Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-08-16, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-08-16/ [0:02:36] We accept that. [0:02:37] We accept that. [0:02:38] The motion from Craig Hawkins, seconded by Sean Berger, to approve the consent calendar [0:02:46] as presented this evening. [0:02:54] Yes. [0:02:56] Yes. [0:02:57] Yes. [0:02:58] Great landing. [0:02:59] Yes. [0:03:00] Yes. [0:03:01] Thank you. [0:03:02] Point. [0:03:03] Yes. [0:03:05] Sean Berger. [0:03:06] Motion passes 7-0. [0:03:07] So, in addition to our normal housekeeping items on the consent calendar, if you are here this [0:03:13] This evening for the vintage car show, [0:03:16] the corn hole tournament, [0:03:18] where the ninth annual haunted swamp, [0:03:20] those were all just approved. [0:03:23] This evening under items of discussion, [0:03:26] under considerations, we have a discussion [0:03:28] on the tentative budget for the city of Twin Falls [0:03:31] for the 2021-2022 fiscal year. [0:03:36] We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler. [0:03:43] Members of the city council, good evening. [0:03:45] This is the second to last presentation [0:03:48] that we'll be having about the budget. [0:03:50] And I can kind of sense the relief [0:03:52] as we're kind of getting through this journey, right? [0:03:55] But tonight really is a heavy lift for the council. [0:04:00] Tonight is the night which you will assign $770,000 [0:04:04] that has been part of the council capital, [0:04:08] part of the budget for the last several years. [0:04:11] And members of the team are here to walk you through that. [0:04:14] Just as we've done over the course of the last several weeks, [0:04:17] I'm going to provide a bit of an introduction [0:04:20] of the budget and get some of the conversations. [0:04:26] As you have questions, we stop and ask. [0:04:30] Next week's presentation is going to be much more [0:04:32] previewed. [0:04:33] So tonight is the night that we are going to really again dive [0:04:37] into the numbers next week as the public hearing in which [0:04:40] will be much more succinct in the presentation. [0:04:45] So as we started this process back in January, [0:04:51] a budget that was going to be responsive to a ever-changing [0:04:56] and dynamic operating environment. [0:04:59] We recognize that there are many outside influences [0:05:02] that can impact what we do as a city [0:05:03] and we wanted to try to ensure [0:05:06] that we're able to be nimble and to be responsive. [0:05:10] Throughout this entire presentation [0:05:11] and this conversation we've shared with you the, [0:05:14] some of the ideas that we had to support long-term capital [0:05:17] and as you've looked at accounts payable this week, [0:05:20] you notice that there was about $9 million [0:05:22] in total bills for the arsenic debt payoff. [0:05:26] And as we've committed to you that we are paying off that arsenic debt early in an exchange for that, [0:05:32] as was approved by the fee resolution, we are going to create a series of new fees that help us establish a water capital account [0:05:42] that allows us to not only complete main-line maintenance projects, but also to advance capital projects that are critical to that overall infrastructure system. [0:05:50] The end result of that is that we, our citizens, will see an overall rate reduction. [0:05:55] Then we talked a lot about being a service organization. [0:06:00] As a service organization, public services are delivered by people. [0:06:04] It's our goal to retain, to attract, and continue to be an employer of choice in the [0:06:10] Magic Valley. [0:06:12] Just reflected in our strategic plan, which is when every single part of our budget is [0:06:17] directly tied to. [0:06:20] Statistics about the City of Twin Falls. [0:06:23] We've talked extensively about how the city of Twin Falls [0:06:26] isn't a community of just 51,000 as reported [0:06:32] through the census that, honey, every single day, [0:06:35] our population will grow to nearly, if not exceed, [0:06:38] 100,000 people. [0:06:41] And it's that population that we provide services to, [0:06:44] it's that population that not only lives in Twin Falls, [0:06:48] but visits to in Falls that we are required to [0:06:54] public safety and cultural. We've talked about costs. Costs have continued to increase where [0:07:11] the July numbers for the consumer price index have come out and now we're at 5.4% increase [0:07:17] here over year. And the municipal services, the MCI municipal cost index has not been released [0:07:24] yet. We expect that to also increase and you can see that here over year from June costs [0:07:31] of providing municipal services have gone up nearly 10%. [0:07:38] And this is new. [0:07:41] Last week, we showed that the median home value [0:07:44] inside the city of Twin Falls was 290,000. [0:07:48] In one month's time, it gained another $13,000 in value. [0:07:54] And year over year, a median home inside of the city [0:07:57] of Twin Falls has increased by nearly 34% [0:08:02] and they're projecting an additional 14%. [0:08:05] next year. We spent time last week talking for housing on two fronts. There was articles [0:08:13] in the paper this weekend that talked about how hard it is to fight rental property. It [0:08:19] is being able to acquire a home. And that is important as we have retirements come up [0:08:25] as we have individuals who leave our organization. We're trying to fill those positions. It's [0:08:30] important to be mindful through that lens, but it's also important to be mindful through [0:08:34] the employers that are in Twin Falls. That same, because right now it's a 3.3 percent. [0:08:44] Inside of the metropolitan statistical area and 3.6 percent inside the city of Twin Falls. [0:08:50] It's about 853 people inside the city of Twin Falls. [0:08:58] There's also a series of great articles that talked about the number of want-outs that were just on blue legs alone. [0:09:04] and many of us who have connections with the business industry will share how hard it is [0:09:08] to find individuals to be in some of those positions where many of our service industries [0:09:15] and our restaurants today inside of Twin Falls are having to not open on certain days as a result [0:09:21] of their inability to staff, to be able to move about the explosive growth. [0:09:28] We've talked about the number of people who are moving into the city of Twin Falls and yet they're [0:09:33] not joining our local workforce because they're able to work remotely, they're able to bring [0:09:39] their work with them and while they're adding value to our community, they're not helping [0:09:44] fill some of those holes in those labor places that we talk about how the City of Twin Falls [0:09:51] is a regional center not only in terms of the total number of vehicle trips but when you [0:09:57] start taking a look at the economic impact that the City of Twin Falls has in relationship [0:10:04] to the entirety of Twin Falls County, and we measure that not only based upon comparisons [0:10:13] of similar in like cities, but illustrating that of the entire $1.36 billion of economic [0:10:21] and site in Falls County, nearly from the city of 20s of similar size, you see and it's [0:10:39] further points that more people are coming into the city of Twin Falls and utilizing our [0:10:44] services aren't just about as close as we're going to be. [0:10:58] It goes to members of the team, but also to a budget that is designed to maintain current levels of services, [0:11:18] while also finding a way to reduce costs. [0:11:22] And admittedly, we're not reducing to our citizens significantly, [0:11:27] or at which costs are going out by 10% the fact that we're coming. [0:11:31] I think it's really a credit to this team and that has created shows their innovation and shows their thoughtfulness in their approach. [0:11:41] It would be easy just to increase cost 10% because that's the cost of doing business, but members [0:11:48] of our team have really looked within their budgets and made some adjustments. [0:11:52] And then we compare where we're at inside of the city to when falls in terms of our overall [0:11:59] taxes in comparison to other places. [0:12:02] And everybody's still going through that budgeting process until we can't share where they're [0:12:06] going to be this year. [0:12:07] if we take a look last year using the median home value and you use the total tax rate, [0:12:14] you can see folks can see the city of Twin Falls once again is incredibly good. [0:12:23] So our overall budget that we presented to you is nearly 4.6% smaller than the budget that [0:12:31] we're operating under. [0:12:32] current the budget is going to be $69.464 million compared to the budget [0:12:39] we're under for fiscal year 21 of 72. You can see that we're decreasing the tax rate [0:12:45] from $6.83 to $6.24 which is a product of not only the valuation of our community [0:12:53] which is up 16.9 percent but also owners value of the city of Twin Falls and you [0:13:08] Another 630, what a 16.9% represent, well, it's the one of the largest increases that we've seen where you can see that over the past two physical years was 11.12% and 27.02% increase in 20 were continuing to grow. [0:13:35] The total new construction for the city of Twin Falls was about $113 million after it's gone through the Board of Equalization. [0:13:42] Based upon the new house bill 389 were able to claim 90% of that so that's where it comes up to $102 million of new construction [0:13:51] 779,000 and this is the increase in the homeowners exemption that building for rent revenue is up, an increase of about a million dollars [0:14:14] You can see where it has been over the last three fiscal years and this is where it's [0:14:26] at 37 single family permits, 72 minutes, 63 models in addition. [0:14:48] You can see that there is a slight slowdown in the number of single family homes that have [0:14:53] been issued where 73 were issued last July 20th is July and it's a function of a lot [0:14:59] of different things. [0:15:00] It's a function of labor. [0:15:01] It's a function of cost. [0:15:02] It's a function of labor, it's a function of cost of materials, this slow down is only [0:15:13] temps when we start talking that we also will point to the fact that our commercial permits [0:15:29] are up for a very strong, which helps us in all those factors moving forward. [0:15:49] So what's in the budget? [0:15:50] Inside the budget as we talked about where you prove the resolution is not only the 3% [0:15:56] The property tax increased the new construction and the annexation rules, but also using revenue [0:16:02] equal to 1% of our foregone balance. [0:16:05] Spent some time walking through the water, increased analysis illustrates that the residential [0:16:21] customer will pay less in water because of the arsenic. [0:16:28] There is no increase in the sewer rate recommended. [0:16:30] Last week there was about a 3% increase to recycling organization in our process of adding [0:16:48] personnel sparingly processed review, [0:16:53] recognize that when you close into our organization, [0:16:57] the employees that is there better. [0:17:07] As we continue to grow, I will tell you that we're going [0:17:09] to need to continue to add additional employees moving [0:17:12] for cops, grants, while making it safer grants, [0:17:18] whilst we need to move in positions [0:17:21] across the organization in subsequent years, [0:17:24] as we look at span and control in the bill [0:17:26] that we have our services. [0:17:32] Operation and maintenance costs are up this year [0:17:35] And also incorporated into that is going to be the CDBG monies. [0:17:40] We spent some time to talk to council about the 20 allocation [0:17:45] option as well as the CARES allocation and the members [0:17:49] of the planning of projects that are designed. [0:18:11] This is our overall capital projects that we have [0:18:14] and what's not included in this capital number is the $14 million [0:18:18] that we're going to be spending on fire stations [0:18:20] that is ongoing. [0:18:22] Why isn't it included? [0:18:24] Because we recognize that building fire stations [0:18:26] is going to occur over multiple years, [0:18:28] and we're still very much in the design phase. [0:18:31] We hope to be bidding out fire stations sometime between 22, [0:18:37] like fire station number two and fire station number three [0:18:44] attacks and members of the fire to be the structures are not. [0:18:57] We've also spent tiny facility for the fire district [0:19:04] and their grant to help us with that project as well. [0:19:10] This is a little bit in this slide a few times now, [0:19:13] but this is just an illustration on how we're going [0:19:17] to ensure that the estimated 2.10 basis and how we're going to slowly water facility plan [0:19:34] as members of the water team are building up their program to be able to utilize those [0:19:39] funds. [0:19:40] They're an entire series of long-term, very important capital projects that will be able [0:19:44] to embark on this course of the last several weeks, members of our team and all levels of [0:20:04] our organization have come forward and we've talked about the importance of these projects. [0:20:08] So I'm just going to kind of roll through these slides. [0:20:12] If you have any questions, as I do that, please stop me. [0:20:16] And members in the team to be able to share the information we'll once ago over 807. [0:21:19] I appreciate that. I'm really here to talk about the Sidewalk programs. [0:22:35] The City of Tumptalls is either working on or we'd completely want to share with you some good ideas to do in the next year. [0:22:44] This goal here is to be in line with the strategic plan focus here and inform the Travis to show. [0:22:52] The accessible community which is the city will continue to improve the condition and operation of the sidewalks. [0:22:58] So past projects, the two that we've completed most recently are the Grandview Drive North and Harrison Street South Project. [0:23:06] We have this first woman, the Harrison Street Project that was completed. [0:23:30] We put an sidewalk from this corner here, all the way the length of Harrison Street. [0:23:36] All the way down to Orchard, it was about 2,000 feet of sidewalk, [0:23:41] many of your feet of sidewalks, so it was quite a bit of sidewalk. [0:23:44] The project went over well. [0:23:46] We had quite a bit of property owner negotiation that we had to do, [0:23:51] built this approach. [0:23:58] We all said to put some others, quite a bit of court. [0:24:11] The project overall was a success. [0:24:15] Again, this is the Harrison Street South. [0:24:16] This will help kids get down to the middle school down the time. [0:24:24] So that was, and I can continue on once you watch this another second. [0:24:27] So I'll just sit here if you want me to continue getting me in the way or something. [0:24:30] Okay, also the second project that was completed was Grandview Drive North from Rock Creek Elementary School, [0:24:39] which is right here at the bottom of your screen. [0:24:41] We placed sidewalk from here all the way down the length of Grandview Drive to tie into existing sidewalk that was just north of North Fork Road. [0:24:50] This project was very much a pleasure to do the two property owners that we had to deal with for right away acquisition. [0:24:59] We're pretty good to deal with on a scale of things that I've seen. [0:25:02] They were pretty easy to deal with. [0:25:04] We think this was a very successful project. [0:25:09] It's getting used from school, so you know what? [0:25:16] It works. [0:25:17] The Council Direct and Sidewalk project works, and the funds are going to work. [0:25:21] So those are the two most recent projects. [0:25:33] So any questions about what we've done in the past? [0:25:37] The next ones are the projects that we're currently working on. [0:25:43] The first one is the Windows Street project, which I've come to council before to kind of give you an update. [0:25:47] to give you an update. So we are in the process of working with all the property [0:25:50] used. I've spoken with all but one are very excited to have a sidewalk go on the [0:25:56] front of the property. Remember this particular piece is the one that walking [0:26:05] this is the picture on the right side of your screen. They're just walking down that and so [0:26:11] going through how much right we need to get from them. So we're still in that [0:26:17] process of the second project that I wanted to bring to your attention was [0:26:26] the Spark Street project. Now this was one that we'd originally put in the [0:26:29] sidewalk master plan. It's a small piece that will connect to existing sidewalks to get kids [0:26:35] all the way to what's only about 75 feet. And this project, if you remember, there are three [0:26:41] funding mechanisms that we really have tools in our toolbox to help fund sidewalk projects. [0:26:46] And the first one is the Council's Direct and Fund to decide. The second one is the sidewalk [0:26:53] and the Public Works Department. This Spark Street project was actually [0:27:06] from these, which is for Bolster is actually the property and for that piece of property [0:27:24] and he has been gracious enough to let us come. [0:27:27] We're getting ready to actually start the forum that the street cools. [0:27:32] These projects have also been very successful. [0:27:36] Future projects, so in New York Pack Ed, and I'll pull this up, you'll see, these are the [0:27:50] staff, what I mean, staff Josh Baird, myself, and John came from the Public Works Department [0:27:55] I know I'm with the street superintendent. [0:27:57] Once you're in kind of trying to narrow down the list. [0:27:59] What we wanted to do is give you a decent variety of projects to do. [0:28:03] We heard that you're concerned that you want to make sure that they are connected to schools, [0:28:09] that we can get kids safe routes to schools. [0:28:12] So we've hand selected a few and I'm going to go over a few now. [0:28:15] If you have questions during the process, please. [0:28:17] Either side of the road where there aren't sidewalks. [0:28:30] Recognizing like right here, the one that's up on Elizabeth Street, [0:28:33] like on the other side of the road there might be a sidewalk in place. If you can just point out [0:28:37] because you can be a sidewalk in this picture but if you can say hey there there isn't anything [0:28:47] on either side of the road for this stretch. I can, I'll try my best. Okay, thank you. So this [0:28:52] first one is Elizabeth Boulevard. This is one that Josh brought the council is concerned about. [0:28:57] So we took a look at this as one that's been in our master plan. This one will require about [0:29:03] well-hundred. It is on Elizabeth Boulevard and it's between Harmon Park of Northside Elementary [0:29:15] Schools right here. Almost close to Eastland so there's a little piece of sidewalk right [0:29:21] here. Can you all see my cursor? Okay so there's a little piece of sidewalk here that connects [0:29:25] it to Eastland. There's a sidewalk on the north side of the road but there's nothing [0:29:29] on the south side of the road. So this project is fairly large. You can see the price tag [0:29:36] that's associated with it. This one has some right of way that we've recently discovered [0:29:39] that there's some right-way discrepancies that we're going to have to work through on this [0:29:43] project. There's also a box culvert towards the park. There's some wild and great concerns [0:30:03] within. So the next one would be stadium drive. This is a specific piece along stadium that [0:30:13] leads both to Twin Falls High School to school. So there, not this, but not this one, be the [0:30:25] only portion of sidewalk on stadium. There is a piece to this side of sidewalk, but nothing [0:30:37] into existing sidewalk right here, building all new sidewalk all across the [0:30:41] front of this property. We know right away acquisition of this one. It is a project [0:30:49] written in the 1700 of sidewalk with every project right? There's pieces and parts [0:30:57] that we have to take into consideration. This one has power poles that we're going to have to have to move it. [0:31:02] And the other set is everything adds delays and money right? That's that's really what everything [0:31:06] boils down to. But this is a fantastic project because it feeds both the high [0:31:11] school and elementary school for both in this area. The estimated cost you'd [0:31:18] see down on the bottom is 575000 and you said that there isn't a sidewalk on the north side [0:31:25] on the north side of the other side street a sidewalk [0:31:43] a sunrise which point out sunrise and so north side there's sidewalk to there the north side [0:32:05] outside to that and then there's no sidewalk on either side east of east of sunrise any questions [0:32:17] about this this is a particular area should i just want to take up something next one [0:32:25] is on Madrona street this is actually just north of where we are this is the [0:32:29] Majora Street then falls was the where the new signal just went up so this will actually help traffic get [0:32:35] I'm passionate traffic get through that signal and down to the high school in the elementary school [0:32:39] Again, so this has a smaller price tag [0:32:42] Leave there's no sidewalk on the east side of this one either [0:32:46] There is some up to their sidewalk [0:32:55] This is actually one that I've had a couple people recently asked me [0:33:04] Why is there sidewalk home falls for putting them to stop waiting in there? [0:33:08] In this location there's sidewalk on the west side [0:33:19] south of falls and there's sidewalk on the east side and north of falls [0:33:26] further north, there's a falls and it starts and falls and it starts but there's nothing on [0:33:41] on the west side where the blue line that's yeah on the east side there's a sidewalk [0:33:48] i think there's a poor portion but i was thinking that there was some gap [0:33:56] kids that are into their school though there's some sidewalk on the east side [0:34:16] there's some on the west side there's a little bit of a sidewalk on the east side [0:34:40] so that's the drawstring north it's got a smaller cost associated with it [0:34:49] but it has more ramps. There's just constant dislocation on East Wind Drive. [0:35:01] This is just across the street from the LDS temple and south of the new subdivision, Mr. Martins, [0:35:10] has just completed, it's the preserve. And this is the only piece that will be missing [0:35:15] to the south of all this. Once this piece is built, there'll be sidewalk all this month. [0:35:25] So this is one piece that's only about a feet of sidewalk, pretty decent project. [0:35:33] There's only one street department that has multiple conversations with it. [0:35:38] I think I asked this the last time when you presented all this the first so I think I had [0:35:54] asked of whether there would be any cost savings that were an asphalt pathway instead of a concrete [0:36:00] sidewalk and if there's really a cost difference so I've read sections of east side of eastland [0:36:10] that are asphalt pathways instead of sidewalks just curious if that option would be less expensive [0:36:20] By the pros and cons, they come here and have to replace it. [0:36:26] I have the same life as the sidewalk wood, but if we were to ask what I would suggest doing a 10-foot wide, [0:36:33] I'd say I'd just divide it because the sidewalk on the south barks, the site isn't a little wider as well, so I'd have to sit down and do something. [0:36:43] Airbikes out from the... [0:37:05] It is pretty gently sat there. [0:37:22] Which, Nicky has a question, then I want to come back to that. [0:37:25] Okay, so, do you see when... [0:37:28] It doesn't say you just ask, so I know what's happening here soon. [0:37:51] So Tishon's put this week in a crossing zone for all those. [0:38:25] So there, I believe this is existing community. [0:38:27] We have this uncanny village, number three. [0:38:29] Caney Village fires the developer, which is in that southwest corner of that corner, pedestrian crossing of some sort. [0:38:44] As accepted by the city engineer, so I worked with the developer a little bit. [0:38:50] I think we've come to some idea of what we think is appropriate, which is a HAWC system, [0:38:55] which is what we have at the intersection of Caswell and Washington Street that we just [0:38:59] put in a few years ago. The location, I think, is to be determined, but we believe is the [0:39:05] best up. Our location right now is the intersection of Chaney and Eastland, but we also think that [0:39:11] at some future time, maybe not too far in the future, that a full traffic signal would [0:39:16] be worn to that location. And so instead of building a hawk, a few years turned back down [0:39:23] and a building full signal. [0:39:26] We're working with a developer, too. [0:39:28] Have them pay for their portion, [0:39:30] which would be the Hawk System. [0:39:32] And then the city can come back and add on to that, [0:39:34] and instead of building the Hawk System, [0:39:36] just build the full signal outright with them, [0:39:39] their portion. [0:39:41] I know it's expensive, but it almost seems like [0:39:43] that would be a right place for either [0:39:46] and over the road or under the ground. [0:39:48] Like we have a pole line out by Harrison, [0:39:51] some pedestrians without forcing all that truck. [0:40:09] If you're out on polling, it can't stop. [0:40:14] And if there's a pedestrian there, [0:40:15] I don't care if the light turns red. [0:40:16] If they're moving, it can't stop. [0:40:21] I would say there's a couple of things to consider. [0:40:28] First of all, if we provide a crossing, [0:40:32] and so if it wasn't over, over the top, [0:40:35] so a bridge structure, you'd have to have a ramp going [0:40:38] all the way to the top. [0:40:39] I'm not sure that people utilize it as much as they would, [0:40:47] just using a signal and waiting for traffic. [0:40:49] And I would say the same thing underground, [0:40:50] other concern me considerably higher costs than what we could do by just adding a traffic signal. [0:40:59] I do understand that. I just you know every day I hear those trucks lay other horns as they go [0:41:04] through those intersections because they just don't stop. So it just concerns me that we do. [0:41:25] The next one down would be Stadium Boulevard again. This one leads to Casky [0:41:32] Park. It's on the other side of the road from the first one we looked at right. So there's [0:41:36] going to be since sidewalk on the south side but not the north side right there so it [0:41:41] just completes a connection there is what that piece does. I think that's that so the [0:41:48] other piece that we want to talk about tonight just briefly was the Blake Street [0:41:53] and the backstroke dog part so the Parks and Rec department asked me to put together an [0:41:59] estimate but together asked to enforce some sidewalk along that street along the [0:42:05] dog a fancy sheet it wasn't in our it was just a rough estimate that I put [0:42:10] together and so that's the next piece. So what I have done, and I emailed this to you a little earlier, is I sent out an email, or an Excel sheet with all the options. [0:42:22] What I wanted to do is just give you a chance to figure out which option is you liked and then be able to put in a prize. [0:42:29] So for example, I split Elizabeth Boulevard into two because I think it's an unrealistic goal for us to be able to do that project and move the right away pieces that we're dealing with. [0:42:40] It's much like Wendell where we have to deal with design and survey. [0:42:45] I'll tell you what this year has been, and I have some fair trying to get surveyors out to do anything. [0:42:49] They're just so busy. [0:42:51] It's taken me three months to get people on site for Wendell Street to figure out where they surveyed the right-of-way lines for that particular project. [0:42:59] So what I think staff would recommend to councils if you want to do Elizabeth Boulevard that we would encourage you to do an alternative design or delivery meeting the first year. [0:43:11] the first year, help us to do the design, the survey, and get all the right [0:43:15] away associated, get that all done in the first year, and a subsequent year, any year [0:43:20] the council wants to, that will have plans that it'll be a shuttle ready project that we can start in. [0:43:28] So if we peel out the two, we have to separate the staff, be more successful, because we have one [0:43:35] full year to get everything we need, that the council will have plans that are ready to go, [0:43:41] a bit as soon as we get to, right? So my hope would be that if you decide to do the Elizabeth [0:43:50] Bullhug, let's split it up. And let's do part of it this year, all the design, all the right [0:43:56] away, all the survey, get that taken care of, and the box cover, we have the box covered [0:44:00] in with that. And then the subsequent year we can do the other ones we've talked about. [0:44:07] So what I thought we would just do is run through a little exercise read, but yes, and [0:44:12] then it tells you what the total of everything is, right? Or you can say no. So I sent that [0:44:16] that to you so if you want to take a look at that and figure out what it is you [0:44:19] want to do and the different options you have we can run through with you [0:44:23] or you can yourselves however you'd like to what would you like to be [0:44:39] realistically divide this up as far as design surveying all that one year [0:44:47] completely realistically we're gonna say oh hey let's do Elizabeth Street the [0:44:58] ninety four thousand and then Eastland Drive honestly what can we actually get [0:45:05] done in the next fiscal year. [0:45:10] So that's a great question. [0:45:15] The short answer is what we try to do [0:45:17] is distribute these between the other engineers. [0:45:19] Right now, we're down a staff engineer, [0:45:21] and we're still looking for one hour, [0:45:22] but we've got some support. [0:45:24] We've got the assistance engineer that can take it by myself, [0:45:27] or a staff engineer. [0:45:38] Elizabeth Boulevard, if we separate out the survey [0:45:42] and all that stuff first, that's an easier project. [0:45:45] And so there's no C, there's no construction, [0:45:47] inspection that's going on. [0:45:49] It's basically a contract, man, construction, [0:45:55] use it a lot to deal with, it takes a lot of work. So to answer your question, I think the short answer is we could do two to three, two with me saying that. [0:46:13] Projects, the easier it is. Because at the end of the day, a project is going to take so much time no matter how big or small it is. [0:46:27] There's just that management, that has to occur. So if we can, if we can get similar type projects and maybe lump them together as a single project with different locations, that makes it easier. [0:46:39] Or if there's just one bigger project, that makes it easier, but if there's different types of projects that are small [0:46:44] We'll do our best, but it's just it's more difficult, so [0:46:50] Chris I appreciate your [0:46:54] Plished goal [0:46:55] Some of these things if we don't start taking them off now [0:46:58] They're never gonna get done even if they are home to your projects [0:47:02] But I think we have to balance that too, and we're not trying to pressure you guys and say okay [0:47:06] You have to have this done by tomorrow [0:47:08] I'm really good with this, by the way. [0:47:10] These are things that the community years to teach or something in a year. [0:47:21] Project is just curious. [0:47:28] So that plot is very old, and so a lot of those proper descriptions are not... [0:47:33] I don't want to say that they're not accurate there to describe it. [0:47:36] So this surveyor is waiting for those, because right now we're at goal is to have it under... [0:47:50] Because those were the three I.F. through the Blake Street in there as well. [0:48:43] you actually I'll say only exceeded by 47,800 so what my thought was is could [0:48:54] Elizabeth Boulevard alternative delivery design survey and right away [0:49:02] only $47,000 at that time that could offset it. It was a rhetorical statement [0:49:22] question I suppose. You know I like those three road projects that project if we [0:49:39] could part so that we can start the project understanding that we can stay [0:49:55] in our 770 Lake Street or the dog. Yes you've done that. Also remember in [0:50:39] addition to sidewalk projects collection of other projects that you may also want [0:50:48] to use some portion of that for sidewalks you've also used a portion of [0:51:05] that projects and other projects that it necessarily make our initial [0:51:13] conversations but we're very important on an annual basis to balance. It doesn't [0:51:27] mean that they are make sure that council to say this is exactly what we [0:51:40] want to do with the 770 you get locked into that. I go through two more slides and [0:51:47] have you say hello. I wasn't anticipating that so [0:53:31] I don't know if the spend love just came talking about that project specifically an [0:54:16] apparently developer for the preserve was supposed to have that sidewalk wrapped up [0:54:19] by June 2021 so it should be expedited here sure we should see some pro [0:54:25] progress on that section so it should be just this little link that's missing [0:54:29] very soon if they miss that deadline they're supposed to come back in and talk to the city council to get an extension on it so we expect something [0:54:41] So Aaron, back to that question of Nicky's on stadium. [0:54:56] If you combine those two and did them together, could that be a two-year overlap? [0:55:03] Is there any way to break that out so you could do somehow half in this budget year? [0:55:08] Half in next? [0:55:10] For all the stadium we're talking about, we said we could construct the others. [0:55:29] There's options I did not break the design costs out of those, but they're in both of them [0:55:34] So you could okay, and then the second question is on [0:55:39] Baxter Park [0:55:40] When what was our plan and maybe Travis can answer that when we build that park and putting the sidewalk in [0:55:47] Typically, that's what we required developers to do that correct. Yeah [0:55:57] So the first piece on Baxter's Park is that it was [0:56:00] constructed out of a series of donations and the donations went for the construction of the park [0:56:07] it didn't necessarily go around the infrastructure and then in addition to that there was some question [0:56:12] about tying the infrastructure of the curb gutter inside walk back into the road. [0:56:17] First choice was the Medrona Street North project like to see that intersection finished and done [0:56:32] where we've already been working and that balanced to our 770 with the different list of projects in there. [0:56:41] there's nothing on this list I don't like but I just like the idea of having that [0:56:47] corner there were some things on to as well just as a reminder we always do [0:57:05] and say the capital be budget a hundred fifty thousand dollars up to see so you [0:57:09] do have your 717 process but is it something any concern what would I don't [0:57:41] share I don't believe there was any right away we could see it's efficient [0:57:49] So, Armin asked for, which just comes over to $10,600 for Worthy. [0:58:16] I was looking at the replacement of the AEDs for the police. [0:58:20] I also was looking 18. [0:58:28] And if we took a big chunk away from sidewalks, the other thing that I think the street departments [0:58:33] need for that John Deere loader, I know that's a large item, but I thought that one was also [0:58:38] something that was worth considering at this time. [0:58:42] also the train this is on the long-term planning committee but the training [0:58:47] equipment for the pool $4,000 was something else that was on my list and [0:58:54] they're all shut up and want something else here on the top of my list also [0:59:06] like the easier way to do it Christopher Reed so Elizabeth Street [0:59:58] designed so that 94,000 drive this one yeah easily drive [1:00:14] replacement is for 18,000 police red dog pistol sighting 12,600 and the parks pick up replacement vehicle [1:00:37] 30,000 which brings us to $769,400 so $600 short of what we have to spend [1:00:48] understanding that there's gonna be some wiggle room and things like that all up [1:00:56] the streets and everything in category B is worthy. [1:01:00] I was looking at it, but understanding we have, [1:01:03] what was the perks when the pickup replacement vehicle [1:01:19] for 30,000? [1:01:37] So I too have these sidewalk projects [1:01:41] prefer the Madrona Street, I think, [1:01:45] where we've put that new light in. [1:01:47] And now these kids are really walking down Madrona. [1:01:50] I think it would be a worthy consideration. [1:01:55] And then Travis refreshed my memory, but didn't we fund when we had our budget amendment in last spring, all of the spent category B? [1:02:10] We were based upon revenues that are coming in above projections. [1:02:14] The entire list of category B was able to be funded at the conclusion of the second quarter. [1:02:20] It's the same process that we would use in upcoming years, [1:02:25] or this upcoming year is that we would analyze not only expenses, [1:02:29] but as revenues come in, we would then re-present [1:02:33] projects that aid council's consideration at that time performance. [1:02:40] Suppose we were to fund all of the Canada items within the 770. [1:02:59] So all of the category requires a total of out-and-access revenues [1:03:25] at that time. The conversation we've had to address the sidewalk [1:03:39] at this time of year, is that have to actually design them and get them and get them. [1:03:49] I appreciate the category class of art important, that there are slightly different critter [1:03:55] of these projects that require some pretty significant. [1:04:01] I fear it would be a sidewalk project. [1:04:16] I appreciate the stadium, but I know that road probably has the slowest traffic, [1:04:27] and for a no sidewalk area, in my opinion, it's probably one of the safer ones on this list. [1:04:33] I think Elizabeth's traffic is worse. I think the Moderna area, the Eastland, I see more [1:04:41] safety area issues in those areas than I do on stadium. With that park there and there's [1:04:46] a big dip in the road that really slows traffic down through there, I feel like personally [1:04:53] stadium would be my list for this year for this money. [1:05:00] I guess for the sake of argument, I would just say what councilman Reed presented feels like a fairly mixed-up project to me. [1:05:19] That's a good mix-up. [1:05:36] Frankly, if we don't start tackling some of these sidewalk projects, [1:05:40] and I know it's crummy that they eat up, that we've set aside, that's just the reality of it. [1:05:54] fruits there, even if a stadium won the election on the south side of the road, an issue. [1:06:25] That's correct. So, areas where we've struggled in getting projects done in the same year, [1:06:34] it always seems to bother. This project, while fairly large, on a personal one, if I were [1:06:44] to take this one, the day that I got assigned I'd start making phone calls to aggressively [1:06:53] as we construction season starts we're ready to go. So this is one that I'm pretty comfortable [1:07:00] saying we could get done this year. Medrona, it doesn't, I don't believe so on this one. [1:07:14] looked at extensively and there was no right. So, one of these and Josh just brought up in [1:07:26] this section that's there as far as the width of the street and where the sidewalk is doesn't [1:07:31] necessarily mean our transportation plan because that's new and these are old, right? So these [1:07:35] were put in before that plan was written. So what we would actually do is come to Council [1:07:39] and ask for a deviation, ask for a transportation plan. That would really be the only sentence [1:07:49] that's if we'll add to this is we dive in and get the survey and design going, we'll really [1:08:00] I know if we have it, but based on our initial research, which was fairly extensive, I don't [1:08:06] see any need for right away on those two specific projects. [1:08:10] Is Elizabeth Boulevard one? [1:08:12] We will. [1:08:20] That's a different... [1:08:23] Because Eden, here's so not to belabor stadium. [1:08:26] But if I take Elizabeth Boulevard 94-8, Madrona Street 390, Eastland 39, that leaves 250,000 [1:08:37] allocated not quite one forty two forty seven is whether we could do the [1:08:44] engineering and potentially the right away acquisition with two hundred fifty [1:08:49] thousand dollars for both sides of stadium I know that's putting you on the [1:08:58] spot but can we walk through that again I'm sorry yes so if you change the yes [1:09:09] for stadium by 75. That should total 523. And so if that gave us another 247 to potentially [1:09:32] deal with the stadium engineering design and potentially right away acquisition depending. [1:09:42] Yeah, absolutely. So the nice thing is typically design and survey comes in about 15% of what you're seeing that it costs to be. [1:09:49] That's a rough number and fluctuate a little bit based on gear. [1:09:54] So like at stadium or just kind of just rounded up to find our 15,000 or so. [1:10:02] Yeah, we can do some of the design in the first year and then construct the next year. So that's absolutely a possibility. [1:10:10] Where you could add back the first ADM 782 8 which takes us 12 8 over the [1:11:39] 770 which Travis said we could and has started first questions [1:12:01] This is not uh, you need to get this done tomorrow [1:12:06] Everything works out and we can actually get materials and all those types of things [1:12:13] Be able to complete this so materials is always a good question, right? [1:12:19] And we don't have control of that. I understand bandwidth so every October is where the engineering [1:12:24] department says that when we divvy up the assignments, we have very specific other [1:12:29] projects that we do. For example, one of my main primary responsibilities is the commercial [1:12:34] development in the city to the falls. So as you know, Travis talked today about it being [1:12:39] about 40% from last year I think is what he said. So, if you're a conversation that's not [1:12:52] correct for me. Anyway, I'm talking about it. Yeah, I'm talking about it, okay. So, materials. [1:13:02] materials. So every October is where we go through that process of making the sense. So [1:13:08] not only do we have projects that we deal with, but we have end with right now where we're [1:13:15] short one, we've received a pretty significant experience. So really we could plug that. Excellent. [1:13:27] I guess I have a question on the $150,000, the intent there to be designed for both Project [1:13:36] E and Project O because if that's the case, I think we might be low. It's usually about [1:13:40] I would assume a 20% design cost of $200,000. [1:13:45] He said 15, so. [1:13:47] 15 to 20, but at this juncture, I would say whatever we could get done, whatever you guys could pull off with that leftover money in there to start designing the stadium project for next year, I think is what we're after. [1:14:01] It's one side, it's one side, but it's both sides. [1:14:04] How to answer your figure out what projects we're going to get to that point. [1:14:34] There isn't a way reals, whether it's individuals, whether we find out that there's issues, whatever it is. [1:14:43] These funds be reallocated to category B. [1:14:50] The process that determine whether or not the 150 out doesn't. [1:15:03] There's an opportunity for them. [1:15:06] Anytime that we change your allocation, we credit by staff. [1:15:13] See, there's a possibility if the engineering goes over a little bit, we can still. [1:15:21] In addition, we have in which Jonathan, we also have the CDBG funds, which we've talked about, sidewalks. [1:15:33] But with the Census, out in income Census tracts, we're entirely certain. [1:15:46] Just in those Census tracts, we're going to resources and so many that in CDBG will be able to approach [1:15:58] how those Census tracts have changed since the last since 2010. [1:16:04] Did you have something I could see you, uh, it should be able to tell us something? [1:16:10] I was, I did have for council understanding, I see a $390,000 project. [1:16:34] Maybe it's September-directed, weather hits, and like in 18 months, is that unacceptable? [1:16:55] We, we know if we don't get started on these now, they'll never hit anywhere. [1:17:08] Based on our code and staff levels, that ambitious. [1:17:12] So I like the thought of having a plan that I was outlined, um, and in case possible to do, [1:17:28] to do with the understanding that it might be 18, 20 months window for some of [1:17:33] these, um, made it survey Baxter Parks pretty standard in Eastland. So out of [1:17:49] that list probably the drona would be the very good say then or like catches my eye. [1:17:55] The nice thing about splitting off another thing to nice thing about [1:18:01] splitting design off this next year when we come and we start talking about [1:18:05] what we want to fund. We have I'm ready to make a motion but I have one quick [1:18:25] question Travis would you rather we allocated 770 so I dropped the 150 down a [1:18:32] little or is 782 8 okay so there's not really a motion what you're doing what [1:18:48] we're looking is for a collection of head not okay because it's listed as a [1:18:53] discussion item and so what we want is consensus from the council say in the [1:19:09] $770,000 we went from dust-tighten up operations [1:19:22] Okay, I claim a senior moment [1:19:42] You know, they're all great projects [1:19:47] and it's really hard to choose, I don't fill in many ways [1:19:51] because I haven't been on council long enough [1:19:55] that I do feel that we need to go to sidewalk [1:20:03] it seems like that's what we can still fill in the last year [1:20:14] which was thanks [1:20:32] Aaron's wondering why he inherited this entire project [1:20:38] I have John, and we've heard of those in the air, John. [1:20:41] Congratulations on your promotion. [1:20:44] Okay. [1:20:45] One last item was that we do have a month and a half dollar from the sidewalk grant, so we could use some of that potentially to fund some of these if we can get it on too quickly, so there's a little bit more money there potentially. [1:20:56] I have Greg and I have four months left, and we want to be in the ribbon cutting of these December 31st, so there you go. [1:21:02] No pressure. [1:21:06] Travis will let you finish your presentation. [1:21:13] So, tonight really was the last long extended conversation and thank you to the council, [1:21:21] but also I think that when we start talking about being an employer of choice, the value [1:21:28] of team and retention, I don't know if that just took place before your organization. [1:21:46] So, tonight was really the last large presentation that we have for our budget conversation. [1:21:54] We started this conversation internally, shortly after the first of the year, and having conversations with the City Council in April, we followed up in May, we followed up in June. [1:22:08] And then the calendar of the printed budget is up there. [1:22:14] You can see that the course of the entire summer we've been engaged in really took us areas for the city. [1:22:29] Next week, in addition to that, we'll have an answer asking you to the budget as we've presented. [1:22:41] So, as you have questions, there's still opportunities to engage. [1:22:46] There's obviously clear opportunities for citizen input, not only this evening, but also in the budgeting process, or in the public hearing process. [1:22:54] So, as you have questions, as you have thought, as we're approaching that, I love it that we're in the process. [1:23:01] Please feel free to reach out to staff as you have questions and have a process. [1:23:09] I'm happy to stand for any questions for traffic. [1:23:20] So at the end of our budget discussions, [1:23:22] we always have a chance for public comment on the budget. [1:23:26] And so that's really been our agenda. [1:23:28] We're gonna say if you would like to come discuss [1:23:30] anything about the budget with the council, [1:23:33] now is your opportunity, [1:23:34] or if you have something you would like to say [1:23:37] that was not on this evening's agenda, [1:23:40] we're gonna wrap both public speaking times up into one here. [1:23:44] So if you would like to address the council, [1:23:45] come forward, we'll give you this tonight. [1:24:02] Oh, two quick things. [1:24:04] First of all, sort of last minute, just because I [1:24:07] were at it over the weekend and just wanted to mention it. [1:24:09] I just wanted to recognize the brave men and women in Kabul, [1:24:12] Afghanistan, that are dying right now, [1:24:14] because our federal government abandoned them. [1:24:17] And the other thing that I wanted to mention was the CDC [1:24:20] has come out with new guidelines, again, [1:24:23] I drew you to several of them. [1:24:27] And I just wanted to ask pretty brief questions [1:24:31] and have answers for them great. [1:24:33] But if not, I would hope that you guys would consider it. [1:24:37] So the first one is, well, first of all, the Idaho state law for under age consent for getting vaccinated, is that parents don't have to give their consent. It's up to the health care worker. So that's something that I think the public needs to know. [1:24:53] But the three questions that I want to ask is, do you have any plan? The second one is, will you pledge not to impose any kind of vaccine mandate for business owners or city employees or like that? [1:25:18] I just wanted to thank you for coming this evening and I the council has not engaged in any new discussions like that [1:25:38] And should we it would be definitely council this evening on anything [1:26:09] For us [1:27:23] I'd just like to thank the staff tonight, you'd see even tonight as we were making saucy. [1:27:33] I think it was good saucy, but we were making saucy's up here. [1:27:36] I could see conferences all over the room to provide us with a different additional information [1:27:41] with Jonathan coming down from the planning zone in perspective. [1:27:44] I could see Jonathan Kate here, and Jonathan Kate here, [1:27:47] and really interested as we were talking as well, [1:27:50] and then the two engineers getting together, [1:27:52] and I would hope that we could get another engineer hired as soon as possible [1:27:56] this is possible so we can give them some additional help. [1:27:59] Absolutely. It was really fun watching it from this perspective tonight and seeing the engagement from the different departments. [1:28:06] It makes you feel really less to live in a city where our team can work together the way we watched it have tonight. [1:28:14] Very supported. Absolutely. Only announcement. I had this evening is to remind the Everinsville-Crisis-Lunder. [1:28:23] Thursday night, six o'clock in our downtown comments is the Rock Paper Scissors competition [1:28:30] and I'm lucky enough to represent the City of Twin Falls. [1:28:35] So please come and cheer for us. [1:28:37] We want to have a good showing and if anybody has any tips or tricks or scientific background [1:28:45] on what you should do, where you should start, I'd be open for any health or coaching I could [1:28:50] get. [1:28:51] Okay, he's on anything from the city manager's office. [1:29:03] So we have no public hearings this evening, but we do have a request to adjourn into executive session under Idaho Code 74-2061-V to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member, or industry. [1:29:29] or individual agent or a public school student. [1:29:34] Second. [1:29:36] We have a motion from the key boy, seconded by Ruth Pierce, [1:29:40] to adjourn into executive session as was just read. [1:29:44] Amy, roll call vote, please. [1:29:47] Key boy. [1:29:49] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:29:50] Yes. [1:29:51] Frank Lanting. [1:29:53] As I've said, I've always wanted to do this in my last 16 years. [1:29:56] No. [1:29:57] There's a difference. [1:29:59] Yes. [1:30:00] Yes, Christopher Reed and Schonberg, motion passes six to one so we will be adjourning into [1:30:09] executive session. [1:30:11] We will not be making any decisions and we will not be reconvening this meeting. [1:30:16] So with that, we're adjourned.