Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2022-06-21, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2022-06-21/ [0:02:00] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the Tuesday June 21st 2022 City Council meeting [0:02:07] I'd like to confirm we have a quorum we have six of our seven council members present and [0:02:14] Councilman Hawkins is six keys today [0:02:17] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Anybody wishing to join me please rise [0:02:23] Thank you. Um, we have no proclamations tonight [0:02:44] So next is the consent calendar, Council wishes. [0:02:49] Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Jason Brown. [0:02:59] To approve the consent calendar, Aaron Rolkalvo please. [0:03:02] Mayor Pierce? [0:03:04] Yes. [0:03:05] Vice Mayor Reed? [0:03:06] Yes. [0:03:07] John Baraker? [0:03:08] Yes. [0:03:09] Nicki Boyd? [0:03:10] Yes. [0:03:11] Jason Brown? [0:03:12] Yes. [0:03:13] Spencer Keller? [0:03:14] Yes. [0:03:15] Thank you. [0:03:16] Motion passes six to zero. [0:03:18] We're here for any liquor license renewals, a license for Christian Inc, and airport hanger. [0:03:28] Lease agreements, we've all approved those, so you're welcome to stay here, welcome to [0:03:34] go. [0:03:35] So our first item of consideration is a request to confirm the reappointment of Redeash and [0:03:41] to the Urban Renewal Agency Board and we have our City Manager and Interim Economic Development Director Travis Rothweide. [0:03:49] Madam Mayor, Representative, City Council, good evening and thanks for the opportunity to make a request to a reappoint pretty eyeshive [0:03:57] to a digital three-year term on the Urban Renewal Agency Board. [0:04:04] Mr. Asha Brenner has been a member of the Urban Renewal Agency [0:04:08] and he's been active, he's been a significant contributor [0:04:12] and he's also been serving as its chairperson. [0:04:15] Over the course of that period of time, he has been able to assist [0:04:19] in some of the most significant projects that the agency has undertaken [0:04:24] As well as even one that you're going to hear later this evening in relationship to the marketing structure [0:04:29] in a public hearing that's been part of that labor of work. [0:04:34] Mr. Ashenbrenner had the opportunity to have a conversation with Mayor Pierce. [0:04:41] It was after that conversation that we have put his name before you for consideration. [0:04:48] I'm happy to stand for the questions. Should you move Mr. Ashenbrenner to the position? [0:04:57] We have the insight of the motion for you to waive the residency requirement and I have to stand for any questions. [0:05:07] Any questions for Travis? [0:05:09] I am the URA liaison and Rudy is a very active member of the URA board and really has added to that organization, so I highly recommend Sean Berger. [0:05:21] Are you ready for a moment? [0:05:23] I am. [0:05:24] would move to confirm the reappointment of Rudy Ashenbrenner [0:05:28] to the Urban Renewal Agency Board [0:05:30] and to waive the residency requirement for that position. [0:05:33] Thank you to have a second. [0:05:35] Motion by Sean Barricar, seconded by Nikki Boyd [0:05:38] to confirm the reappointment of Rudy Ashenbrenner [0:05:41] to the URA Board and waive the residency requirements. [0:05:45] Any discussion? [0:05:47] Aaron Rolkoffo, please. [0:05:51] Vice-Mayor Reed. [0:05:52] Yes. [0:05:53] Sean Barricar. [0:05:54] Yes. [0:05:55] Nikki Boyd. [0:05:55] Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6 to 0. Rudy's not here today. Okay. He was not able to join us. Okay. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is a request to confirm the city manager's appointment of Ida Clark to the position of human resource director. And again, we have traps for city manager. [0:06:23] So, as you will see, I think I have all the agenda items on the main body, I guess that's [0:06:30] the penalty that you pay for going on vacation is that it all stacks up and it becomes you. [0:06:37] But tonight I'm excited to ask for your consideration for the confirmation of the appointment of [0:06:44] Ida Clark. [0:06:45] I did this with us this evening and as I'm making this presentation I'll ask her to kind of make her way down here [0:06:51] so that we can have her be available. [0:06:55] So as a part of this process, this process began I guess some several months ago as we went forward [0:07:03] to Gretchen Scott to serve as the city's deputy city manager over the internal functions [0:07:13] of our organization. [0:07:14] We made that a point of vacancy inside of our organization. [0:07:23] The Human Resource Director for the City of Twin Falls serves as a department leader and as a member of the city's executive leadership team. [0:07:32] As a result of that standing in our organization, it requires your confirmation per our city code of the appointment for a position on the LT to serve in those roles. [0:07:46] After going through a national search, we were able to hide a clerk as the candidate to [0:07:56] move forward. [0:07:57] Iida has extensive experience inside of the human resource world. [0:08:05] She has a business administration degree with an HR emphasis from the University of Nevada, [0:08:14] Las Vegas. [0:08:15] She is a Sherm certified professional, and she has her Idaho Risk Management certificate. [0:08:22] She is also a representative of several boards that represent Ida, and spent her time over [0:08:36] the site of the city of G. Serve as their Human Resource Director. [0:08:42] And then she met Dennis, Dennis Clarkers with us. Dennis is a member of the Drow Leadership [0:08:56] Police Team. And as a result of that, there was a bit of a conflict so high that, uh, wanting [0:09:01] to stay with the city of Drow decided to branch out and she tried planning and zoning. Recognized [0:09:10] she didn't like it. She went then to work for the state, recognized that she really wanted [0:09:15] to return back to local government, we were lucky to be looking for an HR director to be [0:09:19] serving at that time. So that's a bit of Ida's background. We're really excited to have her as a member of the team and with that, I know that she'll stand for any questions that you might have and then if she is confirmed, [0:09:33] part of the process will be to administer the oath. [0:09:36] Travis, any questions for Travis or Ida? [0:09:40] I stand for Emotion. Jason? [0:09:49] Affirm the City Manager's Appointment of Ida Clark to the Position of Human Resource Director. [0:09:56] Thank you. I have a motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Sean Barrieger, [0:10:02] to confirm the City Manager's Appointment of Ida Clark to the Position of Human Resource Director. [0:10:08] Any discussion? [0:10:10] Aaron Rokalvo, please. [0:10:13] Sean Barrieger? [0:10:14] Yes. [0:10:15] Nicky Boyd? Yes. [0:10:16] Jason Brown? [0:10:17] Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Vice-Mary. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. [0:10:28] I will say if I would known that you were University of Las Vegas, I would have [0:10:32] may be reconsidered, right? You and I are. [0:10:39] Well, thank you very much. I'm excited to be here. I do have my family, my husband Dennis and my [0:11:42] he took his hat off, but he's not coming down here. Thank you very much. [0:11:53] Okay, thank you. Welcome, Ida. [0:11:55] So, Madam Mayor, members of the council, you might have seen that Mr. Asher Brenner snuck in a little bit, Tardy. [0:12:04] Yes. [0:12:05] But that's okay. He was confirmed. [0:12:07] Um, and I don't know if this is also maybe an opportunity if you have any questions for Mr. Asher Brenner at all. [0:12:13] I think his penalty for being Tardy is to come down and say a few words. [0:12:17] Yeah, how do you feel about luck banning library books? [0:12:26] I'm sorry, you don't have to answer that. [0:12:31] Mayor Pierce, Councilman, thanks for the appointment. [0:12:36] I was not tired. [0:12:37] I was outside in case you didn't pass it. [0:12:39] I wouldn't come in and face my embarrassment. [0:12:42] So it's all a little bit planned, but I do appreciate it. [0:12:45] And you guys say five o'clock in it. [0:12:47] So also, thanks for putting me at the front of the agenda. [0:12:50] So I have to go enjoy the splash pad, which I now see as long. [0:12:54] It is out there. It's hot outside. So I'm going to go do that. But thanks again. I appreciate it. If you have any questions [0:12:58] I'm here. Thank you, Rudy. Thanks. Okay. So next time on the agenda is Travis again seeking City Council parties for the development of the 2022, 2023 budget. [0:13:15] We're leaving in mass. [0:13:22] It's the same show they'll be able to see ten more times. [0:13:30] Yeah, we know that. [0:13:42] Alright, so members of the city council, this is the last conversation of pre-season budgeting. [0:13:54] It's the best way to look at it, right? [0:13:57] So after tonight, we will begin about that schedule, but tonight is to just do a simple check-in [0:14:15] prior to publishing the budget, making sure that everything's ready, making sure that from a high level perspective, [0:14:22] the council is supportive of the direction that the team is taking the budget for this fiscal year. [0:14:27] So again, everything is connected directly to our city's strategic plan. [0:14:33] As we shared with you last time, the city's strategic plan will go through a rewrite, [0:14:40] and that we will be acting the city's strategic plan to our priority-based budgeting initiative. [0:14:46] Here is some quick information about the City of Twin Falls. [0:14:52] It is continuing to the rate of growth that we have continued astounding. [0:15:02] Every month I go through and I update increasing the household in Twin Falls. [0:15:22] City of Twin Falls, but also for the state of Idaho. [0:15:25] Then also for unemployment. [0:15:28] Those are important matrices that we consider inside of our budget as we move forward. [0:15:34] And we know that things are growing and we know that things are becoming more and more [0:15:42] expensive. [0:15:47] We learned the city's total taxable value since the last time that we met and the city's total [0:15:58] taxable value grew by nearly $1.6 billion. [0:16:03] I just want you to consider that growth at $1.6 billion just inside of the city of Twin [0:16:13] in a year and then to recognize there are complete cities in Idaho that don't have a total taxable value [0:16:24] to the amount that we in a single year. We'll talk about the growth. You'll notice that the total budget that we've put together is about [0:16:38] about $9 million larger than the budget that we put together last year, and you can see [0:16:44] that about $6 million of it is in the non-tax supported or in the enterprise funds, where [0:16:53] we've intentionally made significant investments and improvements. [0:16:58] We'll talk about as we go through the budgeting process, why those amounts are going up. [0:17:04] But one of the things that I think is important to share is that we are projecting a 30% decrease in our tax rate. [0:17:13] So I want that to resonate also quickly, a 30% decrease in the city's total tax rate. [0:17:20] And we believe based upon how the Idaho Code is, [0:17:25] regulates local government property taxation that you will see other taxing entities inside of the [0:17:33] Twin Falls County and Twin Falls City see a similar decrease in their total tax or their total tax [0:17:43] rates as well as a result of a sizable increase in taxable value. So let's kind of dive into the [0:17:53] numbers. How big is $165 million, 27.9% increase? It is the equivalents. The combined growth [0:18:07] that we experienced from 2018 through 2021. And if you include fiscal year 2017, it's only [0:18:17] $100 million smaller. So six years, $100 million smaller in total growth. That is pretty significant [0:18:27] in terms of total value, and I'm sure many of us. [0:18:32] We recently opened up our newest property tax assessment. [0:18:37] There was a gasp. [0:18:39] I know I did. [0:18:43] And then I quickly did my calculation, [0:18:47] and I breathed a sigh of relief, because I know [0:18:51] that local governments can only collect three more, [0:18:55] 3% more property tax revenue than they did the prior year, [0:18:59] and that the total value of a structure or real property or personal property is only [0:19:08] one part of the equation. [0:19:11] So the good news is that while many of us opened it up with complete shock, I don't [0:19:23] want to say none because there will probably be one. [0:19:26] So I'll say not many of us will see that size of an increase in our property taxes this [0:19:32] year. [0:19:36] New construction, the value of the new construction role, has also [0:19:40] sizeably increased. [0:19:42] So as a result of House Bill 389 that was passed, our legislative session, cities and counties [0:19:53] are able to collect 90% of the new construction growth. [0:19:59] Now for the City of Twin Falls, our total growth was $127.5 million. [0:20:08] 90% of that means that we can claim just shy of $116 million. [0:20:13] The total property tax revenue will result in $554,000 of new revenue. [0:20:22] This is how interesting the system is last year. [0:20:26] year. The city of Twin Falls had a total property tax [0:20:32] and a new construction value of 100. That was the net actually collected product of [0:20:44] the math formula that we have to use, that tax rate significantly deep that you [0:20:55] receive changes as well. So that is the the initial numbers that we use to build [0:21:07] the budget. We want to have a good understanding of where we stand from [0:21:14] and on employment standpoint. The labor shortage falls in the state of Idaho as [0:21:22] well as the country is not projected to correct itself anytime soon and while [0:21:28] this is kind of hovered between that 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, it is still significantly [0:21:36] below what most economists would consider full employment. [0:21:40] And inside of the city of Twin Falls, [0:21:42] we've hovered between 22 and 30 vacancies [0:21:46] inside of our own organization [0:21:48] for the entirety of the fiscal year. [0:21:54] It's organizations taking the highest level of services, [0:21:58] recognizing that nearly 10% of our organization, [0:22:02] those seats on our buses are not. [0:22:06] Recognizing this is why we have chosen to focus [0:22:13] There is a pretend areas of the group as you can recall from that very front slide of the [0:22:23] city's strategic plan inside of that middle, right? The side that we've seen is [0:22:32] Public services it is the most important part that we need to do everything that we can folks and this budget [0:22:47] Reflect that because it's this statement still remains true that if the [0:22:52] 26,000 people in Idaho were all of a sudden gainfully employed, we'd still have 27,000 [0:23:00] vacancies. [0:23:05] It is a very tight labor market and it is one that we need to aggressively compete because [0:23:11] this is an illustration like we shared last time when people say, but there are so many [0:23:16] people moving to Idaho and yes they are, they're not adding to our labor pools. [0:23:22] In fact, Idaho is one of the fastest growing states of individual 65 years and older that [0:23:29] are choosing to come to our country, and we shared this. [0:23:35] Population percent change. [0:23:38] Idaho is one of the few states. [0:23:40] I think it's the only state in the country that is the percent of every single county [0:23:50] was greater than half a percent. [0:23:55] And that growth is not occurring just inside of the city of Twin Falls, but it is occurring [0:24:00] in every surrounding community and that urban center for a geographic area of eight counties [0:24:08] and 300,000 people causes our daily census to significantly increase. [0:24:14] We provide services to all, but we keep flashing this because Twin Falls is bigger than 50,000 [0:24:23] people and we have to service that day in and day out. [0:24:27] We need to make sure that we have the highest talent, but we also need to spend time really [0:24:34] structuring and building the size of our own team. [0:24:38] So not only filling the 30 vacancies that we have, [0:24:42] but we also need to move forward and add to those positions [0:24:46] as we continue to grow about the positions [0:24:50] that we're adding this year. [0:24:52] This is what it looks like. [0:24:54] I mean, this is the number in January per state code [0:24:59] that the county assessor uses to determine [0:25:03] what the total with the assessed [0:25:07] taxable value of your communities. [0:25:10] The City of Twin Falls has grown by more than 34.5%. [0:25:17] Well, how does that compare? [0:25:22] So last year at this point in time, [0:25:26] the median home value inside of the City of Twin Falls [0:25:29] was 285,000. [0:25:31] The national was 200. [0:25:40] So inside of the City of Twin Falls in May of last year, [0:25:44] The median home was $4,000 less than Twin Falls than the national average. [0:25:48] In fact, what happened was we had completely accelerated very, very quickly, as you can [0:25:53] see by this graph, reaching the national level. [0:25:57] We weren't above the price of the median value of a home. [0:26:02] And inside the state of Idaho, it was 400,000 compared to our 285. [0:26:10] In the period of a year, that same home in Twin Falls has $89,309 in the game to $60,000. [0:26:29] So today, Twin Falls is $34,000 more than the meat price for the country. [0:26:42] There is no other point in our history we could say that Twin Falls home prices were [0:26:50] It used to be one of the greatest selling points that we had, that housing is cheap, high quality of life, abundant opportunities. [0:27:03] And now the price of our housing stock is more than 10% greater than the national average. [0:27:13] National, and the state of Idaho in the same period of time is now 472. [0:27:21] It is something that we need to be aware of because as we're continuing to try to track individuals into our community, [0:27:40] We now have to be on a national scene, because it isn't the most cost-effective place to [0:27:51] live. [0:27:54] And if you take a look, so it's really exciting because I shared with you last month that [0:28:03] the April Consumer Price Index went from 8.6 to 8.1, it looked like we're heading in [0:28:09] the right direction. [0:28:10] And now you'll see it's at 8.5, and economists that have been following have been saying [0:28:17] that it is going to hover high probably through the second quarter of 24. [0:28:22] That means that the price of goods and services in our community are significantly increasing. [0:28:33] And then when you take a look at the cost of doing business inside of the city of Twin Falls, [0:28:38] as you know we use the municipal cost index is up 12.45%. [0:28:45] 38% increase since 2012. And as you look at our budgets, we can [0:28:52] to reflect that our maintenance and operation costs haven't increased by 38%. [0:28:56] And really that is to the credit of the tools leading the department in our organization [0:29:04] who are always trying to find a more cost effective approach, the highest level of services. [0:29:10] So what are we doing? It is probably as important to be nimble today as it was two years ago [0:29:20] when we created it. If you were to design a roller coaster off of the ebbs and flows of [0:29:29] the stock market, it would probably not be a ride that anybody would want to go on. So [0:29:37] at three o'clock today it was up. That was a good thing. After over the course of the [0:29:43] last two weeks it had come crashing down below 30,000. It is important for us to remain nimble. [0:29:54] economists are talking about recession, we need to make sure that we are constantly [0:30:00] staying in tune, which is why we want to be sensitive to our operating environment. [0:30:10] We also have a strategic plan, not because it's a best practice, but it helps us remain [0:30:17] disciplined. [0:30:19] If we truly are committed to exercising our strategic plan goals and objectives, we won't [0:30:24] chase the bright shiny things that often get us in trouble. [0:30:29] And when we were building the budget, the thing that I shared with our team was this whole [0:30:36] Montana saying is that most farmers and ranchers will share. [0:30:44] It's the good years that understand that when you recognize that you spend above your [0:30:53] means in the good years and you create systems that you cannot sustain. [0:30:59] We believe this budget is sustainable that we have been building and we believe as a [0:31:07] service organization we need to be the employer of choice and I unapologetically [0:31:12] share that we are going to do everything that we can to treat our employees. The [0:31:19] levels of increases and benefits that are reflective of a very tight labor [0:31:25] market we're asking you to take a 3% statutory allowance that is the most that [0:31:33] you can take we're asking that you take that as well as the values of the new [0:31:38] construction and the 1% fork on balance, all of which are allowed by Idaho Code. We started [0:31:45] out this process of minimizing any rate increases moving forward. What is the tax rate? We believe [0:31:54] it's going to be under $5 per thousand of taxable value, $25, and at no point in our time if we [0:32:05] ever issued a tax rate this month. And the current rates of growth we believe that that [0:32:11] could in subsequent years continue to fall. It could drop below four. And in Idaho, there [0:32:20] are special provisions that we never believe that we would ever get to, to keep an effluent. [0:32:27] So we believe that we've created a conservative budget because it is by far the most conservative [0:32:33] tax rate that we've ever issued. And it's because of this, when you reflect back on [0:32:41] the home of the city of Twin Falls, which is in the gold line, reflect on the maximum [0:32:48] home owners exemption, 50% or less. [0:32:52] 2019 is when those in the legislature increased it to $125,000. [0:33:03] So once again, the gold line in home value [0:33:06] inside of the city of Twin Falls was lower [0:33:10] than the maximum home owners exemption allowed. [0:33:14] The legislature has elected the flat line [0:33:17] owners exemption at 5,000, [0:33:19] homes inside of the city of Twin Falls [0:33:24] have now far surpassed that. [0:33:32] That is one of the primary driving factors [0:33:34] and having that knowledge is why we want to keep the time. [0:33:41] We also are aware increase in values [0:33:47] wasn't just to the homeowners, [0:33:48] it was to industries and commercial businesses [0:33:52] throughout the entire community. [0:33:53] There was not one type of property, [0:33:56] was we are recommending no increases. [0:34:19] That is not increasing their rates. [0:34:23] And again, just a few slides ago, [0:34:25] shared with you that the cost of doing business for us is going up by 12%. I believe it's because [0:34:32] of the strategies that we put in place last year. The Council allowed us to create that capital fund. [0:34:39] Is the reason we're able to help balance in moving forward and that's that forward thinking [0:34:44] approach that this Council has had in making sure that what we do is sustainable. The sanitation [0:34:52] Recycling rate is still generally uncertain. There are three components to [0:34:59] our recycling rate. We know that the tipping fee they're going to be asking at [0:35:03] the county level a slight increase. We know that we're under negotiations with [0:35:07] PSI. They're asking for about a 7% increase. We also do have a size of cash [0:35:14] reserves in this fund that is probably larger than what we need. And so we may [0:35:20] be buying down a portion of that rate this year by no means will it be 7% or [0:35:31] then paying for positions to this budget. We're asking for your consideration for a [0:35:48] deputy fire chief, deputy prosecuting attorney, a water operator, and an engineering traffic [0:35:54] technician. We're asking for at least a 3 and a half percent increase in [0:35:59] compensation. They want time payment that buy down the cost of inflation, not add [0:36:11] compensation into the base. So we're going to cover the increase in health [0:36:22] insurance. We're going to continue to do these to build skills for employees and [0:36:30] we're going to seek out our ships. I mean it's an operation strategies are going to [0:36:40] remain the same. Capital improvement strategies are really linking the [0:36:45] comprehensive plan and all of our facility plans. I want to make sure that [0:36:49] we're increasing technology, the traction workforce attraction business [0:36:55] retention into our marketing efforts and these are some of the larger projects [0:37:03] that are included in the fund and obviously as we go through those individual focus [0:37:07] areas we will be able to hit each one of those but these these projects are [0:37:14] incredibly important in a new deep perspective but also from place-making [0:37:23] perspective. The council will have to go forward with the process to determine how [0:37:29] it's going to spend the $770,000 of council allocated capital. Last year you spent the [0:37:38] entirety of that fund and slightly more sidewalk projects. So additional projects [0:37:48] will be presenting for your consideration and as you want more information about [0:37:52] them, please let them know. Let us know. But as you recall, steal our Assistant Public Works [0:38:00] Director, a significant sidewalk capital project list that has been expanded. There [0:38:08] several projects that could be considered there. We got some different sidewalks [0:38:12] within parks. We got the improvements of parks and park areas. We got the [0:38:17] expansions of trails and some of those private partnerships. There's been a [0:38:21] request for the communities those have. And then this year outside of the budget [0:38:34] process, but running tandem, you will be allocating $8.5 million of [0:38:39] of ARP funding, I have those funds committed by December 31st of 2426, and about six months [0:38:55] ago I believe that was entirely achievable. And now when I think about supply chain issues, [0:39:02] I think about material shortages, I think about labor shortages, and I think about, [0:39:06] as we'll share with you, the types of bids that we're getting on fire stations. [0:39:09] It is going to be important that we identify those projects through that community process [0:39:16] that I talked about so that they can be advanced quickly so that we can [0:39:22] reliance with the requirements of the funding. Yeah, those are the two pots of [0:39:33] money that the council will work through allocation. This is what looks [0:39:44] like. The dates in gold will present with the budget available to the community [0:40:02] focus areas as process. This will complete a large part of the budget process and then [0:40:11] I know we used the final piece of that budgeting process of any fiscal years going through the audit. [0:40:21] And with that, I'm happy to stand for any questions, receive any comments that you have on the overall budget. [0:40:28] Any questions for Travis? [0:40:30] Yes sir. [0:40:32] Yeah, question on the assessment property values. [0:40:35] We're based on a budget or a tax rate based on that estimate at this point. [0:40:40] I understand some things will change. [0:40:43] You expect that number to be significant, like, you know, that doesn't make sense. [0:40:48] If citizens are questioning the assessed value, the assessor has to make changes, is that going to tick dark? [0:40:54] So, more than likely not, and that is because of the pre-work that is done by the county assessor moving forward. [0:41:05] And how code requires that all properties are within 95 and 105 percent of market value. [0:41:13] the source of the largest increases is, as pointed out, by Mr. Will's, is the approach [0:41:21] that they had to take on evaluating commercial and industrial property. I'm so part of that [0:41:27] approach, and he isn't by far the expert to talk about that, but because there are [0:41:33] parameters set by Idaho Code and because those parameters are modified or model text commission, [0:41:43] always is a slight change. It always is a slight change downward. Historically, it has been less than 1%. [0:41:51] 10% is a surprise. It's not something to worry about. [0:41:56] Stop here. Thank you Mayor. Thanks Travis for the presentation. [0:42:03] So as we look at potential council capital projects versus ARPA funded projects, [0:42:11] What are the kinds of things that ARPA funds may be used for her? [0:42:31] This is where the city manager is going to say, I don't have that answer. [0:42:35] But what's really cool is that there's someone in the room that does. [0:42:38] I believe Brianna is just sitting right behind me and she can come down. [0:42:43] We'll put on the spot, right? [0:42:45] And she can kind of share the sources of funds, the use of ARPA funds [0:42:51] for the council as she has spent considerable time. [0:42:54] She actually read the entire federal rules and regulations, and she said she liked it. [0:43:00] This actually does not surprise me, so we'll do it, which is why you're amazing. [0:43:06] I actually don't have a very complicated answer for you. [0:43:09] Fortunately, we have $10 million of a revenue loss category that the state [0:43:15] Twin Falls can spend on anything that we would like to spend it on, [0:43:18] because we are using a standard deduction amount. [0:43:21] So we don't have to. We're not required to. I would say my recommendation is that we spend on something that potentially could have been used beforehand. [0:43:31] Like honestly, I mean, any construction project, any roadways, any streets. I mean, those are all things that were okay beforehand before we have the $10 million revenue loss. [0:43:43] So really, there's not a complicated answer. We can spend on anything we want. It's just something that's going to be public. [0:43:48] public, we're going to want to be transparent, we're going to want to advertise what we're [0:43:52] doing, and this is what we're spending our money on, which is why Travis has indicated [0:43:56] that putting it together. [0:43:57] I guess with that I would just add a comment, and as we're talking about potential direction [0:44:11] from the council on priorities, since there isn't necessarily a set list of categories [0:44:19] that harp of funds might be used for, I think the philosophies and direction that we've had [0:44:25] the last few years with the Council directed funds continue to be important to me sidewalks [0:44:32] for safety, accessibility, connectivity, I think those quality of life issues like park [0:44:39] improvements enhancements, particularly those responding to broader community interest and [0:44:47] desire for that and then the ability to I certainly support the future discussion of creating [0:44:54] I'm certainly supportive of the same types of things we've been doing with the council-directed funds in the past, [0:45:03] already on sidewalk projects, because I think that presentation we had a few years ago about the vast gaps and challenges of our sits with me. [0:45:25] with me, and I know it's an issue to tackle, and even at $100,000 a year, it's decades away, [0:45:32] so to be able to ship away with. [0:45:34] Thank you, Sean. [0:45:37] Anybody else? [0:45:40] Yes, sir. [0:45:42] You've been being new on the Council, and do have some of the historical projects. [0:45:48] It would be really nice to see what has been approved historically, and potentially, what are some of the other projects [0:45:56] previous councils have talked about just so I can kind of get an idea of what's [0:46:01] there. I would agree with Sean, sidewalk projects, infrastructure projects, water [0:46:10] wastewater, there's things hanging out there, road projects, things that will [0:46:16] ultimately benefit the greater populace of the city and help us continue to [0:46:22] provide the services that we have. It would be nice to see some of that [0:46:26] historical list of what we have done if that's possible to see just so I get an idea and get my mind around what we have done. [0:46:34] Okay, so the next item on the agenda is, I believe, general public input. [0:46:55] It's a time for the general public to come down and speak on any issue that was not on the agenda today. [0:47:03] So if there's anybody here that wishes to come down, I'll give you two minutes. [0:47:08] Please state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls. [0:47:12] Mr. Button. [0:47:16] My name is Michael Buttak. [0:47:23] I am a resident here of Twin Falls. [0:47:26] I haven't spoken here before. [0:47:29] I have emailed with a few of you. [0:47:31] But I did this meeting to speak before. [0:47:34] I'm a resident of the new park place. [0:47:37] I was in development that's on 4th Avenue across the street from City Park. [0:47:42] Our developer has met and told seven times with some office in the city, I'm not sure, [0:47:50] which office it is, to request a dedicated, and the developer doesn't know it, I must be [0:47:55] on behalf of the developer, not an agent of the developer, I'm a resident. [0:48:04] To request a dedicated water line to serve the irrigation system that serves the common [0:48:10] areas of our community. [0:48:12] And so far this request has been denied after this numerous attempts. [0:48:20] So the consequence is that the common sprinkler system for our community [0:48:25] is going to be attached to one of the homes. [0:48:28] One house will supply the block. [0:48:36] And so that as you probably can understand places of burden on that home, [0:48:40] it's not my home, but it is one of the homes. [0:48:46] There is going to be a separate meter, so for billing purposes that's taken care of. [0:48:51] the water pressure for that home will drop to 24% of its normal, water pressure level for [0:48:58] seven or eight hours every single. It is quite a problem and that resident will have to pay [0:49:05] a higher water rate than home houses because they're reaching a certain threshold. I'm just [0:49:11] about done. So as I said, I'm not an agent of the developer or the homeowners association [0:49:16] and I just wanted to just say, I think this is not a good solution, we do, and I ask that [0:49:28] if the developer comes to this meeting to present your support in face assessment. [0:49:42] Okay, thank you very much. Any comment? Travis? [0:49:49] We have a combination of individuals. Jonathan Spentla, we have Josh Baird, and I'll submit [0:49:57] who might be able to share, maybe part of the reason as to why, very simply, what is being asked for is what's called a lawn tap. [0:50:07] Those lawn taps are no longer issued inside of the city of Twin Falls. [0:50:12] The city does not have the ability to rank surface water or a pressurized irrigation system into this area. [0:50:19] It is biles from a pressurized irrigation system, and it's not part of the system. [0:50:27] of the system, so I don't know if someone wants to connect or add to what I just shared [0:50:32] or correct that, but those are part of the reasons as to the why is that the long tab [0:50:39] that we have is against the city code, and so it's not the developer who hasn't necessarily [0:50:45] been told, though, because we didn't necessarily want to do it, I'm just saying it's not an [0:50:54] option that is afforded to us by our own code. [0:50:59] You're saying it's against code to have a long tap? [0:51:06] It is against the code to establish any additional long taps. [0:51:10] A long tap. [0:51:11] On L-A-W-N-Hond. [0:51:14] That is what it's called when the system is only used for an exterior irrigation purpose. [0:51:20] That's just an internal language that we use. [0:51:25] It's not, I'm sure you're aware it's not, request to bring in your irrigation water. [0:51:30] Yeah, I was just sharing that for the council as to why it was. [0:51:40] Thank you. [0:51:41] Thank you. [0:51:43] Anybody else in the audience that was just to speak? [0:51:46] Okay. [0:51:49] I don't see anybody else. [0:51:51] The advisory board reports. [0:51:53] Anybody have a report? [0:51:55] City manager's office. [0:52:02] Okay. [0:52:10] So, next item on the agenda is a public hearing which will start at six o'clock. [0:52:16] Madam Vice Mayor. [0:52:17] Yes. [0:52:18] I do believe that you do have three executive sessions. [0:52:21] I do believe that we have time to cover potentially two of them in the ten minute window time. [0:52:30] They're not extensive conversations, but they're just things that we want to make the council aware of and get some input. [0:52:37] So would it be the first two items that we move in for, or just general? [0:52:43] It would be the first two items, yes. [0:52:45] Okay, then I would entertain a motion. [0:52:52] Tom Merger, move to executive session, places on the agenda, 74-206-1, [0:53:07] yay, to consider labor contract matters, authorized under section 74-206-A1-A-N-B, [0:53:17] by no code, and also executive session 74-206-1-A, [0:53:22] to consider hiring a public officer in place to have a member or individual agent, [0:53:26] or in the perspective of the individual's or to be evaluated in order to fill in particular, [0:53:31] vacancy or need. This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an [0:53:35] elective office or deliberations about staffing needs in general. Thank you to [0:53:40] have a second. Motion by Sean Barrigar seconded by Christopher Reed to move [0:53:45] entered into the executive session under 74206 iJ 1J and 74206 1A. Erin [0:53:54] Thank you. [0:53:55] We will be back at 6 o'clock. [0:53:57] We're close there too. [0:53:58] So don't go away for our public hearing. [0:54:01] Thank you. [0:54:02] Thank you everyone. [0:54:03] We're back from our temporary executive session moving back to our public hearing which today [0:59:10] Today is an action item I request to allow for additional hyping. [0:59:14] On 50 feet, I'm probably located on 2nd Avenue South between Hanson Street and Shofshoe Street. [0:59:20] Here are Bill True-Acts on behalf of the Gleana Opportunity, Inc. [0:59:25] We have Jonathan Spindlam, Planning and Zoning Director. [0:59:28] You want me to read my rules first? [0:59:32] Please. [0:59:33] We'll follow these 9 steps under the public hearing portion of the agenda. [0:59:37] City staff will present the request and analysis. The applicant will then present [0:59:42] their request. The Commission will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. [0:59:46] After questions have been asked the public hearing will be open during that [0:59:51] time anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions [0:59:55] about the request being considered. When giving testimony please come up to the [0:59:59] podium state your name and address and present your comments or concerns. After [1:00:04] After giving testimony, please sign the public records sheet located in the lobby with your [1:00:08] name and address for the record. [1:00:11] And we will keep those comments to two minutes. [1:00:13] After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions to [1:00:17] make a closing statement. [1:00:19] Staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed. [1:00:23] After the closing statement, the public hearing will be closed. [1:00:25] No further testimony or comments from the applicant or the audience will be allowed. [1:00:30] And then we will have open discussion and take action on the request. [1:00:34] Okay, now you're adjourned, Jonathan. [1:00:36] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council. I know the applicants represent an email yesterday saying they would be here knowing what they're not here. [1:00:45] The traffic at the bridge is like I think right now, they may be stuck there, I'm not sure, but I did have confirmation that we're going to be in attendance. [1:00:54] I think we're going to try and get them on the phone potentially or ask them what's going on, but I will continue the presentation. [1:00:59] as thank you for sitting there could I have the NPC come up the location we are [1:01:11] discussing tonight is the property located an approximate in here between that [1:01:16] yellow and red box in outlined area the city on parking lot is in this general [1:01:23] area this is the old making trust building most Fargo with their parking area behind [1:01:28] it means reaping right here Hanson is south easterly area second Avenue being [1:01:35] south southwest. That's what current zone is the CB Henderson P1 parking [1:01:45] overlay. Central business P1 parking overlay actually eliminates all off-street [1:01:52] parking requirements from development so there are no off-street parking [1:01:55] requirements within that general area along seconds within those blocks. Basically [1:02:01] along Main Street extending beyond seconds half a block. The applicant [1:02:07] Produced a narrative, I will not read it. [1:02:11] It is within the packet that the council received. [1:02:14] I'm going to go right to the renderings and discuss the issue at hand. [1:02:18] If you want to go to each level, we can, but in general, the renderings tell the story. [1:02:26] The building here on this right, Hanson Street is here, and that's the building being constructed today at its portrayed height. [1:02:33] Hanson Street runs here, second is in the foreground right here, and the building we're talking about is the parking garage. [1:02:39] the parking garage that has this orange look to it. The height that they are requesting [1:02:45] is 60 feet and that would be measured up to the elevator shaft, the tallest point of [1:02:52] that elevator shaft. There's a reason why the elevator shaft is up there and they have [1:02:56] to have access to all the parking for ADA requirements. And we measure height from the [1:03:03] adjacent curb which would be here and then we'd go vertically up and that is the 60 foot [1:03:07] mark, this general building would look like more 50 feet. The elevator shaft adds that [1:03:13] extra 10 feet. So that is the extra height that they're requesting. There's other two buildings [1:03:21] in the picture. This one here, the other one over there to the left, which is along to Shown [1:03:26] Street. Those were part of a previous application and they have a height exemption that came through [1:03:32] this same process through planning and zoning commission for recommendation and the council [1:03:36] decision on those go up to 85 feet at the elevator shaft. Generally, the building is a 75. This is [1:03:47] another rendering we're just shown to be on the left. Second street is along here. That's [1:03:55] two-scale rendering of the building that is in question, which is the parking [1:03:59] planning zone in commission heard this item previously in the Ford and a positive recommendation [1:04:06] to allow the 60-foot height. Normal heights in this area are limited to 50. So they're [1:04:12] just asking for that extra 10 feet. The other two buildings have already received [1:04:16] those exceptions. Two other things I want to mention, not part of this application [1:04:20] per se. This parking garage is part of a special use permit that was approved [1:04:26] through the planning and zoning commission and there were a couple conditions on [1:04:31] that special use permit. They dealt with the landscaping long second. There [1:04:35] would be, there will be a landscaping plan that needs to be approved by the [1:04:38] planning and zoning commission. They would, they were trying to pre-clude the [1:04:43] look of no trees on that road as well as basically a facade treatment of the [1:04:53] parking garage that will also go back to the Planning and Zoning Commission for [1:04:57] approval by them separately. Those are separate from the height unless council [1:05:03] felt that those items needed to be addressed with this extra height. That's [1:05:06] why I brought them up. In conclusion you are basically reviewing and [1:05:14] approving the extra height and looking at the mitigating factors of having a [1:05:17] building that is 60 feet tall at that location. Staffs report, Ava here in Shane [1:05:28] walk out probably on the phone, to know how this overlaps are part of the Urban [1:05:47] Renewal Project. This building, which is in the foreground, which is on Hanson, [1:05:58] and second, is part of the Urban Renewal Project, which is the Urban Renewal [1:06:04] Agency put out that call for essentially proposals for project to offer certain [1:06:09] things certain elements. This group came back with the proposal to build this building [1:06:15] as well as a parking garage for downtown housing. It's the various other aspects of this building [1:06:21] as part of the Urban Road Project. Essentially portions of this garage are also part of that [1:06:26] project. In order for the project, the Urban Renewal Agency to be a successful project, [1:06:33] the garage is essential but it will be a disconnected building. At one point it was going to be [1:06:38] together. They found that I believe in talking with Galena they found that it was to be a costly [1:06:47] project to bring those buildings together and have a garage and the apartments in the same [1:06:51] structure. The garage would be standalone concrete which can be constructed much faster than having [1:06:56] a multi-story building with garage included with apartment buildings. The approval of this would [1:07:03] advance that urban renewal project to the next phase of receiving building permits are able [1:07:08] to receive building permits after the special use permit conditions are [1:07:11] complied with. That's satisfied with the project. 100 parking spaces. That was part of it. This building [1:07:20] occupies the city-owned parking lot that contains roughly 50 public parking spaces. [1:07:26] Part of that agreement is for the urban rental agency to construct or have constructed 100 public [1:07:33] parking spaces in exchange for some financial contribution by the URA. This garage [1:07:39] contains those 100 spaces on the lower level. [1:07:49] This is the entrance off of second, [1:07:51] and the 100 spaces, although difficult to see, are in green. [1:07:54] They encompass pretty much the entirety [1:07:55] of the first level and part of the second level up to. [1:08:02] The remainder of the parking structure [1:08:05] is private parking either for nearby offices or businesses, [1:08:10] or residents of the two adjoining residential structures. [1:08:18] The only thing that I would add is parking stalls that will be reserved for the residential [1:08:29] component parking garage. [1:08:34] Those spaces are being designed in a manner that allows for what's called a car stacker [1:08:40] in which you can actually have vehicles in the same stall. [1:08:56] The space will to expand. [1:09:01] I think they said half of the spaces would be eligible for a car stacker and so you're [1:09:06] looking at a potentially expansion without increasing the footprint of a potentially up [1:09:11] to an additional hundred working stalls. [1:09:15] That could be- [1:09:24] Hey, so we do not have the applicant here. [1:09:28] He could- [1:09:29] Traffic coming for questions with staff, or do you guys want to stop and wait for them? [1:09:41] Have to answer. [1:09:47] So yes, but let me- so are we- do we want to continue? [1:09:54] Sos. [1:09:56] He tried to reach someone. He said they could call. [1:10:00] He's been heartening five minutes away. [1:10:05] 65 minutes away. [1:10:07] He said he's five minutes away. He also said that if I wanted to send the call in number, he could try that as well. [1:10:12] Whatever the council wishes. [1:10:18] What do you guys want? [1:10:29] If he's up. [1:10:34] Yeah, so if he is. So it's important to recognize this. [1:10:38] We've had considerable number of phone calls into the office today with the ITD project. [1:10:44] Yes. [1:10:45] We understand that it is about a 75 minute drive across the bridge. [1:10:59] So what may have taken 5 minutes in the past might be taking a little bit longer so we'll [1:11:06] try to get him on the phone. [1:11:07] I say let's get him on the phone and if he wants to just pull off he doesn't have to [1:11:12] be here in presence in person so we can take it. [1:11:16] He's working on that I believe. [1:11:19] Okay so wow. [1:11:20] I can take questions from staff standpoint, once you get to the point of the applicant's section, that would be worth it. [1:11:26] Okay, Spencer, go ahead. [1:11:29] Thanks, Mayor. Jonathan, so we're looking at one of the plan views right now, and you can see [1:11:37] it looks like tree symbols for pedestrian landscape space, so they've narrowed the footprint in order to provide that landscape area, which is nice. [1:11:48] But the consequences are asking for 10 more feet of height. [1:11:51] So if we were to vote that down, in order to keep the parking spaces, they're going to basically do away with that. [1:11:58] And we lose that pedestrian landscape area. [1:12:03] That would be one way to- [1:12:04] And I understand the applicant's not here, so I don't expect you to answer more. [1:12:17] But there's multiple things they could do, which is really unsafe. They could dig a bigger hole because they only have a half of a story down below. [1:12:24] down below but there's there's limitations of the site and other than 60 [1:12:36] heard all of them is the pedestrian areas that they like to maintain that [1:12:41] there's also limitations on utilities on the property that kind of limit expanding [1:12:45] this you know there's this is the to them I believe is the most cost effective way [1:12:56] of getting the number of spaces they need per the agreement and per what they [1:13:00] believe they need for their serve the retail and office uses in the [1:13:07] in the residential. Other questions for Jonathan? [1:13:14] Building that is going up now in this location, [1:13:31] accommodated them in this parking garage, [1:13:36] accommodated space for them to use in that parking garage. [1:13:55] These structures, as they're downtown, [1:13:57] the parking overlay do not have a requirement [1:14:00] for off-street parking. The city and the 80s have [1:14:05] basically said we want our downtown to be accessible [1:14:08] to new businesses, and we'd like to eliminate [1:14:11] or decrease the cost of parking currently surface parking is $10,000 a parking space [1:14:18] the structured parking is around 22 to $25,000 parking space to build it's a [1:14:24] significant upfront cost for businesses to operate downtown so that is something [1:14:28] we've eliminated previously yes I believe they've accommodated because they [1:14:34] believe it's value added to their development to have at least one space for [1:14:38] that resident to park in are we gonna try to get him on the phone or waiting for [1:14:53] Now, what's the latest? [1:14:55] My understanding is that they were on Bloog's past the major traffic issues, so they... [1:15:03] Let's take a break for a minute. [1:15:09] Okay, with that. [1:15:11] You made it. [1:15:35] I told me never to be able to either one. [1:15:44] No, you did not. [1:15:47] So, two questions. [1:15:49] Do I identify yourself, please? [1:15:51] Oh, sorry. [1:15:52] Thank you. [1:15:53] Dan Fulmer, I'm with Galena. [1:15:54] I'm the head of investments. [1:15:56] I'm not sure who asked the questions, but they... [1:16:08] Fairly general, the intent of going higher, why we would go taller versus going wide. [1:16:15] It's mostly a cost issue, and then the second issue is we want to open up those alleys for those businesses that access stuff through the alley. [1:16:27] It provides a more pedestrian-friendly walk-through capacity for those that coffee shop and a couple other places. [1:16:34] When you engineer a building and you put housing on top of the parking structure, you have to put a lot more steel into it, pillars, bigger to support the housing above it. [1:16:49] This is one way to minimize the cost of the parking garage, so instead of being a $18 million parking garage, it's $12 million. That's one of the reasons. [1:17:02] The other is the simplicity and easy or access to the parking garage instead of wrapping underneath housing. [1:17:09] This makes it more self-contained for parking specifically. [1:17:13] We like the pedestrian flow item. [1:17:20] Pivot North was really quite genius in coming up with that idea. [1:17:24] Because again, putting the trees there makes it feel less urban, even though it is a big parking structure. [1:17:34] is trying to minimize the look of the concrete by having green around it as well. [1:17:39] So the current building at 160, they will have parking. [1:17:50] We have a lot of 35 for the residents, [1:17:55] and 54 the office user or 44 or something like that for the office user, excuse me. [1:18:06] And so then the evening the office user won't be there. [1:18:12] Any questions for the other questions? [1:18:23] Jason? [1:18:25] So in this pedestrian courtyard, assuming that the bottom floor is going to be intended [1:18:34] restaurants, businesses, things of that nature, is that correct? [1:18:39] Those are actually in townhomes. [1:18:41] We stand that page right there. [1:18:43] That would be perfect. [1:18:44] So what we have originally designed those all four be townhomes, but the one that is farthest [1:18:50] far this to the south I believe this is the right direction on second we actually [1:18:54] have a bodega user that wants to take that so we'll put a bodega on that so they [1:19:01] would walk in off of the pedestrian area and then access that bodega. I guess where I was going with that is that courtyard [1:19:10] would be would we ever see tables or things being set up in that courtyard [1:19:14] that would potentially hamper pedestrians from using that you know dining space or [1:19:21] Yeah, I think what do you see in other, no, it's for residents only. [1:19:27] Okay. [1:19:28] There's kind of a line drawn there that kind of shows where the space between the rectangles, [1:19:35] and so that's kind of their patio space. [1:19:38] So they might have furniture on there, but it won't be, [1:19:41] but it would be more gain-croaching into that pedestrian so people can really slow through there. [1:19:45] Correct. [1:19:46] Correct. [1:19:47] Okay. [1:19:51] Other questions for the applicant? [1:19:52] Okay, so any questions for Jonathan? [1:19:58] Good. [1:20:00] Next we'll open up the public hearing. [1:20:03] If there's anybody out there that wishes to comment, please come down. [1:20:09] State your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls. [1:20:13] And make sure when you're done, if you haven't signed up there, please sign. [1:20:17] So go ahead. [1:20:19] So my name's Rosalie Orton, and I'm a... [1:20:27] So I don't have the whole story, I guess, after listening to all of this. [1:20:31] And I'll just say what I... [1:20:35] Just because a lot of people are moving to Twin Falls, [1:20:38] doesn't mean we should throw away the careful planning, [1:20:42] integrity, and charm of we need to preserve our downtown. [1:20:49] I find it very interesting that Galina has said, [1:20:52] in Idaho, the city has been the best we've worked with, for sure. [1:20:56] is that because we gave them everything they desired, [1:20:59] especially the tallest building in town. [1:21:05] We now opportunity fund is finalizing plans and permits [1:21:11] for two additional buildings of similar size [1:21:13] in the parking structure. [1:21:15] Well, and I just was aware of the one that's being built now [1:21:19] and I thought the parking lot was gonna be right. [1:21:23] I wasn't even aware that there were gonna be [1:21:24] two additional apartments. [1:21:29] So officer Dan Fullers said the buildings are all [1:21:32] you're in T to go up, they are 95% going to happen, almost said. And so I'm just, if the paper hasn't [1:21:42] let the citizens know what's going on or what, you know, as a citizen I feel like I've been really [1:21:48] misinformed. I find it interesting that the Planning and Zoning Commission in the City Council approved [1:21:55] 85 foot height on the current building going 35 feet over the allowed 50 foot height buildings. [1:22:05] And now there will be two additional apartment buildings at 85. [1:22:10] Less a parking garage that needs to be 60 feet. [1:22:17] Then I was adding up all the apartments. [1:22:19] They were saying there would be 139 apartments. [1:22:22] I don't know if apartments require two parking spaces for each apartment. [1:22:29] that's just a residential. I think the parking is going to be a real issue, just [1:22:39] even just listening to what he was saying. Will the public have to pay to use the garage? [1:22:46] Will apartment residents be required to use the parking garage and not park on [1:22:53] the street? And also since when as urban renewals we use to the tune of two million [1:22:59] dollars to subsidize a parking garage for a money-making apartment complex. The [1:23:09] The city just beautified the downtown before these apartments were approved. [1:23:15] I definitely don't approve the height exemption for the parking structure. [1:23:19] But more will they ask for as the project progresses. [1:23:23] And I don't approve of two more apartment buildings downtown either. [1:23:28] I thought there was just going to be, well, what I said. [1:23:31] And has there been any kind of survey you see if these apartments downtown are really necessary? [1:23:38] So thank you for your time. [1:23:40] Thank you. Any other public testimony? Okay, so any other comments from the applicant [1:23:54] wish to address anything she said? Or anything else she wished to add or make a closing statement? [1:24:01] Specifically the parking garage is being built just for the apartments. There's obviously public parking that is part of the details surrounding the cost. [1:24:21] It's expected that there will be a couple hours of free parking, but you have to pay [1:24:26] to maintain a parking garage. [1:24:28] It's where they're costly, and so individuals coming to use the restaurants around it would [1:24:34] get two hours to come and hit your bill at the restaurant and leave and have plenty of [1:24:41] time for parking or who is shopping at any of the beautiful shops along Main Street as [1:24:45] well. [1:24:47] But if you're going to stay longer than that, it might cost you a dollar to, therefore, [1:24:53] that extra hour of $3. [1:24:54] Again, those monies are not going to be a profit to the organization they're going to [1:24:59] be used to maintain the parking garage and the public spaces. [1:25:05] It's also being built in. [1:25:07] The increased height is to allow for additional parking. [1:25:14] So it's because the office is being set aside 50 spaces on the weekend. [1:25:21] 50 people aren't going to be at the office, so that's going to be available parking for [1:25:25] people coming, right? [1:25:26] So they can use it to go to friends or whatever they want to on the weekend as well. [1:25:36] So, specifically regarding housing needs, surveys have been done by our group, the demand [1:25:48] is there, people want to live downtown, they want to be part of the amazing main street [1:25:54] that Twin Falls has created. [1:25:56] I'm not sure how to address the concern of us getting more that we've asked for specific [1:26:06] things. [1:26:11] This is the answer for her. Obviously one of the departments, but we're in another city that we build sensitive buildings. [1:26:43] Do you have something to add? [1:26:50] Yeah, I can answer a couple of the code questions. One, apartments do require outside of the P1 overlay. [1:26:57] Two parking spaces per unit for two bedroom. And if you have more than that, it's two and a half spaces. [1:27:03] The departments down in this area are within that P1 overlay, so that requirement is exempted. [1:27:08] Second, anybody can park on the street in areas that are posted for public parking. [1:27:16] Very few are not. [1:27:18] Some of them might be regulated by hours and that ends up being a decision of the city. [1:27:23] I say the city of the city engineers says the safe space is not safe for the city council [1:27:28] to dictate those hours on public streets. [1:27:31] Adding to what Mr. Fulmer said, the public parking area in the garage with the agreement [1:27:37] the agreement from the city to the ura is to maintain the public spaces just like [1:27:41] all the other public spaces or as dictated by the city council some terms of if [1:27:46] the council believes it's a two-hour free and then after that you pay that's [1:27:50] something that this body would decide for the public parking areas just like our [1:27:53] public parking lots are today dictated by this body's decision try to remember [1:28:00] the third one I'm not sure if I didn't I can any questions for okay so that [1:28:16] closes the public hearing. No further testimony or comments from the applicant or [1:28:22] the audience will be allowed. So time for council discussion. That's a wish. Spencer [1:28:29] color. Yeah I just want to comment. It's hard for you to see the town change but [1:28:35] when I think about the alternatives 100 units in an apartment downtown is [1:28:41] different than a hundred house subdivision. I think about the use of a lot less water [1:28:47] 20 years from now. There's so many fewer miles of pipe and roads and sidewalks that [1:28:53] will have to replace at taxpayer expense. And I've also heard business owners are [1:29:00] excited about revitalization down there and they've actually come to previous [1:29:06] to support this, so it's very seldom a black and white line of I like this or I don't like [1:29:13] that you have to balance everything and I would be in favor of this although I wish things [1:29:19] could just not change at all but I don't think that's something that we can do. [1:29:25] Sean Merger. [1:29:26] Thank you Merger. [1:29:28] Echo some of answer's comments, you know, changes inevitable that are partnerships in [1:29:38] in the city of the new agency private development developments in such a way that they're best [1:29:50] to preserve our values and still move us forward as a community. [1:29:55] So, it's a six-story building in the city and it's been since those days we're here [1:30:12] at these taller structures in the last handful of years is pretty surprising, I think, for [1:30:19] the community growing as quickly as we are, so it manages to this the kinds of things that [1:30:26] been explored in her comprehensive plan, full of community input, desire for [1:30:34] dense development, accessibility to mixed use, those types of things. As you all know, [1:30:40] I have been what I say that I will say last six months or so. It is increasingly [1:30:52] more difficult parking space that I used to like to park in to go places and that's a good thing [1:30:58] because that means that Congress is booming in downtown. They're supporting local businesses. [1:31:03] is residential growth downtown. So I think having an opportunity to like a parking structure [1:31:10] like this, replace parking that it's taking up but expand that. [1:31:25] Thank you. I'm also in favor of this and when we look at this as long years and it is [1:31:40] that we're really going to be as many cars with the residents perhaps as we're thinking [1:32:06] But it is part of changing. [1:32:08] It is. [1:32:10] This was one of the biggest complaints we've yet. [1:32:27] Constantly is the parking. [1:32:29] And this actually adds 50 spots which doubles the capacity. [1:32:34] I think that's really a positive. [1:32:38] So any other history? [1:32:41] I echo what everybody said. [1:32:43] I just wanted to add one thing because I've heard this. [1:32:47] Especially from those that are downtown is that a developer comes in, [1:32:50] in, the city does whatever they would like. [1:32:52] I know specifically the Galena group came in two years ago or so, and we turned them now. [1:32:59] This specific group that we're building in, it was because of parking, it was because of [1:33:04] setbacks, and it was because of height. [1:33:07] Not the specific project, but I think that goes to developers working with the city to [1:33:14] make sure that what's being developed in our community fits our community and council as [1:33:18] as well as when we hear from community that says that's not what we want, we have said [1:33:24] now, like this does fit that area. Second Street is a road that's traveled by a lot of people. [1:33:33] This is going to fit well, I'd rather have this than just an open block. This I think [1:33:40] is going to look really nice, I think this is going to fit our community, especially as [1:33:44] we continue to grow. And as we work developers like the Galena group and several others that [1:33:50] They're really trying to help our community grow. [1:33:56] Sean Merricker, anybody else? [1:34:01] I'm ready for a motion. [1:34:03] Go ahead, Sean. [1:34:04] Merrick, I would move to approve the request [1:34:07] to allow for additional height beyond 50 feet [1:34:10] on property located at the south between Hanson Street [1:34:13] and Shoshone Street and Carapal True Act. [1:34:15] On behalf of them, it has presented [1:34:21] with the staff recommended. [1:34:24] Have a second. [1:34:26] I'll second. [1:34:27] Thank you, motion by Sean Merricker, [1:34:28] seconded by Christopher Reed to allow the addition [1:34:33] additional height as proposed. Any further discussion? [1:34:38] Paran roll call vote please. [1:34:42] Jason Brown? Yes. [1:34:44] Dr. Cutler? Yes. Mayor Pierce? Yes. Vice Mayor Reed? Yes. [1:34:49] Sean Berker? Yes. Thank you, Boyd. Yes. [1:34:52] Thank you, motion passes six to zero. [1:34:55] So again, the next item on the agenda is to move into [1:35:01] Executive Session and in this case it's under Executive Session 74-2061-F to communicate [1:35:10] with legal counsel for the public agency, discuss the legal ramifications of and legal [1:35:15] options for pending litigation or controversies, not yet being litigated but immediately likely [1:35:23] to be litigated. [1:35:24] This may be a present of legal counsel's executive session does not satisfy this requirement. [1:35:30] No lift. [1:35:31] Thank you, Motion. [1:35:32] Bye, Nikki Boyd. [1:35:33] Second by Christopher Reed to move into the Executive Session under 742061 F. [1:35:37] Aaron Rokavo, please. [1:35:38] That's your color. [1:35:39] Yes. [1:35:40] Yes. [1:35:41] Mayor Pierce. [1:35:42] Yes. [1:35:45] Yes. [1:35:46] Vice Mayor Reed. [1:35:47] Yes. [1:35:48] Sean Berricker. [1:35:49] Yes. [1:35:50] Nikki Boyd. [1:35:51] Yes. [1:35:52] Jason Brown. [1:35:53] Yes. [1:35:54] Thank you. [1:35:55] Motion passes six to zero. [1:35:56] I just want to remind everybody, all one of you, that we are not going to do that. [1:36:01] We are not going to be reconvening, we will make no decisions in executive and work done. [1:36:07] We'll be done for the night. [1:36:09] Thank you.