Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2022-05-02, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2022-05-02/ [0:00:25] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to our May 2nd City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. All seven members of the City Council are here in person. [0:00:37] Our next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Anybody wishing to rise and join me? Please rise. [0:00:43] Thank you. We have our proclamation tonight. The Idaho GIS Proclamation 2022. [0:01:10] The Idaho GIS May 2nd through 5th, 2022. Whereas nonprofit organizations help build and sustain healthy communities in our state [0:01:21] and enhance the quality of life for Idahoans and others throughout the country and the world. [0:01:26] world, and whereas over 6,000 nonprofit organizations based in Idaho contribute significantly to [0:01:33] our economy by providing services to our communities, employing over 55,000 Idahoans, and producing [0:01:43] total revenue of $5.45 billion, whereas, Idaho's nonprofit leaders are often entrepreneurs [0:01:52] create new solutions to problems, and filling previously unmet needs in the area of health [0:01:58] recreation, education research, arts, social services, and more, and whereas Idaho gives [0:02:05] services the time for Idahoans to join together with one voice on one day to contribute to [0:02:12] and amplify the efforts of Idaho nonprofits and whereas the nonprofit sector acts as a [0:02:19] responsible steward of charitable dollars [0:02:22] to achieve a diverse range of missions and goals. [0:02:25] And whereas nonprofit organizations often fulfill [0:02:28] their missions by advocating on behalf of those [0:02:31] who cannot advocate for themselves. [0:02:34] And now therefore, I Ruth Pierce, [0:02:36] mayor of the city of Twin Falls, [0:02:38] to hereby proclaim May 2nd through 5th 2022, [0:02:44] as Idaho gives and encourage all Idahoans [0:02:48] to join in supporting funds during their 24-hour online event. [0:02:55] Is there anyone from I don't guess here? [0:02:58] Okay. [0:03:00] Thank you. [0:03:01] Um, next on down the agenda is the consent calendar. [0:03:05] Council wishes. [0:03:12] And the motion to approve it. [0:03:15] Thank you. [0:03:17] For a second. [0:03:18] Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins seconded by. [0:03:24] Sean Berge, Berge to approve the consent calendar. [0:03:29] Aaron Roll call vote, please. [0:03:32] Mayor Pierce. [0:03:33] Yes. [0:03:34] Vice Mayor Reed. [0:03:35] Yes. [0:03:35] Sean Berge. [0:03:37] Yes. [0:03:37] Nikki Boyd. [0:03:38] Yes. [0:03:39] Craig Hawkins. [0:03:40] Yes. [0:03:40] Jason Brown. [0:03:41] Yes. [0:03:42] Spencer Cutler. [0:03:43] Yes. [0:03:44] Thank you. [0:03:45] Motion carries. [0:03:46] Passes 7 to 0. [0:03:48] So if you were here for the final plat [0:03:50] for the residents at Breckenridge, number one, [0:03:54] Battle bridge bands at the bridge magic Valley refugee day. All those have been approved [0:04:03] next under items of consideration [0:04:07] Consideration of a request by Matt air magic Valley for public safety and support and special event fee waiver for Jocelyn Fields [0:04:16] 75th anniversary celebration air show [0:04:19] June 16th and 17th 2023 and we have our airport manager [0:04:25] Bill Carberry, welcome Bill. [0:04:27] Thank you, Mayor, good evening Council. [0:04:30] Looking at the City of Twin Falls mission statement [0:04:34] recently, there's a lot of principles [0:04:37] that are embedded in there. [0:04:38] There are a couple that really kind of shine [0:04:42] with their magic valley. [0:04:43] And it talks about promoting citizens' input and involvement [0:04:47] and preserving our heritage. [0:04:50] And Air Magic Valley, through the great efforts [0:04:53] of citizens in our community was formed really, Jim would know more specifically, [0:04:58] but sometime back about 1996, as opposed to we have, at that time, [0:05:02] they celebrated the 50th anniversary of Johnson Field back in 1996. [0:05:08] So, fast forward into the upcoming 2023 year. [0:05:12] They're back once again here at Magic Valley and they'd like to help us honor our heritage next year, [0:05:19] which is Johnson Field's 75th anniversary. [0:05:22] it was May of 1948. It was a cold and blustery day. It was snowing. Ladies wore furs. There [0:05:29] were 4,000 people in attendance in 1948 for the airport's opening. Snow flurries, there [0:05:36] were bands, military parades. It was quite a day back in 1948. So the group was here in [0:05:47] October and they talked about their ambitions and their hopes for the Blue Angels to be [0:05:53] be here for that event. Unfortunately, we didn't make the schedule. Nevertheless, the group [0:05:59] is moving forward with a contingency plan. They're going to have a great event. They're [0:06:02] planning it. I think the community will really love what's going on. [0:06:07] So I'd like to introduce Jim O'Donnell, who's a founder of the organization, has been through [0:06:12] many of your shows. He's here tonight as spokesperson. Steve Kohler is director. There [0:06:17] are other folks that may come straggling in here from what I understand. But please help [0:06:22] Let me welcome Jim O'Donnell who's got a brief PowerPoint and I'll be back to visit with you again. [0:06:27] Thank you Bill. [0:06:28] Welcome Tim. [0:06:29] It's good to see each of you. [0:06:31] I was asking a question when I first came in what I'm here for and I'm here. [0:06:35] I guess I'll do two things. [0:06:36] Number one is I want to invite each of you to attend the law enforcement memorial service [0:06:41] to be held on Saturday, May the 14th at the clock. [0:06:44] It's a time to remember 73 fallen officers in the state of Idaho since the 1880s and a time to honor [0:06:51] honor the men and women who currently serve us. [0:06:54] So that's an invitation. [0:06:55] And by the way, there's free lunch. [0:06:57] So come on out for that. [0:06:59] Thank you. [0:06:59] Now we put on my air show. [0:07:02] We're here to ask your support [0:07:05] because we're gonna put up an air show. [0:07:07] 75 years ago, as Bill mentioned, [0:07:10] the air field was dedicated to Johnson Field. [0:07:14] How many of you know who Sergeant Raymond Josslin was? [0:07:17] Anybody? [0:07:18] I have to confess, I had to look it up too. [0:07:20] Sergeant Johnson was the individual who was named after. [0:07:25] He was credited because he was the first air crew member from Twin Falls County who died in World War II. [0:07:31] He died in 1942 and at B-17, shot down over the Pacific Ocean. [0:07:38] He was interred at the basin, the cot, or the punch bowl, in a humming of the white. [0:07:46] The field was named his honor and that field opened many doors to this community. [0:07:52] Can anybody tell me the first aircraft, commercial aircraft to carry passengers in and out of [0:07:58] twin poles? [0:07:59] Okay, I have a look at up to a DC-3. [0:08:04] What we want to do is remember and celebrate 75 years of aviation history and the fun and [0:08:13] the importance it brings to our community. [0:08:16] So, go ahead, next one, please. [0:08:20] He gave it to me and I'm not trained. [0:08:23] Can you imagine here? [0:08:26] That 75 years, a lot has taken place. [0:08:33] As part of what we're trying to do [0:08:34] is downsize the air shell, [0:08:36] but we have a couple of performers. [0:08:38] Here's some pictures of the ones we've outlined up already. [0:08:41] The first one we have lined up in the upper right hand side [0:08:44] is a P-51. [0:08:46] actually the symbol of World War II. [0:08:48] The next one below that is a T33. [0:08:51] Now if you've been to Twin Falls Airport, [0:08:52] I hope you know there is a T33 on display out there. [0:08:57] It's kind of a symbol of our airport. [0:08:59] We've got one of them lined up to come. [0:09:01] Then on the bottom left is an A37, [0:09:06] which is a aircraft used in Vietnam. [0:09:08] So we've got World War II, Korea, Vietnam covered. [0:09:12] And then for fun, on the upper left-hand corner [0:09:15] is a stunt plane, performance plane. [0:09:18] This particular performer, his very first air show, [0:09:22] was here in Twin Falls. [0:09:24] And so, those are kind of the performance we'll wind up. [0:09:27] Then, we also have, we're gonna try to get [0:09:33] as many aircraft on display as the bus can. [0:09:37] We have a lot of unique aircraft in our airport. [0:09:40] A lot of people really don't know [0:09:41] some of the things we have out there. [0:09:44] Can anybody here tell me how many packages arrive [0:09:47] in Dport from Twin Falls Airport every day. [0:09:50] I have no idea either. [0:09:52] Because we have three carriers. [0:09:54] We're going to try to get them out to show what they've got. [0:09:57] We've got the BLM station out there. [0:09:59] We've got firefighting crews. [0:10:00] We've got all these other things. [0:10:02] We want to get them set up for what Call of Static display. [0:10:05] We can come out and see it. [0:10:06] Now this is going to be a family event. [0:10:09] We were working with the group today already [0:10:12] about the possibilities of having a kid's land set up. [0:10:16] And since we want to make it a time to come out, [0:10:18] can join, to learn about the airport, [0:10:20] to learn about aviation history, [0:10:22] and to involve and encourage young people, [0:10:25] and others to enter that field. [0:10:28] The picture here are some of the other activities [0:10:30] we've had, some people have been involved. [0:10:32] Now, another aircraft we're working on is a B-17. [0:10:35] And of course, why the B-17? [0:10:37] Because that's what Sergeant Johnson was killed in. [0:10:41] The next one we're working on also is a DC-3. [0:10:45] What a great momentum that would be to have one of the original type of aircraft to come [0:10:50] beyond display here to infall it. [0:10:52] So those are part of what's being worked on in preparation for it. [0:10:56] We'll also be putting out a printed program. [0:10:58] We have a gentleman who is a historian who writes a lot of the history. [0:11:02] The history is art in Jawsland, but more importantly, the history of the airport [0:11:06] at Twin Falls, Idaho, Johnson Field. [0:11:09] Now I've got to confess I have a vested interest in this. [0:11:12] My very first place to solo as a pilot was here to Twin Falls. [0:11:17] And just the last two weeks to my grandson, I'm bragging, [0:11:21] I admit it, to my grandson's also solo. [0:11:24] And so we want to see something special. [0:11:28] We want to see it for families and those [0:11:30] who enjoy this community. [0:11:32] It's a great privilege and opportunity. [0:11:35] And so for your support, we can make it happen. [0:11:39] That's it, right? [0:11:41] Thank you for your time. [0:11:43] and I hope to see you a week from Saturday. [0:11:45] Okay. [0:11:50] Thank you, Jim. [0:11:52] So the air show is an expensive event. [0:11:55] The ask tonight of the committee is for public safety support. [0:11:59] We've always been supported by PD and fire in the past, [0:12:03] and as well as the county, their sheriff's department, [0:12:06] EMS representatives, all of these things [0:12:09] that it takes to put on a public event like this. [0:12:12] So to talk a little bit about budget impacts [0:12:16] with something like this is also a small fee waiver [0:12:18] for special use permit they're asking. [0:12:21] You know, there'll be the salary considerations [0:12:23] for public safety folks. [0:12:25] And additionally, as in more of an aside, [0:12:27] I'll be formulating a budget request [0:12:30] in the coming weeks here from the city and county [0:12:33] to help support this event. [0:12:34] It is a city and county facility and looking for a budget request, [0:12:41] which I won't go into numbers now, [0:12:43] but it will come through the budget submittal [0:12:45] that the council receives for things like [0:12:49] logistical support, supplies, insurance, [0:12:52] those kinds of things that really platform the show. [0:12:56] The committee's already off and running, [0:12:58] talking with potential sponsors. [0:13:01] I'm really encouraged to tell those conversations [0:13:03] are picking up and I think they're being well received. [0:13:06] Those kinds of dollars will go to performers, [0:13:08] things like that. [0:13:09] I'll be looking for some dollars [0:13:10] in the airport budget to write checks to local vendors [0:13:14] that provide services and supplies to us for the event. [0:13:18] So as far as regulatory, we've done this before. [0:13:21] We'll work with the FAA, our airport engineer will assist us. [0:13:25] So in conclusion, I would recommend the City Council [0:13:28] approve their magic value request for public safety [0:13:32] support in a way of any fee waivers associated [0:13:35] for the special event for next year's anniversary. [0:13:39] I think they're looking June 16, 17, Friday, Saturday. [0:13:43] There's some talk maybe a two-day show [0:13:44] and maybe go into Sunday, [0:13:45] but that hasn't been determined just yet. [0:13:48] Be happy to answer any questions you might have. [0:13:51] Any questions for Bill? [0:13:53] Sean Berker. [0:13:54] A just question where this is in 2023. [0:13:58] A public safety support items, [0:14:00] would that not just be included in the budget [0:14:05] or do we remove those now and then they do that? [0:14:08] Well, I think they're the request [0:14:10] is that they would be relieved of any responsibility [0:14:13] for those costs and then those considerations would be something I think that would go into [0:14:18] the budget. [0:14:21] Yeah Bill's right, this is the best time to ask for those funds as well as the creation [0:14:25] of the budget if there's not going to be a revenue source coming into office at the [0:14:28] overtime cost we want to make sure that we appropriately budget for those. [0:14:31] Thank you. [0:14:32] Any other questions? [0:14:35] I'd entertain a motion. [0:14:39] I would love to, Nikki. [0:14:40] I would love to do a motion however I'm having just a wee bit of trouble right here but [0:14:41] I'll be right back to it. [0:14:42] Thank you. [0:14:43] Any other questions? [0:14:44] I would entertain a motion. [0:14:45] I would love to do a motion however I'm having just a wee bit of trouble right here but [0:14:48] I'm going to cheat off my major. [0:14:57] May or I move that we grant the request by Air Magic Valley for public safety support [0:15:02] and specially vet fee waiver for Jozlin Fields 75th Anniversary Celebration Air Show June [0:15:09] 16 and 17 of 2023. [0:15:11] Thank you. [0:15:12] Do I have a second? [0:15:14] Also, remember. [0:15:15] Thank you, Chris. [0:15:16] Thank you, Chris. [0:15:17] Motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Chris Reed to approve the request by Air Magic Valley [0:15:24] for public safety support and special event fee waiver for the 75th anniversary celebration. [0:15:31] Any further discussion? [0:15:33] Aaron Roll, call vote please. [0:15:36] Vice Mayor Reed. [0:15:37] Yes. [0:15:38] Non-Barricar. [0:15:39] Yes. [0:15:40] Nicky Boyd. [0:15:41] Yes. [0:15:42] Craig Hawkins. [0:15:43] Yes. [0:15:44] Jason Brown. [0:15:45] Yes. [0:15:46] Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you very much. [0:15:53] Bill. Thank you. Jim. Okay. Next item on the agenda is a request to use city reserves for [0:16:04] the construction of additional parking at the Twin Falls Animal Shelter at 420 Victory Avenue. [0:16:11] We have Mandy Thompson, assistant to our city manager. Mandy, hello. Good evening, [0:16:18] Mayor and Council. I'm sure you're surprised that I'm here to talk about something related to the [0:16:23] fire department this morning. So tonight we're talking about the Fire Training Center and a little [0:16:32] background. The Fire Training Center is being built adjacent to property owned by the city where [0:16:39] the Twin Pills Animal Shelter is the nonprofit people for pets, excuse me, operates out of. [0:16:46] As the city continues to grow, so does the need for additional spaces and services associated [0:16:54] with the animal shelter. [0:16:56] Often the parking in this facility is completely used by individuals visiting the shelter or [0:17:02] volunteering there. [0:17:05] That makes it fairly difficult for the animal control officers to find a place to park when [0:17:09] they're dropping off the animals. [0:17:11] Additionally, employees have been parking at the facility next to the animal shelter at Coca-Cola. [0:17:20] And this has not been a long-term solution. [0:17:23] And one that Coca-Cola has asked that the animal shelter find a permanent solution to. [0:17:28] They'd like them to not want to be utilizing that for employee parking. [0:17:31] So, Mitch Humble, our deputy city manager and fire chief Les Kenworthy, [0:17:36] where they have been working with the animal shelter to come up with a solution. [0:17:41] They have been in the process of raising funds to do a small addition to the animal shelter [0:17:49] that will be dedicated to receiving cats and some housing for those as well. [0:17:54] And so it seems like it's an appropriate time to look at some additional parking [0:17:59] because it's a bit of an integral design for the fire training facility. [0:18:04] training facility. So if you look at the rendering, I apologize. I did put some renderings in your [0:18:12] counsel packet, but I realized when I went to print them off today that those were like [0:18:16] architectural drawings, and I'm pretty sure you can look at them. So I apologize for that. [0:18:22] But what you're looking at on this map is a rendering of the prior training facility. [0:18:29] And number one is what we're speaking about tonight. [0:18:32] So currently, when you come down Victory Avenue, you access the animal shelter, just kind of [0:18:37] to the right of that number one, and you pull into the parking lot, and that's how you access [0:18:42] the animal shelter. [0:18:43] This is part of the overall design of the Fire Training Center, and needing to per city code [0:18:49] only have one entrance and exit into the facility. [0:18:53] We move the design is that we moved that entrance into both facilities a little bit further down, [0:18:58] And as you can see in order to access both on 2A and 3, there had to be some means by which [0:19:05] to connect the two. [0:19:07] So we went ahead and had the land group, our civil engineer design, the parking space at [0:19:13] the parking area, along with the entrance to the comfortable facilities, into the design [0:19:19] of the fire training center. [0:19:22] So as you know, the fire training center is not being constructed with city funds, but [0:19:27] rather by the rural fire district, but because this is a city function, we felt that we needed [0:19:36] to pull this portion of the project out of the fire training center budget, and so I'm [0:19:41] here this evening asking for council to approve use of reserves to pay for that entrance to [0:19:50] the additional parking spaces that will serve the animal shelter as it is designed and you [0:19:59] can see up there. The scope of the project is the grating fill, paving, curving, gutter and [0:20:05] sidewalk and some landscaping adjacent to the road at the entrance and we're working right [0:20:16] now with chance months or new park superintendent on making sure that all of the landscaping [0:20:24] kind of works with the existing landscaping of the animal shelter but also is low in water [0:20:30] use. We have an irrigation, we're going to be utilizing irrigation water from the golf [0:20:36] course and so we're designing something that is relatively low in water use so that we [0:20:40] can make sure that we don't pull any water from the golf course and you can do in [0:20:45] amount of water from the golf course. So in your council packet that I provided [0:20:54] area number one is what we're speaking of and you can see that Michael Arrington [0:21:01] separated this portion of it out and the total budget for this project is $108,643. [0:21:13] Michael would ask me to assure you that that's probably the least amount you will ever see [0:21:18] this portion of the project cost because it was bid out a few months ago and also because [0:21:23] they used a unit pricing for the concrete at the asphalt. [0:21:26] So this is maybe not the timing of it. [0:21:31] We kind of went back and forth whether or not we should wait to build the parking lot [0:21:37] until the ammo shelter had done their renovation, [0:21:40] but in the end, Michael felt pretty strongly that this was, [0:21:45] because we needed to create the entrance, [0:21:47] and it was really the best time, [0:21:49] and probably the least amount of money [0:21:52] that we would be asking you for, [0:21:54] for the project moving forward. [0:21:56] So I would now stand for any questions [0:22:01] that you may have. [0:22:02] Chris or her name? [0:22:04] So, Mandy, on one, the access is gonna be shared [0:22:09] by the new facility and animal shelter. [0:22:15] Yes. [0:22:15] Okay, so have we talked with the folks at the animal shelter [0:22:19] and they're totally good with this. [0:22:20] They're happy with this as well. [0:22:22] Yes, she's thrilled with it. [0:22:23] So she's very much on board. [0:22:25] Perfect. [0:22:27] Thank you. [0:22:27] Sean Bericher. [0:22:33] Yes, go ahead. [0:22:33] Thank you. [0:22:34] Here I would move to approve the use of city reserves [0:22:37] for the construction of additional parking [0:22:38] at the Twin Falls animal shelter as presented in the amount [0:22:42] $1,648,643. [0:22:44] Thank you. [0:22:45] Do I have a second? [0:22:47] Oh, second. [0:22:48] Thank you. [0:22:49] Nicky, motion by Sean Barricar, seconded by Nicky Boyd, to approve the use of city reserves [0:22:55] of 1,843. [0:22:59] Is that correct? [0:23:01] 643. [0:23:02] 643 for the construction of additional parking at the animal shelter. [0:23:05] When falls animal shelter. [0:23:07] Here in Roll Call vote, please. [0:23:10] Sean Barricar. [0:23:11] Yes. [0:23:12] Nicky Boyd. [0:23:13] Thank you, Boyd. [0:23:14] Yes. [0:23:15] Craig Hawkins. [0:23:16] Yes. [0:23:17] Jason Brown. [0:23:18] Yes. [0:23:19] Spencer Cutler. [0:23:20] Yes. [0:23:21] Mayor Pierce. [0:23:22] Yes. [0:23:23] Vice-Mayor Reed. [0:23:24] Yes. [0:23:25] Thank you. [0:23:26] Motion passes 7-0. [0:23:27] Thank you, Mandy. [0:23:31] Thank you. [0:23:32] Next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to approve a contract with Horton [0:23:36] industrial and include 10% construction oversight and observation by Jacobson and 10% contingency for a total amount [0:23:45] of 188.064 to remove the west digester lining in order to complete the engineering inspection [0:23:53] authorized by city council on April 12, 2021. And we have Josh Barrett, our new public works director. [0:24:01] Thanks, mayor, members of council. I'm actually going to let our new environmental manager, Nathan [0:24:06] Erickson, present. I'll be right here for backup. So this is first one to go easy on them. [0:24:11] Okay, welcome Nathan. Thank you, Mayor, Council. So, as stated, I'm here for a project that's [0:24:23] going on down at the wastewater treatment plant back in April 12, 2021, the Council authorized [0:24:32] city staff and Jacob's engineering to proceed with an assessment of the West digester. The project [0:24:39] to remove the bio solids, or the project was to remove bio solids from the digester and [0:24:44] then set up scaffolding in the digester and then have an engineer inspect the coatings [0:24:50] on the digester and then also the concrete. Recently Jacob engineering had an engineer [0:24:57] inspect the digester and he found that the delamination of the interior coating and the resulting air [0:25:04] pockets are not allowing him to a complete accurate inspection of the digester. The pictures in [0:25:13] your packet and also up on the screen right now show what that interior looks like and why it's [0:25:19] hard for him to get an accurate inspection. It's worth noting that the aligner would have to be [0:25:25] removed during the next phase so it's going to have to happen anyways but before we can get that [0:25:31] that is actually completed, we need to have that liner removed. [0:25:34] So Jacobs Engineering has collected three bids, [0:25:38] two when writing one is verbal, [0:25:41] and Jacobs has recommended that the city contract [0:25:44] with Horton Industrial, Horton Industrial's bid was $156,720, [0:25:53] and there's also a 10% construction observation [0:25:57] oversight included which is fifteen thousand six hundred seventy two dollars [0:26:02] then also ten percent contingency or another fifteen thousand six hundred [0:26:07] seventy two so the total comes out to the requested a hundred eighty thousand [0:26:12] sixty four dollars any questions for Nathan a question just when I saw these [0:26:22] pictures is that what we kind of thought before we emptied this thing and and [0:26:27] And everything we thought, I didn't know what to picture, it's very graphic, and so obviously [0:26:33] that lining is completely done. [0:26:36] Yes. [0:26:37] Is that what we were expecting? [0:26:39] Yeah, I think what they were expecting, I think the liner itself has a ten-year life. [0:26:47] And this liner was installed from what I was told around 2012, yeah, 2012, so it's [0:26:57] that at the end of his life. Any other questions? I'd entertain a motion from someone. Jason [0:27:08] Brown. I'd move to approve contract with Horton Industries and includes a 10% construction [0:27:17] oversight and observation by Jacobs for a 10% contingency for a total amount of $188,064 [0:27:26] to remove the digester liner. Thank you. Do I have a second? Motion by Jason Brown, second [0:27:35] by Christopher Reed and Craig Hawkins, I think at the same time, we'll give it to Chris, to [0:27:43] approve the contract to award the contract to Horton Industrial for a grand total with [0:27:50] contingency fees of 188.064 to remove the West Digestor Lightning. Aaron Roll call vote [0:27:57] please. [0:27:58] Thank you, Boyd. [0:28:00] Yes. [0:28:01] Ray Hawkins. [0:28:02] Yes. [0:28:03] Jason Brown. [0:28:04] Yes. [0:28:05] Spencer Cutler. [0:28:06] Yes. [0:28:07] Mayor Pierce. [0:28:08] Yes. [0:28:09] Vice-Mary Reed. [0:28:10] Yes. [0:28:11] Sean Verger. [0:28:12] Yes. [0:28:13] Thank you, motion passes just seven to zero. [0:28:15] Thank you, Josh and Nathan. [0:28:18] Okay, next item on the agenda is a time for general public input. [0:28:22] There's anybody in the public in our audience that wishes to or on the phone to [0:28:30] Give input now sure time [0:28:32] No one advise report reports [0:28:41] I'm here. I just want to report so I have been attending the monthly [0:28:45] Local emergency planning committee meetings and I don't want to speak to a lot of detail probably [0:28:51] Worrying and maybe not so and if I know that it's boring subject matter, but [0:28:57] You know, one benefit of that committee is just inter-agency cooperation, you know, [0:29:02] there are fire a few weeks ago downtown as example of multiple fire departments working together, [0:29:07] and it definitely helps when you get to know people beforehand when you're not under stress or [0:29:13] duress, and so I've been attending those monthly. Also have been attending the regular historic [0:29:21] preservation commission meetings and you know they have a slobas study stream of [0:29:28] certificates of appropriateness coming in and are also looking about what to do [0:29:34] for the anniversary of the evil Knievel Jump and perhaps recognizing that site as [0:29:40] historical site or working with Parks Department to do some sort of recognition [0:29:46] out there. Thank you. Any other advisory board reports? [0:29:51] Did he manage his office? [0:29:55] We are just talking about Lenten from Montana. [0:30:09] We have nothing to report tonight. [0:30:12] Oh dear, how do I follow that? [0:30:17] So again, just a reminder, on the 14th we have the Peace Officers Memorial at City Park. [0:30:23] It starts at 11 o'clock. [0:30:26] Any other idle gifts this week? [0:30:30] Open your wallets and open your hearts for all the nonprofits. [0:30:34] but we do very, very well in Idaho. [0:30:38] We have a very giving state and a very giving community [0:30:42] and I challenge everybody to keep that up. [0:30:49] We have on the agenda of public hearing, [0:30:53] which we cannot start till six o'clock. [0:30:55] We also have on the agenda and executive session, [0:30:58] which is canceled tonight. [0:31:00] So we will take a break and return here [0:31:05] here a few minutes before 6 o'clock for our public hearing. [0:31:10] Thank you. [0:33:08] OK, good evening, ladies and gentlemen. [0:33:10] We're going to reconvene for our public hearing tonight. [0:33:15] And we have the request for amendment to the Federation [0:33:19] Point CDA to allow private and public school [0:33:22] as an outright permitted use and amend the conceptual site [0:33:26] plan and the zoning development agreement. [0:33:29] Cara Paul Berlin Beaumont USA on behalf of Hepworth Family Land Holdings LLC. [0:33:36] We have our own Eonsology. [0:33:40] If you can read the rules of that public hearing. [0:33:44] I will do that first. [0:33:46] Um, Z-Step at first. [0:33:49] Um, the council will follow these nine steps under the public hearing portion of the agenda. [0:33:56] Did the staff will present and request the request and analysis the applicant will then [0:34:02] present their request. [0:34:05] The commission will then ask questions. [0:34:07] The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. [0:34:11] After questions have been asked the public hearing will be open during that time. [0:34:15] Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request [0:34:20] being considered. [0:34:22] When given testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address them, present [0:34:26] your comments or concerns. [0:34:29] After giving testimony, please sign the public sign-in sheet located in the lobby with your [0:34:34] name and address for the record. [0:34:37] After the public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any [0:34:40] questions and make a closing statement. [0:34:42] The staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed. [0:34:47] After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed. [0:34:50] further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed and [0:34:54] then the council will have an open discussion and take action on the [0:34:58] request. [0:34:59] Mr. Reed. Thank you. I just need to make a quick comment after consulting with the [0:35:10] City Attorney. I do have a business relationship with one of the members in [0:35:15] the in the request but after consulting with the City Attorney it is not a [0:35:20] conflict of interest but I did want to make that part of the record. Thank you. [0:35:24] Okay, now, Ian. [0:35:27] Hey, Madam Mayor, City Council. [0:35:29] I'd like to see you, this is a request to amend the Federation Pointer CDA to allow private [0:35:36] and public schools as an outright permitted use and to amend the conceptual site plan in the zoning development agreement. [0:35:43] We have requested to amend the text which would change private and public schools from a special [0:35:55] use to be an appropriate use and to add a concept to a concept plan as an option for development. [0:36:07] The property was annexed into the city in 2001 with the zoning designation of residential mixed use [0:36:14] can in remote relay with the zoning development agreement. The preliminary plan for the property [0:36:19] was approved in 2021, and the file plot was just recently approved. 2016 comprehensive plan [0:36:28] grow with us that needs this area as a town neighborhood. The town neighborhood designation [0:36:33] is meant to provide for residential parks, facilities, schools, and civic facilities. [0:36:39] The application has two parts. Firstly, applicant is requesting to amend the text of [0:36:46] previously approved ZDA, and thanks to allow for that concept plan as an option. [0:36:54] As shown in the exhibits, option B specifically relates to the commercial portion of the Federation [0:37:01] Point ZDA and the layout of the building. [0:37:05] The concept plan would be in addition to the currently approved concept plan, [0:37:10] and if approved, it would not replace it, but it would be an option for the developer [0:37:16] to either develop the school or develop what was previously approved. [0:37:23] Staff anticipates that the greatest impact of the proposed use would be increased in vehicle [0:37:28] traffic. [0:37:29] At during school drop-offs and pickups and parking, the applicant anticipates several different [0:37:34] modes of transportation that will be used by those attending school, including Milwaukee, [0:37:39] buses, bicycling, and cars. [0:37:41] At the adjacent roadway will be constructed to its full required width, and the applicant [0:37:48] is working with the city's near department to ensure adequate striping on federation will [0:37:52] be installed for turn lanes into the school parking lot. [0:37:56] The applicant has shown the design of the school to contain drop-off and pick up loop-flood [0:38:01] traffic flow through the property to mitigate the anticipated traffic. [0:38:06] On this limit, traffic issues at the school site, however, there may be ancillary effects [0:38:11] on surrounding streets which may require mitigating infrastructure. Staff will use that. All other minimum and required improvements including parking will be adequate for this project and these improvements will be installed during the construction of the school. At the March 29th, 2022 planning and zoning commission meeting the commission recommended approval the request of five to zero. Upon conclusion, should the council prove the request as amended or excuse me? [0:38:41] shall prove their quest as presented. Staff recommends the following subject to site plan amendments as [0:38:47] required by building engineering, fire, and zoning officials to comply with all city codes and standards. [0:38:55] I'm just going to go with you and walk you through where this is located. This is a zoning map [0:39:01] already is located here, aligned here. This is the Federation Point ZEA. This is the future land use map [0:39:11] designating a town neighborhood here. This is the site plan, so this is a northern half [0:39:20] of the property. You have federation here to the north, and where federation turns into [0:39:26] Washington Street here, Washington Street. The applicant has shown turn lanes on federation, [0:39:32] a circulation proposal for the site when I pick up and drop off, sufficient stacking to show. [0:39:49] We can see here to present and answer any questions and I would be happy to answer any questions [0:39:58] as well. [0:40:00] Thank you Ian. [0:40:06] Move on to the applicant. [0:40:07] Then we can have questions for both of our members. [0:40:09] Do you want to have questions for Ian right now? [0:40:12] Yeah, this may be applicable for city staff or the applicant. [0:40:17] There was the question about school zones and guns and the thousand foot buffer and I didn't [0:40:24] I didn't see a direct answer from the planning and zoning meeting, but with the city, um, [0:40:31] the training was going to look into it, so. [0:40:33] Thank you, uh, council member color. We, we did look in, I did look into that. [0:40:38] Um, I don't believe that this property meets the definition of school zone as, uh, determined [0:40:43] by federal regulation, I purposely being a little vague, just so that I don't give the [0:40:47] illusion that everything they do there is legal, um, with regards to a school zone, [0:40:51] but I don't believe that's a barrier to this happening at that location. [0:40:58] I do have a question, so the site plan that's showing here, Ian, is slightly different than the one that's in the packet. [0:41:07] The packet shows one with a circular drop-off area, coming into one is the plan site plan. [0:41:16] This is the plan site plan, as the most recent updated site plan, showing this drop-off area for the school buses. [0:41:24] Are you familiar with the one I'm referring to in the packet that shows a circular drop-off? [0:41:30] Yes, and that's what they originally submitted, but as they've, uh, and they can answer more to this what they've changed now. [0:41:37] But this is the most dated site plan. [0:41:39] And then just one other question or process. [0:41:43] So this type of use proves ED. [0:41:50] Actually, it's likely to be what the process would have been for this as opposed to changing the special use. [0:41:59] If this was approved as a, as a, as a, they would go through the, um, the process of a [0:42:06] teeny, especially these permit, which would be an additional hearing for the planning [0:42:11] and zoning commission, the, their intent was that they were already going before the planning [0:42:16] and zoning commission and city council were approval to amend the text and to, to amend the [0:42:21] site plan. [0:42:22] And so they sought to amend the text at the same time to be able to get it done at once. [0:42:29] if they did not, they would have to do an additional year. [0:42:34] Thank you. [0:42:35] Any other questions for you? [0:42:57] Having you tonight, my name is Mariella Rosales. [0:42:59] I'm currently teaching third grade at Gem Prep, Pocatella, [0:43:02] but moving forward, I'll be the assistant principal [0:43:04] for Gem Prep to Unfalls. [0:43:06] So, hey, go ahead to the next one, thank you. [0:43:09] So we are a free K through 12 charter school. [0:43:12] We started online and then we moved on to brick and mortar [0:43:15] schools. [0:43:15] Our focus is college prep. [0:43:17] This seems like a really broad thing, [0:43:18] but we'll go into some detail here [0:43:20] just a few seconds. We serve all students interested in a rigorous college program so [0:43:26] we take students whether they have like special education services, we take all [0:43:31] students. So our school mission is to prepare students for success in college [0:43:38] by providing a high-quality personalized relevant and rigorous education through [0:43:42] exceptional teaching, innovative uses of technology, and partitions with family. [0:43:46] that's a long list of statements. [0:43:48] So as we break it down, [0:43:50] we strive to provide rigorous college [0:43:54] for all these students to prepare them [0:43:56] for life after high school. [0:43:57] So in college, [0:44:00] teaching them these different skills [0:44:01] that they are going to need for college, [0:44:03] and that includes partnerships with families. [0:44:06] We really arrive off of this parent support [0:44:09] in the classrooms and the school, [0:44:11] whether it's in the office or having parents [0:44:14] take home things for teachers. [0:44:16] we really could not do any of our work as teachers [0:44:20] without our partnerships with families. [0:44:23] So we started with our online school, [0:44:25] Gen Prep Online, formally known as Idaho Distance [0:44:28] Education Academy in 2004, and then we moved forward [0:44:31] with opening brick and mortar schools in 2014, I believe. [0:44:34] But Gen Prep will tell you being our first [0:44:36] brick and mortar school, and then from that point on, [0:44:39] we opened Gen Prep Nampa, Meridian, [0:44:41] and then most recently Meridian North this school year, [0:44:44] And then this upcoming school year, [0:44:47] Jeff Redberry in South, [0:44:48] we will open in grades kindergarten through fifth grade. [0:44:53] So we say college prep in elementary, [0:44:58] and that seems like a really broad thing to do, [0:45:00] but it really starts in kindergarten. [0:45:02] The, some of the things that we focus with college prep [0:45:05] is honing in on skills like time management, [0:45:09] communication skills, [0:45:11] and that's not communication skills, [0:45:12] but just like the student and the teacher, [0:45:14] communication skills with working with a partner, working in groups, working with [0:45:19] people that you do not like, which is a skill that we have to teach some of these [0:45:23] scholars as well. And so with the station rotation model it allows teachers to [0:45:28] really hone in on different groups and so one group may be ready for enrichment, [0:45:33] one group may need intervention, so they might need a little bit more support and [0:45:39] scaffolding to get them to that point where they are learning at their own level. [0:45:43] And so again, these competencies really prepare them for their life later on as the approach [0:45:50] like adulthood. [0:45:51] Thank you all for having us. [0:46:02] I'm going to pick up from Ariella left off. [0:46:04] My name is Adam Bruno. [0:46:05] I'm Assistant Principal at Gem Prep Meridian North and I'm part of the new school's academic [0:46:10] team. [0:46:11] So to pick up with our secondary model, this is what we really built on that college prep [0:46:14] model, started to know about my true. [0:46:16] And one of the great things that we offer our scholars is the fact that we're at the opportunity [0:46:20] in three different manners. [0:46:22] First of all, that traditional in-person learning [0:46:23] with amazing teachers for their core classes [0:46:26] of math, science, social studies, and ALA, [0:46:28] who we also offer the option for scholars [0:46:31] to take classes pseudo remotely. [0:46:33] So think about how Zoom was working [0:46:34] during the pandemic. [0:46:35] We were doing Zoom kind of before it was cool [0:46:37] where we maybe had a teacher already [0:46:39] in teaching a class in Pocatello [0:46:41] and just giving our scholars the chance [0:46:43] to learn different modalities [0:46:44] because that's the world that we live in for better [0:46:46] or for worse. [0:46:47] There's also fully online courses to be [0:46:49] out in this learning academy but again giving our scholars we hope to have [0:46:53] it to it falls here at the opportunity to learn in a whole lot of different [0:46:56] manners. A couple others think that are really important about Jim Prep. Ariela [0:47:01] talked about the different competencies of being a self-directed [0:47:04] collaborator independent learning we build on that to help our scholars prepare [0:47:08] for the world after high school and into college but one of the things you [0:47:12] really like to stake our claim on is giving scholars the opportunity to get [0:47:16] the college courses while they're already in high school. So our scholars as early as their [0:47:20] freshman year in high school start taking dual-credit classes because our goal is for every single one [0:47:25] of our scholars to graduate with at least 18 college credits in 60 percent of them to graduate [0:47:31] with an associate's degree which sets them up for life going forward, obtaining them time, [0:47:36] their family's money because we so strongly believe in this mission that we take the Idaho [0:47:41] Fast Forward funds to help our scholars use all those to take those college classes [0:47:45] But then Gem Prep will pick up the tabs, uh, to pick up the tab the rest of the ways [0:47:49] of those scholars will only pay for things like maybe books, other than that. [0:47:53] Gem Prep is paying for their, um, college credits while they're in high school. [0:47:57] And again, giving scholars just different ways to learn as well as giving them the coaching skills and the different life skills [0:48:01] to prepare them for life after high school. And again, one of the great things [0:48:07] about Gem Prep is that we are a smaller school, but our building is fully built out, [0:48:11] and I'll talk about that in just a moment. We will have all of our scholars skindergarten through 12th grade [0:48:15] in one building, which is phenomenal for families. [0:48:17] Mariela talked about those partnerships with families [0:48:20] because we truly love our families at Gem Prep, [0:48:23] but it's great for families to maybe have a kid [0:48:24] in kindergarten sixth grade and ninth grade. [0:48:26] That's one drop off at pick up every single day [0:48:28] as opposed to going to three different schools. [0:48:30] As well as giving scholars the opportunity [0:48:32] to get real life experiences with leadership [0:48:35] and helping younger scholars grow [0:48:36] and just giving younger kids the opportunity [0:48:38] to look up to their older peers. [0:48:43] And so we're really excited to come down [0:48:45] to Twin Falls as a Gem Prep community. [0:48:47] You guys all know better than me, Jim, [0:48:48] are Twin Falls one of the fastest [0:48:50] ground communities in Idaho. [0:48:52] And we're here to give the families of Twin Falls [0:48:54] just another option. [0:48:55] We know how great the schools are in Twin Falls. [0:48:57] Our goal is simply to come and give families [0:48:59] one other option with a college prep emphasis. [0:49:02] And that location on Federation Point Road [0:49:04] is so close to neighborhoods. [0:49:06] It's in a great location for families, scholars [0:49:08] who walk to school if they live in those neighborhoods, [0:49:10] as well as it's not too far of a drive [0:49:12] from family, some other neighborhoods. [0:49:13] And for our secondary scholars going [0:49:15] to take their college classes. [0:49:16] CSI is just right around the corner, [0:49:18] which is a great opportunity for them [0:49:20] to expand their horizons and take those college classes. [0:49:24] Since we've, over the last couple of weeks, [0:49:26] we've been really trying to increase our outreach [0:49:27] in the Twin Falls community. [0:49:29] We had an info session the night before we spoke [0:49:31] at the planning commission. [0:49:33] We had about 15, 20 families there. [0:49:35] We had some information sessions online [0:49:37] where we had families, as well as, [0:49:39] like, that's marketing in the community [0:49:41] around the Federation point location. [0:49:44] And since we actually spoke at the Twin Falls Planning and Zoning Commission, we've had an uptick in families interested as well as we had a couple of new stories about us that gave us the opportunity to spread the word and as I saw our potential enrollment increase with several families sending our interested [0:49:58] lists who are interested in potentially becoming a gem for up Twin Falls families. [0:50:01] Again, we talk about our school being a little bit smaller, we're full at K-12, it's only 574 students and the purpose of that is just to give our scholars and families the best chance to get to know their teachers and administrators. [0:50:14] Our administrators on our campus know every single scholar by name and other families, [0:50:18] and that just really helps build a strong community within our school, [0:50:22] building on the great community that is Twin Falls. And again, our goal is really to mimic [0:50:26] the Twin Falls School District demographics and get every scholar who wants the opportunity [0:50:30] for a high quality college prep education to get that a jet prep Twin Falls. [0:50:34] In order to get their work open up in 2023, [0:50:39] the 2024 school year was only about 208 students, and then we'll grow out over [0:50:43] time, so we won't be a full school of 574 scholars until about 2028, 2029, and that will also include our [0:50:51] building. We'll not be fully built out and turn it over to Dan Hendrickson in just a second to talk a little bit [0:50:56] about our building plan going forward, so I'm going to turn it over to Dan to talk about that. [0:51:00] Thanks, Marielle. My name is Dan Hendrickson and I'm an architect. I work with the Gem Prep [0:51:15] Organization, so I'm third school with them. I got to tell you, working on charter schools without a [0:51:20] I've done enough gas stations in my life to Inasha, so it's just an awesome thrill to be able to work with schools, especially schools that are of this quality. [0:51:32] So I get a chance to talk about the site plan and the building. [0:51:36] I'll try to take too much time since E&R gave us a quick little snapshot. [0:51:41] So it's a two-story school. [0:51:44] We've got a separate parent school bus access point, so maybe you want to point to those? [0:51:49] So that's the bus access. We actually, I think, get the max capacity to be four buses, so it's not a tremendous load on the streets. [0:52:00] There's the main entry for cars and vehicle drop off. We've got about 1,500 limial feet of vehicle drop off, which is equivalent to about 75 cars at a time, a few more than that, and then 108 parking spots in there. [0:52:15] The building is a two-story building throughout. [0:52:19] We do have a gym as part of our phase two program. [0:52:22] What do you see there? [0:52:29] The exterior of the building, again, two-story building. [0:52:33] This is our third building with the gym. [0:52:35] And so all the buildings look similar, not exact, [0:52:37] like each other, but they have a certain color scheme, [0:52:39] certain design, motifs that we've been using [0:52:42] on all their schools to give them a brand recognition. [0:52:45] And so the top left one, the PSU entered the site [0:52:50] basically that's the front door that you see there the two-story element and you [0:52:54] just kind of walk around and see the rest of the building. So again I'm here for [0:52:59] any questions that may be asked so thank you very much. So just to be clear so I [0:53:10] understand the applicant is the school or Epworth family holdings. The applicant is [0:53:20] Epworth family holdings who owns the property and they're currently working on a deal with [0:53:24] school I was applying for this change on their behalf so no one will be speaking [0:53:32] from headworth no okay so council any questions for the applicant or any [0:53:45] other questions for staff just read this is for staff just looking at the [0:53:56] the drawings presented, going back several years now, can you show me where the crosswalks [0:54:06] are to get across? That was a big issue. I have not seen that in any of the drawings, [0:54:14] and the fact that we are looking at a school now, a little bit of a, it's like to know [0:54:21] where we are looking at putting those, looks like I'm one of the, so came through in the [0:54:32] the final plant, the crosswalk was shown here at the corner, but a note stating that the [0:54:38] city engineer would decide on the final location of the crosswalk or crosswalks. I believe the [0:54:46] crosswalk, there will be a crosswalk located here. This site too on federations with the [0:54:52] city engineer has come up with. As the plant is developed and plants are constructed, there [0:54:58] will be a trail that's on the other side and that was part of the approval of the preliminary [0:55:04] and final plans. Sidewalk will exist here along the Eurasian as well. There'll be Sidewalk [0:55:13] that goes a whole length of, Dave, Dave can speak more. [0:55:20] Will we hear from you, Dave? Yes, David. [0:55:22] Pretty well. [0:55:23] We have had 1Hm engineers, 621 North College Road. So, Commissioner, Councilman Reed, we [0:55:29] worked with the city engineering staff to determine that location. There's going to be a crosswalk [0:55:35] here as dictated by Troy B. Tech, now city engineer. [0:55:39] And then there's another one along Federation [0:55:40] that's in was stating there so that there's [0:55:42] plenty of visibility. [0:55:44] We wanted to kind of stay away from the corner [0:55:45] so folks making that right hand turn or left hand turn [0:55:49] with their eight pillars on their vehicles [0:55:50] aren't etching folks in a blind spot. [0:55:52] So that was compliant with our approved construction plans [0:55:56] for the subdivision. [0:55:58] So it will be taken care of hopefully [0:56:00] in advance of these folks' construction [0:56:03] should they be approved here for this evening? [0:56:06] I think they did. [0:56:07] That's sufficiently your question. [0:56:08] They did. [0:56:08] Thank you. [0:56:10] Any other questions for staff or applicants? [0:56:14] Yes, Mayor. [0:56:14] Yes, Councillor. [0:56:16] I wanted to chew on this for a few minutes, [0:56:18] but I still am hung up on the gun issue. [0:56:21] And I have no concerns about the design of this. [0:56:25] But I'd hate to harm the gun club or the members [0:56:27] of the gun club by something we're just overlooking. [0:56:30] If you would change, please just elaborate a little bit more. [0:56:33] the definition of a school zone is listed in the federal code relative to guns being brought into the school zone. [0:56:41] I believe it's paragraph B in that same federal regulation that says what is excluded from the definition of school zone [0:56:49] and what is excluded is private property. [0:56:52] So for this exact reason you can't put a school in an area, so because the gun club itself is a private property, [0:56:59] They are excluded from worrying about being within a thousand feet. [0:57:05] This is if a school were built right next to your house, you wouldn't be expected to get rid of all the guns in your home because of that. [0:57:11] Yeah, I appreciate that you're trying to interpret something that's a thorny issue, but I do respect your opinions. [0:57:19] Thank you. [0:57:22] Any other questions for the applicant or staff? [0:57:25] Okay, having said I will officially open the public hearing if there's anybody here in attendance would like to comment, ask questions, bring up concerns, the voting jurors. [0:57:42] Seeing no one, I will close the public hearing, the public comment section. [0:57:53] So I assume there's no additional information you want to share, Jonathan. [0:57:58] Just bringing up the, we did receive the one letter and I know everybody received it, that was the public comment and writing that we received. [0:58:06] Oh yes, thank you. Anything else from staff? Okay, then the, like I say, the public hearing is officially closed, no further testimony or compliments. [0:58:21] Comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed. Okay, Council wishes. [0:58:26] I move that we approve the request to amend the Federation Point ZDA to allow private and public school as an outright permitted use and amend the conceptual site plan in the ZDA agreement on behalf of HEPA holdings. [0:58:51] Do I need to read that? [0:58:59] Thank you, motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Sean Berger to approve the amendment to [0:59:04] Federation Point's ZDA to allow private and public school and outrighted permitted use in [0:59:10] a monthly conceptual site plan in the ZDA agreement on behalf of the Hepworth family landhold aims. [0:59:17] Any other further discussion? [0:59:19] Yeah, just a comment I would make so I do appreciate that this provides a different option that [0:59:28] is necessarily in the pathway forward, correct? [0:59:30] It's just a variation to the ZDA, [0:59:33] but considering the input that we have on this initially, [0:59:37] a single use on the balance of that property [0:59:41] as opposed to the opportunity for multiple commercial uses [0:59:45] or professional uses may be a better fit in the neighborhood [0:59:49] and appreciate the applicant having a clear vision [0:59:55] for what they're bringing forward [0:59:57] and addressing some of the concerns that perhaps were raised at the Planning and Zoning Commission, [1:00:02] but I personally feel like it's a really decent fit in the neighborhood. [1:00:10] Thank you, Sean. Any further comments? [1:00:13] Aaron, roll call vote, please. [1:00:15] Craig Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. [1:00:21] Spencer Cutler? Yes. Mayor Pierce? Yes. Vice Mayor Reed? Yes. [1:00:27] Sean Baraker? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes. [1:00:30] Thank you, motion carries seven to zero. Thank you, everyone. Good evening. We're adjourned.