Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-03-05, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-03-05/ [0:00:12] Hey Greg are you still there with us? Are you still there? Hello? Unmute your phone Greg. [0:00:48] We're starting. Okay so Greg just to let you know the uh [0:01:01] Civic what's it called? Civic Clerk System is uh not quite working so we're all running off the agenda [0:01:08] that's on the website so if you don't do that you can go to the website and see the agenda so [0:01:13] no need to uh click to vote we'll just do the voice votes and sure it will record those [0:01:18] Thank you. [0:01:19] Thank you. [0:01:20] All right, we're good to go. [0:01:24] So I will call the meeting the order, call the order of the meeting of the Twin Falls City [0:01:29] Council for Monday, March 5th. [0:01:31] I would you have six of seven members present, Nikki Boyd is excused this evening. [0:01:35] Greg Lanting is joining us on the phone. [0:01:37] The next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:01:39] Those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:01:46] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:02:04] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? [0:02:07] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, where the staff is going to ask as a precautionary measure [0:02:11] that you adopt the entire agenda that was published on the city's website as well as [0:02:17] reported on the newspaper as an amended agenda to tonight's meeting. [0:02:22] These staff went forward, we posted it online, it was available for public access, we sent [0:02:28] it out to our media partners, we placed it in various locations, however it was not posted [0:02:34] outside of this meeting per Idaho Code, and therefore we would ask that the entire agenda [0:02:42] in its package be adopted as an amended agenda for tonight's consideration. [0:02:49] The amendments are no different than what has been previously published online and reported [0:02:55] on. [0:02:58] Motion by Chris Tockington is there a second second. [0:03:01] Second by Christopher Reed to consider the entire agenda as amended. [0:03:08] Is there any discussion? [0:03:11] Chair and roll call vote please. [0:03:15] John Beriker. [0:03:16] Yes. [0:03:19] Zann Hawkins. [0:03:20] Yes. [0:03:21] Greg Lanting. [0:03:22] Yeah. [0:03:23] Worth Paris. [0:03:24] Yes. [0:03:26] Yes. [0:03:27] Yes. [0:03:28] Mr. Fareed? [0:03:29] Yes. [0:03:30] Yes. [0:03:31] As talking to. [0:03:32] Yes. [0:03:33] Motion passes 6-0. [0:03:35] Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:03:38] This is a chance for the public to address the council on items not on the agenda this [0:03:43] evening. [0:03:44] So for example, if you are here to speak about the recycling issue, we will have an opportunity [0:03:47] for that input later on the agenda. [0:03:50] So if there's anyone who wishes to address the council, now is your opportunity to please [0:03:54] come forward. [0:03:58] We will move. [0:03:59] Yes. [0:04:00] Just a short piece. [0:04:01] Yes, Chris talking to him. [0:04:02] I think it's worth noting that 155 years ago today, President Abraham Lincoln announced [0:04:08] the formation of the Idaho Territory. [0:04:10] Previously, we were part of the Oregon Territory as of 1846. [0:04:16] The formation of the Idaho Territory, of course, led to our statehood on July 3rd, 1890. [0:04:22] But if any of you are around, besides me, [0:04:25] when I blink and announce the uno territory, [0:04:28] here's Dave and here's Dydow. [0:04:31] Thank you. [0:04:33] And next on the agenda is the consent calendar, [0:04:35] council wishes. [0:04:36] Move to approve the consent calendar. [0:04:38] Second. [0:04:40] Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:04:43] to approve the consent calendar. [0:04:45] Is there any discussion in general call vote, please? [0:04:53] Present Harkins, yes, Greg Lanting, yes, Ruth Piers, yes, Christopher Reed, yes, Chris [0:05:03] Talkington, yes, non-baraker, yes, motion passes six to zero, the next under items of [0:05:12] consideration the first is a request to confirm the appointment of Cindy Bond to [0:05:17] fill the seat vacated by Brad Wills on the Urban Renewal Agency Board and the [0:05:21] appointments of Andy Hoe Wheeler and Doug Volmer to the Urban Renewal Agency Board beginning [0:05:27] in July 2018. So some background here. Brad Wills was appointed to his first three-year [0:05:35] term on the Urban Renewal Agency Board on July 1, 2015. In November, Brad resigned his [0:05:42] position on the URA to take a job with Twin Falls County as our county assessor. Dan Brizzee [0:05:47] and Neil Christensen were reappointed to their second three-year terms on the [0:05:52] URA in July 2015 and their terms expired June 30th 2018. The staff posted a notice [0:05:59] to fill the position vacated by Mr. Wills and staff received applications from [0:06:04] five qualified individuals with strong resumes and interests in serving on the [0:06:08] URA Board. An interview panel consisting of myself, Council Member Ruth Pierce and [0:06:13] and URA Chairman Dan Brizzee. [0:06:16] I interviewed the applicants and vetted them. [0:06:18] The panel recommends that Cindy Bond [0:06:21] be appointed to the URA Board taking the place of Mr. Will's. [0:06:25] Her appointment will be for the remaining four months [0:06:27] of Mr. Will's term, plus a new three-year term [0:06:31] beginning on July 1st and ending July 1st, 2018, [0:06:35] and ending June 30th, 2021. [0:06:38] Recognizing that Mr. Brizzee and Mr. Christensen [0:06:40] will also need to vacate their positions [0:06:42] of the URI Board at the end of June. [0:06:44] The panel also recommends the appointments of Doug Ulmer [0:06:48] and Andy Hoeweiler to begin three-year terms [0:06:50] beginning July 1st, 2018, ending June 30th, 2021. [0:06:56] These board members are appointed by the mayor [0:06:58] and confirmed by the council, [0:06:59] and serve a maximum of two, three-year terms. [0:07:03] The three recommended appointments are here this evening [0:07:07] if councilman Talkington wants to give them [0:07:09] the constitutional inquiries otherwise I would recommend that those three be [0:07:16] appointed as presented second I do I think it's motion by Ruth Pierce second [0:07:28] by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the appointments as recommended all just 20 [0:07:33] minutes I do think it's worth noting the success and urban renewal as the most [0:07:38] successful local development policy to come out of the state, allowing us to bring in new [0:07:49] businesses, raise the wage scale significantly, and revitalize the whole downtown area. [0:07:56] When I was mayor in 82 and 83, we had a thing called the Business Improvement District, and [0:08:02] it did not have the same incentives, and was not successful. Urban Renewal has done everything [0:08:08] the BID couldn't do, and I hope our new applicants will remember the value of local planning and [0:08:15] control that this best exemplifies is by the opposition of most of our local legislators. [0:08:21] Thank you, Councilman. [0:08:24] Talkington, is there any other discussion? [0:08:26] I share a roll call vote, please. [0:08:29] Great landing. [0:08:38] Worth-cares? [0:08:39] Yes. [0:08:41] Christopher Reed? [0:08:42] Yes. [0:08:43] Chris Talkington? [0:08:44] Yes. [0:08:45] John Berriger? [0:08:46] Yes. [0:08:47] Yes, motion passes at six to zero and the and [0:08:59] Thank you so much. Look forward to your service on the board. Next on the agenda is a presentation from Superintendent Brady Dickinson [0:09:09] About the upcoming renewal of the Twin Falls school districts plant facilities. Lovey. Welcome, Dr. Dickinson. Thank you. Thanks for having me [0:09:18] A couple of things here before I start. [0:09:22] I do know you have a full agenda today, and so I'll try to keep the presentation brief. [0:09:28] And today is really just informational. [0:09:31] And so I want to provide you with some information on the upcoming levy. [0:09:37] This is the time of year when the levies are important. [0:09:42] The schools in this one in particular is a 10-year levy. [0:09:45] It's been around for a long time since 1958. [0:09:48] and so I tell people the good news is you won't have to listen to me talk about [0:09:52] this one again until 2028 after after this presentation. I do want to [0:10:01] before I start I want to thank the Council. I think we have a unique [0:10:04] relationship in our community between the school district and with the city and [0:10:09] I just continue to appreciate that partnership and I want to once again say [0:10:14] thank you for that and I look forward to continuing to work with the Council a [0:10:18] with city leadership into the future. I think that our mutual planning has really [0:10:23] paid off in our community and so thank you for that. Look forward to continuing [0:10:28] to work with you as our community grows. As we are a growing community, you know one [0:10:33] of the things that we have to do is we have to ensure that our schools are [0:10:36] set up for the future and that's really what this levy does. Plant facilities [0:10:41] levies are used to pay for maintenance items for schools and so plant facilities [0:10:47] These levies are used to pay for things like asphalt, roofs, you can do technology upgrades, [0:10:53] what you can't do is up with plant facility levies or you can't buy curriculum, you can't [0:10:59] pay salary, benefits, things like that. [0:11:02] So it's actual building maintenance, building upgrades, maybe small remodels, things like [0:11:07] that. [0:11:11] The school board utilizes a budget advisory committee to make recommendations on things [0:11:16] like levies. [0:11:17] I think this is a really smart way to approach it, because when you bring educators together [0:11:22] and you start talking about funding, we tend to look at it through a particular lens, because [0:11:27] we recognize how that funding is utilized within our schools, and so bringing people [0:11:31] together from all different walks of life is important to make these recommendations. [0:11:36] So, as you can see on the list in front of you, we have people from all different backgrounds [0:11:40] here in the community, from business. [0:11:44] We had retired folks, people that were on a fixed income, students, and they all came [0:11:50] together and they analyzed their budget and really dug into the needs of the district, [0:11:54] and then made a recommendation to the school board in terms of, first, whether or not to [0:11:58] go forward with the renewal of the levy, and then, number two, you know, how much they should [0:12:04] go forward. [0:12:05] There were two considerations that the committee made this time when making the decision one. [0:12:11] They want to make sure that we're set up for the next ten years in terms of a long-range [0:12:14] plan. It's one thing to know what your needs are today. For example, bickel elementary school [0:12:19] needs a new roof badly. So this summer we're going to need to do that. But we're talking [0:12:24] about what are the needs going to be over the next ten years. So we have to consider not [0:12:28] only what we need, what needs are today, but in 2028 what kinds of needs are they going [0:12:32] to be within the district and in terms of the buildings spaces that we have. And then [0:12:37] secondly, wanting to be very, wanting to make sure that we're addressing taxes that folks [0:12:45] pain within our community. Again this impacts people's property taxes and so [0:12:49] they wanted to look at could we reduce the overall tax rate or at least maintain [0:12:54] the overall tax rate that people are paying so that they don't experience an [0:12:59] increase. And as you're going to see in this presentation that the committee did [0:13:03] a nice job meeting both of those goals and so this is a renewal and it's actually [0:13:09] a renewal at a slightly reduced rate to what historically has been paid but in [0:13:14] in the long run it's actually going to generate additional funds to the district because of [0:13:19] the fact that we are a growing community and because our market value is increasing. [0:13:22] And so again those were the two things the committee was looking at. [0:13:28] So let's look back over the last 10 years and what's happened just here in Twin Falls [0:13:32] since 2008 when the last levy was approved. [0:13:36] These are all spaces that now need to be maintained within the district. [0:13:40] Obviously when you look at plant facilities money you know you need to maintain your [0:13:44] new spaces, you also need to come back and maintain your older spaces. These spaces obviously [0:13:50] are less money to maintain because they're new, but it's still an area that needs to be [0:13:55] cleaned, it's still a keep that needs to be taken care of and it's going to age over the [0:13:59] next 10 years. And so again, just looking back since 2008, we built Canyon Ridge High School. [0:14:05] Not only did we build our second high school, but we've had so much growth that we had to [0:14:09] put an addition on it since 2008. We added the gymnasiums like the one pictured here [0:14:14] on to the elementary schools that didn't have gymnasiums, we built two new elementary [0:14:18] schools which have now been open a little over a year and a half. South Hills Middle [0:14:22] School just opened this year. I mentioned the addition that went on to Canyon Ridge and [0:14:28] then two pretty significant remodels in the district. Magic Valley High School was remodeled [0:14:32] this year and then we had Twin Falls High Schools come through a couple of iterations [0:14:36] of remodels. But roughly about 600,000 square feet have been added to the district over [0:14:42] the last 10 years. Again, just considering the growth that we've experienced in this community, [0:14:47] that's part of a space that we've added in terms of school space. When you look at what [0:14:53] we're going to need going forward, again, this won't pay for new schools. This will pay for [0:14:57] maintaining and upgrading the schools we have. But in projections hold, and if we push that [0:15:03] out, say, 12 years to 2030, probably looking at two more elementary schools in the next [0:15:09] 10 to 12 years and then by 2030 if the growth trends continue at about 3% a year, you'll [0:15:15] add your third high school to when it falls somewhere around 2030. [0:15:20] So again, this money won't pay for new schools, this is what we'll use to maintain the facilities [0:15:25] that we have. [0:15:26] And what I've been arguing is that now since we're not building new schools, we're probably [0:15:31] in a window of four to five years until we're doing that, it's a good time to come back [0:15:35] and reinvest in some of the older facilities that we have in the district. [0:15:42] So let's talk about those older facilities. I found this kind of enlightening [0:15:46] or interesting. I didn't really realize just how old some of these buildings were, but [0:15:50] again, 53 years is the average age when you take out the newer [0:15:54] facilities in the district. What I would argue [0:15:58] within our community is that we have some of the best maintained facilities [0:16:02] around. So if you go to some of the surrounding communities [0:16:06] and you look at and you compare the school buildings compared to what we have here in [0:16:10] Twin Falls. Our buildings are exceptionally well-capped, big elementary, which is still [0:16:14] one of my favorite schools in the district is 80 years old this year. I still think of [0:16:19] Perrine and Oregon Trail as the new schools and they're now 23 and 33 years old. These [0:16:25] facilities, although they're very well-capped, there are some needs that need to be addressed. [0:16:29] And I'm going to go through what some of those are here in this presentation. But again, [0:16:34] It's a good time since we're not building the schools to come back and reinvest in some of these older facilities [0:16:39] and ensure that they are usable well into the future. [0:16:42] You reach a tipping point with buildings that have a certain stage. [0:16:46] It becomes more you're putting money into it and you really just need to replace the building [0:16:51] so you're not getting a return on the investment within the building. [0:16:54] We've now raised a lot of these facilities. [0:16:56] They're all worth investing in during the next 10-year period. [0:16:59] And over the long run, it's going to save us money. [0:17:01] When you consider it, it costs about $15 million [0:17:04] to build a new elementary school. [0:17:06] The longer we can utilize these facilities, [0:17:09] the better maintained we can keep these facilities [0:17:11] and use them into the future, [0:17:14] then the better off we're going to be in the long run. [0:17:16] But Fosbury School is a great example of a building [0:17:18] that's an older facility, but it's been well kept, [0:17:20] it's been maintained, it's had some upgrades over the years, [0:17:24] and it's going to be used well into the future. [0:17:30] We use the funding for, again, facility maintenance, technology upgrades, and remodeling some small [0:17:38] additions. [0:17:39] Again, it's not enough money to build schools, but you can do some additions. [0:17:42] It's been around in Twin Falls for a long time, was first approved in 1958, has passed [0:17:47] every 10 years in Twin Falls since then. [0:17:49] I'm going to talk about that tax rate here in just a minute, but historically we're going [0:17:54] to be talking about a combined rate, so it's the money for the school bonds and the plant [0:17:59] facilities levy. [0:18:00] So if you add those two together, historically it's been $3.04 and again I'll give an example [0:18:05] for those in the audience to really show what that means. [0:18:08] It's going to be renewed at $2.99 so it's a slight reduction in the rate and so again [0:18:15] this will not be a new tax, it's nothing that will add on to people's tax bill it will [0:18:20] overall be just a slight reduction from the historical rate. [0:18:24] It currently generates $3.3 million a year but because of the fact that we're in a growing [0:18:29] district and our Mac market value is increasing, it actually will generate 4.75, which it provides [0:18:35] for two things. [0:18:36] One, it allows us to become more aggressive with some of the needs in the district that [0:18:40] allow line here shortly. [0:18:42] And then it also sets us up for the next 10 years, knowing that we don't know what kinds [0:18:46] of needs you're going to have in the district 8 to 10 years from now. [0:18:49] So it provides for that long-range facility planning and the tax relief that the committee [0:18:53] was looking for. [0:18:54] This data is 60% approval in order to pass. [0:19:02] This next slide shows you the levy rates for the 10 largest school districts in Idaho. [0:19:08] And so as you can see, we're pretty average in terms of levy rates, quarter lane being [0:19:13] on the low end in Bonneville and value being on the high end. [0:19:16] The one thing that this does not take into account are property values. [0:19:20] So obviously property values and levy rate go hand in hand and determine why you pay [0:19:24] in property taxes. [0:19:25] And so quarter lane, which is a pretty low rate also has very high property values, which [0:19:31] play into that but again when you look at the chart we're pretty average in [0:19:34] terms of just the rate that folks are paying. The next two slides really [0:19:40] demonstrate the nuts and bolts of the levy and school funding and so what [0:19:45] you're seeing here are the combined rates for the Twin Falls School District [0:19:48] and so when folks get their property tax bill this is really the breakdown of [0:19:53] how the levies work. You want to pay particular attention to the three colors [0:19:58] kind of in the middle, the green, the red, and then the dark blue at the bottom. [0:20:02] The green is the supplemental levy, and you'll notice that prior to 2011-12, we didn't have [0:20:06] a supplemental levy, and that was the case for most districts in Idaho. [0:20:10] In 2011-12, there was a real shift. [0:20:13] The state funding dropped off during the recession, and we reached a point where, without a supplemental [0:20:18] levy, we were going to have to make drastic cuts within the district, and that was statewide, [0:20:23] And so on the 2011 and 2012, most districts around the state have supplemental levies to [0:20:29] help fill in that last revenue from the state level. [0:20:32] So we went from something like 30% of the district's in Idaho with supplemental levies to over [0:20:37] 80% of the district's in Idaho. [0:20:40] And so again, we were in that same boat. [0:20:43] Over the years since then, the state funding has started to come back up. [0:20:46] And so you can see last year 2017-18, it was a slight reduction. [0:20:51] And that's because in the last renewal of the supplemental levy, our committee recommended [0:20:55] reducing it slightly since state funding had come back up. [0:20:58] So that was that drop from 4.82 down to 4.62. [0:21:02] Below that you see the red and the dark blue. [0:21:06] That's really what we're talking about with this levy. [0:21:08] The dark blue is the bond. [0:21:10] So that's the money for new schools. [0:21:12] And then the red portion is the plant facilities. [0:21:15] And so the only portion that we're voting on is that red area. [0:21:19] So you can bring those two together, that's where you get that 3.04. [0:21:23] And so you can see it 2018, the 2.99. [0:21:27] So again, that's a combined rate, that's the plant facility and the bond those two together [0:21:32] because they really work together in terms of funding. [0:21:37] And so what we're looking at then, the question is how much is just that red area? [0:21:41] How much is the plant facilities? [0:21:43] And it comes out to 82 cents. [0:21:45] So it's $82 cents per $1000 of taxable value. [0:21:49] So the example that we give folks is that if you take out your homeowner's exemption, [0:21:53] you have $100,000 of taxable value, it's about $6.83 a month of your overall tax bill for [0:22:00] about $83 a year. [0:22:02] And again, it's not going to be an additional taxes as money that we're currently paying. [0:22:07] It's just a renewal and a continuation of that tax. [0:22:11] So this next slide also demonstrates the long-range planning going forward, it's a little bit complicated, but the line across the top is the revenue line. [0:22:25] So that's the money that the levy will generate over the next ten years. [0:22:29] Below that you can see the bond and you can see the plant facilities and then you'll notice there's a gap. [0:22:34] That gap's really important and I'll explain why here just a minute. [0:22:38] First, I want to let you know that the committee was very conservative in their projections. [0:22:42] They wanted to make sure that regardless of what market value did in Twin Falls, [0:22:46] that we were going to be okay. They didn't want to bank on large increases in market value, [0:22:51] even though potentially we are going to continue to see increased market value here in Twin. [0:22:56] But as you can see by this graph, they're projecting the line to be pretty flat. [0:23:00] And so their banking, or at least they're projecting that, [0:23:04] If the market value in Twin Falls does not increase over the next 10 years, that we're [0:23:09] going to be okay financially. [0:23:10] Then you have your plant facilities and your bond. [0:23:14] We're in the process of refinancing our bonds and what that gap will buy down our current [0:23:19] debt. [0:23:20] By simultaneously refinancing the bonds that we currently have because of our market growth, [0:23:25] we're going to be able to pay off those 30-year bonds in five years, which is going to save [0:23:30] us $5 million in interest in the long run. [0:23:33] It's not only interest that our community will not be paying back on those bonds and again it's because we've had increased market value here in Twin Falls that we're able to do that. [0:23:42] The other thing that it'll do is somewhere down the line when you need to build new schools, for example you push this out to 2023, 2024. [0:23:50] You'll be able to labor in those additional schools potentially through a bond election and as long as you don't push that above that revenue line you will not have to increase taxes. [0:24:00] And so in the short run it allows us to become aggressive in some of the maintenance needs. [0:24:05] In the long run down the road, when those new schools need to be built, [0:24:09] we potentially be able to do that without raising taxes. [0:24:13] And so again, that's an advantage for a growing community like Twin. [0:24:16] And these two slides are about the needs in the district. [0:24:23] And so what will the funds be used for? [0:24:25] I mentioned roofs. Big Elementary has to have a new roof this summer. [0:24:29] actually needed a roof last summer, but then the parking lot at Robert Stewart claps after [0:24:34] last year's winter. And so we ended up buying asphalt instead of roofing material. [0:24:39] Satyotooth, Rolpernolleri are all going to need roofs in the next ten years. Again, I mentioned [0:24:44] parking lots. We have just about every school in the district has a parking lot that needs [0:24:49] to be resurfaced at this time. Heating and air conditioning, this is a big one in our district [0:24:55] Right now, schools like big alone Harrison, [0:24:58] basically all of our older schools [0:24:59] are using antiquated heating and cooling systems [0:25:02] that are inefficient, particularly have problems [0:25:05] on the cooling side, and so that it's just time [0:25:08] to replace those systems and they're not cheap [0:25:10] to come through and redo the heating and cooling system [0:25:13] in the building, so we'll need to cycle through. [0:25:16] Modernizing older buildings, Twin Falls High School, [0:25:19] as it continues to grow, is probably gonna need [0:25:21] to have a cafeteria in large or some other work [0:25:24] that will need to be done. [0:25:25] Safety upgrades, our safety is on the hearts and minds [0:25:28] of all of us right now with the recent events in Florida. [0:25:32] And so we need to continue to look at how we can modernize [0:25:36] and increase security within our schools. [0:25:39] In the new elementary and middle school [0:25:42] which have the vestibules that we're built, [0:25:44] you may have seen where people that are coming in, [0:25:46] the building have to go into the front office area. [0:25:49] Older schools were built during a time [0:25:51] when that wasn't a concern. [0:25:53] And so some of the older facilities have offices where you can come in and completely bypass the office very easily. [0:26:00] And so coming back and redesigning those for an injury way so that we have the same level of security at our older schools as our new ones is going to be an important component. [0:26:09] Not only that, but what can we do within the schools to continually upgrade and provide additional security for all the schools. [0:26:16] So that will be a priority as well. [0:26:18] Technology, we were really during the economic downturn back off of our technology upgrades, [0:26:25] and so now we're at a state where our computers are in desperate need to be in replace. [0:26:30] The average age of computers in our buildings is eight years old, which means in some labs, computers are as old as 12. [0:26:37] And if you have a 12-year-old laptop at home, you know how much fun that is to use. [0:26:41] And then furnishing is one of the concerns that I have in the district right now is the [0:26:46] The parody issue you know you go into the new schools and you have the nice new furniture [0:26:51] And then you go into some of our older facilities, and you you have desks that are in disrepair [0:26:56] You have you have tables and need to replace lunchroom tables that have been fixed over the years [0:27:01] It's just time to come back through and replace some of those [0:27:04] Matter of fact Chris I think we found your desk over in bickel at 1972 Carp in the top [0:27:09] Yeah, 71. So, election. There are two ways to vote. Actually, the absentee ballot [0:27:21] balloting is over now. But next week on Tuesday the 13th is actual election day [0:27:27] for May to 8th. And then early voting is now available. And you can [0:27:31] early vote through through Friday if you choose to. But the one point that we've [0:27:37] tried to make at every one of these presentations is that this is an [0:27:41] important community decision. You know, again, we pull a group of people from Twin [0:27:45] Falls together, we looked at the levy structure, and then they made a [0:27:48] recommendation going forward. I think it's important for everybody to weigh in on [0:27:52] the decision, and I've been telling people throughout the community whether [0:27:56] you think this is the greatest idea ever, or you think this is the worst idea ever, [0:28:00] we want people to give us their input by voting on the election. Because, again, we [0:28:06] view this as an important community investment in the schools and the community. [0:28:09] So, with that, I would take any questions you might have, and again, thank you for your time tonight. [0:28:14] Thank you, Brady. Are there any questions for Brady? [0:28:17] I don't see any questions. Great. Did you have any questions? [0:28:24] I'm good. Are we in clear chance that we're going to make the proposals that we support the more upon that council? [0:28:32] I would certainly entertain that if you would like to make a motion. [0:28:36] I move that the compulsory camp will support the five facilities levy for the tonnful still district and ask our patrons to vote favor. [0:28:46] Second. [0:28:48] Motion by Greg Lanting. [0:28:52] Seconded by Christopher Reed, who endorsed the upcoming levy and encouraged our citizens to support it. [0:29:01] Any discussion? [0:29:02] In general, I'll vote yes. [0:29:06] Yes. [0:29:08] Christopher Reed? [0:29:09] Yes. [0:29:10] Chris Hockington? [0:29:11] Yes. [0:29:12] Don Berriger? [0:29:13] Yes. [0:29:14] Is Ann Hawkins? [0:29:15] Yes. [0:29:16] Greg Lanting? [0:29:17] Yes. [0:29:18] Motion passes 6-0. [0:29:19] Certainly investment in our infrastructure and our community is important, something that [0:29:28] we do at the city. [0:29:29] Certainly encourage the school district to be wise with those dollars and do encourage [0:29:34] and support that much needed investment there. [0:29:39] So thank you for your presentation. [0:29:44] Next on the agenda is a presentation [0:29:46] of the City of Twin Falls 2017 [0:29:49] audited financial statements. [0:29:51] We have Scott Honsaker of Mulkey Honsaker and Company. [0:30:01] If I could, Mayor and City Council, [0:30:03] if I could just introduce Scott, [0:30:05] it just a minute, Scott's a partner in Mulkey Honsaker. [0:30:09] They've been involved with our audit for a while now, and have represented as well. [0:30:14] I think they do a thorough scrubbing of our financial statements and their great assistance [0:30:20] throughout the year. [0:30:21] Maybe a couple of notes from me. [0:30:25] Anticipating approval this evening. [0:30:28] We've gone ahead and used these financial statements for compliance. [0:30:32] We have two requirements to build into the system at the end of each fiscal year. [0:30:37] One is the Idaho Legislature in 2014 past requirement. [0:30:42] It's set up at Idaho Portal where every municipality has to file with the legislative office, [0:30:49] putting on record their financial statements, their budget, their current officers. [0:30:55] So we have complied plenty early. [0:30:58] December 1st is the deadline for that. [0:31:00] We've complied with that. [0:31:01] The second one is just our bonds. [0:31:04] Was the I don't want bank require part of the covenants annual compliance letting them know our financial [0:31:12] position so we've done that as well [0:31:15] And then with that I'll turn the time over Scott. Thank you, Brent [0:31:23] Welcome Scott. Thank you [0:31:26] Good to be with you today [0:31:31] Like I said, I appreciate being here with you again this year and presenting the financial statements [0:31:42] especially in this beautiful new facility. It's a little bit more intimidating than the old facility, but it's great. It's beautiful. [0:31:51] We feel the same. [0:31:52] We're all over here. So it's great. We appreciate the opportunity to be a service and to provide the service to the city. [0:32:03] Appreciate the relationship we've had over the years and it's a great thing for us. [0:32:08] Just want to mention at the beginning we appreciate the help of the finance staff, [0:32:14] Lori and Brent and their staff in getting us the information that we need to complete this audit. [0:32:20] That's not always the case. Some audits are more difficult than others, [0:32:25] and this one we're able to get information timely and accurately [0:32:29] so that we can actually perform audits rather than reconciling everything over and over. [0:32:34] That's a great thing, so you've got some very good staff there that we use as assisting [0:32:43] us. [0:32:44] What you've been given in your packets is a CAFRA comprehensive annual financial report, [0:32:54] which is more significant than most entities present. [0:32:58] We talked a little bit about it last year. [0:33:01] This is a higher level of financial statement than most governmental entities provide. [0:33:08] There's more detail here and it's reviewed more closely than most financial statements. [0:33:17] In fact, again, the cities received this outstanding budget award from the GFA-GFO, which is a significant award. [0:33:29] They really go through an audit, the audit. [0:33:32] I look at line by line, have questions, [0:33:35] and there's quite a significant review process there [0:33:38] that your financial statements have gone through, [0:33:41] and I think it's important that you know and recognize that, [0:33:44] and recognize the city staff and their efforts in getting that done. [0:33:48] That is a big deal. [0:33:54] Well, that's what I'm here really to report on. [0:33:56] You get financial statements and reviews, [0:33:59] and Lori provides that to you regularly. [0:34:02] But as far as the audit went very well this year, we were able to complete it in a timely manner. [0:34:09] Like I said, because of the city staff, the most important document there is on page. [0:34:15] It's I-X and X, which is your audit report. [0:34:20] That's an unqualified opinion that we're issuing for the financial statements, [0:34:25] which is what you want to see on an audit. [0:34:28] There's nothing that caused us to qualify our opinion and to say that there's an issue [0:34:32] here. [0:34:33] This is a standard report or a clean auto report depending on who you or terminology you use, [0:34:41] which is what you really want. [0:34:43] Now these are, continue to grow here for an answer statement, now we're at their 120 pages [0:34:49] and it seems like every year we're having a dozen pages or so just with the complexity [0:34:54] and what's required. [0:34:56] There are many sections here, different types of presentation of the financial information. [0:35:05] And again, since the last few years, I've really encouraged the City Council to pay attention [0:35:10] very closely to the Management's Discussion Analysis section. [0:35:15] That's, you know, demonstrate pages long, but it's written by city staff using the audited [0:35:21] numbers and put into layman's English so that it's not financial terms so that you can see [0:35:29] what's happening here and kind of oil down rather than 120 pages and 7 or 8 pages. [0:35:35] That's where I would focus if I were sitting in your seats. [0:35:39] You have government-wide statements, fund statements, and there's all these terms [0:35:43] which you get described in that management's discussion analysis. [0:35:47] There's also these government funds and then proprietary funds and how they're handled differently. [0:35:54] And those definitions are both in the MD&A as well as in the notes. [0:36:00] If you have questions about what is a business type fund that those answers are in those financial statements for you to find. [0:36:10] Also, there's significant notes for you to review in the back of the United States, as [0:36:17] well as budget to actual numbers, and then, at the end, we have the internal control report [0:36:24] that we test your internal controls as part of our government audits to make sure that [0:36:28] they're in compliance with the internal controls that you've established, and that we didn't [0:36:33] find any issues with your internal controls. [0:36:36] Just a couple highlights, your governmental fund accounts or balances actually increased [0:36:45] this year by just under $4 million, the amount that's available to spend, the unrestricted [0:36:50] balance, and then the business type activities increased by just over $5 million this year. [0:37:00] Obviously, there were significant capital improvements this year which are shown on these financial [0:37:06] statements with the new city hall as well as the safety building additions and so [0:37:13] there's a lot going on here there's also some some great graphs that are shown [0:37:18] in the NDNA for a deceit where your expenses are compared and as well as [0:37:25] your revenue by funds overall it did go very well. The city's in very strong [0:37:33] financial position looking at the balance sheets and the financial statements as [0:37:39] we present them looks very strong, very well managed as well as finances are [0:37:45] concerned. Well if you have any questions I'd be glad to. Any questions? [0:37:53] I don't know if you have what [0:37:55] with other Idaho or the other not in the West communities, [0:37:59] but how do our personnel cost as a function of total budget [0:38:05] compared to you have any idea? [0:38:07] I don't have that data. [0:38:08] That would be interesting to see. [0:38:10] I know that that's an emphasis of the city council [0:38:12] is to address that and that's talked about [0:38:15] in that MDNA section, [0:38:16] but I don't have any comparative numbers there, [0:38:20] which I would have to do some research [0:38:22] to find out what that would be. [0:38:23] Is it possible before or next year you might be a little site research on that we could we could look into it [0:38:28] I don't know the next meeting [0:38:33] Oh next year in March. I'm not sure [0:38:47] It's got thank you so much for your efforts and for your partnership with the city and [0:38:54] to cover this weekend. Next on the agenda is a request to approve a contract with [0:39:05] Pivot North Architecture for the completion of a recreation center [0:39:09] feasibility study. Mitch Humbler, deputy city manager. Okay so Wendy's here and she [0:39:26] might turn down and help me out with some of the facts but I'm gonna give it a go. [0:39:30] As we start they'll remember last year in the budget, last fiscal year's budget. [0:39:35] We included some money to put a committee together and start a process to figure out [0:39:41] how we might best go about putting together a recreation center. [0:39:45] As we started working on that last year, it became pretty apparent to us pretty quickly [0:39:51] in that process that what we really needed was a feasibility study. [0:39:54] That study that could help us kind of understand what the needs of the community are, what [0:40:02] what the community would support financially, [0:40:06] what they would support. [0:40:08] I attended and used at the facility [0:40:10] and were a good location. [0:40:12] All these kind of questions come up [0:40:14] in the feasibility study. [0:40:16] So we came back to the council last summer [0:40:18] and we basically said, can we go out [0:40:21] and get some professional help to help us, [0:40:24] architect to help us do a feasibility study? [0:40:26] So we specialized in stuff. [0:40:28] And we suggested that the money we had in the budget last year wasn't going to be appropriate [0:40:36] to cover it. [0:40:37] It was $10,000. [0:40:38] And so we said it was after the budget had already come through for this fiscal year. [0:40:43] Maybe we could use reserves and you guys will go look into that. [0:40:48] And so we went away. [0:40:49] We did a request for qualifications for architectural services. [0:40:53] And through that process we in January came back to the council and selected Pivot North [0:40:58] as an architect firm with, I'm going to get this wrong, BRS, I always get the S and R mixed up, [0:41:06] but BRS as a sub-consultant in the Fitbit North, and those guys bring a team together that really [0:41:13] specializes in this feasibility study, and so we selected them as our number one qualified kind of consultant, [0:41:22] And then since then we've been working with them to kind of negotiate this scope and this contract. [0:41:28] In the meantime, last fall, we also appointed a committee. [0:41:31] So we have a steering committee for this process. [0:41:34] We've met a few times. [0:41:36] They're ready to go. [0:41:37] They're pumping at the bid wanting to get this process going. [0:41:40] I have to tell you, this was more expensive than I thought it was going to be. [0:41:45] And the reason why it's taken me a month and a half to come back to you is because I've been really kind of hammering [0:41:51] hammering them on the fee, right? And the first version came back at $150,000 and do that, you know. [0:41:58] And then we got to talk about it. And then I got them down to $130,000 or $120,000 and we had to [0:42:05] get the knife out again and start cutting things. And anyway, the version that we have in front of [0:42:09] us tonight is about $98,000, $90,272. And that's a thought to exceed amount. That includes both [0:42:18] their fee for services as well as their reimbursable expenses. [0:42:24] And I think we probably can't get this down anymore. [0:42:27] This is kind of a bare bones minimum sort of a scope to this contract. [0:42:31] So that's kind of where I met now where I was going to lean on Wendy here is if you guys [0:42:37] have questions about the actual details of the contract. [0:42:41] What they're going to come to do and they're going to come to town several times, they're [0:42:44] going to do lots of community outreach, lots of working with our committee meeting or with [0:42:49] our steering committee, they have focus group meetings, and then they have a bunch of specialists [0:42:55] that they're going to look at finances of the community, you know, how much both to construct, [0:43:02] but also how much in operations and really do a thorough look at this opportunity for a recreation [0:43:09] center from construction through operation. And that's what they're going to bring to the table [0:43:17] with us. And so if you've got some questions I can try to answer them. Wendy's also here [0:43:21] as you can try to answer them. But what we're basically going to recommend is that we go ahead [0:43:26] and authorize this contract with, even north, there'll be the signature on the contract. [0:43:34] And these are reserve funds too. So with that, I'll turn it over for questions. [0:43:41] Mitch, I don't have a question just to comment. I think the two things that really stood out [0:43:45] to me that I like about this plan is a true feasibility of programming not based [0:43:55] upon a wish list but based upon a level of participation in a willingness to pay [0:44:02] for it. Secondly, the operational business plan. I think as we heard from [0:44:08] the community in the original strategic plan and then re-heard from them this [0:44:14] year in the update of, hey, we said we want a rec center, why aren't you working on a rec center? [0:44:24] We're past the step of should we have a rec center, it's what should be in it, [0:44:27] what's it going to cost, now we're going to pay for that. Those were things that stood out to me [0:44:32] in this plan, based upon other plans we've done in the past, where we didn't get into that operational [0:44:41] detail, because I think that's maybe a bigger concern of this facility, not just the initial [0:44:45] construction costs. It's been five, six years ago when we did our last kind of look at this [0:44:54] at a recreation center facility and that process got us to a point where we were going to build [0:45:00] four basketball courts in a big building, wasn't that big of a building? 110,000 square foot [0:45:08] building or something like that. And that's what we're going to do because that was what the [0:45:13] the community and what's what we need at, you know. [0:45:18] Operationally, that's a loser. [0:45:20] I don't know how, and I think that's the reason [0:45:22] why we haven't proceeded with that. [0:45:24] And so it's been really enlightening talking [0:45:27] to these guys and learning about not just construction costs, [0:45:31] but what is it going to take to operate a facility. [0:45:34] And there are things in a recreation center [0:45:36] that take up a ton of space that don't generate [0:45:38] a lot of revenue, like basketball courts, [0:45:43] swimming pools. And there are things in recreation centers that don't take up a ton of space, but [0:45:49] actually do generate revenue for the center like fitness centers, classes and those kinds of things. [0:45:58] And so we know that recreation centers can be profitable. We've seen examples of that in our [0:46:06] region, in our state. We know they can operate in the black and that's what they're going to help us [0:46:11] understand here whether those kinds of facilities that we need to include in our [0:46:18] in our recreation so it's going to help it operate and without looking for a [0:46:22] subsidy every year for the general fund budget, it'll be a good process to get [0:46:27] through and in the end it's going to give us a recommendation either yes you can [0:46:31] do it and include these types of things or you know we're not ready for it yet [0:46:37] I think we are. [0:46:39] I think we can make it work. [0:46:42] You could start, kind of, following on some of your questioning, Mayor. [0:46:47] I'm not convinced yet I can support a recreation district or a center unless a true needs analysis based upon the competition it will provide to CSI and their recreation facilities, definitely the YMCA's impact, the new climbing center. [0:47:07] I certainly hope that the contract will have enough public feedback coming to them to see [0:47:14] whether or not what kind of facility, but if facility can be justified. [0:47:19] Does that have part of the contract? [0:47:20] That is exactly part of the work that they're going to do is to, what have we got in the community [0:47:26] already, the climbing facility you mentioned. [0:47:29] It may very well be that our recreation center does not need a climbing facility because [0:47:33] the needs of the community are met at JIMSTALL. [0:47:36] They're going to look into that kind of stuff and they're going to look into fitness centers [0:47:41] and swimming pools and all of those things. [0:47:43] Is the need being met? [0:47:44] Is there more of a need that this community has that's not being met and put our mix of [0:47:52] uses together to fill the need? [0:47:55] That's exactly the point. [0:47:57] There's an auto starting a prior assumption that yes we will have one to suggest what [0:48:01] kind we're going back to step and saying is there justification for it. [0:48:06] And then one of our early drafts of this scope included, [0:48:10] like, I want to say, four sort of steps. [0:48:14] And we would stop at this point and look, [0:48:17] is it worth going on or not? [0:48:19] And we kind of eliminated to bring this scope down. [0:48:24] We kind of eliminated some of those big steps. [0:48:26] We'll still do those, but we didn't drag out the process [0:48:29] as quite as long as. [0:48:31] But yeah, there's going to be points along the way [0:48:33] where we're going to say, are we still moving forward? [0:48:36] Yeah, can the community support this? [0:48:41] Are we overloading our community or saturating our market? [0:48:45] Exactly the point of this feasibility study. [0:48:50] Does that happen? [0:48:52] I appreciate your work on getting this contract down, but if my memories right when we talked [0:48:57] last we were shooting for a $30,000 ish price tag is that correct? [0:49:02] So I think what Wendy told you was about $70,000 was the number that we talked about was what [0:49:07] We thought it might be in the 60s, 70 range, we had 10 in the budget. [0:49:12] And that's one of the reasons why 150 wasn't cut out. [0:49:16] This is a little higher than what we thought we might look at. [0:49:19] I'm just having a difficult time spending money on something that could tell us it's going nowhere for this kind of a price tag. [0:49:27] I understand we need the information and I understand there's a cost involved in getting that. [0:49:33] I'm very much in favor of trying to get to the end of this road, but at this point I [0:49:41] can't in good conscience support this kind of a expense for a study that might lead to [0:49:48] a dead end. [0:49:49] So I will be voting against it, but know that it's not because I'm against the rec center [0:49:54] and doing a study. [0:49:55] I just, to me, this is just too extensive. [0:49:57] the exact same way, we're $100,000, potentially be told, but he won't support this. And so [0:50:16] that's where I just have a lot of heartburn, spending that kind of money. I think we need [0:50:21] to have a feasibility study, just not at that dollar amount. Ruth Pierce? [0:50:34] Which other sections of the feasibility study we could do instead of the $500,000, could there [0:50:42] be a broken out into parcels, potentially? [0:50:45] So we've got it right now, divided into kind of, I guess I'll call it work periods. [0:50:54] We'll finish work period one before you go to two, and I'm three to four, I want to [0:51:01] say. [0:51:02] At any point along the way, we could stop if we felt like it wasn't producing fruit. [0:51:10] Like we weren't getting what we needed or we're learning that the community isn't really [0:51:15] as behind it as we think they might be. [0:51:18] But really, if what we're after is a feasibility study, [0:51:24] then that's kind of the final deliverable project. [0:51:27] The product final deliverable is this feasibility. [0:51:30] And that'll tell us, here's what we found out about the community, here's what they need in a facility, here's what the cost estimates will be to build one, here's what the estimates will be to operate it. [0:51:41] That'll be the final plan that you would then have the pretty picture that you could show people and say, this is what we need to build. [0:51:48] And right there on that location, at any point along the way, we could stop it, particularly these four work periods. [0:51:59] I think that's what they're going to work for. [0:52:01] Right, do you have any input? [0:52:07] It takes me a minute to get it off mute. [0:52:18] Whether or not we can afford this down the road, [0:52:23] operationally as well as cross the bill. [0:52:27] So I'm in favor of the building study, [0:52:31] because it might be a really cheap way to find out what we need [0:52:36] and what we have for you, all the forms. [0:52:39] Thank you. [0:52:41] Mr. Reed, can I ask you another question? [0:52:45] So you talked about those four areas, is that something we could, or however, you know, as [0:52:51] they move through it, I don't do feasibility studies and I'll pretend to. [0:52:54] But is that something that we could break it into those areas? [0:52:57] So they focus on one area and, yeah, 25,000 and if that looks good and everybody's happy [0:53:04] to come and talk to us at the council and, hey, let's move to the next step. [0:53:08] Instead of saying here's [0:53:12] $98,000 can we say let's do this in phases so as we get to first phase and phase one looks good [0:53:18] And yeah, this is something people want well, then let's look at maybe location [0:53:22] And what it should look like in different areas that we should have in this [0:53:27] facility can we do that and say and that's kind of how the [0:53:32] Scope is already drafted. There's these four [0:53:35] They're not really phases of the work, but they're more like you have to do A before you can do B, right? [0:53:45] So that's something we could approve A first for a certain dollar amount, and then they would come in. [0:53:51] That's the one thing I don't have is how much each piece of it costs. [0:53:56] We did have that in one of the earlier drafts, but when we were [0:54:01] you're airing down the scope to get it more affordable in the end, right? [0:54:08] Those pieces of it kind of ended up coming out. [0:54:12] We still have the four, the four tasks, um, and they're defined that way and we can sort of stop them at any point. [0:54:22] And the idea was that when you do task one, you'll know where you're at to start task two, um, [0:54:32] I would suspect however that those four areas are not in cost. [0:54:49] Right. [0:54:51] Because really looking at the- [0:54:53] There is a cost with each of the four steps. [0:54:55] But they're not each 25,000. [0:54:57] They're not equal costs, no. [0:54:58] As I look at it, it's really at a six work period. [0:55:04] It's one, two A, two B, two C, three and four. [0:55:09] to his sort of [0:55:12] Here's some general programming [0:55:16] Let's see how that sounds [0:55:18] Let's refine that and we start looking at what kind of a facility to those programs have to fit in so [0:55:25] And one and two are big they're the bulk of them being here doing work [0:55:31] And four is like this little tiny piece at the end that's putting it all together and here's your deliverable [0:55:36] you know [0:55:38] So Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, you have an entire series of options that are before [0:55:49] you aside from this potential. [0:55:52] So, as you recall, the Council authorized staff to negotiate a scope of work that I think [0:56:00] that even the staff we've gone through the negotiation process have felt that the costs [0:56:06] certainly were much higher than what we had anticipated. [0:56:12] One option would be to go to number two on the list of those that we presented to you initially [0:56:19] as being qualified. [0:56:22] Another option would be for the Council to instruct staff to break this into more of a [0:56:31] concentrated phase that would allow us to achieve answers at certain decision points to continue [0:56:38] to determine whether or not we want to continue down that path. [0:56:43] I would hate to have the council vote to approve a dollar figure when we don't know if that dollar figure is going to lead to the solutions. [0:56:55] So we could spend a little bit more time with the firm that's presented to you today and try to understand what those break points would be and the deliverable after each of that phase if that would help. [0:57:08] The third option, obviously, is for you not to advance and move forward with this project [0:57:18] on this current path, that is certainly an option that's available and staff can go out [0:57:24] and it can begin to retool and work with the members of the committee on defining a process [0:57:30] that might lead to some of the similar answers. [0:57:35] I will say that when we've done this in the past and we haven't used those experts, we've [0:57:44] flailed a little bit. [0:57:46] We've gone to the spots where we can determine the need, but internally we lack the capacity [0:57:54] to be able to share this is what the ongoing operating costs are of a facility of this nature [0:58:00] into the foreseeable future. [0:58:03] I think that should the citizens pass a bond or approve funding to construct a facility, [0:58:10] our larger concern needs to be after the doors are open, how we're going to maintain that, [0:58:15] and how we're going to be able to generate revenues needed to be able to support its operations. [0:58:21] I would echo Travis's comment that I think in the past sometimes we get what we pay for, [0:58:30] If we're not going to make the commitment to experts who actually have expertise in this, [0:58:37] that we're going to, I don't think we'll quite be at, you know, four basketball courts, [0:58:42] but I worry that we won't get past the rec center, it would be swell. [0:58:51] I too am concerned it's a large number, but it seems we have opportunity to, [0:58:58] if we get to a point where it's this isn't feasible, then we're done on that path. [0:59:05] I don't think it takes $98,000 to tell us that. I think we get there sooner. I just don't know. [0:59:11] $7,000 to $5,000 somewhere. $45,000 what? Is Andy, do you have another comment? [0:59:16] I did. I understand the end goal of gathering this information. I would be comfortable at this point [0:59:26] even negotiating with the second firm, I don't, I think of where you've already got this down [0:59:31] with this company as low as you can. It's just steal too much money for the information we need. [0:59:37] I don't know if there's, I don't want to tell them how to do their job, but I just cannot get [0:59:44] my head wrapped around almost $100,000 to find out if we need a rec center and if we do where we [0:59:50] need it, who's going to use it? It just, it seems like there has to be a less expensive way to get [0:59:55] to that answer. [1:00:00] Yeah, Kevin, the loose ends that have come before us tonight. [1:00:03] I've moved to table the issue. [1:00:05] All the city do gather more information. [1:00:08] Second. [1:00:11] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Ruth Pierce to table this issue. [1:00:19] Would staff prefer some direction on what you should be doing while we have a table? [1:00:24] I think it would be beneficial. [1:00:26] I mean, are we going to just walk away from Pivot North and go to number two, for example? [1:00:32] we're going to try and put those numbers in by step, which we can go back and do. [1:00:39] In the end, we still end up with a $98,000 project if it all went forward with PIVEN [1:01:07] be helpful if you could get rice breakdowns by section 4 at certain benchmarks through the process [1:01:20] with this company. Is that something you believe they could share with you? [1:01:23] I think we can do that pretty easily. I mean, if it's helpful for the council, it was my question. [1:01:29] I think that's readily available. I've seen it before when the total cost was $150,000. [1:01:35] So I know they can do it. So I'm hearing a couple of different things up here. One is [1:01:41] 90,000 is too much no matter what. [1:01:44] Other is, 90,000 is too much if at some point it's we're not going to build this. [1:01:52] So if there is more of a stage work period to be... [1:01:59] If we were to visit pretty good for him, this road is it okay to proceed? [1:02:05] I think the information that we would get out of this feasibility study [1:02:09] we're going to need no matter what. And whether in the north does it, number two, [1:02:15] number three, wherever we're at, on that list gives us that information. We need [1:02:19] the information. My heartburn is we're going to say, here's 98,000, they can [1:02:26] come back and say, no, the community won't support this. That's a lot of money for [1:02:31] it, no. If we're going to do this, we still need to know what types of [1:02:36] programs will go in there, where it should be located, all of those types of [1:02:41] of things, but I want to be able to say Phase 1, whatever we're going to call it, if they [1:02:46] come back with a no. What's that dollar amount look like for a no? But then we know moving [1:02:52] forward. That's why I think, yeah, I'd like to know, I think that at some point in time, [1:02:58] whether it's in the north of the next group or next company, there's still not that information, [1:03:05] and I feel that they're going to probably charge us about the same amount. It's not going [1:03:09] be a huge difference but that's why I think let's break it up into chunks that [1:03:14] we can manage and then they can come come back to us and say this is what we [1:03:19] think should we move on to the next phase. Mayor comments and that yes why [1:03:29] don't you let staff take this back and we went with your permission if we don't [1:03:38] feel like we can move the ball then what we'll do is we'll go to number two on [1:03:46] on that contract. [1:03:47] I think that we've heard enough of the conversation [1:03:49] to understand what the council's looking for [1:03:52] in terms of not only process, but also in terms of [1:03:56] what the total financial impact could be moving forward. [1:04:02] And so what we'd like to do is maybe take this back. [1:04:04] We'll have some internal conversation [1:04:06] to work with the different vendors. [1:04:07] It is a requirement that we separate negotiations [1:04:11] with number one in its entirety before we move to number two. [1:04:15] And so we would want to have some conversations, not only internally, but with, um, if at North [1:04:20] and that firm before we made that move, if we made that move, then we would just then begin [1:04:26] negotiations with number two and we would like permission to be able to do that if that falls [1:04:31] within the table. [1:04:32] Personally, I would prefer that you come back to the council if you're going to move to number [1:04:38] two. [1:04:44] I think if there's an opportunity to get some price breakdown within this proposal, maybe [1:04:51] some benchmarks and bring that back and if at that point it's well gosh we're [1:04:55] gonna be next number of dollars in before we have a decision let's go try [1:05:00] something else I would prefer that we have the opportunity. Greg did you have [1:05:06] anything else to do not we need to we do have a motion on that on the floor to [1:05:16] table this so I'll call both please. Christopher Reed yes Chris [1:05:23] Yes. [1:05:24] Yes. [1:05:26] John Berrigger. [1:05:27] Yes. [1:05:28] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:05:29] Yes. [1:05:30] Greg Lanting. [1:05:31] Yes. [1:05:32] Ruth Pierce. [1:05:33] Yes. [1:05:34] She passes 6-0. [1:05:35] Thank you, Mitch. [1:05:36] Thank you, Wendy. [1:05:37] You're continuing to work on this. [1:05:40] Next on the agenda, which will be a match, is consideration and act on a resolution declaring [1:05:50] the city's intent to dispose of real property, setting a date for a public hearing and we [1:05:55] We have much humble. [1:05:57] Hey, so, I didn't feel like I should walk away and walk. [1:06:02] That's right, I just hadn't heard that page yet. [1:06:06] You all know that on our second floor of this building [1:06:09] is our development services team, engineering and building [1:06:13] inspections and planning and zoning. [1:06:14] What that means is that they're no longer in the hands of building. [1:06:18] That building has now become, I guess, access to our needs. [1:06:24] We have different members of city staff [1:06:26] different points in the last couple of months have had conversations with a few [1:06:30] different parties that are maybe interested in acquiring that property. [1:06:35] And so knowing that there's at least, you know, a couple, two or three that [1:06:40] out there are interested in it. And then also knowing the state laws regarding [1:06:45] cities disposition of real property, we wanted to come here and talk to the [1:06:50] council tonight about declaring this property kind of surplus to our needs [1:06:56] and then starting the process to dispose of it in the result of that process. [1:07:00] In this case, we're going to recommend going to an option. [1:07:03] And then, I'd better get that. [1:07:06] So, to start that process, though, is a resolution that's in your package tonight. [1:07:13] Basically, that resolution does a couple of things. [1:07:15] It sets a public hearing date. [1:07:17] That date is a couple weeks out. [1:07:23] Yeah, March 26th. [1:07:25] And then we kind of declare that it's a surplus and we're going to go through this process and we're going to take it on this date while I have it all be caring so that the public can come and say, no, you really shouldn't sell that. [1:07:39] You should keep it and turn it into a rec center, whatever they're going to say. [1:07:44] So what we're going to ask you to do tonight is adopt the attached resolution. [1:07:50] Couple of things we can do that I'm not really sure quite how to do it, but I thought I'd talk about it anyway [1:07:56] We can set like a minimum value that we expect to get out of the building which [1:08:03] We haven't done a lot of that in my time with the city [1:08:08] But we can't I don't have an appraised an appraisal of this building [1:08:12] I didn't go out and spend the five grand to get in the prison so I could come here and [1:08:17] talk to you about that. [1:08:18] If you would like us to do that, we can certainly do that. [1:08:21] The appraisal that I do have is from 2006 and probably not worth the paper that's written [1:08:29] on. [1:08:31] It's a pretty low value. [1:08:32] I know that in 2007 when we acquired the building, I can tell you what we have in the [1:08:40] building, right? [1:08:41] And then we added some construction work to the tune of about $140,000. [1:08:48] So we're about $410,000 into that building, most of that from like 2007, 2008 timeframe. [1:08:57] I'm not sure what depreciation might have done. [1:09:00] I'm not sure what appreciation of the value of the property might have done. [1:09:04] So that's kind of what I know in terms of value without going and getting an appraisal. [1:09:10] I know that if I look at the county tax records, [1:09:13] they won't tell me about you because it's a public bill. [1:09:15] It's going to be a big fat zero. [1:09:17] That doesn't help me at all. [1:09:20] But we can, if we want to, set a minimum price that will take [1:09:24] an auction for this. [1:09:25] And that can be that part of it. [1:09:30] So that wouldn't necessarily have to happen tonight. [1:09:34] But we can do that before we go to auction. [1:09:37] Anyway, there's something to think about. [1:09:40] So that's what we've got is I want to start this process so that we can get this building [1:09:46] off our hands and get it into somebody's tax-producing hands. [1:09:51] Well, with that, we just request that you approve the resolution. [1:09:57] A question I have on a March 26th is spring break. [1:10:02] I believe we're not supposed to be scared of that. [1:10:07] Oh yeah, one we're not supposed to have a public hearing is that night and two I'm not confident we're gonna have a quiet change that date [1:10:16] Push that back a week to [1:10:21] April [1:10:26] April 2nd we'll just make that as part of your motion to approve the resolution changing the date April 2nd [1:10:33] We can do that as far as the evaluation. That's not something that we need to do on that evening [1:10:43] Well, the action that night will be, yeah, go auction this building off, and that would [1:10:49] be a good time to understand if we want to set a floor or not. [1:10:55] You're stuck. [1:10:56] Yeah, for instance, whatever value we establish, or find market value for the property, are [1:11:03] we obligated to accept that if any bids come in, add or even below that? [1:11:11] We set a minimum, and we received that minimum offer, and we would be obligated. [1:11:15] We don't get the venom on that. [1:11:19] Obviously we're not obligated. [1:11:21] Thank you. [1:11:23] Any other questions for staff? [1:11:26] Then we would be obligated to take the highest venom. [1:11:31] Whoever that might come from. [1:11:35] Do you have a resolution number? [1:11:37] Resolution 2018-3. [1:11:40] And solutions. [1:11:45] We're talking to a passage of resolution 2018-3. [1:11:51] With a change in date change [1:11:55] My Chris Stockton second of my Christopher Reed to approve resolution [1:12:04] 2018-3 [1:12:06] With a date change of the public hearing to April 2nd 2018 [1:12:11] Or any discussion here in a roll call vote. Thanks Chris Stockington. Yes [1:12:22] Burger yes [1:12:24] Hawkins. Yes, Reg 19. Yeah [1:12:30] Yes, motion passes 6-0. Next on the agenda is a request to continue consideration of options [1:12:42] for the recycling program managed by PSI and consider authorizing cost sharing with PSI for [1:12:47] calendar year 2018. And we have Bill Baxter with our utility services. And while Bill is giving us [1:12:55] a little overview there because someone from staff go grab a sign-in sheet pretty [1:13:00] please look at the mayor and council it's a pleasure to be with you again look [1:13:06] forward to the feedback and the discussion this evening first of all [1:13:11] we we have included in the staff report this evening some options to kind of [1:13:18] bracket the discussion real quick is your mic oh yes I'm just not [1:13:23] Okay, that's okay. I just wanted to make sure that [1:13:25] I'm just going to do this. [1:13:27] So you can pull it up on the edge there. [1:13:29] Okay, perfect. [1:13:31] Thank you. That's better. Thank you very much. [1:13:35] So I wanted to make sure that people understand that [1:13:39] the options included in the staff report are simply to bracket [1:13:43] the conversation. And then I have a couple of other things [1:13:47] I want to make sure are understood. Then I'm going to have Jeff come up and talk a little [1:13:51] bit about option one as listed in the report. [1:13:57] First of all, the rate increase that we are considering at this point in time is the city's [1:14:04] rate increase. [1:14:05] This is not a request from PSI for a rate increase. [1:14:09] I've had a conversation with a couple of citizens and it became clear that was part [1:14:13] of the confusion. [1:14:15] are two that some change in rates under the operation of this as a proprietary or enterprise [1:14:25] fund will be required. We're going to have extra cost at the landfill if all of it goes [1:14:31] there. We can't escape that. And the third point, again, just for clarification, the numbers [1:14:40] that you will see tonight, and I'm going to, after we're done, I'm going to pop up a schedule [1:14:44] of projected rates and what that does to the cost comparison between recycling and the landfill [1:14:51] are estimated based on cost information we currently have and the landfill rates as they [1:14:57] currently stand. [1:14:58] So these are estimated numbers for purposes of the conversation. [1:15:03] With that, I've promised 10 minutes and I'm going to do my best. [1:15:07] First of all, the bottom line of this whole thing is we just discontinue the program and [1:15:14] it all goes to the landfill. [1:15:16] So with that, I'd like Jeff to come down and just give a little input from PSI's point [1:15:21] of view as to the price decrease number that's in the staff report. [1:15:25] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the council. [1:15:30] Can you hear me? [1:15:32] Yes. [1:15:33] So yeah, basically with obviously eliminating the recycle program all together, it would [1:15:39] come with some cost savings, obviously how we'd arrive at that cost savings would be [1:15:44] parking the truck, elimination of an employer, an employee, not an ideal solution, but that's [1:15:51] really how we arrived at that number. I think the savings was 80 cents per home per month. [1:15:56] Bill stated that, but also that does not include the cost of landfilling that material, [1:16:02] so that's really how we arrived at that question though, man. [1:16:07] That was very short. [1:16:10] I have a question. [1:16:11] Yeah, I have a question. [1:16:12] Okay, so in the analysis on the cost versus landfill, if we continue to recycle, you're [1:16:21] showing 40 cents to go to the landfill. [1:16:25] So when you talk about that number, you're talking about all the garbage versus just recycling, [1:16:32] correct? [1:16:33] Correct. [1:16:34] I'm sure that would be plenty of other questions for you, Jeff. [1:16:40] I'll still get too far. [1:16:43] I'll stick or I can. [1:16:46] Wonderful. [1:16:47] Ruth actually, that 40 cent comparison, [1:16:51] that is the landfill tonnage. [1:16:54] Had a million, eight hundred and eighty seven thousand pounds. [1:16:58] A thousand, eight hundred and eighty seven tons. [1:17:01] That's what it would cost us 40 cents, basically broken down [1:17:05] by the number of customers last year. [1:17:08] So when there's a discussion of an 80 cent fee, [1:17:14] 80 cent reduction. Yes, then you would add 40 cents back to that. [1:17:20] So that's a net 40 cent reduction. [1:17:25] It's off the first site, 40 cents back to the land. [1:17:31] Right, so a 40 cent overall decline, if that were the option. Thank you. [1:17:38] Second option, middle of the road. [1:17:43] This is a little more complex, in that what we would do under that option would be to say [1:17:54] this is what the city is willing to contribute in a cost chair or in cost of the landfill. [1:18:01] And that would be what we call the breakpoint. [1:18:07] And then city management and PSI would consult as these prices fluctuate monthly to where [1:18:14] Where are we in comparison with that breakpoint? [1:18:17] The recycle program would stay in effect as far as the discipline of putting only the [1:18:24] qualified things in the carts. [1:18:28] NPSI would run their recycle truck on the route like we normally do. [1:18:33] But if the price to recycle is above this breakpoint, the truck would go to the transfer [1:18:41] station and empty its load. [1:18:44] If the price comes to or below that acceptable breakpoint, the trucks would go to Magic Valley [1:18:51] recycling. [1:18:52] It would be bailed and sent into the street. [1:18:55] That gives us the flexibility of responding to the market as things change. [1:19:01] This last year, monthly the rate fluctuated, and we don't want to try to keep having this [1:19:08] conversation and adjusting the dollar figure. [1:19:12] So that's what NUT2 is, 3, evaporating as we are, keep putting it into the stream, negotiate [1:19:21] our cost chair and just keep sending it to Boise for sorting and processing, then on [1:19:28] to Oregon or Washington where it goes to the port or it doesn't. [1:19:35] I know the industry is wrestling with this right now as our number of cities, no Josh [1:19:40] has spoken to me about some input he's had from looking at what's happening in [1:19:44] some cities in Oregon. But the flexibility goes away at either end of this scale. [1:19:51] Somewhere in the middle is an ability to respond as the market shifts which it [1:19:56] is bound to continue to do as markets. Open up, people open facilities, China [1:20:03] changes its rules, however that's gonna happen. The only other common I'd make [1:20:10] is BSI's fill the whole role up here with their personnel. I think that indicates their investment in this process. [1:20:19] So with that, I would stand for questions. [1:20:23] I have to do it out of there and put you on it back and give us just to make a point with option number two [1:20:28] being that there's that threshold of kind of the happy medium where there would be land field or go to the recycle stream. [1:20:36] Basically, one of the prices are extremely high like it is right now, that's really when [1:20:41] you're running with the possibility that maybe this material has no value, therefore [1:20:45] it may go into the landfill, when the price comes down, obviously there is value to that [1:20:50] material and it definitely would be a recycle, so something to consider. [1:20:55] Quick question on that, if that's all right, Mayor. [1:20:58] In the last couple of months, as prices have gone up, not knowing what the break point is [1:21:03] right now, how much would you have estimated that would have gone at that point in time [1:21:07] with the price where it's at this time what we're hearing is everything is [1:21:10] but being sold overseas it's not to China as it was before higher prices but a [1:21:14] lesser price like Indonesia India Malaysia those countries so it is being [1:21:20] recycled now just in a lesser price yes there's talking to so is it safe to say [1:21:27] the thing that appeals to me as I understand item two it's not going the [1:21:32] baby out with recycling it's not continuing a program that is that is [1:21:38] It's costing you a lot of money and is going against what we had called recycling. [1:21:45] Our rates would be, but this gives us time and I really like that and we can almost monthly [1:21:53] adjust it and have ongoing negotiations. [1:21:56] But what happens in the worst of worlds if there is an absolute, almost permanent appearance [1:22:05] of a dropout in any recycling time? [1:22:08] We envision going six months with some period of both negotiation or would you come back [1:22:16] at that specific break point to say we've got to take some more decisive action? [1:22:21] Yeah, absolutely. I think this would at least does bite by type, like you said. [1:22:27] What we're hearing from the industry is obviously recycling is not going to go away. [1:22:32] They're going to have infrastructure somewhere, whether it be in China or they move to the states side [1:22:36] somewhere on the west coast or other countries adopted. They use this material for packaging overseas and there's a great need for this. [1:22:44] So there is going to be a need for this recyclable material so it's not going to go away. [1:22:48] It's just how do we make it profitable? Again, it's really what it comes down to. [1:22:52] That option too actually gives us the most flexibility planning for the future, whichever way the work goes and kind of pales you guys out. [1:23:03] I think it's the best, best direction for all parties. [1:23:06] Thank you. [1:23:07] Jeff, why are you there? [1:23:10] It's the idea where that sweet spot is. [1:23:14] Just in working with Bill and discussing that, I'd say the sweet spot's really kind [1:23:18] of close to the $80 a ton. [1:23:20] With cost sharing, that's $40 for the city, $40 to P.S.I. [1:23:25] And obviously, now that the landfill rate is $37.50, so it keeps your portion really close [1:23:31] the same all year round with a very minimal impact of constituents. [1:23:37] So at that $80 a ton range, that would still require a pre-store current fee. [1:23:45] 32 cents, is that the rate? [1:24:00] So, Councilman Talking Tenet mentioned, you know, is this six months we give this a shot, [1:24:08] so as I run the math on the rest of the fiscal year, [1:24:11] Assuming we can get this in place in March that seven months before the end of the fiscal year. [1:24:16] I would assume that would give us some time through plant September, right? [1:24:21] March, April, May, June, July, August. There's probably not enough time. [1:24:25] No, no, no, no. But I'm saying if we were to do something now, make a decision on this now, [1:24:32] there would be time through the budget planning process for the upcoming budget year, [1:24:38] maybe take a closer look at what if this goes to 150 bucks a ton next year what [1:24:46] do we want to do for next year's rates yes so we do have several folks who have [1:25:03] signed up here to give us an input this evening which we encourage them to do so [1:25:08] now it might be a good time for us to do that and then we'll have some [1:25:11] discussion as a council and I'm sure I have some more questions and there may [1:25:16] be others who are here who did not sign up and that doesn't mean you can't speak [1:25:20] We'll just go through the list that signed up to speak first and then we'll get to you. [1:25:24] So Sarah or Britt, did you want to speak on this issue? [1:25:28] Okay. So next I have Roberta Kelly. [1:25:33] She knocked out. [1:25:37] Next is it Cheyenne? [1:25:40] Cheyenne? [1:25:44] Cheyenne. [1:25:49] So I would ask folks to please try to keep your comments concise. [1:25:54] I'm going to put a time limit on but just keep them concise and try not to be terribly repetitive. [1:25:58] Terribly repetitive as we go through the evening and if you would that please state your name and whether you are a resident [1:26:04] Or property owner in the city of Twin Falls for the record, please [1:26:08] Che on sheen and I'm a resident [1:26:11] Thank you. Welcome in recent concerns about the expedit expenditure on our local Twin Falls recycling system as a local resident and senior [1:26:26] At Twin Falls High School. I'd like to share my firm thoughts on the situation as the founder of environmental [1:26:31] Here at Twin Falls High School, I have seen a need for continuing the recycling program. [1:26:36] In only the past few months, the 20 club members and I have collectively created a multimedia [1:26:40] recycling system at our own high school. [1:26:42] We have increased the recycling immensely. [1:26:44] At the beginning of the year, there is approximately two small plastic and aluminum bins for recycling. [1:26:50] Only collecting about 20 bottles and cans a month. [1:26:52] With our observances, we have seen that many do not want to go through the hassle of recycling. [1:26:57] Hence why we have made it our mission to make recycling more convenient to all students [1:27:00] at Twin Fools High School. Through the generous donation from the graduating [1:27:05] class in 1966, we have expanded our recycling system to every hallway and every classroom. [1:27:10] We approximately collect over 200 bottles, 200 cans, and hundreds of papers every two weeks. [1:27:16] We have seen a significant and positive trend in the daily habits of our peers and firmly [1:27:20] believe that recycling increases the long-term quality of life rather than myopic financial [1:27:25] profit. I realize and recognize that the cost is very important. Factor in recycling [1:27:31] costs and recycling costs extra due to contaminated recycling. I would just like to [1:27:35] share Twin Falls High School experience and recycling. In the beginning of a recycling [1:27:39] program, I would go around individually to clean them and I would find the randomest [1:27:44] stuff like waffles, burritos, fermented milk and everything that the lunch ladies provided [1:27:48] in the lunch room. And there was also a lot of plastics that were considered as like wishful [1:27:53] wishful recycling and we had a lot of this improper recycling and but now we [1:28:02] hardly have that and why it's because education and positive motivation along [1:28:08] with the post of proper recycling we put out on our bins we went to every single [1:28:13] classroom with a bin and encouraged and taught our peers how to properly recycle [1:28:16] we have learned that fear is not a very good inducer for taking action [1:28:21] rather the opposite. If I can share an example, there's a podcast by Hidden Brain called You're Right, [1:28:26] I'm Wrong. And they give an example about how there's a hospital in the East Coast and [1:28:32] obviously we all know we should probably wash our hands before and after we treat a patient. [1:28:36] But they're at the hospital only about one out of ten employees were doing the proper ways of [1:28:43] disinfecting their hands. And so even with all of their like, hey, you need to click like, wash [1:28:48] your hands like it's a bunch of germs like it's still say the same until they [1:28:52] put in a digital screen where every time you wash your hands the camera would [1:29:00] notice and it would give you real-time statistics on how many people wash [1:29:06] their hands that week and how many people washed their hands in that [1:29:10] current shift and it would just go up and so they would see this positive [1:29:13] feedback and the number one from one to ten employees to nine to ten employees [1:29:18] a 90% and it stayed there. And so with that we implemented this in our own school and [1:29:26] so when we see people recycle we're very encouraging and we go out and we give statistics [1:29:30] like hey last week we only recycle 20 plastic bottles but this week we have 40 that's double [1:29:36] the amount and people like that and people want to keep increasing that number and so [1:29:42] we've seen a lot of positive trend from that. And I believe that the City of Twin [1:29:50] Falls should be able, should do the same thing and should send out like bi-weekly [1:29:55] reports and how many times like we recycled, how many tons we recycled. And [1:29:59] also Earth Day is coming up April 22nd and I believe that we can have a [1:30:03] community little education and like hey like here's free food and here we're [1:30:09] planting trees and this is really awesome and recycling is fun. I believe [1:30:14] that most people will not go out of their way to recycle but if we give them the [1:30:19] opportunity, if we give them this recycling bin at their house and if we [1:30:23] give them a positive environment then more people will continue to recycle [1:30:28] properly. But if we can't recycle that's completely in action and we want action [1:30:35] and we want positive change. [1:30:42] I'd just like to say, if 20 high school students can do it with 2,000 people, then with the [1:30:47] city's help we can do it with 50,000 people. [1:30:50] As a 24-year-old high school environmental club, we would be more than willing to support [1:30:53] any efforts in keeping recycling in our town. [1:30:55] If that means holding meetings and teaching community members how to do proper recycling, [1:31:01] we would do it. [1:31:02] If that means going door to door to take a survey, we would do it. [1:31:05] If that means receiving half of our student population support, we would do it. [1:31:08] Please consider the next generation of voters when making your decision. [1:31:12] Open to questions. [1:31:14] Any questions for our question? [1:31:17] No questions, but thank you very much. [1:31:19] I appreciate you taking the time to come and for sending us an email this week. [1:31:22] It really helps us make a good decision. [1:31:25] Thank you. [1:31:27] Next is Kylie Hanson. [1:31:37] Hi, my name is Kylie Hanson, and I am a resident. [1:31:40] Thank you. [1:31:40] Welcome. [1:31:43] So I'm a part of the environmentalist club [1:31:45] that I just spoke about. [1:31:48] I am an individual who lives for the future. [1:31:51] From when I was very little, I aspired [1:31:52] to go to college for a degree in physics. [1:31:55] And now I'm living that future, I envision for myself [1:31:58] as part of MIT's incoming freshman class. [1:32:01] Now, only do I think about my own future, however, [1:32:03] but the future of the world that I will live in. [1:32:06] One of the things I realize is that we urge, [1:32:09] one of the things that we all should realize [1:32:11] is that resources on this planet that we live on [1:32:13] The recycling, we recognize this fact and become proactive, progressive, intelligent, and appreciative of the only planet we currently inhabit. [1:32:22] One of the main arguments against recycling is the cost and the value of the material. [1:32:27] But if we take a step back to consider the water purpose of recycling, of ensuring the efficient usage of finite resources, [1:32:35] then it becomes obvious that cost is leaving an argument that should be made on a raptorscale. [1:32:44] You cannot bury additional plastic once all fossil fuels have been used up. [1:32:48] You cannot bury additional aluminum once we've used all of it and mined all of it. [1:32:54] Also, there is an article or an air pollution in public school districts in the Guardian that I recently read. [1:33:01] And in it, 21st was number six on the list of worst air quality in the United States in districts that have public schools. [1:33:11] If anything, we should be doing more for the environment than less. [1:33:15] By thinking to the future, we ensured the wellbeing of future generations to come. [1:33:21] Recycling is merely universally agreed upon as a necessity to push back against the waste of society. [1:33:28] By moving the community's ability to recycle, we are not only indirectly claiming that we [1:33:35] don't care about future generations, but also claiming that we are not a global community. [1:33:40] We would rather follow ourselves from the rest of humanity in favor of a little monetary [1:33:45] cost. [1:33:46] There was also a Thomas O'Rourke article on recycling recently, and it said that the [1:33:50] PSI paid $110,000, and that ratepayers would have to pay $7 additionally annually to cover [1:33:58] the class, and I'm a student who only works part-time, but I could still easily [1:34:04] pay this amount I've asked of me. If people in this community can pay seven [1:34:09] dollars monthly for Netflix, then they can easily pay seven dollars annually for recycling. [1:34:14] Open for questions, thank you. Thank you Miss Hanson, any questions? Thank you for taking the time to come to the meeting tonight. [1:34:24] Next on the list is Dennis Crawford, I am Dennis Crawford, I am both a property owner [1:34:42] and a resident of this community for 42 years. [1:34:46] I have had my support with these two young women that tonight I really appreciate the single stream [1:34:55] of recycling that we have in our community. [1:34:58] I'm a recycler. I think it would be a shame if we were to lose that [1:35:05] we'll need to recycle and level two of our part for our environment. [1:35:10] I guess I haven't heard the different options. [1:35:17] The option that sounds most appropriate would be that second option [1:35:22] that the parks would have the option of taking it to recycle [1:35:28] or to level two at their cost. [1:35:33] But, having said that, just like this young woman said, $7 more per month, because, if I take perils, [1:35:42] it would not cost me $5 for one trip, $7 plus the fuel. [1:35:48] I am so $7, a very affordable amount for me, and I think for most people. [1:35:56] I am retired. I have to look at it to keep the dollars to lose the ability to recycle, I think, with a terrible shame. [1:36:06] Thank you, Mr. Crawford. [1:36:11] Thank you, Mr. Crawford. [1:36:14] Next on the sign-up sheet, I have Laverne Fairchilds. [1:36:17] Good evening. My name is Laverne Fairchild, and I am a property owner at Twin Falls County. [1:36:33] The reason I'm here is just responding to your request for more information regarding recycling. [1:36:41] I wanted to make myself available if necessary. I was on the task force for recycling in the City of Plano, Texas back in 1991 for almost six years. [1:36:56] It was a comprehensive program. [1:36:59] It started off really small in the community. [1:37:02] People were not very happy with us. [1:37:05] They said, you are the pickiest people with your trash. [1:37:09] But it actually became very streamlined, very positive, [1:37:15] and it was very positive for the community. [1:37:19] It was a long process. [1:37:22] And I highly recommend if you're serious about recycling and moving forward with this [1:37:29] community as far as you realize you're trying to get your population of 50,000 for all these [1:37:35] other issues, you need to consider a solid waste department. [1:37:44] It's a long-term plan, but that's where you need to be if you want to really do this right. [1:37:51] You can still use PSI initially in the beginning, but eventually we took everything in house [1:37:58] and with our Solid Waste Department we made it streamlined so we recycled just about everything. [1:38:07] My trash can really didn't need to be emptied, but maybe once every three months. [1:38:16] It was pretty much empty. [1:38:17] By the time I bought in bulk, I had the HDPEs, the PETEs, all the glass, the bi-metals, all [1:38:26] these things can all be recycled. [1:38:30] We actually utilized what you would call special kids or the mentally challenged, which was [1:38:38] a real positive for our community to sort all of our recyclables. [1:38:43] young people love having a job. They like the fact that they feel valuable, they [1:38:51] enjoy the fact that they get paid, they like that they have a place to go, and it [1:38:57] was a really incredible success story because we utilized a segment of the [1:39:05] community that was untouched and that was lost. So, you know, there's a long-term [1:39:12] term plan to doing all this, but I think that, you know, Twin Falls should start to [1:39:19] entertain these ideas. So we did the trash and the recycling. We also did a bulky waste [1:39:26] program like you were doing with Christmas trees. We took all the Christmas trees and [1:39:32] all the leaves. You had to pack your leaves, break your yard, put your leaves in a large [1:39:37] paper bag that we would sell for a dollar and the bags got to our area, our reclamation [1:39:48] area and we had the tractors come in and turn the compost. All of that compost went on the [1:39:55] city parks. It was not wasted. It was used in the parks and rekt department. All residents [1:40:01] of the city were able to purchase, it's been a while now, but you could get your first load [1:40:11] every quarter for free because you showed your driver's license, you live in the city, [1:40:17] you contributed waste to get your compost and then, therefore, you could put it on your [1:40:23] trees and flowers and flower beds, you know, in the spring or the fall, before the winter [1:40:29] time. [1:40:30] It was completing the cycle. [1:40:33] We also did household chemicals. [1:40:37] You could call up and if you needed to put your leftover [1:40:41] paint, your cleaning supplies or anything else like that, [1:40:45] the trucks would on certain days pick up all of your chemicals. [1:40:51] And then we had a little shack in town near the Solid Waste [1:40:54] Transfer Station. [1:40:56] And you could walk in there and if you're needy or it didn't matter who you were, you [1:41:04] could, you know, a lot of needy people would like to have some paint or whatever, it's [1:41:09] free. [1:41:10] We recycle it, you could pick up four or five cans of paint, mix them all together and make [1:41:15] a fun color and, you know, paint your garage. [1:41:19] So we were recycling all of these materials at no charge to the community. [1:41:26] And then there's also medical waste. [1:41:29] So there are a lot of answers out there. [1:41:30] If you're truly interested in exploring any ideas, [1:41:34] I highly recommend you write down this web address [1:41:38] and then perhaps call them and talk to the Solid Waste [1:41:43] Director and ask them about their program [1:41:45] because there's no sense reinventing the wheel. [1:41:48] If someone's already done it, then learn from them. [1:41:52] I'm sure when I lived in Texas for 22 years, we would see bus stops that we [1:42:00] like down in Austin and we'd call them for their plans and if we wanted to, we [1:42:05] could build them here and we got the plans for nothing. So why not take advantage of [1:42:09] it? Somebody's already paid for it. The web address is www.plano.gov. [1:42:20] GOV, forward slash, 1-6-5-1, forward slash, residential, hyphen services. [1:42:36] I highly recommend you look at their web page, it's very comprehensive, we've gone through [1:42:40] lots of different strategies. [1:42:42] We would also put out a calendar for the year that would highlight the dates that you had, [1:42:50] You know, this pick up and that pick up and whatever. [1:42:53] You could also call in, if you have one to quarter, [1:42:56] you could also call in and say, [1:42:58] I have a bulky trash pick up. [1:43:00] And that means I've got a mattress, I've got a TV, [1:43:03] I've got a microwave, and then it's all picked up. [1:43:07] You get one a month for, one a quarter for free, [1:43:11] and if you needed more than that, you had to pay a fee. [1:43:14] So I don't know where you're at, [1:43:17] If you're looking long term at building this community, I think that this is a good place to start. [1:43:24] Thank you. Any questions? [1:43:26] Any questions? [1:43:28] Thank you so much. [1:43:32] So, that is all I had who signed in on the sheet to sleep, but I certainly am welcome to any others coming forward. [1:43:39] So, if you'd like to come forward, it's going to harm us a little bit. [1:43:44] Whoever is closer. [1:44:05] Welcome. [1:44:07] I'm a resident here at Quint Falls. [1:44:10] I'm also in favor of continuing the recycling program and want to consider some of the benefits [1:44:16] of doing that in addition to what we've already heard, consider economic development in the [1:44:21] city, and businesses like to see cities that have sustainable practices in place, and [1:44:26] Cliv part, which would be one example of that. [1:44:29] Also, it would probably be beneficial to include more public education. [1:44:36] I'm not sure of the best approaches to that, but mailings, perhaps stickers on the bins [1:44:43] themselves that talk about things that could be placed there. [1:44:46] And I'll also offer to the High School Environmental Club the CCSI Sustainability Council, [1:44:51] who we'd be willing to help with educational things as well. [1:44:54] Thank you for any questions. [1:44:56] Thank you, Jan. Any questions? [1:44:59] No. Thank you. Thanks. [1:45:01] Next. Welcome. [1:45:13] Hello, thank you. I'm a Miss Joss. I'm a resident here in Twin Falls. [1:45:17] I always wondered why we came at recycled glass. [1:45:21] I understand I was trying to... [1:45:25] someone was in the recycling business. It's more expensive and it's worth... [1:45:30] but we can't glass glass forever. [1:45:34] I was trying to front of mine tonight in Canada and instead they recycle everything. [1:45:39] So I cannot have them in Twin Falls and not recycling. [1:45:44] We need to do that. [1:45:49] All right. [1:45:51] Thank you. [1:45:52] Thank you. [1:45:53] And we'll get you an answer to the reason the glass does not include in our current program [1:45:59] after we're done hearing the rest of the input. [1:46:01] Anyone else who wishes to address the council? [1:46:04] My answer is Robert Plass. [1:46:18] I'm a property owner here in Twin Falls. [1:46:21] I want to thank those who have ladies for their input. [1:46:25] They're the future. [1:46:27] If they don't get input from us, they're not going to have the future. [1:46:32] Among the other end of the spectrum, people in my KH category, I think, and everybody [1:46:39] else who respond to this recycling, I'm impressed with the recycling that we do. [1:46:45] I understand it's a financial concern and a gentleman that's talking about glass. [1:46:52] I found out you can take glass at the target and they won't recycle it for you. [1:46:56] At least it does go to some place where they can use it. [1:46:59] I've talked to a gentleman that's in the window business and he says we're running out of glass because they're running out of sand. [1:47:06] That's something to look forward to. [1:47:08] I don't mind if we have to pay a little bit more money because if we don't do something now, these guys are younger. [1:47:16] aren't going to have anything to be proud of. [1:47:19] It involves a city of 80,000 people with big dumps around it. [1:47:25] And we're getting the landfill there to converting that to methane gas. [1:47:30] But that's a great step forward. [1:47:32] But they can't convert plastic and cardboard to methane gas. [1:47:36] And I know I understand it right. [1:47:40] Our plastics now are down to just ones and twos. [1:47:43] And I think when it first started, we had a little bit more leeway there, [1:47:46] but the market is changing. [1:47:48] But I truly think if we don't continue this program, [1:47:52] we're going to have problems down the road from now. [1:47:54] And we're going to look back on today's economy and the situation and think, [1:47:59] I didn't do so. [1:48:00] And it's not going to be us. [1:48:01] It's going to be our younger people, our younger generation is going to say, [1:48:04] why didn't they? [1:48:06] Don't say it's important to us. [1:48:08] I think a lot of us going to go out to be responsible for education [1:48:14] People are just throwing away all sorts of dirty tuna fish cans in their aluminum, so they think we can recycle that, but that's contamination. [1:48:21] We need to make sure they understand that that has to be cleaned up, or it's going to, it's going to, you know, a few cans in a truckload, as I understand, it's going to contaminate the whole thing of having to be rejected. [1:48:33] I think education is going to be a big step, and I think we need to work on that. I think we need to, let's continue it. [1:48:40] As a homeowner, I don't mind paying a little bit more, but I've also heard rumors that it might be on the homeowners, if not the renters. [1:48:49] I think it should be across the board. Everybody is educated. Everybody pays the same. [1:48:54] We don't have, I hate to say this, but renters growing their trash into homeowners. [1:49:02] and homeowner absorbs that responsibility. [1:49:07] I think it should be equitable across the board. [1:49:10] And it's just, education is not a one-time thing. [1:49:14] You know, we didn't go to kindergarten and graduate [1:49:16] from college to next week, but you know, [1:49:18] 16 years of education, you have to get where we're at now. [1:49:21] And I think this is what we should look at [1:49:22] as far as our recycling program, that's a few questions. [1:49:29] Questions? [1:49:30] Thank you so much for your input. [1:49:34] anyone else who wishes to speak. Yes, come forward, please sir. [1:49:39] Ann Burgerner and the City Council, my name is Steve Tonks. I'm tired and retired, [1:50:07] citizen and property owner of the City of Twin Falls. A couple things that I have [1:50:15] not heard any answers to that I have. One is that the current rate that we're [1:50:21] filling up the landfill, how much more life expectancy do we have in that [1:50:26] landfill before we have to go out and find another location. Finding another [1:50:33] location is also going to be a challenge. The fact that you have property owners [1:50:39] that are going to be adjacent and are they going to want a landfill next to [1:50:45] their property. I don't think you'll find very many people raising their hand [1:50:50] asking for that to happen. The other thing that will occur when you try to go [1:50:55] up for a new landfill is you have to have the environmental impact of what's [1:51:02] going to go on with the new landfill. In our area right here, one of the things that [1:51:08] have shown up just recently is sage graphs. On the natures we can list. You try to find [1:51:18] a landfill where there's no sage graphs. I don't know how successful you're going to [1:51:23] be. Those are a couple of questions I have about where we're at and if we discontinue [1:51:34] with this recycle, how much more is that going to affect our landfill and what rate? [1:51:42] I think we should postpone as much as possible filling up that landfill and finding other [1:51:49] ways to use it. [1:51:50] I don't know if an incinerator has been looked at, that takes trash, material, and changes [1:51:59] into some type of usable energy, but I understand that's the possibility of those of the questions [1:52:07] I have. [1:52:08] Thank you. [1:52:10] Thanks. [1:52:11] Any questions? [1:52:13] I don't see any. [1:52:14] Thank you. [1:52:16] There are anyone else who wishes to speak on this issue? [1:52:19] Anyone else in the audience have some discussion amongst the Council? [1:52:30] Mr. Stockington. [1:52:31] Well, for those of you in the audience may have heard this. [1:52:35] I apologize if not. [1:52:36] I hope you can look at it as a celebration of our recycling since about 2010. [1:52:43] We have kept 14.5 thousand tons out of the landfill at the current landfill, [1:52:52] across the 37.5. [1:52:55] We've kept 29 million pounds out of the landfill by recycling, as given, [1:53:02] provided about 178,000 revenue, and kept about $543,000 in [1:53:12] landfill costs. So that's a total value just since about 2010. 721,000 dollars. Now for [1:53:24] the bean counters, I kind of get you all excited. But you've spoken so eloquently here [1:53:29] tonight about the human value and the value to our society and what we're teaching her [1:53:35] kids or future generation. We need to pat ourselves on the back, but we also as a council [1:53:44] or facing an extremely difficult time where the economics of recycling are in dramatic [1:53:52] change and we need to buy ourselves some time, we're not in good conscience going to [1:53:58] be succeeding and addressing the problem by saying we're going to discontinue the program, [1:54:05] likewise continuing with its current rate, I don't think this infrastructure is not feasible, [1:54:10] So I'll just bring this back to the council. [1:54:13] I very much support the option too, as Ben provided tonight. [1:54:18] Thank you, Chris. [1:54:22] Is that not good? [1:54:23] I agree with Chris. [1:54:25] After listening to testimony, I was actually leaning even [1:54:30] towards lifting the cost up and keep recycling. [1:54:34] But I think as a balanced to our community, [1:54:37] I know I did receive some emails that I think [1:54:39] passed on and shared and some testimony that we haven't maybe heard orally here [1:54:44] tonight for a few folks with fixed income that are really struggling. So I [1:54:49] think going with the option two and finding a middle ground until we can come [1:54:52] up with a solid answer in the next few months is probably in the best interest [1:54:57] of everyone. I wanted to thank everybody that came here tonight to talk [1:55:04] about that or talk about this. I also think that a couple of people who emailed me I [1:55:09] I feel the same way I think option two is our best option, understanding the volatility [1:55:15] in the market right now, not knowing what's going to happen, but also making sure that [1:55:19] we can meet the needs of not only current residents, but future residents, realizing [1:55:26] that there's a huge impact that this will play on those generations to come. [1:55:30] So, I am in favor of finding that breakpoint also, I know realize that two would have a [1:55:37] Great increase, but I think that's what we need to do with peers. [1:55:43] Great landing. [1:55:46] I think it's bigger. [1:55:51] Number two as well. [1:55:53] Again, again, we're looking at the first thing you can put up. [1:55:57] Usually, on the Oregon Loop, right now, I was looking at one of the models. [1:56:02] If we have the number eight of your license, it's for 10 cents. [1:56:09] Oregon is one of the four routes of the biggie. [1:56:12] sure that each plastic is where we can get recycled, but also know that the [1:56:19] point is that the original battery has been working on some way, and in [1:56:25] voice, we've lowered that amount of that 20-0 time for the spear, which looks a lot of [1:56:30] time there, but thank you. And we may have been doing the top two years of [1:56:36] some time to constantly work with our neighbors through the West, to see whether [1:56:41] Thank you, Greg. [1:56:50] I too believe that this middle ground is the way we're going to need to go. [1:56:58] I will chair in Suzanne's sentiment, though, based upon some of the, certainly the testimony [1:57:05] we've heard tonight and what I've heard this week. [1:57:09] I think I was willing to go with a potential higher rate increase to accommodate continuing [1:57:17] as is I would question whether we might look at a higher break point of maybe [1:57:29] the hundred dollars a ton which based upon these numbers is pretty darn close to [1:57:34] what we would be paying anyway if we were to just take all that to the landfill [1:57:37] it's the 42 cents instead of the 40 cents simply because looking at the track record [1:57:43] here for the past four months, 120, 100, I have ish because I would hate to look at this [1:58:01] middle ground, raise rates, and dump everything because the goal really is to continue the recycling. [1:58:10] I think in a couple of other comments that were made tonight that I think are very important [1:58:14] and we need to find ways to partner on that whether it's the city and PSI, but I think [1:58:19] outreach from the High School Environmentalist Club from CSI Sustainability Council, we need [1:58:25] to work on some education. [1:58:27] I will freely admit I've had a family meeting at my house to point out all the things that [1:58:32] they're doing wrong, not me of course only them. [1:58:36] But we as a community need to do our part to try to clean up that stream of waste so that [1:58:42] it can be utilized. [1:58:44] But I do think if we're going to talk about this middle ground, I would certainly be supportive [1:58:49] of trying to up that a bit beyond that 80's. Is that August? I just like to add on a little bit. [1:58:55] When we're talking about the education piece maybe we can even reach out to some of our neighboring [1:59:00] cities. I have grandkids that don't live in Twin Falls proper and every time they come to our house [1:59:07] it's a struggle to get them to remember. We have a recycling bin, we have a garbage [1:59:11] and this goes here and that goes there and I mean that's just filer and refuel and kimberly [1:59:17] enhancing and maybe we can even look at the bigger picture and try to help find [1:59:21] ways to encourage some of our neighboring cities to look seriously at [1:59:26] recycling. I think you know Twin Falls has been a great leader on this for some [1:59:31] time and now it's maybe time to see if we can't get more of the valley to come [1:59:36] to the field with us on this one. [1:59:41] There's sort of some two cents from the from the six of us [1:59:47] Well, I will just say that it was deeply gratifying to me to sit here tonight and listen to the people that spoke [1:59:58] You're not supposed to have an opinion when you do this, but that would be mine [2:00:04] This this world needs our help now, I think the trick is [2:00:09] We will go to work on the numbers, we'll have to project given the best information we have, what that rate might be, and we would certainly need then to discuss what to do, come back to council. [2:00:24] Time frame, obviously we are getting involved in the budgeting process. [2:00:30] We'll need to be a part of that as well. [2:00:35] But I look forward to moving forward. I like the idea that we would have some collaboration [2:00:42] with high school with CSI and with residents that have spoken tonight. [2:00:51] Thanks for your research and per shot. [2:00:54] I think too it's important, you know, I think Bill tried to clarify some misconceptions maybe at the beginning. [2:01:01] Now, PSI and the city are partners in this. [2:01:06] This is not only about profitability. [2:01:09] I certainly saw some of that. [2:01:10] I think it's about fiscal responsibility that we all have to be able to cover those costs. [2:01:18] My personal opinion, and we heard a lot of it tonight. [2:01:21] It is the right thing to do. [2:01:22] We ought to be figuring out ways to do it. [2:01:25] I'm also from a believer in the invisible hand of economics and somebody's going to figure [2:01:33] out how to make money at this, whether it's China or Indonesia or United States is going [2:01:41] to, somebody's going to step up and figure out how to make this pencil. [2:01:45] So in the meantime, there's a cost to it to do the right thing if we can find that little [2:01:51] ground that's tolerable for when I say the city that's all of you in the audience and [2:01:56] everybody who's out there and those rates. [2:02:00] So Mr. Mayor, staff would like a little bit of guidance [2:02:04] on where that middle ground might be. [2:02:07] All of the options that were presented, [2:02:10] even up to the, you know, on the graph [2:02:14] or below the 5% threshold requiring a public hearing. [2:02:18] So what staff needs from the council to move forward [2:02:23] is a motion confirming the option. [2:02:27] with the middle dollar figure that you would like for us to incorporate into both a addendum [2:02:38] to the contract and addendum to the rate resolution that was passed in October so that we could [2:02:46] have those both be effective. The turnaround time for us would be next week. These are [2:02:51] both very, very simple processes for us and we could have this back on the agenda for [2:02:57] Council's consideration if we receive guidance this evening. [2:03:00] I'll put the motion to make option two, but I don't have anything else. [2:03:11] We need to discuss the dollar. [2:03:16] What the break point is, is that what you're asking me? [2:03:19] So, opting staff needs a direction on what the rate increase that we're proposing is? [2:03:24] Yes. [2:03:25] So, option two, as presented by Bill, has that break even point at $80? [2:03:34] If you want to maintain that $80 as option to us present it, that's enough information. [2:03:41] If you'd like to adjust that one side or the other, we would need to know that in preparation of the documents. [2:03:47] Why don't we go with the $80 and then be flexible not to adjust it sometime later? [2:03:56] We see it going against it. [2:03:58] I agree with that. [2:04:01] Can you throw up the Twin Falls City Recycling Program, that one, the recycling fees, and the only reason is the last four months wouldn't fall in there. [2:04:16] If we're concerned about rates going up, well, either if they even maintain at 106, then everything's going to the dump. [2:04:25] That's why I think that if we're going to do it, it needs to be either 100 or 110. [2:04:29] and realizing that's more than what we've discussed, [2:04:33] but if we do it at 80, I don't think in the short term, [2:04:37] we're gonna see a fluctuation like that in the market. [2:04:40] Actually, what was the February rate? [2:04:45] 136, though it's, and September was the shy of 80. [2:04:53] I too, I think if we don't set a high enough bar here [2:04:58] for the cost share, basically select option one. [2:05:05] which is go down to everything. [2:05:07] But isn't a lot of this driven by the seasonal [2:05:10] variability to the chart? [2:05:12] Or is this 100% China? [2:05:13] Market. [2:05:15] It's 100% the market right now. [2:05:17] It's nothing to do with the 100%. [2:05:19] I'm comfortable with the 100%. [2:05:25] So I would entertain a motion with a price. [2:05:31] I move that we go for option two [2:05:33] and set the breaking point at 100%. [2:05:36] Second. [2:05:39] Motion-based exam, how can second about root of pierce [2:05:43] to go with a cost share of the expense of recycling with a $100 per ton breakpoint that [2:05:55] if it exceeds that it would go to the landfill if it is at that or below that we would cost [2:06:02] share between city and PSI discussion, Greg. [2:06:07] Yes, I have a little bit, but make sure that we're keeping PSI hold here as well. [2:06:16] Because that means an additional ten doors and then potentially although there is a distinction on that or not. [2:06:30] I thought the cost sharing was keeping PSI hold. [2:06:36] Jeff is here, I'll let him respond to that. [2:06:39] Yes, obviously as for post-cost sharing keep it does keep us whole [2:06:43] It is what we planned on and keeps this program going. That is very much [2:06:47] So so PSI seems comfortable with that amount. Is that enough? [2:06:58] Yeah, honestly, are we just [2:07:00] Wishing this on and we're gonna be back in two months. If it's that 130 [2:07:05] What was it for February? [2:07:07] 136 if it's market driven that's not gonna cover it [2:07:13] So to have a question, if there were a lines up from the council to approve that larger rate increase in the larger cost share, if it collected more revenue than was needed with that just going to reserves in the sanitation fund. [2:07:38] So for example, if we were to go to the 150, I guess the first question would be, is that an amount of PSI is willing to cost share? [2:07:47] The second is if it never hit that point with those funds just going to reserves and then [2:07:56] with the new budget year, could we look at a re-evaluation of the... [2:08:03] If we're doing that, we're actually taking option three then, right? [2:08:10] Just about? [2:08:11] I look at it as there's still some flexibility where if the market just dictates and it's [2:08:19] Ridiculously high we're not asking people to pay more than what they truly truly can't afford [2:08:25] Well, and I don't know if everybody's budget, but we're not gonna come back and say it's 30 40 50 dollars more a year [2:08:32] We're setting that limit there, but saying hey, there's [2:08:38] 70 [2:08:39] Nine dollars more a year, but everything's still going to the dump at that point in time because the market's not dictating that [2:08:44] It's gonna be below that that break even points too low [2:08:47] So that's my concern, is we're going through these motions to ultimately say everything [2:08:54] still goes, because we haven't set that limit high enough. [2:08:59] 150 seems high to me. [2:09:01] And I only threw that out because that was dollars just number of dollars. [2:09:06] I also didn't see a great enthusiasm from Jeff's eyes when I mentioned that number. [2:09:15] further discussion on this motion. [2:09:24] That's option two and a hundred. [2:09:33] Who made the second? [2:09:35] Excellent question. [2:09:36] I did. [2:09:37] Yes. [2:09:46] Sean Bericher? [2:09:48] Yes. [2:09:49] Zann Hawkins? [2:09:50] Yes. [2:09:52] Reg Lanting? [2:09:53] Yes. [2:09:54] Ruth Pierce? [2:09:55] Yes. [2:09:57] Christopher Reed? [2:09:58] Yes. [2:09:59] Chris Hockington? [2:10:00] Yes. [2:10:02] The motion passes six to zero. [2:10:05] So a couple of things that I would like to see. [2:10:09] One, I think we should report back to the Council [2:10:14] on a monthly basis what's happening with this [2:10:16] to continue to keep it top of mind. [2:10:20] And two, I think we need to have some discussion [2:10:25] about improving community education [2:10:29] and I'll call it compliance for a lot of a better word, [2:10:32] but the opportunity to do a good job [2:10:34] of keeping our recycling stream recyclable exactly what that looks like but I think we [2:10:43] had a couple of offers tonight from community organizations who would like to be a part of [2:10:46] that. I certainly would be willing to be a part of that but I think we need to have a [2:10:51] concerted effort with that. Now is the time to build up to capitalize on the fact that [2:10:57] this has been in news now for a couple of weeks. If we do that, the most way of the City of [2:11:02] Sorry, Mike, are the city water bill ever has a billboard? [2:11:06] Plus bill is need, need recycling oversight guy upstairs. [2:11:15] We're going to try to be. [2:11:19] Um, if with council's permission, Jeff would be willing to address the glass recycling. [2:11:25] That'd be great. Thank you, Jeff. [2:11:27] Along lines of obviously contamination and recycling. [2:11:29] The reason we can't accept class in our current [2:11:32] commingle program is when glass gets into that material and breaks, [2:11:36] it contaminates all the cardboard and paper products that are in that container. [2:11:41] That's why you do have to keep that glass separate, [2:11:44] as was mentioned by another gentleman. [2:11:46] They do accept it at Target, so there are options for recycled glass, [2:11:49] but it cannot be in the commingle program. [2:11:52] If we used to accept glass, I know it was in a separate container [2:11:58] Back in the day when we had the little bins and we delivered them ourselves [2:12:02] Is there an option to do that? [2:12:05] I understood that there was no market for it, where we were. [2:12:09] Yeah, where we're at is very difficult, there is no market nearby [2:12:13] and that's really what it comes down to as the cost of shipping this material is extremely high. [2:12:18] Denver is about the closest bottle recyclers to Twin Falls, so that's pretty much where we go to Coors [2:12:24] and leave that in Isaac Bushes, they're also, it does a lot of other segments, but obviously [2:12:31] Target has a back haul with their trucks, so they just take it back with the money, their [2:12:36] products, they shouldn't back out, so that's why they do it feasibly. [2:12:40] And then there was a comment earlier regarding homeowners versus renters, I think the best [2:12:44] way to look at that is it's the customer, is it's the one? [2:12:48] It is the account holder and at the present time, tenants in properties are allowed to [2:12:55] put the account in their name with a copy of the lease and a deposit, whoever's licensed [2:13:01] in that information so that we can track them like all our customers. [2:13:06] So a renter of a home in town may be an account holder, whereas apartments however, you don't [2:13:13] pick up apartments, right? [2:13:14] They would be a commercial account, not a residential account. [2:13:19] Okay, any other questions on that? [2:13:23] There's a lot of staff on what we need to do in that. [2:13:27] Okay, great, thank you. [2:13:30] And, right piece of paper that I haven't written on the back of here yet. [2:13:34] So next is another opportunity for general public input. [2:13:37] If there's anybody who would like to address the council [2:13:40] on any other issues, now there's a chance to come forward. [2:13:44] Being none, any advisory board reports from council members, [2:13:52] announcements from staff. [2:13:56] Alright, and without the meeting is adjourned.