Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-09-05, recording 1 (started 15:28) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-09-05/ [0:00:09] Good evening. I'd like to call the order of the Twin Paul City Council meeting for [0:00:17] the bus stop in just a moment. For Tuesday September 5th, it is 3.30. We are meeting early to go over [0:00:30] and tour the public safety complex and the new city hall building. So we will continue on the [0:00:37] regular agenda when we get back at, do we have to wait until five for that part? [0:00:44] At five o'clock. So we'll go take our tour now. So we'll recess to that. Good [1:28:46] evening. I'd like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Tuesday [1:28:50] September 5th. We did call the meeting in order at 3.30 and then went over and [1:28:54] did a tour of the new public safety complex and city hall buildings and [1:29:00] we'll have a report on that a little bit later in the agenda. So I would confirm we [1:29:04] Do you have a quorum in the council here, six of the seven members present this evening, [1:29:10] Vice Mayor Suzanne Hawkins is excused. [1:29:13] Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [1:29:15] Those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [1:29:22] To the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one [1:29:29] nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. [1:29:39] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening? [1:29:43] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments this evening, but we do want [1:29:46] to go on the record to clarify that we did send out a revised agenda this morning. [1:29:53] The purpose of the revised agenda is for an Executive Session 742061B as in boy for the [1:30:02] evaluation of an employee. [1:30:06] I do apologize to the Mayor to ask me to put that on the agenda. [1:30:09] for my evaluation, and I decided not to, no, and it was... [1:30:14] Do we know that? [1:30:16] He was mistakenly left off, and over the weekend I had that moment of remembrance, and so we [1:30:25] put that on first thing, so we just wanted to let the public know that that is for the [1:30:31] beginning of the city manager's evaluation. [1:30:33] Thank you, Travis. [1:30:35] We have no proclamations on the agenda this evening, so next would be an opportunity for [1:30:39] for general public input. [1:30:41] This is a chance for the public to address the council [1:30:43] on items that are not on the agenda this evening. [1:30:47] There's anyone wishing to address the council? [1:30:54] Seeing no one, Chris Stockington. [1:30:56] Well, I'd like to make a little personal play for people [1:31:01] to keep my old home state of Puerto Rico in the memory. [1:31:05] We have a category five hurricane Irma [1:31:09] that is 50 miles, due to go 50 miles north of the coast, [1:31:14] 185 mile an hour winds, 10 foot surge currents. [1:31:20] Last report I got this afternoon is Puerto Rico, [1:31:23] by the way, is not recovered from the 2007 or eight recession. [1:31:29] A lot of the infrastructure is crumbling, [1:31:30] people are leaving the island, [1:31:32] but they're saying that there may be places [1:31:34] where power will be out four to six months. [1:31:37] So it's a very small microcosm of the world, [1:31:40] but keep it in your prayers as we have the people [1:31:45] that are recovering from Hurricane Harvey. [1:31:48] And watch out for it. [1:31:50] I'm sure it comes. [1:31:52] Thank you, Chris. [1:31:54] Next on the agenda is the consent calendar. [1:31:57] Council wishes. [1:31:58] Nikki Boyd, did you have a question you wanted to ask? [1:32:00] I didn't even get to turn my line off. [1:32:02] It's been on there. [1:32:03] I can't even read my mind. [1:32:07] I do have a question. [1:32:10] in the accounts payable under capital [1:32:16] in the police department. [1:32:20] We've got an expenditure of 88,560 and we had 74 budgeted. [1:32:27] Did we have a conversation here recently? [1:32:30] Were they proposed that where we came up, [1:32:34] where we had that other money? [1:32:36] I'm not remembering. [1:32:37] So I don't remember the conversation occurring [1:32:41] before the city council, [1:32:42] making back at the chief. [1:32:45] But prior to we had conversations internally [1:32:48] and we reviewed the police department's budget, [1:32:50] we were able to determine that they have savings [1:32:53] in other parts of the budget [1:32:54] to be able to move forward with that acquisition. [1:32:58] The amount that they had budgeted was not enough [1:33:01] to cover the complete cost of the project. [1:33:03] So that fully covered, [1:33:05] and that is a computer program, chief, evidence? [1:33:12] to your lease payment? [1:33:15] Welcome Chief. [1:33:16] Thank you. [1:33:17] Mayor, Council, Councilperson Boyd. [1:33:20] That is our annual payment for the Axon Body War and Camera Program. [1:33:25] So that is our payment for this coming year's evidence.com [1:33:31] through Axon and the Body War and Camera Program. [1:33:34] Okay, thank you very much. [1:33:36] You're very welcome. [1:33:39] And excuse me, the City Manager did ask me to share something. [1:33:43] Well, we first put the budget together over a year ago. [1:33:47] We weren't exactly sure. [1:33:49] So that's the reason for the difference [1:33:51] of what the cost was. [1:33:52] But we do have money within our budget that's covering that. [1:33:57] Thank you. [1:33:58] Thank you, Chief. [1:34:00] Chris Reed. [1:34:01] I move that we approve the consent calendar. [1:34:03] Sure. [1:34:04] It's OK. [1:34:06] The motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Nikki Boyd, [1:34:07] to approve the consent calendar as presented. [1:34:10] Is there any further discussion? [1:34:12] Sharon, roll call vote, please. [1:34:24] John Barrieger, Nikki Boyd, Greg Lanting, Ruth Pierce, Christopher Reed, Chris Tockington. [1:34:37] Motion passes six to zero. We were all delayed there with our technology. [1:34:48] Under items of consideration, the first is a request to confirm the appointment of Daryl [1:34:52] Allen, Easterling, and reappointments of Debbie Latin and Lucy Wills to the Historic Preservation [1:34:58] Commission. So, Andrew Dunn was appointed to the Historic Preservation Commission in July [1:35:22] of 2016 to serve a full three-year term, but due to conflicts in his school and work schedules, [1:35:27] he had to resign. So City staff did post the vacancy notice for the position and the staff [1:35:33] received one application with an interest in serving on the Historic Preservation Commission. [1:35:39] I've advertised the vacancy a second time or received one more application. [1:35:43] We had an interview panel that consisted of the Historic Preservation Commission Chair, [1:35:47] Nancy Taylor, Councilwoman Ruth Pierce, Kelly Weeks from the Planning Department, and I interviewed [1:35:54] the individuals. [1:35:56] And the interview panel felt that the two applicants were very qualified to serve on the HPC, but [1:36:01] we recommend that Alan Easterling be appointed to the commission. [1:36:07] It would be a two-year appointment to complete the current vacant term, and then the appointee [1:36:12] would be eligible for two full three-year terms for reappointment following the act could serve [1:36:19] up to eight years on the commission. [1:36:21] Debbie Latin recently completed her first full term on the commission. [1:36:24] She was appointed in February of 2013 to finish a previous term that had ended in July of 2014. [1:36:32] She was reappointed in 2014 to serve her first full three-year term. [1:36:36] she is eligible for and has requested reappointment to the commission. [1:36:40] She's a business owner in the historic residential district. [1:36:42] Her passion for the historic preservation is a great asset to the commission and [1:36:45] her attendance to the meetings and extracurricular activities has been excellent. [1:36:50] Lucy Wills recently completed her appointment of a partial term and [1:36:55] was appointed in January of 2016 to finish filling a three-year term that [1:36:59] ended in July of 2017. [1:37:02] she too has requested reappointment to the commission and her reappointment should the [1:37:07] council confirm it will be for her first full three-year term. It will be eligible for [1:37:11] another three-year term following completion of that one. This is like a long story problem. [1:37:16] It's a big math question. So Lucy as well has had excellent attendance to the meetings [1:37:24] and extracurricular activities and so I would ask for council consideration of the appointment [1:37:32] of Allen Easterling and the reappointments [1:37:34] of Debbie Latin and Lucy Wills as presented. [1:37:36] Greg Lanting. [1:37:38] I move that we appoint Daryl Allen Easterling [1:37:41] to fulfill the partial term of two additional years [1:37:46] and the reappointment of Debbie Latin and Lucy Wills [1:37:49] to the historic preservation commission. [1:37:51] Second. [1:37:52] The motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce [1:37:55] to approve the appointments. [1:37:57] Is there any discussion? [1:38:00] I should note that Allen is here this evening. [1:38:02] If anybody has any questions, they'd like to grill him on. [1:38:05] Notice I don't know where you're going to do that. [1:38:06] So is Lucy. [1:38:07] And Lucy as well. [1:38:10] All right, seeing no further discussion. [1:38:12] Chair and roll call vote, please. [1:38:15] Nikki Boyd, yes. [1:38:17] Greg Lanting. [1:38:18] Yes. [1:38:19] Ruth Pierce. [1:38:19] Yes. [1:38:22] Christopher Reed. [1:38:22] Yes. [1:38:23] Chris Tockington. [1:38:24] Yes. [1:38:25] Sean Berriger. [1:38:26] Yes. [1:38:27] Motion passes 6-0. [1:38:30] Alan, would you like to say a couple words? [1:38:33] Well, it's censure here, and Nancy as well, and Lucy. [1:38:37] Thank you. [1:38:38] Welcome. [1:38:39] About myself, I guess. [1:38:44] Sure. [1:38:45] Sure. [1:38:45] Please. [1:38:46] I'm a fifth generation Magic Valley person. [1:38:54] Great, great, great. [1:38:55] Grandpa, I guess, helps settle the salmon track. [1:38:58] Been really active in history in Magic Valley history [1:39:01] since I was a small kid. [1:39:04] When my grandpa was one of the founding members of Francis [1:39:07] and we're kind of going out and picking up square nails and stuff like that. [1:39:11] I started working one chance and she was when I was 18 years old and I kind of moved out through the company. [1:39:16] She sells officer there now. [1:39:18] And we have a business on Main Street and I started walking Main Street [1:39:23] about a year ago and just in walking and after the trees were cut down, [1:39:29] kind of looking at the buildings and talking with our CEO, Tony Prater, [1:39:32] about kind of the history behind some of them and things like that [1:39:35] I saw the newspaper ad come up, I just kind of felt that that was a great calling for me and I do love history, but I still understand the business side of it and want to move forward and make sure that the community does continue to move forward while we're on our path. [1:39:50] That's why I did it. [1:39:53] Thank you and welcome. [1:39:54] Chris talking to us. [1:39:57] I'd be really curious, not only at your perspective, [1:40:01] but Debbie and Nancy, Lucy and Nancy. [1:40:07] What we can do to emphasize the true, unique nature [1:40:11] of the turning on the water in the springtime, [1:40:16] your great-grandfather was at the work in the salmon track. [1:40:19] Oh, yeah. [1:40:19] This is my personal opinion, that we have not given enough [1:40:23] attention to that turning on the water, an annual event, [1:40:26] that has made us through the private and the public investment [1:40:30] is the most successful irrigation system [1:40:33] and not only in this country but the world. [1:40:36] And I know the canal company has done something, [1:40:39] but I would really like to have your thoughts either now [1:40:42] or later or what we can do to really start maximizing [1:40:46] the historical importance of that event. [1:40:48] I would love to look into that. [1:40:50] My great-grandpa was Fred Huggs, who actually helped [1:40:54] did a lot of the canal structure for that. So I mean, without looking into it, you know, [1:41:02] I can't give a great answer, but I think that that's something that we definitely should [1:41:06] focus on, you know, water is what made the valley. [1:41:10] So that means he probably was involved with the draft horses pulling the Fresno's dick [1:41:15] and the canals on that. Yeah, that's cool. I like that. [1:41:21] Well, I would just certainly want the other people to speak as well, but I would say the assignments we have as council, I think my favorite was the historic preservation commission and should I be successful in this election coming up here. [1:41:40] I think I'm going to ask to be back on there. [1:41:42] Everybody's had a shot. [1:41:43] I think Mike. [1:41:44] Thank you. [1:41:45] There might be a fight. [1:41:46] Yeah. [1:41:47] It's pretty fun. [1:41:48] Nancy makes it fun. [1:41:50] Thank you. [1:41:51] Thank you, Ellen, Lucy, did you have anything you want to say or an answer? [1:41:55] I just wanted to say that that's a great idea, Chris. [1:41:58] I think that that would probably be a joint effort with the city and the county. [1:42:05] Yeah. [1:42:06] Give us some thought. [1:42:11] I just want to say we have such a strong commission. [1:42:13] Now I'm so happy about it. [1:42:16] In the past year, we have really made an effort. [1:42:20] Now we have two more overlay districts, which we have authority over. [1:42:23] over and that was our five-year plan in our goal. [1:42:28] So now we are truly, truly able to look at every historic building, [1:42:33] every historic piece of land, and deal with it on that level. [1:42:39] I've heard so many people say when the trees came down on Main Street, [1:42:43] now you see the buildings. [1:42:46] And I'm happy to report that most business owners are stepping up, [1:42:50] and they're trying to renovate their properties [1:42:53] and new signage, Tony is one of them putting up a new sign. [1:42:58] So we just have a commission that is just absolutely committed [1:43:02] to what we're doing and we're very, very proud of them. [1:43:06] Thank you, Nancy. [1:43:10] Excuse her. [1:43:12] We're about as a story as you can get for about it. [1:43:16] I wanted to say that I just came from the school district [1:43:20] administration building, and you can really see that building, [1:43:24] not only did they remove the trees, [1:43:26] they removed some of those bushes right in front. [1:43:29] It looks so awesome. [1:43:31] That's pretty cool. [1:43:34] And Kelly, you're here here on Wonder Gal. [1:43:37] Yeah, she won't get a picture. [1:43:39] Congratulations. [1:43:47] Thank you all. [1:43:49] And next on the agenda is a request [1:43:50] to approve the purchase of a historic reproduction [1:43:53] of Shoshone Falls on the Snake River, [1:43:55] city manager Travis Rothmiler. [1:43:57] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening. [1:43:59] And the piece of artwork, the reference is before you, [1:44:05] and we were able to bring that in this evening [1:44:08] to show you what we may have the opportunity to purchase [1:44:14] as we move forward and look at our new city hall. [1:44:19] So inside of the staff report, the background was provided. [1:44:22] And it was really an illustration. [1:44:24] Now in 2007, there was this grand vision [1:44:27] of a geotourism center that was going to showcase the American West, the settling, the [1:44:35] exploration, the artwork, and it was going to be an interpretive center. However, when [1:44:40] they went through and they built the space and the facility, what it finally came to [1:44:45] be, they removed the art. And the art did not have a location, but yet in that process [1:44:51] there were more than 20 pieces that were commissioned as a part of this process and this project [1:44:56] to be included. [1:44:58] And so this and several other pieces of art, [1:45:02] are sitting at a storage facility over in Eastern Idaho. [1:45:06] And the individual reached out to us [1:45:09] and asked because of the nature of the piece of work, [1:45:14] would we be interested, in fact, they've [1:45:16] worked, reached out specifically to the mayor, [1:45:18] saying would we be interested in acquiring this piece? [1:45:23] And so we thought a little bit about it, [1:45:25] And we said, you know, there's an opportunity [1:45:27] to maybe hang this piece and other pieces of art [1:45:30] inside of our new city hall, the building [1:45:33] that you had a chance to tour. [1:45:34] You notice that there is lots of white space, lots of wall [1:45:40] space that we could really kind of [1:45:42] sprucing up those walls with some interesting art, not only [1:45:47] this piece, but if you should elect to acquire it, [1:45:51] but also pieces from other local and regional artists [1:45:55] throughout the entire area. [1:45:57] So many of you may know, I think, but you know, [1:46:01] my father's an artist, and my father being an artist [1:46:05] would often tell you that a white wall is a naked wall, [1:46:08] and that you should really place artwork in areas [1:46:13] because it really does create a new and dynamic experience [1:46:16] for individuals who are entering into your place. [1:46:18] In fact, when we were building City Hall, [1:46:20] just as a side note, my father said, [1:46:22] I hope that you have the appropriate spotlights that you can shine on the art so that you can [1:46:28] actually bring out the characters of the art because fluorescence don't do that well. [1:46:36] So Michael, don't disappoint my father. [1:46:41] So one of the questions that we often get asked is, well, how would we pay for this unbudgeted [1:46:45] project and what we have inside of our budget is we have a amount of money that on an annual [1:46:51] basis we put aside for the acquisition of public art. We've never gone through a process [1:46:58] to define what is public art. We've never said that it has to be a statue, it has to be [1:47:06] in a park, it has to be on public display. Really what we've done is we've set aside funding [1:47:12] on an annual basis that we could use to acquire art and we've done that. Should the council [1:47:18] be interested in acquiring this piece, staff's recommendation would be to hang this in City [1:47:26] Hall in a prominent location that it could be enjoyed by all members of the community. [1:47:32] Right now we have about nearly $16,000 on the small side of monies available in the Public [1:47:40] Art Fund. [1:47:41] You'll recall that we spent all significant portion of that at the beautiful piece out [1:47:46] at five points. [1:47:48] The reason I say that that's small is because there was an allocation that was, additional [1:47:52] allocation that was provided to Wendy through Parks and Recreation and we don't believe that [1:47:57] entire allocation is going to be expended, but all of the processes aren't complete yet. [1:48:02] So that will add to that. [1:48:04] And then there's also on an annual basis amount usually close between $65,000 and $7,000 that's [1:48:11] connected to our capital fund that we place into this fund on an annual basis. [1:48:17] So it's a percentage of total capital spent to the general fund that we spent. [1:48:20] So with that we're happy to stand for any questions, but we wanted to present this opportunity [1:48:26] to you for your consideration as it was presented to us. [1:48:31] Thank you, Travis. [1:48:32] And I believe we also have a couple of members of the community who might like to speak to [1:48:36] this issue this evening as well. [1:48:53] It's not a large crowd I suppose I could just invite you out. [1:49:02] Travis. [1:49:07] So, Art, if you would like to come up and speak. [1:49:10] So, I would just ask the, please keep your comments brief [1:49:14] into this topic, and then we'll turn it over [1:49:18] to the Council for some discussion. [1:49:20] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:22] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:26] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:27] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:29] because I hadn't heard about this project before. [1:49:31] I think we have a Arts Commission [1:49:33] that makes recommendations on public art, [1:49:36] And I don't recall anything going on in that regard. [1:49:40] I agree 100% with Travis, and this is a great reproduction here, well worth the money. [1:49:49] But I guess my consideration would be, is there something else that we want to spend this [1:49:54] amount of money on? [1:49:55] There's a lot of local artists available, and it'd be nice to commission a local artist [1:50:00] to do a master, a main piece for the city hall. [1:50:04] So my recommendation is that we kind of hold off just a bit [1:50:07] and see if there's somebody that's really interested [1:50:09] in doing a nice piece for the city hall [1:50:12] that will use our local artist and promote our local arts. [1:50:18] I see this painting around quite a bit. [1:50:20] There's a lot of prints that have been sold of this [1:50:22] over the years at the library. [1:50:24] Did a fundraiser a few years ago with this. [1:50:26] So I would say, rather than jumping in [1:50:29] and saying yes, let's get it, let's send it back off [1:50:31] and see what other possibilities are out for this. [1:50:34] Thank you. [1:50:35] Thank you, Art. [1:50:38] And next is it, is it Galene? [1:50:44] Excellent. [1:50:45] If you would just, when you get up here to the microphone, [1:50:47] if you could state your name for the record, I'd appreciate it. [1:50:51] No, no. [1:50:53] Thank you. [1:50:54] It's Galene Zambic. [1:50:57] And I'm a local artist. [1:50:59] In fact, I'm very local. [1:51:00] I was raised and born a night. [1:51:02] Burley, went to school in Shoshone, my high school, but I've been doing art for, I don't [1:51:11] know how many years, but I have a piece that I think you should consider. [1:51:19] I brought it with me, but it's still my heart. [1:51:24] But it's up, Shoshone falls. [1:51:27] And it's kind of a historic piece because I did it, I oil painted it 20 years ago, this [1:51:36] June, when the water, we had a national, all time record high, like 33,300 in some [1:51:47] odd cubic feet. [1:51:49] And it was 20 years ago that it did this. [1:51:53] So that was kind of like, wow, 20 years. [1:51:57] Anyway, I really would like to have you consider it. [1:52:01] My painting is a whole lot cheaper than that, [1:52:04] and he's not a local resident. [1:52:07] He's out of the country, I don't think he ever visited Idaho again [1:52:12] after that. [1:52:14] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:52:18] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:52:20] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:52:24] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:52:30] my art piece would probably go for, [1:52:33] if you had it framed and matted, [1:52:36] like similar to the one I've got, [1:52:38] it's probably the high side would be maybe 500. [1:52:43] Not only that, [1:52:46] can't just use to have one at the city chamber [1:52:50] or whatever it's called out there on the road. [1:52:52] Chamber of Commerce. [1:52:53] Yeah. [1:52:54] And then I used to have prints at the visitor center, [1:52:58] but like they said when they changed the visitor center, [1:53:01] that went south. [1:53:04] So I haven't sold prints for a long time. [1:53:07] Can't used to sell prints out of the chamber of commerce too. [1:53:13] So you could sell prints, you know, and make some money. [1:53:19] For future art, I don't know, you know, but you could. [1:53:24] So that makes it more available than that one. [1:53:29] I have a limited edition of Prince of 2000. [1:53:34] So. [1:53:36] Thank you. [1:53:37] Yep. [1:53:38] You want me to bring in that painting so you can see it? [1:53:41] Well, so we're discussing this one here this evening. [1:53:43] We'll see what happens here with the discussion. [1:53:46] OK. [1:53:48] So that's the only folks I had signed up to speak. [1:53:51] Nancy, would you like to give some brief comments, please? [1:53:55] Just to update the council, Mayor and the council. [1:53:58] The Historic Preservation Commission was approached by the management of the Wells Fargo branch [1:54:03] down here, wanting to donate their photos and prints from the bank to us, which would [1:54:10] then, of course, become city property. [1:54:13] We haven't seen them yet, Kelly is going to get in touch with them. [1:54:20] We've tried but haven't gotten an answer, so we're anticipating lots more art. [1:54:24] We also, the developers of the new city council, the new city administration building have offered [1:54:32] the HPC historic preservation commission wall space to do a revolving art, history art pieces. [1:54:42] So depending on the size of those, we'll do rotating art, depicting our history from [1:54:48] the beginning and then we'll go decade by decade and then start it over again. [1:54:53] So we will have those art pieces. [1:54:56] I personally think this is beautiful. [1:54:58] I think with all the wall space you're going to have, it's perfect. [1:55:04] I appreciate the fact that you want to look at local artists, however there are artists [1:55:09] that are not so local that do fabulous work. [1:55:13] So we need to look at that from a historic value of the picture itself. [1:55:19] But we do have some artwork to be donated and we'll keep you posted. [1:55:24] Thank you Nancy. [1:55:26] Chris talking to. [1:55:27] Just a little more perspective on the Thomas Moran piece. [1:55:30] I was on the library board with Dave Mead for those last centuries whenever that was. [1:55:37] It came to retention about the original sitting in the museum in Tulsa, Oklahoma. [1:55:43] It is only expense day went back and took pictures and viewed the picture, which I think [1:55:49] was close to 15 feet long. [1:55:51] I think this is about a half size on the thing. [1:55:54] The library board was so taken by the presentation, that's how we went into the lithos of reproducing [1:56:01] and sewing them for raising money for the library. [1:56:04] I have no idea how many are sold. [1:56:06] you've had one in our house for ever long as taken, but the library board and historic preservation [1:56:14] efforts I think really are important to maximize the knowledge. This is a 117 year old perspective [1:56:23] of the formation of nature's formation of the entire Canyon complex in Twin Falls. I personally [1:56:34] think there's room for both for us to acquire this our new city hall to have a space for local [1:56:41] artists of the same or different subjects. I don't think it's an either or or how to put a value on [1:56:47] a piece of art like this. I don't know except it is pretty historical perspective on this worth [1:56:55] remembering and keeping and I'd be very supportive of spending up to that amount of money for this [1:57:02] just a copy further discussion from we can't speak. [1:57:08] I guess the question that I would have is, [1:57:11] does this need to be decided today? [1:57:13] Is there a timetable in which we have to purchase this? [1:57:19] It sounds like, and I don't know, [1:57:21] that maybe there's a process for approving artwork, [1:57:24] maybe there isn't. [1:57:25] Is that the case? [1:57:27] Is this something that can go through that process? [1:57:29] Or the group who currently owns that, [1:57:32] they said, hey, we need to know by the end of this week, [1:57:35] kind of what does that look like, [1:57:37] because there is a lot of wall space in the new city hall. [1:57:45] So in terms of a timeline, I wouldn't say that there is, [1:57:49] but I think that there's probably an expectation [1:57:52] that we would be making a decision [1:57:56] prior to hanging it on a wall. [1:58:00] In terms of, certainly we value the partnerships [1:58:04] that we have, but we don't have an approval process [1:58:10] or third party group to utilize. [1:58:13] I know that we've worked in partnership [1:58:15] with the Arts Council, but there's nothing [1:58:17] that I'm aware of in our ordinances [1:58:21] that would dictate that you would go there [1:58:25] like a planning and zoning decision [1:58:27] or a traffic safety commission like we've done in the past. [1:58:32] Certainly we've utilized their thoughts [1:58:34] and value their opinions and you can certainly ask them to weigh in whether it be on this piece [1:58:41] or the formation of a public art policy which I think would be, you know, as we look at the [1:58:49] acquisition of more public art whether it be for facilities or for open space and locations [1:58:57] I think that having clear guidance and understanding except by the council would probably provide [1:59:02] staff of good direction. Okay. Thank you. Nicky Boyd? I also think that there's room to do this and I think City Hall is a fabulous place and all of downtown to have as much public art, local artist exposure down there as we can possibly do. I think there's so many people that need to learn more about what we have here locally. This is incredibly [1:59:31] incredibly historic, this is a man who came through and charted this part of the country. [1:59:38] And I would agree that we could acquire this and also move forward with other pieces and [1:59:47] continue to do that. [1:59:51] Any other discussion from the Council? [1:59:55] Chris, I can all flow to motion before us to approve the expenditure of up to the 7900? [2:00:02] Yeah, but the Thomas Moran, 1900, [2:00:07] Shoshone Falls replication of the painting. [2:00:12] I'll second it. [2:00:14] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd [2:00:16] to approve the purchase of this particular piece. [2:00:20] Greg Lanting. [2:00:21] Well, the only question I would have is I certainly agree [2:00:24] that there's room for all the de-hospeady [2:00:27] that we could certainly purchase this one, [2:00:29] and we have a lot of space over there to cover, [2:00:31] It may have a real merit to have both her 1987 or 83 or anything. [2:00:40] 83 was one of the water went over, but as well as the 1900 reproduction thing, the only [2:00:51] question I have is, I don't know, I'm not an art critic, and so thus I don't, or a [2:00:57] and so I'm not sure I know that $7,900 is a good price. [2:01:02] It is a, we just because they paid that much for it. [2:01:05] I don't know what they paid, but if they paid for it, [2:01:07] they didn't mean that they didn't overpay, [2:01:09] and we could get something similar for a lesser value, [2:01:13] but I don't know how we find that out either. [2:01:15] Was there some sort of appraisal on it, [2:01:17] Travis that came with it? [2:01:19] So, tall chamois, so the request for the amount [2:01:23] is their cost of the original production. [2:01:26] Say the original Glee-Say process, which is so it's not a lithograph. It's not a print. It's a [2:01:33] Glee-Say, which is like a [2:01:35] Almost like a oil laser printing type thing and the frame construction [2:01:42] That's what they're trying to do great. They cooperate their cost. There you go. All right. That's any further discussion [2:01:52] Seeing none sure in roll call vote, please [2:02:03] Greg Lanting [2:02:05] Yes [2:02:06] Ruth Pierce yes Christopher Reed yes Chris talking to yes Sean Bericher yes Nicky boy yes motion passes six to zero I [2:02:19] Would echo some of Travis's comments that I do think that [2:02:24] Moving forward as a community a more robust public art [2:02:31] policy and process makes sense for us as we continue to grow and continue to find ways to [2:02:38] work on placemaking with projects like the five points project this year with the [2:02:46] haze statue that will be going in at the commons downtown, certainly with the facilities that we [2:02:52] have available to not only celebrate local art but I think to inspire local history. [2:02:59] I think that's one of the things I like about this piece is it helps to tell a story that happened [2:03:03] before Twin Falls was a city. [2:03:05] And you know, short of 10 million bucks for the original, [2:03:09] this has been opportunity to help celebrate that. [2:03:12] So I think we can continue to work on that route. [2:03:15] So the only thing I wanted to add is as we look at this, [2:03:19] let's focus on local artists. [2:03:22] There's a lot of talented people out there, [2:03:25] and there could be a myriad of pictures. [2:03:29] Like, you know, we think about vis-à-vis photographs, [2:03:33] but also local artists in their art. [2:03:35] So I would like to see us really focus on that. [2:03:41] Thank you. [2:03:42] Travis. [2:03:43] Travis? [2:03:44] I guess Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, [2:03:45] just kind of a question. [2:03:47] We've talked in the past about the need [2:03:50] for looking at creating and adopting a public art policy. [2:03:55] Is that something that you would like the staff to work [2:03:58] with the Art Council on developing them to bring back [2:04:01] for your consideration? [2:04:03] Yeah, yeah, so I think maybe having the staff look at perhaps what some other communities in Idaho are doing and [2:04:10] the kinds of partnerships they've created whether they have [2:04:14] internal arts commissions or they work with existing arts arts guilds or arts councils [2:04:21] partnerships with their historic preservation groups or what that looks like, but I think finding some of that information and [2:04:27] looking at how we might develop something, you know that [2:04:30] Boise and Moscow are two that come to mind that have pretty robust community policies that [2:04:36] impact mentally public art but guidelines for private development as well as they're looking [2:04:42] at landscaping, building facades and trying to mash that with the common vision so I think [2:04:50] that would be great. [2:04:52] Thank you. [2:04:56] Next is the presentation regarding the building project updates for City Hall and the public [2:05:01] Safety Complex, Mitchell Humble, Deputy City Manager. [2:05:06] We're just going to ask Jason to come talk to you about the project. [2:05:09] I'm going to defer to me, so it's always hard to follow up after we've walked the project, [2:05:13] so I'll just give some highlights and then stand for any questions. [2:05:16] At the Public Safety Police Operations Building, we're in the final stages of the final touch-up, [2:05:21] getting the millwork set. [2:05:23] The tile was underway as you saw. [2:05:25] Here in the next two weeks Brian from Hama will be down to do a punch list on that building and then we'll start turning it over to the [2:05:32] City for the installation of furnishings in that building [2:05:38] Parking lot we touched on a little bit while we're out there, but we're getting ready to move into phase two [2:05:42] We've split it into two parts so that they can continue to park out there while we redo [2:05:47] while we put in new sidewalks curb and gutter and [2:05:50] redo the [2:05:52] The asphalt in there is that needed to be modified for the fence. [2:05:56] It'll be an automatic fence installed, so we have to tear up some asphalt to put in the controls for that fence. [2:06:02] At City Hall, there's a lot going on as you are able to observe on all the floors. [2:06:06] We're pushing the first and the third floors. The furnishings for those two floors arrive on October 6. [2:06:12] I believe the Dave Mandy has given us. So that would be the first floors that get furnishings. [2:06:17] and the other two floors will follow a couple of weeks later. [2:06:20] So our focus is switch to the first and third floors to get those ready. [2:06:25] And then the basement and second floor come along after that. [2:06:29] Second floor is further along as you saw today. [2:06:31] So we've kind of tried to redirect some of the forces to those other two floors. [2:06:36] The biggest challenge we're having right now is manpower. [2:06:38] We've been able to redirect some manpower from other projects. [2:06:43] And we've had subs on the same project without, maybe that project doesn't have the same critical [2:06:49] schedule that we have here. [2:06:50] So we've been able to increase our manpower. [2:06:52] Friday we had 85 people there. [2:06:55] I haven't got the count for today, but I guess it's around 80 people today. [2:06:58] So we've got a lot of people there making a lot of progress and doing a lot of work. [2:07:01] I'm sure you may have some questions after what you saw today. [2:07:04] So I'll stop there and see if I can answer any of these. [2:07:07] Chris, talk. [2:07:09] Any surprises on your material pricing? [2:07:13] So far, uh, no, fortunately we locked in all of that labor and material pricing at the time of bid. So there's been no surprises there. Uh, there has been some increases in the market, but they haven't affected the project. [2:07:25] And, uh, some of the reserve money you haven't had to stretch out on that? Not for those things. No, there's been a few items that have been added, such as, wall, [2:07:34] Wall account rates on the exterior that we talked about that have come out of that reserve, but but none for our escalation [2:07:40] So it's safe to say no surprises. No surprises. I love that. We did too [2:07:46] Nikki boy, I don't have any questions because they asked them all when we were there, but it's just fabulous [2:07:52] I'm really excited. It looks really nice. Thank you [2:07:57] Chris read any concerns that you have with that might delay the schedule moving forward [2:08:05] The manpower was my concern with us being able to increase, [2:08:10] that's not the only place we've received more manpower [2:08:13] some of the jobs. [2:08:13] But for example, the electrician has doubled their crew, [2:08:16] and they've been working 10 hour, 12 hour days, and Saturday. [2:08:20] So, GEDSons really stepped up to make sure the electrical's [2:08:23] on track. [2:08:24] New view has all of their frames built now, [2:08:27] and glasses have ordered. [2:08:29] There are a few items that have a longer lead item [2:08:32] that still aren't here, we added some doors for the safety side of the change order that [2:08:38] we did, PR-12. You probably know what I'm talking about, but we added some security laws. Those [2:08:44] doors won't be here until the end of September. They were ordered right when that change order [2:08:47] is approved, but there is a lead time with those doors. They'll be here in time for the [2:08:52] move-in day at the end of October, but they will be going on what furnishings are going [2:08:56] in. Those are the biggest concerns I have right now. [2:09:00] So that's the other part of this, should I touch on? [2:09:05] The plan is City Hall will move out of the temporary location, the 26th of October, 23rd [2:09:12] of October. [2:09:13] That's that week there. [2:09:14] So furnishings needed two weeks to complete their install and then they'll be that week [2:09:19] for the staff to move over and start setting up in there to be out of the building by the [2:09:23] implement. [2:09:27] Any other questions for Jason? [2:09:28] Okay. [2:09:29] Thank you. [2:09:30] It's a pleasure to be part of it. [2:09:31] We'll be forward. [2:09:32] Thank you. [2:09:33] So, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, I guess that brings up just two quick things. [2:09:39] Number one, we're going to continue to operate out of here. [2:09:43] All of our commissions will continue to operate out of here. [2:09:47] And the process moving forward is if we have permanent homes that the city owns, then those [2:09:53] will be the last to kind of move over. [2:09:55] And so we've developed that as we've kind of looked at this labor issue with Star, and [2:10:00] they've been incredibly responsive to that. [2:10:03] The second piece is we're eventually all going to be in that building. [2:10:07] And so certainly to begin having the thoughts that we have two structures that will be vacated. [2:10:19] One, partially, this room right in here, and the question is, what do we do with this space? [2:10:25] Because this is a building that we have to own and occupy. [2:10:28] The second is the Hanson Building. [2:10:31] The Hanson building is a building that the city at this point in time does not have any long [2:10:38] range plans of occupying and we have been asked and people are starting to ask what is our [2:10:44] intent or plans with that building and so certainly no decisions need to be made tonight, but we [2:10:51] want to start having the thoughts as to what do we do with those assets. [2:10:57] One time we talked about the historic museum usage, is that still on the table or be considered? [2:11:05] I certainly think it could be on the table. One of the conversations that we've had with [2:11:10] the group just permanently was a question about ADA access. Being one of the concerns [2:11:16] and the second concern was their ability to really maintain, have the financial resources [2:11:23] to be able to maintain the structure of the facility and to perpetuity. [2:11:26] We'll give that some thought. [2:11:35] I suspect it will be back for discussion at a very near date. [2:11:44] Next on the agenda is a request to approve a guaranteed maximum price for construction [2:11:48] of the Hanson Street roadway and sidewalk adjacent to the new City Hall. [2:11:52] We have Deputy City Manager and Mitch Humble. [2:11:55] Again, I'll do a little intro here in the alternative over to Michael. [2:12:01] Okay, so a couple of things I put in the staff report that are of interest that we should [2:12:07] talk about. [2:12:08] This is a project that's being funded by the Urban Renewal Agency, and so some of you might [2:12:13] be asking yourselves, why are we issuing or approving the GMP? [2:12:17] Early on in this project, we decided that for coordination of work right around the City [2:12:23] Hall, it would be better if that work was done by Star Court. [2:12:27] And so they work for us, they are CMGC, and so we've got a deal worked out with the agency [2:12:34] where we're going to do the work for the sidewalk, the road, and the plaza, and then they'll pay [2:12:40] for it, essentially. [2:12:41] So since this is a contract with STAR, we're going to ask you to approve the GMP tonight. [2:12:47] And the second thing I was going to tell you about was in my staff report I talked about [2:12:52] two parts of the project that you're going to be considering tonight. [2:12:56] open bids on Friday and we weren't particularly fond of those bids and so [2:13:01] we're gonna go back and do some work on that so you just have one part that [2:13:04] you're gonna be asked to consider tonight and then I'll let Michael come up [2:13:07] and talk about the one and there'll be a couple more after that so it's at least [2:13:11] three parts maybe four depending on how we put it all together but that point [2:13:16] I'll turn to Michael. [2:13:23] Michael? [2:13:24] Thank you. [2:13:25] Mr. Mayor and Council people. [2:13:26] Mr. Mayor. [2:13:27] Okay, so this evening, would you like that? [2:13:31] No, sorry, we have a little sidebar. [2:13:35] My apologies. [2:13:36] It's like that. [2:13:37] Dear, it looks fun. [2:13:39] Okay, so tonight this piece is for the concrete work that is immediately outside the city hall [2:13:47] in front of Main Street and Hanson Street right to the Kerwin Gutter. [2:13:52] So with like Mitch mentioned, it's been divided into a handful of pieces, and that's what this takes into account. [2:13:57] So this is the concrete work there. This takes care of your flag poles, handrail, and some provisions for landscaping that will come in a future bid package that we would present to you for your consideration. [2:14:12] So this has the, just to, I mean this is a much shorter one than you're used to seeing. [2:14:19] Very little project management or superintendent money, because it's right next to that existing [2:14:26] project a little bit and a couple of allowances for the quality control testing that would [2:14:30] take place and then the good to take care of the concrete work and we roll that into [2:14:36] one package to make that more attractive, to take care of the earth work there, the gravel [2:14:41] putting up the flag hole in the handrail. Any questions I can respond to? [2:14:51] So, in your opinion, it is a fair bid for the amount of work that's being claimed there. [2:14:58] I do believe that it is. It falls within the budget that was set up for this particular [2:15:03] portion of work. So it's pretty easy for this to be in line with the whole thing because [2:15:08] it's such a small portion. But when we do those budgets, they're chopped into pieces. [2:15:12] So this is in line with what was set aside for that particular portion of room. [2:15:17] And then the anticipation would be that these other split up packages would be coming through [2:15:24] soon that parts of this project would actually still be completed this fall, for example, the [2:15:29] street and the sidewalk. [2:15:32] Those are great examples. [2:15:33] Yes, it would. [2:15:34] Like Mitch mentioned, we had hoped to present two of those numbers to you this evening, but [2:15:40] I knew that you would ask me the question about it that was fair and reasonable, and [2:15:43] And I could respond affirmatively to this and to that one, I could not. [2:15:47] And so we're not presenting it to you this evening. [2:15:50] We have been back and talked to the contractor that did present the bid that we just wasn't [2:15:55] in line with the budgets we've set up, and we're in the process of comparing some quantities [2:16:01] and understanding why that bid came in where it did. [2:16:05] And then we'll put together a strategy based on that to potentially break it into a few [2:16:10] more parts to increase participation or we'll come back with a strategy on how we're going [2:16:16] to do that. [2:16:17] But the dates would need to stay the same so that access to City Hall was granted. [2:16:23] But this will allow us to move forward that first piece. [2:16:26] Thank you. [2:16:27] Greg Lanting? [2:16:28] Well, this was close to topic, but not quite. [2:16:31] Thank you. [2:16:32] I'm certainly having my own thoughts and questions, but others keep getting asked about the plot. [2:16:39] And when we were going to start on it and do we have any estimates on when we might be able to begin and when we might be able to [2:16:47] Have that glorious plaza open. I know I bought a couple never britzy britzy different people keep hitting me up [2:16:54] We put those into a wall city hall [2:16:58] Yes, I can't speak to that this evening so as Mitch mentioned the project we're moving forward [2:17:04] that is grabbing pieces of it that are 100% ready and moving forward so that we can continue that work. [2:17:11] We had another meeting today to work out some of the last details are just there's so many that [2:17:18] this is the intersection of all those different projects out there and there are so many different [2:17:22] people involved and there's one or two opinions about how things need to get resolved and so we've [2:17:28] been checking those off and then double checking coordinating things on those. [2:17:35] Right now we expect to have the last few details for the restroom building wrapped up the first [2:17:41] part of October so that would be out to bid and that and the wall construction would be [2:17:47] underway yet this year. [2:17:49] Right now we anticipate bidding the plaza work later this year using the winter time [2:17:55] to procure the specialty fountain items and splash park items [2:17:59] so that all those items are here and ready to go [2:18:02] for a spring start. [2:18:04] And so over the winter time, work would progress [2:18:07] on that restroom building and the wall there [2:18:11] against the existing building [2:18:13] and so that the plaza would be ready for you next summer. [2:18:17] Thank you. [2:18:18] You bet. [2:18:21] The further questions for Michael and solutions. [2:18:27] Nicky, boy. [2:18:29] I move that we approve the guaranteed maximum price for construction of the Hanson Street [2:18:35] roadway and sidewalk adjacent to the new city hall location. [2:18:39] Second. [2:18:41] We have a motion to approve the GMP for the project as presented. [2:18:46] What would that amount then be? [2:18:52] Oh, it would be. [2:18:54] This is the 114-151. [2:18:55] Yeah. [2:18:56] Yes. [2:18:57] In the amount of 114-151 dollars. [2:19:01] $51 their further discussion Sharon roll call vote, please [2:19:16] Ruth Pierce yes Christopher Reed. Yes [2:19:21] Chris talkington. Yes, Sean Barrieger. Yes, Nicky Boyd. Yes Greg Lanting. Yes [2:19:30] Passes six to zero [2:19:40] Next another opportunity for general public input as anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council [2:19:46] Seeing no one, advisory board reports, anything from members of the council announcements, Travis. [2:19:56] Just three quick announcements. The first would be just a quick reminder of some upcoming events. [2:20:02] The first would be the city picnic and this Thursday from starting at about five running to about seven, seven, [2:20:13] 30th Harman Park will be in the shelter next to the skate park. [2:20:18] And so we'd certainly welcome the council and encourage the council to come and be a part [2:20:23] of that as you have in the past. [2:20:26] This Friday is the fireman's ball and if you are interested in that tickets can be acquired. [2:20:35] Probably at the fire station through Danielle is what we're thinking. [2:20:38] But it really goes to a great cause. [2:20:40] It's sponsored by the fire department local and it goes to their burnout fund and they [2:20:44] there have been Evelyn's fund. And so two very, very worthy causes in the third is that the [2:20:53] September 11th memorial and service that will be occurring in City Park at 9 a.m. Obviously [2:21:02] on September 11th. [2:21:03] Thank you, Travis. Chris talking to me. [2:21:08] Just like the report, the airport's advisory board, math, interview, replacement applicant [2:21:14] for that board, it's amazing we in years past [2:21:18] have had difficulty getting more than one or two [2:21:22] interested people. [2:21:23] We had nine qualified people, everything from pilots [2:21:27] to people involved in business out there, general aviation [2:21:31] and commercial aviation. [2:21:34] So we were able not only to make a selection [2:21:37] of a highly qualified person, but to keep two or three [2:21:40] other people in the loops, so to speak, [2:21:44] because we anticipate there'll be a couple more vacancies [2:21:47] coming up on that pretty quick. [2:21:50] People are very excited with the terminal project, [2:21:53] and we're always hopeful and expect [2:21:56] that we're gonna have another airline connection in here, [2:21:59] maybe one going to the west. [2:22:01] That's what we always ask the applicants [2:22:04] who may or may not have much of knowledge [2:22:06] of how those new carriers are able to come in the area. [2:22:11] But things are looking pretty optimistic right now. [2:22:15] Thank you. [2:22:16] Anything else from the council? [2:22:18] If not, the next item of the agenda is adjournment to executive session under Idaho Code 74261B [2:22:28] to consider the evaluation of dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges [2:22:33] brought against a public officer, employee, staff member or individual, agent or public [2:22:37] school student, cancel wishes. [2:22:43] So moved. [2:22:44] Ready. [2:22:45] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Greg Lanting, [2:22:48] to adjourn into Executive Session as presented. [2:22:51] Is there any discussion? [2:22:53] Chair and roll call vote, please. [2:23:02] Christopher Reed? [2:23:03] Yes. [2:23:04] Chris Stockington? [2:23:05] Yes. [2:23:05] Sean Berricher? [2:23:06] Yes. [2:23:07] Nikki Boyd? [2:23:08] Yes. [2:23:08] Greg Lanting? [2:23:09] Yes. [2:23:10] Ruth Pierce? [2:23:10] Yes. [2:23:11] Motion passes 6 to 0. [2:23:13] I just let everyone know we will not [2:23:15] be reconvening following the Executive Session, [2:23:18] nor will we be making any decisions in the Executive [2:23:21] Session. [2:23:22] with that merger. A lot of things to go to this week between here and next Monday. [2:23:33] Are you coming to the legislative tour at lunch or whatever? What's that? [2:23:39] It's Tuesday, Tuesday nights the dinner and you went to get the lunch. [2:23:45] So I have to give the invite or what you can just tell you or... [2:24:12] Can you just tell me, do you not see me in the email, do you? [2:24:14] Yeah, I'm sure you did. I just didn't do anything with it. [2:24:18] You and I are in the same email.