Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-04-05, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-04-05/ [0:03:42] We have eight corps this evening, six members in person, and [0:03:48] Councilman Merigar has had a last minute issue come up. [0:03:52] And if he can join us by phone later this evening, he will. [0:03:56] Attendance if you would like to join us for the Pledge of Allegiance, please rise. [0:04:26] Applimations to see in addition to our regular housekeeping, if you were here for [0:05:48] the year we kind of fixed storm members, DJ Martinez, Brian Rice, and [0:05:56] bridge burell who have all completed two full-time commission and therefore they [0:06:02] we also had two engineers who have had to resign so that us with 5 patients which [0:06:41] is fantastic it shows that folks in our community are engaged and wanting to be [0:06:47] a part of what's happened so we went through and we interviewed 10 of the 25 [0:06:58] that we have been working with us. [0:07:16] I'm going to turn it over to Kati to... [0:07:25] Oh, yes, thank you, Mayor. [0:07:32] Yeah, it was a little stankery [0:07:37] to go through 25 applications, [0:07:39] and then narrow that to 10, [0:07:41] and I'm sure there's some good people. [0:07:43] I mean, you just can't do 25 people. [0:07:45] And so, I'm sure there's a good people that didn't make the first cut [0:07:49] that we may have... [0:07:51] What we're there to interview, but we have, even with the tan, we probably had eight or nine [0:07:58] of what commission members, but we only had five openings, only five, that's our thing to say. [0:08:06] But we went ahead and these five, we've been a bit, certainly, trying to man a few. [0:08:14] Have a thought. We thought these five gave us a wide representation across our community age groups, [0:08:22] as well as expertise and interests and all the different things that we were trying to [0:08:30] have happen as part of the mission. Obviously with five of the nine, we knew it's going to be [0:08:39] interesting first meeting because I think two of the people that are no longer there with the [0:08:43] chairman and the vice chairman so we're going to have some uh the first meeting's going to be a [0:09:18] the order and so that's how we decided to do that because obviously anybody on the [0:09:24] partial terms can go ahead and re-apply when their term comes up and if any of [0:09:29] those who are here would like to come down and say a word or two you're [0:09:34] certainly welcome to and I'm sitting very rushing up here nor would I to be honest with you so [0:09:40] unless Mitch has something extra you have something else you'd like to admit the only thing I would [0:09:45] That is the fourth that are here, say your name, you can wave so the council knows who's [0:09:51] who. [0:09:52] That's a good idea. [0:09:53] Heather's over here on the far left, I guess you're left, right? [0:09:57] Me was, yeah. [0:09:58] I had to ask her how to pronounce that, and then Michael Metcalfis in the cap, right here. [0:10:05] Where'd Ashley go? [0:10:07] Ashley's right behind Michael, and then Jade is right over here in the blue pope. [0:10:11] So those are the four. [0:10:12] Kevin, we knew Kevin wasn't going to be able to make it tonight. [0:10:14] He had it at times out of town. [0:10:19] and realize that we were looking for somebody with some landscape being backgrounded. [0:10:26] We ended up with Michael on one of his co-workers. [0:10:29] We're two of the people we interviewed, and I hope that didn't cause any trouble at work, [0:10:33] and we chose you. [0:10:36] But, as I said, a lot of ground was covered. [0:10:40] And we hope that commission, if you're ready for a motion, Mayor, I'll go ahead. [0:10:48] First, I just want to say thank you very much for being here. [0:10:51] It means a lot that your willingness is here. [0:11:03] So before you leave this evening, please introduce yourselves to her that you're just comfortable with. [0:11:11] Michael Medcalf to a three-year term makes the squares to a three-year term. [0:11:21] Heather, Muth, to a four-year term, Jay Titus to a one-year term, and Kevin Simpson to a two-year term to our partial recognition. [0:11:37] Although I just want to confirm with me that if a partial term, they are still eligible to serve two full terms after that partial, correct? [0:11:59] for this commission that's true. [0:12:01] So for J.D. Kevin, congratulations. [0:12:04] You can get more here. [0:12:06] So this commission resolution declaring a surplus letter [0:12:48] truck to the. [0:13:04] That's a lesson. [0:13:04] I want to give you just a little bit of background [0:13:07] on that truck. [0:13:07] So we purchased that truck in October of New Year's of Service, [0:13:12] the 30 Year's of Service. [0:13:14] It's been just an awesome apparatus for us. [0:13:17] We do a few years ago. [0:13:19] Honestly, we have that tested from an outside third party [0:13:23] that it's a still a viable apparatus. That's a five-year test. [0:13:32] As the truck aged over the years, we started to become [0:13:43] the hazards department. We started training with it. [0:13:56] So we knew a few years ago that if we didn't start testing that every year, [0:14:01] we could find ourselves just because of the age of the truck in a situation where [0:14:08] in 2019 that actually happened for us. It actually had three Type 1 fails, [0:14:13] two of which are relatively, I wouldn't say they're minor, but they're not really expensive [0:14:20] and then one of them on the extension ramp turns out it could possibly be out of fix. [0:14:27] So that's when we started working through the process of putting a new ladder truck. [0:14:31] And that's basically what gets in the city of Tronofa. [0:14:44] Chief Comfort and Filer, who asked us basically what we're going to do. [0:14:54] Let us know that he was really interested, knowing Chief Comfort the way that I do, [0:15:00] but he's very resourceful and sure that he'll put it in service to the best or to the every resourceful. [0:15:19] So with that we're actually asking if if I could just really quickly a few years ago we actually donated an engine that engine was also in need of some pretty significant repair. [0:16:00] They were able to get the truck, they did some fundraisers and they raised a little bit of aid through their budget process as well to actually put that truck, or that truck and actually put it in for service. [0:16:12] They've been used for a smaller process that leads trucks are really with that. [0:16:34] We'll last that you run a resolution. [0:16:36] Resolution number is 2021-007 in grade 19. [0:17:22] I'm sure, buddy. That will exit to this degree. It makes it very useful. [0:17:27] We're with them and they haven't completed yet, but they have a nice new firehouse. [0:17:31] I'm sure they will give them room to store this thing. [0:17:35] I'd also like to comment, the filer has been, we have police, especially fire employees from filer, including our battalion chief speaking to us, and we always pronounce this name a little differently there, but a lot of, a lot of fire employees come from filer, and so I think it's a very fitting that we [0:17:58] of resolution 007 declaring or plus and authorized the donation of the ladder check to the filer [0:18:30] second then, [0:18:35] solution 22- 007 [0:18:45] I wanna speak, appreciate it and be something we pray to use service to you guys [0:19:33] as is needed, as is the opportunity, as is maybe, as is the next thing you know, we'll try to just have a different name on it [0:20:29] it's not very often, we get a chance to be a blessing back, so thank you for accepting [0:20:33] I'm trying to throw out the compiler. [0:20:57] Yeah, yeah, yeah. [0:20:58] There's actually a full of folks who kind of this process, which is a bit maybe sadistic. [0:21:12] So I don't know. [0:21:25] The questions that you might be asking is, are we doing this a little early answers now? [0:21:32] No, last year, virus, aid issues that we had, and almost scheduled that we have a conversation [0:21:57] about landing is completed, their initial work. [0:22:03] And you'll see members of the city's leadership team in the audience to kind of help and [0:22:08] this process that we do want to share that this is not the first time that we'll engage the city council and the plenary budgeting process. [0:22:16] As you know, there will be two other occasions. So today is just really an opportunity to [0:22:22] formation from what we're seeing. So some initial budget thoughts and some are very, very similar. [0:22:34] I'm the first as we want to tie it to this city's strategic plan. But we're also going to, this year, begin to track, [0:22:49] to be starting to do this next year, leaders will be looking at five to seven performance [0:22:57] indicated all parts of our budget, we want to make sure that we fit in what you could [0:23:43] have in the last 12th calendar. So 12 months ago we were talking about 12 to 16% budgets, [0:24:09] those amounts are very conservative in our sense, they come in, we'll share a little bit about [0:24:36] reputation of being a strong truly sound, fiscally sound, local, all across the board, one that doesn't [0:24:51] have massive rate spikes or increases or doesn't rely on significant tax adjustments on an annual basis to be able to make sure [0:25:01] forecast in use, make sure that we objectives of that strategic plan. So here's some interesting data. The city of Twin Falls has 50,197 people based upon the July 19 census estimate. [0:25:32] That is the best from the Census Bureau, there's lots of other projections, rents are servicing [0:26:02] 100,000 people of a budget that is supported with property tax dollars and user fees predominant. [0:26:11] That is, this right here was staggering to me when I was looking at it. [0:26:30] Median household income inside of Twin Falls is now 50,739. [0:26:39] Our house prices are exploding at a rate far faster. [0:26:42] So the median value of $176 this year, this time it was at 220 years ago at the state of [0:27:09] Idaho is nearly $360,000 because in my opinion, the legislature and certain members don't agree [0:27:35] with me. [0:27:36] That's entirely their prerogative. [0:27:37] I believe one of the best ways that you can fix the property tax issue inside the state [0:27:43] Idaho is to reestablish indexing to the property values. [0:27:48] We're rate right now is 3.9% [0:28:06] high is 16. [0:28:20] So this is the budget. [0:28:21] Those tax rates was associated with [0:28:29] CARES dollars so it was a one-time infusion of cash [0:28:34] where the city's tax rate was $6.83. [0:28:38] We were able to ward office and we received [0:28:44] a 1.7 million across the city of Twin Falls. [0:28:52] Value of the city, the total value of the city of [0:29:20] 20,000 and 12 rates over the last several years, [0:29:49] the city's tax rate has been debt service and transfers. [0:30:12] The debt service represents 9%, [0:30:14] but it's only the interest price funds. [0:30:16] We hear some pretty interesting [0:30:34] if I had the city of Twin Falls. [0:30:41] And you can see that right now, [0:30:42] like I shared, it's 258,000. [0:30:45] They are projecting 179 of the city of Twin Falls. [0:30:59] The price per square foot unseen as a city, [0:32:07] because as houses continue to escalate in value assessor. [0:32:17] To assign represents the houses are going to, [0:32:26] but it's also going to have a location [0:32:37] on people doing this massive price escalation. [0:32:59] We're cognizant about what that's doing to rent. [0:33:07] We also need the total number of single family home [0:33:46] for bids that we've issued. [0:33:50] This is fresh off the presses. [0:33:52] This was, so it knew the last month's number [0:33:57] of bids was able to work. [0:33:58] We turn this around. [0:34:02] This is hot off the presses. [0:34:05] So for the first six months, the city of Twin Falls [0:34:07] is issued 306 single family bill 2018 permits [0:34:25] We're projecting somewhere between 650 and 800 single-family prevents just this year alone. [0:34:55] It doesn't include multi-family. [0:34:58] If you take a look at the 573 that we issued last year, the look it sends a stat that says [0:35:04] that the average household size inside the city of Twin Falls is 2.6 residents, perhaps. [0:35:11] Last year we added here that the city of Twin Falls is not the only city in the Magic Valley [0:35:31] experiencing these types of numbers witnessing this transportation police [0:35:55] officers and firefighters that we have [0:36:14] they understand our physical year starts October 1st [0:36:17] between the inmates and the six months of these are numbers since October 1st [0:36:21] they're not the last 12 months they're that's October 1st [0:36:27] that's right so in in hand it's also important to remember those six months [0:36:32] winter usually the slowest time of our building cycle that's how you can [0:36:42] go from 306 to potentially 800 because 6 months of the year 4% of the total and so [0:37:04] while news anticipated associated with building we had somewhere start to see [0:37:36] significant number that's coming with what I will say [0:37:54] fire station number five don't have the ability to build fire station number five [0:37:59] fire station number five to stand up and say you should not annex this property [0:38:08] to the east of this line because we don't believe once this is highly takes [0:38:41] time to design and construct the most importantly, it takes an organization being committed in this calendar year. [0:39:29] We budgeted for the fiscal year to $45,000. [0:39:33] In the first six months we've collected $1,000,000. [0:39:41] Beak with some confidence that we're going to beat that budgetary number of course in the next six months. [0:39:46] Right here is wrong, just so you know, this is the old information we've plugged in charts and so I apologize, but if you take a look, [0:40:10] The estimated value of Oregon's height of the City of Twin Falls for the first six months [0:40:15] is $96,300,500 in fiscal year to actual. Much of that relies as largely dependent. [0:40:40] We've seen an explosion. Our collection is approximately the same for a living unit for Lee. [0:41:49] How much time it takes our building departments to expect those or is it more of a... [0:41:56] I've just been saying that I've figured it's 40 other cities, one of those buildings, I don't know whether it's East here or former, harder because they're all too storied for the most part and things. [0:42:05] We have seen a lot of people going to show up on this report, and so that's amazing to me that people are actually knocking on my door, asking to put them in a once, so I got spursale in my room. [0:44:36] I kept sharing. Across last year, we're 16% in some places in our state, and across the US unemployed and statistical area sectors. [0:45:30] I thought this was pretty interesting to prove some make-ups and sense to me. [0:46:36] I found some stuff that, well, this is pretty interesting. [0:46:39] So this is the overall consumer price index. [0:46:43] I could assume a consumer customer and a citizen. [0:46:51] And this kind of illustrates what that looks like to recovery. [0:47:40] You'll also notice that series of other, this is how Gen Zers, [0:48:53] Millennials, Gen Xers, and baby boomers. [0:49:24] So depending on your education team, the next one I thought was the most interesting [0:49:54] anime until election day, and then it tanked, and if you were a Democrat, [0:50:08] cleared yourself as a part of our design as a society. [0:51:13] We as a local budget is that we credence that people who are price index is another [0:52:32] measure. You can see the price index, 0.7% of those funds to help. [0:54:46] Here's the MCI, a cost index, which is government's version, consumer price index, [0:55:10] How the services are continuing to present impact on the fresh air memory because we saw this, the B-shaped, but certainly the W-2. [0:56:57] So any questions on close attention the council needs to act. So every single year in this foregone that it may be there when we'll legislate just now looking. [0:58:06] All of the good work that you've done as a city council to keep taxes low and use that $2.2 million for a potential rainy day is now getting about property values. [0:58:27] We'll remember it's going to take a must. We've said we don't want to touch the foregone balance. [0:58:55] The pin of saying we don't want to touch the ido will legislate you this last year. [0:59:04] Services will be having us only be able to take 50% of a new construction value or have a hard cap of 4%. [0:59:25] Isn't going to allow us to continue at the basic level of services that we need as a growing conversation with you about impact fees. [0:59:40] and Jonathan H.S. reserves offset the impact of price paid absorb thousand in [1:00:35] that's tail service which as every other community is growing you have 77 [1:00:44] sworn police officers on the street at a hundred thousand people that's less [1:00:50] than one officer per thousand. See 77 police officers at 52 thousands of [1:01:00] is a number that makes you feel good, but 77 police officers at the community, over 100,000 [1:01:07] of population served, isn't. [1:01:09] The business at the flat, but we have some real needs, I mean, brook springs, you would [1:02:38] see in every residential facility, 73 cents, but the tirements that we have, but it's impacting [1:03:33] our workforce, but losing employees, I've shared with you that we've lost three critical [1:03:45] positions, or we'll lose three critical positions as a result of retirements. [1:04:01] The compensation isn't the only recent job the films cost us organizationly $232,000, [1:04:32] $2,000 in four capacities, but if we stop investing, it'll has done through these years [1:06:58] $170,000 of council capital projects. [1:07:49] Here's the list of the projects that you $7,70. [1:07:53] There's a list of potential words discussed by long term planning and they also appeared [1:08:07] on a list that were not $1,000 for the evil. [1:08:15] the road to 1000 furnished sidewalks as well as you remember but makes us a little bit [1:08:45] unique is that we also have the opportunity to apply for federal funds through direct [1:08:51] and nice new fit walks and the city is going to engage in that process just as we have in the past [1:09:07] and in the past we've been able to do more funds to help us with the acoustics recipient of [1:09:25] funds that in receiving those funds it's important around they're going to go somewhere [1:09:30] to the City of Twin Falls so that we can use those funds to offset increases in property taxes, increases in user rates that to be able to support and advance the system. [1:09:47] So we have manned up with some folks in Washington, D.C. to fully understand that your resources to help us cover significant projects that we otherwise couldn't hear. [1:10:32] Most of the time, it's that my biggest concern was making sure that the process and I look [1:11:48] up my politically smoothie as well, just have an honest conversation about where we stand [1:11:55] at the end of this month. [1:12:46] So what we committed is that we would come back, here's the CAD projects, which of these [1:12:54] do you want to spend. [1:12:55] So we have the, as you know, we kind of stacked when we come and ask you to spend some [1:13:31] of the unanticipated revenues that we realize to fund those category B projects so that [1:13:36] We've captured enough fun. Let's say one year, at some point you're 97 single-family friends again in a position where I out of the council and say, right? [1:15:50] So here's what it looks like. This is the formal presentations, right? [1:15:56] So if you're budget sometime, shouldn't be, shouldn't say the third, should say also on the 26th, we're going to have our second input session. [1:16:28] But on that input session, you're going to prompt some prompting of arsenic debt. [1:16:43] those types of conversations because really those will be part of the drivers [1:16:47] that we'll use. It's the following week, fifth and sixth, we'll say this is what the [1:17:00] county... and then we go through our day. This is what we held the state as money coming into the city of the city. [1:17:46] The conversation you've heard anyway from the governor's office about a repeat of last [1:17:52] years this specific