Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-09-11, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-09-11/ [0:02:12] Good evening. I would like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council [0:02:27] for Monday, September 11th and confirm that we do have a quorum this evening. Six of [0:02:32] the seven members of the Council are here. Councilman Tawkinton is absent and excused [0:02:37] this evening. The first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those who [0:02:41] to be wishing to join us please rise. [0:02:48] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:03:04] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments [0:03:06] to our agenda this evening? [0:03:08] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:03:09] there are no amendments this evening. [0:03:11] Thank you. [0:03:14] So for proclamations this evening, we do have one. [0:03:18] September 11th as a day of service and remembrance. [0:03:22] Whereas on September 11th, 2001, the American people [0:03:25] endured with courage and heroism, the worst terrorist [0:03:28] attack on US soil in the nation's history. [0:03:31] And whereas in response to this tragedy, [0:03:33] Americans across the country came together [0:03:35] in a remarkable spirit of patriotism and unity [0:03:39] and carried out countless acts of kindness, [0:03:41] generosity, and compassion. [0:03:44] And whereas community organizations and family members [0:03:46] of 9-11 victims began observing the anniversary of September 11th [0:03:51] as a charitable service day to honor the memory of those [0:03:54] who were lost and those who united in response [0:03:57] to the tragedy, including first responders and volunteers. [0:04:00] And whereas the Edward M. Kennedy Serve America Act approved [0:04:04] by Congress and enacted into law on April 21, 2009, [0:04:09] requested September 11th, excuse me, September 11th to be observed [0:04:14] and recognized as an annual National Day of Service and Remembrance, and charged the Corporation [0:04:19] for National and Community Service with leading this nationwide effort. And whereas participating [0:04:24] in service and remembrance activities, on September 11th is a positive and respectful [0:04:29] way to remember the lives of those lost, pay tribute to those who rose in service, and [0:04:34] honor those who continue to serve our country today, including veterans, soldiers, military [0:04:39] families, and first responders. [0:04:41] And whereas September 11th National Day of Service and Remembrance activities are being [0:04:46] organized by a wide range of non-profits, faith-based and community groups, public agencies, educational [0:04:54] institutions, private businesses and other organizations across the nation. [0:04:58] And whereas on September 11th, 2017, and on the days leading up to and following this day, [0:05:05] citizens of Twin Falls have an opportunity to participate in activities that honor 9-11 [0:05:09] victims and heroes by joining together in service projects to meet community needs. [0:05:15] Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls proclaim September 11th [0:05:20] a day of service and remembrance in Twin Falls and call upon the people of Twin Falls [0:05:24] to honor the lives and memories of those lost through participation in community service [0:05:29] and remembrance ceremonies on this day and throughout the year. [0:05:34] Earlier today, Vice Mayor Suzanne Hawkins had the opportunity to read this proclamation [0:05:39] that an event at City Park today. I appreciate you participating in that, Suzanne, and thank [0:05:44] all who attended that event to help us follow the guidance of this proclamation in remembering [0:05:52] today as a day of service and remembrance. And here to accept this proclamation this evening [0:05:57] is Chris Hawley who was first responder to ground zero. [0:06:01] One of the very special to me is it is we want here hopefully. We must never forget as [0:06:34] We distance ourselves from that day. [0:06:37] First responders are still dying to this day due to the effects of 9-11. [0:06:42] And we must honor those families and those victims. [0:06:45] Thank you so much. [0:06:46] Thank you. [0:06:54] Next on our agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:06:58] So this is a chance for members of the public to address the council [0:07:02] and issues that are not on this evening's agenda. [0:07:04] So if there's anyone wishing to address the council, please come forward now. [0:07:12] Greg Lansing. [0:07:13] Just kind of done. [0:07:14] I mean, that was a very fitting that we were doing [0:07:18] that proclamation. [0:07:19] We have one of first responders here as well. [0:07:21] We have a lot of service organizations here [0:07:23] since it is a day of service, so perfect timing. [0:07:27] Great for all of them to be here. [0:07:30] If there's no one else wishing to address the council, [0:07:32] we'll move on with the agenda. [0:07:34] The next item of business is the consent calendar [0:07:36] and I would ask if item six C [0:07:40] could please be removed from the consent calendar [0:07:43] As it's a Twin Falls Chamber event, [0:07:45] I will recuse myself from that vote. [0:07:47] Greg Lansing. [0:07:48] Mayor, I'm of approval of the consent calendar [0:07:50] minus item C. [0:07:52] Second. [0:07:54] Motion by Greg Lansing, seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:07:56] to approve the consent calendar minus item six C. [0:07:59] Any discussion? [0:08:01] Sharon Roll, call both please. [0:08:20] Sean Beriker. [0:08:21] Yes. [0:08:22] Nicky Boyd, yes. [0:08:24] Suzanne Hawkins, yes. [0:08:26] Greg Lansing, yes. [0:08:28] Ruth Pierce, yes. [0:08:29] Christopher Reed. [0:08:30] Yes. [0:08:31] Motion passes six to zero, and Vice Mayor Hawkins. [0:08:37] I would take a motion on item six C, and I can't see like Greg, and then Ruth, and [0:08:43] Greg, granting Vice Mayor, I move that we approve item six C. [0:08:49] I'll second that. [0:08:51] We have a motion from Greg, Lansing, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request for [0:08:55] the Twin Falls Chamber of Commerce for their dinner for the Magic Valley Legislative Tour. [0:09:00] Is there any discussion or questions from the council? [0:09:04] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:09:08] Nikki Boyd? [0:09:08] Yes. [0:09:10] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:09:11] Yes. [0:09:15] Greg Lanting? [0:09:16] Yes. [0:09:16] Ruth Pears? [0:09:17] Yes. [0:09:17] Christopher Reed? [0:09:19] Yes. [0:09:25] Motion passes 5-0. [0:09:26] It's all right. [0:09:26] It's all right. [0:09:27] That's all good. [0:09:28] It's hard to remember to do that down here. [0:09:31] Thank you, Suzanne. [0:09:32] I apologize. [0:09:33] Next on the agenda are items of consideration. [0:09:35] The first is a presentation by the Twin Falls Community [0:09:38] Foundation that's when Paul's Rotary Club acknowledging a donation to aid construction of the main Avenue Commons Plaza [0:09:45] And we have on the agenda here in Nate Murray economic development director for the city [0:09:50] So I didn't see you were hiding amongst the crowd [0:09:56] Thank you for this time mayor and council so the work we're seeing along main Avenue is [0:10:01] The tail end of what's been a pretty lengthy process the process that's filled with many community partners, so we're here tonight to [0:10:07] to receive a presentation from one of those community partners regarding the participation [0:10:16] with some of the into construction. [0:10:17] And that is the Twin Falls Rotary Club and Twin Falls Foundation. [0:10:20] So we'll give time to their President, Travis Kwosnau, to make that presentation as well [0:10:25] as some of the presentation you made earlier today to our urban renewal agency. [0:10:29] Thank you, Nathan. [0:10:30] Welcome, Mr. Kwosnau. [0:10:32] Thank you. [0:10:33] Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. [0:10:35] My name is Travis Kwosnau. [0:10:36] I have the pleasure of serving as the President of the Twin Falls Rotary Club. [0:10:39] Our club is 109 members strong, and tonight we have several of those members with us here. [0:10:44] I won't spend the time to introduce them, but if I can, I'd like to ask them to stand just [0:10:47] so you know who's here from the Rotary Club tonight. [0:10:52] Thank you. [0:10:58] In 2018, the Twin Falls Rotary Club will celebrate a centennial. [0:11:02] The model of Rotary is service above self, and our club has a long history of serving and [0:11:05] giving back to this great community. [0:11:07] During our club's nearly 100-year history, I can only begin to speculate on the number [0:11:11] of projects and the hundreds of thousands of dollars that have been distributed to our [0:11:14] community. [0:11:15] the signature projects that our club has been involved in over the years has been the centennial [0:11:19] park down along the river and the fitness trail located along the CSI campus. Approximately [0:11:24] five years ago under the leadership of our then president Terry McCurdy, a plan was developed [0:11:28] to refurbish the old fountain in downtown Twin Falls. Terry brought the idea of the club [0:11:33] and to the club and over the past five years the Rotary Club is the air market portion of [0:11:38] their fundraising efforts for the downtown fountain project. The Twin Falls Rotary Club [0:11:43] has several popular fundraisers each year, [0:11:45] including the death by chocolate, ice cream fund days, [0:11:48] and the bites of brilliance. [0:11:51] In addition, we've sold over 300 bricks [0:11:54] to be placed in the downtown commons area. [0:11:57] So fast-forged today, we're excited at the downtown renewal [0:12:00] and the development of a splash park in the city commons [0:12:03] that will be built across from the new city hall. [0:12:05] So today it's our great pleasure on behalf [0:12:06] of the Twin Falls Rotary Club to present the city [0:12:09] with a check for $120,000 to go towards completion [0:12:12] the splash park in the plasma. [0:12:27] We'd love to get a photo with you. [0:12:30] We can all crowd up behind you. [0:12:35] Yes, I'll come down there. [0:12:38] Let's go down. Come on down. [0:12:41] Come on. [0:12:43] Come on down. [0:12:46] I need you guys scoop down that way a little bit. [0:12:57] I like it. [0:12:59] Don't go over it. [0:13:01] So just in conclusion, if I can, [0:13:41] This again, as I mentioned, in 2018, we'll be celebrating our Centennial Sofield Mark [0:13:46] your calendars. [0:13:47] Wednesday, April 4th, we'll be having a Gala event that we'd like to invite you all to [0:13:51] participate in. [0:13:52] Thank you. [0:13:53] Thank you. [0:14:00] Travis, I'd like to say to you and your club members, currently, but certainly for the [0:14:04] past five years, thank you so much for your dedication to the community. [0:14:08] I thought that Greg's comment at the beginning of the meeting was appropriate. [0:14:11] We have so many folks from a significant service club here in our community. [0:14:16] mentioned a few of the large projects but I know you all do great things throughout the year so [0:14:21] thank you for that and certainly thank you for the contribution of the commons I look forward to [0:14:25] dancing in the splash pad next to my brick next year Greg Lansing yes thank you 120 000 that's [0:14:33] impressive really appreciate everyone for their efforts and I look forward to [0:14:39] to dancing in the splice park next to my two pricks. [0:14:43] Oh, there you go. [0:14:44] Well, again, thank you so much. [0:14:51] Next on the agenda, we have a presentation [0:14:52] by Family Health Services from Aaron Houston, CEO [0:14:55] of Family Health Services, and Patty Klinekopf, [0:14:57] Business Development Director. [0:15:00] Hello, Mayor and City Council. [0:15:02] Thank you for giving us a little bit of time. [0:15:06] We're here tonight just to kind of inform you [0:15:08] about who and what Family Health Services is, [0:15:11] and then maybe just plant a seed for the future. [0:15:14] So we'll see how it goes. [0:15:16] So hopefully you have a packet in front of you. [0:15:19] Family Health Services is a not-for-profit organization, [0:15:22] and we provide medical, dental, behavioral health, [0:15:25] and pharmacy services to low income or underinsured patients. [0:15:30] That's primarily who we serve. [0:15:32] And we are governed by a volunteer board [0:15:35] that give up their time. [0:15:37] And we currently have about 235 staff. [0:15:41] On the next page, you can just see the communities we're in, [0:15:44] or throughout the Magic Valley, Twin Falls, [0:15:46] Dule, Kimberly, Jerome, Burley, Rupert, and Fairfield. [0:15:51] We do have a monopoly in Fairfield, so business is good there. [0:15:57] In 2016, we served just over 25,000 patients. [0:16:02] 41% were uninsured, and 32% were Medicaid. [0:16:06] That's significant because not everyone who has Medicaid [0:16:09] has access to care, especially in some of the smaller communities. [0:16:14] And so that's kind of what we bring is that just the access [0:16:21] for patients. [0:16:22] We had another 7% Medicare and about 18% insurance. [0:16:26] We do accept a few insurances that others don't. [0:16:31] Or they might have a really high deductible. [0:16:33] So if you have like a $10,000 deductible or even a $5,000 deductible, [0:16:38] you really don't have health insurance. [0:16:41] You have catastrophic insurance. [0:16:43] And so we're able to provide a sliding fee discount [0:16:46] to those patients as well. [0:16:48] The way it works is if a family is 200% or below the federal poverty [0:16:52] guideline, then they qualify for our sliding fee discount. [0:16:56] They can just bring in a check stub right to us. [0:16:58] It happens instantly at that time. [0:17:01] They qualify for the discount. [0:17:03] So it's $20 to see the physician. [0:17:05] It's $20 for an hour long counseling session. [0:17:09] Dental is a little bit different. [0:17:10] We do have about a 90% discount for preventative services, [0:17:15] but dental has a lot of hard cost materials to it, [0:17:19] like crowns and stuff like that. [0:17:21] So it's generally a 50% discount for those patients. [0:17:26] And then another big thing we do is a 340B discount, [0:17:29] which provides discounted pharmacy. [0:17:32] Some of the medications we get are like some of the not the newest latest greatest insulin, [0:17:40] but some of the older ones, we can get those for a penny and pass that on to our patients. [0:17:45] So that's a significant thing to make sure that our patients, you know, can afford the doctor's visit, [0:17:52] but then can also afford the medications. [0:17:55] And we do have two pharmacies, one in Berlin, one in Twin Falls, and we have the ability to go ahead [0:18:00] and adjust that down even further if we need to, [0:18:03] to make sure our patients have those medications. [0:18:05] So, we also have pretty significant payment plan options. [0:18:09] So as long as a patient is making an effort, [0:18:12] so like a dollar a month, we'll accept that [0:18:14] as a payment plan, as long as they're calling us up [0:18:21] or letting us know, or making that dollar payment [0:18:23] or $20 payment, whatever it is, they're standing. [0:18:26] So we've had accounts on our balance sheet [0:18:29] for 10, 15 years, it's no problem. [0:18:31] So, specific to Twin Falls, last year, [0:18:35] we served about 15,000 patients with 60,000 visits, [0:18:40] and we provided almost $3 million in charity care. [0:18:44] The way we do that charity care is, [0:18:45] let's say it's about $120 to go to the doctor, [0:18:48] we slide that down to $20, so that $100 is what we consider [0:18:53] charity care, and so $3 million, [0:18:56] That's pretty significant for the low income of twin. [0:19:02] The next couple of sheets just kind of go through [0:19:04] who our providers are and kind of their tenure. [0:19:08] We do have some long-term providers that are committed [0:19:12] to Twin Falls and family health services and their patients. [0:19:16] And so we're very proud of them. [0:19:17] And we always like to recognize those providers. [0:19:22] I'm going to skip real quick to the other reason we're here is we're starting to work [0:19:33] a lot with other communities, other city councils. [0:19:36] So right now in Rupert, we're working on a new building. [0:19:39] The city actually purchased the land, and we got a grant to demolish that building, and [0:19:46] then we're going to pay back the city. [0:19:49] They're helping us with some upfront costs. [0:19:50] We pay them back with interest. [0:19:52] The city owns the building, but then we pay them back at $1 a year after they're kind of [0:19:57] made whole. [0:19:58] So whatever they put into the project, we'll pay them back then for the next 50 years, we'll [0:20:02] pay them $1 a year. [0:20:04] We've done the same thing in Burley with the hospital there. [0:20:07] They donated land. [0:20:08] We built the building, we'd pay them $1 a year. [0:20:11] We did the same thing in Kimberly. [0:20:13] There was no medical provider in Kimberly, so we went into there, we worked with the city [0:20:18] council. [0:20:19] They tore down an old city hall. [0:20:21] We paid over time the demolition of that building, built a new building and then we pay them a dollar a year for 50 years. [0:20:28] So I don't know what we're going to do in 50 years when all that's gone, when the city's all take it back. [0:20:35] But until then, we're pretty excited about those partnerships and we do have kind of a five to ten year plan that we need to do something in Twin Falls. [0:20:46] because we are just, we've outgrown our Twin Falls clinics. [0:20:49] We have four of them. [0:20:51] We have two right across the street on Martin Street. [0:20:55] And they're just packed in there. [0:20:57] We did remodel our 388 Martin Street clinic. [0:21:02] We just did that about two or three months ago. [0:21:04] We finished up. [0:21:05] But we're bursting at the seats. [0:21:07] We have to turn patients away because we just [0:21:10] can't see everybody in the day. [0:21:12] And the only thing that I'll fix that is more providers. [0:21:15] And so at some point, we would like to have all of our services [0:21:20] under one roof, which would be a pretty big building. [0:21:23] And we would like the city at some point [0:21:25] to be a partner with that. [0:21:27] I think it would be a very positive thing for Twin Falls. [0:21:30] Right now, we have dental and behavioral health [0:21:32] in the same building. [0:21:33] That's not always the best combination. [0:21:35] So if we could get maybe behavioral health out of there, [0:21:40] that would be a pretty positive thing as well. [0:21:43] That was fast. [0:21:44] I apologize for that. [0:21:46] I'm just want to thank the council for listening to us. [0:21:50] We wanted to make sure that you all know who we are. [0:21:53] Because I think for the last 30 plus years, I think we've been one of the best-kept secrets [0:21:57] in the Magic Valley and our presentations as we have gone around, [0:22:01] that usually the opening question is, who are you? [0:22:04] And yet we've been here forever. [0:22:06] The other thing that I want to make sure that it is clear is that we're not here just [0:22:11] for the low-income or for the uninsured or the underinsured or for Medicaid patients. [0:22:16] We desperately need to be a part of the community, and we need other community members. [0:22:21] Those of you who are insured, just help support family health services also. [0:22:26] We have a new foundation that is supporting colorectal cancer screening. [0:22:31] I see you'll hear more about that over the next year or so. [0:22:35] But we're here for the community. [0:22:37] We need to make sure that Twin Falls, the city of Twin Falls knows who we are [0:22:42] and what we're all about, because we do some good work in the area, [0:22:47] and I don't think everyone knows who we are and what we're about. [0:22:51] Thank you for listening. [0:22:53] Thank you. [0:22:53] I think we do have a couple of questions here, so Ruth Pierce. [0:22:56] So, yeah, it'll be all right. [0:23:00] So how do you interact with the wellness tree? [0:23:03] Do you refer patients? [0:23:05] Yes. [0:23:06] Do you have some cross referrals? [0:23:09] And we have some providers that work over at the Wellness Tree as well volunteer their time. [0:23:14] We have a very good relationship with the Wellness Tree. [0:23:18] Usually when they have some chronic patients, not an acute issue, they'll send them over to us or significant dental work. [0:23:26] They'll certainly refer them over to us. [0:23:28] The Wellness Tree has services that we don't provide. [0:23:31] They do the eyeglasses and the hearing, and so we refer that way as well. [0:23:36] So we also do OB, we deliver a lot of babies, and so the one the street refers are way for [0:23:43] those. [0:23:44] Thank you. [0:23:46] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:23:47] I was able to attend your ribbon cutting at your expansion on your Martin Street location, [0:23:53] and I just want to say wow, I was really impressed. [0:23:55] I got to tour back to some of those rooms, and I had no idea, as you said, that you guys [0:24:01] were there and what you did and what an education I got that day. [0:24:06] I was so impressed with everybody on your staff and how kind they were and just the whole [0:24:10] facility lay out and I want to give you kudos because I know you guys do a good work there [0:24:16] and your new expansion was great. [0:24:18] Well thank you, thanks for going. [0:24:21] Nicky Boyd? [0:24:22] Yeah. [0:24:24] So we do, so we have a three to eight Martin Street, that's our main clinic, it's. [0:24:34] Tell me exactly where it is so I can, I can, it's the former pediatric center, does that [0:24:41] That's what I want is for everybody to be able to visualize this, okay, and the second one. [0:24:50] So the one that's 325 Martin Street, it's just south of the 388 clinic on the same street, [0:24:58] and we outgrew our 388 clinic, which is medical only. [0:25:02] We put dental and medical in that one, then we got an expansion grant, so we only had five [0:25:08] dental chairs at the 325 clinic. [0:25:11] We were close to patients, closed the new patients. [0:25:14] We had, we received a grant and we bought the 826 Eastland, moved dental out of there. [0:25:22] And now we have... [0:25:23] That's before we're home health and hospitals. [0:25:24] They got it. [0:25:25] The home health and hospitals. [0:25:26] Okay. [0:25:27] All right. [0:25:28] Thank you. [0:25:29] So, and now we have so we have the two medical clinics kind of side by side that are over there [0:25:34] on that street. [0:25:35] So the 325 mark that's created for those from Twin Falls from many years that Dr. George [0:25:42] Okay, so we have to go back here. [0:25:52] Visual is good. Thank you very much. [0:25:55] Greg Lansing. [0:25:56] You mentioned, and I'm sure it's never enough, but you mentioned some of the times you get grants and thanks. Did you talk about where some of those come from for you? [0:26:05] Sure. So we received grants from quite a few different foundations, local foundations, support us. [0:26:12] And then we get state grants, like the Colorado Cancer Screening Grant, we got that, and then [0:26:19] we get quite a few federal grants. [0:26:21] So under the Affordable Care Act, we were actually able to expand quite a bit, especially [0:26:26] with buildings, and then we've also done business development block grants. [0:26:33] And so that's how we got our Fairfield Clinic and our Kimberly Clinic. [0:26:37] And so we'll go after any kind of funding to help. [0:26:40] They're potentially like economic development, those kind of things. [0:26:44] Yeah. [0:26:46] Thank you, man. [0:26:48] I have spent a lot of time with some medical services during this last year when I lost [0:26:53] my parents, and some of those very names on your list were some of the best providers they had, [0:26:58] so you've got good quality people helping you. [0:27:00] Are there any other questions or comments? [0:27:05] Erin and Patty, thank you so much for your presentation. [0:27:11] We'll look forward to future opportunities to partner with you as we try to reach some of the goals of our city's strategic plan as a healthy community. [0:27:20] Thank you. [0:27:24] Next on the agenda is a presentation by John Brecken, Principal Landscape Architect and Owner of Brecken Land Design, regarding Landscape and Irrigation Requirements. [0:27:33] Welcome. [0:27:34] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, thank you for taking the time to listen to me tonight. [0:27:41] and prepare a brief presentation. [0:27:53] I think Sharon's got to flip a switch over there. [0:27:57] Anyway, I'm here to request minor modification [0:28:29] to the city's existing city code [0:28:32] that addresses landscape requirements. [0:28:35] The intent is that this will ensure that the installation, [0:28:39] landscape installation will meet and match [0:28:42] the city's intention for beautification [0:28:45] water conservation. [0:28:48] Certainly this city has a [0:28:50] landscape code in place, and it's [0:28:53] certainly adequate. However, [0:28:59] there's a couple items that are a little bit [0:29:02] missing that could make it a little bit better. [0:29:05] And the one is, [0:29:09] the plants need a little bit more [0:29:13] detail on them to ensure that the [0:29:21] implementation meets the city's expectation. [0:29:26] This is just some of the excerpts from the code. [0:29:45] There's some of the excerpts of the existing code, [0:29:48] existing city code, which does require a landscape plan. [0:30:00] And here's some of the specific landscape plan [0:30:03] requirements that are quoted out of the code. [0:30:07] Code does not currently address who is qualified [0:30:10] to prepare a landscape plan or what the information is [0:30:14] required on the plans in order to determine [0:30:17] the plan meets the city standard or not. [0:30:20] So there's a requirement for a plan, [0:30:22] but it doesn't really say what's required on that plan, [0:30:27] and how can someone check to see a plan meets the intent [0:30:32] of the code. [0:30:35] And so what I have here is some model landscape code [0:30:41] that you might see from other towns. [0:30:45] And the highlighted area there speaks specifically [0:30:49] is some of the language that we'd like to see added to the code. [0:30:53] And it says that the landscape plan preparation is required in that. [0:30:59] It would all landscape plans shall be prepared by either a landscape architect, [0:31:05] licensed in the state of Idaho, a qualified landscape designer, [0:31:09] working as a professional in the field, or a qualified nurseryman. [0:31:14] This is kind of some broad language, but it does give some requirement there [0:31:19] So that somebody who is knowledgeable in landscape design could prepare the plants. [0:31:27] Trying to exclude anybody from preparing the landscape plant. [0:31:32] Attendance to estimate if that kind of knows what they're doing. [0:31:37] Along with that is irrigation design. [0:31:43] Obviously our plants keep around here typically does need irrigation. [0:31:49] And the same along the same lines, irrigation design would ensure that the plants would survive, and also ensure water conservation. [0:32:04] The plan is designed, and the design is essential for one for review by the city and the staff to make sure that what's designed is meets the requirements, [0:32:20] requirements so forth so you're getting what you're expecting and also it gives [0:32:27] the designer an opportunity to go through calculate water water requirements and [0:32:32] make sure that the irrigation system is matched to the plant design. The question [0:32:44] that always comes up when you require these sorts of plans is okay well who is [0:32:48] going to make sure that what's installed is for the plan and so in order to address [0:32:54] that question best practices to either have speak from the city to it [0:33:02] do is knowledgeable staff or have the designer certified and go inspect [0:33:09] installation make sure it was installed for the plans and then they would what [0:33:13] other towns do this. We will have the designer go out, check it, make sure it's all installed [0:33:19] for the approved plans, and then write a certification letter for the city. Here's some comparisons [0:33:31] with some other towns, Chubbock, Idaho Falls, Pocatello. They also have landscaping requirements, [0:33:38] requirements, landscape plan requirements, and just as a comparison, see what else is [0:33:49] going on relatively locally. [0:33:54] But the other thing is that I'd like to see the qualifications for preparing the plan or [0:34:04] what the minimum submittal requirements should be. [0:34:08] So making sure that the plans meet the attention of the code. [0:34:23] Here's an excerpt, Pocatello's drawing requirements, which is the other items. [0:34:30] So there's really, there's two items. [0:34:31] One is to have somebody who is competent in the landscape design, preparing the plans. [0:34:40] And then also to have minimum requirements for what is shown on the plan. [0:34:45] So, you can see here in this list, there's some specific industry standard requirements, [0:34:51] scale, the things are drawn to scale, there's a north arrow, the street names on there, and [0:34:58] this is all just kind of standard, what is standard practice for site design and landscape [0:35:03] design in the industry. [0:35:04] But I just brought this to show you as a quick example. [0:35:09] So then, what does that look like? [0:35:11] What that looks like is, this is an example of, [0:35:15] if you were to do a plan per the existing code requirements, [0:35:21] it would show what areas are to be landscaped. [0:35:25] And then really just some number of quotes [0:35:28] that you can see in the bottom right hand, [0:35:30] the page, the verbiage, it says, [0:35:32] okay, this means we're a feed of landscaping, [0:35:35] and it meets the code, [0:35:37] We've got so many trees and so many shrubs that would be it. [0:35:42] What we're proposing is that it's a more detailed document. [0:35:46] So this is an example of the proposed drawing requirements [0:35:49] that we'd like to see. [0:35:51] And so you can see there's a lot more detail here, [0:35:53] actually calling out each plan, shrub on the plan. [0:35:58] There's a key that notes botanical names. [0:36:03] So you really know what you're getting before it's actually [0:36:07] installed, you know, it's similar to other engineering or architectural plans that you [0:36:12] would see on commercial type projects. [0:36:14] Here's just a little blow up of some more detail. [0:36:19] So the landscape notes, topsoil requirements, just kind of some standard things that repair [0:36:28] these kinds of plans. [0:36:32] And then, you know, ultimately what we're trying to achieve is that what's installed [0:36:37] in the landscape meets the, let me say intent of what you want to see is that the city [0:36:43] look like in the future with the beautification, the aesthetics of nice street trees and what's [0:36:55] appropriate throughout the city. I stand for questions. [0:37:11] So I actually have a question. So is the intent of your recommendation that we have more specific [0:37:21] language in our code in this more specific design submittal process, to actually improve [0:37:26] the landscaping or is it to have more plans in place before that? [0:37:30] To improve the landscaping. [0:37:33] Yes. [0:37:34] I guess the issue I see right now is with the way things are, there's nothing to hold and [0:37:42] anybody to what is actually installed. [0:37:45] I mean, the code speaks to the landscape plan requirement. [0:37:48] There is a plan that's required. [0:37:51] there's not really anything that's required to be shown on the plant. And so [0:37:57] thereby, you almost need gain the necessity of the plant. So you don't, this plant, this [0:38:05] plant is required. That's really much that's required to be on the plant. And so [0:38:11] you don't know what you're getting as far as landscape installation. Okay, Nicky [0:38:19] Boyd. Have you worked through the planning and zoning process? We have talked [0:38:25] to staff to some degree, and that's one of the reasons we're here tonight. They seemed [0:38:30] amenable to these considerations and suggested we present it to the council. [0:38:36] So I was three years on planning and zoning, and I understand, and I love landscaping. A [0:38:44] lot of times landscaping beats a building, you know, crazy. But when we do have, we do [0:38:55] have requirements and so what you're proposing I understand is to make sure [0:39:03] those requirements are carried out how do you propose that that happens well so [0:39:11] proposed that there's more detail on the plants there's more specific maybe even a [0:39:18] checklist requirement for what should be shown on the plan as in specific plants [0:39:25] It's bushes, trees, and irrigation. [0:39:27] Correct. [0:39:28] Okay. [0:39:29] And then, once those plants are approved by the city, that the designer inspect the installation. [0:39:38] Who is the designer? [0:39:39] Whoever selected. [0:39:41] And, you know, I know there's a lot of people locally here, lots of landscape companies. [0:39:47] They're all, I'm sure they have qualified person. [0:39:51] I just want to read. [0:39:58] So you mentioned conservation of water, and that's a big topic for us. [0:40:03] I know Councilman Talkington, who's not here, is something that he's been talking about for [0:40:07] several years. [0:40:09] Can you speak more to that? [0:40:10] I think out of all of this understanding how this can help us conserve water is something [0:40:15] that would really benefit the city. [0:40:17] Sure. [0:40:18] Water conservation goes hand in hand with the landscape design. [0:40:23] plants have different watering needs as such. That's why we've designed the irrigation systems [0:40:31] is so that the plants get the appropriate amount of water. You can easily over water [0:40:37] a plant depending on the plant. You can also easily under water a plant depending on those [0:40:43] needs, transportation, wind rate, and so forth. So, having a landscape plan would show and depict, [0:40:56] you know, specifically plants that are zerick, actually, and then also the watering needs of those [0:41:05] plants. Without a specific plan, being your hat on you, you know, it could be all turf. It could be a [0:41:16] variety of different plants, potentially some that eat more water than not. Throughout the landscape, typically the greatest water users is turf areas. [0:41:29] And if you look historically as far as water consumption throughout cities, throughout the states, and whole 50% of our water consumption is in landscape, sometimes more. [0:41:46] So it's irrigation design is specifically addresses, zero skating and water conservation. [0:41:58] Thank you. [0:42:02] So Mr. Mayor, members of the council, so just maybe on a part of the process. [0:42:10] Obviously those interested at any point in time looking at a land use code, there's a [0:42:16] couple of different options. [0:42:19] One of those options is to file an application and kind of roll through that process and my [0:42:27] understanding is that has been done in another community and at the end of a very long and [0:42:32] lengthy process that City Council had elected not to move forward with making some ordnance [0:42:39] changes as a result of landscaping and so prior to going through the potential lengthy [0:42:45] process if here, the thought was maybe kind of gauge the council to see if there was even [0:42:54] an interest in proceeding and moving forward. Because regardless, you're going to have to [0:43:00] go through all of the public hearing processes before planning and zoning as well as at the [0:43:07] city council level because it deals with a land use ordinance and that is required through [0:43:12] Title 67 to go through the public hearing processes. [0:43:19] Greg Lanting. [0:43:22] Well, a couple of things. [0:43:25] When I, the one plan you showed, I don't know if I've ever seen or had one come to me, [0:43:31] I should say, that was a little better thing. [0:43:35] Even though my years of honey and zonning are in counsel of that, not the case. [0:43:41] Because typically we're dealing with PUDs and ZDA's and things that require more information [0:43:48] to us about what they're going to do and what they're going to plan and things like [0:43:53] that. [0:43:54] So although I understand exactly what you're saying and I could want to misrepresent it, [0:43:58] that's what we typically see. [0:43:59] Because that's not what we typically see when you fly stuff there. [0:44:02] It's current in code. [0:44:03] And so I can see the need to maybe put that fourth of the one on each CDA and each PUD [0:44:11] He typically has additional requirements beyond what the city code says. [0:44:17] Yes, the intent, my intent there was just to show if I read through the code and prepare [0:44:23] a plan for the code right now, that was my interpretation, I guess I've learned to utilize [0:44:34] our city manager system and have Mitch speak to us a little bit on what what you [0:44:42] see in this plan that you like maybe what you see in this plan that maybe you [0:44:47] have concerns about because that's why we hire professionals is to to give us [0:44:51] advice so he's our professional yeah he's our he's our deputy city manager [0:44:59] under over this field. So I think that we have required landscaping in our [0:45:09] plans. I'm not gonna spout off what that is off top of my head because actually I [0:45:14] don't know at all. But the planners do right and they review those plans all the [0:45:19] time. They're gonna and we don't say in our code this is what a landscape plan [0:45:24] has to include right and that's that's true but we also get plans that we [0:45:31] review and approve and we have to be able to know whether they meet code or not so I'm not [0:45:38] sure that that's ever been a real problem that we've identified with our code is that we need [0:45:43] more in there really specifying what needs and doesn't need to be on a plan. I think what [0:45:53] what landscaping we require is certainly out for debate. Do we have enough landscaping? [0:45:58] do we have not enough landscaping? [0:46:00] Should we require zero escaping, [0:46:04] or should we encourage zero escaping, [0:46:05] or allow zero escaping? [0:46:08] Lots of different ways to approach that. [0:46:10] All those subjects, [0:46:11] and I think that is the very reason why [0:46:13] this kind of stuff goes through a public hearing process. [0:46:15] I have some ideas that what I think might be good. [0:46:19] It might be different than what Travis thinks, [0:46:22] or what other people think. [0:46:26] Getting through that process [0:46:28] So the public hearing would kind of help zero in on that. [0:46:31] I don't believe, well, let me back up a little bit. [0:46:36] I think our code needs some attention, particularly [0:46:39] with regards to the zero-scaping stuff [0:46:41] and the water conservation stuff. [0:46:43] That's one of the topics on the list of amendments [0:46:47] that Jonathan and Renee are actively working [0:46:51] through this big list. [0:46:53] They're not the one they're working on right now. [0:46:54] They've got a big one they're working on right now [0:46:56] about land uses and things like that. [0:46:58] So this one comes next, probably next on the list [0:47:01] if I was going to prioritize that form. [0:47:06] Honestly, I don't even know if we should go here or not, [0:47:10] but our Title 10 in its entirety [0:47:14] is in need of major overhaul. [0:47:18] And I'm not a real fan of peace-mealing that [0:47:22] like we've been trying to do for the last 10 years [0:47:24] that I've been here. [0:47:26] I honestly think we should re-write the whole thing, [0:47:30] throw the old one away and adopt a new one that works for us [0:47:33] because we have some landscaping issues [0:47:35] that need to be addressed. [0:47:37] We have some land use issues that need to be addressed. [0:47:39] We have some setback issues that need to be addressed. [0:47:41] We have some parking issues. [0:47:42] You know, you can go down the list [0:47:44] and tell you the whole thing needs some really care, [0:47:48] some in-depth care and attention paid to it. [0:47:52] It would be my proposal, my desire to just try [0:47:55] whole new Title X all at once because we're going to miss things when we try and [0:48:02] piece them together and we find holes that we forgot to we didn't quite cover [0:48:07] when we tried and do them all one at a time having said all that anybody at any [0:48:15] time can make the application to min or code again I think the intent here was [0:48:20] to gauge the interest in doing that before making the application for fear of [0:48:26] getting to the end and not having it well-received again. [0:48:31] I think this is one piece of code that we do need to spend a little attention on. [0:48:36] I don't know that I would spend a lot of time in the actual code specifying what needs [0:48:42] to be on a landscape plan or not. [0:48:45] I think that can be done a lot of other ways besides in code. [0:48:47] I do think we need to talk about whether our landscaping is appropriate. [0:48:52] It's a bigger picture kind of a conversation do we have. [0:48:54] You know, he talks about some other communities in here that do a tree every 30 foot on center and ours doesn't say that [0:49:02] ours gets you to a number of trees and you can group them if you want [0:49:05] We have a lot more flexibility in our code than other cities do [0:49:10] I believe that's a strength of our code [0:49:12] But if what you want is a tree every 30 feet on center, that doesn't necessarily what you get with our code [0:49:18] So it's probably worth taking a little time to look at [0:49:22] along with like every other chapter in our code needs some time and attention so [0:49:30] how's that for not exactly what you asked me [0:49:36] I got an idea from it so thank you [0:49:40] Susanna do you have something here it's okay okay thank you boy Mitch thank you [0:49:45] very much I know and Jonathan I know this is really near and dear to a lot of [0:49:51] parts and it is something that is been an ongoing thing for a long time. The [0:49:59] continued dialogue and the continued updating I don't know maybe a whole new [0:50:05] title 10 thing is what's needed but is your job here tonight to open the [0:50:14] conversation or do you actually actually have some specific ideas that you're [0:50:20] moving forward? [0:50:21] Well, I think, like you were saying, that really the intention was to see if there was [0:50:28] any interest in this, obviously, if there's not, then I waste my time on it. [0:50:35] But if there is, yes, definitely, I think the two things that would help the most would [0:50:44] be to have specific requirements for who prepares the plans. So it's one of those knowledgeable [0:50:51] plans and irrigation systems. And then the second one is specific requirements on this [0:50:58] plan. And I think that would be a huge step in the right direction. And even though maybe [0:51:05] the whole title 10 needs to be reworked, that would be, I think you would see a great improvement [0:51:11] with just those specific things. [0:51:13] I'd be glad to volunteer some time to work with the staff [0:51:16] to maybe come up with some refurbishment [0:51:18] with everyone. [0:51:23] So in my opinion, really, bottom line [0:51:27] is what you're proposing is that we have a, [0:51:29] and what's the exact name, a landscape architect that [0:51:34] is employed by the city, that's a full-time staff member, [0:51:37] that goes through all as things come before, [0:51:43] with ZDA, somebody who is knowledgeable in the area, [0:51:48] the water requirements, the trees, the shrubs, [0:51:51] all of that, and who sees that too fruition. [0:51:55] Yeah, I don't know that Australia needs to be a landscape architect. [0:51:58] What's the, it might have a different name, [0:52:00] but it is a specific person on staff full-time that attends to that. [0:52:05] And necessarily? [0:52:07] Okay. [0:52:08] It seems like every city does it differently. [0:52:12] landscape architect would be one of those city art risk. [0:52:15] Most of the time, we see the planning department perform [0:52:22] that task with a little bit of training. [0:52:27] But then as far as review of the installation, [0:52:31] that should be performed by the designer. [0:52:35] I mean, that would be one way to do it. [0:52:36] Some cities do have their own planning staff [0:52:40] go and inspect the installations, or the city arborist. [0:52:48] Really seems to be somebody who's knowledgeable. [0:52:53] So the proposal that was up on the screen talks [0:52:56] about the plans being prepared by a qualified person. [0:53:00] We'll call it a landscape architect, [0:53:02] or qualified landscape designer, [0:53:05] or qualified nursery men, right? [0:53:07] And I'm a proponent of people drawing plans [0:53:09] that know what they're doing. [0:53:12] I'm not sure how many we have around here. [0:53:15] I don't really know that. [0:53:18] You might know that better than I do. [0:53:19] Well, I would challenge it. [0:53:21] I think you have quite a few global people [0:53:24] who are very well qualified, willing to say that most [0:53:31] of the nurseries have qualified people on staff. [0:53:35] And they probably already are drawing up these plans [0:53:39] to some degree, even though they might not be submitting [0:53:42] those specific plans for you. [0:53:46] And then the second part of that was the plan [0:53:49] And it comes in the staff and is reviewed by staff for compliance with City Code. [0:53:54] And then at the end of that process, we do send our planners out to do inspections. [0:53:58] And I would probably support what he's saying that when Jonathan or Kelly go out and look [0:54:03] at a tree that's been planted, I'm not sure that they could tell you if that was planted [0:54:09] correctly. [0:54:10] So it might be a good idea to have an inspection after installation by somebody who is a bit [0:54:20] more versed in those kinds of things, do those inspections, and then submit the letter [0:54:24] kind of thing afterwards. [0:54:26] My only concern would be like a third party kind of a thing, not the same one that did [0:54:32] the design or the installation, but somebody else. [0:54:37] That might be a really good addition to our code, but I don't know that we need to have [0:54:45] somebody on staff that's an L.A. or a nurseryman or whatever, probably we can probably accomplish [0:54:52] a lot of this without hiring an additional body or sending Jonathan to L.A. school. [0:55:02] Mr. Barid? [0:55:05] So when I saw this coming up, it was something that really intrigued me because we've discussed [0:55:09] water so often and conservation and the concern that people have of water and also bring me [0:55:16] back to days on planning and zoning. But landscape was just, it was difficult because plants [0:55:23] would come forward and you know half the council would think one thing, half the council would [0:55:28] think something else and we never really agreed in planning and zoning and that was always [0:55:32] a frustration for us. And so when Mitch you were talking about that it doesn't quite fit [0:55:37] And we want to make sure that it speaks to what's going on now, not 10, 20 years ago. [0:55:45] But also probably the biggest thing, and I'm completely in favor of this, is water conservation. [0:55:51] We need to look at that. [0:55:52] I know irrigation is a big issue. [0:55:57] As we look at it, maybe basic things, wrong sprinkler heads, things put in the wrong place. [0:56:04] I run in the mornings and it's amazing to me how often the streets being watered and the [0:56:09] grass is dead around it because those types of things yes that's maintenance but we need [0:56:13] to look at those to make sure that in years to come we're not looking back and thinking [0:56:20] man I wish we had done something so I'm I'm in complete favor of this Susan Hawkins thank [0:56:28] you I think it's always a good idea to look back at our codes and ordinances and make sure [0:56:33] that we're meeting best practices where we can a couple concerns I have first of all [0:56:38] as what the cost of hiring these people to do these jobs is going to do to the developers. [0:56:44] And I think it's important to be sensitive to the private property owners rights too. [0:56:49] And I like the fact that our code is flexible now. [0:56:52] Yes, they have to meet requirements for putting in landscaping. [0:56:58] But we give them a chance to have a little freedom in how they do that and it is their [0:57:02] property. [0:57:03] And it is their money that they're spending to do that for the community. [0:57:06] So I would just like to caution us that as we look at these things that we consider the [0:57:09] cost we're passing on to others because somebody has to pay for that inspection. [0:57:15] Somebody has to pay that planner to develop it and at the same time it is still their property [0:57:19] and I think we've done a pretty good job with some of our landscaping around town and people [0:57:25] meeting what they tell us on their plans that they're going to do. [0:57:28] I just want to be careful that we're not stepping on private property owners' rights and being [0:57:33] and so nitpicky that everything's down to the foot and the inch and that we try to make [0:57:37] everything the same. I like some of the variety we have around town. [0:57:44] I would share some of the concern of the expense whether it's on the private property owner or [0:57:49] the city itself. Having done a little bit of developing with the chamber facility, I can [0:57:58] tell you that it can get very expensive to have very detailed plans of where you're figuring [0:58:02] out where all of these things go and two years into it you may have a tree that isn't [0:58:09] doing so well and you go ask someone about it and they have a different opinion than the [0:58:12] guy who planned it the first time. [0:58:14] So I think finding some way to physically go out and inspect is this tree that was on [0:58:21] the plan designed to do exactly what it was supposed to do. [0:58:27] I do think that's beyond the full scope of what our planners should be doing when they're [0:58:31] out doing those inspections, but I also question whether there's an effectiveness to having [0:58:35] a sole person responsible for doing that. [0:58:41] I also would caution creating such burdensome regulations for development that we discourage [0:58:48] development. [0:58:49] Now, does it need to be more than the back of the napkin drawing of I'm going to throw [0:58:55] some gravel here and a shrub here? [0:58:58] Yes, but I think those conversations that our planners can have with those folks can accomplish [0:59:04] a lot of that short of having a here's all new section of code and a new requirement. [0:59:09] So I don't disagree that maybe to Mitch's point we need some attention to our landscape [0:59:15] code. [0:59:17] This information tonight to me feels like it's more about the plan and less about the end [0:59:23] result of what gets in the ground. [0:59:27] slides speak to who's doing the plan, how's the plan implemented, how's the plan [0:59:33] executed, how's the plan inspected, and you touch briefly on should we be looking [0:59:39] at more detail on the kinds of trees you're planting, some reference to shrubs and [0:59:44] those types of things, and to me that's probably the more important piece. So my [0:59:50] sentiment is this is already in the hopper, at least some piece of this, in our [0:59:56] ongoing review of the development codes and who knows maybe Mitch is going to [1:00:02] come back in a couple of months with a big giant proposal but it's going to [1:00:06] cost us to just rewrite the whole shooting match so I don't know that I [1:00:11] would be supportive of moving forward with this specific request or item not [1:00:22] saying don't go through the process but there is a process for that any other [1:00:30] Comments or questions? Anything else from you Mr. Prekin? [1:00:37] Thank you. [1:00:42] Next on the agenda is an update on the Twin Falls urban renewal agency main avenue redevelopment project. [1:00:47] We have Karen Robinson, our project manager. [1:00:52] Hello. [1:00:53] Good evening. [1:00:54] Mayor Council, it's a pleasure to be here again. [1:00:56] I do have a few photos to, but I'm sure as your will aware construction continues to be very active out there along main avenue. [1:01:14] A lot of progress is being made and have a few photos and some updates to share. [1:01:21] So this first photo is shown to good electrical cabinet. [1:01:26] Wires present would be pulled and landed for street lighting and the receptacles out there. [1:01:30] So the electrical work is well underway with a big emphasis to be ready in time for Oktoberfest. [1:01:35] So very sensitive to that and people working hard to that end. [1:01:40] So that's the primary activity going on between Shoshone and Fairfield. [1:01:44] The tree grates will be arriving this week, so this will be installed on that two block [1:01:51] section here soon as well. [1:01:53] The furnishings are being fabbed, so some of those finishing elements will go into place [1:02:00] here soon. [1:02:01] Next, we've got Shoshirod to Hanson, the concrete has gone down, it continues to go down, actually [1:02:06] there was another port just this afternoon, so just out in front of the temporary city hall. [1:02:11] So that's really starting to take shape, starting to look like a really beautiful block as well. [1:02:16] So that work will be ongoing with more concrete work preparing for asphalt in that nature. [1:02:24] So the utility work on Hanson Street, for the most part, is done, is completed, and road base is down, [1:02:32] being placed. And then from Hanson to Idaho, again preparing for concrete work is coming up, [1:02:41] and placement of a road base. [1:02:43] So just a little photo there showing that work. [1:02:48] And then a little bit of work going on at the Idaho intersection. [1:02:53] And that utility work is halfway done. [1:02:56] So portion done and a little bit more to do yet. [1:02:59] So I believe it's the electrical and irrigation utility work [1:03:03] that still needs to be done at that intersection. [1:03:07] Contractor is here in attendance. [1:03:09] So if there are some detailed questions, [1:03:10] We can bring representative from Guhoa Loaf. [1:03:15] They're keeping an eye on the weather. [1:03:18] We now are coming into that season where we could see some [1:03:20] rainy periods. [1:03:21] And I believe there's some being forecasted for the end of [1:03:23] the week. [1:03:23] So Guhoa's being very mindful of that and trying to schedule [1:03:27] the work appropriately, trying to button up and seal up some [1:03:30] of those areas that are disturbed right now in anticipation [1:03:32] of some wet weather coming, and then not getting too far ahead [1:03:36] of themselves, and then just working in really logical [1:03:39] fashion, so they're not opening and exposing and could put themselves in jeopardy when the [1:03:45] event came through. [1:03:46] So, that is one reason why the Idaho Jerome section has not been closed yet, not wanting [1:03:54] to get too far ahead of themselves. [1:03:55] But overall, the project is still tracking very well with the schedule, very close to [1:03:59] that original schedule that was produced. [1:04:04] That is, well, I guess two other factors or things to mention, the engraved bricks were [1:04:09] mentioned by the Rotary Club. [1:04:11] And so that layout is being finalized by the landscape [1:04:16] architect there. [1:04:17] And then also the lines club flags. [1:04:20] We are still discussing exactly how [1:04:22] to go about placement of those flags and holders [1:04:26] and things of that nature. [1:04:27] So most recently, the lines club approached some of the building [1:04:31] owners and asked if they would be supportive of a holder [1:04:34] on the side of the building. [1:04:36] And they were getting some mixed reactions [1:04:39] to some of the owners saying not really, not a big fan of something being attached to the [1:04:42] side of the building. [1:04:43] So we're taking a look at some other options. [1:04:45] So it's still being discussed, but we're working in lines of making sure we have their flags [1:04:50] accounted for. [1:04:51] Here for questions and also we're happy to bring Rob up from you, Mo. [1:04:58] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:04:59] Good evening. [1:05:00] I have a question on the bricks. [1:05:02] So are they going to be laid in a manner where you can just walk through and read them? [1:05:07] I know in Boise they put them in on different angles. [1:05:10] And it's impossible to read what's there. [1:05:13] So what we've talked about most recently is yes, they will be, I mean, the answers, yes, [1:05:17] they will be placed in a direction such that I believe the current discussion is as you're [1:05:22] looking at comments, that's how they will read. [1:05:26] And then laid out in a pattern to accommodate the space that we have to work with, with the [1:05:31] 300 or so bricks, but you'll be able to stand there if you have a little direction. [1:05:37] That is great. [1:05:38] Thank you. [1:05:39] Thank you, Boyd. [1:05:40] If people haven't bought bricks yet, but they'd like to, is there room for them? [1:05:44] Well, I have to defer to my rotary club friends. I believe there is room, but I believe that [1:05:53] this window for sales is closed. They may still be available online on the community [1:05:58] Foundation website unless they've taken it down very recently. [1:06:01] So I attend the community foundation meetings and I believe the bricks have already been [1:06:06] sent in to be engraved and so that was kind of the deadline because the add-on now would [1:06:12] cost extra possible but I think it's probably very difficult and more expensive. [1:06:18] Ruth Pierce. [1:06:19] So there would be two places to check. [1:06:21] I don't community foundation or the Twin Falls Rotary website because you could order [1:06:26] their Kevin Bradshaw, Travis Guast, Terry McCurdy, I mean the whole board would be available. [1:06:35] I think it's closed, but yeah, I saw an e-mail that had a list that was being referred to as the final list. [1:06:42] I'll say in line. [1:06:53] I'm asking for everybody who might, you know, not realize you. [1:06:57] Any other questions? Thank you. [1:07:02] Next on the agenda is a request to increase the already approved capital improvement project for [1:07:12] I have to say that I attended your class on harassment in the workplace, and I just saw that. [1:07:19] Mr. Mayor, members, council, thank you for giving me this opportunity tonight. [1:07:30] For those of you who don't know, my name is Brent Wright, and I'm the Staff Sergeant with the Police Department. [1:07:37] for giving me this opportunity tonight. [1:07:40] For those of you who don't know, my name is Brent Wright, [1:07:41] and I'm a Staff Sergeant with the Police Department. [1:07:44] And out of the many hats that I wear for the department, [1:07:46] one of them is the Field Commander [1:07:49] for our Special Weapons and Tactics Team work SWAT team. [1:07:53] So for FY 17, we requested a capital project [1:08:00] in the amount of $28,000 to buy replacement vests [1:08:04] for our current vests that were purchased in 2010. [1:08:08] Those best have the same warranty as the concealable armor that our officers wear, which is five years. [1:08:15] So they're currently out of warranty. [1:08:17] We're testing and evaluating multiple bests on the market. [1:08:27] And we finally came to the decision we wanted to point blank best. [1:08:33] That best is being worn by several agencies up in the Treasure Valley, Boise, [1:08:38] County, and they all really like the best. It is a little bit different from [1:08:46] what we have worn in the past. In the past we wore what's more of a traditional [1:08:51] tactical vest. It has a single rifle rated plate in the front and more [1:08:57] concealable body armor all the way around. The current point blank vest that [1:09:02] we're looking at is more of a hybrid between a plate carrier, which is the [1:09:06] military wares, which is just a plate in the front and plate in the back. This is [1:09:10] kind of a hybrid. It's a plate carrier with some side protection. That that cost [1:09:17] came in for the current 13 members of the team came in $10,402 more. So in the [1:09:27] other capital projects we have some savings and we're asking to be able to [1:09:31] use some of that savings to offset this shortage. Talk to Shane Carpenter today [1:09:39] I'm ready to make sure that I told you there is no blood to impact, it's already allocated funds. [1:09:48] Thank you, sir. [1:09:48] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:09:50] I'm ready to make. [1:09:53] I move that we approve the request to increase the capital improvement, but project for SWAT bulletproof protective vests from 28,000 to $38,402. [1:10:04] Second. [1:10:06] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins second by Nikki Boyd to approve the request as presented. [1:10:12] Is there any discussion? [1:10:15] Chair and roll call vote please. [1:10:18] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:10:19] Yes. [1:10:20] Greg Lanting. [1:10:21] Yes. [1:10:22] Ruth Pierce. [1:10:23] Yes. [1:10:24] Christopher Reed. [1:10:25] Yes. [1:10:25] Sean Bericher. [1:10:26] Yes. [1:10:27] Nicki Boyd. [1:10:28] Yes. [1:10:29] Motion passes 6 to 0. [1:10:30] Thank you. [1:10:31] Thank you, sir. [1:10:34] Next is a presentation to recognize [1:10:36] the achievements of three firefighters, Austin Sharpe, [1:10:39] who has completed his Twin Falls Fire Department Firefighter [1:10:42] Level 1 certification. [1:10:44] Firefighters Joe Rinaldi, Kyle Eldridge, and Austin Sharpe [1:10:47] their successful completion of this year's Twin Falls Drivers Academy. [1:10:52] Mitchell Brooks, Battalion Chief. Welcome sir. [1:10:59] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Good evening, Mayor and Council. I appreciate the [1:11:04] time to honor some of the achievements from these [1:11:08] three firefighters. This is organized here [1:11:19] so one of the three firefighters recently completed his first year with us. [1:11:23] His name is Austin Sharpe and I'd ask if Austin could come [1:11:27] front please. Front center face. So first of all I'd like to have Austin introduce [1:11:44] some of his family members here in the audience please. Unfortunately. Yeah, we'll take lots of pictures. Yeah. So Austin joined our [1:12:11] department July of last year. Prior to employment Austin served admirably with [1:12:16] the Air Force for four years and is happily married to his wife Ryan who's in [1:12:19] clinicals. So when you're a new recruit, you're issued a recruit helmet shield to [1:12:24] wear until this day comes in or issued a new one that says firefighter on it. So [1:12:28] this is an example of what he has been wearing for the last year. So says [1:12:33] recruit, it's purple, not my favorite color, probably not his either, but his helmet [1:12:40] gets decorated with purple stickers as well. So it basically gives us an idea of [1:12:45] of where those new recruits are at all times, so. [1:12:48] It's kind of like a beaming of the first one in college. [1:12:53] That's it. [1:12:54] So Austin has not only shown that he has the skills and abilities to perform the duties [1:12:59] and ask of a firefighter, but has earned the trust of everyone on the department. [1:13:04] We're certainly very fortunate to have Mr. Sharp on our team. [1:13:08] At this time, I would ask you, Mr. Mayor, to issue Austin as firefighter level one certificate [1:13:14] And with us his current engine company to come forward and issue him his helmet with new shield [1:13:38] Picture everybody's good over here. So you probably ought to come up here and be in the picture [1:14:16] He's been dying to have that [1:14:26] Anything but purple [1:14:28] Okay, also our annual driver's academy kicked off in May of this year and just recently [1:14:36] finished in late August. [1:14:38] This academy involves over 100 hours of training and covers defensive driving, hump theory, [1:14:44] tender brush truck operations, fire ground pumping, tower operations, airport rescue, [1:14:51] and equipment maintenance. [1:14:53] This has proven to be an excellent program that all of our driver's captains and battalion [1:14:56] chiefs have been through in some point in their career. [1:15:00] I introduced the graduating class of 17. [1:15:02] I would like to acknowledge the two instructors. [1:15:06] As a former instructor, I know how much work goes into this program [1:15:09] and certainly appreciate their efforts. [1:15:11] So I would like to introduce Fred McDonald, his dean back, and Joelle Miller. [1:15:30] These two are excellent operators. [1:15:32] And I look forward to them becoming officers in the future. [1:15:39] So the instructors have a role to educate the guys on the basics. [1:15:41] and then they turn the students loose and have them participate with their [1:15:45] engine companies or practice. I want to thank that all the engine company [1:15:48] officers for their help in getting these guys where they're at. So at this time I'd [1:15:53] like to ask Joe Renaldi, Kyle Eldridge, and star of tonight's presentation Austin [1:15:59] Sharp to the front please. Pretty good looking guys right here. So both Renaldi [1:16:18] and Eldridge started their careers with the fire department in February last year. [1:16:22] Joe is accompanied by his girlfriend, [1:16:24] Karrish Hatridge and grandmother Jane, [1:16:27] did she get to make it? [1:16:29] Okay, and yeah, if you could introduce her please. [1:16:37] Welcome. [1:16:40] Joe's had a very productive year, [1:16:41] completing his firefighter level one certification, [1:16:45] a semester of EMT school, [1:16:46] which I got to participate with him with. [1:16:49] And now the driver's academy. [1:16:51] And the one thing I do like about Joe the best [1:16:53] is definitely his hair. [1:16:55] Oh. [1:16:56] It doesn't matter day or night. [1:16:59] It always looks just like that, so he's fortunate. [1:17:08] So Kyle Eldridge is accompanied by his wife, Paige, [1:17:11] and son, Brinson. [1:17:13] Are there any others? [1:17:26] Welcome, thanks for coming. [1:17:30] Kyle is a highly motivated individual [1:17:32] and has a strong background in the medical field. [1:17:36] One of my personal areas of responsibilities is EMS. [1:17:40] And I'm certainly fortunate to have Kyle as one of my guys [1:17:42] helping me with that project. [1:17:43] So thank you. [1:17:46] One thing I can say about all three of these guys [1:17:47] standing in front of us is that they are highly [1:17:49] motivated individuals, and I'm very excited to see [1:17:52] what their future has to hold for them. [1:17:54] So at this time I'd ask you, Mr. Mayor, [1:17:56] to issue them, their Driver's Academy certificates? [1:18:56] Okay, so I was just gonna mention that I think you all [1:19:00] need to spend a little bit more time working on the [1:19:02] camaraderie and brotherhood amongst the firefighters, [1:19:05] and doesn't seem to be much checked. [1:19:07] Look, congratulations to all of you, [1:19:10] and thank you again for your service to our community. [1:19:12] Greg Lanthing? [1:19:14] Well, I was gonna do this during the board reports [1:19:17] at the end, but I had the honor of attending [1:19:19] the firefighters ball on Friday night. [1:19:24] And somebody had been doing a lot of work [1:19:28] getting items for the raffle without a doubt, [1:19:31] because there were amazing number of things there, [1:19:34] and I thought it was, [1:19:35] it's for the proceeds that would go to their burnout fund, [1:19:38] themselves, people, if they're burned down their home, do you hotel rooms and the different [1:19:42] things to help them get back home, get their life together after such a commanding event. [1:19:48] I appreciate the invite to being able to go and have a great time and even one of the baskets. [1:19:55] Thank you. [1:19:58] Mr. Mayor, before you begin the next one, just from a matter of kind of logistics, as we kind [1:20:04] to move forward so staff would recommend that you would go forward, you do the board reports, [1:20:11] you would do the citizen input piece, you make a motion to adjourn into executive session [1:20:17] and then we can go do outside of the building, do the show and tell and so that you don't [1:20:22] have to come back to the dais and then take those motions as well. [1:20:26] Is that all right with you, Italian? [1:20:28] Absolutely. [1:20:29] All right. [1:20:30] So are there any other advisory report reports from members of the council, Suzanne Hawkins? [1:20:34] Thank you. [1:20:35] Tonight was our fall kickoff for the Twin Falls City Youth Council, and I am very excited [1:20:39] to announce we had 19 new members join tonight, and we had one come back, and I had 11 of [1:20:47] the students put their names in for executive positions that we will vote on next month. [1:20:51] So it was really exciting, and I do want to say thank you to Josh Palmer. [1:20:55] I don't see him since I had to leave our meeting a little early to get here until we all get [1:20:59] back downtown together again. [1:21:01] He stepped in and finished the meeting for me, so I appreciate the help from City staff. [1:21:07] Great news, Suzanne, thank you. [1:21:09] Anyone else from the Council? [1:21:12] So just a quick reminder to the members of the Council, we do have, we are hosting the [1:21:17] Magibae Legislative Tour in the Valley. [1:21:20] I actually spent all day today out in the Minicazia area with about 36 legislators who are participating [1:21:26] in the event. [1:21:27] So tomorrow will be in the Twin Falls and Jerome area, and we do have a dinner schedule with [1:21:32] them tomorrow evening, as well as the lunch on Wednesday. [1:21:36] It was interactive days already. [1:21:38] So just a reminder on that. [1:21:40] Travis, anything from you? [1:21:43] Yes, Suzanne? [1:21:44] Sorry, I forgot. [1:21:45] I would just like to make sure that everyone in the community has a chance to know that this [1:21:49] Friday night at 5.30 at Harmon Park, there will be a ceremony to honor our MIAPOWs. [1:21:57] So everybody's invited to come out and spend a few minutes in honor of those from our community that have never made it home. [1:22:04] Thank you, Suzanne. [1:22:06] And again, another opportunity for general public input. [1:22:10] Anyone here from the public wishing to address the council on an item that was not on the agenda this evening, now's your chance to come forward. [1:22:18] Seeing no one, I would entertain then a motion for adjournment to executive session under Idaho Code 742061B [1:22:28] to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining of, [1:22:31] or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, [1:22:34] employee, staff member, or individual, agent, or public school student. [1:22:39] Greg Lant. [1:22:40] I move that we adjourn into Executive Session under ADO Code 74-206-1B [1:22:47] for the items that you listed. [1:22:49] I'll second that. [1:22:51] Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce to adjourn into Executive Session [1:22:55] as presented as any discussion. [1:22:58] Chair and roll call vote, please. [1:23:03] Greg Lanting. [1:23:04] Yes. [1:23:05] Ruth Pierce. [1:23:06] Yes. [1:23:07] Christopher Reed. [1:23:08] Yes. [1:23:09] Sean Berriger. [1:23:10] Yes. [1:23:11] Nikki Boyd. [1:23:12] Yes. [1:23:13] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:23:14] Yes. [1:23:15] Motion passes 6 to 0. [1:23:17] So we are going to pop out and see [1:23:19] the Show and Tell presentation, which [1:23:21] is showcasing the new Battalion Chief Command Vehicle [1:23:25] Rescue 2 and Brush 1. [1:23:28] And then we will adjourn into executive session [1:23:31] Just a reminder, we will not be making any decisions [1:23:33] in executive session, nor will we be reconvening [1:23:37] following that session. [1:23:38] With that, we're adjourned. [1:23:49] They are nice and shiny, aren't they? [1:23:51] They look good. [1:23:58] That's time for a new phone. [1:23:59] But.