Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-10-16, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-10-16/ [0:04:04] Are you guys ready? [0:04:05] Do I get one? [0:04:12] Good evening and welcome to the Twin Quality Council meeting for October 16, 2017. [0:04:21] First thing tonight is I would like to confirm that we do have a quorum of the council here [0:04:26] tonight. [0:04:27] And with that, we are going to now stand to say the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:04:31] If you'd like to join us, please feel free to do so. [0:04:33] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:04:57] Travis, are there any amendments to the agenda tonight? [0:05:03] Madam Vice Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments this evening. [0:05:06] Thank you. [0:05:07] Next on our agenda is time for proclamations and we do have two proclamations tonight. [0:05:13] I am going to read the first one, and I'm going to ask at the end of this for Max Newland to come up and receive this proclamation. [0:05:21] And the second one will have Councilwoman Ruth Pierce read for us tonight. [0:05:29] And this is an official proclamation for the City of Twin Falls from the Office of the Mayor for the bicentenary of the birth of Baja Bola. [0:05:38] Did I get it? [0:05:39] Okay, whereas the Baha'i community of Twin Falls, Idaho, was formally established in 2004, [0:05:48] and whereas in the 19th century, Baha'u'llah, the founder of the Baha'i faith, brought a [0:05:55] message of human dignity, capacity, and oneness suited to the requirements of contemporary [0:06:02] life and whereas on October 22nd, 2017 marks the 200th anniversary of the birth of Baha'u'u'llah [0:06:11] and whereas the Baha'i community of Twin Falls, Idaho works to eliminate all forms of prejudice [0:06:19] to develop and enhance the spiritual life of the human family and to demonstrate the value [0:06:24] of unity and diversity, and whereas Baha'is gather in Twin Falls are open to all, they [0:06:32] provide a social space for reflection and consultation to find areas of unity and collaboration [0:06:40] for achieving social good, and whereas the Baha'is of Twin Falls and their families, [0:06:46] friends, neighbors and colleagues are commemorating this bicentenary along with the Baha'is across [0:06:53] the United States and around the world. Now, therefore, Sean Berriger, the mayor of Twin [0:06:58] Falls, Idaho, does hereby declare Sunday, October 22, 2017, as the bicentenary of the [0:07:07] birth of Baha'olah in the city and urges all to resolve on this day to promote in themselves [0:07:15] and in their relations with others those qualities and attributes that will help bring about the [0:07:21] recognition of oneness of humanity to embrace diversity and to work for unity in [0:07:27] our local community in our country and in the world. We'll have Max Newland. [0:07:57] Thank you Vice Mayor and Council I appreciate this. We are also going to [0:08:11] plan a tree in the Harmon Park when tree planting season comes back around and we [0:08:18] are going to have a commenory dinner on Saturday, the 21st, at 630 at KMBTV, and you're all invited for that. [0:08:26] And I have some brochures I'd like to pass out to the commissioners. [0:08:30] Thank you. [0:08:31] Thank you. [0:08:42] Thank you. [0:08:44] Thanks Max. [0:08:55] The next proclamation will be read by our Councilwoman Ruth Pierce. [0:09:00] Thank you Suzanne. [0:09:00] So this is a proclamation for Breast Cancer Awareness Day. [0:09:04] Whereas every year too many Americans are touched by the pain and [0:09:08] hardship caused by breast cancer, and whereas breast cancer remains one of the leading causes [0:09:13] of cancer-related deaths among women, the City of Twin Falls proudly honors those who [0:09:19] have lost their lives to breast cancer and the courageous survivors who are still fighting [0:09:24] it. [0:09:25] And whereas October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, the City of Twin Falls with bold pink [0:09:30] ribbons and shirts displayed proudly throughout our community will stand with breast cancer [0:09:37] survivors and raise awareness in advancing research efforts. [0:09:41] Furthermore, we commit ourselves to support survivors, their loved ones, and organizations [0:09:46] that seek to forge a future future free from all cancer. [0:09:51] That's a mouthful. [0:09:52] Therefore, Sean Berriger, Mayor of Twin Falls, does hereby proclaim Thursday, October 20th [0:10:00] as Breast Cancer Awareness Day. [0:10:03] So I appreciate everybody that we're paying today, but you get to wear it again on Thursday. [0:10:08] He encourages citizens, government agencies, and private businesses, nonprofits, and all [0:10:14] of others to join in activities that increase awareness of breast cancer prevention. [0:10:20] And he signed it effective today. [0:10:24] Thank you, Ruth, for sharing that with us. [0:10:26] At this time, I believe it's appropriate to let Ruth keep this proclamation as she is a [0:10:30] a breast cancer survivor and we're all very glad to have her here. The City [0:10:35] Staff has been wonderful at supporting this proclamation in this issue as you [0:10:40] can see by the pink tonight and at this time I'd like to invite Battalion Chief [0:10:44] Mitchell Brooks to come up and say a few words. Good evening Vice Mayor and [0:10:51] Council. Thanks for allowing me the time to come up and say a few words. Fire [0:10:56] Department also echoes this proclamation and for the month of October we're [0:11:01] wearing pink uniforms, so you can see a lot about here. Some of the city leaderships wearing them as well. [0:11:09] Typically, we take a picture with fire department only in a fire truck with Ruth. [0:11:14] But today, we had the honor of taking a picture downtown on some of the new construction with Ruth [0:11:20] and many other city employees. So at this time, we'd like to present Ruth with one of our official [0:11:25] firefighter shirts, let's pink and dark pink over there. And also, we have a small picture [0:11:34] that we'd like to present to you as well. A small picture? Take it out to my car. You [0:12:18] No, I'm just kidding. [0:12:20] You didn't set up by the wherever. [0:12:21] Put it right there, yeah. [0:12:23] Perfect. [0:12:24] Oh, Chris, carry it. [0:12:25] So I just really want to thank the police department [0:12:29] and the fire department for all their support on this issue. [0:12:33] It's very heartwarming to see, and we [0:12:36] had a fire alarm at Chicago the other night, [0:12:41] and to see all the guys in their pink shirts. [0:12:43] And I really appreciate this, because now I [0:12:46] have something to wear on Thursday. [0:12:47] So thanks. [0:12:48] Thank you to everyone who participated in that today. [0:12:55] At this time, the next item on our agenda is general public input. [0:12:59] If there's anyone in the audience who would like to address the council on an issue that [0:13:03] is not on tonight's agenda, now is your opportunity. [0:13:07] Yep, you may come forward. [0:13:12] Please state your name and if you would keep your comments to three minutes if you can, [0:13:16] that would be wonderful. [0:13:17] Thank you, Vice Mayor and Council. [0:13:20] My name is Terri Edwards, I'm resident of Jerome, my own property and Twin Falls, and I'd just [0:13:26] like to remind everybody of the meeting tomorrow night at seven o'clock at the Herritt Center. [0:13:34] Mr. Tom DeWeese, the National Sustainability Expert and Property Rights Expert, will be speaking [0:13:41] on those subjects from seven until nine o'clock. [0:13:45] Tickets at the door are five dollars. [0:13:48] It looks like it's going to be pretty full and I think there's only room for 240. [0:13:52] So if you're planning on going, I'd suggest to get there a little bit earlier. [0:13:57] And the folks that weren't here, the council members that weren't here last week, I provided [0:14:02] Sharon with your ticket. [0:14:04] So if you decide to go, she should have those for you. [0:14:07] So thank you. [0:14:08] Thank you, Terry. [0:14:09] Appreciate your reminding us. [0:14:11] Is there anyone else who would like to address the council? [0:14:18] Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar. [0:14:22] Chris talking to. [0:14:23] No good approval is presented. [0:14:24] Second. [0:14:28] We have a motion from Chris talking to seconded by Nikki Boyd [0:14:31] to approve the consent calendar. [0:14:33] Is there any discussion? [0:14:36] Sharon roll call vote please. [0:14:43] Nikki Boyd yes. [0:14:45] Suzanne Hawkins yes. [0:14:48] Greg Lanting yes. [0:14:49] Ruth Pierce yes. [0:14:51] Christopher Reed yes. [0:14:52] Chris talking to yes. [0:14:54] Motion passes six to zero. [0:14:56] If there's anyone in the audience tonight waiting for approval on a special event, we [0:15:02] had a few the night time skies, gourd fest, trick or treat on bish street, voices against [0:15:07] violence, all of that was just approved in that vote. [0:15:12] You're welcome to stay and participate and listen to the rest of the meeting, but you're [0:15:15] also free to go if you'd like. [0:15:17] We'd love to have your stay. [0:15:27] So under items of consideration, the first item we have tonight is to recognize recently [0:15:33] promoted firefighter Jeff Miller to the rank of driver operator and driver operator Dave [0:15:39] Owens to the rank of captain and we have our battalion chiefs here and I'll let you guys [0:15:45] introduce yourself as you go through it. [0:15:47] Hello thank you Vice-Marron and council for letting us come and recognize our folks tonight. [0:15:52] My name is battalion chief, it's a funny name for a guy, I'm Ronna Geary. [0:15:57] So first of all I'd like to have Jeff Miller to be here, I'll read a little bit of stuff [0:16:05] about the rank of driver operator. [0:16:09] So Jeff started with the fire department on November 1st, 2011. [0:16:17] He achieved his firefighter level one certification on October 24th, 2012. [0:16:23] He became a Tender Attack Certified Driver on May 1st, 2013. [0:16:27] He achieved his firefighter level two certification on December 1st, 2016. [0:16:34] He became a certified relief driver, which means he was working in the capacity of the [0:16:38] driver in the absence of a driver on December 1, 2016. [0:16:44] He became an EMT basic certified firefighter, May 5, 2016, and he was recently promoted to [0:16:51] the rank of driver operator on October 4, 2017, congratulations Jeff. [0:16:57] So in order to achieve the rank of driver operator, a firefighter spends hundreds of [0:17:01] hours drilling, practicing, and studying, if the driver operator's essentials, which include [0:17:08] apparatus inspection and maintenance, theoretical pressure calculations, hydraulic calculations, [0:17:14] fire ground pumping, and fire pump theory, as well as local streets and maps, and a whole [0:17:21] host of training that we do on the very specific apparatus that we have in Twin Falls. [0:17:26] Now, in my opinion, one of the toughest parts of being a driver operator is the expectation [0:17:31] to be an expert on all five of those front line apparatus, [0:17:35] the ladder, the airport rescue apparatus, [0:17:39] and all other equipment that goes on those. [0:17:42] So these drivers, when you see them out there, [0:17:44] they're not just driving that truck. [0:17:46] They know everything there is to know about that. [0:17:48] When you see them work, and we've asked them [0:17:52] for something very specific, they are able to do it, [0:17:55] no problem. [0:17:58] So the one thing I like about the driver operator position, [0:18:02] And I'll tell anybody that asked me this. [0:18:04] It's the first opportunity to really kind of see what we do [0:18:08] from a big picture standpoint. [0:18:11] So if I paint a little picture for you as a hoseman, [0:18:14] they're usually on a hose line. [0:18:16] We'll just use a fire, for instance. [0:18:17] They're on a hose line. [0:18:18] They're being directed by their captain. [0:18:19] They're going to go into a house. [0:18:21] They're very specifically thinking about one thing [0:18:24] and nothing else except for what they're being told [0:18:26] and what's right directly in front of them. [0:18:29] And that, of course, includes all the safety aspects. [0:18:32] Now as a driver operator, I think it's very important that those guys, they're outside, [0:18:35] they get to see the big picture, they get to see what the battalion she sees, what the safety [0:18:39] officer sees, and they're in a position where they need to start anticipating the needs of [0:18:44] those engine company crews. [0:18:46] So based on what they're seeing, the activity of the fire, the color of the smoke, everything [0:18:51] that's going on, they're in a position to anticipate the needs that they're going to be asked for, [0:18:56] and every really good driver that we have is able to do that. [0:19:01] They have it in place before it's ever even asked for, and I'm sure Jeff is going to be [0:19:04] one of those guys. [0:19:05] So what we'd like to do now is we'd like to pin Jeff's collar pins on him, and I'm going [0:19:09] to ask him to cut him up and pin his collar pins on and the pain sheet brooks to pin his, [0:19:14] um, I used to camp camp. [0:19:21] So that's really tough to do on a white shirt because you usually have little red spots [0:20:09] everywhere once you get to poke those pins through. [0:20:34] Nice. [0:20:35] Thank you, Jeff, and congratulations. [0:20:36] Next week we'd like to congratulate Captain Dave Owens with the Twin Falls Fire Department. [0:20:48] Okay, so Dave started with the Twin Falls Fire Department on April 2nd, 2007. [0:21:04] He became a Tender Attack Certified Driver on August 6th, 2007, a Relief Driver October [0:21:10] 1st, 2007, and achieved Firefighter 1 certification on March 1st, 2008. [0:21:17] firefighter to October 1, 2010, firefighter 3, October 1, 2014, fire officer 1, certified [0:21:25] September 9, 2016. He was promoted to the rank of driver operator June 8, 2015. He achieved [0:21:33] his EMT basic certification May 2, 2016. Now, I can spend the next 30 minutes going over [0:21:41] what it takes to be a captain, but I think what I've decided to do instead, I have it [0:21:46] all written down here. So I wanted to talk a little bit about the process on how you become [0:21:52] a fire captain. And I mean specifically the promotional process. Here recently we've gone [0:21:58] to a new assessment style of promotions that we had lots of help from many in the department [0:22:05] and throughout actually the state of Idaho. So we asked three chiefs from southern Idaho [0:22:11] and the state of Idaho to come in and do a tactical assessment. [0:22:15] And what happens there is these guys were given a tactical scenario that was put up on [0:22:21] a screen and they had to walk through that tactical scenario and how they would handle [0:22:24] the scene. [0:22:25] Now we had five applicants that went through that. [0:22:28] And we got kudos from every single chief on the quality of applicants that we had, okay. [0:22:34] One of the other things that they did was they interviewed with a peer group which consisted [0:22:37] of members of all different departments around the city. [0:22:41] And again, we heard the same thing. [0:22:43] The quality of applicants that we had was just amazing. [0:22:47] They also participated in a written test, which covered all [0:22:50] of the things that they should know as a fire captain. [0:22:52] And in basket exercise, which shows us [0:22:55] that they can prioritize their day. [0:22:58] And also a command staff interview. [0:23:02] Again, I'd like to say we had five very qualified applicants [0:23:05] and Dave actually tested number one. [0:23:08] he come out on top. [0:23:09] So the position of fire captain demands more time, [0:23:14] more commitment, and more sacrifice [0:23:16] than any position that Dave has held up to this point. [0:23:19] We understand that really well. [0:23:21] Our families understand that really well. [0:23:24] So I know Melissa, and I've known her since Dave's worked [0:23:27] for the fire department, and I know that she supports Dave [0:23:30] 100%, I know his boys do, right? [0:23:33] I don't know of a single fire captain [0:23:35] that hasn't been successful without the support of his family. [0:23:39] So we've actually asked Melissa to come up [0:23:41] and pin the collar pins on Dave [0:23:43] from a family gesture standpoint. [0:23:45] So I've got to do somewhere. [0:23:48] I hope that's a monster. [0:24:10] So again, in the fire captain rank, [0:24:15] the engine company officer, which is the captain, [0:24:17] he's the go-to guy on the engine, right? [0:24:20] So any life and death, life safety, decisions that are made, [0:24:26] it comes from him. [0:24:27] It comes from him. [0:24:28] Any leadership, decisions that, or any leadership items [0:24:31] that are, that are, that are, that are, that are, that are, [0:24:35] that are, that are, that are, that are, that are, that are. [0:24:36] It's his job to make sure that those guys go home safe [0:24:39] every night. [0:24:40] So it's a very important position. [0:24:42] And Dave, I know, will take it very seriously [0:24:45] and do a great job. [0:24:46] So now I'm going to take the opportunity [0:24:48] to pin this badge on, because Dave actually comes to my shift. [0:24:51] he's going to be the captain at this point at station three, so we have a way of doing this. [0:24:58] We just like this. [0:24:59] Yeah, I guess they're a tangent. [0:25:02] Could we look, please? [0:25:22] Hang on. [0:25:23] Oh, the council's coming down with me to get his picture. [0:25:31] Well, hello. [0:25:32] Yes. [0:25:47] Thank you. [0:25:59] Paul wins and thank you. [0:26:00] Oh, thank you. [0:26:01] Can you see anything for us back here? [0:26:42] Great. [0:26:43] Great planting. [0:26:44] Well, I'd like to congratulate both on their new positions, but I also like to thank [0:26:47] Thank the fire department and our fire Marshall for the open houses. They have the other night [0:26:54] I guess you probably had some excitement. I think he had a fire in the middle of the second one [0:27:00] But really well attended. I couldn't believe how many people there and how many kids were there there were a lot of children [0:27:05] Came to the thing and I see dandy lair's he was Sparky [0:27:09] Thank you for doing that for our community and I think a lot of people got it some good [0:27:19] information and had a good time at the same time. [0:27:23] It was very well done. [0:27:24] Thank you. [0:27:25] Thank you gentlemen for everything tonight. [0:27:32] The next item on our agenda is an update on our main avenue project and I believe we [0:27:37] We have Perin Robinson tonight to give us an update on what's happening. [0:27:41] Her goals are a audience. [0:27:43] Don't take it personal. [0:27:46] Well thank you Vice Mayor, Council members. [0:27:52] I am here to provide an update on that main avenue project that is progressing along very nicely and I hope you will agree in that assessment that they continue to make good progress out there. [0:28:01] We do have Rob with Guho in the audience as well to answer any detailed questions that you may have. [0:28:06] So, just a quick update. [0:28:09] As you may now know, this section from Shoshone to Hanson has been re-opened to traffic, and [0:28:16] so that's being utilized, and folks are able to park and get access directly now back to [0:28:21] those businesses and stores there. [0:28:24] So landscaping is in, as you can see, the brick pavers are in. [0:28:28] We are going to put some of those wheel stops, concrete wheel stops in this stretch as well [0:28:34] as we had done on the other side, kind of as we had done it just to kind of check out to [0:28:38] see the response and it improved the parking situation. So we're going to do that on this [0:28:43] side as well. So engraved brick pavers have all been installed. Hopefully you've had an [0:28:50] opportunity to walk by and see those. There's a very nice, again, it's going along, going [0:28:57] along very well in this stretch. Hands in the Idaho sidewalks have been poured, brick pavers [0:29:03] are being installed, the road base is ready for asphalt pavement which is scheduled for [0:29:09] Thursday, so asphalt will be going in. This stretch is going to be open up to traffic [0:29:14] by next Friday, so we're getting very close on this block as well. And then Idaho to Jerome [0:29:22] finishing up some insulation of some underground electric conduit, starting to put in the road [0:29:28] base sidewalks are prepared for sidewalks so that ones come along very well as well. [0:29:36] So this paving for this Idaho to Jerome section is we're looking at middle of November at [0:29:44] this point. [0:29:45] There were a few little setbacks because of some weather that came through and then also [0:29:48] it hit some rock actually in this stretch here. [0:29:51] So during the installation of some storm drain inputs. [0:29:54] So that wasn't anticipated, but they've overcome it, [0:29:57] but there was a little bit of impact there. [0:29:59] But anyway, paving in this stretch schedule [0:30:01] for like I say, mid-November, [0:30:03] within the entire main avenue being open [0:30:06] by the end of November. [0:30:09] So again, things are going quite a plan very smoothly. [0:30:12] Wonderful. [0:30:13] Who's talking to them? [0:30:14] A couple of questions. [0:30:15] I'm not sure if this is within your contract, [0:30:17] but Hanson Street in front of City Hall, [0:30:20] is that part of the Plaza Project? [0:30:22] That's not under your purview then correct, but I see that they're doing Hanson back to the second [0:30:29] They got that asphalt a half way back [0:30:38] Cars are able to go on Hanson [0:30:40] They are and the other question I've had from a couple people I walked out a couple times a week and [0:30:45] And some of the people I've surprisingly not aware of, the interface between the end of the [0:30:51] city right away, the sidewalk and interface with the building is that unfinished portion. [0:30:56] Exactly how does a business owner go about assuming they can either contract somebody to finish it for them [0:31:05] or do it themselves as a protocol for that? [0:31:08] A protocol, per se. [0:31:14] It would be on private property. [0:31:16] I mean, I'm talking about some brick [0:31:17] that's fallen off the face of things of that nature, [0:31:20] but it's not always a tight interface. [0:31:27] We are recording and live streaming, [0:31:29] so that's why we have you come to the microphone, [0:31:31] and thank you. [0:31:33] Thank you. [0:31:34] It's our intention to go back [0:31:35] in anything that we damaged, [0:31:42] really focusing on getting the bulk of the work [0:31:46] of those issues as they come. [0:31:48] We started some in front of the Crowley building. [0:31:51] That's the most other areas, but the brokers. [0:31:53] Probably the time consuming minutia part of the work. [0:31:56] Yes. [0:31:57] Yeah. [0:31:58] So that is on our agenda to go back and fix [0:32:00] some of those areas that have been damaged and constructed. [0:32:03] Thank you. [0:32:04] Thank you very much. [0:32:06] Nicki Boyd? [0:32:08] Yes. [0:32:08] You said he ran into rock. [0:32:11] Did that affect our budget at all, our cost? [0:32:13] No, not did not affect the cost, just a little bit [0:32:16] of an impact, a scheduled impact, but actually [0:32:20] they did a very good job of it. [0:32:21] Good. [0:32:22] Because I know running into rock can be, you know. [0:32:24] The rock clause. [0:32:26] All kind of issues for everybody. [0:32:28] So thank you very much. [0:32:31] We have any other questions? [0:32:33] Thank you very much for the update. [0:32:35] We always appreciate the information. [0:32:38] And under budget, right? [0:32:40] Oh. [0:32:41] Oh. [0:32:45] The next item on our agenda is a request [0:32:47] to award a bid to Rosenbauer for a new airport fire [0:32:52] truck in the amount of $640,172.16 under FAAAIP grant number 40 and we have Bill Carberry [0:33:02] from our airport tonight. [0:33:03] Thank you, Vice-Merigee. Good evening, council members. Well, the airport fire truck that [0:33:10] we have out there now was purchased in 1996 or about 2,122 years into its life and under [0:33:18] direction of the FAA it's really about time that we replace that and it probably [0:33:23] is good to draw a line at some point. So with the old truck, assuming we accept [0:33:29] this bid and move forward, we'd like to keep the old truck in after consulting [0:33:32] with the fire department as a ready reserve that we have in case we need it [0:33:37] for if anything happened or if one was down for maintenance. So I think there's [0:33:41] certainly some useful life in this truck so it'll be a nice ready reserve. So in [0:33:46] In August, we opened bids August 16th, we received two bids, one from Oshkosh for a [0:33:53] fire truck for $641,434.62, and Rosenbauer of Minnesota submitted a bid of $640,172.16. [0:34:06] Roughly a $1,200 difference between the two bids, so they were very, very close. [0:34:11] The low bid was Rosenbauer, about 7% below the engineer's estimate of $689,000. [0:34:19] I want to thank the Fire Department for their help in specking the truck. [0:34:23] They've been involved ever since. [0:34:25] Talking with them, they're comfortable with the low bid with Rosenbauer and [0:34:30] their equipment, I'd like to show you a picture of the truck here. [0:34:35] It's not the best resolution there, but these modern trucks look kind of sleek and [0:34:39] a lot of cab visibility and lots of other things. [0:34:43] I'm sure the firefighters could tell you about, [0:34:45] but it should be a very capable piece of equipment [0:34:48] for us out there well into the future. [0:34:51] So we have the grant money for the truck. [0:34:55] AIP-40 was awarded and is awarded by the city and county [0:34:58] back in August. [0:35:00] As they were closing out business, [0:35:01] they awarded us that grant based on this bid estimate, [0:35:04] which did come in within our budget. [0:35:08] So the match we have in our funds, 6.25%, [0:35:12] this is 93.75% fairly funded with the small match of 6.40%. [0:35:20] So with that, staff would recommend Council approve the request [0:35:23] to award the bid and contract to Rosenbauer for $640,172.16, [0:35:30] and authorize the mayor to sign the notice of award in contract. [0:35:34] With that, I'd take any questions that you might have. [0:35:37] Great, great, great. [0:35:39] Just Bill, remind me, our older truck is an Oshkosh. [0:35:44] It is. [0:35:45] Okay, well the difference between the two trucks be a problem for training with the fire department [0:35:51] or are they similar enough that once they get out and play with them, they'll be good to go. [0:35:56] As intimate as they get with the equipment, I think it would just be a matter of time, but I could [0:36:02] We'll hold the firm and let it all figure out what's mixing the drinks now, so I'm kidding. [0:36:09] Now speaking with them, I thought I'd let them speak for themselves, but they're not back there. [0:36:13] Yes, they've told me they have no problem with the equipment. [0:36:16] I think some of their engines now have a Rosenbauer frame, so these guys know all the nuances [0:36:21] and they were very comfortable with Rosenbauer as the low-bed equipment they would provide. [0:36:25] So I think it would just be a matter of time before they're up to speed. [0:36:29] I'm sure they'll have a roll out process where they'll want everybody to be trained on this before they. It's the first line [0:36:38] And we have a follow-up question [0:36:40] Well, I noticed there was no bit on the auxiliary equipment. What is that and what how what do we either do about the auxiliary equipment? [0:36:46] It's something I'm working with our consultant. It's all the gloves. It's the [0:36:52] The equipment the air tanks the uniforms all those kinds of things [0:36:56] We had to move very, very quickly to bid this and the equipment. [0:37:02] We gave them two weeks to give us a number on the truck. [0:37:05] That was actually a lot more work in putting together a bid for all of those 63 items in the equipment list. [0:37:12] So unfortunately we rebid it again recently and also got no bid on that. [0:37:17] So we're working on the third round of trying to get a bidder for the equipment. [0:37:22] I believe if you go three rounds without any bids for the equipment you can go and negotiate [0:37:27] So we hope we don't have to take that step, but I'll be back to the council [0:37:31] With the results of our attempts in the near future [0:37:36] Thank you bill Nicky Boyd bill in with this old piece of equipment [0:37:41] It was determined that our highest [0:37:43] Investes was to keep it here and have it as a good backup was selling it and [0:37:47] And recouping some money there, one of the things that was explored. [0:37:53] It was. [0:37:54] It was considered, and I think the feeling was that the benefit of having that piece of equipment [0:37:59] outweighed any revenue we would get on the used market. [0:38:03] Okay, and then on that auxiliary list, it sounds like there's a lot of things on that. [0:38:10] We don't have that yet. [0:38:12] This is all functional and usable if we don't have that other thing, those other things? [0:38:17] No, it won't. This truck won't be functional without all the auxiliary equipment. [0:38:21] We, this truck, we're giving the manufacturer a year to deliver it. [0:38:25] That usually is a much quicker turnover time on the incidental equipment items. [0:38:29] So we're certainly looking to have all those items here and in our possession by the time the truck gets done. [0:38:35] And that wasn't part of the budget that you turned in for fiscal year 18. [0:38:41] This is separate from that. [0:38:43] The money for the equipment is also in the grants as well. [0:38:46] Okay, all right. Yeah, the grant will be usable for a few years. Awesome. Thank you [0:38:53] Chris talkington [0:38:54] I'm real proud of the airport situation down with the new expanded [0:38:58] Terminal and getting ready to move a lot of dirt on the new taxiways under that another four million [0:39:04] Contract between the two grants. I believe we [0:39:08] Garnet about four and a half million dollars and as such I would like to [0:39:11] to move to award the bid to Rosenbauer for a new airport fire truck in the amount of $640,172.16 [0:39:21] under the FAA Grant-40. [0:39:24] I'll second that. [0:39:27] We have a motion from Chris Talkington, seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept or to award the to [0:39:34] approve the award of the bid for the new airport fire truck. [0:39:38] Is there any other questions or discussion? [0:39:42] Chair and roll call vote please. [0:39:51] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:39:52] Yes. [0:39:53] Greg Lanting. [0:39:54] Yes. [0:39:55] Ruth Pears. [0:39:55] Yes. [0:39:56] Christopher Reed. [0:39:57] Yes. [0:39:58] Chris Tockington. [0:39:59] Yes. [0:39:59] Nikki Boyd. [0:40:00] Yes. [0:40:02] Motion passes. [0:40:03] 6 to 0. [0:40:04] Thank you. [0:40:05] Thank you Bill. [0:40:05] Thank you Bill. [0:40:08] Go ahead, Greg. [0:40:08] It asked me to vote twice. [0:40:10] I voted twice so I didn't. [0:40:12] Is it all right? [0:40:14] Thank you. [0:40:15] Just wanted to be sure. [0:40:17] Kind of crazy. [0:40:18] Kind of crazy. [0:40:20] The next item on our agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance for annexation with the [0:40:29] zoning designation of R2 for 2.19 acres located at 491 Canyon Rim Road and we have Renee Caraway [0:40:38] Johnson tonight. [0:40:39] Good afternoon Vice Mayor Hopkins and council members. [0:40:43] I'm actually here this evening to present your request for two ordinances to be adopted. [0:40:49] The first one is a request to consider in order to annex about two acres on the canyon [0:40:56] rim. [0:40:57] On April 25th, the commission held a public hearing on this request. [0:41:02] Presentations were given by the applicants' representatives and by staff. [0:41:06] Public hearing was opened and no one spoke at this hearing. [0:41:10] Upon conclusion of the presentations, the public hearing and deliberations, Commissioner [0:41:15] gray made in motion to recommend the existing zoning of R2 as an appropriate zoning designation [0:41:22] as presented and subject to one condition. That condition is subject to a 15-foot wide [0:41:28] public access easement to be located adjacent to the Snake River Canyon rim being recorded [0:41:34] prior to the annexation ornaments being approved by council, location of the 15-foot easement [0:41:41] to be determined by city staff. [0:41:43] And I do have just for the benefit of both you and the audience. [0:41:50] This is the property in question. [0:42:02] There's the Canyon Rim on the east side of the property. [0:42:05] And so there is a trail system on the south side of this property [0:42:09] that goes up and around. [0:42:11] And that is the easement that we're talking about in this condition. [0:42:16] Commissioner Musser did second that condition. [0:42:18] and all members of the commission did vote in favor of the motion. [0:42:22] On May 30th, 2017, the City Council held a public hearing on this request. [0:42:27] Presentations were given by the applicants representative and by staff. [0:42:31] The public hearing was opened and Brian Lancaster, director of the Twin Falls Highway District, [0:42:36] stated he had concerns regarding the trail and barriers. [0:42:39] The applicants engineer addressed those concerns and the public hearing was closed. [0:42:46] Upon conclusion of the public hearing and council deliberations, [0:42:49] council member Talkington made a motion to annex the 2.19 plus or minus acres as presented, [0:42:55] subject to the following two conditions, one subject to the 15 foot wide access easements [0:43:04] going through the process and being determined by staff. [0:43:08] That access easement was recorded October 2nd and was approved by city staff. [0:43:13] The second condition is subject to a warranty deed [0:43:16] for the entire property being proposed for annexation [0:43:19] provided prior to the adoption of this ordinance. [0:43:22] That was also verified by engineering staff on October 3rd. [0:43:27] Commissioner Boyd did second the motion [0:43:29] that was made by Council Member Talkington. [0:43:32] Roll call vote showed all members present [0:43:34] in favor of the motion. [0:43:36] The motion was approved 7-2-0. [0:43:39] As directed by Council staff is prepared an ordinance [0:43:42] for your consideration, which is in your packets. [0:43:44] Staff recommends the council adopt the ordinance [0:43:47] by third and final reading. [0:43:49] Upon adoption of this ordinance, [0:43:51] it may be published and the property will then be annexed. [0:43:55] Thank you. [0:43:56] Do we have any questions for Renee? [0:43:59] Sharon, do we have an ordinance number? [0:44:02] Ordinance 2017-25. [0:44:08] If there's no questions, [0:44:09] I would stand for a motion. [0:44:10] Greg, 19. [0:44:11] Vice Mayor, I move that we placed Ordinance 2017-25 on 3rd and final by title only by U.C. [0:44:22] You see the suspension of the rules. [0:44:28] Second. [0:44:31] We have a motion from Greg Lantine, seconded by Nikki Boyd to place Ordinance number 2017-25 [0:44:40] on 3rd and final by title only. [0:44:42] Is there any questions? [0:44:45] Chair and roll call vote. [0:44:48] Reg Lanting. [0:44:49] Yes. [0:44:49] Reg Pears. [0:44:50] Yes. [0:44:51] Christopher Reed. [0:44:52] Yes. [0:44:53] Chris Hockington. [0:44:54] Yes. [0:44:55] Nikki Boyd. [0:44:56] Yes. [0:44:57] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:44:58] Yes. [0:44:59] Motion passes six to zero. [0:45:00] Sharon, could you read the title, please? [0:45:03] Ordinance number 2017-25, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, [0:45:11] annexing certain rail property below described, providing the zoning classification, therefore [0:45:17] for and ordering the necessary area of impact [0:45:23] and zoning district map amendment. [0:45:26] Thank you. [0:45:28] You pass it to 2017-25. [0:45:31] So you get it. [0:45:32] We have a motion from Chris Stockington, [0:45:34] seconded by Greg Lanting to approve Ordinance 2017-25. [0:45:39] And I see no lights, so we'll call vote please. [0:45:55] Ruth Pierce. [0:45:56] Yes. [0:45:57] Chris Reed. [0:45:58] Yes. [0:45:58] Chris Stockington. [0:45:59] Yes. [0:46:00] Yes, this is Ann Hawkins. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes. Motion passes six to zero. [0:46:06] Thank you, Renee, and we'll let you just keep going. Okay. Thank you. The second ordinance is to vacate a [0:46:15] condensed plant that was approved back several years ago. There was a desire to [0:46:20] remove that plant so that they could build on this property under the same [0:46:25] ownership. So with that I will give you the history. On August 22nd 2017 the [0:46:31] Commission held a public hearing on this request. Presentations were given by the [0:46:35] applicants representative and my staff. Public hearing was open and there is no [0:46:39] one that spoke at the public hearing. Upon conclusion, Commissioner Higgly made [0:46:44] a motion to recommend approval of the request as subject, as presented [0:46:48] subject to the following conditions. There were three conditions placed on [0:46:53] this motion, the motion, the commissioner Munio seconded that motion and all members present [0:46:59] voted in favor of that motion. On September 18th 2017 the city council held a public hearing [0:47:06] on this request. Presentations were given by the applicants representatives and by staff. [0:47:11] Public hearing was opened and again there was no public comment. Commissioner Boyd made [0:47:15] a motion to vacate the garner and subdivision as presented subject to the three conditions [0:47:20] as recommended by the Commission, Commission, and the Council Member Lanting [0:47:25] seconded that motion. Roll call vote showed all members present in favor of the [0:47:29] motion. It was approved six to zero. So upon conclusion as directed by the Council, [0:47:34] staff has declared an ordinance for your consideration, which is in your packets. [0:47:39] Staff recommends that Council adopt the ordinance by a third and final reading [0:47:43] upon adoption of the ordinance that may be published and the property shall then [0:47:47] Thank you Renee. I'm assuming Sharon this is 2017-26. Yes. Okay. Hickey Boyd. I move that [0:47:58] we suspend the rules and place ordinance number 2017-26 on third and final reading by title [0:48:05] only. Second. We have a motion from Nikki Boyd seconded by Ruth Pierce to place ordinance [0:48:13] 2017-26 on third and final by title only. [0:48:18] Does anyone have any discussion or questions? [0:48:21] Sharon roll call vote please. [0:48:24] Ruth Pierce. [0:48:25] Yes. [0:48:26] Christopher Reed. [0:48:27] Yes. [0:48:28] Chris Talkington. [0:48:32] Nicky Boyd. [0:48:33] Yes. [0:48:34] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:48:35] Yes. [0:48:36] Greg Lanten. [0:48:37] Yes. [0:48:38] Motion passes 6-0. [0:48:39] Sharon, could you read the title please? [0:48:43] Ordinance number 2017-26. [0:48:47] ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating [0:48:52] the subdivision described below. [0:48:54] Thank you. [0:48:57] Chris Reed. [0:48:58] I move that we approve ordinance 2017-26. [0:49:04] We have a motion from Christopher Reed, seconded by grade landing to approve ordinance number [0:49:09] 2017-26. [0:49:11] And I see no lights. [0:49:13] Roll call, vote please. [0:49:20] Christopher Reed. [0:49:21] Yes. [0:49:22] Hockington, Lickie Boy, Suzanne Hawkins, Greg Lanting, Ruth Pierce, motion passes six to [0:49:31] zero. [0:49:32] Thank you very much Renee, I'm not trying to not look at you, I'm trying to hit all [0:49:37] the right buttons on this iPad while we're going. [0:49:42] It's a learning process. [0:49:46] The next item on our agenda is a request to approve a joint application with CSI's [0:49:51] to I.T.D. for the 53-11 funds for public transportation and I believe Mandy Thompson is going to take [0:50:00] the lead on this issue. [0:50:01] Good evening, Vice Mayor Council. I appreciate your time tonight. So without going into a whole [0:50:15] lot of detail over the past four years of discussions over transportation since I've been at the [0:50:21] city, we'll go back a little bit. I'll just briefly cover the staff report for the next [0:50:27] some background, but currently transfer buses is provided [0:50:32] continuous transportation services in Twin Falls since 1979. [0:50:37] They provide scheduled demand response service to the citizens [0:50:41] at a very low cost rate. [0:50:43] They target those who cannot provide their own transportation, [0:50:46] whether it's because of a physical or mental disability. [0:50:51] They're a senior citizen, low income or just general public. [0:50:56] No one there's no one that is not able to use the service, [0:51:00] it is truly public transportation. [0:51:02] All of the transformers equipment is wheelchair lift equipped [0:51:05] and we solve the ADA requirements. [0:51:08] If you recall last summer, we went through a process [0:51:10] in which we commissioned a study, [0:51:13] a transit development study that took a look at our first steps, [0:51:18] some of our first steps that Twin Falls needs to take [0:51:21] as we continued the discussion on public transportation. [0:51:24] The study recognizes the distinct challenges that we have in Twin Falls. [0:51:29] I still continue to call this role, but here in a few, probably a matter of a few years, the [0:51:35] federal government will look at it as small urban, and when that designation comes, likely [0:51:41] following the 2020 Census, there will be some requirements of the City of Twin Falls, one [0:51:46] of which is that we have to take a look at public transportation as a city-provided service. [0:51:51] not required to offer a fixed route system, we can really kind of design whatever it is [0:51:57] that we would like, but the reality is that that day will come where we have to start budgeting [0:52:05] for public transportation through our city budgeting process. [0:52:09] One of the things that the transit development study recommended was that we not look at [0:52:15] a fixed route immediately, but that we look at the partnership that we have with Transfer [0:52:19] and how are some of the ways that we can better utilize the service as public transportation [0:52:23] now as we kind of take those steps towards providing it as a city service in the future. [0:52:31] Another recommendation was also that potentially that we could look at working with some of [0:52:36] the larger employers in the community for some sort of transportation for workers that [0:52:44] are coming in to, to involves from the outer line communities, again trying to address transportation [0:52:49] needs, but also some of the congestion issues that we experience on a daily basis when people [0:52:54] come into City of Twin Falls to work. [0:52:57] So with that background, several months ago, Travis Rothweiler and myself met with Jack [0:53:05] Harmon with CSI and Lynne Baird with Transport, and what they asked of us from the city is [0:53:12] that we consider doing a joint application of their 5311 funds. [0:53:18] The 5311 funds are the funds that are federal funds that are passed through the state I.T.D. [0:53:25] I died at the Department of Transportation for public transportation in the state of Idaho. [0:53:31] And in the past it's been a sole application by transfer and they've received those funds [0:53:36] in order to operate the demand response service. [0:53:39] And one of the things that transfer, and I will, Lynn obviously can come up and speak to any great detail. [0:53:45] But one of the difficulties they've had in the past several years is that a lot of their [0:53:50] sources for matching funds that they're required to provide for their 53-11 funding has dried [0:53:57] up. [0:53:58] And they, if you recall, every year, when comes to the City of Twin Falls through the [0:54:02] AMPOG process to ask for funding that is used for match for these 53-11 federal funds. [0:54:09] typically asks for between $50,000 and $60,000 and through that [0:54:13] M-Pod process, we usually, I think the most that we've awarded in [0:54:17] recent years is $25,000. They always are very appreciative of the [0:54:22] funding that we give them, but it is always woefully short of what [0:54:25] they need. At this point, they're starting to, they're no longer [0:54:31] able to break even because of, like I said, some of those [0:54:34] matching funds that are no longer available. Additionally, the [0:54:39] The last go around, these are two year funding cycles and we're in the second year of the [0:54:44] current funding cycle. [0:54:45] So these requests will be for 2019 and 2020. [0:54:49] The previous funding cycle, Twin Falls, will transform into City of Twin Falls, they actually [0:54:57] had a decrease on the amount of funding that they were awarded by about $101,000. [0:55:02] that was because at the time, the public transportation office through ITD was putting [0:55:09] more emphasis on fixed-rep systems. And because transport is not operating fixed-rep system, [0:55:15] we were not given preferential consideration during that funding cycle. [0:55:20] And Linna said that even if we had gotten the 505,000 that he had applied for, he's not [0:55:24] sure he could have accepted the full amount because they did not have to match. So based [0:55:29] some of the conversations that we had earlier this summer [0:55:31] about doing a joint application, I am here tonight, [0:55:35] to ask the council to consider allowing the city [0:55:39] to jointly apply with transfer for this next funding cycle. [0:55:44] But that does involve committing $45,000 [0:55:49] each of those two subsequent years to public transportation. [0:55:54] So I'm not really sure if you want to have some specific [0:55:58] questions for Lynn or Jeff, or where we go in this conversation. [0:56:04] We're gonna let Travis weigh in first [0:56:06] and then we will go to questions. [0:56:09] I'm just here to answer any questions. [0:56:10] Okay, I'm just backing up, Mandy. [0:56:14] So I'm gonna go ahead and jump in [0:56:15] with the first question real quick [0:56:17] and where in our budget are we going [0:56:18] to pull this $45,000? [0:56:21] So, at this point in time, [0:56:25] the way I'm understanding it is for 19 and 20 commitment. [0:56:29] Okay, so we have different. [0:56:31] So what you're doing, so the application process has a significant lead time over the time [0:56:38] in which the funds are actually owed and due as a part of that process, and but Mandy needs [0:56:43] to have the commitment on the front end. [0:56:45] And so what you're doing is you're committing FY19 funds to be included into the budget. [0:56:52] So we're about ready to, we just started FY18. [0:56:56] So this council will do is that they will then instruct staff and will start that process at [0:57:01] our long-term planning process that we will allocate $45,000 to support the joint application [0:57:08] that the city has entered into should you do that this evening. [0:57:11] Thank you. [0:57:12] I have another question but I'm going to let the rest of the council wait first. [0:57:15] Chris talking to you. [0:57:16] Well, yeah. [0:57:17] And just so I can answer questions, taxpayers are going to ask them roughly doubling the [0:57:22] amount that the city might be committing, that extra $20,000 would go directly toward [0:57:29] support of personnel, new equipment, Lynn, could you kind of help give us a little bit [0:57:40] of explanation of how it will be utilized? [0:57:44] So, I mean, we get the $25,000 from our grant, we project a loss this year, somewhere between [0:57:53] $15,000 to $15,000 on the service. [0:57:56] If we have the application, I applied for about another $25,000 each year for the upcoming [0:58:07] two years. [0:58:09] And with that, that would increase our loss in probably the $25,000 to $30,000 to $40,000 [0:58:15] range. [0:58:16] And this would help offset some of that. [0:58:18] We still would have had the lost building that we have now, [0:58:23] but that would offset the additional loss [0:58:25] from the additional money that we may or may not get from I.T.D. [0:58:30] I mean, you're not pointing your losses at our reserves. [0:58:33] You would be faced with cutting back potential employment [0:58:36] and bus service, would you not? [0:58:37] So far, we've been able to put on our reserves, [0:58:40] but that's a short-term thing, rather than a long-term deal. [0:58:44] Yeah. [0:58:46] Thank you. [0:58:46] Chris Reed. [0:58:47] I remember during the M-HOG when we kind of talked a little bit about the service. [0:58:53] Can you just speak to how it's being utilized, how many citizens of Twin Falls use this, and [0:59:00] the benefit that it is to the city? [0:59:02] Well, it's available. [0:59:04] By federal law, it has to be available equally to anybody that asks for it. [0:59:09] You can't really give preference for the guy that's going to dialysis, but we definitely [0:59:15] and try to provide that, and we provide that. [0:59:20] We provide a lot of the wheelchair transportation [0:59:23] for this area. [0:59:24] There are not many other transportation providers [0:59:29] that have that available. [0:59:31] And we have our people trained to handle those [0:59:34] in a safe manner, and that. [0:59:36] And then a lot, probably, 47% of it [0:59:42] is handicapped people, either physically [0:59:45] or mentally handicapped, and then another large portion [0:59:50] of senior citizens. [0:59:52] And with the senior citizens, they take people [0:59:54] to the senior center, and we take them [0:59:56] to the doctor's appointments, too. [1:00:00] And I would say the majority of our service, [1:00:02] the seniors probably are for medical transportation. [1:00:06] And also, so they get a chance to go, you know, [1:00:09] once you can't drive, you can't drive [1:00:11] to the shopping center anymore. [1:00:13] And we do a lot of that taking people that. [1:00:15] Or if it's just a lady that needs to go get her air done. [1:00:18] That's really important. [1:00:19] It is. [1:00:20] I have a question to me. [1:00:23] Chris, are you going to go ahead? [1:00:24] You sure can. [1:00:25] How many buses do you have? [1:00:28] How many people do you service? [1:00:29] We actually have 13 buses, and we have about 10 of them [1:00:36] on the road each day. [1:00:38] The other two are older, and use those for backup. [1:00:42] And how many people would you service in, say, a week's time? [1:00:46] You know, that varies, but I would say that probably was around 30,000 last year in the [1:00:55] five-day work week, probably a hundred a day. [1:01:00] Thank you. [1:01:01] And what way it works is if the office on aging gives us some money that helps first [1:01:09] with senior rides, link gives us some money for rides, and that's, so a lot of people [1:01:16] a ride or they're under Medicaid and those rides don't cost people really anything out [1:01:23] of their pocket. The normal ride for the general public is $5 and we come to your house, [1:01:30] pick you up or wherever it might be or tell or whatever and take you to where you want [1:01:35] to go and then when you're ready to go back because when you go to the doctor you don't [1:01:40] know when you're going to get out of there. They call and then we send somebody as quickly [1:01:45] as we can to get them and there is no cost for the return trip. [1:01:48] Thank you. [1:01:49] I do have a question. [1:01:51] So if we approve this for the 2017 or the 2019 budget, would you still in 2019 be applying [1:01:57] for Imgrant on impog on top of that? [1:02:00] Or would this replace that and free up those impog dollars for others in the community? [1:02:05] Well, if we don't increase the days of service, 47,000 was maybe doing some weekend service [1:02:16] and that type of thing, but if the service that we have now, no, I would not, probably. [1:02:22] I would need it for next year. [1:02:24] Right, I understand that. [1:02:26] So typically it's hard for us as a council to make a decision that's going to tie the [1:02:32] hands of future council members. [1:02:34] But in this case, it makes sense and I understand why you're asking now. [1:02:38] Well, we appreciate it and I've been working with Mandy on this application and we want [1:02:45] to do whatever's best for the City of Twin Falls. [1:02:49] 100% of our service is really not in Twin Falls, but it's real, real, in fact, since we stopped [1:02:57] doing a little demand response in Jerome, it's probably 100% in Twin. [1:03:01] Well, we appreciate all your hard work. [1:03:03] We know you've been a great partner of the city. [1:03:05] Thank you. [1:03:06] Thank you. [1:03:07] Chris talking to me. [1:03:08] We are good partners and anything that takes up to 30,000 vehicles off the road in a year's [1:03:12] time as we're supporting. [1:03:17] Great glanting. [1:03:18] Are you ready for a motion? [1:03:19] I am. [1:03:20] Vice mayor, I move that we approve the joint application of the CSI transport to ITD for [1:03:27] for 5311 funds for public transportation to involve and direct staff to include it in the [1:03:33] 2019 budget. [1:03:34] Is there a second? [1:03:36] I'll second that. [1:03:40] We have a motion from Greg Lampteen, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the joint application [1:03:45] for funding with Transporters CSI. [1:03:48] Is there any comments or questions? [1:03:52] Sharon will call vote. [1:03:59] Chris Tockington. [1:04:00] Yes. [1:04:01] Nikki Boyd. [1:04:02] Yes. [1:04:03] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:04:04] Yes. [1:04:05] Yes. [1:04:06] Yes. [1:04:07] Yes. [1:04:08] Christopher Reed. [1:04:09] Yes. [1:04:10] Motion passes six to zero. [1:04:11] Thank you again to Jeff and Lynn for your help and Mandy. [1:04:15] Thank you for heading that up for us. [1:04:17] Thank you very much. [1:04:18] Great. [1:04:19] I want to publicly apologize for cutting you back on this last end, Paul. [1:04:24] We get in that mode where we're trying to make everybody happy and we have to realize [1:04:28] that sometimes we're making choices that you can't provide the services you need because [1:04:34] were not providing you money you need well I appreciate it and you know I think it [1:04:37] was about three or four years ago we were 32,000 and then the last two or three [1:04:42] years we've been down at the twenty five there have been more requests yeah thanks [1:04:47] well thank you the next item on our agenda is a request to approve records [1:04:55] destructions resolution and we have Sharon Brian [1:05:14] I didn't get credit for voting last time either, so now we're all on here. [1:05:20] Thank you, Sharon. [1:05:22] Okay. [1:05:23] This is a records destruction resolution 2017-16 as you know we are getting excited about moving [1:05:37] to our new digs and so we are trying to get rid of some of our paperwork so we don't have [1:05:45] to move it and so this is a resolution listing items that are semi-permanent records that [1:05:54] the state regulations states that the city council has to authorize approval of destruction [1:06:05] of these records, so that's what I'm asking tonight. [1:06:10] Great, Lantie. [1:06:11] Sharon, do we have these in some sort of electronic form, [1:06:14] or do we just think we don't need it all? [1:06:16] These are things that are older records [1:06:19] that we have not gotten on electronic. [1:06:23] Once we get records on electronic, [1:06:27] I don't have to bring that, the hard copy [1:06:30] ask you permission, because once they're electronic, [1:06:34] That is our original. [1:06:36] And so we're getting rid of the copy. [1:06:40] And so these are actually original records. [1:06:44] And as you see, they're like records in 2014 in back. [1:06:50] We have to keep original records for five years. [1:06:54] And so these are records that we would like to get rid of [1:06:57] that are older than that have not been scanned. [1:07:02] Chris, and follow on Greg's comment. [1:07:05] These older records and as I recall, they're shredded. [1:07:08] And are they recycled? [1:07:09] They don't go to landfill, I hope. [1:07:11] Well, when you shred documents, they're not recyclable [1:07:16] anymore is what I've been told. [1:07:21] I won't go for it unless they're recycled. [1:07:23] It's absolutely unconscionable. [1:07:24] Put 80,000 dead trees back in a landfill instead of recycling. [1:07:29] Can you see or do what you can? [1:07:31] Well, I know the recycling or the shredding [1:07:34] that we do at City Hall, they've told us it is not recyclable, so we actually have to dump [1:07:42] it in the garbage. [1:07:44] Was that something to vote against on this meeting? [1:07:47] Sorry, the recycling is too dug on important to leave it to the whim of somebody's convenience. [1:07:53] Travis, did you have something there? [1:07:54] I can't tell. [1:07:55] The only thing I was going to share is that we can certainly look into it, but I mean we [1:07:59] We can't make a commitment. [1:08:03] We've been told that the individuals who do the processing for us, because it is secure [1:08:08] information, sometimes, like, for example, if you took a look here, we have time cards, [1:08:14] we have personnel files that's going to have sensitive information. [1:08:17] But it's all shredded. [1:08:18] It is. [1:08:19] And so we don't shred that ourselves. [1:08:21] We actually hire a firm to come in and shred that. [1:08:24] And so we can contact vendors to see if they do recycle, but in the past, Sharon is right. [1:08:33] The vendors that we have spoke with actually take that and they dispose of that inside of [1:08:38] the landfill. [1:08:39] But we can ask if there's an alternative. [1:08:40] If you can at least ask, then you have my book. [1:08:43] Ruth Pierce. [1:08:44] I see no harm in asking. [1:08:45] So we use the service because we don't shred because it takes forever and it's recyclable, [1:08:51] bonded and they bring a trek around and so I think it really, and I can provide you with [1:09:01] that information. [1:09:02] Nicky Boyd? [1:09:03] I was just, you know, I would ask why it's not recyclable, is it a matter of, a lot of [1:09:09] those things, they'll grind everything, you know, giant paper clips, everything, and that's [1:09:16] tainting the paper. [1:09:18] when we recycle, when we throw things out, then yes, those paper clips, there's staples, [1:09:26] there's plastic bindings, because we can't, we don't have the manpower or the time to [1:09:34] take everything apart, so there's boxes of this stuff, and it all goes to the shredder, [1:09:42] So there's a lot of contaminants in it. [1:09:48] Thank you. [1:09:49] Chris Reed? [1:09:50] I was just going to say at the bank, it's not recycled. [1:09:52] It is destroyed and sent in that way, and there was a long explanation at one point in time [1:09:57] why that happened. [1:09:58] I don't remember, but. [1:09:59] So now that they've rashed now, I'm sorry. [1:10:03] Sorry. [1:10:04] Unless it's my personal bank record. [1:10:06] All right. [1:10:07] If there's no other discussion, I will take a motion. [1:10:15] Chris Reed. I move that we approve the destruction of records. Resolution [1:10:23] 2017-16. Is there a second? Yes. Second. We have a motion from Christopher Reed [1:10:30] seconded by Greg Lanting to approve Resolution 2017-16 and I see no lights [1:10:39] so Sharon will call vote please. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. [1:10:47] Yes. [1:10:48] Ruth Pierce. [1:10:49] Yes. [1:10:50] Christopher Reed. [1:10:51] Yes. [1:10:52] Chris Tockington. [1:10:53] Yes. [1:10:54] Motion passes six to zero. [1:10:59] We are back to that point on our agenda where we open up the microphone for anyone in [1:11:02] the public who has general comments that they would like to make to the council. [1:11:08] Jesse's you're coming forward. [1:11:09] Ruth Pierce just turned on her light, so I'm going to let Ruth go while you're walking [1:11:12] up. [1:11:13] So I just need to clarify that the 20th for breast cancer, tough enough to wear a pink [1:11:18] Day is actually Friday, not Thursday. [1:11:21] So if you want to wear a pink all week, [1:11:22] then you're good, but the day is actually Friday. [1:11:26] Thank you Ruth. [1:11:27] I believe it's Nikki's birthday. [1:11:31] Well, it sounds like there's a little party coming up, huh? [1:11:36] Jessica, the floor is yours. [1:11:38] My name is Jessie Stroop, and I actually [1:11:39] have a comment on the transfer bus thing. [1:11:42] I don't really know. [1:11:43] I couldn't really get up to sit during it. [1:11:45] But I used it Tuesdays and Thursdays, all of the fall semester last year, I believe. [1:11:55] And I mean, I don't want to say anything that's going to like hurt their feelings, [1:11:59] but I used that bus every Tuesday, Thursday, and I was the only passenger on the bus. [1:12:04] And I'm not really seeing how that's economical to have 10 buses going around picking up one person [1:12:10] and driving them to one place and coming back like it was convenient, [1:12:13] but I'm not seeing how that's economical. [1:12:16] Because I mean sometimes it would be one of a person with me, [1:12:18] but I mean that's a lot of money. [1:12:20] Those are big buses. [1:12:22] That's like 15 people that could fit on that bus. [1:12:25] So maybe they should look into having a fixed route a little bit [1:12:28] more than what they are now. [1:12:30] Because I think that would be a more economical choice for them [1:12:33] and also for the city of you're going [1:12:34] to be joining with them in this application. [1:12:37] So that's just my two things. [1:12:39] Thank you. [1:12:39] Before you sit down, Chris talking to you. [1:12:41] Yeah, and I really appreciate your comments. [1:12:42] It's actually that study we conducted last year based upon the experience of municipalities [1:12:48] that set up a fixed route system that's the surest way to fail. [1:12:53] We're starting off even with the low ridership of picking up people, let's say in front of [1:12:59] a retirement home and taking the hospital or the mall. [1:13:03] And although it sometimes results in lower ridership, the history shows that a fixed route [1:13:08] system is not the way to start. [1:13:11] we make due to that later. [1:13:13] The other point is once we reach 50,000 of population, [1:13:17] federal mandates pretty much requires [1:13:19] to have some form of public transportation. [1:13:22] This is still up and the flocks [1:13:24] and we appreciate your comments, Linda. [1:13:27] Thank you. [1:13:28] Appreciate you stepping up and speaking. [1:13:31] Is there anyone else in the audience [1:13:33] who would like to address the council? [1:13:38] Seeing no one, we are going to move on to our public hearing. [1:13:41] Oh, I'm sorry, did anybody have advisory board reports? [1:13:44] We'll quick. [1:13:45] No, but Sharon, did you get me down as voting? [1:13:49] Thank you. [1:13:50] There we go. [1:13:51] What was that on documents? [1:13:53] So the next item we have tonight is a public hearing [1:13:56] for a request for a zoning district change [1:13:59] and zoning map amendment from R2 to R2 Pro on property [1:14:03] located at 2016 Addison Avenue East. [1:14:07] And I show Dave Teapal here to be presenting. [1:14:12] And I'm assuming Jonathan Spindlove is here [1:14:14] for the city sorry I have to put my glasses back on. [1:14:20] Vice mayor and members of the city council. [1:14:23] My name is David Tebow with EHM engineers located at 621 North College Road here in Twin Falls [1:14:29] and I represent the Janis Sea Graves family foundation this evening in their application [1:14:33] for a rezone. [1:14:44] The property is located at 2016 Addison Avenue East at the southeast corner of sunrise and [1:14:53] Addison and it is bounded on the north the east and the west by property that has been [1:14:59] rezoned with a professional office overlay and right here's the subject property location [1:15:08] across the street to the north east and the west has all been rezoned with the PRO designation. [1:15:15] We're requesting that we too be zoned and designated as R2 with a professional office [1:15:19] overlay to allow conversion of this residence to an office to serve the Janice Sea Graves [1:15:25] family foundation so that they have a place to administer their business and [1:15:30] interview candidates for scholarships and other charitable donations that the [1:15:34] organization promotes and funds. I think it's a pretty straightforward request we [1:15:39] had a recommendation positively from the Planning and Zoning Commission and I [1:15:43] would answer any specific questions that you may have regarding this application. [1:15:47] Chris Topington and Dave I think that that whole South border at least is [1:15:51] intended by our overview zoning map to be professional residential. [1:15:56] Yeah, that is correct. This request is consistent with the comprehensive plan. [1:16:00] Yeah, there's an alley directly behind the residents here that really assist and [1:16:06] alleviate some of the concerns with access and refuse disposal and that kind of stuff. [1:16:11] Pick up and alleviate some traffic off of Addison, the primary arterial at that location. [1:16:17] So you are correct, Councilman. [1:16:20] Thank you. We will go ahead and hear from Jonathan Spindlof. [1:16:24] Nice to meet you. [1:16:28] The history of the parcel is recorded in 1947 as part of the federal subdivision. Several properties along the corridor have been rezoned to professional office. [1:16:36] The previous map showed all those darker with the PRO to the east and then there's commercial to the west. [1:16:43] of the West, kind of a decent transition from Eastland [1:16:48] down towards Smith's, basically. [1:16:52] The House had a residence built in 1952, [1:16:55] and they've had it be a house since then, as far as we know. [1:16:58] And in reviewing a request for zoning and zoning map [1:17:03] amendment, the Commission had two main tasks. [1:17:05] One was to determine whether the request [1:17:06] is in conformance of the comprehensive plan. [1:17:08] And two was to evaluate the requested [1:17:10] to determine the extent and nature of the amendment. [1:17:13] 2016 comprehensive plan designates his corridor [1:17:16] as like a neighborhood commercial, [1:17:19] supports those offices, those smaller businesses [1:17:23] along your collectors, arterials, [1:17:26] and therefore complies with that plan. [1:17:28] To make a decision in the affirmative, [1:17:29] the council must determine in the same the request [1:17:32] is in conformance with the comprehensive plan [1:17:33] and the extent nature of changing the zoning [1:17:36] from R2 to R2 to a professional office overlay [1:17:41] would allow development to be compatible with [1:17:43] to not detract from surrounding area. [1:17:45] On September 26th, the Planning Commission [1:17:47] forwarded a positive recommendation by a vote of six to zero. [1:17:51] The council's task of making a decision on this request. [1:17:53] They may approve the request as presented [1:17:55] to neither request or call for additional information. [1:17:59] Thank you, Jonathan. [1:18:01] Do we have any questions before I open the public hearing? [1:18:05] So I have one quick question. [1:18:06] If we approve the zoning change and see graves [1:18:10] decide to sell the property, [1:18:11] what other things would be openly allowed in there then [1:18:14] that aren't now. [1:18:15] Actually nothing's openly without a public hearing. [1:18:18] Okay. [1:18:19] Everything in the professional office doesn't really require a special use for that. [1:18:22] Thank you. [1:18:23] And in office. [1:18:24] Okay. [1:18:25] So at this time then we'll go ahead and open up the public hearing on this item. [1:18:28] Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak on this decision? [1:18:33] See a no one? [1:18:35] I will close the public hearing and turn it over to the Council for discussion. [1:18:41] Nicky Boyd. [1:18:43] I think it's pretty cut and dried. [1:18:44] Are you ready for a motion? [1:18:45] I'm ready. [1:18:46] I move that we grant the request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from [1:18:53] R2 to R2, professional overlay on property located at 2016 Addison Avenue East, care of [1:19:01] David Tebow, EHMing, engineers, Inc. on behalf of Janicey Graves Family Foundation application [1:19:08] 2894. [1:19:09] Second. [1:19:10] We have a motion from Nicky Boyd, seconded by Chris Reed to approve the request for the [1:19:17] zoning district change and zoning map amendment as presented. [1:19:21] Any discussion? Sharon roll call vote please. [1:19:26] Nicky Boyd? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. [1:19:34] Greg Lanting? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes. [1:19:38] Chris Talkington? Yes. Motion passes 6-0. Thank you very much. [1:19:42] The last item on our agenda tonight is a request to adjourn into [1:19:50] a request to adjourn into executive session under [1:19:53] said Idaho Code 74-2061-B to consider the evaluation, [1:19:59] dismissal, or disciplining of, or to hear complaints or charges brought [1:20:03] against a public officer, employee, staff member, individual agent, [1:20:08] or public school students. [1:20:10] And I will stand for a motion. [1:20:15] Ruth Pierce. [1:20:16] I move that we adjourn to executive session under section 74-206-1. [1:20:23] be et cetera. [1:20:25] Second. [1:20:28] We have a motion from Ruth Pierce, [1:20:29] seconded by Chris Reed, to adjourn into executive session [1:20:34] under the aforementioned section. [1:20:36] Is there any discussion? [1:20:39] Sharon Roll, call vote. [1:20:44] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:20:45] Yes. [1:20:45] Greg Lanting. [1:20:46] Yes. [1:20:47] Ruth Pierce. [1:20:47] Yes. [1:20:48] Christopher Reed. [1:20:49] Yes. [1:20:50] Chris Talkington. [1:20:51] Yes. [1:20:51] Nikki Boyd. [1:20:52] Yes. [1:20:53] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:20:54] Yes, again. [1:20:55] motion pass the six to zero and I would like to say for the public that we will not be making [1:21:00] any decisions in executive session and we will not be returning to the council chambers tonight. [1:21:05] With that we're adjourned. [1:21:15] So, use your back button.