Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2019-08-12, recording 2 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2019-08-12/ [0:00:04] Good evening. I would like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, August 12th and confirm that we do have a quorum of the Council. All seven members are here this evening. [0:00:13] Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those who wish to join us, please rise. Proclamations this evening. So next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:00:47] Someone here who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening. Now is your opportunity to please come forward. [0:00:54] Please state your name and whether you are a property owner or resident of the City of Twin Falls, please. [0:01:15] And can you check and see if that microphone's on this little button that says push. Green light comes on. [0:01:20] Sorry. [0:01:21] My name's Mona Blay Myers-Wicks and I'm a Twin Falls City resident. [0:01:28] And what I wanted to ask about was the recycling. I know it was mentioned last Monday. [0:01:32] and I wanted to ask you guys all the questions. [0:01:35] When did you guys sign the newest contract? [0:01:37] My understanding we just signed a new contract in January, [0:01:39] is that true? [0:01:40] So I don't have that information. [0:01:42] We are going to discuss the recycling issue [0:01:45] on the six o'clock public hearing, [0:01:47] so it is an item on the agenda this evening. [0:01:49] We certainly can track down that information [0:01:51] if that question would be helpful for you. [0:01:53] I don't have it off the top of my head. [0:01:55] Can you answer that the last two years [0:01:57] that the olive city has been paying for recycling [0:02:00] and we have not been recycling? [0:02:02] to answer that question. [0:02:03] So again, we're going to have a public hearing at six o'clock [0:02:06] to discuss the recycling issues of the public input session [0:02:08] right now is for items that aren't on the agenda. [0:02:11] So since we're going to have that at six o'clock, [0:02:13] I mean, you'd be welcome to speak there. [0:02:14] And if you have questions, we can certainly [0:02:16] work with our staff and try to get answers to those. [0:02:19] Thanks. [0:02:19] All right. [0:02:20] Thank you. [0:02:21] There anyone else who wishes to address the council [0:02:23] on an item not on the agenda this evening? [0:02:29] On to the consent calendar. [0:02:33] Chris Reed, who the consent calendar has published. [0:02:38] Second. [0:02:39] Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar. [0:02:44] Is there any discussion? [0:02:45] We'll call it vote, please. [0:02:49] Paul Bericher? [0:02:54] Yes. [0:02:55] Nicky Boyd? [0:02:56] Yes. [0:02:57] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:02:58] Yes. [0:02:59] Greg Lanting? [0:03:00] Yes. [0:03:01] Christopher Reed? [0:03:02] Yes. [0:03:03] Chris Tockington? [0:03:04] Yes. [0:03:05] Motion passes at 7-0. [0:03:06] If you were here for the 9th Annual Optimist Club Wings and Things Ultimate Tailgate Challenge, [0:03:13] just approved, as well as the findings of fact and conclusions of law for the [0:03:17] prime point. Mayor, sir, a chance we'd have a just lawyer come down to describe the [0:03:23] wings and things. I'm not sure I know what that is. Sure. Thank you Greg. I couldn't get out of your [0:03:31] eye. My name is Dennis Boyer. I'm a board member. It is right this hard 9th annual [0:03:42] wings and things. Ultimate tailgating challenge. What we do is we try to have [0:03:48] participants out there cooking food in which you have to provide 500 samples, [0:03:53] whatever and I happen to do broads and you know so I have provided least 500 samples of broads throughout the day and [0:03:59] What's really unique? I think about this low fundraiser. It's really weak a lot of the schools in this area [0:04:05] It doesn't have to be athletic teams or just could be activities truly there's man debate [0:04:10] We really focus on that area where we want to give money that day. We give about [0:04:16] $10,000 out that day to [0:04:18] We're trying to get all three high schools, now three with Magic Valley High School, and [0:04:29] also we get some private schools involved with too, so it's a fun day, it's from 5 to 8 on Saturday, September 7th. [0:04:36] It only costs $10 a ticket to try a bunch of different type of food, and if you buy an advance, it's $2 for $15. [0:04:46] Next on the agenda under items of consideration the first is an action item [0:04:55] This is a request to consider the pollinator friendly community resolution to become a B City USA and monarch city USA affiliate [0:05:11] So what you have before you is [0:05:19] is not that so we're not talking about the park [0:05:37] we're talking about becoming a pollinator friendly community [0:05:43] a little bit of history, I've been up here before [0:05:47] next week to inform you all [0:05:51] that we are going through that process [0:05:55] and to develop a draft resolution. As you all were aware [0:05:59] a citizen confronted or came here one night [0:06:03] evening during council meeting to petition you all to become a B-City USA [0:06:09] affiliate. Throughout that process we received another solicitation to become [0:06:15] a monarch city USA affiliate and so through that whole process we kind of [0:06:22] just merged everything together into one resolution, one draft resolution. So this [0:06:46] This is the draft resolution that combines, that turns us into a pollinator friendly community [0:06:53] by joining the B-City USA, affiliation and the Monarch City USA affiliation as well. [0:07:02] There are several members of what is being called the Twin Falls Pollinator Council [0:07:08] in the audience tonight and that is going to be a private council of concerned citizens [0:07:14] and local business leaders and industry managers [0:07:18] that have kind of come together to form this council [0:07:21] to promote the health and the growth of pollinators, [0:07:27] not just here locally, but throughout the region, [0:07:30] and then also nationally. [0:07:32] So if any of them would like to come forward and speak, [0:07:36] I would welcome that right now. [0:07:41] Here we go. [0:07:42] And if you have any questions after this, [0:07:44] I will certainly take them. [0:07:50] Good evening, Sherriles and Frank. [0:07:52] I came before you several months ago on this project. [0:07:55] I'm so excited to see how far it's come. [0:07:58] Just wanted to kind of let you know that this month I went up [0:08:02] to the Garden City's B-USA, Pollinator Garden. [0:08:07] And it's just a pocket garden. [0:08:09] It's not very big. [0:08:11] It's right next to a trail and the Garden City Library. [0:08:16] So there's lots and lots of activity there. [0:08:19] So, you know, I'm hopeful that we can do something like this in the Twin Falls area, [0:08:25] where it's, you know, just a small pocket park that has tons of information and gives that information [0:08:31] out to the public, and, you know, where they are instead of them having to go to a destination [0:08:38] to see it, it'll be there where they're going. [0:08:41] So, I'm very excited about this. [0:08:43] I'm happy to answer any questions. [0:08:48] I don't see any questions over there. [0:08:49] Thank you very much. [0:08:50] I haven't heard of any, I know I believe Mountain Home is another one that has a B-City USA designation. I have not been in contact with them. There are quite a few in the United States and it's a growing event. [0:09:23] I mean, there's a lot of folks that are because they have BUSA campuses as well as BUSA cities, [0:09:29] governments, et cetera. So it is kind of a grassroots thing that has taken hold. Sure. Thank you. [0:09:42] Any questions for me? I have no question. I just want to say I appreciate the effort that you put into [0:09:56] kind of shepherding both of these projects along and certainly appreciate the engagement we've had from [0:10:02] residents in the community to kind of carry the water on this, so to speak, and I help push it forward and excited to see the city look for being a part of it, so thank you. [0:10:12] Steve, I just have a couple really quick questions. [0:10:15] I think this is a great idea and I noticed in your report that there's minor, minor budget [0:10:24] impact that would come out of operating budget. [0:10:27] I wondered if as it relates to parks and rec, whether there are any budgetary impacts for [0:10:36] utilizing pest safe and excuse me be safe pest control and we control and also for any changes [0:10:48] to the Tom Courtney Park would there be any budget impact for that? So we've had that discussion with [0:10:56] Windy and Kevin, they currently actually implement [0:11:04] be safe policies when they start be friendly [0:11:11] and then if the need increases they increase that. [0:11:14] However, every single individual that sprays [0:11:17] in the city that is hired by the city [0:11:18] or contracted by the city follows the USDA standards [0:11:24] for spray and they have already outlined [0:11:27] That process, as they follow it very be friendly, [0:11:32] have been brought over a book of three inch binder [0:11:40] full of how their policy and their integrated [0:11:43] test management program. [0:11:46] And so it starts very low with just oils. [0:11:49] And if that takes care of the problem, [0:11:51] then nothing else is needed. [0:11:52] As far as the Tom Courtney Park and designating that [0:11:55] as the kind of city run garden, [0:11:58] there's really not gonna be much change [0:12:00] because it is a native park. [0:12:02] There may be a few plantings that have to happen here and there, [0:12:06] but there was no real concern, a budgetary concern from Wendy or Kevin about that. [0:12:11] Thank you. [0:12:13] Chris Talkington, what was going to do you have a question? [0:12:16] Well, it's kind of on subject a little bit, [0:12:19] but just because this is dealing with Tom Courtney Park, [0:12:22] I've had some sinister comments and I noticed driving by there [0:12:25] that some of those shrubs are growing out in the road and over the sidewalk [0:12:29] And I know it's trying to be natural, but it seems like it's maybe needing attention to be able to designate it with something. [0:12:40] I don't know what the specific plans are with turning it into more. [0:12:46] I know native plantings based on some of the lists that have been given to me by the council members, the pollinator council members, [0:12:56] and planting that style of plant and then obviously maintaining it is a big thing. [0:13:03] I'm sure Parks will, once the funding is set aside for maintaining it and updating it. [0:13:11] I can't commit to that. [0:13:14] I understand. [0:13:17] Chris Stockton. [0:13:20] Ready to move. [0:13:21] In 2018-10. [0:13:28] To approve a resolution 2018-10, the Twin Falls is a pollinator friendly community. [0:13:39] The City-USA and Monarch City, USA affiliate. [0:13:44] Sir. Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve resolution 2018-10. [0:13:54] That related to becoming a B-City-USA and Monarch City-USA affiliate. [0:13:58] Does there any discussion? [0:14:00] Ms. Clarifan, I thought I heard the motion for 2018-10 and you said 2019-10 and I just might make sure. [0:14:06] 2019-10 is the number. [0:14:08] Thank you. [0:14:09] Thank you for the discussion. [0:14:18] I'll make sure that the mayor has to do that. [0:14:20] Give us things. [0:14:23] We'll call we replaces. [0:14:25] Nicky Boyd. [0:14:27] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:14:28] Yes. [0:14:29] Great glanting. [0:14:30] Yes. [0:14:31] With peers. [0:14:32] Yes. [0:14:33] Mr. Perried. [0:14:34] Yes. [0:14:35] Yes. [0:14:36] And Sean Perrick. [0:14:37] Yes. [0:14:39] Motion passes 7-0. [0:14:40] Thank you, Steve. [0:14:41] And next on the agenda is an action item. [0:14:42] This is a request to accept a financial guarantee for work being performed unlocked for Block 1 WSNB Subdivision 1st Amendment. [0:14:50] First amended, we have tried to detect our city and chair. [0:14:55] Missed in city and chair. [0:14:56] Sorry to give your approach in there, Troy. [0:15:02] Thank you, Councilor Meir for having me before you this evening. [0:15:05] This is a discussion. [0:15:11] There was a subdivision that came before the city several years [0:15:13] ago called WSNV subdivision located here, the six-day [0:15:17] year church North College Road. [0:15:19] We were chinese extended now. [0:15:22] Some way soccer complexes here. [0:15:24] They planted this entire part of that planning process [0:15:29] requires a couple of things. [0:15:30] They're requires the improvements to be completed, [0:15:33] all the public improvements as water sewer, [0:15:35] redways, or a bond to the city for those who trust [0:15:49] because there's no financial, [0:15:53] gets a slot at that time. [0:15:55] They have chosen to sell the slot, [0:15:59] a North and West corner of this development [0:16:09] of Creek site way on the past. [0:16:15] The city engineering has come through [0:16:17] and reviewed these bonds for conformity to city code, [0:16:22] current prices, stuff like that, [0:16:23] not brought through council, but we are always doing process review and so has [0:16:42] authority to be counsel. So I'm bringing this before you tonight because it looks [0:16:51] like we should be bringing before you for all. Tonight, it's not our intent to [0:16:56] view this participation. [0:17:50] Yes, I move we accept the financial guarantee for work being performed on [0:17:56] law for block one west south and past subdivision first amended [0:18:02] Nicky Boyden, the motion by Ruth Pierce, seconded by Nicky Boyden to accept the financial guarantee as presented is there for their discussion. [0:18:12] Oh please. Suzanne Hawkins, yes. Greg Lantey, Ruth Pierce, yes. Christopher Reed, yes. Chris [0:18:24] Yes. [0:18:25] John Berriger. [0:18:26] Yes. [0:18:27] Nicky Boy. [0:18:28] Yes. [0:18:29] Motion passes in 7-0. [0:18:30] Thank you, Troy. [0:18:33] Next on the agenda is an action item. [0:18:34] This is a request to award the Caswell Avenue Sidewalk Improvement Project to R.E.G. [0:18:40] Contracting up Twin Falls, Idaho in the amount of $243,100.85. [0:18:45] We have here in Steel Staff Engineer. [0:18:49] Welcome. [0:18:50] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Council members. [0:18:52] I'm here hopefully for the last time. [0:18:54] And I'm very excited. [0:18:56] This project has been exciting. [0:18:58] My baby over the last time, very excited for the project. [0:19:01] We'll say both. [0:19:02] How's that? [0:19:03] I'm very excited. [0:19:05] This project has been my baby since December, in December of 2018. [0:19:09] I applied for a grant through the local highway technical assistance committee [0:19:14] for it to supply sidewalk along casual avenue along the stretch here. [0:19:23] on some casual level of avenue between Washington and Sparks right here in the corner is Perine [0:19:29] Elementary School and on the other side is the middle school that is Robert Stewart. [0:19:35] Thank you. [0:19:36] I'm going to run right on my brain there for a second. [0:19:38] So we want to grab for the total amount of $248,500 I came to council a few short weeks [0:19:46] ago because when we put the project out to the bed we didn't get any better. [0:19:50] After a conversation with one of the individuals that picked up a set of plans, it was determined [0:19:54] that he really wanted to bid on the project he just didn't have. [0:19:58] The time frame didn't quite work out, but he was willing to take a run at it now. [0:20:03] So he supplied a bid of $243,185. [0:20:09] $100.85. [0:20:10] Engineers' estimate was $236,000. [0:20:15] So it was a little over that, however, with the total grant price being $248,000. [0:20:22] We have about a $5,000, so we're not close to exceeding this budget for this project. [0:20:37] So I'm here for tonight to request that the Council approve this contract and award the [0:20:47] contract to RIT contracting in the amount of $243,100.85, I'm happy to answer any questions [0:20:54] if you have any. [0:20:58] Mine is for our potential to be at this log. [0:21:03] It won't be done before school starts. [0:21:04] I can guarantee that. [0:21:05] However, the project deadline for the grant is December 6th of 2019, out to almost 1200 feet of sidewalk. [0:21:16] Move that we approve the request to award the CASWEL and Avenue sidewalk improvement project to RHE contracting in the amount of $243,185.85. [0:21:41] Motion by Susan, how can second by Christopher read to award a project as presented? Is there any discussion? [0:21:49] Thank you for your attention. [0:21:55] Reglanting. [0:21:56] Yes. [0:21:57] Chris Pierce. [0:21:58] Yes. [0:21:59] Christopher Reed. [0:22:00] Yes. [0:22:01] Chris Tockington. [0:22:02] Yes. [0:22:03] Not Berrigger. [0:22:04] Yes. [0:22:05] Nikki Boyd. [0:22:11] Yes. [0:22:12] And Suzanne Hawkins. [0:22:13] Yes. [0:22:14] Thank you. [0:22:15] Next on the agenda is an action item. [0:22:16] This is a request to amend the 2018-2019 budget and use funds currently designated for a gun range study to purchase additional capabilities in time clock plus the digital timekeeping software for the police department. [0:22:27] Craig Kingsbury, our Chief of Police. Welcome, sir. [0:22:31] Thank you, Mayor and Council. Yes, this is rather straightforward. As you are well aware, [0:22:37] the city recently purchased a timekeeping system called Time Clock Plus, which allows us to [0:22:43] automate our time system for our employees. We have run into a little bit of some operability [0:22:52] problems in the police department where we operate on 24-hour shift and the current [0:22:57] system that we purchase does not work well with a 24-hour shift. [0:23:03] So in working with human resources in the finance department and working with the company [0:23:08] Time Clock Plus, they were able to find, I'll call it another company within Time Clock [0:23:15] Plus, that we can purchase that will work within our 24-hour system, allow our time, [0:23:22] pay period to end at 6 a.m. on Sundays every two weeks, which is the normal [0:23:27] operation of the business that we have at the police department. We currently [0:23:31] have in our current FY 19 budget $50,000 allocated and budgeted to conduct a [0:23:38] study to look at the feasibility of either improving or changing our firearms [0:23:43] range. If you remember from a few weeks ago, Captain Barnhart was here speaking [0:23:48] about some things that we have moving forward and we are working towards a [0:23:51] partnership with Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office. Hopefully next year or two to [0:23:56] partner on a gun range of some property that they have south of town. [0:23:59] Therefore, this is made the necessity to pay $50,000 for a study in Dolan void. So the [0:24:08] request tonight is to for council to authorize the police department to [0:24:13] reallocate no more than $25,000 from that particular item to purchase the time [0:24:21] The total cost is listed at $21,642. [0:24:28] That's the estimate that we have. [0:24:30] Make a G for any questions for the Chief. [0:24:35] Make you believe? [0:24:37] Any questions? [0:24:40] Any questions? [0:24:41] It's in it. [0:24:42] Request to amend the 2018-2019 budget and use funds currently designated for a gun range [0:24:54] study to purchase additional capabilities in the time clock plus the digital time keeping [0:24:59] software for the police department up to but not to exceed the twenty five [0:25:04] thousand dollars second motion by Nicky Boyd second by Ruth Pierce [0:25:08] who approved the request as presented as their discussion with peers yes Christopher [0:25:21] Reed yes Chris talking to yes on America yes Nicky Boyd yes Suzanne Hawkins yes [0:25:27] great glad to yes as a 7-0 thank you chief and next on the agenda is a discussion [0:25:35] This is a discussion on vehicle parking. [0:25:38] We have Sean Stanley, air code enforcement coordinator, [0:25:40] as well as Brian Pike, [0:25:42] if you see the manager start off with Brian. [0:25:45] Thank you, Mayor and members of the council. [0:25:47] It seems like you've been in that preview [0:25:49] of this presentation throughout the council meeting tonight. [0:25:52] And I apologize for that. [0:26:02] It's been popping up all night, [0:26:03] and now that I need it, I won't be able to find it. [0:26:19] So what we'd like to do tonight is really talk [0:26:22] about vehicle parking, [0:26:23] and I've talked a lot with Sean about this, [0:26:26] And I know that he doesn't like the title that I've used [0:26:29] because we're talking about parking [0:26:32] and parking doesn't just encompass residential areas. [0:26:35] It encompasses a number of different areas [0:26:37] in the city manufacturing and commercial areas. [0:26:40] But tonight really, what we're talking about [0:26:42] is a change for emitting a coat [0:26:46] that would have a direct impact in residential areas. [0:26:48] And so I wanted to make sure [0:26:50] that there was a clear understanding of that. [0:26:51] And this has really been a team approach. [0:26:54] We've got a whole team here. [0:26:55] We've got our legal team planning and zoning, [0:26:58] please depart of an engineering and code enforcement. [0:27:01] So what we want to make sure tonight is that you have [0:27:05] all the answers to your questions [0:27:07] that you feel comfortable with where we're at, [0:27:09] that we're being as open and as honest as we can, [0:27:12] and that we're speaking honestly about possible changes [0:27:16] and how it may impact residential areas [0:27:19] or which one falls, so we think that's important. [0:27:21] So at any point, I've got a whole team behind me [0:27:23] If you have any questions or any concerns, please feel free to get the right person to [0:27:32] address this. [0:27:33] I want to give just a little brief background, May 20th of this year, Mr. Heider King Ford [0:27:39] made a presentation in front of Council. [0:27:42] I won't speak directly for Mr. Heider, he's here, but one of the concerns that he has, [0:27:49] he runs a small business from his home, not out of his home, but he has a trailer that's [0:27:53] parked in front of his house. [0:27:54] That's his primary means of doing business. [0:27:57] And currently in our code, our code [0:28:00] doesn't allow for that trailer to be parked in that area [0:28:02] because it's over one and a half tons. [0:28:04] And we'll get into that a little bit later. [0:28:06] So what he did is he came for you on May 20th. [0:28:09] And he asked you to consider amending the code [0:28:12] that would allow him to park his truck and trailer [0:28:15] in front of his house as a means of doing business. [0:28:18] And I think he represented, for the most part, [0:28:20] a number of small businesses. [0:28:22] They weren't here, but in spirit, [0:28:24] he was saying to the small business owner [0:28:25] that has the functions in this manner, [0:28:28] these are some of their concerns. [0:28:30] So coming out of that meeting, [0:28:32] we talked about a number of solutions or possible solutions. [0:28:36] And if you recall, one of those discussions [0:28:38] that we had was the possibility [0:28:39] of exploring the special use application. [0:28:43] So that would allow an individual to come in [0:28:45] and submit a special use application. [0:28:48] It would be reviewed and looked at, [0:28:50] we'd have some public input, [0:28:52] And we really went back as a team and started to look at whether that was even possible. [0:28:57] To be really honest with you tonight, the special use application process is just not [0:29:03] a viable option for what Mr. Hider is proposing. [0:29:07] It creates a very bureaucratic process I think would be frustrating for anyone coming [0:29:13] into it. [0:29:14] You would get some public input related to that individual, but it has a number of pitfalls [0:29:18] that I think both planning and zoning and legal can talk about tonight if you'd like to go there. [0:29:23] We just thought it wasn't a viable option, it wasn't a good long-term solution for you, [0:29:28] and it probably creates, unfortunately, probably a little more difficulties for us, [0:29:33] then just an outright change to the code. [0:29:37] So really tonight, that's what we want to talk about. [0:29:39] We want to talk really, it's a two-step process, not get into it in just a little bit, [0:29:44] It's really about the council's acceptance or willingness to make a change to our current parking code. [0:29:53] If you're not willing to do that, we'll discuss that path and then if you would like to consider that, we have an alternate path for you to consider to get your input to help give us an in-supply direction. [0:30:04] Also understanding out of that special use application process, one of the concerns that planning and zoning had was they were worried about creating a process that would allow, and I know they wouldn't use this term, [0:30:15] use this term, but this is the reality of the change permanent parking in front of residents [0:30:22] right now you can park on our roads right where parking is allowed and that vehicle has to be [0:30:28] moved every 24 hours and that's true of all parking on the street and that way it keeps [0:30:34] the flow of traffic moving and the public space on the roadway doesn't become a permanent parking [0:30:39] spot and so that was one of the concerns are we will we create situations in which we are [0:30:45] Granting individuals the right to to park and you'd say well, we're not doing that but but the practice of [0:30:52] The practice that we would have would be just that so we were really cautious and moving forward [0:30:58] One of the things I'd like to do is have our code enforcement coordinator Sean Stanley come up and talk a little bit about the public input that he's received [0:31:05] And then kind of lay the foundation for our discussion tonight [0:31:15] Council I know you've heard some of these numbers before but we do receive a lot of public [0:31:20] from citizens of the community regarding Part Kingdom streets. [0:31:24] In 2018, we had 601 of these violations, whether it be RVs, [0:31:31] utility trainers, boats, jeskeys, you name it. [0:31:34] And 401 of those were citizens that called in to complain about them. [0:31:41] Thus far, in 2019, we have issued 432 of these violations. [0:31:48] and 357 of those have been from the citizens calling them. [0:31:53] And when they call in, they do. [0:31:55] They do complain about worrying about backing out of their driveway [0:32:00] and the oncoming traffic. [0:32:02] They complain about backing across streets [0:32:05] and having to worry about hitting a trailer on the other side of the street. [0:32:08] They complain about pedestrians, bicyclists, bike lanes, [0:32:13] all that type of stuff. [0:32:14] They're just worried about backing out of their driveways [0:32:16] and having to maneuver around trailers [0:32:19] that are permanently parked on the streets. [0:32:21] But one thing I can talk about is a different section of our city code in regards to vision [0:32:57] and obstruction of vision at intersections, alleys and driveways. [0:33:03] Whatever we choose to do tonight, we need to keep this code in mind as well as every [0:33:07] intersection has a 40 foot train. [0:33:11] And that train goal, I'm just going to take blue lakes and find out that we would allow [0:33:15] parking at that intersection. [0:33:16] But if you go down blue lakes 40 feet, and then if you go down fighter avenue 40 feet, [0:33:22] and you make a point at those two areas, and then draw a line there, nothing can be in [0:33:26] that triangle, taller than three foot. [0:33:28] The other obstruction that we have to worry about that we hear quite often is the obstruction [0:33:35] at driveways. [0:33:36] I'm a little bit confusing, but if you're the driveway, and I'm looking at the driveway, [0:33:41] And I go up from the street pavement, tan feet, and then make a point, and then I have to go to the right 125 feet, and nothing's allowed in that section, taller than 3 foot. [0:33:54] And then it's the same thing to the left of the driveway, 100 foot. [0:33:58] And the reason they do the 125 feet to the right is because you're backing into oncoming traffic. [0:34:03] And so, just kind of want to explain this part of the coke as well. [0:34:08] And I've only made this presentation as difficult as you can imagine in moving around this. [0:34:36] So what I would like the council to see tonight is that as we continue on in this conversation, [0:34:42] really, what I wanted to do is I wanted to take our code and I wanted to break it down [0:34:46] in a manner that's just really easy to understand because when you read the code, I don't find [0:34:51] it as easy to interpret as Sean does because he does it on a regular basis. [0:34:55] I think sometimes our citizens probably read it the same way, but currently 968, which is [0:35:03] really a reflection early 50s, 1958, so it's been around for a long time. [0:35:10] And this is really what it allows and what it does and allows. [0:35:12] And there's some exceptions and I've got Sean here to help me with this, but really what's [0:35:17] important to understand is the vehicle type. [0:35:19] And then of course whether it's allowed or not, and so it's real simple, a motor truck, [0:35:23] So any truck that's more than one and one and a half ton capacity is not allowed to be parked on the street. [0:35:29] Motor vehicle with an overall weight of two feet. [0:35:37] When we talk about trailers, so regardless of the trailer, whether it's utility trailer or commercial trailer, [0:35:47] trailers less than one half ton are allowed like a vehicle for 24 hours so they can be parked in front of your residence. [0:35:55] They just need to be moved every 24 hours. [0:35:59] So don't have unused vehicles sitting in front of residences [0:36:03] for a long period of time. [0:36:06] And generally what happens is that, [0:36:08] and John's talked about this over the years, [0:36:10] this is not something that we go out and force these, [0:36:13] usually our calls that we receive from neighborhoods [0:36:16] when the neighbors are become frustrated [0:36:19] with that vehicle and they'll call. [0:36:22] So trailers more, and going back a trailer, [0:36:24] a half ton trailer would be equivalent [0:36:28] to what you would see at Home Depot. [0:36:31] It'll be a small trailer. [0:36:34] Generally, any double axle trailer [0:36:36] would probably be more than that. [0:36:37] And then a trailer that is more than one half ton [0:36:40] is just simply not allowed other than in manufacturing areas. [0:36:44] Or the, and there's also a provision, [0:36:47] I want to talk a little bit, [0:36:48] the actual loading or unloading. [0:36:50] So you could have vehicle in front of your house [0:36:54] and you could be loading it, actively loading it [0:36:56] and unloading it, and that would be acceptable. [0:36:59] But you would have to be actively loading it and unloading it. [0:37:02] So it's kind of confusing a little bit. [0:37:04] So we wanted to at least present that with you [0:37:06] and let you know that's the current code. [0:37:10] That's what we have in place. [0:37:11] That's what we've used, and very similar to what we did. [0:37:14] May 20th, we have a recommendation. [0:37:17] And really, the recommendation from where we're at, [0:37:20] and this is part of that two step process, [0:37:22] is that we believe that our current code [0:37:26] related to vehicle size and trailer time is defined by weight is adequate that it [0:37:31] works for us it's worked well I know it's an older code but it really does take [0:37:37] into consideration all the things that we've talked about we've talked about [0:37:40] the concerns that staff has that engineering has that we won't we're [0:37:43] talking about site obstructions what that really looks like it takes into [0:37:48] consideration safety for vehicular traffic having to move through areas where [0:37:53] where you have trailers on both sides of the road or other types of vehicles. [0:37:58] It takes into consideration pedestrians and bicyclists that are in neighborhoods. [0:38:03] When you think about it, the sidewalk is probably the safest place, [0:38:06] but we know probably most of us as parents for children to ride bikes [0:38:11] and as people move as they grow past that, adults really don't ride bikes [0:38:16] and really not allowed to ride bikes on sidewalks, they have to ride in the street. [0:38:20] And it's not easy to navigate that. [0:38:22] So really, when we take this in totality, we believe that the current code that we have [0:38:28] is adequate. [0:38:29] It's probably not adequate for Mr. Hider and other individuals that are in that area, but [0:38:35] we feel that given the totality of where we're at the code works and seems to work really [0:38:39] well, we would add one recommendation. [0:38:42] And that would be amending the current code to allow for recreational vehicles. [0:38:47] So these are vehicles, you know, RVs, motorhomes, recreational trailers, things like that. [0:38:55] The ability to load is actually to set the time at 24 hours. [0:38:59] So we're not saying they have to be actively loading or unloading, but to actually move [0:39:04] that to a set time. [0:39:06] That was one of the recommendations. [0:39:07] We have a lot of individuals in our community that recreate, that have trailers and the [0:39:12] reality of that is if Sean and his team gets a call and they go out to a residence and [0:39:17] dealing with somebody they're going to allow that time. So it's not like they [0:39:21] go out and say this trailer has to move immediately and you have to do it right [0:39:24] now. They usually go out and say okay trailer needs to move it can't be here [0:39:27] we'll give you 24 hours to do that. So we really thought that was a reasonable [0:39:33] approach to amending the code however ultimately this decision lies with you [0:39:38] believe is the best for for the community which really leads us to this as I've [0:39:44] It's really a two-stage process if you believe that the current code is adequate, or you'd [0:39:50] like to consider our recommendation in the whole, allowing for that 24-hour period. [0:39:56] We can take that if that's where you're at and we can stop there. [0:40:00] If that's where you're comfortable, if you're not comfortable there or you want to consider [0:40:04] other options that would make additional allowances for someone like in this or a hider situation, [0:40:11] We can do that too, and we're prepared to throw out some options to help you give us [0:40:15] some direction. [0:40:16] So, ultimately, regardless of the path that we take tonight, we'll be back in front of [0:40:21] you with an ordinance, a draft ordinance, something that we believe represents what you [0:40:26] would like to see and what you could support, and then we would go through a public hearing [0:40:30] process. [0:40:31] And unlike other processes, maybe where we move right to third and final, we don't have [0:40:37] to do that, right? [0:40:38] literally have republic hearings on this, if that's the direction that you choose to go. [0:40:44] I do believe that when John talks about receiving 400 citizens generated complaints, that's actually [0:40:55] it's 357 citizens generated complaints, that's a lot of public input, and these are really [0:41:01] concerns in neighborhoods. [0:41:02] And it's that quality of life piece that we're trying to balance, so I'd certainly appreciate [0:41:07] Mr. Hider is coming from and I want small business to be successful. [0:41:11] The issue is the location in the residential area, so that's where we're at. [0:41:17] And what I would do is turn it over to you for some direction. [0:41:22] Ruth Pierce. [0:41:23] Brian, I have a question that 24 hours unload unload for a recreation vehicle. [0:41:30] Is that in a particular time frame? [0:41:32] I noticed some of the other cities. [0:41:34] How does 7-day time frame? [0:41:36] I mean, it's subject to interpretation, but you could have 24 hours, quote unloading and [0:41:43] unloading and then the next day have the next 24 hours loading and unloading. [0:41:49] Are you recommending a time frame or? [0:41:52] You know, it's a really good point and we did send out in the council packet, we sent [0:41:56] out a number of cities and their codes and we wanted you to see that. [0:42:01] It's not like we're trying to hide that. [0:42:02] I'm reading in the MPa make a lot of allowances. [0:42:05] They allow up to 72 hours for a vehicle of Mr. Hiders type to be parked in front of his [0:42:11] vehicle. [0:42:12] I mean from this home. [0:42:13] But once that vehicle moves they have attached to time. [0:42:15] So they say that once that vehicle moves it can be there for 72 hours. [0:42:19] But once it moves it has to be gone for 48 and that goes back to the earlier conversation [0:42:26] about not having. [0:42:27] If you don't have that provision. [0:42:29] And we could have a provision, some provision like that, [0:42:33] then that becomes a permanent parking spot. [0:42:35] And what's not, what's very common, [0:42:37] and I think Sean and his team could really address this. [0:42:41] It's not uncommon for us to make contact with someone [0:42:44] that has a move to vehicle. [0:42:45] Because neighbors are complaining that person [0:42:47] will go out and then move that vehicle one foot technically, [0:42:51] that starts the clock again. [0:42:52] So you could have, although honestly, [0:42:56] we're trying to keep it as simple as possible. [0:42:59] But if you were to decide to consider other options, [0:43:02] I would strongly recommend that you put some language in there [0:43:05] that would limit the ability, [0:43:09] because if not, ultimately the practice becomes, [0:43:12] the trailer sits in front of the house all the time. [0:43:15] Right. Okay, thank you. [0:43:23] It's talking to you. [0:43:24] I guess I just had a little room for a common art show, [0:43:29] satisfied with the current code from as an extremely difficult, [0:43:34] if not as the hadn't trailer even, [0:43:44] states attached to by this allow in residential areas like this this suddenly [0:43:59] becomes very much a public safety issue especially for kids with bikes starting [0:44:05] in on pedestrians when they consider that this is a safety issue that if we make it [0:44:18] anymore anymore allow it's for perky residential area by businesses it'll be [0:44:23] creeping environment, saying more, I call some trucks. [0:44:30] I'm sorry to say this, I'm a small business person. [0:44:37] I've got that, but I've always tried to stay off the main street. [0:44:41] Chris Reed, two questions, Brian. [0:44:49] First of all, thank you for this presentation. [0:44:51] Thank you for working on it. [0:44:53] The first one is he just kind of touched on some options. [0:44:59] Mr. Hider's case and some things that he's been struggling [0:45:01] with, what were some of the options that you have maybe looked at, [0:45:05] and that specific case since he did bring this forward, [0:45:10] the second is, yes, 24 hours is a long period of time [0:45:14] and I appreciate that, but other cities [0:45:17] have gone a little bit farther, [0:45:18] and in knowing some of my neighbors, [0:45:22] a fifth wheel might be parked out there [0:45:23] for a couple of days while they're cleaning it out, [0:45:25] and that takes time depending on age [0:45:29] and different things like that, [0:45:30] and so I'm gonna make you 72, [0:45:36] because this isn't just formulas and jet skis [0:45:40] that are coming in, [0:45:41] people that might be taking care of that before they put it away in distortion, just making [0:45:46] sure that we're good neighbors, but you have some time to take care of it, so those are... [0:45:53] I actually have that, and on my way there I would say this I think is really important [0:46:00] to take into consideration. [0:46:02] Nine dash, nine dash, sixteen, especially when it comes to site restrictions, because [0:46:07] I don't think when we start thinking this through, you know, a hundred, we're talking [0:46:13] about 100 feet. I mean, that's, that's, some people will never be able to actually meet [0:46:18] that site restriction. I mean, they wouldn't be able to comply with that. I think that's [0:46:22] important. And you're not going to be able to see this. And Mike, if I switch over to [0:46:25] the word document, that's going to, if you have it in your packet, I know it's, I hope [0:46:41] the audience can see that. Okay. I apologize. But we, what we really did started kind of [0:46:47] creating a matrix and giving you some options about motor vehicles, utility trailers. You [0:46:51] see we broke down motor homes, campers, recreational vehicles, and then we had a fourth class, [0:46:58] snowmobiles, boat trailers, I mean just about anything you can imagine that you've seen here [0:47:01] and probably will see that we tried to put some time frame on it. And that really goes [0:47:07] back to what the council would feel comfortable allowing. So we have a motor vehicle, we started [0:47:13] there 24 hours and we feel really comfortable with a vehicle moving every 24 hours. Utility [0:47:20] If you decide to move that direction, then we would recommend, I mean, we don't, we're [0:47:26] reluctant to make a recommendation other than saying that you could establish a time frame [0:47:31] whether it's 24 hours, and like I said, Meridian Nampa, they go 72 hours, so you've got a wide [0:47:37] range of area that you could choose from if that's the direction that you wanted to go. [0:47:43] You know, how long do you allow someone to, you know, and I think to, to councilman rates [0:47:49] point. This occurs on a regular basis throughout our community. People come home from camping. [0:47:54] They, for generally, right? They haven't worked out with the neighbors. There is their give and take between [0:48:00] those smaller communities in Twin Falls. It's when the one person, right, for whatever reason [0:48:07] decides that the trailer will stay there longer or they run a power cord to it or, I mean, you can only imagine, right? [0:48:16] That's when, you know, obviously we get a call, so it really depends. [0:48:20] I mean, there's a number of options that would be available to council. [0:48:23] Like I said, it's hard to make a recommendation because I think ultimately, I could say 24 hours, [0:48:32] you may want longer. I personally think 72 hours is probably a little long, but ultimately, [0:48:39] that's, I would leave that up to you. I do like the provision. If that's something that's allowable, [0:48:46] You'll see that both Meridian and Nampa, they'll say 72 hours and then that went once that vehicle, and it has to move. [0:48:53] It can't stay longer than 72 hours, so once it moves it can't be back for 48. [0:48:58] Honestly, I worry about our ability to even to try to enforce that. [0:49:03] Now we would have calls from neighbors, you know, that's generally how we operate now, but it becomes a little more problematic for Sean and his team. [0:49:13] But you'll see though there are some options. [0:49:15] There's some other options below that I like to time limit [0:49:20] as we discussed. [0:49:22] And then really there are some exceptions that are occurring. [0:49:25] And I apologize to the audience for not being able to scroll down. [0:49:30] There are really five exceptions you could consider [0:49:37] that are included in these are in practice already happening. [0:49:41] So if you're loading or unloading materials or merchandise, [0:49:45] Sean and his team, if you're in that process, [0:49:48] effectively loading and unloading, [0:49:49] they're not going to take any action on you. [0:49:53] The same is true in construction areas. [0:49:55] I mean, Sean and his team could go out on a daily basis [0:49:58] and find people in violation of this we understand. [0:50:01] But those exceptions could be included, [0:50:03] like for the purpose of construction projects, [0:50:06] as long as it's a valid project, [0:50:09] You could link it back to a city permit if you chose to. [0:50:13] And that trailer's parked within 100 feet of the construction area. [0:50:18] That wouldn't be a problem. [0:50:19] And I think that's the practice, you know, anyway. [0:50:23] So it would just be kind of more realizing that. [0:50:30] Thank you, Brian. Suzanne Hawkins. [0:50:32] My guest, everybody on my street has violated this every day of the week. [0:50:37] Just about comfortable having an ordinance or a rule that is [0:50:45] causing people to break the lawn and callular bases. I had no idea because in our [0:50:53] neighborhood there's no where to park the driveways are too close nobody would [0:50:56] ever be allowed on the street and that's not practical either. So personally I [0:51:01] would like to see some kind of a clean up so that we're not causing people to be [0:51:07] out of compliance. 24 hours even on motor vehicles is pretty short. I know we [0:51:14] have neighbors that have teenagers and they might for a couple days not go [0:51:19] I would like to see maybe more of a 48-hour compromise on some of that, or how to clean up the language to make it more applicable, but I guess I worry about now knowing I had no idea. I had no idea. We were parking illegally when we parked in front of our home on the street. [0:51:42] You can park there. You absolutely can park. [0:51:44] But I'm too close to the driveway. [0:51:45] Well, as long as it's three feet, right? So you're looking at the three feet. [0:51:49] So I guess I don't understand the hundred feet of three foot of torture driveway vegetation [0:51:59] That's what I said. [0:52:02] Right. [0:52:03] Okay. [0:52:04] Thank you. [0:52:05] I'm glad I'm not breaking alcohol. [0:52:06] We're heading right over right now even as we... [0:52:10] Team is moving. [0:52:11] I have a few kids and grandchildren with a few vehicles behind the slide. [0:52:18] I think the side restriction part is important to think about cars backing out of driveway [0:52:25] We were children coming out of driveway or off sidewalks, you know, when you're passing [0:52:29] through those areas. [0:52:31] It's not uncommon for us to have incidents where kids will run out. [0:52:36] And it's not just trailers. [0:52:37] It can be vehicles. [0:52:38] It can be any obstacle. [0:52:40] So I'm not just pointing to trailers because that wouldn't be fair. [0:52:43] The truth of it is we're encouraging people to move around in neighborhoods to walk more [0:52:48] to be a little more mobile, and we're trying to do things that not discourage, you know, [0:52:54] that activity. [0:52:55] So we worry, we do worry about the safety, the overall safety. [0:52:59] Yes, and I do agree with all that, but I also believe we need to teach our children to pay attention to their surroundings also, and I think sometimes we miss that piece of it. [0:53:09] Yes, one thing I would add on the hours is I'm trying to think through how that makes it much different than what we have now. [0:53:29] Now so, Abraham's there, marked outside, and it's bothering me, and I call a coten first when the day show up. [0:53:37] Responses, he's parked outside all day. The spirit of it is, necessarily see them. [0:54:19] But he, that's what we're doing an day later, maybe two days later. [0:54:33] And see if the heartbeat's been moved, and if it's been moved, we resolve it. [0:54:36] I just like check this is. [0:54:41] For us, if we changed it, ours, rather than, do for us as well. [0:54:55] as well. [0:54:56] But really the 24 hour time clock starts from the time you show up to see it from the complete [0:55:02] notice of it. [0:55:03] So it may have been misery. [0:55:10] Somebody calls in. [0:55:11] Are they notified of the code? [0:55:12] Is it one of those when they call it a complaint about a trailer or whatever's parked out there? [0:55:19] Are they notified that they have 24 hours at this point in time? [0:55:23] 24 hours of unloving and loading? [0:55:25] Yeah, usually we'll ask them how long it's been there. [0:55:28] They'll tell us if it's been longer than 24 or then we'll go out and contact. [0:55:32] If it's just showed up, we do make them aware that they have some time. [0:55:37] Their questions are comments for it. [0:55:49] So again, this is a discussion item, but I do think we need to give some direction to staff [0:55:55] about what we'd like to do next, if anything, if you would. [0:55:58] It is. It has actually served as well for their so into with. [0:56:22] I'm sure that most people when they call, they don't necessarily just, [0:56:29] just something shows up, they call it in. [0:56:31] It's an ongoing thing that they've thought about for a while. [0:56:36] it's something that is finally affecting their sense of security. Something is off and we're [0:56:48] staffed to spend this much time reviewing it and have all the in-how-this works, what plays out in real life. [0:56:56] Sounds like it has served as well and is continuing to serve as well, except for the exceptions of the 356 people, [0:57:06] But those are, they know what the rules are, do such and such, and when there's something really out of the word that that sounds like that's a pretty good system we have. [0:57:28] If it would make it easier for the towers, I don't have a problem, and it's, I think Shanda's 24-7 for the most part is talk to people and help them understand why things are. [0:57:47] If so many takes a long time to clean out their trailer, neighbors and sort of work it out amongst themselves without having to have police, [0:58:04] I don't know, the longer I've listened to this and thought about it, although it's not a perfect system, I think it's a pretty darn good one. [0:58:11] And it has served our city well for a very long time. [0:58:15] Where I've said I'd think I could've shot his, and his team a little more. [0:58:30] This is not really a good word, but a little more correction than they can when they talk to people that you tell them. [0:58:36] If you have this amount of time, you think you're part of it, I even realize they still have an indication to walk a lot on the President's streets. [0:58:45] You've had somebody parked on the street on the President's street with an RV. [0:58:49] They're blocking traffic. [0:58:51] People are going to have to take turns going around them because those streets are not very wide. [0:58:55] And there's other city streets that are similar to that. [0:58:58] I mean, some of the newer streets that are 50, probably not as big a question, but I think [0:59:05] we have to make an ordinance that fits all, and I think the burn ordinance, 24 hours, [0:59:10] is the way I would like to go. [0:59:12] That sounds like, potentially, bringing back the amendment to revise the, maybe for hours, [0:59:28] instead of the, potentially not. [0:59:33] Well, those will take your recommendation. [0:59:45] We'll put that in a draft ordinance form. [0:59:47] ordinance form we'll make sure everyone is comfortable with it and then we'll [0:59:50] bring it back and then if you choose you can take that through the public hearing [0:59:54] process so we have a couple more items on the regular agenda before we get to the [1:00:04] public hearing on recycling so again that's noticed to occur no earlier than 6 [1:00:09] p.m. the next item on the agenda which is a presentation of the city manager's [1:00:16] recommended budget for fiscal year 2020 followed by citizen input Travis [1:00:23] Mr. Schrenthweiler, City Manager, welcome. [1:00:33] Well, Mr. Mayor moves to the council, you say that now. [1:00:37] You might have noticed this flurry of activity occurring off [1:00:42] onto the side, but we are trying not to distract Mr. Pike [1:00:46] in his presentation. [1:00:49] But sometimes when you look at the agenda on a Thursday, [1:00:54] it looks absolutely perfect. [1:00:58] And then when you get to a council meeting [1:01:00] and you look at the agenda, you begin [1:01:03] have this moment of oh we aired and as you shared it is a presentation and tonight [1:01:12] it is supposed to be an action and and in the old days the Idaho Code allowed for [1:01:21] us to make amendments to the agenda when we had these errors we have been sharing [1:01:29] that this would be the night that we would have you adopt the tentative [1:01:32] budget since the very beginning of our budgeting process and so it shouldn't be a surprise, [1:01:39] but what the surprise should now be is that because of changes in state law and the way [1:01:44] in which we publish the agenda, we are unable to have you adopt a tended budget this evening [1:01:50] and ultimately what happens is the budget goes through my eyes last and I didn't catch [1:01:56] it, so I own it and so I apologize to you for the error. [1:02:00] What we've been doing is then scrambling off to the side to build a solution and before we [1:02:07] get into the process I kind of want to build that solution with you if we could. [1:02:13] So state law requires us once you have adopted a tentative budget that we set a public hearing [1:02:19] and we published that with the final tentative budget for your maximum spending cap twice [1:02:30] with a seven-day break. [1:02:32] And so our proposal, if you are so able, [1:02:37] is to have a special meeting, which calls for a 24-hour notice. [1:02:43] And this can be done by any person over by calling it. [1:02:46] And to meet that timeline, we'd be [1:02:48] looking at Wednesday at noon, or at five. [1:02:55] Apparently that didn't work well, [1:02:59] so that we could publish on the 16th and the 23rd [1:03:02] and still kind of move forward with adopting the budget [1:03:05] the 26th and the 26th is the date in which we provided to the county that appears on everybody's [1:03:15] tax notice and assessed values. So if that works, if you let us know if you could be able to be [1:03:30] present or to call in, we really don't anticipate it being a lengthy meeting. We [1:03:35] We anticipate the bulk of the conversation occurring this evening. [1:03:39] Wednesday would be the time to pick up for the clerical error that I alone has on the agenda. [1:03:47] Then we'd be able to proceed as publishing on the 16th and 23rd as intended with the adoption of the budget still scheduled for the 26th. [1:03:57] either of those times that absolutely positively don't work for someone looking Wednesday and so [1:04:27] what we'll do is what I'm hearing is noon would be best and five would be out again I do apologize [1:04:38] for that error and so the reason I wanted to kind of do this before was that because of us [1:04:44] noticing the air we want to make sure that citizens have an understanding of what actions [1:04:49] would be taking and why there would be a special meeting. Again, I anticipate that conversation [1:04:56] being relatively short because the bulk of our conversation I'm hoping would occur this [1:05:00] evening and that we would come in. You would very simply make potentially one or two motions [1:05:07] and then we would be able to move forward expeditiously. Again, the budget isn't adopted. On Wednesday, [1:05:15] It is just setting a maximum spending cap and all of the actions for the budget still would go until August 26th. [1:05:31] All you're doing is adopting a total maximum spending, that's right. [1:05:36] And what we do is we take that number and we publish it and make it part of the ordinance and the public hearing. [1:05:46] All right, so with that, we will roll into a simple presentation onto the budget as opposed to looking for some action from the Council Book, but I will share that there is one critical step that you do need to have a conversation about and we'll get to that in a minute. [1:06:05] So as we have been sharing over the course of the last five weeks with the council in [1:06:11] several weeks on and off throughout the calendar year, this is directly connected to our strategic [1:06:17] plan and we're really trying to enhance public safety, trying to enhance the quality of life. [1:06:23] We're trying to enhance the overall well-being of the City of Twin Falls and we do that by [1:06:29] taking taxes and fees and applying that to the production of goods and services. [1:06:36] The City of Twin Falls has a reputation for being physically strong as a municipal government [1:06:42] that is illustrated by the several awards that we presented to you on an annual basis [1:06:48] by the GFOA and other organizations. [1:06:52] One of the things I think that's most important about our budget is it is thoughtful and it [1:06:57] is sustainable. [1:06:58] And by sustainability, what do I mean? [1:07:00] I mean, it is a setting a course of action [1:07:03] that doesn't cause us financial issues into the future. [1:07:06] That we very thoughtfully go through our processes. [1:07:09] We make sure that long-term spending plans [1:07:13] can be carried into the future. [1:07:15] That we don't budget on one year increments. [1:07:17] And many of you have seen our five-year budgeting, [1:07:20] forecasting tools and models. [1:07:22] We try to put a tremendous amount of science [1:07:25] into our budget. [1:07:26] And that's why we have confidence in moving forward, [1:07:28] that we will be able to carry this path well into the future. [1:07:33] This is the City Strategic Plan. [1:07:35] These are the various focus areas [1:07:37] that have been discussed throughout the entire conversation. [1:07:41] And our budget is really designed [1:07:43] to provide goods and services to a community census [1:07:47] of a little less than 50,000 population [1:07:50] of the time of this, July of 2018. [1:07:54] We do know that we serve a geographic area [1:07:56] 260,000 people and we have an estimated daytime population that grows to about 90,000 and when [1:08:04] we host events on weekends we've seen that number exceed more than 1,000 individuals, all [1:08:11] of which those services are provided by the City of Twin Falls. [1:08:15] Our median household income has continued to grow and we now have that at $46,284 in the [1:08:22] median house value is $205,200. [1:08:28] The rate has covered below 3% or 2.4% for the last several years. [1:08:33] And one of the things that you'll notice about Twin Falls is we are continuing to become more diverse [1:08:38] as our Hispanic and Latino population have grown to about 16.1%. [1:08:43] In addition to that, our median age is relatively young and a youthful 32.7 years. [1:08:49] Again, we say this is directly connected to the strategic plan, and this budget is taking advantage of what we refer to as the statutory increases, which is the 3% spending and the opportunity to capture new growth associated with new construction and annexations. [1:09:11] Both will yield roughly about $1.1, $1.2 million in the property tax dollars. [1:09:18] You'll notice that the new construction value is about $75 million for this fiscal year. [1:09:25] That is the single largest new construction value that we have on record. [1:09:30] And it is significantly more than what we've seen in the last two fiscal years. [1:09:34] property tax collections are scheduled to be about $23.26 million. Water and sanitation or sewage excuse me and that's called for a 1% rate adjustment. Sanitation calls for 4.9% and I want to talk about that just for one second. [1:09:57] That is if you do nothing and we know that we're going to have a conversation a little bit later as it relates to sanitation and should the council make changes in its sanitation program, that will be reflected in that. [1:10:11] So if you choose to take a different option, you should see a reduction in that rate as opposed to the 4.9%. [1:10:20] The last item and it's the second bullet from the bottom is this budget does not utilize any of the foregone balance. [1:10:27] This is your last chance to incorporate any portion of the foregone balance into this budget should you choose. [1:10:39] And the reason I say it is your last chance is because in the past, one of the things that we would be able to do is we would say we intend to take all of the foregone balance. [1:10:50] When you set the maximum cap, only has an opportunity to provide the council some flexibility [1:10:57] as we continue through our budgeting process. [1:11:00] And oftentimes what has happened is the entire forgum balance has been removed and you have [1:11:06] just taken the standard amounts that are allowed. [1:11:10] With changes in the ideal legislature, you are not allowed to do that anymore. [1:11:13] You have to specifically adopt a resolution and host a public hearing. [1:11:19] So tonight, and when you say you're going to take foregone balance, any portion of it, [1:11:26] you have to clearly describe what you intend to do in the resolution. [1:11:35] And so if there is an interest to take any portion of the foregone balance, we can prepare [1:11:40] the resolution, the public hearing. [1:11:42] If there's not, this budget doesn't rely on it. [1:11:45] We are set and good to go. [1:11:46] So that really is kind of the first conversation piece this evening as if there is any very specific and identify projects that we have shared with you that we did not include in this project that you would like for us to carry forward. [1:11:59] Now is the time or as they say forever hold your piece until at least next fiscal year. [1:12:08] It's kind of said there's one comment you made you have to list what you're going to use it for this for the first year [1:12:21] That's correct. Yeah, whenever you incorporate moneys into [1:12:25] From the foregone you describe what your intent is to use that very first year [1:12:29] Yes [1:12:30] We're just talking to I don't care to touch the foregone. I'm not seeing an appetite or a list of [1:12:41] Projects to address the foregone this year's our feelings are not hurt. That makes it much easier for us [1:12:48] We've already heard once, we don't want to make it any more complicated. [1:12:54] So when we take a look at the entire budget, we break our budget into six primary areas. [1:13:01] And when you take a look at the totality of it, you can see that 43% of our budget goes [1:13:06] to personnel, 18% to capital, 25% to maintenance and operations, 9% to debt service, the only [1:13:13] debt that we carry are associated with water and sewer improvements, and then 9% of transfers [1:13:19] and the way to look at a transfer is each of the enterprise funds functions as a small business [1:13:24] and they pay a rent to the tax-supporting funds to be able to cover their share of the appropriate cost. [1:13:31] Transfer dollars and those increases on an annual basis are based upon the municipal cost index [1:13:39] which is 1.9%. So this is the side-by-side comparison of a lot of different numbers, but [1:13:47] it is how we determine a tax rate inside of the state of Idaho. So we are provided a total [1:13:54] taxable value number of $3.184 billion by the county assessor. That is a collection of all [1:14:02] properties within the city's corporate boundary, excluding urban renewal properties. The value [1:14:08] The urban and old properties brings the city total tax [1:14:12] level value within our corporate boundaries of nearly $3.75 [1:14:16] billion to put that in comparison. [1:14:19] That same value in 2012 was $2.3 billion. [1:14:23] So we have increased by $1.5 billion in total value [1:14:28] over the course of the last seven years. [1:14:32] You can notice that our net expenses are more this year, [1:14:37] And they're in the tax-supported funds. [1:14:39] And as we've shared the tax-supported funds, [1:14:42] doesn't mean that all that money is derived [1:14:45] from property taxes. [1:14:47] It means that some portion of those funds are, [1:14:49] and you can see below that we're going to collect [1:14:52] total property taxes, about $23 million, [1:14:57] like we had shared in the previous slide. [1:15:01] $40 million in the tax-supported fund [1:15:04] comes from other sources, like building permits, [1:15:06] shared revenues from the state. [1:15:08] The use of cash reserves for significant one-time projects that we otherwise wouldn't [1:15:14] absorb like the CAD system and others like we talked about. [1:15:18] Determining a tax rate in Idaho is a simple mathematical formula where you take the total [1:15:25] government's tax spending and you divide it by the total taxable value and it really is [1:15:29] a simple math product that allowed to increase the tax collections by 3% in your basis. [1:15:39] This is a graph illustrating the increases inside of the city's total taxable value. [1:15:45] You can see that it grew by 9% over the course of the last year, and that's on top of $211 [1:15:53] in prior fiscal year. [1:16:00] When you take the tax rate, you apply that to a home, and if it's owner occupied or not, [1:16:05] is when you take that value, but this is a graph that illustrates how properties have [1:16:11] appreciated inside of the City of Twin Falls. The median house in Twin Falls is $205,200. [1:16:18] However, the median listed price inside the City of Twin Falls is $245,000, and we have [1:16:26] spoken to several realtors who have told us that they believe that number is low, that [1:16:31] many of the houses in Twin Falls are in the two-meany range if they are for sale. We have watched [1:16:37] Our houses appreciate by 12.3% this year and they're [1:16:41] anticipated to go up an additional 8.9% in the subsequent year. [1:16:49] The things about the median house value inside of is we use it as an illustration. [1:16:56] It is not intended to indicate what the assessed value is. [1:17:02] That is a formula that's completely driven by, again, by the county assessor's office. [1:17:06] And they have certain benchmarks that they're required to follow through the state. [1:17:10] So if you, as you know, if you reside in your home and is your primary place of residence, [1:17:17] the state of Idaho says that you could take a maximum exemption of $100,000 or 50% of its value, whichever is less. [1:17:25] And so that $205,000 home is going to have a taxable value to the city of Twin Falls of $100, $2,500. [1:17:34] And then the tax rate would be applied to that number. [1:17:39] So over the course of the last several fiscal years since 2013, this is what has occurred [1:17:46] with the city's tax rate. [1:17:47] And you can see that this tax rate that we have proposed in the budget is the lowest tax [1:17:52] rate that we have issued since fiscal year 2013. [1:17:58] One of the things that we often are asked is how does that compare to other cities within [1:18:03] the state of Idaho? [1:18:04] And so what we like to do is kind of do a little bit of a comparison, and I'll just point out [1:18:09] Idaho Falls as an example because this is based upon the median property value of [1:18:15] 2018 and the resource we're doing last year's is because that's the tax rate information that we have and so when we apply the tax rate to the appropriate [1:18:25] Median value you'll notice what that debt load is on the left-hand side [1:18:30] the median house for a house in Caldwell, Twin Falls, and Idaho Falls are within [1:18:38] reason of one another. And then when you take the tax rate and you multiply it, you [1:18:45] can see the differences. And what I found really interesting is the same house, [1:18:51] the same median house in Twin Falls and comparison to Idaho Falls, it has the [1:18:55] the same value, but the tax rate is not the same. [1:18:59] And so that same house inside of the city of Idaho Falls [1:19:04] will cost a city resident $198 more per year [1:19:09] in city property taxes than what it would cost [1:19:12] inside the city of Twin Falls for the same local service. [1:19:15] Suzanne, did you have a comment on this? [1:19:17] I did, I just want a clarification. [1:19:19] We were talking about the median home [1:19:21] and the deduction on that, [1:19:23] but isn't there a cap of $100,000? [1:19:25] that's what I said. I thought I, I'm sorry, I thought you said that. [1:19:29] You actually said 102,000, man. [1:19:33] They only get 100,000, I'm sorry. I did the math quick. [1:19:37] So 105,000 would have been. So again, it's the taxable, [1:19:41] the median, the homing owner's exemption is a maximum of [1:19:45] 100,000 or 50% whichever [1:19:49] is lower of the two. If you go back to the slide [1:19:54] for a second than one of those cities. [1:19:59] This one, you know, think of different, [1:20:03] I don't know, falls as they have a zoo, [1:20:05] that zoos didn't aren't expensive, [1:20:12] or comments and a question, sorry. [1:20:15] And I had one to provide back, but not while we're televised. [1:20:25] So again, you can kind of see those different tax rates. [1:20:28] We think this is a really good illustration. [1:20:32] When we chart that graphically, the city of Twin Falls [1:20:35] appears in the green and all of the other cities [1:20:40] that are what we describe as full-service cities would appear in blue. [1:20:45] And then what's unique is you'll see two cities, Boise and Meridian, [1:20:49] that appear in red. [1:20:51] And what's unique about them is their roads are provided to them [1:20:54] by the Eda County Highway District. [1:20:56] And so if you incorporate roads into the Eda County Highway District's budget portion [1:21:03] into those individual cities, you would be able to develop more of an apples-to-apples comparison. [1:21:09] And this is reflective of what those individual tax rates would be on those median homes [1:21:14] within those communities that are surveyed. [1:21:16] We talked about the number of employees in this budget. [1:21:22] There are 312 total employees that work for the City of Twin Falls. [1:21:26] The true additions to this budget as we shared are 1.25 FTE. [1:21:32] We used the budget to catch up, but so as an example, one of the new positions [1:21:39] that we wouldn't necessarily call new would be our city attorney. [1:21:43] When the 2019 budget was created, the firm of Wonder, Lake & Wakefield offered that service. [1:21:50] It was a contract. The city attorney did not appear as an employee of the city over a period of time. [1:21:59] And on Princess retirement bought that employee in-house. As you know, our city attorney is Mr. Shane Nope. [1:22:07] And so while he's not new to the organization, how that is funded in those different categories, [1:22:13] those six categories is there, and we use this to catch up and to share what we're at [1:22:19] from the total number of employees that we have. We're requesting a 3% increase in base [1:22:26] compensation to remain market competitive, and our health insurance plan will increase by another 5%. [1:22:34] So what is it going to cost more? How much more is it going to cost inside of the City of Twin Falls? [1:22:40] This year is compared to last year. We're looking at about $7.78 a month and the largest source of that is the significant increase in appreciation individual home values. [1:22:50] You'll notice that when we take a standard customer of 18,000 gallons of water consumed, 12,000 gallons of water going into the city's source system and sanitation, [1:23:02] You can see what those rates are, and again, this is subject to change to the conversation [1:23:07] that you're about to have next as it relates to recycling. [1:23:11] If you elect to do something different in cycling, that number, that increase of 90 cents [1:23:17] per household per month is anticipated to decrease. [1:23:26] So I apologize, but we're going to ask you to come in on Wednesday. [1:23:35] Any questions for us? [1:23:36] We have members of the city's executive leadership team available to answer any questions that [1:23:41] you have. [1:23:42] On Wednesday, we would ask you to come in and set the public hearing in the tentative budget. [1:23:48] We would have a subsequent conversation on the 19th, which is again, council-driven, and [1:23:53] then anticipation of the budget to be adopted on the 26th. [1:23:57] So with that, staff would be happy to stand for any questions that you would have. [1:24:02] The Travis statistic clarifies of the post budget numbers, the 67, 77, 77, 36, 36, that one. [1:24:15] Yes, that one. [1:24:17] My second question would be understanding we will see revisions to the total price value of the county over time. [1:24:25] Are we anticipating any in the next month, weeks as we're approaching the adoption of the budget? [1:24:32] We are not. We believe that the number that we have is the number that we will continue to use through the budgeting process. [1:24:39] County will certify the tax roll and we will send out, we have to by process, notify for 24 hours in advance and we will do that. [1:25:07] I've sent an email invitation, an account invitation out to the entire council for that, so if you'll just look in your email, show up on your calendar here pretty quick. [1:25:20] and we promised it listed as an action item. [1:25:28] Other input here, we have an opportunity for citizen inputs. [1:25:33] So if there's anyone here who wishes to give input [1:25:36] on the budget item, now is your opportunity [1:25:39] to please come forward. [1:25:47] The next item on the agenda, which is an action item, [1:25:51] this is an update on the pilot program [1:25:53] to determine whether to expand or discontinue the program. [1:25:58] And we have Bill Baxter with utility services. [1:26:01] Welcome Bill. [1:26:02] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [1:26:03] I'll try to keep this short, and I apologize for the error in my agenda. [1:26:08] So, in September of 2017, we made our first announcement of the option to elect to carry [1:26:19] either a 65 or a 35-gallon garbage cart in place of the 95-gallon size that is common to the city. [1:26:29] The idea here was not only to encourage recycling, but also to address council concerns that [1:26:35] had been expressed over several years regarding not being able to hire a smaller card size since [1:26:42] I think it was 2018-06, when council elected to do away with the small card sizes. [1:26:50] We followed that September 2017 option up with another pilot area of town, the northwest [1:26:57] corner from North College to the northern boundary of Blue Lakes to the western boundary [1:27:03] of the city limits. And over those two election announcements, we contacted 2, 1983 people, [1:27:16] northwest area, about 1,600 in the what was the northeast area of town, or a total of about [1:27:23] 4500 households. The date of 6765 gallon carts in service and I believe it's 44 35 [1:27:36] gallon carts. Restrictions on the use of those carts included no extras except [1:27:44] three times a year which were posted on the calendars where PSI would pick up [1:27:49] extras for those residents as well. It was spring cleanup, fall cleanup in a week [1:27:53] after Christmas. It has been less than a large participation, so coming before you to get [1:28:07] some input on how you would like us to proceed. One item that has come up recently is PSI [1:28:15] has analyzed their actual costs of the program. 65 and 35 gallon cards, really the only savings [1:28:23] is the rental of the cart, stop the truck, make the lift, even with no extras cost about [1:28:30] the same no matter what cart size. The bonus to the smaller carts is ability of elderly and [1:28:37] disabled people to move their own cart to the street although the contract does provide [1:28:42] more notification of PSI or the city utility services office and we can arrange for the [1:28:48] driver to wheel those cards out as necessary. So pricing is going to increase for those [1:28:59] card sizes. In my original agenda item, it indicated that potentially the original one [1:29:05] can customer surviving from the 2006 termination would maintain their existing price. We would [1:29:13] certainly take counsel input, but PSI's costs for those cards are just as high as they are [1:29:18] for the pilot program. [1:29:20] Well, the question before you tonight, [1:29:24] is shall we continue offering the pilot program as is, [1:29:28] or should we perhaps consider a different option? [1:29:33] Not sure what that other option would be [1:29:34] other than termination, but that is for councils consideration. [1:29:39] The new costs for those cards, we've [1:29:42] been billing $5.25 for the PSI portion of the card price. [1:29:49] That's going to rise to about $9.30. [1:29:54] The $65 gallon cart we've been billing at $7.45, [1:29:59] that price is going to rise to $10.24. [1:30:04] And then the city's additional fees [1:30:06] will depend on what you decide tonight [1:30:10] with the recycling program. [1:30:16] So with that, I would stand for questions. [1:30:20] Yeah, Bill, I have a question for you. [1:30:21] Can you tell me how many art numbers [1:30:24] I told total customers we have total utility customers who are doing $9,930. [1:30:35] I checked because I thought you'd want a percentage. [1:30:38] We touched roughly 30% of the households that we serve in Twin Falls with that pilot program. [1:30:43] Presented the option to weigh percent of the community and have less than one percent participation. [1:30:51] I really do think it's that no extras. [1:30:54] One thing that has worked really well for us is the offer of extra cards. [1:30:59] We have around 1,295 gallon cards out there in service and I can't remember exactly in a [1:31:06] recycle at somewhat smaller, around 100. [1:31:12] So Bill in your narrative, you said the pricing of these cards is built by the city has most [1:31:18] recently been 35 gallon, 977, 65 gallon, 1343. [1:31:25] Yes. So is that including the city amount or the city amount plus the PSI amount? [1:31:32] That's the city amount plus the PSI amount. The PSI amounts on those cards were $5.25 for the $35 gallon in 7.4 for this. [1:31:40] Which is included in the $9.77 or not. Okay. That is correct. [1:31:44] And so what would it be for the $95 gallon? What are you talking about in increases? [1:31:51] Well, it increased that will relate to the recycling conversation. [1:31:55] Because we were in 1844, but the PSI price on those cards was $10.90. [1:32:05] Greg Lanting. [1:32:06] Bill, did you remind me? I thought you probably said it, and I was looking at other things. [1:32:12] Which areas of the town? I know you said North East Northwest. What's the other boundaries? [1:32:19] What's the matter? [1:32:20] We have three areas that we're doing right now. [1:32:23] No, sir, just the two. [1:32:25] We have not tried a pilot in, let's say, the presidential streets or the old town. [1:32:31] That's a great question. [1:32:33] Thank you for bringing me back around to this. [1:32:36] The areas that were tested were shown by PSI to be the strongest recycling areas in town [1:32:45] and the most diligent about paying attention to what the rules were. [1:32:49] We wanted to have as clean a test as possible as to who could really utilize those cards. [1:32:54] We actually, I was surprised, but this is a testament to the citizenry. [1:32:59] We only had one individual, tried to game the system, [1:33:03] ordered a 35-gallon cart to save money. [1:33:07] The first week he put out his extras and they didn't get picked up, we returned his 95-gallon. [1:33:15] Those only one, we were, when we got to that level of test, with those areas of town where we expected the greatest success and the greatest interest to be, we decided that it was time to come back. It's been almost two years, so definitely time to come back and at least report on our success and ask for some direction. [1:33:37] And I hope you have all on decision making for the council to decide whether or not to reduce recycling of the cardboard tenon that will hold on for the decision process. [1:33:53] Well, from the standpoint of what we anticipate in that scenario with recycling, it will increase the loads on the trash. [1:34:03] And if anything, it will restrict the number of people that qualify for that 35 and 65 gallon cart. [1:34:08] That's speculation, but the trash will have to go someplace, and if we take the mixed paper and the plastics out of it, as is stated in option two, that will have to go somewhere. [1:34:20] So that might answer the question. [1:34:26] Another recycling of a potential scenario could turn to the recycling program, and then they kept their small can, [1:34:45] thing in the recycling can, and continued to increase contamination, which is kind of the driver's of this problem. [1:34:55] Frankly, I'm a little surprised at the small number of people who are taking advantage of this program, and that's like, seven tenths of one percent of them. [1:35:09] Another thing I will point out when we first kicked out the first area of town, which by [1:35:16] the way was Addison de Falls, Locust, Tank, and Throne. [1:35:21] We mailed that announcement when we came around to the June of 2018. [1:35:28] Josh had some ability in Facebook to geofence an area. [1:35:33] That lasted four days until we found out that Facebook didn't like that. [1:35:38] was too selective, so they took the ad down, but Josh modified it and was able to get it back up. [1:35:45] It was up for 217 days, and we know people shared it because people from unqualified areas for the test [1:35:53] called and wanted to participate, but it has been out there quite a while, and within the first, [1:36:00] probably two months, we had these numbers, and it just didn't grow even with the announcement [1:36:08] the northwest side of town, we did not increase kill much. I think, again, I think 95 is handy. [1:36:18] You can put your extras out any week you want. Bull decided that availability of the option [1:36:25] was worth the additional cost. [1:36:27] This in his point of two years is a long time to do a test. There is really discern something [1:36:39] It may be six months, but two years is a good test. [1:36:43] You reached out to 30% of users of this system. [1:36:49] 1% participated. [1:36:55] That was a great test. [1:36:56] You got good data. [1:37:01] The same item participation rate. [1:37:08] Oh, I just feel like we got the data that we were looking for. [1:37:15] Tells us that this is not the best way to go. [1:37:18] Right here. [1:37:23] So I guess my question is, let me understand, [1:37:27] is the second go around with strictly Facebook, correct? [1:37:32] So if we've got seniors or the elderly disabled that would qualify potentially for something [1:37:41] like this, it was dependent on them being Facebook users. [1:37:46] Well, other than the news coverage, that's correct. [1:37:49] In June of 2018, we had a couple of stories in the Times News, I believe, in the K&B [1:37:54] and it was on the city website, but again, if they're not Facebook users, hiding it on [1:38:06] the website would not have been. [1:38:07] Maybe I'm missing something, but does it cost the 95 gallon users more to allow the smaller [1:38:23] cans at the lesser price? Is there a downside to the cost of the whole system, or is it just [1:38:29] each individual pricing group? [1:38:31] No, each PSI price is the contract to include the rental of the card, and the drive time [1:38:38] the stop and the lift. [1:38:40] So there's no extra cost to the city to keep this program going for those that appreciate it? [1:38:46] No, no that's true. [1:38:48] In fact, PSI has said that they would like to be able to offer those cards to people who want them for mobility purposes. [1:38:59] Simply the volume. [1:39:01] There's no downside to offering it to the entire city at this point, seeing where it goes. [1:39:07] Not that I know of just just the price change [1:39:13] But the price change is going to happen [1:39:15] But it's not that the larger users are subsidizing the smaller users [1:39:20] No, not the way the contract is priced [1:39:22] That was happening I believe to some degree [1:39:25] But the pricing has been adjusted now with their review [1:39:30] But it's a new pricing structure for the 35 and 65 gallon cards [1:39:34] However I would assume [1:39:36] It's based on a level of participation [1:39:39] that's and so say we did a part of this and just made it available the town [1:39:51] suddenly signed up for dollars and twenty-four cents is not going to have [1:39:59] a cost of service right I believe that when we started the pilot program [1:40:04] anticipating a greater than the five percent participation level there was [1:40:08] some discussion the pricing of those lower cards would have to change so yes [1:40:12] and that is because of the operational costs of the vehicle they're stopping [1:40:19] more at a smaller cart size than the price would probably rise, I'm guessing. [1:40:24] Bill Wagon, yes, the city bill, at the information. [1:40:31] I'm sorry, Chris, we did put that out there originally. [1:40:34] I have not revisited that once a year or more often than that with the messaging, but it [1:40:41] did go out of our insert, I think, for both years where we do our budget billing in September [1:40:49] included an announcement about cart size. [1:40:53] Is that what you have to do? [1:40:56] Mix messages here. [1:41:04] They're shaking their head. [1:41:05] No. [1:41:06] The contract isn't dependent on the number. [1:41:07] Is that correct? [1:41:08] Yes, I. [1:41:09] If you could please come up to the EGO LPSI. [1:41:10] There's no change in operational costs. [1:41:11] We just want to be fair and give a little bit of a price break for those customers that don't [1:41:24] use as much garbage. [1:41:25] But that's where there's all the town decides to go 65. [1:41:37] That's the brand we brought. [1:41:39] Thank you. [1:41:41] That doesn't make any sense to me that you're charging a lower range. [1:41:46] A lower rate to a smaller can, if your operational cost doesn't change, why are we just giving everybody half? [1:41:51] 65 gallon can, the benefits of sunday textures out there, the cards are a little cheaper, so there's some in-house savings, like smaller cards, eight-week and a whole round one. [1:42:03] Wait, also what is your question before I say that? [1:42:28] Whether we're expanding the pilot or expanding the discount, discontinue, continue, expand the program, or perhaps discontinue. [1:42:39] I'm ready to make a motion. [1:42:45] So if I understand everything correctly, I cannot see a downside to allowing our citizens [1:42:51] the option for what fits them. [1:42:53] So with that, I would move that we expand the pilot program throughout the city as long [1:42:58] as PSI can keep the cost towards that and continue on with the project we started two [1:43:04] years ago. [1:44:09] Chris Tockington. [1:44:10] Yes. [1:44:11] John Berger. [1:44:12] Yes. [1:44:13] Nikki Boyd. [1:44:14] Yes. [1:44:15] Zann Hawkins. [1:44:16] Yes. [1:44:17] Rick Lanting. [1:44:18] Yes. [1:44:19] Yes. [1:44:20] Motion passes. [1:44:21] Seven zero. [1:44:27] Thank you very much. [1:44:28] Thank you. [1:44:29] And let's do our these last. [1:44:32] So next on the agenda's not for general public input. [1:44:35] So again, this is not on the recycling program. [1:44:37] We'll have that public hearing coming up momentarily. [1:44:39] So if there's anyone who wishes to address the council on an item out of the agenda, [1:44:43] now is your chance to please come forward. [1:44:49] report reports from the council. We got the advertisement of the day for the [1:44:58] fireman's ball which will be September 7th and everyone to attend or to fireman. [1:45:07] Do you have anything from the city manager's office at this time? We are going to take a [1:45:18] short recess. I admit it's would be ideal to reconvene at a 10 till with the public hearing [1:45:29] on the recessed [1:45:31] there's a [1:46:05] compensation of a ten recidable [1:46:12] to some of it has a large [1:46:34] the sign up sheet [1:55:07] I'd like to reconvene the city council meeting for Monday [1:55:11] August 12th following the recess [1:55:13] it is five minutes to seven [1:55:17] the next item on the agenda is a public hearing [1:55:19] this is an action item this evening [1:55:21] the public input session of the city council [1:55:24] to gather feedback from the citizens of Twin Falls [1:55:27] on the direction of recycling. [1:55:30] We have Lori Race, our Chief Financial Officer, [1:55:32] who will make his staff presentation. [1:55:34] Welcome, Lori. [1:55:35] Thank you. [1:55:36] Good evening. [1:55:37] Tonight, I'd like to provide information regarding [1:55:40] the city's current recycling program, [1:55:43] and including the costs associated with that. [1:55:47] I'd also like to share options and costs [1:55:50] if we were to change the program, [1:55:52] or if we were to temporarily shelve the program. [1:55:56] I've asked Josh Bartlemay from Southern Idaho Solid Waste [1:56:00] and Mike Doyle, Jason Kirschman, and John Tilton from PSI [1:56:06] to join us this evening. [1:56:07] It's good to have experts with us. [1:56:18] So single stream recycling is a system [1:56:21] in which all recyclables are placed [1:56:23] in a single banner card for recycling. [1:56:26] And this is the type of program that the cities have [1:56:29] since 2010. [1:56:32] From the recycle cart, that material is baled in twin falls at a cost of $30 a ton. [1:56:39] It's then shipped to Boise for an additional $40 per ton, and sorted at a cost of $90 per ton, [1:56:47] making the cost of that material $160 a ton before it's determined where it will go. [1:56:54] This year, we've sent almost 1200 tons of material to be recycled, or about 133 tons per month, [1:57:04] with the expected annual tonnage to reach almost 1,600 tons. [1:57:08] Through June, the city's cost has been 133,000, and I'm estimating that we'll reach about 180,000 by year end. [1:57:21] And it's really important to note, PSI contributes $50 per ton, which would really [1:57:28] bring the total annual costs for our 1,600 tons of recyclables just shy of $260,000. [1:57:38] Our citizens pay a dollar per month or $12 per year per household. [1:57:44] Without PSI's cost-sharing, we would need to charge our customers an additional $5.35 [1:57:50] to cover the current cost of recycling. [1:57:53] So what does a ton of baled material look like? [1:58:00] Well, the composition of materials [1:58:02] included in recycled bins, [1:58:04] along with the value commodity, is as follows. [1:58:08] Cardboard makes up 37% of the total [1:58:11] and is currently valued at $55 a ton. [1:58:15] This commodity then goes to Washington, Oregon. [1:58:19] mixed paper makes up the majority of 43% and it costs over $36 a ton. It's [1:58:29] transported to Washington. 10 makes up only 2% for the value of $175 and it [1:58:37] ends up in Portland. Aluminum makes up 1%. It's valued at $1,000 a ton and it has [1:58:46] to be transported to Kentucky. Last sticks are 6% of the total and actually have a value [1:58:54] of less than a dollar per ton. This item also ends up in Portland, Oregon. Finally, the trash [1:59:01] that makes it into the recycled bins accounts for 11% of that total ton, and we pay $64 per [1:59:09] ton for that material to either go to the Aida County Landfill or Landfill and work. As you [1:59:19] can see from this pie chart between the mixed paper and the trash over half of [1:59:25] this ton of recyclable material has additional costs associated with its [1:59:30] disposition. While she's looking at that, so this is the cost for recycling. What is [1:59:42] the cost per ton for just taking it to the landfill? Or am I ahead of you? Just [1:59:46] give me a few more slides and I'll be right there. So this slide represents the [1:59:59] values or costs for the various commodities. And it's based on that ton of recyclable material. [2:00:08] As you know, commodity values change constantly, but for comparison purposes, [2:00:13] these are the updated numbers that I have and there will be what we're using. [2:00:17] Currently, we are in $20.35 for the portion that's cardboard, [2:00:23] 1867 for the portion of mixed paper. We received $350 for $10 for the aluminum and $0.06 for the plastics. [2:00:36] We pay $7.04 for the 11% of the ton. It's actually trash. Now these numbers net to a positive value of $11.20 per ton. [2:00:48] And after adding the bailing, the shipping, and the sorting that costs per bail currently [2:00:55] of recyclable material is approximately $149 a ton. [2:01:09] Makes the same assumptions as the previous accepted assumes were only going to recycle [2:01:15] the commodities with value. [2:01:17] Those would be cardboard tin. [2:01:20] And the reason that I chose this option is because from the April 22nd meeting, [2:01:26] This is the option that you folks showed interest in. [2:01:31] I made the assumption that the other commodities would go to the landfill as it's really difficult [2:01:38] to figure how much that would become the trash portion. [2:01:41] We would have an education process to go through. [2:01:49] Please be aware that this is really a best case scenario. [2:01:54] I'm assuming that the mixed paper and the plastic is going to go to the landfill and the rest of it [2:02:00] rest of it will shake out as it is. In order for this to work, PSI's drivers would have [2:02:07] to have the authority to take a load of recyclables to the lamp. In this case, it would still cost [2:02:21] us $160 a ton to sort or to bail transport and sort. But these costs could be offset by [2:02:33] Again, please remember it's best case scenario, or the cost in this example would be $107 per tonne to recycle. [2:02:45] It's important to remember that the cardboard tin would be transported to Washington, Oregon, and our aluminum would go to Kentucky. [2:02:55] of the average amount of 133 tons of recyclables per month, [2:03:01] it's estimated that this would drop to 68 tons in this scenario. [2:03:06] I would estimate this option reducing recycling expenses for the city by about half, [2:03:13] from 180,000 to 90,000, while increasing our landfill fees by a little over 29,000. [2:03:34] If we were to shelve the program until such a time as there's a change [2:03:38] the commodities market or until there's a local presence to sort the recyclable [2:03:42] materials and potentially lower costs we would reduce recycling costs in the [2:03:47] current budget by about $180,000 while increasing our landfill costs by about [2:03:54] 60 because now our $133 per ton that we're recycling would all go to the [2:04:00] landfill. It's important to recognize that this discussion is certainly not [2:04:08] unique to the City of Twin Falls. According to the current issue of the [2:04:13] municipal, Michigan launched a two million dollar education campaign dedicated to [2:04:19] increasing its low recycling rate and reducing the amount of material improperly [2:04:25] left in their curbside recycle bins. People are mistakenly trying to recycle [2:04:31] plastic bags and not rinsing their plastic glass and metal and at least a [2:04:36] contamination that makes materials unrecyclable and increases costs for local [2:04:41] government. [2:04:43] Deltona, Florida, has actually suspended all weekly residential recycling due to the [2:04:50] market demands for plastics, glass, and paper decreasing. [2:04:56] Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, discontinued their recycling program as of June 30, 2019. [2:05:03] recycling costs drove that city to end their report program which was similar [2:05:09] to the recycle bank program that the city had several years ago. In order to [2:05:14] reduce recycling contamination proper recycling is a necessity. Their new [2:05:20] education campaign is entitled take a minute before you bin it and when it [2:05:25] out throw it out. Williamson County Tennessee shared that their recyclables [2:05:31] are taken to local and regional markets. With China placing new restrictions on what's accepted, [2:05:37] the markets in the U.S. are saturated, driving costs higher and revenues from commodities lowered. [2:05:46] So I presented three options tonight and I am happy to pull together costs for any other options [2:05:53] that you would like to identify going forward. I have those options displayed and would just like [2:06:01] to point out again that if we were to go with option number two it is just a [2:06:07] best-case hypothetical situation. Would our citizens do a perfect job of only [2:06:12] putting cardboard aluminum and tin in the recycled cart? Probably not. And that's [2:06:18] not unique to our city. As I shared earlier for this option to work, PSI's [2:06:24] drivers would have to have the authority to be able to landfill the [2:06:27] contaminated loads. So that is all that I have prepared for you tonight. Suzanne, I [2:06:34] wanted you to know it costs $37.50 a time to take trash to the land. That'll be to answer [2:06:44] questions and southern Idaho solid waste. Yes, I are here as well. [2:06:48] Thank you. [2:06:50] Just to send another question, I'm here to find Chris reading. [2:06:56] When PSI was here last couple of months ago, [2:06:58] talked a little bit about the carbon footprint, [2:07:00] or so when we helped with hearing, [2:07:04] we talked a little bit about it to recycle. [2:07:08] That conversation we found out that shipping [2:07:14] some of these things all over the country wasn't the case. [2:07:18] So I was wondering if we could, [2:07:19] we had somebody here that could speak to that. [2:07:25] Maybe they don't want to, and I understand that too. [2:07:31] I know it's not an exact science. [2:07:35] Maybe it's more of an opinion, [2:07:36] and I understand that to recycle emissions from the vehicle traveling to Kentucky to Portland to Washington. [2:07:53] Yes, so Jason Kurzmann with PSI, all I can say is this material is going to travel some miles. [2:08:16] It's going to cost, and also the emissions that those vehicles put out start recycling again. [2:08:26] There's a cost there, and put a lot of size and command views in the West. [2:08:51] Yeah, I am not Chris. It just the same things that we're experiencing here [2:09:06] seem to be [2:09:07] state-wide [2:09:14] Exactly take some public to the house of discussion [2:09:29] So we have a fair number of folks who are signed up this evening [2:09:33] Certainly value everyone's opinions and input however [2:09:36] I would ask people to please be concise in your input [2:09:40] And if it is repetitive of what other people are saying, you can just kind of hit that as [2:09:45] a high point and move on to your point so that we can make it through all of the input. [2:09:50] Again, I have a list of folks who have signed up, but at the end of that we'll give an opportunity [2:09:54] if there are those of you who didn't sign up and want to give some input. [2:09:59] So first of all, I have Mona Weeks. [2:10:02] I have questions for us. [2:10:10] We're likely going to take those notes down and then at the end of all of the input be [2:10:14] able to give back to answering those because again, this isn't really a back and forth conversation, [2:10:19] it's a you giving us input. [2:10:22] After listening to the later that was just speaking, I do have a couple questions. [2:10:26] Why have we not looked at other alternatives versus recycling, like Singapore, Australia, [2:10:32] and the other areas that are actually doing it where they're burning it, it's not going [2:10:36] into the air, the air coming out of the incinerators is clean air, there is absolutely zero waste. [2:10:42] Why haven't we looked at that? [2:10:44] As big as our communities is growing, I think having a landfill in all of this and not giving [2:10:50] that an option to look at is just a waste on you guys not doing that to protect everybody [2:10:57] here that's the city. [2:10:58] I mean, why are we just continually dumping more stuff into the landfill? [2:11:02] The second one that I had for you guys, my understanding is we have not had recycling [2:11:07] happening in the entire city of Twin Falls for the last two years. [2:11:12] you guys can clarify that my understanding is from different people that [2:11:16] have worked for PSI and other areas all of what we thought was being recycled has [2:11:21] been going directly to the landfill and I understand she only had information [2:11:26] tonight for this year from January to June why don't we have if we have been [2:11:33] doing recycling why can't she provide those statistics so that's what I would [2:11:37] like to know tonight. We can certainly get that information and we've been having this [2:11:40] conversation for about two years, so we've had regular updates with that information, but we'll get that to you at the conclusion of the public hearing. [2:11:47] So can you say whether or not we have been recycling? [2:11:49] Yes, we have been. [2:11:50] Technically for the last two years, because we've been paying for it. [2:11:52] Yeah, we have been. [2:11:53] Okay, so when we follow a track that's picking up what's supposed to be landfill, and it's going to the dump, and I follow it, and it goes to the dump, you're telling me it's not going to the dump? [2:12:04] So again, I'm just asking. [2:12:08] Yeah, so we've had a variety of ways that recycling has been being handled over the last couple of years [2:12:13] when we have a contaminated load that's full of plastic bags that aren't going to recycle. [2:12:18] That load goes and gets dumped because it's contaminated and it's not going to work. [2:12:22] We've been off and on with following the market prices on a monthly basis, [2:12:27] so some months when it exceeded the amount that we were able to pay, that was getting dumped. [2:12:32] But consistently for two years, no one has not been going to them. [2:12:35] Okay, that answers it. Thank you. [2:12:38] Next up, Kathy Hanson. [2:12:41] Nicky, how many come down if you please state your name for the record? [2:12:45] I live here in Twin Falls and I'm probably your extreme recycler. [2:12:55] Not, but my recycling into the cans lately [2:13:01] because of what's been going on with the marketplace. [2:13:04] I've actually been taking them to the recycling place, so I'm still recycling. [2:13:08] But I totally support it, but I don't want to be subjected to that. [2:13:14] So my initial thought was not to recycle because I'm concerned about my environment and consuming [2:13:25] and using it in our lab. [2:13:28] But my question has the city and the broad look at the possibility of developing, recruiting [2:13:41] a key to come into Twin Falls who would reuse, recycle these materials that we're collecting [2:13:49] so that we close the loop and we keep it here, and you don't have to ship it. [2:13:55] And they can develop, but then brings jobs and money back into our community. [2:14:03] That's... [2:14:11] Josh, Bartlett... [2:14:21] I did the same thing. [2:14:23] You did sign up. [2:14:24] If you don't want to speak, you don't have to. [2:14:26] I used to go into County Commissioners and usually assign in, but while I'm up here, I would like to address a couple things. [2:14:33] The city is in a decision to make a tough decision tonight, and I won't get into it a whole lot, but this is something that's happening nationwide. [2:14:44] You know, city councils are having to make the decision to bite the bullet and continue these single-stream recycling programs or to scale it back. [2:14:53] And there's not a real solution here in the next couple of years. [2:14:58] You know, we're probably looking at a real good solution in the five years. [2:15:02] So, being said, it is a recycle in the city of Twin Falls, it's at what cost, right? [2:15:13] Expensive proposition, instances. [2:15:22] Take a touch. [2:15:27] And she, nobody told you there was going to be a penmanship test tonight, right? [2:15:41] So, if you would please state your name. [2:15:44] Hello, my name is Chiang Sheen, and I'm a local resident of Twin Falls. [2:15:48] A little over a year ago, I stood up here in this exact spot and also spoke about my thoughts on the recycling system [2:15:55] here in Twin Falls. The previous time I mentioned that, I believed it was very important to keep this recycling system [2:16:01] and that the multi-medium recycling system that I created at Twin Falls High School was just like the beginning stages [2:16:07] of what our city should be going into. And I also mentioned how if a club of 20 students could manage and encourage over 1,000 other students to properly recycle, [2:16:19] cycle, then as a city we could too, and reach a solution for the recycling. [2:16:24] I suggested a few ideas such as having a big event to teach community members about popular [2:16:28] recycling and other ways to be more environmentally conscious and active. [2:16:32] However, what I didn't fully understand my senior year of high school is that everything [2:16:37] is deeply intertwined within the capitalist society and even things like recycling and [2:16:42] planting trees cost money. [2:16:46] Because we have seen, we have not been able to find a clear solution due to many things. [2:16:52] And therefore, my opinion and proposal is that the current recycling system should not be [2:17:02] co-mingled. [2:17:03] It should be single streamed, but instead we need to educate all residents of all ages [2:17:08] how to properly recycle and we need to separate the recycling. [2:17:12] Our biggest repulsion with recycling is contamination and then the distribute. [2:17:16] Tation after collection. [2:17:18] And so that would be more solved by separating the recycling in the first place. [2:17:23] We could collect these recyclables from a lot of people who, excuse me. [2:17:32] And so when we collect these recyclables, we have people who really try to recycle like [2:17:37] their heart, and then we also have people who maybe just like they're garbage, also in [2:17:42] their they don't have room, and then we also have people who don't fully understand how [2:17:45] how to properly recycle, like even me, sometimes I have problems like, okay I have an envelope [2:17:49] that has paper on it but then it also has plastic and then it also has glue that's like, can I recycle that or not? [2:17:53] and that's like a hard question for a lot of us and so in the end [2:17:57] all this gets mingled together and then we have like really contaminant recycling like we all know [2:18:01] and so instead if we, my proposal is that we have [2:18:10] bigger bins in neighborhood sections and if we carefully plan [2:18:14] This we can have three sever bins just like how Twin Falls High School has [2:18:20] That they're clearly labeled packages that says recycle [2:18:26] Okay, let me back up a little bit. Okay, so [2:18:32] After we attempt to collect all this recycling that we have been doing [2:18:38] And then we try to like ship it off to other places [2:18:41] Obviously no recycled plant wants to open a clearly labeled package that says recyclables and then you open it and [2:18:48] you not only find some dirty recyclables, but then also you find a half-eaten burrito from the high school cafeteria. [2:18:54] And I'm sure they're just like, what is this doing in here? [2:19:00] And I would personally know how surprising that would be to find a half-eaten breakfast burrito in the recycling, [2:19:06] because I have actually had that happen to me twice while I maintain Twin Falls High School's recycling. [2:19:12] But regardless of all the fermenting chocolate milk bottles I found in the ABC gum, I and [2:19:20] my fellow environment solo club members easily continued to make the recycling clean for Western [2:19:26] waste recycling when they came picked it up because we had separate bins and separate [2:19:31] boxes. [2:19:32] So we have a box of paper, a box of plastics, one and two, and then one from Luna Cams, [2:19:37] which were anxiously created and donated by capstone paper and packaging. [2:19:40] And then we also have one that's just for plastic bags, [2:19:42] so that's for me, it was poly. [2:19:45] And so this is something that we need to implement [2:19:46] in the city of Twin Falls in order [2:19:47] to further fix our recycling system. [2:19:53] And so with that, if we have already separated recycling, [2:19:58] then we can easily see the contamination levels in those, [2:20:02] and then we can pick and choose which to send [2:20:06] to certain places, depending on how the market is. [2:20:10] And with that, we're less dependent on the market, [2:20:15] and we're more dependent on what's going on in our own city, [2:20:19] and making it less troublesome for everyone. [2:20:24] And I believe that if we don't obviously [2:20:27] have the resources to give everybody three sub-air bins [2:20:30] and a plastic bin for every separate thing, [2:20:33] but if we do big bins like I stated earlier, [2:20:37] it would be a little bit less convenient for people [2:20:39] just to throw their trash outside their garage. [2:20:43] And so I think making it a little bit less [2:20:45] and convenient would actually help those [2:20:47] who truly know how to recycle and truly want to recycle [2:20:49] to go out and then put their clean recycling in those bins. [2:20:54] And then my last point is that I would like to bring up [2:20:57] that recycling is only one of the three Rs. [2:21:00] Twin Falls also needs to not only focus [2:21:02] on recycling but also focus and take initiative [2:21:05] on ways to reuse and reduce. [2:21:08] Twin Falls is a growing leading city in the entire nation. [2:21:11] And as we grow, we should be an example to fellow growing cities around the United States. [2:21:15] Because recycling isn't our strongest point, we should be growing our green energy and making plans to be more environmental and conscious. [2:21:21] And so if it causes a bigger carbon footprint to ship all these recyclables, [2:21:25] then we need to influence other cities in the state of Idaho and other states to create better recycling plants that are closer. [2:21:31] However recycling since it's not our strong suit then we need to look at [2:21:38] plants to be 100% renewable energy by 2025 or 2030. We need to look for ways [2:21:43] to grow our local markets and bring in more produce from local farmers. We need [2:21:47] to reduce unnecessary plastic and make sure all plastic bags go back to recycling. [2:21:50] We should become a pollinator from the community. We should be putting solar [2:21:54] panels on our new rec center and our schools. We need to make plans for our [2:21:58] future not just because they affect the planet but because they affect the people [2:22:01] on this planet, and they directly affect the people of Twin Falls. [2:22:07] So if we did that, the growth of green energy would help increase auto powers renewable energy [2:22:12] and the people who work there. [2:22:13] And then buying more local produce helps our neighborhood farmers, making sure plastic [2:22:17] bags go back to recycling helps healers poly and their workers. [2:22:20] Being a pollenured friendly community helps everyone's gardens and farms. [2:22:24] Solar panels decreases the overall cost for energy. [2:22:31] And as I previously mentioned, other businesses like CASA paper and packaging has helped Twin [2:22:37] Falls High Schools recycling, and Web Landscades has run trees to our school, and other businesses [2:22:43] in the community like Orange League and EHM engineers have helped Twin Falls High School [2:22:47] become more green. [2:22:49] And so in order to grow Twin Falls for the future and all residents, we need to find effective [2:22:55] and efficient ways while also keeping the environment in mind. [2:22:58] We need to be sustainable and invite and encourage more environmentally conscious, eco-friendly [2:23:02] businesses to win falls, instead of businesses that don't care of our environment, because [2:23:07] in the end that decreases the quality of life for Twin Falls citizens. [2:23:10] We need to be just like our monosys, people serving people. [2:23:15] Like I said, I am a resident of Twin Falls Heights. [2:23:16] I have Twin Falls. [2:23:17] I graduated from Twin Falls High School and even though I moved around a lot as a child [2:23:21] and I studied in Europe last year, I chose to come back to the city. [2:23:27] I could have gone to New York or California or abroad and the reason why I came back is because I call this place my home [2:23:34] This is my home just like everybody else in this room, and I simply want the best for it and the residents now [2:23:41] For the residents now for the near future and also for the distant future [2:23:45] I believe that we can secure our future and for the future for generations to come as we carefully plan and act with the [2:23:51] Environment of the people and Twin Falls in mind [2:23:53] And with that, I hope to have any questions. [2:23:55] Thank you very much. [2:23:56] And next I have... [2:24:00] On a brassy. [2:24:02] The Council appreciate that the City of Twin Falls is a curbside recycling program. [2:24:25] I'm here this evening to ask that the City of Twin Falls continue with the current recycling program. [2:24:32] I understand that recycling is a business. [2:24:35] I would hope that you would take this opportunity to lead by example, [2:24:42] rather than follow the trend taken by other towns. [2:24:45] the spending the recycling program the recycling program is suspended like you [2:24:58] to consider the future costs and I apologize new to this game this is my [2:25:03] first city council meeting so if you've discussed these items before I apologize [2:25:08] in advance if the recycling program is suspended how much will the recycling [2:25:13] or garbage free pick up increase which Lori covered in her presentation and I [2:25:18] appreciate it that. If it is suspended or shelved, how much will it cost restarted a future suspended? [2:25:31] And this recycling goes into our garbage. Our landfills will fill up faster. Granted, I understand there's a 40-year picture here, but that's just pushing it off to our children and grandchildren. [2:25:44] And once those landfills are full, I think it's time to start thinking about other options. [2:25:57] We could all have a meeting of the mines. [2:25:59] There's so much knowledge in the Wind Falls County, Southern Idaho, uh, so Dave Trent Falls, [2:26:06] PSI environmental, Magic Valley recycling, Western recycling, Idaho Department of Environmental [2:26:14] quality. We need to, even the local universities, high schools, elementary schools, come together [2:26:23] and think of solutions. And again, I apologize if you guys have all discussed this before. [2:26:28] As consumers, can we think before we buy? I struggle with this all the time. Can we buy [2:26:33] less? Can we buy food that isn't packaged in plastic, that isn't recycled? Work with [2:26:41] local companies to minimize the amount of plastic coming into Twin Falls if it doesn't [2:26:45] come in, we don't have to recycle it. [2:26:49] And we generate some sort of revenue by upcycling. [2:26:53] This recycled, these recycled products, the plastic [2:26:56] can be created infrastructure here in Twin [2:27:01] that can upcycle these recycled items into park benches [2:27:06] or playground structures for either charity, anything [2:27:14] for revenue. [2:27:15] But a closed loop compost system can [2:27:19] We start collecting green material to process them and then use as compost in this area. [2:27:26] Again, I mentioned providing funding for research and development at local schools so that we can figure out a sustainable recycling program in this area, not only twin of southern Idaho. [2:27:43] Or there are other options out there that we haven't thought of. [2:27:47] Can we apply for grants from other done line today? [2:27:55] Close loop partners. Can we apply for grants to offset the increase in cost [2:28:01] or recycling? I just urge you to think, [2:28:07] urge that we can think of other things. [2:28:11] Think outside of the box. I urge you not to cancel the recycling program. [2:28:16] I urge that we educate their PR campaign to educate in [2:28:23] recycling practices and this goes into play even if we [2:28:28] tend to be re-educated and reminded and think about how we [2:28:37] communicate to the community issue with the pilot program. [2:28:44] You just have your bills in the mail, paperwork in the mail, [2:28:47] how many of you have their bills online? [2:28:49] Don't look at all trying to minimize paperwork but you're [2:28:53] sending it to us. [2:28:56] So what other things can we do? [2:28:59] There are options, and it's not easy for everyone to do. [2:29:05] For example, TeraCycle.com has zero-ways boxes. [2:29:08] I've sent a box of plastic to New Jersey to pre-recycled. [2:29:12] Just run out and do anything with it here. [2:29:13] I refuse to throw the plastic away. [2:29:16] Earth 911 is another website you can go to to figure out where to bring your recycling. [2:29:24] Granted, there aren't a lot of options in Southern Idaho. [2:29:28] I know that I do bring my styrofoam that's labeled with number six to dart down on south [2:29:34] Avenue south they accept styrofoam and that's awesome let's keep that out of the [2:29:41] or target I bring my glass to recycle a target and I'm sure a few people in this [2:29:47] room do that as well Idaho is growing more people move here every day this is [2:29:55] a worldwide problem that, in conclusion, Twin Falls, [2:30:06] to continue with the current recycling program, [2:30:09] let's strive to do more good than harm, [2:30:13] so that we can keep the City of Twin Falls and the [2:30:17] state of Idaho beautiful for future generations. [2:30:20] Weigh to all read, and the resident homework, [2:30:40] I spent about seven and a half bucks this morning on breakfast, [2:30:45] and to think, you know, when we think about values and costs, [2:30:50] $5.35 a year is what we're thinking about giving up. [2:30:55] We've got to save that $5.5, is that really worth our values on it? [2:30:59] So I would say unequivocally, option one is the way to go. [2:31:03] I work as an environmental manager, one of the manufacturing facilities here in the valley, [2:31:08] so I understand it worked daily with trying to find homes for recyclable sites. [2:31:14] continuous is tough. I don't I think Josh is more sunny on this one. I don't [2:31:20] think three years from now we have an outlet for all this stuff. I personally [2:31:25] don't believe that but I say we still try to keep recycling but I think we [2:31:29] changed the question and as leaders I think we all should step back and say [2:31:34] how do we do this differently instead of saying how do we recycle this stuff [2:31:39] as a city, how do we not create the recyclables in the first place? [2:31:44] I know, you know, being a lifelong Idaho resident, these words sound odd coming out of my mouth. [2:31:51] How do we not ban plastic bags or put a cost on that? [2:31:57] You know, the city of San Francisco, again, this is tough for me to say, but later this month, [2:32:03] they're banning single-use water plots. [2:32:07] You know, we got a problem where this plastic is going, maybe we just stopped making it in the first place. [2:32:13] Since between years of 1990 to 2015, plastic in our landfill has gone from 8.2% to 13.1%. [2:32:25] Maybe it's time we think about how do we not put plastic in there. [2:32:29] Over 50% of the stuff that's going to the landfill can be pulled out. [2:32:34] It can be composted and put back into good use. [2:32:39] It doesn't have to sit in landfill forever. [2:32:41] That stuff we can do is it cheap? [2:32:44] Nope. [2:32:45] Is it easy? [2:32:46] Nope. [2:32:47] But you know what? [2:32:48] We're Idahoans. [2:32:49] We're not about doing cheap, easy stuff. [2:32:51] We're old people that do bold things. [2:32:53] It's time to change the question and it's time to change the way we approach this. [2:32:58] And that's what I would ask us to do. [2:33:00] Thank you. [2:33:04] Max Newlin, Max, Barry Olson Frank. [2:33:13] Hello again. [2:33:23] Sherry Olson Frank. [2:33:24] I didn't realize this was on the agenda tonight, so I'm not very prepared about it. [2:33:30] I just wanted to let you know that I was on the original committee who looked at this recycling program many moons ago. [2:33:39] I still think it's a good idea. [2:33:42] I still think it's something that we need to do. [2:33:47] Yes, there's a cost, but it's basically the right thing to do, is there's some different [2:33:53] ways we can do this, I'm sure there is, I haven't, you know, looked at that, the different ways [2:34:00] to recycle or have a closed system or some of these other things that we're spoken about. [2:34:07] There seem to be some really good ideas that have already been said, I'm just here to say [2:34:12] I'm still in favor of it. I'd still like to see Twin Falls doing a recycling program. [2:34:19] I'm not sure what that's going to look like, but I would like, like it's not to put it on the shelf. [2:34:26] Thank you. Thank you. I'm Winslow. Hi, my name is Karen Winslow. I'm currently a senior at Twin Falls High School [2:34:42] and I'm also the president of the schools and environmental club. So my family and I have lived [2:34:47] in Twin Falls for 14 years, and we've always been actively involved in recycling, which [2:34:52] is something that many other family and community members are also involved with, especially [2:34:55] with Twin Falls citizens that are my age specifically. [2:34:59] So for example, as president of the Twin Falls High School Environmental Club, one of the things [2:35:04] that we do is to promote a more of a green school. [2:35:07] So we currently have about 20 members in our club, and it's a heavily growing club as well. [2:35:12] We also manage the school recycling program and are highly involved in other projects [2:35:16] around campus and around town. We're working to promote being green out of our school many [2:35:20] ways such as reducing plastic, plastic, styrofoam and trash in the school cafeteria, planting [2:35:26] trees, working to get solar panels, planting a garden and creating compost for the garden, [2:35:31] which are all run by students. As I mentioned, our club manages the school recycling where [2:35:36] recycling out of our school has been growing. As a student at the high school, I consider [2:35:40] students want to be more involved and want to help the community become more environmentally [2:35:45] friendly. With about 1,000 students on campus, [2:35:48] and majority of them do choose to do their part of recycling. [2:35:51] Our students want to be involved and want to help [2:35:53] be more environmentally friendly town, as the community should too. [2:35:57] The students want to help recycle and maintain a clean town, [2:36:00] which is one reason keeping the recycling program in Twin Falls [2:36:03] would be beneficial. As a growing town, one thing we can do [2:36:07] is to help keep Twin Falls and the Canyon clean by continuing [2:36:09] the recycling program to help reduce littering and trash as a whole. [2:36:14] To conclude, I strongly believe that the younger Twin Falls [2:36:17] citizens, specifically students my age, [2:36:19] do want to promote more of a green community, [2:36:21] as many of the students have already [2:36:23] participated in environmentally friendly activities [2:36:26] and projects, and will work to promote a clean town, [2:36:30] even if that means take the extra steps to recycle correctly, [2:36:33] as every Twin Falls citizen should too. [2:36:35] Thank you. [2:36:58] I sent you all the proposal to commission. [2:37:03] It would study the problem of recycling [2:37:06] from the idea of developing industries here locally, [2:37:13] well, in the Magic Valley, use recyclables. [2:37:21] Also study what is the plethora of information [2:37:26] that comes every day of various prototypes [2:37:31] and actually operating recycling entities all over the world. [2:37:41] in the subsequent months, I have looked at so much stuff that people are doing, and much [2:37:49] of it is very low scale. The other thing I've noted is that there is a real desire on the [2:37:59] part of investors and grant grant grant grant tours to invest in recycling programs. [2:38:12] What I am suggesting again because I think this is way too big an issue for the council [2:38:19] to do at once every couple of months coming and up. [2:38:27] I really think we should establish a commission. [2:38:30] It should include people from the Sustainability Council at CSI, and my thought is the Workforce [2:38:40] development, a small business incubator, people who have spoken here have made very good presentations, [2:38:53] I think, about the fact that there's a lot of new thinking about recycling. [2:39:03] I will have to say that I've been very disappointed in PSI, because they always seem to be thinking [2:39:10] about what they can collect and how they can send it out and how, you know, can they make [2:39:16] a profit doing what they've always done. [2:39:21] You know, I can understand from a business model that maybe what they want to do. [2:39:25] I've talked to people from, I believe in Western Waste Management that operate in Burleigh, [2:39:32] And they seem to have some more vigorous thinking on the idea of recycling. [2:39:39] So the other thing I would say is the next time we consider a contract for waste management, [2:39:45] we go out for bids and make a very strong effort to find companies that will cooperate [2:39:53] with recycling. [2:39:54] But right now, I would say option one to just cancel it is the thing to do. [2:40:02] The money that the city would save could be used to, in some ways, incubate the commission, [2:40:09] incubate ideas, because what we're doing now is really almost costing us money. [2:40:18] It certainly is costing us money in carbon footprint, and I don't know that it is doing [2:40:24] anything really useful as far as recycling. [2:40:27] I had no problem at all, taking my cardboard, my tin, my aluminum to western, or to the waste management over my record. [2:40:42] So, I just think that right now we should go ahead and end the recycling program. [2:40:48] with the idea that we're going to expand our efforts to be smart about recycling and bring jobs and investment to the Magic Family. [2:41:00] and counsel my name is David Moore. I'm a property owner, resident and voter in the city of Twin Falls [2:41:37] and I have a bunch of notes. I'm not going to read them all because I take notes that virtually [2:41:41] every city council meeting and we have been adding this thing around. My earliest notes in this [2:41:47] particular book date to February of 2018 that are another discussion in March of 2018. [2:41:57] we had another discussion in February of this year, we had a discussion in March of this year. [2:42:07] And there's been a lot said, and a lot of people here are saying, oh, we've got to recycle, we've got to recycle. [2:42:15] The thing that I would like to address, I don't disagree with the concept of recycling. [2:42:21] What I disagree with is when we put a bigger carbon footprint on the nation than the value [2:42:29] of the materials salvaged through recycling. When we're spending sending our recycle 600 miles away [2:42:40] on a truck that gets six miles to the gallon and burning 100 gallons of diesel fuel to get our [2:42:47] stuff hauled to Portland. That's a negative impact on the environment compared to the value of the material saved through recycling. [2:43:01] We have to send our own room to Kentucky. There's been mention made of, well let's get somebody here that'll do it. [2:43:08] The number of places that'll recycle are on the decline, not on the increase. [2:43:14] And until we can find a way to recycle in such a manner that we are not having a negative impact by our recycle efforts. [2:43:27] I'm all in favor of option three, shelf the program, figure out how to do it without having a negative impact on the environment and move forward. Thank you for your time. [2:43:46] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council to not sign up? [2:43:49] Yes, sir. [2:43:50] Yes. [2:43:57] Please stay here. [2:44:03] John Nothing Huddleson is my name and recycling is my game. [2:44:10] When I recycle, I recycle 6 days a week for 6 hours a day from 6 a.m. to use day 2 o'clock [2:44:18] in the afternoon. [2:44:19] I go to a pupils trash. [2:44:21] I'm not afraid to admit it. [2:44:23] I carry 2 bags with me. [2:44:25] I carry 1 for aluminum cans, which I do to make extra monies aluminum cans. [2:44:30] Then I cast in £5,320 this year and the other bag is for all the recyclables, junk [2:44:36] mail, cardboard, newspaper, no pizza boxes, because they aren't recyclable and I take [2:44:44] it and I put it in the bag and then I take it to the nearest recycling bin in the alley. [2:44:49] The orange bin, I do 30 to 38 of those orange bins a week for the City of Twin Falls and [2:44:55] I'm very happy with what I do to help the environment and I'm against the [2:44:59] shelving the recycling program that's terrible idea and stopping the recycling [2:45:05] programs terrible idea I think we should continue recycling if we have to pay a [2:45:10] small extra fee five dollars a year that's not that much really I could even [2:45:14] do that and I think I'm a good man and I deserve to recycle a lot of people are [2:45:24] recycling and when I go through the alleys or when I go through a recycling [2:45:28] bin if I see trash in the recycling bin I will flip the lid that way the garbage [2:45:33] bin don't take you so it's not contaminated I find a lot of yard waste junk [2:45:39] diapers you know stuff that isn't recyclable in the recycling bin and I [2:45:44] flip the lid so the garbage bin will see it before he dumps it so it's not [2:45:49] contaminated and to answer your question about the recycling program it was going [2:45:54] the landfill for two months. They were taking all the recyclables to the landfill for two [2:45:58] months. They did that. That's a fact. [2:46:01] Which would I explain we did when the prices were exceeding our taxes. [2:46:05] Yeah, they just want to know that they did take it to the landfill for two months of recyclables. [2:46:10] Not just because it was contaminated, because that's a fact. They did take it to the landfill. [2:46:15] And I appreciate your time. You have any questions for me? I'm willing to answer. And [2:46:20] if you guys would like to, maybe one of you guys can come with me any day and I can show [2:46:24] you all the stuff that I do recycle, but only one of you at a time that way, if there's [2:46:29] not a group of people, it might cause me problems with my recycling program. [2:46:33] You know, nobody's going to want a bunch of group of people around there, you sure as [2:46:37] can, you know what I mean? [2:46:38] So, I'm more than willing to take one of you at a time and take you out if you've got [2:46:42] a bicycle because I cover 5 to 10 miles a day. [2:46:46] I appreciate your time. [2:46:47] Do you have any questions for me? [2:46:49] You get my beer. [2:46:52] What's that? [2:46:53] You get my beer can every Wednesday at the plaza. [2:46:56] Oh, yeah, I do the Wednesdays tonight. I'm not ashamed of it [2:46:59] I also pick up anywhere from 500 to 600 cigarettes a night at the Wednesdays tonight [2:47:04] And I bring home and or cans a night every Wednesday [2:47:10] Any more questions? All right [2:47:14] There anyone else who wishes to speak on this item [2:47:18] Most of the public input portion here and turn it over to cancel for some discussion [2:47:28] Oh, there's a spoke tonight. I can recite things some way or not for this [2:47:48] The markets going to change have been unrecycling since 1971. [2:47:53] I'll tell them how far the recycling effort there, which is still going. [2:48:00] But the markets are always contracting and expanding and changing. [2:48:03] The fact that we have since our program started in 2005, [2:48:10] kept 17,000 tons out of the landfill is no small achievement. [2:48:16] But that question of the carbon footprint that they brought up is the real bug, but I can't see how tipping aluminum to Kentucky or wherever it is, makes sense in anybody's world, unless the council would be in favor of shelving the program. [2:48:41] to look for me right now. It's hard to say here from now where the mark is going to be, except there are [2:48:48] markers, potentially some use for plastics. If not, we're going to be having stuff. There's folks. [2:49:05] Chris Reed, I was just wondering if we could maybe answer a couple of other questions that were posed, [2:49:13] have we looked at other alternatives and recruitment? So AF, what is the cost of incineration? [2:49:28] and it's the city kind of looked at that. [2:49:30] My understanding is that the incinerators [2:49:32] are ridiculously expensive, and that's [2:49:35] why there are so few around in the country. [2:49:37] Knowledgeies that are coming out, maybe that's something [2:49:44] that is to go forward. [2:49:46] I've been kind of trying to scroll what is out there [2:49:51] in terms of incinerators. [2:49:54] It's certainly a place that a lot of places are going. [2:49:57] I'm not entirely certain that all Twin Falls is growing. [2:50:01] We're still small by many, many standards, [2:50:03] I'm not certain that we generate enough of a stream to create an incinerator. [2:50:08] I don't think Josh has done a really great work out in projects and stuff like that. [2:50:17] So he might be more in terms of how do you transform this into either an energy or just simply get rid of it better than I. [2:50:24] There was a question about why don't we just ban the creation of plastic bags that are created. [2:50:31] It has legislation that we describe as pre-emptive legislation, and they base restrictions on what [2:50:44] we can and can not as a local government Idaho is what is commonly referred to as a [2:50:55] Dillon Rule State in which our powers are provided to us by the Idaho legislature. [2:51:00] They set the parameters of our decision-making powers, and then we have the ability to make [2:51:04] decisions within those parameters. If it's not contained with those parameters, it's not included. [2:51:12] We'll have to have some conversations with our economic development team, but I'm not directly aware of intentional reachouts that we have done for [2:51:26] in recycling communities bringing most facilities. [2:51:35] to Travis's comment for capacity. We have had several conversations with [2:51:42] companies who utilize recycled eerions for their product stream. [2:51:48] Travis's point, Twin Falls may feel like a booming metropolis to summon this room is not significant enough to. [2:52:00] It's not that there has not been effort, but also maybe comments about [2:52:19] drill investors and grant programs and all those things. [2:52:24] Our door is certainly open to local businesses who would like local investors and local companies that would like to set up ground. [2:52:32] I think the city going into the recycling business is probably not something that's on our agenda. [2:52:39] So as those people come, I would say I think we certainly could look at ways to do that. [2:52:44] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:52:55] Thank you. [2:52:56] So I have a couple of things and I hope I don't jump around too much. [2:52:59] much. For some of you who haven't been at our previous meetings, as we've discussed [2:53:04] this before, if we continue to recycle what we're recycling today in the next 40 years, [2:53:11] we add 50 days to the landfill. The costs we're looking at and the other environmental concerns [2:53:21] takes water to wash the garbage to make it clean to recycle, the fossil fuels to ship [2:53:26] it across the country where half of it still ends up in the landfill because [2:53:31] there's no commodities for it. It's real it's just a tough sell. I believe that if [2:53:37] there was a outlet for it, there would be people ready to build those [2:53:43] facilities and to make that work. Unfortunately in today's world we're not [2:53:48] seeing that. The real key and I think I've come back to this in the past is not [2:53:53] about recycling but it's reducing how do we reduce our use as a city council we [2:53:59] don't have the authority to control packaging what's coming in and how it's [2:54:05] being used it's up to the consumer we have a lot of people who $5 a year seems [2:54:10] like a lot of money to them to ship recycling to have it in an in landfill [2:54:16] anyway it's a hard thing not all of us are on the same plane filled with that [2:54:21] It's difficult because we want to do what's right by our environment, but spending fossil [2:54:29] fuel and water and money to ship things across the country that are really ending up in a [2:54:35] landfill anyway is just not good for anybody. [2:54:38] It's not good for our environment, it's not good for our citizens, the younger people [2:54:43] that are here tonight, you're the ones we're looking to to come up with solutions, to come [2:54:48] up with the inventions that give us a use for these recycling so that we don't [2:54:53] have to throw them away. But in the overall picture 50 days and 40 years is [2:54:59] not a lot of life to add to our landfill. Well I wanted to make sure what Travis said [2:55:12] and more correct terms. Light of a legislature says we cannot ban plastic [2:55:19] bags from the city of Twin Falls. They flat out past the ball of buildings that we can't [2:55:25] I just have a question for Josh Bartle me. [2:55:32] He's really regretting signing up, man. [2:55:38] I know your, you know, I applaud your efforts to utilize our trays to get methane to produce [2:55:47] energy and those types of things that I applaud that effort. [2:55:51] If we shelve it and we send all of this, recycle a little material to the landfill, [2:55:57] wouldn't that actually harm your, that process because none of that is the kind of things that is actually producing methane and unless I'm misunderstood, I understand. [2:56:07] You have to push the whole green button at least. [2:56:13] Mr. Huygens, we're not going to put maybe like a user. [2:56:16] Recyclable material isn't really beneficial for landfogast energy. It doesn't produce methane gas. It does take up space in the landfill, but it doesn't necessarily [2:56:35] Incineration expensive you're talking you know cost for those facilities are very expensive [2:56:47] The closest one is in Spokane, Washington and $110 per ton makes sense to do that [2:57:00] Pass the emission standards, but thank you, Justin. I'm coming down on my option to [2:57:22] to be mostly for the carbon input situation. [2:57:29] I'm concerned if we shelved it, [2:57:32] how do we get started back up? [2:57:36] We take people out of the motion of recycling. [2:57:40] I think we would have a hard time getting it back again. [2:57:48] I love the idea of reducing. [2:57:50] I'm just not, maybe I'm not smart enough [2:57:52] or not, I can't think outside the box [2:57:54] enough like somebody said for us to figure it out as a city because I'm pretty sure [2:58:00] if we tried to pass an ordinance that said something about reducing plastic [2:58:06] on pretty much slightly to figure out a way of tells we couldn't maybe not I [2:58:11] understand the plastic bag was was the direct response to one of the major [2:58:17] plastic bag right factors in the country is in Dromino and I'm sure they [2:58:21] concerned about that industry. Option one I just really struggle with sending [2:58:31] trash to Boise and put it in their landfill and pay the diesel fuel to get it [2:58:36] there. Or if it ends up all the way in Portland and ends up in a landfill in [2:58:40] Seattle, I think most of it I probably ends up in the Boise and I feel I struggle [2:58:44] with that I would rather send it to our landfill and so just before the [2:58:49] Carbonate in print I realize it takes fuel to run the [2:58:54] trucks over to have you as well as it's not a complete difference, but it costs this morning to take it [2:59:02] $64 is [2:59:04] 3750 I'm gonna come down on the I would prefer to go with the option to [2:59:15] Really have a strong program [2:59:20] was to get educated and teach people in some way if we can think outside the box. Maybe the high school students can help us to do that. [2:59:32] Think outside the box to get people recycling in the proper way so that we don't have to send bins. [2:59:39] I appreciate Jonathan. Do you flip and don't let up to kind of give the drivers and heads up to make this not one that they can do? [2:59:47] I said it's got some idea that I am like Chris, I appreciate you, you recycling all the ants [2:59:55] you can end up on the Wednesday night concert because there's a lot of very good souls over [2:59:59] the top and there's a lot of cans so I appreciate your help there. [3:00:03] I would add to your comments great, I too think I could be supportive of option two, one because I think [3:00:13] comments saying how we think about things differently so I don't look at option two so much as about [3:00:21] It's less expensive, or I think it's an opportunity to actually start that reeducation by pulling out the thing that seems to be the most confusing, which is plastic, because while some plastic has some market, but doesn't, plastic has everything from plastic grocery bag to the styrofoam to the all these other things, by reducing it down to three very simplistic things that people know that is. [3:00:51] There is a lot of opportunity, whether it's partnership of the city and PSI, but the high school [3:01:02] I'm terribly impressed with their efforts in that enthusiasm and energy spread to grownups in our community [3:01:11] who actually should know better. So, an option to untrain us from doing the curbside recycling, it gets us closer to a separated recycling stream [3:01:27] extreme because they are at a piece in this carbon footprint. [3:01:37] I actually heard a piece in the radio a couple of weeks ago [3:01:40] about aluminum. [3:01:41] So the cost of shipping that aluminum, [3:01:50] this story was about the actual cost of extraction material [3:01:55] that makes aluminum cans is through the companies now [3:02:02] looking at finding landfills to go. [3:02:15] We can talk about this carbon footprint all the way back [3:02:17] to the beginning of carbon on just about every product [3:02:21] that we have. [3:02:22] It's one thing to say, yes, it's a truck traveling. [3:02:27] It gallons the acid, smells the gallon, and all that. [3:02:32] What's the cost of the trees it takes to make the cardboard? [3:02:37] And all those damn two scenario. [3:02:44] And though it's some concerted education effort, [3:02:47] and it can't just be, you ran some Facebook ads. [3:02:50] It's gotta be something bigger than that, [3:02:52] and if that is a community driven volunteer group [3:02:56] that wants to do it, [3:02:57] that's something we actually put a judge at line item two, [3:03:02] I was in favor of option two when it was first brought out and the reason I am is because [3:03:25] we are still teaching people about recycling but people taught recycling for 30 and 40 [3:03:37] And the things that we have found practices and this single stream is huge New York City. [3:03:53] Everything there just goes in a recycle bin. [3:03:56] No one gives it any thought. [3:03:58] But nobody was ever, and everybody felt good because everybody recycled everything and undue [3:04:09] that information. [3:04:12] So I agree with what Sean was saying. [3:04:15] It's exactly what I think is that if we can get people better information, it's I just [3:04:23] look at all the efforts that Bill at what your department has gone through and how we've [3:04:27] tried to educate people and get rid of paper but yet we're sending bills. [3:04:36] So earlier tonight we were talking about people who didn't know about things because they're [3:04:42] older if they don't get it or see it on the news or read it in the paper, they don't get [3:04:50] that information. [3:04:52] So there is a place for everything and it's awesome how this community is all trying to [3:04:58] come together and figure out what's best. [3:05:01] But I think our greatest asset is having correct information being taught to students because [3:05:09] those kids that go home and straighten their parents out. [3:05:14] You know, it's just how it works. [3:05:15] And so we, but where you can sort trash of a thousand students, [3:05:22] how many sort trash for 50,000 people who have mixed everything [3:05:27] all together. [3:05:28] So I have one. [3:05:30] So I'm definitely in favor of number two, [3:05:32] but I do have a question. [3:05:34] I don't know where I got this idea, [3:05:35] but on the recycling trucks, when those things are tipped, [3:05:40] is there a camera so the driver can see? [3:05:43] That's what I thought, so they know right away, if it's super contaminated, a key recycler, [3:05:52] and I make sure things are cut up and they fit in and all that, [3:05:55] or doors down, what diapers in there, because they just had all their grandkids there. [3:06:02] What I did is everything I just did is ruined. It's of no use to anything, [3:06:09] and that's really frustrating. And so I think people have to know what they're doing. [3:06:14] It's very difficult to have 2,000 people, so that's our biggest hurdle right there. [3:06:23] So I'm also in favor of option two, in fact, getting feedback from citizens. [3:06:35] I haven't had anybody yet tell me they'd like to shelve the entire process and thinking [3:06:42] that getting rid of the items that aren't in the plus column is huge. [3:06:48] I think education, education, education, and this is a perfect use for the New Archway [3:06:56] with 15,000 cars going down show shown every day, [3:07:01] what a great place to help start that education process, [3:07:05] but it needs to be more than Facebook for sure. [3:07:14] Mavis, do you need an action this evening, please? [3:07:20] Where I would move that we modify our recycling program [3:07:34] to the option two as it was presented to us? [3:07:37] Second. [3:07:39] Should my great landing second by Ruth Pierce [3:07:41] to modify the cycling program to the cardboard [3:07:46] and the discussions that happens. [3:07:53] Against the motion, even though I don't have a problem [3:07:58] with it personally, I did have a few citizens [3:08:01] reach out to me who think we need to take a step back similar [3:08:04] to what Linda did and shall but temporarily [3:08:07] and work through some issues before we continue [3:08:10] on down the same path. [3:08:12] And so I would like to see us come up [3:08:14] with other options as well, so I just wanted to clarify why I'm voting no on it. [3:08:20] I'm also part of that. I'm hoping that the PSI understands it. [3:08:29] At least I am in very much in favor if you have a chronic abuser of the recycling [3:08:34] by putting their own things in that they just don't want her to have a can [3:08:38] and take care of it in that matter. [3:08:40] I think certainly the attention of the program and efforts to educate [3:08:48] I think that's, I'm looking around this room at this number of people who spoke tonight. [3:08:54] I'm asking all of you to please be part of that education as well, because you can't [3:09:00] ambient ordinance about the challenges of enforcing the codes we already have on the books. [3:09:06] How on earth are we going to go around and lease 14,000 recycling cans on a weekly basis? [3:09:12] Oh, certainly help everyone will pitch into that education and we'll certainly do our [3:09:18] this staff and as council as well as possible. [3:09:25] There are further discussion. [3:09:35] Sean Baraker? [3:09:35] Yes. [3:09:37] Zand Hawkins? [3:09:39] No. [3:09:39] Reglanting? [3:09:40] Yes. [3:09:41] Bruce Pierce? [3:09:41] Yes. [3:09:42] Mr. Perri? [3:09:43] Yes. [3:09:43] And Chris talking to us. [3:09:44] Yes. [3:09:46] Are our all motion passes? [3:09:47] I'll end just saying motion passes 6 to 1. [3:09:51] Yes. [3:09:52] I really think we need to revisit this in a period of five [3:09:55] like in six months without Marcus and Otto. [3:09:59] I would also say I have no doubt that our utility services [3:10:09] Department reviews this on a daily basis, so I would trust that if there are significant [3:10:13] changes to the program that we would have in that come back before us. [3:10:20] I agree with it. [3:10:21] I think the biggest issue that I know that I heard is really focusing on the carbon footprint [3:10:28] and not the dollar amount. [3:10:30] Not if China starts taking our recycling or we need a good stewards of our community [3:10:37] of our land. [3:10:38] And I believe in Cheyenne said we need to do a re-education on reduced reuse, recycle. [3:10:46] This morning we're on the radio talking about it and Ryan Fight brought up refused. [3:10:53] We need to start saying no to plastics if that's what we want to do. [3:10:57] We need to start saying that this isn't something that we want in our community and that doesn't come from City Council. [3:11:02] That comes from citizens deciding, hey, I'm going to start using a... [3:11:08] I'm going to start using a water bottle over there instead of a plastic bottle and that doesn't [3:11:16] come from the seven of us sitting here. [3:11:18] It comes from 49,000 residents in Twin Falls. [3:11:23] Thank you. [3:11:28] Other business we are actually in the meeting. [3:11:32] Okay. [3:11:47] I shared that with you. [3:11:49] I shared that in my comments earlier that we've spoken to companies who can use these [3:11:52] products and there are challenges as it's single stream so it's not sorted here so then [3:11:57] it goes to Boise. [3:11:58] and get sorted and then they are getting some of that product back for use in these companies. [3:12:03] It's just not coming directly from your garbage can to their company. [3:12:08] And I'd be happy to just to kind of afterwards and talk to you about other opportunities that you may have ideas on. [3:12:15] So with that, however, the meeting is adjourned.