Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2019-04-22, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2019-04-22/ [0:00:07] Good evening, I would like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, April 22nd, and confirm that we do have a quorum. [0:00:14] All seven members of the Council are here this evening. [0:00:17] And next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:00:35] Next on the agenda are Proclamations. [0:00:46] evening I have two proclamations. The first is for Optimus International Youth Appreciation [0:00:52] Week 2019, whereas the vast majority of youth are concerned, knowledgeable and responsible [0:00:58] citizens, and whereas Optimus International and the Twin Falls Optimus Club have developed [0:01:03] and promoted a program entitled Youth Appreciation Week. And whereas the citizens of Twin Falls [0:01:08] have indicated a desire to join the Optimus in expressing appreciation and approval for [0:01:13] contributions of youth. I, Sean Berriger, therefore proclaimed the fourth week of April as Youth [0:01:18] Appreciation Week and Twin Falls, Idaho. By this action, let it be known that we have faith in the [0:01:23] ability of today's youth as they assume responsible roles in the future of mankind. We have a couple [0:01:29] of optimists here this evening, Hannah Scholes, Dennis Boyer, who I will present this to you. [0:01:52] Thank you very much. I appreciate your time. I also wanted to make sure you got the invitation. [0:01:58] We are having an event on Thursday at 1145 at the Stone House, where we'll have each of the honorees come and our mayor is nice enough to come and present a specific. [0:02:12] Coffee is in the proclamation. [0:02:16] Coffee is in the proclamation too. [0:02:18] We're really excited because on that very same day, our own very noble is going to be honored that morning at the Chamber of Breakfast and we feel like this comes full circle. [0:02:28] We feel like these people that we're honoring at noontime are going to be the berry noblix [0:02:35] of the future, so we're pretty excited about them. [0:02:37] So thank you very much. [0:02:38] If you have time in your schedule, we hope you can come. [0:02:41] Thank you, Hannah. [0:02:42] The second proclamation I have this evening is for Arbor Day. [0:02:49] Arbor Day Proclamation, whereas in 1872, J. Sterling Morton proposed to the Nebraska Board [0:02:54] of Agriculture that a special day be set aside for the planting of trees. [0:02:59] Whereas this holiday called Arbor Day was first observed with the planting of more than a million [0:03:03] trees in Nebraska. [0:03:05] Whereas Arbor Day is now observed throughout the nation and the world. [0:03:09] Whereas trees can reduce the erosion of our precious topsoil by wind and water, cut heating [0:03:13] and cooling costs, moderate the temperature, clean the air, produce oxygen and provide habitat [0:03:19] for wildlife. [0:03:20] Whereas trees are a renewable resource giving us paper, wood for our homes, fuel for our [0:03:26] firefighters and countless other wood products. And whereas trees in our city increase property [0:03:30] values, enhance the economic vitality of the business areas and beautifier community. [0:03:36] And whereas trees wherever they are planted are a source of joy and spiritual renewal. [0:03:40] Now, therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim Friday, [0:03:45] April 26, 2019 as Arbor Day in the City of Twin Falls. I urge all citizens to celebrate [0:03:51] Arbor Day and to support efforts to protect our trees and woodlands, and further I urge [0:03:56] all citizens to plant trees to gladden the heart and promote the well-being of this and [0:04:01] future generations. [0:04:02] And Wendy Davis is hiding out in the back. [0:04:08] Do you want a copy of this photocopied one, or do you want the real one on Friday? [0:04:14] I can give you a copy of this one if you would like, or you may be already have it. [0:04:22] You may have already snitched it from me. [0:04:25] Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director would like to tell you about her forecast for a beautiful weather on Friday afternoon as we will be planting trees. [0:04:33] Absolutely, and I see low 70s, possibly. [0:04:40] Maybe cloudy, but you know, if we're gonna have a two-hour birthday, we gotta have a little rain, a little snow, a little mist. [0:04:46] It is notoriously a little challenging weather wise. [0:04:48] That's true, it was actually hot and we needed water, which was like a first. [0:04:53] So I just wanted to invite everybody to join us. [0:04:57] We are holding our Arbor Day celebration at Sonai's Park, which is off of Madrona Street [0:05:05] between Heyburn and Filer. [0:05:07] We're going to do it at four o'clock in the afternoon. [0:05:10] We'll be planting four trees there. [0:05:12] This is a, I think the park is about 3.57 acres, it's a small park, kind of a little hidden [0:05:19] gem back in there. [0:05:21] We've had some older trees that we've had to remove and so we're planning some new ones [0:05:25] to keep that renewal going and this is the first time we've held Arbor Day at Sunrise [0:05:29] Park so we didn't invite anybody to join us for Arbor Day on Friday at 4. [0:05:36] We'll be there to come rain or snow. [0:05:39] That's right. [0:05:40] Yes. [0:05:41] Or wind. [0:05:42] Wind. [0:05:43] Thank you. [0:05:46] Thank you. [0:05:47] I'll get to trust me it's official. [0:05:50] I signed it and everything. [0:05:54] Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:05:58] If there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council and item that is not [0:06:01] on the agenda, now is your opportunity to please come forward. [0:06:05] When you do, if you would please state your name and whether you are a property owner or [0:06:09] resident of the city of Twin Falls and you just touch the microfutus. [0:06:16] The rest says push down there in the middle. [0:06:19] Okay, perfect. [0:06:20] Thank you. [0:06:21] Thank you. [0:06:22] My name is James Parrot and I appreciate this public comment a lot, especially since [0:06:28] I don't see too many people come and take advantage of it. [0:06:31] I did not intend to say so, but we have most awesome parks here. [0:06:36] I can't believe how good the city parks are in Twin Falls. [0:06:40] I've lived in a lot of cities, Chicago, Waterford, Wisconsin. [0:06:44] I grew up over in the Bay Area. [0:06:46] We even have a park that's just wide open green that doubles as a flood control area. [0:06:52] It's really beautiful. [0:06:54] But that's not what I came to talk about. [0:06:56] I came to remind you about opportunity cost. [0:06:59] I'm sure you all know the phrase. [0:07:01] When you go to McDonald's, you spend $10. [0:07:04] You spent the $10 plus you also spent the $10 you could have spent at Subway. [0:07:09] Well, the same thing is true with you guys. [0:07:12] If you go ahead and decide to build a rec center that costs 40 million or 50 million dollars, [0:07:19] that's 40 million that you didn't spend on sidewalks. And we have great parks. I don't believe we need [0:07:26] a rec center at all, but I'm not an expert on rec centers because I want to do in Twin Falls, [0:07:32] but I absolutely am an expert on sidewalks. The one embarrassment your council has [0:07:38] is the sidewalk situation in Twin Falls. It's a very small city. I walk every week to the [0:07:45] movie theater. It's only three miles, but it's literally a disgrace to look at what I got a walk on, [0:07:53] which if it was only me, fine, I don't matter, I'll be dead soon. But really, sidewalks matter to [0:07:59] a city. So please remember the opportunity cost. The paper today talks about how you're going to be [0:08:06] discussing the cost of recycling when you're really making the matters worse. I'm not sure [0:08:12] they're going to conclude that. They're going to talk about a carbon footprint. I'm guessing [0:08:16] they're going to say that our recycling program's really not working. We're trying to reduce [0:08:21] pollution, but with the cost of everything, maybe that's not working. But $90,000 would [0:08:27] buy a lot of sidewalks. It would get at least 90 home front sidewalks. It'd probably get [0:08:32] 45 corners we need corners almost worse than sidewalks and so I really want you to pay attention [0:08:39] To the need for sidewalks and how easy it is to waste money on things that sound good like rec centers [0:08:46] What you really need just I got a great new example [0:08:49] I've always good on Knight Street, but I just tonight went down by mistake popular [0:08:55] I got if you've been on popular between locust and [0:08:58] and elm? [0:09:00] It's almost embarrassing. [0:09:02] It's like street out of a movie. [0:09:04] Yeah, fancy trees, fancy sidewalks, fancy porches, [0:09:08] and then just come one block over that I walk on on Night Street. [0:09:11] Everything is missing, broken up. [0:09:13] There's one guy that's got a beautiful sidewalk. [0:09:15] Anyhow, the point is, when you spend money, [0:09:18] please remember you could have bought sidewalks [0:09:21] with whatever money you spent, and we need them badly. [0:09:24] And now, when you do get around to talking about recycling, I really think that it's [0:09:30] not working and you need permission to think outside the box, but you've got permission [0:09:36] on Friday. [0:09:37] And what happened on Friday? [0:09:38] Something gross, something is going to sound like I'm just joking with you, but literally [0:09:44] the legislative body of the state of Washington put on a desk Friday, put on the governor's [0:09:50] desk. [0:09:51] law, but allows them to compost the elderly, to literally when you die, to compost your [0:09:58] body. [0:09:59] It's literally on the desk, I'm thinking he's going to be to it, but who knows, but what's [0:10:07] that mean to you? [0:10:08] It means you don't have to follow the coastal thinking, you don't have to follow anybody's [0:10:14] thinking. [0:10:15] This is your city, you run the city, don't be afraid to think outside of the box. [0:10:19] If those crazies in Seattle can compost the elderly and legally set it up to do that, [0:10:25] you can think about putting an end to the recycling program because it isn't working [0:10:30] and spend the 90,000 on sidewalks. [0:10:32] Sorry if that was cynical, but I really am serious. [0:10:36] Thank you. [0:10:37] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [0:10:38] I would like to point out, by the way, in the payables tonight, we actually approved three [0:10:44] of our sidewalk reimbursement grant programs. [0:10:47] so there are three properties that have taken advantage of them that we've just [0:10:51] funded and I wish it was a thousand dollars per home front it's not quite [0:10:56] that inexpensive but I appreciate pointing that out and we are that I just [0:11:01] wanted to say we have done some of that with the program that we have now so [0:11:05] thank you there anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening [0:11:09] Chris Stockton, next on the agenda we have the consent calendar, Chris Stockton. [0:11:21] Move those, move for approval as printed. [0:11:26] Second. [0:11:27] Motion by Chris Stockton, second by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar. [0:11:32] Is there any discussion for the council? [0:11:38] Any none? [0:11:39] Amy Roll, call vote please. [0:11:41] Sean Verriger. [0:11:45] Yes. [0:11:46] Thank you, boy. [0:11:47] Yes. [0:11:48] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:11:49] Yes. [0:11:50] Great landing. [0:11:51] Yes. [0:11:52] Yes. [0:11:53] Christopher Reed. [0:11:54] Yes. [0:11:55] Yes. [0:11:56] Motion passes 7-0. [0:11:58] So, if you were here for the alcohol license for Persian coffee shop, the findings of fact [0:12:06] and conclusions of law or the vacation for Germanma LLC, or the special use permit for [0:12:12] Carlin Duncan, or the annual Mother's Day of Fiesta and Senko De Mayo, Special Event [0:12:18] approval or the Magic by Law Enforcement Memorial Service Special Event [0:12:23] approval. Those were all just approved. Next on the agenda under items of [0:12:30] consideration the first is an action item. This is a request to confirm the [0:12:34] city manager's appointment of Mark Holson as the City of Twin Falls City [0:12:39] Engineer. We have Travis Roth, our City Manager. Thank you Mr. Mayor, members of [0:12:42] the Council, Mr. Holton and his family are with us this evening and so we'll ask [0:12:48] came to come forward in a few minutes but before that I'll kind of go through [0:12:53] the process and the formality of what you are asked to do this evening. So section [0:12:59] 1-7-8 states that it is my role as the City Manager to place individuals before [0:13:08] you for consideration for members of our Executive Leadership Team and tonight [0:13:13] to have that opportunity to do so with Mark Holton, who will be our next city engineer [0:13:21] and his term of service will begin sometime towards the end of June, the first part of [0:13:27] July after Jackie has completed her term with us. So Jackie announced that her intention [0:13:36] to retire close to the beginning of this year and shortly after that we started a national [0:13:43] search and that national search allowed us to review 11 applications and before I [0:13:52] go much further yet we're gonna have a great opportunity to celebrate Jackie's [0:13:56] career but as evidence even earlier today at 1130 we still have some work to do [0:14:03] especially when it comes to like master transportation plans and less [0:14:06] type of thing so we're not gonna quite start the band yet because there's quite [0:14:11] a bit of work that we're going to get for our note, of course, in the next few months. [0:14:16] So right now tonight is our process to have you go through and confirm Mark Holton, or [0:14:24] being asked to confirm Mark Holton. [0:14:27] So again, we have received a total of 11 applications, and in that process, we had the opportunity [0:14:34] to interview seven of those candidates. [0:14:41] When we went through this entire process, we had a board that [0:14:45] were viewed the candidates, and then we performed a combination [0:14:48] of both Skype interviews and in-person interviews. [0:14:52] The in-person interviews were reserved for those who were [0:14:54] internal to the organization. [0:14:57] And then the Skype interviews were those who were from outside [0:14:59] of the organization. [0:15:02] In that process, I will tell you that we had the fortune [0:15:05] of really reviewing credentials of some phenomenal [0:15:09] individuals who placed their name into the hat. [0:15:13] And the one thing that really set Mark apart [0:15:17] was the amount of time, effort, and energy he has [0:15:21] in supervising and leading teams. [0:15:24] In fact, those of us who are on the selection committee [0:15:27] initially, which included Laurie Race, [0:15:29] Nichumble, Sean Gretchen Scott, and myself, [0:15:35] really marked at the coaching inventory. [0:15:38] In fact, I really believe that Mark is bringing tools that we will all be able to learn from [0:15:43] when it comes to coaching, mentoring, and leading and developing staff. [0:15:48] And Mark is an entity or a person who is really known to our entity. [0:15:55] He has been with JUB for the past 19 years. [0:15:59] He is a Jerome native and he has led some of the most significant public infrastructure [0:16:05] projects that we've had inside of our city. [0:16:08] He is assisted with the Arsenic Project. [0:16:12] He assisted in our water facility plan, our wastewater facility plan. [0:16:16] He helped with the Auger Falls Project, and he also helped with the Parks and Recreation Project. [0:16:22] So while he is outside of our organization, he has been essentially an extension of our team, serving in the role of [0:16:30] consultant and Mark elected to place his name into the have for consideration and [0:16:36] the committee that helped me go through this process was supportive in us moving [0:16:42] forward with him and so I present to you Mark Holton you serve in the role of [0:16:47] city engineer upon Jackie's retirement which is going to occur in mid to late [0:16:55] June and with that I'd be happy to stand for any questions. Thank you Travis or [0:17:00] any questions for Travis. May you have a follow-up? I think we could give Mark an [0:17:11] opportunity to come up and visit with us. I think we can probably go ahead and [0:17:16] take our actions. I would like to move that we confirm the city managers [0:17:22] appointment of Mark Holson as the city of Twin Falls City Engineer. Okay. [0:17:29] Motion by Suzanne Hockens second by Nicky Boyd to confirm the city managers [0:17:34] Appointment of Mark Holson as the city of Twin Falls City engineers [0:17:39] Give me a roll call, please [0:17:44] Nicky Boyd yes Suzanne Hawkins yes great landing. Yes, Ruth Pierce. Yes, Christopher Reed. Yes. Yes [0:17:53] Yes [0:17:55] 7-0 [0:17:56] Congratulations mark [0:18:09] Thank you Mary Council so my family's here with me tonight a beautiful wife Josie [0:18:14] of 18 years. I'm at oldest daughter, chorus, 16 years old. My son is Luke and he is 14 years old. [0:18:23] My youngest daughter, Myla, is 12 years old. And then see my parents are here as well and my mother [0:18:29] and father also came as well. So nice. Happy to have you here. So yes, I'm grateful and humbled [0:18:42] for this opportunity to serve as a city engineer. As Travis mentioned, we currently reside on the [0:18:48] on the wrong side of the river in your home. [0:18:51] You know, we're lifelong residents of the Magic Valley, [0:18:54] and we really consider twin to be part of our home [0:18:56] and our community. [0:18:57] It's a community that's thriving and it's vibrant [0:19:00] and it's poised for a lot of growth and prosperity [0:19:02] in the future, and I'm just really excited [0:19:04] to be part of the team that gets to work with you [0:19:07] and Travis and Mitch and other leaders within the city, [0:19:10] and then also the engineering department, [0:19:13] many of which I've worked with over the past 19 years [0:19:16] and really have some strong bond relationships [0:19:18] those people. I'm of course working with the citizens really help address some of [0:19:24] the challenges that are going to come with some of the growth that's happening with you. [0:19:27] I'm blessed I just like to thank Jackie she's been a really good friend and [0:19:30] mentor to me and she's been very gracious and willing with her time as we go [0:19:34] through this transition. I want to wish her all the best as she moves to a new [0:19:40] phase of her life. I have some big shoes to feel but I'm looking forward to the [0:19:44] Thank you. [0:19:45] Thank you, Mark. [0:19:47] Any questions or comments from Mark? [0:19:49] Welcome. [0:19:50] Wait until that first meeting when you're in the hot seat and see how it goes. [0:19:56] Thank you, Mark. [0:19:58] Thank you, Travis. [0:19:59] And next on the agenda, we have a presentation. [0:20:02] This is the Southern Idaho Tourism Annual Update from Melissa Bering, Executive Director for Southern [0:20:07] Idaho Tourism. [0:20:08] Come, Melissa. [0:20:12] Is that working? [0:20:16] Yes. [0:20:17] Awesome. [0:20:18] Thank you. [0:20:19] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:20:20] I appreciate your time this evening. [0:20:21] just kind of an annual update to kind of give you an idea of what we've been doing for the past year [0:20:25] as well as what our plans are for the upcoming grant cycle. So I think you guys all have our print [0:20:30] out and I'll run through that and if you have any questions or comments feel free to interrupt [0:20:34] me at any time. So for tourism in the state of Idaho it's the third largest industry it's a very [0:20:40] influential industry but in our region it's a little bit smaller we don't necessarily have as [0:20:44] much as some of the other regions do in the terms of visitor attractions and things to do but we do [0:20:51] are working towards becoming more of that type of destination. [0:20:54] So we've seen a lot of good growth come from the past couple of years. [0:20:58] This last year has been a little bit slower. [0:21:00] We are a little lower on the numbers of vacation rentals. [0:21:03] It's something that we're kind of trying to work through. [0:21:06] There might be some education processes encouraging people to maybe list their homes [0:21:11] for that vacation rental aspect. [0:21:14] But our region compared to the rest of the state, [0:21:17] we have a very minimal amount of those types of properties. [0:21:20] And as the visitor kind of changes and has different trends, [0:21:24] this tends to be where they're going towards. [0:21:27] They want to have more of an authentic experience. [0:21:29] And so some of those branded hotels [0:21:30] aren't necessarily what they're going for. [0:21:33] But so for that reason, plus we don't [0:21:35] have the same type of traffic that we [0:21:37] did the year before for the eclipse. [0:21:39] We're flat, we're up 1.5%. [0:21:42] And that's not terrible considering where hotel collections [0:21:46] are compared to the rest of the state. [0:21:47] but it's not where I would like to be. [0:21:50] Additionally, we're also always looking at ways [0:21:53] to kind of boost the shoulder season [0:21:55] in that winter timeline for lodging collections [0:21:58] because that's really where we're the weakest. [0:21:59] And I do have good news on that end. [0:22:02] November and December, we're both up. [0:22:04] December of 15%, so that's fantastic. [0:22:07] The only thing I can't really tell you [0:22:08] is what's happened since then. [0:22:10] I've gotten a couple of reports from the hoteliers [0:22:12] as far as what they're seeing, [0:22:13] but the lodging collections, [0:22:15] the tax commission is going through different changes. [0:22:17] are trying to figure out where collections are being put in correctly and we just haven't [0:22:22] received those numbers since December so we'll have those information soon and if any of you [0:22:27] would like that information I'd be happy to send that to you. So the 1.5% is just since December. [0:22:32] But so far I think we're trending positive so that's a good thing. Looking back at last [0:22:40] year we collected 885,000 lodging collections and so based on how many [0:22:46] people have come here at $100 average daily rate which is a little high for our [0:22:50] area we can assume about a half a million people have come and spent the [0:22:53] night that doesn't equate those day users but it does you know really try to [0:22:58] bring into the effect of what that type of spending happens because when someone [0:23:02] spends the night they tend to be more engaged in the community do more shopping [0:23:06] die now instead of maybe just a one quick stop and head out. So the total that we can [0:23:12] estimate is $101.7 million in that non-lodging spending. So that's a really good [0:23:17] boost for our economy. You know, tourism is usually fairly low impact and it helps [0:23:22] offset a lot of those costs that even for our citizens and for the state of Idaho as [0:23:27] well. The hospitality industry is also doing very well. We've seen a lot of [0:23:31] restaurants and positive growth throughout the valley. We have about four [0:23:35] new hotels that are in different stages of development so hopefully we'll see more of [0:23:40] those types of things but like I said before hopefully we'll get a few more vacation rental [0:23:44] properties online as that's where kind of that new trend is going for a lot of the people [0:23:48] who are traveling through our area especially the European travelers. [0:23:53] The last part of the sales part of it is for Twin Falls County in general. [0:23:58] As you can see the calendar year sales kind of take up the majority of the sales for the [0:24:05] Magic Valley. I believe it's above 60% when you break it all out on all the [0:24:09] different counties. And so it's 31 million in sales and when you do the same type of [0:24:15] equation you can see that about 72 million in spending is done here in Twin [0:24:20] Falls County. And obviously Twin Falls being the hub of the Valley and even of [0:24:24] the county we can assume that most of those sales happen within the city limits [0:24:28] of Twin Falls. Buell does have some hotels and campgrounds but typically most of [0:24:34] that happens here. So very good things for the City of Twin Falls and I'm very [0:24:38] grateful for the partnerships that you guys have given us. Looking at some of the [0:24:42] campaigns that we've done typically we focused on two top leaders for national [0:24:47] coverage. Those would be waterfalls and national parks. They tend to convert really [0:24:52] well. We hired Roger Brooks to come and kind of look through all of our marketing [0:24:56] stuff and give us an idea of where we should be on that. And so that's really [0:25:00] where we focus on those two top campaigns. [0:25:04] And so that's whenever we look at a sunset ad [0:25:07] or trip advisor or any big placement, [0:25:10] those are either two topics that we really focus on. [0:25:13] And then once we draw them in, [0:25:15] the website is really where we get them to figure out [0:25:18] maybe other things to do add on [0:25:19] to get them to stay a little bit longer. [0:25:21] And our goal this year is to really fulfill [0:25:23] that on an SEO basis. [0:25:26] We have really great content, [0:25:27] but it tends to be in story format [0:25:29] and doing an audit of our website, [0:25:31] I found like Centennial Park wasn't listed in his actual site. [0:25:35] So we talked about Centennial Park with zip lining [0:25:37] or with kayaking, things like that, [0:25:40] but there wasn't the actual listing of just Centennial Park. [0:25:42] So we just wanna make sure we fill those holes, [0:25:45] really garner that organic traffic [0:25:47] because that's something we don't really have to pay for. [0:25:49] And when people are searching, we might as well fulfill [0:25:52] one of our main goals, which is to be that clearing house [0:25:56] of information, and so that's really our goal [0:25:58] this next coming grant as well as probably will start now as we're developing [0:26:03] through the summer to get some of those holes filled. With that we also have [0:26:07] another campaign that we're really focusing on that's going to be more [0:26:10] localized. It's not going to necessarily be on a national level but it's really [0:26:15] more for our target markets. So Boise Salt Lake and Eastern Idaho area is all [0:26:20] going to be focused on our hidden gems. So places that maybe people don't always [0:26:23] think of to go that will really get them to spend a little bit more time [0:26:27] traveling to maybe a few distant corners of the region. And with that, there will [0:26:32] be a photography contest as well as we've partnered with Outdoor Magazine to [0:26:37] essentially write the content on that, provide a digital piece. We'll have [0:26:40] video and it's really going to hopefully create a lot of content and be, it'll [0:26:44] most likely be a very digital, drawn campaign, but our hope is it'll create [0:26:50] kind of a buzz and a stir. And with that, we're also hoping to do some Easter [0:26:54] So for example, at the base of Shoshan Falls, we thought we would give away some, you know, [0:26:59] paddle boards. [0:27:00] So very high dollar value items in that way we can kind of promote it the week before [0:27:06] and then there'll be certain categories that they have to fulfill. [0:27:10] So for example, they might have to provide a hotel receipt or they need to get here between [0:27:14] these certain times and we'll be partnering with some local influencers that also have [0:27:18] a really large social media following. [0:27:20] So hopefully it'll just kind of compound all of those pieces as we get going. [0:27:24] So that's kind of our plan for the summer. [0:27:26] And then on top of it, you can kind of read the next section has all of our listings of [0:27:30] ad placements. [0:27:31] We do the gamut of print, digital, TV, you know, anything you can kind of think of. [0:27:37] We do focus a lot on the Boise, Salt Lake, and Eastern Idaho market, but that's because [0:27:41] we see that as an easy conversion. [0:27:43] But those are kind of our main placements. [0:27:46] A couple of things I already mentioned in the winter collections being up. [0:27:50] We've hosted a lot of social media influencers that seems to be trending very well. [0:27:54] It's helped drive that social media piece. [0:27:57] There's a big movement in Instagram to go get your photo and places it are undiscovered. [0:28:03] As many of you guys know, Idaho is a little bit undiscovered. [0:28:06] We're becoming more discovered, but it's still not maybe not mainstream when you think about [0:28:10] places to go for vacation, so it's a really good market for us to reach into. [0:28:16] We are looking for a big year run off. [0:28:19] I think it's been a little fluctuating between really high, I think we're at 12 or 14 today, [0:28:25] but just last week we're down to 2000 CFS. [0:28:28] So hopefully the Bureau will start pushing more water out as we see the warmer weather [0:28:34] pick up and we'll have some bigger, heavier flows because that's always a crowd pleaser. [0:28:38] Everyone loves the big show show falls water. [0:28:41] So lights and lasers, you guys approved that last week. [0:28:45] thank you again for that. We're trending very, very well, sold out Friday, Saturday, and all of our VIP tickets. [0:28:52] Thursday's 57% sold out, and Wednesday's the slowest with 30%, which I'm, I was never expecting this amount of sellout, so I'm very happy with the [0:29:02] results so far and what we've seen from the community, so I'm very excited on that part. [0:29:08] And then I think, I'm not sure if you guys have seen the proposal for the next event listed. [0:29:12] I know that it's been talked about a little bit, but I can always provide more information [0:29:17] on those what we've got planned for September, but I'm not sure where we are in that presentation [0:29:23] here yet. [0:29:24] So on fiscal year 19, we're really just going to try and focus again on those basics, website [0:29:29] performance, ad placements, making sure that all of our dollars, every single set is paying [0:29:34] off because we do have a significant budget, but we don't at the same time, so we just [0:29:38] to make sure all those dollars are working as hard as they can. Women's travel and adventure [0:29:44] travel are a very much increasing segment. Women's travel especially and Idaho is known [0:29:50] as a very safe state so we fit really well into that market so we're trying to figure [0:29:55] out ways that we can kind of get in there and really turn that audience back to Idaho [0:30:02] and get them to come to our region and spend a few of their tourism dollars in our area. [0:30:06] And then we'll obviously continue focusing on shoulder season because while we're at 90 [0:30:10] percent plus occupancy during the summertime, once the shoulder season of winter months hit [0:30:14] we're 60 or lower depending on what's happening in the valley. [0:30:19] And that's really the big focus is we need to make sure that we have a very robust season [0:30:24] all year round instead of trying to allow some of our smaller businesses who are very [0:30:28] dependent on tourism to only survive during the summertime and then have to figure out [0:30:33] what to do during the wintertime. [0:30:35] So that's kind of our big focus and we'll be continuing working on that. [0:30:39] And as far as, you know, if you have suggestions, we have technically already put our grant proposal [0:30:45] in, but there's always room for the small tweaks and I'll have my presentations coming [0:30:50] up here fairly soon. [0:30:51] So if, again, if there's anything that we can add or, you know, tweak, I'm more than happy [0:30:55] to do that. [0:30:57] For the grants, we receive $377,750. [0:31:02] The majority of that is used for marketing only. [0:31:06] That's just to get more heads and beds, more people here to spend the night in our hotels, [0:31:11] our campgrounds, and even in the vacation rentals now. [0:31:14] And so with that, we have a cash match requirement as well as our operating costs. [0:31:19] And so that's one of the times that we ask our cities and counties to contribute. [0:31:23] And Twin Tolls has always been a really great partner. [0:31:25] So I just want to say thank you and thank you to Parks and Rec for working with us. [0:31:29] Wendy Davis is fantastic and sits on our board and you can see the rest of the list of our [0:31:33] board members here but it's always a pleasure to work with you all and if there's any other [0:31:38] questions I'd be happy to answer them. [0:31:40] Thank you Melissa and Greg Lanting. [0:31:43] Thank you Mayor. [0:31:44] Melissa, I'm a student of an university one and I haven't checked it out myself since I [0:31:49] got back. [0:31:50] I was in the Grand Canyon area about three weeks ago and talking to some people and they [0:31:55] They came to Twin Falls and they couldn't find Shoshun Falls because there's no signs on blue lights. Is that true? I've never paid any attention. [0:32:04] Well, there's any signs saying Shoshun Falls. [0:32:07] There's signs and falls happening. [0:32:09] Okay, well, they said they couldn't see it. [0:32:12] I had their contact information. They said it's going to now we're trying to find Shoshun Falls. [0:32:18] I've never looked inside of Shoshun Falls yet. [0:32:21] Yeah. [0:32:22] Yeah. [0:32:23] So both North and South. [0:32:24] Right. [0:32:25] Right. [0:32:26] I think some of the problems are fairly, or those signs are fairly small, and so I know, [0:32:31] like, we've had lots of people that have been traveling and said they couldn't see them, [0:32:35] and they are out there. [0:32:36] I just think they're a little small, maybe compared to some other larger attractions, [0:32:40] but I do think they're fairly well marked along the way to Shoshan Falls. [0:32:45] It's just, maybe they weren't looking right in the right spot because the legs is pretty [0:32:48] busy. [0:32:49] I just want to give a little bit of a shout-out to Melissa, so I also serve on the Idaho Travel [0:33:02] Council as our region's representative and Melissa's grant presentation and the marketing [0:33:09] program is always touted as one of the best in the state so we should be very proud of that [0:33:14] recognition of getting great value out of those limited dollars and helping to drive more visitors [0:33:20] to you Melissa. [0:33:21] Thank you. [0:33:22] I appreciate it. [0:33:23] Any other questions or comments? [0:33:25] All right. [0:33:26] Thank you. [0:33:27] Thank you. [0:33:31] And next on the agenda is an informational item. [0:33:33] We have an update on the municipal powers outsource grants process from Mandy Thompson, [0:33:39] our grant and community relations manager. [0:33:41] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:33:43] I will be brief, but I just wanted to give you a quick update on where we are with this, [0:33:49] the MPOT process for this year. [0:33:51] year. As you recall, we had several conversations back in 2018 about the [0:33:57] M-PUG program and some potential changes that could be made to make the awarding [0:34:05] of the grant funds a little bit more efficient. And in November, you all [0:34:09] elected to make several of those changes. And I had the opportunity to meet this [0:34:13] morning with representatives from 11 nonprofits here in the Valley. One of the [0:34:20] changes we made to the program was that they would have to attend a mandatory pre-gram meeting [0:34:24] if they wanted to apply for funds. [0:34:26] So we put that out, Judge Palmell, we put that out in a PSA and it was in the newspaper [0:34:32] and left folks to know if they wanted to come. [0:34:35] And then I also personally contacted anyone who had previously received an MPOT from us in [0:34:39] the past. [0:34:41] So as I said, representatives from 11 organizations, a couple which are new, attended the meeting [0:34:47] today and it was very well received. [0:34:49] think that those attendance appreciated getting first-hand knowledge about the [0:34:54] changes to the process and also just a little bit of reasoning behind why we [0:34:58] made that or why you all made the changes that you did. And so moving forward just a [0:35:05] quick reminder that we have a very strict requirement for them to make a direct [0:35:10] link and tie it as a strategic plan. They will be limited to no more than ten [0:35:16] $10,000 in their requests and there will also be no partial funding. [0:35:21] So with that I asked the folks that were there today to be very mindful of the budgets that [0:35:28] they were creating and reminded them that the funding is limited. [0:35:31] So if you need $10,000 and you can show a need, ask for $10,000. [0:35:36] If you can't show a need or you don't necessarily need that much or have other sources of funding [0:35:41] that could cover some of those costs and those dollars. [0:35:46] Be mindful of that because if you ask for 10, [0:35:49] maybe only need five of you, [0:35:50] or maybe you're gonna end up with zero at the end. [0:35:53] So I think everyone understood the intent [0:35:56] behind that request. [0:35:58] So just the same amount, [0:36:00] limitation as in previous years on grants, 10,000. [0:36:03] We've never had a limitation on grants. [0:36:05] Folks, applicants have come to us [0:36:08] and asked the GAMA of I think the smallest award [0:36:11] we have were made with $1,000 and we've had applications that have asked for 50 or 60,000, [0:36:17] which as you know is more than half of what we have available to award in the first place. [0:36:22] And the idea being if they're not, they'll be a little bit more mindful hopefully and what [0:36:30] they're asking for and what they say they're going to do because they have that limitation. [0:36:34] And that's a fairly, actually a fairly standard practice with smaller grant programs is to [0:36:39] just have a limitation of how much you can ask for, or how much you know, kind of an up-to amount. [0:36:45] So, a few dates to go over with you all very quickly. May 15th is when the applications will be due here at City Hall. [0:36:55] That will give Shane and no varsity attorney a few days to go through and make sure that all of those applicants that have applied are eligible. [0:37:03] And just a quick reminder, the applicant themselves can be eligible, but if they propose a program [0:37:08] that is not followed within the purview of Idaho Code, then that would then be deemed ineligible. [0:37:15] So it just gives the chain a little bit of time to go through and make sure that all [0:37:19] applications and programs that are being proposed are eligible. [0:37:23] I will then gather all of the applications and get those to all of you by May 20th. [0:37:30] And then you will have the, let's see, eight days to score those applications based on a [0:37:36] very simple rubric. [0:37:39] That matrix will give you the opportunity to look at their eligibility and whether or [0:37:42] not they did make that direct tie, their demonstration of need, whether or not this is [0:37:47] a duplication of service that they've had shown some demonstrated outcomes and some ways [0:37:53] in which to measure those outcomes and then a budget. [0:37:57] Then I will ask that you have those all back to me by May 28th, and I will compile the [0:38:02] scores. [0:38:03] And those will be included in your council packets. [0:38:07] And then the traditional MPOT meeting will be placed on Monday, June 3rd. [0:38:12] And you will have again, if you're just with all of the applications, as well as that matrix [0:38:17] and how each of the applicants, how they scored, and then it will be your opportunity [0:38:24] to then make those awards at council. [0:38:28] as I explain today, this is a new process, and there might need to be some tweaks as we go through, [0:38:36] which you do have the opportunity to do, but I do think that this is a good step towards making it a little bit more of a business meeting [0:38:46] and less of you all having to try to figure out ways to give everybody a little bit of the funding. [0:38:52] And then just a quick reminder, we have $85,000 available for the funds, because if you recall, [0:38:59] we took a transfer out of the process last year, we utilized a portion of the MPOG funds [0:39:06] to provide them with a grant match, excuse me, for their federal transportation dollars [0:39:12] that they apply for. [0:39:13] Any questions or comments from Andy? [0:39:20] I do. [0:39:23] Ruth, please join up. [0:39:25] Thank you very much. [0:39:26] I'm very looking forward to the new process, and it will make it a lot easier and maybe [0:39:34] not so emotional. [0:39:35] So thank you for all your hard work. [0:39:38] Thank you. [0:39:39] I also just want to say thank you. [0:39:41] I know this hasn't been an easy process. [0:39:42] I know that we've made it a little more challenging on you, so thank you for taking time and [0:39:43] energy to get this done and work with those individuals and those companies, those nonprofits and [0:39:44] this process. [0:39:45] So thank you. [0:39:46] Thank you. [0:39:47] Thank you. [0:39:48] Thank you. [0:39:49] Thank you. [0:39:50] Thank you. [0:39:51] Thank you. [0:39:52] Thank you. [0:39:54] Thank you. [0:39:55] Thank you. [0:39:56] office in this process, so thank you. [0:40:01] Thank you. [0:40:03] Thanks, Mandy. [0:40:07] Next on the agenda we have an informational item. [0:40:10] This is a recycling history for Twin Falls, a new conversation regarding market issues, [0:40:16] costs, and the carbon footprint factor. [0:40:18] We have Bill Baxter, our utility services supervisor, and I Nancy countant. [0:40:27] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:40:30] This continues to be fascinating to me. [0:40:33] I would say thank you for the opportunity, but I'd like it to settle down a little bit. [0:40:40] So just to review my comments, I won't go over them extensively, because Jason and Mike [0:40:47] are here from PSI to show you their PowerPoint presentation and some specifics about our [0:40:52] existing program. [0:40:55] The existing circumstances of the recycling market and the costs associated with our current [0:40:59] single stream. Recycling now do call for a shift in the conversation in order that we [0:41:06] be certain to address those factors that give a clearer view of the success of our efforts [0:41:11] to recycle. As a first step in broadening our discussion we have begun to review the full [0:41:16] process of our current recycling from curbside to end point of use and also to open the conversation [0:41:23] on the carbon footprint or the green impact of what we're doing with that I'm going to [0:41:32] simply allow the rest of the written presentation to stand and I'll let Jason and Mike step up [0:41:38] if I can get this to work like Jeremiah told me it would okay sure this is the opportunity [0:42:08] short guys. So one of the things we wanted to address and know in meetings past this kind [0:42:20] of come up is where does our recycle actually go and what does it happen? Does it get shipped [0:42:27] off and half of it gets land filled down the road and we've been doing a ton of research [0:42:34] for the last month. Trips to Boise trying to figure out exactly where where our commodities [0:42:41] actually end up going and it's kind of made me feel like you're doing some [0:42:45] private investigating but it's it's been it's been kind of eye-opening to see [0:42:49] actually what happens to it so what we're gonna talk about today is kind of the [0:42:55] recycle cost breakdown you know and what the materials are actually in the [0:43:00] cards and the commodity breakdown of what the price is for each commodity [0:43:08] and once it's sorted where does it actually go to and kind of how much this [0:43:15] will extend the life of our landfill because that's important I mean you guys [0:43:18] everyone always talks about that is hey we want to extend the life of our [0:43:23] landfill so what what are actually the facts how long does it can extend why [0:43:27] the life of our landfill all right so if you're looking at a recycling cost [0:43:44] breakdown. Magic Valley recycling here in Twin. They bail all of our recycling and [0:43:52] that's $30 a ton. The shipping freight is $40 a ton and those are fixed costs. [0:43:57] Whether we're making a ton of money on recycling or whether we're paying a [0:44:02] much to get rid of it, those costs are not going to change. The SORC Center right [0:44:07] right now through the first quarter of 2019, it's very between $70 and $100 a ton and right [0:44:15] now it looks like it's more at that $70 range and we're trying to work different avenues [0:44:21] to make sure that we keep it at that low cost, which isn't really a low cost, but as low as [0:44:28] we can get it, Twin Falls recycles about 120 tons every month, so there's 120 tons that [0:44:36] are not going to landfill. That's the rate through this first quarter of 2019. [0:44:43] You know, so what's in the cart? 37% of that is cardboard. OCC cardboard. And this is by [0:44:53] weight too. This isn't by volume. Mixed paper, 43%, 10 cans, 2%, aluminum, 1%, plastic, [0:45:02] 6, 6, and trash at 11%. So that's that 11% that could be just [0:45:09] Plastic that is the rock kind of plastic could be a number [0:45:13] It also could be trash right stuff to just absolutely never should have been in their diapers. Y'all are pretty whatever it is [0:45:21] But 11% now to kind of put that into perspective where we were [0:45:27] About six months ago [0:45:29] five months ago [0:45:31] We were at about 25 percent. So starting the the program back up [0:45:37] There was definitely a curve there and really and so we've seen a great improvement [0:45:43] By the residents and so that's a great thing. Let's see. So if we look at a commodity breakdown [0:45:54] Cardboard [0:45:55] $30 a ton. That's a ton. That's actually what what we are paid for that product [0:46:01] Mix paper we have to pay $50 a ton [0:46:04] a recycle mix paper big number a thousand dollars a ton for aluminum and [0:46:12] if we could just recycle aluminum I think we'd be all be happy plastics five [0:46:17] tin cans 145 and then trash we all know that we pay 3750 here but because this [0:46:25] is sorted in Boise it goes to eight a county and it's sixty five dollars a [0:46:30] ton for that trash that is pulled out of there on the sort line so where does [0:46:36] our material go. If you look at our route drivers that are in twin, they take it to Magic Valley [0:46:45] Recycling, it is bail. Our guys average about 35 miles a day, going through the city back [0:46:51] and forth, making sure we pick up those, every customer, and those trucks to put an [0:46:56] introspective get a mile and almost two miles to the county. Not very good, not a Prius. [0:47:05] So just to kind of put that into perspective, we use about 420 gallons on that truck, those [0:47:11] trucks every month of diesel fuel. [0:47:14] Yeah, and if you guys can look, this is actually a picture that was taken last month. [0:47:23] If you guys notice, there is a lot of contamination in there, but there's where you get to 11%. [0:47:29] There's some styrofoam, some different plastic that's not, it's more wishful recycling. [0:47:33] Yes, it's plastic, but it's not patent number one or number two. [0:47:38] And this was actually taken from an area that generally was not, they're not recycling advocates, [0:47:45] kind of the downtown alleys area where sometimes it's not the greatest recycling product. [0:47:51] And, but it's improving big time. [0:47:54] So, I was saying they bought a send there anyway. [0:47:56] Always a good thing. [0:47:58] Always. [0:47:59] So if we're looking at our cardboard, where does that go? [0:48:08] And so from there, Western recycling will send that after it's sorted. [0:48:13] It's sent to Springfield, Oregon, and then there's a couple of different mills in Longview, Washington. [0:48:20] So those are all right around 600 miles away. So you have to look at, you know, if you're talking about carbon footprint, that's 600 miles. [0:48:28] It's six miles to the gallon because of tractor trailer going down the highway. [0:48:32] And you're looking at right around 100 gallons of fuel to get our product there. [0:48:38] You know, keep in mind that we do between four and five loads altogether every month. [0:48:44] So if we were to, you know, take a quarter load of cardboard that we produce and ship it, [0:48:51] this is all mixed in with other communities recycling as well. [0:48:55] And that's sorting is taking place here in Twin Falls, that's getting it down. [0:49:00] The sorting is actually taking care of everything done in Boise. [0:49:04] Okay, so they're just bailing the mixed stuff that they used to. [0:49:09] Yes. [0:49:10] So the mixed paper, if you guys just remember back, this is what we actually truly pay and drives, [0:49:20] and it's our largest percent of what's actually in our recycle bin, [0:49:25] is 30 to 35 percent of that stays. [0:49:28] Domestic, the rest actually gets exported. [0:49:32] And again, those are right at that 600 mile mark to get to where they need to be shipped off. [0:49:37] I think it would be good to remind everybody what mixed paper really is. [0:49:42] Yeah, and mixed paper is essentially any kind of paper that's not cardboard. [0:49:47] You're talking about newspaper, newsprint, junk mail, all those things. [0:49:52] But, you know, any things school work from the kids when they bring it home. [0:49:57] Magazines? [0:49:58] Magazines, any kind of paper like that. [0:50:07] I'm sorry to back up one side so the piece of that that's exported where is that getting [0:50:12] exported to now that China's not taking that anymore right so yeah Philippines [0:50:19] it's hard to tie a line but there are some international markets that are [0:50:24] so safe but that seems to be drying up as well hence the $50 a tonne to recycle it [0:50:32] Now tin cans, that goes to Portland Oregon, can add aluminum cans, they have a long trip, [0:50:46] they coat a Kentucky, but that's where they'll use it. [0:50:49] And if you think about how many cans it actually takes to make available of those, there's a lot there. [0:50:58] So when we were able to tour the plant and take, in fact, all these pictures are taken from their plant there in Boise [0:51:05] to see the sheer volume of that that comes through that plant is amazing. [0:51:12] So plastic goes to West Rock in Portland, Oregon, and then also the plant in Logan, Utah, [0:51:20] a little bit unreliable as far as what they can take and when they can take it, it'll [0:51:24] be nice if we can take it there all the time because it's a lot less distance to get to, [0:51:29] but we can't seem to rely on them to take it what we need it to. [0:51:38] So that last 11% goes to travels in Ada County Landfill, and it's already traveled to the [0:51:46] sorting facility there and when it's sorted, all the rest of the stuff that is non-recyclable [0:51:50] gets landfilled there. [0:51:54] So some good news on the horizon. [0:51:56] Their waste management is $16 million into Salt Lake City, Murph, where they can sort, [0:52:04] and that should actually stabilize and drive down the price for us, even though we probably [0:52:11] are going to ship, it will still go west. [0:52:14] There's a lot more, a lot more city's [0:52:20] that will actually send it to Salt Lake [0:52:22] and that should kind of stabilize the MRF [0:52:26] that we do use. [0:52:30] So saving landfill space, so milling reviewed, [0:52:32] that's where all pretty much all the Magic Valley trash [0:52:37] ends up at. [0:52:39] They take in 250 tons per year, or 250,000 tons per year. [0:52:45] And they have about 40 years of life left. [0:52:49] They also, I'm talking to them today, [0:52:52] they have the ability to probably get another 40 years [0:52:56] after that, but as of right now, [0:52:58] it is permitted for another 40 years. [0:53:01] So if we're talking about the diverting, [0:53:03] the Twin Falls recycling is gonna save about, [0:53:06] essentially a little over a day, a year, [0:53:09] 50 days of space in that landfill [0:53:12] is what we're saving by recycling. [0:53:17] I was one of those that I didn't know what it was gonna be, [0:53:20] but 15 minutes, 40 years. [0:53:28] No, it's kinda, it's shocking that that's the number. [0:53:42] So I kinda skipped over this on the slide. [0:53:46] The one thing that we're seeing, [0:53:48] and it's just, it's an option. [0:53:49] It's not anything, we're not pushing anything here [0:53:51] because we wanna, we wanna pick up whether it's recycling, [0:53:54] whether it's trash. [0:53:56] We're here for you guys to pick it up. [0:53:58] But we're seeing communities that are deciding to take [0:54:02] the mixed paper, we're paying $50 a ton for this. [0:54:06] Let's not recycle that. [0:54:09] Let's go ahead and put that into the trash. [0:54:10] Let's do cardboard, aluminum, and kind of scaling back [0:54:15] their recycled efforts. [0:54:18] And so we're seeing that. [0:54:20] There's a lot of communities that are going that way. [0:54:23] So it's just kind of one of those options. [0:54:24] something to think about, like you guys don't have anything else to worry about, but... [0:54:29] Can I ask a question? The mixed paper, or if it comes at another time, I want to know the decomposing time of mixed paper when it's stirred in the landfill, so when we get to that part, I would really like to find out how quickly that decomposes and melts into the situation. [0:54:55] That was a great question. [0:54:57] Well, it was interesting. [0:54:59] They had the benefit of being at the CSI sustainability fair today. [0:55:03] And PSI brought a phenomenal presentation of treats and they had a real crowd over there. [0:55:08] So they got to talk to a lot of people about this. [0:55:10] But Nate from Southern Idaho Solid Waste was at the table just behind us. [0:55:16] And in trying to figure out how my certain areas of the landfill were not generating the amount of methane [0:55:24] they were expecting for their electricity generation system they have fired up. [0:55:29] He said they drilled some test holes in the landfill and they went down to 20 years ago [0:55:35] in some parts of that and found newspaper they could still read. [0:55:39] He said that, you know, it's no oxygen down there, it's dry, it's just sitting there. [0:55:49] So depending on where the landfill is and in what circumstances it gets compressed [0:55:56] pressed into a landfill itself, that's just kind of a clue that some of it doesn't go away very fast at all. [0:56:06] Chris Reed, a quick question for you in talking about one of these factors that would mean that they would have to start putting it into garbage can, not the recycling. [0:56:19] So another education process, because if not, it's going to Boise and we're paying more money. [0:56:26] Boise for it to get put into their landfill. [0:56:32] You guys decided to do something like that. [0:56:34] You want to be a huge educational process. [0:56:37] Yeah, I mean, we've taken what? [0:56:40] Once eleven is good, [0:56:44] nine people, what kind of paper can go and what can. [0:56:48] I think the question at this point, [0:56:57] and there is more information we can gather. [0:57:00] Transportation, carbon footprint, [0:57:03] the other pieces of information I gave you [0:57:05] are from studies that are much more complete. [0:57:08] The transportation piece tends to be around 1% as far as the carbon footprint for transportation of the product. [0:57:16] It goes up some if you're producing a product because you have further to haul the raw material. [0:57:22] But overall, the question is going to be which of the products we currently accept, which are easily identifiable. [0:57:34] And we say, these are what you put in. [0:57:39] Cardboard is, seems fairly obvious as a plus, aluminum and metal cans. [0:57:46] And I think if we could figure out a way to improve the use of the recycling for aluminum cans, [0:57:55] which surprises me, but the statistics I've seen is about 45% of aluminum cans actually get recycled, [0:58:02] the rest of its inner landfill. Nate also told me, and this fascinated me, [0:58:09] down in the Salt Lake area, as well as a number of other places, [0:58:12] they are beginning to mine landfills that are filling up, [0:58:16] and dig up the metals and things that have value [0:58:22] from previous landfilling efforts. Mill, that product, [0:58:27] and they're creating a whole while they do that for the new stuff coming in. [0:58:33] That just blows me away. That cannot be cheap. [0:58:36] They'll back to your proposal to, uh, just include metal, aluminum, and cardboard. [0:58:41] Removing all plastics, including the, used to be sacred number one and two recycling that, that has no market then. [0:58:48] If there is a market there, it's a, it's a positive on the screen. [0:58:52] But the important thing to remember is those are positive numbers as to the value of those products per ton. [0:58:58] It does not mean, as Jason and Mike and I talked about today, that we will go to making money again. [0:59:07] That will help cover the costs of the sorting of the transportation. [0:59:12] And I think Jason said we'd be fortunate, although it's probably possible, with enough volume of the materials with value, [0:59:23] The poll are recycling costs down to in the neighborhood of the landfill, but that goes [0:59:30] back to education. [0:59:31] It goes back to those people we can't seem to contact and say this is what the card is [0:59:36] for. [0:59:37] This can't get through to them, but the important thing was to come before you with some more [0:59:44] information about where the product was going and thanks to Jason and Mike for taking that [0:59:49] in that tour and identifying those sources but under your first proposal [0:59:57] that would not preclude us from sometimes should the market turn around to [1:00:01] re-accept those unusable non recyclables now that's correct it's a [1:00:07] flexibility it we we recycle what makes sense and as more things make sense [1:00:12] should that occur it would open that door seems to me that one of the drivers [1:00:19] of the cost is less about what is getting recycled and more of a process. [1:00:27] So, the fact that we have mixed stream in the first place, it has cost. [1:00:32] It has a transportation cost because it has to go someplace to get sorted, as a sorting [1:00:37] cost because you have to get it all separated, and a portion of that is trash. [1:00:45] That has a cost to potentially limiting the things that should go in there to maybe assist [1:00:55] I think frankly I can remember aluminum cans, tin cans, and cardboard pretty easily. [1:01:01] If that's what we were to limit to, use those significant costs with the end of the market. [1:01:13] So, since that gets a little closer. [1:01:16] As we discussed previously, though, one of the concerns I think is [1:01:21] we don't want to un-citizens in what we're trying to do. [1:01:28] If we think things may come around again in another six months or so. [1:01:34] So that is challenging. Do you think it's a bit eye-opening though? If you're looking at the broader [1:01:42] We're having this conversation on Earth Day [1:01:46] But you're having this this discussion about [1:01:50] being kind but [1:02:02] things all over the place [1:02:04] And I think that a carbon footprint for lack of a better term for it [1:02:10] Probably is a little more significant [1:02:13] We're probably doing more harm than good to get the product to the place that it needs to [1:02:18] to do the good thing. It's important that some of these things happen, but there is certainly [1:02:26] a cost back, so it's a struggle. [1:02:28] I just have to tell you, I have still blown away at saving 50 days of life in the landfill [1:02:35] in 40 years of recycling. When you wrap your head around that with the cost of transporting [1:02:40] it and the pollution we're doing by getting the recycling goods to where they need to be, [1:02:46] But it really makes you wonder what is the right choice? [1:02:50] That's true. [1:02:52] One of the sheets I gave you talks about the carbon footprint of making new aluminum from [1:03:00] raw product. [1:03:01] I think that has to be a part of the conversation. [1:03:04] Because if we just look at what we're doing with what has already been produced and seen [1:03:10] out of line, whether it's whether Twin Falls can make that kind of an impact. [1:03:17] I think Travis has pointed out, you know, we're minuscule. [1:03:22] Is it worth not spending that money? [1:03:25] So I guess that goes back to the reduce. [1:03:28] Bingo, right. [1:03:29] That is the reason that's the first thing on the list. [1:03:32] I haven't seen us as a city or as a city council [1:03:35] come up with some really good, clever ideas on reducing, [1:03:38] you know, something, maybe some kind of advertising [1:03:42] or, I don't know, I know the city employees [1:03:45] had their contest for that month [1:03:46] to see what they could reduce. [1:03:49] Maybe look at something like that [1:03:50] and introducing it to the community. [1:03:52] I'm just thinking I'm loud right now, honestly, [1:03:55] but we need to do something to encourage the reducing. [1:04:00] And it's a big topic among manufacturers, [1:04:04] Coca-Cola and Pepsi, I think, [1:04:05] are starting to pursue some kind of a thing. [1:04:08] Problem is all that's out there beyond our control. [1:04:10] I understand with an uncertain future. [1:04:13] So we certainly are pleased to take additional questions. [1:04:18] I think PSI's gotten a nice launch on at least where does this stuff go. [1:04:22] Carbon footprint of that fuel use, just some numbers I ran after Jason gave me this information. [1:04:31] The Bernigallen of Diesel is about 22.38 pounds of CO2, though we're talking the trucks driving around town each day, 448 pounds of carbon dioxide. [1:04:49] Yet the plastics are too gap long to be Washington. [1:04:56] Let's see here that number was 8 pounds of CO2. [1:05:05] What that's doing is putting that carbon into the air, warming the atmosphere if you're somebody who believes we are affecting it by putting more carbon in there than what naturally occur. [1:05:17] Those are just the issues. At what point in time, give up on a program because the cost exceeds the benefit to this city at this point. [1:05:29] I think that's why Travis wanted this information out there. [1:05:33] America is one of the most wasteful countries in the world that we made a heck of a lot of [1:05:38] process since that end from this day called Earth Day 1970. I'm dog unpronged that since [1:05:45] we started our recycling in 2010 we put in, say, more than 17,000 tons from the landfill [1:05:52] at that time the economy was such that we were actually a turning a little profit. I want [1:05:58] to remain flexible so that the generation or two [1:06:02] has learned that recycling is part of life [1:06:05] as opposed to throwing plastic out the windows [1:06:07] and then it doesn't make any difference [1:06:10] with the question. [1:06:11] Keep that ethic there. [1:06:12] We remain flexible on a single stream [1:06:15] that's recycling to add as the market changes [1:06:18] or hopefully the what my district is gonna start changing [1:06:22] some of that wasteful plastic [1:06:23] and then throw the recycling program out to me. [1:06:28] of the 2019 America that I have a kinship with, it's unacceptable. [1:06:36] Great landing. [1:06:37] Well, what I find very interesting gentlemen is that this is my background is in education, [1:06:46] and we spend an awful lot of time in the schools putting little blue bins in the corner and having every kid put every piece of paper [1:06:54] in that blue bin so we can recycle it. [1:06:57] Now, we're not recycling paper doesn't make sense, so it's hard to think of all those years of education doing that, and now we're sitting here and just finding out. [1:07:07] But by the way, I really appreciate where everything's going, and the amounts of it, and what we're paying, or getting, and that was valuable information we haven't had in the past. [1:07:20] That's the first time we've had that, and I certainly appreciate it. [1:07:24] I mean, I know we can't make a decision tonight because it's not listed as an action item. [1:07:30] But since I would like to continue with what we can, those that make sense, [1:07:37] I would certainly be willing to look at the future as I know we started getting this process. [1:07:42] We already want staff to go. [1:07:45] I would like to see whether we could establish a recycling program that was cardboard, aluminum, and tin cans, and then as others make more sense, we can add them back here. [1:07:56] We could certainly have to have an educational program to get people to understand, and that may mean every can. [1:08:05] They need a big sign for them. I don't know what it may mean. [1:08:10] If we lower our costs to our gentlemen who spoke to us before the meeting, you have to [1:08:18] think of water, sewer, garbage, and water, sewer, garbage as a separate business. [1:08:23] The money we save here we can't use on sidewalks because it comes from a different fund. [1:08:29] It comes out of people's checks they write to us for their utility bills. [1:08:34] That sidewalks has to come from other funds. [1:08:37] So, I'm willing to take a look at that. [1:08:41] I don't know if the others are in that category or not, [1:08:44] but that seems like a logical path forward to me. [1:08:49] I could be wrong, it happened before. [1:08:52] Nicky, we can hardly get into that data that you presented. [1:08:56] Yes, that's easy to do. [1:08:57] I have a comment and we can email it to each of you. [1:09:01] Nicky, do you have a comment? [1:09:05] I am wondering if perhaps I have always [1:09:08] been a huge recycling fan, but as we [1:09:14] go through the evolution of society, and we know now things we didn't know before like Greg was talking about. [1:09:22] I think we need to be less wasteful, and one of the ways is to reduce, and part of reducing is purchasing less. [1:09:36] That is not something that we can tell people how to do. We can just implement it in our own homes really. [1:09:44] And that affects a lot of things, that affects business, that we're gonna have to learn how to do things different, [1:09:52] but I cannot believe the paper situation, because there's not one person that I don't know, [1:10:01] that when you say cardboard, it's cardboard and paper, and it's the junk mail, it's everything, everything that feels like it's made out of paper. [1:10:13] paper, and that is the good recycling. That's the stuff that people feel really good about. [1:10:20] The magazines, the old catalogs, whatever you're dumping tons of that in there, and that's [1:10:25] the good clean stuff, and that's what's cost me this money. And I just think I would [1:10:32] really love to come to the landfill, and I would like to see for myself. I've wanted [1:10:37] to do that. I've never gotten around to it, and I'm pretty motivated. I think landfills [1:10:41] have become state-of-the-art places where they have a lot of things in place. I feel [1:10:47] pretty bad that the the trash has to be shipped somewhere for another place to [1:10:54] sort it and then they're gonna put it in their landfill. I don't know the whole [1:11:00] system's like I said I've always liked recycling but I think we are in a broken [1:11:05] down what we thought was true perhaps isn't and there's got to be a whole [1:11:10] different way of doing things maybe some consensus so first of all thank you [1:11:23] to you and your team this was eye-opening I think for most people who looked over [1:11:28] this I know for me knowing that off goes to Kentucky to get recycled and [1:11:38] that's kind of ridiculous that we're spending that kind of to save on one [1:11:44] thing we're spending that carbon footprint gas however you look at it I [1:11:50] I do think that as a council as a city looking at alternatives to Nikki's point and tell people if they're going to drink out of a plastic bottle or if they're going to do something, a regular cup, whatever. [1:12:04] But I do think it would be a good opportunity for us to look at some different alternatives, reduce, reuse, those types of things. [1:12:13] Whether we we can be an example as a council as a city. Maybe work with some of our partners [1:12:19] I think that's an alternative. I would like to take some time and look over this and think about it because this is eye-opening [1:12:28] Realizing that this waste [1:12:31] Recycled was our traveling and just the country this is one of the things that [1:12:42] We could check out but Josh Palmer and I was standing at the sustainability fair today. He said that [1:12:50] aluminum recycling plant in Oregon that he was familiar with shut down because of energy cost and [1:12:57] So that's why Kentucky's on the list. There's is pretty cheap back there. I understand [1:13:03] But seems like everybody's aluminum cans are going to Kentucky because there is no longer a place on the west coast [1:13:09] But it begs the question. Yeah, does it make sense? [1:13:14] Who out there's the person ready to build a plant here and take care of it? [1:13:19] Early there's an opportunity. [1:13:27] So, sounds like generally the council would like to digest some of this data a little bit more, [1:13:33] but potentially in the near future to come back with some perhaps an action item [1:13:40] if we wanted to make changes to or would you like direction from another conversation? [1:13:45] I'm looking at Travis for staff contemplation here. [1:13:49] here. So we felt that in past conversations that the process or the [1:13:57] information you're receiving really talking about the glowing aspects of recycling [1:14:01] and we challenged Bill and yes I share the rest of the story and I think that [1:14:07] this is that rest of the story that that word narrative that needed to be told [1:14:11] recall that had the conversation of increasing rates it was unanimous and [1:14:21] significant of individuals that wanted to come forward that evening across all [1:14:26] different spectrums and generations about the importance of recycling. So what I [1:14:34] would say is it's probably important to have additional information but I also [1:14:43] think it's important for this presentation to occur again and host it [1:14:48] as more of a public hearing so that you can once again capture that public input [1:14:54] and help drive that decision forward. [1:14:58] We wanted to continue to provide information to you [1:15:02] as we approach the budgeting season, [1:15:06] because as we go into budgeting, [1:15:07] that's what we want of those important conversations [1:15:09] as to what do we do with recycling [1:15:12] and that premium that we've been assessing [1:15:18] our citizens to recycle. [1:15:21] So again, this is purely information we want that [1:15:23] to be as such, and we've labeled that [1:15:25] because we did not want you to take an action tonight. [1:15:28] That might allow us to engage our community [1:15:35] and get their sentiments that are on the schedule [1:15:43] and the future to allow the general public to know [1:15:49] that's on the agenda and know there's an opportunity [1:15:50] for the input here, the same information, [1:15:53] and then talk about that would be, [1:15:57] again, this is very eye-opening information. [1:16:01] I think the challenges with the recycling market [1:16:03] have been no secret in the big going on [1:16:05] for years now almost with significant swings [1:16:11] and I've followed with some interest [1:16:13] what other communities are doing [1:16:14] and what I like about this presentation is, I think, [1:16:18] it's not necessarily a all or nothing proposition [1:16:21] and I see many communities are making that decision. [1:16:24] We're either all in or we're just gonna bag it [1:16:26] and I think that there may be a sweet spot of the bills. [1:16:31] Anything else from the council on this item? [1:16:35] I think it's some portion keeper here to the ground [1:16:38] I thought it was safe, but like rural Western communities [1:16:42] maybe trying all six feet in and failing, [1:16:45] so that we keep abreast that we're not in the desert by ourselves. [1:16:49] So we do have a public hearing that is on the agenda this evening. [1:17:00] That's scheduled to begin no earlier than 6 PM. [1:17:05] We're still planning to have that. [1:17:06] We do have one more presentation on our regular agenda. [1:17:12] Move on to that item first, and that is a presentation [1:17:15] on the finances of the City of Twin Falls [1:17:17] for the six months of the fiscal year 2018-2019 [1:17:21] at the Lowery Research Chief Financial Officer. [1:17:38] Thank you, Mayor, and good evening. [1:17:41] So tonight, we're going to review the city's finances [1:17:45] for the first half of fiscal year 2019. [1:17:49] Six months is 50%, so that's gonna be our benchmark. [1:17:53] And as always, we're gonna start with a look [1:17:55] at the tax-supported funds, [1:17:58] focusing on those major revenue sources, the expenditures, [1:18:02] and then we'll move on to the three major enterprise funds, [1:18:05] water, wastewater, and sanitation. [1:18:18] So this slide is just a reminder of the nine tax-supported funds [1:18:23] and then the largest revenue categories [1:18:25] that provide funding for these. [1:18:28] The total of these revenues is over $35 million [1:18:31] and they make up 84% of the total revenue picture [1:18:35] in our tax-supported funds. [1:18:39] Property taxes are the largest source of funding, and the 22.1 million we expect to receive [1:18:46] is over half of the budget for our tax-supported funds. [1:18:50] This graph just shows the total property taxes budgeted, and then what we've received six months [1:18:56] through the year of each of these fiscal years. [1:18:59] Now, when you look at a 14-year picture of our property taxes received, we've averaged [1:19:07] a little over 55% of actual revenue that we're going to receive at this time. We have, we're [1:19:16] about 59% of our budget right now. And Twin Falls County is seeing strong collections. So [1:19:22] simply put, people are paying their taxes. The highway user revenue is on track to meet [1:19:31] budget. State shared revenues are projected to come in significantly more than budget, about [1:19:39] half a million dollars more than what I budgeted and I'm thinking what Lori what [1:19:43] have you done well so I start looking for an answer and in January the state of [1:19:50] Idaho's Division of Financial Management forecast predicted the sales tax revenue [1:19:55] would advance a little over four percent from December of 17 and it came in at [1:20:02] almost 10 percent that was about six point seven million dollars more than [1:20:09] they anticipated which is good for us. In their most current report they're seeing [1:20:14] sales tax for their fiscal year today continues to have a surplus of almost [1:20:19] six million dollars. Franchise fees make up 5% of the total revenue and this is [1:20:29] where I'm going to change my story for the first time since I started providing [1:20:32] financial updates. This revenue is coming in almost 10% below what I [1:20:37] budgeted. I can't find anybody to blame that on yet. So, you know that these [1:20:46] revenues are from natural gas, power, and cable, and that they're the rent that [1:20:51] these utility companies pay to us to use our right-of-ways. So, Intermountain [1:20:56] Gases, when I contacted them to see why our revenue was off, they had a really [1:21:02] good answer, and they shared that the federal tax reform of June 1st, 2018, [1:21:07] reduced their residential customer tariff rates by almost 3%. The rate was [1:21:16] further reduced as a result of lower purchased gas rates as of October 1st [1:21:21] 2018 and we were well into the budget by then. This does fluctuate yearly and [1:21:29] overall the cost per therm has decreased over 8 cents for every therm used. Now [1:21:37] Now with Idaho Power, I just noticed that our first two quarterly payments were off. [1:21:43] October's payment was back to like 2016 levels and the January payment was back to 2014 levels. [1:21:52] And so I contacted Idaho Power and they really didn't have a good explanation. [1:21:56] In fact, they think that usage is up and that we should be collecting more revenue in this [1:22:02] category. [1:22:03] So this one has not been resolved yet, but I'm still working on it, and we'll let you [1:22:07] know as soon as we have a good answer. [1:22:10] And L'Oreal, on that too then, so, um, Cable, though, is that? [1:22:17] I would assume that they're in a very competitive market these days, and that their revenues [1:22:23] may be declining. [1:22:25] So, cable is projected to come in about 2% under budget, and I budgeted 7% less this [1:22:36] current year than I had before. [1:22:38] I've been sharing that that revenue source has been declining for some time now. [1:22:44] So I'm projecting we'll get about $3,400 less than what I budgeted to just do that. [1:22:50] So that's a look at the major revenue sources in our tax-supported funds. [1:22:54] received about 56% of the budgeted revenues through March and that's above our typical [1:23:00] average. Thank you state shared revenue. So before we look at the expenditures and the [1:23:08] tax-supported funds, I thought you might be interested to know how much of every dollar [1:23:13] goes to which expenditure. So personnel costs take up 61 cents of every budget to dollar and [1:23:21] And that includes our police and fire teams. [1:23:25] M&O uses 19 cents, and these costs are utilities, fuel, and other items that regularly occur [1:23:32] to keep business running. [1:23:35] Capital improvement makes up 15 cents of the total, and our interfund transfers account [1:23:40] for the remaining nickel. [1:23:41] Now, this slide illustrates the budget for each expenditure category, along with the [1:23:49] amount that's been spent halfway through the year. [1:23:52] And as you can see in total, we're 47% spent halfway through the year. [1:24:01] As we move into the enterprise funds, this graph shows the actual water fund revenues [1:24:06] received for the first half of our fiscal year and 16, 17, 18, and 19. [1:24:13] Now there was an adjustment of about $62,000 this year that was made due to a billing error, [1:24:20] so that actually brings this percentage closer to 37%. [1:24:25] Looking back at the past 14 years of revenue history, we're typically at approximately 38% [1:24:30] of total will receive this time of year. [1:24:44] I also wanted to share how much of every dollar in the water fund goes to which expenditures. [1:24:49] Personnel accounts for a $0.20 of every dollar. [1:24:53] MNO takes $0.26. [1:24:56] Capital improvements cost $0.19. [1:24:59] Debt takes $0.25 and transfers. [1:25:03] for the remaining 10 cents. [1:25:09] Personal costs are above the 50% benchmark [1:25:13] in the water fund, but M&O expenditures are well below budget. [1:25:17] Summer's coming and pumping costs will help [1:25:20] boost that expenditure. [1:25:22] Capital projects are only at 39% of budget, [1:25:25] while debt is at 10.4. [1:25:28] We've only made one interest payment [1:25:30] and there'll be principal interest coming in September. [1:25:34] Overall, we're at 32.4% spent halfway through this fiscal year, and in the Wastewater Fund, [1:25:44] we'll start with revenues and look at total residential, industrial, and municipal user [1:25:49] fee budgets along with the actual amount we've received, and this information is provided [1:25:54] for the last three years. [1:25:56] Now, we're currently short of where we've been in the past, and this can be attributed [1:26:02] to our industrial users. [1:26:04] environmental engineer, Jason Brown, shares that he sees this decline due to our reduction [1:26:11] in the industrial loadings. And at the end of the day, discharge compliance is what's most [1:26:17] important. And in the wastewater fund, every dollar covers the following expenditures. Personnel [1:26:29] costs only 8 cents of every dollar. We only have personnel costs in our collection department. [1:26:36] M&O takes $0.35 of every dollar, capital takes $0.13, debt is responsible for $0.35, and transfers [1:26:47] account for $0.09, and on the expenditure side, personal costs are below our benchmark. [1:26:57] M&O appears over, but only because we pay Jacobs in advance after adjusting for that [1:27:03] extra payment were below the 50%. Capital is showing about 33% of budget, and again, only [1:27:11] an interest payment has been made in the debt category with our transfers right where they [1:27:16] belong. All in all, this fund is showing 39% spent to date. And finally, we get to sanitation. [1:27:26] When looking at the revenues, excluding a small portion of interest income, you can see the [1:27:31] amount received to date is almost 50% for all years. Actual revenues are meeting projections. [1:27:42] And expenditures need very little explanation. M&L is a tick under our benchmark and there's no [1:27:49] capital or no debt and transfers are on target. Overall, this budget is 48.7% spent halfway through [1:27:58] the fiscal year. I had a little page here with some sanitation, some recycling trivia, [1:28:06] But I read all the answers in the paper this morning, so. [1:28:10] So I thought, well, maybe we'll skip it. [1:28:13] Basically, at the end, I just wanted [1:28:15] to share with you that your today, we've spent about $90,000 [1:28:19] to recycle that was in the paper. [1:28:21] And we'll easily be approaching $200,000 or 5.5% [1:28:26] of our budget before the fiscal year ends. [1:28:32] E, so that's a look at the revenues and expenditures [1:28:35] in our tax-supported funds and our three major enterprise [1:28:39] This is just a summary of what we've just talked about in the enterprise funds, and I'm [1:28:45] happy to answer any questions anyone might have. [1:28:51] I remember, Lori, some of these departments are not equal expenditure month by month. [1:28:58] Someone had back in London. [1:29:00] Could you tell us what the one forward to? [1:29:03] As far as I have here, waiting on expenditures the last six months. [1:29:08] So, did you have a particular department? [1:29:10] Are you counting on me to think of something quickly? [1:29:13] So, water for water? [1:29:19] Exactly. [1:29:20] So, we know the pumping costs are going to kick up as people are irrigating in that type [1:29:25] of thing. [1:29:26] So, when you look and I'm talking about, oh, we're only 38% spent, that's pretty typical. [1:29:33] There's not anything out of the ordinary there. [1:29:35] And the next time I give this presentation, it'll probably be 75% or whatever. [1:29:41] So that's exactly what's happening, Chris, and I really, you would think I'd be able to rattle those off very easily since I look at that, and I've been doing that for a long time. [1:29:52] Well, knowing the number of pressure you are, you probably got the year over years late on that, that the chart don't you can tell just pretty much exactly if they're in line or not. [1:30:00] Exactly. [1:30:01] I mean, if we have an exceptionally hot summer that may change things. [1:30:04] I want to thank you so much for your very succinct and easy-to-follow presentation. [1:30:15] Thank you. [1:30:16] With a beautiful combination of graphs and charts and pictures. [1:30:20] All the stuff that makes me happy. [1:30:23] It does make me miss Jim. [1:30:25] He would be so sad to miss this tonight. [1:30:30] I'll be sure to email him a copy. [1:30:32] I think he should. [1:30:34] Thanks, Laurie. [1:30:37] Next on the agenda is an opportunity for a general public input [1:30:40] if there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council [1:30:43] on an item that is not of the agenda. [1:30:44] Now I should change to please come forward. [1:30:46] Being no one, any advisory board who performs from the council. [1:30:53] Susan Ockens. [1:30:56] I just have a question. [1:30:58] I think it's probably more for Josh Palmer. [1:31:00] I got a message today from someone who was trying, well, [1:31:05] actually I helped someone download the C-click fix onto their phone [1:31:09] and work with them a little bit, but when they take pictures, they said there's nowhere [1:31:15] to link them to the Parks and Rec. They can find the water in the streets. And is that true [1:31:22] or is there a way to get it to Parks and Rec through that app? [1:31:27] There we go, Council. I'm Judge Palmer, Public Information Officer with the City. So yes, [1:31:39] there is. We need to, we do need to work with it. So we have pre-defined categories that are [1:31:44] to send those requests to essentially our Public Works [1:31:48] and Code Enforcement, but it's malleable in the sense [1:31:51] that we can work with it to have it sent to parts direct, [1:31:55] depending on what that is. [1:31:56] We don't have it set up, not to my knowledge, [1:31:59] I don't think we have it set up that way now. [1:32:00] It only goes to our Public Works departments [1:32:02] and Code Enforcement. [1:32:04] Okay, so should I have that person contact you or IT [1:32:10] or who's the right person to send them to the House? [1:32:12] Have to call the Public Information Office to me. [1:32:14] Okay. [1:32:15] And we can work with them on that. [1:32:17] We work with Information Technology, [1:32:19] which is the Rich Hall, [1:32:22] who has, is it adding categories in [1:32:24] as we receive them from the community, [1:32:27] so that we can make this really fine to and for our city. [1:32:30] So you have them give me a call or contact any of us [1:32:34] and we'll get that set up for them. [1:32:37] And then, if I can, we're planning for a presentation [1:32:41] is coming Monday, which I'm looking forward to. [1:32:43] So we can kind of show you how it works. [1:32:44] And then also, that's one of the areas we want to talk [1:32:47] is how it gets filtered into the, as a work order, [1:32:51] to our crew. [1:32:52] So I'm going to talk a little bit more about that. [1:32:54] And that might even be a good example that we can use. [1:32:56] OK, thank you. [1:32:59] I will just add a little bit of that topic up. [1:33:01] So last Monday, after the council meeting, [1:33:03] I was walking down the street and was informed by a citizen [1:33:07] that the button that turns on the blinking light of the crosswalk [1:33:10] on Shoshan Street wasn't working, so Tuesday morning, I downloaded the app on my phone, [1:33:17] checked in the information, and by about three o'clock on Tuesday afternoon, I'd received [1:33:22] two or three communications back that had been addressed and taken care of, so it is a slick [1:33:27] system. [1:33:28] Two will say, though, I had a difficult time figuring out what category to plug it into. [1:33:33] I had to put it in as I think it was a broken sign or something like that, because it gave [1:33:37] made those selections, but worked out very well. Chris Reed, this is not an [1:33:45] advisory report report, but an announcement I just wanted to thank the [1:33:48] group of base shumpers on Saturday. My family and I were walking the trail and [1:33:54] there was a group of base shumpers and my wife asked them, is this a certain group? [1:34:00] They just said, no, we just come here, we enjoy Twin Falls and we wanted to clean [1:34:04] the canyon and so there's a picture of the trash that they cleaned up on [1:34:08] Saturday and those four shopping carts it's a little concerning when you're [1:34:13] walking and you just see a group of guys with a rope pulling things out of the [1:34:17] canyon I thought what's going on down there and then all of a sudden the shopping [1:34:20] cart comes flying up so I want to thank them for doing that I really [1:34:25] appreciate it but also those who left their garbage there please don't do that [1:34:28] it's a beautiful canyon we wanted to remain beautiful but again thank you to [1:34:33] those base jumpers. [1:34:35] Miss. [1:34:36] Anything else from the council? [1:34:40] We have a city manager's office. [1:34:42] Okay. [1:34:43] All right. [1:34:45] So we do have a public hearing scheduled and we will move on to that action item now. [1:34:50] This is a request to pay key plan of easements and dedicate it right away within the prime point subdivision blocks five, six, seven, and eight. [1:34:58] Located at the 1000 block of falls Avenue West. [1:35:01] On behalf of Trayscreen goes care of the H.M. engineers incorporated [1:35:05] I got a good much cheat sheet here so I can review the procedure. Oh, look at that, it's all in. [1:35:11] And a bigger font for me, so that's awesome. [1:35:17] So I just want to review the process for this public hearing on this land use item. [1:35:24] So we will have City staff will present the request and analysis. [1:35:29] The applicant will then present the request. [1:35:32] We'll have an opportunity to ask any questions of the applicant or the staff at that time. [1:35:36] After the questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened. [1:35:39] During that time, anyone in attendance has given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being considered. [1:35:45] I would do ask that when given testimony, please step up to the podium. [1:35:48] State your name and address and then present your comments or concerns. [1:35:52] Make sure that after giving your testimony that you have signed in on the public sign-in sheet [1:35:57] located either in the lobby or in the podium. [1:36:01] After the public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions of a closing statement, and then staff will answer or clarify any comments as needed. [1:36:10] After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed and no further testimony or comments from the applicant, [1:36:16] where the audience will be allowed and the council will then have an open discussion and take action. [1:36:21] on the request. With that, we will have our staff report from the steeple connor city planner. [1:36:28] Welcome to the evening, Mr Mayor and council members. We have before you a request to vacate [1:36:34] the rights away in easements within blocks 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the paren points of division. [1:36:41] The purpose of the request is to remove the undevelopable barrier for future development [1:36:46] identified in the narrative from the applicant as multifamily housing. We have received all [1:36:53] the required letters from the appropriate utility companies and only Twin Falls Canal [1:36:57] Company has existing infrastructure and they will agree to new easements once the new lateral [1:37:02] is piped and rerouted to standard. That lateral is down here in the southwest corner of the [1:37:09] of this image here running across the southwest portion of where the easements in the right [1:37:15] way want to be vacated. And to make this a little easier, this will be easier, right? [1:37:31] So, all that red that you see right there, that is the right of way and the easements that [1:37:36] they are requesting to be vacated. It's all the utility, the public access, anything you [1:37:45] can think of right there that they're requesting and the purpose, as I stated before, was [1:37:49] to make way for future development, [1:37:53] that we currently do not have a plan for, [1:37:56] and it will also require, [1:37:58] if they do multi-family or require another zoning action, [1:38:03] that we do not have a application for it as of yet as well. [1:38:07] So, this is the first step in this process. [1:38:10] And the first step from this one was on March 26th, [1:38:15] the Planning and Zoning Commission voted unanimously [1:38:17] to afford a positive recommendation for vacation [1:38:19] of these easements and right away. [1:38:23] This request is in compliance with the Grow With Us 2016 [1:38:27] comprehensive plan. [1:38:28] It doesn't need such areas town neighborhood [1:38:31] and the transportation master plan. [1:38:34] This area is also identified as residential as well. [1:38:37] Therefore staff has determined it is in compliance [1:38:40] with those master plans. [1:38:42] The regulatory impacts approval of this request [1:38:45] will remove any entitlement that the easements [1:38:47] afforded the different agencies or entities for those development within those easements [1:38:54] and are also take away the right-of-way access that the city currently has. [1:39:01] So in conclusion, City Council is tasked with approving with conditions, denying or [1:39:07] tabling the request for more information. [1:39:09] If approved, staff recommends approval be subject to the following conditions. [1:39:13] One subject to continue compliance with all local, state, and federal code requirements [1:39:17] and other standards as applicable [1:39:19] and to subject to city engineer and fire marshal approved [1:39:22] permanent public accessing utility easements [1:39:24] to replace the planet rights of way and easements. [1:39:28] I'll stand for any questions [1:39:29] after the applicant has his name and appropriate answer. [1:39:36] Fantastic, thank you. [1:39:44] Have the applicant and mayor, members of council. [1:39:52] My name is Tim Vosser with EHM Engineer, [1:39:55] so I'm representing the applicant on this matter. [1:39:58] So, Steve's presentation went over a lot of it, I'll just go into a little bit more detail as to the intent of this. [1:40:07] The developers were approached by a group of gentlemen that wanted to put a multifamily project there. [1:40:14] It worked within the PUD, although the existing layout of right-of-ways and easements within that did not work for their development layout. [1:40:25] the wishes to do with family development within there, and as you can see, all's is [1:40:56] on the south, gravity drive on the north, Frank Henry Road, which is still undeveloped, [1:41:02] actually all of this internal subdivision is undeveloped at this point. No utilities [1:41:08] go through or anything. To the north of that is Centera subdivision. At this point we've [1:41:16] purposely put this development to the south and left to block or to to lot deep separation [1:41:25] between Centera and this. The goal is to keep the traffic out of Centera and direct them [1:41:33] more to cressview and or field stream when a third phase comes in a second phase. What [1:41:40] will happen is if you approve the vacation request, we will continue to provide utility [1:41:49] easements as needed as Steve stated. The benefit of Steve didn't really state it as a benefit [1:41:58] but I will benefit to the city is that the roads within the internal portion of this become private. [1:42:05] So the maintenance of those streets become the responsibility of the property owners within that [1:42:11] development. All utilities will continue to be routed to easements will be given to the city [1:42:18] as it's developed and approved. The most important part about this request is you will get an [1:42:25] staff and you will get an opportunity to view this again. When we come back in [1:42:31] with a layout, we will be doing a PUD amendment to make sure that it complies [1:42:36] with the existing PUD and allows you an opportunity to visit again. This is [1:42:42] really a preliminary step as we're somewhat ahead of ourselves. I got utility [1:42:49] company responses much earlier than I usually do otherwise I probably would [1:42:53] over in this concurrently, but we got the utility company responses, all were in favor, [1:42:59] so we're bringing this through, and we ask for your approval, and I'd be happy to stand [1:43:04] for any questions. Thank you. Any questions for Tim? Great landing. [1:43:09] Well, basically, the straits will be private, but the utilities will just now work with the [1:43:17] plan of four plexus or whatever you put it in there and so there will be in the [1:43:24] future there will be utilities but they're just in different places than they are now [1:43:28] that's correct for the questions for Tim thank you sir thank you and with that we [1:43:39] will open the hearing up for public input there's no one wishing to speak on this [1:43:48] issue major opportunity to please come forward seeing knowing we will close the [1:43:54] public input portion of the public hearing or from the applicant closing [1:44:00] statement or anything. All right with that well close up the public hearing [1:44:05] we'll turn it over to Kim Seoul. Susan Hopkins. Nice last question. Oh yes you [1:44:09] can I'm sorry. Okay sorry. So how many developments do we have where the streets [1:44:14] are private and not designed and then given to the city? That's a very good [1:44:20] question. I don't know right off the top of my head. I'll defer this one. We have [1:44:25] numerous ones, a lot of them end up in the form of like an apartment complex, like one [1:44:30] off of Addison can't really, some of those are just internal streets. One like this [1:44:37] is going to be a little bit different. But worry about the upkeep and getting [1:44:41] property owners to maintain it. I'm not sure I'm in favor of that, but I don't [1:44:47] know that that has anything to do with this easement right and I'm just curious. [1:44:50] Yeah, so there's, there are some, I'm not saying they're really prolific, but there [1:44:54] Our phone brick is one. [1:44:57] The phone brick is another one. [1:44:58] There's a single family home being put in this neighborhood too, so it's not exactly [1:45:04] like an apartment comp. [1:45:05] So I don't have, that's what's kind of different, is this one that don't have the actual layout [1:45:10] in the form of an application we've talked with the developer what it could look like. [1:45:14] I can tell you that a four plex was not on the table when we discussed it with them, but [1:45:19] we'll see when the application comes in. [1:45:21] This just gives me a little heartburn right now. [1:45:23] what we do know is their plan is to own it all together. The entity is not going to sell the land. [1:45:29] They want to own all the land and rent out the homes. So it would be like a home, not even a home [1:45:34] owners association. It's almost like a commercial property, but one person responsible for all of it. [1:45:39] The basic group of press departments or something like that. [1:45:42] Yeah. [1:45:43] So if that goes through that way, can they change that later, though, without city approval, [1:45:48] it starts selling off property and then we have problems with the road maintenance? [1:45:52] That would be taken care of during that PUD discussion. [1:45:55] Something that we can have that conversation about is this exactly we're talking about. [1:46:00] Thank you. That helps. [1:46:01] There's going to be a motion if somebody else has a question. [1:46:05] Any other questions? I'm sorry. I kind of asked the questions. [1:46:08] Go ahead, Greg. [1:46:12] Mayor, I move that we approve the request of a key to platadysments and dedicated right away with it. [1:46:18] at Prine Point Subdivisions Block 5678, located at the 1,000 Block of Falls Avenue West. [1:46:25] On behalf of Tres Gringos, the care of EHM engineers, and I will also include the staff [1:46:33] recommendations. [1:46:34] Second that. [1:46:35] Motion by Reglanting, second by Chris Tockington to approve the request as presented with these [1:46:41] staff recommendations to be included with that. [1:46:44] Is there any further discussion? [1:46:46] Suzanne Hawkins, yes Greg Lanting, Pierce, Christopher Reed, Miss Tockington, John [1:47:01] Berriger, and Nicky Boy, yes. [1:47:05] That's a 7-0. Thank you Steve, thank you Tim. [1:47:07] Thank you. [1:47:08] And that is the end of the agenda so that the meeting is adjourned.