Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2022-11-28, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2022-11-28/ [0:02:23] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the last meeting of November 28, 2022. [0:02:31] When we confirm we have a quorum, we have six members present. [0:02:36] Councilman Harkins is excused. [0:02:40] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:02:43] If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:03:04] Thank you. [0:03:05] We have no proclamations today. [0:03:08] So next item on the agenda is the consent calendar, council wishes. [0:03:13] Move to approve. [0:03:16] A second. [0:03:17] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Alex Kavad to approve the consent calendar is written. [0:03:24] Any other couple of votes, please? [0:03:26] Ruth Pears. [0:03:27] Yes. [0:03:28] Chris Reed. [0:03:29] Yes. [0:03:31] Thank you, Boyd. [0:03:32] Yes. [0:03:33] Jason Brown. [0:03:34] Yes. [0:03:36] Spencer Cutler. [0:03:37] Yes. [0:03:38] And Alex Kaval. [0:03:39] Yes. [0:03:40] Thank you. [0:03:41] So if you are here for the Villas on Falls Subdivision, the Trust Agreement for Eastern [0:03:47] Sun Subdivision, or the Living Nativity of Twin Falls, those have all been approved. [0:03:55] Okay, next item and our Out-Autumns of Consideration is an Action Item, a request to appoint Shawnee [0:04:02] Burke to the Twin Falls Public Library Board of Trustees, and we have Tara Bartley, our [0:04:09] Library Director. [0:04:10] Welcome, Tara. [0:04:11] Thank you. [0:04:13] Mayor Pierce, Council Members, it's a pleasure to be here tonight, standing in front of you, [0:04:18] putting forward our recommendation for appointee for our Library Trustee, Shani Burt. [0:04:25] We have a trustee that is currently ending her term, Eleanor Young. [0:04:30] She has served her five-year term. [0:04:32] She'll be done in December. [0:04:34] And so early fall, we put a call out to our community and said, you know, who would be [0:04:38] interested in serving on the trustee for the library board and Shawnee sent a [0:04:44] letter of interest in your packet and I'm sure if you've read the letter you'll [0:04:48] see that not only does she have a love for libraries but she is a big advocate for [0:04:54] early literacy and so we are pleased to put forward this recommendation and if [0:05:00] you have any questions I'd be happy to answer if not I'll give it over to Shawnee. [0:05:04] any questions for Tara? You can't? Is it your mouse? Probably. [0:05:13] Oh, Council, I'm so happy to be here today. I'm like, Tara said my name is Shawnee Burt, [0:05:21] and I'm very much looking forward to serving on the library board. I have a deep love for [0:05:27] early literacy, and we attend the library for five days a week. I have pretty young kids, [0:05:35] So we love the library, I think our Twin Falls Public Library is just top of the deck. [0:05:42] It's amazing. [0:05:43] They do so many activities and I just look forward to being able to contribute to our [0:05:47] city. [0:05:48] I love Twin Falls as well. [0:05:49] We've lived here about nine years now and it's just a wonderful place to be. [0:05:53] So if anyone has any questions for me, I'd be happy to answer any questions for Shawnee. [0:06:00] Nikki Boyd. [0:06:01] Honey, it was a pleasure to meet you and interview you and it was fun having you at our last meeting even though you weren't voting yet, but to make it official, I would like to grant the request to appoint Shawnee Burt to the Twin Falls Public Library Board of Trustees. [0:06:18] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:06:19] Second. [0:06:20] Excellent. [0:06:21] Emotion by Nicky Boyd. [0:06:22] Seconded by Jason Brown to appoint Shawnee Burt to the Twin Falls Public Library Board of Trustees. [0:06:28] Amy Rokow, please. [0:06:30] Yes. [0:06:32] Yes. [0:06:33] Yes. [0:06:34] Yes. [0:06:35] Yes. [0:06:36] Yes. [0:06:37] Yes. [0:06:38] Yes. [0:06:39] Yes. [0:06:40] Yes. [0:06:41] Yes. [0:06:42] Yes. [0:06:43] Motion passes six to zero. [0:06:46] Welcome. [0:06:47] Aye. [0:06:48] Next item on the agenda is the action item. [0:06:49] A request to confirm the mayoral appointment of Ariana Harmon and Terry McCurdy to the Historic Preservation Commission. [0:06:58] And we have Lisa Strickland. [0:07:00] Welcome Lisa. [0:07:01] Good evening, Council. [0:07:02] This is a request to appoint two new commissioners to the historic preservation commission. [0:07:07] In September, the city published requests for volunteers, and we received three interested applicants. [0:07:14] The city council liaison Spencer Cutler, the historic preservation chairman, Doug Hoffman, and I interviewed the three applicants and the interview team found these two candidates to be very qualified and committed to the goals and objectives of the commission. [0:07:27] We forwarded the recommendation to the Mayor. [0:07:32] She's decided on presenting Ariana Harmon and Terri McCurdy for confirmation of these appointments [0:07:38] and a simple majority vote of the Council's needed to approve this request. [0:07:42] Approval of this request will fill two vacant seats. [0:07:47] We have one more to fill and the third person that we interviewed was interested [0:07:52] and we're just waiting on background check and so it will be scheduled for another Council meeting. [0:07:56] Council meeting upon conclusion staff recommends the Council confirm the [0:08:00] appointment and they're both here tonight if you have any questions perfect [0:08:05] Spencer Cutler I just want to take a chance to say thank you for being [0:08:09] interested and willing to serve and got some great citizens perfect want to [0:08:16] turn that into a motion yes [0:08:22] Is that your name is there? [0:08:24] Mayor, I move that we approve the appointment, or sorry, I move that we confirm the appointment [0:08:33] of Ariana Harmon and Terry McCurdy to the Historic Preservation Commission. [0:08:37] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:08:39] Second. [0:08:40] Thank you. Motion by Spencer Carler, seconded by Jason Brown to confirm the appointment [0:08:44] of Ariana Harmon and Terry McCurdy to the Historic Preservation Commission. [0:08:49] May we roll call a vote please? Nicky Boyd? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer [0:08:54] Cutler? Yes. Alex Kaval? Yes. Bruce Pierce? Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6 to 0. [0:09:02] Now if Terry or Ariana want to come down and say anything you're not required or [0:09:08] you can just wave. Okay that's Terry that's Ariana got it. Thank you. Okay next item on [0:09:15] the agenda is a request to confirm the mayoral appointment of Ex-Mallwood to the [0:09:21] URA agency, URA of the City of Twin Falls Board of Commissioners and we have [0:09:27] Sean Berriger our Economic Development Director. Welcome Sean. Thank you Mayor and [0:09:32] Council. The Urban Real Agency of the City of Twin Falls Board of Commissioners has [0:09:38] seven members and we had a vacancy on the board that was created when Alex [0:09:42] of the city council. [0:09:43] The agency and city sent out a call for candidates to consider to fill that vacancy and receive [0:09:52] two applications. [0:09:54] An interview board composed of Mayor Ruth Pierce, or Mayor Monuel Board Chair Rudy Asham-Brenner, [0:10:00] City Manager Travis Weiler, and myself interviewed the two applicants on Monday, November 7th. [0:10:05] At the conclusion of the interviews, the selection committee unanimously recommended that Eric [0:10:10] Smallwood be advanced to the mayor for consideration for nomination and that [0:10:15] nomination is now before the council for your consideration. If appointed Mr. [0:10:19] Smallwood would begin service immediately and complete the term which ends June 30th [0:10:25] of 2023. The approval requires a simple majority of the council members present [0:10:32] and just under the regulatory information there the Urban Renewal [0:10:36] agency board. It's a separate entity from the city, however, the board is [0:10:40] appointed and approved by the mayor and confirmed by the council. So that is the [0:10:46] exercise we are going through this evening. And Mr. Smallwood is here if you [0:10:50] would like to grill him. Do we need to as I call access? Any questions for Eric or [0:11:00] Sean? I'd entertain a motion. Ms. Fareed. Mayor, move that we confirm the [0:11:06] appointment of Eric Smallwood to the Urban Renewal Agency of the City of [0:11:10] Twin Falls Board of Commissioners. Thank you, Nikki Boyd. Second. Thank you, [0:11:15] Emotion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Nikki Boyd to confirm the appointment [0:11:20] events available to the Urban Renewal Agency of the City of Twin Falls Board of [0:11:25] Commissioners. Amy Wilkow, please. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Alex [0:11:32] Yes. [0:11:33] Ruth Pierce. [0:11:34] Yes. [0:11:35] Chris Reed. [0:11:36] Yes. [0:11:37] And Nikki Boyd. [0:11:38] Yes. [0:11:39] Thank you. [0:11:40] Motion passes six to zero. [0:11:41] Thank you. [0:11:42] Do you have anything you want to say or you're just going to say something? [0:11:45] I just want to thank you for the opportunity to serve on this on the board and I think [0:11:56] that the people before me up there and the people before me on the urban renewal have done [0:12:01] amazing job in the city and we're on the right path and I just looking forward to contributing [0:12:06] my time and talents to keep the ball rolling. Thank you, Eric. Thank you. Okay, next item [0:12:13] on the agenda is a presentation as the results of the 2022 National Citizen Survey for Twin [0:12:20] Falls and we have Mandy Thompson. Welcome, Mandy. Good evening, Mayor Pears Council. That's [0:12:29] Well, it's a pleasure to be here this evening to present to the results of the 2022 Citizen [0:12:45] Survey that we completed this fall. [0:12:48] Just a little background for those of you that have not participated in one of these presentations [0:12:54] in the past and for those in the audience that are not familiar. [0:12:58] The National Citizen Survey is a nationwide survey that is conducted currently by a company [0:13:03] called Polco. It used to be conducted by the National Research Committee that was based [0:13:15] in the Denver, Colorado area. They were bought up by Polco and so that is the new managing [0:13:21] company that conducts the Citizen Survey. This is a standardized survey that is used [0:13:29] to ensure high quality, it uses high quality research methods and is used by hundreds of [0:13:36] different cities across the United States. And the Citizen Survey uses the results of [0:13:42] comparable cities that we look at as benchmarks to the City of Twin Falls to really kind of [0:13:48] look at how we are doing rated against other comparable cities to Twin Falls. The survey [0:13:56] captures residents opinions about three pillars of the community. So that would be the community, [0:14:01] characteristics, governments, and participation. And it also looks at key facets of the community, [0:14:08] which is safety, mobility, natural environment, built environment, the economy, recreation and [0:14:14] wellness, education and enrichment, and community engagement. The reports that are provided by [0:14:20] by the National, excuse me, by Polko now, I, in my notes, [0:14:24] I had the NRC, discuss trends over time, [0:14:27] and they compare, again, like I said, [0:14:30] similar communities, but it also goes back and looks [0:14:33] at what our ratings have been over the past several surveys, [0:14:36] so just that we can kind of get an idea [0:14:38] of how we're doing in the eyes of our citizens. [0:14:41] This is the seventh citizen survey that we have conducted. [0:14:44] We started out in 2009, took a quick break, [0:14:48] and then in 2012, [0:14:50] We started doing the survey every other year. [0:14:54] This will be the first year, moving forward, [0:14:57] where we will start doing the survey every year. [0:15:01] As part of our move toward performance measurement, [0:15:04] we're really wanting to utilize some of these factors [0:15:08] and some of the findings within the citizen survey [0:15:10] as the basis for some of our performance, [0:15:12] the performance measurement programs. [0:15:13] So we're gonna start doing that every year. [0:15:19] Excuse me. [0:15:20] So the last time that we did this was in 2020, [0:15:25] I could not have imagined that the survey would be mailed out [0:15:28] in the fall of 2020 when if you recall some of the events [0:15:31] that were going on in our community, we're taking place. [0:15:34] And so we took a dip across the board. [0:15:38] It's, I often say our department never gets a bad rating, [0:15:44] everyone lives a firefighter. [0:15:45] And even the firefighter, [0:15:47] the firefighter department took a hit in 2020. [0:15:49] So I don't want to say you can throw all of those results out, [0:15:53] but definitely the climate by which individuals [0:15:56] were taking the survey in 2020, [0:15:58] I think really did influence that. [0:16:00] A lot of the findings that we see in 2022 [0:16:03] are a little bit more similar to 2018. [0:16:07] So how the survey works is it's mailed [0:16:09] in a set of several different waves. [0:16:11] First is a pre-notification, you get a postcard. [0:16:14] Postcard tells you either here's a code [0:16:17] and you can go online and take your survey, [0:16:19] which was the first time we could do that this year, [0:16:21] or you can wait for a paper copy to be sent to you [0:16:24] in the mail. [0:16:25] And then those individuals are tracked [0:16:29] based upon their address. [0:16:30] And so the City of Twin Falls is created, [0:16:33] we kind of divided into four quadrants down, [0:16:35] Addison and Bluix, and then that's kind of how we track [0:16:38] kind of the different areas of the city [0:16:40] where the responses come from. [0:16:42] They have to enter a code when they're taking [0:16:44] response online or if it's return in the paper copy, then we know just not who they are, but [0:16:52] that the geography or kind of the area of the community in which they live. [0:16:57] So the original postcard was emailed in August, August 3rd, and the surveys were mailed a [0:17:03] week later, and then it was opened through September 21st. [0:17:06] So citizens had that that frame of time in which to complete the survey. [0:17:13] In addition, this year for the first time, we also did an open participation survey, which [0:17:19] launched on September 7th, so it was only open for two weeks, but it allowed anyone in the [0:17:24] city to take the same survey. [0:17:26] We just didn't combine the results. [0:17:28] So what I'm talking to you tonight, essentially, is this statistically sound survey, and then [0:17:35] I'll kind of do some comparisons with the open survey. [0:17:39] We had a dip in participation percentage-wise, because Polco actually, of their own volition, [0:17:48] they, we usually, in the past, have mailed out 1500 surveys. [0:17:52] This year, we mailed out 2800. [0:17:55] I was not aware that we were, they were mailing more, that's just something that they as a [0:18:01] company have increased the number of surveys that they're mailing in each community based [0:18:07] on population. [0:18:08] So even though we had about the same number of respondents, our percentage of participation [0:18:13] went down because we actually mailed out quite a few additional surveys. [0:18:18] So the results that you see tonight are based upon 495 completed surveys, which is an overall [0:18:25] response rate of about 18%, which is definitely lower than the national average of between 30 [0:18:30] and 33%. [0:18:33] So starting out, I wanted to talk just a little bit about some of the highlights that we saw [0:18:42] in the actual survey itself. [0:18:59] So most of these aren't going to surprise you. [0:19:02] While residents are optimistic about the economic progress [0:19:06] in Twin Falls, the overall confidence in the economy [0:19:09] is wavering. [0:19:10] And several of the factors that we could [0:19:13] see that wouldn't make that conversion with the economy [0:19:18] is that the cost of housing is increasing. [0:19:22] It's not commiserant with our citizens' income. [0:19:26] And on the cost of housing, but also the quality of housing [0:19:31] and housing choice. [0:19:33] So while I think that is an overall, [0:19:39] I apologize I grabbed the wrong one. [0:19:44] So that's an overall theme that we're [0:19:46] seeing across the country. [0:19:49] So as a little bit of a reminder, [0:19:51] when we look at percentages, and you see on that first one, it says 57%. [0:19:55] That's 57% of the individuals that responded rated. [0:20:00] The question is either being good or excellent. [0:20:03] So just to kind of give you an idea. [0:20:05] So the overall economic health of the City of Twin Falls are respondents, [0:20:09] which is very similar to the benchmarks of the other communities in the United States [0:20:13] that we were compared to. [0:20:15] 57% said it was either good or excellent. [0:20:20] And then as you kind of just go down and you look at the overall quality of businesses and services [0:20:25] establishments in Twin Falls, vibrancy of the downtown and commercial area is doing quite well, [0:20:33] which shows that obviously the investments that we've made in the community, and especially in [0:20:40] downtown, are being seen by our residents, economic and opportunities. Excuse me, I'm still [0:20:48] getting over my illness from almost a month ago. [0:20:52] So I don't want to go over each of the different numbers, [0:20:54] but one of the ones that I did want to talk or highlight on [0:20:56] is the cost of living in Twin Falls. [0:20:58] So obviously the cost of living is [0:21:02] a measure of increased cost of housing [0:21:04] and the income of the par citizens [0:21:08] not keeping up with the increase in the cost of housing. [0:21:10] So that kind of gives you a little bit of information [0:21:13] as to why that kind of overall loss of confidence [0:21:17] in the economy. Mobility and walkability. So no surprise, mobility is a challenge in our [0:21:28] survey. It always makes me laugh when we get some, a few individuals that talk about the [0:21:34] quality of the public transportation system that we have and to involve. It always makes [0:21:39] me wonder, you know, who's writing the buses when, because we don't really have an option [0:21:47] for that right now, but so it doesn't, it's not surprising that you're going to see some [0:21:51] really low numbers when it comes to the quality of transportation. [0:21:54] So we go down here so you can see a public transportation, 11%. [0:21:59] So this is good because this, you know, this is something that the council a few weeks ago [0:22:04] chose to address as we're moving forward with launching microtransit in Twin Falls. [0:22:11] But also just thinking about the walkability of Twin Falls is increasing, and so that is [0:22:21] ease of walking in Twin Falls is again in about 50%. [0:22:25] So while it's lower than the benchmark communities, it has increased a little bit from the 2020 [0:22:31] survey. [0:22:32] So as we continue, as the Council continues to make investments in sidewalks, I know that's [0:22:36] It's been a goal of the council is to continue to invest in the construction of new sidewalks [0:22:47] and also the replacements of existing sidewalks. [0:22:49] And so we hope to see that continue to increase over time. [0:22:54] But again, lack of public transportation, possibly with the ease of traveling by bicycle, [0:22:59] we don't have a lot of bicycle lanes in to involve. [0:23:01] So that could potentially be a reason why that doesn't receive a higher score. [0:23:06] So again, just a little bit of an idea for that, kind of the responses behind that overall [0:23:12] trend on the jump around here, just a little bit. [0:23:19] So the next one is a little bit is Parks and Recreation. [0:23:24] So overall, the overall quality of Parks and Recreation opportunities in Twin Falls, as [0:23:29] you can see, is we're doing well at 76%. [0:23:34] So as we continue to make investments in the amenities that we have in Twin Falls, whether [0:23:39] that be in our parks, on the amenities within our parks, our trail system, those are some [0:23:44] of the things that the respondents are seeing. [0:23:49] So this is good news, this is really good news for Twin Falls. [0:23:52] As you can see, we're kind of on an upward trend across the board for the most part. [0:24:00] the quality of each of the following services city parks for 71% say we're doing, you know, [0:24:05] if they're either good or excellent. [0:24:09] Recreation programs and the like recreation centers or facilities, it's lower. [0:24:15] So this is kind of maybe some data that we can consider as we're continuing the conversation [0:24:20] about recreation center and windfalls. [0:24:22] But you have to someone, we had a conversation at EMT the other day and someone said, well, [0:24:27] You know, those 54% that think we're doing a good or excellent job, what are they using? [0:24:31] But we have to remember that somebody might look at a recreation facility as like the City [0:24:35] Pool, our tennis courts, pickleball courts. [0:24:39] So, again, just because it's not a recreation center, it's a facility that individuals in [0:24:45] the community access that are provided by the city. [0:24:48] So, overall, the Parks and Recreation Department did well, so that was good to see. [0:24:57] A resident sense of civic and community pride and the connection engagement with their community [0:25:04] both saw an increase of about 15% over 2020. [0:25:09] They received positive ratings from 62% and 54% of citizens respectively. [0:25:18] So our residents really have a sense of pride in our community. [0:25:23] And they haven't and they're connected and engaged with the community as I apologize. [0:25:29] As seen in some of the results of the survey as well. [0:25:34] Another overall trend that we saw was in the overall feeling of safety in Twin Falls. [0:25:40] This is one that the police department keeps a close eye on. [0:25:44] And then also they do some additional polling separately to kind of continue to keep an eye on the [0:25:52] on their overall, I guess, scorecard with the community, [0:25:56] but the overall feeling of safety and Twin Falls, [0:25:59] while going down is 67%, 67% of those that took the pulse [0:26:06] that we were either doing a good or excellent job. [0:26:09] But what I find interesting is if you just go down [0:26:12] to this next set of questions, [0:26:16] most individuals feel safe within the community. [0:26:19] So, these are questions that sometimes you have to wonder, [0:26:22] like, kind of, what were people thinking about [0:26:25] when they answer the questions? [0:26:26] Maybe they read it a little bit lower, [0:26:28] but, I mean, 89% feel safe in their neighborhood, [0:26:31] 88% feel safe in the downtown core, [0:26:34] 70% think we're doing a good job with property crime, [0:26:39] 79% believe that they feel safe [0:26:42] and they're not, they're safe, violent crime. [0:26:46] So, overall, within kind of everyone's kind of living environment and when we're talking [0:26:52] specifics of crime, the responses were that we're doing a good job when we're doing well. [0:26:57] But that's a hard thing about a survey like this. [0:26:59] You don't really can't get in the mind of someone to really truly understand why they are answering [0:27:04] the questions that they are. [0:27:05] But it gives us still kind of a benchmark. [0:27:07] So, when we start looking at those performance measures of how you know overall safety of [0:27:11] the community, it's something that we can continue to look at. [0:27:16] And then the last thing I wanted to go over tonight is just general confidence in government. [0:27:21] And we were having a conversation before the meeting started tonight about the reality that [0:27:33] the reality that we get lumped in with all levels of government. [0:27:39] When you ask an individual about how well your local government is doing, [0:27:45] not everyone fully understands the delineation between even the city or the [0:27:51] county but even the state and the federal government and I think sometimes [0:27:54] that's a little bit hard to believe but if you think of kind of about the [0:27:56] national conversations that we have going on right now there is an overall [0:28:00] distrust in government and I do think that it tends to kind of trickle down a [0:28:05] little bit into the local government. We are the closest level of government to [0:28:10] our system. Someone has a problem and they and then they're seeking you know [0:28:14] they have a perceived issue that they're looking for a resolution to, were the most [0:28:18] accessible level of government. They can come here, they can find someone to speak [0:28:21] with either if it's one of you, if it's a staff, if it's a police officer at the [0:28:25] police department, were very accessible. And so I think that's, there are a lot of [0:28:30] positives to that, but with that comes some level of restoration when we kind of [0:28:34] get lumped in with that overall larger level of government and governance. So, [0:28:39] but just to kind of look at some of these, the results, [0:28:47] if you look at our overall confidence [0:28:50] in the city of Twin Falls in our government is, [0:28:53] I mean, we're still doing fairly well at 41% [0:28:58] think that we're, you know, they have overall, [0:29:00] they have confidence in what we're doing. [0:29:03] But you look a little bit down here, [0:29:06] the value of service or the taxes paid [0:29:08] were definitely kind of on a downhill trend, [0:29:10] which makes sense considering the constant conversation [0:29:13] around property taxes and taxes in general. [0:29:18] So we had a conversation the other day in EMT also [0:29:22] where we talked about where we have these, [0:29:25] we talked a little bit earlier about the community pride [0:29:28] and connection to community. [0:29:30] And yet we also have only 47% of the responses [0:29:34] say that we're doing a good job [0:29:36] and that overall direction of the Twin Falls is taking. [0:29:40] So I think these are places for us internally as staff [0:29:44] and opportunities for us to speak with the council [0:29:48] about and even for you to speak with residents [0:29:51] that you come in contact with about like how are we doing? [0:29:54] I mean, are we going the wrong direction? [0:29:58] Or is this just a kind of like, again, [0:30:00] these are only 495 citizens within our 52 or 53,000 [0:30:06] overall number of citizens that are living here? [0:30:08] So, it is a little bit hard to really fully understand what is behind some of these questions, [0:30:19] but I would hazard to guess that one of the biggest reasons is because in general when [0:30:23] you see government in Nina right now, there's such a negative connotation associated with it, [0:30:29] I would say that there's going to be some trickle down from that. [0:30:33] So we'll need to kind of continue to work to address and be wary of and aware of the fact [0:30:40] that we do have citizens in the community that maybe don't think that we are taking the [0:30:45] community in the direction that they would like it to go. [0:30:49] But yet we are providing quality services. [0:30:51] Our residents feel safe. [0:30:54] They appreciate the amenities that we're providing. [0:30:57] So again, it can be a little bit inconsistent, but at the same time, something, you know, [0:31:01] a place to start the conversation. So I could be here all night going over all of the intricacies [0:31:09] of this. I included the PDF in your council packet for you to go over even further. And [0:31:17] if you really are a data junkie, I could give you the login to this in here and you can [0:31:22] start comparing and digging out and looking at specific data. [0:31:27] So, but here I have a question, okay. [0:31:33] More of a statement, if you scroll to the bottom of this one, [0:31:35] the governance kind of what you were talking about, [0:31:38] right there, the overall, how would you rate the quality [0:31:42] of service provided by each of the following, [0:31:44] you look at the city of Twin Falls, [0:31:46] where we were in the 40s, now we're 63, [0:31:50] and then federal government, you can kind of tell [0:31:53] where people's frustration and anger really is at. [0:31:56] But above this, definitely, there's a feeling towards [0:32:00] we're all lumped in together. [0:32:01] So as you were talking about that, [0:32:02] and I read this earlier, I just thought, yeah. [0:32:06] And it's hard. [0:32:06] It definitely shows it right there. [0:32:08] That's exactly what Brian and I were talking about. [0:32:10] I'm like, well, how can they have a lower confidence [0:32:12] but then still great the quality of services [0:32:14] that we're providing? [0:32:15] And I do think it still kind of comes into that. [0:32:18] But you can tell there's a frustration [0:32:20] with government in general. [0:32:21] In general, absolutely. [0:32:23] But I think that this is also a point of, [0:32:25] I would like to thank you for calling that out. [0:32:28] So yeah, 63% are calling out that we are offering [0:32:32] quality services to the citizens. [0:32:34] So that's something to note. [0:32:38] Thank you. [0:32:39] Any other questions for Mandy? [0:32:42] Comments? [0:32:45] OK. [0:32:46] Thank you. [0:32:47] So Josh will post the link to the overall report [0:32:51] and some kind of smaller, well, tease out some things [0:32:55] that will have a place on the website. [0:32:57] so citizens can take a look and get a little better understanding of the responses if they choose to do so. [0:33:04] Thank you. [0:33:06] Thank you. [0:33:10] Thank you. [0:33:11] Next item on the agenda is another presentation, fourth quarter financial update. [0:33:16] We are with CFO Briana Howard. [0:33:19] Welcome. [0:33:23] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:33:43] This is the fun one. [0:33:44] This is the compilation of the entire fun for me. [0:33:47] I hope I'm putting a little bit of nuggets into a pre-tibue that you can take away some [0:33:52] of these things because I do get excited about it. It's fun to see where we come out, where [0:33:56] we compare and how we start of the year and go through a quarter by quarter. So hopefully [0:34:01] it's not too drudgery and it's something that you can enjoy a little bit. What I'm going [0:34:05] to do is I'm going to start talking about the big picture. So I'll have a couple of [0:34:10] graphs that show the big picture in general, how it's split up between tax-supported funds [0:34:14] and enterprise funds. And then I'll dive a little bit deeper into the tax-supported [0:34:18] funds followed up by the enterprise funds and then some national statistics and comparisons. [0:34:26] This one's a little bit complicated. [0:34:28] These first couple of slides and the reason being is because we have an adopted budget [0:34:32] and an amended budget. [0:34:34] So all year long I've been presenting on this adopted budget. [0:34:37] You'll see that you'll recognize this number, this 77, almost 78 million dollars was our [0:34:42] budget presented beforehand. [0:34:44] 41% of that makes up our non-tax supported funds, which is our waste mine. [0:34:49] already yawning Spencer. Just wait, give me this time. Yes, interesting. So 78 million dollars and non-tax [0:35:07] support funds is like your water, your wastewater, your sanitation. That again is enterprise funds, [0:35:12] which are like businesses without a profit motive. The tax-supported funds which are majorly [0:35:17] substantiated or supported by tax funds is 46 million dollars. You can see on the [0:35:23] right is the major fund composition. General makes up about 41% of our total [0:35:28] budget with water and wastewater coming in second and third. The difference here, if [0:35:34] you look at this next slide, is it's now 87 million. So I kind of liken this to we [0:35:41] took the test, we found out the answers, we studied, we came back and we gave the [0:35:45] test again and we got the right answers. It's very frustrating in government because what [0:35:50] happens is we cannot over-expend what we've reported publicly. So even though we didn't [0:35:56] get any more funds, we are using things like reserves, we're using things like the certificate [0:36:01] of participation that we initiated to get to our total expenditure and revenue budget of [0:36:08] $87 million. The biggest difference here is in the tax-supported funds. We had fire station [0:36:15] build out of $4 million in our training facility of just about one and a half [0:36:19] million. The waste water fund had a digestive replacement of 750,000 and a [0:36:26] boiler replacement of a million. Those contrary to private sector, those are [0:36:31] actually revenues. So that's the money that's coming in that we are using to [0:36:35] expend and increases our total budget to show us of around 87.7 million. The tax [0:36:45] So I'm going to dive off a little bit into the tax-supported funds. [0:36:49] This is our fund composition. [0:36:50] You can see the pie chart on the side with 69% of the general fund. [0:36:55] And on the largest contributing revenue sources on the side, our total revenue [0:36:59] services on our adopted budget versus the amended one next has been $46 million, [0:37:06] with about 55% being the property taxes that we received from our citizens. [0:37:12] In the up of the revenue section, the largest revenue sources included are permits of 1.4 [0:37:19] million, airport revenue of 1.2, and everything else is less than a million dollars that's [0:37:24] all combined together to create that other. [0:37:29] The next one shows amended where it's at now, and the biggest difference I've got circled [0:37:35] here is the COP. [0:37:36] If you remember, we went through the Certificate of Participation earlier in the year to build [0:37:42] fire stations. That was that fun game day that we that we did where we sold and a [0:37:47] couple of different larger enterprises purchased our what I kind of consider in [0:37:52] my mind like a bond. They purchased and they we pay them interest. Wells Fargo was [0:37:56] a bigger purchaser or Piper Sandler who we invest with was a purchaser. These are [0:38:01] a couple of the bigger entities that bought our certificates of participation [0:38:05] and that becomes income. That's three point three six million dollars that is [0:38:10] added to our revenue side. We also use reserves like the wastewater we talked about in the fire [0:38:15] station. Sorry, not wastewater because this is tax-supported funds. But in our fire station and [0:38:20] anything else, we use reserves of $2.6 million. So our total revenues of the tax-supported funds [0:38:26] now are $53 million. I'm going to dive into property tax history a little bit, so I'm kind of [0:38:37] explain and maybe back up a little bit more so than I've done in the past. You can see starting in [0:38:43] In 2019, we had 22 million dollars in property taxes, and it's incrementally gone up until [0:38:51] we get to 2022, and it's just under 26 million. [0:38:56] There are three reasons for the most part, most significantly, that we can increase property [0:39:02] taxes. [0:39:03] We have a 3% increase, which in my mind, I've always kind of equated to an adjustment, like [0:39:09] a CPI adjustment. [0:39:11] It doesn't really work right now when CPI is 10%, 12%, but in my mind it's kind of that [0:39:16] inflationary adjustment. [0:39:18] So we have a 3% increase that we can take, so the City of Twin Falls can increase our [0:39:23] revenue. [0:39:24] We can give to the county the number that we're going to take, which is approved by Council. [0:39:28] Council can decide that they want to take 3% or they don't. [0:39:33] The next biggest piece is new construction. [0:39:37] we build when people build, they're creating value for the City of Twin Falls and they're [0:39:43] building stuff, they're building property on top of it and they need to pay a part of the [0:39:48] resources to be able to get some of the services that we provide. So they pay their piece. So [0:39:55] with new construction and our property taxes, those are the two largest pieces. The third [0:40:00] one is annexation. That's actually pretty small. It's not very large at all. I want to say [0:40:06] It's a less than 5,000. [0:40:09] It's been 2,000 or 3,000 last couple of years. [0:40:11] So that's a reason we can increase. [0:40:13] We annex property in and we can build our property tax base. [0:40:17] But the two largest ones are property tax or new construction and [0:40:22] I'm sorry, new construction in 3%. [0:40:25] The 3% increase to give you kind of a rough feel for those numbers [0:40:29] was about 760,000 this year inside of this budget [0:40:34] In about 715,000 in the prior year, our new construction, which was limited 90% to this [0:40:41] last year, the new construction has been around 625 to 700,000. [0:40:47] Those are the pieces that increase our budget significantly, ish. [0:40:53] The difference on this chart, if you look at that 25 million to the 24 million, that's [0:40:58] $1.6 million increase to our budget that we received and what's called new [0:41:03] money. That's the 3% and the new construction. But the year before the [0:41:08] difference of 23.4 million to 24 is only 625,000. [0:41:13] Does anybody know why it's so small? Yeah, you're actually on it because it [0:41:23] cares. We did not take the 3% because we wanted to opt into Governor Little's [0:41:29] property tax rebate, and so we didn't increase by anything beyond the new construction amount. [0:41:37] So that's the reason why we don't see such a significant jump, but when it comes to the [0:41:41] budget that the City of Twin Falls gets and what we give to the county, I want to clarify [0:41:45] again too, as the City of Twin Falls we do not collect property taxes, we don't assess [0:41:51] property tax values, we give to the county what's called an L2 form that shows the amount of money [0:41:58] that we are saying we are going to collect, so council approves to collect next year. [0:42:04] Does that make sense so far? [0:42:08] There's a foregone in there too, but that's kind of small and it's limited, but it's really [0:42:12] small. [0:42:13] Any questions on property taxes? [0:42:18] So what I'm going to do is I'm going to show you a new diagram. [0:42:20] I've got a question over the weekend on how property taxes are calculated. [0:42:26] So one of the interesting things that I've learned quite a bit from working at the City [0:42:30] when falls is, number one, we don't assess property taxes, we don't assess values, we [0:42:35] only get so much. So what I'm doing here is I have a hypothetical analysis. We're going [0:42:41] to say, so this 25 million, if you remember, that's the amount that we're getting here, [0:42:47] we're going to do a hypothetical example. We get 25 million. Let's just say this is a [0:42:52] perfect world. We have 50% in residential that pay property taxes and we've got 50% in commercial. [0:42:59] In this hypothetical situation, that 25 million is paid 50%, so 12.8 million is paid by residential, [0:43:06] 12.8 million is paid by commercial. [0:43:09] Remember, one of our biggest increases, not counting new construction, one of our biggest [0:43:13] increases is 3%. [0:43:15] So everything's stagnant, let's say everything stays the same, we increase our budget by 3%. [0:43:20] That's the difference that you see from the 25 million to the 26 million. [0:43:24] Okay, now let's say in this hypothetical example, like we saw a couple years ago, residential homes increase 30%. [0:43:33] We all saw significant increases in our values on our property tax statements. [0:43:38] We've just received these last year and I haven't seen as significant of an increase, but two years ago we did. [0:43:45] So hypothetically, let's say residential increases 30%, every home increases 30%. [0:43:52] But everything else stays the same. In this situation, that number shows that residential, [0:43:59] because the pie is the same, shows that residents now make 63% of the pie because they grew more [0:44:06] than the 3% and commercial is now 37%. What that's showing is your commercial, with all [0:44:12] things being equal, no new construction, and just a shift of 30% of this pie, residential [0:44:18] is now paying 16 million and commercial is paying 9.7 million. [0:44:23] So you can see why property tax owners on a residential basis [0:44:28] hurt by their paying so much. [0:44:30] This is why you're getting questions from individual residents [0:44:33] in the city of Twin Falls. [0:44:35] That pie shifted. [0:44:36] This is purely hypothetical. [0:44:38] I'm actually reaching out to the county right now [0:44:40] to get legitimate actual numbers to show you [0:44:43] what that shift is, because I think it's quite interesting. [0:44:46] But right now, that's kind of a big picture of why residents see it. [0:44:51] We only get so much. [0:44:52] We can only increase so much. [0:44:55] It just depends on who's sharing that pie more. [0:44:59] Does that make sense? [0:45:05] This next page is our major revenue sources that are not property taxes. [0:45:09] We receive highway money, state revenue sharing, and franchise fees. [0:45:14] The highway user revenue includes a few one times money that we were not anticipating. [0:45:18] You can see, we got 145% of what we had budgeted. [0:45:23] We received 950,000 from the state general fund for roads [0:45:26] in addition to 325,000 for additional sales tax money [0:45:31] being used to fund transportation. [0:45:33] So when Travis comes to you and says, [0:45:35] hey, do we want to fund category B? [0:45:38] This is where that comes from. [0:45:40] When we get extra money on top of what we budgeted, [0:45:42] these are the two categories for the most part [0:45:45] that are giving us extra money [0:45:47] that we can use for things that we had not budgeted. [0:45:51] Our state shared revenues, our sales tax and liquor [0:45:54] and are received quarterly. [0:45:55] We're capped at a 1% increase, [0:45:57] but this year we've received more [0:45:59] because the state of Idaho received much more than anticipated [0:46:02] and we received the additional pro-rata distribution. [0:46:05] Franchise are only 3% of our total revenues [0:46:09] and they include gas, electric, and cable. [0:46:13] And a more detailed note, this gas, electric, and cable, [0:46:17] you can see that gas has continuously gone up. [0:46:22] I'm sorry, electric has continuously gone up. [0:46:25] That's Idaho power. [0:46:26] So this is the rent that we are paid [0:46:29] from franchise fees. [0:46:30] The utility company pays them. [0:46:33] There was a, so one thing I've mentioned before in the past [0:46:36] is it frustrates me that we can't tax, we can't rent, [0:46:41] or we can't get any fees from digital, [0:46:45] so from like Netflix or from that kind of stuff. [0:46:47] So what was interesting, I read an article [0:46:49] and it counted today a few weeks ago that said [0:46:52] Maryland's digital ad tax was struck down [0:46:54] on the grounds that it is in violation of the US Constitution [0:46:57] as well as the Federal Internet Tax Freedom Act, [0:47:00] which is another reason why, more substantially, [0:47:03] you can't tax TDS here in the city of Twin Falls. [0:47:06] Maryland was the only state that I had read out [0:47:08] that tried to tax digital ad tax and it was struck down. [0:47:12] On a similar note, Mitch asked last time I presented [0:47:15] and EMT, how much do we pay Idaho Power? We paid globally Idaho Power about $1.7 million [0:47:21] dollars and we're receiving $1.6 so they're getting their fair share. Butch Taxwell's [0:47:32] expenditures, personal L is typically the largest percent of our budget and comes in [0:47:37] around 56% of our total budget expenditures included in these actual personal expenses [0:47:43] is they had unbudgeted $2,000 that you remember we approved for every city of Twin Falls resident. [0:47:49] We are, I'm sorry, every city of Twin Falls employee. [0:47:52] You can see we're still at only 93.9% budgeted, which is the common theme across the city. [0:48:01] In M&O, overall items available were difficult to obtain, but the significant increases in [0:48:06] prices mitigated the savings. [0:48:08] I talked with Norm at the shop, and he said, hand tools have increased due to specialty [0:48:12] new tools needed for new equipment, the cost of chemicals for uniforms, rags, rugs, etc. [0:48:18] has increased in addition to a fuel surcharge, motor fuels for shop service trucks increased [0:48:24] significantly, even though we have a negotiated price through the CFN program, it is hinged [0:48:29] on an 8 cent per gallon price tag over United Oils invoice price. This increase shows up [0:48:35] across the fuel line in the city. Mark Thompson with our streets department says they spent [0:48:39] about 84% of the street budget for M&O and had to encumber $528,000 in equipment and [0:48:46] projects due to supply shortages and contractors too busy to take on more work. [0:48:51] In a capital improvement fund, this consists largely of the street fund for $3.7 million [0:48:57] and fire stations in a training facility expenses to $8.3 million. [0:49:02] Lag times on equipment are still excessive, streets are still waiting on a snow plow track [0:49:06] for 164,000 that they ordered in December. They actually just took possession of their [0:49:12] street sweeper of 184,000 that they purchased back in December again. Mark shared with me [0:49:20] that they were able to lock in prices for street purchases in 2122 early enough that they didn't [0:49:25] see the huge increases at that point. But when we started our long-term planning process, [0:49:31] which were about ready to kick off again starting in January and February, but this last year [0:49:35] They were told by vendors that they would be some significant price changes. [0:49:39] When they started asking for updated quotes, prices started coming in at $20,000 to $90,000 [0:49:45] more than were quoted. [0:49:47] They're currently looking to see if they can change components to less than the cost. [0:49:51] There's a chance they may have to push out some of their capital purchases because they [0:49:54] can't get to their budgeted number. [0:49:56] They're also currently evaluating trying to find ways to lessen the cost of the equipment [0:50:00] they planned on buying this year. [0:50:02] Cav and chassis prices have come down a little in the last month, but steel components are [0:50:07] still high, even though steel prices have started to decrease, as again the just where [0:50:12] we live, city of Twin Falls, we tend to see a lag in almost everything. [0:50:17] The transfers are high because of our annual transfer from the general fund to the capital [0:50:21] improvement fund. [0:50:22] If you remember right, we take 25% of what we had in the prior year above and beyond what [0:50:28] we spent and we transfer that to a capital improvement fund so that we can purchase things [0:50:32] in the future like this building like City Hall and like the fire station. [0:50:37] Since we are talking about personnel, I wanted to bring up a couple of things that Gretchen [0:50:45] and Ida shared with me. [0:50:46] Personnel is a common theme for quite some time now and there are multiple different shifts [0:50:50] that we are seeing. [0:50:51] Ida, the head of our HR department, let me know that we have hired 36 new employees [0:50:57] in this last fiscal year and seven in the fourth quarter alone. [0:51:00] This is over 10% of our organization. [0:51:04] She said the applicant pool since the beginning of the fiscal year have grown and are showing [0:51:08] a few more qualified candidates than she had seen the previous fiscal year. [0:51:11] She's seen a lot more people changing careers and not necessarily unemployed. [0:51:16] HR is also considering applicants they'd interviewed for positions and not selected for [0:51:21] other positions in the city. [0:51:22] So I talked with Gretchen quite a bit on this and she forwarded me this chart which is quite [0:51:27] intriguing. [0:51:28] We haven't made any changes yet, but we need to strongly evaluate if we should. [0:51:34] She forwarded me this graphic that shows the number one concern for the current workforce [0:51:38] is flexibility. [0:51:40] She forwarded me another article from Pew Research that indicates quit rates. [0:51:45] We're reaching levels not seen since 1970, and that while most workers who leave a job [0:51:51] are not working another one immediately, the preceding month, the majority of those who [0:51:55] are switching are seeing it pay off in higher earnings. [0:51:59] Another article from Pew Research said in January, 59% of employed Americans whose job [0:52:05] duties could be performed remotely reported they were still working from home, which is [0:52:09] crazy. [0:52:10] In Idaho, for the most part, most of us are still back at work. [0:52:15] But unlike earlier in the pandemic, the majority of these workers that they were doing so by [0:52:18] choice, not because their workplace was closed or unavailable. [0:52:23] These are other things that the city manager's office are considering when they're talking [0:52:27] about what can we do to help retain some of our employees or frankly probably to get employees [0:52:34] since we are significantly understaffed. [0:52:36] Here's some more interesting data. [0:52:39] We have these charts are neat. [0:52:45] Women are more likely than men to leave the labor force each month on average. [0:52:49] Workers with less tenure are more open to changing jobs in the coming months and about [0:52:53] Half of the workers who change employers are also moving to a different industry or occupation. [0:52:59] We have personally experienced some of this. [0:53:02] A first-line supervisor in the PD left to start their own business, remained in good terms, [0:53:07] then came back to fill-in part-time shifts when after six months they couldn't sustain [0:53:10] the lease and their property and didn't want to go into debt. [0:53:13] We have a police officer that left to be an IT director. [0:53:17] We have firefighters choosing passions that are not for career or suitability, like pursuing [0:53:21] pilots license. It doesn't take long to make a list of what we're seeing. These are not [0:53:26] typical stories, but people are thinking and acting on doing these extra businesses. Building [0:53:35] permits is kind of a no story, but we've been talking about it all year, so let's just [0:53:39] throw the numbers up there and I can show you where we're at. We budgeted 1.3 million, [0:53:43] we budgeted conservatively just to make sure we didn't over extend ourselves. Again, for [0:53:48] government, we cannot expend more than we budget, and have we budgeted high, we would [0:53:53] extended high and it would have put us in the negative. So in this case we are [0:53:57] significantly down from 21 but we are still reach 111% of our budget and this [0:54:06] is the building permits their history updated for 22. Last year just to get put [0:54:12] this in perspective we had 486 single family permits and this year we had only [0:54:18] 154. This stops the tax. This is segues in the tax. They enterprise funds. [0:54:28] Is there any questions on the tax supported funds? What do you project building permits to do? [0:54:38] I saw your graph. That's it. I have a guess but I think Mitch would have probably more knowledge [0:54:47] than I would. I like how you started that with the various tax tax. He probably knows more. [0:54:54] Well we budgeted for revenue to be totally flat again or not anticipating much more [0:55:01] than we got in fiscal year 22. We've only had one or one month complete now [0:55:08] for the current fiscal year and we continue to be down on residential [0:55:14] permits. Fortunately our commercial permit site is up in [0:55:20] October of 22 looked pretty good from a revenue standpoint compared to October of 21, but residential permits were like one permit in October and, you know, seven last October, right? So I think, essentially, we'll still continue to see a pretty slow residential market, but like I said, fortunately on the commercial side, we've been higher than we have been last year. [0:55:50] Well, let's see if it continues and I'm kind of wondering if this is the inflation effect that's starting to kick in with the interest rates being high [0:55:58] a depression on the revenue side for us on the building permits and then as I hear you talking about [0:56:05] you know norm and the rest of the [0:56:08] Expense site we're gonna be in for a shock on the expenditure [0:56:13] So this is probably gonna be the year where inflation it sounds like it's gonna kick in [0:56:17] or where we're going to really feel it. [0:56:19] Agreed. [0:56:20] I think we've started to feel inflation, [0:56:22] but the rest, like we typically do, I think we lack. [0:56:25] And it's interesting a lot of the national reports I read [0:56:28] show that single family permits are going down [0:56:31] across the nation, but multifamily permits [0:56:33] are where people are investing a lot of their money right [0:56:35] now, so I don't agree with Mitch. [0:56:38] I don't know that it's going to, I don't think it's ever [0:56:40] going to be that well, sorry. [0:56:42] Ever's pretty good. [0:56:43] It's going to be a while. [0:56:44] It's going to be a while before we see increases [0:56:47] like it is, and then it's going to be some shift. [0:56:49] Residents are going to probably go down and multiplexes are going to go up. [0:56:53] Well, and just to be clear, the way we categorize permits, [0:56:56] commercial includes multifamily. [0:56:58] I was just going to say, yeah, so that's, I mean, if you drive around time, [0:57:02] you can't say we're not building multifamily units. [0:57:05] And the other thing we're doing from the cost side is we have a vacant building [0:57:10] inspector position right now. [0:57:11] We're keeping it vacant for a while to see how this goes. [0:57:15] So we're not continuing to overspend. [0:57:19] Perfect. [0:57:19] Thank you. [0:57:20] Thank you. [0:57:23] So I'll jump into the Water Waste Water and Sanitation [0:57:26] ones. [0:57:26] These are our enterprise funds. [0:57:28] They're like the business, but do not have a profit motive. [0:57:32] Users pay specific fees for this service. [0:57:35] This graph shows the actual Water Fund user fees received [0:57:38] for each of the fiscal years from 2019 to current. [0:57:42] Included in this graph is that $2.3 million [0:57:45] mandated arsenic charge that was approved last year [0:57:48] to start the Waterline Maintenance Program. [0:57:50] I've also included this in prior years, [0:57:52] so it can be comparative. [0:57:54] We are actually $400,000 shy of what we had budgeted, [0:57:58] but this was a, what we had done is we had tried [0:58:02] to take what we would have made by not making [0:58:04] the extra arsenic payment and pushing it out there. [0:58:08] And so right now we are $400,000 shy [0:58:10] of what we had anticipated bringing in. [0:58:13] We are up 500 accounts from last year. [0:58:19] on the expenditure side. [0:58:21] Personnel is almost 30% of the total budget expenses. [0:58:25] Water has not been fully staffed [0:58:27] and comes in around 87.4%. [0:58:30] This also includes the additional $2,000 [0:58:33] that we paid for each employee. [0:58:36] On M&O, it is typical for water to spend [0:58:38] most of their M&O expenses during the summer months [0:58:41] using power to pump water. [0:58:43] Although we were only 56% of the budget last quarter [0:58:46] when I presented, we've jumped up to 94%. [0:58:49] you can see the biggest difference in this last quarter of a year. [0:58:53] In capital, the two largest expenditures budgeted were a hydro excavation truck for 445,000 and [0:58:59] a mainline replacement of 350,000. [0:59:02] The hydro truck was purchased, but the mainline replacement was not performed due to staffing [0:59:06] shortages. [0:59:07] In talking with raw bowling, we don't have the local contractors like we used to. [0:59:12] Everybody's busy and it's very difficult to find anybody to do the smaller jobs like [0:59:16] the mainline replacement budgeted. [0:59:18] He says they still haven't been able to get anyone to bid the airport test while yet and [0:59:22] are finally receiving endpoints for some of our mirrors that we've been waiting more than [0:59:26] a year on. [0:59:27] They have a $35,000 drive for one of our wells if they are staying is still probably a year [0:59:32] out. [0:59:33] For the most part we are fortunate though because we keep a good inventory that has helped us [0:59:37] to get by. [0:59:38] Part of the capital that was spent was $275,000 for the water facility plan update and $121,000 [0:59:48] for pond liners. [0:59:50] For debt, we paid off the $6.4 million bond last year and another $3 million bond in September. [0:59:57] This leaves only one left in the 2017 bond for $1.5 million. [1:00:02] This significantly reduces the percentage that we will spend on debt in the water fund. [1:00:09] For wastewater. [1:00:10] In the wastewater fund, we start with revenues and look at the total residential, industrial, [1:00:15] and municipal user fee budget along with the actual amount received. [1:00:19] In August of last year, we sold some more capacity to the city of Kimberly, which is [1:00:23] why we are seeing slightly higher revenue for this year. Industrial penalties are [1:00:28] five to six hundred thousand and industrial use has gone up one point five [1:00:32] million dollars. This year we had increased our revenue estimate to include [1:00:37] some of the penalties that we were forecasting which is why our budget is [1:00:40] higher. For the record we don't like penalties we would prefer to have [1:00:47] compliance so when we get excessive amounts and penalties that's not a [1:00:53] Plus, that's not something that we are excited about. We would much rather have industrial users [1:00:59] or do what they need to do. [1:01:01] I think part of this too in talking with some businesses is that they've had to use different byproducts and so having the different products come in [1:01:11] potentially creates different byproducts, which creates additional waste on the expenditure side in our waste [1:01:19] In our wastewater fund, we contract most of our services out, so personnel is not the largest [1:01:24] percent. [1:01:25] We have budgeted personnel to be about only 8% of the total expenditures. [1:01:30] When I asked Doug to see what his take was, he replied that since he was promoted to superintendent, [1:01:36] we have been operating without a supervisor. [1:01:38] They are understaffed as well. [1:01:42] The prices inside of our M&O are a constant battle. [1:01:45] Doug says the price of metal, pipe, and motor fuels have all gone up, hand tools were overspent [1:01:49] because they've replaced a power saw at the end of the year that they couldn't wait for [1:01:53] a new budget year on. [1:01:55] In capital, our four largest expenditures budgeted are a master plan update, mainline [1:02:00] upgrades, the digester boiler replacement, and a sludge truck, all of which are right [1:02:04] around $250,000. [1:02:07] The boiler replacement digester two lining have been paid for, but they fell short in [1:02:11] a few other items. [1:02:13] You remember, they came and presented on the CIPP, Cured in Place Pride, they showed pictures, [1:02:19] it was kind of a really neat process. [1:02:22] These improvements were anticipating were not funded because they were not able to secure [1:02:25] a contract before the end of September. [1:02:27] They are currently meeting with JUB to discuss moving forward with looking at contractors [1:02:32] to do that type of work. [1:02:34] Also a local business that they purchased equipment from went out of business and they [1:02:38] didn't find out about it until later. [1:02:40] think the price of metal may have contributed to them going out of business. [1:02:43] We paid off the 2012 bond for $4 million this year and there are $31 million left in bonds. [1:02:52] We have until 2033 before we pay off the wastewater bonds. [1:02:59] And last but not least on the enterprise funds is sanitation. [1:03:03] Sanitation is more steady than wastewater and does not experience significant fluctuations. [1:03:08] We have an additional 500 more accounts this year which directly relates to the increase [1:03:12] and sanitation revenue and on the expenditure side we have no capital or [1:03:20] debt just M&O transfers to account for that is the enterprise funds do you have [1:03:28] any questions on enterprise funds before I switched to the last section [1:03:32] looks good thank you okay so what I like to do is I like to stay on top of [1:03:40] what's happening what's happening how Idaho relates to the nation what's [1:03:43] happening the nation in a few different categories and what I do is I try to [1:03:47] to compile what I see and relate it. [1:03:50] So this last quarter, the stuff that I've been reading, [1:03:53] kind of falls into these few categories. [1:03:56] So inflation, cost of living, housing, and rents, [1:03:58] and student loans. [1:03:59] So it's probably not anything new. [1:04:01] You guys have probably already seen quite a bit of this [1:04:02] in your own research and your own reading. [1:04:04] But I thought I'd bring out some of the few things [1:04:06] that have stuck out to me. [1:04:08] First off, I want to talk about Idaho, though. [1:04:11] Idaho brings first of the nation, again. [1:04:15] So this is slide as a chart I pulled from a state [1:04:17] comparative report that investment bank Piper Sandler publishes quarterly, and I just received [1:04:22] the latest from the second quarter of 2022. [1:04:24] It's a little bit of a lag, but by the time they get the data to come in, but you can see [1:04:30] we are ranked first in the nation at 114.6. [1:04:34] Utah and California are following. [1:04:36] This financial strength index is a calculation that takes into account employment information, [1:04:43] housing price index, state revenue collections, and pension funding ratios. [1:04:48] This article stated Idaho leads the rankings for the 8th consecutive quarter and continues [1:04:52] to benefit from transit housing prices, personal income tax collections and pension funding. [1:04:57] However, the state's growth may slow as year over year comparison increases become more [1:05:03] difficult to retain. [1:05:07] This was a report from Moody, a record 43 states have the cash they need to weather an economic [1:05:13] slump. So when you talk, Alex, about this downturn that we're possibly going to see, [1:05:17] this is a graph that shows the states that can weather it without having to [1:05:21] resort to severe spending cuts or tax increases. The top five were North Dakota, [1:05:27] Wyoming, Idaho, was third, California, and Delaware. You can see some of the ones that [1:05:33] can't, the red. This was interesting. 21 states have cut personal or corporate income [1:05:41] tax rates in the past two years. I know, being one of them, I'm sure everybody saw a nice or small [1:05:47] ish check come from the state of Idaho. And inflation. Inflation. This is an article I had received from [1:05:58] Fortune, so 87% of fund managers believe it has peaked. 79% believe it will fall over the next 12 [1:06:06] months, and the US dollar index is up nearly 20%. So John Hopkins University Economics Professor [1:06:21] Jonathan Wright said the US Dollar Index is up nearly 20%. A rising dollar will probably [1:06:27] drive US inflation down somewhat because it makes imports into the US cheaper. The con [1:06:34] is that it's harder for US corporations to sell their goods overseas because they are [1:06:38] now more expensive. So the dollar index measures the US Dollar against six global currencies, [1:06:44] including the Euro and the Japanese yen. If that is raising short-term interest rates [1:06:48] quite steeply and is doing so more quickly than other central banks. This one's from [1:06:57] Bloomberg. Core CPI is the highest since 1982. I'm sure you guys are all aware of [1:07:03] that and I've seen that. Prices for gas and the alien and used cars have declined. [1:07:07] Like really gets me though since I drive a diesel as diesel is skyrocketed. [1:07:12] Gas is down to four something dollars and we've got diesel that's still closer [1:07:17] towards six. Unemployment rates are still at a five-decade low. [1:07:21] businesses continue to raise wages to attract and retain employees. Airfare is [1:07:26] climbing. We keep seeing significant increases. Bill has talked about some [1:07:31] of the negotiations that they're trying to work with with our partners. It's it's [1:07:35] high. They don't anticipate it going down anytime soon. OPEC announced oil [1:07:41] production cuts which I totally don't understand. Biden talked about a gas [1:07:45] export ban. Inside the city lawn mowers for a golf fund or 17,000 overbid. Our [1:07:52] parks department has a three-quarter ton truck, eighteen thousand dollar over [1:07:56] budgeted. Instead of two trucks we're only able to afford one. Inflation will [1:08:00] affect the equipment that we have budgeted for the next year. This is [1:08:06] interesting. This is a graph that shows how many are feeling the inflationary [1:08:12] crunch. You can see 74% of low-income households are feeling the hardships [1:08:19] created by by inflation. This is compiled by statistics on inflation's [1:08:25] causing hardships. Note the discrepancy in low and moderate income households but [1:08:29] also the change in moderate income households. So from $40,000 to $90,000, [1:08:34] 46% were worried in November of 2021 and now 63% this is our neighbors, this is [1:08:41] us, this is our employees, these are most of us that fit into this category and are concerned [1:08:47] heavily by inflation. Majority of Americans are very concerned by prices for food, so [1:08:54] this graph shows the top ones that are people are concerned with. Food and consumer goods, [1:08:59] gasoline and energy, and the cost of housing being the top three. Cost of living. Social [1:09:07] security gave a COLA a cost of living increase of 8.7% that's the highest [1:09:14] increase in 40 years. There was an article by the American City and Council [1:09:20] said 84% of public sector employees have anxiety about the impact of economic [1:09:24] conditions and market volatility on their personal financial security. Those who [1:09:29] expressed anxiety around financial security were much more likely to be [1:09:33] female and come from a household with an annual income of less than $100,000. [1:09:38] Amid these financial difficulties, 50% said retirement benefits and 62% said other benefits [1:09:45] like health care, insurance and time off for keeping them in their job. [1:09:48] So what are we doing? [1:09:50] What are we doing to give people security? [1:09:52] We're hugely motivated to figure out what we can do to help ease the anxiety to our employees. [1:09:57] We don't know what the answer is, so we're trying many different things. [1:10:00] We're looking at budgeting classes, emergency funds, jobs, stability, meal prep class. [1:10:10] This was an interesting chart I thought was just food for thought, kind of a data junkie [1:10:14] I like stats because it's interesting. [1:10:17] Younger Americans capitalize on freedoms associated with being child-free. [1:10:21] 61% of millennials, 61% of millennials cite the reason for not having kids is they simply [1:10:27] can't afford it. [1:10:28] And Americans are having fewer kids, a trend, for over a decade now. [1:10:32] This chart shows a pool of people without children. [1:10:35] The cost of raising a child through high school is calculated at $310,000. [1:10:40] The annual price of child care, sorry HR department, got me some stats together, is [1:10:45] about $7,000 to $8,000 depending on age, ranging from $5,700 to $8,800, which translates to [1:10:53] around $500 to $665 per child per month. [1:11:00] crazy to see how people can afford that and what they do and how they work. We were talking earlier [1:11:10] today that you can have a kid or buy a car. So apparently millennials are and younger are not [1:11:17] having children. On the flip side, since November 2021, there have been 16 employees that have utilized [1:11:24] our newly offered family bonding leave, which is six weeks of paid time off at the City of Twin Falls. [1:11:31] So for housing, so we're starting to decline since the inception of their data, um, his [1:11:39] Piper Sandler series in 1985. [1:11:42] You can see home, sorry, cost of living. [1:11:49] This one's interesting too. [1:11:50] Food were thought. [1:11:51] Pison Food's Inc. [1:11:52] Apologize. [1:11:53] Let's back up. [1:11:55] So Tyson Chicken produces roughly a fifth in the United States supply of chicken. [1:12:03] They said average sales price for beef was 1.2% lower. [1:12:07] These are people, all of us, making individual changes when we go to the grocery store. [1:12:12] When you can tell when inflation hits when we're making decisions like this, I don't [1:12:16] know why you guys, but I'm making decisions like this. [1:12:19] Do I buy meat? [1:12:20] Do I buy chicken or do I go vegan? [1:12:21] I've actually done a little bit of both. [1:12:23] Pork was 3.9% lower. [1:12:25] Chicken serves 20%. [1:12:29] Consumers are choosing to buy chicken and cheaper cuts of beef. [1:12:38] Okay, now this is where I was at housing. [1:12:41] So we're starts of decline since 1985. [1:12:43] You can see home builder confidence is it just inked. [1:12:46] This goes from 94 to 18. [1:12:48] It's a pretty big chart. [1:12:49] Building permits have shown modest improvement [1:12:51] driven by multi-family certs [1:12:53] as rising home ownership costs continue to support [1:12:57] rental demand. [1:12:59] The worst stretch of decline since 1985 [1:13:02] and the first year since 2011 [1:13:04] to see a decline for single family units nationally. [1:13:08] 2023 is forecasted to see additional declines so interesting. I don't know if you guys follow Zillow [1:13:17] If you ask any real estate person, they will tell you I'm looking at Nikki [1:13:21] They'll tell you don't look at Zillow, but you know what you guys don't produce any research for us to actually clean their look at so if you have some insights let me know [1:13:34] So Zillow [1:13:36] Their nose down at you are like well you Zillow [1:13:38] What else are we gonna use because they keep that pretty close to their chest? [1:13:41] So Zillow was funny. Remember last year when Travis was getting the budget presentation like, oh, it's gonna skyrocket [1:13:48] 17.8% between February of 22 and 23. In April, they adjusted to 14.9%. And May, they adjusted to July, they adjusted. [1:13:56] They finally ended off. The last I read September is like, okay, it's gonna increase 1.2%. [1:14:00] I would say that's a stretch. If you watch Zillow right now, things are static. [1:14:05] They are staying on the market. The homes are not selling. [1:14:08] And I've actually seen a 10 to 12% decrease even in Twin Falls from the stuff that I am watching pretty closely [1:14:15] Boise has already seen about a 15 to 20% drop [1:14:19] And you remember many of the reports that well someone that presented on some of the ones you've read said that Boise was 80% [1:14:26] Overvalued, so we are going down [1:14:29] It's gonna be interesting to see where we head to and how far especially as the feds keep increasing rates [1:14:35] The consensus is that it will be the second sharpest home price decline since the Great [1:14:43] Depression. [1:14:44] A fortune article said, sharp home price declines are incredibly rare. [1:14:49] Only the Great Depression and the Great Recession saw nationwide home prices fall in the double [1:14:53] did it range. [1:14:54] Twin Falls, I've highlighted here, is shown as overpriced by about 52% overpriced means [1:15:01] the cost of living or the amount of income that you have versus what's affordable. [1:15:06] So that's how they get they back into that Goldman Sachs showed a home price reduction [1:15:11] forecasted at 5 to 10% and Moody's analytics of another 5 to 10% as well. [1:15:20] Mortgage applications are near their lowest levels since 1997. [1:15:26] Mortgage rates have doubled since last year. [1:15:28] They're their highest levels in 16 years. [1:15:30] Freddie Mac, 30 year fixed rate was 6.61%. [1:15:34] If you've been watching, there was a little tiny bit of a dip. [1:15:36] November 17th, previous week was 7.08% and previous year was 3% and it's [1:15:44] anticipated to keep going as the feds meet again. Housing affordability is near its [1:15:49] lowest level since 1989. This was this is good food for thought. Homebuyers [1:15:56] remorse. Hopefully nobody bought a house this last year because this article from [1:16:00] Fortune interviewed people that bought houses. 30% of America this last year [1:16:06] during this crazy increase. 30% of American home buyers say they overpaid for a property. [1:16:12] 35% of Americans say they compromised their priorities to find a home and 33% maxed out their budget. [1:16:18] Over 50% say they spent less than two months searching for their new home with 40% spending less [1:16:25] than four weeks and 36% of home buyers making an offer without ever seeing the property in person. [1:16:32] I don't know if this is all right, we've watched this coming now, we've watched it, this was never sustainable, we've just watched this coming. It's here like it was gonna be. [1:17:04] The good news is that is conservative as we are and we're kind of behind the real world [1:17:09] It doesn't hit us as bad. I we saw that in [1:17:14] Last time the last couple times. I've seen it just doesn't it is like it's [1:17:20] Yeah, and on the conservative side we're budgeting flat so we're not the next time I'll put a comic in there [1:17:27] Stick it a little bit of a laugh right in the middle [1:17:29] Apartment rents nationally fell 0.1%, this doesn't seem substantial, but it's the first time it's dropped in nearly two years, there's positive. [1:17:38] It's dropped, that might be, we might be headed down. [1:17:41] Apartment listing website rent.com showed 2.8% decrease for one bedroom apartments, 23% overall increase in rents in August of 2020, so we have a little bit of a waste. [1:17:52] Any substantial relief for cost burden renters is still a way off. [1:17:56] Not only do we lag, you've got to remember that most tenants have a one to two year contract that they sign. [1:18:01] So they will see it afterwards. [1:18:03] Okay, so next slide is for fun. [1:18:06] It's nothing to do with the city of Twin Falls. [1:18:08] Student loans? [1:18:12] Debt relief? [1:18:13] Just because it's intriguing and I kind of think [1:18:16] inflation and we're really forgiving student loans. [1:18:19] The White House estimated to reduce revenue at $240 billion over a decade [1:18:23] and 75% of eligible buyers would apply non-partisan congressional budget office estimated $400 billion. [1:18:31] This is what it's going to cost. The Penn Wharton budget model is up to $519 billion, [1:18:36] with the total cost of $1 trillion. And we wonder why we have inflation. [1:18:42] Obama administration economist Jason Furman says the debt relief risks pouring roughly half [1:18:47] trillion of gasoline on the inflationary fire. Wall Street analysts say the near-term impact [1:18:53] is likely to be limited because debt relief isn't like other forms of stimulus. Individuals won't [1:18:58] immediately have more money to spend because almost all borrowers haven't been paying during [1:19:02] a government repayment moratorium during the COVID-19 pandemic. Now why aren't it gave you guys the [1:19:09] answers? But if you can do it without looking, anybody have any idea of how many signed up as of [1:19:13] November 3rd that didn't look? Her student loan really debt relief, forgiveness. So within a month, [1:19:24] 26 million people. It's already at a [1:19:31] dentist day actually right now. There's [1:19:33] been a few states that have sued the [1:19:35] federal government but what they have [1:19:36] to prove is that it impacts them [1:19:39] individually and so they're waiting for [1:19:41] that one suit to come through that says [1:19:43] okay this is negatively impacting an [1:19:45] individual and then it won't happen but [1:19:47] as for right now they're saying with [1:19:50] all intents and purposes that that many [1:19:52] people will get their their loans [1:19:54] forgiven. If you remember that's 10 and [1:19:56] $120,000 with her incomes under $125,000. [1:20:06] Questions? [1:20:07] That's it. [1:20:08] No, I should have just left. [1:20:14] Any questions for Brianna? [1:20:17] Okay. [1:20:18] Thank you very much. [1:20:19] Yes. [1:20:20] Okay. [1:20:22] So next item on the agenda is the time for public input. [1:20:26] If there's anybody in the public that wishes to address city council, [1:20:30] you can come down and say their piece. [1:20:33] That's what it looks like. [1:20:34] It doesn't look like there's anybody advisory board reports anything from [1:20:38] council and advisory boards anything from the city manager's office I will [1:20:48] note next Monday we'll be starting council at 4 30 or a 30 minute executive [1:20:54] session before and then we'll do our regular meeting at five and then we [1:20:58] have an executive session at the end as well no public hearings so the next item [1:21:05] is adjourned to executive session. We do not need executive session number A. So, will adjourn [1:21:16] in under section 74-206-1E to consider preliminary negotiations involving matters of trader commerce, [1:21:24] which the government body is in competition with governing bodies in other states or nations. [1:21:30] No move. [1:21:31] Thank you Nikki. [1:21:32] Second. [1:21:33] Thank you. [1:21:34] Motion by Nikki Boyes. [1:21:35] Seconded by Jason Brown. [1:21:38] To move into executive session under 74-2061. [1:21:44] Any more car vote please? [1:21:46] Spence for Cutler. [1:21:48] Yes. [1:21:49] Alex Cabal. [1:21:50] Yes. [1:21:51] Ruth Pierce. [1:21:52] Yes. [1:21:53] Chris Reed. [1:21:54] Yes. [1:21:55] Nikki Boyes. [1:21:56] Yes. [1:21:57] And Jason Brown. [1:21:58] Yes. [1:21:59] I said we're not going under 8. [1:22:05] So we're just going under B. We'll not be making any decisions in executive session and we will [1:22:11] not be returning. [1:22:12] Thank you all. [1:22:13] Well.