Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2019-10-28, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2019-10-28/ [0:00:07] Good evening. I would like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting from Monday, October 28th and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here. [0:00:15] Six of the seven members are present this evening. Vice Mayor Boyd is absent this evening. [0:00:21] Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:00:25] Next on the agenda, we have clomations and I do have a proclamation this evening. [0:00:56] With permission of Governor Brad Little, I am issuing an order that all United States and Idaho State flags at public facilities in the City of Twin Falls. [0:01:07] He flown at half staff from Sunrise today until sunset on Friday, November 1st in honor of former Twin Falls Fire Chief Ron Clark. [0:01:16] I further invite interested organizations and individuals to join in this observance. [0:01:21] Clark died unexpectedly Monday, October 14, 2019, surrounded by his loved ones. [0:01:27] Mark often said that he won the career lottery when he started his career with the Twin Falls Fire Department in February 1976. [0:01:35] He rose through the ranks of the Fire Department serving as a driver, captain, and battalion chief. [0:01:41] He was appointed to the role of Fire Chief in May 1998. [0:01:45] Mark served in that role until his retirement in July 2016, [0:01:49] after more than 40 years with the City of Twin Falls among the longest serving public servants of the citizens of Twin Falls. [0:01:56] Park was actively involved in supporting firefighters and the profession, even serving as president [0:02:03] of the Twin Falls Professional Firefighters Union, Local 1556, and as president of the Idaho [0:02:08] Fire Chiefs Association. On behalf of the City of Twin Falls, I express my sincerest condolences [0:02:15] to the family of Chief Clark. His dedication to the citizens of Twin Falls during his tenure [0:02:20] is a testament to the core values of public service and the city's mission of people serving [0:02:25] people. So please join me. His family is here this evening. I present this proclamation to them. [0:02:32] And our sincereless condolences to you on your loss. Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general [0:03:07] public input. There's anyone here who wishes to address the council on an item not on the agenda [0:03:12] this evening. Now as you're opted to please come forward. I do want to just review the public [0:03:17] input procedures to please wait to be recognized by the mayor and approach the podium and state your [0:03:23] name and whether you are a resident or a property owner in the City of Twin Falls, [0:03:27] and then you can proceed with your input and we are going to limit that to three [0:03:32] minutes this evening for individuals speaking to the Council. [0:03:35] For your service in our city and I genuinely, since the last time I stood before you, [0:04:06] nearly 60 babies have been murdered in our city, was originally to request an appeal [0:04:25] of you to reconsider your decision in August to not discuss this ordinance request to abolish [0:04:34] abortion in the City of Twin Falls. [0:04:37] I've been working with people across our state for several years now with Citizen Initiative [0:04:45] ballot measures introducing bills to state legislators to abolish abortion, not to regulate [0:04:53] abortion, not to regulate when it can happen and when it cannot happen, but a total abolition [0:05:03] of abortion, where I argue that the City of Twin Falls has the jurisdiction to stop the [0:05:11] murdering of our neighbors. [0:05:13] I respect that not all see this as I do. [0:05:18] We will once again introduce the Abortion Human Rights Act again when state legislation returns [0:05:25] January of 2020. Know this that when I address you, I'm not speaking on behalf of my church. [0:05:35] I do not pretend to speak on behalf of anyone but myself. I speak before you as a God-fearing, [0:05:45] tax-paying, property-owning, law-abiding neighbor or my neighbors who do not have the opportunity [0:05:54] to stand before you and speak. Tonight, I will ask you if you would be willing to consider [0:06:03] a resolution or a proclamation addressed to our state legislators to act on behalf of our [0:06:09] city to abolish abortion in Idaho, only three cities in the state of Idaho that allow the [0:06:18] murdering of babies. Twin Falls is one of those cities. Idaho code has already settled the [0:06:28] human personhood question of the baby in the womb, our human neighbors are at risk [0:06:35] of being murdered in broad daylight. I stand prepared to offer to you a draft [0:06:42] resolution or proclamation for your consideration to deal with and to act [0:06:49] upon at a further date and to ask that you make preparation to either present or [0:06:56] be presented with this resolution in support of the Abortion Human Rights Act of Idaho. [0:07:04] With respect to my God, it is that I make this appeal to you today, and I request that [0:07:10] you respond to my... [0:07:11] Yes, I was just going to briefly describe process, and then I'll certainly turn it over there. [0:07:24] So, your request is for one of two different things, proclamation is actually issued by the [0:07:30] by the mayor's office, resolutions are an action of the council, and as you know, we can take action on no items that were not on the agenda, so I guess if there is input from the council, the question would be whether that would also note that historically it comes to issues of the legislature, and I can only maybe think of it that we typically wait until there is bill that's been presented by [0:08:05] They're the ones who can introduce legislation, so that's just my process. [0:08:11] There's an option at this time. Start their session. We can bring it back. [0:08:49] So, just let me be clear. You would work with Pastor Paul. That's what you're saying. [0:08:53] Okay. [0:08:54] Legislation that will already have sponsors and co-sponsors of the bill, [0:09:20] and it will be introduced as a legislative session begins. [0:09:25] So, I will ask for your urge, the Attorney General. [0:09:37] Yes, he is. [0:09:41] I disagree with you to an else who wishes to address the council [0:10:05] Anyone else who wishes to address the council on and I am not on the agenda this evening. No, Chris talking to me. I'm sorry [0:10:45] To address the first statement I agree [0:10:58] I do not support working down in this actions of which you've been received [0:11:03] I don't know that you can I spoke before you as a citizen of the city of Twin Falls [0:11:13] And I do pastor a local church in the city, and it would surprise me if anyone in my church [0:11:19] spoke to you. [0:11:22] If I find out that any have, I would appeal to them, it gave better than that. [0:11:28] To the second, or your second, stage of your life. [0:11:36] And it was not intended. [0:11:41] Yes, sir. [0:11:42] Yes, sir. [0:11:45] I totally support that. [0:11:48] I support, especially for parents, especially for fathers and mothers, to teach their children [0:11:54] the proper way to handle sex and sex education. [0:11:59] I am in support of sex education of our young people and of all citizens. [0:12:03] I have no reservations about the education of sex education. [0:12:12] We would have to have a discussion about what earth control you're speaking of. [0:12:15] If we're talking about abortifacients, then no, I do not and would not be in support of [0:12:20] abortifacients. [0:12:22] that actually do murder the inception after the fertilization of the egg. [0:12:30] I would not be in support of any such birth control is an issue that families can weigh [0:12:37] in and deal with. [0:12:38] And I do not forbid anyone in my church even to teach their children about sex education [0:12:45] and birth control. [0:12:46] responses. So at the risk of having a debate about an item that is not agendized or just to [0:12:57] hold our continued conversation when this may anyone else who wishes to address the council [0:13:06] this evening on an item not on the agenda. I did see one other name signed up up there on [0:13:12] item seven. So this is similar to item seven that it's general input. So if there's anyone [0:13:18] One new wish is to come forward and ask for a chance. [0:13:21] We will still have item seven as well. [0:13:23] But on the agenda, which is the consent council wishes on that. [0:13:40] Second. [0:13:41] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce. [0:13:46] The consent calendar. [0:13:47] Is there any discussion? [0:13:48] John Paraker? [0:13:54] Yes. [0:13:55] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:13:56] Yes. [0:13:57] Greg Lanti? [0:13:58] Yes. [0:13:59] Ruth Pierce? [0:14:00] Yes. [0:14:01] Christopher Reed? [0:14:02] Yes. [0:14:03] Miss Tockington? [0:14:04] Yes. [0:14:05] If you are here for the special event application for the, excuse me, trick-or-treat on Bishes [0:14:12] Street, I'm award the findings of fact and conclusions of law for a waste and stop-and-go. [0:14:18] Those were just approved along with the payables and minutes from the next and the agenda and [0:14:27] their items of consideration. [0:14:29] The first is a request to confirm the mayor's appointment of Joe Mason to the airport advisory [0:14:34] board. [0:14:37] So the city advertised for applicants interested in becoming a city representative on the airport board due to the departure of Brady Workman who fulfilled his two-term [0:14:48] element to have worked with the city public information officer and issuing press releases and listing the opening on the city's website. [0:14:55] An interview committee composed of myself, City Airport Liaison, Chris Tawkinton, Airport Board Chairman Mike March and the Airport Manager, Bill Carberry interviewed six candidates for that opening. [0:15:06] The committee was impressed with Joe Mason and unanimously agreed to recommend him. [0:15:11] He grew up in Kimberly attended CSI and the University of Idaho is a small business owner [0:15:16] of Floyd Lilly Company here in Twin. [0:15:18] He lives in the city limits, holds a private pilot, license and flies out of the airport [0:15:22] regularly for business and pleasure. [0:15:25] So the approval process under city code states that airport board member appointments are [0:15:30] recommended by the mayor and confirmed by the city council. [0:15:33] So I would request council approval to amason to the firm the your appointment of Joe Mason to the airport advisory board [0:15:49] I should buy a root beer second of I [0:15:50] This is and Hawkins to confirm the appointment of Joe Mason to the airport advisory board is there a discussion [0:15:57] Great landing. Yes. Yes, Mr. Feree. Yes. He's talking to yes [0:16:21] Yes [0:16:23] to zero. Would you like to come up and say a few words? I gave you the warning. You'll [0:16:35] have to come to the podium to do so. Sorry. Yeah. You'll get your warmed up for those high [0:16:40] intensity airport board meetings. I'd like to say thank you and for the opportunity and [0:16:46] I'm looking forward to serving you. May I have a next on the agenda we have a this action [0:16:59] item. This is a request to change lane dimension on Grandview Drive north near the intersection [0:17:05] of Falls Avenue West, and I'm Jason Brandt with our engineering department, welcome Jason. [0:17:10] Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. Appreciate this opportunity to come before [0:17:14] you tonight. And, you know, not very often that the environmental engineer has to deal [0:17:19] with traffic or roadways, so that's typically what I'm coming through with the sewer expansion [0:17:24] or something that we deal with roadway. But this particular section of town is where we're [0:17:31] We're in the process of designing and reconstruct the sewer line that goes down portions of [0:17:40] Grandview. [0:17:41] Can I get the... [0:17:42] And so that's why I'm here tonight in consultation with the engineer that we've hired for this [0:17:52] design and then also other city departments. [0:17:55] We've had over the past little bit, we've stormed events, we've had some issues with storm water [0:18:01] here. [0:18:02] idea of putting a curving gutter from Robins here, all the way in connecting the curving [0:18:07] gutter to what turning radius there and falls would help benefit the stormwater in this area [0:18:16] keeps some water from going into yards in this particular area and looking at that, this [0:18:22] is an arterial road in our master transportation plan. And so what we'd like to do is use what [0:18:30] our current right away is put some Kermit Gutter in and not additional right away and I have [0:18:39] a did a schematic I had the engineer provide a schematic force and what maybe that would [0:18:47] look like. And so if you if this bottom one it's not showing on your item that I put in [0:18:54] here on the screen you have a solid red line and a dashed red line would be the complete [0:19:09] build out that'd be the the full ride away at 46 feet on one side of center [0:19:14] line of 46 on the other side and as you can see those houses would be affected [0:19:20] quite a bit if we went parts and so help this project the sewer project go along [0:19:38] we would like to put some curb and gutter dimension for an artillery [0:19:49] process we'd actually be actually gaining a slight feat of drivable surface [0:19:54] and I'll go back to Google Maps and drop this and you can kind of see right here at the corner [0:20:01] of it's process, partisan clarification. [0:20:20] I think I just had another question. [0:20:39] So yeah, there is some sidewalk down Robbins here in the engineering department. [0:20:45] We've looked at other aspects. [0:20:48] They're actually in the process of developing this West side. [0:20:52] We've looked at actually providing a mid-block crossing for the kids to get across and use that sidewalk there. [0:21:02] As it stands now it would be very difficult to get a sidewalk in that portion. [0:21:09] And so we've looked at other avenues to be able to get kids across. [0:21:13] And as a side note, we're looking at a tool for sidewalk and I know the council in times past has looked at other areas around here. [0:21:26] And those areas are. [0:21:35] this particular project we did look at how would sidewalk fit into there and for us it would be [0:21:41] trying to get up across the street. There's nowhere for the kids now in that other sites at least a [0:21:59] year away if not further. Yeah so we're that's a concern for me for the kids in that neighborhood. [0:22:04] Yeah so we're actually in schedule wise we're behind the development so they actually will [0:22:09] develop before we will actually be here. The reason I'm coming tonight is because we didn't [0:22:14] want to go down a path of looking at some design without having some [0:22:19] direction from the council so we're really we're so because that was you know [0:22:29] driven it a couple of different times when school is out there our kids walking [0:22:34] I've noticed a lot of kids trying to get them to go to Caswell on that safe route [0:22:39] and get into the neighborhood but it's a free for all [0:22:42] it can be a free for all so we and that's why we were looking at Robins can we [0:22:47] Get them across the street to mid-block or there's actually a crosswalk here or this one is behind [0:22:58] So the sidewalk Chris read stop signs. I know that we had discussed [0:23:14] Read his agenda a stop sign over on falls [0:23:18] So are you saying falls and grand view or signs? Okay? [0:23:33] So putting a stop sign here we can look at putting and I'd have to go back and do talk to our [0:23:40] our traffic engineer and talked to the street superintendent what that would look like to traffic [0:23:45] and so that is something that we can look at if we need to come back and have a conversation [0:23:50] I wasn't definitely can change in making that a four way a four way stop there at the intersection [0:24:03] of crossing slowing that traffic so the speed limit we aren't we have no intentions of changing [0:24:38] the speed limit on that section and I believe it's 35, I'm talking second by Chris Reed to [0:25:20] to approve the lane dimension change as described as presented. [0:25:25] Greatly to do that. [0:25:26] I asked the recent question. [0:25:28] This and I think I know where they go to school with the kids. [0:25:31] The new kids are going to be on the subdivision. [0:25:34] This is currently under development to the west there. [0:25:37] This one here? [0:25:38] Yes. [0:25:41] What they be going to pride or are they going to Rock Creek? [0:25:45] I'm going to make these ones go to Rock Creek. [0:25:49] Yes, I be prying and then Robert Stewart, yeah, I don't know where exactly the boundaries [0:25:57] would be, but I know that I've seen these kids in this neighborhood walk, so Robert Stewart, [0:26:05] a prying and they're busting them up for their discussion on the motion. [0:26:41] With Fierce, yes, Mr. Fareed, yes, Mr. Tocquieton, Sean Berriger, yes, and Suzanne Ockett, yes. [0:26:48] I should pass a 6-0, thank you. [0:26:50] And next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input. [0:27:00] If there's anyone who wishes to address the council now, [0:27:03] should you please come forward? [0:27:05] The same procedure is in place for this batch of public input. [0:27:13] Please state your name and whether you're a property owner or resident in the city [0:27:17] and we're going to limit it to three minutes. [0:27:19] Thank you. [0:27:20] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:27:23] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:27:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:27:39] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:27:43] And this current campaign that has been going on has me a bit concerned. [0:27:50] I don't have a pony, a dog in the horse, in the race, but I have seen things that concern me. [0:27:59] And they concern me from the standpoint of I have been involved with speaking with people, [0:28:10] door to door, helping out with various campaign personnel. [0:28:17] I'm not going to say which ones because it's not just one. [0:28:21] There are a number of them that I do support. [0:28:24] And the reason that I support them is that I have personally complaints about property [0:28:32] taxes that I've seen up, I had a business on Addison Avenue, our business taxes more than [0:28:40] doubled. [0:28:42] I had problems with traffic, I have problems with the infrastructure, paralyzing commercial [0:28:51] Building permit processes for established business owners, one of one that bought my business. [0:28:58] And to name a few other issues, I'm a little bit concerned about where we're going with urban renewal. [0:29:08] I know that this perhaps doesn't concern me directly, but it does indirectly, [0:29:14] that I am a commerce person in twin falls. [0:29:19] I use twin falls every day. [0:29:22] There's another reason many, not just me, but other citizens, [0:29:27] aren't so involved in politics, I've found. [0:29:31] And one of them is, I think the average person feels as if perhaps [0:29:36] they're not being represented so much. [0:29:39] I personally have been up here a number of times, not just in this chamber, [0:29:43] chamber, but before. And I feel as if sometimes my voice has not heard, I've heard this before, [0:29:52] and this is a real concern to me, that people don't know that their voice is being listened [0:30:00] to, and their concerns are perhaps going ignored. I think that one of the things that I noticed [0:30:10] in terms of that hit me really strongly was an article that came out just recently really [0:30:19] bothered me in the Times News. [0:30:22] And I have tried to get articles in Times News and I've had much trouble doing that. [0:30:27] However, I found an article in Times News on October 23rd of this month regarding the City [0:30:35] City Council candidate was Firefoam TSA in 2011 for inappropriate contact and candor. [0:30:43] This made a front page and this bothers me that had this happen to anybody else, if it [0:30:54] was your mother, it was your grandmother, how would you feel? [0:31:00] I just think that this this article borderlines on yellow journalism and for that reason I [0:31:09] would like you all to please please consider your position the power you have as you know [0:31:17] authority council on city business this evening advisory board reports found the council [0:31:39] And just a later date to prove as small as to recommend to us that we approve the commences [0:32:10] who as long as the council to ask, the celebration is going to be held on the elite citizens begin [0:32:50] to have that information on the calendriod of Anthony as the time process of it's been [0:33:33] our system signed on November 11th. [0:33:35] Now that's what they've done, that's how they've typically had it in the past. [0:33:50] So I would just remind folks maybe to the points that our last speaker was making [0:33:54] that's still early voting this week, County West, [0:34:00] for the municipal election, most of there are some other items, [0:34:03] for our school board seats, as well as a bond issue [0:34:07] with the county, trail section, it's trail section [0:34:24] at two o'clock asking people to meet at Candy Crest [0:34:30] and Park there and walk everything else is in. [0:34:39] All right, so with that, we do have a request to adjourn [0:34:43] to executive session under Idaho Code 74206-1-B [0:34:48] To consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining of, or to hear complaints for charges brought against public officer employees, staff, member, or individual, agent, or public school student, an IDO code 742061F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of, and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated, but immediately likely to be lit in mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy that. [0:35:19] This requirement can solicit us. [0:35:24] Second. [0:35:26] Chris Stockington, Pierce, move adjournment to executive session [0:35:32] as stated is there any discussion. [0:35:37] Travis, I have an answer to describe the reason [0:35:43] for the executive session on the last one of us. [0:35:48] A big school student, though as we get to have section [0:35:57] of the Idaho, come from section seven. [0:36:15] Ruth Pierce, yes. [0:36:16] Christopher Reed, yes. [0:36:17] Chris Talkington, yes. [0:36:19] John Baraker, yes. [0:36:20] Suzanne Hawkins, yes. [0:36:22] Yes, we should pass this 6-0. [0:36:25] In adjourning, just let everyone know we will not be reconvening the council meeting following the executive session, [0:36:32] or will we be making the decisions in the executive session. [0:36:36] With that, being adjourning.