Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-07-09, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-07-09/ [0:01:08] when false city council meeting for Monday July 9th confirm that we do have [0:01:13] on the council all seven members are here this evening. The next item on the [0:01:16] agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. I see we have some scouts in the audience. [0:01:20] Are you guys scouts too? Would you all mind coming down and leading us in the [0:01:24] Pledge of Allegiance this evening and does it you wish me to join us please rise. [0:01:27] If you guys run off from this right in front of you right here, please come [0:02:02] forward and tell us your name and your troop and what badge you're working on [0:02:08] this evening please. My name is Dr. Stevens I'm from troop 100 and we're working on our communications [0:02:16] verbiage. Awesome welcome. My name is Diyash Rong and I'm from troop 100 and I'm working on my community. [0:02:26] Thank you. Mark Ysera and I'm working on citizens in the troop 79. My name is Chase Barlow and also [0:02:44] from troop 79 and I'm working on citizenship in the community. You're this evening. Next on the [0:02:54] agenda are proclamations of which we have none this evening so next will be a [0:02:58] chance for general public input if there's anyone here from the public who wishes [0:03:02] to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening now is [0:03:05] your opportunity to please come forward seeing no one consent count Chris [0:03:20] Stockington the best operation in the city park is coming Saturday beginning at 10 [0:03:30] a.m. hundreds of thousands the millions of veterans this serve and [0:03:40] The first few orders will be a cycle right to various places by a button, Chris. [0:03:58] So next on the agenda is the consent calendar, Council wishes Suzanne Hawkins. [0:04:05] If we can separate out the minutes and the payables, I was not at last week's meeting and I don't feel like I should vote on the minutes. [0:04:12] The motion by Chris Reed seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the accounts payable as presented, Chris Stockington. [0:04:42] I was trying to have a question of about $633,000 expenditure from Rock Creek, [0:04:49] So it is a funded project and I believe it's part of the bond reserves that we're using and the [0:04:59] Glaismy is going to come down and give you a quick status update on that project [0:05:03] But this goes back to the waste water treatment plant [0:05:07] Reserve are six million dollars that were as a part of the [0:05:11] 38 million at least we can talk about other discussion from the council Amy roll call. Oh, please [0:05:49] John Berriger? Yes. Nicky Boyd? Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes. And Chris Talkington? Yes. [0:06:07] Which passes 7-0. Would entertain a motion on the July 2nd City Council minutes Christopher Reed? Second. [0:06:23] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the minutes of the July 2nd meeting, is there any? [0:06:30] Nicky Boyd, Susanne Hawkins, abstain. [0:06:47] Abstain. [0:06:50] Yes. [0:06:53] Board is zero with three abstentions. Next on the agenda under items of consideration, we have a presentation on the finances of the City of Twin Falls for nine months of fiscal year 2017 through 2018. [0:07:21] This is an overview of the tax-supported funds and the three major enterprise funds, water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:07:28] We have Lori Race, our Chief Financial Officer. Welcome, Lori. [0:07:32] Thank you. Oh, good evening. Financial presentations. [0:07:42] And since we're there distributed. [0:07:54] So just because I haven't been up here, it doesn't mean you're not very involved in aware of our finances. [0:08:03] But tonight on track and up on the city finances for the last 9 months of the current fiscal year, [0:08:12] a month is 75% so that's going to be our measuring unit. [0:08:19] Tax supported funds, the major revenue sources, the expenditure categories will compare actual [0:08:27] to do the same thing when our price funds, water source, sanitation, don't panic. [0:08:38] So this pie chart is just a reminder of our 9 tax supported funds and the percentage [0:08:44] to make up the total, the largest revenue sources in these funds, comes from property [0:08:51] taxes, franchise fees, state shared revenues, street fund monies, and transfers. [0:08:57] In total, these five revenue sources make up close to 82% of the total revenues in these [0:09:04] funds. [0:09:09] The taxes contribute the largest amount of resources, and the 20.2 million we expect to [0:09:15] receive is about half of our tax-supported fund budget. [0:09:20] The three-year average of receipts this time of year is almost 64% and that does include [0:09:25] delinquency collections. [0:09:27] We're currently at 65% of budget. [0:09:33] Brand size fees make up 5% of the total and they're coming in at 87% of budget. [0:09:39] Now, natural gas has come in ahead of projections and I'm guessing we'll get about $30,000 more [0:09:45] revenue there. [0:09:47] expected to yield an additional $80,000 of revenue, while cable continues its downward trend. [0:09:55] Cable franchise fees reached a high of $272,000 in 2010, but it's projected to come in about [0:10:04] 43% lower this year at $156,000. [0:10:10] State shared revenues are received quarterly, and they account for 10% of the total revenue [0:10:15] in our tax-supported funds. [0:10:18] The prior three-year average of receipts to date in this category is 77% and we currently [0:10:24] stand at almost 78%. [0:10:27] In May, the Idaho Division of Financial Management reported sales tax receipts are forecast to [0:10:33] perform well this fiscal year and they have grown slightly faster than projected. [0:10:40] Dedicated street revenues have two components. [0:10:44] The highway user revenue is on target with a 3-year average of 74% and the other piece [0:10:50] highway M&O is coming in a bit higher than the 4.3% increase I projected. [0:10:57] Transfers are a bit above target, but there was a correction we needed to make from the [0:11:02] impact fee fund to the capital improvement fund. Once that's done, those will be right [0:11:07] on track. So that's a look at our major revenue sources in our tax-supported funds, 75% per [0:11:15] Here, we've received 77% of our budgeted revenues, [0:11:20] and that is above where we typically are, [0:11:22] but the majority of this increase [0:11:24] is due to grant revenues received in our street fund, [0:11:28] and we received some more today. [0:11:33] So for the expenditures in the tax-supported fund, [0:11:36] this slide illustrates the percentage of budget allocated [0:11:39] to each category. [0:11:41] You can see that personnel is the largest piece at 59%, [0:11:46] with M&O at 19, caps at 18, and interfun transfers at 4%. [0:11:54] In reviewing expenditures, expenditure categories [0:11:57] in our nine tax-supported funds, [0:11:59] we start with personnel, and the actual costs include [0:12:03] 20, 26 payrolls, so that should be almost 77%, [0:12:09] not our 75% measure. [0:12:12] We are at about 75%. [0:12:16] M&O is below the benchmark. [0:12:20] costs do not typically come in evenly throughout the year so using a benchmark really doesn't [0:12:26] mean a lot here. But in looking through those actual expenditures we do have final numbers [0:12:31] coming in for the City Hall and Police Station project and we will be including those in [0:12:36] a budget amendment for this fiscal year. Transfers will be right on after a minor correction. [0:12:44] The tax-supported funds are 75% spent three quarters of the way through this fiscal year. [0:12:51] So that's all I have for the tax-supported funds so there are any questions before we move on to enterprise funds. [0:12:58] Chris Stockington, or is there a recall the reason we... [0:13:40] This graph shows actual revenues received for nine months of each fiscal year from two thousand. [0:13:45] When the water fund, this graph shows actual revenues received for nine months of each fiscal year from 2015 through current. [0:14:05] And as you can see at 65% of budget received to date, we're just ahead of our past three-year average of 64.7%. [0:14:16] Personnel costs are actually coming in a tick under the true benchmark for these expenditures. [0:14:28] Remember the 20 out of 26 payrolls is really 69%, or 67%. [0:14:34] And we're just a bit below that at 76.5%. [0:14:39] M&O expenditures are well below budget, costs that are really going to pick up in the summer, [0:14:51] so these expenditures will be substantially increasing. [0:14:55] Capital projects are showing that they're only 56% spent, but much of the reason for this [0:15:01] is the $960,000 we have budgeted for the New Southwell and the Hyperchlorite unit. [0:15:08] We've only spent about 10% of this to date. [0:15:12] They're getting close to putting the bid together to upsize the whole and that we'll be starting on the design in September. [0:15:30] Transfers are as expected and overall we're 50% spent three-quarters of the way through the fiscal year. [0:15:38] In the wastewater fund we start with a look at budgeted revenues for residential, industrial, and municipal users along with actual must receive to date. [0:15:51] This information is provided for the last three years plus current. [0:15:55] The average of the last three years is 75.9% and both are residential and industrial revenues [0:16:04] are on track with budget. [0:16:05] Municipal is just on the expenditure side, personnel costs are below the benchmark. [0:16:19] M&O is above, but that's mostly due to the fact that the wastewater treatment contract [0:16:26] is paid in advance. [0:16:28] So that's really 10 months worth. [0:16:31] Capital expenditures are showing that they are over budget, but the majority of these [0:16:36] are for the collection lines like the $630,000 you talked about earlier. [0:16:41] And they will be included in a budget amendment in September. [0:16:45] This project is a part of the wastewater bond to be paid for with those remaining proceeds. [0:16:49] An interest-only payment was made in the debt category and just like in the water fund, [0:16:56] we'll be paying out of the rest of that later this year. [0:17:00] are right on track and all in all this fund is showing it's 75.6% spent to date [0:17:07] after adjusting that 2 million of collection line costs this fund is closer [0:17:12] to about 56% spent three quarters of the way through the avenues you can see [0:17:25] now perceived here to date is about 75% for all years we are slightly ahead of [0:17:32] that at 76.5% but that's due to the mid-year rate increase implemented the [0:17:38] cost of recycling. Datures in the sanitation fund are very simple. There are no personnel costs. [0:17:50] M&O looks like we're under the benchmark, but only because PSI and the landfill [0:17:55] bill in a rear, so that's only seven months. After adjusting for the June [0:18:01] payments, this category is much closer to about 76% spent to date. There is no [0:18:08] capital and there's no debt in this fund. Transfers are on target. Overall, after [0:18:15] just seeing the M&O expenditures to include the nine payments instead of eight, this budget [0:18:20] is really 76.5% spent a quarter of the way through the fiscal year. [0:18:29] So that's a look at the revenues and expenditures for our three major enterprise funds. Most [0:18:34] revenues are coming in as expected and expenditures are at or below the benchmark for our three [0:18:40] major enterprise funds with explanations for those deviations. We know there are some [0:18:45] approved expenditures that were not anticipated at the beginning of the [0:18:48] fiscal year and they so these financial summaries I present them to you and they [0:18:58] but please know that's exactly what I want it lets credibility that our revenue [0:19:06] projections are sound and that our budgets are being followed as presented [0:19:10] and so so so we do have a Travis can explain on the next month it's thank you [0:20:03] so much presentation I think you get it spot on it's nice to have no surprises [0:20:08] and we have a presentation of the City Manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2019 and [0:20:24] we will have an opportunity for a citizen input of the conclusion of this presentation [0:20:29] and discussion by the Council. [0:20:31] Welcome Travis. [0:20:32] Thank you. [0:20:43] So Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, good evening and it is my pleasure to present to [0:20:49] you what we refer to as the City Manager's recommended budget but I have to tell you that [0:20:54] The process that we used this year really illustrates many helping hands going through [0:21:01] to create and craft this budget. [0:21:04] So as you're aware, we have the long-term planning committee that spends a long period [0:21:10] of time shortly after the first of the years, they explore capital acquisitions, they also [0:21:27] look at staffing levels. [0:21:28] And in those conversations in the past, they've come forward and they've made a series of recommendations to you. [0:21:33] When we had that conversation, they would make that recommendation and that many had felt that, okay, what happened next? [0:21:39] Because then members of the city's management team would go off, we'd take that recommendation, changes to that. [0:21:46] And oftentimes they were often lost as to what happened and what was that disconnected. [0:21:53] So this year they actually made that recommendation to the management team in a collective spirit [0:22:00] Then they also got the opportunity to help us balance the budget because as you know, the long-term planning committee [0:22:07] Has never had the charge of balancing and so we added that piece and so this year this budget was really crafted by about [0:22:15] 60 different individuals over a two-day period the vetting and head conversation of long traditions [0:22:24] initial, our entire process this year is going to include members of the long-term planning [0:22:33] committee coming in and talking about different aspects of the focus areas that they're going [0:22:39] to represent. [0:22:40] So we're trying a new twist. [0:22:42] I was sharing with the team that you'll hear a lot less from me, others, which should make [0:22:49] us all happy. [0:22:53] But the formality is, this budget is crafted in accordance with its also crafted best practices [0:23:07] in mind, taking the need using all of the different hands and incorporating them into a single [0:23:18] document. [0:23:20] As you can understand as we've gone through the strategic planning process, it is really [0:23:25] no easy task. [0:23:27] So we want to spend some time because this is going to be a bit different than in the past, [0:23:32] the past, but one of the things we're going to do is we're going to share with you the [0:23:36] end of the story first. And in the end of the story, what we've done is we've illustrated [0:23:43] what the total potential of the impact to this budget will be to the inside of the City of [0:23:51] Twin Falls. And if you've been following along over the course of the last several years, [0:23:56] you'll know that we followed Census data. And unfortunately, Census data has not been [0:24:02] updated since 2016, and so we had to turn to some different sources, and those sources [0:24:07] have a much significant and much higher median house value than what was available. [0:24:14] But when we've had conversations, they said that this median household value probably more [0:24:18] accurately affects the Twin Falls market, and a little bit later we'll talk that looks like. [0:24:23] So when you take, last year we had presented, based upon census data, that the median house [0:24:28] House inside of the City of Twin Falls was just under $145,000. [0:24:34] Based upon the data that we use in these scenarios this year, you'll see that we believe [0:24:39] that House was under this data collection was $163,000 and it has grown to $178,000 over [0:24:46] the course of the last count. [0:24:50] Now again, this is purely illustrative and it does not necessarily mean that this is [0:24:58] what will happen to every single house [0:25:02] with the inside of the city of Twin Falls [0:25:04] or any house for that matter. [0:25:06] In fact, what we can illustrate is we use this as [0:25:10] just a simple illustration, as a single point [0:25:13] to illustrate what could occur inside of this budget. [0:25:16] So if you look at this, you will see that the median house [0:25:20] inside of the city of Twin Falls, [0:25:22] under the last fiscal year, paid total city property taxes [0:25:27] of $6.05 and they had a corresponding tax rate of $7.43 per $1,000 in value. The tax rate [0:25:37] that we're projecting for this year is actually lower. It's $0.12 lower. It's $7.31. And so one [0:25:44] of the common questions that we can ask is if the tax rate is going down, why could my [0:25:50] taxes be going up? And it's important to remit in Idaho, we do let these. The tax rate is a [0:25:58] simple multiplier and it's multiplied against the value of the property. In this case, in [0:26:06] the illustration that we have here, the value of the prop has grown at a rate greater. We [0:26:20] have control over our spending, have control. The assessed value of it is. But in looking [0:26:32] at this, we believe that these numbers closely come to reflecting our market and will go [0:26:38] through a scenario of illustrating those moving forward. [0:26:42] And then the adjustments to the water rates, [0:26:45] the sewer rates and the sanitation rates, [0:26:47] are also illustrated in these, [0:26:52] when you take a look at the property tax increase, [0:26:55] and you take a look at the sewer increases [0:26:59] based upon nothing changing. [0:27:03] And there could be two changes that occur [0:27:06] in the sewer and the sanitation. [0:27:09] But if nothing changes, [0:27:10] and we continue to operate in the exact same manner. [0:27:13] This example, this individual resident within our community [0:27:18] would be $6.32 more in city services [0:27:23] than what they do under the current. [0:27:27] It will spend time talking a little bit later [0:27:29] about potential changes in the sewer, [0:27:32] and then also potential changes in sanitation [0:27:34] and recycling, both conversations [0:27:36] that we've had, questions on that slide. [0:27:49] So as we shared, and we want to continue [0:27:52] to remind individuals that the strategic plan is directly connected or budget is directly connected [0:27:58] to our city strategic plan and as you go through the entire budget document and as you look [0:28:02] at the individual department it illustrates how the expenditure is attempting to or begin [0:28:11] that process of accomplishing or carrying on completing strategic goals and objectives [0:28:17] that were created in partnership with the council. [0:28:23] And as you recall, we spent 18 months [0:28:26] going through the strategic freshening, the goals, objectives. [0:28:30] We realized that the vision statements reflected [0:28:34] the direction that we wanted to go as a community [0:28:36] in those processes. [0:28:42] And here's the city's strategic plan illustration. [0:28:45] We've seen this many times. [0:28:47] But as we go through this process and we have a conversation, [0:28:51] we've taken this budget conversation [0:28:53] And we've tried to break it into chunks that are directly connected to the strategic plan. [0:28:58] And so next week, we will be talking about focus areas four and five, [0:29:03] but the accessible community and the members of. [0:29:19] So when I say that the city's budget is connected to best practices, [0:29:24] what I'm really saying is we don't present a whole series of spreadsheets [0:29:28] and ask you to guess the outcomes. We don't ask you to try to anticipate [0:29:33] what we're doing with those resources. [0:29:35] And as we started making these changes [0:29:37] over the course of the last several years, [0:29:39] we use numbers, we use graphs and pictures, [0:29:43] and we use words. [0:29:44] And it really does follow these four larger categories [0:29:48] that's recommended by the Government Finance [0:29:50] Office Association, which is it's a policy document. [0:29:53] And I think that's explained as you look at [0:29:56] side of the city's strategic plan, it's a financial plan. [0:29:59] The budget clearly illustrates how we intend [0:30:02] to expand the resources that comes in. [0:30:05] It's an operations guide, [0:30:06] and especially as we begin the process [0:30:09] that you'll see having corporate performance measurement [0:30:11] into this budget, it really will help us evaluate workload, [0:30:15] workload trends, workload measures [0:30:16] to have a better understanding of the goals [0:30:20] and the tasks that are desired by the council. [0:30:24] Also important is it's a communication device. [0:30:28] To get clear understanding of how we are spending [0:30:32] these resources on an annual basis. [0:30:39] So in a nutshell, the total budget that is presented to you is $68,179, which is $3,151,000 [0:30:51] less than the budget that we are currently operating on. [0:30:57] If we've broke that down into two categories, the first is it is a decrease in the government [0:31:02] funds or those funds that typically receive some or a significant portion of their allocation [0:31:08] from property taxes, that's going to include, as Lori was sharing earlier, the General Fund, [0:31:13] the Street Fund Airport. Total expenses in those government fund categories total 40,000,000, [0:31:20] and that is a decrease of about a half a million dollars. Enterprise funds, those funds that [0:31:33] we have that operate like small independent businesses that collect fees to sustain their [0:31:38] level of operation, those total collection are down 8.79% or roughly $2.7 million in comparison. [0:31:54] So when you do a side-by-side comparison, you can see that the city's total taxable value [0:32:00] has grown from $2.68 billion to just under $2.87 billion. [0:32:09] We illustrate the total net expenditures as it's moving forward. [0:32:13] We estimate the total property tax collections and then also reflecting how the decrease in [0:32:19] the tax rate will occur based upon the spending plan and the tax level value. [0:32:25] Suzanne, how can we? [0:32:31] The taxes is just one piece of that. [0:33:01] Property taxes in the government funds represents between 52 and 54 percent of the total budget. [0:33:07] There are lots of other revenue sources that come into that, whether it be specifically [0:33:14] from shared revenues with the county, alcohol licensing revenues, maybe it's gas tax sharing, [0:33:21] rodent bread, airport fees, so they will fall in in the total collection, even though we [0:33:26] are collecting more property taxes this year. [0:33:29] The tax rate is down, but that's a product of the list spending. [0:33:39] A representative of the tax-supported fund spending is about 40 points. [0:33:59] So when you look at the city of Twin Falls as an entity we have revenue allocation areas [0:34:05] that are carved into those areas and if you taxable value of the city of Twin Falls including [0:34:16] their new agencies, you would buy $6 billion so it really strates a increase that illustrates [0:34:28] a total taxable value of their agency as of December of 2017, 6956, which of those numbers [0:34:58] is used for it is that the city's value exclusive of the urban renewal agencies [0:35:07] it would be the two eight six six [0:35:12] so when you take a look at the net assess total taxable value of the city of [0:35:47] Twin Falls this kind of illustrates where we were in 2011-2012 and remember [0:35:55] we're always looking reflection is a bit of a leg in comparison to what you [0:36:01] might be seeing date prices. In fact, did the recession impact the City of Twin Falls [0:36:17] as a total tax in fiscal year 2000? That is going to be shared this. The [0:36:31] recession occurred before that we say yes, but it's reflected in the [0:36:35] valuations. You can illustrate, as we illustrate here, the City of Twin Falls's [0:36:43] total valuation had increased by 183.34, brought by 6.8% and that is on top of [0:36:54] of the $323,000 that was realized in the prior fiscal year. [0:37:02] And a lot of that market and the equation of property. [0:37:17] Another slide that we'd like to illustrate [0:37:19] is the fact of that total taxable value [0:37:23] and what has occurred with the tax rate over the course [0:37:27] of the last several years. [0:37:28] And you can see in 2017, our tax rate was over $8, [0:37:32] about $8.04 per $1,000 in value. [0:37:35] Now we're estimating that tax rate is going to be $7.31 in its total taxable value, and I [0:37:43] want to say that we estimate because what's important to recognize is the final levy or [0:37:49] fact, if I said it, I'm a product of a graduate program that taught me all of the time, it [0:38:01] was just thumped into us. [0:38:03] So the tax rate, here you can see increased to $7.31 in its total value, the $7.43 is different [0:38:17] than what we presented last year. [0:38:19] We're right around $7.52, but as those values come in and remember that we're projected [0:38:28] values in about March, you'll start seeing that tax rate and over the course of the last [0:38:39] a few years, our tax rate total taxable value is presented to us then then what [0:38:51] we've been illustrating. This is one of the greatest impacts that we have in [0:39:02] determining what happens to each individual property. This begins to [0:39:09] fit to look a bit like a roller coaster. In 2006 state tax code said that all [0:39:19] all properties shall have 50% or $50,000 in value, [0:39:23] whichever is less than what is part of the homeowner's [0:39:26] exemption. [0:39:27] By act of the legislature, they increase that in 2007 to 75,000. [0:39:33] And if you'll recall what was going on in the market, [0:39:35] we are seeing significantly growth in 2006, 2007 [0:39:40] in total values. [0:39:41] And so they indexed it. [0:39:44] You can see that that indexing follows [0:39:47] to the height of the market of nearly $100,000 of homeowners exemption or 50% whichever was less. [0:39:56] And then as properties declined in value, the total exemption allowed [0:40:02] beer at that. All the way up, 2018, where the legislature then rewrote the code again, [0:40:11] very similar to what they had prior to 2008, and that has remained at $100,000 for the upcoming fiscal year, and it will continue to be $100,000 until the state legislature modifies that section of the code. [0:40:33] So this is one of the interesting graphs that we looked at, and like I was sharing with you at the beginning of the presentation, we always utilized the data that was available in the Census. [0:40:46] We would go to the quick facts, we would take a look at that, we would utilize the associated [0:40:53] taxpayers of Idaho to capture the tax rate and we were able to put together some information. [0:41:00] Unfortunately, the census information was that we could find lucky this year has not [0:41:06] been updated since 2016 and so we found we looked at many many sources and as Mandy was [0:41:13] helping create, we went through these different processes, we looked at probably several different [0:41:20] examples and we could illustrate where the 178 median home value here was low, where [0:41:27] it was high, this seemed to be about the middle, but it also reflected the 9.2% that we were [0:41:33] out because a lot of the information that we were here was that the property values increased [0:41:40] just under 10% inside of the city of Twin Falls. [0:41:45] And so this really reflects what has happened [0:41:47] in our market since 2008. [0:41:49] House was, this house in our fictitious example [0:41:53] had a total $46,000. [0:41:58] They would have perceived a 50% exemption. [0:42:02] And then the recession occurs, [0:42:04] that total value declines to a low of 116. [0:42:08] And you can see that in house value [0:42:14] of the City of Twin Falls according to Zillow is $178,000. [0:42:19] It is projected to rise in additional 3.8% [0:42:23] and that is all demand driven. [0:42:25] That is what Zillow is projecting over the course of the next year. [0:42:30] Median square foot inside of the City of Twin Falls is about $102. [0:42:39] This does not reflect homes that are on the market. [0:42:42] Homes that are on the market today, according to Zillow, [0:42:46] are listed at $234,000. [0:42:49] So that's the houses that are on the market, [0:42:53] and this is a reflection of all houses within our area. [0:42:57] So that $178,000 is going to have a taxable value, [0:43:09] the tax rate to that. [0:43:13] And so then we take that same information [0:43:15] and we compare that to the inside of the state, [0:43:25] I might hope, which is also using Zilla, [0:43:29] to see in our information and then you take the 2018 tax rate as we received from the associated [0:43:36] taxpayers of Idaho website and you can see where we like this. City portion of tax is paid inside [0:43:50] of the city of Twinfall are less than the cities that we have done the good analysis with. Notice [0:44:00] that there are two cities that are excluded. Boise, Britain, and we intentionally exclude them [0:44:07] because they're unique and we district that oversees all functions of their transportation system where these cities like the City of Twin Falls [0:44:18] oversee that as a function of its local government and to put that in perspective our street fund budget in fiscal year [0:44:26] 2019 represents 13% of our total 13.8% of our total slightly more than dollars [0:44:36] So we've reached out also to the SSR and asked that we had was pretty significant, but we've [0:45:08] asked for him to do and we hope to tweak this just for our purposes or to see how compared [0:45:14] that is, but we've asked him to share with us what the net taxable value of the residential [0:45:23] structures are inside of the City of Twin Falls were residential utility accounts that we have set up. [0:45:46] the new assessor chose to use a different [0:45:50] assessing we have some [0:46:00] I know that we have some I mean it's certainly some that would classify [0:46:05] received the agricultural exemption but that is something that we could also ask for [0:46:09] because those are always going to go to 20% [0:46:12] and I know it's also it's yeah some value and also could we [0:46:34] at some point in the future like you said our budgets 13% is just our streets [0:46:44] this for comparative purposes we throw them on that chart to see where they're at [0:46:49] I get a feeling they're probably not the list and they don't have to do their streets. [0:46:53] This is what we illustrate and we can certainly do that. [0:47:08] That's a pretty easy. [0:47:10] All this information is readily available. [0:47:13] Certainly the Zillow is accessible by everybody and then the Associated Text Period of Idaho is a subscription based [0:47:21] and because we're members of the association we have access to our database and we're able to pull that [0:47:28] This is reflected in a publication that they present and is available for anybody I'm sure they would ask for. [0:47:36] Thank you, Dr. President. [0:47:37] It's just residential only, residential structures only, we've never asked for it, but Brad was really kind of contemplating on how he would be able to capture that. [0:47:56] It's also important to recognize that we start our process so much earlier than most individuals, and right now, our county commissioners have been locked up into board of equalization. [0:48:07] And so their primary focus right now has been on really settling [0:48:11] on what that total taxable value is, and I'm fairly confident based [0:48:15] upon the conversations that we've had with Mr. Wells, [0:48:18] that you'll get the assessors. [0:48:45] So, certainly, we'll certainly try to have the midges up here, [0:48:52] any of the slides. [0:48:59] A significant portion of revenue that we receive is associated [0:49:03] with construction and annexation rules, and you can see [0:49:09] that our new construction and annexation role, [0:49:12] With the exception of the significant blood that occurred in 2017, [0:49:16] we'll notice that there have been continuing in trending. [0:49:22] I'll be putting some information into this to confirm it's that it's been issued by Jared. [0:49:41] His team as a result of the completion of the $0.6 million is going to associate it [0:50:00] beneath $1.00 because that number took some of these projects that are included in our level of work. [0:50:25] which is the reason why we look at the comparative year over year. This year we're at 100 and [0:50:39] here at the same point just above 73 to continue to see a significant robust [0:50:53] out low permits that have been issued. Our revenues coming in will notice that [0:51:08] very conservative because you never know what is going to occur. The other side of the reports [0:51:20] that we present earlier this year. Presidential single family housing was significantly below [0:51:28] attached to the local, dissipating, and other indices for us to be judicious in that process. [0:51:56] And so you'll notice that we have taken building parameters in this budget, and we've estimated [0:52:02] that based upon conversations data coming in. The cost of doing business for all local governments [0:52:27] has gone up. One of the things that we utilize is the Municipal Cost Index. The Municipal Cost [0:52:33] Index, as we've shared with you many times, is our version of the Consumer Price Index. [0:52:38] And we take a specific point and you'll notice that the MCI is increased 8.6 points to an [0:52:46] index of 248.43, which is an increase of about 2.81% index of increase of about 2.2 points. [0:53:01] This data reflects from April of 17.47, and so you can see the prices decreased. [0:53:19] So when you take a look at all of our funds budget, [0:53:32] these are the five categories. [0:53:36] 43% of our dollars go to operations. [0:53:40] 26%, excuse me, 4%. [0:53:42] 26% goes to operations. [0:53:44] 17 goes to capital. [0:53:45] 9% of debt services. [0:53:47] 6% to internal fund transfers. [0:53:50] The capital number is a bit misleading [0:53:54] because we will go forward and budget on reserve or revenues [0:54:02] because revenue source and so that's why we won't come in. [0:54:12] You'll see that as an amendment. [0:54:13] You will not see that as a revenue source. [0:54:16] We don't treat that bond proceeds as a revenue source [0:54:19] because it would be really organizations [0:54:23] doomed to exclude nonforest the bond payment. [0:54:31] So as we make those misreflection [0:54:38] and it allows us to really measure our spending [0:54:40] over a period of time by taking out the really high [0:54:43] and low swings whether it be an arsenic bond [0:54:49] which we're doing plant bond or potentially even issues [0:54:53] that we're looking at fire stations or for rec centers, [0:54:57] we increases or decreases, we move in light data. [0:55:09] So that kind of talks about the budget overall [0:55:13] are the questions. [0:55:15] We're gonna start diving down now into more specific pieces. [0:55:27] So, Terrell, we're gonna start with total personnel expenses [0:55:31] inside of your budget. [0:55:35] So there up, 1.75 million represents the 43% of the 20. [0:55:45] It adds 11 new employees into the budget. [0:55:48] We want to talk about what that looks like, [0:55:50] because not all 11 have a direct cost. [0:55:54] In fact, a lot of the employees that [0:55:56] are coming into this process are really a reflection [0:55:59] on how we do business in bringing better outcomes [0:56:05] and more employees in, because we [0:56:08] used to save resources and produce a higher level of service. [0:56:15] It provides a 3% performance adjustment for all employees, [0:56:18] and a 1% compensation table movement. [0:56:21] And it also covers the city share of health insurance [0:56:24] of 6.4%, the total number of this budget. [0:56:41] So part of those employees, our actual employees [0:56:45] that we brought in, and we shared this with you [0:56:48] a little bit earlier, of the 11 employees, [0:56:50] 5.5 of the employees are really a reflection of [0:56:54] and completing the 2018 additions that we moved from. [0:56:59] So, as we shared, we started that process of bringing the complete prosecution services [0:57:06] in-house and we funded those at those mid-year levels. [0:57:11] For the paralegal, we funded at 0.75 and for the deputy prosecuting attorney, we funded [0:57:17] at 0.5 in the budget. [0:57:19] This brings those up to Kathy Marcus and her team had a contract for about $44,000 that [0:57:28] We're using a vendor in Boise for GIS services. [0:57:32] Upon reflection, they know, based upon workload and performance, [0:57:36] that they can achieve a greater effort by bringing that house. [0:57:42] And so this individual was brought in house. [0:57:45] Those contract dollars were shifted from the personnel budget. [0:57:55] There are two dispatchers that were part of the overhire [0:57:58] that we talked about because they are here [0:58:01] and we're able to have our center. [0:58:06] We're going to those individuals in the aquatics assistant and the lifeguard in the past. [0:58:13] We contracted for labor employment service to assist with that and on reflection and examining costs as well as level of service. [0:58:27] It was cheaper for us to actually bring these individuals and have them come in and meet city employees. [0:58:33] And so these are the 5.5 of the 11.4 course of the last time that we time. [0:58:41] So the 6.4 is the final number. [0:59:15] That is the firm. [0:59:16] That is the firm and final number and Gretchen instructed our insurance brokers to execute [0:59:24] and create the contract documents. [0:59:26] And just 7.4. [0:59:39] These are the 6 patients that are being organization. [1:00:08] You'll notice that some of them are from tax-supported funds, some of them are enterprise funds. [1:00:15] We are requesting a water operator and a wastewater operator in both of those cases we're requesting [1:00:22] those so that we can maintain the tools on work and such sex so look at those as kind [1:00:29] of design and flooders between the various crews or fully staffed we'll be able to augment [1:00:35] board with assistive cover vacations, illnesses so that we're not in crews go up, out or raise [1:00:46] wood is our new approach to sidewalks, keeping resources within our budget, going to assist [1:01:07] with fluff. You follow the construction trades and as we've been, as it's been shared with [1:01:14] us internally, it is one of the areas of the construction area covered since the recession. [1:01:24] We're really excited for resources that have been committed for us that need to be a more [1:01:58] accessible community. We also do fire inspection, electrical inspection, to all that's an electric [1:02:26] isn't tested. It's not the same level of required professional certification. We have [1:02:36] They do pass this, but it's not a licensure, like being an electrician, but enforcement administrative [1:03:13] assistant is really to assist Sean in taking those calls. [1:03:19] One of the things that, after a series of conversations, we made the decision that we would take a run [1:04:27] at the hopefully not short-sighted in being over yet, and also the ability to get us the money. [1:04:41] money, but there's also the issue of supplanting that if you put monies into a budget and you [1:04:48] apply for a grant and into some issues. So we made the decision that like for a safer [1:04:57] grant, we were successful, we were successful, we were successful. There were six positions [1:05:24] and they're listed above that were not the issues budget, but it's important that is [1:05:32] that every single one of these positions that were removed by the sponsoring department [1:05:38] through our balanced budgeting process. [1:05:44] And share one more library position we really believed [1:05:49] was we describe in some level of need resources, [1:05:57] and you want to bear sacrifices that you have to make, [1:06:05] and these are the positions that can process us, [1:06:12] and that will clear new ways. [1:06:15] And if we are unsuccessful, these positions [1:06:18] then force subsequent fiscal year funding. [1:07:30] So I shared those same thoughts with Chief Kingsbury, [1:07:41] and he's going to be in a position [1:07:42] to release departments, the staffing, and the plan. [1:07:50] I shut down with all of them. [1:08:14] So, it includes the personnel piece. [1:08:17] When you take a look at the total operations costs, [1:08:21] you'll notice that the cost increases about 4.7% [1:08:25] or about $7, $2,000 across all of our funds location. [1:08:32] It's about $17.5 million. [1:08:35] Operation maintenance really is that catch all [1:08:38] that is not a capital item. [1:08:40] And a capital item is very easily defined as a durable good [1:08:44] that's going to be most cases. [1:08:48] This is going to be professional services, [1:08:49] that is going to be training these things [1:08:56] that help us to the municipal cost index field, [1:09:07] as we shared, it was over four. [1:09:09] But these are a reflection of our costs [1:09:11] that we're seeing locally. [1:09:12] And members of our finance team really do spend [1:09:14] a lot on the gas costs, making sure [1:09:23] that we have the resources to make sure this is. [1:09:38] But a fund, a fund, is $11.36 million. [1:09:44] It is absolutely amazing. [1:09:48] When you take a look at 987.0 and 56 million in the City of Twin Falls has made investments [1:10:06] since 2000 and a few years ago, that's more than invested in the facilities, which are [1:10:26] treatment, water facilities, and all of those different things, I think that really illustrates [1:10:33] the work that is being performed by the members of our team. [1:10:36] They can also illustrate the solid foundation that we are creating within the City of Twin [1:10:42] falls to continue to take advantage of additional [1:10:45] economies as they present themselves. [1:10:49] And to make sure that we have our resources available [1:11:05] this budget as it moves forward and creates that solid [1:11:19] specifically, here are some of the, [1:11:24] these are highlight items that were yet [1:11:30] across to our organization. [1:11:34] You'll see $3,000 to information services [1:11:39] outside of our organization, $517,000 [1:11:47] and open space improvement, [1:11:48] Park S-Corp is servicing facility in Hanbury, [1:11:56] is that we had those assets that we have [1:12:01] as the golf course and while we don't, [1:12:09] it is a city asset. [1:12:10] And we have to make sure that we maintain that asset [1:12:13] as such because you never know [1:12:15] when that contractual relationship that we have, [1:12:21] anything Steve is doing an absolutely fabulous job, [1:12:24] but Steve may not wanna work forever. [1:12:27] Invest in the kind just as we do other assets, [1:12:36] $1.6 million for zone 7 maintenance in miscellaneous improvements and overlays and then the sidewalk [1:12:45] development program which is $330,000 plus. [1:12:51] We're really excited to get a process next week and so if you can just give us a week [1:12:59] before we really unveil the new sidewalk program, pay for presentations. [1:13:09] I'm setting the bar high, John. [1:13:12] I think it's cooler. I think it's incredibly resourceful. [1:13:19] We're going to complete North College Road Zisting Porta Replacement, so you see that. [1:13:43] We have $600,000 in pressurized irrigation systems, and so that is going to continue to [1:13:49] decrease our potable water demand in these residential areas, and so we'll build those [1:13:56] stations in the lives chairs that we have, our last system. [1:14:05] There is a $750,000 for Southwell Field Design and Build, and that, as they will talk [1:14:11] about next week is just to take advantage of the rights that out of [1:14:16] Durkeys we're looking at a doctor placement and those projects are those [1:14:26] dedicated funds these would fall into those enterprise categories where we [1:14:30] collect the funds in those and for specific areas. Any question about the [1:14:39] tax-supported funds? Here is the entire enterprise fund and you can see one of [1:14:55] the questions is well if you have so many enterprise funds why do you only [1:14:59] focus on three. The balance of them represent two percent. When you take a look at water, wastewater [1:15:07] and sanitation, that's why we really focus on that big three. The majority of the revenues that we [1:15:12] have in these funds come from user fees about 37 percent. So the Water Fund this year we're looking [1:15:34] at to say that the dollar figures represented here are illustrated illustrative in use rates of [1:15:49] If you use 18,000 gallons, which is a lot of water, [1:15:54] it's a gallon of water, but if we used 18,000 gallons, [1:15:59] we would see about $1.96 increase. [1:16:13] Total revenues projected are seven, [1:16:17] that is a decrease of 1% in comparison [1:16:22] to the sanitation fund. [1:16:44] And she just started thinking about some potential [1:16:46] opportunities in the SOAR fund, [1:16:50] and also the conversation in the sanitation fund. [1:16:55] What is the direction that we want to go to last year? [1:17:00] We spent some time sharing with you that we have a maximum cap of a thousand gallons. [1:17:09] Considerable analysis. [1:17:14] I want to say it's about a third of our residents because we don't have sewer meters. [1:17:35] But if you take a look at water consumption in November, December, January, [1:17:41] for our citizens are sending more than 8,000 gallons to the waste. [1:17:47] We say that's okay. [1:17:55] Keep this system. [1:17:56] The rate increases about one and a half percent. [1:18:00] If we were to change how we built, be a reflection, more of a reflection. [1:18:09] Actual consumption, we believe that it's about a 1% decrease going to more of a seasonal adjustment. [1:18:22] So rather than proposing a 1%, I'd be closer to a half a percent adjustment and the, I might [1:18:32] would be less than 41 cents. [1:18:34] The advantage is that it would refer consumption [1:18:39] by hose to cannot accounting for all revenues moving forward. [1:18:53] So I want you to be thinking about that [1:18:55] because as we move forward, [1:18:59] we want to understand the direction [1:19:02] that the count will want to go. [1:19:04] And if this is of interest to continue further exploration, [1:19:09] we will build that into subsequent power [1:19:12] presentations and fabulous job analyzing the different accounts and rates in a position [1:19:23] to present that information which I certainly would like because I think it's more of a rate [1:19:36] as opposed to trying to but so here if nothing were to change you're looking at about a 41 cent [1:19:56] per month increase for the waste water fund which is about $4.91. [1:20:01] the next annotation fund by us to some conversations as we move forward to [1:20:21] looking at a total increase percent and cents per month and that is not making [1:20:32] any change to how we recycle dollars a ton hundred dollars a ton we change that [1:20:47] of those things that we could understanding of how high do you offset [1:20:56] that to discontinue really so the council has those options and McGill, Bill Baxter, has done some work at [1:21:07] Peace as well as Roy Racing. We would continue to explore at least validating the [1:21:26] free recycling with the progress through the budgeting process. So we will we will [1:21:39] bring forward, plus PSI to join us in that conversation, we'll bring forward a [1:21:44] a series of different options for you to consider. [1:21:47] We know that this was a topic from members of our community, [1:21:53] and so as we're talking about recycling, [1:21:55] we'll want to make sure that we'll do our job at the staff [1:22:00] level to send out notices that we will be talking about, [1:22:06] to make sure when everybody's here. [1:22:07] And this is something similar to last time [1:22:17] that Bill was able to bring that sort of the options from [1:22:23] nothing to everything, and what those had cost are based on. [1:22:54] So is that a use tax on them or is that a one-time sales tax when we purchase new? [1:22:59] So, sis, am I would just share with you that I have an outstanding team, [1:23:04] and Janie Higgins is one of those members, and she's really done a lot of work on the sales tax piece, [1:23:12] and she discovered that on the, we are two-beating sales tax on that, [1:23:21] and really the sleeve twin false is just a pass-through commission. [1:23:28] for the ones that are rented that belong to PSI, we have to exist just a little portion [1:23:51] that's for the trash and are separately taxed on the entire, so Janie's currently working on. [1:24:01] So, one of the conversations that counts are started, inclusion of advanced presentation, [1:24:50] and you can see that we included it in here. [1:24:55] This budget does not include any portion of the city's foregone balance, [1:25:00] on balances, $2,186,253 when the city of Twin Falls, [1:25:16] a whole X not to take the statutory allowances that are provided in code [1:25:20] is the 3% in the new construction. [1:25:24] This is the same balance that we're projecting, [1:25:29] because in this budget we do request that you take the 3% [1:25:32] as statutorily, a taxes, and that is reflected. [1:25:39] What's important is, what are the questions we get asked? [1:25:43] Well, how long is it going to be there and it is there so long as section 83-208 sub-section [1:25:52] E of the Idaho Code remains unchanged. [1:25:59] It's important that Idaho Code allows you subsequent budgets. [1:26:13] You don't go back and collect. [1:26:15] You can take what you did not collect in the past, incorporate it into your budgets, and [1:26:21] you can move that forward. [1:26:22] Again, this budget does not call for any of the foregone balance to be used, and should [1:26:29] you choose to use that or want to have a conversation about that, we need to know August 6th, the [1:26:50] Council wants to utilize any portion of the foregone balance by July 30th. [1:26:54] It would be very helpful because what we have to do is, with through a special notice process, [1:27:04] in addition to the normal public hearing that you have on the budget, to declare that it [1:27:08] our intent to some notice to be able to complete our statutory obligations one of [1:27:22] the questions that the things that we did really quickly is we did an analysis [1:27:32] so right now no foregone balance there's no change $7.31 tax rate of $7.43 [1:27:57] you could utilize $342,000 of the foregone balance and that would keep the tax [1:28:07] tax rate at $7.43. If you moved that to $500, the tax rate would be $7.48, would be $7.66. [1:28:28] $1.5 million would be $7.83. Two million would cause the tax rate to grow to eight, and [1:28:39] the entire balance of $86,250, and we grow to $8.07. [1:28:56] We have not to this. [1:29:04] What's important is a lot of time talking at Ecos, [1:29:12] and that is the economic decision of choosing one thing [1:29:15] over and not collecting not to incorporate the $10.2 million [1:29:29] is trying to figure out how that math works at $2.186. [1:29:38] What's important to recognize is you get the $2.186 [1:29:42] all of the time that increases significantly. [1:29:51] And so that's how, again, we have not in conversation [1:30:01] that the count information that you've had decision. [1:31:10] And we are certainly, [1:31:14] you're the most in our local area, yes, by far. [1:31:43] Chris, we did take a while on the council. [1:31:48] We did, we put one of the two falls, [1:32:04] which department be interested in, [1:32:10] the symphony cleaning funds towards operations. [1:32:16] We do so, and followed Chris's line of thought, [1:32:23] because we have the foregone, suddenly legislators [1:32:27] start talking about, well, maybe they don't need [1:32:29] must share revenues they have. They've got sales time, they've got property tax [1:32:34] available to them. So let's take some of their state revenues shared revenue away. [1:32:38] Which in our cases we can point to how much we've talked about the 78,000 [1:32:45] 80,000 people, our population grows each year. [1:32:49] They're each day from people outside the city who come here for our education, our jobs, [1:32:55] or shopping or whatever the case may be, and this is the shared revenue, as long as we pay that back [1:33:03] money back to do a small miniscule amount, we collected it, it's amazing, we received back, I'll use the name for it as long as Mr. Moyle is the, he's gonna start it, he also uses foreground balances as a reason we should get less shared revenue, so I would really never to see what week Dean might be able to show us he could use [1:33:56] We're going to go in this apartment, the 342 or the 500,000, towards a project that we [1:34:03] could show in our city and some council members didn't feel there was enough and I asked [1:34:17] the dean and he agreed the team is right, got this information available so all four [1:35:13] gun balances inside of the state of Idaho. [1:35:17] Total four gun balances and that's not just cities, that's cities, that's counties, that's [1:35:21] cemetery districts, that's every single taxing entity follows this provision is [1:35:29] 31,598 cities, 8.5, 80% was the smallest at 1.461. Idaho Falls is the largest at 6.6 [1:35:55] puts in poor flex words, tax burden is, but one of the things that you might want to look [1:36:24] Go ahead. There's also their corresponding tax rates that they assess. [1:36:31] So I would maybe, yes, I think we should have a conversation about the Thorgon amount. [1:36:43] I'd like to see a list of capital projects. [1:36:53] Objects needed sense. I suspect many of those would be great projects. [1:37:08] Can use for firefighters if it's... [1:37:42] So our challenge is that as we've... [1:37:45] the things that we'll share as you take a look at [1:37:48] a tense of effort that we've placed into [1:37:52] bed of salaries in those positions. [1:38:03] Pace new revenues coming in, [1:38:05] so always that fine-bound philosophy [1:38:12] inside of the organization as well. [1:38:14] Just give me the raise, we'll work harder. [1:38:16] At some point, Council has done a phenomenal job [1:38:21] and when we talk about focus area, [1:38:23] eat the improvements that we've made [1:38:25] in the area of compensation, [1:38:27] allowed us to publish the tasks, [1:38:43] because as we illustrate in that strategic plan, [1:38:53] We will be moving forward through August 20th and with the budget that will give staff the appropriate time to be able to complete all the necessary paperwork and submit that to the county based upon our statutory deadline. [1:39:16] We're going to publish this list because there might be very specific areas that people want to come and be a part of those conversations. [1:39:24] So next week, we'll be talking about an accessible community as well as in [1:39:31] July 16th and then the rest of the schedule follows the critical dates. [1:39:40] Sixth, be asking the council to consider any proposed rate adjustments that require a public hearing [1:39:50] and those are hearing or rate adjustments that exceed 5% and that will also ask you on very [1:40:00] budget sets the maximum cap of spending, and so that's why we need to have an understanding [1:40:05] of what that four-elets, if you want the budget process is not completed after the sixth, you [1:40:16] can still reduce the budget from the sixth forward, but you just cannot increase spending [1:40:21] after the sixth because you will set that ten-a-budget that will move that forward, but [1:40:27] publish that number, and that is the number that we'll use for the public hearing, and budget [1:40:37] is, if it's not, it certainly will be available online, as always, if any questions during [1:40:45] the process if the citizens have any questions during the process are [1:40:51] accessible we would encourage them to reach out to us and Mr. Mayor I would [1:40:56] share that you accepting public and staff will answer those questions if we [1:41:02] have the information resources at our fingertips if not we will present that [1:41:07] information at a subsequent setting. We typically have more exciting things to [1:41:41] talk about I agree. Certainly invite any members of the public who wish to give [1:41:51] of the major process, certainly for an opportunity [1:42:04] throughout the budget process. [1:42:07] So if there are areas of interest or particular focus [1:42:10] that you want to address, line those up with the night [1:42:14] that we're having those conversations [1:42:16] because we'll more likely have, [1:42:18] and actually answer your questions in attendance. [1:42:22] All right Travis, thank you so much for the presentation, [1:42:24] and thank you to the entire finance team [1:42:28] and the whole team that's been working on this. [1:42:30] Again, this is a no-night reading for us [1:42:33] but it certainly is, it's very well organized. [1:42:37] It flows nicely with the planning process. [1:42:41] We've just gone through, gone through, it makes sense. [1:42:44] It's easy to connect those dots both through. [1:42:47] So, most exciting thing for some folks. [1:42:52] And next on the agenda is another opportunity [1:43:02] for general public input on items, not on the agenda. [1:43:05] So, if there's anyone who'd like to jump down to chat [1:43:07] with us about something else, now's your chance. [1:43:11] Seeing no one, advisory board reports from the council [1:43:14] anything here, Chris talking to Greg Lanting? [1:43:20] Yes, uh, well, hey, it's Friday and Saturday's [1:43:27] thing is the festivities in the downtown commentary, [1:43:30] I was sad to see the email today saying that we had to turn the splash pad off [1:43:35] for a little bit to make it a little safer, make some flight changes, but [1:43:39] as anything's new, that's going to happen. I remember certainly a lot of [1:43:48] Rosalie had her estimated the number of people, and they said [1:43:51] the best way skills might be better. Also, with all the sponsors for the [1:44:04] had never seen before. I saw a possible relay race next year, but I'm excited to see the [1:44:45] finish of the DATAT Commons and with the finish of this building and also the bridge to the [1:44:57] main site to see for all of its most of it was them not their listening down to see it. [1:46:33] Being this meeting here, I apologize. We have had adjournment to Executive Session [1:46:39] Item Code 74206 1A to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member or individual [1:46:46] agent. We're in the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated to fill [1:46:51] a particular vacancy or need unless a vacancy in an elective office is being fulfilled. [1:46:56] The left. [1:46:57] Second. [1:46:58] Motion by Nikki Boyd. Seconded by Greg Lanting to adjourn into executive session. As stated, [1:47:05] is there any discussion? [1:47:09] Yes, Mr. President, I'm [1:47:12] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:16] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:18] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:20] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:22] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:24] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:26] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:28] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:30] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:32] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:34] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:36] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm [1:47:38] Mr. President, I'm Mr. President, I'm