Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-07-30, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-07-30/ [0:03:39] I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, July 30th [0:03:44] and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council. Here's six of the seven members are present this evening. Councilman [0:03:50] Tawkinton is absent. Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you who wish to join us, please rise. [0:03:56] Commations this evening, so next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. If I can ask someone from staff to go grab the sign-in sheet. [0:04:29] That was fantastic, please. [0:04:32] Just a reminder, our public input procedures, individuals wishing to provide public input [0:04:42] regarding matters relevant to the City of Twin Falls, shall wait to be recognized by [0:04:47] the mayor, approach the microphone and podium up here, state your name, and whether you [0:04:52] are a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls and proceed with your input, [0:04:57] we are going to limit public input this evening to three minutes per individual. [0:05:02] I would please ask that folks keep it concise as we take your input off the sign in sheet first and then we will provide an opportunity for those of you who did not sign in who addressed the council. [0:05:18] Alright, so going sign in sheet here the first I have is Paul Sturman. [0:05:34] My name is Paul Sturm and I'm a resident of Twin Falls. [0:06:03] I want to fix one. [0:06:05] Christi is driving in 165, Christi. [0:06:08] Question. [0:06:09] You have a southern Idaho progressive coalition. [0:06:14] I'm here to speak on behalf of the children of our boy, [0:06:23] because of injustice. [0:06:25] What's happening to them? [0:06:29] Twin Falls seems to have taken the attitude that we're a small town, [0:06:33] and so, therefore, what we do, doesn't matter. [0:06:37] We can't change the law. [0:06:38] We have to change the law, but we can express an opinion. [0:06:42] We have a growing Hispanic community, so by not supporting these people, what we're saying to them. [0:06:50] Boise took a stand on the issue. [0:06:57] Twin Falls is also a part of Idaho. [0:07:00] Matters whether we have a boy or not. [0:07:03] Our boy should stand in support of those who are being oppressed on the border. [0:07:08] We can stand and make a statement and not support injustice. [0:07:15] The support we can't say. [0:07:28] So I think as a community, as a part of Idaho, we should make a stand. [0:07:46] We should make a statement whether we can change the law or not. [0:07:50] It doesn't matter. [0:07:51] It matters as the way. [0:07:55] The case into the community can stand on the issue. [0:08:05] Next on this, I need to cheat. [0:08:07] I have Susie Campillares. [0:08:34] Some first straight to address expectations. [0:08:39] As a citizen of the city of expectations of the city council, [0:08:44] Members representing me in the meeting last night are the first last week we met. [0:08:53] Council Member Reed's response to Leah was both against meeting procedures and downright rude. [0:09:00] As a member of our community, who is a small business owner, former member of City Forest [0:09:04] political activist and citizen, she deserves more respect. And I was ashamed at the treatment [0:09:11] she received, listening to the meeting in between shuttling children. I was not able to be here, [0:09:17] Although I emailed, I was embarrassed. City Council members are here representing constituents [0:09:24] not to debase them and to ignore public input. Also, the public official, you have an obligation [0:09:32] to be informed affairs for the local to global. It's your job to stay informed of facts and policies [0:09:40] and consider their impact on our community, because we live in a global, there's no excuse [0:09:48] I hope to see the expectations met in the future, or I will be voting in representatives who will meet them and represent us well. [0:10:16] Good evening, Mayor Council. I have been the country for almost three weeks now, watched you online. [0:10:30] So and ran quite a bit of my data doing so that, hey, what the heck? [0:10:38] The reason I am here is kind of twofold. [0:10:43] First, I would highly request that you move public speaking [0:10:48] to the end of the meeting because I'm here to do business today [0:10:56] on the agenda. [0:10:58] And as a result, my business won't be heard [0:11:02] until much later. [0:11:05] And so, and I would like to get on with my evening, [0:11:11] and I judging from what I've seen last couple of weeks, [0:11:15] that's not going to be possible for a couple of hours. [0:11:19] Additionally, you guys have been criticized [0:11:23] and accused of not having a moral compass. [0:11:27] I know some of you personally and I voted for some of you and I have not, I wouldn't have voted for you, had I felt that to be true. [0:11:42] I think that you guys are upstanding and you have high moral standards and you're to be congratulated for that. [0:11:54] We live in a great community. [0:11:57] We live in a community that reaches out to everybody. [0:12:01] If there is something that we, that a community member needs, [0:12:06] we step up and not only do we step up, [0:12:09] we perform to our highest expectations. [0:12:13] So to say that we are uncaring or empathetic, [0:12:19] that is just, that's insulting to me [0:12:22] because I feel like I live in a great, empathetic community. [0:12:30] Illegal immigration is just that illegal. [0:12:34] As I mentioned, I have just returned [0:12:36] from almost three weeks in my birth country, [0:12:40] not my home country, this is my home, [0:12:43] but in my birth country. [0:12:45] And my father brought five of his children [0:12:50] and a pregnant wife to this country almost 50 years ago. [0:12:55] He waited five years and eight months to do so [0:13:00] to bring us all here as a family. [0:13:03] He had the option of coming alone, but he chose not to separate his family [0:13:09] because that's just his value system, that's his morals. [0:13:17] We were a family and we were either going to all go legally [0:13:21] none come legally so I just I applaud you I applaud what you're doing I we don't [0:13:31] need to have we don't need to be show voted okay so anyway that's just what I [0:13:41] have to say thank you [0:14:04] against any resolution to assist people down at the border, very animative. [0:14:11] I think this is the wrong platform to be talking about anything like that. [0:14:16] We have rules as a country for a reason. [0:14:19] Our country is based on our language, our culture, and mostly its borders. [0:14:24] If people want to come into the country, they should come into the country legally. [0:14:28] That's what happened at Ellis Island. [0:14:30] You know, we are made up of immigrants in the United States. [0:14:34] I met through Ellis Island and was vetted as we have procedures to do so now, so I really [0:14:42] think that this is the wrong platform. [0:14:44] I'd like to encourage the City Council to think of a way to stop this from happening. [0:14:50] My understanding from a direct conversation with Ms. Mabayan was that she was going to [0:14:56] continue to come and talk here at City Council until resolution was passed. [0:15:02] And I just think it's a waste of the time of the city and I think that there may be some [0:15:07] grander goals here to possibly be elected to a higher office, although that has been [0:15:12] told to me maybe these kinds of things could be spoken of in other places that city council [0:15:23] who next I have. [0:15:30] The children that are being a resolution to get them back together, social workers are [0:16:24] representatives that are there to help them work proceedings, just hearing that I have [0:16:40] seem you know firsthand as a social worker how so I just ask that resolution to [0:16:58] reunify that there's a lot more I just hope that you guys consider voting yes [0:17:26] on the resolution should be a priority. Richard, Alva Chitaldama and I am a resident in [0:18:06] home motor in the city of Twinfall. I appreciate the opportunity to return and [0:18:11] offer more comments on the issue of family separation. Need for our local [0:18:16] government to make a statement against the results this nation's previous [0:18:21] policy. We are all well aware that this policy has been rescinded. The horse may be dead, who [0:18:28] should all be aware of the fallout that still exists from this policy. Specifically, as of [0:18:34] last week's deadline, there was a US government court filing that revealed the following 1,500, [0:18:42] 2,500 children have been reunited. There are over 700 children, they are not eligible for [0:18:50] for reunification as of last week's deadline. [0:18:54] More than 400 of those 700 children could not be reunited [0:18:59] because their parents were deported. [0:19:01] On this last issue, there are reports that people [0:19:04] were misled into returning to their home country [0:19:07] with the belief that this was the only way [0:19:09] to be reunited with their children or child. [0:19:14] It is quite possible that many of these children [0:19:16] will never see their parents again. [0:19:18] This is a travesty. [0:19:21] If there is just one child who is in the situation, this country should do what it could to ensure [0:19:27] that that child will be reunited with its parents, but there are over 400. [0:19:32] This whole notion that many of these people have arrived illegally is not true. [0:19:39] Asking for asylum at a port of entry is a legal act under US law, bringing this issue [0:19:46] back to Twin Falls, there are facts that should be considered. [0:19:51] As I mentioned in my last presentation, a lot of our local workforce is Latino, and many [0:19:56] of them may be undocumented. [0:19:59] The U.S. Census Bureau estimate date of July 1, 2017 lists the Hispanic population of the [0:20:06] city of Twin Falls at 15.2%. [0:20:10] The county is listed at 16.5%. [0:20:12] There have been recent articles that identify Idaho as the fastest growing state with the [0:20:19] Hispanic population, driving population growth in the Magic Valley. [0:20:23] Recognizing that percentage of this representation may be undocumented, [0:20:27] we know that there is a percentage that doesn't vote. We cannot marginalize the [0:20:32] presence of this population and pretend that issues that concern them are not [0:20:36] those that our local government needs to address. We cannot and should not ignore the [0:20:40] contributions this population brings to our economy and culture. [0:20:44] A final note was seated in the audience last week [0:20:48] the fact that there was a female majority on our council that day jumped out of me. [0:20:54] I was pleased to see that I firmly believe that this world would be a better place [0:20:58] that more women in control. I must add though that there is probably a long [0:21:02] history in our local government but this was not the case. [0:21:05] Women did not have a voice on this council in many other governmental [0:21:08] entities, so I asked the female members of this council [0:21:12] to think back to that history of disenfranchisement and see how it relates [0:21:16] to the local Hispanic population. [0:21:18] Strel, thank you very much. [0:21:21] Next I have Leah. [0:21:45] Ready to go. [0:21:48] Thank you. [0:21:49] I would like to take this opportunity to apologize to absolutely no one on this council. [0:21:54] If anyone it is the city council who ought to apologize to the Hispanic and immigrant community [0:21:59] for being agents of systematic oppression, disenfranchising, blocking, and for dismissing [0:22:06] their voice, their community, and their community's concern for generations. [0:22:11] Some of you were rude and completely out of order last week, [0:22:15] demonstrating very little faith in our vice mayor to hold order. [0:22:19] How do you expect us to trust and have faith in our democratic process when clearly even you don't? [0:22:26] I will now restate my comments so that it is heard clearly and understood correctly. [0:22:32] You should be ashamed of yourself, and the shame that it brings to this institution and [0:22:36] here is why. [0:22:38] The City of Twin Falls and City Council's approval of 2,030 strategic plans sets a goal [0:22:44] to be a healthy, inclusive learning, secure, accessible, prosperous, and responsible community. [0:22:50] That's all words. [0:22:51] But your actions do not support these words in the strategic plan. [0:22:56] What efforts systems goals have you set and accomplished in the last three decades to reach [0:23:01] Connect include and represent the Hispanic and immigrant voice in the local decision-making process. [0:23:07] When's the last time you heard from this community? [0:23:10] From citizen surveys, from staff reports, from ground tables? [0:23:14] The answer is easy. It's never. [0:23:17] You have never heard directly from this community. [0:23:20] When is the last time they stood before you? Never. [0:23:23] Who represents them? What committee? [0:23:26] The one and only time, let me remind you, the only time in the history of Twin Falls City Council that the Hispanic community approached you with a symbolic resolution that's from the core values for community, humane treatment of children and family integrity, and you completely dismissed them, disregarded them, and closed the door. [0:23:49] They recommended they contact their state representative, which we have long before we approached you. [0:23:55] You referred them to the hierarchy of state representatives as if you are not here to serve them too. [0:24:01] You expect them to vote for people who do not care about their community. [0:24:06] You know they don't vote for you. [0:24:08] How can they? You're not concerned with issues that they face every day as members of this community. [0:24:14] And regardless if someone voted for you or not, the 10% that have voted the base, they have a constitutional right to local direct representation and it is your job to represent everyone in our community, not just your base. [0:24:30] You do not represent your political party here or corporations or associations or your church or the ideology or your fringe. [0:24:39] Your job is to represent the people at Twin Falls, [0:24:42] and this includes the generations [0:24:45] of Hispanic and immigrant residents of our community. [0:24:48] Your supported no vote was hypocritical, claiming, [0:24:53] this matter is not within your jurisdiction [0:24:55] and that you're ignorant of the facts, or worse, [0:24:58] that your budget was more important [0:24:59] than a symbolic resolution from a community [0:25:02] you never hear from. [0:25:04] That's just unacceptable. [0:25:06] Yeah, the resolution is is symbolic. Separating of families. It's symbolic. Thank you. [0:25:14] Those are all of the people that I have signed up on this to request to speak. If there are others who wish to address the council, now is your opportunity to please come forward. I will remind you again to say your name and whether you are a property owner in the city of Twin Falls, so proceed with your input and we are limited to three minutes to see. [0:25:38] I was looking up the definition of the piece, but you actually are, and sometimes I voice [0:26:22] just cracks when I start thinking about the end. [0:26:33] So the actual situations of simply not knowing where your parents are, is child abuse, because [0:26:44] anxiety and depression which you've seen the pictures with, you've seen child abuse, [0:26:55] and it's a symbolic resolution, but you have a present which has just said that you say [0:27:06] What you are seeing is the enemy of the people. [0:27:12] Chris said, tell for sure what's going on. [0:27:17] So I did send documentation of a court case [0:27:20] that he can look at. [0:27:21] He actually did confirm today an email. [0:27:28] This is still going on. [0:27:29] Florida settlement calls for, so separating. [0:27:53] So the simple resolution that we are witnessing [0:27:56] is separating children from their fans [0:27:59] un-American and unacceptable. [0:28:02] And to make sure that the people who are backlashing [0:28:04] against you in this meeting with one gentleman, [0:28:07] I agree with so much of what they said in half of what President Trump says. [0:28:11] I don't want them to think of us as the enemy. [0:28:13] But the man said you're not even sent you a biblical verse. [0:28:29] Look at Matthew, amongst us you do. [0:28:49] 1961 nuclear meltdown with the wind flow out right now to the magic [0:28:55] valley for a solid week. [0:28:56] And to be treated with 400 returns. [0:29:05] Anyone else who wishes to to ask the council, yes, ma'am? [0:31:32] Those people, when you come to this country and seek asylum, [0:31:35] you must be standing on the United States ground [0:31:38] to ask for asylum. Those are the rules. Those are our rules. [0:31:43] Are you disappointed to be a person that's on my Facebook in every community? I can reach [0:32:28] well-known. [0:32:29] Anyone else who wishes to address the council? [0:32:45] Continue some of the statements by Laiya B'bai. The M'baiyan. [0:33:14] Yes, the resolution concerning separation of families is symbolic, like the position is [0:33:19] mayor, but we need symbols. Like the symbolic resolutions you've supported regarding systematic [0:33:24] oppression of people throughout the world, she stood before you when you did exactly this. [0:33:29] Proclamations regarding the Bosnian genocide, the Armenian Genocide, that this same council, [0:33:34] each of you voted yes to condone and take official council position on. [0:33:38] Is Armenia, Bosnia, Rwanda, Cambodia, Baku with you in your jurisdiction and under the [0:33:44] duty of your oath of office? [0:33:47] Rather than closing doors, open doors and build a bridge with the Hispanic community. [0:33:51] what your strategic plan set as a goal and become an inclusive, learning, [0:33:54] accessible, responsive community. Starting with listening to the largest and [0:33:58] longest marginalized community here, the Hispanic community, who is lived here [0:34:02] without a voice for generations. Show them, reach out, work with them on the [0:34:06] wording, work with them on building a relationship and include them in your [0:34:09] advisory process. You could, if they're informed on the facts surrounding the [0:34:13] policy of family separation issue, directive your staff to research and [0:34:17] you up to date. You could, as you promised a year ago, look into funding and designate [0:34:21] the Diversity Commission to serve as an advisory to the council on issues concerning diverse [0:34:26] communities and twin falls from their own direct voice and representatives. Our parks, [0:34:30] our trail systems, and historic buildings and golf course have more of a voice and representation [0:34:35] through designated commissions that Hispanic and immigrant people do in our city council [0:34:39] and our community. Show them, represent them. Be cautious that working in this bureaucracy [0:34:45] does not callist or humanity. You are human's first and then a public official. And as my [0:34:50] personal statement, I would like to reaffirm what has already been said, that this does not [0:34:55] need to be a debate of humanity versus legality, although I would like to hope in that event [0:35:00] we would all choose humanity. It is not simply a matter of legal immigration and is often [0:35:06] portrayed. From all the research that I've done, people are still being turned away of [0:35:10] ports of entry, which is always what people tell you when they hear about illegal immigration. [0:35:14] There is a way to do it legally, and there should, but people are being turned away at [0:35:18] the bridges, being told they don't have the capacity, even though from anything that has [0:35:22] been studied of the great resources available to ICE, that is complete crap. [0:35:27] Some of these people don't have a second opportunity. [0:35:30] When they're approaching the ports of entry for seeking asylum, they have real legitimate [0:35:34] fear waiting for them outside these borders. [0:35:37] Some of them don't come back, some of them are kidnapped. [0:35:40] not something I'm implying those are stories those are what we know from facts [0:35:45] and also as a Christian I do not stand behind this and I cannot agree with the [0:35:53] president who calls himself Christian and ignores this very simple plea truly I [0:35:58] tell you whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of [0:36:02] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:36:12] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:36:49] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:36:57] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:37:06] There are moments that should haunt a politician for the rest of their careers, and this should be one. [0:37:13] We have reached into new meaning of ungaring evil. [0:37:16] These are not easy words to say very clearly. [0:37:20] These are words with consequences, because they need you to act. [0:37:25] We need you to act. [0:37:29] In a shocked and confused state, children are left at these borders, have no idea where their parents are. [0:37:36] Over 2,000 children have so far been ripped from their parents, and many fear they may [0:37:43] never be reunited with their families. [0:37:46] A new federal court filing has detailed accounts for migrant children and their families about [0:37:51] the conditions they experienced recently in federal detention. [0:37:54] They are troubling. [0:37:56] People are sleeping on cold, concrete floors, lights were left on all night and they were [0:38:00] not able to sleep. [0:38:03] In some cases, children were denied access of water. [0:38:08] When a mother was feeding her one-year-old child, she was only given formula when he [0:38:14] needed solid foods. [0:38:16] She asked an officer for more food, and the officer only responded with, this isn't a [0:38:21] seven-star hotel. [0:38:23] What do you want? [0:38:25] Dead kids? [0:38:26] Or skinny kids? [0:38:27] This is a reality. [0:38:31] This reality stands to create a part of a part need, a kind of a part need. [0:38:36] Endowing in a blatant political government agency with a power to decide which families are allowed to stay together and who can recover from devastation. [0:38:46] And may I quote, and the king shall answer and say unto them, [0:38:50] Fairly I say unto you, since you have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, you have done it unto me. [0:38:59] So be our voice, be their voice, and take action. Thank you. [0:39:08] to address the council. [0:39:10] This evening, the consent calendar souls. [0:39:29] The occurrence that we provide is loaded on separately. [0:39:35] We live to approve the consent calendar with the exception of item C as presented. [0:39:56] Second. [0:39:57] Vice, who's in Hawkins second by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar minus item 5C. [0:40:20] Who's in Hawkins? [0:40:21] Yes. [0:40:31] Yes. [0:40:57] Who's in Hawkins 2? [0:40:58] Yes. [0:41:19] Yes. [0:41:21] To pass us five to zero with one abstention. [0:41:26] Next on the agenda is a request to confirm the appointment of Allen Horner to serve on [0:41:33] the recreation center ad hoc committee. [0:41:35] One listed for this 2017. [0:41:51] The council approved the charter for the Twin Falls recreation center ad hoc committee. [0:41:55] Committee was to be populated with members representing certain identified partners and [0:42:01] interests as well as some members at large. [0:42:03] One of the committee members, Brad Wills, has stepped down from his seat due to additional time commitments to prevent him from participating, [0:42:11] as well as Wendy Davis, the President of For Vacancy, and... [0:42:30] Second. [0:43:15] Keep going, second. [0:43:18] Member of the recreation center, and another discussion on that. [0:43:38] Yes. [0:43:39] Yes. [0:43:41] And yes. [0:43:43] And we should pass this in 6-0. [0:43:44] Next is a request from the Twin Falls Highway District to waive the building permit fees for two new structures we have. [0:43:54] Brian's here, I'm just going to have him come up and explain the two projects and I'll be here for you for any questions. [0:44:06] Hey, caster, calls Highway District commissioners proposing a 5,000 square foot equipment for each building. [0:44:29] We have an E400 consultant standing with the city to ask you a question. [0:45:08] Requested asking us to waive different fees, one of them being the impact fees. [0:45:28] These aren't actually impact fees. These are area of impact. [0:45:57] Should have been more clear on the staff report. We can't waive the impact fees. We never have. [0:46:00] have so there's no impact fees assessed for area impact projects. It's the [0:46:06] difference between what we collect versus what the county would collect [0:46:09] for building permit fees. We don't assess or collect the county's building permit [0:46:20] so they've reached out to the county as well. [0:47:12] I'm not showing up trying to show up. [0:48:26] I did twice. [0:48:36] Okay. [0:48:37] So I know we approve the request of the Twin Falls Highway District to waive the building permit fees for two new structures, totaling approximately $3,940 in some odd sense. [0:48:51] The Mayor seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the request to waive the building fees as presented for their discussion. [0:49:02] Greg Lanting? [0:49:11] Yes. [0:49:14] Yes. [0:49:18] Yes. [0:49:19] Yes. [0:49:20] Nicky Boyd. [0:49:24] Yes. [0:49:25] Passes 6-0. [0:49:29] The consent calendar, so any of you who were here for special event application approvals [0:49:34] for the Chamber's Many Masters tournament, merge now, end of Summer Jam, or the House, [0:49:42] chirred root as part of the consent calendar. [0:49:45] Stick around and let's enjoy the rest of the show. [0:49:59] Next on the agenda is a presentation and possible adoption of the Twin Falls Historic Preservation [0:50:04] Master Plan. [0:50:05] Johnathan's been a lot of our planning and zoning director. [0:50:09] I think Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:50:11] and this presentation will be, [0:50:24] is it working on a master plan? [0:50:25] This master plan was part of a grant that was approved [0:50:28] and or awarded by the state historic, [0:50:32] I can't think of their historic society, [0:50:34] but their official name is in the amount of about $8,000. [0:50:38] Over that year and a half, they've looked at different consultants [0:50:41] and different things and getting input from the commission. [0:50:45] Really, it kind of came to a five to six months [0:50:52] in general and I'm guessing everybody has had a chance to look at it. [0:50:57] We fashioned it after our strategic plan and our comprehensive plan [0:51:01] in the way that it looks, the way that it functions, the fonts, all that kind of stuff. [0:51:05] We tried to streamline people's familiarity with it so they didn't have to spend time looking at it [0:51:11] to get familiar with it. They was prepared by Logan Simpson who also did our comprehensive plan, [0:51:18] which was beneficial. They had a lot of our history, so the introduction piece and some of those things [0:51:24] We spend less time on those, more time on things and some maps and goals, and this is meant to commission into some things that they'll be doing over the next ten years or so. [0:51:47] It gets at education components and the things that are looking at the current as a commission, at least for that commission itself, came up with being shows all of the different historic areas. [0:52:08] We have three, although there's four that the pink area, which is the historic district, [0:52:13] is separated into two different areas, but it's under one design guideline. [0:52:17] We have the downtown shown here in blue, and then the city park is shown in green. [0:52:22] City park has very few non-public facilities. [0:52:25] There's a couple private buildings, most of those are the courthouse. [0:52:29] The city park, the entirety of that's a ban shell, all those things come under. [0:52:33] They have done been done previously, but they come under a design guidelines for. [0:52:38] renovation or when someone goes to rebuild to meet certain guidelines. [0:52:42] This plan kind of re-establishes all of those into a concise map as well as some overall goals that they're looking for. [0:52:49] Last bit, I kind of go through photos of two structures that were located outside four districts. [0:53:14] We have a lot of structures that are not in any of those districts. [0:53:17] And then we also listed all the structures within those districts. [0:53:20] It's kind of within this table. It goes on for quite a few pages. [0:53:23] I'm working with our consultant. We do have one of the largest residential historic districts [0:53:30] in the region. In the west we have a lot of historic buildings in that downtown which is [0:53:39] here outlined in blue. By size it's one of the largest contiguous locations that they've [0:53:45] worked with. Staff glues or finishes up the grant program as we adopted has looked at it [0:53:59] and comments once it's adopted we submit it back to them as the final day. [0:54:09] So this document really is more city staff and the commission on efforts moving. [0:54:22] Yeah, there's no regulatory effect of this document whatsoever. [0:54:26] It's really a level here, some things we should be doing or should look to do. [0:54:33] It's not a regulation as far as you cannot or can do this on a specific property. [0:54:38] That is held within those design guidelines that were previously adopted. [0:54:42] Vision and objectives for as opposed to specific. [0:54:47] I'm just going to show up on everything I would ask to you, and this has gone through the historic preservation commission. [0:55:03] Yeah, we had a meeting and there are some members. We had a short timeline, so they have seen it twice, maybe three times. [0:55:11] I have not seen what the state added, which was honestly just some grammatical things that they had noticed. [0:55:17] They've looked at it again in two or three public meetings. [0:55:22] Nancy, did you want to give it to Lucy? [0:55:29] Nancy Taylor, I'm chair of the City's Historic Preservation Commission. Lucy [0:55:34] Wills is our vice chair. We have reviewed the master plan and please keep in mind [0:55:45] that this backs up our five-year plan, which we have every five years. Our last [0:55:50] plan of 2012 to 2017, we have accomplished every goal that we set [0:55:57] forward. And we are in the process now of developing our next five-year plan. I need [0:56:07] to acknowledge first of all our commission members who are as you know [0:56:11] volunteers and passionate about our historic preservation and my motto is [0:56:18] always historic preservation is good for business tourism business we we worked [0:56:32] on this and I need to really thank City staff, Jonathan Stiegel Connor and Bryce, which really [0:56:43] who really helped us. This was developed in the Grow With Us plan for the City and we believe [0:56:53] as a commission that historic preservation can live with modern design just as we have our city [0:57:03] Hall, our downtown commons, the juxtaposition of our historic city is important to us and [0:57:14] we intend to do that without compromising business going on in our city. [0:57:21] So we're passionate about it and we hope that you have read our plan and again we will be [0:57:30] presented we will be presenting to you our next five-year plan and what we hope [0:57:35] to accomplish. That was part of my vacation reading and there are some in [0:57:47] this city we can declare as historic. Thank you so much to both of you and [0:57:56] certainly to all the Commission members who have been a part of the Council [0:58:06] Greg Lanting preparation for making the motion to accept the motion I'd like to [0:58:13] make the historic preservation Commission recently found one of the [0:58:19] the old brochures that was the walking and driving tour of the old parts of downtown and [0:58:24] we actually walked the driving tour portion and some of those people they'd see you looking [0:58:30] at the building and they're very proud of their buildings and they come out to talk to you [0:58:34] about it and what they may have changed since it was new mostly on the inside but as a very [0:58:39] informative we did one day we did the area to the I guess generally the northwest of [0:58:45] of Shudshun Street and the other day we did the area, [0:58:48] generally, southeast of Shudshun Street, [0:58:51] and a lot of interesting buildings there in the year, [0:58:54] the brochure had some very interesting tidbits [0:58:57] of some of the family members who lived in those houses [0:58:59] could actually build on for you. [0:59:02] So it was amazing to have four different houses [0:59:04] we stepped outside, we're looking at it and they came out, [0:59:07] else about it, they knew exactly what we were doing. [0:59:10] Councilman, I need to tell the entire council [0:59:13] that we are in the, we have finally redesigned, [0:59:17] redesigned the four brochures that we had originally, [0:59:22] and City staff is looking into bins for those. [0:59:28] The CSI designed it, the students designed it, [0:59:33] and I think you'll find it wonderful [0:59:35] and one status printed, we'll get it to you. [0:59:43] I was gonna second the motion. [0:59:45] Thank you. [1:00:26] is scheduled to begin no earlier than six o'clock. [1:00:29] And I'm thinking that recess first for those [1:00:40] who are here for that item, the presentation [1:00:44] I'm gonna recess until six o'clock. [1:09:36] Like to reading the City Council meeting for it is 608. [1:09:44] We are going to move to the public hearing portion [1:09:47] of the agenda and then we will go back up [1:09:49] to the items for consideration [1:09:51] and interline put and so forth. [1:09:53] The public hearing we have best scheduled for this evening is a request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to R4 NCO CDA, or property located at 1122 Washington Street, South. [1:10:07] Care of the community council of Idaho. [1:10:09] We have Terry Blum, who is here to present this evening. [1:10:13] Welcome sir. [1:10:14] Good evening. [1:10:15] What I'd like to do is give you a little bit of background. [1:10:18] I wanted to say, rebuild building something brand. [1:10:28] So I'll do a little bit of the presentation. [1:10:30] you have questions after that, or more at our CEO is here from the Community Council of [1:10:36] Idaho, our developer from Desert Ridge Financial, it's all like is here, as well as other members [1:10:44] of our team. [1:10:45] So we think we'll be able to handle almost all the questions that you might, I said, [1:10:52] where I'm on the start with is the aerial view this in front of you and this is the current [1:10:58] property, let's see if I get the address right because 1,122 Washington Street [1:11:04] South housing started by the fire security administration in 1942 and it [1:11:14] was started as migrant seasonal farm worker housing and it was really never [1:11:20] developed or envisioned to be permanent housing. It was designed to be was a city [1:11:25] for migrant workers when they were here in in season and the vision of the FSA [1:11:32] at that point looked at providing housing, community center, services and education and [1:11:42] looked at basically being a relatively self-contained city, migrant season of farm workers as a council [1:11:53] have done a lot of research looking at and we started with the plan of what about one [1:12:01] of the discoveries that I'm sure we've heard from a lot of the contractors before is what [1:12:04] we discovered is those buildings were never designed, fully winterized permanent housing, [1:12:09] We have issues of old, we have issues of design that was started in the 19 of that seemed like, but prospect for a strong family community. [1:12:27] So, I recall a lot of the leadership of our law has been looking for a number of years at how we could redevelop that property. [1:12:36] And so, we're looking at a plan that basically will create more plexes, clustered in housing, as well as a non-commercial overlay or neighborhood commercial overlay. [1:12:48] like I'm in phase four, which will be as we envision a campus of sorts for non-profit [1:12:56] organizations to provide services to the south side of Twin Falls. [1:13:01] So, to our phase one, which is if you drive by the properties of currently vacant parcel of land except for one housing, [1:13:13] so we can proceed with that building, disrupt as few residents as possible. [1:13:21] The plan is once we complete phase one. [1:13:24] Click options to begin to move. [1:13:28] Residents into network quality housing. [1:13:31] Be commenced with phase two, which is the phase right behind. [1:13:36] Please notice that that person is starting in here. [1:13:43] If we look at the neighborhood commercial overlay, [1:13:45] we envision a couple of things. [1:13:48] One of them is in working with the city, [1:13:51] we are aligning the street that comes out of El Malagro [1:13:54] with the street that is across Washington. [1:13:57] Or future development that is here, [1:13:59] making stop lights for where you're going to release [1:14:01] to be done for traffic easier. [1:14:04] And unfortunately, all realign in that street [1:14:06] has to write through our migrant seasonal head start school. [1:14:10] Students are not too bad, but the teachers are really upset. [1:14:14] So the first priority we have in the neighborhood [1:14:18] cummercimic is creation of a migrant seasonal head [1:14:21] start school, which is the upper most building that [1:14:26] would replace the existing structure, which is also, [1:14:29] by the way, in quads and huts and mobile units. [1:14:32] the United States. [1:14:34] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:35] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:36] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:37] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:38] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:39] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:42] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:43] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:44] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:52] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:53] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:55] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:56] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:58] The United States is a very important part of the United States. [1:14:59] The youth build program will district and other partners to coordinate services to the local and possibly bringing in other services that we have from other places in the state. [1:15:15] We do medical planning in Eastern Idaho, federally certified immigration services program. [1:15:23] So we're hoping to bring as many of those services as possible to that one location. [1:15:28] It's in the girls club, the YMCA. [1:15:35] I shouldn't hear, I was just something I know, services to those locations. [1:15:44] For example, a Community Learning Center with CSI and the School of Duster. [1:15:50] We could extend the Boys and Girls Club services to that area. [1:15:57] So all of that together is kind of what we're looking at, as well as the big open space, [1:16:01] where we have been talking with Wendy in phase four, beginning to develop it with the city. [1:16:08] So, it is our plan, and as I said, we've been serving since 1942. [1:16:18] that we have been in this community and partnering for seven decades. [1:16:22] We hope to create the private next seven decades. [1:16:27] I'll stand for questions or if I'll let John the folks in the community. [1:16:37] So we'll turn to Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. [1:16:45] Make Terry explain the project very well. [1:16:48] We're just going to talk about the process and what we're here for. [1:16:51] The current zoning on the property is R4. [1:16:53] We have that zoning map. [1:16:55] Logger was in its own kind of the portion where the homes are to remain [1:17:14] residential R4 zoning district, the place where they're going to do the head start, [1:17:18] some of those other offices, is more conducive for a neighborhood commercial overlay, [1:17:22] and then they're going to allow some uses outright [1:17:26] and the document I'm scrolling down to is basically the ZDA. [1:17:30] This is the R4 zoning district. These are going to be the permitted uses. [1:17:34] What used to be some of these used to be special uses which require [1:17:38] another public hearing. When we go through this ZDA process, we feel like [1:17:43] there's so many public hearings already. [1:17:44] Three public meetings, two hearings. [1:17:47] The public meetings are the first one. [1:17:49] It's at a planning and zoning commission [1:17:51] that basically talk about the project. [1:17:53] We take comments. [1:17:54] The second meeting is a public hearing. [1:17:56] It's notified of everybody within at least 500 feet, [1:17:59] not the property boundary in this case. [1:18:01] 750 for those on the northeast part. [1:18:04] I have another public hearing with the council again [1:18:06] to talk about the uses. [1:18:07] And as we declare all of those, [1:18:09] those that would be interested should know [1:18:12] be notified of what's happening for plexus or something part. So some of these uses you can tell [1:18:22] there's the dwellings of the triplex and foreplex we've made as a or they've asked to be permitted [1:18:28] which means they just go and get a builder. Things they asked about is to build multiple [1:18:39] dwelling units on a lot. This is all going on by one entity. Most buildings in the R4 district [1:18:45] as a single family home you require each building to be on its own lot. In this case it's going to be [1:18:50] be almost 120 some odd units or more on one single lot because they're going to own it [1:18:56] entirely and manage it all. [1:18:59] All that is allowing that portion is allowing that there's some other site development criteria [1:19:05] for private streets to allow smaller streets of the more pedestrian friendly. [1:19:10] Some of those types of aesthetic things that they're looking for. [1:19:13] Neighborhood commercial does this similar. [1:19:15] They allow for permitted uses such as a doctor's office, a clinic, a rehab service, the park [1:19:21] and auditorium school, the list you can see going down. [1:19:26] Those, some of those items are special uses. [1:19:28] This process, we feel like criteria, they're asking for a similar, [1:19:43] it's a private street criteria that they're looking for. [1:19:45] Go from here, city council makes a decision on any zoning map amendment. [1:19:56] So what we're doing tonight is we're amending the zoning map. [1:19:58] We're creating the R4 NCO, ZDA, which will become its own ordinance. [1:20:03] We'll bring the later date along with this document detailing each of the items. [1:20:07] to the items they're looking to be deviated from our normal code section, might once that's [1:20:13] codified and or the ordinance is approved and it is recorded and published. [1:20:17] They can then pursue building permits for their project. [1:20:23] Council determines the proposed request appropriate. [1:20:26] You can approve it as presented subject to the following conditions. [1:20:29] We only have one which is a site plan of M&S as required by building engineering for zoning [1:20:34] officials to comply with applicable city codes and standards. [1:20:38] is a process for that, where those aren't listed as, [1:21:00] and it uses that that, the process for how would that work? [1:21:05] It may, so it depends on what the permitted and special uses are [1:21:08] in that neighborhood commercial. [1:21:10] I believe there's some allowance for some type of smaller retail establishments [1:21:13] in that neighborhood commercial overlay, [1:21:17] or going through our changing Marzony codes, [1:21:20] if it were amended to allow it in the future, [1:21:22] then we'd go with whatever the base zoning code is permitting. [1:21:25] So it could, to possibility, could come back here and depends on the use. [1:21:29] on the use of the, so the pace down in there would be the neighborhood commercials, right? [1:21:33] Overland had to say that that's what your plan is, but... [1:21:38] For the examples they gave us for the housing that they're looking at doing, [1:21:54] since they provided them, we'll be looking for similar housing materials [1:21:57] when they come back through their billing permits. [1:21:59] Council so we won't project that there's two speaking address on the record. [1:22:46] Edwards Twin Falls, we always hear about all these folks that come from other countries, [1:23:02] countries come here to assimilate and be part of our community. We shouldn't give them any special [1:23:10] interest, but we're building a ghetto. La Colonia is similar to this. They build a community for [1:23:24] illegal immigrants and refugees and whoever else can shoot the system to get into one of these [1:23:31] facilities and we're segregating them off from the rest of the community. Whatever happened to [1:23:38] the integration, whatever happened to a simulation. [1:23:42] This is not a simulation. [1:23:43] This is building a separate community, [1:23:44] or we can have a fire station and a police station, [1:23:47] and a other facility there specifically for themselves. [1:23:54] This is not suitable to an inclusive city. [1:23:59] I think it's disgusting that we're even talking [1:24:02] about this kind of thing. [1:24:04] You know, I'm sure they got to have housing. [1:24:06] Well, the people that bring these in here, [1:24:08] The dairy industry wouldn't they provide housing for these folks. [1:24:13] You know, they're needed by the dairy industry and we keep saying, oh, look at how we're doing [1:24:18] this. [1:24:19] We need all these people because Americans won't do it, so we're bringing these folks in [1:24:27] and now we're going to give them a housing project, we're going to give them medical care, [1:24:30] we're going to give them separate education. [1:24:33] Why can't we do this for veterans, why can't we do it for the elderly? [1:24:40] This is ridiculous. [1:24:42] This should be for everybody. [1:24:44] If we're going to build something like this, it shouldn't be for immigration or immigrant [1:24:52] workers or refugees or illegal aliens. [1:24:56] This should be for citizens of Twin Falls and it opened to all of them. [1:25:02] Now I would suspect that they could say, well, we can handle that. [1:25:06] just have a check-off sheet that you apply to get accepted into this facility and we'll [1:25:15] just make it so like with Biz you put a minimum bid and minimum requirements for a bid and [1:25:22] you knowing that the person that you want to win the bid can only produce that product that [1:25:29] you're asking for a bid because it's so limited so they could do that they could say yeah well [1:25:34] will let you apply for it. Oh, I'm sorry. You don't qualify. [1:25:38] You have 30 seconds left since I know I'm on the screen. [1:25:42] I didn't see any time. I just set the timer on the screen, so I was letting you know you have 30 seconds left. [1:25:47] Well, I appreciate that. Just keep that in mind that, you know, you're creating a ghetto, [1:25:52] and that ghetto is going to be a problem in the future. So, next time we have a minority group come in here, [1:25:59] do we create another ghetto for them? [1:26:01] As anyone else who wishes to provide on this land use request, work with several non-profits. [1:26:54] I'm out of Salt Lake, but I work for two non-profits out of Salt Lake, Western Region non-profit [1:26:59] and salt and work working since 2008 in Western Region to do specific developments in affordable [1:27:17] housing. [1:27:19] We use low income housing tax credits to finance these allocated through the Idaho Housing [1:27:24] and Finance Association. [1:27:25] and this is a competitive process because the allocations are basically what you find [1:27:32] projects. Unfortunately, there's not enough of these things to go around affordable housing [1:27:39] as a crisis right now in our communities. Incomes are going up, rents are going up, but [1:27:48] they're not fast enough to support or can exhibit the service industries, valuable services for us, [1:28:00] But happened to earn a little bit lower wages. [1:28:03] This is one of the first things I said when I was interviewed as a consultant. [1:28:08] But this is not more. [1:28:13] This is specifically affordable housing. [1:28:17] So we're not going to be able to put preference on our weightless and things for race specifically. [1:28:27] Going into this, that we were changing the neighborhood and direction of this community. [1:28:33] There will be rent and income that will have to be with fair housing and be segregated in a diversion to anybody. [1:28:53] In fact, I wanted to tell you that we will have three units set aside as permanent supportive housing. [1:29:00] Those are very, very low income housing. [1:29:03] There are supportive services to help people that are basically transitional housing and be supported in a community of 60 units. [1:29:15] permanent supportive housing doesn't work if you have a 60 unit project or [1:29:20] a 28 project of just transitional housing. We are integrating a lot of [1:29:28] these groups into the housing so that they do get the response. There are several [1:29:32] income tiers that will be happening on the housing. 30% all the way up to 60% [1:29:40] and anybody from Twin Falls can come and be supported a decent safe [1:29:52] for housing, subsidize rent, although that is there's a place for that as well. [1:30:00] Those are very housing options that really are valuable in the community. [1:30:05] The housing work for housing is also very valuable. [1:30:08] And this is subject to fair housing. [1:30:12] Anyone else who wishes to answer for the last? [1:31:05] Housing for the starting jobs, just breaking into, we have struggled [1:32:12] finding people willing to partner with and help us take on these challenges and [1:32:18] build places where people can be proud to call at their home back to the [1:32:26] community and become a part of Twin Paul. I appreciate the fact that somebody is [1:32:31] willing to step up to the plate now with this. Not very many years ago we had [1:32:36] someone else who developed something similar to this west of town, just [1:32:41] west of the hospital and it's a nice development. I know my last campaign I [1:32:46] not been a real success and a help to our community. And thirdly, this particular, this neighborhood [1:32:58] is near and dear to me. My daughter-in-law grew up in that neighborhood and it has made her [1:33:03] who she is today. The most wonderful wife to my son, a wonderful mother, a part of my family [1:33:10] and life. To see this property become something nicer and more fitting for this community, [1:33:17] I would be so proud to be set to say I'm a part of that. Thank you for bringing this [1:33:21] I would just add, 1942 is when this neighborhood would be here. [1:33:36] I think sometimes we forget was that was 76 years ago. [1:33:40] That is a significant that this residence would have been a part of some of Suzanne's comments. [1:33:53] I think the investment and the services expand the opportunities for those who live there. [1:34:01] The services that are provided. [1:35:25] Yes, Mr. Fareed. Yes, the motion passes 6 to 0. [1:35:30] Very thank you and thanks to the entire team from the Community Council. [1:35:35] Didoration item TEA presentation from the City Manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2019, followed by an opportunity for citizen input specific to the budget and the city manager. [1:36:25] And so I'm going to start today with, we've already seen this slide, basically we're submitting to a [1:36:31] budget that meets all these high standards. But right here I want to tell you a new information, [1:36:39] so some of the slides we're going to look at today, you're going to, if you're following along [1:36:43] really closely, you'll notice that there's a few changes tonight from the past couple of [1:36:50] three weeks. And so let me just tell you briefly what some of those are. Okay, so I'm working with [1:37:00] with the county, we have, and we see this every year, right, where we get some updated [1:37:05] information as we're going along. We got some updated information this last week, [1:37:08] and the first one I'm going to tell you about is that last year's market value actually changed for us. [1:37:15] That's interesting because I'm not talking about next year's, I'm talking about the [1:37:20] market value actually changed, so we got an additional $241,000 worth of that. What that did is it [1:37:28] It actually changed last year's levy rate, so decreased by 0.00. [1:37:37] It's actually less than the levy rate we've been sharing with you. [1:37:48] New construction also decreased, that decreased from 52,000,000 to 52,000,000. [1:38:01] That causes a slight decrease in our proposed [1:38:05] Tax dollars, a slight decrease being about $2,080 less than what we have taxable value for next year, also has decreased slightly [1:38:20] 2.866, okay, so that also changes our proposed levy rate that we are increases, we talked about $7.31 [1:38:40] Now be $7.33 dollars in excess value. [1:38:46] And lastly, we had some new annexations that got added to the role, $1,600,000 in the annexation value that increases revenue in that room in the new annexation by $12,000. [1:39:03] So in the end, the total impact of these changes in the $4,077,68 budget, $4,077 is getting [1:39:21] the split, basically makes some minor $2,000 worth of tweaks, or you know what's happening. [1:39:53] The slides that we've shown you for the last three weeks are going to have the new numbers [1:39:56] reflected, so 68,167,383 dollars is the new slides. [1:40:10] So again, a few changes. [1:40:13] This one shows you the new taxable value. [1:40:15] You can see the reduction there, that's [1:40:22] at 2.83 cents per $1,000 in value. [1:40:36] And so that's kind of compared to last year's $7.43. [1:40:42] So we're still projecting a decrease in a sense. [1:40:46] You can just ask any time. [1:40:57] You know, just a sec. [1:41:04] You've seen this slide before. [1:41:06] Just trying to show you the trend and median hope [1:41:08] that is the reason why I'm showing you that slide. [1:41:10] So I can show you this next one. [1:41:13] And I need to talk about a change we made [1:41:15] this one too. Basically if we apply our rate to the median home values this is kind of the total [1:41:21] tax burden that we can expect to see. We showed you this new table a couple of weeks ago where we [1:41:28] added Boise and Buridian and then through the ACHD so you can kind of see with it without ACHD. [1:41:35] One thing that's changed here and this was a math error that we found today, the Boise rate of [1:41:44] $953. We actually had that last week down at like $880. We had Miss Cowker, we did the math [1:41:51] wrong and all water's exemption to that number eight. And so, actually moved out on the list [1:42:05] to $953. So, Boise's tax rate, and I think it was great, I think you should mention this, [1:42:11] that next week you can see that Boise, you know, ACHD, tops the list, pair ourselves, [1:42:29] We're pretty, and this slide is going to talk about the impact of this proposed budget on the individual, and we change this a little bit. [1:42:58] So if I look to 36, actually me as well. [1:43:28] So we have the water in the sewer and sanitation rates and there's well those rates added to the sawts. [1:43:57] Really that's very similar to the last one we've been trying. [1:44:01] It's just a slight tweak the post. [1:44:35] So we were seeing it reverse. [1:44:54] So, the additional that we have. [1:44:59] It's really the sweetest. [1:45:24] It's a new sense for 1,000. [1:45:32] Okay, so that's all the overall big picture stuff we're going to jump into, [1:45:51] how this particular budget ties to our strategic plan. [1:45:55] Specifically tonight, I'm going to talk about healthy community, which is folks area one, [1:45:59] and prosperous community, which is folks who are six. [1:46:02] I kind of highlighted those a little bit there for us to first talk [1:46:08] talk of mine is what we're trying to accomplish here in healthy community it is [1:46:23] like a minute just about this first slide and then I'm gonna get Kevin [1:46:53] skeleton was on our US representative from the parks department and everything [1:47:00] that we're gonna talk about me is parks department expenses before he gets up [1:47:06] here I want to talk to you a little bit about parking lot maintenance I told you [1:47:10] a couple weeks ago we're gonna be spending some money on parking lot maintenance I [1:47:15] think at the time I said I need to back up a little bit and tell you that what we've [1:47:20] got in the budget is $250,000 for parking. [1:47:22] It isn't necessarily specific to our park. [1:47:31] Plus, for the street department, actually, [1:47:32] the street department might take the lead on this, [1:47:34] spending this money, because they do this kind of stuff. [1:47:38] They do even so, where there's a great and cheap seal [1:47:49] contracts are going, various kind of variables, [1:47:53] and we're gonna up to our cheap seal money [1:48:07] in the street department. [1:48:49] The first batch will probably focus on some parks, [1:48:53] but you know, we had, in fact, [1:49:07] isn't that great analysis of all the city parking lots [1:49:19] including some public ones downtown here. [1:49:22] The two over at the senior center. [1:49:24] We have parks all over the place. [1:49:26] We've got parking lots that are basically all the city parking lots [1:49:32] and just making the street department cheap this time. [1:51:52] Those things that you had in your house, [1:56:03] it was actually called Slaughterhouse Creek, [1:56:05] because it was a slaughterhouse. [1:56:07] So this building has served its time well. [1:56:10] There's just equipment outside, [1:56:23] I don't want to probably start to see a theme as I talked the same kind of as well you saw with the we saw with consistent [2:03:03] the other great expenses this year. In addition that there's a slide that I didn't put up here but I'll talk to you a little bit about it because I think it's kind of important. [2:03:12] There's some money, a little bit of money for some efforts through soil, you'll take apart and there's some money in there for these soil this year and you'll be planting them. [2:03:50] I might see some cap where I didn't have a slide up there for the new personnel request and resist not putting it swimsuit on these guys for a quick couple of weeks ago. [2:04:19] Skinning it up the one, so it looks a little bit more fit, but that probably still takes [2:04:26] So the new, the new personnel, this is really new in, okay, so that was the city facility at that time [2:04:46] In John, the rest of the pool, like Personal Plus are all temp employees, right? [2:05:01] And that's kind of how we did some things, and then earlier this year back in like the January, February timeframe [2:05:07] We started to evaluate that process, and it actually shifted away from using employees [2:05:15] There's a number of reasons for that, and we think it was the right decision to make, and so basically at that point, all those temporary employees who weren't city employees at the time had just showed up as a... [2:05:26] There's most of them are... those guys became time city employees back in like March, and so this is just a correction of the budget to recognize that we have two additional full-time city employees now that you have the reasons that we did this as a projected cost savings, and we actually expect that in a year we'll see something like a $25,000 year savings. [2:06:13] We haven't got a year under our bill yet, so we can't really do no employees, but like [2:06:27] you said, they've been here for a while. [2:06:29] I know that one's a guy and one is a girl, so that's why I had to put one in it. [2:06:36] So that's our new employee count for Focus Area 1. [2:06:40] So with that, I'm about to switch gears to Focus Area 6. [2:06:43] So if you have any questions, this would be a good time. [2:06:52] I would maybe be the accessible, because they also made some sense there. [2:07:07] Is the second one going to end? [2:07:24] This is the one through access to applying with regional partners to ensure [2:07:37] I'm in center, and I hear the vision language talks to you about is his much of this coming year [2:08:10] and cancel. [2:08:12] So economic development is not very in monies and we're requesting probably not. [2:08:27] So what we're actually looking for new monies to do is cut ourselves. [2:08:30] We've been tasked with maybe in situ to kind of raise our profile past. [2:09:03] We share a message. [2:09:08] I think that's got us to a point that we're sort of coming to a close and I did this two weeks [2:09:33] because I thought I'd do it again here plus I want to show you my pictures when we're done. [2:09:39] That's the summary of our new personnel for tonight. We got two people that we already talked with this whole cap all together, so there's questions, again, about to go into a foregone conversation, so for the last few weeks, I do have some changes to the slides tonight again. [2:10:06] This is about because of the changes that we saw in tax rate and valuation of the community, and so most of the numbers on this have changed slightly like a penny or two, so 733 last week was 731. [2:10:23] But anyway, this table shows you what would happen to our tax rate on taking the same [2:10:35] taken chunks of 500,000 after that. [2:10:37] So that's for your information. [2:10:39] We can certainly rotate back to this at any point in the conversation. [2:10:43] But I want to show you this next slide, too. [2:10:45] This is a new slide that we hadn't shown you before. [2:10:47] But we thought it might be helpful for the conversation tonight. [2:10:51] So again, this one here is what happens to your tax rate. [2:10:55] If we take some of the money, this one here is a historic look at what our tax rate has [2:10:59] been since 2012, so we can see that we are at 7.033 cents per 1,000, was proposing for next [2:11:09] year, that's a decrease from last year, significant decrease from two years ago. [2:11:13] That historic data we thought would be helpful for you as you conversation. [2:11:23] Again, I'll come back to this if you want me to come back to this too, but I wanted to [2:11:28] show you this slide and I'll talk to you a little bit about this slide too as well. [2:11:33] last week Jackie came to the meeting and shared with you some [2:11:37] assessments on some of those projects that the council had talked about wanting [2:11:41] to learn a little bit more about I'm sorry put those numbers in here for you to see [2:11:46] I separated the list out so on the next page here these are the ones that we [2:11:52] showed you before that you had elected not to talk about I still have them there [2:11:57] if we want to go back and add them in late these are the cost estimates and I'm [2:12:03] gonna add them to be determined when I have okay so Easton and Hillcrest the [2:12:09] road widening projects, east and west, and then falls at Blue Lakes. Those are construction [2:12:15] and right-of-way acquisition costs. So that's the total together. So 1.1 of relays a few [2:12:28] weeks ago. They're the costs that we hold out of the street budget to fund the sidewalk [2:12:33] and we had those numbers handy. It's easy to put back in if you want to put sidewalk [2:12:42] jobs and talk to you a little bit about that $87,000 for Federation. There was a cost [2:12:47] that we got from an engineer at the HM to say that we think you could do this for this [2:12:53] much money that engineer was working with my city and says hey we could do this [2:13:03] 87,000 job our ground is something would like to partner that 87 would just be if [2:13:12] with traditional bit of ice some materials maybe I do some work piece of it [2:13:38] that material city so as far as cost goes we're doing some other work I don't [2:14:01] need some some right of sidewalk jobs that are really separate but the price [2:14:31] that we have is from a grant application that we made last year, [2:14:35] and we'd lumped them together into one rice, and that was $275,000 to do both of those projects. [2:14:41] Have a good split outside the applicant. [2:14:49] This sidewalk to Rock Creek, I'll view as 181 miles access road, [2:15:07] because that is completely dependent on the scale of the job. [2:15:10] Obviously, that could be a $3.5 million job recommendation from Jack. [2:15:17] The first step for that being this kind of a public average sort of a process, [2:15:22] process, like the process can't define what that process might cost $500, $600,000 to get [2:15:35] through it, but in estimated, since it's her concept of what that product pulls some of [2:16:03] the keys, but those are the conversations that are under these are the projects that we showed [2:16:41] you in the last couple of weeks. I'm pretty solid estimates. Some will make me estimate [2:17:44] 768. Exactly for you, and it's the matter. I did smell and looked at the smaller projects [2:18:49] and did not make any adjustment on Federation Northside with Moutech, that total was 855,400 [2:19:01] without allocating anything to any of the other projects, which for me sounds like a pretty [2:19:12] is it possible to allocate 500,000 to the social falls road without being able to do something [2:19:23] The words in your mouth a little bit was that he talked to me about object estimate. [2:19:34] She had suggested this five or six hundred thousand with that right off the bat would be [2:19:40] Crouchon. [2:20:09] Let's see how that impacts the tax rate. [2:20:18] The Chisholm fall, but Chisholm falls off another thousand of the foregone and take care [2:20:44] of Harrison. [2:20:45] 3600 in the grand view and take care of those crossings to the school which to me is the highest priority that we see and if we did 500,000 that would leave up 47 left to put towards the Federation Project should map tech be ready to move forward. [2:21:03] Okay, so we're sitting over here and we certainly don't want to challenge the numbers, but we would suggest that $500,000 and just really looking very closely in a larger conversation about that as a priority moving forward. [2:21:28] We can't tell if it's the right number or the right, it seems to challenge Jackie's numbers. [2:21:39] I only say that because when we compare water facility planned at a half a million dollars or $30,000 and so on, [2:21:47] it just seems to be a bit different. [2:21:49] So, allow us as a staff to spend some time perfecting those types of numbers [2:21:55] with the recognition that this is ongoing money. [2:21:59] When you incorporate the money, the foregone balance in budget [2:22:05] It is money that would continue to our budgetary process until the council made the decision to reduce spending, which then at one point what you'd be doing is if you didn't take this ballot and the full 3% and the new construction in subsequent years, you'd be adding to the ballot, so that $8.55,000, it is ongoing money and that would allow us to spend some time on some projects that we have with the public. [2:22:42] that we have defined and have much better cost estimates, [2:22:46] we can spend the next several weeks perfecting numbers, [2:22:51] drive them through and be better prepared to spend allocation [2:23:00] on long-term projects moving forward. [2:23:02] So what's going to happen is if I understand your question, [2:23:40] and Laurie has fully prepared me with an email to read to you this evening. [2:23:44] So what you're going to do is you're going to, [2:23:48] You're going to have to prepare a resolution, and then you're going to adopt that resolution, [2:23:55] and it is going to describe the specific amount, as well as the purpose in which those revenues [2:24:02] are going to be used to process, in which your conversation you're having is set for the [2:24:25] next six o'clock, once that resolution is proved as well as to the item. [2:24:48] So, yeah, you're running next week, we have to set the maximum spending. [2:25:24] Next week you have to set the maximum spending that is going to then drive the resolution. [2:25:29] So we'll have a resolution at next week's meeting. Briefly recess once you. [2:25:36] Unless you're ready tonight to set an amount but we'll briefly recess, we'll have a resolution. [2:25:43] Jeff, these things I would judge if they're so right. [2:26:23] Those are painted guesses and tell you actually go through the recess to require a relevant that she has. [2:26:44] Like on the Shoshone Falls piece is we say we want to improve the road, [2:26:49] possibilities to improve, and so then we're asking her really the impossible to ask on what could that be said. [2:27:00] We want to leave it in different legend as opposed to what Shoshone said, [2:32:05] but if I get it wrong, they will walk up to the podium really fast, watch this. [2:32:10] So last year is right around $110,000. [2:32:13] You gave $25,000 to transfer the city's commitment to $1000. [2:32:34] So what we choose budget is we script out, let's say it's $25,000, $1,000, all 15 outside of that process. [2:32:56] So that would have, is that not quite? [2:32:58] It was actually $45,000, then we were obligated to. [2:33:06] So, but the, we found the balance of the funds, so the, I, or the, because not the, I, but the [2:33:12] but the mplug piece is 110 minus 25, I believe, [2:33:16] for the allocation set, but that was? [2:33:18] So it's 85,000, this one remains in the... [2:33:24] So I actually think under the line, I didn't... [2:33:49] What's available, there's still 110,000 in the sister position, [2:33:59] and we split the 45, so what I'm saying is, [2:34:03] if we continue the same process, [2:34:05] what's the pot that we have decision [2:35:06] to outsource grants will not exist next year? [2:35:09] It gives for several months lead to the purposes that some of those applicants [2:35:25] have considered something like this is critical, so we're going to crisis center [2:35:35] and there are tears against violence and the services that they provide, [2:35:39] least department that's considered some sort of a that same need as help us highlight specific organizations [2:36:26] to meet parts council and we want to put a piece of art in like the one that [2:36:32] Chris spearheaded down the corner down there. We just kind of turned it over to the archcats [2:36:36] They took care of it first. They took care of the bidding process thing [2:36:41] So that was part of that [2:36:44] Fund teases me we couldn't do it ourselves [2:36:52] Relations out there that this budget and they always say this is the last year for it and we give it my year [2:37:12] Or so the year for a lead time again, it's only 85,000 out of [2:37:17] nearly [2:37:19] 68 to 71 million depend on the year, but some of those organizations absolutely 100% rely on those funds. [2:37:27] They get some of it may be processed in philosophy or processed thing, so let's use the Arts Councils example. [2:39:46] That's not to say that we don't them that says we want to do this earth piece down here, and services cost and requests, and we're going to PIDS and let's us through really an excursion. [2:40:11] I go to their graduations, I show support, the official, or as a human to the places where [2:41:46] I can really see their doing thing. [2:41:49] We needed to our budget in line items is really so during the accused myself. [2:41:55] Our budget, that really made me weren't sure the future of these grants were going to be, [2:42:01] but I would feel better making just this sense in this community. [2:42:12] I can see your thoughts. [2:42:25] future of these grants we're going to be that I would feel better making just this [2:42:59] sense of this community. I can see your thoughts. I guess I would ask Travis if we [2:43:11] take this out of this 85,000 I did this one time waiting the process. I took 85,000 out of the budget and [2:43:17] they didn't go on it in Emcorn, they just evaporated. I don't want to see that but also [2:43:23] see voices on the violence I see some other programs that I would like to see put it [2:43:30] into a portion of the budget that the police department could do a separate contract with [2:43:36] them because they show up there with people, officers, maybe I'm incorrect on it, they show [2:43:42] up with the doors with people. These are all programs that Francis determined that we could [2:43:50] be doing as a city or they can't even apply. Though that doesn't mean that some we shouldn't [2:43:57] be doing if it's something that city or cities in the state of Idaho provide as a service. [2:44:03] That's something we decide on. [2:44:05] It's our decision whether we fund those programs or at least if we're going to go this route [2:44:11] that I want to say that money gets split up into. [2:44:14] Other or other parts of the budget that they have in mirror mark for potential contracts [2:44:19] with these nonprofits to provide a service to the city which they are definitely providing [2:44:25] to the city, just like Sean said, a contract for the Arch Council War, the police department [2:44:30] for victims against violence or whatever the term, the top terminology, I was like, there [2:44:37] are other resenters, I don't want to see the 75,000 just evaporate. [2:44:47] So to answer Councilman Lentick's question, when you adopt the budget, you're going to [2:44:54] adopt an ordinance that talks about the entire spending of the city. You look at the tax rate, [2:45:04] That's going to be really driven by the amount of tax revenues that you're going to bring [2:45:08] and ask to collect into the system. [2:45:12] Shifting dollars, so long as they still remain, these are property tax dollars that you, so [2:45:20] long as you keep those into those property tax funds, we can move from different general [2:45:27] fund categories throughout that entire year. [2:45:31] You can move them to the agency fund and have this conversation later, but just so long [2:45:36] as you adopt a budget that reflects the [2:45:40] impact dollars still there. [2:45:42] And because they're property tax dollars, you're going to describe that very [2:45:46] specific and exact amount. [2:45:48] Those dollars are made in there and you can shift them and move them [2:45:52] in really a site to preserve the conversation [2:46:06] to enter into specific contractual relationships for services [2:46:10] with the different partners that were laid out. That is all totally within [2:46:14] within your works and, for example, [2:47:59] Travis said it said, [2:49:02] that we say, well, because it says it's an impot, [2:49:10] doesn't mean it has to stay an impot. [2:49:12] We can change it in any time. [2:49:18] Sorry. [2:49:18] I think we do probably owe it to the nonprofits [2:49:22] that have put in an applications in the past [2:49:27] sooner than later, [2:49:28] just so we can put this issue to bed [2:49:32] instead of getting closer to the time [2:49:34] and then having everybody freak out. [2:49:37] So, yeah, I think we should do it as fast as possible. [2:49:46] Process, we will also just, we'll consult with the... [2:50:01] Look, it is either the second meet or so. [2:51:05] You might see them next week having a good time. [2:51:32] So what is that? [2:51:40] It sounds like there is a ceiling of about one point [2:51:45] others that's been proposed. [2:51:46] Certainly that's not what everyone is suggesting [2:51:49] that be taken, suggested, is now associated with. [2:52:30] What's also important is, because you adopt a resolution and it declares that you, it does not mean that the 6th, you're going to set the matter spell out that conversation is still very active until August and New Gessments to what F is recommending. [2:53:09] I'd never say you suggest we do this, but early on when our foreground wasn't nearly that big of a... [2:53:23] And the full foregone amount, and then that gave us up. [2:53:35] I'm the sixth, going some lower. [2:53:47] I'm not suggesting that because our foregone is much larger than what's in those days. [2:53:52] And to leave ourselves in the middle room, we suggest the full one point to try and staff if we did that because they could make the resolution. [2:54:13] I would suggest that because we have an additional reporting request, because we want to share with the public what we are doing. [2:54:26] I would suggest that you try to whittle that close to what you're thinking, but no intentless [2:54:54] that as an option is counsel's not in favor of taking one thumb, sort of, if that is a collective [2:55:14] group where you stand today. [2:55:16] The more work that you can do to whittle that down for us as a staff tonight, and I guess [2:55:21] I understand the night easier it would for us, especially. [2:56:14] So, um, I just need a clarification of what Phase 1 on Shoshan Falls might be costing. [2:56:24] I've heard 500, I've heard maybe 250. [2:56:28] Oh, because that really drives this. [2:56:35] So what we would suggest is, so that's really hard for Jackie to do, and I think that she [2:56:46] may be the best number that she could have since understanding what we want to do on the conversation [2:56:57] What does the roadway look like? [2:56:59] But there's going to be some [2:57:02] Devsum under the basic project. [2:57:08] I will say that [2:57:11] I'm just going to jump in. [2:57:26] Is there a chance to get a jump start [2:57:28] on plenty of subsequent years? [2:57:31] And remember that we always have the option. [2:57:39] The city is very fortunate on sitting on [2:57:42] some healthy reserve accounts [2:57:45] and if that project were something [2:57:47] that we want to advance forward through a public engagement process [2:57:50] we could spend some time to what's interested. [2:57:55] So, I guess, and then nobody checked my math, so when I added up all those projects, smaller projects without Shoshone files, I got 855,000 or 100, so if we're not going to include Shoshone files, I would be comfortable with that number. [2:58:27] We want to round it up to 900. [2:58:30] Maybe that gets Travis a little more direction. [2:58:34] Sorry, did you check my math? [2:59:11] Okay. [3:00:41] 87,000 out from the Federation North Side Project because we really don't know what we could drop that number to just under 800,000. [3:00:51] And we could still do the road overlays and the sidewalk improvements by the school, which are the four projects that keep rising to the top. [3:00:58] top instead of taking that 87 that we really don't know what is I don't see any [3:01:04] reason to raise taxes any you know to that level if we don't have to so I would [3:01:09] propose that we do if my math's right seven hundred and sixty eight thousand [3:01:14] three hundred eighty eight yes that's what I'm figuring as well I think it's [3:02:54] gonna be close it does go to research the project never came to fruition so it wasn't [3:04:17] used for this purpose and wasn't reassigned to another. [3:04:26] The conversations that I've been a part of that there's going to be a solution that is not [3:04:31] going to not certainly believe that's the current secure additional right away as well [3:04:54] as two prepareals that are outside of what would be 2070. [3:05:07] But in the state that we needed to not have the same problem, but it's the same thing we [3:07:05] have reserves and water to fix that now. [3:07:13] We can't say, well, we're going to fix that here from now because that's how long it takes [3:07:16] for our money to get there, in effect, actually. [3:07:21] And so, to preserve for a reason, I've worked too many years in school districts that had no reserves. [3:07:28] I mean, there was time for me to borrow money, health reserves for the emergencies, because you know they're coming. [3:07:39] Then there's going to be a discussion which described that but it gets sidewalks as an on-go expense. [3:08:40] A hundred and seventy thousand million dollars of sidewalks deficiencies and our efficiencies be victful. [3:09:04] So, Biden decides, again, $770,000 that we can have, [3:09:16] a separate and distinct conversation with, you know, [3:09:18] basis about how would best spend been 60 instead of 60, [3:10:33] 80 or 70? [3:10:34] My name is Dave Moore, and I reside in City of Twin Falls. [3:11:35] And my discussion with my representative was that I am concerned [3:11:40] that the City of Twin Falls is looking way too hard [3:11:43] at saving money and infrastructure. [3:11:48] How old was that water pipe that broke? [3:11:50] broke over to we have that are going how much time is being spent look at the [3:12:02] bigger picture for the longer term is to save money that $50 isn't in my taxes [3:12:13] lose businesses lose growth potentials reputation of the city of being up [3:12:27] to see the city to be placing antiquated crisis bases to elf into [3:12:54] That's the next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input if there's anybody else to cancel and ask your chance to come forward. [3:13:42] Lucy's sentiment, Lucy Wells, I'm going to disagree with her sentiment. [3:13:57] As I've been polling other communities around, we're about dealing with one left with this public input. [3:14:03] I'm not saying we irrelevant, but everyone else has chosen to strike it. [3:14:08] I'm not sure that her idea about putting it at the end of that bad idea. [3:14:12] Just for food for thought, we do it on the do it today in reaction to anything, but we've been over the last couple of years, spent hours to begin to get to the business, and if they are that interested, they'll stay. [3:14:29] And that's, they're more appropriate than we don't have people waiting for their portion on the agenda. [3:14:35] on the agenda. There's schedules on the agenda. They have a recent white [3:14:38] expectation that there if they're the second item they're going to be somewhere [3:14:42] at 5 10 or 5 15 not at 6 15 or 7 15 or what we've had in the past. Just food for [3:14:50] them. [3:14:50] It was survey down and so right next center get slash. Just also remind us also [3:17:24] So the Purple Heart Ceremony, [3:17:44] turn to Executive Session, under item 74206C, [3:17:54] and 74261F, the Council for the Public Agency [3:18:00] to discuss the legal ramifications of [3:18:03] and legal options for pending litigation. [3:18:06] Diversity is not getting the inglidigabial presence [3:18:11] of legal counsel at an executive session. [3:18:13] It's not satisfied. [3:18:14] It's a requirement. [3:18:18] Second. [3:18:24] Executive Session has stated, is there any discussion? [3:18:40] Yes. [3:18:41] Piers? [3:18:42] Yes. [3:18:44] Okay. [3:18:45] Yes. [3:18:51] As a six to zero, we go to executive session just to let everyone know we will not be made [3:18:56] decisions in executive session nor we'll be.