Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-02-20, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-02-20/ [0:00:30] What's streaming now? [0:00:38] Good evening. I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Tuesday, February 20th and confirm that we do have a quorum of the Council. [0:00:51] All seven members are here this evening. [0:00:53] Excuse me. [0:00:56] Next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:00:58] And we have some scouts here this evening, actually our first scouts in our new council chambers to help lead us in the pledge. [0:01:05] So gentlemen, if you wouldn't mind coming down to the front there and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance [0:01:53] Thank you gentlemen and before you get too far [0:01:55] Can you step up here to this microphone and on this podium over here right over here and you can talk right in that microphone right there [0:02:04] Right in front of you [0:02:05] If you could tell us your name and which troop you're with and what you're working on this evening [0:02:12] I'm Isaac. You know what's true. You're with [0:02:23] Okay, or then I guess then because you're we below is right? Okay [0:02:26] And we're working on building a better world. [0:02:33] Excellent. [0:02:35] Thank you. [0:02:36] And if you would mind introducing yourself to us, please? [0:02:39] My name is Benjamin and I'm a Weeblow and Pac is 81 and I'm a Weeblow. [0:02:47] Excellent. [0:02:48] Hey, did you have other stuff you wanted to share with us here? [0:02:56] You're good. [0:02:57] Alright. [0:02:58] Thank you so much. [0:03:00] Mr. Rothwell, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? [0:03:09] Mr. Member, as the Council, there has been a request to change the order on the public [0:03:17] hearing schedule to move item B to the top of the public hearing schedule. [0:03:24] We've had a conversation with both parties and both are agreeable for that switch, so [0:03:29] we would just like that recognized on the agenda. [0:03:33] All right. [0:03:34] We don't actually need to amend the agenda to do that, do we? [0:03:37] Nope. And both will be after 6 p.m. Anyway, so thank you Travis for pointing that out. [0:03:42] Thanks to the applicants for being willing to swap places there. [0:03:46] Next on the agenda is Proclamation's, which we have none, so an opportunity for general public input. [0:03:57] If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council, now is your opportunity to please come forward. [0:04:07] Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar. [0:04:12] Council wishes, Chris Stockington. [0:04:14] No do approve the consent calendar is printed. [0:04:17] Second. [0:04:18] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar as [0:04:25] published. [0:04:26] Is there any discussion? [0:04:27] Seeing none, Chair and roll call vote please. [0:04:32] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:04:35] Yes. [0:04:36] Nicky Boyd. [0:04:37] Yes. [0:04:39] John Berger. [0:04:40] Yes. [0:04:41] Chris Stockington. [0:04:42] Mr. Stockington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Mr. Fareed. Yes. Sweet Beers. Yes. [0:04:49] Motion passes 7-0. Under items of consideration, the first is a request to [0:04:54] appoint Mary Shaw to the Twin Falls Housing Authority as a commissioner to [0:04:59] serve a five-year term. We have Leanne Trappen with the Twin Falls Housing [0:05:03] Authority. Leanne, welcome to the right spot on my agenda here. Hold on. Thank you so much for [0:05:17] and I appreciate the opportunity to request support to appoint Mary Shaw to our Board of [0:05:25] Commissioners for a five-year term. [0:05:28] She has a lot of experience and has served this community in many capacities, either [0:05:34] on boards, leading boards, and as a realtor. [0:05:37] So we feel like she has a lot to contribute and I'm excited she has agreed to this point. [0:05:45] Thank you, Leanne. Mary is here in case anyone would like to grill her on constitutional law or any other items [0:05:53] So I certainly concur with the work that the housing authority has done and in finding an appropriate candidate [0:06:00] And I would certainly be willing to appoint Mary to fill this spot with the [0:06:07] Council's concurrence Greg Lantik [0:06:09] Uh, Mayor, I move that we appoint Mary Shaw to the Tom Paul's Housing Authority for a five-year term. [0:06:15] And I don't have the exact date when it begins, so whatever it begins. [0:06:19] Exactly. [0:06:20] Motion by Great Lanting, seconded by Christopher Reed to approve the appointment at Mary Shaw to the Tom Paul's Housing Authority as presented as their any further discussion. [0:06:34] Mayor and roll call vote please. [0:06:37] Nicky Boyd. [0:06:43] Sean Baraker. [0:06:46] Yes. [0:06:47] Chris Talkington. [0:06:48] Rockington, Greg Lanting, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pears, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:06:55] Motion passes, 7-0. Congratulations, Marion. Thank you, Leanne. [0:07:00] The next is a request to adopt a resolution authorizing the mayor and city clerk to execute a cooperative agreement with the IDO Transportation Department for Americans with Disabilities Act CURB-RAMP program, key number 20369. [0:07:17] I have Aaron Steele, engineer on the agenda. [0:07:20] Welcome. [0:07:21] Good evening. [0:07:22] Thanks for having me. [0:07:23] Time to come with a request to adopt a resolution authorizing the mayor and city clerk to execute [0:07:29] a corporate agreement with the Idaho Transportation Department. [0:07:33] This week, last year, around April, applied for a grant from ITD for $60,000 to help on [0:07:42] State Route Fund State Highway System to update ADA ramps on parts of the system. [0:07:51] This is the max amounts of the grant is good for us. [0:07:54] We achieved the maximum amount. [0:07:57] We need your approval for this. [0:08:00] There are 11 total ramps. [0:08:03] I have a couple of maps to show you just so everybody is on the same page. [0:08:20] You can see the old part of town. [0:08:21] We've got ramps in these various locations. [0:08:23] Two of them on most of the corners for a total of 11 ramps all the way arounds, we have a couple of pictures to show you. [0:08:30] So I TD went through [0:08:32] 2010 and 2011 and created a massive inventory of every ramp on the steaks. [0:08:38] And so a couple of, they go through and they put these ramps and they categorize them as bad, good or okay. [0:08:47] So these are considered bad, and so when you apply for the grant, if they're on the bad [0:08:53] list, you get more points. [0:08:54] If they're on the okay list, you don't get as many points. [0:08:57] So we have quite a few on the state route that are bad, and this is one example of a bad [0:09:04] system. [0:09:05] Either one of these two corners have a ramp that's a third patch that they didn't herb [0:09:10] to say they're all at least right out into the street. [0:09:13] This grant allows us to go and fix these not using city funds, but using state funds. [0:09:19] One more shot for it here. [0:09:21] This is on the corner of Blake and Addison. [0:09:25] As you can see on this one, the sidewalk just ends. [0:09:31] This grant helps make these work, helps get the state route back up to code without using our funds. [0:09:39] So in order to delineate what responsibilities are for the city and for the state, the state requires this cooperative agreement to be signed. [0:09:49] And so this is the request authorized to the mayor and Sharon, the city clerk to sign and execute the agreement. [0:09:58] So that would be the staff recommendation sign. [0:10:00] Thank you, Aaron. Suzanne Hawkins. [0:10:03] Excuse me, on the corner of Blake and Addison, where there's no sidewalk on Blake, are we just putting in one ramp there, are we building something else or how does that work? [0:10:15] So, this ramp will only be a singular directional ramp, crossing Blake, moving across, walk across Addison, only across Blake. [0:10:25] Thank you. [0:10:27] I was wondering the interface with state highways or streets clearly, but is there any measure [0:10:38] of the actual volume of traffic on a daily basis or is there any point given for accidents [0:10:44] related to this? [0:10:47] For pedestrian, we don't have any database that shows accidents on this system. [0:10:52] We could come up with some accident data, but it might take a little bit to try to draw [0:10:56] from that I don't have any numbers off the top of my head for you tonight. [0:10:59] Follow up about how many more intersections to state highways do we have that need these [0:11:06] ADA ramps? [0:11:08] You'll have, yes, quite a few. [0:11:12] So, originally in 2010 and 2011, I did my internship and part of my internship was going [0:11:18] around on the state routes and inventory and every single one of these ramps and I didn't [0:11:22] I didn't do all of them, but I did a fair amount of these, and so I've seen a good, bad in the ugly, and some of these are the ugly, so thank you, boy. [0:11:37] For this, so they pay 75% up front, and then they inspect what we've done, and they're 25%. [0:11:54] So, that extra 25% of the people work just way to get paid from the state, we don't have to front money. [0:12:01] No. [0:12:02] Okay. [0:12:02] So, they'll get it through us, but we'll pay them after we get the funds. [0:12:06] Any further questions or comments for Aaron? [0:12:13] So, to clarify, is this just a motion to authorize the mayor and clerk to execute the agreement and not a resolution? [0:12:20] There's a resolution. [0:12:22] There is a resolution. [0:12:23] Yes. [0:12:24] I'm sorry, I didn't come across it. What's the resolution? [0:12:26] I'm 2018-2 [0:12:29] And so [0:12:36] Chris Stockton [0:12:40] moved to adopt resolution [0:12:42] 2018-2 authorizing the mayor of the city clerk to execute the [0:12:47] Welcome to agreement with I.T.D. for the 88 curb ramp program [0:12:54] second motion by Chris talking to second about Ruth Pierce to [0:13:00] adopt [0:13:01] resolution [0:13:02] 2018-2 [0:13:03] Is there any further discussion? [0:13:05] Aaron, we'll call the vote, please. [0:13:09] Sean Bericher? Yes. [0:13:15] Chris Hockington? Yes. [0:13:17] Reg Lanting? Yes. [0:13:19] Christopher Reed? Yes. [0:13:21] Ruth Pierce? Yes. [0:13:23] Zann Hawkins? Yes. [0:13:25] Nicky Boy? Yes. [0:13:27] Motion passes. Seven to zero. [0:13:30] Thank you, Aaron. [0:13:31] Don't have those installed as well. [0:13:33] I'm right on those, sir. [0:13:36] Next on the agenda is a request from Lincoln and Heather Tubbs to enter into an agreement [0:13:45] regarding fencing along a portion of the Canyon Rim Trail adjacent to their home, and I have [0:13:51] David W. Gadd listed on the agenda. [0:13:58] Welcome sir. [0:13:59] Thank you Mayor and Council. [0:14:01] I appreciate you taking time to listen to our request. [0:14:05] stated I represent the Tubbs family with respect to a request for what is [0:14:12] essentially reimbursement for the cost to install a fence along a portion of [0:14:17] their property that abuts the canyon rim trail that was recently installed. All of [0:14:22] you I believe were provided with a copy of the proposed agreement and speaking [0:14:27] with Mitch Humble he recommended that we submit our request by way of a proposed [0:14:32] contract or agreement that would delineate liability, ownership of the fence, etc. [0:14:39] That is what we have done and attached to that as Exhibit A is a map that shows the property [0:14:47] and the trail location both as it was originally planned and then as it currently exists. [0:14:54] Which is it possible to get that up there? Excellent. [0:14:57] As you can see, the blue outline represents the property line for the TubSYS property. [0:15:09] The yellow line is the original trail location, and then the red line is the actual location of the trail as it was installed. [0:15:18] As the council may recall, I came before the council last summer with respect to the proposed purchase of parcel 2 by the TubSYS. [0:15:28] Their purchase in, excuse me, their purpose in purchasing that parcel was at least two-fold. [0:15:36] One is it allowed them to increase the size of their property that they were able to use [0:15:42] and also push out the fence, excuse me, the trail from coming up very close to their residence [0:15:50] as it was originally planned. [0:15:52] The second, as I explained to the council last summer, was it would, by purchasing that property, [0:16:00] it would improve the quality of the trail and reduce the cost of the construction of the trail. [0:16:05] It was our intention and our hope in doing so that the council would consider this request [0:16:12] for reimbursement for the expense to put up a privacy fence along the portion of their [0:16:20] property that abuts the trail. As outlined in the proposed agreement, it's our [0:16:29] understanding that the purchase of parcel 2 by the TubSAs saved the county [0:16:34] approximately $30,000 and the proposed offense that they wish to install and for [0:16:41] which they're seeking reimbursement totals approximately $25,000 so less than [0:16:45] the amount that was saved the council. In reading the staff response, it's my [0:16:49] understanding that there are essentially two arguments in support of the staff's recommendation [0:16:56] that does not be approved. One is that there have been a number of requests from other [0:17:02] property owners. They're similar situated and essentially the council would be stepping [0:17:08] on to a slippery slope if it was to approve this particular request. They're by inviting [0:17:15] these similarly situated property owners to make similar [0:17:20] similar requests to the council. [0:17:23] In response to that, I would say that this is a bit [0:17:27] of a unique situation, in that the Tubzas [0:17:29] actually purchased parcel two with the intent [0:17:33] of saving the council, the city, excuse me, money [0:17:37] for which the city could then use to reimburse it [0:17:39] for all or part of the costs for the construction of the fence. [0:17:43] To my knowledge, that is a unique situation that does not apply to any other property owners. [0:17:54] This is the only instance of which I am aware in which a property owner has expended its [0:17:58] own money, at least in part for the purpose of saving the city money that can then be [0:18:03] used to help pay for this fence. [0:18:05] The second reason is that there was an overrun on costs and that any savings that the city [0:18:12] realized by the purchase of property to have since been spent elsewhere on these overruns. [0:18:19] I recognize that there are frequently overruns with projects such as these, however, I would [0:18:26] point out to the council in response to this particular consideration that we're not for [0:18:30] the types of purchase of parcel two. [0:18:33] Those overruns would be $30,000 give or take more than what they currently are. [0:18:39] And in recognition of the contribution that the Tubsters have made to saving the city [0:18:48] money, we would request that all or a portion of those costs is outlined in Exhibit B. Those [0:18:55] are the various estimates that have been provided for purposes of constructing this fence, [0:19:04] that those be approved and that the agreement be signed either as proposed or in some modified [0:19:12] form as the council would agree to. [0:19:16] If you look at the attachments included in Exhibit B, those estimates, it's approximately [0:19:22] $16,000 for the fence itself, approximately $5,000 in order to build up the earth next [0:19:28] the fence is my understanding that in constructing the path that is now several feet higher than [0:19:36] the ground around it. As a result if you were to construct a six or seven foot fence on one side it [0:19:42] would only be a four foot fence, three foot fence on the other. And so in order to have a six foot [0:19:49] fence on both sides there's some earth work that needs to be done that totals approximately five [0:19:53] $5,000 and then the finished work is approximately $4,500, that would be the [0:20:00] staining. Afterward of course is provided in the agreement the fence would be owned [0:20:05] by the tubs as it would be their responsibility to maintain and upkeep it, [0:20:09] but as as explained the tubs are requesting the city council a for all or a portion [0:20:20] of the cost to construct that fence, given the proximity of the trail to their residents. [0:20:27] Are there any questions? [0:20:31] Are there any questions at this point from Mr. Gadd? [0:20:34] No question, great. [0:20:44] Great. [0:20:45] Thank you. [0:20:46] Great, thank you. [0:20:47] Sir, what was the cost of parcel 2? [0:20:49] Is it the subsidy? [0:20:50] Do we have that information or do we really share that information? [0:20:55] 40,000. [0:20:56] Okay. [0:21:02] Mitch, did you want to say the thing that's part of the staff report? [0:21:16] a whole lot to add because I think Dave was pretty thorough in his presentation. [0:21:21] The one thing I would add was that there was at least two other parcels that were property owners [0:21:26] that did exactly the same thing that we're talking about here, where we had some people purchase property [0:21:31] and we'd re-align the trail. [0:21:33] So they're not completely unique. [0:21:35] There's at least two others that have that same argument. [0:21:40] The other thing I would say is that the cost savings is an estimation at this point. [0:21:45] this point so we didn't ever go to bid for the trail before the property swaps [0:21:53] happened and so I don't know what it would have cost before so this [0:21:57] estimation is coming based on the linear feet of trail that we built for the cost [0:22:02] that we paid and so with the with the savings it's estimated about a $30,000 [0:22:09] savings for this but again it's an estimate at this point I don't know if [0:22:12] it's exactly that or not. So with that, I would just kind of even to the council [0:22:19] I would provide all the information in the staff report so any questions I'm [0:22:23] happy to answer for you. Which questions for Mitch? You need? So council [0:22:40] wishes discussion to like mine. Chris talking to? [0:22:52] Better thing to do than just to on behalf of the applicant put the matter up for us to [0:22:57] discussed with the motion so I would so authorize reimbursement for Lincoln and [0:23:06] Heather Tubbs the agreement regarding the reimbursement for fencing along the [0:23:11] portion of the Ken room. Trail has described in the amount up to $25,343. [0:23:18] Motion by Chris Togginton, seconded by Greg Lanting, [0:23:27] that the agreement does present it for the reimbursement of the offense request. [0:23:36] We'll have some discussion now, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:23:40] I don't have much of a voice, so I'm going to try to keep it short. [0:23:44] I am not in favor of this motion for a multiple reasons. [0:23:48] First of all, being the fact that it would be setting a precedent with others. [0:23:52] And secondly, when the home was purchased, they did know that sometime in the future [0:23:57] there would be a trail going through there. [0:23:59] And, you know, I think it's just part of the property. [0:24:05] They do have the value of the property they bought. [0:24:07] So if they ever do resale, they will get that back at that time. [0:24:11] And I just don't think that this is the right move for us to make as a council. [0:24:15] So I will be voting against the motion. [0:24:17] Thank you, Susan. [0:24:22] Chris, this is one of those most difficult decisions to make. [0:24:28] I think there's some merit to their request at the same time as described by the city staff. [0:24:36] I have a hard time supporting it. [0:24:40] I would hope that the well thought out purchase of this parcel too that you can improve it, [0:24:48] but in some urban VDIS, some edges that can act as a screening and will actually become [0:24:54] improvement to your property increase it and provide yourself privacy that as it [0:25:01] stands right now it's really difficult for me to look like it would be setting up [0:25:07] for president that's going to mean more applicants requesting for similar [0:25:14] situations. Greg Lanting. Well I second the motion so we can have the [0:25:21] schedule I too will be voting against. President is the weak concern. I think [0:25:29] to other areas, some of before I was on council and one of them just like within [0:25:34] the last month where we're either expanding a street or push a street [0:25:40] through the one to come to mind me would be Madrona Street east of Twin [0:25:44] Falls High School. That street didn't used to go through those people's backyard [0:25:48] was involved high school and a big lawn, and we pushed Madrona Street through when [0:25:54] sawtooth came about to make the flow of traffic better through that area and I [0:25:59] don't think we built a fence of there, I'm all certain we didn't. The one we just [0:26:04] are currently doing right now is this folks who live out there good as they [0:26:09] drive home where we've went into the lawns of two houses that face bitter root on [0:26:15] on Eastland, because we had the right away, we owned the right way, one house obviously [0:26:21] knew we had the right way, one house obviously didn't, and we've gotten much closer to those [0:26:27] houses than we were before, and I don't see, there's no plans to build fences there either. [0:26:34] I mean, so it's one of those situations where, from the conversation, I'm not sorry tonight [0:26:42] but the newspaper that they apparently didn't know the trail was going through, it just went [0:26:46] through quicker than I thought. But I can't see bending and false citizens money or to [0:26:56] basically build a fence in the county. That's what we would be doing. Is that [0:27:00] private or property is in the county? It's not even in the city of Twin Falls. [0:27:04] So I will be voting no. [0:27:05] Thank you, Boyd. [0:27:08] I will also be voting no and I'm not as worried about sitting president as I am [0:27:14] Just the facts of property are it's located. [0:27:20] There was always going to be a trail. [0:27:22] I admire that. [0:27:24] That live out there, we're gracious. [0:27:26] It worked with us. [0:27:28] I think everybody did their very best to come up with something [0:27:32] as good as we could, but really the fence [0:27:37] for private properties. [0:27:40] OK, for their discussion. [0:27:46] Time with this one. [0:27:56] And this is a very difficult situation. [0:27:58] I know for the Tubbs family, they've come and spoke to us a lot of years ago in understanding [0:28:06] this is a large expense to you and your family. [0:28:10] Having an issue ultimately where does the tax payer money pay for privacy, whereas on one [0:28:19] side, yes, that was a safety concern, keeping cattle off the trail as opposed to not wanting [0:28:26] people to see you back yards to your home. [0:28:29] And that's why ultimately, as I was looking this over and thinking about it, I'm going [0:28:33] to be voting no-all. [0:28:34] So realizing that it is going to be a strain on your family, but it's taxpayer money that [0:28:38] would be paying for that benefit one, so. [0:28:41] Any further discussion? [0:28:47] One more. [0:28:48] Yes. [0:28:49] So, E7. [0:28:50] I'm going to be voting no-one's for my biggest concern is the fact that it is a county property [0:28:57] and a city of a president, and it is taxpayer money. [0:29:01] So I will be voting no. [0:29:07] I don't think I have anything specific to add beyond what's been shared from the rest of the council. [0:29:12] Again, I appreciate the work that property owners, private contributors, public dollars, were able to come up with a project that really we as a community can be proud of. [0:29:27] of. I do appreciate the opportunity for those property owners to purchase some [0:29:36] buffer zones around their own properties that help to straighten the trail and [0:29:40] help make it just a better amenity. But I think utilizing public dollars to build [0:29:49] privacy fences, not something that I can be supportive of. So with that, Sharon I [0:29:57] I would call for a roll call, please. [0:30:04] Chris Talkington? [0:30:05] No. [0:30:07] Greg Lanting? [0:30:08] No. [0:30:09] Christopher Reed? [0:30:10] No. [0:30:11] Ruth Pierce? [0:30:11] No. [0:30:12] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:30:14] No. [0:30:15] Nikki Boyd? [0:30:16] No. [0:30:17] Don Barricor? [0:30:18] No. [0:30:19] That motion fails on a 0 to 7 vote. [0:30:29] Next on the agenda is a request to approve a change order [0:30:34] for the 2017-07 Eastland Drive North and Pull Line Road Project, John Keaton, our Public Works Director. [0:30:42] Welcome, John. [0:30:43] Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:30:46] First of all, I'd probably need to revise the wording of the request to request authorization to approve a change order or the Eastland project in the amount not to exceed 200,000, if I may. [0:31:02] And to give you a little background on the change order as you as councils well where we've begun the [0:31:09] Rehabilitation of East Link from Mountain View on Pull Line all the way around to just about to falls [0:31:17] As a part of this project we [0:31:20] staff intended to [0:31:24] form most of the utility work [0:31:27] that [0:31:28] that needed to be upgraded [0:31:30] including pressurization crossings on Eastland, the intent was to cross Eastland [0:31:36] with the irrigation pipe and leave it to construct another day. As part of the [0:31:43] review process, we realized that we had a right-of-way issue on the East side of [0:31:48] Eastland in the vicinity of Bolin. They don't have all the right-of-way, plus [0:31:52] there are other utility conflicts. So the change order contemplates the [0:31:58] construction of pressurize irrigation pipe from chaney to julie lane, it's 12 inch irrigation [0:32:06] pipe and it'll directly contribute to a pressurize irrigation service delivery issues we're having [0:32:14] in the easter edge professional subdivision that's in the vicinity of julie lane on the east side [0:32:20] of Eastland. So this would directly contribute to improved delivery for that project or for [0:32:28] that pressure zone. So right now the water fund would fund this change order if it was [0:32:35] approved tonight. And normally I would bring forward the change order and ask this specific [0:32:40] change order to be approved. Part of the reason where I don't have a change order here is we're [0:32:45] still in negotiations. We have an estimate. The estimate is below 200,000 and we're working [0:32:52] to negotiate that. Normally I would wait until I have the actual change order, but the schedule [0:32:59] is critical path. This project as you know is currently partially funded by SAVE funds [0:33:07] with all work must be complete by August 18th. So in order to keep schedule going, [0:33:14] I wanted to request counsel give us authorization to approve this change order in the amount [0:33:23] not to exceed 200,000. [0:33:25] Thank you, John. [0:33:29] Are there any questions or comments for John? [0:33:36] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:33:37] Said the Water Fund would be where we're taking the water out of the—where are we [0:33:46] getting that? [0:33:47] Is it something we have in savings? [0:33:50] Are you canceling another project? [0:33:52] Where is the money coming from? [0:33:54] enough money in our existing budget, you know, each year the hope and intent is to [0:34:01] construct and realize the entire budget, but each year there are some savings. [0:34:08] This year we have some savings in our inventory and also there would be some [0:34:14] reserves available to fund this. [0:34:17] Nicky Boyd. [0:34:21] Mother discussion, authorization. [0:34:23] I mean if I have this wording right, we're granting the authorization and improving a change order [0:34:38] up to $100,000 for the 2017-07 Eastland Drive North in the Blue Line Road Project. [0:34:47] That's good. [0:34:50] Motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Greg Lanting, to give authorization to approve a change order [0:34:57] up to $200,000 for the Eastland Drive North End Pulling Road project. [0:35:06] Further discussion? [0:35:07] Hearing roll call vote, please. [0:35:11] Reg Lanting. [0:35:14] Yes. [0:35:15] Christopher Reed. [0:35:16] Yes. [0:35:17] Ruth Pears. [0:35:18] Yes. [0:35:19] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:35:20] Yes. [0:35:21] Nikki Boyd. [0:35:22] Yes. [0:35:23] John Berger. [0:35:24] Yes. [0:35:25] Chris Hawkins. [0:35:26] Yes. [0:35:27] From passes 7-0. [0:35:28] Thank you. [0:35:29] Thank you, John. [0:35:30] Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input. If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item, not on the agenda. [0:35:42] Now is another chance to come forward. Seeing no one, do we have any advisory board reports from the council? [0:35:55] Next right item on here. Scream them out if you have one. [0:36:04] Nothing from the council. [0:36:10] Travis, anything from the city manager's office? [0:36:13] No, sir. [0:36:15] All right. [0:36:17] Well, with that, we do have two public hearings that are scheduled, but not to begin before [0:36:23] 6 PM, so we will stand in recess until 6 PM. [0:37:03] We will reconvene the council meeting for Tuesday, February 20th, now 6 o'clock. [0:37:08] We do have two public hearings scheduled this evening, but I guess we won't be flip-flopping [0:37:16] them if Mr. Sleddy is not here. [0:37:20] So we will go ahead and go with the order that we have them on the agenda. [0:37:24] So the first is a request for annexation with a zoning district change and zoning map amendment [0:37:32] from R1 variable canyon rim overlay to R4 canyon rim overlay for parcel 2 DBS conveyance [0:37:41] This plaque consisting of 13.43 plus or minus acres located 130 feet east of the canyon [0:37:48] falls drive and Harris and street intersection. [0:37:51] We have Rob Struthers on behalf of Katie Breckenridge. [0:37:57] We have Katie Breckenridge as the applicant to present. [0:38:02] Welcome. [0:38:06] It was late. [0:38:19] You know, let's just go ahead and keep going forward with this one since we're already [0:38:23] into it. [0:38:24] Okay. [0:38:25] Thank you. [0:38:26] Katie. [0:38:27] I'm Katie Rickenridge and on behalf of myself and Rob Struthers, we're asking that you annex and rezone the last piece of the Rickenridge farm. [0:38:47] The reason we're asking for this annexation and rezone is because we have found only this property for over a hundred years that things come and go. [0:38:59] And what if we really have noticed in the last 15 years that with change in zoning, [0:39:07] or pardon me, in staffing and in elected officials that many times meeting the true [0:39:14] meaning behind things get lost and we can't keep bringing them forward. [0:39:20] When we did the rezone and annexation of my sister's property, both planning and zoning, [0:39:29] of you, the citizens, neighbors, mentioned that this should be our land should be our [0:39:36] fore. And so in looking at that, we decided that we would step forward and annex and rezone [0:39:45] now, or everyone is in an agreement as to what's going on. Our land is not for sale. And we [0:39:54] wanted to make that very clear. We also wanted to point out to you that in the annexation [0:39:59] process of my sister's land. We did annex the bike path and that the bike path is connected [0:40:08] to this piece of property, but it has already been annexed. Did I make that clear enough? Okay, [0:40:18] so we could go into the history. You've heard the history so many times. I think you know the [0:40:26] the history. And so what we would like to do is to sit down, let the staff make their [0:40:35] report, and then you can ask me any questions that you want to ask me, and we would give [0:40:41] a rebuttal. And then you do your deal. So if it's alright with you, I don't see any need [0:40:51] to go into the history. Again, I'd like to sit down unless you have a question for me. [0:41:00] Are there any questions for Katie quite yet? Otherwise, we can go ahead and go to the staff report and then we'll come back to it as I said. [0:41:09] That sounds fine. Thank you, Katie. [0:41:14] Jonathan spend love with our staff report. Welcome, Jonathan. [0:41:19] I think Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. [0:41:21] Um, Katie usually does the history and the truncated version as it's been a farm for a long time. [0:41:28] Um, that's pretty much the history that I've got written in this staff report. [0:41:31] Um, what we have here is a zoning map amendment, um, as well as a annexation. [0:41:37] When we annex properties, um, in order to do that, um, they go through a public hearing process with the Planning and Zoning Commission. [0:41:43] that commission does not debate the annexation to annex or not to annex they [0:41:50] really only talk about what an appropriate zoning for that property is [0:41:54] the decision to annex it is left to the city council the comprehensive plan puts [0:42:01] this area as a mixed use on a micro level if we only take this property the [0:42:06] R4 that comes close to completing that comp plan if we go a little bit further [0:42:11] to a little macro level. The mixed use is a mix of types of uses, some [0:42:15] commercials, some residential macro level on a larger scale. The point was brought [0:42:23] up last time as Katie of Song of Azusa's property. It's this southern portion, it's [0:42:27] got R6 down here, and then R4 starts with the Kenyan River overlay. That's what [0:42:33] this hash mark is kind of a diagonal. There's a couple of diagonals up there, [0:42:36] but it's this area here and it kind of comes down this line. Anything in that [0:42:41] area, which is essentially a certain distance from the canyon rim. Anything in [0:42:46] that area has to get a ZDA to actually be developed. What we have, our camera, the [0:42:52] total acreage of this property, all of the sacriages in a conveyance plant and part [0:42:58] of it is in a canyon room overlay, so they have to finish the plant and get a ZDA [0:43:02] to actually build anything. So the actual change of anything on this property won't [0:43:06] occur until there's more public hearings for the types of uses that they would [0:43:11] declare at the time they're ready to develop so really what we're talking [0:43:14] about today is is it appropriate to annex and is the R4 zoning district [0:43:18] appropriate as well that's really the crux of the issue tonight the planning [0:43:24] and zoning Commission held the public hearing on January 23rd that Commission [0:43:29] forwarded a positive recommendation as R4 with the vote of 7-0 and I conclude [0:43:38] any questions for Jonathan. Jonathan I have a question so you discussed the [0:43:50] for development it would take a zoning development agreement. Is that an actual zoning? [0:43:57] Yes, it's kind of a sub-district what we call it, but it acts more like an overlay. [0:44:03] It's just like a separate agreement and that's a requirement of the [0:44:07] can you overlay. You have to have a ZDA if you're in that overlay area near the [0:44:13] for any residential or commercial property. [0:44:16] So it would not be necessary to change the zoning on this request to include ZVA? [0:44:27] No. [0:44:28] Because it would be a requirement. [0:44:29] Yeah, it's a requirement either way. [0:44:31] We don't have a plan. [0:44:32] There's no master development plan. [0:44:34] There's no declared uses. [0:44:35] So we can just put our four still required later. [0:44:38] Thank you. [0:44:39] Any questions for Jonathan? [0:44:43] Okay. [0:44:47] I don't see any. [0:44:48] So with that, we will open the public hearing to take public testimony on this request. [0:44:58] Is there anyone who wishes to speak to the council on this request? [0:45:07] Mr. Sladdy, welcome. [0:45:13] Thank you. [0:45:14] I didn't realize you were so punctual. [0:45:16] We are very prompt. [0:45:17] I guess, I just, uh, uh, period and night as a citizen or at least a property owner of [0:45:25] the City of Twin Falls to support the application that Katie has submitted. [0:45:30] I think it's consistent with everything that's gone on in that area. [0:45:36] Thanks. [0:45:37] Thank you, Mr. Slutty. [0:45:40] There went else who wishes to speak on this item. [0:45:46] I think no one will close the public testimony portion of the public hearing. [0:45:51] I'll turn it back to Katie if you have any additional comments you need to make. [0:45:56] Katie Brackenrich, I would like to make two comments. [0:46:08] The first is to recognize that in the staff report it talked about possibilities of the roads and the entrances and the roads on this piece of property. [0:46:19] And when we did the TBS subdivision, a pad of conveyance, those two entrances are 60 feet. [0:46:29] And the reason that we did 60 foot on either side is so there would be good in the future. [0:46:35] There would be good road access. I'd like to point that out. [0:46:39] And the second thing I'd like to point out is that we did connect the bike path. [0:46:45] And we did get an agreement with the city. [0:46:48] And you did agree to take the Eastland. [0:46:52] And so now, the pressure is on us to give again, [0:46:58] or do something again on the rim. [0:47:00] And we feel we gave Susan and I, and then Rob and I, [0:47:06] and we connected the bike path. [0:47:09] And for whatever reason, the city chose not to connect at that time. [0:47:15] So, I would like that in the minutes that we did connect the bike path and that we have [0:47:21] two really good entrances onto this property and that part of the agreement when we connected [0:47:28] the bike path is that IDT brought up to standard the entrance of Kang and Falls Drive on both [0:47:36] sides of us. [0:47:37] So, we have addressed the road issues. [0:47:40] Thank you. [0:47:41] And if you want to hear what my grandpa did in 1902 and we're going to forward now, thank you very much. Can I sit down now? [0:47:51] You may, thank you, Katie. [0:47:58] All right. [0:47:59] Council, wishes. [0:48:03] Great landing. [0:48:07] There I move that we approve the request of annexation with the zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R1 variable CRO to R4, CRO for personal number two, TBS, convenience, black, consistency. [0:48:20] against Black consistency of 13.43 plus or minor acre plus or minus acres located at 130 [0:48:27] feet east of Canyon Falls Drive and Harrison Street intersection and care of Rob's [0:48:33] brothers and Katharine records. Motion by Greg Lanting seconded by Nicky Boyd to [0:48:41] approve the request as presented. Is there further discussion or do you have [0:48:48] something well sorry. You know further discussion? Sharon Roll Call vote please. [0:48:59] Christopher Reed? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes. Don [0:49:10] Bericher? Yes. Miss Hockington? Yes. Rick Lanting? Yes. [0:49:15] I should pass it 7-0. One more very brief [0:49:23] from him after Katie. Mr. Sleddy's already upset that he was late and couldn't go first. [0:49:31] I just have a very personal thing to say. And that this is the end of a book. It's [0:49:46] by a volume three. Volume one was LL and Florence Records. Volume two was John and Mary and [0:49:58] And volume three is Katie Rickenridge with Ralph's Brothers at the End. [0:50:04] It is the end of the Rickenridge Farms. [0:50:08] It will be a new chapter, a new book for whatever happens to the land. [0:50:14] But I thank you for your kindness, I thank you for holding me together as I walk down here [0:50:20] time and time again with tears in my eye. [0:50:23] I didn't swear tonight, but I did have to cry. [0:50:29] And so it's the emotion, it's the tremendous love of the land. [0:50:34] I have pictures, but anyway, it is where I grew up, these were the lambing shits, where [0:50:44] I became who I am today. [0:50:47] And I thank you for your kindness and understanding. [0:50:51] And again, it's the end of a book. [0:50:54] I thank you. [0:50:56] Thank you. [0:50:57] Thank you, Katie. [0:50:58] Thank you, Rob. [0:50:59] Katie, I think our vote shows that we consider counsel considers as the highest and best [0:51:04] views. [0:51:05] So you may think we're doing you a favor, but it's a safe for itself. [0:51:15] Next on the agenda is a request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from [0:51:19] R4 to M2 for property consisting of 10 plus or minus acres located on the south side [0:51:26] the 400 block of Diamond Avenue West and we have Gary Sletty on behalf of Craig [0:51:32] Casperson. Welcome Mr. Sletty. Thank you again. I'm truly not used to punctuality like [0:51:43] that. I think I've been in court too much too long. My name is Gary Sletty. I [0:51:50] represent Craig Casperson. Craig owns the 10 acres that lies West Diamond Street [0:52:00] extended and steel street south. Craig's father owns the storage facility located [0:52:09] to the north of his property. The proposal before you tonight is a proposed [0:52:17] rezone from R4 to M2. The good news is that the rezone request is [0:52:27] is consistent with the Conference of Plan Land Use Map. [0:52:32] The even better news is that I come before you tonight [0:52:37] with a unanimous recommendation [0:52:40] from the Planning and Zoning Commission. [0:52:43] This could be a first. [0:52:45] So, if this rezone is approved, [0:52:49] Craig's Plan is to continue the storage use [0:52:53] in that area to the south. I'm in agreement with the staff report and happy to answer any questions. [0:53:05] Thank you, Mr. Sledder. Are there any questions for the applicant at this time? [0:53:14] I see none, so we will have the staff report. [0:53:17] Jonathan, spend left. I'm sorry, Chris, did you have a question? [0:53:24] Yeah, the button doesn't move very fast. Gary, I just have you contacted Jason property owners. [0:53:32] Certainly you have on file the affidavit of posting and the affidavit of mailing I think we've mailed notice to everyone within a thousand feet of this property. [0:53:50] It should be known that there was no one at the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting who appeared and I concluded that that was unanimous support. [0:54:02] Johnathan, send a love. [0:54:09] Thank you Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. [0:54:11] The history that we have is basically some aerial imagery that we've got. [0:54:14] This is being a farm, or used as agricultural lands. [0:54:17] It's at least 1950 as far back as we go. [0:54:20] Mr. Suddy definitely summarized what the commission's wishes were. [0:54:26] Again, the commission looks at when they're doing a zoning district change. [0:54:31] Looks for the appropriateness and whether it complies with the comprehensive plan. [0:54:34] The map that's on your screen shows that this whole area, by the way, is all on the future [0:54:40] line as an industrial, so M2 is the Zoning District they chose, which is very similar to [0:54:48] what's to the north, where the storage units are and some other types of businesses are [0:54:53] further to the north. [0:54:54] The Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed it, said it was inconformance with the Comprehensive [0:55:00] plan, and the extent to nature changing the zoning property to M2 would allow for development [0:55:07] that would be compatible with and not detract from the surrounding area. [0:55:11] The public hearing took place on January 23rd, and it was unanimous vote by vote of 7-0. [0:55:17] In conclusion, the Council may deny the request to prove the request as presented to prove [0:55:22] the request with a different zoning designation or request additional information be provided. [0:55:27] It concludes the report. [0:55:31] Thank you, Jonathan. Any questions for Jonathan? [0:55:35] I see none. [0:55:42] I open out the public input portion of the public hearing. [0:55:47] Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on this issue? [0:55:54] Seeing no one, we will close the public testimony portion of the public hearing. [0:55:58] Mr. Sleddy, did you have any rebuttal to the robust testimony? [0:56:05] All right. Thank you. [0:56:07] I'm going to go over to the council. [0:56:09] I'm going to talk about it. [0:56:14] I'm not ready to make a motion. [0:56:17] I don't see anybody else. [0:56:19] I would move to approve the zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to M2 [0:56:23] for property consisting of 10 plus or minus acres [0:56:27] located on the south side of the 400 block of diameter west [0:56:31] Second. [0:56:34] I should say by Chris talking to the second by Christopher Reed [0:56:36] to approve the request as presented. [0:56:40] Any discussion from the Council of Right Lanting? [0:56:44] Well, I don't mean, I'm tempted to vote no, this is Gary. I hate to see Gary get a look at him. [0:56:52] I was voting on both of us. I remember I'd be back way back when I was on play in the zoning in the 80s. [0:56:59] We could all be voting against Gary and be voting in a different way, so I appreciate the quality of this application and I will be voting in favor. [0:57:12] Is there any further discussion? [0:57:16] and then Sharon Roll, call the vote please. [0:57:21] Ruth Pierce? [0:57:22] Yes. [0:57:23] Susan Hawkins? [0:57:24] Yes. [0:57:25] Nikki Boyd? [0:57:26] Yes. [0:57:27] Don Bericher? [0:57:28] Yes. [0:57:28] Chris Tockeington? [0:57:29] Yes. [0:57:30] Greg Lanting? [0:57:31] Yes. [0:57:31] Christopher Reed? [0:57:32] Yes. [0:57:34] Those should pass us at 7 to 0. [0:57:36] I guarantee you'll want to get a copy of the minutes [0:57:38] of these meetings to have them framed. [0:57:40] Keep those in your office for future use. [0:57:43] Wait. [0:57:45] Thank you. [0:57:46] We may never be on time. [0:57:47] That's true. [0:57:50] concludes our agenda so the meeting is adjourned.