31:07] Any questions for Jonathan on the web a second? [0:31:36] Key motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins. [0:31:40] Two put, or dance 2023 on third and final reading [0:31:45] by title only by suspending the rules. [0:31:48] Amy Roll call vote please, to pass the six to zero. [0:32:10] Yes. [0:32:15] of the city of twins, sorry, in order to the city council, the city of twin falls, I don't. [0:32:20] Resoning certain real property below, described, providing the zoning classification thereof, [0:32:25] therefore, in ordering the necessary area of impact. [0:32:33] Alex Koval, motion by Alex Koval, second invite Nikki Boyd to approve, ordinance 2020 to 3, [0:32:54] death 0 0 1. Amy Roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. And the key motion passes 5 to 0. [0:33:11] or five to one excuse me. [0:33:15] Next item is another action item [0:33:17] a request to adopt ordinance 2023-002 [0:33:21] or the amendment to the Magic Valley Mall CDA [0:33:25] for signage on property located at 1485 [0:33:28] Poe line road east. [0:33:30] To the council this item came to the Plains County Commission on October 12th. [0:33:36] This amendment consolidated the digital signage of the mall [0:33:48] with the slightly larger signs of the council action [0:33:56] Similar fashion to the last one. [0:34:03] Any questions for Jonathan? [0:34:17] The first question, Chris Reed? [0:34:19] That we dispense with the reading rules that put Ordinance 2023-002 on third and final by reading. [0:34:25] Alex Koval, then most by Chris for Reed. [0:34:32] Second by Alex Koval to put Ordinance 2023-002 by suspending the rules on third and final reading by title. [0:34:42] Call. [0:34:44] Amy Rochon, Vote, Please. [0:34:51] Yes. [0:35:00] Motion passes 6-0. [0:35:01] Hey, Chris Reed. [0:35:03] Oh, would you please? [0:35:05] Sorry. [0:35:06] I can't. [0:35:07] There's something there. [0:35:08] That's why I have a year. [0:35:09] We're having some computer. [0:35:10] Order in December 2023-002, and ordinance of the City Council. [0:35:16] The City of Twin Falls, Idaho, rezoning certain real property below, [0:35:19] describing providing the zoning classification, therefore, [0:35:22] and ordering the necessary area of impact, district's map and [0:35:29] Chris Street, can you have a second? [0:35:36] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Nicky Boyd, [0:35:40] to adopt Ordinance 2023-002. [0:35:45] Amy Rollcovall? [0:35:49] Yes. [0:35:55] Yes. [0:35:55] Thank you, motion passes 6 to 0. [0:36:00] Thank you, Jonathan. [0:36:05] Next on the agenda is the time for public input. [0:36:09] There's anybody in the public that wishes to come down and speak. [0:36:13] Please come down, state your name, [0:36:15] and whether you're a resident of the advisory board report [0:36:24] is advisory, right? [0:36:26] OK, so we do have a public hearing at 6 o'clock, [0:37:12] which we can't start before then. [0:37:17] We'll take a break for about 25, 24, 6. [0:37:22] Meeting back to order, still that we have a quorum, [0:39:41] six members present. [0:39:43] Our next item is a public hearing. [0:39:45] It's an action item. [0:39:47] Are we quest to exchange real property [0:39:49] with the College of Southern Idaho, [0:39:54] Deputy City Manager. Excuse me Mayor Pierce. I'm employee of the college so I will step [0:40:02] down from the diastring the public hearing portion. I mentioned to the public we do not [0:40:08] have access to our computer set all though we're going to be kind of struggling up here [0:40:14] but we'll do our best. Go ahead Mitch. [0:40:17] Is the item where we'll pass us on our own by the city. A couple of weeks ago we had [0:40:27] Station number two of our station number two at six fifty-five [0:40:57] To CSI, the second would be where the armor is at. I think it's 1069 [0:41:01] Frontier, so that's the view of this CSI and it comes to the resolution. [0:42:02] Any questions for me? [0:42:20] I mean, also CSI is some stuff that's going to take a little time too, so for them to dispose of property they have to go in. [0:43:20] Imagine the next step that you'll see will be these processes just one of the city has. [0:44:14] And sometimes it's all processes, so we can rule that the city's going to receive, and college doesn't have, so inside of the agreement, it is going to first require an appraisal of the property. [0:44:39] And when appraisal is complete before you see the agreement, Mitch said that could be somewhere between, let's say, several weeks. [0:44:49] The biggest challenge that they're going to have is going through an appraisal process. [0:44:53] They're going to have to find something of similar value compared to being recently gone. [0:45:14] The second piece is there's a series of triggers that will occur. [0:45:17] The first is move out of station two on the city's request. [0:46:20] The reason we want to- [0:47:26] So basically, after public input, we can see that's where the group chooses, okay. [0:47:32] So, I will then open it up to the public if there's anybody out there who wishes to come down. [0:47:38] See that's set-shaking now, so I'll close the public hearing part of it. [0:47:44] Mr. Ears coming so a lot of work [0:48:12] Second motion by Chris Reed seconded my Alex Kaval to [0:48:18] approve the request to exchange real property with College of Southern Idaho as a present [0:48:24] Amy Rokovo, please [0:48:26] Yes, you motion passes five four and one abstention or meeting tonight. We are adjourned. Thank you everyone