Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-08-02, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-08-02/ [0:01:38] members are in attendance this evening these rise for the pledge of [0:01:43] proclamations this evening so we will move forward to the consent calendar and [0:02:14] I will turn it to the council. Ruth Pierce? Yes Mayor I move we approve the [0:02:22] consent calendar. We have a motion from Ruth Pierce seconded by Sean [0:02:29] to approve the consent calendar as printed. [0:02:33] Give me roll call vote please. [0:02:35] Yes. Yes. Yes. [0:02:40] Yes. Yes. Thank you. [0:02:48] This is 7-0. If you are here this evening for the Twin Falls Old Town Criterion, [0:02:54] that was just approved with all of our other house going to move on to our items of consideration. [0:03:03] And first this evening we have a presentation on the finances of the City of Twin Falls for the third quarter. [0:03:10] And we have our Chief Financial Officer, Brianna Howard, the C.E. [0:05:13] for the City of Twin Falls and talk about the budget as a whole. [0:05:17] And where we are at currently, and talk about the enterprise funds, [0:05:22] where we said to compare it against the nation and going forward. [0:05:27] So this first slide has a couple of graphs. [0:05:31] The first graph shows the total budget as it is split into our [0:05:35] Property tax are tax-supported funds and are non-tax-supported funds. [0:05:40] The 40% is our most-ier enterprise funds, which are water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:05:46] And the tax-supported funds at 60% is right around 46 million. [0:05:50] So when we talk about the property taxes that we receive or what we most of our general fund [0:05:55] is, that's off of the 60% category. [0:05:58] The major fund composition is a recap of what makes up most of those funds. [0:06:04] General Fund is 38% as most, water is at 17%, wastewater and street are just under 13 and 12%. [0:06:16] This next slide shows the fund composition for our tax supported funds. The General Fund makes [0:06:23] up 64% so most of our tax supported funds is allocated to the General Fund and then the second [0:06:30] one is that streets at 20%. Our largest contributing revenue sources are from property taxes, [0:06:36] 52% comes from property taxes at $23.9 million. [0:06:41] The total revenues in the tax-supported funds make up 46 million. [0:06:46] The six largest revenue sources make up 88%. [0:06:51] Included in other is airport revenues and permits. [0:06:58] This next slide is our property taxes for the last four years. [0:07:04] We budget right around so normally we get 3% increase in property taxes with [0:07:09] the annexation and new construction. [0:07:11] So you can see from 2018 starting at 20 million, [0:07:15] up to the 23 million that we have budgeted [0:07:17] for this last fiscal year. [0:07:19] This last fiscal year was quite different [0:07:21] because of Governor Little's plan [0:07:24] and the amount that we received when we received it. [0:07:28] So currently at a property tax, [0:07:29] as we've only received 12 million, [0:07:31] as opposed to the 14 almost 15 million last year. [0:07:35] But if you'll remember, [0:07:36] we actually opted into Governor Little's plan, [0:07:38] of three cities, fuel, Kimberly and us, and that was $5.2 million that we pushed back to [0:07:45] our residents in the city of Twin Falls. So we've received $12 million plus the $5 million [0:07:51] that we received earlier on the year, which gives us a total of $17,497. We actually just [0:07:57] received the last $6 million, $6.8 last week. So we've received 100 percent just shortly [0:08:06] after this close. I talked with Becky Peterson at the Twin Falls County and [0:08:12] she says collections are at 97.97% and she actually said when I was on the phone [0:08:17] with her that we are blessed to live in the city of Twin Falls and as I go for [0:08:22] some of these numbers you'll see that like last time we are starting sky [0:08:26] rocketing ahead our other states in the nation. This next slide shows our [0:08:35] for major revenue sources outside of property taxes. [0:08:39] Franchise fees, 4% of the total revenues [0:08:42] and the tax-supported funds. [0:08:44] And I have a detailed slide a little bit in the next one. [0:08:47] Last year, we'd received 78%, we're just over that at 89%. [0:08:52] And most of that is because of our power, [0:08:54] because of the hot summer that we are experiencing. [0:08:59] State share revenues, we've received quarterly 78%, [0:09:03] We're at 86% this year at $4.1 million. [0:09:07] This is an item that we will start to see more closely [0:09:11] budgeted in the next few years, [0:09:13] because the state legislature capped us at 1% [0:09:16] in population size. [0:09:18] So in the past where we've seen excess money [0:09:20] coming from state revenue sharing, [0:09:22] we won't going forward as we start narrowing down [0:09:25] what that 1% cap is gonna look like. [0:09:29] Highway actually is a number that can be influenced [0:09:32] by the economy. [0:09:33] So we're at 102% and we are ahead of the three-year average. [0:09:38] We've received a one-time payment of $563,000, [0:09:43] but this money also comes from vehicle registration fees, [0:09:46] state fuel taxes, and other transportation-related fees, [0:09:49] such as fines and forficures. [0:09:51] So we are significantly over in our highway money. [0:09:56] The next slide breaks up the franchise fees. [0:09:59] We've got gas, electric, and cable. [0:10:02] Gas is the first one in red over the last few years. [0:10:05] It's relatively consistent around 310,000 until 2018. [0:10:10] And that's when we had a record cold year [0:10:12] with daily cold temperatures. [0:10:15] As opposed to 18 electric this year, [0:10:19] we've gotten $1.1 million, which is the flip side. [0:10:23] We've had record high temperatures for months on end, [0:10:26] and we are receiving more from electric companies. [0:10:30] Cable's small enough itself continues to decline every year. [0:10:34] There was an article in the county today quoted Brendan Carr, a Republican member for [0:10:38] the Federal Communications Commission, saying, we're taxing the telephone networks to pay [0:10:43] for the broadband network that's like taxing horseshoes to pay for highways. [0:10:49] Carr, another interview, also said one way to do that is by getting companies such as [0:10:53] Amazon, Google, and Netflixe to pay. [0:10:56] If and when I've listened to Travis's presentations enough on sales tax in 1% and yes, knowing [0:11:06] that would probably. I think that's the last time that I probably answered me and I've [0:11:10] forgotten already is that strictly television or do we yet the franchise fee on the internet? [0:11:15] That's television only cable and PMT is what cable that requires state law [0:11:19] change to be able to collect it on internet or not. As internet's where with [0:11:24] everybody pulling the flag supposedly everybody's going to stream services [0:11:27] which are not be taxed because that's your internet so I wanted to have that [0:11:32] We'll take a state law to help us set on that or not. [0:11:38] So I think it's important to look at a franchise fee as a rent. [0:11:43] So the franchise fee is a rent for individuals [0:11:46] to be able to write some way, not necessarily [0:11:51] a risk inside of a kid. [0:12:02] Because of how a franchise fee is set up, [0:12:05] which gives them the right to utilize our right of ways, [0:12:09] franchise fee is the rent that they pay for that entirely [0:12:14] certain the city of New Falls can make a clear waste. [0:12:18] But when you start looking at streaming services [0:12:20] that are going to be coming through a satellite provider of service. [0:12:29] You have the cable and it runs on the same lines. [0:12:38] It's in our street as the television signal does. [0:12:41] And I think that we've had conversations in the past [0:12:43] about how that's protected as a form of communication. [0:12:46] But Ching can jump into that so big, [0:12:49] leaves that it might be more. [0:12:54] And that's correct. [0:12:54] We're seeing a lot of different municipalities [0:12:58] wrestle with this idea because you can have one provider come in [0:13:01] and lay infrastructure that with fiber that could run [0:13:05] both cable and internet. As you're describing here, there are certain state [0:13:09] laws for some of those providers that say cities you can't have a separate [0:13:14] franchise agreement. We're actually working through that that balance right [0:13:17] now as to are you truly a telephone? Are you truly a cable? Are you just providing [0:13:22] internet? And so it's not real easy to answer the question because a lot of [0:13:27] companies do all of those things and expect whatever law at state level helps [0:13:33] in the best. And so we're negotiating with a couple of companies right now that are wanting [0:13:37] to come into Twin Falls with the fiber, for example, and they provide us a certificate saying [0:13:43] you know we've registered with the state of Idaho as a video provider therefore we should [0:13:50] just get a right-of-way permit and be done and know that's long-winded way of saying it really [0:13:59] depends on the company that's coming in. [0:14:08] I think that's something to consider, for example, a one-service at my home, but I only use it for internet, and so I think that that's something to [0:14:28] dust that same others and that is relative association about those or someone else to... [0:14:58] Statewide for broadband, and I assume that's going to come in as we see who's... [0:15:16] The states are struggling with the same issue that the taxes of franchise fees are coming from, something that's irrelevant. [0:15:33] This next slide shows where we are at budget to actual expenditures. [0:15:52] The red is what we budgeted for the year, and the yellow is where we have come in. [0:15:58] Right now the 74% is deceptive, it seems like that's very close to the 75%, but what you'll [0:16:04] see here and with water and wastewater, water and sanitation specifically is we actually [0:16:12] have, we're on a biweekly of pay scale, so we have one extra pay check, so that would [0:16:16] be you'd almost think that we should be just above 75%, which is like everybody in the [0:16:21] city in the nation, we are significantly our labor shortage and the expense. So we are [0:16:31] actually under budget in personnel but it's not by will, it's by the amount of positions. [0:16:39] So deceptive at 74%, it's less than what we budgeted and it's not where we want to be. [0:16:45] M&O is pretty close right around 75%. It's at 5.8 million. Our capital is less because [0:16:56] of streets. So typically streets does most of their work later on towards the end of this [0:17:01] quarter and then the last part of the year. Last year we were actually pretty close to [0:17:06] right around the same dollar amount. The biggest projects that we've got going is Hankins Road [0:17:12] and Seal Coating the $6.7 million. So once we see those come to fruition, we'll start [0:17:18] to see that actually this last quarter we're going to see that. That go back to where it [0:17:22] It should be. [0:17:25] It transfers are high because of our annual sweep from the capital improvement to, or from [0:17:33] the capital improvement. [0:17:37] We're at 72%. [0:17:38] Next couple slides, we've talked a little bit in the past about our building permits because [0:17:48] it's astronomical. [0:17:49] What we're seeing today is not normal and we see it all over Twin Falls. [0:17:55] As you can see, we've budgeted $1.1 million [0:17:58] for our building permit revenue, [0:17:59] and we're at 141% at $1.6 million. [0:18:06] We've budgeted slightly down. [0:18:08] You remember, we're always a year, year and a half, [0:18:11] and we've budgeted slightly down because of COVID, [0:18:14] and nobody knew what was gonna happen. [0:18:16] Obviously, things hindsight is 2020, [0:18:18] and we all know construction across the nation [0:18:21] is off the boards. [0:18:24] The next slide I showed this last time [0:18:27] is our building permit revenue, [0:18:28] it's interesting because we've actually seen the slight softening. You can see we [0:18:33] had what we're at 1.6 million right now with 1.8 million from 2020. You can see [0:18:40] since 2006 where our building permit revenue has been. So currently through [0:18:47] three-quarters of the year we have issued 417 new single-family home [0:18:53] permits through the third quarter of the year. If you take that number divided by [0:18:58] 75% just all things equal. He would get 556 permits that we would estimate would be issued [0:19:05] through year end. I did that exact same calculation last quarter assuming it was conservative because [0:19:11] we still had our summer building months to go. Last year, our last quarter, it was 306 divided by [0:19:18] So just conservatively, all things equal, measuring out, we're softening a little bit [0:19:28] in what we're seeing from our building permit history. [0:19:33] Last year the new single family permits were 573 for the total year. [0:19:38] So if we're at 556, then that's less than what we had last year. [0:19:42] In the fiscal year 2007, totaled 641. [0:19:47] So we're still in a great year, but it's probably not as great as what we have potentially projected [0:19:53] last quarter. [0:19:54] Next one's of the fun ones, like I said, I'm competitive, I have a good time looking at [0:20:05] laser reports, this market is what's going on in our inter-nation. [0:20:09] So the rental market, so Travis hits the housing market a lot, so I took some of those lights [0:20:13] out so I don't worry a little bit. [0:20:15] The rental market is crazy, it's off the charts. [0:20:18] This graph here is printed from a part list national rental report, and it shows the [0:20:23] the change since March 2020 among the 10 cities with the largest rent increases. [0:20:31] Leading the trend, they said, is Boise, Idaho, where rents grew by a staggering 6.6% just [0:20:36] over the past month. This is the fastest month over month growth rate among the nation's 100 [0:20:42] largest cities. And Boise also continues to rank number one for fastest year over year [0:20:47] growth. On this chart, it shows you Boise, Idaho was a total of 31% with Spokane, Washington [0:20:54] at 22% and a couple of other cities, California and Samarazona. [0:21:00] It also states the pandemic, [0:21:01] which we've heard pandemic did not necessarily [0:21:04] serve a new trend in these markets, [0:21:06] so much as accelerated an existing one. [0:21:08] So by May, Boise has grown to a two-bedroom house [0:21:12] being rented for $1,229, [0:21:15] which means it's just at 2.1 times that of San Francisco, [0:21:21] or San Francisco's 2.1 times of Boise. [0:21:24] I guess that just kind of caught me off guard. [0:21:26] You think of California, you think of the higher rents, [0:21:30] and you think of Boise being at 1229. [0:21:33] So I talked to Steve Irwin at First Federal [0:21:36] and got some stats for Twin Falls that he has seen [0:21:39] in a two-bedroom in Twin Falls. [0:21:40] It's right around $1,000, a one-bedroom at 800, [0:21:44] and just for kicks and giggles, three-bedroom is 1,400. [0:21:48] We are getting almost unaffordable. [0:21:51] So when I talk about rental market, talk about CPI, talk about these next couple slides, [0:21:56] it's all in relation to what are our employees experiencing, what can they afford? [0:22:01] When we talk about pay raises, we talk about things that we can provide, it all relates [0:22:06] to what are we seeing in the market. [0:22:07] And the rental market is crazy. [0:22:10] This next slide is kind of a fun graph. [0:22:13] And it's by Apartment List, apartment guide, it's a rent report. [0:22:19] The year-over-year state comparison of two-bedroom houses, you can see by the color, so red, [0:22:27] deep red actually, is the highest amount of increase. [0:22:31] Idaho is 58 percent, Louisiana is 45 percent, and a whole lot of greens and light pinks [0:22:42] and negatives. [0:22:43] Paper Market. [0:22:51] This is something that was put together by Advisor Smith from March 2019 to March 2021. [0:22:58] Idaho is ranked as at 4.1% in job growth, only three states in the nation added jobs. [0:23:06] Twenty states were above the national average, but only three states added. [0:23:11] What was interesting here is if you look at this graph on the right, the small cities [0:23:16] were number eight, as every small city in the entire United States were at 1.3% in job growth. [0:23:25] There's some other instant comparison there that I've listed, which is intriguing when you look at our 3.3% unemployment rate, as opposed to 5.9% federal, and you look at twin. [0:23:40] I don't know if you guys have driven around lately. [0:23:45] This is a bunch of pictures I compiled and has some help from some people. [0:23:49] I drive blue lakes. [0:23:51] Travis has told me multiple times he avoids it, so maybe you have not seen blue lakes. [0:23:55] These are mostly blue lakes. This is all of our businesses. Dairy Queen, that one's a fun one. [0:24:03] Fifteen day help for managers. It's across the board. [0:24:07] So as a couple of stats, in May 11th, Governor Little ended Idaho's participation in the federal unemployment program. [0:24:14] I don't know if you remembered, but we were third in the nation to do that. [0:24:19] I thought that was pretty good. Don't know why we weren't first, but I thought it was pretty good that we were third. [0:24:24] We're now part of 21 states, and I think Travis has shared multiple times, too, about [0:24:30] the 3% equating to 900 people, and then you see this, we almost wonder why isn't it 0% [0:24:36] AMP-y, economics won't let you, but it's crazy. [0:24:40] We are in a nationwide shortage that economists say is plaguing employers. [0:24:45] We've seen creative hiring strategies from one I've read. [0:24:49] They are hiring workers out of state and boarding them, using middle-men's recruit, which is [0:24:54] costly measure. Indeed, jobs are changed and reported that 4.1% of all job postings advertised [0:25:01] have hiring incentives. Sign-on and retention bonuses, one-time cash payments, which has not [0:25:06] been typical in the past. What are we seeing in the city? We have Twin Falls. I've got some numbers [0:25:14] from Kristen for the City of Twin Falls. She says applications here to date meet calendar year [0:25:21] is 755. 2020 just last year we saw 1430, 2019, [0:25:28] 1,098. Job postings, 53 here to date, last year was 62, and then 77. [0:25:38] Kristen has shared with me that candid it responses down as well as several [0:25:42] are not responding to requests to complete testing or schedule interviews. [0:25:46] We've had more repeated postings as compared to the last two. [0:25:50] Gretchen has shared with me that we typically turn over 10% of our organization each year. [0:25:55] I wonder what these numbers are going to do. What does this mean? What does it mean for the [0:26:08] labor market? Average producer prices for truck transportation rose 10% in April from a year ago. [0:26:16] In an interview with chief executives of chef's warehouse, a $1 billion Bronx-based [0:26:22] food supplier for restaurants, hotels, and other businesses, said labor shortages are quickly [0:26:27] translating into higher prices for consumers. 54% increase in 35 pound tub of [0:26:33] canola and soybean fry oil. 30% increase in kosher salt, chocolate and olive oil. [0:26:38] 20% increase in meat. I've begun out to eat lately. I just went last week, North [0:26:47] End of town. A salad cost $13. A cup of soup that I added on this $5. I paid for the meal [0:26:57] and walked out with the $50 bill. [0:26:59] Two. [0:27:00] Here's a local place down here I use like to eat. [0:27:04] I'm parocal. [0:27:05] I don't like to spend a ton of money. [0:27:06] It was $7.95. [0:27:07] I thoroughly enjoyed it. [0:27:08] It was great. [0:27:09] Pre-COVID. [0:27:10] Post-COVID? [0:27:11] $12.95. [0:27:14] I hate to admit it, [0:27:15] but ever since I've had a child, [0:27:17] I go to McDonald's frequently. [0:27:19] And I was astonished when I ordered a small fry [0:27:22] because it didn't come with whatever I was ordering. [0:27:26] I'm pretty sure there's like 15 fries in that small fry. [0:27:28] I mean, it's quite small. [0:27:30] $1.99 for small fry. We hear in the news, hey, your workers more. I stand to say they are, [0:27:39] and I'm pushing it to the consumer. In a tight margin industry, I wonder if the people crying [0:27:45] this initiative realize there's no such thing as a free lunch. CPI, Travis has talked about CPI a [0:27:54] little bit too. Headline CPI includes volatile food and energy prices which is more unreliable. [0:28:00] Of course, CPI excludes these. [0:28:03] The headline CPI is the highest level since 2008. [0:28:07] Or CPI since 1996. [0:28:11] When we talk about our staff, our employees, what are we going to do? [0:28:17] How are we going to support them? [0:28:19] How are we going to support them to live? [0:28:21] It's with this and what can they buy? [0:28:24] Purchase and a home. [0:28:27] Economic snapshot. [0:28:32] There was a quote saying the Fed views the recent jumps and prices as transitory, [0:28:36] We will not know the answer for at least a few more months as the domestic and global [0:28:40] supply chains gradually unclog and resume normal functioning and our price funds. [0:28:51] This is the next section, talking about the business like functions. [0:28:54] They don't make a profit, but we charge fees to cover the services that are offered. [0:29:02] We budgeted conservatively again in 2021 because we didn't know. [0:29:06] We didn't know what COVID was going to bring. [0:29:07] We figured people would be more concerned about and for food than watering their lawns. [0:29:12] And we have been proven wrong. [0:29:14] As you can see, we've collected 77%. [0:29:17] So I had a number of interesting conversations [0:29:19] with Travis today, so if I put for this, [0:29:21] or any of the water crew, if I put through this, [0:29:23] let me know. [0:29:24] So when you look at this number, 5.3 million, [0:29:27] and it's it indicates we're using water, [0:29:31] you walk a drive around Twin Falls, [0:29:33] there's a lot of green lawns out there. [0:29:35] And you think, well, what's going on? [0:29:41] This is new information to me. [0:29:43] So what I've understood is pressurize irrigation is very different than normal water. [0:29:50] So what happens is most of our houses that have come up since early 2000s are on pressurize irrigation. [0:29:58] So pressurize irrigation has to do with flow and how the resources get to each house. [0:30:05] So in all these newer homes, all these newer areas since 2000, we have smaller canals with more water [0:30:13] to get rapid water movement versus larger canals with low water that doesn't move. [0:30:19] So if you think about it, if everybody on pressurize irrigation stops using water, [0:30:24] it would overflow. So the way our system works with pressurize irrigation is you have to use water. [0:30:32] So if you're on pressurize irrigation, it's okay to use water. Did I butcher that? Am I okay? [0:30:38] I think you're okay, yep, you did good. [0:30:42] I'm not definitely not necessarily an ag person, I'm a numbers person, and I can tell you it looks right. [0:30:48] We're seeing quite a bit in our water. [0:30:51] The other thing I might add to that is the pressures of irrigation. [0:30:56] You have to find one that works in your neighborhood, and that may be a three in the afternoon. [0:31:01] Because that's when the water's there. [0:31:03] It may not be there in three in the morning when you think you should be watering. [0:31:06] Because that's what everybody else wants to water. [0:31:08] That's why you see it in fresh rice irrigation [0:31:10] a little more throughout the day [0:31:13] because that's how it can help [0:31:14] whoever's it can never. [0:31:15] 24 hours it doesn't go for more [0:31:17] at night than it does during the day. [0:31:19] So. [0:31:20] Okay, make sense. [0:31:21] We have Ruth Pearson and Schunkberger. [0:31:24] So the other thing is, this doesn't include July, [0:31:28] August, July being super hot. [0:31:31] Do you happen to know what the fourth quarter [0:31:34] from last year dollar amount was? [0:31:37] I don't know if tough my head, [0:31:38] I mean it'd be interesting to see but we're going to end up it appears to me 100% over [0:31:44] 100% of budget. [0:31:46] I would guess based on the numbers and where we're at that we are going to be over 100%. [0:31:58] It's not as good of a thing as being inside the general fund where you can use that for [0:32:04] other sources with the water and wastewater. [0:32:07] There's specific state laws that allows you to only use that excess for the water fund [0:32:14] the wastewater fund or the sanitation fund which is okay as we'll hear from [0:32:17] water and wastewater and sanitation or water wastewater later they have quite a [0:32:21] few projects that they need to use but my guess is is that we are projecting [0:32:25] that we are going to be over on water well that goes into reserves to those [0:32:29] in the reserves or to help with maintenance so we don't lose it yes big [0:32:33] projects it's just not as fun as being able to use it for everything [0:32:38] So just an observation, and there might be a question rolled in there too. [0:32:46] So actually at 77% we're not significantly over where we would anticipate this time of [0:32:52] year. [0:32:53] No, but I agree with Ruth's analysis that we are still hitting some of the hotter months [0:32:57] too, so we might see more in that last quarter. [0:33:00] Though with pressure irrigation that's a flat fee around, so it doesn't flush away based [0:33:04] upon over usage or additional usage. [0:33:07] So, maybe this is just a majority of our water users who are using that for you. [0:33:14] That's the breakdown of irrigation versus potable water. [0:33:18] But just, I mean, that's an observation is that, yes, much like the electricity and gas that we see fluctuate with cold weather and hot weather. [0:33:34] We see that some with water though, whatever percentages, pressure irrigation doesn't fluctuate. [0:33:40] Yes, so from the Council, good to see you guys again. [0:33:44] I think we have roughly irrigation, but the total usage in town, it's not what bikes, pressurize irrigation fields. [0:34:38] So we don't care. [0:35:11] We saw that by sure, pressurize irrigation. [0:35:15] The next slide is expenditure wise. [0:35:25] Personnel is the same issue. We are understaffed. [0:35:30] We are not full. So we personnel is the largest expense, 19% of our total expenditure side for water. [0:35:37] And we're under. [0:35:38] It's typical for water to spend most of their maintenance and operation expenses during [0:35:43] the summer months, similar to straits, so we are less at 50% than what we would expect 75%. [0:35:50] But it's not as even keeled divided by 12 months. [0:35:56] After talking with Rob a little bit too, they are still experiencing huge lead times on [0:36:00] meters and other parts sometimes 12 weeks or more. [0:36:04] So we are hoping to spend 100% of the M&O, but there might be outside forces that are going [0:36:10] to have to struggle with. [0:36:13] Capital's 27% of the total budget expenditures, some of the larger projects that we budgeted [0:36:18] for that are not significantly started, is solid wall number 5. [0:36:22] That's at 2.1 million, the digester boiler replacement for 550,000. [0:36:28] Only 11% of what we've been budgeted so far has been spent on the water side. [0:36:33] That is another one that should be small, we only have two payments, we pay twice a year, [0:36:41] interest in March, principal interest in September. [0:36:43] We've had quite a few conversations on the bond and we will be paying off that bond in [0:36:48] September of principal interest which will leave us with only two bonds left. [0:36:53] 2012 bond, that's 355,000 and the 2017 bond for 1.5 million. [0:36:59] most of our dad and the water fund will be going away for the next time we talk. [0:37:06] Overall, we spend about 36% of our budget, which is not abnormal for water because of the timing. [0:37:13] Waste water is a lot more consistent, and we don't have much fluctuation. [0:37:24] So the last three years, four years, you can see here, we typically are 6.8 to 7, just over 7 million, [0:37:31] and we're at 76%. We're pretty close to where we budget from year to year. [0:37:36] On the expenditure side, personnel is not the highest because we contract most of that service out, [0:37:44] but we're at 66.4%, which is the same story as everything else, we're understaffed, [0:37:53] and we don't have, we're not expending the 75% that we've anticipated. In the wastewater fund, [0:38:00] we spend about 53.8%, maybe 5% the way through the year. Enterprise fund is sanitation, [0:38:11] which is much more consistent than the other ones, and not a lot of fluctuation. [0:38:15] Sanitation is about 3.5 million, of which we're just over 78% and on the expenditure [0:38:24] side, there's not much at all, M&O and some transfers, transfers are spot-on at 75%. [0:38:37] In total, for our enterprise funds, water revenues we've received 77% we've expended [0:38:43] We've experienced some transition in utility building and so we are working. [0:39:08] I'll have those numbers next time. [0:39:10] Also I've taken some to I like to run and so I'm always on the trail with my son and so sometimes [0:39:30] Sometimes the other day I was driving outside of sports [0:39:33] and the sun was just coming out. [0:39:35] I think I used one of the pictures [0:39:36] and I stopped the car and I jumped down. [0:39:39] James, what are you doing, Mom? [0:39:40] What are you doing? [0:39:41] I'm taking pictures of some cars honking behind me. [0:39:43] This is important. [0:39:44] It's a pretty picture. [0:39:46] That's right. [0:39:47] Priorities, very much. [0:39:56] Action item, and it is a request to increase compensation [0:40:01] for the mayor and city council. [0:40:04] we have our city attorney shay nope to walk us through all of this. [0:40:14] Members of the City Council, for the staff report attached to kind of a template ordinance, [0:40:21] what it would look like, just input 10% in terms of compensation adjustment in their workplace filler. [0:40:31] Today, just as a reminder, the ordinance has to be published 75 days prior to the election, which is November 2nd. [0:40:39] and so while there is some exact number 75 days between I believe close if there's something so [0:40:52] we really need to have by this Thursday to the each and ordinance so it can be public Thursdays [0:41:02] state statute so should the council wish to move forward with a compensation adjustment too [0:41:10] that has to be be awarded in essence this has been the rules and pass it today so we can get a bit [0:41:29] on this screen for now though but when I was anticipating as if the council wanted to discuss [0:41:40] the draft I did send late to the council of draft just so everyone's aware that [0:41:46] excludes the option of submitting some of the payment to a 125 or cafeteria type [0:41:53] plan and so just we're just discussing compensation just we'll stand for any [0:42:01] questions the council has and I'll try to give there's edits that need to be made [0:42:05] we can make those we can pull it up on the screen and then there should that be [0:42:11] the council's wishes. The copy that is here still has the section 125 information in it. Right, but this is the one they left that [0:42:25] if it's passed for me to sign and it's still in here so I don't I just want to make sure that we're doing it. [0:42:31] like Shane Chaired should expect the amendments would be for your signature [0:42:50] Counsel in November of 2005 taking seat in [0:43:23] 2006 everybody does their math at 60 almost 16 years ago but there was a slight [0:43:30] change in compensation within a couple years of beginning on council and it [0:43:39] really wasn't an increase in compensation we just did that point when I got on we [0:43:43] We had a salary and then we had a certain amount, one to one twenty-five, every person got a thing, it was two fifty a month. [0:43:51] There was a decision made that since that was different than the regular employees were doing it, we probably wouldn't be better if we made it so it was closer to what in the same way it was being paid. [0:44:09] paid, so that $250 was moved over into the compensation portion, which didn't actually [0:44:16] increase it, it actually decreased it because the $250 was tax-free, when it was moved into [0:44:21] compensation, suddenly it was available for taxes, for low security, for perceived income [0:44:27] tax, for state income tax, everything, so actually, we actually took a reduction in [0:44:32] pay, and I believe it was 2008, as it worked out, but it was cleaner for everybody because [0:44:38] I'm not sure when we actually, the council actually got a race. [0:44:43] It had to be before 2005. [0:44:45] I don't know what our record show would probably 2000 or somewhere, I guess, that's 21 years. [0:44:52] I'm not sure what compensation race we have given to staff in those 21 years. [0:44:58] And it's been substantial. [0:44:59] Far more than we're going to be discussing tonight. [0:45:02] we have given to staff in those 21 years, and it's been substantial. Far more than we were going to be discussing tonight. [0:45:09] I'm going to throw a figure out of 15 percent. I could be persuaded to support more, or less, depending on what the council is. [0:45:22] I'm bringing this up because I'm one of the two that has already announced that I'm not running, and so nobody's going to come after me at the ballot box [0:45:31] box because I won't be there. My name won't be on the ballot, but I do think it's fair that we, [0:45:39] it's a touchy subject, it's an always-hast but that's the reason we haven't touched it for 20 years. [0:45:44] And so I'm suggesting 15% of somebody has a different number. I'm willing to listen. [0:45:50] Thank you, Ruth Pierce. So with my little geeky brain, I ran some numbers. [0:45:56] I asked Gretchen to put together the health insurance, how it had increased over the years [0:46:05] and in 2007 which is in the ordinance that that's when the last increase was, the health [0:46:11] insurance was $300 so for just four employees, employee paid. [0:46:18] So if you pull that off our balance right now, which is, I'm talking about council only [0:46:27] at this point in time 1160 that puts our base salary down at 860 if you compare [0:46:34] to the other communities that really puts us in the middle if you don't count health [0:46:40] insurance because it's a package outside their base salary. Does that make sense to [0:46:46] everybody? So and then since then it's increased another $463. So if you back off [0:46:56] Often you're at 860 and you added in another 700, whatever that puts you almost at 2000, [0:47:05] which is more like a 25 to 30% increase. [0:47:10] I'm not advocating that. [0:47:11] I'm just saying if you back us off and compare us apples to apples to the other councils who [0:47:19] meet like twice a month and don't have some of the commitments, it puts us right in the [0:47:25] metal as a base salary. So just some food for thought. So months ago that I will not be seeking [0:47:38] reelection this year and that is one of the reasons why I felt like this is a good year [0:47:43] for this conversation. When I am through with my term in December, I will have served just [0:47:49] a few months short of ten years. In those ten years, the amount of time that this job has [0:47:58] required and the energy and the emotional stress and wear and tear believe it or not [0:48:04] has definitely increased and I think we want good people to serve on our council [0:48:12] and part of that is treating each other fairly and I think it is time that we [0:48:18] acknowledge that compensation for this position is important as well as our [0:48:25] city family. We have all I know love to serve and we have served from our hearts [0:48:31] with everything else and I would not trade a minute of that but I think it is [0:48:36] fair as expenses are going up and cost of living is going up at the amount of [0:48:40] time and I mean if you look at fuel and the amount of time we spend in our [0:48:44] vehicles traveling that is all on our own expense. So we do spend money out of [0:48:50] our pocket to do this job and I think we all try to do it very well. 10% I'm [0:48:58] come 15 if that's what the council looks at and again this isn't something I'm [0:49:03] standing to benefit from. It is the right thing to do for our community so that in [0:49:08] the future we have strong leaders in these seats. I'll have to say this is the first [0:49:17] time I've ever been able to even discuss giving myself an increase. It's not the [0:49:21] most enjoyable thing to be completely honest. It's actually really awkward [0:49:25] especially talking with a lot of people. I was one of those individuals [0:49:30] that any time the federal government gave themselves an increase, so at the same time [0:49:42] understanding that people should be fairly compensated for their time. No matter what [0:49:47] job you're doing, looking at the numbers, understanding that we can go back 20 years, [0:49:57] we can go back, and there was a recession in there, so there weren't some increases or [0:50:04] decreased. I guess I have a hard time going back in time and saying pay me for [0:50:11] we should go in there should be an increase for that period of time. I [0:50:15] struggle with that because if that was the case then the council should have done [0:50:19] that at that point in time and so understanding that we just take care of [0:50:25] the time that we have right now I guess I would be in favor of an 8% that keeps [0:50:33] says that $92 a month increases not over $100, annual and I'm talking city council [0:50:39] members, an annual increase of $1,113.60, 8%. I understand it doesn't go back 20 [0:50:50] years. I wanted to keep that under $100 a month. I feel like looking at the time [0:50:59] that we've taken hasn't been an increase. We should have done an increase. We should [0:51:05] done at that point in time I'm just not comfortable saying well we haven't done [0:51:10] it for 20 years we should take it for all that period of time the max amount [0:51:17] for me with Chris this is really I see where Chris is coming from this past [0:51:43] years been relatively part of me says to us little bit and said you know you [0:52:21] look at other cities and so forth or those it's not apples to councils let me [0:52:27] twice [0:52:59] here's one question that was for Travis but Gretchen maybe and Shane my [0:53:08] My understanding is it's possible to split an increase and do part this year and part next [0:53:16] year as long as we hold it within the two-year election cycle is that correct I honestly don't [0:53:26] know the answer to that the statute the 75 days published breeding it's doing this year [0:53:38] they're doing seven and a half percent this year and seven and a half percent next year [0:53:42] I may ask because I haven't seen that did they do that in the one ordinance just it's [0:53:48] I didn't see a copy of their ordinance, I just heard it. [0:53:52] Their council members told me that. [0:53:55] So maybe we can confirm that with Travis, because it was Travis that told me that. [0:53:59] I was told that it's not as clean at once. [0:54:05] It's more transparent to just... [0:54:09] Travis, my question is... [0:54:21] And speaking to you, you thought potentially we could split a raise and do part this year and part next. [0:54:30] Is that just a... [0:54:31] So I'll look to Shane, but I believe that... [0:54:34] Huh? [0:54:36] So my understanding is there are cities that have done that, and be that... [0:54:45] What you're doing is you are defining the rates of compensation that are going to occur. [0:54:51] It is what if, let me change drastically, and we've already obligated ourselves to increase the... [0:55:22] In the code section, they're ordinance and it does ordinance because of that, you're passing the ordinance for the statute. [0:55:52] I percent basically a hundred dollars. Is it slightly over? Chris. [0:56:15] That's one sixteen. [0:56:17] Among the very small. [0:56:29] The reason I'm thinking that is because what you said is that as people for this position, there has to be some fairness in this or some. [0:56:46] Now we're asking people to give up a lot of their time, so I guess if we're only going to raise it $92, I hate to say that that's not enough to really make a difference. [0:57:10] I think it should be easily 10 or 15% and potentially more. That makes a difference in the future. [0:57:19] I also think that things could change in the next six months, and so then, but we still have to make decisions in a timely fashion, because there's a role that has to be done by Thursday. [0:57:35] done by Thursday, so I think we have to move the best that we know at this time and what [0:57:42] we think, see how the vote comes out. We do this next year, but I think it should be done [0:57:49] all at one tiny kind of substantial amount of money, but for $50 or $92 or $116, it just [0:58:02] seems like a bunch of paperwork here's... [0:58:14] Just one thing to add, the increase of cumulative for the employees over the last 14 years is [0:58:22] about 41% and it includes years where there's no increase and it's not increasing on increase [0:58:31] it's just a flat total of 41%. I kind of agree with Chris I don't I what we do and what full-time [0:58:41] employees do are very different and when I first brought this up it wasn't about [0:58:47] catching the council up to what has happened in the past with city employees to me I look at this [0:58:52] is a separate issue. We all knew what the pay was when we decided to run for this job. [0:58:59] We all did that gladly. No regrets. Right now it's just about maybe catching up a little [0:59:06] bit with the cost of living and some of the things that Brianna was discussing this evening [0:59:11] and making this job at least help cover our expenses and some of our time for the hours [0:59:18] that we do donate and I know on top of that that everybody here wants to donate to our [0:59:24] community and be giving there is a real cost to it and so try to make it so that those who [0:59:32] want to serve can serve was more of what I was looking for not catching up with past years [0:59:39] where we didn't get a raise or keeping up with the percentages that full-time employees [0:59:45] make this is not a full-time job and so more just kind of getting us current with [0:59:51] where what is a fair compensation 10% was where I started and that was the [1:00:01] number I threw out and I'm very comfortable with that 10% still in a motion [1:00:14] and we'll see where it goes maybe this may be our struggle number ex-ordinates [1:00:35] the ordinance [1:00:41] proposing the actual ordinance [1:00:46] 2021-014 thank you [1:00:56] considering this evening is on your screen [1:01:06] Wama changed a little bit from what I said down here because I said it was open to thought processes [1:01:13] proposed it on January 1st 2022 that there will be a 7.5% race [1:01:19] January 1st of 2023, there'll be another 7.5% raise that keeps it under Chris 100 for the first year and makes a total of 15%. [1:01:31] I do believe when you pass that in a public eating future council by the fact that they do the change the arguments and decide not to give that second 7.5% should the economy be at a point where they don't feel like an afforded. [1:01:46] So that's what we would that would be my promotion [1:01:48] standardized for lack of a second. I'll listen to somebody else's motion. [1:01:52] Is there a second to that motion? [1:01:56] I'll second that. Right. So we have a motion and a second to, I guess, I don't know if we need to do this through legal motions, but I think to keep it clean we will, um, to [1:02:13] on this ordinance dash zero one four and change the ten percent the seven point five percent [1:02:22] again seven point five percent more i'm in favor of emotion because half percent this year and then [1:02:47] another seven and a half percent is actually more than fifteen because you're taking the increase [1:02:51] off the second amount not a lot but a little bit and i think it's just cleaner if we deal with it at [1:02:57] one time. [1:02:58] I guess it's a general comment on us. [1:03:08] This is a complex enough issue and all of us at one grabs up ten percent. [1:03:30] It'll basis they actually review this as part of the budget process. [1:03:41] What's the amendment? [1:03:56] So I would move to amend the motion in person. [1:04:03] So we have instead of doing seven and a half percent for the next two years to do a flat ten percent this year. [1:04:31] Comments or questions on that amendment before we call for a vote passes five to two [1:05:08] So this was not an emotion to put this on third and though since the M.S. So now we needed to vote on the motion [1:05:35] Essentially the same thing that was just made [1:05:47] Rubber's rule process [1:05:52] Alright, John Beherger? Yes [1:05:58] Yes, Mr. Beher's motion passes six to one [1:06:13] So, we counsel and mayor's compensation increased by the 10% amount, ordinance 2021-014 on the screen is exactly [1:06:37] five if somebody would like to. [1:06:48] Mayor, I move that we place artist 2021, 014 on third and final. [1:06:54] My title only and my name is someone that buys my suspension rules. Thank you. [1:07:01] Second. [1:07:04] Second. [1:07:07] Motion from Greg Lampteen seconded by Craig Hawkins to suspend the rules and place ordinance 2021-014, a third and final by title only. [1:07:17] Yes. [1:07:24] Depasses six to one. [1:07:35] Ordinance 2021-014, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, repealing and replacing ordinance number 2913, [1:07:46] setting forth the compensation plan for the mayor and city council and providing [1:07:51] for an effective date. [1:07:53] I move that we pass ordinance 2021 day 0-1-4. [1:08:06] I'll second that. [1:08:10] I have a motion from grade 19 seconded by Ruth Pierce to pass ordinance 2021-0-1-4. [1:08:17] 6-1. [1:08:41] Dane is there anything else you need from us on that? [1:08:45] Which place do we have that right here? [1:08:51] possible. I have a traveston that would be next on our agenda is a request to [1:09:09] consider entering into a memorandum of understanding with Twin Falls County [1:09:14] regarding building department permits and we have our city manager Travis [1:09:18] Frathweiler. Madam Mayor members of the city council tonight I am bringing [1:09:30] a Ford and has been developers of the city staff and the county commissioners as [1:09:39] as it relates to building services. [1:09:43] So as you recall over a period of time, [1:09:47] we have always come before you, [1:09:49] and we said we would like to have you wave a collection [1:09:53] of fees as it relates to building inspection services [1:09:57] and building safety services. [1:09:59] And at the last conversation, we asked if you'd be interested [1:10:04] in entering into a memorandum of understanding [1:10:06] with basically have us take responsibility [1:10:12] for our own services and in exchange, [1:10:14] we wouldn't assess a building permit fee. [1:10:19] Now the city of Flint Falls would still assess [1:10:21] its connection fees from the appropriate [1:10:23] and its impact fees were appropriate [1:10:24] because those are fees that we cannot waive. [1:10:27] But all the work fees that we would assess from work [1:10:30] that we would for us would assess. [1:10:37] And basically what the agreement says [1:10:39] is that we will appoint one another [1:10:43] to serve as their own building, official building inspector projects. [1:10:51] So rather than the City of Twin Falls overseeing any construction related projects for the county, [1:10:56] the county's team would oversee their own work. [1:11:00] And that's a real benefit because they can work at their pace that they need to. [1:11:04] In addition to that, we all follow the exact same rules, those processes. [1:11:13] For the City of Twin Falls, they will still come forward and they will look at plan review [1:11:19] those type of things to make sure they're in compliance with all land use items because [1:11:23] that would be something that we're going to be here at Stiction Organization number one [1:11:31] expediency but number two organization when we're sitting back in conversation about this [1:11:43] we can't recall the time and so rather than waiting for that fee waiver inside of the [1:11:51] it has that fee waiver built in so rather than waiting for a council meeting or a commission [1:11:57] meeting that sets out the times so with that I'd be happy to stand for any questions Shane [1:12:05] and can assist as well as he was. [1:12:07] So this only covers building farm and fees. [1:12:22] I remember again, I'm going to go back here [1:12:25] because I was on plenty of zoning for eight years before I was on council. [1:12:29] And there was a gap in there for a while, so it's been a long time ago. [1:12:32] We got in there for you to get spatted plenty of zoning with the County of [1:12:37] Uxner-Himpleman, I believe, who was, they were doing a building and didn't want to follow it. [1:12:43] We have our landscape rules and we've, I don't know what the council wants. [1:12:48] I can't remember what the council wants to go or not because I can't feel what the council wants. [1:12:52] So this is just, we're many fees which is your right. [1:12:56] I've been out here for like 16 years. [1:12:58] I can never remember requiring them for the school district or the county because it's the same taxpayers for the most part. [1:13:06] So, I just wanted to make sure that it's just the belly of the family, [1:13:09] which we would still have landscaping and things like that. [1:13:14] It's so big. [1:13:15] This does not resolve or remove the city of Twin Falls, [1:13:25] or any other things that we would still be subject to all those things. [1:13:32] So Travis, we don't have attachments today, [1:13:37] so the original memorandum hasn't changed since it was posted. [1:13:45] It has not. [1:13:46] Okay. [1:14:34] Thank you. [1:14:35] Yes. [1:14:36] And it passes 7-0. [1:14:39] And our agenda is a presentation of the city manager's recommended budget for the fiscal [1:14:48] year 2022 at this presentation. [1:14:52] Right. [1:15:18] Sometimes that's as you continue to do. [1:15:21] So as we approach, we're also going to be asking the city council to continue to deliberate [1:15:29] and make decisions. [1:15:30] So I want to, I want to share that with those decisions be this evening or whether they [1:15:35] be next week. Really, we want to have a good understanding about the council [1:15:40] capital projects that you want to fund this year. As you know, we allocate [1:15:44] $770,000, generally under the city council, under capital, and those are the [1:15:49] projects that the council has embarked on over a period of time. We want you to [1:15:55] be thinking about those this week and next week as you're going to hear [1:15:59] focus areas four, five, and seven this week, and area focus areas one and six [1:16:03] next week be really thinking about how that we move forward and I promised math that I would [1:16:07] make that plug at the very very beginning so that we can get it with our budgeting process. [1:16:14] Some of this is going to be a bit of a repeat. We do that intentionality number. We share [1:16:21] the thoughts that we use to construct the budget because we don't know who's joining [1:16:29] us along in this journey. So we've been having this conversation about a budget for the last [1:16:35] several meetings. We started the initial conversations at the council level in April. [1:16:40] We had subsequent meetings in May and June and then we've been having a conversation about the city's budget [1:16:46] every single week to continue that August when we started that process. [1:17:02] We really wanted to hit on some broader themes and I think that Brianna in her [1:17:07] finance presentation really kind of talked about several of these themes [1:17:13] when she was talking about the numbers that we're seeing inside of the budget. [1:17:18] We wanted to create a stable and nimble budget. [1:17:20] We talked about how dynamic the environment has been, [1:17:23] and if you just take a look at the building permit numbers [1:17:25] that she was talking about in the third quarter, [1:17:27] we were expecting to break all records, [1:17:29] and then we've seen a softening over the course of the last couple of months [1:17:32] as it may be related to supply. [1:17:34] It may be related to cost. [1:17:36] It may be, so we've seen a softening in the increments. [1:17:43] We're still going to see record number building permits [1:17:47] being issued inside the City of Twin Falls, but we don't know if that's [1:17:51] often is going to continue into fiscal year 22. And so when we construct the [1:17:56] budget, we want to make sure that it is able to be responsive to a dynamic [1:18:01] environment that is ever changing. When we created the budget for last fiscal year, [1:18:05] it was in the middle of the COVID pandemic. And now we're starting to watch the [1:18:13] Delta variant begin to increase in certain parts of our country and certainly inside the City [1:18:21] of Twin Falls. [1:18:22] How that is ultimately going to play out in a year from now is really anybody's guess. [1:18:27] But what's important is we are creating a budget that requires you to use a crystal ball [1:18:32] to make the best sound financial decisions to create a stable budget. [1:18:36] We believe that we've done that. [1:18:38] We want to make sure that we tie every single expenditure to our strategic plan. [1:18:41] The strategic plan serves as our guide post, and it is something that was built not only [1:18:45] by this council, but also in concert with the citizens. [1:18:48] It creates the community we all want to live in by the year two. [1:18:53] And with that, we want to continue to honor that strategic plan, the water bill. [1:19:00] And in addition to that, we want to be the employer choice. [1:19:02] We want to be the place that people choose to work. [1:19:07] And this year, we're going to see more turnover. [1:19:10] We're going to see a significant number of retirements that are going [1:19:13] to occur this year, individuals that have spent 25 and 30 years and as an employer, choice [1:19:22] that's a really, really good marker, longevity, but also what happens on that next day is they [1:19:29] take tremendous institutional knowledge with them to make sure that we have the next man [1:19:37] or woman ready to stand up and to fill in those roles because public services provided [1:19:42] by people. And as we've shared last week, and then we're going to chair to their presentation, [1:19:46] the firetruck's not going to drive itself to the fire. And when our citizens are in their [1:19:51] greatest time of need, is when our employees perform at their level best. And that is when [1:19:57] retention matters. No one wants the fire department or the police department that you [1:20:03] can afford. They want the best when they're at that time of need, and we try to do everything [1:20:08] that we can to attract and retain the best employees in our organization. That's why they [1:20:13] will always remain at the center of what we're trying to do. [1:20:16] And hopefully last week during Focus Area 8, Gretchen [1:20:19] illustrated the things that we're doing not only in the areas of compensation, [1:20:23] but also in the areas that are really not compensatory, [1:20:27] trying to be the employer of choice through policy as well. [1:20:31] So here's a quick demographics about the City of Twin Falls. [1:20:34] Tonight we're going to spend time about that census. [1:20:38] Focus Area 7, we have members of our team tonight that's going to talk about what [1:20:41] What does it mean for the City of Twin Falls [1:20:43] to be a small urban community? [1:20:45] What are those impacts going to be [1:20:47] as we continue to move forward? [1:20:49] We continue to be concerned about fast [1:20:53] the median household income as continuing comparison [1:20:59] to the home facing falls. [1:21:06] But if you do a quick search, [1:21:08] it's absolutely amazing to look at the home values [1:21:11] in Meridian and Boise where they're nearing [1:21:14] or exceeding, it's something that as being an employer, [1:21:24] we need to take a look at. [1:21:26] So right here, the median home value in the state of Idaho [1:21:29] is $403,000. [1:21:31] You can see the median value in Twin Falls is 490, or 290. [1:21:37] At least it wasn't June, because what we shared in May [1:21:40] was that it was actually $10,000 less, [1:21:44] and we watched the significant incline in the next slide. [1:21:49] We take a look at costs. [1:21:50] The cost of us providing services based upon municipal [1:21:53] cost index. June, it was up nearly 10%. So the municipal cost index is very different [1:22:03] than the consumer price index because as an economic indicator, it takes a look at bushel, [1:22:10] if you will, of services that we acquire in the materials that we use, diesel fuel, cement, [1:22:16] asphalt, and it puts us into a basket and it looks to see how those have been increasing [1:22:21] over a period of time because your price index really kind of reflects what is the cost of [1:22:27] inflation based upon normal and typical household goods. And you can see that both are growing [1:22:33] in Brianna shared in her presentation. Both seem to be growing at record. This is an illustration [1:22:40] of what is occurred inside of the city of Twin Falls and the housing market. Property taxes [1:22:47] are going to be based upon these numbers right here. Idaho code states that it shall be value [1:22:56] as of shall be the property value that is used in determining an individual's property tax [1:23:04] for the so while we continue to grow to two hundred and ninety thousand dollars know that it is going [1:23:11] to be based upon somewhere lower and as this number continues to grow hopefully the Idaho [1:23:18] legislature will continue to look at a homeowner's exemption that is more closely tied to indexing [1:23:24] as opposed to a flat fee and also that the tax rate that will be created next year will [1:23:31] be largely based upon the total growth of the city's taxable value in future years. [1:23:37] So last week we had shared that we had some new numbers and the numbers had changed slightly [1:23:42] as a result of the county's work and again I wanted to send out a great thanks to Brad [1:23:48] Willes over at the assessor's office because it's really with his work in giving us information [1:23:53] very, very early that we're able to engage in a conversation that's meaningful with the council. [1:23:59] So there's a couple of things that are slightly different based upon the total taxable value of [1:24:03] the city. So right here, and this is what we choose to focus on, right? Everybody wants to know [1:24:11] how much more is going to cost me next year. And what we're able to illustrate is over all [1:24:19] all based upon the median household or the median value of a home, less home-wide exemption, [1:24:28] multiplied by the tax rate, and then taking a look at different rates and those type of [1:24:33] things, we are able to believe that that median person, person who uses 18,000 gallons of [1:24:41] water and 12,000 gallons of suitor, who sewer and participates in sanitation recycling and [1:24:47] lives in that median hope, whoever that median person is, they would save $1.43 under this [1:24:54] budget in comparison to the prior year. [1:24:57] Now, $1.43 isn't significant, but what is significant is we're saving $1.43 per month [1:25:04] in an era in which we're seeing a 10% increase in cost. [1:25:08] And that is a credit to the members of our team really looked within their budgets to [1:25:14] find the best ways that we can forward. [1:25:19] So here are some of the changes in the numbers, and I'll be flucked off of this and kind of [1:25:22] share what it was in the last slide. [1:25:28] So one of the numbers I want to talk about is if you take a look at your paying attention [1:25:34] to Brianna's slides, you would have seen that Brianna's share that the city's budget adopted [1:25:40] for fiscal year 21 was $77,424,565. [1:25:45] And now you're wondering over the course of the last hour, how in the world did it shrink [1:25:51] 5 million bucks, right? How did that happen? So it's important is when Brianna is taking [1:25:57] a look at her number, both numbers are right. In fact, we even described that at the very [1:26:02] first page of the city's budget message. Brianna is looking at the entirety of the city's budget [1:26:09] would include transfers from the enterprise funds to the tax-supported funds for the [1:26:14] rent of staff. Essentially, what Brianna shared is we asked all of the enterprise funds to [1:26:20] act like they are a small business. The water fund, while it has, you know, [1:26:25] rock serving as an amazing superintendent, it doesn't have its own human resource [1:26:30] director. It doesn't have its own legal staff. It doesn't have the other pieces [1:26:38] of the organization that allow them to be successful and viable. They pay a rent. [1:26:43] That rent is referred to in government as a transfer. And so we remove transfers. [1:26:49] And if we were to take a look at net budgets, those are reflected up there. [1:26:56] If you were to take a look at the entirety of the budget, rather than being $69 million, [1:27:01] that number would be $73,453,000. [1:27:06] So for those who are paying attention, why are the two numbers? [1:27:09] I wanted to explain that. [1:27:11] We have historically focused on the net budget because when you start looking at the transfers, [1:27:15] it really is a double accounting where you're taking it from one pocket and you're pushing [1:27:19] pushing it over to another. This keeps it very, very clean and we'll continue to do that. [1:27:24] But tonight I wanted to just take a minute because we had the presentation for Brianna [1:27:27] to explain the differences in the numbers. In addition to that, you see that there is a decline [1:27:34] in the tax rate. Last week we had illustrated that this was going to be $6.22 now and it's $6.24 [1:27:44] and you would ask why did that increase? It's not that the government spending site increased [1:27:48] The size of the total tax of the value decreased from 4.0 to 4.1 million that is reflected on the screen. [1:27:58] So that decrease in the total tax of the value created a different tax rate. [1:28:04] Determining a tax rate inside the state of Idaho is incredibly easy. [1:28:08] It is probably the most elementary math that you can take and that is taking the total tax dollars spent divided by the total tax of the value. [1:28:17] gives you a multiplier that is then taken to every single property. [1:28:22] So that is going to be the tax rate, and it is reflected cost of living when falls next year compared to this year has changed slightly. [1:28:39] This is an increase or an illustration, an increase in the city's total taxable value since fiscal year 2013. [1:28:46] And another number that changed was the total taxable value [1:28:49] of the Herbinger New Agency. [1:28:50] That number before the Board of Equalization was 654 million. [1:28:56] That is now 600. [1:29:02] Any questions on this? [1:29:09] Is an illustration of the city's tax rate over a period of time? [1:29:13] And you can see that the tax rate that we're issuing here [1:29:16] is among the lows that has been issued by the city of Twin [1:29:19] Falls. [1:29:24] The budget that we have in here takes advantage [1:29:27] of what is allowed under Idaho Code. [1:29:30] It takes a 3% statutory increase. [1:29:32] It takes the value of the new construction and annexation [1:29:35] rolls, and it takes a portion of the foregone balance [1:29:39] equivalent to 1% to cover additional operation and maintenance [1:29:43] costs. [1:29:44] The donation of the arsenic debt. [1:29:51] And we've shared over the course of the last several weeks [1:29:54] the importance of using those dollars and applying and creating [1:29:57] a new capital fund that would allow us to complete [1:30:00] several projects. We're not recommending any increase in the sewer fund. We're not recommending [1:30:06] a sizable increase in sanitation recycling. In fact, that's a pass through with our relationship [1:30:11] that we have as a service provider. And when you take a look at the water, we will, based upon our [1:30:16] analysis, presidential customers will also receive a decrease in their water bill able to place those [1:30:30] into significant capital projects over a period of termination of the new fees will [1:30:36] just slightly more than $2.3 million based upon current customers in use that can be used [1:30:44] not only to increase mainline maintenance which members of our team are going to spend [1:30:48] time talking to you tonight but also it's going to be a allow us to complete some significant [1:30:53] capital projects that are part of our water facility plan. [1:30:58] So with that, I get to turn it over to members of the team who are going to kind of roll through [1:31:02] the next several slides, the first piece that we're going to talk about is an accessible [1:31:07] community, and I'm going to turn the time I believe over to John Keaton. First person [1:31:30] speaking for Public Works Science is actually going to be the street superintendent, Mark [1:31:33] Thompson, so I'll be talking later. So this is what happened when he asked the city manager [1:31:42] to, you know, head-in for the deputy who's unable to be with us tonight, so... Mark? [1:31:48] It's all good, love Mark. If you see about our steel coating, spreadsheet up there, it is [1:32:33] It's really some more effect to flow within the city, as a signal going up within the city of intersections. [1:32:53] V49, cross your fingers hopefully, next to all the pieces and parts are in, so we should be good to go. [1:33:01] Oh sorry. [1:33:02] Up those four sections, that also includes all the signals on row state routes. [1:33:13] And depending on the complexity of the intersection, we kind of, a signal alone here is actually 6th Avenue. [1:33:38] It can be a stand-alone system, set it up to different intersections, change things around. [1:33:55] So we start with an optical system, every one of our signals has an optical system, which is an emergency preemption system, EMS vehicle direction they're flowing. [1:34:13] Then we also get into a detection system, and we have two types within the city right now. [1:34:22] We have an infrared system, and we have a detection system. [1:34:26] Video is never sees it [1:34:33] Fred system is based off of the heat signature of what's coming up to so that's kind of where we're headed [1:35:11] There's also a UPS system which stands for un-airappable power supply [1:35:20] That's basically a battery protection system to intersections [1:35:39] option system or intersections in [1:36:11] System points are focusing on like those two [1:37:19] Signals on Kimberly Road are fairly new [1:37:22] Yes, they are, um, and the problem we're having is the way they were designed. [1:37:41] Puck system, and I'm not sure how the puck system works, but we've had nothing but problem. [1:37:48] Traffic situation is good in my book. [1:38:00] Yes. [1:38:01] This is my maiden voyage up here, so bear with me. [1:38:28] I've never been here, at least presenting it. [1:38:31] We're going to make sure you get lots of questions then. [1:38:33] Okay, thanks. [1:38:35] We'll see our three capital requests for next year. [1:38:40] The one I want to start off with and really focus on is the shop expansion. [1:38:45] In 20 department and golf course came to us and requested that we take over 100% of the maintenance and repair their equipment that they had been doing for the last 75 years. [1:39:01] We took that on to increase the workload in the shop substantially. [1:39:08] To the point that whole section that you see in the picture movements in it, I think lights and other shop expansions, it's a lot total. [1:40:13] This includes, of course, because we've tried more 191 pieces of equipment on the handle list, just a few. [1:40:23] Just a few. Doesn't include string trimmers and backpack loaders, and some of that smaller equipment that I've changed so that's not all. [1:40:52] So right now, without this workspace, we have no room to add another. [1:40:56] Yeah, the proof this area, our intention is to move all weird stuff [1:41:07] Onto that into the things I don't work on, actually I want to move on to the kill replacement [1:41:34] Because that's pretty important also [1:41:36] So that heater replacement amount is for the main portion of the shop [1:41:42] We spent several thousand dollars over the last two or three years [1:41:45] To try and repair, continually repair the heater system that it was installed when the building was built [1:41:54] That was in 1980. [1:41:56] Companies that we've used over the last few years are telling us now there are no more parts available. [1:42:07] But this would replace the entire heat system in the main portion of the shop and our wash base. [1:42:15] Councilman, I'd like to just tip on the items for water. [1:42:51] This year we're asking for a hydro-exclamation truck. [1:42:55] We have wastewater departments and last year we need a budget unit. [1:43:10] Working around with all the utilities now in twin hoodies, but on this subdivision on the [1:43:19] farm grounds pretty easy because there's a lot of things you can go up, get into for [1:43:33] the next grader around this stuff. There's new technology, there's better ways to do it now, utilize some of that, and see the benefits of huge safety. [1:44:16] Nice and clean things, you can see where they're at, and they're just taking each benefit. Less space, most of the time, and with the next grader. [1:44:31] There's also guys who are feet and rocks on the side. [1:44:57] It's with an ex-computer and you're not sure what's all there. [1:45:03] It's laying along the side with fiber up to connect stuff. [1:45:08] If you get one of those lines, it can be thousands of dollars. [1:45:12] Because it just makes it a whole lot easier for our guys. [1:45:18] We're able to get, if in an emergency, [1:45:21] we're able to get right out there on the job site immediately. [1:45:34] It's on time. [1:45:42] It's our main placement. [1:45:45] We're getting 50,000 this year. [1:45:49] over the next five years you'll see [1:45:51] um [1:45:52] as being the arsenic off [1:45:54] we don't look at ramping up [1:45:57] replacement [1:46:01] this year [1:46:02] five thousand next two years [1:46:10] we're really excited to be able to finally start doing some of this [1:46:13] we've worked a long time and tried to figure out how to afford it [1:46:16] the arsenic bill [1:46:20] a couple jobs already designed [1:46:31] litter almost shelf ready to go [1:46:33] the lakes can be revocussed [1:46:39] not messing up throughout athlete [1:47:01] just get through trying not to do that [1:48:23] The place they stay is, well, some stuff that's in, so yeah, it's kind of like a car you don't wait until the motor blows up before you change the oil, but when, you know, there's a maintenance schedule, and so we're like, our facility, plan, since we should be done. [1:48:57] It's like a good step in the way. This is fantastic. Thank you. I'm excited about it. [1:49:02] The meter replacement, I'll just touch on it. [1:49:08] um, place, trying to replace roughly 1,000 to 1,200 meters a year [1:49:13] I'm on our meter replacement program [1:49:15] I'm replacing meters and we've got meters [1:49:19] and we're getting every replacement time on meters [1:49:27] it's a 20-year lifecycle, I'm not a cell [1:49:30] I'm losing our revenue, that's what we do [1:49:34] so when we're accelerating through 1,000 or 1,200 [1:49:50] at pace and then we can kind of slow down [1:49:55] to be started, I believe, about 70 to about 17,000 [1:50:13] You are seeing no attention [1:50:25] and being able to get parts and that kind of stuff [1:50:28] and that kind of stuff. The chipboards that go now in the weeks, but it also what works [1:51:03] for that is everybody else will. That was all on distribution side. We've got our water [1:51:13] facility plan in months and water supply this year. We just put in 60,000 in there for [1:51:32] fault replacements. We've got nine different pressure zones in our system and those faults [1:51:38] I'm going to try to control the pressure between the South and 80 PSI. [1:51:48] We lose 100 feet of elevation and we'll be on PSI. [1:51:52] So those pressure faults have pressure releasing valves in them. [1:51:56] A lot of them are formed up some boards and little dead iron, and that's how it's. [1:52:07] So we want to get those to where they're safe for the guys to get in. [1:52:11] We have good lids and hatches on them. [1:52:13] I think that was the council. [1:52:43] The waste would have treated them. [1:52:48] items. There's only five there listed I want to talk about. Two of the big dollar ones. So one is a [1:53:02] sledge truck. Chassis is in slicker bed. The waste water tree plant has four of these currently. The oldest one I [1:53:10] live is in 1993. It has about 600,000 miles on it. Seen better days. And what happens is through the [1:53:20] the treatment process, the liquids are separated from the solids, and those solids are then physically [1:53:26] and can we treat it to create a bio-solid, and you have to get rid of those bio-solids [1:53:31] in one of the best ways, it's still not an apply it to the local farmers field, so we [1:53:36] work with DEQ for that regular process. [1:53:38] They can get rid of something that we are trying to get rid of, and also give a nutrient-rich [1:53:43] bio-solid farmer, so it's a win-win, and I just want to show you what it looks like, [1:53:48] Maybe this isn't exactly it, but this is a different version of how you would see biosols and what this slinger trick can do. [1:53:56] Oh, see. [1:54:01] When you see it, you'll think it's slinger because it is pretty cool. [1:54:13] This is the figure. [1:54:24] So imagine this, the waste search you're planning taking a farmer field, and the farmer's like it because you're not going up as many passes. [1:54:31] It really is slinging across the field. [1:54:33] And the waste water you can plant would take that and equally distribute it across the field. [1:54:38] So it's kind of a cool thing that we can do. [1:54:40] So what you saw was a tractor pulling an actual bed, what we're looking at is that the truck itself is able to do it all on its own. [1:55:04] And then the other item I was going to discuss was another $250,000.00 smasher. [1:55:12] We have some old boilers, we're trying to replace them. [1:55:15] We've already procured the money in the Siskir for the boilers, and the $250,000 is the cost to do some additional piping and the installation of that boiler for this year. [1:55:28] The thing that is noteworthy there is when you want to make sure that bugs are doing their job and actually taking care of the digestion. [1:55:38] So it's important of when you make their replacement as opposed to doing that in the dead of winter once it's cold, it doesn't work well. [1:55:44] So I think the intent of me to do it probably in the spring is a little hotter. [1:55:48] So that would be the cost to install those. [1:55:52] And those are two projects I have that I can answer any questions you might have on any of them or those specific projects. [1:55:59] Christopher Reed. [1:56:02] A few months we had a presentation and there some of the equity aside to look at some of [1:56:17] our old equipment. [1:56:18] I don't think it was the boiler, there an update on that, understanding that we're doing [1:56:26] a budget, we're putting funds towards that, wishing that I remembered all the terminology. [1:56:34] Me and you both. [1:56:35] I know there's also a digester project that was coming out there. [1:56:41] That was the digester. [1:56:42] We're but on the even a couple of weeks before I should be coming to council with requests [1:56:48] so we'll work a bit on the digester project that is intended to replace one of the digesters [1:56:53] that we'll be looking at or at least repairing or rehabilitating a digester. [1:56:58] We'll be looking at the second digester and making sure it's up to par and if not potentially [1:57:05] rehabilitating it as well. [1:57:06] Okay, so that'll be in this year's budget. [1:57:09] Yes, this is one. [1:57:11] I think it's $500,000 in this year's budget, maybe more in the next year's budget. [1:57:20] I'm not pausing on that. [1:57:21] I don't see it on the list, but I'm pretty sure it's all taken care of under this current [1:57:24] fiscal year's budget. [1:57:25] Perfect. [1:57:26] I'll lighten up that changes. [1:57:27] We do have, for us, to under just for this fail, that several, it's been something [1:58:15] that the, what's important is the digester's full balance that are in it and this takes [1:58:33] time to start that process and the other digester as well. [1:59:00] We just wanted a collection superintendent, but he is on vacation, so I'm going to touch [1:59:08] on just a couple of these things as well, but just like Josh was saying, [1:59:11] these feel free. We just wanted a collection that is in a similar place to water replacement, [1:59:25] and how it's outlined in our master plans. It takes, not only money, but it takes a program. [1:59:35] I liked what Rob said when he said it's a maintenance schedule. [1:59:38] That's what Reid was asking questions about. Is it going to tie in towards our maintenance? [1:59:43] I was really glad you asked that question because obviously it's really important that [1:59:47] our underground utilities are maintained properly if we have a robust surface treatment, if we [1:59:53] have a robust street maintenance program, it doesn't matter if the utilities. [1:59:59] What I found interesting over the almost 14 years I've been here, the streets get so much [2:00:04] attention from our customers that it does get funded and over the years it's been really [2:00:11] hard to build a program. No criticism on anybody but you know they're the two [2:00:20] enterprise funds you think we'd be able to you know make this happen but it's [2:00:23] been years in the making and so I'm really excited as well about the arsenic [2:00:28] potential that we could do with that money difference and so let me go back [2:00:35] to sewer because that's where I was talking about it so the things that can [2:00:43] help us take our mainline dollars a long way is trenchless rehabilitation so [2:00:47] you do the traditional open trench, it can, and it costs what it costs. I, the number I put on there [2:00:54] is pretty optimistic. There are, there is data out there that shows that for every dollar you spend [2:00:59] on an open trench replacement, you could spend 25 cents on CIPP for that length. Generally for [2:01:08] planning purposes, they're going to say it's half the cost, but I've been looking, J.E.B.'s really [2:01:13] really helped us get these facts and page put together. [2:01:16] Cordolane is a great program. [2:01:18] They have a great program more than since 2004. [2:01:21] They've been CIPP every year in the amount, [2:01:27] on average about $400,000. [2:01:28] So they're doing miles and miles of rehabilitation [2:01:33] each year for cost. [2:01:37] And that's exactly what we're trying to do [2:01:39] is to build up to the reason it's taken us a while is, [2:01:48] when you start looking at rehabilitating, [2:01:51] miles of sewer line condition of it and they seem to say and so we've we've [2:02:02] simplified how we assess is keep it simple there's a beauty to keep it [2:02:08] simple and so we've we've modified several things several ways with we [2:02:13] assess the pipe and go out as you all know we use a TV camera to the sewer to [2:02:19] it's video inspect the sewer score it prioritize it we put it on the list to [2:02:24] I'm excited because this year we've done some, and I'll show you a picture, we've done some, [2:02:31] but test the IPPs, been around for years and years, here in place piping is what it's called, [2:02:39] it's a trenchless technology. This will be the first year that we will in this next budget [2:02:48] we should have a large contract to put, at least a mile plus is the process for CIPP. [2:02:59] see IPP you can see this gentleman and Costco there a sock it's a it's um it's [2:03:13] unfelving but it's like it's a fabric that's impregnated with resin and they [2:03:21] keep it cold you can see in that back of the truck there's bags of ice so they [2:03:25] have to keep it temperature controlled they pull it in into the to the sewer [2:03:34] the inflated, I get to temperature with steam, basically cook it in place and it becomes a whole new pipe. [2:03:42] Most of the time you don't capacity and it gets smaller. [2:03:50] Well it also gets smoother in many cases. It improves the situations where we're not really losing capacity [2:03:56] and we're replacing a pipe and PVC pipe's got at least 100 years. [2:04:01] Um, so, uh, CIPP. [2:04:07] Do you hide your gender first year on the routes that takes it in place or do you... [2:04:17] There's this force that runs out. [2:04:20] Yes, I... good, great question. [2:04:22] There's a lot that goes into getting a pipe ready for CIPP. [2:04:26] And it takes us, you know, we'll see, but it's gonna take us, you know, a good part of the year [2:04:32] to get a mile of pipe ready for CIPP. [2:04:35] It means you're cleaning it, you're making spot repairs. [2:04:38] This stuff will bridge problems pretty well. It'll bridge gaps [2:04:43] But but they want any do need to remove roots [2:04:50] So yes, there's a lot of prep that goes into it going to the other item. I'm excited about [2:05:04] This Vanguard pathogen defense system is what it's called and really what it is. It's a system that is vehicle mounted [2:05:16] We have four systems that we're posing [2:05:18] one two for two jets and one you can see in this picture on the left what you're [2:05:30] seeing is a jet hoses being pulled back from the sewer and you can see below that [2:05:39] coupling it's pretty gross and up to the picture in the middle you can see [2:05:44] there's nozzles in the jet that spray the hose and remove all the all the stuff [2:05:49] and it disinfects it kills pathogens and things like that so when you pull the [2:05:54] the hose retract the hose from the sewer, the operators man handling the hose getting it back on the reel. [2:06:01] It's a lot when it's coming back clean. [2:06:07] The other thing to do is you get it on things, you get it on your boots, you get it where. [2:06:13] And so there's also a hand held gun that you can spray down disinfect your boots all day long. [2:06:25] This is a really nice feature for our operators that I'm really looking forward to. [2:06:39] That's the S-Man one for questions. [2:06:52] I still seem to be a lot more choice. [2:06:57] Yes, so I'm going to start and kind of share some of the processes that I'm going to turn [2:07:18] it over to members of our team, planning its owning to relate to fees. [2:07:30] One of the things I had shared at the very beginning was what does it mean when the city [2:07:35] of Flint falls crests over the 50,000 population. [2:07:38] And as we had shared, there was a point in time where the federal government was considering [2:07:44] to increase that 200,000. [2:07:46] Then recently they made the decision that they were in June, so it still remains at 50,000. [2:07:52] In this result of that, there are a whole series of federal requirements that are passed on to those cities that are now considered urban. [2:07:59] Once they hit that 50,000 legislation, it's not a designation that we requested. [2:08:06] It's a designation that counts as a result. [2:08:08] So we believe that the city from falls is going to surpass the 50,000 population threshold [2:08:15] When the 2020 Census is officially certified, it probably won't be certified for probably about another... [2:08:22] He has to make that in 2019, the City of Twin Falls' population had crescent over, [2:08:32] and as you've seen the amount of building activity you've seen, [2:08:35] we have seen inside of the City of Twin Falls, [2:08:39] not only when we talk about sick of family permits, but we also talk about what we believe [2:08:44] that the City of Twin Falls is going to be close to when that Census is finally certified. [2:08:52] So with that becomes a whole series of processes, and none of these should be surprised to use [2:09:00] one of them is that we're looking at a metropolitan statistical area, which is that area that encompasses [2:09:07] not only twin falls, but also drone inside of that eventually the census will create what's [2:09:15] called an urbanized zone. [2:09:18] That urbanized zone is going to be critical when they start taking a look at the creation [2:09:22] of a metropolitan area and some initial conversations [2:09:26] with some essential stakeholders that will be a part [2:09:30] of the MPO they believe. [2:09:32] We know the city of Twin Falls will be included. [2:09:34] We know that the city of Kimberly will be included. [2:09:39] That will also include county as part of that [2:09:41] on the corporate areas, the state and the highway districts. [2:09:46] How it continues to grow outside of that will ultimately [2:09:50] be through the census period. [2:09:52] But there's a whole series of stakeholders. [2:09:54] We've had one meeting. [2:09:55] the committee says we're looking at standing up an organization. [2:10:00] In addition to that, as Ian and members of the planning team have presented, even had a conversation [2:10:16] about the CDBG projects that are incorporated, so you'll notice that we have the 20 allocation, [2:10:23] the 20 CARES allocation, the 21 allocation of about $1.1 million, including this budget. [2:10:32] We've defined how those projects are going to be spent through the portionality of the public [2:10:37] hearing and the over-representatives from starting to projects and present those to you, [2:10:47] but also by being a part of a responsible community to make sure that we're covering our costs. [2:10:57] Taking a low process review, what is the cost of us doing business? [2:11:03] And if government is supposed to operate like a private entity, [2:11:09] what we would and should be responsible to ensure that our costs are being covered. [2:11:16] And especially when we start talking about how growth needs to pay for growth, many of [2:11:21] the planning and zoning fees are really driven through a growth process. [2:11:27] So members of our planning and zoning team really took upon the challenge to explore [2:11:31] what is the cost of providing a service? [2:11:34] What is the cost of reviewing a plan? [2:11:36] What is the cost of reviewing a special use permit? [2:11:40] What is the cost of then publishing it and creating [2:11:43] an ordinance and going through all of those parts and pieces? [2:11:47] What is the cost of staff time that [2:11:52] relates to the new subdivision in the infrastructure there? [2:11:58] So members of our planning and zoning team [2:11:59] have taken a look at this, and they [2:12:01] are going to be sharing those costs with you, [2:12:06] as we will ask for you to consider [2:12:08] increasing those costs during the digest that information as well. So with that, I'm going to turn it over to members. [2:12:33] Nice to see everybody tonight, and members. As you recall, I'm pin-shitting tonight, obviously. [2:12:40] But as you recall, Jonathan and I were here a while ago to discuss the proposal that we had to increase our planning and zoning application fees. [2:12:50] So, the answer for emotional support. [2:12:58] The first slide is a review of what you guys saw last time. [2:13:02] So, Jonathan took the preliminary and the final application fee was created in comparison [2:13:19] the cost of a new home was 62.5 and going down and the same thing with the zoning applications [2:13:26] last time they were updated. Cost of a new home was 166 and going down and as you can see [2:13:33] in the previous presentation the cost of a median home in Twin Falls is nowhere near either one of [2:13:40] those but our fees are stayed the same. This is just a list of our current application fees in [2:14:09] alphabetical order the last two are the preliminary and the final plats and the years that they were [2:14:16] established anywhere from 1978 with the plats to 2010 with design permits and these are all [2:14:22] categories categorized under as planning and zoning applications. You had asked us to go back and [2:14:34] break down our costs more than we had. So the required public notice in the paper, [2:14:41] the costs are recent and voices range anywhere from $50 to $200 depending on the length of the item [2:14:47] And how many items are on that posting? [2:14:52] The average public hearing item, each item, [2:14:55] lasts an hour. [2:14:57] Many can be less, but I know you guys [2:15:00] know that many can be more. [2:15:03] And the required staff at a planning and zoning public hearing [2:15:08] is our city attorney or planning and zoning director, [2:15:11] assistant city engineer, a planner, a member of IT, [2:15:15] and me, the administrative assistant. [2:15:19] So, heart cost, we know that every public hearing [2:15:24] has to be publicized in the paper. [2:15:26] It's around $100, we're estimating, [2:15:29] depending on the number of hearings. [2:15:33] Though, breaking down just at the fully burdened rate [2:15:38] of those six staff members per hour, [2:15:42] Our public hearing staff time costs $317 an hour. [2:15:48] And that was, Kristen helped me come up with that number. [2:15:54] That's not taking into consideration prep and review time. [2:15:57] And we went back and forth. [2:16:00] We estimated the time. [2:16:02] I was supposed to have a handout for you guys [2:16:04] with the full breakdown, [2:16:05] but I couldn't find it today. [2:16:07] So I can get you that information. [2:16:10] But, so the estimated average amounts very greatly [2:16:14] from $220 to upwards of $1,200 depending on the type of application. [2:16:19] Okay, so this is just a sample of some of our application costs, [2:16:26] me applications, we couldn't fit them all on one slide, [2:16:29] so Jonathan, I think he took the top 12. [2:16:33] So the first is just the list of applications. [2:16:36] The second column is the number of public hearings that each of [2:16:40] these applications require. [2:16:42] And for the hearing cost alone is what staff time would cost in the second column. [2:16:53] It is by hour or so for an annexation is too public hearing so average staff cost for that [2:16:59] public hearing time is $635 and so forth. [2:17:04] The review cost is different. [2:17:07] This is all behind the scenes stuff that we do getting prepped for the meeting. [2:17:13] For me personally, it's sending out public notice packets, [2:17:16] contact with the applicants, taking minutes at the meeting [2:17:22] and preparing them for approval on the back end, [2:17:26] plus all the review time of all of our other staff members. [2:17:29] It could be our engineering tax, engineers, planners, [2:17:35] other assistance building department, [2:17:38] depending on the type of application [2:17:39] who gets involved with those. [2:17:41] So, the total of those two columns is that that's just a cost of staff time. [2:17:47] That's not taking into consideration the hard costs that we talked about earlier. [2:17:52] And in the last column are the proposed fees that we have come up with. [2:17:57] These were the fees that we showed you at the last meeting. [2:18:00] And this is how they compare now to the actual cost per staff, by application for staff. [2:18:10] And then this is the technical practice for staff. [2:18:12] Yeah, of course, Steve, one more minute. [2:18:14] Sorry. [2:18:21] And so this is a slide you guys saw before. [2:18:27] This was my part of the first presentation, [2:18:29] is I took all of our current applications [2:18:33] at our current rate and compared them [2:18:36] to similar jurisdictions of our size, [2:18:39] plus it included Twin Falls County. [2:18:42] We have a more extensive, we went all over, [2:18:45] but these were the five, five or six [2:18:48] that are closest to us in size or never. [2:18:53] And so here's our current cost. [2:18:56] Here's our current application fees [2:18:58] compared to the other jurisdictions on the low end. [2:19:02] That's how they compare. [2:19:04] And then on the high end, [2:19:06] that's the third column is the high end cost. [2:19:10] And then the last column is what we are proposing [2:19:13] to increase our fees to. [2:19:16] Does anybody have any question to digest here? [2:19:29] There is, there is. [2:19:31] I guess not a question, but just to comment. [2:19:33] So in the print, since these had enix. [2:19:43] Oh, yeah, yours are covered, huh? [2:19:44] Yeah. [2:19:45] OK. [2:19:45] So if we could just get those before we have to. [2:19:48] Sure. [2:19:48] Get to the point. [2:19:49] Get that in the decisions on them. [2:19:51] What's important is this is also, [2:19:52] so we're bringing this up this evening. [2:19:54] Again, this is going to be a part of the field [2:19:56] for all public hearing that we'll walk through next week. [2:19:59] Oh, we have Jonathan. [2:20:20] They're aware that they might know that not know the numbers [2:20:24] because they're not said yet, but they're aware that we are recognizing it's time to [2:20:31] do some changes, make some changes to the fees. [2:20:37] So that's it on public, I mean the planning and zoning application fees, and then now to [2:20:43] the impact fees, this will be coming before you as a public hearing later. [2:20:50] Our first public hearing for impact fees with planning and zoning is August 10th, so [2:20:54] next week and it's kind of the same thing. It's time to take a look at these. We can look at these every five years, I believe, and assess the fees and what's an equitable program for our growth. [2:21:10] So again, for Chris for your question, they have extensively gone over these impact fees with these certain, I know Johnson's made a lot of field trips to different associations. [2:21:32] we've had people in the office that he's gone over and explained and they kind of they understand they don't probably don't like it but they understand it so so moving forward we're going to have public hearings with Planning and Zoning Commission to see if what's been studied and looked at is equitable or okay with them and then we'll bring it to you for public hearing. [2:21:58] I think that is all I have. [2:22:01] Thanks guys. [2:22:13] Thank you. [2:22:14] Thank you for stepping in. [2:22:15] Appreciate it. [2:22:16] I just want to go back to the impact fees just really quickly. [2:22:25] It's important to also recognize that we have an impact fee advisory committee's project for a very long time associated with the members of the building of subdivisions and the creation of homes. [2:22:58] So the fees are increasing. [2:23:02] members of. So one of the things that we talked about was the need for the Council [2:23:16] to have a conversation about the $770,000 that we've allocated each of the last several years. [2:23:25] We're not looking for a decision this evening, but maybe some guidance as to where projects [2:23:33] that you might be most interested in, projects that you would like for us to [2:23:37] We will go through some of these items. [2:23:42] One of the things that the Council has passed for was what was the category B list of projects. [2:23:49] Here's the list of category B projects that we have as it relates into the budget. [2:23:56] Remember that we established category B projects to ensure that we were able to advance the project list that we've created [2:24:05] and then take advantage of a more robust economy than maybe we'll, and so what we have done this [2:24:15] year and what we will continue to do is we will identify projects that are important but didn't make [2:24:20] the fine, that's what we refer to as a category B project. Those projects will come before the City [2:24:26] Council. I'm at the conclusion of the second quarter of fiscal 2022. Should revenues be [2:24:33] how pacing projections, your tax collections, can be recalled that we were able to fund projects [2:24:45] of the second quarter. Here are some of those projects. You can see the department referenced [2:25:00] as well as the specific piece of equipment. So if there are items that you'd like to learn [2:25:06] more about, our hope is to have the department leaders present next week to share. So if there's [2:25:13] There's anything on this list that is exciting to you, [2:25:16] because we have more, right? [2:25:17] I can scroll down to the next page, [2:25:22] but next page, because what I think this illustrates is [2:25:26] there is never for us to be able to accomplish goals [2:25:34] and objectives, and so we make a whole series [2:25:36] of difficult choices, whether it be in budget balancing, [2:25:41] where we create category B projects, [2:25:43] or whether it be through the long-term planning process [2:25:46] starts in January where projects are not advanced by members of that question. So something I would like to get a little more detail on is what the [2:26:00] opens on this time. I was trying to remember everything that was presented last week. Like safety and I'm not sure that that's all included on this list. [2:26:41] Everything that has gone, so everything that has gone officially through our processes, including on the list. [2:26:50] Here's some additional long-term planning things that you might be taking a look at. [2:26:56] So these are the real list of police and fire items that are, I guess, maybe not our city engineers in here, copious notes, because he'll be ready. [2:27:40] This does seem like I'm picking up. [2:27:48] For issues with our streaming, is it the second one? [2:27:57] No, that can't explain that more. [2:28:06] It's more about that, but that's really more of what we do, as I understand it, with also next week as your call area is six, and so that's where really parks and recreation will be able to answer several of the questions, and then also the airport is will be following under prosperous community this year. [2:28:56] Projects to consider these are not necessarily projects that we had placed on our list, but they had come up through a series of other conversations. [2:29:06] will say that the conversation has been about floral avenue. We brought up last [2:29:15] year's numbers. What we can share with you is that we will leave that these [2:29:20] numbers are low in comparison to what it would actually cost to construct. But we [2:29:28] didn't want to spend a lot of staff time if there wasn't considerable interest [2:29:33] from the city council to kind of move forward with some of these projects. What [2:29:38] What I will share with you is based upon current spending and level of cash reserve in the [2:29:44] street fund. [2:29:45] The top two options mean significantly altering the husband presented this evening as it relates [2:29:57] to the zone maintenance program. [2:29:59] So these are certainly projects that we could, if interest accounts that we can floor and save [2:30:07] for, it does not have capacity. [2:30:14] It's in the executive condition and leads from. [2:30:36] So there may be a spend significant cost and program. [2:30:47] It was not in interest from the city council to advance those projects this year. [2:30:53] Not saying that you may not in a subsequent year, but just if there wasn't the desire to move. [2:30:58] So for this year, we're going to focus our efforts on those things that you're more interested in that list back up. [2:31:19] And obviously, as you have a chance to digest this list, [2:31:24] please send us an email, a little bit staff member, [2:31:34] these items is available. [2:31:40] And, Travis, we have started, [2:31:41] two years ago, working on touch-up, because we didn't have the money to rebuild [2:31:52] that or disaster thing we need to look at it. [2:31:56] So that's going to conclude, focus areas four, five, and seven, [2:32:23] and then we're going to move into focus areas one and six. [2:32:27] Next week, it's a pretty big week going to, [2:32:31] and only here focus areas one and six, but you're also going to get a overview of the budget again. [2:32:38] Because we're going to ask you to adopt the preliminary budget, which is one of the first moves that you have to make in accordance with, I don't know, adopting a preliminary budget means you're going to set the maximum spending. [2:32:50] So in setting that maximum spending, with changes in what the council has done in the past is they've incorporated the pin that left open the possibilities of including your foregone balance. [2:33:08] in its entirety, that option has been taken away by the legislature, but yet you still [2:33:13] have to go through the formality of taking a look at the preliminary budget, and also [2:33:16] as a part of that, you will go through the process of establishing the public hearing date which [2:33:22] has already been set when we placed all of that information to the counties when they [2:33:28] sent out tax information. They also published on the notice when the public hearing dates [2:33:33] and scheduled to occur on the E-third any sooner than six o'clock or see [2:33:44] public will ask the council to consider the budget. Proud of is if you think [2:33:54] about the number of conversations that we've had but also to illustrate the [2:34:05] purposes behind decisions or I guess the rationale behind the decisions that [2:34:10] we've made and contrast that to other organizations I think we have to stand for. [2:34:19] Travis was asked on what was presented item that is just general public input so if [2:34:56] If there's anyone in the audience who has questions or comments for the council that was not on this evening's agenda, [2:35:03] now is your opportunity to bring those forward, right? [2:35:10] Council for advisory board reports or announcements? [2:35:14] Six o'clock? [2:35:26] Yes, sir. [2:35:27] So, um, national light out. [2:35:30] Is out. [2:35:31] You want to give us a quick invitation to National Night out tomorrow night. [2:35:36] Thanks for calling on me in the last minute. [2:35:41] You want to know tomorrow is our annual event national night out in City Park. [2:35:44] This is part of a nationwide program that we started participating in several years ago. [2:35:49] We will have representatives from almost every public safety entity in the tribe, excuse me, the Magic Valley. [2:35:56] You can come out and meet officers in joy. [2:35:58] I'm in the serve here, King of Fire, Sheriff's Law Enforcement, and EMS. [2:36:05] And we look forward to seeing you there. [2:36:07] Sorry, it's from five to eight in City Park tomorrow. [2:36:11] the city park. Thank you for the city manager's office. We have no public hearings this evening, [2:36:29] so we are adjourned.