Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-08-23, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-08-23/ [0:00:06] August 23rd meeting of the Twin Falls City Council. [0:00:10] At this time I would like to call the meeting to order [0:00:12] and confirm that we do have a quorum. [0:00:14] We have five members in person this evening [0:00:17] and council members, Baragar and Reid, [0:00:20] are joining us via the telephone this evening. [0:00:24] You would like to join us at this time, [0:00:26] please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:00:53] Proclamations this evening, [0:00:54] so we will move forward with our consent calendar. [0:01:01] Make a motion that we approve the consent calendar. [0:01:05] second then we have a motion from Craig Hawkins seconded by Ruth Pierce to [0:01:10] approve the consent calendar as it is printed this evening be no one with [0:01:16] questions Amy roll call please. Thank you Boyd. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, yes. [0:01:33] Christopher Rea. Yeah. And Sean Barrieger. Yeah. [0:01:41] as the 7-0. If you were here this evening for the official naming of the Vicky Love Fiverr, [0:01:54] as I say it would be Bike Skills Park or the RIM to RIM event, those were just approved. [0:02:07] We will move on with our action items of consideration and the first this evening is a request to [0:02:14] to confirm the reappointment of Camille Barrigar [0:02:16] to the Public Art Commission. [0:02:19] Mill has served a one year term. [0:02:22] When we started that commission a year ago, [0:02:24] we staggered the term so we would not have a whole group [0:02:28] timing out at the same time. [0:02:31] Camille has shown an interest to serve [0:02:35] a full term on the commission [0:02:38] and she has had great attendance [0:02:40] and been a good member of that commission. [0:03:23] by the key board to confirm the reappointment of Camille Barrigar to the public art commission. [0:03:30] Any roll call please? [0:03:33] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:03:35] Yes. [0:03:36] Great Blanting? [0:03:37] Yes. [0:03:38] Ruth Pierce? [0:03:39] Yes. [0:03:40] Great Hawkins? [0:03:41] Yes. [0:03:42] Christopher Reed? [0:03:44] Yes. [0:03:47] Abstance? [0:03:52] Passes 6-0 with one abstention. [0:03:54] Would you please pass along our thanks to Camille? [0:03:58] Appreciate that. [0:04:00] Next item on our agenda this evening is a request for a nonconforming building expansion waiver to allow for an expansion on property located in 343 Martin Street. [0:04:14] And I do not see Elizabeth, but I see Jonathan's been love. Good evening. [0:04:21] There's less time, so I'm going to take over for her in this one. [0:04:28] Location is a 343 Martin Street, who we have an existing home. [0:04:44] Been there for quite some time. [0:04:46] Didn't review everything to know the dates, [0:04:48] but it's been at least a couple of decades. [0:04:50] She's going to sleep with that. [0:04:51] You can see in the aerial, there is a, what's it like, [0:04:57] a co-owners came, you know, if it was a detriment or they [0:05:06] could fall over anything, but it was just older. [0:05:07] They wanted to replace it. [0:05:09] They progressed with doing that. [0:05:11] It did come to us through a code enforcement type of thing. [0:05:14] There's an education on needing a building permit to add on to it. [0:05:18] Once you have that, we review the building permit to see if there's anything else from [0:05:23] a code perspective, because we enforce all of the codes and this happens to be a non-conforming [0:05:28] building. [0:05:29] The centerline setback on Martin is 62 feet, it comes to this point. [0:05:33] So close to half of it is in that centerline setback. [0:05:39] There's also this extension or the covered porch is closer than the 20 feet on the front [0:05:46] yard as well. [0:05:47] There's two setbacks, right, front yard setback from the front property line, and then we have this that additional like centerline setback on roads that we think we might need to expand in the future. That's where that centerline setback comes in. [0:05:58] This is what's existing today as a stance. They've had this portion demoed and they've started a little bit of construction. [0:06:07] That's where the enforcement and education piece came in to get a building permit to make sure it was safe. [0:06:12] They're asking to extend that covered porch to 7 feet and have it come up to this point. [0:06:22] I believe the idea was to get it covered while going to the not to extend this point beyond [0:06:28] what was existing. [0:06:29] They would just take that line because that staff's recommendation down to see if there's [0:06:48] any questions for Jonathan on this. [0:06:54] Dispositing an extra long second since we have two members on the phone this evening. [0:07:03] before this, I'm going to be clear on what we're doing, so what the council action is, is to prove the waiver for the non-conforming billing expansion. [0:07:13] The waiver allows for the applicant to not go through the normal public hearing process, which is about a 42, a six, seven-week process. [0:07:24] This allows, it's only allowed for residential properties. The council only does have a residential only. [0:07:30] So that's kind of like a short cut sort of for people's homes when they have situations like this. [0:07:35] Great. Thank you. [0:07:37] If you're here, anyone else, Ruth Pierce? I'm ready to make a motion. Please. May I move? [0:07:52] We honor the request of a waiver of the nonconforming building expansion to allow for expansion on [0:07:59] property located at 343 Maines or Martin Street. We have a motion for Ruth Pierce, seconded by [0:08:12] and keep Boyd to approve the request for the non-conforming building expansion waiver. [0:08:19] Greg, did you have something? Amy, we'll call the police. [0:08:24] Craig Hawkins? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes. [0:08:31] On Baraker? Yes. [0:08:35] Keep Boyd? Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes. [0:08:40] And Ruth Pierce? Yes. Ocean passes 7-0. Next is a request for declaring a sole source resolution [0:08:50] for axon enterprise incorporated for body worn cameras and looks like we have [0:08:57] Captain Matt Hicks this evening if you haven't seen that video you are missing [0:09:10] out I will not be doing that for you tonight but I do have show and tell I do [0:09:14] have a body camera coming around so you can see how small this device is and how [0:09:18] complicated this issue we're here tonight to discuss our request to the city [0:09:23] Council to consider declaring a sole source resolution to award acts on [0:09:27] enterprises a five-year contract or a body-worn camera program in the amount [0:09:32] of $484,320. Our presentation will take about ten minutes. In 2015 at the [0:09:39] direction of the City Council, our department began a year-long process of [0:09:43] researching the feasibility of launching a body-worn camera program. In [0:09:47] September of that year, our project team was established and they began conducting [0:09:51] research in the policy development, community outreach, and testing evaluation of different [0:09:56] body-worn camera systems. [0:09:58] Through their work, the project came identified some very specific technical requirements, needed [0:10:02] in a body-worn camera system to meet the provisions of our policy, the best practices [0:10:07] of our profession, lessons learned from other departments, and the safety and ease of use [0:10:13] by our police officers, employees, and prosecutors. [0:10:15] Not to bore you, but some of the most important specific specifications included. [0:10:22] Hardware must be comprised of a body worn camera with no audio or wire and tabs protruding [0:10:27] off the camera. [0:10:28] Must have at least a 12 hour battery life. [0:10:31] Must have auto turns to the user and if you want to go ahead and turn it on, you can [0:10:36] do a police report. [0:10:37] It must have at least a 30 second buffering of pre-recorded footage. [0:10:48] You may remember that our cameras are always recording, and when the officer activates it, it actually captures 30 seconds before they push the button. [0:10:56] It must have multiple docking bay stations as we have multiple employees and locations that we serve. [0:11:02] We must have an automated video, camera, activation solution. [0:11:05] Our cameras automatically activate when our sirens and lights come on our police cars. [0:11:10] We must be able to automate the tagging of the video or metadata from our computer-aided dispatch system. [0:11:16] We must have a host data management system and an unlimited data storage. [0:11:21] We must be able to seamlessly share information and data with prosecutors, officers, other law enforcement personnel, and other criminal entities, and we must be able to search and secure and auto-blog to track all changes in use of the system. [0:11:35] In 2016, after a competitive sealed-bit process, TASER International, which is now axon, was awarded the bid to provide body-worn cameras and infrastructure. [0:11:47] as well as digital evidence storage and management software to the Twin Falls Police Department. [0:11:52] We began at that time a phased approach to implement our body-on-camera and we have been active for five years now. [0:11:57] Axon provides us with a website evidence.com that provides unlimited storage and management solutions of our data [0:12:09] and provides access to the City and County Prosecutor's Office [0:12:12] and gives them the ability to retrieve digital evidence for judicial proceedings. [0:12:17] It also allows us to store and secure digital evidence and compliance with best practices [0:12:23] as well as state rules of evidence. [0:12:25] Since starting our program in 2016, our organization has recorded almost 59 terabytes of data. [0:12:33] Record on average about 1.72 terabytes per month and to date we have captured over 139,000 [0:12:40] video files, which equates to over 33,000 hours of video, over 161,000 images, and over [0:12:49] 3,000 audio files. Our initial five-year contract with Axon expires next month in order to ensure [0:12:56] an interrupted service, but then we need to sign a new contract. Tonight we're asking for [0:13:02] the City Council to consider declaring a sole-source resolution, Idaho Code 67-2808, subsection 2, [0:13:10] To permit sole source expenditures or the compatibility of equipment components, computer software, replacement parts of service, is a paramount consideration. [0:13:20] It also permits sole source expenditures or competitive solicitations in practical or unreasonable under the circumstances. [0:13:30] We have conferred with the city attorney and only believe our proposal and might meet these requirements. [0:13:35] The city's body-worn-camera programs, equipment, replacement training, and software was built [0:13:41] solely around the use of axons equipment and software. [0:13:43] We believe that a competitive solicitation at this point would be impractical, given the [0:13:49] substantial training and capital investment that the city has made in axon equipment and [0:13:54] the significant cost associated with moving our entire program to a new product. [0:13:58] This would involve removing nearly 70 terabytes of data from the axon servers within 30 days [0:14:04] and hoping that five years worth of video and pictures would transfer me compatible to a new system. [0:14:10] Finally, we think that Axon is still the only vendor that would able to meet our precise requirements. [0:14:17] Our experience and research over the past five years was less to believe that given that Axon was the only vendor [0:14:22] that met our specifications in 2016, they are still the only one that can meet those requirements. [0:14:29] A draft copy of the resolution was attached to your packet and we can have it shown again if needed. [0:14:37] The renewal of the Axon Enterprise contract will cost $96,864 per year for five years. [0:14:44] The first-year payment has been budgeted out of the Police Department's patrol operating [0:14:47] line for the next budget year. [0:14:50] In summary, we've been asked that the Council consider declaring a sole-source resolution [0:14:54] for Axon Enterprise as for a five-year contract renewal of her body-worn-camera program, the [0:14:59] amount of $484,320. [0:15:02] And I will stand for any questions you might have. [0:15:07] Hopkins. Maybe you just expand a little bit more. I didn't hear a lot about maintenance, but that's [0:15:15] included in this package. The other thing is how they held up the last five years. So part of [0:15:21] the built-in contract that we had the first time in his part of the second contract is that they [0:15:25] replace the hardware at years two and years five. So the camera that you're passing around to us [0:15:32] is now a replacement camera. They will be updating that again here. We'll be getting their more [0:15:38] recent version but they update all of the docking stations that we use in the [0:15:42] hardware on two-year intervals and they've held it very well in the few occasions [0:15:46] we've had equipment break, axon has been great to work with and they should [0:15:50] place that within days. [0:15:56] I've started the conversation whether or not we should go down the road with [0:16:00] bodyboard cameras and it was a very thorough very long process to get to that [0:16:06] point in 2016 that your team and staff and the IT department and the council did a lot [0:16:14] of digging and research and soul searching to make sure that we were doing this in a thorough [0:16:19] and accurate way. The videos back then that showed how different angles of cameras could [0:16:27] change a perception on what was actually happy with. [0:16:37] We don't want to take a step backwards. We hope that you're happy with the way the programs [0:16:40] Our prosecutors are over clients and the community is happy with it and we would ask them to continue. [0:16:52] Questions or comments? [0:16:53] I'm going to stand for a motion. [0:17:01] The motion that the sole source resolution for acts on enterprises for body one cameras, [0:17:21] the fighter contract renewal is 4,480,4,320. [0:17:26] We have a motion from Craig Hawkins, seconded by Sean Barriger to approve the request for declaring [0:17:45] a sole-source resolution for the axon enterprise-incorporated body-worn [0:17:50] cameras and authorizing the mayor to sign crank a B roll call vote Christopher [0:18:02] Reid yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes motion passes 7 to 0 thank you very much [0:18:19] we'll have those documents I've seen me before we leave next on our agenda is a [0:18:28] request to award a contract to merit professional coding for the wastewater [0:18:33] treatment plant digester lining replacement project and we have Troy [0:18:38] B. Tech, our assistant city engineer this evening. Welcome. [0:18:42] Thank you Mayor, Council members. Tonight I'll come before you for a merit coding [0:18:50] previously, but if the wastewater treatment lands is digester down the [0:19:07] process, this charges to the really herb stuff, well this is a pretty harsh [0:19:21] Thank you for explaining that price variance, because that was my question coming into this. [0:21:44] When I saw that I thought I would really get the job done, the privacy of prices, it was [0:21:54] a little shocking. [0:21:55] I was surprised to see the large variance. [0:21:57] I figured we'd have a couple of bits and they'd be a little closer together. [0:22:02] It was quite a bit. [0:22:04] And so when I asked Jacob's why is this happening, they said, well, that's where is anybody else? [0:22:33] I move we award the contract to merit professional coatings for the wastewater. [0:22:38] treatment plant digester lining replacement project for a total of $379,079,766, which includes the 10% contingency. [0:22:51] We have a motion from Ruth Pierce, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the request to award the contract to merit professional coding for the wastewater treatment plant digester lining replacement project. [0:23:09] and the questions. Roll call vote please. Great landing. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Mr. Fareed. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you, Troy. Next on our agenda is a presentation and it is a presentation of the Twin Falls Police Department's 2020 annual report and we have our chief of police, Craig Kingsbury this evening. [0:23:50] Thank you Mayor, Council, and just like Captain Hicks, I am not going to be trying to do this [0:23:59] with us to introduce you tonight, Mayor, but that was very impressive. [0:24:02] You know, it was, so for those of you who are wondering, last Thursday night was the Rock [0:24:07] Paper Scissors competition here at the Downtown Commons, and I guess I wasn't fully prepared [0:24:14] that you have to have some kind of a welcoming presentation as you go out on stage, and so [0:24:20] Officer Hayes was very gracious to go up and do a nice little dance and a full-out jump splits in complete [0:24:28] Uniform and just wow the crowd and so if you get a chance to fuck Facebook and check out that video. It's pretty impressive [0:24:36] It was very impressive and that just leads to the skill set that we have [0:24:42] And the organization here at the city [0:24:52] But Mayor Council, this is a topic. [0:25:05] I know we have a public area section, [0:25:08] I could talk for hours about the TFPD. [0:25:11] I love this organization. [0:25:12] I have so much pride in the men and women that work for us [0:25:17] in the city as a whole, [0:25:18] but obviously within the police department. [0:25:20] So I just want to take a little bit of time [0:25:22] to go over our 2020 annual report with you [0:25:25] and for the citizens. [0:25:26] I would say I'm going to be putting the report up [0:25:29] on these screens and go through a PowerPoint, [0:25:32] but we do have hard copies of our annual report, [0:25:34] which Mayor and Council, you all have. [0:25:36] We have some, any citizens in the audience [0:25:38] that would like some officer O'Donnell up there [0:25:40] in the corner, has somebody can hand out, [0:25:42] so if anybody would like one of these. [0:25:43] And I will also say that this will be placed [0:25:45] onto our website. [0:25:47] So citizens can view this on our website as well. [0:25:50] So everybody can have access to the 2020 annual report. [0:25:55] One question that people might be wondering [0:25:57] is well, it's August 23rd. [0:25:59] Why are we just now doing the 2020 annual report? [0:26:02] Well, part of the reason that we wait so long, [0:26:05] and I know Council Mayor, you're aware of this [0:26:07] before our community, we wait to do an annual report [0:26:10] after the state of Idaho releases the statewide crime [0:26:14] numbers, the crime in Idaho data. [0:26:17] So we're gonna discuss some of the crime statistics [0:26:20] as they're released specifically to the city of Twin Falls. [0:26:23] Those can be found in this report. [0:26:25] And if any citizen would be interested, [0:26:28] could go to the Idaho State Police website and click on the crime in Idaho [0:26:32] tab right on the front page of their website and look at the data for any [0:26:37] municipality in the county within the state of Idaho and the state as a whole. [0:26:43] And I think I would start off by saying as we all know Idaho is a very safe state. [0:26:49] Bily crime in Idaho is a relatively rare occurrence and our long-sportioned [0:26:56] professionals in this state and our partners do a very good job of solving [0:27:01] violent crime if the one that does occur as well as preventing violent crime in many aspects. [0:27:06] So here's our annual report and this is the the front page which is on the screen. [0:27:14] Start by talking about our staffing current in 2020 excuse me we'll talk in 2020 [0:27:21] numbers and I will at the end go a little bit into some year to date for 2021 as [0:27:26] well and please mayor council if you have any questions um you know I can talk a lot so just just [0:27:32] paul around me or something please uh we currently are allocated for 77 sworn officers that was our [0:27:38] allocation in in uh 2020 that is the current allocation in 2021 we do have 20 civilian employees [0:27:46] such as uh our community service officers officers who operate in a crime lab they take street CSOs [0:27:55] and we have a committee service officer that works the front counter in our reception area, [0:27:59] so that includes records as well. In 2020, we hired five police officers and three civilian [0:28:09] employees. Of those eight, six still are working for the city of Twin Falls, [0:28:14] least one. Three are working as officers, two are working in records, and one is the executive [0:28:21] this isn't in my office. Now you see up here on the document we list our [0:28:28] retirements for 2020. It's always fun to hire new officers and get them going but [0:28:33] of course we all hope that officers and all employees especially Idaho get the [0:28:38] chance to retire after a great few decades of service and then collect their [0:28:43] per seat retirement checks and then three employees that did that in 2020. In our [0:28:48] records division. We had Elizabeth Davis and Janie Jones. So Beth and Janie retired. They [0:28:53] retired basically two weeks apart. They had served for the city. Beth had 22 years. Janie [0:29:00] had 21 years. Great employees. They retired in the summer of 2020. We miss them. They do [0:29:07] occasionally stop by. So, so part of our family in that regard. And then Captain Anthony Barnhark, [0:29:13] If you don't follow him on Instagram, you're missing out because he's a great follow on Instagram now as a retired guy. [0:29:21] He retired last December after 25 years of service with the city in Twin Falls. [0:29:27] So we did have those three retired ones as well. [0:29:30] If you open up into the page, you'll see the crime statistics and I know it's hard to see up here. [0:29:37] I just want to point out to Mayor Counsel and to our citizens, one of the things is the police [0:29:44] chief that I look at, I look at the five year trends because to me it's all about what are [0:29:49] the trends, are we seeing anything that isn't a normal, anything that jumps out to me as [0:29:54] a police chief to our community. [0:29:57] And really what you see in the five year trends is that year 2017 was kind of an anomaly. [0:30:03] I'm not really sure why both our arrest numbers [0:30:06] and our crime numbers were a little bit higher in that year. [0:30:10] But I think if you look at the graph that is included [0:30:12] and you can see it up here, [0:30:14] our numbers stay pretty steady, right? [0:30:17] Now 2020, as we'll talk about the minute, [0:30:19] as we all know, was the year of COVID. [0:30:22] We did make some operational changes [0:30:25] in the way that we were policing due to COVID. [0:30:29] We asked our officers to not have [0:30:32] as many traffic stop contacts and that sort of thing, [0:30:35] just as in an effort to try to keep them safe [0:30:38] and to keep the community safe. [0:30:40] Well, we were still, of course, responding [0:30:42] to calls for service and such, [0:30:44] but we did ask to be a little bit more, [0:30:46] I use a little more discretion in their contacts. [0:30:49] So while I look at this, I see that our arrests were down [0:30:51] a little bit, we had 2014 arrests in the year 2020, [0:30:55] but that's down about 200 arrests from the previous year. [0:31:00] Any questions on the crime stats, and I would also point out the clearance, percent clear, [0:31:07] 45.71% of all police reports that were filed, criminal reports filed with the DFPD were clear. [0:31:13] And that means we either arrested a perpetrator, charged him or her criminally with the crime, [0:31:18] or that it was cleared by an exception. [0:31:21] Maybe the prosecutor for some reason decided not to continue with the prosecution [0:31:27] the victims' wishes or something on those lines, but those were cases where we adequately [0:31:32] identified a suspect and were able to bring a resolution, so 45% of everything filed with [0:31:38] the police department, you know, in major leagues, a 450 batting average would get you [0:31:42] in the hall of fame any day. So, you know, I'll take that. Any questions about crime stats? [0:31:47] I also would say if anything comes up, counsel, even for the community members, you can always [0:31:52] email me or call me as you're looking through this, and I would be more than happy to answer [0:31:56] of course COVID. COVID did like all departments in the world did alter a little bit about [0:32:06] how we did business at the TFPD. You can see in our insert we have, you can see in the insert [0:32:14] we have some photographs there. Sanitation became very, very big part of our daily operation. [0:32:21] We had some great partners here both within the city also some of our businesses such [0:32:26] to serve pro who were able to come out and sanitize our vehicles if we had somebody that we would [0:32:33] maybe put in the back seat of the vehicle that exhibited symptoms are quite often what we saw [0:32:39] at the beginning when people claiming that they had COVID in an effort to maybe not go to jail. [0:32:45] But I would tell you that our great county sheriff Tom Carter and his staff there at the Twin Falls [0:32:51] County Jail they had that figured out and they had a separate wing and they were testing those people [0:32:56] So it did not detour us from taking people who needed to be incarcerated to Sheriff Carter's facility. [0:33:03] As you can see, as we all still kind of coming through, [0:33:06] Mass Square, a big part of our daily attire during COVID. [0:33:14] In 2020, the City of Twin Falls Police Department handled more than 53,000 calls for service. [0:33:20] Now, you think about that 365 days, 77 police officers, 53,000 separate calls for service [0:33:30] that were handled by the police department over to the right up on the screen in our report. [0:33:41] You can see the types of calls. [0:33:44] So the biggest type of call that we handle, a 911 drop-off, what is that? [0:33:49] a call comes into our communications center, 9-1-1 call comes in, and then the dispatcher, [0:33:54] the emergency communication officer, loses contact with the phone caller. Maybe the call [0:33:59] gets hung up. Maybe they have an open line. I will tell you that probably eight out of ten times [0:34:06] turns out to be something innocuous, a child playing with a phone, a mistyle, you know, [0:34:11] that sort of a thing. But every once in a while, what we find is that those are, [0:34:15] And the reason we still continue to respond to those is once one of those becomes something [0:34:20] a lot more serious. [0:34:22] Sometimes what we have, maybe domestic violence scenarios and a victim of an intimate partner [0:34:27] violence, me is her only option, maybe to dial 911 and leave the line open. [0:34:34] And so they're not able to give any information to our emergency communication officers, but [0:34:39] because that call has been made and our professionals in our communications center get the data to [0:34:45] show us where they're at and then we will dispatch officers to check on them [0:34:49] and every once in a while it does turn out to be some sort of criminal action [0:34:54] that we respond to. We do a lot of welfare checks, you know a welfare check [0:35:00] can be something somebody calling in because they have a family member or a [0:35:04] loved one that they're concerned for their mental health or maybe they just [0:35:07] have a you know have a relative that lives here and they live a distance away [0:35:11] and they have contact with that person, so when they call, we're going to send an officer [0:35:16] out to that house to check on that person, you know, make sure that if it's, especially [0:35:20] if we have oftentimes these children of elderly parents calling, so you know I have heard from [0:35:24] my mom, I have heard from my dad in five days, we'll go out there and make sure that they're [0:35:29] okay, and then make sure that we notify the, uh, the party who called us. We can go all [0:35:35] the way down through here. One of the things that, um, we continue to work really hard on [0:35:40] And the Twin Falls Police Department is our response [0:35:43] and investigation of intimate partner violence. [0:35:46] And if you look at domestic calls in 2019, [0:35:49] we responded to 250. [0:35:51] And we talked earlier about COVID and how we, [0:35:55] our numbers were down a little bit, [0:35:56] but we still responded, [0:35:57] increase in domestic violence types calls, [0:35:59] 329 of those types of calls. [0:36:03] Any questions on calls for service [0:36:05] or the things that you're meant to be at your handling? [0:36:08] Okay. [0:36:09] question on what you have here but just curious is this like a predefined list of [0:36:15] what you track or is that like I would be curious on calls you get on firework [0:36:21] complaints just for curiosity sake. Mayor that is a great question I actually do [0:36:28] track that I can actually get you that number for the call calls that we had [0:36:32] over the period of Fourth of July time I think I tracked it from July 1 until July [0:36:38] I worked most of those days on patrol and it was quite a few. [0:36:46] I would think so. [0:36:47] It was. [0:36:48] Yes. [0:36:49] Any other questions on calls for service? [0:36:50] Now I'm going to talk about the Office of Professional Standards. [0:36:53] The Office of Professional Standards. [0:36:56] If I can go, yeah, right there. [0:36:58] A little blurb. [0:37:00] That is made up of two of our employees. [0:37:05] Currently headed up by Lieutenant Terry Lewis. [0:37:08] and with Staff Sergeant Ron Fustis under the direction of Captain Matt Hicks and this is [0:37:15] an office that we started in 2016 and really it's too full. [0:37:21] Number one, they are in charge of making sure our officers have the right training and then [0:37:27] number two, they're also in charge of making sure our officers are conducting themselves [0:37:31] in the professional and employees, not just officers but our employees within the PD are [0:37:35] conducting themselves in the professional manner that we demand. So as we said earlier, [0:37:42] we had about 53,000 calls for service and we arrested 2014 people, those were physical [0:37:49] arrests in 2014. We tracked every use of force that a police officer utilizes during his or [0:37:58] her time with the TFPD. A use of force can be something as simple as an officer may be [0:38:04] putting somebody into a control hold, [0:38:07] having to take them to the ground [0:38:08] to effectuate an arrest or something like that, [0:38:11] to obviously as serious as a use of something like [0:38:14] a police canine or utilizing a service weapon. [0:38:18] So in 2020, 214 physical arrests, [0:38:24] 14 vehicle pursuits in that year. [0:38:27] We had 90 incidents that had applications of force. [0:38:32] There was 215 total applications of force, and so what that means is, in some instances, [0:38:40] if an officer was trying one technique or tool to take somebody into custody and that technique [0:38:47] or tool was not working, he or she then transitioned to another technique or tool, or maybe two [0:38:52] officers were involved in that scenario, so that would be two uses of force in that particular [0:38:58] scenario. [0:38:59] We think as far as us for being transparent, it's important that we have this data available for our public to see. [0:39:07] You can see that the most common use of force was a simple takedown technique. [0:39:15] That's zero K9 deployments. [0:39:19] Oftentimes with our police K9, I think we'll gosh, if we have the K9s but we don't deploy them, what are they doing? [0:39:27] Well, they're a very good deterrent and when somebody maybe is informed they don't give [0:39:34] up that a canine may be released if it's a proper scenario, oftentimes then the people [0:39:40] surrender peacefully and we don't actually have a canine deployment, but it was a very [0:39:44] effective scenario to get the arrest and get everybody safe. [0:39:49] Any questions about use of force? [0:39:50] I know at the national level it's a, you know, we just approved, you counsel just approved [0:39:55] our body-worn contract for another five years. Obviously we utilize that video to [0:40:00] help us to review the use of the force. It goes with our transparency and being a [0:40:05] transparent police department. Any questions on any of those? So I have a quick [0:40:11] question. Even though it appears obvious, what is this? Great, great question. And [0:40:18] there Council person appears to submit the technique is just like it sounds. It [0:40:23] It is a hood that is placed over somebody's head when they're trying to spin. [0:40:28] The top portion is mesh so that they still can see and all that. [0:40:33] But there is a, almost like a mass that we would wear that covers their face and [0:40:39] nose to try to prevent them from spitting on people. [0:40:42] But it sounded like, thank you. [0:40:44] You're very welcome. [0:40:46] Any other questions or I can go in more depth if you would like? [0:40:49] I would say another important part of the Office of Professional Standards is [0:40:53] investigating complaints. Complaints need to come in from citizens or complaints that [0:40:58] may be supervisors' rights. And you can see that in 2020, we had 14 complaints [0:41:04] investigated by the Office of Professional Standards. Of those 14 complaints, 13 were sustained. [0:41:11] Sustaining means that the Office of Professional Standards and the Police Administration found [0:41:18] that a policy was violated in 13 of those complaints. [0:41:23] Generally speaking, that might be something [0:41:26] that may result in coaching or teaching for an officer. [0:41:30] There could be some more significant ones, obviously, [0:41:32] if they're very significant, they could result [0:41:34] in an officer maybe no longer being employed [0:41:36] or employed no longer being employed. [0:41:38] And I think this also shows that we have great people, [0:41:43] but we work really hard to maintain those high standards [0:41:46] that this community demands. [0:41:49] Any questions about Office of Professional Standards? [0:41:51] I do have a question about the Narcan deployments. [0:41:55] I see we had nine doing here in 2020. [0:41:57] How does that compare to previous years, do you know? [0:42:00] Yes, Mayor, I do. [0:42:01] Thank you, great question. [0:42:03] Yes, we had nine Narcan deployments [0:42:05] in the calendar year 2020. [0:42:08] We'll skip ahead a little bit when I talk about 2021, [0:42:11] as far as this year we have 13 in year to date. [0:42:14] So that's January to today. [0:42:16] In 2019, we started utilizing our tan. [0:42:22] I want to say I'm gonna look back to my staff [0:42:23] here about February or March of 19th. [0:42:25] I'm looking at Captain Wright, yes. [0:42:27] And I think back then we had about nine or 10 [0:42:29] and we went back here again, give or take. [0:42:31] So that was the first year we started using it. [0:42:33] And I also would say that our fire department carries [0:42:35] it as well, so they're utilizing it, of course, [0:42:37] as well as our Magic Valley paramedics. [0:42:40] It's no secret, opioids are really a major problem [0:42:45] a major problem for our community right now, not just our community, for many communities [0:42:49] across this nation. [0:42:51] And what we are seeing, quite honestly, is that now, you know, a couple of years ago if [0:42:57] I were up here speaking to you there and counseling to this community, I would have told you that [0:43:02] we were seeing a lot of prescribed opioids, opioids that people were abusing and or that [0:43:09] maybe young people were stealing from their parents or grandparents and using in that method. [0:43:14] That is not transition because what we saw happen a few years ago, those actually became harder to obtain and then heroin became a little less expensive and readily available. [0:43:27] And people were using, we arrested literally soccer moms, or possessing heroin to high school students. [0:43:36] Now, we have transitioned and what we see are these, they're basically a counterfeit oxy [0:43:42] type pill that they're referred to on the street as Mexican blues or Mexican oxy and [0:43:48] they come out of labs, out of Mexico, their blue pill made to look like a opioid pill, but [0:43:57] instead they contain fentanyl, which is a very potent opioid. [0:44:02] And what we are seeing these different saves from Narcan in the last several months generally [0:44:10] it's a result of a fentanyl overdose. [0:44:13] I hope that answered your question. [0:44:16] I would also say that last year thanks to Council and City Manager we were able to make [0:44:28] a few capital purchases obviously. [0:44:31] We purchased two hybrid police vehicles. [0:44:34] their Ford interceptor vehicle similar to a Ford SUV with our Ford SUV, but their hybrid [0:44:40] and we deployed those about 13 months ago and I'm happy to report that they're functioning [0:44:45] very well in our fleet and we recently took possession of two more hybrids for under the [0:44:52] 20-21 budget so they haven't really been deployed yet they're getting prepared by Norma's team [0:44:57] at the city shop so we think we will see a decrease in cost for fuel which right now [0:45:05] that's the big deal and as well as decrease in our maintenance costs because [0:45:10] of those hybrids they seem to be working very well that the biggest complaint I [0:45:14] heard I hear from them about them from the officers and I can attest I driven one [0:45:19] from time to time is you go to get in it is actually on it you try to start it [0:45:23] again because you forgot that it's running as you've been sitting there for a little bit because it's so quiet. [0:45:28] So we also purchased last year a forensic service van you can see in the photograph here. [0:45:34] So our crime scene unit was in desperate need of a new vehicle. [0:45:38] And so you can see our three of our crime scene technicians standing out in front of this Ford crime scene van that they've been utilizing it as a great storage area. [0:45:49] Plus, they don't have to jump-started every time they go to start it, so very happy with that van. [0:45:55] Any questions about 2020? I'm moving to 21 just a little bit to get you up to date on where we're at. [0:46:02] Like I said earlier, we have purchased two more hybrid police vehicles. Those are getting ready to roll out in our fleet soon. [0:46:09] Now, code enforcement also became a part of the police department in 2021. So I owe Shawn's back here. [0:46:16] Everybody knows our great code enforcement supervisor, Sean Stanley, [0:46:19] and he and his team were integrated into the police department. [0:46:23] And, you know, primarily it didn't change anything and how they operated [0:46:28] because Sean and his team did such a great job. [0:46:31] But it allowed them access through some criminal justice information [0:46:35] that they couldn't have unless they were under the police department umbrella. [0:46:38] So it really was just kind of a move to allow them that access [0:46:42] and make their jobs easier by bringing the code enforcement team [0:46:46] enforcement team into the police department. [0:46:48] We increased our staff by six. [0:46:51] Well, Sean and his staff now currently has one opening [0:46:54] for code enforcement. [0:46:55] And I know he also has another code enforcement officer [0:46:58] that started three weeks ago, Sean, before, [0:47:02] or next week. [0:47:03] All right, I've got to head myself there. [0:47:04] So we have her ready to start. [0:47:09] 2021, three weeks ago, four weeks ago tomorrow, [0:47:13] we went live with Central Square, [0:47:15] our records management system, [0:47:16] computer data dispatch system. That was a purchase that was approved by this [0:47:21] council a couple of years ago. If you may recall, we went out to a request for [0:47:25] proposal through many vendors came down to a couple of vendors after a year [0:47:31] process. We selected Central Square. Shout out to Kathy Marcus and our IT staff. [0:47:37] They have been wonderful in helping us with this transition and leading the [0:47:42] transition. I helped with leading this transition. Her team has just been amazing. [0:47:46] Of course, our city attorney is his office very involved in the negotiations with Central [0:47:52] Square about four weeks ago, tomorrow at 04 a.m. [0:47:56] We flip the switch and we won't lie. [0:48:00] You might say, well, is it really smooth? [0:48:03] Not quite, but it's getting there. [0:48:04] It is a lot better product than what we used to have. [0:48:08] And we're pretty excited about the capabilities that Central Square will have for the listening [0:48:14] public. [0:48:15] You know, this was a very just just under $1.5 million purchase. So we are moving forward with that and [0:48:22] Great, please with where we're at [0:48:24] in [0:48:26] 2021 [0:48:27] So far we've had two retirements back in March lieutenant John Wilson retired and it's no secret Lieutenant Wilson is battling pancreatic cancer [0:48:37] We did a tribute to him in our in our [0:48:41] report here [0:48:43] Lieutenant Wilson served with the TFPD for over 20 years and served totally I believe 36 years as a law enforcement officer. [0:48:50] He continues his fight today. One of the things I wanted to point out, he left us with a quote that he asked that the officers remember as they go about their business. [0:49:01] And I think it really holds true to what we try to get all of our employees to do. [0:49:06] Be safe, be professional, and be compassionate. [0:49:10] So, John Wilson is continuing his fight in retirement. [0:49:16] Also, Officer Matt Triner retired here after 20 years with the TFPD 18 years as a School [0:49:22] Resource Officer. [0:49:23] I know many of you know Officer Triner and so he is enjoying his retirement. [0:49:27] With that said, we have upcoming four other retirements that I expected to take place by [0:49:35] the end of January. [0:49:36] I tell you that as we talk about staffing with those six retirements that will have taken place in about a 13 to 14 [0:49:45] month period, we of course have to [0:49:49] hire somebody to replace those people. In [0:49:54] 2021 thus far, we have hired five police officers. We have hired three code enforcement officers [0:50:01] and of those three [0:50:04] one is still working with us. [0:50:06] The good news right now is we currently have only three open police officer positions [0:50:13] So respecting for more retirements. We have three open police officer positions [0:50:17] We're not really in dire straits. I see a lot of news reports about agencies in Idaho that are [0:50:23] At staffing crisis levels [0:50:26] Happy to report to you and I think if she's not gonna [0:50:29] We have a young department [0:50:34] We're hiring we have three officers that started the [0:50:36] the CSI law enforcement program today. [0:50:40] We have three officers going through that program right now. [0:50:43] They will graduate this December [0:50:45] and then they will start their field training program. [0:50:48] Well, as you also are aware, [0:50:49] we have applied for a grant through the justice assistance [0:50:55] to hire four officers. [0:50:57] So if we were to receive that grant [0:50:59] and we look at the three openings that we have [0:51:02] and we're looking for, you know, [0:51:03] so eight, nine, 10, 11 openings that we may end up having [0:51:07] to try to hire as we move forward into 2021. [0:51:11] I'm here to tell you that our team is ready for that. [0:51:13] We're preparing for that. [0:51:14] And I think we're doing a great job in recruiting [0:51:18] and hiring, but also throw out for the public. [0:51:20] If you know anybody that's interested in a law enforcement [0:51:22] career, TFPD's hiring is a great place to work. [0:51:25] So look us up. [0:51:28] Now Mayor Council, that concludes my presentation. [0:51:32] I wouldn't stand for any questions that you may have. [0:51:37] Any questions? [0:51:38] Was in the emergency room a year or so ago, and it just came to me, I was reminded of [0:51:50] this way you were speaking. [0:51:54] There were, it was late at night. [0:52:04] Officer was, I don't read, but there was obviously somebody who had maybe some mental [0:52:11] health issues or was in a bad place and pretty traumatized and they were doing everything [0:52:18] they could to sit still, but the compassion that I saw that officer, it was a woman, her [0:52:29] side, answering questions, and just his mannerism, it was so obviously that this was part of his [0:52:40] training officers do their very best to have this kind of behavior in this kind of an [0:52:50] But to actually see it and just see what everybody was going through was really eye-opening [0:52:57] and I was very proud that that was my community. [0:53:01] One boy, thank you for sharing that story. [0:53:05] You're welcome. [0:53:09] Captain Barnhart had a saying when he was here and he would always remind officers that [0:53:14] the kindness matters to be kind. [0:53:16] In 25-30 years ago when I was getting the profession, that wasn't really something that [0:53:23] we talked about with new recruits, but we do speak about that often with our people. [0:53:28] It was a great point to bring up. I just, you know, because I always plug the youth council, [0:53:37] we have a recent graduate of the youth council this last year who is very interested and has [0:53:43] started the path to hopefully someday be part of the Twin Falls Police Department as well. [0:53:48] And so there's another great reason to support our youth and bring them up and train our local kids [0:53:54] to stay home and take these jobs. [0:53:56] Thank you, Mayor. We'll look forward to seeing that person. [0:53:59] Yes, any other questions? Anything from Chris or Sean? [0:54:06] This is Sean. I would say Chief, thank you to you and all of your team for all that you do. [0:54:15] It's been a challenging 20 months or so. [0:54:20] It was top of the already challenging five that you all need. [0:54:24] So I appreciate the service to the community and thank you for the presentation. [0:54:27] Thank you, sir, very much. I appreciate that. [0:54:30] Chief, I would just echo what Nikki and Charlotte said, [0:54:37] just please put your given limit to how much we appreciate them. [0:54:42] And we'll do that, Councilman. [0:54:43] Thank you. [0:54:44] Thank you. [0:54:45] Great presentation. [0:54:46] And make sure you take back our thanks to everyone [0:54:49] in your department for all that they do for us. [0:54:51] Thank you. [0:54:55] Next on our agenda is a chance for general public input. [0:54:58] And this is an opportunity for anyone [0:55:01] who would like to address the council on an item that [0:55:04] not on this evening's agenda. The advisory board reports and announcements. Great, you look like you're ready to go. [0:55:18] The city of Travis Mitch on the reception for Ron McGuire today was there. I had to stand up here because there wasn't room in the chambers. [0:55:32] But it was really wonderful. I thought it was a great tribute to him. I didn't know it that well. [0:55:38] that I express my gratitude for his service. [0:55:41] And there's a lot of humor in it. [0:55:45] It's kind of a roasted away with the Travis. [0:55:48] But in all in a good way. I just want to bring that up. [0:55:51] Thank you. I have a few public hearings that are scheduled to start at six o'clock. [0:56:07] So we have four minutes. [0:56:09] Feel free to, I guess, move amongst yourself for a few minutes. [0:56:13] And we will start at the public hearings in four minutes. [0:56:16] We'll call City Council and move on to our public hearings. [1:01:27] Our first item this evening is a public hearing on the use of our foregun balance and instead [1:01:34] of reading through it all, I'm going to turn it over to our City Manager, Travis Rothweiler, [1:01:38] and we'll begin. [1:01:40] Okay, so Madam Mayor, members of the City Council, maybe yes, I don't want to say we're [1:01:45] going to deem you from the agenda, but we're going to, did you say just look at me really [1:01:50] quickly, Edgar? [1:01:51] It's always good to get your legal counsel's attention at the very beginning of their conversation, [1:01:56] right? [1:01:57] He just woke up right up. [1:02:00] Everything that we're going to be talking tonight is interconnected, and so what I thought [1:02:03] I would do is I would go over the larger presentation, go through the presentation and [1:02:09] talk about exactly what is in this budget, and then what we'll do is we will then entertain [1:02:16] the agenda items as they are listed, and I'll walk you through each one of those. [1:02:21] So first we're going to do a presentation on the overall budget. [1:02:23] The second you'll open up a public hearing of the resolution to use the equivalent of 1% [1:02:30] property tax revenue of the city's foregone balance. [1:02:34] Be asked to consider a resolution and you can find the outcome of that resolution [1:02:42] hearing on the budget, which at the conclusion of that we will ask for you to opt [1:02:49] appropriation ordinance for fiscal year. So with that I'm going to say you made it. [1:03:00] So, this is a process that the staff level we began in January, we created and went forward [1:03:11] with the budgeting process and we engaged with the community and the council beginning in April. [1:03:19] And we've met again in May and we met again in June and then we have met every Monday [1:03:27] since Independence Day holiday, until tonight, have a conversation about the budget. [1:03:33] And in every one of those conversations, we've been talking about these six main goals in driving the budget forward. [1:03:45] So tonight, for those who are maybe joining at the end of our conversation, [1:03:53] this is a quick understanding of the thought process that went into the creation of this budget. [1:03:59] Number one, we recognize that we live in an incredibly dynamic, ever-changing environment. [1:04:07] In fact, the environment that we built this budget changed and modified several different [1:04:13] times just over the course of this last calendar year. [1:04:16] To be able to be responsive, we wanted to make sure that it was nimble. [1:04:23] It was able to be responsive and that we are also creating a stable action plan. [1:04:27] So, being sensitive to that overall operating environment was absolutely important. [1:04:35] We wanted to make sure that every single budget was directly tied to the city's strategic [1:04:39] plan and that we wanted to make sure that we were balancing all of our resources and [1:04:45] revenues with the available resources to make the appropriate expenditures. [1:04:51] We were able to pay off the arsenic bond. [1:04:54] As we shared last week, we made that final payment on the bond with the approval of the [1:04:59] Council and now what we're doing is we're asking you to consider some innovative [1:05:04] capital ideas moving forward. And then most importantly and I think that the [1:05:09] Chief's presentation a little bit earlier talked about the importance of our people, [1:05:12] the importance of holding on to the employees that really drive and provide [1:05:18] service inside of the City of Twin Falls and our pursuit of being an employer of [1:05:22] choice. So over the course of the last several weeks we've talked about every [1:05:28] single one of these focus areas in depth, we spent time describing how we're going to [1:05:32] allocate resources, talking about projects, talking about funding, we've talked about [1:05:38] opportunities. It was with these different stats that we had in mind. And as you've seen, [1:05:44] while the picture has remained the same, the words have changed. Where, if you look now, [1:05:52] the most recent update is to our unemployment. Where it isn't now, we present. I'll spend [1:05:58] a little bit of time talking about that last week before the unemployment [1:06:01] numbers were released, a lot of part of last week, we were listening to that at 3.3%. [1:06:08] The median home inside of the state of Idaho has gone down significantly. [1:06:13] The median home inside of the city of Twin Falls continues to grow as well. [1:06:17] And with the official result of the census release, we can say that 18 months ago, [1:06:24] the city of Twin Falls had a population of 51,807 people. [1:06:28] And we can just look around and we know that a number is already updated. [1:06:33] We spent incredible time talking and sharing economic data and sharing information as it [1:06:42] continued to move forward. [1:06:43] We've shared how our cost of business has gone up 9.8% comparison to June to June. [1:06:50] We talked about how a home has increased 33.8% inside of the Magic Valley. [1:06:57] We've illustrated our population increase where the City of Twin Falls has increased 17.5% in [1:07:02] Census to Census and the county has increased 16.6. [1:07:06] And we know that the City of Twin Falls serves as the epicenter for the retail, for medical [1:07:15] and for education. [1:07:16] And we see our daytime population on all of the primary roads entering into the City of [1:07:22] falls causing that to grow to over 100,000 people. [1:07:25] Unemployment, about labor shortage. [1:07:31] We've talked about how hard it is to continue to find quality individuals to join our workforce. [1:07:42] So here's our budget. [1:07:43] Our budget is based upon a total taxable value of $4,025,958,356. [1:07:52] Our total budget this year is $3,337,000 less than it was last year. [1:07:59] It's roughly a 4.58% reduction. [1:08:04] And we're also able to reduce the tax rate from $6.83 to $6.24, which is a 8.64% reduction. [1:08:13] We've shared how our tax rate has kind of ebbed and flowed through the years, but over the [1:08:21] Over the course of the last four fiscal years, we have been able to drive our tax rate down [1:08:28] and at $6.24 per thousand dollars of taxable value, it will be the lowest tax rate that we've offered inside of the City of Twin Falls. [1:08:38] And a lot of individuals want to know how much more is it going to cost to live inside of the City of Twin Falls this year compared to last. [1:08:50] we have shared, as we've perfected these numbers, it's about $1 a month less if you're [1:08:56] in the median home of consuming the median level of goods and services, and $1 a month [1:09:02] less isn't significant. We acknowledge that. But it isn't an era where we show it in the [1:09:08] last slide, the cost of doing business has grown more than 10%. That really is a credit [1:09:14] set of the leadership team that is inside this room where they look at their budgets, [1:09:18] They find ways to innovate, they find ways to be efficient, [1:09:22] and that is our pledge, and we will continue to do that, [1:09:27] as we work through this upcoming fiscal year [1:09:29] and future fiscal years. [1:09:36] So when you start taking a look at the overall budget, [1:09:39] when you start looking at property taxes, [1:09:41] this incorporates the 3% statuatoria [1:09:43] allowed increase as well as the new construction [1:09:46] and annexation values, and it asks to use 1% revenue [1:09:51] of the equivalent of 1% of property tax revenue [1:09:54] of the facilities for gun balance, which equates to $251,000. [1:09:59] It is designed to cover operational fees and increases [1:10:02] that we've seen as a result of just crazy market [1:10:09] in which we're trying to capture goods and services. [1:10:12] We've eliminated the arsenic flat fee, [1:10:14] and what we're asking the council to do [1:10:16] and what was approved in the rate resolution [1:10:19] was to incorporate a new fee, which allows us to capture [1:10:23] the necessary resources to expand and grow our system. [1:10:29] We're not recommending any increases in sewer. [1:10:32] The total solid sanitation and recycling program [1:10:35] will see about a 3% increase. [1:10:37] And as a direct result of the pass through the agreement [1:10:40] that we have with PSA. [1:10:44] Last week the city council completed its work [1:10:47] and it has went through and it is appropriated [1:10:49] of the council's direct capital allocations [1:10:53] to fund these projects. [1:10:58] The total is 780,000. [1:11:10] We shared very early on this would be [1:11:12] a much more abbreviated conversation. [1:11:18] It could appear before you for the last eight weeks, [1:11:20] I'm sure that any one of you could have probably given [1:11:22] this tonight, so happy to answer any questions [1:11:24] that you might have before we start moving [1:11:27] into the parts of the agenda. [1:11:30] Before we turn into the council here, [1:11:33] I'm gonna start with Sean. [1:11:34] Sean, do you have any questions? [1:11:39] I did not have any questions. [1:11:41] I would just make a general comment that I believe the diligence of the staff and the council [1:11:51] in serving the city manager in putting a budget together that helps to address these parts of our community [1:12:00] in spite of the constant uncertainties we've been dealing with the last many, many months. [1:12:08] to other cities that I see and I know I think that we all have citizens should be very proud of the work that's been done and I appreciate the innovation and prudence of department managers and clear down to all of the front line employees of the city. [1:12:28] Thank you for serving the citizens of our community. [1:12:33] Thank you. [1:12:34] I would just echo what Shops said, thank you to everyone who has put this together in the time and effort that's gone into presenting this. [1:12:45] Great landing. [1:12:54] Travis, please have house bill 489, and part of that is we have lost some of our revenue that we have would have gotten from the construction and annexation where what I talk about, I talk about those two allowing growth to pay for growth. [1:13:15] And the bill took those away from us. [1:13:18] What is about it? [1:13:19] You have just the rest estimate of the dollar amount we lost to our budget by those by 489 with those two. [1:13:27] And we were able to capture 90% correct. [1:13:32] Right, but we had to reduce our amount to 102 million, so I'm just looking for a rough estimate too. [1:13:58] Well Matt's looking at that, so yeah, remember, we're working with members of our accounting team [1:14:11] that really don't use the term rough estimate. [1:14:14] They use laser precision. [1:14:19] So when I went up to Madden, I said, [1:14:21] hey, can you give me a rough estimate? [1:14:23] He is now scrolling through his spreadsheets [1:14:26] to get you that number, which would be close. [1:14:31] So maybe just kind of a back-up. [1:14:34] So people in the audience in viewing [1:14:37] understand the question that is being asked. [1:14:40] In prior years, the cities and counties who had new construction were able to take the taxable value, [1:14:50] and they took the prior year's tax rate, and they multiplied that to create a total revenue stream for that year called New Construction. [1:14:59] They were able to do that same thing for the annexation rules, were calculated into this year. [1:15:09] They changed the formula and so the City of Twin Falls [1:15:13] only received credit for 90% of the growth and so [1:15:18] The City of Twin Falls was able to dollars of new construction opposed to the [1:15:34] $114 million that we truly did grow and [1:15:36] Then we applied to tax rate for this year as opposed to the prior tax rate [1:15:44] So it's not only a reduction based upon the lower tax rate, but it's also the 90%. [1:15:50] And so the variance was $152,000 this year. [1:15:55] Thank you very much for the information. [1:16:00] Where I was trying to get to is we're taking $251,000 from our foregone amount that goes to existing taxpayers, [1:16:11] whereas that new construction amount would have been to the new taxpayers. [1:16:16] And so, I'm trying to point out that the backward logic of House Bill 489 is that they're texting everybody in the city for what should have been basically a new construction amount. [1:16:29] It's not an exact formula, I understand that, and I don't want to say this not exactly there, but I'm hoping as the legislature as it appears now from information I have for AIC that there's maybe going to be a special session in September to try to fix House Bill 489. [1:16:45] I'll spill for you, maybe if we hadn't done it in four days at the end of the session, we wouldn't have to come back to fix it, but that's one of the things I think that hopefully they will look at is being encountered to us and I'm not sure if legislators understood exactly the way it would work. [1:17:03] That was my so much for the moment. I want to also thank the staff and things we we spend more time on our budget than any city [1:17:13] Then I can know of by far more time on our budget [1:17:19] First starting doing it I was a little resentful [1:17:21] But now I understand why we do it because I know my budget our budget far better than any of the other fellow [1:17:33] And because of that, it makes me be able to make more better form and form decisions. [1:17:38] We're here for our staff on a weekly basis, why they need something, [1:17:44] what they're doing, going to be doing with it, how it meets our strategic plan. [1:17:48] And I thank you, Travis and your staff for bringing it to us this better, [1:17:53] so we understand it. [1:17:55] And those of you who are listening, possibly on air, [1:17:59] I'm down during those next year come down during those eight meetings and we're only get to download your city's budget because that's where we're explaining exactly what we're gonna spend using the money for. [1:18:11] Thank you. [1:18:19] That was just this probably stupid question, but I'm trying to have some out of planning done and so forth. [1:18:27] It seems like the rate of inflation is going so much up so quickly just in the last 30 days. [1:18:33] Are we still comfortable with the budget to meet for our safeguards inside of the budget? [1:18:55] budget. At the end of the day, we deliver a balanced budget and process. And so what's [1:19:08] important to recognize is that when we, after you approve the budget, we don't go on an autopilot [1:19:14] of spending. The past have had to put in holdbacks. We believe we've established processes [1:19:21] and we don't have to third category A and category B projects that we've talked about, [1:19:28] but it will require us to monitor or require us to make sure that as we make those capital [1:19:35] investments that we have the resources and the revenue coming able to believe so [1:19:47] is a fairly dynamic world. I don't want to stand up and say 18 months from now this [1:20:02] is going to be absolutely spot-on. We will make the appropriate adjustments to ensure that it is. [1:20:08] I'm asking our city staff is already been said. I know that hours and hours of staff [1:20:24] has put into this. Up here we kind of joke about eight meetings and that's [1:20:29] nothing compared to the time that you guys have put into this. It does help make it [1:20:35] easier and more confident when we've gone through this detail as we have that we [1:20:40] know that we understand so when we agree that this is the proper budget for the [1:20:46] city this year that each of us can defend it if we're asked by our citizens [1:20:51] why we supported it and how we supported it. Ruth did you have something? I just [1:20:56] wanted to add with my bean counter add-on and having worked with a couple other [1:21:01] cities on their budgets I am I believe we have the most professional organized [1:21:10] finance team in the state and I'm very proud to be a participant and be able to [1:21:18] represent the citizens with this detailed and analyzed budget appreciated [1:21:24] Right before we move forward, I'm just going to real quick throughout a clarification because we do have a signup sheet. [1:21:35] We have two separate public hearings this evening. [1:21:39] So the first one we're going to discuss is on the foregone balance. [1:21:42] So when we open that public hearing, please keep your questions directed to that portion. [1:21:48] The second one will be on the budget itself. [1:21:51] So if those are the questions you brought tonight, please wait for that second public hearing to ask those questions. [1:21:57] So Madam Mayor, members of the City Council, the next step in the process is to all the public hearing on the use of $251,803 of foregone revenue to be included in the city's fiscal year 2021-2022 budget, which begins on October 1st, 2021, and ends on September 30th of 2022. [1:22:23] So this is one of the changes that came up with House Bill 389 as a part of House Bill [1:22:31] 389. [1:22:32] There are a whole series of modifications. [1:22:35] We talked to part of the modification that occurred as a result of the new construction [1:22:40] and annexation rules. [1:22:42] The second and another equally important was the use of the cities for gun balance. [1:22:47] and while hospital 474 passed the IDO legislature to [1:22:52] outstanding 16 that required this process. [1:22:55] In the last legislative session, they shared that the cities can only take 1% or the equivalent [1:23:02] of 1% revenue to be used to support ongoing operation and maintenance costs or 3% to [1:23:10] be able to support one-time capital projects. [1:23:14] Prior years, the city could have taken its entire foregone balance, [1:23:18] it could have taken that and applied it. [1:23:21] And one of the things that the city's been able to do [1:23:23] is it's been able to accumulate that foregone balance. [1:23:26] And at the right time, it's been able to bring in [1:23:30] some of that revenue to support long-term capital projects. [1:23:34] And we've spent a lot of time talking about those projects. [1:23:39] Part of that is to use to really build projects like this. [1:23:43] and I thought that members of the engineering team last week did a really good job [1:23:47] sharing and illustrating all of the work that has been done on the council directed capital. [1:23:54] So, Madam Mayor, members of the City Council tonight, you have a resolution before your consideration [1:24:02] after the public hearing to use $251,803 of the city's foregone revenue balance. [1:24:12] I know that the council is aware but maybe just a really paraphrased version you can explain [1:24:25] to the balance of what is foregone balance. [1:24:29] So, under state code, these county school districts are allowed to collect what we refer [1:24:41] to as a statutory increase and that statutory increase is a 3% increase in property tax [1:24:47] plus the value, or 90% of the value, of the annexation and new construction rules. [1:24:55] At any point in time in which you do not take that money, it falls into this, it is tracked and recorded by the IoTeX Commission. [1:25:11] And right now the city has a bank in this foregone of nearly two point, which is to say it's $2.2 million of property tax, [1:25:25] property tax revenue that the city could have collected since 2010, but has elected not to do so. [1:25:34] In every year you don't take the 3% or the value of new construction or the value of annexation. [1:25:42] It goes that true dollar value flows into that. And so what we're asking for right now is to [1:25:51] you use a portion of that $251,000 to offset the operational costs that we're experiencing [1:25:59] as a result of inflation and as a result of not being able to collect the full value of [1:26:05] new construction to be able to support operations and maintenance and is still with that inclusion. [1:26:10] We're still projecting a significant decrease in the property tax rate as we shared and [1:26:16] that should translate into a modest reduction [1:26:21] pretty taxes to the medium. [1:26:26] Amy, before we open the public hearing, [1:26:28] do you have a resolution number for us? [1:26:32] Is Dash at 0-1-3. [1:26:37] Thank you very much. [1:26:40] 0-1-3. [1:26:44] Any last minute questions for Travis [1:26:46] before we open the public hearing? [1:26:49] Seeing none, at this time, [1:26:51] we will open the public hearing [1:26:53] on the city's use of foregone balance, [1:26:57] amount of $251,803, seeing no one close the public hearing and turn it back to the council. [1:27:19] Prove resolution 2021 day 0132 for the city to use $251,803 of the foreign revenue incorporated [1:27:41] the 2021-2022 fiscal year budget beginning October 1st. [1:27:45] second we have a motion from great landing seconded by Ruth Pierce to adopt [1:27:52] resolution 2021-01-3 going to pause for a minute are there any questions from the [1:28:02] council or comments please Sean Barriger yeah Christopher Reed yeah Craig [1:28:21] Yes. [1:28:22] Yes. [1:28:23] Ruth Pierce. [1:28:24] Yes. [1:28:25] Frank Lanting. [1:28:26] Yes. [1:28:27] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:28:28] Yes. [1:28:29] Nikki Boyd. [1:28:30] Motion passes seven to zero. [1:28:33] Next is, um, do you have an introduction on the budget besides what you presented before [1:28:40] we have a public hearing? [1:28:42] So at this time we are going to open the public hearing on the City of Twin Falls Budget for [1:28:50] the fiscal year 2022. [1:28:51] I'm going to start with my sign and sheet. [1:28:55] The first person I have is Tom Tucker. [1:28:58] I think to say this evening, well this is the last item this evening. [1:29:08] Next we have Larry Roberts. [1:29:22] You did not, but we had that call for public comment before the public hearing. [1:29:27] Okay, sit tight. [1:29:30] We'll come back to you. [1:29:31] Hang on. [1:29:32] Hang on. [1:29:33] Okay. [1:29:34] Is there anyone in the audience who would like to address the council on the budget? [1:29:38] this evening. [1:29:41] On capillaries, come forward. [1:29:42] Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. [1:29:47] I'm John Capillaries, one, two, three, one, son, first. [1:29:52] Last week, there was an idea brought up about pedestrian bridges, and that idea was kind [1:29:59] of a good food by our staff. [1:30:05] But I just wanted to say that as someone who has served on the Twin Falls City Traffic [1:30:13] Safety Commission and the Arshway Committee, and to a view, were on that committee. [1:30:19] I'm not a glutton for punishment, but I just wanted to point out that we got a lot of push [1:30:29] back on that Arshway. [1:30:33] But a lot of the comments I got on Facebook were for it when they thought it was an actual [1:30:44] pedestrian bridge, and then they were against it when they found out it wasn't. And also [1:30:48] I wanted to point out that the pedestrian bridges are about half the cost of what we [1:30:56] paid for for the archway. And so we could actually fundraise for one of those. So if [1:31:04] going forward, if you're not able to get some project like that into the budget, you [1:31:11] You know, you should always consider having another citizen committee be able to fundraise [1:31:17] and bring that forward. [1:31:20] You know, this is something that goes all the way back to the beginning of Twin Falls. [1:31:26] The first bridge across the Rock Creek Canyon was mostly citizen funded by a committee that [1:31:34] got together and funded that. [1:31:36] You know, private citizen sponsored infrastructure goes all the way back to ancient Rome during [1:31:44] the Roman Republic, the APN Way, which is still there, was funded and built by APS. [1:31:52] Yeah, so going forward, I think that that should be an option that the council considers. [1:32:01] Thank you. [1:32:03] There are any questions on the budget this evening? [1:32:07] We'll close the public hearing. [1:32:16] And on this one, Amy, do you have an ordinance number? [1:32:19] It is ordinance number 2021-015. [1:32:25] The council, I'm Stafford also asked that Jesus spend the rules. [1:32:37] Read it by adoption so we can read the statute or your requirements. [1:32:46] They're held too far, which instructs the amount of taxes that need to be lent. [1:32:56] Great landing. [1:32:59] I have a motion from Greglantine, seconded by Sean Barrigar to suspend the rules and place [1:33:23] ordinance 2021-015 on 3rd and final by title only, a last comment, maybe roll call vote. [1:33:34] Susanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. [1:33:47] John Parryger. Yes. [1:33:52] She passed this 7 to 0 and let's see if I can read through this title. [1:33:57] Ordinance 2021-015, an ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, appropriating $69,464,941 [1:34:10] for the 2022 fiscal year to defray all necessary expenses and liabilities of the City of Twin Falls, [1:34:18] providing for the objects and purposes for which such appropriations are made and the amount [1:34:25] appropriated for each object or purpose, levying add the law of taxes in the amount of 25,432,026 [1:34:38] for the 2022 fiscal year, providing that a copy of this ordinance shall be filed with [1:34:44] the county commissioners of Twin Falls County, Idaho, providing for this ordinance to take [1:34:51] effect upon its passage approval and publication according to law. The rule requiring that an [1:34:58] ordinance be read on three separate occasions having been suspended. [1:35:15] Here I move we adopt the ordinance number 2021-15 for the city of Twin Falls for the 21-22 [1:35:24] to fiscal year budget beginning on October 1, 2021, [1:35:31] and ending on September 30th, 2022. [1:35:41] Thank you, Sean. [1:35:42] I think great to be here by here there. [1:35:45] We have a motion. [1:35:46] All right, sorry. [1:35:47] No, you're good. [1:35:48] I understand. [1:35:49] We have a motion from Ruth Pierce, [1:35:50] a second by Greg Lanting to adopt ordinance 2021-015. [1:35:58] Hey, we roll call vote. [1:36:01] Nicky Boyd. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yeah. Christopher Reed. Yeah. [1:36:11] Hawkins. Yes. Rose Peirz. Yes. Greg Glanting. Yes. [1:36:16] And Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Ocean passes 7 to 1. I feel like we should have a celebration or something. [1:36:24] Hey. Congratulations to everybody. I think this was a good piece of work by everybody involved. [1:36:32] All righty, so we are going to back up and we will allow two minutes each for public comment at this time [1:36:40] and we will start with Tom Tucker. [1:36:59] There's a green button on the top of that microphone. [1:37:12] I represent the Homeward Association of Breckenridge, which is on the key to the city for making the annual Springs Grade Safer. [1:37:27] And as a result, all you've noticed that the increase in traffic on that road and as homeowners [1:37:36] along that stretch of Canyon, we're concerned about the speed of vehicles going up and down [1:37:44] the grade. [1:37:45] We've seen cars coming up the grade passing other cars, we've seen cars passing cars going [1:37:51] down the grade and there's way too many pedestrians on that. [1:37:56] I think that it's great how that we have a side of the road set up for pedestrians. [1:38:01] That seems to help, although not all pedestrians recognize as some people for out of town. [1:38:06] They don't stay on that side. [1:38:08] We're just concerned about the traffic speed along there. [1:38:12] At one time we had, I think it was a road that was coming across the street or a short speed pump [1:38:17] towards the stop sign on the south part of Canyon Springs. [1:38:22] brings great but that's been leveled out so now it's that kind of was a speed pump that slowed some [1:38:29] people down but now that's gone and it's smooth and we're just wondering if we could maybe bring [1:38:37] to your attention that we're concerned for the safety of pedestrians and also people up and down that. [1:38:46] Thank you we will address that I assume you're both here on the same subject so we'll hear both [1:38:50] comments and then circle back is that okay very Robert's pressing arc [1:39:21] and walkers and from the city was helpful earlier this lighting some study [1:39:51] study done and the study showed that the speed limit average was 33 points [1:40:02] something miles per hour which is should be you have that concerned about [1:40:11] I'm sure you know you have a number of staff members listening to your concerns tonight [1:40:54] and we will make sure that we have someone follow up with you and report back to the council [1:40:59] to see what the appropriate steps should be. [1:41:03] Alright, anything else from city managers office after that? [1:41:15] To all the staff that's here, thank you again so much [1:41:18] for all of your time in this budget. [1:41:20] And with that, we're adjourned.