Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-12-18, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-12-18/ [0:02:59] Good evening, I would like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, December 18th, [0:03:05] and confirm we do have a quorum to council here. Five members are present this evening. [0:03:09] Council members read and pierce are both absent this evening. [0:03:13] Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:03:17] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:03:30] Any other business will ever see you in Justice for All? [0:03:38] Mr. Rothwell, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? [0:03:42] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we would, staff would request that you add an executive session [0:03:48] under adjournment when which there already is an executive session that appears. [0:03:54] This would be 74206 1B as in boy. [0:03:59] And that would be to consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints [0:04:06] or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member or individual agent [0:04:12] or school student. [0:04:15] Greg Lanting. [0:04:16] I would move that we had an additional executive session under Idaho Code 74-6-1B for the [0:04:24] items that Travis outlined. [0:04:27] Second. [0:04:28] Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to amend the agenda as presented. [0:04:33] Is there any discussion? [0:04:36] Sharon Roll, call vote please. [0:04:37] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:04:42] Yes. [0:04:43] Nicky Boyd? [0:04:44] Yes. [0:04:45] Sean Berger? [0:04:46] Yes. [0:04:47] Chris Hockington? [0:04:48] Yes. [0:04:49] Greg Lanting? [0:04:50] Yes. [0:04:51] Motion passes 5-0. [0:04:52] We have no proclamations this evening, so next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:04:59] If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council, may I ask your opportunity to come forward? [0:05:03] Mr. Brennan, you wish to. We'll just get you up there first. If you would please state your name for the record. [0:05:11] My name is John Brennan. I am not a resident of the city. I am resident from Falls County. I am an instruction and nursing program at the College of Southern Idaho. [0:05:20] And I'm here tonight to recognize all of you. Several years ago, we started a project at CSI, which was called the CSI Disability Project. [0:05:31] project, and it was to engage the people within the college itself, not that CSI is an uncivil [0:05:38] place, but it was to bring an awareness of civility and what that meant to be civil to [0:05:42] one another and to listen to the discussion. [0:05:47] In that process, we also held a night of civility, it was that fall in love with Twin Falls, get [0:05:56] engaged with the community. [0:05:58] Sean was kind enough to show up, we had some other leaders in the community, because this [0:06:02] This is a great place to live. I've lived in this area for 27 years and it's a matter [0:06:08] of everyone working together with the government, the local businesses, the community, to make [0:06:13] this place what it is and this is really a wonderful place. [0:06:18] During the process of the Civilian Project, we had several events that occurred in Twin [0:06:22] Falls that were very, very challenging and during that period of time because of the [0:06:30] events. The things that happened that were very, very stressful. I know that some people [0:06:37] were even threatened during that time. And I think it's important that, first of all, [0:06:42] we understand that that's the very small segment of what's happening in this world. But I came [0:06:49] here tonight, when we did the Civility Project CSI, people could go on to this civilitypledge.org [0:06:55] and they could take the civility pledge and put their name in. And then I went to open [0:06:59] a night's outfit, the night of civility, and I would present them with a pen, well I didn't [0:07:04] want to really show up with my night's outfit. I have a little professional tonight. But tonight, [0:07:10] because of the good work that you've done, and the goodness that you bring to our community, [0:07:16] if I may, I would like to approach each one of you and give you one of the pens of civility, [0:07:21] if I may. [0:07:22] Thank you John. [0:07:23] I won't go down in history. [0:07:33] Thank you. [0:07:35] Thank you. [0:07:36] I'm going to leave one here for the other two. [0:07:55] Perfect. [0:07:56] We'll make sure they get them. [0:07:58] Thank you for all the good work you've done here in the way that you've done yourself. [0:08:04] Thank you. [0:08:05] Thank you sir. [0:08:06] Thank you very much. [0:08:09] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening on an item that is [0:08:13] not on the agenda? [0:08:17] Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar. [0:08:20] Nicky Boyd. [0:08:21] I move that we accept the consent calendar as posted. [0:08:25] Is there a way I can vote on it without voting on the minutes since I was absent from the last meeting? [0:08:31] Sure, we can remove the minutes. [0:08:33] Thank you. [0:08:35] I'll second the motion of the smaller agenda or smaller consent calendar. [0:08:44] Motion by Nicky Boyd second by Greg Lanting to approve items [0:08:48] C and AC and the on the consent calendar [0:09:03] Any discussion on that Sharon all about please Nicky Boyd. Yes [0:09:11] Sean Berger yes, Chris talking to yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Suzanne Hopkins. Yes [0:09:18] Motion passes 5-0 and I would entertain a motion for item 6-B the minutes. [0:09:24] Great landing. [0:09:25] I move that we accept item B of the City Council minutes for December 11. [0:09:30] I'm talking about motion by Greg Lanting seconded by Chris Talkington to [0:09:34] approve these City Council minutes for December 11th. Is there any discussion? [0:09:39] Sharon will call vote please. [0:09:47] Sean Berricher. Yes. [0:09:49] Chris Talkington. Yes. [0:09:50] Greg Lanting. Yes. [0:09:52] Suzanne Hawkins of state Nicky Boyd yes [0:09:57] Motion passes 4 to 0 with one abstention [0:10:00] under items of consideration the first is a request to authorize the mayor to sign the program agreement [0:10:07] Form for the local strategic initiatives program 2018 application. We have our city engineer Jackie Fields. Welcome Jackie [0:10:17] This is a new program [0:10:19] that's being administered through LTCH and it is a way to reflect the state [0:10:23] legislature's willingness and desire to share some of the surplus [0:10:28] millimeter funds that are available. 40% are available for local communities [0:10:32] throughout the state. The maximum grant opportunity for any given entity is a [0:10:40] million dollars and there is one project to be awarded per district in general. [0:10:48] So every district will have an opportunity to have a project. [0:10:52] The challenge with utilizing surplus-limbinator funds [0:10:55] is that the schedule is really aggressive [0:10:58] and requires the project to already be [0:11:02] into design or quite tidy when running up the project. [0:11:06] Environmental considerations, right-of-way acquisition, [0:11:10] those things are too time-consuming [0:11:12] to produce a project by March. [0:11:17] We have the ability, because we started to think about Locustreet several years ago, [0:11:24] and have done some initial materials where to investigate what the depth of the road wish [0:11:30] would be. [0:11:31] We have some knowledge that we would not normally have with regard to that section. [0:11:35] Locust is not a normal collector. [0:11:37] It's very heavily traveled, and so we thought that maybe we'd better pay a little bit of attention to it [0:11:43] since it's a pretty important roadway for us. [0:11:46] So we do have a geological or geotechnical investigation that tells us what that roadway should be. [0:11:53] This is a really good candidate for the project. [0:11:59] A section of locus that we're proposing is between Pulline Road and North College. [0:12:05] So the right-a-way is there. [0:12:07] The roadway has not totally fallen apart yet. [0:12:10] The utilities, underground utilities are in pretty good shape. [0:12:14] And we think we can deliver the job in a timely manner. [0:12:18] I'm just checking to make sure I didn't necessarily appoint her. [0:12:32] And you can get it done within that time period? [0:12:34] Yes, we can. [0:12:35] So I have been very pleased with how staff was performed. [0:12:41] We've left ahead several different times in the decade that I've been here and most recently. [0:12:47] John Keaton had submitted for some projects for emergency relief funds. [0:12:53] The cash bear has been delivering on those together with Aaron Steele, and they have left [0:12:59] through the gap. [0:13:00] They have taken jobs that have very little scope and managed to deliver on something that [0:13:04] is actually viable and appropriate. [0:13:06] So they actually, they'll have more knowledge on this project than they have when they started [0:13:11] the ERF project money. [0:13:14] So really confident. [0:13:18] The consequence of not delivering the project in a timely manner is that you have to give [0:13:22] the money back. [0:13:23] And you have to give back any money that you don't spend on this particular project, which is fine. [0:13:30] We also have to provide a report talking about our progress as we go through it. [0:13:35] So the request tonight, the application form is very simple, and it basically has a form, a letter description of how we're going to be ready, [0:13:46] and why we think we can do the job in a timely manner, and why we think it's an appropriate use of funds. [0:13:51] And I've just kind of covered that with you. [0:13:53] And then there's a sheet called a program agreement sheet that is to be signed by the mayor. [0:13:58] So the request tonight is that the council authorized the mayor to sign the program agreement form so that we can apply for the project. [0:14:05] First, really important point. [0:14:09] There's no cash match on this job. Our match is our labor effort. [0:14:15] Thank you. Chris talking to. [0:14:16] It's almost too good to believe what's the downside. [0:14:20] The downside is that you have to give the money back if you don't completely deliver [0:14:24] in a timely manner. [0:14:26] Somehow I don't think that's going to happen. [0:14:28] I'm pretty comfortable that we'll be able to get it out of the shoot and finish it. [0:14:33] So the challenge is to finish it. [0:14:35] If we had a contractor that vaporized in the middle of construction, we would really start [0:14:40] begging for mercy. [0:14:41] I don't think there's a problem we should be decided. [0:14:44] Well, I'm convinced I would recommend Councilor Authorizer may have assigned the program agreement [0:14:48] for the local strategic initiatives program in 2018 [0:14:51] and which will be used for reconstruction [0:14:54] of the state North and North College to pull line. [0:14:57] Second. [0:14:58] Motion by Chris Hockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd [0:15:01] to approve the request as presented. [0:15:03] Is there any further discussion? [0:15:07] Chair and roll call vote please. [0:15:13] Chris Hockington. [0:15:14] Yes. [0:15:15] Greg Lanthine. [0:15:16] Yes. [0:15:17] Suzanne Hockington. [0:15:18] Yes. [0:15:19] Nikki Boyd. [0:15:20] Yes. [0:15:21] John Berriger. [0:15:22] Yes. [0:15:23] In your next as well next is a request to authorize the mayor to sign the program agreement form for the Children at Pedestrian Safety Program [0:15:32] so under the same house bill of the legislature [0:15:36] there was a [0:15:38] move and a desire to invest in [0:15:40] some child pedestrian safety projects on the state system and the local system the same 6040 match the maximum program or [0:15:49] project application is [0:15:52] $250,000 [0:15:54] And the project needs to address pedestrians, particularly child pedestrians. [0:15:59] So, let's skip over to South Hills Middle School. [0:16:02] It's currently our newest school with the most substantial surprises [0:16:07] in that children are walking for more than a mile away school, [0:16:11] which is a little bit spectacular given the history of other schools in the neighborhood. [0:16:15] It's a great trend for the health and well-being of our community, [0:16:19] but our challenge is that Harrison Street South is a little tiny road south of Orchard. [0:16:23] It's 22 to 24 feet wide. [0:16:26] You have buses and parents sharing the road with bicyclists and [0:16:31] programs. [0:16:32] And on the weather is in common. [0:16:34] They're not inclined to ruin their shoes by walking the ditch. [0:16:38] So an extension of a sidewalk or pathway from about El Camino [0:16:44] north to Orchard would provide excellent connectivity between the existing [0:16:49] the sidewalk sections on the other side of Orchard and going towards the middle school. [0:16:56] Also we have, we are going to apply for 1100 feet of sidewalk and like a re-grant pathway [0:17:03] that will make transit from the area of Sky Lane Mobile Home Park over to the pedestrian [0:17:10] crossing on 3600 north and then shooting down in the most direct way we could possibly do [0:17:17] on land that we have ownership of to provide a pathway for students coming out of that area. [0:17:25] Those kids are really good street crossers and they do just fine with no shoulder but really [0:17:29] it's an unsafe condition and that land became part of the city a long time ago. [0:17:36] There's no real opportunity to have sidewalk placed. [0:17:39] There will be a short section of that roadway that needs a retaining room and we tried to [0:17:46] be as direct as possible because when I was 12 years old, I never took the long way anywhere. [0:17:51] So in the process of you getting a package and me talking to the traffic safety commission [0:18:00] about what we did, I made a sketch that kind of describes what we have going on, so I'll [0:18:04] show you my written sketch, what we intend to implement on 3600 mark. Oh, we're so close. [0:18:25] Okay, there it is. There's my total act of artistic capability. We're standing on 3600 mark [0:18:35] The fence line is to the Skyline Mobile Home Park. [0:18:39] There is a great change between the fence and the bottom of the ridge. [0:18:43] There, the road has a crown on it. [0:18:47] So, in order for us to put curbing gutter on this side of the road [0:18:51] at this point in time, we would have had to reduce the size of the Child Safety Grant application. [0:18:55] And we don't have any place to dispose of the surface water that runs off. [0:19:01] that runs off. So retaining it in the ditch has it stands right now. It's not too bad of a plant. [0:19:06] There'd be a little retaining wall up against the fence. It should be less than four feet in height, [0:19:13] just about everywhere with a sidewalk that has the ditch between the kids and the roadway. [0:19:21] What we're looking at on the near on the lower side of the picture, close to where my little sketch ends, [0:19:28] is the pathway that goes back from the canal companies [0:19:32] is to access the Cooley and immediately out of the view line [0:19:36] towards us is the pedestrian crossing [0:19:38] that we just recently installed. [0:19:41] The regrain path is on private property. [0:19:45] It's actually a school district property [0:19:47] and the nose is up next to the edge of the PI station. [0:19:51] And at the top of the page, you have the very edge [0:19:56] of the South Hillsborough School of Parcel. [0:19:58] And so our hope is to just put a little surface [0:20:03] that will eventually be destroyed because the property adjacent to both sides will develop [0:20:09] and the kids will have some, like, relatively clean way to get through the area [0:20:13] on the straightest shot that we could find that was not imminently to be developed [0:20:19] because this area over here, this is well-supported. [0:20:32] Bradwells and the Seabills are here to support the use of the application of the sidewalk [0:20:40] where it's planned. [0:20:42] Traffic Safety Commission loves the idea. [0:20:45] Greater Trim Falls Area Transportation Committee [0:20:47] is supporting it. [0:20:49] Also, the police department is very happy [0:20:52] because they also hear a fair amount of concern. [0:20:57] So the request tonight is for the Council [0:21:00] to authorize the mayor to execute the program agreement. [0:21:03] This is also 100%. [0:21:06] So no cash matches required are available [0:21:09] of our program administration, program administration, sorry. [0:21:14] We have a few comments or questions here. [0:21:18] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:21:19] Thank you. [0:21:20] So on the Harrison section of it, I'm assuming [0:21:25] that's going to be on the west side of Harrison Street? [0:21:32] Well, it sure would be nice if it's on the west side of Harrison, [0:21:34] but we actually have right away dedication [0:21:36] on the right hand side. [0:21:37] That's what I was going to ask. [0:21:39] Where do we have property and are we [0:21:40] having to obtain any property? [0:21:42] Okay. [0:21:43] It would be, I have not yet engaged the person on the other side of the street to see if they're [0:21:49] willing to allow this one. [0:21:50] That area comes out of farm. [0:21:51] That'll be a development requirement if they do anything other than live in the house [0:22:01] that's there. [0:22:02] So it may be a win-win for them. [0:22:04] The developer of the flats on the other side of the street is not here tonight at this time. [0:22:14] But there's no reason to believe that there wouldn't be a manual test built in the sideline. [0:22:21] But we do have the right away then on the east side. [0:22:23] I'm understanding. [0:22:24] Okay. [0:22:26] I think it's great. [0:22:27] In fact, when Greg and I were up at AIC, they were talking about this program. [0:22:32] We looked at each other at the same time and said, Sal Pills Middle School. [0:22:35] So when you had this on the packet tonight, I was excited because we had just learned of [0:22:40] this opportunity last month. [0:22:42] It's really a long way away from that. [0:22:48] You know, it makes sense and good for those kids [0:22:49] for being low in the block. [0:22:51] I agree with the police school. [0:22:52] I support this 100%. [0:22:55] Chris, talk. [0:22:56] I think we talked about this before, [0:22:58] but were we going to do something about a lower speed [0:23:01] limit on orchard on 3700 north, either through the highway [0:23:06] district or the county for the poor. [0:23:08] I believe for the speed limit on orchard [0:23:10] in advance of the Highway District's consideration [0:23:12] and the item and also chose to lower the speed limit [0:23:19] in their corresponding jurisdiction. [0:23:23] Thank you. [0:23:24] Greg Lindt. [0:23:25] Jackie, is this the sidewalk that you were showing there [0:23:28] along the skyline? [0:23:31] Well, that actually helped that subdivision that [0:23:34] is just to the west of Skyline a little bit with those kids [0:23:38] as well. [0:23:39] At least they could get through it [0:23:41] on a portion that's on Skyline as well. [0:23:44] I can't remember if there's a sidewalk for them or not, because to the west of Skyline [0:23:48] Mall Park there's a subdivision. [0:23:51] Yeah. [0:23:56] I think I'm using a shake from Radvis is probably not. [0:24:03] So everything on the south side all the way to Washington is, there's quite a big grass [0:24:09] area there for them to walk, but that Skyline subdivision, it's actually a street went through [0:24:16] there and actually another one to the north on 3,600, there's probably 12 houses go down [0:24:24] there too. [0:24:25] But they can all walk up past the mobile home park to that part with a pretty wide open [0:24:31] area. [0:24:32] But once they get to that past the old filter plant, it gets a little bit dicey form. [0:24:39] Okay. [0:24:40] All right. [0:24:41] Thank you. [0:24:46] comments or questions for Jackie like Christmas up there. I'm ready to make [0:24:55] a motion for through. I move that we authorize the mayor to sign the program [0:25:01] agreement for the Children pedestrian safety program with the information that [0:25:05] we were provided tonight. Second motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Nikki Boyd [0:25:12] to approve the request as presented. I would just add Jackie thank you for your [0:25:17] work in putting together the paperwork for not only this project but the [0:25:21] other again it's money that's out there to help make some significant [0:25:26] improvements and we had some projects that fit so thanks to you and your team for [0:25:29] the work you've done on it. Sharon Rolkel, please. Greg Lanting. Yes. Suzanne [0:25:37] Houghton. Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Sean Berriger. Yes. Chris Taukington. Yes. I also just [0:25:44] like to add Shawn's comment what Greg brought up some time ago is this prioritizing child [0:25:51] safety so important passes five to zero thank you Jackie very Christmas Jackie next on the [0:26:04] agenda is a city policy on annually testing of backflow devices as it relates to state [0:26:11] administrative policy and the Idaho plumbing code discussion we have a city resident Lance [0:26:17] This is the last meeting for the council and I didn't pick that tonight for that reason. [0:26:43] In fact, I was going to come in November, [0:26:45] then I realized I might mess around with the elections issues. [0:26:49] I want to share with you some thoughts [0:26:50] about the backload device testing requirements of the city. [0:26:53] As you know, if you have a sprinkler system hooked up [0:26:56] to the city water, you're required to have it tested every year. [0:27:02] This requirement goes back many years. [0:27:04] When I was on city council, this item used to come up all the time, [0:27:08] and we resisted and resisted. [0:27:10] I'm not here tonight to really pass dispersions [0:27:13] on that we should never have done it, [0:27:15] but I'm concerned about the annual nature [0:27:17] of the testing requirements. [0:27:20] I also made note that John Branham was here on a civility thing. [0:27:23] I don't know if you invited him here [0:27:24] to make sure I stayed the civil, [0:27:26] but I'll try to follow that. [0:27:28] And I know that Greg had added an amendment [0:27:30] to the agenda in case you have to have a discussion [0:27:34] about a public official in the seconds of the nominee. [0:27:37] I'll try to keep this pretty civil. [0:27:40] I've always had personal concerns about this issue, and I'm here as much as a city resident, [0:27:48] but also as a legislator too, because the issue reaches a whole broad base of bureaucracy. [0:27:56] It starts at the federal level probably, and it works its way down to the state, and then [0:28:02] it gets to the city, and you're expected to follow various types of rules. [0:28:06] And many of those rules are set up through the Idaho [0:28:09] Administrative Procedures Act. [0:28:12] And that goes to, just think of it, [0:28:14] these are the regulations that the state issues, [0:28:16] they're not laws, we review those laws. [0:28:19] But there's an interesting thing that happens [0:28:21] in those review processes is that quite often we, [0:28:25] as legislators, we will see these rules come through [0:28:27] and we'll look them over. [0:28:28] And it might be two or three pages long, [0:28:30] not much in there, and they'll make a little reference. [0:28:32] And by reference, we adopt the Agile Plumbing Code, [0:28:36] which is 429 pages. [0:28:39] They don't want to reprint that for everybody to have, [0:28:42] but they reference you to go look it up. [0:28:45] And then what changes in that code [0:28:48] that might impact other people along the way? [0:28:50] So it gets, it's pretty complicated. [0:28:53] And then it also gets more complicated [0:28:55] when organizations like the Department of Environmental [0:28:57] Quality start referencing other codes, other sections, [0:29:02] And they make decisions based upon those things. [0:29:06] I started looking at this in 2016. [0:29:08] I actually met with the director of the Department of Environmental [0:29:11] Quality and one of his representatives to talk about, [0:29:15] is there anything we can do about the annual inspections? [0:29:18] Basically, I just kind of ran into a wall, [0:29:22] didn't have any place to go. [0:29:24] And I just kind of let it sit. [0:29:26] Then this, in the past two years, the city's [0:29:28] been getting more aggressive with their letters to citizens. [0:29:30] And I got one too. [0:29:32] And all of a sudden, I got a call from one of our mutual constituents. [0:29:37] He was pretty upset. [0:29:38] He was calling me, I'm not 100% certain why, but I guess because I was a representative. [0:29:45] And he was complaining about the requirement to inspect his sprinklers and have a test done [0:29:50] and pay the money to do that. [0:29:52] And it was unrealistic. [0:29:54] And I tried to calm him down, tried to explain to him the history, etc. [0:29:57] And the more I listened to him, the more I realized that I probably, as a legislator, [0:30:01] We need to look into this a little bit deeper and find out what is the nexus for all these [0:30:06] issues. [0:30:07] So my goal has always been in its own remains that flexibility in the policy not to eliminate [0:30:12] testing. [0:30:13] You need to know that. [0:30:16] But I want to make sure that it's done on a rational basis and not some arbitrary reason [0:30:20] that's given. [0:30:21] We've faced this in the city with our arsenic program, facing that for years and we kept [0:30:27] trying to challenge the EPA, how do you come up with these requirements that you lower from [0:30:31] 50 parts per billion down to 10? And they never had really a good scientific explanation. They [0:30:37] would just say, well, you know, in Singapore, not Singapore, some foreign country, you know, [0:30:41] they have 150 parts per billion and their cancer rates are high. And so we have a, that's [0:30:48] 150. We have a 50 parts per billion requirement, years lower than 10, you know, on what basis. [0:30:54] Anyway, long story short is we ended up complying with that. [0:30:57] The city bocked that for a long time until we could find some ways if you're gonna best that kind of money [0:31:01] to bring some other benefits to the citizens, which was enhanced water system, [0:31:05] which I thought our staff did a great job coming up with some alternatives. [0:31:10] But these things, they tripled down, they come down to us in many different ways. [0:31:15] Last summer, after this gentleman contacted me, I then contacted the EQ again, [0:31:23] EQ again, I said, come on, point to me exactly where it is in your rules and code that says [0:31:28] it requires annual inspections. [0:31:31] And they came back and they wrote me an email. [0:31:33] Basically that email said, oh well, it's because the plumbing code requires it. [0:31:38] And I thought, what do you mean the plumbing code? [0:31:40] You said, yeah, and the plumbing code said you should have annual inspections on back loads [0:31:43] so we put that into our rules. [0:31:44] So here we have one group of bureaucracy to rely on another set of bureaucracy to set up [0:31:49] the same note testing. [0:31:51] And so I responded back with a little bit of an anger in my letter, and he's commented [0:31:59] about it because I think I referenced to it it was a bunch of bureaucratic doublespeak [0:32:03] because they weren't answering the question, they were just passing it down the road. [0:32:07] So after that I contacted Travis and asked him if he could set up a meeting with his staff [0:32:12] and friends and I invited DEQ and I invited the plumbing department to come down, the department [0:32:18] building city and state to be in that meeting, and talking about this rule and how do we come [0:32:25] down to the fact that we need annual inspections? And everyone said, what's in the plumbing code? [0:32:30] I said, why do we need that? Why is it in the plumbing code? And I could argue that it's [0:32:38] the Pull Employment Act, but that's not the answer. But finally, someone came up and finally [0:32:46] They said, well, that's because the equipment, these backflow devices that are installed and [0:32:50] there's basically two types. [0:32:51] I don't know, there's an above ground and there's an underground one. [0:32:56] The companies only warranty them for one year and then they recommend an annual inspection [0:33:01] there after. [0:33:03] So we have rules in place throughout the state, maybe throughout the country based upon an [0:33:09] attorney in some big city that told their manufacturers, let's protect our interests and [0:33:14] said a limited warranty and tell people to inspect it. [0:33:18] And that is the basis for annual inspections. [0:33:22] Think about all the equipment you have in the city. [0:33:24] All the equipment you have buried underground that may be under [0:33:28] warranty that is now out of warranty and would probably [0:33:31] benefit by having annual inspections. [0:33:34] During these meetings, one of the other things that I heard [0:33:36] and I heard it in other meetings, but I also heard it again [0:33:39] in our meeting with the city, comments like, wow, did you [0:33:42] here about Meridian and they had like 40 homes, I had a problem and people got that water was [0:33:48] polluted and there was a backflow problem and I said, really? So I'll have that all happen. [0:33:54] It turns out it wasn't a failure of an individual's backflow device. The original backflow device [0:34:00] in this area was put in backwards. So they should have been able to discover that at the [0:34:06] first inspection, which I think we shouldn't expect the first time, but they should have [0:34:11] caught it at the first time, almost every case was a situation where it was installed [0:34:15] wrong. [0:34:17] Think about if you have a back-to-device in your property, the only way that you're going [0:34:20] to have a problem is if the city's water has a problem and their pressure drops so low that [0:34:26] it's going to siphon your water back out of your sprinkler system. [0:34:30] So you have to have the two issues happen at the same time. [0:34:35] And in all my years in City Council, not once do I ever recall anybody come to City Council [0:34:40] and reporting something along the lines, [0:34:42] and we've made a bunch of people sick with our water. [0:34:45] I've heard boil orders and things like that, [0:34:47] but I've never once heard of this situation. [0:34:50] It costs about $25. [0:34:53] I think I paid $35 on mine one time, [0:34:57] and we probably, I don't know how, [0:34:58] we used to have about 15,000 water hookups, [0:35:01] so I'm estimating, what if we have 10,000 [0:35:03] sprinkler systems out there? [0:35:05] And then I'll pay at 25 bucks a year. [0:35:07] That's $250,000. [0:35:10] That's $5 million over the next 20 years that we're going to assess to protect ourselves [0:35:16] from these issues that no one's ever pointed out that we've ever really had a failure. [0:35:20] We're ones that actually caused a problem where we've actually had to call in somebody to correct this. [0:35:28] I'm just my main point tonight is to bring you up aware of where all this comes from. [0:35:34] I intend this year to excuse me to, through the business committee that I have happened to be on, [0:35:40] to look at the plumbing rules and see if that one paragraph of this one rule can be rejected and [0:35:48] Give them instructions come back and give us a better inspection say every three years [0:35:53] And then let the cities to and counties or whoever make the decisions from there and sit at this mandated requirement down [0:36:02] So that's one of the directions that I'm primarily going [0:36:05] So this is where it references in the DEQ rules about the plumbing code. [0:36:23] And if you go to the plumbing code, and it's a different section of the DAPA section, [0:36:29] it goes 7, it goes 6, it gets down to the real details of having why it's annual infections. [0:36:35] So DEQ is saying you got to do it because it's plumbing practice. [0:36:39] And the plumbing practice, the plumbers are telling us what we're doing [0:36:44] because there's only one year warranty, and we want you to inspect them. [0:36:48] And I'm sure that's part of the legal protections that any good attorney would give to their clients. [0:36:55] But it doesn't mean that these systems are all going to fail at one time, at the same time we have a failure in the street to do that. [0:37:02] In fact, when I'm talking to the sprinkler guys that work on these things, they have to get licensed, they get all the equipment. [0:37:09] It's not cheap for these guys to do it. [0:37:11] I almost hate to bring this up because if I'm successful, [0:37:13] but if you are in testing going on, [0:37:16] and some of the guys are not going to make [0:37:18] as much money doing testing, [0:37:19] and I'm sorry if that happens to be [0:37:21] one of the consequences of this discussion. [0:37:24] But they pointed out that anybody that blows out [0:37:28] their sprinklers, that's the most common reason [0:37:32] the next year of workload device is gonna fail. [0:37:36] So we do this all the time. [0:37:38] So we inspect in the middle of the year towards the end of the year, then we blow out our sprinklers. [0:37:44] And if there's going to be a failure, it's going to happen probably because of that sprinkler blowout. [0:37:49] And then we're going to put the water in and it could be a failure. [0:37:52] I'm not going to mention another thing when I was trying to get mine tested. [0:37:58] It turns out that if you have an above-ground backflow device, it has to be a foot above the highest point in your property for a sprinkler. [0:38:07] So if you have a sloping property or you have a riser in the back, I would have had to have [0:38:13] mine up about three or four feet above the ground. [0:38:16] So I thought, I don't really want that, but let me investigate my options. [0:38:20] So I'd ask them, could you test my device before you raise it to make sure it's working, [0:38:25] and the plumbing rules say no, you can't test it if it was installed incorrectly in the [0:38:29] first place. [0:38:30] And I'm not going to do it yourself, I didn't install these myself, they're all done myself. [0:38:34] So the point I'm trying to make here is, now they won't even test the device, so I can [0:38:39] make the right choice of do I want to abandon this field device and go underground, what my [0:38:45] options are. [0:38:46] So there's all these little side issues once we start adopting funding codes. [0:38:53] Anyway, I think I've covered most of the topics that I wanted to touch on. [0:39:00] The main issue here is that I'd like to bring the citizens in. [0:39:07] You need to start thinking about these issues and what are the risks. [0:39:11] For a long time, we challenged the DDQ that the requirement was two owners. [0:39:17] And if the inspection requirement was once every three years or once every two years, [0:39:20] but annually just doesn't seem right for me. [0:39:24] I did have a failure in my system one year and the next year when they came back and they [0:39:30] They wouldn't test it because they discovered that one of my sprinkler heads was above it. [0:39:35] So I don't know what goes on with everybody else. [0:39:38] That's just my own personal experiences. [0:39:42] This request that I was free to be open and thinking about what's coming down and pretty [0:39:47] much to share and put everyone on notice that I'm not upset with the city, I just happen [0:39:52] to be one of your patrons in this case. [0:39:54] I know what you're doing and why you've done it. [0:39:57] I am going to be approaching at the state level to try and see if we can adjust that one paragraph [0:40:02] in that one section. [0:40:04] And to remind you, this is one of the problems that we've run into in the last couple of years [0:40:09] is we're just several legislators like myself, we're looking at things. [0:40:12] What's this by reference, you know, an electrical code, a thousand pages by reference that you're [0:40:19] adopting, and you have no clue, I mean, if you read it, I wouldn't know it again, so [0:40:25] I just share with you that that's what I'm going to be doing. [0:40:28] And I also want to say I'm very proud of the city, [0:40:31] proud to live here. [0:40:33] You guys have done some miraculous things the last two years. [0:40:36] I think downtown is looking great. [0:40:38] City Hall was a great decision. [0:40:41] I kind of will miss this room, but I look forward [0:40:44] to going to the new council chambers. [0:40:47] You guys have managed the city well, [0:40:50] and I respect that, and I'd be glad to answer any questions. [0:40:54] if you have it. [0:40:57] Thanks, Susan. [0:40:58] Thank you, Lance. [0:40:59] I don't have any questions, but I appreciate all the work and effort you've put into this [0:41:04] because as a council, this was a very hard one for us to have to enact when we feel very [0:41:08] similar to how you did about forcing this on the public. [0:41:12] So if you need help or support when you're addressing it, I'd be happy to come up to Boise [0:41:16] and Linda Boyce or support or whatever I could do to help. [0:41:20] Thank you. [0:41:23] Well, I answered one question for you, and I was, I see my father is at the tune of 300 [0:41:30] It seemed like because it had to be replaced as it failed and then they end up putting it [0:41:36] Way higher and they said something about the highest point [0:41:38] I didn't think about a riser to their system had a spigot in the back that came up out of the [0:41:45] Planning area so you could attach a host to it [0:41:48] And so that became the highest point and so thus the one in the front had to be even higher and so at least you [0:41:54] you did answer my question and like Suzanne said, it was a hard decision for us if we could [0:42:00] find a compromise amount of time to make sense, because I do feel I watched a movie at one [0:42:06] point where I watched some old chili that got discarded, got sucked back into the system [0:42:13] of high-rise and gave everybody tell me in poison or something. That's stuck in my mind. [0:42:20] I do think they probably have to be tested in some regular basis, I'm just like you, [0:42:25] I'm not sure, nearly as necessary. [0:42:27] The riser having it that high, it seems odd, but that was where I ran into one of the problems [0:42:36] I ran into, is it well, do I want to rise it that much, what's my option, the other's [0:42:40] the very infotental and expensive, trying to figure out which way I wanted to go with this [0:42:45] device was a real challenge, and I told your staff, so I'm willing to let you try and ship [0:42:51] shut my water off. That's what it takes to get the point made here. I mean really [0:42:57] that's what the thread is. You're going to cut people's potable water off because [0:43:00] the sprinkler system doesn't have an appropriate backflow device. That's pretty harsh too. [0:43:05] So it's a challenge. But think about this, the risk of that versus the risk of kids [0:43:13] It's swimming in Durkys Lake, really kids, and adults, for that matter, or in the Snake [0:43:21] River, and all the potential contaminants are out there, and we're worried about whether [0:43:27] or not a break in the line is going to force this water back into the system and that it's [0:43:33] going to fail. [0:43:35] And I believe this high point that we talked about, you mentioned, is a problem because [0:43:40] I have in my sprinkler system little balance that when the pressure is off it opens up and [0:43:45] it's supposed to drain out. [0:43:46] So a lot of people have those so they don't have to blow their sprinklers out. [0:43:49] So there's no water in there. [0:43:50] It doesn't matter how tall it is, no water in those risers. [0:43:53] So anyway, thank you, Greg. [0:43:56] Chris, talk about it. [0:43:57] Your discussions, I asked with the state and federal bureaucrats, the issue of cross-connections [0:44:02] come up between potable and non-potable water supplies on their property. [0:44:07] Mr. Mayor and Chris, no, I didn't get into that, [0:44:11] but I have seen that and some of the questions [0:44:14] that are out there have to do with, [0:44:16] in the cross-connections, because, you know, [0:44:18] you do have your pressurized irrigation systems, [0:44:21] and some people have been cross-connections, [0:44:23] and obviously there's a little more risk there, [0:44:25] because the water directly has gone [0:44:27] from one system to the other. [0:44:29] I don't, I can't recall what we ended up with policies [0:44:32] on that in the city at one time. [0:44:33] We were going to charge all those systems, [0:44:35] because they remember, we're going to charge those with their potable water until the shoulder [0:44:40] pass until the canal company came in. [0:44:42] Well, the reason we're bringing it up is I thought with the previous city discussions that [0:44:46] cross-connection issue of non-sanitize water potential has some bearing on decisions being [0:44:53] made. [0:44:54] I might keep that in your mind. [0:44:55] I think those were people who did them themselves. [0:45:00] I went out and ran my pot of a water to my PI system so that I can water in April and [0:45:06] October. [0:45:07] Doubt they're getting those inspections. [0:45:08] So you were the cause of the problem? [0:45:09] No. [0:45:10] No. [0:45:11] That was the discussion. [0:45:12] I doubt they're getting those inspected by a plumber when they're doing it. [0:45:17] Well, anybody you're all welcome to come over and take a drink out of my hose. [0:45:20] I did that all my life as a kid and I think that's perfectly safe too. [0:45:23] Thanks Lance. [0:45:24] Alright. [0:45:25] Thank you. [0:45:26] Thank you. [0:45:30] Next, on the agenda, is on the back of the page, is the annual impact fee report from the [0:45:40] Development Impact Fee Advisory Committee presentation and possible action. [0:45:44] We have Jonathan Spendlove for our planning department. [0:45:47] Welcome, Jonathan. [0:45:48] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. [0:45:50] Since August 1st, 2009, the City started collecting impact fees with new building permits, a part [0:45:56] that state requirement sites to have an impact fee program and annual reporting [0:46:00] from that development impact fee advisory committee. This is that annual report for [0:46:06] the close of fiscal year 2017 that the committee met on December 6th to make [0:46:11] their final recommendation to the City Council. The financial data is included [0:46:15] in your packet shows the actual culmination of the impact fee program [0:46:19] since 09 total collected fees and any expenditures that have happened this [0:46:24] This past year, the expenditure of note was about $750,000 for the construction of the trail [0:46:31] section between the jump site and Eastland Drive North. [0:46:33] That's where that new section is now open. [0:46:37] The bulk of that came from that impact fees. [0:46:39] Some of that was alone from the capital improvement fund that we paid back by that. [0:46:47] So that's just kind of a side note. [0:46:49] The equity of the program is another requirement. [0:46:52] In addition to the financial information, the committee provided that recommendation regarding [0:46:58] the operation impact key program and the capital plans. [0:47:02] First and foremost, the committee did not report any perceived inequalities in implementing the [0:47:06] plan or imposing development impact fees. [0:47:09] This recommendation is important since it's required by state statute to review and report [0:47:12] on the equality or equity of the program and associated fees. [0:47:17] in case anybody's listening that has talked to me, [0:47:19] there have been requests of staff to provide the program [0:47:24] to various people paying for the impact fees [0:47:27] as they question the amount, things like that. [0:47:28] So that does happen on that. [0:47:30] Often, we basically give them the report back [0:47:33] with the cap of improvement plans, the projects, [0:47:35] how the amounts come up with, [0:47:36] how we come up with the total. [0:47:39] Hasn't gone to anything past that. [0:47:41] So we had those requests and the annuals request [0:47:43] as needed would be passed forward [0:47:45] when they're getting the building permit. [0:47:48] The impact fee adopting ordinance contains a provision for the capital improvement cost [0:47:53] to be automatically adjusted on January 1st of each year by an amount equal to the year's [0:47:58] municipal cost index. [0:48:00] Seven years since the beginning, seven or eight, our impact fee program, we've allowed [0:48:04] the automatic increase to happen four times and we adopted an ordinance for going to automatic [0:48:08] increase three times and had a negative MCI one since about two or three years ago. [0:48:14] The latest report available on October 2017 shall the NCI rate as increased by 3.19% over [0:48:20] the previous year. [0:48:21] The committee discussed the automatic increase and during the writing of the report the next [0:48:26] first half that sentence should be there. [0:48:28] So since it has been two years since we've updated, I didn't save it when I was writing [0:48:33] the report and that should have been deleted. [0:48:35] But the committee did not forward a recommendation to forestall the increase. [0:48:41] They actually recommended that increase to occur. [0:48:44] did allow it to occur last year as well. So should the council agree with the [0:48:49] committee's recommendation allow the automatic increase to occur no further [0:48:52] actions necessary. They also added in the end they did say that the increase could [0:49:01] happen they did want us staff to have a little bit more notification to people as [0:49:06] well as have that increase happen on April 1st as far as collecting the fees [0:49:11] would start on April 1st so we would they would ask us to let the building [0:49:16] community and developing developers community know around January 1st or whenever we know [0:49:20] what the MCI is going to be and the costs are going to be enforced all the collection [0:49:24] of those fees starting April 1st which is what happened this last year. [0:49:29] So a conclusion, the committee recommends to the council to review the annual report and [0:49:35] allow the automatic increase to occur as scheduled with those guidelines for staff to [0:49:41] to notify the community and then have that fee increase date [0:49:45] be able first. [0:49:49] Thank you, Jonathan. [0:49:50] Chris, talking to us. [0:49:51] Well, as Leah is and for the impact fee, [0:49:53] I'm going to propose we do that. [0:49:55] But I just want to remind the public the impact fee [0:50:00] has had on the development of Twin Falls and the areas [0:50:03] of parks and streets and police and fire since 2009. [0:50:08] We've collected almost $5 million or over 5 million [0:50:11] dollars, I guess, really, Jonathan. [0:50:13] and this year alone, 688,000. [0:50:17] This is all Corg debated and approved. [0:50:21] On the impact advisory committee are developers, [0:50:25] people in the building business, [0:50:26] they were supportive of it. [0:50:29] As we mentioned, Jonathan earlier, [0:50:31] we didn't take one last year, [0:50:32] and so this would be the 3.2 approximate for this year. [0:50:37] So they've been very hesitant to, [0:50:41] given the appearance of always jumping on board [0:50:43] and getting as much money as we can, [0:50:45] it's been a very restrained response, [0:50:48] but has paying for new development. [0:50:51] And as such, I would so move approving [0:50:56] the impact fee hike as proposed by impact advisory committee [0:51:03] as of January 1st, 2018, approximately 3.2%. [0:51:09] So if I understand we actually don't need to take action [0:51:12] if we wanted to go into effect. [0:51:14] We would only take action if we weren't doing it. [0:51:17] Or a different amount. [0:51:18] Yeah. [0:51:19] Or a different amount. [0:51:20] That's what I'm saying. [0:51:21] If we'd put the council's approval, [0:51:23] we'd have that implementation of advance notice [0:51:26] having that E-collection started that data. [0:51:28] I don't believe we need any action to do those two things. [0:51:31] So I'll withdraw the last 45 minutes of time on that. [0:51:34] That's the thing. [0:51:36] I think you make very valid points [0:51:37] about the purpose of impact fees [0:51:40] and how we have utilized those over the past, [0:51:44] although it's been years to help offset [0:51:46] that impact of growth. [0:51:47] Thank you. [0:51:48] Great landing. [0:51:50] This is possibly a question for Fritz. [0:51:52] Maybe Mitch or Jonathan might remember. [0:51:55] I heard just the side comment at the last day I see [0:52:00] meaning about a case that was coming to that [0:52:02] on spring court concerning, it wasn't exactly impact fees, [0:52:06] But it was something where growth was paying for something in a city, [0:52:14] but they didn't use the word impact fees. [0:52:16] And I was wondering if that was still in the docket, [0:52:21] or maybe I misheard it. [0:52:22] Maybe it was a different state. [0:52:23] It was always a good possibility. [0:52:25] I just heard that I should have stopped. [0:52:27] Travis, do you have a thought, or, Fritz? [0:52:29] So I believe you're referring to the case that involves [0:52:32] the community of Hayden and how they [0:52:35] we're collecting capacity fees, and part of those capacity fees were going actually from [0:52:46] the system and being used to subsidize general government operations. Essentially, they were [0:52:52] taking those funds and passing them through. And the courts, I believe, ruled that that [0:52:57] was an improper transfer of the fee, and then obviously that is, it's not something that [0:53:06] we do. [0:53:07] All of the capacity fees that we collect stay with those systems and they must be used for [0:53:12] those system improvements, and it's same with the impact fees as we collect those impact [0:53:16] fees for those specific projects defined in those specific categories that are applied [0:53:22] into those areas as well. [0:53:24] Any other questions for Jonathan Riggard and the impact beads? [0:53:31] Thank you, sir. [0:53:35] And thank you to that committee for the work that they do as well. [0:53:38] They do a great job of keeping their thumb on the development pulse. [0:53:43] Next on the agenda is the mayoral selection process discussion. [0:53:49] So this is just a reminder, partly for the general public, [0:53:54] but also for the council as well. [0:53:56] So since the City of Twin Falls operates under the Council Manager Plan, the Mayor is selected [0:54:04] by the Council following every Council election. [0:54:08] So we just had an election in November. [0:54:11] Three members of the Council will be take their oath of office at the meeting in January, on [0:54:17] January 2nd, and then the first item of business will be to elect a Mayor. [0:54:23] So last year, or two years ago, it was actually the first time I think we used this new process [0:54:29] or a different process. [0:54:36] I would suggest that that was not a bad process to use, that those who were interested in [0:54:42] running for mayor make a brief presentation of the council and then there is the vote. [0:54:49] So certainly opened any input if others have other suggestions, but otherwise I think [0:54:53] that will be the plan and just wanted to share that. [0:54:56] Make a landing. [0:54:57] I can't remember, did we have the potential candidates [0:55:02] announced tonight or just at that first meeting? [0:55:05] We did not. [0:55:06] There was some discussion about possibly doing that. [0:55:08] And then I don't believe that it was just [0:55:12] once we got to the meeting. [0:55:13] But it's clear I'm not interested. [0:55:15] It's so good. [0:55:18] Chris, I can see. [0:55:19] Well, I think the process has served us very well. [0:55:23] that's been the most transparent and public involving format that I can think we do is [0:55:28] to come together on that night. [0:55:31] Those people who consider themselves candid have obligation and an opportunity to speak [0:55:37] publicly at the dias and make any statements they wish to on what they'd like to see done [0:55:43] and the vote to follow fits hard to improve on this policy. [0:55:50] So that will be the plan for the meeting on January 2nd, [0:55:54] which will be our first meeting over in the new council chambers. [0:55:58] Frank Linton. [0:56:00] The only one I might suggest is a change and it's only a slight one. [0:56:07] It's typically the first thing we vote on. [0:56:10] So the first person who will vote on is always the same person, [0:56:15] because we've started at the beginning of the alphabet [0:56:17] that maybe we start that meeting with some sort of a lottery [0:56:20] who asked the little first on the motion is made as a matter of fairness. [0:56:25] Can I weigh in? [0:56:26] You may. [0:56:27] Since two years ago, both Sean and I wanted the position and I was the lucky first voter [0:56:32] on Sean's nomination. [0:56:34] It was very, very awkward. [0:56:36] So I think if there's some way that that doesn't happen again, I would be in favor of [0:56:40] that. [0:56:41] Perhaps we could just draw numbers, put one through seven on numbers and just draw the [0:56:46] seeds and vote in that order. [0:56:48] So it would be random. [0:56:51] Thank you. [0:56:55] Okay. [0:56:59] With that we have no public hearings scheduled this evening. [0:57:04] We would give another opportunity for any general public input if there's anyone from the audience [0:57:09] who wishes to address the council. [0:57:11] Welcome, sir. [0:57:16] Max Newland, Twin Falls. [0:57:17] I wanted to co-tail on Lance's program. [0:57:20] When I first came in, I got the little letter since I got to have my test and searched around, [0:57:25] found out where I get the test. [0:57:27] I did the test and I still got letters. [0:57:28] You didn't do the test, you knew the test. [0:57:30] So I called him up and said, where's my name? [0:57:33] Did the guy turn it in or no? [0:57:34] He says, is this a fraud or what? [0:57:36] And they said, oh, we have silver oil. [0:57:37] We don't know. [0:57:37] We don't have little key records. [0:57:40] And I'm hoping time has passed and that pound has been fixed. [0:57:44] Yes. [0:57:44] So we do keep all the records. [0:57:46] And we have a database of everybody, [0:57:48] as they've submitted their annualized testing results. [0:57:53] It is the responsibility of the tester [0:57:55] to provide that information. [0:57:57] And so we do collect that information. [0:57:59] Can you, my name be taken off the naughty list? [0:58:03] Only if your testers submitted the documentation. [0:58:07] Well, that's what I, I never get off the, [0:58:09] it's that little notice on the bill says you, [0:58:12] everybody in town has to do this. [0:58:13] You went with the wrong do here. [0:58:15] On this and I did, I stepped on all the hoops, [0:58:17] I've done everything. [0:58:18] So, Max, do you have a copy of your testing results? [0:58:21] No. [0:58:23] I give it to the plumber, the plumber gives it to you guys, [0:58:26] And I'm done. [0:58:27] So what happens? [0:58:28] How about I give him is the money. [0:58:29] Yeah, so. [0:58:30] Every year. [0:58:31] Typically what happens in other cases, [0:58:34] what happens in other cases, is that there is a copy that [0:58:39] is mailed to the city, and then there's a copy that is [0:58:41] retained by the individual property owner. [0:58:44] So I can go to the new city hall to the front desk there, [0:58:48] and they can check my names if I've got, if I'm in certifying. [0:58:52] It's actually down at the Public Works Department. [0:58:55] Yes. [0:58:56] Okay. [0:58:57] I know where that is. [0:58:58] Thank you very much. [0:58:59] And if you don't get a copy this year, I might suggest a different tester. [0:59:03] I'm going to test it every year because my plumbers tell me it's critical that they do [0:59:08] fail because I said this is a girl I keep the plumbers working job and sometimes they [0:59:14] rush down, sometimes this. [0:59:16] So I'm with last, let's see what we can do. [0:59:19] Thank you. [0:59:20] That's a good thanks Max. [0:59:21] Anybody else from the general public who wishes to address the council seeing none Chris talking to I'd just like to take a moment to [0:59:29] I think John Brennan again for a civility project [0:59:32] About buttons he gave out his words of encouragement for our community to [0:59:39] Be more civil than it has in the past as we leave this building in these council chambers [0:59:44] I can say that this is my second one. I'm leaving we keep getting booted out [0:59:49] into a new council chamber and it looks very promising for us. But these seats [0:59:56] have seen some extremely popular, loud demonstrations. It has also seen [1:00:05] masses of the public show up and endorsed Twin Falls as a welcoming [1:00:10] community in opposition to those people who distrust outsiders. We have had at [1:00:16] at the same time of all the last 18 months or so of the public unrest. [1:00:22] We've probably seen more dynamic development of Twin Falls City than any time in my history [1:00:29] on the council. [1:00:30] And we've gone from one of the flattest growth communities to one of the most dynamic. [1:00:35] And it shows, I think, the direction we're going and so fitting for us to have John hand [1:00:40] out the pins as we close the doors for the last time and head to our new chambers and [1:00:45] and the Twin Falls, I think we all are very optimistic [1:00:50] about it becoming, so I'll walk out, [1:00:52] I won't look behind when those doors close to the last time, [1:00:55] and we'll look forward to the new doors opening. [1:00:57] Thank you. [1:00:59] Thank you. [1:01:00] Chris is in Hawkins. [1:01:01] I was wondering if somebody would mind taking a picture [1:01:04] on my phone of us for our last meeting in this building, [1:01:06] just so I can have the memory. [1:01:09] Josh, thank you. [1:01:11] Only five of us though. [1:01:12] Well, we can only do what we can do, [1:01:14] But this is our last night here as a group, [1:01:16] so I would appreciate it. [1:01:20] We can do that. [1:01:21] Why don't we do it when we adjourned? [1:01:23] OK, that'd be fine. [1:01:24] Thank you. [1:01:25] Great lantern. [1:01:27] Similar to Chris is only talking [1:01:29] about the different council chambers. [1:01:30] I was not on council at any point in the old chambers, [1:01:34] but I wasn't planning the zoning for six years, actually [1:01:38] seven years. [1:01:39] I guess I was one year on this one, seven years. [1:01:40] and that's the old facility and I saw one of these only means [1:01:47] you get a little white, well, crazy too, [1:01:49] and we had a couple of interesting ones over there as well, [1:01:52] but I just feel like at each time we've left though, [1:01:55] we've improved the size and quality of the council chambers [1:01:59] and I am high tuned looking forward to walking out of this one [1:02:04] and walking into the new one on January 2nd [1:02:06] because I think it's a beautiful facility [1:02:09] and I'll be proud to serve there. [1:02:13] Thank you. [1:02:14] Anything else from the council? [1:02:16] Travis, any announcements from? [1:02:20] Well, just so as this was stated, [1:02:23] this is our last meeting for the calendar year here [1:02:26] in this building, just so that it's clear [1:02:28] there will not be a meeting next week [1:02:31] as we are all celebrating Christmas holiday [1:02:35] with our family will not be meeting on the Tuesday. [1:02:39] Our first meeting will be January 2nd, will not be the first, but it will be January 2nd, [1:02:45] also on a Tuesday evening, and that will occur at 5 o'clock PM in the new city council chambers, [1:02:52] which is located at 203 Main Avenue East. [1:02:57] There is parking in many different locations, so parking should not be any issues, and we [1:03:05] would encourage individuals to utilize the accesses off of Hanson Street or off of [1:03:12] Main Street. The access off of the alley is an employee access and so we will use [1:03:20] those others. We have ADA parking on the sides of the building. You will go forward, [1:03:28] we will draw the numbers and then we're also going to be taking some of the items [1:03:34] that make this room special and we'll be placing them into this. Yes, that is, it [1:03:40] will be a little bit different than it is now. Vital Science doesn't want to have [1:03:45] that in its 200 pieces or they're about to to reconstruct. So we're looking at [1:03:51] moving and also the Centennial, some of the other awards that we've also got as [1:03:58] well. And Travis, the public can expect that there'll be video and audio streaming [1:04:03] and the meeting on January 2nd. [1:04:05] Yep, in fact, we believe that as we've made the improvements [1:04:09] that you're going to see improved technology. [1:04:12] Kathy, Marcus, and the entire information services team [1:04:16] have been really working very hard in getting that facility [1:04:20] up and running, not only for it operationally, [1:04:22] but also for council chambers moving forward. [1:04:25] And we would encourage you to come in and get acquainted [1:04:29] with the room and the buildings and see the screens [1:04:32] and kind of get acclimated prior to the January 2nd meeting. [1:04:37] I will say that the organizational meeting piece of that, [1:04:41] that you do go through as a part of our form of government, [1:04:45] will be the only item on the agenda that evening, [1:04:48] that balance of that work and that conversation. [1:04:52] So the council can expect chairs at night. [1:04:55] You will have chairs. [1:04:57] We couldn't have some this morning. [1:04:59] Because you're sitting in that still. [1:05:01] Yes, so we get our same chairs. Yes. Okay. Yeah. That's a deal. That's a good trade off. [1:05:08] And City Hall will be closed on Christmas Day and New Year's Day. Yes. And I was functional as well. Yes. And [1:05:18] And obviously all emergency services will be working around the clock on both of those all of these. [1:05:25] Thank you, Travis. [1:05:27] So the next item on the agenda is adjournment to executive session under Idaho Code 742061-F [1:05:34] to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for [1:05:41] pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated the mere presence of legal counsel at an [1:05:48] executive session does not satisfy this requirement and [1:05:53] 742061-B [1:05:57] to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining over to hear complaints or charges [1:06:02] brought against a public officer, employee, staff member, individual, agent, or public [1:06:06] school student. [1:06:07] So moved. [1:06:08] Second. [1:06:09] Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adjourn into executive session as stated, [1:06:17] Greg Lanting. [1:06:18] So if one of us wants to know, we don't have to do it. [1:06:21] We have to have five votes. [1:06:23] Okay. [1:06:24] Okay. [1:06:27] Okay. [1:06:28] Sheron Roll Call vote please. [1:06:33] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:06:35] Yes. [1:06:36] Nikki Boyd. [1:06:37] Yes. [1:06:38] John Berrigger. [1:06:39] Yes. [1:06:40] Chris Talkington. [1:06:41] Yes. [1:06:42] Shwickbaw. [1:06:43] Motion passes 5-0. [1:06:44] Thank you all for being here tonight. [1:06:46] Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to everyone. [1:06:48] And we will look forward to seeing everybody over in the new digs on the second. [1:06:55] Meaning it is a journey. [1:07:00] It was our opportunity. [1:07:03] If it had been something we didn't want to do, [1:07:04] it would have been a pretty good chance.