Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-11-27, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-11-27/ [0:00:31] Good evening. I would like to call to order the Twin Falls, the council meeting for Monday, November 27th, [0:00:39] and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council. All seven members are here this evening. [0:00:42] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Those of you who wish me to join us please rise. [0:00:46] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:01:02] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? [0:01:10] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, we would like to add one item for the Council's consideration. [0:01:14] This item would be on the consent calendar, and it would be a event to occur this Saturday, [0:01:20] December 2nd, from 11 to noon in City Park, and it is a rally to celebrate religious freedom. [0:01:27] It is sponsored by the faith leaders of the Magic Valley, and it has been through our [0:01:32] process for review and we would be submitting it to the Council for its review [0:01:37] to be included on the consent calendar this evening. So moved. Second. Motion [0:01:44] by Chris Tockenton seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to add the rally to celebrate [0:01:49] religious freedom special event application to the consent calendar. [0:01:54] Is there any discussion? Sharon Ralcalvo please. Suzanne Hocken. Yes. [0:02:18] Leakey Boyd? Yes. Sean Bericher? Yes. Chris Talkington? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes. Christopher [0:02:26] Reid? Obstain. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 6-0 with one abstention as Councilman Reid is one of [0:02:35] the organizers of the event. Just to clarify why he's abstaining from that. Alright, so we [0:02:39] will add that to the consent calendar. We have no proclamations this evening, so the next [0:02:45] item would be general public input. This is an opportunity for the public to address [0:02:49] the council on issues that are not on the agenda this evening. If anyone would care to address [0:02:54] us, now is your chance to please come forward. Seeing no one. So the next item is the consent [0:03:03] calendar and I would ask that we take the new item that we added and leave that separate [0:03:08] so that councilman read and vote on the balance of the consent calendar. Greg Lantik. [0:03:12] approval of consent calendar minus the religious freedom rally amendment we made. [0:03:20] Second. Motion by Greg Lanting seconded by Nicky Boyd to approve the consent [0:03:26] calendar items 6a through e. I just want to mention that Orville Hanson's name was [0:03:32] spelled incorrectly. It's spelled O-R-V-A-L which I believe we had it right on [0:03:37] everything for some reason that's wrong. I meant Sharon I'm sorry I meant to get [0:03:42] you an update but we will get that corrected in the minutes thank you Ruth [0:03:47] any other discussion on the consent calendar general elbow please Nicky [0:03:56] Boyd yes Sean Beriker yes Chris talking yes Greg Lanting yes Chris Christopher [0:04:12] Reed yes yes yes yes and Hawkins yes motion passes at seven to zero and then I [0:04:20] I would entertain a motion on the amendment [0:04:26] for the rally to celebrate religious freedom. [0:04:28] Greg Lanting. [0:04:29] I move to be pass the remaining item [0:04:32] on the consent calendar of the rally for religious freedom. [0:04:36] Ruth Pierce. [0:04:37] I second that. [0:04:38] Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:04:40] to approve the rally to celebrate religious freedom [0:04:43] at City Park on Saturday. [0:04:46] Is there any discussion? [0:04:48] Sharon Roll, call vote, please. [0:04:53] John Berger, Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hocking, [0:05:02] Nikki Boyne, motion passes six to zero with one abstention. [0:05:08] Next, under items of consideration, the first is a presentation of value awards to several [0:05:18] city employees by the employee recognition committee, and we have Matt Hicks, the employee [0:05:23] recognition from the employee recognition committee. [0:05:26] Good evening, sir. [0:05:28] Good evening to the rest of the members of the City Council. [0:05:29] As you know, my name is Matthew Hicks. [0:05:31] I'm the Chairman of the Employee Recognition Committee. [0:05:34] This is actually the third opportunity [0:05:36] we've had to present awards for the City Council, [0:05:38] and we're very appreciative of that opportunity. [0:05:40] Tonight we actually have four different awards to get out tonight. [0:05:44] As you know, this was an effort to recognize [0:05:49] outstanding acts of public service, [0:05:52] performed by our employees, that followed the five [0:05:57] of separate values that the employees individually voted on last year, [0:06:01] just for refresh about this coming up right now. [0:06:04] Those are as follows, integrity, connection, honesty, commitment, and teamwork. [0:06:10] The order is to be in some of who are here tonight, [0:06:12] not only receive a distinctive token highlighted in the value that we filled. [0:06:17] They displayed during their applicable event, but they also receive a certificate [0:06:20] where we should like to hand out tonight. [0:06:24] One other member of my committee is here tonight, [0:06:26] a strict one from Planning and Zoning, and if we can have the Mayor's help come down, [0:06:30] I will turn it over to Lisa for the presentation of the first of all. [0:06:49] Wendy Thompson and the other is for Lee Glaceman and the third is for Lori Bauer. [0:06:58] Wendy and Lee are the first two I'd like to present to. [0:07:06] They were recognized because about a month or so ago we had some individuals out on a [0:07:13] along the street, and one of the individuals was on a motorized scooter. There was no longer [0:07:20] mobile, and Lee came up and realized they needed some help, went downstairs and drug out [0:07:27] an extension cord and tried to get things charged again, but it wouldn't charge. So he [0:07:34] wasn't able to help, so he decided he would help bring them inside, not realizing at the [0:07:40] time that they were also hearing impaired. And so he asked Wendy if she could help them [0:07:46] to get someone to come get the scooter or come pick them up. So she insisted on trying [0:07:54] to help them. She got someone the first time they were hearing impaired when they called [0:07:59] when she called. And they were able to give her another number. She actually got in touch [0:08:03] with someone else to come and help them. In the process of this, the person that was hearing [0:08:08] and parrot also speaks really loudly because apparently maybe she could hear some and kind [0:08:15] of disturb the whole office so everybody kept after our you know shooter incident training. [0:08:20] Everybody was coming up to the counter to see what was going on. [0:08:23] Anyway, they did a really good job taking care of these people and they were very excited [0:08:27] that they got help so they are being recognized for connection. [0:08:32] And the next one is for Lori Bauer, and she is being nominated for the award commitment. [0:08:52] Apparently, her supervisor was on a trip, and he had expected to get a package for himself, [0:09:00] and it wasn't there. [0:09:02] So she called around, she tracked the package down, and made arrangements for him to be able to get the package on a weekend [0:09:10] so that he could have everything prepared for his meeting on Monday. [0:09:14] And so he was, he recognized her and submitted a nomination for commitment. [0:09:41] For the next award, I'd like the following employees to come forward. [0:09:44] Dave Owens, Zach Fleming, Dallas Williamson, Austin Sharp, and Mitchell Brooks. [0:09:57] Early in the morning of July 13th of this past year, the Twin Falls Fire Department conducted an exercise with St. Luke's Magic Valley Hospital, [0:10:04] simulated fire response with an evacuation shelter in place exercise with actual patients [0:10:10] and hospital staff. [0:10:12] This was not only an opportunity to conduct some valuable training, but a chance to spend [0:10:15] precious time with our partners at St. Luke's and meet several new friends that day. [0:10:20] One of the participants that day was an elderly female patient who the engine wound crew in [0:10:24] front of you learned during the exercise only had a few more days to live. [0:10:28] And she was evacuated as part of that exercise. [0:10:30] Later that day, battalion chief Brooks received a phone call from St. Louis asking if his crew would sign a picture taken by the staff of the [0:10:37] staff of the lady as she is a big fan of the footballs fire partner. [0:10:40] B.C. Brooks took it upon himself and Andrew and crew to walk to the hospital and meet personally with this patient. [0:10:46] According to the St. Luke staff, this gesture was greatly touched this woman, her family and their entire staff that witnessed the event. [0:10:54] The crew also took the opportunity to pose several other patients and express their gratitude [0:10:58] for participating in the exercise. [0:11:01] We all know that it's extremely easy to get caught up in turning the crank, and to miss [0:11:04] an opportunity to simply show those that we serve how much we care. [0:11:08] While we are all proud of our fire department for the excellent service they provide every [0:11:12] day, we want to thank these five fire department members for taking the time to display compassion, [0:11:18] kindness, and thoughtfulness to a woman who is in her final days. [0:11:22] behalf of the employee recognition committee, we'd like to present each one of you with the [0:11:25] connection award. [0:11:26] For the final award, I would ask that the following employees please come forward. [0:12:04] Matt Dorsey, Tina Kelly, Katherine Beer, Heather Posey, and Amanda Gear. [0:12:17] On the evening of August 31st, CERCOM experienced an interruption in their telephone lines which [0:12:21] calls all of CERCOM's emergency calls to be rerouted to the Twin Falls Dispatch Center. [0:12:27] Everyone working that night handled not only their normal call load, but the rest of the [0:12:32] emergency calls for the eight-county regions and emergencies. [0:12:35] In Twin Falls alone, they dispatched a patient and cardiac arrest, a significant motor vehicle [0:12:39] accident, a car fire caused from another motor vehicle accident, and a possible structure [0:12:44] fire with a domestic disturbance call as well. [0:12:48] Their ability to handle these calls along with all of the other additional calls in [0:12:51] the City of Twin Falls was nothing short of incredible. [0:12:54] Their ability to work as a team within our dispatch center and with their partners at [0:12:57] serve column was amazing and they never missed a beat. The fine folks of dispatch [0:13:02] will never receive all the praise they truly deserve for that night but their [0:13:06] supervisor stated that she was truly humbled by their ability to react adapt [0:13:09] and completely handle a unique situation. We've learned that some people stayed [0:13:14] longer than their normal shift called for and some people came in on their day [0:13:17] off to help out when it was needed. The most amazing part of the whole night was [0:13:21] that people walking by the dispatch center heard laughter coming from the room [0:13:24] has told everybody that not only did we're able to handle the workload of two call centers, [0:13:30] but they weren't lending the stress and the pressure of the situation, get them down. [0:13:33] They all have amazing attitudes and it's very humbling to win just their professionalism, [0:13:38] work ethic and overall attitude. So on behalf of the employee recognition committee, [0:13:42] we'd like to present each one of you with the team of the world. [0:13:44] Bill, guys. So does this mean we're shutting down Sir Cum in the north side then? [0:14:24] We have such talented staff. Great landing. [0:14:46] matter, Tammy, when does they get to move into their new digs at the call center? [0:14:53] The consoles the last week of December and then we will get everything together [0:15:00] with IT and move in about the second week of January. Okay, thank you. Ruth Pierce? I [0:15:06] just want to mention that this is why I live in Twin Falls. We have citizens and [0:15:13] staff that go above and be beyond or you always know there's somebody that's [0:15:17] got your back, given some bright idea you had. [0:15:21] Thank you very much, everybody. [0:15:23] Covering me for this last year, but this is honestly what [0:15:27] makes us who we are, and I appreciate it. [0:15:31] It's outstanding work by everyone. [0:15:32] Thank you so much for being part of the city team [0:15:35] and for taking care of our citizens and your fellow [0:15:38] employees. [0:15:39] Congratulations. [0:15:41] You all are excused, and that's the name of the rest of the [0:15:44] family. [0:15:45] Thank you all. Next on the agenda is a request to waive all the building permit fees associated [0:15:56] with an expansion of the property located at 511 Hankins Road. We have Nathan Murray, [0:16:01] our economic development director. I welcome Nathan. [0:16:08] Thank you. So this is a connection with the announcement for the expansion of the H.J. [0:16:11] facility. This has been in the news and the state's [0:16:17] participating as well as the county, and we'd like to assist them in their expansion at that [0:16:24] side it will bring approximately 250-300 jobs over the course of the next year or two, as well as about a $20 million [0:16:32] improvement to the nine areas and the permit fees approximately about $60,000. I don't have that total right now, but it's about $6.62 I think that it is. [0:16:45] Chris Stockton. Nathan has also noted that the Twin Falls County is offering a [0:16:55] partial tax rebate abatement process so it's kind of a joint effort sitting in [0:17:01] County. Do we know when they're going to start construction and those kinds of [0:17:15] things? So their permit is in now if you're probably the issue the next week or two. [0:17:19] Okay, so they're going to get going right away. [0:17:22] Are they building both buildings at the same time? [0:17:24] It's going to be just one facility now. [0:17:26] Okay. [0:17:27] It's about 160,000 square feet. [0:17:28] Where are you? [0:17:29] Actually. [0:17:30] All right. [0:17:32] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:17:33] I'm just curious. [0:17:34] Do they still pay impact fees for this? [0:17:36] Yes. [0:17:37] Okay. [0:17:38] Thank you. [0:17:39] So this would just be the building permit fees as part of a local match to the state's [0:17:44] contribution to the tax reimbursement incentive that's [0:17:49] around $5 million on the state of Santa Fe. [0:17:54] Chris Stockington. [0:17:55] So I would move to waive the whole building permit fees [0:17:59] associated with the expansion of the property described [0:18:02] at 5-11-Hankins Road. [0:18:03] Second. [0:18:05] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:18:08] to approve the waiver of building permit fees. [0:18:13] Any discussion? [0:18:14] I want to add to that the amount not to exceed 62,000. [0:18:20] It may come in. [0:18:23] I don't know the exact number that's approximately 62,000. [0:18:28] It's significantly higher. [0:18:31] We will pass that back. [0:18:34] Great. [0:18:34] That would be perfect. [0:18:36] I need a further discussion. [0:18:39] Sharon, I'll call both, please. [0:18:48] Chris Stockington. [0:18:50] Yes. [0:18:51] Greg Lanting. [0:18:51] Yes. [0:18:52] Christopher Reed. [0:18:53] Yes. [0:18:54] Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins, Nicky Boyd, Sean Berger. [0:18:59] Yes. [0:19:00] Motion passes. [0:19:01] Seven to zero. [0:19:02] Look forward to that further expansion in our community and more great jobs. [0:19:08] Next on the agenda is a request to accept the 2017 Professional Services Roster, Erin [0:19:20] Steele, engineer from our engineering department. [0:19:25] Hi there. [0:19:26] Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor and Honorable Council members. [0:19:29] I'm here today with a request to approve our 2017 professional services roster. [0:19:37] This is to help keep us in compliance with the state statute. [0:19:40] I've included that with your packet. [0:19:42] It's 672320. [0:19:43] I'm going to give you a very bare-bones, cliff note version if you have questions, I'm more [0:19:48] than happy to answer. [0:19:50] But usually the legal jargon I leave to the lawyers. [0:19:54] Anyway, so we released back in July a request for any interested parties that want to do [0:20:02] work in the Sea of Twin Falls, professional services work, that they give us a proposal [0:20:07] with their qualifications, with their experiences, with their project management, that we can [0:20:13] take as an engineering department and use to pick the most qualified firms to do projects [0:20:19] that we need. [0:20:21] This roster will help us eliminate costs because we don't have to send out requests for qualification [0:20:28] for each time a project comes up. [0:20:30] We can just have one basic roster that we can go to and look at for individual service [0:20:35] categories, pick a group of firms from that, create a selection or scoring matrix and score [0:20:42] based on specific project criteria. [0:20:45] Now, this doesn't eliminate the fact that sometimes projects are very specialized and we need [0:20:51] a specialized firm to deal with those projects. [0:20:54] So we can still release a general RFQ to pick those up, [0:20:59] but this will help us, the majority of our projects [0:21:01] will fall in line with this roster. [0:21:04] It will help us as project managers. [0:21:06] There's one list we can consult, grab information from, [0:21:10] select the best firm available, and run with it. [0:21:13] It cuts down our load as project managers [0:21:17] and helps us get through projects efficiently and quickly. [0:21:21] So, I was made aware this morning that there is one typo on the roster that you see, and [0:21:30] JUB, if you look on their roster, they're approved for architecture when they actually [0:21:36] applied for landscape architecture. [0:21:38] And so there is one typo, so I would ask that you would approve this without one typo corrected, [0:21:45] and then also I would ask that if we come back and we find that there's a few more errors, [0:21:50] I would love to say I'm perfect, I'm not. [0:21:53] So there's a potential that there might be another error [0:21:55] in there, that if we do find one that we could just send it [0:21:57] through is a consent item in there. [0:22:00] So I would do that up to you to go in there. [0:22:06] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:22:08] So what if a new firm moves into town in the next year? [0:22:10] Is there a way to add them to this list, [0:22:12] or do they have to wait until next year to apply, [0:22:14] or how does that work? [0:22:15] So they would have to wait until the next go [0:22:18] around the group or is that one of these out. [0:22:20] We try to do it every two years. [0:22:21] Oh, okay. [0:22:22] So they would have to wait until then. [0:22:24] Thank you. [0:22:26] So what, do we have deadline information available on the website so if somebody wants to do business [0:22:33] with us, they know what they have to provide when or do they have a contact person. [0:22:38] I've had a couple of people ask me and I'm in a committee right now that we may have to [0:22:43] select because of expertise, a person that is not from our area or approved and how, we're [0:22:50] We're working on how to go through that process, but I just want to know, so the public knows [0:22:56] kind of what the thought, you know, is this 2017 calendar year? [0:23:00] No. [0:23:01] Fiscal year. [0:23:02] Well, this is for multiple years. [0:23:03] So, this roster will be good for multiple years. [0:23:06] So, it will be for the rest of this year, 2018, and perhaps part of 2019. [0:23:12] Okay. [0:23:13] What was the deadline to submit? [0:23:15] Let's see. [0:23:16] First deadline, we had some computer issues, [0:23:18] and so we weren't receiving packets and stuff [0:23:21] like we were supposed to, [0:23:22] so we had to kick it back. [0:23:23] First deadline was the beginning of August, [0:23:25] and then we moved it back to the end of August. [0:23:27] And we, [0:23:29] because to make our job easier on one of the committees [0:23:32] that I'm liaison to, [0:23:35] we are probably gonna have to figure out a way [0:23:38] to be able to use this firm, [0:23:40] from a cost standpoint, savings for the city, [0:23:43] And so I just want to make sure that we're following the process [0:23:47] and I can talk to you about that later. [0:23:48] Yeah, and I can talk to you offline, but the important part is [0:23:52] that piece that I mentioned that this doesn't. [0:23:54] Lock us in. [0:23:55] Exactly. [0:23:56] Yeah. [0:23:56] You can release another RQ just for that specific point. [0:23:58] Thank you. [0:24:02] Nikki Boyd? [0:24:03] Yes. [0:24:05] I understand that not talking lawyer, Laura, talk. [0:24:09] But I do have a question in the Idaho Code [0:24:11] that addresses the $25,000 amount. [0:24:15] Can you address that or do we need Fritz to stand up? [0:24:18] I can try. Fritz can back me up. [0:24:20] Okay. [0:24:22] So anything under the $25,000 range puts it into a separate category [0:24:27] that we can use for open solicitation of projects and stuff [0:24:31] like that for bid amounts. [0:24:35] If it's under $25,000, we can just select right from the list [0:24:38] that we don't have to do anything other than that. [0:24:40] We can just go look at the list and pick a firm right off. [0:24:43] Okay. All right. [0:24:45] So if it's 30,000, then we, then we do requests for qualifications. [0:24:53] Well, then we can still choose from this list, but we'd have to choose multiple firms, [0:24:56] three, four, five, depending what falls into the service category, create a scoring matrix. [0:25:01] Got it. [0:25:01] Okay. [0:25:02] I wanted to make sure I understood that. [0:25:03] Thank you very much. [0:25:04] And so does this, but you spend in that to your period, the word limited or is it just the one shot deal? [0:25:11] Her project. [0:25:12] Her project. [0:25:12] I'm sorry, I'm sorry. [0:25:14] So from a accountant standpoint, where's Lori when we need her? [0:25:18] My question is, in this particular example, [0:25:23] if he comes up with a concept that we thought he would, [0:25:26] he's probably going to be the one that bird dogs it, which [0:25:30] means it'll probably be more than the 25. [0:25:33] And I just want to understand the process. [0:25:35] So for continuing projects, we can continue [0:25:38] to use the same firm that started the project. [0:25:41] Thank you. [0:25:42] specific exception for that. So we don't [0:25:44] requalify for those. We continue with the [0:25:46] same firm. Perfect. Thank you. Chris [0:25:51] Reid. So first of all, I thank you. Good [0:25:54] job. Looking at the roster, there's a [0:25:57] couple of areas that we don't have a lot [0:25:59] of firms in. In those situations, [0:26:04] realizing that we're in Idaho, fairly [0:26:07] rural. Are we doing anything to reach out [0:26:10] to other firms to bring them in on this [0:26:12] roster, I look at planning, there's one. So what types of things are we are we able [0:26:19] to do and are we doing? So we on the for polls or the request for information, we [0:26:24] said if you feel like you're qualified in an area that we haven't mentioned, right [0:26:29] at the end and we can add it to the list. So this was one of those that they added [0:26:34] this planning category as one of their pieces that the company could do. Now it [0:26:40] It was very generic, very broad in that sense. [0:26:44] So a lot of these other firms do planning, [0:26:46] but it's roadward planning or traffic planning [0:26:51] or water planning, that kind of thing. [0:26:54] And so this one just says planning. [0:26:56] And so to speak to the point of what we're doing [0:27:00] to try to reach out and grab other firms, [0:27:02] I don't know, we had this year, [0:27:03] we had over 40 consultants proposed last time [0:27:07] when we had 14. [0:27:08] Well, so we were encompassing many from across the Valley. [0:27:12] We had him as far north as Cordolane down in the Salt Lake [0:27:16] and over in the Boise quite a few. [0:27:19] So we are, as we grow, more people [0:27:21] are interested in what we need. [0:27:23] And so they're submitting based on what they think our needs are. [0:27:26] Will you answer your question? [0:27:27] Yes, thank you. [0:27:28] You're welcome. [0:27:29] Chris Tockington. [0:27:29] And the growth in that vendor list, [0:27:31] I would have supposed that all of them [0:27:33] have to qualify with bonding. [0:27:37] So the bonding comes in under exceptions bonding comes in for the construction [0:27:42] work construction where the engineering and the design they don't necessarily [0:27:50] bond for only the actual construction. [0:27:57] Ruth Pierce. So my other question from an accounting standpoint or notification [0:28:02] thinking about my clients he've asked me about this process. [0:28:06] Now I forgot my question because I've have about four but just so there's a way that we could direct [0:28:11] somebody to someone, because I find boots on the ground people that know everything, have [0:28:16] really helped me with my job and helping our citizens that if we have somebody that would [0:28:21] like to, that's a proven resident that's built on lots of projects. We got the name of this [0:28:27] one, it has nothing to do with, it's a certain specialty that nobody, our boots on the ground [0:28:36] person knows through other projects like this that we actually saved quite a bit of money [0:28:42] just on design fees. So I just think we need to reach out because there's a lot of people [0:28:47] that would like to be on that list. Sure. And maybe set up subcategories of specialties. [0:28:54] So once they're on the proof list, we know he's the go-to for whatever and so that's [0:29:01] all I want. Any other comments or questions? Ruth Bierce? I guess I'll make the motion [0:29:15] to approve. Let's put the one typo correction. Second. Seconded by Ruth Bierce. Seconded by [0:29:26] Chris Reed to approve the 2017 professional services roster with the correction of landscape [0:29:34] architecture for JUB engineers. [0:29:38] Is there any further discussion? [0:29:41] Sharon Roll, call vote please. [0:29:45] Greg Lanting. [0:29:46] Yes. [0:29:47] Christopher Reed. [0:29:48] Yes. [0:29:49] Ruth Pierce. [0:29:50] Yes. [0:29:51] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:29:52] Yes. [0:29:52] Nikki Boyd. [0:29:53] Yes. [0:29:54] Sean Beriker. [0:29:55] Yes. [0:29:55] Chris Tockington. [0:29:56] Yes. [0:29:57] Motion passes 7-0. [0:29:59] Thank you. [0:30:02] Next on the agenda is a request to authorize negotiations [0:30:05] with top ranked firm to conduct a feasibility study [0:30:08] for a community recreation center, Wendy Davis, our Parks and Recreation Director. [0:30:13] Good evening Mayor and Council. I guess that was kind of a mouthful, sorry Sean. [0:30:21] It's okay. So I'm excited to be here tonight because we're really making some progress with [0:30:28] our efforts toward a recreation center. As you know in April you approved a charter for [0:30:37] an Ad Hoc Committee which has been meeting and the first item on their agenda was to [0:30:44] put together a [0:30:45] request for qualifications for a feasibility study which we have done and [0:30:50] Advertised it we received five proposals. We had a committee review those five proposals and then rank [0:30:59] Select the top three to listen to [0:31:02] presentations and interview questions with the full committee so that happened [0:31:07] on the 17th of November we brought those three firms in and they gave their [0:31:11] presentations to the committee and at that point after that then the committee [0:31:16] ranked the three firms that proposed and we have the rankings as as follows and [0:31:24] that's what we're asking for your approval is to move forward with number [0:31:28] one which would be Pivot North architecture. We listen to Pivot North LCA [0:31:32] architects and BCBO and rank them. Number one was Pivot North. Number two was LCA [0:31:39] architects and number three was BCBO. The expectation would be that we can [0:31:47] negotiate a contract with them and then come back to you to seek funding to do [0:31:55] a feasibility study. Do you have any questions? Great landing. [0:32:00] Well, I'm assuming that you're asking us to begin negotiations with more if you're unable [0:32:06] to negotiate a contract then we need to put it in our motion that you will go up then move [0:32:11] down to number two and then a tree if necessary. So maybe is it approved the ranking? So if [0:32:18] you approve the ranking then we can move through the ranks if you need to. [0:32:21] Okay. Susan Hawkins. I was ready to make a motion if there's other questions all [0:32:27] Chris, talking to you have a question? [0:32:30] A couple of them. [0:32:32] We've had virtually no feedback on the specifics of the meetings going on, and I'm getting some [0:32:37] feedback from people that are questioning this. [0:32:40] A couple of points about the needs assessment will, whomever has the contract, will evaluate [0:32:47] the impact on the new climbing gym that's just constructed as well as the YMCA. [0:32:55] That's the intent of the needs assessment. [0:32:57] assessment? [0:32:58] So the expectation of a feasibility study is going to look at the broader spectrum. [0:33:02] Not only what does the community need, but also what's it going to support, what do we [0:33:08] currently have, what needs are currently being met. [0:33:12] So I think we look at it from a bigger perspective as far as what we come out of the feasibility [0:33:19] study with the recommendations that will bring forward, will address the existing facilities, [0:33:25] existing services that are being provided, and how that's meeting the needs of the community. [0:33:31] You're not saying to me that you are assuming it's going to be built and trying to justify [0:33:38] it rather than the needs assessment leading to the validation of the... [0:33:43] I believe the feasibility study will give us the information to determine whether or not [0:33:48] building a recreation center is even a feasible thing to do in the community. [0:33:52] Thank you, that's... [0:33:53] The first point, the second point is the financial assessment will also include private support [0:34:00] for such a construction, or as an intended only to be publicly supported, as they've been [0:34:07] stated in the goals, aims, to understand the way we laid out the financial assessment would [0:34:14] include not only the cost to build and operate, but also what does the community support and [0:34:21] how to fund such a facility. So it's a multifaceted approach at the financial side of it. [0:34:28] So not only the ongoing operations budget, but the initial construction. [0:34:32] Yes. Can we afford, what would it cost to build it? Can we afford to do it? Can we afford [0:34:38] to support it and sustain it? And is it sustainable? And what can the community support? [0:34:44] And also which funding models may make sense? [0:34:48] Yeah, they're going to make those kinds of recommendations as well which could include public funding as well as private donations. [0:34:55] And is it anticipated that there be any polling of the public to see their support for such a structure? [0:35:01] I believe that that will all be as part of this feasibility study. [0:35:06] There's a whole, actually very large public engagement piece. [0:35:11] Thanks. [0:35:12] Have a seat. [0:35:14] You have something you wanted to add there. [0:35:16] I think one of the important things to recognize, and I think that Windy hit all of those points, [0:35:21] but the creation of a rec center might be something larger than what the City of Twin Falls as [0:35:27] an entity can take on, and then you may be looking at the creation of recreation districts [0:35:34] or other types of structures to support a broader recreation mission. [0:35:39] So what the City of Twin Falls is doing is in under Windy's leadership is taking a look [0:35:44] at the recreational assets that we have inside of the community [0:35:47] in determining whether or not those need to be expanded, [0:35:51] if they need to be expanded, what needs to be included, [0:35:54] and then coming up with the real magical answers of who is going [0:35:59] to be the entity that has the financial capacity to be able [0:36:02] to not only create the structures that are being called for, [0:36:06] but then also to support them into the long-term future. [0:36:09] So it's important to recognize that this process is very much [0:36:13] in its infancy and moving forward with this step will help begin to have a lot of those answers [0:36:21] and I think that the public contribution will add to that process but then it will also give [0:36:28] us the opportunity to really set those paths and move forward. [0:36:34] The work of the committee to date has been to get to this point which is not something [0:36:39] that we've done in the past, and that is to hire an expert who understands recreational [0:36:46] components to help walk us through this process, which is what we presented to the Council last [0:36:51] spring. [0:36:53] And I would just stand on that just a tiny bit further to say that I think we can learn [0:36:59] from this feasibility that it could work or that it's not going to work. [0:37:03] And that's part of where we want to land, because if we want to invest in this, we want [0:37:07] be fairly certain that it's something that's going to work and then it's sustainable and [0:37:11] it's feasible and then it's going to work in the community and not negatively impact [0:37:16] the other service providers. So that's the intent of doing the full feasibility study. [0:37:21] Thank you. Any other questions or comments before a motion here? Suzanne Ockens. [0:37:33] I move that we approve the request to authorize negotiations and rank the three firms as presented [0:37:40] tonight. Second. Motion by Susan Hawkins seconded by Mickey Boyd to approve the [0:37:47] ranking of the firms as presented. Greg Lantig. [0:37:52] Well I think this is a good step for us to decide where we're going because I [0:37:58] can just harken back to the forum we had during the election this year we had [0:38:02] nine candidates that turn on the grid. Nine different ideas what's in a rec [0:38:06] that's involved with HAP. [0:38:08] So it's even what's in it is a whole, [0:38:12] whether or not you're a foreword or a sustainment [0:38:14] is what's involved in it is a lot of different opinions. [0:38:18] So I'm very much in favor of us. [0:38:22] We need somebody in here that's worked with rec centers [0:38:24] and so we can pick their brains on what we need [0:38:29] and whether we can afford it. [0:38:32] But there's- [0:38:33] The only thing I wanted to mention [0:38:34] is this is a perfect example of why we are [0:38:37] how successful we are, is I've been listening to the downtown redevelopment rec center discussion [0:38:45] for ever since I moved to Twin Falls and that's been 40 years. So this is the furthest that [0:38:52] I recall that in either one of those projects ever got, I mean Main Street is a perfect example [0:38:57] of win, win, win and I'd love to see the rec center be the same thing personally. Big, big [0:39:06] community need. So I appreciate it. When do you thank you? [0:39:11] No, we haven't mentioned a price for this study. Is it to exceed the $10,000? We're [0:39:18] reading that we're getting the expectation that it will. Yes. So we're given an open [0:39:22] net that mandate for the contract would come back to the council for [0:39:28] so right now you're authorizing us to negotiate a contract at which time we [0:39:32] will bring, if we can reach a satisfactory number and contract content, then we'll bring [0:39:41] that back to council for approval and funding. [0:39:47] Any other questions or comments? [0:39:51] Sharon Rolkow, please. [0:39:56] Christopher Reed. [0:39:57] Yes. [0:39:58] Ruth Pierce. [0:39:59] Yes. [0:40:00] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:40:01] Yes. [0:40:02] Nicky Boyd. [0:40:03] Yes. [0:40:04] Sean Verger. [0:40:05] Yes. [0:40:06] Chris Talkington. [0:40:07] Yes. [0:40:09] Greg Lanting. [0:40:10] Thank you Wendy. Next is another opportunity for general public input if there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council now is your [0:40:19] opportunity to come forward. Seeing no one clamoring to podium. Any advisory board reports from council members Travis anything from you? [0:40:33] So, Mr. Mayor members the council as you know this is a fairly busy week inside of the city of Twin Falls and so I just kind of want to go through a recap of the events that we [0:40:45] are looking at and then also not only for our benefit to kind of get those on the [0:40:54] calendars but also for those who may be watching and listening that are related [0:41:00] this week. So beginning on Friday we are going to have a series of community [0:41:07] events inside of the new city hall building. They'll begin at one o'clock and [0:41:12] And we anticipate those guided tours will end sometime around 3.45, [0:41:18] at which time then we will at 4 o'clock have an official ribbon cutting [0:41:23] and dedication for the public. [0:41:26] That's going to be in conjunction with the annual light parade. [0:41:31] This year the light parade, we're going to swap directions. [0:41:34] And it's going to start at Magic Valley High School, [0:41:37] and it's going to proceed, let's say, generally east, right? [0:41:42] And so it will travel and all of the floats and entrances will continue. [0:41:52] However, the fire truck will then turn on the newly refurbished Hanson Street. [0:41:58] And that will be led by a series of Twin Falls City employees and family members walking and guiding Santa in the big red fire truck where the council will be. [0:42:09] will be if that's where you want or you can walk beside us and then behind the [0:42:13] Times News is encouraging the members of the community who come and to the parade [0:42:19] to follow the fire truck in Santa to the corner of Maine and Hanson where we are [0:42:26] going to then be having the lighting of the city's Christmas tree and the [0:42:32] Christmas tree should be placed into the ground tomorrow and will be [0:42:38] already for the lighting and dedication of the Christmas tree to occur seven [0:42:43] o'clock ish and we use emphasis on the ish because sometimes parades can last [0:42:50] a little bit longer than anticipated but we're going to do what we can to kind [0:42:53] of marshal this one through so that's kind of the events that are going to [0:42:59] take place on Friday, and then on Saturday morning there are a series of events. We're [0:43:05] going to have the long anticipated ribbon cutting for the trail in conjunction with MavTech [0:43:13] and all of the partners who sponsored that event. And we're going to have that with the [0:43:18] Santa's, like it's a run event that's sponsored by MavTech. And so we would encourage you to [0:43:26] to come out and if you're so inclined to run the Santa [0:43:29] Run 5K, registration is still open and available. [0:43:33] So you can do that. [0:43:34] And then the event that we approved earlier this evening [0:43:39] on the consent calendar for the religious freedom rally [0:43:45] that's going to occur from 11 o'clock to noon. [0:43:48] So clearly a whole bunch of activities [0:43:51] are going to be occurring inside of our community. [0:43:53] a lot of them focusing on downtown and on main avenues. [0:43:56] So we would encourage you and the citizens to come [0:44:00] and participate in those events. [0:44:03] Travis? [0:44:03] Travis, what time is the map tech river, [0:44:07] the ribbon cutting at the trail? [0:44:09] Is it 930? [0:44:11] 930? [0:44:12] 930. [0:44:13] 930. [0:44:14] OK. [0:44:15] And the rotation is that the run will be at about 10. [0:44:17] OK. [0:44:18] Can I add on to that? [0:44:19] Also Saturday morning at 9 a.m. [0:44:22] at Twin Beans here on Main Street is another coffee with the cop opportunity so [0:44:27] anybody who would like to come visit with our police officers and have a cup of [0:44:30] coffee you have 20 minutes before you run down to the ribbon so so you can get [0:44:36] your caffeine you can cut a ribbon and then you can run in a race exactly what [0:44:41] a fun day and just for the council I forgot also Wednesday at Canyon Crest [0:44:46] is AIC's fall rally training here. So, if any of you are available for that, it's always [0:44:52] a good refresher on what we do and why we do it and to help encourage other cities who [0:44:57] maybe don't have the resources we do when they have questions that we can help them answer [0:45:01] as well. [0:45:02] City staff as well, any staff is invited as well. [0:45:05] So did we all get invites and they're just at the bottom of my email? [0:45:08] Yes. [0:45:09] Okay. [0:45:10] You did get an invite. [0:45:11] I would try to come if I can for my schedules. [0:45:13] I don't know if she can get it. [0:45:14] Yeah, so in and out, but I learned a lot last year. [0:45:19] I just have one question that I've been getting since I'm down town. [0:45:23] Is what are the parking rules during the parade? [0:45:26] Have that changed? [0:45:27] New Main Street? [0:45:29] Businesses are going to be open. [0:45:33] So we hope that businesses are going to be open and then one of the things that we're [0:45:37] doing this year and Craig could probably talk to this. [0:45:42] We are going to be very similar to what we do with the concert series where cars are kind [0:45:49] of encouraged to leave the main avenue parking area. [0:45:54] We will begin that process relatively early and I believe it's our intent to have vehicles [0:46:02] not be allowed to park on main avenue hours before the event and then we also are going [0:46:08] to be utilizing city resources to block main intersections so that vehicle traffic cannot [0:46:16] come into the parade route. [0:46:19] Well, Western days is an example of public clouds. [0:46:22] Oh, I'm sorry. [0:46:23] But the public lots will all be open and we're encouraging individuals to park in those parking [0:46:29] lot areas as well as on the side streets and then walk across the seconds. [0:46:39] Chris Reed. [0:46:40] I just wanted to thank city staff and also the council for approving the rally to celebrate religious freedom and encourage all [0:46:46] We're listening to join us that day. So, thank you [0:46:51] Ruth Pierce and now I have permission to speak I know a lot of the businesses are like they normally do during the [0:47:00] Parade or hot chocolate and you know whatever places to keep warm. Hope the weather's nice [0:47:06] I don't know if we call Brian [0:47:08] That'll work, and there was some other thing that was kind of new that I thought, everybody [0:47:16] out of, oh they're celebrating Main Street, I mean that's what we're all celebrating, so. [0:47:21] Anything else from anyone? [0:47:28] Next on the agenda then, we have no public hearing scheduled this evening, so next is adjournment [0:47:32] and we do have a request for an executive session under Idaho Code 7400-2061-C to acquire [0:47:39] an interest in real property, which is not owned by a public agency, Greg Lee. [0:47:43] Go ahead. [0:47:45] Second. [0:47:46] Motion by Greg Lansing, seconded by Nikki Boyd to adjourn into executive session as stated [0:47:56] as any discussion. [0:47:57] Sharon Roll, call both leaves. [0:48:05] Ruth Pears. [0:48:06] Yes. [0:48:07] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:48:08] Yes. [0:48:09] Nikki Boyd. [0:48:10] Yes. [0:48:11] Sean Berriger. [0:48:12] Yes. [0:48:13] Chris Talkington. [0:48:14] Yes. [0:48:15] Greg Lanting. [0:48:16] Yes. [0:48:17] Christopher Reed. [0:48:18] So we will adjourn into executive session. [0:48:21] We will not be reconvening the council meeting, nor will we be making any decisions in executive [0:48:27] session. [0:48:28] With that, we are adjourned.